﻿

Science-Based Medicine: Miscellaneous CAM A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer. 2025 Edition. 
by Executive Editor Steven Novella. Managing Editor David Gorski. Series Editor Mark Crislip.
Contributions by The writers of the Science Based Medicine blog.
Published by SBM
2025

   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
About This Book
DETOXIFICATIONS
The Detox Scam: How to spot it, and how to avoid it | S Gavura
Detox: What “They” Don’t Want You To Know | S Gavura
Detox: What “They” Don’t Want You To Know | S Gavura
Detox Scams are Worthless and Potentially Dangerous | S Novella
“Detox”: Ritual purification masquerading as medicine and wellness | D Gorski
The one thing you need to know before you detox | S Gavura
Top ten signs your detox may be a scam | S Gavura
Are we all contaminated with chemical toxins? | S Gavura
Colon “cleanses”. A load of you know whatColon “cleanses”. A load of you know what…… David Gorski
Would you like a liver flush with that colon cleanse. David Gorski
2024 Detox Trends To Watch (Out) For | S. Gavura
The New Year’s detox secret THEY don’t want you to know about | S Gavura
Detox 2026: What Big Wellness Wants You to Believe | S Gavura
Taxpayers Fund Scientology Research on Gulf War Veterans | H Hall
Coffee enemas: This TikTok trend can be deadly | S Gavura
Activated charcoal: The latest detox fad in an obsessive food culture | S Gavura
Activated charcoal, the wellness scam | S Gavura
Constipation Myths and Facts. Scott Gavura
Vibrating Pills for Constipation: Safe and Effective or Bowel-Shaking Earthquakes of Doubt and Remorse* | C Jones
Nuubu: Here We Go Again! Recycling Debunked Foot Detox Myths | H Hall
“Base Spike Detox” and Signature Spike Support Formulas: Nattokinase quackery to treat COVID-19 and COVID-19 “vaccine injury” | D Gorski
What Is Dopamine Detox? | S Novella
Infrared Saunas for “Detoxification” | S Novella
NCCIH funds sauna “detoxification” study at naturopathic school
You’ve done a detox. Now what? | S Gavura
NEAR DEATH EXPERIENCE
Near Death Experiences and the Medical Literature. Mark Crislip
NDE Update. Mark Crislip.
My Woo. A Confession. Mark Crislip
TRIAL TO ASSESS CHELATION THERAPY (TACT)
Of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy, Bayes, the NIH, and Human Studies Ethics | K Atwood
The TACT is at least as Bad as We Predicted. Kimball Atwood
The result of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT): As underwhelming as expected | D Gorski
The Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy: Equivocal as Predicted | K Atwood
Misinterpreting TACT: No, Chelation Does Not Outperform Statins for Heart Disease | H Hall
We finally learn from TACT2 what we should have known two decades ago: Chelation therapy doesn’t work for heart disease | D Gorski
Son of (the unethical and unscientific) Trial To Assess Chelation Therapy rears its ugly head to the tune of $37 million | D Gorski
Bisphenol A in Plastics – Should We Worry? Steven Novella 
Massage Therapy rubs me the wrong way | J Bellamy
Massage for AIDS. Harriet Hall
PERSONALIZED MEDICINE
Personalized Medicine Bait and Switch. Steven Novella.
Hope and hype in genomics and “personalized medicine” David Gorski 
Direct-to-Consumer Genetic Testing: Road Map or Tarot Cards? Scott Gavura.
Functional Medicine – New Kid on the Block. Wallace Sampson
Bill and Hillary Clinton go woo with Dr. Mark Hyman and “functional medicine” | D Gorski
Functional medicine: The ultimate misnomer in the world of integrative medicine | D Gorski
“Functional medicine” in practice | D Gorski
Functional medicine: Reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other | D Gorski
Dietetics: Embracing Integrative and Functional Medicine? | K Klatt
AAFP: Functional Medicine lacks supporting evidence; includes “harmful” and “dangerous” treatments | J Bellamy
AAFP should publish research behind finding that functional medicine lacks evidence, contains harmful and dangerous practices | J Bellamy
The NCCIH embraces the quackery that is “functional medicine” | D Gorski
Cleveland Clinic genetic experts call out functional medicine on worthless genetic testing and supplement prescribing | J Bellamy
Surgeon General nominee Dr. Casey Means and functional medicine: Legitimizing quackery | D Gorski
Precision Medicine: The Coolest Part of Medicine | H Hall
“Precision medicine”: Hope, hype, or both? | D Gorski
Precision Medicine and Uncertainty | H Hall
The elusive “potential” of integrative medicine | J Bellamy
On “integrative medicine” and walking and chewing gum at the same time | Science-Based Medicine
Is there a distinct standard of care for “integrative” physicians? The Woliner case | J Bellamy
Broken Brain | H Hall
Goop and Dr. Mark Hyman join forces for some functional medicine heavy metal fear mongering | J Bellamy
Dr. Joel Fuhrman Sells Useless Iodine Test | H Hall
The return of marketing hype for “whole body scans”…now with AI! | D Gorski
A University of Michigan Medical School alumnus confronts anthroposophic medicine at his alma mater. David Gorski.
Quack Clinics. Steven Novella
Be Wary of Stem Cell Pseudoscience. Steven Novella
Biologie Totale and other bastard offspring of Ryke Geerd Hamer’s German New Medicine. David Gorski.
4 Minute Exercise Machine. Harriet Hall
Conspirituality: Where New Age wellness meets right wing conspiracy thinking | S Gavura
In Through the Nose, Out Through the Mouth | H Hall
Vital Signs: Buteyko Breathing | M Crislip
Buteyko Breathing Technique – Nothing to Hyperventilate About. Joseph Albietz 
Death by Aromatherapy | H Hall
Why It’s Worthwhile to Debunk Shivambu | J Howard
SPECT Scans at the Amen Clinic – A New Phrenology? Published by Harriet Hall 
Cold Water Immersion Not Always Beneficial | S Gavura
The Water Cure: Another Example of Self Deception and the “Lone Genius”. Harriet Hall
The Evidence for Hydrogen Water | H Hall
Bleaching away what ails you: The Genesis II Church is still selling Miracle Mineral Supplement as a cure-all | D Gorski
Navage Promises Benefits from Cleaning Your Nose with Their Expensive Machine | H Hall
Rom Houben: Not communicating through facilitated communication. David Gorski.
Charlatan: Quackery Then and Now Harriet Hall
Alternative Reproduction? | M Crislip
IVF and CAM Use. Steven Novella 
Menopause Isn’t Taboo | H Hall
Risibility. The Superior Therapeutic Intervention? Mark Crislip.
Cell Phones and Behavior. Steven Novella
Prepare for Surgery, Heal Faster? Kimball Atwood
Fatigued by a Fake Disease. Scott Gavura.
Cytotron – Magical Device Pseudoscience | S. Novella
CAM for the Management of Heart Failure | S Gavura
Treating Nightmares with a Smart Watch | H Hall
Does xenon gas improve athletic performance? | S Gavura
Spontaneous Human Combustion. A Sort of Narrative Review. | M Crislip
Science-Based Satire: Could Spontaneous Human Combustion Become a Chronic, Treatable Disease? Maybe. Yeah, I think so. | C Jones
ENERGY THERAPIES
Fields, Alternative Medicine, and Physics. Eugenie Mielczarek.
A review of Are Electromagnetic Fields Making Me Ill? How Electricity and Magnetism Affect Our Health, by Bradley J. Roth | H Hall
When a “scientific study” is neither
What Would It Take? | H Hall
Full of Energy | J Bellamy
Energy Medicine – Noise-Based Pseudoscience | S Novella
Frequencies and Their Kindred Delusions. Harriet Hall.
Energy Bracelets: Embedding Frequencies in Holograms for Fun and Profit. Harriet Hall
Magnets Provide Amusement, But Not Health Benefits | H Hall
Magnets and Blood Flow. Steven Novella.
Can Magnets Heal? Steven Novella 
Novak Djokovic credits the TaoPatch for his success: What does the science say? | S Gavura
Energy Medicine Pain Relief Patches Are Laughable Quackery | Hall
Update on Energy Medicine Pain Patches: Jovi and Its Targeted Marketing Strategy | H Hall
Bogus Electrodermal Testing Devices and the Failure of Regulators to Act | H Hall
Electromagnetic healing devices for dogs: Studies show “Meh” | G Bishop
Electrodermal Testing Part I: Fooling Patients with a Computerized Magic Eight Ball. Harriet Hall.
Electrodermal Testing Part II: Legal and Regulatory Aspects. Harriet Hall
“Electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and “wifi allergies”: Bogus diagnoses with tragic real world consequences | D Gorski
Reassessing whether low energy electromagnetic fields can have clinically relevant biological effects | D Gorski
Nonsense about the Health Effects of Electromagnetic Radiation | H Hall
BioCharger’s Claims Are Too Silly to Take Seriously | H Hall
Frequency Specific Microcurrent | S Novella
Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Snake Oil | S Novella
Galvanic Skin Response Pseudoscience | S Novella
The “Healing Codes” of Alex Loyd: Energy Healing with Words and Finger Exercises | H Hall
Eric Pearl “Reconnects” with Hands-Off Healing. Harriet Hall.
I Visited a Chickasaw Healer and All I Got Was an Elk Sinew and Buffalo Horn Bracelet | M Crislip
Reiki | S Novella
No, editors of The Atlantic, reiki does not work | D Gorski
Reiki and Therapeutic Touch. Compare and Contrast. | M Crislip
A Journalist Asks if Your Child Needs an Energy Healer. The Answer Probably Won’t Surprise You. | C Jones
Mayo Clinic Promotes Reiki | S. Novella
Johrei: The next energy healing craze? | J Luke
Adventures in defending science-based medicine in cancer journals: Energy chelation | D Gorski
Pseudoscience Sells. Steven Novella
Another EMF Scam | S. Novella
Bioptron: Too Silly to Write about | H Hall
Radioactive 5G Pendants | S Novella
Radioactive Energy Cards | S Novella
CFLs, Dirty Electricity and Bad Science. Steven Novella.
Quack Book Reviews: EMF*D | B MacBeth
Scientists Sign Petition Warning about EMF | S Novella
Are Smart Meters a Health Risk? | S Novella
Earthing Update | S Novella
Train Therapy. Mark Crislip
Elemonics – Nothing but a dance and a tune | C Pearcey
Crystal Healing | S Novella
Closing out 2012 with a bit of fun: Do you want some quantum with that pseudoscience? | D Gorski
Biofield Tuning: Another Example of Tooth Fairy Science | H Hall
ZYTO: An Electrodermal Diagnostic Device Is Tested and Fails Miserably | H Hall
This Scary Mask Is Not for Halloween: It’s for Anti-Aging Skin Care | H Hall
Visual Stress | H Hall
Joovv and Other Red Light Therapies | H Hall
Red Flags For Red Light Therapy | S Gavura
Low Level Lasers: N-Rays in action. | M Crislip
Blue Light. Special? | M Crislip
Blue Light | H Hall
Blue light blocking glasses: How much of the hype is science-based? | S Gavura
The Blu Room | H Hall
Biofeedback and Laser for Allergies. Harriet Hall
Laser Therapy for Vaginal Rejuvenation | H Hall
Blonde Blood: Hydrogen Peroxide Infusions | M Crislip
Don’t drink hair bleach | S Gavura
FTC settles false advertising suit against low-level light therapy marketer with $22 million judgment | J Bellamy
The Light Fantastical. Ultra Violet Blood Irradiation. | M Crislip
Ultraviolet Blood Treatment Revisited | S Novella
Ozone Therapy | S. Novella
Extracorporeal Blood Oxygenation and Ozonation | S Novella
The Blood Cleaner: Invented by Ray Jardine | H Hall
Belly Button Healing: Science plus Magic for Only $99? | C Jones
Amino Neuro Frequency: Just More “Embedded Frequencies” Silliness | H Hall
Access Consciousness: Phrenology fused with energy medicine | D Gorski
Wishing Away Warts. Harriet Hall
Who Is Amy B. Scher? | H Hall
Did Microwaves Harm US Employees at Its Embassy in Havana? | K Foster
Visiting a Victorian Duckpond | H Hall
Lawsuit Alleges School Wi-Fi Harmed Child with Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity | H Hall
5G Is Coming | S Novella
Infomercial in PLOS One links to website selling unproven treatments for fibromyalgia and dementia | J Coyne
It’s Hard Out There for a Psychic | M Crislip
Willow Curve Device for Pain: Strong Claims, Weak Evidence | H Hall
Whole Body Vibration Therapy | S Novella
Whole Body Cryotherapy | S Novella
Parabiosis – The Next Snakeoil | S Novella
Can A One-Minute Cure Really Heal Virtually All Diseases? Harriet Hall
FAITH HEALING
Faith Healing. Harriet Hall
Faith Healing: Religious Freedom vs. Child Protection | H Hall
Trying to Impose Religion on Medicine | S Novella
The Power of Faith and Prayer? Steven Novella
Another Useless NCCAM-Funded Study Harriet Hall
AA is Faith-Based, Not Evidence-Based. Harriet Hall.
Religion and SCAM | M Crislip
Idaho allows faith-based medical neglect to kill children | J Bellamy
Islamic Medicine and the Biopolitics of Antiscience in Iran | Kiarash Aramesh
TOUCH
Why I Quit My Massage Therapy Career | P Ingraham
Healing Touch and Coronary Bypass. Harriet Hall.
Touched by a Touched Healing Toucher. Kimball Atwood
Therapeutic Touch Pseudoscience: The Tooth Fairy Strikes Again | H Hall
“Imbalanced Energy Field” is not a valid diagnosis and therapeutic touch is pseudoscience, so why can’t nurses just give it up? | J Bellamy
“Magic Socks?” Alternative Medicine’s Obsession With Your Feet. | C Jones
Socks to Treat High Blood Pressure? | H Hall
Reflexology. Insert Nancy Sinatra Reference Here. Mark Crislip.
Modern Reflexology: Still As Bogus As Pre-Modern Reflexology | H Hall
Reflexology for Babies? | C Jones
Bodytalk: Medical theater | S Gavura
Cranial Osteopathy in Dentistry | G. Richey
Alas poor Craniosacral. A SCAM of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy. | M Crislip
Craniosacral Therapy Is Bogus but DOs Are Required to Learn It | H Hall
Structural Energetic Therapy | S Novella
Astrology, Alchemy, ESP and Reiki. One Of These Is Not Like The Other | M Crislip
Emotional Freedom Technique – Acupuncture for the Mind | S Novella
What Is Somatic Therapy? | S. Novella
Pain Reprocessing Therapy | H Hall
Can Airrosti Really Resolve Most Chronic Pain in Just Three Visits? | H Hall
Does massage therapy decrease inflammation and stimulate mitochondrial growth? An intriguing study oversold | D Gorski
Visceral Manipulation Embraced by the APTA | H Hall
Videos Said to be “Proof” that Nonverbal Autistics Can Communicate by Spelling | H Hall
Facilitated Communication Is Still Pseudoscience | S Novella
Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises (TRE) | H Hall 
The (binaural) beat goes on | S Gavura
Dubious Autonomic Nervous System Claims | S Novella
Soothing Your Heart: Does practicing self-compassion have physical and mental health benefits? | J Coyne
Is Mindfulness Meditation Science-Based? | S Novella
Another Broken Meditation Study | S Novella
Can mind-body practices “reprogram” our DNA? | D Gorski
Past Life Regression Therapy: Encouraging Fantasy | H Hall
Pseudoscience invades Social Work | J Bellamy
Juvent: Space Age Technology to Achieve Total Health? | H Hall
Innovo for Bladder Leakage | H Hall
Allergy Release Technique | S Novella
Fake treatments for real diseases: A review of allergy and asthma advertisements by naturopaths, chiropractors, homeopaths and acupuncturists | S Gavura
Coca’s Pulse Testing to Diagnose “Allergies” | H Hall
Are skin-lightening glutathione injections safe and effective? | S Gavura
Holotropic Breathwork | S Novella
Alternative Arthritis Treatments | S Novella
SCAMlandia. CAM in Oregon. | M Crislip
Halotherapy – The Latest Spa Pseudoscience | S Novella
Do You Need Daily Treatment to Repair Damaged Enamel? | H Hall
InstaHard: Hard to Believe, Easy to Laugh At | H Hall
Prolotherapy | S Novella
Dry Scooping – A Harmful Internet Fad | S Novella
Taopatch Offers Everything… Except Science | H Hall
Applied Kinesiology by Any Other Name… | H Hall
Applied Kinesiology: Nonsense on Full Automatic | M Crislip
The Influence of Kinesiology Tape Color on Athletic Performance: An Actual Published Study…Seriously | C Jones
Nonsense for Elephants: The Houston Zoo Promotes Kinesiology Tape | C Jones
Olympic Pseudoscience – Tokyo Edition | S Novella
Iridology | S Novella
Lumen’s Information Is Not So Illuminating | H Hall
Oxygen Is Good, Even When It’s Not There | H Hall
Oxygen Myths That Refuse to Die | H Hall
Quackery (still) kills: A five-year-old boy dies in a hyperbaric oxygen chamber | D Gorski
Drinkable Sunscreen Snakeoil | S Novella
Access Consciousness: A New Version of Phrenology? | H Hall
Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: Separating facts from fiction | S Gavura
Bach Flower Remedies | H Hall
Kambo: Frog Poison for Health? | H Hall
Ground Glass Is Not a Poison | H Hall
CAM use leads to delays in appropriate, effective arthritis therapy | S Gavura
Freud Was a Fraud: A Triumph of Pseudoscience | H Hall
Leech Therapy | M Crislip
Cryotherapy: A Layman’s Attempt to Understand the Science | Z Hoffman & Hall
Anesthesia-Assisted Rapid Opioid Detox | J Bellamy
Leaky Bowel | M Crislip
The Human Mold: Another Example of Self-Deception | H Hall
Pyroluria and Orthomolecular Psychiatry | S Novella
Antipodean CAM | J Bellamy
Brainspotting is Classic Pseudoscience | S Novella
Do our mitochondria need support? | S Gavura
Injectable Peptides – The New Snake Oil | S Novella
VETERNARY MEDICINE
What do veterinarians think about complementary and alternative medicine? | G Bishop
Alternative Medicine Is Infiltrating Veterinary Continuing Education | H Hall
Alternative Medicine: Placebos for Pets | Science-Based Medicine
Dog breath and stinky studies: Do pets need to be knocked out for dental care? | G Bishop
Do I really need to do a fecal test on my dog every year? | G Bishop
Heartworms, fear-mongering, and perilous advice. The bad recommendations of Dr. Peter Dobias regarding heartworm disease in dogs. | G Bishop
The English (Bulldog) Patient: What A Travesty of Canine Health Teaches us About Cognitive Dissonance | G Bishop
The White Coat Effect in Animals: Reducing Fear in the Vet Clinic | G Bishop
Pee Values: Tapping into large databases to answer an awkward situation in veterinary medicine | G Bishop
What’s the Truth behind The Truth About Pet Cancer? | B McKenzie
Are Rattlesnake Vaccines for Dogs Effective? | G Bishop
Alternative Flea Control Products | G Bishop
NuVet: Pet Supplement Snake Oil | S Gavura
The Great Outdoors (Debate) | G Bishop
FDA & CDC find raw pet food unpalatable | J Bellamy
Pet Food Mislabeling: Let Food Be Thy Dogma | G Bishop
Licking | M Crislip
An Age of Endarkenment? The American Veterinary Medical Association and Homeopathy | B McKenzie
An Appraisal of Courses in Veterinary Chiropractic | R & O Kjellin
Veterinary Chiropractic | B McKenzie
People Encouraging Turtle Agony*: Animal Acupuncture | M Crislip
Animal Therapy | M Crislip
What to make of Medical Dogs | P Lipson
Learning from Animals: Evolutionary Medicine with a Twist | H Hall
Add-on Services for IVF – The Evidence | S Novella
Tampon: Our Closest Enemy vs. The Vagina Bible | B MacBeth
SmartJane Test of Vaginal Health: Clever Marketing, Questionable Science | H Hall
Placenta Eye Drops | S Gavura
Lotus Birth To Blame for Death of Australian Newborn | C Jones
FDA Warns About Miracle Mineral Solution | S Novella
Skin pH: Salesmanship, Not Science | H Hall
“Young blood” infusions: same old snake oil | J Bellamy
Debunking Sleep Myths | S Novella
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Systemic Exertion Intolerance Disease Speculcation | M Crislip
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Rituximab | H Hall
Medical Apartheid | H Hall
The Real ID. Mark Crislip
Alternative Microbiology | M Crislip
Your terrain, your fault? Germ Theory Denial 2025 | S Gavura
The Marshall Protocol. Mark Crislip.
The Microbial Metagenome. Mark Crislip.
Live Blood Analysis: The Modern Auguries. Mark Crislip
The Paddison Program for rheumatoid arthritis: An unproven treatment that provides only the illusion of control | D Gorski
Urinary Tract Infections Cause Depression. Directors Cut.* | M Crislip
Hi Ho Silver. Mark Crislip
Honey. Mark Crislip
Candida and Fake Illnesses | S Novella
Black mold is the new Candida | S. Gavura
Delusional Parasitosis. Steven Novella.
Morgellon's Itching and the Imaginary Passenger Brake. Wallace Sampson
Parasites. Mark Crislip.
Parasite Cleanse S. Novella
Rope Worms: C’est la Merde | H Hall
No, Everything You Thought You Knew About Disease Is Not Wrong | H Hall
There is really nothing super about Antibiotic Resistant Gonorrhea | C Jones
Does Everybody Have Chronic Lyme Disease? Does Anyone? | H Hall
Lyme: Two Worlds Compared and Contrasted | M Crislip
Chronic Lyme Disease – Another Negative Study | S Novella
Chronic Lyme disease: Fake diagnosis, not fake disease | D Gorski
Political Science: Chronic Lyme Disease | J Bellamy
Lemons and Lyme: Bogus tests and dangerous treatments of the Lyme-literati | J Snyder
Lyme Testing | M Crislip
More Lyme ‘Guidelines’ | M Crislip
More Political Science: Proposed laws protect “Lyme literate” doctors from discipline | J Bellamy
Avoid prolonged antibiotics for “Chronic Lyme” | S Gavura
Another “Chronic Lyme” VIP disciplined by NY medical authorities: Bernard Raxlen | J Bellamy
“Chronic Lyme” VIP Daniel Cameron disciplined by New York medical authorities | J Bellamy
Jarisch-Herxheimer and Lyme disease | S Novella
A Review of Under Our Skin, A Cult Classic | B MacBeth
Conspiracy theories about monkeypox: Déjà vu all over again or same as it ever was? | D Gorski
Medical Misinformation Falsely Links a Serious Infection to Leftover Chinese Food | C Jones
The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment: A Fiasco with a Silver Lining | H Hall
No, Purell Does Not Breed Super-Anything | A Wegman
Elephants, Herpes, and Protests: A Zoo Tragedy Distorted | G Bishop
Jurassic Farce | M Crislip
Buzzword Medicine – Anti-Proinflammation | S Novella
Wim Hof, the Iceman | H Hall
Tattoos Won’t Boost Your Immune System | C Jones
Tattoos Still Won’t Boost Your Immune System | C Jones
Dry Drowning | H Hall
Nurse Practitioner Pushes Dubious Aesthetic Treatments | H Hall
Can A One-Minute Cure Really Heal Virtually All Diseases? | H Hall
Integrative Psychiatry | J Luke
Scientology’s War on Medicine | H Hall
Eminent Harvard psychologist, mother of positive psychology, New Age quack | J Coyne
Is Gaming Addiction a Thing? | S Novella
Video Games and the Brain | S Novella
Mental Illness Denial | S Novella
Psychology and Psychotherapy: How Much Is Evidence-Based? | H Hall
False Memory Syndrome Alive and Well | S Novella
The Medical Medium’s Thyroid Pseudoscience | S Gavura
Overtreating the thyroid | S Gavura
Adrenal fatigue: A fake disease (updated) | S Gavura
Australian review finds no benefit to 17 natural therapies | S Gavura
In the Spirit of Choosing Wisely | M Crislip
Acupuncture, Organic Food, and Other Questions | S Novella
CAM and Headaches | S Novella
And Now for Something Completely Different | H Hall
April Fool Cannot Surpass SCAM | M Crislip
Hungover | M Crislip
November Hodgepodge | M Crislip
Olympic Pseudoscience | S Novella
Is your workout gear killing you? | S Gavura
Corrigendum. The week in SBM for 1.22.2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in SBM for 01.29.2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum: The week in review for 2/5/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The week in review for 02/12/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 02/19/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 02/26/2017. | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The week in review for 03/05/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The week in review for 03/12/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 03/19/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review. 03/26/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/02/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/09/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/16/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/23/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/30/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/14/2017. | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/21/2017 | M Crislip
Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/28/2017. | M Crislip
I Got Nothing | M Crislip
Science-Based Medicine’s Not-So-Psychic Predictions for 2016 | C Jones
Yet Another Miscellany of Medical Malarkey | C Jones
An Unexpected Miscellany of Medical Malarkey | C Jones
A Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Episode 3: The Revengening | C Jones
Rise of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey…Again | C Jones
The Return of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Strikes Back | C Jones
Dr. David Villarreal’s “Holistic Dentistry:” Full of Holes? | H Hall
(Dys-)Functional Medicine Comes to Dentistry | G Ritchey
Science-Based Satire: Hiring a Doula for Dental Procedures | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Alternative Medical Adverse Events on the Rise | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: NASA Teams with NCCIH to Study Alternative Medicine in Space | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Florida Authorities Report First Case of Mosquito-Borne Fentanyl Overdose | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: A Powerful and Ancient Practice is Revolutionizing Medical Venipuncture | C Jones
Science-Based Satire: Alternative Medical Alert Systems in the News | C Jones
   Title Page
Science-Based Medicine: Miscellaneous CAM

A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

As of 2025, there are over essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 






   Detoxifications

The Detox Scam: How to spot it, and how to avoid it
Scott Gavura on January 2, 2014
Link
Note to SBM’s regular readers: Today’s post revisits some older material you may have seen before. Happy New Year!
New Year, New You, right? 2014 is the year you’re finally going to get serious about your health. You’re winding down from a week (or more) of celebrations and parties. You’re pretty much recovered from New Year’s Eve by now. It’s time to make some resolutions. Conveniently, there is no shortage of solutions being advertised to absolve you of your sins while overhauling your body and soul for 2014: What you need to do is “detox”. You’ll see the detox kits at your local Whole Foods (or even your local pharmacy). Books, boxes or bottles, with some combination of “detox”, “cleanse” or “flush” in the product name. Supplements, tea, homeopathy, coffee enemas, ear candles, and footbaths all promise detoxification. The advertising suggests you’ll gain a renewed body and better health – it’s only seven days and $49.95 away. Or try to cleanse yourself with food alone: Dr. Oz is hyping his Holiday Detox plan. Bon Appetit is featuring their 2014 Food Lover’s Cleanse. Or what about that old standby, the “Master Cleanse”? It’s the New Year – wouldn’t a purification from your sins of 2013 be a good idea to start the year? After all, the local naturopath offers complete detoxification protocols, including vitamin drips and chelation. There must be something to it, right?
Wrong. “Detox” is a case of a legitimate medical term being turned into a marketing strategy – all designed to treat a nonexistent condition. In the setting of real medicine, detoxification means treatments for dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, like heavy metals. Detoxification treatments are medical procedures that are not casually selected from a menu of alternative health treatments, or pulled off the shelf in the pharmacy. Real detoxification is provided in hospitals when there are life-threatening circumstances. But then there are the “toxins” that alternative health providers claim to eliminate. This form of detoxification is simply the co-opting of a real term to give legitimacy to useless products and services, while confusing consumers into thinking they’re science-based. Evaluating any detox is simple: We need to understand the science of toxins, the nature of toxicity, and how detox rituals, kits, and programs claim to remove toxins. With this framework, it’s a simple matter to spot the pseudoscience and be a smarter consumer.
Premise one: Our bodies are accumulating toxins
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification – we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or perhaps sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication.” Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science led us to discard autointoxication by the 1900’s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Despite the science, however, the idea persists among alternative practitioners. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that some combination of food additives, gluten, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, and perhaps last night’s bottle of wine are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. But what is the actual “toxin” causing harm? It’s nothing more than a meaningless term that sounds scientific enough to be plausible. A uniform feature of detox treatments is the failure to name the specific toxins that these rituals and kits will remove. For example Renew Life promises you:
CleanseSMART is a 2 part, 30 day, advanced herbal cleansing program. It is formulated to stimulate the detoxification process of the body’s 7 channels of elimination: the liver, lungs, colon, kidneys, blood, skin, and lymphatic system. In today’s toxic world, cleansing and detoxification is a necessity. Toxins enter our body daily through the air we breathe, the food we eat, and the water we drink. Over time, these toxins build up and slowly start to affect our health in a negative way.
Through cleansing and detoxification, you enable your body to better process this toxic load. Reducing the toxic load in your body decreases the risk of developing chronic health problems, improves overall health and immune response, and can increase energy levels. CleanseSMART works to cleanse and detoxify the entire body, but with focus on the body’s two main detoxification pathways – the liver and the colon. CleanseSMART is essential for helping eliminate constipation and improving bowel health.
Note the vague language. Toxins are alluded to – but not named. It sounds somewhat plausible, but is non-specific. Note that even if you’re well (and presumably toxin free?) a detox is still recommended.
The colon remains ground zero for detox advocates. They argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, Candida (yeast) and other nastiness. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. Ask any gastroenterologist (who look inside colons for a living) if they’ve ever seen one. There isn’t a single case that’s been documented in the medical literature. Not one.
Premise two: Illness is the result of toxins
Marketing materials for detox treatments typically describe an array of symptoms and diseases linked to toxin buildup: A few that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specifics to frighten you (cancer, etc.) Which toxins cause which disease is missing, and how the toxins cause the symptoms is never actually explained. Here again we see the contrast with real science. To establish that even a single chemical can cause disease requires a significant amount of research (i.e., the entire field of epidemiology). Despite the variety of toxins that are claimed to be causing your illness, marketing claims for detox treatments will uniformly fail to link specific toxins to specific symptoms or illnesses.
The reality is that our bodies are constantly being exposed to a huge variety of natural and synthetic chemicals. The presence of any chemical in the body, (natural or synthetic) does not mean that it is doing harm. Many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, and consequently the human body has evolved a remarkable system of defenses and mechanisms to defend against, and remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, our gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up our astoundingly complex and sophisticated intrinsic detoxification system. Importantly, the dose makes the poison – even water can be toxic (dilutional hyponatremia) when consumed in excessive amounts.
Advocates for detox typically describe the liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the reality is the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated in bile, or the kidneys. The liver is self-cleansing – toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions without any problem. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine – otherwise the substance stays in the blood. To argue that either organ need a “cleanse” is to demonstrate a profound ignorance of human physiology, metabolism, and toxicology.
Premise three: Detox treatments remove toxins
A search of the medical literature for clinical studies of detox kits provides the following result:
No Items Found
There is no credible evidence to demonstrate that detox kits do anything at all. They have not been shown to remove remove “toxins” or offer any health benefits. The same can be said for quackery like coffee enemas – there is no credible evidence to support claims that coffee enemas help the body to “detoxify” compounds, or help the liver function more effectively. Vitamin injections are another treatment that fail to offer meaningful benefits to consumers, and have no beneficial effect on the ability of your liver or kidneys to work effectively. Chelation injections are touted as a cure-all for all kinds of illnesses, but unlike real chelation that’s administered in hospitals for real cases of poisoning, naturopath chelation is not science-based and doesn’t seem to do much of anything.
Can Detoxing be harmful?
If they provide no benefit, is there the potential for detox treatments to harm?
When it comes to simple dietary changes, there’s little evidence of harm. Eating more quinoa and kale, and less processed and refined foods is reasonable dietary advice for everyone. Homeopathic “detox” is also likely safe – with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. As you get into more unorthodox detox treatments that actually contain active ingredients, it’s clear that some approaches are demonstrably risky. Coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Harms such as septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been reported. Even deaths. Vitamin injections don’t seem as risky, as long as you trust the sterile technique of your alternative provider. However, given some naturopaths seem to be willing to inject products intended for oral use, you might want to think carefully about taking a vitamin injection or chelation treatment, especially when there’s no reasonable expectation of any benefit.
What about the detox kits? Contents vary, but typically contain two categories of ingredients:
     1.  A liver “booster” – typically milk thistle (Silibum marianum). If the liver can’t be wrung out and rejuvenated, can it be boosted to do a better job? Milk thistle is the most popular product purported to “boost” the liver’s effectiveness. There are no published studies that demonstrate milk thistle has a detoxifying effect on the liver. Milk thistle has been studied in patients with alcoholic liver disease, and in patients with hepatitis B or C, and it has not been found to exhibit any meaningful effects. There is no evidence to suggest that consuming milk thistle will cleanse you of unnamed “toxins”.
     2.  A laxative – Typically magnesium hydroxide, senna, rhubarb, cascara, etc. Laxatives are the ingredients in detox kits that give you the effect you can see (and feel). However, these ingredients can cause dehydration and electrolyte imbalances if not used carefully. Regular use of stimulant laxatives, like senna and cascara, are ill-advised for most healthy adults due to the risk of dependence and electrolyte depletion. They’re among the most potent laxatives, usually used for short periods to alleviate significant constipation or to clear out your bowels before a medical procedure. With regular use, your bowel can grow accustomed to the effects of laxatives which may result in constipation once you stop using them. It’s a perfect case of the treatment causing the illness: After the detox, you get could conceivably become constipated: Time for another detox!
Side effects can continue once a detox ends. Some people experience post-detox effects like nausea and diarrhea. Advocate call these “cleansing reactions” and will assure you it’s “toxins leaving the body”. A more plausible, science-based explanation is that this is a consequence of restarting the digestion process after a period of catharsis, where, depending on the extent and duration of fasting, little to no digestion occurred, and the normal gastrointestinal flora may have been severely disrupted. It’s the same effect seen in hospitalized patients who have difficulty initially digesting food after being fed intravenously. The detox ingredients, and resulting catharsis, may irritate the colon to such an extent that it may take time to return to normal.
Immediate weight loss is not uncommon after a detox, especially one that involves a laxative. Unfortunately this is usually due to losses in water and possibly muscle tissue, depending on the how disruptive the detox was to normal body function Regardless of the weight loss, the body will move back to its pre-detox weight over time if diet and activity levels remain the same.
Conclusion
Any product or service with the words “detox” or “cleanse” in the name is only truly effective at cleansing your wallet of cash. Alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. They do have the ability to harm however – not only direct effects, like coffee enemas and purgatives, but the broader distraction away from the reality of how the body actually works and what we need to do to keep it healthy. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, and gives consumers the impression that they can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee pushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, you’d do well to ignore the suggestion, and question any other health advice they may offer.

Detox: What “They” Don’t Want You To Know
Pseudoscientists HATE him! You won’t BELIEVE what this pharmacist says about detox products!
Scott Gavura on January 1, 2015
Link

Happy New Year! Today’s post was some old material, dusted off, repackaged, and updated for 2015.
New Year, New You, right? We’re just into 2015, and you’ve resolved to finally get serious about your health. Starting today. But first need to cleanse yourself, eliminating last year’s lifestyle and dietary sins. You’ve seen the ads and the Facebook links, all suggesting you need a “detox”, “cleanse” or “flush” to be healthy. Supplements, tea, homeopathy, coffee enemas, ear candles, and footbaths promise you a detoxified body. Amazon has entire detox and cleansing categories in supplements and books. The descriptions all suggest detoxing will deliver a renewed body and better health — it’s only seven days and $49.95 away. Dr. Oz has several detox plans — you just need to decide which one. The local naturopath sells detoxification protocols, including vitamin drips and chelation. Even your pharmacy probably has a wall of products for sale. Wouldn’t a purification from your sins of 2014 be a good idea to start the year? Unfortunately, there’s something very important that detox promoters aren’t telling you.
“Detox” isn’t real
“Detox” is a legitimate medical term that has been turned into a marketing strategy — all designed to treat a nonexistent condition. Real detoxification isn’t ordered from a menu of alternative health treatments, or assembled from ingredients in your pantry. Actual detoxification is provided in hospitals under life-threatening circumstances — usually when there are dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or other poisons in the body. These are not products you can purchase in a pharmacy for personal use. What you’re seeing promoted as “detox” is using medical terminology, but only to give the perception of scientific legitimacy to medically-useless products and services. Fake detox is built around a number of easily-debunked premises. Once you can spot the flaws, it’s easy to tell fact from fiction.
Premise one: Our bodies are accumulating toxins, so we need to detoxify
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or perhaps sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication.” Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science discarded autointoxication by the 1900’s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Yet the term persists today, but now it’s used to sell useless products and services. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that some combination of food additives, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, and perhaps last night’s bottle of wine are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. And don’t forget gluten. Gluten is the new evil and therefore, is now a toxin. So what is the actual “toxin” causing you harm? Detox kits and treatments never name the toxins that they remove, because they’ve never been shown to remove toxins. For example, Renew Life promises you:
CleanseSMART is a 2 part, 30 day, advanced herbal cleansing program. It is formulated to stimulate the detoxification process of the body’s 7 channels of elimination: the liver, lungs, colon, kidneys, blood, skin, and lymphatic system. In today’s toxic world, cleansing and detoxification is a necessity. Toxins enter our body daily through the air we breathe, the food we eat, and the water we drink. Over time, these toxins build up and slowly start to affect our health in a negative way.
Through cleansing and detoxification, you enable your body to better process this toxic load. Reducing the toxic load in your body decreases the risk of developing chronic health problems, improves overall health and immune response, and can increase energy levels. CleanseSMART works to cleanse and detoxify the entire body, but with focus on the body’s two main detoxification pathways — the liver and the colon. CleanseSMART is essential for helping eliminate constipation and improving bowel health.
Note the vague language. Toxins are alluded to — but not named. It sounds somewhat plausible, but is non-specific. Note that even if you’re well (and presumably toxin free?) a detox is still recommended.
The colon remains ground zero for detox advocates. They argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, Candida (yeast) and other nastiness. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. Ask any gastroenterologist (who look inside colons for a living) if they’ve ever seen one. There isn’t a single case that’s been documented in the medical literature. Not one.
Premise two: Illness is the result of chemical toxins
Marketing materials for detox treatments typically describe an array of symptoms and diseases linked to toxin buildup: A few that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specifics to frighten you (cancer, etc.) Which toxins cause which disease is left out, and how the toxins cause the symptoms is never actually explained. Here again we see the contrast with real science. To establish that even a single chemical can cause disease requires a significant amount of research (i.e., the entire field of epidemiology). Despite the variety of toxins that are claimed to be causing your illness, marketing claims for detox treatments always fail to link specific toxins to specific symptoms or illnesses. That’s because they can’t — there is no scientific evidence to show that detox treatments have any useful medical effects.
The reality is that our bodies are constantly being exposed to a huge variety of natural and synthetic chemicals. The presence of any chemical in the body, (natural or synthetic) does not mean that it is doing harm. Many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, and consequently the human body has evolved a remarkable system of defenses and mechanisms to defend against, and remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, our gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up our astoundingly complex and sophisticated intrinsic detoxification system. Importantly, the dose makes the poison — even water can be toxic (dilutional hyponatremia) when consumed in excessive amounts.
Advocates for detox typically describe the liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs need to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the reality is that the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated in bile or urine . The liver is self-cleansing — toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions without any problem. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine — otherwise the substance stays in the blood. Anyone that suggests these organs need a “cleanse” is demonstrating their ignorance of human physiology, metabolism, and toxicology.
Premise three: Detox treatments remove toxins
A search of the medical literature for clinical studies of detox kits provides the following result:
No Items Found
There is no credible evidence to demonstrate that detox kits do anything at all. They have not been shown to remove “toxins” or offer any health benefits. The same can be said for alternative medicine treatments like coffee enemas — there is no credible evidence to support claims that coffee enemas help the body to “detoxify” compounds, or help the liver function more effectively. Vitamin injections are another treatment that fail to offer meaningful benefits to consumers, and have no beneficial effect on the ability of your liver or kidneys to work effectively. Chelation injections are touted as a cure-all for all kinds of illnesses, but unlike real chelation that is administered in hospitals for real cases of poisoning, naturopath chelation is not science-based and doesn’t seem to do much of anything.
Even massage is allegedly detoxifying, which is the main reason massage therapists often insist you drink water after treatments (to “flush” the released toxins). But, ironically, massage may actually backfire and “toxify” rather than detox. Certainly there’s no evidence that massage detoxifies.
The onus is on promoters of detox to show their kits and potions and methods actually deliver as promised — but they don’t, because they haven’t done the studies.
Is detox harmful?
If they provide no benefit, is there the potential for detox treatments to harm?
When it comes to simple dietary changes, there’s little evidence of harm. Eating more quinoa and kale, and less processed and refined foods is reasonable dietary advice for everyone. Homeopathic “detox” is also likely safe — with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. As you get into more unorthodox detox treatments that actually contain active ingredients, there is the potential for harm. Coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Harms such as septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been reported. Even deaths have occurred. Vitamin injections won’t provide you with any medical benefits but don’t seem as risky, as long as you trust the sterile technique of your alternative provider. However, given some naturopaths seem to be willing to inject products intended for oral use, you might want to think carefully about taking a vitamin injection or chelation treatment, especially when there’s no upside — only risk to your health and to your wallet.
What about the detox kits? Contents vary, but typically contain two categories of ingredients:
     1.  A liver “booster” — typically milk thistle (Silybum marianum). If the liver can’t be wrung out and rejuvenated, can it be boosted to do a better job? Milk thistle is the most popular product purported to “boost” the liver’s effectiveness. There are no published studies that demonstrate milk thistle has a detoxifying effect on the liver. Milk thistle has been studied in patients with alcoholic liver disease, and in patients with hepatitis B or C, and it has not been found to exhibit any meaningful effects. There is no evidence to suggest that consuming milk thistle will cleanse you of unnamed “toxins”.
     2.  A laxative — Typically magnesium hydroxide, senna, rhubarb, cascara, etc. Laxatives are the ingredients in detox kits that give you the effect you can see (and feel). However, these ingredients can cause dehydration and electrolyte imbalances if not used carefully. Regular use of stimulant laxatives, like senna and cascara, are ill-advised for most healthy adults due to the risk of dependence and electrolyte depletion. They’re among the most potent laxatives, usually used for short periods to alleviate significant constipation or to clear out your bowels before a medical procedure. With regular use, your bowel can grow accustomed to the effects of laxatives which may result in constipation once you stop using them. It’s a perfect case of the treatment causing the illness: After the detox, you get could conceivably become constipated: Time for another detox!
Side effects can continue once a detox ends. Some people experience post-detox effects like nausea and diarrhea. Advocate call these “cleansing reactions” and will assure you it’s “toxins leaving the body”. A more plausible, science-based explanation is that this is a consequence of restarting the digestive process after a period of catharsis, where, depending on the extent and duration of fasting, little to no digestion occurred, and the normal gastrointestinal flora may have been severely disrupted. It’s the same effect seen in hospitalized patients who have difficulty initially digesting food after being fed intravenously. The detox ingredients, and resulting catharsis, may irritate the colon to such an extent that it may take time to return to normal.
Immediate weight loss is not uncommon after a detox, especially one that involves a laxative. Unfortunately this is usually due to losses in water and possibly muscle tissue, depending on the how disruptive the detox was to normal body function. Regardless of the weight loss, the body will move back to its pre-detox weight over time if diet and activity levels remain the same.
Red flags for detox quackery
I’ve pulled a few advertisements from some of the most popular proponents of health quackery, and circled the red flags for quackery:
Homeopathic Detox: Homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. Heel is a homeopathy manufacturer recently ceased operations in Canada and the USA under threat of a class action lawsuit. Now a new manufacturer is reselling the same products. They have no medicinal ingredients in them. Dana Ullman is a homeopathy proponent who often contributes to The Huffington Post, a site that more often than not gets the science wrong. In this advertisement from Ullman’s site, the Heel “Homeopathic Detox Kit” is now just called a “Cleanse Kit”:
Mercola.com is one of the biggest purveyors of health quackery online. Note how the site encourages a fear of unnamed “chemicals.”
Natural News: Mike Adams of Natural News is a conspiracy theorist and purveyor of pseudoscience and bad health information. It’s wise to ignore anything you read at Natural News. Here Adams uses the naturalistic fallacy to promote the idea that GMOs are toxic, when there’s zero evidence that’s the case:
Dr. Oz is the biggest purveyor of health pseudoscience on television today. More often than not, his health advice is wrong, except when it comes to detox, when it’s consistently wrong.
The Food Babe: Vani Hari also promotes the nonsensical idea of “detox”. Her writing suggests she lacks an understanding of medicine, nutrition, and basic biology.
Conclusion
Any product or service with the words “detox” or “cleanse” in the name is only truly effective at cleansing your wallet of cash. Alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. They do have the ability to harm however — not only direct effects, like coffee enemas and purgatives, but they also distract and confuse people about how the body actually works and what we need to do to keep it healthy. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

Detox: What “They” Don’t Want You To Know
Before you start your New Year’s detox, here’s a tip that will save you time, money, and possibly your health.
Scott Gavura on January 2, 2022
Link

Happy New Year! Today’s post updates some old – but still relevant – material.
New Year, New You, right? It’s 2022. We’re entering the third year of the pandemic. You’re resolving to finally get serious about your health. That’s great.
But first, you apparently need to cleanse yourself, eliminating last year’s lifestyle and dietary sins. Some even think you need to detox from all those COVID vaccine injections. Supplements, tea, homeopathy, coffee enemas, ear candles, and footbaths all seem to promise better health. Amazon has entire detox and cleansing categories in supplements and books. The descriptions all suggest detoxing will deliver a cleaner, healthier body. Goop publishes an annual detox guide ($58 lip balm, anyone?). Senate candidate Dr. Oz has endorsed several detox plans over the years, but you may find them harder to find these days. Your local naturopath may offer detoxification protocols, including vitamin drips and chelation. Even your pharmacy probably has a wall of products for sale. Wouldn’t a purification from 2021 be a good way to start the year? Before you buy anything, there’s something very important that detox promoters aren’t telling you.
Detox is a scam
“Detox” is a case of a legitimate medical term being turned into a marketing strategy – all designed to treat a nonexistent condition. In the setting of real medicine, detoxification means treatments for dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, like heavy metals. Detoxification treatments are medical procedures that are not casually selected from a menu of alternative health treatments, or pulled off the shelf in the pharmacy. Real detoxification is provided in hospitals when there are life-threatening circumstances. But then there are the “toxins” that alternative health providers claim to eliminate. This form of detoxification is simply the co-opting of a real term to give legitimacy to useless products and services, while confusing consumers into thinking they’re science-based.

One of the widely promoted ideas about “detox” is that it acts like some sort of cleaner for your organs. Detox marketing describe your liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the reality is, the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions, using enzymes, to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated through the bile or the kidneys. The liver is self-cleansing – toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions fine. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine – otherwise the substance stays in the blood. To argue that either organ need a “cleanse” simply demonstrates a lack of understanding in biochemistry. Your organs will be fine without that supplement, smoothie, or fad diet. Just leave them alone.

But toxins!
There’s a reason we can be sucked in by the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication“, to be treated with colonics and purgatives. Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science discarded autointoxication by the 1900s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Yet the term persists today – but now it’s a marketing slogan. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that our environment is increasingly toxic, and it’s making us ill. Man-made chemicals are absolutely in our environment, so the reasoning goes that it must be making use sick. Depending on who you ask, some combination of food additives, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, not “eating clean”, or perhaps not “eating paleo” are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. So what is the actual “toxin” that is causing you vague but apparently real harm? Detox kits and treatments never name the toxins that they remove, because they’ve never been shown to actually remove toxins.
Alkali anything is a scam
The idea that our body’s acidity needs monitoring and adjusting is regularly promoted by “alternative” health providers. There is the persistent belief that anything that makes the body “acidic” is bad and anything basic or “alkali” is good. But all of this is nonsense, designed to confuse you about basic biochemistry. The pH scale is a measure of the acidity of a liquid. A pH of 7 is neutral. Anything lower is called acidic, anything higher is basic, or alkaline. The pH is a logarithmic scale – that is, a difference of 1 pH is a 10x difference.
Our blood’s pH is 7.4 – slightly alkaline or basic. Enzymes that facilitate chemical reactions in the cells work only in a narrow range of pH. Any significant change means almost certain death. A series of buffers and compensation mechanisms keep the pH in our blood from moving far from 7.4. Because the blood circulates throughout the body constantly, it can compensate any changes in pH in any of our organs (e.g., our muscles during intense exercise). Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the most prevalent acid in our body, and is a product of cellular activity. The blood carries CO2 away and eliminates it in the lungs. The lungs actually provide the biggest source of acid elimination in our body.
Everything we eat is broken down by stomach acid. The pH in our stomach is about 3 – very acidic, due to production of hydrochloric acid. Everything that is ejected from our stomach, into our intestines, is then immediately neutralized by digestive liquids and enzymes. The net effect is that everything we eat or drink and digest will eventually be at the pH in our intestines. Nothing you eat or drink will have a significant effect on the pH of food once it reaches your intestine to be absorbed. And claims that “acidity is the root of all disease” are without basis – and reflects a lack of understanding of basic physiology and biochemistry. If your detox claims to “restore” your acid-base balance, or is supposed to make you more “alkali” – it’s a sure sign of a scam.
What about coffee, but not the kind you drink?

Consuming coffee for the vast majority of people is safe and possibly even beneficial. However, there is the widespread alternative health belief that the real benefits of coffee are realized when you flush it into your rectum. Despite the hype, coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have been reported.
Coffee enemas have their roots as part of the “Gerson Treatment” for cancer, developed by physician Max Gerson in the 1940s. His regimen included coffee enemas, supplements, juice, and injections of calves’ liver. The approach has been investigated and been shown to be useless for the treatment of cancer. Some proponents of coffee enemas believe that the chemical components of coffee stimulate liver and gall bladder function. There is no credible evidence to suggest this occurs, or that it is necessary.
There are no quick fixes
        ◦ There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature. Popular ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

Detox Scams are Worthless and Potentially Dangerous
A case report of a healthy woman who landed in intensive care due to her New Year’s detox regimen highlights that detox treatments are a dangerous scam.
Steven Novella onJanuary 4, 2017
Link 


A recent case report in BMJ Case Reports tells the story of a 47 year old healthy woman who decided to do a New Year’s detox and wound up in intensive care:
A 47-year-old woman presented with seizures secondary to euvolaemic hyponatraemia. A collateral history revealed recent increased oral fluid intake and increased use of herbal remedies including valerian root over the New Year period. There was no history of psychiatric disease to support psychogenic polydipsia. She responded to careful sodium replacement in the intensive care unit and was discharged with no neurological sequelae.
It seems about once a year we remind our readers that detox is a scam. The basic idea is that modern life results in the accumulation of “toxins” in your body, and every now and then you should have a tune up by flushing those toxins out. The specific toxins are never mentioned. There is also no basic science reason or clinical evidence to support the notion that the methods recommended actually remove any specific toxins from the body.
Of course we are assaulted by toxins on a daily basis. Everything is potentially a toxin – as the saying goes, the dose makes the poison. Some things are toxic at tiny doses while others would require a significant dose to cause problems. Even water is toxic at high enough dose (usually around 10 liters or more per day).
The natural world basically wants to kill us. Plants evolved toxins to protect themselves from being eaten, for example. That is why animals evolved mechanisms to process and remove toxins that get into their system. One primary function of our livers, which are giant chemical factories, is to filter anything potentially toxic from the blood, metabolize it, and excrete it. Toxins are also filtered from the blood by the kidneys, and excreted in the urine. A healthy liver and pair of kidneys are all most of us need to sufficiently “detox.”
Problems arise when the liver or kidneys are not healthy enough to do their job, or if you ingest a poison in a sufficient dose to overwhelm these organs.
Sometimes people deliberately expose themselves to harmful levels of a drug (alcohol, for example), and may need to be legitimately “detoxed” from that drug.
The detox scam
The term “detox,” however, has been hijacked for clever marketing of worthless products and treatments. Like much of what happens under the umbrella of so-called alternative medicine, a successful marketing slogan is more important than science or evidence. “Detox” is now frequently attached to many dubious treatments as a handwaving explanation for how they allegedly work. This is often the case, where a new idea is retrofitted onto an old treatment. In fact the treatments rarely change, but the justification for them evolves to optimize marketing.
Some detox treatments include coffee enemas, with the idea that many toxins get clogged up in the colon. Other “colon cleanse” products are meant to be consumed orally. This is as unnecessary as “detox.” The colon removes waste on its own – that’s what it does.
You can also detox (by which I mean waste your time and money accomplishing nothing) by soaking your feet in a bath. They may use some kind of salt or even gentle electric current to draw out the toxins. Offered as evidence that the foot baths are working, the water will become dark over time. This is simply a result of corrosion of the electrodes in the salt solution. Detox foot pads are similar, and also offer discoloration of the pads as evidence they are working. The color change there is likely due to chemicals contained in the pads which simply oxidize.
The changing color is a simple parlor trick meant to deceive the unwary, and in both cases the water or pad will change color even if they never go near your feet. You can’t really remove significant toxins through the skin, and most of the chemicals you would want to remove are colorless.
One popular component of detox regimens, as with the case reported here, is drinking lots of water, as much as 60 liters. This is far more than is safe, and is more than enough to cause hyponatremia, which is a dangerously low sodium level in the blood. Animals evolved elaborate mechanisms to maintain electrolytes, water, and other substances in the blood and body in proper amounts. We drink when our bodies need more water, and our kidneys can concentrate the urine over a wide range to keep electrolytes like sodium within an optimal range. It takes effort to overwhelm this system in a healthy individual.
As an aside, the notion that we can do better than evolution in managing our fluid and electrolyte status is naïve. For most people in most situations, you should drink when you are thirsty. Your body knows how much fluid it needs. If you are going to be in an extreme situation (heat, dry environment, high altitude, athletic performance) then you could benefit from staying ahead of your fluid and electrolyte needs because dehydration can happen quickly. Otherwise, just listen to your thirst.
If you try to override your thirst by forcing fluid intake, your body can adjust (you will just pee out the excess) – but these mechanisms have limits. There is a minimum amount of electrolytes that pass through the urine. So if you drink too much water, you can overwhelm your kidneys’ ability to maintain a sufficient concentration of electrolytes like sodium. What you will be flushing out of your body is mainly salt. The result will be hyponatremia.
I have treated several cases of self-induced hyponatremia over the years, mostly due to primary polydipsia (drinking too much water). In one case a patient increased their water intake and was also taking a supplement called tri salts, which contains magnesium, calcium, and potassium. The kidneys had to get rid of the unnecessary and excess salts, and in doing so they also eliminated sodium. The result was hyponatremia.
Hyponatremia is extremely dangerous. It can cause delirium, and even seizures. There is also a risk of correcting the low sodium too quickly, which can cause brain damage.
Sometimes detox regimens include herbal remedies. As we have discussed many times before, herbs are drugs. They typically contain many potential active ingredients in variable doses, making their effects difficult to predict. The herbal industry is also poorly regulated, leading to a high risk of substitution, contamination, and adulteration.
Even when the bottle contains what is on the label, we generally have a dearth of information about all the risks and effects of the poorly-regulated drugs.
This brings us back to the current case report. The patient did increase their fluid intake, but according to the case report, not enough by itself to explain the hyponatremia. The authors can only speculate about what other factors were at work, and their attention turned to the many herbal supplements she included in her regimen. It is possible that one or more of the herbal drugs are diuretics, which themselves can contribute to hyponatremia.
The authors found another case report of a man who suffered hyponatremia after taking herbal drugs. The one herbal product that the two cases have in common is valerian root. Valerian root is known to be a diuretic, so this is a possible mechanism.
The lesson
There are several lessons we can take from this case and others like it. The big one, in my opinion, is the realization that there are two worlds out there. There is the medical world which is based on science and evidence, and strives for a coherent understanding of health, disease, and medication interventions. This exists alongside an “alternative” world which is not built upon logic and evidence, but upon marketing of appealing and simplistic narratives.
The notion of a “detox” treatment is one such narrative. It is not based on our understanding of biology or medicine, and in fact runs contrary to it. Detox treatments are entirely unnecessary, and should not be assumed to be benign.
Another lesson is that we cannot simplistically hack our health and think that we can do better than the elaborate feedback systems that evolved to maintain optimal physiology. This applies to many claims within so-called alternative medicine – taking megadoses of vitamins, shifting the balance of oxidative compounds, or drinking more than our bodies seem to want.
Finally, we should not assume that any intervention “can’t hurt.” As a matter of principle, if something can help, then it can also hurt. No intervention is entirely benign. That is part of the CAM narrative, however, that treatments which are “natural” are magically risk free. This and other cases prove otherwise.
All interventions should be considered in the context of risk vs benefit, with the best evidence available being the guide.
Detox treatments have no benefit, and as this case illustrates they also have risk. Stay away.

“Detox”: Ritual purification masquerading as medicine and wellness
If the “central dogma” of alternative medicine is that wishing makes it so, one of the most important of the other organizing dogmas of alternative medicine is that “toxins,” whether they come from inside or outside, are making us sick and that we can’t be healthy until we “detoxify.” This is far more a religious belief than a science-based one.
David Gorski on January 30, 2017
Link

“You need to detox.”
How many times have you heard or read this? Maybe a friend of yours suggested it for the New Year. Maybe you saw it on a website, in a magazine, or as part of an ad. I like to say sometimes, “Toujours les toxines,” because in many branches of alternative medicine the overarching idea behind the interventions used is that vague, unnamed “toxins” are somehow poisoning you and that the only way to fix what’s wrong with you is to “detoxify.” These “detox” interventions can take many forms, ranging from the relatively (but not completely) benign, such as “juice cleanses,” to the downright dangerous, such as chelation therapy.
I’ve been meaning to return to the topic of “detoxification” in alternative medicine (or, as I now like to call it, fake medicine) since earlier this month, when Dr. Daniel Neides, the medical director of The Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute, published a virulently antivaccine article for a local news website. He was, of course, widely condemned—and quite rightly so—for his article, which was loaded with tired antivaccine tropes that I’ve been battling at least since 2005, and the Clinic promised disciplinary action and loudly proclaimed its pro-vaccine bona fides. Unfortunately, Dr. Toby Cosgrove, CEO of The Cleveland Clinic later doubled down on his hospital’s support for the pseudoscience and fake medicine that it has embraced through its Wellness Institute, Center for Functional Medicine, and traditional Chinese herbal medicine clinic. In his article, just as Capt. Renault in Casablanca was “shocked—shocked—to find that gambling is going on” in Rick’s cafe, Dr. Cosgrove came across as “shocked” that there is antivaccine pseudoscience at his Wellness Institute. The key difference, of course, is that, in contrast to Renault, who was obviously cynically making up an excuse to shut down Rick’s establishment at the bidding of the Nazi occupiers, Dr. Cosgrove seemed genuinely clueless how the sort of “detox” quackery his Wellness Institute had embraced led in a pretty straight line to antivaccine quackery, much of which is based on the same ideas, only with vaccines as the source of the “toxins.” On the other hand, Dr. Mark Hyman’s Center for Functional Medicine still exists at the Clinic, and Hyman still has an important position as its founder and titular head. Given that Hyman co-authored an antivaccine book of the thimerosal fear mongering variety (toxins!) along with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. right around the time that the Clinic hired him and even appeared on The Dr. Oz Show with RFK Jr. to promote it ten days before his hiring was announced, maybe Dr. Cosgrove is more like Capt. Renault than I’d like to believe. In any event, if you’re selling homeopathic detox kits on your online store, as The Cleveland Clinic was, you either believe in the pseudoscience or care more about money than good medicine.
I’ve discussed what I consider to be the “central dogma” of alternative medicine before, namely that wishing makes it so. If that’s the central dogma, the belief that your body has been so overwhelmed by toxins that you need to remove to be healthy is one of the top—if not the top—additional dogmas, and I do mean dogma. As you will see, the belief in “detoxification” resembles a belief common in many religions that sinners (or those who do wrong in the eyes of the deity) are somehow “unclean” and must undergo ritual purification in order to be on the deity’s good side again. The ideas behind “detox,” more than anything else, resemble ideas undergirding those of ritual purification, with unnamed “toxins” rather than sins or impure thoughts and deeds being the cause of the taint producing the unclean state that must be purified.
Autointoxication: Beware the toxins within!
If there is someone who never wavers in promoting what I consider to be cancer quackery, it’s Ty Bollinger. Bollinger, as you might recall, is the quack behind a video series entitled The Truth About Cancer: A Global Quest. My skeptical antennae always start a’twitchin’ fiercely whenever I see something entitled “The Truth About…” and, as Harriet described, Bollinger’s video series is no exception. Truth be told, I tried to watch the series, but the first episode contained so much misinformation, pseudoscience, and, yes, “alternative facts,” that I didn’t see how I could do the whole series justice without doing a blog post on each installment given my in-depth knowledge of why pretty much everything in the series was quackery. I sampled other episodes and found the same thing. Let’s just put it this way, Bollinger interviewed a rogue’s gallery of quacks, including Matthias Rath, Mike “Health Ranger” Adams, Joseph Mercola, Jonathan Wright, Rashid Buttar, Russell Blaylock, Stanislaw Burzynski, and Tullio Simoncini.
So it’s not surprising that Bollinger promotes “detoxification,” and the article I came across over the weekend thanks to my being on his mailing list is the epitome of “thinking” about detox, if you can call it that. In his article entitled “Fact Over Fad: Why Body Detoxification is Essential for Vibrant Health” Bollinger lays out one of the central premises of a lot of alternative medicine quackery (but I repeat myself):
Growing older is unavoidable. It’s a reality that each and every one of us will one day have to face as part of the collective human condition. And yet, while nobody can escape the aging process entirely, the good news is that we can avoid some of the worst effects by simply making the right lifestyle choices.
Wherever you currently fall on the age spectrum, there are immense benefits to be had from properly maintaining your body. Even if you’re just now starting down the path to better health. Just like your car requires regular maintenance in the form of routine oil changes, new tires, fresh coolant, and a thorough washing and detailing… so is regular body detoxification a necessity for optimal health.
I hate this analogy. The body is not a car; it is orders of magnitude more complex than a car. More importantly, a car is not designed to fix itself or replenish its own fluids. In contrast, the human body has evolved over billions of years, all the way back to the simplest one cell organisms, to be self-sustaining and self-“detoxifying,” needing little more than adequate nutrition (fuel), water, and activity to maintain itself. Yet quacks like Bollinger often make this analogy, selling “detox” pseudoscience as “routine maintenance” of the body.
Before I go into Bollinger’s flawed analogy more, I can’t help but ask: Where do all these “toxins” come from? What are they? There are commonly two sources. One is internal and is known as “autointoxication.” The basic idea behind autointoxication is that our bodies are constantly building up waste “toxins” that are slowly poisoning us. While it is true that our bodies constantly produce waste, some of which can be toxic, it is also true that our bodies have a number of systems of disposing of them, including the kidneys (which eliminate waste through urine), the lungs (which eliminate the CO2 produced by the “burning” of nutrients for energy), the liver (which can chemically transform many toxins to render them harmless and able to be excreted), and of course the colon, which houses and eliminates the solid waste from digesting our food.
The colon, of course, is the focus of a lot of “detox” quackery, based on the mistaken belief that feces are constantly building up in our colons to the point that a typical adult has ten or even twenty pounds of waste built up in their colons that is slowly leaching out into the bloodstream to poison the rest of the body. Just Google “death begins in the colon,” which is a common saying among believers in this sort, and you’ll get the idea. This concept is the rationale for “colon cleanses,” which often involve juices, purgatives, and enemas, including coffee enemas. Of course, any surgeon who’s ever operated on the colon or performed colonoscopy on patients with unprepped bowel (which is sometimes necessary in emergencies), as I used to do before I specialized in breast cancer, knows that this is an utterly fantastical claim. Except in the case of colon obstruction or toxic megacolon there is nowhere near that much feces in a typical colon, and the colon is quite good at containing it and eliminating it. That’s what it evolved to do.
Ironically, autointoxication as the cause of disease was mainstream medicine as recently as the early 20th century, and it’s a concept that dates back to the ancient Egyptians, possibly earlier. Egyptian priest-physicians (Egyptian medicine originated in the priesthood) believed that a putrefactive principle associated with feces was somehow absorbed by the body, where it acted to produce fever and pus. Later, the ancient Greeks extended the idea beyond digestive waste in the colon to include the four humors and incorporate the concept into the humoral theory of medicine. Even so, it was also a concept promulgated by proponents of scientific medicine as late as the early 1900s. The concept was very much like what I’ve described so far, namely that putrefactive products of digestion remained in the colon, there to leach into the bloodstream and sicken patients due to autointoxication. Indeed, some surgeons, chief among them Sir W. Arbuthnot Lane, advocated total colectomy for the autointoxication that was thought to be the cause of diseases ranging from lassitude to epilepsy. I even remember the concept showing up in an episode of The Knick, a series that portrayed a fictional 1900-era hospital in Manhattan, in which the wife of one of the surgeons at the Knick was treated for severe depression by Dr. Henry Cotton (an actual doctor from the period), who removed all her teeth because he believed that “all mental disorders stem from disease and infection polluting the brain.” If she didn’t respond, he was then going to remove her tonsils and adenoids, and, if that still didn’t work, her colon.
Given that there were no antibiotics back then, intestinal surgery was fraught with peril due to the high rate of postoperative sepsis and death, making this approach reckless indeed. Eventually, even Sir Arbuthnot Lane came to the same conclusion and by the 1920s had changed his mind, deciding that diet was the answer. Also by the 1920s, science had shown that the various symptoms observed in patients with chronic constipation were largely due to distension of the bowel and were not due to autointoxication. Unfortunately, the belief that mental illness was caused by focal infection persisted longer and it took investigations in the 1920s, which found that Cotton exaggerated his success rates and downplayed his mortality rates, before the practice was finally abandoned, although Cotton was never punished. Quite the contrary, in fact. Thus, as is its wont, scientific medicine did eventually move on from a failed hypothesis, although at a pace that, from the vantage of 2017, appears frustratingly slow. In marked contrast, as is their wont, alternative medicine practitioners clung all the more tightly to this failed hypothesis, an embrace that continues to this day and show no signs of changing. Some of them would have been quite at home with the priest-physicians of ancient Egypt.
Toxins here, toxins there, toxins everywhere!
Bollinger doesn’t really focus that much on autointoxication. Although he does allude to it, he concentrates more on external toxins:
Detoxification is about a whole lot more than just a superficial notion of feeling “clean” as part of some trendy dieting fad. It’s about protecting your body against the very real and damaging effects of toxic buildup. For instance, did you know that peer-reviewed science continues to show that harboring toxins inside your body can trigger a wide array of health conditions – including everything from chronic fatigue and muscle and joint pain to brain disease and cancer?
Chronic toxic exposure is also a leading cause of obesity, which now afflicts more than one-third of Americans. A 2012 study published in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives explains how so-called “obesogens” are a major contributor to the American obesity epidemic, which more often than not is erroneously blamed solely on people eating too much rather than walking around with polluted, poor-functioning bodies.
As they say, quacks use the medical literature in much the same way a drunk uses a streetlight, for support rather than illumination. That’s just what Bollinger is doing here. Of course, like most quacks, he doesn’t actually provide a link to the reference. Fortunately, it wasn’t too hard to discover the reference, namely this article, which wasn’t a study but rather a commentary that didn’t provide any significant evidence to back up Bollinger’s claim. Certainly it didn’t conclude that “obesogens” are a major contributor to the American obesity epidemic. Reading the article, I was struck, more than anything else, by how speculative it was, at how little hard evidence its author could present to support the concept of obesogens, and, most of all, how there was almost no evidence of obesogens in humans. Pretty much all of the putative obesogens mentioned were implicated as such based on rodent experiments, with a handful of not-particularly-convincing epidemiological studies. A more recent article on the topic states the problem succinctly right in the blurb after its title: “Low doses of environmental chemicals can make animals gain weight. Whether they do the same to humans is a thorny issue“, which it is. A PubMed search I did also produced animal experiments and a lot of commentary, but no convincing evidence in humans that I could find.
Oddly enough, Bollinger also failed to back up his claim that “peer-reviewed science continues to show that harboring toxins inside your body can trigger a wide array of health conditions – including everything from chronic fatigue and muscle and joint pain to brain disease and cancer.”
Obesogens (whether they will be found to exist or not or be a major cause of human obesity or not), aside, Bollinger lists all the “toxins” that you have to avoid:
     1.  Endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs)
     2.  Pesticides
     3.  “Soft” and “heavy” metals
     4.  Fluoride
     5.  Food additives, preservatives, and growth hormones
     6.  Electronic smog
     7.  Pharmaceutical drugs
There’s even a graphic (click to embiggen):
Let’s just dispense with one of these right away. “Electronic smog” might as well be renamed “miasma.” Miasma theory, if you’ll recall, was the idea that disease was caused by miasma (μίασμα, ancient Greek: “pollution”). It was basically an attempt to explain how contagious diseases could spread in a population, which is why it rapidly lost favor after Louis Pasteur’s discoveries and the germ theory of disease was postulated. It went beyond just infectious diseases, though, with some claiming, for example, that one could become obese by inhaling the odor of food. Electrosmog is basically the concept that low level electromagnetic fields (EMFs) are causing disease, with EFMs in essence functioning as a miasma. Believers in electrosmog sometimes also add the concept of EMF hypersensitivity, with sometimes tragic results.
Among the others, fluoride is safe at the levels used, no matter how much cranks try to convince us otherwise, and, although pesticides can be harmful at high concentrations, neither those consuming food nor agricultural workers are likely to be exposed to levels high enough to cause harm. There is also surprisingly little evidence that food additives, preservatives, and the like cause harm. Endocrine disruptors, of course, are sometimes touted as The One True Cause of many disorders. It’s true that they might pose a health risk to humans, but the evidence is nowhere near what I would call clear, with most of the studies being in animals and not a lot of convincing human data collected yet, particularly at the very low concentrations humans encounter. Let’s just say that the studies are conflicting and inconclusive. If the evidence for adverse health effects in humans due to these compounds at the concentrations encountered is relatively weak, there’s practically no evidence at all that avoiding them or “detoxing” to get rid of them will have any health benefits.
Not surprisingly, it is also an article of faith among people like Bollinger that pharmaceutical drugs are more toxic than beneficial and that natural is always better; so it’s not surprising to find drugs on the list. And don’t even get me started on “heavy metals,” which are one of the most common “toxins” implicated by naturopaths and others promoting “detox” quackery and lead to dangerous therapies like chelation therapy and the wasting of tens of millions of dollars to study chelation therapy as a treatment for cardiovascular disease.
The bottom line, from Bollinger’s line of thinking (if you can call it that) is that the products of modern life are leaving toxins here, toxins there, toxins everywhere that are slowly killing you, and if you don’t “detox” first trying to lose weight might kill you:
The problem with trying to lose weight before detoxifying is that toxins tend to live inside fat tissue. This means that the minute you start burning off that spare tire, those toxins will immediately start flooding your system. Depending on your personal level of toxicity, this process might overwhelm your vital organs.
Many holistic practitioners recommend doing a series of detox cleanses before trying to actively lose weight. This isn’t to say that you should intentionally hold off trying to clean up your diet out of fear of toxic overload. Rather, you should do a few things first before embarking on a major dietary overhaul that could cause you to lose a lot of weight very quickly.
This is, of course, nonsense, as is Bollinger’s implication that you can never be healthy unless you “detox.”
But how do you detox?
Elsewhere on Bollinger’s website, there is a video promoting his three DVD documentary series on The Truth About Detox. Right at the beginning, Bollinger asks:
What if I told you that disease doesn’t just strike at a whim? What if I told you that you’ve been lied to about what’s really going on? I’m going to show you the reasons why cancer, autoimmune diseases, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, degenerative brain diseases like Alzheimer’s and dementia, as well as host of life-destroying symptoms like hair loss, skin outbreaks, unwanted weight gain, depression, and fatigue are on such a dramatic rise today and you are at serious risk. You’re about to discover that all these diseases and symptoms have toxic causes that you aren’t being told about. Sadly, you’re also not being told about the true solutions to these life-destroying diseases and symptoms.
Later, he claims that in this day and age that we’re being “bombarded with more chemicals than ever before in the history of mankind,” a claim that is full of hyperbole. All you have to do is to compare photos of the pollution 50 or 100 years ago to realize that the environment, at least in developed countries, is way cleaner now than it was then. Just the removal of lead from gasoline did wonders for reducing exposure to toxic lead, and that’s not the only example. However, the whole concept behind “detox” is an old one, namely that modernity is killing us and that things were better when humans lived close to nature. (That must be why life expectancy back then was so poor.) Bollinger even says that there are some “crazy” detox schemes out there as a way of portraying his as rational.
So, to find out how to detox, you have to buy Bollinger’s DVD, although he does have an article on how to detox from chemotherapy. In it, Dr. Veronique Desaulniers recommends “detoxing” from chemotherapy using broccoli, beta glucans, curcumin, chorella, and hyperthermia. Lovely. Of course, this particular doctor goes by the name “Dr. V” and promotes a veritable cornucopia of cancer quackery, including laetrile, bio-Energetics, thermography, meridian stress analysis, homeopathy, and chiropractic.
In reality, there is so much “detox” quackery that it’s really hard to summarize it all. Indeed, pretty much any alternative medicine treatment can claim to be “detox.” I’ve even seen ridiculous claims that acupuncture works through “detox,” thanks to a claimed diuretic effect. However, most “detox” falls into one of these categories:
    • Dietary. Often this involves juices, supplements, and the like. The Gerson protocol incorporates a lot of this, along with a whole lot of supplements.
    • Enemas and laxatives. If you’re going to purge yourself of those autointoxication toxins, you have to get rid of all the nasty feces supposedly hiding out in your colon. Often, the enemas use coffee or other substances, not water.
    • Sweat. Often “detox” involves “sweating out” the toxins, through sweat lodges, saunas, including infrared saunas.
    • Chelation therapy. If “heavy metals” are poisoning you, the only way to get rid of them, if you believe naturopaths and other practitioners of fake medicine, is to use chemicals that bind to the metals and allow you to pee them out. A lot of antivaccine quackery involves chelation therapy.
    • Activated charcoal. When medically indicated, doctors use activated charcoal to treat acute poisoning. It is not absorbed from the gastrointestinal tract, but it does absorb a wide variety of chemicals and prevent the GI tract from absorbing them. Usually a nasogastric tube has to be inserted to pour the slurry of activated charcoal into the stomach because most people can’t swallow it, particularly if their consciousness is impaired. It’s also being added to juice detoxes in amounts far below what is really necessary to do real detoxification (were there any actual poisons ingested) as more of a marketing gimmick than anything.
These methods are, of course, mixed and matched, depending on the specific protocol, and there are many variants.
Detox is a scam
There is a role for detoxification in science-based medicine, but it is very limited. Specifically, some detoxification treatments, like chelation therapy or activated charcoal, are used in the case of acute poisonings. Hemodialysis is used to replace the detoxifying function of the kidneys. There is no good evidence that “toxins” of the sort that Bollinger blames for virtually all disease actually do cause all the diseases attributed to them or that routine “detox” regimens will maintain “vibrant health.” Indeed, the very concept of “detox” is based on one or both of two very old ideas, autointoxication or miasmas. Indeed, the concept behind detoxification is very ancient indeed and resembles in concept, more than anything else, purification rituals found in many religions through many cultures throughout history designed to eliminate uncleanliness as defined by the religion. I can’t help but conclude that the religion behind the purification rituals of detox is a form of modernized nature worship.
It saddens me that so many academic medical centers, like The Cleveland Clinic, are embracing forms of medicine that rely on such prescientific and mystical concepts. I wonder if we can find a way to convince the woo-friendly that vaccines are a powerful talisman to ward off miasmas and toxins.

The one thing you need to know before you detox
Before you start your New Year’s detox, this one weird tip will save you time, money, and possibly your health.
Scott Gavura on December 31, 2015
Link

New Year, New You, right? Here’s a perennially popular post, revised for 2016.
With 2016 upon us, it’s finally time get serious about your health. You’re resolving to eat better and exercise more. But first, you need to reset your body – and purge yourself of all of your lifestyle and dietary overindulgences. But how? The options seem limitless, and everyone has advice: There’s Dr. Oz, Gwyneth, and even your favourite Kardashian has advice: They’re all telling you how it’s essential to “detox”, “cleanse” and “flush” away all of your toxins. Your local pharmacy has an ever-growing section of products promising a newer, more pure you: supplements, homeopathy, ear candles, and an entire aisle of “detox kits” all promise to suck toxins out of your body. Don’t forget your local naturopath who sells IV vitamin drips as the detoxification solution to your problems. The approaches may differ but all the advocates are completely convinced of one fact: Detoxing will deliver a renewed body and better health. Not only will you look better, you’ll feel better. It is a new year. Wouldn’t a purification from last year’s habits (dietary and otherwise) of last year be the best way to start? Well before you pull out your credit card, there is one fact that “detox” advocates are reluctant to tell you.
“Detox” is a scam
“Detox” is a legitimate medical term that has been co-opted to sell useless products and services. It is a fake treatment for a fake condition. Real detoxification isn’t ordered from a menu at a juice bar, or assembled from supplies in your pantry. Real detoxification is provided in hospitals under life-threatening circumstances — usually when there are dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or other poisons in the body. Drugs used for real detoxification are not ingredients in a smoothie. What’s being promoted today as “detox” is little different than eons-old religious rituals of cleansing and purification. Framing detoxification in religious terms won’t have the appeal in a world that values science. So use the word “toxin”, not sin, and call the ritual a “detox” – and suddenly you’ve given your treatment a veneer of what sounds scientific. Fake detox is marketed based on three easily-debunked ideas. Once you can spot the flaws, it’s easy to spot the spin and misinformation, and to make smarter, healthier decisions.
Premise one: Our bodies are accumulating toxins, so we need to detoxify
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication.” Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science discarded autointoxication by the 1900’s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Yet the term persists today – but now it’s marketing slogan. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that our environment is increasingly toxic, and it’s making us ill. Depending on who you ask, some combination of food additives, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, not “eating clean”, or perhaps not “eating paleo” are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. And don’t forget gluten. Gluten is evil and therefore it is a toxin. (Never mind the science.) So what is the actual “toxin” that is causing you vague but apparently real harm? Detox kits and treatments never name the toxins that they remove, because they’ve never been shown to remove toxins. Picking one common drug store detox kit, Renew Life says:
Did you know that we come into contact with toxins every day—from the environment, our food, and even within our own digestive tract? While the body was built to process these toxins, today’s world places increased stress on our elimination channels. Renew Life Advanced Cleansing Programs are powerfully formulated to promote regular elimination and support the body’s natural detoxification process.* They provide targeted support to the body’s pathways of elimination: liver, lungs, lymphatic system, kidneys, skin, blood, and bowel.*
Note the vague language, which is universal with detox kits and treatments. Toxins are alluded to — but not named. It sounds somewhat plausible, but is non-specific.
The colon remains ground zero for detox advocates. Advertisements may argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, Candida (yeast) and other nastiness. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. Ask any gastroenterologist (who look inside colons for a living) if they’ve ever seen one. There isn’t a single case of mucoid plaque that’s been documented in the medical literature. Not one. The same can be said for rope worms. The do not exist.
Premise two: Illness is the result of chemical toxins
Marketing materials for detox treatments typically describe an array of symptoms and diseases linked to toxin buildup: A few that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specifics to frighten you (cancer, etc.) Which toxins cause which disease is left out, and how the toxins cause the symptoms is never actually explained. Here again we see the contrast with real science. To establish that even a single chemical can cause disease requires a significant amount of research. Despite the variety of toxins that are claimed to be causing your illness, marketing claims for detox treatments always fail to link specific toxins to specific symptoms or illnesses. That’s because they can’t — there is no scientific evidence to show that detox treatments have any useful medical effects.
The reality is that our bodies are constantly being exposed to a huge variety of natural and synthetic chemicals. Air is chemicals. Food is chemicals. Drugs are chemicals. Herbs are chemicals. The presence of any chemical in the body, (natural or synthetic) does not mean that it is doing harm. Many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, and consequently the human body has evolved a remarkable system of defenses and mechanisms to defend against, and remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up our astoundingly complex and sophisticated intrinsic detoxification system.
Advocates for detox typically describe the liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs need to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d squeeze out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the reality is that the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated in bile or urine. The liver is self-cleansing — toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions without any problem. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine — otherwise the substance stays in the blood. Anyone that suggests these organs need a “cleanse” is demonstrating that they don’t understand basic anatomy or physiology.
Premise three: Detox diets and treatments remove toxins
A recent review of detox diets in the Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics provides the best summary of the evidence supporting detox diets:
To the best of our knowledge, no rigorous clinical investigations of detox diets have been conducted. The handful of studies that have been published suffer from significant methodological limitations including small sample sizes, sampling bias, lack of control groups, reliance on self-report and qualitative rather than quantitative measurements.
The authors could find only a single detox product has been evaluated in the literature. Ultra Clear is a supplement that is claimed to detoxify the liver. The “evaluation” of Ultra Clear, was not blinded, and lacked any controls. The research subjects were 25 naturopathy students. Perhaps not surprisingly, the students reported improvements on a number of measures – but without a properly designed trial, the results don’t provide any evidence that the product is effective.
In general, there was no credible evidence to demonstrate that detox kits do anything at all. While they can be very unpleasant, they have not been shown to remove “toxins” or offer any health benefits. Coffee enemas are commonly promoted as toxin-removers. Coffee enemas offer no medical benefits. Vitamin injections are a popular naturopathic offering that has not been shown to provide meaningful benefits to consumers, as it has no beneficial effect on the ability of your liver or kidneys to work effectively. Chelation injections are touted as a cure-all for all kinds of illnesses, but unlike real chelation that is administered in hospitals for real cases of poisoning, naturopath chelation is not science-based and doesn’t seem to do much of anything (except enrich its proponents).
There is just as little evidence for detox programs. The only one to have been evaluated is via L. Ron Hubbard and the Church of Scientology, called the Hubbard Purification Rundown. It involves niacin supplements, saunas, exercise, polyunsaturated oil consumption, and vitamins, minerals and electrolytes. The protocol was used on a small group of firefighters after 9/11. With small sample sizes and no control groups, any critical evaluation of the results is impossible. Another evaluation with firefighters was equally limited by a lack of proper randomization and blinding. The same protocol was also used in healthy volunteers. Owing to a lack of blinding and placebo, the results are not credible, which is probably why the paper ended up published in Medical Hypotheses.
The bottom line? The onus is on promoters of detox to show their kits and protocols and methods actually deliver as promised — but they don’t, because they don’t have the evidence and they haven’t done the studies. If someone tells you that a detox kit or procedure is effective, ask for evidence.
Detox treatments can be harmful
If they provide no benefit, can detox treatments harm?
When it comes to simple dietary changes, there’s little evidence of harm. Eating more quinoa and kale, and less processed and refined foods is reasonable dietary advice for everyone. Homeopathic “detox” is also likely safe — with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. As you get into more unorthodox detox treatments that actually contain active ingredients, there is the potential for harm. Coffee enemas are a detoxification process that has a real risk of harm. From a medical perspective, coffee enemas are considered unsafe. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have also been reported.
Vitamin injections won’t provide you with any medical benefits but don’t seem as risky, as long as you trust the sterile technique of your alternative provider. However, given some naturopaths seem to be willing to inject products intended for oral use, you might want to think carefully about taking a vitamin injection or chelation treatment, especially when there’s no evidence they do anything meaningful. Glutathione injections, while often touted as a “hangover cure” (among other uses) actually has very little published safety information available to support its use.
What about the detox kits found in pharmacies? Contents vary, but typically contain two categories of ingredients:
     1.  A liver “booster” — typically milk thistle (Silybum marianum). If the liver can’t be wrung out and rejuvenated, can it be boosted to do a better job? Milk thistle is the most popular product purported to “boost” the liver’s effectiveness. Milk thistle has been studied in patients with alcoholic liver disease, and in patients with hepatitis B or C, and it has not been found to exhibit any meaningful effects. There is conflicting evidence on the use of silymarin, a milk thistle constituent, for acute toxic liver damage, but there is no published evidence to suggest that consuming milk thistle will cleanse you of unnamed, non-specific “toxins”.
     2.  A laxative — Typically magnesium hydroxide, senna, rhubarb, cascara, etc. Laxatives are the ingredients in detox kits that give you the effect you can see (and feel). However, these ingredients can cause dehydration and electrolyte imbalances if not used carefully. Regular use of stimulant laxatives, like senna and cascara, are ill-advised for most healthy adults due to the risk of dependence and electrolyte depletion. They’re among the most potent laxatives, usually used for short periods to alleviate significant constipation or to clear out your bowels before a medical procedure. With regular use, your bowel can grow accustomed to the effects of laxatives which may result in constipation once you stop using them. It’s a perfect case of the treatment causing the illness: After the detox, you get could conceivably become constipated – just in time for another “detox”.
Side effects can continue once a detox ends. Some people experience post-detox effects like nausea and diarrhea. Advocate call these “cleansing reactions” and will assure you it’s “toxins leaving the body”. A more plausible, science-based explanation is that this is a consequence of restarting the digestive process after a period of catharsis, where, depending on the extent and duration of fasting, little to no digestion occurred, and the normal gastrointestinal colonies of bacteria may have been severely disrupted. It’s the same effect seen in hospitalized patients who have difficulty initially digesting food after being fed intravenously. The detox ingredients, and resulting catharsis, may irritate the colon to such an extent that it may take time for digestion to return to normal.
Immediate weight loss is not uncommon after a detox, especially one that involves a laxative. Unfortunately this is usually due to losses in water and possibly muscle tissue, depending on the how disruptive the detox was to normal body function. Regardless of the weight loss, the body will move back to its pre-detox weight over time if diet and activity levels remain the same.

There are no quick fixes
Any product or service advertised with the words “detox” or “cleanse” in the name is only truly effective at cleansing your wallet – of cash. Alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. They do have the ability to harm however — not only direct effects, like coffee enemas and purgatives, but they also distract and confuse people about how the body actually works and what we need to do to keep it healthy. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

Top ten signs your detox may be a scam
Before you begin a New Year’s detox, look for these ten signs you may be getting scammed.
Scott Gavura on December 28, 2017
Link

As we prepare to welcome 2018, it’s time to start thinking about your New Year’s resolutions. And what better way to start fresh in 2018 than by literally purging yourself of 2017, inside and out? You may already been seeing advertisements for all forms of detox products and services: Your local pharmacy likely has a shelf of supplements and kits that promise a svelte, glowing you within a few days. A Facebook post is promoting lemon juice, cayenne and maple syrup as a cure-all. Or there’s your local naturopathic clinic promoting IV vitamin infusions – not only will a detox make you feel better, you’ll look better too.
Unfortunately, most of the hype around detox is useless at best, and expensive and potentially harmful, at worst. Most detoxes are only successful at cleaning you of your savings, not your toxins. Here are the top ten signs that you may be getting scammed, or risking your health, with a detox. 
1. Watch for the word “homeopathic”
Homeopathic “remedies” look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on store shelves. Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, like a form of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what appears to be the active ingredients. But unlike conventional medicine, homeopathic products don’t contain any “medicine” at all. They are effectively and sometimes literally sugar pills – placebos. Not surprisingly, there is no convincing evidence to show that homeopathy has any medical value. So while there may be hundreds of homeopathic remedies for sale, they are chemically indistinguishable, usually containing just sugar, water, and/or alcohol. The best that can be said for these products is that homeopathic “detox” is likely safe — with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. It won’t remove toxins any faster than doing nothing at all. It’s notable that the FDA seems to be finally willing to take action against “potentially harmful” and “unproven” homeopathic products. Homeopathic detox, like homeopathic anything, is a scam.
2. The detox claims to treat or remove Candida
If you read alternative-health magazines, books or websites, you’ll eventually see the idea promoted that we are all apparently filled with Candida – yeast. Candida albicans is a fungus that most of us carry in or on our bodies. However, it is rarely a cause of serious or prolonged illness – the more common infections are thrush (an infection of the mouth) or vaginitis (commonly called a yeast infection), both of which are easily treatable with anti-fungal medication. Serious Candida infections are quite rare, and usually only seen in those with compromised immune systems – think cancer chemotherapy, or advanced AIDS.
Candida became a made-up cause of disease and illness in the 1980s, and alternative-medicine practitioners have never let this go, despite the lack of any evidence. That doesn’t stop people from selling “kits” that are claimed to eliminate yeast in the body. These aren’t antifungal drugs: Most are combinations of laxatives and purgatives, all promising to sponge up toxins and Candida and restore you to an Enhanced State of Wellness™. Advertisements may argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, and yeast. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. Ask any gastroenterologist (who look inside colons for a living) if they’ve ever seen one. There isn’t a single case of mucoid plaque that’s been documented in the medical literature. Not one. If you have a widespread candida infection, you’re seriously ill and need to be under the care of a medical professional – not anyone telling you that Candida is what you need to eliminate in your detox.
3. Intravenous vitamin infusions
Forget getting your vitamins from food, or even from a vitamin pill. For the real detox, you apparently need to bypass your digestive system entirely. Roll up your sleeve, find a vein, insert a needle and watch that colourful concoction flow directly into the bloodstream. It may sound somewhat illicit, but that person infusing it is wearing a white coat, and you’re sitting in a chic clinic. There must be something to it, right? Sadly, despite the hype and all the endorsements from pro athletes and celebrities, there is no credible evidence to suggest that routine vitamin infusions are necessary or offer any meaningful health benefit. Vitamin infusions are a marketing creation, giving the illusion you’re doing something for your health, but lacking any demonstrable efficacy. Yes, there is an established medical role for injectable vitamins, though it’s no energy-boosting cure-all – they’re used to replace what we should obtain in our diet, when we cannot eat. With so many purveyors of vitamin infusions, one would hope the practice was grounded in good science. But despite the lack of good evidence, there is a near-obsessive devotion to touting the benefits of intravenous vitamins while railing against the mysterious entities (like me, and this post) which are blocking The Truth. But the reality is more mundane. In the absence of a deficiency, vitamin infusions don’t do much of anything. And they’re not free of risk – anytime you allow your skin to be punctured, there’s a small but non-zero risk of an infection. Do you trust getting an injection of chemicals from someone that isn’t a health professional, and is only trying to get you to buy something? If you need hydration, drink some water. And if your body needs vitamins, eat some food.
4. It’s coffee, but not the kind you drink

I wrote a few weeks ago about the potential health benefits of coffee consumption. Consuming coffee for the vast majority of people is safe and possibly even beneficial. However, there is the widespread alternative health belief that the only real benefits of coffee are delivered when you flush it into your rectum. Despite the hype, coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have been reported.
Coffee enemas have their roots as part of the “Gerson Treatment” for cancer, developed by physician Max Gerson in the 1940s. His regimen included coffee enemas, supplements, juice, and injections of calves’ liver. The approach has been investigated and been shown to be useless for the treatment of cancer. Some proponents of coffee enemas believe that the chemical components of coffee stimulate liver and gall bladder function. There is no credible evidence to suggest this occurs, or that it is necessary. Your liver and gallbladder don’t need a coffee enema in order to work effectively. They will work just fine on their own.
5. It contains activated charcoal
Activated charcoal is a medicine and drug sponge – it’s used routinely for poisonings. So will it work if you’ve overindulged in tequila and tacos? Compared to real detoxification protocols, the amount of charcoal in detox products is tiny. And despite the marketing hype, activated charcoal has no ability to suck out the toxic chemicals from the rest of your body once they’re absorbed. Its effects are limited to the gastrointestinal tract only, and it’s been studied in poisoning situations only. While ingesting charcoal is probably going to be well tolerated, taking it with a healthy diet is exactly what you want to avoid. Activated charcoal appears to bond vitamins like ascorbic acid (vitamin C), niacin, pyridoxine (vitamin B6), thiamine (vitamin B1) and biotin, so it has the potential to make food and drinks you consume actually less nutritious, not more. The only reason you should be taking activated charcoal is when the emergency room physician is telling you it’s going to save your life. Otherwise, consider anything with activated charcoal to be a warning flag for something promoted without credible evidence.
6. The detox is promoted by a naturopath
Britt Marie Hermes is an ex-naturopath who described how she set up and promoted her own detox program:
It is surprisingly easy to sell snake-oil. I know, because I’ve done it. In 2014, I helped create and sell The Right Detox. This was a bogus detoxification program that purported to improve anyone’s well-being and perhaps, cure disease. I was the face of the scam. I launched The Right Detox at a spring-time women’s health expo in Tucson, Arizona.
and
Detox programs are created with one goal: make money. I am not generalizing here. I’ve helped create detox programs at more than one clinic. In each instance, the decisions to include specific detox supplements, protein powder shakes, or therapies were based on profit margins.
and
We pretended that patients could save money by buying supplements in bulk or by starting the detox program with a group of friends. We were hoping to increase business by luring customers into becoming long-term patients. It worked. They would come to the practice ready to invest more time, energy, and money into their healthcare regimen. We were ready to sell them false promises and false hope in the form of supplements and naturopathic therapies like intravenous vitamin drips, enemas, and far-infrared saunas. The detox program did not help patients achieve their health goals.
Read Britt’s entire post for the warning signs of naturopathic detox plans.
7. Alkali Anything
The idea that our body’s acidity needs monitoring and adjusting is regularly promoted by “alternative” health providers. There is the widespread belief that anything that makes the body “acidic” is bad and anything basic or “alkali” is good. But all of this is nonsense, designed to confuse you about basic biochemistry. The pH scale is a measure of the acidity of a liquid. A pH of 7 is neutral. Anything lower is called acidic, anything higher is basic, or alkaline. The pH is a logarithmic scale – that is, a difference of 1 pH is a 10x difference.
Our blood’s pH is 7.4 – slightly alkaline or basic. Enzymes that facilitate chemical reactions in the cells work only in a narrow range of pH. Any significant change means almost certain death. A series of buffers and compensation mechanisms keep the pH in our blood from moving far from 7.4. Because the blood circulates throughout the body constantly, it can compensate any changes in pH in any of our organs (e.g., our muscles during intense exercise). Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the most prevalent acid in our body, and is a product of cellular activity. The blood carries CO2 away and eliminates it in the lungs. The lungs actually provide the biggest source of acid elimination in our body.
Everything we eat is broken down by stomach acid. The pH in our stomach is about 3 – very acidic, due to production of hydrochloric acid. Everything that is ejected from our stomach, into our intestines, is then immediately neutralized by digestive liquids and enzymes. The net effect is that everything we eat or drink and digest will eventually be at the pH in our intestines. Nothing you eat or drink will have a significant effect on the pH of food once it reaches your intestine to be absorbed. And claims that “acidity is the root of all disease” are without basis – and reflects a lack of understanding of basic physiology and biochemistry. If your detox claims to “restore” your acid-base balance, or is supposed to make you more “alkali” – it’s a sure sign of a scam.
8. “Recommended by Goop”
Gwyneth Paltrow’s website was in the news repeatedly in 2017 – not all of it positively. Goop promotes the most absurd pseudoscience, so much so that it must be making Dr. Oz blush. A search for “detox” on the Goop website is a pretty good reflection of the lack of sensible health advice. Goop promotes a “heavy metal detox” from the “Medical Medium” Anthony William whose apparent source of knowledge is ghosts that give medical advice. Yes, ghosts. Goop also has an “anger detox” which at least isn’t trying to sell you anything. Goop’s diet detoxes offer some reasonable-looking recipes and advice (cutting back on caffeine, alcohol and added sugar) with highly restrictive and unnecessary food restrictions, like rice, soy, corn, red meat, gluten, shellfish, nightshades and dairy. Pass the kale smoothie? As David Gorski wrote earlier this year:
Now, a shruggie might say that this is all harmless nonsense. Beauty products have always featured a healthy helping of woo, after all. But that’s not all Goop promotes. It also promotes The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy, plus other quackery like detox cleanses, naturopathy, colon cleanses, functional medicine, and a whole lot of dubious fad diets. This dubious medical advice is then coupled with fear mongering about “mold toxicity,” the Epstein-Barr Virus as the root of all chronic illness, and the long-debunked claim that bras predispose to breast cancer. So, yes, it might be amusing that Paltrow has claimed that there are all sorts of “toxins” in shampoo (which is, of course, why she says you should buy her shampoos) or that goat’s milk is the cure for what ails you, but she’s fused the usually relatively minor woo associated with beauty and “wellness” with some serious quackery. She’s basically taken beauty woo and weaponized it into something that is no longer just a relatively harmless bit of nonsense for customers with, as comedians Mitchell and Webb once put it, a “vague sense of unease, a touch of the nerves, or even just more money than sense.” It’s gotten serious.
There is every reason to be suspicious of anything that Goop recommends you do or buy. Its detox advice is no exception.
9. The detox doesn’t name the specific toxins that are removed
Marketing materials for detox treatments will usually list symptoms and even diseases that are claimed to be the result of “toxins”: Several that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specific enough to frighten you into buying (cancer, etc.) Which toxins cause which disease is left out, and how the toxins cause the symptoms is never actually explained. Despite the variety of toxins that are claimed to be causing your illness, marketing claims for bogus detox treatments will never list the toxins that are removed – that’s because these detox kits have never been proven to actually remove toxins at all. They always fail to link specific toxins to specific symptoms or illnesses. There is no credible evidence to demonstrate that detox kits/plans/diets remove toxins that are the cause of health problems.
10. The detox is said to clean your organs
One of the widely promoted ideas about “detox” is that is acts like some sort of cleaner for your organs. Detox advertising describe your liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the reality is, the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions, using enzymes, to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated through the bile or the kidneys. The liver is self-cleansing – toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions fine. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine – otherwise the substance stays in the blood. To argue that either organ need a “cleanse” simply demonstrates a lack of understanding in biochemistry. Your organs should be fine. Just leave them alone.
So what’s a good detox?
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature. Popular ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

Are we all contaminated with chemical toxins?
Are we all being gradually poisoned by environmental toxins? And what is the evidence for detoxification kits and cleanses?
Scott Gavura on February 22, 2018
LInk


I have reached the age where my family doctor, looking at my family history, recommended I undergo a specific examination. This particular procedure required me to consume only clear liquids for a day, followed by a purgative with packaging that essentially warned me “do not leave your home.” Thinking optimistically, I decided to consider it research: My first goop-worthy cleansing and “detox”. I’m probably loaded with toxins. I don’t buy organic, I don’t wear gloves when I handle receipts, I still use an old Nalgene water bottle, and I’ve never had a good “cleansing”. Would I achieve the enlightenment and wellness that detox and cleansing advocates promise? The reality was much less pleasant: just cramping and food cravings. It took a few days before I felt back to my (presumably toxic) self.
Why would anyone choose this discomfort voluntarily? It’s because many believe that we are contaminated with chemical and various harmful substances, and that by “detoxing” our bodies (usually starting with our colon) through different types of rituals, we can reduce or eliminate various toxins.
It seems every few days there’s a new story in the media raising alarm about the risk of chronic exposure to some sort of chemical. It sounds at least plausible, because in some cases, it is true: Fish consumption warnings, like the sign above, are commonplace today, and reflect the fact that we have collectively poisoned parts of our food supply. But worries that we’re being poisoned by toxins go well back in history, before the time humans were putting mercury and PCBs into the environment. One of the oldest surviving written documents is an Egyptian papyrus from the 16th century BCE that linked the cause of disease to digestive wastes in our colon, suggesting that these types of fears may be innate. Since that time, our scientific knowledge about the cause of disease has advanced, but the underlying obsession with diet, elimination, and toxins hasn’t waned. Part of the modern appeal of “detox” may be that detoxification is a legitimate medical term and treatment. While it is used regularly in reference to the acute treatment of substance-use disorders, it’s also a term that may be used when managing acute poisonings and other toxicological emergencies. Alternative health advocates have embraced the word and the concept of detoxification, but skipped the need for good science and evidence, as they promote countless strategies and products around this nebulous idea of “toxin removal”.
Alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification
“Detox diets” and “detox kits” are dietary interventions that are claimed to support or promote the elimination of toxins. They are often simultaneously marketed at weight-loss strategies, although they are routinely promoted to those without any weight or health problems whatsoever. Detoxification strategies are very popular with alternative-health providers such as naturopaths. A 2011 online survey of naturopaths noted that 92% of naturopaths claimed to use “clinical detoxification strategies”, with clients starting in infancy, and continuing through adulthood:
Detoxification therapies reportedly used by more than 75% of NDs [naturopaths] included dietary measures (cleansing foods, increased fruit/vegetable intake, vitamin/mineral/antioxidant supplementation, organic foods, elimination diet, stool bulking agents/fiber), probiotics, reducing environmental exposure, and cholagogue herbs (herbs that promote the excretion of bile).
Britt Marie Hermes was once a naturopath that promoted the alternative medicine view of detoxification to her clients. In her post “The Anatomy of a Detox Scam,” Hermes (who subsequently quit naturopathy, and is now its harshest critic) described how she invented a detoxification scheme she called The Right Detox:
Detox programs are created with one goal: make money. I am not generalizing here. I’ve helped create detox programs at more than one clinic. In each instance, the decisions to include specific detox supplements, protein powder shakes, or therapies were based on profit margins. Detoxers doing The Right Detox could purchase different “tiers” of the program. The scheme was simple. The “deeper” the detox, the higher the tier, and the more expensive the package.
Like all other over-the-counter or alternative medicine detox plans, there is a lack of robust evidence to show that these types of detox strategies do anything at all.
While naturopathic and alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification have no solid grounding in science, it’s fair to ask if there’s anything science-based to the general concerns about chronic chemical exposure toxicity. Fortunately, there is some evidence to inform our decisions.
What exactly is a toxin?
The word “toxin” is used casually in alternative medicine and the popular press. Gluten came from nowhere to be seen as some sort of toxin, now seemingly replaced by sugar as the toxin du jour. Fat used to be a toxin. Now it’s carbs. And salt. (Or salt is OK now). Some claim genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are toxins (they aren’t). The CDC uses the following definition:
Toxic agent: Chemical or physical (for example, radiation, heat, cold, microwaves) agents that, under certain circumstances of exposure, can cause harmful effects to living organisms.
There are legitimate reasons to be concerned about our exposure to toxic substances. From radon in our basements to lead in our drinking water, there are many chemical substances we may be exposed to that have the potential to cause serious harm. And it is true that industrialization and modernization have increased the number of synthetic chemical substances that we may be exposed to. It is also true that some substances can accumulate in the body, and have the potential to cause harmful effects. The ability of any particular substance to cause harm will be affected by that substance’s action in the body, which will be influenced by out body’s innate detoxification systems, provided mainly through the liver and kidneys.
The extent to which any substance may be toxic can be influenced by the route of exposure (e.g., inhaled asbestos fibres can cause mesothelioma), the dose, which is the amount in the body (e.g., acetaminophen is safe at low doses but highly toxic in overdose), and the length of exposure, where chronic or long-term exposure may create a different toxicity profile than short-term exposure. Not everyone will react to a chemical in the same way. Genetics, age, and other factors can influence how substances we are exposed to are metabolized or eliminated.
Concurrent with our growing awareness of our environmental exposure to thousands of substances has been the advancement of analytical testing methods that allow the identification of these substances at vanishingly low concentrations. We can now verify that human tissue or breast milk may contain substances like persistent organic (carbon-based) pollutants (POPs). While this may sound concerning, we need to acknowledge that their identification does not automatically mean that they are causing us harm.
In the United States, the National Toxicology Program (NTP) coordinates research across different federal agencies and evaluates the effects of chemicals on health. The NTP has a detailed report of 248 products or substances known to cause, or anticipated to cause, cancer. However, the NTP notes:
There are tens of thousands of chemicals in the world that we know very little about. Only a small number of chemicals have been assessed adequately for potential toxicity to humans.
There is no scientific consensus on whether chronic very-low-dose exposure to substances like POPs is harmful to human health. And it is this uncertainty (and fear) that has bolstered the current alternative-health detoxification market. Preying on these innate fears of “poisoning from within”, the industry promotes the view that any exposure, no matter how slight, is harmful, and that alternative-medicine detoxification will help. Many detox diets and diet kits claim to remove unspecified “toxins” from the body. Other approaches promoted claim to bolster the ability of organs like the liver to work more effectively. However, few if any actually name the specific toxins that are removed, or provide evidence that toxins are actually removed as a direct consequence of the detox process recommended.
Cause for concern?
Should we be concerned about the chemicals we are exposed to in the environment? Last month David Gorski noted how alternative medicine has latched on to the idea of “obesogens” in the environment as a contributor to the increasing prevalence of obesity, when the evidence itself seems far less convincing.
Similar claims have been made about pesticides – particularly the residue that on food. As Harriet Hall has noted, the Pesticide Data Program of the USDA monitors food residues, focusing on those products consumed by infants and children. The 2016 results were reassuring:
    • Again this year, the PDP results shows that the U.S. food supply is one of the safest in the world. The PDP testing methods detect the lowest possible levels of pesticide residues, including levels below the EPA established tolerances.
    • In 2016, surveys were conducted on a variety of foods, including fresh and processed fruit and vegetables, eggs, and milk. The report includes data from over 10,000 samples collected in a variety of States and throughout the year ensuring the samples are representative of the entire United States.
    • Over 99 percent of the samples tested had residues well below the EPA established tolerances. The results also showed more than 23 percent had no detectable pesticide residue.
    • Samples with residues exceeding the EPA-established tolerance were found in 0.46 percent (48 of 10,365) of the samples, and 2.6 percent (273 of 10,365) of the samples had residues with no established tolerance for the specific commodity tested. For eggs and milk, there were no residues found that exceeded the tolerance levels, nor were there any residues with no established tolerance.
There’s a lack of evidence to suggest that the synthetic pesticide residues found in food are at levels that have negative health effects. Bruce Ames published a now-famous and widely-cited paper on pesticides back in 1990 that concluded that almost all of the pesticides we eat are “natural”, and that few of them have ever been tested for harm:
We calculate that 99.99% (by weight) of the pesticides in the American diet are chemicals that plants produce to defend themselves. Only 52 natural pesticides have been tested in high-dose animal cancer tests, and about half (27) are rodent carcinogens; these 27 are shown to be present in many common foods. We conclude that natural and synthetic chemicals are equally likely to be positive in animal cancer tests. We also conclude that at the low doses of most human exposures the comparative hazards of synthetic pesticide residues are insignificant.
Finally, if there could be “one true cause” of toxicity it has to be endocrine disruptors (e.g., bisphenol A), synthetically-produced chemicals that mimic naturally-occurring hormones in the body. As the products are now ubiquitous in our environments, there are understandable questions about the health effects of this chronic exposure. Summarizing all of the evidence is beyond the scope of this post, but it’s fair to say that the evidence is unclear, with some regulators taking steps to reduce potential exposure to infants and children as a precaution.
Summing up
Technology’s progress has allowed us to detect our exposure to chemicals with remarkable sensitivity. While there is evidence supporting the claim that there are synthetic and other environmental toxins in humans and in our food supply, there is a lack of evidence to show that (with some exceptions) there is specific cause for concern. Serious toxicity and poisonings are managed in hospital emergency rooms: That’s where the only effective detoxification interventions occur. Detoxification ideas promoted in the popular press, including anything sold as a kit or diet, or promoted by alternative medicine practitioners, lack evidence they do anything beneficial at all. The best evidence we have for reducing the risk of disease may be to do things we already know: eat a balanced diet, move as much as possible, keep alcohol consumption as moderate as possible, and don’t smoke.

   Colon “cleanses”. A load of you know whatColon “cleanses”. A load of you know what…
David Gorski
Link
“”Death begins in the colon.”
Perhaps you’ve heard this little bit of “alternative medicine” wisdom. Oddly enough, I had never heard it until well after I had become a surgeon (although my first thought upon hearing it was that it would make a killer name for a rock band or a blog). That’s when I began encountering claims that seemed to indicate that constipation was the most evil thing in the world, something that must be avoided at all costs. Naturally, I wondered just what the heck was meant by this bit of “wisdom.” What, I wondered, was it based on? What, I wondered, was the purpose of it? To answer this question, recently I decided to go back and review what people say about colon health:
Have you ever considered this simple question: Are you clean inside?
Well, no, not really. I know that, like every other human, I’m most definitely not “clean inside,” if by “inside” you mean my gastrointestinal tract and upper respiratory tract. As is the case for everyone, my colon is crawling with hundreds of species of bacteria, where the most common species (E. coli) makes up only 1% to 2% of the total bacterial count and by the time the stool makes it out around 10% of its mass is made up of bacteria. We humans aren’t even “clean outside,” either, given the bewildering variety of bacteria that live on our skin and mucous membranes. Any part of our body that comes into contact with the outside world, whether it be skin, pharynx, or gastrointestinal tract, is most definitely not clean. Indeed, the variety and rich ecosystem of the bacteria living in various ecological niches in your body and mine actually makes it more difficult for pathogenic bacteria to gain a foothold and cause disease. Your little critters living all over and in your body are your friends most of the time (one exception being when your immune system is suppressed).
And that’s completely normal. Unless you’re a believer in colon cleansing, of course. If you believe in colon cleansing, the concept of commensal bacteria living within you is impossible to bear:
Of course you take care of the outside: You shower, brush your teeth and wash your hair on a regular basis, but do you clean yourself inside? In this modern, toxic world it’s becoming a simple fact of life that our colon (the ‘sewer system’ of the body), liver and other organs also require regular cleaning. Just like a car requires an oil change periodically.
It all sounds perfectly reasonable, doesn’t it? We clean other parts of our body regularly; so why don’t we all clean our colons as well? Here’s the concept behind colon cleansing in brief, so that you don’t have to wade through websites that I’ll be linking to (unless you really want to, that is). Colon cleansers claim that, thanks to our degenerate low fiber Western diets, the colon does not empty itself out properly when we defecate, and that we therefore build up layers of stool on the insides of our colons that slowly poison us, leading to all sorts of disease. True, low fiber diets may be responsible for health problems, but not in the way described by these “alt-med” mavens. But, here, don’t just take my word for it:
You need internal cleansing, unless you’ve been a vegetarian since birth and lived on a pristine island away from pollution growing your own food. (Otherwise how could you bear the thought of having stuff like you see in the picture INSIDE YOU?!)
I warn you in advance that this is not the sort of thing that those who are easily grossed out should look at, but this is the sort of picture that they’re talking about. Don’t click on the link if you have a weak stomach, as there are many pictures of the “results” of colon cleansing. (I’m particularly amused, although also somewhat disgusted, by the series of photos near the end in which the proud colon cleanser has carefully arranged the results of his efforts around the rim of the toilet bowl.) It is then asked:
So what is the root cause of most digestive ailments? Look at the picture below. How would you feel if long pieces of old toxin-filled fecal matter were stuck to the inside of your colon for months or even years? Would you feel constipated, bloated and lethargic? Would your bowels be irritated by this debris day in and day out causing what we call IBS? Just think about what else toxic build-up like this can cause? Stomach pain and constipation? Fatigue, gas and bloating? Headaches and indigestion? Weight gain and a large protruding belly? The list is almost endless.
It is–if you don’t know anything about how the colon works. For one thing, if you peruse sites pushing colon-cleansing products, one thing you will quickly find is that many of them seem to have a rather unhealthy obsession with bowel movements. Indeed, you will learn that a “healthy colon” should have at least two to three bowel movements a day, or, as I’ve seen more than once, “one BM for each meal eaten” and that they must be soft and light brown. Some sites go even further and claim that, not only should your feces not stink but they should float. Here is one example:
Many conventional doctors are under the misconception that having a bowel movement every two or three days is sufficient and even “normal” for some. This is a dangerous fallacy! A person with a healthy colon should in fact have two to three bowel movements per day, or one for each meal eaten. Elimination should be complete, fast and easy. The stool should be light brown in color, long and large in diameter, “fluffy” in texture and floating on top of the water. There should be no offensive odor and it should break apart with the toilet flushing. Going to the bathroom once every few days, sitting there straining for half-an-hour and passing black, hard “pebbles” that drop to the bottom is not only abnormal, it is also serious trouble waiting to happen.
This is, of course, utter nonsense.
In fact, most of the time, stool shouldn’t float. As strange as it may seem, physicians, particularly surgeons, often ask patients suffering from abdominal or digestive complaints that very question: “Does your stool float or sink?” Patients look at us as though we’ve lost our minds when this question is asked, but the question has a purpose: If your stool floats, it may have too much fat in it, which may mean that you’re not absorbing enough fat, which can be a sign of various diseases. It could also mean that you’re not absorbing the nutrients other than fat in your food, thus letting more nutrient- or fat-rich material reach the colon, where your friendly neighborhood commensal bacteria feast on it, producing–you guessed it– gas bubbles in the stool. These gas bubbles make the resultant stool less dense overall and thus more likely to float! Indeed the proverbial floating poop can be a sign of celiac sprue, cystic fibrosis, biliary disease resulting in inadequate bile flow to the bowel, or GI infections. Moreover, if you eat any red meat at all, your stool won’t be light brown, nor should necessarily it be. It shouldn’t be black, of course (which can be a sign of GI bleeding, as digested blood turns stools black), but it doesn’t necessarily need to be light brown either. Indeed, if your stool is too light (“clay-colored”), it might be a sign of liver, pancreatic, or biliary disease, and the reason surgeons often ask it is that floating stool can be an indication that gallbladder surgery is required. Floating stool may mean nothing at all, and healthy people can have them, but it can in the proper clinical situation be indicative of serious disease.
Some websites even go further, making incredibly silly observations like this:
If you’re not eliminating approximately the same amount that you are eating, then what do you think happens to the remainder? The accumulation of old, hardened feces sticks to the colon walls, inhibiting its proper function of absorbing the remaining nutrients from the fecal matter.
Instead it is forced to absorb toxins from the build-up and from the parasites that make this debris their breeding ground. The passage through which the feces are forced to travel is also greatly reduced in diameter so the stools become much narrower – even as thin as a pencil sometimes.
The first silly part, of course, is the claim that you must eliminate “approximately the same amount that you are eating.” Why on earth would anyone think that that must be true? After all, what happens to the part of the food that we actually use for energy? It’s digested into its component sugars, fats, and amino acids and absorbed. The second silly part is those evil unnamed “toxins” again, the ones that are, according to the “detoxifiers,” the cause of basically all disease. They’re probably unnamed because it excuses these sellers of colon cleansing and “detoxifying” products from having to provideany actual evidence for their claims. Here’s a more pointed example of such thinking:
It may be said that almost every chronic disease known is directly or indirectly due to the influence of bacterial poisons absorbed from the intestine. The colon may be justly looked upon as a veritable Pandora’s box, out of which come more human misery and suffering, mental and moral, as well as physical than from any other known source.
My first reaction to this sort of thinking was: Every chronic disease? This is the sort of thinking that leads paragons of “alternative” medicine like Hulda Clark to proclaim a liver fluke as the cause of all cancers. Believe it or not, there is actually a Guild of Colon Hydrotherapists, and this is what it says about the colon:
The colon is a sewage system but by neglect and abuse it becomes a cesspool. When it is clean and normal we are well and happy; let it stagnate, and it will distill the poisons of decay, fermentation and putrefaction into the blood, poisoning the brain and nervous system so that we become mentally depressed and irritable; it will poison the heart so that we are weak and listless; poisons the lungs so that the breath is foul; poisons the digestive organs so that we are distressed and bloated; and poisons the blood so that the skin is sallow and unhealthy. In short, every organ of the body is poisoned and we age prematurely, look and feel old, the joints are stiff and painful, neuritis, dull eyes and a sluggish brain overtake us; the pleasure of living is gone.
In other words, if you don’t poop the way colon “hydrotherapists” think that you should, the pleasure of living will be gone. Really.
And here’s more:
When the colon does not do its job, all organs suffer. Uneliminated waste material soaks back through the colon into the lymph glands throughout the system. When these glands become overloaded with toxins, disease will set in. Cellular mutation will take place and abnormal growth will form in the body. It is not hard to understand why the sensitive mammary glands are one of the first targets for disease. One of the largest sites for lymph elimination is the underarm. If the lymph is congested, the toxins flow into the mammary glands. The breast will also take on toxic overload when underarm toxic elimination is decreased through the use of antiperspirants.
Lymph is also dumped into the colon wall. If the colon is backed up with debris, lymph congestion cannot be relieved. It will back up within the lymph system causing even further congestion, and affects the liver. The toxins taken up by the liver are excreted as part of the bile. When the bile toxins become excessive, the bile backs up into the intestine and the result is nausea.
[...]
Toxins and poisons are given off by the body but may become dry and hard as the material becomes glued to the pocket of the colon wall. A person must do a colon cleanse to get this matter out. Most people have a transit time (for food to completely pass through the intestinal tract) of seventy-two hours. After a colon cleansing, however, this time is reduced to twenty-four to forty-eight hours (digestion and elimination).
An English doctor tested a lady by giving her a marker pellet. Every day she moved her bowel after taking the pellet, but it took one week for the marker pellet to come out. Even though your bowels may move every day, you can still be constipated.
So what’s the answer? Super-regularity above and beyond the call of duty, or, as I call it, regularity über alles! It’s not enough to have a bowel movement a day. Oh, no. That’s for putrefaction-poisoned wimps. To be healthy, if you believe these colon detoxification mavens, you simply must poop way more often than that, helped along by a wide array of enemas, herbal laxatives, and purgatives. In other words, you have to do whatever it takes, and what it takes can be pretty extreme. Look at these testimonials for Colonix, a typical product designed to remove all these evil humors, if you don’t believe me.
Of course, this stuff must work, right? Otherwise, how could we see such glowing testimonials? I still remember a truly hilarious testimonial (in a rather disgusting sort of way) that I saw a couple of years ago. Unfortunately, the original is gone, but it still lives on on the Randi.org forums. As I recall the original quote, the person giving the testimonial was ecstatic over having 14-20 bowel movements a week and sometimes as many as three to five bowel movements a day, and exulted:
We are having awesome adventures in the bathroom.
That’s just way too much information, I’m afraid.
Having a bowel movement three to five times a day may be desirable if you’ve had a total proctocolectomy and had to have an ileal pouch reconstruction, using a small bowel loop to replace the reservoir function of the resected rectum, but that’s only because these patients can sometimes have as many as 10-12 bowel movements a day after such surgery. Trust me on this. They don’t like it. They don’t like it one bit.. Sometimes they don’t like it so much that they ask their surgeon to convert them over to a permanent ileostomy, for easier management. The bottom line is that such patients tolerate having 3-5 bowel movements a day in return for not having to wear a bag, not because they think it’s such a great thing to have to go to the bathroom that often.
But is there anything to all this? Does decaying, nasty feces stuck to the insides of your colon poison you with toxins and lead to disease?
Not really, except under very uncommon circumstances.
First of all, the bacteria decried by colon cleansers are in reality completely normal and do not “poison” their host, except occasionally, such as when a new strain (such as pathogenic strains of E. coli that cause food poisoning or simply bacterial strains that “don’t belong” and cause travellers’ diarrhea). They are even beneficial in that they help with the breakdown of bile salts in the stool, among other things. Indeed, one of the reasons that antibiotics often cause diarrhea or a secondary infection known as Clostridium difficile colitis (which can be life-threatening) is because antibiotics kill the normal bacterial flora of the colon, allowing pathogenic bacteria to grow into the niche left behind by the dead normal bacteria. Second of all, yes there are parasitic diseases of the colon (Giardia or entamoeba, anyone?), but worms and gastrointestinal parasites are relatively uncommon causes of colon disease in the developed world. Third, as a surgeon, I can tell you from simple experience operating on the colon that hardened feces do not accumulate on the walls of the colon as the colon cleansers claim. Any gastroenterologist who does a lot of colonoscopies could tell you that too. Even in disease states in which colon motility is impaired, we generally do not see the feces “caking” on the walls. Even in the case of mechanical obstruction by, for instance, a colon or rectal cancer, what we see is lots of fecal matter fairly evenly distributed in the lumen of the colon.
But what, you may reasonably ask, is all that nastiness that colon cleansing websites so proudly display as evidence of the “success” of their cleanses? One thing you will find, if you look closely at the ingredients of many colon cleansing products, is that many of them contain bentonite clay. This clay is touted as having been used by indigenous tribes for many centuries (the fallacy of ancient wisdom–my favorite!) and as a “natural” laxative. What it really is is an absorbent aluminium phyllosilicate clay that expands in the gastrointestinal tract as it absorbs fluid. Often the bentonite clay is combined with psyllium, which is often used as a bulk-forming laxative. The beauty of this, as far as sellers of colon cleansing products go, is that bentonite clay is responsible for those disgusting rope-like stools that are touted as “evidence” that people’s colons are coated with layers of disgusting waste that is “poisoning” them. Such stools consist of the clay expanded by the liquid from the gastrointestinal tract, plus the bulk formed by psyllium, all coated with feces. Thus, the product itself produces the very condition that it claims to treat! I sometimes envision experienced and skillful con men tipping their hats in appreciation and respect when they learn this little fact about colon cleansing products.
The problem all boils down to an obsession with “toxins,” “waste,” and “putrefaction.” Colon cleansing mavens seem to view their own waste products as somehow inherently “harmful,” obsessing about them in much the same way as General Jack T. Ripper obsessed about his “purity of essence” in Dr. Strangelove: Or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. Indeed, if you hang around on enough the “right” discussion forums, you will get the distinct sense that they find the very thought that they have feces accumulating in them all the time, loaded with bacteria, to be hateful and impossible to bear. This attitude is, of course, odd, to say the least, given that the very function the colon evolved over millions of years to do is to remove our digestive wastes safely and efficiently, extracting water, electrolytes, and what little other nutrients are left over, before depositing the waste into whatever receptical its owner sees fit to use. For the vast majority of people, whether it does it three times a day or once every three days does not matter much. Worse, in the cases of people who do have a real parasitic infection, all the purging in the world won’t get rid of the critters causing the disease, no matter how many times a day one drives oneself to go. Only appropriate drugs to kill the parasites can correct the problem.
In any case, constipation is determined more by the hardness of the stool and the difficulty a person has expelling it, rather than any arbitrarily determined frequency of bowel movements. Mild constipation can be treated with fiber-containing laxatives, although occasionally a purge with magnesium citrate or even GoLytely may be necessary for very severe cases. However, in general, stimulant laxatives, enemas, and purgatories can mess up a colon up really bad and should be avoided when possible. They can result in dependence on them over time just to be able to defecate. Another favorite colon cleansing method, colonic irrigation, has risks, too, including excessive fluid absoption leading to electrolyte abnormalities and, if too much pressure is used, it can even cause colon perforation! During my residency, I encountered a couple of patients who had abused laxatives. They were truly miserable, and totally depended on their laxatives just to have a normal bowel movement.
In reality, there is a great deal of similarity between the concept of “autointoxication” and certain religions. In the case of “autointoxication,” the body of the person with a disease is viewed as “unclean,” contaminated by itself, and, of course, in dire need of cleansing. Does anyone see the parallels to Christian doctrine? Consider: According to Christian religions, people are inherently “unclean” because of original sin that, no matter what they do themselves, they cannot remove. (Only God can.) Now consider the beliefs that drive colon cleansing, in which adherents believe that they are inherently unclean, full of “putrefaction,” and being “poisoned” from within through the absorption of “toxins” (whose exact identities are conveniently rarely, if ever, specified). They believe that they need something to “cleanse” that uncleanliness before they can be well. Compare that to not just Christianity, but to a number of religions in which adherents must “cleanse” themselves of evil and putrefaction by various purifying acts and rituals. This should not be surprising, as the beliefs that drive people to cleanse their colons by various means are not based in science, but rather seem to be more religious or quasireligious in nature.
One thing’s for sure. Colon cleansing is a dubious and almost always useless procedure that shows no signs of going away. There is a thriving market offering an amazing number of products that claim to be able to rid you of all that nasty fecal buildup that doesn’t exist. It may be the most obvious retort in the world for such woo, but the very nature of these sorts of products makes it difficult to avoid–nay, it demands that I not avoid–saying that colon cleansing is a load of…well, you know.

   Would you like a liver flush with that colon cleanse.
David Gorski
Link
I have to apologize for last week’s post. I’m not apologizing for the subject matter (the obsession that reigns supreme among some alt-med aficionados over “cleansing” their colons to “purge toxins” and achieve the super-regularity of several bowel movements a day). Rather, I’m sorry I probably didn’t emphasize quite strongly enough just how disgusting one of the links that I included was. Among all the glowing testimonials found there touting how lovers of that “clean feeling” inside felt after having supposedly rid themselves of all that nasty fecal matter caked on the walls of their colons and achieved the Nirvana of many bowel movements a day (or, as one happy customer put it, “awesome adventures in the bathroom” and another put it, “I have not noticed anything really weird come out of me yet, but I am sure that there will be”), there were also links to various pictures people took of their own poop, complete with graphic descriptions. A couple of years ago when I showed an acquaintance of mine the Dr. Natura website shortly after I had discovered it, he declared it the “grossest thing on the web.” Sadly, I had to assure him that it was not–not by a longshot. However, I will try spare you any links to anything significantly grosser, preferring instead to leave finding them as an exercise for interested readers.
After having apologized for perhaps grossing out some of our readers, who come to this site for science- and evidence-based discussions of various so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” therapies, not pictures of the various excretions of the human body proudly lined up by the humans who produced them, I thought about what might be a suitable followup this week to such a topic. There really is only one followup that’s appropriate to this stuff, believe it or not. The problem with which I wrestled is that it really is pretty much as disgusting as last week’s topic, if not more so. (You’ll soon see why.) So there I was, trapped on the horns of a dilemma. Hesitating only momentarily, though, as any good general surgeon would do (remember, before I specialized in breast cancer surgery I was a general surgeon, as prone to dive into big brown on the loose as any other general surgeon), I decided just to dive in to the topic as I would have in the old days dived into a particularly foul belly full of purulence, particularly since this week’s “CAM” modality of choice claims to be able to take away a big chunk of the “bread and butter” practice of general surgery by curing a common surgical disease without all that nasty cutting, even if these days it’s almost always done laparoscopically.
So, are you ready for liver flushes? Of course you are. Don’t you want a way to “remove gallstones without surgery“?
Of course you do.
First off, so that I don’t repeat the same mistake as last week, be advised that some of the links mentioned here will lead to some disgusting pictures, particularly things that people have fished out of their own feces, although not as disgusting as last week. (Don’t ask me why they spend so much time examining and picking through their own waste; if I understood it, I probably wouldn’t be writing about it. The fact that believers in this particular therapy are prone to straining through their stool looking for nuggets that prove the therapy “works” is, in fact, why some may consider this topic to be even more disgusting than last week’s. Click at your own peril.) So, warning completed, what sorts of benefits can you expect from liver flushes? To answer that question, let’s go to a woman who is the very embodiment of all that is bad about CAM in that she blames all cancer on a liver fluke (hence her interest in “flushing them out of the liver) and claims to be able to cure virtually any disease, Hulda Clark, for some input, from her book, The Cure for All Diseases (you didn’t believe me when I told you she claims to be able to cure virtually any disease, did you?):
“Cleansing the liver of gallstones dramatically improves digestion, which is the basis of your whole health. You can expect your allergies to disappear, too, more with each cleanse you do! Incredibly, it also eliminates shoulder, upper arm, and upper back pain. You have more energy and increased sense of well being.
Pretty amazing, eh? I can’t figure out why such flushing would eliminate allergies or shoulder, arm, and back pain, but then I’m not Hulda Clark. I suppose her latter example might have been meant that it will get rid of the referred pain of gallbladder and other biliary disease, which is often perceived radiating to the right shoulder and upper back, but I suspect that might be attributing too much medical sophistication to someone who blames a liver fluke for all disease. In any case, let’s continue with her rationale for this particular form of “therapy”:
It is the job of the liver to make bile, 1 to 1.5 quarts in a day! The liver is full of tubes (biliary tubing) that deliver the bile to one large tube (the common bile duct). The gallbladder is attached to the common bile duct and acts as a storage reservoir. Eating fat or protein triggers the gallbladder to squeeze itself empty after about twenty minutes, and the stored bile finishes its trip down the common bile duct to the intestine.
For many persons, including children, the biliary tubing is choked with gallstones. Some develop allergies or hives but some have no symptoms. When the gallbladder is scanned or X-rayed nothing is seen. Typically, they are not in the gallbladder. Not only that, most are too small and not calcified, a prerequisite for visibility on an X-ray. There are over half a dozen varieties of gallstones, most of which have cholesterol crystals in them. They can be black, red, white, green or tan colored. The green ones get their color from being coated with bile. Notice in the picture (pg. 545) how many have imbedded unidentified objects. Are they fluke remains? [Note: Your friendly neighborhood surgeon-blogger almost spit up his drink upon reading this question; suffice it to say that, no, they are not fluke remains.] Notice how many are shaped like corks with longitudinal grooves below the tops. We can visualize the blocked bile ducts from such shapes. Other stones are composites- made of many smaller ones- showing that they regrouped in the bile ducts some time after the last cleanse.
Hulda’s apparently never heard of ultrasound, which is very good at visualizing both gallbladder and liver stones. If there were gallstones or liver stones there, ultrasound would almost certainly be able to detecit them in the vast majority of cases. Certainly, ultrasound is also very good at detecting bile duct obstruction as well. Best of all, it’s a noninvasive, relatively inexpensive, and radiation-free test–just the sort of test that any CAM practitioner or patient should love! And, in the uncommon cases where ultrasound fails, CT scans can often see biliary obstruction and stones. Also, I don’t know where Hulda got the idea that gallstones are common in children, but they aren’t. I could quote epidemiology, but a less boring way is to have you just ask yourself: How many children do you know or have you seen who have needed gallbladder surgery? Not very many. How many adults, now? I will give Hulda credit for one thing, though. She’s correct that some cases of gallstones are completely asymptomatic or only mildly symptomatic (usually bloating or other vague GI symptoms). And guess what? These days, we evil allopathic surgeons who are constantly castigated for “medicalizing” and “overtreating” everything generally don’t recommend cholecystectomy just for the presence of stones. If the stones are truly asymptomatic and only incidentally found on a study done for other reasons, we usually leave them alone, except sometimes in cases where a case of cholecystitis would be very dangerous, as in elderly diabetics or patients with other comorbidities. We usually wait for symptoms to occur, and in an impressive percentage of cases they never do. The stones remain asymptomatic, and the patient takes them to the grave. In the case of vague symptoms that might or might not be attributable to gallstones (a not uncommon clinical situation), before taking out his gallblader, we will tell the patient that, although his symptoms are probably due to gallstones, we can’t be absolutely certain that something else isn’t going on and we can’t guarantee that the surgery will relieve all his symptoms.
But I digress somewhat. Let’s get back to Hulda Clark’s claims:
At the very center of each stone is found a clump of bacteria, according to scientists, suggesting a dead bit of parasite might have started the stone forming.
Wrong.
Most gallstones do not contain any such thing. Gallstones and liver stones form when cholesterol and/or bile salts in the bile form tiny crystals, which then enlarge. Most gallstones are cholesteral gallstones, and liver stones are much less common. Not that that stops Hulda:
As the stones grow and become more numerous the back pressure on the liver causes it to make less bile. Imagine the situation if your garden hose had marbles in it. Much less water would flow, which in turn would decrease the ability of the hose to squirt out the marbles. With gallstones, much less cholesterol leaves the body, and cholesterol levels rise.
Not quite. In any case, if true obstruction were present and increasing the “back pressure” on the liver, it would be fairly straightforward to demonstrate by observing dilated biliary ducts in the liver on ultrasound. As is the case with most tubular structures in the body (small bowel, colon, bile ducts, ureters, etc.), when bile ducts are blocked, pressure behind the blockage causes them to dilate proximal to the cause of the obstruction, in the case of chronic obstruction quite impressively. Distal to the obstruction they tend to be normal in caliber or even collapsed (otherwise known as “distal collapse”). That’s how we figure out initially whether the obstruction is somewhere within the liver or if it’s in the bile duct outside of the liver. This part of surgery is not particularly complicated. It’s simple fluid dynamics, and that’s how we can usually tell where an obstruction is. It ain’t rocket science, as they say. So why don’t we see dilated bile ducts in all of these patients complaining about “liver stones? Hulda has an answer, of course:
Gallstones, being porous, can pick up all the bacteria, cysts, viruses and parasites that are passing through the liver. In this way “nests” of infection are formed, forever supplying the body with fresh bacteria. No stomach infection such as ulcers or intestinal bloating can be cured permanently without removing these gallstones from the liver.
The vast majority of stomach and duodenal ulcers are caused by H. pylori. Is Hulda claiming that gallstones form a “nest” in which H. pylori dwell? On what evidence? None, of course. Hulda’s a bit different than most liver flushers, though, in that she emphasizes her all-powerful and all-explaining liver fluke as the cause of cancer and “all disease.” She thus recommends the use of her “zapper” to “kill parasites” before doing a “liver flush” to flush them out. Most practitioners selling liver “cleanses” emphasize their flushy goodness as a means of eliminating “liver toxins” (whatever that means) and “stones”:
The liver is the gateway to the body and in this chemical age its detoxification systems are easily overloaded. Thousands of chemicals are added to food and over 700 have been identified in drinking water. Plants are sprayed with toxic chemicals, animals are injected with potent hormones and antibiotics and a significant amount of our food is genetically engineered, processed, refined, frozen and cooked. All this can lead to destruction of delicate vitamins and minerals, which are needed for the detoxification pathways in the liver. The liver must try to cope with every toxic chemical in our environment, as well as damaged fats that are present in processed and fried foods.
So what, exactly, does a liver flush entail? Most liver flushes involve drinking large quantities of fruit juices of some kind, usually along with epsom salts and oils such as olive oil. For example, here’s one protocol found (where else?) on CureZone that resembles many that I have seen:
Materials:
1 gallon apple juice (freshly pressed)
2 ounces orthophosphoric acid (Phosfood from Standard Process or Ortho phos from Nutra-Dyn)
Enema bag and colon tube
Coffee
Epsom Salts
Whipping cream and berries
Olive oil
Protocol:
Add one bottle (2 ounces) of orthophosphoric acid to the gallon of apple juice. Shake and refrigerate. Over the next three to five days, drink the gallon of juice (3 to 4 8-ounce glasses a day) between meals. Be sure to rinse your mouth out with baking soda and/or brush your teeth after drinking the juice to prevent the acid from damaging the teeth. Eat normally during the liver flush.
On the day following whatever day you finish the gallon of juice, eat your normal breakfast and lunch.
Two hours after lunch, drink 1-2 tablespoons of Epsom Salts dissolved in warm water.
Four hours after lunch, do a one pint coffee enema.
Five hours after lunch, drink 1 tablespoon of Epsom Salts dissolved in warm water.
Six or seven hours after lunch, eat a dinner of heavy whipping cream and frozen or fresh berries – as much as desired.
At bedtime, drink 1/2 cup of olive oil. A small amount of orange, grapefruit, or lemon juice may be added if desired. Immediately after drinking the oil, go to bed and lie on your right side with knees drawn up for 30 minutes. You may feel nauseated during the night. This is due to the release of stored toxins from the gallbladder and liver. This is normal and a sign that the protocol is working.
Upon arising in the morning, do a coffee enema.
Ah, yes, the coffee enema, arguably the most ridiculous “CAM” therapy there is, other than homeopathy. I still haven’t figured out how the coffee enema “flushes” the liver. I also still haven’t figured out why anyone would want to partake of the glorious caffeine-laden coffee bean in any way other than the usual way. Certainly, enemas are a rather difficult way to get a morning caffeine fix!
There are, of course, many variations to the basic “liver flush” protocol. Here are but a few:
     1.  Hulda Clark’s Liver Cleanse-Gallbladder Cleanse
     2.  Dr. Kelley’s Liver-Gallbladder flush
     3.  Are You Stoned? Liver-Gallbladder flush
     4.  Liver flush protocol with apple juice and orthophosphoric acid
     5.  “Classic Coke” liver flush and gallbladder flush (Egads, this one requires a good slug of magnesium citrate!)
     6.  “Cleansing or Surgery” liver and gallbladder cleanse (with four gallons of apple juice!)
     7.  Olive oil liver/gallbladder cleanse
     8.  Seven day program liver/gallbladder cleanse
     9.  Dushan’s grandmother’s liver/gallbladder cleanse
The list goes on and on and on and on. (And so will you if you try these cleanses.)
So what will happen if you do this (besides your producing a lot of unusually stinky and liquid poop)? Well, you will find things in your stool. If you read the many testimonials and look at the disgusting pictures on all the websites touting liver flushes, you will see photos proudly displayed of greenish balls or various other things that sort of look like–well, sort of “stone”-like. Naturally, the liver flushers claim that these are gallstones–without actually proving that’s what they are. Indeed, although it is certainly possible to pass gallstones into the stool and occasionally even find one, it’s highly unlikely to pass such huge numbers of stones (as claimed by testimonials) without previous clinical symptoms of gallbladder disease or without easily detectable stones on ultrasound examination. In some cases, the number of “stones” observed in the stool would have required a gallbladder the size of a football to hold them all! And, given that more always seem to “come out” when additional flushes are done, it would seem to imply that there is an endless supply there to be “dumped” out, a concept that defies plausibility, given that gallstones do not form rapidly enough to replace all the ones supposedly “flushed” out. In any case, check out this testimonial to see what I mean:
I just completed my 3rd liver cleanse. Whew! 1st cleanse 250 small stones pea size or less brown and green. 2nd cleanse 460 stones, small stones pea size or less brown and green. 3rd cleanse 260 stones light and dark green. Many marble size and 2 almost as big as golf balls (I saved these!) I highly recommend Andreas Moritz’s book, “The Amazing Liver Cleanse”. I followed to the letter and did colosan and colonics before and after. I read your testimonials and thought I would add my information.
As a surgeon, I feel obligated to point out that I have never seen a common bile duct (the tube that runs from the liver to the duodenum, through which bile passes) the diameter of a golf ball. The claim that anything so large could “pass” thanks to these flushes strains credibility to the breaking point. This testimonial gets a bit closer to what may be the truth behind liver cleansing:
I did a ‘liver cleanse’ or gallbladder flush about 6 nights ago! I’m a 50 year old female in good health. I’m not overweight and have no health problems. I’m active and have been a schoolteacher for 25 years.
I did not have any symptoms of gallstones nor did I have an ultrasound. I just had always been curious to try a gallbladder flush and see if anything came out- as they say most everyone has these gallstones and it’s good to get them OUT.
I did the flush at about 9:30 p.m. And I vomited about 12:30!!! I thought oh hell what an un-pleasant waste of time. BUT the next morning I DID pass some (25?) gelatinous looking things that were greenish – none larger than a small pea. I felt lousey – bloated and not hungry the next day. But since then I’ve felt great!!
I think I vomited because I ate some plain white rice and drank some carrot juice about 5pm. I have been researching various liver/gallbladder cleanses and most say NOT to eat all day and to drink organic apple juice and only that for at least 2 days prior. I took only 4oz of fresh squeezed lemon juice followed by 4 oz of olive oil at about 10 pm. I nearly gagged **YUK** as I was taking it! I will do it again but will follow your directions. I wish I had come across this website BEFORE I did my flush!
Note that this is an asymptomatic woman with absolutely no evidence of gallbladder or liver disease by clinical history, lacking the classic symptoms of right upper quandrant abdominal pain after a fatty meal (more succinctly known as biliary colic)–or any GI symptoms at all! (Although she certainly did produce some symptoms, didn’t she?) Because of curiosity, she made herself miserable for a couple of days with this “liver flush” and then noticed something “coming out.” These “gelatinous things” were almost certainly not gallstones. There are several varieties of gallstones. Of these, cholesterol stones can be rather soft and easily broken, but I don’t think they could be correctly described as “gelatinous.”
In any case, if these “flushes” actually flushed gallstones in to the GI tract, to be removed via the feces, it would be fairly straightforward to test scientifically, as I’ve pointed out time and time again in other venues. All that’s needed is an ultrasound machine and a willing radiologist, and possibly a biliary surgeon to evaluate symptoms and response. (Whether any IRB that is truly dedicated to human subject protection go for the protocol, however, I can’t guarantee.) Certainly, the ultrasound machine is not an onerous requirement, either. Ultrasound machines have become quite ubiquitous, as the price has fallen dramatically (and the quality has increased dramatically) in recent years. Virtually every OB/GYN practice that does prenatal care has at least one in their office, if not one in each exam room. Many general surgeons have them now, too; as do most emergency rooms. Pretty much any self-respecting breast cancer surgeon has at least one. There are even good portable ultrasound machines that fit into briefcases, and you can even find ultrasound machines in very poor parts of China and India, where, unfortunately, they are used to determine the sex of fetuses, so that parents can abort the females they don’t want. All that’s left is to draft a scientifically valid protocol with the proper controls and then to follow through and document symptoms, physical examination, diagnosis, pre-flush stone load in the gallbladder, and post-flush stone load in the gallbladder rigorously with high quality ultrasound examinations. Not surprisingly, it’s still never been done, as far as I can tell. I search in vain for actual physical evidence to support the claims of liver flushers.
What has been done, however, is a lovely little study that suggests just how much self-delusion is involved in liver flushes. Like the case of colon cleanses, when seasoned con men learn how liver flushes actually “work,” they will be likely to tip their hats in appreciation for such simplicity and perfection, a scam, where the remedy induces the “evidence” of its efficacy. But on to the case report to which I refer that a group in New Zealand contributed to the Lancet:
A 40-year-old woman was referred to the outpatient clinic with a 3-month history of recurrent severe right hypochondrial pain after fatty food. [Note: Here "hypochondrial" means "below the ribcage,' not "hypochondriac."] Abdominal ultrasound showed multiple 1-2 mm gallstones in the gallbladder.
She had recently followed a “liver cleansing” regime on the advice of a herbalist. This regime consisted of free intake of apple and vegetable juice until 1800 h, but no food, followed by the consumption of 600 mL of olive oil and 300 mL of lemon juice over several hours. This activity resulted in the painless passage of multiple semisolid green “stones” per rectum in the early hours of the next morning. She collected them, stored them in the freezer, and presented them in the clinic.
Microscopic examination of our patient’s stones revealed that they lacked any crystalline structure, melted to an oily green liquid after 10 min at 40°C, and contained no cholesterol, bilirubin, or calcium by established wet chemical methods. Traditional faecal fat extraction techniques indicated that the stones contained fatty acids that required acid hydrolysis to give free fatty acids before extraction into ether. These fatty acids accounted for 75% of the original material.
Experimentation revealed that mixing equal volumes of oleic acid (the major component of olive oil) and lemon juice produced several semi solid white balls after the addition of a small volume of a potassium hydroxide solution. On air drying at room temperature, these balls became quite solid and hard.
We conclude, therefore, that these green “stones” resulted from the action of gastric lipases on the simple and mixed triacylglycerols that make up olive oil, yielding long chain carboxylic acids (mainly oleic acid). This process was followed by saponification into large insoluble micelles of potassium carboxylates (lemon juice contains a high concentration of potassium) or “soap stones”.
In other words, the “stones” that liver cleansers are so proud of and go to such effort to strain their poo for after doing their flushes are not gallstones and were almost certainly the product of the actual flush itself! (Cue the con men tipping their hats in appreciation.) It makes perfect sense, if you think about it. These protocols usually involve fasting and then consuming up to a half liter or more of olive oil at one time. That could easily provide the conditions for this sort of reaction to take place. Neat, isn’t it? The very sign of “success” of the liver flush is something that has nothing to do with gallstones and everything to do with the results of the flush itself. Indeed, it’s quite clear that, even if you don’t have gallstones, if you do a liver flush and then look closely enough, you’ll find things in your stool that very much look like gallstones that are really due to saponified oil. Now I know (and you do too) why virtually every liver flush protocol includes large amounts of olive oil or similar oils plus epsom salts or orthophophoric acid and fruit juices. Unfortunately, I have not seen any more recent studies, and I’m not sure if any are really needed after the investigators discussed above conclusively showed that they could mimic these “stones” chemically.
In any case, it’s a beautiful scam. People do these flushes, they see things that look to them like gallstones being “flushed” out, and they believe it works. Consequently, they keep doing it. Because these flushes involve materials that don’t have to be purchased from a “healer” (although certainly many “healers” sell various “supplements” to “aid” liver flushes), they can be viewed more as a means of healers to demonstrate their skill and keep the patient coming. (And going, too!) It also serves as a way of “demonstrating” the efficacy of “detoxification.” After all, if this “flush” appears to cause “gallstones” to be eliminatd as promised, then perhaps the other detoxification modalities beloved of alt-med believers are also “flushing out toxins” as claimed and might be worth a try. (Never mind what the “toxins” are.) In this light, liver cleanses might indeed be viewed a “gateway” CAM therapy that leads users to the even more scientifically implausible ones, like homeopathy (which at least has the advantage over liver flushes of not making one spend long periods of time on the porcelain throne). To me the ironic thing about liver flushes is that they are so strongly advocated by CAM believers, who frequently castigate “conventional” medicine for “iatrogenic diseases or complications” (iatrogenic=caused by doctors). What, then, can we call these “stones” coming out of people using liver flushes, given that they are caused by the very CAM therapy that claims to be getting rid of them?
I’m open to suggestions.

2024 Detox Trends To Watch (Out) For
Trends come and go but the popularity of detoxification and cleansing in January is eternal.
Scott Gavura on January 4, 2024
Tweet

Commitments to improve one’s health are common at this time of year. Marketers know this – your social media is likely filled with gym advertisements and health product marketing. Health trends come and go. Here are some that I’ve seen this year, with some comments about the science behind these claims:
1. “Homeopathic” detox
Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, like a form of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what appears to be the active ingredients. But unlike conventional medicine, homeopathic products don’t contain any “medicine” at all. They are effectively and sometimes literally sugar pills – placebos. Not surprisingly, there is no convincing evidence to show that homeopathy has any medical value. So while there may be hundreds of homeopathic remedies for sale, they are chemically indistinguishable, usually containing just sugar, water, and/or alcohol. The best that can be said for these products is that homeopathic “detox” is usually safe — with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. It won’t remove toxins any faster than doing nothing at all.
2. The dopamine detox
Popularized on the creator of all trends, TikTok, the dopamine detox (or digital detox) basically involves not visiting TikTok (or using digital devices at all) for an extended period, based on the belief that constant digital stimulation is giving us dopamine “hits” in our brain that are ultimately harmful. (The effect of our devices on our brains is also the topic of a book I’m currently reading, Stolen Focus, by Johann Hari, which looks at the dwindling willpower we seem to have over our devices, and what can be done about it). Power users takings some time away from our devices is probably beneficial. However the idea that we can “detox” from a naturally-occurring chemical is bad science. I have no doubt that taking an extended break from technology can be invigorating and plausibly even make us feel much better. But there’s no toxins actually being removed.
3. The papaya parasite cleanse
Another trend that either got its start (or boost) from Tiktok, is the idea is that papaya seeds will help the body expel parasites from the gastrointestinal tract. While the idea that we can be infected with roundworms is certainly true, infections in developed countries are uncommon, especially past childhood. There is limited data that looks at the effectiveness of papaya seeds, and nothing that shows that seeds are more effective than medication. Papaya seeds are edible and they contain trace amounts of naturally-occurring cyanide. More obvious may be their high fibre content which can cause stomach upset – and may be why consumption is felt to help “expel” the parasites. If you feel you have a parasite infection – see a medical professional for evaluation and, if necessary, medical treatment.
It’s also worth noting that there are social media posts about the consumption of the aquarium antiparasite product Paraguard. It goes without saying that you are not a fish, and consuming a product intended for aquatic life is not advisable. There is also a herbal concoction also called Paraguard which is glorified snake oil and has no demonstrated efficacy. There are no natural remedies that have been proven to eliminate parasites.
4. The activated charcoal cleanse
Activated charcoal is a medicine and drug sponge – it’s used routinely for poisonings. So will it work if you’ve overindulged in tequila and tacos? Compared to real detoxification protocols, the amount of charcoal in detox products is tiny. And despite the marketing hype, activated charcoal has no ability to suck out the toxic chemicals from the rest of your body once they’re absorbed. Its effects are limited to the gastrointestinal tract only, and it’s been studied in poisoning situations only. While ingesting charcoal is probably going to be well tolerated, taking it with a healthy diet is exactly what you want to avoid. Activated charcoal appears to bond vitamins like ascorbic acid (vitamin C), niacin, pyridoxine (vitamin B6), thiamine (vitamin B1) and biotin, so it has the potential to make food and drinks you consume actually less nutritious, not more. The only reason you should be taking activated charcoal is when the emergency room physician is telling you it’s going to save your life. Otherwise, consider anything with activated charcoal to be a warning flag.
5. The Candida cleanse
This detox has been around for decades, and anecdotally its popularity seems have dropped over the past several years. It is based on the unproven idea that we are all infected with Candida – yeast. Candida albicans is a fungus that most of us carry in or on our bodies. However, it is rarely a cause of serious or prolonged illness – the more common infections are thrush (an infection of the mouth) or vaginitis (commonly called a yeast infection), both of which are easily treatable with anti-fungal medication. Serious Candida infections are quite rare, and usually only seen in those with very compromised immune systems – think cancer chemotherapy, or advanced AIDS.
Candida became a made-up cause of disease and illness in the 1980s, and alternative-medicine practitioners have never let this go, despite the lack of any evidence. That doesn’t stop people from selling “kits” and diets that are claimed to eliminate yeast in the body. These aren’t antifungal drugs: Most are combinations of laxatives and purgatives, all promising to sponge up toxins and Candida and restore you to an Enhanced State of Wellness. Advertisements may argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, and yeast. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. There isn’t a single case of mucoid plaque that’s been documented in the medical literature. If you have a widespread candida infection, you’re seriously ill and need to be under the care of a medical professional and not purchasing or attempting your own detox.
6. Intravenous vitamin infusions
Despite the pretty pictures, the hype and the endorsements from pro athletes and celebrities, there is no credible evidence to suggest that routine vitamin infusions are necessary or offer any meaningful health benefit. Vitamin infusions are a marketing creation, giving the illusion you’re doing something for your health, but lacking any demonstrable efficacy. Yes, there is an established medical role for injectable vitamins, though it’s no energy-boosting cure-all – they’re used to replace what we should obtain in our diet, when we cannot eat. But the reality is more mundane. In the absence of a deficiency, vitamin infusions don’t do much of anything. And they’re not free of risk – anytime you allow your skin to be punctured, there’s a small but non-zero risk of an infection. Do you trust getting an injection of chemicals from someone that isn’t a health professional, and has no evidence for what they’re promoting? If you need hydration, drink some water. And if your body needs vitamins, eat some food.
7. Coffee, but not the kind you drink
Fill’r to the rim.
Consuming coffee for the vast majority of people is safe and possibly even beneficial. It’s delicious. However, there is the widespread alternative health belief that the true benefits of coffee are delivered when you flush it into your rectum. Despite the hype, coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have been reported.
Coffee enemas have their roots as part of the “Gerson Treatment” for cancer, developed by physician Max Gerson in the 1940s. His regimen included coffee enemas, supplements, juice, and injections of calves’ liver. The approach has been investigated and been shown to be useless for the treatment of cancer. Some proponents of coffee enemas believe that the chemical components of coffee stimulate liver and gall bladder function. There is no credible evidence to suggest this occurs, or that it is necessary. Your liver and gallbladder don’t need a coffee enema in order to work effectively. They will work just fine on their own.
8. The alkaline cleanse
The idea that our body’s acidity needs monitoring and adjusting is another persistent bit of pseudoscience that continues to be promoted as an alternative-to-medicine. There is the widespread belief that anything that makes the body “acidic” is bad and anything basic or “alkali” is good. But all of this is nonsense, designed to confuse you about basic biochemistry. The pH scale is a measure of the acidity of a liquid. A pH of 7 is neutral. Anything lower is called acidic, anything higher is basic, or alkaline. The pH is a logarithmic scale – that is, a difference of 1 pH is a 10x difference.
Our blood’s pH is 7.4 – slightly alkaline or basic. Enzymes that facilitate chemical reactions in the cells work only in a narrow range of pH. Any significant change means almost certain death. A series of buffers and compensation mechanisms keep the pH in our blood from moving far from 7.4. Because the blood circulates throughout the body constantly, it can compensate any changes in pH in any of our organs (e.g., our muscles during intense exercise). Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the most prevalent acid in our body, and is a product of cellular activity. The blood carries CO2 away and eliminates it in the lungs. The lungs actually provide the biggest source of acid elimination in our body.
Everything we eat is broken down by stomach acid. The pH in our stomach is about 3 – very acidic, due to production of hydrochloric acid. Everything that is ejected from our stomach, into our intestines, is then immediately neutralized by digestive liquids and enzymes. The net effect is that everything we eat or drink and digest will eventually be at the pH in our intestines. Yes, diet can influence our urine’s pH, but that says nothing about health – it’s just a sign that your kidneys are working to eliminate waste properly. Any detox that claims to change your body’s pH is either useless or, if it actually worked, might kill you.
9. The blood detox
Marketing materials for detox treatments will usually list symptoms and even diseases that are claimed to be the result of “toxins”: Several that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specific enough to frighten you into buying (cancer, etc.)
One of the widely promoted ideas about “detox” is that is acts like some sort of cleaner for your organs. Detox advertising describe your liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. The kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions, using enzymes, to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated through the bile or the kidneys. The liver is self-cleansing – toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions fine. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine – otherwise the substance stays in the blood. Your organs should be fine. Just leave them alone. If your kidneys or liver are not working properly, no detox diet, kit or plan is going to make any difference.
Is there a “good” detox?
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature. Popular ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

The New Year’s detox secret THEY don’t want you to know about
The dirty secret about detoxification and cleanses.
Scott Gavura on January 5, 2023
Link
Happy New Year! Today’s post updates some old – but still relevant – material.
New Year, New You, right? It’s 2023. It’s hard to believe that we’re entering the fourth year of the pandemic. Resolutions are popular this time of year – particularly in the first week of January where you may still be enjoying some holidays, contemplating your plans for the year. This year’s theme, you decide, will be to get serious about your health. You’re another year older, after all.
But first, you need to cleanse yourself, eliminating 2022’s lifestyle and dietary sins. Supplements, tea, homeopathy, coffee enemas, ear candles, and footbaths all seem to promise better health. Amazon has entire detox and cleansing categories in supplements and books. The descriptions suggest detoxing will deliver a cleaner, healthier body. Goop has 383 articles tagged detox, which is a slightly more that this blog. Wouldn’t a purification from 2022 be a good way to start the year? Before you buy anything, there’s something very important that the detox promoters aren’t telling you.
Detox is a scam
“Detox” is a case of a legitimate medical term being turned into a marketing strategy – all designed to treat a nonexistent condition. In the setting of real medicine, detoxification means treatments for dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, like heavy metals. Detoxification treatments are medical procedures that are not casually selected from a menu of alternative health treatments, assembled from your spice cupboard, or pulled off the shelf at a health food store. Real detoxification is provided in hospitals when there are life-threatening circumstances.
The “toxins” that detox advocates claim to cleanse are another thing entirely. This form of detoxification is simply the co-opting of a real term to give legitimacy to useless products and services, while confusing consumers into thinking they’re science-based.

One of the widely promoted ideas about “detox” is that it acts like some sort of cleaner for your organs. Detox marketing describe your liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs need to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d rinse out a sponge, or change the air filter in your house or car. But the reality is, the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions, using enzymes, to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated from the body through the bile or the kidneys. The liver is self-cleansing – toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions fine. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine – otherwise the substance stays in the blood. To argue that either organ need a “cleanse” simply demonstrates a lack of understanding in biochemistry. Your organs will be fine without that supplement, smoothie, or fad diet. Just leave them alone.

But toxins!
There’s a reason we can be sucked in by the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication“, to be treated with colonics and purgatives. Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science discarded autointoxication by the 1900s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Yet the term persists today – but now it’s a marketing slogan. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that our environment is increasingly toxic, and it’s making us ill. Man-made chemicals are absolutely in our environment, so the reasoning goes that it must be making use sick. Depending on who you ask, some combination of food additives, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, not “eating clean”, or perhaps not “eating paleo” are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. So what is the actual “toxin” that is causing you vague but apparently real harm? Detox kits and treatments never name the toxins that they remove, because they’ve never been shown to actually remove toxins.
Alkali anything is a scam
The idea that our body’s acidity needs monitoring and adjusting is regularly promoted by “alternative” health providers. There is the persistent belief that anything that makes the body “acidic” is bad and anything basic or “alkali” is good. But all of this is nonsense, designed to confuse you about basic biochemistry. The pH scale is a measure of the acidity of a liquid. A pH of 7 is neutral. Anything lower is called acidic, anything higher is basic, or alkaline. The pH is a logarithmic scale – that is, a difference of 1 pH is a 10x difference.
Our blood’s pH is 7.4 – slightly alkaline or basic. Enzymes that facilitate chemical reactions in the cells work only in a narrow range of pH. Any significant change means almost certain death. A series of buffers and compensation mechanisms keep the pH in our blood from moving far from 7.4. Because the blood circulates throughout the body constantly, it can compensate any changes in pH in any of our organs (e.g., our muscles during intense exercise). Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the most prevalent acid in our body, and is a product of cellular activity. The blood carries CO2 away and eliminates it in the lungs. The lungs actually provide the biggest source of acid elimination in our body.
Everything we eat is broken down by stomach acid. The pH in our stomach is about 3 – very acidic, due to production of hydrochloric acid. Everything that is ejected from our stomach, into our intestines, is then immediately neutralized by digestive liquids and enzymes. The net effect is that everything we eat or drink and digest will eventually be at the pH in our intestines. Nothing you eat or drink will have a significant effect on the pH of food once it reaches your intestine to be absorbed. And claims that “acidity is the root of all disease” are without basis, reflecting a lack of understanding of basic physiology and biochemistry. If your detox claims to “restore” your acid-base balance, or is supposed to make you more “alkali” – it’s a sure sign of a scam.
What about coffee, but not the kind you drink?

Consuming coffee for the vast majority of people is safe and possibly even beneficial. However, there is the persistent alternative health belief that the real benefits of coffee are realized when you flush it into your rectum. Despite the hype, coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have been reported.
Coffee enemas have their roots as part of the “Gerson Treatment” for cancer, developed by physician Max Gerson in the 1940s. His regimen included coffee enemas, supplements, juice, and injections of calf liver. The approach has been investigated and been shown to be useless for the treatment of cancer. Some proponents of coffee enemas believe that the chemical components of coffee stimulate liver and gall bladder function. There is no credible evidence to suggest this occurs, or that it is necessary.
There are no quick fixes
The hardwiring of “purity” and “contamination” fears in the human brain means we are unlikely to ever be rid of scams like “detox”. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves (some even believe that the COVID vaccines are poisonous) and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature. Popular ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. Our kidneys and liver don’t need a detox treatment. If anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

Detox 2026: What Big Wellness Wants You to Believe
Detox trends come and go. Modern “detox” claims, from microplastics to microbiome resets are marketing, not science.
Scott Gavura on January 2, 2026
Link

Google searches for “detox” reliably peak every January.
Google Search Trends for the word “detox” show a consistent pattern: There is a surge of interest every January in ridding our lives and bodies of toxins. The years pass, but the belief stays the same: Your body has accumulated hidden toxins that can be “flushed out” with the right action, supplement, device, or protocol. While the core idea of detox remains unchanged, the forms it takes are constantly evolving – adapting to current fears and trends. In the past, I’ve blogged about Candida cleanses, coffee colon flushes, and vitamin drips. In 2026, trends have shifted toward microplastics detox, microbiome “resets,” longevity medicine, and data-driven wellness dashboards, all dressed in the veneer of science. Let’s take a look at what’s new, how it’s recycled, and why your liver and kidneys remain the unsung heroes of detoxification.

The Persistent Myth of Detoxification
There’s a reason we fall for the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it. Purification rituals date back as far as recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems part of human nature. Detox programs ranging from bloodletting, purging and enemas to more modern juice cleanses and extreme vitamin regimens all stem from this belief that our bodies are filled with toxins.
Before we had a working understanding of biology, chemistry, and physiology, it was perhaps understandable that rituals emerged to offer spiritual or physical cleansing. Illness was mysterious and the idea of purging unseen harms had intuitive appeal. What’s harder to justify is the persistence of these beliefs in an era where we understand how the body actually handles waste and toxic exposures.
Our liver, kidneys, lungs, and skin are extraordinarily effective at neutralizing, transforming, and eliminating substances we encounter in everyday life. For most people, these systems do all the heavy lifting of detoxification without any help from supplements, saunas, or special protocols. They do not need activation, support, or “boosting”.
Real Detox isn’t Elective
When the term “detox” is used in legitimate medical settings, it has a very narrow and specific meaning. It refers to the treatment of dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, including certain heavy metals. These are medical emergencies or clearly defined clinical conditions, managed in hospitals using evidence-based interventions. Detoxification, in this context, is not a lifestyle choice, a wellness goal, or something selected from a menu of alternative treatments or purchased off a pharmacy shelf.
What has changed over time is how the wellness industry markets detoxification. Where detox once focused on obvious gimmicks like foot baths or juice fasts, in 2026, the same idea is sold in more scientific language, appealing to concerns about aging, environmental pollutants, and microbiome health. Today, detoxification is marketed as precise, personalized solutions. However, the central myth of detox remains unchanged: your body cannot be trusted to do what it already does exceedingly well.
Microplastics Are The New Candida
Headlines about plastic particles being detected in blood, lungs, placentas, and other tissues have been rapidly assimilated into the wellness ecosystem. Microplastics are tiny plastic particles that come from the breakdown of larger plastic pieces. Because microplastics are ubiquitous, persistent and easily dispersed, they are found in water, food and air – and our bodies. While their impact on human health continues to be studied, the message from wellness entrepreneurs has been simplified to: Plastics are accumulating inside you, and are causing you harm.
This is the perfect setting for detox marketing. Much like the Candida detox kits popular 20 years ago, supplements, binders, sauna protocols, and “plastic detox” programs now claim to remove microplastics (instead of yeast) from the body or reduce an individual’s “plastic burden.” Some businesses and clinics offer testing panels that purport to measure retained plastics, despite the absence of validated methods to do so in a clinically meaningful way. Unlike Candida, microplastics are a real environmental and health issue worthy of study. And that’s happening. But, just like older detox trends, a real scientific issue is already being used to justify claims that go far beyond the evidence.
What’s missing from the marketing claims is any evidence that these detox interventions actually work. Detecting microplastics in human tissues does not automatically imply that they can be selectively removed, or that proposed detox strategies meaningfully alter health outcomes. There is no credible evidence that supplements, saunas, chelation-like binders, or dietary protocols can “flush” plastics from the body. The leap to offering a personal detox solution is marketing, not evidence-based medicine.
The microplastics detox narrative we’re seeing also exploiting a familiar (and recurrent) misunderstanding of toxicology: the assumption that detection equals danger, and that identification necessitates purging. In reality, exposure does not make toxicity a certainty. The body’s handling of microplastics is far more complex than the simple input-output model wellness entrepreneurs use. We can see in the detox marketing companies will substitute fear-based marketing where they should be doing the hard science, and promoting unproven products rather than providing evidence their intervention actually does anything.
Microplastics are a legitimate environmental issue and an active area of health research. What they are not is a justification for consumer-driven detox. They’re an invisible villain being used to sell products and services.
Longevity Medicine and the Reinvention of “Toxic Load”
One of the more revealing shifts in detox culture I have observed is that the word itself may be avoided. While the desire to live longer and live better is not new, the term “longevity medicine” is a marketing term you’ll see that describes approaches to slow age‑related decline and extend healthy lifespans. While it’s not a formally recognized medical specialty, you can think of it as a range of interventions, from scientifically grounded prevention and screening that every science-based health professional will advocate, to more speculative anti‑aging claims and treatments.
Among the more dubious statements you will see in longevity medicine are terms like “toxic load,” “metabolic waste,” or “cellular cleanup.” Here the detox framing is different and perhaps more sophisticated: toxins are no longer just making you sick, they are accelerating your aging.
Longevity “clinics” now claim that aging can be slowed by reducing this supposed burden. Programs promise to “support mitochondrial detox,” enhance “glymphatic clearance,” or eliminate “senescent waste.” These phrases are borrowed from legitimate areas of research, but they are often used without evidence that the proposed interventions meaningfully affect human health or lifespan. Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) infusions, IV cocktails, and supplement combinations (“stacks”) are marketed as solutions, despite a lack of persuasive evidence they offer meaningful benefits on lifespan or quality of life.
This version of detox is aimed at people who are largely healthy. Aging is universal – so the potential market is massive. Normal biology is reframed as dysfunction. The promise is not treatment, but optimization and prevention: sharper cognition, better energy, slower aging. But, like all detox, the core error remains the same. Aging cannot be simplified to a toxin-driven process. The presence of cellular byproducts does not mean they can, or should, be removed. Research into aging is important, multidisciplinary and incremental. In longevity medicine, detox is a shortcut to sell products under the guise of science and precision medicine.
Resetting your Microbiome
Colon cleanses haven’t gone away. As interest in the gut microbiome has grown, cleanses have new marketing. They’re now marketed as “resets,” “rebalancing,” or “clearing dysbiosis,” all built on the same premise that our modern lives and diets leave our gastrointestinal tracts filled with sludge, waste, toxins and bad bacteria that must be purged. To keep you buying, current marketing frames these regimens as health maintenance, suggesting that without periodic flushing or special supplements or dietary approaches, gut bacteria will become “unbalanced”, causing an array of vague but often common symptoms.
These programs can range from short-term restrictive diets and high-dose probiotic regimens to herbal “antimicrobials” and fiber loading. Despite the new terminology, the underlying claims remain scientifically unproven. The gastrointestinal tract is not a stagnant set of organs that requires manual cleaning; it is a dynamic system with its own mechanisms for managing microbes, metabolizing food, and eliminating waste. Yet the promise of quick fixes and internal “cleansing” continues to appeal, especially when packaged as part of a modern wellness routine rather than an outdated detox ritual.
Once again, this language replaces evidence-based health measures (eating healthy fiber-rich food and minimizing ultra-processed foods) with marketable interventions. The promise is control over a system that we may not personally understand, delivered through products and protocols rather than sustained, boring fundamentals.
Data-Driven Detox and the Illusion of Precision
As I have blogged about before, wellness has wrapped itself in data. Once used primarily by athletes, wearables are fully mainstream, and are now tools for health “optimization”, and personal accountability. I wear a Garmin myself and use it to track my workouts. It generates a great deal of data: some of it useful, much of it not. But it’s all collected, graphed and then analyzed.
This is exactly the environment in which modern detox programs thrive. Normal physiological variation is reframed as evidence of toxin exposure or impaired detoxification, giving these programs the veneer of personalization and scientific credibility. My Garmin, for example, measures heart rate variability and uses it as one factor to estimate stress. Presented without context, numbers like these can easily be misinterpreted, especially when dashboards rely on unvalidated markers or clinically meaningless thresholds.
Wearables, continuous glucose monitors, and direct-to-consumer lab panels now play the same role in detox marketing. The approach depends on the same error I see with my own workout data: assuming that measurement equals insight. These metrics are rarely validated to assess toxin burden or the effectiveness of the body’s intrinsic detoxification pathways.
Detox programs are then offered as solutions to problems the data itself created. Numbers suggest objectivity, dashboards imply insight, and intervention feels justified. But precision is meaningless when the underlying premise is wrong.
Same Myth, New Packaging
Detoxification myths will always be with us. What once took the form of juice cleanses, foot baths, and Candida colonics has been reborn as microplastics detox, microbiome resets, longevity protocols, and data-driven dashboards. The language has changed, the tools look more sophisticated, and the claims are better packaged. But the core belief remains the same: that our bodies are quietly but undeniably failing, and that intervention is required to fix it.
Science and our understanding has progressed, but the fundamentals have not. The organs responsible for detoxification, our skin, liver, kidneys, and gastrointestinal tract, continue to do their jobs efficiently in the vast majority of people, without you needing products or services to help them. In 2026, focus on what truly supports health: adequate sleep, varied diet, regular physical activity, avoiding smoking, moderating alcohol, and appropriate medical care.


Taxpayers Fund Scientology Research on Gulf War Veterans
Harriet Hall on August 25, 2015
Link

The “Hubbard protocol” is Scientology’s religion-based, pseudoscientific “detoxification” treatment used in its Narconon program to treat drug addiction. It was dreamed up by a science fiction writer with no medical training. Now it is being studied as a treatment for veterans suffering from Gulf War illness. Our limited public money for research is being wasted on a study with no scientific merit. Whether or not you consider this a church/state conflict, the study is clearly ill-advised.
The study: $600K worth of sweat
A description of the study is available online in the government’s clinical trials registry. The DOD funded this study to the tune of $633,677. The subjects are veterans with Gulf War illness characterized by persistent memory and concentration problems, headaches, fatigue, and muscle and joint pain. The illness has not been well defined, and its cause has not been determined; but the researchers are working on the assumption that toxins are the cause and that the treatment will relieve symptoms by removing toxins from the body.
The control group will get only “usual care.” The experimental group will get:
A four to six week regimen consisting of daily, supervised, mild-moderate exercise as tolerated for 20 minutes, supervised, intermittent Finnish saunas (at about 140’F) sauna time with breaks and showers, gradually increased as tolerated to approximately 4 hours, dietary supplements including immediate release niacin in gradually increasing doses from 100 mg to a maximum of 5000 mg per day, salt and water, other vitamins, minerals and oils per Hubbard protocol.
Subjects are randomized to the treatment or control group but are not a random sample of veterans with Gulf War illness. They are a “convenience sample” of veterans who reside in the local area and “show interest in the study,” whatever that means.
The outcomes they measure are quality of life, symptoms as reported on questionnaires, performance on neurocognitive tests, and physical health as measured by standard medical examination and blood tests (metabolic panel, lipid profile, hormones).
Toxins? What toxins?
They describe the intervention they are testing as a detoxification program, but they have no way of knowing whether toxins are responsible for the patients’ symptoms, they don’t identify the toxins, and they don’t demonstrate that any toxins have actually been removed.
One of the participants said, “I was going to be done today, but…I had some more junk come out of my legs. Some black stuff. So I’m going to do one more day and see if I can clean it all out.” The program director, Dr. Crystal Grant, shows off towels with various colored stains (pink, blue, brown, purple, orange, light yellow) that she calls evidence that the program rids the body of nasty toxins. It is no such thing! It is reminiscent of the bogus claims for those detoxification foot baths. It is evidence that something colored the towels, not evidence that the program removes toxins.
One of the participants said by the end of the study she was taking two large canning jars of vitamins a day (!) along with a few spoonfuls of peanut oil.
Scientology’s “Purification Rundown”
The Hubbard protocol is also known as the “Purification Rundown,” and is based on the belief that toxins affect both the body and the soul, and that they can be eliminated from the body by exercise, saunas, and supplements. L. Ron Hubbard believed the regimen would take humans to a higher plane of existence, improve their IQ, and allow them to survive nuclear fallout in World War III.Scientology’s Narconon program uses this regimen to treat drug addiction. Numerous deaths have been attributed to it, and Scientology has been responsible for deaths from its other programs. Its most famous victim is probably Lisa McPherson, who died during an “introspection rundown” treatment for her mental illness. The Wikipedia article provides a handy summary with links to original sources.
The lead investigator, David Carpenter, is a professor of environmental health at the University of Albany who has been embroiled in controversy because of his research on the questionable diagnosis of electromagnetic sensitivity. He was approached by Scientologists and asked to do this study. A Scientology group is providing the therapy; it charges $2,000 per participant, a discount from the usual rate of $3,000. The vitamins they dispense are labeled with a picture of Scientology leader David Miscavage’s personal chiropractor, who has now gone into the supplement business.
Co-investigator Kathleen Kerr is a prominent Scientologist who has appeared in advertisements for the church and served as chair of Narconon Toronto’s board of directors in 2010.
The lead investigator, David Carpenter, was unaware of her conflict of interest until he read about it in The Daily Beast.
Scientology is behind organizations that purport to give impartial advice about drug rehabilitation programs but that actually use detailed scripts to inveigle prospective customers into paying exorbitant amounts for Narconon treatment and subject them to Scientology influence.
Sure, the treatment seems to work
Patients report feeling better, but that could be from a combination of exercise, enjoyment of saunas, and suggestion. They are subjected to an elaborate, time-consuming regimen and have to work at it. The Hawthorne effect of just being in a study may come into play. There is a natural resistance to thinking one’s time and effort have been wasted. It is only natural that participants will believe it has helped them. They are suffering. They want it to work. They expect it to work. They need it to work. A “usual care” group is not a valid control group; it does not control for confounding factors.
When used as a treatment for hyperlipidemia, niacin causes a number of side effects in 92% of patients. It must be started slowly to minimize problems like “niacin flush,” an uncomfortable warmness and redness of the skin. Study participants may interpret these side effects of niacin as a sign that the detoxification is working. It’s not just a matter of innocuous flushing. High dose niacin in the amounts used in the Hubbard protocol can sometimes cause liver failure and death.
Proponents have claimed that niacin releases fat stores into the blood stream to remove toxins stored in fat. In reality, niacin is used clinically to treat hyperlipidemia by decreasing blood lipid levels.
Public funds have been used for this before
Utah has used public funds to “detoxify” cops with the Scientology protocol after they raided meth labs. Public funds have also been spent on “detoxifying” 9/11 workers with the Scientology protocol. This effort has been severely criticized by scientists.
The sins of Scientology
I have written previously about Scientology’s war on medicine. They discourage medical treatment, although medicinal doses of vitamins are part of the Hubbard protocol. Scientology is a religious cult invented by L. Ron Hubbard, a science fiction writer. There is a Deadly Devotions episode that provides insight into how people become attracted to Scientology’s promises of a better life and how they are gradually indoctrinated into bizarre beliefs, persuaded to spend their money on a series of self-improvement courses, and let the church take over their life. It tells the true story of Elli Perkins, a woman who reached a high place in the church hierarchy, refused medical treatment for her paranoid schizophrenic son, was misled by a doctor who was a fellow Scientologist who told her son only had a yeast infection and needed treatment with vitamins and isolation. The story ends in tragedy and then attempted cover-up to protect Scientology’s reputation.
Conclusion: A predictable propaganda win for Scientology
In my opinion, this study is ill-advised from a scientific standpoint. It will do nothing to elucidate the cause of Gulf War symptoms or to credibly test the effectiveness of the Hubbard protocol. We can predict that more subjects will report improvement with the treatment than with usual care. That will not be strong enough evidence of its effectiveness to convince scientists; but it will be enough to bolster Scientology propaganda, to provide pseudoscientific support for their lucrative drug rehab business, and to help entrap suffering people in a dangerous cult.
The Center for Inquiry (CFI) has issued a strongly worded protest against spending public money on a pseudoscientific/religious practice and using our veterans as guinea pigs in a treatment that does nothing to address their plight. They went so far as to call this study obscene. They wrote a letter to the Secretary of Defense urging him to immediately halt the study and open an investigation into how it came about. I would love to see him do just that, but I am not optimistic.

Coffee enemas: This TikTok trend can be deadly
There’s no evidence flushing coffee into your rectum is safe or effective, despite what you may see on TikTok.
Scott Gavura on November 9, 2023
Tweet

It might not occur to you, sipping your morning coffee, that TikTok influencers are suggesting you can derive tremendous health benefits by bypassing your mouth, and firing that beverage directly into your rectum. I first wrote about coffee enemas in 2013 and like other pseudoscientific fads, coffee enemas seem to come and go: Each generation seems to turn to the same “greatest hits”. Coffee colonics are no exception.
Since I can’t easily post an array of TikToks, I’ll turn to an old post, where I looked at a column by Suzy Cohen, who calls herself, “America’s Pharmacist™” and also “America’s Most Trusted Pharmacist®”. Cohen is a proponent of coffee enemas. Her syndicated column Ask the Pharmacist contained this question and response:
Question: I see a naturopathic doctor for chronic fatigue and fibromyalgia. She recommended coffee enemas. Suzy, I’m a faithful reader, do you think this is safe? V.A., Seattle, Washington
Answer: Yes. Coffee enemas are used by holistic physicians for all sorts of conditions including cancer. Lots of people find help with constipation, fatigue and liver detoxification concerns. I know this sounds bizarre because you prefer to taste your coffee, not insert it rectally! Agreed. You may be hearing about coffee enemas today, but they are nothing new and complications from coffee enemas are highly unusual. Hey, I just thought of a new franchise concept called Starbutts … entrance in the rear.
Seriously, coffee enemas may help relieve constipation, insomnia and cognitive problems; they may eliminate (or control) parasites, candida and other pathogens (without disrupting intestinal flora). Coffee enemas are frequently used in natural cancer protocols such as the Gerson Therapy (www.gerson.org). Coffee enemas were outlined as a treatment in the revered “Merck Manual,” a thick book that physicians used as their primary reference for decades, until the mid 1970s.
It’s not the enema as much as it is the coffee that helps. You are exposed to a barrage of toxic compounds in your life, you can easily become overloaded. Some of you cannot detoxify properly. Coffee enemas help you make glutathione, an antioxidant and that sends poisons packing. More on that momentarily.
Coffee enemas can be done at home inexpensively. You just need a comfortable spot on the floor of your bathroom, or bathtub. As the coffee is retained in your bowel, the fluid goes through your intestinal wall, through the portal vein to your liver. The stimulating effects and healing compounds of coffee jumpstart your liver and gallbladder. Bile flows. There are compounds in coffee like kahweol and cafestol which spark production of glutathione, and that is a strong cleansing compound in your body, one that consumers pay good money for when they buy glutathione as a dietary supplement, or get IV injections of it. To make more glutathione naturally (by using a coffee enema) is awesome.
These enemas may allow for relaxation, a better mood, more energy, refreshing sleep and greater mental clarity. If you do too many enemas per week, you may experience electrolyte imbalances. Restoring your electrolytes is crucial, as coffee is a potent drug mugger of minerals. While the controversial cancer specialist Dr. Max Gerson suggested up to six per day, I think that is way too much for the average person. Doing a coffee enema weekly (even daily for awhile) is probably okay for most, but always follow your doctor’s recommendation. The recipe for a coffee enema is different than the beverage.
I was pretty stunned to see this response, particularly from a health professional. Here’s how I’d answer the same question:
A Science-Based Take on Coffee Enemas
Question: I see a naturopathic doctor for chronic fatigue and fibromyalgia. She recommended coffee enemas. Scott, I’m a faithful reader of Science-Based Medicine, do you think this is safe?
Answer: No. Coffee enemas are considered unsafe and should be avoided. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, proctocolitis, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have been reported.
A 2020 systematic review noted, “Nine case reports that describe adverse events were identified and included in the analysis. Of these, 7 recent ones reported colitis after self-administration, mentioning that the most plausible cause assumed was the coffee fluid itself, which contained numerous chemical substances. Two others reported more critical adverse events. All 9 case reports with acceptable quality of evidence warned against the self-administration of the procedure. No study that reports the effectiveness of coffee enema was found.” It concluded, “..this systematic review does not recommend coffee enema self-administration as a complementary and alternative medicine modality that can be adopted as a mean of self-care, given the unsolved issues on its safety and insufficient evidence with regard to the effectiveness.”
Coffee enemas are based on a pre-scientific idea called “autointoxication”, the belief we are being poisoned by toxins because we are not digesting and eliminating waste products from our colons. This concept is not new, and has roots as far back as the history of medicine. Autointoxication as a concept was discarded over time, as the scientific basis for disease was discovered. “Humoral medicine” emerged from ancient Egyptian and Roman ideas that the body was composed of four liquids: black bile, yellow bile, phlegm, and blood. “Balance’ in the humors was the goal, and an accumulation of waste in the colon was though to lead to humoral imbalances. The remedy was flushing colon through enemas and purgatives. This philosophy, now discarded from science-based medicine, is still found in alternative medicine practices.
There is no credible evidence to suggest that coffee enemas can help with insomnia and cognitive problems. In fact, caffeine is absorbed by the colon when coffee is administered as an enema, so it is a poor option for insomnia. The idea that you are contaminated with parasites or candida are just that – ideas. While alternative practitioners may state that these conditions are widespread in the population, there is no scientific evidence to suggest this. There is no reason to treat conditions which do not exist.
Coffee enemas have their roots as part of the “Gerson Treatment” for cancer, developed by physician Max Gerson in the 1940s. His regimen included coffee enemas, supplements, juice, and injections of calves’ liver. The approach has been investigated and been shown to be useless for the treatment of cancer.
The Gonzalez regimen, developed by Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez, is an alternative cancer treatment protocol that involves the consumption of pancreatic enzymes, dietary supplements, and twice-daily coffee enemas. This treatment protocol has also been investigated and found to be ineffective and possibly harmful. In one study, patients treated with standard chemotherapy survived a median of 14 months and patients treated with the Gonzalez regimen survived a median of 4.3 months.
Some proponents of coffee enemas believe that the chemical components of coffee stimulate liver and gall bladder function. There is no credible evidence to suggest this occurs, or that it is necessary. Your liver and gallbladder don’t need an enema in order to work effectively. There is no evidence to suggest that you need to boost your liver’s production of glutathione with enemas. You may in fact be boosting your glutathione already, if you’re a coffee drinker.
I’m very sorry to hear about your chronic fatigue and fibromyalgia. Science-based medicine lacks a good understanding of this illness, and there is a lack of effective treatments. Unfortunately, that can make patients with these illnesses targets to those that profess certainty and offer dubious and unproven treatments, like coffee enemas. A decision to undergo any treatment needs to consider the risk and benefits, and treatments need to be investigated to determine if the benefits outweigh the risks. With coffee enemas, the evidence is clear. Given the lack of benefit and potential harms, there is no plausible justification to undergo these treatments. You should ignore any medical advice from anyone that recommends coffee enemas to you.
A trend to ignore
Autointoxication is a belief that has persisted for hundreds of years. These ideas seem almost a part of human nature: Purification rituals are common features of different cultures worldwide. In modern society, and with many alternative medicine providers, detoxification gets wrapped with a “science!” banner, in an attempt to give the treatments (and their purveyors) a veneer of credibility. Autointoxication beliefs are not only wrong, but they are demonstrably dangerous. Practices like coffee enemas have no plausible benefit and a real risk of harm. More broadly, and perhaps most importantly, the continued promotion of these practices distracts people from legitimate science-based advice and better health care decision-making.

Activated charcoal: The latest detox fad in an obsessive food culture
Scott Gavura on May 7, 2015
Link

Our diet is either the cause of, or solution to, all of life’s problems. I’m paraphrasing a great philosopher. We just can’t seem to let food be food. Today each ingredient we eat seems to be demonized or glorified. Gluten is the latest evil. It used to be fat. At some point in the past, it was MSG. Or it’s a superfood, preferably local, organic and GMO-free. Even on the healthiest diet, however, we’re apparently still ingesting too many harmful chemicals. After all, this is apparently a toxic environment we live in. Gwyneth Paltrow says so. So does the Food Babe. In an era of daily television quackery and loony internet health conspiracy websites, one might think that bizarre food ideas are a recent phenomena. But worries that we’re being poisoned from within are probably innate. One of the oldest surviving written documents is an Egyptian papyrus from the 16th century BCE that linked the cause of disease to digestive wastes in our colon. Since that time, our scientific knowledge about the cause of disease has advanced, but the underlying obsession with diet and elimination hasn’t waned. Anecdotally, it seems to be growing. The idea that our bodies need to “detox” is thriving, despite the fact that it has no scientific basis or validity. Part of the modern appeal of “detox” may be that detoxification is a legitimate medical term and treatment. However, in the alternative-to-health perspective, the word has been co-opted, but the science part has been ignored. Fake “detox” is easy. And now proponents of “detox” have taken it one step further. They’re using real medicine for a fake “detox” with. That’s how activated charcoal has become the latest health fad. 
The popular use of charcoal got a big boost in 2014. After Gwyneth Paltrow’s magazine “Goop” named charcoal lemonade as one of the “best juice cleanses”, the idea of socially consuming charcoal really took off. If you spot someone drinking what looks like a bottle of ink, it could be “lemonade with activated charcoal” made with “alkali” water and sweetened with cane sugar. All this for just $8.99 for 500mL, making this fad a pretty costly one.
Paraphrasing another philosopher, if you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. And when you add charcoal to lemonade, it doesn’t make your lemonade tastier, or healthy. Nor does it give a beverage any magical properties. It gives you black, gritty, gag-inducing lemonade that is in all likelihood even less nutritious than plain lemonade. So how did someone arrive at the idea that adding charcoal to lemonade might be a good idea? It’s based on the popular, but baseless ideas about the toxins that are apparently harming us.
True poisoning can be very real. “Detox” is pure marketing.
What’s popularly called a “detox” today has nothing to do with actual medical detoxification. In the setting of real medicine, detoxification means treatments for dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, like heavy metals. Real detoxification is a treatment for a medical emergency, when a poisoning may be life-threatening. Real detoxification isn’t something you contemplate based on a menu. You don’t order real detoxification treatments at juice bar, and it’s not delivered in smoothie format.
Fake detox, the kind you find in magazines, and sold in pharmacies, juice bars, and health food stores, is make-believe medicine. The use of the term “toxin” in this context is meaningless. There are no toxins named, because there’s no evidence that these treatments do anything at all, but it sounds just scientific enough to be plausible.
The fact is that we are constantly exposed to a huge variety of chemicals, both natural and synthetic. Given many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, we evolved a remarkable system of defenses and mechanisms to remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, our gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up this sophisticated system.
But there’s no question that those defences can be overwhelmed. In the setting of real poisonings, activated charcoal is one treatment that’s used to reduce the risk of harmful effect. Whether or not something is a “poison” depends on the dose. Acetaminophen is remarkably safe at appropriate doses yet causes almost-certain fatalities in overdoses.
Activated charcoal is a medicine and drug sponge. It’s not absorbed into the body, and is put into the gastrointestinal tract to reduce the absorption of drugs and other poisons after they have been ingested, but before they have been absorbed into the body (scientifically speaking, the contents of the mouth, throat, stomach, large and small intestine and rectum are considered “outside of” the body). While the overall effectiveness of charcoal isn’t well documented for all drugs and poisons, it has become a routine part of poisoning protocols. Huge doses of activated charcoal are given with the intent of clearing the harmful substance out of the gastrointestinal tract.
Activated charcoal is produced by heating wood (or another high-carbon product) to high temperatures, and then oxidizing it. The fine particles that remain are almost pure carbon, and the resulting structure has an enormous surface area. The preparation process gives the charcoal the ability to absorb various chemicals to its surface. This is why you’ll see charcoal as a routine ingredient as a filtering agent in commercial and household use, ranging from gas masks to water filters. Depending on the production process, its ability to absorb different chemicals can be made to vary.
Compared to real detoxification protocols, the amount of charcoal added to charcoal lemonade products is small. Given it’s more for aesthetics and marketing than any actual medicinal effects, ingesting charcoal should be well-tolerated with few side effects. It’s not entirely without potential negative consequences, especially when added to a regular diet (or even combined with juice). Activated charcoal doesn’t discriminate between the healthful chemical components of food, and any unwanted chemicals in the digestive system. Activated charcoal appears to bond vitamins like ascorbic acid (vitamin C), niacin, pyridoxine (vitamin B6), thiamine (vitamin B1) and biotin, so it has the potential to make food and drinks you consume actually less nutritious, not more.
Despite the marketing hype, activated charcoal has no ability to suck out the toxic chemicals from the rest of your body. Its effects are limited to the gastrointestinal tract only, and it’s been studied in poisoning situations only. There’s no evidence to demonstrate that the everyday consumption of activated charcoal is either beneficial or helpful in any way.
Charcoal lemonade does seem to have one profound effect though. At $9 per pint, the product does seem very effective at removing cash from the wallets of unsuspecting consumers. As I have noted before, if you hear the words “detox” uttered anywhere but an emergency room, keep in mind that you’re being marketed to.

Activated charcoal, the wellness scam
Charcoal lemonade is yet another detox scam aimed at separating customers from their money.
Scott Gavura on August 8, 2019
Link

Summer days, SBMers. Scott is on vacation and here’s an old post from 2015. See you in two weeks!
Our diet is either the cause of, or solution to, all of life’s problems. I’m paraphrasing a great philosopher. We just can’t seem to let food be food. Today each ingredient we eat seems to be demonized or glorified. Is gluten still evil? It used to be fat. At some point in the past, it was MSG. Or it’s a superfood, preferably local, organic and GMO-free. Even on the healthiest diet, however, we’re apparently still ingesting too many harmful chemicals. After all, this is apparently a toxic environment we live in. Gwyneth Paltrow says so. So does the Food Babe. In an era of daily television quackery and loony internet health conspiracy websites, one might think that bizarre food ideas are a recent phenomena. But worries that we’re being poisoned from within are probably innate. One of the oldest surviving written documents is an Egyptian papyrus from the 16th century BCE that linked the cause of disease to digestive wastes in our colon. Since that time, our scientific knowledge about the cause of disease has advanced, but the underlying obsession with diet and elimination hasn’t waned. Anecdotally, it seems to be growing. The idea that our bodies need to “detox” is thriving, despite the fact that it has no scientific basis or validity. Part of the modern appeal of “detox” may be that detoxification is a legitimate medical term and treatment. However, in the alternative-to-health perspective, the word has been co-opted, but the science part has been ignored. Fake “detox” is easy. And now proponents of “detox” have taken it one step further. They’re using real medicine for a fake “detox”. That’s how activated charcoal has become the latest health fad. 
The popular use of charcoal got a big boost in 2014. After Gwyneth Paltrow’s magazine “Goop” named charcoal lemonade as one of the “best juice cleanses”, the idea of socially consuming charcoal really took off. If you spot someone drinking what looks like a bottle of ink, it could be “lemonade with activated charcoal“. All this for just $10 for 16oz, making this fad a pretty costly one.
Paraphrasing another philosopher, if you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. And when you add charcoal to lemonade, it doesn’t make your lemonade tastier, or healthy. Nor does it give a beverage any magical properties. It gives you black, gritty, gag-inducing lemonade that is in all likelihood even less nutritious than plain lemonade. So how did someone arrive at the idea that adding charcoal to lemonade might be a good idea? It’s based on the popular, but baseless ideas about the toxins that are apparently harming us.
True poisoning can be very real, but “detox” is pure marketing
What’s popularly called a “detox” today has nothing to do with actual medical detoxification. In the setting of real medicine, detoxification means treatments for dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or poisons, like heavy metals. Real detoxification is a treatment for a medical emergency, when a poisoning may be life-threatening. Real detoxification isn’t something you contemplate based on a menu. You don’t order real detoxification treatments at juice bar, and it’s not delivered in smoothie format.
Fake detox, the kind you find in magazines, and sold in pharmacies, juice bars, and health food stores, is make-believe medicine. The use of the term “toxin” in this context is meaningless. There are no toxins named, because there’s no evidence that these treatments do anything at all, but it sounds just scientific enough to be plausible.
The fact is that we are constantly exposed to a huge variety of chemicals, both natural and synthetic. Given many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, we evolved a remarkable set of defenses and mechanisms to remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, our gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up this sophisticated system.
But there’s no question that those defences can be overwhelmed. In the setting of real poisonings, activated charcoal is one treatment that’s used to reduce the risk of harmful effect. Whether or not something is a “poison” depends on the dose. Acetaminophen is remarkably safe at appropriate doses yet causes almost-certain fatalities in overdoses.
Activated charcoal is a medicine and drug sponge. It’s not absorbed into the body, and is put into the gastrointestinal tract to reduce the absorption of drugs and other poisons after they have been ingested, but before they have been absorbed into the body (scientifically speaking, the contents of the mouth, throat, stomach, large and small intestine and rectum are considered “outside of” the body). While the overall effectiveness of charcoal isn’t well documented for all drugs and poisons, it has become a routine part of poisoning protocols. Huge doses of activated charcoal are given with the intent of clearing the harmful substance out of the gastrointestinal tract.
Activated charcoal is produced by heating wood (or another high-carbon product) to high temperatures, and then oxidizing it. The fine particles that remain are almost pure carbon, and the resulting structure has an enormous surface area. The preparation process gives the charcoal the ability to absorb various chemicals to its surface. This is why you’ll see charcoal as a routine ingredient as a filtering agent in commercial and household use, ranging from gas masks to water filters. Depending on the production process, its ability to absorb different chemicals can be made to vary.
Compared to real detoxification protocols, the amount of charcoal added to charcoal lemonade products is small. Given it’s more for aesthetics and marketing than any actual medicinal effects, ingesting charcoal should be well-tolerated with few side effects. It’s not entirely without potential negative consequences, especially when added to a regular diet (or even combined with juice). Activated charcoal doesn’t discriminate between the healthful chemical components of food, and any unwanted chemicals in the digestive system. Activated charcoal appears to bond vitamins like ascorbic acid (vitamin C), niacin, pyridoxine (vitamin B6), thiamine (vitamin B1) and biotin, so it has the potential to make food and drinks you consume actually less nutritious, not more.
Despite the marketing hype, activated charcoal has no ability to suck out the toxic chemicals from the rest of your body. Its effects are limited to the gastrointestinal tract only, and it’s been studied in poisoning situations only. There’s no evidence to demonstrate that the everyday consumption of activated charcoal is either beneficial or helpful in any way.
Charcoal lemonade does seem to have one profound effect though. At $10 per pint, the product does seem very effective at removing cash from the wallets of unsuspecting consumers. As I have noted before, if you hear the words “detox” uttered anywhere but an emergency room, keep in mind that you’re hearing a marketing pitch, not credible health advice.

   Constipation Myths and Facts
Scott Gavura
Link
When it comes to health issues, bowels are big business. Bowel movements are part of everyday life, and we notice immediately when our routine changes. Constipation, from the Latin word constipare (“to crowd together”) is something almost everyone has some experience with. In most cases, it’s an occasional annoyance that resolves quickly. For others, particularly the elderly, constipation can be a chronic condition, significantly affecting quality of life. Depending on the question and the sample surveyed, prevalence seems to vary widely. It’s estimate that there are 2.5 million physician visits per year in the USA, and the costs of management are estimated at about $7.5 billion annually. It’s not a trivial issue.
One of the biggest challenges in interpreting both individual patient situations, as well as the literature overall, is understanding what’s defined as “constipation”. One person’s regular routine may be another person’s constipation. From my dialogue with patients, personal definitions seem to vary. Some panic after a single missed bowel movement, while others may be unconcerned with daily (or even less frequent) movements. What’s the optimal frequency? It depends. Infants may be 3x/day. Older children may be once daily. Adults may be daily or less frequently. The literature generally, though not consistently, defines constipation as a delay or difficulty in bowel movements ( usually less than 3 per week) lasting two weeks. Symptoms can include infrequent, painful bowel movements, straining, and lumpy or hard stools. When these problems last for more than three months, it’s termed chronic constipation. When constipation is accompanied by other symptoms like bloating, diarrhea, and abdominal pain, it may be termed irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).
There are multiple causes of constipation. It may be a consequence of other illnesses (e.g., high/low thyroid, diabetes, cancer, and neurological diseases like multiple sclerosis). Drugs, both prescription and over-they-counter, can also cause constipation. Primary or idiopathic constipation is a diagnosis of exclusion, after other causes have been ruled out. If there are no signs of a more serious underlying condition, treatments can be considered.
Many have firmly-held opinions about their colon and their bowel movements: what’s normal, and what’s not. And there are equally strong opinions about the causes of, and solutions to, constipation. But despite the ubiquity of constipation and the firmly-held opinions on treatments, there’s a sizable chasm between practice and evidence. This is an area with crappy (sorry) data, and it’s hard to sort out what are true treatment effects. But an absence of evidence isn’t evidence of absence, so we’re challenged to make the best decisions possible, despite a disappointing evidence base. Here are some common statements I’ve encountered, and an evidence check on their veracity.
The colon is the root of all illness
Colonic dysfunction as constipation has been described as a cause of disease since at least the 16th Century BC. It’s been a recurring medical motif as long as medicine has existed, starting with ideas of internal putrefaction, and later, once germ theory arrived, became a worry about autointoxication. This theory proposed that unnamed “toxins” were being absorbed from the bowel and causing systemic disease. Now discredited in science-based medicine, these ideas continue to manifest today, largely in the realm of CAM with its warnings to “detox”, irrigate our colon, and indulge in other ritualistic “cleansing” practices. So today the colon continues to be blamed for all manners of illness, including eczema, cancer, high blood pressure, allergies, and more. There’s no evidence to substantiate these claims.
I need to have a bowel movement at least every “X” to avoid toxins/allergies/chronic disease/certain death
This argument is an extension of beliefs about the necessity of bowel movements to avoid systemic disease. Interestingly, over hundreds of years, there’s always been the idea that constipation is a modern disease, one of urbanization and civilization: dietary changes, the busy pace of life and a lack of exercise. So if you don’t feel constipated, you aren’t. Bowel habits can be evaluated on their own merits. As long as they’re not painful or hard, there is no ideal frequency. In the absence of constipation, the flushing of the colon, or the use of laxatives or other purgatives is at best unnecessary, and at worst, potentially harmful.
A lack of fibre can cause constipation, and fibre supplements are effective constipation treatments
The granddaddy of fibre cereals, All Bran, appeared on the market in the 1900s as a treatment for the diagnosis of the day, autointoxication of the colon. Since then, fibre has held a special place in the armamentarium of health professionals and CAM advocates alike: It’s not only natural, but nature’s little broom, right?
Fibre, from cereal or other foods, serves multiple purposes in the bowel. It adds bulk to the stool and can increase the frequency of bowel movements. But there is a lack of correlation between dietary fibre intake, and the risk of constipation. And in patients given fibre supplements, the response in patients with chronic constipation is erratic. Fibre, particularly bran and other insoluble fibres causes gas formation, which can limit acceptance. Soluble fibres, like psyllium (Metamucil) are better tolerated.
Studies suggest that that low fibre diets may be a a contributing factor to constipation in a subset of patients, who may respond to higher fibre diets. Consequently, Fibre supplements may be useful in some patients with mild or occasional constipation. But in more severe cases of chronic constipation, fibre can actually aggravate symptoms,and does not appear to be an effective therapy.
Drinking more fluids can help reduce the risk of constipation
The idea that consuming more water will result in softer, easier to pass stools hasn’t been substantiated when studied in patients with chronic constipation. Studies in the elderly have also failed to reveal an association between increased fluid intake and constipation. Constipated children, randomized to consume different amounts of fluid, didn’t experience any changes in stool frequency, consistency, or ease of defecation. Unless there’s evidence of dehydration, consuming extra fluid on its own is unlikely to make any difference in cases of constipation.
Exercise can help constipation
In most patients with constipation, this statement is true. There’s an established relationship between our activity level and our bowel habits, giving us the luxury of sleeping several hours without interruption. There seems to be a relationship between exercise levels and incidence of constipation, though across several studies, it’s not clearly a causal relationship. And in cases of vigorous exercise (e.g., running) there is clearly evidence of a significant increase in activity. While it’s not possible to do a truly randomized, double-blind trial, the evidence available supports the use of physical exercise can be helpful for modest constipation, but it does not seem to be effective for severe cases.
Stool softeners are effective
Stool softeners (e.g., docusate sodium (Colace)) are among the most popular products prescribed for the prevention or treatment of constipation. They’re often a reflex prescription that accompanies narcotic prescriptions, because constipation is a frequent side effect of narcotic drug use, mainly due to effects on transit time through the colon. Stool softeners are essentially soap, and the theory is that they make the stool easier to pass. Despite their widespread use, there’s no good evidence that docusate sodium or docusate calcium are effective for the treatment of constipation. I find it quite fascinating that docusate sodium is one of the active ingredients in Corexit, last seen being dumped in large quantities into the Gulf of Mexico to disperse the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Presumably the evidence is better for that indication.
Natural or synthetic, the drugs don’t work
Before treating constipation, getting an understanding of symptoms, other medications, and other illnesses is important. In cases where reversible factors have been ruled out, drug therapy may be warranted. Despite the lack of good evidence, dietary and lifestyle changes usually precede drug therapy. In cases that don’t respond or resolve on their own, medications are next. Broadly, categories of treatments include bulk-forming products, stool softeners, osmotic agents, and stimulant laxatives. Products available are a mix of naturally-derived and synthetic products. Some of the most popular laxatives are naturally-derived. The strange smell of Senokot tablets gives a clue to its origin: They’re senna glycosides, a product of the senna plant. The naturally occuring glucosides it contains are colonic irritants, stimulating colon contraction. Metamucil is psyllium seed husks, which swell into a gelatinous mass in the stomach, carrying water and bulk to the colon. Most of the other fibre supplements are naturally-derived as well.
The other commonly used products are synthetically derived. Milk of magnesia, despite its natural sounding name, is a suspension of magnesium hydroxide.When consumed, most of the magnesium isn’t absorbed, and it pulls fluid with it (via osmotic pressure) when it’s shunted to the colon. Polyethylene glycol (PEG) works this way, as does lactulose, a non-digestible sugar. The cathartics taken before endoscopy are all osmotic agents, too.
Bisacodyl (Dulcolax) is another popular over-the-counter product. A stimulant laxative like senna, bisacodyl stimulates colon contraction.
Despite the number of products, and prevalence of constipation, the evidence base for drug treatments is weak. There’s little head-to-head evidence that has pitted on treatment against another. So we’re largely left to make inferences from poor studies on different populations. The best evidence (which is still pretty weak) exists for the osmotic agents like PEG. Some evidence exists for psyllium, but it’s underwhelming. There’s evidence for lactulose as a treatment, as well. An excellent systematic review from the Oregon Evidence-Based Practice Center summarizes the evidence base in greater detail.
Probiotics can be effective for constipation
Probiotics, covered in depth by Mark Crislip already, are live microorganisms administered with intent of a therapeutic effect. If you like yogurt that does double duty, you’ll probably see brands that include Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus, and, depending on your national regulator, there may be vague health claims about intestinal “wellness” on the label. The idea of probiotics for constipation is at least plausible, as probiotics have the potential to disrupt the colon’s bacteria ecosystem – if only to a very limited extent, as Mark noted in his post. For constipation, their effectiveness hasn’t been demonstrated though. A systematic review published in 2010 examined the data supporting their use in adults and children. Five high quality trials were identified and the results were unimpressive:
Data published to date suggest that adults with constipation might benefit from ingestion of B. lactis DN-173 010, L. casei Shirota, and E. coli Nissle 1917, which were shown to increase defecation frequency and improve stool consistency. However, in some cases, even if there was a significant difference in results, their clinical relevance is unclear.
Their conclusion:
Until more data are available, we believe the use of probiotics for the treatment of constipation condition should be considered investigational.
Overall, not encouraging. And little reason to recommend their use. That’s the opinion of some regulators, too. The European Food Safety Authority has largely rejected general health claims for probiotics.
Taking laxatives continuously is dangerous and leads to tolerance and then dependence
This is a common myth, but not substantiated by fact. [ little evidence to demonstrate that laxatives are effective in children. A systematic review published earlier this year summarized the evidence base. Like treatment for adults, the data are limited. Because of the lack of evidence, dietary changes, while also not well supported by evidence, should precede any drug therapy. Acute treatments should be followed with longer term strategies to prevent further episodes. While the effectiveness of fibre for the treatment of constipation in children hasn’t been demonstrated, encouraging fibre-rich fruits or vegetables as a first step may plausibly help, and have numerous other health benefits as well.
Conclusion
Constipation is is common condition, yet there’s little high quality evidence to guide our actions. Myths about constipation further complicate treatment strategies. In the absence of high quality evidence, it would seem most conservative to carefully evaluate each situation for potentially causal factors, and introduce the treatments backed by the best evidence only after core dietary and lifestyle factors have been implemented

Vibrating Pills for Constipation: Safe and Effective or Bowel-Shaking Earthquakes of Doubt and Remorse*
A vibrating pill designed to treat chronic constipation is now available by prescription. It will likely help some people, and it’s safe, but it isn’t a game changer.
Clay Jones on February 17, 2023
Link

Last week there was a bit of potentially exciting news for the millions of Americans with chronic functional constipation who don’t tolerate, or perhaps would simply like to avoid, medication side effects. A vibrating pill, made from the same material as the pill cameras (capsule endoscopy) used to capture images of areas of the intestines that are difficult to reach using standard endoscopy, is now officially available by prescription after having been cleared by the FDA last August. But does it really work? And is it even safe?
Chronic constipation is an extremely common problem that affects people of all ages, and is particularly common in young children. I covered this issue in kids a few years ago. In the adult population for which this new drug-free medical device is cleared, chronic constipation is a daily concern for millions (10-20%) of Americans, most of which have functional, also known as idiopathic, constipation. This is diagnosed when constipation occurs but no anatomic or physiologic cause can be identified. In functional constipation, there are many potential contributing factors such as diet, poor hydration, stress, and a sedentary lifestyle.
Constipation is typically treated with lifestyle modifications and laxatives, of which there are many different types. Some work by simply softening or lubricating the stool for easier passage through the intestines. Others act as a stimulant that causes the intestines to contract and push stool on its way. These can cause nausea and uncomfortable cramping, but they can all potentially result in diarrhea. There are prescription treatments, but these have typically been prescribed for irritable bowel syndrome rather than functional constipation.
The new vibrating pills are claimed to work through a similar mechanism as stimulant laxatives. Instead of triggering contractions (peristalsis) through chemical irritation, however, they work by stimulating specialized sensory cells in the lining of the intestine mechanically. So there is at least the plausible possibility that these pills could also cause cramping, nausea, and diarrhea.
But do they really work?
New reports, along with a press release from the company that developed the device, are touting a study that involved 349 people, 200 of which took the vibrating pill 5 days a week for 8 weeks. The remaining 149 study subjects took a placebo pill that did not vibrate. The study wasn’t published, instead being presented at a conference, but I was eventually able to track down the study design, which was randomized and blinded, although it is unclear how well blinding held considering that some subjects reported being able to feel the vibrations.
The study found that 39% of patients taking the vibrating pill had one or more additional “complete spontaneous bowel movement” per week compared to their individual baseline, which was 17% more than in the placebo group. 23% of subjects in the treatment group reported two or more additional satisfying poops per week, compared to half that in the placebo group. These results, along with reported improvements in stool consistency, amount of straining, and overall quality of life were statistically significant and there were no severe adverse events or worrisome diarrhea or nausea in the treatment group.
So it appears that the pill could be a safe and helpful intervention for many, but won’t work for a decent percentage of people. And unfortunately, because I don’t have access to a published and peer reviewed paper, I can’t speak to how well the study was controlled and blinded. If blinding broke down, there could have been some inspired changes in lifestyle that resulted in improvement in constipation rather than the treatment.
Also, the study did not compare the vibrating pill to other treatment options, so we don’t know how they stack up. I doubt that these pills work better than other options, however. But I can believe that they result in fewer side effects. I don’t think patient non-adherence to constipation treatment because of side effects is a common concern though.
One concern with the vibrating pills, however, is expense. They are not currently covered by insurance, and the company making them claims that they will offer a coupon to cap the monthly out-of-pocket cost at $69 per month for patients who have health insurance. That isn’t terrible as far as pharmaceutical interventions go, but it works out to several dollars per extra poop. You can easily find a month supply of name brand Miralax, an effective and gentle stool softener in common use for chronic constipation in pediatric and adult patients, for less than a third of that amount.
Conclusion: Vibrating pills are likely not a game changer for chronic constipation
Meh. I’m not saying that these devices are useless. They will likely help some people who are dealing with chronic constipation and are sensitive to the nausea and cramping sometimes caused by standard drug treatments. But it doesn’t look like this will be some kind of revolution in management.
*The very first SBM reference to a CAKE song: Clever and Funny or Not Worth the Effort?

Nuubu: Here We Go Again! Recycling Debunked Foot Detox Myths
Companies come and go, but the claims remain the same, that you can (insert claim) with (insert product) without any evidence. A new company offering magical footpads are just putting new wine in old bottles.
Harriet Hall on December 14, 2021
Link
In an ideal world, rational people would stop believing false claims that had been conclusively debunked. Ours is not a rational world. Here, unbelievable claims just keep going and going, like the Energizer Bunny. The myths are like zombies that refuse to die. Products are tweaked and given new names, and customers keep buying them.
I first wrote about detoxification quackery over a decade ago after I observed vendors at a local fair demonstrating ionic foot baths to gullible customers. Detoxification quackery is silly. The idea of detoxing through the skin of the feet is even sillier. First it was foot baths and then it was foot pads.
Myth vs. reality
Myth: we are exposed to all kinds of hazardous chemicals and toxins in our environment.
Reality: yes, but there is a difference between hazard and risk. A hazard is anything that could potentially cause harm. A risk is the chance that someone will actually be harmed by the hazard.
Myth: toxins accumulate in our bodies, as evidenced by blood tests.
Reality: our lab tests have become so good at identifying minuscule quantities that we are tempted to forget the old adage that the dose makes the poison. Even drinking too much water has been known to kill people, while tiny amounts of most toxins have never been shown to cause harm. One atom of a radioactive element has never killed anyone, except maybe Schrodinger’s cat; and that is nothing but a hypothetical thought experiment where the cat is rendered simultaneously both dead and alive.
Myth: we need to detoxify.
Reality: our liver does a good job of removing toxins. It doesn’t need any outside help.
Myth: toxins can be removed through the skin of our feet.
Reality: no, they can’t.
Myth: “detoxifying” foot baths and pads remove toxins.
Reality: the toxins are never named, and attempts to measure decreased amounts of toxins in the body or increased amounts in the water after treatment have all failed.
Myth: the color in the water shows which toxins were removed:
    • Yellow-green = detoxifying from the kidney, bladder, urinary tract, female/prostate area
    • Orange = detoxifying from joints
    • White cheese like particles = most likely yeast
    • Brown = detoxifying from liver, tobacco, cellular debris
    • Black = detoxifying from liver, gallbladder
    • Dark green = detoxifying from gallbladder
    • White foam = mucous from lymph
    • Black flecks = heavy metals
    • Red flecks = blood clot material
Reality: the color in the water is created by hydrolysis. It is either rust from the electrodes or due to impurities on the skin or in the water. The process is well understood. Early on, skeptics observed that the water changes color if you run the footbath without putting your feet in it.
Myth: the detoxifying foot pads change color overnight, proving that toxins, waste products, chemicals, and heavy metals have been removed. This is said to have all kinds of health benefits, such as:
    • Lower your blood pressure
    • Relieve headaches
    • Reduce cellulite
    • Ease symptoms of depression
    • Improve your life with diabetes
    • Help you sleep better
    • Increase weight loss
Reality: The adhesive foot patches don’t remove any toxins. They occlude the skin and make it sweat. The patches contain vinegar. The color change is produced by skin debris, vinegar, and sweat. Using vinegar-soaked gauze will accomplish the same thing.
Kinoki foot pads
Kinoki foot pads were banned for deceptive marketing:
The defendants also advertised that when applied to the soles of consumers’ feet at night, the foot pads could remove toxins, metabolic wastes, heavy metals, and chemicals from the body; treat headaches, depression, parasites, fatigue, insomnia, diabetes, arthritis, high blood pressure, cellulite, and a weakened immune system; and cause weight loss. In its complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey on January 27, 2009, the FTC charged that these advertising claims were false or unsupported.
The defendants agreed to a judgment of $14.5 million, which represents the total revenues from the sale of Kinoki Foot Pads.
A new kid on the block: Nuubu
So Kinoki foot pads are out, but Nuubu foot pads are in.
The company says “The largest concentration of harmful toxins is in the feet“. That’s simply not true. They offer no evidence, because there isn’t any.
These foot pads contain loquat leaf, vitamin C, wood vinegar, bamboo vinegar, dextrin, houttuynia cordata, tourmaline, and negative ion powder. Claims are made for each of these ingredients. For instance, negative ion powder is said to “restore the healthy pH level and harmonize oxygen level in the blood stream”. and tourmaline “improves the detoxification process and strengthens your liver and kidneys”. Vague, unsubstantiated pseudoscientific gibberish. No supporting references.
The Nuubu website tells us all of these are signs of toxic build-up:
    • Brain fog
    • Irritability
    • Skin problems
    • Muscle aches
    • Body odor
    • Insomnia
    • Headaches
    • Exhaustion
    • Stubborn weight
    • Constipation
They use familiar altmed buzzwords: traditional, ancient wisdom, all-natural, holistic, treats the cause rather than just the symptoms, cost-effective (because it treats multiple symptoms at once). Yes, they contradict themselves, claiming it doesn’t treat symptoms while also claiming it treats multiple symptoms. There is pressure to “buy now” while the foot pads are on sale for a limited time. There is even a page that repeats the ridiculous reflexology claim that all the body’s organ systems flow through the feet!
They claim to be using “tried-and-true Asian medicinal techniques”. They mention 360 acupoints, more than 60 of which are found on the soles of the feet. They say their herbs are picked in the remote East-Asian mountainsides and are eco-friendly. The website carries an extensive disclaimer.
Conclusion: No evidence here
I can’t say that Nuubu foot pads and detox foot baths have no benefits. Subjective and placebo benefits are always possible. Maybe you find that sitting for a while with your feet in warm water is soothing and relaxing. Maybe you enjoy carrying out chemical experiments that cause color changes. Maybe you like feeling that you are doing something to help yourself by carrying out a ritual.
        ◦ What I can say with confidence is that there is no evidence that removing toxins through the skin of the feet is possible.

“Base Spike Detox” and Signature Spike Support Formulas: Nattokinase quackery to treat COVID-19 and COVID-19 “vaccine injury”
Dr. Peter McCullough and a number of “anti-COVID-19 vaccine” antivaxxers out there has pivoted to quackery to “detox” from the supposedly malign effects of COVID-19 vaccines. Everything old is new again, this time with nattokinase.
David Gorski on July 24, 2023
Link

If there’s one reliable characteristic of physicians who go all-in on antivaccine beliefs, it’s that, after they have come to identify vaccines as The One True Source of All Chronic Disease (or just a bunch of toxic sludge causing “vaccine injury”), it is almost inevitable that they come up with quackery to treat what they view as vaccine-induced chronic disease or injury. Back in the “old days,” I used to write about what was called “autism biomed,” because the primary antivaccine claim 15 years ago was that childhood vaccines cause autism. Basically, “autism biomed” was—and remains—a blanket term used by believers in the vaccine-autism conspiracy theory to describe a rather large collection of quackery that included chelation therapy, various “detox” regimens, “metabolic” treatments, and more, none of which had one iota of evidence to support them as treatments for autism spectrum disorders. Use of the term “biomed” was meant to imply that these were legitimate “biomedical” treatments for “vaccine-induced autism,” when in reality they consisted mainly of a motley collection of “detox” quackery, often bolstered by “functional medicine” and various alternative medicine treatments like naturopathy and homeopathy. This brings me to Dr. Peter McCullough and his “Base Spike Detox,” which uses enzymes like nattokinase and bromelain to “detox” the spike protein from both COVID-19 and COVID-19 vaccines. As it turns out, Dr. McCullough’s protocol is just a variant of an earlier protocol that I first learned about earlier this year, Signature Series Spike Support Formula sold by The Wellness Company and promoted by Dr. McCullough, a video of whom is featured on the product page, but had never gotten around to writing about on this blog.
Here are the ingredients of the supplement, which is advertised to let you “get back to that pre-COVID feeling”:

As for the claims:
Spike Support Formula contains all natural, non-GMO, scientifically-supported ingredients:
Nattokinase has been researched to dissolve spike proteins and blood clots.
Dandelion root may prevent spike protein from binding to your cells.
Selenium to help reduce stress, aiding in helping the body repair itself and recover.
Black sativa extract may facilitate cellular repair.
Green tea extract provides added defenses at the cellular level through scavenging for free radicals.
Irish sea moss is mineral-rich and could help rebuild damaged tissue and muscle.
Leaving aside the nattokinase for a moment, you can see that most of the claims for the herbs and extracts are all fairly generic; i.e., “rebuild damaged tissue”; “facilitate cellular repair”; or “help reduce stress.” We’ll look at the other claims in a moment, such as that nattokinase dissolves spike protein and dandelion root “may prevent spike protein from binding to your cells.”
Obviously, Dr. McCullough is far from the first example of COVID-19 antivax docs making a pivot towards unproven treatments. One prominent example that comes to mind is America’s Frontline Doctors, a group that first made a name for itself resisting “lockdowns,” masking, and public health interventions for COVID-19 but then later pivoted to a highly profitable grift running a telehealth prescription mill for ivermectin. Ivermectin, of course, was billed the inexpensive highly effective treatment for COVID=19 that “They” don’t want you to know about. In addition, although I have been unable to figure out who first came up with the idea of using nattokinase to “dissolve spike protein,” I do know that this particular detox formulation appears to have been the “brainchild” (and I do use the word “brain” very loosely here) of Jen VanDeWater, who’s a pharmacist selling something called “Dr. Jen VanDeWater’s Spike Recovery Formula,” which is billed as the “gold standard” in combatting “shedding” and fending off the “deadly spike protein”:
These are the basics for the claims about nattokinase as a treatment for COVID-19, long COVID, and COVID-19 “vaccine injury.”
Dr. McCullough, however, is a bit different in that he’s promoting his nostrums not just to treat COVID-19 and long COVID, but to “detox” people from the dreaded spike protein used as the antigen in COVID-19 vaccines. The key ingredient in the Spike Support Formula is nattokinase, which is a proteolytic enzyme (an enzyme that cleaves proteins at specific sites), and now apparently Dr. McCullough has added another proteolytic enzyme, bromelain, to the mix:
I have found in my clinical practice that most multiply infected and or COVID-19 vaccine injected patients with post-COVID-19 symptoms respond slowly after three months or more of “Base Spike Detox” which contains:
Nattokinase 2000 FU (100 mg) twice a day
Bromelain 500 mg daily
nano Curcumin 500 mg twice a day
So what are nattokinase and bromelain, and why does Dr. McCullough promote them as treatments to “detox” you from spike protein, whether it comes from COVID-19 or the dreaded and much more evil (apparently) spike protein that the mRNA vaccines induce your cells to make in minute quantities? Let’s find out.
Nattokinase
I was unfamiliar with nattokinase before, but several months ago I had bookmarked a post by Dr. Paul Alexander that basically laid out the entire “rationale”—again, if you can call it that—for using nattokinase to “detox” from the dreaded spike protein. First, he says that you need to “detox” the spike protein, particularly if you’ve had the vaccine:
Spike protein (due to the COVID vaccine or virus) is becoming increasingly concerning and people are begging for solutions. They are scared and in many instances distraught as to the spike circulating within them. As a result, a spike detoxifier is needed. This detoxifier can potentially help manage the amount of spike protein in your body (especially spike induced by the Pfizer and Moderna gene platform).
Seeing a claim like this leads me to point out some things. First, the amount of spike protein that gets into the bloodstream as a result of the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines made by Pfizer and Moderna is infinitesimally small, definitely smaller than the amount of spike protein one gets from an—oh, you know—actually infection with SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. Second—and I know I’m repeating myself from above, but bear with me—antivaxxers have been recommending “detoxification” to treat “vaccine injury” or “vaccine toxicity” since long before I ever first took notice of the antivaccine movement which was well over two decades ago. Nattokinase, as you will see, is just the latest wrinkle in this old narrative.
Unsurprisingly, instead of blaming the virus for long COVID, Alexander blames—you guessed it!—the vaccine:
This is a particularly important consideration given the massive reporting of symptoms post recovery from virus infection or taking the COVID mRNA-DNA gene injection (Pfizer and Moderna). I am referring to what is called ‘LONG-COVID’ and you may have heard this term or similar. The advancing ‘maturing’ science is focusing on clarifying this condition yet it is clear just by looking around us in our own personal daily lives (ourselves, our family members, our friends, or our work colleagues as well as just strangers who shared their struggles), that this COVID gene injection or the virus leaves many with symptoms and often debilitating crippling one. This is no laughing matter and some (many) people are very damaged by the gene injection vaccine (as well as the virus).
At least Dr. Alexander sort of acknowledges that the virus might actually cause long COVID. Of course, he frames it by saying “some (many) people” were damaged by the “gene injection” vaccine “as well as the virus.” His readers know what he really means, namely that he’s claiming that the vaccine is the primary cause of what is being labeled “long COVID.” Lest you fail to get that message, he rapidly pivots to claim:
The reality is that the COVID gene injections (so called vaccines) induces the very toxic dangerous part of the COVID virus that causes severe and often fatal disease sequelae, this being the spike protein, as part of the immune response. The spike protein and especially the S1 sub-unit of the spike protein is highly pathological and is more than likely involved in the often crippling post-vaccination syndrome e.g. LONG COVID. The spike protein is devastatingly toxic (references here, here, here).
I can’t help but note that the first article uses a mouse model to study acute lung injury from COVID-19 involving artificially high doses of spike protein. The second article is by Stephanie Seneff, a naturopath, and Peter McCullough. (‘Nuff said.) The third article is about the incidence of acute allergic reactions to COVID-19 vaccines, and I note that pretty much all vaccines can cause rare allergic reactions, making COVID vaccines nothing unique on that score. None of these articles, other than the mouse model, demonstrates that the spike protein is a “toxin” that causes long COVID, and even the mouse model is of limited utility in that the dose used (400 µg/kg) is huge compared to anything a vaccine could cause and arguably even more than infection can cause. Also, the recombinant spike protein was administered not intramuscularly or intravenously, but intratracheal, meaning that the investigators squirted saline containing it into the tracheas of the mice. Anyway, cherry picking and misrepresenting studies is how dishonest antivaxxers roll.
So what does nattokinase supposedly do? Actually, maybe it’s more appropriate to ask: How does nattokinase supposedly “dissolve” the dreaded spike protein, which to antivaxxers is so much more horrible if it comes from the toxin-laden vaccines rather than naturally from the disease?
According to Alexander:
Recent literature has shown nattokinase to be effective in degrading the spike protein associated with COVID-19 [3]. It has long been known to reduce the risk of clot formation and improve circulation [3].
Before I started looking into what nattokinase is even supposed to do, let me just briefly note that the first thing I always wonder about when I see an enzyme being touted as a treatment for anything is how a protein—an enzyme—can work when taken orally. In general, proteins are rapidly broken down in the stomach and proximal small intestine by a number of other very efficient enzymes that chew up the peptide chain. It is true that there are a few exceptions, but they tend to be digestive enzymes, which can survive in the harsh chemical environment of the stomach and enzymatic environment of the small intestine. Examples include pancreatic enzymes, whose function can indeed be replaced by oral supplementation because these enzymes are among the enzymes that work in digestion. Nattokinase does not appear to be one of these enzymes. So what is it?
It turns out that nattokinase is an enzyme used to ferment soy bean products that have long been a dietary staple in Japan. It also turns out that it’s been a popular supplement dating back to long before the pandemic. If you do a Google search for just “nattokinase” a lot of the results will be supplement sellers promoting it for its various claimed health benefits. In brief, nattokinase is extracelluar enzyme secreted by the bacterium Bacillus subtilis, used to ferment boiled or steamed soybeans resulting in a preparation called nattō. The Memorial Sloan-Kettering website notes:
Nattokinase is also available as a supplement and is most known for its effects on prevention and treatment of clots and to improve blood circulation.
And:
Nattokinase has been promoted as an alternative anticancer treatment based on the notion that it can help dissolve the fibrin coating around a tumor, and increase oxygen supply in the blood to inhibit cancer cell growth. However, these mechanisms have not been proven in humans.
Nattokinase is also purported to treat Alzheimer’s disease and hypertension and a number of other disorders, because of course it is.
So right away you can see why nattokinase would be attractive to COVID antivax quacks, given that one of the main false claims about these vaccines is that they are causing people to “die suddenly” of clotting disorders leading to strokes and myocardial infarctions (heart attacks). (They aren’t.) To quacks, nattokinase could be a two-for, both supposedly “dissolving” that nasty, toxic, evil spike protein (from the vaccine) and also dissolving clots. It’s also not as though nattokinase doesn’t have activities in vitro (test tube and cell culture) that do have relevance to clotting:
In vitro studies show that nattokinase decreases clot formation by cleaving and inactivating the plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) via proteolysis at P1-P1’ peptide bond. PAI is a key inhibitor of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) that converts plasminogen to plasmin. PAI inactivation allows for greater tPA activity and increased lysis of clots (10) (11). In the absence of PAI, nattokinase affects direct proteolysis of fibrin; however, this effect is less than the protelysis achieved by the PAI-mediated pathway (2). The fibrinolytic activity of nattokinase is estimated to be four-fold that of plasmin (12).
The question, of course, is whether the in vitro activities of nattokinase translate into anything therapeutic in vivo in humans. The answer is: We don’t know. However, it strikes me as highly unlikely that nattokinase does these things in the human bloodstream when taken orally. One WebMD perusal of the evidence is full of “maybes” and other qualifiers like “possibly,” in which it’s claimed that nattokinase “might” increase your risk of bleeding, decrease your blood pressure, etc., but notes that there’s basically little to no clinical evidence to support these uses.
So what evidence do doctors like Dr. McCullough cite when recommending nattokinase? They always have some evidence to cite, but is it in any way convincing? In an earlier Substack post from February, Dr. McCullough was touting the Dissolution of Spike Protein by Nattokinase, which he called the “Holy Grail of COVID-19 vaccine detoxification,” handwaving an “explanation” of why the vaccine-induced spike protein is so much more nasty than the much huger amounts of spike protein produced by an actual infection:
Far and away the most common question I get from those who took one of the COVID-19 vaccines is: “how do I get this out of my body.” The mRNA and adenoviral DNA products were rolled out with no idea on how or when the body would ever breakdown the genetic code. The synthetic mRNA carried on lipid nanoparticles appears to be resistant to breakdown by human ribonucleases by design so the product would be long-lasting and produce the protein product of interest for a considerable time period. This would be an advantage for a normal human protein being replaced in a rare genetic deficiency state (e.g. alpha galactosidase in Fabry’s disease). However, it is a big problem when the protein is the pathogenic SARS-CoV-2 Spike. The adenoviral DNA (Janssen) should broken down by deoxyribonuclease, however this has not be exhaustively studied.
This leaves dissolution of Spike protein as a therapeutic goal for the vaccine injured. With the respiratory infection, Spike is processed and activated by cellular proteases including transmembrane serine protein 2 (TMPRSS2), cathepsin, and furin. With vaccination, these systems may be avoided by systemic administration and production of Spike protein within cells. As a result, the pathogenesis of vaccine injury syndromes is believed to be driven by accumulation of Spike protein in cells, tissues, and organs.
It is, of course, utter nonsense to claim that the vaccines were rolled out with “no idea on how or when the body would ever breakdown the genetic code.” Extensive preclinical work on the vaccines, plus the two decades of work before that developing the mRNA vaccines in general, provided a lot of knowledge on how mRNA, even the modified mRNA used in the vaccines, is broken down in cells and the body. Just because we don’t know everything does not mean that we know nothing, although that is a frequent false dichotomy promoted by antivaxxers.
It is, of course, true that the mRNA vaccines were designed using modified ribonucleotides that are more resistant to being broken down by human ribonucleases, but that’s mainly because most mRNAs are quite short-lived and rapidly broken down this way. To have a chance of making sufficient spike protein to elicit an immune response, a much longer half-life was required. Instead of half lives of minutes to hours which is typical for most mRNAs (the median half-life of all human mRNAs as a group is around 10 hours), a half-life on the order of days was required. (As an aside, the half-life of the mRNA for a gene that I once studied as a graduate student was around 4 hours, but would decrease to less than an hour in response to cell stimulation with serum.) In contrast, the half-life of the mRNA for spike protein used in the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines is on the order of a few days, with the spike protein being detectable for at most a few weeks. While it is true that one study oft-cited by antivaxxers found vaccine mRNA fragments in the blood as long as 28 days after vaccination, I note that this was mostly fragments, meaning that the mRNA would not be expected to generate further spike protein and that the authors speculated that this finding might have been due to slow leakage of the lipid nanoparticles out of the injection site. In any event, contrary to what antivaxxers claim, neither the modified mRNA nor the spike protein coded for by that mRNA persist longterm in the human body. They do not need to be “detoxed.” The body can do a perfectly find job of that.
In the same post, Dr. McCullough cites three studies. One is, unsurprisingly, an in vitro study in which cells infected with SARS-CoV-2 and lysates from cells were exposed to different doses of nattokinase, after which the authors reported:
When cell lysates transfected with S protein were incubated with nattokinase, the S protein was degraded in a dose- and time-dependent manner. Immunofluorescence analysis showed that S protein on the cell surface was degraded when nattokinase was added to the culture medium. Thus, our findings suggest that nattokinase exhibits potential for the inhibition of SARS-CoV-2 infection via S protein degradation.
They also appear to have done some of the appropriate controls, such as heating nattokinase to inactivate it or treating it with a protease inhibitor to inhibit its ability to cleave protein strands and then observing that such treatments eliminated the ability of nattokinase to degrade spike protein. A similar study, also cited by Dr. McCullough, reported that nattokinase can inhibit SARS-CoV-2 infection in cell culture. Of note, both studies examined whether nattokinase had an effect on spike protein produced by the virus (SARS-CoV-2) not whether the enzyme could degrade spike protein produced by cells transfected with the vaccine. Overall, the two findings aresomewhat interesting. They might or might not lead to the use of nattokinase to treat or alleviate COVID-19 infection. My prediction is that they probably won’t, simply because the vast majority of cell culture results don’t translate to a treatment, but I’ll concede that the findings are somewhat interesting nonetheless.
Of course, Dr. Peter McCullough is a lot less…measured…in his reaction to the study:
Based on these findings, nattokinase and similar products such as serrapeptase should undergo well-funded, accelerated preclinical and clinical development programs. The issue at hand is the urgency of time, similar to that with SARS-CoV-2 infection and empiric early therapy. It will take up to 20 years to have a fully developed pharmaceutical profile to characterize the safety and efficacy of nattokinase in the treatment of vaccine injury and post-COVID syndromes. Large number of people are sick now and many believe empiric treatment is justified given sufficiently low risk of side effects and potentially high reward. My recommendation is to discuss this with your doctor or seek a specialist in holistic or naturopathic medicine who is experienced with the safety profile of nattokinase in a range of applications.
Notice how McCullough assumes that this will be used for “vaccine injury,” even though the intent of the researchers who published these papers was to explore whether nattokinase can inhibit the infection of human cells by SARS-CoV-2. Also notice how much he exaggerates the timeline for figuring out whether nattokinase has a clinical effect on SARs-CoV-2 infection. It doesn’t take 20 years to test a compound that already exists and already has some preclinical evidence, even if you count doing the necessary preclinical animal model studies. Far from it! Dr. McCullough is simply exaggerating how long it would take to provide strong clinical evidence for nattokinase in order to justify using it now without any such evidence.
But what about the claimed effects of nattokinase with respect to clotting? There, the evidence is rather mixed. There is, for example, some in vitro evidence for activities in vitro (test tube and cell culture) that do have relevance to clotting:
In vitro studies show that nattokinase decreases clot formation by cleaving and inactivating the plasminogen activator inhibitor (PAI) via proteolysis at P1-P1’ peptide bond. PAI is a key inhibitor of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) that converts plasminogen to plasmin. PAI inactivation allows for greater tPA activity and increased lysis of clots (10) (11). In the absence of PAI, nattokinase affects direct proteolysis of fibrin; however, this effect is less than the protelysis achieved by the PAI-mediated pathway (2). The fibrinolytic activity of nattokinase is estimated to be four-fold that of plasmin (12).
The question, of course, is whether the in vitro activities of nattokinase translate into anything therapeutic in humans. The answer is: We don’t know, but it strikes me as highly improbable. Let’s look.
Again, nattokinase is an enzyme. It should be expected to be digested when taken orally; it would not be expected to get into the bloodstream where it might actually be able to exhibit its ability to break down clots that it exhibits in a test tube. Its proponents, however, frequently cite this review article that claims otherwise. However, the way this review was written immediately got my skeptical antennae twitching with claims such as:
Nattokinase is considered to be a safe, powerful, low cost, and all-natural supplement for the treatment of heart and cardiovascular disease [5,6,7]. Animal [3,4,8] and human trials [9,10,11] have demonstrated that NK provides support to the circulatory system by thinning the blood and dissolving blood clots.
That first sentence is…something. But what about the cited articles? There are animal studies, but I zeroed in on the human studies. What impressed me about them was that none of them ever actually showed that nattokinase actually got into the bloodstream by measuring its concentration in the blood. For example, this randomized, double-blind study randomized healthy volunteers to receive a single dose of nattokinase supplement or placebo after a baseline blood draw. After the dose, blood was collected at 2, 4, 6, and 8 hours and various clotting parameters measured. The results? Basically nothing, although the authors sure tried to make it seem otherwise:
As a result, D-dimer concentrations at 6, and 8 hours, and blood fibrin/fibrinogen degradation products at 4 hours after NK administration elevated significantly (p < 0.05, respectively). Factor VIII activity declined at 4 and 6 hours (p < 0.05, respectively), blood antithrombin concentration was higher at 2 and 4 hours (p < 0.05, respectively), and the activated partial thromboplastin time prolonged significantly at 2 and 4 hours following NK administration (p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). All the changes, however, were within the normal range. In conclusion, thus, a single-dose of NK administration appears enhancing fibrinolysis and anti-coagulation via several different pathways simultaneously.
The key passage: “All the changes, however, were within the normal range.” In other words, no clear effect was demonstrated, and the authors did not actually even measure nattokinase in the blood of study subjects, which is odd, given that they went to the trouble to draw all those timed blood samples.
In fairness, there is a pharmacokinetic study in humans—a ten year old study!—suggesting that nattokinase can get into the bloodstream, but interestingly the study did not say that it detected bioactive nattokinase. Given that it used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to detect nattokinase in the blood, it is entirely possible that the antibody in the assay detected consisted of large fragments of degraded nattokinase or nattokinase that had been denatured (the protein unfolded) and was therefore inactive, leading the authors to note that “looking for intact enzyme and bioactive nattokinase peptides should be a consideration for future studies investigating the pharmacokinetic profile of nattokinase.” No kidding, as I noticed that a lot of the human studies of nattokinase (for example, this one) didn’t measure it in the blood even by ELISA. This all left me wondering whether it was actually nattokinase or something else in the concoction that might be affecting what was observed.
As you might expect, I couldn’t resist doing my own PubMed search on nattokinase to see what sorts of studies had been done more recently on nattokinase. I couldn’t help but immediately find this 2021 double-blind randomized controlled clinical trial that found zero effect of nattokinase versus placebo on the progression of atherosclerotic disease, which is one of the indications claimed for this enzyme. My entire take on nattokinase with respect to clotting and atherosclerosis is that it’s possible that maybe some intact enzyme survives digestion in the gut to be absorbed into the bloodstream to do something therapeutic, but that the evidence that it actually does anything clinically relevant in cardiovascular disease when administered orally is quite weak.
However weak the evidence is for oral nattokinase as a clot buster and drug to prevent atherosclerosis, the evidence base to support a conclusion that it does anything therapeutic whatsoever for COVID-19, long COVID, or COVID-19 “vaccine injury” is far, far weaker, as in close to nonexistent. None of this stops Dr. McCullough or others from promoting this quackery.
But what about bromelain? I think you know the answer.
Bromelain
Bromelain is an enzyme extract derived from the stems of pineapples, although it exists elsewhere in the pineapple as well. Wikipedia tells me that bromelain is commonly used in cosmetics, as a topical medication, and as a meat tenderizer, the last of which is something I always look for in a therapeutic enzyme. (That’s sarcasm. I realize that nearly all of you realize that, but I can never count on everyone realizing it.) In any event, bromelain contains proteases, which break down proteins by using water to break the bonds between the amino acids, usually at specific sites based on short peptide sequences recognized by the enzyme. It turns out that bromelain has a fairly broad specificity.
So what does Dr. McCullough claim about bromelain for “detoxing” spike protein? He starts out by referencing a review article by Varila et al, noting:
Bromelain is available in topical Nexobrid to cleanse third degree wound eschars. One vial contains 2 g of concentrate of proteolytic enzymes enriched in bromelain, corresponding to 0.09 g/g concentrate of proteolytic enzymes enriched in bromelain after mixing (or 2 g/22 g gel). The proteolytic enzymes are a mixture of enzymes from the stem of Ananas comosus (pineapple plant).
Oral bromelain has been safety tested up to 12 grams per day which is considerably higher than the typical 500 mg once a day used for Base Spike Detox. Bromelain partially degrades the Wuhan Spike protein and is a mild blood thinner. The review by Varilla points out that the PT and PTT blood tests can be prolonged with Bromelain. I have found patients taking Bromelain and Nattokinase together in Base Spike Detox need to be informed of the risks of bleeding and for them not to undergo d-dimer, PT, or PTT testing since the results will be abnormal as a result of therapy.
Again, just like activity as a meat tenderizing, I always look for something that, when used topically, breaks down burn wound eschars, which is the black burned skin overlying third degree burns and deep second degree burns that needs to be debrided (removed) before skin grafts can be applied. Oddly enough, Dr. McCullough even includes the prescribing information for Nexobrid:

This is all very interesting to me as a surgeon, but it is irrelevant to whether or not Nexobrid (and bromelain) are useful at all for treating COVID-19 or “detoxing” spike. It’s just information that looks impressive to nonphysicians.
Still, bromelain is one of the proteins that can be absorbed orally and retain its activity in the bloodstream, the evidence being more robust than the evidence for nattokinase:
Bromelain is absorbed efficiently in the human body and thus has a high bioavailability in an in vitro study [35]. This occurs as a result of its ability to bind to the two principal antiproteinases in the blood, alpha 2-macroglobulin and alpha1-antichymotrypsin. Without any significant side effects, it has been recorded that almost 12 g/day of bromelain can be taken in an in vivo study [36]. In addition, bromelain is absorbed in its active form throughout the gastrointestinal tract, with approximately 40 percent of the total bromelain absorbed in its high molecular weight form from the intestine [37]. In terms of pharmacokinetics, the maximal level of bromelain in the blood was obtained an hour after oral dosing [35]. Furthermore, [36] found that bromelain retains its plasma proteolytic function. Based on this, a more recent in vitro test showed that after 4 h, approximately 30% of bromelain remained stable in artificial stomach juice and that after the same time, roughly 20% of bromelain also remained stable in artificial blood [35].
Of course, just because bromelain can get into the bloodstream as an active enzyme does not mean that it does anything for COVID-19. This bothers Dr. McCullough not in the least, as he doesn’t even try to claim that bromelain does anything other than get into the bloodstream in active form and possibly break down clots:
We await additional post-COVID-19 and vaccine injury studies with Bromelain. It is reassuring it has bona fide proteolytic effects in the form of an approved topical therapy and its oral formulation is well absorbed and at doses of 500 mg patients are well below a threshold of concern. Since the Spike protein is known to be thrombogenic and many of the post-COVID-19 and vaccine injury syndromes are potentially related to micro- and macro-thromboses, Bromelain is well positioned as a component of Base Spike Detox.
Let me get this straight. Even Dr. McCullough admits that bromelain is unproven in COVID-19 and that there are no studies. (He can’t even cite an in vitro study showing that bromelain can actually digest spike protein in cell culture!) Out of curiosity, I did a quick PubMed search for studies examining bromelain and the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. I found three. One study suggested that antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 can cross react with bromelain (among a number of other antigens from food). I looked at the chart, and it only shows 30% crossreactivity. Make of that what you will. I don’t make very much of it. Another study found that a lectin constituent of bromelain could bind spike protein with a “low micromolar KD,” which is not particularly tight binding for a drug. (Let’s just say that I’ve worked with repurposed drugs whose concentration to achieve 50% effect is in the low micro molar range and rapidly learned the hard way that such compounds are generally not considered particularly good drug candidates because generally a lot of drug is needed and that means toxicity. The third study presents evidence that bromelain can decrease the expression (amount made) of the ACE2 receptor, which is what SARS-CoV-2 binds to via its spike protein to get into the cell. However, the concentrations of bromelain required are huge, as high as 75 µg/ml, which reminds me of ivermectin, where the amount of drug required to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 in cell culture is a couple of orders of magnitude higher than what can be achieved safely in the bloodstream.
No wonder quacks love it. In fairness, there are other papers on bromelain and COVID-19 that have been published that only come up if I search just “bromelain” and “COVID-19.” One study showed that bromelain can inactivate SARS-CoV-2, but required, again, very high concentrations of bromelain (at least 50 µg/ml). Another study is quite speculative, combining curcurmin and bromelain and suggesting that they might modulate the immune system to treat COVID-19. (Unsurprisingly, Dr. McCullough loves this study.) Then there’s an in silico modeling study suggesting that bromelain can bind to the spike protein. (Dr. Paul Alexander loves this one.) I could go on, but you get the idea. This is all very thin gruel indeed even to try to use as preliminary evidence to justify a randomized clinical trial, much less to treat anyone with in the absence of clinical trials.
Treatments targeting spike protein
In the end, everything old is new again. If you are an antivax physician, you believe that vaccines are toxic sludge pits that poison your body with “toxins” that need “detoxing.” In the age of COVID-19, the only difference is that the “toxins” being targeted by “detox” regimens are different. They’re the spike protein, primarily, even if the antivax quacks have to find a way to portray that evil “unnatural” spike protein made by the vaccines as so much worse than the “natural” spike protein from the infection that to them causes no harm other than producing “natural immunity.”
I like to say that the antivax movement is, when you boil it all down, a purity cult, and the quacks who use unproven treatments like nattokinase and bromelain to treat a disease like COVID-19 through “detoxification” are just catering to that belief.

What Is Dopamine Detox?
Just another fad that oversimplifies a complex problem to sell an easy fix.
Steven Novella on April 12, 2023
Link
The latest TikTok, Silicon Valley, wellness fad is “dopamine detox”. To me, the term is a good example of many of the things that are wrong with the wellness and self-help industries. It takes a complex topic and boils it down to a misleading and drastically oversimplified “life hack”, that can be packaged and sold. In this case it may be ironically reinforcing some of the behavior that it claims to address.
What, allegedly, is a “dopamine detox”?
The idea comes from a hyperreductionist and misleading popular notion about what dopamine is. It is supposed to be the “reward” chemical. When you do something pleasurable, you get a “hit of dopamine.” This oversimplified notion leads people to believe that dopamine itself is addictive, or that the dopamine is what is causing the pleasurable reward experience. None of this is true.
Dopamine is simply a neurotransmitter, one of the many chemicals that allow different cells in the nervous system to communicate with each other. The chemicals themselves don’t have a specific neurological function. What determines their function is the effect of binding to receptors and the circuit in which they are being released. Neurotransmitters are essentially either excitatory or inhibitory – they either increase or decrease the activity of the neuron they bind to. But the net effect of their action depends entirely on the circuit itself. An inhibitory neurotransmitter can decrease the activity of an inhibitory circuit, thereby increasing some activity.
What matters, in other words, is the neurological circuitry itself, not the neurotransmitters they use. Dopamine, for example, is used in many parts of the brain for different purposes. It is involved in the basal ganglia, which regulates voluntary movement. Dopamine producing neurons are what are damaged in Parkinson’s disease. But dopamine is also involved in many higher cognitive functions as well, which is why if patients with Parkinson’s disease take too much medication intended to increase the dopamine-mediated activity in the basal ganglia they can get psychotic side effects, and why some psychiatric medication can cause movement disorder side effects.
In other words – there is nothing inherently rewarding or pleasurable about dopamine. It just happens to be the neurotransmitter involved in the reward circuitry. And in fact, dopamine secreting cells in the reward circuitry are more involved with motivation and behavior than any pleasurable sensation. When you have sex or eat cheesecake, it’s not dopamine in the nucleus acumbens that makes these things feel pleasurable, just motivate us to engage in these activities in the first place.
The idea of detoxing from a neurotransmitter is therefore nonsensical. Of course, “detoxing” is still a trendy wellness concept, which is why this is all being framed as a detox. Sometimes it is called a “dopamine fast”, which is still trendy and problematic.
The overall idea is to avoid behaviors for a period of time that allegedly release dopamine. For either a few hours a day, or one day a week, or one week a year, you avoid any activity that might trigger a reward reaction in the brain. The claim is that this will keep your brain dopamine levels low (utter nonsense) and therefore “detox” your brain from dopamine. The slightly better, but still highly problematic, claim is that it gives your dopamine receptors a break so that they will not be as tolerant to the neurotransmitter, and therefore “reset” your addictive behaviors. This is getting a litter closer to reality, but still, in my opinion, is overly reductionist and misleading, and turns a complex situation into a simple “life hack”.
The deeper problem with this approach is that it frames a complex behavioral issue into a simple matter of brain chemistry. This is similar to the “brain training” marketing. It focuses on brain function in a simplistic way, taking attention away from the behaviors themselves and the whole person, in order to sell a quick fix.
Human behavior is a complex combination of inherent neurological traits, culture, environment, individual experience, and circumstance. I am all for understanding how our brains work as one method for having insight into our own behavior, cognitive biases, and motivations. But human behavior cannot be reduced to this. To generalize, systems need to be understood at every level of organization, not just their most fundamental parts. You cannot understand traffic patterns, for example, by studying the workings of the internal combustion engine, or the chemical reaction of burning fuel. You cannot understand human behavior by focusing on neurotransmitters.
Ultimately the “dopamine detox” is about addictive behaviors. This is a complex topic I cannot do justice to here, but suffice to say that humans have the potential to engage in behaviors compulsively. And yes, we can understand the neuroanatomical correlates of compulsive behavior, and the circuitry that underlies this behavior, but this does not explain at every level why someone may be engaging in such behavior, nor how they can change their behavior in a positive direction. Another layer here is that it is common to frame behavior addictions as if they are the exact same thing as chemical addictions. They aren’t. A chemical or physiological addiction is primarily a brain phenomenon that can be best understood at the neuroanatomical and neurochemical level. But psychological addiction (while it has neurological correlates) needs to be understood and addressed at the psychological level.
It is tempting, however, to focus at the neurological level, because then the problem is not you, the choices you make or the behaviors you engage in. The problem is your pesky brain. And if the brain is the problem, then the fix is also in the brain. The complexity here is that for many conditions, the problem is, in fact, with the brain. Sometimes these are understood as neurological disorders, but if the manifestation is primarily behavioral or mood, they may be considered psychiatric, even though they are brain function disorders. Mistakes can be made in both directions – blaming people (environment, parenting) for a brain disorder, or blaming the brain for bad choices (because dopamine).
When it comes to addictive behaviors (psychologically addictive, not chemical dependence), dopamine is irrelevant. It’s focuses on the wrong level. There is also no “one crazy trick” that will solve the problem. But it is a good idea to think about your day-to-day life and ask if there are any behaviors that you may be engaging in compulsively, or that are taking up a lot of your time with little reward or benefit. Electronic devices and social media likely fall into these categories for many people. It is helpful to recognize that people can be susceptible to compulsive behavior. For some things it may be best to stop the behavior entirely, for others to set limits or have down time. “Everything in moderation” is a good rule of thumb.
If you are having difficulty with this, then the compulsive behavior may be a manifestation of a more complex issue, or you may lack the skill sets necessary to change the behavior. This is where cognitive therapy can play a role. The questions to ask yourself are – why am I engaging in this behavior, is it having a negative impact on my life (if for no other reason than it’s a huge time suck), and do I need help in changing my behavior.
But don’t just blame it all on dopamine and think that a quick “detox” or fast is going to solve the problem. In fact, seeking out and engaging in these quick fix life hacks can be just another form of compulsive behavior.

Infrared Saunas for “Detoxification”
Sweating in saunas is not a good way to remove toxins, whether traditional or infrared.
Steven Novella on February 17, 2021
Tweet

“Detoxification” or “detox” for short has become a standard justification for all sorts of treatments that are not based on solid scientific principles or evidence. As we often refer to it – the “toxin gambit” is a marketing technique for scaring the public about the menace of unspecified toxins, then offering a treatment that will remove those vague and mysterious toxins. It is best not to reference specific amounts of specific toxins, because then they could be measured and the scam blown.
Any claim to detox, therefore, is a red flag for quackery. It is a hand-waving explanation to fill in the gaps of a lack of a plausible mechanism, along with antioxidant, or increasing oxygen (take your pick), increasing blood flow, boosts the immune system (or, alternatively, is anti-inflammatory) or at the extreme woo end of the spectrum, balancing your energy or harmonizing your vibrations.
In 2016 Jann Bellamy did a great job debunking the sauna detox claims. The idea here is that toxins come out in our sweat, so that if you sweat a lot in a hot sauna that will provide a nice deep detox. The problem with this claim is that it’s not true. More specifically, sweat releases an insignificant amount of substances that you would want removed from your body, like heavy metals, for example. If, for some reason, you had too much of these substances in your body and needed to remove them, don’t head for the sauna, head for your doctor’s office.
In fact, saunas can be counterproductive. The liver and kidneys are the primary organs evolved to remove toxins from the blood. By increasing your sweat you are actually decreasing the amount of urine produced and may in fact reduce toxin excretion. There is one potential exception to this, based on preliminary case-report level evidence – heavy metals like cadmium, lead, mercury, and arsenic. A 2011 review did find case reports of clinically relevant excretion of one or more of these heavy metals in sweat. This is not sufficient to justify sauna as a medical intervention, however. It is also not evidence for using sauna treatments to maintain health or routine “detox”.
The bottom line is that there is no evidence or rationale to think that sweating for the sake of sweating is good for you. But there are two further wrinkles I would like to explore. One is the evidence for health benefits from regularly using a sauna, independent of the sweating aspect, which I will deal with later. But first, now there are claims being made for infrared saunas.
One infrared sauna claims at the top of their website:
Sweating is good for you. Sweating is one of the body’s safest and most natural ways to heal and maintain good health. And that’s why every Sunlighten sauna is specifically designed to promote a deep, healthy and natural detoxifying sweat. Detoxification is important because it strengthens the body’s immune system and helps the body’s biochemical processes function efficiently so that we are better able to digest the nutrients in our foods.
This is all complete nonsense, but hits many of the marketing points for medical scams I listed above, throwing in that it’s “natural”. Promoters further claim that infrared detox (unlike regular saunas – I love how they throw older scams under the bus) mobilizes toxins from deep inside the tissue. The evidence for this claim: zero. The site has a single reference – to a promotional blog.
But this does get us to the broader claim – are there any health benefits (unrelated to detox) from regular use of saunas or specifically far-infrared saunas (FIRS)? Even mainstream sources will claim that there is some evidence for possible cardiovascular benefits. But let’s look at the state of the evidence, which is sparse.
A 2018 systematic review published in a CAM journal found:
Only 13 studies were randomized controlled trials and most studies were small (n < 40). Reported outcome measures were heterogeneous with most studies reporting beneficial health effects.
Small preliminary studies with heterogenous outcomes could describe any of hundreds of implausible therapies not likely to work, or that are later determined not to work by more rigorous testing. In other words, this level of evidence does not predict that a treatment will ultimately be found to work.
Most studies also do not report on side effects. While saunas are relatively safe, they are not risk-free. There are also case reports of sudden cardiac death while using a sauna, probably from dehydration. It is easy to get too overheated or dehydrated if not done properly. Everything in medicine is risk vs. benefit – you can’t just look at potential benefits and claim a treatment is worthwhile. What we are lacking with saunas, including FIRS, are the kinds of net health outcome studies that would be necessary to make a risk vs. benefit assessment.
Most of the mainstream attention is on the cardiovascular effects. Using a sauna does correlate with reduced blood pressure (in some, BP may also increase), increased heart rate, increased dermal perfusion with a reduction in organ perfusion, and increased left ventricular function and arterial flexibility. There are several problems with linking this evidence to alleged health benefits.
First – these effects are all short term, during the sauna and for 30 minutes following. We don’t know if there is any sustained change in cardiovascular function. Second, we don’t know that these changes are improvements. This relates to the third issue, it is possible that at least most of these changes may simply be due to dehydration. Reduced blood volume from water loss (similar to a diuretic effect) will reduce the blood pressure and increase the heart rate, relaxing blood vessels to increase perfusion. So perhaps all we are seeing is a transient effect of the dehydration that accompanies using a sauna.
What we need are longer-term studies and studies that follow net clinical outcomes. There is observational data, but this is highly problematic because it cannot be controlled.
At this point we can conclude that there is a thin rationale and little evidence to support sweating as a mechanism for detox. It is far better to allow the kidneys and liver to do their job. Saunas, both regular dry saunas and FIRS, result in short term changes to cardiovascular function, but there is no convincing evidence this is sustained or beneficial. In this latter case, more and better research is needed. Specific health claims are not justified, but if you choose to use a sauna for relaxation or because it feels good, remember to keep well-hydrated and keep the time limited.

NCCIH funds sauna “detoxification” study at naturopathic school
Jann Bellamy on September 15, 2016
Link

It is no secret that we at SBM are not particularly fond of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine (NCCIH; formerly, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine). We’ve lamented NCCIH’s use of limited public funds for researching implausible treatments, the unwarranted luster NIH/NCCIH funding bestows on quack institutions, the lack of useful research it has produced, and its failure to shoot straight with the public when discussing alternative/ complementary/ integrative medicine. Nor does NCCIH’s research appear to affect CAM practice. Lack of evidence of safety or effectiveness is no impediment to use among CAM practitioners or “integrative” physicians.
So I shouldn’t have been surprised (NCCIH’s promise to “do some real science for a change” notwithstanding) when, a few days ago, I ran across a study of which I was previously unaware (for good reason, as you’ll see) on clinicaltrials.gov:
Sauna Detoxification Study: Pilot Feasibility
The goal of this study is to assess the feasibility of the approach, conduct a dose-finding investigation, and obtain pilot data on hyperthermia via sauna to apply in follow-up trials in the assessment of human chemical body burden reduction, for general wellness, detoxification, and pain reduction.
The investigators wish to determine if a hyperthermia-based detoxification protocol is feasible to conduct: including assessment of recruitment, enrollment, retention, protocol adherence, adverse events, and changes in serum polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs).
And:
Complementary and Alternative Medicine Sauna Detoxification Study: Phase I
The purpose of this study is to determine the impact of sauna use on polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) in the blood of healthy human adults, as well as to assess safety, feasibility, and tolerability, and effects on quality of life and wellness. We hope to determine if there is a link between lower PCB levels in blood and sauna use.
The studies were conducted at Bastyr University, which awards degrees in pseudoscientific fields of study like naturopathy, TCM, and ayurvedic medicine, and funded by NCCIH to the tune of $736,938 between 2011 and 2013, under an award titled “Complementary and Alternative Medicine Detoxification: Safety and Efficacy.”
And the rationale for this?
According to our nationwide survey of Naturopathic Physicians regarding use of detoxification, approximately 80 percent of NDs (Naturopathic Doctors) use some type of detoxification interventions in clinical practice on a regular basis. Of the interventions used, 66% of respondents reported using sauna therapy. Of the conditions treated, over 80 percent of practitioners use sauna-based detoxification for “general cleansing/preventive medicine.” This protocol will utilize a sauna as the primary method of detoxification. . . . Previous studies on hyperthermia-based protocols for detoxification have been methodologically challenged and are not readily reproducible. Furthermore, there are no studies in the literature that identify how long of a protocol is tolerated, is feasible in the general population, or how long is needed to observe PCB (or other pollutant reduction).
So, the survey confirms what we’ve long known: Naturopaths are nuts for detoxification, despite the lack of evidence that it is of any benefit whatsoever to patients. They love to scare the willies out of patients by claiming our enviornments are full of disease-causing “toxins,” which must be eliminated posthaste via saunas, supplements, and other concoctions, colonics and restrictive diets. Otherwise, as one naturopath advised,
If you don’t detoxify, you’ll blow up!
This survey of naturopathic detoxification practices was published in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine and also funded by NCCIH. The lead author is the principle investigator, Bastyr naturopath Jason Allen. He and the other authors, one of whom is naturopath Wendy Weber, an NCCIH employee and recently the subject of a post by David Gorski, try to put a positive spin on the fact that the survey showed widespread use of detoxification despite the lack of evidence of benefit:
The wide variety in responses regarding age, patient populations/conditions, and therapies may reflect the philosophy of “comprehensive, multidisciplinary, and individualized interventions,” typical of the naturopathic profession.
The only problem being, of course, that these “comprehensive, multidisciplinary, and individualized interventions” are a hodgepodge of quackery, detoxification being one of the interventions the authors admit has no basis in evidence.
The authors note that environmental chemicals can have deleterious health effects, which is true. Yet, having just established that there is no evidence supporting the various “detoxification” treatments as an effective therapy and that naturopaths nevertheless use them willy-nilly for all sorts of things, the authors make a gigantic leap to the conclusion that:
Detoxification therapies used by NDs may serve as an adequate means to reduce the body burden of synthetic chemicals found today in humans; however, scientifically rigorous research is needed to determine the safety and efficacy of these therapies.
They don’t come close to suggesting any plausible means by which “detoxification therapies used by NDs” could possibly “reduce the body burden of synthetic chemicals” sufficient support a trial of sauna “detoxification.” But that is the beauty of NCCIH-sponsored research: if CAM practitioners are doing it, we must spend money studying it, to heck with all those pesky interim requirements other scientists have to jump through, like animal studies, scientific plausibility and such.
Sweating it out, or not
I did find one article on Bastyr’s website explaining the basis for Allen’s belief that a few turns in the sauna would get rid of “toxins:”
While subjects may literally sweat out small amounts of chemicals, the heat treatment’s chief benefit will most likely come from lipolysis — breaking down fat, where toxic substances are stored. That would allow them to move through the bloodstream to the kidneys and liver, which are the primary organs of excretion . . .
That sweating won’t really accomplish anything useful, though, and it can be detrimental.
Dr. Dee Anna Glaser, a professor of dermatology at St. Louis University and founding member of the International Hyperhidrosis Society, a medical group dedicated to the study and treatment of heavy sweating, says sweat does contain trace amounts of toxins. But, she says, sweating has only one function – cooling you down when you are overheated.
Sweating for the sake of sweating has no benefit . . . Sweating heavily is not going to release a lot of toxins.
Dr. Glaser points out that heavy sweating can actually impair your body’s natural detoxification system. We count on the liver and kidneys — not the sweat glands — to filter toxins from our blood. If you don’t drink enough water to compensate for a good sweat, dehydration could stress the kidneys and keep them from doing their job. So, “if you’re not careful, heavy sweating can be a bad thing.”
Sweating definitely won’t help clear the body of mercury or other metals, according to Donald Smith, a professor of environmental toxicology at UC Santa Cruz, who studies treatments for metal poisoning. Almost all toxic metals in the body are excreted through urine or feces, he says. And less than 1% are lost through sweat. In other words, according to Smith, you’ll do far more detoxifying in the bathroom than you ever could in a sauna.
Here’s what Smith said about one sauna company’s claim that “sweat carries toxins out of the body and pushes [them] out of the pores, . . washes away pesticides and industrial chemicals but is especially effective in removing heavy metals such as lead, mercury and arsenic.”
Baloney.
But will a sit in the sauna break down fat and cause toxins to exit the body? If that’s a viable theory, it is apparently not well known in the field:
Roger Clemens [is the] director of an analytical laboratory at the University of Southern California that evaluates environmental toxins in the food supply. Clemens remarked that the most efficient system for detoxification is not an infrared sauna but rather the kidneys, liver, gastrointestinal tract and immune system. ‘Except when one of the major organs breaks down, there isn’t a medical device or any diet that can accelerate the body’s natural process of detoxification,’ he says.
I couldn’t find anything supporting what Allen says on PubMed, but just to be sure, I ran it by my own panel of experts. Dr. Hall assures me that this doesn’t make any sense and Dr. Crislip finds that it is indeed “nonsense.” Dr. Jones notes that if the sauna’s heat is high enough to break down fat, it’s going to cook your skin also. That’s good enough for me.
But, despite these substantial flaws, what if the study showed an association between using saunas and a reduction in PCBs in the blood? Would that be worthwhile information? Not really. While PCBs are known to be harmful and their manufacture has been banned, blood testing for PCBs isn’t likely to yield useful health information. And because most of us have a measurable level of PCBs in our bodies, trial participants will be alarmed for no good reason when their tests prove positive.
Tests are available to measure the levels of PCBs in the blood and breast milk. Because PCBs are common in the environment, most people will show some level. The problem, though, is that there are no reference values that define a “normal” level of exposure to PCBs. Thus, your physician will not be able to tell you the meaning of a PCB level in your blood or breast milk beyond the fact that it is present. A test that shows PCBs in your blood will not explain how long the exposure lasted or if there will be health effects from the exposure.
In other words, based on our current state of knowledge, we don’t know that reducing PCBs in the body will produce beneficial health effects, so there is no known value in reducing their level. Nor does testing predict treatment. If that is the case, what’s the point of studying whether saunas are associated with reduced level of PCBs?
If saunas don’t work, it’s not for lack of trying. Allen described his protocol thusly in one newspaper article on the study:
What I’m proposing is a little more aggressive protocol, it’s like spring cleaning . . .
Boy, he wasn’t kidding either. In the pilot feasibility study, “low dose” participants got 1 hour of sauna a day, 3 days a week, for 3 weeks, or 9 sessions. The “high dose” participants got a whopping 30 hours of sauna over the 3-week period, coming in for 2 hours of sauna 5 days a week. (From the description provided, it is not clear to me how many hours of sauna participants in the Phase I trial endured, only that their visits to the Bastyr clinic lasted 3.5 hours.)
And the results are?
We don’t know. No results are posted for the pilot study. The Phase I trial, which was to have been completed in April, 2014, was terminated for reasons that are not explained. I can find no published results on PubMed and no study results on the Bastyr or the NCCIH website. Bastyr, contrary to clinicaltrials.gov, says the study is “completed;” NCCIH doesn’t mention the study at all. In fact, the NCCIH’s page on “‘Detoxes’ and ‘Cleanses'” doesn’t even mention sauna detoxification.
So, history repeats itself and the NCCIH has apparently blown almost three-quarters of a million dollars on a questionable study of “detoxification” conducted at an institution that teaches its students rank quackery like homeopathy, promotes anti-vaccination ideology, and misrepresents naturopathy education and training to the public. To add insult to injury, Bastyr uses this NCCIH funding in PR to promote itself, giving it undeserved legitimacy and the false appearance of scientific rigor. Yet, it will continue to teach “detoxification” to its naturopathic students despite its admitted lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness and practicing naturopaths will continue to “detox” their patients, all to the benefit of their bottom lines.
And one more thing
While we are on the subject of naturopaths and NCCIH, it is interesting to note that the NCCIH website has completely sanitized its description of naturopathy, a development I wrote about last year on SfSBM and worth repeating here. NCCAM’s description of naturopathy used to be refreshingly frank, with statements like:
Although some of the individual therapies used in naturopathy have been studied for efficacy and safety, naturopathy as a general approach to health care has not been widely researched.
‘Natural’ does not necessarily mean ‘safe.’ Some therapies used in naturopathy, such as herbal supplements and restrictive or unconventional diets, have the potential to be harmful if not used under the direction of a well-trained practitioner.
Some beliefs and approaches of naturopathic practitioners are not consistent with conventional medicine, and their safety may not be supported by scientific evidence. For example, some practitioners may not recommend childhood vaccinations. The benefits of vaccination in preventing illness and death have been repeatedly proven and greatly outweigh the risks.
Naturopathy is not a complete substitute for conventional care. Relying exclusively on naturopathic treatments and avoiding conventional medical care may be harmful or, in some circumstances (for example, a severe injury or an infection), have serious health consequences.
Even though none of these warnings has proven false, all of them are gone.
The public now learns only about the education and training of naturopathic “physicians” at 4-year “medical schools” and the fact that they have “continuing education requirements.” As well, “some U.S. states and territories have licensing requirements for naturopathic physicians; others don’t.” The public doesn’t learn the fact that they are licensed or registered in only a handful of states. And, if they’re not (and NCCIH doesn’t tell you this either) naturopathic “physicians” better not be calling themselves “physicians” or trying to pretend they can practice as “physicians,” as that would be illegal. To be fair, some of this information was in the former information page on naturopathy, but it was tempered by appropriate warnings.
The public is now told that “people visit naturopathic practitioners for various health-related purposes, including primary care, overall well-being, and treatment of illnesses.” Of course, to the average member of the public, unaware of the total nonsense that comprises a good portion of naturopathic practice, this probably implies that seeing a naturopath for “primary care” or “treatment of illnesses” is perfectly sensible. And the NCCIH isn’t going to discourage anyone from thinking otherwise.
The naturopathy page does link to the study showing an association between lower vaccination rates and children seeing a CAM practitioner, and the association between use of naturopathy and significantly more vaccine-preventable disease diagnoses. It also says, however, that we don’t know if these associations are simply because parents who are anti-vaccination seek out CAM practitioners, or whether they are actually getting anti-vaccine advice. That is true, but studies confirm the anti-vaccination ideology of naturopaths, and that should be clearly stated. It is a fact. This is particularly disappointing in light of the NCCIH director, Dr. Josephine Briggs, agreeing with David Gorski, Steve Novella and Kimball Atwood that anti-vaccination ideology in CAM providers should not be tolerated.
At the time I wrote the SfSBM post, in October of last year, if you dug around you could still find the original information on naturopathy in the form of a pdf. Now, that link doesn’t work and I can’t find the pdf anywhere on the website. Consequently, the benign impression of naturopathy presented by NCCIH goes unchallenged.
Back when he was posting on SBM, Kimball Atwood opined that
For a number of reasons, well-argued many times here on SBM, it would be beneficial to American citizens if the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) were abolished.
Six years later, NCCIH is carrying on the tradition of annoying SBM posters to the point of their calling for its closure. Count me among them.


You’ve done a detox. Now what?
What is the best thing to do after you’ve completed a detox or cleanse?
Scott Gavura on January 23, 2020
Link

It’s mid-January and some of you are finishing up your New Year’s detox or cleanse. Congratulations. Taking steps to a healthier lifestyle isn’t always easy. It probably wasn’t pleasant. It may have cost you some money. And you may have lost some weight.You’re now wondering what should come next – how to be healthier in 2020, and how to recover from some of the lingering effects of the detox. While there are hundreds, perhaps thousands of “detox” regimens, products, and approaches, most of them have similar components and have similar effects. Understanding what they are, and what they do may help you with your choices in 2020. 
What is a detox, exactly?
Your detox plan may have come from a website, or even a box. It may be celebrity endorsed or it could be the classic “Master Cleanse” of lemon, cayenne, and maple syrup. Pharmacies and health food stores have aisles of “detox kits” all promising to suck the toxins out of your body. The approaches may differ but there is one constant to the marketing: Detoxing will deliver a renewed body and better health. But you’ll never find a description of what the detox actually detoxes – what’s being removed? And that’s because deliberately vague marketing is used, to imply health benefits that don’t exist. And it starts with the term “detox”.
“Detox” is a legitimate medical term that has been co-opted to promote products that don’t actually remove toxins. Real detoxification isn’t ordered from a menu at a juice bar, or assembled from supplies in your pantry. Real detoxification is provided in hospitals under life-threatening circumstances — usually when there are dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or other poisons in the body. Drugs used for real detoxification are not ingredients in a smoothie. What’s being promoted commercially as “detox” is little different than eons-old religious rituals of cleansing and purification. Framing detoxification in religious terms won’t have the appeal in a world where science is king. So use the word “toxin”, not sin, and call the ritual a “detox” – and suddenly the program has a veneer of what sounds scientific. Fake detox is marketed based on three easily-debunked ideas. Once you can spot the flaws, it’s easy to spot the spin and misinformation, and to make smarter, healthier decisions.
But toxins!
There’s a reason we can be sucked in by the marketing of detoxification — we seem hardwired to believe we need it, perhaps related to our susceptibility to ideas of sympathetic magic. Purification rituals date back to the earliest reaches of recorded history. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves and we need to atone for our sins seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why it’s still a part of most of the world’s religions. It’s not miasmas or sin that we’re as worried about today, however. As our knowledge of biology grew, these fears manifested as “autointoxication“, to be treated with colonics and purgatives. Clean out the bowels, went the theory, and you could cure any illness. Science discarded autointoxication by the 1900s as we gained a better understanding of anatomy, physiology, and the true cause of disease. Yet the term persists today – but now it’s marketing slogan. Today’s version of autointoxication argues that our environment is increasingly toxic, and it’s making us ill. Man-made chemicals are absolutely in our environment, so the reasoning goes that it must be making use sick. Depending on who you ask, some combination of food additives, salt, meat, fluoride, prescription drugs, smog, vaccine ingredients, GMOs, not “eating clean”, or perhaps not “eating paleo” are causing a buildup of “toxins” in the body. So what is the actual “toxin” that is causing you vague but apparently real harm? Detox kits and treatments never name the toxins that they remove, because they’ve never been shown to remove toxins.
But my colon!
The colon remains ground zero for detox advocates. Advertisements may argue that some sort of toxic sludge (sometimes called a mucoid plaque) is accumulating in the colon, making it a breeding ground for parasites, Candida (yeast) and other nastiness. Fortunately, science tells us otherwise: mucoid plaques and toxic sludge simply do not exist. It’s a made-up idea to sell detoxification treatments. Ask any gastroenterologist (who look inside colons for a living) if they’ve ever seen one. There isn’t a single case of mucoid plaque that’s been documented in the medical literature. Not one. The same can be said for rope worms. They do not exist.
Will detoxing improve my organs?
Marketing materials for detox treatments typically describe an array of symptoms and diseases linked to toxin buildup: A few that are general enough to apply to anyone (e.g., headache, fatigue, insomnia, hunger) with a few specifics to frighten you (e.g. cancer) Which toxins cause which disease is left out, and how the toxins cause the symptoms is never actually explained. Here again we see the contrast with real science. To establish that even a single chemical can cause disease requires a significant amount of research. Despite the variety of toxins that are claimed to be causing your illness, marketing claims for detox treatments always fail to link specific toxins to specific symptoms or illnesses. That’s because they can’t — there is no scientific evidence to show that detox treatments have any useful medical effects.
If you’ve completed a detox, you may feel very different from when you started. You could be dehydrated. You may have disrupted the normal bacterial in your colon. Your body could be in a fasted state due to a lack of calories – it all depends on the approach taken. But no detox plan or kit will have any meaningful effects on your organs, or your ability to remove toxic substances from your body.
The reality is that our bodies are constantly being exposed to a huge variety of natural and synthetic chemicals. Air is chemicals. Food is chemicals. Drugs are chemicals. Herbs are chemicals. The presence of any chemical in the body, (natural or synthetic) does not mean that it is doing harm. Many naturally-derived substances can be exceptionally toxic, and consequently the human body has evolved a remarkable system of defenses and mechanisms to defend against, and remove unwanted substances. The skin, kidneys, lymphatic system, gastrointestinal system, and most importantly, the liver make up our astoundingly complex and sophisticated intrinsic detoxification system.
Advocates for detox typically describe the liver and kidney as acting like filters, where toxins are physically captured and retained. It’s argued that these organs need to be cleaned out periodically, like you’d squeeze out a sponge, or change the air filter in your car. But the kidney and liver don’t work this way. The liver performs a series of chemical reactions to convert toxic substances into ones that can be eliminated in bile or urine. The liver is self-cleansing — toxins don’t accumulate in it, and unless you have documented liver disease, it generally functions without any problem. The kidney excretes waste products into the urine — otherwise the substance stays in the blood. Anyone that suggests these organs need a “cleanse” is demonstrating that they don’t understand basic anatomy or physiology.
Is there any evidence to support detoxing?
A 2014 review of detox diets in the Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics provides a good summary of the evidence supporting detox diets:
To the best of our knowledge, no rigorous clinical investigations of detox diets have been conducted. The handful of studies that have been published suffer from significant methodological limitations including small sample sizes, sampling bias, lack of control groups, reliance on self-report and qualitative rather than quantitative measurements.
The authors could find only a single detox product has been evaluated in the literature. Ultra Clear is a supplement that is claimed to detoxify the liver. The “evaluation” of Ultra Clear, was not blinded, and lacked any controls. The research subjects were 25 naturopathy students. Perhaps not surprisingly, the students reported improvements on a number of measures – but without a properly designed trial, the results don’t provide any evidence that the product is effective.
In general, there was no credible evidence to demonstrate that detox kits do anything at all. While they can be very unpleasant, they have not been shown to remove “toxins” or offer any health benefits. Coffee enemas are commonly promoted as toxin-removers. Coffee enemas offer no medical benefits. Vitamin injections are a popular naturopathic offering that has not been shown to provide meaningful benefits to consumers, as it has no beneficial effect on the ability of your liver or kidneys to work effectively. Chelation injections are touted as a cure-all for all kinds of illnesses, but unlike real chelation that is administered in hospitals for real cases of poisoning, “naturopathic” chelation is not science-based and doesn’t seem to do much of anything (except enrich its proponents).
There is just as little evidence for detox programs. One I have found evaluated is via L. Ron Hubbard and the Church of Scientology, called the Hubbard Purification Rundown. It involves niacin supplements, saunas, exercise, polyunsaturated oil consumption, and vitamins, minerals, and electrolytes. The protocol was used on a small group of firefighters after 9/11. With small sample sizes and no control groups, any critical evaluation of the results is impossible. Another evaluation with firefighters was equally limited by a lack of proper randomization and blinding. The same protocol was also used in healthy volunteers. Owing to a lack of blinding and placebo, the results are not credible, which is probably why the paper ended up published in Medical Hypotheses.
Have I harmed myself with a detox?
If you’re reading this post-detox, probably not. When it comes to simple dietary changes, there’s little evidence of harm. A detox can be a dietary reset – so take advantage of that. Eating a healthier diet and less processed and refined foods is reasonable dietary advice for everyone. (But avoid quinoa – no level of purported health benefits is worth quinoa.) Homeopathic “detox” is also likely safe — with no active ingredients, homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system. As you get into more unorthodox detox treatments that actually contain active ingredients, there is the potential for harm. Coffee enemas are a detoxification process that has a real risk of harm. From a medical perspective, coffee enemas are considered unsafe. Rare but serious adverse events like septicemia (bacteria in the bloodstream), rectal perforation, and electrolyte abnormalities have been caused by coffee enemas. Deaths from the administration of coffee enemas have also been reported. Take your coffee by mouth – not any other orifice.
Vitamin injections won’t provide you with any medical benefits but don’t seem as risky, as long as you trust the sterile technique of your provider. However, given some naturopaths seem to be willing to inject products intended for oral use, you might want to think carefully about taking a vitamin injection or chelation treatment, especially when there’s no evidence they do anything meaningful. Glutathione injections, while often touted as a “hangover cure” (among other uses) actually has very little published safety information available to support its use.
Laxatives are the ingredients in detox kits that give you the effect you can see (and feel). However, these ingredients can cause dehydration and electrolyte imbalances if not used carefully. Regular use of stimulant laxatives, like senna and cascara, are not recommended for most healthy adults due to the risk of dependence and electrolyte depletion. They’re among the most potent laxatives, usually used for short periods to alleviate significant constipation or to clear out your bowels before a medical procedure. With regular use, your bowel can grow accustomed to the effects of laxatives which may result in constipation once you stop using them. It’s a perfect case of the treatment causing the illness: After the detox, you get could conceivably become constipated – just in time for another “detox”.
Side effects can continue once a detox ends. Some people experience post-detox effects like nausea and diarrhea. Advocate call these “cleansing reactions” and will assure you it’s “toxins leaving the body”. A more plausible, science-based explanation is that this is a consequence of restarting the digestive process after a period of catharsis, where, depending on the extent and duration of fasting, little to no digestion occurred, and the normal gastrointestinal colonies of bacteria may have been severely disrupted. It’s the same effect seen in hospitalized patients who have difficulty initially digesting food after being fed intravenously. The detox ingredients, and resulting catharsis, may irritate the colon to such an extent that it may take time for digestion to return to normal.
Immediate weight loss is not uncommon after a detox, especially one that involves a laxative. Unfortunately this is usually due to losses in water and possibly muscle tissue, depending on the how disruptive the detox was to normal body function. Regardless of the weight loss, the body will move back to its pre-detox weight over time if diet and activity levels go back to pre-detox levels.
There are no quick fixes
Any product or service advertised with the words “detox” or “cleanse” in the name is only truly effective at cleansing your savings – of cash. Alternative medicine’s ideas of detoxification and cleansing have no basis in reality. There’s no published evidence to suggest that detox treatments, kits, or rituals have any effect on our body’s ability to eliminate waste products effectively. They do have the ability to harm however – not only direct effects, like coffee enemas and purgatives, but they also distract and confuse people about how the body actually works and what we need to do to keep it healthy. “Detox” focuses attention on irrelevant issues, giving the impression that you can undo lifestyle decisions with quick fixes. Improved health isn’t found in a box of herbs, a bottle of homeopathy, or a bag of coffee flushed into your rectum. The lifestyle implications of a poor diet, lack of exercise, smoking, lack of sleep, and alcohol or drug use cannot simply be flushed or purged away. If you’ve detoxed, take advantage of this opportunity to understand what’s happened and how to prevent yourself from ever detoxing again. And in the future, if anyone suggests a detox or cleanse to you, remember that you’re hearing a marketing pitch for an imaginary condition.

   Near Death Experience

   Near Death Experiences and the Medical Literature
Mark Crislip
Link
MIRACLE MAX: See, there’s a big difference between mostly dead, and all dead. Now, mostly dead: he’s slightly alive. All dead, well, with all dead, there’s usually only one thing that you can do.
INIGO: What’s that?
MIRACLE MAX: Go through his clothes and look for loose change.
— The Princess Bride
Can you trust anyone when they purport to tell you what the medical literature says? No. As an example we will use the issue of near death experiences, or NDE’s.
We will avoid the obvious paradox in this entry, sort of the ‘everything I say is a lie paradox’ that will cause computers in the Federation to shut down.
Why am I going to comment on this issue? Well, this months Skeptic has a back and forth between Michael Shermer and Deepak Chopra about life after death.
No. I am not going to comment on whether there is life after death. I am more interested in life during life, thank you very much. I’ll let the afterlife take care of itself.
But in their point counterpoint, they both refer to a Lancet article about NDE’s and it then begs the question:
Does anyone actually read or understand the literature they quote ?
This is a small point, but I went and read, really read, the December 1 Lancet, “Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands.” You can read it too, if you want to follow along at home.
I read the article with the bias of a practicing physician who spends all his time in an acute care hospital and has been involved with many cardiac arrests over the years. I haven’t caused them, by the way, I have just helped out with their care in one way or the other.
Both sides in this article say the patients were dead, or nearly dead. Or close enough for an organ harvest. Read the paper. I don’t think so.
In the article they “defined clinical death as a period of unconsciousness caused by insufficient blood supply to the brain because of inadequate blood circulation, breathing, or both. If, in this situation, CPR is not started within 5–10 min, irreparable damage is done to the brain and the patient will die.”
Every patient in this study had CPR; most within 10 minutes of their arrest. Everyone had blood delivered to their brain. That is the point of CPR: to provide sufficient blood to the brain and other organs.
It is, as an aside, why the conclusion of the study in the discussion is flawed “If purely physiological factors resulting from cerebral anoxia caused NDE, most of our patients should have had this experience.” Good CPR does not lead to cerebral anoxia Most patients in this study did not have an NDE because they had CPR, so they had blood and oxygen delivered to the brain so they could not have an anoxia mediated NDE.
So the real question is whether patients who had brain anoxia had an NDE, and there is no way to determine that in this paper. CPR by its self is not a good surrogate for cerebral anoxia.
Having a cardiac arrest and being promptly coded does not mean there is insufficient blood and oxygen being supplied to the brain.
CPR has variable efficacy, depending on the both the patient and the experience of the provider. Most of us who have had to be involved with a code know, for example, the horrible sensation of all the ribs cracking when you start CPR on a frail old lady and knowing that the CPR is probably not going to be effective.
AS a result of variable CPR, the time it takes the brain to become anoxic is variable. And you would be surprised at how little oxygen people can tolerate with no discernible dysfunction in their cognition, although you might not want them flying your 747. People come into the hospital all the time with with the amount of oxygen in their blood decreased by 30,40, 50% and can walk and talk.
The point is that during a resuscitated cardiac arrest the ability of the brain to get oxygen can be quite variable and if the CPR is done effectively, the brain gets enough oxygen that it is not damaged.
By the definitions of the paper, nobody experienced clinical death. No doctor would ever declare a patient in the middle of a code 99 dead, much less brain dead.
Picky picky, I know, but having your heart stop for 2 to 10 minutes and being promptly resuscitated doesn’t make you “clinically dead”. It only means your heart isn’t beating and you may not be consciousness. Although the discussion states they were”clinically dead”, it takes a lot more than a short course of no heart beat to be dead in this this day and age. But it sure sounds impressive. So when Dr. Shermer quotes the article as saying the patients were “clinically dead”, they weren’t. They were cardiac arrest patients who all received prompt resuscitation. They were “clinically dead” only if nothing was done to them, which is probably not going to pass the hospital ethics committee.
And that brings up the question as to when you are dead. Dying is a continuum. If your heart doesn’t beat for 15 minutes, you are a goner.
10 minutes? not so much.
5? you will be OK.
1 minute? 30 patients in the study had a deliberate cardiac arrest in the cath lab that lasted less than one minute. Were they dead?
Point is that declaring someone dead if their heart isn’t beating is not so simple and in this study you were dead if you had no pulse and were unconscious. Not a good definition. But good for making a splash.
Was Superman really dead when he was beaten to death by Doomsday? No. He met the criteria of the paper, but he came back.
How about Westley when he was cast into the pit of despair and hooked up to The Machine? Dead? I think not.
That’s the issue, they say the patients were DEAD. But they look at “Near Death” experiences. Were they mostly dead? Completely dead?
All these people had change in their pockets when they left the hospital; they were not dead.
The only case I know where someone was truly dead and mouldering in their grave and came back with a good description of a NDE, or in this case a DE, was Buffy Summers.
But I digress.
The other way you can declare people dead is brain dead, again, not so easy to do. There are many criteria for brain death:
The patient has to have no clinical evidence of brain function by physical examination, including no response to pain and a variety of nerve reflexes that do not work: cranial nerve, pupillary response (fixed pupils), oculocephalic reflex, corneal reflex, and no spontaneous respirations.
They have to be off all drugs that mimic brain death for several days and they cannot have metabolic conditions that mimic death. It is important to distinguish between brain death and states that mimic brain death and most of the patients received either a benzo (valium like drugs) and/or a narcotic.
It’s nice to have flat line EEG’s as well, usually two at least 24 hours apart.
And the patient has to drive 45 in the left lane of the freeway with the left turn signal on. That example is not really considered brain dead. But it should be. There are a lot of people I think I should be able to declare brain dead. But I digress. Again.
Being declared brain dead is a time consuming and detailed procedure, as it should be. This will become important in a moment.
Dr. Shermer at least quotes the paper that the patients were ‘clinically dead” using the papers own flawed definitions. But as we have seen their definition of being clinically dead is an artifice used for the paper but of no clinical or physiological relevance. Dr. Chopra, as best I can tell, just makes stuff up. He states, and the emphasis is his “when there was no measurable activity in the brain, when they were in fact brain dead.”
Nowhere, and I mean nowhere, in the Lancet article do they mention whether, besides being unconscious, neurologic function was assessed and the clinical diagnosis of brain dead was determined.
Brain dead, as we saw, is a condition not made at the time of an arrest but a diagnosis that takes time and the patient has to meet multiple criteria before being declared brain dead. They were unconscious for a short period of time after a cardiac arrest, and that is not the same as no measurable brain activity or being brain dead.
None, that’s none, zero zilch, nada, zippo, empty set, of these patients in this study were brain dead. If they had been brain dead they would have been organ donors then buried, not interviewed. They were unconscious for mostly short periods of time, a state that, if the same as being brain dead, means many college students are dead Saturday nights.
In the discussion of the paper the authors state ”Also, in cardiac arrest the EEG usually becomes flat in most cases within about 10 s from onset of syncope’
They reference an annals of internal medicine article as well as one in the journal Anesthesiology where they put EEG monitors on patients in who were having defibrilators implanted. One of the side effects of having a defibrilator placed is that your heart is often stopped for a period of time or you have a heart rhythm induced called ventricular tachycardia, that is usually fatal but can, to a small degree, perfuse the brain.
That quote is not true. I pulled the articles and read them.
What they showed was slowing, attenuation and other changes, but only a minority of patients had a flat line and it took longer than 10 seconds.
The curious thing was that even a little blood flow in some patients was enough to keep EEG’s normal
To quote the annals “Electroencephalographic changes were variable. Background slowing was usually followed by relative loss of electrocerebral activity. ”
Big difference between that and saying everyone flat lines in 10 seconds.
How long does it take to flat line? If there is zero perfusion, the best I can figure out in talking with the experts around my hospital is more like 20 seconds. That’s with NO perfusion. And the EEG experts tell me that the sensitivity of an EEG for function is more like a one megapixel camera than a 5 megapixel. The brain probably doesn’t start to die until several minutes goes by. In my state an EEG is considered so insensitive it does not have to be included as part of the criteria for determining if someone is brain dead, although we get it anyway, a flat line EEG is only part of the mix.
So there is flat line EEG that occurs acutely when the brain is not getting oxygen and there is the flat line that occurs when the brain is dead and an EEG cannot distinguish between them, only the person at the bedside can do that.
So the quote “in cardiac arrest the EEG usually becomes flat in most cases within about 10 s from onset of syncope” by the authors of the Lancet article is not supported by the literature they reference.
So that brings up several options. 1) They cannot read. 2) They can read, but they cannot understand. 3) They can read and understand but they can’t write a coherent sentence or 4) They are deliberately making stuff up to bolster their position knowing that few will look up their references.
In medicine and in the medical literature, either you have integrity all the time in everything or everything you do is suspect. That one lie, I mean line, in the article, being so counter to the substance of the articles referenced, means to my mind that the whole article is suspect. You judge a man by the company he keeps.
Dr. Chopra’s analysis that they were flat line and brain dead suffers from the same problems as the authors of the Lancet article. It simply isn’t supported by the particulars of the literature he quotes. So in my mind, Dr. Chopra’s writing has the same options: 1) He can’t read, or doesn’t read, the literature he quotes. 2) He can read, but he cannot understand what he read. 3) He can read and understand but he can’t write a coherent sentence or 4) He are deliberately making stuff up to bolster his position.
I have not read the rest of Dr. Chopra’s oeuvre, so I do not have the information at hand to be able to distinguish which of the above options represents his modus operandi.
Both authors quoted the article correctly as to number of NDE. It depended on how an NDE was defined, hence saying 12% (Shermer) or 18% (Chopra) of patients had an NDE is correct. It depends on how many criteria you include as part of your NDE as an NDE is defined two different ways in the paper,
Also, if you read the discussion, you will find that the authors suspect a selection bias in their study and offer a ‘real’ rate of 10% for NDE, or only 5% of patients if based on the number of resuscitations, as more CPR’s lead to more NDE’s. They also admit in the discussion that their broad definition of NDE’s makes their percentage higher as it is more inclusive. It’s all in how you define NDE.
Dr. Shermer has the intellectual honesty to at least delineate which criteria he used from the study for his percentage. Dr Chopra doesn’t bother to explain why there are two different percentages of NDE in the study, choosing to present the alternative percentage as if Dr. Shermer were misquoting, rather than selectively quoting, the study.
“(The actual figure was 18%, by the way).” I love the snarky way this is said.
On his website Dr. Chopra puts MD after his name, and based on his reading and analysis of the paper, I am suspicious that the MD represents an homage to Maryland. Perhaps he has an affiliation with U of M. Go terrapins. Or has an affinity for Baltimore. I am hence forth to be known as Mark Crislip, OR as I like Oregon so much. But if MD means medical doctor, then he should know better.
If I had a medical student on service do such a sloppy analysis of a paper and make up the conclusions, they would be hard pressed to pass their rotation.
It is doubly ironic as Dr. Chopra refers to Dr. Shermer as having “slipshod reasoning” and ‘misrepresents and distorts… Rupert Sheldrake” and saying “skepticism is only credible when it is not being devious.” Holy Pots, kettles and blackness, Batman.
The only thing this article can say is who in this study population had an NDE and what constituted an NDE.
Nothing can be said as to what causes an NDE, except with the caveat that to quote from the accompanying commentary.
“The investigators report that, at the 2-year follow-up, four of 37 patients contacted to act as controls (i.e., people who had not initially reported an NDE) reported that they had had one. Although these patients represent fewer than 1% of the total sample, they represent over 10% of the 37 patients interviewed with a view to acting as controls. If this subsample is at all representative, it implies that around 30 patients from the sample of 282 who initially denied an NDE would, if they had survived for another 2 years, be claiming that they had had one. ”
Some of the NDE’s were, it seems, implanted memories.
The discussion also greatly exaggerates the conclusions that can be drawn from their data.
“We did not show that psychological, neurophysiological, or physiological factors caused these experiences after cardiac arrest.”
Of course not, as set up the study could not have any reliable data as to causation of NDE’s.
Followed by:
“NDE pushes at the limits of medical ideas about the range of human consciousness and the mind-brain relation.”
I do not see this conclusion from the data in this article. Upon close reading I think the only thing this paper is qualified to determine is a description of who get NDE’s and what patients report. As to etiology of NDE’s, much less mind brain relation, it can say nothing. Their reach exceeds their grasp.
I am not saying NDE don’t happen, and I am certainly not going to disagree with the idea that nearly dying is transformative. It is. It is probably why real NDE have greater effects than lab induced NDE. The knowledge that you are really truly mortal is life altering. Cancer survivors can have the same epiphany with out the cardiac arrest
The devil is in the details. As is so often the case, when you go back and read the original paper and its references, what the paper says and what the paper is purported to say often turn out to be two very different things.
In the end the point counterpoint on the NDE’s was, to my mind, done between two people who may not have really understand the literature, one honestly, the other maybe not so much.
Take home message:
Read the original literature. Remember that what a paper says and what people say it says are not the same thing.
Trust no one. But me. References follow. Now you can read them yourself. Let me know if I got it wrong.
References
December 1 Lancet, Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands.
Skeptic. Vol 13, #4. The Great Afterlife Debate. Page 52 – 57.
Electrocerebral accompaniments of syncope associated with malignant ventricular
arrhythmia’s. Ann Intern Med. 1988 Jun;108(6):791-6. PubMed ID: 3369769.
Electroencephalographic changes during brief cardiac arrest in humans. Anesthesiology1990;73:821–25. PubMed ID: 2240671.

   NDE Update
Mark Crislip
Link
Back in 2008 I wrote on Near Death Experiences (NDE’s). I have an interest in this topic as I have frequent exposure to near death; my wife has a predilection for watching Judge Judy. Since 2008 there have been a few studies on the topic of NDEs as researchers try and find evidence that consciousness transcends the brain, if that is what a NDE represents. I have also been ill for most of the last week and have not had the usual time to spend generating typos to drive some readers to distraction. Fortunately, I have a miracle cure that is 100% effective in resolving all my self-limited illnesses: time. It passed and with it the illness. As a result I am about 10 days behind in the commitments in my life, so this will be a shorter than usual post.
As will come as no surprise to anyone who reads this blog regularly, I am of the opinion that NDEs are almost certainly physiologic in origin. I see no reason why consciousness should exist beyond physiologic brain function. I am not sympathetic to the whole mind-brain dichotomy and see no reason why the mind is not the result of brain function. No one ever speaks of the lung-gas exchange dichotomy or the kidney-urine production dichotomy. But that is my bias, and I mention it at the beginning of the post in the interest of openness.
There is an enormous popular literature on NDEs, but little in the way of science, probably, I would guess, is that it is difficult to prospectively find subjects upon which to do studies.
There are people, however, who are going to die and it is nice to allow them to go gentle into that good night. I appreciate the efforts of palliative care specialists, as while I have never particularly worried about being dead, the process of getting there has never seemed particularly inviting. Part of ensuring that patients are comfortable is to monitor their cerebral function to make sure the remain unaware. This technique was developed by anesthesiologists who did not want their patients to become conscious during surgery yet have no ability to communicate that they were now aware that their appendix was being removed.
Dying patients had their brain function monitored to make sure they remained unconscious as they died. If you decide to remove a patient from the ventilator as an example, you do not want them to be aware.
As the brain dies, there appears to be a last, short, burst of a of electrical activity.
…loss of blood pressure, as monitored by indwelling arterial line, was followed by a decline is BIS/PSI activity followed by a transient spike in BIS/PSI activity that approached levels normally associated with consciousness. This spike in electroencephalogram (EEG) activity had short duration and the activity then declined to a level of activity associated with burst suppression.
A last gasp of activity before the void. What is happening? What does this burst represent? Is the world being observed one last time? Does the patient see themselves from afar? Are they going to the light? Are memories reviewed or being formed? No one knows. Everyone died and are unable to report what they thought or experienced with the burst of activity. But one could speculate. And one does
We speculate that this level of BIS/SEDline activity is related to the cellular loss of membrane polarization due to hypoxemia. We further speculate that since this increase in electrical activity occurred when there wash no blood pressure, patients who suffer “near death” experiences may be recalling the aggregate memory of the synaptic activity associated with this terminal but potentially reversible hypoxemia.
So perhaps the NDE is the last flurry of electrical activity by the brain and, if the patient were brought back from the grave, they would recall this activity as a NDE. Or not. Like most of what occurs in the minds of the dying, it is lost to death.
NDEs can be induced by drugs. Ketamine, an anesthetic drug, can also cause a reaction similar to an NDE. Ketamine can cause visual distortions and a lost sense of time, sense, and identity. Ketamine works as a NMDA receptor antagonist, similar to the action the more familiar drugs dextromethorphan, phencyclidine (PCP), and nitrous oxide. All these drugs can cause a dissociative state. I remember when I had nitrous oxide for my wisdom teeth extractions, I became convinced that I was not in the dental chair, but was somehow outside looking in on the oral surgery. To ‘prove’ I was in the chair, I kept lifting my hands up and waving them, to the distraction of the oral surgeon. I had a similar reaction to indomethacin, a sense that I was in the corner of the room looking down at me. It is most odd.
Ketamine can cause NDEs.
We aimed here at assessing, in a sample of ketamine misusers, concordance between the typical near-death experience (NDE) features and the on-drug psychoactive effects the subjects experienced. In 2003-2005, a sample of previous ketamine misusers recollecting a ketamine-related NDE were recruited through snowballing and screened with the means of the Greyson NDE Scale; 125 participants made an initial contact with the researcher and 50 reported a minimum score of seven at the “Greyson NDE Scale”. Interviewees were in the range 21-66 years old; 27 participants (54%) were educated at BA level, 18 (36%) had an MSc, and 5 (10%) a PhD. Eight (16%) interviewees had a definite religious background. An average lifetime ketamine intake of 140 occasions was reported by the interviewees, who typically presented with a polydrug, including cannabis and MDMA/ecstasy, misuse history. In 45 (90%) cases, the NDE occurred during the first few occasions of intake. Most frequent features of reported NDE states included: altered perception of time (90%), strong sense of detaching from own physical body (88%), and a sense of peace/joy (76% of subjects). Although results here described were elicited from a self-selected, nonrandomized, limited size sample of misusers, we suggest that recreational ketamine intake may be associated with occurrence of near-death related states.
Of course, just because James Randi can bend a spoon using prestidigitation doesn’t mean that Uri Geller isn’t bending spoons with his mind. Similarly, just because NDEs can be mimicked in ketamine abusers, er, I mean misusers, doesn’t mean that ‘real’ NDEs are not the consciousness going towards the hereafter. But I am an Occam kind of guy; why should entities be multiplied beyond what is necessary?
Numerous physiologic parameters go awry as you die and all your body functions fail. Many tightly controlled parameters become progressively deranged: pH, C02, sodium, etc. Could these derangement’s have something to do with the physiology of NDEs?
In a recent study they evaluated 52 patients who survived an out of hospital cardiac arrest, of whom 11, or 21% had an NDE. As a group, the NDEs had both higher CO2 levels and lower O2 levels in the blood. They also found increased potassium in those with NDEs.
They note prior studies that demonstrate that low levels of oxygen can result in NDEs, perhaps by way of the NMDA receptor as well. Low oxygen and high CO2 may be a plausible physiologic partial explanation for NDEs. Whether some brains are predisposed to NDEs (since some patients had more than one, poor guys, nearly dying more than once) or there are other factors has yet to be elucidated.
The high potassium? In the discussion they comment,
“Alternative theories found the explanation for NDEs in quantum theory, which suggests that consciousness may arise from quantum processes within neuronal microtubules. The recent work of Bernroider and Roy suggests that quantum entanglement in the ion channels (especially in the potassium channel) of brain cells underlies information processing in the brain and, ultimately, also consciousness. Although untenable and purely theoretic, this possible connection between potassium channels in the brain and the mechanism of consciousness (and therefore the possible mechanism of NDEs) deserves further investigation.”
Once you invoke quantum mechanics for any process macroscopic process in medicine (except, perhaps, MRIs), you lose credibility. Exactly why an untenable explanation deserves further investigation is not explained.
Potentially psychologic factors were not associated with NDEs in this study. “Sex, level of education, fear of death, time until ROSC, and religious belief” were not associated with an NDE, lending credence to that idea that NDEs are a physiologic response rather than spiritual response, although I suspect the authors lean towards the spiritual side.
“Clearly, the presence of NDEs pushes the current knowledge of human consciousness and mind-brain relation to the edge of our understanding.”
To my mechanistic, reductionist way of thinking, NDEs are the last gasp of activity of a dying brain. Like a cramp in an ischemic leg, it does not push the muscle-contraction relation to the edge of out understanding.
Again, association is not causation, but there is an interesting rat study that suggests that both low pH and increase C02 combine to inhibit NMDA receptors, just like ketamine.
BACKGROUND: Carbon dioxide (CO2) dose-dependently decreases minimum alveolar concentration (MAC) of anaesthetics in rats. CO2 also dose-dependently decreases cerebrospinal fluid pH. N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) channels exhibit pH sensitivity and are putative targets for inhaled anaesthetics. We hypothesized that CO2 dose-dependently decreases rat NMDA channel current via an acidifying effect at concentrations relevant to CO2 MAC.
METHODS: To test this hypothesis, we studied rat NR1/NR2A glutamate receptors expressed in voltage-clamped Xenopus oocytes. To measure pH effects, we used perfusates adjusted between 7.3 and 5.3 with HCl. To measure CO2 effects, we used equimolar sodium perfusates containing either 0 or 24 mM NaHCO3 and CO2 between 0% and 87% atm. Solution compositions were measured using a blood gas analyser with values corrected using a calibrated pH meter and gas chromatograph with solutions at 37 degrees C.
RESULTS: We found that decreasing pH decreased NMDA current. Moreover, pH effects produced by adding CO2 to NaHCO3-containing perfusates were identical to those produced by adding HCl to normal perfusates. The pH inhibiting 50% of NMDA current was 6.52. The CO2 concentration inhibiting 50% of rat NMDA current was 63% for solutions with 24 mM NaHCO3. CO2 exhibited a linear dose-dependent NMDA response analogous to that observed for in vivo CO2 anaesthetic potency in rats.
CONCLUSIONS: CO2 and hydrogen ions act via the same mechanism to inhibit NMDA receptors. Moreover, CO2 inhibits rat NMDA receptors in a manner that is consistent with CO2 MAC-sparing effects in rats.”
NDEs will unlikely be an area of research that will ever lead to definitive conclusions. Dead men tell no tales and those that survive are unlikely to volunteer their brains for further evaluation, and most patients to survive a cardiac arrest are in no condition to be used in acute clinical studies.
NDEs appear to be reproducible by medications and are probably the response of the dying brain to an inhospitable metabolic milieu. However, like Houdini, when I die, if I can come back, I will come back and tell you about my dying. In the meantime, if I see the light, I’m not going towards it, no matter how inviting.

   My Woo. A Confession
Mark Crislip
Link
It’s a case of mind over matter. I have no mind but it doesn’t seem to matter.
— George Burns
I should be working on my taxes. Instead, I’ll dwell on the other, more pleasant, inevitability.
Its been a bad couple of months for death. Everyone dies, and people often die of infection, but the flu season has been busy and with the MRSA lurking in the community, I have seen too many young die who should have otherwise survived their influenza.
I spend most of my professional day working in an acute care hospital, and most people in the hospital die of something. They die when their heart or lungs or liver or brain or some combination sustain more damage than can be compensated for. People live within fairly narrow operational parameters and when those parameters are exceeded for any length of time, they die. It is never a surprise when people die due to organ failure past the point of return or support. That is the cause of death in most of the patients I see.
Sometimes, and not very often, people die of nothing in particular. They just die. You get an autopsy, and there does not appear to be any single event that caused the death, nor does the sum of the underlying diseases seem to have lead to death. Usually it is the advanced elderly who just die. There reaches a point where the organism shuts down. I once had a patient die as I walked into the room on rounds. He looked at me and then died. He had many medical problems, but none that should have killed him, and his blood work on the day of death was normal and his autopsy had no clue as to why he died. Creepy. I like to have a definitive cause of death, but I do not always get one.
Then there are the people who appear to choose when they die. Not active suicide. There appears to be a small number of people who make a conscious decision that their time is up and then they die. It is apparently a rare phenomena. Phenomenon. One of the two. When it does happen, though, it makes quite an impression. Death is always an impressive event, when the patient seems to consciously choose the time they die, it is all the more impressive.
Those who choose to die come in two types. There is the old person, usually the male, who has been married for 60 years who loses their spouse. Shortly after the spouse dies, they die. As best as can be determined, they give up and die of nothing. Or perhaps a broken heart. Or, depending on the marriage, an excess of joy.
The other is the cancer patient or other terminal disease who has a personal goal: a wedding or a birth or a reconciliation or some other idiosyncratic reason to postpone death. These patients are few, but do seem to hang on until they reach a goal, then they die.
If you ask doctors who deal with terminal patients, they uniformly agree that this phenomena exists (personal communication). I certainly have had enough of these type of experiences that I have always considered it a fact, based entirely on personal experience, that occasionally people choose when they die. They were rare events, as most people who die do so under circumstances totally beyond their control.
I never saw the point in ‘mind-body’ medicine and the power of mind over matter. Such practices always seemed to put Descartes before the horse. The mind is the result of the function of the brain, just like the blood pressure is the result of the pumping of the heart. No one ever talks about some mystical heart-blood pressure relationship. The components of ‘mind-body’ medicine, such as “relaxation, hypnosis, visual imagery, meditation, biofeedback, cognitive-behavioral therapies, group support, autogenic training, and spirituality (1) “ do not alter disease course in an objective way.
Clinically I never saw any benefit in thinking good thoughts and having a good attitude when it came to disease progression. Happy or sad, upbeat or a downer, disease marched along to its own drummer. A good attitude may help a patient tolerate their illness, but alter disease course? Never. I read Norman Cousins and was unimpressed, as much as I love the Marx brothers. While I expect disagreements from this post, Duck Soup is the funniest movie ever made. End of story.
I never really thought about the apparent conflict that choosing ones time of death was an apparent example of of ‘mind-body’ interaction and my dismissal of the whole concept. They existed in different sections of my mind and I never thought about the contradiction. After all, the hallmark of an educated mind is the ability to hold two diametrically opposing and conflicting ideas simultaneously. By this definition, I know quite a few highly educated people.
Usually when I read the skeptic literature there is a lot of agreeing with what I read. If there was ever a member of the choir, it is me. I’m the one in the castrati section. “Yeah, I know that. Yeah. I agree. Interesting. Makes sense with my world view.” Lots of nodding ‘yes’ as I read.
Then I saw a reference to a paper that suggested that patients could not delay death. For the first time ever when reading a skeptical article I thought, wait. That’s not true. That completely goes against all my experience. No way. It is jarring to read information that goes completely against your deeply held beliefs, especially when it occurs in a source that is trusted. It’s kind of like finding a support for homeopathy in Nature. Such things cannot be. It violates the perceived natural order of the universe. When presented with information that violates your world view, you can a) ignore it, or b) read the original source. One thing you learn in medicine is what people say an article says and what it really says are often two different things.
So I found the original reference (2).
What they did in this study was look at birth certificates of 309,221 persons dying with cancer and to see if their deaths occurred near Thanksgiving, Christmas or their birthdays. There was no correlation with dying and those dates. If there had been, there would have been a spike in deaths after those days. The presumption is that Thanksgiving, Christmas and birthdays are worth living a little longer for, and if you are dying of cancer, you would put off your death to reach those special days.
I have terminal cancer, but let me live just long enough to experience one last drunken, dysfunctional family get together. Seems reasonable to me.
They did find that for “black individuals there was an increase in cancer deaths in the week before Thanksgiving (P = .01), whereas women showed an increase in cancer deaths in the week before their birthday (P = .05).”
Yawn. This is the “Mars Effect” for deaths. An unimportant data spike.
Large epidemiologic studies are not going to answer the question: can people choose when they die. Partly because the event is rare, but more importantly because what causes people to put off death is more personal and idiosyncratic than Christmas or a birthday.
The authors realized this:
personally salient events such as weddings, anniversaries, and graduations could present greater emotional impact for the individual with cancer and thus have a greater effect on the timing of death. Unfortunately, no practical means exist to ascertain the impact of these events in large population-based registries for the hundreds of thousands of persons dying of cancer. We are additionally unable to determine from our database the proportion of individuals who were comatose before death and therefore were incapable of knowing the approach of a holiday.
It is a small point, but are people postponing their death or are they waiting for an event and deciding to die? The first suggests they are overcoming, by will power, a physiology that should have killed them. The latter suggests that there may a process whereby patients choose when they die. These are not the same thing.
So is there any biologic plausibility that has me hanging on to this little bit of woo?
Of course.
It is a frequent question from patients: the role of stress in their illness. I usually give some answer to the effect that stress is bad, but it is hard to quantify the effects on an individual: stress can increase disease risk, but I can’t really say that it is a specific stress that causes a specific illness. Unless, of course, the stress kills you.
Can you die of a broken heart? Or be scared to death?
Maybe.
In the NEJM from 2005 (3), they looked at
19 patients with “stress cardiomyopathy,” a syndrome of profound myocardial stunning precipitated by acute emotional stress, in an effort to identify the clinical features that distinguish this syndrome from acute myocardial infarction and the cause of transient stress induced myocardial dysfunction.
These patients had heart failure, often severe, from stress. What was the stress? Family deaths, bad news, arguments, even a surprise party or two.
The cardiac effects? arrhythmias, heart failure, a small bump in their cardiac enzymes (which occurs in a heart attack).
The cardiac evaluation? a markedly decreased cardiac pump function and normal coronary arteries. No anatomical reason found for the heart failure.
The putative reason for the cardiac dysfunction? markedly elevated catecholamines (epinephrine, norepinephrine, dopamine, metanephrine and normetanephrine) as well as other vasoactive substances: 2 to 3 times the level of heart attack patients and 7 to 34 times the levels in normal people.
What does that mean?
It means that stress can cause a massive bolus of a potentially fatal vasoactive chemicals; what is popularly called an adrenalin rush. These high levels of chemicals are potentially directly toxic to the heart, although the exact mechanism of the damage is speculative. I would venture to guess that an older heart would be more susceptible to the ill effects of such a surge.
There is biologic plausibility to suspect that people can die from the stress of a broken heart or be scared to death.
How is this related to choosing when to die?
Imagine you have a terminal disease. Many people intellectually know they are going to die, but perhaps they haven’t had that emotional understanding of their mortality yet.
They decide they want to wait for a wedding, a birth, or a reconciliation. The event occurs. They realize that they have nothing to live for and have that “holy moly, I am really going to die” moment. It hits home that, to quote P. Pig, “that’s all folks.” That intense realization leads to a catecholamine surge and it kills them.
They ‘chose’ the time of their death.
If that is the mechanism of choosing the time of death, then it would be be testable in that one could measure catecholamine levels at the time of death in these patients, although it would be a logistically awkward study to perform.
Intellectually, I know that I am suffering from an enormous confirmation bias from witnessing extremely emotional events. I am remembering hits and have no way of knowing how many misses there were. I know there is no good data to support the contention that people can occasionally chose their time of death. I have too many personal experiences, as do my colleagues, to disbelieve. I am, heaven forbid, choosing an irrational belief based on anecdotes over science, although in my defense I do not find the studies compelling that suggest that people cannot choose their time of death are flawed. I have biologic plausibility on my side.
I am not yet dissuaded of my underlying belief, or to elevate it, I’ll call it my clinical observation, that rarely people can decide when to die.
That’s my woo and I am sticking to it.
References
What Is Complementary and Alternative Medicine?, http://nccam.nih.gov/health/backgrounds/mindbody.htm
Holidays, Birthdays, and Postponement of Cancer Death. JAMA. 2004;292:3012-3016. PMID 15613670
Neurohumoral Features of Myocardial Stunning Due to Sudden Emotional Stress. N Engl J Med 2005;352:539-48.

TACT

Of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy, Bayes, the NIH, and Human Studies Ethics
Kimball Atwood on May 30, 2014
Link
An experiment is ethical or not at its inception; it does not become ethical post hoc—ends do not justify means.~ Henry K. Beecher
A couple of weeks ago, Dr. Josephine Briggs, the Director of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), posted a short essay on the NCCAM Research Blog touting the results of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) (italics added):
The authors found that those receiving the active treatment clearly fared better than those receiving placebo. The accompanying editorial in the AHJ reminds readers about the value of equipoise and the need to “test our beliefs against evidence.”
Most physicians did not expect benefit from chelation treatment for cardiovascular disease. I readily admit, initially, I also did not expect we would find evidence that these treatments reduce heart attack, strokes, or death. So, the evidence of benefit coming from analyses of the TACT trial has been a surprise to many of us. The subgroup analyses are suggesting sizable benefit for diabetic patients—and also, importantly, no benefit for the non-diabetic patient. Clearly subgroup analyses, even if prespecified, do not give us the final answer. But it is also clear that more research is needed to test these important findings.
And TACT findings are indeed a reminder of the importance of retaining equipoise [sic], seeking further research aimed at replicating the findings, and neither accepting nor rejecting findings based on personal biases. The scientific process is designed to weed out our preconceived notions and replace them with evidence.
Dr. Briggs concluded:
So, TACT is a reminder—an open mind is at the center of the scientific method.
Dr. Briggs’s title was “Bayes’ Rule and Being Ready To Change Our Minds”, a reference to a recent editorial that had accompanied one of the TACT papers. That editorial, by Dr. Sanjay Kaul, a physician and statistician from UCLA, begins with this quotation:
Preconceived notions are the locks on the door to wisdom.~ Merry Browne
Here is the relevant passage from Dr. Kaul’s editorial (italics added):
Sixth, it has been argued that the trial was unethical because there was no compelling clinical or preclinical evidence that chelation therapy has significant efficacy against atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, and given that chelation therapy can cause harm, the risk was not minimal. A Bayesian analysis would not look kindly on the results because of the low prior probability of treatment effect (the so-called implausibility argument).6 This is an uncharitable (and unwarranted) interpretation of the data because previous systematic reviews concluded, “insufficient evidence to decide on the effectiveness or ineffectiveness of chelation therapy in improving clinical outcomes among people with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease.” It is axiomatic that absence of evidence of efficacy is not the same as evidence of the absence of efficacy.
From a Bayesian perspective, the strength of evidence is often summarized using a Bayes factor, which is a measure of how well 2 competing hypotheses (the null and the alternate) predict the data. The Bayes factor and the corresponding strength of evidence for the primary end point result in TACT overall, and diabetic cohorts are shown in Table 1. The p-value of 0.035 for TACT overall cohort translates into a Bayes factor of 0.108, which means the evidence supports the null hypothesis ≈1/9th as strongly as it does the alternative. This reduces the null probability from 50% pretrial (justified by suspension of one’s belief in treatment effect) to 10% post-trial. Although this does not represent strong evidence against the null, it does reduce the level of skepticism surrounding chelation therapy. In the diabetic cohort, the nominal p-value of 0.0002 translates into a Bayes factor of 0.002 (1/500), which reduces the extremely skeptical prior null probability of 95% to 4% post- trial, indicating very strong evidence against the null.
In concluding, Dr. Kaul states:
Finally, TACT highlights the double standard when it comes to accepting inconvenient results not aligned with our preconceived notions on so-called dubious quack cures such as chelation…
Closed minds?
Dr. Kaul’s reference “6” above is to a lengthy article that we published in 2008 titled “Why the NIH Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy Should Be Abandoned”. So, it seems, both Drs. Briggs and Kaul were chastising us for our biased, preconceived beliefs about so-called dubious quack cures. Our minds were, apparently, not open. Let’s examine this contention. 
Here is the relevant passage from our 2008 article (references in the original, italics added now):
The Likely OutcomeEven if the TACT is completed, which it should not be, it is unlikely to reduce the promotion of reckless uses of Na2EDTA. Whatever the outcome, chelationists have already positioned themselves to continue the practice: By virtue of ridding the body of toxic heavy metals, they claim, chelation is useful for more than 70 conditions. Without exception, chelationists have refused to accept previous results that contradict their beliefs. Their response to the TACT, should it yield definitive, negative results, is unlikely to be different.
The trial, moreover, is unlikely to yield “an informative negative result” even though chelation is almost certainly ineffective for CAD (coronary artery disease). It is more likely to yield ambiguous results. There are multiple endpoints, including subjective quality-of-life measures, and several subgroup analyses. The variety of trial settings increases the likelihood of heterogeneity of procedures and reporting. Promotions of chelation by TACT co-investigators have already introduced unacceptable bias into the trial. There is ample, additional opportunity for mischief, and ample reason to think that several co-investigators are inclined to make it. The statistical analyses will not be Bayesian.
Thus, merely on the basis of chance and bias, it is likely that some outcome data in some subgroups will differ sufficiently, between those receiving Na2EDTA and those receiving placebo, to reassure chelationists that chelation “works” and to sustain “lingering questions of efficacy” in the minds of apologists. Dr. Lamas himself has made much of 2 or 3 “tantalizing positive secondary outcomes” of a previous trial in which only 15 subjects received Na2EDTA, and in which the remaining 30 secondary outcomes and all 7 primary outcomes were unequivocally negative. The all-but-inevitable “tantalizing positive secondary outcomes” of the TACT would likely lead to years of additional, unnecessary trials or, at the very least, unremitting peddling of chelation by practitioners armed with fresh fodder in their perpetual battle against rational standards of care.
Preconceived? Or perhaps just prescient? Dr. Kaul correctly cites our paper as having “argued that the [TACT] was unethical (etc.).” He then opines that our argument was “uncharitable and unwarranted,” because systematic reviews (published after the TACT grant had been approved!) concluded that there was insufficient evidence either for or against chelation for atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease.
Clinical equipoise?
He misses the point, and also missed the pre-existing evidence of the absence of efficacy. The point was made by the TACT investigators themselves, in their pitch for the grant. While acknowledging that every RCT of Na2EDTA for atherosclerotic disease had failed to show an effect, they argued:
The very large number of published case reports and case series support a hypothesis that EDTA chelation therapy provides clinical benefits in atherosclerotic vascular disease.
A very small number of trials of very small sample size have randomized 275 patients in aggregate, a number far too small to reliably detect or exclude the most plausible benefits.
Thus the case for clinical equipoise was not based on previous trials having been too small to exclude a small effect, but on “thousands” of confirming case reports and case series contradicting the disconfirming data from those clinical trials.
Even this, however, was wrong. In our paper we reviewed the purportedly confirming case reports and case series (ours is the only such review that we are aware of), and showed that they were neither credible nor accurately represented by the TACT protocol (the most charitable interpretation is that its authors had never read those case reports). That left only the RCT data and a couple of credible but disconfirming case series, which, even if inadequate to exclude a small effect, were more than adequate to exclude the huge effect claimed by chelationists, including those involved with the TACT—which, after all, was the only reason the trial was being done. They were also more than adequate to exclude, in the absence of favorable phase I and II trials, a $30 million, phase III trial, particularly according to the NCCAM’s own language. These and other considerations also argued strongly against a state of clinical equipoise, as we discussed at some length.
Both Drs. Briggs and Kaul seem innocent of the meaning of clinical equipoise. Dr. Briggs, in particular, appears to believe that “retaining equipoise” is akin to “maintaining an open mind” or “withholding judgment” and, furthermore, that there is value or virtue in doing so. Such are not the case. The long-accepted understanding is as follows:
According to this concept of “clinical equipoise,” the requirement is satisfied if there is genuine uncertainty within the expert medical community—not necessarily on the part of the individual investigator—about the preferred treatment.
Thus one cannot simply choose to “retain equipoise” or “suspend one’s (dis)belief in the treatment effect” in order to be less “uncharitable” than the alternative. Clinical equipoise—necessary to render a clinical trial of an unproven treatment ethical—either does or doesn’t exist for a particular treatment, even if the expert medical community is not unanimous in its opinion, and even if it isn’t always possible to know what that opinion is. In the case of EDTA chelation for CAD, the expert medical community was overwhelmingly skeptical, as we documented (that a small effect of EDTA had not been utterly disproved—what Dr. Kaul calls “the uncertainty associated with the possible benefit of chelation therapy”—is beside the point).
Henry Beecher understood, even if Drs. Briggs and Kaul do not, that this fact cannot be changed retroactively.
Bayes and human studies ethics
Regarding Bayes, our implication that the prior probability of a favorable treatment effect for Na2EDTA ought to be very low was based on a warranted interpretation of the existing data, which were entirely disconfirming, and on theoretical considerations discussed in our paper. It was also based on a lack of trust in the judgments of the only practitioners who believed that chelation works: those practitioners also peddle homeopathy, laetrile, Nambudripad’s Allergy Elimination Technique, and myriad other pseudoscientific nonsense, and have a rich history of corrupt, even criminal, behavior (many of them were also TACT investigators).
All of this is meticulously documented and referenced in our paper. We suggest that of all those who have published papers in the medical literature about the TACT, we are the only ones sufficiently open-minded and unbiased to have comprehensively reviewed the prior evidence and the history of the trial—and that includes the TACT investigators themselves.
We don’t see how Dr. Kaul can justify a “suspension of one’s belief in treatment effect” and thus arrive at a prior probability of 0.5 (or even 0.05). Systematic reviews notwithstanding, there were substantial prior trial data, even discounting our other reasons for judging the treatment implausible. If pushed to do so, we would have chosen a prior considerably less than 0.01. Na2EDTA still has a very low probability of being therapeutic for CAD, even if our opinion is now slightly less skeptical (for diabetics only), as Bayes Theorem dictates.
Laetrile and internal mammary artery ligation
Regarding NIH policy and human studies ethics, the existing evidence against chelation for atherosclerotic disease, as we explained in our paper, was considerably stronger than the evidence against many once-popular claims—we cited laetrile for cancer and internal mammary artery ligation for coronary disease—that no responsible scientist or ethicist would now consider subjecting to human trials. Drs. Kaul and Briggs might consider that if their post hoc reasoning about the TACT were to become the norm at the NIH, numerous dubious claims would be fair game for large human trials, each awaiting only the political arm-twisting that was the real impetus for a chelation trial. Then again, that’s why Congress created the NCCAM. Silly me.
Ironically, the TACT also violated the NCCAM’s own, stated intention to “to elucidate mechanisms of action and conduct small, well-developed phase I and II trials” prior to phase III trials. In 2002, prior to the enrollment of TACT subjects, that plan included “studies of the biology of EDTA chelation therapy in animal models,” which, although dubious, would have been more in accordance not only with sound science and public policy but with accepted ethical preconditions for a large human trial. Those studies, apparently, never happened.
The small effect that the TACT authors have now reported, limited to diabetics, may or may not be real, as Drs. Kaul and Briggs (sort of) acknowledge. Here’s hoping that the NIH doesn’t waste more public money pursuing it, unless some legitimate scientific clue suggests doing so, perhaps stemming from the sort of work described in the previous paragraph.
TACT: the real winners
Dr. Kaul is reassured because he thinks, based on formal reports, that “the presumption that the TACT trial [sic] provides actionable evidence for clinical practice is not endorsed even by the TACT investigators…” Alas, he and most academics have little idea whom they’re dealing with. Here is TACT investigator L. Terry Chappell on his own website (italics added):
The Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) showed statistically significant benefits for patients with heart disease…This is the first major randomized clinical trial on chelation for vascular disease, and it is a positive study…
I cannot wait to share with our patients and friends what TACT and previous studies mean to current medical science and to those who could benefit from them…
Our experience is that chelation can reduce your chances for blindness, kidney failure, amputation and other vascular complications of diabetes. I believe that ALL diabetics should take chelation, starting about age 30…
I believe that chelation is the most powerful prevention intervention that we have. Everyone should take it to improve his or her chances for living a disease-free life. Scientific evidence is accumulating to back me up…
You do not have to be a doctor, nurse or paramedic to save lives. Just share the vital information contained in this message with others. Bring them to our clinic. Or ask them to set up a free phone consultation with me (Dr. Chappell) to discuss whether we can be of help. See to it that they know what they should know so that they can save their lives too!
Chelation is not just a treatment that is slowly emerging into the spotlight. It is a movement against the forces that are resisting change, especially from powerful economic interests…
TACT is the breakthrough study we needed. More studies will follow, but that will take years…but we want to help people now. Join the movement. Spread the word.
Isn’t it clear what has happened here? It was Dr. Chappell who—as President of the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), a group of several hundred chelationists—made the original pitch to congressman Dan Burton, who subsequently bullied NHLBI Director Claude Lenfant into accepting a chelation trial. Chappell was also a member, contrary to the NIH conflict of interest policy, of the scientific review committee that approved Dr. Lamas’s application—the same application that had named the ACAM the “the world’s largest and most respected organization of physicians who employ chelation therapy” and Dr. Chappell a “prominent expert.”
Chelationists seem to have got exactly what they’d hoped for from the TACT: a free pass to peddle their favorite, lucrative ‘remedy’—which they tout not only for CAD but for COPD, dementia, schizophrenia, skin wrinkles, and 70 other disparate indications—without being inconvenienced by pesky regulators. If a double standard is highlighted here, it’s a double standard of care, unwittingly encouraged by naive medical academics and a cowardly NIH.
There are numerous additional reasons that the TACT was unethical, including an almost universal lack of informed consent and incompetent medical care given by practitioner/investigators. These will be further explained in future postings.

   The TACT is at least as Bad as We Predicted.
Kimball Atwood
Link
I had wanted to follow Dr. Sampson’s discussion of “Healing Touch” with one of my own, because I had an interesting experience with one of its proponents years ago, and I’ll do that soon. I had also wanted to begin a series of posts about acupuncture, which I’ll also do eventually. Just yesterday, however, Liz Woeckner, co-author of our recently published critique of the NIH Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT), made a startling discovery: the TACT “Portal” website, intended for investigators and others associated with the trial and previously password protected, is now available to anyone: http://www.chelationwatch.org/s/tact/index.html It is a goldmine of information and I’ve barely begun to look at it, but so far it verifies much of what we’ve written and more. For example, the latest version of the Consent Form is dated 2006 and includes this statement under “risks”:
EDTA, or ethylenediamine tetraacetate is in the chelation solution. It is approved for use by the FDA as a treatment for lead poisoning but not for coronary artery disease.
Yet three Investigator Brochures, dating back to 2003, contain this language:
Edetate disodium USP should not be confused with its calcium salt (calcium edetate), which is used to treat lead toxicity.
We had called attention, in our article, to TACT literature repeatedly conflating NaEDTA and the safer CaEDTA. Now we have reason to believe that this has been done cynically, with eyes wide open.
Another example: the TACT newsletter of Mar ’04 is the “Special Advertising Edition.” On p. 3 is a “TACT spotlight interview with [Site Investigator] Dr. Sangeeta Shah.” The interviewer’s second question is: “Aside from the television interview, how did you advertise for this trial? What venues did you contact?” Part of her answer is:
Also, do not forget about advertising the trial on websites that a physician may have already have established. I have done this on my own website and if people are interested, they can visit the page at the following address: (here)
If you go to that link and click on “Chelation Therapy,” you’ll find much of the exact language that the FTC had compelled the ACAM (American College for Advancement in Medicine: the most conspicuous chelation advocacy organization) in 1998 to stop using in its advertisements for chelation:
WHAT IS CHELATION THERAPY?
Chelation Therapy is a safe, effective and relatively inexpensive treatment to restore blood flow in victims of Atherosclerosis without surgery. Patients with blockages and poor circulation in their hearts, extremities and other parts of their bodies often find relief without surgical intervention and heavy medication. Chelation Therapy involves the intravenous infusion of a prescription medicine called ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid (EDTA).
WHAT IS CHELATION THERAPY USED FOR?
Chelation Therapy is used to reverse symptoms of hardening of the arteries and blockages, also known as Atherosclerosis or Atherosclerosis. Atherosclerosis is caused by multiple complex factors, including abnormal accumulations of metallic elements. The end result is plaque formation within arteries, which blocks the flow of blood. Hardening of the arteries is caused by excess calcium building up in the walls of the arteries. Plaques are composed of fibrous tissue, cholesterol and calcium. Atherosclerosis leads to heart attack, stroke, and senility and may lead to amputation of extremities. Every single study of the use of Chelation Therapy for Atherosclerosis that has ever been published, without exception, has demonstrated an improvement in blood flow and symptoms. Adverse editorial comment to the contrary lacks evidence and stems primarily from physicians with a vested interest in catheterization and surgery. [etc.] [emphasis in the original]
Yet Federal Code prohibits investigators from promoting investigational drugs, as follows:
(a) Promotion of an investigational new drug. A sponsor or investigator, or any person acting on behalf of a sponsor or investigator, shall not represent in a promotional context that an investigational new drug is safe or effective for the purposes for which it is under investigation or otherwise promote the drug.
In our article we had called attention to individual “Site Investigators,” including Dr. Shah, promoting chelation with sensational claims. Now we find that such promotion has itself been promoted by a newsletter emanating from TACT Central.
The tenor of the newsletters suggests that Dr. Lamas, the PI, thinks of his Chelation Site Investigators as immature, easily distracted schoolchildren. Hence the Sesame Street-like tone of “TACT Jeopardy” (TACTTALK Jan/Feb 06), “ALL THINGS BEING EQOL…” (TACT Tips Dec 05), “Congratulations TO THE WINNERS OF A CHOCOLATE GIFT BASKET FOR ENROLLING TWO PATIENTS IN OCTOBER 2005″ (TACTTALK Dec 05), “Informed Consent – More than just a form” (TACTTALK March/April 2005), ” ‘Roadrunner Award’ for the swift completion of the regulatory requirements (Beep-Beep)” (TACTTALK Dec 04), “Hear ye, Hear ye… ALL TACT SITE INVESTIGATORS and COORDINATORS” (Flyer Apr 05) and many more.
The newsletters show that recruitment has been difficult and that many subjects have dropped out and are lost to follow-up. The treatment would seem to be neither as popular nor as pleasing as its promoters and TACT investigators have claimed, thus negating the NIH’s main justification for the trial. Or, perhaps, there’s another explanation: that, as was the case for the “Gonzalez Regimen,” most prospective subjects don’t want to take the chance of being in the control group. But that would only limit enrollment if chelationists were offering the treatment outside of the TACT. They are, of course, but probably not legally.
That might have something to do with why Dr. Rajiv Chandra of Melbourne, FL, is frequently cited as the “top enroller” for the trial. Chandra, as we explained in our article, promised this to prospective subjects:
If you participate in this study, you will receive 28 months of treatment, and be asked to participate in up to 32 months of follow-up. You will not be charged for participating in this exciting study and will receive the study drug and vitamin and mineral supplements.
Deaths
Reports of Serious Adverse Events (SAE) include two deaths. One occurred in a 74 yo man with critical aortic stenosis and moderately poor left ventricular function who was admitted to a hospital in florid congestive heart failure 6 days after his 32nd chelation infusion. In the other, a 59 yo woman with a history of congestive heart failure suffered an acute episode of left ventricular failure and pulmonary edema 14 hours after her 33rd chelation infusion, followed shortly by cardiac arrest. In each case “The investigator assessed the causal relationship between the study drug and the serious adverse event as not associated,” citing the subjects’ underlying diseases.
In the first case, however, during the subject’s most recent chelation infusion “the investigator [had] noticed evidence of gross lower extremity edema and administered an extra dose of Bumex 2 milligrams followed by as needed treatment.” There is no report that “as needed treatment” occurred, but the onset of signs of congestive heart failure in a subject with critical aortic stenosis constitutes a medical emergency. It is not grounds for an unmonitored extra dose of Bumex (a diuretic that can paradoxically worsen the circulatory problems associated with critical aortic stenosis).
The subject, moreover, may have been a better surgical than medical candidate (we can’t tell from the SAE report) precisely because of his critical aortic stenosis, for which most medical treatments are fraught with hazard. The man’s worsening renal function may have been due to his many NaEDTA infusions, for which renal toxicity is a well-described outcome, the SAE report notwithstanding. Thus there may or may not have been a “causal relationship between the study drug and the serious adverse event,” but there is a strong likelihood that there was a causal relationship between the clinical incompetence of the Investigator and the demise of the subject.
According to the second case report, “pertinent laboratory information includes serum creatinine between 0.9- 1.0 mg/dL during the months of January through April of 2004, rising to 1.1-1.2 during May through July of 2004, 1.4 mg/dl in September of 2004, and 1.8 mg/dl on the day of her death.” This represents a progressive deterioration of renal function, again consistent with a known toxicity of NaEDTA. In this case the proximity of the final infusion to the cardiac arrest, together with presenting signs and symptoms of “volume overload,” argue for a “causal relationship between the study drug and the serious adverse event.”
Even if the woman’s demise was merely a coincidence (also plausible, given her heart disease), her history of progressive renal insufficiency constitutes strong evidence that in this case, as in the previous one, the Site Investigator had dropped the ball. The Investigator did not even know that the woman had died until she failed to show up for her next chelation infusion, which, since she was in the “maintenance” phase, would have been scheduled several weeks later. Also disconcerting is this statement by the author of the SAE report:
We are distributing an investigator alert, since cardio-pulmonary arrest is not specifically mentioned in the TACT Investigator’s Brochure. We will keep you informed if further relevant information becomes available on this type of adverse event.
“This type of adverse event”? TACT investigators are purported to be “experts” in “chelation therapy,” a treatment with a rich history of “this type of adverse event,” and to “have substantial experience in the treatment and management of CAD,” a disease frequently associated with ”this type of adverse event.” Does the reviewer of such Serious Adverse Events really think that TACT Investigators are surprised by them, and seek “further relevant information”?
These reports, I am more than angry to say, fulfill an implicit prediction that we made in our article:
The NIH has hired nearly 100 unqualified co-investigators to care for nearly 2000 unsuspecting subjects. In announcing the TACT, the late NCCAM Director Stephen Straus tacitly acknowledged that such soon-to-be co-investigators had been pushing chelation “in lieu of established treatments.” The TACT consent form warns subjects to “continue to use proven standard medicines for heart attack patients,” but the Declaration of Helsinki expects better:
Medical research involving human subjects should be conducted only by scientifically qualified persons and under the supervision of a clinically competent medical person. The responsibility for the human subject must always rest with a medically qualified person and never rest on the subject of the research, even though the subject has given consent.
It is the obligation of investigators to provide reasonable predictions of efficacy and assurances of safety, on the basis of all “relevant sources of information,” prior to exposing human subjects to a phase 3 trial. The TACT investigators did not do that.
Your government at work.

The result of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT): As underwhelming as expected
David Gorski on November 5, 2012
Link

Chelation therapy.
It’s one of the most common quackeries out there, used by a wide variety of practitioners for a wide variety of ailments blamed on “heavy metal toxicity.” Chelation therapy, which involves using chemicals that can bind to the metal ions and allow them to be excreted by the kidneys, is actually standard therapy for certain types of acute heavy metal poisoning, such as iron overload due to transfusion, aluminum overload due to hemodialysis, copper toxicity due to Wilson’s disease, acute heavy metal toxicity, and a handful of other indications.
My personal interest in chelation therapy developed out of its use by unscrupulous practitioners who blamed autism on the mercury-containing thimerosal preservative that used to be in many childhood vaccines until 2001 but has since all but disappeared from such vaccines except for one vaccine (the flu vaccine, for which a thimerosal-free alternative is available) and in trace amounts in some other vaccines. Mercury became a convenient bogeyman to add to the list of “toxins” antivaccinationists hype in vaccines. In fact, my very first post after I introduced myself on this very blog discussed the idea that mercury in vaccines was a significant cause of autism and autism spectrum disorders, and I’ve periodically written about such things ever since, in particular the bad science of Mark and David Geier, whose idea that chemical castration of children with Lupron “works” against “mercury-induced” autism is based on a chemically ridiculous idea that somehow testosterone binds mercury and makes it harder to chelate. Unfortunately, this particular autism quackery has real consequences and has been responsible for the death of a child.
Chelation isn’t just for autism, however. Despite many practitioners advertising it for autism, cancer (often with dubious studies that I might have to take a look at), Alzheimer’s disease (which Hugh Fudenberg has blamed on the flu vaccine, a claim parroted by Bill Maher, of course!), and just about every ailment under the sun, it’s easy to forget that the original use for chelation therapy promoted by “alternative medicine” practitioners was for cardiovascular disease. When it is used for coronary artery disease or autism, on a strictly stoichiometric and pharmacological basis, it is extremely implausible. Moreover, it is not without potential complications, including renal damage and cardiac arrhythmias due to sudden drops in calcium levels. Such arrhythmias can and have led to death in children, and in adults complications such as renal failure and death.
Despite this extreme implausibility, randomized controlled studies showing that chelation is no better than placebo for cardiovascular disease, a veritable cottage industry of chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease has sprung up, fueled by extravagant claims likening chelation to a “Roto-Rooter for your arteries“, an alternative to angioplasty and coronary artery bypass surgery, and portraying the hostility of SBM to it as not based on medicine but rather on the “need” to protect the “billion dollar industry of angioplasty and CABG.” With most regimens costing $100 to $150 per treatment and “requiring” 30 to 40 doses, it’s a tidy little profit center for “alternative” physicians.
The belief that chelating toxic metals out of people can treat cardiovascular disease has no basis in physiology, biology, or pharmacology, but it’s a major treatment modality favored by naturopaths and many other “alternative” practitioners. Given the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia, it should not be surprising that its advocates promoted clinical trials of this disproven modality. In the early 2000s, they succeeded in the form of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT), a five year phase 3 trial begun in 2003 to test office-based, intravenous disodium ethylene-diamine-tetra-acetic acid (Na2EDTA) as a treatment for coronary artery disease (CAD). A while back, I learned that the results of this trial would finally be revealed on Sunday (i.e., yesterday) at the American Heart Association’s annual meeting in a session on late-breaking clinical trials in the form of two abstracts:
    • Results of the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy
    • Quality of Life Outcomes in the Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT)
The story was embargoed until last night, but now the embargo is lifted and we can write about it freely, thanks to press releases and reported results of the trial. I expect that the results are—shall we say?—disappointing to chelationists. Certainly if this were a conventional medical therapy it would not be viewed as a particularly favorable trial. However, there are enough equivocal findings that the alt-med websites will soon be touting this study as ironclad evidence that chelation therapy works as well as bypass surgery. I guarantee it. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if such articles appear at the same time as this post. Chelationists have access to press information too and tend not to be as fastidious as us in honoring press embargoes.
The story of this $30 million trial is long and depressing and was documented ably and in extreme detail in 2008 by our very own Kimball Atwood and Wally Sampson, as well as Elizabeth Woeckner and Robert Baratz, in an article for the Medscape Journal of Medicine entitled Why the NIH Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) Should Be Abandoned. In it, Atwood et al. documented the long and dubious history of TACT, how it came about through the political influence far more than scientific merit (of which it has virtually none), and how the investigators are utterly unqualified to carry out such a large multicenter trial, concluding that the TACT is “pointless, dangerous, unethical, and wasteful.” It’s worth reading the article in full detail, as well as other posts right here on SBM that have examined the trial. In addition, you should check out R. W. Donnell’s Magical Mystery Tour of NCCAM Chelation Study Sites, Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, Part V, Part VI, and Part VII. Seriously. As Dr. Donnell points out, only 12 of the 110 TACT study sites were academic medical centers. Many of the study sites were highly dubious clinics touting highly dubious therapies, including heavy metal analysis for chronic fatigue, intravenous infusions of vitamins and minerals (I could never figure out how infusing minerals could be reconciled with chelation therapy to remove minerals, but that’s just me), anti-aging therapies, assessment of hormone status by saliva testing, and much more. Dr. Donnell also points out that the blinding of the study groups to local investigators was likely to have been faulty. So right off the bat, this study was dubious for so many reasons, not the least of which was that some of its site investigators were felons, a problem blithely dismissed by the NIH as being in essence irrelevant to whether the study could be done safely.
Efficacy? What efficacy?
Let’s take a look at the results of TACT, starting with the main outcome measures first, and then we’ll move on to the presentation describing quality of life (QOL) measures. The first presentation is by Gervasio Lamas, MD, a professor of clinical medicine at the Columbia University Division of Cardiology and now Chairman of Medicine at Mount Sinai Medical Center. and was entitled The Trial To Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT): Chelation-Placebo Comparison. One notes right away that the study was funded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM, grant U01AT001156) and the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI, U01HL092607). What’s interesting here is that the study was originally funded by NCCAM and then taken over by NHLBI later. Indeed, when Steve Novella, Kimball Atwood, and I met with Dr. Josephine Briggs, the director of NCCAM, and brought up TACT with her as an example of a scientifically dubious, expensive, and unethical study, she was very quick to dismiss it as no longer within NCCAM’s purview. She was clearly embarrassed by our question and also dismissed it as having come into existence before she took over as director at NCCAM. The second thing I noticed was that this was funded under the NIH U01 mechanism. This mechanism is designed to fund multi-institution collaborations to “discrete, specified, circumscribed projects to be performed by investigator(s) in an area representing their specific interests and competencies.” In practice, what I gather from more senior investigators is that U01 grants are less like R01 grants and more like contracts (more specifically, they are cooperative agreements) to carry out specific projects. As such, they appear to be a bit more amenable to political pressures to be granted—or at least were.
So what about the study itself? The clinical trial at the heart of TACT was a 2 x 2 factorial design that looked at:
    • Chelation plus high oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement
    • Chelation placebo plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement
    • Chelation plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement placebo
    • Chelation placebo plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement placebo
The regimen was also quite rigorous and is described in detail in a recent publication. One notes that the vitamin supplements included doses ranging from 25% to 6,667% of the RDA for these vitamins. For instance, the dose of vitamin C was 2,000% of the RDA; thiamin, 6,667%; and vitamin A, 500%. There were a total of 40 infusions that took three hours each. Thirty of these were administered weekly, followed by ten “maintenance” infusions administered two to eight weeks apart. Now let’s look at the nitty-gritty, followed by the results. First up, the inclusion criteria were:
    • Age 50 or older
    • MI > 6 months prior
    • Creatinine <2.0 mg/dL
    • No coronary or carotid revascularization within 6 months
    • No active heart failure or heart failure hospitalization within 6 months
    • Able to tolerate 500cc infusions weekly
    • No cigarette smoking within 3 months
    • Informed consent
The exclusion criteria were:
    • Chelation therapy within 5 years
    • Allergy to any study drug
    • Coronary or carotid revascularization within 6 months
    • Planned revascularization
    • Symptomatic or clinically evident heart failure
    • Heart failure hospitalization within 6 months
    • Blood pressure > 160/100
    • No venous access
    • Serum creatinine > 2.0 mg/dL
    • Platelet count <100000/mm3
    • Cigarette smoking within the last 3 months
    • Liver disease or ALT or AST >2.0 times the upper limit of normal
    • Diseases of copper, iron, or calcium metabolism
    • Inability to tolerate 500 mL of fluids weekly
    • Inability to keep to study schedules
    • Medical condition likely to affect patient survival within 4 years
    • Women of child-bearing potential
The placebo infusion consisted of 500 mL normal saline and 1.2% dextrose, while the chelation infusion consisted of:
    • disodium EDTA, 3 grams, adjusted downward based on eGFR,
    • ascorbic acid, 7 grams
    • magnesium chloride, 2 grams
    • potassium chloride, 2 mEq
    • sodium bicarbonate, 840 mg
    • pantothenic acid, thiamine, pyridoxine,
    • procaine, 100 mg
    • unfractionated heparin, 2500 U
    • sterile water to 500 mL
I find it very interesting that the investigators included procaine (a product of evil big pharma) in the chelation mixture. Yes, I know that disodium EDTA is also a product of the evil big pharma, but one can’t very well do chelation therapy without the chelating agent, can one? In any case, procaine is actually Novocaine and is a topical anesthetic. Its inclusion makes me wonder how much the chelation concoction being tested in TACT hurts as it is injected, as we usually don’t add local anesthetics to infusions unless the infusion causes significant pain at the injection site. Could this also contribute to the ability of patients to know if they’re getting the “real” drug (and, yes, disodium EDTA is a drug)? One wonders, one does.
One last piece needs to be put into place, and that’s to let you know the outcomes that were tested in TACT. The primary endpoint is a composite of death, myocardial infarction, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina. In other words, investigators took all of these endpoints and added them together. The significance of this design will become clear in a moment, after I reveal the results. Another important point was that the original plan was to randomize 2,372 patients with a one year followup, a design that was estimated to have 85% power to detect a 25% difference. However, in 2009, due to low enrollment (more on that later), it was pointed out that “blinded investigators asked for a reduction of total sample size to 1700, with a compensatory increase in follow-up to maintain same unconditional power.” I find it rather interesting that the word “blinded” is used, instead of just saying that the investigators asked for a decrease in number and a longer followup time in order to try to compensate for low accrual. The implication to me is that there were some investigators who were not blinded. Whether I’m reading too much into this or not, I don’t know, but it sounds odd. In any case, the request was approved.
So, on to the results. The result being touted by the investigators is described in the press release:
Heart attack patients given weekly infusions of chemicals used for chelation therapy had fewer cardiovascular events than those who received identical appearing placebo infusions, according to late-breaking clinical trial results presented at the American Heart Association’s Scientific Sessions 2012.
In the multicenter, double-blind efficacy trial, Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT),1,708 heart attack patients were randomized to receive 40 infusions of a 500 mL chelation solution or a placebo infusion, with a second randomization to an oral vitamin and mineral regimen or an oral placebo. The chelation solution contained three grams of the synthetic amino acid ethylene diamine tetra-acetic (EDTA), seven grams of vitamin C, B-vitamins, electrolytes, a local anesthetic and heparin, an anti-clotting drug. The placebo infusion was salt water and a small amount of sugar.
Researchers found that patients receiving the chelation solution had fewer serious cardiovascular events than the control group (26 percent vs. 30 percent). Cardiovascular events were defined as death, heart attack, stroke, coronary revascularization and hospitalization for angina.
Although participants with diabetes appeared to have a particular benefit from the infusions, the study team cautioned that subgroup analyses can be unreliable and need to be reproduced.
There’s the spin. Let’s look at the results. The primary endpoint (i.e., the aggregated serious cardiovascular events) did indeed show a modest difference, namely 30% of placebo subjects versus 26.5% of the EDTA chelation subjects (hazard ratio 0.82 for chelation). However, the result is just barely statistically significant, p = 0.035, with the 99% confidence interval for the hazard ratio ranging from 0.69 to 0.99. Note that the predetermined level for statistical significance for purposes of this study was 0.036. More importantly, if you look at the individual endpoints that make up that aggregate, there was no statistically significant difference in death, myocardial infarction, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina. Subgroup analysis (always a questionable analysis that requires replication, even when preplanned, as in TACT) purported to show a much greater benefit for diabetics, with a hazard ratio of 0.61 (p=0.002), while patients without diabetes showed no statistically significant difference in any of the outcome measures, including the aggregated total bad outcomes (I like that term better).
There were some problems, as you might imagine. First off, only 65% of subjects finished all infusions, with only 76% finishing at least 30. That’s a high drop-out rate, and is likely largely due to just how grueling it is to have to undergo weekly three hour infusions for well over six months, followed by several more months of less frequent infusions. Moreover, 17% withdrew consent, resulting in missing data. I’m not sure how the investigators tried to correct for this (there are standard ways to do it), but these issues are serious. They might not be so serious if there had been a much more convincing treatment effect, but when you get equivocal results such as this such issues loom much larger. Indeed, critics have correctly pointed this out, as in this AP report:
Other experts questioned the results, especially because 60 more people in the group getting dummy infusions withdrew from the study than in the group getting chelation. Usually, more people in a treatment group drop out because of side effects, said Dr. Christie Ballantyne, a Baylor College of Medicine heart specialist. To find the opposite is “a red flag” that suggests those who got dummy treatments found that out and decided to drop out.
“There’s something funky going on here,” Ballantyne said. “It raises questions about study conduct,” especially since a difference of one or two people or complications could have nullified the small overall benefit researchers reported.
Dr. Clyde Yancy, a Northwestern University cardiologist and a former Heart Association president, agreed.
“It’s funny business,” he said. “I’ve never seen a study in which one in five people withdrew consent.”
As Kimball has pointed out, there was a lot more than “funny business going on here.” Moreover, this concern is quite consistent with worries expressed over six years ago by Dr. R. W. Donnell about the adequacy of the blinding of the trial. In light of such concerns, the differential drop-out rate between the two groups makes a lot more sense. Too bad that Dr. Lamias apparently didn’t see fit to include specifics about the drop-out rate for each group in his press release or in his slide set.
Finally, no study would be complete without a consideration of adverse events. After all, in determining whether a therapy is worth pursuing, it is important to weigh its efficaciousness versus its safety. Overall, 79 adverse events were observed forcing discontinuation of infusions. Reasons included: reaching an endpoint; heart failure; other cardiac issues; GI problems; hematological problems; and a variety of other problems. Unfortunately, the presentation slides did not break down how many of these 79 adverse events occurred for patients in the treatment group versus patients from the placebo groups. In fact, given that there were four groups, these adverse events needed to be broken down into four groups but were not. There were a total of four unexpected severe adverse events possibly or definitely related to study therapy, two in the placebo group with one death and two in the treatment group, with one death. Kimball Atwood discussed some of the serious adverse events before in detail. They also don’t appear to line up exactly with what I saw in the presentation:
Reports of Serious Adverse Events (SAE) include two deaths. One occurred in a 74 yo man with critical aortic stenosis and moderately poor left ventricular function who was admitted to a hospital in florid congestive heart failure 6 days after his 32nd chelation infusion. In the other, a 59 yo woman with a history of congestive heart failure suffered an acute episode of left ventricular failure and pulmonary edema 14 hours after her 33rd chelation infusion, followed shortly by cardiac arrest. In each case “The investigator assessed the causal relationship between the study drug and the serious adverse event as not associated,” citing the subjects’ underlying diseases.
In the first case, however, during the subject’s most recent chelation infusion “the investigator [had] noticed evidence of gross lower extremity edema and administered an extra dose of Bumex 2 milligrams followed by as needed treatment.” There is no report that “as needed treatment” occurred, but the onset of signs of congestive heart failure in a subject with critical aortic stenosis constitutes a medical emergency. It is not grounds for an unmonitored extra dose of Bumex (a diuretic that can paradoxically worsen the circulatory problems associated with critical aortic stenosis).
I will be awaiting the full publication, in which (hopefully) more will be revealed about these two deaths. In the meantime, it is clear to me that, even if these results are valid and there is a small benefit to chelation therapy, it’s a long run for a risky short slide.
Quality of life? What quality of life?
Still, even though the results are so unconvincing that the study investigators concluded that TACT “does not constitute evidence to recommend the clinical application of chelation therapy” and that (of course!) “additional research will be needed to confirm or refute our results and explore possible mechanisms of therapy” while also saying TACT showed “some evidence of a potentially important treatment signal in post-MI patients already on evidence-based therapy,” maybe the therapy does something for quality of life. It’s possible, albeit highly implausible. So in parallel, QOL outcomes were measured and presented as a second abstract at AHA presented by Daniel B. Mark, MD, MPH.
Several QOL tools were administered to participants in TACT. These included:
    • DASI: A cardiac-related functional status tool that ranges from 0-58 and reflects the ability of patients to do physical activities without difficulty or assistance in 12 domains
    • MHI-5: A tool that measures psychological well-being, including both depression and anxiety. Investigators normalized scores to 50±10, with clinically significant difference being >2.5 points.
    • Other measures: SAQ (frequency, stability, QOL), SF-36, EQ-5D
In brief, 911 (53%) of the 1,708 main TACT subjects were randomly selected for the QOL substudy, with structured interviews at baseline, 6 months, 12 months, and 24 months. Let me tell you, though, that this study will be much easier to discuss than the main TACT trial for one very simple reason: there were no statistically significant differences in QOL outcomes measured for any of the assessment tools used at any of the time points examined.
So what do you do when your study is completely negative? Easy! You do subgroup analysis, and that’s what Mark et al. did. Well, actually, these subgroup analyses were prespecified; so it’s basically legitimate. Even so, they couldn’t find much. All they could find is that patients with angina symptoms at baseline showed a modest treatment effect in favor of chelation therapy at one year, but at none of the other time points. A good rule of thumb is that for repeated measures, seeing an effect at only one time point is strongly suggestive that the difference for that time point is spurious and not real; so there isn’t much to say about this other than that this was about as close to a completely negative study as one might imagine, and even the press release had to acknowledge that:
“We didn’t see any effect on the quality of life of chelation therapy patients,” said Daniel B. Mark, M.D., M.P.H., lead author of the sub-study and professor of medicine, director of outcomes research at Duke University Medical Center and Duke Clinical Research Institute in Durham, N.C. “Patients weren’t any worse, but they weren’t any better.
One of the tools used to measure quality of life was the Duke Activity Status Index, DASI, to measure patients’ ability to complete daily tasks. The lowest score of 0 means the patient couldn’t do any chores associated with their own care such as feeding, toileting and dressing themselves. The highest score of 48 would be achieved by a professional athlete, Mark said.
At the beginning of the study, patients taking chelation therapy had a score of 24.6 and after two years it went up to 27.1. Those on placebo, dummy infusions that contained no medicine, had a baseline score of 23.5 that went up to 25.1. The small difference between chelation and placebo wasn’t significant enough to show a notable impact on how patients functioned in their daily lives.
The results were similar when researchers used the SF-36, the Short Form Health Survey, which assesses mental wellbeing or stress. After two years of chelation or placebo, patients reported similar scores.
“We thought it might make people feel better, but we didn’t see that consistently enough,” Mark said.
No, Dr. Mark didn’t see it at all, just as the trial investigators apparently didn’t see Edzard Ernst’s criticisms of their trial design when they cited his review article as a source. As Dr. Ernst put it:
The TACT has been criticized as being “unethical, dangerous, pointless and wasteful.” Yet, Lamas et al inform us that it went ahead with “reduced sample size” and that “TACT has finished enrolment.” From my perspective, the most puzzling part of the article of Lamas et al is the following sentence: “EDTA chelation of divalent and trivalent ions has been postulated to produce a favorable effect on atherosclerotic plaque, questionably leading to improvement in endothelial function, reductions in symptoms, and major vascular events.” To support this statement, Lamas et al cite my review that shows an “almost total lack of convincing evidence” and concludes that “given the potential of chelation therapy to cause severe adverse effects, this treatment should now be considered obsolete.”
Ernst was correct, and the now-revealed results of TACT only serve to confirm that.
The bottom line
When we criticize NCCAM and the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia, we often point to the many pernicious effects that “integrating” pseudoscience with science- and evidence-based medicine has. One of these is the drive to test highly implausible therapies without adequate preclinical evidence, a practice at odds with the Helsinki Declaration’s requirement that clinical trials be based on firm basic science in preclinical models. This is problematic enough from an ethical standpoint when the treatment being tested is water (i.e., homeopathy), but when it’s an active treatment with real risks, it is completely unethical. That’s why I have said on multiple occasions that TACT is unethical. Worse, TACT was not funded based on a clinical need, scientific or clinical promise, or scientific merit due to its potential to reveal an important previously unsuspected mechanism of disease or target for treatment. Rather, it came into existence because a pro-quackery legislator, Rep. Dan Burton (R-IN) strong-armed the then-director of NCCAM to green light it. Later, it became such an albatross about NCCAM’s neck that NCCAM ceded control to NHBLI and downgraded its involvement to an advisory capacity. Indeed, Dr. Lamas himself seems to indicate that even he didn’t expect any positive results from TACT, although I suppose it’s possible that he means it was unexpected that this trial was, in essence, a negative trial:
“We have to look carefully at these unexpected results,” said Gervasio A. (Tony) Lamas, M.D., lead author of the study and chief of Columbia University Division of Cardiology at Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami Beach, Fla. “Although not approved by the Food and Drug Administration for treating heart disease, chelation therapy has been used for over 50 years and has generally been believed by conventional medical practitioners and cardiologists to be without value. A definitive answer on chelation therapy will take much additional research. The most exciting part of this study is that there may be an unexpected signal of benefit. We need to understand whether the signal is true, or whether it occurred by chance.”
No, the “signal” only comes from having aggregated a bunch of outcomes into one large outcome, and even then this signal, in a study of over 1,700 patients, strained to reach statistical significance. On each and every individual outcome, the “signal” doesn’t exist!
Let’s step back a moment an look at this. In the case of TACT, the result of the “integration” of quackery with scientific medicine has been to spend $30 million on a trial conducted at highly dubious CAM and “integrative” medicine clinics whose practitioners were completely unqualified to carry it out. This expenditure of scarce research dollars has resulted in a primary finding that is at best equivocal and at worst completely negative, and a secondary finding that is completely negative. Even if this study’s results are taken at face value, we can say that chelation therapy for coronary artery disease does not increase survival, obviate the need for angioplasty or CABG surgery (a prime claim frequently made by chelationists), or even decrease the severity of patients’ angina symptoms or increase their tolerance for physical activity. It is worthless. Actually, it’s worse than worthless, because it’s expensive, arduous, and, even if we took TACT’s reported results at face value, promises minimal benefit.
I am not condemning this trial because it was negative. Sometimes—often, in fact—clinical trials fail to find a benefit from the experimental treatment. There’s nothing wrong with that. However, such clinical trials are based on a sound preclinical evidence base of basic science and animal experimentation that indicates scientific plausibility and a reasonable likelihood that the treatment would be efficacious in humans. TACT had none of these things. Indeed, there was an existing preclinical and clinical evidence base that gave every indication that chelation therapy shouldn’t work.
The acceptance of chelation among CAM practitioners is also as good an example of the CAM double standard as I’ve ever seen. Imagine, if you will, if big pharma produced a treatment like chelation therapy that had no good preclinical evidence suggesting its efficacy and several existing clinical trials suggesting that it does no better than placebo for cardiovascular disease. Imagine that big pharma tried to get FDA approval to market its chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease. Imagine how CAM practitioners would react. Now look for how they react to this trial. I can predict it. (Not that it’s hard or anything.) They’ll make excuses. They’ll cherry pick the one seemingly promising result. They’ll claim that there was something wrong with the protocol or that the wrong chelating agent was used. They’ll demand more studies. In other words, they won’t simply admit that their therapy doesn’t work and move on.
Same as it ever was. Forever and ever and ever, amen.

The Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy: Equivocal as Predicted
Kimball Atwood on November 4, 2012
Link
The ill-advised, NIH-sponsored Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) is finally over. 839 human subjects were randomized to receive Na2EDTA infusions; 869 were randomized to receive placebo infusions. The results were announced at this weekend’s American Heart Association meeting in Los Angeles. In summary, the TACT authors report a slight advantage for chelation over placebo in the “primary composite endpoint,” a combination of five separate outcomes: death, myocardial infarction, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina:

Although that result may seem intriguing, it becomes less so when the data are examined more carefully. First, it barely achieved the pre-ordained level of statistical significance, which was P=.036. Second, none of the individual components of the composite endpoint achieved statistical significance, and most of the absolute difference was in coronary revascularization–which is puzzling:
Third, the difference in the primary composite endpoint was limited to diabetic subjects (about 30% in each group), as shown here:

Since the numbers of diabetics were substantially smaller than the total, and since, as the authors themselves admitted, “subgroup analyses can be unreliable,” this finding may or may not reflect a real phenomenon. There was also a fair amount of incomplete data, as shown here:

Unfortunately, the authors did not report the numbers of dropouts from each of the arms of the study. If there was a substantial discrepancy, that alone could explain an apparent difference in outcome.
The authors reported that the treatment was safe:

We are not told how many of the 79 who discontinued infusions came from each arm, however. Regarding the two deaths that were “possibly or definitely related to study therapy,” could those have been the same two subjects discussed here? It seems unlikely, because in each of those cases “The site investigator has assessed the causal relationship between the study drug and the serious adverse event as not associated stating the cardiopulmonary arrest was due to progression of the disease under study,” and the SAE reports from Duke University barely challenged those assessments. That makes me wonder about the details of the remaining 180 reported deaths, even though they were nearly evenly distributed between the active and placebo groups.
The authors offered these caveats and conclusions:
I agree with the caveats and with the final conclusion. I do not agree that “additional research will be needed.” Now, for the “I told you so” part of this post.
Not Definitive, Somewhat Informative
When Gervasio Lamas, the Principle Investigator of the TACT, announced his plans to pursue a trial of chelation, he touted it as
a definitive trial [that] would, once and for all, either put to rest the lingering questions of efficacy or add EDTA chelation to the armamentarium for clinicians who treat patients with coronary disease.
When the TACT began in 2002, NCCAM Director Stephen Straus opined:
The public health imperative to undertake a definitive study of chelation therapy is clear. The widespread use of chelation therapy in lieu of established therapies, the lack of adequate prior research to verify its safety and effectiveness, and the overall impact of coronary artery disease convinced NIH that the time is right to launch this rigorous study.
The description of the TACT on ClinicalTrials.gov promised this:
The results of TACT will provide either a significant positive result or an informative null result upon which rational clinical decision-making and health policy can be based.
Clearly the $30 million TACT, the most expensive “CAM” trial yet paid for by taxpayers, has not put to rest lingering questions of efficacy, although those did not really exist prior to its inception. Rather, the trial’s results are consistent with this prediction:
The Likely Outcome
Even if the TACT is completed, which it should not be, it is unlikely to reduce the promotion of reckless uses of Na2EDTA. Whatever the outcome, chelationists have already positioned themselves to continue the practice: By virtue of ridding the body of toxic heavy metals, they claim, chelation is useful for more than 70 conditions. Without exception, chelationists have refused to accept previous results that contradict their beliefs. Their response to the TACT, should it yield definitive, negative results, is unlikely to be different.
The trial, moreover, is unlikely to yield “an informative negative result” even though chelation is almost certainly ineffective for CAD. It is more likely to yield ambiguous results. There are multiple endpoints, including subjective quality-of-life measures, and several subgroup analyses. The variety of trial settings increases the likelihood of heterogeneity of procedures and reporting. Promotions of chelation by TACT co-investigators have already introduced unacceptable bias into the trial. There is ample, additional opportunity for mischief, and ample reason to think that several co-investigators are inclined to make it. The statistical analyses will not be Bayesian.
Thus, merely on the basis of chance and bias, it is likely that some outcome data in some subgroups will differ sufficiently, between those receiving Na2EDTA and those receiving placebo, to reassure chelationists that chelation “works” and to sustain “lingering questions of efficacy” in the minds of apologists. Dr. Lamas himself has made much of 2 or 3 “tantalizing positive secondary outcomes” of a previous trial in which only 15 subjects received Na2EDTA, and in which the remaining 30 secondary outcomes and all 7 primary outcomes were unequivocally negative. The all-but-inevitable “tantalizing positive secondary outcomes” of the TACT would likely lead to years of additional, unnecessary trials or, at the very least, unremitting peddling of chelation by practitioners armed with fresh fodder in their perpetual battle against rational standards of care.
The ACAM, the PPO that most pushes chelation, is already licking its chops to have Dr. Lamas present his own tantalizing positive secondary outcomes at their fall meeting in Las Vegas. It’s a cinch that whatever else comes of the TACT, it will protect quacks from state medical boards for years to come.
It’s ironic, then, that the TACT results are informative in an important way that its authors seem to have overlooked: it convincingly demonstrates that the claims of chelationists have been bogus all along. That’s because those claims have been far more dramatic than even the small effect that the TACT may appear to support. Typically, chelationists, including those involved in the TACT, claim “improvement” or even “marked improvement” in 80-90% of patients with ischemic heart disease or other vascular disease. A review of such claims is here.
Note to Medical Journals: Publishing the Formal TACT Report would Violate your own Ethics
The TACT was an unethical trial for numerous reasons. What follows are a couple of those reasons that are not in dispute, quoted from this summary:
    • We have shown, and both the federal Office of Human Research Protections (OHRP) and the University of Miami IRB have acknowledged, that the TACT proceeded with a misleading consent form—so misleading that any change now, more than 6 years after the trial began, couldn’t possibly reverse the damage already done. Misleading statements in the consent form included a strong implication that the study drug was the relatively less dangerous calcium-sodium ETDA, not the very dangerous disodium EDTA used in the trial. The consent form also failed to state important risks, including death.
    • We also showed, and the OHRP and U. Miami IRB also agreed, that many of the investigators in the TACT have criminal records, histories of discipline by state medical boards, histories of membership in IRBs disciplined by the FDA, and other indications of incompetent practices or worse.
Most medical journals subscribe to the Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals, established by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. The Uniform Requirements include honoring the Helsinki Declaration, which includes these passages:
24. In medical research involving competent human subjects, each potential subject must be adequately informed of the aims, methods, sources of funding, any possible conflicts of interest, institutional affiliations of the researcher, the anticipated benefits and potential risks of the study and the discomfort it may entail, and any other relevant aspects of the study.
16. Medical research involving human subjects must be conducted only by individuals with the appropriate scientific training and qualifications. Research on patients or healthy volunteers requires the supervision of a competent and appropriately qualified physician or other health care professional. The responsibility for the protection of research subjects must always rest with the physician or other health care professional and never the research subjects, even though they have given consent.
30. Authors, editors and publishers all have ethical obligations with regard to the publication of the results of research…Reports of research not in accordance with the principles of this Declaration should not be accepted for publication.
So don’t do it.

Misinterpreting TACT: No, Chelation Does Not Outperform Statins for Heart Disease
Harriet Hall on December 8, 2015
Link

Chelation with intravenous EDTA (disodium ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid) has long been used for heavy metal poisoning. It binds the metal ions and facilitates their excretion from the body. In recent years it has been used for many other indications that are not evidence-based, such as autism and coronary heart disease.
The Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) was done to assess the effectiveness and safety of EDTA plus high-dose oral vitamins for preventing second heart attacks in patients who had already had one. An article on The People’s Pharmacy website portrays the study as strongly positive. The Graedons, authors of the website, claim that science supports the use of chelation. They report that for every 12 patients undergoing chelation, one heart attack will be prevented over a five-year period. They cite a 5-year NNT (number needed to treat) of 16 for statin therapy and they conclude that:
EDTA chelation outperformed statins because fewer people needed to receive treatment to achieve a desirable outcome.
That’s just wrong. It compares oranges to apples (truckloads of statin oranges to one wormy, rotten chelation apple). The benefits of statins have been established in multiple studies; the alleged benefits of chelation are based on a single fatally-flawed study. You can’t say chelation outperforms statins unless you have done a controlled study comparing the two. In fact, in the TACT study the subjects were all on standard therapy after a heart attack; most of them were taking statins. The Graedons don’t seem to understand the actual results of the study. The Graedons downplay the known risks of chelation and the serious flaws that make the study unreliable, and they provide anecdotes, saying that in combination with the TACT results, those anecdotes mean that some people do get benefit from EDTA chelation therapy. No, they don’t mean that at all, and the Graedons should know better.
Criticisms of the Trial to Assess Chelation TherapyIn 2008, while the trial was in progress, SBM’s own Kimball Atwood and Wallace Sampson, along with two other authors, wrote an exhaustive evaluation of TACT’s rationale, methodology, and ethics. They said:
We present our findings in 4 parts: history, origin and nature of the TACT, state of the evidence, and risks. We present evidence that chelationists and their organization, the American College for Advancement in Medicine, used political connections to pressure the NIH to fund the TACT. The TACT protocols justified the trial by misrepresenting case series and by ignoring evidence of risks. The trial employs nearly 100 unfit co-investigators. It conflates disodium EDTA and another, somewhat safer drug. It lacks precautions necessary to minimize risks. The consent form reflects those shortcomings and fails to disclose apparent proprietary interests. The trial’s outcome will be unreliable and almost certainly equivocal, thus defeating its stated purpose.We conclude that the TACT is unethical, dangerous, pointless, and wasteful. It should be abandoned.
Results and criticisms of the completed trial
It wasn’t abandoned. When the results were announced, David Gorski wrote a masterful analysis pointing out its many flaws, including a high drop-out rate and missing data. The results were essentially negative. They reported it as positive, because the primary endpoint (an aggregation of serious cardiovascular events plus softer criteria) showed a modest difference (30% for placebo vs. 26.5% for chelation) that was just barely statistically significant. But there was no significant difference in the individual endpoints of death, heart attack, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina. Only the subgroup of patients with diabetes appeared to benefit from chelation. For non-diabetics, there was no statistically significant difference in any of the outcome measures. A separate investigation of quality of life showed no difference between placebo and chelation. Even the study investigators concluded that TACT “does not constitute evidence to recommend the clinical application of chelation therapy” and as usual, they recommended further studies.
When the TACT study was published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), it was accompanied by an editorial written by cardiologist Steven Nissen. He said:
many important limitations in the design and execution of a clinical trial compromise the reliability of the study and render the results difficult to interpret. Unfortunately, the efforts of these investigators fell short of the minimum level of quality necessary to adequately answer the question they sought to investigate.
He goes on to elaborate some of TACT’s deviations from the scientific principles of a good trial. And he concludes:
Given the numerous concerns with this expensive, federally funded clinical trial, including missing data, potential investigator or patient unmasking, use of subjective end points, and intentional unblinding of the sponsor, the results cannot be accepted as reliable and do not demonstrate a benefit of chelation therapy. The findings of TACT should not be used as a justification for increased use of this controversial therapy.
Kimball Atwood covered the equivocal results and went even further. He argued that it was unethical for journals to publish the study.
Lessons to be learned
This trial was a good example of why we established this blog promoting science-based medicine over evidence-based medicine. We had good evidence from preliminary studies that chelation didn’t work and was dangerous. There was no underlying rationale for why it should work. There had been no laboratory, animal, or human phase 1 or 2 studies; so doing such a trial would fail to meet the Declaration of Helsinki guidelines for ethical research. But evidence-based medicine looks only at what it classifies as evidence, and it fails to consider how human foibles and flawed experimental design make some of that evidence unreliable. It values the results of any randomized controlled trial even if it is Tooth Fairy science done for a treatment that basic science tells us couldn’t possibly work, like homeopathy or therapeutic touch. An article in the American Heart Journal argued that we couldn’t say chelation didn’t work because there hadn’t been any large scale randomized controlled studies. NCCAM was happy to oblige. Evidence-based medicine embraced the study; science-based medicine didn’t.
Conclusion: TACT was a journey to nowhere
The TACT study should never have been done. It accomplished nothing. The published results allow chelationists to claim that it works, just as they did before the study. They allow science-based doctors to claim that it doesn’t work, just as they did before the study. So after spending $31.6 million of taxpayer money, we are right back where we started.

We finally learn from TACT2 what we should have known two decades ago: Chelation therapy doesn’t work for heart disease
At SBM, we’ve long argued that chelation therapy for heart disease is quackery. An abstract presented recently finally confirmed that. Why did it take so long?
David Gorski on April 29, 2024
Link

In the days leading up to my starting to write today’s post, I thought that I’d just write a followup to last week’s post about “turbo cancers” supposedly caused by COVID-19 vaccines, mainly because there are as yet two truly awful articles supposedly supporting this antivax claim that I have yet to deal with. However, as I was perusing my usual sources for blogging topics, I realized that I’ve already written about “turbo cancer” twice in a row, but more importantly I came across articles that would allow me to “close the loop,” so to speak on a topic that was a frequent topic of discussion on this blog going back to its very beginning, as well as on my not-so-super-secret other blog going way, way back. That topic is the quackery known as chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease (particularly coronary artery disease) and how the evidence-based medicine (EBM) model had led the NIH to spend $30 million on an unethical study (Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy, or TACT) to assess whether chelation therapy actually works. The result was an at best equivocal study that was widely touted by quacks after its results were reported in 2012 as proof of the efficacy and safety of the treatment, even though it only showed a benefit using a composite endpoint—there was no statistically significant difference in any of the endpoints that made up the composite endpoint—and then only in diabetic patients.
Given its $30 million price tag, we at SBM considered TACT to be arguably the most egregious example of the single biggest blindspot in EBM, namely the failure to consider prior probability in deciding whether a treatment has sufficient preclinical evidence to justify a large phase 3 clinical trial. It was pure quackademic medicine, in which, thanks to that blindspot in EBM, quackery is treated seriously enough to merit a study costing tens of millions of dollars that could have been better used to study treatments with an actual likelihood of working. Moreover, as predicted, the results of TACT didn’t change “integrative medicine” practice. As I wrote at the time, if “integrative medicine” specialists, naturopaths, and the like actually believed the conclusions of TACT, they should have immediately stopped treating their nondiabetic patients with heart disease using chelation therapy. After all, TACT clearly showed zero difference between chelation and placebo in cardiovascular outcomes, even using the Frankenendpoint chosen (the composite endpoint). They did not. Instead, chelation advocates used the results of TACT to persuade the NIH to fund to the tune of $37 million what I called the “Son of TACT” but what ended up being called TACT2, the original TACT now being referred to as TACT1. Its aim was to study the use of chelation therapy in diabetic patients with heart disease. It was the reporting of the results of TACT2 at the recent American College of Cardiology meeting earlier this month that chelation therapy that made me immediately realize that I was tired of writing about turbo cancer and needed a brake. Spoiler alert: TACT2 was a completely negative clinical trial, which is why I wanted to write this post.
So basically, the NIH spent $67 million on two trials that never needed to be done to come up with a result 21 years after the first TACT trial started that we had been predicting all along. What really made me want to write about this again, though, was the reaction of a certain cardiologist and EBM maven, Dr. John Mandrola, who posted to Sensible Medicine an article Chelation Did Not Work But Science Did, with the tagline, “When the TACT 2 trial failed to confirm TACT 1, the winner was science.”
Nope. In fact, TACT2 was anything but a win for science, and reactions from EBM mavens like the one above are part of what is so infuriating about the current EBM model. Let me explain why. I’ll start by discussing chelation and its history, move on to discussing TACT1, and then finish by discussing TACT2, all while interspersing my usual commentary about how credulous some doctors can be.
A typical advertisement for chelation therapy.
TACT1: The genesis of an unethical and unnecessary clinical trial
Perhaps the most definitive description of why TACT1 was unnecessary and unethical and never should have been done, much less at a cost of $30 million was written by former regular here at SBM, Dr. Kimball Atwood, along with Elizabeth Woeckner, Dr. Robert Baratz, and the late great Dr. Wally Sampson, in Medscape in a 2008 article entitled Why the NIH Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) Should Be Abandoned. It’s an article worth reading in its entirety, but what is interesting is the history of chelation therapy and how the trial came to be, all of which I’m pretty sure that Dr. Mandrola and those thinking similarly about chelation therapy are unaware of. It’s a history that goes back to the 1950s—nearly 70 years ago.
First, though, what is the rationale for chelation therapy to treat atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease? The rationale is simple enough. Mature atherosclerotic plaques often have calcium in them; so it was hypothesized that “decalcification” of these plaques could reduce them in size, improve blood flow, and decrease the complications that result from decreased blood flow due to such plaques. However, as Atwood et al noted about coronary artery disease (CAD), peripheral vascular disease (PVD), and cerebrovascular disease (CVD):
Beginning in 1956, a few small, uncontrolled case series reported that IV Na2EDTA seemed to have striking, beneficial effects on CAD, PVD, and cerebrovascular disease.[32,50,51,52,53] By 1963 it became clear that those reports, which were based primarily on subjective outcomes, had been wrong. When followed for more than a few months, subjects with CAD had rates of death and MI similar to those expected for untreated patients at that time.[54] Two small series of subjects with intermittent claudication had also shown no evidence of improvement.[54,55] Several autopsies from various series had revealed no evidence of decalcification of plaques or reduction of plaque size. Within a couple of years, case series of IV Na2EDTA for cardiovascular disease no longer appeared in the academic medical literature.
Note that references #54 and #55 cited by Atwood et al. are from 1963 and 1964, roughly 60 years ago. So what happened? Why did chelation therapy for CAD, PVD, and CVD not only persist but actually make a comeback a couple of decades later, even though evidence as it existed in the early 1960s would seem to have been enough to bury it for good as ineffective and potentially dangerous, the key risk coming from the possibility that chelation could lower the concentration of calcium ion in the blood to a dangerously low level that could cause fatal arrhythmias? It wasn’t, though. A small band of enthusiasts who still believed that chelation not only worked but worked nearly miraculously kept offering it in their offices, amending the protocol to include not just disodium EDTA, but magnesium, vitamins, and minerals, followed by monthly “maintenance” infusions, advertising the concoction as a “chemical Roto-Rooter” or a “chemical endarterectomy.” (An endarterectomy is a surgical procedure that removes atherosclerotic plaques from arteries to improve blood flow. It’s used primarily for the carotid arteries in order to prevent strokes in patients with a high degree of narrowing due to atherosclerotic plaques.)
As is often the case with treatments like this, “indication creep” lead “alternative medicine” practitioners to tout chelation therapy as a panacea, a near cure-all, for conditions as unrelated and diverse as disparate as multiple sclerosis, schizophrenia, autism, cancer, peptic ulcer, back pain, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Indeed, my first encounters with chelation therapy as a skeptic of alternative medicine were in the context of its use to treat “vaccine-induced autism.” Sadly, one of my strongest memories from that period long ago included a tragic case in 2005 in which a 5-year-old autistic boy named Abubakar Tariq Nadama died of a fatal arrhythmia while being treated with chelation therapy for autism. The quack, an otolaryngologist named Dr. Roy Kerry, was ultimately charged with involuntary manslaughter, endangering the welfare of children and reckless endangerment. Outrageously, the prosecutor dropped all charges based on a rather technical point about which form of EDTA was used. What penalty did Dr. Kerry face? In 2009, he signed a consent agreement under which his medical license was suspended for six months, after which he had to serve probation for 2-1/2 years. The agreement also barred him from chelating anyone under age 18 and required him to undergo a fitness-to-practice evaluation and have his practice monitored by another doctor during his probation. That’s it.
I guess chelation therapy is no longer likened to a Roto-Rooter for the arteries, but instead chelationists are likening it to a broom sweeping away that nasty plaque.
Of course, one might concede that of course it’s quackery to treat autism with chelation therapy given that there’s no evidence that “heavy metal” toxicity has anything to do with the development of autism while still believing that chelation might prove beneficial treating CVD, even though, similarly, there’s never been good evidence that elevated levels of calcium, lead, etc., contribute to the development of atherosclerotic plaques or, more importantly, that chelating heavy metals leads to their reversal. So let’s get back to the genesis of TACT1.
A dispassionate ad for chelation therapy.
Atwood et al go on to describe the formation of the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), which advocated for various alternative medicine treatments, in particular laetrile, to be “integrated” into medical practice, whose doctors had a large role in developing the “evidence base” (if you can call it that) used to justify TACT to NIH:
Reports of uncontrolled series of IV Na2EDTA for cardiovascular and other diseases began to reappear in about 1980. Unlike the original reports, these were written exclusively by advocates, all members of the AAMP/ACAM, and published, with 1 or 2 exceptions, in little-known, nonrefereed journals. Several articles reported sample sizes in the hundreds or thousands. Each series reported dramatic improvements in 80% to 90% of subjects.[34,57,88,89]
Complications, if mentioned, were described as minor. Rates of death from any cause, if mentioned, were implausibly low. For example, in a report of 2870 subjects, most of whom were said to have CAD (844 subjects), PVD (1130 subjects), or cerebrovascular disease (504 subjects), followed in Brazil for a 2-year period in the early 1980s, the authors reported 7 deaths; 2 were in the CAD group.[90,91] In a subsequent report, the same authors wrote that when chelation had been “administered according to the ACAM protocol,” there hadn’t been “a single reported incident of renal failure or death since 1960.[92]” As discussed in Part III of this article, the claim was false and the authors had reason to know it.[18,93,94] One of those authors, James Carter, is now a TACT co-investigator.[7]
Two reports were “meta-analyses” of the others, reporting more than 20,000 subjects and creating, for their statistical analyses, imaginary control groups “defined to have no improvement in cardiovascular capability.[95,96]” The first author of those reports is “prominent expert” L. Terry Chappell, also now a TACT co-investigator.[4,7]
In particular, I like these images found on a chelationist websites likening chelation to a magnet sucking out metals from the blood and an atherosclerotic plaque. Whoever made this image apparently doesn’t realize that lead and most heavy metals are not ferromagnetic and not attracted by magnets.
And here’s another one likening chelation to a magnet!
As for the “decalcification” hypothesis that ACAM used to explain why chelation “worked”:
As it became clearer that the decalcification theory was no longer taken seriously by medical scientists, chelationists sought new explanations for the putative effects of Na2EDTA, though never relinquishing the old one.[80,100]Several were proposed, among them platelet function inhibition, anticoagulation, lowering of serum lipids, and calcium channel blockade. The most popular one, which persists, was based on the removal of toxic heavy metals. Through the removal of iron, mercury, aluminum, lead, and other metals that, according to advocates, are toxic even at the miniscule levels found in most people, the panacea effects of chelation are explained.
So how did TACT1 come about? Dear reader, here’s where a politician familiar to longtime readers enters the picture, Rep. Dan Burton (R-Indiana). You might remember him for being a longtime chair of the House Oversight Committee, where, back in the 1990s and early 2000s, in the service of his belief that vaccines had caused his grandchild to become autistic, would frequently hold hearings in which he would torment CDC and FDA officials about bogus science supposedly linking vaccines to autism. Guess what? It was Rep. Burton who pressured the NIH to fund TACT:
In March 1999, ACAM presidents L. Terry Chappell and Ted Rozema shilled for chelation at a hearing of the House Committee on Government Reform, chaired by a powerful “health freedom” ally and veteran of the Laetrile wars, Rep. Dan Burton (R-IN).[41,167,168] NHLBI Director Claude Lenfant, whom Burton had summoned, was present. Burton criticized the NHLBI for “never funding any research into chelation therapy”; he criticized the National Library of Medicine for not listing the Journal of Advancement in Medicineon MEDLINE; he criticized the FTC for “launch[ing] an attack on the free flow of information from a non-profit professional medical association.[41]“
Burton scolded Director Lenfant for his institute’s “bias” against chelation and other “alternative” methods and declared that he, Burton, would personally bring the purportedly large number of applications for chelation research “right to your office and lay them on your desk.[41]” Dr. Lenfant replied that there had been only 1 proposal to the NHLBI for a clinical study of chelation in the previous 30 years.
Ultimately, in 2001 the NIH (specifically the NHBLI and the then-named National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine) wanted to do a randomized controlled trial (RCT) and issued a joint Request for Applications (RFA):
…for a $30 million, “multi-site, randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled trial investigating the efficacy and safety of EDTA (ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid) chelation therapy in individuals suffering from Coronary Artery Disease.[1]” The ACAM’s influence was explicit: “It is expected that the trial will investigate the EDTA Chelation treatment protocol recommended by ACAM.” It was also implicit: “Common conventional medical treatments for CAD include percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) and coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery, procedures that are invasive and costly.[1]” There was no mention of statins, aspirin, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, beta-blockers, calcium channel blockers, nitrates, antihypertensives, smoking cessation, diet, exercise, or other common “conventional” medical treatments for CAD.
he RFA cited several articles by Edward McDonagh, the chelationist who had previously admitted in a court of law to having falsified his data.[44] The 2001 and 2003 TACT protocols contain at least 5 more references to studies by McDonagh, including one purporting to show that chelation is not nephrotoxic and another purporting to show that it does not cause bone loss.[174,175] The protocols misrepresent a large part of the rest of the chelation literature, as we discuss in Parts III and IV.
The rest, unfortunately, is history. In August 2002, NCCAM announced the $30 million grant award, naming Dr. Lamas as PI. Part of its rationale was in its press release, which cited “the widespread use of chelation therapy in lieu of established therapies [and] the lack of adequate prior research to verify its safety and effectiveness…” and argued that the “public health imperative to undertake a definitive study of chelation therapy is clear.” One can’t help but note that ACAM had promoted chelation, making it very popular among the “holistic” crowd, and now that very popularity was being used to justify a dubious and expensive clinical trial of chelation. Edzard Ernst had been right in 2000, when he published a review of EDTA chelation therapy for CAD for the American Heart Journal, in which he noted that the literature consisted of numerous enthusiastic but uncontrolled case series countered by a few, exclusively negative controlled trials and concluded: “The most striking finding is the almost total lack of convincing evidence for efficacy. Given the potential of chelation therapy to cause severe adverse effects, this treatment should now be considered obsolete.”
Yet NCCAM, Dr. Lamas, and the NIH marched bravely on, and, I bet, Dr. Mandrola was utterly ignorant of this history of TACT1, which I’ve only summarized briefly from Atwood et al; you (and Dr. Mandrola) should read the whole article.
TACT1 results: Equivocal at best
When the results of TACT1 were presented at the American Heart Association meeting in 2012 and published in 2013, both Dr. Atwood and I discussed the trial again, along with its results, but I’m rather interested on Dr. Mandrola’s take first. Let’s just say that he was “stunned” and way too impressed. He also perfectly encapsulates the blind spot of EBM, namely the way that it values RCTs above all other evidence and gives little weight to prior probability based on basic science and preclinical studies in assessing treatments:
Let’s pause here and pretend we are neutral Martians unencumbered by priors regarding alternative vs traditional medicine.
It is not “encumbered” to consider “priors” with respect to chelation therapy. The priors, as I discussed above, were all negative, making TACT1 unnecessary and highly unethical. We already had more than enough evidence to conclude that chelation therapy does not impact CAD in any meaningful fashion. In fairness, maybe “stunned” isn’t so surprising a word to use, but only if you don’t know the history of chelation therapy and also how the trial was carried out. Still:
NIH sponsored the trial. Dr. Lamas is a seasoned and established trialist. Co-investigator Daniel Mark also boasts traditional academic credentials. TACT had a proper-placebo control and endpoint. It had long follow-up and enrolled patients who had established heart disease.
If the treatment were a drug or lucrative procedure, Lamas’ presentation of a 41% reduction in major cardiac events in patients with diabetes would have been celebrated and likely sailed through FDA review.
But chelation was not a traditional therapy. Heavy metals were not an established cause of atherosclerosis. So, this was, as Dr. Harlan Krumholz wrote, “inconvenient” evidence.
One might look at it this way. After all, the lack of prior plausibility is not a 100% foolproof reason to reject unexpected findings of a clinical trial. Sometimes, such findings will lead scientists to reassess their understanding of a disease and therapy, leading to major advancements in understanding and treatment. This, however, is not one of those times. For reasons that I will try to explain, it’s more akin to trials of homeopathy in that it is incredibly unlikely that even this study points to a scientific mechanism.
Let’s start by just looking at the problems with this study, all of which Dr. Atwood and I enumerated in detail. The results as reported did show that primary endpoint (i.e., the aggregated serious cardiovascular events) did indeed show a modest difference, namely 30% of placebo subjects versus 26.5% of the EDTA chelation subjects (hazard ratio 0.82 for chelation). However, the result is just barely statistically significant, p = 0.035, with the 99% confidence interval for the hazard ratio ranging from 0.69 to 0.99. Note that the predetermined level for statistical significance for purposes of this study was 0.036. More importantly, if you look at the individual endpoints that make up that aggregate, there was no statistically significant difference in death, myocardial infarction, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina. As I said at the time, I’m generally suspicious of a composite endpoint of aggregated endpoints like this, as it’s always difficult to know whether that composite endpoint represents a true clinical benefit. That suspicion goes double when none of the individual endpoints that make up the composite endpoint hit statistical significance. As I said at the time, the only “signal” of efficacy comes from having aggregated a bunch of outcomes into one large outcome, and even then this signal, in a study of over 1,700 patients, strained to reach statistical significance. On each and every individual outcome, the “signal” didn’t exist!
As for the findings in diabetics, subgroup analysis (always a questionable analysis that requires replication, even when done in a preplanned fashion, as in TACT) purported to show a much greater benefit for diabetics, with a hazard ratio of 0.61 (p=0.002), while patients without diabetes showed no statistically significant difference in any of the outcome measures, including the aggregate. As I wrote at the time and keep repeating here, if chelationists had been truly interested in following the results of this trial, they would have immediately stopped using chelation therapy in non-diabetic patients with heart disease, for whom even TACT showed not a hint of a whisper of a benefit. As we know, they did not.
That’s not surprising, given that many of the centers where the trial was carried out were “integrative” and alternative medicine practices that offered a panoply of quackery to their patients, as documented by Dr. R. W. Donnell (the blogger who first coined the term “quackademic medicine”) in his Magical Mystery Tour of NCCAM Chelation Study Sites, (Part II, Part III, Part IV, Part V, Part VI, and Part VII). Seriously. As Dr. Donnell pointed out, only 12 of the 110 TACT study sites were academic medical centers. Worse, most of the study sites were highly dubious clinics touting highly dubious therapies, including heavy metal analysis for chronic fatigue, intravenous infusions of vitamins and minerals, anti-aging therapies, assessment of hormone status by saliva testing, and much more. Atwood et al echoed this point by describing how nearly “all chelationist co-investigators are members of an organization or one of its offspring founded ‘to promote the use of EDTA chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease'” and listing examples of how they advertised chelation therapy in general and TACT in a manner that suggested subjects would receive chelation for free. Dr. Donnell also made a compelling case that the blinding of the study groups to local investigators was likely to have been compromised. So right off the bat, TACT1 was dubious for so many reasons, not the least of which was that some of its site investigators were felons, a problem blithely dismissed by the NIH as being in essence irrelevant to whether the study could be done safely.
Dr. Mandrola looked at the results this way:
Drs Lamas and Mark did not promote chelation therapy. They did not recommend that people—even those with diabetes—seek chelation.
They were cautious about their surprise findings. The clinical equivalent of their approach was similar to stress testing for finding coronary stenoses. It was as if they had found a positive stress test in a patient with low-risk for heart disease. In the clinic and in trials, you have to consider the priors.
This doesn’t sound like a “measured” take on TACT1.
While Drs. Lamas and Mark might have been cautious about their findings, I can’t say the same believers in alternative medicine, who immediately started portraying TACT1 as strong evidence that the “despised” chelation therapy is highly effective and supported by science as a treatment and preventative intervention against atherosclerotic CAD. Some even tried to use it to argue that chelation outperforms statins at preventing the progression of CAD. The promotion of TACT1 to justify their quackery aside, the question, of course, is what to do when the “priors” involved low quality, highly dubious evidence justifying the trial from quacks, political pressure from a powerful antivax Congressman who was also very much into alternative medicine, and a study with all the problems that I described above. Never mind all that though; equivocal results always seem to demand a followup trial, and that’s just what happened. Meet TACT2.
TACT2: A completely negative trial, as predicted
Given that TACT2’s results were reported as a talk at the at the late-breaking clinical trials session at the American College of Cardiology meeting earlier this month, I can’t do my usual deep dive into the paper, as, unlike the case when the results of TACT1 were first reported at a cardiology meeting, I don’t have the slide set. All I have are the reporting on the study and the summary on the College website. Basically, TACT2 was a randomized, multi-center, double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial of EDTA chelation in patients with diabetes and a history of prior myocardial infarction. The treatment involved 40 weekly intravenous infusions of 500 mL EDTA (n = 483) or saline/1.2% dextrose placebo (n = 476). The EDTA infusion included up to 3 grams of EDTA based on each subject’s renal function, and each arm was also randomized in a 1:1 fashion to receive an oral high-dose vitamin and mineral supplement or placebo, although the results of this latter part of the trial were not reported. (Not that I’m cynical or anything, but does anyone want to bet that the EDTA/vitamin cocktail will be positive versus placebo in some subgroup or other and that that result will be used to justify continuing to treat heart disease in certain patients with the EDTA/vitamin concoction? Nahhh. Couldn’t be. Right?)
The results, after the enrollment of 1,000 subjects showed after a median followup of 48 months:
The primary outcome, composite of time to all-cause death, MI, stroke, coronary revascularization, or hospitalization for unstable angina, for EDTA vs. placebo, was: hazard ratio (HR) 0.93 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.76-1.16), p = 0.53
Secondary outcomes for EDTA vs. placebo:
    • All-cause death: HR 0.96 (95% CI 0.71-1.30)
    • Change in median blood lead level from baseline: -5.5 vs. -0.6 µg/L, p
    • Change in median urine cadmium level from baseline: -0.04 vs. 0 µg/g creatinine, p = 0.15
Compliance with all 40 infusions, EDTA vs. placebo, was: 68% vs. 67%.
In other words, this was as negative as a negative study can be. TACT2 clearly shows that chelation therapy didn’t work to decrease progression of or complications from CVD in diabetic patients with a history of previous MI. The authors, however, just had to try to explain why their results were so resoundingly negative:
The original TACT trial demonstrated a modest reduction in death and cardiovascular events associated with EDTA, driven largely by lower rates of coronary revascularization. Given the historically contested reception to chelation therapy for atherosclerotic disease, TACT2 was designed to replicate its predecessor’s findings in patients with DM, who derived the greatest benefit compared with placebo in the original study. Surprisingly, no difference in clinical outcomes was observed in this cohort despite similar adherence over a similar follow-up period.
Note, however, his rather bland characterization of chelation therapy as “historically contested.” As I hope that you can see from my previous discussion, the reason that chelation therapy has been “historically contested” is, of course, because (1) there was no plausible scientific mechanism for it to cause the regression of atherosclerotic plaques and (2) the more rigorous existing evidence dating back six decades showed that it didn’t work on any objective measure used to assess CAD. Moreover, it was actually unsurprising that this study was completely negative. What was surprising was that TACT had produced a positive result. Again, those of us who had been following chelation and TACT, even that result wasn’t particularly surprising, as several of us were long predicting that TACT would produce a weakly positive but equivocal result, which is just what it did. None of this stopped the authors from speculating wildly even as they were forced to conclude that chelation is not indicated after MI:
The authors note that this may reflect a smaller potential treatment effect size as blood lead levels in the US and Canada have continued to decrease since the TACT cohort was studied and were even lower in the study cohort compared with contemporary population data. Moreover, a greater proportion of patients in TACT2 were not only taking statins or antiplatelet therapies but also sodium-glucose cotransporter-2 (SGLT2) inhibitors and glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor agonists, agents with proven cardiovascular benefits that were not available during TACT. The current findings therefore do not support chelation therapy for post-MI patients with DM. Given the outsized benefit originally seen with TACT in this subset further implies that chelation therapy is not indicated regardless of DM status after MI.
Once again, although there is—as Dr. Lamas likes to point out—evidence that elevated lead levels can increase the risk of atherosclerotic disease, there is not—and never has been—good evidence that decreasing lead levels does anything to treat atherosclerosis, but I do like the hand-waving that maybe their negative results are due to the fact that we now have better treatments for type II diabetes that also have cardiovascular benefits. Even if that were true, then maybe we should just abandon chelation entirely in favor of those drugs that actually work.
At this point, you might be thinking: Why are you being so harsh on Dr. Lamas? After all, TACT2 did ultimately conclude that chelation doesn’t work for and shouldn’t be used in diabetic patients with CAD and history of MI. True, but if you know the history of what happened after the results of TACT1 were reported, you can probably guess what happened after TACT2. Dr. Gervasio Lamas, MD, principal investigator of both TACT1 and TACT2, as well as chair of medicine at Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami, Florida, did his best spin to explain away the negative results:
Lamas noted that, in addition to the lower lead levels in the TACT2 population, patients in the second study also had more advanced diabetes and more severe associated health impacts than those in the first TACT trial, reducing the trial’s ability to meaningfully affect clinical outcomes.
He suggested, however, that the study’s findings in terms of overall lead reduction could still be relevant for informing health interventions in the majority of the world where lead exposure is more common.
“Our method of treatment was effective at reducing lead, even in patients starting with low lead levels, and it was safe,” Lamas said.
“In most countries outside of North America and western Europe, lead remains a serious cardiovascular and neurological problem,” he said. “This study may be more relevant to those areas of the world, but this is a hypothesis that requires further study.”
In other words, Dr. Lamas is still looking for a rationale for a followup study to a completely negative study done as a followup study to an equivocal trial, and Dr. Mandrola is credulous:
Lamas explained at the meeting that lead levels had dropped over time. One study had found that lead levels were 17 mcg/L back in the early 2000s. Now levels are about 11 mcg/dl.
This is a compelling explanation. Conditions change. We have seen previously effective therapies (aspirin, defibrillators, and post-MI beta-blockers) all lose their efficacy over time because the conditions they treat have become less severe.
Maybe, but not in this case. Again, one notes that no one has actually shown that decreasing lead levels in the blood leads to regression (or even stabilization) of atherosclerotic plaques in CAD. I will give Dr. Mandrola credit for recognizing one thing, though. The likely reason that TACT1 was positive was because of random chance and low statistical power, although he loses points big time for not knowing about all the problems with the trial, including its being carried out mostly at quack clinics, that likely lead to a false-positive signal. He also loses points for making the equivalent argument that TACT2 was negative for the same reason, as if the findings in TACT2 were equally likely to be false-negatives as the findings of TACT1 were to be false-positives.
Then Dr. Mandrola serves up a huge straw man:
The lack of a positive finding in TACT 2 likely closes the chapter on chelation to prevent atherosclerosis.
It also somewhat dampens our enthusiasm for heavy metals as a modifiable source of atherosclerosis. I added “somewhat” because lead levels were less over time.
I would not use the non-significance of TACT 2 to conclude that heavy metal exposure is fine. It is clearly not.
The main lessons here are humility and skepticism. Medical science is hard. We have made great progress. If TACT 1 had studied a new drug or appendage closure device, I am afraid we would have been too accepting.
If only! I only the negative finding in TACT2 would close the chapter on chelation therapy to prevent or treat atherosclerosis! I predict, given Dr. Lamas’ equivocating and Dr. Mandrola’s credulity towards that equivocating, that it will not, the most likely area of “further study” being overseas in underdeveloped countries, where lead exposure is higher. Moreover, no one—and I mean no one—is using the “non-significance of TACT 2 to conclude that heavy metal exposure is fine.” What we are saying is that no one, particularly chelationists, has ever shown that acutely lowering lead levels with chelation therapy treats or prevents atherosclerotic CAD.
As for the last part, I would argue Dr. Mandrola’s point a little differently. First, let me preface my different take on Dr. Mandrola’s point by referring to a couple of old posts, in which I likened ivermectin as a treatment for COVID-19 to acupuncture and used that analogy to argue that SBM isn’t just for “complementary and alternative medicine” or “integrative medicine.” Indeed, the widespread adoption of ineffective treatments for COVID-19, even in some academic medical centers, is rooted in the same problem with EBM that leads to RCTs for highly implausible alternative medicine modalities, such as acupuncture and homeopathy: the discounting—or lack of consideration altogether—of “priors,” as in prior probability based on consideration of the sum total of previous evidence, but in particular basic science that strongly concludes that a treatment cannot work. With homeopathy, this is an easy point to make, given that homeopathy involves diluting homeopathic remedies to the point where none of the starting material remains, leaving you with water or whatever diluent was used. With acupuncture, there is no evidence that meridians exist or that inserting needles in what are represented as meridians does anything specific for any disease. In the case of ivermectin, the concentration required in cell culture to inhibit SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19 is 50- to 100-fold higher than what can safely be achieved in the human bloodstream.
TACT1 and TACT2 illustrate this problem very well. In fact, I would argue that, unlike the case of ivermectin, which was being tested as a treatment for a novel virus and for which there was little evidence other than the in vitro cell culture work, the evidence base for chelation wasn’t just inadequate. It was strongly in favor of the conclusion that chelation doesn’t have any clinically meaningful effects preventing or treating CAD, which makes spending $30 million on TACT1 indefensible in the first place, never mind the additional $37 million that never would have been spent on TACT2 if TACT1 hadn’t been greenlighted in the first place. Looking at it that way, doing a few RCTs on ivermectin seems more forgivable than spending $30 million on TACT1. Also, one can’t help but note another parallel, that of ideologue politicians pushing for ivermectin and for chelation therapy. Quite simply, had there been no Rep. Dan Burton—whom ACAM described in its May 2000 newsletter as a “Wonderful ally”—pushing for TACT1, the trial never would have been funded.
Back to my different take on Dr. Mandrola’s observation. If chelation were a new drug or appendage closure device, TACT1 and TACT2 would never have happened. The reason is simple. Pharmaceutical and device companies are loathe to waste tens of millions of dollars to mount a large multicenter RCT of an intervention with a preclinical and clinical evidence base as weak-to-nonexistent as the evidence base that existed in 2000—no, in the 1960s—for EDTA-based chelation as a treatment for atherosclerosis. They abandon the development of such treatments as dead ends and shift their R&D dollars to other, more promising products in their developmental pipelines. (I like to point out that no pharmaceutical company would invest in a large phase 3 RCT of a drug like ivermectin that requires a dose that is at least 50-fold higher than what can safely be achieved in the human blood stream.) Unfortunately, since the formation of NCCAM (now the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, or NCCIH), the NIH has been all too willing to sink huge money into treatments with low to nonexistent “priors” based on the the existing preclinical evidence base for them. TACT1 and TACT2 are nothing more than some really spectacular evidence of how quackademic medicine has corrupted medical research.
I do hope that Dr. Mandrola is right about one thing. I keep hoping that TACT2 does finally close the chapter on chelation therapy as a treatment or preventative for CAD. Then I remember Dr. Lamas’ excuses and that the second part of the trial, in which groups were randomized to receive placebo or chelation ± the mineral and vitamin cocktail, has yet to be reported even at a cardiology meeting, and despair. Far from being a win for science, TACT1 and TACT2 show just how credulous academic medicine can be and how willing it is to spend huge sums of monehy to put patients at risk unnecessarily to test what is obviously quackery.

Son of (the unethical and unscientific) Trial To Assess Chelation Therapy rears its ugly head to the tune of $37 million
First, the NCCIH and NHLBI spend $30 million on a clinical trial of quackery for cardiovascular disease that produces predictably negative to at best equivocal results. Then that result, apparently, is enough to justify wasting another $37 million on a followup study—while dozens of other deserving studies go unfunded. Meanwhile STAT News lionizes the principal investigator of both trials as a brave persecuted maverick who’s just “following the science.”
David Gorski on December 28, 2016
Link

Quackademic medicine.
I didn’t invent the term. (Dr. R. W. Donnell did—nearly nine years ago.) However, I sure use it a lot, because it perfectly describes a phenomenon that has proliferated and metastasized throughout the body of academic medicine like the cancer it is. I like to think that, in my own way, I’ve popularized the word to describe this particular phenomenon. But what it this phenomenon? It is nothing less than the degradation of the scientific basis of medicine through the infiltration of pseudoscience and quackery into medical academia, with academic physicians who otherwise should know better embracing pseudoscience like reiki, distance healing homeopathy, acupuncture and most of the rest of traditional Chinese medicine, and studying them scientifically—and even teaching them to medical students as though they had validity. Never mind that, for many of these modalities (I’m talking to you, homeopathy and reiki), basic science considerations are sufficient to reject them as the quackery that they are. Worse, quackademic medicine taints what should be perfectly acceptable science-based modalities, such as nutrition, exercise, and lifestyle with the stench of quackery by association when it “rebrands” them as somehow being “alternative,” “complementary,” or “integrative.” Indeed, quackademic medicine was arguably the original “sin” that ultimately led to “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and now “integrative medicine” (the integration of quackery with medicine).
The history of how the NIH has funded well over $2 billion worth of dubious research through the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), which was recently renamed the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), has been recounted here and elsewhere many times. It’s not just NCCIH, either. The National Cancer Institute has an office, the Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine, with the most inappropriate acronym ever, OCCAM, funding and promoting CAM in cancer medicine with a budget as large as that of NCCIH’s.
TACT: The worst abomination of quackademic medicine
Many have been the abominations against science funded by NCCIH over its 25 year history, but from my perspective the very worst, the most egregious, the most unethical study ever funded by the NCCIH was the Trial To Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT). Basically, it was a large, multi-institution clinical trial to examine whether chelation therapy was a potentially useful treatment for coronary artery disease. Indeed, it’s one of the oldest topics covered by SBM. Indeed, SBM co-founder and former regular Kimball Atwood wrote extensively about TACT in our very first year of existence (e.g., how TACT was unethical, unscientific, and a waste of money). Before that, Kimball Atwood, Elizabeth Woeckner, Robert Baratz, and Wally Sampson wrote the definitive explanation why TACT was unjustified by science and totally unethical. Eventually I started paying more attention as well. Meanwhile, Dr. Donnell, the man himself who coined the term “quackademic medicine,” led his readers on a magical mystery tour of the quack clinics signing patients up for TACT.
TACT has clearly been the greatest triumph of quackademic medicine in the history of quackademic medicine thus far. It’s not just because quacks managed to persuade the then-NCCAM and then later the National Heart Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI) to spend over $30 million on this clinical trial to produce at best equivocal results that were completely underwhelming. Rather, it was because quacks managed to parlay those pathetic results into another, even more expensive, trial that will spend $37 million of taxpayer money to do a followup clinical trial examining the supposed “effect” of chelation therapy in diabetics with heart disease, the only subgroup for which the investigators of TACT could seemingly find an effect, or, as it has been called, Son of TACT.
All of this serves as background as to why I was so irritated and disappointed to see an article by journalist I’ve otherwise had no reason to find objectionable, Karen Weintraub (oops, maybe I was wrong before), entitled “For daring to study a discredited therapy, this doctor earned scorn — and a $37 million grant.” Can you say “false balance”? Sure, I knew you could.
False balance and a “brave maverick” doctor versus science
I was actually a bit reluctant to write about this article in my inimitable manner. The reason was the source: STAT News. I’ve already apparently completely alienated one reporter from STAT based on her reporting on Stanislaw Burzynski, and I hate to risk completely alienating another. However, sometimes, a blogger’s gotta do what a blogger’s gotta do, and, given how irritating and full of false balance this article is, I’ll take that risk.
Anyone who does any amount of writing knows that framing is everything, and that every article has to have a frame, a “spin” or point of view, if you will. In other words, there is no such thing as true “objectivity.” All a writer can hope for is to minimize his or her own personal biases. On the other hand, the obsessive fetishization of “balance” can lead to travesties like this article, which portrays Dr. Gervasio Lamas, the cardiologist who has been the principal investigator of TACT, as a “brave maverick doctor” whose only offense was following the evidence where it went, which is the sole reason why he’s being “persecuted” (i.e. ostracized). The problems start right from the beginning, with this framing:
The new heart patient asked Dr. Gervasio Lamas if he thought chelation therapy was worth a try. “Of course not!” the cardiologist replied emphatically. His Harvard training had taught him that alternative therapies were a waste of time and money, and potentially risky to boot. “I told him it was quackery.”
But Lamas went home that night unsure if he had given his patient the best medical advice. He looked up research on chelation therapy, which removes heavy metals from the body, and found very little data either supporting or contradicting the procedure.
Lamas was troubled by the idea that he had offered this man a medical opinion that wasn’t supported by science. And he decided to conduct a study himself. He had no idea what he was getting into.
Seventeen years later, his research into a therapy many of his colleagues consider bunk has earned him scorn and sideways glances at medical meetings. Some accuse him of wasting taxpayer money. But Lamas persevered — even briefly taking out a second mortgage on his house to help pay for a clinical trial.
Three years ago, he announced results of that $30 million study: Chelation was safe and potentially helpful. The conclusion shocked the mainstream medical world, including Lamas. After all, the procedure had been so discredited that doctors previously could lose their medical licenses for using it.
Actually Dr. Lamas was right the first time. Basically, TACT was a negative trial, when viewed critically.
I notice how Weintraub describes Dr. Lamas as having found “very little data either supporting or contradicting the procedure.” I’ll give you the translation of that: He didn’t find much in the way of clinical trials “supporting or contradicting” the procedure. However, if he had just looked a bit closer he would have seen that, even then, the existing evidence was very much like the evidence for acupuncture for various conditions. There were the occasional “positive” trials, but the preponderance of evidence was most consistent with there being no specific effect due to chelation therapy on cardiovascular disease above and beyond that of placebo effects. Moreover, the various concepts used to “explain” how chelation therapy “works” were unconvincing then and remain unconvincing now.
Indeed, the ever-shifting concepts of how chelation therapy supposedly works remind me a lot of the same sorts of ever-morphing explanations for how acupuncture supposedly works. For example, first there was the “roto-rooter” hypothesis, in which chelation proponents claimed that calcium was an integral part of the atherosclerotic plaque and that removing calcium would cause the plaques to “melt away.” Of course, many, if not most, plaques don’t contain calcium deposits, and in those that do calcium deposition occurs quite late in the pathological process. Then there was an even more nonsensical “explanation” that when ionic calcium was removed from serum by chelation, it was replaced by calcium from bone, which would then stimulate the parathyroid glands to secrete parathormone, which then promoted remineralization of bone. The really nonsensical claim was that the calcium for this bone remineralization came from the “gradual transfer” of calcium from hardened arterial tissue and plaque, which would then “soften” the arteries and cause plaques to disintegrate. Then, of course, there was the “free radical” concept because, of course there was, and, even more implausible, there evolved the concept that chelation therapy somehow prevented “mutations” that lead to atheromas and later atherosclerotic plaques. Never mind that atheroma formation is a chronic inflammatory process, not a process involving mutation of the vascular endothelial and smooth muscle cells. Moreover, in pretty much all cases, stoichiometry just doesn’t work out, and the bottom line is that chelation therapy is incredibly implausible. Not homeopathy-grade implausible, perhaps, but plenty implausible.
The token skeptic and how to dismiss him
In fairness, one can’t fault Weintraub for not going into detail about how implausible chelation therapy is. However, I can fault her for portraying Dr. Lamas as a brave iconoclast suffering for pure science, unafraid that his results seemingly buck the establishment and then basically dismiss critics. For example, Steve Salzberg is quoted thusly:
Now, he’s launching a second trial, with $37 million from the National Institutes of Health, to study chelation’s effect on diabetics with heart disease. That’s not sitting well with some scientists.
Steven L. Salzberg, director of the Center for Computational Biology at Johns Hopkins University, said it’s “just crazy” to do another trial. “There are better ways to use this money to study much more promising treatments of all sorts,” he said.
Salzberg, who writes the Fighting Pseudoscience blog on Forbes.com, said the history of science is littered with studies that began with good intentions or were conducted by nice people, but were still bad ideas. “There are many legitimate MDs who’ve come up with theories that were just wrong, but clung to them, despite all the evidence to the contrary,” Salzberg said. “I wouldn’t put them in jail, but I’m not going to give them $37 million.”
And dismissed by Weintraub thusly, with a blithe wave of Dr. Lamas’ “I’m just following the evidence” hand:
For his part, Lamas said he has learned to ignore the critics and just follows the evidence. If the study had shown chelation to be completely useless, he would have believed the results. So why shouldn’t he believe the data now?
That’s exactly the problem, though. Dr. Lamas doesn’t believe his own data. He spins his data as positive when, viewed critically, TACT was a negative trial and didn’t show what Lamas thought it did, which Weintraub described thusly:
The unveiling of results at a meeting in 2013 shocked everyone. A picture taken afterward shows a roomful of stunned faces. Chelation was safe, the study revealed. And it also seemed to be effective.
Overall, patients getting the active therapy had “modestly” fewer heart attacks and needed fewer bypass surgeries and hospitalizations for chest pain than those getting the saltwater placebo, according to the study, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association. When the researchers drilled down into their data, they realized that the patients who had both diabetes and heart disease saw all the benefits. Among the 633 test subjects with diabetes, there was a 41 percent reduction in cardiovascular events such as heart attacks, over as long as five years.
Not quite. TACT relied on a primary endpoint that was a composite of death, MI, stroke, coronary revascularization and hospitalization for angina. Now, I realize that other clinical trials of cardiovascular disease use composite endpoints, and no doubt TACT apologists will point that out. That doesn’t make it less of a problem. I find such composite endpoints to be highly dubious, particularly when they include something like hospitalization for angina. Death is a “hard” endpoint. You’re either dead or you’re not. MI (myocardial infarction) and stroke are “hard” endpoints. You’ve either had a stroke or MI or you haven’t. However, when composite endpoints are used, different confounding factors can be amplified, as González et al concluded:
The use of composite end points in cardiovascular trials is frequently complicated by large gradients in importance to patients and in magnitude of the effect of treatment across component end points. Higher event rates and larger treatment effects associated with less important components may result in misleading impressions of the impact of treatment.
Two elements of the composite endpoint used by Lamas, coronary revascularization and hospitalization, are subject to a great deal of clinical judgment in deciding who requires them. More problematic is the variation in usage of such interventions that has nothing to do with whether the treatment works or not. For instance, in the state of Michigan, there is up to a 2.4-fold variation in rates of percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI; i.e., angioplasty) between the highest use and lowest use areas. That’s just one state. Similar studies have shown wide variability in coronary revascularization rates just on geography alone. Adding such a variable to a composite endpoint is thus a bad idea on a scientific basis. At best, it adds unnecessary variability to the composite outcome measure for no useful benefit; at worse it adds significant bias, particularly if subjects being treated in academic centers, where patients are more likely to be referred for appropriate coronary revascularization interventions were in areas with significantly different PCI usage rates than areas where subjects being treated in “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) centers, where one might reasonably expect that referral for revascularization might be a bit less—shall we say?—expeditious (more on those centers later).
TACT: A recap of some of the reasons why it was bad science
Let’s step back a minute and show you how negative TACT really is. TACT had a 2 x 2 factorial design
    • Chelation plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement
    • Chelation placebo plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement
    • Chelation plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement placebo
    • Chelation placebo plus oral high dose vitamin and mineral supplement placebo
The regimen was described in detail in a 2012 publication. The vitamin supplements included doses ranging from 25% to 6,667% of the RDA for various vitamins. For example, the dose of vitamin C was 2,000% of the RDA; thiamin, 6,667%; and vitamin A, 500%. The first results of the trial were published in JAMA in 2013. The first thing we can eliminate is the high dose oral vitamin and mineral supplements. No matter how much the data were tortured, no positive result was seen from those arms of the study, either in any of the individual endpoints, the composite endpoint, or the quality of life measures.
As for the primary endpoint (i.e., the aggregated serious cardiovascular events), there was indeed a modest difference, namely 30% of placebo subjects versus 26.5% of the EDTA chelation subjects suffering an event (hazard ratio 0.82 for chelation). Unfortunately, as Dr. Atwood and I have noted before, the result was just barely statistically significant, p = 0.035, with the 99% confidence interval for the hazard ratio ranging from 0.69 to 0.99. (The predetermined level for statistical significance for purposes of this study was 0.036; so this is statistically significant by the barest margin.) More importantly, if you look at the individual endpoints that make up that aggregate, there was no statistically significant difference in death, myocardial infarction, stroke, coronary revascularization, and hospitalization for angina. Subgroup analysis (in fairness, preplanned) purported to show a much greater benefit for diabetics, with a hazard ratio of 0.61 (p=0.002), while patients without diabetes showed no statistically significant difference in any of the outcome measures, including the aggregated total bad outcomes.
One question that came up last time had to do with other ingredients in the chelation mixture, specifically procaine and heparin, either of which could conceivably have had an effect on cardiovascular outcomes, particularly when given over the course of months intravenously. Another question that came up was how there could have been a seemingly so much better outcome in diabetics. One notes that the placebo solution contained 1.2% glucose in order to match the osmolarities of the control and experimental solutions. That could conceivably have contributed to slightly worse outcomes in the control group even in the absence of a therapeutic effect due to chelation. Whatever the case, one notes that in nondiabetic patients there was no statistically significant detected benefit due to chelation therapy. Finally, only 65% of subjects finished all infusions, with only 76% finishing at least 30. That’s a high drop-out rate. Moreover, 17% withdrew consent, resulting in missing data. The investigators tried to correct for this in an online supplement, but these issues remain serious. They might not be so serious as to call into doubt the effect reported if there had been a much more convincing treatment effect, but when you get equivocal results such as this such issues loom much larger.
Again, I don’t necessarily expect a journalist to go into detail about these problems, given space considerations, but perhaps if she understood them better she might have understood that the problems with TACT were real and that criticisms of the trial weren’t just “conventional” doctors closing ranks but the result of very serious issues with the trial, its interpretation, and its sale to the public. Or maybe not. There’s no way of knowing now. What I do know is that this whole article frames Dr. Lamas as a skeptic who did nothing more than “follow the science,” even having started out trying to “disprove” chelation therapy. Personally, I call BS on that claim. No physician sinks a decade of his life into a project as large as a $30 million clinical trial solely for the purpose of proving that something doesn’t work, or, as Dr. Lamas is portrayed, hoping “chelation wasn’t dangerous” and wanting to “be able to tell patients with confidence that it was also a waste of their time and money.”
Weintraub does mention some of the problems with TACT, but almost in passing:
The trial faced repeated challenges, from an investigation into whether patients were adequately safeguarded against a treatment that conventional doctors considered dangerous to a public call for its abandonment from a group of fellow doctors.
These “challenges” went far beyond that. For example, one of the highest-accruing TACT sites was inspected by the FDA and garnered a Form 483 filed by the FDA at least as brutal as previous Form 483s filed on Stanislaw Burzynski. Here are some of the findings:
    • The investigators didn’t conduct the investigation in accordance with the signed statement and investigational plan. Several examples were given of shoddy procedures, prefilled forms, and failure to train personnel.
    • Failure to report promptly to the IRB all unanticipated problems involving risk to human subjects or others. Examples are given, including failure to report the deaths of patients on the study in a timely fashion (in one case the death wasn’t reported to the IRB until four months later; in another case it was never reported at all). In other cases, adverse event reports were not submitted to the IRB.
    • Failure to prepare or maintain adequate case histories with respect to observations and data pertinent to the investigation.
    • Investigational drug disposition records are not adequate with respect to dates, quantity, and use by subjects.
One of TACT’s critics, Dr. Steven Nissen, chairman of cardiovascular medicine at the Cleveland Clinic, is quoted criticizing both TACT and the new study, TACT 2. Remember what I said about the composite endpoint used? Dr. Nissen was even more critical at the time in an editorial in JAMA, where he noted that because he primary composite endpoint included “softer” endpoints and these softer endpoints represented 318 of the 483 events reported, ““if any unblinding occurred, investigator biases could potentially influence the decision to hospitalize or revascularize individual patients.” He then went on to point out why we should worry about unblinding:
Differential dropout in TACT suggests unmasking, but the problem of intentional unblinding is more concerning. The sponsors of the trial, the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), were unblinded throughout the trial. The National Institutes of Health policy unwisely allows the sponsor access to unblinded trial data, and both organizations sent observers to the closed sessions of the data monitoring committee. This gave them access to confidential data during each of the 11 interim analyses. The unblinding of the study sponsor represents a serious deviation from acceptable standards of conduct for supervision of clinical trials. If a pharmaceutical company sponsoring a trial were allowed access to actual outcome data during the study, there would be major objections. Like any sponsor, the NHLBI and NCCAM cannot be considered unbiased observers. These agencies made major financial commitments to the trial and may intentionally or inadvertently influence study conduct if inappropriately unblinded during the study.
That’s in addition to something in the TACT protocol first noted by, yes, Dr. R. W. Donnell over ten years ago, namely that the protocol is inadequate and that the blinding was probably not secure at many TACT sites, and there were many recruitment irregularities, including advertising that everyone gets chelation at some clinics.
STAT: Failing journalism this time
So let’s backtrack. What we have here is a study of a treatment that was correctly considered to be quackery that cost $30 million and produced at best a marginally significant result in one subgroup and at worst (and far more probably) a spurious result that could well have been due to bias. As a result of the incredibly flawed data from that trial, the federal government has greenlighted a new trial that not only uses the same flawed composite endpoint but is even worse in that it is a pragmatic trial, uses many of the same quack clinics to accrue patients, and will cost even more, $37 million. Now that would actually be a great story, but instead what we get is a human interest story about the principal investigator of both of these boondoggles that checks all the boxes. Not a believer at first? Check. Caring doctor? Check. Dedicated researcher? Check. Is just “following the science, no matter where it leads”? Check. Persecuted by his conventional medical colleagues? Check. I can see the pitch for a movie treatment of the story of TACT in the back of my mind already, and, not surprisingly, Weintraub is by no means the first to have spun Dr. Lamas’ story this way.
At one level, I can see the temptation to frame the story in this manner. After all, if someone were to pitch to me an idea for a story in which an expensive clinical trial of something widely derided as quackery had produced an unexpected “positive” result, I’d say, “Hmmm. That’s interesting.” The failure here is that that is not the story of TACT. The story of TACT is ideology triumphing over science to the tune of first $30 million and then $37 million to carry out unethical studies of an ineffective treatment. My spin on this story would be how, in this time of highly constrained research funding, spending $67 million to study quackery that, even if you take the results of TACT at face value, is completely ineffective in anyone other than diabetics with prior MIs and, if you are critical, is almost certainly ineffective in them too, is inexcusable, an unconscionable waste of funding that could have been used to study actual, important medical questions.
I’ll give Weintraub credit, though, for recognizing one thing correctly. Unfortunately, she also gets one thing wrong, too:
Despite the time, effort, and money, the initial trial hasn’t had much of an impact. Few mainstream doctors have changed their minds about chelation, and alternative medicine therapists apparently haven’t stopped using it in patients without diabetes — though the trial found essentially no benefit in the broader heart disease population.
At one level, that’s the way it should be. No single scientific study can be considered the truth. Findings must be repeated to be confirmed.
Well, yes and no. Yes, no single scientific study can be considered “the truth,” but, on the other hand, a large, negative clinical trial like TACT, even if viewed uncritically and taken at face value, should shut the door forever on the use of chelation therapy in non-diabetics, other than in research settings. It’s an easy prediction to make that, even if TACT2 is even more resoundingly negative than TACT was, few, if any, alternative practitioners will abandon the practice, because their practice is based on belief, not science.
I once predicted the results of TACT, long before the trial was finished, I predicted that it would be a largely negative trial but that there would be one seemingly “positive” result and that chelationists would latch on to that result to justify continuing to use chelation therapy and doing another trial. Given that TACT 2 is, like most sequels, worse than the original, I make the not-so-difficult prediction that the same sort of thing will happen here. The results will show a marginally statistically significant result in some subgroup or other (e.g., diabetics with previous MIs over the age of 70 or under the age of 50 or something like that) and will be completely negative for everyone else. A critical reading of the study results will be that it’s a negative trial, but chelation advocates will latch on to the even more narrow seemingly positive result than the one in TACT in order to justify another clinical trial, and the NCCIH and NHBLI will go along. Meanwhile, critics will be attacked as “shrill and brutish” ideologues unwilling to go where the science leads, just like what happened after TACT.
Rinse, lather, repeat.

   Bisphenol A in Plastics – Should We Worry?
Steven Novella 
Link
Bisphenol A (BPA) is a chemical used in the manufacture of hard plastics which can be found in a wide range of products, including baby bottles, plastic utensiles, and plastic food containers. It has been the focus of some controversy over its safety, and the resulting debate reveals much about how the current system deals with such issues.
The concern is that BPA can leech from plastic containers into the food or liquid it contains, and when consumed can have negative health effects. The debate is over how to interpret existing evidence about BPA safety, which gives conflicting results. Essentially it is a debate about how to weight different kinds of evidence, and where safety thresholds should be.
The Science of Toxins
Toxicity is always a function of dose. Anything is toxic at high enough dose, and safe at a low enough dose. Regulatory agencies concerned with protecting the public health, therefore, typically use scientific evidence to establish doses that are likely to cause toxicity in humans and then set safe levels of exposure significantly below that level to create a buffer of safety. But what kind of evidence is used?
The only evidence that is considered direct evidence of cause and effect between a putative toxin and a specific toxic effect are randomized blinded controlled clinical trials. This is why these types of trials are considered the best type of evidence – variables are controlled for as much as possible, and they are done in a prospective manner.
Randomized controlled trials are the mainstay of evaluating the possible toxic effects of therapies, like pharmaceuticals. However, these types of trials ethically cannot be done on humans simply to assess the toxicity of a substance that has no potential therapeutic benefit. For example, you cannot perform a study that randomizes people to smoke to see if smoking causes cancer.
Therefore we must rely upon other types of evidence – all of which are imperfect. And this is what leads to debate over the question of toxicity.
One type of data is from animal studies – essentially doing randomized, blinded, controlled studies using animals instead of humans. The advantage of these types of studies is that they control for variables and can make specific conclusions about cause and effect. The weakness is that they are in animals and not humans. While some animals may be biochemically and physiologically similar to humans, there are always differences.
A second type of evidence is physiological/biochemical – searching for a potential mechanism by which a substance might cause toxicity. If such mechanisms match the actual toxicity seen in test animals, then a cause and effect conclusion is strengthened. Also, this type of evidence might be used to measure human exposure, absorption, how efficiently the toxin is cleared from the body, and its effects on cells in a dish or test tube. The strength of this type of evidence is that it is very reductionist – we learn what the chemical actually does. The weakness is that effects on cells in a dish does not always predict the effects of chemicals in a living system.
The third type is epidemiological evidence. The strength of this evidence is that it deals with humans and can assess toxicity that has actually happened in the real world with real people. The weakness is that it can be used to establish correlation only, not causation. This is because exposure is not randomized. For example, if you correlate a toxin with a disease, does the toxin cause the disease, does the disease increase the exposure to the toxin, or does some third factor increase both toxin exposure and risk of the disease?
Despite the fact that no one form of evidence is perfect, a consistent picture can emerge that points very strongly to a specific toxin causing a specific disease. We can say with a high degree of confidence that cigarette smoking causes certain types of lung cancer.
We can build to this confidence by showing mechanisms of toxicity that match what is seen in animal studies and epidemiological studies. Further, we can use triangulation to see if multiple correlations all line up and point toward one causal hypothesis. For example, if duration of smoking also correlates with cancer risk, and quitting correlates with a subsequent decreased risk, and smoking unfiltered has a stronger correlation than filtered, etc. then smoking probably causes cancer. If all the correlations predicted by the hypothesis that smoking causes cancer turn out to be true, then that interpretation is probably the correct one.
Controversies arise when all the evidence does not point in one direction. Then we can get into endless fights over which kind of evidence is more compelling, or which studies were better designed. This fighting, however, is often constructive, allowing the scientific, medical, and regulatory communities to sort out a large and complex body of evidence and try to make a reasonable judgment.
BPA
What does the evidence for BPA show? The FDA (whose job it is to review such questions) recently made public their assessment of all the scientific evidence for the toxicity of BPA. Here is an excerpt from the executive summary from their draft report:
FDA estimates that BPA exposure from use in food contact materials in infants and adults is 2.42 µg/kg bw/day and 0.185 µg/kg bw/day, respectively. FDA has determined the appropriate no observed adverse effect level (NOAEL) for its assessment of BPA to be the NOAEL for systemic toxicity of 5 mg/kg bw/day (5000 µg/kg bw/day) derived from two multigenerational rodent studies. This NOAEL results in adequate margins of safety of approximately 2,000 and 27,000 for infants and adults, respectively. The data reviewed on highlighted endpoints, such as the prostate gland and developmental neural and behavioral toxicity, were insufficient to provide a basis to alter the NOAEL used to calculate the margins of safety. FDA has concluded that an adequate margin of safety exists for BPA at current levels of exposure from food contact uses.
The FDA primarily relied upon animal data for its conclusion, specifically deciding that this type of evidence is the most useful for the question of BPA.
The National Toxicology Program (NTP) disagreed with the FDA. They believe that scientific studies showing that BPA can have hormone-like effects in the human body (specifically mimicking the action of estrogen) should be given more weight. Reviewing the same data they came to a slightly different conclusion. NTP Associate Director John Bucher, Ph.D. summarized their findings in an NIH press release:
“There remains considerable uncertainty whether the changes seen in the animal studies are directly applicable to humans, and whether they would result in clear adverse health effects. But we have concluded that the possibility that BPA may affect human development cannot be dismissed.”
The regulatory agencies of other countries also differ on their assessments of the safety of BPA. Canada has decided to take steps to limit human exposure to BPA, starting with a ban on baby bottles with BPA. The purpose of the ban is to err on the side of safety.
Meanwhile, the European Union is at the other end of the spectrum, going as far as saying that the US (referring to the NTP report) and Canada are using bad science to create unwarranted fears about BPA. In a recent update to their policy on BPA they write:
The conclusions of the Panel are that after exposure to BPA the human body rapidly metabolises and eliminates the substance. This represents an important metabolic difference compared with rats. EFSA will continue to monitor closely scientific findings regarding BPA and any related health effects.
They are pointing out one of the weaknesses of rat studies – differences in metabolism – and arguing that rat studies showing there is a risk are therefore flawed, and we should be reassured by the fact that humans rapidly metabolize and eliminate BPA from the body.
New JAMA Article
One of the interesting aspects of such controversies is that the science is a moving target. This week an epidemiological study was published in JAMA looking at the levels of BPA in the urine of adults and comparing that to the incidence of several common diseases. Remember, this is correlation only and cannot, by itself, establish causation. What they found was:
Higher urinary BPA concentrations were associated with cardiovascular diagnoses in age-, sex-, and fully adjusted models (OR per 1-SD increase in BPA concentration, 1.39; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.18-1.63; P = .001 with full adjustment). Higher BPA concentrations were also associated with diabetes (OR per 1-SD increase in BPA concentration, 1.39; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.21-1.60; P < .001) but not with other studied common diseases.
This suggests that BPA exposure is associated with a higher risk of heart disease and diabetes. This is supported by mouse evidence suggesting that BPA can block the effects of a hormone that prevents obesity and diabetes.
Conclusion
What we have is a vigorous debate among various scientific agencies about the relative merits of animal, toxicological, and epidemiological evidence for the risks of human exposure to BPA. I find this all a healthy part of transparent science. Slowly, debating the evidence and performing further studies will get us closer to the truth with greater confidence.
Given the existing evidence I suspect that there are real but small effects from BPA at current human exposure. These effects may be too small to worry about, but (and here is where most agree) more research is necessary.
The question that cannot be answered just with scientific evidence is where we should draw the line in terms of guaranteeing safety. There is no such thing as absolute safety or zero risk. Everything entails some risk. Everything we eat, drink, wear, drive, touch, and use comes with some finite risk. Most reasonable people would agree that we should avoid excessive risks and not worry about trivial risks – but much of the world entails the gray zone in between these extremes.
Also – eliminating something like BPA is not without risk either. What will take its place, and is that safe? BPA is used because it is cost effective and there are advantages to the durable plastic that is used in many products. What will we lose if we give up this technology?
Canada may decide to err on the side of caution, while the EU is happy that the current margin of safety is adequate. These are judgment calls not entirely answered by scientific evidence alone.
But good science and transparent debate will inform these judgments. And they will be endless.

Massage Therapy rubs me the wrong way
Jann Bellamy on September 17, 2015
Link


Back in my days of practicing law, one of my escapes from reality was a good massage. It was a great treat, exchanging the high-octane atmosphere of the law office for the soothing music, subdued voices and pastel tones of the treatment room. I could have stayed on that table for hours.
Little did I know just how much an escape from reality massage therapy would soon become.
About 15 years ago, when I called to book an appointment with my favorite therapist, a recorded message offered something called “ray-kee” – at least, that is how it was pronounced. I assumed it was just a form of massage and didn’t think anything about it. Then, at one session, while my feet were being rubbed, my massage therapist – an RN, no less – suggested I would be surprised at how often a sore spot actually correlated with a medical problem. She was talking about reflexology, of course.
Fast forward a few years. A new massage therapist and a new location, this time a “health center” (actually, a gym) owned by a local hospital. The massage therapist inquired whether I’d like to try “cranial sacral therapy“. “What’s that?” I asked. “Oh,” she said, “it would be hard to explain.” (She got that right.) She then proceeded to inform me that she had actually used it in one of our sessions. This alerted me to the possibility that informed consent was not part of the massage therapy protocol.
A few more years went by. Another therapist (also an RN), another location. I was pleased with her because I thought she did a good job and she also taught me some simple stretching exercises. To my surprise, in one session, she started pressing on the space between my toes because, she said, it corresponded with the (something, something – I didn’t get this part) of my neck. Reflexology again. (Are they now teaching reflexology in nursing school? I am beginning to wonder.
By this time, I was a fully committed SBM poster. I had little tolerance for nonsense. I left and never came back.
I moved on. Still another massage therapist and another location, a day spa. I was getting along fine with their therapists until I came upon one who announced (not asked me for permission, but announced) that we were “going to try some polarity therapy,” (which I had never heard of; more on this later) and put some arnica on my upper back. As I was already on the table, I submitted. If she ever did the polarity therapy, I didn’t realize it.
Same spa, different therapist. (I didn’t schedule with the “polarity therapist” again.) Finally! A massage therapist who does, well, massage. Thank you, Lisa!
Why was this so hard? Scheduling a massage, once a happy refuge from stress and pain, had become a pain. And stressful, if clients must interview each potential therapist to rule out quackery.
Or were my experiences an aberration? Did I just happen to come across a few who on the fringes? As it turns out, no. Sadly, it seems the whole profession has become infiltrated with pseudoscience. Its associations, its schools, its continuing education, and what appears to be a good percentage of its practitioners embrace quack treatments. We’ll get to a number of examples below. But first, a word about regulation.
Regulation: public protection?
In the U.S., massage therapy is a regulated practice in all but 5 states, according to the Federation of Massage Therapy Boards. It administers a national licensing exam, the MBLEx, which is accepted by most of the states where massage is regulated. Each state requires a certain amount of education to become licensed as well annual continuing education (CE). Some schools are accredited by the Commission on Massage Therapy Accreditation (COMTA), which is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education as a specialized accrediting agency. Graduation from a COMTA-accredited institution is not required in all states, but attendance at an accredited school or program gives students access to federal student aid. COMTA is made up of practitioners and school educators (including two chiropractors) and administrators, plus a public member.
Organizations like the American Massage Therapy Association (AMTA) and the National Certification Board for Therapeutic Massage & Bodywork (NCBTMB), which also offers a “Board Certification,” approve CE courses. These courses are, in turn, accepted by the states as fulfilling CE requirements.
Sound familiar? To regular SBM readers, it should. We’ve discussed various aspects of this same closed-loop, fox-guards-the-henhouse regulatory system before with regard to naturopathy, chiropractic, and pseudomedicine. (And, over on SfSBM, registered dietitians). From what I can tell, none of these professions does a particularly good job of protecting the public from quackery, and massage is no exception.
What’s the evidence?
SBM’s own Paul Ingraham, himself a former massage therapist, has some excellent articles on massage on his website, Pain Science. I particularly recommend “Does Massage Therapy Work?” The take-away message I got was that a plain, Swedish massage will do you as much good (or more) than the fancy techniques, the good being relaxation (including a reduction in blood pressure) and possibly more transcendent benefits plus maybe some short term pain relief. Which is pretty much what I concluded from my own experience. Paul includes a frank assessment of the pseudoscience problem in his former profession in an Appendix: “Powerful Bullshit: quackery pollution in massage therapy.”
According to NCCIH, massage therapy “may” benefit certain types of pain and improve quality of life, and it can be relaxing and improve mood, although overall the evidence is preliminary and conflicting. The effects, NCCIH says, are short term, so you have to keep getting massage to sustain any improvement. It’s not cheap, either. As Paul points out, it costs about a buck a minute.
Massage’s purported beneficial effect on back pain just took a big hit with the publication, this month, of a Cochrane Review, concluding:
We have very little confidence that massage is an effective treatment for low back pain.
Questionable practices
Unfortunately, massage therapy has evolved (or, some might say, devolved) from a simple relaxation and short-term pain relief technique into a cornucopia of quackery that rivals naturopathy. There is no clear definition of what constitutes massage therapy and no taxonomy of practices. This creates a large tent under which many practices, unchallenged by science, can live harmoniously.
And they do.
(Here I’ll post a warning to my friend and colleague Mark Crislip: There’s a whole lot of loose talk about “energy” coming up next, and it could drive a physics major nuts.)
To illustrate just how deep into pseudoscience massage therapy has sunk, I’ve chosen a number of different practices from currently available continuing education courses, an accredited school and massage practitioners listed on the AMTA website. Note that none of these practices have any scientific plausibility whatsoever, yet a number make far-reaching claims about their ability to bestow actual therapeutic benefit on the client. (I apologize for the lengthy quotes, but I find it difficult to summarize gibberish. Plus, some are just laugh-out-loud funny.)
We begin with a course titled “Energy Introduction,” a sort of “Energy 101.” For reasons that will become obvious, I suggest that all massage therapists could benefit from learning the (alleged) differences between various “energy therapies.” It would also make a great Mitchell & Webb skit. [My comments are in brackets.]
Energy Introduction [CE course]
Unsure what the difference is between Reiki and crystal healing, or what chakras are all about? [I must confess that I am, indeed, confused about this very topic.] Maybe you struggle with how/when to best use your innate energy to help facilitate healing in others? Come discover how energy work may enlighten and simplify your practice by increasing revenue and minimizing your own fatigue as you introduce other service options (once properly trained in a specific energy modality). Note: This class will not include attunements of any kind [bummer!], but could involve chakra clearings or related exchanges.
The massage therapist can also learn, for school or continuing education credit:
The World at Your Feet: Foot Reflexology One Day Adventure [CE course]
It is simply amazing to see how the feet are a microcosm of the body! We will cover the history, mapping of the points, benefits, etc and of course correct technique to access the reflexology points.
Pranic Healing Level I [CE course]
Energetic anatomy: You will learn to work with the network of chakras, meridians and auras to accelerate the healing processes of your body.
Preventive healing: You will learn to remove the negative energetic patterns of a disease to prevent it from fully manifesting as a physical ailment.
    • Step-by-step techniques for ailments related to your:
    • respiratory system, e.g., asthma
    • circulatory system, e.g., heart ailments
    • gastrointestinal system, e.g., irritable bowel syndrome
    • musculoskeletal system, e.g., arthritis and back pain
    • reproductive system, e.g., menstrual problems
Cranial-Sacral Therapy Techniques [CE course]
CST works directly on the central nervous system to help speed healing to all parts of the body. . . It’s a great way to integrate your current tools and techniques with the [central nervous system], encouraging neuromuscular re-programming
Who can benefit from CST?
I’ve successfully used CST on kids with ADD, seniors with a variety of conditions, people of all ages with migraines and tension headaches, people at all stages of cancer, those suffering from anxiety or depression, infants with various disorders, people with back problems, people with advanced multiple sclerosis, professional athletes with pain or limited ROM, patients with brain injury, and much more – and I’ve seen dramatic, positive results!
Zero Balancing I & II [several CE courses; see, for example, here]
This was a new one on me, and a perfect example of how a promoter can fabricate a treatment and sell it to credulous clients and practitioners. Because there was only a brief description of the courses, I went to the website of the Zero Balancing Health Association (ZBHA). I learned there that ZBHA courses are not only approved in some states for massage therapists, but also for nurses, physical therapists, and acupuncturists.
Fritz Smith, MD created Zero Balancing in the early 1970s. It sounds to me like some sort of orthopedic energy therapy. Here’s how the ZBHA describes it:
. . . a powerful body-mind therapy that uses skilled touch to address the relationship between energy and structures of the body [using] finger pressure and gentle traction on areas of tension in the bones, joints and soft tissues to create fulcrums, or points of balance, around which the body can relax and reorganize . . . By addressing the deepest and densest tissues of the body along with soft tissue and energy fields . . . [it] helps to clear blocks in the body’s energy flow, amplify vitality and contribute to better postural alignment.
Ortho-Bionomy [500-hour course from the New Mexico Academy of Healing Arts, a COMTA-accredited school]
This was a new one to me also. For this, I had to go to the website of the Society for Ortho-Bionomy International. This technique, invented by a British osteopath,
. . . is a gentle, non-invasive, system of healing that reminds the body of its natural ability to restore balance. Its principles are based on a simple and profound philosophy: allow the body to correct itself . . . The body is stimulated using gentle movements, comfortable positioning, brief compression and subtle contact.
Polarity Therapy [CE course; polarity therapy also offered at New Mexico Academy of Healing Arts]
Developed by Dr. Randolph Stone, who had degrees in naturopathy, chiropractic and osteopathy.
The class introduces concepts of energy medicine through Polarity therapy theory and explores how to explain “energy work” in western terminology. Learn how to use affirmations and energy exercises from Polarity tradition . . . Polarity Therapy is a unique blend of bodywork, exercise and self-awareness that works with the human energy field. Polarity Therapy bodywork uses specific contact points to help balance and stimulate the body’s electromagnetic fields.
So far, we’ve covered energy, reflexology, Pranic healing, cranial-sacral therapy, zero balancing, ortho-bionomy and polarity therapy. Unfortunately, that’s not the end of it. Here are a few more treatments I found advertised by numerous practicing massage therapists listed on the AMTA website:
Amma Therapy [Yet another new one for me]. An “extremely specialized form of massage therapy rooted in a philosophy based on Taoism.” Instead of inserting acupuncture into “the energy pathway to stimulate and move the energy” the therapist uses her hands.
Acupressure: physical pressure applied to acupuncture points by the hand, elbow, or with various devices.
Reiki: a form of “energy healing,” “laying on of hands” that purports to transfer “life energy” to the client.
Structural integration: a/k/a “Rolfing.” Posits that muscles hold a memory of an incident in a particular part of the body. Therapist adjusts the massage technique when she detects “energy imbalance” to effect an “energetic release” which restores the flow of “vital energy.”
Oriental bodywork: “the treatment of the human body/mind/spirit, including the electromagnetic or energetic field which surrounds, infuses and brings that body to life, by using pressure and/or manipulation.”
Conclusion: Vitalism by any other name
As best I can tell, all of these practices boil down to pretty much the same thing: all are a variation on vitalism, the long-discredited, pre-scientific notion that there is some incorporeal force that governs your bodily functions. When this force is “unbalanced,” you get sick. When the therapist re-balances your force, you get well. The massage therapy profession has worked hard to escape its reputation as a cover for that oldest profession, prostitution. But I wonder if too many of them have simply transitioned to another form of prostitution: shilling for pseudoscience in the name of an improved bottom line.

   Massage for AIDS
Harriet Hall
Link
I recently learned of a study entitled “Dominican Children with HIV not Receiving Antiretrovirals: Massage Therapy Influences their Behavior and Development.” It disturbed me, and I couldn’t get it out of my head. They’re massaging these kids but letting them die of AIDS? I went back and read the complete article, and it left me even more disturbed.
They studied 48 Dominican children ages 2-8 with untreated HIV/IDS, randomizing them to receive twice weekly sessions of either massage or play therapy for 12 weeks. The abstract said that those in the massage group improved in self-help abilities and communication, and that children over the age of 6 showed a decrease in depressive/anxious behaviors and negative thoughts. That’s what the abstract said. The text revealed a more complex story.
One thing that may be irrelevant but that bothered me: there were several errors that should have been caught by an editor, a proofreader, a peer reviewer, or even a spell-checker:
• Caribbean was spelled “Carribean,”
• “…for enhancing varying behavioral and developmental domains” (I have no idea what this means).
• “A second objective of our work was to determine the absence of antiretroviral treatment on the impact of HIV infected Dominican children’s mood and behavior.” (I have trouble even guessing what they meant to say here.)
• “in helping reducing” instead of “in helping reduce”
• “interesting” where it should say “interestingly”
• The abstract referred to 20 minute sessions, but the text said 30 minutes.
When a journal overlooks errors like these, I always wonder if they’ve overlooked more serious errors of science or logic. In this case, it appears that they did.
Introduction.
The introduction usually provides a brief review of the literature and explains the rationale for doing the study. In this case, the rationale was not clear. They seemed to make two main claims for massage: enhancement of immune function and psychological/developmental effects. This study was not designed to assess immune function, but it suggested that improved immune function would improve psychological/developmental outcomes; in fact, it speculated about possible mechanisms for this.
They stated as a fact that massage improves immune function; they failed to acknowledge that the evidence is mixed. Some studies have shown an increase in certain parameters like natural killer cell counts, others have shown no benefits, like this study and this one involving HIV patients.
No study has shown that massage produces any objective improvement in outcome for HIV/AIDS patients.
There is research showing that massage improves outcome for premature babies, but a Cochrane review concluded, “Evidence that massage for preterm infants is of benefit for developmental outcomes is weak and does not warrant wider use of preterm infant massage.” Another Cochrane review of normal infants concluded, “The only evidence of a significant impact of massage on growth was obtained from a group of studies regarded to be at high risk of bias.”
Their stated hypothesis was “that Dominican pre-school age children infected with HIV would show improved mood, fewer behavioral problems, and enhanced development following massage therapy.” I don’t think they made a good case that such a hypothesis was plausible.
Methods
Each child had 30 minutes of one-on-one interaction with a trained nurse, who either administered a standardized massage protocol or the play therapy protocol, which consisted of giving the child a choice of coloring/drawing, playing with blocks, playing cards, or reading children’s books. Parents were present throughout, and they were interviewed to score the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) and Developmental Profile (DP-II).
Results
On the CBCL, on the empirically based scales used to evaluate children under the age of 5, there were no significant differences between the massage and the play groups. (The scales include emotionally reactive, anxious/depressed, somatic complaints, withdrawn, attention problems, aggressive behaviors, other problems and sleep problems.)
For children over the age of 6, they reported “significant” improvements for the massage group in
• anxious/depressed behaviors (p = .026)
• negative thoughts (p=0.059)
• overall internalizing scores (p=0.02)
Note that p=0.059 is above the usual cutoff of p=0.05 and would be reported as not significant by most researchers.
Their definition of significance seems to vary with whether it supports their hypothesis or not. Interestingly, 100% of the children in the play group showed an increase in their score on rule breaking behaviors, significant at a p=<0.05 level. Interestingly, the researchers commented that this significant change “was not clinically meaningful.”(!?)
They characterized a change in IQ data as “marginally significant” for the massage group at p=0.07. Most researchers would simply call anything over p=0.05 not significant.
They only provide part of the data. They do not explain that this checklist involves 8 “syndrome” scores and 3 general scores (total, externalizing and internalizing). So presumably there was no significant difference for 2 of the 3 overall scores, and for the 8 syndrome scores they did not report a significant change in 6, and reported a significant improvement in one and a significant loss in another, which sort of cancelled each other out. Not very impressive.
On the DP-II developmental profile, five areas are assessed: physical, self-help, social, academic, and communication. The massage group showed significant improvements in self-help and communication. The play group showed a significant improvement in social development, while the massage group showed a significant decrease in social development. There were no significant differences in the physical or academic scores. If you add up all the gains and losses on their bar graph (figure 1), it looks like a gain of about 8 points for the massage group compared to a gain of 9 for the play group. It may not be statistically legitimate to draw any conclusions from adding all 5 together, but I’m not sure the inferences the authors draw are legitimate either.
All in all, I don’t find their data very compelling, especially since it is based on subjective caregiver reports and the caregivers were not only not blinded but were present for all the treatment sessions.
Discussion
They interpreted their data to mean that “massage therapy was effective in reducing maladaptive internalizing behaviors in children aged 6 and older” and that “children 2-8 years of age who received massage demonstrated enhanced self-help and communication skills.” They found it “interesting” that children in the massage group remained at the same social developmental level, suggesting that it was because those children had little or no play activity at home. (Did they? We don’t know.)
They were “puzzled” by their failure to find any effect on behaviors in the under-5 age group because they were so sure massage therapy improves children’s moods and anxiety levels. They tried to rationalize what might have gone wrong.
They commented that “anecdotally, the nurses who conducted the massages reported changes in the children over time, including better mood.”
Their whole discussion gave the impression that they believed in massage and were trying to make it look as good as possible given their marginal data.
They recommended massage therapy as a cost-effective option to improve symptoms and functioning in children with untreated HIV.
What Does This Mean?
The whole idea of treating these children with massage in lieu of drugs is abhorrent. These are children who are going to die, children whose lives might be saved with modern medical treatment. Instead of saving their lives, these researchers propose to give them a cheaper treatment (massage) that at best can only hope to produce small short-term improvements. It is demeaning to these children to treat them like second-class citizens and just accept that they will continue to be denied effective treatment. I won’t call it racism, but some might. At the very least it reminds me of Val Jones’ newly coined “shruggies.” Not our problem. Not in our job description. These kids are doomed, but we can tell their parents to massage them. Massage is good.
They observed that AIDS patients treated with antiretroviral drugs show improvements in cognitive and affective symptoms. They speculate that since the drugs improve immune function, they reduce physical symptoms and improve quality of life, thereby attenuating the psychological impairments caused by the disease. Alternative medicine advocates frequently accuse scientific medicine of treating the symptoms instead of the disease. Here’s a case where science addresses the underlying cause (the HIV virus) whereas massage therapy only attempts to address secondary factors (symptoms and possibly immune function). Even if their premise that massage improves immune function is correct, massage is surely not a very effective way to achieve that.
If this study accomplished anything, it was to highlight the plight of these children who are dying and who need not die. It got full ethical approval from the Institutional Review Board, but was it really ethical? Was this study really justified? Was it designed to improve the lives of these children, or were they used as guinea pigs for massage advocates seeking to justify what they believe in and like to do?
This study reminds us that all children need human interaction, play, touch, and TLC. It does nothing to convince me that massage is a useful therapeutic tool beyond the feel-good and human-interaction effects. It certainly does nothing to justify using massage as an alternative to life-saving anti-AIDS drugs.
The money that was spent on this research might have saved lives if it had been spent instead on getting antiretroviral drugs to these unfortunate children. I know it was not a choice between those two options, but I think it must have been very difficult to stand by and see a child get a research-funded massage knowing that you could have spared the money from your own salary to save that child’s life. I wonder if the researchers have nightmares.
REFERENCE:
M. Hernandez-Reif, G. Shor-Posner, J. Baez, S. Soto, R. Mendoza, R. Castillo, N. Quintero, E. Perez, G. Zhang (2006). Dominican Children with HIV not Receiving Antiretrovirals: Massage Therapy Influences their Behavior and Development Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 5 (3), 345-354 DOI: 10.1093/ecam/nem032

   Personalized Medicine

   Personalized Medicine Bait and Switch
Steven Novella
Link
Mark Hyman, a proponent of so-called “functional medicine” promoting himself over at the Huffington Post (an online news source that essentially allows dubious medical infomercials to pass as news) has posted a particularly egregious article on personalized medicine for dementia. In the article Hyman distorts the modern practice of medicine, the current state of genetic science, and the very notion of “disease.” It is, as usual, a fine piece of medical propaganda sure to confuse many a reader.
Hyman starts with some standard epidemiology of dementia – it is a common and growing disorder – but then descends quickly into distortion and pseudoscience.
Conventional Medicine Strawman.
Hyman creates what readers are likely to recognize by now as the standard straw man of conventional or science-based medicine, and then uses that caricature to create a false dichotomy with his “functional” medicine. He writes:
But first I want to explain why just naming a disease — whether it is dementia or anything else — is becoming increasingly unhelpful (unless you just want to match the drug to the disease which is the only thing doctors are trained to do).
and
In fact, disease and diagnosis as we know it will soon be an obsolete concept, an artifact of medical history, like bloodletting or phrenology (the art of diagnosis based on the shape of your skull, popular in the 19th century). The reason is simply this: Naming a disease does nothing to help us identify and treat the underlying causes of the disease. We must address these causes if we have any hope of helping individuals heal.
As a neurologist who treats dementia, his straw man is more than a bit offensive. Hyman does not seem qualified, if his writings and videos are any indication, to offer an opinion on medical training. Hyman would have you believe that the science-based approach is going the way of bloodletting. But what he is really indicating is that he does not understand the label of dementia, the concept of disease, or the complex relationship between science and medical practice.
What is a disease?
Hyman uses the term “dementia” quite loosely in his article, so let me explain what we actually mean by this term. Dementia is a clinical syndrome (not a disease) – it is the term applied to a condition of chronic cognitive impairment, regardless of cause.
On the other hand, Alzheimer’s disease is a specific disease – a pathophysiological entity with specific changes to the brain on biopsy and markers in the blood and spinal fluid (although at present only biopsy is useful for diagnosis).
When a patient presents with dementia (actually they present with cognitive symptoms and are diagnosed with dementia based upon history and exam, distinguishing it from other entities, like delirium, psychosis, or specific disorders like language dysfunction) the first order of business is to rule out treatable or reversible forms. This may include depression, medication side effects, nutritional deficiencies, anatomical lesions, strokes, inflammatory diseases, toxicities, and other causes. This is done by history, physical, MRI scan of the brain, EEG, and blood tests.
If an underlying treatable cause is found, it is treated. Patients may then stabilize, improve, and even be entirely cured, depending on the cause and if any permanent damage has already occurred.
If the workup for reversible causes is negative then the patient is not given the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease – rather they are diagnosed with an Alzheimer’s-like dementia, or a related but still irreversible cause of dementia.
It is true that simply attaching a label to a syndrome does not necessarily lead to effective treatment or even better understanding, as I have pointed out myself previously. In fact, some syndrome labels are over-used. But the same is not true of a genuine disease label – a diagnosis that carries with it a host of information about epidemiology, risk factors, underlying causes, genetic predispositions, and treatment outcomes.
Hyman hopelessly confuses these two situations, demonstrating a profound lack of understanding of how medical thinking has progressed over the last couple of centuries. Hyman demonstrates his confusion by using the term “dementia” as if it were interchangeable with “Alzheimer’s disease.” He writes:
“There is no effective known treatment for dementia.”
This statement is flawed on many levels. Some dementias are treatable, even curable, if the cause is reversible. It is true there is no cure for Alzheimer’s disease, and no disease-modifying treatment, but there are treatments. Currently available treatments for Alzheimer’s disease, however, are symptomatic only – they improve function but do not alter the course of the disease. Hyman’s sloppy language reflects his sloppy thinking, the likely result is that his readers will end up as confused as he appears to be.
Hyman’s Anecdotes
Hyman’s article goes from bad to worse – after distorting the current state of neuroscience and medical practice regarding dementia, his infomercial for his own idiosyncratic methods begins. He offers, of course, just anecdotes – two patients whom he treated and who we are told improved.
Of course, we are given no information to confirm a diagnosis. Since Hyman appears not to know the difference between dementia and Alzheimer’s disease, it is quite possible that either or both of these patients had a reversible cause of dementia, and their improvement may or may not have had anything to do with his ministrations. But they are useless as evidence for any superiority of Hyman’s approach to the science-based approach.
For example – despite the fact that Hyman would have you believe my training was restricted to pharmacotherapy, I routinely will check patients who present with dementia for folate and vitamin B12 deficiency (this is standard practice). In addition I check homocysteine and methylmalonic acid levels, because these markers may be elevated even with low normal levels of folate and B12. If this blood work indicates a functional deficiency of either vitamin, then I supplement and monitor the blood work to see how they respond.
This is the evidence-based approach. Scientific doctors are good at asking meaningful questions and then doing research to answer them. Is the B12 and folate level enough? Turns out, the other metabolic markers may be a more sensitive indicator of a relative deficiency. Should we treat every dementia patient with folate and or B12? Turns out, there is no clinical response to routine treatment – so treatment should be targeted at those with a documented deficiency.
Gurus like Hyman, however, are not evidence-based. Rather, in my opinion, they seem to search for any tenuous evidence to support their philosophy or marketing strategy and then make huge hand-waving extrapolations from the evidence to their practice. Hyman, for example, writes:
George had another gene called MTHFR(viii) that made him require very high doses of folate to lower his blood levels of homocysteine, which is a substance very toxic to the brain.
This is part of his genetic “personalized medicine” marketing. But what I described above is true personalized medicine – using markers that have been shown to be useful in individualizing treatment – who needs folic acid and who doesn’t.
But looking at genes sounds more cutting edge – better for marketing. Hyman seems to be cherry picking the evidence. At present there is inconclusive evidence linking the MTHFR gene to an increased risk of dementia in the elderly, and a recent large study showed:
MTHFR genotypes or alleles also did not show any correlation (with dementia).
But worse, Hyman confuses the role of risk factors, markers for diagnosis, and markers for treatment. Some genotypes correlate with an increased risk of developing a disease, but are not helpful in diagnosis. Other genes are useful in diagnosis, but only some of these genes are useful in predicting outcome to specific treatments.
Now, it is true that we hope one day to usher in a phase of medicine where we use genetic testing to tailor our treatments. This is theoretically possible, and we are making progress, but we are not there yet. Just as we hope one day to cure many diseases with stem cells, but I would not pay to go overseas to a stem cell clinic today.
Hyman is misusing current research to determine treatment – but this is simply not evidence-based. It is not “functional” medicine, it is bad medicine. Science-based doctors want to know what markers actually mean – and for treatments that means they need to be tied to treatment outcomes. None of the studies Hyman references actually support the genetics-based treatment decisions he is advocating.
I would also point out that he mixes in some advice that is based on evidence, but that is already part of standard evidence-based practice (or is being incorporated in response to published evidence). For example, here is a study which concludes:
CONCLUSION: Vegetables, unsaturated fats, and a high MeDi score may be beneficial to cognitive function.
MeDi is short for a Mediterranean diet. The evidences shows decreased risk and better long term outcomes for patients who eat plenty of vegetables, have low saturated fats, and generally eat a Mediterranean diet (which has lots of vegetables and low saturated fats). This is a generally healthful diet in many ways – and we don’t need to test your genes to recommend it.
Hyman also recommends exercise – and there is evidence that exercise reduces risk and improves outcome in vascular dementia and other dementias. So that is also part of conventional treatment. I wonder who Hyman thinks is doing all these studies on diet and exercise, since he believes physician training only includes matching drugs to diseases.
Conclusion
Science-based medicine includes many modalities of intervention, including diet, targeted supplementation, exercise, risk modification, symptomatic treatment, and where possible disease modification. The research on any particular medical topic, like dementia, is very deep and nuanced and requires understanding of the complex relationship between syndrome, disorders and diseases, the relationship between biomarkers and pathophysiology, the differences among markers for risk, diagnosis, and treatment outcomes, and the types of evidence that are useful in determining which treatments work and are appropriate for specific patients.
Mark Hyman, in advocating for his “functional” medicine, appears to understand none of this. Instead he whitewashes over all this complexity and would have his readers believe that science-based practitioners take a simplistic knee-jerk pharmacological approach to all patients. The evidence clearly puts the lie to this caricature.
Meanwhile he himself takes what appears to be an overly simplistic approach – extrapolating tenuously and inappropriately from various different kinds of evidence to ultimate treatment decisions. Specifically in this essay he abuses preliminary evidence on the relationship between various genetic markers and disease risk factors to give the illusion of personalized medicine – prematurely declaring the death of the indispensable notion of “disease.”
He seems to have failed to notice that the very evidence he is citing is often closely tied to, or even dependent upon, the concept of a pathophysiological disease.
He further borrows from legitimate science in order to argue for the inadequacy of the scientific tradition that created the evidence in the first place. We know about the legitimate benefits of exercise and a healthful diet because of science-based medicine – not the slick marketing of self-promoting gurus.

   Hope and hype in genomics and “personalized medicine”
David Gorski 
Link
“Personalized medicine.” You’ve probably heard the term. It’s a bit of a buzzword these days and refers to a vision of future medicine in which therapies are much more tightly tailored to individual patients than they currently are. That’s not to say that as physicians we haven’t practiced personalized medicine before; certainly we have. However it has only been in the last decade or so that our understanding of genomics, systems biology, and cell signaling have evolved to the point where the vision of personalized medicine based on each patient’s genome and biology might be achievable within my lifetime.
I was thinking about personalized medicine recently because of the confluence of several events. First, I remembered a post I wrote late last year about integrating patient values and experience into the decision process regarding treatment plans. Second, a couple of months ago, Skeptical Inquirer published an execrably nihilistic article by Dr. Reynold Spector in Skeptical Inquirer in which he declared personalized medicine to be one of his “seven deadly medical hypotheses,” even though he never actually demonstrated why it is deadly or that it’s even really a hypothesis. Come to think of it, with maybe–and I’m being very generous here–one exception, that pretty much describes all of Dr. Spector’s “seven deadly medical hypotheses”: Each is either not a hypothesis, not deadly, or is neither of the two. Third, this time last week I was attending the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) meeting in Orlando. I don’t really like Orlando much (if you’re not into Disney and tourist traps, it’s not the greatest town to hang out in for four days), but I do love me some good cancer science. One thing that was immediately apparent to me from the first sessions on Sunday and perusing the educational sessions on Saturday was that currently the primary wave in cancer research is all about harnessing the advances in genomics, proteomics, metabolomics, and systems and computational biology, as well as the technologies such as next generation sequencing (NGS) techniques to understand the biology of each cancer and thereby target therapies more closely to what biological abnormalities drive each cancer. You can get an idea of this from the promotional video the AACR played between its plenary sessions:
Which is actually a fairly good short, optimistic version of my post Why haven’t we cured cancer yet? As I mentioned before, with this year being the 40th anniversary of the National Cancer Act, as December approaches expect a lot of articles and press stories asking that very question, and I’m sure this won’t be the last time I write about this this year.
““Personalized medicine” in CAM
In the meantime, before I discuss a couple of examples of how science-based medicine is moving ever more closely to personalized medicine, I can’t help but note that part of what inspired this bit of my typical blather on this topic was sitting in the audience at AACR hearing about all these tour de force genomic analyses that begin to reveal the individuality and complexity of tumors, and, more importantly, to suggest strategies to target the specific abnormalities that drive the growth and metastasis of each cancer and contrasting in my mind the claims of “personalized” or “individualized” medicine that practitioners of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and “integrative medicine” (IM) like to make. As I pointed out about a year ago, “individualized” treatment in CAM-world basically means “making it up as you go along.” Consider, for example, homeopathy, which postulates prescientific ideas for the cause of disease, claiming that “like cures like,” and then using unscientific “provings” to determine which remedies can be used to “treat” each condition. Never mind that homeopathy is water (does it really need to be repeated?), consisting of remedies serially diluted and succussed so many times that in many of them it is highly unlikely that there is a single molecule of remedy left in the concoction. Not only that, but one of the most popular homeopathic remedies for flu consists of basically the ground-up liver and heart of a Muscovy duck.
In CAM-world, “personalization” or “individualization” means “making it up as you go along.” A good example of this is a post on that wretched hive of scum and quackery, The Huffington Post, by Dr. Mark Hyman, he of “functional medicine” fame, where, under a section entitled “Treating individuals, not diseases” he writes:
There is no effective known treatment for dementia. But we do know a lot about what affects brain function and brain aging: our nutrition, inflammation, environmental toxins, stress, exercise, and deficiencies of hormones, vitamins, and omega-3 fats.
It is not just one gene, but the interaction between many genes and the environment that puts someone at risk for a chronic disease such as dementia. And we know that many things affect how our genes function — our diet, vitamins and minerals, toxins, allergens, stress, lack of sleep and exercise, and more.
Hyman then goes on to describe an anecdote of a man with developing dementia. Typical of many CAM doctors, Dr. Hyman chased down all sorts of “abnormalities,” prescribed all sorts of supplements to “fix” those abnormalities, and subjected the man to various “detox” regimens, including unspecified “medications that helped him overcome his genetic difficulties by getting rid of toxins.” As Steve Novella pointed out at the time, in reality what Dr. Hyman was doing was a “bait and switch,” in which he extrapolates from preliminary results in real science and uses them to come up with proposed treatments that have not been validated for the purposes that he uses them for. His evidence for success? Not science, not clinical trials, not even preclinical data, that’s for sure. Instead Dr. Hyman presents a couple of anecdotes.
Indeed, much of this sort of “making it up as you go along” is on full display in the anti-vaccine movement. Indeed, the anti-vaccine crank blog Age of Autism has numerous examples of just this sort of “personalization,” including the hijacking of mitochondrial disorders as a predisposing factor for “vaccine injury” causing autism, the serial use of all manner of “biomedical quackery” to “recover” their children, up to and including stem cells, and de facto unethical experimentation on autistic children. Be it chelation therapy, supplements, hyperbaric oxygen, dubious stem cell therapies, and other quackery, the anti-vaccine movement, “biomedical” quacks “individualize” their treatments to each autistic children, using dubious labs like Doctor’s Data to come up with lab abnormalities to “treat.” Of course, there is a fundamental disconnect between the claims of DAN! doctors to “individualize” therapy to each patient with their unwavering belief that vaccines cause autism. No matter how much they try to hide it, vaccines remain The One True Cause of the conditions known as autism and autism spectrum disorders.
There are many, many more examples of this kind of “personalization” of medicine in CAM based on either no science or unjustified extrapolation from existing science, dubious lab tests, practitioner biases, and a veritable panoply of One True Causes of disease. So let’s contrast with evolving personalized medicine in science-based medicine.
Personalized medicine in SBM
Because I’m a cancer researcher and surgeon, I find that currently the most promising examples of how genomics can contribute to personalized medicine come from cancer. This should not be surprising, because cancer is not one disease. It’s hundreds, perhaps thousands, of diseases, and even cancers arising from the same cells in the same organ can have very different biology. Basically, as I put it before, stealing liberally from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, Cancer is complicated. You just won’t believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly complicated it is. I mean, you may think it’s complicated to understand basic cell biology, but that’s just peanuts to cancer. This point was driven home in the AACR video above, and I see it driven home with each new study of cancer genomics or heterogeneity that comes out in high impact journals every month.
For example, couple of months ago, I described a tour de force study of changes that occur in the genome of prostate cancer cells compared to normal prostate. The study demonstrated a number of alterations in the genome affecting molecular pathways that drive growth and metastasis and that could potentially be targeted for therapy. Then, not long before going to the AACR meeting, I came across this article in my news feed, Lung Cancer Evolves With Treatment, Study Finds, which refers to this study from Harvard by Sequist et al, Genotypic and Histological Evolution of Lung Cancers Acquiring Resistance to EGFR Inhibitors. The study itself demonstrates something we’ve known for quite some time, which is that tumor cells evolve under selection by various modalities used to treat them. In this case, the authors studied how non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) evolves resistance under treatment with drug therapy targeted to the specific mutation driving their growth. In this case, the gene in which mutations result in its being turned on is the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), and the targeted therapy consists of inhibitors of EGFR such as gefitinib (brand name: Iressa) or erlotinib (brand name: Tarceva). Basically, the investigators subjected tumor tissue from patients who had developed resistance to EGFR tyrosine kinase inhibitors to systematic genetic and histological analysis. What they found represented a confirmation of some known genetic changes that occur to result in resistance but also some unexpected changes, including:
All drug-resistant tumors retained their original activating EGFR mutations, and some acquired known mechanisms of resistance including the EGFR T790M mutation or MET gene amplification. Some resistant cancers showed unexpected genetic changes including EGFR amplification and mutations in the PIK3CA gene, whereas others underwent a pronounced epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition. Surprisingly, five resistant tumors (14%) transformed from NSCLC into small cell lung cancer (SCLC) and were sensitive to standard SCLC treatments. In three patients, serial biopsies revealed that genetic mechanisms of resistance were lost in the absence of the continued selective pressure of EGFR inhibitor treatment, and such cancers were sensitive to a second round of treatment with EGFR inhibitors. Collectively, these results deepen our understanding of resistance to EGFR inhibitors and underscore the importance of repeatedly assessing cancers throughout the course of the disease.
Or, as Dr. Lecia Sequist, lead author of the study, put it:
“It is really remarkable how much we oncologists assume about a tumor based on a single biopsy taken at one time, usually the time of diagnosis,” lead author Dr. Lecia Sequist said in an MGH news release. “Many cancers can evolve in response to exposure to different therapies over time, and we may be blind to the implications of these changes simply because we haven’t been looking for them.”
“Our findings suggest that, when feasible, oncogene-driven cancers should be interrogated with repeat biopsies throughout the course of the disease,” Sequist said. “Doing so could both contribute to greater understanding of acquired resistance and give caregivers better information about whether resumption of targeted therapy or initiation of a standard therapy would be most appropriate for an individual patient.”
Now, that would be personalized medicine, based on science, in marked contrast to what passes for “personalized” medicine in CAM.
Another cancer for which new findings in genomics and systems biology hold great promise is the cancer I spend most of my time treating and researching, breast cancer. Current methods to predict prognosis and guide treatment are crude and include stage as measured by volume of the primary tumor; presence and number of lymph node metastases; presence or absence of distant metastases; tumor grade as measured histologically; expression or lack of expression of important hormone receptors such as estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor (PR); and amplification of ErbB2 (HER2). Used together, these factors allow, albeit roughly, a degree of prediction of prognosis, as well as of personalization of therapies such as hormonal treatments (tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitors) or agents targeted at HER2 (trastuzumab). Aromatase inhibitors had not yetbecome widely available, and Herceptin (trastuzumab) had been FDA-approved for women with HER2-positive metastatic cancer but not yet for the adjuvant therapy of women with earlier-stage HER2-positive breast cancer. (That did not come until 2006, and then only with chemotherapy.) Then, in 2000, Perou et al published a classic paper in Nature that used then state-of-the-art cDNA microarrays to divide breast cancers into subtypes based on gene expression patterns, which, based on this work and work done since then, currently include normal-like, basal-like, luminal (A and B), and HER2(+)/ER(-), and there is a growing body of literature (for example, this study) that suggests that these different subtypes respond differently to different chemotherapy and targeted agents.
We learned many things from this work, which has accelerated over the last decade. For example, we now know that there are several intrinsic groups of breast cancer based on the patterns of gene expression they exhibit, and these groups subdivide many of the “classic” divisions we have been using for at least two decades, such as ER(+) or ER(-). More importantly, there is one form of breast cancer that expresses none of these markers. Dubbed “triple negative breast cancer” (TNBC), this form of breast cancer is defined as expressing neither ER, PR, nor HER2. TNBC is a close relative of a type of breast cancer categorized a decade ago through gene expression profiling and dubbed “basal-like” (synonymous terms include “basal-type,” “basal-epithelial phenotype,” “basal breast cancer,” and “basaloid breast cancer”). For the most part, currently the same treatments are used for TNBC and basal-like breast cancer because the sine qua non of TNBC is that there are no known molecular targets in this breast cancer subtype, while non-TNBC basal-like breast cancer tends to express HER2 and thus be susceptible to Herceptin. Because TNBCs do not respond to drugs targeting ER or HER2, cytotoxic chemotherapy is currently the only option for adjuvant or neoadjuvant therapy in women with operable TNBC or for systemic treatment for metastatic disease. Paradoxically, TNBCs are more sensitive than ER(+) luminal tumors to standard chemotherapy regimens, but unfortunately this increased chemosensitivity does not translate into prolonged overall or disease-free survival. Consequently, the identification of new molecular targets or oncogene signatures that can be targeted for therapy, either with new agents and/or of new synergistic combinations of old agents, is a critical problem to be overcome for TNBC. Tantalizing hints of how this might be done arose at AACR, for example, this study in which the genomes of 50 breast cancers were sequenced.
Another area in which genomics might assist us as clinicians in breast cancer is through answering a rather vexing question regarding racial disparities in cancer outcome. For example, although the incidence of breast cancer among premenopausal African-American women is lower than among Caucasian women, African-American women are more likely to die from their disease, with a breast cancer-specific mortality of 33 per 100,000 and five year survival of 78% compared to 23.9 per 100,000 and 90%, respectively, for Caucasians. Breast cancer among African-American women tends to be characterized by higher grade, later stage at diagnosis, and worse survival, even after controlling for age and stage. Although it is true that the causes of these observed differences are likely to be multifactorial and include socioeconomic factors, such as differences in access to screening and treatment, there also appear to be biological differences in breast cancer in AA women. Indeed, evidence supporting biological differences as a major part of the explanation for these observed racial disparities was reported from the Carolina Breast Cancer Study. This study reported that that the TNBC/basal-like breast cancer subtype is nearly three times more common among premenopausal African-American women than among Caucasian women In marked contrast, the HER2(+)/ER(-) subtype did not vary appreciably with race or menopausal status, and the less aggressive ER(+) luminal A subtype was less prevalent in premenopausal African-American women. These results suggest that two questions remain open: (1) whether there is a difference in breast cancer biology that drives the tendency of young AA women to develop TNBC at a much higher rate than Caucasian women and (2) whether these biological differences, if they exist, can be exploited therapeutically to develop personalized regimens targeted at patients’ individual tumors. These are the sorts of questions that genomics can potentially answer and personalized medicine be based upon.
Don’t get me wrong. We are not yet near true personalized medicine for breast cancer. Indeed, if you want to get an idea of the challenges that remain, several of the talks I attended are available for free at the AACR website. Talks that are worth watching include:
    • Harold Varmus, New Directions in Cancer Research
    • Lynda Chin, Translating cancer genomics: From discovery to medicine (unfortunately, nearly none of the slides from this talk have been made available)
    • Waun Ki Hong, The landscape of cancer prevention: Personalized approach in lung cancer
    • Andrea Califano, A systems biology approach to integrative cancer genomics (Another one without slides.)
There are many others, but unfortunately most of the relevant talks are either not posted yet, require payment, or both. It’s annoying to me, but on the other hand I understand that it costs money to produce these and put them up on the web. Still, the sheer number of talks on The Cancer Genome Atlas, which goes by the annoyingly cutesy acronym TCGA, is telling. Every day, or so it seemed, there were multiple talks on TCGA, reporting findings, telling investigators how to access the data on its website, and discussing the progress. Basically, TCGA is becoming a repository of genome sequences of many cancers, a resource that can be mined. It’s not too hard to envision that one day, when it has many thousands of cancer genomes stored away from before and after treatment, its database might serve as the basis for computer algorithms that compares a patient’s tumor genome to the database and comes up with a list of recommended treatments.
Unfortunately, the move towards personalized medicine not without its share of opportunists and companies selling kits based on genetic tests that either haven’t been validated in clinical trials sufficiently to support their clinical use, for example Anne Wojcicki of 23andMe, whose pitch is has a lot more in common with “health freedom” arguments than it does with actual scientifically validated uses of genomic data, complete with heavy promotion in various social media. It’s a trait shared with enthusiasts of direct-to-consumer genetic testing, whose language really does harken to that of the “health freedom” movement. For example, compare this post with this post by Mike Adams, and the main difference you’ll find in the arguments will be in degree, not kind. It’s “health freedom” all around. Even while promoters, in a fit of cognitive dissonance, simultaneously accuse physicians of paternalism on this issue and admit that the burgeoning personal genomics industry needs to be “purged of scammers and bottom feeders,” it’s an effort designed to create an army of people who “will go nuts” at any attempt by legislators to legislate direct access to personal genomic data or regulatory agencies to control more tightly access to direct-to-consumer genetic testing. As Harriet Hall put it correctly, when it comes to routine genomic testing, we’re not there yet, not the least of which because, as Scott Gavura has pointed out, there are lots of problems with the testing. As I put it, much of the promotion of personal genomic testing is disturbingly similar to the promotion of various autism “biomedical” therapies by DAN! doctors or Dr. Hyman’s panoply of woo to which he subjects his patients in that it is an extrapolation from data that are too preliminary to justify widespread use. That may well change one day, but today is not yet that day, and saying so, to me at least, is akin to pointing out that the “do it yourself” use of unproven cancer therapies like dichloroacetate is usually not a good idea.
We are, however, making progress, and we’re making that progress not based on speculative extrapolation of preliminary science or accepting dubious science as true. I’ll close with an example that is now routinely used in the treatment of ER(+) breast cancer. As I mentioned above, ER(+) breast cancer tends not to be as sensitive to chemotherapy as ER(-) (and in particular, triple negative) breast cancer, even though it has a better prognosis. Over the last decade, a 21-gene assay has been developed for women with ER(+)/HER2(-) cancer that has not yet spread to the axillary lymph nodes called the OncotypeDX® assay. Based on the results of this assay, a recurrence score can be calculated. If it’s high, the tumor is likely to be sensitive to chemotherapy, which will improve the woman’s chances of survival. If it’s low, the tumor is likely to be insensitive to standard chemotherapy, and the recommendation is for the woman not to undergo anything other than anti-estrogen therapy. In this way, thousands of women will be spared chemotherapy that will not help them. Current trials are investigating the utility of this and other genetic prognostic tests in node-positive tumor or, in the case of Oncotype, in determining whether patients with intermediate scores can be spared chemotherapy, and, if so, which ones.
The revolution in genomics has been likened to a flow of water. In the late 1990s, it was a trickle. Five years later, it was a firehose. Today, it’s Niagara Falls, with terrabytes of data being produced every month. The cost of sequencing an entire genome has fallen from $100,000,000 ten years ago to under $30,000 per genome by late 2010, with the era of sub-$1,000 genome sequences in sight. There is definite promise in genomics to result in truly personalized medicine. The key will be to combine it with proteomics, metabolomics, and an understanding of environmental influences. Doing that will not be easy, and, despite the Niagara Falls of data currently deluging us, it will not be fast. Unlike the claims of personalized medicine that arise from CAM and IM, it will take science and clinical trials to tease out the true associations from the noise, to differentiate correlation from causation, to separate and quantify effects of environment from effects of genome, and to figure out the interactions between them all. Oddly enough, that’s why I find last year’s AACR promotional video to be a bit more realistic than this year’s, annoying techno background music aside:
There are successes, challenges and even failures, but always hope. It’s our time, but we have to stick to science-based medicine.

   Direct-to-Consumer Genetic Testing: Road Map or Tarot Cards?
Scott Gavura
Link
A topic of growing interest (and concern) at SBM is laboratory and diagnostic test pseudoscience. Bogus tests are everywhere, and Kimball Atwood recently discussed several of them. But over the past several years, diagnostic tests have emerged that appear to be science-based and offer gene-level insights into your health. And these tests don’t even require a physician’s visit – just a swab of saliva and a credit card get you reams of information on your genetics, traits, and risks of dozens of diseases. It looks like the ultimate in consumer health information, with the potential to offer truly personalized treatment strategies. Companies like 23andme, deCODEme, and Navigenics all promise “genetic insights” to improve your health. How could this information be anything but helpful?
Personalized medicine describes medical practices that use information about a person’s genes, proteins, and environment to prevent, diagnose and treat disease. Science-based practice has routinely incorporated environmental advice (e.g., diet and exercise) into medical management. And there are a number of genetic tests in routine use that are well established, clinical validated, and are highly predictive of future outcomes, such as tests for Huntington’s disease and hereditary breast cancer.
Predicting how well drugs will work is another area of personalized medicine. Cancer cells have specific genetic mutations that lead to uncontrolled growth. Identifying the mutation, and then developing drugs to target it, means more targeted treatments. Trastusumab (Herceptin) works only in patients overexpressing the Her-2/neu oncogene. Panitumumab (Vectibix) and cetuximab (Erbitux) effectively treat colorectal cancer, but only in patients whose tumors have wild-type KRAS oncogenes. And gefitinib (Iressa) a drug that initially didn’t look that promising, seems to offer a much better risk/benefit perspective in patients with EGFR mutations. Tumor testing for these specific genetic markers helps predict patient response, guides drug selection, and spares the costs and consequences of ineffective therapies.
Whole-genome testing, offered directly to the public, is the latest development in personalized medicine. Companies typically offer to test for genetic traits that predict the risk of disease or estimate the effectiveness of drug therapies. In a typical test, up to a million single nucleotide polymophisms (SNPs) may be analyzed. A customized report is generated, describing the SNPs and your individual risk factors, usually based on population-level studies of what these SNPs mean.
But our understanding of the correlation between SNPs and the risks they identify is still in its infancy. It’s fair to say we only have a preliminary understanding of the relationship between SNPs, environmental factors, and other influencers of illness. It’s not even clear that SNP variants provide meaningful information on risk, beyond what we already know. For example, a study published earlier this year concluded that adding ten additional genetic variants to to a standard breast cancer risk assessment model had little effect on improving the accuracy of predictions. It adds to a growing list of variants which don’t seem give us any actionable information. But the science doesn’t seem to be stopping the vendors of these tests from making unsubstantiated claims about their accuracy and relevance.
The GAO and the FDA
The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently released the results of an investigation into 15 companies offering DTC genetic testing. And it raised some serious questions about the accuracy and validity of information currently available to consumers. The GAO purchased ten tests from four companies, and sent duplicate samples to each company, changing the demographic information each time. The results were alarming:
GAO’s fictitious consumers received test results that are misleading and of little or no practical use. For example, GAO’s donors often received disease risk predictions that varied across the four companies, indicating that identical DNA samples yield contradictory results. One donor was told that he was at below-average, average, and above-average risk for prostate cancer and hypertension.
and
Although the experts GAO spoke with believe that these tests show promise for the future, they agreed that consumers should not rely on any of the results at this time. As one expert said, “the fact that different companies, using the same samples, predict different directions of risk is telling and is important. It shows that we are nowhere near really being able to interpret [such tests].” GAO also found 10 egregious examples of deceptive marketing, including claims made by four companies that a consumer’s DNA could be used to create personalized supplement to cure diseases. Two of these companies further stated that their supplements could “repair damaged DNA” or cure disease, even though experts confirmed there is no scientific basis for such claims. One company representative even fraudulently used endorsements from high-profile athletes to convince GAO’s fictitious consumer to purchase such supplements. Two other companies asserted that they could predict in which sports children would excel based on DNA analysis, claims that an expert characterized as “complete garbage.” Further, two companies told GAO’s fictitious consumer that she could secretly test her fiance’s DNA to “surprise” him with test results–though this practice is restricted in 33 states. Perhaps most disturbing, one company told a donor that an above average risk prediction for breast cancer meant she was “in the high risk of pretty much getting” the disease, a statement that experts found to be “horrifying” because it implies the test is diagnostic.
To be clear, this was not a scientific study, and the results can’t be interpreted to be a comprehensive analysis of the state of the marketplace. But they do give consumers and health professionals cause for concern. Not only did the investigation raise questions about whether these tests are are accurate, there is mixed information about what the results actually mean. The marketing goes well beyond the robust evidence that’s needed to draw stronger correlations between SNPs and specific risk factors. And while some companies are offering legitimate tests (albeit of questionable use), other companies are selling snake oil diagnostics, wrapped in a double helix.
Not surprisingly, the FDA recently took action, sending warning letters to several companies, informing them that these tests require regulatory approval before they can be marketed. While the letters and the FDA’s intent has been subject to considerable scrutiny, the message is clear: the FDA intends to regulate this marketplace.
Expert Opinion – Also Pessimistic
If anyone should be enthusiastic about genetic testing, it would be Craig Venter, who was the first to sequence the human genome. Yet in an intriguing interview in Der Speigel magazine, he is decidedly skeptical about its utility, as noted in a few exchanges:
SPIEGEL: Why is it taking so long for the results of genome research to be applied in medicine?
Venter: Because we have, in truth, learned nothing from the genome other than probabilities. How does a 1 or 3 percent increased risk for something translate into the clinic? It is useless information.
SPIEGEL: Do you think there will be a time when you can extract all this information to yield real medical results?
Venter: For that to happen we need a lot more information: Information about your body’s chemistry, your physiology, your complete medical history, your brain and your entire life. We would need to do that a million times on different people and correlate that data with their genetic information.
SPIEGEL: Will that lead in the end to the kind of personalized medicine that genetic researchers have always touted? Each person would get his or her own personal treatment that is tailored precisely to that person’s genetic make-up?
Venter: That was another one of these silly naïve notions that was out there. It’s not, ‘Oh, we know your genome, we’re going to make this drug for you.’ That will never happen. It is more important that you use the information in the genome about your personal risks and reduce them through intelligent behavior.
It’s anecdote, yes. But when one of the world’s leading scientists is this pessimistic, it doesn’t send a positive signal.
The British Approach
In the United Kingdom, the Human Genetics Commission is taking a different approach than the FDA. Rather than move forward with regulatory intervention, it recently published the Common Framework of Principles for direct-to-consumer genetic testing services, which supports industry self-regulation, while focusing on consumer interests. Here are the highlights:
     1.  Scope: The framework is intended to ensure good practices; meeting consumer expectations while safeguarding their interests. The principles apply to tests ordered directly by consumers or by a non-medical intermediary.
     2.  Marketing and Advertising: Validity claims should be supported by peer reviewed evidence, and references should be provided. This evidence must be presented fairly and transparently (i.e., no cherry-picking).
     3.  Regulatory: Evidence for the association between a genetic marker and a disease, condition or trait identified in the test must be provided. “Associations should be validated at genome wide significance level in more than one large case control study and in a cohort of the ethnic/geographic background relevant to the client. The associations should be published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, they should be undertaken in line with the recommendations made in the STREGA statement, and the provider should supply standard references for these publications.” Accepted and transparent statistical methodologies should be documented to document how the risk of the disease, condition or trait was calculated.
     4.  Information for Consumers: Clear and transparent information should be provided to consumers about the tests offered, their scientific basis, counselling offered, how samples will be handled post-test, possible consequences to future decisions (e.g., life insurance), etc. Data shall be presented in easy-to-understand formats. If a test provider intends to recommend products such as supplements, then information about lifestyle modification and other strategies should be provided. Depending on the type of test being offered, a health professional should oversee the information provided under this principle.
     5.  Counselling and Support: “Where the test is a genetic test in the context of inherited or heritable disorders, that test should only be provided to consumers who are given a suitable opportunity to receive pre- and post-test counselling.”
     6.  Consent: “A genetic test should be carried out only after the person concerned has given free and informed consent. Informed consent can only be provided when a consumer has received sufficient relevant information about the genetic test to enable them to understand the risks, benefits, limitations and implications (including the implications for purchasing insurance) of the genetic test.” “Genetic tests in respect of children when, according to applicable law, that child does not have capacity to consent should normally be deferred until the attainment of such capacity, unless other factors indicate that testing during childhood is clinically indicated.”
     7.  Data Protection: All genetic information must be protected as per any other medical or personal health information.
     8.  Sample Handling: All handling of genetic samples must be carried out in accordance with legal, medical and professional standards.
     9.  Laboratory Processes: Laboratories performing tests should be accredited for quality assurance in molecular genetic testing.
     10.  Interpretation of Test Results: Depending on the test, interpretation should be carried out under guidance of an appropriately trained and accredited professional. When information is provided related to risk assessment, the differences between relative and absolute risks should be made clear.
     11.  Provision of Results: Information should be provided in an easy-to-understand format. When testing for conditions or traits, non-genetic factors should be identified.
     12.  Continuing Support: Depending on the test, ongoing access to consultation should be offered.
     13.  Complaints: A robust process for dealing with complaints should be in place.
In order for the DTC market to avoid strict regulation, the Framework looks like a good place for the industry to start. It allows full access by consumers to their own genetic information, while requiring a full disclosure when any interpretation of that information is offered.
Towards a Science-Based Approach
Our access to genetic information currently exceeds our understanding of what that information actually means. The science underlying these tests is still evolving, and that means the interpretations of this data will continue to evolve. Until better and more conclusive data emerges to correlate SNPs with actual health outcomes, consumers will be dealing with probabilities that are largely irrelevant for health decisions. Luckily, there’s a more powerful and far simpler approach: You can make far more substantial reductions in your risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, or diabetes without any genetic testing at all: simply follow science-based prevention and treatment guidelines.

   Functional Medicine – New Kid on the Block
Wallace Sampson
Link
New Kid on the Block
Well, I’m not sure how new, but it was to me 6 months ago when I heard about Functional Medicine (FM) on a doc call-in program originating in Santa Cruz, Calif. The doc often presents a plurality of approaches to the callers’ problems, most of whom call because they seek self-help methods, supplements, or other short-cuts to help, or who share the utopian dream/meme of sectarian health claims through rearranging implausible ideas on the deck of the good ship Nature. (There could be a mixed metaphor in there somewhere but I go on…)
The radio call-in host, a middle-age sounding woman with a holistically oriented practice in a nearby town seems quite intelligent, grounded in real physiology, biochemistry, and mechanics of the body. I sometimes can catch her in errors but not as often as one could a more typical quacky doc, such as a chelationist. What I can hear is an intermittent string of recommendations I had never heard of, or sometimes had heard of and known to be false. The program beams to a wide area – from Santa Cruz/San Jose area to the central coast in San Luis Obispo. It broadcasts on KUSP FM Saturday mornings at 9 AM Pacific time for those who want to listen on the net (Ask Dr. Dawn.)
When she first spoke about Functional Medicine, the term was new to me, but some of the advice and principles sounded familiar. Standard supplementing. But always with some obscure physiological reason. A look at the FM home page of the web site gives clues to what FM is about. Here is their list of defining terms…
Functional medicine is personalized medicine that deals with primary prevention and underlying causes instead of symptoms for serious chronic disease. It is a science-based field of health care that is grounded in the following principles:
Biochemical individuality describes the importance of individual variations in metabolic function that derive from genetic and environmental differences among individuals.
Patient-centered medicine emphasizes “patient care” rather than “disease care,” following Sir William Osler’s admonition that “It is more important to know what patient has the disease than to know what disease the patient has.”
Dynamic balance of internal and external factors.
Health as a positive vitality – not merely the absence of disease.
Promotion of organ reserve as the means to enhance health span.
Let’s do what we like to do – deconstruct the message and the language – simply and briefly.
“Personalized medicine” is a code for leeway for departure from proved methods and into treating with unproved methods tailored at the discretion of the physician rather than at the need of the patient.
“ Primary prevention” is a standard medicine, but “underlying causes” implies those naturopathic and other sectarian creeds that state biologically based medicine does not concern either one, and that a special kind of medicine is required – which the FM physician happens to have.
“““Biochemical individuality” is a slogan invented by Roger Williams of U. Texas fifty years or more ago that was the forerunner of “Orthomolecular Medicine” of Linus Pauling, Avram Hoffer and Humphrey Osmond… and their megavitamin therapies, now discredited. Williams’s theory stated that because every human is different, each one’s vitamin requirement is as well, so one has to take massive quantities of all vitamins to cover each person’s presumed specific higher than “normal” requirement. I may deal with this concept in a later post on this same subject, although all bloggers here do not need such instruction. .
“Patient centered” medicine implies that medicine and physicians do not concern themselves with the patient as a person, but as a disease – a political myth popular for nearly a century, to rationalize all sorts of bizarre pluralistic approaches from homeopathy to orthomolecular to chiropractic.
“Dynamic Balance” recalls ancient Greek and traditional Chinese concepts of external forces (External Q’i) and internal forces (internal Q’i) and Yin/Yang, all abandoned for want of a piece of evidence for their existence.
“Health” as more than absence of disease: a concept dating from the 1970s “Holistic Medicine” era, still meaningless and without existential proof.
“Promotion of organ reserve” – new one to me, but another concept that is without meaning. I know of no way to promote a reserve in an organ. Do they mean exercise to improve heart or skeletal muscle function? Or, meditation and relaxation to reduce stress, adrenal function, brain activity…what? Anyone with any answer?
What we see here is a collection of word collections that at most are slogans, rather than concepts. Most are abandoned concepts, and one is surprised to see their reusrresction under a more modern slogan, “Functinal Medicine.”
We read on :
Web-like interconnections of physiological factors – an abundance of research now supports the view that the human body functions as an orchestrated network of interconnected systems, rather than individual systems functioning autonomously and without effect on each other. For example, we now know that immunological dysfunctions can promote cardiovascular disease, that dietary imbalances can cause hormonal disturbances, and that environmental exposures can precipitate neurologic syndromes such as Parkinson’s disease.
So here we read that an animal body has a variety of networks and that those networks interact – a revolutionary idea I first learned in undergraduate courses in physiology and endocrinology back in …ummmm…1949?
But we are also told that immunological dysfunctions can promote cardiovascular disease (huh?) and dietary imbalances hormonal disturbances – say what? What other than malnutrition you might ask? Which hormonal disturbances? That might get too technical, so we can leave that out. And environmental exposures can precipitate neurological syndromes such as Parkinson’s…? Say, who? What besides synthetic speed drugs has induced Parkinson-like syndrome? Educate me.
The paragraph is necessary to rationalize the taking of supplements and herbs with distant effects that can then through undefined network connections, but we know are there, can affect a patient‘s call-in complaint…and without either physiological rationale or proof by clinical trial…Functonal Medicine at its best.
They go on:
Functional medicine is anchored by an examination of the core clinical imbalances that underlie various disease conditions. Those imbalances arise as environmental inputs such as diet, nutrients (including air and water), exercise, and trauma are processed by one’s body, mind, and spirit through a unique set of genetic predispositions, attitudes, and beliefs. The fundamental physiological processes include communication, both outside and inside the cell; bioenergetics, or the transformation of food into energy; replication, repair, and maintenance of structural integrity, from the cellular to the whole body level; elimination of waste; protection and defense; and transport and circulation. The core clinical imbalances that arise from malfunctions within this complex system include:
Hormonal and neurotransmitter imbalances
Oxidation-reduction imbalances and mitochondropathy
Detoxification and biotransformational imbalances
Immune imbalances
Inflammatory imbalances
Digestive, absorptive, and microbiological imbalances
Structural imbalances from cellular membrane function to the musculoskeletal system
This stopped me. I got the same blankness of feeling I got when I first faced calculus. What the hell is this all about? The difference is that one can use some math – a bit of trig and a bit more algebra, form some graphs, and see what it’s about. But none of this FM lays out a map from which one can get from here to there. From detoxification to biotransformation imbalances? What is either one of them? No statement can be solved or applied by any physiological principles I could call on. And I know just enough biology and physiology to know that this is blowin’ smoke.
Imbalances such as these are the precursors to the signs and symptoms by which we detect and label (diagnose) organ system disease. Improving balance – in the patient’s environmental inputs and in the body’s fundamental physiological processes – is the precursor to restoring health and it involves much more than treating the symptoms. Functional medicine is dedicated to improving the management of complex, chronic disease by intervening at multiple levels to address these core clinical imbalances and to restore each patient’s functionality and health. Functional medicine is not a unique and separate body of knowledge. It is grounded in scientific principles and information widely available in medicine today, combining research from various disciplines into highly detailed yet clinically relevant models of disease pathogenesis and effective clinical management.
Functional medicine emphasizes a definable and teachable process of integrating multiple knowledge bases within a pragmatic intellectual matrix that focuses on functionality at many levels, rather than a single treatment for a single diagnosis. Functional medicine uses the patient’s story as a key tool for integrating diagnosis, signs and symptoms, and evidence of clinical imbalances into a comprehensive approach to improve both the patient’s environmental inputs and his or her physiological function. It is a clinician’s discipline, and it directly addresses the need to transform the practice of primary care.
Thanks for reading this far.
Clearly, this is an organization with claims cloaked in the language of science, but with the distinguishing characteristics of sectarianism – pluralities of approaches to illness, absence of evidence for efficacy, a unifying concept of illness as a body out of sync with Nature (with the capital N,) undecipherable babble and descriptive word salad. And note the last sentence, a bow to postmodernism, “transform the practice…” A transformative what?
Apparently the formers of the organization put on educational programs for physicians and others. Perhaps a pony or an Esperanto dictionary is required. What other activities FM produces I do not yet know. I’ll bring some examples of questions and answers in a few weeks.

Bill and Hillary Clinton go woo with Dr. Mark Hyman and “functional medicine”
Mark Hyman is a “pioneer” (if you can call it that) in a new form of quackery known as functional medicine, which combines a lot of the worst features of conventional medicine with a large dollop of “make it up as you go along” quackery. Unfortunately, it appears that the Clintons find his narrative compelling.
David Gorski on April 14, 2014
Link
Dug the Dog strikes again.
I was all set to write about a mass of pseudoscience published in a prominent online news/comment site, one that addressed a topic near and not-so-dear to my heart, mainly EMF and cell phone radiation as an alleged cause of cancer and many health problems. Ready to rip into it with gusto, I did have a bit of reservation because I had recently addressed the very same topic when Dr. Oz engaged in a bit of fear mongering about it. It must have been posted to various breast cancer forums or forums dedicated to discussing the purported health issues due to cell phones, because every so often, for the last three months, outraged commenters would show up and lash out at me. But, then, I was made aware of an article that appeared in the New York Times a couple of days ago that brought up memories of something I haven’t written about for a long time.
Squirrel!
Besides, I can always blog about the other execrable article on my not-so-super-secret other blog. That’s what it’s there for.
In any case, the NYT article appeared, appropriately enough, in the Fashion & Style section, not the Health section, and is entitled “He Tells the Clintons How to Lose a Little. Dr. Mark Hyman: Advising the Clintons on Their Health.” It’s written by Amy Chozick, a reporter I’ve never heard of, probably because I know the names of most, if not all, of the health reporters for the NYT and national news outlets, but am blissfully unfamiliar with reporters covering the fashion and style beat. Actually, it turns out that Chozick is a political reporter “with a focus on covering Hillary Clinton.” Obviously her focus isn’t on covering health, as her article makes clear.
The article demonstrates one thing, and that’s how good Dr. Mark Hyman is at schmoozing powerful celebrities like the Clintons. In fact, after reading this story, I’m less likely to be supporting Hillary Rodham Clinton for President in 2016, because the article makes it clear that the Clintons are Hyman’s friends and that they rely on him for advice with respect to health matters, including, increasingly, health policy. If she’s elected, it wouldn’t surprise me in the least if Hillary Clinton taps Hyman as a health advisor. For all we know, she might make him Surgeon General or give him a major advisory role in health policy. It all apparently began not long after Bill Clinton had his quadruple bypass surgery ten years ago. Hillary Clinton apparently found Hyman—how, it’s not clear—and viewed him as a “30th anniversary present” to her husband designed to keep him healthy after his health scare:
One of the first things Dr. Hyman did was to wean Mr. Clinton off his previously prescribed vegan diet. Despite persistent news media reports that he is vegan, Mr. Clinton does occasionally eat fish and lean protein. “It’s hard being a vegan to eat enough good, quality protein and not have too much starch,” Dr. Hyman said over lunch at the Four Seasons restaurant in New York. “I know a lot of fat vegans.”
Dr. Hyman, who made a name for himself advising the moneyed urbanites who retreat to Canyon Ranch in Lenox, Mass., met Mrs. Clinton at a fund-raiser in New York when she was in the Senate. The two quickly dived into a wonky conversation about childhood obesity and his philosophy of healthful eating. “She then called me and we’ve just become friends,” he said.
If there’s anyone who embodies the concept of “integrative medicine,” in which pseudoscience and unscientific medicine are “integrated” with science-based medicine and innocuous advice like eating more vegetables and fish, it’s Dr. Hyman. As the article points out, he is known for practicing “functional medicine,” but what the article does not point out is exactly what “functional medicine” is. Actually, that’s not a straightforward question, because what constitutes functional medicine has never been clear to me, although it’s clear that a lot of it is pseudoscience. Let’s see what Chozick says about it:
His latest book, “The Blood Sugar Solution: 10-Day Detox Diet,” a sequel to his best seller “The Blood Sugar Solution,” provides a 10-day cleanse for quick weight loss, but the splashy promise of pounds shed is mostly a way to get readers to quickly experience the benefits of healthy eating, he said. “Writing books, you kind of have to come up with the way to get people’s attention. I would probably call it something different if I had a choice.”
More broadly, he embraces a wellness philosophy called “functional medicine,” or the practice of addressing the root causes of chronic diseases (from diabetes and arthritis to insomnia and fatigue) through dietary and lifestyle changes, rather than diagnosing them and prescribing traditional medicine to treat the symptoms. Weight loss is a nice side effect, he said.
And:
“He did amazing blood work on me and a lot of other people I know,” Mr. Clinton said, adding that it all started with “a very sophisticated biomedical analysis and he basically gave them their whole lives back.”
I note that “sophisticated” doesn’t necessarily equal science-based, as you will see.
What is this “functional medicine” thing, anyway?
I’ll get straight to the point (unusual for me, I know, but I console myself that I used—for the umpteenth time—my favorite Dug the Dog joke to start out the post, even though it only occupied a paragraph). Functional medicine is pure pseudoscience, as Wally Sampson has explained. It postulates “imbalances” in hormones and neurotransmitters, oxidation-reduction, detoxification and biotransformation, immune function, inflammation, and cell structure. It’s all so vague that these “imbalances” could mean almost anything, and when practitioners of “functional medicine” refer to them, they usually do. Arguably the most famous practitioner of “functional medicine” is Mark Hyman, known for creating “Ultrawellness,” the very name of which should tell you pretty much all you need to know about functional medicine. Indeed, it just seems to be a label used to encompass a whole lot of alternative medicine practices being “integrated” with real medicine. As our one of our founding bloggers and now emeritus Wally Sampson put it:
Functional Medicine – What is it?
After extensive searching and examination, my answer is still – only the originators of “FM” know. Or, at least one must assume they know, because so far as I can see, I certainly see nothing that distinguishes “FM” from other descriptions of sectarian and “Complementary/Alternative Medicine” practices. A difference may lie in the advocates’ assumptions to have found some “imbalance” of body chemistry or physiology before applying one or more unproved methods or substances. From what I could determine, the “imbalance” or dysfunction is usually either imaginary or at least presumptive. And the general principles are so poorly defined as to allow practioners vast leeway to apply a host of unproven methods.
Indeed, I haven’t been able to figure out what, exactly, distinguishes functional medicine itself from quackery, as functional medicine recommends treatments full of supplements, dietary manipulations, and “detoxification.” It’s the sort of treatment that practitioners of “autism biomed” quackery, chiropractors, and naturopaths love, in which “imbalances” must be measured through a battery of lab tests and corrected with whatever woo functional medicine practitioners can dream up. That, very likely, is what constituted that battery of “sophisticated” blood work that so impressed the Clintons, rather than any actual science. Of course, when you don’t understand medicine or science, any battery of blood tests with levels of lots of blood components with fancy names being tested, accompanied with science-y sounding explanations of what the results all mean, will often seem hugely impressive. Even seriously sophisticated people in other realms will often be taken in. Actually, it’s often those very sophisticated people who are most impressed because they think they understand when they don’t. The Dunning–Kruger effect and motivated reasoning can indeed affect even people like the Clintons—or maybe especially people like the Clintons. After all, it is the most intelligent people among us who are most skilled at making arguments and (often unconsciously) cherry picking data to support our own arguments, particularly lawyers like Bill and Hillary Clinton. Sadly, functional medicine has even found its way into academic—or, as I like to put it these days, quackademic—medicine.
But, let’s get back to the question: What, exactly, is “functional medicine,” anyway? I thought it was worth going straight to the source, the Institute for Functional Medicine (the chair of whose board of directors is—surprise! surprise!—Mark Hyman), to find out how much, if at all, functional medicine has changed since the last time I looked into it. If you take a look at the IFM’s page What Is Functional Medicine? you’ll see quite rapidly that it’s a very nice package of woo “integrated” with sensible science-based advice, all tied up with a rhetorical bow of buzzwords common in “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM) and “integrative medicine,” buzzwords and catch phrases such as:
    • “Patient-centered care,” which is touted as “personalization” of medical care and “listening to patients,” in which ” functional medicine supports the unique expression of health and vitality for each individual,” whatever that means.
    • “Understanding the origins, prevention, and treatment of complex, chronic disease,” again, whatever that means, given that the functional medicine view of the origins, prevention, and treatment of complex chronic diseases tend to resemble the science-based view of the origins, prevention, and treatment of complex chronic diseases only occasionally, and then only by coincidence or through the co-opting of SBM paradigms as somehow being “alternative” and “functional” (because, you know, alternative and functional are cooler).
    • “Integrating best medical practices,” which is, of course, the “best of both worlds” fallacy.
Functional medicine claims to be guided by six core principles:
    • An understanding of the biochemical individuality of each human being, based on the concepts of genetic and environmental uniqueness;
    • Awareness of the evidence that supports a patient-centered rather than a disease-centered approach to treatment;
    • Search for a dynamic balance among the internal and external body, mind, and spirit;
    • Familiarity with the web-like interconnections of internal physiological factors;
    • Identification of health as a positive vitality not merely the absence of disease emphasizing those factors that encourage the enhancement of a vigorous physiology;
    • Promotion of organ reserve as the means to enhance the health span, not just the life span, of each patient.
It all sounds well and good—on the surface, that is. I could (and would) point out that the “understanding of the biochemical individuality of each human being, based on the concepts of genetic and environmental uniqueness” seems custom-made to cater to the belief among some of the woo-prone that they are special snowflakes, so utterly unique that treatment must be tailored to their finest uniqueness. Alternatively, as Wally pointed out five years ago, “biochemical individuality” is an expression invented by Dr. Roger Williams of the University of Texas 50 years ago to justify administering massive doses of vitamins and other supplements in order to achieve “optimum health.” Linus Pauling, proving that Nobel Laureates can be taken in by pseudoscience, adapted the concept, along with other treatments involving massive doses of vitamins, into the idea of “orthomolecular medicine,” a type of medicine that seems to have at its very core the concepts that all disease is due to some sort of vitamin or nutrient deficiency (or “imbalance”) and that, if some vitamins are good, massive amounts more are even better. It’s no wonder that functional medicine frequently goes hand-in-hand with orthomolecular medicine.
Of course, it’s a typical massive straw man to claim that, somehow, functional medicine treatments—or whatever “alternative” or “integrative” treatments you care to name—are “individualized,” and science-based medicine is not. It’s actually rather amusing to contemplate that over the last ten years there has been a large move towards what has been called “personalized medicine,” based on genomic profiling and other tests but that the movement has been renamed to “precision” medicine. The reason? To paraphrase the National Research Council report on precision medicine, “precision medicine” refers to tailoring the medical treatment to the individual characteristics of each patient. It does not literally mean the creation of drugs or medical devices that are unique to a patient but rather the ability to “classify individuals into subpopulations that differ in their susceptibility to a particular disease, in the biology and/or prognosis of those diseases they may develop, or in their response to a specific treatment,” thus allowing the concentration on those who will benefit, “sparing expense and side effects for those who will not.” The NRC also points out that the term “personalized medicine” is also used to convey such a meaning but that the “term is sometimes misinterpreted as implying that unique treatments can be designed for each individual.” In other words, “precision medicine” just slices groups of patients with a disease into smaller and smaller categories for purposes of deciding therapy, not to the point where each patient gets a different treatment.
In contrast, as I’ve described before, in the world of alternative medicine, be it “functional medicine” or whatever, the “individualization of treatments” and a “holistic approach” tend to mean “making it up as you go along” or, basically, whatever the practitioner wants them to mean.
I like to quote Humpty Dumpty from Lewis Carroll’s Through The Looking Glass:
“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.”
“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”
“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master — that’s all.”
Functional medicine practitioners are masters of bending language to their wills, just like Humpty Dumpty, and to them “individualized” or “personalized” medicine means whatever they want it to mean, as Wally Sampson has described again and again and again and again. It’s a pseudoscientific medical “specialty” that mixes dietary recommendations both reasonable and quackery-laden with the treatment of nonexistent or inadequately-validated “imbalances” in various nutrients and hormones in the body
Perhaps, you think, I paint with too broad a brush. Maybe Dr. Hyman is different. So let’s look at what he does.
Dr. Hyman, revisited
If there’s one thing I’ve learned in the world of woo, it’s that one of the fastest ways to find out what a practitioner is doing—actually doing—is to head on over to his website. Dr. Hyman actually has at least two. First, there’s his own website, which has its own store. Then there’s his UltraWellness Center, apparently because “wellness” isn’t enough and “ultrawellness” is so much better—so much more “ultra.” From the UltraWellness Center website, it didn’t take long for me to find a link to the website for Dr. Hyman’s latest book The Blood Sugar Solution 10-Day Detox Diet. It’s endorsed by Dr. Oz and Dr. Amen, so you know it must be good woo, and on that website there was a link to a quiz to determine whether you need “detoxing.” Here it is:
Do You Need to Detox?
     1.  Do you crave sugar and carbs?
     2.  Do you have belly fat?
     3.  Do you have trouble losing weight?
     4.  Do you have FLC syndrome (Feel Like Crap – fatigue, brain fog, digestive issues, mood problems, allergies, joint pain, skin problems, autoimmune disease)?
If you answered YES to even ONE of the above questions, keep reading.
Yes, apparently if you crave sugar and carbs, have a bit of belly fat, have trouble losing weight, or feel run down, you need detoxification! A naturopath couldn’t have said it better! At least 75%, if not much more, of the adult population is likely to answer “yes” to at least one of those questions; so apparently everybody needs “detoxification.” And, of course, Dr. Hyman is right there, ready to sell you the supplements you need to detoxify, including his PureLean Pure Pack, PGX Fiber, and Vitamin D3, which, or so Dr. Hyman claims, can do these wonderful things for you:
The 10-Day Detox Diet Basic Kit includes all of the supplementation needed to support healthy blood sugar balance while on the 10 initial days of the program or the basic plan after transition. The unique combination of supplements in this kit is designed to provide a foundation for cellular sensitivity to insulin as well as sustain the metabolism of fats and sugars. This bolsters healthy metabolism, blood sugar balance, cholesterol levels, and more. These supplements should be taken every day for the rest of your life for maximum effect.
So what’s in these supplements? The PureLean Pure Pack includes:
    • Multivitamins and minerals
    • MacularSynergy Complex, which is described as a “proprietary blend of lutein and zeaxanthin—two of the most crucial nutrients for macular function.”
    • Metabolic GlycoPex, described as a “unique combination of alpha lipoic acid, cinnamon, and l-carnosine provides critical antioxidants and phytonutrients that help improve insulin sensitivity, scavenge free radicals, and support healthy blood sugar levels.”
    • Metabolic LipidPlex, described as a “special blend of green tea catechins, taurine, and more supports insulin sensitivity, healthy fat burning, and metabolism.”
    • Alpha Lipoic Acid with GlucoPhenol, described as “useful in supporting healthy nerve function in those with diabetes and pre-diabetes: and a “powerful antioxidant and mitochondrial booster.”
    • Omega-3 Fats, described as “crucial for healthy cardiovascular, nervous system, and immune function.”
    • Magnesium
    • Taurine, described as a “powerful antioxidant” that “supports healthy cardiovascular, nervous system, skeletal muscular, and retinal function.”
Not only is Dr. Hyman a basic supplement hawker, but he sells PGX Fiber, which is widely touted as a fiber that expands in the stomach to produce a feeling of fullness, alleviating hunger pains, the idea being that if you take 2 to 5 g of it before a meal you will eat less. I did a quick PubMed search for the fiber and found a smattering of in vitro studies, rodent studies, and preliminary clinical studies (small pilot studies and a small randomized trial) suggesting that PGX might be useful for such purposes, but nothing particularly compelling. That’s better than the evidence base that exists for the average supplement, but nowhere near enough to advocate widespread use of the supplement for “detoxification” and lowering cholesterol and glycemic index of foods. Like most supplement hawkers, Dr. Hyman runs ahead of the evidence. But, hey, if you buy his 10-Day Detox Diet Starter Package, he’ll give you a 10% discount on your first order of The Blood Sugar Solution 10-Day Detox Diet supplement support kits. You’ll need it, given that the supplements above cost $140 for a four week supply. To ease the anxiety over the price, you might want to buy some of Dr. Hyman’s UltraMind (sounds like a supervillain) supplements to calm your mind. Certainly, I was tempted to do just that after reading Dr. Hyman’s claim that the laws of thermodynamics “doesn’t apply in living, breathing, digesting systems.” That might require a post of its own sometime.
Or maybe I need Dr. Hyman’s Thyroid Support Kit or his Essentials Kit for Men, the latter of which he tells me “should be taken every day for the rest of your life for maximum effect.” Of course it should. I’ve always wondered why it’s considered so unethical and such a conflict of interest for physicians to sell medications that it’s illegal under most circumstances, but to the “integrative medicine” and alternative medicine crowd it’s apparently perfectly fine for a physician like Dr. Hyman (or Dr. Joe Mercola or alternative practitioners like naturopaths) to manufacture and sell the very supplements they prescribe to their patients, even going to the point of recommending supplements without pointing out that they own a supplement company. Perhaps Jann Bellamy can help me out with that one. (Stay tuned.)
In any case, we can see the consequences of how Dr. Hyman defines and treats disease in several examples, such as an article in which he touted anecdotal evidence for the “personalized treatment” of dementia, in which he actually had the temerity to paint current medicine as “obsolete,” like bloodletting or phrenology, and touts functional medicine as finding the “true cause” of disease. It’s rare to see a case of such massive projection outside of the antivaccine movement. Indeed, Dr. Hyman has been known to engage in a bit of germ theory denialism, stating:
We are the same – we need to have a healthy soil or terrain in order to be healthy.
In fact, Louis Pasteur on his deathbed realized this – and it is the terrain, NOT the germ, that is the most important determinant of health.
This explains why giving zinc to malnourished children in the third world can reduce death from infections by over 75% – it doesn’t stop exposure to the bugs, but zinc boosts immunity, helping the children stay healthy.
So by believing in this “germ theory” of disease, medicine has ignored one of the most important scientific ideas of the last century – that our health is determined by the interaction of our genes and our environment.
Anyone who cites the myth that Louis Pasteur somehow “recanted” germ theory on his deathbed is deep into germ theory denialism. Hyman was also attacking a straw man, in that science-based medicine already does take into account the “terrain,” which can modify susceptibility to disease, be it infectious disease or other diseases. Much of the rest of what Dr. Hyman teaches when he gives his course of functional medicine includes the usual alt-med claptrap, such as a woo-ish take on inflammation, hormones, gut and digestive health, mind-body interactions, mitochondrial metabolism, and, of course, detoxification, the other One Quackery To Rule Them All (other than homeopathy, of course). Indeed, take a look at the brochure for the Institute for Functional Medicine 2014 course on detox. (Seriously, it’s offering a course on detox.) It’s chock full of detox pseudoscience, with competencies to be acquired including understanding the “synergistic” effects of toxins, developing “personalized dietary protocols to support detoxification and elimination pathways,” and applying “various nutraceuticals, botanicals, pharmaceuticals, and lifestyle interventions to increase mobilization, biotransformation, and elimination of toxic compounds in the body.”
I thought I was reading an outline of a naturopathy course.
Such proclivities routinely lead Dr. Hyman to do things like mangle systems biology and cancer research. He’s even appeared to ascribe to the antivaccine view that vaccines cause autism, without, of course, explicitly saying that vaccines cause autism—although he does support all sorts of “autism biomed” quackery for autism and recently has been Tweeting support to antivaccine crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. He’s also been known to criticize science-based medicine as being “for sale” based on a paper that doesn’t really provide compelling evidence to support such a conclusion, all the while neglecting to note that he has minimal to no evidence to support the supplements he sells and that he sells the very supplements that he recommends.
Conclusions
These days Dr. Hyman appears to be becoming more and more well-known. For example, Chozick’s article mentions that Dr. Hyman has recently appeared on The Dr. Oz Show. I was half-tempted to look up the episode and see what sorts of woo he discussed with Dr. Oz, but this post has already grown long enough. Actually, I did look up the videos (part 1, part 2, part 3). Maybe I’ll do a full post on them if I can stand to watch. In any case, apparently he’s touting something now that he calls “diabesity,” apparently a term that Dr. Francine Kaufman coined in 2008 for a book. It refers to the combination of type II diabetes and obesity, for which he combines reasonable recommendations (avoiding processed sugars) with unsupported recommendations (“detox” from your “addiction” to carbohydrates), opining that “diabesity can be caused by or worsened by many things: inflammation, environmental toxins, gut problems, hormonal imbalances and nutritional deficiencies” and that “customizing the program according to your specific triggers will help you get the best results.” Of course.
Unfortunately, Dr. Hyman appears to be one of those “integrative medicine” doctors who’s very good at sounding reasonable as he “integrates” pseudoscience and unsupported medical modalities into science-based medicine. He gives the game away by the way he attacks science, touts anecdotal evidence over science, and subscribes to ideas based on prescientific thinking, such as “detoxification” and “imbalances” of hormones, vitamins, and nutrients that could easily be imbalances in the four humors or the five elements. Particularly depressing was this passage from Chozick’s article:
These days conversations with the former first couple usually focus on the functional-medicine movement and health policy, Dr. Hyman said. And he has spent time working with the pastor Rick Warren on “The Daniel Plan,” a diet based on community and biblical principles that helped 15,000 of Mr. Warren’s congregants at the Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, Calif., lose a combined 250,000 pounds. “We have the knowledge to relieve needless suffering for millions of people,” Dr. Hyman said. “People like Hillary get it, Bill gets it.”
Before she left the State Department, Mrs. Clinton invited Dr. Hyman to her Washington home to discuss working on health-related issues at the Bill, Hillary & Chelsea Clinton Foundation.
Pastor Rick Warren? A diet based on Biblical principles? And this is the guy who, if Chozick’s article is to be believed, seems to be Hillary Clinton’s primary advisor on health and medicine? This is disturbing indeed.
If Hillary Clinton is the Democratic Party nominee in 2016, I’m likely to have a real dilemma. Should I vote for her, knowing that she’s likely to appoint people like Dr. Hyman to health policy positions? It won’t be an easy choice, because, to me, at least none of the current likely Republican candidates with a shot at becoming the nominee is acceptable—and for so many more reasons than just having a health advisor who is the world’s most famous practitioner of the woo known as “functional” medicine. Yet, there you have it. Say what you will about Hillary Clinton, before meeting Dr. Hyman, she didn’t use to be into what I would consider woo, at least not as far as I can tell. I was half-tempted at the beginning of this post to crack a lame joke about how Hillary Clinton, when she found Dr. Hyman to take care of her husband, wasn’t actually trying to keep him around for decades to come at all, but then I thought better of it. The reason is that she clearly does take Dr. Hyman and his functional medicine woo seriously, just as Senator Tom Harkin took a lot of alternative medicine seriously and Representative Dan Burton took the antivaccine view that vaccines cause autism seriously. Does she take him seriously enough to try to take his ideas and put them in health policy if she is elected President in 2016? I don’t know, but we might find out.

Functional medicine: The ultimate misnomer in the world of integrative medicine
Functional medicine. It sounds so…scientific and reasonable. It’s anything but. In fact, functional medicine combines the worst features of conventional medicine with a heapin’ helpin’ of quackery.
David Gorski on April 11, 2016
Link


We at Science-Based Medicine often describe “integrative medicine” as integrating quackery with medicine (at least, I often do), because that’s what it in essence does. The reason, as I’ve described time and time again, is to put that quackery on equal footing (or at least apparently equal footing) with science- and evidence-based medicine, a goal that is close to being achieved. Originally known as quackery, the modalities now being “integrated” with medicine then became “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), a term that is still often used. But that wasn’t enough. The word “complementary” implies a subordinate position, in which the CAM is not the “real” medicine, the necessary medicine, but is just there as “icing on the cake.” The term “integrative medicine” eliminates that problem and facilitates a narrative in which integrative medicine is the “best of both worlds” (from the perspective of CAM practitioners and advocates). Integrative medicine has become a brand, a marketing term, disguised as a bogus specialty.
Of course, it’s fairly easy to identify much of the quackery that CAM practitioners and woo-friendly physicians have “integrated” itself into integrative medicine. A lot of it is based on prescientific ideas of how the human body and disease work (e.g., traditional Chinese medicine, especially acupuncture, for instance, which is based on a belief system that very much resembles the four humors in ancient “Western” or European medicine); on nonexistent body structures or functions (e.g., chiropractic and subluxations, reflexology and a link between areas on the palms of the hands and soles of the feet that “map” to organs; craniosacral therapy and “craniosacral rhythms”); or vitalism (e.g., homeopathy, “energy medicine,” such as reiki, therapeutic touch, and the like). Often there are completely pseudoscientific ideas whose quackiness is easy to explain to an educated layperson, like homeopathy.
Then there are modalities being “integrated” into medicine whose quackiness is not so easy to explain. Perhaps the most popular and famous of these is a specialty known as “functional medicine” (FM) whose foremost practitioner and advocate (in the US, at least) is Mark Hyman, MD, a man whose fame has led him to become a trusted medical advisor to Bill and Hillary Clinton. Perhaps Hyman’s greatest coup came in 2014, when the Cleveland Clinic Foundation hired him to create an institute dedicated to FM, an effort that has apparently been wildly successful in terms of patient growth. Never mind that around the same time Dr. Hyman teamed up with rabid antivaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to write a book blaming mercury in the thimerosal preservative that used to be in vaccines for causing autism, an idea that was shown long ago to have no scientific merit. Unfortunately, elsewhere FM has been pretty successful as well, to the point where there is even “functional dentistry.”
The problem with “functional medicine” is that at its core it is close to being as nonsensical as the more “obvious” forms of quackery. It just hides it better, given the number of fancy-sounding laboratory tests. It’s also incredibly difficult to pin down just what the heck it even is, as we’ve discussed many times in the past, starting with the late, great Wally Sampson’s plaintiff post, Functional Medicine: What Is It? It was a question he asked after referring to it as the “New Kid on the Block.”
That’s why I’m grateful to Jann Bellamy, who sent me a case study on the use of FM in oncology published in a journal that I had never heard of before, Integrative Medicine: A Clinician’s Journal (IMCJ). Even better, the case is a woman treated for breast cancer, my area of expertise, which allows me to discuss this in even more depth. Before we do that, let’s review a bit about FM as a prelude to diving into the specifics of this published case report. To be honest, I’m surprised that anyone would publish such tripe, as it’s incredibly embarrassing. Or at least it would be to any competent oncologist. What really scares me is that FM is now specializing. What we are seeing here is the birth of “functional oncology,” and it is terrifying to me.
Functional Medicine: What Is It?
I begin by asking the same question that Wally Sampson asked, lo those many years ago: Just what the heck is functional medicine, anyway? It has been a long time since any of us here has asked that question; so now is as good a time as any to ask it again. Indeed, I was curious to know just what has changed about functional medicine; so I even went back to the same source that Dr. Sampson used eight years ago, the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM), an organization founded by the other big name in FM, Jeffrey Bland, PhD.
Like pretty much all of “integrative medicine” it claims to look at the real cause of disease:
Functional Medicine addresses the underlying causes of disease, using a systems-oriented approach and engaging both patient and practitioner in a therapeutic partnership. It is an evolution in the practice of medicine that better addresses the healthcare needs of the 21st century. By shifting the traditional disease-centered focus of medical practice to a more patient-centered approach, Functional Medicine addresses the whole person, not just an isolated set of symptoms. Functional Medicine practitioners spend time with their patients, listening to their histories and looking at the interactions among genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that can influence long-term health and complex, chronic disease. In this way, Functional Medicine supports the unique expression of health and vitality for each individual.
You could remove the word “functional,” replace it with “integrative,” and easily plop this paragraph down into just about any article written about integrative medicine by an apologist. It’s the same weasel words of woo, different branch of woo. Or actually it’s the same branch, just a different sub-branch. But what does this all mean? The IFM claims:
    • Functional Medicine offers a powerful new operating system and clinical model for assessment, treatment, and prevention of chronic disease to replace the outdated and ineffective acute-care models carried forward from the 20th century.
    • Functional Medicine incorporates the latest in genetic science, systems biology, and understanding of how environmental and lifestyle factors influence the emergence and progression of disease.
    • Functional Medicine enables physicians and other health professionals to practice proactive, predictive, personalized medicine and empowers patients to take an active role in their own health.
You know, I hate it when woo-meisters liken things to “operating systems” while referring to “outmoded acute care models.” One thing you can be sure of, though, is that whenever someone like Dr. Bland refers to using the “latest in genetic science, systems biology, and understanding of how environmental and lifestyle factors influence the emergence and progression of disease,” you will be in for a heaping helping of abuse of those new sciences. We’ve seen it time and time again with, for example, epigenetics (which doesn’t do or mean what quacks think it does), placebo effects, the power of diet (which is often grossly exaggerated), and, of course, systems biology, which FM guru Mark Hyman himself abuses shamelessly in the service of his made-up specialty. Indeed, Hyman is an excellent example, as he’s mangled science in the service of FM in many areas, including cancer, autism (of course, given his latest foray into antivaccine propaganda), and, of course, Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia. That’s just a sampling, of course. What’s worse, is that FM seems to value anecdotes over actual clinical studies. Basically, its form of “personalized medicine” appears to be a “bait and switch” designed to lower the standard of evidence required to justify a treatment.
Don’t believe me? Read it right from the horse’s mouth, so to speak. First:
Functional Medicine is an approach to health care that conceptualizes health and illness as part of a continuum in which all components of the human biological system interact dynamically with the environment, producing patterns and effects that change over time. Functional Medicine helps clinicians identify and ameliorate dysfunctions in the physiology and biochemistry of the human body as a primary method of improving patient health. Functional Medicine is often described as the clinical application of systems biology. [Emphasis in original]
But more tellingly, see what Bland says about the evidence base for FM:
When people ask to see the evidence for Functional Medicine, they often mean, “Where are your research trials, comparing Functional Medicine to conventional medicine in a clinical setting?” Unfortunately, current research models do not have a way to test each individualized, patient-centered therapeutic plan that is tailored to a person with a unique combination of existing conditions, genetic influences, environmental exposures, and lifestyle choices. Clinical trials do play a significant role in evaluating and comparing the efficacy of new pharmaceutical treatments, especially when it is important to rule out placebo effects, but they have many inherent limitations which constrain their ability to inform clinical decision making.
So let’s not even bother doing clinical trials, then, amirite? Basically, this is a manifesto for doing whatever the heck a physician wants in the name of “personalizing” care. Whenever I see such piece of utter nonsense used as a justification, I can’t help but point out that real doctors and scientists are trying very hard to figure out new clinical trial methodology in order to test precision medicine (which used to be called “personalized” medicine) in a scientifically rigorous manner. Yes, in the early “wild west” days (which we are only now coming out of), a lot of physicians made it up as they go along with respect to interpreting the results of whole genome sequencing to select cancer treatment, but that is increasingly frowned upon. If scientists can put together a trial as clever and complex as the SHIVA trial, I laugh at Jeff Bland telling me that FM can’t be tested because it’s two “personalized.” It’s a lame excuse—the very lamest—and exactly the same excuse that homeopaths, acupuncturists, and the like make for not doing clinical trials testing their quackery, though FM tries to “science it up” by rationalizing it with these seven principles:
    • Acknowledging the biochemical individuality of each human being, based on concepts of genetic and environmental uniqueness
    • Incorporating a patient-centered rather than a disease-centered approach to treatment
    • Seeking a dynamic balance among the internal and external factors in a patient’s body, mind, and spirit
    • Addressing the web-like interconnections of internal physiological factors
    • Identifying health as a positive vitality—not merely the absence of disease—and emphasizing those factors that encourage a vigorous physiology
    • Promoting organ reserve as a means of enhancing the health span, not just the life span, of each patient
    • Functional Medicine is a science-using profession
That very first principle is FM’s “get out of jail free” card for basically anything its practitioners want to do. They can always find ways to justify any form of treatment, be it science-based or quackery, simply by invoking the “biochemical individuality” of each human being. Here’s the problem: Yes, human beings are individuals, and each human being is unique. However, we’re not so unique that our bodies don’t all work pretty much the same way. In other words, in terms of biology, physiology, and yes, systems biology, human beings are far more alike than they are different. If that weren’t the case, modern medicine, developed before we had the tools to probe our genetic individuality, wouldn’t work as well as it does. FM fetishizes “biochemical individuality,” not so much because humans are so incredibly different that each one absolutely has to have a markedly different treatment. We’re not. FM fetishizes “individuality” because it distinguishes FM as a brand from science-based medicine and, I suspect, because it makes FM practitioners feel good, like “total” doctors never at a loss for an explanation for a patient’s symptoms or clinical condition. As for the last bit about FM being a “science-using” profession, I like to say that FM “uses” science the same way that a drunk “uses” a streetlight pole or a wall: To hold himself up against the force of his inebriation’s effect on his brain.
Overall, there are some things that FM gets right, although they are no different than the things every primary care doctor should be getting right, namely emphasizing healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health (e.g., smoking). They tend to spend more time with patients, which is something that primary care doctors have a harder time doing these days. They emphasize prevention, which is a good thing but again something that good primary care doctors do anyway.
Where they go wrong is in what Grant Ritchey described as a major unstated premise. That premise is that FM really does address the root causes of disease better than conventional medicine. FM also encompasses a lot of quackery, such as acupuncture, chiropractic adjustments, and especially “detoxification” programs. There also seems to be considerable overlap between FM and orthomolecular medicine, as FM practitioners seem quite enamored of high dose vitamin C infusions. Indeed, one of the quackiest of the quackademic medicine centers in this country, the University of Kansas, emphasizes FM and orthomolecular medicine and is run by a woman who is very much a proponent of high dose vitamin C infusions for cancer.
One of the most prominent identifying features of FM is its reliance on laboratory tests, lots and lots and lots of laboratory tests. They use these laboratory tests to seek out each patient’s “biochemical” individuality and analyze his systems in these areas:
    • Assimilation: digestion, absorption, microbiota/GI, respiration
    • Defense and repair: immune, inflammation, infection/microbiota
    • Energy: energy regulation, mitochondrial function
    • Biotransformation and elimination: toxicity, detoxification
    • Transport: cardiovascular and lymphatic systems
    • Communication: endocrine, neurotransmitters, immune messengers
    • Structural integrity: subcellular membranes to musculoskeletal integrity
This search for “biochemical individuality” leads FM practitioners to order incredible numbers of labs, as you will see, many of which, as Kimball Atwood pointed out a long time ago, are bogus and of no use, and many of which are routine lab tests that regular doctors order but often end up massively misinterpreted and abused. In particular, FM practitioners appear to like to order lab tests related to endocrinology. Of course, “normal” lab values are usually defined to be a certain number of standard deviations from the population mean, which means that by random chance alone a small percentage of “normal” people will have an abnormal value of a given laboratory test. When a clinician orders a bunch of laboratory tests on a patient, the likelihood that one of those tests will be “abnormal” will approach 100% the more tests are ordered. No wonder FM practitioners can always find lab abnormalities to chase. Of course, to correct those lab abnormalities, there are always many, many supplements to be sold. Indeed, arguably the IFM was founded as a means of marketing the supplements Jeffrey Bland sold. Mark Hyman, through his “Ultrawellness” brand, also sells a lot of supplements.
Functional oncology in action
This brings us back to the case report. The authors include Elliot T. Taxman, BA; Erin D. Conlon, BS; Alex Speers, BA; Kristin L. Dismuke, BS; Tonya S. Heyman, MD, FACOG; Thomas L. Taxman, MD, FAAP. It turns out that Elliot Taxman, Erin Conlon, and Alex Speers are all students at the National College of Natural Medicine, while Tonya Heyman is a gynecologist specializing in “integrated personalized medicine” and Thomas Taxman is a pediatric gastroenterologist and functional medicine practitioner. The physicians are located at the Cleveland Health Institute in Lyndhurst, OH, which is a suburb of Cleveland. Given that the authors are all affiliated in some way with an “integrative medicine” clinic, I wasn’t sure where the patient discussed was treated for real. (I mean real cancer treatment, as opposed to the quackery she was subjected to in addition to her cancer treatment in a “complementary” fashion.) Perhaps it was at the Seidman Cancer Center at the University Hospitals of Cleveland, given that Dr. Taxman is an assistant clinical professor at the Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine.
Be that as it may, here is the clinical presentation as described in the case report:
An 80-year-old Caucasian female patient presented to an integrative medicine clinic in December 2012 with a 1-month history of a tender right breast. Her history was significant for arthritis, obesity, hypothyroidism, chronic gastritis, and hypertension. Her current medications included hydrochlorothiazide and triamterene, quinapril hydrochloride, levothyroxine sodium, and esomeprazole. Her family history was positive for breast cancer (daughter at age 46 y and sister at age 70 y). Physical exam revealed an erythematous, warm mass with irregular borders and localized skin thickening palpated across both upper quadrants of the right breast. The mass measured approximately 15 × 10 × 5 cm. In addition, a prominent 1-cm right axillary lymph node was noted.
This presentation sounds like that of an uncommon and particularly nasty form of breast cancer known as inflammatory breast cancer (IBC). IBC is characterized clinically by more than half the breast being involved with an inflammation-like reaction and pathologically by tumor cells in the dermal lymphatics (the lymph vessels right under the skin). The standard treatment for this aggressive form of breast cancer is neoadjuvant chemotherapy (chemotherapy before surgery), a modified radical mastectomy (removal of the breast and the axillary lymph nodes), followed by post-mastectomy radiation therapy to the chest wall. By definition, IBC is at least stage IIIB. On the other hand, IBC is a clinical diagnosis. Absent a skin biopsy showing tumor cells in the dermal lymphatics, its diagnosis is purely clinical so this woman might not have had IBC. Still, from the description, it looks as though neoadjuvant chemotherapy was appropriate:
Mammography revealed increased irregular density in the central upper quadrants of the right breast. A subsequent ultrasound noted a mass in the right breast that was highly suggestive of malignancy and the accompanying guided biopsy concluded invasive ductal carcinoma, grade 3, with involvement of a right axillary lymph node. A magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on January 7 confirmed the previous diagnosis and indicated that a small mass was found in the left upper outer quadrant of the left breast. A follow-up sonogram and mammogram of the left breast confirmed the MRI findings. She was given a Breast Imaging-Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) score of 6 and her cancer was concluded to be ER/PR negative and HER2 positive.
A tumor that lacks estrogen receptor and progesterone receptor but does have amplified HER2 almost always gets neoadjuvant chemotherapy consisting of a regimen of cytotoxic chemotherapy combined with Herceptin, which targets HER2. The patient underwent a bone scan and PET-CT scan, the latter of which is bit of overkill, because PET-CT has never been shown to be superior to CT alone in the setting of breast cancer. Both were negative, which means that the patient was not stage IV and the title of the case report, “Chemotherapy and Functional Medicine in a Patient With Metastatic Breast Cancer: A Case Report,” shows that the people writing and reviewing it were clueless about breast cancer. This woman did not have metastatic breast cancer, at least not the way a breast cancer surgeon and oncologist look at it. Lymph node metastases are generally considered regional disease. Use of the term “metastatic disease” tends to imply there are metastases to distant organs (i.e., stage IV disease), which is why breast cancer specialists distinguish between locoregional and distant metastatic disease; the implications are very different if a patient has a metastasis in an axillary lymph node (or even several) than it is when she has a metastasis in, say, liver, bone, or lung. The former still represents potentially curable disease, the latter does not. Be that as it may, this woman was potentially curable and was clearly in pretty good shape for an 80 year old if they were willing to give her chemotherapy, even though she did have a fairly typical litany of diseases and conditions of the elderly (arthritis, obesity, hypothyroidism, chronic gastritis, and hypertension). On the other hand, it’s not as though there was much choice, given that the cancer was ER/PR-negative and therefore estrogen blocking treatments were not an option.
In any case, what sounded like fairly standard chemotherapy was initiated, including docetaxel (Taxotere), carboplatin (Paraplatin), and trastuzumab (Herceptin) and underwent a right modified radical mastectomy after six cycles, followed by radiation therapy. She also underwent a left simple mastectomy (no evaluation of lymph nodes) for reasons that were unclear to me. She apparently had had something spotted in the right breast on her preoperative MRI, but it was never biopsied, as far as I can tell, and therefore never proven to have been cancer. Given that there is no survival benefit in doing it in the absence of a deleterious cancer-causing mutation, it’s hard enough to justify a prophylactic mastectomy on the other side in much younger woman, say 50 years old, but to do this operation on an 80 year old, whose life expectancy (and thus time remaining in her life to develop another life-threatening invasive cancer) is so much shorter, is questionable. Yes, they did find a small focus of ductal carcinoma in situ, but that would have been very unlikely to have progressed to endanger this patient’s life in her remaining time. Of course, the choice of surgery was on the conventional breast surgeon, not the FM doctors, but I felt obligated to point this out, given that we’re talking about my specialty here.
Now get a load of this chart, which shows what she got overall (click to embiggen):
She received 97 infusions of vitamin C. Yes, you read that right. In the eleven months or so that her complete science-based therapy of her breast cancer required, this woman was subjected to 97 unnecessary and potentially harmful infusions of ascorbate. Afterward, she received “sporadic” doses of vitamin C up through to August 5, 2014, which was one year after her mastectomy. Fortunately, she was tumor-free. As I’ve written before many times, there is no good evidence that high dose IV vitamin C has a clinically useful antitumor effect. No, Linus Pauling has not been vindicated, although FM practitioners, naturopaths, and other believers have been trying for decades.
But that’s not all this poor patient received.
She was placed on a dairy-free, gluten-free, low glycemic index diet for…why? Who knows? There’s no good evidence that such diets have an anticancer effect. She was also placed on the following supplements:
    • Melatonin: 20 mg QHS
    • Digestive enzymes AC
    • Probiotics: 60 billion CFU BID
    • Lactobacillus acidophilus NCFM
    • Bifidobacterium animalis Bi-07
    • Medical food shake bid
    • Vitamin D3: 5000 IU QD
    • EPA:DHA: 6000 mg QD
    • Wheat germ extract: 5.5 g QD
    • Oral vitamin C: 18-24 g QD
    • Standardized herbal inflammation relief supplement
One wonders why she was taking 18-24 g (that’s right, grams) of vitamin C per day in addition to the boatloads of vitamin C she was receiving intravenously three times a week. As for the rest, they probably don’t hurt, but there’s no reason to think they help. They add no detectable medical benefit, but they certainly do add cost. That’s not even counting the labs ordered. Chemotherapy patients get a lot of labs done, but look at the additional unnecessary labs ordered on this patient. The results take up more than two pages of the case report, and include amino acid levels, “gut immunology” markers, secondary bile acids, parasite tests, pancreatic enzyme levels, heavy metal levels, and, of course, the most beloved lab tests of FM practitioners and autism quacks, oxidative stress markers like glutathione and coenzyme Q10.
And I haven’t even listed them all. None of these tests were necessary. Almost certainly, none of them added any value to the patient’s care. Equally certainly, they added a great deal of cost to this patient’s care.
In fairness, what the FM practitioners added wasn’t all bad. An exercise program was started consisting of 10 minutes of bicycling a day working towards 30 minutes, Qigong classes, a sleep log, individual counseling and group support, and a part-time caregiver. None of these things, however, is the least bit “integrative” and could easily have been done by any oncologist, assuming the patient’s Medicare would pay for it.
The end result: Nothing
So what was the result after all of this? The patient survived two years, but the odds of her surviving five years were probably around 70% anyway with conventional therapy and probably 85% of surviving two years, based on her clinical presentation and final pathology, worse if she actually did have IBC. Try as they might, even the FM docs who wrote up this case report couldn’t make a case that what they did added anything to this patient’s care, other than getting her off of her hypertension medications, which could easily have been result of weight loss and exercise, coupled with a hypersensitivity reaction she suffered when her cardiologist changed her medications. Indeed check out the final paragraph:
This case is unique because of the integrated approach guided in part by nutritional and digestive evaluation (NutrEval) from a Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA)-certified laboratory testing company (Genova Diagnostics, Asheville, NC, USA) that was used in the management of this patient with advanced ductal breast carcinoma.5 Because this is a case report from the real world practice of medicine, it is not possible to determine the responsibility of the treatments in this patient’s success in achieving remission. Nevertheless, the patient survived her cancer with minimal side effects during treatment and is now in her third year of remission. This case study highlights the potential benefits of integrative therapy in the comanagement of patients with invasive ductal carcinoma of the breast.
No, we can say with a very high degree of certainty that the only benefits this patient experienced came from exercise, a personal care giver, counseling, and perhaps her sleep log. The high dose vitamin C, the dozens of lab tests, and all the supplements did her no good but certainly cost a lot of money. I can’t help but shake my head at this. In particular, I am amazed that the FM doctors presenting this case actually seem proud of what they did. They should be ashamed.
I am, however, glad they wrote up this case report, as crappy as it is. It shows what FM really is when in actual use. All those high-sounding ideals and principles, all the claims that FM treats the “underlying cause” of disease are revealed to be delusions when you just look at what FM doctors really do when treating cancer patients. Harriet Hall’s aphorism about CAM in general fits perfectly: What’s good about FM is not unique, and what’s unique about it is not good. My conclusion about FM is, in addition to Harriet’s, that it takes “making it up as you go along” to a whole new level, and that’s not a good thing in medicine.

“Functional medicine” in practice
“Functional medicine” is a form of quackery that combines the worst aspects of conventional medicine and alternative medicine. Specifically, it combines massive over-testing with a lack of science and a “make it up as you go along” ethic, all purportedly in the service of the “biochemical individuality” of each patient. Don’t believe the hype. It’s mostly quackery.
David Gorski on November 28, 2016
Link

I’ve frequently written about a form of medicine often practiced by those who bill themselves as practicing “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (or, as I like to refer to it, “integrating” quackery with medicine). I’m referring to something called “functional medicine” or, sometimes, “functional wellness,” which Wally Sampson first introduced to readers of this blog way back in 2008, and continued to educate our readers over multiple posts. Over the years, I’ve tried to explain why the term “functional medicine” (FM) is really a misnomer, how in reality it is a form of “personalized medicine” gone haywire, or, as I like to refer to it, as “making it up as you go along.” Unfortunately, thanks largely to its greatest popularizer, Dr. Mark Hyman, FM is popular, so much so that Bill and Hillary Clinton count Hyman as one of their medical advisors and the Cleveland Clinic, not satisfied with embracing prescientific traditional Chinese medicine, has gone “all in” for FM by hiring Dr. Hyman two years ago to set up a functional medicine clinic. Unfortunately, it’s been “wildly successful” there.
Unfortunately its success is not deserved, at least from a scientific standpoint.
The rights and wrongs of functional medicine
FM, like so much of integrative medicine, sounds good in principle. Look at its seven principles and, knowing nothing more than what these principles are, you’ll find it hard to disagree:
    • Acknowledging the biochemical individuality of each human being, based on concepts of genetic and environmental uniqueness
    • Incorporating a patient-centered rather than a disease-centered approach to treatment
    • Seeking a dynamic balance among the internal and external factors in a patient’s body, mind, and spirit
    • Addressing the web-like interconnections of internal physiological factors
    • Identifying health as a positive vitality—not merely the absence of disease—and emphasizing those factors that encourage a vigorous physiology
    • Promoting organ reserve as a means of enhancing the health span, not just the life span, of each patient
    • Functional Medicine is a science-using profession
In any post about FM, I feel compelled to remind our readers that the very first principle is, in essence, FM’s “get out of jail free” card for basically anything its practitioners want to do. They can always find ways to justify any form of treatment, be it science-based or quackery, simply by invoking the “biochemical individuality” of the human being whom they are treating. I also like to remind my readers of my retort to this: Yes, human beings are individuals, and each human being is unique. However, we’re not so unique that our bodies don’t all work pretty much the same way. In other words, in terms of biology, physiology, and yes, systems biology, human beings are far more alike than they are different. If that weren’t the case, modern medicine, developed before we had the tools to probe our genetic individuality, wouldn’t work as well as it does. FM fetishizes “biochemical individuality,” not so much because humans are so incredibly different that each one absolutely has to have a markedly different treatment. We’re not. FM fetishizes “individuality” because it distinguishes FM as a brand from science-based medicine and, I suspect, because it makes FM practitioners feel good, like “total” doctors never at a loss for an explanation for a patient’s symptoms or clinical condition, and makes patients feel like special snowflakes whose every bit of “individuality” is being catered to. As for the last bit about FM being a “science-using” profession, FM “uses” science more as a means of justifying whatever its practitioners do rather than guiding them to scientifically-proven treatments.
Here, it must be stated that are some things that FM gets right, although these things tend to be no different than the sorts of things every primary care doctor should be getting right anyway, such as emphasizing healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health (e.g., smoking). One advantage FM doctors have over primary care doctors practicing science-based medicine (SBM) is that, because insurance often won’t cover much of what they offer, FM doctors tend to spend more time with patients, which is something that primary care doctors have a harder time doing these days. They emphasize prevention, which is a good thing but again something that good primary care doctors do anyway. Unfortunately, the FM version of “prevention” isn’t always in line with the SBM version of prevention. Where FM doctors go so very wrong is in what Grant Ritchey described as a major unstated premise. That premise is that FM really does address the root causes of disease better than conventional medicine. FM also encompasses a lot of quackery, such as acupuncture, chiropractic adjustments, and especially “detoxification” programs. It’s little wonder that many naturopaths are very enthusiastic about FM.
Although I’ve discussed FM before and even shown how its use to treat a cancer patient led to enormous amounts of unnecessary treatments, what I haven’t really done is to show what typical FM clinics offer. Given that we’ve just finished enjoying (I hope) the Thanksgiving weekend and FM is, in part, all about the diet, I thought it might be interesting to survey a couple such clinics.
Lauren Grace
Although not a physician, Lauren Grace is a self-proclaimed functional medicine practitioner. She is a licensed acupuncturist and doctor of oriental medicine who did “additional study” in naturopathy, whatever that means. (Apparently it means that she uses mesotherapy, homeopathy, and something called the Maxim Life Health System, which purports to “take patients through a series of detoxes to eliminate any disease or disorder” and claims a 95% success rate.) I don’t remember where I first encountered Lauren Grace. I think it was on Twitter, but memory is foggy. I do remember, however, that she was laying down some really dubious medical advice and statements. Unfortunately, I can’t find them now. Fortunately, I don’t need to because there are plenty of other examples.
For example:
As is frequently the case with such practitioners, Grace starts out with reasonable advice about diet and not stopping exercising. However, by the time you get to the 4:30 mark, she’s suggesting “mini-cleanses” and selling her two week digestive cleanse, which, according to her, pretty much all of her patients do every three months anyway. For the holidays, she suggests three-day “cleanses” to get rid of “all those toxins.” What does this cleanse involve?
This:
There’s some serious woo here. For instance, Grace claims that, because there is a component of the immune system in the gut, cleansing the gut to make it “healthy” will boost your immune system. She even invokes the untrue claim about there being pounds of “rotting food” in your colon. Basically, to Grace, cleansing can fix all sorts of medical conditions, such as eczema, autoimmune diseases, digestive ills of all sorts. Amusingly, her cleanse seems to consist only of special magic smoothies, plus some supplements, a recipe guide, and a two week meal plan. The cost? $175. Oh, and the site has a quack Miranda warning right here.
I ran down the services offered by Ms. Grace and her physician collaborator Dr. Carter (who, for some reason, is listed only as “Dr. Carter,” no first name). Maybe this is why:
Dr. Carter is a Board certified physician who has been in practice for 22 years and over the last several years has focused on providing excellent care in the preventive medicine and minimally invasive cosmetic world. He was the previous owner, Cosmetic Surgeon and Functional Medical Physician at Atlanta Liposuction. His focus has always been on treating the patient as a whole, not only from an outward cosmetic improvement but from a naturopathic, holistic view which paves the way for overall health of the patient. Addressing the hormonal, adrenal, immune, GI and endocrine systems are all critical to balance for a truly successful and optimal outcome.
As the Medical Director here at Sarasota Integrative Health, Dr. Carter consults with Dr. Lauren Grace regarding client cases. He assists with diagnosis and treatment plans and contributes to the latest research studies in the field of functional medicine.
In case you’re wondering how Lauren Grace can provide medical services even though she doesn’t have a degree in medicine or even naturopathy, Dr. Carter is how. Amusingly (to me, anyway), Google reveals his name to be Dr. Michael Carter, and it didn’t even take Google Image Search!
Be that as it may, the services offered by Ms. Grace are fairly typical for an “integrative medicine” clinic, including quackery such as acupuncture, thermography (which is not a screening modality for breast cancer more effective than mammography), life coaching, and the like. However, for purposes of functional medicine, the money is in the description of integrative medicine and the “advanced lab testing” on Grace’s website. As with many other services, Grace offers this helpful video:
Grace starts out by saying that these are “not typical lab tests,” like the CBC. No kidding! Of course, she also claims that her tests are “much more preventative” and “much more advanced.” Personally, the FM definition of “preventative” tends to mean preventing disease by diagnosing lab abnormalities that have little or no effect on health or disease and then “treating” them. As for “much more advanced,” that’s a ludicrous claim. These lab tests don’t test anything that conventional lab tests can’t test. It’s just that FM doctors use them indiscriminately to test pretty much anyone with any symptom whatsoever, no matter how vague.
Let’s take a look at the sorts of tests offered:
    • Genova or Spectracell Single Panel: $175
    • Diagnostechs Female Hormone Panel: $150
    • Diagnostechs Male Hormone Panel: $150
    • Doctors Data Heavy Metal Test: $100
    • Germany Stool Panel DNA: $175
    • Diagnostechs ASI Panel: $150
    • Genova Rhythm Plus: $175
    • Genova Thyroid Panel: $150
There are even combo deals:
    • Any 2 test reads: $250
    • Any 3 test reads: $300
    • Any 4 test reads: $350
You know right away that you’re dealing with highly dubious tests by one name that stands out: Doctors Data Heavy Metal Test. Doctors Data, as you might recall, specializes in dubious hair tests and “provoked heavy metal tests.” Basically, these are tests in which patients are given a chelating agent and then their urine is collected and various heavy metals, such as mercury, are measured in it. The results are then compared to “standard” levels in patients who have not received a chelating agent, an inherently deceptive way of measuring metal levels. Let’s just say that Doctors Data is well known among those of us who try to refute antivaccine and autism quackery, as it’s the go-to lab quacks use to justify chelation therapy. Quackwatch has documented this extensively, and as a result Doctors Data has sued Steve Barrett.
But what about the other lab tests?
Check out Spectracell Micronutrient Testing:
Are you taking too many supplements? Not enough? Nutritional status is a vital foundation of health and performance. SpectraCell’s micronutrient testing is an innovative assessment of nutritional status. Unlike traditional serum, hair and urine tests, SpectraCell’s tests evaluate how an individual’s white blood cells respond to varied environments of over 32 vitamins, minerals, amino acids and antioxidants. As a result, individual differences in metabolism, age, genetics, health, prescription drug usage, absorption rate or other factors are taken into consideration. Nutrient Functions & Deficiency Symptoms.
Ah, yes. Another test to pander to the patient’s need to feel special and unique. Not only is there no convincing evidence that this method of “micronutrient testing” provides actionable information more useful than other tests or that its use results in better outcomes, but it’s not cheap. It does, however, produce pretty reports:

Then there’s the Genova GI Comprehensive Stool Panel:
By evaluating targeted biomarkers, the GI Comprehensive Stool Profile can reveal hidden conditions that other stool tests may overlook. Balancing gut microbiota is key for improving core gastrointestinal functions, such as digestion and absorption of nutrients, as well as metabolic functions.
I looked at a sample report. It’s a mix of standard tests and tests that are basically meaningless. For instance, there is a test for ova and parasites, which is a standard stool test with specific indications. Ditto tests for fecal blood, C. difficile, Campylobacter, H. pylori, and certain strains of E. coli. Then there’s a nonstandard test of sensitivity of various fungi in the stool to various antifungals, both natural and pharmaceutical. This is a test that is rarely indicated, but quacks love it for diagnosing the catch-all made up disease of “systemic candidiasis.” Yes, I know that systemic candida infections exist, but generally if candida has infected the whole body the patient is usually immunosuppressed and becomes sick as snot (a real medical term) as a result. Naturopaths, however, like to blame “chronic candidiasis” or other yeast infections for all manners of vague complaints. Basically, it’s another version of chronic Lyme disease. In addition, by testing basically everybody who wants to be tested for all the conditions Grace tests for, the false positive diagnosis rate will be astronomical.
Then, of course, there is the Genova Full Spectrum Allergy Panel:
Testing aids the clinician in the specific dietary change that is needed, helping to achieve positive outcomes sooner, even when combined with elimination or provocation testing.
Because FM loves to blame all manner of symptoms on various “allergies,” whether the patient has such an allergy by standard criteria or not. Consistent with FM, Grace offers all sorts of tests for female and male hormone levels, thyroid function, and, of course MTHFR mutations, one of latest dubious lab tests beloved of FM practitioners and naturopath quacks (but I repeat myself) everywhere.
Basically, FM takes one of the worst aspects of conventional medicine (the “shotgun” lab tests) with speculation based on science not yet validated in humans, and uses it to order batteries of lab tests on patients, which, because of the sheer number of lab tests, will virtually always discover “abnormalities.” Then, FM doctors will state that these “abnormalities” demand treatment. Never mind that in the vast majority of cases it’s unknown or unclear whether these abnormalities have any health significance.
The Grand Poobah himself
One might think it’s picking too easy a target to concentrate on someone like Lauren Grace, but she’s really not doing anything different than the Grand Poobah of Functional Medicine himself, Mark Hyman, who runs the Center for Functional Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic and is without a doubt the most famous and influential advocate for FM. Get a load of what is said about FM on the CCF website itself:
Cleveland Clinic Center for Functional Medicine physicians spend time with their patients, listening to their histories, mapping their personal timeline, and looking at the interactions among genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that can influence long-term health and complex chronic disease.
Perhaps you have experienced being examined by your doctor, having blood tests done, x-rays or other diagnostic tests taken, only for your doctor to report back that “all your tests are normal.” Yet, both you and your doctor know that you are unwell.
Unfortunately, this experience is all too common. Our physicians at the Center for Functional Medicine aim to reduce this problem by applying a new model that focuses on treating your body as a whole system, that treats the causes not only the symptoms, that sees the body as a whole organism, rather than simply a collection of organs. This emerging model of diagnosis and treatment – called Functional Medicine better matches the need to improve the management and prevention of chronic diseases.
By changing the disease-centered focus of medical practice to this patient-centered approach, our physicians are able to support the healing process by viewing health and illness as part of a cycle in which all components of the human biological system interact dynamically with the environment. This process helps to seek and identify genetic, lifestyle, and environmental factors that may shift a person’s health from illness to well being.
Damn those regular doctors practicing SBM! They run the standard lab tests and don’t find anything. Don’t worry, though. FM has way, way more lab tests to run. Dr. Hyman and his acolytes will definitely find “abnormalities” to “treat,” no matter how hard they have to look or how many hundreds of individual nutrients, minerals, hormones, and chemicals they have to measure!
Now, again, I have to concede that not all of FM is bad. For instance:
A new patient consult will last approximately four hours, that consists of a medical consult with the physician, nutrition counseling, education on laboratory testing and health coaching. We are committed to addressing all of your concerns and will provide recommendations as well as construct a personal health plan.
If you are traveling from out of town, please arrange overnight accommodations and be sure to fast prior to your appointment for same-day laboratory testing. You need to bring insurance cards, current medications and vitamins. It’s very important to also bring your medical records if they were not already sent.
A four hour visit with a physician, dietician, and a “health coach” could well be beneficial for many people. However, the price of that visit is the massive overtesting that FM mandates and that therefore comes along with that visit. Of course, the Cleveland Clinic is fairly vague about what actually happens at its Center for Functional Medicine, as is often the case for FM clinics, who don’t want to advertise the rank quackery that often falls under rubric of FM. If you wander over to Dr. Hyman’s website, however, you’ll find “detox” (of course), “ultrametabolism,” and this gem about autism:
TODAY MOST PEOPLE BELIEVE that Autism is a genetic brain disorder. I’m here to tell you that this isn’t true. The real reason we are seeing increasing rates of autism is simply this: Autism is a systemic body disorder that affects the brain. A toxic environment triggers certain genes in people susceptible to this condition. And research supports this position.
Think about it. Rates of autism have skyrocketed over the years, from an estimated 1 child in 3,000 to just 1 in 150 kids today. Sure, wider criteria for diagnosis and better detection might explain some of it but not an increase of this magnitude.
He dances around the issue of whether he thinks vaccines cause autism by noting that he treated a 2 year old boy named Sam who “was born healthy but diagnosed with autism after his vaccination for measles, mumps and rubella at 22 months,” noting:
Every child with autism has unique genetics, causes or triggers. And it is not usually one thing but a collection of insults, toxins and deficiencies piled on susceptible genetics that leads to biochemical train wrecks we see in these children.
In other words, “I’m not sayin’ it was the vaccines, you know, but it was the vaccines plus other stuff.” No wonder Hyman was willing to be co-author of an antivaccine book by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. In any case, Hyman subjected Sam to a huge battery of tests typical of the “autism biomed” movement and, as is usually the case, found all sorts of “abnormalities” in detoxification pathways (a favorite of autism biomed quacks), methylation (another favorite of autism biomed quacks), and oxidative stress (still another favorite). Of course, Dr. Hyman found elevated levels of aluminum and lead in Sam’s blood and antimony and arsenic in his hair. (Yikes! I thought Hyman, at least, would know not to use hair tests for metals. It sounds as though he probably used the typical quack tests for heavy metal “toxicity.”) Oh, and Sam was found to have multiple allergies and a “gluten sensitivity” as well, because, of course he did.
In any case, you can guess the rest. Sam improved, which is not necessarily unexpected, given that autism is a condition of developmental delay, not stasis. Sam “lost his autism diagnosis,” which happens in a significant proportion of autism cases. Most likely, Hyman’s nostrums had nothing to do with Sam’s loss of his autism diagnosis, but there’s no way of ever knowing for sure one way or another because there are no good clinical trials to tell us whether his nostrums do anything for the symptoms of autism.
Yes, this is the doctor in charge of a major clinic at a major academic medical center. Quackademic medicine rules in the form of functional medicine.
Functional medicine: Fake “individualization”
I’ve written before about how CAM and “integrative medicine” fetishize “individualization” of treatment über alles and how, unfortunately, that individualization is more akin to making it up as you go along than it is to any sort of science-based individualization. This is an aspect of all of CAM, and it strikes me, more than anything else, as a means of catering to the normal human desire to feel special. It also caters to the physician’s desire to feel like a “real” and “complete” doctor who can take care of the “whole patient” and handle basically anything. None of this is to say that it’s not important to individualize treatments, but such tailoring of treatment to patient must be based on evidence and science, coupled with what the patient values. It must be shown to produce superior outcomes. Functional medicine has failed that test.
Basically, FM borrows from the worst tendencies of conventional medicine through its indiscriminate use of dubious lab tests, all in the name of “individualization.” Unfortunately, FM is “individualization” run amok based on more on a desire to individualize for the sake of individualization more than anything else.

Functional medicine: Reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other
“Functional medicine” preaches the “biochemical individuality” of each patient, which is why one of its key features is that its practitioners order reams of useless lab tests and then try to correct every abnormal level without considering (or even knowing) what these abnormalities mean, if anything. So they make up fake diagnoses and profit.
David Gorski on December 17, 2018
Link

We’ve written about so-called “functional medicine” on many occasions before here at SBM. The reason, of course, is that, of all the forms of “integrative medicine” pseudoscience practiced, functional medicine “feels” the most like real medicine, so much so that it often even fools physicians into thinking there must be something to it. Indeed, the guru of functional medicine, Dr. Mark Hyman, who originally made a name for himself advising moneyed urbanites who retreat to Canyon Ranch in Lenox, Massachusetts, now counts Bill and Hillary Clinton as admirers. He’s also the founder of the Cleveland Clinic Center for Functional Medicine, which, unfortunately, has apparently been highly successful (financially, that is) thus far, complete with stealth advertising disguised as news reports in Ohio. That’s because one of the hallmarks of “functional medicine” is the ordering of lab tests—lots and lots and lots and lots of laboratory tests. There’s a reason that I’ve described functional medicine as the “worst of both worlds”. It combines the massive overtesting and overtreatment that can happen in conventional medicine with pure quackery, like “detoxification,” naturopathy, homeopathy, and chiropractic. It’s basically “making it up as you go along” with respect to interpreting the dozens (sometimes hundreds) of laboratory tests ordered by functional medicine practitioners, plus treating fake diseases, like “adrenal fatigue” or “leaky gut.” Speaking of chiropractic, what spurred me to discuss functional medicine again is an article by a chiropractor named William Cole, “Feeling Off? These Are The Tests To Have Your Doctor Run.” It’s basically an article that encompasses all that is wrong with the very construct that is “functional medicine” in a single article.
Functional medicine
Before I get to the article itself, let’s briefly discuss functional medicine itself. There’s a reason the construct attracts not just physicians, but alternative medicine practitioners as well. The lab testing and false claims of being able to understand what the results of all those lab tests mean can be attractive to doctors, but its claims of “getting to the true cause” and how each person has “biochemical individuality” are particularly attractive to quacks, such that we now often see naturopaths and chiropractors claiming to practice “functional medicine.”
It’s actually a very old paradigm—old as in “ancient”—tarted up and combined with science-y sounding jargon. What do I mean by ancient? Well, let’s just reconsider the seven “precepts” or “principles” of FM yet again:
    • Acknowledging the biochemical individuality of each human being, based on concepts of genetic and environmental uniqueness
    • Incorporating a patient-centered rather than a disease-centered approach to treatment
    • Seeking a dynamic balance among the internal and external factors in a patient’s body, mind, and spirit
    • Addressing the web-like interconnections of internal physiological factors
    • Identifying health as a positive vitality—not merely the absence of disease—and emphasizing those factors that encourage a vigorous physiology
    • Promoting organ reserve as a means of enhancing the health span, not just the life span, of each patient
    • Functional Medicine is a science-using profession
In any post about functional medicine, I feel compelled to remind our readers that the very first principle is, in essence, functional medicine’s “get out of jail free” card for basically anything its practitioners want to do. They can always find ways to justify any form of treatment, be it science-based or quackery, simply by invoking the “biochemical individuality” of the human being whom they are treating. I also like to remind my readers of my retort to this: Yes, human beings are individuals, and each human being is unique. However, we’re not so unique that our bodies don’t all work pretty much the same way. In other words, in terms of biology, physiology, and yes, systems biology, human beings are far more alike than they are different. If that weren’t the case, modern medicine, developed before we had the tools to probe our genetic individuality, wouldn’t work as well as it does. Functional medicine fetishizes “biochemical individuality”, not so much because humans are so incredibly different that each one absolutely has to have a markedly different treatment. We’re not. Functional medicine fetishizes “individuality” because it distinguishes functional medicine as a brand distinct from science-based medicine and, I suspect, because it makes functional medicine practitioners feel good, like “total” doctors never at a loss for an explanation for a patient’s symptoms or clinical condition, and makes patients feel like special snowflakes whose every bit of “individuality” is being catered to.
As for being a “science-using” profession”, functional uses science the same way a drunk uses a lamp post – not for illumination, but for support. Just look at the way functional medicine guru Mark Hyman has mangled autism science and systems biology, and you’ll soon realize that this is true. Also, any specialty that is willing to consider homeopathy as anything other than rank quackery cannot claim to be science-based.
But what’s ancient? Well, let’s look at its focus on “imbalances”:
     1.  Hormonal and Neurotransmitter Imbalance
     2.  Oxidation Reduction Imbalances and Mitochondropathy
     3.  Detoxification and Biotransformational Imbalances
     4.  Immune and Inflammatory Imbalances
     5.  Digestive, Absorptive, and Gut Microbiological Imbalances
     6.  Structural Imbalances from Cellular Membrane Function to the Musculoskeletal System
     7.  Mind-Body/Body-Mind Imbalances
Does this remind you of anything? How about “imbalances” in the four humors? Or “imbalances” in the Five Elements in traditional Chinese medicine. Basically, functional medicine also fetishizes “balance” in a way that sounds very much like both ancient Asian and European medicine. It’s a philosophy more than a scientific principle. Mark Hyman, of course, is guilty of all these things, as are other prominent functional medicine advocates.
There’s also a variant of the “principles” of FM that I’ve come across. It’s similar, but with some differences:
FM has five basic principles. 1. We are all genetically and biochemically unique so it treats the individual, not the disease. 2. It’s science-based. 3. The body is intelligent and has the capacity for self-regulation. 4. The body has the ability to heal and prevent nearly all the diseases of ageing. 5. Health is not just the absence of disease, but a state of immense vitality.
Notice that part about the body being “intelligent”? Doesn’t that sound rather vitalistic to you? Of course, one other part is rather ridiculous, namely #4. If the body truly has the capacity to heal and prevent nearly all the diseases of aging, then why does every single human being eventually die? Why is it still quite uncommon for a human being to live beyond 100 years? Functional medicine mavens would claim it’s because of the “toxins” and our lifestyle choices, and it’s true that our lifestyle choices can contribute to and exacerbate chronic disease (one of the few things they get right), but it does not follow from that that if we did all the happy magical things functional medicine practitioners suggest that almost none of us would suffer from diseases of aging. We all would, although perhaps at a more advanced age. It would also still be true that none of us would live forever.
Now, back to the chiropractor.
Lab tests galore!
You can see the elements of functional medicine that I discussed above coming into play immediately right from the very beginning of Cole’s article:
When we’re not feeling our best—maybe we’re suffering from chronic bloat, migraines, fatigue, or insomnia—it’s tempting to search for that one hidden illness, dysfunction, or deficiency. The truth, however, is that every system of our body is inextricably connected to others, and health problems are almost always multifactorial—due to a number of different dysfunctions and imbalances that, over time, finally show up as various symptoms.
As a functional medicine practitioner, I run a lot of labs. They are great for pinpointing specific problem areas and help guide my treatment recommendations in a major way. And while it is important to remember that every person’s health case and biochemistry is unique—and health issues are often caused by a lot of small problems rather than one big one—talking to your doctor about testing is a great place to start.
Of course, Cole is not a doctor so he might not be able to order blood tests, depending on the state. Instead, he might have to have real doctors order blood tests. In any event, he’s basically telling people to do one thing that is rarely helpful when you have a health issue: Ask your doctor to order a bunch of lab studies. Cole even implicitly admits that these labs are not indicated in the next paragraph:
Unfortunately, many of these test won’t be covered by insurance (although you should always call and check to be sure!), and unless you have a particularly open-minded conventional medical doctor who is willing and has the time to explore these tests with you, the typical general practitioner probably won’t be ordering these tests on the reg or be comfortable making them part of your treatment plan. Because of this, I’d recommend working with an integrative or functional medicine doctor who is well-versed in these labs and how to read them from a holistic perspective.
The reason, of course, that insurance doesn’t cover most of these tests and that “conventional” physicians won’t order them is because they are unhelpful, useless, and/or not based in science and evidence. I once discussed a functional oncology case report published by naturopaths. They ordered dozens upon dozens of laboratory tests and prescribed a boatload of supplements for this poor woman with breast cancer, and the only things they did that arguably helped her were to prescribe exercise, a personal care giver, counseling, and perhaps her sleep log. Everything else was not evidence-based and almost certainly at best useless and at worst potentially harmful. All of it cost a lot of money.
But, hey, if you can’t get a real doctor to order you all the useless functional medicine tests Cole recommends, then Cole’s more than happy to recommend at-home tests:
If that’s not in the cards for financial or other reasons, another option would be to order the labs yourself. Companies like Thorne, EverlyWell, and Found My Fitness all have at-home tests you can purchase, administer yourself, and send in to be processed. These can also be pricey and time-intensive, but if you’re feeling less-than-optimal and you’ve explored the standard options offered by conventional medicine without any success, they can be great options. Many of them come with a detailed description of your results or a health plan based on your results.
I perused the lab tests offered by these companies. They include (of course) tests to measure heavy metals (e.g., cadmium, lead, mercury, zinc, copper, etc.) from a blood spot on filter paper; hormones using saliva and a blood spot; an “adrenal fatigue” factors using saliva; testosterone levels; vitamin D; thyroid hormones; and the like. There are “metabolism panels”, “methylation profiles”, micronutrient reports, and other tests favored by quacks. Not surprisingly, given that these tests are not evidence-based and certainly not optimal (saliva and blood spots are not the best source to measure many of these factors), there’s a quack Miranda warning on the websites of the companies selling the tests. (A quack Miranda warning goes something like this: “the tests we offer are not intended to diagnose or treat disease, or to substitute for a physician’s consultation” and the more common variant, “These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.”)
So what sort of labs does chiropractor Cole think you should have if you’re feeling a bit run down?
     1.  A 24-hour adrenal stress index
     2.  A full thyroid panel
     3.  Gut permeability labs
     4.  Sex hormone labs
     5.  Inflammation labs
     6.  Genetic testing
I’m surprised he didn’t include tests for chronic Lyme disease, candida, “heavy metal toxicity,” or “gluten sensitivity” (hint: there appears to be no such thing as non-celiac gluten sensitivity), other favorites as The One True Cause of All Diseases among quacks.
Adrenal fatigue, of course, is a fake disease. It’s a wastebasket diagnosis for people with symptoms like this:
     1.  You feel tired for no reason.
     2.  You have trouble getting up in the morning, even when you go to bed at a reasonable hour.
     3.  You are feeling rundown or overwhelmed.
     4.  You have difficulty bouncing back from stress or illness.
     5.  You crave salty and sweet snacks.
     6.  You feel more awake, alert and energetic after 6PM than you do all day.
It becomes clear if you look at a typical diagnostic questionnaire for adrenal fatigue that it’s a dubious diagnosis. I took the questionnaire myself, and guess what? According to the questionnaire I have “moderate” adrenal fatigue myself! Get me to a naturopath, STAT, for some diet changes and supplements! Well, not so fast. The Hormone Foundation and The Endocrine Society both point out that adrenal fatigue is a bogus diagnosis. Adrenal insufficiency is a real diagnosis, and, yes, sometimes it’s not obvious to diagnose, leading to confusion, but there are definite diagnostic criteria to guide physicians in making it. But “adrenal fatigue” is a nonexistent diagnosis.
As I mentioned before, the symptoms of “adrenal fatigue” are nonspecific and could be indicative of many different conditions—or nothing at all. Using the criteria I’ve seen on various naturopath, “integrative medicine,” and chiropractic websites, I conclude that nearly everybody suffers from some degree of “adrenal fatigue”; that is, unless one doesn’t ever have stress, is always happy, and eats a raw vegan diet, and even then one might still have “mild” adrenal fatigue.
Next up, thyroid:
Every cell of your body needs thyroid hormones to function, and unfortunately for us, many underlying thyroid problems don’t show up on standard labs because conventional medical doctors typically only run TSH and T4. A full thyroid panel is a blood test that looks at TSH and T4 but also at T3 uptake, total T3, free T4, free T3, reverse T3, and thyroid antibodies to give you the most accurate picture of your thyroid health and rule out possible autoimmune thyroid problems. Functional medicine also has a narrower reference range for what constitutes a “healthy” thyroid, which can explain why you may still be experiencing symptoms but haven’t yet been diagnosed with a thyroid problem.
As for thyroid disease, yes, sometimes nonspecific symptoms of feeling “run down” or “out of it” can be an indication of hypothyroidism, but there are usually other clinical indications of thyroid disease. As Harriet Hall has pointed out, most thyroid tests marketed by people like Cole for screening for thyroid disease are not helpful (and messing around with T3 is dubious). Notice, however, the very last part about how functional medicine has a “narrower reference range” for normal thyroid labs? That’s so that functional medicine doctors can treat more people for “thyroid problems”. I mean, do you really think that a chiropractor or an association of “functional medicine” advocates dedicated to overtesting and overtreating is more likely to have the most useful normal range of thyroid tests nailed than, say, actual endocrine physicians and scientists? If you look at his article on thyroid labs, you’ll also see this tidbit:
If you still have low thyroid symptoms and your TSH is “normal,” something is not being addressed. How do we get the “normal” lab range anyway? The reference range is based on a statistical average of the population of that lab. This is why, other than vitamin D and cholesterol levels, lab reference ranges will vary depending on the lab.
The people who typically have work done on labs — in other words, the population of that lab — are statistically not the healthiest segment of the population. So if the lab results are “normal” despite your having symptoms, what your doctor is essentially saying is you’re just like a lot of other sick people.
In functional medicine, we look at a much narrower range where your body functions optimally and you feel great, in perfect health.
There isn’t a facepalm big enough for this except perhaps this one:

I can sense our resident clinical pathologists getting concussions from all the facepalming. Does Cole really think that the population isn’t taken into account, that the reference ranges for thyroid function tests aren’t determined from healthy people without known thyroid disease? Here’s how reference ranges are really determined. I also can’t help but point out that in surgery, we sometimes say that the enemy of good is “perfect”. It’s in trying to make good results “better” or “perfect” during an operation that bad things happen, like accidentally cutting the aorta. I’ve described functional medicine as basically ordering every lab under the sun and then chasing the results and then using supplements, micronutrients, and other measures to try to make them perfect. Apparently Cole agrees with me that functional medicine is the chasing of the elusive “perfect” lab values.
As for the rest, measuring hormone levels outside of a specific indication is fraught with problems. Contrary to what Suzanne Somers or those promoting testosterone supplementation say, hormone supplementation is not an anti-aging panacea. “Leaky gut” is another fake diagnosis. “Inflammation panels” are rarely informative, and genetic testing should really only be done in concert with a genetic counsellor and/or physician skilled in the interpretation of the results. Basically, Cole is advocating tests that are expensive, whose results often can’t be interpreted and are not useful for guiding treatment, and that often lead to taking expensive and useless supplements.
Mitchell and Webb summed it up best
As I read Cole’s article, I couldn’t help but be reminded of a famous Mitchell and Webb comedy sketch about homeopathy. It’s pretty close to as applicable to functional medicine as to homeopathy if a few changes are made. For example, in my functional medicine version of the sketch, the doctors portrayed by Mitchell and Webb would be measuring hormone and metabolite levels of the trauma patient and maybe testing him for adrenal fatigue while giving him large doses of intravenous vitamin C while his condition deteriorated:
Of course, the part that is most applicable to functional medicine is this line near the end:
…when someone comes in with a vague sense of unease, or a touch of the nerves, or just more money than sense, you’ll be there for them, a bottle of basically just water in one hand, a huge invoice in the other.
In my functional medicine version of this sketch, all I’d change would be the part about a “bottle of basically just water in one hand, a huge invoice in the other,” for which I’d substitute something like “reams of useless and impossible-to-interpret lab results with a plan to correct each and every one of them in one hand, a huge invoice in the other.”
Now that’s functional medicine in a nutshell.

Dietetics: Embracing Integrative and Functional Medicine?
The Accreditation Council for Education in Dietetics is planning on changing the accreditation standards for requirements Registered Dietitians to include integrative and functional nutrition as core components. This should worry science-based practitioners, and the general public.
Kevin Klatt on January 10, 2017
Link

Ed. Note: Harriet Hall was injured in a fall in Australia earlier this month. While she recovers, we are running guest posts in her regular Tuesday slot for as long as our supply of guest posts lasts. (Hint: If you ever thought of submitting a guest post and want a shot at your guest post being published on a Tuesday, now’s the time.) We wish Harriet well and hope she recovers sufficiently to resume blogging soon.
Kevin Klatt is one such contributor, a Nutritional Sciences PhD candidate and dietetics student who blogs at nutrevolve.blogspot.com. Welcome Kevin!

Registered Dietitians (RDs) are credentialed nutrition professionals who work across a broad range of clinical and public health settings to provide general nutrition recommendations and medical nutrition therapy. To become a RD, an individual must complete a set of core coursework (the Didactic Program in Dietetics) toward a Bachelor’s degree (at least), complete an accredited dietetic internship, and pass a final national examination. These standards, however, are set to change; as with many other allied health professions (e.g. Physical Therapists, Physicians Assistants, Nurse Practitioners), the dietetics profession is planning to move the RD credential to a graduate Master’s level as part of their proposed future education model. While advancing the education standards for a profession is generally seen as a smart opportunity for improving the practitioner’s entry level knowledge, the proposed education standards accompanying this shift to a Master’s degree reveal some cause for concern, for those who value science & evidence based nutrition.
The draft future standards for dietetics
In the latter half of 2016, the Accreditation Council for Education in Dietetics (ACEND), the accrediting agency for dietetic education programs, released their Draft Future Education Model Accreditation Standards for Associate, Bachelor’s and Master’s level dietetic practitioners, and their rationale for doing so. The language of the proposed standards, coupled with the proposed rationale, contain the expected education standards for a dietitian: foundational knowledge in physiology, biochemistry and genetics; fundamental knowledge regarding nutrient metabolism; understanding of pathophysiology of disease and where medical nutrition therapy might be employed; and basic counseling skills. Lumped in with these core components of dietetic practice is ‘integrative and functional nutrition’ terminology. For regular readers of the SBM website, this should raise red flags, as integrative medicine represents little more than a rebranding of complementary and alternative health.
The functional brand works its way into the curriculum
The proposed standards work the ‘integrative and functional’ language into the ‘Competencies and Performance Indicators’ section. For example, the Foundational Knowledge Competency 1.8 states that practitioners will apply ‘knowledge of pharmacology and integrative and functional nutrition to recommend, prescribe and administer medical nutrition therapy’. Another competency, under Client and Patient Services, is described as: ‘Prescribes or recommends nutrition-related pharmacotherapy and integrative and functional nutrition’. The language of ‘integrative and functional’ sticks out here, as it is not clearly defined within the standard what makes a therapy ‘integrative and functional’ (this issue of unnecessary branding is an issue for all ‘integrative medicine’). As someone familiar with the long time co-opting of nutrition therapies by alternative practitioners who themselves promote other dubious or harmful therapies, the inclusion of this wording in the dietetic education standards is a loaded association. I’m all for dietitians being aware of alternative medicine practices for safety and efficacy conversations with the whole healthcare team, but adoption of uncritical language that suggests RDs should ‘prescribe or recommend’ integrative and functional therapies is worrisome. Additionally, the use of the terminology is confusing, given that it is not used throughout the documents; some competencies just use the terminology of ‘nutrition interventions’ or provides ‘nutrition care’ – why, for a few competencies, was the ‘integrative and functional’ language chosen?
Why it was included
To understand the thinking behind the proposed education model, ACEND released a rationale document [PDF]; the rationale provided for the inclusion of integrative and functional medicine is as concerning as the actual use of this language (note: the rationale document has not been updated on the ACEND website in over a year). The document provides the details of healthcare and industry environmental scans that identified an increasing focus on ‘integrative healthcare’. Essentially, a major component of the rationale for including the ‘integrative’ language for medical nutrition therapies was to meet a market demand, not a deficit in current practices employed by RDs.
In addition to this environmental scan, ACEND released surveys to practitioners to judge their perspective on the importance of specific topics. The responses of 6,267 practitioners ranked the importance of applying ‘integrative nutrition principles to nutrition care and medical nutrition therapy, including the use of nutritional genomics, dietary supplements, and/or herbal remedies’ as 3.56 out of 4. Given this item’s wording, it’s impossible to determine how RDs feel about utilizing the integrative and functional nutrition terminology, or whether those responding have a clear understanding of the practices associated with the term. It is not surprising that this item received a high score, given that RDs have long recommended supplements when diet is unable to meet nutrient needs (e.g. b12 for vegan clients/patients), and are likely interested in learning about recent developments in areas with preclinical potential (e.g. nutrigenetics). What’s unclear in the rationale provided by ACEND is, what makes these practices ‘integrative’? I would argue that, if anything, RDs should be trying to reclaim medical nutrition therapies from their supposed ‘integrative’ counterparts (naturopaths, chiropractors) who have co-opted nutrition as somehow being outside the spectrum of evidence and science-based therapies. Instead of embracing this language, the field of dietetics might consider giving pause to further associating ourselves with integrative practitioners who do not practice evidence-based medicine.
Some problematic sources
Probably the most concerning component of the rationale document is the one page description of ‘Integrative Health Care and Integrative Medicine’. To discuss integrative medicine, ACEND cites three groups: The Institute of Medicine, the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine, and the (now defunct) Bravewell Collaborative, the latter two being notable advocates for the use of ‘integrative’ practices. The descriptions of ‘integrative medicine’ contains the typical handwaving about treating the whole person (mind, body, spirit) and focusing on prevention, as though these characteristics warrant their own brand of medicine. The ACEND document writers even rehash concerning statements from the Bravewell Collaborative, such as their emphasis on using effective interventions that are ‘natural’ whenever possible. As a profession, do RDs want to be adopting a philosophy that aligns itself with the appeals to nature fallacy? Naturalism has long invaded the popular culture perspective on nutrition (e.g. ‘Paleo diets’); acceptance of this philosophy due to a market demand is far from warranted or scientifically justifiable.
The consequences of embracing functional medicine
The consequences of using ‘integrative and functional’ language is particularly concerning when placed in the context of the field of dietetics as a whole. One of the major medical nutrition therapy textbooks, Krause’s Food and the Nutrition Care Process, often jokingly referred to as ‘The Dietitian’s Bible’, contains discussions of ‘integrative care’ which lack a critical perspective on the topic and often mixes aspects of historical practice, pseudoscience, mechanisms of action, and naturalism to produce clinically dubious recommendations. For example, in Chapter 6 on Biochemical Assessment (pages 172-173), there is a section on ‘functional nutrition assessment’ that highlights assessment of toxins entering the body, methylation and acetylation states, and antioxidants, hoping to ‘support the body’s natural mechanisms and restore balance and health’. Apart from textbook references, the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics hosts professional interest groups, one of which is the ‘Dietitians in Integrative and Functional Medicine’, a practice group focused on ‘holistic’ and natural medicines [PDF]. As one can see from exploring these resources, critical perspectives on integrative and functional philosophies are lacking in the field, and current resources serve as a caveat for how these philosophies can lead to enthusiastic acceptance of therapies which lack validated clinical utility (e.g. assessing ‘epigenetic’ states, many supplements) or are outright scientifically implausible (e.g. spirit healing, homeopathy).
The overall lack of a critical and cautionary perspective about the inclusion of integrative and functional language in dietetics coursework should leave current RDs, students, and other allied health professionals, concerned about how these standards will be instituted by dietetic programs. The notion that a didactic education standard should become a focus for the profession based on “the popular market” rather than the scientific evidence is also of concern. If the registered dietitian is to remain “the nutrition expert” it would serve the profession best to maintain a clear identity that is grounded in food/nutrition science and evidence-based therapies.
If the inclusion of this language is concerning to individuals as dietetic practitioners, please reach out to the ACEND (they have monthly virtual town hall meetings) or relevant members in the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. For individuals who are not part of the field of dietetics, the impact of the inclusion of this language is something to look out for – the curriculum of an entire medical profession is currently set to adopt language associated with practitioners who promote dangerous pseudoscientific thinking about health.

AAFP: Functional Medicine lacks supporting evidence; includes “harmful” and “dangerous” treatments
The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) found Functional Medicine lacking in evidence and said some treatments are harmful and dangerous. The AAFP is right and should stick to its conclusions.
Jann Bellamy on October 26, 2017
Link

In 2014, the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) placed a moratorium on continuing medical education (CME) credit for all programs related to Functional Medicine (FM) through 2018. The AAFP determined that
a lack of accompanying evidence existed to support the practice of Functional Medicine . . . [and the AAFP] identified some treatments as harmful and dangerous.
The AAFP will review its decision in February of 2018. To assist in the review, the AAFP issued a
call to collect peer-reviewed, evidence-based literature that supports claims for the efficacy of Functional Medicine practices and therapeutic modalities.
An online survey was posted for comments through October 6, 2017. Unfortunately, I discovered both the decision to ban FM courses from eligibility for CME credit and the call for comments after the deadline. As might be expected, the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM) is fully aware of the ban and has provided canned comments for FM practitioners as well as a list of references which presumably, in the IFM’s view, will provide the AAFP with the evidence of efficacy it seeks, as well as allay the AAFP’s fears that its practices are harmful and dangerous. If this is the best IFM can offer, I feel confident the AAFP’s ban will remain in place.
We’ll return to the IFM’s response in a moment. First, we’ll briefly review so-called “Functional Medicine” and take a look at the organization whose courses have come under the AAFP’s scrutiny, as well as the courses themselves.
What is Functional Medicine?
According to the IFM:
The Functional Medicine model is an individualized, patient-centered, science-based approach that empowers patients and practitioners to work together to address the underlying causes of disease and promote optimal wellness. It requires a detailed understanding of each patient’s genetic, biochemical, and lifestyle factors and leverages that data to direct personalized treatment plans that lead to improved patient outcomes. By addressing root cause, rather than symptoms, practitioners become oriented to identifying the complexity of disease. They may find one condition has many different causes and, likewise, one cause may result in many different conditions. As a result, Functional Medicine treatment targets the specific manifestations of disease in each individual.
This is a nice word salad, but it tells us nothing about how FM practitioners go about doing things like promoting optimal wellness, understanding each patient’s genetic, biomedical, and lifestyle factors and addressing root causes rather than symptoms.
Far better minds than mine have raised these same issues and gone looking for answers. Wally Sampson (also here, here, and here), David Gorski (also here, here, and here), Steve Novella and Harriet Hall (also here) have all taken a crack at it and have come away wanting for information, although they were able to gather bits and pieces from, for example, published case studies, which they found less than impressive. The medical literature isn’t much help because the proponents of FM have never bothered to set forth their “individualized, patient-centered, science-based approach” in any forum where actual scientists could evaluate it.
From what we’ve been able to gather, it appears that FM includes conventional practices like healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, and cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health, all of which are rebranded “Functional Medicine,” combined with a whole lot of lab testing – both unvalidated tests and conventional testing that is, in Dr. Gorski’s words, “massively misinterpreted and abused.” From these lab results, said genetic and biochemical “root causes” of disease are divined and “personalized treatment” instituted, which seems to involve a lot of dietary supplements, conveniently sold to the patient by the practitioner, plus assorted other quackery.
Or, as Dr. Sampson put it nearly a decade ago,
After extensive searching and examination, my answer is still – only the originators of “FM” know. Or, at least one must assume they know, because so far as I can see, I certainly see nothing that distinguishes “FM” from other descriptions of sectarian and “Complementary/Alternative Medicine” practices. A difference may lie in the advocates’ assumptions to have found some “imbalance” of body chemistry or physiology before applying one or more unproved methods or substances. From what I could determine, the “imbalance” or dysfunction is usually either imaginary or at least presumptive. And the general principles are so poorly defined as to allow practitioners vast leeway to apply a host of unproven methods.
Team SBM isn’t the only group both befuddled by FM’s word salads and concerned about the lack of evidence supporting its practices. In response to a “functional medicine case report” and accompanying editorial by Patrick Hanaway, Medical Director for the Center for Functional Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic, in a 2016 issue of The Permanente Journal, four physicians had this to say:
We certainly agree that approaching our patients in a holistic and caring manner is always best, but we are unaware of a scientific basis for the “unique operating system” and “personalized therapeutic interventions” suggested in these articles. Perhaps accidentally, Hanaway acknowledges that functional medicine does not have an adequate evidence base and relies on unproven suppositions when he writes, “As we move from Case Reports to randomized controlled trials and population-based trials, Functional Medicine research will offer insight into the best ways to improve the value of the care we offer.”
And, addressing the case report:
The patient in the case was assessed with a Comprehensive Digestive Stool Analysis 2.0 (CDSA 2.0) and a Nutritional Evaluation (NutrEval) by Genova Diagnostics. [The authors] claim that these tests offer insight into the patient’s functional status with regard to several of the proposed core pathways comprising functional medicine. . . . Although the case report documents improvement in patient-reported outcomes scores across three scales . . . attributing this improvement to the multitude of interventions presented in Table 3 of the article, “Stool and urine metabolic testing results and therapeutic interventions,” is dubious. Association is not necessarily causation.
Finally:
In Hanaway’s editorial, we noted with interest that randomized controlled trials comparing functional medicine with current standard care are underway at the Cleveland Clinic. But unless and until such clinical trials demonstrate efficacy of the functional medicine approach, we believe TPJ should not encourage Permanente physicians to incorporate functional medicine into clinical practice as it has done implicitly by publishing this case study and editorial.
Actually, Hanaway misrepresented the nature of the clinical trials at the Cleveland Clinic. They do not compare functional medicine with current standard of care. They compare standard of care alone with standard of care plus functional medicine, and one of them is a pilot, proof of concept study. As Edzard Ernst and Mark Crislip have pointed out, this type of trial almost guarantees that the results will favor the addition of functional medicine.
Uncovering the secrets of Functional Medicine, for a mere $15 grand
The only place you can learn the all of secrets of Functional Medicine practice appears to be the Institute for Functional Medicine’s proprietary courses, the very ones the AAFP refuses to recognize for CME credit. They aren’t cheap either, costing from about $1,500 to over $3,000 per course. It comes as no surprise that companies offering dubious lab tests and dietary supplement sellers are exhibitors and sponsors of these courses (see also here and here).
Completing seven of these courses (Applying Functional Medicine in Clinical Practice, GI, Detox, Energy, Hormone, Cardiometabolic, and Immune), presentation of one case report ($800 fee) and passing a test (another $800 fee), makes one eligible for a certificate that allows one to claim he or she is an “IFM Certified Practitioner.” Altogether, the IFM estimates the total cost of becoming certified at $12,000 – $15,000.
The IFM takes a big-tent approach to awarding IFM Certification. It is available on equal terms to MDs, DOs, dentists, naturopathic doctors, chiropractors, acupuncturists, nurses and nurse practitioners, registered dietitians, and pharmacists. IFM does not explain how it came to determine that chiropractors, naturopaths, and acupuncturists have sufficient education and training in endocrinology, gastroenterology, immunology and cardiology to pass their courses in, and knowledgeably practice in, those areas.
Unlike the AAFP, the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education, which is more tolerant of pseudoscience, has accredited the IFM as a CME provider. This means that MDs can get state-required CME credit for IFM courses, if not AAFP credit. Because PAs and nurses also allow AACME-accredited organizations to provide CME, those professions can get credit for IFM courses as well.
Whatever shortcomings the AAFP has observed, it doesn’t seem to have affected the IFM’s bottom line. Because it is a tax-exempt organization, it must file a Form 990 income tax return, available on the Guidestar website. According to the latest available return, its educational courses brought in revenue of almost $9 million in 2015.
Functional Medicine guru Mark Hyman, whose mangling of medical science and anti-vaccination sympathies have been called out before on SBM (also here) and by our good friend Orac (also here and here) is Chair of the Board. (No surprise there either.)
Also on the Board is naturopath Joe Pizzorno, a founder and former president of Bastyr, the premier naturopathic “medical school,” and instrumental in establishing a separate accrediting agency for naturopathic schools, which shields them from effective oversight of their pseudoscience-filled curricula. Pizzorno is co-editor of the naturopathic masterwork, The Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine, which tells us that 25% of the US population suffers from heavy metal poisoning. Pizzorno has given talks on “assessing body burden” and “detoxification” to the American Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine, both concepts rejected by medical science. Keep this in mind when we get to a discussion of IFM’s coursework.
In fact, the IFM is very naturopathy-friendly. Both of its Directors of Medical Education, are naturopaths, as are the Assistant Director of Medical Education and the Medical Education Program Coordinator.
IFM “Detox Advanced Practice Module”
That one of the seven courses required to become an IFM Certified Practitioner is called “Detox Advanced Practice Module” should be a big red flag for the AAFP. As we have explained many times here on SBM (also here), it is a fundamental tenet of alternative medicine that we are all infested with vaguely defined “toxins” which our natural “detoxification” systems (basically, the kidneys and liver) can’t get rid of. Thus, these “toxins” must be removed from our bodies with various “detoxification” interventions, lest we become ill. Dubious lab tests are sometimes employed to assist the practitioner in uncovering these “toxins.” IFM’s “Detox Advanced Practice Module” is Functional Medicine’s version of this medical fantasy.
According to the faculty,
we are what we absorb and fail to eliminate.
So, “patterns of clinical presentations with possible connections to toxic exposures” and “routine laboratory findings linked to toxicity” as well as “functional and genomic assays” will “aid in the assessment and treatment of toxicity cases.” Participants learn of the “detoxification-promoting Detox Care Food Plan . . . tailored to optimize your patient’s metabolic detoxification processes.” As well, they learn “which nutrients [i.e., dietary supplements] are involved in detoxification and biotransformation pathways . . . [and] address oxidative stress, along with cytochrome P450 enzymes and the conjugative pathways of phase 2. A “Functional Dentistry” expert helps participants “identify and address toxicity with a dental component.”
And so on. Sounds positively naturopathic.
Faculty include an MD who is the Chief Medical Officer of a dietary supplement company and a chiropractor who claims to treat autism, ADD, ADHD and developmental delays with “dietary plans, nutritional supplementation and detoxification strategies” which, of course, includes “essential laboratory testing . . . review of pertinent laboratory findings [and] customized dietary and nutritional supplementation,” as well as “testing for nutrient deficiency and chemical / metal toxic overload, nutritional needs based upon genetic profile.” Lest one think this sort of thing is beyond the capability of a chiropractor, not to worry. He is an IFM Certified Practitioner. Other quackery in his practice includes applied kinesiology testing, “Digital Meridian Imaging to diagnose the acupuncture imbalanced energy channels,” something called the “BioCranial technique – unlike any other cranial procedure to remove nerve interference throughout the whole body,” as well as the sacro-occipital technique and Activator “adjustments.” The dentist teaching “functional dentistry,” also an IFM Certified Practitioner, is a member of the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology, which engages in fear mongering about fluoridation and urges the removal of amalgam fillings.
The IFM’s response to the AAFP
As noted, the AAFP has issued a call for peer-reviewed, evidence-based literature that supports claims for the efficacy of Functional Medicine practices and therapeutic modalities. The IFM has suggested proponents respond with two paragraphs that make the same sort of vague, uninformative statements that have stumped others trying to figure out just what they are up to. Such as:
A major premise of Functional Medicine is that, with science, clinical wisdom, and a deep empathy for the patient, many of the underlying causes of chronic disease can be identified and interventions to remediate those causes can be addressed earlier and more effectively.
OK, but how? Show your work.
They also say:
The modalities taught in Functional Medicine are all focused on safety and efficacy with a deep underpinning in the peer-reviewed literature.
The Detox Advanced Planning Module has a “deep-underpinning in the peer-reviewed literature?” Where?
When pressed to come up with actual studies backing up FM’s claims, Hanaway, as noted by his critics, has pretty much admitted there aren’t any. What the IFM does offer in its response to the AAFP is a list of journal articles, but without any explanation as to how they support the practices of functional medicine. I have to assume that if there were a cogent justification for Functional Medicine supported by citations to the medical literature, the IFM would have come up with one. They didn’t and that speaks volumes. The burden is on them to do so, not on the AAFP to try to figure it out from a list of journal articles and obfuscatory language. That, as I said, gives me confidence the AAFP will come to the right decision and make its moratorium on Functional Medicine courses permanent. If I am wrong, the AAFP’s requirements for CME courses have no meaning.

AAFP should publish research behind finding that functional medicine lacks evidence, contains harmful and dangerous practices
For the public’s health and safety, the American Academy of Family Physicians should publish their research behind their claims that functional medicine lacks evidence, and contains harmful and dangerous practices.
Jann Bellamy on September 27, 2018
Link


The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) has partially lifted its moratorium on continuing education credit (CME) for courses in so-called “functional medicine,” but only to the extent that these courses give family practice doctors sufficient information to educate interested patients about the topic. “How-to” courses teaching various functional medicine techniques, modalities or applications for implementation in treating patients remain under the CME moratorium.
The AAFP’s decision was announced in AAFP News in March and later reprinted in the Annals of Family Medicine. Unfortunately, it is only by accessing these articles that physicians and the general public will learn the history and current rationale behind the AAFP’s decision: Previous literature reviews did not find sufficient evidence to support the use of functional medicine in family practice and “in some cases, determined the claims being made to be potentially dangerous”. Even then, we are not given a complete history of the AAFP’s review and left in the dark regarding what the research revealed or exactly which claims are “potentially dangerous”. Given the lavish claims made for functional medicine by practitioners and the paucity of research, the AAFP, in my opinion, has a duty to protect the public’s health, safety, and welfare by publishing its findings in full.
Speaking to AAFP News about the decision, the chair of the AAFP’s Commission on Continuing Professional Development (COCPD), Melody Jordahl-Iafrato, MD, explained that, following the AAFP’s third review of the evidence on functional medicine,
given the current lack of evidence, the COCPD does not deem it appropriate to learn how to practice functional medicine or implement related techniques within an AAFP-certified CME activity.
However,
The COCPD acknowledged that while sufficient evidence does not exist, patients still may be utilizing or asking about functional medicine; therefore, it’s important for [AAFP] members to be informed on the concept of functional medicine and what patients might be asking about regarding their health care and treatment options.
While, according to the COCPD chair, this may include some examples of techniques,
a session that teaches how to treat a specific disease – such as neurological or gastrointestinal disease – with functional medicine principles would not be eligible.
In a telling comment, Dr. Jordahl-Iafrato added this remark:
The AAFP Credit System strives to certify CME that is evidence-based, objective and balanced, which means benefits have been proven and all possible risks, side effects and negative outcomes should be acknowledged. Ideally, CME includes fair, balanced consideration of all usual and customary approaches and not only the approach preferred by the CME provider.
In other words, courses teaching physicians how to practice functional medicine do not meet these standards.
According to the AAFP News, the first review of functional medicine, in 2014, was in response CME providers getting inconsistent results when they applied for credit for their functional medicine courses. After a literature review, the AAFP made its initial determination that not only was there insufficient evidence to award CME credit, in some cases claims being made for functional medicine were “potentially dangerous”. Actually, according to, of all organizations, the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM), which “certifies” physicians, naturopaths, acupuncturists and chiropractors as functional medicine practitioners, the AAFP “identified some treatments as harmful and dangerous”. Perhaps the IFM was made aware of this conclusion in the AAFP’s response to its application for CME credit for its courses.
Based on this literature review, the AAFP placed a moratorium on functional medicine courses. A similar evidence review in 2016 came to the same conclusion and the moratorium was extended to 2018. In anticipation of that deadline, last year the AAFP issued a call for comment, including a request for evidence on functional medicine’s efficacy and any additional supporting evidence and/or literature. At the time, I expressed confidence that the AAFP would stick to its guns and continue the moratorium. Unfortunately, I was only partly correct.
Next,
the information received was objectively reviewed and summarized in a report by a third party and presented to the COCPD. That information, along with several literature reviews and results from the AAFP Member Survey, informed the [COCPD’s] decision to lift the moratorium on functional medicine.
That decision was reviewed by the AAFP’s Board of Directors. The end result is a new question under “AAFP Credit System FAQ” – “Are Functional Medical topics eligible for AAFP credit?” The answer simply sets forth the new policy in anodyne terms, approving the overview, but not the “how-to,” courses. While it refers to the literature reviews, it does not mention the lack of evidence, or “potentially dangerous” claims, or “harmful and dangerous” treatments.
Predictably, the IFM lamented that the AAFP’s decision “wasn’t the exact outcome we had hoped for” but was “thrilled to see AAFP take a step forward and recognize the merits of Functional Medicine,” which the AAFP most certainly did not. The IFM explained that,
in an effort to provide a better understanding of how our programs were developed, we supplied AAFP with evidence-based literature and clinical feedback demonstrating the efficacy, safety, and effectiveness of Functional Medicine education for all family physicians. In addition, we asked our physician partners to participate in the “call for comment” process.
Putting it a different way, IFM gave the AAFP its very best effort and still came up short.
Support was not unanimous. Although the comments have not been released, the Michigan Academy of Family Physicians, to its credit, posted its comment calling for a continuation of the moratorium “because there remains much unknown about functional medicine”.
SBM’s evidence review
Fortunately for the public, over the years, SBM has conducted its own evidence review of sorts of functional medicine. As we’ve discussed numerous times, despite patronage from the venerable Cleveland Clinic, whose own genetics experts have called out functional medicine for its dubious use of genetic testing and supplement prescribing, the safety and efficacy of functional medicine, as the AAFP itself determined, has yet to be established. In fact, it’s hard to know exactly what functional medicine is, other than a marketing term, partly because there is no detailed explication of its principles and practices anywhere in the medical literature. For that (if it exists at all), physicians, chiropractors, naturopaths and the like must attend the IFM’s proprietary courses, to the tune of about $15,000, to become “certified” in functional medicine.
Wally Sampson (also here, here, and here), David Gorski, (also here, here, and here), Steve Novella, and Harriet Hall (also here) have all taken a crack at trying to fathom functional medicine and have come away wanting for information, although they were able to gather bits and pieces from, for example, published case studies, which they found less than impressive.
From what little information is available, it appears that functional medicine includes conventional practices like healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, and cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health, all of which are rebranded “functional medicine,” combined with a whole lot of lab testing – both unvalidated tests and conventional testing that is, in Dr. Gorski’s words, “massively misinterpreted and abused.” From these lab results, said genetic and biochemical “root causes” of disease are divined and “personalized treatment” instituted, which seems to involve a lot of dietary supplements, conveniently sold to the patient by the practitioner, plus assorted other quackery.
Functional Medicine guru Mark Hyman, whose mangling of medical science and anti-vaccination sympathies have been called out before on SBM (also here) and by our good friend Orac (also here and here) is Chair of the Board of IFM. Naturopath Joseph Pizzorno, is on the Board as well. Pizzorno is co-editor of the naturopathic masterwork, The Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine, which Dr. Hall thoroughly shredded in a recent post. Faculty at past IFM presentations include a cell phone radiation alarmist who warned against keeping your cell phone in your bra (debunked here), a dentist who advocates removing amalgam fillings based on mercury fear-mongering, a chiropractor who spoke on “Ensuring a Safe Detox Program: Applying Oral Chelation Therapy to Reduce an [nonexistent] Elevated Heavy Metal Burden with Case Studies,” a naturopath whose clinic offers hyperbaric oxygen therapy and IV therapy delivering “micronutrients and pharmaceuticals” for, among other things, “support for detoxification” and “heavy metal chelation”, and an MD who authored “a guide to mastering one’s genes to reverse disease.” Unfortunately, most of these courses were approved for CME credit by the ACCME, which is decidedly more tolerant of pseudoscience, having not only accredited IFM as a CME provider, but accredited it with commendation.
While I’d like to think SBM’s information on functional medicine is persuasive, and that our posts might be consulted by anyone thinking of becoming a functional medicine practitioner or seeing one as a patient, I am far from sanguine that the science-based medicine community alone can stem the tide of pseudoscience being introduced into medical practice by the purveyors of functional medicine. Given the Cleveland Clinic’s and the ACCME’s complicity, it is of utmost concern that no one from within the medical establishment has come forward to oppose the rosily simplistic deceptions coming from the IFM and the Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Functional Medicine. If the AAFP had similar misgivings about a drug or conventional medical practice, I feel certain they would release their research and warn the public. It is a mystery to me why the AAFP is pulling its punches with functional medicine.
Author’s note: On Monday, I emailed the AAFP ([email protected]) asking for the literature reviews and other information on which they based their CME decision. A quick response simply referred me to the new policy and information on CME standards. I replied that this was not the information I needed, adding that I thought “it incumbent upon the AAFP to release its evidence reviews in the interest of the public health, safety and welfare”. There has been no response to that email.

The NCCIH embraces the quackery that is “functional medicine”
David Gorski on September 30, 2024
Link
[Editor note: Regular readers might—or might not have—noticed last Monday that, for the first time in more years than I can remember, I failed to post anything and didn’t even repost something from the archives or announce my absence. The explanation is unfortunately all too simple. The Sunday before, I spent something like 13 hours in the hall of at the emergency room of a local hospital with my father, who had called me early Sunday morning. (Fortunately, he’s OK now, but was admitted for a couple of days.) The exact nature of the medical problem that precipitated this ER visit is not something I’m going to discuss publicly other than to note that our ER sojourn made it impossible for me to complete a post by Monday and that, unfortunately, no one could fill in at the last moment, not even Dr. Howard. In any case, I’m back. To get back into the groove, I thought I’d discuss something that’s been sitting in my fodder folder since June about NCCIH, because, well, you’ll see. Hint: It involves functional medicine.]
On this blog, we have been very critical of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), which until several ago had gone under the name the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (which produced the easier-to-remember NCCAM). It was a rebranding that began a decade ago, when NCCAM director Dr. Josephine Briggs proposed renaming NCCAM (mainly because, wanting to be—or at least seem to be—all about the science, she didn’t like the word “alternative” in the name) and asked the public for suggestions. Unsurprisingly, I likened it to “polishing a turd.” A few months later, NCCAM was rebranded as NCCIH, the better to “integrate” quackery into health. A few years later, Dr. Briggs retired, to be replaced by a true believer in acupuncture, Dr. Helene Langevin. Thus ended a ten year stint in which NCCAM tried to pivot to be more scientific, mainly by trying to rebrand lifestyle medicine such as diet and exercise as “alternative” or “integrative” and some fairly meaningless outreach to critics such as Dr. Steve Novella, Dr. Kimball Atwood IV, and myself. (Unfortunately, she also met with homeopaths.) From what I can see, with Dr. Langevin’s ascension, NCCIH started to revert back to its old ways, “integrating” more pseudoscience into medicine.
Before I tell you what I mean, let’s go back to when I discussed how longtime antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. had suspended his presidential campaign in order to endorse Donald Trump for President. The two of them cooked up a health-related slogan that, if you know anything about RFK Jr. or Trump, will make you laugh: “Make America healthy again,” or MAHA. When I discussed it in detail three weeks ago, I noted that RFK Jr. had assiduously left out any mention of his signature health-related issue for the last two decades, namely fear mongering about vaccines as a supposed cause of autism and chronic disease in children and adults, to focus on a plan whose points ranged from the defensible (curtailing undue regulatory capture of regulatory agencies by big pharmaceutical companies) to the usual bonkers claims that today’s children represent the “sickest generation” to proposals like:
Devote half of research budgets from the NIH toward preventive, alternative and holistic approaches to health. In the current system, researchers don’t have enough incentive to study generic drugs and root-cause therapies that look at things like diet.
In other words, give NCCIH half of the NIH budget, as opposed to its 2024 appropriation of $174 million (compared to the overall 2024 NIH budget of $48.8 billion). Unless Congress were to double the NIH budget, that would mean massive cuts in all the science-based programs run by the NIH to accommodate the shift towards studying quackery.
Another of RFK Jr.’s proposals involved functional medicine:
Require nutrition classes and functional medicine in federally funded medical schools. Today, 7 out of 10 of the leading killers of Americans are chronic diseases that are preventable, sometimes through improved eating habits. Yet about 80% of medical schools don’t require a course in nutrition.
As I noted at the time, RFK Jr. yoked a relatively unobjectionable idea (depending on the specifics, of course) that increasing the teaching of nutrition in medical schools might be desirable to the pure quackery that is functional medicine, or, as I like to call it, reams of useless tests in one hand and a huge invoice in the other. I also noted that his complaint that there isn’t a specific class on nutrition in many medical schools was a bit deceptive. There are a lot of topics that we cover in medical school for which there is no specific class but instead the topic is covered in multiple classes, with a lot of time dedicated to it in different classes in different contexts. I also note that the late Dr. Harriet Hall once wrote about how in 2014 the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) placed a moratorium on continuing medical education (CME) credit for all programs related to Functional Medicine (FM) through 2018 because of “a lack of accompanying evidence existed to support the practice of Functional Medicine . . . [and the AAFP] identified some treatments as harmful and dangerous.” Unfortunately (and, sadly, predictably) the AAFP reversed itself in 2018, although it did decide to determine what functional medicine courses could be eligible depending on the specific topics, part of its general drift towards more tolerance of “integrative medicine” quackery. Amusingly, but unfortunately ineffectively, pathologists at The Cleveland Clinic, one of the most egregious quackademic supporters of functional medicine, called out the “specialty” for worthless genetic testing and prescribing of supplements.
All of this brings me to note that the NIH is already cozying up with functional medicine quacks, as I discovered three months ago in a post by NCCIH Director Dr. Langevin entitled New Coalition Is Another Stepping Stone Toward Whole Person Health. Let’s take a look.
NCCIH Coalition for Whole Person Health: Run by a functional medicine quack
In June, Dr. Langevin announced a new NCCIH initiative that she sounded quite proud of:
I am proud of the progress that the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) has made, taking distinct steps toward supporting the health of the whole person. Not only did we prioritize whole person health within NCCIH by incorporating it into our strategic plan, but we have also taken the lead in engaging colleagues within the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and stakeholders outside of NIH to encourage a wider conversation on integrating a whole person approach into research. Additionally, we defined a framework for discussion and fostered the necessary work to develop research methods that support increasingly complex studies on whole person health.
Now, I am excited to announce a new endeavor that will help to engage patients, health care professionals, and researchers, called the NCCIH Coalition for Whole Person Health (the Coalition). This independent coalition of nonprofit organizations will allow interested stakeholders to coalesce under a common umbrella to discuss challenges and opportunities in the research field related to delivering whole person care to individuals. The Coalition will represent perspectives of patients, communities, and professionals about the importance of whole person research, interprofessional collaboration, and keeping people and patients at the center of the conversation.
NCCIH will interact with the Coalition through events such as scientific meetings, retreats, roundtable discussions, webinars, and listening sessions, including an inaugural meeting this fall. Interactions with the Coalition’s volunteer representatives will foster information sharing, bring valuable external perspectives to NCCIH’s work, and, conversely, ensure that stakeholders are aware of and can amplify NCCIH’s research. This two-way flow of information and forum for collaboration will help to tackle important challenges related to the work of advancing research on whole person health, such as building greater research capacity, fostering interprofessional collaboration, and identifying the most promising areas of research.
Note the common trope used by proponents of “integrative health” or “integrative medicine,” namely that conventional science-based medicine is not “holistic” and does not treat the “whole person.” As I like to say, a good science-based physician in primary care, internal medicine, family practice, pediatrics, or any specialty involved in primary care already delivers “whole person care” to their patients. It’s a false dichotomy that I’ve long complained about, namely the claim that as a physician you have to embrace quackery in order to provide “holistic” or “whole person” care, which is utter nonsense. True, far be it from me to deny that physicians can fall short of this ideal, largely because the current reimbursement model for medicine tends to make it very difficult for primary care doctors to earn an income if they don’t see lots and lots of patients, limiting the time spent with each one. My response to this complaint is that the solution is to fix the system and reimburse primary care docs enough to be able to afford to spend more time with each patient, something that the vast majority of doctors would appreciate, not to outsource “holistic” or “whole person” care to quacks like naturopaths and functional medicine doctors, most of whom can charge whatever the market will bear because they are not reimbursed by health insurance.
For example, in 2021 NCCIH published on its website, Whole Person Health: What It Is and Why It’s Important:
Whole person health involves looking at the whole person—not just separate organs or body systems—and considering multiple factors that promote either health or disease. It means helping and empowering individuals, families, communities, and populations to improve their health in multiple interconnected biological, behavioral, social, and environmental areas. Instead of just treating a specific disease, whole person health focuses on restoring health, promoting resilience, and preventing diseases across a lifespan.
See what I mean? Again, a good science-based primary care doctor already does most of this, and as for the rest (communities, etc.), a good science-based public health program will help as well.
But let’s get back to one thing: Why do I keep harping on functional medicine? This is why. Look who will be leading the Coalition:
The Coalition will be led by two experienced professionals who are passionate about addressing the health challenges that patients face and the role that a whole person approach can play in meeting the health needs of people. Amy Mack, M.S.E.S./M.P.A., is chief executive officer of The Institute for Functional Medicine, and Samantha Simmons, M.P.H., is chief executive officer of the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine & Health. Together, they will serve as cochairs of the Coalition and lead a steering committee of eight founding member organizations.
The Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM)? You might remember that we at SBM have been writing about the quackery promoted by IFM going back nearly to the beginning of this blog, when the late great Dr. Wally Sampson first asked just what the heck “functional medicine” even was, finding copious examples of quackery and scientific nonsense on the IFM website. I myself once called “functional medicine” the ultimate misnomer in the world of integrative medicine, because of how it combines one of the worst features of conventional science-based medicine (namely overtesting and overtreatment based on that overcasting) with some of the worst quackery you can imagine, including naturopathy and even homeopathy. There’s a reason that in another post I referred to functional medicine as “reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other,” a play on the famous description of homeopathy by the comic duo Mitchel & Webb:
When someone comes in with a vague sense of unease or a touch of the nerves or even just more money than sense, you’ll be there for them, a bottle of basically just water in one hand, and a huge invoice in the other.
Heck, even though the main topic of this post is functional medicine and not homeopathy, I can’t resist dropping a video of Mitchell & Webb’s famous “Homeopathic A&E” sketch into this post before moving on:
Always a classic, and I’ll use any excuse to include this in a post, no matter how tangential.
As I noted in my post, in my functional medicine version of this sketch, all I’d change would be the part about a “bottle of basically just water in one hand, a huge invoice in the other,” for which I’d substitute something like “reams of useless and impossible-to-interpret lab results with a plan to correct each and every one of them in one hand, a huge invoice in the other.” That basically sums up functional medicine.
But has functional medicine changed, or, more specifically, has IFM changed? Who knows? Maybe it’s more scientific now, worthy of teaming up with a major NIH center.
IFM: NCCIH’s new partner in promoting functional medicine and “whole person medicine”
It’s been several years since I’ve perused the website of The Institute for Functional Medicine. Perusing the leadership page of IFM, I did indeed find it odd that the leadership of IFM contains only one MD. The rest of the membership consists of a naturopath and an MPH, with the rest being mostly laypeople, led by Amy R. Mack:
Amy holds a BS degree in Biology and master’s degrees in Public Affairs and Environmental Science. Amy spent the last 30 years in mission and service-oriented organizations focused on empowering individuals and community to drive systems change. As the daughter of a gastroenterologist, Amy understands the importance of patient engagement in their own health and witnessed the sacrifices of a physician in the search for good medicine. Today she pulls from these experiences to lead IFM in its mission of ensuring the widespread adoption of functional medicine.
But she is a daughter of a gastroenterologist!
Let’s just take a look at the “functional medicine model.” Hopefully longtime readers will forgive me if this is a bit repetitive of what I’ve written before, but I do feel the need every so often to reiterate our objections to functional medicine. Looking over the IFM website, I can’t help but note that a lot of what used to be public information is now either restricted content on members-only pages or otherwise unfindable. A lot of it seems to have been incorporated into a series of courses, some free, most paid. So I will use Archive.org when needed, for example, to refer to this page What Is Functional Medicine? Here’ are a couple of excerpts. First, here are its main principles:
Functional medicine is personalized medicine that deals with primary prevention and underlying causes instead of symptoms for serious chronic disease. It is a science-based field of health care that is grounded in the following principles:
Biochemical individuality describes the importance of individual variations in metabolic function that derive from genetic and environmental differences among individuals.
Patient-centered medicine emphasizes “patient care” rather than “disease care,” following Sir William Osler’s admonition that “It is more important to know what patient has the disease than to know what disease the patient has.”
Dynamic balance of internal and external factors.
Web-like interconnections of physiological factors – an abundance of research now supports the view that the human body functions as an orchestrated network of interconnected systems, rather than individual systems functioning autonomously and without effect on each other. For example, we now know that immunological dysfunctions can promote cardiovascular disease, that dietary imbalances can cause hormonal disturbances, and that environmental exposures can precipitate neurologic syndromes such as Parkinson’s disease.
Health as a positive vitality – not merely the absence of disease.
Promotion of organ reserve as the means to enhance health span.
In any post about functional medicine, I feel compelled to remind our readers that the very first principle is, in essence, functional medicine’s “get out of jail free” card for basically anything its practitioners want to do. They can always find ways to justify any form of treatment, be it science-based or quackery, simply by invoking the “biochemical individuality” of the human being they are treating. I also like to remind my readers of my retort to this: Yes, human beings are individuals, and each human being is unique. However, we’re not so unique that our bodies don’t all work pretty much the same way. In other words, in terms of biology, physiology, and yes, systems biology, human beings are far more alike than they are different. If that weren’t the case, modern medicine, developed before we had the tools to probe our genetic individuality, wouldn’t work as well as it does. FM fetishizes “biochemical individuality,” not so much because humans are so incredibly different that each one absolutely has to have a markedly different treatment. We’re not. Functional medicine fetishizes “individuality” because it distinguishes functional medicine as a brand from science-based medicine and, I suspect, because it makes its practitioners feel good, like “total” doctors never at a loss for an explanation for a patient’s symptoms or clinical condition, and makes patients feel like special snowflakes whose every bit of “individuality” is being catered to. As for the last bit about FM being a “science-using” profession, FM “uses” science more as a means of justifying whatever its practitioners do rather than guiding them to scientifically-proven treatments.
Also, functional medicine is all about the “imbalances”:
Functional medicine is anchored by an examination of the core clinical imbalances that underlie various disease conditions. Those imbalances arise as environmental inputs such as diet, nutrients (including air and water), exercise, and trauma are processed by one’s body, mind, and spirit through a unique set of genetic predispositions, attitudes, and beliefs. The fundamental physiological processes include communication, both outside and inside the cell; bioenergetics, or the transformation of food into energy; replication, repair, and maintenance of structural integrity, from the cellular to the whole body level; elimination of waste; protection and defense; and transport and circulation. The core clinical imbalances that arise from malfunctions within this complex system include:
Hormonal and neurotransmitter imbalances
Oxidation-reduction imbalances and mitochondropathy
Detoxification and biotransformational imbalances
Immune imbalances
Inflammatory imbalances
Digestive, absorptive, and microbiological imbalances
Structural imbalances from cellular membrane function to the musculoskeletal system
Imbalances such as these are the precursors to the signs and symptoms by which we detect and label (diagnose) organ system disease. Improving balance – in the patient’s environmental inputs and in the body’s fundamental physiological processes – is the precursor to restoring health and it involves much more than treating the symptoms. Functional medicine is dedicated to improving the management of complex, chronic disease by intervening at multiple levels to address these core clinical imbalances and to restore each patient’s functionality and health. Functional medicine is not a unique and separate body of knowledge. It is grounded in scientific principles and information widely available in medicine today, combining research from various disciplines into highly detailed yet clinically relevant models of disease pathogenesis and effective clinical management.
Functional medicine emphasizes a definable and teachable process of integrating multiple knowledge bases within a pragmatic intellectual matrix that focuses on functionality at many levels, rather than a single treatment for a single diagnosis. Functional medicine uses the patient’s story as a key tool for integrating diagnosis, signs and symptoms, and evidence of clinical imbalances into a comprehensive approach to improve both the patient’s environmental inputs and his or her physiological function. It is a clinician’s discipline, and it directly addresses the need to transform the practice of primary care.
No. It is not a clinician’s discipline, and it does not address the “need to transform the practice of primary care.” Also, does the focus on “imbalances” remind you of anything? How about “imbalances” in the four humors? Or “imbalances” in the Five Elements in traditional Chinese medicine. Basically, functional medicine also fetishizes “balance” in a way that sounds very much like both ancient Asian and European medicine.
In fairness, here I generally mention that there are some things that functional medicine (sort of) gets right, although these things tend to be no different than the sorts of things every primary care doctor should be getting right anyway, such as emphasizing healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health (e.g., smoking). Functional medicine also claims to emphasize prevention, which is a good thing as far as it goes, but again something that good primary care doctors do anyway. Moreover, the functional version of “prevention” isn’t always in line with the SBM version of prevention. Where functional medicine doctors go so very wrong is in what Grant Ritchey once described as a major unstated premise. That premise is that functional really does address the root causes of disease better than conventional medicine. It also also encompasses a lot of quackery, such as acupuncture, chiropractic adjustments, and especially “detoxification” programs.
No wonder it’s a perfect partner for NCCIH.
The other perfect partner for NCCIH is the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health, led by the other co-chair of the NCCIH Coalition for Whole Person Health, Samantha Simmons, MPH. You’ll recall that the ACIMH is one of the foremost organizations promoting quackademic medicine; i.e., the “integration” of quackery under the guise of “integrative health” and “integrative medicine” into academic medical centers.
When last I wrote about NCCIH’s most recent strategic plan (from 2021-2025), I noted how the groundwork had been laid for “whole person health” that appealed to a traditional Chinese medicine framework for multimodality diagnoses and treatments but also pointed out that in “conventional” medicine, diagnoses are based on science, as is the “framework” that ties the interventions together in multimodality treatments, which is very much in contrast with traditional Chinese medicine. One notes that the report referred to TCM as being more “holistic.”
The bottom line here is that “whole person health” and “whole person medicine” serve the same purpose that the “holistic” has always served among advocates of medicine that is not science-based, namely an excuse to bring in all manner of quackery in the name of being “holistic” (or treating the “whole person), particularly adding a dash of “biochemical individuality to justify doing whatever quackery a practitioner wants.
And if Donald Trump wins and actually keeps his word to RFK Jr., look for the role of NCCIH and the quackery in the federal government to expand exponentially.

Cleveland Clinic genetic experts call out functional medicine on worthless genetic testing and supplement prescribing
Cleveland Clinic genetics experts call out functional medicine on worthless genetic testing and dietary supplement prescribing: “Poor science, leading to even worse medicine.” Irony meters exploded everywhere.
Jann Belselamy on February 15, 2018
Link


Years ago, the late syndicated Chicago Sun-Times columnist Sydney Harris had a regular column he called “Things I Learned En Route to Looking up Other Things.” He filled it with bits and bobs of interesting information he’d come across while doing research for his reporting, such as this, from “Don’t get grabbed by the Japanese spider crab:”
the Japanese spider crab is the world’s largest crustacean, measuring up to 26 feet between the tips of its legs, with claws that may be 10 feet apart when in an offensive posture.
Earlier this week, I experienced a similar serendipity, although the subject was not crustaceans. I was researching genetic testing and its misuse in prescribing dietary supplements, a topic I previously addressed in a 2015 post titled “Dubious MTHFR genetic mutation testing,” and will soon write about again. (Stay tuned.) My research led to a particularly interesting article that included some revealing criticisms from experts at the Cleveland Clinic. I don’t know if Mr. Harris’s irony meter ever exploded when he stumbled upon his fortuitous column fodder. Mine did, hence this post.
As I described in my previous post, naturopaths, chiropractors, and “integrative” physicians are urging patients to test for “mutations” in the MTHFR gene via direct-to-consumer genetic testing, the results of which supposedly support the prescription of dietary supplements to ward off the supposedly deleterious effects of these supposed “mutations.”
(Skeptical Raptor also did a post on MTHFR quackery in 2015, which has since been updated.)
In 2016, former naturopathic doctor and occasional SBM blogger Britt Hermes exposed this scam as well, in a post for Forbes. As I did, she featured Ben Lynch, a naturopathic doctor who:
has built an online empire selling genetic analysis and naturalistic treatments for particular genetic variants, which are highly common and have almost no impact on health or disease.
As she explained:
Testing for MTHFR SNPs [single nucleotide polymorphisms], what Lynch is calling “mutations,” is not recommended by any professional medical organization. Some organizations have taken a step further and published statements against ordering tests to identify MTHFR polymorphisms.
She also quoted a genetics expert who found a “significant conflict of interest” in recommending a treatment regimen, such as dietary supplements, that he or she would profit from, a practice the expert called “highly unethical.”
“MTHFR: Hope or Hype?”
This week, I came across yet another publication with an article on dubious MTHFR testing being used to prescribe expensive dietary supplement regimens. A magazine called Genome (“the personalized medicine stories of today and the breakthroughs of tomorrow, so that patients have information they need to get the care they deserve”) published an article last year: “MTHFR: Hope or Hype?” which made many of the same points as Britt’s and my posts:
Ironically, just as the mainstream scientific community has decided that the test for MTHFR variations is not very useful except in rare cases, it has become a popular test for naturopaths, homeopaths, and alternative medicine companies to recommend. Several direct-to-consumer DNA testing labs screen for MTHFR variations. And at least a handful of supplement companies and alternative medicine websites maintain that MTHFR variations could be the key to everything from fatigue to schizophrenia to cancer.
The article showcased the hazards of overselling MTHFR testing and shilling for supplements based on the results with this anecdote:
Last spring, a woman in her early 30s came into the office of Jay Flanagan, a genetic counselor in a reproductive clinic at Sanford Health in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. She was trying to get pregnant, and she brought a bag with all the supplements she was taking in her effort to start a family.
“The first thing I asked her was, ‘Why are you taking $800 worth of supplements every month?'” says Flanagan. “Someone in her family had tested positive for a mutation in a gene called MTHFR. So she had gone to a homeopathic group and asked to get the same test. Her test came back positive, and they told her that she had to take all these supplements in order to reduce her risk of pregnancy loss.
“So then I had to explain that MTHFR helps change folic acid from one form to another form,” says Flanagan. . . “It helps to change one amino acid building block, homocysteine, into another, methionine. The problem isn’t the MTHFR, it’s the amount of homocysteine in your blood.”
Flanagan had the woman stop taking all her supplements so that he could measure the level of homocysteine in her blood. Despite the variation in her MTHFR gene, her homocysteine blood level came back normal.
About this incident, a geneticist and researcher commented:
I believe in the power of genetic testing in the right clinical context . . . but just because you can test for something doesn’t mean you should. Most MTHFR testing is unnecessary.
Who said this? Charis Eng, MD, PhD, the founding director of the Center for Personalized Genetic Healthcare at the Cleveland Clinic, a source I referenced in my MTHFR post as well.
Dr. Eng was not the only Cleveland Clinic expert to weigh in on MTHFR genetic testing.
As the article noted:
Some “functional medicine” specialists . . . contend that if MTHFR variants are associated with many things, there must be some process at work that we don’t yet understand. That’s a position completely at odds with the conclusion of the medical establishment.
Genetic counselors and geneticists say that if there’s no evidence to back these treatments, then they shouldn’t be recommended. “It’s pretty poor science, leading to even worse medicine,” says Eng of the Cleveland Clinic.
The article then relayed this incident:
Amy Shealy, a genetic counselor at the Cleveland Clinic, recently counseled a well-educated middle-age woman. “She was having problems with fatigue,” Shealy says. “She went to a functional medicine clinic, and they recommended doing some blood work including testing for MTHFR.”
The blood results came back with two MTHFR variants, and the functional medicine doctor reportedly told her these were causing her to have depression. Moreover, she reported that when she told the physician she was not depressed, she was told she’d probably been depressed for so long that she didn’t even realize she was depressed, according to Shealy. The functional medicine practitioners said that the woman should take supplements for depression, but she wanted her fatigue treated, not her depression, and became suspicious the more the doctors told her she was depressed. To be clear, the doctors were not selling her the supplements. [Apparently, the latter is not the norm for functional medicine practices, as we shall see.]
“That’s when she came to us,” Shealy says. “When she found out that national medical societies do not recommend MTHFR testing, she was not happy that the previous physician had tested her.”
Say what? Functional medicine clinics testing for MTHFR and advising patients to take supplements based on the results? That’s bad, according to the Cleveland Clinic’s own experts?
Do these Cleveland Clinic experts realize that the mothership of all functional medicine, the Center for Functional Medicine itself, is located at – wait for it – the Cleveland Clinic? But there’s more. Do they realize that the:
Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Functional Medicine offers an easy to use, convenient way to order the supplements you have been prescribed.
As the genetics expert quoted by Britt Hermes says, “highly unethical.”
Apparently, they missed the Cleveland Clinic’s own press release (the original is no longer available but, fortunately, David Gorski preserved this quote in a post):
In its ongoing focus on wellness and disease prevention, the Cleveland Clinic is opening a new Center for Functional Medicine. In doing so, the Clinic is the first academic medical center in the United States to embrace functional medicine, the focus of which is more on identifying underlying causes of illness and less on symptom management.
Or, as Dr. Gorski, said, eschewing press-release hyperbole:
The CCF has embraced the medical pseudoscience that is “functional medicine” and even hired its most famous practitioner, Dr. Mark Hyman. We’ve met Dr. Hyman before many times. For instance, he has argued for turning back the clock and relying on anecdotal medicine instead of scientific medicine and has mangled cancer research and systems biology to justify “functional medicine.” He’s also twisted autism science beyond recognition.
And, of course, there’s Dr. Hyman’s infamous foray into anti-vaccine pseudoscience and his latest effort, questionable claims about an epidemic of “broken brains.”
Functional medicine does love its lab tests, which are “massively misinterpreted and abused,” all in the service of finding that illusive “root cause” of a patient’s problems, and selling a bunch of dietary supplements to boot.
In fact, the Cleveland Clinic named Patrick Hanaway, former chief medical officer of Genova Diagnostics, to run the day-to-day operations of Center for Functional Medicine when it opened. As Dr. Gorski pointed out, Genova Diagnostics is:
a laboratory that offers all sorts of tests of, in my opinion, questionable medical value seemingly custom-made for functional medicine assessments, including a saliva adrenal stress profile [now called the adrenocortex stress profile], comprehensive diagnostic stool analysis, and toxic effects CORE, among others.
And guess what else? Testing for MTHFR polymorphisms, which Genova uses to recommend specific dietary supplements. How convenient for the functional medicine practitioner, what with the dietary supplement recommendations printed right there on the lab report.
But, to be fair, was this MTHFR testing by a functional medicine practitioner described in Genome an aberration? Did he or she stray from the basic principles of functional medicine (such as they are) into the fringes? If functional medicine were a real medical speciality, instead of one fabricated by its proponents, one could, say, find out the answer to this question in the medical literature, or by reviewing the specialty’s practice guidelines, or look into the curriculum of its residency program. Sadly, that’s not possible with functional medicine, which hides its protocols behind a $15,000 paywall. So, we’ll have to look for clues elsewhere.
According to Jamie Starkey, LAc, the lead acupuncturist at the Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Integrative Medicine, MTHFR testing is part and parcel of integrative medicine. Speaking on acupuncture and other treatments for depression, Starkey says:
Many integrative and functional medicine physicians will look closely to be sure you are not deficient in nutrients such as Vitamin D and also check for chromosomal abnormalities such as MTHFR mutations.
Other functional medicine practitioners are into MTHFR hyperventilation as well. Amy Meyers, MD, a graduate of the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM), where physicians get “certified” in functional medicine. (The Cleveland Clinic Center for Functional Medicine is a “featured partner” of the IFM and Mark Hyman is a on the IFM’s Board of Directors, where he and Hanaway also teach.) According to Dr. Meyers:
in functional medicine and increasingly in mainstream medicine [nope, at least not in the way she’s implying], a tremendous amount of research has surfaced regarding the MTHFR gene mutation. This mutation, which I see frequently in my functional medicine practice, has been linked to a decreased ability to detoxify, as well as over 60 chronic health conditions including Hashimoto’s and hypothyroidism, blood clots, infertility, cardiovascular disease, Alzheimer’s, depression, birth defects, and certain cancers.
Not to worry, though. She will sell you her Amy Myers, MD-branded supplements to “support MTHFR, adrenal stress, and detoxification efforts.” ($43.97 for 120 tablets.)
Jill Carnahan, MD, who also holds a certification from the Institute for Functional Medicine, agrees that:
this common genetic mutation that can affect everything from depression and anxiety to risk of heart attack or stroke . . .
She, too, recommends a host of dietary supplements and has her own line of “Dr. Jill” brand for sale.
Even the naturopathic guru of MTHFR-testing cum supplement-selling himself, Ben Lynch, is a fan of functional medicine. He lists the Institute for Functional Medicine as a source on his “Find a doctor who understands MTHFR” webpage.
But what about the master, Mark Hyman? What does he think of MTHFR testing? Does he use it in his practice of functional medicine? Yes, he does. In his typical n=1 “proof” of the success of his functional medicine approach, he describes “Joe,” failed, of course, by conventional medicine but saved by Dr. Hyman’s ministrations, including:
We also found he had some genetic imbalances (MTHFR homozygous polymorphism) that increased his need for vitamin B12 and folate (both of which are important in controlling mood and cardiovascular risk).
In his 2010 TEDMED talk, Hyman even references his own MTHFR SNPs as a source of his health problems which, he claims, originally led him to the wonders of functional medicine.
What was that the Cleveland Clinic’s genetics expert said about this sort of thing? Oh yes, “pretty poor science, leading to even worse medicine.”

Surgeon General nominee Dr. Casey Means and functional medicine: Legitimizing quackery
Surgeon general nominee Dr. Casey Means is an advocate of “functional medicine.” She, MAHA, and a new “board certification” will falsely legitimize quackery.
David Gorski on October 20, 2025
Link
Ever since antivax activist turned independent Presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. suspended his Presidential campaign to bend the knee to Donald Trump in return for a high-ranking position in his administration should he win, coining the term “make America healthy again” (MAHA) as a direct riff on Trump’s “make America great again” (MAGA) slogan, we’ve been faced with the consequences the possibility, later becoming the reality, of putting a conspiracy mongering, antivax, alternative medicine crank in charge of all non-military federal medical, public health, and biomedical research programs. Now that RFK Jr. is Secretary of Health and Human Services, we have seen the consequences of letting RFK Jr. “go wild on health,” “go wild on the food,” and “go wild on the medicines,” as Trump promised during the campaign, and it’s not good, particularly for vaccines, as I’ve written about extensively. However, what I haven’t written about so much is how the other vibes-based, unscientific ideas behind MAHA could end up reshaping medicine. For example, leaving aside the extreme antivax views of our HHS Secretary—and, make no mistake, he is antivax to the core and coming for your vaccines—one aspect of MAHA is its embrace of a form of alternative medicine known as “functional medicine” (FM), as embodied in one of RFK Jr.’s key allies in MAHA, previously little-known physician named Dr. Casey Means, who is Donald Trump’s nominee for Surgeon General.
It’s been a long time since I’ve written about functional medicine, which used to be a common topic on this blog back in the pre-MAHA ancient past. However, given that our next Surgeon General is likely to be a functional medicine quack, I thought that now was as good a time as any to revisit the topic of functional medicine, in particular because Means is not the only force that is likely to work to legitimize functional medicine. Before I write about Dr. Casey Means, what functional medicine is, why it’s quackery, and why MAHA likes it so much, let me point to an announcement from last month by the Institute of Functional Medicine (IFM). Here’s part of the press release:
The Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM) today took the next step in the new Functional Medicine Certification Program™ by announcing the formation of the International Board of Functional Medicine Certification (IBFMC)™. Established by a formal resolution of the IFM Governing Board of Directors (BOD), IBFMC™ is the first-ever certifying board for functional medicine and operates autonomously to oversee and set standards for the Functional Medicine Certification Program™ (Certification Program).
“Aligned with IFM’s mission to ensure the widespread adoption of functional medicine, the IFM Governing Board of Directors is proud to establish this autonomous body to lead the new Certification Program,” said Dr. Gail C. Christopher, chair of IFM BOD. “IBFMCTM ensures proper oversight on the assessment of practitioner competencies in functional medicine through their successful completion of the industry-leading Certification Program for the field of functional medicine.”
I always laugh when I read something like this. After all, how does one determine what the core competencies and core knowledge are in a quack specialty? (Imagine the same thing for homeopathy.) Some of you out there might think I’m being unfair and too harsh throwing around the q-word as I’ve been doing, but, as you will see, while FM does include some science- and evidence-based bits (as in some of the stuff about nutrition), these morsels of non-quackery mostly serve as seasoning to disguise the flavor of all the massive overtesting, overtreatment, and embrace of quackery like homeopathy and acupuncture, all in the name of “holistic” medicine. Moreover, as we’ve long documented here at SBM, one of the favored techniques that quacks use to slather on a patina of seeming legitimacy onto an edifice of quackery is the formation of what Dr. Kimball Atwood dubbed way back in 2008 “pseudo-professional organizations,” some of which form pseudo-professional boards in order to grant practitioners of quackery pseudo-certifications in various quack practices. (Naturopathy as a “specialty” has been particularly effective using this technique.) This “board certification” for FM is just the most recent of which I’m aware, and, truth be told, when I learned about the IFM certification, I was rather surprised that the IFM had never done something like before.
I note here, as I do whenever I see one of these “wholistic” or “integrative”-style “board certifications,” that this is not a board certification granted by one of the boards falling under the American Board of Medical Specialties, such as the American Board of Internal Medicine or the American Board of Surgery. It is mainly certifications from boards that fall under the ABMS that are recognized by hospitals, insurance providers, etc. as allowing a physician to be considered “board certified” in a specialty.
Let’s start with who Casey Means is and how she embraced functional medicine before I explain why that is a problem and what her elevation to surgeon general and the MAHA embrace of FM could mean for medicine.
Casey Means, MD: A conversion story
As is the case for many conventional doctors who “go rogue” and embrace “wholistic” medicine that is largely not science- or evidence-based, Dr. Means’ story sounds a lot like a religious conversion story. I find it useful to go to her website and quote it from the horse’s mouth, so to speak. Here is how Dr. Means describes her journey, in which she quit her otolaryngology residency during its final year in order to embrace “wholistic” medicine, when she was just months away from being board-eligible as an otolaryngologist:
After completing four years of surgical residency in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck surgery, Dr. Means resigned from her residency in late 2018 to focus on reforming the “sick care” paradigm in American healthcare. Her work centers on introducing a systems-thinking perspective to clinical medicine, highlighting the interconnected physiological root causes of many of the most common Western chronic diseases. After being awarded a full medical license in Oregon in 2018, she opened a private practice in Oregon in early 2019 focusing on holistic health and functional medicine, called Means Health.
In an aim to scale functional medicine principles and nutritional awareness to a wider population, she co-founded the health company Levels in late 2019, which empowers individuals to monitor and understand their key metabolic biomarkers, aiming to increase awareness of factors that contribute to the most common and preventable diseases in the United States. The company’s stated mission is to “reverse the metabolic disease epidemic,” and since 2022 has undertaken an Institutional Review Board-approved research study of over 10,000 participants to characterize glucose patterns in a non-diabetic population to better understand the transition from healthy glucose levels to overt metabolic dysfunction.
I can’t help but cringe at some of the language, which should be very familiar to readers of this blog. As you will see, FM docs love to claim that they are engaging in “systems-level thinking” (as opposed, obviously, to those of us who supposedly engage in that horrible “reductionist” scientific thinking) and addressing the “interconnected physiological root causes of many of the most common Western chronic diseases” (as opposed to those of us who supposedly only treat the symptoms and not the “root cause” of diseases). It’s a false dichotomy that I’ve long detested: The alternative medicine claim that one must embrace woo in order to practice “wholistic” medicine. True, she doesn’t say this (exactly) in this passage, but the attitude is there. Unlike the unimaginative and boring doctors trying to apply evidence-based medicine to patients, she is the bold maverick embracing a much more complex and “systems-level” way of thinking. In her bio, she brags repeatedly at her scientific accomplishments, and, I must admit, they are indeed impressive for a young investigator. However, as is almost always the case with “brave maverick” doctors like Means, pretty much all of these impressive accomplishments took place before she left conventional medicine to embrace FM.
In addition, in her book Good Energy, Means recounts the story of her mother’s death from pancreatic cancer, as described in this New Yorker article:
The second was the death of Gayle Means, in January, 2021, at the age of seventy-one, from what Casey calls a “preventable metabolic condition,” also known as pancreatic cancer. Casey depicts her mother as active and watchful of her health: she got her preventive tests at the Mayo Clinic, saw doctors at Stanford, ate mindfully, and exercised regularly. But she was also a former smoker, and, like many seniors, took metformin to manage her blood sugar and a statin for cholesterol. On the eve of the pandemic, mother and daughter visited Sedona, the New Age destination in Arizona, for what Casey describes as “‘Dr. Casey’s Bootcamp’ of proven actions to improve metabolic health: extended fasting, cold plunging, exercise, morning sunrise hikes.” Gayle, her daughter says proudly, “was actually very much on the same page about, sort of, holistic health as me.”
About a year later, according to Casey, her mother felt fatigue and stomach pain while on her daily hike. After getting blood work and a CT scan, she received a diagnosis of Stage IV pancreatic cancer, via text message. Casey got a FaceTime call from her mother, she writes, in which “she told me that she was dying, that she had to leave me, and that she would not meet my future children.” She had “softball-sized tumors all throughout her belly.” Thirteen days later, Gayle Means died. In “Good Energy,” Casey rues the fact that her mother “didn’t have the resources to make sense of her biomarkers.” Still, her final days, Casey said in 2022, added up to “a very beautiful, transformational experience”—a “spectacular two weeks” for the Means family, in which Gayle experienced “pure joy.”
A physician should know that, alas, there are no reliable “biomarkers” that will allow pancreatic cancer to be diagnosed early. Sadly, the majority of pancreatic cancer patients present late, like Casey’s mother Gayle. However, in the story you can see the regret, the very real human physician’s belief that if only she had done something different maybe her mother would still be alive. I myself have experienced that same feeling thinking back over the death of my father this year and the ongoing deterioration of my mother’s health. Again, the above stories are the sorts of stories we hear frequently from physicians who convert to alternative medicine and quackery, that “something” led them to see all that is supposedly wrong with evidence-based medicine, a realization that led them to convert to something that they saw as better, more “holistic,” more able to take care of patients. Here is how she further characterizes her “conversion” to FM:
As her residency progressed, however, Means grew increasingly disillusioned with the reactive “sick care” model she encountered in her clinical practice. This shift in perspective led her to take time away from her surgical training to explore the intersection of holistic health and surgery. Extensive documents and emails from this period show a prolonged effort to merge her surgical work with a holistic and “root cause” approach, securing meetings with the Chief Wellness Officer at Cleveland Clinic, faculty from National University of Natural Medicine, the Casey Health Institute (which has developed an integrated approach to healthcare blending complementary and conventional therapies), and many other experts for guidance on opportunities to design and foster a more proactive and holistic practice within the surgical ecosystem. Ultimately, she felt so disillusioned with the practice and incentives of surgical care that she chose to resign and work on reform from outside the “system.”
She summarizes this in her book Good Energy,
I deeply respect doctors, but I want to be very clear on something: at every hospital in the United States, many doctors are doing the wrong things, pushing pills and interventions when an ultra-aggressive stance on diet and behavior would do far more for the patient in front of them. Suicide and burnout rates are astronomical in health care, with approximately four hundred doctors per year killing themselves. (That’s equivalent to about four medical school graduating classes just dropping dead every year by their own hand.) Doctors have twice the rate of suicide as the general population. Based on my own experience as a young surgeon, I think a contributor to this phenomenon is an insidious spiritual crisis about the efficacy of our work and a sense of being trapped in a system that is not working but seems too big to change or escape.
Two weeks after resigning from residency, Means participated in a business retreat for physicians with Dr. Pamela Wible focused on designing an “Ideal Medical Practice,” beginning on October 14th, 2018. In December 2018, she obtained her unrestricted medical license with the state of Oregon, and incorporated her medical practice, “Means Health,” in January 2019, to implement a holistic and functional medicine approach in clinical practice. She began training with the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM), completing the foundational “Applying Functional Medicine in Clinical Practice” on March 8th, 2019 and completing further coursework with IFM, and started giving talks on Functional Medicine and “food as medicine” in Portland, Oregon.
In other words, she had come to a “revelation” that somehow what she was doing in her surgical residency were the “wrong” things and that, instead of surgery and medications, she should be pushing an “ultra-aggressive stance on diet and behavior,” justifying her conversion by citing statistics showing that physicians and other health care professionals have a higher rate of death by suicide than average and attributing it to an “insidious spiritual crisis.” Whenever I see that sort of language coming from a surgeon, I always wonder: What did you expect going into a surgical specialty? Surgery is only sometimes preventative. It’s most frequently a treatment for something that’s already gone wrong, sometimes catastrophically wrong, that can best be fixed by removing or rearranging pieces of human anatomy. If a doctor is interested in holism and prevention, she should go into primary care or internal medicine rather than into a surgical subspecialty.
Unsurprisingly, reporters who have looked into what actually happened in 2018 that led Dr. Means to abandon her surgical residency so close to finishing have found that the story is…more complex…than what Means relates on her website and in her interviews. There’s an excellent report in Vanity Fair by Katherine Eban entitled “She Was Tearful About It”: The Nuances of Casey Means’s Medical Exit and Antiestablishment Origins, in which Eban interviewed fellow residents and her department chair about what had happened to lead Means to abandon her residency so close to the finish line. Remember, although there is attrition among surgical residents, it’s very uncommon for a surgical resident to quit in her last year, other than for health challenges or switching specialties, and even then the vast majority of attrition happens in the first couple of years.
There does, however, appear to be a grain of truth in Means’ characterization of her departure. Remember that part about suicides among physicians? According to the Vanity Fair article and an LA Times article, the reason that Means departed was largely due to stress and anxiety.
From the LA Times:
Dr. Paul Flint, a former chair of Otolaryngology/Head and Neck Surgery at Oregon Health and Science University, said Means resigned from the residency because of anxiety.
After four years of training, Means came to him and Dr. Mark Wax, the residency program director, and said she wasn’t sure it was the right job for her.
“She wasn’t even sure she wanted to be in medicine,” Flint said. “She wanted to do something different. She wanted to resign.”
Flint and Wax urged Means to think about it more and offered her three months paid time off.
“She was under so much stress,” he said. “She did that, came back and decided she wanted to leave the program. She did not like that level of stress.”
Flint said Means was competent, a good resident. “But there was a lot of anxiety around this,” he said of the role of the surgeon. “You become much more responsible the more senior you get.”
Don’t I know it! That’s also one very understanding department chair, to offer her three month’s paid leave to “think about” her decision, although in her book Means also says that she took the leave also to deal with neck pain.
From the Vanity Fair report:
Two former residents she served alongside offer a version of her departure from the program that matches with Flint’s. They say that contrary to Means’s oft-told version of events, she exited due to her inability to handle the admittedly high pressure. They describe her as being deeply unhappy and fearful of harming patients, and say she took a leave of absence before departing altogether. The former residents also tell VF that they do not recognize the version of events laid out in the book. In their view, Means misrepresented her residency training and proclaimed a medical conspiracy against good health that simply doesn’t exist. (Both former residents have asked not to be named because they fear retaliation from the Trump administration.)
Another resident, who was one year ahead of Means in the program and has asked not to have his name used due to restrictions imposed by his current employer, says, “I thought she handled the stress of the program exceedingly well, and that’s one of the reasons why people wanted her to stay and see it through.” He adds, “The way she explained it to me at the time, she felt it wasn’t the best fit for her, the residency in general and otolaryngology in particular. It wasn’t as fulfilling or rewarding as she expected.”
I’m about to do something a bit unexpected here and express some empathy with Means about this. I myself came very close to quitting my general surgery residency during my third year due to the stress. I even went so far as to investigate what it would take to transfer, for instance, into the pathology residency program at the hospital where I was training. With the help of an understanding chair and residency director, I didn’t resign and managed to finish my residency with good marks, but I fully understand the stress, maybe even more so, given that I trained in the era before resident work hour restrictions. It does take guts to realize so close to the finish line that you had made a mistake in your specialty choice and then actually do something about it. If Means had just said that she had changed gears because she was stressed out and unhappy with practicing otolaryngology, I’d be fine with that; I might even admire her for her choice, other than that she chose FM as her specialty.
Unfortunately, according to the Vanity Fair article:
After she left, the two former residents grew increasingly skeptical of her public claims. “I did not witness a spiritual awakening,” the former junior resident says. “It felt more and more like she was preying on the less educated and using the MD she had to tout these pseudoscience things.”
The other former resident observes, “She’s a good person and does care for people and wants what’s best. But it feels disingenuous, demonizing your training. She didn’t make it through.” The former resident adds, “By trying to question our entire field and sowing distrust in medicine, it’s hard to ignore that she may benefit from that.”
Indeed. However, sowing distrust in medicine and “reinventing” one’s “journey” to sound a lot more altruistic than it actually was are key components of any “brave maverick” doctor’s journey, as regular readers know. As you will see, that first junior resident quoted sounds pretty spot-on. For one thing, Means’ actual functional medicine practice didn’t last very long. It wasn’t long at all before she pivoted to sales of products to treat “metabolic health” and raising venture capital to do so. Since then, she has bragged about appearing on Joe Rogan’s and Tucker Carlson’s podcasts to promote her viewpoint that the chronic disease epidemic is “metabolic” and that diet and lifestyle are the answer. Part of that evangelism (and business) involves her forming a company that markets, among other questionable products, continuous glucose monitoring devices to everyone, not just people with diabetes or pre-diabetes, as a near-panacea for monitoring diet. (More on that later.)
Finally, like a lot of other “brave mavericks,” Means’ reaction to criticism, as included in her bio on her website, is very much of the “poor, poor persecuted me” variety, just like “brave mavericks,” COVID contrarians, and any others who portray valid science-based criticism as an attempt to “silence” or “cancel” them:
Responses to this widespread backlash from legacy media included articles criticizing mainstream media for their biased framing of her work, including “Rise of the “Woo-Woo” Woman: The Witch Hunt for Dr. Casey Means” by Lauren Lee, which stated that “the backlash against Trump’s pick for Surgeon General isn’t about science — it’s about a country terrified to confront its own spiritual collapse.”
Means is considered controversial because her work challenges the economic and cultural foundations of U.S. healthcare, agriculture, and food systems. She criticizes “sick care” medicine for profiting from disease management, calls for reform of the Farm Bill, pharmaceutical incentives, food culture, and industrial agriculture, and integrates spirituality, ecology, and patient empowerment into her philosophy—departures from conventional frameworks that have led some outlets to label her “unscientific.” Legacy media critics often dismiss her credibility because her message exposes institutional failures and calls for disruption, and her career trajectory has included periods without direct one-to-one patient care while pursuing work in preventative health that has reached tens of millions. Some critics cite her work as an entrepreneur and health-technology co-founder as incompatible with public health leadership, overlooking Levels’ large-scale research collaborations with academic institutions and the complex management and operational skills required to build a high-growth company. Others argue she oversimplifies chronic disease and places too much responsibility on individuals, failing to recognize that her approach explicitly advocates for both bottom-up empowerment—equipping individuals with the knowledge to understand their own bodies—and top-down systemic reform that makes healthy choices affordable, accessible, and the cultural default. Finally, her stances on medications and emerging therapies such as vaccines, oral contraceptives, and psychedelic therapies have drawn intense scrutiny, though her consistent position on each of these therapies has strongly emphasized informed consent, medical freedom, and ending corporate liability shields and conflicts of interests that often distort research findings and prioritize profit over patient well-being.
You get the idea. Like so many quacks, she portrays criticism of her as not being about the science but being because she, brave maverick that she is, “challenges the economic and cultural foundations” of medicine, “criticizes “sick care,” and “integrates spirituality, ecology, and patient empowerment into her philosophy.” I’m also amused by how she is clearly stung by criticisms of MAHA, which are quite justified, that it undermines public health and ignores the social determinants of health in favor of a model in which health is entirely a matter of one’s personal choices, where good health is a consequence of “virtue”; i.e., eating the “right” diet, engaging in the “correct” behaviors, and the like. Then, of course, she’s not anti-medicine or antivaccine; she’s just for ending “corporate conflicts of interest” and for “informed consent” and “medical freedom.” In fairness, I’m not yet sure if she’s antivaccine, if only because of some of the highly negative reaction of some prominent antivaxxers to her nomination, although a recent Washington Post article by Lauren Weber and Rachel Ruben notes that she has started questioning “the cumulation of the childhood vaccine schedule and the hepatitis B vaccine” and has asked on Joe Rogan’s podcast, ““I bet that one vaccine probably isn’t causing autism, but what about the 20 that they are getting before 18 months?”
Yes, she’ll come the rest of the way over to RFK Jr.’s antivax views soon enough.
It occurs to me right here that advocating continuous glucose monitoring devices for almost everyone as a means of improving health is so very, very functional medicine. Indeed, the entire program offered by her company Levels, is very much the epitome of functional medicine quackery. (Let’s just say that the highest “Level” program, costing $1,499 a year, involves twice a year measurements of “100+ health markers,” two months of continuous glucose monitoring, and a lot more.
On to functional medicine.
Functional medicine: The worst of conventional and alternative medicine
Over the years, I’ve frequently referred to the kludge that is known as “functional medicine” as the “ultimate misnomer” in medicine and “worst of both worlds.” What I mean by that is that FM combines the worst elements of conventional medicine, overtesting and overtreatment involving reams of questionable lab tests and imaging studies (many not reimbursed by health insurance), with the worst elements of alternative medicine, specifically embracing quackery like naturopathy and acupuncture and “integrating” them with medicine. Indeed, I’ve often riffed a major punchline in a famous Mitchell & Webb comedy sketch about homeopathy and referred to FM as “reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other.” Even if you don’t know anything about FM, you can get the feeling that overtesting is a key component of it just from realizing that Means’ plan offers to look at 100+ biomarkers drawn twice a year. Unsurprisingly (to anyone who knows anything about FM) this sounds very similar to a panel of 100+ tests offered by one of the longtime gurus of FM, Dr. Mark Hyman, who himself was (prepandemic, at least) a frequent topic of this blog. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Hyman is himself tight with RFK Jr., a longtime buddy, and promoting FM as part of MAHA.
But what is functional medicine itself? It is a “specialty” that was “pioneered”—actually more or less made up of whole cloth—by Dr. Jeffrey Bland, who co-founded IFM, and then championed by people like Dr. Mark Hyman, who is quoted as characterizing FM thusly:
Dr Hyman, a medical doctor, says FM is “a rigorous system for assessing chronic illness using new advances in systems biology and systems thinking”.
“Functional Medicine is not about a test or a supplement or a particular protocol,” he adds. “It’s really a new paradigm of disease and how it arises and how to restore health. Within it there are many approaches that are effective, it’s not exclusive, it doesn’t exclude traditional medications, it includes all modalities depending on what’s right for that patient.”
We’ve asked (and tried to answer) the question of what FM is many times on this blog going way, way back to Wally Sampson’s posts explaining why FM is quackery. (Even 17 years later, I like his characterization of FM as an “indecipherable babble and descriptive word salad.“) Basically, FM invokes “systems” thinking in order to make it seem as though it is more “holistic” than conventional medicine. Oddly enough, however, when Dr. Hyman used to discuss the systems biology of autism, he made no sense and mangled the science; ditto for cancer.
Is that too harsh? I don’t think so. I’ll explain why by first taking a look at the “functional medicine model.” Hopefully longtime readers will forgive me if this is a bit repetitive of what I’ve written before, but I do feel the need every so often to reiterate our objections to functional medicine without forcing you to click on multiple links. In other words, every few years I like to lay out why FM is quackery in another post. Looking over the IFM website, I can’t help but note that a lot of what used to be public information is now either restricted content on members-only pages or otherwise unfindable. A lot of it seems to have been incorporated into a series of courses, some free, most paid. So I will use Archive.org when needed, for example, to refer to this page What Is Functional Medicine? First, here are FM’s main principles:
Functional medicine is personalized medicine that deals with primary prevention and underlying causes instead of symptoms for serious chronic disease. It is a science-based field of health care that is grounded in the following principles:
    • Biochemical individuality describes the importance of individual variations in metabolic function that derive from genetic and environmental differences among individuals.
    • Patient-centered medicine emphasizes “patient care” rather than “disease care,” following Sir William Osler’s admonition that “It is more important to know what patient has the disease than to know what disease the patient has.”
    • Dynamic balance of internal and external factors.
    • Web-like interconnections of physiological factors – an abundance of research now supports the view that the human body functions as an orchestrated network of interconnected systems, rather than individual systems functioning autonomously and without effect on each other. For example, we now know that immunological dysfunctions can promote cardiovascular disease, that dietary imbalances can cause hormonal disturbances, and that environmental exposures can precipitate neurologic syndromes such as Parkinson’s disease.
    • Health as a positive vitality – not merely the absence of disease.
    • Promotion of organ reserve as the means to enhance health span.
In pretty much every post about functional medicine that I’ve ever written, I feel compelled to remind our readers that the very first principle is, in essence, functional medicine’s “get out of jail free” card for basically anything its practitioners want to do. FM docs can always find reasons, whether science-based or not, to justify any form of treatment, be it science-based or quackery, simply by invoking the “biochemical individuality” of the human being they are treating. I feel compelledto remind my readers yet again of my favorite retort to this claim: Yes, human beings are individuals, and each human being is unique. However, we’re not so unique that our bodies don’t all work pretty similarly. In other words, in terms of biology, physiology, and yes, systems biology, we human beings are far more alike than we are different. If that weren’t the case, modern medicine, developed before we had the tools to probe our genetic, metabolic, and biochemical individuality, wouldn’t work as well as it does.
FM fetishizes “biochemical individuality,” not so much because humans are so incredibly different that each one absolutely has to employ a totally different treatment for a given disease or condition in any given individual. We’re not. Nor am I arguing that the insights scientists have derived from genomics, metabolomics, and proteomics, which have revealed different system-level biochemical and metabolic pathways in physiology, don’t matter. They do. We’re just not as radically “individuals” on a biochemical basis as FM docs try to argue. In essence, FM fetishizes biochemical “individuality” because emphasizing such “individuality” distinguishes functional medicine as a brand distinct from conventional science- and evidence-based medicine and, I suspect, because it makes its practitioners feel good, like “total” doctors who are never at a loss for an explanation for a patient’s symptoms or clinical condition and can always think of more tests to figure out a problem. It also patients feel special and that their every bit of “individuality” is being catered to. As for the last bit about FM being a “science-using” profession, FM “uses” science more as a means of justifying whatever its practitioners do rather than guiding them to scientifically-proven treatments.
Also, functional medicine is all about the “imbalances”:
Functional medicine is anchored by an examination of the core clinical imbalances that underlie various disease conditions. Those imbalances arise as environmental inputs such as diet, nutrients (including air and water), exercise, and trauma are processed by one’s body, mind, and spirit through a unique set of genetic predispositions, attitudes, and beliefs. The fundamental physiological processes include communication, both outside and inside the cell; bioenergetics, or the transformation of food into energy; replication, repair, and maintenance of structural integrity, from the cellular to the whole body level; elimination of waste; protection and defense; and transport and circulation. The core clinical imbalancesthat arise from malfunctions within this complex system include:
    • Hormonal and neurotransmitter imbalances
    • Oxidation-reduction imbalances and mitochondropathy
    • Detoxification and biotransformational imbalances
    • Immune imbalances
    • Inflammatory imbalances
    • Digestive, absorptive, and microbiological imbalances
    • Structural imbalances from cellular membrane function to the musculoskeletal system
Imbalances such as these are the precursors to the signs and symptoms by which we detect and label (diagnose) organ system disease. Improving balance – in the patient’s environmental inputs and in the body’s fundamental physiological processes – is the precursor to restoring health and it involves much more than treating the symptoms. Functional medicine is dedicated to improving the management of complex, chronic disease by intervening at multiple levels to address these core clinical imbalances and to restore each patient’s functionality and health. Functional medicine is not a unique and separate body of knowledge. It is grounded in scientific principles and information widely available in medicine today, combining research from various disciplines into highly detailed yet clinically relevant models of disease pathogenesis and effective clinical management.
Functional medicine emphasizes a definable and teachable process of integrating multiple knowledge bases within a pragmatic intellectual matrix that focuses on functionality at many levels, rather than a single treatment for a single diagnosis. Functional medicine uses the patient’s story as a key tool for integrating diagnosis, signs and symptoms, and evidence of clinical imbalances into a comprehensive approach to improve both the patient’s environmental inputs and his or her physiological function. It is a clinician’s discipline, and it directly addresses the need to transform the practice of primary care.
No. It is not a clinician’s discipline, and it does not address the “need to transform the practice of primary care.” Also, does the focus on “imbalances” remind you of anything? How about “imbalances” in the four humors? Or “imbalances” in the Five Elements in traditional Chinese medicine. Basically, functional medicine also fetishizes “balance” in a way that sounds very much like both ancient Asian and European medicine. Indeed, if you read much about FM from its advocates, you’ll soon find images like this one:
Functional Medicine practitioners like to make patients think that this
diagram actually means something.
Or this one:
Can you see why I sometimes compare FM to the four humors in humoral medicine or the Five Elements in traditional Chinese medicine?
In fairness, here I generally mention that there are some things that functional medicine (sort of) gets right, although these things tend to be no different than the sorts of things every primary care doctor should be getting right anyway, such as emphasizing healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health (e.g., smoking and being sedentary). Functional medicine also claims to emphasize prevention, which is a good thing as far as it goes, but again something that good primary care doctors do anyway. Moreover, the functional version of “prevention” isn’t always in line with the SBM version of prevention. Where functional medicine doctors go so very wrong is in what Grant Ritchey once described as a major unstated premise. That premise is that functional really does address the root causes of disease better than conventional medicine. (It does not.) Worse, FM also encompasses a lot of quackery, such as acupuncture, chiropractic adjustments, naturopathy, and especially “detoxification” programs. FM medicine also includes a slew of fake diagnoses, like adrenal fatigue, chronic Lyme disease, and “heavy metal toxicity.”
Basically, FM is a triumph of marketing over science, which is why it seems so appealing on the surface. Means, like Hyman before her and Bland before him, portrays FM as a new paradigm in medicine, tossing around catchphrases and buzzwords like “systems-level,” “biochemical individuality,” the body’s “operating system,” “empowerment,” and the like, all while demonizing conventional medicine. Unfortunately, the marketing has paid off, with Hyman having founded a functional medicine institute at The Cleveland Clinic, and FM finding its way into “integrative medicine” programs at academic medical centers.
Casey Means and functional medicine
Now that you know a bit about FM, I hope you can see why continuous glucose monitoring for even non-diabetics is the ultimate in the FM paradigm. It provides reams and reams of measurements of blood glucose that might or might not mean anything or be actionable to improve health. Basically, Means’ Level program is FM on steroids. It includes a panel of over 100 biomarkers that includes standard labs (e.g., electrolytes and complete blood counts) plus a raft of tests that are normally only ordered when a condition is suspected. Then it adds the continuous glucose monitoring to measure basal glucose, glucose variability, and post-meal glucose dynamics. This is all fed into an artificial intelligence program that supposedly provides actionable “advanced AI insights” by way of a proprietary smartphone app.
As you might imagine, there is evidence that continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) can be beneficial in patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes, as well as in patients with prediabetes. When it comes to the use of this technology (which is not cheap) in nondiabetics, as you might imagine, the evidence is a lot more mixed, confusing, and far from compelling, despite Means’s selling it thusly:
Over the past few years, however, interest has grown in the use of CGM among people without diabetes, driven by a desire to avoid prediabetes and Type 2 diabetes (conditions of high blood sugar), as well as to gain insights about how diet, sleep, and activity influence blood sugar levels.
For people without diabetes, a CGM offers real-time feedback on how foods and other lifestyle factors affect your glucose levels. This information can help you aim for more stable blood sugar to boost energy, improve focus, aid weight loss, prevent and manage chronic disease, and even foster longevity. Here, we explain what a CGM is, how it works, why people without diabetes might want one, and how you can get one.
“Even foster longevity”? Sounds awesome, right? But is there any good evidence for these claims for the use of CGM in healthy nondiabetics? The answer, in brief, is: Not really, with the possible exception of people at high risk for diabetes and prediabetes. The American Diabetic Association, for instance, explicitly states that there is insufficient evidence to support the use of CGM for screening or diagnosis of prediabetes or diabetes, and that FPG, HbA1c, and OGTT remain the standard of care for these purposes. Even in patients with prediabetes and metabolic syndrome, evidence is mixed, as this recent systematic review of personalized nutrition strategies points out. There is also some scattered evidence that CGM can improve cardiovascular outcomes in nondiabetics by guiding lifestyle and dietary interventions, but, again, as the ADA points out in its recommendations, CGM is a lot more expensive than the standard screening blood tests. For a discussion of CGM targeted at the lay audience, I recommend this article in NPR, which notes some of the promise of CGM while also cautioning:
Many people find the data confusing and unhelpful.
“Many people come to me and say, ‘I have been using the device for three or even 12 months, and I have all this data, but I don’t know what it means. I don’t know how to lower my blood sugar or improve it,'” Kennedy says.
People really need to be educated about what the data means, Popp agrees. But that education will go only so far because at this point, some of the data is still mysterious to scientists and doctors.
If you’re staying within a normal range, say about 70 mg/dL to 140 mg/dL, scientists still don’t understand what the peaks and troughs mean.
“There’s no real standard guidelines about what’s a good peak or a bad peak in nondiabetics,” Popp says.
Emphasis mine.
Perhaps I should write a more detailed post about CGM in the future, as this post is already long and CGM is not the main topic, but rather an indication of Means’ proclivities for FM and FM-adjacent overtesting. It is these proclivities that will, if she is confirmed—which is not entirely certain at this point, given that Sen. Bill Cassidy, who so woefully failed as a physician and a legislator by voting twice in favor of RFK Jr., once to send his nomination out of committee and to the full Senate and then voting to confirm him, seems leery—give her the strongest voice yet to promote FM quackery as the answer to all of America’s problems in public health, chronic disease, and diet, while supporting the faux legitimization of FM as a specialty by the IFM’s pseudo-board certification.
And so the process of “integrating” quackery into medicine that began nearly 35 years ago will continue apace, only turbocharged by President Trump, MAHA, RFK Jr., and, yes, Casey Means. Her conversion is, as I have described above, every bit a religious one, and, like many converts, particularly “medical apostates,” Means appears to revel in being seen as a “heretic.” Again, note her frequent characterization of standard evidence-based medicine as more of another religious sect than anything else. This is incredibly common language used in these spaces by advocates of FM, naturopathy, homeopathy, acupuncture, and lots of other forms of alternative medicine, as is the citation of a “spiritual crisis” as a reason for abandoning evidence- and science-based medicine. They don’t call it that, of course. Means, as does MAHA in general, seems to think that she’s following “gold standard science.” Means’ medical worldview is also largely based on fear, as so aptly described by Jessica Winter in the same New Yorker article that described Means’ reaction to her mother’s death:
The health-care system, she has claimed, is rife with “fear-based thinking,” and doctors “weaponize fear of death” in order to force harmful drugs and procedures on patients. A flawless commitment to diet, exercise, and sleep hygiene means nothing, she writes in “Good Energy,” if stress and anxiety are present, because a “cell living in a body experiencing chronic fear is a cell that cannot fully thrive.”
And yet, for long stretches of “Good Energy,” the prescription appears to be fear. Fear of Smartfood popcorn and Ben & Jerry’s ice cream. Fear of progestin pills and dryer sheets and unfiltered shower water. Fear of your glucose levels, or of not knowing what your glucose levels are at any given moment. Fear of your mother’s sub-optimized mitochondria, which she passed down to you. Fear of the takeout dinners and late nights that Gayle Means enjoyed as a twentysomething living in the West Village half a century ago. (Casey cites these youthful habits as possible causes of her mother’s “metabolic abnormalities.”) The Good Energy message, in the main, is that if you’re afraid of everything you have nothing to fear. You cannot eat your way out of death, but you should follow the Calvinist urge to try.
Any religious conversion has to include a devil that the religion will protect you against. Unfortunately, we’re probably about to find out how much she can proselytize as Surgeon General, as well as the extreme limitations in how much FM can protect one against the demons that drive Dr. Means’ fears.


Precision Medicine: The Coolest Part of Medicine
Harriet Hall on May 20, 2014
Link

One size rarely fits all. Most medical knowledge is derived from studying groups of subjects, subjects who may be different in some way from the individual who walks into the doctor’s office. Basing medicine only on randomized controlled studies can lead to over-simplified “cookbook” medicine. A good clinician interprets study results and puts them into context, considering the whole patient and using clinical judgment to apply current scientific knowledge appropriately to the individual.
CAM practitioners claim to be providing individualized treatments. Homeopaths look up symptoms like “dreams of robbers,” “sensation of coldness in the heart,” and “chills between 9 and 11 AM” in their books, and naturopaths quiz patients in great depth about their habits and preferences; but they don’t have a plausible rationale for interpreting the information they gather. And they have not been able to demonstrate better patient outcomes from using that information.
A new concept, “precision medicine,” was recently featured in UW Medicine, the alumni magazine of my alma mater, the University of Washington School of Medicine. Precision medicine strives to provide truly individualized care based on good science. It identifies the individual variations in people that make a difference in our ability to diagnose and treat accurately. Peter Byers, MD, director of the new Center for Precision Diagnostics at the University of Washington, calls it “the coolest part of medicine.” 
The “omic” tool set
It’s not enough to map the DNA; knowing that a patient has a gene doesn’t tell us whether that gene will be active, how it will interact with other genes or the environment, or what effects it will have. We need to understand how genes are expressed, what controls gene expression (what turns a gene on or off, or modifies its rate of function), and how RNA transcription molecules, proteins, and metabolic processes are involved. The 4-part “omic” tool set consists of:
    • Genomics: DNA sequencing and analysis. We have gone far beyond the methods of the Human Genome Project and can now sequence all the genes at the same time.
    • Transcriptomics: study of RNA transcript molecules.
    • Proteomics: study of the complete array of proteins produced by genes.
    • Metabolomics: study of small-molecule metabolites that fingerprint cellular processes resulting from gene expression.
The UW-Oncoplex cancer gene panel
Want personalized information about your cancer? Your surgeon can submit a sample of your tumor for a UW-Oncoplex cancer gene panel. It uses genetic sequencing to detect mutations in tumor tissue and identifies 194 cancer-related genes. It looks for “actionable” mutations, those we can do something about, for instance those that tell us one drug will work better than another. Potentially, it might some day be able to pick out cancers that are slow-growing and unlikely to metastasize, identifying patients who can safely avoid the risks and discomforts of radiation and chemotherapy.
Oncoplex uses next-generation “deep sequencing.” I don’t understand what that means, but apparently it can identify more kinds of mutations – not just single nucleotide variants, but also small insertions and deletions, gene amplifications, and selected gene-fusions. In an example given by Dr. Byers, a patient with metastatic lung cancer was found to have a gene fusion that had been missed by other genetic testing panels. Based on this new information, the patient was switched to crizotinib and had a complete symptomatic and radiographic response.
Quellos High-Throughput Screening Core
Researchers used to work with single test tubes. The process has been automated and miniaturized (see the picture above). Scientists can now work with plates that have as many as 1,536 compartments (“wells,” essentially tiny test tubes) that a machine automatically fills with as little as 50 nanoliters from tiny dispensing nozzles. The Quellos High-throughput Screening Core has a library of 120,000 compounds, including FDA-approved drugs, drugs in the testing stage, and candidates for future testing. Diseased cell samples can be simultaneously exposed to a multitude of compounds in various concentrations to see which ones damage or kill the cells, identifying drugs that merit further study. The system has both clinical uses (guiding treatment) and basic science applications like studying what happens downstream in cell metabolic processes when a specific gene is knocked out.
Precision medicine research at UW
Cancer researcher Pam Becker has been testing cells donated by her acute myeloid leukemia patients, and in almost every case the screening has suggested an alternate treatment that would not have been next in line.
Tony Blau, director of the UW Medicine Center for Cancer Innovation, and his wife, oncologist Sibel Blau, are using these techniques to test biopsy samples from women with metastatic triple-negative breast cancer, investigating how the tumor cells respond to 180 compounds and trying to incorporate the positive responses into the patient’s treatment regime.
Ophthalmologist Jennifer Chao is using Quellos to study macular degeneration. Stem cells are prodded into transforming into retinal pigment epithelium and the resulting cells are bombarded with factors that are thought to cause macular degeneration (the death of retinal cells), then they are exposed to 2,000 different medical compounds to see if any of them prevent cell death.
Neuropathologist Tom Montine is using precision medicine tools to study Alzheimer’s disease, which he compares to arthritis of the brain. A damaged joint can be further damaged by the body’s immune response, and immune regulation in the brain seems to play a key role in Alzheimer’s disease. He is attempting not just to identify the genetic drivers of the disease but to track the molecular pathways that provide the mechanisms for genetic influence.
The Act Smart initiative at the Institute for Prostate Cancer Research is a multi-million-dollar effort to understand and target prostate cancer tumors in ways specific to each patient, using the new tools of precision medicine.
Conclusion
This is an exciting time in medical science. We are just beginning to see authentic science-based individualized medical care. Accept no substitutes.

“Precision medicine”: Hope, hype, or both?
David Gorski on August 31, 2015
Link


I am fortunate to have become a physician in a time of great scientific progress. Back when I was in college and medical school, the thought that we would one day be able to sequence the human genome (and now sequence hundreds of cancer genomes), to measure the expression of every gene in the genome simultaneously on a single “gene chip,” and to assess the relative abundance of every RNA transcript, coding and noncoding (such as microRNAs) simultaneously through next generation sequencing (NGS) techniques was considered, if not science fiction, so far off in the future as to be unlikely to impact medicine in my career. Yet here I am, mid-career, and all of these are a reality. The cost of rapidly sequencing a genome has plummeted. Basically, the first human genome cost nearly $3 billion to sequence, while recent developments in sequencing technology have brought that cost down to the point where the “$1,000 genome” is within sight, if not already here, as illustrated in the graph above published by the National Human Genome Research Institute. Whether the “$1,000 genome” is truly here or not, the price is down to a few thousand dollars. Compare that to the cost of, for instance, the OncoType DX 21-gene assay for estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer, which costs nearly $4,000 and is paid for by insurance because its results can spare many women from even more expensive chemotherapy.
So, ready or not, genomic medicine is here, whether we know enough or not to interpret the results in individual patients and use it to benefit them, so much so that President Obama announced a $215 million plan for research in genomic mapping and precision medicine known as the Precision Medicine Initiative. Meanwhile, the deeply flawed yet popular 21st Century Cures bill, which passed the House of Representatives, bets heavily on genomic research and precision medicine. As I mentioned when I discussed the bill, it’s not so much the genomic medicine funding that is the major flaw in the bill but rather its underlying assumption that encouraging the FDA to decrease the burden of evidence to approve new drugs and devices will magically lead to an explosion in “21st century cures,” the same old antiregulatory wine in a slightly new bottle. Be that as it may, one way or the other, the federal government is poised to spend lots of money on precision medicine.
Because I’m a cancer doctor, and, if there’s one area in medicine in which precision medicine is being hyped the hardest, it’s hard for me not to think that the sea change that is going on in medicine really hit the national consciousness four years ago. That was when Walter Isaacson’s biography of Steve Jobs revealed that after his cancer had recurred as metastatic disease in 2010. Jobs had consulted with research teams at Stanford, Johns Hopkins, and the Broad Institute to have the genome of his cancer and normal tissue sequenced, one of the first twenty people in the world to have this information. At the time (2010-2011), each genome sequence cost $100,000, which Jobs could easily afford. Scientists and oncologists looked at this information and used it to choose various targeted therapies for Jobs throughout the remainder of his life, and Jobs met with all his doctors and researchers from the three institutions working on the DNA from his cancer at the Four Seasons Hotel in Palo Alto to discuss the genetic signatures found in Jobs’ cancer and how best to target them. Jobs’ case, as we now know, was a failure. However much Jobs’ team tried to stay one step ahead of his cancer, the cancer caught up and passed whatever they could do.
That’s not to say that there haven’t been successes. For instance, in 2012 I wrote about Dr. Lukas Wartman, at the time a recently-minted oncologist who had been diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia as a medical student, was successfully treated, but relapsed five years later. He underwent an apparently successful bone marrow transplant, but recurred again. At that point, there appeared to be little that could be done. However, Dr. Timothy Ley at the Genome Institute at George Washington University decided to do something radical. He sequenced the genes of Wartman’s cancer cells and normal cells:
The researchers on the project put other work aside for weeks, running one of the university’s 26 sequencing machines and supercomputer around the clock. And they found a culprit — a normal gene that was in overdrive, churning out huge amounts of a protein that appeared to be spurring the cancer’s growth.
That was 2011 as well. Today, the sequence could have been done much more rapidly. In any case, Ley identified a gene that was overactive and could be targeted by a new drug for kidney cancer. His cancer went into remission. Wartman is now the assistant director of cancer genomics at Washington University.
The technology now, both in terms of sequencing and bioinformatics, has advanced enormously even since 2011. With it has advanced the hype. But how much is hype and how much is really hope? Let’s take a look. Also, don’t get me wrong. I do believe there is considerable promise in precision medicine. However, having personally begun my research career in the 1990s, when angiogenesis inhibitors were being touted as the cure to all cancer (and we know what happened there), I am also skeptical that the benefits can ever live up to the hype.
The origin of “precision” medicine
“Precision medicine” is now the preferred term for what used to be called “personalized medicine.” From my perspective, it is a more accurate description of what “personalized medicine” meant, given that many doctors objected to the term because they felt that every good doctor practices personalized medicine. Even so, “precision medicine” is no less a marketing term than was “personalized medicine.” If you don’t believe this, look at the hype on the White House website:
Today, most medical treatments have been designed for the “average patient.” In too many cases, this “one-size-fits-all” approach isn’t effective, as treatments can be very successful for some patients but not for others. Precision medicine is an emerging approach to promoting health and treating disease that takes into account individual differences in people’s genes, environments, and lifestyles, making it possible to design highly effective, targeted treatments for cancer and other diseases. In short, precision medicine gives clinicians new tools, knowledge, and therapies to select which treatments will work best for which patients.
If you think this sounds like what alternative medicine quacks (but I repeat myself) routinely say about “conventional medicine,” you’d be right. It’s not that precision medicine advocates don’t have a germ of a point, but they fail to put it this criticism into historical context. Medicine has always been personalized or “precision.” It’s just that in the past the only tools we had to personalize our care were things like family history, comorbid conditions, patient preferences, and aspects of the patient’s history that might impact which treatment would be most appropriate. In other words, our tools to personalize care weren’t that “precise,” making our precision far less than we as physicians might have liked. Genomics and other new sciences offer the opportunity to change that, but at the cost that too much information will paralyze decision making. Still, at its best, precision medicine offers the opportunity to “personalize” medicine in a science-based manner, rather than the “make it up as you go along” and “pull it out of my nether regions” method of so many alternative medicine practitioners. It could also offer the clinical trials tools to do it, such as NCI-MATCH. At its worst, precision medicine is companies jumping the gun and selling genomic tests direct to the consumer without having an adequate scientific basis to know what they mean or what should be done with the results.
In any case, up until 2011, the term “personalized” medicine tended to be used to describe a form of medicine not yet in existence in which the each patients’ unique genomic makeup would serve as the basis to guide therapies. Then, the National Academy of Sciences Committee issued a report, “Toward Precision Medicine: Building a Knowledge Network for Biomedical Research and a New Taxonomy of Disease“, which advocated the term “precision medicine” and differentiated it from “personalized medicine” thusly:
“Personalized medicine” refers to the tailoring of medical treatment to the individual characteristics of each patient. It does not literally mean the creation of drugs or medical devices that are unique to a patient, but rather the ability to classify individuals into subpopulations that differ in their susceptibility to a particular disease or their response to a specific treatment. Preventive or therapeutic interventions can then be concentrated on those who will benefit, sparing expense and side effects for those who will not. (PCAST 2008) This term is now widely used, including in advertisements for commercial products, and it is sometimes misinterpreted as implying that unique treatments can be designed for each individual. For this reason, the Committee thinks that the term “Precision Medicine” is preferable to “Personalized Medicine” to convey the meaning intended in this report.
As I said, “precision medicine” is a marketing term, but it’s actually a better marketing term than “personalized medicine” because it is closer to what is really going on. That’s why I actually prefer it to “personalized medicine,” even though I wish there were a better term. Whatever it is called, however, the overarching belief that precision medicine is the future of medicine has led to what has been called an “arms race” or “gold rush” among academic medical centers to develop precision medicine initiatives, complete with banks of NGS machines, new departments of bioinformatics and genomics, and, of course, big, fancy computers to analyze the many petabytes of data produced, so much data that it’s hard to have enough media upon which to store it and we don’t know what to do with it. Genomic sequencing is producing so much data that IBM’s Watson is being used to analyze cancer genetics. It’s not for nothing that precision medicine is being likened to biology’s “moon shot“—and not always in a flattering way.
So what is the real potential of precision medicine?
Complexity intrudes
I discussed some of the criticism of precision medicine when I discussed the 21st Century Cures Act three weeks ago. I’ll try to build on that, but after a brief recap. Basically, I mentioned that I was of a mixed mind on the bill’s emphasis on precision medicine, bemoaning how now, at arguably the most exciting time in the history of biomedical research, the dearth of funding means that, although we’ve developed all these fantastically powerful tools to probe the deepest mysteries of the genome and use the information to design better treatments, scientists lack the money to do so. I even likened the situation to owning a brand new Maserati but there being no gasoline to be found to drive it, or maybe having the biggest, baddest car of all in the world of Mad Max but having to fight for precious gasoline to run it. I also noted that I thought precision medicine was overhyped (as I am noting again in this post), referencing skeptical takes on precision medicine in recent op-eds by Michael Joyner in The New York Times, Rita Rubin in JAMA declaring precision medicine to be more about politics, Cynthia Graber in The New Yorker, and Ronald Bayer and Sandro Galea in The New England Journal of Medicine. Basically, the number of conditions whose outcome can be greatly affected by targeting specific mutations is relatively small, far smaller than the impact likely would be from duller, less “sexy” interventions, such as figuring out how to get people to lose weight, exercise more, and drink and smoke less. The question is whether focusing in the genetic underpinnings of disease will provide the “most bang for the buck,” given how difficult and expensive targeted drugs are to develop.
Over the weekend, there was a great article in The Boston Globe by Sharon Begley entitled “Precision medicine, linked to DNA, still too often misses“, that gives an idea of just how difficult reaching this new world of precision medicine will be. It’s the story of a man named John Moore, who lives in Apple Valley, UT. Moore has advanced melanoma and participated in a trial of precision medicine for melanoma. His outcome shows the promise and limitations of such approaches:
Back in January, when President Obama proposed a precision medicine initiative with a goal of “matching a cancer cure to our genetic code,” John Moore could have been its poster child. His main tumors were shrinking, and his cancer seemed to have stopped spreading because of a drug matched to the cancer’s DNA, just as Obama described.
This summer, however, after a year’s reprieve, Moore, 54, feels sick every day. The cancer — advanced melanoma like former president Jimmy Carter’s — has spread to his lungs, and he talks about “dying in a couple of months.”
The return and spread of Moore’s cancer in a form that seems impervious to treatment shows that precision medicine is more complicated than portrayed by politicians and even some top health officials. Contrary to its name, precision medicine is often inexact, which means that for some patients, it will offer false hope rather than a cure.
On the other hand, in the Intermountain study, after two years, progression-free survival in the group with advanced cancer treated using precision medicine techniques was nearly twice what it was in those who underwent standard chemotherapy, 23 months versus 12 months. Moore himself reports that with a pill he had one year of improved health and quality of life before his cancer started progressing again. It’s not yet clear in this trial whether this will translate into an improvement in overall survival, the gold standard endpoint, but it’s a very promising start. It is, however, not a miraculous start.
Here’s the problem. I’ve alluded to it before. Cancer genomes are messed up. Really messed up. And, as they progress, thanks to evolution they become even more messed up, and messed up in different ways, so that the tumor cells in one part of a tumor are messed up in a different way than the tumor cells in another part of the tumor, which are messed up in a different way than the metastases. It’s called tumor heterogeneity.
Now enter the problem in determining which mutations are significant (commonly called “driver” mutations) and which are secondary or “just along for the ride” (commonly called “passenger” mutations):
But setbacks like Moore’s show that genetic profiling of tumors is, at this point, no more a cure for every cancer than angiogenesis inhibitors, which cut off a tumor’s blood supply, or other much-hyped treatments have been.
A big reason is that cancer cells are genetically unstable as they accumulate mutations. As a result, a biopsy might turn up dozens of mutations, but it is not always clear which ones are along for the ride and which are driving the cancer. Only targeting the latter can stop a tumor’s growth or spread.
Knowing which mutation is the driver and which are passenger mutations is so complicated that the Intermountain researchers established a “molecular tumor board” to help.
Composed of six outside experts in cancer genomics, the board meets by conference call to examine the list of a patient’s tumor mutations and reach a consensus about which to target with drugs. Tumor profiling typically finds up to three driver mutations for which there are known drugs, and the board reviews data on how well these drugs have worked in other patients with similar tumors.
And:
The next difficulty, Nadauld said, is that “the mutations may be different at different places in a tumor.” But oncologists are reluctant to perform multiple biopsies. The procedures can cause pain and complications such as infection, and there is no rigorous research indicating how many biopsies are necessary to snare every actionable mutation.
But a cancer-driving mutation that happens to lie in cells a mere millimeter away from those that were biopsied can be missed. Similarly, cancer cells’ propensity to amass mutations means that metastases, the far-flung descendants of the primary tumor, might be driven by different mutations and therefore need different drugs.
Or, as I like to say: Cancer is complicated. Really complicated. You just won’t believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly complicated it is. I mean, you may think it was tough to put a man on the moon, but that’s just peanuts to curing cancer, especially metastatic cancer. (Apologies to Douglas Adams.) Because of this, precision medicine as it exists now can lead to what Dr. Don S. Dizon calls a new kind of disappointment when genomic testing fails to identify any driver mutations for which targeted drugs exist because “discovery is an ongoing process and for many, we have not yet discovered the keys that drive all cancers, the therapies to address those mutations, and the tools to predict which treatment will afford the best response and outcome—an outcome our patients (and we) hope will mean a lifetime of living, despite cancer.”
Too true.
None of this is to say that precision medicine can’t be highly effective in cancer. I’ve already described one patient for whom it was. It’s also important to consider that even extra year of life taking a pill with few side effects is “not too shabby,” either, if the alternative is death a year sooner. Prolonging life with good quality is a favorable outcome, even if the patient can’t be saved in the end.
What is precision medicine, anyway?
As I thought about precision medicine during the writing of this post, one thing that stood out to me is that, although precision medicine is rather broadly defined, in the public eye (and, indeed, in the eyes of most physicians and scientists) its definition is much narrower. This narrower definition of precision medicine is the sequencing of patient genomes in order to find genetic changes that can be targeted for treatment, predict the response to therapy of various pharmaceuticals or dietary interventions, or predict disease susceptibility. In other words, it’s all genomics, genomics, genomics, much of it heavily concentrated in oncology. (I concentrated on oncology for this post because it is what I know best.) If you reread the definition from the National Academy of Sciences Committee report, you’ll see that precision medicine is defined much more broadly. Other similar definitions include metabolomics, environmental factors and susceptibilities, immunological factors, our microbiome, and many more, although even a recent editorial in Science Translational Medicine emphasized genomics more than other factors.
In fact, in the most recent JAMA Oncology, there are two articles, a study and a commentary, examining the effect of precision medicine in breast cancer. What is that “precision medicine”? It’s the OncoType DX assay, which is generically referred to as the 21 Gene Recurrence Score Assay.
Basically, this assay is used for estrogen receptor-positive (i.e., hormone-responsive) breast cancer that has not yet spread to the axillary lymph nodes. Twenty-one different genes related to proliferation, invasion, and other functions are measured, and an empirically derived formula is used to calculate a “recurrence score.” Scores below 18 indicate low risk of recurrence as metastatic disease and insensitivity to chemotherapy. Patients with low scores generally receive hormonal therapy but not chemotherapy. Scores over 30 indicate high risk and greater sensitivity to chemotherapy. For such patients, chemotherapy and hormonal therapy are recommended. Patients who score in the “gray” area from 18-30 remain a conundrum, but clinical trials are under way to better define the cutoff point for a chemo/no chemo recommendation. In any case, this study indicates that the use of OncoType DX is associated with decreased use of chemotherapy but because of limitations in the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) data set with linked Medicare claims, it wasn’t clear whether this decline was in appropriate patients. In any case, there’s no reason why genomic tests (like the Oncotype DX test) that are rapidly proliferating shouldn’t be considered “precision medicine,” and they are in practice already. Contrary to the image of oncologists wanting to push that poisonous chemotherapy, OncoType DX was designed with the intent of decreasing chemotherapy use in patients who will not benefit. Imagine that.
Conclusion: Medicine that works is just medicine
In the end, I don’t really like the term “precision medicine” that much. It seems to be a term that reminds me, more than anything, of Humpty Dumpty’s famously scornful boast, “When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.” It’s a sentiment that definitely seems to apply to the term “precision medicine.” To me, when new tests or factors that predict prognosis or response to therapy or suggest which therapies are likely to be most effective are developed and validated, it’s an artificial distinction to link them to genomics, proteomics, or whatever, as well as “big data” and refer to them as “precision medicine.” To me, medicine that works is just “medicine.”

Precision Medicine and Uncertainty
Harriet Hall on November 15, 2016
Tweet
Precision medicine is a development that promises to tailor treatments to the individual patient based on genetic and other molecular and cellular analyses. In his 2015 State of the Union address, President Obama announced the Precision Medicine Initiative. A website for Precision Medicine claims to offer “perfect care for every individual.”
Much of what we read about precision medicine gives the impression that it provides certainty. That’s a false impression. As David Hunter pointed out in a recent article in The New England Journal of Medicine, it may actually increase uncertainty.
He uses breast cancer gene studies as an example. New tools have extracted information about mutations, epigenetic events, and gene-expression alterations in tumors. Products like Oncotype DX, MammaPrint, PAM50 and others contribute information that goes beyond the traditional clinical prognostic factors like tumor size, grade, and nodal status. The new products are based on evidence about the risk of tumor recurrence, but no direct evidence about which specific treatments were more effective.
A study by Cardoso et al., published in the same issue of the NEJM, looked at the possibility of using the 70-gene MammaPrint test to select patients for adjuvant chemotherapy. They stratified patients into high and low clinical risk (C-high, C-low) and high and low genomic risk (G-high, G-low) and randomly assigned them to either get or not get adjuvant chemotherapy. In the C-low, G-high group, there was no difference between those who did and didn’t get chemotherapy; the genomic information was not helpful for patients at low clinical risk. In patients at high clinical risk, the results were equivocal: forgoing chemotherapy on the basis of low genomic risk resulted in a slightly worse outcome, but the difference was small, only 1.5 percentage points, and the study was not powered to determine whether it was statistically significant. This leaves women at high clinical risk with a difficult decision: if their genomic risk is low, they could avoid the toxic effects of treatment, but it might slightly increase their risk of recurrent cancer.
It’s good that studies like this are being done, but the results don’t provide certainty. In this particular study, dividing a continuous variable into two groups (high and low risk) sacrificed precision for interpretability. Different gene-expression products may result in different risk categorizations, and they improve as technology changes and more data becomes available; the MammaPrint data is 14 years old.
Cancer genomics data is problematic for a number of reasons. Different studies find different information. The raw sequences are usually not published, so results remain ambiguous and questionable. There are many variables, like changes in gene copy numbers and tumor sub-clones, that are not taken into consideration. Precision medicine doesn’t really tailor the treatment to the individual; it lumps large numbers of patients together in order to reach reproducible conclusions.
Hunter concludes:
In the future, we are likely to face a potentially bewildering array of probabilities — estimates of disease risk based on inherited germline sequencing and, once a disease is diagnosed, of prognosis and therapeutic options guided by “-omic” and other analyses. Assessing and acting on these probabilities will require approaches to data presentation, risk quantification, and communication of uncertainty for which we are largely ill equipped and that we already struggle with. In most situations, the best advice will be far from obvious and will often rely on a preliminary estimate as the data mature. In parallel to developing the tools for “-omic” analyses, we urgently need to develop methods to help our patients absorb large amounts of complex information that will help them make choices among increasingly numerous options with increasingly numerous trade-offs. These methods should also help our colleagues answer the age-old question, “What would you do, doctor?”
Conclusion: uncertainty remains
In the early days of genome analysis, the promise seemed infinite. We hoped to pinpoint the genes responsible for every illness. We hoped to find certainty and solutions. We are not there yet, and we are beginning to question whether we ever will be. Uncertainty has always been a part of medicine, and it will continue to be. Precision medicine has great potential, but so far it may only be increasing our uncertainty and making decisions more difficult.

The elusive “potential” of integrative medicine
Jann Bellamy on October 29, 2015
Link


UPDATE: Dr. Katz has responded to this post in his usual venue, The Huffington Post.
Alternative medicine was all about “potential” from the get go:
In 1991, the Senate Appropriations Committee responsible for funding the National Institutes of Health (NIH) declared itself “not satisfied that the conventional medical community as symbolized at the NIH has fully explored the potential that exists in unconventional medical practices.”
Thus, the Committee, led by chair Sen. Tom Harkin, directed the NIH to create an advisory panel that would “fully test the most promising unconventional medical practices.”
The advisory panel became the Office of Alternative Medicine, which became the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, which became the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine, its current iteration.
This effort to unlock the “potential” of unconventional (renamed alternative, renamed complementary and alternative, renamed integrative) medicine forced an uncomfortable alliance between science and pseudoscience from the beginning. Advocates like Harkin, and his two quackery-promoting constituents, Berkeley Bedell (colostrum and something called “714-X,” derived from camphor) and Frank Wiewel (immuno-augmenative therapy for cancer), were all for “fully testing” until they realized what “fully testing” meant to a scientist: double-blind, placebo controlled trials. It was thus that the true believers discovered the value of special pleading: they “favored quick field studies that would validate alternative treatments.”
Taxpayer monies flowed into legitimate medical and scientific research institutions to conduct alternative medicine research: the Maryland School of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, University of California at Davis, and the Texas Health Science Center, among others, received funds for the study of antineoplastons, cartilage products, magnets, mind-body control, and even Bedell and Wiewel’s beloved “714-X” and immuno-augmentative therapy.
As we discovered hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars later, the “potential” of alternative medicine was (surprise!) never realized.
Can I put you on hold?
Nearly a quarter century later, we are still waiting for the “potential” of integrative medicine, the grandchild of alternative medicine, to reveal itself. Proponents still argue that the scientific method must give way if we are to discover this potential. And taxpayers are still footing the bill.
A 2012 Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) grant is the perfect exemplar of the continued quest to unlock this much-ballyhooed potential. The American College of Preventive Medicine was the recipient of this grant, designed to establish an “Integrative Medicine in Preventive Medicine Education program,” in 12 preventive medicine residency programs (yet another exercise in quackademic medicine). A special issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine (AJPM) provides the details.
A familiar figure hovered behind this effort: Sen. Tom Harkin, who was involved in what is described as “an extended period of discussion . . . about the need for just such a program.” This appears to be yet another effort by members of Congress to rob HRSA of monies designed to improve access to health care so that pet projects devoted to integrating pseudoscience into medicine can be funded.
Another familiar promoter of integrative medicine (sometimes referred to as “IM”) was even more deeply involved: David Katz, MD, who teed off the special issue with an article: “Preventive Medicine Training: the Case for Integrating Integrative Medicine.” Joined by Ather Ali, ND, his protégé at Yale, he authored another article as well: “Disease Prevention and Health Promotion: How Integrative Medicine Fits.”
Dr. Katz has been the subject of several SBM posts. The Cliff Notes version is this: he is the director of the Yale-Griffin Prevention Research Center. Its goal, according to the website, is to “develop innovative approaches to health promotion and disease prevention that will directly benefit the public’s health.” Nothing wrong with that. But Dr. Katz has an unfortunate affinity for CAM, especially naturopathy.
Naturopathy: Abandoning patients into pseudoscience
Dr. Katz believes that CAM treatments can and should be offered to patients, apparently on the premise that, when conventional medicine has no proven treatments for a patient’s condition, physicians are free to proffer the unproven and implausible because, to do otherwise, would be to “abandon” patients. (Which is, as we at SBM have pointed out more than once, a false dichotomy.) His view of CAM providers is appallingly naïve: he apparently thinks that they are sitting around twiddling their thumbs until they get the call from a physician to administer a carefully curated treatment. He seems blind to the fact that naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists are, in fact, practicing a vast array of quackery that he would never dream of suggesting to a patient.
Thus, he is a relentless promoter of integrative medicine, which he believes offers “the best of both” conventional medicine and CAM. And he can get testy when challenged on the subject. Which I am about to do.
The premise for the grant was, according to Dr. Katz:
Preventive medicine residents are trained to prevent disease and promote health. Integrative medicine places a considerable emphasis on these same goals, on holistic models of care to facilitate them, and on lifestyle practices.
Note that word: “goals.” Dr. Katz freely admits that these “goals” remain unrealized:
Integrative medicine . . . offers, in theory at least, the opportunity to combine the ‘best’ of the conventional healthcare system and practices and providers commonly considered to be CAM, and thereby produce better outcomes. . .
He then goes on to “discuss the potential for integrative medicine across the prevention spectrum,” admitting that this potential is not “fully elucidated” and that “data derived from direct tests of integrative care models are promising but preliminary.” And, despite much lip service being given to integrative medicine’s alleged emphasis on preventing disease and health promotion, he admits that “this potential” is unrealized: “the authors are not aware of evidence of enhanced screening and preventive services in integrative medicine.” However, “many CAM approaches have demonstrated promise . . . [and] the potential to improve outcomes rationally follows.”
Integrative medicine, as well, “has the potential to add to obesity prevention and control efforts,” although the “scientific evidence underlying [recommendations of dietary supplements] has long been suspect.” CAM therapies for pain “vary in demonstrated efficacy” and other integrative approaches for diabetes and cardiovascular risk markers “suggest public health benefits as well as possible cost savings.”
And so on: Integrative medicine offers “the promise of” achieving the goals of preventive medicine, outcomes research on models of integrative care “demonstrate promise” and “potential cost savings” and “some posit” a salutary effect of integrative research.
And, finally, in the penultimate paragraph of the Katz-Ali article:
Evaluating the current state of integrative medicine and preventive medicine leads to a number of fundamental research questions that can address essential gaps. The role of integrative medicine in areas germane to primary and secondary prevention needs to be better assessed in terms of rates of uptake of clinical preventive services, as well as the ability to demonstrably improve diet, physical activity, and smoking-cessation efforts. The question of whether integrative clinicians model healthy behavior and influence their patients in comparison to other clinicians is relevant, as well as cost-effectiveness studies of integrative practices in high-priority areas such as pain management and adjunctive cancer care.
In other words, according to Katz and Ali, here’s what we don’t know about integrative medicine:
    • Whether IM really offers the best of conventional medicine and CAM.
    • Whether IM produces better outcomes.
    • Whether IM is effective in the area of prevention, including obesity and cardiovascular risk.
    • Whether IM has anything to offer preventive medicine.
    • Whether future IM research will yield beneficial results.
    • Whether IM has a positive impact on utilization clinical preventive services, smoking cessation, diet and physical activity.
    • Whether IM is cost effective.
I think the only “case” Dr. Katz makes is that integrative medicine promoters need more research money to pursue the ever-elusive “potential” of integrative medicine, and preventive medicine residencies happened to be a convenient and free parking place for the moment. And they do it by taking funds from a limited pot of the public’s money that would otherwise be devoted to improving access to health care. What a waste.
Having admitted that they’ve got nothing, Dr. Katz ventures forth with what might be called the W.C. Fields protocol:
If you can’t dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with bullshit.
Or, in his words:
The simple argument supporting integrative are is that modern medical science and knowledge, despite profound successes, comprises far less than patient need. Integrative care is not a comprehensive solution, but does expand the array of patient options, and can increase the likelihood of success that can be assembled across the stages of prevention.
The “array of patient options” being, in the language of Mr. Fields, the aforementioned BS, here in the form of CAM. Which nicely segues into Mark Crislip’s famous observation:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Warning: Tongue diagnosis may cause discomfort
The lack of evidence for integrative medicine is not the discipline’s (if one could call it that) only problem. As I’ve discussed before, there isn’t even a taxonomy of IM practices to guide a research agenda. More basically, there isn’t an agreed definition of the term “integrative medicine.” Dr. Katz admits this as well, noting the “competing definitions” and “perennial dissatisfaction with the relevant nomenclature.”
Another challenge was a distinct queasiness concerning incorporating pseudoscience into a science-based preventive medicine residency program. This, in turn, evolved into an interesting question: is CAM necessary to integrative medicine? We’ll return to that in a moment.
Some of the residency programs involved in the grant described their efforts in articles included in the AJPM issue. Each program incorporated IM in a different way (e.g., journal clubs, lectures, working with IM and CAM practitioners). As best I can tell from reading these reports, IM was presented by those in charge of implementation as worthy of incorporating into preventive medicine residency. Dr. Katz’s statements about the overlap between IM and preventive medicine goals, the “potential” for IM, and so forth, were repeated without questioning.
For example, from the IM training program at the University of California, San Diego, preventive medicine residency program:
PA [physical activity] and nutrition, the backbone of integrative medicine training programs, served as the curriculum framework.
Even though the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health IM medical school curriculum mentions exercise only in passing. (Who’s that, you say? There’s another name change for you: this is the new name for the Consortium of Academic Medical Centers for Integrative Medicine.) Ironically, UC San Diego’s program doesn’t seem to have employed integrative medicine as part of its IM residency training at all. It based its so-called IM training on the “Exercise is Medicine” initiative developed by the American College of Sports Medicine and “utilizing guidelines developed by [the ACSM], Cooper Clinic, American Heart Association, International Society for Clinical Densitometry, and American Geriatric Society.” Because, you know, conventional medicine doesn’t know anything about exercise.
(Other articles cover the IM program in preventative medicine residencies at the University of Maryland, Rutgers, University of Michigan, Johns Hopkins, Boston Medical Center, and Yale.)
Despite the particular affinity of IM for CAM, the medical staff and residents were not all that warm to the idea of including pseudoscience.
At the University of Maryland:
Resident feedback suggested discomfort with concepts of Traditional Chinese Medicine such as tongue diagnosis as well as terms, such as “kidney” points and “obstruction” that may be interpreted differently by allopathic physicians and [TCM] practitioners.
And, at the University of Michigan:
Another concern addressed . . . involved the anti-vaccine beliefs held by a community-based IM physician that one of our residents visited and is incongruent with the principles and practice of public health and preventive medicine.
So, did the IM program kick this anti-vaxxer out? Apparently not.
Owing to this concern, [we] requested that the IM rotation become elective for future resident cohorts.
At Yale, the IM program wanted a “naturopathic physician” to attend clinic with the residents. To the clinic administration’s credit, this didn’t happen. For one thing, the administration was unwilling to bypass the normal credentialing process for the naturopath. He (or she) was allowed only limited access to educate the residents, but could not interact with patients.
In fact, the Yale Integrative Medicine Clinic closed its doors in 2014 due to lack of financial viability and residents can no longer do an elective IM rotation there, although it is still available at the Yale Stress Center where Dr. Katz is also involved.
At the end of the two-year grant, it was far from clear that the PM residency programs would continue with IM training. According to the post-program analysis, the most prevalent expectations were for IM rotations to continue, but only as elective rotations, and for IM lectures and grand rounds to become less frequent.
Is CAM necessary?
In the post-program analysis, the inclusion of CAM emerged as the main stumbling block in implementation of IM training in residency. This led to the observation that:
The [Institute of Medicine, IOM] definition of IM guiding this project does not require inclusion of what are generally thought of as CAM modalities, and the funder did not require CAM inclusion. Nonetheless, it is widely held that IM comprises both conventional Western and CAM practices.
(This definition is contained in the IOM’s “Integrative Medicine and the Health of the Public,” an effort Kimball Atwood deconstructed. His post also demonstrates that IM has long claimed, without evidence, that it is all about “prevention.”)
To Dr. Katz, CAM is essential to IM. IM is “the fusion . . . of conventional medical practices that fall under the . . . CAM rubric.” The “best” of both. Indeed, he says, “the rationale for integrative medicine depends largely on a rationale for CAM.” And he proposes a distinctly double standard for employing conventional versus CAM treatments.
Nevertheless, the authors of the post-program analysis think the “foremost” question to be answered in further discussion among the preventive medicine community in integrating IM into training and practice may be “the extent to which inclusion of CAM procedures is essential to the practice of IM.” They note that the IOM offers “little guidance” in answering this question and that the reference in the definition to “therapeutic factors known to be effective and necessary . . .” could exclude CAM just as well as include it.
Conclusion: When is enough, enough?
But if Dr. Katz is correct, if integrative medicine = conventional medicine + CAM, what is left of IM if the CAM is left out? Conventional medicine. Which we already have, so IM is unnecessary. Which has, in fact, always been the case.
But, more to the point, when is it time to abandon the search for this elusive “potential” of alternative/complementary/integrative medicine? What is a sufficient amount of time to allot to this expensive yet unyielding research? I’d say 25 years is a nice, round number. That would be 2016, or about two months from now.

On “integrative medicine” and walking and chewing gum at the same time
Evidence matters. Science matters. However, when advocates of “integrating” quackery into medicine via the vehicle of “integrative medicine” invoke weak science and poor quality evidence in conventional medicine in response to criticism, what they are really doing is deflecting attention away from their quackery. More importantly, advocates of science-based medicine are capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time. We can call out quackery while still advocating for more rigorous science supporting medicine.
David Gorski on November 16, 2015
Link

I didn’t think I’d be discussing Dr. David Katz again so soon. In fact, when Mark Crislip (who clearly hates me, given how often he sends me links to articles like this) sent me a link to Dr. Katz’s latest article, “Cleaning the House of Medicine“, published—where else?—in The Huffington Post, that home for “reputable” quack-friendly bloviation since 2005, when I first read the article, my first reaction was that Katz must surely be trolling us here at SBM. At first, I wasn’t going to respond to him again. However, Katz’s article represents a very common misconception about science-based medicine that is worth refuting. It is not my intention to be arguing back and forth with Dr. Katz every couple of weeks, but I did think it worth one more round. I think you’ll understand why by the end of this post.
First, however, a brief recap is in order for readers who might not have been following the discussion over the last month or so. It all started a couple of weeks ago, when Jann Bellamy, in response to a special issue of the American Journal of Preventative Medicine edited by Katz and dedicated to making the case for integrative medicine in preventive medicine training, quite correctly discussed how “integrative medicine” is always all about the “potential.” Indeed, after having spent considerable sums of federal grant money studying the “integration” of pseudoscience into medicine with respect to preventive care, the journal couldn’t come up with any concrete examples how integrative medicine adds anything (other than quackery) to medicine. Dr. Katz, who is well-known in the world of quackademic medicine for his infamous 2008 speech in which he asserted that physicians need to use a “more fluid concept of evidence” in evaluating treatments, particularly “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), responded with another HuffPo article entitled “Science and Medicine, Fools and Fanatics: The ‘Fluidity’ of Woo“. In lieu of reasonable, science-based arguments, Dr. Katz’ article was little more than a rant that consisted mainly of outrage that mere mortals lacking his awesome academic credentials had had the temerity to question his awesomeness and dedication to science coupled with an accusation that we are just too rigid and simplistic in our thinking to understand the subtle complexities of how different standards of evidence must be applied to complex patients. Steve Novella and I both responded that we understand just fine, explained how doctors do this all the time without using quackery like naturopathy and homeopathy (both of which Katz has advocated), and pointed out his argumentum ad ignorantiam with respect to energy medicine.
There’s where I thought it would end. Unfortunately, I was mistaken. On Friday, Katz launched another broadside at us, couched in the form of an argument that medicine must “clean its own house” before worrying about his quackademic medicine. It’s something I hear often enough that I thought it would be worth responding to, even if Dr. Katz was indeed trolling us.
Worry about what I think you should worry about
A frequent attack on science-based medicine (both the blog and the concept) goes something like this: There are so many problems in medicine when it comes to the rigorous application of evidence to medical treatments, such as the distortion of evidence by big pharma, the overuse of various treatments, and the use of treatments without a good basis in evidence, that we really shouldn’t worry so much about things like CAM or integrative medicine because there are far bigger fish to fry. In other words, worry and write about what I think you should worry and write about! If you don’t, clearly I can discount you as ideologically blinded. Indeed, Katz makes exactly this argument near the end of his article, with the further implication that because we here at SBM focus mostly on integrative medicine and CAM it must be due to ideology, not science (or, of course, as implied elsewhere, because we are in the thrall of big pharma):
To the best of my knowledge, a rather boisterous group in cyberspace calling itself “science based medicine” is silent on all of this. They preferentially malign all alternatives to conventional medicine, implying that problems of evidence and its application lie entirely without, and not within. This, in turn, makes it clear that such protest is itself unconcerned with the underlying evidence, and born instead of ideological zealotry. If evidence matters, it matters equitably, and universally.
Of course, we at SBM agree that evidence and science must matter equitably and universally. Indeed, our fearless founder Steve Novella wrote of this in the very first post ever on this blog, in which he laid out its manifesto:
This is why the authors of this blog strongly advocate for science-based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. The authors are all medically trained and have spent years writing for the public about science and medicine, tirelessly advocating for high scientific standards in health care. Together, and with contributions from other medical science writers, they will turn a critical eye toward all issues relating to science and medicine. They hope to make the Science-Based Medicine blog a vital resource for consumers, providers, regulators, the media, and anyone interested in quality health care.
That was the beginning. Over the years, I’ve lost track of how many times I (and other bloggers here) have pointed out that we advocate applying a single science-based standard to all of medicine. Dr. Katz also clearly has only ever read our posts here about him, because he sets up a rather massive straw man argument by characterizing us as claiming that we are saying that the problems of evidence and its application lie “entirely without, and not within.” What? No, the problems with application of evidence are indeed within medicine. The reason we discuss CAM so frequently is because the reason it is becoming more “respectable” is not because it’s being forced on medicine from without, but rather because certain, well-respected members of the medical profession (like Dr. Katz) are misapplying evidence from within, so to speak. After all, this is the physician who thinks naturopathy is a valid medical specialty and is willing to use homeopathy.
It was also at this point that I wanted to make like Ygritte in Game of Thrones and retort, “You know nothing Jon Snow David Katz.” Clearly, Dr. Katz knows nothing (or next to nothing other than our occasional criticism of his statements) about what we do here.
Because we at SBM argue for the rigorous application of science to medicine, over the years we have written posts questioning all manner of “conventional” medical interventions. I’ll start by mentioning just a few of my own posts questioning various conventional medical interventions, such as vertebroplasty for osteoporotic compression fractures, which I referred to as “placebo medicine.” Then there’s mammography, which has been a frequent topic on this blog ever since the USPSTF issued screening guidelines in 2009 that involved not starting screening until age 50 and then screening only every other year rather than every year and continuing to the publication last month of new guidelines by the American Cancer Society guidelines, which also backed off, albeit not as much, from starting mammographic screening at age 40. In the context of screening, I’ve discussed overdiagnosis in cancer screening and criticized a certain eminent radiologist who defends mammography at all costs, to the point where he wrote an e-mail complaining to me that reminded me of Dr. Katz’s displeasure with us. I’ve discussed how surgical procedures are often adopted too rapidly, before there is adequate evidence that they are as good as or better than the procedures they supplant. That doesn’t even count the times I discussed some downright abusive and criminal conventional doctors and spectacular failures of state medical boards.
That’s just me writing about science in medicine, particularly one of my areas of interest, overdiagnosis due to screening.
It would be unfair to discuss only my writings, though; so I will “cherry pick” some recent high points from other SBM regulars. Over the last few weeks, Steve Novella, for instance, has discussed concepts like the number needed to treat, low energy sweeteners and weight control, whether placebos are getting stronger, open versus blinded peer review, and a lot of other topics that have nothing to do with integrative medicine. Harriet, for her part, has written about breast milk testing, immunity, misleading headlines about “female Viagra,” and the horror of conventional medicine gone wrong when frontal lobotomy became widely popular. (Come to think of it, so did I once when discussing medical history and how procedures were portrayed in radio shows of the 1950s.) Meanwhile, Scott Gavura wrote about whether an aspirin a day decreases your risk of cancer.
I could go on, but got tired after finding just this much. You get the idea. Yes, we do write a lot about CAM and “integrative medicine.” We make no apologies for that. If I’m sounding a little defensive as editor of SBM, I make no apologies for that, either. Attacks based on ignorance of what we do irritate me. We write about plenty of other medical topics that have nothing to do with CAM. What they do have to do with is exactly what Dr. Katz accuses us of ignoring: Calling out areas of medicine where the application of scientific evidence is not so rigorous. He ought to love us for that, but he doesn’t. I wonder why.
The flying carpet problem
Dr. Katz uses a recent systematic review published in JAMA Internal Medicine presenting evidence against certain medical practices that should be reconsidered in 2015 as his jumping off point:
A recent report in JAMA Internal Medicine highlights prevailing medical practices that should be “reconsidered” in 2015 based on the weight of evidence. The paper, appropriately, is written in the matter-of-fact style customary for the peer-reviewed literature. To some extent, that semblance of analytical calm belies the storm swirling between the lines of the report, and the mess it has long been making in the House of Medicine.
The authors, for instance, note that excessive zeal for cancer screening results in “unnecessary surgery and complications.” As a statement, that is rather bland, and even when statistics are attached to show scale, as the authors do, it likely fails to evoke any deep impression. But consider any time you have been through surgery yourself, either as the patient, or as a family member. Unless you are the rare individual who has avoided the OR entirely, even by proxy, those occasions are likely indelible in your memory, and easy to recall.
Of course, this is nothing that we (myself in particular) haven’t been discussing quite frankly on SBM since at least 2008 (which, not coincidentally, is the year SBM was founded). Just type the words “overdiagnosis” and “mammography” or “overdiagnosis” and “screening” into the search box of this. Heck, I even just recently co-authored an article in the New England Journal of Medicine discussing this very issue and how widespread mammographic screening programs appear not to have decreased the incidence of metastatic breast cancer at diagnosis. I note that this NEJM article came about because H. Gilbert Welch has read SBM. Liking my posts on mammography, he invited me to co-author the article with him, and I jumped at the opportunity. In fact, I can’t help pointing out to Dr. Katz that this NEJM article, as well as my Nature Reviews Cancer article about integrative oncology and Steve’s and my article on clinical trials of highly implausible treatments are extensions into the peer-reviewed medical literature of what we’ve been doing here at SBM since the beginning. We hope to do more.
But back to the study. Let’s summarize its findings briefly. Basically, the authors, from Yale University, the University of Maryland, Johns Hopkins, and the Memorial-Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, did a structured review of studies published in 2014 selected for use of the following words in the title: overuse, overtreatment, overdiagnosis, inappropriate, and unnecessary. Results were limited to human studies and the English language and reviewed by the authors for relevance to overuse. The ten most relevant studies were selected, highlighted, and organized into the categories of overdiagnosis, overtreatment, and methods to avoid overuse. Here are the findings:
     1.  There Is No Benefit to Screening for Asymptomatic Carotid Stenosis. The authors cited the USPSTF review that showed that screening for asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis leads to false-positive results. There is no evidence that it reduces stroke on the side where carotid blockage is found.
     2.  Screening Pelvic Examinations Are Inaccurate in Asymptomatic Women and Are Associated With Harms That Exceed Clinical Benefits. The authors cite a review from the American College of Physicians that failed to demonstrate benefit of routine pelvic examinations in women who are asymptomatic.
     3.  Head Computed Tomography Is Often Ordered but Is Rarely Helpful. If you’ve ever done trauma (as I did during residency and as a part-time trauma attending back in the late 1990s), you know that we order too many head CTs. The study cited didn’t necessarily show that ordering the first CT is not indicated, but rather questioned the use of serial CTs, leading the authors to conclude that a second head CT scan “rarely affects patient management” and that “clinicians should be judicious in ordering multiple CT scans in the same patient,” as only 4% of these CTs showed clinically significant findings that changed the medical or surgical management of the patient.
     4.  Thyroid Cancer Is Massively Overdiagnosed, Leading to Concrete Harms. I discussed the overdiagnosis of thyroid cancer as part of a post about screening for cancer in general way back in 2008. Harriet has discussed overdiagnosis of thyroid cancer herself. This is not a new topic.
     5.  There Is No Benefit to Paracetamol or Acetaminophen for Acute Low Back Pain. A large, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial tells us so.
     6.  Postoperative Opioid Use Continues Past the Postoperative Period. Basically, the authors cite a cohort study that showed that 3% of patients given a prescription for opioids after surgery are still taking them 90 days later. To be honest, I’m not sure I buy this one; undertreatment of pain appears to me to be more of a problem than overtreatment, at least in cancer patients.
     7.  The Harms of Perioperative Aspirin Outweigh the Benefits in Patients Undergoing Noncardiac Surgery. The Perioperative Ischemic Evaluation-2 [POISE-2] trial tells us so.
     8.  Renal Artery Revascularization for Renal Artery Stenosis Has No Clinical Benefit. There are several randomized trials that show that medical management does as well as stenting for blood pressure control and preventing deterioration of kidney function.
     9.  Medications to Raise High-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol Level Do Not Improve Cardiovascular Outcomes. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis supports this conclusion.
Another systematic review from earlier this year suggests that testing doesn’t reassure patients; testosterone supplementation might harm patients (as Peter Lipson, Harriet Hall, David Kroll, and I have pointed out); inappropriate antibiotics use can cause C. difficile colitis (well, duh!); and that dramatic regional variations in surgical practice is driven largely by physicians.
So, yes, medicine has a lot of “housecleaning” to do. Here’s the problem. His implication is that because medicine has problems with treatments that are not as rigorously evidence-based as they should be our focus on CAM is misguided and based on ideology rather than science. To this, I respond: Nonsense! I also like to quote Ben Goldacre at this point:
Quacks citing problems in pharma make me laugh. FLAWS IN AIRCRAFT DESIGN DO NOT PROVE THE EXISTENCE OF MAGIC CARPETS.
— ben goldacre (@bengoldacre) January 31, 2013
Similarly, just because big pharma misbehaves and conventional medicine practitioners don’t always use the most rigorous evidence does not mean that, for example, homeopathy or energy medicine works, as Dr. Katz seems to believe they might. It’s also worth pointing out at this point that the reason we tend to emphasize the pseudoscience that is much of CAM is because (1) there are plenty of others in medicine now calling out big pharma and insisting on more rigorous evidence and (2) CAM largely gets a free pass because the expertise needed to analyze CAM claims in light of science is not an expertise possessed by many physicians. In other words, SBM fills a gap in the movement to promote a more rigorous application of science to the practice of medicine. In addition, contrary to what Dr. Katz thinks, we at SBM can walk and chew gum at the same time. We can call out the pseudoscience of CAM and integrative medicine while we advocate for more rigorous science in all areas of conventional medicine.
Let’s look at an example of how we do this.
In which I walk and chew gum at the same time
At this point, I feel as though I’ve flipped the script and, to an extent, changed roles with Dr. Katz. Last time, I criticized him for referring to his own medical authority (and awesome CV) over and over again in comparison, presumably, to us mere medical mortals and Jann Bellamy, who is not a physician. Here, I am about to assert my authority on this issue, because, well, you know nothing, Dr. Katz, about what we here at SBM do aside from criticizing pseudoscience in medicine. Also, doing so serves the purpose of demonstrating that it is indeed possible to walk and chew gum at the same time, as hard as it seems for Dr. Katz to believe.
Near the end of his article, Dr. Katz pontificates:
Were I tasked with rebutting the very case I am making in this column, I would say: Well, the articles cited here are evidence that conventional medicine is policing itself, seeking ever more evidence and a higher standard. That is just what we would hope to see.
That is the best, and perhaps only argument for the defense, and might matter if it managed to thrive, but alas, it is stillborn. The simple fact is that the products of conventional medicine — Big Pharma, Big Tech, and the associated patents — are routinely promulgated, widely practiced, and massively reimbursed, often for years, before there is evidence to support them. Evidence to repudiate them comes after, and this despite our prime directive: first, do no harm. In stark contrast, the often kinder, gentler, but unpatented offerings of other domains are repudiated for years until or unless evidence comes in to exonerate them, and sometimes, even then.
In other words, the prevailing pattern is that “we” (i.e., conventional medicine) are innocent until proven guilty, but everyone else is guilty until proven innocent. No special olfactory acuity is required to discern how bad that smells.
One can’t help but note that I discussed that bit of CAM allegedly “repudiated for years.” Let’s just say that Dr. Katz’s take on the matter is…exaggerated.
And, yes, it is rather amusing that Dr. Katz writes so bitterly about medical practices that lack rigorous evidence using an article from a peer-reviewed journal that is about as mainstream as there is, JAMA Internal Medicine, pointing out that those very practices should be questioned in light of new evidence. Heck, I’ll even concede that if Dr. Katz had written this article ten years ago, he would have had a point about medicine not being sufficiently vigorous at calling out and abandoning practices for which the scientific evidence is not sufficiently strong. Apparently, though, Dr. Katz is unaware that over the last several years there really has been a movement to do exactly what he says he wants done: To subject conventional medical practices to heavier scientific scrutiny and discard the ones that don’t make the cut.
My example of this movement in medicine is an initiative from the Foundation of the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) called Choosing Wisely, whose goal is to advance “a national dialogue on avoiding wasteful or unnecessary medical tests, treatments and procedures.” It did this by working with Consumer Reports to challenge medical specialty societies in 2012 to come up with lists of medical practices that should be questioned in light of evidence. Thus far, over 70 medical specialty societies have done so. We at SBM like the Choosing Wisely initiative so much that we’ve written about it several times, most recently my post from three weeks ago pointing out how thus far Choosing Wisely hasn’t had much of an effect on medical practice because changing entrenched practices is very hard.
In fact, I’ll let Dr. Katz—and you—in on a little secret. (Well, it’s not a secret, given that I’ve mentioned it before.) I spend a lot of my time doing exactly what Dr. Katz says we as physicians should be doing and working to improve the quality of care by making it more evidence-based. In fact, I am the co-director of a statewide collaborative quality initiative (CQI) known as the Michigan Breast Oncology Quality Initiative (MiBOQI). We are 25-hospitals strong and looking to expand to more. Our mission is “to collect accurate data on women diagnosed with breast cancer in Michigan. We will collect demographic, diagnostic, treatment, and outcome data, and use this information to evaluate current standards of care and to initiate quality improvement efforts that will advance breast cancer treatments in order to improve patient outcomes.”
Indeed, one of our quality initiatives is based on Choosing Wisely, specifically the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) guideline not to do advanced imaging (PET, CT, or bone scans) in patients with early stage breast cancer without symptoms suggestive of metastasis. The reason, of course, is that in this group of patients metastasis is so uncommon at the time of presentation that the false positives far outstrip the true positives, leading to the sorts of additional interventions that Dr. Katz is so concerned about, and rightly so.
Isn’t this exactly what Dr. Katz says we at SBM don’t do in our ideological hatred of all things CAM? Near the end, he sneeringly writes:
The cleanup will certainly not come courtesy of those calling themselves “science-based,” who live within its glass walls, tossing stones outward. They produce nothing more useful than shards of glass.
It will come courtesy of those who concede, with suitable humility, that no single domain of influence has a monopoly on dirty boots. It will come courtesy of those who like a level playing field, and respect the potential for baby and bathwater in any given tub.
It will come courtesy of those who acknowledge that the blank in “_____ based medicine” has a long and rather unsavory list of applicants: profit; pharmaceutical; habit; preference; patent; turf; privilege; and status quo, to name a few. It is up to us to fill in that blank with a designation that is both desired, and deserved; both what we want, and what we actually do. That requires a much harder task than calling out the dirt on everyone else’s boots. It requires a serious devotion to cleaning our own house.
Which is exactly what I am involved in doing. It is possible to walk and chew gum at the same time. What, I wonder, is Dr. Katz doing to make the actual medicine more science-based? In fact, I’ll take it one step further. I have yet to see a single “CAM” organization or advocate like Dr. Katz take any serious, concrete steps to make their practice more science-based by abandoning treatments unsupported by evidence. The reason, of course, is that if they were to do that they would have to abandon most of the practices they want to “integrate” into medicine.
Dr. Katz’s double standard
Dr. Katz’s latest screed is very much of a piece with his previous screeds. Although I didn’t want to at first, I ultimately considered it necessary to counter his criticism, even though I suspected Dr. Katz was trolling us, because his criticism is one that is directed at us all too frequently. Basically, he is accusing us of hypocrisy because we write so much about the pseudoscience and quackery that is being “integrated” into medicine in the specialty known as “integrative medicine” but, from his perspective, do not write about problems with the evidence base of conventional medicine. He is wrong on both counts, and I suspect that, even if 95% of our output was about conventional medicine and 5% about CAM pseudoscience and quackery, Dr. Katz would still focus like a laser beam on that 5%. As I’ve shown above, we do write about issues with evidence in conventional medicine—and not infrequently, either. Also, unlike Dr. Katz, outside of our blogging and other activism, some of us do far more to promote what Dr. Katz claims he wants to promote than Dr. Katz himself does.
As I and the other bloggers here have said time and time again, enshrining this principle in our mission, the best medicine is medicine that has a firm basis in science. It doesn’t matter whether we are referring to conventional, big pharma-produced drugs, surgery, or diagnostic tests or whether we are referring to anything that is considered “alternative,” CAM, or “integrative medicine.” We here at SBM always advocate for a single, science-based standard of evidence for evaluating medical practices. Yes, we concentrate more on CAM and “integrative medicine.” We make no apologies for that because we fill a niche that is not well covered by those advocating a the more rigorous application of science to medical practice and also because most physicians are genuinely unaware of just how much pseudoscience has infiltrated—excuse me, been “integrated” into—conventional medicine. Moreover, This integration of quackery into medicine in the form of what we like to call “quackademic medicine” is in itself a double standard, allowing into medicine treatments that someone like Dr. Katz would never approve of if they had been developed by big pharma or medical device companies. Just look at his conspiracy mongering about “big food” and “big pharma” conspiring for big food to profit by making people sick and then to have big pharma profit by treating those sicknesses, if you don’t believe me.
Dr. Katz is correct that “if evidence matters, it matters equitably, and universally.” We don’t argue with that at all. In fact, we not only agree with that statement, but we champion it in word and deed. If only Dr. Katz would do the same, instead of advocating a double standard whereby pseudoscience and quackery can be integrated into medicine using a standard of evidence that he would never accept for any other medical treatment.

Is there a distinct standard of care for “integrative” physicians? The Woliner case
We at SBM argue that there should be a single, science-based standard of care in medicine. Unfortunately, with the rise of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) also called “integrative medicine,” there is a separate standard emerging that allows CAM practitioners to get away with using unproven and disproven treatments. The case of Dr. Kenneth Woliner illustrates this problem.
Jann Bellamy on October 13, 2016
Link


Florida Atlantic University student Stephanie Sofronsky was diagnosed with Hodgkin’s lymphoma in 2011, after review of her case by oncologists and pathologists at Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa, the NIH/National Cancer Institute, and the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville. By June of that year, a PET scan showed the cancer had progressed to her pelvic region. She decided to be treated locally by oncologist Neal Rothschild, MD, and met with him to discuss chemotherapy and ongoing management of her cancer. At this point, with Stage III Hodgkin’s lymphoma, she had an 80-85% chance of being in complete remission with appropriate treatment.
Unfortunately, at the same time, Sofronsky was also seeing Kenneth Woliner, MD, a family medicine practitioner. Despite the fact that world-renowned cancer specialists agreed that Sofronsky had Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and knowing that she was about to start chemotherapy, Dr. Woliner told Sofronsky that cancer was “low on his list” of possible medical concerns and that increased lymphoctyes shown in her tests were not indicative of cancer, insinuating that oncologists “often overreact” to the presence of lymphocytes and recommend chemotherapy before making an actual diagnosis. Dr. Woliner suggested instead that Sofronsky have her house tested for mold, which could be causing allergies, and therefore her symptoms. Convinced, Sofronsky pursued treatment for her allergies and cancelled her follow-up appointment with Dr. Rothschild.
Sofronsky complained repeatedly to Dr. Woliner of symptoms that were, as our good friend Orac points out, consistent with progressing lymphoma – back pain and pain and swelling in her lymph nodes, abdomen and legs, to the point of having to use a cane. Yet, Dr. Woliner, over the next couple of years, continued to attribute her symptoms mostly to her allergies and also thyroid issues and some other minor illnesses. On February 7, 2013, at her last visit to his office and in significant distress from pain and severe leg swelling, he ordered a 100 mg shot of iron, despite the fact that her blood tests showed she was not iron deficient. She rapidly decompensated and died in the hospital three days later of from complications of untreated Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
In 2015, the Florida Department of Health filed a complaint against Dr. Woliner alleging medical malpractice, failure to keep legible medical records, exploiting a patient for financial gain, and accepting or performing the professional responsibilities of an oncologist that he knew, or should know, he was not competent to perform. A hearing was held before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) in February of this year. The ALJ issued a Recommended Order in April, and, based on the facts she found, some of which I’ve set out above, she concluded:
    • Dr. Woliner fell below the standard of care in treating Sofronsky, by failing to timely refer her to an oncologist, educating and counseling her on the risks, including death, of not treating her cancer, and by failing to appropriately attribute her symptoms to her lymphoma.
    • He failed to keep legible medical records providing an adequate medical justification for his diagnoses and treatments.
    • He exercised influence over his patient in such a manner as to exploit her for financial gain by scheduling appointments, selling and administering drugs, and obtaining blood work when he knew or should know that none of these would reasonably alter her medical condition, treatment or life expectancy.
    • He practiced beyond the scope permitted by law by minimizing, if not outright rejecting, Sofronsky’s diagnosis of Hodgkin’s lymphoma, because he is not an oncologist nor was he qualified to give any advice regarding treatment of her cancer.
The ALJ recommends that his medical license be revoked, a $16,000 fine, and repayment of the money Sofronsky paid him to her estate as well as the state’s costs of prosecuting the case. The Florida Board of Medicine will make the final decision, although it has very limited legal authority to reject the ALJ’s findings of fact. It can, however, independently decide all legal issues, including the penalties.
The standard of care for “integrative” medicine, if any?
Given my interest in the intersection of science-based medicine and the law (or, more usually, the lack of intersection), I find one of the defenses presented by Dr. Woliner particularly fascinating. He argues that, even though he is Board-Certified in family practice, he is an “integrative” physician and, as such, is not held to the same standard of care as a “conventional” doctor.
And integrative he is. Dr. Woliner’s website, which advertises his board certification in family practice and calls itself “Holistic Family Practice,” also notes he is Board Certified in Integrative Medicine, certified by the American Board of Integrative Holistic Medicine, and certified in Functional Medicine. He sells patients Metagenics-brand dietary supplements and his website has an online store. His specialty list includes candida, thyroid conditions (even though he is not an endocrinologist or an ENT), food allergies (even though he is not an allergist) and “bioidentical hormones” (a marketing, not a medical, term). If you click on any of these headings expecting to find more information on the topic, you won’t. Instead, you’ll find anecdotes describing cases in which Dr. Woliner was able to figure out what was really wrong with the patient and how he successfully treated that condition, usually after other doctors had failed.
Woliner’s charming anecdotes are a perfect lesson in how unsuccessful cases are excluded from testimonials, one reason they are worthless as evidence of safety and effectiveness.
I imagine he won’t be adding the Sofronsky case to his list. You’ll also not find, under “Thyroid Conditions,” his 2005 settlement with the Board of Medicine, in which he admitted he had, among other things:
    • diagnosed a patient with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis who had no indication thereof clinically or biochemically,
    • diagnosed the patient with adrenal insufficiency who showed no biochemical indication,
    • overdosed the patient on thyroid medication, making him hyperthyroid, and
    • failed to consult with an endocrinologist instead of “treating conditions that did not exist.”
Ironically, as part of his settlement with the Board, he was required to take a course on keeping adequate medical records.
The Department of Health presented two expert witnesses at the hearing. One, an oncologist, testified to the scope of practice of oncology, which was necessary to establish that Dr. Woliner practiced outside of his, whether it be family practice or integrative medicine. The other, a board-certified family practice doctor, testified to the standard of care for that specialty, and that Dr. Woliner fell below it.
Dr. Woliner argues that neither expert’s testimony should be admitted because, as an integrative physician, only a “qualified” integrative physician can testify to the appropriate standard of care. For Dr. Woliner, that expert is Stephen Silver, MD, a Boca Raton doctor, who, interestingly, does not claim on his website (“HealthSmart MD: Private Family Medicine and Medi-Spa”) that he is an integrative specialist and actually says he follows the same standard of care as the traditional medical community. However, he does offer, among other services, “anti-aging” medicine, IV vitamins, and medical astrology. As he, um, explains,
Astrological Medical and Psychological constitution are determined at birth, affording a skilled Medical Astrologer a valuable tool when diagnosing and treating patients. . . . A Natal Chart is constructed utilizing your birthday, birth time (call mom) and birth location. Astrological Philosophy states that each soul incarnates at a precise time and in a precise place to best predispose the native to fulfill his/her life purpose. This chart describes in accurate detail the twelve (12) spheres of mundane (earth) life and your basic drives and motivations in these areas . . . I use the natal chart as invaluable tool to better understand myself, my patients and the energy flow between people. I am delighted to perform an Astrological chart analysis and profile upon request . . . The Astrological Signs and Planets utare correlated with the anatomy, physiology and disease potential of the human body and provide an excellent basis for “Energy Medicine”.
Because, when your medical license is at stake and you need an expert to testify on the standard of care for integrative medicine, you call only the best. I wonder what the standard of care is for medical astrology?
Unfortunately, while the transcript of the hearing and many other documents are available online (although excruciatingly hard to find; hint: see pages 8900-10592) from the Board of Medicine, Dr. Silver’s testimony (submitted by deposition) is not included for reasons that are unclear. However, from the ALJ’s Recommended Order we learn that Dr. Silver opined Dr. Woliner’s role was that of an out-of-network, adjunct holistic doctor,
more comparable to an acupuncturist or a Reiki specialist than a medical doctor . . . [and] suggested that Respondent should not be held to the same standard of as other family medicine doctors providing primary care services.
In other words, an integrative physician has no duty to refer a patient with cancer to an oncologist, no duty to explain to her the grave consequences of her decision to forego chemotherapy, no duty to correctly attribute her symptoms to Hodgkin’s lymphoma. Doesn’t say much for integrative medicine doctors, does it?
The ALJ ultimately rejected Dr. Silver’s assertion that a different standard of care should apply, as well as Dr. Woliner’s claim that he wasn’t acting as Sofronsky’s PCP, which she found “specious.” In response to Dr. Woliner taking exception to the ALJ’s determination, the Department of Health notes, correctly, that Dr. Silver never said what this purportedly different standard actually was.
It is ironic that a physician with Dr. Woliner’s disdain for “conventional” medicine would argue that he is somehow held to a lower standard of care than a conventional physician. (I realize he doesn’t explicitly argue that the standard is lower, but that is in essence what he is saying.) Here’s what he has to say about you “traditional” doctors in an issue of Aventura, a local “lifestyle” magazine:
What is different about holistic medicine from traditional medicine?Holistic medicine requires the assessment of the whole person, body, mind and spirit, in the quest for optimal health and wellness. While traditional allopathic medicine often relies on looking at individual symptoms and covering up those symptoms with prescription drugs, a holistic approach looks for functional imbalances and seeks to treat the underlying causes of illness.
As Harriet Hall, MD, said, “this stupid CAM mantra is a vile, false accusation,” and it is a dangerous one too. Dr. Woliner’s smug attitude about “conventional” medicine led him in both this case and his previous run-in with the Board of Medicine to reject the superior education and training of specialists in two complex fields, oncology and endocrinology, in favor of his own supposed expertise as an “integrative” physician. He even used the “if the only tool you have is a hammer” analogy with Sofronsky’s mom when describing oncologists. Yet, he was so blinded by that pet all-purpose bugaboo of integrative medicine – allergies – that he kept insisting that her obvious symptoms of spreading cancer were caused by them.
Not a different standard – a lower standard
Integrative medicine gives a physician permission to lower the standard for evidence of safety and effectiveness. After all, alternative medicine that’s been proven to work is just medicine. But, it is not only in their employment of quackery that integrative physicians are a menace to patients, it is this disdain for conventional medicine too. That disdain came through loud and clear in Dr. Woliner’s testimony, where he defined “mainstream medicine” as “patentable drugs and surgery.”
In one final, sad irony, here’s what Dr. Woliner says on his website about “the ideal candidate for holistic medicine”
Anyone who is interested in actually fixing the cause of their medical problems, rather than merely attempting to cover up symptoms, is the ideal candidate for holistic medicine.
Chemotherapy had a great chance of “fixing” Sofronsky’s “medical problems” but that chance was squandered on “holistic medicine.” I hope the Board of Medicine accepts the ALJ’s recommended penalty and revokes Kenneth Woliner’s medical license. He shouldn’t get a third chance to choose arrogance over “conventional” medical treatment for his patients.

Broken Brain
In his new video series, Dr. Mark Hyman says your brain is broken and functional medicine can fix it. He mixes conventional healthy lifestyle advice with highly questionable claims and recommendations based on speculation rather than on evidence.
Harriet Hall on January 30, 2018
Link

Mark Hyman has a new series of 8 documentaries on The Broken Brain. He interviews over 50 “experts” carefully selected to agree with his ideas, with nary a word of dissent. He says we are experiencing an epidemic of broken brains, manifesting as anxiety, depression, ADHD, autism, Alzheimer’s, bipolar disorder, and a host of other mental disorders. Even if you don’t have one of those, you may be suffering from subtle symptoms like poor memory, poor sleep, poor concentration, brain fog, etc. Even if you think you are healthy, you could be better. And he claims to have the solution: following his recommendations will not only heal you but will take you beyond normal to optimal functioning. He says brain diseases, and pretty much all diseases, can be prevented.
If only that were true!
Who is Mark Hyman?
Mark Hyman, MD, is a sort of poster boy for functional medicine. He is the Chairman of the Institute for Functional Medicine, founder of the UltraWellness Center, and a best-selling author of books like Ultramind, Ultrametabolism, The Blood Sugar Solution: A 10 Day Detox Diet, and coauthor of The Daniel Plan, a diet based on Biblical principles. He is on the staff of the Center for Functional Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic. He is a medical advisor to Bill and Hillary Clinton. He sells dietary supplements and detox cleanses. He has said that the law of thermodynamics doesn’t apply in living organisms, and that current medicine is as obsolete as bloodletting or phrenology. He says diseases don’t exist. He is essentially a germ theory denialist, saying it’s the terrain, not the germ.
What is functional medicine?
The Wikipedia article on Mark Hyman calls functional medicine “a discredited set of pseudoscientific beliefs.” Jeffrey Bland, a PhD, not an MD, invented functional medicine and Hyman became a convert after attending one of his lectures. It is vaguely defined as a systems approach that focuses on identifying and treating underlying causes. It emphasizes prevention, individualizes treatment, and aspires to optimization rather than just normalization of function.
Back in 2009, SBM’s own Wally Sampson wrote a series of four articles about functional medicine. Here, here, here, and here.
He concluded:
None of this FM lays out a map from which one can get from here to there…. Claims [are] cloaked in the language of science, but with the distinguishing characteristics of sectarianism – pluralities of approaches to illness, absence of evidence for efficacy, a unifying concept of illness as a body out of sync with Nature (with the capital N), undecipherable babble, and descriptive word salad.
David Gorski has criticized functional medicine, calling it “a form of quackery that combines the worst aspects of conventional medicine and alternative medicine,” with massive over-testing and a “make it up as you go” ethic. He has described how it was typically implemented in the case of an 80-year-old woman with breast cancer. After conventional treatment and surgery that was probably curative, she was subjected to 154(!) unnecessary, nonstandard lab tests (like urine representativeness index) and numerous useless and possibly even dangerous interventions (97 IV infusions of vitamin C, a long list of supplements including a “standardized herbal inflammation relief supplement,” melatonin, probiotics, and a medical food shake, a dairy free/gluten free diet, and more) that did nothing to change her outcome.
Hyman’s thesis
The title The Broken Brain is really a misnomer. Hyman says it’s actually the whole body that is broken, and dysfunctions elsewhere cause problems in the brain. The standard medical approach of “name it blame it tame it (with drugs)” is misguided. There is a new paradigm. The idea of diagnosing patients with diseases is obsolete; there are really no such things as diseases. Everything is connected. By optimizing bodily health, autism, dementia, and bipolar disorder can be reversed. He says he sees miracles every day in his practice. He has seen patients completely recover from autism by simply taking cod liver oil. A woman’s Alzheimer’s disease reversed when he gave her thyroid supplements for a “slight imbalance.”
He tells his own story of recovery from depression, anxiety, and extreme fatigue. He says heavy metal toxicity, deficient diet, high stress levels, and a leaky gut created the perfect storm that led to his broken brain. Different specialists made different diagnoses and were unable to help him. After he became a convert to functional medicine, he “peeled the layers” and gradually got better using the roadmap of FM. “The problem wasn’t in my brain, it was in my body. All that inflammation, toxicity, gut dysfunction was feeding back up to my brain.” It was a slow process. He discovered he had mercury poisoning. He went on an elimination diet of turkey, broccoli and rice. He had to find all the causes, one after another. He compares it to standing on several tacks: removing just one tack doesn’t solve the problem. Which directly contradicts his claim to have reversed autism and Alzheimer’s with single interventions.
His seven steps to an ultramind are:
     1.  Optimize nutrition
     2.  Balance hormones
     3.  Cool off inflammation
     4.  Fix your gut
     5.  Detoxify the body
     6.  Boost the mitochondria
     7.  Calm the mind
And also: exercise, community, and other important stuff like supplements. You can buy supplements at Hyman’s online store. He sells an Eat Fat, Get Thin Support Kit, a 10-day Detox Diet Basic Kit, Blood Sugar Solution Supplements, a Regulate Male Hormone Kit, an Enhance Energy Metabolism Kit, and much more.
The six-week jumpstart plan to heal your brain:
     1.  Eat right for your brain: eliminate gluten and dairy, processed and junk foods, coffee, alcohol, trans fats, and food additives. Increase fat, protein, fiber, and complex carbs. Eat organic. Eat every 3-4 hours.
     2.  Tune up your brain chemistry with supplements. These are the “must have” supplements for brain health:
        ◦ Multivitamin / Mineral
        ◦ Magnesium and calcium
        ◦ Vitamin D3 (2000 IU a day and maybe more if you’re deficient – check with your healthcare practitioner)
        ◦ Methylated B complex vitamins
        ◦ Omega-3 fats (EPA & DHA from fish oil)
        ◦ Probiotics
     3.  Live the UltraMind lifestyle: exercise (walk 30 minutes every day), relax (using soft belly breath and Ultrabath, which are explained in his book), sleep (7-9 hours a night), and train your brain (crossword puzzles, board games, reading books, etc.)
     4.  Live clean and green: drink clean water, limit exposure to chemicals and metals, limit exposure to household, gardening and personal care products, keep your bodily fluids moving, reduce electro-pollution and electromagnetic radiation (details of how to do all this are in his book).
Questionable claims
There are a lot of questionable claims and recommendations in the videos, some of which are demonstrably wrong and none of which are based on acceptable evidence. Some examples:
    • Nutrients often work better than meds.
    • Nutritional deficiencies are a primary causes of most diseases.
    • There are 3 big epidemics of hormonal problems in America. Too much insulin (from sugar in the diet), too much cortisol (from stress), not enough thyroid.
    • Just controlling insulin will balance all the other hormones.
    • We are bombarded with thyroid toxins: fluoride in the water supply, BPA in plastics, triclosans in antibacterial soaps, flame retardants in bedding.
    • Clean up your environment. Get a reverse osmosis fluoride filter. Avoid plastics; go all glass.
    • Thiamine 600 mg can reduce thyroid fatigue in 3-5 days.
    • Fatigue, stress? Check adrenal function with a saliva test.
    • For stress, develop a breathing practice. Exhaling for longer than you inhale activates the vagus nerve and the parasympathetic nervous system, immediately lowers the heart rate, relaxes the digestive system, and lowers blood pressure.
    • Have a rest period to help your body muscle memory remember what it’s like to be relaxed.
    • Testosterone drops with age, but this is because of lifestyle. You can naturally raise testosterone levels with lifestyle changes.
    • Give men a little topical bioidentical hormone. It lets them build muscle and bone, lose weight, relieve depression, and improve memory. Women benefit too.
    • Things that cause sex hormone imbalance: sugar, refined carbs, stress, dairy, hormones in dairy and meats, toxins from pesticides, plastics, pollution, lack of exercise.
    • Inflammation is behind essentially every brain dysfunction.
    • Two thirds of brain cells are immune cells. [I think that refers to microglial cells, which constitute only 10-15% of brain cells.]
    • Leaky gut syndrome.
    • Depleted soil fallacy.
    • Extraordinary amounts of toxins in our food since 1970. Chronic disease is not because of lifestyle changes but because of toxins in the environment.
    • The primary cause of disease is environmental toxins. (Not!)
Marketing genius
Either Mark Hyman copied the idea from Peggy Sarlin or they both learned from the same marketing expert. Peggy produced a series of 14 videos on “Awakening from Alzheimer’s,” claiming that Alzheimer’s is largely preventable and can be reversed in 9 out of 10 patients. I wrote a SkepDoc column critiquing her series; it is scheduled to appear in the next issue of Skeptic magazine. Like Hyman, she interviewed a number of different experts who all had different approaches. They recommended everything from coconut oil to banana peel tea, multiple supplements, avoiding gluten, etc. Like Hyman, they told miraculous success stories. Like Hyman, they talked about “leaky gut syndrome,” a hypothetical condition not recognized by medical science. Both mentioned chronic Lyme disease, which doesn’t exist.
Think about it: if they really had a cure for Alzheimer’s or for all brain diseases, would we have to watch a series of videos to learn about it? Wouldn’t it be all over the news? Wouldn’t someone win a Nobel Prize? Wouldn’t it be irresponsible not to share it with the world for free?
The videos were made available for free, but each video was only available for 24 hours, making it easy to miss an episode. This encourages the viewer to buy a package of all the videos plus supplementary materials, for $99 and up. Or you can buy the books. These video marketing schemes are a clever ploy to make money; it’s marketing genius!
The fallacies of functional medicine
Hyman is trying to promote functional medicine, but in these videos he inadvertently exposes the fallacies of that approach. He isn’t even doing what he claims to be doing.
He stresses individualizing treatment. Instead of asking “what” patients have, he asks “why.” Four people with heart disease might have 4 underlying whys; four people with 4 different diseases might have a single underlying why. Everyone is an individual, and requires a different individual approach.
But if everyone is different, how could you possibly know how to treat each of them? If there are multiple underlying causes, how can Hyman report having cured patients with a single intervention? If there are multiple underlying causes, how can you determine which ones apply to which patient? You can’t. All you can do is what Hyman does: throw everything but the kitchen sink at them and see what sticks. Try one thing and if it doesn’t work, add another thing. Guesswork. Uncontrolled experimentation. Forget about the scientific method and the need to test every claim systematically; that’s not in Hyman’s paradigm.
And of course, the seven steps to an ultramind and the 6-week jumpstart plan are anything but individualized: he recommends them for everyone.
If everything is connected in an interlocking web, how could you possibly know enough to intervene at one point of the web? Wouldn’t that cause unexpected effects elsewhere in the web?
The idea that Hyman is looking for and finding “the underlying cause” is ludicrous. He merely lists all the possible underlying causes he can think of and tries to treat all of them. He speaks of the “roadmap” of FM. There is no such roadmap, just unsystematic trial and error.
It is silly to think functional medicine understands the underlying causes and can identify them and appropriately individualize treatments. Functional medicine is a blind doctor leading a blind patient, trying anything and everything that they hope might possibly help.
Functional medicine hasn’t discovered anything new. We already knew the brain affects the rest of the body and the body affects the brain. We knew the body and mind are connected into an interlocking whole. Everyone knows lifestyle is important for health: exercise, healthy diet, stress reduction, adequate sleep, and interaction with other people all matter. Functional medicine pretends to know things about diet that are not based on evidence. It pretends to know that we all need dietary supplements and which ones we need. It pretends deep understandings that it simply doesn’t have. It pretends that it knows how to use non-standard tests to effectively guide treatment. It pretends to know how to create optimal functioning, but it has never demonstrated that it can do that, or even that there are levels of functioning greater than “normal.” The functional medicine approach has never been tested to find out if it can produce better outcomes than the science-based medicine approach.
Conclusion: Good marketing, not good medicine
The video series The Broken Brain is not a reliable source of medical information. Hyman includes standard advice about a healthy lifestyle, but he mixes it indiscriminately with advice that is based on speculation rather than on credible evidence. And he makes claims that defy belief (curing autism with cod liver oil) and many that are demonstrably not true.
To echo David Gorski,
What’s good about functional medicine is not unique, and what’s unique about it is not good…it takes “making it up as you go along” to a whole new level, and that’s not a good thing in medicine.
        ◦ t

Goop and Dr. Mark Hyman join forces for some functional medicine heavy metal fear mongering
Goop and the Cleveland Clinic’s Dr. Mark Hyman join forces for some functional medicine heavy metal fear mongering featuring bogus diagnostic testing and discredited treatments. Experts crush their pseudoscience.
Jann Bellamy on November 8, 2018
Link


Goop, Gwyneth Paltrow’s “den of celebrity pseudoscience,” has been aptly described as “pure, unadulterated, blood-diamond free, organic-certified, biodynamic, moon-dusted bullshit” that “you should avoid . . . at all cost,” “stoking fears and selling unproven and mostly quack therapies,” “a reliably laughable source of pseudoscience” and peddling “fake empowerment through snake oil.” The Cleveland Clinic’s functional medicine guru, Dr. Mark Hyman, has been called out by SBM and others for his anti-vaccination and anti-fluoridation ideology, “chemical hypocrisy,” promotion and practice of so-called “functional medicine,” dubious “broken brain” advice, use of unvalidated diagnostic testing, selling dietary supplements of questionable value and anecdote-based “evidence,” as well as mangling autism and dementia science, systems biology, and cancer research. [New fun fact I learned about Dr. Hyman in researching this post: He wrote the forward to the Food Babe’s book.]
So, when I recently happened upon a Q&A with Dr. Hyman on Goop’s website entitled “What to Know about Heavy Metals”, I suspected I was in for a heavy helping of what science journalist Julia Belluz calls “Goopshit.” Turns out my prediction was correct.
That is not to say the article did not hold value, just not in the way Goop and Dr. Hyman likely intended: It shed some light on the occult practices of functional medicine, heretofore hidden behind a $15,000 paywall, protected from critical observation in the medical literature.
In submitting to Goop’s Q&A, Dr. Hyman sticks to his usual modus operandi, which is to avoid the scrutiny of actual scientists by pitching his dubious advice straight to consumers via outlets like The Huffington Post, TED talks, books, DVDs, and PBS infomercials, in lieu of publishing a cogent explication in, say, a respectable medical journal. As one physician critic pointed out, to support his fringe ideas,
Dr. Hyman has used what I refer to as a cut-and-paste technique; he takes isolated observations out of context to generate a theory not proven or justified by the findings.
As we shall see, the Goop article is no exception.
Faux “heavy metal toxicity”
First, the fearmongering. While it is true that heavy metal toxicity a dangerous medical condition, it is also rare (a fact even Goop’s introduction admits). That, however, is not what Dr. Hyman really means when he talks about “an unhealthy accumulation of heavy metals” in the body. What he is trying to sell us on is the notion that common conditions like chronic fatigue, depression, anxiety, insomnia, and digestive problems could be symptoms of this “unhealthy accumulation”. They can also be “a neglected factor in treating chronic disease”. Thus, in his view, “it is essential to look at heavy metals as a potential factor”. To add fuel to the fire, Dr. Hyman warns us that heavy metals “may contribute” to autoimmune diseases and that obesity, ADD, autism, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and heart disease have been “proposed to be affected by heavy metals”.
But, because “traditional physicians [presumably meaning those who adhere to evidence-based practices] have very limited training in diagnosing and treating patients with heavy metal poisoning”, he recommends a functional medicine (FM) practitioner because “they will be able to assist you in a safe detoxification process”. He suggests you check with the Institute of Functional Medicine (IFM), where he teaches and sits on the Board, or the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM) to find a practitioner.
Thus, having planted the suggestion that you may have heavy metal poisoning based on any number of symptoms of common conditions that very likely have nothing to do with true heavy metal poisoning, he poisons the well by diverting you from seeking the advice of a “traditional” physician and reroutes you to a functional medicine or ACAM practitioner. What he doesn’t mention is that functional medicine lacks supporting evidence and is potentially dangerous, according to that bastion of “traditional” physicians, the American Academy of Family Physicians, and that ACAM is, in the words of former SBM regular Kimball Atwood, MD, a “pseudomedical pseudoprofessional organization” that “stands at the center of what is probably the largest and most insidious family of organizations hyping implausible practices and the ‘freedom’ to peddle them”. ACAM is also on Quackwatch’s list of questionable organizations.
Once you reach your FM or ACAM practitioner, “specialized tests” may be necessary to determine your assumed exposure, according to Dr. Hyman. The most common, he says, are blood tests to “detect your current heavy metal exposure”, hair testing, which “detects specific types of mineral imbalances and deficiencies in the body”, and chelation challenge testing “to find out your total body load of heavy metals.” He laments that chelation challenge testing and the “benefits of chelation” aren’t “taken more seriously” and are “not widely accepted in traditional medicine” “given the evidence of its effectiveness [citing this article] and safety [citing this article]”. In fact, he says he’s “used this test on tens of thousands of patients” [emphasis added] in his 30 years of practice.
Not “widely accepted?” That hardly begins to describe it. As it turns out, there are good reasons why science-based medicine rejects these “specialized” tests. Fortuitously, I discovered that the inimitable Dr. Jen Gunter had read the article too and consulted a real expert, Dr. David Juurlink, who is board-certified in Medical Toxicology and head of the Division of Clinical Pharmacology & Toxicology at the University of Toronto. She quotes him in her post, “GOOP posts dangerous, bullshit article on heavy metals”.
Hair testing? According to Dr. Juurlink,
‘Hair testing for heavy metals is bullshit. I have seen people fall for this scam more times than I can remember.’ He added that the issue with hair testing is that the levels are almost always very high and that ‘any toxicologist worth his or her salt will tell you [the test] cannot be interpreted.’
What about the chelation challenge test? (For an explanation of how the test is done, see here.)
It’s not widely accepted because it’s uninformative and misleading. It’s not validated, the types and doses of chelating agents used are inconsistent, and depending on what’s being tested, urine levels will go up in normal people after a ‘challenge.’ This isn’t indicative of poisoning or the need for treatment, and it’s not a valid indicator of a given metal’s body burden. Provocation testing [another name for challenge testing] does not distinguish between poisoned and non-poisoned people and simply should not be done. [Emphasis added.]
Dr. Jurrlink’s assessment of hair and challenge testing is well-established in medical toxicology science. As the American College of Medical Toxicologists (ACMT) explains, we are all constantly exposed to metals and often have detectable levels without being poisoned. Indiscriminate testing may result in needless concern when a test result is outside the “normal” reference range. So, among AMCT’s “Ten Things Physicians and Patients Should Question” are three of Dr. Hyman’s testing recommendations:
    • Don’t administer a chelating agent prior to testing urine for metals, a practice referred to as “provoked” urine testing.
    • Don’t order heavy metal screening tests to asses non-specific symptoms in the absence of excessive exposure to metals.
    • Don’t perform hair or nail testing for “metal poisoning” screening in patients with non-specific symptoms.
Nothing in the two articles cited by Dr. Hyman as supporting the purported effectiveness and safety of chelation challenge testing overcomes this overwhelming consensus among toxicology experts. (I’m not even sure what he means by the “effectiveness” of the chelation challenge test. If he’s trying to claim the test is clinically valid, it isn’t, according to both the FDA and Dr. Juurlink.) They do, however, provide excellent examples of what one critic called his “cut and paste” cherry picking of the evidence. To add insult to injury, the 2009 article he cites on “safety” touts widely discredited DMSA chelation for autistic children, a treatment SBM’s own neurologist, Steve Novella, labeled quackery. It was among the studies in a 2015 Cochrane Database review, which Hyman fails to mention, resulting in the conclusion,
. . . no clinical trial evidence was found to suggest that pharmaceutical chelation is an effective intervention for ASD. Given prior reports of serious adverse events, such as hypocalcaemia, renal impairment and reported death, the risks of using chelation for ASD currently outweigh proven benefits.
If by blood testing, Dr. Hyman means red blood cell testing (RBC) “offered by certain commercial laboratories (usually not mainstream clinical laboratories affiliated with hospitals)”, here’s what experts say about that:
Multiple searches of online medical databases were unable to uncover peer-reviewed scientific literature regarding the accuracy, methods, or usefulness of red blood cell testing of . . . metals [other than mercury].
RBC was a “reasonable proxy” for methylmercury exposure but “there was large inter-individual variation.”
ACMT Bingo!
But, let’s assume that a hapless patient has been convinced by his “certified” functional medicine practitioner (who could just as easily be a chiropractor or a naturopath as a physician) that he is indeed infested with heavy metals. What to do? According to Dr. Hyman, in addition to some anodyne advice on increasing the intake of “detoxifying foods” and avoiding exposure, he recommends dietary supplements, exercise and sweating via a “sauna, steam or bath” to “rid your body of toxins,” removing dental amalgam, and chelation.
Hyman prescribes IV or oral chelation “to remove lead and mercury from the body”.
I may prescribe chelation therapy for severe cases, such as chronic fatigue, depression, kidney failure, or a server autoimmune condition.
He explains that there are risks associated with chelation, but for “most patients, the risks outweigh the benefits”.
He doesn’t recommend just any dietary supplements for your “detoxification” either. He touts those sold by his personal online store, including brands connected to his Institute for Functional Medicine compatriots: Jeffrey Brand, who “created the concept of functional medicine” and formerly found himself in the crosshairs of the FDA, and Dr. Robert Roundtree, who teaches several sessions of IFM’s “Detox Advanced Practice Module,” a subject we’ll return to in a moment. Bland started Hyman-recommended Metagenics (since sold to the same company that owns Amway) and Roundtree is the Chief Medical Advisor for Thorne, also recommended. That’s another advantage of publishing your ideas in pop culture media instead of the medical literature: no pesky financial interest disclosures.
Here again, we find Dr. Hyman’s advice runs counter to that of experts in medical toxicology. According to the ACMT’s “Choosing Wisely”:
    • Don’t use homeopathic medications, non-vitamin dietary supplements or herbal supplements as treatments for disease or preventive health measures.
    • Don’t recommend chelation except for documented metal intoxication which has been diagnosed using validated tests in appropriate biological samples.
    • Don’t remove mercury-containing dental amalgams.
    • Don’t recommend “detoxification” through colon cleansing or promoting sweating for disease treatment or prevention. . . Promoting sweating doesn’t produce clinically relevant toxin elimination. Methods to promote sweating may cause heat stroke, dehydration, burns, myocardial injury, carbon monoxide poisoning and liver or kidney damage, which might compromise toxin elimination.
I think Dr. Hyman just won American College of Medical Toxicologists bingo, having recommended fully seven out the ten things toxicology experts say you shouldn’t do.
As the ACMT explains further,
Even when used for appropriately diagnosed metal intoxication, chelating drugs may have significant side effects, including dehydration, hypocalcemia, kidney injury, liver enzyme elevations, hypotension, allergic reactions and essential mineral deficiencies. Inappropriate chelation, which may cost hundreds to thousands of dollars, risks these harms, as well as neurodevelopmental toxicity, teratogenicity and death.
(See also here.) Hardly worth it for a diagnosis based on bogus testing.
The ACMT, of course, is not alone rejecting Dr. Hyman’s recommendations. For one thing, ironically, herbal remedies and dietary supplements are actually a risk factor for heavy metal poisoning. (For a more detailed description of the scant evidence for, and risks associated with, dietary supplements recommended for elimination of toxic substances, see here.)
The American Dental Association, whose members could make a bundle extracting old fillings and replacing them if they wanted to scare-monger, after a review of the evidence (also here), concluded that
Dental amalgam is considered a safe, affordable and durable material that has been used to restore the teeth of more than 100 million Americans. Dental amalgam has been studied and reviewed extensively, and has established a record of safety and effectiveness.
Not surprisingly, Grant Ritchey, SBM’s semi-resident dentist, reached the same conclusion.
But, again shielding the gullible from anyone who might disagree with him (or call his ideas a “hot mess”, like Dr. Gunter did), Dr. Hyman’s recommended source for dental advice is the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology. That organization, as Dr. Ritchey points out, is chock full of anti-amalgam dentists. Dr. Ritchey also recommends this excellent review of the literature refuting like-minded claims.
Finally,
consideration of chelation therapy for patients with suspected or confirmed metal exposures should be made in conjunction with a medical toxicologist or the local poison control center
. . . and not a functional medicine practitioner.
But, as I mentioned earlier, Goop’s article does have some value, in that it lifts the veil on the practice of functional medicine. One of the IFM’s courses for “certification” as a functional medicine practitioner is the previously-noted Detox Advanced Practice Module. Although the “Detox” course is vague about its content, the tropes of faux toxicity are all there:
Our expert faculty team will review the foundational biochemistry and genetics of biotransformation pathways, connect organ system dysfunctions to potential toxic exposures, and detail the available laboratory evaluations useful in working up a toxin-exposed patient. Once these important clinical connections are made, the team will detail specific treatment approaches.
The “expert faculty team” includes Hyman (in the form of a course pre-requisite), Thorne’s Dr. Robert Roundtree, a chiropractor who previously taught an IFM course on chelation, a dentist/naturopath whose practice includes amalgam removal, and Joseph Pizzorno, a naturopath whose textbook tells us that a whopping 25% of the U.S. public suffers from “heavy metal poisoning” and recommends chelation challenge testing.
Given the fact that actual heavy metal toxicity is rare, IFM’s devotion of a whole course (out of six modules) to “toxic exposures” is suspect. My guess is that IFM is teaching the same sort of discredited testing and treatments that Hyman espouses in Goop, then sending out its “certified” practitioners into the world to foist these expensive, unnecessary and potentially dangerous regimens on the public. If that is the case, then the Cleveland Clinic’s association with functional medicine and its functionaries is all the more ethically reprehensible. And the “detox” module shouldn’t get 17.5 CME credits via the ACCME either.

Dr. Joel Fuhrman Sells Useless Iodine Test
Joel Fuhrman is selling an overpriced iodine urine test that is not valid for testing individuals. Patients may be led to believe they are iodine deficient when they are not. Iodine supplements on the market vary widely including orthomolecular doses, and they make unsupported claims that mislead customers.
Harriet Hall on March 27, 2018
Link

[NOTE ADDENDUM]
Joel Fuhrman, MD, who practices so-called functional medicine and integrative medicine, sells an at-home urine iodine test on his website for $131. He claims the test can assess if one is deficient in iodine. The test requires two urine samples (morning and evening) dried on filter paper and submitted by mail.
Dr. Fuhrman recommends avoiding salt and supplementing with iodine. He says:
If the iodine results are low, please note it still is NOT recommended to consume high and potentially harmful amounts of iodine. Recommended levels of supplementation would be between 150 and 300 mcg/day. For someone with high iodine results, the recommendation would be to reduce or eliminate high iodine seaweed and seafood, all iodinated salt, and not consume more than the 150 mcg/day RDA for iodine.
There is at least one other brand of direct-to-consumer iodine test that sells for much less: $84.99. Even at the lower price, these tests are a waste of money. No test can reliably diagnose iodine deficiency in individual patients.
No test can reliably diagnose iodine deficiency in individual patients.
Single urine tests are not accurate because the level fluctuates due to factors like variation in iodine intake and the amount of water consumed. Iodine excretion can vary from day to day even if the iodine intake is the same. The most accurate test measures the total amount of iodine excreted in the urine in 24 hours. More than one 24-hour urine collection should be used to get more reliable results. For population screening, less precision is needed if a large number of people are tested, so single urine tests suffice.
Several respected medical organizations have spoken out against individual iodine testing. The World Health Organization says “Urinary iodine concentrations are, therefore, not useful for the diagnosis and treatment of individuals.” The American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists says “urinary iodine concentrations cannot be used to determine the iodine status of individuals.” The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says the tests are “useful for classifying population risk but are not categories to define individual risk for adverse health outcomes.” The American Thyroid Association and the Endocrine Society concur.
Background
Iodine deficiency causes goiter, hypothyroxinemia, neurodevelopmental disorders, cretinism, stillbirth, and increased perinatal mortality. Worldwide, it is the leading cause of intellectual and developmental disabilities. Deficiency is bad, but excess is bad, too. Chronic iodine toxicity (intake of over 1.1 mg/day) is associated with increased risk of Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, hypothyroidism, and goiter.
People who live in coastal areas tend to get adequate iodine from their food; those who live in the interior are more likely to develop iodine deficiency. Iodine deficiency is a worldwide health problem, but there is an effective and inexpensive way to combat it: adding iodine to table salt. 120 countries have passed laws requiring salt to be iodized. In the US, goiter was once common, especially in the Great Lakes and parts of the Pacific Northwest. In 1924, the Morton Salt Company made iodized salt available nationally. The incidence of goiter dropped. The IQ of the quarter of the population most deficient in iodine rose by one standard deviation. Iodized salt protects the population as a whole, but some people forgo its protection by choosing specialty salts (kosher, sea salt, etc.) that don’t contain iodine.
Dr. Fuhrman turns back the clock
Dr. Fuhrman doesn’t want us to take advantage of this important public health measure. He recommends avoiding salt and supplementing with iodine at 150-300 mcg (0.15 to 0.3 mg) a day. The RDA is 0.15 mg a day. So he is recommending up to twice the RDA from a supplement, without counting the iodine obtained from foods.
This celebrity doctor is selling an invalid test at an elevated price, telling patients to trust those invalid test results, and making recommendations that go against an accepted public health measure. In my opinion, that is unethical.
Questionable iodine supplements
An email correspondent wrote to ask me about Survival Shield X-2, an iodine supplement touted on the InfoWars website. They claim that “proper iodine levels may provide support for normal response to environmental and dietary toxins to keep your body clean and moving,” that it “supports thyroid health to regulate hormone production and vitality,” and that it “may support breast milk production and quality for new mothers.”
My correspondent asked whether iodine is as critical to good health as claimed, and whether this particular product is worth the money, and if not, what other iodine supplement would I recommend.
I answered,
Iodine deficiency is rare in Western nations. Iodine was added to our salt to prevent deficiency. Even without iodized salt, most people get enough iodine from food. This article covers the subject well: It warns “additional iodine should only be taken with a doctor’s supervision… The amount in the Survival Shield supplement exceeds the maximum recommended daily intake and would be more likely to cause harm than benefit. The health information on the InfoWars website is pseudoscientific bullshit designed to sell overpriced products to naïve customers.
He replied, “but this NON-commercial source NOT SELLING iodine is thought-provoking:”
From that website:
Are there any easy answers? Not really. It appears that both insufficient and excessive amounts of iodine can be problematic. Dr. Christianson believes that a safe daily intake is 150mcg, and that occasionally 1,000mcg (1mg) is tolerable. I, along with others, believe that short-term, high levels of iodine, for specific therapeutic purposes, can be of value, but should only be done briefly, and ideally with the help of a health professional. I believe that we can still safely consume near the Japanese level of intake (1 to 2 mg daily) if it is in a complex form (i.e. seaweed), or if it is the mix of iodine and iodide (e.g. Lugol’s solution). And, as always, I recommend not taking any supplement daily, so skip a few days every week, and give the body a chance to use up any iodine that is in excess of its needs.
It also says,
Because of the extra radiation currently in the environment from the Fukushima power plant meltdown, now is a good time to keep our levels of iodine relatively high.
I answered:
They may not be selling it on their website, but they are a company selling supplements and they tell you where you can buy them. The link you provided is a blog post by an anonymous author and contains information I do not consider reliable (“We need more iodine because of Fukushima” is nonsense.) Please note that he says “I believe” without providing evidence to support his beliefs. And he cautions that supplementation should be done with the help of a health professional. Yes, you can find websites telling you you need iodine supplements, but you can also find websites telling you the Earth is flat. …searching the Internet is full of pitfalls and will lead you to false claims that may be harmful. You are only alarming yourself needlessly.
I went to the website of the Dr. Christianson they referred to. He is a naturopath. He advises against iodine testing, but gives this advice:
    • If you’re on thyroid medication, use non-iodized salt, and avoid iodine in supplements and sea vegetables like kelp.
    • If you’re not on thyroid medication, iodine supplementation is not necessary.
    • If you’re not on thyroid meds and you’re a raw food vegan, use iodized salt and eat at least 3 servings of moderate iodine sea veggies
The so-called Great Iodine Debate is summarized on the unreliable Weston Price Foundation’s website. They cite studies showing that high doses of iodine can prevent and treat a variety of diseases including breast cancer and fibrocystic breast disease. They suggest that iodine may be helpful in treating other cancers because it induces apoptosis, it can detox heavy metals, and it can protect against the harmful effects of fluoridated water (!?). They recommend iodine supplementation in doses considerably higher than the generally accepted upper limits of intake.
Orthomolecular doses
An orthomolecular website makes claims that are not accepted by mainstream medicine. They provide a long list of conditions they say are related to iodine deficiency, including various cancers, reduced alertness, autism, ADHD, fatigue, depression, insomnia, dry skin, muscle pain, fibromyalgia, erectile dysfunction, infertility, miscarriages, overweight, high blood pressure, and an elevated risk of heart attacks and strokes. They speak of “iodophobia,” the idea that mainstream medicine has been unduly biased by faulty research and fears using the high doses of iodine that are required for health. They say that the doses needed to prevent cancer are 100 times the RDA. And they claim that adults need 2-5 mg of iodide daily for optimum health and 15-50 mg a day in illnesses like thyroid disease, fibrocystic breast disease, or cancer. The references they cite are mainly studies by one author, Guy E. Abraham.
Guy E. Abraham
Abraham’s research is cited on the website of the Optimox supplement company. His research studies are not listed on PubMed; he published them in a non-listed alternative medicine publication called The Original Internist, dedicated to promoting natural health care as a primary treatment. The publishing organization also provides marketing and administrative support for the 300-hour Chiropractic Family Practice Diplomate Program.
In a paper titled “ Orthoidodosupplementation: Iodine sufficiency of the whole human body” he starts with a rant about “iodophobia and misinformation about iodine” and goes on to claim that the optimal daily requirement for iodine is 6 mg for the thyroid and 5 mg for the mammary glands. In an “Epilogue” that is decidedly out of place in a scientific publication, he says evolution does not account for our need for extra iodine, but the Biblical account does. The original planet contained a topsoil rich in iodine, but this was washed away by the Flood. He says, “The post-deluvian [sic] worldwide I [iodine] deficiency may be a reminder to mankind of the flood, their fallen state and their need for a Redeemer.”
Requirements in pregnancy and lactation
Iodine requirements are greater during pregnancy and lactation. The World Health Organization and UNICEF recommend iodine supplementation during pregnancy and lactation for women in countries where less than 20% of households have access to iodized salt. This does not apply to the US. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists does not even mention iodine in its webpage on nutrition during pregnancy. On the other hand, the American Thyroid Association and other groups have called for adding small amounts of iodine to all prenatal vitamins.
Conclusion: No need for testing
In my opinion, it is unethical for Dr. Fuhrman to sell those iodine tests without giving customers the information about validity that they need to make an informed decision. There may be cases where iodine supplementation is indicated (pregnancy, lactation, a diet deficient in iodine and iodized salt) but in those cases supplementation (at low doses) should be recommended by a doctor and there is no need for prior testing. High dose “orthomolecular” supplementation is not supported by good evidence. I see iodine testing and supplementation as just another example of alternative medicine creating something for people to worry unnecessarily about and profiting from that worry.
ADDENDUM: Dr Fuhrman wrote to us on May 17, 2018 with this request:
Dear Dr. Gorski and Dr. Hall.
I was hoping you could remove the article criticizing me for selling a urine test for iodine on my website; since I no longer do so. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/dr-joel-fuhrman-sells-useless-iodine-test/I had removed that test due to concerns about the misuse and inaccuracy of the test. before I saw this article criticizing me about it.
I do not want a disagreement about this controversial issue to distract from my overall mission of encouraging the consumption of more green vegetables, beans, nuts and seeds in the diet.
Since reviewing the literature on this subject, I agree that these tests are not needed for the general public and I had taken it off our website. However, I do feel there is some value in this test for those who are not using any iodinated salt, seaweed, animal products, or iodine supplements to assure adequacy. The reason urinary iodine testing is often considered inaccurate for individuals is because of day to day variations in dietary iodine intake.1, 2 Consistent intake improves accuracy. Individuals interested in this test will most likely be those who are not taking supplements and not eating any iodized salt or iodine-rich foods. In these individuals, day-to day variation in intake would be small. The other interested group would be those who are potentially eating too much iodine rich foods (such as seaweeds) and are concerned about getting too much iodine.
Although a single fasting urinary iodine test is not considered to be as good as the more accurate 24 hour collection method, performing a urinary iodine test using the ratio of urinary iodine to creatinine from two different urine samples – first thing in morning and last before bed (the method the ZRT test uses) – are similar to 24 hour urine collection results.2 We had encourage users to follow their usual diet and supplemental regimen consistently for days before the test to limit day-to-day variation. Even if iodine results are low, I do not recommend anyone consume high and potentially harmful amounts of iodine. Recommended levels of supplementation would be between 100 and 200 mcg/day. You may be aware there are some advocating very high intake of over 1000 mcg/day and testing was used to convince them to reduce that to safer levels.
     1.  Pearce EN, Caldwell KL. Urinary iodine, thyroid function, and thyroglobulin as biomarkers of iodine status. Am J Clin Nutr 2016, 104 Suppl 3:898S-901S.
     2.  Soldin OP. Controversies in urinary iodine determinations. Clin Biochem 2002, 35:575-579.
Thank you for your consideration of this request.
Joel Fuhrman, M.D.
Because this post was accurate at the time it was published we declined Dr. Fuhrman’s request to remove it. We did, however, in the interests of accuracy, agree to post his e-mail response.

The return of marketing hype for “whole body scans”…now with AI!
Two decades ago, I cut my skeptical teeth countering advertising for whole body scans by companies making extravagant promises for their products. This particular medical fad faded for a while, but now it’s back with a vengeance…with AI! Looking at these products, what I see is basically the quackery that is functional medicine on steroids and powered by AI.
David Gorski on July 10, 2023
Link

It just struck me the other day that, in less than a year and a half, I will have been at this blogging thing for two whole decades. I’ve been writing for SBM for over fifteen and a half years, having started my first blog more than three years before that and having been active on Usenet countering quackery and antivaccine pseudoscience for five or six years before that. (Yes, I’ve been at this in one form or another since the late 1990s.) I was reminded by a recent spate of laudatory (or at least very unskeptical) stories about Neko Health last week touting their “lofty promise of preventative healthcare via full-body scans backed by AI software” of the very first time that I actually put my then relatively recent turn to combatting dubious medicine into action with respect to a medical fad that had been going on for quite some time, that of whole body scans for preventative healthcare.
Reading some of these stories, I immediately felt a profound sense of what Yogi Berra would have called “déjà vu all over again”:
Neko Health, a healthcare technology company co-founded by Hjalmar Nilsonne and Spotify founder Daniel Ek, announced the successful completion of a €60 million ($65 million) series A funding round. The company aims to revolutionize the health industry through artificial intelligence (AI)-driven full-body scans, specifically focusing on preventative healthcare.
Do tell. What, exactly, does this “whole body scan” involve? Let’s find out:
Neko Health has introduced an innovative medical scanning technology that enables extensive and non-invasive health data collection, prioritizing speed, accuracy and convenience.
The company operates private clinics with proprietary and off-the-shelf diagnostic products, including its own 360-degree full-body 3D scanner integrated with over 70 sensors. The scanner can collect 50 million data points within minutes.
This data undergoes analysis by a “self-learning AI-powered system,” providing doctors and patients with insights.
So Neko Health is a bit more than what I dealt with, lo, those many years ago. Clearly, the industry hawking “whole body scans” as a health panacea has evolved since I last seriously dealt with these products. Two decades ago, when I first started complaining to a local NJ radio station about ads by a company called AmeriScan making unrealistic and extravagant claims for “whole body scans” and “screening MRIs” that’s all it was, CT scans and MRIs. Now it appears that “whole body scans” involve so much more, both a proprietary “its own 360-degree full-body 3D scanner integrated with over 70 sensors” and a raft of other test, to the point that it reminds me very much of how I once described “functional medicine”: reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other. the only difference being that companies like Neko Health add artificial intelligence to the mix, because it’s the latest tech fad.
In fairness, the invoice for Neko Health’s “whole body scan” isn’t that huge (€250), but it’s still at least not insubstantial. None of this changes my perception that Neko Health simply represents the latest iteration that, consistent with the latest tech fad of the times, just adds AI to a very old idea, that some variant of “whole body scans,” whatever the form they take, is a magical tool for finding disease super early and managing health.
You think I’m being unfair by using the word “magical”? Take a look at this LinkedIn post by one of the company’s founders, Hjalmar Nilsonne:
Again, the sales pitch is very much like the sales pitch favored by practitioners of “integrative medicine,” including naturopaths and “functional medicine” practitioners, representing their methods as The One True Preventative Medicine. I note that, among the many commenters praising Neko Health, there was one commenter who exhibited the appropriate level of skepticism, a question that I will expand on as I look at Neko Health’s product and products like it:
Instead of alleviating pressure on our health systems this will probably just add to it. All scans find ‘something’, will Neko help ‘solve’ them or just refer the patient to the already struggling general practitioners and public hospitals?
Excellent question, Mr. Bateman! Did Nilsonne answer it? Nope. Only one person did, and he appears not to be affiliated with the company:
Why rely on human eyeballs when computer vision can easily detect and track hundreds of 2mm skin lesions over time?
We say the same thing to physios and personal trainers about recording movement in pixels and milliseconds, and some insist they can see/measure and report dysfunction with their eyes, and adequately report it with text.
If Mona Lisa were to be described in words alone, she would have many faces!
The cost of bias, malpractice and delayed intervention will easily outweigh the cost of early diagnosed and early intervention.
In any case, this seems like out of pocket for now. They should be paid a % of saved future costs for early detection, based on historical data IMHO.
Mr. Bilby’s faith in computer algorithms is….touching, as is his faith that screening everyone willy-nilly like this will do anything more than cost more money in downstream confirmatory tests and procedures. It’s not as though we haven’t gone down this road before many times. It is up to the promoters of a new technology like this to show that it does what it says, not to critics to show that it doesn’t, but for some reason it never seems to work out that way. I do like the Mona Lisa analogy, though. It sounds so profound without actually saying anything substantive about the technology. I also note that, if all this does is to take images of skin lesions and track whether they grow over time or not, it’s just a more sophisticated way of doing skin screening exams in a way that more systematically records every lesion on the skin, of which most people have dozens, if not hundreds.
Moreover, there is also already a rather extensive scientific literature on the use of AI to classify skin lesions and carry out skin screenings, particularly for people with darker skin, (Does Neko use recommended best practices for its image acquisition, for example?) for which AI could be particularly useful given the difficulty in identifying and classifying moles as benign versus potentially malignant in darker skin types. However, as this recent review put it, for non-melanoma skin types, AI has “sensitivity and specificity that are not inferior to those of trained dermatologists,” which is hardly a ringing endorsement. Neko Health will have to show that its system is superior to the many existing systems under development and testing. Can it? I sure can’t tell from what I can find out.
Also concerning is this:
What’s perhaps most notable about Neko at this juncture is its aversion to interviews, particularly against the backdrop of high-profile health techs such as Theranos’ spectacular fall from grace after making bold claims with little foundation. Indeed, Neko Health declined to give interviews to international media when it formally launched earlier this year, and little opportunity was given to ask questions ahead of today’s funding announcement.
It is, of course, difficult not to get a Theranos vibe from Neko Health, although the difference here is that, unlike the case with Theranos, where the technology was clearly half-baked and arguably even impossible, the technology clearly exists to produce the devices and tests that Neko Health markets. Indeed, as you will see, other than the “whole body scan,” Neko appears to be doing nothing particularly novel, not even coupling AI with existing technology The main problem is the assumptions behind this raft of tests and the seeming lack of concern about the well-known negatives of screening people for so many measurements at once. The company claims it is doing clinical trials, but searching PubMed failed to find any published results, as did scanning the Neko Health website. I found the latter observation particularly telling, because, if there’s one thing companies marketing a new medical test love, it’s to tout their scientific publications on their websites.
What is Neko Health selling, though?
Neko Health’s “whole body scan”
I noted when I first visited the Neko Health website to see what it says about its whole body scans that the website is incredibly slick but rather lacking in much detail, coupled with language that sounded very much like that used by AmeriScan, the company whose “whole body CT” and screening MRIs had caught my attention back in 2003. Touting its products as “Your health checkup got upgraded, Neko Health brags:
Try the Neko Body Scan, get instant results, and let us monitor your health—so you don’t have to.
Sounds nice, but doesn’t the paternalism of this message conflict with the “take control of your own health” pitch going on elsewhere? And:
Detect. Prevent. Relax. Your body is constantly changing. By measuring, analyzing, and following millions of data points, we create an individually tailored overview of your health.
This is just another form of a favorite advertising buzzword among both conventional physicians and quacks designed to make patients feel special—”individual”—if they use the product being touted. Which use of the “individually tailored” or “personalized” view is being touted here? Let’s take a look.
First, however, let’s see what Neko Health promises with “its own 360-degree full-body 3D scanner integrated with over 70 sensors” (plus, as you will see, a lot of other tests). Neko Health’s Twitter feed touts three main aspects of its products.
First, skin:
How long do you think it will take you to capture every mole on your body? pic.twitter.com/jXskiMjn57
— Neko Health (@NekoHealth) June 20, 2023
I see many punch biopsies in this woman’s future.
Then the cardiovascular system:
How is your heart feeling today? Better health is only a heartbeat away. pic.twitter.com/xw3tGz1p7R
— Neko Health (@NekoHealth) June 28, 2023
And, finally, the scan:
Ahead of your health. The more you understand, the more you can improve how you feel. pic.twitter.com/JmuCrBqmX4
— Neko Health (@NekoHealth) July 3, 2023
The scanner reminds a bit like an over-wide version of the cryogenic tubes featured in Lost in Space in the 1960s:
Read more about our latest financing round here: https://t.co/SXA7ytQy7I
— Neko Health (@NekoHealth) July 5, 2023
And, because I couldn’t resist, here’s what I mean, dedicated to those of you too young to remember the original Lost in Space:

But what, exactly, does Neko Health do at its clinics, in particular its Stockholm clinic that is currently the only location where it has its super-duper-AI-powered whole body scanner? It’s clearly popular. The website brags that all the available appointments are booked and that, if you want one of these whole body scans, you need to get on a waitlist.
First, let’s look at how Neko Health characterizes its whole body scans:
Start with a 360-degree skin scan
Everyone knows it’s important to take care of your skin and regularly check for birthmarks, but seeing a specialist can take months. Neko Body Scan images every centimeter of your skin in less than 20 seconds and tracks every birthmark—so you don’t have to worry.
    • Full body scan in underwear
    • Detects birthmarks, rashes and age spots
    • Follows changes as small as 0.2mm
This is basically a dermatologic skin screening on steroids and AI. While it is true that skin screening is an important modality to detect early cancers, particularly melanoma, one has to wonder how this AI system will do better than the experienced eyes of a dermatologist or melanoma surgeon in detecting suspicious lesions. One way that I could envision such a system having utility would be if it can decrease the number of false negative skin biopsies done on suspicious lesions, but there seems to be nothing on the website even addressing the question. Also, why exclude parts of the body covered by underwear? You can get skin cancer on your buttocks, perineum, and anywhere else covered by underwear.
As I read through Neko Health’s website, I was surprised at how mundane most of it was. For instance, part of the screening involves taking a fasting blood sample for routine labs like a lipid panel and a “full-body blood pressure with 8 non-invasive sensors.” A more detailed description of the tests can be found here, where Neko touts its three clinical trials, which it calls Cardio Alpha, DermaFlow Alpha, and Spectrum 1.
Cardio Alpha is described as a clinical trial “about evaluating the suitability of a novel Laser-Radar-based technology, to assess arterial stiffness and its correlation to cardiovascular risk and diseases” and consists of collecting heart sounds, pulse wave analysis, pulse wave velocity, blood pressure, ECG, and cardiac ultrasound images, none of which is particularly novel or even all that interesting.
Next up, there’s DermaFlow Alpha:
This clinical trial is about evaluating the suitability of multi-modal imaging technology that virtually covers the entire body, to assess the potential of screening and early detection of disease.
The multi-modal technology is based on camera systems, which can capture high-resolution color images (visible spectrum), 3D, and thermal images (infrared spectrum).
By studying the correlation and sensitivity between disease states, gradients, and asymmetries in collected image data, the potential can be evaluated.
Did they say “thermal images”? Holy thermography, Batman! Neko Health is using a fancy, tarted up version of thermography coupled with high resolution images. It’s hard for me not to recall that thermography is an imaging modality that’s long been a favorite of naturopaths, “holistic practitioners,” and other quacks (but I repeat myself), who make extravagant unsupported claims about its ability to detect many diseases, but in particular breast cancer. (Christine Northrup is a big fan, as I first noted in 2010.) To me, this sounds suspiciously like nothing more than an observational study designed to collect a dataset to train Neko’s AI. Recruiting patients to evaluate and test a new technology and train its AI is nothing nefarious in and of itself, but such a mundane goal rather conflicts with all the company’s hype for its products. Do patients who pay for these tests know what they’re signing up for? They expect to be given reassurance (no disease) or to find disease early, the assumption being that finding disease early will result in a better outcome. Do they know that in many cases such tests will trigger further tests and even invasive procedures?
These first two studies are just the buildup to what Neko Health obviously considers its main accomplishment, its “whole body scan.” (I’m surprised that the company didn’t come up with a pithier name for it.) So let’s look at how it describes its Spectrum 1 trial:
Most skin conditions affect and/or are caused by the skin’s microcirculation (blood flow in the smallest vessels). Microcirculation in the skin is also affected by many systemic diseases, such as for example, diabetes and autoimmune diseases.
The disease of large vessels (macro-circulation) can also be caused by basic problems with microcirculation.
Today, there is little opportunity to detect microcirculatory problems early, and it is often discovered when the course of the systemic disease has gone quite far.
This clinical trial will evaluate a trial device that uses a projector to depict patterns on the skin, which the skin absorbs, reflects, and spreads depending on skin composition and structure.
There’s a lot to unpack here. First of all, it is true that many diseases have dermatological manifestations, but certainly by no means do all diseases manifest themselves on the skin in a manner that can be picked up by a system like this. Yet the company makes grandiose claims for this system, which, besides the visual images it records, also measures concentrations of oxyhemoglobin (oxidized hemoglobin) and deoxyhemoglobin (non-oxidized hemoglobin), as well as the “oxygenation within the measured skin area,” to which the wag in me can’t help but say: Congratulations! You’ve reinvented the pulse oximeter as a whole body pulse oximeter! In fairness, the device also measures the concentration of water and melanin in the skin area examined, but in reality it is sounding more and more like a glorified pulse oximeter that measures a few other things.
Again, like the others, this clinical study looks to me like nothing more than a method to gather a training dataset for the company’s AI, which, again, is nothing nefarious in and of itself. What is dubious to me is having your patients fund the research and development of your technology by paying for an unproven test to be part of its AID training dataset. This is the sort of activity that should be funded by the company developing the experimental technology, not patients, but that’s not what appears to be happening. Moreover, the company appears to be enticing patients by making promises, albeit vague ones, about their test being the ultimate in preventive medicine. If that’s not what the company is doing, I have been unable to find any evidence telling me what the specific questions they are asking are.
I was particularly taken by this quote:
Nilsonne said that the company has already proven the resonance of its unique approach to preventative healthcare. Strong demand signals a genuine need and desire for change, which has propelled the company to broaden its horizons and accelerate its growth by forming partnerships with external investors for the first time.
This is nothing more than an appeal to popularity. All it says is that Neko Health’s marketing of its as yet unproven device has been effective.
“Whole body scans” as functional medicine?
Having perused the company website and as much as I could find with Google and PubMed, I was left…dissatisfied. I understand a company wanting to protect its proprietary intellectual property, but the vagueness of the claims was frustrating, especially coupled with the lack of detail about what, exactly, Neko Health’s scans will actually be used for other than a generic “health screening” that will somehow revolutionize preventative medicine. I was interested in learning the identities of the physicians running the clinical development of this technology, because screening asymptomatic populations for occult disease in the hopes that early intervention will result in better outcomes is an area of medicine that is highly complex and fraught with pitfalls, such what to do with “incidentalomas” (lesions or abnormalities found incidentally on a test that a patient is undergoing to look for something else, but more importantly the problem of overdiagnosis, lead time bias, and length bias. Yet, under the “leadership” and “transparency” section of Neko Heath’s website, all I could find were the identities of the founders of the company and its systems for safety, documentation, and quality improvement, which apparently are in accordance with Swedish law. Its press kit was no more informative, consisting mainly of photos of its device.
As the late Dr. Harriet Hall, who was a family physician who served as a flight surgeon in the Air Force, pointed out well over a decade ago, even the yearly physical examination with routine bloodwork is a medical screening tool that has come into question given its low yield in most healthy, asymptomatic patients who have no symptoms or signs of disease and are not a high risk of certain specific diseases.
She also noted:
We are increasingly questioning screening tests that were formerly recommended. The annual chest x-ray, tine test, and urinalysis are long gone. The recommended age limits for mammography have changed. Routine PSA testing is being discouraged. A recent study suggested that a woman whose DEXA scan shows normal bone density or mild osteopenia need not be rescreened for 15 years.
We don’t need to examine all the published literature on screening tests, because the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) has done all the work for us. They continually update recommended screening tests for different age and risk groups based on the latest studies. There are other organizations in the US and elsewhere that make similar recommendations but that may differ to some degree in different countries. In general, a specialty organization is likely to recommend more screening in its particular area of interest, based on a different focus in interpreting the same published evidence. The American Academy of Family Physicians, with a broader perspective, generally follows USPSTF recommendations.
Any new screening test needs to be viewed very skeptically in the light of these observations. For some reasons why, feel free to review some of my articles that discuss the issues involved with any screening test. I discussed mainly screening tests for cancer, like mammography for breast cancer, PSA for prostate cancer, and thyroid ultrasound for thyroid cancer, all of which can artificially inflate survival statistics for cancer, but all involved problems of overdiagnosis, lead time bias, and length bias. (It’s not just these cancers, either.) In fact, let me cite a couple of graphs that I always like to cite whenever the topic of screening comes up. First, here’s an illustration of lead time bias:

Here’s another illustration of the concept that I like to cite. Note that lead-time bias is a factor in screening for any disease that can result in death, not just cancer:
As a result of lead time bias, it’s very easy for screening to make it look as though patients are doing better after early detection of their disease, whether they are, in fact, doing better or not. One of the best explanations of the concept of lead time bias that I’ve ever encountered can be found here.
The other factor most relevant to cancer screening is overdiagnosis and length bias illustrated here with the concept of overdiagnosis:
The above graph demonstrates how screening favors the diagnosis of relatively slowly growing cancers, known as length bias. Fast growing cancers, like Tumor D, grow so fast that they become symptomatic or detectable on physical examination between screenings. As a breast surgeon, I see this occasionally, the woman who laments that she gets her mammograms regularly but felt a lump 6 months after her last mammography that turned out to be cancer. This graph also illustrates the problem of overdiagnosis that also results from length bias, as Tumor B is what happens when a slow growing cancer reaches the stage of being detectable by a screening test but is so slow growing that the patient will die of other causes before it causes any problems. Also, remember that this whole discussion only applies to patients who have no symptoms or physical findings. If the patient has symptoms or physical findings, then the test is no longer a screening test but a diagnostic test. If you have symptoms or physical findings that are worrisome for serious disease, you should always see your doctor to have them checked out.
None of this is to say that screening tests are useless, don’t save lives, or at the very least allow less invasive and radical treatments to succeed. Several are not. However, what these entrepreneurs selling new unfocused screening tests for even healthy people always seem not to understand (or even be much concerned about) is that screening for any disease involves a difficult balancing act between disease biology and natural history versus any benefits of intervening in the disease process in its asymptomatic phase. Remember, overdiagnosis is not a false positive, although that is a frequent misunderstanding of the concept. For example, breast cancers and prostate cancers overdiagnosed by mammography and PSA, respectively, are real cancers. Upon biopsy, they look like any other cancer under the microscope to the pathologist. Overdiagnosis represents the diagnosis of a real medical disease or condition that progresses so slowly that, if left alone, it would never put the patient’s life at risk or significantly impact the patient’s health but ends up being overtreated because we currently have no reliable tests to differentiate overdiagnosed disease from disease that needs intervention. These issues are why some screening tests (e.g., mammography) make the cut for clinical utility while others (PSA for prostate cancer) are increasingly questioned. It’s also why the indications for screening tests like mammography (e.g., age to begin screening, interval between tests, etc.) undergo continuous reevaluation based on new science.
One Twitter doc noticed the issue right away, this issue is a problem that we have seen in the past many, many times with these sorts of technologies. The only difference nowadays is that tech people think that adding AI will fix the problem; that is, if they ever even bothered to consider this problem at all, which Neko Health appears not to have:
Do investors think no one in medicine ever had the idea of doing imaging to detect cancer? Or more cynically do they think the worried well will just shell out $317 for a low res scan read by a buggy algorithm? Have they considered the enormous liability of missed diagnoses?
— Nick Mark MD (@nickmmark) July 6, 2023
If there’s one area that AI might have utility, it’s in identifying factors that allow us to differentiate between overdiagnosed disease detected by screening and disease that requires treatment. Frustratingly, from what I’ve observed during the last two decades that I’ve been paying attention to these issues, companies like Neko Health never seem particularly interested in attacking this more difficult problem, again, because they lack the necessary domain evidence and. Again, it “just makes sense” to people without the requisite background expertise who might tell them that their misconception that finding things early will always be good is often not true, or, as one Twitter user put it:
They don’t know what they don’t know likely describes Hjalmar Nilsonne and Daniel Ek quite well. It’s a common occurrence whenever tech entrepreneurs venture into healthcare.
Unfortunately, we know from long experience that in some cases screening for disease does more good than harm (e.g., breast cancer, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and others), but more often all these sorts of screening tests do is to trigger additional tests, some invasive, that can result in harm. You need physicians and scientists with the necessary expertise and a proven track record demonstrated by peer-reviewed publications evaluating the sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value of screening tests in addition to your AI experts. In fact, you probably need an even rarer breed, the physician or scientist with experience assessing screening tests who also understands AI and AI algorithms.
One commenter nailed it:
I don’t understand how anyone thinks this is going to save money, either. As soon as you shell out $317 for the scan, that’s gonna lead to thousands of dollars of potentially unnecessary appointments, labs, more imaging that doctors will actually trust, and biopsies.
— chelsea 🙂 (@chelseadjones) July 6, 2023
Before I move on, though I have to contradict one thing that Dr. Mark said. If there’s one thing the history of such tests demonstrates, it’s that the worried well will shell out far more than a mere $317 to undergo various iterations of the “whole body scan.” In fact, there is a whole area of pseudomedicine that tells us that: functional medicine, and Neko Health’s whole body scan and other companies adding AI to a very old idea of doing whole body scans reminded me of this
The comparison between functional medicine and its “everything but the kitchen sink” approach to lab tests was driven home when I found this chart on the Neko Health website:
Here’s where Neko Health reminds me of functional medicine. Remember how I characterized functional medicine as “reams of useless tests in one hand, a huge invoice in the other“? That’s because functional medicine takes a very similar approach of doing lots and lots of tests (both standard and nonstandard) and then correcting every abnormality, whether it’s truly an abnormality or not given that all tests have false positives and if you do enough of them you will by random chance alone get a few abnormal test results, and whether it needs to be “corrected” or not. I’m very much getting a functional medicine sort of vibe from Neko Health.
The whole body scan—with AI!—gold rush
I don’t want to pick on just Neko Health though. It’s far from alone in its rush to raise venture capital to fund the development of this sort of product and suite of tests. It appears to be quite the gold rush out there to add AI to the very old (and discredited) practice of offering whole body scans to the healthy worried well as “preventative medicine.” For example, there’s one startup, Ezra, that’s marketing whole body screening MRI scans. The company claims that “its full-body MRI service monitors for possible cancer and more than 500 other conditions in up to 13 organs,” offering “three-year memberships for $5,300 or five-year plans for $7,000. They include annual exams along with a 45-minute follow-up consultation.” Another company, Prenuvo, is backed by Cindy Crawford and offering another AI-fueled whole body MRI scan direct to consumers for a mere $2,499, showing that, yes, the worried well will pay a lot more than $317 for tests more likely to cause them harm than good, although price competition is coming to this industry, with companies like SimonMed Imaging trying to undercut companies like Prenuvo, although its product doesn’t appear to use AI.
Most of these startups are covered pretty credulously by the press, but I have to give credit to Radiology Business for including some serious skepticism about at least one of them, Prenuvo:
However, some are expressing concern that the service could cause more harm than good. Catherine Livingston, MD, a family medicine specialist who served as lead author of a 2016 report recommending against this practice, is one such skeptic.
“There is certainly not enough known about the use of [artificial intelligence] in direct-to-consumer imaging services,” Livingston, an associate professor of family medicine at Oregon Health Sciences University School of Medicine, told the newspaper. “We don’t even know that the benefits outweigh harms for whole body scans in asymptomatic people. Adding in … AI is a Pandora’s box.”
And, from a December story about Prenuvo:
Dr. Matthew Davenport, the vice chair of the American College of Radiology’s Quality and Safety Commission, said that using MRIs to screen the general population is not likely to improve patient health.
“It is a terrible idea,” he said.
Davenport said there’s a big risk with using a scan as sensitive as an MRI of finding abnormalities that are later found to be benign. Screening may make sense for people with a higher risk for disease.
But Davenport said that for the general public, imaging every organ with such a sensitive test “will harm the patients.” Even if the scan itself doesn’t pose much of a risk, he said, more procedures down the line might pose a bigger risk.
“You find all sorts of stuff that would never occur to the patient,” he said. “And you end up triggering workups, biopsies for imaging studies, operations, for findings in the body that would never have any importance for the patient.”
Precisely. This is the aspect of screening healthy people for everything under the sun that the general public doesn’t understand. Unfortunately, neither do the tech bros who think that AI will make everything better. As always, the devil is in the details, and from my perspective it’s profoundly unethical to charge patients large sums of money merely to provide you with another data point in your training dataset for your AI.
None of this phases the tech people running these startups, unfortunately. For example, listen to Andrew Lacy, founder and CEO of Prenuvo:
“The current healthcare system is reactive. For many, health information comes too late, once a disease or condition has progressed, has symptoms, and is more difficult and expensive to treat,” Lacy said in a statement last fall announcing the $70 million fundraising round. “Our series A financing is validation of Prenuvo’s mission to catch conditions before they become crises and transform the healthcare approach as we know it to one that is rooted in proactive health.”
I love how Lacy equates success in raising venture capital with the medical and scientific value of its technology, which it claims to be unique, because all these companies claim that their AI is unique and better than the others. For example, last year Lacy said:
Lacy said Prenuvo uses proprietary software and artificial-intelligence tools invented by Attariwala to make its whole-body scans different from other scans offered in hospitals.
“Most MRI scans rely on anatomical imaging, which simply shows organ structures,” Lacy said. “Core to Prenuvo’s imaging protocols is a heavy reliance on the combination of anatomical imaging together with newer functional imaging techniques, which increases the ability of MRI to accurately discriminate many conditions.”
Prenuvo’s website indicates it charges $1,000 for a torso scan, $1,800 for a head-and-torso scan, and $2,500 for a whole-body scan, and it doesn’t take insurance. The website says the scans are performed by MRI technologists and analyzed by radiologists trained to read Prenuvo scans.
Lacy said that if a scan finds something abnormal, it shows up in a patient’s dashboard — that patient can take the result to their primary-care physician.
My experience is that primary care physicians are not fond of this sort of thing, because they often don’t know what to do with the results of such scans—or at least are unsure—because these tests are prone to discover all sorts of things that might or might not be harmful but then require a workup. Unsurprisingly, like all companies imaging such imaging systems, Prenuvo claims that its technology avoids pitfalls described by because of its special proprietary technology. How does Prenuvo know this?
Unsurprisingly:
Prenuvo has not published any studies finding that these scans catch diseases early and improve people’s health. Lacy said Prenuvo is recruiting for a clinical trial.
I’m shocked—shocked!—to find that Prenuvo started selling its test for big bucks first and only now is trying to prove that it works. I’m also shocked—shocked!—that a search of PubMed for the name of the company showed no clinical trials open, although a search for “MRI” and “artificial intelligence” resulted in dozens of hits for clinical trials looking at AI in imaging. Add the term “screening,” and you’ll find a bunch of clinical trials utilizing AI-fueled MRI to screen for specific diseases, such as breast or pancreatic cancer. Add the term “whole body,” and the number drops to basically zero.
Perhaps this is why I found no clinical trials from Prenuvo:
Andrew Lacy, Prenuvo’s founder and chief executive, said his company plans to partner with researchers to further study its model. It has not yet published data but plans to soon in concert with the American Academy of Neurology conference, among other events.
So, not only has Prenuvo not published any clinical trial results, but it seems to have no clinical trials registered with ClinicalTrials.gov. Does anyone want to bet that what Prenuvo plans is just a large case series of all of its customers who have purchased its scans, a study that without controls is highly unlikely to be informative.
While it’s nice that Prenuvo plans to “partner with researchers to further study its model,” my retort is always; The time to partner with researchers to study your model is before you market it to the public, not after. Also note the utter lack of understanding of the potential complications of using such screening tools. At the very least, event thought the gadolinium used as contrast for MRI scans is safe, gadolinium is not without risk. That’s why yearly doses of gadolinium should at least trigger a risk-benefit analysis, something that none of the companies marketing whole body MRI screening using AI appear to have done, just as AmeriScan never bothered to consider the risk-benefit ratio of yearly doses of gadolinium, plus all the other potential unnecessary workup and biopsies, compared to the potential benefits of its yearly screening.
AmeriScan and a number of “whole body CT scans” and “whole body MRI scans” proliferated two decades ago, only to disappear (for the most part) for several years. Unfortunately AI has provided a seemingly reasonable rationale to resurrect these discredited screening modalities in the likely vain hope that AI will somehow eliminate or at least mitigate the problems associated with old-fashioned whole body scans, be they CT, MRI, or Neko Health’s fusion of photography and thermography coupled with cardiovascular scans. Unfortunately, whether AI can succeed in this is very much an open question, but that doesn’t stop these companies from using AI as a marketing buzzword to sell their product before it’s been proven superior (or at least not inferior) to existing diagnostics.
Truly, these companies are the AmeriScan of the 2020s.

   A University of Michigan Medical School alumnus confronts anthroposophic medicine at his alma mater
David Gorski 
Link
I graduated from the University of Michigan Medical School in the late 1980s. If there’s one thing I remember about the four years I was there, it’s that U. of M. was really hardcore about science back then. In fact, one of the things I remember is that U. of M. was viewed as being rather old-fashioned. No new (at the time) organ system approach for us! Every four weeks, like clockwork, we’d have what was called a concurrent examination, which basically meant that we were tested (with multiple choice tests, of course) on every subject on the same morning. The medical curriculum for the first two years had been fairly constant for quite some time, with a heaping helpin’ of anatomy, histology, biochemistry, and physiology in the first year and the second year packed full of pharmacology, pathology, and neurosciences. Nowhere to be found was anything resembling “energy medicine” or anything that wasn’t science-based!
Of course, back in the 1980s, the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical schools and academic medical centers hadn’t really begun in earnest yet, although the rumblings of what is now called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and, more frequently these days, “integrative medicine” (IM) were starting to be heard in East Coast and West Coast schools. Even there, though, the incipient CAM movement was viewed as fringe, not worthy of the attention of serious academic physicians. Indeed, in the late 1980s, even at what are now havens of quackademic medicine if someone had suggested that diluting substances until there is nothing left, as in homeopathy, or waving your hands over a patient in order to channel the “universal source” of energy into a patient in order to heal a patient, as in reiki, had any place in scientific medicine, he’d have been laughed out of medical school–and rightly so.
Not so today, unfortunately. Although the problem of infiltration of quackademic medicine into academic medical centers goes way beyond this example, I can point out that faith healing based on Eastern mystical beliefs instead of Christianity is alive and well and ensconced in academic medical centers such as the University of Maryland School of Medicine Center for Integrative Medicine, where reiki masters are roaming the halls of the University of Maryland R. Adam Cowley Shock Trauma Center and Bonnie Tarantino, a Melchizedek practitioner, holographic sound healer, and an Usui and Karuna Reiki Master holds sway. Meanwhile, all manner of woo, such as acupuncture, homeopathy, craniosacral therapy, reiki, and reflexology are offered. Truly, you know that when an academic medical center has gone so far as to offer homeopathy, reflexology, and reiki, it’s all over as far as academic credibility is concerned, and it has become a center of quackademic medicine. Sadly, even a hospital where I trained, MetroHealth Medical Center, has succumbed to the temptation to add the quackery that is reiki to its armamentarium. That aside, I had never expected that my old, hardcore University of Michigan would go woo in such a big way.
I was wrong.
Over the last decade, the University of Michigan Medical School has gotten into alternative medicine, adding IM to its curriculum and even having a fellowship in IM. At the time I first learned of this a few years ago, as disturbed as I was, I reassured myself that at least U. of M. seemed to be sticking to the milder woo, like acupuncture and massage. Then, while browsing the blogs last month, I came across reports by P.Z. Myers and Tufted Titmouse, both of which contained a link to the University of Michigan Integrative Medicine (UMIM) resource page. And what to my wondering eyes did appear? (Actually, I should rephrase that as, “What to my despairing eyes should appear?”) The answer: Anthroposophic Medicine. Yes, it’s anthroposophy, Rudolf Steiner’s mystical, magical system that is the bottom of a lot of quackery and anti-vaccine beliefs. Indeed, outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease have been distressingly common at Waldorf schools, where the educational philosophy is based on the teachings of Rudolf Steiner, which is why they are sometimes called Steiner schools or Steiner-Waldorf schools. Although the European Council for Steiner-Waldorf Education, which represents approximately 700 of the 1000 Waldorf schools world wide, has stated unequivocally that opposition to immunization forms no part of the goals of Waldorf education, Waldorf schools are magnets for parents opposed to vaccination. One example occurred in California in 2008, when there was a measles outbreak at the East Bay Waldorf School in El Sobrante. Given that the UMIM program, although interdisciplinary, boasts heavy involvement of family medicine faculty, I can’t imagine the cognitive dissonance that must be going on. After all, many family medicine doctors also take care of children and are responsible for making sure they are properly immunized just as much as any pediatrician.
But let’s look at what UMIM’s webpage on anthroposophy says about it:
Anthroposophic medicine views health as a matter of mind-body-spirit balance. It is centered on the idea that humans are not independent organisms but, instead, beings composed of the interactions of physical body, inner life body, soul (mind and emotions), and spiritual ego (self-awareness). Whereas conventional medicine focuses on “fixing” the part of the physical body that is “broken,” anthroposophic medicine prescribes treatment for the whole being through conventional methods in combination with holistic methods. As such, anthroposophic medicine integrates theories and practices of modern medicine with alternative, nature-based treatments and a spiritual-scientific understanding of the human being. The practice is based on Austrian philosopher Rudolf Steiner’s concept of anthroposophy, a scientific and philosophical world view that connects the spiritual within the human being to the spiritual in nature, the world and the cosmos.
This is consistent with what the Holistic Health Internet Community says about anthroposophic medicine:
Austrian scientist and philosopher Rudolf Steiner (1861-1925) refused to accept the contemporary scientific view of the body as a purely physical entity. From that conviction was born the doctrine of anthroposophy, a word he coined from the Greek words for “man” and “divine wisdom.” Steiner believed in the uniqueness of each human being, and contended that health and well-being deteriorated without that belief. Trained as a scientist and a mathematician, he was influenced by Hindu and Buddhist beliefs and founded a school in which his theories became practice.
Anthroposophical medicine determines the nature of illness based on Steiner’s principal of polarity. His system attempts to link and harmonize both the upper and lower poles of the body. Good health then depends on a harmonious relationship between the physical, etheric and astral bodies, and the ego. Practitioners are trained as medical doctors and may treat childhood infections, hay fever and asthma, anxiety, depression, cancer, musculoskeletal problems and fatigue.
If twenty years ago someone had told me that one day that not only would my medical alma mater be publishing dreck like this, but that it would have formed an interdisciplinary program devoted to it, I would have told that person he was delusional. If you had told me that anthroposophy would be part of a larger program of woo run by a physician who is described as having “studied herbalism and spiritual healing for 14 years with a Native American Healer” and as having research interests that include the “use of herbs, energy healing, environmental healing, and the therapeutic relationship” or that a physician trained in “functional medicine” would be a big part of a program in anthroposophic medicine there, I wouldn’t have believed it. All I can wonder is what Bill Kelley, the infamously hardcore scientific chair of the Department of Internal Medicine while I was at Michigan, would think or say if he were still at U. of M. In fact, having read the section on anthroposophy on U. of M.’s website, I wish I were delusional. But I’m not. The section is real, and the medical school from which I graduated has not only started to tolerate such nonsense, but begun to embrace it.
Anthroposophical medicine, it turns out, is rooted in prescientific vitalism. Rudolf Steiner, before he came up with the idea of anthroposophy, had led the German section of Theosophy. When he became enamored of his spiritual concept of anthroposophy, Steiner in essence caused a schism. Anthroposophy, it further turns out, is far more a religious and spiritual philosophy than a scientific or medical one. Based on his philosophy, Steiner created Waldorf schools, anthroposophic medicine, and biodynamic farming, the last of which would be a suitable topic for an amusing post on a non-medical blog. Suffice to say that some of the practices of biodynamic farming involve stuffing Yarrow blossoms (Achillea millefolium) into urinary bladders from Cervus elaphus, Red Deers, placing them in the sun during summer, burying them in earth during winter and retrieving them in the spring, all to strengthen the “life force” of the farm. There’s also a lot of use of cow horns, based on Steiner’s rationale, “The cow has horns in order to reflect inwards the astral and etheric formative forces, which then penetrate right into the metabolic system so that increased activity in the digestive organism arises by reason of this radiation from horns and hoofs.” Moreover, many of the concepts of homeopathy are combined with Steiner’s woo, such that many of the concoctions of biodynamic farming, which consist of various bits of dead animals plus or minus ground quartz crystals, are diluted into many tons of compost, to be spread over acres of farmland.
But let’s get back to anthroposophic medicine, which is based on the same sort of mystical philosophy that biodynamic farming is. Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst characterize this form of medicine thusly in their book Trick or Treatment?:
Applying his philosophical concepts to health, he [Rudolf Steiner] founded, together with Dr. Ita Wegman, an entirely new school of medicine. It assumes metaphysical relations between planets, metals, and human organs, which provide the basis for therapeutic strategies. Diseases are believed to be related to actions in previous lives; in order to redeem oneself, it may be best to live through them without conventional therapy. Instead, a range of other therapeutic modalities is employed in anthroposophic medicine: herbal extracts, art therapy, massage, exercise therapy, and other unconventional approaches.
Perhaps the most common example of anthroposophic medicine is the use of mistletoe extracts for the treatment of cancer. Perhaps you’ve heard of Iscador? While Iscador might actually have some activity against, for example, breast cancer, it is not without toxicity, and the evidence for its efficacy in cancer is at best conflicting. Even if Iscador turned out to be an effective treatment for breast cancer, it would be an example of being right for a reason that is spectacularly wrong. That’s because Steiner argued that mistletoe is a parasitic plant that eventually kills its host. To him, this represented a striking parallel to malignant tumors, which, like mistletoe, are parasitic entities that eventually kill their hosts. Steiner’s conclusion? Because of this resemblance, mistletoe must be an effective treatment for cancer. Readers knowledgeable about homeopathy will immediately recognize that Steiner clearly must have believed in the homeopathic principle of “like cures like.” In fact, he even went beyond that to generalize that “a plant is a healing plant when it has a distortion or an abnormality in its physiology and morphology,” presumably related to human disease. Indeed, according to Dr. Peter Hindenberger this represents a “modern, scientific reformulation of what, in former times, existed in the ‘doctrine of signatures‘”; i.e., the belief that God has marked everything he created with a sign (signature) that is an indication of the purpose for which the item was created.
Although you can read more about anthroposophic medicine, either at a Steiner website or the Physician’s Association for Anthroposophic Medicine (to get it right from the horse’s mouth, so to speak) or over at The Skeptic’s Dictionary and Quackwatch, including a description of what being a student at a Waldorf school is like, because this is about UMIM’s apparent embrace of anthroposophical medicine, I think that I will close by discussing what UMIM says about it. But, before I do so, let me quote a passage from what PAAM says about it in a PDF booklet. After all, U. of M. includes a link to PAAM on its website, which leads me to assume that the UMIM program in anthroposophic medicine endorses PAAM. So does the fact that PAAM is based in Ann Arbor. But back to the PAAM pamphlet:
Medicine based purely on material science is limited to explaining an illness solely on the basis of the laws of physics and chemistry.
I’m sorry. I can’t help but interject here that PAAM says this as though it were a bad thing. Personally, though, I’m curious as to how we can explain illness not based on the laws of physics and chemistry. Unfortunately, PAAM is more than happy to tell us how anthroposophic medicine is “more ambitious” than us mere practitioners and proponents of science-based medicine. I suppose it is, casting off, as it does, all those inconvenient laws of physics and chemistry that took hundreds of years to discover and understand:
Anthroposophic medicine is more ambitious. It takes into account additional factors, both general and individual, that may affect the patient’s life, mind, and soul, and their physical manifestation: in growth, regeneration, microcirculation, fluid retention in the skin, muscle tone, biorhythms, head distribution, posture, uprightness, gait, mental focus, speech. When illness occurs, examination of the above may reveal deviations, imbalances, and extremes–additional diagnostic parameters that need to be considered when selecting a therapy. Anthroposophic medicine also has a different understanding of the role played by the patient in overcoming illness. The patient is not simply a passive recipient of medical skill, but an equal partner with the doctor. After all, nobody can know the patient better than the patient. During an illness, the patient has the opportunity to recognise the state of imbalance body and soul have reached, to understand this and rectify it. The illness can provide an opportunity to learn new modes of behaviour, to develop further insights, and acquire greater maturity.
And, yes, anthroposophic medicine embraces homeopathy:
In addition, other substances tailored to the patient’s unique characteristics are administered. These are frequently homeopathic substances designed to stimulate the organism and its powers of self-healing.
Science-based medicine, anthroposophy clearly is not. Of course, that’s quite obvious from what UMIM itself says about the anthroposophic view of health. According to UMIM, this consists of these tenets, with my comments in brackets after each item:
    • Health involves a dynamic balance and high functioning of all aspects of a person’s life. [This is so vague as to be meaningless and all but impossible to argue with, but it's the sort of trope common in alt-med circles.]
    • Illness is the result of disharmony and imbalance amongst the three systems of the body and their related forces and effects. [This sounds very much like attributing disease to imbalances in the four humors. Teach the controversy! about the Four-fold Man!]
    • Illness is a tragedy, but also an opportunity for learning and transformation. [This sounds very much like the quackery that is the German New Medicine and Biologie Totale to me; that is, if you strip away Steiner's belief in reincarnation wherein illness isn't the working through of unrecognized emotional traumas in this life (as German New Medicine teaches) but is rather the working through of issues from previous lives.]
    • The signs and symptoms of an illness are often the body’s attempts at healing and, in general, should not be suppressed, but rather, aided, observed and resolved. [More German New Medicine- and Biologie Totale-like gobbledygook. Again, odd how U. of M. leaves out Steiner's belief that these body's attempts at healing are related to past life experiences.]
    • Many illnesses, especially benign ones, should not be artificially prevented, but should be allowed to occur and be treated and healed. The patient thereby gains strength and experience, both biologically and spiritually. [This would appear to be the basis for so many anti-vaccine beliefs that permeate every aspect of anthroposophic medicine and the education taught in Waldorf schools. After all, what is vaccination, but preventing illness? I guess your kids get so much stronger, spiritually and biologically, if you just let them, take their chances with measles, mumps, whooping cough, and Haemophilus influenzae type B. Because, you know, that worked out so well for children in terms of childhood mortality back in the days before vaccines could prevent these diseases. Oh, wait. No it didn't.]
    • True prevention of illnesses involves a healthy lifestyle with positive habits, strengthening the biological, psychological and spiritual aspects of a person, and avoiding the detrimental and illness-producing effects of much of modern civilization. [Do I detect a reference to "toxins" here? I think I do.]
UMIM even goes on to link to a company that produces skin care products and medicines based on Steiner’s biodynamic farming (including Iscador and homeopathic remedies), as well as to point out that many anthroposophical remedies can only be administered as an inpatient at a facility like the Rudolf Steiner Health Center in Ann Arbor, Michigan. There, you can find a video about anthroposophic medicine:
”The Art of Healing” (English subtitled) from Frigyes Fogel on Vimeo.
Check out the part around 24:25, where a chemist describes how anthroposophic medicines are made, including the part about how he “potentizes” many of them in decimal fractions, just as homeopaths do with their remedies. His goal is, as he puts it, to “strengthen the vital forces within the living organism while at the same time respecting its natural rhythm.” He also heads out to the French border at 4 AM during the summer so that he can harvest Arnica plants at dawn, thus allowing the “morning strength” to be maintained in them. I kid you not. Then, get a load of this description of anthroposophic medicines, right off the U. of M. website:
Many anthroposophic remedies are specially prepared using homeopathic or modern alchemical pharmaceutical processes to naturally stimulate healing processes in the ill person.
Yes, it would appear that alchemy is alive and well at U. of M.!
Fortunately, the Rudolf Steiner Health Center does not appear to be affiliated with the University of Michigan, at least as far as I can tell. Unfortunately, it’s still very disturbing that UMIM would recommend such an institution and even more disturbing that “anthroposophic physicians at the University of Michigan” appear to be partnering with the Rudolf Steiner Health Center to research anthroposophic medicine as supportive care for cancer patients.
Personally, I think that Robert Carroll gets it exactly right when he characterizes anthroposophic medicine as being “even more out of touch with modern, science-based medicine than homeopathy.” Think about it. Homeopathy is based on just two magical ideas: The Law of Similars and the Law of Infinitesimals, which together can be viewed as an expression of the ancient principles of sympathetic magic. In marked contrast, anthroposophic medicine is based on many ideas with no basis in science that can best be described as pure magical thinking. Indeed, to me at least, anthroposophic medicine resembles more than anything else naturopathy in that there doesn’t appear to be a form of unscientific, prescientific, vitalism-based woo that it doesn’t embrace. In fact, anthroposophic medicine appears to go far beyond naturopathy in that respect. It also brings into play a veritable cornucopia of mystical concepts, including the etheric body, the astral body, and the ego. It postulates that the soul, the senses, and the consciousness are beings that have an independent existence outside of the body and further asserts that herbs, essential oils, and movement therapy known as eurythmy can bring these things into harmony and balance with each other and the physical body. Reading about anthroposophy and anthroposophic medicine, I had some serious acid flashbacks to my youth, when I used to be an avid Dungeons & Dragons player. My personal oddities during my high school and college years aside, anthroposophic medicine openly denigrates science-based medicine for only being able to diagnose and treat disease according to its understanding of the laws of physics and chemistry, to which I respond: Upon what else would a physician base his understanding of disease? As Carroll put it:
Steiner approached medicine the same way he approached everything else from astrology to Atlantis to education to farming to metaphysics: He dictated his visions. Why anyone considers him a scientist is a great mystery. His notion of science as involving the explanation of how immaterial entities affect material entities is the very opposite of science.
Indeed, and the medical school from which I graduated over 20 years ago now has a program dedicated to teaching physicians and medical students as fact the medical philosophy of this very man, whose philosophy is not only far more religion and mysticism than science but is indeed antiscience at its very core despite its superficial declaration of allegiance to science. Indeed anthroposophic medicine’s assertion of relationships between the various bodies (physical, etheric, etc.) and astronomical bodies is far more akin to astrology than science. Would that it were only homeopathy U. of M. were teaching and practicing!
I used to be very proud to have graduated from the University of Michigan Medical School. When I was there, it was one of the top public medical schools in the country and compared quite well with any private medical school in the U.S. you could name. In many ways, it still does. Unfortunately, like those other top medical schools, including Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and Columbia, U. of M. appears to have embraced quackademic medicine. I only wish it had, instead of imitating such schools, resisted the siren call of unscientific, prescientific, and pseudoscientific medicine. Unfortunately, as its embrace of anthroposophy demonstrates, it has not. As a result, the pride I have as a U. of M. alumnus is now tarnished with the knowledge that, even though the vast majority of what happens at the medical school and its affiliated hospitals is still solidly science-based and U. of M. boasts some of the best medical research programs anywhere, there now exists section within it that teaches pseudoscientific nonsense as if it were science. It makes me very sad and depressed to contemplate.
No doubt the U. of M. faculty and leadership responsible for this travesty will say that they pick and choose only the bits from anthroposophic medicine that are evidence-based and ignore all the woo. Quite frankly, to me anthroposophic medicine is pretty much all woo as far as I can tell. Or perhaps they would argue that the anthroposophic medicine program is a tiny part of a vast enterprise of science-based medicine. This is almost certainly true. It’s also probably true that relatively few U. of M. faculty even know about the existence of a Steiner-inspired program at their school. To me, however, there is zero place for such religious- and mysticism-inspired nonsense in any reputable medical school, other than as a footnote in courses in the history of medicine. Certainly there is no place for it being taught or practiced as though it had any validity whatsoever anywhere near medical students, residents, or fellows–and especially nowhere near patients.
Finally, knowing that U. of M. is teaching and practicing anthroposophic medicine makes me very irritated whenever I get mail soliciting donations for its medical school. From here on out, I think that, whenever a U. of M. Medical School solicitation arrives in the mail, I’ll send it back with a link to this post as the reason why I must decline.

   Quack Clinics
Steven Novella
Links
Reuters recently reported on the raid of a stem-cell clinic in Hungary. This is welcome news, if the allegations are correct, but really is only scratching the surface of this problem – clinics offering dubious stem cell therapies to desperate patients. And in fact this is only one manifestation of a far greater problem – the quack clinic. They represent a serious problem for patients, doctors, and health care regulation.
Stem Cell Clinics
There is a very disturbing trend in the last few years – the proliferation of clinics offering stem cell therapy for a variety of serious, often incurable, diseases such as spinal cord injury, ALS, Parkinson’s disease, and other neurological disorders. These clinics claim to improve and even cure these diseases by injecting stem cells into the spinal cord or other parts of the body. Treatments typically cost 20-25,000 dollars, plus travel expenses, for a single treatment.
The problem is that these clinics do not have any published evidence that their treatments are valid. There is good reason to think that they are not – stem cell technology is simply not at the point yet where we can use them to cure such diseases. There are many technical hurdles to be overcome first – knowing how to control the stem cells, to get them to survive and become the types of cells necessary to have the desired therapeutic effect, and also figuring out how to keep them from growing into tumors. Basic issues of safety have not yet been sorted out.
So in essence what these clinics are claiming is that they are years, perhaps decades, ahead of the rest of the world. And yet they have no science to show for it. They should be able to produce dozens of studies demonstrating their technology, but they can’t.
Further, they should ethically be giving such treatments as part of clinical research, to establish their safety and efficacy, but they haven’t. What little information we have comes from outside observation. For example, Bruce Dobkin published a review of cases at one Chinese stem cell clinic. He concludes:
The phenotype and the fate of the transplanted cells, described as olfactory ensheathing cells, are unknown. Perioperative morbidity and lack of functional benefit were identified as the most serious clinical shortcomings. The procedures observed did not attempt to meet international standards for either a safety or efficacy trial. In the absence of a valid clinical trials protocol, physicians should not recommend this procedure to patients.
In other words – we don’t even know what the clinic doctors are injecting into patients and what happens to the cells, if any are even present. There are risks to the procedure without any evidence of benefit. And the clinic is not following standard ethical procedures for experimental treatments.
Although China seems to be a hot spot for such clinics, the recent raid occurred in Hungary. The reason for the raid was that the clinic in question did not have the permits necessary to use human tissue – the stem cells allegedly used by the clinic are reported to come from aborted fetuses. What is not clear is, if it were not for this issue, would the clinic still be free to offer a dubious treatment for serious diseases.
Robin Lovell-Badge of the National Institute of Medical Research in London is quoted as saying:
“I hope it scares others from offering untested treatments and will be a cautionary tale to members of the public.”
I share her sentiments but this statement strikes me as hopelessly naive. Such clinics have been in operation continuously over the last century, and they are increasing in number – not decreasing.
The Quack Clinic
Regardless of the treatment, the formula for operating a so-called quack clinic is now well-established. Typically such clinics are created by an individual, who may or may not be a physician. Often they are based upon one dubious treatment – this can be ozone therapy, an unconventional use of approved drugs, or an imagined new agent. Typically the therapy is based upon a fanciful and unproven philosophy of disease, such as the notion that all cancers are caused by fungal infections, or that all disease is caused by a liver fluke.
Clinics sometimes focus on one disease or condition to start, but over time the claims tend to expand to include more and more conditions (a good way to expand the customer base).
Here are the features of such clinics that should make any patient very cautious:
- The clinic often has an impressive name, such as “The Institute Of,” but lacks any formal affiliation with an established institution, like a university or hospital, and was founded and may even continue to be operated by one person. Essentially, a lone practitioner can easily surround themselves with the trapping of prestige and legitimacy by attaching fancy names to their operations.
- The clinic claims to treat or cure one or more diseases that is currently believed to be incurable. Their claims sound to good to be true.
- There is only one clinic in the world that can perform their special procedure or that uses their proprietary treatment. Sometimes, like with the stem-cell clinics, the treatment offered is a new and experimental treatment. The clinic takes advantage of the hype surrounding a new technology, but is premature in their claims.
- The clinic claims to cure a variety of diseases all with different causes and pathophysiology with a single treatment – the one cure for all diseases approach.
- The clinic is located in a country with little or no regulation.
- The clinic claims that it is the victim of repression. Typically they will say that either Big Pharma, the medical establishment, the insurance industry – or some other convenient villain is trying to suppress their revolutionary treatment.
- Testimonials are used to promote the treatments offered by the clinic, but they have not published appropriate research in legitimate peer-reviewed journals. Often this failing is defended with the excuse that they are “too busy curing patients to publish research.”
- When challenged by professional organizations, the clinic defends itself by appealing to politicians, using the testimonies of previous patients who believe they have been helped by the clinic and the accusation of a conspiracy of those trying to protect their monopoly. It is not difficult to find a sufficiently naive and scientifically illiterate politician to take up their cause and shield the clinic from efforts at regulation.
Of course, not every dubious clinic has every feature I outline above, but they tend to have most of them. Any of these features should be treated as a red flag and provoke extreme caution. Unfortunately, patients and families of patients with serious or terminal diseases are often desperate. They want to believe the extraordinary claims, and are encouraged to believe that they have nothing to lose. However, I have seen first hand that they do. Such clinics have bankrupted families who could not deny their loved-one the chance of a cure. They have also robbed the terminally ill of whatever time they had left to spend with their families.
Occasionally I have had patients admit with anger that they wasted tens of thousands of dollars and wasted the last six months of their life on a false hope. But most of the time such a realization is too painful – there is too much insult being added to injury. Patients and families often convince themselves that the dubious treatment was worthwhile, despite all the evidence to the contrary. One patient of mine, after having stem cells injected into their behind to treat Parkinson’s disease, was convinced that their disease would have been worse without the treatment – despite the fact that their disease was end-stage and about as bad as it gets. Another patient’s father convinced himself that taking his son with muscular dystrophy to Mexico, at a cost of about $50,000, was worthwhile because now his son seems to be drooling a bit less (his neurological exam was unchanged).
There is also the recently reported case of the mother who was convinced that her blind child could see after getting stem cell therapy in China, despite the fact that objective opthalmological exams showed the child to still be blind.
These stories are extremely sad. These are also the same people who will give glowing testimonials that will help ensnare the next victim, and who will come to the aid of the clinic when the regulatory agencies finally catch up with them.
Conclusion
Regardless of where along the spectrum the operators of dubious clinics are from well-meaning and self-deluded to deliberate and callous frauds, the harm they do to the most desperately ill is incalculable. It is frustrating that regulatory bodies are generally ineffective in dealing with such clinics, unless they run afoul of a specific law like a ban on using fetal tissue.
In the US, it is actually getting more difficult. So-called “health care freedom” laws are being passed in more and more states – these laws erode the standard of care and create a safe zone where dubious clinics can thrive without fear of regulation.
Lovel-Badge, quoted in the article about this recent stem-cell clinic raid, says:
“Many of us have been deeply concerned about some of the clinics that are offering untested, and often illogical ‘stem cell’ treatments,” he says. “They take advantage of desperate individuals or their family members, charging them large sums of money for procedures that are unlikely to work, may in fact be dangerous, and may use cells of dubious origin.”
You can remove the words “stem cell” from her first sentence. There are clinics offering many types of treatments that are equally harmful and exploitative. I am glad to see some mainstream media attention to this problem, but they vastly underestimate the nature and scope of the problem.
Without the ability and political will to enforce a reasonable science-based standard of care, the public will continue to be victimized by quack clinics.

   Be Wary of Stem Cell Pseudoscience
Steven Novella
Link
At the end of the 18th and beginning of the 19th century electricity and magnetism were cutting edge science, full of excitement and unknown potential. Capitalizing on this excitement, Franz Anton Mesmer captured the imagination of the European intelligentsia with his bogus claims of animal magnetism. At the turning of the next century radioactivity was the new and fascinating scientific discovery, and this lead to a market for radioactive tonics good for a multitude of complaints, or just for extra energy. A few decades later radio waves were the latest healing craze.
Cutting edge science is cool and exciting, it evokes the promise of the future and the public has learned to expect that the latest gee whiz science appears like magic. Its newness also virtually guarantees that the public at large will mostly not understand the science or its true implications. This is a situation ripe for exploitation.
Today one medical technology that does possess great promise but is not yet ready for prime time is stem cell therapy. Legitimate scientists involved in stem cell research are almost giddy about the possibilities. Early applications are possibly just around the corner, and only time will tell what the full potential of this technology is. But right now there are no legitimate stem cell therapies outside of research protocols. It is therefore not surprising that the con artists of today are exploiting the tremendous hype of stem cells.
The most direct exploitation are clinics that claim to have stem cell therapies today for terminal or debilitating diseases. For example there is in China one Dr. Hongyun Huang (not to be confused with disgraced Korean stem-cell researcher Hwang Woo Suk) who runs a clinic where he injects (or claims to inject) stem cells derived from olfactory sheath cells taken from aborted fetuses into the spines of those suffering from spinal cord injury or motor neuron disease. Dr. Huang claims (while simultaneous saying he promises nothing) that his treatment has resulted in miraculous cures of his patients. His clinic has lured the desperate from around the world, at a fee of $20,000 plus all associated expenses. He is abetted by a gushing and disgraceful press (such as in this Guardian article) who sensationalize his vision and courage, while cynically disparaging those skeptics in “western medicine.”
Dr. Huang’s clinic has all the red flags associated with quack clinics – optimized for money extraction from the desperate rather than actually helping people or extending medical knowledge. First, Dr. Huang has not disclosed to the scientific community what is in the cocktail he uses to culture the cells he extracts from fetuses. He has performed no tests on the cultures themselves to determine what cells are present, their viability, or their biological activity. There is no way to confirm that what he is injecting, therefore, is what he claims.
Dr. Huang has also failed to conduct even the most basic observational controls in assessing his treatments. There are no blinded before and after examinations, no objective tests of function, no imaging or other anatomical or physiological tests to see what is happening. Rather, he relies entirely on the uncontrolled subjective experience of his patients.
When confronted with this apparent lapse on his part, his response is absolutely typical – he states that he is simply too busy treating people and doesn’t have the time to do research. He also states that such research would be unethical because of the need to do sham surgery (expose patient’s spinal cords and then not inject his cocktail).
Of course, this is the opposite of the truth, in that it is unethical not to do appropriate research. His treatment might be worthless, or in fact harmful, and it is unethical to subject patients to a highly invasive procedure without adequate assurance of safety and effectiveness. He can also use controls that do not involve sham surgery, or at least make objective measurements of function to compare to historical controls. If, on the other hand, his treatment works, then he is robbing the world of its benefits by refusing to conduct proper observations. He is in an ethical lose-lose situation.
There are good reasons to suspect that his treatment is worthless. First, most patients who report improvement say that they had an improvement immediately after the surgery. Of course, this does not allow enough time for any kind of neurological regeneration to have occurred – but is perfect timing for a good old-fashioned placebo effect. When confronted with this “inconvenient truth” Dr. Huang simply responds (again, true to form), “I don’t know how it works.”
Also, reports of improvement are typical of placebo responses. One touted case of a young girl with a spinal cord injury indicates that she continues to need a respirator and a wheelchair, but she has a new tiny sensation in her right forearm, which gives her hope that the treatment will work.
Frustrated by the tide of patients Dr. Huang is turning into victims, some skeptical western physicians decided to at least do some basic before and after observations of patients who chose to receive the treatment. Dr. Dobkin and others found that in the 7 patients they observed, not one had any objective improvement with up to a year of follow up. Five patients had serious ill effects from the surgery, including three who developed meningitis.
The one bright spot in this dismal picture is that responsible patient advocacy groups (like the ALS Association and the Motor Neurone Disease Association) are generally warning patients away from Dr. Huang’s clinic. But such warnings tend to be drowned out by the din of credulous reporting and glowing anecdotes on the internet – with one common theme: that Dr. Huang is offering the one thing his patient’s most keenly desire – hope.
But patients do not need to travel to China to be victimized – they can be injected with stem cells from cord blood through various companies online. Regenecell claims their treatment is useful for “Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Type II Diabetes, Heart Disease, Multiple Sclerosis, Parkinson’s Disease, Rheumatoid Arthritis, Stroke, Inflammatory Bowel Disease, Anti-ageing.” None of these claims have been established by clinical research. It should also be noted that stem cell technology has not even progressed to the point that is can be deemed safe. In early trials, for example, stem cells have revealed a tendency to form tumors. One of the big challenges for stem cell therapy will be controlling the stem cells so that they form the desired type of tissue without causing cancer.
Other companies have exploited the “stem cell” hype without injecting or claiming to inject stem cells. Stem Tech advertises “breakthrough stem cell research” but a closer look reveals they are not selling stem cells but rather just another nutritional supplement cocktail. They claim their supplements will “help to support the release of stem cells from the bone marrow into the bloodstream.” This is the type of ambiguous “structure function” claim that the law (in the US) currently allows manufacturers to make for supplements without any requirement for research or data to back up the claims.
Conclusion
The lesson for the public is to be very skeptical of claims that seem to be echoing the latest research or cutting edge science, but that seem too good to be true or to be ahead of schedule. New therapies tend to take at least several years (usually at least 5-10) from the time they first appear in popular science magazines or make the evening news, to the time that they are actually available to the public. By the time a therapy becomes available it may seem to already be old news.
Also be wary of amazing treatment claims that are peppered with the latest scientific buzz words but, but are either vague or seem out of place. Take the time to research such claims by checking to see what legitimate organizations have to say about it – before you invest time, hope, money, and your health in what could very well be a scam.

   Biologie Totale and other bastard offspring of Ryke Geerd Hamer’s German New Medicine
David Gorski
Link
A few months ago, I wrote about a particularly nasty form of cancer quackery known as the “German New Medicine” or Die Germanische Neue Medizin in German. As you may recall, the German New Medicine is based on the nonsensical idea that cancer arises from an internal emotional conflict. This conflict then results in what is called the “Dirk Hamer Syndrome” (DHS) or “Dirk Hamer focus” in the brain, named after Dr. Ryke Geerd Hamer‘s son Dirk, who was tragically shot in his sleep by Vittorio Emanuel, the last crown prince of Italy. After a prolonged course requiring multiple operations, Dirk succumbed to his wounds and died. Three years later, Dr. Hamer developed testicular cancer, and, in a perfect case of post hoc ergo propter hoc, Hamer decided that it was the psychic shock of his son’s death that had caused his cancer. Thus was born Die Germanische Neue Medizin, which, according to Hamer, promises a 95% or more chance of curing any cancer, no matter how advanced. Never mind that Hamer apparently underwent a combination of surgery and other “conventional therapies for his testicular cancer. Also never mind that these “Dirk Hamer Focus” to which Hamer pointed on CT scans of the brain appeared, more than anything else, to be artifacts of the imaging process and nothing real.
As I described in my previous post in October, the German New Medicine is a seriously dangerous form of cancer quackery that is not only worthless but in many cases blames the patient for having developed cancer. Evidence can be found in this video, where a proponent of German New Medicine gives as examples of psychic stress a “cancer blow” that comes from menopause, in which loss of estrogen supposedly leads women to feel that they “aren’t the woman they used to be” and that that conflict is manifest in the bone or an athlete’s anger because of an injury that screws up his ability to perform leading to an osteosarcoma of extremity.
Unfortunately, cancer quackery frequently evolves under the selective pressure of competition with other cancer quackeries and based on the unique environments in which various forms of quackery come to land. Since I first wrote my post about Die Germanische Neue Medizin, I’ve been meaning to address one of its offshoots. The particular offshoot that I plan to address is, in essence, the French cousin of Die Germanische Neue Medizin, and it’s called Biologie Totale, or Total Biology (Claude Sabbah’s official site is here, but it’s all in French). I first became aware of Biologie Totale about a year and a half ago through this news story:
A new therapy that claims to cure cancer and other diseases but has been blamed for dozens of deaths in Europe is gaining popularity in Canada, according to a Radio-Canada investigation.
“Total biology” is a therapeutic approach that claims illness is caused by psychological conflicts in the brain.
The approach, also known as new medicine or bio-psycho-genealogy, professes to heal all disease, including AIDS and advanced forms of cancer.
The method is gaining traction in Quebec where patients are often told to ignore their cancer, or stop medical treatment altogether, according to an investigation by CBC’s French-language service.
The similarity of Biologie Totale to German New Medicine should be apparent just from the description above, but Biologie Totale, while resembling German New Medicine, appears to be on the way to “speciating,” so to speak from its precursor, except that Dr. Claude Sabbah appears to have been able to do something that I thought impossible: To make German New Medicine even more ridiculous. It always cracks me up to see such a name, too: Total Biology. Not New Biology (like German New Medicine). Total Biology. Apparently Sabbah thinks that he’s discovered a way of understanding the complete and total biology of the human organism. It would be nice if he did, but he doesn’t, as is demonstrated here:
The Total Biology of Living Beings is a concept that was developed by Claude Sabbah, the fruit of over 35 years of experience. In addition to his medical training (as a specialist in oncology, emergency medicine, sports and hyperbaric medicine and psychotherapy), Claude Sabbah is a researcher, NLP practitioner and a teacher and speaker of world renown. Total Biology integrates the knowledge drawn from several areas of medical specialization, recognized scientific research and various observations on the plant, animal and human realms. The concept sheds light and understanding on the normal functioning of a living creature, how it becomes ill and how it is possible for it to regain health and well being.
NLP, by the way, is neurolinguistic programming, a form of psychotherapy based on the concept that success can be achieved by simply modeling the language, behavior, and thought patterns of successful people. This concept in and of itself sounds very seductive and even fairly reasonable on the surface, but, as our fearless leader Steve Novella pointed out three years ago, research has shown it to be wrong. Steve used the example of an episode of Spongebob Squarepants in which Spongebob’s friend Patrick, envious because Spongebob has won lots of awards and he hasn’t, decides to mimick Spongebob’s every move. As Steve put it, Patrick is an affable loafer, lazy and not too bright, and he is no smarter or any less lazy due to simply mimicking Spongebob’s behavior. However, one can see how someone enamored of NLP might find Hamer’s concepts in German New Medicine to be seductive. Not surprisingly, Dr. Sabbah cites his inspiration as being from Dr. Hamer. Then he, like so many purveyors of pseudoscience, claims to have taken Dr. Hamer’s woo and gone much further:
Claude Sabbah has applied these findings from 1985. Since then, with his years of medical practice, his own findings, with the cooperation with many other researchers and scientists… Claude Sabbah has set the concept of Total Biology which integrates: Dr Hamer’s New Medicine, Modern Western and Asian Medicine, Observation of the Biological Laws of the Fauna & Flora, Biological Cellular Memorized Cycles, NLP, the concept of the mini-Maxi Schizophrenia, Biogenealogy, personal researches, and many more…
Is there any quackery Dr. Sabbah hasn’t mined for his Biologie Totale? More importantly, what, exactly, do Dr. Sabbah and his acolytes spreading like a–if you’ll excuse me–cancer throughout Quebec and Canada tell their patients to do to try to fix the results of these “psychic traumas”? In 2008 Radio Canada journaists went undercover to find out. It isn’t pretty. In fact, it’s an unholy combination of seemingly faith healing and German New Medicine:
He [Sabbah] teaches his approach in six-day seminars offered in France and Canada. He tells students that cancer and other diseases are formed in the brain first, and must be deprogrammed.
During the investigation, Radio-Canada journalists went undercover with hidden cameras seeking medical advice about fictitious diseases.
One of the journalists claimed to have breast cancer. She visited several total biology practitioners who told her that her life was not in danger, and the lump in her breast was the result of a maternal conflict.
She was recommended to stop chemotherapy altogether. During another visit a practitioner told her to drink champagne and relax.
Another undercover journalist who claimed he had prostate cancer was told his ailment was caused by a conflict between his parents at the time of his conception.
He was given orders to recite a prayer 15 times a day.
A CBC television news report can be viewed here. Oddly enough, it notes that Claude Sabbah had suffered a stroke and was recovering, which was why he missed a seminar in Quebec that he had been scheduled to do. Apparently Totale Biologie didn’t save him from that. In any case, the story of the woman with breast cancer sounds very familiar, doesn’t it? Do you remember a woman named Michaela Jakubczyk-Eckert? She had breast cancer, and she listened to Dr. Hamer. She ended up dying a horrible, painful death. It’s a good thing it was just reporters pretending to have breast cancer this time, as any real woman with breast cancer who listened to this nonsense risks suffering the same fate.
It’s also pretty amazing that anyone could think a malignant tumor is the result of a “maternal conflict.” But, as mentioned above, it’s not just this life we have to worry about. According to this quackery, a psychological conflict at conception can result in cancer later in life. But it goes even further than that. Indeed, Biologie Totale is a cornucopia of woo that goes into the past before conception and continues to differentiate into different flavors of Hamer’s concepts. I hadn’t had any idea, but after looking into it I found that it’s somehow become attached to a form of pseudoscience known as Memorized Biological Cellular Cycles and Biodecoding. If you want to get a load of how far this quackery goes by expanding on German New Medicine, read and be amazed at Psycho-biogenealogy & Transgenerational, which gets all lumped together with neurolinguqitic programming in a manner that is hard to believe. Even more amazing, it is now postulated that it’s not just this life we have to worry about. You can apparently have as close to a perfectly “conflict-free” life as there is, but if your parents or grandparents or ancestors even further back had “conflicts,” well, you’re out of luck. These can give you cancer:
Through Dr Hamer’s theories, we understand that diseases, emotional impacts associated with them and memories of traumas can be transmitted to future generations via genes. It seems logical that in some cases the primary programming cause of illness can be found on previous generations.
The modern face of the biogenealogy was mainly developed by Anne Ancelin-Schutzenberger, Doctor in psychology and researcher, who has conducted numerous research programs in Europe, Canada and the US. Her interest in spychogenealogy started when one day, she was concerned by a remark of her daughter who said : ” Do you realize, Mom, you are the elder of 2 children among which the second is dead. Dad is the elder of two children among which the second is dead. You know when uncle Jean-Paul died, I was afraid that my brother dies [...] ” Until the day the brother passed away…
Completed by Bert Hellinger’s works on the transgenerational and family constellations, biogenealogy explains the family dynamic and the way of transmission of ancestral memories of traumas. It brings a brand new understanding on how biological, behavioral and psychological patterns are transmitted, and offers amazing technics to deprogram them on the family alienation level. Working on those ancestral memories helps to free ourselves from them as well as the whole lineage from our ancestors to our descendants.
Cancer patients just can’t catch a break, can they? If their developing cancer isn’t their fault for thinking bad thoughts or being unable to overcome “psychic trauma” on their own, then it’s the fault of their family and previous generations! Never mind that there sort of idea is inconsistent with modern biology. In fact, it’s downright Lamarckian! I wonder if Dr. Sabbah is a creationist, too.
So what evidence does Dr. Sabbah and the panoply of other “blame-the-victim” quacks who draw inspiration from Hamer have to back up their claims that Biologie Totale or the many variants of the German New Medicine can cure cancer and pretty much every other disease just through psychotherapy to erase “psychic conflicts”? Do you even have to ask? It’s testimonials all the way down, of course, including these testimonials on various Biologie Totale websites. One testimonial in particular comes from a naturopath (of course) named Olivier Comoy, who claims that he’s seen many people recover from various illnesses but doesn’t specify the illnesses.I’m guessing, however, that Comoy didn’t see a single case of cancer or a non-self-limited disease that was cured by his ministrations. Either that, or he treated diseases with a waxing and waning course, saw the patient during the waning phase of his illness, declared a “cure,” and then sent the patient on his way, never to see the waxing phase return. Certainly there’s nothing like any sort of clinical trials, of even crappy quality, to support it. Unfortunately, there are more and more like him. Worse, it’s metastasizing to the United States, as these testimonials demonstrate.
There are few things I detest more than quacks like these believers in German New Medicine and Biologie Totale preying on the desperation of seriously ill patients. Not only can they not cure any patients, but they actively hurt them by telling them that the means to cure themselves is within them, not caring that the flip side of that message is that if they are not healed by tis quackery it must be their fault for not wanting it enough or not being able to work through some psychic trauma.
But why do people believe in this stuff?
Ever since I first discovered Hamer’s German New Medicine, Sabbah’s Biologie Totale, and the various flavors of this sort of quackery that have proliferated like cockroaches over the last decade, I’ve asked myself why people believe such obvious nonsense. As for a lot of cancer quackery, there is the desperation of patients who are faced with a life-threatening disease like cancer or AIDS or a debilitating chronic disease like multiple sclerosis. But that in and of itself doesn’t strike me as enough. I think part of the answer can be found in passages like this:
In the concept of Total Biology of Living Beings, dis-ease constitutes a perfect solution of the brain to ensure, in the short term, the survival of the organism. The dis-ease is a very precise transpose of an unresolved conflict, conscious or not, into the body.
Dis-eases, health problems and even behavioural problems appear when our conscious thought (our sixth sense) is unable to find a solution to a conflict which is either very intense or long-lasting and which, due to this, generates a stress which affects the whole body collectively. By means of these stresses, from minor to the more severe, the brain will direct the threatening stress to a particular body part or function of the body that is in correspondence with the conflict.
The conflict, once resolved, results in the absence of the dis-ease. However, if there is no solution, the brain will take charge to dispatch into the body and order a mutation of cells which will produce a state of dis-ease. This is the conversion into the biology of an unresolved stress affecting a precise area of the brain.
First, note how “disease” is spelled “dis-ease.” This is a common way of spelling the word on a wide variety of “alternative” medicine sites, and Hamerian woo fits very well into this thinking. For instance, at About.com’s Holistic Healing site, the reason for this spelling is explained thusly:
The term “dis-ease” is used as a substitute for the the word disease by individuals and healing communities who are aligned with wellness. In doing this it is their intent to place emphasis on the natural state of “ease” being imbalanced or disrupted, desiring not to give too much focus to a particular ailment.
Hamerian woo like German New Medicine and Biologie Totale go beyond even this by postulating that diseases afflicting humans aren’t really diseases at all, but rather the body behaving appropriately. But it goes even further by implicitly equating the word “ease” with emotional and psychological ease, with “dis-ease” being due to a buried psychological traumas. Moreover, German New Medicine and Biologie Totale are not unique in this respect of claiming that diseases like cancer and infections are not really diseases at all. Robert O. Young, for instance, postulates that cancer is not a disease as well. In fact, he claims that cancer is an acid liquid of “spoiled cells” and that cancerous tumors are nothing more than the body’s reaction to these “spoiled cells” to protect the rest of the body by encapsulating the cells. He claims the same thing about viruses, characterizing them as “molecular liquids or gases (venom) that can be created by chemical imbalances in humans.” Young even claims that sepsis is not caused by bacterial infection, terming it an “out-fection” which he characterizes as the “cell breaking down from the inside out from an emotional or physical stress or disturbance giving rise to increased acidity.” Amazing how so many of the various forms of woo circle around to blaming psychological trauma for physical diseases, isn’t it? Of course, Young takes an entirely different approach where alkalinization is his answer to everything, but there are echoes of Hamerian woo in a wide variety of “alternative” medicine.
Another example is a “healer” named Andreas Moritz. He’s been mentioned before on SBM for his book on “liver cleanses,” but his woo goes much farther than just that. Most recently, he was the subject of a bit of a blog storm for his having tried to shut down a blog critical of his quackery. What brought on the criticism was an article on his website entitled Cancer Is Not A Disease – It’s a Survival Mechanism. It’s all there: The claim that cancer is not really a disease but is in fact a normal response either to extreme “toxic” insult or to this:
After having seen thousands of cancer patients over a period of three decades, I began to recognize a certain pattern of thinking, believing and feeling that was common to most of them. To be more specific, I have yet to meet a cancer patient who does not feel burdened by some poor self-image, unresolved conflict and worries, or past emotional trauma that still lingers in his/her subconscious. Cancer, the physical disease, cannot occur unless there is a strong undercurrent of emotional uneasiness and deep-seated frustration.
Cancer patients typically suffer from lack of self-respect or worthiness, and often have what I call an “unfinished business” in their life. Cancer can actually be a way of revealing the source of such inner conflict. Furthermore, cancer can help them come to terms with such a conflict, and even heal it altogether. The way to take out weeds is to pull them out along with their roots. This is how we must treat cancer; otherwise, it may recur eventually.
“Poor self image”? Emotional traumas? Is that how mice and other animals develop cancer, too?
Basically, Moritz appears to take concepts from the quackery that is German New Medicine and Biologie Totale but doesn’t limit himself to them given that he clearly believes that exposure to large amounts of “toxic” carcinogens can lead to a collapse of the body’s defenses. More importantly, like Robert Young, he views cancer as a “survival mechanism.” In fact, Moritz calls cancer the “wisdom of the body.” Indeed, he goes so far as to rationalize how tumors can hijack normal physiological processes like angiogenesis (the ingrowth of new blood vessels) as “evidence” that the body doesn’t view cancer as a threat and actually goes out of its way to supply it with blood, oxygen, and nutrients. It never occurs to him that tumors actually trick the body into helping them grow.
Why does so much “alt-med” claim that cancer is actually not a disease but rather an example of the body’s “wisdom” or that cancer is due to unresolved psychological conflicts, past emotional trauma, or poor self-image? I’ve speculated multiple times about why there is this tendency to “blame the victim” in “alt-med,” an undercurrent of “The Secret“-like thought, sometimes implied sometimes explicity, that tells people that they have control over reality if they just want it badly enough. As far as Hamerian woo goes, I think there’s also an undercurrent of a view of nature and the human body that views nature as perfect, where disease (or “dis-ease”) is not because the body malfunctions but because it does what it is designed to do. While there is a germ of truth in this idea, as evidenced by our knowledge of how chronic inflammation can lead to cancer and vascular disease for example, Hamerian woo, like much of alt-med, takes this germ of a reasonable science-based idea and runs off the cliff with it to deny that bacteria can cause sepsis, that HIV can cause AIDS, or that viruses can cause disease.
But it goes even beyond that when it comes to cancer. Cancer is a set of diseases where the body’s own cells turn on it, ignoring the “ease” and “balance” so beloved of “alt-med” believers that normally control cellular proliferation. Cells grow out of control, damaging organs, hijacking the body’s own blood vessels, and parasitizing the body’s nutrient supply. How can that happen if the body is so perfect? There must be a secret “trauma” that leads the body to cause such a reaction to wall off the psychic trauma, of course! Or, if you don’t subscribe to Hamerian woo, then it must be external “toxins,” almost always unnatural human-made evil chemicals that disrupt the happy paradise of the body and must be purged. Come to think of it, it’s not unlike the story of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, with science, including science-based medicine with its chemotherapy, surgery, and drugs playing the role of the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Add a whole lot of wishful, magical thinking à la The Secret, creating a world in which either wishing makes it so or overcoming subconscious psychic truamas, and you have a recipe for a belief system that bears far more resemblence to religion than to science.

   4 Minute Exercise Machine
Harriet Hall
Link
I know I should exercise regularly, but I’m congenitally lazy and am ingenious at coming up with excuses. There’s an exercise machine that sounds like the end of all excuses, a dream come true. You’ve probably seen the ads in various magazines. The ROM Machine: “Exercise in Exactly 4 Minutes per Day.” It claims that you can get the same benefit, at home, from 4 minutes a day on the ROM as you can from 20 to 45 minutes aerobic exercise plus 45 minutes weight training plus 20 minutes stretching at the gym. It allegedly balances blood sugar and repairs bad backs. It is for everyone from age 10 to over 100.
Does this sound too good to be true? That’s usually a clue that it is too good to be true. I was skeptical and I sent in for the company’s free DVD. There were more clues in the DVD. They had testimonials from 2 chiropractors, several trainers, and lots of satisfied users, but they didn’t have recommendations from a single medical doctor or scientist. In fact, they mentioned a couple of doctors who disputed their claims, including one cardiologist who told his patient that kind of strenuous exercise could kill him. To prove you could get a good workout from the machine, they put people on it, got them to huff and puff and sweat a lot, and then got them to say, “That was a real workout!”
They said Tony Robbins uses the machines – but he also exercises 1 ½ hours a day (down from his previous 3). They said Tom Cruise and John Travolta bought the machines. That’s not much of a recommendation. Those guys also bought Scientology’s stories about Xenu and Thetan levels.
The machine looks like a futuristic mechanical octopus, with parts going every which way. It weighs 405 pounds and requires 5 by 11 feet of floor space. It costs $14,615.00. They explain that it is still the cheapest way to exercise because of all the time it saves. You use the “rowing machine” end of the machine for 4 minutes one day and the “stair-stepper” end of the machine for 4 minutes the next day, allowing 48 hours for each muscle group to recover. There is a flywheel that automatically adapts resistance to any user. “ROM” stands for range of motion, and this machine really does put a lot of muscles through a large range of motion while simultaneously providing anaerobic muscle-building and aerobic exercise.
I watched the demonstrations on the DVD and got cold chills. They are recommending that anyone, even a frail 100 year old, should get on these torture devices and stress themselves to the max. It can’t be good to stretch muscles that way if they aren’t used to stretching. That kind of intense aerobic plus anaerobic exercise sounds like a recipe for a heart attack. And just watching the lower extremity exercises made my knees cringe. They require stepping up about 3 feet, bending knees into configurations that put the joints at tremendous mechanical disadvantage. They look like they were designed to create knee replacement customers. Orthopedic surgeons tell patients with knee problems to build up the supporting muscles by straight leg raising exercises and other exercises with restricted range of motion.
There’s often a small truth behind a big claim. There are studies showing benefits of high-intensity interval training (HIIT). The package the company sent me with the DVD included reprints of 3 studies.
The first is a Canadian study that didn’t use the ROM machine, and it didn’t use the 4 minute continuous exercise protocol. It started with 30 minutes of continuous milder exercise, progressing to short (15 to 90 second) bouts of intense exercise interspersed with short rest periods. It showed that the HIIT group burned more calories than the control group, presumably because muscle metabolism was raised to higher levels and continued to burn fat after the exercise period. Interesting, perhaps, but not directly applicable to the ROM machine or its 4-minute protocol.
The second study, from Japan, showed more improvement in VO2max (an indicator of aerobic capacity) with HIIT than with endurance training. Instead of 4 minutes on the ROM, this protocol involved a stationary bicycle, a 10 minute warm-up period, and 20 second bouts of exercise with 10 second rests between bouts. Again, interesting but not applicable to either the ROM machine or the 4 minute exercise protocol.
The third study was done with ROM machines in 1995 at USC and was reported directly to the company. I found a webpage quoting the author of that study:
The study was NOT a published research study and I would never recommend the ROM for just 4 minutes, as compared to a 30 min aerobic workout. ALL I showed for them was that VERY unfit subjects can increase their aerobic capacity by working 5 days/week on the Rom for 4 min, but these were VERY unfit subjects.
He sounded a bit miffed.
These studies can be found on the company’s website, along with a couple more studies that are equally unimpressive. Readers of this blog will have no trouble seeing that none of these studies support the advertising claims.
I consulted experts in several disciplines. The consensus was that 4 minutes’ exercise is better than none but that the ROM provides a complete workout only if you make up your own definition of complete workout. The injuries and heart attacks it might cause must be weighed against any good it might do. And its price is way out of line with manufacturing costs. You might want to buy it as a status symbol or a work of modern art, but if you want an effective exercise program you should probably spend your $14,615.00 elsewhere.
It annoys me that these questionable ads are appearing in reputable science magazines like Scientific American. I’ll write more about that next week.

Conspirituality: Where New Age wellness meets right wing conspiracy thinking
Conspiracy theorists and QAnon may sound miles apart from wellness, yoga and GOOP, but they’re converging into “conspirituality”, the integration of spirituality and conspiracy theories.
Scott Gavura on February 4, 2021
Link

Two weeks ago I described the master narrative that antivaccinationists have united around with the goal of destroying confidence in COVID-19 vaccination. Antivaccinationists with different background and motivations, from across the political spectrum, have aligned around three key messages, and are leveraging social media to spread FUD. The ability for these seemingly disparate groups to find common ground in rejecting public health advice amidst a pandemic is actually not that surprising when you take a closer look at their motivations and beliefs. David Gorski pointed out last week that all science denial, whether it comes from the “left” or the “right,” is at its core a conspiracy theory. Recognizing this makes it less surprising that some antivaccinationists have aligned with or embraced QAnon, which has become a “big tent” conspiracy where many seemingly-different perspectives have mixed and arguably metastasized during this public health crisis.
Steven Novella wrote recently that conspiracy thinking threatens science-based medicine. At this blog, the authors have been writing for years about how many of the health fads that have emerged from the political and cultural left (think Goop, the Food Babe, etc.) are grounded in science denial, and we have also written extensively about right-wing conspiracy theories and thinking as it applies to medicine, and in some cases overlaps with alternative medicine. The integration of the two communities, and the growing embrace of conspiracies by the left, has been called “conspirituality”. The confluence was described back in September by David Gorski. I first heard the term Conspirituality as the title of a podcast where the hosts study right-wing conspiracy thinking, COVID denial, Qanon, and the increasing convergence with the yoga/spiritualism/wellness community. It is that movement that I want to explore in today’s post.
Defining conspirituality
While the term may have been coined by Canadian musicians, conspirituality was academically defined back in 2011 by Charlotte Ward and David Voas, writing in the Journal of Contemporary Religion. They described how two popular but seemingly very different perspectives had common roots, and in some circumstances, were merging into a new belief system. The first is the “New Age” wellness community, typically seen as left wing, predominantly female, with a deep embrace of “alternative” medicine and an emphasis on “holistic” ideas and different forms of spirituality. They may not be politically active. The second group were the conspiracy theorists, who traditionally are predominantly conservative, right-wing, and male. Ward and Voas noted that both the seemingly-optimistic liberal wellness/alternative community, and the more pessimistic and conservative conspiracy community, tended to agree that:
    • A secret group covertly controls, or is trying to control, the political and social order.
        ◦ For the wellness community, this group may be Big Pharma, the FDA, conventional medicine, or anyone that dismisses or criticizes any “different ways of knowing”.
        ◦ For conspiracy theorists, this is the shadow government, New World Order, Illuminati, etc.
    • Humanity is undergoing a “paradigm shift” in consciousness, or awareness.
        ◦ For the wellness community, this is usually described as an “awakening” or “enlightenment”, which may not be tied to any particular religion.
        ◦ For conspiracy theorists, this typically refers to realization of their truth of the matter, and ultimately, the rejection of “tyranny” (“Wake up sheeple!”).
Ward and Voas pointed out that the central principles of nearly every conspiracy theory dovetail quite nicely with alternative medicine views of health. Both communities share a distrust of science, expertise, and conventional medicine, except when it supports their own narrative:
    • Nothing happens by accident (“your disease, your fault“).
    • Nothing is as it seems (“your science can’t measure the effectiveness of my remedy”).
    • Everything is connected (Think phrenology, reiki, acupunture, etc).
Though this paper was published in 2011, it accurately describes many of the themes we’ve seen grow and collide over the past decade: The growing acceptance of conspiracy ideation, the belief in a shadow government/New World Order, the growth of “Patriot movements” of armed and mainly white militia, and overarching satanic threats and panics. Add in the anti-vaccination sentiments that have always been strong in the alternative health community, and it is perhaps not surprising that the COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated growth of QAnon. Because alternative medicine and the wellness community has little to offer in terms of COVID-19 treatments or prevention, it’s also not surprising that the same group was receptive to conspiracy ideas about the cause of the pandemic, and its possible treatments.
Conspiracy thinking is contagious
Since Ward and Voas published their paper, conspirituality has grown along with the growth of the wellness community and culture. A 2015 response to the paper by Asprem and Dryendal argued that conspirituality was neither novel nor a surprise, but rather a predictable outcome of 19th and 20th century occultism that spawned the New Age/wellness movement:
The cultic milieu is flooded with “all deviant belief systems” and their attendant practices. Moreover, the communication channels within the milieu tend to be as open and fluid as the content that flows through them. The resulting lack of an overarching institutionalized orthodoxy enables individuals to “travel rapidly through a variety of movements and beliefs”, thus bridging with ease what may appear on the surface to be distinct discourses and practices. Political, spiritual, and (pseudo-)scientific discourses all have a home here and they easily mix. Joined by a common opposition to ‘Establishment’ discourses rather than by positively shared doctrinal content, conspiracy theory affords a common language binding the discourses together.
Reviewing the hundreds of posts on alternative medicine and wellness in the SBM archives, there are common traits across the believers of these disparate health practices. Some are at odds with mainstream medicine despite efforts to “integrate” them into routine practice. Because many have been rejected as ineffective or even quackery, promoters and supporters tend to be suspicious of “official” narratives and critical of “mainstream” medicine. For example, if you already believe that magic sugar pills (homeopathy) works despite the need to reject the foundational principles of chemistry, physics, and biology, it is perhaps not surprising that you may be more accepting of wild theories about vaccines, COVID-19 and the pandemic, or perhaps some of the bizarre QAnon conspiracy theories.
It may be that there has been a general rise in the acceptance of conspiracy ideas since the COVID-19 pandemic began in early 2020. The dramatic changes in how we live our lives, the uncertainty, and the genuine fear, may have led many to see this period, at least initially, as apocalyptic – exactly what some conspiracy theorists have been touting for years. For many, it has meant breaks in our knowledge and our expectations of what the future may look like. Perhaps this created a vulnerability in some that accelerated the embrace of conspiracy theories across different groups and communities.
The term “Pastel Qanon” was coined by Marc-André Argentino, a Canadian PhD student who has documented the growing use of Qanon messaging in the wellness community, which has accelerated during the pandemic. Argentino notes how social media influencers has taken Qanon content and applied a softer, less dark aesthetic to the same core messages. It may have started with antivaccine messaging and later the “save the children” campaign, who saw the movement as worthy of supporting, possibly without initially realizing that this was a QAnon content. He has called QAnon a public health threat, citing its rising popularity and the continued spreading of medical disinformation.
Embracing and rejecting conspirituality
The Conspirituality podcast has compiled a long list of wellness “influencers” that have “Redpilled” QAnon messaging and beliefs. Late last year some organizations and leaders in the wellness community, including alternative medicine providers, started to push back against the growing embrace of these ideas. Some began to explicitly warn against the dangers of QAnon and its companion conspiracy theories. The CBC quoted one yoga instructor:
“The colours might be pastel. The fonts are very specific. There’s maybe one post of someone doing yoga. Then the next day it’s their food. The next day, it’s a lifestyle shot,” she said.
“But on maybe the fourth day, there’s going to be a post that says, you know, very prettily “COVID is a hoax” and then a bunch of slides that keep giving misinformation and invite you to another link that then gives you more misinformation.”
“In the wellness community, there’s often a lot of magical thinking,” she said.
For example, she says people may turn to crystals or prayer as a Band-Aid solution for their life’s problems, without engaging with those problems on a deeper level.
“I think that some of the messaging in QAnon is appealing to magical thinking. People are afraid. Their instincts are telling them that there’s something else going on, but ‘I just don’t know what it is. I think I’m being lied to,'” she said.
“Someone is coming in and saying, ‘Actually, you are,’ and taking them down this rabbit hole.”
Much of the content remains subtle. Terms like “awakening” and “enlightenment” have been part of the yoga/wellness vocabulary for years, well before QAnon. It’s also possible that the dramatic changes to yoga and other fitness businesses, driven by COVID-19-related business restriction and closures, have led practitioners to push back against public health measures, finding common ground with conservatives with the same objectives. As I noted in a prior post, anti-vaccine ideology and conspiracy theories have thrived on social media, bringing influencers that share these ideas more web traffic and even revenue.
Some have questioned if the US election results would mean an end to QAnon and the growing embrace of conspiracy-type theories. If the past several weeks are any evidence, that seems a bit optimistic. Extremes in ideology, as defined by conspirituality, can intersect and in some cases, even converge. QAnon is ridiculous and absurd, but is growing in popularity. We need to take it, and the emergence of conspirituality, seriously.

In Through the Nose, Out Through the Mouth
The advice to breathe “in through the nose, out through the mouth” appears to be based on superstition rather than science. Nose breathing is preferable.
Harriet Hall on November 22, 2022
Link

Breathing is automatic. We breathe in oxygen and breathe out carbon dioxide without having to think about it. But many people tell us we should think about it.
Breathwork includes many different practices like shamanic breathwork, Vivation, Transformational Breath, Holotropic Breathwork, Clarity Breathwork, and Rebirthing. There’s also circular breathing, box breathing, and 4-7-8 breathing.
And then there’s Buteyko breathing. Buteyko claimed it would cure 150 diseases! Joseph Albietz evaluated it for SBM in 2009 and not surprisingly found a lack of evidence.
Each method is supported by those who practice it, and each is supported by testimonials rather than credible evidence. There is no consensus as to which method works best, and there are no controlled studies comparing the outcomes from different methods.
All kinds of benefits are claimed for breathwork.
Proper breathing is said to decrease fatigue, reduce anxiety, reduce symptoms of asthma in children and adolescents, improve stress management, reduce blood pressure, reduce aggressive behavior in adolescent males, and improve migraine symptoms.
Dr. Andrew Weil thinks 4-7-8 breathing can help with reducing anxiety, helping a person get to sleep, managing cravings, and controlling or reducing anger responses.
Alleged potential benefits of deep breathing include:
    • Decreases stress, increases calm
    • Relieves pain
    • Stimulates the lymphatic system (detoxifies the body)
    • Improves immunity
    • Increases energy
    • Lowers blood pressure
    • Improves digestion.
I remember reading about a woman who always cut the end off a roast. When asked why she did it, she said it was because her mother had always done that. When finally prompted to inquire why she did it, her mother explained that it was the only way a large roast would fit into her small roasting pan.
The daughter assumed that her mother did it to somehow make the roast come out better. She was blindly following a practice she didn’t understand, just like those cargo cult natives in the South Seas who built imitation runways in the hope that planes would land and enrich them with valuable cargos.
I know a lot of the breathwork stuff is nonsense, but I started to wonder about the admonition to breathe in through the nose, out through the mouth. In almost every exercise video I looked at, the trainer had students breathe like that, and the exhalation was usually through pursed lips. Being a curious skeptic, I couldn’t help asking WHY. Was that practice based on science or superstition? I looked for evidence.
Everything I could find indicated that breathing through the nose (both in and out) was preferable. The nose filters out dust and allergens. It warms and humidifies the inspired air. Mouth breathing lacks these advantages and can dry out the mouth. A dry mouth may contribute to bad breath, gum inflammation, tooth decay, and other problems.
The American Lung Association says pursed lip exhalation is beneficial for patients with chronic obstructive lung disease (COPD) and asthma.
I consulted Paul Ingraham, an Assistant Editor Emeritus of Science-Based Medicine who now runs Pain Science, a science-based website for pain and musculoskeletal medicine. He is currently looking into common claims about breathing and plans to write an article on the subject. He has already looked at the claim that longer expirations are more sedative. He says, “It seems to have a credible rationale, but the evidence shows no effect.” He suspects that the mouth/nose/pursed lip claims are “a thing that a lot of people have learned to say without really having any idea why.” In other words, a sort of folk wisdom that people assume is based on physiology but that probably isn’t.
Effects of breathing mode on exercise
Can nose breathing improve athletic performance compared to mouth breathing? Two small studies found that it lowered the respiratory rate but increased the heart rate, which could increase cardiovascular stress. They concluded:
…breathing technique doesn’t affect athletic performance, and the mode of breathing during exercise should be decided by the individual.
So is the advice wrong?
I couldn’t find any scientific evidence to support the common advice to breathe “in through the nose, out through the mouth.” Unless you have asthma or COPD, the evidence seems to show that nose breathing is always best. Some people may subjectively find it more satisfying to breathe out through the mouth, but I suspect the advice originated with someone who misinterpreted the physiology and was blindly followed by others just as the cargo cults imitated practices they didn’t understand, and like the woman kept needlessly cutting the ends off her roasts.
Conclusion: Don’t think, just breathe
You don’t need to think about your breathing. It is automatic and effortless. The mantra “in through the nose, out through the mouth” is based on superstition, not science.

Vital Signs: Buteyko Breathing
Mark Crislip on June 29, 2012
Link
As I have mentioned in the past, almost all of my practice is inpatient medicine, doing infectious disease consults in acute care hospitals. I only spend three hours a week in the outpatient clinic, so I have a skewed perception of medicine and disease. The patients I see are sick, really sick, often trying to die and are a complicated collection of abnormal labs and deranged physiology.
I remember finishing residency thinking that a potassium of 2.8, a hemoglobin of 9.8 or a bilirubin of 4.5 wasn’t all that bad, losing track of normal physiology amongst all the medical pathology. I never did lose track of normal vital signs (VS): pulse, respiration, blood pressure and temperature. Like trying to be the fifth Beatle, over the years other values have vied to become the fifth vital sign: pain level or O2 saturation, but none have the importance of the fab four. I can live without pain*, but I can’t live long if the other vital signs are abnormal for extended periods of time. Watching the vital signs return to normal is often an important variable that signifies the patient is improving.
“Fever is a mighty engine which Nature brings into the world for conquest of her enemies.” –Thomas Sydenham 1666.
Of course I have an inordinate interest in fevers: their cause, their patterns and their treatment. Fevers lead to consults and while I say my job is ‘me find bug, me kill bug, me go home’, more often it is ‘me find cause of fever, me treat cause fever, fever goes away, me go home’.
One aspect of fever I harp on year after year and where I am continually ignored is the importance of not treating a fever. It is estimated that the fever response is 400 million years old. How do they know that? Got me. Most molecular techniques are “sufficiently advanced technology indistinguishable” from magic; all I know is that they were not measuring core body in T. rex. Every creature that can make a fever will make a fever when infected. All branches of the immune system function better at 102 than 98.2 (yes, 98.2), but in the calorie poor environment most creatures live in, if we maintained our core temp at 102 we would all starve to death. It is also quite remarkable how many potential pathogens cannot grow at 98.2, much less 102. Being above ambient temperature protects against thousands of molds and bacteria.
Almost every animal and human study demonstrates that outcomes are worse if you treat a fever: increase in mortality and/or complications, although it is not always clear if it is the anti-inflammatory or anti-pyretic effects of medications being used that lead to the poorer outcomes. You cannot find studies to demonstrate benefit in treating infections from suppressing fevers.
There are times when you may want to treat a fever: the patient does not have the physiologic reserve from cardiac or pulmonary disease to tolerate the metabolic stress, or they have had a stroke or heart attack or the fevers are high enough to cause damage. In the hospital there are multiple factors that should be considered before whipping out the acetaminophen for an increased fever.
Fevers are an important, evolved response to infection and you inhibit fevers at your patients peril. If a patient had a pulse of 120 or a respiratory rate of 25, you wouldn’t slow them to normal would you? No. You would treat the underlying cause of the tachycardia or tachypnea and watch the vital signs normalize as evidence that your clinical intervention is effective. The same should be true of fevers, although I know all too well that most people expect their fevers to be treated and that no one will believe you if you suggest their fevers should be allowed to run free.
I am listening to The Stand at the moment and most of the world has died off from a biologically engineered superflu. However, everyone who gets a fever seems to take aspirin, so maybe is was the aspirin that helped killed everyone off. It would not be the first time aspirin may have contributed to influenza deaths.
In our household my children do not get antipyretics when they are febrile and I am the one at home taking care of them, and as a result they are calm and quiet. Then I go to work and my wife, a nurse, takes over and treats the fever. Peu d’hommes ont esté admirés par leurs domestiques. Not that my wife is my domestic, but you get the idea. My home is a microcosm of the hospital, n’est pas?
If you have a fever either let it go untreated and you will probably get better faster than if you treated the fever or find and reverse the underlying cause. The same concepts apply to the other vital signs, pulse and respiratory rate, as long as the patient can cope with the physiologic demands of the tachypnea or tachycardia.
The autonomic nervous system is quite a wonder and will compensate though a remarkable range of derangements to keep the vital signs stable at a level to prevent death, although it has its limits. I have seen some remarkable derangements in physiology over the years, some I would have thought incompatible with life, and would have been fatal without ICU intervention. Most of the time for mild to moderate illness the self-regulating systems perform remarkably well keeping the body running along, compensating for whatever pathophysiology is afflicting us and we do not have to think about it.
Breathing is an excellent example. It is a good thing breathing is on autopilot, except for those with Ondines curse or very end stage lung disease, and we do not need to think about our breathing. Helping with acid/base balance and gas exchange (out goes the bad air, CO2, in goes the good, O2) we breathe until we breathe our last.
Many illnesses will alter how we breathe, both the rate and pattern, and you can get a hint as to the underlying disease if you know some pathophysiology and watch a patient breathe. It is fun to walk in a room and see Kussmaul breathing or Cheyne-Stokes respiration and think oooohhhhh, I know what might be going on. Being under almost total automatic control, there is not much most people can do about their breathing for any significant period of time. You can neither breath fast nor hold your breath without soon giving in to the metabolic demands for equilibrium.
Let’s see, can you guess what I am going to write about?
1) Discovered by lone genius? Check.2) The one true cause of all disease? Check.3) One treatment for all disease? Check.4) Divorced from physiology? Check.5) Lots of positive testimonials, minimal clinical trials for efficacy. Check.6) “Ironically, his work was never fully accepted by his colleagues” Check.7) Lack of understanding of the word ironic. Check.
Chiropractic? Reiki? Therapeutic Touch? Homeopathy? So many lone geniuses who discover the cause and treatment of disease to the benefit of mankind yet unproven and ignored by the closed minded medical industrial complex. Or is this SCAM paradolia on my part? Not quite Robert Parks Seven Warning Signs of Bogus Science, but in its spirit.
Somehow I got on the mailing list for one of the most impressive bass ackwards alt therapies I have yet to find. The Breathing Center in Woodstock New York keeps sending me emails, suggesting, amongst other things, that I spend my vacation breathing away my medical problems with the official Representation of the Clinica Buteyki Moscow, home of the Buteyko breathing technique.
Lets go through the list.
1) Lone Genius
Konstantin Buteyko was a Russian physician who was evidently dying of severe hypertension, oddly painful, and more likely panic attacks in the early 1950’s. One night he was contemplating his mortality during what sounds like a panic attack when he noted he was breathing deeply and rapidly though his mouth. He slowed his breathing down and immediately felt better. He tried it on an asthma patient who was having an asthma attack and, by slowing the breathing rate down, the asthma attack subsided.
Eureka. Chronic hyperventilation was not the effect of disease but the cause of disease. Like I said. Bass ackwards. Based on this N of 2, he then began treating patients with all manner of diseases with, it is maintained, great effect.
2) The one true cause of disease.
There is a list of over 150 diseases reported to be caused by chronic hyperventilation, including cancer and AIDS. Chronic hypoventilation is also the cause of a disease reported, at least that I can find, only on the Buteyko sites, perplexed sclerosis. Must be a spelling error, but I can’t think of for what.
As best I can tell, all diseases are in part caused by chronic hyperventilation, which is present in at least 90% of people. The chronic hyperventilation leads to chronic hypocapnia (low CO2) which results in a multitude of adverse metabolic effects and diseases. In medicine, low CO2 from overbreathing results in a respiratory alkalosis. This begs for an Epic Rap Battle: Buteyko with respiratory alkalosis as the cause of all disease against Robert O. Young with acidosis as the cause of all disease. They can’t both be right can they? But they can both be wrong.
Here is where I am old school. Alterations in breathing are the result, not the cause of disease, and there is almost no reason to suspect otherwise.
3) The one true treatment of disease
Breathing slowly and shallowly through your nose will reverses the chronic hyperventilation, reverses all the detrimental metabolic effects, and cures or improves all disease. I doubt it. Based on simple prior probability nose breathing would be as likely to have an effect on post-operative scars, hypothyroidism, gingivitis or pyelonephritis, to pick 4 off the list of 150, as homeopathy or reiki. It would, I think, would be excellent in the treatment of perplexed sclerosis, a disease that has defied all other interventions, conventional or alternative.
Here, however, is room for pause, I would not say categorically, it doesn’t work and can’t work. Most of the clinical evaluations of Buteyko have been not for perplexed sclerosis and other diseases, but asthma.
Breathing exercises in general have no utility in asthma, at least for objective findings and the Buteyko method would appear to be no different.
However, if you have ever seen someone with a bad asthma attack and the panic that ensues with difficulty breathing, worsening the attack, you would not be surprised if patients do better when given control over their asthma/breathing. Part of treating patients with acute severe shortness of breath is getting them to calm down and relax. Suffocating is not fun and panic adds to that feeling.
There may also be benefit from raising CO2 in patients with asthma, although the effect is probably not clinically relevant.
There is in vitro animal evidence suggesting that low alveolar PCO2 causes bronchoconstriction, while a high PCO2 acts directly on the airway smooth muscle to cause bronchodilatation. There is also in vivo animal evidence that hypocapnia increases airway resistance. In addition, there is support for the association between hypocapnia and bronchoconstriction from experimental evidence from humans.
I also note for a time my pulmonologists were fans of permissive hypercapnia on hard to ventilate patients and I confess to not paying much attention: the various modes of vital sign support come and go in the ICU (they still have not figured out optimal pressor use as best I can tell) depending of the current state of the art, and not being an active part of my practice, I defer to others as the benefits and risks. Me find bug, you know?
Reading the literature on the Pubmeds would suggest an improvement in subjective symptoms, a decrease in medication use, but no physiologic alterations:
No significant change in FEV1 (forced expiratory volume in one second) was recorded in either group. The BBT group exhibited a reduction in inhaled steroid use of 50% and beta2-agonist use of 85% at six months from baseline. In the control group inhaled steroid use was unchanged and beta2-agonist use was reduced by 37% from baseline
and little support for the proposed mechanism of increasing the CO2 as the cause of improvement.
It is placebo effect: the patient believing there is improvement where none is occurring, and as usual I have mixed feelings. Giving people control over their disease will make them feel better, especially when the disease has a strong emotional component, as the feeling of the inability to breathe will always engender. Doing so under what appears to be false premises, not so much. I get the impression that people are more willing to live with whatever their pulmonary function is and, because of the control, less likely to use medications inappropriately or prn.
I suspect it is not the specific intervention, but shifting to a sense of control over your disease that is important:
Where meta-analyses could be done, they provided evidence of benefit from yoga, Buteyko breathing technique and physiotherapist-led breathing training in improving asthma-related quality of life.
4) Divorced from known anatomy and physiology.
For the most part. As mentioned, with the exception of reactive airway disease, there is no reason to suspect that the mighty 150 diseases Byteyko thought were amenable to his therapy is caused in anyway from chronic hyperventilation. It is the best example of mistaking cause and effect I have ever witnessed. Of course, I am old school. Respiration is for gas exchange and little else. No known physiology would lead to suspecting that mild, chronic hypocapnia, even if it were present, would lead to any disease. Sorry. Except for perplexed sclerosis. I have become enamored of perplexed sclerosis, which does not even have an ICD-10 code although it is on many of the Buteyko sites. So I can neither confirm nor deny its Buteyko-ian physiology.
5) Lots of positive testimonials, minimal clinical trials for efficacy
As mentioned a review of the Pubmeds finds little meat on the bones of the assertion that the 150 are amenable to treatment by slow nose breathing. There are numerous testimonials on the interwebs, reaffirming the credo that the plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data. Most concern asthma, few other diseases are mentioned except in passing. Some testifiers had a diminution in kidney stones and eczema. No testimonial that I can find mentioned improvement in their perplexed sclerosis, which deeply saddened me.
6) “Ironically, his work was never fully accepted by his colleagues.”
Buteyko been ignored by the medical industrial complex and for good reason: he is wrong on basic principals and there is a lack of proven efficacy for most of the mighty 150.
7) The American Heritage Dictionary defines irony as: “incongruity between what might be expected and what actually occurs.” Since Buteyko is wrong, there is no irony in his never being accepted by his colleagues, who, I am sure, prefer reality to fantasy in treating most diseases, except, of course, the dread perplexed sclerosis.
At least no one tries to alter the blood pressure or pulse as an alternative treatment, although there is the imaginary taking of the pulse as part of pseudo-diagnosis in TCM. Half the vital signs are safe from SCAM interventions. I hope.
So the take home today: don’t treat a fever. Avoid perplexed sclerosis. And breathe normally my friends.
Notes
*Well, I can’t. Those born without the ability to feel pain usually die young and do not grow up to terrorize Lisbeth Salander.

   Buteyko Breathing Technique – Nothing to Hyperventilate About 
Joseph Albietz 
Link
A reader recently sent in a link to a New York Times article that discussed an alternative breathing technique developed in Russia for the treatment of asthma called the Buteyko Method, or the Buteyko Breathing Technique (BBT), and asked for an evaluation of the claims on SBM. This post will attempt to be a reasonably comprehensive evaluation of Buteyko and his therapy so that subsequent discussions, should they be necessary, may be more terse.
The NYT article is primarily an anecdote of a friend of the author who suffered from severe asthma, but who had improved since he began using the BBT. The author briefly discusses asthma, the history and theory behind Buteyko and hyperventilation before wrapping up with an attempt to provide evidence to support the legitimacy of the story. The friend’s pulmonologist is quoted to confirm that “based on objective data, his breathing has improved…” She cites controlled clinical trials “in Australia and elsewhere” where patients have reduced their use of medications, including a purported British study of 384 patients where patients had a 90% reduction in rescue inhaler use and 50% reduction in steroids. She ends by pointing out that the British Thoracic Society has given BBT a “B” rating, and an admonition to “the pharmaceutically supported American medical community to explore this nondrug technique.”
Never having heard of BBT before, the NYT article left me with several questions. Who was Buteyko? How did he develop the BBT? What is BBT, what does it claim to do, and how does it claim to work? Is the evidence as presented in the NYT article accurate? And finally, what evidence exists within the literature that BBT is an effective treatment for asthma?
Who was Konstantin Buteyko?
Given the relative obscurity of BBT in the US and in modern medicine in general, I am using the sites of Buteyko’s primary presence in the US, the Buteyko Center, and the Buteyko Institute of Breathing and Health as my primary sources of its theory and history.
Buteyko’s story is proudly presented in great length (but frequently lacking in critical detail) on the Buteyko Center website. I encourage you to read it in its entirety for full effect, for it is fascinating and bears a striking similarity to that of the other founding figures of alt med belief systems (D.D. Palmer, Hulda Clarke, Mikao Usui, Samuel Hahnemann). What follows are the high points from a full bio on Buteyko by Sasha Yakovlev-Fredrickson, a Buteyko Specialist at the Buteyko Center USA.
Born in 1923 in the Ukraine, he trained as a mechanic until World War II, where he served in the Soviet military on the Eastern Front and became fascinated by the injuries he witnessed. After the war ended he joined the First Medical Institute in Moscow and began his medical training.
Somehow, while still a medical student he is said to have specialized in hypertension. Around the same time and while still in his 20’s, he is diagnosed with “a severe and lethal form” of hypertension that left him with months to live in 1952. We are given no more detail, and the story is already bordering on medical incoherence.
His discovery apparently came in a moment of insight, or perhaps revelation. One night in 1952, as he stood alone staring out at the night sky and contemplating his illness, he was dazzled by a bright light, and that “in the midst of his impending demise” he noticed that he was breathing heavily as was struck with the revelation that the heavy breathing he was experiencing was not a symptom, but the cause of his problems. He intentionally slowed his breathing, and as he did so, he felt immediately better. Following this revelation we are told that he went around the hospital telling people to breathe more slowly and that they immediately felt better as well. Based on these experiences he created the Buteyko Breathing Technique.
It might be that he stumbled in this moment onto an immensely powerful and hitherto unknown insight into human pathophysiology. On the other hand, there may a more simple explanation. We have in Buteyko a young man recently returned from the battle lines of WW II, suffering from hypertension (extremely uncommon in a young man), who is experiencing hyperventilation, flashing lights, and an apparent feeling of impending doom. One would be hard pressed to find a better setup for and description of a panic attack. Slow, controlled breathing that Buteyko described using can not only resolve the acute symptoms of a panic attack, but can also return a sense of control to the person afflicted, reducing their anxiety, and potentially alleviating hypertension. Panic attack or stroke of stunning inspiration; Occam’s razor might have something to say on the matter.
Nevertheless, smitten with his new theory and armed with his very personal n=1, Buteyko began to treat patients. The subsequent decades of his life are full of stories of persecution and suppression, physical intimidation and destruction of his laboratory, professional sabotage and fears of incarceration. Undaunted, Buteyko continued using and promoting his therapy, and supposedly discovered that BBT could cure at least 150 different diseases and disorders! Buteyko compared himself to Dr Semmelweis, and the power of his technique to atomic energy. In 1987, having obtained a “top secret” patent on BBT from the Soviet government, he established the Buteyko clinic.
Never one to rest on his laurels, Buteyko continued to explore the power of BBT. He is said to have hardly slept, and to have lived without food for 50 days at a time. It is further claimed that he became an advanced spiritual practitioner with the ability to read people’s thoughts, predict the future, and at one point declared that civilization would die if we didn’t stop hyperventilating.
I’ll let these claims stand on their own without further comment, other than to reflect on the reliability of the mind that makes such statements.
What is Buteyko Breathing Therapy?
Eccentricity of the eponymous inventor of BBT aside, what can we say about the therapy itself?
How Buteyko researched and practiced his treatment from his revelation in 1952 until the establishment of his clinic in 1987 is obscure at best. Per the history given on the Buteyko Center site, at the same time that he is enduring professional ridicule and sabotage and hiding his practice from the government for fear of imprisonment, he is also able to treat enough people to discern over 150 different uses for BBT and be offered (and then refuse) a job with the Russian Space Agency. Despite what one would expect to be a wealth of data to support claims of efficacy for so many different conditions, Buteyko himself never published a single paper, and not until 1995 does any reference to his name appear in the medical literature.
Even according to the history provided by the Buteyko Center, not until 1981, nearly 30 years after Buteyko’s revelation/discovery was a second trial conducted regarding BBT’s efficacy; it is never peer reviewed or published. The same source then tells that soon after acquiring his “top secret” patent for BBT, in 1985 the Soviet Public Health Ministry issued a recommendation that all medical professionals treat patients with his method. After establishing his clinic in 1987 he treated people with asthma, allergies, hypertension, kidney problems, cardiac problems, gastrological problems, immune deficiency, cancer, and even victims of Chernobyl and AIDS patients.
The list of diseases treated by BBT didn’t end there. On the Buteyko site you can peruse the list of 150 curable diseases and conditions Buteyko believed he could treat.
But what is BBT? How can one therapy treat the varied legion of diseases on that list? Again, I’ll let the Buteyko Center and the BIBH speak for themselves on the matter here and here.
As you can see if you follow the links, there is a lot of talk about hyperventilation, but they are rather sparse on the details. If you want the details, break out your wallet. The Buteyko Center and BIBH are willing to start doling out details in exchange for the digits on you credit card.
What of BBT’s Physiologic Plausibility?
So BBT’s origins are highly dubious, but what of its plausibility?
Let’s examine the physiologic explanation provided by the Buteyko Center for why it cures not only asthma, but all of the myriad conditions listed on their site. They are kind enough to have Ira Packman, M.D. provide an explanation for doctors derived from that of Buteyko himself that can be found here. (Buteyko’s is here.)
The explanation can be distilled down to this:
-When people hyperventilate, their arterial CO2 drops, making their blood alkaline.
-An alkaline pH increases hemoglobin’s affinity for oxygen.
-If hemoglobin holds onto oxygen more tightly, it won’t release as much to tissues.
-Less oxygen released by hemoglobin will cause hypoxic damage to tissues.
-Kidneys will try to correct the alkalosis by eliminating bicarbonate.
-Along with bicarbonate loss phosphorus and magnesium will be lost.
-Hypophosphatemia will compromise the creation of ATP.
-A lack of ATP will impair the function of afflicted tissues.
-A low level of CO2 can cause vasospasm and further reduce the blood supply to tissues.
Ignore the gross oversimplifications and important omissions in the explanation for the moment and take it at face value. These are all testable hypotheses. If Buteyko is correct, and chronic hyperventilation is the cause of all (or any) of the diseases listed on their site, then one would expect to see a high pH, low CO2, low bicarbonate, low phosphorus, low magnesium, and signs of anaerobic metabolism such as a low mixed venous O2 saturation or elevated serum lactate level.
These are extremely common labs that physicians (especially ICU physicians such as myself) are intimately familiar with. According to Buteyko, this lab pattern should be a nearly universal feature of all disorders cured by BBT. Guess how many actually routinely display anything remotely resembling it.
None.
This hypothesis also predicts that an asthmatic who begins to retain CO2 should have both their symptoms and pathophysiology improve. In truth, elevation of CO2 in a symptomatic asthmatic is one of the more ominous signs in critical care medicine, and is the harbinger of respiratory failure and death.
What about the omissions and inaccuracies? First, the mechanisms Buteyko and Packman discuss to maintain blood pH are highly efficient, and are capable of correcting dramatic derangements in pH over the span of hours to days. This is superbly demonstrated by chronic hypoventilation, where for a variety of reasons people retain carbon dioxide and yet have a normal pH. With a normal pH the Bohr effect is neutralized.
Second, even if the Bohr effect remained in play, it is a minor determinant of oxygen delivery, easily compensated for by numerous other mechanisms, and insufficient to independently cause hypoxic injury or dysfunction.
Third, Packman says there is an “over excretion of bicarbonate.” Even within his flawed concept of physiology, loss of bicarbonate would be an appropriate response to balance the blood’s pH, and the kidney will not overcompensate, therefore the term “over excretion” is inappropriate and implies a nonexistent pathology.
Fourth, the electrolyte interactions described by Packman are very confused. The electrolytes most closely tied to the kidney’s bicarbonate management are sodium and chloride, not magnesium and phosphate. Phosphorus does play a smaller role in the buffering capacity of the kidney, but contrary to Packman’s claim that a state of alkalosis will result in loss of phosphate, it is in fact when excessive hydrogen ions are secreted during a state of acidosis that phosphate is lost in the form of H2PO4-. It is true that hypophosphatemia can induce loss of bicarbonate through the actions of parathyroid hormone, but the inverse, that loss of bicarbonate induces phosphate loss, is not true.
Finally, though extreme hypophosphatemia can indeed compromise the body’s ability to create ATP, the resulting energy failure will cause a metabolic crisis which will not only be clinically and biochemically apparent, but which will cause the exact opposite pH-based effects upon which Buteyko’s hypothesis depends.
Now the lack of physiologic plausibility does not in and of itself mean that Buteyko method is ineffective. What it does mean is that the physiologic explanation for its mechanism is likely dramatically wrong, and that the primary proponents of the technique have not only failed to recognize this fact, but have ignored elementary flaws in their hypothesis apparent in both theory and practice.
Buteyko Breathing Therapy and the Literature – Not Burdened by an Overabundance of Evidence
Buteyko and his devotees have made some remarkable claims while providing almost no evidence; an unrestricted Pubmed search of “Buteyko” yields a grand total of 21 hits. But 21 is (slightly) more than zero, so let’s look at the published literature. Virtually all of these 21 Pubmed hits discuss the use of BBT for asthma, as was indicated in the NYT article that triggered this post. There are no published studies evaluating BBT for any of the other 149 diseases Buteyko claimed to cure.
The following are the sum total of published clinical trials regarding BBT’s use without regard to quality, design, size, bias, or result:
1) Buteyko breathing techniques in asthma: a blinded randomized controlled trial. Bowler SD et al. Med J Aust 1998: 39 subjects. Significant reduction in use of both chronic and rescue inhalers, but no change in lung function tests (PEF or FEV1) or end tidal CO2.
2) Effect of two breathing exercises (Buteyko and pranayama) in asthma: a randomized controlled trial. Cooper S. et al. Thorax 2003. 90 subjects enrolled, 69 completed the study. Improved symptoms and reduced bronchodilator use with BBT, but no change in lung function tests (FEV1), number of exacerbations or amount of steroids used.
3) Buteyko Breathing Technique for asthma: an effective intervention. McHugh P et al. N Z Med J. 2003. McHugh: 38 subjects. 50% reduction in steroids and 85% reduction in rescue inhaler use at 6 months in BBT compared to no change in steroid use and 37% reduction in rescue inhalers in the control group, but no change in pulmonary function tests (FEV1).
4) A clinical trial of the Buteyko Breathing Technique in asthma as taught by a video. Opat AJ et al. J Asthma 2000. Opat: 36 subjects. Participants viewed a video of BBT or a placebo video twice daily for 4 weeks. Modest improvement in quality of life and a reduction in bronchodilator use, but no improvement in pulmonary function tests.
5) A randomized controlled trial of the Buteyko technique as an adjunct to conventional management of asthma. Cowie RL et al. Respir Med. 2008. 129 subjects. Significant reduction in the amount of steroid used in BBT group, but no difference in asthma control between the two groups.
6) Effect of mouth taping at night on asthma control – a randomized single-blind crossover study. Cooper S. Respir Med. 2009. 51 subjects. No difference in pulmonary function tests or symptom scores resulted from forced nasal breathing overnight.
7) Investigating the claims of Konstantin Buteyko, M.D., Ph.D.: the relationship of breath holding time to end tidal CO2 and other proposed measures of dysfunctional breathing. Courtney R et al. J Altern Complement Med. 2008. 83 subjects. Breath Holding Time as defined by Buteyko was found to have the exact opposite correlation with alveolar CO2 that his theories predicted it would have.
8 ) The effects of carbon dioxide on exercise-induced asthma: an unlikely explanation for the effects of Buteyko breathing training. Al-Delaimy WK et al. Med J Aust. 2001. 10 subjects. Patients were supplemented with CO2 to test Buteyko’s hypothesis that a higher CO2 would result in a reduction in asthma symptoms. Breathing 3% CO2 did not prevent exercise-induced asthma.
Notably absent from this list is the British study containing 384 patients touted and linked to in the NYT article. As it turns out, that was not a peer-reviewed study, but instead only an abstract at the 2003 British Thoracic Society Winter Meeting. In spite of its remarkable results, it has not in the following 6 years been published in a peer-reviewed journal. It is, for all intents and purposes, a non-study.
The three studies designed to test Buteyko’s proposed mechanisms of action (6, 7, and 8 ) do not support Buteyko’s theories, and are in keeping with my earlier analysis of its plausibility.
The five studies comparing BBT to a control for treatment of asthma (1-5) show a variable though reasonably consistent reduction in both rescue and maintenance drug use. Even more consistent however is the utter lack of any change in the participant’s pulmonary function tests.
Given the most charitable interpretation and taken at face value, these studies imply that BBT can alter a patient’s perception of their symptoms, and perhaps prevent overuse of asthma medications. However, they also provide evidence that BBT does very little to alter the underlying pathophysiology of asthma, and absolutely no evidence to support Buteyko’s claim that BBT can cure asthma.
Buteyko Breathing Therapy and Asthma – A Broken Clock is Still Right Two Seconds Per Day
Taken as a whole, this reading of the literature is in keeping with the British Thoracic Society’s Guidelines, which state:
The Buteyko breathing technique specifically focuses on control of hyperventilation and any ensuing hypocapnia. Four clinical trials suggest benefits in terms of reduced symptoms and bronchodilator usage but no effect on lung function. Buteyko breathing technique may be considered to help patients to control the symptoms of asthma. Grade B”
Though I think that the BTS authors were overly generous in ranking the four evaluated articles as 1+ level of evidence (meaning a well conducted meta-analysis, systematic review, or RCTs with a low risk of bias), their conclusions are not unreasonable within the framework of Evidence Based Medicine.
Of course, as I consider this small set of literature from the perspective of Science Based Medicine, I’m reminded of John Ioannidis’ essay “Why Most Published Research Findings Are False.”
…a research finding is less likely to be true when the studies conducted in a field are smaller; when effect sizes are smaller; when there is a greater number and lesser preselection of tested relationships; where there is greater flexibility in designs, definitions, outcomes, and analytical modes; when there is greater financial and other interest and prejudice; and when more teams are involved in a scientific field in chase of statistical significance.”
These studies can be found wanting on nearly every point outlined by Ioannidis. Already weak when viewed through the lens of Evidence Based Medicine, through that of Science Based Medicine the Buteyko literature looses much of its remaining impact.
SUMMARY
Buteyko reminds me in many ways of D.D. Palmer. Starting from an erroneous observation, using flawed logic, lacking prior plausibility, forsaking scientific validation, and promoting their techniques as virtual panaceas, they each nevertheless may have found small medical niches where their techniques may have some limited utility. Palmer’s niche appears to be treatment of low-back pain, and for Buteyko, it may be the symptomatic relief of mild asthma symptoms.
If however, you are looking for the Buteyko Breathing Technique to cure your asthma, I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Death by Aromatherapy
An aromatherapy room spray was contaminated with bacteria that caused melioidosis, resulting in deaths and serious sequelae. Buyers were misled.
Harriet Hall on March 22, 2022
Link

When cases of melioidosis were diagnosed in four patients in four different states, doctors were puzzled. Melioidosis, infection with the bacterium Burkholderia pseudomallei, is typically associated with exposure to soil and water in tropical and subtropical environments, and is rarely diagnosed in the US. When it is, it is usually in patients who had travelled to endemic areas. These patients had not.
Patient 1 was a 53-year-old woman in Kansas with a history of COPD and several other chronic diseases including drug abuse. She presented to the ER with a 4- to 5-day history of shortness of breath, cough, malaise, and weakness. Blood cultures grew B. pseudomallei. Despite aggressive treatment, she died after 9 days in the hospital.
Patient 2 was a previously-healthy 5-year-old girl in Texas who developed a fever. A lower respiratory culture confirmed the diagnosis of meliodosis. She was treated with antibiotics and recovered enough to be discharged, but she remained wheelchair-bound and non-verbal.
Patient 3 was a 53-year-old man in Minnesota who was brought to the ER by family members who found him with altered mental status and weakness. He appeared to have encephalopathy. He also complained of hip pain, and cultures of both blood and joint aspirate grew B.pseudomallei. He was treated with antibiotics, but there was osteonecrosis of the infected hip joint and his confusion did not decrease after discharge.
Patient 4 was a 5-year-old boy in Georgia who was diagnosed with both melioidosis and COVID-19. He died after 4 days in the hospital.
None of these patients had travelled outside the US. An article in The New England Journal of Medicine reported the ingenious detective work that eventually explained what happened. An aromatherapy room spray from the home of Patient 4 was found to be contaminated with melioidosis bacteria and all four patients were determined to have been infected with the same strain. The strain was traced to India.
The product, Better Homes & Gardens Lavender & Chamomile Essential Oil Infused Aromatherapy Room Spray with Gemstones, was sold at Walmart. The advertising said:
Transform your home into a spa with Better Homes & Gardens Essential Oil Infused Aromatherapy Spray in Lavender & Chamomile. The lavender scent is great for soothing anxiety and helps with restlessness while the Chamomile scent adds a sweet mixture to the spray. Use at your home or in the office. Just a couple sprays of your favorite Better Homes & Gardens Essential Oil Infused Aromatherapy Spray enhances the space for a stress free, relaxing, and re-energizing experience. Better Homes & Gardens Essential Oil Infused Aromatherapy Spray comes in various soothing fragrances to meet any of your emotional and body wellness needs.
The FDA issued a press release, and Walmart recalled the product.
Conclusion: Aromatherapy is not risk-free
It might not be fair to call this melioidosis outbreak a consequence of aromatherapy, but it was surely a consequence of consumer gullibility and inadequate regulation.
Users of this room spray were led to believe, without evidence, that it would enhance their space, relieve stress, relax and energize them, and meet their emotional and body wellness needs. The Better Home and Gardens label reassured them that it was safe. Better Homes and Gardens didn’t explain why they added gemstones; I can’t help wondering what their thinking was. This certainly wasn’t science-based medicine.

Why It’s Worthwhile to Debunk Shivambu
Richard Feynman famously said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool”. This is the most important lesson skepticism has to offer.
Jonathan Howard on December 17, 2021
Link

What is Shivambu?
An anti-vaccine doctor I trained with, Dr. Kelly Brogan, recently interviewed a man who claims he cured his cancer by drinking his own urine, a practice called Shivambu. Literally everything about this is sad and disgusting. Though she’s retired from the practice of medicine and is now a full-time guru/online marketer, such balderdash is standard fare for Dr. Brogan and her ilk. However, the point of this article is not to debunk Shivambu, but rather to explain why it may be worth someone’s time to do so.
Obviously, few people reading this article believe that drinking urine cures cancer, and those who believe such folly are unlikely to have their mind changed by it. So other than maybe convincing a few people that Shivambu is nonsense, why bother writing about it?
Several intelligent people have argued that sites like Science Based Medicine are essentially a waste of time (here and here). These critics feel that skeptics do little other than “bashing people outside your tribe, who ignore you.” They claim skeptics are simply “preaching to the converted”, and so accomplish nothing beyond making themselves feel superior. They feel that alternative medicine may be worth discussing only after mainstream medicine has fixed all its flaws and world peace is declared.
I don’t claim to speak on anyone’s behalf, but I think that when skeptics discuss something like Shivambu, their main aim often isn’t to debunk that specific nonsense. Rather, I think most skeptics have several larger goals in mind, and discussions of topics like Shivambu are merely a template for them to make their main points.
The lessons of skepticism part 1: People are seriously hurt and killed by alternative medicine all the time
Having said this, one reason to debunk Shivambu is to debunk Shivambu. Critics of skepticism often portray alternative medicine as ridiculous, but ultimately harmless. “What’s the harm if someone believes crystals ward off disease?” they ask.
While many alternative treatments are harmless, many others are not. People can be harmed directly by alternative therapies or because they used them in lieu of evidence-based treatments. For example, one study found that “After a median of 5 years, patients with breast or colorectal cancer were nearly five times as likely to die if they had used an alternative therapy as their initial treatment than if they had received conventional treatment.” As the pandemic has demonstrated, people are seriously hurt and killed by medical misinformation all the time. Just because war kills more people, doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try to save lives in other ways, a flawed line of thought dubbed the fallacy of relative privation.
It’s good when doctors warn people about the dangers of bogus treatments. It’s good when doctors educate people about the benefits of evidence-based treatments. It’s astonishing that this is controversial.
The lessons of skepticism part 2: Some people are persuadable if they are given accurate information in a clear and thorough manner
Additionally, critics of skepticism often infantilize anyone who uses alternative medicine, scornfully treating them all as unreachable naïfs. One such podcasting oncologist said, “You can’t waste all your time arguing with people who do not accept evidence and rationality as a precondition to debate. You’re wasting your time…They’re (skeptics) are not actually successful in converting the minds of different people… You can spend your life arguing with them on all these issues, but you’re not going to achieve any traction.”
This bold claim was made without any evidence, and as tends to be the case with such claims, it is wrong. We can’t reach everyone, but some people are persuadable if they are presented with accurate information in a clear and thorough manner. Even though few Shivambu devotees would have their mind changed by an article here, some might! For example, there are multiple accounts of people deciding to vaccinate their children after learning the facts. It’s a big deal when people are steered away from quackery and towards evidence-based treatments. I am certain that Science Based Medicine has done just that. My friend Amanda said the following in response to this podcaster:
Any defense of skepticism could legitimately end here, and I imagine the long-time writers here would say stories like Amanda’s alone are worth all of their effort.
Beyond this, doctors routinely treat people who use alternative medicine and are wary of evidence-based treatments. Very few of them are as far down the rabbit-hole as Dr. Brogan, and many are open to facts. Doctors need to be able to relate to their patients and help them make wise decisions. We can do this only if we make some minimal effort to understand where they are coming from, especially during a pandemic where millions of people are refusing to be vaccinated. I am very familiar with anti-vaccine disinformation, and I’ve familiarized myself with techniques to help people who are skeptical about vaccines. Hopefully, I’ve helped my patients reject the myths they encounter online, some of them inspired by contrarian doctors I’ve discussed here before. Doctors who thought that learning about alternative medicine was beneath them are likely not as prepared to do this.
I fully agree that skeptics have to be thoughtful in how they discuss these issues. Exposing and mocking Dr. Brogan is appropriate. People need to know that doctors who actually care for patients view her as an object of ridicule. However mocking someone who is genuinely confused about alternative medicine isn’t going to help anyone. As Dr. Steve Novella wrote recently, “ordinary people who believe, use, and even spread false medical beliefs are victims. They do not deserve our condemnation, but our sympathy.” Given that some prominent doctors have spread misinformation, repeatedly minimizing the virus and hyping every vaccine side-effect, it’s not a surprise that many people are legitimately confused about whether or not the vaccine is beneficial for young people (it is). I also agree that skeptics need to be wary of amplifying pseudoscience that would have gone unnoticed otherwise. The best way to refute a lot of nonsense is to ignore it and let it quietly die on its own.
However, I wonder where people like Amanda would be if Dr. Brogan and other members of the Disinformation Dozen had their deluge of disinformation greeted with complete silence by the medical community. If ethical doctors said nothing, the countless grifters, frauds, and quacks would have the internet to themselves, completely unopposed by rational voices.
While this may not be the desired goal of skepticism’s critics, it is the obvious end point to their position. Either they don’t recognize this or don’t care about it. This too is astonishing.
The lessons of skepticism part 3: Skepticism is an allegiance to a method of inquiry rather than any answer
Ideally, a true skeptic would not start out trying to debunk Shivambu. Rather, a true skeptic would realize her preconceived notions could be wrong, even about something that seems as absurd as Shivambu. After all, stool transplants are now the standard of care for treatment-resistant C. difficile infections. As such, our true skeptic would first acknowledge her biases, and she would do her best to investigate Shivambu with an open mind. She’d examine the all the evidence, and she’d report her findings as fairly as possible. If new evidence emerges that contradicts her initial conclusions, she would acknowledge it and adjust her opinion accordingly.
Skepticism then is fundamentally about allegiance to a method of inquiry, not to any final answer. For example, my first article here argued that children should be vaccinated against COVID-19. My second article reported that incidental COVID-19 hospitalizations were common in children, and I’ve since discussed evidence that the pediatric death toll may be inflated, as well as vaccine-related myocarditis. Though the virus remains much more dangerous than the vaccine, these subsequent articles all weakened the case to vaccinate children. However that’s what the evidence showed, and so without any hesitation, I reported it as thoroughly and honestly as possible. I’ve done my best not to overstate the harms of the virus or understate flaws with the vaccine. As an all-around scold, I’ve called out people several times for overstating the harms of COVID-19 to children. I’ve written about my own errors (here and here). My loyalty is to a process, not a result
Because of this, I’ve defended people (here and here) who were not in my “tribe,” and I’ve argued with people who are in my “tribe”. I’m glad they argued back. Of course, skeptics bash quacks like Dr. Brogan, but they also disagree with each other all the time. For example, Dr. Gorski recently called out Richard Dawkins for embracing the lab leak theory based on a shoddy documentary. To the extent I have a “tribe,” it consists of people who are not afraid to thoughtfully call me out when they think I am wrong.
In contrast, pseudoscience vendors like Dr. Brogan start with the answer they want, and work backwards to find the “evidence.” She readily admits this, saying, “It’s time to decide what you believe. And make no mistake, it’s about belief, not about facts, not about science as the final objective.” Anyone and anything that threatens her desired beliefs is wished away as a conspiracy or ignored entirely. Because she defines what is true as what she wants to be true, not only will she never admit error, she essentially feels she’s incapable of being wrong to begin with. There’s literally no evidence or study that would lead Dr. Brogan to change her mind about Shivambu, vaccines, or basically anything at all. That’s a problem, but not one that is unique to Dr. Brogan.
The lessons of skepticism part 4: By understanding the flaws in alternative medicine we can identify flawed medical practices elsewhere
Having learned to evaluate the claims of alternative medicine, the skeptics’ next hope is that they can identify and avoid flawed medical practices elsewhere. Someone who can spot the defects in acupuncture studies published in prestigious medical journals will be prepared to spot defects in wide swaths of medicine. Skepticism’s methods work not just for critical appraisals of Shivambu, but also for problematic drug approvals, useless medical procedures, cancer screening, and flawed research methodologies. Skeptics discuss these topics often, despite what their uninformed critics may claim.
I think my exposure to skepticism, mainly reading Science Based Medicine, helped me be a more thoughtful doctor. For example, at the start of the pandemic, I had one demand when the medicine service asked me to run a COVID-19 team: I would not practice alternative medicine. As I wrote previously,
I also made sure that no patient on my team received any experimental treatments (such as hydroxychloroquine). Doing “nothing” is often very difficult for doctors, but is preferable to giving out unproven treatments unless patients are clearly dying or in a clinical trial.
Though they would have denied it, many doctors were practicing alternative medicine at that time. I understand why. COVID-19 was a horrifying new disease and we were desperate save lives. However, I recognized that doctors who used unproven treatments like hydroxychloroquine were no different than alternative medicine practitioners, and I wanted no part of that. Learning about the flaws in practices like Shivambu helped me make better choices for my patients – at least I hope so – and I suspect fewer doctors would have used dubious treatments early in the pandemic if they had a better understanding of alternative medicine.
The lessons of skepticism part 5: There is no such thing as a harmless alternative treatment
Another core goal of skepticism is to show that while any individual practice in alternative medicine may be harmless, the overall practice of science-denial is not harmless at all. There is a significant price to be paid when a large percentage of the population lacks the basic scientific knowledge and critical thinking skills needed to evaluate the claims of alternative medicine. The same distorted thinking that allows people to believe in Shivambu often leads them to reject evidence-based treatments such as vaccines, something called crank magnetism. The anti-vaccine movement cannot be disentangled from the seemingly benign treatments in alternative medicine. Believing in “harmless” things is harmless until it leads tens of millions of people to reject vaccines and embrace quack therapies in the middle of a raging pandemic.
As such, skeptics would argue that there’s really no such thing as a “harmless” alternative treatment. Anything that weakens people’s ability to think critically about medicine and health is dangerous. Indeed, wellness influencers who promoted crystal-healing and “clean-eating” in 2019 are comparing vaccines to the Holocaust today, an unholy union of noxious beliefs termed conspirituality.
Skeptics are not surprised by any of this, and many sounded the alarm prior to the pandemic. In a conversation from 2019, Dr. Mark Hoofnagle said, “Science communicators have been warning about the dangers of conspiracy theorists for decades now. AGW, antivax, evolution denial – all the same. Here we are. This is what it looks like when conspiracy theorists take over. They are the worst people.” I agreed and added that “the biggest danger to my kids isn’t the measles, but the thought process that leads people to reject the vaccine in the first place.” Little did we know.
In contrast, our pollyannaish podcasting oncologist actually thought not long ago that children’s “risk of covid will decline precipitously” after “all adults are vaccinated“. Only someone with a complete ignorance of the depths of anti-vaccine sentiment in the US would believe that adult vaccination rates would be high enough to obviate the need to vaccinate children. I was under no such illusions, even before the Delta (let alone omicron) variant arrived.
Rachel Moran, who studies medical misinformation, explained the scope of the problem well when she said,
Medical misinformation doesn’t just result in people making bad personal and community health choices, but it also divides communities and families, leaving an emotional toll. Misinformation narratives have real sticking power and impact people’s ability to make safe health choices.
She’s absolutely right. While there are complicated and varied reasons behind vaccine-refusal, at the end of the day, 1,000 Americans are dying daily because they declined a safe and effective vaccine against a deadly virus. Science denial is a leading cause of death right now, and children have died because their parents declined to have them vaccinated against COVID-19. Skepticism’s detractors survey this carnage and are mostly perturbed that someone might use an hour of their free time to debunk Shivambu.
Prior to the pandemic, several doctors mocked skeptics who discussed topics such as Shivambu. They felt it was a waste of time and easy to do, likening it to dunking on a 7-foot hoop. They felt that warning about bogus cancer cures took time away from more urgent, challenging tasks, such as dunking on bad studies on coffee, Dr. Oz and skeptics, I guess.
I fully agree with skepticism’s critics about one thing however; in one sense, it’s extremely easy to debunk Shivambu. A doctor whose priority is to flaunt his research prowess would not tackle this topic. It takes no special abilities to quickly discover the unsurprising fact that there is no evidence drinking one’s own urine cures cancer. I am certain my teenagers could do this.
However, I do not think my children would be able to communicate about Shivambu in a thoughtful manner to a newly diagnosed cancer patient who had stumbled on to Dr. Brogan’s interview. That’s an entirely different skill set. Moreover, my children would not be able to think deeply about the broader implications of Shivambu. They would not be curious as to why some smart people believe drinking urine cures cancer. They would not be able to place Shivambu into the wider context of the rampant science-denial and institutional mistrust in the world today. They would not be able to link Shivambu to 1,000 people dying everyday of a vaccine-preventable disease, to violence in the anti-vaccine movement, or to an anti-vaccine doctor being arrested for her role in the January 6th insurrection. They wouldn’t be able to see it as a symptom of the dangerous world of alternative facts that has enveloped much our culture, including doctors I’ve discussed before. They wouldn’t grasp that a fantasy world where drinking urine cures cancer is also a world where COVID-19 is a hoax that is cured by ivermectin and there’s no reason to get vaccinated.
It’s good that there are doctors who can see these connections and who care enough to push back against the misinformation that creates such delusions.
The lessons of skepticism part 6: We are all in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops
The skeptic’s final goal is to examine the cognitive flaws and distorted thinking that leads smart people to believe that drinking urine can cure cancer. Dr. Brogan went to MIT where she studied systems neuroscience. She then attended Cornell medical school and graduated NYU residency with me. She’s many things, but she’s not stupid, even though she’s come to believe really stupid things. The skeptic’s aim is therefore not to just understand what is wrong with Shivambu, but also to understand what is wrong with Dr. Brogan. And since we all have cognitive biases and blind spots, we need to understand what is wrong with Dr. Brogan to avoid becoming like Dr. Brogan.
Were skepticism’s detractors to read an article debunking Shivambu, they’d merely see it as an article debunking Shivambu and nothing else. I think these concrete-minded critics missed the larger points skeptics were trying to make, and as a result, they missed out on what skepticism has to offer. Put another way, people who think they’re above learning about 7-foot hoops are in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops.
However, skepticism teaches us that we are all in danger of becoming 7-foot hoops. Unfortunately, it’s easy to find examples of smart people who’ve suffered this fate. Just think about Dr. Oz or Dr. Joseph Ladapo. Pseudoscientific treatments are routinely offered by highly-educated doctors at prestigious medical centers, a sad phenomenon dubbed “quackademic medicine“. Doctors who were widely-admired vaccine advocates prior to the pandemic have since repeatedly minimized the virus and mocked those who, rightly, warned about its dangers, calling them prophets of “doom and fear”. Even brilliant Nobel Prize laureates have claimed that vitamin C was a magic cure-all, that HIV doesn’t cause AIDS, that Black people are less intelligent, that COVID-19 vaccines create new variants, and that COVID-19 was much less dangerous than it was made out to be. Like I said, really smart people can believe really stupid (and horrible) things.
Perhaps because they know they are smart, intelligent people may erroneously feel they are less vulnerable to biased thinking than everyone else. This is itself a bias, one that skeptics are keenly aware of. Almost all skeptics enjoy optical illusions and magic. They love learning how easily we can be fooled, and how we are often completely unaware of it. Dr. Novella called awareness of these vulnerabilities neuropsychological humility and defined it thusly:
Being a functional skeptic requires knowledge of all the various ways in which we deceive ourselves, the limits and flaws in human perception and memory, the inherent biases and fallacies in cognition, and the methods that can help mitigate all these flaws and biases.
Given that no one is immune from biased thinking, we all need to be open to the possibility that we could be wrong. Psychologist Adam Grant shared two wise thoughts on this theme recently.
The hallmark of an open mind is not letting your ideas become your identity. If you define yourself by your opinions, questioning them is a threat to your integrity. If you see yourself as a curious person or a lifelong learner, changing your mind is a moment of growth
It takes humility to consider information that contradicts your opinions. You’re willing to concede that you might be wrong. It takes curiosity to actively seek evidence that challenges your views. You’re eager to find out if you might be wrong.
He’s right. Just because I sanctimoniously boasted that “My loyalty is to a process, not a result” doesn’t mean I’m actually good at that process. I know I’ve fallen short at times.
We all need to be humble and listen to our well-meaning critics. Oftentimes only they can show us our errors. It’s a serious mistake to insulate yourself in an echo chamber of sycophants, dreaming you are persecuted whenever you are contradicted. Oddly enough, Dr. Brogan was on to something – it is very easy to let your beliefs replace facts and science, especially when these beliefs lead to financial rewards, TV appearances, and social media adulation. We all need to be continuously on guard against this.
Richard Feynman famously said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool.” This is the most important lesson skepticism has to offer.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 1
Sadly, several contrarian doctors haven’t grasped skepticism’s lessons, and so they seem to have fallen into the same cognitive traps as Dr. Brogan. They have an almost petulant need to be different, no matter the evidence. One Twitter commentator wryly called this “obligate contrarianism: The need to be contradictory no matter what the mainstream stance is”.
They are hostile to criticism, claiming that anyone who challenges them is trying to “quiet” them. They conflate criticisms of their ideas with personal attacks, and so instead of engaging with those who disagree with them, they ask to be left alone. They brush off all who disagree with them with unsubstantiated accusations of “tribalism” and “groupthink.” They rarely, if ever, admit error, and most tolerate only fawning lickspittles on social media. They mock people who fear or warn of the virus, implying that life is passing them by or that they are addicted to doom and being on TV. Many have repeatedly declared the pandemic over, though they continue to talk about it constantly. They have a shared sense of grievance, believing they are the real victims of this pandemic because YouTube removed some of their videos – and boy do some of them make a lot of videos. At the risk of sounding like a conspiracy theorist myself, several have connections to shady right-wing think tanks.
Like Dr. Brogan, several contrarians started the pandemic with the belief that COVID-19’s harms were greatly exaggerated (here and here), and they’ve spent the past 20 months floundering to justify this initial, flawed premise. One contrarian has peddled identical conspiracy theories as Dr. Brogan, claiming that death certificates have been unreliable this pandemic (in direct contradiction to the evidence), and the COVID-19 death toll is inflated. He wants you to believe many people died with COVID-19, not from COVID-19 and that healthcare workers have perverse financial incentives to put COVID-19 on death certificates. Even worse than this, he repeatedly claimed, again in direct contradiction to the evidence, that doctors killed patients by intubating them too quickly. All this to avoid saying, “I underestimated COVID-19”.
He is not alone. Another noted early in the summer that “cases are FALLING PRECIPITOUSLY” and that for children, “COVID and MIS-C is plummeting with adult vaccination“. He used these numbers to justify his belief that children should not be vaccinated against COVID-19. When cases were at their nadir, he wrote a lengthy piece criticizing the CDC for using outdated numbers when modeling the benefits of the vaccine for adolescents. He called this a “noble lie”. However, when pediatric cases and hospitalizations spiked to their highest levels soon thereafter, he then said that hospitals “admit less sick patients” to for financial gain. Rather than admit that he too had underestimated the virus, he claimed the number of patients hospitalized with COVID-19 is an “inaccurate” metric and is instead merely a “fear monger tactic”. Beyond this, he fantasized that public health measures to contain a virus could one day lead to totalitarianism.
Dr. Brogan wouldn’t object to any of this. She believes the entire pandemic is a fear monger tactic for profit, and that totalitarianism has already arrived, saying COVID-19 was planned for the “entrapment of citizens worldwide.” Their combined message is: Don’t believe news reports of overwhelmed hospitals. Don’t believe what doctors in the trenches are saying. They are out to deceive and scare you for profit. Only I will tell you the truth. Purchase a subscription to my newsletter/online course or pay my speaking fees to gain access to my unique insights.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 2
Nowhere is the overlap between contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan more complete, however, than their shared stance on the risk of COVID-19 to children and whether or not they should be protected against it. There’s no question these contrarian doctors have more in common with her than with the American Academy of Pediatrics, the CDC, and almost every practicing pediatrician in this regard. That says a lot considering Dr. Brogan is a germ-theory denier who does not believe HIV causes AIDS, that SARS-CoV-2 causes COVID-19, or that we are experiencing “a real medical pandemic“.
However, these contrarians and Dr. Brogan all agree that COVID-19 poses minimal-to-no threat to young people and measures to protect them against the virus will likely do more harm than good. They felt this spring that children should not get the COVID-19 vaccine. Once adolescents started getting vaccinated, they felt that “the US should suspend all vaccination in children under 18“. They agreed that “the downsides of masking young students are real“. They agreed that “Children should return to their normal lives this summer and in the upcoming school year, without masks and regardless of their vaccination status“. It’s no surprise that their ideas get favorably shared (here and here) by anti-vaccine cranks like RFK Jr., who posted an article by some of these doctors arguing against the Emergency Use Authorization of the COVID-19 vaccine for most children. Thank goodness no one with real power took that idea seriously.
Highly credentialed doctors from Stanford and Harvard penned Broganesque articles such as “The Ill-Advised Push to Vaccinate the Young“. This article opened by saying:
The idea that everyone must be vaccinated against COVID-19 is as misguided as the anti-vax idea that no one should. The former is more dangerous for public health.
That’s right. These doctors believe the idea of nobody getting vaccinated is better for public health than the idea of everybody getting vaccinated. In the middle of the worst pandemic since 1918, these doctors feel that vaccine-advocates are a greater menace to public health than anti-vaxxers. I’m curious to know what they think the folks at Voices for Vaccines might do that would lead to over 1,000 Americans dying every day for months at a time. That’s the toll of the anti-vaccine movement at present. What great evil do they think Karen Ernst is capable of? She’s always seemed nice to me.
This article also claimed that mandating the vaccine for young people “threatens not only public health but also the future of science“. Elsewhere, one of the authors even spread the absurd myth that vaccine mandates will actually spread the virus. These histrionic, preposterous statements seem plagiarized from the most deranged anti-vaccine websites. Not surprisingly, Dr. Brogan also opposes ‘public health measures imposed in violation of bodily sovereignty (for example, mandated vaccination in exchange for “privileges” which may actually be inalienable rights)’.
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 3
By the time this article was published, hundreds of American children had already died of COVID-19 and many thousands more had been hospitalized. Though I agree that the virus poses an “extremely low” mortality risk for children, millions more children contracted the virus after this article was published, and so hundreds more children died, including some without underlying conditions. Young adults suffered even more. According to the CDC’s Covid Data Tracker, just under 6,000 Americans younger than 29 years have died of COVID-19 thus far, including over 1,000 children. All of these young people died from the virus, not the vaccine.
Tens of thousands more children and young adults have been hospitalized. Though they thankfully survived, many were very sick, needing ICU-level care and mechanical ventilation. Some pediatric COVID-19 survivors suffered strokes or encephalitis. Others needed lung transplants or amputations. Their lives will never be the same. 5,973 children have had MIS-C thus far, though this may be a substantial undercount. In one study, 80% of children with MIS-C went to the ICU and 20% needed mechanical ventilation. 52 children have died of MIS-C. Nearly all these tragedies occurred in unvaccinated people, many after the vaccine was widely available. Thankfully, these tragedies remain very rare. Almost all young people with COVID-19 will be fine.
Fortunately, the vaccine has proven highly effective in keeping adolescents alive and out of the hospital. Hospitals were deluged with children suffering from COVID-19, not side effects from the vaccine. One study found that “Hospitalization rates were 10 times higher among unvaccinated than among fully vaccinated adolescents”. Another study of adolescents showed the efficacy of the vaccine in this age group. It found:
Among 179 COVID-19 case-patients, six (3%) were vaccinated and 173 (97%) were unvaccinated. Overall, 77 (43%) case-patients were admitted to an intensive care unit, and 29 (16%) critically ill case-patients received life support during hospitalization, including invasive mechanical ventilation, vasoactive infusions, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; two of these 29 critically ill patients (7%) died. All 77 case-patients admitted to the intensive care unit, all 29 critically ill case-patients, and both deaths occurred among unvaccinated case-patients.
There’s good news about vaccine-safety as well. Over 7 million doses have been given to children ages 5-11 years, including over 2 million second-doses, and there have been only 8 verified reports of myocarditis so far with 6 more cases under investigation.
In addition to this, evidence continues to accumulate that almost all young people with vaccine-myocarditis have a “mild” course and recover well. Dr. Dongngan T. Truong, who authored a large case series on the topic said “most cases of suspected COVID-19 vaccine-related myocarditis in people younger than 21 are mild and resolve quickly”, though he acknowledged “we are awaiting further studies to better understand the long-term outcomes of patients who have had COVID-19 vaccination-related myocarditis”. The Pfizer vaccine seems safer than the Moderna vaccine for young men, as does using a longer interval between the two vaccine doses. With this knowledge, it’s possible to take a low-risk event and make it even lower. I am aware of literally just one death of a young person (a 22-year-old) in the entire world from the mRNA vaccines. There’s no question that the vaccine is safer than the virus for young people.
Neither Dr. Brogan nor these contrarian doctors want you to know or even believe any of this. Since they only report information that bolsters their preconceived notions, they will never mention most of these facts. If you encounter accurate information elsewhere about pediatric hospitals being overwhelmed with COVID-19 cases, they’ll claim they the numbers are a “fear monger tactic”. If you believe the numbers, they’ll claim that COVID-19 can’t be that bad for kids because it’s worse elderly people (true, but irrelevant), that more children die of suicide (true, but irrelevant), that the flu is worse (false), and that it’s only children with leukemia who are dying (false and repellent). Others have “wondered” whether incompetent pediatricians were misdiagnosing RSV as COVID-19 (they weren’t). Several doctors simply spread wrong blatantly wrong numbers, always minimizing COVID-19’s impact on children, of course. I’ve even seen some contrarians claim that hundreds of dead children from COVID-19 can’t be that bad, because after all, there are 74 million kids in the USA.
What is so different about COVID-19 that makes it so easy for these doctors to brush off the deaths of children? Though almost all children with COVID-19 do well, enough of them have contracted the virus to make it a leading cause of pediatric deaths this year. These tragedies can now be prevented with a vaccine. Imagine if we could prevent suicides, accidents, and drownings with a vaccine. We’d do it, right? However, beyond magically isolating themselves from older people, these doctors don’t want most children to do anything to prevent COVID-19 – no masks, no vaccines, no testing, nothing. Meanwhile, the American Academy of Pediatrics keeps adding 2-3 deaths per day to its grim tally.
Imagine the outrage there’d be if a doctor tried to diminish the tragedies of pediatric cancer the way pediatric COVID-19 deaths are routinely minimized. Imagine if after the next school shooting some doctor pointed out that 99.999% of children won’t die this way, so we shouldn’t do anything to try to prevent these tragedies. Maybe more people need to read about the individual children who have died of COVID-19 (Skylar Herbert, Tagan White, Kimora Lynum, Wyatt Gibson, Zyrin Foots). These were real lives, cut tragically short, not just numbers in a CDC dataset. Their deaths shouldn’t be diminished just because their grandparents were statistically more likely to die. Again, what makes 1,000 pediatric COVID-19 deaths so uniquely tolerable, especially considering the only unique thing about them is they can be now prevented with a vaccine?
Though they claim to be “pro-vaccine“, it seems these contrarians will do anything to avoid acknowledging an obvious truth: COVID-19 can be a devastating, even fatal, disease for a very small percentage of young people, and the vaccine can prevent these tragic outcomes. In contrast, they are extremely eager to discuss vaccine side effects. One doctor even repeatedly mentioned post-vaccination fevers as a reason not to vaccinate children. Just a few short months ago, doctors were arguing in a still unpublished pre-print that the vaccine could cause more harm than the virus for adolescent boys. It’s likely that the number of times they’ve collectively mentioned vaccine-related myocarditis (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here) exceeds the number of children currently hospitalized with the condition. However, since vaccine-related myocarditis almost always has a very favorable clinical course, they are generally only willing to discuss the frequency at which this condition occurs. One doctor even used the death of that single 22-year-old to argue the vaccine could kill as many children as the virus. Studies showing the vaccine’s significant benefits for adolescents are, of course, completely unmentionable.
Because their loyalty is to a result, not a process, these doctors have consistently refused to enumerate the harms of the virus and the benefits of the vaccine. As a result, their writing on COVID-19 and children is uniformly uninformative and devoid of nuance, especially compared to the work of doctors familiar with skepticism and critical thinking. After the Delta variant hospitalized many thousands of children and killed hundreds of them, some contrarians belatedly altered their blanket opposition to vaccinating children, though they did so without acknowledging their previous stance and what role this vocal opposition might have had in creating significant vaccine-hesitancy in parents. However, as with Dr. Brogan, there’s literally no evidence or study that would lead these doctors to conclude it was a mistake to have left tens of millions of young people vulnerable to COVID-19.
After all, if the deaths of thousands of young people, including 1,000 children, doesn’t give them pause, what possibly could?
Contrarian doctors and Dr. Brogan part 4
Though Dr. Brogan and these contrarians have little credibility in the medical community, like alternative treatments, they are not harmless. They have stellar credentials. They all have large audiences. People listen to what they say. They speak without a trace of doubt. They can easily speak in scientific jargon, misrepresenting information to make dangerous ideas sound reasonable to those who are ignorant of the facts.
Their conviction that it was preferable to leave young people vulnerable to COVID-19 convinced politicians like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis to let the virus rip through young people in his state. Dr. Brogan has had more impact at the local level in that state as she influences anti-vaccine schools in Miami. Thanks in part to their combined efforts, children’s hospitals were overwhelmed at the end of this summer. Some children died, including healthy teens who were eligible to be vaccinated. Their ideology also seems to have influenced the UK’s response to vaccinating children, with disastrous consequences I discussed previously.
The doctors are all generally sheltered from the consequences of their words. Dr. Brogan has never cared for a patient hospitalized with COVID-19, and neither have most contrarians. They’ll likely never see a young person gasping for air, regretting their decision not to get vaccinated. The pandemic exists entirely on a computer screen for most of them. Despite this, they remain defiantly proud of their efforts, calling Florida a “success“. It’s frightening to contemplate, but their influence may grow significantly if the political winds blow their way.
I was friendly with Dr. Brogan during her time at NYU. It wasn’t until after she graduated that she decided to reject “facts” and “science as the final objective”. I similarly admired some of these contrarian doctors before the pandemic. Like Dr. Brogan, they aren’t stupid. It’s certainly sad they’ve come to share many of her beliefs on COVID-19 and children. COVID-19 will fade into the background one day, and these contrarians will be remembered only for their poor predictions, vaccine fear mongering, and relentless minimization of virus that was benign for most young people, but because it was encouraged to spread so widely, managed to kill thousands of them and injure many thousands more.
        ◦ Who knows? Maybe they could have avoided this sad fate if only they hadn’t thought it was beneath them to debunk Shivambu.

   SPECT Scans at the Amen Clinic – A New Phrenology?
Harriet Hall 
Link
Phrenology was a 19th century pseudoscience that claimed to associate brain areas with specific personality traits. It was based on palpating bumps on the skull and was totally bogus. New brain imaging procedures are giving us real insights into brain function in health and disease. They are still blunt instruments, and it is easy and tempting to over-interpret what we are seeing. In his book The New Phrenology William Uttal warns that “the excitement of these new research tools can lead to a neuroreductionist wild goose chase” and that we must be careful not to succumb to new versions of the old phrenology.
The Amen Clinics, founded by Daniel G. Amen, MD, offer SPECT (single photon emission computed tomography) scans to help diagnose and manage conditions such as attention deficit disorders (ADD), mood disorders, anxiety and panic disorders, autistic spectrum disorders, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), substance abuse, toxic exposure, brain trauma, memory problems, temper problems, and relationship and marital struggles.
The scans generate colored pictures of the brain that show “areas of your brain that work well, areas that work too hard, and areas that do not work enough.” They do not actually provide a diagnosis, but “must be placed in the context of a person’s life, including their personal history and mental state.” “The goal of treatment is to balance brain function, such as calm the overactive areas and enhance the underactive ones.”
SPECT depicts blood flow or chemical reactions in different areas of the brain. It is invasive and potentially harmful: it requires the injection of a radioactive tracer. Areas of low blood flow show up as apparent “holes” on colored pictures of the brain, giving a moth-eaten appearance. Amen says that when patients improve clinically, the appearance of their follow-up scan typically improves. Patients using marijuana had areas of low activity in the temporal lobes compared to patients not using the drug. Dr. Amen says he can literally show his patients “this is what your brain looks like on drugs.”
In a typical patient with attention deficit disorder, obsessive thinking, anger outbursts, and depression, Amen found demonstrable defects on the initial scan which were visibly improved after three years of clomipramine therapy. He says that this kind of graphic demonstration can help persuade patients that their problem is physical or physiological and might be helped with medication or other treatments. I’m not convinced. Doctors regularly diagnose and treat depression on the basis of clinical symptoms, and both doctors and patients can recognize symptomatic improvement. Do SPECT scans really add anything significant to this process?
Insurance companies consider SPECT scans for diagnosis of psychiatric disorders to be a research tool, an experimental procedure not yet ready for prime time. In my opinion, Amen has jumped the gun by using SPECT scanning clinically before research has validated his methods. He thinks he is helping patients; but without proper controlled studies, he can’t really know for sure. The FDA would never have approved a new medication on the basis of the kind of evidence Amen is going by. We don’t know (1) whether the scans really improve accuracy of diagnosis, (2) whether the defects we see represent causes or results of the illness, (3) what the progressive changes from scan to scan really mean, (4) whether seeing a picture of their brain actually improves patients’ understanding of their disease, (5) whether it improves their compliance with treatment, or (6) whether Amen’s whole process actually improves patient-oriented outcome compared to optimal treatment without scans. Amen is convinced his methods work, because his patients improve, and because they give him grateful feedback and reinforcement. He may be right, or he may be wrong. Quacks all have patients who improve and give them reinforcement too, even for the most nonsensical remedies that can only act as placebos.
The charge is $3250 up front, and most insurance companies will not provide reimbursement because they consider it experimental. There is a 10% discount for testing additional family members. The testing procedure takes four days. The Amen Clinic’s informed consent form is misleading: it does not divulge that the American Psychiatric Association has spoken out against SPECT scanning for these purposes and has warned of potential harm – especially to children, who are more susceptible to the effects of radiation.
Desperate patients will grasp at any straw. There is an argument for offering unproven treatments as a last resort that “might” help. There are also arguments for limiting treatment to closely monitored research settings until the truth is known. There is no excuse for misrepresenting an unproven treatment as a treatment that has been proven effective. And there is no excuse for concealing essential information from patients, or for creating false hopes by implying a promise of more than they can really deliver.
In 2005 I wrote an article for Quackwatch critiquing the Amen Clinic. Amen and his lawyers protested. Dr. Stephen Barrett and I posed specific questions and they attempted to answer them, but we didn’t find their answers satisfactory. Their answers and my comments can be seen at this link.
In one of his books Amen suggests that “Mother Teresa and Mahatma Gandhi had optimal brain function” whereas “Adolph Hitler and other brutal dictators had faulty brain wiring.” The fact that he can make these historical diagnoses without SPECT scans argues against the need for SPECT scanning in his patients. I saw a TV documentary where a teenager was being shown his scan results and was told one area showed that he had difficulty controlling impulses. Why would you need a scan to tell that?
Amen’s website has lots of testimonials from satisfied patients; but he doesn’t tell you about the patients who were dissatisfied, who felt their money was wasted. In one case “nothing that was written or diagnosed actually came from the SPECT image, but from a history taken orally from the family.” A relative of a patient sent me the glossy Amen Clinic brochure that is being handed out at her son’s school. The sender was particularly amused by a set of brain pictures of an “overfocused wife” and an “underfocused husband.” Yes, Amen is using SPECT scans for marital counseling!
Some of the treatments he offers are even more disturbing. Once the pretty pictures have guided him to a diagnosis, Amen recommends a number of questionable treatments, some of which have been tested and found not to work, and many of which are not recommended by science-based medical doctors – such as Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), hyperbaric oxygen therapy, and oral GABA, which is not likely to help with any problems in the brain since it can’t get there: it doesn’t even cross the blood-brain barrier. For “temporal lobe issues” he prescribes phosphatidyl serine, gingko biloba, vitamin E, and ibuprofen. He has his own line of vitamins and diet supplements which are available for purchase on his website. He also sells books and videos, lectures, and has developed his ideas into a big business.
It’s nice to have pretty pictures, and I’m sure they do serve as a visual aid to help doctors engage their patients in appropriate treatment programs. But do they really need those pictures, or is it just something “nice to have” like those ultrasound pictures of fetuses taken with no medical indication, just because parents want to “see” their unborn child? Can Amen really justify what he is doing? Desperate patients are being sold hope at these clinics, at a high price, at a small but real risk, and without any scientific evidence that SPECT improves patient outcome over those who receive optimum treatment without SPECT.
When William Withering wrote his book on foxglove in 1785, he described all his failures along with his successes, and he humbly suggested that “if” his observations were confirmed by others, foxglove “might” become a useful part of standard medical practice. That was the voice of a critical thinker and a true scientist.
There is no suggestion of that kind of caution on Amen’s website. He seems very certain he is right – but lots of people have been equally certain of other things that turned out to be wrong. Humans are very good at fooling themselves, and the only corrective is the scientific method properly applied.
Dr. Amen was recently in the news for advocating SPECT scans for all the presidential candidates. I don’t think I need to explain why that’s a very bad idea.

Cold Water Immersion Not Always Beneficial
Two papers look at the effects of cold water immersion after exercise, with mixed results.
Scott Gavura on April 25, 2024
Link

I live very close to Lake Ontario and I’ve noticed over the past two years that the number of people that are doing morning cold plunges in the lake – throughout the winter – has grown dramatically. It’s no longer an oddity – I see people every single day doing cold plunges, and some are regulars. I’m typically walking the dog bundled up with a coat, hat and gloves, and right beside me, people are stripping down and taking cold plunges, usually in groups.
Cold therapy, which advocates believe can boost the immune system, enhance cardiovascular health, and is just a tough thing to do, has been growing in popularity. Back in 2021, the late Harriet Hall wrote about Wim Hof, the Dutch athlete famous for his ability to tolerate extreme cold temperatures, and one of the most well known proponents of this activity. His Wim Hof Method® says you’ll be “happier, healthier, and stronger” with his method of hyperventilation, cold plunges and “commitment”. Harriet’s conclusion at the time was that while this practice could conceivably reduce inflammation, it would be limiting a “normal protective response that promotes healing.” She concluded that most of Hof’s claims were speculation, and not supported by evidence.
Since Harriet’s post, cold plunges seem to have increased in popularity, and more evidence has emerged on the merits of this therapy. With respect to exercise, its benefits are not so clear cut.
First of all, it should be obvious that you can’t do a double-blind randomized controlled trial with cold therapy. While researchers have tried to examine objective measures, the subjective is harder to assess. If you simply like to do cold plunges because it makes you feel good/tough/alive/strong – then have at it. There’s no evidence that I can present that’s going to confirm or refute how cold bathing makes you feel by doing it.
I should also point out that the trials I found focused primarily on cold baths and did not appear to include the hyperventilation that Hof advocates as part of his method. So this is less a review of Hof’s specific recommendations, but of the act of cold plunges/cold water immersion.
It’s worth summarizing what actually happens physiologically when you immerse your body in cold water. A sudden plunge can lead to the cold shock response: a rapid increase in breathing, heart rate and blood pressure which can place stress on the heart, even causing heart attacks. Within minutes, the loss of heat from the body can start to cause other problems. Blood will move from the extremities to the core to protect vital organs. Hypothermia can result. These effects can be mitigated or delayed in part through training over time – but the heat loss from the body is inevitable – it’s physics. (It should be noted that deaths have been attributed to Hof’s approach and cold plunge therapy.)
Effects on exercise recovery
Russian and Chinese researchers completed a meta-analysis looking specifically at fatigue recovery. Twenty studies were analyzed, including some randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Cold water immersion was defined as immersion in water at ≤15°C (59℉). Control groups would typically rest, with no cold immersion. They looked at measures of recovery from high-intensity exercise (e.g., rugby, football) after 0, 24 and 48 hours. Ratings of perceived exertion, delayed-onset muscle soreness (DOMS), and countermovement jump test results, as well as blood markers of exercise recovery were also examined.
The analysis found that cold water immersion reduced DOMS at 0 hours and 24 hours, but not at 48 hours. Ratings of perceived exertion and countermovement jump were improved at 0 hours, but not subsequently. Some lab measures improved (that is, they were reduced) but others were not affected. A subgroup analysis showed that colder water (<10°C (<59℉)) was more effective than ≥10°C, in improving countermovement jump, but had no effect on other measures, like fatigue recovery. There was also no difference noted between partial plunges (waist) to full plunges (shoulders). The authors concluded that immersion in cold water immediately after exercise improved subjective symptoms such as muscle soreness and could accelerate recovery. However, because the quality of the trials was poor (which was acknowledged by the authors), it’s reasonable and prudent to consider these findings as interesting but not conclusive.
Effects on muscle growth
Another meta-analysis examined effects of cold water immersion on muscle growth in subjects that were doing resistance (strength) training. Eight studies were included, with studies ranging 4-12 weeks and adults (almost all males) aged 20-26. Some trials uses untrained volunteers, others used those accustomed to resistance training. Studies looked at different measures of strength, including handgrip strength, wrist flexors, but also lower body and whole body workouts.
All studies used post-exercise cold water immersion – with some exposing upper or lower limbs, and some using whole-body immersion. Water temperatures were 10–15℃ (50–59℉), and the duration of immersion was 10-20 minutes.
Muscle size was assessed using different imaging techniques but also biopsy and also limb circumference.
The study fond that cold water therapy combined with resistance training had less muscle gain (hypertrophy), compared to resistance training alone. The supports the hypothesis that cold water immersion may be blunting or attenuating the inflammatory response, which reduces muscular adaptation – and ultimately, fewer gainz.
Inflammation isn’t all bad
Cold water plunges may seem trendy and may even feel subjectively good, but that doesn’t mean that health benefits are a certainty. For those that exercise, it’s important to remember that the benefits of your workout are realized during the recovery period. Hard workouts can be painful, through damage to tissues that prompt the body to remodel and strengthen itself for the next workout. Inflammation is an expected (and desirable) result, even if it is painful. Blocking the inflammation process, which cold plunges appear to do, may delay that recovery and adaptation process. When rapid recovery is the priority, cold baths may be worthwhile and subjectively beneficial. When growth in muscle size is sought, cold therapy’s benefits are less clear.

   The Water Cure: Another Example of Self Deception and the “Lone Genius”
Harriet Hall
Link
A correspondent wrote:
I hear all day long on my local radio station commercials for The Water Cure, which was created by a Dr. Batmangelli (I have no idea how to spell his name) promising wonderful cures by eliminating caffeine and alcohol and drinking water and sprinkling sea salt on your food. If you REALLY want to get cured even faster, swim in the ocean everyday.
That’s Dr. Fereydoon Batmanghelidj. His Big Idea was that dehydration is the main cause of disease. It was untenable to begin with, is supported by no evidence, was debunked on Quackwatch several years ago, and Dr. Batmanghelidj died in 2004, so I was surprised to hear it was still being vigorously promoted. But not very surprised. After all, homeopathy is still around.
The Water Cure is another in a long list of alleged miracle cures discovered by “lone geniuses” who are allegedly persecuted by a resistant medical establishment. These stories follow a pattern, and I think it is worthwhile looking at this prime example to understand something of the psychology of self-deception that is involved.
How It All Started
Dr. Batmanghelidj was imprisoned for political crimes in Tehran’s infamous Evin prison. A number of his fellow prisoners had previously been diagnosed with peptic ulcer disease (PUD). Their symptoms recurred in jail and didn’t respond to Cimetidine and antacids. Dr. Batmanghelidj gave a prisoner with unbearable pain two glasses of water. The pain disappeared completely after 8 minutes.
He treated other PUD patients with remarkable success. One patient was semiconscious from pain but after drinking water he recovered in 20 minutes. (One wonders about the wisdom of making a semiconscious patient drink, since there is a risk of aspiration). Patients were advised to continue drinking 1500cc of water daily for 6 weeks, allowing time for the average ulcer to heal. Symptoms did not recur.
During treatment, urine volume increased and patients had to get up at night to pee. Dr. Batmanghelidj assumed this meant that they were losing sodium so he added salt to their treatment regimen.
It seems logical that drinking water would dilute the stomach acid and provide some temporary relief. In a majority of patients the relief of pain was preceded by eructation of gas. Hmmm… For some reason, Batmanghelidj decided that the real problem was dehydration: dehydration was the sole cause of pain so the pain was relieved by drinking water.
Dr. Batmanghelidj eventually got out of prison and came to the US, where he developed his ideas further and wrote a series of books. His philosophy expanded. Although water alone had worked for his initial patients, he added salt (without any comparison studies to show it improved outcome) and then declared that it should be sea salt to supply trace minerals (again with no comparison studies). He recommends Himalayan or Celtic sea salt (!?) Rather than adding salt to your food or water, you should let it dissolve on your tongue (Why?). If you are urinating within 2 hours of drinking water, you should eat bagels to help keep the water in your body long enough for it to work. This is referred to as “Bagel Magic.”
He spoke out against alcohol, caffeine, and anything else that might contribute to dehydration. He expanded his thinking to include acidity and immunology:
the causes of most so-called incurable diseases are nothing but symptoms of a weak immune system caused by consuming caffeine, alcohol and/or soda and lack of water and/or salt. They create an acid pH and the more acidic it is, the weaker your immune system, the worse your health becomes and the more difficult it is for your body to repair itself.
He claims the water cure will:
     1.  Prevent and reverse premature aging
     2.  Eliminate pain, including heartburn, back pain, arthritis, colitis, angina, and migraine headaches
     3.  Cure asthma in a few days, naturally and forever
     4.  Cure hypertension without diuretics or other medications
     5.  Lose weight effortlessly and naturally, without strict dieting
He suggests that water is a no-cost solution to heart disease. But that’s not all! His websites include testimonials from patients who were allegedly cured of:
Terminal Cancer – Diabetes – Herniated Discs – Chronic Pain – Depression – Fibromyalgia – Suicidal Tendencies – Edema – Acid Reflux – Watering Eyes – Hiccups – Pet Arthritis – Asthma – Syncope – Migraines – Chronic Fatigue – Bronchitis – Vision – Raccoon Eyes – Energy – Skin Ailments – Dizziness – Allergies – Diabetes – Eye Edema – Herpies [sic] – Weight Loss – Leukemia
Where’s the Evidence?
The Water Cure website provides a list of scientific documents. Most of them are opinion pieces written by Batmanghelidj himself in a journal he established himself and self-published for three years (Science in Medicine Simplified) because he couldn’t get published in reputable journals.
Batmanghelidj claims to have done a lot of research, but he hasn’t. All he has done is theorize and speculate. He has only two listings in PubMed for articles published in peer-reviewed journals.
The first was published in 1983 in The Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology. It is not a scientific study, but an “editorial” that describes his experiences with patients in the prison. It is an anecdotal account that doesn’t even rise to the level of case reports or case series. He says he treated 3000 patients with PUD, and his account suggests that about a third of all prisoners had PUD, which seems a bit high even considering the stress of prison. These diagnoses were clinical diagnoses: in other words, completely unreliable. It is impossible to differentiate peptic ulcers from non-ulcer dyspepsia or other conditions without an endoscopy or an imaging procedure. He says he also successfully treated a few cases of “appendix pain” (whatever that means) and from that he concludes that “a site of pain other than epigastric may herald a clinical picture of duodenal ulcer disease.” This leaves me at a loss for words.
The second article, published in Anticancer Research in 1987, is a speculative rumination calling for a paradigm change in thinking about pain. It claims that pain is a signal system denoting free water deficiency of the cell. It is poorly written and doesn’t make sense to me. For instance, he says that this new paradigm does not apply to conditions with local tissue pathology, like cholecystitis. But peptic ulcers are local tissue pathology. Why should the water cure work for ulcers but not for cholecystitis? Bizarrely, he ends his article with an acknowledgement thanking the Almighty for his light and fine detailed guidance.
Batmanghelidj’s Other Weird Ideas
In an interview with Mike Adams he made a series of very questionable statements:
“thirst in the body can manifest itself in the form of abdominal pain to the level that the person can even become semi-conscious.”
“water shortage is actually the background to most of the health problems in our society.”
He claims that histamine regulates the water in the body and that antidepressant drugs are antihistamines, pain medications are antihistamines, and other medications are directly and indirectly antihistamines.
“the whole entire existence of the pharmaceutical industry is based on presentation of false science”
“we measure the level of cholesterol in the body in the blood we take out of the veins of the body, and nowhere in the history of medicine is there recorded one single case of cholesterol ever having blocked the veins of the body.”
“a lot of children who drink soft drinks actually become ‘stupid’, but once you take the soft drink away from them, their grades improve tremendously — C’s and F’s become A’s and B’s.”
This kind of thing is bad enough, but he really loses it when he descends into AIDS denialism:
… everyone assumes that AIDS is actually a viral disease, which is a fraudulent statement by those people who presented it, because the human body is the product of many, many years of having fought various viral diseases, and has survived. Smallpox, polio, measles, and all the other viruses that can kill very easily, and the body has an ability to mount a defense system against these hot viruses, viruses that actually very quickly can kill. But having survived those, how is it possible that the slow virus would kill us in the name of AIDS? I can’t understand it.
I have researched this topic extensively, and I have shown in fact that AIDS is a metabolic problem, when the body begins to cannibalize its own tissue because of certain missing elements in the raw materials that it receives through food or beverages, and the body of a person who gets AIDS, actually, is short of quite a number of building block amino acids. They’re short of tyrosine, they’re short of methionine, cysteine, they’re short of histidine, and they’ve got a whole lot of others in excess. So how can we expect a body that depends on the other amino acids to survive?
Elsewhere he has claimed that water is one of the main sources of energy for the brain and the entire body and that it produces “hydro-electric” energy by splitting into hydrogen and oxygen!
How Do Intelligent People Go Wrong?
Dr. Batmanghelidj follows a well-beaten path. From chiropractic to eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR), innumerable non-science-based practitioners have gone down this same slippery slope. Here is the typical progression from initial self-deception to “lone genius” woomeister status:
     1.  He witnesses an unexpected improvement after a treatment.
     2.  He assumes the treatment caused the improvement.
     3.  He does not test this assumption or try to rule out other possible explanations.
     4.  He proceeds to treat many other patients the same way, with apparent success, and allows confirmation bias to bolster his conviction.
     5.  His ego is boosted by grateful patients and by the conviction that he has special knowledge.
     6.  He extends the treatment to patients with other diagnoses.
     7.  He exercises his imagination and speculates about a possible physiological mechanism by which the treatment might work.
     8.  He generalizes, often claiming to have found the “one cause of all disease.”
     9.  He tries to convince scientists by describing his anecdotal experiences.
     10.  The scientists refuse to accept his untenable explanations or to publish his scientifically unacceptable papers.
     11.  He accuses the scientific establishment of persecuting him and suppressing knowledge that would undermine the status quo and help many patients.
     12.  He plays the lone genius card, often comparing himself to Galileo or Semmelweis.
     13.  He writes books and sells things.
For Batmanghelidj the epiphany was a glass of water that apparently relieved a stomach pain. For D. D. Palmer (chiropractic) it was a back adjustment that apparently restored a deaf janitor’s hearing. For Samuel Hahnemann (homeopathy) it was the supposedly malaria-like symptoms he experienced after taking an anti-malaria drug. For Francine Shapiro (EMDR) it was the observation during a walk in a park that moving her eyes seemed to reduce the stress of disturbing memories. For Edward Bach (Bach Flower Remedies), a walk in the country revealed his intuitive psychic connection to various plants.
The initial error was the same in all cases: they failed to consider the possibility that they might be wrong. They failed to use the scientific method to test their observations. The rest of the sequence followed naturally from human psychology. The Water Cure is nonsense, but its story provides a cautionary tale. The most important thing a scientist can say is “I could be wrong.”

The Evidence for Hydrogen Water
Alex Tarnava sells Drink HRW Rejuvenation tablets. The evidence for the health benefits of drinking hydrogen water is not convincing.
Harriet Hall on October 6, 2020
Link


I am always ready to follow the evidence wherever it leads, but it has to be good evidence. Good scientists do experiments to find out “if” a treatment is effective; but a lot of poor science and pseudoscience is done by people who already “know” the treatment they are using is effective and are looking for evidence that will prove to others that they are right. I frequently write about the claims for dietary supplements, devices, and other questionable treatments. The satisfied users and true believers can’t understand why I don’t recommend their favorite treatment. They send me emails with links to studies. They seem to think that if only I would look at their “evidence”, I would change my mind and become a believer. They can’t understand why the evidence they found so convincing would fail to convince me.
A rebuttal of my article
Last year I wrote about hydrogen water. I reviewed the evidence and concluded that it hadn’t established that hydrogen water was any healthier than regular water. Alex Tarnava disagreed with what I wrote. He published this rebuttal. He called my piece “incredibly poorly written”. He accused me of incompetent research. He thought I had just read his ads, regurgitated a FOX News article, failed to review the literature, and hadn’t even looked at Wikipedia. Those accusations are all false. It’s easy enough to compare my article to the FOX article: there’s no “regurgitation” to be found.
As for the Wikipedia article, it pretty much agrees with what I wrote. It concludes:
There is so far a lack of scientific consensus concerning the evidence that hydrogen has health benefits in humans. A few articles have been published on the topic, but the clinical literature is sparse and what has been published covers many conditions, but not multiple trials of any one condition. Hydrogen water proponents claim that it has health benefits such being an antioxidant, reducing inflammation, reducing risk of metabolic syndrome, providing neuroprotection for various diseases, and reducing side effects associated with cancer radiation treatment. But none of the published articles concerning these claims are systematic reviews or meta-analyses and very little work has been done in animals.
Tarnava is not content to just criticize me; he goes on to criticize the Science-Based Medicine blog, Skeptics Guide to the Universe, and skeptics in general. And he goes on to provide a data dump of human studies. A few of them are labeled as having studied OUR TABLETS, but a lot of them were studies where hydrogen was inhaled, infused, or applied to the skin, so they are not really relevant. And many of the studies lacked an appropriate control group. The great majority of the human studies looked at biomarkers rather than at POEMS (Patient-Oriented Evidence that Matters). I don’t want to know whether hydrogen water makes the blood tests look prettier; I want to know if it produces any clinically significant health benefits.
His list includes two studies of rheumatoid arthritis (RA); there have only been two human studies of RA. The first is a study of infused hydrogen, so it doesn’t tell us anything about drinking hydrogen water. The second was an open-label pilot study of patients with RA. There were only 20 subjects, no control group, and no blinding. Subjects were given high H2 water (4-5 PPM of hydrogen), and were aware of what they were drinking. They found statistically significant reductions in measures of oxidative stress; and amazingly, all five of the patients who had early RA without antibodies against cyclic citrullinated peptides achieved remission, and four of them became symptom-free. The authors concluded, “The results suggest [emphasis added] that the hydroxyl radical scavenger H2 effectively reduces oxidative stress in patients with this condition. The symptoms of RA were significantly improved with high H2 water”.
Anything that produces remissions in 100% of RA patients and relieves all symptoms in 80% would be front-page headlines for rheumatologists and they would all be recommending it; but I find it hard to believe. My crystal ball predicts that future researchers will fail to get such great results.
Tarnava and his claims
Who is Tarnava? He has no medical or scientific background. He runs the spiffy DRINK HRW website and sells Drink HRW Rejuvenation tablets. You are supposed to dissolve the tablets in a glass of water, wait 1-2 minutes, and then drink the water immediately. It ain’t cheap: the tablets cost around a dollar each. He claims that his product supplies more hydrogen than any other product, with a peak concentration of 7.4 PPM. The benefits claimed include:
    • Improving athletic performance and recovery
    • Supporting a healthy redox, the harmony between our natural antioxidant defense and beneficial oxidative species
    • Supporting a healthy inflammatory response
    • Supporting our body’s resilience to a wide array of stresses
    • Delivering 80mg of highly bioavailable magnesium per tablet
He also sells other products such as Hydrogen Beauty Tablets, a Rejuvenation + Essentials bundle, fish oil, vitamin D, and caffeine and creatine supplements.
Two new studies
An email correspondent wrote me about a friend of hers who bought an expensive machine to make his own hydrogen water at home and sent her this updated information. It was a link to an article in Scientific Reports, an online open-access journal from the publishers of Nature. The study was randomized, double-blind, and placebo-controlled. It compared two groups of healthy Korean adults: 20 who drank hydrogen water for four weeks and 18 who drank plain water. They measured several biomarkers. Biological antioxidant potential (BAP) was not significantly different in the two groups, but subgroup analysis detected an increased BAP in the hydrogen water group for subjects under the age of 30. They found less apoptosis, fewer CD14+ cells, and more down-regulation of transcriptional networks in the hydrogen water group. Will those changes result in significantly improved clinical outcomes? We have no way of knowing. They concluded, “These finding suggest [emphasis added] HW increases antioxidant capacity thereby reducing inflammatory responses in healthy adults”.
The believer in hydrogen water followed up with a second new study. It was a randomized controlled trial of 60 people in India who met at least 3 out of the 5 criteria for metabolic syndrome. It found that supplementing with high-concentration hydrogen water for 24 weeks resulted in significantly reduced blood cholesterol and glucose levels, attenuated serum hemoglobin A1c, and improved biomarkers of inflammation and redox homeostasis as compared to placebo (P < 0.05). Furthermore, H2 tended to promote a mild reduction in body mass index and waist-to-hip ratio. The authors noted that their results were consistent with the results of some animal studies but differed from the results of some other human studies. They said, “a larger prospective clinical trial is warranted”. It’s hard to know what to make of their results, but I think it would be unwise to make too much of it unless the results can be corroborated by other researchers and in other populations.
Biomarkers can be misleading. Homocysteine is a prime example. Elevated homocysteine is thought to be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, so it seemed logical that lowering it would reduce the risk. Treatment with B vitamins effectively lowered homocysteine blood levels, but it didn’t reduce risk. A Cochrane systematic review concluded that lowering homocysteine did not prevent heart attacks or reduce death rates.
Conclusion: the evidence is not convincing
Researchers are continuing to evaluate the possible health advantages of drinking hydrogen water, and some of their preliminary results look promising. I will keep an open mind and stay tuned, but we know that promising small preliminary studies tend not to pan out. Meanwhile, I am not convinced by the evidence. I see no reason to buy expensive tablets or invest in a machine to produce hydrogen at home.

Bleaching away what ails you: The Genesis II Church is still selling Miracle Mineral Supplement as a cure-all
Miracle Mineral Supplement (MMS) has been sold by the Genesis II Church of Health and Healing as a cure-all to treat conditions and diseases as diverse as autism, cancer, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, and malaria. Indeed, it’s touted as a cure for nearly all disease. It is, however, basically industrial bleach. As ridiculous and harmful as MMS is, it’s a quackery that just won’t die, as I realized this weekend reading stories about a promotional seminar for MMS in Washington.
David Gorski on April 22, 2019
Link

Last week, I noted that I’m back after a nearly three week hiatus for a little cervical spine surgery. This week, I’m forced to note that something else is back. No, that’s not correct. It actually never went away, but it’s making the news again. I decided to write about it again (1) because it’s been a long time since it’s been covered on SBM and (2) it’s a good example of how many forms of quackery, no matter how ridiculous, never go away regardless of negative news coverage, evidence, or even prosecution. I’m referring to the so-called “Miracle Mineral Supplement” (MMS, often also called Miracle Mineral Solution), or, as we like to call it here at SBM, a form of industrial bleach. Thanks to a man named Jim Humble and his Genesis II Church of Health and Healing, bleach is sold as a treatment and cure for autism and a number of other diseases, including HIV/AIDS. It’s a treatment that the FDA has issued warnings about, starting in 2010, and for which one of the most notorious sellers of MMS, Louis Daniel Smith, was convicted of conspiracy, smuggling, selling misbranded drugs, and defrauding the United States.
Let’s back up a bit. There are some forms of quackery that I’ve never been able to understand, quackery that is so bizarre, so without a reasonable scientific rationale, and so potentially harmful that it boggles my mind that anyone would ever think it is a good idea. MMS is just such a treatment, and I first took note of it nearly nine years ago. Mind bogglingly, MMS is a form of bleach. Specifically, it is, in essence, industrial strength bleach, 28% sodium chlorite in distilled water. It is frequently diluted in acidic juices, such as orange juice, resulting in the formation of chlorine dioxide, which is, as the FDA characterized it, “a potent bleach used for stripping textiles and industrial water treatment”. According to its proponents, MMS can cure almost anything: cancer, AIDS, and just about any other serious disease you can imagine. Never mind that there is no biological plausibility and no evidence, either preclinical or clinical, that MMS can do what its proponents claim it can do. True, bleach can kill bacteria or cancer cells in a dish at a high enough concentration, but that doesn’t mean it’s a useful antibiotic or chemotherapeutic agent. Feeding autistic children bleach or, even worse, subjecting them to bleach enemas, is horrifying—and, yes, this is really a thing. There are quacks out there, in particular Kerri Rivera, who advocates diluting MMS and giving it to autistic children, both orally and in the form of an enema, to treat their autism. Before she agreed to sign an assurance of voluntary compliance under which she was barred in Illinois from selling MMS or similar substances to Illinois residents and presenting at future Illinois conferences concerning the use of such substances to treat autism, Rivera was a regular fixture at the Autism One quackfest in Chicago for multiple years. She is, however, still selling MMS in Mexico.
So imagine my distress when I saw a post by Hemanta Mehta and a story in The Guardian on Friday informing me of this:
A group calling itself Genesis II Church of Health and Healing plans to convene at a hotel resort in Washington state on Saturday to promote a “miracle cure” that claims to cure 95% of all diseases in the world by making adults and children, including infants, drink industrial bleach.
The group is inviting members of the public through Facebook to attend what they call their “effective alternative healing” at the Icicle Village Resort in Leavenworth on Saturday morning. The organizer of the event, Tom Merry, has publicized the event on his personal Facebook page by telling people that learning how to consume the bleach “could save your life, or the life of a loved one sent home to die”.
The “church” is asking attendants of the meeting to “donate” $450 each, or $800 per couple, in exchange for receiving membership to the organization as well as packages of the bleach, which they call “sacraments”. The chemical is referred to as MMS, or “miracle mineral solution or supplement”, and participants are promised they will acquire “the knowledge to help heal many people of this world’s terrible diseases”.
Since Saturday was two days ago, I looked around for any reports of what happened. I found a brief announcement of the event, which took place in Leavenworth, WA, on the Genesis II website, but not a lot else. I also note that the event page in Facebook linked to above is no longer there. In addition, there’s apparently another seminar scheduled for August 17 in Eden, NY. On the church’s official Facebook page, however, it’s not difficult to find ads for something called the G2 Sacramental Kit:
As an aside, if you peruse the Genesis II official Facebook page, you’ll find all manner of quackery, including functional medicine, antivaccine tirades, anti-GMO pseudoscience, anti-fluoridation fear mongering, and, of course, an ad for a “documentary” lauding the church as having found in MMS the cure to 97% of disease:
And here’s the trailer:
In the trailer, a man claims that a small band (the “church”) has found the cure for “pretty much every disease” that afflicts humans but that is—of course!—being suppressed. There’s a clip of Jim Humble calling diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, and diabetes “fake” and “made up” diseases.
Unfortunately, this “church” is using religion to disguise its quackery as a “sacrament”. On the website, the link to Genesis II founder Jim Humble’s book of MMS protocols is described as “Health Sacramental MMS Protocols,” and MMS providers are described under lists entitled First G2 Sacrament Provider and All G2 Sacrament Providers. Under the latter link, there are listed “sacrament providers” all over the world, including in Africa, Europe, South America, the Philippines, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the US. Particularly odd is Genesis2Church Chapter 321 in Arizona:
Genesis2Church Chapter #321
Website: https://www.discovermms.comEmail: [email protected]Sacraments: MMS, HCL 4%, CA 50%, CDS, MMS2, DMSO, Calcium bentonite clay,Diatomaceous earth, Sodium chlorite flakes, Test strips, Plastic bottles, Empty CapsulesShips: Worldwide
If you go to the link, you’ll see MMS/CDS described as “CDC water purification drops”, which is amusing because that’s what CDS is actually used for in industry. If you follow a link to one of the MMS providers, Atlantis Healing Center, you’ll find the uproarious line, “MMS Sacraments Are Now Available in Discount Bulk Packs”.
Every few years, it’s worth explaining what MMS is and why it’s still sold; and this resurrection of the topic in international news presents the perfect opportunity, particularly since I didn’t bite (at least not here) last year when a father in Indianapolis accused his wife of giving their child MMS.
MMS: Bleaching away disease?
Because I’m most familiar with her and her quackery, I’ll discuss it mainly (but not exclusively) in the context of Kerri Rivera’s protocols. To the best of my knowledge, advocacy for using MMS, either orally or by enema or both, first bubbled up from the underground autism “biomed” quackery movement around 2010 or so. However, it was at the 2012 edition of the yearly Chicago antivaccine autism quackfest known as Autism One, Kerri Rivera gave a talk touting how she supposedly “recovered” 38 autistic children in 20 months. At the time, Rivera was running a clinic in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico that she called AutismO2 Clinica Hyperbarica. Unsurprisingly, the website is no longer there. Fortunately, the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org provides the now defunct material we’re interested in under “Protocolos”. Conveniently, it provides versions of the protocols in both English and Spanish.
It’s been a long time since I discussed this, so I thought I’d go over Rivera’s protocols as shown in her archived slides. Much of them parrot the same sort of nonsense that antivaxers like to parrot, for instance, a model in which “toxins”, diet, genetics, and antibiotics “load the gun.” There’s also a bit about “biofilms there” too. There’s a mention of chelation therapy. Amusingly (and horrifyingly), near the beginning, there’s this:
MMS/FDA
    • The most powerful killer of pathogens known to man. It has been used in stockyards to kill pathogens on meat, and on slaughtered chickens; it has been used to sterilize hospital floors and benches and to kill pathogens in water works without killing friendly bacteria for over 70 years.
    • Now this same formula is used in the body, and the same situation results. No damage is done to the body, but the pathogens are destroyed. In its powerful form, MMS is chlorine dioxide that reverts back to harmless chloride and neutralized oxygene. It leaves nothing behind to build up.
Because industrial bleach is just what you want to ingest or feed to your child.
It doesn’t get any better. Later, there is a slide that reads:
My journey through MMS
With the idea of virus in the brain, I visited Google University in July 2010 after a friend began doing Goldberg’s protocol with no improvement. But, I really think that he is onto something. Goldberg and Usman for me are the 2 people curing autism for obvious reasons, and they are both thinking pathogens first.
MMS kills virus, bacteria, candida, neutralizes metals, and MMS passes through the Blood Brain Barrier. What more do we need?
How about a plausible scientific rationale plus evidence of safety? I note that this is the same rationale for using colloidal silver: It kills pathogens on surfaces and the skin very well, and indeed silver does. That’s why it’s in a variety of antimicrobial salves used to treat burns. It’s just not possible to get it into the bloodstream at a high enough concentration to do the same there, although it is possible with prolonged use to turn someone blue.
In any case, much of the rest includes pretty standard-issue chelation therapy quackery. As you may recall, chelation therapy is a quack therapy used in autism that presumes that autism is due to “heavy metal toxicity”. Chelating agents bind to heavy metals and facilitate their excretion in the urine. Unfortunately, among the heavy metals removed are calcium and magnesium, and lowering levels of those two metals too much can result in cardiac arrhythmias and death. This is not a theoretical danger.
Then there’s the MMS protocol grafted on to some standard issue autism quackery:
    • 10-15 drops MMS enabled and 500 mL water
    • In the colon for 12 – 30 minutes
    • Use pipette and syringe
    • Is applied 2 or 3 times per week
It goes beyond that, though. I’ve noted in the past that proponents of MMS not only give MMS to autistic children orally, but that some even bath them in it, and, of course, Rivera advocated enemas with it. Rivera advocated continually upping the dose. She even discussed the potential adverse reactions. A long time ago, I remember seeing a video (that I unfortunately can no longer locate) in which Rivera discussed how autistic children might get diarrhea from the MMS, but how that was OK as long as it was “detox diarrhea”. She even likened the reaction she expected to a Herxheimer reaction, which is sometimes seen after the initiation of antibacterials for tick-borne relapsing fever. It was first described as a reaction to the treatment of syphilis with penicillin and is also seen after treatment of other diseases caused by spirochetes, such as Lyme disease and leptospirosis. Basically, this reaction is due to the release of endotoxin-like products by microorganisms as they die off during antibiotic treatment. Rivera also discussed what she referred to as the “72-2” protocol, which involves giving MMS every two hours for 72 hours. She also recommended “fever therapy” and argued that it’s a good thing that MMS can cause fevers because it’s “waking up the immune system” which realizes that there’s “autism in the house.” She also exulted about how she “loves the enemas” so much for autism.
Shockingly, Rivera’s slides from the 2012 Autism One quackfest are still on the website. They make for some bizarre reading. I do have to admit to some amusement, though, at Rivera’s choice of closing quote:
“Miracles happen every day. Not just in remote country villages or at holy sites halfway across the globe, but here, in our own lives.” – Deepak Chopra.
Yes, that seems appropriate. It is also appropriate that apparently (as I just learned yesterday) Facebook has finally shut down Rivera’s page:
6 years campaigning against BLEACH witch Rivera and FB has finally shut her down.Even her personal page has been removed.Screenshot is latest video of her crying about FB booting her.Well done to all who campaign with me, Autistic kids are safer now.Be proud ❤ #ENDMMSABUSE pic.twitter.com/PasRqoRSdl
— Fiona Pettit O'Leary (@fionapettit71) April 21, 2019
Well done, indeed, Ms. O’Leary.
One of the most common claims made by Jim Humble and his disciples is that MMS is perfectly safe and causes zero or minimal side effects. My perusal of the autism biomed underground on social medial has shown me otherwise.
MMS: Case reports
Just how nasty MMS can be when administered to children can be appreciated if you read the story of a mother subjecting her child to Kerri’s MMS protocol, including both oral ingestion of MMS and MMS enemas. It’s six years old, but oddly enough it’s still on the web. The introduction sets the background. The boy’s name was Jojo, and he was then nearly eleven. He had been diagnosed with autism when he was three years old, and his mother had subjected him to “autism biomed” interventions since December 2005, beginning because, as she put it, “I decided to give it a go because my mother’s instinct told me that Jojo suffers from egregious tummy problems.”
So apparently Jojo underwent a wide variety of “autism biomed” woo over the last seven or eight years before the events of the blog, but in March 2013 the “biomed” treatment took a turn to the terrifying when Jojo’s mother discovered MMS and began to follow Kerri Rivera’s MMS protocol:
Jojo is given 1 oz of the mixture hourly, so effectively he is getting 1/8th of a drop each time. His first dose was given after school at 1 pm. He is now given 8 doses only although my reading tells me that it is a minimum. I suppose I could increase up to 9-12 doses a day but I’m kinda leery of the possible increase in die-off effects too.
As well she should have been leery, but apparently not leery enough not to undertake biomedical quackery. Even as early as day 1, she noted Jojo running a low-grade fever and coughing, which, of course, could simply have been a coincidence. Similarly, she also noted JoJo to have increased hyperactivity, which could very easily have been due to confirmation bias. By day 2, Jojo continued to have fever, and his cough got worse. Somehow, his mother came to believe that “coughing after taking MMS could be due to parasites in the lung dying,” as incredible as it might be that anyone would believe something like that. Later entries describe Jojo developing constipation, and, when that resolved, his mother thinking that parasites were coming out in his stool. It is a theme that continues through the rest of the blog, as Jojo develops diarrhea, languor, and flareups of his chronic eczema (blamed on parasites, of course).
Finally, Jojo’s mother decides that he needs to have MMS enemas after having had a text message exchange with Kerri Rivera. Jojo’s mother tells Rivera that he is constipated, and Rivera responds:
Do an enema. There is probably a worm in his intestine. And give more MMS doses orally if he is awake. More MMS now, please.
So Jojo’s mother did just that and administered the first enema on day 7.
So what happened? Here, it’s very useful to compare the claims of someone like Kerri Rivera to those of quacks selling “liver flushes” that are touted as causing one to pass gallstones out into the stool . The very first example of this can be found in an entry called Worm. Here’s where the gross pictures begin. (I’ll save you from having to look at them unless you want to by not embedding the actual photos.) Now take a look at that link and the picture contained therein. It’s basically a stringy bit of something that looks a little bit like a worm. Jojo’s mom asked her mom buddies on the MMS Facebook group, all of whom were “pretty sure” it was a worm. It’s not. Any surgeon or doctor who deals with GI problems will recognize it as a bit of mucus, possibly with a bit of colon mucosa (the lining of the colon). We see this sort of thing all the time, and it’s definitely not a worm.
Over the month of April and into May, Jojo’s mother treated her blog readers to regular photos of things like this. For instance, in this post, she spread a bunch of nasty stuff out and photographed it. Kerri Rivera, we were told, had informed her that this stuff is “worm INTESTINES. The outer skin is already digested and the inside (intestines etc) disintegrates like this.” No, it was just more mucus mixed with colonic mucosa (the lining of the colon). Disturbingly to me as a surgeon, it looked to me like a fairly decent-sized chunk of colonic mucosa with mucus. I can’t say for sure how large it is because Jojo’s mom was, unfortunately, not kind enough to provide a ruler next to it. Oddly enough, the lower picture showed more mucus, and Jojo’s mother correctly labeled it as such. Then, right after that, we were treated to more pictures of mucus and sloughed colon mucosa, which Rivera characterized once again as “the intestines of the worm, the outer ‘skin’ having already been digested.”
Later on her story, Jojo’s mother told us:
It’s been a while since I wrote in this blog but I have been so busy. I have been poop-diving for quite a while now, started about a week before April’s Parasite Protocol. Getting to be more confident about differentiating between biofilm (translucent, clear, film-like gel), mucus (breaks up in water) and worm pieces (looks like layers of opaque tissue, when lifted with work it intertwines around itself like a rope).
Kerri says that the outer skin of the worm is usually totally digested by the time these worms are expelled and what we see, that rope-like, intertwined tissue are its intestines, the insides of the worm.
Later still, because the “worms” were still coming out (as they would always come out given that they were intestinal lining and mucus, not worms), Rivera told Jojo’s mom that she needed to treat her son not only with bleach but with Mebendazole, a drug used to treat worms, such as pinworms, roundworms, tapeworms, hookworms, and whipworms. The new protocol included:
With the parasite protocol, one will have more to keep track of:
    • Mebendazole / Combantrin
    • Diatomaceous Earth (DE) + Rompepiedras (RP)
    • Castor Oil
    • Neem
All the above were given in different combinations on different days, no real pattern to it so one has to be on the ball enough to know what is given on which days of the Parasite Protocol from Days 1 – 18. From Day 18 onwards it’s just the DE and the RP.
I have to say that I have seen a lot of worms only after starting the Parasite Protocol. So what I read about Andreas Kalcker saying that CD (read: MMS) alone will not kill the parasites and that mebendazole is required must be true. Whilst it does happen ~ parasites being killed by CD alone, best results are achieved with the Rivera CD protocol done in conjunction with the Kalcker Parasite Protocol.
Remember what I said about the liver flushes above? Basically, most liver flushes involve taking Epsom salts, olive oil, and fruit juices, such as apple juice or lemon juice. As I have pointed out before, these “gallstones” are nothing more than saponified oils, thanks to the acids from the juice and the salt from the Epsom salts or phosphate salts often used in these protocols. Similarly, what I suspect to be going on here is that the castor oil and neem (which is an oil as well), mixed with the diatomaceous earth, combine in much the same way that the Epsom salts, oils, and acid from the juices do in liver flushes, the difference being that the mixture probably doesn’t saponify in the same way. However, clearly, when enemas are added, what comes out, instead of looking like little stones, looks like the pictures we see.
It’s not just this child, either. In 2017, there was this news report in the UK:
The woman, from Cheshire, has been reported to police for her activity in a secret Facebook group for parents that claims autism is caused by parasites that can be cleansed using the potentially lethal treatment.
However, autism campaigner Emma Dalmayne who infiltrated the group, says the images actually show children’s bowel lining that has been burned away by the bleach.
The treatment being administered is CD (Chloride Dioxide) or MMS (Miracle Mineral Solution), which is administered orally or via an enema.
Dalmayne reported some truly horrible things:
No parents will admit to doing this to their children publicly. This treatment is not illegal at the moment but we need to get rid of it,’ said the mother-of-six.
‘The most extreme case I have seen to date is a six-year-old boy who had to have his bowel removed and a colostomy bag fitted after his parents gave him these enemas.
‘What you see in these images is the bowel lining of these victims.’
I can’t help but also repeat an anecdote I described the last time I wrote about MMS:
My 14YO son has autism. I’ve been treating him with a parasite cleanse system for 1.5 years (5 days on, 2 days off). He’s made some remarkable improvements, but every time I try to wean him off the cleanse, the parasite symptoms flare up. He is nonverbal and fairly low-functioning, so I don’t get any feedback from him as to how he is feeling. Last week, I started him on 1 drop of MMS then upped the dose to 1 drop, 2x a day this week. After about 4 days at 2 drops/day, he vomited once and had diarrhea all day. I am assuming it is the MMS. I decided to drop down to 1 drop/day again until he gets beyond this. He tends to have loose stools anyway, which I am guessing is related to this ongoing battle with the parasites.
Reports like this are everywhere.
The cult of bleach
Like nearly all alternative medicine, MMS is basically an element of a cult. Indeed, the cult itself (Jim Humble’s Genesis II Church) makes that point explicit by calling MMS a “sacrament” in its religion. Now, it’s hard to say whether Genesis II exists primarily to sell MMS now or whether MMS really is just part of the religion. Certainly, Jim Humble is a major league crackpot:
The Genesis II Church of Health and Healing believes that MMS, which is essentially industrial bleach, is a religious sacrament.
The church excommunicated an Eyewitness News producer after she went undercover armed with her iPhone at a seminar in Costa Mesa.
Their founder, Jim Humble, is a former Scientologist who claims he’s a billion-year-old god from the Andromeda galaxy.
“And then I asked to be put in the part of the space navy that watched over Earth,” Humble, the self-proclaimed Archbishop of the Genesis II Church of Health and Healing claims in a video.
Humble also claims he discovered the miracle potion in the jungles of South America.
“I just treated 800 cases of HIV just recently in Africa, every one of them came out good,” Humble is heard stating in another video.
It would be one thing if Humble just thought he was a billion year old god from Andromeda who was part of the space navy watching over earth. Then, he’d just be a harmless (and possibly amusing) crank. But he goes beyond that claiming to be able to cure cancer, HIV, diabetes, autism, multiple sclerosis, malaria, and basically almost any disease with industrial bleach, concocting a history of how he supposedly discovered MMS in 1996, although with a caveat:
In 1996, while on a gold mining expedition in South America, I discovered that chlorine dioxide quickly eradicates malaria. Since that time, it has proven to restore partial or full health to hundreds of thousands of people suffering from a wide range of disease, including cancer, diabetes, hepatitis A, B, C, Lyme disease, MRSA, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, HIV/AIDS, malaria, autism, infections of all kinds, arthritis, high cholesterol, acid reflux, kidney or liver diseases, aches and pains, allergies, urinary tract infections, digestive problems, high blood pressure, obesity, parasites, tumors and cysts, depression, sinus problems, eye disease, ear infections, dengue fever, skin problems, dental issues, problems with prostate (high PSA), erectile dysfunction and the list goes on. This is by far not a comprehensive list. I know it sounds too good to be true, but according to feedback I have received over the last 20 years, I think it’s safe to say MMS has the potential to overcome most diseases known to mankind.
It is important to note that MMS does not cure disease. MMS is an oxidizer, it kills pathogens and destroys poisons. When these are reduced or eliminated in the body, then the body can function properly and thereby heal. I often say, “The body heals the body”. MMS helps to line things up so the body can do just that.
All of this, of course, is transparent nonsense.
It’s not just autistic children who suffer, either, because MMS is being sold as a treatment for just about every disease and condition under the sun, and a common part of MMS protocols is similar to what Kerri Rivera recommended: Keep increasing the dose until you start getting nausea and/or diarrhea. Indeed, there’s been at least one death that I know of associated with MMS (although in fairness it’s not entirely clear that MMS caused the death). There’s no doubt that many who’ve tried MMS have suffered symptoms consistent with corrosive injuries to the GI tract, including vomiting, stomach pains, and diarrhea, plus the aforementioned sloughing of the lining of the GI tract. The FDA, in its warning letter, cited receiving reports of injuries associated with MMS, including severe nausea, vomiting, and life-threatening low blood pressure from dehydration. Other potential complications can include kidney damage and acute hemolysis.
Of all the alternative medicine cults out there, MMS is one of the more pernicious and ridiculous. Unfortunately, it’s hard to laugh at the ridiculousness of MMS without simultaneously being alarmed at its potential for harm. Just watch this video of cult members persuading parents in Uganda to administer MMS to their children to treat malaria if you don’t believe me. It’s horrifyingly unethical and reeks of racism and preying on vulnerable populations. (Particularly hard to watch is a segment around 7:25, where a baby is being fed MMS and is clearly not liking it at all.) This is the face of the cult, and I fear that MMS won’t disappear even after its “discoverer” Jim Humble goes back to Andromeda.

Navage Promises Benefits from Cleaning Your Nose with Their Expensive Machine
Navage is a machine that uses salt water to rinse out the sinuses, allegedly alleviating the causes of congestion, allergies, colds, and more. The evidence for their claims is lacking.
Harriet Hall on December 7, 2021
Link

Navage airs its TV commercials with annoying frequency. They say:
Pandemics remind us that germs invade through your nose, the body’s natural air filter for trapping allergens, dirt, and viruses. But how do you clean it? It’s easy with Navage. Navage uses powered suction to flush out all the stuff that causes congestion, allergies, colds, and worse. When your nose is clean, so many good things happen: you breathe better, sleep deeper, snore less, and feel healthier. Join millions who use all-natural, drug-free Navage. You’ll love that clean nose feeling.
This ad raises a lot of questions in my mind
This is all marketing with no science. It seems to imply that Navage can prevent COVID-19, but there is no evidence that it does. The only evidence that “good things” happen is unreliable testimonial evidence from satisfied users. There have been no clinical studies to evaluate the company’s claims. Millions may use it, but the argument from popularity is a logical fallacy. It uses saline pods, but no drugs (unless you consider saline to be a drug). But is it all-natural? I don’t see how a battery-powered device with a motor could be considered “natural.” It may give you a “clean nose feeling,” but that doesn’t mean it is clinically effective.
What is Navage?
The Navage system is a plastic, motorized, battery-powered device with two chambers. The upper chamber is filled with water and a saline pod is inserted and pierced by a device that mixes salt into the water. Two prongs are inserted into the nostrils and as the solution in the upper chamber is pumped into the nose, it rinses out both sides of the nose and is sucked out into the lower chamber, which is transparent so you can see any gunk that was removed.
Many ENT specialists recommend nasal irrigation
There is scientific evidence that nasal irrigation benefits allergies, sinus infections, and colds; but the evidence is not very robust, and it is not recommended for long-term use, which may increase the frequency of infections. When recommended, it is more often used as an adjunct rather than used alone. Hypertonic saline may be more effective but causes more side effects. Nasal steroid sprays are more effective than irrigation. Is Navage safe? They recommend using distilled water. Tap water that hasn’t been boiled and cooled may contain bacteria or amoebas. Several people have died from Naegleria fowleri amoebas in the water supply, but this is rare.
There are other ways to clean the nose, including squeeze bottles and neti pots. I wrote about neti pots before. They are a teapot-like device that originated in India in Ayurvedic tradition; the user inserts the spout into one nostril at a time and bends over the sink; gravity does the work. Which irrigation method works best? We don’t know. The various methods have never been tested against one another. I found testimonials online from patients whose doctors told them to stop using neti pots and switch to Navage, but other patients said their doctors had advised them to stop using Navage and switch to neti pots.
Problems reported
Satisfied users swear that they got wonderful benefits from the Navage system, but using it can be problematic. The website features a number of videos on how to assemble it, on how to use it, and on troubleshooting various problems; apparently users need a lot of help. I found reports from people who had purchased a device that quit working, and then had purchased a second device that also quit working. Some people reported difficulty getting the hang of it; apparently there is a learning curve. Some complained that water kept going down their throat and they felt like they were being waterboarded. Users complained about the cost of the special saltpod capsules (around $20 a month). One described a cumbersome work-around that allowed them to trick the machine into allowing the use of the less expensive saline packets intended for neti pots. The cost of the system is around $100 or more, and many people complained that they wanted to try it but it was too expensive for them. There were reports of perforated eardrums, Eustachian tube dysfunction, and even Bell’s palsy attributed to the device. Many users said it didn’t work for them. Many called it a scam because it requires you to use their special saltpod capsules. They described the process as messy, saying it must be used over a sink. They complained that the ads didn’t divulge that the solution doesn’t get to the frontal sinuses. They said the device leaked. They said it was difficult to clean. And there were many more complaints. One even said “I almost died” (in a mishap that sent concentrated salt up their nose).
Conclusion: Marketing, not science
        ◦ The Navage website doesn’t even pretend to supply any scientific evidence. The ads are aimed at scientifically naïve people who value testimonials and gadgets, not at those who value science and evidence. There is no reason to think the results of Navage are superior to the results of other methods of nasal irrigation. The nose doesn’t need regular cleaning; that’s a fictitious need that they invented just to sell their product. There is a legitimate concern that using nasal irrigation too often can be harmful. Admittedly, some individuals may have a personal preference for Navage over other methods of nasal irrigation, but I can’t see any compelling reason to recommend it; Neti pots are probably just as effective and far less expensive.

   Rom Houben: Not communicating through facilitated communication
David Gorski
Link
The news is finally filtering out to the rest of the world.
As Steve Novella and my good buddy pointed out a few days ago (and as Steve pointed out in an interview on NPR), Dr. Steven Laureys admitted that Rom Houben, the unfortunate victim of a car crash that left him in what had been diagnosed as a persistent vegetative state, was in fact not able to communicate through the woo known as facilitated communication. This came as no surprise to anyone who has followed FC over the years. In fact, what had come as a surprise is that Dr. Laureys could have been so easily taken in by pseudoscience that had been so thoroughly debunked in the 1990s. To his credit, though, after a period of initially stubbornly defending FC, he relented and allowed objective testing, and the result was predictable. It took a few days, but the English language world is learning of the failure of FC in Houben’s case:
The sceptics said it was impossible – and it was. The story of Rom Houben of Belgium, which made headlines worldwide last November when he was shown to be “talking”, was today revealed to have been nothing of the sort.
Dr Steven Laureys, one of the doctors treating him, acknowledged that his patient could not make himself understood after all. Facilitated communication, the technique said to have made Houben’s apparent contact with the outside world possible, did not work, Laureys declared.
“We did not have all the facts before,” he said. “To me, it’s enough to say that this method doesn’t work.” Just three months ago the doctor was proclaiming that Houben had been trapped in his own body, the victim of a horrendous misdiagnosis, and only rescued from his terrible plight thanks to medical advances.
What was not reported is that skeptics were involved in the testing of Rom Houben. I recently received a statement from the Belgian Skeptics (SKEPP):
At the request of the medical institution where Mr Houben is cared for, on February 4 2010 SKEPP was present as advisor for a planned test of this controversial method of communication, and we also conducted our own tests. From the staff of the institute we learned that during two years all attempts to establish any form of communication with the patient by detecting and coding minute movements of the eyes or any other body part had failed. With FC he now seemed to produce correct words and elaborate sentences. Indeed, his answers to our simple test questions were intelligible and sometimes elaborate, but when the facilitator did not know the questions, his answers were all completely wrong. Most of the time he typed with his eyes closed, but as soon as the keyboard was shielded from the facilitator’s view the typing produced gibberish and halted. There clearly was no communication with the patient, only with the facilitator. We wonder what world-shaking news there would have been to communicate if it hadn’t been for the spectacular answers the facilitator produced.
Our intent was to not to test Mr Houben, but to test FC, and once more we demonstrated that the method is a sham. This is not to deny that Mr Houben may have some limited consciousness. If so, how frustrating must it be for him to hear all the bogus messages being produced in his name, without any possibility to protest ? After our test we had a long conversation with Dr. Laureys. He insisted that we test more facilitators before drawing conclusions. We declined and advised him to clearly distance himself from the FC scam, which he has done today. Out of respect and to allow them time to discuss the results with the family and the dedicated staff, we agreed on a 2 weeks embargo before making the results of our test public. Of course, not everyone is convinced yet. In a phone conversation today Mr Houben’s mother told us that she still believes in FC, because “sometimes it had produced answers that only her son could have known”. She is convinced that Dr. Laureys will ultimately find a method to communicate with her son. His team is experimenting with other methods. Let’s hope her wish comes true.
Indeed.
I want to emphasize once again that those of us who blasted FC in the wake of this case said nothing about whether Mr. Houben is conscious or not. We merely pointed out that FC is a long-discredited sham and, from evidence of videos available on the Internet, clearly could not be a mechanism by which Houben communicated if he in fact has consciousness. I and others have also pointed out that it’s horrible enough to be conscious and trapped in a motionless, useless shell, but imagine how much more horrible it would be to be conscious, trapped in a motionless shell, and having the only hope for communication with the outside world coopted by a facilitator.
In any case, props to SKEPP. They done good. Real good. Now let’s hope that, if Houben is conscious, Dr. Laureys, chastened by this experience, will find a way to communicate with Houben that isn’t based on the ideomotor effect and wishful thinking.

   Charlatan: Quackery Then and Now
Harriet Hall
Link
Charlatan: America’s Most Dangerous Huckster, the Man Who Pursued Him, and the Age of Flimflam, by Pope Brock, is not only a rip-roaring good read, but it brings up serious issues about regulation of medical practice and prosecution of quackery. It tells the story of John R. Brinkley MD, who transplanted goat glands into people, and of Morris Fishbein MD, the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association, who tried to stop him.
The Charlatan
Brinkley was a colorful character whose very first job was a scam, selling a patent remedy. He went to medical school but never finished, eventually buying a diploma elsewhere for $100. A bigamist, drunkard, liar, and con man of incredible audacity, he built up an empire of quackery that made him filthy rich. Apart from his medical adventures, he practically invented modern political campaigning techniques, revolutionized advertising, and was almost single-handedly responsible for popularizing country music and the blues with his radio station.
An impotent patient supposedly told Brinkley, “Too bad I don’t have goat nuts.” So Brinkley gave him some. A few weeks later he went back for a refresher course in surgery (which he failed because of drunkenness and poor attendance). He began to feel that he was gifted and should not be bound by the “jealous sheep ethics” of the AMA.
In 1918 he founded a clinic in Milford Kansas whose main purpose was to rejuvenate men by surgically implanting goat testicles. Hormones hadn’t been isolated yet, and other medical men were experimenting with animal gland transplants, starting with Brown-Sequard, who “after a long and distinguished international career, wandered off the reservation in the late 1880s.” He injected himself with an emulsion of dog and guinea pig testicles and claimed he felt like a new man. Other doctors followed his lead with goat, ram, and monkey testicles. Steinach offered what was essentially a vasectomy, thinking it would make hormones flow back into the body. One American research program was cancelled after the chimps escaped the lab on a Sunday morning and reassembled in a local church, interrupting worship services.
Brinkley had an advantage over his rivals in his superior guile, marketing genius, and unbeatable chutzpah; and goats were an inspired choice of animal, because the goat’s appetite for sex was famous. His fame rose meteorically on the basis of testimonials, but his treatments were implausible, ineffective, and dangerous. At least 42 patients entered his hospital vertical and departed horizontal. Others survived surgery long enough to die at home, and others succumbed from using the quack remedies he sold via the radio. “[G]iven the Jurassic state of malpractice laws in Brinkley’s day” his medical license was a license to kill. His body count was higher than that of the worst serial killers.
He advertised that his treatments worked wonders on 27 different ailments from emphysema to flatulence, with a 95% success rate. (It worked less well on “stupid types.”) He had a program called “Medical Question Box” on his own radio station. A patient would write in with symptoms, he would advise “remedy no. 20,” and both the inquirer and all the listeners with similar symptoms would buy his line of numbered quack remedies sold through a chain of participating drug stores with a 100% money-back guarantee. Nothing could stop him. When he lost his license to practice medicine in Kansas, he ran for governor. When his radio station was shut down, he moved it across the border to Mexico and set up the most powerful radio transmitter ever, to blast his message throughout North America.
There were rumors… that he bit a man’s ear off in drunken rampage and stole goats from neighboring farms when his own supply ran low. But he was idolized by tidal wave of grateful patients and staunch supporters.
What finally led to his downfall was a libel lawsuit he filed against Morris Fishbein. He lost, and he made a fool of himself on the witness stand. One thing that came out in the trial was that the special Formula 1020 ( which he sent home with surgical patients for post-operative injections to “stimulate” the production of white blood cells) was nothing but colored water. The trial verdict, in 1939, branded him as a quack, and this unleashed a slew of other lawsuits by injured patients. The IRS pursued him for back taxes, and he ended up bankrupt in 1941, just months before his death.
Fighting Quackery Then
Brock says, “…quacks have flourished in all ages and cultures, for nothing shows reason the door like cures for things. Unlike most scams, which target greed, quackery fires deeper into Jungian universals: our fear of death, our craving for miracles. When we see night approaching, nearly all of us are rubes.”
Quacks were embraced in America due to a “perverse stream” of independence running back to Jacksonian democracy when education was despised and the common man exalted and when all but 3 states actually repealed licensing requirements. “Americans not only tolerated but demanded incompetence.” The AMA was founded in 1847 as a reaction to the free-for-all, but it “simply swapped one form of chaos for another” – licensing of everything from osteopathy to homeopathy, from chiropractic to “eclectic” medicine and herbalism.
In1905 Samuel Hopkins Adams wrote an expose of patent medicines for Collier’s magazine. He named names: 264 companies and individuals. Within a year, one manufacturer of an alcohol-based remedy was told by the IRS to either put real medicine in his product or open a bar. Did you know ketchup started life as a patent medicine?
In response to the Collier’s expose, the AMA hired Arthur Cramp to head its Bureau of Investigation. He and Fishbein formed a quackbusting team that lasted over 20 years. The AMA was proactive and had its own lab to analyze quack remedies. Cramp created a poster for national distribution: Testimonials are Worthless. The JAMA ran a regular feature – a 2 page spread with a testimonial on one side with a picture of the person who gave it and the disease they were miraculously cured of; and on the facing page, the same person’s death certificate, cause of death: same disease.
Morris Fishbein only practiced medicine for 1 year before turning to journalism. He was famous for investigating a girl with an unexplained (and impossible) fever of 114 and finding the hot water bottle she was hiding. He was appalled by what Brinkley was up to – he called him a one man medical emergency. He vowed to put him out of business, and he tried for decades, but he was hamstrung. Cramp said, “There is nothing the medical profession can do except to warn the public against the thing.” Fishbein tried the AMA, FTC, BBB, articles excoriating Brinkley. Nothing put a dent in Brinkley’s success. In fact, the publicity helped him, because he could portray himself as the lone genius doctor being persecuted by the hidebound medical establishment. He could say they were only trying to protect their own monopoly on medical income. He could say Fishbein was on a personal vendetta. Despite a few setbacks, he continued to kill patients and get obscenely rich doing it. In a touch of hubris reminiscent of Greek tragedy, it was Brinkley himself who filed the lawsuit that ended his career.
Fighting Quackery Now
I wish Brinkley were just a historical curiosity; but there are Brinkleys out there today, and we haven’t gotten much better at stopping them. A recent Nightline featured a doctor who has treated 30,000 patients for a non-existent illness, using dangerous bogus treatments. Only now is there an investigation that threatens his license, but the hearing won’t be until December.
It’s difficult to get a state board to act against an MD, a chiropractor, or any other licensed health care provider on the basis of quackery. It gets the boards’ attention if a patient dies, or if injured patients file malpractice lawsuits. Sexual misconduct generally gets their attention, as does defrauding Medicare. But in general, the people on the boards are hesitant to criticize their peers. We need to do better.
The problem is, danger lurks on the borderlands of quackery. What we don’t want to do is stringently restrict doctors to approved practices so that they are unable to implement new treatments as they come along. Even if we stick to evidence-based guidelines, we have to leave room for clinical judgment. I don’t mean any vague “art” of medicine, but the judgment of how to apply the existing evidence to individual patients in everyday clinical practice. Doctors need leeway to prescribe medicines off-label when there is published evidence that hasn’t yet been translated into FDA approvals. If evidence-based medicine has nothing to offer, we need the option of judiciously trying something that we don’t have good evidence for but have reason to think might help. But where do you draw the line? The MD featured on Nightline says he is practicing legitimate, cutting edge medicine; and so did Brinkley.
There are whole areas of alternative medicine that most of us consider quackery, but political correctness and legal repercussions discourage even the use of that word. One man’s quackery is another man’s miracle cure; postmodernists and New Agers tell us science is only one of many ways of knowing. When scientific doctors try to suppress quackery, they are automatically accused of jealously trying to protect their guild from outsiders. If that is ever true, it certainly isn’t common. I don’t think financial concerns enter into the equation when MDs speak out against things like homeopathy or therapeutic touch.
Read Charlatan and enjoy; then think about today’s charlatans and weep.

Alternative Reproduction?
Are there effective forms of SCAMs for birth control or reproduction? Of course not.
Mark Crislip on September 22, 2022
Link

I usually start these blog entries with an idea and then see where the research takes me. Certainly I go down many rat holes. Thanks to the recent reversal of reproductive rights by the SCOTUS, with perhaps more to come, I wondered what SCAM alternatives were available when/if reality-based reproductive interventions were no longer an option. I wonder no longer.
There are four aspects of reproduction I will consider, along with some rat holes: contraception, infertility, erectile dysfunction, and pregnancy termination.
As I start this, my assumption was there would be few SCAM approaches to pregnancy prevention, as SCAMs have no efficacy when there is a hard end point to the intervention. There are no SCAM therapies for the infections I see most days as many have almost 100% mortality rates. No one, I would hope, would use a SCAM for the sole treatment of endocarditis or meningitis – although there is the occasional person who will rely solely on SCAMs for cancer treatment. It does not end well.
I have told this story before, but I first learned about SCAMs early in my practice when I was called to see a case of wet gangrene of the leg. A young female had a sarcoma of her leg that would have likely been cured with amputation. She chose naturopathy instead and the cancer advanced until most of her leg was cancer, much of it dead and putrefying. That is why they called me, not there was anything I could do. She refused any care (she was admitted because she had passed out) and that night the cancer eroded into an artery and she bled out. That is where I first encountered naturopathy and the first of many cases where cancer denial was an important aspect of the patient’s care.
Contraception
Like SCAM cancer therapies, it is obvious when contraception fails. I would think pregnancy would be harder to deny than cancer, but I will not be surprised if the comments have stories that demonstrate otherwise. The “if only they had used our SCAM sooner” gambit is unlikely to be a convincing argument as to why birth control failed.
Before I wander the SCAMs, though, I wondered how people avoided pregnancy in the era before oral contraceptives. Sure, there are barrier methods, abstinence (like that ever works), and the rhythm method. And you know what we call people who use the rhythm method for contraception? Parents.
If you visit the old towns of the West, it appears that most of the hotels and restaurants were once bordellos. I wonder where they found all the workers for these bordellos. It would seem that most of the female population of the Old West would have to be employed in these houses of ill repute.
But how did the prostitutes, and others, avoid pregnancy? Were there, for lack of a better term, natural forms of birth control? Or were the bordellos filled with their offspring? Besides a variety of barrier methods (half a lemon used as a cervical cap!), the techniques used were not that different than ‘modern’ SCAM ideas:
Roman women put a leather pouch filled with cat’s liver on their left foot during sexual intercourse to prevent pregnancy. Some women believed that spitting three times into a frog’s mouth was a good method of birth control. European women thought that they could prevent pregnancy by turning backwards a wheel of a mill at midnight. And, in many cultures women constantly wore various necklaces and amulets, which were supposed to have the power of controlling the act of conception. Women were advised to hold their breath and draw their bodies back during sex in order to stop the sperm from entering her body. It was also suggested a woman to jump backwards seven times after sexual intercourse or take something to cause sneezing.
As one website noted:
Until modern contraceptives were invented, women relied on all kinds of ancient birth control methods that had inconsistent results. Some were even dangerous, including the use of heavy metals such as mercury, lead, and arsenic, which did prevent conception but also led to organ failure and brain damage.
I was also amazed to learn that the relationship between ovulation and menses was not discovered until the 1930s, so that method of contraception was unknown for most of human history.
Also used were:
syringes to inject mercury, arsenic, and vinegar into the body to induce abortions or treat diseases.
Much to my amusement, one Boston brothel had:
…a homeopathic doctor “considered to be crackpotty at the time,” according to Beaudry. He prescribed unusual remedies for the women, most likely for treating sexually transmitted diseases and inducing abortions.
He would likely be considered crackpotty today.
One would think, wouldn’t one, that if acupuncture is efficacious in aiding in pregnancy and given its numerous alleged salubrious effects on female and male reproductive physiology, acupuncture and traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine could also be used for contraception. I can think of one application where acupuncture might be efficacious, but there are no acupuncture points on the genitals.
While I was not surprised to find zero papers on the Pubmeds on using acupuncture for birth control, I could also not find any with a general Google search.
There are no SCAMs that are touted for contraception. Not acupuncture, not homeopathy, not chiropractic, not naturopathy. No surprise. There would be no way to rationalize away pregnancy.
One site mentioned in passing, stone seed root, thistle, wild carrot seed, and ginger root as potential contraceptives. I would suggest not.
Since, as noted above, the goal is to adjust and harmonize the state of the female body from a holistic approach and there is no useful form of SCAM contraception, the harmonized state appears to be barefoot and pregnant.
Infertility
Infertility has a complex differential diagnosis with a variety of anatomical and hormonal abnormalities leading to an inability to conceive. It also makes for a huge literature, although like most of the SCAM literature, high-quality studies are few and far between. I am going to discuss a few I find instructive and or amusing.
SCAM providers are fond of claiming that their raison d’etre is to help return the body to its optimal state of homeostasis or as one review noted, to “…adjust and harmonize the state of the female body from a holistic approach”.
There are a vast number of SCAMs that are used as an adjunctive therapy for infertility. In China, not unsurprisingly, Traditional Chinese Pseudo Medicine, especially acupuncture and moxibustion, are used as primary treatment for infertility. And, as is always the case in studies out of China, the studies are uniformly positive.
It is a massive literature of Tooth Fairy science and I will note here an infertility study that was randomized and double-blind comparing real acupuncture with placebo acupuncture (same thing) in patients undergoing IVF treatment. The results? No difference, really; p=0.038. But what was amusing was that the pregnancy was increased in the placebo group:
The overall pregnancy rate was significantly higher in the placebo acupuncture group than that in the real acupuncture group (55.1 versus 43.8%, respectively).
But there is no “real” acupuncture, as I have argued before. And their conclusion? Not that doing two interventions with no reality-based reason for efficacy is going to lead to random noise that looks significant. Nope:
Placebo acupuncture was associated with a significantly higher overall pregnancy rate when compared with real acupuncture. Placebo acupuncture may not be inert.
LOL. What is inert is the critical thinking functions of the researchers.
Reading even the meta-analysis is the usual mess, because acupuncture, as always, is a heterogeneous intervention, with traditional, electro, cat gut, and warm being some of the variations used and compared. It is quite the mess for drawing any conclusions about whether a specific intervention is effective. But as I have mentioned before, it is not the specific intervention that is allegedly useful, it is the concept of acupuncture that is allegedly effective.
But if limited to quality studies, the efficacy of acupuncture is not impressive:
There was no statistically significant difference between the acupuncture group and no acupuncture (intervention) controls around the time of embryo transfer (ET; risk ratio, RR, 1.24, 95% confidence interval, CI, 1.02-1.50) or in unblinded trials, trials blinded to physicians and double-blind trials (95% CI 1.26-1.88, 0.82-1.33 and 0.89-1.25, respectively). This was also the case when comparing acupuncture with sham acupuncture controls around the time of ET (RR, 1.03, 95% CI 0.87-1.22) or when restricting to unblinded trials, trials blinded to physicians and double-blind trials (95% CI 0.80-2.02, 0.82-1.18 and 0.77-1.17, respectively).
Much of the primary literature is in China and, for example, I could not find the Chinese Journal of Family Planning and similar journals to see the details about the effects of TCM retention enema on tubal obstructive infertility. Yes. Really.
A warm enema containing Chinese medicine is administered before going to bed to treat fallopian tube adhesion. The drug can be absorbed directly by rectal mucosa, which is beneficial to improve the congestion, edema, adhesion, and hyperplasia of local tissues, and thus restoring the function of the fallopian tube.
What continues to amaze me is how health care professionals, well versed in anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, etc., apply the techniques of reality on fiction. It only happens in medicine. You do not see engineers trying to apply the physics of Warner Brothers cartoons to the building of bridges and tunnels. There is no alternative engineering or aviation but doctors continue to act like acupuncture and other SCAMs are not ludicrous.
Huge numbers of herbal preparations have been tried for male and female infertility, more than I have time to review except to note the “efficacy” is often secondary endpoints like cervical mucus consistency or sperm motility and concentration, not conception rates.
Chiropractic has been used for infertility but:
There are very few original data articles documenting responses of infertile females treated with spinal manipulation.
And:
In the absence of a robust body of primary data literature, the use of spinal manipulation the management of female infertility should be approached with caution.
The Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research (not on Pubmed as Pubmed does not list science fiction) has papers purporting to show benefit of chiropractic in infertile patients. And, to no one’s surprise, chiropractors tout the benefits of their interventions on the web.
I can find next to nothing on Pubmed using homeopathy or naturopathy for infertility. Well, for homeopathy preparations it would be exactly nothing.
Erectile dysfunction
The acupoints for erectile dysfunction are distant from the problematic organ, in one study being, slightly below the navel, slightly above the hairline at the back of the head, between the inside ankle bone and the achilles tendon, in the inside wrist. And the results?
No definite conclusions can be drawn.
A conclusion supported in the most recent meta-analysis where:
Low quality evidence shows beneficial effect of acupuncture as adjunctive treatment for people mainly with psychogenic ED.
And the best results were:
Acupuncture combined with tadalafil appeared to have better effect on increasing cure rate.
Lol. It takes a ‘Western’ medicine to get the best results.
There is the also creepy “Clinical Holistic Medicine: Holistic Sexology and Acupressure Through the Vagina (Hippocratic Pelvic Massage)“.
Noted in one clinical study:
The most difficult problem of this procedure seems to be that it makes it very difficult to be sure that the procedure and all the involved steps are always necessary and rational.
Eye roll and head shake.
There is nothing on the PubMeds for using chiropractic, homeopathy or naturopathy for ED, but no shortage of websites promoting their use.
I wondered about homeopathy, so I picked a website at random. The first suggestion is Agnus castus:
This remedy may be helpful if problems with impotence develop after a man has led a life of intense and frequent sexual activity for many years. A cold sensation felt in the genitals is a strong indication for Agnus castus. People who need this remedy are often very anxious about their health and loss of abilities and may have problems with memory and concentration. This remedy is one of the best homeopathic medicine for ED.
Agnus castus is the chaste berry, which one site says:
The fruit has been historically used for reducing sexual desire.
As one site notes:
The leaves of this plant were used to adorn the beds of Greek women during the absence of their husbands so as to prevent any impure thoughts from entering their minds and also by medieval monks to repress sexual desire. In the actual provings the remedy has shown that it does repress sexual instinct and desire.
And:
Agnus castus is indicated for promiscuous young people who have abused their sexual energies through either homosexual or heterosexual multiple contacts and who have contracted repeated venereal infections, especially gonorrhea.
Huh? Homeopathic teaching is that a product that causes the symptoms undergoes serial dilution and succussion to make a more potent medication. Somehow a medication that reduces sexual desire increases libido when homeopathized? Writing these entries leads to some of the weirdest stuff.
Abortion
While no trials can be identified in the Pubmeds, acupuncture was used for abortions in China although it was unreliable. Cue Louie. Acupuncture does have “forbidden points”. Specifically if you stimulate:
San Yin Chiao (SP6) in conjunction with He Gu (LI4). The abortion is generally realized within 24 hours.
But that’s in humans, in Wistar rats stimulating the forbidden points does nothing:
We found no evidence that acupuncture in LI4-SP6 and sacral points could be harmful to the pregnancy outcome in Wistar rats.
But then, why would it? Was trying to confirm or deny a fiction worth abusing and killing rats? I doubt it.
I have often wondered how they map human acupoints and meridians onto animals; evidently so do acupuncturists in search of One Acupuncture. One Acupuncture to rule them all, One Acupuncture to find them, One Acupuncture to bring them all and in the darkness bind them, I suppose.
Moving toward a neuroanatomically accurate veterinary acupuncture system requires rethinking current atlases and embarking upon a systematic analysis of the human points in terms of where, if at all, corresponding sites exist in the nonhuman.
Good luck with that. Because you might run into issues such as those with Boa constrictors, although why one would want to torture a snake with acupuncture is uncertain.
Thus, the objective of this study was to map and describe the main points of acupuncture in the species Boa constrictor, and their indications to promote the balance of this species. The unprecedented result of the mapping was the discovery of specific acupoints with individual location indications without distribution in specific meridians and dispersedly distributed in the body.
Careful, clever, scientists, they measured the heart rate:
HR was obtained by counting heart rate.
And if you wondered how they found acupuncture points?
Use of the electrostimulator and location of EL points 30 – 10/100 Hz NKLpoints of Brazilian origin. The EL30 is an electronic device that is intended exclusively for non-invasive applications in the technique called electro-acupuncture. It was conceived as a point detection instrument, where an electrostimulation therapy, used in different media with a purpose of detection and determination of qualities as stimulus conditions for different species and for different points. It was traversed with an exploratory tip of the animal’s body points to an occurrence of an audible signal indicating the localized point and an impedance. The sensitivity controller has been adjusted to find a better setting.
More animal abuse for no good reason. But I digress. Again.
Consistency not being a strong point in acupuncture, when acupuncture was used as an adjunct to medical abortion they used Hegu (LI 4), Sanyinjiao (SP 6), Neiguan (PC 6) and Kunlun (BL 60). I suspect the increased efficacy was due to BL 60.
Acupuncturists can get quite wiggens over the forbidden points, going as far as to suggest the auricular acupuncture should be avoided in pregnancy. I would add it should be avoided when not pregnant as well. Several reviews suggest acupuncture is safe in pregnancy “when correctly applied”, whatever correctly applied might be.
While I can find papers where acupuncture is purported to prevent spontaneous abortion, and I can find nothing to confirm the abortifacient effects of acupuncture.
I can find nothing on using homeopathy, chiropractic or naturopathic techniques to induce abortion, although they allege they can help prevent spontaneous abortion/miscarriage. The one-way street that is SCAM.
Herbs? There’s a problem. I will admit, I am not one for social media. Twitter is a time suck and Facebook opaque and pointless. I certainly do not grok the concept of influencers. So TikTok? So out of my geezer understanding. But, per the Rolling Stone (geezer cred?) TikTok is a popular source for information on DYI abortions using pennyroyal, blue cohosh, and mugwort. Herbs that are not efficacious but are certainly toxic and could be fatal. As one PubMed review noted:
the ingestion of plants to induce abortion involves the risk of severe morbidity and mortality.
Hard to believe, but when it comes to medical advice it is suggested:
not to “listen to what you hear on TikTok.”
It is a question with no real answer: would a SCAM provider be any better?
It turns out self-managed abortion is not that uncommon, with 7% of “US women of reproductive age” (kind of redundant, women not in their reproductive age are unlikely to need an abortion) going the DYI route, often with herbs and without success.
With the Handmaiden’s Tale decision this year, I expect DYI abortions will only increase with resultant morbidity and mortality. Desperate people will do desperate things.

   IVF and CAM Use
Steven Novella 
Link
Perhaps the biggest hurdle to broader acceptance of the need for a consistent scientific basis for medical interventions is the attitude that worthless treatments are harmless. I often have the experience, after reviewing the evidence showing lack of efficacy for a specific intervention, of getting the head-tilt and shrug along with some variation of the dismissive attitude, “Well, if people feel better, then what’s the harm?” In my opinion, ethics and intellectual honesty indicate that we have to do better than that.
The “what’s the harm” refrain is so tired and overused that it prompted a website by that name, documenting direct harm caused by unscientific treatment modalities. This is a helpful reminder that any intervention that actually does something (has biological activity) must also contain some risks. But this site also has significant limitations. First, it is anecdotal. But also it emphasizes direct harm, while the indirect harm of unscientific methods (for example by delaying definitive treatment) likely vastly outweighs the direct harm. However, indirect harm is extremely difficult to quantify.
Studies looking at the net clinical effects of using or relying upon unscientific methods is therefore desirable. Recently Danish researchers have published one such study: Use of complementary and alternative medicines associated with a 30% lower ongoing pregnancy/live birth rate during 12 months of fertility treatment.
The study is a prospective follow-up cohort study, which means they followed a group of in-vitro fertilization (IVF) patients for 12 months and tracked their outcomes. (This is also a follow up of earlier data they presented two years ago with the same results.) They assessed their use of so-called CAM at the onset and at 12 months, and found:
About 30.6% (n = 223) of women used CAMs during the observation period. At T2 the ongoing pregnancy and live birth rate was 31.3% lower in CAM users (42.2%) compared with non-users (61.4%). Adjusted odds of pregnancy/live birth remained lower in CAM users versus non-users, odds ratio = 0.467 (95% confidence interval 0.306–0.711) after controlling for prognostic indicators (age, parity, years infertile).
The effect size is substantial – 31.3%, and the power of the study was robust. There are weaknesses, however. While they report that CAM modalities include acupuncture, reflexology, herbal and aromatherapy, they did not collect data in such a way as to assess the effect of specific CAM modalities on IVF success rate. Also, this study is not randomized. This means that the door is open for confounding factors. While the researchers controlled for obvious things, such as known prognostic factors for IVF success, it is always the unknown factors that cannot be controlled for. In other words, it is possible that another factor leads to CAM use and low IVF success, rather than CAM use directly causing low IVF success. But of course the latter interpretation is possible also – we just cannot tell from this one study.
Specific CAM modalities, like the use of herbal drugs, may have a direct adverse effect on IVF success. Herbal drugs are poorly controlled and are known in some cases to cause drug-drug interactions. There may also be indirect effects, such as reliance upon an ineffective CAM modality reducing compliance with the IVF procedure.
While this one study does not prove a specific adverse effect, it does reinforce what mainstream medical researchers already understand – a treatment that is unproven may in fact be harmful. This is precisely why unproven interventions should be used with extreme caution – either in the context of a clinical trial, for compassionate use, or perhaps with high plausibility in the absence of proven alternatives – and always with proper informed consent.
A major problem with proponents of CAM therapies is that the usual ethics of clinical care seem not to apply – as if they practice by a separate standard where treatments either work or have yet to be proven to work, but risks are generally ignored.
As an example, a recent study comparing acupuncture to placebo acupuncture showed that patients receiving placebo acupuncture had a higher pregnancy rate. In reality, most outcome measures were not statistically different – the study is consistent with a negative result and noisy data that just happened to favor placebo. The best scientific conclusion from this study is that acupuncture does not work for IVF, however the authors concluded: “Placebo acupuncture may not be inert.”
Although I think it’s most likely that this study is just negative, it may also be true that placebo acupuncture did better because real acupuncture has a negative effect on IVF rates. This latest study might lend support to this conclusion.
The authors concluded that CAM use in IVF patients should be monitored, but I think we can make a stronger conclusion that it should be discouraged. There is no evidence for benefit, and there is a suggestion of harm – in the real world of medicine this should lead to a suspension of using these techniques, at least until better studies show they are safe and effective. This is even without considering the extreme scientific implausibility of many CAM modalities, which makes the case for their continued use even worse.
Continued research into implausible treatments remain controversial precisely because those using these modalities in the first place do not follow standard medical ethics – they don’t base their practice on the evidence. I am still waiting for proponents to abandon a CAM modality because research shows it is not safe or that it is ineffective.

Menopause Isn’t Taboo
Menopause is not a taboo subject, and the Care Package is a mixture of quack remedies, questionable products, and placebos. This is silliness, not science.
Harriet Hall on February 1, 2022
Link 

I recently got an email with the subject line “Menopause shouldn’t be taboo – this gift can help.”
I wholeheartedly agree that menopause shouldn’t be a taboo subject, and the gift in question might get some women to talk about it, but I think it’s the wrong way to go about it. They say “Le Wren’s Menopause Support Care Package includes easy-to-use luxuries to alleviate common side effects, with a dose of loving self-care”.
They say the Care Package consists of:
    • Cooling Spray – Made with peppermint and menthol oils, this all-natural spray provides instant relief. Fits easily in her handbag or bedside drawer.
    • Arnica Hand & Joint Cream – This rich cream incorporates arnica, an ancient flower used for centuries to treat inflammation to help bring relief.
    • Lavender Eye Pillow – The combination of this pillow’s gentle weight and light lavender aroma help to calm the body and spirit. Can be cooled or heated.
    • Drift Bedtime Balm – This relaxing blend of lavender, chamomile and other natural sleep remedies help induce peaceful rest, naturally.
    • Beauty Bar Chocolate – Because, chocolate. Everyone needs a little dose of chocolate.
And they want you to spend $98 to give this package of quack remedies, questionable products, and placebos to someone you know who is menopausal. If I received the Care Package it would go straight into the trash.
The claims are not backed by scientific evidence and can be disregarded. I don’t agree that “everyone needs chocolate,” and I was appalled by the ingredients of the “Beauty Bar”. It contains ground up sea pearls for collagen, plus monk fruit and rhodiola. Do sea pearls contain collagen? No, of course they don’t. They supposedly contain amino acids that supposedly stimulate the skin to make its own collagen. And if you ate collagen in a chocolate bar, it would just be digested and would not contribute to the body’s store of collagen.
Conclusion: This is all just too silly
        ◦ It gets even sillier: they also sell a “Feel-Good Roll On“. Don’t waste your money. If you know someone with menopausal symptoms, it’s not taboo. Why not talk about it and educate them? Effective remedies are available. Isn’t reality preferable to fantasy? When my husband read about the Care Package, he said it was just a marketing trick designed to separate gullible customers from their money.

   Risibility. The Superior Therapeutic Intervention?
Mark Crislip
Link
Dad always thought laughter was the best medicine, which I guess is why several of us died of tuberculosis. ~Jack Handey, “Deep Thoughts“
We have a saying in medicine that you can’t kill a jerk. Not that we try to kill anyone, but that particularly unpleasant individuals, rife with psychopathology, survive whatever illness comes their way. The corollary is that particularly nice people are prone to having horrible diseases with unpleasant outcomes. We all know intellectually that it is not true, but there is an ongoing feeling in health care providers that somehow patient personality determines the consequences of their diseases. As an aside, I am often left with the explanation for patients that the reason for their odd infection comes down to bad luck. Everyone responds something to the effect that “Typical. I get all the bad luck.” I have never had a patient say, “That’s odd, I am usually so lucky.”
On the question of nurture versus nature, raising two children has convinced me of the relative lack of importance of nurture in the personalities of my children. While abusive/pathologic environments will certainly lead to pathologic personalities, for the average child raised in middle class America I can’t help but think that, to quote Popeye, “I yam what I yam and that’s all what I yam.” I expect to be schooled in the comments on that subject. Yes, I read the Blank Slate and have some understanding of the literature. And yet. My kids, my friends kids. I watch them grow in what is (and isn’t) a similar environment and end up with diverse personalities that often appear present before they can speak. I am well aware of the multiple logical fallacies that lead to that conclusion. Parenthood and medical practice (where people seem to do the same damn stupid things over and over) have lead me to the conclusion that free will is mostly a myth and we are mostly programmed to behave the way we do. Discuss. It is not the main point of the post, but my bias.
“Nothing shows a man’s character more than what he laughs at.” ~Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
One personality trait is a sense of humor. No one admits to being a bad driver and I have never met someone who admits that they lack a sense of humor. Humor is, of course, personal. I find Seinfeld irritating, not funny. The rest of my family does not share that assessment. During Pulp Fiction, my wife and I realized that we were the only ones in the theater laughing during the scene when they are doing a cardiac injection to revive Uma Thurman after her drug overdose. I once read that in choosing a mate, the best indication of long term compatibility was whether or not you both share a understanding of the essential hilarity of Bob and Ray. I would agree and wonder if eHarmony uses that in their compatibility tests. What would those examples say about whether or not I have a sense of humor and if so what kind?
What effects, if any, does a sense of humor have on health? Emotional states alter physiology, some for the better, some for the worse. The popular opinion is that laughter is of benefit; there is a reason Reader’s Digest didn’t call their column ‘Schadenfreude, the Best Medicine.’ Are funny people or people who laugh easily more prone to better health because they have a sense of humor or laugh? Or it is an association without causation, that whatever personality that laughs easily also leads to improved health outcomes?
“Whoever said ‘laughter is the best medicine’ never had gonorrhea.” ~Kat Likkel and John Hoberg
Perhaps the topic of laughing your way to health gained the most traction with the publication in 1979 of Norman Cousins book, Anatomy of an illness as perceived by the patient: reflections on healing. The book, which I read thirty years ago, details how, after being diagnosed with ankylosing spondylitis, Cousins left the hospital for a nice hotel, where he treated himself with good food, high dose vitamin C, and laughter from watching Marx brothers movies.
Did he have ankylosing spondylitis? The interwebs suggest he did not, and I can’t find the diagnostic criteria that were used to make the diagnosis and ankylosing spondylitis is a disease that can spontaneously resolve. So causality is particularly problematic in Cousins’ case, since the diagnosis is uncertain. Even though I am an avowed Marxist, I would be suspicious of the power of Duck Soup to alter the course of disease for the better, as is the popular misconception of Mr. Cousin’s book. I would not doubt that a good laugh will help decrease the perception of the severity of pain, as Mr Cousin’s suggested.
Is laughter medically beneficial? Is a sense of humor medically beneficial? Not the same question.
“Perhaps I know best why it is man alone who laughs; he alone suffers so deeply that he had to invent laughter.” ~Friedrich Nietzsche
Laughter, of note, is not limited to humans:
Vocalizations referred to as “laughter” also occur in great apes engaged in tickling and social play. Vettin and Todt have shown key similarities in the respective acoustics of play- and tickling-induced vocalizations in juvenile chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and tickling-induced laughter in adult humans.
They estimated that laughter has been present in the human lineage for 10 to 16 million years. I would estimate that is also how long humans have been farting. Still nothing funnier to my children.
And some suggest that rats have a laughter equivalent with play and tickling. Tickling rats. I laugh at the mental image. Is that laughter, if not the best medicine, a useful therapeutic intervention?
Laughter decreases blood glucose two hours after eating in type 2 diabetics. I prefer eating in restaurants. Laughter leads to vascular relaxation and decrease in serum cortisol, decreases renin in type 2 diabetics, and increases natural killer cell function.
Some studies seemed needlessly perverse:
Twenty-four male patients with atopic eczema viewed a humorous film (Modern Times, featuring Charlie Chaplin). Just before and immediately after viewing, semen was collected, and seminal B cells and sperms were purified. Seminal B cells were cultured with sperms and IgE production was measured, while expression of galectin-3 on sperms was assessed.
RESULTS: After viewing the humorous film, IgE production by B cells cultured with sperms was significantly decreased. Moreover, expression of galectin-3 on sperms was reduced.
I can’t access the complete reference to discover the rationale behind the study, except, perhaps, to induce giggling.
“I am thankful for laughter, except when milk comes out of my nose.” ~Woody Allen
Are there clinical correlates to these physiologic effects? Sort of.
Laughter may help the depressed (why wouldn’t it?) and cheer up the schizophrenic (what a surprise). Pello the clown, with his noted a humor intervention, decreased air trapping in COPD patients and laughing decreases the bronchial responsiveness in asthmatics.
That is about it for the medical application of laughter. A smattering of small studies, rarely repeated, with small numbers of patients published in the more obscure journals. I would not doubt the laughter is of benefit, but the benefit is small.
What is more interesting are the pathologic laughter syndromes: some (Angelmans) are genetic and some due to central nervous system strokes or tumors. I suppose the silver lining for these unfortunates is the beneficial physiologic effects of the continued laugher. Somehow the potential health benefits do not seem worth it.
These studies involved making people laugh, usually with movies. Humor is not without its dangers in the medical field, given the idiosyncratic nature of what people find funny.
When used sensitively, respecting the gravity of the situation, humor can build the connection among the caregiver, patient, and family. However, insensitive joking is offensive and distressing, and experience suggests a variable acceptance of humor by patients with life-threatening illnesses, making humor a high-risk strategy.
So if laughter is the best medicine, it is best used sparingly and with the knowledge that as an intervention to cause lasting physiologic change, laughter has had little support.
“A sense of humor always withers in the presence of the messianic delusion, like justice and truth in front of patriotic passion” ~ Henry Louis Mencken.
Maybe it is not laughing that is important, but the more vague idea of having a sense of humor, that is important to health.
Four studies have tested the association between sense of humour and longevity. One reported that comedians and serious entertainers on average die earlier than authors. Two publications from the Terman Life-Cycle Study reported a negative association. Cheerfulness (sense of humour and optimism) was the index variable in the first study. In the second study, optimism was taken out, but the negative association prevailed. The fourth study reported a 31% reduction of mortality risk among patients with end-stage renal failure provided that they scored above the median on a test of sense of humour.
Dr Sven Svebak evaluated a sense on humor based on three questions and looked at survival in a large cohort of Norwegians who were being followed for long term health, much like the Framingham study. The questions he used were
“Do you easily recognize a mark of humorous intent?” (Cognitive; N = 53,546; standardized item alpha = .91, item correlating .87 with sub-scale sum);
“Persons who are out to be funny are really irresponsible types not to be relied upon” (Social; N = 52,198; standardized item alpha = .91, item correlating .88 with sub-scale sum); and
“Do you consider yourself to be a mirthful person?” (Affective; N = 53,132; standardized item alpha = .74, item correlating .78 with sub-scale sum).
The participants responded to four-step scales (labeled for the three items respectively: very sluggishly – very easily; yes indeed – not at all; not at all – yes indeed).
Not an impressive criteria for determining a sense of humor and this is noted in the discussion of the article. ”It may be regarded a hazardous task to assess psychological characteristics by use of three items.” However, they felt that similar studies in depression validated the approach.
These questions measure friendly humor. The test is not sensitive to humor that creates conflicts, is insulting or that is a variation of bullying. So much for laughing at my posts as evidence of a sense of humor.
What they found was those with a friendly sense of humor as judged by these three questions were more likely to survive compared to those that scored low on a sense of humor.
The authors are quite thoughtful on the applicability of this study:
There is a semantic point in the affective item where “mirthful” was used in the present study instead of “cheerful.” In Norwegian as well as English language “cheerful” and “mirthful” (Norwegian equivalent “munter”) can refer to a subjective state of mirthfulness as well as to the overt expression of mirth through smiling and laughing. The present assessment was by subjective report that may have addressed both the subjective and the expressive tendencies of an individual for being mirthful. A subjective state of mirthfulness appears to be closely related to cognitive processes, whereas expressive display is often triggered by social context. Support to this view came from the relatively high coefficient of correlation between scores on the cognitive and the affective items (r = .40: Table 4). In prospective studies of positive wellbeing, subjective state appears to have been at focus and has proven to reduce mortality. This association has been a fairly consistent pattern of outcome in prospective studies of healthy populations as well as of diseased populations.
In light of these findings for positive wellbeing, as well as of the complex conceptual content of sense of humor, it is possible that sense of humor is best conceived of as one aspect of a broader psychological characteristic that facilitates a general state of wellbeing, rather than a specific emotional state of mirthfulness.
Emphasis mine. I think this is interesting and have little argument with the study except in on interview, Dr. Svebak stated “He adds that a sense of humor can be learned and improved through practice.”
There I have my doubts. I cannot find evidence that people can learn to appreciate humor or learn to become humorous. In my experience (do I dare use those words?) the capacity for understanding and producing humor appears fixed.
That has therapeutic implications. If a sense of humor can be developed, the humorless grouch can be taught to laugh and experience the benefits of humor. More likely, your sense of humor, like your ability to run the mile or learn French, is mostly static in the adult.
Being thoughtful, the authors conclude
There is a risk of taking the present humor findings too far as a booster of longevity. The role of confounding variables is hard to precisely assess in multi- variate approaches, partly because of the often opportunistic availability of such variables in population research projects as well as all the potentially relevant variables that may have been included, but were left out for many reasons, such as lack of funding and time consuming data sampling procedures. The present study included quite a range of variables that are well established in the scientific community as influencing health hazard. A cautious approach is to directly compare hazard ratios across the range of variables, including traditional risk variables as well as an index of sense of humor.
An interesting study with a nuanced discussion. However, a molehill of interesting information does not prevent some doctors for making a mountain of advice. The You Docs are hard at work again.
“Analyzing humor is like dissecting a frog. Few people are interested and the frog dies of it.” ~EB White
In this new Norwegian study, researchers who tracked the health of 70,000 people found that those who scored highest on sense-of-humor tests were twice as likely as dour sorts to still be alive — and laughing — seven years later. You didn’t have to be the type that laughs at the drop of a hat, either. All sorts of humor styles boosted survival. “A twinkle in your eye can be more than enough,” notes lead researcher Sven Svebak of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology.
Oh, for that twinkle in the eye, the key to health. The study, based on three questions, makes no conclusions based on humor styles.
What’s behind humor’s life-prolonging powers? For one thing, laughter is a mini-workout. Ten to 15 minutes of mirth burns up to 40 calories and exercises your abdominal muscles.
About the same as is burned during 15 minutes of sex. For a real work out combine the two as has been what my partners do… I may be oversharing here. Everything can be considered a “mini workout” and is a lame reason to suggest laughter as medicine. Given how much I laugh, where is my 6-pack?
The You Docs evidently reviewed the same marginal literature and discovered that
A good belly laugh also boosts your immunity, motivating natural killer cells in your bloodstream to work harder.
In one study, watching a funny movie relaxed the endothelium — the fragile inner lining of your arteries — enough to boost blood flow by 15 percent. Laughter eases stress and reduces levels of the high-anxiety hormone, cortisol. In people with diabetes, it can even help keep blood sugar lower and steadier.
Then there’s resilience. Laughter helps you build and maintain friendships, eases fears and gives you a hand at coping with whatever life throws your way. It may also thwart the flu and protect against cancer.
The last two I cannot find the reference for, but protecting against cancer? My goodness. They make it sound so all encompassing, rather than the limited results I found. And they never mentioned the sperms.
“What soap is to the body, laughter is to the soul.” ~Yiddish Proverb
The You Docs end with suggesting by suggesting you get a daily dose of humor for its health benefits, and they give multiple ways to find a good laugh. It is interesting how the authors of the study suggest that humor is part of an over-arching personality, whilst the You Docs go for simplistic and overwrought advice:
Get your daily quota of yucks. Check in with yourself at lunch time: Have you chuckled today, or maybe even gotten that tingly “this is hysterically funny” feeling? If not, do something about it. E-mail or call your funniest friend. Plan to watch your favorite sitcom or wise-cracking commentator tonight. The Web is loaded with joke sites, bookstores are brimming with humor books, video stores offer thousands of comedies and stand-up comic shows. Make it a point to learn at least one new joke a week, then tell it to your friends.
See the humor in your life. You took the stray cat you rescued to be spayed and discovered that she’s a he? Trade funny stories: Make it a habit to ask friends and family about the most ridiculous thing that’s happened to them today, this week, this month.
Discover what really tickles your funny bone. Your sense of humor is as unique as your fingerprints, so stop laughing at what you think you ought to find amusing (Who does that? Besides Ed McMahon? If he had heeded that advice, he would have lived longer than 86 years) and do a little research into what really hits your sweet spot. Try watching, reading or listening to types of humor that are new for you. You may discover you prefer political humor or cowboy jokes, martini-dry wit or a really bad knock-knock (Or the You Docs).
For me, it is reading the You Docs.
It is always curious how a few studies of limited scope get inflated. Sad advice really. Research what makes you laugh. That is one of many annoyances of the alt med life style recommendation: the medicalization of the joys of life. Drink red wine because it is good for you, not because it is joy in a bottle. Eat chocolate because it is a natural medicine, not because it is delicious. Laugh because it improves your health, but not because it soothes your soul. I prefer to laugh and eat and drink and work for the significant pleasures these things provide, not for their minimal health benefits. Live a good life and you will reap the rewards. I see a lot of people at the end of their lives. When people look back, the regrets they express are not for the time they wished they had spent laughing to manage their sugars, but the time they did not spend laughing with their loved ones.
Fortunately I read the You Docs: they provide me yucks, in both senses of the word. As a result I expect I am never going to get ill, never get cancer and will live forever.

   Cell Phones and Behavior
Steven Novella
Link
Cell phones continue to be a focus of epidemiological studies and public concern, despite the fact that so far there is no compelling evidence of any health risk from cell phones. Concerns are likely to be sparked anew with the report of a study linking cell phone use to behavioral problems in children.
The study, by Divan, Kheifets, Obel, and Olsen, is a follow up of a prior study which showed a correlation between cell phone use in pregnant women and behavior problems in their children. They sought to replicate this study with a larger data set and taking into consideration more possible confounding factors. They found:
Results The highest OR for behavioural problems were for children who had both prenatal and postnatal exposure to cell phones compared with children not exposed during either time period. The adjusted effect estimate was 1.5 (95% CI 1.4 to 1.7).
Conclusions The findings of the previous publication were replicated in this separate group of participants demonstrating that cell phone use was associated with behavioural problems at age 7 years in children, and this association was not limited to early users of the technology. Although weaker in the new dataset, even with further control for an extended set of potential confounders, the associations remained.
For children of mothers who used cell phones, and who also used cell phones themselves, there was a 50% relative increase in reported behavioral problems. For children who did not use cell phones but whose mothers did while pregnant, the relative increase was 40% – these relative increases are with an absolute baseline risk of 2% reporting behavioral problems (so a 50% relative increase would be a 1% absolute increase in risk). This is a small, if statistically significant, effect. An odds ratio of 1.5 is a reasonable effect size, depending on what is being measured. In this case the outcomes were based upon questionnaires, and are therefore reliant on subjective reporting.
The results of this study are interesting, but the usual caveats apply. The absolute effect size is small, and the outcomes based upon subjective reporting. This is an observational study, not an experimental study, so no conclusions can be drawn regarding cause and effect. The study authors did not even speculate about a possible mechanism, and would not suggest that cell phone use causes the observed behavior problems.
It should also be noted that while this study replicated a previous study, the effect size was smaller. Also, accounting for other possible correlates, such as social status and maternal history of behavioral problems, tended to decrease the effect size as well (although not eliminate it).
It is possible that the correlation is spurious or is an artifact of reporting bias. If the correlation is real, it seems likely that there are confounding factors that have not been sufficiently accounted for. The authors themselves considered as many as possible. They report:
“One thought was that it was it not cellphone use but mothers’ inattention that led to behavior problems. While it was important, it didn’t explain the association that we found.”
So inattention partially explained the results – perhaps other behavioral or personality attributes also correlate with both cell phone use and behavior problems. Given that the absolute effect size is small (about 1%) there can be many such factors that can exert such an effect, and it is unlikely that the authors thought of all of them.
The plausibility of a direct effect of cell phone use is quite low. Physicists have pointed out that cell phones generate only small amounts of energy, the primary effect of which is to heat up surrounding tissue. But the non-ionizing radiation from cell phones, by definition, is of too low energy to break chemical bonds or cause any cellular damage. Concerns over cell phone use have largely surrounded the risk of brain cancer, and epidemiological studies have not shown increase in brain cancer overall or an increased risk correlating with cell phone use. The data does not entirely clear cell phones either, but so far the evidence does not support a link.
Given the low biological plausibility and generally negative epidemiological data, it is unlikely that cell phones directly cause any biological harm. This also applies to behavioral problems, as investigated in this study.
Conclusion
While sure to garner headlines, this study is not compelling evidence that cell phones are a health concern with regard to behavioral problems in children. The study found a small absolute effect size which is very likely to be due to confounding factors that were insufficiently accounted for in this study. It is very difficult to derive any firm conclusions from observational studies such as this. Many such studies are required to pinpoint a likely cause and effect relationship – no one observational study can do this.
I do not even think that this study warrants precautionary measures, as the likelihood of a real risk from cell phones is small and implausible. Cell phone use is increasingly common, and epidemiological studies such as this are certain to turn up a great deal of noise in the data – apparent correlations or the downstream effects of complex behavioral influences. There are likely to be more studies showing similar apparent correlations and it would be premature to respond to each one with calls for precautionary measures.
At best this study suggests questions for future research. But the results are within the predictable noise of preliminary epidemiological data that is best ignored by the public. Most such correlations do not hold up with future research and the ultimate interpretation of such correlations is often different from the most direct cause and effect that grabs headlines and public attention. Basing decisions on preliminary epidemiological evidence such as this is likely to be unnecessarily disruptive and inconvenient and is unlikely to provide any health benefit.

   Prepare for Surgery, Heal Faster?
Kimball Atwood
Link
Quacks and their apologists often cite surgery and emergency treatments of traumatic injury and a few other catastrophic or potentially catastrophic events as the only ”conventional” or “allopathic” methods that they consistently recommend. Explicitly or implicitly, for most problems they tout “holistic” or “CAM” treatments. In modern medicine, however, there are plenty of non-surgical and non-emergency treatments whose outcomes are so manifest that even the most exuberant advocates of implausible medical claims (IMC) seem careful to steer clear, lest they blow their cover. Where are the promoters or consumers of homeopathic contraceptives? Why haven’t we heard of a chiropractic adjustment for high blood sugar? How many pitches for Ayurvedic treatments of gout have you seen? There are exceptions, of course, the most notable being the nearly ubiquitous anti-immunization stance among IMC promoters.
Anesthesiology and Implausible Claims
In my day job I specialize in anesthesiology, a non-surgical field whose methods are so obviously effective that little is heard from the IMC crowd. Consider: is it likely that even the slickest of the current crop of snake oil salesmen, if they had the bad sense to try, could talk many people into accepting an implausible method for rendering the body insensible to pain? No, that would require a more effective form of persuasion, such as that used in China to promote “acupuncture anesthesia” from the mid-1950s until the end of the Cultural Revolution in 1976. That’s a story I’ll tell another time.
A few other implausible claims have crept into the broader realm of anesthesiology. Stimulation of the “pericardial 6″ acupuncture point on the ventral aspect of the wrist is said to prevent post-operative nausea. There is little basis for this, the Cochrane Review notwithstanding. Verbal messages, given to a patient under general anesthesia, are said to result in “faster healing.” The major proponent of this claim is Peggy Huddleston, a self-described psychotherapist with an M.T.S. (Master of Theological Studies) degree from the Harvard Divinity School. Ms. Huddleston appears to have parlayed the “faster healing” claim into a successful entreprenurial venture, featuring a website, workshops, CDs, and a book:
The book and the website are chock full of flattering endorsements. Most are from usual IMC suspects such as Andrew Weil, psychokinesis proponent Larry Dossey, Christiane Northrup (who wrote the book’s foreward), Therapeutic Touch guru Jean Watson, “medical intuitive” Caroline Myss and her patron, former neurosurgeon and “Holistic Person of the Year” C. Norman Shealy, cardiac surgeon Mehmet Oz, whose apparent scientific naiveté is more than matched by his expertise in making a buck from nonsense and banalities, and “mind/body” maven Joan Borysenko.
Some of the endorsements are from people who should know better, such as surgeon Susan Troyan and anesthesiologist Gerald Zeitlin, and four surgeons who appear on a series of “Testimonial” DVDs available for purchase on Ms. Huddleston’s website. I’ve met or worked with each of the MDs who should know better, and I’m guessing that none has bothered to consider Ms. Huddleston’s claims in more than a fleeting way. Rather, they are understandably more than willing to endorse a program that appeals to a few of their patients, particularly those who are frightened.
Plausible Claims, Prosaic Claims
Indeed, one of Ms. Huddleston’s core claims is entirely plausible:
…if you are facing major surgery, or a life-threatening condition, surgery can be frightening. The mind-body techniques you’ll learn here will give you ways to cope with your fears and actually feel peaceful during the hours, days and weeks before your operation.
Relaxation exercises, including visual imagery, really do help some people feel less anxious. It is even plausible that feeling less anxious can seem to reduce pain, because the discomfort of pain is reasonably construed as two distinct phenomena: the pain per se and the associated anxiety. To the extent that anxiety can be alleviated by non-narcotic means, it is reasonable to predict that narcotic requirements will be reduced. In 1977 a psychiatrist at the Massachusetts General Hospital made this point to a group of medical students, including me, in the context of teaching us to do hypnosis (so much for that being defined as “unconventional medicine” by virtue of its not being taught in medical schools).
It is also conceivable that a reduction in narcotic requirements might reduce the time a patient remains in the hospital after surgery, which is a recurrent claim in Ms. Huddleston’s book. This could be true because the need for pain medicine requires hospitalization only if the medicine must be given “parenterally,” i.e., by the intravenous or intramuscular route, and because ambulation and return of bowel function (in the case of patients who have undergone intra-abdominal surgery) occur sooner if the patient has had less narcotic. Ms. Huddleston’s claim that her method reduces hospital stays by an average of 1.5 days, however, requires more evidence than mere possibilities. More on that below.
Another of Ms. Huddleston’s claims is not only plausible, but is nearly self-evident and has been accepted for more than 40 years: meeting the anesthesiologist before surgery reduces a patient’s anxiety. Other assertions in the book are equally reasonable, if equally self-evident: talk with your surgeon, ask about alternatives, consider seeking a second opinion, discuss plans for post-operative pain medicines, ask about donating your own blood in advance in case you need a transfusion (although Ms. Huddleston is incorrect when she states that doing so confers ”no risk to being exposed to disease,” because clerical errors in blood banking still apply), consider short-term psychotherapy if you’re really scared, and a few more. If these were her only claims, Ms. Huddleston’s book would hardly be worthy of a skeptical review here at SBM. It would also hardly be worthy of having been written.
Extraordinary Claims
No matter: a series of other claims impugns the book, among which a few examples follow.
…recent studies have documented that care, appreciation and love boost the immune system and enhance the functioning of the heart…Since the heart creates a large electrical field of energy that influences every cell, this has a very positive effect on the entire body.
Your illness or physical condition is already trying to “talk” to you, telling you that something is amiss. Your intuition knows what is out of balance and causing a health problem. Allow yourself to hear what it is.
While surgery will correct the physical problem, you’ll want to look for the underlining [sic] emotional component that may be causing it. Often there is one.
The key to her recovery was sending healing to her finger whenever the thought of it came into her mind. It was a simple but profound act. It re-established the natural flow of energy to her arm and finger. With time, this allowed her broken finger to mend as well as her broken heart.
Without touching the body, practitioners use their hands to influence the field of energy that pulsates in and around the physical body. Physicists call this a force field. A growing body of clinical research shows that Therapeutic Touch lowers blood pressure, reduces pain and helps wounds heal faster.
The results of Dr. Byrd’s [intercessory prayer] study are remarkable. If a drug study had these results, it would be hailed, becoming the drug of choice.
Lakota children could easily merge their beings with an eagle, soaring with it through the clouds.
If you can’t use anesthesia or pain killers, acupuncture makes even major surgery free of pain. For 5,000 years, acupuncture has also been used for the treatment and prevention of disease.
You’ll use less pain medication after surgery if your anesthesiologist says three Healing Statements to you during surgery. Medical research documents the dramatic benefits…Therapeutic statements will someday be a routine procedure…While there is ongoing scientific debate about how much an anesthetized patient can hear, one point is clear: We never stop hearing.
Many of these claims are familiar to SBM readers or are plainly absurd, and need not be discussed here. I’ve already promised to discuss acupuncture-as-anesthesia at another time. Here I’ll limit my comments to the last claim, which is both less familiar than the rest and the crux of the book. Here is her summary of “Healing Statements for Surgery” that Ms. Huddleston recommends be recited to patients under general anesthesia:
(Give this page to your surgeon and another to your anesthesiologist. Tape a third page to your hospital gown, so it is visible as you go into surgery.)
As I am going under anesthesia, please say:
#1. “Following this operation, you will feel comfortable and you will heal very well.” (Repeat 5 times.)
After saying the statments, please put on my earphones and start my tape player.
Toward the end of surgery, remove my earphones. Say:
#2. “Your operation has gone very well.” (Repeat 5 times.)
#3. “Following this operation, you will be hungry for ______________ .You will be thirsty and you will urinate easily.” (Repeat 5 times.)
#4. “Following this operation ____________________________________________________ .” Fill in your surgeon’s recommendations for recovery. (Repeat 5 times.)
Ms. Huddleston offers several references in support of this claim, most of which are either more than 40 years old, were never published, or are book chapters rather than scientific papers. Two exceptions are controlled trials that are about 20 years old. The first, of which I’ve only read the abstract, is a small study that reports shorter hospitalizations and shorter periods of fever in the study group. The second is slightly larger; its entire report is available online. It reports modestly reduced post-operative morphine use in the study group, but no differences in pain scores or nausea. It did not address duration of hospitalization.
What Ms. Huddleston fails to tell us is that there have been numerous other relevant studies, many of which preceded her book’s original publication in 1996 and almost all of which preceded her book’s 2nd edition of 2006. Although there are exceptions, the preponderant findings fail to support her claim. That aggregate result, as Steve Novella pointed out recently, is the real story here. There is also a body of literature demonstrating that various agents used for general anesthesia suppress recall and learning in a dose-dependent fashion, exactly as someone familiar with biology would predict.
Can Pre-Operative Psychological Intervention Reduce Hospital Stays?
What about the more plausible notion that pre-operative suggestions, particularly those aimed at reducing anxiety, can reduce the duration of hospitalization? In her book Ms. Huddleston offers two references. One reports an earlier return of bowel function in patients who have undergone intra-abdominal surgery if they had previously received a suggestion that their bowel function would return promptly. The control group received a non-specific “reassuring” suggestion, so it can be argued that the two groups had equivalent anxiety-reducing interventions. The study was small, and the identical number of 20 subjects in each group casts doubt upon its claim of randomization. Ms. Huddleston’s other reference has no abstract.
On her website, Ms. Huddleston cites three studies purporting to show that her own method leads to favorable outcomes, including shorter hospital stays. She provides abstracts for two of the studies (here and here), neither of which appears to have been subsequently published. The third, a letter published in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, looked at non-surgical subjects and fails to support her claim, merely reporting “a tendency for a decrease in anxiety in the imagery group.”
There is, nevertheless, a body of literature that gives modest if inconsistent support for the notion that reducing anxiety may be helpful in various ways, including a reduction in requirements for pain medicine and reduced hospital stays. Do patients actually “heal faster”? Ms. Huddleston offers several anecdotes in her book to suggest that this is the case—with the word “heal” actually used in its literal sense—but there is no literature to support it.
Vitamins?
An appendix in Ms. Huddleston’s book is titled “Vitamins that Speed Healing,” written by Judith Petry, MD. It sensibly advises against “supplements” that are known to delay blood clotting. It recommends vitamins A and C and bromelain to “improve the immune system” and “promote healing.” For these recommendations it cites “volumes of medical literature,” all from the 1960s and ’70s. I hope that few post-menopausal women will take the vitamin A recommendation seriously, because doing so over several years will likely result in an increase in the number of hip fractures.
It’s funny that Dr. Petry did not mention vitamins that probably do improve certain outcomes after anesthesia. It turns out that nitrous oxide, until recently a nearly ubiquitous agent in general anesthetics, increases plasma homocysteine levels by means that are entirely understood. It also turns out that this increase in homocysteine, a substance known to be a risk factor for heart attacks and strokes, confers an increased risk of post-operative myocardial ischemia (inadequate blood supply to the heart muscle). Finally, the pre-operative ingestion of three vitamins—folic acid, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12—prevents this effect by entirely known mechanisms. Although the use of nitrous oxide has diminished markedly over the past few years, precisely because of such findings, it still might be useful for some patients to be aware of the risk and its simple prevention.
Conclusion
Ms. Huddleston’s book, like much of the literature espoused by her champions, is a mixture of unremarkable suggestions and extraordinary claims for which there is no credible evidence. Her business appears to be booming: at about $500 a pop, she has grossed more than $3 million in 2-day Workshops alone, and she needn’t even be present. Her asking fee for a one-hour talk at Grand Rounds, according to Someone Who Knows, is about $5000. Her fee for a 50-minute phone call, by comparison, is a mere $155. I dunno how much she’s made from her book and her tapes, but she also invites websurfers to make tax-deductible contributions to her Foundation, in order to fund more promotional studies. Not bad work if you can get it.

   Fatigued by a Fake Disease
Scott Gavura
Link
One of the realities of being a pharmacist is that we’re easily accessible. There’s no appointment necessary for consultation and advice at the pharmacy counter. Questions range from “Does this look infected?” (Yes) to “What should I do about this chest pain?” to more routine questions about conditions that can easily be self-treated. Part of the pharmacist’s role is triage — advising on conditions that can be self-managed, and making medical referrals when warranted. Among the most common questions I receive are related to stress and fatigue. Energy levels are are down, and patients want advice, and solutions. Some want a “quick fix,” believing that the right combination of B-vitamins are all that stand between them and unlimited energy. Others may ask if prescription drugs or caffeine tablets could help. Evaluating vague symptoms is a challenge. Many of us have busy lifestyles, and don’t get the sleep and exercise we need. We may compromise our diets in the interest of time and convenience. With some simple questions I might make a few basic lifestyle recommendations, talk about the evidence supporting supplements, and suggest physician follow-up if symptoms persist. Fatigue and stress may be part of life, but they’re also symptoms of serious medical conditions. But they can be hard to treat because they’re non-specific and may not be easily distinguishable from the fatigue of, well, life.
This same vague collection of symptoms is called something entirely different in the alternative health world. It’s branded “adrenal fatigue,” an invented condition that’s widely embraced as real among alternative health providers. There’s no evidence that adrenal fatigue actually exists. The public education arm of the Endocrine Society, representing 14,000 endocrinologists, recently issued the following advisory:
“Adrenal fatigue” is not a real medical condition. There are no scientific facts to support the theory that long-term mental, emotional, or physical stress drains the adrenal glands and causes many common symptoms.
Unequivocal words. But facts about adrenal fatigue neatly illustrate why a science-based approach is a consumer’s best protection against being diagnosed with a fake disease.
The adrenals are a pair of glands that sit on the kidneys and produce several hormones, including the stress hormones epinephrine and norepiniephrine that are associated with the “fight or flight” response. Can you tire these glands out? In the absence of any scientific evidence, chiropractor and naturopath James Wilson coined the term “adrenal fatigue” in his 1998 book of the same name. Take a look at the James’ own questionnaire, at adrenalfatigue.org, to see if you have have it. Do you ever experience the following?
     1.  Tired for no reason?
     2.  Having trouble getting up in the morning?
     3.  Need coffee, cola, salty or sweet snacks to keep going?
     4.  Feeling run down and stressed?
     5.  Crave salty or sweet snacks?
     6.  Struggling to keep up with life’s daily demands?
     7.  Can’t bounce back from stress or illness?
     8.  Not having fun anymore?
     9.  Decreased sex drive?
If you answered yes to any of these questions, you may have adrenal fatigue.
Some lifestyles are apparently more vulnerable to adrenal fatigue, including single parents, shift workers, an “unhappily married person”, and the “person who is all work, no play.” There’s no information provided to substantiate the quiz, qualify the vague terminology, or link to any relevant literature. (Of course there is the usual Quack Miranda warning which makes all of this possible: “These statements have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration … etc.”)
Based on this quiz, it’s safe to assume that adrenal fatigue is the most prevalent fake disease in the world. And sure enough, that’s what its proponents think, too:
Dr. John Tinterra, a medical doctor who specialized in low adrenal function, said in 1969 that he estimated that approximately 16% of the public could be classified as severe, but that if all indications of low cortisol were included, the percentage would be more like 66%. This was before the extreme stress of 21st century living, 9/11, and the severe economic recession we are experiencing.
So let’s look into the medical literature on adrenal fatigue. There’s no entry in Dorland’s medical dictionary, nor does the ICD classify it as a medical condition. Pubmed lists only one relevant paper which is a review by two naturopaths, and published in the Alternative Medicine Review. But there’s no evidence for them to review.
Fake diseases are compilations of various symptoms into conditions without any scientific basis. Peter Lipson has examined this in detail here at SBM. As Dr. Lipson points out, it’s human nature to want answers and to understand patterns of symptoms. Defining a cluster of symptoms in general terms is the first mistake. Symptoms need to be collated in a rational way to understand the parameters of the disorder. With adrenal fatigue, there’s no objective operational description, nor is there a validated symptom score. Using a vague list of symptoms to identify patients is the second mistake. While laboratory tests are advertised for identifying adrenal fatigue, there’s no persuasive data to demonstrate that blood or saliva tests provide any meaningful information, or are correlated with any underlying pathology.
Adrenal fatigue shouldn’t be confused with adrenal insufficiency, a legitimate medical condition that can be diagnosed with laboratory tests and has a defined symptomatology. Addison’s disease causes primary adrenal insufficiency and usually has an autoimmune cause, with symptoms appearing when most of the adrenal cortex has been destroyed. Secondary adrenal insufficiency is cause by pituitary disorder that gives insufficient hormonal stimulation to the adrenals. Some liken adrenal fatigue to a milder form of adrenal insufficiency — but there’s no underlying pathology that has been associated with adrenal fatigue. That’s actually a common method of disease invention: take a real disease and claim that it exists in a subclinical form, though of course it lacks a single unambiguous sign or symptom. We are supposed to believe that it’s still a serious problem even though it is, by definition, so mild that it is undiagnosable by any physician.
While adrenal fatigue may not exist, the same can’t be said for the treatments. When you’re treating a fake disease, anything goes. Everything from homeopathy to herbal remedies to hydrotherapy, to traditional Chinese medicine and vitamin supplements are advocated for treatment. The endpoints of treatment are as nonspecific as the criteria for diagnosis. Young, conveniently, has his own supplement programs. The Adrenal Fatigue Institute (apparently unrelated to Young) sells a supplement called Cylapril via TV infomercials and online ads. Disappointingly but perhaps not suprisingly, there are a number of health professionals that offer adrenal fatigue services, from labs that will diagnose it with scientific-looking lab reports [PDF], to pharmacies that offer specialty-compounded adrenal fatigue products.
Conclusion
While adrenal fatigue may not exist, this doesn’t mean the symptoms people experience aren’t real. These same symptoms could be caused by true medical conditions such as sleep apnea, adrenal insufficiency, or depression. Accepting a fake disease diagnosis from an unqualified practitioner is arguably worse. Patients don’t receive a science-based evaluation of their symptoms, and they may be sold unnecessary treatments that are probably ineffective and potentially harmful. There’s no question that it would be frustrating to be experiencing fatigue symptoms and then to be told by a health professional that there is nothing medically wrong. But that is arguably better than the distraction of treating a fictitious condition.

Cytotron – Magical Device Pseudoscience
The claims of Neurocytonix are extraordinary and dubious.
Steven Novella on December 6, 2023
Tweet

The news media loves their human interest stories, which often take the form of some likable person suffering from a medical condition who benefits from an experimental or fringe treatment. Throw in a celebrity angle, and you have pop media gold. This narrative fits perfectly with quack treatments, and allows charlatans easy access to free media exposure.
This story from the Mail Online (hardly a respected outlet) is a great example. Former rugby star, Alix Popham, is apparently suffering from early onset dementia, thought linked to his sports career through thousands of sub-concussions. Research has shown a potential link between sports that involve minor head trauma and early onset neurodegenerative diseases. In this Lancet study, the risk of dementia was increased in professional soccer players who frequently head the ball, but not for goalies who rarely head the ball. This likely relates to what is now called chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE).
The Mail reports:
The 44-year-old is the first former professional sportsman to undergo this treatment in South America being conducted by pioneering American biotech firm Neurocytonix for incurable neurological disorders.
This, of course, raises immediate red flags for me. Any new treatment for incurable neurodegenerative diseases would be massive news, and perhaps the biggest medical news over my entire neurological career. A new treatment coming out of the blue without a long history of academic research and published papers, from basic science through animal research and finally human research, is also suspect. Further, an American company conducting treatments in Mexico raises eyebrows – raising the possibility they are evading US regulations. In fairness, the founder and CEO of Neurocytonix, Dr. J Roberto Trujillo, is Mexican American, which may be the explanation, but still Mexico would be the friendlier venue.
Popham’s story, as told, is also not very compelling. He speaks of having headaches associated with light-sensitivity – that sounds like migraine. A temporary improvement in migraines could be random or due to lots of factors, and could be misinterpreted by Popham as his underlying dementia improving (especially if that is what he is being told to expect). Further, Popham says he felt improvement after three days. That is implausibly fast for a treatment that is supposed to cause neuronal regeneration. An implausibly fast response to treatment is a classic sign of placebo effects.
The treatment is based on a machine, the cytotron, developed by Dr. Rajah V Kumar. It uses magnetic fields and radiofrequency treatments. Kumar has been using the machine to treat cancer and osteoarthritis. He bills it as “tissue engineering”. Strange that the same device will kill cells to treat cancer, and also cause neuronal regeneration. Looks like another case of a treatment in search of an indication. Trujillo picked up the device and rebranded it as a Neurocytotron.
Neurocytonix claims they completed a clinical trial involving cerebral palsy in January 2023. They do have a registered clinical trial, but no official results. They say they are preparing papers for publication, but PubMed has nothing so far. Taking a year to publish results is not unusual in itself, but the more time goes by without a publication the more suspicious it becomes. There is a history of trials for dubious treatment somehow never being published. The trials themselves are simply used to give the patina of legitimacy. Neurocytonix reports that “The results of this clinical trial provide support for additional studies.” I would think that if the results were clearly positive, they would say so. The conclusion that the results “support further research” is well known here at SBM as a euphemism for “negative”.
If you look for images related to Neurocytonix you see lots of images like this one. This is clearly false color, meant to show the growth of new neuronal pathways. But of course, we have no idea if this is legitimate. These kinds of images are easy to manipulate, or just select the images that tell the story you want to tell. Without proper blinding and controls, we can’t really draw any conclusions. But they do make for good marketing.
The Mail concedes, “the science still needs to be proven through clinical trial”, just as an aside, as if it is just a bookkeeping thing, like dotting the “i’s”. Of course, the science is where most new treatments fail.
The claims being made for the Neurocytotron are highly implausible. Neural regeneration in the central nervous system is perhaps one of the most challenging research problems in neurology. In many ways it is the holy grail for neurological research.
It is highly unlikely that a repurposed cancer-treating machine from India has suddenly solved this vexing problem, through something as simple as magnetic and radio frequency waves. This is beyond an extraordinary claim. What we have so far is just hype – no scientific evidence, let alone extraordinary evidence. Unfortunately, in my opinion, this has all the red flags of a dubious and exploitative fringe treatment.
Spreading hype about this treatment online and in news media, before a single paper is published, is also highly irresponsible. Something like this should not rise to the level of popular reporting until it has passed some basic thresholds of science. If it were legitimate, there are standard procedures for evaluation. First we should see some basic science showing why these frequencies should cause the central nervous system to do something it does not ordinarily do. Then let’s see some proof of concept with plated neurons, and then in animals studies. There is no mention of any such research on their website and nothing I can find on PubMed. Finally we then need human clinical trials showing safety and efficacy. Again – we have nothing.
I will keep an eye on that one registered trial, to see if they ever publish the results and what it shows. In the meantime, I remain highly skeptical of these claims.

CAM for the Management of Heart Failure
A new report provides a comprehensive summary of the evidence for and against CAM in patients with heart failure.
Scott Gavura on February 2, 2023
Tweet
Complementary and alternative medicines (CAM) are medical products and services that are considered “outside” conventional medicine, but are intended to prevent or treat illness. CAM is big business, and widely used: Most Americans take some sort of supplement. While CAM is purported to be effective for many medical conditions, the evidence supporting routine use is very limited. Heart failure is a common cardiovascular disease affecting over 6 million Americans and causing substantial morbidity and mortality. A scientific statement from the American Heart Association was recently published and is intended to give patients, the public, and health professionals a comprehensive summary of the efficacy and safety of CAM in patients with heart failure.
What is heart failure
Heart failure, also called congestive heart failure, is a chronic, progressive medical condition that is the result of your heart’s inability to meet the needs of the body. In heart failure, a weak heart cannot supply the body with enough blood. It can occur when the heart cannot fill with enough blood and/or when the heart is too weak to pump properly. Symptoms include weakness and difficulty with activities like walking or climbing stairs. Heart failure can cause the heart itself to adapt (enlarging and developing more muscle mass) and also cause a number of compensations in the body that may partially alleviate some of the problems, while causing other problems (e.g., kidney and liver damage). There are two main types of heart failure (left sided vs right sided, referring to the sides of the heart) that can affect the treatment approaches taken.
Treatments for heart failure are determine based on the type of heart failure and the underlying cause. Core recommendations include regular exercise, ceasing any tobacco use, and managing conditions like hypertension and high cholesterol. Surgery or other interventions may be appropriate (e.g., coronary artery blockage) and medications may be recommended depending on the severity of the disease. The overarching goal is to control symptoms and preserve/extend quality of life.
CAM for heart failure
As has been pointed out in many prior posts, CAM is not regulated like conventional medicine in most countries. Regulators tend to use a “light touch” with these products and generally do not subject them to the same requirements for manufacturing or for evidence to support any claims of efficacy. It is perhaps because of this confusion that CAM is widely used despite a general lack of evidence to suggest these products are high quality, safe and effective. It is estimated that over 30% of heart failure patients may be using CAM.
Given the popularity of CAM and the importance of medical therapy for the treatment of heart failure, patients and practitioners alike need to understand the effects, benefits and risks of CAM in the management of this disease. To support this, a group of cardiologists, pharmacists, scientists and a nurse practitioner undertook a comprehensive literature search to identify (1) evidence for efficacy of CAM in heart failure and (2) evidence on the safety of CAM, including the repercussions of combining CAM with heart failure medications.
The paper is titled “Complementary and Alternative Medicines in the Management of Heart Failure: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association” and it was published in December, 2022. The statement includes a detailed summary on the oversight and regulation of CAM (from a US perspective) but also discussed global utilization trends. The authors caution that health care professionals and patients should be aware of the regulatory status of CAM if considering these therapies.
CAM efficacy in heart failure
Several CAM products have been investigated in clinical trials, and some have been associated with improvements in symptoms, functional capacity and quality of life. The report has a detailed summary of the mechanism of action (if known), the evidence, known benefits, and harms. I’ll provide a short summary and highlight some of the products here, but please refer to the report for the full details.
Alcohol – I wouldn’t consider alcohol CAM, but this statement does. Observational data suggests low-to-moderate amounts of alcohol may be associated with a reduced risk of developing heart failure. Habitual consumption or abuse of alcohol is a known cause of cardiomyopathy (heart enlargement) and heart failure.
Coenzyme Q10/Ubiquinone/Ubiquinol – CoQ10 occurs naturally in some foods and is a cofactor in many biologic pathways. Administration of large amounts has been shown to have modest effects on ventricular function and quality of life in small trials. The largest randomized trial (I blogged about it back in 2013) had no effect on some measures but did reduce major cardiovascular events at two years. Given the overall quality of the evidence the report says CoQ10 has “uncertain value”.
Omega-3 Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids/Fish Oil/Eicosapentaenoic Acid/Docosahexaenoic Acid – Omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) are found in foods like fish, soybeans and organ meats. These supplements have been extensively studied, and while not a slam dunk, there have been benefits shown that include reductions in hospitalization and improvements in ventricular function. Some cardiovascular guidelines recommend PUFA consumption. The report is supportive of supplementation (but not at the expense of guideline-directed medications) at doses of <4g per day.
Thiamine/Vitamin B1 – Thiamine is a water-soluble vitamin found in grains, legumes and yeast. Severe deficiency is a documented cause of heart failure. Many heart failure patients have a relative deficiency from chronic diuretic (water pill) use, dietary factors and age. However, supplementation does not appear to be worthwhile (and is not recommended) unless there is a clinically significant thiamine deficiency present.
Vitamin D/Ergocalciferol (Vitamin D2)/Calcifediol (23-hydroxyvitamin D)/Cholecalciferol (Vitamin D3)/Calcitriol (1,25-Dihydroxycholecalciferol) – Vitamin D naturally occurs in food and has been touted as a panacea for just about everything. Supplementation has shown to have positive effects on some markers, but not others. The VITAL_HF trial examined 2,000 IU of vitamin D per day over 5 years and did not reduce the risk of a first heart failure event compared with placebo. The overall evidence is felt to be inconclusive.
Yoga and Tai Chi – Both yoga and tai chi are felt to be safe, effective, and well tolerated therapies for heart failure. Small trials show improvements in walking distance and lower depression scores as well as improvements in quality of life. While the evidence is overall modest, the report describes them as having “promise” as beneficial forms of exercise.
CAM harms in heart failure
There is an extensive list of supplements that may cause drug interactions:
CAM can have negative effects through different mechanisms:
Alcohol – Excessive alcohol, as noted above, has harmful effects. Consumption of >10 drinks per week is associated harmful effects.
Caffeine – The effects of caffeine on heart failure seem neutral to possibly negative. Avoidance of excessive amounts seems to be warranted, and caffeine may present a greater risk in those sensitive to its effects.
Gossypol – This is a compound derived from the stem, seeds, and roots of the cotton plant, and has been used as a male contraceptive and also an antimalarial. Consumption depletes potassium (bad if you have heart failure) and chronic use can cause circulatory problems.
Grapefruit Juice – I’ve blogged about how grapefruit juice can cause drug interactions in a past post. Given grapefruit juice can affect the absorption of several drugs used to treat heart failure, the report recommends complete avoidance given the unpredictable effects.
Hawthorn – Seems to have some positive effects on heart contractility but may interact with a common heart failure drug, digoxin.
L-arginine – While l-arginine is an amino acid that occurs naturally in food, RCT data of supplements shows an increase risk of death and is not recommended.
Licorice – Glycyrrhetinic acid is an active metabolite of black licorice and has negative effects on heart failure. While I am not certain how much of this is found in candy products like Twizzlers, the report notes that red licorice has no associated risks.
Lily of the Valley, Oleander, Strophanthus, Ouabain – Digoxin, identified from the digitalis plant, is commonly used to treat heart failure. However, many other plants, like lily of the valley, have been identified to contain related chemicals. Because of the narrow range between beneficial and toxic doses, self-medicating with natural plants is a dangerous and potentially fatal alternative to using digoxin medically.
Vitamin E – Supplement doses in excess of 400 IU/day may increase the risk of heart failure and so use with caution is advised.
Conclusion: Limited benefit for CAM
CAM is undoubtedly popular and may be used alongside conventional treatments for heart failure, or in place of evidence-based therapies. While there are a few products (e.g., PUFAs) and approaches (e.g., yoga/tai chi) that may be beneficial, there are also a large number of products that can worsen heart failure or cause negative interactions with prescribed medications. While additional research is undoubtedly advisable, taking a cautious approach to CAM use (of any kind) would seem to be the safest strategy with the lowest risk of unanticipated harm.

Treating Nightmares with a Smart Watch
Preliminary evidence suggests a watch may help people with severe nightmares. Of course, more research is needed.
Harriet Hall on December 20, 2022
Link

Nightmare Disorder is a diagnosis defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) as:
…repeated awakenings with recollection of terrifying dreams, usually involving threats to survival, safety or physical integrity
According to the Mayo Clinic,
Although nightmares are common, nightmare disorder is relatively rare. Nightmare disorder is when nightmares happen often, cause distress, disrupt sleep, cause problems with daytime functioning or create fear of going to sleep.
Prevalence
As many as 34% of veterans have PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder), and according to the US Department of Veterans Affairs, as many as 71%-96% of veterans with PTSD may have nightmares. Nightmares are a hallmark of PTSD in civilians, too. As many as 5% of young adults and 2% of older adults report nightmares on most nights.In the National Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Study, 52% of combat Veterans with PTSD reported significant nightmares.
Treatment
Several approaches to treatment have been tried, including sleeping pills, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), treating sleep apnea, etc., but evidence for their effectiveness is less than impressive.
In November 2020 the FDA approved marketing of a new device designed to reduce sleep disturbance related to nightmares in certain adults. It is called NightWare, and was approved under the FDA’s Breakthrough Devices Program. It was invented by Tyler Skluzacek to help his father, who had nightmares from PTSD after returning from a deployment to Iraq. The nightmares were so bad he feared going to sleep and tried to self-medicate with vodka and sleeping pills. His life unraveled, his marriage fell apart, and he lost his house, his job, and everything. Tyler’s invention turned his father’s life around and it is now available to the public by prescription.
How does it work?
It uses the Apple Watch heart sensor, accelerometer, and gyroscope data to determine if the patient is having a nightmare. It uses cumulative data to calculate the level of sleep disturbance. It uses artificial intelligence to learn and improve its algorithms. It monitors and analyzes the data in real time to determine if intervention is needed to disrupt a nightmare. If intervention is indicated, it provides vibrotactile stimulation to the patient’s wrist. This interrupts the nightmare without waking the patient. Sleep quality is improved.
Evidence for efficacy
A randomized, controlled double blind clinical trial was published in The Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine in October, 2022. It studied 72 veterans with trauma-related sleep disorders. Half were treated with the active device and half with a sham device. There were no significant differences between the two groups, but a post hoc analysis that excluded subjects with low frequency usage showed statistically significant improvement in perceived sleep quality in the active group. They called it preliminary evidence that the device could be effective for compliant users.Testing in civilians is pending.
Caveats
    • The evidence is only preliminary and is not strong.
    • The device does not eliminate or cure nightmares.
    • It is not intended to be used alone, but only in conjunction with other treatments.
    • It is covered by Tricare for active-duty patients but not covered by most insurance or Medicare.
    • It requires a prescription.
    • It requires an Apple Watch, an iPhone, and special software.
    • It may disturb bed partners.
    • It is only intended for adults over the age of 22 who have nightmare disorder or nightmares from PTSD.
    • It is contraindicated for those who have acted out their nightmares (sleepwalking, violence).
Conclusion: May help those who use it consistently
This device will not cure nightmares, but if it improves sleep quality it may facilitate other treatments. Inadequate sleep has been associated with a wide range of adverse health consequences including cardiovascular events, high blood pressure, depression, glucose intolerance, mood changes, daytime sleepiness, decreased concentration, arrhythmias, and alcohol use. Further studies will be needed to see if any of these can be shown to improve when using NightWare.

Does xenon gas improve athletic performance?
Were the Russians on to something in 2014 by huffing xenon gas?
Scott Gavura on December 22, 2022
Link
I have a colleague who is a real sports fanatic who also suffers from repeated (and now chronic) sports-related injuries. A few weeks ago they asked me about the athletic benefits of xenon gas, where it had been discussed in some online forums as a performance-enhancing drug that can also support injury recovery. I’m always surprised (and also not surprised) at the pace of innovation of doping in sport. Xenon is already banned by the World Anti-Doping Agency, so that must mean it’s effective right? I took a closer look at the history and the medical/sports use of this gas.
More that just headlights
Doping with a gas that you may be more likely to associate with car headlights might seem a bit odd. If it’s been a few years (or decades) since you looked at the periodic table, xenon is a noble gas, way off on the right hand side:

Noble mean “non-reactive”, in that these elements do not normally form compounds with other elements. Chemically, they are essentially inert and are colourless, odourless, tasteless and non-flammable. Xenon is present in the environment in only trace amounts. However it can be extracted from the air through distillation. As a gas, xenon is bioactive in the body. Xenon is said to be a very effective general anesthetic and more widespread use for this reason seems to be limited to its cost.
In terms of athletic performance, xenon’s asphyxiant properties appear to activate production of HIF-1α, which is a consequence the resultant oxygen deprivation. A secondary effect is erythropoietin stimulation, which promotes the production of red blood cells and consequently the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood. If this is the primary mechanism of action to aid performance, then it is akin to altitude training (or training/sleeping in oxygen-deprivation environments.)
Just before the Sochi Winter Olympics in 2014, The Economist declared that xenon was being used in Russia to boost athletic performance:
Xenon works its magic by activating production of a protein called Hif-1 alpha. This acts as a transcription factor: a chemical switch that turns on production of a variety of other proteins, one of which is EPO. Artificially raising levels of EPO, by injecting synthetic versions of the hormone or by taking so-called Hif stabilizers (drugs that discourage the breakdown of Hif-1 alpha), is illegal under the rules of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). Other methods of boosting the hormone, however, are permissible—and that fact has not gone unnoticed by the Russian sports authorities.
After the Olympics (in which Russia did very well, and was also found have implemented a massive doping program), Russian athletes admitted to using xenon. Later that same year, WADA placed xenon (and argon) on the banned substance list, despite not having an effective test, and despite the lack of much evidence it actually had performance-enhancing effects. Since that time, the purported benefits have been explored scientifically.
A 2016 trial randomized 24 volunteers to a xenon/oxygen mix or a control group breathing air, for 45 minutes. Xenon was found to increase erythropoietin level after exposure. A 2019 trial sought to understand the effects of short- and long-term use of xenon inhalation and its effects on blood parameters as well as athletic performance. Through communication with Russian trainers, the methodology was developed which included variations in xenon concentrations in inhaled air. The trial recruited 22 healthy individuals. The data safety monitoring board included experience anesthesiologists who had experience with xenon as an anesthetic, even though the doses were insufficient to induce anesthesia. There were three phases to the trial. Phase 1a, with seven participants, evaluated single doses of three different concentrations of xenon (mixed with nitrogen and normal levels of oxygen) in a non-blinded manner. Phase 1b used the preferred doses from Phase 1 as part of a seven-day treatment protocol. Phase 2 compared four weeks of xenon inhalation to “placebo” gas inhalation in a single-blind manner in recreational runners. Blood parameters and athletic performance were assessed.
The trial found that inhaled xenon cause a small but consistent elevation in serum erythropoietin and total blood volume. However, athletic performance did not benefit. Whether the mixed effects were due to the dosing regimen or perhaps due to counterbalancing effects was not clear:
In conclusion, while acute xenon inhalation of various concentrations caused small but prolonged increases in EPO, short-term daily exposure did not provide superior benefits beyond an acute dose. Although there was no indication of accelerated erythropoiesis in response to xenon exposure, a short-term daily dosing protocol induced significant increases in plasma volume. However, this physiological adaptation was transient and was not observed after chronic (4-wk) exposure to xenon. Xenon inhalation did not increase fitness or improve athletic performance, and, given the adverse symptomology associated with dosing, our findings do not support the use of xenon as an erythropoiesis-modulating agent in sports.
Not snake oil, but unclear effectiveness
I personally find the idea of sports doping both fascinating and sort of horrifying, in that athletes become guinea pigs with their long-term health sacrificed in order to eke out any theoretical advantage. Since xenon was banned by WADA in 2014, some evidence has emerged that painted a mixed but not clearly compelling case that inhaling the gas actually does enhance athletic performance. There is certainly no evidence that xenon has any recreational use, nor is there any evidence that it can help injury recovery. I’m not putting it in the same category as kinesio tape, but it’s probably fair to say that the potential benefits are not worth the risks and the cost, compared to legal (and safer) methods of boosting erythropoietin.

Spontaneous Human Combustion. A Sort of Narrative Review.
Burning Man. It is more than a rained out festival in the desert.
Mark Crislip on September 19, 2023
Link

I recently read Charles Dickens’ Bleak House. 5/5. An excellent book and well worth the time. It is a lengthy book. He definitely got paid by the word. I like to read older books using audio. I don’t know why, but the logorrheic circumlocutions of 19th century writers are better heard than read. It is why I listen to Respectful Insolence.*
Deep into the book I came across this:
..The cat remains where they found her, still snarling at the something on the ground before the fire and between the two chairs. What is it? Hold up the light.
Here is a small burnt patch of flooring; here is the tinder from a little bundle of burnt paper, but not so light as usual, seeming to be steeped in something; and here is—is it the cinder of a small charred and broken log of wood sprinkled with white ashes, or is it coal? Oh, horror, he IS here! And this from which we run away, striking out the light and overturning one another into the street, is all that represents him.
Help, help, help! Come into this house for heaven’s sake! Plenty will come in, but none can help. The Lord Chancellor of that court, true to his title in his last act, has died the death of all lord chancellors in all courts and of all authorities in all places under all names soever, where false pretences are made, and where injustice is done. Call the death by any name your Highness will, attribute it to whom you will, or say it might have been prevented how you will, it is the same death eternally—inborn, inbred, engendered in the corrupted humours of the vicious body itself, and that only—spontaneous combustion, and none other of all the deaths that can be died.
Death by spontaneous human combustion. What the?

I will henceforth refer to it as SHC to ease my weary fingers. Turns out the Dickens was a proponent of SHC. He was criticized for that and, like any good believer in the absurd, he doubled down.
The possibility of what is called spontaneous combustion has been denied since the death of Mr. Krook; and my good friend Mr. Lewes (quite mistaken, as he soon found, in supposing the thing to have been abandoned by all authorities) published some ingenious letters to me at the time when that event was chronicled, arguing that spontaneous combustion could not possibly be. I have no need to observe that I do not wilfully or negligently mislead my readers and that before I wrote that description I took pains to investigate the subject. There are about thirty cases on record, of which the most famous, that of the Countess Cornelia de Baudi Cesenate, was minutely investigated and described by Giuseppe Bianchini, a prebendary of Verona, otherwise distinguished in letters, who published an account of it at Verona in 1731, which he afterwards republished at Rome. The appearances, beyond all rational doubt, observed in that case are the appearances observed in Mr. Krook’s case. The next most famous instance happened at Rheims six years earlier, and the historian in that case is Le Cat, one of the most renowned surgeons produced by France. The subject was a woman, whose husband was ignorantly convicted of having murdered her; but on solemn appeal to a higher court, he was acquitted because it was shown upon the evidence that she had died the death of which this name of spontaneous combustion is given. I do not think it necessary to add to these notable facts, and that general reference to the authorities which will be found at page 30, vol. ii the recorded opinions and experiences of distinguished medical professors, French, English, and Scotch, in more modern days, contenting myself with observing that I shall not abandon the facts until there shall have been a considerable spontaneous combustion of the testimony on which human occurrences are usually received.
As mentioned by Dickens, although he got the name wrong, the first reported case of SHC was Cornelia Zangheri Bandi who died in 1731, having been found in the morning
… reduced to a pile of ashes that was a little more than 1 metre (3 ft 3 in) from the bed, although her lower legs below the knee, three fingers and front of her skull were relatively intact. The bed and the rest of the furniture had not been affected by the fire, but were covered by a greasy and smelly layer.
The event was reported by the Reverend Joseph Bianchini, a Prebend in the City of Verona. It has been suggested that since this particular SHC was reported by a member of the Church, the facts of the case must be true. Right. Like the Church is noted for the being honest and forthright. I would be disinclined to automatically grant veracity on any topic to such a source, except, perhaps, on how to maintain a worldwide child molestation ring without the need of a pizza parlor as a front.
I am sure her death by fire had nothing to do with the fact she was known to sprinkle camphorated brandy on her body at bed time to relive pain. Naw. Covering yourself with flammable fluids in a world lit by candles would never lead to disaster.
The likely cause of SHC has been worked out. Someone dies. Often a smoker and a drinker. The coal from the end of the cigarette, or perhaps a spark from a nearby fire, smolders through the cotton clothes, burrowing down until it hits fat. Then you get a slowly burning candle, the cotton being a wick, that is fed by the adipose until most of the torso is gone. Ick. But a straightforward explanation.
So what does that have to do with science-based medicine? Well, for hoots and giggles I entered “spontaneous human combustion” into Pubmed. 111 hits dating back to 1848. While most turned out not to be human spontaneous combustion (hay, garbage dumps, and coal can suffer the same fate), I thought it would be entertaining to wander through the medical literature on the topic. Hence the ‘Narrative Review.’ A narrative review is
a review method in which the researchers summarize different primary studies from which conclusions may be drawn in a systematic way and from a holistic point of view, contributed by researchers’ own experience and existing theories.
Practically speaking, it is a book report with unsubstantiated opinions by people who can’t do the statistics required for a systematic review. Perfect for me.
Case Reports
Let’s start in 1848 and move forward in time and see what the medical literature has to say about SHC.
The first report was interesting for two features. First, when the body was first discovered, it was noted
“..on the body of the deceased a small, lambent, whitish flame…”
Lambent, btw, means glowing, gleaming, or flickering with a soft radiance. It is a word I did not know.
But it is curious he was burning like a candle. Fits with the most likely explanation of how SHC occurs.
The deceased was not fat, nor a drinker, but was known to carry matches in his waistcoat. They eventually blamed a warm brick he had in bed with him to keep his feet warm as the source of the combustion, although at the time it was thought that whatever process kept the body warm could spin out of control and ignite a person.
The other fact was that the son and daughter were accused of killing him and burning the body, but were acquitted after the examining physician called it spontaneous combustion.
The second case of the 19th century. concerns the death of Countess of Goerlitz at Darmstadt, on the 13th June 1847, and is presented like a murder mystery in a lengthy report from 1852. Part of the mystery is she was found burned in bed, but she had the habit of locking herself in the room at night and she had the only key. Atypical for SHC, it appeared to start at the head and neck rather than the torso.
It was said the SHC is difficult to extinguish with water (like any grease fire?) and this fire was easily put out, so, per Dr. Graff, it was one of the many reasons the death was typical for SHC.
In the end it was decided she had been murdered by John Stauff and set alight.
The author did note of the famous case referenced by Dickens as
a very silly and fabulous relation, abounding in those marvelous circumstances which weak minds take please in remarking
and the author also noted
The tendency of which is to create wonder and terror at an unknown event of doubtful occurrence, and at variance with known physical laws.
That could be the motto of this blog.
The last case from the 19th century in the medical literature was not really spontaneous human combustion, but I enjoy the style:
Twelve years ago last August, a man met death in a peculiar and horrible manner in San Francisco. James Harley, the victim, had just recovered from an attack of delirium tremens. He had been a regular sot and was thoroughly soaked with alcohol. His last attack of the “ jim jams ” was the third he had undergone within a few months. On the morning in question he had started on another spree. At about 11 o’clock in the day, he had about all the liquor on board he was able to carry. Stepping into a saloon on one of the principal streets he called for a swig of “bug juice,” which was promptly refused, the bartender noting the condition of the man and remembering his late battle with the snakes. Harley scowled and turned to a gas jet to light his pipe. A second later there was a drunken moan, a flash of alcoholic flame, and Harley fell heavily to the floor, his head and neck veiled in smoke, while blue jets of flame were issuing from his ears, mouth and nostrils. As soon as water could be procured (water was a commodity rather scarce around such places) it was dashed into the sufferer’s face, not in time, however to save his life. The face was as black is that of a negro. The ears were charred, the inside of the mouth black and the tongue burned to a crisp.
I wonder how high his blood alcohol was to become a human alcohol flame.
There was a lull in the medical literature until the 1990s.
One case was a seizure patient who had two matchbooks in his pocket. The seizure caused the one matchbook to rub against the striking surface of the other, igniting the patients pants. Again, not a true SHC, but another way, albiet rare, that a human could erupt into flames. Probably more plausible than exposure to cosmic radiation.
Most of the other papers are reviews of the topic that rehash the topic from the point of view of forensic medicine. Which is important. Was the person killed, then set alight? Usually. Or was it the rare perfect storm that led to not-really-so-spontaneous human combustion. Is it SHC? Or murder?
Experiments
There have been few experiments published in the medical literature looking into SHC. Given its (rare) importance in forensics, I was surprised at the lack of basic research. Probably why the topic has never been covered in one of those police procedural shows.
Finding a body to burn is hard, but there is a pig model.
Previous tests by these authors have demonstrated the conditions necessary to promote combustion of a body: the presence of adequate body fat, presence of a porous, rigid char to act as a wick, and an external flame source sustained for several minutes to char the body and cause the subcutaneous fat to begin rendering. In the test reported here, a freshly-slaughtered pig carcass with a net weight of 215 lb. (95 kg) was wrapped in a cotton blanket and placed on a carpet-covered plywood panel. The fire was initiated using 1 L of gasoline poured on the shoulder area of the blanket-wrapped carcass. The gasoline burned off within 4 min, having ignited a large area of the blanket and adjoining carpet. Flames from those fuel packages resulted in the establishment of a steady-state fire sustained by the rendering of the body fat, with the necessary wick provided by the charred cotton blanket and carpet. The heat release rate of this fire was 60+/-10 kW, with flames less than 12 in. (0.35 m) high for its duration. The fire sustained itself by the rendering process for more than 6 1/2 h from ignition, at which time it was extinguished. An average mass loss rate of 1.5 g/s (5.3 kg/h) was observed during the self-sustained fire. Extensive destruction of the carcass (more than 60% by weight) included reduction of large bones to a fragile, ashen state.
I think I will stick with a pellet smoker for my next BBQ pork shoulder. Although, my wife has long been of the opinion that most men are pigs, so it may be a good model.
But one always starts small and works their way up. For example, burn bits of people:
Two experiments were conducted. The first involved the cremation of “healthy” and “osteoporotic” human bone and observing the resulting fragmentation and color change. Osteoporotic elements consistently displayed more discoloration and a greater degree of fragmentation than healthy ones. The second experiment involved the combustion of a sample of human tissue (an amputated leg) and observation of the flame height and burning area in order to calculate the effective heat of combustion. The resulting heat was 17kJ/g indicating a fire that is unlikely to spread.
Man. The smell. I could never tolerate the smell of electrocautery, I hope they used a hood. Although
Burning muscle tissue gives off an aroma similar to beef in a frying pan, and body fat smells like a side of fatty pork on the grill.
I hope to never learn from experience.
That is mostly it for the basic research on SHC. But not an area that would be easy to explore and not open to odd speculation. Or is there?
Theories
As mentioned, the mechanism by which most cases of SHC occur is reasonably well worked out. But not everyone is convinced.
For example, Mr. Seun Ayoade, an independent researcher in Nigeria, wondered if Spontanous Human Combustion-are the Microzymas the Culprit?
The short answer is no. But he suggests
It could very well be that in rare instances microzyma carry out some extremely exothermic reactions for which tissue conductance is hopelessly inadequate, and thus the cells, tissues, organs and systems literally burn up! The death of the unfortunate individual coincides with the de-coordination of the microzyma and that explains why the fire doesn’t affect inanimate objects around the victim to an appreciable degree.
It could very well be? Not so much.
Published in Global Journal of Forensic Science & Medicine, I think the GJFSM is failing their aim of that aim of publishing quality articles. And it was peer reviewed. Who would review that article? A naturopath?
But it is curious how ideas never die. Microzymas were first hypothesized by Bechamp, the anti- Pasteur. The microzyma, which by the way do not exist,
.. is an independently living element, found in all living organisms and survives after the death of the organism. It functions to both build and recycle the organism.
Mr, Ayoade seems to have an idee fixe on the topic, as he is also of the opinion that The Future of Medicine Lies in Microzyma Research, Not in Stem Cell Research; Flexner the Germ Theory Fiend
I love that. Germ Theory Fiend. I want that on my tombstone.
So, what have we learned? Not much. So I will conclude with the always lame classics: more research needs to be done, and the next time you see a person mostly consumed by fire, consider spontaneous human combustion.
—
*Joke, David.

Science-Based Satire: Could Spontaneous Human Combustion Become a Chronic, Treatable Disease? Maybe. Yeah, I think so.
Do humans spontaneously burst into flames? Can these mysterious cases be predicted and kept at bay by homeopathic remedies? No. They don’t and they can’t. I made it all up. Is it just me, or is getting really hot in here.
Clay Jones on June 23, 2023
Link

Alan Wick was 46, with a family celebrating the high school graduation of his oldest daughter, when he first became concerned that he was at high risk of suddenly bursting into flames after watching an episode of That Might Be Real? on Travel Channel earlier this year. 
“My first thought was a bit selfish,” Wick recalled, now nearly four months later. “How long did I have left? Had I accomplished everything I wanted to do in my life? I don’t want to blow up. But then it hit me. What if I was petting my dog or giving my wife a hug? Or pumping gas? The last thing I ever wanted to do was take a crowd of innocent people down with me when it’s my time to go.”
Wick’s anxiety wasn’t far-fetched. According to the National Fire Protection Association, spontaneous combustion is the occurrence of fire without the application of an external heat source due to chemical, biological, or physical processes. This causes an estimated 14,070 fires each year in the United States alone. Experts in Spontaneous Human Combustion, known as SHC, aren’t sure how many of these fires involve a human being, but hundreds of people are likely to be worried about just up and exploding one day. 
Patients like Wick, who live every day in a vermiculite fire entry suit on loan from the National Institute of Geophysics and Volcanology, are looking for answers. Finally, there does appear to be a light at the end of this dark and mysterious tunnel. Researchers at the prestigious Swedish Institute of Modern Hyperdilutional Therapeutics (SIMHT) have announced a breakthrough in the diagnosis and management of SHC, a condition long considered to be undetectable and incurable.
“SHC patients typically are only identified after a pile of greasy ash and singed hands or feet are discovered by a landlord or family member,” lead researcher Scotch Magnusson explained. “But with our recent advances in screening for SHC, and prophylactic hyperdilutional therapies, people no longer need live in fear of unexpectedly erupting into flames anymore.”
Though the exact mechanism through which SHC patients ignite remains unclear, many experts believe that the condition originated in Africa when spontaneous simian combustion was transferred from non-human primates to humans training chimpanzees to participate in early NASA suborbital flight missions. Regardless, the possibility of an instantaneous and catastrophic transition from one’s baseline state of health into a smoldering mound of bones, teeth, and clothing remnants has deserved its terrifying reputation. To many, the lack of any known warning signs is particularly unsettling. Preliminary studies have found that unlucky sufferers are often simply minding their own business and unwinding on an old couch with a bottle of liquor and a cigarette after a long day.
Adding to the mystery and suspense of SHC is the fact that there has never been a witnessed case. This has fueled a variety of implausible and unproven etiological hypotheses, such as ball lighting, a new subatomic particle, or thinking that your 1st cousin is kind of sexy, even if just for a second before you catch yourself. Progress, however, is finally being made.
After more than a year of intensive research and testing, Magnusson and his colleagues at SIMHT have developed and validated a screening test for SHC. According to Magnusson, the test consists of a panel of fifty questions that take family history, environmental exposures, diet, and a number of other key factors into account. But identifying who is at risk is only half the battle. “A screening test is only helpful if we can offer patients a solution so they no longer need to sleep in a tub of water.”
The team also formulated a cocktail of specially prepared plant and animal parts with the intent of preventing SHC events in high risk patients. Magnusson, who was unwilling to reveal any of the ingredients, wasn’t shy about touting their success and pointing out the obvious implications. “We are taking people who might have literally melted to death and we are giving them their lives back. And as long as they continue the preventive treatment, we expect them to live long enough to die of something much less exciting…like cancer.”
Today, Wick checks in virtually with the team at SIMHT every three weeks. He also continues to take his daily preventative elixir. And, at least so far, he hasn’t burst into flames. “My original goal was to see my youngest daughter finish the 8th grade, and I’ve done that, so now I want to be around for everything the future has in store for her, and for all of us.”
“Life is really good right now,” he revealed. “Still, a part of me worries that at any minute, maybe even right in the middle of this sentence, I could combust. But I live my life like it’s gone. I live my life like it’s never going to happen, like it’s not even a real thing that ever existed.” 
Exploding the Myth
Obviously spontaneous human combustion is not a real thing that has ever existed. And the explanations for it are known:
A unique sequence of events takes place for the human body to incinerate to ashes. The flame burn victim has to die for the body fat to start melting. A tear in the skin has to occur for the melted fat to impregnate the charred clothes, igniting a wick effect that produces localized heat for extended period.
So a victim dies, likely because of a heart attack, while holding a lit cigarette. This ignites their clothing, chars the skin, and fat leaches out turning the torso into a giant candle. It’s disgusting, tragic, and not really the point.
What inspired me to write up this little bit of satire, other than the fact that there are people who actually believe in SHC, was a recent a Washington Post article on the future of cancer treatment. The take home point of the article is essentially that many previously incurable cancers are being treated effectively, and more patients than ever are living for decades past their diagnosis:
Some 2 million people in the United States will be diagnosed with cancer this year, the National Cancer Institute estimates. But the death rate from all cancers has fallen 33 percent since 1991, according to an American Cancer Society report released in January.
For some types of cancers, the progress is even more impressive. The mortality rate for lung cancer — the leading cause of cancer deaths — has dropped 58 percent since 1990 in men and 36 percent since 2002 in women. Breast cancer is another striking success story, with a 43 percent drop from 1989 through 2020. So is melanoma, with death rates between 2011 and 2020 falling by about 5 percent a year for adults younger than 50 and 3 percent for those older than 50.
As more patients have what is essentially cancer the chronic disease, there are numerous potential pitfalls in their care. The needs of these survivors are often different and more complex. One issue discussed in the article is so-called “scanxiety”, where patients are required to get frequent imaging checks to look for recurrence of their cancer or the development of cancers perhaps associated with their treatment and have trouble dealing with the uncertainty and suspense.
It’s a good article. Check it out.

   Energy ‘Therapies’

   Fields, Alternative Medicine, and Physics
Eugenie Mielczarek
Link
In 1996 the American Physical Society, responding to a request from the National Research Council, was asked to examine the potential health hazards of power lines. One of the concerns was that electromagnetic background fields of 2 milligauss might cause cancer (for comparison the earth’s magnetic field is 500 milligauss and fields generated by human physiological processes are hundreds of thousands of times less than 2 milligauss). Monitors of outdoor exposure for children to wear were marketed to parents. “Some city regulations sought to constrain B fields to less than 2 milligauss”. The report, which was a comprehensive study of the alleged dangers, included both molecular and epidemiologic studies and found that no adverse health effects could be attributed to these low fields.
One of the conclusions emphasized that physical calculations rule out carcinogenic effects because at physiological temperatures thermal noise fields in human cells are larger than the background fields from power lines.1, 2 Thus the political agenda, concerned with fear of carcinogenic mechanisms arising from low level magnetic fields, lost credibility. However, about 10 years later claims for health effects from mattress pads equipped with small magnets were marketed. A study of this was funded by National Institute of Health’s Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine and claims for their benefits were published in alternative medicine journals.3
Some of the rationale for the claims were ludicrous. I attended one sales pitch which claimed their mattress magnets were better because they incorporated only North Poles. About the same time, small 300 gauss magnets, began to appear on the shelves of drug stores. In 2007 a lawsuit brought by the National Council against Health Fraud against advertisers of these products was successfully settled. I was one of the persons who agreed to appear as an expert witness if needed. The Federal Trade Commission also threatened to prosecute purveyors who claimed healthful benefits for these products.
Amazingly, in the last few years the health and medical and nursing communities in their ‘integrated medicine’ outreach are now marketing the unsubstantiated claims that healing fields of 2 milligauss are emitted from the hands of practitioners.4,5 This belief in distance healing, Therapeutic Touch, Reiki, and Qiqong cobble the language of physics with the language of physiology, misleading the patient. For example, in Therapeutic Touch the protocol requires that a therapist moves his or her hands over the patient’s “energy field,” allegedly “tuning” a purported “aura” of biomagnetic energy that extends above the patient’s body. This is thought to somehow help heal the patient. (Curiously, the rubrics never define what may happen if the practitioner is inept.) Although this is less than one percent of the strength of Earth’s magnetic field, corresponding to billions of times less energy than the energy your eye receives when viewing even the brightest star in the night sky, and is billions of times smaller than that needed to affect biochemistry, the web sites of prominent clinics nevertheless market the claims6 This belief has been published in the peer reviewed medical literature.7 Silence on this issue by the major scientific societies is a serious compromise of the scientific endeavors of those of us who work at the frontier of physics, medicine and biology.
The terms, energy and field, are used by alternative medicine practitioners, and integrative medicine physicians without any understanding of their meaning — their on-line and public lectures impart the pretense that fields are unknown philosophical constructs. Invited speakers at medical meetings at major academic institutions philosophize relationships between phenomena of many different magnitudes and sources, such as dark matter and biochemistry. The laws of quantum mechanics and electromagnetism are responsible for the biochemical bonding of molecules. Scientists understand that the discovery of dark matter is associated with the gravitational forces in our universe. No formulation of the properties of dark matter could have any observable effects between individual molecules in a cell.
What follows is a tutorial on fields:
Transmission of a force when objects are not in contact is represented by a set of vectors defined at all points in space which enumerate the direction and magnitude of the force. This set of vectors constitutes the field. There are four fundamental forces: gravitational, electromagnetic, weak nuclear and strong nuclear. Other fundamental forces have been looked for and not found. Scientists cannot rule out the possibility that science may one day find a new force field, but should such a discovery occur it will be through using the tools and methodology of science. Theorists understand that the strength of such a force must be much less than our weakest known force.
We live in a gravitational field which causes an object near the surface of the earth to fall with acceleration such that its velocity increases each sec by 32 feet per sec. Further out from our planet this number is less. Place signs with these numbers all over space and you have a picture of the field and its associated ‘action at a distance’ force. Knowing these numbers allows us to build rockets and satellites and explore outer space.
Similarly we know the numbers for electromagnetic fields. This allows us to build MRI machines. Ultrasonic imaging arises from us knowing the numbers at the level of cells to image the densities in tissues. We are constantly bathed in electromagnetic fields from communication devices.
Studies of equations for these forces and the enumeration of the strength of their fields underlie our current technology. When energy fields are used as a medium for conveying information, scientists ask and answer the following key questions: How large is the signal? What is the transmitter located in the source, and what and where is the receiver? How can the device be tuned and detuned? Lastly, how can one replicate this by a device to be used for medical intervention?
The alleged source of TT’s purported biomagnetic field is the practitioner, and the alleged receiver is the patient. Beyond this, TT practitioners fail to give detailed and plausible answers to the key questions above. TT practitioners’ adoption of the scientific term “biomagnetic” field, without an equation to describe the field and without any grounding in known physics and biochemistry, conveys the impression of scientific respectability to claims that have no scientific basis. Its claims are anecdotal and no measurements such as blood work or respiratory function are made.
I’m sure your ENT or GP would never suggest visits to a TT practitioner to cure a hearing loss. Practitioners of alternative medicine never recommend it as an intervention for a condition that has an easily measurable physiological response. The clinical trials using TT associated with the 1.8 million dollar NIH grant, which were to measure the health of women with cervical cancer, were completed in 2006 and 20078 but a recent search using Clinical Trials .gov data base yields no reported results. Curiously, expert scientific opinion, and inventions using fields are welcomed by the evidence-based medical community but rejected by the integrative medicine community when this knowledge contradicts belief systems purported to be medically healing.
Notes
     1.  David Hafemeister, “Resource Letter BELFEF-1: Biological effects of low-frequency electromagnetic fields,” American Journal of Physics 64(8), 974-981 (1996).
     2.  Robert K. Adair, “Constraints on biological effects of weak extremely-low-frequency electromagnetic fields,” Physical Review A43(2), 1039-1048 (1991).
     3.  Static Magnetic Fields for Treatment of Fibromyalgia: A Randomized Controlled Trial
     4.  Alan P. Alfano, Ann Gill Taylor, Pamela A. Foresman, Philomena R. Dunkl, Geneviève G. McConnell, Mark R. Conaway, George T. Gillies. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine. February 2001, 7(1): 53-64. doi:10.1089/107555301300004538.
     5.  A report detailing the current claims, authored by myself and Derek Araujo, was issued by the Center for Inquiry, on September 28, 2009.
     6.  “Healing Touch is performed by registered nurses who recognize, manipulate and balance the electromagnetic fields surrounding the human body, thereby promoting healing and the well-being of body, mind and spirit.” Scripps Institute website: http://www.scripps.org/services/integrative-medicine/services
     7.  Affiliated with Harvard Medical Center is Brigham Hospital’s Osher Center. Course offerings have featured Reiki: “During this class you will receive a reiki level one attunement. This attunement enables you to become a channel for this universal healing energy which will be with you for your lifetime. From this point on you will be a reiki practitioner. With level one reiki you will be able to do healing on yourself, friends, family and pets.” See http://hms.harvard.edu/hms/home.asp; see also http://www.brighamandwomens.org/medicine/oshercenter/
     8.  Journal of Orthopaedic Research 26(11), 1541-1546 (2008).
     9.  Clinicaltrials.gov NCT 00065091
About the author:
EUGENIE VORBURGER MIELCZAREK is Emeritus Professor of Physics at George Mason. Her experimental researches in materials science, chemical physics and biological physics have been published in The Physical Review, the Journal of Chemical Physics and the Biology of Metals. She has been a visiting scientist at the National Institutes of Health, and a visiting Professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. She is a recipient of the Distinguished Faculty Award at George Mason University. She has advised National Public Radio, judged the U. S. Steel-American Institute of Physics prize for science journalism, and written book reviews for Physics Today. She was the primary editor of Key Papers in Biological Physics. She is the author of a popular science book, Iron, Nature’s Universal Element: Why People Need Iron & Animals Make Magnets. Her most recent article was a review of research frontiers linking Physics and Biology. In May 2009 she was honored by the Washington Academy of Sciences for ‘Distinguished Research in Biological Physics’.
Parts of this blog post also appeared in the April 2010 Newsletter of the Forum on Physics and Society of the American Physical Society

A review of Are Electromagnetic Fields Making Me Ill? How Electricity and Magnetism Affect Our Health, by Bradley J. Roth
A new book explores some of the (un)scientific controversies about electromagnetic radiation and health.
Harriet Hall on June 14, 2022
Link

Bradley Roth is a retired physicist and acknowledged expert in electromagnetism who co- authored the textbook Intermediate Physics for Medicine and Biology. In this new book, Are Electromagnetic Fields Making Me Ill?, he shares his knowledge and understanding with the general public. The book asks a number of questions about electricity, magnetism, and health claims, starting with unchanging static magnets and progressing through fields that change with increasing frequencies, from 60 Hz to fields that oscillate at up to trillions of times per second. Each chapter title is a question, and his answer is usually “probably not” or “no”. I’ll elaborate chapter by chapter, starting with Chapter 2, after the Introduction. His explanations are thorough and full of interesting facts that will help the reader decide if health claims are plausible and may help them win a trivia contest.
Chapter 2: Can Magnets Cure All Your Ills?
Magnetic fields are claimed to relieve pain; to cure arthritis, backache, and menstrual cramps; to heal sports injuries; and much more. Testimonials abound, but the evidence is iffy.
Roth does a great job of explaining the physics of magnets. Magnetic fields are measured in tesla. The earth has a magnetic field of 0.00005 tesla, refrigerator magnets have a field of about 0.001 tesla, and an MRI scanner has 1.5 tesla. For comparison, the magnetic fields recommended to relieve pain are around 0.1 tesla. The magnetic field produced by the brain is so feeble it can only be measured by a supercooled SQUID device. The magnetic fields of nerves are far too weak to affect nerve conduction; those claims are not true. Physiotherapist Isaac Goiz Durán claims that his biomagnetic therapy can cure cancer, diabetes, AIDS, and COVID-19. He believes the north and south poles of a magnet have dramatically different biologic effects. He is wrong: the only difference between the poles is the direction of the field.
Some bacteria are magnetotactic; they can react to the earth’s magnetic field because they contain magnetite. Homing pigeons have magnetite in their beaks. Isolated iron atoms, like those found in the blood’s hemoglobin, can’t sense a magnetic field; that requires densely packed iron atoms whose unpaired electrons tend to spin in the same direction. Magnetite has been found in the human brain. Is it possible that humans can detect magnetic fields? Roth says the evidence is tantalizing but inconclusive; he has his doubts. Free radicals also might detect magnetic fields, but the jury is still out.
Roth explains diamagnetism, which is exhibited by water and has been demonstrated by levitating a frog. (I wonder what the frog thought was happening. Did he think it was the Rapture?)
Biological effects could only occur if the magnetic energy is greater than the thermal energy of Brownian motion. Roth covers this in greater depth in subsequent chapters.
I was surprised to learn that the south magnetic pole of the earth is located near the north geographic pole.
Chapter 3: Can a 9 Volt Battery Make You Smarter?
A device that applies a weak electrical current to the head is said to improve “productivity, focus, and performance”.
“…when people are exposed to an electric field, charge accumulates on their skin but no electric field exists anywhere inside their body; their tissues are shielded from an external field”. Electrical fields are created when electrodes are used.
Electroreception. Some animals can detect small, static electrical fields, for instance by the ampullae of Lorenzini that can be seen as pores on the snouts of sharks. But does detection have any physiologic effect on the animals, or on humans?
Electricity is used to promote bone healing when there is non-union of a fracture, but “After decades of research and clinical use, we still are not sure if electric fields help bones heal.” Roth’s verdict: plausible but definitely not proven.
Transcranial direct current stimulation:
Three meta-analyses published from 2014 to 2016 concluded that the influence of tDCS on memory is either small, partial, or nonexistent.
There is much debate about tDCS. Roth’s conclusion: “First, science is difficult. Large effects are relatively easy to discover, but small ones tend to be buried in noise. Second, a single study or analysis does not decide an issue.”
There is “a slow slog ultimately leading to a consensus among scientists”. We will have to wait and see.
“The science behind transcranial direct current stimulation is unclear. There are enough positive studies that we cannot reject it out of hand, but there are enough questions that we cannot accept it as an established therapy.”
Chapter 4: Do Power Lines Cause Cancer?
Paul Brodeur’s 1989 book Currents of Death alleged that electromagnetic fields associated with power lines, electric blankets, and video display terminals cause cancer, and that people who denied it were engaged in a conspiracy to hide the truth from the public.
While radio stations and cell phones use frequencies in the millions and billions of Hz, power lines and the entire electrical grid operate at the extremely low frequency of 60 Hz (they alternate at 60 cycles per second).
The electrical field under the highest voltage power lines can be as high as 15,000 V/m; the magnetic field is less than 1/3 the magnetic field of the earth. Surface charge is very effective in shielding our bodies from electric fields. The magnetic field is not shielded; it can produce small electrical fields in the body through induction.
Roth points out that the electric fields induced in the body by power lines are smaller than the endogenous electric fields that always exist in our bodies.
Can humans detect a 60 Hz magnetic field? When an experiment in the 1970s showed that some “super perceivers” could, the experimenters did not trust their original results. Roth tells a fascinating story about the series of extraordinary measures they took to remove every possible confounder from the experimental setup. Their final determination was that no real perception had occurred.
He points out that “The thermal noise electric field experienced by a cell and the endogenous field produced by the heart are both larger than the electric field induced by a power line. Power line fields are swamped by thermal noise.” Numerous physicists and committees have reviewed the evidence and found no evidence that power lines can cause cancer. If they could, shouldn’t the incidence of childhood leukemia have risen? It hasn’t. The supposed association proved to be spurious when better studies were done.
Chapter 5: Will Electrical Stimulation Help Your Aching Back?
Electrical stimulation by Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS) and other devices are often used to treat backaches. Electrical stimulation has proven effective for pacemakers and defibrillators, which operate at a frequency of around 1000 Hz. That’s higher than the 60 Hz of power lines but much lower than the frequencies of radio, TV, and cell phones.
Hodgkin and Hughes won a Nobel Prize for their studies of nerve conduction in the giant nerve axon of the squid. Nerve conduction in peripheral nerves is now well understood; electrical stimulation of the brain is not as well understood. “Heart pacemakers, neural prostheses, deep brain stimulation, and transcranial magnetic stimulation represent dramatic biomedical advances…but the success of TENS has been uninspiring.” The consensus of numerous meta-analyses is that “clinical studies to date are either inconclusive or mildly negative about the use of TENS.” Electroconvulsive therapy has received a lot of bad press, but it has been proven effective. Several randomized, controlled clinical trials have found that “electroconvulsive therapy is significantly better than a placebo for treating depression and is significantly better than antidepressant drugs.”
Electric eels stun their prey with a strong electric shock that acts like a taser, causing the fish’s muscles to go into tetanus. An electric fish called a ray was used in ancient Rome to treat headaches and gout.
Roth relates this interesting bit of trivia: “The Tennessee Aquarium’s electric eel, Miguel Wattson, has his own Twitter account (@EelectricMiguel) that sends out a tweet every time he delivers a shock.”
Chapter 6: Is Your Cell Phone Killing You?
In her book Disconnect (discussed on SBM), Devra Davis asks whether “the pervasive use of cell phones is causing a host of subtle, chronic health problems today, damaging our ability to have healthy children and creating long-term risks to our brains and bodies?” Vini Kurana even announced on the Larry King Live show that “cell phones are more dangerous than smoking”. One widespread fear has been that cell phones cause brain cancer. Roth shows how physics and epidemiology have essentially ruled out that possibility.
He explains Maxwell’s equations, which “brought electricity, magnetism, and optics together into a single unified theory” but did not account for quantum theory and wave-particle duality. Ionizing radiation can remove an electron from a molecule, damaging DNA and causing mutations that might develop into cancer. The radiation from cell phones is not ionizing; it is non-ionizing.
The new 5G cell phones will make use of frequencies up to nearly 1000 GHz, with a photon energy of 0.004 electron volts. This is less than the thermal energy of randomly moving molecules (Brownian motion), which is 0.02 electron volts.
Roth explains how diathermy, radio frequency ablation, and electroporation work by heating the tissues.
He reaches these conclusions:
     1.  A photon from a cell phone is so weak that it cannot break bonds in a DNA molecule and cause cancer directly. If cell phones cause cancer the effect must be indirect.
     2.  Cell phone radiation is not intense enough to heat tissue. Any mechanism by which cell phone radiation causes cancer must be nonthermal.
He covers the proposed non-thermal mechanisms for tissue damage from cell phones and explains how physics shows that those mechanisms are not plausible.
The evidence is questionable, and has been interpreted differently by different observers, but the clincher is that the incidence of brain cancer has not risen as the use of cell phones skyrocketed. Major health agencies like the FDA, CDC, and NCI have examined the evidence and concluded that cell phones do not cause cancer.
Chapter 7: Did 5G Cell Phone Radiation Cause COVID-19?
Roth calls this an “outlandish” conspiracy theory circulated on social media. He refuses to discuss the nonsense, but he examines the physics of 5G to see whether it might affect our health. Compared to 4G, 5G uses higher frequencies and offers higher download speeds (more bits per second), lower error rates, shorter delays between sending data and receiving a response, and greater connectivity (more devices can join a network). Roth explains that in some ways 5G is safer than 4G: the brain is shielded, and the greatest risk is to the skin and the cornea of the eye.
After evaluating the evidence, Roth concludes: “Dangers arising from cell phone radiation strike me as unlikely, but not inconceivable. However, the claims that there exists a vast plot, with scientists colluding to conceal the facts, are ridiculous. Scientific consensus arises when a diverse group of scientists openly scrutinizes claims and critically evaluates evidence. Science is the best way to debunk conspiracy theories and uncover the truth.”
Chapter 8: Did Cuba Attack America with Microwaves?
The Havana Syndrome refers to mysterious medical symptoms reported by personnel at the American and Canadian embassies in Cuba in 2016, including ringing in the ears, fatigue, and dizziness. Questionable studies blamed everything from crickets to acoustic or microwave weapons aimed at the embassies by enemy agents. Roth explains what physics has to say about the evidence and why the most likely explanation is mass psychogenic illness.
Chapter 9: Is That Airport Security Scanner Dangerous?
Airport scanners expose people to microwaves. A physician writing on the Scientific American blog refuses to be scanned “until there is proof that the machines … are 100 percent safe even with long-term chronic exposure.” That seems like excessive caution, since airport scanners only expose you for half a second.
A National Academies report concluded that “As a result of the short time of exposure, the weak intensity of the radiation, and the lack of penetration, millimeter wave scanners should be harmless. The relative risk is less than the risk from talking on your cell phone for a minute.”
A bonus: Explaining critical thinking
As he asks his questions about health claims, Roth has much to say about the principles of critical thinking. He points out that “You can find peer-reviewed scientific studies supporting all points of view. Hundreds of papers of varying quality have been published describing laboratory experiments, and generally dozens of these reports are consistent with your opinion regardless of what your opinion is.”
He explains how confounders can lead to false results and how meta-analyses can help sort out the truth from conflicting studies. He explains placebos, randomization, blinding, the need for large sample sizes, the meaning of “statistical significance,” the file drawer effect, publication bias, p-hacking, and HARKing (hypothesizing after results are known). A well-done meta-analysis concluded that in most cases the evidence is against static magnets for pain relief, although in the case of arthritis there is not enough evidence to decide.
Promoting placebos because they help patients deal with pain is counterproductive. Roth explains why.
…for almost any illness, some people get better and some do not. If you give patients just about any treatment, no matter how silly, some of them are bound to improve. You can then point to those people and tell their story to justify the effectiveness of the treatment. The main purpose of randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical trials is to go beyond anecdotes and determine if a treatment has a real effect.
Science does not proceed by proclaiming universal truths, but by accumulating evidence that allows us to be more or less confident in our hypotheses.
Conclusion: We needn’t worry
Roth says “Nobody is able to prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that power lines do not cause cancer, magnets fail to reduce pain, or those airport scanners are 100% safe, but to me the evidence supporting their safety is overwhelming.”
This book is an essential reference that would be a great addition to every skeptic’s bookshelf. It summarizes the evidence about the health effects of electromagnetism and provides ammunition for debunking pseudoscientific rumors. It’s short, inexpensive, well-written, and full of interesting facts. I was particularly intrigued to learn that an electric eel has its own Twitter account.

   When a “scientific study” is neither
Peter Lipson
Link
There is quite a bit of art to the practice of medicine: knowing how to get and to give information to a patient, how to create a sense of worry without creating a feeling of panic, how to use the best available science to help them maintain or return to health. Underlying all of the art is the science: what blood pressure is likely to be harmful in a particular patient? What can I offer to mitigate this harm? This science is developed over years by observation and systematic study. We have a very good idea of what blood pressure levels are optimal to prevent heart attacks in various populations. These data are hard-won. It has taken decades and it continues.
If a researcher were to discover a promising, new blood pressure intervention, they would have a long way to go from bench to bedside. They would have to prove as well as possible that it is safe and effective—and from a science-based medicine perspective, that it is even plausible. If the discovery is a drug that relaxes blood vessels, or a type of exercise, we have good reason to believe it might work and can go on to figuring out if it does work. If the intervention is wearing plaid every day, we have little reason to think this would be effective, and it probably isn’t worth the time and cost of looking into it.
The well-respected journal Cancer has just wasted space in the study of wearing plaid. Well, not really; it’s worse than that. The article is called, “Complementary medicine for fatigue and cortisol variability in breast cancer survivors: A Randomized Controlled Trial.” There is nothing that isn’t wrong with this study, and if it weren’t published in a major journal, it might even be light comedy.
Tragedy wins the day, however, because cancer is a big deal, and I don’t like it when people mess around with cancer.
People with cancer suffer from a number of vague and specific discomforts related to the disease and its treatment. Everything from life-threatening blood clots, to intractable pain and nausea, to depression threaten to kill or disable people with cancer. One symptom common to many illnesses is fatigue, and during chemotherapy, fatigue can be debilitating. This new “study” allegedly investigates an intervention to alleviate fatigue.
Fatigue is one of those symptoms whose study can be difficult and deceptive. It rarely has a single cause, is subjective, and waxes and wanes naturally. Because of this natural variability, it is easy to attribute changes in fatigue to an intervention when if fact we may be observing the natural course of the symptom. My patients with colds often want antibiotics. Without antibiotics, their cold will likely last a week or two; with them, 7-14 days. If I give them antibiotics, they will certainly credit me with curing their cold, but were I to take credit I would be riding nature’s coattails.
In the current study, the authors have chosen to ride the coattails of nature but rather than cling to them with medicine, they have chosen “biofield therapy”. My spell checker doesn’t recognize “biofield” and neither should you. The authors at least acknowledge this in passing:
Biofield therapies are complementary and integrative medicine modalities often used by breast cancer patients, and have been described as therapies that are intended to affect energy fields that purportedly surround and penetrate the human body for the purposes of healing. (Emphasis mine, PalMD)
I have a big problem with studies built around something that only purportedly exists. What’s next, a study of cancer rates in Sasquatch?
This paragraph effectively nullifies everything that follows, but what follows is so horrid and humorous that we can’t just stop here.
The “biofield healing” technique chosen for the study? ”Energy Chelation”. It’s almost as if they looked for a term that took all of quackery and combined it into two simple words. Nowhere does it tell us what sort of “energy” is being “chelated”; so I looked it up.
According to the study, the technique was chosen by one of the authors, Reverend Rosalyn L. Bruyere. Is she an oncologist? A physicist?
Rosalyn L. Bruyere is an internationally acclaimed healer, clairvoyant and medicine woman.
You don’t need to be a capital-S Skeptic to translate that as “con-artist”, although that would simply be an opinion. The real question isn’t whether or not she is a con-artist (she may in fact be very sincere despite a website that makes her look like a cult leader) but why in the world any real physician or scientist would take such a person seriously?
Still, I want to know what the hell “energy chelation” is. It’s not an easy question to answer, but various searches describe it as a hands-on energy healing technique that, analogous to chelation therapy, “chelate” and remove negative energies from the body. In other words, it’s a fantasy spun out of happy thoughts and a juvenile imagination.
The “science-y” bit of the study isn’t any better, relying of famously inaccurate “saliva cortisol” measurements, and something called “cortisol variability”, which does not appear to be a validated marker of the symptom in question (fatigue). From my reading, I’m unclear that it’s ever been validated to measure anything.
For all I know, the editors of Cancer are detoxifying themselves in a sweat lodge to rid themselves of the embarrassment of publishing such dreck. I just hope they remember to drink lots of water—faith healers do not have a great track record for patient safety.
References
Jain S, Pavlik D, Distefan J, Bruyere RR, Acer J, Garcia R, Coulter I, Ives J, Roesch SC, Jonas W, & Mills PJ (2011). Complementary medicine for fatigue and cortisol variability in breast cancer survivors: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Cancer PMID: 21823103

What Would It Take?
Harriet Hall on June 12, 2012
Link
I recently wrote a SkepDoc column on fantasy physics in Skeptic magazine in which I mentioned a study that had allegedly measured 2 milligauss emanations from a healer’s hands. A reader inquired about it and went on to ask “what criteria is [sic] necessary for gaining acceptance in the scientific community in regards to purported healing processes using energy fields generated in the human hand, specifically the palm area.”
What would it take to prove this implausible claim to the satisfaction of the scientific community? That is an excellent question with a complicated answer. It’s worth looking at because there is only one science and the same standards apply to how science evaluates any claim. I’ll take a stab at it, and perhaps our commenters can add words of wisdom.
The claim in question is a variant of energy healing at a distance, in the same family as therapeutic touch, Reiki, and Qigong, and it is highly implausible. Physicist Eugenie Mielczarek explains 
a two milligauss field strength is 18 orders of magnitude below the energy needed to affect any biochemistry. The postulate of an unknown energy field which eludes all science-based investigation and measurement, but nevertheless causes a transmission of energies large enough to affect the chemistry of cell cultures, flies in the face of all micro and cellular biology experimentation and well tested theories of physics. This postulate of a medically healing energy field, which can only be generated by certain individuals, fails all tests of medical science.
When energy fields are used as a medium for conveying information, scientists ask and answer the following key questions: How large is the signal? What is the transmitter located in the source, and what and where is the receiver? How can the device be tuned and detuned? Lastly, how can one replicate this by a device to be used for medical intervention? 
This methodology has led to the invention of many important medical devices—such as ultrasonic and MRI imaging. The alleged source of TT’s purported biomagnetic field is the practitioner, and the alleged receiver is the patient. Beyond this, TT practitioners fail to give detailed and plausible answers to the key questions above. TT practitioners’ adoption of the scientific term “biomagnetic” field, without an equation to describe the field and without any grounding in known physics and biochemistry, conveys the impression of scientific respectability to claims that have no scientific basis.
Energy medicine proponents claim to have measured a 2 milligauss magnetic field emanating from the hands of practitioners. Reproducible measurements by other scientists fall in the range of 0.004 milligauss. The magnetic field of the earth is 500 milligauss. Even if the 2 milligauss measurement were accurate, it would be 15 orders of magnitude below the cell’s noise level and billions of times less than the energy received by your eye when viewing the brightest star. A typical refrigerator magnet is 50 gauss (50,000 milligauss).
Science doesn’t automatically reject anything on the basis of implausibility alone. If there were strong evidence that energy medicine practitioners could significantly improve health outcomes, we would have to accept it at face value and we would start using it before we had a good explanation or a reconciliation with other scientific knowledge. When the first trials of penicillin were carried out, the evidence was so strong that penicillin was rushed into general use long before we had any idea how it worked (by inhibiting bacterial cell wall synthesis). The evidence for clinical effectiveness of energy medicine remains weak and flawed even after decades of study.
As Carl Sagan famously said,
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
And in the case of energy medicine and the human energy field, we don’t have even an ordinary level of evidence.
The first logical step would be to see if the 2 milligauss measurement was reproducible and if so, to study its characteristics. A scientist would ask all sorts of questions: Could there have been something wrong with our experimental setup? How does the effect decline over distance? Does everyone produce it? Do energy practitioners produce the same field under all conditions? Does it originate from the palm only, or from other sites? Does it require conscious intention? Could purported effects be attributed to placebo responses? Do the much stronger earth’s magnetic field and the much higher energy received by your eye when looking at a star have even stronger effects than the healer’s emanations? Wouldn’t a refrigerator magnet have an effect that is 25,000 times stronger? And on and on… But instead of verifying and further investigating an initial report, energy medicine researchers tend to jump from experiment to experiment, showing a lot of different alleged phenomena but not delving into any of them to establish their validity and characterize their properties.
Before you can seriously study a phenomenon like the human energy field, you need to determine that it exists. So far no one has been able to refute Emily Rosa’s demonstration that the alleged perception of that field amounts to self-deception. Studies of energy medicine are a prime example of what I have dubbed “tooth fairy science.” 
When we criticize any CAM method as not being supported by high-quality controlled studies, we mean that such studies are necessary: we don’t mean that they would be sufficient. Science is a collaborative, progressive endeavor that builds on itself to produce a gradually more convincing edifice over time. There is no black-and-white certainty, but rather a spectrum of probability: saying that a claim has been “proven” does not mean that it is “true” in some absolute sense, but only that the accumulated evidence makes it so probable that it would be perverse not to accept it. And even in the most certain cases, science must always remain open to new evidence and the possible need to revise earlier conclusions.
The Bottom Line
To gain acceptance in the scientific community, energy medicine would have to accumulate a large body of strong evidence that was reproducible (by believers and nonbelievers alike), that was coherent, that showed progress as new evidence built on older findings, and that used several different routes of investigation to arrive at the same conclusions. That seems highly unlikely, but it’s not for us to declare it impossible: the burden is on the proponents to produce credible evidence. I’m not holding my breath.
There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio…
Maybe, but there are also a lot of things that aren’t in heaven or earth, but only in people’s imaginations. Only rigorous science can help us tell the difference.

Full of Energy
Jann Bellamy on October 31, 2013
Link
Want to know what a craniosacral treatment is actually like? How about reiki? What about Eden energy medicine – do you eve n know what that is? Read on, because this past Sunday afternoon I experienced all three.
But first, the why and where. The local Healing Arts Alliance of the Big Bend (which is what they call the area of Florida I live in) held an information session for the public at our local library’s meeting room. Practitioners of about 10 different “healing arts” sat at a circle of folding tables chatting with visitors and handing out information. One even brought her diagnostic machine, which measures a person’s aura. (More on this later.) Some offered free samples of their treatments. It was a great opportunity for science-based medicine field work and I aimed to take full advantage.
The Alliance handed out a free booklet at the door listing local health care practitioners who:
. . . share a commitment to the whole person, patient-centered approach to health and wellness.
But, as the booklet explains,
[w]e do not endorse any specific method or system. Our member/practitioners are committed to a nonjudgmental collaboration and cooperative relationship . . .
This philosophy is indeed fortunate. If any of these practitioners endorsed a specific method, such as, say, the scientific method, it could lead to the judgment that what some of the others are saying is gobbledygook.
The booklet contains a helpful “Glossary of Holistic Health Terms,” which further serves to make the point that nonjudgmental collaboration is absolutely necessary to the cause. A few examples:
BioMat: This device delivers the highest vibrational resonance deep into all the tissues of the body using negative ions, amethyst, and Far-Infrared light to open the channels for intelligent cellular communication leading to DNA repair and total body wellness. Negative ions, found in abundance in nature, heighten alertness and mental energy, and decrease drowsiness. Amethyst enhances strength, stability and vigor. Far-Infrared light assists blood flow, helps release toxins and enlivens metabolism. Elevating temperature eliminates bacteria, heals and relaxes muscles, boosts immune system [sic], and promotes cardio fitness and healthy arteries.
Total body wellness is hard to beat. The one true cure, indeed!
BioMat has some stiff competition in the cellular woo department. According to the booklet, there’s also Frequency Specific Microcurrent which:
. . . uses micro amperage current (1/1,000,000th amp) to balance tissues at their own level of frequency. Like the brain or heart, each type of tissue resonates/vibrates at a unique frequency. FSM modulates the imbalanced frequencies the cells may be producing to assist the body in correcting the imbalance.
What, no quantum? You just haven’t read far enough. Here’s Matrix Energetics, another remedy for poor cellular function:
Based on the laws and expression of subtle energy physics and the concepts and laws of quantum physics, superstring theory, and Sheldrake’s Morphic Resonance. In physics reality can be described as vibrations and wave pattern; everything is light and information. Disease may be defined as a disruption, cessation, or distortion in the matrix of these fields. Physical and emotional injuries impair communication at the cellular level.
And so on. But this is small potatoes when you consider the more global perspective of Earth Acupuncture, defined here:
Disperses and regulates the flow of vital energy within the earth. A treatment used to heal Geopathic Stress on-site or from a distance.
Geopathic Stress?
Unnatrual vibrations of energy within the land (below the foundation of a building) that cause health problems in people, animals, plants, and trees. “Chaos underground” is caused by electromagnetic fields from fault lines, sink holes, subterranean water, and underground power lines.
There’s no explanation of how Earth Acupuncture is done but I found this on the internet. It looks like a lot of geometry, which I never liked, so you’ll have to figure it out for yourself. But don’t be judgmental! We want to maintain our cooperative relationships here, even if it requires extreme cognitive dissonance.
There is also Visionary CranioSacral Therapy, as opposed to run-of-the-mill craniosacral therapy, which is what I had. (We’ll get to that next.) Pay attention – this is hard to follow.
Because of the proximity of the reciprocal tension membrane – a system of membranous partitions inside the head – to the respiratory, circulatory, and locomotive centers of the central nervous system, VCT can have widespread and profound effects on peripheral circulation and general well-being as it accesses specific brain structures and psychological states by directing energy in the form of chi kung; applying sensitive mechanical pressures, which act via an improvement in the position, motion, and piezoelectric field of specific cranial bones; causing improved hydraulic flow patterns in the cerebrospinal fluid; optimizing brain temperature by reducing muscular tension and increasing heat dissipation.
Got it? No? Me neither.
It’s all about the energy
The therapist who provided my complimentary craniosacral treatment had a much more mundane explanation for how craniosacral therapy works, but then again, I did not get the Visionary kind. Perhaps she wasn’t properly trained in it or perhaps you can’t just give that sort of thing away for free. Or maybe she determined that my brain temperature was already optimal. I’d like to think so.
In any event, my therapist explained that each person has an internal “body sock” which includes the fascia and perhaps some other things I can’t recall. What craniosacral therapy does is enlarge the body sock. I didn’t quite understand her explanation of how this enlarged body sock might benefit my health. Nor did I think to ask her what happened if the body sock got too large. Does it sag, like a pair of ill-fitting hose? Anatomy aside, she told me some of the conditions it could help, including ADHD, autism and problems of special needs children. She also said that newborns benefited from craniosacral therapy because the birth process is so hard on them. You’d think a fresh body sock like that wouldn’t need to be stretched, but what do I know?
The actual treatment is pretty easy to explain. She sat beside me and put her hands on my upper back, near the shoulder. We sat there for a few minutes like that while she talked about craniosacral therapy. She thought she felt some sort of “release” at the end of the treatment but I don’t know what exactly was released. An energy blockage perhaps? Obviously, I can’t check the size of my body sock so I can’t tell you whether it got bigger. I think not, as I didn’t feel anything during the treatment and, as far as I can tell, it conferred no health benefit. The treatment did have a side effect – nausea, at the thought of her treating children.
Reiki was different. For that treatment, two therapists sat behind me for about 10 minutes and each put a hand on my upper back. See the difference?
I thoroughly enjoyed talking to these women. They were entirely sincere about reiki and also had a great sense of humor. As they explained it, there is a universal life force which flows through the practitioner to the recipient. (I didn’t think to ask why the universal life force couldn’t just flow directly into a person who needed it.) All they do is get out of the way. In some cases, literally out of the way, as reiki can be remotely, from a great distance away. They need only the person’s name and address and the universal life force will find them. Maybe the universal life force uses Google maps. Sometimes they shoot some universal life force in a person’s direction even if he didn’t ask for it. Later, according to one, the person claims to have felt something. If she asks him what time this happened, guess what? She will recall that it was just as she was sending him a dose of universal life force.
What if the practitioner actually messes up the energy flowing into the recipient? I asked that question and they had actually thought about the issue. One simply said it was faith – in her abilities, I suppose. The other said it had to do with having actually felt the energy flowing between her two hands when she held them a short distance apart, a phenomenon I’ve heard described before by a therapeutic touch practitioner. I’m not sure how this answered my question but it satisfied her concerns.
They remarked that they were feeling warmth and asked if I was too. Well, yeah, I thought, that happens if you put your hands on another person for a few minutes. If the reiki affected my health in any fashion, I have yet to discover it.
My third clinical encounter was with an “Eden energy” practitioner. She too was a very nice person and quite sincere and sweet-natured about what she did. I didn’t get an actual treatment from her, but rather an examination of sorts. I held out my arm and she had me resist her hand pressing on the arm. (It was not unlike the type of thing a medical doctor would do during a neurological exam.) She then lightly pinched my upper arm and repeated the resistance test. After that she performed another diagnostic test. She had me hold out my arm again and resist her hand. This time she pulled slightly on a bit of my hair. Like the first test, we repeated the arm resistance.
The point of all this was to detect a difference in the movement of my arm following application of resistance while I continued to hold the arm straight out from my body, both before and after the arm pinching or the hair pulling. The latter were means of causing a temporary disturbance in the flow of energy through my body and each was associated with a particular diagnosis. The hair pull was a test of hydration, although she wouldn’t say whether I was hydrated or not because she said the tests were not valid due to my being in a room full of people, which likely caused me to be somewhat self-conscious. I never learned what the arm pinching was supposed to diagnose. Had I proceeded to actual treatment, energy blockages revealed by testing would be unblocked by energy therapy.
What interested me was that all three of these treatment methods were based to a degree on the flow of energy through my body, yet they had entirely different approaches. I got the impression that this was not a wholly nonjudgmental state of affairs. When the Eden energy practitioner and a reiki practitioner (but not one of my reiki practitioners) were sitting at the same table earlier in the afternoon, before my treatment, I asked each of them whether their treatments were hands-on or not. The Eden energy practitioner said no and the reiki practitioner said yes. I detected just a bit of negative energy flow between them during that exchange. Perhaps the reiki practitioner slapped the Eden energy practitioner long distance with a smidgen of bad universal life force and the former zapped the latter back with a tad of evil energy. I just hope none got on me.
The worst, saved for last
Although I didn’t get to talk to her, a chiropractor was there with her pamphlets extolling thermography for detection of breast cancer, an idea David Gorski thoroughly debunked. But evidence be damned. The chiropractor’s pamphlet recommends annual DITI (Digital Infrared Thermal Imagining) screening for all women. Why?
DITI detects the subtle physiologic changes that accompany breast pathology, whether it is cancer, fibrocystic disease, an infection or a vascular disease. Your doctor can then plan accordingly and lay out a careful program to further diagnose and/or MONITOR you during and after any treatment.
Your doctor? And who is this doctor? Who decides if further diagnosis is needed and who monitors you during and after treatment? I don’t know. The chiropractor lists herself as the thermographer on the brochure. The manufacturer of the DITI equipment says on its website that a radiologist or “thermologist” reads the digitized images, so at least she is not reading the thermograms. Then, according to the manufacturer, if the thermogram is positive:
. . . the job of differential diagnosis begins. Reports are colour printed and sent to the patients [sic] physician / specialist.
Who is this physician and who is doing the differential diagnosis? Let’s hope it’s not the chiropractor. Of course, if the patient is referred to a medical doctor he may be put in the uncomfortable position of trying to dissuade the patient from further unnecessary diagnostic procedures or telling her she wasted her money on the thermogram.
An “integrative” primary care practitioner had a table too, manned by a nurse practitioner, who apparently runs the practice. They also have an M.D. on staff and another one as a consulting physician. The practice offers “bio-identical hormones” based on a test referred to as “FSP,” a saliva test. They also test (via a different method) for “toxins.” They sell supplements to patients and conduct Functional Medicine tests. They use the iSpot Lyme test to diagnose “difficult cases which may be Lyme Disease,” even though the incidence of Lyme Disease in Florida is miniscule. They say this test is covered by Medicare and Tricare. According to their literature, most of their Spectracell FIA – Functional Nutritional Analysis – is covered as well. This test “asks” your own cells what nutrients they lack.
And now, the worst of the worst.
I earlier mentioned the aura measuring machine. Here it is, the REBA device:
I’ll try to explain how this REBA device “works,” according to the M.D. who uses it in her practice. That’s right, an M.D.
The device shoots waves, such as gamma waves, into the patient. The doctor then interprets how the waves are affecting the patient. This gives her a diagnosis. The diagnosis is part of a system called Psychosomatic Energetics, which is, according to the pamphlet she handed out:
. . . a new method of treating illnesses in a holistic way, considering the body and soul as well as the vital energies. . . . It is based on a combination of Eastern energy medicine, such as acupuncture or yoga, with scientific, modern thinking. . . . Psychosomatic Energetics enables you to measure the subtle energy field of the body (aura) very precisely. [The aim is] to find energy deficiencies and to rebalance them, like in acupuncture and homeopathy.
The pamphlet goes on to explain how one’s energy levels are disturbed by unconscious emotional conflicts which alter the function of the autonomic nervous system, leading to energy blocks. Different emotions are related to different chakras. These blocks, in turn, lead to malnutrition of the cells, resulting in pain and illness. Relief is obtained through the use of “homeopathic chakra remedies,” (sold under the brand name Rubimed) including those effective in treating the aforementioned geopathic stress, as well as electro-smog, which I take to be a related problem. One uses a homeopathic remedy called Geovita for this unfortunate condition, along with repositioning one’s bed in the bedroom, which assists in rebalancing energies and overcoming the effects of electro-smog.
I suppose if your back goes out repositioning the bed there is something for that too.
When I questioned the M.D./Psychosomatics Energetics Practitioner about her methods, her answers tended to attack medicine, not defend what she was doing. She claimed “science is a religion.” Yet, she freely traded on her status as an M.D. and a “science nerd” in promoting her practice. (According to the Alliance booklet, she completed an Integrative Medicine residency at the University of Arizona. This information is right next to “Certified in Professional Applied Kinesiology.”) I kept repeating that I was not defending medicine, I was asking her to defend her practice. She said she “had seen it work,” but never really responded to my point that this could easily be regression to the mean, confirmation bias, or the placebo effect. I asked if there were any clinical trials of her methods and she said there were in Europe and that they had been published there, where Psychosomatic Energetics is widely used. (This reminded me a little of the TV infomercial pitch: “Not sold in stores, thousands sold in Europe.”) However, the only studies I could find were referenced on the International Society of Psychosomatic Energetics website. In a classic example of Tooth Fairy Science, they were three practice-based studies published in the Swiss Journal of Holistic Medicine. The Society notes that:
Although the phenomenon has long been known and demonstrated on TV and even on YouTube, there is as yet no recognized body of knowledge.
I later found out that, in May of this year, the FDA sent a warning letter to the manufacturer of the REBA device, located in Switzerland. The letter is four pages long and details, in mind-numbing bureaucrat-ese, a number of legal problems the FDA has with the REBA, which the FDA classifies a bio-feedback device, not an aura detector. The end result of all this is that the FDA “is taking steps to refuse entry of these devices into the United States until these violations are corrected.” I don’t know if this affects REBA devices already in the U.S. or not. I called the FDA to find out but have not heard back. The website of the U.S. distributor says that the device is “currently unavailable.”
Alternative medicine as observed in the field is pretty much what one would expect. New, and sometimes competing, forms of pseudoscience are simply rehashes of the same old pseudoscience, tarted up with more advanced “sciency” terms like quantum physics and superstring theory. Words are strung together in meaningless phrases like “open the channels for intelligent cellular communication leading to DNA repair.” Unfortunately, even medical (including nursing) education appears to be insufficient to inoculate practitioners against irrational beliefs. It is deeply disturbing to see this in action. Other practitioners, who don’t have a clue about how the body works, hawk treatments that have no plausible basis in science and are either known to be ineffective or their effectiveness is unknown, but doubtful. Silly diagnostic devices are used to convince the public they have diseases and conditions they don’t have, followed by treatments sold to them by the same practitioners who test them. Under the banner of “complementary and alternative medicine” anything goes.

Energy Medicine – Noise-Based Pseudoscience
Steven NovellaconcDecember 12, 2012
Link
So-called complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is largely philosophy-based medicine rather than science based. There are a few core concepts that are endlessly recycled in various forms, but it is mythology and culture, not grounded in the rigorous methods of science that allow us to tell the difference between our satisfying fantasies and hard reality. Sometimes proponents of such philosophies try to cloak their beliefs in the appearance of science, resulting in what we simply call pseudoscience.
Harriet Hall coined an excellent term to refer to such pseudoscience –” Tooth Fairy science.” In her metaphor, pseudoscientists sometimes act like scientists by describing the details and statistics of their claimed phenomenon (such as examining all the details of the Tooth Fairy phenomenon) without ever testing the reality of the phenomenon itself. The fundamental concept at the core of their belief is never challenged, or only superficially so, and they proceed prematurely from their faulty premise.
Another term that I find extremely apt is “Cargo Cult science,” a term coined by Richard Feynman. This is a reference to the cargo cults of New Guinea – the pre-industrial tribes were observed building straw mock-ups of control towers, planes, and runways in hopes that the planes they observed flying over head would deliver their cargo to them. In other words – the cargo cults mimicked the superficial appearance of an aviation infrastructure but had none of the real essence or function (because of lack of understanding). This is a perfect analogy to much of what passes for science within the world of CAM.
Not that we need another analogy, but I have often described such pseudoscience as being lost in the noise. In any endeavor to detect something there is the issue of the signal to noise ratio. Often the core challenge of scientific research is pulling the signal out from the background noise, or (more to the point) deciding if there is a signal in the noise, or if the information represents pure noise. In this analogy “noise” refers to any randomness in the data or interference from effects other than the alleged signal of interest. What I find is that pseudoscientific investigations of tooth fairy phenomena are completely lost in the noise of data, seeing whatever phantom “signals” support their philosophy. Elaborate but entirely illusory constructs are often crafted (or retrofitted to) these phantom signals.
Energy medicine is a perfect example of cargo-cult, Tooth Fairy, noise-based pseudoscience.
Energy medicine began its life as a philosophy-based notion, and is still philosophy-based, but many of its modern practitioners are desperate for the respectability that science has to offer. Some have therefore erected a pseudoscientific facade for this pre-scientific superstition.
One example I was recently asked to investigate is the Heartmath institute., which promotes an energy-medicine based claim that the heart sends out “energy” waves that regulate the body, including the brain. According to proponents, the heart has its own memory and emotion and the health and functioning of the body depend upon the energy rhythms generated by the heart. Heartmath explains:
Most of us have been taught in school that the heart is constantly responding to “orders” sent by the brain in the form of neural signals. However, it is not as commonly known that the heart actually sends more signals to the brain than the brain sends to the heart! Moreover, these heart signals have a significant effect on brain function—influencing emotional processing as well as higher cognitive faculties such as attention, perception, memory, and problem-solving. In other words, not only does the heart respond to the brain, but the brain continuously responds to the heart.
The noise that is the basis of their “research” is heart rate variability (HRV) – the beat-to-beat variability in the time between successive heart beats. Proponents claim that there is an optimal HRV for mental and physical health, sometimes called “coherence” (because pseudosciences need to have their own fake jargon). Negative emotions cause chaotic HRV which then negatively affect the brain and rest of the body, while happy emotions result in HRV coherence and health.
I could not find any published peer-reviewed studies that establish any of these premises. I did find one recent review of coherence and HRV therapy for anxiety and depression, which concluded:
Our literature search focused on 1) the assumption that poor mental health is definitely linked to deviant heart rate variability, and 2) the assumption that optimising heart rate variability leads specifically to a reduction of complaints and symptoms.
There is insufficient evidence to support these two assumptions.
Slow breathing and heart coherence training probably achieve their effects as a result of non-specific psychological mechanisms.
The last statement assumes that any effects are achieved, a question which was not the focus of this review. Any feedback type intervention likely results in a degree of relaxation and stress reduction, however – the non-specific effects referred to above. Of course, HeartMath assures us (without evidence) that coherence is not simply relaxation.
Heartmath sells a machine, the emWave, that measures the heart rhythm (it seems as if it is measuring the pulse, although this is not explicitly described), and also breathing. This creates lots of data in the form of waves, which can either be smooth or chaotic looking:
As I sated above, there are multiple sources of “noise” in data, including simple random variation and interference from effects other than the effect of interest. The pulse waves above are not correlated with an EKG (at least not in the material provided), but it would certainly be interesting to see the heart rhythm that accompanies the above pressure waves. The assumption being made is that the top pressure wave (during frustration) is real and not due to technical interference, but that would be the most probable cause. It is common to measure pulse waves in the hospital, so I am used to looking at them displayed on a monitor. The top tracing looks to me like technical interference, such as from moving or tensing the muscles. In other words – this is likely literal noise, not a true measure of anything physiological. This is the equivalent of interpreting pigeons nesting on the radio dish as alien signals.
The breathing tracings are even worse – one would have to believe the subject when not in “coherence” is hyperventilating and on the brink of passing out to believe the tracings are real and not artifactual.
That is it – that is the core evidence for the entire premise of Heartmath, bad tracings, technical artifacts, and noise. Everything else is just mythology and storytelling – a tale woven from intertwining threads of pre-scientific superstition and some modern jargon and concepts.
Weaving in some actual science is also a common ploy of pseudoscience. The best lies have a kernel of truth at their center. For example, in the documentary linked to above we are told that the heart generates the largest electromagnetic field of anything in the body. This is mostly true, because the heart is regulated by an internal electrical system and muscles in general are electrical tissue. The heart puts out the largest signal while the body is at rest. When engaging in physical activity, the muscles put out large amounts of electrical signals as well on the same order of magnitude as the heart. But all of this has nothing to do with the claims of Heartmath and coherence – it’s just a science factoid used to make it seem as if the energy medicine claims are based on science when they aren’t.
The documentary goes on to say that the pulse (what they are measuring with their emWave) is not a result of blood flow but of an energy wave from the heart. This is patently false – the pulse can be interrupted by blocking blood flow. But this bit of error is necessary for the Heartmath construct – that their emWave is not simply a pulse meter prone to noise, but is measuring energy from the heart that is magically communicating to the brain and the rest of the body. They start with a trueish but irrelevant fact, then leap off the cliff.
Conclusion:
For many pseudosciences, when you dig down to the core of their claims you will find there either nothing, or simply noise – some source of random or artifactual signals that generate data to feed into the predetermined conclusions of the pseudoscience. Energy medicine in general, and Heartmath in particular, are excellent examples of this phenomenon.
What you do not find are rigorous scientific studies that are designed to test the core premises of the pseudoscience – designed so that they are capable of disproving their premises or distinguishing the new effect they are claiming from existing known effects. In other words – you will not find any actual science, just the “cheap imitation” of cargo-cult, tooth fairy science.

   Frequencies and Their Kindred Delusions
Harriet Hall 
Link
The word “frequency” ranks right up there with “quantum” and “energy” as a pseudoscientific buzzword. It is increasingly prevalent in product advertisements and in CAM claims about human biofields and energy medicine. It doesn’t mean what they think it means.
I have written about Power Balance products, the wristbands and cards that allegedly improve sports performance through frequencies embedded in a hologram. They amount to nothing but a new version of the old rabbit’s foot carried for superstition and their sales demonstrations fool people with simple musculoskeletal tricks. I addressed their ridiculous claims (including “We are a frequency”). I pointed out that
The definition of frequency is “the number of repetitions of a periodic process in a unit of time.” A frequency can’t exist in isolation. There has to be a periodic process, like a sound wave, a radio wave, a clock pendulum, or a train passing by at the rate of x boxcars per minute. The phrase “33⅓ per minute” is meaningless: you can’t have an rpm without an r. A periodic process can have a frequency, but an armadillo and a tomato can’t. Neither a periodic process nor a person can “be” a frequency.
There are a number of similar embedded frequency products with different names. I got an e-mail from a man who thought he had found the best one yet: Ancestor Bands that promised to put him in contact with his forebears and allow him to benefit from their wisdom.
The "Ancestor Band"
I thought he was pulling my leg, but he insisted he wasn’t. I asked him to wonder how they might have determined which frequencies the ancestors use. I asked him to question how he would know that any messages he got were really from his ancestors rather than from Pol Pot, from Hitler, from Jeffrey Dahmer, from an ignorant Stone Age caveman, or from some random village idiot. He said I had given him some things to think about, but he was trying to keep an open mind and really wanted to believe they worked. The website says
We are all uniquely connected to our ancestors genetically. The bands you see here will help you tap into the proper frequencies that your Ancestors transmit throughout the Cosmos. They are desperately trying to connect with you and impart their Newfound Universal knowledge of the Universe. The bands are designed to increase your mental power, physical strength, and reverse the effects of aging. Try it today, feel the difference tomorrow.
They start with the idea that all living things are interconnected and produce energy waves that we can tap into, apparently even after they have stopped living! The Ancestor Band uses “energetic therapy and informational balancing” to
directly address the energetic level using light, sound, electricity and magnetism as carriers of client- and condition-specific information… to remove tiredness, weakness, reduce pain, and eliminate stress… a group of spiritual advisors have transformed each piece into a Unique Genetic Communications link to the Past, Present, future, and beyond.
That’s about as silly a piece of gobbledygook as I have ever read. It would be impossible to test their claims because you can’t even figure out what they are claiming. For starters, I can’t begin to guess what “beyond the future” means.
Recently I’ve been getting e-mails advertising Philip Stein watches. They use “natural frequency technology” to embed frequencies in watches. This provides improved sleep. And they even have a published double blind randomized placebo controlled study that proves it. Only it doesn’t. It did not give statistically significant results, but they interpreted it as positive because 96% of subjects reported improvement on at least one variable. That is not a meaningful scientific finding. In fact, it reminds me of a clever ploy that is taught to chiropractors: instead of asking whether the patient’s back pain got better after the last spinal adjustment, they are supposed to ask “What’s better?” until the patient admits that something is better (he slept better last night, or his appetite has improved, or his ingrown toenail hasn’t been hurting as much, or whatever). Then they can say “See, the treatment is helping you.”
The frequencies they are talking about are electromagnetic frequencies, and several of these were somehow embedded in a disc in the watch. It is a metal disk that has been “infused with key frequencies.” One of the key frequencies is 7.83 Hz, the Schumann Resonant Frequency. (Actually, there are several Schumann frequencies, which are observed peaks in the Earth’s electromagnetic spectrum.) It doesn’t make sense that they could embed electromagnetic frequencies without embedding something that produced those frequencies, with a power source. Or do they mean they are embedding something that will vibrate in resonance with those frequencies? It’s far from clear, and of course they won’t try to explain because of proprietary secrets.
They’re really proud of these watches. They charge anywhere from $1400 to $23,000 for them. Soon the company will launch a new product that, when combined with the frequencies found in Philip Stein watches, delivers even greater benefits in improved sleep. I can’t wait.
I’d love to see these products taken apart by engineers who are competent to analyze what is in them. Even if these products did contain something that generates electromagnetic frequencies or that resonates in response to certain outside frequencies, it would take a big leap of faith to imagine that process would have specific beneficial effects on health. You would first have to accept the concept of a human “bioenergy” field that can’t be measured. Then you would have to accept that the field changes in response to a specific frequency and that those field changes somehow produce a specific physiologic effect. Not only is there no plausible mechanism, but there are no studies showing evidence of benefit. It might work; but in the absence of evidence, believing it does work would require you to have such an open mind that your brain would be in grave danger of falling out.
Perhaps we should monitor the frequency of pseudoscientific claims about frequencies: it might serve to track the degree of idiocy in public misunderstanding of science.
Note: My spell checker didn’t like the word bioenergy any better than I do. (There is a legitimate use for the word, but this is not it.) The spell checker suggested I might want to substitute “beanery” or “baboonery.” I confess to being sorely tempted by the latter.
Another note: my title is a reference to Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes’ classic 1842 article“Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions.”

   Energy Bracelets: Embedding Frequencies in Holograms for Fun and Profit
Harriet Hall
Link
A salesman is demonstrating a new product at a sports store in the local mall. He has a customer stand with his arms extended horizontally to the sides; he presses down on an arm and the customer starts to fall over. Then he puts a bracelet on the customer and repeats the test; this time he is apparently unable to make the customer lose his balance. He has the customer turn his head as far as he can without the bracelet, and shows that he can turn his head a few degrees more after he puts on the bracelet. (Try this yourself: if you turn your head, wait a couple of seconds and try again, you will always be able to turn it further on the second trial). He similarly shows that the customer is stronger when he wears the bracelet. The customer and the onlookers are mightily impressed by the demonstration, by the salesman’s testimonials, and by the endorsements of famous athletes: they buy the bracelets to improve their athletic performance.
These so-called energy bracelets (also pendants and cards) allegedly contain a hologram embedded with frequencies that react positively with your body’s energy field to improve your balance, strength, flexibility, energy, and sports performance; and they also offer all sorts of other benefits (such as helping horses and birds and relieving menstrual cramps and headaches). The claims and the language on their websites are so blatantly pseudoscientific it’s hard to believe anyone would fall for them. Here are just a few examples from the Power Balance website:
    • We react with frequency because we are a frequency.
    • Your body’s energy field likes things that are good for it.
    • Why Holograms? We use holograms because they are composed of Mylar—a polyester film used for imprinting music, movies, pictures, and other data. Thus, it was a natural fit.
    • A primitive form of this technology was discovered when someone, somewhere along the line, picked up a rock and felt something that reacted positively with his body.
People have actually been convinced that this gobbledygook is a scientific explanation. Many sports celebrities swear by the bracelets. Millions have been sold.
Recently an account executive from a public relations/marketing communications firm contacted me about energy bracelets, asking if I would like free samples to check out for myself and if I would be interested in writing about the topic and maybe interviewing his “C-levels,” whatever those are. He represents one of at least 8 companies marketing such devices, but this company, EFX, is allegedly unique because it’s the only one that is embracing scientific studies. He says the other competing brands are avoiding any and all medical/scientific analysis, but EFX currently has “many independent studies being conducted, and is in the process of gathering funds to have an independent double-blind study implemented with seniors.” Are you impressed? They don’t have any evidence that their product works, but they are “in the process of gathering funds” to test it. After selling how many of them?
I don’t know how I got on his list, but he initially addressed me as “Ms.” rather than “Doctor” and he apparently had no idea that I had debunked (actually, ridiculed) a similar product, “Power Balance,” in an article in Skeptical Inquirer some time ago. An expanded version of that article is available online on Device Watch, a Quackwatch affiliate.I am not the only one to pick on them. Richard Saunders, the prominent Australian skeptic, has written about them and has even conducted a double blind test for Australian TV,where they failed miserably. He and Rachael Dunlop also produced their own video about applied kinesiology, explaining the simple biomechanical and psychological tricks that salesmen use to give people the false impression that the products improve their balance, strength, and flexibility. Brian Dunning has debunked energy bracelets on Skepticblog. And Time magazine recently did a story explaining that there is no science behind them but that users don’t seem to care and continue to use them as a kind of mechanized superstition.
When I wrote the Power Balance article, I pointed out that you can’t have a frequency in isolation. A frequency requires a periodic process; you can’t have “33 1/3 per minute” by itself but you can have “33 1/3 revolutions per minute.” A radio wave and a vibrating tuning fork can have a frequency: an armadillo and a tomato can’t. A person can’t “be” a frequency. I e-mailed the company and asked some simple questions like “How do you measure the frequency of a rock?” They didn’t answer.
So when I heard from the EFX account executive, I jumped at the chance to get some answers. I asked if he could ask a company representative
    • How are the frequencies chosen? How do you determine which ones are beneficial?
    • Why would one frequency work for different individuals? Aren’t we unique?
    • What do they mean by frequencies, since a frequency can’t exist alone but has to refer to a number of repetitions of a periodic process per period of time. What is the periodic process that generates the frequency involved in the bracelet technology?
    • How are frequencies embedded in a hologram? Yes, I know there are proprietary secrets, but perhaps you could provide a general answer that would give me a clue.
The proffered answers to my questions were revealing:
     1.  We choose the frequencies based upon research. The electromagnetic spectrum is vast, but there are specific frequencies that have an immediate positive effect on the human body. We determine which ones are the best to use through a lot of trial and error.
     2.  We are unique, and we think that no two people react exactly the same to our holograms. However, some frequencies are universal to the human body, which is why our holograms work with 95% of the people that try the product. Some have a relatively mild reaction, and with others the reaction to our holograms is profound.
     3.  Yes, a frequency is the number of waves that pass a fixed point in a period of time. It is quite possible (I do it when I program) to use a frequency generating machine, modified to work for our needs to “embed” frequencies onto a hologram (that includes a metallic substance) that will hold those frequencies. You are not going to find much support for this “theory” in mainstream science. Many will say that it is “impossible.” I say that there is still much that science does not know. I have been doing this long enough to know that it does work, it is real, and I don’t worry about the people saying that the idea makes no sense. Time is on my side.
Not going to give you any information about how we embed frequencies in a hologram. That is a trade secret.
The account executive was personally convinced because the headaches he used to get after 3-hour (!) cardio workouts vanished, and since he didn’t anticipate that, he can’t accept it as a placebo effect. He commented
My only estimation is that these frequency generating machines are somehow able to embed a self-sustaining frequency onto the mylar material. I haven’t had the opportunity to do in depth research on the theory personally, but from what I understand, this isn’t a theory that has much research discrediting or supporting it for that matter.
A self-sustaining frequency? In Mylar? I asked if he believed in perpetual motion. He answered
I’m not a scientist and I don’t know enough about how they “embed” the frequencies to verify how it works. All I know is that the team that I’ve met with internally at EFX are very adamant about the product, which is why they are willing to submit to the peer reviewed/double blind studies. “If this doesn’t work, we want to be proven wrong” was something the president once said to me. If he were a scam artist, I doubt very highly that he would be eager to submit his product to these tests.
I had asked if they could supply me with a bracelet that had not had the frequencies embedded, so I could use it as a placebo control to test the “active” bracelet. They couldn’t, because
We are currently engaged in independent peer reviewed double blind studies and would prefer to conclude those before sending blanks if you don’t mind.
I don’t think I need to point out what’s wrong with these answers and this type of thinking. The energy bracelet phenomenon is just one more demonstration that humans are a superstitious lot and that consumers can’t tell science from bullshit. This amounts to a high-tech version of carrying a rabbit’s foot for luck. At least the energy bracelets don’t require killing innocent bunnies: can this be considered progress of a sort?

Magnets Provide Amusement, But Not Health Benefits
Static magnets have no health benefits, but the advertising can be quite entertaining.
Harriet Hall on March 7, 2017
Link

Over the years, the claims for health benefits of magnets have provided me with much amusement. Here are just a few examples:
    • A skeptic pointed out that if magnets in health products really attracted red blood cells as claimed, an MRI scan with magnets many orders of magnitude stronger would be deadly: your blood would explode out from your skin all over your body.
    • A friend believed magnets relieved her pain; I told her studies showed they didn’t work; she said that was because the studies weren’t done with her brand of magnets, Nikken magnets, which really did work; I showed her negative studies that were done with Nikken magnets; she rejected the studies, saying science doesn’t know everything; she knew her magnets worked; her mind was made up and she wasn’t about to let me confuse her with the facts.
    • I heard a magnetic mattress pad salesman tell his audience that the negative magnetism was greater at night because the moon was out, and the positive magnetism was greater during the day because the sun was out.
Imagine my delight when I found an email in my inbox with the subject line “Do you have any interested [sic] in our Magnetic Energy Bracelet?”
The message said “Hope my email will bring large profit for your company in the future. [I don’t have a company.] Have you heard Magnetic Energy Bracelet? It’s powerful, can keep healthy for Men and Women. We have more than 200 designs for you choice, stainless steel bracelet, titanium steel bracelets (TA1 Grade), ceramics bracelets, tungsten steel bracelet, etc. The stainless steel bracelet is made of 316L, 85.7% of tungsten in tungsten steel bracelet.” The company that sells them is based in Guanghzou, China, as you might have guessed from the language. They are unbelievably inexpensive, all under $10 and some selling for as little as a penny apiece when purchased in bulk.
The email included pictures of attractive bracelets in various colors. Below the picture section was a section titled “The Function of Elements,” with pictures showing how the elements appear in the bracelets.
    • Germanium
        ◦ Unimpeded blood pressure
        ◦ Enhancement of human immunity
        ◦ The wide antineoplastic function
        ◦ Anti-carcinogen function
        ◦ Prevention and treatment of diseases
    • Anion
        ◦ Restrict oxidation of body cell
        ◦ Activate cell
        ◦ Strengthen immune ability
        ◦ Anti-inflammation
        ◦ Adjust nerve
        ◦ Purify air
        ◦ Antibacterial, deodorization
    • Far infrared
        ◦ Increase metabolism
        ◦ Improve immune
        ◦ Adjust blood pressure
        ◦ Improve arthralgia
        ◦ Adjust autonomic nerve
        ◦ Reduce fattiness
        ◦ Balance body’s PH degree
    • Magnet
        ◦ More restful sleep
        ◦ Increase tissue oxygenation
        ◦ Increase cellular oxygen level
        ◦ Improve blood circulation
        ◦ Improve anti-infective ability
This is high comedy. For a start, anion, far infrared, and magnet do not appear in the Periodic Table of Elements. I can understand how magnets and germanium can be built into a bracelet, but how do you suppose they add anion and far infrared? And the claims of health benefits are mostly vague and garbled. What do you suppose “adjust nerve” and “activate cell” mean? I had a good laugh, and I don’t feel any need to address any of these claims, because as Christopher Hitchens said, “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.”
I wonder how many of the companies that get this email actually order the bracelets and sell them? The very thought boggles my mind. But magnetic health products are big business: a billion dollars of sales a year worldwide and $300 million a year in the US. For example, at this website you can buy magnetic mattress pads, a magnetic power pad for back and hip, magnets for body parts, magnets for pets (collars and pet beds), magnetic massagers, magnetic finger and toe rings, all kinds of jewelry, even magnetic leather necklaces. Other websites offer braces, insoles, seat pads, headbands, pillows, sleep masks, etc.
Do magnets have health benefits?
Pulsed magnetic fields induce an electrical field, and have been used to treat fractures that are not healing properly. Transcranial magnetic stimulation has diagnostic and therapeutic uses, such as treating resistant depression. But the effects are due to the electrical field, not to magnetism.
Static magnets, on the other hand, have no health benefits.
    • The Quackwatch article concludes:
There is no scientific basis to conclude that small, static magnets can relieve pain or influence the course of any disease. In fact, many of today’s products produce no significant magnetic field at or beneath the skin’s surface.
    • The NCCIH says:
Magnets have not been proven to work for any health-related purpose.
    • The FDA says:
To date, the FDA has not cleared for marketing any magnets promoted for medical uses. Because these devices do not have marketing clearance, they are in violation of the law, and are subject to regulatory action. Action is taken on a case by case basis depending on the significance of the medical claims being made. Significant claims that are likely to trigger regulatory action include, but are not limited to, treatment of cancer, HIV, AIDS, asthma, arthritis, and rheumatism.
    • The Wikipedia article says:
Magnet therapy, magnetic therapy, or magnotherapy is a pseudoscientific alternative medicine practice involving the use of static magnetic fields. Practitioners claim that subjecting certain parts of the body to magnetostatic fields produced by permanent magnets has beneficial health effects. These physical and biological claims are unproven and no effects on health or healing have been established. Although hemoglobin, the blood protein that carries oxygen, is weakly diamagnetic (when oxygenated) or paramagnetic (when deoxygenated) the magnets used in magnetic therapy are many orders of magnitude too weak to have any measurable effect on blood flow.
    • A systematic review of randomized trials of static magnets for reducing pain concluded “The evidence does not support the use of static magnets for pain relief.”
Conclusion: Harmless entertainment
These “magnetic energy bracelets” are not likely to cause any harm, and they may do some good. People may get pleasure from wearing an attractive piece of jewelry. They may experience a placebo response: if they believe the bracelets can keep them healthy, they are likely to feel better subjectively even though there is no objective change in their health. The price is low, and there’s little chance that anyone would be tempted to use these bracelets in lieu of effective conventional medical treatment, since the health claims are so vague and incoherent.
If you subscribe to the old adage “Laughter is the best medicine,” you might think this is a useful product. It made me laugh heartily; I got a lot of enjoyment out of reading the e-mail. Wearing magnetic energy bracelets may not improve your health, but reading about them can be a source of harmless entertainment.

   Magnets and Blood Flow
Steven Novella
Link
Over the last week I have received numerous questions about a recent study (yet to be published, but highly publicized in the press) in which it is claimed that the application of a magnetic field can improve blood flow. Physics World declared in the headline that, “Magnetic fields reduce blood viscosity.” This is not a bad summary of the study, but then the first sentence claims:
Researchers in the US claim that exposing a person to a magnetic field could reduce their risk of a heart attack by streamlining the flow of blood around their body.
Science Magazine ran with the also tame headline of “Magnets Keep Blood Flowing” but also had some problems in the text of their report (which I will get to).
The amount of press attention the study is getting is a bit odd. It’s a small proof-of-concept study looking at the effects of strong magnetic fields on blood flow in vitro. I suspect part of the reason is the same as why so many people have been asking me about it – magnets are frequently marketed with health claims and these claims are often justified by the hand-waving explanation that magnetic fields improve blood flow. The concern is that this small study will be abused by huxsters to sell refrigerator magnets with unfounded health claims.
The history of health claims for magnets goes back as far as knowledge of magnetism itself. In the last decade there appears to have been an upsurge in this old scam – a plethora of products promising to treat arthritis, improve healing, or just give extra energy by placing a magnet over the target area. The magnets used are typically very weak and have a field that barely penetrates the skin, let alone reaching down to the joints or the area of pain.
Further – these products are generally using static magnets. Static magnetic fields would not be expected to have any effect on nerve function or blood flow. It is not surprising, therefore, that the clinical evidence for any efficacy is also negative.
This study is very different, and therefore has no applicability to any magnet product on the market (if it has any applicability at all). Physicists Rongjia Tao Ke Huang took donated blood and then measured its viscosity in a small tube used for that purpose. They then applied a 1.3 Tesla magnetic field to the tube (this is about the strength of the magnetic field used in a typical MRI scanner), with the field aligned with the direction of blood flow, for one minute and found that the viscosity decreased by 20-30%. This effect lasted for about 2 hours.
There are numerous problems with extrapolating from this study to a net clinical effect, and also in the interpretation of the mechanism of the effect. The researchers claim that the effect comes from the red blood cells clumping together, mostly in a line, like box cars on a train. The cells moving together as a train produces less resistance than if they were all bouncing around separately. Further, they tend to flow more down the middle of the tube, reducing friction with the tube wall.
The picture above shows the clumping of the cells. Immediately it seems as if there can be a problem applying this to a person. The glass tube used in the study was larger than the smallest arteries in people. Further, capillaries are only large enough to allow red cells to flow through single file. I would not want my red cells clumping as in the picture above and then trying to squeeze through capillaries. I would not be surprised if the effect on viscosity were reversed for smaller arteries, or even caused serious problems with capillary flow. But I suspect the net effect on blood flow in vivo is negligible, because we have been exposing people to magnetic fields of this strength in MRI scans for a couple decades now without any ill effects.
Another major problem is that the effect only happened when the field was aligned with the (straight) tube. Arteries in a living organism are not straight and are not parallel. They will be traveling every which way in relation to an external field. This will probably be the greatest limiting factor in applying this effect to organisms.
The effect (even in the optimal and contrived conditions of the study) was also short-lived – only two hours. Even if the effect could be achieved in a person, this makes it impractical for any application of routine prevention – such as preventing heart attacks and strokes as was reported in most articles on the study. I could imagine an application to an acute event, such as during a heart attack or stroke, and focused on a single blocked artery that can be aligned with the field. But even then, for the reasons stated above, I doubt the net clinical effect will be significant or necessarily positive.
Regarding mechanism, the Science Magazine article reports:
The magnetic effect, the researchers say, all comes down to hemoglobin, the iron-based protein inside red blood cells. In the same way that iron filings align themselves along the field lines around a bar magnet, so the red blood cells align themselves along the straight field lines of Tao and Huang’s electromagnet.
There is a significant problem with the analogy of hemoglobin to iron filings – iron is ferromagnetic, which means it has a strong response to an external magnetic field (in addition to the ability to retain a magnetic field itself, but this is not as relevant to the current study). The iron in hemoglobin is not ferromagnetic. Ferrohemoglobin (without oxygen attached) is weakly paramagnetic (is attracted to an external magnetic field). So it can align with a strong external magnetic field, but this effect is generally very weak. Oxyhemoglobin is non-magnetic (has a magnetic moment of zero, because it has no free electrons) and therefore does not respond at all to an external magnetic field. So oxygenated blood in arteries would have a very weak to no response to to an external magnetic field due to its hemoglobin.
Red cells themselves may be weakly diamagnetic – meaning they are repulsed by an external magnetic field (this is why a frog levitates over a powerful magnetic field) and this may be the effect that causes the observed clumping.
To reinforce this point, the weak paramagnetic or diamagnetic properties of cells or living tissue require a strong magnetic field to have any effect – like an MRI magnet. The small relatively weak magnets used in products with health claims are orders of magnitude too weak to have any such effect. The hemoglobin gambit (based on the fact that hemoglobin contains an iron atom) collapses under close examination.
Conclusion
It is interesting that a strong magnetic field can have a temporary effect on red blood cells. Whether or not this effect will have any future clinical applications remains to be seen. I doubt it, for all the reasons I explained above, but it’s possible someone may find a clever use for this effect.
The simplistic extrapolation from this contrived and temporary effect to improving blood flow and thereby reducing risk of heart attacks, however, is unjustified and misleading. Further, any attempt to use this study as a justification for clinical claims made for weak permanent magnets is beyond misleading , in the realm of the absurd.

   Can Magnets Heal?
Steven Novella 
Link
Belief in the healing power of magnets and magnetic fields has existed since the discovery of magnets several thousand years ago. In the late 18th century, Franz Anton Mesmer, an infamous charlatan, promoted the notion that he could heal with “animal magnetism.” In the 19th century magnetic healers were common – D.D. Palmer was a magnetic healer prior to founding chiropractic. Magnetic devices for everyday aches and pains have been increasingly popular recently, and today they are a multi-billion dollar industry.
Yet the scientific evidence does not, generally, support the use of magnets for specific indications, and the vast majority (if not totality) of claims made for magnetic devices in marketing are either false or unsupported and highly implausible. The media attention given to a recent study of static magnetic fields (SMF) in the treatment of inflammation brings up many important points regarding this disconnect.
A sciencedaily.com headline from January 7th proclaims: “Healing Value Of Magnets Demonstrated In Biomedical Engineering Study.” This headline is extremely misleading, especially the use of the word “healing.” The article is referring to a study by CE Morris and Thomas Skalak(1) published two months ago in the American Journal of Physiology – Acute Exposure to a Moderate Strength Magnetic Field Reduces Edema Formation in Rats. In the sciencedaily article Skalak is quoted as saying:
“We now hope to implement a series of steps, including private investment partners and eventually a major corporate partner, to realize these very widespread applications that will make a positive difference for human health.”
This optimism, however, is premature, and represents a significant problem with many popular therapies, the extrapolation from preliminary pre-clinical studies to clinical applications in humans. But before I look at this new study in more detail I will review some basic concepts for background.
First, it is important to recognize that not all magnets or magnetic fields are the same. The most significant difference is between pulsating magnetic fields and static magnetic fields. Electricity and magnetism are actually manifestations of the same fundamental force: electromagnetism. This was first recognized when it was discovered that a changing magnetic field can generate and electrical current, and a changing electrical current can generate a magnetic field. A pulsating magnetic field, therefore, is capable of generating an electrical current. Many aspect of cell function and communication involve electrical potentials or currents, and therefore it is plausible – at least from a physical point of view – for a pulsating magnetic field to affect electrical current in tissue and thereby manifest an effect. The best established clinical use of a pulsating magnetic field is in the healing of bone fractures. Although this effect is modest, the evidence so far supports the conclusion that there is a relevant biological response.
Static magnetic fields do not generate electrical current, and therefore any biological or medical evidence dealing with pulsating magnetic fields cannot be applied to SMF. An even more significant problem with SMF as a therapeutic modality is that the strengths of magnets commonly used are very low, probably too low to have any biological effect. Further, magnetic field strength decreases as the square of the distance or even as the cube of the distance from its origin (depending upon the shape and orientation of the magnets). So field strength decreases very quickly with distance.
Most magnetic health products list the magnetic field strength at the core of the magnet, but even 1 cm distance may decrease the field to negligible strength. Therefore, if a magnet is in a bandage or casing the field strength will be significantly decreased at the surface of the skin, and then even further decreased below the skin down to the target tissue. (David Ramey goes into this in more detail in this excellent review article.)
Assessing the biological plausibility of magnetic therapy reveals further difficulties. So far no proposed mechanisms for how a SMF would provide a therapeutic effect have been established. Some common claims include that SMF increases blood circulation, thereby providing more oxygen to the tissue and reducing inflammation, but again this has not been established and there is no known mechanism by which this would occur. When tissue lacks sufficient oxygen it sends out powerful chemical signals to increase blood flow. It is unlikely that a weak SMF would provide a stimulus for vasodilation (increasing blood vessel size) greater than what occurs naturally in the setting of low oxygen. Also, ironically, the claims made in the current study by Skalak is that SMF decreases blood flow to inflamed tissue.
Older claims, that SMF attracts the iron in blood, are easily dismissed because the form of iron in blood is not ferromagnetic. More recent claims that SMF affects the flow of ions in the blood, altering blood flow, are not plausible as the SMF strengths are too low to significantly affect the movement of ions. Still others claim that SMF decreases inflammation, and that is the subject of this recent study.
Skalak’s current study is an extension of prior work in which he demonstrated that, under a SMF, blood vessels that were already constricted would tend to dilate and those that were already dilated would tend to constrict. Therefore, a SMF must have a normalizing effect on blood vessel tone. This study has yet to be properly replicated, and one concern about such results is that they could simply be due to regression to the mean (a normalizing statistical effect).
Based upon this preliminary work, Morris and Skalak conducted a study in which they look at various SMF strengths a in a rat model of inflammation. Two different chemical irritants were used to produce local inflammation in a rat hind paw. The paws were then subjected to SMF of either 10mT (miliTesla), 70mT, or 400mT. What they found is that swelling due to histamine induced inflammation was decreased in the 10mT and 70mT groups, but not400mT, and not in the rats where inflammation was induced by lambda-carrageenan (CA). The effects were only seen if the SMF was applied immediately after inflammation was induced, not prior and not delayed or during peak edema. The authors conclude that this shows a dose and temporal dependent effect of SMF on inflammation, probably due to vasoconstriction reducing blood flow to the inflamed tissue. To their credit they measured the strength of the magnetic fields at the level of the tissue, not the core of the magnet, so field penetration was not an issue. (In fact the authors acknowledge that virtually all magnetic products currently on the market report core SMF strength, which is misleading.)
There are significant problems with this interpretation, however. First, there is not a consistent dose response effect, as the strongest field (400mT) showed no effect. The authors make the post-hoc analysis that there is an upper therapeutic threshold, but this was not predicted by the original hypothesis and there is no known mechanism for such a threshold. The more standard interpretation of such a result is a lack of consistent dose-response. Also, the effect was only seen in the histamine induced inflammation and not CA induced inflammation – again, not predicted by the working hypothesis of the study. If SMF works through vasoconstriction of dilated arteries, as the authors hypothesize, why would the mechanism of inflammation matter? Therefore, these results do not show a consistent or predicted pattern, and could easily be interpreted, if taken together, as a null effect.
The authors also looked at the effects of pharmacologically blocking L-type Ca(2+) channels or nitric oxide (NO) to see if either blocked the effects of the SMF. This is a clever and established way to infer mechanism of action, and they found that the former, but not the latter, did block the effect of decreased inflammation by a SMF. Therefore the authors hypothesize that the SMF may work its effect through calcium channels. But again, random effects cannot adequately be ruled out, given the large number of outcomes that were measured in total.
The study design and results are indeed interesting, and I think that such serious attempts at looking at various aspects of SMF effects, including possible mechanism of action, are constructive. However, these current results are only useful as preliminary data since the results require post-hoc analysis and were not specifically predicted ahead of time. In other words, no reliable conclusions can be drawn from this study until it is replicated to see if the pattern of results hold up. Is there really a 400mT therapeutic threshold, or was this simply a lack of dose-response, and therefore a negative result?
Also, there are significant limitations in applying this study to humans. As the authors recognize, SMF strength decreases significantly with distance. Rat paws are very small, and it is therefore practical to apply a strong SMF at tissue depth. A human joint or limb, however, is significantly larger requiring a much stronger SMF in order to maintain adequate strength at tissue depth. If these results represent a real physiological effect, they may not apply at all to humans or may simply be impractical.
Therefore it is premature to conclude from this study that SMF’s can be applied to treating inflammation in humans, or that there is any specific clinical effect. At best this study requires replication and may point the way toward further research.
The media reporting of this study has been misleading and highlights some of the difficulty in dealing with such research in areas where there is already a vigorous and largely unregulated market. Preliminary and problematic results, such as we have here, are presented by the media as if they were reliable clinical evidence that magnets can “heal.” Such studies are also used to market specific products that differ significantly from the magnets used in the study, and to make clinical claims that cannot be extrapolated from the available data.
Reference:
1) Morris CE, Skalak TC., Acute Exposure to a Moderate Strength Magnetic Field Reduces Edema Formation in Rats. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol. 2007 Nov 2

Novak Djokovic credits the TaoPatch for his success: What does the science say?
His ‘Biggest Secret’ is a tiny sticker selling for hundreds of dollars
Scott Gavura on July 20, 2023
Link

Novak Djokovic’s Wimbleton winning streak came to an end this past weekend as he went down to defeat to a young Carlos Alcaraz. One the world’s greatest men’s tennis players, Djokovic is also an anti-vaxxer whose credulity is almost as impressive as his Grand Slam wins. This year he was observed wearing a patch on his chest that he has called “the biggest secret of his career”. The product is called a TaoPatch which is said (by the manufacturer) to “apply the principles of acupuncture to low-level laser therapy using nanotechnology”. Let’s take a closer look to see if his undeniable tennis success could really be supported by this product.
Djokovic is no stranger to criticism for his wellness trends and believes in pseudoscience. He claims that people can change the composition of food and water with the power of belief. His opposition to vaccination led him to miss tournaments like the Australian Open and U.S. Open last year. He follows a gluten-free diet, and he apparently determined that he was intolerant by holding a piece of bread and undergoing strength tests. He is also a supporter of the so-called “Medical Medium” who we’ve covered before. Now he’s endorsing a new product.
What is a TaoPatch?
Its manufacturer calls it a “human upgrade device” that “improves posture, movement and performance without chemistry by acting on the body’s balance”. When you dig into what it actually is, there is little on the website that actually says what it is. On the page called “Research and Experimentation” there are links to some papers (many in Italian) with one that was in English and published. The paper is entitled, “Performance, balance and posture variations with Occlusal Splint and Taopatch® devices: a retrospettive [sic] cross-over study”. In that study, the Taopatch is described as a “naontechnological device based on carbon nanotubules and quantum dots.” This was an uncontrolled study that concluded that wearing the patch improved grip strength and squat jump. This is not surprising, and reminds me of the old “Power Balance” hologram/energy bracelet fad from over a decade ago, where athletes, both elite and everyday, were convinced that a piece of plastic improved their “energy fields”.
I also found a paper published entitled, Taopatch® combined with home-based training protocol to prevent sedentary lifestyle and biochemical changes in MS patients during COVID-19 pandemic. This is apparently a trial with a control group however the research is so poorly described I couldn’t determine if there was any randomization or blinding.
While it looks like a sticker, the manufacturer calls it a “nanotechnological medical device” that features carbon nanotubules and “quantum dots”. It “applies the principles of acupuncture” to “low level laser therapy”. It works by emitting “biophotons”. It “allows the innate intelligence of your body to restore its natural alignment.” “The heat from your body is converted into light of specific therapeutic frequencies, which are similar to the frequencies of photons your nervous system uses to communicate with the rest of your body.” It’s like they chose as many science-y buzzwords as possible and put them all in the marketing pitch.
This isn’t just marketed to credulous athletes. The website has specific pages dedicated to Multiple Sclerosis (“The Drug-Free Way to Reclaim Your Mobility, Freedom, and Independence” and Parkinson’s disease (“Say Goodbye to Tremors, Rigidity and Slowness of Movement!”) A neurologist has reviewed some of the claims about the TaoPatch. He notes the anecdotal claims, but concludes it is “unproven in MS”.
TaoPatch prices start in the hundreds of dollars and rise into the thousands.
Conclusion: The hologram bracelet of its generation
The TaoPatch is just the latest iteration of the seemingly endless stream of products that take advantage of consumer credulity, the belief in superstition, and a lack of skepticism. If this product could genuinely improve Parkinson’s or Multiple Sclerosis, it would be endorsed in medical guidelines and recommended by experts. If it genuinely enhanced sports performance, it would be prohibited in competition. Unfortunately, the results claimed by the manufacturer are highly implausible, and in the absence of any convincing evidence, the TaoPatch remain unproven.

Energy Medicine Pain Relief Patches Are Laughable Quackery
There’s no acceptable scientific evidence that these patches work to relieve pain. The advertising features pseudoscientific energy medicine gibberish. Good for a laugh, but not to be believed.
Harriet Hall on March 9, 2021
Link

Recently I have seen numerous ads for patches that can be applied to the skin to relieve pain. The descriptions are energy medicine nonsense. Imaginative and entertaining, but not to be believed.
The Luminas Patch is charged with the energetic signatures of over 200 natural remedies known to reduce inflammation, from willow bark to curcumin. Your body induces the flow of energy from the patch, choosing which electrons it needs to reduce inflammation. The patches contain no active ingredients, because they are charged with electrons captured from the 200 substances. Each patch contains 5.2 x 10^19 molecular structures, each with 2 oxygen polar bonding areas capable of holding a targeted, host electron, creating a total possible charging capacity equal to 10.4 x 10^19 host electrons. After considering the average transmission field voltage of humans (200 micro volts) we can calculate the relative capacity, per square inch of patch, at 333 Pico Farads. The website claims it took advantage of “revolutions in quantum theory”. David Gorski made fun of these claims in his Respectful Insolence blog.
He says “Somewhere, far back in the recesses of my mind and buried in the mists of time from decades ago, my knowledge from my undergraduate chemistry degree and the additional advanced physics courses stirred—and then screamed!”
The “evidence” they provide to prove that Luminas is effective consists of before-and-after thermography images, with no standardization and no controls. Thermography is notoriously unreliable and images are affected by changes in room temperature and removal of clothing. The images they offer are pretty pictures but are scientifically meaningless.
Signal Relief uses neuro capacitative coupling technology to relieve pain by interfering with the body’s electrical signals and clearing communication. Each device contains billions of micro-nano capacitors. A capacitor is a small particle that conducts electricity and interacts with your body’s natural electricity. The technology was originally developed for the United States Navy SEALS, which used the system to clear static and enhance reception for communication devices. Apparently, one Signal Relief device is all you will ever need; it keeps working forever and only the adhesive patches will need to be replaced. It needn’t touch the skin; it can be applied to clothing. It costs $120 to $140. It doesn’t work for everybody, but you can try it for 30 days and get a full refund if it doesn’t completely relieve your pain. It works nearly instantly to relieve pain.
Kailo patches use a patented technology; an array of billions of charged nanocapacitors that act as a bioantenna designed to assist the body in clear communication and turn down the volume on your pain in seconds. The strength of the body’s electrical field allows Kailo to target the pain when placed on your skin. The patch tells the brain what it needs to know to stop the pain. The patches can be used over and over. No side effects have been reported.
It would be a waste of time to critique each of these claims. You can judge for yourselves. You may laugh. You may scream. But if you have any knowledge of science, you will see that this pseudoscientific language is gibberish. It will raise all sorts of questions. Questions that the sellers of these patches have no answers for. In his article, David Gorski called for a randomized controlled trial of the Luminas patch versus an identical patch that wasn’t infused with the magic electrony goodness of the Luminas patch. The sellers know very well what such a trial would show, so they’re not about to do one.
Conclusion: No science here. If you value truth and reality, you can disregard these ads. And yet…customers are buying these products! It boggles the mind.

Update on Energy Medicine Pain Patches: Jovi and Its Targeted Marketing Strategy
For many women, cramps are a regular feature of their menstrual periods. Jovi is being marketed as a cure. It isn’t. It’s just more energy medicine pain patch nonsense.
Harriet Hall on April 20, 2021
Link


Last month I wrote about energy medicine pain patches, calling them laughable quackery. Now there’s another one: Jovi. It was brought to my attention by a correspondent who belongs to a Facebook group for chronic migraine sufferers. She reports that members of the group are all excited about a new product that they hope will put an end to their migraines and menstrual cramps: Jovi, a reusable patch. When I tried to look at Jovi’s website, I got a warning that it might be impersonating jovi.com to steal my personal or financial information. It said I should close the page, so I did. But it wasn’t hard to piece the story together from Facebook and other sources.
Jovi makes the same pseudoscientific claims as other patches. It allegedly uses technology developed to enhance reception in communications devices used by the U.S. Navy SEALS. It talks of nanocapacitors and neuro capacitive coupling. It is non-invasive. It allegedly acts as a bioantenna that picks up and enhances the body’s electrical fields to somehow prevent pain signals from reaching the brain. Essentially the same incoherent nonsense as Signal Relief and Kailo patches.
Their new marketing strategy specifically targets menstrual cramps and migraine pain. There are testimonials galore on social media. It is specifically designed to appeal to women, even stressing that women were involved in the product’s development. There are no controlled studies. In a courtroom, the testimonials would not be acceptable as evidence; they would be dismissed as hearsay.
Does Jovi work? Well yes, because placebos “work”. In placebo-controlled clinical studies, a third of subjects report that the placebo is effective. But it is unethical to promote placebos by falsely claiming that they are not placebos.
Conclusion: Just more of the same old nonsense
As Christopher Hitchens said, “That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence“. I have no hesitation in dismissing Jovi.

Bogus Electrodermal Testing Devices and the Failure of Regulators to Act
Harriet Hall on March 5, 2013
Link
Electrodermal testing is a bogus procedure where measurements of skin conductance with a biofeedback device are entered into a computer to diagnose nonexistent health problems and “energy imbalances” and to recommend treatments for them, often involving the sale of homeopathic remedies and other useless products. It falls under the general category of EAV (Electro Acupuncture of Voll). The history and variants of EAV are explained in an article on Quackwatch.
I’ve written about electrodermal testing before. I’ve explained how it amounts to fooling patients with a computerized Magic 8 Ball and I’ve discussed the legal and regulatory issues.
Now Stephen Barrett (founder of Quackwatch and Vice-President of the Institute for Science in Medicine) has written an article in FACT (Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies) entitled “Bogus electrodermal testing devices: where are the regulators?” He points out that existing regulations are sufficient to ban these devices, but that regulators have failed to take appropriate action.
Claims of FDA approval are false. The people who promote these devices claim that they are FDA approved. They are not. Dr. Barrett explains:
[The FDA] classifies ‘devices that use resistance measurements to diagnose and treat various diseases’ as Class III devices that require FDA approval prior to marketing. No EAV device has ever been FDA-approved. A few companies have obtained 510(k) clearance (not approval) by telling the FDA that their devices are substantially similar to devices previously cleared for biofeedback or skin-resistance measurement. Their FDA applications fail to reveal that the device would be bundled with software intended to diagnose and/or prescribe, which would make them ineligible for 510(k) clearance.
Electroacupuncture devices are not biofeedback devices. Biofeedback is a relaxation technique that uses an electronic device that continuously signals pulse rate, muscle tension or other body function by tone or visual signal. In biofeedback, the signal originates and is influenced by the patient. In EAV, the signal is influenced by how hard the operator presses the probe against the patient’s skin. (Pressure makes the electric current flow more easily between the device and the patient’s skin.) The 510(k) clearance enables manufacturers to market these devices for biofeedback of skin-resistance measurement but not for diagnosis or treatment.
Inadequate action by regulators. There have been a few actions against users for practicing medicine without a license, and medical boards have looked at their use by licensed practitioners but have rarely acted against them. Sporadic enforcement efforts have banned importation of these devices into the US and have prosecuted or warned individual marketers. But there has been no systematic effort to eliminate them. As a result:
these bogus devices are being used throughout the world by many chiropractors, acupuncturists, dentists, holistic physicians, veterinarians, self-styled nutritionists and various unlicensed individuals. The most common use is for prescribing homeopathic products, dietary supplements and herbal products. The devices are also used to determine allergies, detect nutrient deficiencies and locate alleged problems in teeth that contain amalgam fillings. Some operators claim to tell whether a disease, such as cancer or acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, is absent. Some devices are claimed to treat the patient with electromagnetic impulses transmitted into the body or are used to energise products.
These devices are widely promoted through the Internet, and it would be easy to identify offenders for prosecution, but regulatory agencies don’t seem to care.
What’s the Harm? False health information and false beliefs can lead to unwise health decisions. Over the last 10 years, Dr. Barrett has personally heard from over 200 victims who were unnecessarily frightened about bogus findings and who were bilked of hundreds or thousands of dollars.
Conclusion
Electrodermal testing is clearly bogus and illegal. Inaction on the part of regulators has allowed it to persist and to defraud patients. Dr. Barrett’s article is a call to action. Will regulators answer that call?

Electromagnetic healing devices for dogs: Studies show “Meh”
Does a pulsed electromagnetic field device work to help dogs recover from surgery? The answer is below.
Spoiler alert: The answer is “probably not”.
Greg Bishop on October 11, 2019
Link
The Assisi Loop is a pulsed electromagnetic field (PEMF) device that is placed on an animal and creates a weak (what’s your definition of “weak”, bro) electromagnetic field that is purported to do lots of nifty biochemical things to speed up wound healing and reduce pain. It sounds wonderful, especially since it doesn’t have any (known) side effects and it’s not a pharmaceutical (take that, Big Pharma!). The company who sells it, Assisi Animal Health, even has peer-reviewed research and claims that their technology is proven.
I’ve seen Assisi’s booths at veterinary conferences over the years, and my party-pooping skepticism (PPS) has always been curious about their claims. Usually you can suss out baloney at a product booth by bypassing the glittery prize wheel and asking for copies of the medical research. Often, there’s none, but the majority of sales reps will guarantee you that their product works and promise that there’s some really promising preliminary data. Sometimes, they’ll hand you a sketchy mouse model study. But in the case of Assissi, they actually have clinical trials of their product. Wow! Clinical trials! In peer-reviewed journals! Color me impressed! In fact, their website has quotes such as:
The results show undeniably the Loop’s ability not only to reduce pain in a severe population, but also to help target neural tissue to recover faster.
– Assisi’s Director of Clinical Development, Deirdre Chiaramonte, DVM, ACVIM, CCRT, CERP, CVA
Well why even look further than that? I mean, peer reviewed published research and words like “undeniable” should be enough to sell me, but that dang PPS is a tricky bug to squish. Curiouser and curiouser, I got my hands on these clinical studies and took a careful look. But spoiler alert, the Loop’s undeniable ability is probably being circle-shaped, not reducing pain and speeding tissue healing.
Background
PEMF devices like the Loop are supposed to trigger a biochemical cascade that ends up with good biological effects (reduced inflammation, decreased pain, better tissue healing). Because it’s noninvasive and has no known adverse effects, it’s an attractive alternative to drugs and has been investigated for a lot of animal and human health conditions. It’s far from a proven therapy though, as Steve Novella pointed out a few years ago in a post about a PEMF device for people. He highlighted that the “research” being touted by the devicemakers was preliminary and that there was a lack of clinical trials. It’s interesting to note that systematic reviews and meta-analyses of PEMF have been lukewarm (meh, meh2, and meh3).
Despite the tepidity of the science so far, there is some scientific plausibility with PEMF therapy. Sounds lukewarm enough to start the marketing campaign! But as we know, conflicting lab studies and wishy-washy systematic reviews and meta-analyses hardly prove anything. Good clinical trials are what we really need, and in the last year, two new prospective trials using PEMF in dogs were published.
Clinical trials using PEMF in dogs
These two trials both used the Assisi Loop PEMF device as an adjunctive treatment for dogs with intervertebral disc disease (IVDD, colloquially known as a “slipped disc”), which can cause paralysis of the hindlimbs. In both studies, dogs had surgery to treat IVDD and PEMF was the intervention in the treatment group. They were well-designed clinical trials: prospective, blinded, randomized, and placebo-controlled. Positive findings in both studies were attributed to PEMF treatment, however, much like the excitement over a Van Halen reunion album, this positivity could have been misplaced.
In the first study, dogs had surgery for severe IVDD and were treated with a PEMF (or placebo) device for six weeks. The researchers found less pain at the surgical site in treatments dogs, as well as better spatial limb perception (proprioception) at the end of the study. They also found that blood levels of the biomarker for neurological injury (GFAP) were lower. While this superficially sounds good, there are a number of problems.
Firstly, this was a tiny study, with only 15 dogs in total, so it’s statistically under-powered. But more problematic is that according to the paper’s own data, the control group might have had worse injuries. The authors themselves acknowledge this when talking about how GFAP (indicating spinal cord damage) was higher in the control group. Although they speculate that this may have been a therapeutic effect from the PEMF, there’s no evidence that PEMF would lower GFAP. It’s at least as likely that the higher levels in the control dogs are from more severe spinal cord injuries. In other words, worse injury in the control group, which is a plausible explanation of the data, could also have explained this and every other difference in the study that was attributed to PEMF.
But that being said, most of the measurements were not different between the groups. Gait scores (using two separate methods), time to independent walking, hopping score, pain perception, voluntary urination, and proprioception at 2 weeks were all equivalent. Pain in these dogs was assessed in three different ways, but only one showed any difference. And this assessment (mechanical sensory threshold or MST) was only measured after the PEMF treatment had been started, so there’s no baseline for pain scores before treatment.
The most statistically significant finding from this study was the improved proprioception at six weeks, but it’s hard to interpret. While proprioception is clinically useful and a good indicator of neurologic function, there were a lot of other measures of neurologic function that were not different, and proprioception was only measured at two weeks (no difference) and six weeks. Especially if the control group truly had worse injuries, this effect could easily disappear in another study. All in all, this is a small study that showed a few effects out of many investigated, and the control group might have had worse injuries, which makes interpretation difficult if not impossible.
In the second study, the dogs were treated with a PEMF device right after surgery and continued for one week. This was a larger study, with 53 dogs total, and the authors evaluated pain scores, neurologic function, time it took to start walking again, how frequently owners gave pain medications to their dogs, and incisional wound healing. They reported a significant improvement in wound healing at 6 weeks, and a significant reduction in how frequently dog owners gave pain medication.
Again, superficially appealing, who doesn’t want better wound healing and less drugs?! But alas, there are major problems here too that make these claims troublesome. First of all, it is true that the wound healing was evaluated as better at the six week mark, but skin incisions usually heal within 2 weeks, even for spinal surgery. And the differences in the scores, while statistically significant, are probably not large enough to make much of a clinical difference. There was also no difference in neurologic grades, return to function, and pain scores.
And as for the reduction in pain medication given to the PEMF dogs, the major flaw here is that the owners didn’t rate their dog’s pain differently between groups. Let’s spell this out again: the owners were told to assess their dog’s pain using an established scale, and if they felt they needed pain medication to go ahead and give it. So yes, a secondary measure (frequency of pain drugs) was different, but the actual measure (pain assessment) was not different. It’s possible that the owners were subconsciously detecting pain that the scale didn’t pick up, but it’s also possible that this is statistical noise. As evidence of PEMF reducing postoperative pain, it’s pretty flimsy.
Conclusion: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Both of these studies report statistically significant effects, but they’re not particularly convincing after wading into the details. It’d be great if this device worked really well, but these studies do not prove it. Assissi Animal Health is calling the results conclusive and the clinical effect proven but I think it’s far from that. Like so much in veterinary medicine, the hype and the marketing far outpace the research. For PEMF therapy, I am strongly reminded of laser therapy, which I think may be approaching the “Oh crap what have we been doing for the last 10ish years?” phase (Skeptvet articles on laser). A mountain of data doesn’t equal a proven clinical therapy. There might be an effect from PEMF, but that’s not the only or even the most likely explanation for the results of these studies, in my opinion. Is it crazy to wait until we get some more convincing evidence before embracing PMEF?
Also, thanks for reading this somewhat dry assessment of ambiguous clinical research, because it was almost 0% fun, here’s your reward for getting to the end.

   Electrodermal Testing Part I: Fooling Patients with a Computerized Magic Eight Ball
Harriet Hal
Link
Remember the Magic Eight Ball toy? You could ask it a question and shake it and a random answer would float up into a window: yes, no, maybe, definitely, etc. There is even a website where you can ask an Eight Ball questions online.
I have been meaning to write about bogus electrodiagnostic machines for a long time. These devices supposedly diagnose diseases and/or energy imbalances, indicate which remedies will correct the problem(s), and sometimes even treat the imbalances by transmitting a balancing frequency to the patient. I knew they were bogus, but I had never really realized the full extent of the deception until I viewed a set of training videos recently sent to me by a correspondent. I had never realized how similar electrodermal testing was to the Magic Eight Ball. I was further amazed at how they managed to combine every kind of alternative medicine into one incoherent package and to bamboozle patients with an appalling display of pseudoscientific babble.
This will be a two-part series. In the first, I will describe what the machines and their operators do. In the second (next week), I will address the legal and regulatory issues.
The History of EAV Devices
The first electrodermal diagnostic device was invented in 1958 by Reinhold Voll, a German medical doctor and acupuncturist. He combined acupuncture theory with measurement of galvanic skin responses in the Dermatron. He thought he had discovered that skin conductance was greater at traditional acupuncture points, and he thought he could show that these measurements correlated to diseases in the associated organs. He found that the measurements were affected by allergic reactions. He observed that readings changed when a patient had a bottle of medicine in his pocket. He concluded that some kind of electromagnetic energy was emitted from the medicine and that changes in skin conductance predicted the effects of ingesting the medicine.
One of his students simplified the diagnostic system and created the Vegatest. Other devices followed, including Accupath 1000, Asyra, Avatar, BICOM, Bio-Tron, Biomeridian, Computron, CSA 2001, Dermatron, DiagnoMètre, Eclosion, e-Lybra 8, ELAST, Interro, Interactive Query System (IQS), I-Tronic, Kindling, LISTEN System, MORA, Matrix Physique System, Meridian Energy Analysis Device (MEAD, MSAS, Oberon, Omega Acubase, Omega Vision, Orion System, Phazx, Prognos, Prophyle, Punctos III, Syncrometer, Vantage, Vegatest, Victor-Vitalpunkt Diagnose, Vitel 618, and ZYTO. This is not a complete list. New devices are constantly appearing.
The testing procedure was originally known as electroacupuncture according to Voll (EAV), but is now called by many other names including electrodermal screening (EDS), electrodermal testing (EDT), bioelectric functions diagnosis (BFD), bio resonance therapy (BRT), bio-energy regulatory technique (BER), biocybernetic medicine (BM), computerized electrodermal screening (CEDS), computerized electrodermal stress analysis (CEDSA), limbic stress analysis (LSA), meridian energy analysis (MEA), point testing, and many more.
How It Works
The machine is a galvanometer that measures the electrical conductance of the skin: the same principle used for lie detectors, Scientology’s E-meter, and biofeedback devices. The patient typically holds a metal bar in one hand while the operator applies a probe to acupuncture points on the patient’s other hand. The probe completes a circuit, and a tiny electrical current is sent through the circuit. It is very responsive, so a series of readings can be obtained rapidly. Both contacts are kept wet to improve conduction. There is a whining sound that rises or falls according to the level of conductance. There is also an audible beep indicating that a skin conductance measurement has been made and the machine is ready for the next test. The operator looks for a conductance reading of 50. (Higher readings indicate inflammation and lower ones indicate organ stagnation and degeneration.) He can control the readings (either consciously or unconsciously) by varying the amount of pressure and the angle of the probe, bunching or stretching the skin, and by adjusting the amount of moisture on the skin. He asks binary yes/no questions: a reading of 50 denotes a “yes” answer. Conveniently, the only meridians and acupuncture points used are on the hands and feet, so the patient doesn’t have to undress.
Systems Using a Hand Cradle
The Zyto website tells us:
A skilled EAV practitioner uses intuition….On one hand, credibility may be high … because of the impressive amount of information that can be obtained through it (I know one practitioner who used the device to find out precisely how well his kids had obeyed house rules while the parents were away). On the other hand, both the fact that accurate information depends on changes in pressure applied by the practitioner and the fact that practitioner knowledge and bias plays an influential role in the results makes many people more skeptical.
To get around this problem, Zyto and other companies eliminate the probe and use a cradle where the hand rests. These devices supposedly interrogate the body with hundreds of tests in a minute or two, producing a computer graphic showing imbalances. Then the operator selects remedies on the screen and the computer indicates how many imbalanced items that remedy would bring back into balance. Testing can even be done remotely through the Internet by connecting a hand cradle to the client’s computer. They acknowledge that the results are not reproducible; but they explain that away. The first reading is the most accurate. It creates observer interference: the act of measuring or observing changes the body’s energetic profile due to quantum indeterminacy. Stephen Barrett of Quackwatch has written about Zyto as “Another Test to Avoid.”
Since all these machines can basically do is generate a small electrical current, how can that single stimulus be differently interpreted by the body to provide all that complex information? How could the body know whether you are asking it about the liver or about the benefit of a homeopathic remedy? Never mind. They are gathering information from the subconscious mind which “knows” the intention of the machine or the operator. You have to believe this, because if the operator is skeptical, the quantum link between the operator and the patient’s mind will interfere with patient response.
An energy medicine website further explains
Remedy testing works with names, symbols and even thoughts of the item to be tested. In all these cases, there is neither substance nor energy involved and the remedy testing works either when the remedy representation is in close proximity to the patient or miles away, and whether he is electrically connected or not.
A Typical Examination
The training videos I viewed were produced by Standard Enzyme in Bremen, GA; the system used was the CSA2001. My correspondent had downloaded these videos from the Internet a long time ago. They are no longer available online, and the company’s website no longer advertises the CSA 2001; but it does continue to offer training courses and seminars on CEDSA (computerized electrodermal stress analysis). I’m guessing the website has been “sanitized” in an effort to avoid regulatory action.
Note: I apologize for the length and mind-numbing detail of the following description, but I think it is helpful to understand what actually goes on during one of these testing sessions.
In the videos the operator tests a volunteer, an apparently healthy 24 year old woman, to demonstrate how he would do an initial assessment on a new patient. The procedure can be broken down into 3 basic aspects: stress analysis, remedy selection, and other stuff.
Stress Analysis
In the first stage of the demonstration, he assesses various organs and systems by taking readings at different points on her hand and foot (see diagrams above). On her hand, he takes readings for things like the adrenal, circulation, jaw, hypothalamus, ileocecal valve, “organs,” heart, and “triple warmer.” A reading on one side of a finger joint shows allergies; a reading further down the finger shows food allergies. On her foot, he uses points for things like protein metabolism, fiber, uric acid, carbs, triglycerides, joints, skin, fat metabolism, and the ovary/uterus point. The first screen on the computer lists 35 of these points. The operator applies the probe to each. Of 35 readings, every single one tests abnormal on this patient.
Next he pulls up a screen with a list of the numbers from 1 to 10. He asks how many issues the patient has. It’s OK to use any convenient point for this; he picks circulation. He doesn’t have to verbalize what he is doing. He asks One? Two? Three? When he gets to 3, he gets a 50 reading, so she has 3 major issues. He addresses the first of these 3 issues:
    • Are her issues are emotional or endocrine? The machine tells him endocrine.
    • What major organ is the problem? With yes/no questions he narrows it down to pancreas or intestine. He gets a 50 reading for the pancreas.
    • How many vital force issues does she have? One? No. Two? No. Three? Yes: 3 vital force issues for her pancreas.
    • “I’m going to ask her right brain if it’s an organ, nerve, lymphatic or circulation problem.” Her right brain, or the machine, or something, answers organ and circulation.
    • How much energy will it take to balance out circulation meridian? An 800X dilution.
    • How much energy to balance the organ meridian? 1000X.
    • Are the islets out of balance? Yes.
He repeats this procedure for the other major issues.
Problem no. 2 is the liver. Its vital force is 1. The organ itself is OK but there is a circulation problem, so he takes measurements at the circulation meridian. He asks if there is a hormone issue and determines that her insulin level is 55% above normal. It’s not clear why insulin comes up under liver rather than pancreas.
Remedy Selection
Using a series of lists, yes/no questions determine what remedies will correct each of the problems he has identified.
    • He opens a computer screen showing a group of products, highlights each and uses the probe at the circulation point to determine what will balance the circulation meridian in her pancreas. It says Alpha orthophos. Then he goes back and looks for other products and finds one more: Circuplus.
    • Back to the organ meridian. He gets a 50 reading on antioxidants. Yes/no questions identify sangre de drago. Several other immune support remedies come up: 2 IV products and graviola. He comments that this shows she is weak in the immune system.
    • He goes back and asks her right brain: is there something more you want to tell us about your pancreas? Yes, some more on organ, but not circulation. Miasm and sycosis show up (miasms were Hahnemann’s homeopathic explanation for the cause of all diseases; sycosis was one of the 3 main miasms).
    • Is there a 4th thing? Yes. Digestive enzymes. She needs dydrin forte. He concludes that she has some hypoglycemic issues.
    • Is there something else? Yes, trace minerals IV. The IV Minerals checklist includes things like heparin, bicarb, procaine. He comments that you need to be careful to get it right, because putting remedies in veins can cause reactions. She needs germanium. How many cc? One – no, 1 ½, no, 2, 2 ½, 3, 3/12, 4, 4 ½ – all no. 5cc finally gets a yes answer. She needs potassium chloride 3.5 cc. For magnesium chloride she needs 31 cc. This is a lot: it shows she has quite a deficiency of magnesium. She needs molybdenum 4.5 cc. and manganese 8 cc. With manganese deficiency you get a lot of headaches because it is necessary for the hypothalamus and pituitary.
    • He asks the machine if that is all for the pancreas? Yes. Finally!
He repeats the process for her other issues. He determines that her adrenals are compromised, with a vital force of 3 and an imbalance on organ and circulation but not on nerve or lymphatics. 1000X balances it. What does this dilution mean? He can’t really explain, but he says it can be measured on consecutive visits and if it goes up it shows she’s getting better. Her adrenal hormone is 5% low. She needs Adrena plus and Norepinephrine. As he goes through more remedies, he comments that “She’s almost a story book case.” I had to laugh: it is certainly more compatible with a storybook than a textbook.
Then he double checks. When you think you’re done, go back to the food allergy point [why that one?] and ask if there’s anything else.
Now he goes back and retests the original 35 points to see which have normalized. Most have, but lymphatics and lung are still high. There’s a problem with the uric acid point: “that would give me some sort of an idea that there’s some acidosis involved.” [Umm… uric acid has nothing to do with acidosis.] There’s also a urinary bladder problem.
Why did these points not balance? Let’s check for drainage and herbs. The Amazon rainforest group matches. Arcazon matches – it’s good “for any viral, bacterial, whatever, might be in the system.” Back to see whether adding arcazon to the remedy list restores balance to the unbalanced items. It does.
Next phase: dosing. Now he has a list of all the remedies she needs – 11 of them (not counting the trace minerals). For each, he asks what dose she should take (for example, 55 drops). Then he asks how many times a day she should take it. Take with meals or between meals? Can we reduce it after the first bottle? 2 are for IVs: is it necessary to give them IV? Yes. How many IVs? Every 4-7 days. Can they be combined with mineral IVs? Yes. Can they be given as a push? Yes.
Other Stuff
He asks the machine when the patient should come back for followup. Typical is 4-6 weeks. For her, it says 11 weeks. Then he asks it how many bottles of each remedy he should dispense. He tells her if she runs out of a remedy before 11 weeks, that means she no longer needs it. If she has some left over, the next evaluation may or may not show that she still needs to take it.
How much water does she need to drink a day? Yes and no questions narrow it down to precisely 50 oz.
He uses a vital force checklist: What is her overall ideal? 86. What is her actual level? 14. He checks vital forces for individual organs: blood 1, immune 3, digestive 2, etc. What do these vital force numbers mean? He explains it is like carrying water in a leaky pail: vital force is leaking through her holes. She needs to plug the holes so she can retain energy.
Yes/no-ing all areas rated under 10 can give more information about factors common to various problem areas, usually a virus, bacteria or toxin. He tells an anecdote about another patient: “radiation” came up as a common factor for her. He was puzzled at first, but then found the explanation: she had been microwaving her coffee and other foods.
But wait! There’s more! He asks it what her biological age is and determines that it is 71. She looks really good for her age!
Her WTL (will to live) is 1 on a scale of 100. She’s given up internally and needs to do some psychological work.
He does a pH assessment. pH is one of the most important things. Overall her ideal pH is 6.7and her actual pH is 0.7. I don’t know what imaginary universe he’s in at this point, but in the real world that pH would be way incompatible with life. Even stomach acid doesn’t have a pH that low. Her urinary ideal pH 6.5, actual 4.6. “Because she’s got so much acidity in the tissues – everything is acid.” Acid people can’t wear rings because they turn jewelry black. Saliva pH ideal 6.8; actual 6.4. Her blood pH is OK at 7.3 [Science tells us homeostatic mechanisms keep blood pH between 7.35 and 7.45, but he don’t need no stinkin’ science.] You could use test strips to measure urine pH, but why bother when you’ve got a machine? The machine might disagree with the test strips, but if you are using one method consistently you will see a response.
Using a checklist for other treatments, he also determines that she needs:
    • Footbath – Yes, 3 a week
    • BEST/chiropractic treatments – yes
    • IV EDTA – no
    • Minerals IV
    • Alk ash food diet
Now he asks what makes her vital force so low. 5 issues: miasm, circulation, metabolic acidosis, pancreas, immune dysfunction, in order of priority.
He adds pH enhancer and alpha green to her list of remedies.
Now he asks how many issues there are with the pancreas. It says 3: miasm, acidosis, and emotions. She needs to correct emotional stress and strain. Yes/no answers narrow her problem down to: emotional issue, incident in past, 16 years ago (at age 8), involves another person, family member, male, father. This is the most important emotional issue and is affecting her blood sugar, acidosis, etc. He stops investigating at this point and leaves the rest to her psychologist: probably a good idea to stop before the machine can accuse her father of raping her.
Now he asks the machine if the analysis is complete. Yes. But we’re not finished yet.
Back to trace metals: we already knew she needs IV infusions of germanium, potassium, molybdenum, and manganese. He adds vitamin C and B vitamins to the list. Asks how much of each she needs. What is best fluid to mix them in? Water, dextrose, or normal saline? Normal saline. What size bag? 500 cc. Duration? 3-3 ½ hours. How many bags? 11. How often: 1 per week. Does she need a hydrogen peroxide IV? No. Does she need a separate glutathione IV? Yes. At the same time? No, but it could be given at another time later in the same day. Then he asks if she will tolerate this? Yes, you don’t need to worry about side effects.
As silly as this demonstration is, there is even sillier stuff out there. On one website, an operator places a laser pointer on the machine and supposedly imprints it with the needed “balancing” frequencies, then runs the light from the laser across the patient’s ear over all the auricular acupuncture points. You have to do this not once but three times. Three’s the charm. You couldn’t make this stuff up!
Harmful Effects
These tests identify numerous nonexistent problems and offer useless remedies. Some of them are potentially dangerous, like IV chelation and IV infusions of trace minerals and vitamins. Some of them are just laughable, like detoxifying foot baths.
Patients are lured away from science-based medical care. They are told that their prescription medications are interfering with the actions of these alternative remedies that could otherwise restore their energetic balance.
And what about the emotional impact of being told at age 24 that you have a will to live of only 1 (out of 100) and a biological age of 71? And being told that you need a complicated regimen of oral and IV remedies to improve your health. Along with footbaths, psychotherapy, chiropractic, etc. At a cost of several thousand dollars.
On a blog, one patient describes her feelings:
every time I walked out of that office I felt horribly flawed, horribly sick, and doomed, somehow. Like every move I made in my life was bad for me. Let’s face it, it’s hard to be healthy in the modern world. But what a weight I felt on my shoulders… I felt like I was 75 years old after those visits and it took me a few days to recover.
Where’s the Evidence?
There isn’t a shred of prior probability, but even the craziest-sounding methods “might” work. If the evidence showed that it worked, we would have to accept it and then try to figure out how it worked. I think this falls under Carl Sagan’s definition of extraordinary claims that require extraordinary evidence. In this case, there isn’t even any ordinary evidence, only the usual testimonials.
I could find only one study suggesting that electrodermal testing might work for anything: it found that electrodermal testing could discriminate between allergens and non-allergens. But a later study by the same group found it useless for diagnosing allergies And other double blind studies have shown that it could not detect respiratory allergies.
A review of diagnostic methods for allergies classified electrodermal testing among alternative methods that have “no proven benefit and may endanger patients via misdiagnosis.”
Conclusion
Electrodermal testing makes no sense and is not supported by any credible evidence. It is not based on science or grounded in reality; it is more akin to divination with a Magic 8 Ball. It merits a favorite phrase of Orac’s: a fetid load of dingo’s kidneys.

   Electrodermal Testing Part II: Legal and Regulatory Aspects
Harriet Hall
Link
Last week I described electrodermal testing. I’m sure many readers thought, “There oughta be a law against that.” Well, there are laws. Unfortunately, having laws and enforcing them are two different things.
Some of these devices are not approved at all. Most have received 501(k) approval from the FDA as biofeedback devices so similar to previous devices that they do not require new approval — for biofeedback. It is illegal to use the devices for anything other than biofeedback. The FDA has prohibited their sale or importation for unapproved purposes like electrodermal testing; it has sent warnings to companies, raided clinics, and confiscated machines. States have prosecuted users for practicing medicine without a license. Medical boards have chastised licensed providers. The Quackwatch website lists these regulatory actions but points out that there has been no systematic effort to drive these devices from the marketplace.
Excuses, Excuses
One electrodermal testing website admits that what it is doing is illegal and tries to fight back with this specious disclaimer:
It is important to understand that the laws in the USA forbid me from being able to treat, diagnose, cure or prevent disease. The AMA has a patent on those words and only a licensed medical doctor can do that. And although it is legal for a licensed medical doctor to violate the Hippocratic oath and prescribe toxic drugs that cause harm and sometimes even kill patients, it is illegal for me to claim you can be cured using natural, nontoxic remedies, even though thousands of people can testify how they have been healed using natural remedies.
These machines are being used to practice medicine without a license, but they think they can get around the law by offering a disclaimer and by espousing the fiction that they are not diagnosing or treating diseases but only detecting energy imbalances and advising patients about how to restore balance.
Here are some typical protestations:
    • I can only find imbalances that may be causing problems. It would be up to a medical doctor to determine if what I am finding IS the cause.
    • I wouldn’t call EAV biofeedback “treatment.” You don’t treat anything with EAV. Creating a vial of treated water for a client to take may help balance their energy. Balancing energy is not medical treatment. It is perfectly legal to own one for home usage.
    • And the reason all these people are spending money on this equipment is what??? Would they continue to invest in something that is “bogus”?
    • EAV is not anything like the medical tests that we are used to. It works by quantum physics not biology.
    • Yes, there are a bunch of enforcement actions. I assume that what is listed is about the entire list. Do you also want to list the claims made against regular M.D.s?
    • Something that shows up energetically does not necessarily mean that it is a physical condition!
    • We are only just now getting the scientific ability to test these [homeopathic] remedies by quantum physics.
In the training videos I mentioned in my previous article, the demonstrator answers questions from the audience that reveal more about the way they operate:
Q: I’m not a doctor. I have to send patients to an MD for IV infusions. What do you say when the doctor questions how you determined the patient needs it?
A: Tell him you determined it by electrodermal testing, similar to muscle testing [applied kinesiology] and ask him if what he does is any better. At least we have some monitoring device.
Q: One remedy you recommended is acid, but she has an acid problem.
A: That seems contradictory but we need it for her circulation, and the body can sort out what it needs.
Q: Is the circulation due to blockage in her superior vena cava?
A: No.
Q: Should she stop other medications or products?
A: Bring in the products and put them on the test tray. Medicine is a legal issue, so we can only show her what it does to her pancreas, we can’t tell her to stop using it. You might be liable if you told them to go off their meds.
Q: Will other medications interfere with our treatment?
A: Our treatment will not be as effective if they stay on their meds. Cancer treatments like chemo and radiation will usually interfere with our efforts. If the patient needs to stay on medication, we can give more products to balance out the effect of prescription meds on liver and to reduce med side effects.
Q: [Something about] cancer showed up on the readings. Does that mean she has cancer?
A: I don’t think she has cancer, but if she doesn’t correct the problems in her body, I can guarantee you down the road she will have problems like that. Cancer loves miasms, acidosis, poor circulation, emotional issues, and immune dysfunction. She’s got ‘em all. It’s just a matter of time. You can’t tell a person they have cancer — just that that matches the picture. Biopsy is needed for medical diagnosis. You can treat it before it gets to the biopsiable stage.
Q: What if the patient says “Every time I come in you give me something different.”
A: Well duh, do you want to be on the same thing all your life if it’s not working? If it’s fixed, why keep taking it? The body prioritizes all the time, so what it needs today will not be what it needs tomorrow.
Regulatory Actions
The FDA, state attorney generals, professional licensing boards, and foreign regulatory agencies have all taken action to stop electrodermal testers. Details of many of these cases can be found on Quackwatch.
An examination of 3 cases from my own state, Washington, highlights some of the problems with regulation.
The Ames Case
A licensed physician was using a LISTEN device to diagnose allergies. The findings of fact are interesting:
    • After he used the LISTEN machine, he wrapped the probe in tissue paper and had the patient hold the probe with tissue paper wrapped around it. When the patient asked why, he answered that he has done this so long, that he could do what the machine could do, and that he did not need the machine anymore.
    • He used the machine not only to diagnose, but to treat allergies.
    • He also used applied kinesiology, a phoney muscle testing procedure.
    • He used dubious hair and urine tests to determine that the patient had a mineral imbalance, and told him he needed treatment for metal poisoning.
    • He used what sounds like a chiropractic “activator” device on acupressure points.
    • He prescribed the Metabolic Type Diet, a diet with no scientific justification.
The Washington State Department of Health Medical Quality Assurance Commission suspended his license for 5 years. Only they didn’t, because the suspension was stayed as long as he (a) stops using the device, (b) undergoes quarterly practice reviews, and (c) pays a $5,000 fine. The MQAC’s decision was appealed but the state Supreme Court upheld the decision, saying that Ames had “led patients to believe that LISTEN could diagnose and treat allergies, when in fact it could do neither.” Note that the board and the courts only considered his use of the device and did not even address any of his other questionable practices or his basic competence to practice medicine.
The Trasker Case
Joyce Trasker was convicted of practicing medicine and veterinary medicine without a license. She used the Orion and the Asyra devices to determine a patient’s “energy signature” and to prescribe homeopathic remedies. She offered testing on saliva and blood samples sent to her by mail. Eventually she began taking these samples and the machine onto an Indian reservation to do the testing, claiming that the State had no jurisdiction there. She claimed she was not practicing medicine. She even claimed that the right to free speech protected what she was doing. Her case went all the way to the state Supreme Court. She was ordered to cease and desist and to pay a fine of $10,000.
No problem: she simply moved a short distance across the state line to Idaho where she is still offering the same electrodermal testing for $295 per test. You can mail in saliva samples, even from Washington State: her website says “Washington may not prohibit its residents from patronizing an Oregon or Idaho business.” She is also involved in a long term campaign for the freedom to choose safe unregulated health care.
A Dropped Complaint
A few years ago I found a website for a local clinic offering electrodermal testing. After I filed a complaint with the medical board, all references to electrodermal testing mysteriously vanished from the website. The doctor and his lawyers threatened the medical board with legal action if they tried to act on the complaint. The complaint was dropped.
Confusing Terminology
The variety of devices and the many variants of terminology make it difficult to identify the magnitude of the problem. These devices are illegal and cannot be sold or imported, but they are still available. On E-bay I found 6 Biomeridian systems for sale. They seem to be going for around $5000 compared to an original price of $12,000 to $17,000.
If these systems do use some kind of frequency analyzer to capture EMF and then use a frequency generator to re-introduce that same signal back into the human body for “testing,” now they have produced what the FDA considers a radiation emitting device and not a galvanic skin response meter. The QXCI, EPFX, or SCIO falls into that category. The FDA banned importation of this device after an embarrassing exposé by investigative reporters in The Seattle Times featuring patients who died because they relied on the device to treat cancer.
What Can We Do?
In his exposé, Quackwatch’s Stephen Barrett says:
The devices described in this article are used to diagnose nonexistent health problems, select inappropriate treatment, and defraud insurance companies. The practitioners who use them are either delusional, dishonest, or both. These devices should be confiscated and the practitioners who use them should be prosecuted. If you encounter any such device, please report it to the state attorney general, any relevant licensing board, the FDA, the FTC, the FBI, the Better Business Bureau, and any insurance company to which the practitioner submits claims that involve use of the device.
I echo his plea. There is an online directory of practitioners that could be helpful in identifying some of the offenders, but there are undoubtedly many more who are avoiding publicity for fear of legal consequences. We have the tools to stop most of these offenders, but first we need to identify the offenders and then we need to actually use the tools.

“Electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and “wifi allergies”: Bogus diagnoses with tragic real world consequences
“Electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and “wifi allergies” are two names given to a nonexistent medical condition in low energy electromagnetic fields like wifi are blamed for a variety of health conditions. This is a story in which the parents’ insistence that their teenage daughter, who had posted threats to commit suicide on social media, had this condition appears to have interfered with seeking mental health services in a timely fashion. The results were tragic.
David Gorski on December 7, 2015
Link


I debated about writing about this topic, given that I just wrote about it last week on my not-so-super-secret other blog. However, as I thought about it during the weekend, I realized that the tragic story that so saddened and disturbed me to prod me to discuss so-called “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” or “electro-hypersensitivity” (EHS) was so horrific that a more detailed, SBM-level discussion was indicated, particularly in light of a similar case electromagnetic hypersensitivity that didn’t end so tragically discussed by Harriet Hall in September. I’m referring, of course, to the case of Jenny Fry, a British teen who hanged herself in June and whose mother has been claiming that her “allergy to wifi” was what drove her to suicide. So, while there will be some overlap with my previous discussion, I will try to step back and take a broader view of the evidence regarding the fake diagnosis of EHS, interspersed with examples (hopefully) illustrating my point. Think of this as the post I wished I had written the first time around but, due to time constraints, couldn’t.
Bogus science and lawsuits over EHS
By way of background, it’s worth briefly revisiting the case that Harriet discussed. Indeed, if you Google “lawsuit” and “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and “wifi” the first two pages of results consist mostly of articles discussing it. That’s probably because this is just the latest lawsuit that made the news. It happened in Massachusetts, where the parents of a 12-year-old boy (designated “G” in court records) who was attending Fay School in Massachusetts alleged that the school violated his rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act by failing to make accommodations to protect G from electromagnetic radiation from the school’s wifi routers. From the complaint’s summary statement:
Defendants Fay and its head of school, defendant Gustavson, have violated and continue to violate the rights of plaintiff G, a student at Fay, along with the rights of his parents, plaintiffs Mother and Father. Fay has done so by (i) disregarding G’s rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act (the “ADA”), (ii) breaching its contractual obligations to G, Mother and Father conferred by Fay’s Student Handbook, and (iii) failing to use ordinary care for G’s safety while G is at Fay during the school day. Fay has been informed repeatedly by Mother, Father and a qualified physician that G has a condition known as Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity Syndrome (“EHS”). This syndrome, causing physical harm and the risk of very substantial physical harm, is triggered by exposure to high doses of radiofrequency/microwave radiation (hereinafter sometimes referred to as “emissions”) such as the radiation emitted from the highdensity, industrial-capacity Wi-Fi system that has been installed in the classrooms at Fay. Fay’s Wi-Fi system is not the lower-intensity, low-emission variety used in most homes and in some other locations. Rather, the Wi-Fi system Fay chose to install produces extremely high levels of such emissions. Exposure to Wi-Fi emissions at the levels emitted by the type of Wi-Fi to which the children are exposed in Fay classrooms causes, in those persons affected, most notably children, the symptoms of EHS, which include severe headaches, fatigue, stress, sleep disturbances, skin symptoms such as prickling, burning sensations and rashes, muscle aches, nausea, nose bleeds, dizziness and heart palpitations. These reactions to the Wi-Fi emissions are a disability within the meaning of the ADA.
Basically, the problems began in 2013, when the school installed a new wifi system. Specifically, the school installed an Aerohive Wi-Fi network that increased the power and upped the frequency from 2.5 GHz to 5 GHz. Sometime after the new wifi system was installed G began suffering from “headaches, nose bleeds, dizziness, chest pains and nausea.” Of note, nowhere in the lawsuit does it state how long a time period it was. In any case, G’s parents demanded that the school run Ethernet cables to the classrooms where G attended class, decrease the overall power of the wifi transmissions in the school, and cough up $250,000 in settlement funds. Of note in this story is this line from the lawsuit:
Mother concluded, after much research and study, that Fay’s Wi-Fi was the probable cause of G’s symptoms because G had a sensitivity to such emissions, called EHS. EHS, as will be shown next below, is a syndrome that affects numerous individuals when exposed to certain electromagnetic fields, including high density Wi-Fi emissions such as in the system used by Fay.
It’s a theme that we will see time and time again. Another theme that we will see time and time again is that the parents, convinced that wifi is causing their child to be sick, seek out quacks who validate that view. In this case, the doctor was Jeane Hubbuch, who is board certified in family practice, but, as Harriet described, uses functional medicine, biologic medicine, chelation, orthomolecular medicine, intestinal balancing, saunas, IV nutrients, complex homeopathy, supplements and enzymes, connection of illness to dental amalgams and root canals, high-dose vitamin C, alkaline IVs and an alkaline diet, and immune support for cancer patients with high-dose vitamin C, iscadore/mistletoe, curcumin, bitter melon, and pectasol C. She uses Heart Rate Variability testing and live cell analysis, promises to remove toxins and blockages, and claims that she deals with the underlying causes of illness instead of symptoms. These are all pretty much pure quackery, and many of these modalities have been discussed right here on SBM while those that haven’t have usually been discussed on Quackwatch. In any case, eventually, the school and parents reached an out-of-court settlement, but I have been unable to find the terms.
Another case that I recall, mainly because it happened across the Detroit River in nearby Ontario (OK, it was over 250 miles away in Barrie, Ontario, but local Windsor papers reported on it at the time, which is why it caught my attention), involved a similar story. In 2010, parents blamed wifi signals in school for a panoply of vague health complaints. The main difference between this and the Massachusetts case was that the Barrie case involved a fairly large group of parents convinced that their children were being sickened by the wifi in 14 local schools in Simcoe County. In this case, the pseudoscientist pushing the idea was named Susan Clarke, whom the parents brought to Simcoe County to promote the idea that wifi causes these health problems.
Then, a couple of years later, an Ontario teachers’ union, the Ontario English Catholic Teachers Association (OECTA), demanded an end to wifi setups in the province’s 1,400 Catholic schools and wrote a position paper entitled “A position regarding the use of Non-Ionizing Electromagnetic Radiation, including WiFi, in the workplace.” It’s still up on the OECTA website today and was a lovely example of fear mongering winning out over science and Orwellian language touting fears of what dangers “might” exist without any real evidence that these dangers actually do exist. Basically, the OECTA demanded that all sorts of safety precautions be taken based on a nonexistent risk. For example, they recommended the continued use of wired Ethernet connections and that all new buildings be wired for Ethernet, not wifi. When wifi absolutely positively can’t be avoided, the OECTA recommended the use of a PowerLine HD Ethernet Adapter (or similar technology) to pass a network signal through existing electrical lines, rather than a wireless router and advised that no permanent wireless routers be installed.
You get the idea.
It’s even gotten to the point where a man named Arthur Firstenberg sued his next door neighbor Raphaela Monribot for $1.43 million in damages, for allegedly harming his health by using her iPhone and a Wi-Fi connection. In his lawsuit, Firstenberg attributed his vague symptoms of dizziness, nausea, amnesia, insomnia, tremors, heart arrhythmia, acute and chronic pain to Monribot’s use of wifi, cellphone, computers and other ordinary electronic equipment. Ms. Monribot “refused his requests to replace her dimmer switches with regular switches, use a land-line instead of a cell phone, to turn off her Wi-Fi, and to unplug her computer at night.” She also refused Mr. Firstenberg’s offer of $10,000 to comply with his requests. As a result Firstenberg claimed that “because Ms. Monribot would not comply with these requests, he was unable to use his house for more than a few minutes at a time without suffering EMS symptoms that were caused by radiation from Ms. Monribot’s electronic devices ‘entering’ and ‘leak[ing]’ into his house.” That’s when Firstenberg sued, and Monribot countersued.
This case has been going on for five years. Fortunately, Monribot had a pair of lawyers willing to represent her pro bono who wrote off her legal expenses, which have hit $200,000. Unfortunately, Monribot herself spent $85,000 of her own money in legal fees and to depose expert witnesses. Ultimately, earlier this year the New Mexico Court of Appeals upheld a lower court’s summary judgment against Firstenberg, but this case could well still go on longer, as Firstenberg appeared poised to appeal to the New Mexico Supreme Court.
Meanwhile, periodically in the press there are credulous reports of people who claim to be “sensitive” or “allergic” to electromagnetic radiation of the frequency and power emitted by cell phones and wifi routers, while various organizations flog the concept.
Could an “allergy to wifi” drive a teen to suicide?
Last week, several readers either Tweeted at me or sent me links to what can only be described as an incredibly tragic story of how belief in EHS can impact a real person. It’s a story that started popping up in the UK press Thanksgiving week and continued into last week, about the inquest investigating the death of a 15 year old girl named Jenny Fry from the rural village Chadlington in Oxfordshire, whose body was found hanging from a tree in June.

Any time a teen kills herself—or apparently kills herself, as the coroner testified and her mother believed that she might not have intended to kill herself—it is an enormous tragedy. Few know the pain that Jenny’s parents must have gone through—must still be going through. What makes this particular death unusual, be it suicide or the accidental death of a girl going too far in trying to send out a cry for help, is the reason being reported in the press for her despair. That reason? Take a look at some stories published over the last week or so about her death:
    • “Schoolgirl, 15, found hanged after ‘developing an allergic reaction to the WiFi at her school’“
    • “Schoolgirl found hanging from tree after suffering from ‘rare allergic reaction to WiFi’“
    • “Parents of schoolgirl Jenny Fry are campaigning to have WiFi restricted in schools following her death“
    • “Schoolgirl Jenny Fry found hanged after ‘suffering from allergy to WiFi’“
    • “Jenny Fry: 15-year-old girl found hanging from tree in an apparent suicide after suffering from a rare case of allergic reaction to wifi“
There is also a Facebook page RIP Jenny Fry that has been posting updates on the story, and a video:
You get the idea.
All of these news stories more or less take at face value the claims of Jenny’s parents, Debra Fry and Charles Newman, that their daughter suffered from electrohypersensitivity (EHS) that manifested itself with various health problems that began three years before the girl’s tragic end. What brought her story to the fore again was an inquest held last week:
A schoolgirl was found dead in woodland after suffering an allergic reaction to her school’s WiFi that made her life a misery, an inquest heard.
The parents of 15-year-old Jenny Fry claim that she suffered from electro-hypersensitivity (EHS), which caused her to suffer tiredness, headaches and bladder problems.
Her mother Debra told the hearing that Jenny was badly affected by the wireless internet connections at Chipping Norton School in Oxfordshire, where she was a pupil.
After becoming increasingly distressed by her symptoms – which were never investigated by a doctor – the schoolgirl was found hanged in Brooke Woods, near her home in Chadlington, in June 11 this year.
Earlier in the day she had texted a friend telling her she was not going to school that day, the inquest heard.
Mrs Fry and her husband Charles Newman told Oxfordshire Coroners’ Court two weeks ago that they believed their daughter became ill because of WiFi, and had removed the internet connection from their own home.
They told today how she would often hide herself in empty classrooms and would only sit in certain seats in lessons so that she would be as far away from the router as possible, they said.
Speaking after the inquest, Mrs Fry said: WiFi and children do not mix. I believe that WiFi killed my daughter.’
Found with the girl was a note:
Jenny was found with a note in her diary and there was another saved on her laptop.
It read: “I have no hope for humanity; we are destroying this beautiful earth as we speak. I am insignificant, an insignificant number on someone’s screen and so is my life, a tiny blip in the whole existence of the universe. And I find it hard to be hopeful when I can hardly enjoy anything any more.”
The inquest also heard Jenny previously spoke of suicidal thoughts in November 2014 following the death of close friend Tom Boomer in March last year.
Mental health professionals will no doubt immediately recognize that this note sounds like something written by a profoundly depressed girl, particularly in light of her having exhibited suicidal ideation a year before her hanging, which implies that her depression had been going on for a while. Moreover, teen depression very frequently goes unrecognized by family and even physicians. Given this information, it’s hard not to think that Jenny Fry might very well have benefitted from psychiatric care, which could potentially have prevented this horrible end. After all, teens suffering from depression frequently complain of all manner of physical complaints very similar to what Jenny complained of, particularly severe headaches, fatigue, and difficulty concentrating. It’s also strange that there’s no real medical record to determine whether Jenny suffered from depression versus something else, as her symptoms appear never to have been evaluated by a physician.
On the other hand, that horrible sentence seen earlier in this post does pop up again in this story in The Mirror:
Mrs Fry told Oxfordshire Coroners’ Court Jenny had started showing signs of EHS in November 2012.
She said: “Jenny was getting ill and so was I. I did some research and found how dangerous WiFi could be so I had it taken out of the house.
“Both Jenny and I were fine at home but Jenny continued to be ill at school in certain areas.”
Interestingly, this Daily Mail report of the inquest from less than a week before all the reports blaming Jenny Fry’s death on EHS makes it sound fairly conclusive that the death was a suicide and mentions very little about wifi:
A 15-year-old schoolgirl hanged herself after failing to cope with the suicide of a classmate who leapt off a multi-storey car park, an inquest heard today.
Jennifer Fry was still deeply upset over classmate Tom Boomer’s suicide a year earlier when she ended her own life near her home village of Chadlington in Oxfordshire.
She was found dead wearing her school uniform by her mother Debbie in woodland – six months after she had written her first suicide note, Oxford Coroner’s Court was told.
And:
Today’s inquest heard that officers found Jenny had also sent two suicidal texts to friends, telling them of her plans to harm herself in the woods.
And it was told police converged on her family home in November 2014 because she made suicidal threats over social media websites.
This is the only mention of wifi, at the very end of the news story:
Both her parents also argued that Jenny’s suicidal ideation was the result of radiation poisoning because of Wi-Fi in the home and at school.
Mrs Fry said her daughter had ‘classic’ symptoms of being sensitive to electromagnetic fields but was unable to produce any medical evidence that her daughter had suffered.
Notice how very much different the story above is from the sensationalistic stories published a few days later in which the parents’ claim that their daughter suffered from EHS and that drove her to suicide were front and center. What we clearly have here is a case of depression that, for whatever reason, wasn’t fully recognized or treated.
Reading the stories about Jenny Fry, I learned that in 2012 she started complaining of a variety of symptoms, including cripplingly severe headaches and fatigue, resulting in difficulty concentrating, as well as unspecified “bladder problems.” So how did Jenny’s parents come to the conclusion that it was wifi that was causing her symptoms? There’s no way of knowing for sure, but I can make a fairly educated guess. Humans, as we know, are pattern-seeking animals. Whenever a person starts suffering from unexplained symptoms, it is natural to try to figure out what’s causing those symptoms. Because our “pattern detectors” in our brains tend to be oversensitive and because we also suffer from confirmation bias, the phenomenon of remembering things that conform to what we’ve come to believe and to forget things that do not, it’s not hard to speculate that at some point Jenny or her parents heard about EHS and started looking for correlations with wifi exposure, perhaps consciously, perhaps even unconsciously. Then confirmation bias did the rest, with Jenny and her parents over time coming to see a correlation between the severity of Jenny’s symptoms and exposure to wifi.
One notes that Jenny’s parents state that they removed the wifi from their home, but I couldn’t find any clear report of whether Jenny’s symptoms at home improved after that other than this one where her mother claimed that “Jenny and I were fine at home.” Of course, confirmation bias is a strong thing. Moreover, removing wifi from the home doesn’t necessarily eliminate wifi signals. Whenever I need to log onto the wifi network, my computer detects wifi signals from several of the surrounding houses, some of them nearly as strong as my own wifi network signal. That’s not even counting all the other electromagnetic signals coming from TV, radio, computer equipment, appliances, and the electrical wiring of the whole house. Even believers in EHS acknowledge that; look at Arthur Firstenberg’s lawsuit if you don’t believe me.
There’s another issue, and that has to do with the school. Note how the reports indicate that Jenny would become ill at school. If Jenny’s symptoms were related to stress at school, which they very well could have been, that would make sense. It would also make sense that her symptoms would be better at home. Wifi could just be the thing that the parents and this poor girl and her parents latched on to as the explanation for her illness at school. It’s also hard not to point out the extreme similarity of Jenny’s history to the histories related by the parents in Barrie, as described above. Like Jenny’s parents, they all reported virtually the same thing: That their children’s symptoms went away (or at least got a lot better) in the evenings and on weekends, when they were at home, as well as over the summer, when they were out of school. If that bit of history didn’t suggest stress, bullying at school, and/or depression, it should have. Even worse, after Jenny posted suicidal notes on social media in November 2014, it was explicitly recommended to Jenny’s parents that she be seen by a GP or referred to the children and young adult mental health service. Indeed, during the inquest, Coroner Darren Salter noted that he was “very surprised” that the parents didn’t heed this advice and that the girl’s GP didn’t note any signs of depression.
One can’t help but wonder if, were it not for the parents’ obsession with wifi as the cause of their daughter’s health complaints, her depression might have been recognized and treated earlier, avoiding the tragic end that ultimately occurred.
EHS and “wifi allergy”: Bogus diagnoses
We exist in a world that is bathed in electromagnetic radiation. Sources include radio signals, wifi, cell phones, computers, electrical appliances, and, yes, even the wiring within our homes. As I’ve heard some say, if EHS were a real thing, then a whole lot of us living in developed countries would be very sick all the time, because such signals are ubiquitous. You can’t escape them, at least not easily. I suppose you could move out into the middle of nowhere somewhere and eschew electricity. In fact, a group of Americans has done just that, moving to a small West Virginia town, Green Bank, located in the 13,000 square mile National Radio Quiet Zone, where mobile phones, radio and TV transmitters and Wi-Fi are forbidden to prevent interference with one of the world’s largest radio telescopes. Of course, I don’t see these people eschewing electricity or the use of computers or electrical appliances; so they’re still being exposed to low energy electromagnetic radiation, if a photo of the town is any indication.

In any case, from a strict plausibility standpoint, the hypothesis that low level electromagnetic radiation at energies that can’t even break chemical bonds, can cause major health effects is of very low plausibility indeed. I realize that I’ve been criticized, for example, for being a bit too open to the idea that radio waves can have significant biological effects, but even at my most “open-minded” my usual assessment is that the plausibility of such effects is not homeopathy-level implausible. That’s not exactly a ringing endorsement, given the extreme implausibility of homeopathy. In other words, the most that I will concede is that I don’t think it’s impossible that this sort of electromagnetic waves can have significant biological effects, but on a strictly physical basis (not to mention based on basic physics and biology) it is incredibly implausible that wifi and cell phone radiation cause cancer or any other major health effects. As Steve Novella pointed out, skeptics argue wither the plausibility of EHS is zero or not, but no skeptic argues that it isn’t very, very low indeed.
Also, claims otherwise and disappointingly credulous articles notwithstanding, EHS is not a real syndrome. It’s not as though there hasn’t been considerable research on the issue, either. (Note that in the medical literature, EHS is usually referred to as “idiopathic environmental illness with attribution to electromagnetic fields,” abbreviated IEI-EMF.) There have been enough studies that meta-analyses can be done, and the findings are consistent.
For example, a systematic literature review from 2011 points out:
In most of the randomized trials, no exposure-response association was observed. The sporadically reported associations did not show a consistent pattern regarding the type of symptoms or the direction of the effects (increase/decrease). Similarly, most of the recent observational studies did not show associations between RF-EMF exposure and non-specific symptoms. However, the exposure gradients were small and possible exposure misclassification is a limitation of these studies. Longitudinal studies as well as studies in children and adolescents are scarce. In summary, recent research did not indicate health-related quality of life to be affected by RF-EMF exposure in our everyday environment. Furthermore, none of the studies showed that individuals with self-reported electromagnetic hypersensitivity (EHS) were more susceptible to RF-EMF than the rest of the population
Another systematic review the same year agreed, concluding:
At present, there is no reliable evidence to suggest that people with IEI-EMF experience unusual physiological reactions as a result of exposure to EMF. This supports suggestions that EMF is not the main cause of their ill health.
A more recent study in 2012 tested whether patients diagnosed with EHS could detect radio frequency electromagnetic fields from cell phones better than those without the diagnosis using a double blind design controlled with sham exposures. Consistent with the literature, they could not. Indeed, this is a very consistent finding. In double-blind studies “electro-sensitive” patients are unable to detect whether the offending radiation source has been turned on or not. Indeed, a recent 2015 aggregation of two large studies reported:
Results showed that IEI-EMF participants reported lower levels of well-being during real compared to sham exposure during open provocation, but not during double-blind trials. Additionally, participants reported lower levels of well-being during high compared to low load trials and this did not interact with radiofrequency-EMF exposure. These findings are consistent with a growing body of literature indicating there is no causal relationship between short-term exposure to EMFs and subjective well-being in members of the public whether or not they report perceived sensitivity to EMFs.
In other words, if the EHS suffer knows he’s being exposed to RF-EMF, he’ll experience symptoms.
Even the World Health Organization, which has been rather loose about assigning health risks to environmental factors, particularly for cancer, concluded:
In the area of biological effects and medical applications of non-ionizing radiation approximately 25,000 articles have been published over the past 30 years. Despite the feeling of some people that more research needs to be done, scientific knowledge in this area is now more extensive than for most chemicals. Based on a recent in-depth review of the scientific literature, the WHO concluded that current evidence does not confirm the existence of any health consequences from exposure to low level electromagnetic fields. However, some gaps in knowledge about biological effects exist and need further research.
That “needs more research” bit is the same sort of hedge that Cochrane Reviews always include, even for highly improbable treatments. The bottom line is that, despite lots of research, no one has ever been able to convincingly show that (1) low energy electromagnetic radiation (as from wifi routers or cell phones) has any deleterious effects on health or (2) people claiming to be “electrosensitive” or “allergic to wifi” are able to tell when they are being exposed to wifi or cell phone signals that they believe to be the cause of their symptoms. Although strictly anecdotal, one incident in particular illustrates these principles. In 2009, residents of Craigavon, South Africa were complaining of typical EHS symptoms after a new iBurst cell tower went live. At a meeting in November with the company, a number of residents continued to complain that they were suffering skin rashes, headaches, and the like. It turns out, however, that the company had shut the tower off six weeks before the meeting, meaning that the complaints couldn’t have been due to the radiation from the tower.
The overwhelming evidence supports the conclusion that electromagnetic radiation of the sort produced by wifi routers does not cause health issues and that EHS is a psychosomatic disorder.
A final thought: People are suffering, but EHS is not the cause
Even though EHS is clearly a psychosomatic condition, let me be clear about one thing. Just like the case with Morgellons disease (a.k.a. delusional parasitosis) and “multiple chemical sensitivity,” I must point out that just because EHS is psychosomatic does not mean that those suffering from EHS are not actually suffering. They are. I have little doubt that all the children in Barrie whose parents were lobbying to remove wifi from their schools suffered from real symptoms. I have even less doubt (as in none) that Jenny Fry’s headaches, fatigue, and inability to concentrate were very real and very distressing to both her and her parents. I have no doubt that she was suffering. What I question, based on existing evidence, is belief that these symptoms were caused by radiation from wifi routers, because that evidence does not support the existence of EHS or and “allergy” to wifi.
In particular, the story of Jenny Fry is unbelievably sad. No one with the least bit of humanity can help but feel great empathy and sympathy for Jenny’s parents and Jenny herself. However, no matter how badly I might feel over their loss and the very premature death of their 15 year old girl, I nonetheless feel obligated to point out that they are blaming the wrong thing, just as the parents in Barrie are blaming the wrong thing for their children’s complaints, and Arthur Firstenberg blamed the wrong thing for his health complaints. Wifi did not kill Jenny Fry. It’s very clear even from just the news reports of the coroner’s inquest that it was almost certainly depression that did. Unfortunately, it’s easier to accept an external cause of her death than it is to accept an internal one.
All these cases demonstrate the deleterious real world consequences flowing from the myth of the pseudo-diagnosis of EHS. One consequence of this belief is that it leads quacks to sell and EHS suffers to seek out all sorts of quackery to relieve their symptoms, some of which might be benign, some of which is definitely harmful, and all of which can be expensive. Another consequence consists of the economic harm done to school districts through frivolous lawsuits for a scientifically unsupported “injury,” like the Massachusetts lawsuit against Fay School or Arthur Firstenberg’s lawsuit against Raphaela Monribo.
The worst consequence of the myth of EHS, however, is best illustrated by the sad case of Jenny Fry. Although it’s possible that the stigma over mental illness, which could have been particularly powerful in a small village like Chadlington, contributed to her parents’ denial, by far the largest contributor to a failure to diagnose the girl’s depression appears to have been her parents (and her) belief that her symptoms were caused by radiation from her school’s wifi routers. It might not have made a difference in the outcome, but it’s hard not to speculate that Jenny Fry would very likely still be alive today if that belief hadn’t interfered with seeking mental health services in a timely fashion. Indeed, in a Mirror article, Jenny’s mother was quoted as saying, “I fully believe Jenny did not intend to take her own life. I think she was frustrated with school. She would not see a doctor but was seeing a counsellor at school who was helping her. She had not made any suggestions she was thinking of suicide and I believe it was a cry for help.” Yet we know from other reports that the police were alerted in November 2014 because Jenny had posted “suicidal threats” on social media sites. They took it seriously enough to investigate, too.
If you want a case study of how pseudoscience and quackery can kill, Jenny Fry’s “EHS” is one that will make you want to cry.

Reassessing whether low energy electromagnetic fields can have clinically relevant biological effects
David Gorski on January 23, 2012
Link
It is with some trepidation that I write this, given that I realize this post might lead to charges that I’ve allowed myself to become so open-minded that my brains fell out, but I think the issues raised by what I’m about to discuss will make our readers think a bit—and perhaps spark some conversation. Because I’m in a bit of a contrarian mood, I’ll take that risk, although it’s possible I might end up with the proverbial egg on my face. As our regular readers know, the issue of the health effects of radiation from mobile phones has been a frequent topic of this blog. The reasons are obvious because fear mongering claims not based in science are frequently made in the lay press and in books (for example, Disconnect by Devra Davis) and, unfortunately, also by some physicians and scientists. Moreover, like homeopathy, the issue demands a discussion of prior probability and plausibility based on basic science alone, but the issues are a bit less clear-cut. Whereas the tenets of homeopathy clearly violate multiple laws of physics and chemistry, it is possible, albeit very unlikely, that radio waves might produce significant biological changes.
There’s also sometimes a maddening dogmatism on the part of some physicists that it’s “impossible” that long term exposure to radio waves could possibly cause cancer because such electromagnetic waves do not have anywhere near enough energy to cause ionization and thereby break chemical bonds. While it is certainly true that such radio waves can’t break chemical bonds and the likelihood that the radio waves from cell phones can cause cancer appears very low based solely on physics considerations, all too often the arguments made based on physics considerations alone use a simplistic understanding of cancer and carcinogenesis as their basis. It’s not for nothing that I have referred to such arguments as being based on a high school or freshman level of understanding about cancer—or just an outmoded understanding that prevailed a decade or two ago but today no longer does. Bernard Leikind, for instance, argued and famed skeptic Michael Shermer accepted that, because the radio waves used in cellular communications are too low energy to break chemical bonds and do not produce significant heating compared to other sources, “cell phones cannot damage living tissue or cause cancer.” Note the implicit assumption: That it is somehow necessary to “damage” living tissue in order to cause cancer. That’s an assumption that is arguably quite simplistic and ignores knowledge we’ve gained about epigenetics and how potential metabolic influences might cause cancer. Cancer is associated with characteristic cellular metabolic abnormalities, and determining which is responsible for the formation of cancer, metabolic abnormalities or gene mutations, has become a “chicken or the egg”-type of question.
I do not in any way believe that cell phone radiation actually is a cause of cancer because, unlike the case in homeopathy, where multiple well-established laws of physics would have to be overturned for homeopathy to work, I find the argument that a causation is “utterly impossible” far less persuasive than some physicists do when it comes to cell phone radiation and cancer. Even dismissing the “impossibility” argument, however, clearly such a link is at the very least incredibly implausible on physics considerations alone, as I have pointed out time and time again. Add to that the nearly completely negative epidemiological data in which only one group of researchers has been able to produce apparently “positive” studies, and my personal conclusion is that we probably already have enough data to reject a connection between radio waves and cancer and don’t need any more new large epidemiological studies; following up long term results on the ones already under way should be sufficient. That is not the same thing as arguing that radio waves have no significant biological effect, which is what, in essence, the argument from physics is based on. In fact, the inspiration for the rest of this post came from a meeting I had last week with a scientist and that scientist’s talk for our cancer center’s weekly Grand Rounds. What I learned did not demonstrate that cell phones cause cancer or even that they might cause cancer. Not even this scientist claimed his results were consistent with cell phone radiation causing cancer; in fact, he quite clearly stated they were not. However, what I learned from him cast some doubt (to me, at least) on the assumption that radio waves cannot have profound biological effects. In fact, ironically enough, this scientist is proposing the use of amplitude-modulated (AM) radio waves to treat cancer. I’m not yet convinced by any stretch of the imagination that this researcher is on to something, but his findings made me think about the perils and pitfalls of declaring something “impossible” solely on basic science considerations, because he has some very intriguing results that I can’t find a compelling reason to dismiss.
And, at least as of now, there’s no known physical mechanism that can explain his findings. Leaving aside the possibility of fraud or some sort of systematic bias that is not apparent in the methods sections of the papers I’m about to summarize, either he’s found something new and potentially promising, or he’s somehow very, very wrong.
Boris Pasche and low energy EMF as a treatment for cancer
A couple of weeks ago, a reader sent me a link to a story in The Guardian entitled Hopes rise for new cancer treatment after tests with electromagnetism. It described the use of low energy electromagnetic fields to treat cancer:
Scientists have used low-intensity electromagnetic fields to treat cancer patients in trials which they say could lead to the development of a new type of anti-tumour therapy.
Patients hold a spoon-shaped antenna in their mouths to deliver a very low-intensity electromagnetic field in their bodies. In trials of patients with advanced liver cancer, the therapy – given three times a day – resulted in long-term survival for a small number of those monitored, the team has reported in the British Journal of Cancer. Their tumours shrank, while healthy cells in surrounding tissue were unaffected.
However, the scientists – from the US, Brazil, France and Switzerland – also stressed that the technique was still in its infancy and would require several years for further trials to take place. “This is a truly novel technique,” said the team’s leader, Professor Boris Pasche of the University of Alabama, Birmingham. “It is innocuous, can be tolerated for long periods of time, and could be used in combination with other therapies.”
I responded that I was unfamiliar with this treatment modality. Consequently, I didn’t know what to think (although at the time I thought it sounded very fishy, like Royal Rife or radionics quackery, even) but replied that maybe I would look into it. As is so often the case, given my work from my day job and all the blogging that I do, I didn’t get around to it right away. Little did I realize that a mere two weeks later I would be meeting Dr. Pasche, who came to visit my institution last week, and that he would be speaking about these very results. I must admit, I was intrigued, particularly after reading this editorial in the British Journal of Cancer by Carl F. Blackman entitled Treating cancer with amplitude-modulated electromagnetic fields: a potential paradigm shift, again? that appeared the day before Dr. Pasche’s talk.
Basically, Dr. Pasche and his collaborators have developed a machine that administers very low level electromagnetic fields, modulating their amplitude at frequencies that appear to be specific for various cancers. The energy of these EMFs is considerably lower than that of even the radio waves used for cell phone communications—according to Dr. Pasche, between 100 and 1,000 times lower. I must also admit, the machine is actually rather funny-looking. In fact, I couldn’t help but get the uncomfortable image of a Scientology E-meter in my head when Dr. Pasche showed the audience one of his machines, and it didn’t help that the EMF was administered by having the patient hold a spoon-like device in his mouth for up to three hours at a time in order to receive the treatments at home. So odd is the device that I can’t resist providing you with a photo from one of the papers:
As you can see, the device does look rather low tech, but it’s designed to administer EMF through the buccal mucosa in the mouth. Beginning with a clinical trial in 2009 (Barbault et al) that built upon previous work that used similar electromagnetic frequencies as a treatment for insomnia that produced both subjective and objective measures of improvement, Pasche’s team used EMF with the following characteristics:
    • Carrier output: 100 mW
    • Carrier frequency: 27.12 MHz
    • Amplitude modulation (sine wave) with at least one or several of the following frequencies: 1873.447 Hz, 2221.323 Hz, 3669.513 Hz, 4486.384 Hz, 5882.292 Hz, 6350.333 Hz, 8452.119 Hz, and 10456.383 Hz
Treating various cancers using tumor-specific AM frequencies produced the following results in a patient series in which compassionate use of this therapy was administered to 28 patients with advanced cancer who had limited therapeutic options. The results of the clinical trial were intriguing, but not incredibly impressive, as only thirteen of these patients were evaluable for response, with these observations:
One patient with hormone-refractory breast cancer metastatic to the adrenal gland and bones had a complete response lasting 11 months. One patient with hormone-refractory breast cancer metastatic to liver and bones had a partial response lasting 13.5 months. Four patients had stable disease lasting for +34.1 months (thyroid cancer metastatic to lung), 5.1 months (non-small cell lung cancer), 4.1 months (pancreatic cancer metastatic to liver) and 4.0 months (leiomyosarcoma metastatic to liver).
The interesting result from this paper, which was clearly preliminary, was that specific amplitude-modulated frequencies appeared to be quite specific for specific tumors. One of the most striking demonstrations of this was a patient with metastatic breast cancer whose breast metastases shrank. However, she also had a uterine tumor that grew while she was undergoing this therapy, which Dr. Pasche’s group dubbed Low Energy Emission Therapy (LEET). What was also very difficult for me to believe was how Pasche discovered and identified these tumor-specific frequencies. Basically, he used variations in the amplitude of the radial pulse as a biofeedback method whose presence during scanning indicated a response, as described:
Patients are lying on their back and are exposed to modulation frequencies generated by a frequency synthesizer as described below. Variations in the amplitude of the radial pulse were used as the primary method for frequency detection. They were defined as an increase in the amplitude of the pulse for one or more beats during scanning of frequencies from 0.1 to 114,000 Hz using increments of 100 Hz. Whenever a change in the amplitude of the pulse is observed, scanning is repeated using increasingly smaller steps, down to 10-3 Hz. Frequencies eliciting the best biofeedback responses, defined by the magnitude of increased amplitude and/or the number of beats with increased amplitude, were selected as tumor-specific frequencies.
With the following results:
A total of 1524 frequencies ranging from 0.1 to 114 kHz were identified during a total of 467 frequency detection sessions (Table 1). The number of frequencies identified in each tumor type ranges from two for thymoma to 278 for ovarian cancer. Overall, 1183 (77.6%) of these frequencies were tumor-specific, i.e. they were only identified in patients with the same tumor type. The proportion of tumor-specific frequencies ranged from 56.7% for neuroendocrine tumors to 91.7% for renal cell cancer. A total of 341 (22.4%) frequencies were common to at least two different tumor types.
A single study like this, of course, is not evidence of much of anything. For one thing, it’s a small study. For another thing, there’s no control group. Also, an alternate explanation for the patient whose breast cancer metastases regressed while her uterine cancer grew is that the uterine cancer might have produced something that suppressed the growth of breast cancer. (Angiostatin, perhaps?) Most glaringly, the method by which the tumor-specific frequencies were identified is highly implausible on many levels. Leaving aside the method by which these “tumor-specific” frequencies were identified, however, the result was nonetheless intriguing, because, as the authors pointed out, the objective responses observed in this study due to tumor-specific AM frequencies are evidence that this treatment might actually have efficacy. Certainly it’s safe (after all, it’s even lower energy than cell phone radiation and there were no reported side effects that were attributable to the therapy). And a follow-up study is what Pasche’s group did, in the form of a phase I/II study published in the British Journal of Cancer in 2011 (Costa et al).
Costa et al concentrated on advanced hepatocellular cancer (HCC). Patients were eligible if they had advanced HCC, were not eligible for surgical resection, or had disease progression after locoregional therapies and/or chemotherapy. To summarize the other inclusion criteria, basically, the subjects had to have reasonable liver function and couldn’t have been on chemotherapy for four weeks before entering the trial. They also couldn’t have brain metastases or have had a liver transplant. Treatments were administered three times a day using tumor-specific AM frequencies until their disease progressed or they died. Out of 267 patients assessed for eligibility, 43 were deemed eligible, and 41 underwent the therapy. In actuality, the results of this study, although they don’t sound impressive, were actually somewhat promising, as oncologists familiar with the usual results of phase I trials would recognize. Median progression-free survival was 4.4 months and median overall survival was 6.7 months, while 14 patients had stable disease for more than 6 months. More importantly, there were three partial responses and one near-complete response, a result that would be considered quite good in a phase I trial of a monotherapy with a new chemotherapeutic agent.
Still, although the results of this phase I/II trial were unlikely to be due to chance or other factors given that complete and near complete responses were observed, it certainly wasn’t anywhere near impossible that selection bias or random chance alone might have produced results like this, which are promising, but very preliminary. So Pasche’s group carried out another study, which was published in the British Journal of Cancer just recently (Zimmerman et al). This is the first study where Pasche starts to do some real science on this in the laboratory. He concentrated primarily on HCC and breast cancer, because those were the cancers in which he had observed a clinical response. Basically, Zimmerman et al was an attempt to start to figure out the biology, if any, of the effects observed in the previous two clinical trials. In order to test the effects of tumor-specific LEET, Pasche’s group designed a special incubator that can administer carefully controlled LEET at various AM frequencies and, according to Dr. Pasche during his talk, can do it in a blinded fashion, switching between the different chambers as needed. The design is illustrated in this figure from the paper below:
Basically, this was a very simple study, at least in design. Its findings are fairly easily summarized:
The growth of HCC and breast cancer cells was significantly decreased by HCC-specific and breast cancer-specific modulation frequencies, respectively. However, the same frequencies did not affect proliferation of nonmalignant hepatocytes or breast epithelial cells. Inhibition of HCC cell proliferation was associated with downregulation of XCL2 and PLP2. Furthermore, HCC-specific modulation frequencies disrupted the mitotic spindle.
The effects, however, were quite modest, as this figure shows:
As you can see, growth inhibition of the various tumor cell lines is never greater than 50%, and most of the time it’s between 10% and 25%. This is not particularly impressive for cell culture experiments in cancer, but it appears to be real. Moreover, it has the required characteristics that suggest a real biological effect rather than nonspecific toxicity. First, the LEET only had an effect on malignant cells but not not on nonmalignant cells of the same tissue type. That indicates specificity, as does the observation that HCC-specific frequencies don’t affect breast cancer cells and breast cancer cell-specific frequencies don’t affect HCC. Second, there is an increasing response with increasing dose. In addition, there is a common biological effect observed, specifically mitotic spindle disruption. Finally, using RNAseq, a technique designed to look at all the messenger RNAs expressed in a cell, including noncoding RNAs, Pasche’s group found certain genes downregulated. In his talk, Dr. Pasche also pointed out that he has unpublished results that show that his treatment appears to be working against tumor xenografts in mouse models. For those unfamiliar with what a xenograft is, it’s human cells implanted in immunodeficient mice.
In brief, the combined evidence suggests that there might actually be something going on here, as implausible as it sounds. It’s preliminary and inconclusive, but it can’t be ignored. (At least, I can’t ignore it.) I’ve looked for holes in the studies (particularly the 2011 and 2012 studies), and I can’t find them. Barring a revelation of fraud, which I seriously doubt, the evidence appears to be generally decent quality. Preliminary and unconfirmed by other groups, but, as far as I can tell, of decent quality.
On the perils of concluding “impossibility”
I admit it. I wrote this post because I was in a bit of a contrarian mood, so much so that I was willing to risk taking a bit of flak. (Besides, what fun is blogging if you can’t explore ideas outside of your comfort zone that might provoke a bit of controversy?) More importantly, I wrote it because Dr. Pasche’s results challenged my preconceived notions. The conclusion that cell phone radiation cannot cause cancer is predicated on a combination of the scientifically sound observation that the energy is just too low to do anything more than inconsequential tissue heating and the simplistic idea that, biologically, carcinogenesis requires the breakage of chemical bonds. Dr. Pasche’s results do not demonstrate that it is plausible that cell phone radiation can cause cancer. In fact, he himself pointed that out when I met with him. However, Dr. Pasche’s results also suggest the perils of concluding on strictly physics-based analyses that an effect is “impossible.”
What do I mean?
If it is impossible on a strictly physics-based analysis that cell phone radiation can cause cancer, then exactly the same argument can be made that Dr. Pasche’s results should similarly be impossible. After all, if the radio waves used by cell phones are too low energy to have a significant biological effect, then the LEET used by Dr. Pasche, which is 100-1000 times lower in energy than cell phone radiation, should have even less chance of having a significant biological effects. Yet it appears to have measurable and significant effects, certainly in cell culture at least. True, it is only specific AM frequencies that appear to have a biological effect, but if we were to use the very same argument that Bernard Leikind makes to dismiss the possibility of a link between cell phones and cancer, then what Dr. Pasche has found in his research should be equally impossible. No, more than equally. Remember, the energy levels of the radio waves he uses are considerably lower than cell phone radiation. If anything, they should be less likely to have a biological effect, even taking into account the use of “tumor-specific” amplitude modulated frequencies. After all, whatever the amplitude modulation, it’s still the same energy level.
Yet, Dr. Pasche shows an effect. It’s half tempting to say, “Eppur si muove,” except that I’m not entirely sure, based on Dr. Pasche’s rather preliminary results, that it does indeed move, so to speak. Again, it could turn out that there’s some sort of systematic bias in the methods that isn’t apparent in the papers. As Richard Feynman once said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool.” It could well be that Dr. Pasche is fooling himself. Even so, I am still sure that, with very few exceptions, saying something like this is evidence of a bit too much certainty, at least in biology:
I argue strongly that there is no possible mechanism, known or unknown, by which cell phone radiation might cause cancer.
Saying that there is no possible mechanism, even a mechanism that is as yet unknown, is going too far, at least when it’s coupled to a poor understanding of cancer. Now compare the statement above to Dr. Novella’s more nuanced appraisal:
While electromagnetic radiation from cell phones is a physical mechanism that can potentially have an effect, it is generally too weak to have any plausible biological effect. This by itself is very reassuring, but still cannot rule out a possible effect from cell phones through some as yet undiscovered biological effect of cell phone radiation.
This is the more reasonable approach, to point out the extreme implausibility, but leave the door open to new evidence, which is what I’m trying to do in discussing Dr. Pasche’s work. After all, it is not always easy to determine what is and is not plausible in medicine based on basic science considerations alone. Homeopathy is an extreme example where it is possible to do so, largely because we understand the science involved much better than we understand the science involved in cancer biology and the interaction between electromagnetic radiation and living organisms. In any case, you believe some physicists, it might seem that the cell phone/cancer link should fall into the same category as homeopathy in terms of plausibility. Who knows? Maybe it does. However, as incredibly implausible as even I consider such a link, I can’t quite conclude yet that it does fall into that category of physical impossibility. Yes, it’s possible—likely, even—that Dr. Pasche could be completely wrong and that I’m far too impressed with his preliminary work and charismatic personality. Clearly, Dr. Pasche’s work needs replication by other groups, something that appears not to have happened yet. On the other hand, unless there’s a huge hole in Dr. Pasche’s methodology that I missed, particularly in the 2012 paper, which was the most convincing to me, I’m having a hard time dismissing his results that easily. Maybe someone can show me where I’m wrong, which, while possibly embarrassing to me, would contribute to my education and development as a skeptic. Or we could just wait and see what follows from the labs of Dr. Pasche and others. If we don’t see some followup xenograft studies within a couple of years, it’s a good bet that Dr. Pasche reached a dead end because his current implausible results either couldn’t be replicated or turned out to be, as many expect, wrong. Even if that happens, based on his cell culture studies alone, I consider Dr. Pasche justified in following his results to see where they lead.
REFERENCES:
     1.  Zimmerman JW, MJ Pennison, I Brezovich, N Yi, CT Yang, R Ramaker, D Absher, RM Myers, N Kuster, FP Costa, A Barbault, and B Pasche (2012). Cancer cell proliferation is inhibited by specific modulation frequencies. Br J Cancer 106: 307-313. DOI: 10.1038/bjc.2011.523.
     2.  Blackman CF (2012). Treating cancer with amplitude-modulated electromagnetic fields: a potential paradigm shift, again? Br J Cancer 106: 241-242. DOI: 10.1038/bjc.2011.576.
     3.  Costa FP, AC de Oliveira, R Meirelles, MC Machado, T Zanesco, R Surjan, MC Chammas, M de Souza Rocha, D Morgan, A Cantor, J Zimmerman, I Brezovich, N Kuster, A Barbault, and B Pasche (2011). Treatment of advanced hepatocellular carcinoma with very low levels of amplitude-modulated electromagnetic fields. Br J Cancer 105: 640-648. DOI: 10.1038/bjc.2011.292.
     4.  Barbault A, FP Costa, B Bottger, RF Munden, F Bomholt, N Kuster, and B Pasche (2009). Amplitude-modulated electromagnetic fields for the treatment of cancer: discovery of tumor-specific frequencies and assessment of a novel therapeutic approach. J Exp Clin Cancer Res 28: 51. DOI: 10.1186/1756-9966-28-51.

Nonsense about the Health Effects of Electromagnetic Radiation
There is a widespread belief that low energy electromagnetic radiation fields can cause a wide variety of health issues. Fortunately, there is no convincing evidence that such fears are warranted.
Harriet Hall on January 15, 2013
Link
Helke Ferrie has written an article for The CCPA Monitor, a monthly journal published by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, entitled “Dirty electricity, EMF radiation can be removed or reduced.” It is in the June 2012 issue, and is not available online. She calls herself a science writer, but this is not the writing of a person who understands science. There is hardly a word of truth in it. It’s a classic example of pseudoscientific propaganda, an appalling farrago of false statements and fallacious arguments. The nonsense starts with the very first sentence:
The symptoms of electropollution-induced sickness involve all organs with many debilitating symptoms, from skin rashes to cancer; they are part of the Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) spectrum.
The diagnoses of “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and “multiple chemical sensitivity” are not recognized by the medical and scientific communities. Up to 5% of the population has come to attribute a large variety of nonspecific symptoms to non-ionizing electromagnetic fields from cell phones and other common electrical devices or to the chemicals in their environment. Their complaints have been thoroughly evaluated. Numerous studies and systematic reviews have been done; they are summarized in a Wikipedia article. Just to give one example, a systematic review published in Psychosomatic Medicine in 2006 analyzed 31 double blind studies comparing real radiation to sham radiation. Patients couldn’t tell the difference. 24 of the studies found no effect, 7 reported “some” supporting evidence (2 of which could not be replicated on subsequent trials by the same researchers), 3 were false positives attributed to statistical artefacts, and the final 2 had mutually incompatible results. They concluded:
The symptoms described by “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” sufferers can be severe and are sometimes disabling. However, it has proved difficult to show under blind conditions that exposure to EMF can trigger these symptoms. This suggests that “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” is unrelated to the presence of EMF.
More recent reviews have confirmed these findings, and based on 25,000 articles published over the past 30 years, the World Health Organization concluded:
current evidence does not confirm the existence of any health consequences from exposure to low level electromagnetic fields.
On his website, Brian Dunning recounted an anecdote where various people claimed a new cell tower was affecting their health — before it had even been turned on!
Patients who think they are suffering from EMF exposure are suffering, but not from EMF. The suffering is real, but the cause is not what they think, and treatments based on illusory causes are not likely to help except through placebo effects.
The second sentence of Ferrie’s article says:
In fact, Dr. William Rea, co-founder of the American Academy for Environmental Medicine (AAEM) became EMF-sensitive himself from the operating room lights when he was still a surgeon.
Dr. Rea’s belief that the lights were the cause of his symptoms is not supported by any credible evidence. His AAEM is a questionable organization targeted by Quackwatch and not recognized by the American Board of Specialties. His own practice involves unvalidated tests and treatment with “the electromagnetic imprint” of chemicals in the form of homeopathic remedies. The Texas medical board charged him with several counts including pseudoscientific test methods, failure to make accurate diagnoses, and nonsensical treatments. He claims to have done research but his few published studies range from the seriously flawed to the uncontrolled and outright laughable.
I could go on to deconstruct every paragraph of Ferrie’s article, but I haven’t the patience to write it and you wouldn’t have the patience to read it. A few examples of her silliness will have to suffice:
    • “All the cells in your body are aligned North-South, but they can’t work properly if you sleep on a metal coil bed.”
    • “That microwave oven will radiate you within 9 feet, and wrecks the nutrients in your food.”
    • “The telephone’s sound-amplifying magnet kills off brain cells.”
    • “Energy efficient light bulbs radiate at carcinogenic levels.”
    • “Even if all appliances and lights are off, dirty electricity radiates through the house from the wiring in the walls, which also may be too close to water pipes, increasing conductivity.”
    • “Smart meters are as harmful as all the inappropriately wired gadgets in your entire house combined, because they also attack building materials.”
    • “EMF damage caused by technology separates us from the life-sustaining and healing electromagnetic field activity of Earth.”
    • “This invisible poison wrecks human brains, causes sperm to deteriorate, ovaries to malfunction, and fetuses to die. So there goes the human race…”
She is quick to criticize conventional medicine with the some of the same tired old complaints that have been thoroughly and repeatedly debunked.
    • It treats symptoms, not causes
    • Drugs only make the sick get sicker quicker
    • Doctors are not knowledgeable about EMF
Her solutions?
    • Don’t use cellphones
    • Don’t watch TV
    • Graham/Stetzer filters (plugged into outlets).
    • Shielding materials like metal plates, radiation-repellant paint and curtains.
    • Use low-radiation Apple computers, on batteries, and sit 4 feet away.
    • Monitor yourself with body voltage and gauss meters.
    • “Detoxify” with coffee enemas and supplements.
    • Eat organic food and consume freshly squeezed juices.
    • Use pulsed electromagnetic field therapy to promote healing by resonance with the Earth. You can buy “intelligent Magnetic-Resonance-Stimulation systems” for home use.
    • She calls for legislation to protect the public
Elsewhere she has demonstrated the most egregious cherry-picking, citing outdated and discredited studies and blithely ignoring all the evidence to the contrary. She says:
Living creatures are electrical beings able to function only within specific frequencies. [And those frequencies are…?]
She quotes unreliable sources like Devra Davis. Lorne Trottier has written a blistering two-part rebuttal to Davis’ book Disconnect.
Ferrie says electromagnetic technology:
has the power to obliterate life, phase out our biological future, and kill the brain.
She reports that the very day Graham/Stetzer filters were received by a school, a dairy farmer a quarter of a mile away noticed that his cows started producing ten pounds more milk a day because the dirty electricity was being removed from the ground currents.
Why is Ferrie spewing this arrant nonsense? She gives us some clues. She is a true believer whose vendetta began after a cell phone tower was erected one mile from her home. Over the next 2 months she developed headaches, eye pain, bleeding from one ear, and a cataract in one eye. In a classic application of the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, she attributed her symptoms to the tower. Anyone with a basic knowledge of physics should realize that the only way to get any significant EMF exposure from one of those towers is to climb it and spend a lot of time at the top.
She calls herself a science writer, but this is not science writing — it is a polemic designed to convert readers to a belief system. She clumsily tries to co-opt science to validate her preconceived opinions. A scientist knows that if you search hard enough you can find studies to support almost any belief. Scientists strive for an unbiased evaluation of all the scientific evidence to determine “if” something is true. Instead, Ferrie tries to “use” science to “prove” the truth of what she believes based on her misinterpreted personal experience. She searches for studies in a blatant exercise of confirmation bias and presents poorly digested, misunderstood, and even demonstrably false information to her readers.
This article is a travesty. It’s surprising to see it published in a respectable publication.

BioCharger’s Claims Are Too Silly to Take Seriously
The BioCharger is a subtle energy device based on fantasy, not science. At $15,000, pretty expensive for a placebo.
Harriet Hall on January 21, 2020
Link

Facebook keeps sending me a puzzling picture. It shows clothed adults sitting around (but not touching) a futuristic-looking apparatus: a glass cylinder with tubes and flashing lights visible inside. They apparently believe something is being transmitted to their bodies through the air from the BioCharger. It reminds me of the story of the Emperor’s New Clothes, where the adults are persuaded to “see” beautiful imaginary clothes on the Emperor, and a child has to tell them that he is naked. Is the BioCharger the 21st century equivalent of imaginary clothes? I thought it probably was, but I finally succumbed to curiosity. I wanted to know what on earth those people were thinking. So I went to the BioCharger website to find out what they were selling. The explanation was illuminating, but not surprising.
The BioCharger is a “subtle energy” device that promises to improve performance, recovery, energy, flexibility, sleep, and focus.
The “science”
The question “does it work” can usually answered by controlled scientific testing, but in this case the claims are so nebulous that testing would be difficult. And of course, they haven’t done any such testing. They have lots of impressive testimonials, and that’s all they want. They claim it is backed up by science, and they mention a lot of outdated research by Tesla, Lakhovsky, Royal Rife, Gurwitsch, and others – mostly pseudoscience and obsolete ideas. All that has been covered elsewhere, and I won’t try to go into it here.
The inventor of the BioCharger, Jim Girard, believed those discredited ideas and built on them. He wanted to provide a wide enough bandwidth of frequencies and pulsed harmonics so the cells with very weak vibrations could find their own frequencies and resonate. (Never mind that cells don’t vibrate, don’t resonate, and don’t have frequencies. A tuning fork can vibrate, and a radio station can have a frequency, but a pancreas can’t.) They have developed an extensive, ever-growing library of 600+ energy/frequency recipes. How do you suppose one would go about creating one of those recipes? Perhaps the same way astrologers identified the personality traits associated with different sun signs: it’s easy to just make things up and not bother to test them for validity. The BioCharger is just another in a long list of quack energy medicine devices for diagnosis and treatment. Quackwatch lists 43 brands of these devices based on imaginary frequencies.
BioCharger has the usual FDA disclaimer that it is not intended to diagnose, treat, mitigate, or prevent any diseases. So what is it supposed to do? It allegedly reenergizes weakened cells, revitalizes the body’s natural magnetic energy, aligns mind and body, raises cellular voltage, and restores the body’s natural health and wellness. Its plasma gas spectrum tubes generate bio-photon light, producing a customizable sweep of digitally pulsed electromagnetic fields (PEMF) through a range of frequencies that can include radio, sound, and light. This bathes the whole body in a rich field of bio-compatible frequencies, and each cell in the body selectively absorbs the needed frequencies. They say the voltage of healthy cells is greater than the voltage of sick cells, and the voltage of cancer cells is much lower. They compare the body to a cell phone: our daily lives deplete the voltage of our cells and the BioCharger recharges our batteries. Elsewhere, energy medicine proponents claim you can increase your voltage by walking on the earth barefoot, by releasing negative emotions, by listening to pure sounds, and by drinking alkaline water. They say all disease is due to inadequate cellular voltage. Despite the FDA disclaimer, there are suggestions that the device can benefit patients with cancer, chronic Lyme disease, and other illnesses real and imaginary.
The website has a section about how to get the best results. (How do you suppose they defined results?) The title of that section says for best results, use daily; but the text says for best results, use 5-15 minutes 3 times a week. It says it helps to “relax your mind and think about the situation, issue, or challenge you are experiencing”. How is “mind over matter” supposed to raise cellular voltage?
The device is used on their clients by personal trainers, spas, naturopaths, chiropractors, and others. You can go to them and pay for a session or you can buy your own machine for $15,000. There is a 45-day money-back satisfaction guarantee (minus the $250 shipping charge) and a 2 year warranty on parts and labor.
Conclusion: Too silly to take seriously
This Emperor is naked. Sure, the BioCharger can charge you; but only financially, not energetically or physiologically. If you have money to waste and want to try an expensive placebo, you could buy a BioCharger. If you prefer science and reality to pseudoscience and fantasy, you will have to look elsewhere.


Frequency Specific Microcurrent
Frequency Specific Microcurrents is a dubious energy medicine treatment in the tradition of Albert Abrams.
Steven Novella on January 16, 2019
Link

There seems to be a bottomless pit of dubious medical treatments out there, being created faster than we can examine them. That’s why it’s important to understand basic principles of science-based medicine, so you can at least have a sense if something is legitimate. Also, most new claims are variations on a limited number of themes, so once you can categorize a questionable medical practice, you probably have a pretty good idea where it stands.
But still there is no substitute for exploring a specific claim for plausibility and evidence. We were recently asked to take a look at Frequency Specific Microcurrent (FSM – not to be confused with a noodly deity). This treatment is being promoted by the Cleveland Clinic, now infamous (at least in SBM circles) for promoting quackery in the guise of integrative medicine.
FSM has all the hallmarks of pseudoscience, so let’s go through them in detail.
What Is FSM?
According to the FSM website:
FSM was developed by Dr. Carolyn McMakin in 1995 using frequencies passed on from an osteopath in Canada who had a practice that came with a machine made in the 1920’s.
(Dr. McMakin is a chiropractor, her degree is a DC.) That immediately catches my interest- what machine made in the 1920s? This was indeed one of those black boxes from Dr. Abrams, an infamous oscilloclast. This is a story unto itself, but the short version is that Dr. Abrams was making similar claims to diagnose and treat people with energy frequencies, but his devices were found after his death to be frauds. They were just wires and resistors that made the box hum, but didn’t actually do anything else. This is actually now a classic historical medical hoax.
So McMakin is not getting off to a good start, rooting her therapy in a classic hoax. Regardless of origin, what are the current claims?
FSM is applied to the body with a device that delivers a mild current. Microcurrent is an extremely mild electrical current (one millionth of an ampere). The human body actually produces its own current within each cell.
In FSM, depending on the tissue involved, specific frequencies are selected to encourage natural healing of the body and to reduce pain. Frequencies have been identified for nearly every type of tissue in the body.
One of the ways FSM works is by potentially increasing the production of the substance ATP in injured tissues. ATP is the major source of energy for all cellular reactions in the body. Because treatment with FSM can increase ATP production by as much as 500% in damaged tissues, this may help with the recovery process. Depending on the condition, treatment with FSM can “loosen” or soften the muscles, which can help relieve pain and/or stiffness.
This is essentially energy medicine with a hand-waving explanation about ATP. What does it treat? The Cleveland Clinic lists 22 conditions, from asthma to shingles – a typical list of common ailment seemingly devices to maximize marketing.
The evidence
Let’s look at the published studies. They are pretty thin, starting with the claim that FSM increases ATP. This is based on a single study in vitro with rat heart cells. This is, at best, a preliminary study, with barely significant results. Without independent replication and controlling for possible variables, there is not enough data to conclude what is really going on here, or even if the effect is real.
Also, you cannot extrapolate form a petri dish to a person. There is a lot of potential confounding factors in tissue culture, and directly stimulating cells is not the same thing as stimulating the skin. There is reason to suspect that the tiny microcurrents don’t penetrate significantly through the epidermis.
And that is pretty much it for the basic science. There is no robust literature establishing the basic concepts of FSM, establishing plausibility, that something real and medically exploitable is happening.
What about the clinical evidence? That is also extremely thin. The Cleveland Clinic lists five references, all by McMakin. That is also a huge red flag – when all the research on a treatment involves the same person, that is basically a sign that there has been no independent replication, and there is no interest among serious researchers into the topic. This is the vanity project, apparently, of one chiropractor, not a serious avenue of medical research.
Only one of these references appears to be a clinical study. The others are case reports, commentary, and her textbook. That study, published in 2010, is a typical small pilot study from which no real conclusions can be drawn.
The study looks at FSM for muscle soreness after exercise, and involves 35 subjects. Despite the very small numbers, McMakin did statistical analysis on the results and claims highly significant outcomes. The p-values, in my opinion however, are suspiciously uniform. The baseline comparison between FSM and sham showed no difference, with a p-value of exactly 1.00 (two decimal places). Differences in soreness at 24, 48, and 72 hours were significant, with all three having exactly the same p-value of 0.0005. How nice and tidy.
A small pilot study, without mention of blinding, with a subjective outcome, by the originator of the treatment, with such implausibly uniform results, is not exactly compelling evidence.
I also did a PubMed search on “Frequency Specific Microcurrent” and that was the only actual controlled experimental study that came up.
Conclusion
The claims made for FSM tick many of the familiar boxes of medical pseudoscience. The claims are rooted in demonstrable fraud (Abrams), they are scientifically implausible, there is no body of research establishing the phenomenon, there is no clinical research to establish the clinical claims, the only studies we have are tiny and not compelling, all the publications are being done by the single creator of the treatment, publications are in low-impact journals or those dedicated to alternative medicine, meanwhile there is a long list of implausible applications for this one treatment.
Cleveland Clinic should be ashamed of promoting such rank pseudoscience.

Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Snake Oil
Steven Novella on June 8, 2016
Tweet
Noel Edmonds is a game show host, famous for Britain’s version of Deal or No Deal. As far as I can tell, he has no medical or scientific qualifications at all. This unfortunately has not stopped him from using his celebrity status to offer dubious medical advice via his Twitter feed. Such is the world in which we live.
Edmonds tweeted, referring to the EMP Pad:
A simple box that slows ageing, reduces pain, lifts depression and stress and tackles cancer. Yep tackles cancer!
This Twitter-brief statement packs in many red flags for quackery and snake oil: such as a simple device that can tack a wide range of medical conditions that do not appear to share a common cause or mechanism. The word “tackle” is vague, but implies either a cure or at least a significant treatment. Anyone claiming to treat or cure cancer deserves close scrutiny.
In response, cancer patient Vaun Earl tweeted:
I think Noel Edmonds should stick to what he’s good at. Presenting quiz shows and beard trimming, rather than curing cancer.
To which Edmonds responded:
Scientific fact-disease is caused by negative energy. Is it possible your ill health is caused by your negative attitude? #explore.
There is no such thing as “negative energy,” but that is a common notion used to sell medical nonsense. So is the idea that a “negative attitude” can cause disease. This is blaming the victim (or the patient) which is very common among charlatans.
What is Edmonds selling?
The EMP Pad
Edmonds is apparently a fan of the EMP Pad. Before I get into this device and the relevant science, the company has distanced themselves from Edmonds’ statements, putting out a statement of their own (which looks like it was crafted by their lawyers):
The EMPpad Omnium1 and EMPpad iMRS use very low intensity and frequency pulsed electromagnetic fields (PEMF) which target the cells within the body and help to improve the way they function. Research has demonstrated that this can lead to widespread health benefits, including supporting an effective immune response and a healthy overall body.
Although research using very low frequency and intensity PEMF to help address cancer has produced some promising early results, it is currently in the very early stages and EMPpad does not make the claim that PEMF therapy can prevent cancer.
The company must be delighted – they are getting lots of free advertising and an apparently unsolicited celebrity endorsement. You can see in their statement a common strategy, to imply that a medical device or treatment works without making a specific claim.
This is Britain’s version of “structure function” claims, similar to those allowed by regulations in the US. Companies can make all the claims they want about supporting cell function or improving a structure. They then imply a link to health and disease without making an explicit claim.
But then they allow testimonials to make the final connection for them, and Edmonds has nicely provided that service for the company.
The science of pulsed electromagnetic fields
I always love to click the link on dubious health websites labeled “How it works” or “The science.” Hilarity is certain to follow. The EMP Pad site does not disappoint:
The EMPpad’s PEMF technology has been developed to deliver an electromagnetic pulse at an intensity and frequency which mimics the Earth’s magnetic field. Extensive research has demonstrated that this stimulates a process called cellular resonance throughout the entire body, which can lead to-profound, widespread and life changing health benefits.
Health claims for magnets and magnetic fields are exactly as old as our knowledge of the existence of magnets and electromagnetism. There is something alluring about the idea of invisible fields of energy healing our cells. If only it were true.
One immediate question I had – if the device exactly mimics the Earth’s magnetic field (because it is natural, of course), then why is the device necessary? Aren’t we all being exposed to the Earth’s magnetic field all the time?
They refer to “extensive research” that PEMF causes “cellular resonance.” It is strange that despite this extensive research, there is virtually nothing published about cellular resonance. The only references I can find have nothing to do with PEMF, but only an alleged phenomenon of neuronal communication.
I did find a good reference entitled ‘Nonsense about signal transduction and “cellular resonance,”‘ which nicely debunks the idea as pseudoscience.
Because we are partial to Bayesian analysis here at SBM, we like to consider both plausibility and clinical evidence. There is almost no plausibility to the claims being made by EMP Pad. Low power electromagnetic fields have never been shown to have clinically significant effects on animals or people. There is no way to magically “heal” cells or make them live longer, or affect overall health with simple magnetic fields.
The plausibility for any health effect is not zero, however, since electromagnetic fields are at least real. I could be convinced by compelling clinical evidence. The EMP pad website has a section listing scientific evidence.
This is also a common ploy for dubious health products – provide a long list of scientific studies to give the impression that your claims are supported by science. A careful review of the references, however, typically finds that they are mostly irrelevant to the claims being made.
In this case the vast majority of the cited studies are basic science, looking at cells or at most animals. They are not rigorous clinical trials. They cannot be used to support clinical claims. They are also not studies using the EMP Pad, but any study using pulsed electromagnetic fields.
Having an effect on cells in a dish is a very poor predictor that the intervention will be clinically useful. Most such basic science effects do not lead to effective treatments. It is therefore deliberately misleading to cite such basic science studies to support the claimed efficacy of a treatment or device.
One section did contain some actual double blind clinical studies – orthopedic claims for arthritis and bone healing. They cherry picked a study from 1990 suggesting that PEMF increased the healing of tibial fractures. However, a 2011 systematic review concluded:
Though the available evidence suggests that electromagnetic field stimulation may offer some benefit in the treatment of delayed union and non-union of long bone fractures, it is inconclusive and insufficient to inform current practice. More definitive conclusions on treatment effect await further well-conducted randomised controlled trials.
“More research is needed” is essentially a euphemism for – the evidence is negative.
What about PEMF and cancer? We see only basic science studies of cells in culture, nothing on whole organisms.
Of course, if there were convincing clinical evidence that a particular PEMF could improve survival in any particular cancer, that would already be the standard of care. Cancer doctors would be using it.
Conclusion: The EMP pad is yet another quack scam
The EMP pad, in my opinion, is a typical quack device – it is sold with wishy-washy structure-function claims and vague claims of dramatic health benefits. It uses sciencey jargon about resonance and magnetic fields, the appeal to nature fallacy, and irrelevant references to scientific studies that don’t even come close to establishing their claims.
However, the BBC reports:
The Advertising Standards Authority said it was aware of concerns about Mr Edmonds’s claims but after contacting the company was satisfied that no rules had been broken.
In my opinion this means that the regulations are entirely inadequate. The company charges £2,315 ($3,377) for their device, an added expense that most people suffering from a serious illness probably cannot afford. There is also always the risk that convincing someone a magic box will cure their cancer will make them less likely to pursue standard proven treatments.
In addition, you will now have a TV celebrity blaming you for your own cancer on Twitter.

Galvanic Skin Response Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on July 22, 2015
Link

Selling snake oil is all about marketing, which means that a good snake oil product needs to have a great angle or a hook. Popular snake oil hooks include being “natural,” the product of ancient wisdom, or “holistic.”
Perhaps my favorite snake oil marketing ploy, however, is claiming the product represents the latest cutting-edge technology. This invariably leads to humorous sciencey technobabble. There are also recurrent themes to this technobabble, which often involve “energy,” vibrations and frequencies, or scientific concepts poorly understood by the public, such as magnetism and (of course) quantum effects. Historically, even radioactivity was marketed as a cure-all.
One category of technical pseudoscientific snake oil measures some physiological property of the body and then claims that this measurement can be used for diagnosis and determining optimal treatment. For example, machines might measure brain waves, heart rate variability, thermal energy or (the subject of today’s article) the galvanic skin response.
These are all noisy systems – they are highly variable and produce a lot of random results that can be used to give the impression that something meaningful is being measured. Systems that rely on these measurements to make highly specific determinations are no different than phrenology or reading tea leaves, but they look scientific.
The galvanic skin response
I was recently asked to look into a product called Zyto technology. This is an electronic device that you place your palm on top of so that it can read your “galvanic skin response” (GSR) to specific stimuli. It then uses your responses to prescribe a specific treatment.
The GSR is actually an older term for what is now called electrodermal activity (EDA), which is simply the electrical conductance of your skin (Harriet Hall has written about such devices before). Skin conductance is primarily affected by sweat, as salty water is an excellent conductor. So essentially the machine is measuring how sweaty your palms are.
Sweatiness, in turn, can be affected by a number of variables, one of which is your current level of psychological “arousal.” Arousal is a deliberately non-specific term, because many types of arousal can increase your autonomic activity which causes sweating. Arousal can be anger, fear, anxiety, being startled, excited, or under mental stress. You cannot tell which simply by measuring EDA.
The EDA is one measure that is used in the polygraph test, which is famously unreliable precisely because you cannot infer the source of the stress that is being measured. Is it due to the stress of lying, or the stress of being interrogated?
Environmental conditions, such as ambient temperature, can also affect the autonomic response.
There is also a great deal of individual variability. Different people have very different levels of autonomic activity in response to different stimuli. These highly variable responses can then further vary based upon mood, environment, medication, and underlying conditions.
Such a noisy and highly variable system is problematic for measuring a specific property (such as stress) although it can be of some use in highly controlled situations, such as rigorous scientific studies. The only real clinical application of measuring EDA is for measuring autonomic function itself (in order to diagnose an autonomic disorder). Otherwise it is simply too variable to be of much clinical use.
This variability, however, makes it perfect as a target for pseudoscience.
Zyto Technology
I always love reading that part of a snake oil website that is labeled, “how it works.” In this case the Zyto website has a detailed description. They begin:
ZYTO Scan technology uses Virtual Stimulus Items, or VSIs, which are computer-generated digital signatures that represent specific physical stimuli.
The nonsense begins right up front. They are claiming that they have somehow divined the “digital signatures” of specific toxins, foods, and nutritional supplements. I would love to see the study that established the specific “digital signature” of Gingko biloba.
There is, of course, no basic scientific principle by which you could determine the specific type of electrical stimulation that represents bananas, for example. The very idea is not scientific. If these signatures were determined empirically, imagine how much work that would take. Where are the thousands of studies necessary to create these “VSIs?”
They further claim that:
The body is able to respond to the virtual stimulus in less than one second.
This is demonstrably wrong – EDA requires a few seconds on average. There is nothing they could do to get the body’s autonomic response to be quicker than it is.
After the Zyto hand cradle measures the EDA in response to their virtual stimulus:
The ZYTO software analyzes the data for patterns of coherence. Coherence is a state where two or more things exist without conflict. By tracking the body’s Galvanic Skin Responses, ZYTO technology can calculate shifts in coherence to VSIs. In other words, the shift patterns indicate whether VSIs exist in coherence or conflict with the body.
The concept of coherence or conflict of the EDA (or GSR as they call it) is utter nonsense with no basis in established science. This is the pure magical thinking that ultimately lies at the heart of such devices. This is the “phrenology” component. The device assigns either a positive or negative result to each stimulus then compiles the results.
The ZYTO software then creates a detailed report that translates the analyzed data and your biological preferences in an easy-to-read graphical interface. Essentially, the report presents the body’s responses ranked in order of priority, which can then be used to facilitate better decision making about your health and wellness.
Zyto: Carefully not giving you medical advice (or useful information)
They are careful not to prescribe a specific treatment, just to inform your health decisions. The user gets a result like the picture above. I could determine if you require calcium and magnesium supplements much more accurately by simply measuring the calcium and magnesium levels in your blood, but I guess that’s too old-school.
This is a remarkable chain of claims made for Zyto technology. In order to be true then there would have to be virtual digital signatures for things like food and toxins, the EDA would have to be somehow quicker with their device than normal physiology, and there would need to be some physiological basis for “coherence and conflict” in the EDA which is currently completely unknown to science
Further, think of how extensively each device would need to be calibrated in order for any results to be meaningful. The EDA varies from person to person, with environment, and with current mood. Extensive calibration and standardization would be necessary for the results to be anything other than pure noise. Even the manner in which a user places their hand on the device could affect the results.
In fact, they admit on their website:
Because ZYTO technology interfaces with the body’s fastest moving component, energy, biosurveys can collect a significant amount of information in a short amount of time. Since energy moves and fluctuates so quickly, you are likely to see differences if you repeat a biosurvey and compare individual data points.
In other words – there is no reliability to the results, by their own admission. They make no further comment about this. I guess they think by admitting this, users will expect the variability and not worry about it.
Just to add one more layer of pseudoscience, the write:
Although no meridian points are directly measured, many Virtual Stimulus Items in the software that represent meridians, individual acupuncture points, and even EAV points (Electro-Acupuncture according to Voll) can be measured.
Conclusion: Zyto is Sciencey and pseudoscientific, not science
Measuring GSR or EDA in order to infer some biological property or state is highly problematic, even for careful and rigorous researchers. It is, however, the perfect target for snake oil pseudoscience.
Measuring EDA gives the impression of advanced technology and of measuring something real, at least to the uninformed. It is also a set up for confirmation bias and other cognitive biases that are likely to convince the user that it is working.
For the non-expert who is confronted with similar claims, it is helpful to recognize the red flags. It is highly unlikely that any one approach to diagnosis could provide such a wide variety of specific information. Also, think about all the specific information that would be necessary for such a device to work. Finally, you can ask yourself if the technology is being used by mainstream physicians and at universities. If not, then why not?
When it doubt, of course, you can always search Science-Based Medicine.

The “Healing Codes” of Alex Loyd: Energy Healing with Words and Finger Exercises
Harriet Hall on April 28, 2015
Link


Alex Loyd’s concept of “Healing Codes” is one of the most bizarre, ridiculous offshoots of so-called energy medicine. Loyd is a naturopath who has been criticized by “Dr. Joe” Schwarcz for recycling old bunk for profit. He claims that illness is due to disturbances in the human energy field and that the cells of our body store destructive energy patterns and all our memories, habits, interests, and tastes. This is pure imagination: there is no scientific evidence for the existence of a human energy field or of cellular memory.
By one account, God told Loyd about the Healing Codes in a dream. By another account, he studied under Roger Callahan in 1999 and derived his system from Callahan’s Thought Field Therapy, a fringe psychological treatment with no scientific evidence of efficacy. By another account, a 10-year-old boy had a vivid dream in which a “power” gave him a gift: a series of 10 words that could heal. His parents used the words and experienced near-miraculous healing. They were past clients of Loyd and they offered the words to Loyd. The parents didn’t want any money; they wanted to share their miraculous discovery with the world and help as many people as possible. Loyd was not bound by any such scruples. He proceeded to develop an elaborate money-making business around those words, charging clients hundreds of dollars to get in on the secret. He claims to have customers in 50 states and 143 countries. If using a special sequence of words to heal reminds you of Harry Potter and witches’ books of spells, you’re not alone.
Loyd calls energy medicine “more powerful than anything ever discovered.” He says his method is scientifically proven. He claims that Einstein discovered energy medicine. That’s nonsense. Einstein discovered the relationship between matter and energy, but he never said anything about energy medicine or a human energy field. Loyd quotes the ever-enthusiastic but untrustworthy Dr. Oz: “the next big frontier in medicine is energy medicine.” (Sure it is! And the next big frontier in weight loss is this week’s new miracle weight loss product.) He even cites the discoveries of Dr. Masaru Emoto, whose laughable experiments allegedly showed that unpleasant words written on a container of water could change the molecular structure of the water so it would make ugly snowflakes. He claims that stress is the cause of 95% of all illness and disease, that your beliefs control your DNA, and that cancer can be the result of bad cellular memories.
He says his is the only healing modality that combines words, images, and sounds to open all levels of a hidden immune system, to reprogram unhealthy cells into healthy ones, and to unlock the self-healing and self-growth that makes 100% perfect health possible for the first time. He says frequencies are important, and 528 hertz is the frequency of love. He claims that 9 of the 10 words revealed to the boy have frequencies that have been discovered by scientists to have healing effects.
His Master Key is a push-button therapy that unlocks ALL areas of your being in only 10 minutes. You may not feel any changes at first, but subtle changes will become apparent months later. The Master Key is COMPLETELY different from the Healing Codes. Your health is priceless, and you can get a Master Key package with a value of $939 for only $197. That includes an alpha inducer. And there’s a one-year money back guarantee. But you have to promise to use it consistently every day.
He also offers The Truth Technique to unlock the 99% of information/knowledge/wisdom hidden in your subconscious. It is a bioenergetics testing procedure, an advanced form of applied kinesiology (a phony muscle-testing method) that you can do by yourself.
But wait! There’s more!
LT3 [which stands for life transformation 3] does everything The Healing Codes do, everything The Master Key does, and additionally teaches a mechanism that we have never taught anywhere else but LT3 (the most powerful process I have ever found). LT3 is one-on-one with Dr. Alex, is a lifetime program, and is very limited in number (a small group four times per year, for five weeks).
Users report skin feels smoother, flexibility seems slightly better, “Once, right after the LT3 process, I seemed to have gone into some “meditative” state (not planned) and just “woke up” 30 minutes later….? go figure:)” (I figure he went to sleep.)LT3 opens and clears all meridians and acupuncture points instantaneously and simultaneously, it activates and clears the Chakras, activates the energy healing system, heals the underlying spiritual issues of the heart, activates Cranial Sacral healing in the head, and is credited by a doctor featured in the movie The Secret with curing his ALS. (There has never been a documented cure of that disease, which is what Stephen Hawking has.)
Testimonials work both ways
Loyd has plenty of testimonials and claims a success rating of 4.95 out of 5, and says he has not heard one negative comment. Apparently he hasn’t read the dozens of one-star rating comments on the Amazon.com website.
Some examples:
    • Customers tell how they were suckered into an unending series of purchases. “He has our money, but has now discovered this new, great secret.”
    • “I had a very bad reaction, physically.”
    • “My husband and I did the codes for several months, every day without fail, and during this time we did not have any improvements in our health…we both developed more serious issues.”
    • ‘90% of the book is sales…the book does not give “healing codes.” It encourages readers to sign up for coaching.’
    • “This book and snake oil salesman are a total disappointment. I wasted my money.”
    • “I got the $800 course… totally and utterly useless.”
    • “If they are truly Christian and is this is truly such a major breakthrough, why isn’t it free? Or even just reasonably priced?”
    • “Misleading science and gross verbiage… I am embarrassed for having to give it even one star.”
When I last checked, there were 71 comments like these.
A Certified Healing Codes Coach explains
He has a lot of fodwers. One of them who is a “Certified Healing Codes Coach,” has her own website and a YouTube video where she explains how she cured her asthma and demonstrates the method:
    • Asked how asthma made her feel: restricted.
    • Remembered a teenage experience that also made her feel restricted.
    • Assumed that those memories are encoded in her cells and are causing her asthma symptoms.
    • Says a prayer asking for help getting rid of those bad cellular memories
    • Thinks positive thoughts
    • Performs a sequence of movements with fingers of both hands pointing to (but not touching)
        ◦ Bridge of nose
        ◦ Adam’s apple
        ◦ Jaws
        ◦ Temples
    • Each position is held for 30 seconds and the sequence is repeated several times for a total of 6-8 minutes
    • Look at your memory or truth focus and see if it went down. If it did, or if it didn’t [emphasis added], you keep doing the method. Eventually it will go down to 0; the memory isn’t erased, but you have peace about it.
You may need help in identifying memories or carrying out the process. You can get special, stronger healing codes from her. On her website, she explains that “issues of the heart” and cellular memories are behind most illnesses and are the true source of health, relationship, and success/performance issues.
She explains that Alex Loyd discovered The Healing Codes in 2001 after a 12 year search for a way to heal his wife’s depression, which he then healed in a matter of days. He spent the next year and a half verifying with heart rate variability tests that the Healing Codes removed stress in the autonomic nervous system, thereby allowing the neuro-immune system to do its work of healing the body. Loyd then spent 10 years testing to determine that the Healing Code works for most people and most issues. (If he actually did all that testing, he didn’t publish the results; and I suspect he never thought of comparing the results in his subjects to a control group to minimize the risk of confirmation bias.)
It works! But it will work faster with a coach:
I can develop a custom Healing Code for you to do on your own at home. You will get a Healing Code that is specific to your exact issue, how long to do it, how many times per day, and how long the code will be very strong for you. (Custom Healing Codes do “expire,” usually within 1-2 weeks. That’s because the code is so specific to your issue, that as your issue heals and shifts, the code sort of “goes out of register.” It’s actually a good sign–your issue is changing!)
You can get her help over the phone, and she can even provide healing codes for you to use with other people or even a pet.
There is much, much more on her website, including The Immune System Master Key, Success Codes, Relationship Codes, audios, special music, a timer, pocket guides with all 24 codes, testimonials from patients who were healed of pain, strabismus, and even inoperable tumors; but I couldn’t stand reading any more.
Conclusion
Words cannot express…but I think I have conveyed enough to demonstrate that the claims for The Healing Codes are unbelievable unscientific moonshine. Some people might perceive benefits from the relaxation, the illusion of control, the positive thinking, and the introspection into their problems; but it’s not realistic to think affirmations and finger exercises could cure cancer or have any objective effect on any disease. This is not a miraculous advance in healing, but merely an elaborate commercial scheme to separate soft-headed customers from their hard cash. How sad! Or how funny, if you have a sense of humor. But it’s hard to keep a sense of humor when you reflect that sooner or later someone is bound to die or be seriously harmed because they trusted this nonsense over effective medical or psychiatric treatment.

   Eric Pearl “Reconnects” with Hands-Off Healing
Harriet Hall
Link
I first became aware of chiropractor Eric Pearl through the reprehensible movie The Living Matrix. Several months ago I reviewed that movie and described its segment featuring Pearl as follows:
A 5 year old with cerebral palsy was allegedly healed by “reconnective healing” by a chiropractor who is shown waving his hands a few inches away from the child’s body. Problem: There was no medical evaluation before and after to determine whether anything had objectively changed, and video of the child after treatment shows that his gait is not normal.
I have since learned that Pearl is far more than an eccentric oddball. He is a whole industry. He is teaching his “reconnective healing” methods to others worldwide through seminars in several languages, he engages in aggressive marketing, he offers practice-building advice to his many disciples, and he even foists his beliefs on groups of impressionable young children. I use the word disciples intentionally because there are strong religious overtones to this healing method. 
What is Reconnective Healing? 
“The Reconnection” is similar to therapeutic touch, but goes much farther. He does not need to physically touch patients because they can feel his touch without any contact. They close their eyes and he moves his hands around their bodies but several inches away. They feel a presence, see colors unknown on Earth, and often see angels (one particular angel is George, a multicolored parrot). Afterwards, they report miraculous healings of “cancers, AIDS-related diseases, epilepsy, chronic fatigue syndrome, multiple sclerosis, rheumatoid and osteoarthritis, birth disfigurements, cerebral palsy and other serious afflictions.”
How Did He Learn to Do This?
He discovered this new ability after a “Jewish gypsy” (!?) read his cards at Venice Beach and “Almost as an afterthought she said to me, ? [sic]There’s a very special work that I do through the use of axiatonal lines. It reconnects your body’s meridian lines to the grid lines on the planet that connect us to the stars and other planets.” She told him he could read about it in the Book of Enoch. (I couldn’t stand to read that book, but I skimmed it and didn’t notice anything that seemed pertinent to healing; if readers can find the pertinent sections, I’d appreciate it if they would point them out to me.) He returned for a couple of healing sessions; her fee was $333. Later, at home, a light by his bedside turned on by itself and he thought there were people in his home, that he was not alone and was being watched. He began to have other unusual experiences such as strange sensations and vibrations in his skull and legs, and he started hearing music and sounds. (In psychiatric parlance, the word for this is “hallucinations.”) Then his chiropractic patients started reporting similar unusual experiences, seeing angels and experiencing miraculous healings. 
He learned that “God is the healer.”
Not only did the energy know where to go and what to do without the slightest instruction from me; the more I got my attention out of the picture the more powerful the response. Some of the greatest healings occurred when I was thinking about my grocery list.
Then he discovered he could transmit these abilities to others.
He teaches you how to activate and utilize this new, all-inclusive spectrum of healing frequencies that allow us to completely transcend “energy healing” and its myriad “techniques” to access a level of healing beyond anything anyone has been able to access prior to now!
So what is it? Something he does, or something that a mysterious energy spontaneously does when his attention is elsewhere? A spectrum of healing frequencies, or God, or angels, or axiatonal lines connecting us to the stars, or what? It doesn’t appear that he has even tried to think this through or form any coherent hypothesis.
What About Evidence?
His website is full of miraculous testimonials. These amount to what the courts call hearsay. For all we know, he or his patients could have made these stories up. He offers no medical documentation. The only attempt at any objective evidence is a ridiculous, meaningless pair of Kirlian photos of his hands during and prior to healing mode. He has never even tried to do a properly blinded, controlled test to see if patients really can sense his hands without contact. He’s not about evidence, he’s about belief.
Conclusion
According to the philosopher David Hume’s guidelines for determining whether reported miracles have really occurred, it seems more probable that Pearl’s testimony is misguided than that the phenomena he reports are real. It is far more likely that his claims are explainable through a number of well-documented human foibles: delusion, illusion, hallucination, imagination, fantasy, suggestion, misperception, misinterpretation, and inaccurate reporting. If he wants us to believe there is anything more substantial going on, the burden is on him to test his abilities and offer meaningful evidence. He’s not likely to do that: he has no motivation to test the reality of something he believes in, and he’s garnering far more fame and fortune than he ever could have as a chiropractor. It’s ironic that the etymology of chiropractic implies “hands-on” and that he is now practicing “hands-off.” I’m guessing he’s not a deliberate fraud, but merely self-deluded and lacking in critical thinking skills. His intellectual level is revealed by his own statement that
Books and I never got along. By this point in my life I had maybe read two books, and one of them I was still coloring.
He offers his patients false hope: he is probably harming at least some of them by keeping them from getting real help with their medical problems. Buyer beware!

I Visited a Chickasaw Healer and All I Got Was an Elk Sinew and Buffalo Horn Bracelet
Mark Crislip on February 7, 2014
Link
Which headline is real?
    • I Visited a Alchemist. As American alternative chemistry grows in popularity, I decided to experience an even older style of nontraditional transmutation of metals.
    • I Visited an Astrologer. As American alternative astronomy grows in popularity, I decided to experience an even older style of nontraditional stargazing.
    • I Visited a Bloodletter. As American alternative medicine grows in popularity, I decided to experience an even older style of nontraditional treatment.
    • I Visited a Chickasaw Healer. As American alternative medicine grows in popularity, I decided to experience an even older style of nontraditional treatment.
Difficult? They are similar in that alchemy, astrology, bloodletting and (as we will see) Chickasaw healing are not based on reality. Bloodletting, as best I can determine, is not offered in the US, at least based on the notion of an imbalance of the 4 humors. I have no doubts that a reader will find a practitioner, likely with Hepatitis B and C, somewhere in the US. Probably in Sunnydale.
It was the final option, from The Atlantic. Given their medical reporting in the past, I would not be surprised if any of the above headlines originated in that magazine. This gets to an issue I have with all media. There are two things about which I have expertise: infectious diseases and SCAM. So often the media get both wrong, although I probably notice more when they get it wrong in the areas of my expertise. If they get it so wrong in areas about which I know something, how can I trust the veracity of reporting in all the areas where I have no knowledge?
Still, The Atlantic is perhaps unique among major periodicals in how often they offer up blogging material for me. After setting the stage of the treatment rooms the author, well, embarrasses himself. Watch in amazement as a single paragraph contains perhaps a world record’s amount of fertilizer by a writer who evidently isn’t particularly interested in, well, let’s say completeness:
…alternative medicine has reached an all-time high among ailing Americans. And it’s not just hippies on podunk ashrams–the government, too, has taken note. U.S. taxpayers have devoted $1.5 billion to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) at the National Institutes of Health, a center that researches techniques like acupuncture, yoga, and tai-chi. The University of Maryland’s Center for Integrative Medicine has received $25 million from the NIH for research and offers a treatment in which a healer floats his hands over a patient’s body, as my medicine man did.
“…alternative medicine has reached an all-time high among ailing Americans.” Not referenced, of course, but the only way alternative medicine gets to an all-time high is by defining interventions like diet and exercise as alternative. From 2002 to 2007, according the NCCAM, CAM use went from 36% to 38%, but what CAM was being used?
When you look at the breakdown of the 10 most used therapies it is mostly supplements and exercise. Therapies divorced from reality like energy therapy and acupuncture are not on the list, with the only wackaloon therapy being homeopathy at 1.8%. Most of the popularity in CAM is the due to broad definitions as to what constitutes ‘alternative’. But as has been pointed out CAM is a brand, not a definition.
“U.S. taxpayers have devoted $1.5 billion to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) at the National Institutes of Health, a center that researches techniques like acupuncture, yoga, and tai-chi.”
Note the $1.5 billion is money wasted. Not a single effective intervention has been found by the NCCAM.
Mielczarek and Engler[16] examined the grants and awards funded by NCCAM from 2000 to 2011, which cost a total of $1.3 billion. Their study showed no discoveries in complementary and alternative medicine that would justify the existence of this center. They argued that, after 20 years and an expenditure of $20 billion, the failure of NCCAM is evidenced by the lack of publications and the failure to report clinical trials in peer-reviewed scientific medical journals. They recommended NCCAM be defunded or abolished, and the concepts of funding alternative medicine be discontinued.
There was a link on The Atlantic site to another article, “America’s Shame: Our Ketchup Packets“. The Atlantic got it wrong again. It’s not ketchup packets, it’s the NCCAM. Note that yoga and tai chi, forms of exercise, that are somehow magically transformed into complementary and alternative medicine. Huh. Who would have suspected?
“The University of Maryland’s Center for Integrative Medicine has received $25 million from the NIH for research and offers a treatment in which a healer floats his hands over a patient’s body, as my medicine man did.”
That NIH grant may rank as one of the most appalling I have ever seen. They are going to use reiki and acupuncture, placebos with no plausible mechanism of action, on shock trauma patients to help with pain management. I cover ID patients in our local Level One trauma center. I see how guns and cars and falls can shred a human. To use these worthless therapies on those patients is horrible. I have to wonder if the University of Maryland uses the same IRB as the Burzynski Clinic. And as I think about it, the Grant announcement was from 2007. Shouldn’t there be results by now? Or is that another $25 million flushed down the toilet?
The “healer floats hands over a patient’s body” links to an ‘about us‘ page for a therapeutic touch clinic in Edmond, Oklahoma. Weird. Maybe the author likes the graphic or maybe The Atlantic web page editor is as facile with links as I am with spelling.
That being said, there is no human energy field. If we can pick up the Voyager broadcasting with the power of refrigerator light bulb, 23 watts, from over 10 billion miles from earth, than we should be able to find a human energy field. But pseudo-medicine proponents do not use the term energy in a way that is defined or associated with physics. As Dr. Mielczarek has pointed out at the Society for Science-Based Medicine (sfsbm.org, nice site, check it out):
The fields generated by physical processes associated with human physiology are of the order of 0.004 milligauss. There is no evidence that these fields can be manipulated or tuned to affect human biochemistry for healing purposes. Furthermore there is no evidence to support claims that certain individuals can emit fields large enough for healing purposes. The postulate of an unsubstantiated biomagnetic medically healing energy field, of 2 milligauss which can only be generated by certain individuals, (Therapeutic Touch, Reiki, Qiqong, practitioners) fails all tests of science. This misconception, that an unsubstantiated, biomagnetic energy field which eludes all science based investigation but nevertheless transmits energies large enough to create healing flies in the face of all scientific reasoning and the laws of physics. Thus the Division of Biological Physics of the American Physical Society deplores attempts to mislead the public based on claims by practitioners of Therapeutic Touch, Reiki or Qiqong that they can generate fields which are sources of healing energy. This claim has no basis in physical theory or experiment.
Then The Atlantic asks:
But is this all pure snake oil?
Well, if he had a bit of understanding of reality he could have saved himself some time and money. The answer is yes. Snake oil.
I wanted to find out if there’s some truth to a therapy that doesn’t rely on traditional biological mechanisms.
Traditional biologic mechanisms. You mean fantasy-based mechanisms since there are no human energy fields?
What then occurs is a healing ritual. And healing rituals are important and do have effects. They do not alter any important physiologic parameters but they do make you feel better. The best example is the NEJM asthma/placebo study, where placebo interactions with the medical-industrial improved subjective, but not objective, aspects of asthma.
The author relaxed while
lying on a massage table draped in Native American quilts
while being massaged.
It is a form of social grooming with a side of mysticism . Monkeys do it although they do not get charged 50 bucks for doing it.
Primates provide perhaps the best example of this activity. Primatologists have called grooming the social cement of the primate world. The trust and bonding it builds is critical to group cooperation. Among primates, social grooming plays an important role in establishing and maintaining alliances and dominance hierarchies, for building coalitions, and for reconciliation after conflicts…Primates groom socially in moments of boredom as well, and the act has been shown to reduce tension and stress. It is often associated with observed periods of relaxed behaviour, and primates have been known to fall asleep while receiving grooming.
So many of the alternative therapies appear to be a ritual of relaxation combined with touch, tarted up with spiritual or pseudo-scientific nonsense. In this case it was:
energy of an eagle (from above, with opportunity for perspective) or a bear (on my level, with greater confrontation).
and the author recognizes:
there is a certain mind-cleansing element to abandoning yourself to the motions of this ritual.
If I spend an hour relaxing on a soft table with a massage and hypnotic noise in the background, I would be the better for it, all a more likely outcome for The Atlantic author who admittedly:
come(s) from a nervous people and suffer from bouts of chronic hypochondria.
I have wondered if these rituals tend to have more effects on a fanasy-prone or suggestible person. I would be interesting to do a study of the effects of a Chickasaw medicine man on a selection of the audience at TAM and compare it to The Atlantic contributors. I suspect the latter would have a more profound response. The author, in his reaction to the experience, seems a bit suggestible:
the shaman lightly touched my feet, hitting pressure points such that I felt his touch in the grooves of my cranium…I felt extreme shivers and then, when he palmed my shoulder blades, flowing warmth…I stepped on the buffalo hide rug he had on the floor and was told to absorb the energy up through my feet into my body. I crouched and strained: it was basically like taking a reverse dump.
I can see why he is a hypochondriac; he appears excellent at paying attention to every bodily twinge. And not unsurprisingly after a relaxing ritual:
…wouldn’t you know, that night I had one of the best sleeps of my life. My ear opened up and I felt a remarkable physical and mental equilibrium.
Another Atlantic article: sloppy incomplete reporting about common experience, discussed as if it were rooted in a mystical non-traditional biological mechanism.
But I am now incensed about ketchup packets, so I too am better for the experience.

Reiki
Steven Novella on October 19, 2011
Link
Reiki (pronounced raykey) is a form of “energy healing,” essentially the Asian version of faith healing or laying on of hands. Practitioners believe they are transferring life energy to the patient, increasing their well-being. The practice is popular among nurses, and in fact is practiced by nurses at my own institution (Yale).
From reiki.org, we get this description:
Reiki is a Japanese technique for stress reduction and relaxation that also promotes healing. It is administered by “laying on hands” and is based on the idea that an unseen “life force energy” flows through us and is what causes us to be alive. If one’s “life force energy” is low, then we are more likely to get sick or feel stress, and if it is high, we are more capable of being happy and healthy.
Reiki is therefore a form of vitalism – the pre-scientific belief that some spiritual energy animates the living, and is what separates living things from non-living things. The notion of vitalism was always an intellectual place-holder, responsible for whatever aspects of biology were not currently understood. But as science progressed, eventually we figured out all of the basic functions of life and there was simply nothing left for the vital force to do. It therefore faded from scientific thinking. We can add to that the fact that no one has been able to provide positive evidence for the existence of a vital force – it remains entirely unknown to science.
But the discarded science and superstition of the past is the “alternative medicine” of today. There are many so-called “CAM” modalities that are based on vitalism, including Reiki. Reiki, in fact, is very similar to therapeutic touch, another energy healing modality that was popular among nurses, and although it continues to be used it is much less popular after 9 year old girl (Emily Rosa) performed an elegant experiment to show that it was nothing but self-deception. Reiki nicely moved in to fill the void.
The research on Reiki, and energy healing in general, is similar to that of many similar modalities – those with very low scientific plausibility that are not taken very seriously by medical scientists. The research is of generally low quality, poorly controlled small studies that seem designed to justify Reiki rather than see if it actually works. The most recently published study, for example, looks at anxiety levels and self-reported well being in cancer patient and finds, unsurprisingly, that patients feel better when they receive the kind attention of a nurse. The study is completely uncontrolled, and therefore of dubious value. One might consider such a study a complete waste of time and effort, as the results were never in doubt.
A 2011 review of reiki studies concluded:
The existing research does not allow conclusions regarding the efficacy or effectiveness of energy healing. Future studies should adhere to existing standards of research on the efficacy and effectiveness of a treatment, and given the complex character of potential outcomes, cross-disciplinary methodologies may be relevant. To extend the scope of clinical trials, psychosocial processes should be taken into account and explored, rather than dismissed as placebo.
In other words – existing research is a such poor quality we cannot draw any useful conclusion from it. I disagree, however, that this necessarily means that more research is needed. The low plausibility of using magical energy that has never been demonstrated to exist by medical science argues otherwise. Further, the last sentence is odd – it suggests the authors are trying to spin placebo effects into real effects. This is increasingly the strategy of alternative medicine advocates as it becomes clear that most of the modalities they favor do not work any better than placebo (which means they don’t work).
Reiki is now squarely in that camp. Published at about the same time as the review (and therefore not included in the review) is a well-designed study of Reiki where Reiki was compared to placebo Reiki (someone not trained in Reiki simply goes through the motions) vs usual care (no intervention). Not surprisingly, both the real Reiki and the sham Reiki groups did better on self-reported well-being than the no intervention group, but they were indistinguishable from each other. Therefore Reiki did not better than placebo. That means Reiki doesn’t work (at least in the regular world of science-based medicine).
The authors conclude:
The findings indicate that the presence of an RN providing one-on-one support during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being levels, with or without an attempted healing energy field.
I notice the authors did not conclude “Reiki doesn’t work.” This is odd, given that both the treatment and placebo groups had the same effect on subjective outcomes. With regular medical interventions we conclude from this outcome that the treatment does not work. Imagine a pharmaceutical company concluding:
The findings indicate that taking a pill during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being levels, with or without an active ingredient.
Therefore – taking pills is helpful. Let’s not fret about whether the active ingredient has any specific physiological effects. Reiki supporters appear to have taken a page out of the acupuncture handbook. If real and sham acupuncture are both better than no intervention (they argue), than acupuncture works, whether real or placebo.
This article by Edzard Ernst recently published in the Guardian also discusses this Reiki study. Ernst points out that, not only is it scientifically dubious to conclude from such studies anything other than the treatment does not work, it is ethically questionable to give such treatments as a placebo intervention. He writes
By insisting that patients must not be treated with placebos like reiki, scientists also advocate that they receive treatments that demonstrably work better that placebo. For instance, massage has been shown to improve the wellbeing of cancer patients beyond a placebo effect. If a patient receives a massage with empathy, sympathy, time, understanding and dedication, she would benefit from the placebo effect – just like the reiki patient – but, in addition, she would also benefit from the specific effect of the treatment that massage does and Reiki does not offer.
This is a critical point that I have been making also. Essentially, you cannot justify ineffective treatments simply because they provide a placebo effect. That is because effective treatments also provide the same placebo effect, but also provide specific benefits because they actually work.
I would argue that there are also many potential harms from convincing patients that unscientific treatments are effective because of their non-specific placebo effects. This is a deception, violates patient autonomy and informed consent, and sets them up to perhaps rely on ineffective “magical” treatments for non-self-limiting illnesses.
Let’s get back to the authors conclusions from the Reiki study – they argue that this study shows that the:
“presence of an RN providing one-on-one support during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being levels…”
The part about “with or without an attempted healing energy field” is entirely irrelevant, and you could just as well substitute any ineffective or magical treatment for “healing energy” is that statement. But the first part of the conclusion is also dubious, in that we did not need this study to come to this conclusion.
It has already been well-established, to the point that it is appropriately taken as a given, that people feel better when they get the kind attention of someone else, especially if they are sick and that person is a health care professional with training and experience in comforting sick patients. We don’t need to keep studying this over and over again.
Kind attention plus X makes people feel better, just as well as kind attention alone. Great. We do not need to study this with every possible form of unscientific intervention filling in for X. And it is deceptive and unscientific to suggest that whatever fills in for X has some value because of this equation.
This is what I call the “part of this complete breakfast” fallacy. Even as a child I recognized that when a commercial advertised their pastries as being part of the complete nutrition offered by an otherwise nutritious breakfast, the pastries were nutritionally irrelevant. They added nothing, and the commercial was being deceptive in trying to make me think that they were nutritious simply by their proximity to a nutritious breakfast.
Reiki, acupuncture, homeopathy, and similar methods may be “part of this feel-good intervention,” but they are an irrelevant and superfluous part. It is the kind attention of the practitioner that matters – and only that attention. So such attention might as well be part of legitimate science-based interventions that also have a specific physiological benefit.
This suggests that the real purpose of the ritual of reiki, or other superfluous placebo ritual, is not to achieve a positive end for the patient but to give the practitioner a marketable “skill” (even though the evidence shows that someone without any such skill or training can get the same results). In a recent article about reiki making its way into hospitals, Kryak and Vitale write:
There is a growing interest among health care providers, especially professional nurses to promote caring-healing approaches in patient care and self-care. Health care environments are places of human caring and holistic nurses are helping to lead the way that contemporary health care institutions must become holistic places of healing. The practice of Reiki as well as other practices can assist in the creation of this transformative process.
I submit that if the goal is to make hospitals and other health care environments more nurturing, promoting reiki and similar modalities is that exactly wrong way to do it. They are tying a worthwhile goal to blatant pseudoscience, and therefore legitimate resistance to the pseudoscience will also cause resistance to the nurturing.
If we accept that health care environments can be improved by more time and resources being applied to patient comfort, reduced anxiety, and enhanced self sense of well-being – then let’s use what works, the time and attention of a caring provider. The placebo ritual that is reiki (or acupuncture, or whatever) is wasteful, distracting, and arguably unethical. It unnecessarily complicates efforts to improve patient caring by promoting demonstrable pseudoscience.

No, editors of The Atlantic, reiki does not work
Over the weekend, The Atlantic published an article by Jordan Kisner touting the benefits of reiki and arguing that you shouldn’t listen to all those nasty skeptics calling it woo-woo. Unsurprisingly, the article is a credulous mess citing only token skepticism and relying on weak evidence. The Atlantic‘s embrace of quackery continues.
David Gorski on March 9, 2020
Link

I subscribed to The Atlantic for many years, having been introduced to through my mother’s subscription while I was in high school and college and then subscribing to it myself after I had moved away from southeast Michigan. That all stopped in 2009 when I noticed that the magazine had taken a distinctive turn away from medical evidence in the form of articles spreading misinformation about the H1N1 pandemic, promoting the “integration” of quackery, mysticism, and pseudoscience into medicine, revisionist history of the “evolution” of “integrative medicine,” and even apologetics for chelation therapy. I guess that’s not enough pseudoscience for The Atlantic, though, because over the weekend I became aware that apparently the editors of the magazine are all in for reiki, as demonstrated by a recently published article by Jordan Kisner:
Great. @TheAtlantic goes all-in for a medical scam. @gorskon @CaulfieldTim @stevennovella https://t.co/0hnSb6yMNk
— Steven Salzberg (@StevenSalzberg1) March 7, 2020
What a title!
I hadn’t heard of Jordan Kisner before; so I did a bit of Googling. She’s a writer who’s published in several major magazines. She’s written a book called Thin Places: Essays from In Between, titled after an essay she had written about an experimental neurosurgery developed to treat severe obsessive-compulsive disorder. Her article has been noticed, and she’s aware of the pushback:
Good morning! I wrote for @TheAtlantic about reiki & the swirl of conflicting opinions it produces, even among ppl who practice it. As expected, my mentions are a MESS. Hope you enjoy 😉 https://t.co/TMySjJGhzP
— Jordan Kisner (@jordan_kisner) March 7, 2020
To be honest, I really didn’t think that The Atlantic could go much lower in terms of promoting quackery, but, damn, did they prove me wrong! Reiki? Seriously? If there are two quackeries battling it out for the title of The One Quackery To Rule Them All, based on their sheer ridiculousness and disconnect from reality, homeopathy is obviously a contender, but so is reiki. Reiki is based on the belief that a reiki master is able to channel “healing energy” from something called the “universal source” into another person, with therapeutic effect. Of course, as we’ve discussed more times than I can possibly remember over the years, no one has ever detected or demonstrated the existence of this “life force” or energy (or a “universal source,” for that matter), much less anyone’s ability to control or channel it. Basically, reiki is faith healing that substitutes a different mystical belief system for Christianity. Replace the word “God” or “Jesus” with “universal source”, and there really is no conceptual difference in what is happening. It’s the laying on of hands, pure and simple.
Ms. Kisner starts with the rightful skepticism that many express regarding reiki:
“When I started it, they all just called it that crap. Like, ‘Oh, they’re over there doing that crap.’ ” This nurse, whom I’ll call Jamie, was on the line from a Veterans Affairs medical center in the Northeast. She’d been struggling for a few minutes between the impulse to tout the program she’d piloted, which offers Reiki to vets as part of their medical care, and the impulse to “tread lightly,” because some of the doctors, nurses, and administrators she works with still think that Reiki is quackery or—you know.
Reiki, a healing practice codified in the early 20th century in Japan, was until recently an unexpected offering for a VA medical center. In Japanese, rei roughly translates to “spiritual”; ki is commonly translated as “vital energy.” A session often looks more like mysticism than medicine: Healers silently place their hands on or over a person’s body to evoke a “universal life force.” A Reiki treatment can even, practitioners believe, be conducted from miles away.
Yes, reiki masters do claim to be able to heal over distances, in which case reiki resembles intercessory prayer more than anything else. Of course, there’s no evidence that they can, in fact, do anything of the sort.
I nearly coughed up the coffee I was drinking as I wrote this when I read the next paragraph:
Reiki’s growing popularity in the U.S.—and its acceptance at some of the most respected American hospitals—has placed it at the nexus of large, uneasy shifts in American attitudes toward our own health care. Various non-Western practices have become popular complements to conventional medicine in the past few decades, chief among them yoga, meditation, and acupuncture, all of which have been the subject of rigorous scientific studies that have established and explained their effectiveness. Reiki is the latest entrant into the suite of common additional treatments. Its presence is particularly vexing to naysayers because Reiki delivers demonstrable salutary effects without a proven cause.
Take that, skeptics! How does your science explain that? Well, let’s see what I’m supposed to be explaining:
Over the past two decades, a number of studies have shown that Reiki treatments help diminish the negative side effects of chemotherapy, improve surgical outcomes, regulate the autonomic nervous system, and dramatically alter people’s experience of physical and emotional pain associated with illness. But no conclusive, peer-reviewed study has explained its mechanisms, much less confirmed the existence of a healing energy that passes between bodies on command. Nevertheless, Reiki treatment, training, and education are now available at many esteemed hospitals in the United States, including Memorial Sloan Kettering, Cleveland Clinic, New York Presbyterian, the Yale Cancer Center, the Mayo Clinic, and Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
Yes, it is true that, unfortunately, reiki has infiltrated quite a few respectable hospitals. Heck, I’ve been bemoaning this development a long time, ever since I first discovered the ridiculous reiki pamphlet published by the Cleveland Clinic that touts reiki as “hands-on natural healing using the universal life force energy…which means vital life force energy that flows through all living things. Reiki, an abundant, gentle spiritual energy is not tied to any specific religion or nationality.”
What about the studies that Ms. Kisner linked to? The first one is utterly worthless. It’s not randomized. There’s no control group. It’s not blinded. It’s just a single arm study in which subjects underwent reiki sessions and filled out an online questionnaire immediately before and after. There is nothing in the positive results reported in this study that couldn’t be easily explained by a combination of placebo effects and relaxation from lying on a table for an hour while someone pays attention to you.
The second study is only slightly better. It’s basically a randomized trial of reiki versus classical music versus nothing in patients recovering from acute coronary syndrome (heart attack). It’s unblinded as well, and there’s no result reported there that couldn’t be explained by a combination of human contact, placebo effects, and relaxation. It’s also a ten-year-old study, and a pilot study at that. I was unable to find a follow-up. This is really, really thin gruel to be basing such expansive claims for the effectiveness of reiki on.
So what else does Ms. Kisner have? Anecdotes, of course:
When Jamie introduced Reiki at the VA center 10 years ago, she overrode the objections of some colleagues who thought it was pseudoscience and out of step with the general culture of the VA, where people are inclined to be suspicious of anything that might be described as “woo woo.” But she insisted that the VA—which also offers yoga, acupuncture, massage, clinical hypnosis, and tai chi—should explore any supplementary treatment for chronic pain and PTSD that doesn’t involve pharmaceuticals, especially narcotics. The veterans started coming, slowly, and the ones who came started coming back. Jamie didn’t promise anything other than that it might help them feel calm or help them with pain. The Reiki practitioner she hired was a local woman, somewhat hard-nosed, not inclined to offer anyone crystals. Soon after the program began, Jamie was getting calls from doctors and nurses: “Hey, is the lady here? Someone wants that crap.”
The effects were startling, Jamie told me. Veterans who complained that their body had “forgotten how to sleep” came in for Reiki and were asleep on the table within minutes. Others reported that their pain declined from a 4 to a 2, or that they felt more peaceful. One patient, a man with a personality disorder who suffers from cancer and severe pain, tended to stop his normal routine of screaming and yelling at the staff when he came in for his Reiki sessions.
Has she ever done any sort of rigorous studies to try to determine if reiki, in fact, does what she claims it does? Reiki research is, of course, plagued with the same sorts of methodological flaws that so much research into “alternative” medicine is plagued with. It’s uncommon to find a serious attempt at blinding, for instance, even single blinding the patients, and most studies have sample sizes that are way too small to make much in the way of conclusions. Then there is the issue of prior plausibility. Again, there is no evidence that there is any mystical magical energy field that another human being can impact by channeling mystical magical energy from a mystical magical universal source. If you’re going to convince me that reiki is worth investigating, there has to be concrete evidence that its effects go beyond that of just placebo, regression to the mean, and confirmation bias.
Later in the article, Ms. Kisner describes her experiences after she decided to train to be able perform reiki. She signed up to be able to learn to do hands-on practice and distance healing. (Master training is the next level up, where one can teach others reiki.) There were actually some unintentionally hilarious bits in this section of the article, in which Ms. Kisner described some of what she was taught, and this question and answer session with the reiki masters teaching the course:
You can do Reiki on animals, they told us. “Cats are extra attuned to Reiki—cats almost do Reiki on their own. They can heal you.” No one questioned this. The same goes for plants, the masters suggested. Get two roses and give Reiki to one; that rose will live longer. A student raised her hand. “But you told us never to give Reiki without consent. How can you get consent from a flower or a tree?”
“You can talk to a tree!” one of the masters said. “You should always ask the tree’s permission. Maybe it will tell you to Reiki the next tree.” I glanced around the room for raised eyebrows, but there were only more eager questions: Can you Reiki someone who has transitioned to the afterlife? Yes. Can you Reiki your food to make it healing? Yes, and you should.
We were told that once the masters attuned us, our bodies and spirits would vibrate at a higher frequency than before, and we would stay on that higher frequency for the rest of our life. This would constitute a permanent transition in our physical and spiritual states. I was silently indignant: I do not believe in permanently alterable personal vibrations, whatever that means, and anyway I wanted mine left alone.
And yet she went through with the class anyway.
Still, based on this sort of question and answer session, it’s hard to conclude that reiki is anything but magic. You can aim it at anything you want and magically make it better, more “healthy”. Cats, being creatures long associated with witchcraft, are naturally more receptive to reiki and even able to do it. One wonders, though. If reiki is magic, can it be used for evil? Just as there is black magic, is there black reiki? Inquiring minds want to know!
As for the “attunement” that the masters did at the end of the course to grant their trainees the “power” to do reiki, it sure sounds a lot like a religious initiation ceremony than anything else:
And then, the moment for attunement having arrived, we were led in small groups to a narrow, darkened room. Before we passed through the doorway, one of the masters traced Reiki symbols in the air over each of us. “You guys,” said the other, making what I hoped was a joke, “we’re going to visit some other planets.” I can’t describe what happened next, because our eyes were closed while the masters performed silent rituals that aren’t explained to nonmasters.
I will give Ms. Kisner credit for one thing. In her paragraph of token skepticism, she quotes Steve Novella and me:
Many physicians and scientists still believe that allowing Reiki to share space with medicine is at best silly and at worst dangerous. In 2014, David Gorski, a surgical oncologist, and Steven Novella, a neurologist, co-wrote an article calling for an end to clinical trials of Reiki and other forms of energy medicine. To assess approaches rooted in “prescientific thinking” with tools designed to evaluate “well-supported science- and evidence-based” treatments, they argued, degrades “the scientific basis of medicine.” It saps resources from research into valid therapies, and misleads patients.
Well, yes. Nothing’s happened in the nearly six years since we published that article to make me change my mind. Ms. Kisner’s response:
Other doctors and researchers have accepted the line of argument that Miles and many other Reiki advocates have put forward: The practice has no known negative side effects, and has been shown by various studies that pass evidentiary muster to help patients in a variety of ways when used as a complementary practice. Unlike the many FDA-approved medications that barely beat a placebo in studies and carry negative side effects, Reiki is cheap and safe to implement. Does its exact mechanism need to be understood for it to be accepted as a useful therapeutic option? For decades, experts weren’t precisely sure how acetaminophen (Tylenol) eases pain, but Americans still took billions of doses every year. Many medical treatments are adopted for their efficacy long before their mechanisms are known or understood. Why should this be different?
This is a common trope invoked by supporters of quackery; so I’ll tell her why it’s different. We might not have known the biochemical and physiological mechanism of aspirin and acetaminophen, but, unlike the case for reiki, we had strong evidence that they actually did relieve pain and, in the case of aspirin, inflammation. Furthermore, we knew that, however they worked, the mechanism did not involve invoking mystical magical energy fields and a physical mechanism that violates the laws of physics and chemistry.
In fact, some reiki advocates, like Pamela Miles, seem to understand this very objection:
Miles falls on the conservative end of Reiki evangelists in that she’s careful not to make claims about its mechanisms or efficacy that can’t be supported in a scientific context. She does not, for example, subscribe to the belief that Reiki energy is a substance that can be given, received, or measured. No evidence of this has been confirmed, she pointed out. “Reiki is a spiritual practice,” she said. “That’s what it was to the founder, Mikao Usui. And all spiritual practices have healing by-products because spiritual practice restores balance, bringing us back to our center, and enhancing our awareness of our core selves.” When I asked her to explain what that meant practically, she chose her words carefully. “Through an unknown mechanism, when a Reiki practitioner places their hands—mindfully and with detachment—it evokes the healing response from deep within the system,” she said. “We really don’t know why this happens.”
Of course, this is still faith healing, laying on hands. The difference is that it invokes mystery: We don’t know. Also, there’s no evidence that reiki “evokes a healing response from deep within the system.” There’s no convincing evidence of any specific effect from reiki that can’t be explained by a combination of placebo effects, regression to the mean, confirmation bias, and perhaps relaxation.
Still, this brings me to how I would handle reiki. Personally, I view reiki as more of a religious practice. It is not medicine; so it should not be treated as medicine. Don’t “integrate” reiki into medicine, because, again, it is not medicine. Don’t make any health claims for reiki Instead, treat reiki masters like chaplains and their visits to patients the same way health care facilities treat visits by priests, ministers, rabbis, and imams.
As for The Atlantic, stop publishing utterly credulous paeans to quackery like this article.

Reiki and Therapeutic Touch. Compare and Contrast.
What? I’m not on vacation? I have to write a post? Crap. Remember those college essays? Compare and Contrast two topics and fill a Blue Book with your wisdom. Well, let’s compare and contrast reiki and therapeutic touch, henceforth known as RATT.
Mark Crislip on December 9, 2016
Link

What? I’m not on vacation? I have to write a post? Crap.
Remember those college essays? Compare and Contrast two topics and fill a Blue Book with your wisdom. Do they even use Blue Books anymore? I always hated the fact they were wide, rather than college, ruled. Now it is all about using Word and Microsoft doesn’t have a Blue Book mode.
See? There can be human progress. In Blue Books if not in medical education. I was annoyed to learn that reiki was being offered for continuing medical education at one of my institutions. We have so little pseudo-medicine where I practice that duty rarely calls.
I could not let such an abomination pass without comment. So I fired up the interwebs to find my SBM post on the topic…only to find such a post does not exist. I did a podcast on the topic back in the early days before my SBM life. Who wants to listen to a podcast from 2008? I am not even going to listen to it in preparation for this blog post.
I needed to write a review on the topic, not only to send to those who are offering reiki for CME, but also for the wider world. Reiki, and to a lesser extent its identical twin Therapeutic Touch, are remarkably popular in integrative medicine clinics. And, of course, because the world needs more Mark Crislip™ even if I was recently described on iTunes as an:
arrogant, intolerant, obscene verbal bully.
It is nice to know people are paying attention. Maybe that should be my motto.
RATTing out the science
To make my life easier, when applicable I will lump the two pseudo-medicines together as RATT, Reiki And Therapeutic Touch.
RATT is a form of ‘energy’ therapy and, when it comes to ‘energy’, RATT practitioners are evidently great fans of the Princess Bride, but then, who isn’t?
Energy is, as us physics pedants like to point out, the ability to do work, and comes in many forms, from chemical to thermal.
The ‘energy’ of RATT (and all of CAM) is none of these energies known by science. It isn’t even dark energy. It is ‘energy’, man, and what Thomas Jefferson had in mind when he famously said
Ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible propositions. Ideas must be distinct before reason can act upon them; and no man ever had a distinct idea of the CAM ‘energy’. It is the mere Abracadabra of the mountebanks calling themselves practitioners of reiki.
Jefferson would probably have been called an arrogant, intolerant, obscene verbal bully for a comment like that. ‘Energy’ deserves the scare quotes, much the in same way you know that ‘fresh’ fish isn’t really fresh. There is no ‘energy’ and if the scare quotes had a brain they would recognize the fact.
Yes. I had to do that. Must…Write…Awful…Puns.
This ‘energy’, be it in RATT or Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine or Chiropractic, is undetected and undetectable by reality-based measurements. We can detect gravity waves but not the human energy field. My theory is that the ‘energy’ is propagated by vibrating (yes, there are vibrations) N rays. There must be a carrier by which these ‘energies’ are transmitted. RATT and N rays do have the same key characteristic: they are detectable by their proponents until the ability of the observer to fool themselves is removed.
There is always the chance, however remote, that there is a new form of hitherto unsuspected ‘energy’ that humans produce and can be detected only by humans, although by what anatomical structure is uncertain. It took a PhD physicist to demonstrate that N-rays were a figment of an overactive imagination. For therapeutic touch it required a 6th grader.
Most readers of SBM are aware of Emily Rosa who, in 6th grade, tested the ability of TT practitioners to detect a human ‘energy’ field with a simple and elegant protocol. They couldn’t detect the ‘energy’ and Emily got a publication in JAMA.
Not that such a study dissuaded TT practitioners. Like a dowser who can’t find water under controlled circumstances, the experience was not disconfirming of the intervention. Arguments were raised to the JAMA results but as best I can tell, TT proponents have never bothered to prove the basis of their practice.
So we have established that there is no human ‘energy’ as is understood by reality-based science and, even if there was a new ‘energy’, its proponents cannot prove it exists outside of their reiki box and the power of imagination.
So why does RATT even exist?
TT was, invented? discovered? pulled out of thin air? Just what to you call the process of producing works of fiction? Oh yeah. Created.
TT was created in the 70s by a Professor/RN and a “gifted energy healer”. Gifted? Says who? How does someone get the designation of “gifted energy healer”? I cannot imagine the steps required reach that lofty goal. Just imagine the recertification test. And a google search reveals a step above, the truly gifted energy healer. Somehow much better than a false, terrible energy healer.
I suspect that the popularity of TT derives from the urge in nursing to find a unique way to interact with patients that allows independence from physicians. And unlike much of quackademia, TT started at the quackademic hill top and then rolled down like, well you know the metaphor.
Reiki (bad spell checker. Not reeky. Yes more GOT, perhaps, but stop it) started at the bottom, in fact rock bottom.
Usui Mikao created reiki. After being unable to hold down a steady job he became a Buddhist priest and, after 21 days of fasting and prayer, hallucinating from hypoglycemia and sleep deprivation, it is said he came up with reeky. That’s about right. Most medical acupuncture courses for example, are about three weeks long. It doesn’t really take that much to learn most pseudo-medicines, much less invent a whole new system. DD Palmer seems to have put together chiropractic in a couple of days.
With a spiritual patina and Scientology-like levels, reiki does have the appeal, I suppose, of the mysterious and ineffable.
Homeopathic touching
To me the most amazing characteristic of RATT is, for the most part, the patient is not touched. Hands are just waved over the patient. Watch as a professor of nursing brushes flies off the, er, I mean balances the vibrational energy or some such of her client. Client. Doesn’t she mean mark? Just don’t watch while drinking milk.
And reiki? They seem to have the same creepy propensity of chiropractors for demonstrating on pretty, scantily clad, females. And what is it up with THAT? TT as Therapeutic Trump? Trump Touch?
But RATT is often the homeopathy of touch. Nothing there at all. No energy, no touch. Do not even have to worry about good hand hygiene.
Having a RATT session does look beneficial. Who wouldn’t want to lie down and relax during a busy day? An excuse for a nap is always welcome as long as the whole” inappropriate groping disguised as energy balancing” thing didn’t occur.
RATTy research
But the fact that RATT is a fiction wrapped inside a charade inside a fraud doesn’t mean there isn’t research. It just means the research stinks on ice. Meta-analyses suggest a lack of methodological rigor. As one reiki meta-analysis noted:
The serious methodological and reporting limitations of limited existing Reiki studies preclude a definitive conclusion on its effectiveness.
Although I would disagree about the need for high quality studies for reiki.
Another review, including therapeutic touch, suggested:
The methodologic limitations of several studies make it difficult to draw definitive conclusions about the efficacy of distant healing.
With a follow-up several years later suggesting:
Since the publication of our previous systematic review in 2000, several rigorous new studies have emerged. Collectively they shift the weight of the evidence against the notion that distant healing is more than a placebo.
I keep re-reading the last sentence to parse the meaning. If Hemingway had written the conclusion he might have said the evidence indicates that the effects of distant healing are due to placebo. And noted the dried and frozen carcass of a leopard.
With RATT trials, and in fact all pseudo-medical studies with no basis in reality, you want a good placebo control, you want to know if blinding was successful in the patient and, above all, you do not want a study that compares RATT to usual care.
As has been noted by Dr. Edzard Ernst, a study design that compares a treatment to standard care will ALWAYS yield a positive result, also stating:
They do not represent an honest test of anything, simply because we know their result even before the trial has started. They are not science but thinly disguised promotion. They are not just a waste of money, they are dangerous – because they produce misleading results – and they are thus also unethical.
And there is that whole prior plausibility problem. Sitting right at zero, it is as certain as the sun rising in the east that any positive study of RATT is going to be a false positive.
So I will mostly limit myself to studies that have a placebo control. Which oddly brings up this article, I suppose because it contains “No touch” in the abstract. Sometimes you have to wonder about PubMed.
And now the completely expected results
Reading these studies is partly for amusement, but I find as I age they also generate a bit of angst. About 75% of my life is over and it is a time to look back on what I have accomplished. The thought of having spent the prime years of one’s life immersed in a worthless pseudo-science is so sad.
RATT has been tried for a variety of processes for no rational reason, the old ‘when you have a hammer everything is a nail’ problem. RATT has been used for everything from agitation to carpal tunnel to, I hear, raising the dead, and the results tend to be all over the map, some positive but mostly negative. As is often the case with pseudo-medicine, the better the methodology, the less the effect.
A curious study with placebo is “Therapeutic touch for nausea in breast cancer patients receiving chemotherapy: Composing a treatment.”
Their placebo was:
the practitioner’s hands-to-patient’s body distance was different (more than 20 cm) and in fact there was no energy transfer.
No energy transfer! And they know that how? It was followed by the classic post hoc torturing the data until it confessed. Three different statistical analyses were used to generate significance, one for each table, for reasons never explained. Oddly placebo was better at decreasing the frequency of nausea but not noted as such. It is a study with opaque reporting at best.
In “Investigating the effect of therapeutic touch on the intensity of acute chemotherapy-induced vomiting in breast cancer women under chemotherapy,” TT was compared to placebo and standard care. Connoisseurs of SBM will not be surprised by the results.
…there was a statistically significant difference between the control group and the intervention group and between the control group and the placebo group (P < 0.0001). However, there was no significant difference between the placebo and intervention groups (P = 0.07).
TT had no effect on carpal tunnel compared to sham TT; but why would it?
The other hint as to the mechanism of Reiki is found in “Reiki’s effect on patients with total knee arthroplasty: A pilot study” where reiki was effectively compared to usual therapy except in the post-anesthesia recovery, were patients have little awareness as they wake up. Just what is expected in a placebo therapy.
I think one trial sums up the effects of ‘energy’ therapy best:
The findings indicate that the presence of an RN providing one-on-one support during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being levels, with or without an attempted healing energy field.
A caring provider is what is needed to help patients cope; not a pseudo-medicine based on pseudo-science that only offers fraudulent placebo effects.

A Journalist Asks if Your Child Needs an Energy Healer. The Answer Probably Won’t Surprise You.
A healthcare journalist writing for a respected source of news for millions of people has penned an article that endorses pure quackery in the form of energy healing for kids.
Clay Jones on December 10, 2021
Link

In a 2018 article that I managed to miss until this week, journalist Anna Miller attempts to answer the question of whether or not children benefit from energy healing. Unfortunately she fails in this endeavor and leaves the reader confused, if not fully believing that there actually is some degree of legitimacy to such rank pseudoscience.
Miller, a former senior health editor at U.S. News appears to have the background to appropriately cover a topic like this. She had written about nutrition and fad diets in the past, as well as so-called complementary medicine, and she has a degree in psychology. Her bio even claims that she is a health expert that is frequently called upon to educate the public.
But as readers of SBM know, understanding pseudoscience in medicine is not something that tends to come naturally. We are all at risk of being fooled, and even highly intelligent and accomplished medical professionals often fail when it comes to such a complex issue. This problem requires a mental skill set that must be learned and developed over time. Frequent updates to our critical thinking algorithms are also essential because the proponents of these implausible, unproven, or even thoroughly disproved therapies learn new tricks all the time. They also like to dust off old tricks that haven’t been used in a while in order to get past our cognitive defenses.
One trick that has never gone out of style is the use of the emotional and deceptive anecdote as a hook. Miller’s article begins, as many do, with just such a triumphant success story that involves the use of “energy healing”. It isn’t meant to be critically evaluated but to lower the reader’s defenses and make them more receptive to the low quality evidence that is ultimately provided. In my opinion, this is a clearly biased narrative that raises more questions than it answers:
The hospital staff was at a loss: A young patient with leukemia was writhing in pain and inconsolable. She hadn’t slept in days.
Then Dr. Joy Weydert, a pediatrician who was chief of integrative pain management at Children’s Mercy Kansas City in Missouri at the time, stepped in. The girl, who was about 13 years old, had maxed out on pain medications and refused integrative therapies like guided imagery and massage, even though she’d found relief from them before. “She was beside herself she was so uncomfortable,” Weydert remembers.
So Weydert, now a clinical professor of integrative medicine and pediatrics at the University of Kansas Health System in Kansas City, Kansas, pulled one more tool out of her toolkit: energy healing. While the practice can take many forms, in this case, it involved gentle touch and guidance on breathing regulation.
Within 10 minutes, the patient began settling down, and within 20, she stopped wiggling and steadied her breathing, Weydert says. After no more than 30 minutes had passed, the girl was asleep for the first time in days. When she woke up the next morning, she said, “Do that to me again!” Weydert recalls. She taught the technique to the girl’s mother, who continued to use it at home each night. “It empowered her to be able to help out,” Weydert says.
There is a lot to unpack here. A lot. In fact, I think that’s what this post will focus on, although I do want to point out that later in the article Miller claims that energy medicine has been proven to objectively help with a wide variety of medical conditions in children. This is simply not true. She cites a 2017 clinical report from the AAP in a misleading way:
In babies and children, the evidence is more limited, but still encouraging enough that a clinical report on pediatric integrative medicine written by the American Academy of Pediatrics’ Section on Integrative Medicine included biofield or energy therapies like healing touch, therapeutic touch and spiritual healing among those complementary and alternative medicine therapies that are safe and effective for children.
Here is the totality of what the AAP report has to say about energy medicine:
Biofield therapies encompass several healing practices that include therapeutic touch, healing touch, and spiritual healing, among others. The biofield therapies are “intended to affect energy fields that purportedly surround and penetrate the human body” and are “rooted in concepts of compassion, positive intention, self-empowerment, the mind-body-spirit triad, and the body’s innate tendency toward healing.” Therapeutic touch and healing touch have been used successfully in pediatric oncology patients as a nonpharmacologic approach to reduction of pain and stress.
I wrote about this report when it came out and I wasn’t impressed. The definition used by the AAP is pure pseudoscience. Energy is never defined and the whole concept is akin to just saying it works by magic. Miller uses a similar approach in her article, and also incorporates the concepts of compassion and positive intention into the definition. Obviously compassion for our patients is a good thing, and a key aspect of what most would consider to be a helpful bedside manner, but concepts such as positive intention and “the mind-body-spirit triad” are just catchy marketing terms designed to distract from nonsense about mysterious undetectable energy fields. It’s meaningless jargon appropriated from new age spiritualism and positive psychology.
Also, the study cited in the AAP report in support of energy medicine for children with cancer was garbage that didn’t even look at pain and didn’t tease out energy therapy as a specific intervention from the theater that surrounds it. As I said in my post back then, the AAP has an integrative medicine problem. They allowed a group of biased believers in quackery to establish an official Section, which gives undeserved credibility to that quackery that then loops back around to provide justification for the Section’s existence. As with all integrative medicine, the AAP report uses proven science-based interventions to prop up the nonsense and it is not a serious source that can be used to declare energy medicine effective for anything.
But I am supposed to be focusing on Miller’s opening story, which was clearly included in order to convince readers that energy medicine is a legitimate treatment. It’s being offered in academic children’s hospitals, after all. But I have a few issues with the way the story was presented. I also have a different interpretation.
In the opening anecdote, there are several assumptions forced upon the reader. Right off the bat we are told by Dr. Weydert that the hospital staff was at a loss regarding the patient’s pain and insomnia, which is implied to be related to her leukemia. I’m skeptical that the team was as lost as she recalls. The use of that kind of language reveals what I think is some pretty significant bias and there is a high likelihood that this memory has drifted from the reality of the events over the years as she has reinterpreted and retold it time and time again.
While it is certainly plausible that a child with leukemia might be in pain, we aren’t given specific details to help determine the actual cause. Patients with active leukemia might have severe bone pain. Patients undergoing treatment with chemotherapy might have pain from mucositis, which involves inflammation and injury to the lining of the GI tract. She could have had meningitis from leukemic infiltration of the CNS, or from the chemotherapy used to treat it. She might have developed neuropathic pain associated with her chemotherapy regimen.
She might also have been experiencing pain related to the stress and anxiety associated with her diagnosis and multiple hospitalizations. Patients often have a perception of pain even when there is no tissue injury or inflammation, or any so-called “organic” cause. This does not mean they aren’t in pain, or that the pain isn’t real. Pain is pain and it’s all in the brain, as they say. The distinction is only important because having an understanding of the source of a patient’s pain helps us to determine the best treatment for it.
I think that Dr. Weydert’s recollection of the team being “at a loss” just means that they had actually ruled out pain related directly to her leukemia. They likely strongly suspected that her pain was functional in nature and had consulted the integrative pain management team for help, not because they believe in energy healing or homeopathy, which Weydert also believes in, but because that’s the team who gets consulted for difficult-to-manage pain at that facility. My suspicion, and that’s all I can say that it is, is that Dr. Weydert probably sees herself as a bit of a savior for patients like this and feels that the primary treatment teams, whether they be made up of hospitalists like me or oncologists caring for a child with leukemia, are often lost without her services. We are all the heroes of our own stories, I suppose. It sure would be interesting to get the perspective of the physician who put in the consult in this case.
Another clue that Dr. Weydert might have a biased memory and that the primary treatment team had determined that the patient had pain that would be more amenable to nonpharmaceutical interventions is that the patient was “maxed out” on pain medications. This isn’t a term we typically use, at least not in my experience. I’ve personally never put that in a chart and I don’t really know what it means in this context.
I think that Dr. Weydert is at least implying that this is a patient who was on multiple medications for pain, meaning scheduled doses of ibuprofen and acetaminophen as well as a scheduled intravenous opioid such as morphine or hydromorphone (Dilaudid). She might even be receiving a continuous infusion of one of these opioids. And at 13 years of age, she is old enough to be able to press a button to self-administer an extra bolus dose when needed, with appropriate limitations on frequency and dose.
When it comes to the use of drugs like morphine for pain, we worry about the side effect of respiratory depression so we are careful about initial dosing. Parameters like the time to peak pain reduction and peak respiratory depression are well known with these drugs, so if a patient has persistent pain after the initial dose we can safely give more of that opioid until a patient is comfortable. As long as thought is put into the timing of additional doses, and how much each dose is potentially increased, the risk of some kind of bad outcome is extremely low. In general, with IV morphine for example, if 20-30 minutes have passed, and a patient is in pain and breathing normally, you can safely give another dose and even increase it by 50%.
So when I see that this specific patient was “maxed out” on pain medications, but still “writhing in pain”, it tells me that likely one of two things were happening. One possibility is that her treatment team believed that her pain was related to her leukemia and was opioid responsive, but for unknown reasons they chose to provide inadequate pain control and not increase the dose of her opioid. Because we don’t typically allow patients to suffer from severe opioid responsive pain like that, the more plausible possibility is that her team recognized that her pain was not opioid responsive, and that it may be related to stress and anxiety.
As Dr. Weydert reveals, the team had already attempted to treat the child’s pain with “integrative therapies”, in this case massage and guided imagery. This is a good example of how integrative medicine often just co-opts standard science-based nonpharmaceutical interventions (Ugh. Please ignore the acupuncture in this otherwise excellent summary that I’ve linked to) in order to provide cover for nonsense like homeopathy and energy healing. Massage and other stress reduction and distraction techniques had apparently benefited the patient but for unexplained reasons she wasn’t interested in continuing them. Nonpharmaceutical interventions can be very helpful for any type of pain, even allowing some patients to achieve reasonable comfort with lower doses of opioids or without them at all depending on the source and severity of the pain.
Again, the claim that the patient’s pain medications were “maxed out” tells me that they probably weren’t dealing with opioid responsive pain. At this point, the next step in pain control can be very challenging. Imagine trying to convince a patient (if they are old enough to be part of the discussion) or a caregiver that the patient’s pain is caused by stress/anxiety and that you want to stop the morphine which they might strongly believe is helping despite all the objective evidence that it isn’t. Sometimes we have to settle for putting a hold on increasing the opioid dosing and then slowly reduce it over some period of time in order to preserve the therapeutic relationship.
Nonpharmaceutical interventions are the best approach for pain caused by stress and anxiety, but it’s complicated. Patients and caregivers need to buy into the approach. When we go down this path, it often requires help from people who are experts in treating patients either directly, such as with cognitive behavioral therapy, massage or play therapy, or in teaching patients and caregivers how to take an increasingly active role themselves, such as with massage, exercise, deep breathing exercises, or meditation.
There is no magic to these interventions. When they work, they tend to do so by calming the patient and distracting them from the pain, or by teaching them how to adjust their perception of it. Some people respond to certain interventions but not at all to others, and there are many reasons why these approaches might not help a particular patient. A patient might be in too much pain to participate. They might not want to participate. They might not care for or trust the person working with them. They might be angry. They might be depressed. They might have an altered mental status from injury or medications. It’s a long list.
What I’m getting at with this is that sometimes the specific person providing the nonpharmaceutical intervention can make a huge difference. Obviously there is no such thing as energy healing. It’s made up. And in fact, this story serves as evidence of the absurdity of the whole concept if gently touching a patient in a caring way and talking them through deep breathing exercises can be labeled as energy healing. Am I doing it when I sit with a patient and reassure them that they will have a full recovery? Am I doing it when I explain to a patient that the medication I’m ordering will cure their pneumonia? Is anything I do not some form of energy healing?
It is entirely possible that Dr. Weydert is just really good at connecting with people and gaining their trust. Establishing a therapeutic relationship in a short period of time is a skill and it can make all the difference in situations like this. Maybe that is why the patient described in this anecdote had such a positive response in such a short period of time, although, to be honest, it probably wasn’t quite as dramatic as she presents it. Of course, it is also possible that Dr. Weydert just got lucky and was in the right place at the right time. Maybe the patient was just in a better place to be more receptive to nonpharmaceutical interventions.
Conclusion: Nonpharmaceutical interventions can help reduce pain without the fantasy
Your child does not need an energy healer. Energy healing is silly. It’s fantasy and barely more plausible than homeopathy. It has no place in the treatment of pediatric patients with pain, or any patient with any condition for that matter. I get that some people are going to respond to the fantasy narrative, but that isn’t okay if it involves deception. Lying to a patient about a treatment, even if it is well-meaning and unlikely to cause direct harm, is unethical.
It is okay to develop and implement frameworks that help patients understand a treatment that might not be how I would discuss it with colleagues outside the room. For example, instead of invoking the manipulation of mysterious and undetectable human energy fields, Dr. Weydert might instead set up her interactions by discussing the mysteries of the human mind and how we don’t always understand how things like massage and gentle touch can change the way our bodies perceive pain. She could tell her patients and their caregivers there is good evidence that nonpharmaceutical interventions can be very helpful for some patients. This doesn’t interfere with the desired distraction and also engenders potential non-specific “placebo” treatment effects without the need for any deception or magical thinking.
        ◦ The problem, and it is one that we have discussed many times over the years here at SBM, is that the people providing these interventions tend to be believers in the magical thinking. Dr. Weydert is a prime example. And articles like this aren’t helping because they prime patients to believe in it as well. Miller even credulously quotes an energy healer who performs remote healing that works on a “quantum level”. There isn’t even token skepticism to counter these claims and her article is ultimately just propaganda that fails to truly educate the public.

Mayo Clinic Promotes Reiki
Steven Novella on February 14, 2024
Link

The Mayo Clinic is a prestigious medical institution with a deserved international reputation. It also promotes rank pseudoscience. It does this, apparently, for all the reasons we have explored here at SBM over the years. I have seen first hand how one or a few true believers can promote so-called alternative medicine at their institutions, meeting little resistance from colleagues and administrators who are “shruggies”. They don’t really understand the phenomenon and are content to let the “experts” take the lead.
In this case we see an article published on the Mayo Clinic website promoting the pseudoscientific practice of Reiki. As I and others at SBM have discussed many times before, Reiki is an Asian form of faith healing or laying on of hands. It purports to manipulate an unseen energy field surrounding living things. Proponents make mostly vague claims about “healing” or “wellness” and that the practice will reduce stress and subjective symptoms.
The Mayo Clinic article, by nurse Kenneth Rooth, states:
“Simply put, Reiki is a Japanese healing technique that aims to reduce stress and shift energy in the body. It was discovered by Master Mikao Usui in 1922 and slowly grew in popularity as a healing modality that is now practiced worldwide.”
That’s always a red flag of pseudoscience – when an entire practice was “discovered” by a single individual. What did he discover, exactly? The idea of life energy is ancient. It’s a pre-scientific superstitious idea that was largely a placeholder of our own ignorance of biology. What did the life force do? Whatever we did not understand about biology. Eventually, as science advanced, there was nothing left for the life force to do.
We now also have at least a century of scientific research that has failed to find any clue that such a mysterious life force or life energy exists. It cannot be detected, measured, or confirmed in any way. Also, there isn’t a single energy-based practice that has been shown to have any effect beyond placebo.
On that point, Rooth has this to say:
“When I first started exploring Reiki, I was surprised to find a number of studies that tested Reiki. Some of them were very compelling. In fact, from 1989 to 2018, a total of 74 peer-reviewed research articles have been published on Reiki. Of the higher quality studies, those comparing Reiki to a control “sham” form of Reiki or standard-of-care largely support the hypothesis that Reiki may reduce pain, anxiety, depression, and burnout and may increase relaxation and well-being.”
He then cites a couple of small studies. This is where the Mayo Clinic is truly delinquent. It’s one thing to soft peddle claims of making patients feel better. It’s another to misrepresent clinical science. That has negative effects beyond the topic at hand, and demonstrates a lack of dedication to the science of medicine that should be embarrassing for such an institution.
For context, perhaps the biggest question is medicine is how we know what works and what doesn’t work. This is the overarching question that defines any medical system. Starting around a century ago the medical profession became increasingly dedicated to the idea that the way to know what works is through high quality scientific research. Anecdotes, personal experience, and authority were not enough. This is when the era of scientific medicine truly began. In the 1980s the profession doubled-down on this approach with the advent of evidence-based medicine (EBM).
Since that time, however, there have been essentially two main forces at work within the medical profession. There are those who explore and promote increasingly rigorous standards of EBM, working out the kinks in the system to get to more and more reliable scientific conclusions and evidence based practice.
At the same time there has been an insurgent movement of “alternative medicine” which seeks to weaken the scientific standards within health care, to allow for “other kinds of evidence”. But in reality they are just promoting old-school medical pseudoscience by reverting to anecdotes and authority-based medicine. They are also exploiting some inherent weaknesses in the ways that EBM are conducted, such as insufficiently considering the role of scientific plausibility in calculations of probability. Promoters of alternative medicine have been quick to exploit the weaknesses in EBM.
This is exactly why we formed SBM, to fix the weaknesses in EBM, and to explicitly reject calls to go back to pre-scientific methods in health care and to weaken or in some cases even eliminate the science-based standard of care.
Reiki is a microcosm of this entire struggle. Here were have a practice based upon no foundational science. It is based upon magic and faith healing. Proponents have not established their basic claims, that the life energy exists, has any relationship to health, disease, or symptoms, and can be manipulated by practitioners. Instead they study subjective outcomes with small and poorly designed studies, the kind designed to generate false positive outcomes. But they have never established that Reiki works for anything, not so a reasonable scientific degree.
Reading the systematic reviews give a perfect summary of the weakness of the evidence and how exploitable EBM can be. They generally tout the positive outcomes, but then admit the weakness of the evidence buried deep in the conclusions. For example:
“To date, there are a small number of studies in each area, therefore findings are inconclusive and, more RCTs controlling for placebo in Reiki research are needed. Most included studies were also assessed as having a risk of bias of some concern.”
and
“It is recommended to conduct more randomized controlled trials with a high methodological quality that examine the effectiveness of Reiki application for patients with cancer.”
A better review comes from The Office of Science and Society at McGill University:
“The individual studies listed in this review, as well as most papers testing Reiki, are a teachable encapsulation of bad science. They often involve a single Reiki session with no follow-up; they test small groups, which leads to noisy data that can look positive by chance alone;”
We have only small poorly designed studies looking at subjective outcomes without any plausible mechanism. This is a poster child for alternative medicine. By promoting this practice, and a completely biased review of the scientific evidence, Mayo Clinic is planting its flag on the side of pseudoscience in medicine, and dealing a blow to the institution of scientific medicine.
They may not realize they are doing this. I suspect, as if often the case, we are again seeing a true believer promoting pseudoscience while the shruggies pay no real attention. The alternative is worse – that an institution like the Mayo Clinic, who stakes its reputation on clinical excellence, does not fully appreciate the role of science in medicine. Or perhaps they collectively don’t appreciate the philosophical battle that is happening in our profession – a fight over the proper role of science, over the standard of care, and the nature of clinic evidence.
None of these options are good. For an institution like the Mayo Clinic they are devastating.

Johrei: The next energy healing craze?
Johrei appears to be a flavor of reiki. Is it supported by better evidence? Of course not.
Jesse Luke on July 21, 2017
Link

Readers of SBM are sure to be familiar with reiki, a mystical form of energy healing that promises a plethora of cures and relief by allowing one’s own body to more efficiently heal itself through the manipulation of its vital energy field by a trained user. This miraculous “modality”, as it is often referred to by integrative medicine practitioners, was brought into being by Mikao Usui in 1922 – but only after he travelled to the top of a mountain in Japan and was imbued with this “gift” in a very Moses- and Jesus-like fashion. He wasn’t alone though…a very similar form of energy medicine called “johrei” is also being promoted, with about as much credibility and evidence.
Background: Where did johrei come from?
There is, of course, no proof that this vital energy exists or that humans have any ability to manipulate it. In fact, all methodologically sound, well-controlled studies have shown no evidence of efficacy beyond placebo. In concept, it is closest to a religious belief based upon pure supernatural delusion, and in practice it is an easy scam to pass off in exchange for payment through “healing” sessions and trainings, often under the nebulous label of “self-care”. Of course, reiki is far from the only energy healing practice; there are indeed a vast many that are both old and new. Most have, fortunately, not managed to be thrust upon mainstream medicine. Another one that has, though, is johrei, which has received substantial government funding, but has only one listed active clinical trial. Sadly, I was actually introduced to it in Hurst’s The Heart, a truly mainstream and respected medical text. If it’s worth taxpayer funding and mention there, it certainly deserves a skeptical evaluation here.
Like reiki, it was also invented in Japan, actually just a few years later in 1935 by Mokichi Okada (1882-1955). Okada, often called “the master of light” by proponents, by amazing coincidence also received his gift through revelatory enlightenment. This came after several failed business ventures, reportedly due to illness, banking difficulties, and an economic crisis. Luckily for him, johrei brought moderate fame and fortune. However to truly understand johrei one must appreciate that it is actually a part of a Japanese spiritual/ health movement.
The movement as a whole is sometimes referred to as a non-exclusive religion, and other components of the belief system include art appreciation, flower arranging, and organic gardening. Taken together, like much of CAM and IM, not one of these is based upon actual medicine or science. We already know that there is no benefit to organic gardening beyond the possibly relaxing act of gardening, as non-organic gardening aids such as genetically modified seeds and artificial fertilizers are clearly safe. Flower arranging could also be relaxing, but that’s it. Followers of the johrei movement do not see these practices as simple stress relief, but as a means to attain some form of spiritual enlightenment and steps on the path towards an earthly utopia.
Johrei theory and practice
Johrei is practiced in a way extremely similar to those of its relatives, reiki and therapeutic touch. The “giver” moves their hands over the body of the “receiver” in close proximity, but without physical contact. As with other forms of energy healing, the difference rests in the slightly different purported mechanism of action. In the case of johrei the goal is as follows:
Johrei is a spiritual practice based on the focusing of universal life energy, also referred to as “divine” or spiritual light. We believe that this action fosters positive changes to both the physical and the spiritual body and that it helps to eliminate suffering by dispelling negative energy.
The rhetoric above is common in CAM and IM and shouldn’t be surprising to most readers. All forms of energy healing are based upon spiritualism and mysticism; johrei, however seems to be more forthcoming about it, uniquely bold compared to its cousins. Direct mentions of God can be found in many sources, including the official website, where the following statement admits that the goal is not to treat disease (emphasis added):
Receivers often find that over time they experience spiritual growth, physical healing or increased blessings, according to divine will. We do not prescribe, nor do we diagnose or treat physical illnesses.
It is clear from the above statement that johrei could be immediately attractive to a large group of people, in both a spiritual and medical sense, because many people ignore the last line, seeing only what appeals to them. For those that are desperate in their medical and/or personal lives, there is often a desire to seek out anything that can offer a reprieve and some form of solace, whether or not there is proof or even a promise of success. There is, however, another group that finds johrei more attractive than its followers, although they love the followers as well. That group is, of course, integrative medicine practitioners. Their interest seems based more, as most of their interests are, on profit.
Johrei research
There are multiple red flags that suggest johrei has the propensity to reach the popularity level of reiki in IM in the next few years, and enough information to suggest it is already on its way. That offers too much chance of harm to both human health and the respectability of medical science to ignore, from a group that can’t decide if it’s medicine or not.
The Johrei Fellowship, by their own admission, has no interest in proclaiming remedies. In light of this, the following quote from the same site is curious and presents like orations of a politician (emphasis added):
Johrei has its roots in Japan, and is gaining recognition in the West as a non-invasive energy healing practice. It is a universal vibration that is available to all. The Johrei Institute was established in 1998 to prove the effectiveness of Johrei through scientific medical research and to fund accepted research work through universities.
The Johrei Institute is in fact controlled in part by the Johrei Fellowship, which make the above claims regarding johrei as a medical treatment contradictory. In addition, all listed researchers on the Institute’s website are staff members at the University of Arizona, whose integrative medicine department is headed by Andrew Weil. In fact, they are the only academic medical center in North America currently doing research on it (as far as I could find) which of course raises the specter of suspicion of the Institute that it may be, at least in part, another front for U of A’s integrative medicine center.
From 2002 to 2004 U of A also received four grants, totaling over 2 million dollars, from the NCCIH division of the NIH to fund the now-defunct “Center for Frontier Medicine in Biofield Science” (CFMBS) which has transformed into the “Laboratory for Advances in Consciousness and Health”. The aims of the grants and center were to study three energy healing methods: therapeutic touch (TT), johrei, and Qi-Gong. The main recipient for those grants and the current director of the center, Gary E. Schwartz, PhD, is listed at U of A as a professor of psychology, neurology, psychiatry, medicine and surgery —most of which are highly unusual positions to hold without a medical degree. In addition he has made quite the writing career from publishing books such as: The Afterlife Experiments, The Truth about Medium, and The Energy Healing Experiments, the last of which was based upon work done under the aforementioned grants. The reason for the book is stated on the website: “…the findings were again too controversial for mainstream journals.” Articles did, however, appear in several CAM journals.
Compared to reiki, the current published literature on johrei is not very extensive: a keyword search on Pubmed revealed only 19 results, some not even involving humans. The short list of results did not take away from the questionable nature of the studies with titles such as the following:
    • Johrei Effects on Water: A Pilot Study by Counting Drops
    • Effect of Spiritist “passe” (Spiritual healing) on growth of bacterial cultures
    • Johrei, a Japanese healing technique, enhances the growth of sucrose crystals
    • Effect of Johrei therapy on sleep in a murine model
The last study listed is cited as preliminary research that justifies a clinical trial, currently listed as active at the U of A, entitled: “Johrei Therapy and CBT-I in Facilitating Sleep in ICU Survivors”. In order to save readers the time and frustration I’ll summarize the two studies.
In the first, the murine (mouse) model on johrei and sleep was done in part by the principal investigator for the human trial, Sairam Parthasarathy, MD. The murine model consisted of splitting 45 mice into five groups and depriving them of sleep then measuring two types of reactive neurons in their brains and through EEG. The two groups reported in the abstract were those that did and did not receive therapy. The results, unsurprisingly, were positive for johrei (the groups in the full article showed little difference between them). Forgoing all the technical details and ways the numbers could be easily manipulated, I’ll note the largest problem, aside from being published in Explore: 45 divided by 5 equals 9 (did that all in my head). That, along with the difference being very small, suggests quite strongly that the results are simply noise.
The clinical trial has even more possible confounding factors. It is being conducted jointly by the Johrei Institute and U of A. Once again I don’t want to go too far into the technical details because enough flaws are apparent on the surface. The goal of the study is to examine the effects on sleep between two interventions for former ICU (intensive care unit) patients, in-person johrei done three times weekly, and internet-based CBT (cognitive behavioral therapy) done once a week, both at the patient’s residence, which must be in close proximity of U of A, Tucson. There are 50 subjects that range from 18-85 years of age who eligibly can, with very few exceptions (from the available information), have been in the ICU for any condition and have nearly any other co-morbidity. The only excluding criteria are: being considered too unstable, pregnancy, debilitating neurological disease that prohibits informed consent, not being discharged home, living more than 20 miles from U of A, and/or not having a reliable form of communication. The trial is obviously not placebo-controlled or blinded, and has many obvious problems that make it almost certain to garner a positive result.
Most glaring is the question of dose, if it can be called that. A brief CBT session done once a week over the internet with a psychologist seems non-comparable to home visits three times weekly by a johrei practitioner, for many reasons. Most apparent are the logistical and practical differences. These patients recovering at home are most likely going to be spending some time recovering at home, and (speaking from personal experience) that includes a lot of lying in bed. That alone can often cause insomnia due to lack of activity, both physical and mental. Having someone video chat with you for once a week is probably not going to do much (the duration of the session is not specified). In addition, there is no guarantee of patient compliance with the techniques that are often so critical to the success of CBT. The johrei arm on the other hand, is certain to have compliance because the act is done immediately and any other advice they give (trial-appropriate or not) is more likely to be adhered to because of a more intimate between patient and provider.
The mere event of someone coming to your home multiple times a week and being in a somewhat close proximity is also going to spur the mind and body into a more active state. More activity typically equals better sleep. Of course, there are also placebo effects to account. Patients will most likely be told flat-out about johrei and the “evidence” that it will help them sleep, making it sound like medicine. CBT and psychologists by their very nature rely upon the individual to do a large part of the work; there are no magic cures in the psychologist’s repertoire, only techniques and guidance that must be adhered to if they are to be effective. In addition, the responses to the therapy arms are intended to be measured through 12 different outcome measures. One can therefore imagine which arm is more likely to be adhered to and come out with a statistically positive result — which, it will be claimed, obviously calls for more research on the subject.
In addition, it may be possible that CBT was chosen not just because it is non-pharmacological, but because it is harder to measure objectively and makes it easier to tilt the results towards johrei. There are many drugs that are appropriate and safe for use by patients experiencing short-term insomnia (benzos, z-drugs, melatonin receptor agonists, etc.). If I noticed this fact, it is a fair assumption that the study designers did as well and chose what they felt would provide a more palatable result.
How to assess these claims?
When I evaluate a claim, almost any claim, I look at the source and base of the claim through the lens of logic and current scientific knowledge. If the claim seems logical and at least scientifically possible, then I look further into it to see how it stands up to stricter scrutiny. Johrei does not even make it past the starting point. There is no credible mechanism with which it could interact with a human body to exert effects, no reason to suspect its claims of divine providence are possible, nor that other components such as flower arranging could lead us to an earthly utopia.
The main supporters of scientific research on johrei do not inspire confidence either. Weil with his institute and Schwartz with his books are well known for trying to inject mysticism into every crevice of medicine they can find. An older video on the Tucson johrei fellowship page demonstrates scenes of johrei in practice and shows Weil in conversation with Dr. Michael Dixon, a GP and professor in England known for his promotion of CAM. Dixon has been criticized publicly by Edzard Ernst. Discussed by Weil and Dixon were how “sickness is purification”; that attitude towards cancer affects prognosis (it doesn’t); Mokichi Okada’s problems with western medicine; and how “amazed” Weil was that they were “spot on” and “exactly the same as the philosophy of integrative medicine”. My personal favorite is a common one I hear, that western medicine “doesn’t look for the cause of illness or pathology”. It does.
I personally try not to assume that just because a person has promoted wrong ideas that all their ideas are wrong. Yet the previous and ongoing research of johrei under the ultimate leadership of Andrew Weil, apparently with U of A blessings, just demonstrates to me again that he, through the integrative medicine department’s frequent boondoggles, rejects scientific reality in exchange for money or fame. Such research only helps him to fulfil his apparent desire to become the main Integrative guru at the expense of patients and the integrity of medicine.
Johrei, like other forms of energy healing, is clearly pseudo-medicine that wants to be accepted by mainstream medicine and real doctors. Although it has managed to receive money and limited support, it is still not widespread. This limitation should encourage skeptically minded individuals in all fields to keep it that way or minimize it even more. It is far easier to prevent a person from latching onto a delusion than to rip it away from them.

Adventures in defending science-based medicine in cancer journals: Energy chelation
David Gorski on January 30, 2012
Link
My co-bloggers and I have spent considerable time and effort over the last four years writing posts for this blog (and I for my not-so-super-secret other blog) bemoaning the infiltration of quackademic medicine into what once were bastions of evidence- and science-based medicine. We’ve discussed at considerable length reasons for why this steady infiltration of pseudoscience into medical academia has been occurring. Among other potential explanations, these reasons range from the ascendence of postmodernism in areas where it really doesn’t belong; to a change in our medical culture to a more “consumer”-oriented, “keep the customer satisfied”-sort of model in which patients are often referred to as “clients” or “customers”; to the corrosive influences of moneyed groups (such as the Bravewell Collaborative) and government agencies (such as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative medicine, a.k.a. NCCAM); to the equally corrosive influences of powerful woo-friendly legislators who use their position and influence to create such agencies (such as Senator Tom Harkin and Representative Dan Burton) and otherwise champion “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and “integrative medicine” because they are true believers in quackery; to cynical legislators, like Senator Orrin Hatch, who champions such government programs supporting pseudoscience because he represents a state that is home to the largest concentration of supplement manufacturers in the United States and is consequently a master at bringing any initiative to regulate the supplement industry more tightly to a screeching halt.
As a result of our efforts and the need for a counterweight to the quackery that has infiltrated so much of academia, SBM has become fairly prominent in the medical blogosphere. Our traffic is good, and we have a number of “thought leaders” who regularly read what we write. We’ve even caught the attention of Dr. Josephine Briggs, director of NCCAM, and our founder Steve Novella was even invited to appear on The Dr. Oz Show for “balance.” All of this is something that we are justly proud of. On the other hand, I can’t help but keep things in perspective. While our traffic as a blog is quite respectable and we have become prominent in the skeptical and medical blogosphere and even, to some extent, in academia—we’re particularly gratified at the number of medical students who are regular readers—compared to the forces arrayed against SBM in academia and the media, we have to face facts: We are truly a tiny voice in the wilderness. For instance, we average around 9,000 to 16,000 visits a day. Compare that traffic to the many millions who used to watch Oprah Winfrey and still watch her protégé Dr. Oz or to health media and product empires of people like Andrew Weil and Deepak Chopra, and you get the idea.
All of this is why I started looking for opportunities to respond more directly to incursions of pseudoscience into medical academia. Occasional SBM contributor Peter Lipson provided me with just such an opportunity last summer when he sent me a link to a brain-meltingly bad study about the use of CAM in cancer that shows just how bad a study can be and still be published in what I used to consider a reasonably good cancer journal. I say “used to consider,” because the fact that this journal accepted a study this ludicrous indicates to me that its peer review is so broken that I now wonder about what else I’ve read in that journal that I should now discount as being too unreliable to take seriously. Maybe everything. I don’t know. What I do know is that seldom have I seen such a bad study in such a good cancer journal. Studies like the one about Tai Chi in fibromyalgia or placebo acupuncture applied to asthma don’t even come close.
Soon after this study appeared online ahead of print, James Coyne contacted me and asked me if I wanted to be co-author on a letter to the editor of the journal. Honored by Dr. Coyne’s request, I immediately said yes (of course), and together with Dr. Christoffer Johansen at the Survivorship Unit of the Danish Cancer Society, we submitted our letter to the editor. To my surprise, given the utter failure of past efforts to publish letters to the editor about studies of this sort, our letter was accepted for publication. Last week, the study in question saw print, and our letter was published online ahead of print, along with the response of the authors. All are instructive and, to me, show just what we are up against in trying to prevent pseudoscience from creeping into academia.
The study: “Energy chelation”? I kid you not!
No doubt at this point, some of you are thinking that perhaps I’m being way too harsh when I called this study “brain-meltingly bad.” That is why, even though Peter has already discussed this paper, I feel obligated to describe the study and my objections to it at some length. So let’s dig in, shall we? The journal is Cancer, which is the official journal of the American Cancer Society and has an impact factor of 5.131. That is, as we say in the biomedical research biz, not too shabby. The investigators are from the Samueli Institute (which, as you might recall, published a recent survey on CAM adoption by hospitals), the University of California San Diego, the RAND Corporation, and Healing Light Center Church, and the paper is entitled Complementary Medicine for Fatigue and Cortisol Variability in Breast Cancer Survivors A Randomized Controlled Trial.
Fatigue is a huge problem in cancer patients, and this study was designed to test the effect of what the authors call “biofield” therapies on fatigue in 76 breast cancer patients with significant fatigue during chemotherapy. For purposes of this study, “biofield” therapies were defined to be more or less the same thing as energy healing, which encompasses reiki, therapeutic touch (TT), healing touch (HT), and others. In actuality, from a strictly scientific standpoint, the experimental design of this study wasn’t half-bad. The problem comes from how this study examines a therapeutic modality for which there is no evidence, namely something the authors call “energy chelation.” (I kid you not. That’s actually what they call it! In an actual scientific paper!) To sum up the study in a nutshell, this was a phase 2 randomized, intention-to-treat clinical trial that compared biofield healing (“energy chelation”) with a “mock healing” control and a waitlist control.
Never having heard of “energy chelation” before and having written a lot about chelation therapy as a form of quackery claimed to be useful as a treatment for autism caused by “vaccine injury” and for cardiovascular disease, I was very curious. So I read with interest how the authors described this modality:
The specific technique used in the biofield healing group is termed energy chelation, and was selected by 1 of the authors (R.L.B.), whose healing techniques have been incorporated in modalities such as Healing Touch and Therapeutic Touch.26,27 During energy chelation, the practitioner practices hands-on healing with standard hand positions, beginning with hands on the feet, then to the knees, hips, bladder area, stomach, hands, elbows, shoulders, heart, throat, head, and back to the heart. The practice of energy chelation is 45 to 60 minutes, with a practitioner generally focusing for 5 to 7 minutes on each position.
Naturally, my next question was: Who is “R.L.B.”? R.L.B., it turns out, is Reverend Rosalyn L. Bruyere from the Healing Light Center Church. I did some Googling and found her quickly enough. On Bruyere’s website, she is described thusly:
Founder and director of the Healing Light Center Church, Reverend Bruyere has committed her life to the teaching of these sacred and ancient disciplines, thereby providing her students with practical tools for living the spiritual life, while introducing them to the venerable traditions from which those tools are derived. Her goal is to encourage the compassionate healing and empowerment of the individual, believing that as we each heal, we can be of greater assistance in the healing of the world.
She is the originator of the whole-body technique known as Chelation which has become a classic, taught in many modern healing schools, as well as Brain Balancing and a pain-reducing skill which some have called Pain Drain.
Her book, Wheels of Light, A Study of the Chakras, is an invaluable text for the bridging of ancient and modern healing arts. Rev. Bruyere has studied extensively in areas of Egyptian temple symbology, Sacred geometry, ancient Mystery School rites, international shamanic practices, the pre-Buddhist Tibetan Bon-Po Ways, and various Native American Medicine traditions.
Rosalyn’s knowledge of ancient traditions and practices has led to requests for her technical assistance on several films and documentaries. Among the more notable features on which she has served as technical consultant are “Resurrection” and “The Last Temptation of Christ”.
Although I don’t recall having blogged about “Brain Balance” before, fortunately Harriet Hall already has and quite correctly concluded that it is “based on speculation, not on credible evidence.” Pain Drain is an HT technique in which the “practitioner” holds one hand above an area of complaint until the pain recedes and then places the other hand near the area of relief. In other words, it’s yet another variant of “energy healing” modalities like TT and reiki. As for energy chelation, I Googled that as well and found quite a few links describing it. For instance, here is a Q&A by a healer named Kay Morris Johnson, who charges $65 an hour for her energy chelation (righteous bucks for waving your hands around people) and ensures us that it “works by moving heavy or stagnated energy, once this movement takes on a transformation then your whole body system reacts similar to downloading, accepting the changes in your energy field into your physical being” and that there is indeed detoxification with energy chelation (much like real chelation, I would imagine). She even gives a helpful primer on the difference between energy chelation and reiki:
Reiki is best use for general consistent work to maintain your energy whole field balance. Energy Chelation is best applied to detailed energy needs in defined areas of one energy field. Energy Chelation also has different vibrations associated with it, such as sound energy. Sound Energy is described as a deep vibration and is very effectively use on areas of old stagnate energy, such as childhood issues. These old issues are stubborn dense often times large energy blocks that require that extra boost of vibration to initiate movement.
Well, that’s useful. Reiki is faith healing in which the person being healed is usually not touched but the practitioner believes that he’s channeling healing energy into the patient from a “universal source,” while energy chelation “hands on” energy healing. They’re totally different! Really!
Another website helpfully proclaims the “physical reality on which human energy chelation therapy is based” as:
Human Energy Chelation Therapy (HECT), a process of transmitting or channelling energy, is based on the electromagnetic nature of the human body. The body’s electromagnetic or auric field is generated by the spinning of the chakras. As it spins, each chakra produces its own electromagnetic field. This field then combines with fields generated by other chakras in the body to produce the auric field. An individual’s auric field is manifested via a combination of energies from three chakras. Generally these are the first, third and fifth chakras, which empower the person’s physical, intellectual, and etheric bodies. It is a combination of these three chakras that produces the primary auric field (the inner shell of the aura), which can be physically felt by the therapist’s hand as it is passed over the client’s body in the process of scanning.
And where does energy chelation get its name? Here’s an explanation:
Heavy metals are toxic to the human body. Chelation has been a tried and true method in removing them from the body. The toxins must be removed before the body can benefit from any health promoting actions.
Stuck emotions are very similar to heavy metals in that they too are toxic to the body, mind and spirit. Healthy emotions are energy in motion. However when emotions are stuck, not acknowledged, stuffed and ignored they become like heavy metals and are toxic to the human system. They need to be removed before health-promoting actions can produce beneficial results. Just like chelation removes heavy metals from the body, energy chelation is a method which removes sticky, heavy dark energy from the human energy field.
Is “sticky, heavy dark energy” anything like the long, dark tea-time of the soul? It rather sounds that way to me. In actuality, it might as well be, because energy chelation is every bit as much a work of fiction as anything ever written by Douglas Adams, except that Douglas Adams had far more imagination. In any case, it amuses me to no end when CAM advocates start using metaphors as names for their nonesense. Be that as it may, the next question I had, after learning that energy chelation is “hands-on energy healing” was what the control group would be. In other words, what, exactly, was “mock healing”? Here is a description of the mock healing control group taken straight from the Methods section of the paper (yes, this is verbatim):
Mock healing practitioners were skeptical scientists who were trained to use the identical hand placements as biofield healing practitioners. Mock healing practitioners were asked not to intend to heal the patient when touching, but rather to disengage into “planning mind” by contemplating current and upcoming research-oriented studies and grants they were currently involved in. Given that biofield healing practitioners would have more familiarity with working with patients than mock healing practitioners, to preserve participant blinding mock healing practitioners practiced procedures with study personnel until the mock healing practitioner demonstrated mastery of the hand placements and confidence interacting with and fielding potential questions that a patient might ask the mock healing practitioner before or after the session.
It never ceases to amaze me how science drives out magic; even practitioners of energy chelation seem to accept that. After all, if they didn’t, then why would they have chosen the control group that they did and gone to all the trouble to train scientists to put their hands on people in the same positions that Rev. Bruyere uses while thinking extra super hard about how they don’t believe any of this nonsense? In actuality, it’s not a bad control group–if you accept the premise of the study. What is that premise? It’s that there is a human energy “biofield” that healers using “energy chelation” can manipulate to therapeutic intent and that there has to be a degree of belief for that to work. I do like how that evil “planning mind” (as opposed, I suppose, to a “believing mind”) can destroy the magical rays that supposedly heal by chelating all that bad energy. In any case, this is exactly what Harriet Hall meant by “tooth fairy science” when she wrote:
We can study the amount of money left by the Tooth Fairy in different settings, but since we haven’t determined that there is really a Tooth Fairy, any conclusions we reach will be falsely attributed to an imaginary being rather than to the real cause (parental behavior). In acupuncture studies, the acupuncture points/meridians/qi may be imaginary and we may be studying an elaborate placebo rather than a real physiologic phenomenon.
It has not been established that such a thing as a “human energy field” (at least not what “energy healers” mean by the term) exists, that humans can perceive and manipulate it, or that that perception and manipulation of energy fields allows them to heal. In fact, it’s about as clear as clear can be that humans can’t, as a 12-year-old girl named Emily Rosa demonstrated so clearly back in 1998.
So, after all that introduction, what were the results? What do you think they were? I’ll give you a hint. These results were entirely consistent with placebo responses. Basically, there was no difference in total fatigue levels between biofield healing and mock healing. Both produced a decrease in fatigue that patients on the waitlist control did not. In other words, for the primary outcomes measured in the study “biofield” therapy didn’t work compared to the “mock healing” placebo control. So, given this completely negative result, what did the authors do next? They did what any good CAM believer does (and, for that matter, all too many scientists do) and started mining the data for associations, delving into the Multidimensional Fatigue Symptom Inventory short form subscales. Not surprisingly, they found barely statistically significant differences between biofield healing and mock healing in a couple of measures, as is frequent whenever researchers start making a bunch of pairwise comparisons. They also measured salivary cortisol levels and found a significant decrease in cortisol slope over time for the biofield healing versus both mock healing and control. What this means, I have no idea, given that salivary cortisol “variability” (which they calculated) hasn’t been validated as a reliable diagnostic tool for much of anything that I’m aware of or correlated with fatigue.
I’m not impressed. Here’s why. First, I can’t help but note that none of these differences were mentioned in the abstract, which implies to me that even the authors didn’t consider them particularly significant. More importantly, we have multiple comparisons among small groups of patients. (Remember, there were only 76 patients in this study.) Finally, fatigue is a variable symptom that waxes and wanes frequently. it’s very prone to regression to the mean, placebo responses, and reporting bias. It’s very hard to say a lot about whether these barely detectable differences in a couple of subscale measures are in any way clinically significant. Probably not. Not that that stops the authors from laboring mightily in the discussion section to make it sound as though their biofield therapy is the greatest thing since sliced bread. Let me ask you a question whose answers regular readers of SBM should know: What do we normally call it when there is no difference between the real treatment and a sham treatment in a clinical trial testing a drug or device? That’s right. We say there’s no effect greater than that of a placebo and that the trial is negative; i.e., the tested experimental intervention doesn’t work.
Not this study:
This RCT examined whether biofield healing, compared with both active (mock healing) and waitlist control groups, positively affected fatigue as well as cortisol slope, depression, and QOL in breast cancer survivors with persistent fatigue. In addition, this study explored the role of belief in receiving healing as a potential predictor of responses. Findings indicate that both touch-based interventions reduce fatigue in fatigued breast cancer survivors, with considerable effect sizes. Previous research by our group on a separate sample of breast cancer patients indicated that the mean Multidimensional Fatigue Symptom Inventory-short form total scores was 5.99 immediately before the start of anthracycline-based chemotherapy, and rose to 19.9 immediately before the fourth cycle.38 Our fatigued survivors in the mock healing group (mean postintervention score ¼ 10.9) dropped to fatigue scores lower than those found for breast cancer patients toward the end of chemotherapy, and the biofield healing group (mean postintervention score ¼ 4.2) fell to fatigue scores that were below prechemotherapy scores, as well as below previously published means noted for breast cancer patients overall.28 This drop in fatigue appears to have clinical as well as statistical significance.
In other words, according to the authors, because both the “real” biofield healing and the “mock” biofield healing resulted in a decrease in fatigue scores and a barely statistically significant difference in a chosen surrogate marker, biofield healing “works.” This is the same sort of dubious rationale frequently used to claim that acupuncture “works” when they find that sham acupuncture results in the same apparent measured effects as “real” acupuncture. The correct interpretation of this study is that it’s a negative study, and “energy chelation’ does not work. It is placebo. Stick a fork in it; it’s done. Or, as Drs. Coyne, Johansen, and I wrote in our letter:
The registered primary outcomes of the trial were self-reported fatigue, depressive symptoms, and quality of life. No significant differences were obtained between TT and the mock treatment, whereas both conditions were superior to waitlist control. Essentially, the authors examined 3 primary outcomes, with secondary analyses of 5 subscales of the fatigue measure, and a secondary outcome, cortisol, with all pairwise differences explored between the TT, mock treatment, and waitlist control conditions. With any control for multiple comparisons, the modest difference between TT and mock treatment in cortisol is no longer significant.
And:
There is no known therapeutic benefit to changed cortisol slopes. To justify cortisol as a secondary outcome, the authors selectively cite findings that flatter cortisol slopes are modestly related to metastatic disease and predict mortality in breast cancer patients. These limited correlational data alone do nothing to establish that cortisol is a suitable surrogate endpoint.
We concluded that this trial is negative, something I believe to be even more true when one takes into account prior probability and the lack of correcting for multiple comparisons, which led us to wind up our letter thusly:
We believe that publication of this TT trial encourages more pseudoscientific studies of energy fields or auras and gives the wrong message to clinicians and patients.
The authors respond
Not surprisingly, the authors were not too happy about our letter. Even less surprisingly, in their response they retreated to common tropes used by apologists for reiki and “energy healing.” Their response to our letter is a veritable template for defending tooth fairy science. First, the authors tried to disabuse us of our “misconceptions” about the study by pointing out how very wrong we were to lump “energy chelation” in with HT, TT, and reiki as an “energy healing” modality:
We wish to clarify some misconceptions put forth by Coyne, Johansen, and Gorski regarding our reported randomized controlled trial.1 First, the intervention used was not therapeutic touch but a specific hands-on technique commonly used in many types of biofield therapies for ameliorating fatigue.
Which matters not at all. It was the authors, after all, not we, who said that energy chelation was a biofield therapy, which is another name for “energy healing.” In any case, their complaint reminds me of arguing that reiki is different from TT because reiki masters use different hand motions to channel the “healing energy” or that in reiki the energy comes from the “universal source” while energy chelation removes “energy blocks” in the patient. Until you can convincingly demonstrate that the “universal source” exists and can be manipulated by reiki masters and/or that there are “energy blockages” that “energy chelation” practitioners can remove, all you’re doing is comparing two different forms of magic. Alternatively, you can demonstrate with overwhelming indisputable evidence so powerful as to make us question previously understood laws of physics indicating that these techniques cause objective responses, but unfortunately for the authors of this paper this study does nothing of the sort. We’re looking at effects no greater than placebo on primary endpoints in the study, all of which are subjective responses, and an unvalidated surrogate endpoint that demonstrates a barely statistically significant effect (p=0.04), after no correction for multiple comparisons. In other words, the authors’ criticism completely misses the point.
Here’s their next objection:
Second, there is an evidence base for biofield therapies.2,3
The authors cite this Cochrane Review and one of their own reviews. The problem with this argument, of course, is at the very core of the reason why we call this blog “science-based medicine” rather than “evidence-based medicine.” There is no consideration of prior plausibility in the studies examined, where were all over the place as far as quality goes. Add to what the Cochrane Review characterizes as poor quality, equivocal data the fact that the clinical trials involved testing a class of healing modalities whose explanation if effective would require, like homeopathy, that huge swaths of well-established physics, chemistry, and biology (particularly neurobiology) to be overthrown, and the reasonable conclusion is that “biofield therapies” do not work. In particular, this is a case where “statistically significant” doesn’t mean “clinically significant,” given that the decrease in pain reported in the Cochrane review was less than 1 unit on a typical pain scale that goes from 1 to 10. One unit has commonly been viewed as the smallest decrease in pain that a patient can perceive.
Objection number three follows:
Third, the study was designed to examine nonspecific and placebo elements that may drive responses: This is why we used the mock healing group as a comparison along with the waitlist control group. We also examined patient expectancy, belief, and patient ratings of practitioner attributes all elements of placebo as potential predictors.
So what? It was the authors who concluded against the evidence in their very own study that, in essence, their “energy chelation therapy” works to relieve symptoms of chemotherapy-induced fatigue even though the “real” energy chelation and the “mock” energy chelation were indistinguishable. The correct conclusion should have been that energy chelation performed no better than placebo and therefore did not work. Again, if energy chelation were a drug therapy, would the authors conclude from a result in which the drug does no better than placebo for the primary outcome measures that the drug worked? Why the double standard?
Up next, is this objection:
Fourth, despite Coyne et al.’s seemingly contradictory statements (stating that the study is underpowered while also suggesting cortisol slope results should have been Bonferroni corrected), the power analysis and statistics are correct and clearly described.
“Contradictory”? I fail to see what’s “contradictory” in pointing out that the study was underpowered and that the cortisol slope results should have been Bonferroni-corrected; i.e., corrected for multiple comparisons. They are separate criticisms. Even if the study were adequately powered, it would still be flawed because of the lack of correction for multiple comparisons. At least if the authors had properly corrected for multiple comparisons then they could have blamed their negative result on the inadequate statistical power of the study!
Finally, the authors write something that both amused and depressed me at the same time:
The larger issue is what constitutes “pseudoscience” and what information is worthy of dissemination to the public. Should the data from our well conducted, rigorous, randomized controlled trial be dismissed because the mechanisms are unknown or because some scientists do not believe in the specific therapy? We make no claims surrounding mechanisms. We do note that this intervention has significant promise for reducing fatigue, which is the most common complaint among cancer patients, and the therapy produces no harm. Therefore, it merits further investigation. Premature rejection of findings from rigorous randomized controlled trials are as big a threat to science as the continuation of falsehoods based on belief. Thus, as clinicians and scientists, our highest duty to patients should be to investigate promising solutions with high benefit/risk ratios, not to act as gatekeepers of information based on personal opinion.
There’s so much wrong in this paragraph that I could spend an entire blog post deconstructing it line by line. Note the wounded cry about “dismissing” results based on dogma rather than science. Note the straw man argument that we reject the results of this study because we “do not believe in the specific therapy” or because the “mechanisms are unknown.” The first trope is a massive misstatement of our objections. What we argue is that the results of this trial do not mean what the authors think they mean. The authors conclude that the trial indicates that energy chelation shows “significant promise.” (They even repeated that assertion in their response!) We conclude that the study’s own results indicate that energy chelation functions no better than placebo and therefore does not work. It would have been nice if the authors had addressed our actual criticism than such an easily revealed straw man version of it. The second trope is commonly used in defense of pseudoscience because it is difficult for many to understand that there’s a huge difference between a mechanism that is “unknown” and a mechanism that is physically impossible based on current scientific understanding. An example of the former is a drug whose mechanism of action is as yet unknown but whose effects are easily documented. We know that the drug must function through some sort of biochemical interaction with a receptor, enzyme, or other macromolecule within the cell that we can discover and that we do not need to invoke mechanisms that break the laws of physics and chemistry to explain the drug’s effects. Again, to illustrate the difference between such a drug and impossible mechanisms, I like to use the example of homeopathy, which, if it worked would necessitate the overthrow of huge amounts of exceedingly well-established science in multiple disciplines, including physics, chemistry, and biology. Let’s just put it this way. Energy chelation is the same. For it to “work,” the same sorts of vast quantities of well-established science would need to be overthrown.
As a skeptic, I have to admit that it’s certainly possible, albeit infinitessimally so, that so much of what we understand about science is not just wrong and/or incomplete, but so incredibly wrong and/or incomplete that there might be an as yet undiscovered physical mechanism by which energy chelation and “biofield therapies” could work. However, if you’re going to convince me that something like energy chelation can truly work as a treatment modality, you’d better have evidence far more compelling than a small, equivocal clinical trial like this in which the effect on primary outcomes was no greater than placebo and whose analysis of secondary outcomes didn’t even bother to correct for multiple comparisons. Heck, even Dr. Pasche’s data that I discussed last week was far more compelling than this study, and his results are still not particularly convincing. Bringing a study like this “energy chelation” study to argue that “biofield therapies” work (or even that they might work) is akin not just to bringing a knife to a gun fight. It’s akin to bringing fists to an M2 Browning machine gun and grenade fight.
And that’s not just our “personal opinion,” either. Of course, it’s far easier to dismiss criticisms that one can somehow label “personal opinion” than it is to address our actual criticisms. That’s probably why the authors try to characterize our objections to their study as nothing more than a disagreement of opinion, before floating off into the ether of a self-righteous and condescending lecture to us about our “highest duty” as clinicians and scientists. I retort that, as clinicians and scientists, it is our highest duty not to engage in magical thinking that subverts science-based medicine. It’s our highest duty not to waste precious resources investigating therapies so utterly implausible that their efficacy requires that the laws of physics be overturned in favor of magic. It’s our highest duty to base our treatments in science, not in prescientific vitalism and religion, which is all that most “biofield” therapies are: faith healing, the laying on of hands. I would also retort that our tax dollars should not be funding magic like this. Yes, you guessed it; this study was funded in part by NCCAM.
As I conclude, I’m left wondering, jaw agape: What were the editors of Cancer thinking? I know what I’m thinking now: From now on, I’m going to be extra skeptical of any articles I see in Cancer, and you should too. I’m also depressed. If such a study and such a trope-laden response to criticism of that study can find its way into Cancer, the official journal of the American Cancer Society, what other cancer journals are publishing pseudoscience?
REFERENCES:
     1.  Jain S, D Pavlik, J Distefan, RR Bruyere, J Acer, R Garcia, I Coulter, J Ives, SC Roesch, W Jonas, and PJ Mills (2012). Complementary medicine for fatigue and cortisol variability in breast cancer survivors: A randomized controlled trial. Cancer 118: 777-787. DOI: 10.1002/cncr.26345
     2.  Coyne JC, C Johansen, and DH Gorski (2012). Letter re: Complementary medicine for fatigue and cortisol variability in breast cancer survivors: A randomized controlled trial. Cancer, E-pub ahead of print. DOI: 10.1002/cncr.27415.
     3.  Jain S, D Pavlik, J Distefan, RR Bruyere, J Acer, R Garcia, I Coulter, J Ives, SC Roesch, W Jonas, and PJ Mills (2012). Response re: Complementary medicine for fatigue and cortisol variability in breast cancer survivors: A randomized controlled trial. Cancer. E-pub ahead of print. DOI: 10.1002/cncr.27421.
     4.  So PS, Y Jiang, and Y Qin (2008). Touch therapies for pain relief in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev CD006535. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD006535.pub2

   Pseudoscience Sells
Steven Novella
Link
It is an unfortunate truth that there is money in pseudoscience, particularly medical pseudoscience. Money both attracts charlatans and also funds their activities, which includes marketing pseudoscience and defending their claims from scientific scrutiny. In this way the game is rigged in favor of pseudoscience.
With0ut effective regulation, sites like ours are forced to play whack-a-mole with the medical pseudoscience du jour. The latest case in point is Titanium Ion Bands – which are just another version of the Power Balance bands that have been previously exposed as nonsense. The idea is that by wearing a small bracelet on one wrist you will experience improved athletic performance. This sounds impossible – because it is. But companies have successfully bamboozled enough of the public to rake in millions.
The marketing strategy is three-fold. First, get naive professional athletes to endorse the product. Second, give live demonstrations (deceptive parlor tricks) that convince the unsuspecting that something must be going on. And third, wow the scientifically illiterate with a confusing barrage of medical techno-babble. The combination is sadly effective.
Power Balance, for example, makes vague references to frequencies and energy as the explanation for how a little piece of rubber (with embedded holograms) can have any effect on human physiology. The company was eventually legally forced to admit: “”We admit that there is no credible scientific evidence that supports our claims.” The admission has not ended their sale, however.
Next up is the Titanium Ion Bands. Their claims are essentially the same – wear a little bracelet on your wrist and you will have improved performance. Instead of holograms and frequencies, their bands are alleged to work through negative ions. This is just another recycled pseudoscientific claim that has been around for years. Just search on “negative ions” and you will see a variety of products claiming to improve health with negative ions.
The bracelet claim is nonsense for two independent reasons. The first is that a piece of anything does not generate negative or positive ions. You cannot change the net electrical charge spontaneously – you need a source of energy. The only devices that actually generate negative ions are powered in some way, such as a machine that you plug into an outlet. A chemical reaction, such as occurs in a battery, is also a possible source – but not tourmaline and titanium discs, as the company claims.
Even if the bracelets did give off negative ions, there is no evidence of any healthy benefit from this. You might build up a static charge and get shocked when you grab the doorknob, but there is no evidence or reason to suspect that negative ions will increase blood flow, as the company claims. “Increasing blood flow” seems to be the go-to explanation for a wide variety of dubious health products, especially for those that involve magnets or any kind of electrical force. Such claims, however, are evidence-free.
The company touts “reports” of their own “inspections” using fancy technology like thermography to demonstrate their claimed effects. It’s all very sciencey, while being scientifically worthless. None of the proper controls are in place to make the information anything other than a marketing demonstration, similar to the parlor tricks used by Power Balance.
On the company website there are links to celebrity endorsements and testimonials – but no links to published peer-reviewed quality research backing up any component of their claims.
Conclusion
There is every reason to believe that these titanium bands are medically worthless. However current regulations allow the company to market them with deceptive health claims without the burden to provide reliable scientific evidence to back up their claims. The endless chain of such products will continue as long as the lax regulations allow them to.
At present the best we can do is to continue to educate the public about the underlying science and to be skeptical of all such products. Further, we can pressure pharmacies and other outlets not to sell pseudoscientific products. Further, there are mechanisms to force companies to retract deceptive or unsupported claims for their products. It is a game of whack-a-mole, but it’s better than nothing.

Another EMF Scam
Pulsed EMF for microcirculation is dubious on every level.
Steven Novella on December 13, 2023
Link

Electromagnetic (EM) waves are real, and living organisms are electrical on some level. Electrical and magnetic stimulation is also used in legitimate medical diagnostic and therapeutic interventions. But it is also true that dubious health claims for magnetic fields or electromagnetic waves is a two century old snake oil scam. Magnetic fields seem like magic and advanced science at the same time, and they also seem gentle and non-invasive and yet there is a whiff of plausibility to them. This is a perfect formula for snake oil.
I wrote previously about pulsed electromagnetic fields (EMF) and some of the dubious claims made for them. Another questionable product has come to my attention, the BEMER blanket (based on the more general BEMER effect, for “Bio-Electro-Magnetic-Energy-Regulation”), or BEMER mattress. You can find complaints online about relatives dropping $6,000 for a mattress that will claim all the usual alternative medicine vague claims, but most specifically to increased “microcirculation”. There are many red flags for a dubious CAM product, starting with the fact that it is sold as an MLM product, with customers becoming distributors.
The basic claim is that pulsed electromagnetic fields increases microcirculation – blood flow through capillaries and small vessels. Also, it is supposed to increase white blood cells circulating in the blood. The “increases circulation” claim is always a red flag, as it is a common one with snake oil products. The history of this claim and BEMER also does not fill me with confidence. But let’s review what is published first.
BEMER, proposed by Dr. Rainer Klopp from Germany in 1998. In the last 25 years there has been precious little published about the technique, which is suspicious in itself. What few studies I can find are preliminary, of low quality, or just negative. For example, this is the only study I could find addressing the core claim, of increased circulation. They compared cutaneous blood flow as measured by doppler in healthy subjects, with one leg being treated with the BEMER blanket and the other leg serving as a blinded control. The one good thing about this claim is that it is really easy to blind, with a placebo blanket that simply does not emit EMF. They found:
Comparing both groups, the measurement values during the experiment did not differ (p > 0.05) except for higher flow values in the control group (P = 0.03). Over time, baseline values of both groups showed no significant difference (p > 0.05).
There was no difference in the two groups. This is pretty damning evidence against the core claim of the BEMER effect. Of course, there is often statistical noise in such studies, and in this case the control group had higher blood flow. So if anything BEMMER decreased blood flow in this study, although I doubt this is a real effect.
For clinical applications, there is also a double blind placebo controlled trial of BEMMER treatment in fibromyalgia – dead negative.
Bemmer blankets are also sold for horses, and I found one study looking at potential physiological measures in horses. They found:
After two weeks of treatment, although not statistically significant, hematocrit (%) measured immediately post exercise was lower in horses undergoing BEMER® treatment (48.30% ± 3.21) than both No blanket (51.15% ± 3.57) and Placebo blanket (49.58% ± 5.77). While wearing BEMER® blanket and after treatment, horses had a lower LF/HF ratio compared to other groups, although this difference was not statistically significant. These results possibly suggest an effect of BEMER® therapy on vagal activity and relaxation.
This is also dead negative – no statistically significant difference. But they try to spin non significant trends as meaning something. LF/HF refers to low frequency/high frequency, which refers to heart rate variability. This is dubious itself, in my opinion. This does not mean there is nothing to heart rate variability, but it is a noisy system easily exploited to create the false impression of a result, and the significance of LF/HF ratio is “controversial”.
There are a few other studies, mostly small and looking at subjective outcomes. A clear pattern is that the objective outcomes measures are always negative. There is not much to show for a treatment that has been around for 25 years. The studies are mostly preliminary, small, pilot studies, with the best studies being negative. And yet the claims made for the BEMER products are glowing and expansive. This is a clear pattern of pseudoscience.
The company also makes some red-flag questionable claims. First, they refer to the “BEMER Institute”. Some good detective work tried to track down this institute, and found that it didn’t exist. The “Institute” was simply Dr. Klopp, with the various addresses being given over the years was simply his address. There was never any research labs or hard infrastructure – it was entirely a virtual entity. The “institute of one” is a common feature of such dubious claims, making them seem more legitimate than they are.
BEMER also claims that they are collaborating with NASA, and explicitly state that this proves the legitimacy of their technology. They claim they are developing a space suit with NASA to improve the health of astronauts. However, I could find zero mention of this collaboration on the NASA website. There is no NASA press release announcing the collaboration (which is standard procedure for NASA). Just like the “institute”, this collaboration with NASA seems to be a “phantom”. In my experience, what organizations selling snake oil have done in the past is use some superficial relationship with NASA – giving a lecture, for example – and then portraying that as NASA endorsing their claims. NASA, however, appears completely silent on BEMER.
Some distributors of BEMER also claim that their products are “FDA Approved”, although the BEMER website is more accurate in saying that it is “FDA cleared”. We have discussed this as well – the FDA “clears” medical devices, which simply is verification that they are not directly harmful to patients. That’s it. They are not going to short out and deliver a fatal shock to the user. There is no requirement for any evidence of efficacy, and the FDA is not making any claim at all about the underlying technology and the medical claims. But most consumers don’t know this, and they are encouraged to interpret “FDA cleared” as if it means the FDA has signed off on the clinical claims.
The BEMER technology, the idea that pulsed EMF somehow increases circulation, and the clinical claims for its products have all the red flags of pseudoscientific snake oil. What little clinical research there is also displays a pattern of results very familiar to SBM – consistent with the null hypothesis, that the claims are not true. Certainly no one has scientifically validated the claims with high quality and reproducible clinical research. You will also notice that BEMER remains on the fringe, surviving in the world of CAM, without gaining mainstream acceptance – because the claims are dubious and the evidence is lacking.

Bioptron: Too Silly to Write about
Bioptron is a silly device claiming to work through unproven means, but basically seems to be an extremely colorful flashlight.
Harriet Hall on December 28, 2021
Link

A correspondent from Friends of Science in Medicine in Australia sent me information about the Bioptron, suggesting it would make for a colorful article. Their organization has succeeded in getting it removed from Australia’s Therapeutic Goods Administration listings but, to our shame, it’s still available in the US. She points out that “devices with FDA numbers give companies like Bioptron an easy ride, around the world!” It seems customers are interpreting Bioptron’s 510(k) number as an endorsement of its effectiveness. It’s no such thing! The 510(k) designation only means that the company made a premarket submission intended to show that the new device is substantially similar to another device on the market. It does not imply that the device is effective for anything. It is colorful indeed, but just too silly to write about. There is no science to critique; in fact, it is completely out of touch with reality. It’s based on pure imaginative fantasy.
Despite it being too silly to write about, I’m a sucker for silliness. It makes me laugh and illustrates the foibles of human psychology. How could anyone fall for this product? If it’s not a scam, it’s a great imitation; and I don’t believe the people who sell it could actually believe their own extravagant claims. So I wrote about it. When something is too silly to write about, it’s too silly to read, so feel free to stop reading. There is no science here, but it may have entertainment value. If you want to have a laugh, you can visit the Bioptron website.
They say “The indications [sic] for use is [sic] “in providing temporary relief of minor chronic neck and should[sic] pain of musculoskeletal origin“. The grammatical and other errors are typical of the often incoherent writing. The company claims to have TGA (Therapeutic Goods Administration) approval in Australia. That’s wrong. It was listed (twice) with the TGA but both times it was de-listed because of multiple complaints.
In the US, the Bioptron is promoted by All Nature’s Ways, whose list of treatments offered reads like a textbook of everything wrong with alternative medicine, including homeopathy and even zappers! I urge you to click on that link; you will undoubtedly encounter some alternative treatments you weren’t aware of. It was the first time I had heard of many of them. That same link lists an astounding array of conditions they think they can treat. And the tab for “clinical studies” consists of nothing but testimonials and case reports.
Bioptron is even recommended as a treatment for COVID-19.
Bioptron is an energy medicine device intended to balance your chakras and do all sorts of wonderful things. The chakras are color-coded and supposedly are affected by light of the proper color. They claim it is supported by extensive research – in Switzerland – but I don’t believe it has ever undergone a controlled scientific test. By “research” they don’t mean what I mean by “research”.
You can buy the whole package on EBay for $649 or a single lens for $104.
As I said, just too silly! Just looking at the images should be enough to discourage potential customers:
        ◦ If you believe in chakras, how do you imagine they figured out which chakras corresponded to each color? Imagination is the key word here. And colored bullshit is an apt description.

Radioactive 5G Pendants
Authorities had to warn the public not to use radioactive products to protect against harmless 5G.
Steven Novella on December 22, 2021
Link

What’s the best way to protect against the non-existent risks of harmless non-ionizing radiation? With harmful ionizing radiation, of course.
The Dutch authority for nuclear safety and radiation protection (ANVS) had to issue a warning to consumers about ten products they found contain low levels of radioactive material. These products include the Energy Armor sleeping mask, the “Quantum Pendant”, and the Magnetix Smiley Kids Bracelet with negative ions.
What I find most puzzling is this – if you are going to market useless products to the scientifically illiterate through baseless fears, why make them do anything? Take a page from the Power Balance scam and just make your magic devices out of harmless rubber or plastic. If you want to get blingy then copper is always popular, and if you want to juice your sales by having the product actually do something, just use harmless refrigerator magnets.
But why would a company use actual radioactive material? Do they think their customers carry around Geiger counters and that dangerous radioactivity will impress them? Selling radioactive products is actually illegal. In most countries, selling worthless medical scams is surprisingly not. There is a level of sociopathic con-artist in scams involving ionizing radiation – especially if you market it as a “Smiley Kids Bracelet”.
The level of radioactivity in these products is quite low. They don’t contain plutonium. But they do contain radioactive materials in sufficient amounts that they are significantly above the background level of radiation (the threshold often used to determine safety). The AVNS calculates that these products could cause harm if they are worn continuously over a long period of time, such as a year. Of course – that is exactly how these products are intended to be used. The claim is that they block out allegedly harmful 5G radiation (which is actually non-ionizing and harmless). In order to gain this protection you are meant to wear the bracelets or necklaces continuously and indefinitely. This is where low levels of ionizing radiation can become dangerous – with close proximity over long periods of time.
Radioactive elements are not completely banned from consumer products. That would not be practical, as many substances contain traces of radioactivity. Even bananas, which are high in potassium and a small percentage of potassium exists in radioactive isotopes, are radioactive. According to the EPA: “Each banana can emit .01 millirem (0.1 microsieverts) of radiation”. You would have to eat 100 bananas in order to get the background level of exposure to radiation in one day.
Ceramics are another common source of radiocative isotopes, usually in the glaze, which can contain small amounts of uranium, thorium, or potassium. Usually this is below background levels, and therefore harmless. However, famously, one company created a Fiesta ware line of dishware that contained high levels of uranium oxide in the glaze, enough to potentially cause harm, especially from leaching of the uranium into food. These glazes were banned in 1972, but some of the vintage Fiesta ware is still around.
Other consumer products require small amounts of radioactive isotopes to work. Smoke detectors contain a small amount of americium, which is necessary to their function. However, they are contained and far enough away in normal use the increased exposure to consumers is essentially indistinguishable from zero. Still, you should not tamper with a smoke alarm in such a way that it risks breaching the casing around the americium.
There are also other radioactive snake oil scams. In 2019 I wrote about “energy cards” from Thailand that were found to contain dangerous levels of radioactive substances. The cards were claimed to “boost” the immune system and improve metabolism – typical vague alternative medicine claims. Even inert substances can be harmful when packaged with misleading or entirely fake medical claims, and encourage belief in pseudoscience and distrust of medical science. It’s a doubly whammy when the products are directly harmful, as in this case.
Prior to regulation, radioactivity was directly marketed as a healing elixir. Soon after radioactivity was discovered, it became the latest gee-whiz scientific phenomenon, which made it a ripe target for exploiting the public. This is similar to what happened with magnetism a century earlier, and radio waves later in the 20th century. Today the latest cutting edge science that con-artists exploit to sell their snake oil is anything “quantum”. The difference with radioactivity is that it is actively harmful. It took the FDA banning radioactive products to remove them from the marketplace (dying slowly of radiation poisoning was apparently not enough).
This latest crop of radioactive snake oil is also a scam because it is meant to protect against the alleged risks of 5G, which is a lower energy electromagnetic radiation. 5G is in the non-ionizing range, which means that it does not have enough power to break ionic bonds. It therefore cannot damage DNA, which is the primary mechanism by which low levels of ionizing radiation cause harm. Of course high levels of ionizing radiation can kill cells outright, causing more immediate death (not just an increased risk of cancer years later).
I already reviewed the evidence for the safety of 5G, and older 4G and 3G technology. But here is a recent review of the literature published in Nature. They concluded:
The epidemiological studies showed little evidence of health effects including cancer at different sites, effects on reproduction and other diseases. This review showed no confirmed evidence that low-level RF fields above 6 GHz such as those used by the 5 G network are hazardous to human health.
This has not stopped fearmongering about potential health effects. This is mostly based (when it is based on something) on pre-clinical studies looking at possible biological effects. However, potential biological effects generally cannot be replicated in the research, and also generally do not rule out non-specific effects from local heating. In other words, there is a lot of noise, but no detectable signal. But the noise is great fodder for those wishing to confuse and scare the public about 5G in order to promote conspiracy theories or sell bogus products.
        ◦ In some cases those products may contain actual harmful radiation.

Radioactive Energy Cards
Thailand officials warn of a radioactive snake-oil “energy card.” It’s worse than worthless – it’s actively dangerous.
Steven Novella on June 19, 2019
Link

We are always careful to point out that inactive does not equate to harmless when it comes to fake medicine. Even a product that is completely inert, like most homeopathic potions, causes harm in numerous ways. They divert attention and resources away from more effective treatment, may delay proper treatment, cause financial and psychological harm, may endanger species or the environment, and instill pseudoscientific beliefs which lead to further menace.
But it is true that fake treatments which are capable of causing direct harm are even worse. In this way doing nothing is a small virtue. I was reminded of this when reading about a new medical scam in Thailand – Energy Cards.
The cards are credit-card sized and are claimed to do all the usual things: “The distributors claim these cards can improve the immune system, strengthen the heart and energise the user’s metabolism. The (sic) also claim the card can purify water if it is briefly soaked in it.” The ability to purify water may seem a bit unusual, but remember clean water is a luxury in much of the world. The cards sell for either $35 or $50 equivalent.
That is bad enough, and puts the cards in the same category as the magical power wrist bands, or the plastic cards alleged to improve the taste of wine. But these energy cards are worse than worthless. They are actually radioactive. The Thailand Office of Atoms for Peace (OAP) recently put out a PSA on the danger of the cards. The OAP (I suspect something is lost in translation) is essentially their atomic energy regulatory agency. They research and regulate the peaceful use of nuclear science. They warn:
Tests on sample cards conducted by the state agency found radiation measuring at 40 microsieverts per hour, which is 350 times higher than the maximum exposure humans should get to radiation a year.
The agency also warned against drinking water in which an “energy card” has been dipped, as doing so raises the risk of cancer. It said OAP would take legal action against the distributors once it has gathered enough evidence from its tests on the cards.
So far, tests have revealed that the cards contain radioactive metallic elements of uranium and thorium, as well as their “radionuclide” or radioactive isotope.
Let’s put that amount of radiation into context. First, I think the “350 times higher” is a mistake. If someone is exposed to 40 microsieverts per hour for an entire year, that results in 350 millisieverts (mSv) total exposure. I think that’s where the “350” comes from. The recommended limit of radiation exposure is 100 mSv per 5 years. So that is 17.5 times the recommended maximum exposure. Another way to look at this is that you would reach your 5-year radiation exposure limit in 104 days of continuous exposure. 100 mSv is also the lowest annual dose that has been clearly shown to increase cancer risk. This means that long term exposure to these cards (from keeping it in your wallet, for example) could lead to unsafe levels of radiation exposure.
For further comparison, normal background radiation results in about 3.65 mSv of exposure per year, so the cards result in about 100 times greater than background exposure. A chest X-ray results in 0.1 mSv exposure. A full body CT scan – 10 mSv.
But it gets worse, because these cards may also be a source of radioactive contamination. Radioactive exposure simply means that radioactive particles passed through your body. Someone or some thing exposed to radiation, however, is not themselves radioactive. Radioactive contamination, however, results from exposure to particles that are themselves radioactive. The OAP is warning that these cards, which contain uranium and thorium, may result in contamination. This significantly increases the hazard they represent.
Radioactive contamination can get into one’s environment and then result in ongoing exposure to radioactivity. If it gets in the water (as recommended by the company selling the cards) or into food, then the contamination can be consumed and become internal, which is much more risky. Further, these cards can release radioactive contamination into the environment, causing further exposure and contamination of food and water supplies.
The OAP further reports that these cards are being sold through a pyramid scheme, which is not unusual for snake-oil distributors.
The obvious question is – why would the company bother to make their cards with actual uranium and thorium? And how did they source these radioactive elements? Other reports indicate that the cards also contain heavy metals.
The company selling the cards, Expert Pro Network, sells other supplements with dubious claims. They claim the cards work through “negative ions”. It is further reported that:
Surin, a former police officer, claims to have begun selling the cards after he acquired them from La Genius.
La Genius was a Malaysian MLM company that has since collapsed. The cards themselves are reportedly of Indonesian origin, but also contain the words “German Technology” on them.
So it may be difficult to track down their origin, but I suspect the OAP is working on it. Perhaps the creators of the cards thought that the radioactivity would be a selling point, because the cards are giving off actual “energy”. This was actual a common form of snake oil around the turn of the last century, soon after radioactivity was discovered. There were radon infused waters, radium containing pendants, and thorium and uranium containing medicines. People extolled the curative powers of these radioactive tonics, all the while slowly killing themselves with radioactivity. These products did not disappear from the shelves until the FDA banned them in 1938.
I guess the lesson here is that if you are going to scam people with worthless snake oil, you’re better off making it completely fake, rather than radioactive.

   CFLs, Dirty Electricity and Bad Science
Steven Novella
Link
Governments and environmental advocates are promoting compact fluorescent lightbulbs (CFLs) as a way of reducing electricity use, saving money, and reducing our carbon footprint. CFLs are not a perfect technology – when turned on they take a moment to fully brighten and they contain a small amount of mercury which requires special procedures for disposal. CFLs are likely also to be a transitional technology, as more energy efficient light sources (such as LEDs) are already coming onto the market. But CFLs are a safe and energy efficient alternative to incandescent bulbs.
It seems, however, with any new technology comes a wave of internet fearmongering, and CFLs are now a prime target. YouTube videos are circulating claiming that CFLs cause headaches, mercury toxicity, a host of symptoms from electromagnetic sensitivity, and something called “type 3 diabetes.” Let’s take a look at the claims and the science.
Mercury in CFLs
There is a small amount of mercury in each CFL, necessary for the function of the bulb, about 4mg on average, with some newer bulbs having as little as 1.4mg. There is no exposure to mercury from using CFLs, as long as they are not broken. Even if a bulb is broken the exposure to mercury is negligible, far less than eating a tuna fish sandwich. But still, there are recommended procedures for cleaning up and disposing of a broken bulb to further minimize exposure, such as not using a vacuum, and ventilating the area. These procedures represent the cautionary principle in action, but make it easy to fearmonger about the risks of the mercury in the bulb.
According to an EPA study, only about 30% of the mercury in a CFL is released as vapor after breaking, and this occurs over a 4 day period. So a broken bulb would have to remain in a poorly ventilated area for days to reach this kind of exposure. Ventilating the room and quickly cleaning up a broken bulb is enough to reduce exposure to negligible levels.
The amount of mercury that CFLs put into the environment is actually less than the amount of mercury put into the environment by burning coal for the electricity they save. Therefore, the net effect of using CFLs is to reduce environmental mercury.
While technology that does not require the use of any toxic material is always preferred, the small amount of mercury is CFLs is not a health or environmental risk and should not discourage their use.
Ultraviolet Sensitivity
Another claims is that CFLs put out more ultraviolet light and this can cause skin reactions in those who are sensitive. Those with lupus erythematosis, for example, need to avoid exposure to UV light. It remains uncertain, however, what risk, if any, is posed by indoor lighting. Published research is mostly theoretically, concluding that indoor lamps, including CFLs generally have very low levels of UV radiation, but that long term exposure could potentially lead to a cumulative effect.
However, direct comparisons show that CFLs put out less UVA than incandescent or halogen bulbs, while putting out more UVB radiation. Further, there are CFLs available that are shielded and put out the least total UV light of all options.
For the average user, UV radiation from indoor lights does not appear to be a concern. For those with skin sensitivity long term indoor exposure may be a concern, in which case they may want to use a bulb with lower UV radiation output. There seems to be more variability within bulb types than between them, but the best option is shielded CFLs.
Headaches and Flicker Rate
There are claims that CFLs cause headaches. These claims likely stem from two sources, the first being that headaches are common. Just about every drug in existence lists headaches as a side effect, at least in a few percent of users. This is recognized as just background noise because headaches are so common. But also, older fluorescent lights (the long tubes, not the compact variety) did have a flicker of about 60 hz, and this is noticeable by some people and could cause headaches. The newer bulbs, however, use a different technology (electronically ballasted vs magnetically ballasted) and cycle at about 10,000-40,000 hz, which is not detectable. There is also no published evidence linking use of CFLs to headaches.
Dirty Electricity
The major health claim being made against CFLs, however, is that they put out “dirty electricity” which can allegedly cause a variety of health problems. There is now a video circulating on Facebook making such claims. Fear of dirty electricity goes beyond CFLs – the new bulbs are just the latest target.
Much of this seems to stem from one Canadian researcher, Dr. Magda Havas. She has dedicated her efforts to studying and warning the public about the health risks of electromagnetic radiation for years. She has become the go-to expert for the media, and her name crops up in almost every article on the subject.
This is unfortunate, because she appears to be a lone dissenting voice (some might call her a lone crank), who is often put up against the consensus of scientific opinion as if they were two equal experts. Most articles I read on the subject essentially say – some experts say electromagnetic radiation is safe, but some say that it is causing health problems, and inevitably Magda Havas is that latter expert. Meanwhile, she has published very little research, and no good research, to support her controversial claims.
For example, Havas is now talking to the media about “type 3 diabetes” as if it is a proven and accepted entity. She claims that exposure to electromagnetic radiation (including CFLs) can increase blood sugar. Her evidence is one published study, which is nothing more than a case series of four patients. Exposure to electromagnetic radiation (EMF) was often estimated (for example, assumed from working in front of a computer or using a treadmill) and not measured. There was no blinding at all to the exposure to EMF and measurement of blood sugars.
Case reports and case series are generally considered to be the weakest form of scientific medical evidence. They are one notch above anecdotes. They are used to propose new ideas for further study, but not to form conclusions. In my opinion it is irresponsible to talk to the media about the results of such research as if they demonstrate a new phenomenon. It is premature and misleading.
Regarding EMF in general, The World Health Organization recently reviewed the literature on non-ionizing radiation and found:
In the area of biological effects and medical applications of non-ionizing radiation approximately 25,000 articles have been published over the past 30 years. Despite the feeling of some people that more research needs to be done, scientific knowledge in this area is now more extensive than for most chemicals. Based on a recent in-depth review of the scientific literature, the WHO concluded that current evidence does not confirm the existence of any health consequences from exposure to low level electromagnetic fields. However, some gaps in knowledge about biological effects exist and need further research.
Unfortunately, in popular summaries of the issue I often find that this exhaustive expert review of 25,000 studies is put up against – the opinions of Magda Havas – with the conclusion that “the experts disagree” therefore, who knows?
What about CFLs specifically? They do indeed put out more EMF in certain frequencies than incandescent or halogen bulbs, but there is no evidence that this level of EMF poses any health consequences. Further, one thing is absolutely clear – EMF falls off sharply with distance. Even after a couple of feet the EMF put out by light bulbs falls from tiny by many orders of magnitude to negligible. The EMF intensity at a distance of inches (as shown in the Facebook video) is irrelevant.
Conclusion
The notion that EMF or dirty electricity causes a health risk, and that CFLs are a significant source of exposure, is not based upon any compelling science. Further, such claims stem mostly from a single researcher who appears to spend most of her time spreading fear about EMF than producing quality research. The media and the public should not be confused by this lone researcher on the fringe into believing that “experts disagree.”
Rather, while there is always room for more research, there is already extensive evidence for the safety of non-ionizing radiation. Special cases, like long term (>15 year) use of cell phones, where the source of EMF is held right up to the skin, are still under investigation.
Exposure from EMF in the home, from light bulbs and other sources, pose no credible health risk. The media needs to do a better job of putting claims for health risks into the proper scientific perspective.

Quack Book Reviews: EMF*D
Über-quack Dr. Joe Mercola recently published a book claiming that 5G is the cause of all manner of health problems. Unsurprisingly, it’s full of bad science, pseudoscience, and unproven claims.
Braden MacBeth on June 1, 2020
Link

[Note: I was, unfortunately, unable to complete a post for today due to a situation that came up over the weekend. I will definitely be back next week, though. Sorry about that. Fortunately, we have this post from Braden MacBeth ready to go.– David Gorski]

Dr. Joe Mercola recently released a new book titled EMF*D: 5G, Wifi & Cell-Phones and How to Protect Yourself. Given the author, I felt compelled to give it a preorder. Major telecom companies started rolling out 5G networks in select cities throughout 2018 and 2019, and much larger expansions are expected this year. 5G can offer up to 100x times the speed and a 50th the latency compared to 4G networks. While 5G does use some new technology, it isn’t particularly interesting. But Mercola argues in EMF*D that 5G networks, Wi-Fi, and other non-ionizing radiation can cause serious health effects. So I’m going to point out how why he’s wrong, and what he’s really trying to sell readers.
That’s not how this works, that’s not how any of this works.
EMFs from cell phones, Wi-Fi routers, and 5G networks cannot cause anyone and negative health effects. So in the first chapter Mercola uses the oldest trick in the book to try and convince readers that EMFs could harm them, by teaching them the science at a basic level so when he lies about the science at a higher level, he seems truthful. The first chapter titled “Understanding EMFs” begins with an explanation of EMFs you would find in any basic science textbook. Electromagnetic waves are vibrations between an electric field and a magnetic field, and they have a strength based on the frequency with which they oscillate. EMFs with a high enough frequency such as X-rays, ultraviolet rays, and gamma rays carry enough energy to ionize atoms. When this happens in the human body it can cause mutations in DNA that can lead to cancer.
EMFs with lower frequencies such as the radio waves in your cell phones, very-low frequency waves in Wi-Fi routers, and extremely-low frequency waves in power lines and electronics, are non-ionizing and can’t harm you. Mercola gives a fairly decent explanation of these concepts. He then proceeds to lie and claims that these lower frequency EMFs are actually ionizing and cause DNA damage through a “different mechanism”. Ionizing radiation from high frequency EMFs causes DNA damage through a variety of different mechanisms, but the one Mercola focuses on is the generation of hydroxyl free radicals. A hydroxyl free radical is a highly reactive oxygen species that has lost an electron, and can mess with basically every chemical structure in the human body. Mercola states:
It’s true that non-ionizing radiation, by definition doesn’t have enough energy to break the covalent bonds in your DNA, or produce hydroxyl free radicals that do the same. However wireless radiation results in DNA biological damage that is nearly identical to the harm caused by ionizing radiation. It just it in a very different way that very few people are aware of. Non-ionizing radiation from your wireless devices actually creates carbonyl free radicals, instead of hydroxyl radicals that ionizing radiation gives rise to that causes virtually identical damage to your nuclear DNA, mitochondria, proteins, cell membranes, and stem cells.
Now, there are multiple levels of stupid to be appreciated in this statement. Mercola acknowledges that non-ionizing radiation doesn’t have the energy necessary to create free radicals. Then he proposes mechanism that involves the generation of a carbonyl radical through… ionization! So the statement debunks itself, but it’s so much worse. The generation of a carbonyl radical isn’t a hidden mechanism nobody knows about, it’s called a Norrish reaction. Guess what kind of radiation gets to generate the carbonyl free radical used in a Norrish reaction? Ultraviolet light.
It gets worse when he begins to talk about electricity in a section titled “Understanding the Importance of Pulsed vs. Non-pulsed EMFs”. He begins by explaining the difference between alternating current and direct current. Alternating current is pulsed at a set frequency and travels both directions in a circuit, while direct current travels in one direction in a circuit continuously. Mercola argues that the electric grid should be run on DC power because the human body can tolerate DC power better than AC power because…? I personally haven’t touched any power lines recently and cannot confirm, and I’m not looking to try. To back up this very odd statement he claims:
In fact, when there are variations of more than 20 percent in the Earth’s natural magnetic field during magnetic storms or geomagnetic pulsations that occur due to changes in the solar activity cycles, there are increased rates of animal and human incidents, including nervous, and psychiatric disease, hypertensive crises, heart attacks, cerebral accidents, and morality.
Wat. He cites two books written in 1977 and 1978, both apparently written by Russian parapsychologists, which are available on Amazon for 70 dollars each and probably don’t support what he’s saying. I was unable to find any study that even vaguely resembles what he’s talking about in a credible journal. There is no identifiable mechanism through which low-frequency EMFs can harm you, but Mercola is perfectly happy to make up complete nonsense that ignores basic science to make it seem that way. The question is, if you already paid $12 for the book, what’s he trying to sell you?
The hustle: Dirty electricity
Everything Mercola does is meant to sell you something, whether it be something he sells directly or something someone else pays him to promote. EMF*D is no different, and tries to sell you products that prevent the generation of “dirty electricity”. Mercola defines “dirty electricity” as “all electrical and magnetic fields from any frequency above 50/60 Hz”. He claims that dirty electricity occurs as transient pulses when AC current is converted into DC current and can have a frequency as high as 100 kHz. He can’t be talking about transient voltage surges from lightning or EMPs, which cause outages. I don’t know what he’s talking about and he probably doesn’t know either. Mercola never really gives any further explanation what the health risks of dirty electricity are or any evidence that it actually exists.
According to Mercola, dirty electricity is everywhere; it’s created by cell phone towers by the ton, computers, monitors, and TVs. The reality is that “dirty electricity” isn’t real, and it’s a term created by grifters to scare people into buying their junk. Mercola suggests later in the chapter that you should purchase “dirty electricity filters”. What do these filters actually do? Nothing, but Mercola references a study where researchers installed “dirty electricity filters” into school classrooms and asked them about their well-being and their students behavior with and without the filters installed. 55% of teachers reported improved symptoms, and 18% reported worsening symptoms including frustration, irritability, and fatigue.
The results of the study are interesting because it shows that if you design your study poorly enough, you too can statistically significant results (see the Hawthorne effect). Dirty electricity isn’t a real thing so the installation of “dirty electricity”, or filters for it, would have no effect on any problems teachers may be experiencing. The questionnaires sent out to teachers had a very poor response rate and only 18 of the 55 teachers responded enough times for their responses to be considered in the results. The study concludes:
This preliminary study needs to be repeated in other schools. If the Graham/Stetzer filters are as effective as they appear to be, then the dirty electricity in schools, homes, and offices can be reduced until other methods are in place to minimize the production and distribution of this form of electrical pollution.
Before we get too ahead of ourselves and start doing that I feel like there’s a few key pieces of context that we should understand. The brand of filters used in the study are from a company called Stetzer Electric, and they link directly to Magda Havas’s website. I’m just saying there’s probably a conflict of interest here. Furthermore, putting these filters in schools not only would be a colossal waste of money, it could also cause a lot of schools to burn down. According to a report in The Daily Examiner, one of these devices caught fire in someone’s home and the electrician who looked at the device described it as “a ticking time bomb”. This report bothered Dave Stetzer so much that he felt the need to put up a notice on his site:
Please be advised that false and fraudulent allegations have recently been posted on the internet against Stetzer Electric and its STETZERiZER products. Stetzer Electric has brought a lawsuit for defamation, fraud and intentional misrepresentation against the individuals making these statements.
The bottom line is that these products are a scam, and could potentially be dangerous. Dirty electricity isn’t a thing, and the fact that Mercola tries to sell you on it is enough reason to never take anything he says seriously.
5G isn’t going to kill us all.
The second chapter of EMF*D is titled “5G: The Biggest Health Experiment Ever”, as if health is something one considers when downloading cat videos at lightning speeds. Mercola states that the real risk in 5G is that 5G uses extremely high frequency radiowaves also called millimeter waves (MMW), which are in the 30 to 300 GHz range on the electromagnetic spectrum. Mercola doesn’t provide any reason why this presents and health risks, there aren’t any. MMW radio waves are already used in many devices such as space telescopes, police radar guns, and security scanners. MMW, like the radiowaves used in other technical devices, have no negative health effects (not to mention being longer than, and therefore less energy than, the visible light you are bathed in every day and are using to, you know, read this article). But Mercola, counter to common sense and basic physics, argues otherwise in EMF*D, makes tons of absurd claims about the risks of 5G including causing cataracts, cardiac arrhythmia, pain, suppressed immune system function, and my personal favorite: Thanos snapping 40% of all insect life on the planet out of existence.
For example, Mercola cites a study claiming that up to 80% of people can detect the presence of MMWs on their skin. Both studies he references are published in predatory journals, and I was unable to find a full text of either. Mercola also claims that MMW’s can caused increased electrohypersensitivity particularly in postmenopausal women. I find this claim interesting, since electrohypersensivity isn’t a real medical condition. Unfortunately there is a small set of people who are convinced that they are sensitive to EMFs. However they are attributing symptoms to EMF exposure when in reality their symptoms are caused by something else or aren’t attributable to any medical condition. A study conducted for the Swedish Radiation Safety Authority found that people who claim to be EMF-sensitive have physical symptoms, however the symptoms are not correlated with exposure to EMF radiation and may occur because of the conscious expectation of such symptoms. Mercola makes so many claims about the health risks of 5G and EMFs I literally can’t debunk them all or this post would be longer than the book itself. So just as a catch-all I’m going to state that there’s no plausible mechanism through which 5G cell networks could harm you. 5G is significantly different than 4G from a technical standpoint. 5G networks will have a much higher download speed, lower latency and require different technology to deploy. But otherwise, they’re using the same physics to do the same job, just using a slightly different part of the electromagnetic spectrum.
Non-Solutions to Non-Problems
Since Mercola’s book is dedicated to trying to prove that EMFs are going to irreversibly harm you, he has to give sell his readers something they can do to reverse the “damage”. Mercola claims, in short, that the damage done to your DNA from EMFs can be repaired by PARP enzymes and PARP enzymes consume a very large amount of NAD+. This will cause a deficiency of NAD+, which is required for lots of other processes in your body, and these deficiencies will cause cell death. Fortunately, Mercola has simple solutions to increase your NAD+/NADP levels like getting enough sleep and reducing your EMF exposure. However, my personal favorite recommendation he makes is to get more molecular hydrogen (H2), which inhibits NADPH oxidase increasing the level of NADPH in your cells. How can you get more molecular hydrogen you may ask?
According to Mercola, there are many ways to take hydrogen therapeutically but many methods are ineffective. Fortunately Mercola sells hydrogen water tablets on his site, which he claims create molecular hydrogen when you dissolve them in water. There are a few problems: the tablets don’t create molecular hydrogen in water, molecular hydrogen isn’t a proven treatment for any medical condition, and you don’t even have a NADPH deficiency to begin with because EMFs from electronic devices won’t hurt you. Molecular hydrogen isn’t hard to make, it’s just that generally it involves doing things like running electric current through water (irony!), or adding stuff to water and heating the mixture at very high temperatures and pressures to generate hydrogen gas. The ingredients in Mercola’s tablets include: Magnesium, Dextrose, Malic Acid, L-Tartaric Acid, and Adipic Acid. What does all of this stuff do? None of the ingredients would cause a reaction that would generate a chemical reaction yielding molecular hydrogen. It would just dissolve in the water and give it a slightly tart taste. His tablets are a scam, they don’t even create molecular hydrogen, and wouldn’t provide any health benefits if they did.
Finally, Mercola recommends taking niacin supplements to increase the levels of NAD+ in your body. Unless you have a deficiency in niacin deficiency (pellagra), which has really obvious symptoms, you don’t need to take niacin supplements. You certainly don’t need to take niacin supplements because of NAD+ deficiency from DNA damage from EMFs. EMFs used by cellphones don’t cause DNA damage, and that’s not how this works; that’s not how any of this works. If your cells were really low on NAD+, they can just make more NAD+ through de novo synthesis. NAD+ is a necessary cofactor to make a lot of metabolic reactions work. It’s like coffee in the break room: you kill the joe, you make some mo.
Mercola also makes a number of suggestions for how to prevent dangerous EMF exposure. Mercola highly recommends hiring “EMF specialists” to come to your home and look through your electrical wiring to identify problems that cause strong electromagnetic fields to be created. If that’s too expensive for you, you could buy an EMF meter for $200-400 to identify sources of EMF exposure in your home. I think, much like computer programming, it’s a bad idea to mess with the electrical wiring in your home as long as it works. While there probably is some sort of oddity in your home’s wiring that makes no sense that could be fixed, if it works, don’t mess with it. The best outcome is you’ll rip up your home for no benefit. At the worst you could electrocute yourself or knock out the power to half your home and will be relegated to showering at the YMCA for the next 2 months.
Mercola also recommends making some technical changes to your home network. Mercola recommends switching your entire home over to Ethernet. The problem with this is that it’s pretty rare to find a home with the wiring supports this unless you want to run really long Ethernet cables all throughout your house, or have all of your devices in one room. You could hire someone to wire your home this way, but it’ll cost you a lot of money. The only benefit to Ethernet over Wi-Fi is if you are super worried about consistent network performance.
Now my personal favorite suggestions that Mercola makes in this chapter are for if you really need to use Wi-Fi or your cell phone. If you must use Wi-Fi and are still wanting to reduce your EMF exposure, you can buy an EMF-shielding mesh cloth or box to wrap your router in to reduce the EMF levels. Think about this for a minute. Wireless routers work by emitting EMFs, if there are no EMFs, there is no signal. If the mesh reduces the EMFs the router emits, you will have to stand closer to the router to get the same level of signal to connect to the router. So these products are scams, regardless of whether or not they actually reduce the amount of EMFs emitted by the router. There are many more suggestions that are even more ridiculous but at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter. The EMFs emitted by your home’s electrical wiring and your devices are harmless, the science is clear. There is nothing to be worried about.
Conclusion: Counterfeiting reality
5G/EMF conspiracy theories have been on the rise as seen in the most recent COVID-19 5G conspiracy Dr. Gorski debunked recently. These sorts of ideas on social media have already pushed conspiracy theorists to attack 5G towers because they believe the towers cause the coronavirus. These EMF conspiracies used to be a lot more niche, but that’s not the case anymore. Last October, Scientific American allowed a guest Joel M. Moskowitz titled “We Have No Reason To Believe 5G is Safe“. While skeptics might be aware Scientific American has been to editorial rigor what Velveeta is to cheese as of late, the average person is going to assume that there is some level of truth to Moskowitz’s claims by virtue of his opinion piece being in Scientific American. There isn’t any level of truth to Moskowitz’s claims, EMFs from electronic devices have no health effects.
Books like EMF*D, articles on news sites, fake experts, and EMF safety organizations all contribute to this illusion that there’s this “other side” to a debate about the safety of 5G or EMFs. If they’re able to convince people that EMFs from routers and telephones can cause health effects, these people will begin attributing subjective symptoms to these benign radiowaves. They will look to these websites and their surrounding communities for support, and will buy what they are selling. Taken to the extreme, they will uproot their entire lives. In the Netflix’s Afflicted series, one woman was convinced that moving to a national radio quiet zone in Green Bank, West Virginia was the only way she could find relief for her symptoms.
People like Mercola want to make people feel as though they have to keep track of all the EMFs they’ve been exposed to and look for ways to reduce their exposure. They want to turn people into hypochondriacs and social outcasts. Mercola’s advice for carrying a cell phone is to place it in airplane mode or a Faraday bag, both of which defeat the purpose of having a cell phone. A phone in airplane mode or a Faraday bag cannot make or receive calls, you won’t even receive notification that you received a call or a text until you take it out of airplane mode. I’ll never claim to be an expert on dating or social interaction, but I don’t think people want to hang out with someone when making plans means a 2-3 day game of phone tag every time. It also makes it hard to go out to lunch with your friends when you spent all of your money on $200-a-bucket EMF shielding paint or ripping up your home’s electrical wiring for no reason. EMFs from electronic devices can’t hurt you, sometimes you can just have a good thing in life without wondering what serious health problem it’s going to cause you down the line.
While EMFs from cell phones and other electronic devices don’t cause negative health effects, the information that those EMFs carry can cause people to do things that result in harm. While there has always been and is always going to be Internet misinformation, I don’t think it’s controversial to say that Internet misinformation has had an unprecedented negative influence on our society over the past 5-6 years. This isn’t a technical issue or an issue with tech companies not wanting to fix it. These websites operate on a scale that companies can’t police without spending more than they actually make, crazy that may seem. However, these companies should step in more when things get out of hand (or ideally before).
When it’s proven that books, videos, articles, and posts are created in bad faith and perpetuate misinformation that can harm people, they should be removed. When users are trying to scam other users, they should be banned. Mercola is a perfect example of a user posting in bad faith. He pitches at least 10 products to readers in this book that are all based on health misinformation. Mercola has over 250,000 followers on Twitter, and recently peddled nebulized hydrogen peroxide as a treatment for COVID19. Users like this aren’t adding value these sites, they remove value from these sites. If you can’t take anyone’s information at face value on Twitter without wondering if the user is a snake oil salesman or a bot, are you going to use these sites as much? Of course not.
So Amazon please, remove EMF*D from your store. You’ve already done a lot of good by removing documentaries such as Vaxxed, and Cancer Can Be Killed and that has had a hugely positive impact even if the effects aren’t apparent. It’s clear you don’t want information that can harm people on their store, so why not make it a rule? Amazon has entire page dedicated to restricted products not already specified in the terms of services; why not add products that perpetuate flagrant health misinformation and health conspiracy theories to that list? Conspiracies like the ones presented in Mercola’s book have already done enough harm, you’re just clearing junk off your store.
EMF*D isn’t uniquely terrible compared to other books and documentaries I’ve reviewed, but it’s by far the most cynical. It’s not enough to sell people ineffective, unproven treatments for health conditions they do have. Mercola has to take it a step further and try to convince people whatever random aches and pains people might feel on a regular basis are attributable to the roll-out of 5G cellular networks, or Wi-Fi in order to sell them junk. 5G won’t cause any negative health effects to anyone except maybe if you use 5G to access Mercola’s websites or books.

Scientists Sign Petition Warning about EMF
A petition signed by 250 scientists warns about wireless technology, but the science is not on their side.
Steven Novella on March 13, 2019
Link
Headlines range from: “Are AirPods and Other Bluetooth Headphones Safe?” to “Wireless headphones could ‘pump radiation into your brain and cause cancer.’” They are referring to a recent petition from EMFScientist.org to the World Health Organization (WHO) and signed by 250 scientists.
The spokesperson for this petition (at least the person I am seeing as most quoted) is Jerry Philips who is on the scientific advisory board for a group called Physicians for Safe Technology. The petition warns about the health risks for non-ionizing radiation from wireless devices, that current regulations and research are inadequate, and makes the following requests:
     1.  children and pregnant women be protected;
     2.  guidelines and regulatory standards be strengthened;
     3.  manufacturers be encouraged to develop safer technology;
     4.  utilities responsible for the generation, transmission, distribution, and monitoring of electricity maintain adequate power quality and ensure proper electrical wiring to minimize harmful ground current;
     5.  the public be fully informed about the potential health risks from electromagnetic energy and taught harm reduction strategies;
     6.  medical professionals be educated about the biological effects of electromagnetic energy and be provided training on treatment of patients with electromagnetic sensitivity;
     7.  governments fund training and research on electromagnetic fields and health that is independent of industry and mandate industry cooperation with researchers;
     8.  media disclose experts’ financial relationships with industry when citing their opinions regarding health and safety aspects of EMF-emitting technologies; and
     9.  white-zones (radiation-free areas) be established.
What should we make of this petition and the included requests? First we need to recognize that this petition is coming from scientists with a particular point of view, not a general or all-purpose scientific or medical body. This does not mean their position is wrong, but it does make me more skeptical and concerned that they may be biased toward justifying their existence, rather than taking a totally objective look at the evidence.
There is also a huge red flag in the above requests that is strong evidence for such bias – #6 which refers to “patients with electromagnetic sensitivity” (EMS). On the PST website they openly defend the existence of EMS and multiple chemical sensitivity. This is highly problematic, and does not fill me with confidence that we are getting an objective scientific assessment of the evidence.
EMS refers to people who allegedly have a heightened sensitivity to the presence of electromagnetic radiation. We’ve discussed EMS before – the bottom line is that there is no evidence this condition is real. In fact when tested in a blinded condition, those with this alleged syndrome are unable to tell if they are being exposed to an electromagnetic field or not. The current best interpretation of the evidence is that EMS is not a real physiological syndrome. Citing it as if it is established therefore calls the credibility of this petition into question.
Reading the petition and the PST website feels like I am reading something that warns about GMOs or vaccines. I am not putting this in the exact same category, but what they have in common is the cherry picking of evidence for possible adverse effects, and then listing them as if they are established and non-controversial.
Further, organizations dedicated to warning about a potential health risk tend to confuse hazard with risk. A hazard is something that can potentially cause harm in the right setting. Risk refers to the actual probability of harm with the relevant exposure. The best analogy I read was a shark in a tank at the aquarium. The shark is a potential hazard, but the risk is pretty low as long as you stay outside the tank.
With radiofrequency or non-ionizing radiation, there are two questions. The first is – what is the potential hazard of exposure? Are there any biological effects that can potentially be a problem? The second question, which is more important, is – what is the risk from actual exposure to radiofrequency waves? What does the evidence say about hazard and risk from non-ionizing radiation?
The National Cancer Institute has an excellent summary of the research, which I read through, and there is no reason for me to replicate their thorough summary here. They also list the opinions of many scientific and regulatory organizations, reflecting the consensus of opinion. With respect to hazard they point out that the only biological effect that has been clearly established is tissue heating. This is why current regulations focus on heating, and provide safety limits.
No other biological effect has been clearly established. The FDA specifically points out that other effects have not been replicated in the research. Phillips and his cosigners, however, act as if all the biological effects are established.
With regard to risk there have been several large epidemiological studies with cell phones and cancer. The research focuses on cell phones because they are extremely common and have been so for over two decades. The research fails to consistently show any correlation between degree of cell phone exposure and risk of cancer or tumors.
So – the hazard seems to be limited, and the risk must be small to have eluded clear detection so far. But – we can never prove zero risk, and technology is always evolving. Therefore it is reasonable to call for more research as we further adopt wireless technology.
Of the requests above, the only ones I fully agree with are that scientists need to disclose contacts with industry (for the record, I have none), and more research is needed. Of course children and pregnant women need to be protected – but what does that mean? That is too vague to be useful. I also agree with public education, but not with what the petitioners want, which I think constitutes misinformation and unjustified fearmongering.
I think the best recommendation for right now is that, while there is probably little to no risk, if you want to make sure you are minimizing possible risk then use wired earbuds for electronic devices, rather than putting them up to your ear.
We are living in an increasingly wireless society, and the change is happening relatively quickly. We therefore do need to monitor for potential health effects and continue to do proper research. But so far the apparent risk from non-ionizing radiation from radiofrequency devices appears to be little to none, which is reassuring. Premature warnings that distort the current scientific consensus are not helpful. They tend to cause unwarranted fear, which leads to counterproductive laws restricting useful technology, and unfair lawsuits.
Even for an organization dedicated to assessing the risk of radiofrequency technology, it is advisable not to overstate the science, lest you lose credibility and may actually hurt the cause you are fighting for. I think this will be the ultimate result of this petition.

Are Smart Meters a Health Risk?
Don’t worry. There is no plausible health risk from the miniscule EMF from smart meters.
Steven Novella on February 27, 2019
Link

No!
Oh, you want more? OK. I guess I can give you the long version, for those who want more details.
Smart meters are one of the latest targets for those who like to fearmonger about electromagnetic radiation and “dirty electricity”. I had to say “one of” because 5G, the new mobile network standard, is more recent. Smart meters are still new to many people, however, and as always seems to be the case, the pseudoscience tends to get ahead of the curve.
Smart meters are the obvious next technological step in metering the use of electricity at residential and commercial buildings. They are digital, replacing the older analog meters, and have more functionality. They not only measure total electricity use, they can gather data on the time of day that the electricity was used and peak demand. They can also measure electricity produced and sent back to the grid for those who have solar panels or other power generation. And finally, they can communicate all this data to the power company wirelessly, eliminating the need to send a person to each location to read the meter.
Smart meters essentially use the same technology as cell phones, “The frequency of operation is typically in the 902 MHz and 2.4 GHz bands. Power output is typically 1 watt in the 902 MHz band and much less in the 2.4 GHz band.” So they use similar but less powerful radiation as cell phones.
How often are they transmitting? This is a surprisingly difficult question to answer definitely, because each power company has different practices. Each smart meter will transmit its power usage data (called the duty cycle) back to the company anywhere from once per half-hour to monthly (monthly is the least often it can do so by regulation). Some companies allow customers to choose the frequency.
Many companies will therefore answer this question by saying – a fraction of a second (12-120 miliseconds) every few hours. But that is only for data transmission from the meter to the company. Smart meters also send and receive updates and other information to the company. Further, some companies use mesh technology, so that smart meters will route their data through other meters to get to the receiving station.
Even the FCC was frustrated by the complexity of answering this question – so they hired a company to actually measure it. They found, in their sample, a total duty cycle of 6 minutes in a 24 hour period, or 0.4%.
Duration is only one variable in determining EMF exposure. Strength and distance are also a factor. Strength is similar to, and actually less than, a typical cell phone. Distance here is a key – because most smart meters are going to be on the outside of a building. The inverse square law means that the power of the signal will drop off quickly with distance. The wall of the building also will attenuate the signal. Compare this to holding a cell phone directly up to your head.
What all this means is that the total exposure to EMF from having a smart meter on your home is likely hundreds of thousands of times less than even modest cell phone use. Looked at another way – one thirty minute phone call is worth decades of living in a home with a smart meter.
The comparison to cell phones is deliberate, because we have written many times about the scientific evidence for the safety of cell phone use. Even though exposure to EMF through cell phone use is many orders of magnitude greater than living with a smart meter, the evidence still does not clearly show any health risk from cell phone use.
The numbers here are quite clear, but this has not stopped people from campaigning against this technology through misinformation and cherry picked data. In fact, searching online for information will yield more misinformation and fearmongering than reliable data. They use the same playbook at the antivaxxers, anti-fluoridation, and “dirty electricity” movements. They use the complexity inherent in any such topics to give the impression of a conspiracy, while also exploiting it to cherry pick the sources and fact that serve their purpose, for example.
Also, every pseudoscience movement has its celebrity cranks. In this case that honor goes to “Harvard medical doctor” David Carpenter.
Dr. Carpenter adamantly insists that there is no evidence whatsoever that smart meters are in any way safe for human beings. He goes on to say that there is, in fact, ample evidence that demonstrates “convincingly and consistently” that exposure to radiofrequency radiation (RFR) at elevated levels for long periods of time increases the risk of cancer, damages the nervous system, and adversely affects the reproductive organs.
This is a mischaracterization of the evidence, and ignores the frequency, duration, and intensity of EMF from smart meters that I outlined above. Fearmongering campaigns also rely heavily on and abuse of the precautionary principle and by arguing that there is insufficient evidence of safety. What is sufficient evidence of safety? More than we currently have, whatever that is at any given moment. Sometimes the bar is simply set at infinity – meaning a demand for proof of zero risk (something that does not exist).
As we have to point out here frequently, evidence for a lack of an ill effect from any exposure or intervention is always limited by existing data. You can never prove zero risk, only set statistical limits on the magnitude of the risk. But at some point the potential remaining risk shrinks into the background of life. That is basically where we are with cell phones, and again smart meters are orders of magnitude safer.
It is also much easier to scare the public than to reassure them with a wonky analysis of science and data. It is also easy to use inherent complexity and the typical background of marketing spin to convince people that big companies are lying to them. Sure, power companies are probably oversimplifying things when they report how often smart meters are active. But this does not mean there is a conspiracy, and the actual data supports the bottom line that the meters are only active for a small percentage of the time (0.4% in that one study).
Also as is often the case, the alleged health risks are used as a convenient scare tactic when the real objection to a technology is for other reasons. Often health risks are rolled into a long list of objections to a technology that are mostly economic or moral. GMO are opposed because people don’t like the idea of “patenting life” and fear big corporation control of our food. Vaccines are opposed to protect parental choice, and fluoride in the water is part of some deep conspiracy.
With regard to smart meters, people fear that they will be used to invade our privacy and gather all sorts of information about us. Even if there are economic or privacy issues that are legitimate, wrapping them up with health pseudoscience does a disservice to the entire conversation, and is likely to get legitimate concerns dismissed as crankery. With regard to smart meters the only concern I have read that seems to have any legitimacy is their vulnerability to hacking. But that is an issue that can be dealt with, and should not be connected to pseudoscience about fake health concerns.
Often medical scientific data is complex, but in this case the numbers are easy. The total amount of EMF from smart meters is negligible. Period. There is no plausible health risk from them.

Earthing Update
Earthing is yet another dubious medical claim exploiting weaknesses in the system.
Steven Novella on February 8, 2023
Link

I first wrote about “earthing”, also called “grounding”, about a decade ago. Briefly, the idea of earthing is that electrically grounding oneself has a long list of health benefits. I found these claims dubious a decade ago, but I also like to follow up on the research into topics I previously tackled. One of the best ways to judge the validity and potential of a scientific area of research is to see how it evolves over time. Real sciences tend to make tangible progress, while pseudosciences tend to chase their tail.
In medicine, which is an applied science, there are very concrete differences between the real and the fake, and it is only after we see how the medical research progresses that we can confidently say which approaches are useful and which are not. What we like to see as the medical literature on a topic evolves is a persistent statistically significant and clinically relevant effect size that persists as studies become more rigorous and are replicated. What we typically see with dubious treatments is a persistent failure to replicate, studies generally never progress to more rigorous methods, and an inverse relationship between study rigor and positive outcomes.
As I wrote, again about a decade ago, we know from history that there are reliable indicators of when a medical hypothesis is legitimate. Generally we like to see four simultaneous features: methodological rigor, significantly positive effects, reasonable clinical effect (and signal to noise ratio), and replication. Just three are not enough, because you can manufacture positive-seeming results if you can ignore one or more of these criteria.
There is also the issue of medical plausibility. This is, admittedly, a secondary concern with conventional hypotheses in terms of determining clinical efficacy. But that “conventional hypotheses” is a critical caveat. The more a hypothesis seems to violate the laws of physics, the more prominent plausibility is as an issue. For claims that are implausible but not impossible, we could still accept a real effect if the clinical evidence were a home run. Here plausibility informs us where we should set the threshold for tentative acceptance. Moderate clinical evidence might be enough, for now, for a highly plausibility, even expected, outcome. But if everything we currently know says that an intervention should not work, we should demand a higher threshold of clinical evidence before superseding prior knowledge.
Where does earthing fit into this scheme? When I wrote about it in 2012 I felt it was clearly on the pseudoscience side of the equation. Let’s start with the plausibility. The claim is that in our natural state we were more connected to the Earth, walking barefoot on the ground. This allowed for electrons to flow to and from our bodies, creating an electrical homeostasis that was optimal for health. In our modern world, however, we live inside buildings and wear rubber soled shoes. This isolates us electrically from the Earth causes us to be out of electrical homeostasis. In short, this is utter nonsense.
The reason electrical devices are grounded is to give electrons somewhere to go, in case of some source of overload (like lightening) or just to prevent them from building up. Even a small backup of current can create electrical noise in a sensitive system. And of course the amount of electricity we are talking about is massive compared to what our bodies experience. Further, even with rubber soles, we are far from electrically isolated. We easily share electrons with everything we touch. When you have a brief build up of electrical charge you usually find our right away, because you get a static electric shock the next time you touch something conductive (which, of course, neutralizes the charge). Just from the perspective of basic physics, earthing makes no sense. It sounds like the nonsense someone with only a partial understanding of the underlying science cooked up.
The intervention is mostly to spend time walking on the ground in bare feet. But of course, there are also dubious devices, such as grounding mats, that you can sit, stand, or sleep on, and that are in turn grounded to the Earth. There is no evidence that these devices do anything. There is also no research establishing the basic underlying claim – that there is an electrical homeostasis that has any effect on how the body functions, and that this is affected by grounding.
The medical part of the plausibility equation is also highly dubious. According to one researcher:
Because the continuous semiconducting fabric of the body reaches into every part of the body, including the interiors of all cells and their nuclei, mobile electrons in the grounded or earthed person are thought to be capable of rapidly neutralizing ROS produced by oxidative metabolism taking place in every cell and tissue.
The “antioxidant” gambit rears its head again. I have covered why antioxidants are not a panacea extensively here already. In short, oxidative stress is part of a complex homeostatic system in the body, and we already possess powerful antioxidants that don’t need the help of whatever dubious treatment is being proposed. I would give this one an overall plausibility of close to zero.
What about the clinical evidence – how has that evolved in the last decade? It has progressed like a typical pseudoscience, following the path of other dubious claims like homeopathy and acupuncture. First, it leans heavily on pre-clinical studies that fit the pattern – “look, stuff is happening”.
Another study proclaims:
In previous studies, grounding revealed anti-inflammatory effect, immunity enhancement, anticoagulation, and rising blood oxygenation.
I always love it when a treatment is simultaneously “anti-inflammatory” and “immunity enhancing”. These are almost necessarily contradictory. It shows that no matter what happens it can be interpreted in a positive way. These pre-clinical studies look at markers, like cells or biochemicals, to determine effect. This kind of research is rife with difficulty and dubious results (not to say it can’t be useful when properly done). It also has a very loose connection to later clinical studies – in other words, not very predictive at all. So, take a look at a bunch of immune markers, if any go up that is “boosting immunity”, if any go down that is “anti-inflammatory”.
The last ten years of published clinical studies have been entirely unimpressive. Studies generally have small numbers of participants, focus on subjective outcomes (the usual suspects of pain, “well-being”, and stress), and are poorly controlled. Never do we see all features of rigor simultaneously.
What they do (very much like the acupuncture literature) is allow proponents to claim that there is scientific, even “double blind”, evidence to support their claims. But each individual study does not survive scrutiny. In this study, for example, they used a “wedge” design in which all subjects received the same pattern of treatment (placebo on some days and treatment on others) without variation. I am not sure how this can be “double” blind when every participant had the same pattern. They didn’t even mix it up to make sure it wasn’t an artifact of timing (reporting more of an effect with more treatments). Also, if you look at the data, the results are all over the place, with many outcomes not statistically significant. They are just cherry picking apparently positive outcomes while not properly adjusting the statistics for multiple outcomes. And the number of participants was 16, so we would expect lots of quirky results.
Another pattern that is apparent is that most of the research is published in “alternative medicine” journals, predatory journals, or other low impact journals. This allows for the creation of the illusion of scientific support without ever crossing the threshold of scientific legitimacy.
Earthing is another example of exactly what is wrong with biomedical publishing. It favors the publication of large numbers of low quality studies, with plenty of opportunities for proponents of dubious medical treatments and beliefs to get into the peer-reviewed literature. For the uninitiated this creates the appearance of legitimacy, even for highly implausible treatments.

   Train Therapy
Mark Crislip
Link
Summertime and the living is busy. Finally we have sun in the Northwest. While the rest of the country has been melting in heat, this year we have rarely cracked 85. Global heating has avoided Oregon this year, and I will need some green tomato recipes. Good weather, work is busy, and it is the last two weeks with my eldest before he is off to Syracuse, so there is little time for writing, so a brief entry this week.
I always wince at the way anything can be called ‘therapy.’ We have music therapy and garden therapy and pet therapy and art therapy. I do not deny that it is beneficial for people to participate in those activities while in the hospital, although I am never happy to see disease vectors, er, animals in a hospital. Dinner should be food therapy, reading should be book therapy, and using the internet should be computer therapy. I guess it is like calling something ‘medical’ grade, and you can bill more for it.
Some ‘therapies’ are a wee bit more odd. Indonesians are using railroad therapy. People lie down on electric railroad tracks because “the electricity current from the track could cure various diseases.” To date no one has been either electrocuted or squashed, but I suppose it is only a matter of time.
Why train tracks? Why not a tongue in a light socket or other source of electricity? Evidently rumor has it that “an ethnic Chinese man who was partially paralyzed by a stroke went to the tracks to kill himself, but instead found himself cured.” Sounds good to me. It seems as likely as Palmer cracking a neck leading to a cure in deafness as the basis for a therapeutic intervention.
And so others are using train therapy for their hypertension, diabetes, strokes and other medical problems. Train therapy is evidently a panacea for a variety of diseases and used by those with no other medical options. Like all alternative therapies, it is effective against numerous diseases, regardless of the underlying pathophysiology. If only antibiotics could cure hypertension, diabetes and stroke in addition to bacteria.
Does train therapy work? The patients say it does, despite those know it all skeptical MDs who point to a lack of evidence. And who would gainsay a patient’s response to the therapy? If a patient says they are better, are they not better?
Medical experts say there is no evidence lying on the rails does any good.
But Mulyati insists it provides more relief for her symptoms — high-blood pressure, sleeplessness and high cholesterol — than any doctor has since she was first diagnosed with diabetes 13 years ago.
I was worried they would forget to tell both sides of the story. And just who is expert on the medical effects of lying on electric train lines? They go on to note that
Pseudo-medical treatments are wildly popular in many parts of Asia — where rumors about those miraculously cured after touching a magic stone or eating dung from sacred cows can attract hundreds, sometimes thousands.
It would be easy to be snotty and superior about the Indonesians and their use of train therapy, but really, is it any different than the West? They eat dung from sacred cows, we have the bullshit from the NCCAM. We have reiki and homeopathy and Tong Ren healing, and all the other therapies that are subject of this blog, all equally nonsensical. I see little difference between the use of train healing and much of the published literature in the SCAM world. A series of uncontrolled interventions with soft endpoints.
Indonesians have the same rationale for the use of train therapy: anecdotes. Every homeopathy apologist mentions that the millions who have used homeopathy with good effect can’t be wrong, and neither can the hundreds who are using train therapy. I suppose we could say the Indonesians are doing a pragmatic, real world trial. Who needs the old randomized, placebo controlled nonsense? Lie on an electric train track and you feel better. ’nuff said.
Are the patients who believe they are getting better experiencing a placebo effect? Is this an example where patient centered outcomes are more important that doctor centered outcomes? Maybe we should use train therapy for the treatment of asthma. Conductors and engineers, like doctors, “often dress up in special uniforms that convey power and authority… (and) They have very expensive machines” Probably less expensive than sham acupuncture and sham albuterol.
Train therapy fits the criteria noted in the recent NEJM editorial; it should be sufficient to “simply to show that a treatment yields significant improvement for the patients, has reasonable cost, and has no negative effects over the short or long term. This is, after all, the first tenet of medicine: Do no harm.” The train track users say they are improved, it is free, and as long as they get up in time, should have no negative effects. I would avoid TGV tracks, just to be safe. I expect train therapy to be come incorporated in Integrative Medicine programs everywhere, or at those near light rail.
There was a time when I was inclined to think that the people who participated in SCAMs were either stupid or ignorant. I have long ago abandoned that idea. Some people, as evidenced by occasional comments in this blog, are apparently deranged, but not most. I have realized that while most SCAMs are stupid, the people who use them are not. It seems to be a universal human characteristic to participate in nonsense of one kind or another, but the nonsense varies by culture and opportunity. ‘We’ detox our colons and avoid vaccines, ‘they’ eat dung and lie on train tracks. All are human. Or are they?
Most biologic characteristics have variability. Height, strength, intelligence all vary about the infamous bell shaped curve. I have also wondered about more intangible characteristics: the ability to think rationally or empathy or a sense of humor. Like jumping or math, some people seem to be better at these tasks than others. It does not, I hasten to add, make them better people, except for the task at hand. I wonder if the uber-rational, the skeptics, are mutants, given what appears to be the relative rarity of rational/scientific thought. And to judge from the vitriolic response towards the scientific/rationally inclined, the rational must be mutants as they are feared and hated by those they were sworn to protect.
I don’t know. Idle speculation caused by vitamin D deficiency. I am going to lie in the sun, not on the Max line. I know this will make me feel better, although I doubt it will cure any illness.

Elemonics – Nothing but a dance and a tune
When it comes to quackery and pseudoscience, Mike Adams of NaturalNews.com has few peers. Amusingly, he thinks he’s a scientist, too, and he’s at it again.
Craig D Pearcey on February 5, 2017
Link


Elemonics – a term coined by Mr Mike Adams (The Health Ranger) to propose a “new” concept (hypothesis) he has been promoting since the “Truth on Cancer Symposium 2016” in October last year. The term appears to come from the combination of the words ‘element(s)’ and ‘harmonics’ or similar. Since his introduction of this concept, via a live presentation, at the aforementioned symposium, elemonics appears to have generated significant interest in the Complementary, Alternative, and Integrated-Medicine (CAM) media in a relatively short space of time, with numerous websites and blogs linking to Mr Adams’ articles and video uploads on his symposium presentation in a few short months. Both Mr Adams and many in the CAM media appear convinced that this is a major scientific breakthrough that will usher in a vast number of medical and other scientific applications. So is there anything to elemonics? The answer, as some chemists may say, is that apparently considerable entropy is being generated for a vacuum. In simple English: much talk and excitement about nothing. In fact, elemonics as a hypothesis it is quite meaningless and pure pseudoscience.
For those familiar with Mr Adams’ claims on elemonics, the reader can skip ahead to the section entitled: “Shat the sciences say” to avoid a brief reference and summary on the topic.
The song and dance
Mr Adams’ first Natural News/cite> article on elemonics was entitled “Health Ranger to unveil revolutionary scientific synthesis of atomic physics and musical harmonics” which appeared a few days after his live presentation on this topic at “Truth on Cancer Symposium 2016”. A second more recent article was published on Natural News entitled “Now you can HEAR chemistry: Health Ranger translates molecules into music in stunning video demonstration that will blow your mind (and your ears)” with Mr Adams as the main author thereof as well. There is also a video copy of his symposium presentation which is quite popular in many of the CAM media and blogs. Lastly, Mr Adams (or a business partner) appears also have moved very quickly to commercially capitalize on elemonics as can be seen via the following advertisement:” Upgrade your hydration with the Echo Elemonics hydrogen infusion machine.” Whatever ones opinion, both Mr Adams and many in the CAM industry (which include a few its key proponents and spokesman) have shown strong support for elemonics. It is clear that collectively they believe that Mr Adams has achieved a genuine and “stunning” breakthrough in the sciences via elemonics; and if not them, then certainly Mr Adams’ supporters and fans certainly do based on their feedback on Natural News.
A summary, after review of the available information, shows that the central tenets of elemonics start with quantum mechanics, as given by Mr Adams’ opening statements, in his first article:
All matter — which includes everything in the Table of Elements — is nothing more than organized vibrations…The SPDF orbitals of electrons at the atomic level, for example, are nothing but vibratory probability clouds.
Mr Adams gives considerable focus to electron orbital theory in this opening. However, Mr Adams explanation of the quantum mechanics therein is actually very poor and suggests that Mr Adams may not really understand his subject matter particularly well. From there Mr Adams moves onto the atomic mass of elements and attempts to imply that an element’s mass (or more specifically its inverse mass) is related, or a determinant of, its chemical properties, particularly whether it is beneficial or detrimental to biological systems and general health. He subsequently attempts to relate these inverse elemental masses to acoustic frequencies use a conversion factor of 3520 Hz (which Mr Adams states is the A-note in music, roughly the pitch at 1:47 in this video); and hence his following attempt to relate this to the music notes on a 88-key keyboard. Thus an element can be represented via a musical tone given by 3520 Hz divided by its molecular mass in g/mol. This gives the highest pitched note for the lightest element, namely hydrogen (A-note), to ever-decreasing tones for heavier and heavier elements (D-note for carbon and right at the bottom of the musical scale for mercury). For molecules, Mr Adams represents them as a string of different notes starting at the highest tone (typically hydrogen at 3520 Hz for an organic) down to the lowest (carbon, Sulphur, or a metal – depending on which is the heaviest). Lastly, Mr Adams then proceeds to fit this all into a 4-note chord system (based on the four valence nature of a carbon atom). This allows Mr Adams to represent each molecule, or so he claims, as repeated music tunes. With this “foundation” set, Mr Adams then proceeds to claim that by listening to these simple musical tunes an individual can easily tell “acoustically” if a particular molecule or element sounds harmonious with the background four-note chord system (and so is beneficial) or out of harmony (and is so detrimental). Further, Mr Adams asserts a direct correlation between an elements chemical properties and its elemonics. Thus if an element or molecule is toxic (eg. Mercury, DDT, ect.) it will sound “bad”, but if it is “good/healthy” it will sound “pleasant”. Finally, Mr Adams also states that the acoustic elemonics tones not only serve an analytical purpose, but can also be used to directly manipulate the physical and chemical properties on any element.
As an aside, I found the information given by Mr Adams on elemonics a little challenging to follow. Mr Adams’ discussion around elemonics appeared to be poorly given and rather vague in that his arguments were not well developed and his discussion appeared to lack adequate information to be clearly coherent as a scientific discourse.
What the sciences say
However a review of established science shows that elemonics, as a hypothesis, runs afoul of a number of scientific fields.
First, matter (whether elements or molecules) is not “nothing more than organized vibrations.” In quantum mechanics, a particulate or entity (whether a molecule, a lone atom, their electron cloud, a single electron or photon, ect.) can actually be defined by a wave-function based on specific solutions to the Schrödinger equation. The Schrödinger equation can actually be viewed as a general or broad mathematical scaffold to solve any number of models simulating a variety atomic or molecular processes which also incorporate the quantized nature of energy. (Max Plank discovered that energy is not a continuum in nature when it comes to its magnitude, it actual comes in “bundles” or “energy elements” of discrete size – see the quantization of the energy.) Using specific models, such as: particle-in-a-box, the rigid-rotor, and the harmonic oscillator quantum mechanical solutions for the movement of a particle, the rotational and vibrational energies of a molecule respectively can be (and have been) found showing the discrete energy levels in each. For lone atoms, the s, p, d, and f atomic orbitals serve as good solutions to the orbital wave functions for the atom’s electrons and their energy levels in that atom. For molecules, the observer must employ molecular orbitals instead, such as the Sigma, Pi and non-bonding orbitals, to describe electron distribution and energies in the molecule. It should be noted that a detailed mathematic explanation of these solutions is beyond the scope of this article, and my own knowledge.
Second, Mr Adams’ assertion, in context of elemonics, that an element’s properties can be determined by its total atomic mass (or more specifically its inversed mass) is unfounded. Yes, he is correct in regards the periodicity of the period table of elements in that elements in the same period (ie. vertical column) tend to have similar chemical properties. But this periodicity is not determined by the element’s atomic mass, rather by the electron configuration in the outer valence orbitals of that element – as it is only the outer valence electrons that participate in chemical reactions. This also applies molecules as well and is also the reason why a molecule’s properties are determined by the electron configuration in its outer molecular orbitals (Sigma and Pi orbitals, ect.) instead of its atomic orbitals. This is classically illustrated by the properties of the elements sodium , carbon and nitrogen vs the molecule sodium cyanide; and elemental mercury vs thiomersal. To imply that a substance’s chemical properties (ie. element or molecule) are determined by its atomic mass (and resulting periodicity) is equivalent to saying a substances chemical properties are determine by its total electron content, which is completely false as only its outer orbital electrons are valent (able to combine with other atoms or molecules) in nature – and even then not all of them.
Third, Mr Adams’ method in determining what constitutes a harmonious tune and what constitutes an unharmonious tune (ie. good/beneficial vs bad/toxic) is purely subjective. This subjectivity falls into two categories. In the first category, the preference as to what is harmonious and what is not, is based solely on the preference of the individual observer, meaning that one observer will classify certain music tunes as “good” while another will classify it as “bad”. It is solely at the discretion of the observer (or listener in this case). In fact, given that music and its styles tend to be almost largely cultural constructs, there is likely to be a strong cultural bias to the elemonic’s acoustic results. For the second category, there is simply not a clear numerical quantification or definition as to good and bad. In other words, no quantified zero point with no qualified method of measurement; and if nothing is or can be accurately measure (ie. quantified) the entire process is subject to unlimited levels of bias and uncertainty. In essence, the premises of “good” and “bad” collapse as they are solely observer driven.
Fourth, Mr Adams has not proposed any mechanism by which elemonics operates, whether viable or otherwise. He simply states it as fact, as a given – the equivalent of a magician pulling a rabbit out of the hat shortly after the music starts. This is among the Health Ranger’s most significant failings in regards elemonics. In any field of science, a viable mechanism of action is essential. No mechanism … NO action. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about it. In chemistry, we have the formation of activated complexes during reactions with the shifting of molecular bonds between the reagents after they have come together (new bonds forming and old bonds breaking). This is also the situation when intermediates are formed from a single reaction molecule in a multi-set reaction process. In physics, when a container of water is heated, water molecules with higher kinetic energy (provided by the heat-source) pass that heat energy on by colliding with other less energetic “cooler” water molecules. (It is interesting to note that in terms of the field of force-particles, the thermal heat is passed between water molecules in their “collision” as a photon. This exchange then causes the equivalent of a recoil between the two water molecules based on the law of the conservation of momentum.) These are only two of an enormous collection of examples ranging from swinging pendulums, to the generation of x-rays, through to the photo-electric effect and even black holes. Mr Adams’ elemonic hypothesis lacks this most critical component. This is even more acute an issue if Mr Adams’ claim of manipulating the chemical properties of a substance with acoustical energy is taken as sincere.
Fifth, there is simply no way sound in the audible acoustic range can be used to transfer energy to a chemical reaction with adequate efficiency. To impact a chemical reaction or drive it with sound, the experimenter typically requires ultrasonic frequencies, even in the best of circumstance getting acceptable results tends to be challenging. Audible sound is simply too un-energetic, too low a frequency to influence a chemical reaction. This is clearly illustrated by Planck’s equation on electromagnetic radiation, in which the energy delivered by a photon of light is dictated by its frequency (the higher the frequency the greater the energy carried). The same would apply to acoustic frequencies and the phononic model for such a system. Consequently, the new Echo Elemonics hydrogen infusion machine advertised on Mr Adams’ Natural News website is unlikely to produce any benefits due to elemonics, as audible acoustic sound cannot significantly impact on the behavior on the hydrogen and oxygen atoms making up the water passing through it.
And “amazing” flights of pseudoscience follow
The flurry and flight of pseudo-science that follows (or could follow) from elemonics is likely to be quite notable as is clearly illustrated in the advertisement for same aforementioned new Echo Elemonics hydrogen infusion machine, advertised on Mr Adams’ Natural News website. This requires a direct quote therefrom to illustrate the point:
First, it infuses water with free hydrogen, yet without substantially altering the pH of the water in the process. In other words, it’s not an “alkaline water” machine. …”
And
In essence, Echo Elemonics is a water filter, a hydrogen infusion machine and an Elemonics infusion system, all in one. The result is clean, hydrogen infused water with a symphony of balanced trace elements.
Seriously? … Free hydrogen (locked in a volume of water)? … hydrogen infused water? … a symphony of balanced trace elements? And one query that arises from these claims: Are the advertisers now claiming molecular forms given by H3O, H4O, H6O …?
These are clear examples of pseudo-science run amok in which the proponents are both ignoring and violating a whole gauntlet of scientific laws. First, hydrogen has an extremely low level of solubility in water (like most gases) if we are assuming only a locked-in infusion type process. If they are claiming new molecular forms of “water” then they are suggesting water molecular “forms” that would be extremely thermodynamically unstable and have never been seen before in nature unless under the most extreme of conditions. In addition, they have also not proposed a viable mechanism for the formation of the new “forms” or the bonding configuration. Last, audible acoustic sound cannot influence the properties of any element or molecule, nor can it be used to manipulate matter on the atomic scale. In the end the aforementioned advertisement literally overflows with pseudo-science in places, and this is likely to be the repeated outcome from any future elemonic “application”.
At best, this is expensive music
In conclusion, although Mr Adams’ elemonics produces some interesting audible work and likely would produce some “pleasant” tunes; that is all it can do. It is devoid of many key requirements to qualify as even a low-tier scientific study, let alone a genuine and “stunning” major breakthrough. Thus, elemonics as a concept is both meaningless and poorly constructed. It is not real science; it is pseudo-science from beginning to end, even if it alludes to some real scientific content. The day of the lone maverick redefining entire scientific fields is centuries behind us now. Major advances are always built on the work of dozens or hundreds of others – modern science is simply too complex for any other possibility. Mr Adams overwhelmingly lacks the funds, skill, and expertise to match those on science’s cutting-edge and always will. Hopefully Mr Adams will take this into serious consideration for any science project he boldly embarks on in the future.

Crystal Healing
Crystal healing is back and growing in popularity. What does that reveal about our society and alternative medicine?
Steven Novella on September 18, 2019
Tweet

I guess if believing in a flat earth can make a comeback, so can crystal healing. The popularity of this pure “wellness” pseudoscience has been surging in the last few years, and is now a multi-billion dollar industry. This rising popularity is partly thanks to Goop, but also the general rising tide of new age beliefs.
A 2018 Pew survey found that 62% of US adults believed in at least one New Age belief (spiritual energy can be located in physical objects, psychics, reincarnation, astrology). This was true for both those who do and do not consider themselves members of a mainstream religion (although the lowest belief group was atheists at 22%). The modern crystal healing phenomenon dates back to the 1970s. They eventually fell out of fashion, I think because they became the icon of silly new age nonsense. But now the beliefs that old-school skeptics debunked in the 70s and 80s, then forgot about for a generation, are making a comeback.
Crystal healing has many of the hallmarks of alternative medicine pseudoscience, and is just another manifestation of many common themes. It is a form of energy medicine. Proponents claim that different types of crystals either contain, amplify, attract, or repel different kinds of energy. Like energy medicine in general, we are not talking about any kind of real energy that can be identified or measured by physicists. This energy is not predicted by the standard model of particle physics, and don’t expect the Large Hadron Collider to find any force carrying particles related to crystal energy. There is no Higgs Boson of energy medicine.
The “energy” referred to in energy medicine is purely metaphorical and mythical. Proponents generally claim that it is “spiritual” energy, which is just a way of saying that the energy has no physical properties that can be detected, and is therefore outside the realm of scientific discovery. But at the same time they claim that this mysterious “energy” can affect living things, which is the inherent contradiction at the core of this belief.
Invoking undetectable “energy”, without defining it in any testable way, as an explanation is a common tactic of pseudoscience. Types of energy medicine include straight chiropractic, Reiki, acupuncture, therapeutic touch, healing touch, and is a good fallback position for any other treatment lacking a plausible mechanism.
How do you know which kind of crystal to use for which problem you are having? You can find many guides, which use the typical CAM standard – “It can be used”, “Is often used”, or “Is known to”. That’s it. There is no supportive framework in theory or in evidence. This is the equivalent of parents saying, “Because I said so.” What this illustrates is the human tendency to develop explanatory systems and elaborate on them. We are good at finding patterns and inventive at making stuff up. The history of pseudomedicine is full of such systems, complex and detailed, but ultimately based on nothing. These systems then take on a life of their own, they become culture, and then authoritative knowledge – but again, it is ultimately vaporware.
Some of the claims are based on another common theme in some alternative systems – the superstition of sympathetic magic. This is the intuition that something will have an effects suggested by what it looks like. So walnuts must be good for the brain because they kind of look like a brain. One tradition of homeopathy is entirely based on sympathetic magic. Many traditional remedies make this connection as well.
In crystal healing, rose quartz “is commonly used for attracting and keeping love, as well as protecting relationships”. Of course it is – it’s pink, so it must be infused with the energy of love. Whereas, “Obsidian crystal stone also protects you from shadow traits — addiction, fear, anxiety, and anger– by acting as a mirror to your inner self.” It’s black, so it must have to do with negative energy. This is metaphor, not reality.
Proponents of crystal healing also commit the “appeal to antiquity” fallacy. Often it is pointed out that some ancient Egyptian mummies were buried with crystals. Setting aside the difficulty in interpreting exactly what an ancient culture believed – who cares? Ancient societies believed in a lot of magic. This is hardly a justification for applying leeches or bloodletting.
Unfortunately the crystal healing craze shares another feature in common with some other alternative medicine systems – when you dig down to the bottom of the supply chain, it’s not a pretty picture. Traditional Chinese Medicine traffics in parts of endangered animals. The supplement supply chain is also highly dubious with poor quality control. When your product is based entirely on pseudoscience, don’t expect a lot of ethics and rigor in the industry.
With crystals the problem is exploitation of the populations where many of the world’s largest mineral deposits exist. The Guardian goes into detail, focusing on places like Madagascar, where the mining industry is poorly regulated. Workers have to deal with dangerous mineral dust and mine collapses. They are some of the lowest paid workers in the world, living in horrific conditions. This is the crystal equivalent of blood diamonds. This is all feeding an exploding crystal healing industry, worsening the situation.
Finally, you may be surprised to learn that there was actually a study of crystal healing. In 2001 Chris French did a double blind study with 80 participants meditating with either a real quartz crystal or a fake glass crystal. There was a placebo effect where participants felt what they were primed to feel – a warmth or tingling sensation or a sense of well-being. But they were unable to tell the difference between the real or fake crystals, indicating a placebo effect only.
Of course evidence like this will have exactly zero effect on the crystal healing industry, which is not based on logic or evidence in the first place. The wellness industry is essentially selling placebo effects, philosophy, and a lifestyle. They are not selling science. Crystal healing is perhaps the perfect manifestation of this.

Closing out 2012 with a bit of fun: Do you want some quantum with that pseudoscience?
David Gorski on December 31, 2012
Link
Today is the last day of 2012. As I contemplated what I’d write for my last post of 2012, I wondered what to do. Should I do a “year in review” sort of post? Naahh. Too trite and too much work. Should I just do what I normally do? There are, after all, many topics that are out there, some of them still holdovers from before the holiday season. I can’t get to them all, even between this blog and my not-so-super-secret other blog. I thought about it a minute, but then rejected that possibility. So I decided just to cover one of them. After all, when years begin and end are human constructs, and there’s nothing special about today other than that society has decided that it is the last day of the year, and tradition mandates that a significant proportion of the population will gather before midnight to get drunk and stupid. I’m boring that way, rarely doing anything on New Years Eve other than sitting in front of the TV with my wife and watching the ball drop in Times Square. Then I thought: Oh, what the heck? Why not take on something a bit…different for a change? Maybe even get a bit silly? At least I can finish off the year with a bit of fun. Who knows? I might even be able to be far more concise than usual? (Actually, that might be asking too much.) Besides, the topics I tend to take on here are almost always serious; so a little amusement would be good before diving into the science and pseudoscience that will certainly pop up in 2013.
If there’s one thing about “alternative” medicine, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), or “integrative medicine” that’s always puzzled me, it’s just how gullible some practitioners must think their clients are. In some cases, they might know their customers every bit as well as a car salesman knows his clients or an author knows his readers, but in actuality most people who fall for alt-med are no more gullible than average. However, some words seem to impress more than ever, as promoters of alt-med scramble to appropriate impressive-sounding science terms into their woo. I’ve seen a lot of them. So has Mark Crislip.
Among the favorite real science term that quacks love to appropriate is “quantum.” I blame Deepak Chopra. Although I highly doubt he was the first promoter of alternative medicine and various New Age thought to use and abuse the term “quantum” as a seemingly scientific justification of what in reality is nothing more than ancient mystical thinking gussied up with a quantum overcoat to hide its lack of science, Chopra has arguably done the most to popularize the term among the science-challenged set. In Chopra’s world, the word “quantum” functions like a magical talisman that explains ™everything because in the quantum world anything can happen. Actually, I should clarify. While it’s true that many bizarre and wondrous things can be explained through quantum theory (such as quantum entanglement), it is not, as Chopra and his many imitators would have you believe, a “get out of jail free” card for any magical thinking you can imagine, and quantum effects do not work the way people like Chopra (say, Lionel Milgrom, who seems to think that homeopathy works through quantum entanglement between practitioner, remedy, and patient) would like you to think.
As much as the term “quantum” is used and abused in alt-med, I can’t recall seeing anything as impressively silly as QuantumMAN™, which bills itself as the “world’s first downloadable MEDICINE.” I’m guessing that spelling “medicine” in all capital letters just emphasizes that it’s, like, really “MEDICINE, MAN.” (Yes, the “MAN” in “QuantumMAN™” is also in all caps. Of course.) If you visit the main page of the QuantumMAN™ website, you’ll also see that QuantumMAN™ is apparently much more than just the world’s first downloadable medicine, but that apparently it represents this:
Treat disease with data not drugs!
Simply open a portal with your purchased product’s Portal Access Key™ (PAK™). Data then transfers from a remote quantum computer to your brain’s neural network for the benefits desired.
Holy Matrix, Batman! Actually, it sounds as though QuantumMAN™ is going one beyond The Matrix movies. After all, in those movies, human beings were connected to the Matrix through a giant cables that were plugged directly into connections implanted into the brain through what looked like a giant Ethernet jacks on the backs of their heads. That’s obviously far too primitive for QuantumMAN™, which eschews such primitive physical connections for, apparently, quantum connections. You don’t believe me? Well, it helps that QuantumMAN™ is apparently based on extraterrestrial technology, which is referred to as a “game changer.” No doubt. If QuantumMAN™ were truly based on extraterrestrial technology, it would truly be a game changer!
But how—how?—you ask, does QuantumMAN™ work? Well, the Zürich Alpine Group, which is what the group promoting QuantumMAN™ calls itself, has an acronym (ZAG) that rather closely resembles another acronym beloved of cranks everywhere, ZOG. The jokes about this write themselves; so I won’t bother to. I will, however, take a peek at how ZAG describes itself and QuantumMAN™
The Zürich Alpine Group (ZAG) is a private humanitarian medical research group of scientists and physicians working cooperatively and quietly around the world in the quest to improve the quality, efficacy and costs of medical care. Working with those goals in mind, the group has developed a radical new quantum information technology derived from its discoveries utilizing quantum physics that has thrust it into global leadership in quantum computing. This technology offers solutions to previously insurmountable medical problems….solutions without the slightest possibility of adverse side effects from treatment. The team at ZAG has long understood the toll the drug industry has taken on the populace as it treats medical issues symptomatically with a chemical based approach. However, the universe including the human body and conditions that afflict it all operates according to the principles of quantum physics. Chemical based treatment systems do not operate according to those principles and, as such, are not compatible with the human host as evidenced by their toxicity. ZAG understands that quantum problems require a quantum solution and has found a way to transfer bioinformation from its quantum computer via quantum teleportation to the brain, also a quantum computer, to reprogram the brain to effect positive medical changes within the body and mind. These technological advancements have thus given birth to the world’s first downloadable medicines.
Naturally, ZAG is flying below the radar in order to prevent Big Pharma from crushing its technology, appropriating it for its own, and then charging exorbitant sums for it:
For several years, ZAG has quietly conducted clinical trials around the world testing its new developments for efficacy and safety. ZAG has shunned reporting its research and trials in the traditional medical literature because it believes this venue is heavily influenced by Big Pharma and politics. Finally, after years of testing, it has decided to arrange the creation of a web presence as the venue for the presentation of its numerous products developed from its technology.
I guess that explains why my searches of PubMed have failed to turn up a single reference supporting the use of these “quantum medicines.” Unfortunately, as much as I searched the site, I was unable to find even a description of this research outside of being published in peer-reviewed, PubMed-indexed medical journals. Go figure. What I did find were some nifty videos that purport to explain everything. For instance, here’s an introduction:
For having such an elaborate website and videos with fairly high production values, other than the robotic-sounding voice narrating them, ZAG sure isn’t very creative when it comes to how it introduces itself. There are the usual broadsides against “conventional” medicine, prescription drug deaths, and the like. Boring. I do like how ZAG claims that these quantum medicines are going to replace those primitive old “chemical-based” medicines. Of course, even if these “quantum medicines” worked, they’d still somehow have to alter the chemicals that make up the macromolecules that make up the cells that make up our bodies in a way to correct whatever dysfunction is being treated, which would in the end be a chemical effect, but I guess admitting that is just not as sexy as claiming that you can use some sort of digital “key” to “upload” various “quantum medicines” directly into the brain and body using—of course!—your computer, tablet, or smartphone:
And here’s a hilariously off-base description of why ZAG’s “technology” is allegedly so superior to what exists in medicine:
The entire universe including the human body and maladies that afflict it operates on the principles of quantum mechanics. Chemical based treatment systems do not operate according to those princicples and, as such, are not compatible with human physiology as evidenced by their adverse side-effects. Conventional pharmaceuticals are chemicals that act only on the physical level. On the other hand, QuantumMAN™ delivers medicine on a quantum level to the multiple realms within the human body with an efficacy unmatched by primitive drug delivery systems. Moreover, QuantumMAN™ delivers his quantum treatments without the slightest chance of collateral damage to the host.
I’m sure it would be news to Richard Feynman (a.k.a. the real Quantum Man)—were he still alive of course—that chemical-based treatments (which are basically nothing more than chemicals whose reaction with chemicals in the human body, such as proteins, DNA, RNA, carbohydrates, and the like determines their activity) don’t operate according to the principles of quantum physics. In fact, come to think of it, I bet it would be news to Professor Feynman that quantum effects are not on a “physical level.” Seriously, though, if ZAG could find a single drug that somehow violates the principles of quantum physics and convincingly demonstrate that it did, there would be a Nobel Prize there for whoever did the research! Not surprisingly, there is the usual misunderstanding of quantum entanglement as somehow affecting large, macro-level objects that woo-meisters of many stripes routinely demonstrate. None of this is particularly surprising. It is, however, rather amusing. Or it would be, if these charlatans didn’t apparently charge a fair amount of money for their PAK™s.
In fact, there’s seemingly nothing that QuantumMAN™ can’t do! Apparently, you can vaccinate yourself against malaria, influenza, and even the common cold! You can even protect your children from becoming addicted to meth by downloading some ZAG goodness into them, or, failing that, cure them (or yourself) of meth addiction.. If you have an infection, you can treat it with a quantum antibiotic, and if you’re in pain, you can take Zaxis™, which promises 24 hour pain control. Why only 24 hours if quantum medicine is so much more awesome than regular medicine? Who knows? Then, of course, there are a wide variety of ZAG products designed to help you lose weight because, well, you know, all that dieting and exercising is just so “chemical” compared to the quantum goodness at the heart of QuantumMAN™. You can even undergo a form of “quantum gastric bypass surgery” by reprogramming your brain, if you want. Even more amazingly, if you’re a female going through menopause, you can provide yourself with quantum hormone replacement therapy.
And, of course, if all else fails, there’s always Quantum Doctor (QDr™) or Quantum Chiropractor (QChiro™), while you can also detoxify. Quantumly, of course:
ZAG, the private humanitarian medical research group that employs QuantumMAN™, developed Quantum Detox™ as a bio-weapon against disease for QuantumMAN™’s exploits. Quantum Detox™ is one of the many developments derived from ZAG’s radical new quantum information technology based on quantum physics. Quantum Detox™ is biosoftware that utilizes a set of PAKs™ that are downloaded to your personal computer, smartphone or tablet. When you click on the desired amount of PAKs™ you wish to dose, quantum bioinformation linked to their activation codes is uploaded directly to your brain’s neural network via quantum teleportation. This quantum bioinformation consists of physiologic directives that program your brain to the specifications of Quantum Detox™’s master programs. QuantumMAN™ is the personification of this quantum data which consists of repeater programs that deliver quantum bioinformation several times a day for 30 days.
Lovely.
But what about evidence? I managed to find ZAG’s “clinical trial” page. When I looked at the “clinical trials” described in the various links on the page, what did I find? If you guessed that I found actual clinical trial results, you’d be so very wrong indeed. If you guessed that I found anecdotes and testimonials, give yourself a PAK™ on the back! You’re a winner. For instance, in this case of back pain (re-evaluated with applied kinesiology, of course), using ZAG’s methods fixed her “alignment” issues, and apparently ZAG can even cure urinary tract infections and can fix your sex life (or at least let you download orgasms). It’s even good for horses!
And ya might not believe this little fella, but it’ll cure your erectile dysfunction too.
You know, after reading enough of this site to melt my brain in a quantum fashion, a question comes up. If QuantumMAN™ technology is so awesome, why does it require a smartphone, tablet, or computer to get the PAK™s to your brain? Why the intermediary? After all, if QuantumMAN™ is really using quantum teleportation, why can’t it just upload the PAK™s to your brain directly from its amazingly awesome extraterrestrial computers, when you need them? In fact, why does ZAG even need PayPal to collect its fees? Inquiring minds want to know!
There’s so much material on the QuantumMAN™ website, that I could easily have fun with it for multiple posts, but such is not the purpose of my taking this on. The thought also crossed my mind that the whole thing could be an elaborate hoax by skeptics designed to mock the use and abuse of the term “quantum” by quacks. I’d actually be fine with that, but I doubt that’s the case. There’s too much salesmanship going on, and there is an actual checkout for the store selling these “downloads.” I doubt skeptics would risk fraud charges by actually collecting money from the credulous for the sake of a joke or parody, but I suppose I could be wrong. I also tend to doubt skeptics would go to the expense of renting a booth at the 2013 International CES conference in Las Vegas next month for a company it calls Extraterrestrial Technology based in Honolulu. That’s unfortunate, because I was just in Honolulu a little more than two weeks ago. If any of our readers are going to CES next week, do drop by the booth. I’d love to hear a report of what sort of goodies ZAG has for CES attendees. It’s Booth 35853.
I also realize that some readers might ask why I’m bothering with a site that is so obviously full of pseudoscience that is even more nonsensical than the usual pseudoscience we encounter on this blog, and I do promise to start 2013 out by going back to my usual topics. In the meantime, however, my answers this question are threefold. First, I wanted to have a little fun. Second, I wanted to show an example of just how far quacks will abuse legitimate scientific terms in order to sell nonsensical products. And, third: Reductio ad absurdum. Except that I don’t have to do the reductio ad absurdum myself. The quacks have already done it for me.
Don’t even get me started on Bill Nelson’s EPFX/QXCI Quantum Xrroid Consciousness Interface. Maybe later in 2013. Or, if that’s not bizarre enough, there’s always DNA Activation.
Maybe later in 2013, between my usual oh-so-serious SBM epics.

Biofield Tuning: Another Example of Tooth Fairy Science
Biofield tuning uses tuning forks to assess the health of clients. This study of inter-rater agreement is a prime example of Tooth Fairy science.
Harriet Hall on November 3, 2020
Link

A study recently published in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine is titled “Inter-Rater Agreement of Biofield Tuning: Testing a Novel Health Assessment Procedure“. It is a prime example of what I call Tooth Fairy Science, defined in the Skeptic’s Dictionary as “doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that the phenomenon exists.” It was so silly it made me laugh, and maybe you will laugh too. Amidst all the distressing news about COVID-19, a little laughter is welcome.
The study explains, “Practitioners of Biofield Tuning assess health status of their clients by detecting off-the-body biofield perturbations using tuning fork (TF) vibrations. This study tested inter-rater agreement (IRA) on location of these perturbations.”
Yes, you read that right: tuning forks.
The authors were four PhDs, one ND, and an MA. The study was funded by the Biofield Tuning Institute (Burlington, VT), an organization founded by the lead author.
What they did
Ten subjects were tested by three Biofield Tuning practitioners in randomized order. They struck a 174 Hz tuning fork on a handheld hockey puck and “combed” four sites on the left and right sides of the base of the spine and the heart.
At each site, the audibly vibrating TF is first moved slowly from about six feet away toward the client, supine on a treatment table, to detect the edge of the client’s biofield. The edge is identified by the perception of resistance, tonal change, or a stronger vibration of the fork. The practitioner then moves the resonating TF slowly through the field toward the body, with the aim of detecting perturbations, “turbulence,” or significant tonal changes. When these areas are encountered, the practitioner pauses to allow the sound to break up stuck energy and provide the body with a coherent signal around which to better organize itself. After a perturbation has been resolved, the practitioner resumes moving the activated TF toward the body until the next area of turbulence is detected.
They reported 6.3 perturbations per combed site. There was no control group. Not surprisingly, inter-rater agreement was low. They noted potential weaknesses of their study. They said that the methods of the study may not reflect the complexities of clinical practice and worried that two untested assumptions might have influenced their results: (1) that the process of TF detection does not alter the properties of a perturbation for subsequent detection, and (2) that inter-practitioner variability of their own biofields may contribute to the low IRA.
Their conclusion:
while our research team of biofield practitioners and researchers found the process of collaborative protocol development a valuable endeavor, the agreed upon design may have been suboptimal for testing IRA of Biofield Tuning in a clinically relevant manner. Finally, it is important to note that the present study did not set out to test the existence of a biofield, only to evaluate IRA of an intervention whose explanatory model states that health-related information can be detected at off-the-body sites.
Conclusion: A useless, meaningless study
Their last sentence reveals that this was Tooth Fairy science. They did not set out to test the existence of a biofield. Shouldn’t that have been the first step? If the biofield doesn’t exist, these practitioners were fooling themselves, just as Emily Rosa’s therapeutic touch practitioners fooled themselves. If the biofield were real, this wouldn’t be Tooth Fairy science, but it would still be appallingly bad science. The flaws start with the small size and lack of a control group, but there are many more obvious flaws.
This monumentally silly study could be labeled “For entertainment purposes only”. It may be good for laughs, but it’s not science.

ZYTO: An Electrodermal Diagnostic Device Is Tested and Fails Miserably
ZYTO is a bogus, illegal electrodermal diagnostic device that claims to evaluate organ function and make dietary recommendations. Repeat testing produced results that were wildly inconsistent. The device produces noise, not meaningful information.
Harriet Hall on August 29, 2017
Link

Dr. Stephen Barrett, the founder of Quackwatch, had abundant reason to believe the ZYTO electrodermal testing device couldn’t possibly work as claimed, but belief is not enough: science requires evidence from testing. He followed the advice we so often hear: “Don’t knock it until you’ve tried it.” He managed to obtain a ZYTO (The Elite 5.0) and he used it to test himself repeatedly. He reported his results on Quackwatch, in the journal Missouri Medicine (114:238-244, 2017), and in Skeptical Inquirer (41:5, p. 40-45, 2017). This is the first time such a study of an electrodermal diagnostic device has ever been published.
In my opinion, electrodermal testing is bogus. The devices are basically galvanometers that measure skin resistance. Galvanic skin resistance has no relation to diagnosis or treatment of any disease, but practitioners claim to diagnose and treat all diseases, food allergies, nutrient deficiencies, even defective teeth! I have written two previous articles about it: “Fooling Patients with a Computerized Magic Eight Ball,” and “Legal and Regulatory Aspects.” And Dr. Barrett has written an extensive critique on Quackwatch. He says, “The practitioners who use them are either delusional, dishonest, or both.”
Quackwatch lists 43 brands of these EAV (electroacupuncture of Voll) devices. Many of them rely on probes that are touched to specific points on the skin (“acupoints”). Those readings vary with the amount of pressure applied, the condition of the skin, and other factors. The ZYTO device attempts to minimize operator influence by using a cradle that the patients rest their hand on.
What ZYTO claims to do
The company website makes extravagant claims for what it calls “biocommunication” and “innovative decision support technology.” It “helps inform your wellness decisions by providing accurate readings directly from your body.” The patient rests a hand on the cradle, a computer program presents questions in the form of digital signatures, and the body answers directly by changing galvanic skin resistance. The questions might be ones the patient knew about and wanted answered, or they might be “unknown” questions.
    • The testing allegedly can help with all these personal wellness areas: energy, lifestyle, gut health, detoxification, relationships, weight loss, environmental factors, nutrition, performance, anti-aging.
    • The software evaluates 20 body organs to determine if their functioning is “in range” or “out of range.” It tests everything from the pineal to the spleen, from the thymus to the small intestine, from the lung to the pancreas. For the condition of each organ, they have allegedly determined unique digital signatures that are connected through acupuncture meridians.
    • Then it tests various remedies to see which ones show the most coherent responses – which supplements, homeopathic remedies, diet changes, or procedures would restore the “out of range” readings to “in range.”
    • It does a nutritional survey to determine which foods the individual should be eating or avoiding.
    • It generates a multi-page report with colored graphs and charts.
    • Manufacturers submit their products so the company can create a library of their digital signatures to test.
    • Testing can be done remotely by connecting a hand cradle to the client’s computer.
If all this sounds preposterous, that’s because it is.
Dr. Barrett’s results
Dr. Barrett did a total of 43 basic and nutritional scans on himself over a ten-day period. A series of 16 basic scans over four days identified an average of 11 organs that were out of range, but the organs varied from scan to scan, as did the direction (above or below range) and the corrective measures recommended. The organs that were furthest out of range were the adrenal glands (on 4 scans), the small intestine (3), the heart (2), the thymus (2), and various other organs (once each). Only four of the scans found any organs within range.
Dr. Barrett’s tests reported his gallbladder function as positively out of range 4 times, negatively out of range 4 times, and within range 8 times. Interesting, since he doesn’t have a gallbladder! He does have benign prostatic hypertrophy; his prostate failed to show up on one scan, and was reported as positively out of range on 7 scans, negatively out of range on 4, and within range on 8.
He went on to conduct 12 food category tests and 15 individual food assessments. The results were inconsistent. The category tests recommended avoiding:
    • Grains (10 tests out of 12)
    • Nuts and seeds (9 tests out of 12)
    • Fruits and vegetables (8 tests out of 12)
    • Fruits, vegetables and grains (5 tests out of 12)
One recommended only beans/legumes. One recommended only beverages, fish/seafood, meats/poultry, and spices/seasonings. One recommended only sugars/sweeteners! If clients were to follow ZYTO recommendations, there is a good possibility they would be dangerously malnourished.
The individual food assessment results were also wildly inconsistent. The same food could be positive (recommended) on one test and negative (not recommended) on a repeat test a few minutes later. Pineapple and red potatoes were among the top negative foods on 7 tests and among the top positive foods on 3 tests.
Dr. Barrett applied a statistical test and confirmed that the results did not differ from random. In other words, they were noise, not meaningful data. He points out that to demonstrate that a device can measure something, it must be repeatedly tested to evaluate its accuracy and consistency. The ZYTO company has not done any such tests. To demonstrate that the device can detect organ pathology, patients with disease would have to be tested against a control group without disease. ZYTO has not done any such tests. To demonstrate that a recommended corrective remedy or action improves outcomes, people who are treated would have to be compared to people who are not. ZYTO has not done any such tests.
Regulation
ZYTO has FDA clearance, but only as a galvanic skin measurement device. It does not have FDA approval as a diagnostic device. The FDA has warned the company that selling or marketing it as a diagnostic device is illegal and that it was making unallowable claims; some of their software was recalled. Users of the device often attempt to weasel out by claiming that it is not a medical or diagnostic device and instead calling it something like a “general wellness device” or a “biocommunication” device, and using non-diagnostic language like “out of range.” But a rose by any other name is still a rose. Customers are clearly led to believe that they are being diagnosed and treated.
Electrodermal diagnostic devices cannot be legally marketed in the US, and importation is banned. Regulatory actions have included confiscation of devices, criminal prosecutions, and professional licensing board actions. But there has been no systematic or effective effort to eliminate them, and they are still being widely used by various licensed and unlicensed practitioners.
Conclusion: Not only pseudoscientific but illegal
In my opinion, based on my research, electrodermal diagnosis is not based on reality but on a ridiculous hodgepodge of half-baked ideas borrowed from acupuncture, homeopathy, and so-called “energy medicine.” The claims are preposterous; there isn’t the slightest shred of science to support them. And thanks to Dr. Barrett we now have clear evidence that the results they produce are wildly inconsistent and clinically meaningless, and the recommendations are potentially dangerous. These abuses could be stopped by enforcing existing laws. These devices and the associated software should be removed from the market to protect consumers. Practitioners using the devices should be prosecuted.
Note: as I was writing this, I received an email from someone who had been tested with a related device, the Asyra. She had gone to Simply Health in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, where she saw Jennifer Nelson-Hawks, whose bio bills her as an iridologist and a “board-certified holistic health physician” but does not mention any medical training beyond “Certified Medical Assistant.” Asyra testing showed she had the “energetic signature for Lyme’s Disease” which was “concerning” although she “probably didn’t have the full-blown disease,” and she was told to take vitamin C to support her immune system, see a naturopath, and return for a follow-up with the Asyra tester in a month. She suffered a week of anxiety and panic, desperately contacting her GP and others for advice. She found my SBM article on electrodermal testing and contacted me to ask what I would do in her position, whether I would do anything to report the practitioner or her business. I encouraged her to report her experience to all the relevant authorities and to try to get her money back, since it was obtained under false pretenses. This is just one example of the harm done by users of these devices.

This Scary Mask Is Not for Halloween: It’s for Anti-Aging Skin Care
Evidence is lacking for CurrentBody’s “anti-aging” LED mask.
Harriet Hall on March 1, 2022
Link

CurrentBody’s LED mask provides “anti-aging” red and near-infra-red light therapy to the face. It is supposed to improve the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, “clinically proven to reduce wrinkles by 35% in just 4 weeks”. It promises to improve skin tone and texture and firm the skin. It has won many beauty awards and is loved by celebrities like Kaley Cuoco, Renee Zellweger, and Kate Hudson. 95% of users said their skin tone, texture, firmness, and tightness was improved.
The price of the full kit has been dropped from $868 to $628; such a deal! The mask alone sells for $399. They recommend using it for 10 minutes a day, 3-5 times a week. Some users do it every day.
The device combines Red (633nm) and near Infra-Red Light (830nm) to penetrate deep below the skin’s surface, delivering key nutrients to skin’s cells to stimulate the natural rejuvenation process. This encourages the skin to efficiently repair and renew it’s [sic] cells, naturally reversing the ageing process. The dual technology also helps to increase the production of collagen to reveal a firmer, tighter complexion.
This therapy must be good since it originated with NASA. “NASA discovered that LED light stimulates the body’s natural skin cell renewal process, using the technology for muscle repair and reducing inflammation.”
Testimonials claim glowing skin and benefits beyond the skin: relief of jaw pain, relaxing the trapezius, less stomach bloat and a flatter belly, relief of low back pain and period pain, scar over eyebrow no longer visible, mood improved, improved sleep. It is said to reduce stress, increase serotonin levels, to boost radiance, to improve blood flow, and to boost oxygen to the skin cells. Light therapy has been shown effective for treating Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), acne, and some other conditions. Some studies have shown promise, but the evidence is far from conclusive. Here’s the study they cite – note that it doesn’t test the mask they are selling.
There are many other LED mask products on the market. Is CurrentBody’s better than the others? I couldn’t find any studies comparing one to another.
Conclusion: Glowing testimonials but no conclusive evidence
The testimonials go far beyond the science and claim benefits that are subjective and are almost certainly placebo effects not due to the mask. It may be worth the big bucks to some people who can afford it. It may provide confidence and improve their self-image. I’m not convinced.

Visual Stress
The Opticalm Clinic claims to diagnose and treat visual stress with colored lenses and other aids. Visual stress is a poorly defined, questionable condition and Opticalm’s claims are not backed by scientific evidence.
Harriet Hall on August 11, 2020
Link

What does “visual stress” mean? It appears to be a new term for what has also been called Irlen syndrome (described by Steve Novella in 2013 as an “alternative medicine zombie”), Meares-Irlen syndrome, and scotopic sensitivity syndrome. It is a proposed visual disorder that remains highly controversial. It is said to cause reading difficulties and to be treatable with colored overlays or tinted glasses. The Opticalm Visual Stress Clinic in Ontario offers evaluations and products to treat it.
Visual stress is said to cause
    • Sensitivity to bright and fluorescent lighting and glare
    • Slow or inefficient reading
    • Poor reading comprehension
    • Poor attention and concentration
    • Eye strain
    • Fatigue
    • Headaches and migraines
    • Poor depth perception
Is visual stress real? Is it a meaningful term?
The Wikipedia article conveniently reviews the research and has a section on “scientific repudiation” that asks:
     1.  Whether it exists as a distinct, predictably identifiable disease with a reasonable pathophysiological mechanism, or whether a range of symptoms from other conditions are being placed under this convenient heading;
     2.  Whether it is causally or incidentally related to dyslexia, autism, or other conditions; and
     3.  Whether existing methods of scotopic sensitivity syndrome treatment are appropriate and effective.
It goes on to review statements by several professional organizations that question the diagnosis, attribute the symptoms to other diagnoses, and discourage the use of colored lenses
Opticalm
The Opticalm clinic estimates that Visual Stress affects 20% of poor readers and 15% of the general population. It promises to:
    • Reduce: Symptoms of migraine, photophobia, post-concussion symptoms, visual sensory processing disorder, ADHD and post-stroke vision problems.
    • Relieve: Headache, eye pain and strain, light and screen sensitivity, nausea from movement, visual sensory overload and cognitive fatigue.
    • Improve: Learning, reading, attention, mood, visual perception, balance, confidence, general health, behaviour, recovery time and the effectiveness of other therapies.
Their online store sells non-LCD computers, screen tinting software, lighting solutions, colored overlays, paper and pens, and more. Their website offers a self-test; I took it to see what would happen. The test asks a variety of questions such as whether you have light sensitivity, headaches, difficulty with balance, ADHD, autism, Tourette syndrome, etc. I filled it out as honestly as I could, and received an email in response. It consisted of a more detailed questionnaire and a list of their services and pricing. Assessment services cost $485.00 and a formal report, $125.00. I would think most customers would want a formal report.
They use a device called the Intuitive Colorimeter to present different colors to patients to determine the specific color that will benefit them the most, based on the hypothesis that the optimal color needs to be specifically prescribed, with precision.
Eye strain? Migraine?
The term “eyestrain” is a nonspecific term that means different things to different people: dry eyes, fatigue, headaches, double vision, eye discomfort, and more. Migraine is not known to be caused by “visual stress”.
Conclusion: I am skeptical
This clinic offers to assess and treat a vague, questionable diagnosis. I’m not convinced that their services are worth $485 of my money. I don’t doubt that some conditions may be improved by colored lenses or overlays; but we need better, more specific evidence, and it doesn’t make sense to prematurely rush into treatments that may or may not work. Needless to say, the “research” they list does not include any controlled studies to evaluate whether their clients experience objective benefits.

Joovv and Other Red Light Therapies
The Joovv Go is a handheld device for red light therapy. Red light therapy remains controversial: most of the claims are not supported by credible scientific evidence.
Harriet Hall on October 4, 2022
Link

I recently received an email urging me to try the Joovv Go, a small handheld device designed to provide red light therapy while travelling, to treat pain, relax muscles, and provide faster recovery after workouts.
Use and alleged benefits
It will allegedly “optimize cellular function, and improve overall health and wellness.” It can be set to emit either red light or near-infrared light, and in Recovery+ mode it provides both red light and pulsed infrared light. Eye protection is advised. It can cause detox symptoms if the body is starved for light. It should be held 6-12 inches from the treatment area starting with 1-2 minutes and building up to 10-20 minutes over a period of 2-3 weeks as your body acclimates to the therapy. Daily use is recommended, and whole-body treatments will get best results. For topical heating treatments, the device can be held 1-2 inches away. It is not FDA approved, which would mean that the FDA had reviewed data provided by the manufacturer and had determined that the benefits outweighed the risks, but is “cleared” by the FDA, which only means the manufacturer can demonstrate that their product is “substantially equivalent to another (similar) legally marketed device” that already has FDA clearance or approval.Red light therapy allegedly has benefits for mental acuity, circadian rhythm, performance and recovery, sleep optimization, healthy skin, inflammation, and improved blood flow. I know manufacturers’ websites and testimonials are not trustworthy sources, and I wondered how many of those claims could be confirmed elsewhere. As I kept looking, I soon realized that the question “does it work?” could be answered “yes, no, and maybe.” Not everyone is qualified to judge what constitutes convincing evidence.
Other devices
There are many other devices on the market that provide red light therapy, ranging from panels to handheld devices. Other red light therapy devices I have previously written about include the DNA Vibe Jazz Band, the Willow Curve device, and the CurrentBody mask. Joovv itself sells several different devices with prices ranging from $599 to over $10,000. I couldn’t find any studies comparing Joovv to other brands.
Other sources express concerns
I did find independent sources with comments that were skeptical. According to the Cleveland Clinic:
Most experts say that they don’t know yet if RLT is effective for all its claimed uses. Most say that the studies published so far show some potential for certain conditions, but that more studies need to be conducted. Red light therapy is still an emerging treatment that’s generating growing interest. But at this point in time, there’s not enough evidence to support most uses.
And
There’s no scientific evidence to support red light therapy use in weight loss, cancer, cellulite removal or mental health concerns like depression and seasonal affective disorder (SAD).
According to one online review, the Joovv Go provides “decreased muscle pain, deeper sleep and more energy.” On the other hand, a 3 star review from the brand’s official site spoke of not having any benefits from the light. They expressed their disappointment saying, “Well, it’s been two months and I’ve been using 10 min every day. I was hoping it would improve my mild hip pain and help my plantar fasciitis. So far it’s still the same.”Their own website says “red and near infrared light remains somewhat controversial in the medical community and the full potential is still not completely understood among researchers.”It is seldom covered by insurance. Red light therapy is also known as LLLT (Low Level Laser Therapy) Aetna considers it experimental and investigational for a long list of indications because of insufficient evidence.WebMD says :
Researchers have known about red light therapy for a while. But there aren’t a lot of studies on it, and they don’t know if it’s better than other types of treatment used to help you heal.
And “researchers aren’t exactly sure how and why it works.” They list a number of small studies showing that it “may” help with dementia, dental pain, hair loss, osteoarthritis, tendinitis, and wrinkles.Healthline says:
Many studies have had promising results, but the benefits of red light therapy are still a source of controversy. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) for example, has determined that there isn’t enough evidence to show that these devices are better than currently existing treatments for treating wounds, ulcers, and pain.
And so it goes.
Conclusion: Red light therapy may work, but the evidence is insufficient
Testimonials may be enough to convince some people, but if you’re looking for treatments supported by scientific studies, you will find the evidence for red light therapy lacking.ll

Red Flags For Red Light Therapy
Red light therapy is marketed as a quick fix for fat loss and wellness. The science says otherwise.
Scott Gavura on September 25, 2025
Link
Simply search “Red Light Therapy” on your favourite social media platform and behold the misinformation.
If you’ve been on social media, you’ve probably seen ads for red light therapy — glowing panels, masks and spa treatments promising everything from fat and weight loss to “optimized cellular function” and boosted “energy”. There are a huge number of devices available, with some sold in pharmacies and big box retailers. Given how popular (and potentially expensive) obesity treatments can be today, it’s perhaps not a surprise that red light therapy is being pitched as a non-drug, non-invasive solution. When I see products like these, my first question is always the same: Is there evidence to support this?
What is Red Light Therapy?
“laser”
Red light therapy (RLT), or low-level laser therapy (LLLT) (also sometimes called photobiomodulation (PBM)) uses light in the red light (600 – 700nm) or near-infrared (780 – 1000nm) spectrum, usually delivered by LEDs or lasers. Unlike ultraviolet light, which can damage skin, red and near-infrared light penetrate deeper without causing burns. Proponents claim this light stimulates mitochondria – the “powerhouses” of our cells – to produce more energy (ATP), which supposedly improves healing, reduces inflammation, and accelerates fat breakdown. How red light simulates mitochondria is thought to be through interaction with cytochrome c oxidase (CCO), a key enzyme in the mitochondrial electron transport chain. Red and near-infrared light are thought to be absorbed by CCO, displacing nitric oxide (NO), which otherwise blocks mitochondrial respiration.
The idea sounds appealing and astonishingly simple: shine light, energize your cells, and your body performs better. But while this effect on mitochondria has been observed in vitro, in cells in labs, translating that effect into outcomes that we actually care about, like weight loss or some other measure of improved health, is a very different challenge.
Weight Loss Claims
One of the more common promises made by red light therapy manufacturers and influencers is weight loss or just “melting fat.” Advertisements suggest that shining red light on the body can break down fat cells, reduce cellulite, and shrink waistlines without diet or exercise. While some studies do report modest reductions in waist, hip, or abdominal measurements, these conclusions typically come from small, short-duration trials. Some are device-manufacturer-sponsored, and rely on less accurate surrogate measures (e.g., inches lost) rather than direct measures of fat mass or sustained weight change. Risks of bias are high.
A 2025 meta-analysis by Sun et al. pooled 11 randomized controlled trials with 569 participants and reported statistically significant, though modest, improvements in weight (–3.54 kg), BMI (–1.18 units), and waist circumference (–7.28 cm), along with favourable changes in metabolic and inflammatory markers. The authors concluded that RLT may be a promising adjunct for weight management but emphasized the need for larger, longer-duration, and higher-quality studies. Importantly, most of the included trials were small and heterogeneous, so the true clinical relevance remains unclear.
Overall, the evidence for red light therapy as a weight loss intervention remains weak. Apparent effects may reflect temporary fluid shifts, measurement bias, or placebo effects rather than true fat loss. Red light cannot “vaporize” fat – the body has no mechanism to simply eliminate it this way, and metabolism doesn’t work like that.
Regulation and Risks
Red light therapy is generally marketed as safe and noninvasive, and studies report few adverse effects. The most common side effects include mild skin irritation, eye strain, and headaches, particularly if protective eyewear is not used. Longer-term safety after frequent and prolonged exposure has not been as well studied. Ultimately, safety depends on the specific product in use, and how it is used. There are hundreds, if not thousands of products marketed.
Cost, however, is unavoidable. Spas or wellness clinic treatments can cost hundreds, especially if you have multiple sessions. Home devices range from several hundred dollars to several thousand, with no guarantee of durability or clear evidence of effectiveness. Importantly, each product is unique (considering design, power output, and wavelengths) and it’s consequently not possible to extrapolate the findings from one product to another.
Regulation is mixed and depends on the jurisdiction. Where products are cleared for sale by regulators (e.g., the FDA in the United States) it may only be approved for marketing for limited uses like temporary pain relief or improving skin appearance. Claims about fat loss, enhanced performance, or broader health benefits do not appear to have been formally assessed and approved by any regulator. This means much of the marketing surrounding red light therapy stretches well beyond what regulators have evaluated, leaving consumers left to themselves to evaluate the claims.
Trendy, yes. Evidence-informed, no.
Red light therapy is widely promoted as a treatment for many conditions. The evidence for weight loss is not impressive. While some small studies suggest modest improvements in certain measures, the evidence is inconsistent and based on short-term outcomes. As they say, more research is required.
From a first principles perspective, it seems obvious that red light therapy cannot simply “melt fat” or trigger effortless weight loss. Moreover, sustained health changes will be necessary to sustain any temporary effects, even if they are real.
Reassuringly, red light therapy appears safe when used appropriately and carefully. However the long-term risks are less well understood. High costs is a expected side effect, with potentially substantial costs. Until better evidence emerges, I’d put a red light on red light therapy and look at any claims very skeptically.

Low Level Lasers: N-Rays in action.
Mark Crislip on August 24, 2012
Link
I do not want to get all angsty and omphaloskeptic, but I have been thinking more of late about the purpose of the blog and my role in it. Blogs,and the people who write them, are ephemeral. It takes a unique personality and commitment to churn out these essays and commit them to the ether. Especially since Michelson and Morley.
I have never given much thought as to who our readers are, at least as a composite. I read most of the comments on every entry and have certainly developed a mental picture of some of our regular commenters, although I suspect I probably do not have even the gender correct most of the time. The commenters represent a tiny fraction of the regular readers and an even smaller fraction of occasional readers. It occurs to me I haven’t a clue who the real audience of this blog is.
I write first for my own education and entertainment, then for the slightly bored and overwhelmed medicine resident, since that is who I spend most of my time educating at work. Someone educated with an understanding of basic medicine but has more important things on their mind than a need for a detailed understanding of why homeopathy is complete nonsense. I doubt the majority of my readers are health care workers and I suspect continuing medical education is not a major part of the blog.
I never considered SBM to be a consumer protection group, but this week my wife showed me a half page advertisement in the local paper, and I realized that not only was the advertisement a good topic for blogging, but consumer protection is a fundamental result of this blog. There really is no site on the interweb that looks at both SCAM and real medicine with quite the same skeptical eye. Here is the headline:
A Special Wellness Report
New Medicine Based On An 88- Year Old Theory By Albert Einstein Can Help Almost Everyone Who Is Sick Or Injured!
New? Well, on the Googles I find the same headline for an identical ad and the same ill at ease looking dog going back to 2008 and it was a topic by my second favorite computer in 2009*.
Einstein was one smart person, no doubt, but what does he have to do with medicine? Put your pinky in the corner of you mouth and say “sea bass.” Sorry. Lasers. Fricken lasers.
Since Einstein came up with the first description of lasers he is responsible for their medical application. It is a good thing Einstein is dead, as I am not certain if he would be happy to associated with this particular application of ideas. He was not fond of E=mc2 being turned into an atomic bomb, and, while not as potentially awful as the a-bomb, he was not a fan of the misapplication of any of this ideas.
The advertisement is by Dr. Larry Lytle. The Doctor is in dentistry (and when I think of universal disease treatments, I think dentist. Got lung cancer? See a dentist. Rabies. Dentist. Cavities? Acupuncturist. But that’s me) and the PhD is from Donsbach University, an educational facility of suspect provenance.
The advertisement starts with
Registered with the FDA to be 100% Safe
In 2009 the FDA approved the use of “Healing Light” for Osteoarthritis of the Hand.
Evidently, the limited FDA approval was noted and then expanded upon, resulting in 2011 in a warning letter noting
A review of our records reveals that you did not obtain marketing approval or clearance before you began offering the Q10 Laser and the 808 Enhancer Probe for sale, which is a violation of the law.
and although
A review of our records indicates that we cleared a premarket notification (510(k)) for the Q1000 Laser and 660 Enhancer Probe (QLaser System), K080513, with an intended use “for providing temporary relief of pain associated with osteoarthritis of the hand, which has been diagnosed by a physician or other licensed medical professional.
it was being marketed for other medical reasons. As a result there is now an asterisk pointing to the bottom of the ad which was not present in 2008. The new warning states
“The QLaser system is indicated for providing temporary relief of pain associated with osteoarthritis of the hand, which has been diagnosed by a physician or other licensed medical professional. No other medical treatment claims are made or implied.”
No other medical treatment claims are made or implied?!? Lets see. Lasers can be used
To help almost every health problem ever experienced by a human being!
I guess since no specific disease is mentioned, it qualifies.
It least the description is true.
a somewhat un- scientific description of how this “Healing Light” can potentially reverse the damage done by human sickness and disease…It (low level lasers) reenergizes the cells in your body with the right kind and proper amount of healing energy…low level lasers have been clinically shown to reduce pain, reduce inflammation, increase cellular energy, increase cell permeability (so nutrients the cells needs to heal can get into the cell and even help correct faulty DNA*
The asterisk is where the aforementioned warning comes in. But he summed it up nicely: un-scientific.
Dr. Lytle is understandably coy in his advertisement as to what can be treated with his laser; the FDA is watching after all. His collected works are not.
…program your Q1000 with CANCELING FLU REQUENCIES and apply your laser preventively.
or
Low level lasers such as the Q1000 that produce soliton waves carry electrons back to the damaged atoms and cells, helping to restore normal DNA composition and normal, positive soliton wave communications between cells.
This process is how low level laser therapy can be effective for diabetes. Remember that Type II diabetes results when cellular receptor sites have been altered and will not allow insulin to attach.
This reduces the cell’s ability to produce adequate ATP – the cells energy blocks. When this damaged cell is reproduced millions of times, the result is Type II diabetes.
Low level laser therapy and particularly the patented Q1000 laser produces soliton waves that carry electrons to the damaged cells, restoring their capability to function normally. Mode 3 of the Q1000 has 29 pre-programmed frequencies that have proven effective at restoring intercellular communication and helping to reduce blood sugar levels for Type II diabetics
Slightly un-scientific seems unnecessarily modest. Of course, his lasers treat pain of all types.
So what are low level lasers? Lasers that are put on the skin that emit laser light that does not result in heating, usually somewhere in the infrared spectrum. There is enormous variability in the various low level laser or cold lasers on the market with little (or lytle) in the way of standardization.
The first question is not does it work, but should it work? Is there biologic plausibility?
Low level lasers are supposed to work by
The photochemical theory, which is not yet universally accepted, (which) postulates that the absorbed light interacts with chromophores (organic molecules) which in turn modulate cellular activities.
A simple question is how much laser light actually penetrates the skin? Hardly any.
The intensity of laser radiation reduced by 66% after being transmitted through a 0.784mm sample of human abdominal tissue. In this study most laser radiation was absorbed within the first 1mm of skin.”
and
The penetration of both He-Ne and infra-red lasers was observed for only a few millimeters. The most important absorption was observed at the depth level of 0.4 and 0.5 mm. These results suggested that the dermal vascular plexus barrier seemed to decrease the penetration at that level. This finding should mean that the laser therapy did not have really direct effects on the deep tissues.
It would seem unlikely that the gentleman quoted in one of Dr. Lytle’s testimonials who had relief from passing the laser over his prostate was having effect from the light. If you are a fan of prior plausibility, then low level lasers should only have effects on the most superficial of cutaneous problems.
However, a lack of plausibility is no barrier, since “ the effects can be mediated by many different pathways.”
Wandering the pubmeds and interwebs on low level lasers is a lot like wandering the acupuncture literature. Lasers are popular, has innumerable anecdotes, the validation of those are get paid to offer it and there are enough suggestive lousy studies to keep the therapy alive.
It is difficult to compare results of the various studies into laser therapy as parameters, when fully recorded, often vary. Different conditions are treated, different dosages utilised and different outcome measures are recorded. Investigative findings are ambiguous. For practically every supportive trial, there is a contradictory counterpart. Laser appears a popular therapy lacking sufficient supportive research.
The is no good biologic reason to think that low level laser would have any effect. Most of the purported mechanisms are unimpressive and often in cell cultures where that pesky skin is not in the way. There is apparently no disease that low level laser can’t treat, including acupuncture or perhaps I misread the list. Acupuncture isn’t a disease is it? And it is quantum.
Like the various forms of acupuncture, there is no consensus on where to apply the lasers, what duration, what dose, what wavelength and whether or not to pulse the light.
Like acupuncture the most consistent effect is a decrease in pain, a subjective endpoint that is subject to bias, and like acupuncture, there is no reliable and consistent effect on any objective endpoint.
Like acupuncture, there is a huge literature (4000 on the Pubmeds) of mostly poorly done studies, some showing effect, some not. The Cochrane reviews were not supportive of laser therapy, but note the studies are uniformly lousy.
Like acupuncture, better studies demonstrate decreasing effects.
Like acupuncture, many of the studies are done by believers and published in journals who raison d’etre is the intervention being studied. There is more than ample opportunity for the N-Ray effect.
Like acupuncture, reading the literature suggests there is no reason for lasers to have any real effects beyond placebo, which regular readers know I consider to be no more than the patient convincing themselves they are improved when, in fact, they are not.
The status of laser therapy is not unlike that of acupuncture a decade ago: a complete mess from which you can draw any conclusion you like, but, given prior plausibility and every helpful rules of Ioannidis, suggest that it is all sound and fury signifying nothing.
Unlike acupuncture I would not totally dismiss low level laser. Superficial benefits, like minor wound healing, are not without plausibility, but probably of little clinical relevance.
I suspect that time and careful studies on the efficacy of low level laser will have the same results as the last decade of acupuncture studies: there is no there there.
If I were a potential consumer of medical products advertised in my local paper, I think I would pass on laser therapy. Don’t go into the light.
* I did not read Orac’s column until after I had written mine. Really. Great minds often think alike.

Blue Light. Special?
Mark Crislip on November 11, 2016
Link
I do not sleep as well as I used to. Perhaps it is being tormented by guilt and worry combined with profound existential angst.
Or maybe it is my iPad. I gave up on most dead tree editions. I miss the smell and feel of books and magazines, but nothing is better than being able to increase the font size to 18. So I usually finish the day reading on the iPad.
I have noted programs that will remove the blue light from computer screen to aid in sleep. There is a night mode in iOS 9.3 and a program for the Mac I have on now that filter out the blue. Makes the screen oddly colored but it more restful on the eyes. I think. I am more in need of existential angst filter.
But what is the reality behind blue light as a source of sleeplessness? The Harvard Health Publications has an article on the topic warning of the hazards, and as a rule I have found the Harvard Health Publications to be distinctly gullible or useless when it comes to the more pseudo-scientific side of the tracks. I would suggest that advice such as:
Avoid looking at bright screens beginning two to three hours before bed.
Is great for the Amish but no so much for those who live in the modern world.
The issue is LEDs?
The white-light LED (i.e., the most common type of LED) is essentially a bichromatic source that couples the emission from a blue LED (peak of emission around 450–470 nm with a full width at half max of 30–40 nm) [4] with a yellow phosphor (peak of emission around 580 nm with a full width at half max of 160 nm) that appears white to the eye when viewed directly
And as they age LEDs may degrade becoming increasingly blue. Tell me about it. Been there, doing that.
Compared to fluorescent or incandescent light there is much more blue light in the spectrum of LEDs. And it turns out the blue light suppresses melatonin and has effects on the circadian rhythm. Next time your child asks “why is the sky blue?” you will have an answer. To keep us awake. And green light may put us to sleep.
iPads and their ilk produce lots of white, bright light and that means lots of blue, whether reading or playing Angry Birds and the use of electronic devices is associated with poor sleep.
Is it the blue light that results in poor sleep? In part:
Participants reading an LE-eBook took longer to fall asleep and had reduced evening sleepiness, reduced melatonin secretion, later timing of their circadian clock, and reduced next-morning alertness than when reading a printed book.
And the iPad?
Reading a story from an iPad decreased subjective sleepiness, delayed the EEG dynamics of slow wave activity by approximately 30 min, and reduced slow wave activity after sleep onset compared to reading from a book. No parameters of sleep state timing and sleep onset latency differed between the two reading conditions.
Does blue blocking help? Some hope against the data that it does:
The patients who used amber lens showed an advance of 78 min in DLMO value, although the change was not statistically significant (p = 0.145). Nevertheless, the sleep onset time measured by actigraph was advanced by 132 min after the treatment (p = 0.034).
And it is a consistent effect:
Sleep efficacy and sleep latency were significantly superior for wearers of the blue-light shield
There are no clinical trials of blue blocking software that alter the color of the screen.
Over all there is biologic plausibility and the studies, while few, small, and not of the highest quality, point in the same direction.
To summarize: The truth of blue light? Who cares?
I realize that progress is two steps forward and one step back, or perhaps 20 steps back. In league boots. And what is done one year can be undone the following. But we are at 400 ppm and rising and as a society we have decided in favor of a swan dive to the hard asphalt. The chance of mitigating a disastrous future for our children went from slim to none this week. While the thought leaders are trying for a win one for the Gipper moment, the pooch has been screwed.
I worry that, especially as the Millennium edges nearer, pseudoscience and superstition will seem year by year more tempting, the siren song of unreason more sonorous and attractive. Where have we heard it before? Whenever our ethnic or national prejudices are aroused, in times of scarcity, during challenges to national self-esteem or nerve, when we agonize about our diminished cosmic place and purpose, or when fanaticism is bubbling up around us – then, habits of thought familiar from ages past reach for the controls.
The candle flame gutters. Its little pool of light trembles. Darkness gathers. The demons begin to stir.
The candle is out. There is not even a small coal on the wick to fan to life. The demons rule. Game over.
No blue light filter will help.

Blue Light
Blue light blocking glasses and other products that block blue light promise to improve eye health along with many other questionable claims. The evidence is lacking.
Harriet Hall on December 1, 2020
Link

Blue light is part of the spectrum of sunlight. Other sources include digital screens (TVs, computers, laptops, smart phones and tablets), electronic devices, and fluorescent and LED lighting. We all seem to be increasingly tethered to our devices and spend more and more time looking at screens. Savvy marketers have demonized blue light and frightened a lot of people into parting with their money. The global market size is projected to rise to $38 million by 2026, from $28 million in 2020.
Glasses and other devices that block blue light have become very popular. You can even buy skin care products that block blue light. And after cataract surgery, you can get an intraocular lens that filters blue light (the rationale for this is based on cell culture and animal studies; a large systematic review of human studies recently showed no demonstrable differences in outcomes).The websites that sell blue-light-blocking devices tell us that blue light is bad for your health because it:
    • disrupts the circadian rhythm;
    • causes digital eyestrain syndrome, with blurry vision, difficulty focusing, dry and irritated eyes, headaches, back and neck pain;
    • increases the risk of certain cancers;
    • increases the risk of obesity, heart disease, and diabetes;
    • increases the risk of depression; and
    • may cause permanent eye damage, age-related macular degeneration, and blindness.
Sounds pretty awful, doesn’t it? But how much of that is true? Are blue light blocking devices just a marketing gimmick, or should we all be using them to protect our health? How many of those claims are based on good evidence? What does the science say?
The evidence has been mixed, with both positive and negative studies, and studies of varying quality, so it can be hard to sort out the truth. There have been several systematic reviews. Experts who know far more than I do about eyes have reviewed the evidence, and I won’t try to reinvent the wheel by citing all the pertinent studies. The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) provides expert advice on “Should You Be Worried About Blue Light?” and ““Are Computer Glasses Worth It?” They answer “NO” and “NO”. They say “there is no scientific evidence that blue light from digital devices causes damage to your eye”. We know that too much ultraviolet light increases the risk of cataracts, growths on the eye, and cancer; but we know less about blue light. Its effects are still being researched. Blue light exposure from screens is much less than the amount of exposure from the sun. When people report discomfort after looking at screens, it is not because of blue light. People tend to blink less when looking at screens, and this causes eye strain and dry eyes.
The AAO spokesperson, Dr. Khurana, says that given there is no evidence blue light causes damage to the eye, taking preventive measures against it could be more harmful than the blue light itself. We know that “It’s premature to take preventative action against blue light—there could be unintended consequences”. Some studies suggest that not getting enough sunlight might interfere with the development of vision in children, and could increase the risk of myopia in teens and young adults. Instead of blocking blue light with glasses, the AOA recommends taking regular breaks using the “20-20-20” rule: every 20 minutes, look at an object 20 feet away for 20 seconds”. And if your eyes feel dry, use artificial tears. Another article on the AAO website has more suggestions to limit eyestrain including “blink”; adjusting brightness, contrast, and glare; adjusting your position at the computer; and if you wear contact lenses, take an occasional break and wear your glasses.
What about sleep?
Blue light is known to affect the body’s circadian rhythm by suppressing melatonin production. Better sleep might be achieved by limiting screen time before bed and using the night mode available on many electronic devices.
Is anyone guarding the hen house?
False or unsubstantiated claims about blue light are rampant, and there has been little regulatory action. The glasses are not classified as medical devices and are not regulated by the FDA. In the UK, Boots Opticians were fined £40,000 for making unsubstantiated claims, and a spokesperson for the UK Association of Optometrists said, “…current evidence does not support making claims that they prevent eye disease”.
Conclusion: Mainly a gimmick, not supported by good science
The claims for blue light glasses and other products that reduce exposure to blue light are not based on credible evidence. They are good salesmanship, not good science. I can’t recommend them. But neither can I advise people not to try them. Any hazard is to your wallet, not to your health. They are probably safe, and who knows? They might invoke a placebo response that will make you think you feel better subjectively even when there are no objective improvements. Caveat emptor. I’m not buying.

Blue light blocking glasses: How much of the hype is science-based?
Blue light from our electronics is said to be harmful, and “blue blocking” glasses are touted as a panacea to numerous health issues. Is there any evidence to substantiate these claims?
Scott Gavura on June 25, 2020
Link


Like a lot of people, I’ve been spending a lot more time staring at a computer screen lately. I have been working from home since March, and what used to be face-to-face meetings are now Zoom/Teams/GoToMeeting video calls. With videoconferences and related work, I’m easily spending several more hours per week staring at a computer screen. Afternoon headaches became a common occurrence shortly after this started, which I attributed to screen time and poor ergonomics. School for both of my kids has been transformed to an online environment too, with even more hours per day (above the baseline) spent staring at electronic devices. Recently my daughter told me she was also getting headaches, and she needed “blue light blocking glasses” which would apparently help. (The source of this medical advice was probably TikTok.) I spent some time searching for evidence on blue light exposure, and what I found was a sizeable industry that blames “blue light” for all types of illnesses and holds up special glasses as the panacea. The marketing push for special glasses appears to have accelerated over the past few months given the surge in shelter-at-home orders and the increased reliance on video calls and remote work/education.
Why blue light?
If you search long enough you’ll find blue light from electronic devices is blamed for most modern ailments. Overexposure (however that is defined) is said to increase your risk of cancer, obesity, heart disease, diabetes and retinal damage. And that risk is said to be elevated because of our obsession with staring at electronic screens, large and small.
Our eyes can see only a narrow spectrum of light. Visible light ranges from violet/blue light (around 400nm) through red light (around 700nm). Incandescent lights have a spectrum similar to that of the sun. Low-energy light sources, like fluorescent lights and light-emitting diodes (LEDs) do not. Electronics are often cited as causing increased exposure to blue light, owing to LEDs that have a blue peak in terms of output. While the output may not be high, we stare at these devices for hours per day, increasing the concern that we are being exposed to “unnatural” light that may be harmful.
Our biggest source of blue light, even today, is sunlight. This exposure is arguably beneficial, as it has an important role is establishing our circadian rhythms, which guide our sleep-wake schedule. Blue light can boost attention and perhaps even mood. We all probably get much less blue light exposure than our ancestors of just a few generations ago, with 90% of American lives now spent indoors.
The evidence
There is no published evidence to demonstrate that normal environmental (including electronic) exposure to blue light damages eyesight. However it is acknowledged that eye strain can occur from staring at electronics, which can cause fatigue and headaches. Regular breaks from staring at screens (large or small) is recommended to reduce eye strain.
There is some evidence that blue light from electronics can disrupt circadian rhythms, however, by suppressing the production of melatonin, a hormone that regulates our sleep. This has led electronic manufacturers to offer “night light” settings that reduce the amount of blue light displayed and give your screen’s display a pinkish “warm” tone. In this setting, amber or “blue light” blocking glasses can work like a “night light” setting for our eyes, blocking the blue-light disruption that can be caused by artificial lights or electronic use. But there is no evidence to show that the blue light from electronic devices causes harm. Nor should it, as it’s well below the levels our eyes are exposed to when we’re outside. An analysis published in Nature examined exposure from a number of electronic sources and compared it to international limits. It noted:
Humans have evolved under natural light from the sun. Intentional staring at the sun causes eye injuries, as is reported after solar eclipses.6, 7 However, continuous viewing of the blue sky, certainly in the UK, does not present a risk of eye injuries. Comparing natural exposures with the reasonably foreseeable exposure to optical radiation from lamps, computer screens and mobile devices, such as smartphones shows that the actual spectrally weighted irradiance is lower than the natural exposures.
The panacea: Blue light blocking glasses
Sales of blue light blocking lenses are surging from $18 million USD in 2019 and are expected to reach $27 million USD by 2024. Optical chains are among the biggest proponents of special glasses. Last year the television show CBC Marketplace sent hidden cameras into major eyeglass vendors and found opticians promoting blue-light blocking glasses (or coatings on prescription glasses) as a way of protecting yourself against fatigue, retinal damage and even cancer. In the United Kingdom, Boots Opticians was fined £40,000 in 2017 for making misleading claims about the effects of blue light and the benefits of their “Boots Protect Plus Blue (BPPB) lenses”:
In a decision published today (26 May), the optical regulator found that there was potential for patients to be misled by the multiple overstating claims about blue light and the benefits of its BPPB lenses in an advertisement that was published in The Times in January 2015.
The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) received complaints about the content of the advertisement, including claims that blue light from LED TVs, smartphones and energy saving light bulbs caused damage to retinal cells over time, and that BPPB lenses protected against blue light from these sources. The authority found that these claims were misleading and unsubstantiated.
Blue light glasses can be purchased anywhere. The extent to which they actually block blue light can vary, with some models showing a heavy yellow/amber tint, and others without any tint. There are many testimonials from happy users, but none of the vendors I found online could offer any credible evidence to back up their claims. My daughter ordered a pair off AliExpress for $2.00, but you can spend hundreds.
There is very little published research on the effectiveness of blue light blocking glasses. A 2017 systematic review examined the benefits and harms on visual performance, macular health, and the sleep-wake cycle. It concluded:
We find a lack of high quality evidence to support using BB spectacle lenses for the general population to improve visual performance or sleep quality, alleviate eye fatigue or conserve macular health.
Other relevant or more recent research I could find included:
    • A small study of ten radiology residents (who stare at screens for a living) randomized to blue-light blocking glasses or sham glasses, with endpoints being reported measures of occupational fatigue. Wearers of the blue-light blocking glasses reported fewer symptoms. All I could find was the abstract, which recommends additional studies with larger sample sizes.
    • Another study looked at amber lenses vs. “placebo lenses” worn two hours before bedtime, and their effects on insomnia. It found the amber lenses effectively reduced insomnia.
    • One study that looked at the effect of reducing blue light in smartphones at night. This was not a study of blue light glasses, but of the “night mode” setting in our phones. It found that blue light in the evening, delivered via smartphone, negatively affected sleep patterns.
What we can draw from this is that claims that blue-blocking glasses have vast health benefits are not substantiated by robust evidence. There is some evidence for reducing blue-light exposure before bedtime because of effects on sleep.
What do eye experts recommend?
The American Academy of Ophthalmology says that there is no evidence that the kind or amount of light coming from electronic devices is harmful or damaging to the eyes, and does not recommend special eyewear for electronic use. It makes the following recommendations to minimize eye strain:
    • Sit about 25 inches (arm’s length) from the computer screen. Position the screen so you are gazing slightly downward.
    • Reduce screen glare by using a matte screen filter if needed.
    • Take regular breaks using the “20-20-20” rule: every 20 minutes, shift your eyes to look at an object at least 20 feet away for at least 20 seconds.
    • When your eyes feel dry, use artificial tears to refresh them.
    • Adjust your room lighting and try increasing the contrast on your screen to reduce eye strain.
    • If you wear contact lenses, give your eyes a break by wearing your glasses.
The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Ophthalmologists also notes that there is no evidence behind claims that blue light from electronics is harmful, or that blue light filtering eyeglasses are necessary or beneficial. A 2019 position statement notes:
A review of current literature has concluded there is little evidence with respect to using blue light blocking spectacles to improve visual performance (19). In addition, there are no studies showing such filters can conserve macular health. It should also be noted that avoiding all blue light may have unwanted effects as there is some weak evidence that blue light is useful in the daytime to improve concentration and mood (20).
They also note:
There may be a benefit to reducing screen time in the evening or using night-time settings on screens in the few hours before bedtime to reduce interruption to circadian rhythms. General measures to reduce symptoms of eyestrain include taking regular breaks and focussing on distance objects from time to time as well as ensuring spectacles, if worn, are appropriate for the task. It is recommended to consult a health care professional if symptoms of eyestrain persist.
In the United Kingdom, the College of Optometrists completed a systematic literature review on the issue, and says the following:
The best scientific evidence currently available does not support the use of blue-blocking spectacle lenses in the general population to improve visual performance, alleviate the symptoms of eye fatigue or visual discomfort, improve sleep quality or conserve macula health.
So what about all this eyestrain?
        ◦ While blue light glasses won’t protect your eyes from harm, there is probably some merit in minimizing blue light exposure a few hours before we plan to sleep. The eyestrain we’re all feeling is more appropriately addressed, not with blue light glasses, but with the simple hygiene measures recommended by experts. Blue light glasses are not harmful, but there is no solid evidence that they will effectively reduce eye strain or fatigue more effectively than paying attention to, and addressing, eye strain. Limiting evening exposure to blue light delivered via electronics and smartphones is probably a more effective strategy than counting on eyeglasses to mitigate those potentially negative sleep effects. As for me, as work from home continues for the foreseeable future, I’m taking more breaks from my computer during the day and trying to get outside for a few minutes every hour. Speaking of which…

The Blu Room
Blu Rooms are an expensive way to relax. The testimonials and the medical history of the inventor are not believable. No science, but good for a laugh.
Harriet Hall on January 11, 2022
Link


Strange messages keep popping up in my email inbox. This one was titled “New Technology Helps Fulfill New Year’s Resolutions”. It said the most popular New Year’s resolutions involved health and invited me to a complimentary session or two in a Blu Room.
It went on to explain:
The Blu Room features 20-minute sessions of deep relaxation, music and vibrations inside a mirrored 11′ by 11′ octagon bathed in blue and UVB light. There are Blu Rooms near Seattle, St. Louis, Washington DC, and in Phoenix and Medford, Oregon. Thousands of people with PTSD, Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) and depression have enjoyed the healing properties. Users report a wide range of benefits, including:
    • Deepened focus
    • A faster healing process
    • Greater self-awareness
    • Pain relief
    • Reduced stress and anxiety
    • Overall improved health
I think readers will quickly understand why I was underwhelmed and did not accept the offer of a complimentary session. This is another of those non-science-based health products that are too silly to write about, like the Bioptron. But in this case, it was too funny not to write about. When I saw who was behind the Blu Rooms, I laughed out loud and wanted to share the laugh with our readers.
Guess who developed Blu Rooms? Would you believe JZ Knight? Yes, that same JZ Knight who claims to be channeling the 35,000-year-old warrior Ramtha from the mythical Lemuria. He supposedly fought and conquered the mythical Atlantis. You can read all about it in the Wikipedia article. Knight runs Ramtha’s School of Enlightenment, whose members produced the disreputable 2004 film What the Bleep Do We Know!?. Her ex-husband characterized Ramtha’s teachings as a farce and a money-making business. Shirley MacLaine claimed to have been the brother of Ramtha in a former life, but scientists and prominent skeptics have ridiculed Ramtha’s claims. Michael Shermer has called Knight’s school a cult, and she has been sued by former students. Carl Sagan pointed out that a person who lived 35,000 years ago could teach us much about human history, but instead Ramtha offers only banal homilies.
The JZ Report on the Blu Room website (under the tab “Health Info”) presents “a systematic review” of JZ Knight’s medical records, allegedly showing that she has manifested numerous medical miracles that “can’t be explained by the current scientific understanding of our time.” She claims to have healed herself from numerous serious illnesses, and DNA samples taken when she is channeling Ramtha were supposedly different from the DNA samples taken when she is not channeling. Ramtha is allegedly able to instantly manipulate DNA at will, even converting JZ’s XX chromosomes to XY. I don’t believe any of this.
Conclusion: Not based on science, but good for a laugh
        ◦ The Blu Room experience may be very impressive to naïve, gullible patients, but the testimonials are subjective and easily explained by placebo responses. No objective evidence is offered. The treatments are not cheap (around $60 each), and they now offer a Blu Pod for home use that costs thousands of dollars. Not recommended; there are many less expensive ways to get placebo effects. On the other hand, if “laughter is the best medicine”, there is plenty to laugh at here.

   Biofeedback and Laser for Allergies
Harriet Hall
Link
AllergiCare Relief Centers are a chain of franchises started by a man called David Tucker who is not listed as having an MD or any other title. They offer diagnosis of allergies by biofeedback and treatment of allergies by laser acupuncture. They admit that the method is not backed by any science, and they claim that what they are doing is not medical treatment.
Responsible journalism might have investigated this as quackery or practicing medicine without a license. Instead, irresponsible journalism has helped promote these centers and has given them invaluable free advertising.
From one news story:
Tucker said the device works based on biofeedback. The allergy sufferer wears a sensing clip on his finger for testing, and the computer simulates the bio-frequency for 10,000 known allergens. As the body responds to those stimuli, the computer lists which substances are irritants. “This digitized allergen actually matches the harmonic frequency of the actual allergen, making the body believe it is in contact with the real substance,” Tucker said. “The body will react if it is allergic to the particular substance.” ….Once the allergens are identified, a laser stimulates biomeridian points on the body — the same points used in acupuncture and acupressure. Tucker said the idea is to strengthen organs to act properly the next time they encounter the allergen — that is, to treat them as harmless…So far, there is no science to prove the devices work, but Tucker claims a 70 percent positive response rate.
They asked a representative of the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America to comment. He wimped out, saying, “AAFA is not familiar with this treatment option and therefore cannot comment.” An allergy specialist, Dr. Goldsobel, was a little more forthcoming. He called the AllergiCare business “a media campaign with specious claims.” The reporter compared the new treatment to conventional allergy treatment and in the process, managed to cast doubt on conventional allergy treatments.
The company website says “The BAX3000 is the first and only FDA cleared, US patented system for eliminating allergies.”
That’s not exactly true. The BAX3000 is a biofeedback machine, approved ONLY for biofeedback by the FDA. The only thing the company has patented is the digital conductance meter. The BAX3000 is just another in a long line of quack electronic diagnostic and treatment devices that started with electroacupuncture according to Voll (EAV) in the 1950s. They basically measure galvanic skin conductance. There are various versions making different claims. In this version they claim to be measuring what a patient is allergic to; then they return the same frequencies back to the acupuncture points as treatment. Stephen Barrett of Quackwatch doesn’t mince words: he says
I believe that EAV devices should be confiscated and that practitioners who use them are either delusional, dishonest, or both.
They treat runny nose, sinus congestions, watery eyes, itchy skin, hives, asthma, wheezing, stomach upset, eczema, lower GI problems. Fatigue, lack of energy, almost anything could be a sign of allergies. They don’t claim to treat anaphylaxis. I wonder why.
You can go to their website and use their allergy symptom checker to enter your own symptoms and get a preliminary idea where your problem lies. I had fun checking various combinations of symptoms. Entering “headache, yearly, evening, and indoors” produced glutamates, gliadin, yogurt, gluten and iron. Checking “IBS, after meals, and indoors” yielded inactive digestive enzymes, inorganic salts, H-C-L [sic], histamines and iron. Checking “bloating and cramps in the morning” yielded histamines, salicylates, coffee, mucigen and mucin. Checking EVERY symptom on the list yielded “Mucus Membranes, Mucus, Mucin, Mucigen and Glutamates.” It wouldn’t give an answer if I checked nothing, but when I checked only “morning” it yielded Coffee, Epithelial Cells, Mucus Membranes, Dust Components, and Leukotrienes.
I knew I was allergic to mornings, but I thought coffee was the treatment, not the allergen. How could anyone be allergic to mucus membranes? Or iron? Or in the case of a patient mentioned on the website, vitamin B12?
I phoned the company to ask some questions. I got a confused rigmarole of pseudoscientific hogwash. The machine is a biofeedback device that acts as an ohm meter, with impedance indicating the acupuncture meridians. There are some kind of mysterious skin receptor molecules that receive the information and then send signals to the rest of the body. They refer to named acupuncture points and meridians that they assume are real. They use a laser to reprogram specific acupuncture meridians, apparently teaching the body not to respond to the allergen. He kept trying to tell me that there was some kind of neurologic response to immune stimuli but couldn’t explain it coherently.
I asked how they determined the unique frequency of each allergen in the first place. He said they did it with an oscilloscope. I asked how they managed to accomplish that and he couldn’t explain. I asked if the measurements were repeated and validated (apparently not). I asked how they could verify that they had the correct frequency. He answered,
When the wellness of the patient takes place.
I had great difficulty maintaining my composure at that point in the conversation. He admitted there were no studies yet, and that it required a leap of faith. But he could give me lots of testimonials and recommendations from lots of chiropractors. He was really sure it worked because he’d seen the results.
I don’t doubt it. If you are diagnosed as being allergic to something you’re not allergic to, then you can be exposed to it without getting any symptoms, and that counts as success. If you have any vague symptom that goes away on its own or responds to suggestion, that counts as success. If you really are allergic to something and the symptoms vary over time (as they almost always do), that counts as success too.
After the phone call I e-mailed the company again and asked if their technical experts could tell me the frequency of ragweed pollen. They never answered.
They are charging patients several hundreds of dollars for this nonsense. And they have happy customers. They claim a high success rate: “proven by over a decade of consistent results with solid success with tens of thousands of people who have had their allergies/sensitivities completely eliminated.”
They have a disclaimer: “The treatments we perform are not medical treatments. It has been developed from an entirely different field of therapeutics using the principles of Traditional Chinese Medicine, the study of human physiology and an in-depth knowledge of allergens.”
The reporter didn’t do his homework. He could easily have found out that using a biofeedback machine (with or without lasers) to diagnose and treat allergies not only doesn’t work but is illegal. The FDA confiscates these machines whenever it learns about them and has the time and manpower to act. In a recent series in the Seattle Times, reporters Mike Berens and Christine Willmsen did a thorough expose of related “energy medicine” devices, an expose that led to prosecutions and regulatory actions. This reporter missed the chance to do something equally useful.

Laser Therapy for Vaginal Rejuvenation
Some doctors are offering laser therapy for “vaginal rejuvenation”. It is no more effective than placebo, can cause harm, and is very expensive.
Harriet Hall on October 19, 2021
Tweet

After menopause, the absence of estrogen may cause a number of symptoms. About half of women develop vulvovaginal atrophy (VVA). The lack of estrogen causes thinning and fragility of the vulvar and vaginal skin. Women with VVA have vaginal dryness, poor lubrication, painful intercourse, and urinary symptoms including incontinence and bladder infections. Hormone replacement therapy is an effective treatment. Estrogen can be provided topically in doses too small to cause systemic effects; but many women are reluctant to use hormones, and some have been advised by their doctors to avoid estrogens. Some gynecologists are offering laser therapy as an alternative.
An article published on Harvard Women’s Health Watch on October 1, 2021 said that laser therapy can counter the vaginal symptoms of menopause. They reported a small trial published in the journal Menopause in July 2021. It studied 25 women divided into two groups: one got topical estrogen, the other got laser therapy. The study found that “although vaginal estrogen performed better on certain measures, laser therapy is an effective treatment for vaginal atrophy as well”.
Less than 2 weeks later, a larger study showed that laser therapy was not significantly better than sham treatment. It was a randomized double-blind sham-controlled clinical trial of 85 patients in Australia (UNSW Sydney) and was published in The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). The lowest possible laser setting (too low to have an effect) was used as the sham control, and both the laser group and the control group got the same local anesthesia. Participants in both groups got 3 treatments a month apart and were followed for 12 months. Biopsies were done and histology confirmed that there were no statistically significant differences between the two groups. In fact, “A shift from postmenopausal to premenopausal histology was found in two of 22 (9%) of participants in the treatment group and three of 24 (12.5%) in the sham group.”
The authors concluded:
The annual cost of laser treatment to the individual for management of vaginal menopausal symptoms was reported to be $2733, and because there is no demonstrable difference versus sham treatment, it cannot be considered to be cost-effective.
As reported by Heather Saxena in AusDoc magazine:
The findings have prompted two US obstetrician-gynaecologists from the University of Utah’s school of medicine to call for vaginal rejuvenation therapy to be restricted to research settings until high-quality evidence supported both effectiveness and safety. They wrote in an editorial that the widespread use of the therapy based on “highly optimistic short-term uncontrolled trials” followed by mounting reports of adverse events evoked a sense of deja vu as it was akin to the rush to market of vaginal mesh products before completion of rigorous trials. Although marketing prior to the availability of evidence demonstrating efficacy and safety may be associated with short-term profits for companies and clinicians, this approach closes any window of opportunity to actually learn what individuals, if any, benefit from the treatment, as well as those at increased risk for harms,’ they wrote.
Vaginal laser treatments are not alternative medicine but are used by mainstream MDs
Many MDs offer vaginal laser treatments. Here’s just one example. There are many others who offer vaginal rejuvenation with devices like Juliet, Renovalase, and Monalisa touch. Sciencebasedmedicine.org is an equal opportunity website: we don’t just criticize alternative medicine, we criticize conventional medicine when it is not based on good scientific evidence. Sometimes mainstream doctors get it wrong, and this is a prime example.
How is it supposed to work?
It is said to work by heating the tissue, improving blood flow, and stimulating regeneration. The cells are injured, and as they heal, they supposedly return to their healthy premenopausal state.
A clinic that offers vaginal rejuvenation explains:
As we age, the vaginal cells lose both collagen elastin. This unhealthy state cause a womens [sic] vaginal cells to become dry and inflexible. Eventually sex becomes very painful and for a vast number of women frankly impossible. The MonaLisa laser causes an injury to the cells lining the vagina. In an effort to heal this injury, the body sends in growth factors and stem cells which increase both collagen and elastin production in the cells. After three painless mona lisa treatments the vaginal cells are back to a normal healthy state and sex is once again painless and pleasurable.
But the 2020 genitourinary syndrome of menopause position statement of The North American Menopause Society said:
There are insufficient placebo-controlled trials of energy-based therapies, including laser, to draw conclusions on efficacy and safety or to make treatment recommendations.
Does it work?
A 2020 systematic review concluded:
There are 3 randomized trials comparing energy-based systems with hormonal treatment, with no clinical difference in these 2 approaches. Although prospective data continue to show promising outcomes, without strong evidence from well-powered, double-blind placebo-controlled trials to determine the efficacy of treatment compared with placebo, the use of energy-based treatments should continue to be undertaken in research studies only, with high-quality studies essentially free from bias.
Is vaginal laser therapy safe?
The safety of this treatment is questionable. There have been reports of scarring, burning, and pain.
On July 30, 2018, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a warning about energy-based devices used to treat vaginal conditions and symptoms related to menopause, urinary incontinence, or sexual function. Currently, no vaginal laser device or procedure is cleared or approved by the FDA for any of these vaginal issues.
Conclusion: IMHO, not the best choice
Laser therapy for postmenopausal vaginal atrophy is no better than placebo, is much more expensive than topical estrogen, and may have serious side effects. Topical estrogen is proven to work, and in my opinion it is a much better choice.

        ◦ Note: Thanks to Loretta Marron of Friends of Science in Medicine for suggesting I write about this and for providing helpful links.

Blonde Blood: Hydrogen Peroxide Infusions
Mark Crislip on November 16, 2012
Link
Two scientists walk into a barThe first one says “I’ll have some H2O.”The second one says, “I’ll have some H2O too.”Then he dies.
I have come to believe in my own version of The Secret.
The Secret describes the law of attraction as a natural law that determines the complete order of the universe and of our personal lives through the process of “like attracts like. The author claims that as we think and feel, a corresponding frequency is sent out into the universe that attracts back to us events and circumstances on that same frequency.
Obviously not true as I have yet to win Powerball. But a variant of the Secret is kind of creepy. As soon as I learn about a new concept, in medicine or life, I start to see it. All the time. Perhaps my learning a new concept causes it to spring forth like Athena. I would have said instantiate, but I got all sorts of grief when I used that word last time. For example, shortly after reading a review of infections in patients with Osler-Weber-Rendu, I saw a case. Creepy. As I drive from hospital to hospital I listen to Audible books and it is equally creepy how often I see a word in my visual field that is identical to the word I am listening to.
Two weeks ago I reviewed the SCAM (supplements, complementary and alternative medicine) that is UV irradiation of the blood. I had never heard of the therapy before, and within the week of the blog I receive a brochure from ACAM, the American College for Advancement in Medicine, who modestly refers to themselves as “the voice of integrative medicine.” Somehow I imagine they speak in the voice of Sylvia Brown, but that’s probably just me. The brochure concerns their fall conference and trade show where you can learn Oxidative Medicine in a one day workshop including ultraviolet blood therapy for somewhere around $649, as well as workshops to learn chelation and hyperbaric oxygen.
I didn’t know that by writing about UV irradiation of the blood that the universe would provide me the opportunity to learn more about it. I think the universe is twisted.
Part of the oxidative therapy course is learning to perform intravenous hydrogen peroxide therapy. I had never heard of that one either, and I write this with trepidation since, given the universe’s current malicious intent, I might end up a bleached blonde. So here goes. Wish me luck.
I have mentioned in the past my fundamental bias: that at level of humans we have a good understanding of how the world works. But, I guess, that applies to the world in which I live. The many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics suggests that every possible event that could happen has happened, resulting in a parallel universe we can neither see nor measure. I think they are partly correct. There are multiple universes that have split off from functional reality, the reality I inhabit. We can see the alternative reality, measure it, but oddly despite being able to interact with these realities, we cannot alter them. More terrifying, but not as dull, as the shrimp worlds are the alternative worlds of SCAM, where all the known rules of by which we understand the natural world need not apply. Like the world that uses hydrogen peroxide as a therapeutic intervention.
Why hydrogen peroxide?
The one true cause of all diseases is inadequate oxygen (there are two situations that violate the Pauli Exclusion Principle. One is The One True Cause of All Disease, of which there may be too numerous to count occupying the same ‘unique’ position. The other is newborn babies, all of whom are simultaneously the most adorable human. Ever). There are forms of SCAM where a little nugget of truth is magnified out of all proportion to its significance. This is one of Dr. Oz’s modus operandi. For example, some tumors and infections grow in a relatively oxygen poor environment. Therefore the cause of disease is low tissue oxygen. Not just cancer and the occasional Bacteroides abscess, but all diseases have a component that is due to a lack of intracellular oxygen. To overcome that deficiency, give oxygen intravenously as H2O2, aka hydrogen peroxide. There are other ways oxygen can be given to those in need: ozone therapy, hyperbaric oxygen, drinking H2O2, peroxide enemas, soaking in peroxide and withdrawing blood, bubbling O2 in it and reinfecting (funny, that is what the automatic spell check gave for my mis-type of injecting. My Mac may have more AI than suspected) the patient. So give oxygen, but not the old fashioned way: breathing.
The purpose of the H2O2 is to oxygenate the blood and thence the unoxygenated tissues. The chemical reaction is simple: H2O2 → H2O + O-. There is your free oxygen.
Practically, how is peroxide given? Hydrogen peroxide 0.0375% or lower concentration is added to a saline solution and infused in doses of 250 ml , slowly over a period of 1 to 2 hours. Another therapist gives 5 cc of three-percent hydrogen peroxide in 500 cc five percent glucose in water as a carrier solution which is infused or 100 ml aliquots of sterile l5% hydrogen peroxide infusion solution made from 30% “food grade” hydrogen peroxide then diluted with 5% dextrose to give the final 0.075 % product.
This makes me wish I was a bit closer to my chemistry days: I don’t have the time or wherewithal to calculate how much oxygen such a process would add to the human body compared to taking a deep breath. Others have made the calculation and it suggests that the oxygen provided, relative to breathing, is nearly homeopathic:
Under normal conditions, hemoglobin in blood leaving the lungs is 98% saturated with oxygen. The hemoglobin in one liter of blood can carry about 200 ml of oxygen, and about 50 ml of this is extracted each time it passes through tissue capillaries. The metabolism of a normal 60 kg adult requires delivery of between 200 and 250 ml of oxygen each minute [32]. Since the amount of hydrogen peroxide that is infused into a patient during one “oxidative therapy” session, yields a total of 100 ml of oxygen per day, the treatment can make no significant contribution ones oxygen requirements [33].
Or 288,000 mls a day of O2 is used by the body. Add the 100 mls from hydrogen peroxide and you up your O2 delivery by 0.03472%, which is approximately zero.
If the hydrogen peroxide makes it to the arterial side before undergoing degradation, there is essentially no unsaturated hemoglobin to take up the oxygen and plasma can at best dissolve 20 ml of O2; the rest will have to form bubbles that have the potential to cause gas emboli. So the best you can say about using peroxide as a mechanism for oxygen supplementation is that the amount generated is infinitesimal and is offered in a form that could cause the most mechanical damage. And I would fret about the fastidiousness of those taking a bottle of peroxide and preparing it for injection. One lapse in focus and the you could inject a higher concentration of peroxide than intended with terrible consequences. Compounding pharmacies have a long history of occasional lapses that lead to death. I always wonder about the environment of the clinic where providers make up their own concoctions for patient use. I have in my mind the same conditions as the production of gin.
Is there any reason to suspect that there is biologic plausibility behind the therapy?
Nope. At least not that I can find. Peroxide is used to kill bacteria. It is found in white cells where it is localized to the phagolysosomes and is rapidly degraded by catalases. In the blood hydrogen peroxide is also rapidly degraded and there can be no H2O2 in the blood at levels to kill bacteria, as demonstrated in an animal model. As best I can find, the normal concentration of H202 in the blood is at most 35 micromolar. Like many potentially toxic molecules, the body keeps H2O2 tightly segregated so it cannot cause harm. Futher, there is no reason to suspect that low oxygen is a cause of any medical condition except suffocation.
When you look at a list of diseases treated with peroxide (everything of course) it is hard to see where either O2 or H2O2 could have any benefit on the underlying pathophysiology. One list included.
1. Asthma, 2. Emphysema, 3. Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (COPD), 4. Cardiovascular Disease, 5. Cerbrovascular Disease, 6. Alzheimer, 7. Peripheral Vascular Disease, 8. Arrhythmias (Irregular heart rhythms), 9. Influenza, 10. Herpes Simplex (Cold Sores), 11. Herpes Zoster (Shingles), 12. Temporal Arteritis, 13. Migraine headaches, 14. Cluster headaches, 15. Vascular headaches, 16. Coronary artery spasm with angina, 17. Chronic Epstein-Bar Virus infection, infectious, mononucleosis, 18. Diabetes Type H, 19. HIV Infections, 20. Hepatitis, 21. Parasitic infections, various, 22. Fungal infections, various, 23. Bacterial infections, particularly chronic unresponsive, infections, 24. Candidiasis, 25. Chronic pain syndromes, various, 26. Pain of metastatic cancer, 27. Environmental allergies, 28. Early multiple sclerosis, 29. Rheumatoid arthritis
The data in my current reality convening treatment with iv hydrogen peroxide? None. Proponents note it is a natural product of metabolism (it is, like formaldehyde) but fail to note the importance of concentration and location of the molecule as well as systems to scavenge H2O2. I don’t know why those who feel getting patients properly oxygenated do not give them supplemental oxygen, except, of course, they can’t charge for that.
There are rare deaths reported with hydrogen peroxide and are attributed to bubbles of oxygen causing obstruction and tissue damage, a gas embolism. It is also of interest that hydrogen peroxide can lead to red cell hemolysis, especially in vitamin E deficient individuals. and perhaps other anemias as well.
Another example of the Secret: last week grand rounds was on the adverse physiologic effects of hemolysis presented by Mark Gladwin from University of Pittsburgh and it was fascinating. The basic physiology is free hemoglobin is extremely toxic and kept tightly sequestered or immediately scavenged by haptoglobin when released. When free it rapidly and irreversibly binds to NO in the vascular tree leading to multiple physiologic derangements, depending on amount released and chronicity. For example, it is one of the causes of pulmonary hypertension in sickle cell and part of the derangements seen in severe malaria. I would wonder when I read the reports of the H2O2 deaths if hydrogen peroxide induced hemolysis was the major cause of the pathophysiologic derangements that killed the patient, especially if it were accidentally given at too high a concentration. But that is pathophysiologic speculation. Regardless of the mechanism, it can kill the occasional unlucky recipient.
To sum up: non potest fungebantur, non fungebantur, occidere potest (cannot function, does not function, can kill, at least according to google translate)
* These opening paragraphs are logical fallacy central and are intended as humor.

Don’t drink hair bleach
Hydrogen peroxide is consumed and injected in alternative medicine practices as a sort of “cure all”. Is there any evidence to back this up? And how safe is it to inject or consume?
Scott Gavura on January 14, 2016
Link

One of the most satisfying parts of being a health professional is the opportunity to help people make better health decisions. In between the emails suggesting I’m a paid lackey of the Pharmaceutical-Industrial Complex™ for not endorsing coffee enemas, vitamin C, or homeopathy, I do receive the occasional note thanking me for my advocacy, or for writing about a subject in a way they found helpful. I’m also sent questions – too many to answer, but occasionally opening my eyes to new “concepts” in alternative medicine. And while I spent years working in a pharmacy with a huge “holistic” health section, containing products that, if they worked, would have defied one or more laws of physics or chemistry, I can still be surprised at novel alternative-to-medicine approaches to health care. Last week I was sent a questions about hydrogen peroxide – not for first aid use (where it may not be as useful as thought), but for oral consumption, as some sort of health “cure-all”. I was baffled, but the concept does exist – and the Big Pharma Overlords apparently don’t want you to know about it. There must be a rule 34 of alternative medicine – if it exists, there is an (inappropriate) alternative medicine use for it. The active ingredient in hair bleach and teeth whitening strips is no exception.
If you’re not into holistic healing or alternative medicine, you probably haven’t thought much about hydrogen peroxide since perhaps your last cut or wound, as bottles of peroxide have been a mainstay of first aid kits for decades. Peroxide is chemically two atoms of hydrogen and two atoms of oxygen: H2O2. It can be a potent oxidant and effectively act as a bleach, rapidly breaking down to H2O and O2 (water and oxygen). I recall it being poured onto my knee scrapes when I was a child, and I thought that the fizzing (and searing pain) was a sign that the wound was being cleaned, and bacteria were being killed (in fact, the oxidation was causing superficial tissue damage, and my parents should have been using water or saline). I still have an apprehension of peroxide. I soak my contact lenses in a peroxide solution, and unless they sit a full six hours in the case (with a catalyst that accelerates its conversion to water and oxygen), then the burning eye pain I experience later is a reminder that even low concentrations of peroxide can severely irritate tissues. Consequently, I’ve never thought of drinking peroxide. So how did a first-aid kit disinfectant end up as a health panacea? Like many ideas in alternative medicine, its use is based on prescientific ideas about how the body works that have persisted despite the evidence.
Peroxide: Not “natural”, not effective
Holistic and alternative medicine doesn’t necessarily mean “natural”. There are no natural sources of hydrogen peroxide you can buy. Peroxide is commercially manufactured, and most of the world’s production is used (at high concentrations) to bleach pulp and paper. For household use, peroxide is prepared as a 3% to 10% solution in water, where it’s much less chemically unstable, and is an effective disinfectant. Other common uses include “chlorine free” clothing bleach, as a hair lightener, and to whiten teeth, where direct contact with teeth will bleach stains. Apparently you can buy “food grade” peroxide at 35% which, unless you dilute it, is going to cause serious harm if you consume it.
One of the “facts” you’ll be told when you peruse alternative medicine sites on peroxide is that peroxide is some sort of magical, “super water”. Isn’t it just water with the added goodness of more oxygen? This line of reasoning is akin to saying that ethanol is just methanol with more carbon. Peroxide is a different chemical than water, with different physicochemical properties. So why would someone think of consuming a powerful bleaching oxidant? Isn’t alternative medicine all about antioxidants? The most likely rationale is that peroxide is simply an extension of the purification beliefs I blogged about a few weeks ago. The idea that we’re somehow poisoning ourselves, and we need to “cleanse” ourselves, seems to be a part of human nature, which may explain why purification still persists as an idea. It’s not miasmas or sin that we’re as worried about today, however. It tends to be illnesses like cancer, or other chronic disease. So the thought process seems to be that peroxide, a source of oxygen, will bleach and purify away our toxins, our cancer, our HIV, and our heart disease. That’s where the scientific reasoning seems to begin and end. Now from a scientific perspective, this is ridiculous, but wrap the description with some sciencey-sounding words, and these prescientific ideas sound quite plausible. Consider what Winnipeg naturopath Sean Ceasar says about intravenous peroxide, which is promoted for the treatment of cancer and other serious conditions:
Intravenous Hydrogen Peroxide Therapy is an alternative health therapy with a large number of devoted adherents. Advocates of this therapy claim that injecting 3% hydrogen peroxide intravenously via a drip for approximately an hour and a half per session will cure a number of diverse conditions ranging from the common cold to cancer. When hydrogen peroxide comes into contact with blood it reacts with the enzyme catalase, causing it to break down into water as well as into copious quantities of oxygen.
Any part of the body that might for any reason have been oxygen deprived (due to circulatory problems, for example) will benefit from this increased oxygen. In addition, the released oxygen performs a host of helpful actions within the body including the inhibition and/or destruction of a number of anaerobic organisms such as viruses, bacteria and cancer. (Anaerobic organisms are all pathogens.)
Additionally, hydrogen peroxide stimulates the body’s production of white blood cells, helps to break down calcium deposits within blood vessels, dissolves cholesterol, and converts the waste products and toxins that are the by-products of cellular processes into a form that is easily eliminated.
Furthermore, Intravenous Hydrogen Peroxide Therapy helps form adenosine triphosphate (ATP), a nucleotide that is responsible for providing the energy necessary for the proper functioning of cells. ATP is made in a cell’s mitochondria. Some researchers believe chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia are caused by faulty mitochrondrial and ATP performance.
IV hydrogen peroxide works to regulate mitochondrial membrane exchanges, and people who suffer with these conditions benefit from this treatment. In addition, hydrogen peroxide improves and/or cures a host of other ailments — Lyme disease, viruses including herpes, HIV influenza [sic] and the Epstein-Barr virus, sinus infections, hardening of the arteries (Arteriosclerosis), strokes (if treatment is initiated rapidly enough, damage can be reversed), Transischemic Attacks (TIAs, or so-called “mini-strokes), asthma, emphysema, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and more.
Cancer cannot thrive in the presence of oxygen, and therefore IV hydrogen peroxide is a potent anti-cancer treatment, one that is used alone, but which can also be used in conjunction with other treatments. Hydrogen peroxide is widely considered to be one of the most impressive of all the natural therapies that are available because of how many useful benefits it offers.
It is true that the body does produce peroxide naturally. However this is under very tightly controlled conditions, at the cellular level. Consuming or injecting peroxide, and hoping for some sort of medicinal effect, is the medical equivalent to spraying gasoline all over your car’s engine and interior and then wondering why it doesn’t make the car run better. Like gasoline in an engine, you need the right substance in the right place at the right time and under the right conditions in order to have a useful effect. And perhaps not surprisingly, there is no evidence to show that peroxide, either consumed orally, or injected intravenously, has any useful medical effects. You can search PubMed yourself – there are no clinical trials with hydrogen peroxide that study its use for cancer or any other medical conditions, other than trials for dental purposes. Yet it is regularly and repeatedly promoted for the treatment of cancer and other conditions – without any evidence demonstrating it does anything useful. Calgary-based naturopath Kin Leung also promotes peroxide injections, and claims the following:
Hydrogen Peroxide and Cancer: In 1966, Doctor Otto Warburg discovered that the key precondition for the development of cancer is a lack of oxygen at the cellular level. Cancer cells need 60% less oxygen than normal, healthy cells and perform poorly in the presence of excess oxygen. Therefore, cancer cells may be destroyed in the high-oxygen environment that is produced through hydrogen peroxide therapy. Hydrogen peroxide is an antineoplastic, meaning that it inhibits the growth of new tissues, like tumours. Hydrogen peroxide also increases production of interferon and tumour necrosis factors, which the body uses to fight infections and cancers. Cancer cells in the presence of increased oxygen tension become more sensitive to irradiation, and this increased oxygen tension is produced by hydrogen peroxide.
Hydrogen Peroxide and Lung Disease : Hydrogen peroxide administered intravenously works very well against emphysema, asthma and chronic lung disease. It cleans the lungs by producing oxygen bubbles in the alveoli, the tiny air sacs in the lungs, and lifting the mucus deposits out. This allows you to cough out the deposits, making the procedure natural and non-invasive.
Perhaps not surprisingly, there’s no evidence to demonstrate any of this is correct (the Warburg Effect is a real thing, but of course is more complicated and less of a road to the cure for cancer than portrayed here).
No evidence of safety
Hydrogen peroxide isn’t necessarily safe. It can cause harm in three ways: corrosive damage, the unwanted formation of oxygen gas, and by lipid peroxidation. At low concentrations, the risks of serious harms are remote. At high concentrations, peroxide is highly toxic. Peroxide can cause significant tissue damage. As a tooth whitener, it can irritates gums. When swallowed in larger volumes, it can cause nausea and vomiting. High concentrations of peroxide will cause mucosal burns. The secondary harm is due to oxygen release. Peroxide can cause an oxygen embolism in the bloodstream, which can cause strokes. In other body cavities, like the stomach, it can cause distension and painful gas. Deaths have been associated with injectable use – a “naturopath” was convicted of criminally negligent homicide for administering intravenous peroxide to a cancer patient that died the day after treatment. Lethargy, confusion, coma, cardiorespiratory arrest have been reported following consumption of hydrogen peroxide. Quackwatch has a nice summary of how the harm can occur:
Hemoglobin in red cells of arterial blood gives up about 25% of its oxygen when it passes through the tissues, so the hemoglobin of the venous blood leaving the tissues is oxygen-poor. When hydrogen peroxide is injected into venous blood, the oxygen released by the action of catalase is taken up by oxygen-poor hemoglobin. When this venous blood reaches the lungs, it is carrying more oxygenated-hemoglobin than normal. Less oxygen from inspired air is required to saturate it. When arterial blood leaves the lungs it is almost fully (98%) saturated with oxygen and so it becomes impossible for the intravenous infusion of hydrogen peroxide advocated by “oxygenation” proponents to further increase the amount of oxygen carried to the tissues.
The infusion of hydrogen peroxide into arterial blood is a completely different situation. A theoretical model [37] predicts the effects of an infusion of a hydrogen peroxide solution into arterial blood. Hemoglobin in arterial blood is already saturated with oxygen, so the oxygen released from hydrogen peroxide would not be taken up by hemoglobin. Therefore it would go into plasma. But the process of solution is slow, so undissolved oxygen gas could linger in the blood as bubbles for as long as 30 minutes. In the model, Johnson used 0.12% peroxide to produce a final level of 0.006 volumes peroxide per 100 ml in rabbit blood. Although this amount of hydrogen peroxide released 3.0 ml of oxygen gas in every 100 ml of arterial blood, most of the gas could be taken up by the small amount of unsaturated hemoglobin (2%) in the arterial blood. If however, the hydrogen peroxide content of the blood was doubled, 6.0 ml of oxygen gas would be generated per 100 ml of blood, and this could not be handled by available hemoglobin. Undissolved arterial oxygen would then create gas embolism. Consistent with this prediction for peroxide levels higher than 0.006 volumes percent, Johnson found that at 0.01 volumes 0.12% peroxide, oxygen gas embolism resulted in complete shut down of capillary blood flow in the treated rabbits.
Embolisms can occur and has been documented with peroxide use – even when used for wound irrigation. The FDA has also warned about the dangers of oral consumption of peroxide:
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is warning consumers not to purchase or to use high-strength hydrogen peroxide products, including a product marketed as “35 Percent Food Grade Hydrogen Peroxide,” for medicinal purposes because they can cause serious harm or death when ingested. FDA recommends that consumers who are currently using high-strength hydrogen peroxide stop immediately and consult their health care provider.
FDA is working to stop companies selling high-strength hydrogen peroxide from making illegal medical claims about their products. These claims are illegal because these products do not have FDA approval and are therefore being sold illegally for medical indications without any proven clinical value. The products can instead cause significant harm. As part of these ongoing efforts, FDA today issued Warning Letters to two firms illegally selling “35 percent hydrogen peroxide” products on Web sites for the treatment of AIDS, cancers, emphysema, and other serious and life-threatening diseases. These Warning Letters are available on FDA’s Web site, at http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/wlcfm/recentfiles.cfm.
“This concentration is not approved by FDA for any purpose,” said Dr. Steven Galson, Director of FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. “No one has presented any evidence that hydrogen peroxide taken internally has any medical value. In fact, consuming hydrogen peroxide in the manner touted by these websites could lead to tragic results.”
FDA has never approved high-strength hydrogen peroxide to be taken internally and considers hydrogen peroxide at 35 percent strength dangerous, even if handled according to the manufacturer’s directions. This high-strength hydrogen peroxide — more than 10 times stronger than the solution used in over-the-counter drugs to disinfect minor cuts — is highly corrosive. Ingesting hydrogen peroxide can cause gastrointestinal irritation or ulceration. Intravenous (IV) administration of hydrogen peroxide can cause inflammation of the blood vessel at the injection site, gas embolisms (bubbles in blood vessels), and potentially life-threatening allergic reactions.
Hydrogen peroxide injection practices reminds me of the Miracle Mineral Supplement (MMS) autism quackery that David Gorski has blogged about before. MMS is 28% sodium chlorite in distilled water, equivalent to industrial strength bleach. And like peroxide, MMS is promoted as a cure-all for virtually everything, from autism to AIDS. Health Canada and other regulators continue to seize this product from retailers, who continue to promote its consumption. Hydrogen peroxide, when sold and purchased for consumption, is little different. There are already case reports in the literature over accidental poisonings from the consumption of high concentration peroxide. As the FDA has noted, there is no need to purchase or own high-concentration peroxide.
TL;DR: Drinking or injecting peroxide is not advisable
As a disinfectant on surfaces, or as a dental bleach for tooth whitening, hydrogen peroxide is safe. But there are no medical benefits to consuming or injecting it, and there are significant risks, including death, when hydrogen peroxide is used inappropriately. The promotion of hydrogen peroxide in the alternative medicine field is yet another example of how there really is no such thing as alternative medicine that works. If it did work, we’d call it medicine. The rest is unproven, or proven ineffective. That’s the state of hydrogen peroxide today. Alternative medicine’s ideas about the medicinal effects of hydrogen peroxide may sound impressive, but they have no basis in reality and there is zero evidence to demonstrate that it is useful.

Other resources
    • Mark Crislip wrote about intravenous peroxide in 2012.
    • Snopes has a reasonable article on hydrogen peroxide myths and facts.
    • David Gorski on Miracle Mineral Solution and autism quackery.

FTC settles false advertising suit against low-level light therapy marketer with $22 million judgment
Per a settlement with the FTC, the marketers of Willow Curve, a low-level light therapy device costing hundreds of dollars, will have to stop making deceptive claims that the device treats chronic, severe pain and associated inflammation. Any health claims made for the device must be supported by “competent and reliable scientific evidence”.
Jann Bellamy on July 2, 2020
Tweet


The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the marketers of Willow Curve, a low-level light therapy device, have agreed to a Stipulated Order for Permanent Injunction and Monetary Judgment forbidding false claims that the device treats chronic, severe pain and associated inflammation. The Order also imposes a $22 million judgment, suspended pending the payment of $200,000 each by individual defendants Ronald Shapiro, MD (a kidney specialist) and David Sutton, co-owners of the defendant companies marketing the device, based on their ability to pay. The Order resolves a six-count Complaint filed by the FTC against the defendants for violation of federal laws against deceptive advertising.
The FTC, which had been investigating the defendants since 2017, apparently agreed with SBM’s own Dr. Harriet Hall, who wrote about the Willow Curve in 2015:
Willow Curve makes a lot of claims, but there is no credible evidence to back them up. There are a lot of unanswered questions and red flags. Even if the effect is significant, it appears to be small in magnitude. . . . I’m not persuaded that the Willow Curve has any unique advantages over other, much less expensive products. . . . My inclination would be to stick to less expensive, more evidence-based treatments until Willow Curve has been properly tested.
You heard it here first, folks.
What’s a Willow Curve?
According to the FTC’s Complaint:
Willow Curve is a curved plastic device that applies low-level light and mild heat to the site of pain, via light-emitting diodes (“LEDs”) and heat resistors. To start a 24-minute “treatment” session, consumers select from among five different settings, which differ with respect to the parameters of the light emitted, such as angle, frequency, and sweep pattern. Willow Curve also includes sensors on its curved underside that purportedly measure skin-surface temperature.
“Low level light therapy” is a confusing and, per some experts, inaccurate term, as it can refer to devices with differing light sources and with varying mechanisms of action and therapeutic intent. The devices go by many names in addition to low-level light therapy, including low-level laser therapy, cold laser therapy, low-power laser therapy, low-intensity laser, low-energy laser therapy, monochromatic infrared light energy therapy, and, when applied to acupuncture points, laser acupuncture. According to a 2018 review by Quackwatch, these devices
may bring about temporary relief of some types of pain, but there’s no reason to believe that they will influence the course of any ailment or are more effective than standard forms of heat delivery.
But if you read or heard Willow Curve’s marketing materials, you’d think it was something out of a Silicon Valley start-up, a veritable Theranos. Advertisements used words like “therapeutic laser technology” and “digital anti-inflammatory technology” with “diagnostic sensors [to] gather information that’s used to adjust the kinetic energy that stimulates your body’s own natural pain-relieving pathways”, equipped with a “smart onboard computer [that] adjusts the protocol to your needs”. The device’s “joint scanning technology collects information from at and below your skin surface. . . [and] calculates and digitally delivers multiple energy beams that change thousands of times/second” and “produces dynamic multi-band alternating pulse therapy” to boot.
Promoted as an alternative to opioids, steroid injections, and surgery, the Willow Curve was “proven to relieve pain and stiffness in minutes”, sometimes in “as little as 12 minutes”, or just “24 minutes”, or at least “the next morning”, or in “two or three days”, depending on the particular testimonial. And no side effects! In sum, “nothing short of a miracle”.
Of course, if you’re selling miracles, you can charge a lot, and Willow Curve did just that. Since around 2014, Willow Curve typically cost $599, the price rising to $799 in 2018.
Big claims can get you in big trouble. The FTC requires “competent and reliable scientific evidence” to support health claims and testimonials like those used extensively by Willow Curve only serve to convey “the implied claim that the advertiser has proof to support the underlying efficacy representation”. Willow Curve had none of this, and is now, per the Stipulated Order, permanently enjoined from claiming that any device they sell is clinically proven to:
    • Treat or relieve severe or chronic pain, including that due to rheumatoid arthritis, diabetic neuropathy, nerve damage, fibromyalgia, shingle, lupus, torn tendons, broken bones, or other specific health conditions;
    • Treat or reduce inflammation;
    • Provide pain relief comparable to drugs or surgery;
    • Restore mobility and joint function to consumers with restricted movement;
    • Reduce pain by a specific amount on pain scales or relieve pain for a certain percentage of users; or
    • Evaluate or diagnose the cause of individual consumer pain.
Which just goes to show you how expansive Willow Curve’s claims were. For example, advertising represented that the device “reduces pain by three to ten points” on a numerical pain scale and that an incredible 99% of consumers “achieve significant pain relief”.
The Order leaves open the possibility that, at some point, the defendants might actually create a device that does any or all of these things and more. If they do, they’ll have to support any advertising claim with competent and reliable scientific evidence, defined in the Order as:
tests, analyses, research, or studies (1) that have been conducted and evaluated in an objective manner by experts in the disease, condition, or function to which the representation relates; (2) that are generally accepted by such experts to yield accurate and reliable results; and (3) that are randomized, double-blind, and placebo-controlled human clinical testing of the Device, when such experts would generally require such human clinical testing to substantiate that the representation is true.
Not FDA anything
Misrepresenting the Willow Curve’s effectiveness was not the defendants’ only sin. Various promotional materials represented that the device was “FDA Registered”, certified, or approved. But, as the FTC explains in the Complaint, the FDA classifies medical devices into one of three categories based on the risk they pose to the public. Higher-risk products (think X-ray machines) cannot be sold without pre-market approval, which requires a rigorous review of safety and efficacy data. Lower-risk devices undergo the less stringent “510(k)” review, which requires showing the new device is “substantially equivalent” to an existing device already legally marketed in the U.S. Finally, the FDA has exempted some lower-risk devices from even this less stringent level of review, “such as heating pads and topical heating devices that emit infrared light, such as Willow Curve”, requiring no FDA review before being marketed. In other words, the Willow Curve, with its alleged “digital anti-inflammatory technology” and “diagnostic sensors” and so forth is actually the regulatory equivalent of a $13.98 Walmart heating pad.
The FDA also requires that manufacturers and distributors of medical devices register annually and submit a device list so the agency knows where devices are made. The defendants never did this either. Thus, the Willow Curve was never registered, certified, or approved by the FDA, as claimed.
(Consumers may not be aware that, as the FDA explains, “Registration and Listing does not denote approval or clearance of a firm or their devices”, meaning that when you see “FDA registered” or “FDA listed” in advertising it not indicative of the efficacy or safety of the product, no matter how much the marketer would like you to believe otherwise.)
After paying hundreds of dollars for this gizmo and finding out it didn’t work as claimed, some purchasers tried to exercise their advertised right to a “risk-free trial” or a refund. Even that turned out to be a sham. Per the Complaint, consumers were required to pay shipping, handling, and other fees to return their devices. In many cases, refund requests were not honored or took a year or more to process. The FTC also charged the defendants with using deceptive “native” ads, which were commercial content disguised as independent journalistic content. Defendants are permanently enjoined from all of these deceptive and misleading practices as well.
If the individual defendants don’t pay the $200,000 each, the full $22 million judgment can come crashing down on their heads, as it will if they violate any of the other terms of the Order. And, as if in warning to similar device marketers, the FTC’s press release announced that that the suit is “the FTC’s first to challenge health claims made for a low-level light therapy device”, with the implication that others may follow.
But what about the poor consumers, stuck with their curved plastic casings embellished with LED lights? The Order does not specifically mention any relief for them, although the Order does say that the monies from the defendants “may” be deposited into a fund administered by the FTC and be used for “consumer redress”. The defendants are required by the Order to send all of their customers a letter telling them about the suit, and that the FTC says they don’t have evidence to support their health claims and can’t make any claims unless they have evidence to back it up. It does not say anything about customers recovering any money for their troubles.
The Willow Curve (now $699) is still on the market, albeit with far more subdued health claims. The consumer must also purchase a battery “specifically intended” for it ($39.99) or a charger ($29.99) to run the thing.
The website says that Willow Curve is “currently focused entirely on temporary relief for joint pain” and that a there is a “great deal of published research which is ongoing”. Two journal articles are referenced, one of which doesn’t have anything to do with joint pain. The other is more or less an opinion piece saying that “low-level laser (light) therapy [LLLT]” is “beneficial for pain relief and can accelerate the body’s ability to heal itself”. It cites some supporting evidence, but is not a critical review of the evidence, and acknowledges limitations on the therapy’s acceptance. The website also claims “the Willow Curve device is the only LLLT device recognized by the American Medical Association and was granted a unique insurance CPT Procedure code 0552T”, but I was not able to verify that information.
        ◦ Willow Curve has also rescinded its “risk-free trial” and refund policies. If you pay $699 and don’t like it, too bad. Caveat emptor!

The Light Fantastical. Ultra Violet Blood Irradiation.
Mark Crislip on November 2, 2012
Link
What would you do if your swimming pool was dirty? Clean it of course. But how? Would you take out a few pails of water, treat the water in the buckets, then toss the water back into the pool and declare the pool clean? And if it were the bathroom that needed cleaning, would you clean it by treating a few bucket fulls of water from the pool? Seems an odd approach to me, but, metaphorically speaking, it is the approach used by ultraviolet (UV) and laser treatment of blood.
A weird bit medical therapy, I get the occasional ‘Hey Dr. Smartypants, what do you think of this treatment?’ email. UV blood irradiation is an odd treatment, with an peculiar history.
UV light does have many effects on tissues, as a trip to Hawaii can rapidly demonstrate to a pasty Oregonian. In my world UV is used to sterilize the environment and UV kills off everything from MRSA to C. difficile to tuberculosis. We vent potentially microbially contaminated air to the outside in part to dilute any infection but more importantly we know that most pathogens will die when exposed to solar UV light. Do not use UV light on people as a rule, since it causes tissue damage and we fret about injury to eyes and skin.
Back in the 1930’s a physician named Knott had two patients, one with a brain abscess and one with sepsis, who he evidently cured by irradiating the patients’ blood and returning it to them.* His rationale was since cutaneous TB can be cured by UV light (the discovery resulted in the 1903 Nobel Prize in medicine and physiology), perhaps other infections would be amenable to the therapy as well (1).
250 to 300 cc is the average amount of blood withdrawn, irradiated and returned to the patient. Given the mythical 70 kg human has about 5 liters of blood, that would mean they were ‘treating’ about 6% blood volume, which is irradiated for 10 seconds. Hardly seems a sufficient volume and time for treatment of anything. These studies were done at the beginning of the antibiotic era when sulfa antibiotics were the only commonly used agents.
The mechanism(s) by which UV irradiation are suppose to work include
1) Bactericidal effects
If they are doing the irradiation for antimicrobial effects it is uncertain how they could kill off a significant percentage of the infecting organisms, since the blood stream, if containing germs, usually has much less infection than the source: brain abscess, pneumonia, etc. Irradiating peripheral blood for treating a brain abscess is not unlike the aforementioned cleaning the kitchen by cleaning a bucket of pool water
It was also suggested that the effect on bacteria was indirect. Some in vitro data at the time suggested an increase in phagocytosis of bacteria by WBC of 50%, but increasing the function of 6% of circulating white cells seems insignificant. One review recognized it was not reasonable to credit direct bacterial killing:
These favorable clinical results obtained have to been shown to be due to a tremendous and rapid rise in the patients own resistance to infection rather than to any direct bactericidal effect, though ultraviolet rays are lethal to all common coccal bacteria. This is not surprising as only 3 percent of the total blood volume is exposed to ultraviolet light during a blood irradiation. Furthermore the amount of ultraviolet irradiation is not sufficient to directly kill bacteria in vitro, although the patient whose septicemic blood was tested recovered with a rapid disappearance of bacteria from the blood stream (3).
2) Detoxification
They note that many bacterial toxins (diphtheria tetanus, botulism; they actually named toxins!) are inactivated by UV light in vitro so it should work in vivo against the toxins made by bacteria. I can find no papers to confirm this hypothesis.
3) Increased oxygenation
Evidently UV irradiated blood increases oxygen content, although I cannot find a modern confirmation of a beneficial effect.
4) Vaccine Effect
A somewhat incoherent suggestion that since UV irradiation can lead to immunizing agents (irradiated viruses are not infectious but can elicit immunity), perhaps the same is occurring with UV irradiation of blood. Herpes and Staphylococcal furuncules are given as examples where UV irradiation of blood led to resolution of diseases by a vaccine effect. Since none of the causative agents are in the blood at the time of the irradiation, it is difficult to imagine how enhancing ‘vaccine’ effect could occur.
One site explains it thus:
the UV light concurrently kills infecting organisms, making them “antigenic.” This means the fragments of the killed infecting agents create a safe, autogenous vaccination-like response. This further activates and directs your immune system to the specific infections your body is attempting to overcome. The net result is the induction of a secondary kill of these infecting agents throughout the entire body. Thus, treating only 35 cc of your blood with UBI induces a beneficial systemic response.
If they were doing the irradiation for immunomodulation, as best I can tell (and most of the modern literature is for the treatment of psoriasis ) UV is immunosuppressing, which may help modulate the clinical course of sepsis (which is due to an overactive response to infection) but should make all other infections worse.
5) Photosensitization
UV interacts with never elucidated molecules and activates those molecules to kill bacteria, much as acridine exposed to UV light will kill paramecia.
6) Other effects with UV treatment of blood that were thought important and real included vasodilatation, desensitization (sort of the opposite of the vaccine effect) and a reduction in edema. One site suggests that some of the UV light is stored in the blood and then released after it is infused to kill bacteria in a burst of intravascular radiation.
There was fairly widespread use after the initial reprots. One review in 1949 suggested 60,000 people had received the therapy over the prior 15 years (2). There were no randomized placebo controlled trials that I could find, but a number of impressive case series of very ill patients: sepsis, abortion, peritonitis, gall bladder disease, and the acute surgical abdomen. Patient after patient ill with serious bacterial infections improving when medicine was little better than using stone-knives and bear-skins. It appeared to be highly effective with minimal toxicity for the treatment of many infections and some other diseases as well such as cancer (of course) and asthma. And no side effects worth reporting.
There were many obvious problems with the papers: no randomized, placebo controlled trials, just collected anecdotes, and as we all know the plural of anecdote is anecdotes not data, But they are an impressive series of anecdotes nonetheless. The studies make you wonder whether a legitimate effect is really occurring. Of course the same could be said for internal mammary artery ligation of angina. 
It is a worry that most of the literature was generated by three researchers. Many of the case reports were a wee bit too dramatic, almost at the level of miracles than medicine
Botulism, a uniformly fatal condition, was treated by Miley. The patient was in a coma and could not swallow or see. Within 48 to 72 hours of one irradiation treatment, the patient was able to swallow, see, and was mentally clear. She was discharged in excellent condition in a total of 13 days.
And
Results of recovery were 100% for early infections, 46 out of 47 for moderately advanced, and 17 out of 36 of those who were moribund. Staphylococcus had a high death rate, but those patients were also using sulfa drugs, which may have inhibited the effectiveness of the UV irradiation treatments. In fact, when Miley reviewed his data, he found that all the Staph failures had been on sulfa. A second series of nine patients (six Staph aureus, three Staph albus) had a 100% recovery rate with one or two treatments when sulfa was not used.
When a treatment seems too good to be true it probably is. The stories are so uniformly positive with no side effects it doesn’t seem legitimate, but I have no way to know without access to the original data. He waxes desperate with imagination…Something is rotten in the state of Denmark. But the papers don’t ‘smell’ right.
Then the therapy just vanishes in the medical literature and I can’t determine why. There wasn’t a seminal study that demonstrated UV blood irradiation was not effective. Evidently it was a fad that just vanished like hula hoops, mullet haircuts and Uggs (well, I can wish). Even sites like the Whale, which I would have expected to have some anti medical-industrial complex conspiracy theory, fails to have an explanation, just that modern medicine came to prefer medications over UV light. Anyone practicing at the time have any insight?
Just because the technique disappeared from standard medicine doesn’t mean it is not still used. Multiple machines are available for purchase and appear to run around $5,000, and, as would be expected, the indications for UV light therapy have broadened:
Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation has been used to treat the following conditions:• Allergies – inhaled and food.• Autoimmune diseases such as lupus, rheumatoid arthritis and Sjorgen’s Syndrome.• Cancer – various types including breast, colon and prostate.• Chronic candidiasis – chronic yeast overgrowth.• Chronic fatigue syndrome and conditions.• Mononucleosis• MRSA infections• Multiple sclerosis• Osteomyelitis• Pain• Peripheral vascular disease.• Shingles
• Toxicity
And more. It depends on what web site you visit. One treatment for everything.
Of course, UV is so last century. Now they use lasers to irradiate the blood. Both as a modification of the Knott technique where a laser is used in place of UV light or by sticking a laser in your nose to irradiate the blood passing through the nasal mucosa. Really. This is not fiction. Check out the Wikipedia page and giggle.
There are a smattering of Pubmed papers mostly out of Russia using “laser “blood irradiation”” as search terms, where the bulk of the laser blood irradiation research is done, and the abstracts gave me insufficient understanding as to what they are doing.As an example
The authors report a bacteriostatic effect of He-Ne laser irradiation on Tb growth. Endovascular blood irradiation used in 85 tuberculous patients induced no side effects. Ten-twelve sessions relieved the symptoms of tuberculosis-related intoxication, reduced the infiltration and destruction, promoted abacillosis. Laser irradiation holds promise in management of torpid infection and hepatotoxicity induced by isoniazid and rifampicin. The highest effect occurred in infiltrative tuberculosis.
Laser blood irradiation is also used for preop in surgery to decrease infections, treat cardiac arrhythmia’s and glomerulonephritis, all with salubrious effects. Color me skeptical that irradiating a small volume of blood could have beneficial effects on such a wide range of diseases with such disparate pathophysiologies.
To date, I still think the only wonder drug that works wonders is Bayer aspirin. UV and laser treatment of blood, for all the impressive case reports from 50 years ago, is neither tried nor true by the standards of modern medicine and science. I suspect it died as it was not effective and probably can’t have any effect. From basic principles it appears to be almost the homeopathic application of light. The effects are from N-rays more than UV or Laser rays.
Note
* There are, to my discomfiture, many second hand sources for my information. Many of the references are not available though the interwebs or Pubmed and I do not ask my library for copies of papers when they get charged and it is not for direct patient care.
References
     1.  Miley, George, Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation Therapy (Knott Technique) in Non-Healing Wounds, American Journal of Surgery, Vol. 65, No. 3, September, 1944, pp. 368-372.
     2.  The role of ultraviolet blood irradiation therapy; Knott technic in surgery. OLNEY RC. J Int Coll Surg. 1949 May-Jun;12(3):353-6)
     3.  Miley and Christensen, Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation Therapy in Acute Virus and Virus-Like Infections, The Review of Gastroenterology, Vol. 25, No. 4, April, 1948, pp. 271-276.Miley and Christensen, Ultraviolet Blood Irradiation Therapy in Acute Virus and Virus-Like Infections, The Review of Gastroenterology, Vol. 25, No. 4, April, 1948, pp. 271-276.

Ultraviolet Blood Treatment Revisited
Steven Novella on September 28, 2016
Link


If there is one thing this election cycle has demonstrated it’s that, when ideology or emotions are involved, people can be entirely immune to facts. The narrative takes control, reinforced by motivated reasoning and confirmation bias.
Even worse, people tend to think they are actually informed, and are confident in their opinions, even when they are grossly misinformed. Regular contributors here frequently receive e-mails from people who truly believe they have it all figured out – modern medicine is a con and we are all shills, while alternative gurus speak the Truth. The confident reality distortion is amazing to behold.
A total lack of ethics and regulation
Let’s take one stunning example from the world of alternative medicine – ultraviolet blood treatment. Britt Hermes, who has contributed to SBM before, is an ex-naturopath who wrote recently about a medical device called the UVLrx. This is a device that is inserted into a vein like a catheter, and then emits UV light directly to the blood.
As she nicely documents, the device is being used by alternative practitioners, mostly naturopaths and chiropractors, without supporting scientific evidence or rationale. There isn’t even sufficient reassurance of safety. How do they do this?
The pattern is one we are now very familiar with here. The company makes a long list of (sort of) clinical claims for the treatment. There are many ways to imply clinical claims without directly making them, or they may just boldly make unfounded claims.
These are supported by a combination of hand waving BS pseudoscientific technobabble, and basic science papers which sound impressive but don’t really directly relate to the claims being made.
You then have a choice of other support – you can always resort to just posting anecdotes. You can even make them up, no one will check. Or you can claim to be studying the clinical claims. You can do in-house pilot studies, without controls, without blinding, and without any chance of getting an inconvenient negative result.
Savvy snake oil providers are now also just constantly doing clinical trials as a back door way of selling treatment with an investigational drug or device.
As Hermes reports – naturopaths are using the UVLrx device, which has not been proven to do anything, and charging thousands of dollars for treatments. The company is being very coy with their claims, with the website referring to basic science that does not support their claims, and pilot studies which are essentially useless. They talk a good game for those who don’t know the difference, doing just enough to create the false impression that their company is interested in science.
The evidence for UV treatment
Mark Crislip discussed the dubious history of UV treatments a few years ago, and not much has changed. The idea of using UV light to treat infections started with a Nobel Prize – using UV light to treat tuberculosis infection of the skin. This, of course, is an external use. Using UV light to treat the blood had its heyday in the 1950s, but fell out of favor without leaving much of a paper trail behind. This often happens with treatments that don’t work. The few practitioners using the treatment fail to convince the scientific community of their claims, which then fade when they die. Sometimes others pick up the claims and carry it on, sometimes not.
UV light is seeing a resurgence recently, because pseudoscience in medicine is now hugely profitable. Many people have observed that we seem to be living in a post-fact world, where you can make up your own reality and spread it across the internet. It’s a golden age of quackery.
But the plausibility of this treatment has not changed. Treating infections by treating the blood with UV light is not likely to have any significant impact, as most of the viruses or bacteria will not be in the blood. Further, you would need to give an adequate dose to a significant portion of the blood, and many treatments only affect a small percentage, like 5%.
The UVLrx claims to fix that problem by placing a laser inside a vein and then treating all the blood as it flows by. This doesn’t really fix the problem, however, as the dose will be small to any part of the blood as it quickly flows by the light. There is no evidence that this treatment does what it is supposed to do.
And of course charlatans are quick to add all the usual evidence-free claims that are frequently made for alternative treatments: it boosts the immune system, while also decreasing inflammation, and increases oxygenation in the blood (so that you can later take antioxidants) while detoxifying it. This is cut-and-paste pseudoscience. These are not even plausible, or really even coherent, medical claims.
Further, in this case there isn’t evidence to show that the treatment is safe. UV light can cause tissue damage, as anyone who has suffered a sunburn can attest. What damage is being done with the UV light from this device, and can it have any clinically significant effect on infections at a dose that is safe for the tissue? These are unanswered questions.
Conclusion: A dubious device and a double standard
This is just one dubious medical device out of the countless that are out there. What it shows is that the rules change based upon whatever narrative you wish to operate under.
Here we have practitioners who are charging thousands of dollars for a treatment without evidence that it is safe or effective, making claims not backed by evidence, and conducting worthless research without proper oversight or transparency, but this is all somehow alright because they are “alternative” or “natural.”
It just shows the power of an effective marketing narrative. Now believers who seem intent on being taken advantage of will accuse me of being a paid shill for raising these obvious questions.

zone Therapy
Ozone therapy sits in the border zone between science and pseudoscience.
Steven Novella on November 8, 2023
Link

I was recently asked if ozone therapy is scientifically legitimate. It’s an excellent example of how challenging it can be to answer what may seem like a straightforward question. This difficulty is exacerbated by the culture of alternative medicine, which actively seeks to blur the lines of science and pseudoscience and exploit the complexity and gray zone of clinical evidence.
The question, as asked, is unanswerable, other than to say – it depends. What you really need to ask is if a specific type of ozone therapy is safe and effective for a specific indication. Asking if hyperbaric ozone is effective for healing skin ulcers is very different than asking if autohemotransfusion of ozone is effective for fibromyalgia. But often practitioners operating outside the bounds of a science-based approach to medicine will use evidence for a narrow scope of effect to say that a treatment is generally effective (without qualification). They might claim that acupuncture works or homeopathy works, which are nonsensical statement. They are equivalent to saying surgery works, or drugs work. However, there is no convincing evidence that acupuncture or homeopathy work for anything, so that is one difference.
Ideally we would also want to dive deeper than specifying treatment type and indication. Clinically, we also want to know the dose and duration of treatment, and if there are any patient demographics that modify the safety or efficacy of the treatment. For example, a clinically useful and scientifically valid statement might be – ozonated oil at a specific dose, when applied at a specific frequency over a determined length of time, had a specific and measurable beneficial effect in diabetic patients with infected skin ulcers of a certain range of severity.
From a basic science perspective, we also like to know what the mechanism of action is. While this is not necessary in order to establish clinical safety and efficacy, it does potentially modify the amount and quality of evidence that would be necessary to reach a threshold of recommending the treatment. If the putative mechanism (such as with homeopathy) is that it’s magic, then that threshold should be extremely high. If the mechanism is plausible and already shown to have some biological effect, a more standard threshold can be used.
Let’s apply this approach to the broader question of ozone therapy, breaking it down appropriately. Ozone is a highly reactive gas comprised of three oxygen atoms (O3). It is found in the upper atmosphere, and is important in its UV blocking effects. You may also encounter ozone when electrical equipment shorts out, the energy creating ozone from oxygen in the atmosphere, and you likely have smelled it.
One potential biological effect of ozone is antimicrobial. Because it is a highly reactive gas it may break down bacterial cell membranes. This reaction will liberate oxygen, which can have further negative effects against anaerobic bacteria. This seems to be the one well-established effect of ozone. Treatments which expose external skin infections to ozone have been shown to be effective in promoting wound healing. However, I need to point out that the FDA has not approved it for this use, and more research is needed to make specific recommendations.
This specific effect, however, cannot be used to support the efficacy for ozone therapy for any other indication or any other putative mechanism. There may be other potential mechanisms of action, but at this point they are hypothetical. One that is often cited is that exposure to ozone may trigger a temporary upregulation of antioxidant enzymes. I find this putative mechanism particularly unconvincing, since the anti-oxidant hypothesis has been shown to be far more hype than reality. This is also often offered as an all-purpose mechanism by alternative practitioners for any fad treatment they wish to sell.
Putative mechanisms include:
i) Increasing oxygen levels, glucose and ATP transporter molecules in ischemic tissues; ii) increasing the activity of bone marrow stem cells, so as to promote angiogenesis and tissue regeneration; iii) the upregulation of the expression of antioxidant enzymes in blood; iv) Promoting the neuronal medium rise; and v) Inducing growth factors
Again, I find these potential mechanisms frequently appear promoting dubious treatments. That does not mean they are wrong or can’t possibly be effective, but I find they are commonly over-called. A lot of basic science research looking for possible mechanisms of action fall into the “stuff happens” category. Cells, tissue, and organisms react to stimulation, especially trauma. The immune system will respond, and compensatory homeostatic mechanisms will kick in. This does not mean they are a mechanism for any meaningful or enduring biological effect that can be exploited for clinical benefit. That is a huge leap, one that cannot be made automatically, and historically the one that most often fails. Most putative mechanisms turn out not to be clinically meaningful, or have more downsides than upsides.
There is also commonly a lot of post-hoc reasoning. Anything that happens can be spun into a potential benefit – increasing or decreasing some measure of immune activity, increasing or decreasing oxygen, increasing or decreasing blood flow. It’s all good.
At this time the FDA states about ozone therapy:
Ozone is a toxic gas with no known useful medical application in specific, adjunctive, or preventive therapy. In order for ozone to be effective as a germicide, it must be present in a concentration far greater than that which can be safely tolerated by man and animals.
That is the key – even if there are effects which are potentially beneficial, we need to know if these effects occur at a dose and type of exposure that will not cause intolerable side effects.

Extracorporeal Blood Oxygenation and Ozonation
Steven Novella on December 10, 2025
Link

There is an entire industry catering to people who, as Webb once famously said on the hilarious Homeopathic A&E skit, have “more money than sense.” This is the so-called “wellness” industry, now supercharged by an online army of “wellness influencers”. At first approximation, this entire industry is basically a scam. That may sound unfair, but it is built into its very essence.
Consider – there is a proven and generally accepted process for determining which treatments and health interventions are safe and effective. Science-based practitioners will follow the recommendations of this process. It is imperfect, but it is by far the best we have.
The wellness industry largely sits outside of this process. That doesn’t mean everything offered under the umbrella of wellness is useless – they will incorporate some advice which aligns with scientific recommendations. But anything they offer that is science-based you will get from conventional outlets, and anything they offer that is outside of science-based recommendations range from experimental and premature to outright fraud and pseudoscience.
Their purpose is to prey on health concerns and fears using manipulative and misleading marketing tactics, often wrapped in harmful conspiracy theories and unscientific notions. There are countless examples on this site, and I am going to add one to the list – Extracorporeal Blood Oxygenation and Ozonation (EBOO).
This intervention is aimed at the high end of the market, to those getting older and realizing their millions cannot buy them the one thing they may want the most, extra time on this mortal coil, especially with prolonged youth and vigor.
The treatment is very invasive – it is essentially a blood pheresis treatment. Two IVs are placed, a large volume of the client’s blood is removed, treated, and returned to the client. The blood is oxygenated, exposed to ozone (which is a highly reactive form of oxygen), and then filtered. Some clinics will also expose the blood to UV light. None of these interventions have been shown to be effective in the general population, and the justifications are very thin.
The idea behind oxygenation is to improve oxygen delivery to the cells of the body. However, this makes not sense as a health-promotion intervention. If our hearts and lungs are working properly, the blood leaving our lungs should be between 98-100% saturated with oxygen. You can’t get better than 100%, so for those without specific cardiopulmonary disease, oxygenating the blood over one treatment will do absolutely nothing. Also, if someone did have pulmonary disease that reduced their ability to saturate their blood with oxygen, then a one-time treatment would do little to nothing. Generally these people need frequent or even continuous supplemental oxygen to increase their saturation on an ongoing basis. A one-time boost of oxygen will not help them much (try holding your breath to see how long your supply of oxygen lasts you).
The second component of the treatment is exposure to ozone, “ozonation”. The idea here is to expose the blood to oxidative stress in order to trigger the body’s antioxidant countermeasures. This is a typical gambit for alternative wellness treatments – either they do something generally considered good, in which case they are claimed to be a direct benefit, or they do the opposite, in which case they are claimed to be a benefit by triggering natural defenses. They win either way. So oxygenation is good, anti-oxidants are good, pro-inflammatory is good, anti-inflammatory is good – it’s all good.
The body does not need to be exposed to ozone to trigger the natural anti-oxidants, they are already triggered by the regular functioning of your mitochondria, the energy factory of your cells, which produce oxygen free radicals which are then scavenged by anti-oxidants. There is already an evolved balance of oxidative stress, which is also used by your immune system to fight invaders and also as a way to calibrate certain biological function to metabolic rate, and powerful protective antioxidants. There is no simple way to game this system, nor would you want to if it is functioning normally. Only if you have a specific disease which impairs your natural antioxidants would an intervention make sense.
Also notice how this claim significantly undercuts the “antioxidant” supplement claims of the wellness industry. They admit here that the body has natural antioxidants – in fact they are literally a thousand times stronger than anything you can get in a supplement. The treatment is also premised on the claim that some oxidative stress is a good thing, to maintain these natural mechanisms.
Finally the treatment filters the blood before returning it to the body. Again – in a healthy individual, the kidney is a finely tuned machine for precisely filtering the blood to remove toxins and maintain a balance of a long list of blood constituents. If your kidneys are functioning you do not need your blood filtered. And if you are having enough kidney disease to compromise this function, you should be getting dialysis ordered and monitored by a physician, not EBOO from a wellness center.
So the justification for EBOO is not convincing in the slightest, and is in line with typical alternative medicine hand-waving nonsense. But what about the clinical evidence – maybe it works despite the poor plausibility or by some other mechanism. This is also not convincing.
There is basically no research looking at the efficacy of EBOO in the general population, and no evidence for increased overall health and longevity. The scant research that does exist is in specific disease conditions, where at least there is some rationale. Here is a good example: Extracorporeal blood oxygenation and ozonation (EBOO): a controlled trial in patients with peripheral artery disease. This is a small pilot study showing some improvement in the skin lesions, but no change in vascularization. These are patients with vascular disease, so at least there is some minimal plausibility for a temporary benefit, from 14 treatments over 7 weeks. But the mechanism is unclear, and the results were never verified. This study is from 2005.
There are a few other studies, mostly by this same researcher, all in the early 2000s. At best they indicate there may be a role for this type of procedure in patients with severe skin lesions due to infection or poor oxygen delivery. This means there has been 25 years to do further research to study potential mechanisms and therapeutic effects. By now we should have a fairly definitive answer to the question of efficacy for EBOO, but there isn’t. We just have some preliminary research, some basic science, and then direct-to-consumer implausible claims not supported by research. That is the wellness industry.


The Blood Cleaner: Invented by Ray Jardine
Harriet Hall on June 14, 2016
Link


I recently heard about a man who was planning a hike in a tick-infested area and thought he could avoid Lyme disease by using Ray Jardine’s Blood Cleaner. Ray Jardine is a well-known mountaineer, rock climber, long-distance hiker, and outdoor adventurer. A lightweight hiking enthusiast, he has branched out into selling lightweight equipment like backpack kits, tarps, and insulated hats. Most of his products are reasonable, but one is not: the Blood Cleaner. It is a micro electronic device that allegedly kills or disables pathogens in a person’s bloodstream. It is worn on the wrist in a pocket on a wristband that has another pocket holding a 9-volt battery. He and his wife make the devices themselves at home and sell them for $78.95. It could not possibly work as claimed. It is as useless as Hulda Clark’s infamous zappers.
How Ray’s Blood Cleaner supposedly works
It sends pulsed micro-currents through the skin and into the blood vessels. The micro-currents are claimed to electrocute the germs in the bloodstream, killing bacteria, protozoa, and fungi, and disabling viruses, without harming the white blood cells. It is supposed to clean germs out of the blood just as taking a shower cleans germs off of the skin. It comes with two probes, one for cleaning the bloodstream and another for making nano-silver in a glass of water to kill pathogens in the upper GI tract. Nano-silver (a form of colloidal silver) may kill germs in vitro, but it is useless and potentially harmful when ingested by humans. Colloidal silver has been known to turn people as blue as a Smurf.
The Blood Cleaner is contraindicated in anyone with a pacemaker or taking strong drugs, and it is “not suitable for a person adverse [sic] to drinking lots of water,” since the killed pathogens must be flushed out of the body before they reach toxic levels and make you ill. It should be used only 10 minutes at first, building up to an hour a day for a month or so; then it can be repeated as needed, once or more each year or two. If you use it for too much time, you may experience what he calls bonking, symptoms caused by a massive toxic overload as the body dumps large amounts of wastes. Bonking is a “healing crisis” and a sure sign that the Blood Cleaner is working and that the person has “vast amounts” of pathogens in the blood.
Pathogens in the blood can allegedly make you more susceptible to catching infectious diseases; killing them gives your immune system a boost. They can sap a person’s energy and vitality, in both body and mind.
There is a tiny screw on the underside of the device that can adjust the frequency of the current from the Beck Frequency to the Schumann Resonance, and to the Tesla Resonance. I won’t comment on these except to say there is no evidence that they have any relevance to human health.
Testimonials
He claims to have some dramatic success stories concerning malaria, Lyme disease, and chronic fatigue syndrome, but he doesn’t provide them. He does provide his own testimonial. He had Lyme disease, was treated with 6 weeks of antibiotics, but continued to have chronic fatigue. He had not used the Blood Cleaner for a few years (why not, if it’s so great?) but he started using it again daily, and 10 days later he was back to normal. He also credits the device for the fact that he hasn’t had a cold or flu for 22 years.
What’s wrong with this?
Practically everything. In the first place, we don’t harbor pathogens in the blood. If we did, we would be sick; and they would be detectable by blood cultures and by simple examination of the blood under a microscope. I think Jardine or the people he relies on for his information may have been misled by unreliable live blood cell analysis. In the second place, applying a micro-current to the wrist couldn’t possibly affect pathogens in the blood, much less “electrocute” them. And even if you could eliminate all the pathogens at one point in time, what would prevent them coming back before the recommended treatment interval of a year or two? And of course there are no studies to compare the presence of pathogens before and after treatment, much less controlled clinical studies showing health benefits for users.
Jardine’s 40-day water-only fast
How likely is it that Ray Jardine has discovered a problem (pathogens in the blood) unrecognized by medical science and has found an effective treatment? He has no training in science or medicine, and he works alone. His blog account of his 40-day water-only fast demonstrates his gullibility and lack of critical thinking skills. He references an integrative medicine website that claims that a water fast of up to 40 days can save your life and will “help you overcome common diseases such as hypertension, diabetes, autoimmune diseases, and many others.” That is a ridiculous claim, but apparently Ray swallowed it whole. In a day-by-day journal he describes his suffering: hunger, lack of energy, lightheadedness, a period where “every cell of my body felt like it had a headache,” low enthusiasm, not getting much work done, “could hardly walk across the room without getting tired,” headaches, nausea, backaches, inability to stay warm, etc. He describes “malaise, as though this is a self-inflicted illness” [It is!] He lost 35 pounds. Essentially he starved himself and tortured himself for 40 days. It is a tribute to his willpower, but there is no reason to think it improved his health and every reason to think it subjected him to danger and useless suffering. His lack of medical knowledge is further demonstrated by the fact that he took half an aspirin every 12 hours for his back pain, a dose too low to have any effect.
Conclusion: Probably harmless, definitely quackery
The Blood Cleaner is probably harmless and might induce a placebo response, but there is no evidence that it has any meaningful effects on human health, and the rationale behind it is pseudoscientific. And if you want to avoid Lyme disease, a good tick repellent would be a much better investment.

Belly Button Healing: Science plus Magic for Only $99?
Clay Jones on September 9, 2016
Link


If you wanted to design and market an ineffective treatment with the best chance of successfully fooling consumers, it would have to include a certain set of key components in order to maximize profit. A connection to nature is extremely important, the more emotional the better. Although trickier to pull off, your product would need to call upon ancient wisdom while also being associated with cutting edge science. But keep the association vague and let the consumers connect the dots. A hint of conspiracy, where the consumer believes that they are being let in on a secret or suppressed cure helps too.
The mechanism of action should be unclear in order to avoid easy refutation, and should preferably involve concepts such as removing toxins and balancing energy or hormones. Again, it’s important to combine science with your magic, so include things like lymphatic drainage or increased blood flow. The ailments your treatment would remedy need to be subjective and likely to respond to numerous placebo effects. And the treatment should be simple, even a bit fun, in both concept and execution. Finally, throw in a catchy slogan or two and you’ll be rolling around on a pile of hundreds in no time at all.
Ilchi Lee, the founder ChangeYourEngergy and an “international mind-body expert”, has done exactly this, perhaps minus the pile of hundreds, and it is a thing of pseudomedical beauty. In an effort to help consumers naturally achieve “total body health” by stimulating the body’s “reset button” and harnessing the power of our “2nd brain”, Lee developed the process of Belly Button Healing (BBH) as well as a special tool for home therapy. If you think this sounds like something a clever CAM satirist might have come up with, you’re right. Unfortunately, Lee came up with his version years before I discovered the miraculous healing powers of the navel.
What is Belly Button Healing?
Belly Button Healing involves the “regular and mindful stimulation of the entire abdomen using the navel as the point of contact to relieve pain in the body, release toxins, improve digestion, boost energy and elevate mood.” It’s an “internal workout!” Sounds simple, and it is. It’s just acupressure with a gimmicky focus similar to the kind we’ve seen before involving the ear or the feet. The key to BBH is the use of a specialized belly button stimulating wand known as the Healing Life Wand.
The Healing Life Wand is a small plastic device with 4 different sized points that was, according to Lee’s website, modeled on an inspirational branch of the sacred Hwangchil tree that Lee found one day. The Hwangchil tree, again according to the BBH folks, is known as the “cure all tree.” Most of the sources I could find discussing it were associated with Lee, however there are a few Pubmed references that look into possible medicinal uses.
It’s hard to imagine how the medicinal properties of a tree branch might come into play when poking yourself in the belly button with it. Regardless, the Healing Life Wand is made out of plastic. It does boast an ergonomic design, a textured surface so your sweaty hands don’t slip, and those aforementioned points, which allow consumers to poke themselves in the belly button in various ways without fear of muscle fatigue. Why the different points matter isn’t explained on the website or on any of the available videos. Maybe it’s explained in the illustrated how-to book, which you can own along with the wand and access to an online course for only $99.
In addition to assisting with the therapeutic component of BBH, the wand also serves as a diagnostic tool:
The belly button is energetically connected to every organ and body part. You can target different pain points around the body by focusing on and stimulating the corresponding point in the navel.
Think of it as a line of energy extending from the navel to the corresponding organ. By using the special wand to detect tension or tightness at different points, you can easily determine where you need healing the most.
That’s right. As long as you know up from down and left from right, you can use the want to detect where the problem is and poke your aches and pains away. And if not, the kit includes a helpful diagram. But there is apparently much more to BBH than simply treating pain.
As we have seen with many similarly questionable treatments and products discussed on the pages of Science-Based Medicine in the past, the makers of BBH provide a list of generic reasons that a consumer may want to check out the product. The list is made up of vague complaints and problems that everyone experiences, like stress or tense muscles. There are also some that appeal to people who have already self-diagnosed themselves as having problems with digestion or unbalanced hormones. They also clearly want to appeal to the TCM and mind-body crowd.
    • Have digestive issues, IBS, frequent constipation or diarrhea, or a weak stomach
    • Have tense muscles or residual pain from a previous injury
    • Have drastic mood swings or feel depressed
    • Want to balance hormones
    • Frequently experience stress
    • Want to cool off the head and heat up the belly
    • Want to improve your digestion
    • Are looking to reconnect to your authentic self and strengthen your mind/body connection
How does BBH help people with the above concerns? Not surprisingly, the proposed mechanisms of action for this trifle of pseudomedical nonsense are almost entirely made up of vague and subjective claims no different than with thousands of other products and therapies. Cupping is a good example that recently found itself in the spotlight. There is nothing specific to poking yourself in the belly button on this list.
    • Promotes blood circulation
    • Warms abdomen, increases body temperature
    • Improves digestive and excretory functions
    • Relaxes body and mind
    • Increases immunity and detoxification
    • Boosts physical vitality
    • Clears head and improves concentration
    • Relieves pain and tension in joints
    • Expands physical and mental well-being
    • Makes skin lustrous and smooth
    • Creates feelings of centeredness
Ultimately their proposed mechanism of action is simply the manipulation of energy or “chi”. This is glorified acupressure after all. But as you will soon see, they attempt to link the prescientific notion of energy imbalances and stagnant chi with our scientific understanding of the enteric nervous system and the so-called “brain-gut connection.” It’s a blatant means of giving this ridiculous example of theatrical placebo more credibility in the same way that medical acupuncture proponents might invoke the release of endorphins.
Why the belly button?
This one is actually pretty obvious in my opinion. Other than serving as prime raspberry blowing real estate and a natural trap for navel fluff, the belly button, also known as the umbilicus, is likely an anatomical structure of significant importance in our collective unconscious. It serves as a constant reminder of our origins, our connection to the life-giving womb that was severed so that we might enter the world as an individual entity.
It’s also a visual focal point approximately at the center of our bodies. So I can certainly understand how it came to be a focus in various cultures and traditional medical systems such as TCM and Ayurveda. That’s where things stop making sense.
According to the website, “just below the surface” of the belly button is a number of vital structures, key neurotransmitters, and other important sounding stuff:
    • 90% of the body’s serotonin – the happiness hormone
    • 50% of the body’s dopamine – the joy hormone
    • An extensive network of fascia tissue (holds all your organs together)
    • About a third of the blood in the body
    • Enteric Nervous System
    • Digestive System
    • Lymphatic System
Of course the same would be equally true of any other location on the abdomen, but I guess that “McBurney’s Point Healing” is considerably less sexy and wouldn’t have the same widespread recognition as the belly button.
This is simply a list of things associated with the intestines, not all of which make sense scientifically or would in any way be influenced by poking them around a bit. The gut does produces serotonin and dopamine, for example, but they can’t cross the blood brain barrier and make us happy or joyful. In fact, a thorough discussion of the brain-gut connection is worthy of it’s own post because of the sheer enormity of pseudoscience out there taking advantage of such a complex biological system to fool consumers and patients.
Lee and the BBH team want the consumer to make a connection between the belly button and the gut more meaningful than simple proximity. Once established, and I’m sure you have seen this coming from a mild away, they attempt to pull a bait and switch. The BBH folks further explain this connection between the belly button and health:
While it may sound strange at first, the belly button is actually incredibly important to your gut and overall health.
Why? Your gut is known as your 2nd brain and hosts a plethora of neurons, nerves that directly linked to the brain, major arteries and hormone producing glands.
As the center point of your gut area, the belly button is like the gatekeeper to this inner world of health and vitality. In East Asian Medicine, major energy lines, or meridians, run through the abdomen, so when you stimulate your belly button, energetic blockages are released.
So because the belly button is near the gut, and the gut plays a large role in overall health, the belly button must be important too…because energy. There is certainly some truth to the concept of the gut as a “2nd brain”, but it is often used in the marketing of bogus treatments or in overzealous assumptions about the origins of psychiatric disorders. The enteric nervous system doesn’t think on it’s own, as is sometimes implied, but there is a complex relationship with the brain and it does play a potential role in mental health and mood. Again, this would make a great topic for a focused post.
Aside from testimonials on the BBH website and recommendations found on the websites of other proponents, there is no evidence to even review for Belly Button Healing or navel acupressure in general. Not even poorly designed pragmatic trials designed to yield positive results. And taking into account the utter lack of plausibility, the evidence would need to be pretty impressive.
Conclusion
Belly Button Healing is acupressure with a gimmick device and a silly underlying philosophy that attempts to connect the magic of TCM with the science of the enteric nervous system. It’s just another example of the theater of alternative medicine that might appear to be of benefit through myriad placebo effects. There is absolutely no plausible scientific reason to make a connection between the intestines, the enteric nervous system, or nearby organs with the belly button any more so than anywhere else on the abdominal skin, and there is no reason to believe that manipulation of the belly button would yield systemic benefits as described on the products website. Don’t waste your money.

Amino Neuro Frequency: Just More “Embedded Frequencies” Silliness
Amino neuro frequency treatment uses one-inch stick-on patches with embedded “frequencies” that the body recognizes and directs to the proper area to treat pain and inflammation. The concept of “embedded frequencies” is bogus and ANF is nothing but a theatrical placebo.
Harriet Hall on October 3, 2017
Link

What is ANF?
Amino Neuro Frequency is a treatment system being taught mainly to physical therapists and chiropractors. To quote from the website:
ANF is a revolutionary holistic approach to pain and inflammation. Practitioners examine the body following the nerve paths and focus on finding the root cause of the patient’s problem. They apply ANF discs to the skin to reduce pain, remove inflammation and prevent it from spreading via the nervous and lymphatic systems. They use the discs in conjunction with manual therapy.
How does it work?
From the same website:
It uses a combination of frequency emitting wearable devices, the ANF Discs. Each disc is applied directly on the skin and activated by the body heat. They transmit a unique range of frequencies through the neurons in the body. The nervous system picks up these frequencies, starting a self-healing and self-regulating process. By improving the nervous system signaling directly at the cellular level, the effect of the treatment is much faster and has remarkable durable results. The ANF Therapy does not require the use of any drugs or chemicals.
ANF discs are one-inch patches that stick to the skin. They contain 22.8% organic carbon fragments that allegedly store and transfer radio frequency in the form of sub-harmonic signals, programmed to a specific frequency by a patented AFG device. It provides the biofield with information via sympathetic resonance; your body recognizes which targeted result the patch is supporting. The “connection from the patch to the body is made through the nervous system and the seven layers of bio energy the body naturally produces, the patch providing the signal to promote cellular communication to reduce stress and anxiety while restoring imbalances, as an example.”
I don’t buy any of that. Do you?
Can you buy the discs?
No, first you have to attend the courses to be qualified to use them. Each course introduces a range of discs. Course 1 introduces the use of the first 20 discs, which is sufficient to help 80% of all pain and inflammation cases. Multiple discs are used on each patient. In the videos, they have them stuck all over, prominently on their face, several in one anatomical area like the abdomen. The discs allegedly decrease pain levels within minutes and are effective for 72 hours.
Testimonials
There are three video testimonials from doctors who use ANF and claim to have gotten dramatic results treating everything from sprains to fibromyalgia. The titles of the videos list them as “doctor” and do not divulge that they are chiropractors rather than MDs. One describes a patient whose pain went from 10/10 to 2/10 mere minutes after the disc was applied. If the pain is caused by injury or inflammation, how could it resolve so quickly, without time for tissue repair?
There are patient testimonials, of course, which are always problematic. What is missing is any evidence from controlled scientific studies. We are asked to accept the efficacy of ANF on the basis of testimonials alone, with nothing resembling scientific evidence. And we all know that testimonials are not reliable evidence and that any quack or snake oil salesman can provide any number of testimonials (some from actual customers, some fabricated).
A student reports
We have a first-hand account. A physical therapist attended the level 1 course and described his experience.
First, he explains why he attended the course. His wife has multiple health issues and has been “miserable for the last ten years.” After multiple conventional practitioners had failed to help her, “it came time to look into doing some crazy stuff.” A friend gave her ANF disc treatments, and “Her energy changed, her skin tone changed, and she had a life again… [she was] starting to feel better for the first time in over a decade.”
He attended the course with “an open, yet skeptical mind.” He learned that the body is full of energy, and there are thousands of different frequencies (Hz) in the human body. The ANF discs have flexible carbon metal built in; they have varying frequencies meant to target different systems/structures/etc.
After ANF treatment, he was able to touch his toes for the first time in 20 years. The class was small (15) and students got at least two patients every hour to learn with. Every single patient got results, some more than others.
The class included a review of anatomy, especially the lymphatic system. He says, “We as clinicians very frequently forget how important the lymphatic system is for everything.” (Oh, really? How important? How do you know? And what does that have to do with the discs and frequencies? And I really doubt that it is important “for everything.”) ANF was taught as an adjunct to other treatments, not as a replacement.
He plans to use ANF in his practice, but he still has some questions. And I have some answers:
    • How do we know what structure/system/cell/etc of the human body is what frequency? [We don’t.]
    • How are the discs created and how do they hold their energy? [They won’t tell us how they are created, because they don’t want to reveal how bogus their proprietary method is. And they don’t hold energy.]
    • What type of research was done specifically to develop treatment protocols? [None whatsoever.]
He assumed that the improvements he observed were produced by the discs. But the discs may have had nothing to do with it. There are other possible explanations for his observations: factors like attention, suggestion, relaxation, peer pressure, etc. To rule out the possibility that the discs are mere placebo, you would have to do a double-blind study. And it would be trivially easy to do. The manufacturer could supply placebo discs that had not been processed and programmed. If the ANF discs are truly effective, doing a proper placebo-controlled study would have validated their product and the expense of a study would have been an excellent investment that would give them bragging rights with great potential financial returns. No such study has been done. I think I can guess why.
I encourage you to go to this webpage and click on the video “Why Does It Work” where a patient asks that question and the therapist attempts to answer. He gives a hilarious non-answer filled with all kinds of pseudoscientific gibberish; it’s quite entertaining. Among other things, he explains that after treatment, the patient can expect to experience the symptoms of detox: dizziness, nausea, sweating, headache. He says this is a good sign because it shows that the body is healing; the symptoms can last for a couple of days.
“Embedded frequencies” are bogus
I have written about “Frequencies and Their Kindred Delusions” before. Some other products that claim to have embedded frequencies are Power Balance products, Ancestor Bands (they have the special frequencies that will put you in touch with your dead ancestors), and Philip Stein watches (with frequencies that will help you sleep).
They usually use the word “frequency” in isolation. But the word is meaningless unless you specify “frequency of what.” Frequency is defined as the number of occurrences of a repeating event per unit time, and you have to specify what event is repeating. Revolutions per minute (RPMs), heartbeats per minute, waves of light or sound, cycles per second. Hertz is the unit of frequency defined as one cycle per second.
There are a number of questionable websites like this one with long lists of frequencies for everything but the kitchen sink and the family cat: things like the body as a whole (62-72 Hz), individual organs (liver is 55-60 Hz), diseases (colds and flu are 57-60 Hz), “receptive to cancer” (42 Hz), canned food (zero Hz), fresh foods (20-27 Hz), and essential oils (320 Hz for rose oil). They mention nonsense like Rife generators, Kirlian photography, and electrodiagnostic devices derived from EAV (Electroacupuncture of Voll). Some even claim that if you maintain the proper body frequency you will never get sick. The claims on these websites are pseudoscientific balderdash, bull, codswallop, drivel, flapdoodle, piffle, and twaddle. Take your pick. The information on those websites is not to be trusted.
You can’t embed a frequency. You might be able to embed something that would produce vibrations or electromagnetic waves with a frequency, but it would require a power source. If a product contained a frequency generator, so what? It requires a phenomenal leap to imagine that exposing the body to that frequency would have a specific beneficial effect on an individual organ or that it would somehow improve human health.
Conclusion: “Embedded frequencies” are bogus
A little knowledge of basic science and human psychology should be enough to vaccinate people against believing the claims for ANF, especially in the absence of anything remotely resembling scientific evidence for its efficacy. In my opinion, it is a theatrical placebo like acupuncture.

Access Consciousness: Phrenology fused with energy medicine
Access Consciousness claims to show how to improve your mental and physical health by touching 32 Access Bars on your scalp. It’s basically phrenology reborn and fused with “energy medicine.”
David Gorski on July 8, 2024
Link

Ever since COVID-19 hit, it has seemed that 90% of what I write is about COVID-19, the antivaccine movement that was turbocharged by the pandemic, and associated quackery, such as repurposed drugs for COVID-19 that don’t work, false claims that COVID-19 vaccines cause sudden death, “turbo cancer,” and all manner of other maladies. Yet, the more “boring” health nonsense is still with us; it’s never gone away. So when I encountered something called “Access Consciousness,” I thought it would be a nice change of pace to discuss this rather odd “healing modality.” Moreover, as Jonathan Howard argues, as horrible as misinformation and quackery involving deadly diseases is, it’s nonetheless important to critically examine seemingly “benign” modalities like Access Consciousness, because (1) many of the ideas behind such “benign” treatments undergird a lot of more dangerous quackery and (2) the these “benign” treatments are often not nearly as benign as they first seem. Moreover, often these same ideas can be traced back much further back in time. They persist, reappearing in new forms over time.
Which brings us to Access Consciousness, which is an unholy combination of energy medicine and what is arguably modern phrenology.
Three years ago, Harriet Hall wrote about this particular form of nonsense, but rather briefly. So I wanted to look at it a bit more, if only to educate myself about something that I either had never encountered before or just didn’t remember ever having encountered before. Again, as Harriet pointed out, Access Consciousness, no matter how bonkers its precepts are, is not benign, and Jann Bellamy briefly mentioned how Access Consciousness. has invaded social work, while my reading has opened my eyes to how much this form of pseudoscience has invaded athletics too. With opening ceremony of the 2024 Paris Olympics less than three weeks away, one wonders whether we’ll start seeing credulous stories on Access Consciousness being used by Olympic athletes, the way that we’ve been seeing the promotion of cupping for Olympic athletes in 2016 for the Rio Olympics and 2021 for the 2021 Tokyo Olympics. Like the case for cupping, there is a direct line between seemingly “obvious” quackery and the less obvious quackery that we see in “integrative medicine,” which is perhaps why someone like Dr. Vinay Prasad, who before the pandemic thought that debunking quackery like homeopathy was a waste of time, didn’t take long to drift into COVID-19 contrarianism and echoing even RFK Jr.’s old antivax tropes.
“Access Consciousness”
So what the heck is Access Consciousness? If you do some searches, it doesn’t take long to find this five minute video:
Notice how happy and enthusiastic everyone is. That’s no surprise, of course, given that this is a promotional video, with people saying how unhappy they had been before they discovered Access Consciousness. Some of the claims are quite overblown, too, for example:
Access Consciousness What could the world be? War and famine and all the things that are considered dreadful here would not have to occur. It would be a place where when there is a forest fire, we could bring rain. Where there’s a sense of need to bomb, that need goes away. So everything could change with great ease if people were willing to use all these tools. I know that sounds idealistic and a bit crazy, but I know it can work.
Whoa. World peace, if everyone would just embrace Access Consciousness? That’s some claim there! It’s also so very, very deep, ma-an:
It’s a set of tools that you use, and at some point you actually become them, you be the tools. I can’t even express how much has changed because if I look before and after … two lives. It’s a whole new world, where for me personally, I was actually allowed to live. That’s what Access is for me, a world where I am allowed to live as me. That’s that … That’s that. Access Consciousness is a way of having your life back …it’s a way of getting the joy of living back, and ultimately create a different space for you to live as, that lets other people know that change in their lives, and change in the world is possible. Consciousness includes everything and judges nothing.
“Includes everything and judges nothing”? What does that even mean?
This, apparently:
Most people say, “be conscious.” What do you mean by that? If your eyes are open, you are conscious. No, you’re not. Being awake is not conscious; being aware is conscious. Consciousness is about never cutting off your awareness of anything. Always having that place where you’re willing to include everything, so you miss nothing and you get the choice that is always available. If you live from the place where you have a different choice, you get how much is possible for you, that isn’t it possible for others. What could you choose today, to create the world and the future that you’ve always known was possible?
Regular readers will recognize just how vacuous all this is. It’s Jack Handey’s Deep Thoughts applied to consciousness and health, a backbone to a “therapeutic frame work” that claims to offer its recipients all sorts of tools to change their lives, as it distinguishes between humans—those who judge others—and “humanoids,” people who supposedly, for example:
    • recognize their oneness with the universe and they don’t pit themselves against it.
    • look for ways to make things better.
    • tend to sit in judgement of themselves
    • recognise their oneness with their bodies and the world around them
But how does one achieve this ever-so-deep accessing of even deeper consciousness, brilliance, and nonjudgment (other than of oneself, which to me sounds potentially harmful if taken too far)? Well, that’s where it all falls apart.
If you go to the Access Consciousness website, the splash page proclaims it to be:
The home of Access Bars® and pragmatic tools to change things in your life that you haven’t been able to change, until now.
ALL OF LIFE COMES TO ME WITH EASE, JOY AND GLORY®
OK, then, but how? First, there are the Ten Keys to Freedom:
    • Would an infinite being really choose this?
    • Everything is just an interesting point of view.
    • Live in 10-second increments.
    • Live as the question, not as the answer.
    • No form, no structure, no significance.
    • No judgment, no discrimination, no discernment.
    • No drugs of any kind.
    • No competition.
    • Do not listen to, tell, or buy the story.
    • No exclusion.
Naturally, you can pay to find out the details of all of these “keys.”
Ironically, the only one of these that I could approve of without much reservation is #9, “Do not listen to, tell, or buy the story”; that is, if the “story” is the one that Access Consciousness is trying to sell you. But what do the rest of these even mean? Who cares if an “infinite being” would “choose this”? We are not infinite beings; the belief that we are is a religious, not a medical or scientific, belief. If you’re peddling religion, you should just admit it.
I also wondered what the heck “living in ten second increments” means. Here’s one description:
I often talk to people about living in ten-second increments. The idea is being present for every moment of your life. If you live in ten-second increments, you create being in the present moment. Most people, rather than living in the moment, try to create a plan and a system for the future so it will show up the way they want it. They create the plan and think they don’t need to be aware any longer. But there’s only one place we can live—and that’s right here, right now. Anything else kills you. You don’t get to have a life. You miss out your own life.
If you live in ten-second increments, you can start to break down the conditioning that has you figuring things out and planning in advance. You can learn how to choose in each moment. You can’t judge in ten seconds because it’s here and it’s gone. We prolong our agony in life by judging ourselves and trying to fix what we have judged. This is especially true of the way we parent.
To the extent that this just means learning to move on and not perseverate over your mistakes and things that you might have done differently and/or to try to enjoy the present while you’re living it and not be constantly thinking about what you should do tomorrow, that’s all well and good. However, all the rest just sounds like more Deep Thoughts, combined with appeals to what is very transparently a variation of “energy healing.”
On first reading, I also wondered what “no drugs of any kind” means. Does it mean just no alcohol or mind-altering drugs, or does it mean no drugs at all? My most generous first assessment was that it probably just means no mind-altering recreational drugs, like alcohol, marijuana, or others, but, unfortunately and problematically, it also appears to mean no psychiatric drugs:
When Access Consciousness™ says “no drugs,” no one is recommending you stop taking your insulin if you’re a diabetic or your thyroid medication if that’s what your body requires. Drugs in this sense applies to all street drugs (including that “natural herb” marijuana) as well as prescription drugs that keep you from showing up as you. Among these prescription drugs are those prescribed for ADD and ADHD (including Ritalin which is more hallucinogenic per weight than LSD), as well as the mind altering anti-depressant and anti-anxiety drugs.
The danger of these mind-altering drugs, even though they are legally prescribed, is that they alter who you are. One woman who had done cocaine and alcohol for 13 years before getting sober in a 12-step program actually stopped also taking her anti-anxiety and anti-ADD drugs when she became involved in Access Consciousness™.
Notice how Access Consciousness equates psychiatric drugs for ADHD, anxiety, depression, and the like with “street drugs.” This is profoundly anti-psychiatry, no less so than Scientology, with advocates even likening the effect of drugs to possession by demons “entities”:
Another interesting consequence of using drugs is that it invites entities to come into the body. This doesn’t occur with a glass or two of champagne, but it does occur with heavy alcohol use, as well as the use of other drugs. When an entity occupies the body, the body’s “owner” does not have full control or use of it. It is hard for those around him or her to know exactly who they’re talking to, as the entities’ personalities are usually quite different from the original person’s, and generally not an improvement upon it!
If you’ve ever noticed the smoky feel to bars or pubs, even now that smoking in them is banned most places in the world, then you have been perceiving the entities that surround alcoholics. That smokiness is the alcoholics who no longer have physical bodies to drink the alcohol, trying to enroll others who do inhabit bodies to take a drink for them to satisfy the entity’s craving.
Street drugs all invite entities to come into the body, as do some of the “mind-altering drugs” available with a prescription. These include the drugs that change your personality, such as anti-depressants, anti-anxiety, and anti-ADD drugs. The experience of being anesthetized for surgery can also invite entities into the body. As this is a rather finite incident, the problem of recurrence of entities that is the rule with regular users of drugs does not occur.
Hmmm. Maybe “demon” was the wrong word. Alcohol in bars sounds more like possession by ghosts than demons. At least Access Consciousness lets you undergo anesthesia for needed surgery because anesthesia is a “rather finite incident.” However, you get the idea.
I like how the Access Consciousness blog entry that I cited above is called Can Consciousness Change Your Cash Flow, Part V, because of course there appears to be a bit of an element of prosperity gospel to this whole grift.
Of course, thus far I’ve just described the philosophy (such as it is) of Access Consciousness. What are these “tools” described on the website and by its practitioners? Chief among them are Access Bars.
Access Bars
Here’s where the “new phrenology” comes in. Why? It turns out that “Access Bars” are supposed points on your head for which light touch can supposedly cause all sorts of psychological and health benefits. If you believe Access Consciousness, there are 32 of these points, and they supposedly store thoughts, memories, and emotions that can be manipulated for positive intent by gentle touching or “running the bars.” This three-minute video on the Access Consciousness website describes the process, promising to “reset your brain” with it:
Who doesn’t like a nice scalp massage?
Elsewhere:
Access Bars is a gentle touch hands-on process that releases hundreds of thousands of points of view which are limiting you in different areas of your life and body. These areas include body, aging, healing, sexuality, money, joy, sadness, control, awareness, creativity, plus many more. What would it be like to have more freedom in all these areas?
Having your Bars run tends to be a relaxing and nurturing process. At worst you’ll feel like you’ve had a great massage. Best case scenario, your whole life can change into something greater with total ease!
Looking at this, my first impression was: Who doesn’t like a nice, gentle scalp massage? It’s part of the reason many enjoy going to the hair stylist, because before the stylist styles your hair often the first step is a nice shampoo and scalp massage. OK, it’s not really a scalp massage, at least not as it’s shown in this video. Rather, it just looks like lying on a comfortable pillow and letting the practitioner gently hold your head. I love the part of the video where one of the speakers says, “The worst thing that can happen is that you just relax.” I can’t really argue with that. It does look relaxing. However, relaxation is also probably the best thing that can happen, because certainly touching some of the 32 bars (running the bars) won’t do anything more for you than that. It’s all the more amazing in that you—yes, you!—can become an Access Bars practitioner after just a one day online course, and Access Consciousness lists as of yesterday 486 such courses all over the world, with over 15,000 practitioners, again, all over the world.
Of course, I was curious about exactly where these “bars” are located. I wanted a map, and Google was my friend:
See why I say it looks like phrenology?
A more detailed map wasn’t too hard to find:
But what, you ask, is the evidence that any of this has any relationship to biology, medicine, neuroscience, or psychology—or even just to anatomy? The short answer is: none, at least no good evidence. The longer answer is: Of course Access Consciousness has a neuroscientist or two who claim to have “evidence,” published in—try not to laugh—the Journal of Energy Psychology: Theory, Research and Treatment by someone named Terrie Hope, PhD. in the form of a “trial”/case series of running the bars in seven subjects with mild-to-severe anxiety or depression and a more recent, even smaller case series of four UK police officers with anxiety and depression. Unsurprisingly, Hope is a naturopath “with advanced studies in quantum medicine, transformation and consciousness and has published multiple scientific research studies relating to neuro-activity, anxiety, depression and changes in stress levels and consciousness.”
But where did “Access Bars” come from? On Czech Wikipedia, there is an article that references an article in French that describes the origin of the process, as well as the beginner practitioner’s handbook. Fortunately, Google Translate tends to work well with French (unlike some other languages); so I’ll just quote the relevant part, translated:
Access Consciousness Bars is a supposed therapeutic practice promising “total health and ease and joy with our bodies,” as the promotional brochures claim. Invented in 1995 by Gary Douglas, an American who had a close relationship with members of the Church of Scientology, the practice arrived in France around 2010 and has been growing since 2015. For 2019 alone, the official website lists more than 500 classes and events in French.
In practice, the “therapist” places his fingers on one of the 32 points located symmetrically around the skull to “activate” different bars : that of sexuality, money, power, consciousness, healing, but also the tunnels of space and time, “reactivation”, the “aging toaster”, etc.
And:
The first document (71 pages) is intended for first-level practitioners. From the outset, the founders of Access Bars insist on the need to “free oneself” by accepting that “everything we think, feel, believe, judge or have decided is simply an interesting point of view”. This basis appears, in light of the following documents, highly necessary for the acceptance of the new – supernatural – truths proposed by Gary Douglas.
Because the American simply claims to have “asked questions to the Universe” and to have received, in return, “medium and channel abilities”, which allowed him to invent the “32 points on the head that we now call the Bars”. Information that “did not exist in this reality before it was transmitted to Gary”. The latter then “realized that the Bars were a tool to help people function differently on this planet” and that he had to “offer classes to strengthen and facilitate more choices and possibilities in others”. The term “offer” is obviously relative, since the many classes and trainings are obviously paid.
Of course they are. Elsewhere in a blog post, Access Consciousness basically admits that Douglas just pulled the Bars out of his nether regions, so to speak:
Where did the Bars come from?The Bars were originally channeled by Gary Douglas, the founder of Access Consciousness, in 1990. They did not exist on earth prior to that.
How nice. Also, it’s all basically just “energy healing”:
Are the Bars like Reiki or Cranial-Sacral work? Are they Acupuncture points?The Bars never existed on earth before they were channeled by Gary M. Douglas. While the points may appear to be cranial-sacral or acupuncture points, they have a different function when done as part of the Bars. We have not seen any other method generate the changes that are created by the Bars.
Reiki practitioners tend to do very well at learning the Bars since they are already familiar with energy. The Bars and doing the Bars for others seem to have a more wide-ranging effect on the whole lives of the people doing the Bars than Reiki practitioners seem to experience.
There you have it! Gary Douglas “channeled” the Bars into existence, and they’re not at all like reiki, cranioscaral therapy, or acupuncture, even though they very much are.
I also like how Gary Douglas basically “invented” the 32 bars based on “information that did not exist in this reality before it was transmitted to Gary.” But who is Gary Douglas? According to a page from the Access Consciousness website that is now only available on the the almighty Wayback Machine:
Gary describes the creation of Access as a series of revelations and insights. “What we now call Access started coming through in about July 1990 when I was a successful Realtor in Santa Barbara, California,” Gary explains. “I began channeling information about points on the head that act like a computer bank for all our thoughts, feelings, emotions, considerations, attitudes and decisions; anything that we decided that was important at anytime in this life or any other lifetime. I felt that maybe this could be a class for massage therapists or body workers. I came home and called four friends to come to a class on energy work. That was the first Access class.”
There you go. Douglas was soon joined by Dain Heer, a chiropractor, because of course Heer is a chiropractor. He apparently experienced an Access Bars session and instantly became a believer.
There is, of course, more to Access Consciousness than just Access Bars, because of course there is. There is also the Clearing Statement, which supposedly “clears the energy underneath the words,” as well as Access Body:
The Access body processes are an energetic, hands-on method that creates miraculous change, possibilities, and space in our bodies. They unlock the tension, resistance, and dis-ease of the body by shifting energy dynamically.
An Access Consciousness Body Process is a hands-on method that uses different hand placements on various positions on the body while asking specific energies to run at each spot. These processes facilitate the body’s return to its original functions, which assist with repair and longevity. The energies are the natural energies that bodies access from everywhere in the universe.
Nope. Nothing like reiki or acupuncture, is it? Actually, this sounds a lot like “healing touch” or “therapeutic touch,” except that the practitioner actually does touch the subject. And, of course, a cardinal sign of quackery is there, the use of the word “dis-ease” instead of disease.
Access Consciousness: More “energy healing” nonsense combined with modern phrenology
The bottom line is that Access Consciousness, its practitioners’ denials notwithstanding, really is a lot like reiki, craniosacral therapy, therapeutic touch, acupuncture/acupressure, and every other form of “energy healing” nonsense. It’s primarily religious or mystical in nature, requiring the belief in “energetics” or “energy fields” that are manipulated by the practitioner through touching these various points. Like many forms of energy healing, it’s basically faith healing that substitutes New Age mysticism for Christianity as the religion or supernatural belief system undergirding it.
I’m sure that someone like Vinay Prasad will say that Access Consciousness is so obviously ridiculous that I just wasted my time writing 4,000 words deconstructing it, but if there’s anything that the pandemic has taught us it’s that nothing is too ridiculous to become widely believed, even the idea that COVID-19 vaccines contain nanobots or somehow turn you magnetic yourself.

   Wishing Away Warts
Harriet Hall 
Link
Common warts (verruca vulgaris) are more of a nuisance than a serious health problem, but they are interesting. There is a whole mythology surrounding their cause (touching toads?) and treatment (everything from banana peels to vitamin C). Many people believe they can be made to vanish by suggestion or hypnosis. I used to believe that too.
Every doctor has wart stories. Here are some of mine.
    • A patient made an appointment to see me because he had a wart, but when he tried to show me his wart he discovered that it had vanished! Apparently, just making the appointment cured it.
    • Another patient did have obvious warts and I prescribed the “wart medicine” that our pharmacy tech compounded, based on salicylic acid. He was out of one of the ingredients and had to ask my patient to return in a week. When she returned, her warts were already gone. The wart medicine apparently worked so well that you didn’t even have to use it!
    • I worked with a dermatologist who used a colorful laminated card with a picture of a toad to stroke children’s warts, telling them it was a wart remover. In his experience, this would frequently make the wart vanish over the next few days. Was this ethical? Was he lying and deliberately deceiving patients, or could this be excused as playing make-believe to distract the child and improve his attitude about the wart?
He was certainly deceiving himself in thinking that this foolishness was actually effective based on his own uncontrolled observations. Hypnotists claim success in treating warts with direct suggestion: they say that prepubertal children respond almost without exception, although it is less effective in adults. I was taught that if a patient had multiple warts and you treated just one of them, the others would likely vanish too. This might sort of make sense if the treatment stimulated an immune response, but I haven’t seen any evidence to support it.
What can science tell us about warts?
A new review article in American Family Physician, “Treatment of Nongenital Cutaneous Warts” by Mulhem and Pinelis provides a thorough update of the current evidence.
Cutaneous warts are epidermal proliferations caused by over 100 types of human papillomavirus. They are spread person-to-person or by contact with contaminated objects. They are most common in children. Walking barefoot is a risk factor for plantar warts (warts on the sole of the foot that that have a different appearance due to being under pressure). Nail-biting, meat handling, and immunosuppression are also risk factors. 90% of renal transplant patients develop warts.
Warts are usually self-limited. Half resolve spontaneously in a year, two-thirds within two years. Watchful waiting is an option, but patients often want treatment because of discomfort or social stigma. Two treatments have been clearly proven effective by scientific studies: salicylic acid and freezing with liquid nitrogen. There is limited evidence for silver nitrate, topical fluorouracil, and topical zinc. There is little to no good evidence for cantharidin, dinitrochlorobenzene, oral cimetidine, oral zinc sulfate, podophyllin, propolis ointment, retinoids and topical garlic extract. A few years ago, duct tape was reported to work, but subsequent studies showed that it probably does not. Warts can also be surgically removed, and dermatologists can offer specialized treatments such as intralesional bleomycin and pulse dye laser.
I found it interesting that the AFP review didn’t even bother to mention hypnosis, suggestion, or CAM.
Salicylic acid preparations are available over the counter for self-treatment. They are well tolerated and produce a 73% cure rate in 6 to 12 weeks. Cryotherapy with liquid nitrogen is equally effective but is more expensive, requires multiple office visits, and can cause pain, blistering, pigment changes, and other complications (tendon or nerve damage, scarring), especially if used too aggressively. A combination of cryotherapy and salicylic acid may give the best results. If a treatment caused permanent scarring, that would be worse than the disease.
To take a page from Mark Crislip’s job description, the patient has the mindset “Me have wart. You cure wart. Me go home.” The health care provider can re-frame the issue as “You have wart. Me educate. You think. We discuss.” Since warts are benign and self-limited, the option of not treating should always be on the table.
What about CAM?
Warts provide a fertile field for CAM. Various CAM modalities (chiropractic, acupuncture, homeopathy, energy medicine, etc.) have been claimed to cure warts. Acupuncturists have claimed a 90% success rate in only 1-3 weeks. PubMed lists a recent article about treatment with “sparrow-pecking” moxibustion that sounds intriguing, but no abstract is available. When warts follow their natural history and resolve, CAM is happy to take the credit. When they fail to resolve, CAM can continue treatments and continue to generate income. It’s a cash cow and ideal CAM fodder. Since warts are so common, potential clients are plentiful.
I used to believe that warts could be wished away. Now that I am older and wiser, I think warts vanish because of the natural course of the disease, not because of suggestion. Observers have reached false conclusions due to the post hoc ergo propter hoc (correlation is not causation) fallacy. Warts that went away after suggestion didn’t go away because of suggestion. The many folk remedies, like banana peels, were perpetuated by similar errors in reasoning. No matter how much we wish mind-over-matter worked, warts can’t be wished away: that’s the truth, warts and all.

Who Is Amy B. Scher?
Amy B. Scher is a proponent of energy medicine and things like astrology and homeopathy. She claims to be a “science geek,” but how could anyone who understands science think that tapping on the breastbone will fix the thymus?
Harriet Hall on March 23, 2021
Link

An email correspondent asked if I was familiar with Amy B. Scher. I wasn’t; and after reading about her, I am not impressed. She is a so-called “energy therapist”, and “mind-body-spirit healing expert” who has written four books, most recently How to Heal Yourself From Depression When No One Else Can. I have no interest in reading her books. She was interviewed in a podcast, and her own words told me everything I needed to know.
Her medical history reveals multiple errors on her part. She had some kind of debilitating health crisis that was hard to diagnose. It started with headaches, nausea, and other nondescript symptoms and progressed to neuropathy, inability to walk, and confinement to a wheelchair. She was even bedridden for a time. It was finally diagnosed as “chronic Lyme disease“, or CLD. (1) She readily accepted a fake diagnosis that is rejected by science but is promoted by so-called “Lyme-literate” medical doctors (LLMDs). CLD and LLMDs have been extensively covered here on Science-Based Medicine. (2) Her second mistake was to indiscriminately try “all available conventional and alternative methods” of treatment, including a year of antibiotics and a trial of hyperbaric oxygen. Her parents went into debt financing this wild goose chase. When nothing worked, (3) she travelled to India to get an experimental stem cell transplant, which “seemed to work” for about a year, after which her symptoms returned. (4) Next, she embarked on a quest to explore her “inner landscape”, assuming that unconscious thoughts, beliefs, or emotions might be impacting her healing process. She claims she discovered that unconscious beliefs and thoughts were affecting her physical body. (5) She adopted untested techniques from energy psychology (such as tapping rituals and rewriting unconscious scripts) to clear her unconscious beliefs and became convinced that she had healed herself. (6) Without submitting her beliefs to any kind of testing, she proceeded to tell the world, writing books and working with hospitals and organizations to teach her energy techniques to thousands of people.
In the podcast interview, she says she “discovered that some of the patterns I had in my life were crushing my spirit”. She says, “I lived in deep fear of being who I really was”.
She teaches methods to access the unconscious. She teaches “the Sweep technique” to sweep out unwanted beliefs like “I don’t matter”. She teaches “micro-movements”, tiny steps like tapping for 30 seconds or massaging the ears. She offers many different tools, saying that if one technique doesn’t work, you can simply try another. She claims the thymus gland is the master gland of the immune system and is connected to the entire energy system. She claims that tapping on the breastbone will affect the thymus gland underneath, sending a force of energy through the thymus gland to “swoosh out” stress and stressful emotions.
Rather than defending her techniques, she tells clients “Just try it. What do you have to lose?” She believes symptoms are neither good nor bad but are simply the body’s communication system. She struggled with depression when she didn’t even recognize it as depression. She felt blah and teary and exhausted but says she was never clinically depressed. And now she believes she is qualified to teach depressed people how to heal themselves? Has she tested that belief? Of course not!
She made herself three promises and encourages others to do the same: “tell yourself the truth, lighten the F up on yourself, and take action”. She advises clients to “trust the Universe”.
She accepts acupuncture, Ayurveda, and Reiki, muscle testing, and even astrology. She believes in inherited trauma, that life traumas can be passed down through the generations like DNA, that the Holocaust continues to affect the descendants of survivors, and that we inherit an energetic imprint. She believes that empaths “take on the energy around them”. And yet she claims, “I’m such a science geek. I love lab tests. I love the science of everything”.
Conclusion: Fantasy, not science
The interviewer on the podcast, Tami Simon, is the founder of Sounds True, a multimedia publishing company whose mission is disseminating spiritual wisdom. Are Amy Scher’s beliefs spiritual wisdom? I don’t know, because I don’t know what “spiritual wisdom” is; but I sure as heck recognize that they are not science. She calls herself a science geek but comes across as a gullible fantasizer.

Did Microwaves Harm US Employees at Its Embassy in Havana?
A recent review of unexplained symptoms in employees of the US Embassy in Havana pointed to microwaves. Was it mass psychogenic illness instead? Or something entirely different?
Kenneth Foster on March 26, 2021
Link

[Editor’s note: This is a guest post from two contributors, Drs. Kenneth R. Foster and Chung-Kwang Chou, exploring the controversy of “Havana syndrome“. Welcome!]
“An individual assigned to the U.S. Embassy in Cuba was awakened one night at home in Havana by severe pain and a sensation of intense pressure in the face, a loud piercing sound in one ear with directional features, and acute disequilibrium and nausea”, began a 2020 report by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NASEM) that investigated the problem.
The first incident occurred in November 2016. In early February 2017, a second person reported an unexplained onset of similar symptoms. The Embassy alerted its employees as a group that they could be under attack and requested any employees to report similar symptoms. Ultimately 68 US Embassy employees in Havana reported symptoms. The incidents occurred in residences or hotel rooms, not in the Embassy itself.
According to a heavily redacted June 2018 report by the U.S. Department of State (DoS), the Embassy had a series of “town hall” meetings with Embassy staff. On February 6, 2017 the embassy medically evacuated the first patient and, the end of September 2017, the Secretary of State ordered the departure of all non-emergency staff in response to what the DoS report termed the “health attacks”. The CIA withdrew its personnel from Havana as well. The embassy installed “recording devices that are geared to record high-frequency sounds” in some residences, without finding the source of the problem. “As of [June 2018], the who, what, when and sometimes the where behind these incidents is still unknown”, the report concluded.
As of mid-2018, according to the DoS report, “24 Embassy Havana community members have been medically confirmed to have sustained brain injuries while serving in Havana with the severity of injury ranging from mild impairment to injuries in a few patients so severe they may never be able to return to their previous jobs”. Other US employees at the U.S. Consulate in Guangzhou, China described similar experiences. At least 14 employees of the Canadian Embassy in Havana also reported symptoms. A February 2021 news report describes a similar experience to a covert CIA agent while he was sleeping in a Moscow hotel room. After suffering for months with crippling headaches, the agent retired prematurely from the Agency.
The symptoms typically occurred in two stages: some (not all) of affected individuals perceived loud noises accompanied by a headache, and a feeling of pressure in the head. A few days later they experienced vestibular disturbances (balance difficulties) and cognitive deficits (“brain fog”).
An account, relayed to us by a member of the NASEM panel that investigated the matter, described a “funny clicking sound and the feeling of being pushed or pressure with head pain”. These sensations persisted while the individuals were “outside or in front of a window, and they went away when they went behind a wall or left the room”. Multiple individuals, who had worked in Havana and Guangzhou who were interviewed by members of the NASEM panel, gave similar accounts, emphasizing the directionality of the pressure and its attenuation behind walls.
Medical follow-up
The DoS partially evacuated the Embassy in Havana. Affected individuals were referred to U.S. doctors for treatment and evaluation. Some went to an otolaryngology (ear specialist) group led by Michael Hoﬀer at the University of Miami (UM). Hoffer, a former military physician who had done extensive research on traumatic brain injury, conducted a series of vestibular (inner ear and balance) tests on the patients. Other individuals, including some of patients who had previously been evaluated at UM, were evaluated by a head injury group led by Doug Smith at the University of Pennsylvania (Penn; note that Dr. Foster is an Emeritus Professor at Penn but had no connection with this work).
The UM group reported that all 25 individuals it examined had vestibular (inner-ear) damage and suggested that their findings were reminiscent of mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). Using a different set of tests, the Penn group concluded that the individuals “appeared to have sustained injury to widespread brain networks”, a different diagnosis but likewise pointing to mild brain injury. Hoffer concluded:
It does not seem imprudent to speculate that a highly speciﬁc unidentiﬁed energy exposure, perceived as a sound or pressure, could be producing an inner ear disturbance or demonstrate ﬁndings suggestive of an mTBI.
Both studies were challenged for a variety of reasons that can be roughly summarized as over-interpreting weak and in most respects normal clinical findings. The Penn findings, in particular, were challenged in a scathing editorial in the journal Cortex, and a devastating review by Neuroskeptic.
Late in 2017 at the request of the DoS, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reviewed medical records of 95 individuals reporting symptoms, including those receiving care at UM and Penn as well as patients seen by DoS medical facilities. The records varied greatly in completeness, many even lacked information about when the symptoms began, and dates of arrival and departure from Cuba. More than a third lacked rudimentary information such as dates of birth and gender of the individuals. The CDC study had no comparison group to allow it to assess risks and mitigation factors for the symptoms and no independent way to diagnose the health problems. It could only line up symptoms in secondhand medical data in search of patterns.


The CDC identified 15 “presumptive” cases based on similarities of the patients’ symptoms. These cases had a “biphasic” onset of symptoms, with some symptoms developing immediately after their presumed exposure, followed a few days or weeks later by other symptoms (Table 1). The most commonly reported “initial onset” symptoms were headache, nausea, and auditory symptoms, and the most commonly mentioned “subsequent onset” symptoms were cognitive deficits and vestibular disturbances (Table 2). All of the symptoms were self-reported and nonspecific, so they could have had other causes.
Responding to their employees’ concerns, in 2019 the DoS turned to the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NASEM) which put together a blue-ribbon panel of distinguished physicians, engineers, and scientists to investigate. The panel was charged to “review the cases, their clinical features and management, epidemiologic investigations, and scientific evidence in support of possible causes, and advise on approaches for the investigation of potential future cases”.
However, the panel worked under constraints that limited its ability to carry out these charges. The panel had no access to patient records or results obtained by previous investigators, lacked access to classified information, was not permitted to contact Cuban physicians who were likewise mystified by the events, and – until late in its work – could not even read the CDC report. It did, however, interview some of the affected individuals who had worked at the US Embassy/Consulate in Havana and Guangzhou. The panelists, which included very senior neurologists, neuro-otologists, and psychiatrists, did not consider the symptoms typical of any known psychiatric disorder.
The panel met three times, in December 2019, February 2020, and May 2020. In its first meeting, it heard from Hoffer and Smith – but not from scientists who had criticized their studies. In its second meeting, the panel heard from three speakers who had studied the biological effects of radiofrequency (RF) energy or microwaves (part of the RF spectrum that is used by communications and other applications). Two of these speakers had previously proposed that pulsed microwaves were the cause of the problems. Three additional speakers were affiliated with the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL), which had developed a high-powered pulsed microwave weapon (THOR) to destroy drones; little information is publicly available about that weapon, and is presumably classified.
Thus, the panel was steered by its agenda to focus on microwave weapons as the cause of the symptoms. The panel lacked the time and resources to explore other theories. In particular, it lacked participation by a social psychologist with expertise in mass psychogenic illness (an explanation proposed by, among others, the famous psychiatrist Simon Wessely of King’s College London).
In its final report (June 2020) the NASEM panel concluded that the symptoms were “consistent with a directed radio frequency (RF) energy attack”. Six months later, after a prolonged review by the government, the report found its way to the media, leading to numerous reports about “directed microwave weapons” possibly being used against the embassy employees.
Microwaves on the brain
Two main theories, not necessary mutually exclusive, have surfaced to explain what has come to be called the Havana syndrome. The first was that the employees were targeted by a weapon – the NASEM panel thought that the evidence pointed to microwave energy as the cause of the symptoms.
“Microwaves” entered the conversation initially through an almost comical series of non sequiturs: The employees heard unexplained sounds. In its investigation, the FBI found no evidence that an attack using acoustic weapon had occurred. Under some specialized exposure conditions, pulsed microwaves can elicit auditory sensations in some individuals. Ergo, microwaves were the cause of the problem.
This theory rests on the so-called microwave auditory effect (sometimes called the Frey effect), which two of the present authors studied in the early 1970s (KRF and C-KC). When a pulse of RF energy is absorbed in a person’ head, the resulting temperature rise causes tissue to expand slightly. This launches a pressure wave that propagates throughout the head to the cochleae, eliciting auditory sensations. Under realistic exposure conditions, the temperature rise is very tiny (microdegrees), and the pressure wave is far too weak to cause tissue injury.
This explanation accords poorly with the experiences reported by the embassy staff. Some (but not all) of the subjects perceived loud sounds from a particular direction, whereas the auditory sensations from pulsed microwaves are threshold hearing phenomena that requires the subject to be in a quiet room to perceive. The pressure waves are generated within the head and the sensations are not externally localized.
In the 1970s, the microwave auditory effect was chiefly studied using radar pulses. Recently, directed energy weapons such as THOR transmit extremely intense microwave pulses that would induce stronger but much briefer pressure waves in the head than old-style radar pulses. However, limited studies show that the microwave pulses transmitted by such a weapon are unlikely to cause tissue damage. Moreover, the equipment is large. It is hard to see how one could navigate such equipment to provide a line-of-sight view to a window in the victim’s home or hotel in what U.S. Senator Rubio called “the most heavily monitored city in the most heavily monitored country in the Western Hemisphere“.
The panel bolstered its conclusion by citing a number of RF bioeffects studies. These included speculative theories that have never been accepted by health agencies or expert groups but are sometimes invoked by activists to justify their concerns about health hazards of cell phones and Wi-Fi. The report also pointed to the long history of microwave bioeffects research in the former USSR, which reported many biological effects but typically failed to meet present standards of scientific quality. It did not cite the many extensive reviews by Western health agencies and expert groups that failed to uncover clear evidence for hazards at exposure levels below international exposure limits. Now, after seven decades of controversy, the recognized injuries from acute overexposure to microwaves only involve excessive heating of tissue.
In short, the microwave weapon theory falls apart on even cursory examination, being neither consistent with the facts of the case, nor supported by a plausible biophysical argument, nor supported by any observations of microwaves at places where the presumed exposures took place.
Other physical agents have been reported to cause effects reminiscent of those reported by the employees. High intensity infrasound (which has a frequency below 20 Hz, the threshold for human hearing) has been reported to cause dizziness, vertigo, imbalance, nausea, and other effects – similar to symptoms reported by the Embassy staff. According to French journalist Juliette Volcler in Extremely Loud: Sound as a Weapon, the U.S., U.K., Russia, and other countries have at some time or other launched programs to develop nonlethal infrasound weapons, leading to occasional stories of uncertain reliability in the press. However, a 2007 review by two researchers in a U.S. directed energy bioeffects laboratory concluded that infrasound weapons are not feasible as military weapons, in part because of the difficulty of generating and transmitting infrasound waves at militarily useful amplitudes.
But such weapons exist! In September 2019, Steven King, a tech reporter specializing in China, reported that China “had created the world’s first portable sonic gun for riot control”. The developer, Xiujuan Xie (Technical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Beijing) had earlier (2011) developed a novel generator to produce high intensity sound waves. The device that she described operated at a frequency (71 Hz) that is above the infrasound range but its design could undoubtedly be adapted to generate high intensity infrasound as well.
No technical information about the sonic gun is available. According to news reports, the device causes “extreme discomfort, with vibrations in the eardrums, eyeballs, stomach, liver and brain”. At some level of exposure, such effects would clearly be dangerous, although brief exposures at modest levels might be very unpleasant to an individual but not cause lasting damage. Since, as King reported, the “project team has completed its assessment of the device’s effects on the body” it presumably has good data on its effects on humans. Or maybe not.
But the story is not completely consistent. The weapon, shown in King’s article, resembles a rifle – and seems implausibly small for something that operates on gas at very high pressures and temperatures and consumes hundreds of watts of power as described in Xie’s original reports.
It’s in your mind
A completely different theory, in many respects more plausible, proposes that the symptoms were a manifestation of a mass psychogenic illness. This illness, formerly called mass hysteria, refers to “outbreaks of illness attributed to a toxic agent but for which no plausible organic cause is found“.
Writing from the perspective of social psychiatry, Bartholomew and Baloh proposed that the “Havana syndrome” was a mass psychogenic illness (MPI). They write:
…symptoms such as difficulty concentrating, brain fog, memory problems, and sleep-related complaints (e.g., drowsiness, insomnia) were present in nearly all patients, but are also common in those with anxiety, depression and both individual and epidemic forms of psychogenic illness.
Bartholomew and Baloh noted that the diagnoses of brain injury by the UM and Penn groups are hardly unambiguous. Physicians can “shape the presentation of symptoms through suggestion, as many of these complaints are common in the general population”. “The process of referring patients with non-specific symptoms to a clinic specializing in brain trauma can shape the symptoms into a specific pattern”.
In other words, the medical advice that a patient gets can depend on the kind of specialist he or she visits. This effect is well known to ordinary consumers: if my car makes a funny noise and I take it to a transmission shop for repair, the diagnosis is likely to have something to do with the transmission. That, roughly speaking, is analogous to what the DoS did with their employees who complained about symptoms.
In their 2002 article “Protean nature of mass sociogenic illness“, Bartholomew and Wessely gave historical examples of MPI. In the 1930s and 1940s, for example, a series of “mad gasser” attacks were reported in American towns, when residents became agitated by unfamiliar smells and assumed that they were the result of a gas attack. In Mattoon IL, more than two dozen cases were reported in 1944 of gassings by an unknown assailant, producing symptoms including “breathlessness, nausea, headache, dizziness and weakness”. No physical evidence or suspect were ever found, and the presumed victims recovered quickly. (By contrast, some of the affected individuals in Havana reported lasting disabilities).
The feeling is inescapable that something had happened to the employees who had experienced unusual and disquieting sensations while standing in front of their doorways. But those were only a small fraction of the Embassy employees who reported symptoms. According to Alon Friedman (professor of neuroscience at Dalhousie University, Halifax) who investigated the Canadian cases, only one of the affected Canadians had reported auditory sensations and acute events.
The NASEM panel “considered [the possibility of a mass psychogenic illness], while keeping in mind that the likelihood of mass psychogenic illness as an explanation for patients’ symptoms had to be established from sufficient evidence. It could not be inferred merely by the absence of other causal mechanisms or the lack of definitive structural injuries.” (The panel did just that in pointing to microwave attacks). Bartholomew, Wessely, and other social psychologists who have studied many incidents of MPI could have provided an expert assessment of this case as well, had they been asked.
After reviewing all publicly available evidence on the issue, we honestly have no idea what had happened. Mitchell Valdés-Sosa, director of the Cuban Neuroscience Center in Havana who is leading Cuban efforts to investigate the matter, emphatically pointed out to one of us that the Cuban government had no interest in harassing US diplomats given the urgent need to roll back the US economic sanctions which have devastated the Cuban economy.
However, in the murky world of intelligence, other calculus might apply. According to an October 2020 report in The New York Times, some of the affected individuals in China were CIA agents meeting with counterparts in other countries to discuss ways to counter Russian covert operations. According to the Times report, some members of the US intelligence community believed that Russia was to blame for the attacks in China. We will likely never know.
The window of opportunity for resolving this series of incidents has passed. The US response was simply too slow and uncoordinated. “Despite some early attempts to provide consistent support for potentially affected employees”, the 2018 DoS report concluded, the DoS response was hampered by the “lengthy vacancies at the Under Secretary level” with “no senior official [being] identified as having ownership of the issue”. The report found the “delay of almost six weeks between first knowledge of injury and the first briefing of Embassy staff to be unfortunate and the exclusion of family members from this knowledge to be unjustified, given the incidents were taking place at residences”. It appears that slowness of the Trump administration in filling senior DoS positions directly contributed to the unacceptably slow response of the DoS.
Science based medicine broadly refers to medical evaluation and treatment supported by the best available evidence. That project is complicated for the Havana patients by the many nonmedical factors surrounding the case, which may involve possible spy vs. spy machinations, classified information about weapons systems, and the policies of the Trump administration towards Cuba, China, and Russia that undoubtedly affected the responses of the DoS.
From the extensive redactions in the DoS report (which include, for example, almost the entire timeline of the events), it seems that the government knows a lot more about the affair than it has disclosed. The best one can hope for is that the government is better prepared to respond properly the next time a similar thing happens. If a weapon were involved (we are not convinced that one was) it surely will.

Visiting a Victorian Duckpond
Harriet Hall on July 2, 2013
Link

Ever heard of George Augustus Scott? Probably not. Although he was once touted as “Man of the Century,” he was actually a charlatan who sold electric hairbrushes. (No, an electric hairbrush isn’t a device that will brush your hair for you; it’s a hairbrush that supposedly produces a “permanent electric current” to cure everything from baldness to headaches.) He went on to sell magnetic corsets, electric rings for rheumatism, and sarsaparilla, advertised as the “GREATEST MEDICAL DISCOVERY of the AGE.” (You probably haven’t heard about that greatest discovery either.)
He and his many comrades in crime are profiled in a new book, The Medical Electricians: Dr. Scott and his Victorian Cohorts in Quackery by Robert K. Waits. You will find more quacks in this book than in any duck pond. It provides historical insights and reminds us that there is nothing new under the sun; similar charlatans continue to sell similar quack devices today, facilitated by the Internet and other media.
Electricity and magnetism sounded exciting to Victorian ears, but their properties were poorly understood. Great hopes were raised for medical applications. The opinions of experts varied. Priestly reported experiments from Italy and Germany in 1747-8 showing that a patient who held a vial of medicine while being electrified would get the same benefit as if he took the medicine by mouth. Benjamin Franklin, on the other hand, was persuaded that these reports were not true.
An advertising diagram of the innards of Scott’s brushes shows a cargo cult parody of an electric battery. There is a thin piece of zinc separated from a piece of copper by a felt layer. Sure, some of the elements of a battery were there; but they weren’t put together in a way that could produce electricity. Later versions had a small embedded magnet, but since it was too weak even to attract pins, Scott included a tiny compass in each box so customers could verify for themselves that there was a magnet in the brush that could move the compass needle.
An earlier device based even more loosely on concepts of electricity was Perkins’ famous tractors, where two rods made of different metals were drawn along a patient’s limbs to remove pain. George Washington bought a set. Early skeptics tested placebo tractors made of wood and found that they worked just as well, and that the effects demonstrated were merely the effects of hope and faith.
The variety of electrical products sold by Scott and his contemporaries is astounding. In addition to all kinds of brushes and garments, there were self-lighting electrical cigarettes, electric insoles, electric toothbrushes, hair crimpers, a “hydro-electric chain,” a pocket battery to treat the eyes, and an electropathic belt. The Actina promised to cure blindness, deafness, catarrh, and various chronic diseases. It had to be returned to the manufacturer every 4 months for recharging (at additional cost). The London Galvanic Generator was a pendant that would quickly relieve stomach, liver, and kidney complaints. The Ammoniaphone improved the voice and was endorsed by the famous soprano Adelina Patti. The patent magnetic Amynterion prevented cold feet, coughs and colds, and treated everything from paralysis to dyspepsia. Electrical products were even claimed to prevent cholera, based on an urban legend that telegraph operators were immune from that disease.
The book is exhaustive, and counting the profuse text illustrations plus two appendixes, it must contain every extant illustration of these products and their advertising. You could almost read it as a picture book: the illustrations themselves tell much of the story.
The theosophist Madame Blavatsky was skeptical, but for all the wrong reasons. She wrote that magnetic appliances could not work, because they did not connect the wearer to terrestrial magnetism (in her view, the chief source of human health).
Another early skeptic wrote in The Electrician that the claims for curative magnetism were:
…that particular combination of ignorance and impudence which in conjunction with rapacity, constitutes the worst form of quackery.
Such criticism had no impact. Sales continued to soar. The prestigious medical journal Lancet continued to accept ads for quack electrical products.
When product demonstrators at the Great Exhibition at the Crystal Palace were found to be cheating with a concealed battery, a company representative explained:
We have to do something like this to amuse people, you know.
They relied on some of the same sales tactics we see today, from doctor-bashing (“Nine doctors in the ten are murderers”) to ecstatic testimonials, grandiose claims, and money-back guarantees. They insisted each device should only be used on one person, so you had to buy one for each family member.
One of the funniest things in the whole book is this bizarre claim of integrity from a company selling magnetic shields:
If we are attempting to impose upon the sick for money, we deserve the severest punishment the law can inflict. No living man can gain anything by writing, speaking, or advertising a falsehood. God knows it all, and honesty is the best policy.
There was a lot of in-fighting among the various medical electricians. They plagiarized each other’s ads, imitated each other’s products, sued each other, and warned against imitations. Fortunes waxed and waned. Companies went bankrupt, but the owners went on to start new companies along the same lines. “Dr.” Scott (who had no medical credentials) died a wealthy man in 1890 and his company endured long after his death.
The author brings up an interesting point. He quotes the FTC’s Deception Policy Statement:
Advertisers cannot use fine print to contradict other statements in an ad or to clear up misimpressions the ad would otherwise leave.
So it would seem that most of those “Quack Miranda” warnings violate FTC policy. They appear in fine print at the bottom of ads to say the product has not been evaluated by the FDA and is not intended to diagnose, treat, or prevent any disease. Isn’t that intended to clear up misimpressions in the ads?
Why did so many people endorse these bogus products? According to Benjamin Franklin:
It would be justly said, ‘quacks were the greatest liars in the world, except for their patients.’
In the early years of the 20th century, the AMA published an extensive series of articles investigating patent medicines and quackery. Collier’s magazine published a series on “The Great American Fraud” in 1906. In response to these and other efforts, Congress passed the Federal Food and Drugs Act of 1906. It prohibited the interstate transport of unlawful drugs, and declared misbranding to be illegal, including false and fraudulent statements. In 1912 the Pure Food and Drugs Act was amended to make it illegal to sell drugs that the manufacturers knew to be worthless. The US Post Office also acted to investigate and prosecute for fraud those who sent false advertising through the mail.
If you think regulatory measures accomplished something, I need only remind you of the recent sales of power bands. And just look at this “as seen on TV” product and the list of claims for it. Its magnets even remove “toxins.” And here’s a company that sells various products with the claim that magnets have been used for hundreds of years as a homeopathic (!) treatment for pain, edema, and swelling. The website claims that magnets improve medical conditions such as arthritis, cardiovascular conditions, chronic pain, fibromyalgia, migraines and headaches, and osteoporosis. It is full of pseudoscientific mumbo-jumbo and demonstrably false statements. The only FDA disclaimer in the entire website is for the health claims they make for essential oils.
Even when a company does something that is clearly bogus or clearly against the law, they can make millions before the law gets around to taking action, and they gladly pay a small fine and move right on to the next scam.
I can’t exactly recommend this book as a “good read.” It beats the reader over the head with too many oppressive details. I can, however, recommend the book as a fascinating glimpse into history and a reminder that regulation has done little or nothing to discourage today’s charlatans. As a historian quoted in the book said, “…quacks and their nostrums will be with us forever.” And skeptics will always be there right along with them, investigating new quackeries and revisiting old quackeries that were investigated long ago and discarded, only to be resurrected and recycled today by a new quack.

Lawsuit Alleges School Wi-Fi Harmed Child with Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity
Harriet Hall on September 8, 2015
Link

My mother had a favorite saying that rhymed: “All you need from dawn to dawn is someone else to blame it on.” WiFi involves mysterious emissions that you can’t see and that sneakily permeate our environment, and they have become a popular target for blame.
A lawsuit has been filed against the Fay School in Massachusetts on behalf of a 12-year-old boy designated as “G,” alleging that the school violated his rights under the Americans with Disabilities Act and failed to use ordinary care for his safety. They allege the school was negligent in failing to make accommodations to protect the boy from extremely high levels of radiofrequency/microwave radiations. He allegedly suffers from Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity Syndrome (EHS). The family is seeking $250,000 in damages.
The symptoms
After the school upgraded its Wi-Fi system in 2013, G began to have headaches, itchy skin, rashes, nosebleeds, dizziness, chest pains, and nausea. He frequently went to the school nurse and had to leave school early. His symptoms would usually resolve after he had been home for several hours, and he did not experience “the intense symptoms” on weekends and holidays.
The diagnosis
One day when G’s mother picked him up from school, she discussed his symptoms with the school nurse, who indicated that various children in G’s classes had also reported similar symptoms. This led the mother to do “much research and study” which eventually convinced her that her child was suffering from EHS.
After learning of EHS, the parents took G to a doctor who was recommended to them by “environmental health specialists.” Jeanne Hubbuch, MD, determined that G’s symptoms were caused by exposure to the school’s Wi-Fi system.
The school’s response
The school engaged the services of an independent company, Isotrope, LLC, that specializes in measurement and analysis of radio communication signals and evaluation of emissions safety compliance. It was one of the firms recommended as an expert source by the parents who raised the concern. It reported that
levels of Access Point emissions, inside the School and on the grounds, were substantially less than one ten-thousandth (1/10,000th) of the applicable safety limits (federal and state).
The science cited in the lawsuit
The lawsuit claims that the diagnosis of EHS is supported by compelling science showing that when sensitive people are exposed to electromagnetic fields (EMF), it causes a higher risk of developing headaches, increases in heart rate, arrhythmias, changes in blood pressure, dizziness, and sleep deprivation. It shows that EMF “can change neurotransmitter functions, blood-brain barrier, morphology, electrophysiology, cellular metabolism, calcium efflux, and gene and protein expression in certain types of cells even at lower intensities.” That is not an accurate representation of the body of scientific evidence.
The scientific consensus
There is an excellent overview of the subject on the Quackwatch website that summarizes the findings of the World Health Organization and other organizations. Briefly, the symptoms that “EMS” patients report are real, but there is no evidence that they are caused by EMF exposure. In provocation studies, patients were unable to tell when they were being exposed to radiofrequency emissions, and they reported the same symptoms regardless of whether the devices were turned on or off. Steven Novella has written about it. Bad Science Watch has issued a position paper that reviews the science and concludes that the evidence “robustly” dispels the connection between WiFi and symptoms of “electromagnetic hypersensitivity.”
In one amusing development, protestors demanding the removal of a tower were informed that the tower had been switched off during the period when they claimed it was causing symptoms.
The doctor
Dr. Jeanne Hubbuch is board-certified in both family practice and in environmental medicine. Her website raises a number of red flags. She advocates functional medicine, biologic medicine, chelation, orthomolecular medicine, intestinal balancing, sauna, IV nutrients, complex homeopathy, supplements and enzymes, connection of illness to dental amalgams and root canals, high-dose vitamin C, alkaline IVs and an alkaline diet, and immune support for cancer patients with high-dose vitamin C, iscadore/mistletoe, curcumin, bitter melon, and pectasol C. She uses Heart Rate Variability testing and live cell analysis, promises to remove toxins and blockages, and claims that she deals with the underlying causes of illness instead of symptoms. These are all questionable practices ranging from the inadequately tested to the bogus and disproven. I won’t go into detail here, but most of them have been critiqued on this website, on Quackwatch, and in the Skeptic’s Dictionary. She doesn’t accept insurance or Medicare; if she did, I suspect they would refuse to reimburse for much of what she offers.
The doctor’s organizations
Hubbuch is a member of the American Academy of Environmental Medicine (AAEM) and the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS). The AAEM is a questionable organization that is not recognized by the American Board of Medical Specialties. I have written about the problems with that organization before. One of its major proponents is the infamous Dr. William Rea, who was featured on a Nightline exposé and who has repeatedly faced charges from his state medical board. He is not alone: Quackwatch has a page dedicated to the regulatory actions against AAEM members.
ILADS is a questionable organization dedicated to a questionable disease. Chronic Lyme disease has been covered repeatedly on the Science-Based Medicine blog here, here, here, and here. Skeptical Raptor sums it up concisely: “There is no evidence that chronic Lyme disease exists.”
Legal precedent
In a 2012 case in New Mexico, the court excluded the testimony of “experts” who claimed a scientific basis for EMF sensitivity on the grounds that their evidence was not generally accepted by the scientific community, and that “experimental and epidemiological studies have failed to provide clear support for a causal relationship between electromagnetic fields and complaints of EMS.” The suit was dismissed.
Never mind
In the current case, both sides have asked the judge to postpone a hearing until September 25, saying an agreement may eliminate the need for that hearing. The case may be dropped (and in my opinion should be dropped), but it serves as a cautionary example. If cases like these with no scientific merit were to succeed, it would create difficulties for schools that are trying to provide a computer-age education for their students. It would encourage public misunderstanding of the issues, and would encourage quack diagnoses and treatments.
Most importantly, this lawsuit is a disservice to this child. He has symptoms that deserve to be taken seriously, rationally investigated, and treated appropriately. Jumping to the conclusion that they are caused by “electromagnetic hypersensitivity” and seeking a remedy through litigation are surely not in his best interest.

5G Is Coming
The imminent roll out of 5G technology has again sparked media coverage of the possible risks of EMF exposure, but the scientific consensus remains that the technology is safe.
Steven Novella on May 15, 2019
Link

Imagine if a new technology was being proposed that would provide a substantial convenience, to the point that most people would use it in one form or another, and our economic infrastructure would be reshaped around this new technology. However, the technology involves some risk and scientists estimate that 50,000 people in the US would die each year as a consequence of its widespread use. There is even risk to people who do not use the technology. With optimized safety measures and regulations we could get this number down to 35,000 or so. Would the new technology be worth the risk?
I am talking, of course, about automobiles. In 2017 in the US, 37,000 people were killed in automobile accidents. The point is that we accept some risk along with the convenience of some modern technologies. We pump explosive gas into homes to use for cooking and heating. Sometimes there is a risk-benefit – heating homes keeps people from freezing to death, and automobiles can be used to save lives as well. But we also engage in risky pastimes, like skiing.
This context is important as we consider adopting new technologies. Nothing is without risk, and the best we can do is minimize risk, and consider the overall risk to benefit ratio of any new technology. Demanding zero risk, however, is unrealistic and will likely cause more harm than it prevents.
The 5G question
This background is important while considering the imminent role out of 5G technology. This refers to a new standard in wireless communication, using a carrier electromagnetic wave of higher frequency than the current 4G. It is the fifth generation wireless standard.
We are already increasingly dependent on computers, the internet, and wireless technology to connect. The promise of 5G is that it will increase information throughput, allowing for faster communication and decreased lag time. This will do more than just decrease download times or streaming quality, but also allow for the full realization of the “internet of things” that will connect many everyday devices and allow for new functionality.
Of course this is partly hype, and we will have to see how much of an effect it actually has. But computer and internet technology has more than lived up to the hype recently. It has transformed our world, on a level equal to the internal combustion engine. I think it’s fair to predict that there will be substantial benefits to the new technology.
The real controversy surrounds the question of risk. If we are about to flood our environment with 5G electromagnetic fields (EMF), what are the health risks? There is some controversy about the science itself, but mainly opinions vary in terms of how to interpret the implications of that risk.
First we need to differentiate hazard vs risk, a common source of confusion. Hazard is merely the potential for causing harm. A loaded gun is a hazard. Risk is the probability of actual harm. If that loaded gun is locked away in a safe, then the risk it poses is minimized. If that same loaded gun is in the hands of a child, the risk is huge.
So what is the potential hazard posed by exposure to 5G? Part of the problem is that as technology progresses, it presents a moving target for research. There is a lot of research into the biological effects of EMF exposure, but then when a new technology emerges it can be argued that we need a whole new set of research on this specific version of the technology.
Another source of disagreement is over exposure times. What if there are biological effects only after 10 years of exposure? Whatever research currently exists, you can always ask – but what if the risk kicks in at longer or higher exposure? These are legitimate questions, but the point is that we never get to the point that the question is closed, and zero hazard has been proven.
Currently the only proven biological effect of exposure to EMF, even at 5G frequencies, is slight tissue heating. There are many other effects hinted at in the research, but none have been reliably replicated and therefore are not established. Further, many of the biological effects are simply looking at changes in markers of biological activity. They don’t show actual hazard, just the potential for hazard if we make a chain of assumptions about what the markers mean.
For example, EMF has been shown to increase oxidative stress. But does this result in actual biological harm, or does the body simply adjust and reach a new homeostasis without harm? Oxidative stress is a normal consequence of metabolism, and organisms already have powerful antioxidants to deal with it.
The majority of scientists, including organizations and regulatory bodies like the National Cancer Institute, the FDA, and the EPA, look at this research and conclude that the hazard is minimal and the current safety limits are adequate. But some scientists have looked at this same data and come to a different conclusion, emphasizing extreme caution.
One such group I have written about before. They wrote a petition to the WHO which seems to get mentioned in virtually all media coverage of the topic. My recent linked article covers in detail why this group, in my opinion, is not credible and is likely highly biased, so I just refer you to that prior article.
The bottom line is that the consensus is that there isn’t much potential hazard from 5G, but there is a lot of speculative hazard that is driving a lot of the media concern. We do need to continue to do research, as the technology changes, so this will be an evolving area that does need monitoring. But at present there does not appear to be a reason to ban the technology.
What about risk of 5G? Obviously, we won’t know that until it is actually rolled out and in widespread use. But we can research the risk of technology already in use. The research fails to consistently show any correlation between degree of cell phone exposure and risk of cancer or tumors. (Most of the research involves cell phones because it is the most common source of exposure.) Again, you can never prove zero risk. But we can say any remaining risk is likely minimal. We will have to continue to monitor risk as 5G is adopted.
So both hazard and risk with wireless technology in general appear to be minimal, and well below the current safety recommendations. However, we have to acknowledge the uncertainty inherent in an evolving technology. The practical implications of this uncertainty is that:
    • We need to continue to do various kinds of research to monitor health hazard and risk as the technology and its use continue to evolve.
    • Common sense behaviors to reduce exposure, especially in children and pregnant women, are reasonable. For example, phones can be used held in front of your face, rather than held up to your ear. Or you can use hands-free technology when convenient.
    • Technology companies should consider features that minimize the exposure of users when designing applications.
I consider these recommendations to be out of an abundance of caution, meaning they may not be strictly necessary, but are a nod to the unavoidable uncertainty in the research. I don’t see any reason to stop the adoption of 5G or to avoid the technology completely. Further, as time goes by and we continue to monitor real world risk, hopefully our confidence in the safety of the technology will grow.
In terms of the risk vs convenience ratio, wireless technology is already far superior to many other technologies, like cars, that we take for granted.

Infomercial in PLOS One links to website selling unproven treatments for fibromyalgia and dementia
PLOS One recently published a clinical trial that was essentially a poorly-disguised advertisement for an unproven product. I object to this use of the scientific literature to market such a device.
James Coyne on May 30, 2019
Link

[Editor’s note: Scott is having a very busy week, and stepping in to help out is Dr. James Coyne with another guest post.]
Bizarrely, the megajournal PLOS One has published a paper that is suspiciously similar to an advertisement. The paper LOOKS like it’s reporting on a test of a product that supposedly treats fibromyalgia, but also pain, dementia, Parkinson’s disease and more with just SOUND: basically just listening to a 40hz tone (listen to the sound here). But it’s actually junk science that was probably created just to advertise a treatment gadget. Somehow this extremely low quality paper got through PLOS One peer review, even though it prominently links to an advertisement for the gadget. That advertisement is much more blatantly pseudoscientific, as it leans heavily on a flashy, but misleading promotional TEDx video: “Music Medicine: Sound at a cellular level.”
Join me in a call for a speedy retraction! In this article, I critique the paper and show exactly why it’s obviously junky science, and share my letter sent to the senior editor of PLOS One.
The article presents results of a pre-registered randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000 to a sham treatment.
As reported in PLOS One, the RCT was designed as a crucial test of the effectiveness of the device in treating fibromyalgia. Yet, standard analyses did not find a statistically significance between the active treatment that is being promoted in the video and a sham treatment constructed as a placebo. Ouch!
Technically speaking, the study found no time-by-treatment interaction. What does that mean? Patients were assessed with a battery of at least six self-report questionnaires at baseline – before any exposure to the treatment or the sham – and afterwards, post-treatment. In this case, the time-by-treatment analysis showed that the before/after differences for patients receiving the active treatment were no different than the results for patients assigned to the sham treatment.
However, reporting of the trial emphasized only differences that occurred within the active treatment group. The paper went on to declare these results:
provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
What was not emphasized is that similar analyses would have shown the same effects for patients who received the sham/placebo treatment. That is a big problem for any claims for the marketing of the device.
Presenting the results in this way disregards basic rules for interpreting a clinical trial. Peer reviewers should have caught this immediately. Actually, the PLOS One Editor should have noticed this error in interpreting the trial and not even have sent the paper out for review.
A linked website calls attention to the Clinicaltrials.gov registration of the trial:
Sound Oasis VTS-1000 – Current Medical Trials The medical potential of the VTS-1000 goes beyond sleep and stress and this is seen in the use of this potent device in three clinical trials registered with the U.S. National Institutes of Health – (1) Depression: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02685982?term=VTS1000&rank=2 (2) Fibromyalgia: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02493348 (3) Temporomandibular Disorder: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02427113?term=TMD+music&rank=1
This use of trial registration as suggesting some kind of endorsement by NIH is misleading. The actual trial registration page for the trial contains the standard warning:
The introduction of the article justifies the study with reference to preliminary data concerning ‘a well-established technique’ whereby sensory stimulation delivered to the skin can reduce pain.
Mechano-acoustic vibrations have been extensively used to address acute pain during orthodontic [26–28] and cosmetic procedures [29], and is a well-established technique in orthopedic practice [30] and physiotherapy to reduce muscle soreness [31–33], low back pain [34], and orofacial pain [35]. However, little is known regarding the application of vibroacoustic stimulation in the treatment of chronic pain conditions. Previous clinical studies have explored the use of rhythmic sensory stimulation to treat fibromyalgia [36–38]. Rhythmic sensory stimulation (RSS) broadly refers to the use of sensory events – including vibrotactile, auditory, and visual flickering stimuli – applied in pulsed forms with repeated short, transient stimulus events at regular intervals, or in continuous forms which generate oscillating (e.g., sinusoidal) stimulus patterns [39]
Actual studies of treatment of fibromyalgia are cited in the introduction, but they do not clearly support the efficacy of rhythmic sensory stimulation to treat fibromyalgia.
The Discussion section concedes a lack of established plausible mechanism by which the treatment should work:
There is no consensus regarding the mechanisms underlying the effects of sensory stimulation on pain.
The Discussion section attempts to neutralize the lack of differences between active and sham treatment by raising the possibility that maybe the control/comparison group is not really a sham, but another poorly understood active, effective treatment.
(Deja vu: We often see this argument when acupuncturists cannot find differences between active and sham acupuncture.)
However, the linked TEDx talk claims strong scientific support for cartoonish, simplistic explanations of miraculous effects in some dramatic case examples.
The PLOS One article is an infomercial, a key element of a marketing strategy selling unproven medical devices to persons who believe they are suffering from health conditions that are poorly understood and that have poor outcomes within conventional evidence- and science-based medicine.
The marketing campaign leaves patients and their families with the impression that a medical device that is for sale has been proven powerful and that it is similar to what is being used in prestigious hospitals.
The marketing campaign gives no indication that treatment of debilitating, complex, and poorly understood medical conditions should be conducted under medical supervision.
The American Medical Association advises against medical journals accepting direct-to­-consumer advertisements for medical devices, even when the devices are approved by the US Food and Drug Administration.
The AMA does not even consider what we find in this PLOS One article: A spun clinical trial directly promoting an unproved medical device with a link to a shopping cart allowing payment and home delivery to be arranged. No cost to the company for the advertisement, only payment of the Article Processing Costs (APCs).
We must ask how senior PLOS management and lax editorial and review processes allow readers to be misled and exploited by a journal publishing such infomercials as peer-reviewed scientific articles, not paid advertisements.
But let’s immediately get this article retracted. See my letter to the Senior PLOS One Editor at the end of this article.
The article
Janzen TB, Paneduro D, Picard L, Gordon A, Bartel LR. “A parallel randomized controlled trial examining the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia symptoms.” PLOS One. 2019 Mar 1;14(3):e0212021.
The abstract gives the basic design for the study:
A double-blind, two-arm parallel randomized controlled trial investigated the effects of gamma-frequency rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia. We were interested in whether rhythmic sensory stimulation would promote significant changes in fibromyalgia and associated symptoms, and whether treatment effects would differ between two distinct treatment parameters.
A total of 50 patients who had been diagnosed with fibromyalgia were randomly assigned to two test groups.
One group received vibrotactile stimulation from a continuous sine wave single-frequency stimulation (40 Hz) for 30 minutes, five days per week, over five weeks, concomitant with usual care. The second group completed the same treatment protocol but received a different stimulation, consisting of random and intermittent complex wave gamma-range vibrotactile stimulation.
The two groups were evaluated before and after for self-reported fibromyalgia symptoms, pain severity and interference, depression symptoms, quality of life and sleep quality.
What could be seen as a clever but uncool spinning of the results:
Results indicated that there were statistically significant changes from baseline to post-treatment in measures of fibromyalgia symptom severity, pain interference, depression, and sleep quality. However, treatment outcomes did not differ significantly between groups.
The spin becomes explicit in the conclusion. The seemingly good news is great for advertising the device, but should have caused the reviewers and editor to cry foul.
These findings provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
Basic study design
The presentation of the technical details of the study is linked to a picture of the device being marketed and even links to where it can be purchased.
Participants enrolled in the study were randomly assigned to one of two study arms (Fig 1). Both groups received 25 sessions of 30-minute rhythmic sensory stimulation over five weeks concomitant with usual care. Group one received vibrotactile stimulation from a continuous single-frequency sine wave at 40 Hz that was amplitude modulated on an 11-second cycle plus isochronous auditory stimulation with a 160 Hz tone amplitude modulated at 40Hz. Group two received vibrotactile stimulation from randomly intermittent sounds consisting of complex wave gamma-range noise with pitch peaks at 33 Hz and 45 Hz. In the initial trial study protocol, the stimulation delivered to group two was intended as a sham stimulation, however, careful spectral analysis of the stimulus conducted after study completion revealed that this was not the case. The stimulation was delivered via a portable consumer device (Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000) with a built-in low-frequency transducer located at the middle back region and stereo speakers located at ear level (S1 Fig).
Clicking in the (S1 Fig) took the reader to a photo of the device prominently displayed at the end of the article and links to the sales page.
Portable consumer device (Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000) equipped with a built-in low-frequency transducer located at the middle back region and two stereo speakers located at ear level. Source: https://www.soundoasis.com/products/sleep-sound-therapy-systems/vibroacoustic-therapy-system/
The intervention
The sound stimulus delivered to group one consisted of a continuous single-frequency sine wave at 40 Hz that was amplitude modulated on an 11-second cycle, plus isochronous auditory stimulation with a 160 Hz tone amplitude modulated at 40 Hz with secondary pitch peaks at 120 Hz and 200 Hz (Fig 2). The track has a 1-second fade-in and a 13-second fade-out, with an output level of -12.7db.
The comparison control condition
The second track, administered as stimulation to group two, comprised of randomly intermittent sounds consisting of complex wave gamma-range noise with pitch peaks at approximately 33 Hz and 45 Hz, and a secondary pitch peak at approximately 95 Hz (Fig 3). The sound was generated from a single hit on a percussion instrument (gran cassa), which generated a sound burst with a duration of 500 milliseconds. Each sound burst was separated by intervals generated by a random number generator producing numbers between 1-10. Each digit had an equivalent of 250 milliseconds; so that number 1 represented 250 milliseconds, number 2 represented 500 milliseconds, number 3 represented 750 milliseconds, and so on. These numbers were used to determine the intervals between each sound onset throughout the trial. The track was produced by arranging sound bursts separated by the random intervals until one minute of material was generated. This first minute of material was repeated four more times, but each of these five identical segments was set to a different tempo; the first minute played at 120 bpm, the second at 110, the third at 115, the fourth at 125 and the fifth 130.
Competing Interests
A competing interest statement discloses a conflict of interest, but an effort to manage it by keeping the conflicted author out of key decisions.
Authors T.B.J., D.P., L.P., and A.G. declare that no competing interests exist. L.B. declares a potential conflict of interest as he has served as a paid scientific consultant to Somerset Group and Sound Oasis, and receives limited royalties from the Somerset Group for the Sonic Aid series and from Sound Oasis on the sales of the Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000 device. To manage this potential conflict of interest, L.B. was not involved in patient recruitment, consenting, or data collection process, and had no direct role in the data analysis process. This does not alter our adherence to PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Maybe LB was not involved in these activities, as stated. But how do we explain the alignment of the spinning of the null results in the PLOS One article with the needs of an advertising campaign for a ‘powerfully’ effective device? I do not think this declaration lets the authors off the hook for a nonstandard interpretation of the results.
The website
A click on one of the links in the PLOS One article takes one to the product page for the VTS-1000 Vibroacoustic Therapy System, just as pictured in the article, but with pricing and a full range of accessories.
I have been visiting this site over a few weeks and the “! Only one left in stock” has been there every time.
The device is described as:
Clinically Proven, Doctor Developed Sounds…The revolutionary Vibroacoustic Therapy System uses clinically proven, doctor developed sounds and vibration to help you sleep, relax and renew your body – naturally! Vibroacoustic therapy systems, costing several thousands of dollars, have been successfully used in hospitals and clinics around the world. Now you can enjoy this same therapeutic technology at a fraction of the price. Sound therapy provides soothing music with clinically proven brainwave entrainment for effective stress reduction, relaxation and healing.
Vibroacoustic research and Dr. Bartel’s TEDx talk
The webpage allows a visitor to click directly to a TEDx talk pitch for these products:
Dr. Lee Bartel’s TEDx talk at Collingwood, Ontario gives an excellent overview of the current state of vibroacoustic medical research. Dr. Bartel explains how scientifically developed sound played through Vibroacoustic devices can help reduces the symptoms of Fibromyalgia pain, Alzheimer’s Disease, Parkinson’s Disease, Depression, and increase blood flow.
The video is a classic example of a well-polished TEDx talk pitch. Lee Bartel’s requisite moment of epiphany was extracting honey on a farm in western Canada. Honey sticking to belts made them:
Go squeak squeak squeak to drive me nuts and just as inevitably a cricket would walk into the honey house and would go chirp chirp chirp… it didn’t take very long before what started as a sort of a random chirp would synchronize with the squeak on the belt. Why this was happening was a question that lingered in my head for very many years until I discovered the principle of entrainment in physics, how one rhythmic vibrating object will synchronize with another and so I used that idea and started creating music to affect your brainwaves music…

Years later, Bartel would discover a single pitch of 40 HZ would reduce pain in fibromyalgia and Alzheimer’s symptoms.
The video gives detailed clinical examples of seeming miraculous, enduring improvements in an Alzheimer’s and a fibromyalgia patient using this Vibroacoustic Therapy System. In the example of the fibromyalgia patient:
We gave her a prescription of 23 minutes of 40 Hertz sound stimulation two times a week for five weeks on this device…and what we found after five weeks was that she had stopped using all her medication. She’s reported that she could sleep much better and she was less depressed. The chiropractor checked her neck and shoulders and she had more mobility.
The effects of the sound stimulation on a patient with are given a simple explanation:
Research shows that fibromyalgia has connectivity issues between parts of the brain and then the pain circuits so the theory would be in our assumption was that 40 Hertz sound stimulation would restore this connectivity and she demonstrated that there were positive results.
The TEDx talk ends with a rousing promise of this powerful music medicine at the cellular level being integrated into routine, conventional medicine.
I could not have foreseen that the idea that came from this cricket could start to create sound that might impact cells in your body. That stimulating cells with sound can reduce the risk and impact of health problems like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s and fibromyalgia and depression. But what I do foresee now in the not-too-distant future is that when a doctor encounters something like Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s or depression they might take out their prescription pads and write a prescription for sound stimulation and that’s music medicine at the cellular level [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]
The letter
I have written to Dr. Joerg Heber ([email protected]) Editor-in-Chief of PLOS One. If readers share my concerns, they might want to tell him directly.
Dear Dr. Heber:
I am writing to request a formal investigation of an article that appeared in PLOS One. I believe that a prompt retraction would be in the interest of the reputation of the journal and would protect consumers from the marketing of a dubious unproven medical device claiming dramatic effects of a 40 Hz sound on Fibromyalgia pain, Alzheimer’s Disease, and Parkinson’s Disease.
The article is
Janzen TB, Paneduro D, Picard L, Gordon A, Bartel LR. A parallel randomized controlled trial examining the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia symptoms. PLOS One. 2019 Mar 1;14(3):e0212021.
The PLOS One article reports a RCT in which no differences were found between the active treatment of rhythmic sensory stimulation of 40 Hz Vibroacoustic Therapy System and a cleverly constructed sham treatment. Despite this being a null trial, the article focuses on the within-differences for the active treatment (no different than in the sham group) and declares the results
provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
The PLOS One article contains a picture of the device that is being marketed direct to consumers and the caption to the picture is redundant with another link going directly to a product page where the VTS-1000 Vibroacoustic Therapy System is offered for $399.99, but with the admonition that there is only one device left in stock.
The website also prominently displays a TEDx talk with outlandish claims that I recommend you view.
The PLOS One article is an infomercial, part of a crass marketing of an unproven medical device to vulnerable patients and their families struggling with managing complex and poorly understood medical conditions for which conventional evidence- and science-based medicine do not offer much hope of relief.
AMA advises against medical and scientific journals accepting advertisements for medical devices, even those with FDA approval. PLOS One is now in the position of marketing an unproven device for the relatively low cost of APCs.
I hope the journal will respond promptly to this alert. I recognize that policing the quality of articles in a megajournal with ~20,000 articles published per year is a formidable task. But only a few, or even one articles displaying a few breakdowns in editorial and peer review can have substantial impact on authors and lay and professional perceptions of the trustworthiness of the journal. A prompt investigation to determine whether this article should be retracted or merely have a correction could be an important step in limiting any damage. I obvious favor a retraction.
Please let me know if I can provide further information.
Sincerely,James C. Coyne, PhD

NoteThanks to Paul Ingraham of PainScience.com for editorial assistance. I highly recommend his science-based fibromyalgia tutorial.
Note: The article was retracted.

It’s Hard Out There for a Psychic
Psychic? Exorcist? Acupuncturist? Homeopath? Naturopath? The practice is the same. The consequences differ.
Mark Crislip on December 23, 2016
Link


You know it’s hard out here for a PsychicWhen she tryin’ to get this money for the rentFor the Cadillacs and gas money spentBecause a whole lot of skeptics talkin’ shit
You know it’s hard out here for a PsychicWhen she tryin’ to get this money for the rentFor the Cadillacs and gas money spentWill have a whole lot of skeptics jumpin’ ship
In my eyes I done seen some crazy thangs in the clinicsGotta couple NDs workin’ on the track just for meBut I gotta keep my game tight like Kobe on game nightLike takin’ from a patient don’t know no better, I know that ain’t right
Thomas Jefferson
The recent Skeptical Inquirer has an article entitled “Psychic Arrested in Exorcism Scam.” It makes for an interesting analysis.
A New York based psychic was arrested for convincing a client that her failing marriage was caused by an evil spirit that could be driving out only after expensive exorcism.
Evil spirits do not exist.
But then, neither does chi. Or meridians. Or subluxations. Or innate intelligence. Or effects of hyper-dilute solutions. Or the ‘energy’ that is allegedly altered by reiki or therapeutic touch. Or toxins. Or the diagnoses from applied kinesiology. Or the intracranial fluid fluctuation of craniosacral therapy. Etcetera etcetera.
None of the theories of alternative therapies differ in any meaningful way from possession by a devil.
Psychic Lisa knew how get rid of the devil.
Just as acupuncturist knows how to unblock the chi, the chiropractor knows how adjust the subluxation, the naturopath knows how to detox, the homeopath knows curing like with like or the reiki practitioner knows how to adjust ‘energy’.
None of the treatments of alternative therapies differ in any meaningful way from exorcism of a devil.
the psychic conned the victim out of nearly $62,000 dollars over the course of several months.
It takes alternative cancer clinics to reach that kind of money. Anti-neoplastons cost $7,000 to $9,500 per month. Chiropractors charge $100-200 a visit, but you can get a deal of 20 visits for $429, cash. Acupuncturists are a bit less. But as a country? $30 billion a year or so.
While the mean per user out-of-pocket expenditure for complementary health approaches was $435 for persons with family incomes less than $25,000, those with family incomes of $100,000 or more had mean per user expenditures of $590
The legitimacy of spending money on alternative therapies does not differ in any meaningful way from the spending money on the exorcism of a devil.
Nicholes’s alleged scam [no, not supplements, complementary and alternative medicine] – as bizarre as it seems – follows a well-worn and often successful formula.
Why bizarre? 59 million Americans partake of in one kind of alternative therapy or another, which does not differ in any meaningful way from possession and exorcism.
What is the psychic’s formula?
    • incremental investment
    • sunken cost fallacy
    • people who are vulnerable to exploitation
    • people who are unhappy with some aspect of their lives
Psychic scammers become masters of emotional manipulation and quick learn what deep psychologic issues their client in going through and thus will respond to.
Does mentioning a cancer cure qualify? A cure of an imaginary chronic Lyme? Lifetime adjustments to maintain spinal health?
Is the formula used by SCAM providers substantively any different from the exorcist?
In a particularly insidious theme of victim-blaming, the psychic may even tell the client the entire success or failure of the curse removal depends on their faith that it will work- thus entertaining any doubt will jeopardize the plan.
Compare that to:
After at least 15 years of looking at alternative cancer cure claims, one thing I’ve learned is this. Whenever these “cures” fail, it’s never, ever the quack’s fault. It’s always the patient’s.
At least the victims of the possession scam ‘only’ lose a fortune and do not usually die. Usually. There are occasional deaths. But most who are involved with the psychic scam do not
come forward because they are embarrassed at having been fooled by what in retrospect was an increasingly outlandish series of claims.
No outlandish claims in any ND, DC, AC or Integrative Medicine Clinic. Oh, no.
SCAM users can lose far more than money and thanks to the internet, dead men can tell their tales:
On Feb 9, however, someone at his bedside reports that James is acidotic, his breathing is failing. He dies an hour and a half later. He was 6 years old. Burzynski’s treatment seems to have done nothing but make the boy miserable while he was conscious.
Or Katie May. Or acupuncturists.
Deaths from pseudo-medicine are materially no different than a death by exorcism.
Those who run the possession/exorcism scam, if caught, are fined and can go to jail, sometimes for a long time.
Pseudo-medical providers? They have nice clinic in the suburbs and a comfortable salary, and if they are lucky, an integrative medicine clinic in a University. With insurance reimbursement for their services.
It isn’t what you do, but how you do it. Billy gets fired, Donald gets to be President.
Don’t be a psychic, fortune teller or palm reader. Call yourself an alternative medical provider, you do not even need the quack Miranda, and you will can get away with anything, no matter how ludicrous. Including exorcism.

Willow Curve Device for Pain: Strong Claims, Weak Evidence
Harriet Hall on October 20, 2015
Link

Willow Curve is advertised as the “world’s first digital anti-inflammatory device”, “a laser smart device” designed to relieve joint pain with thermal and photonic energy. It contains over 150 bio-sensory and bio-therapeutic components that continuously monitor the body’s thermal and electrical response to the device, and computer chips use that information to tailor a digital prescription on the fly. That prescription consists of “multiple energies” that change thousands of times a second.
It’s not clear exactly what the sensors sense, or how they work. It’s not clear how the device responds to information from the sensors to alter the output of heat and light, and it’s not clear how it chooses the appropriate dose for that patient. They don’t divulge information like intensity and wavelength for the various treatment protocols. They claim that the treatment “stimulates 15 bio-physiological processes for treating the joint and surrounding tissues.” Which 15 are those, exactly? They say that the Willow Curve dilates blood vessels, slows nerve response time (is that a good thing?), releases endorphins, blocks specific pain receptors, and detoxifies by removing toxic debris from the joints.
They offer no evidence in support of these claims. I tried to get clarification from the company, but they didn’t answer my inquiries.
The Willow Curve is portable and battery powered, but looks somewhat cumbersome. It is curved, and can be applied to various parts of the anatomy. It measures 6.5″x3.74″x 4.75″, weighs 2.85 pounds, and costs $599.
Red flags
There are a lot of red flags that make me suspicious that this company may not be entirely on the up-and-up. The Truth in Advertising website discovered that:
    • Several of the patient testimonials are faked: the “customer photos” are taken from stock images.
    • They claim that the device has “helped save people from invasive surgery like knee replacement.” They offer no evidence that this is true. In a video commercial, Chuck Woolery tells us that NHL Hall of Famer Charlie Sanders cancelled his knee replacement surgery after using the Willow Curve, but elsewhere on the website they say “he significantly postponed his knee surgery.” So which is it? A commenter on the Truth in Advertising website provided this additional information:
FYI Charlie Sanders died in July 2015. He had a malignant tumor underneath his knee, only discovered during his knee replacement surgery. Had he not used [the Willow Curve] and delayed the surgery, maybe he would have lived.
    • It is said to treat a long list of conditions, but there is no evidence that it has been studied for any of those conditions.
    • They claim it “has been used successfully to treat a number of conditions in thousands of hospitals and clinics nationwide,” but that seems unlikely for a device that was invented so recently, and they don’t name any of those institutions.
Toxic joint syndrome?
One of the conditions the Willow Curve allegedly treats is “toxic joint syndrome,” a condition defined in this (unpublished) article as:
a constellation of signs and symptoms associated with an unhealthy joint resulting from injury and/or disease…[such as] …pain, swelling, redness, restricted movement, clicking or crunching, a catching sensation, reduced capacity for repetitive or enduring action(s), limitation of activities, failure of the joint to perform, radiographic changes, abnormal joint fluid and arthroscopic findings.
The author is Ronald Shapiro, the researcher who did the studies cited on the Willow Curve website; and in “Part 2” of his article he joins forces with a retired doctor, Charles A. Bertrand. Bertrand graduated from medical school in 1948, so he must be in his 90s by now. He is a cardiologist who served as an expert witness in malpractice cases for over 20 years and wrote a book about being an expert witness. I wondered why he would suddenly speak out to promote a device to treat knee pain, and I then I realized that he is on the company’s medical advisory board. And Shapiro is the company’s medical director. Conflict of interest, anyone?
Part 2 reads like a commercial for Willow Curve. The only mentions of “toxic joint syndrome” on the Internet are on sites associated with Willow Curve, so it is probably a bogus diagnosis invented to help promote a commercial product.
Clinical trials of Willow Curve
There are only two clinical trials, both carried out by the company’s Medical Director, Ronald Shapiro, in conjunction with other authors, most of whom are also associated with the company.
The first trial, in 2005, didn’t actually study the Willow Curve at all: it studied a precursor device, The MedLite. The title was “Safe and Effective Relief of Knee Pain for Patients with Renal Insufficiency and Renal Failure” — but it didn’t study patients with kidney disease! The subjects were patients with chronic knee pain and normal kidneys. It was a randomized, open label crossover study comparing ibuprofen 200 mg, ibuprofen placebo, and the MedLite device. It was a small preliminary study with only 26 subjects. Patients’ self-assessment of pain with the device was not significantly different from ibuprofen or placebo. The authors said it “outperformed” the other groups, but the only statistically significant difference between the device and ibuprofen was for flexion change. There was no significant difference in extension change or change in number of steps compared to ibuprofen, although it was significantly better than placebo for extension change and number of steps. We would expect that an impressive device providing heat would outperform an inert pill.
The study was essentially negative (patients didn’t report more pain relief than with placebo) but they found a way to make it look positive. They measured what they called “objective knee improvement” by a contrived composite of objective findings and differences in total pain scores between baseline and day 6, and lo and behold! They managed to get a highly significant difference favoring the device. They waved away the fact that subjects didn’t report improvement of their knee pain by speculating that true effectiveness might be obscured by “the extremely wide variation in pain perception” among their subjects (something they had not tested for).
The second trial, in 2013, was a pilot study conducted by three members of the Willow Curve Medical Advisory Board. In my opinion, the disclosure statement fails to adequately disclose their conflict of interest. At least this study actually tested the Willow Curve device. The subjects were 69 patients with chronic knee pain, randomly assigned to 4 groups of approximately 17 patients each. The groups got either treatment with the device set to provide only dynamic kinetic thermal energy, set to provide only dynamic photonic energy, set to provide both modalities, or a disabled sham device. It looks to me like the methodology was reasonably good. The findings: the fully activated device performed better than sham. The partially activated devices trended “in the direction of improvement” compared to sham, but the results weren’t statistically significant.
I have some questions about the graphs that perhaps a statistician could answer: they threw out some of the outliers; was that legitimate? They graphed the quartile ranges, and there is considerable overlap. I suspect that if they had calculated 95% confidence intervals, there would have been considerable overlap there, too. Isn’t this an indication that a repeat study might have gotten different results?
They did an exit poll that showed patient satisfaction, but they didn’t ask whether the patients had been able to detect which group they were in. Could there have been clues like heat sensations allowing them to detect when the device was activated? Even the authors of this study pointed out that it was only a pilot study and would have to be confirmed by larger studies. And we know how often the results of small pilot studies with a high risk of bias are reversed by subsequent larger, better-designed studies.
The study they didn’t do but should have: a comparison of the Willow Curve with other devices that provide the same modalities. Are the improvements due to heat that could be provided in other ways, or is there really something special and more effective about their sensors and computer chips? I’d want to know that before I spent six hundred dollars on their product. In the Q and A section, they ask, “How does Willow Curve compare to laser units on the market?” The answer compares cost and convenience, not effectiveness.
Is Willow Curve a scam?
They ask that on their Q&A page, and their answer is a mixture of paranoia, “they laughed at Galileo” arguments, and “we have testimonials.” They say people fear what they don’t understand, and Willow Curve is so revolutionary that it scares skeptics. They compare people who question its effectiveness to the members of the British parliament in 1878 who opined that lightbulbs were a useless invention. I’m not scared at all, and I’m not calling it useless or a scam. I’m just asking to the kind of evidence any reasonable person ought to ask for before believing in the effectiveness of any new treatment or drug.
Willow Curve makes a lot of claims, but there is no credible evidence to back them up. There are a lot of unanswered questions and red flags. Even if the effect is significant, it appears to be small in magnitude. Willow Curve appears to be unlikely to cause direct harm, and I don’t doubt that anything that delivers heat might help relieve pain; but I’m not persuaded that the Willow Curve has any unique advantages over other, much less expensive products. If you can afford to spend $600 on an experiment that might have real or placebo effects, you might want to try it. They do offer a money-back guarantee. My inclination would be to stick to less expensive, more evidence-based treatments until Willow Curve has been properly tested.

Whole Body Vibration Therapy
Steven Novella on October 14, 2015
Link

When skeptics hear the term “vibration” a red flag goes up, because that is a common term used in pseudoscientific jargon. Vibrations are often used to refer vaguely to energy or some physical or even spiritual property that cannot be detected, and is used in a hand-waving manner to explain extraordinary claims.
Vibrations, however, are also a real thing, referring to physical oscillations. Whole body vibration therapy (WBVT) refers to these legitimate physical vibrations. It is being offered as a treatment for balance, back pain, neurological disorders, and also simple fitness. Does it actually work, however, for the indications claimed?
What is WBVT?
WBVT is considered a passive exercise modality, in which something is being done to the person, rather than the person actively engaging in an activity, such as walking, weight lifting, or swimming. With WBVT users lay, sit, or stand on a platform that vibrates rapidly in one or more directions. The idea is that the rapid vibrations force the muscles of the body to contract in reaction, providing a form of exercise.
The plausibility of this treatment is therefore higher than many of the CAM therapies we typically discuss on SBM. In fact, I would not consider WBVT a CAM therapy. It is simply a relatively new treatment idea that is being explored.
Actually, the idea of using physical vibrations as therapy is probably much older, going back to the 19th century. However, research using modern WBVT machines is about 15 years old.
There are two basic categories of whole body vibration – physiotherapy simply uses vibrations to stimulate tissues, but not induce actual exercise. Whole body vibration training, however, uses the vibrations in combination with positions that induce muscle exercise, and should essentially be looked at as a form of physical exercise.
Various types of vibration can be used. Lineal refers to up and down movement. Pivotal refers to a “teeter-totter” movement. Either can also be high or low frequency.
As is often the case, there is the science of WBVT and its ethical incorporation into medical practice, and in this case also physical therapy and fitness, and then there are the claims that are made for WBVT by companies selling equipment. Not surprisingly, the commercial claims significantly outstrip the evidence.
For example, the Vibeplate has a long list of indications for WBVT including detox, back pain, increasing energy levels, increasing bone density, and neurological rehab. They also include this amusing explanation for why their product works so well:
We have gravity that pushes us from the top, it jams us into the earth and we have ground reaction force. Whole Body Vibration if properly mechanically designed, like the VibePlate, gives us vertical hits of the same kind of thing from the bottom up. Therefore, if we are caught in the middle, which the body is between gravity and the whole body vibration plate we also realize the benefits we are getting from the load of gravity, from the ability of the gravity to stimulate our bones, stimulate our muscles, stimulate our nerves, becomes very, very powerful. And if we can enhance that very quickly, very rhythmically, that is good.
I don’t know why they felt obligated to include a completely pseudoscientific explanation such as this, but it calls into question the reliability of everything on their site. Of course, gravity does not push people down from the top. Gravity is an attractive force – it is pulling down (at least in classic physics). It is also pulling equally on every atom in one’s body (ignoring insignificant tidal effects over the distance of a human body).
It seems that the marketing culture for medical devices and products requires this sort of magical explanation. Simply stating that WBVT is a form of exercise does not seem sufficient, there has to be a gimmick.
Does WBVT work?
Regardless of mechanism, the primary question is whether or not WBVT is an effective intervention. This question has to be asked for every individual use – WBVT by itself or combined with other forms of exercise and therapy, for each specific indication, and for various outcomes.
Let’s take the most basic question first – does WBVT have added benefit to regular exercise? A 2007 review found:
Twelve articles were included in the final analysis. In four of the five studies that used an adequate design with a control group performing the same exercises as the WBV group, no difference in performance improvement was found between groups, suggesting no or only minor additional effects of WBV as such.
Another 2007 review by a different group found:
Preliminarily, there is strong to moderate evidence that long-term whole-body vibration exercise can have positive effects on the leg muscular performance among untrained people and elderly women.
Looking through the specific studies, including some later than these reviews, that is generally what I find. The studies are mostly preliminary and tend to find that WBVT has some benefit for leg strength, specifically knee extension, but overall no significant difference than regular exercise. This makes sense, as the knee-extension muscles (quadriceps) are exactly those that would seem to be most exercised by standing on a vibrating platform.
Next up is bone density. This can be a serious problem in older individuals. It has already been demonstrated that weight-bearing exercise is beneficial to bone density. Perhaps WBVT is another option. A 2011 systematic review found:
Whole body vibration is beneficial for enhancing leg muscle strength among older adults. However, the review suggests that whole body vibration has no overall treatment effect on bone mineral density in older women. No randomized trial has examined the effects of whole body vibration on bone mineral density in older men.
Again, there seems to be a benefit for leg strength, but no specific benefit for bone density in women.
What about older subjects as a subgroup? A 2012 systematic review found:
Whole body vibration training may improve strength, power and balance in comparison with a control group, although these effects are not apparent when compared with a group that does conventional exercise.
This is another theme in the research results – WBVT works as a form of exercise for improving leg strength, but no better than other more conventional forms of exercise.
WBVT has also been looked at in patients with specific problems. In patients with lung disease, for example, either COPD or following lung transplantation, there seems to be benefit for walking endurance. This could simply be a leg strength effect, however.
WBVT is also being marketed at neurological populations, with the implication that it can positively affect neurological function beyond leg strength. In multiple sclerosis the evidence so far is unimpressive, as a 2015 review concludes:
Quality assessment revealed that the WBV training protocols were heterogeneous and the methodological quality of the studies was generally poor. We found borderline indication for improved 2-6 min walking endurance [ES=0.25 (95% CI=-0.06-0.0.55)] favoring WBV training whereas no benefits were indicated for short-distance (20m or less) walking speed or balance.
What about balance and walking overall? A 2015 systematic review found:
Although balance and mobility appeared to be responsive to WBV-plus-exercise, particularly in lower-functioning patients, compared with WBV-only, caution is required when interpreting the findings. Although there is some evidence for an overall effect of WBV on selected balance and mobility measures, its impact remains inconclusive.
Finally, a 2012 systematic review looking at functional treatment in neurological patients concluded:
There is insufficient evidence of the effect of WBV training on functional performance of neurodegenerative disease patients. Also, there is insufficient evidence regarding its beneficial effects on signs and symptoms of the disease, body balance, gait, muscle strength and quality of life compared to other active physical therapy or passive interventions in Parkinson’s disease or multiple sclerosis.
Conclusion: Putting it all together
The simplest way to make sense of the entire research literature on WBVT, in my opinion, is this – WBVT provides exercise to the legs, especially the thighs. This may improve strength, endurance, and walking. It does not appear to be superior to other forms of exercise, or to add much to a regular exercise program. It does not appear to have any specific benefits for bone density.
WBVT is a reasonable intervention to study, and it seems that more high quality studies are needed before we can definitely conclude its ultimate effects. However, existing evidence argues against any dramatic or specific benefit from WBVT.
The trap to avoid with this and other similar interventions is to fail to separate out specific from non-specific effects. WBVT is exercise, and provides the expected benefits of exercise, without providing any additional or novel benefits. For some, however, it has the allure of novelty, with the suggestion that it will provide some benefit beyond regular exercise. Certainly those marketing WBVT machines exploit this phenomenon.
Similarly, there is no evidence suggesting that yoga is anything but exercise, that meditation is anything but relaxation, or that Tai Chi is anything but exercise and balance training.
I think it is beneficial to our understanding, to guiding research, and to evaluating interventions to understand what they actually are, and to not get distracted by their superficial or gimmicky aspects.
WBVT may be useful as a form of exercise, but it does not appear to have any specific or unique benefits beyond that.

Whole Body Cryotherapy
Steven Novella on October 28, 2015
Link

Last week a Hawaiian woman living in Las Vegas, Chelsea Ake, was found dead in a cryotherapy chamber where she works. Apparently she was using the chamber unsupervised and accidentally locked herself in or passed out, and was found 10 hours later. Her death, of course, is tragic and we have nothing but sympathy for her and her family.
The event, however, was the first time many people heard of whole body cryotherapy (WBC) and prompted many questions. Three months ago Zachary Hoffman published a guest post on SBM about cryotherapy, showing that the science is just not there. He focused mainly on using ice packs to treat sprains and sports injuries (which is surprisingly not evidence-based, but also perhaps not unreasonable), I am going to focus on using WBC for general health.
What is whole body cryotherapy?
As is often the case, perfectly legitimate or perhaps preliminary medical procedures are hijacked by entrepreneurs and hyped into a bogus “spa” therapy, snake oil, or medical device. Preliminary evidence or legitimate uses are then used to justify the pseudoscientific extrapolations. Stem cells are a legitimate area of medical research, but I would not go to a stem cell clinic in China to treat your ALS.
In this case, any medical use of cold or any basic science showing that cold temperatures have some physiological effect on the body are wildly extrapolated into claims that cooling the entire body with extreme temperatures has some overall health benefit.
One cryotherapy sauna provider claims on their website:
Clients report that the experience is invigorating and improves a variety of conditions such as psychological stress, insomnia, rheumatism, muscle and joint pain, and various skin conditions.*
*These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
We see many of the signs of medical pseudoscience right here – using anecdotal claims, vague complaints, and now the common FDA “quack Miranda warning.”
At the extreme end, alternative medicine gurus are claiming that WBC treats cancer, and pretty much whatever ails you. They offer the usual hand-waving nonsense to justify such extreme claims:
Your body effectively goes into survival mode when it rushes all the blood to your core. In the process, your blood picks up extra enzymes and nutrients normally held in storage-mode by your body.
And of course they claim this can “detoxify,” boost the immune system, and improve circulation – the usual trifecta of alternative medicine bogus claims.
The procedure involves spending 1.5-3 minutes in a chamber of dry air cooled to -200 to -240°F. Treatments cost between $40 and $100 for a single three minute session. Frostbite is a very legitimate concern, so your skin cannot touch any surface. Entering with damp socks is enough to produce frostbite.
The evidence
Perhaps the most plausible claims made for WBC is its use following exercise to speed recovery or sore muscles. There is a September 2015 Cochrane systematic review of this specific claim which concludes:
There is insufficient evidence to determine whether whole-body cryotherapy (WBC) reduces self-reported muscle soreness, or improves subjective recovery, after exercise compared with passive rest or no WBC in physically active young adult males. There is no evidence on the use of this intervention in females or elite athletes. The lack of evidence on adverse events is important given that the exposure to extreme temperature presents a potential hazard.
Other reviews have come to the same conclusion – there is simply a lack of high quality clinical studies to draw a firm conclusion. What evidence we do have is not impressive. Effects seem to be very small, and only when compared to no intervention. Doing a usual exercise warm down is just as effective as cryotherapy – meaning that any beneficial effect disappears when basic controls are put into place.
Much is made by proponents of WBC of the research into its effects on depression and anxiety. However, the entire literature seems to consist of three studies performed by the same researchers, led by J. Rymaszewska. The three studies are small and poorly controlled, either without a control group or with no apparent blinding. These studies are all preliminary at best and cannot be used to draw conclusions, and I could not find any independent replication.
WBC has also been studied for rheumatoid arthritis (RA), which is a chronic inflammatory disease. A 2014 systematic review found:
Cryotherapy should be included in RA therapeutic strategies as an adjunct therapy, with potential corticosteroid and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug dose-sparing effects. However, techniques and protocols should be more precisely defined in randomized controlled trials with stronger methodology.
In other words, well-designed clinical trials are still lacking.
Conclusion: Cryotherapy is plausible but unproven
Cryotherapy in general, the use of cold to affect physiology, is a reasonably plausible treatment for various conditions, but requires further study before the net health effects can be sorted out for specific indications.
Whole body cryotherapy, cooling down the entire body (which may or may not include the head) to extreme temperatures for a brief time, seems less plausible in terms of having long term physiological benefits. Something real is happening to the body, however, and so there may be sufficient plausibility to warrant clinical research.
Currently, however, the clinical research for the most plausible applications, muscle recover from exercise or injury and chronic joint inflammation, is lacking. In both cases there is insufficient evidence to warrant making clinical claims, and less extreme interventions are likely to be just as effective. There is room, however, for further high quality clinical research.
Mental health applications are less plausible, and only have the most preliminary of studies from a single group. High quality studies are necessary to take such claims seriously.
Other applications of WBC are progressively less plausible and completely lack evidence. There is absolutely no reason to recommend the treatment for a serious illness, like cancer, or for overall health. This, of course, makes it the perfect spa treatment.
As always, with any treatment we need to consider risks vs benefit. The benefits are unproven, and in some cases implausible. There is insufficient rationale for treatment to justify any significant risk. The research is just as lacking on risks as it is on benefits, and it does not seem reasonable to assume such an extreme treatment is risk free.
WBC has now caused at least one death (even if accidental). That stands against the relative lack of evidence for any benefit.

Parabiosis – The Next Snakeoil
Steven Novella on August 3, 2016
Link
The pattern has repeated so many times that it is truly predictable. Scientists turn their eyes to one type of treatment that has theoretical potential. However, proper research from theory to proven treatment can take 10-20 years, if all goes well. Most such treatments will not work out – they will fail somewhere along the way from the petri dish to the clinic.
However, the media likes a good story, and one of their favorite narratives is the “new miracle cure.” They will often take preliminary basic science research and present it with headlines promising a cure for some horrible disease (sometimes they will add a question mark).
When we see these headlines, we know what will happen next – hucksters will ride the hype with a wave of snake oil products promising the same cure, and claiming to be based in science. Dr. Oz will probably promote it on his show, and Mike Adams will rant about the government conspiracy to keep this cure from the public (but he will sell it to you).
We have seen this pattern with antioxidants, stem cells, resveratrol, and countless others. Sometimes the hucksters manufacture their own hype, as with green coffee beans. They don’t wait for actual scientists, they corner the market on some worthless bean or berry, then invent health claims for it and try to hype demand through the usual channels. This sadly works.
Parabiosis
The huckster cycle is beginning again with a treatment called parabiosis. Actually, it is a treatment based on parabiosis, but is not parabiosis itself. The term refers to experiments that were first conducted in 1864 by Physiologist Paul Bert. He cut the skin of two mice, then sewed them together. When they healed together their blood vessels combined, enough so that they essentially shared their circulatory systems.
This technique became popular for studying physiology. Researchers could discover if blood factors affected some physiological property. The technique could be used to study the effects of hormones, for example.
In the 1950s researchers connected old mice to young mice to determine its effects. They found that the old mice experienced numerous rejuvenating effects. Many biomarkers of youth returned, and the mice lived longer. The younger mice connected to older mice also had shorter lifespans.
Parabiosis experiments died out in the 1970s, partly because researchers had learned what they could from the technique, and regulations of animal research made it more challenging to conduct the experiments.
Elixir of Youth
Interest in parabiosis, however, is now coming back. A recent article on Inc.com is sure to spawn interest and another cycle of snake oil promises. The article focuses on how billionaire Peter Thiel is interested in plasma transfusions from young donors as a life extension and rejuvenation treatment, based on the science of parabiosis.
I can’t help but also see the supervillain angle to this story – an aging billionaire, desperate to live forever, is feeding off the blood of young healthy victims. Of course, to get the full effect, a simple transfusion will not do. He will have to connect their circulatory system to his own.
What is the current state of the science in terms of parabiosis and anti-aging effects? Any specific health claims for humans is definitely unproven at this time, but the research is intriguing (i.e., perfect for snake oil). The mouse experiments convincingly show a benefit from parabiosis for older mice. One question is, does this benefit come from specific factors in the blood or from the fact that they are sharing their entire circulatory system?
In other words, are the younger mouse’s kidneys, livers, and lungs just supporting the older mouse’s organs by doing the heavy lifting of cleaning and oxygenating the blood? This is probably a factor, but the other option is that there are proteins in the young mouse blood that exist in smaller amounts in the older blood.
The latter seems to be true also. Researchers have found that higher levels of oxytocin in young blood, for example, stimulate muscle growth. Factors in the blood also seem to stimulate stem cells in many organs to start dividing again. This may be the main rejuvenating effect, bringing stem cells throughout the body back to life, helping to heal damage, replace cells, and increase organ function.
We are in the preliminary research stage. In order to truly answer these questions we need to do carefully-controlled clinical research in humans. Open questions include whether one time transfusions of plasma from young donors (<30) will have any enduring benefit on older recipients. It seems from mouse studies that blood cells are not necessary, just the plasma, which contains all the proteins and hormones that are likely having any effect.
If plasma is enough, then what effect does it have? Can it treat diseases like Alzheimer’s? Can it increase lifespan? How long do the effects last?
Critically – are there any risks or side effects? The mouse research revealed what was called parabiosis disease. In an experiment with 69 mouse pairs, 11 of them died quickly. It is believed this was from some incompatibility, a form of rejection. This has been reduced in later experiments by using genetically matched inbred mouse strains. So – how carefully matched do the plasma donors have to be to the recipients?
Some researchers have also raised concerns about stimulating stem cells in older patients. Parabiosis researcher Thomas Rando said:
My suspicion is that chronic treatments with anything — plasma, drugs — that rejuvenate cells in old animals is going to lead to an increase in cancer. Even if we learn how to make cells young, it’s something we’ll want to do judiciously.
Some researchers object to the notion that young plasma transfusions should be considered “rejuvenation.” No cells are being rejuvenated, they are just being stimulated into working harder. This may provide a temporary benefit, but is unlikely to significantly affect aging.
There may be a real benefit in specific disease states that are missing some critical protein in the plasma. Again – this will take years of research to sort out.
Other researchers feel we should identify the specific factors in the plasma that are having specific physiological effects and then give them in purified and specified amounts for specific conditions. This, of course, would be ideal, but the more clumsy method of just giving plasma may have to do until we identify those specific factors.
Where do things stand?
As of right now, young blood transfusions as the next elixir of youth is enjoying its 15 minutes of fame. The science is genuinely interesting, and seems deserving of further research. What is clearly needed is high quality clinical research, before any clinical claims are made.
Given history, however, it is likely that young transfusions, or even some form of parabiosis, will now also take on a life of its own as the latest snake oil product. Already there is a company called Ambrosia who is running a “study,” and as Inc.com reports:
The study is patient-funded; participants, who range in age from late 30s through 80s, must pay $8,000 to take part, and live in or travel to Monterey for treatments and follow-up assessments.
This is ethically dubious, in my opinion. Subjects should not have to pay for a treatment that is part of research. This opens the door to selling unproven treatments under the guise of doing a study (which we have seen Burzynski do for years).
Hopefully I will be able to tell you in 10-20 years if transfusions of plasma from young donors is of any clinical benefit. Until then the treatment will likely have a second life on the fringe as snake oil. Given that this is likely to be a very expensive treatment, it will probably be elite snake oil for the wealthy.
It will probably not be limited to the wealthy, however. Hucksters prey not only on the rich, but the desperate. Poor individuals with Alzheimer’s or other serious diseases will mortgage their house, or raise funds from friends and family, to pay for very expensive yet dubious treatments, even those costing hundreds of thousands of dollars. The international stem cell clinic fraud is one example of this.
The only thing that will end this cycle of exploitation and pseudoscience is for the scientific and academic communities to take proper interest and speak out, and for government regulators to do their job to protect the public from health fraud. Sadly, this is unlikely to happen. That is part of the repeating pattern also.

Can A One-Minute Cure Really Heal Virtually All Diseases?
The author of this book claims to have found a one-minute cure that will heal virtually all diseases. The claim is ludicrous, and is not supported by any evidence.
Harriet Hall on June 18, 2019
Link

I guess medicine as we know it might as well quit. We don’t need it any more. Madison Cavanaugh has discovered The Secret to Healing Virtually All Diseases and shared the secret in the 2008 book The One-Minute Cure.
And now for something a bit different. Many of you have been reading the Science-Based Medicine blog for long enough to have learned how we go about evaluating health claims. It’s time for a little audience participation in the form of a quiz to test your critical thinking skills.
Take the test
Read the following paragraph from the description of Cavanaugh’s book and answer these two questions:
     1.  Do you think the statements in the paragraph are true?
     2.  Can you guess what the “powerful healing modality” might be?
The One-Minute Cure reveals a remarkable, scientifically proven natural therapy that creates an environment within the body where disease cannot thrive, thus enabling the body to cure itself of disease. Over 6,100 articles in European scientific literature have attested to the effectiveness of this safe, inexpensive and powerful healing modality, and has been administered by an estimated 15,000 European doctors, naturopaths and homeopaths to more than 10 million patients in the past 70 years to successfully treat practically every known disease — including but not limited to cancer, AIDS, heart disease, diabetes, Alzheimer’s Disease, Parkinson’s Disease. hepatitis, multiple sclerosis, herpes, Rheumatoid Arthritis and asthma.
Answer the questions before you scroll down to compare your impressions to mine and to learn the identity of the powerful healing modality.
How did you do?
This is a self-graded test. You can check how you did.
    • Did you notice that no supporting evidence was offered? As Christopher Hitchens said, “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.”
    • Did you figure out that the miraculous treatment was hydrogen peroxide?
    • Did you wonder how a single treatment could be effective for such a wide variety of diseases, diseases with completely different etiologies and mechanisms?
    • Did you wonder if the author was a trustworthy expert?
    • Did you try to look up Madison Cavanaugh and discover that there was no information about scientific or medical credentials and no other publications listed for that author?
    • Did you do enough research to figure out that Cavanaugh was recommending 35% food grade hydrogen peroxide, starting with one drop in a glass of distilled water three times a day and working up to 25 drops? (I guess the “one minute” is the time it takes to mix the dilution each time, or to drink the mixture; but that would add up to many minutes over a long period of time, making the title deceptive.)
    • Did you discover that the regimen includes not eating for 3 hours before and an hour after taking each dose, and you’re supposed to stay on a maintenance dose forever?
    • Did you look for those 6,100 articles? Did you find any of them? (I found that many articles about hydrogen peroxide, but not a single article about its effectiveness for any of the diseases listed here.)
    • Did you wonder how they arrived at the estimate of 15,000 doctors, naturopaths, and homeopaths? Did you wonder who they were? Were you able to identify any of them? Was the treatment promoted on their websites? Were you impressed that homeopaths were using it? Did you notice the logical fallacy (appeal to popularity)?
    • Do you accept that 10 million patients were successfully treated? Would there be any way to verify that number? Did you wonder how many patients were successfully treated for each of the diseases listed? Did you wonder if the diagnoses of those patients were correct? Did you wonder how many patients were unsuccessfully treated?
    • Did you look for clinical studies published in peer-reviewed journals? Did you find any? I didn’t. No controlled studies, not even published case studies.
    • Did you notice they were allegedly treated over a 70-year period? Did you wonder why the effectiveness of the treatment is not widely known after such a long time?
    • Instead of looking for confirmation and succumbing to confirmation bias, did you look for sources that disagreed, that said hydrogen peroxide therapy was not safe or effective?
None of this makes sense
Think about it for a minute. If they had been able to reliably cure patients of almost all diseases for all those years, or even just since the book was published in 2008, can you imagine that we all wouldn’t know about it by now and be using it? No conspiracy is capable of suppressing the evidence of 10 million patients cured of diseases like cancer and Alzheimer’s or of suppressing their bragging rights. Patients and providers would not want to keep it secret; they all have friends and relatives with those diseases; they would want to spread the word and let others be cured. The news should have been all over the headlines. And surely someone would have won a Nobel Prize for such a paradigm-changing scientific discovery. The whole paragraph is laughable.
The rationale is pseudoscientific
The premise is that almost all diseases are anaerobic and cannot exist in the presence of oxygen. This is simply not true. It is a ridiculous extrapolation from a grain of sort-of-truth, the Warburg effect. Warburg studied cancer metabolism and made some useful discoveries; but his idea that oxygen would inhibit the growth of cancer cells proved wrong, and there is no way that ingesting hydrogen peroxide could increase the exposure of cancer cells to oxygen. Arterial blood is already 98% saturated with oxygen; it can’t carry much more, and hydrogen peroxide couldn’t supply more.
Testimonials are easy to find
There are numerous videos online with testimonials from people who have read the book and used its protocols and have noticed amazing results like complete clearing of their psoriasis.
Warnings are easy to find, too
Hydrogen peroxide therapy has been criticized on Quackwatch, Science-Based Medicine, and numerous other websites. There is even a video explaining the science that invalidates the pseudoscientific claims. Hydrogen peroxide is converted to water and oxygen in the stomach and the oxygen is burped out, not absorbed into the body. It does not raise body oxygen levels. The amount (a few drops added to a glass of distilled water) is negligible; adding this amount of 35% hydrogen peroxide to water doesn’t even bring it up to the level of the 3% solution sold as a topical disinfectant.
In 2018 Karen Savage wrote an article explaining how “ Peddlers of ‘FoodGrade’ Hydrogen Peroxide Exploit the Sick and the Desperate“. She reproduced an advertisement claiming benefits for a long list of diseases, including Alzheimer’s, cancer, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, food allergies, and cirrhosis. She quoted an FDA spokesperson:
No one has presented any evidence that hydrogen peroxide taken internally has any medical value. In fact, consuming hydrogen peroxide in the manner touted by these websites could lead to tragic results.
She went on to say:
The ingestion of hydrogen peroxide… has not been approved by the FDA to cure, treat, prevent, or mitigate any disease, so vendors who market hydrogen peroxide for ingestion — or with claims that it can cure or prevent cancer, AIDS, or other ailments by whatever means — are in violation of FDA regulations and they risk criminal prosecution.
She reported that there are thirty cases a year of hydrogen peroxide poisoning, sometimes resulting in death; and she covered the difficulties of taking any regulatory actions.
The FDA has been working to stop companies selling high strength hydrogen peroxide products from making illegal medical claims. In 2006 they warned consumers
not to purchase or to use high-strength hydrogen peroxide products, including a product marketed as ‘35 Percent Food Grade Hydrogen Peroxide,’ for medicinal purposes because they can cause serious harm or death when ingested. FDA recommends that consumers who are currently using high-strength hydrogen peroxide stop immediately and consult their health care provider.
Customer reviews
It is interesting (indeed, highly entertaining) to read the many customer reviews on the Amazon website. There are testimonials about improved eyesight, resolution of “minor arthritis,” warming of cold hands and feet, hearing 10% improved, white tongue turned pink, cancers cured (melanoma, brain tumor, lymphoma), more energy, better sleep, wonderful dreams (!?), dialysis down from 3 to 2 times a week, off all medications. One said it cured his skin cancer – before he could get a biopsy to find out if it was cancer! One user had tried a lower concentration and claimed that the preservatives in the 3% product made his kidneys hurt.
Several commenters said it didn’t work, was hard to do, and required a lifelong commitment. Several reported bad side effects. One said:
There was no data to back up the claims, no references cited, and no personal experiences cited. There was no information about the author’s education or experience treating patients.
Several said it was a short book (really just a pamphlet), overpriced, with no information that wasn’t readily available on the Internet for free. One said it was mostly a rant against the pharmaceutical industry. Many advised against buying the book. Some called it a rip-off and a hoax. Several called it dangerous. One pointed out false statements in the book like “in some especially polluted areas [oxygen] is as low as 10%.”
Conclusion: Pull the other one!
When a proposed treatment is untested or inadequately tested, I generally call for controlled studies and promise to follow the evidence. But in this case, I think we already have enough evidence to conclude that it doesn’t work, can’t possibly work, and is likely to cause harm. I think doing controlled studies to test the efficacy of Cavanaugh’s protocol would be a big mistake, a waste of money and a risk to the health of participants. You can call me biased; I am biased in favor of science and reason.
These claims for hydrogen peroxide deserve some kind of “worst ever” award. My immediate reaction was “pull the other one!” I find it hard to comprehend how anyone could believe such arrant nonsense. It’s a sad commentary on the thinking skills of the general public. It shows that common sense is not common. I despair!


   Faith Healing

   Faith Healing
Harriet Hall
Link
Faith healing is based on belief and is about as far as you can get from science-based medicine, but it is not exempt from science. If it really worked, science would be able to document its cures and would be the only reliable way to validate its effectiveness. Miraculous cures continue to be reported on a regular basis: what are we to make of them? In the Healing Rooms Ministry of Bethel Church in Redding, California, people regularly claim to be healed of cancer, broken bones, multiple sclerosis and many other ailments. Page after page of testimonials of cures are listed on their website. Are these cures real? If not, what is going on?
Amanda Winters, a journalist doing a series of articles on Bethel Church, interviewed me for a scientific view of these faith healings. She asked me some very incisive questions and understood my answers. She wrote what I thought was a balanced article, quoting me fairly and at more length than reporters usually allow.
Her article features a patient who believed his flat feet would be healed (bones would crack and form an arch). Healers poked him, blew a shofar at his feet, and covered him with a blanket when he collapsed on the floor. When he got up, his feet were unchanged. But
his faith was not shaken, he said, because he felt so loved and maybe the physical healing was secondary to the spiritual experience he had.
Multiple Sclerosis Healed
One impressive testimonial was of a woman who had had multiple sclerosis for 30 years and whose symptoms and impairments apparently vanished during a healing session. The reporter asked me what I thought of the situation and the testimony. What medical, scientific explanations could there be for the perceived healing?
In the first place, stories like these are notoriously unreliable. They are layman’s testimonials that amount to nothing but hearsay. How can we know they were not invented, exaggerated, misunderstood, or otherwise misrepresented? They fall far short of the kind of case reports that are published in medical journals with x-ray, lab and other documentation and the opportunity for peer review.
In the second place, multiple sclerosis is a notorious quack magnet because its symptoms come and go erratically. It is a disease with a wide variety of symptoms. It is characterized by remissions and exacerbations: to make the diagnosis you have to show that the symptoms go away and come back over time. It is very difficult to tell if any treatment has “worked” or if the disease was simply following its natural course and happened to be improving on its own at that time. We don’t have any objective report from a doctor about this patient’s condition before and after the “healing” episode. Some of the improvement could have been because she was trying harder: muscle strength is particularly effort-dependent. We don’t know what happened after the “healing” or how long the improvement lasted.
There are many, many similar reports where follow-up found the patients still just as sick or worse off. Patients who “get up and walk” may not be healed. In one unfortunate case a woman was encouraged to get up out of her wheelchair and discard her braces at church. The faith healer proclaimed her “healed.” Unfortunately her cancer of the spine had weakened her bones, and the activity caused bones in her spine to collapse; she died not long after. The faith healing hastened her death and caused her unnecessary agony. For the faith healer and the witnesses at church and for the patient herself that day, it appeared to be a miraculous healing: they couldn’t have been more wrong! Incidentally, many of the faith healing patients who get up out of a wheelchair and walk had actually walked into church and had been offered wheelchairs they didn’t really need.
Cancer Cures
The reporter asked me about a woman with brain cancer who was healed and a subsequent doctor’s visit showed the brain cancer was gone. Are there cases of cancer where it simply goes away?
There are cases of spontaneous remission but they are rare. There are other explanations that are more likely. Many “cancer cure” claims involve cases that were never proven to be cancer by biopsy. This story is particularly unbelievable because the “healing” supposedly relieved her tunnel vision and then produced a discharge from the ear. The vision and ear parts of the brain are in different locations — where was her tumor supposed to be? One report I saw on the website (not sure if it was the same patient) reported that the size of the tumor had decreased but it had not gone away. Release of liquid and a lesion that became smaller sounds more like some kind of cyst or abscess might have spontaneously drained. Where are the medical reports? Where are the x-rays? Why was this case not written up in a medical journal? What happened to the patient afterwards? There are too many unanswered questions for anyone to even make an educated guess.
Many years ago the Journal of the American Medical Association used to have a regular feature where there would be a testimonial on one page describing how a patient was cured of cancer. On the opposite page, they would print the patient’s death certificate showing that he had died of that cancer shortly after providing the testimonial.
The explanations for most alleged cancer cures are:
     1.  The patient never had cancer. (Was a biopsy done?)
     2.  A cancer was cured or put into remission by proven therapy, but questionable therapy was also used and erroneously credited for the beneficial result.
     3.  The cancer is progressing but is erroneously represented as slowed or cured.
     4.  The patient has died as a result of the cancer (or is lost to follow-up) but is represented as cured.
     5.  The patient had a spontaneous remission (very rare) or slow-growing cancer that is publicized as a cure.
Raising the Dead?
Bethel even reports resurrections: one patient began to move shortly after she was declared dead, and she made a full recovery. This is uncritically accepted as a triumph of prayer and faith healing, without even considering other possible explanations. Which is more likely: that the doctor who declared her dead made a mistake or that a dead person returned to life? I know which I would bet on.
One of their students has formed a Dead Raising Team that is attempting to help the police in Mason County, Washington in cases of accident or fatality. The manager of the county Department of Emergency Management reports there have been no resurrections so far.
Bethel is part of a larger movement known as the Word of Faith movement, which teaches that faith is a force through which anything can be done. They believe they can train people in the supernatural ministry and they can go out and heal people and raise the dead. Other Christian denominations condemn this as a false teaching, because in the Bible healing ability was limited to Jesus and the apostles.
Their questionable claims are not limited to healing. They say angel feathers have floated down into their church. Ornithologists identified these as common bird feathers. They say diamonds and gold dust have also mysteriously appeared.
The Evidence for Faith Healing
There are lots of reports describing the emperor’s new clothes, but investigations consistently show he is naked. There is a good review of faith healing on Quackwatch. When faith healings have been diligently investigated by qualified doctors, they have found no evidence that the patients were actually helped in any objective sense. Even at Lourdes, the Catholic Church has only recognized 4 cures since 1978, out of 5 million people who seek healing there every year.
There simply is no evidence that faith healing heals. Not what science considers evidence. And the true believers don’t value evidence or the scientific method: for them, belief is enough.
The Psychology of Belief
Winters asked about healers who “feel someone else’s pain” and are led to a patient because God tells them words like “baby” and “blue” and “foot” and they use those correlations to find a baby with a foot problem and some association with the color blue who needs healing. What could cause someone to feel a pain they believe isn’t theirs? Are there neurological reasons why someone could think they hear prophetic words that are from God?
People have wonderful imaginations, and they are great at finding patterns, real and unreal. They can find ways to connect words to a patient, just as they can see the Virgin Mary on a toasted cheese sandwich, just as numerologists can find imaginary connections everywhere. People can convince themselves of almost anything if they want to believe. There are neurologic conditions that make people hyper-religious. Temporal lobe epilepsy can present as a religious experience. Experiments with magnets have created religious-like experiences of a higher presence. And hallucinations are not uncommon even in normal people. According to one study, 39% of people report having experienced hallucinations when they were neither sick nor on drugs. There are even mass hallucinations where one or a few people insist they are seeing something that is not there and they get a whole group of people to believe they can see it too.
These faith healings are never documented properly or investigated, because the people involved want to believe, need to believe. If you challenge the pastor to participate in a formal study to establish that these healings are really occurring, you will get lots of rationalizations and backpedalling with no understanding of how science can go about testing for the truth of a claim. They have no interest in finding out if the healing is “real” because they already “know” it is real for them. (Winters’ article confirmed my prediction: she says the pastor “doesn’t feel he needs to provide any documentation or hard evidence to inquiring minds. He also said he doesn’t check up on people who come to Bethel for healing – he doesn’t have the time.”) Some people who have had recurrences of cancer after faith healing have continued to claim that they were “healed” in some nebulous psychological or spiritual sense even though they know they are dying.
For more insight into the psychology behind faith healing, see this article from the Skeptic’s Dictionary.
Faith healers run the gamut from cynical con artists to well-intentioned but self-deluded true believers, with some in the middle who know they are cheating but whose exposure to grateful patients allows them to convince themselves there is something happening beyond the con. “Healing” may not mean objective cure of physical disease; it may mean a subjective feeling of wellbeing or a coming to terms with a disease.
Faith healing can comfort, but it can also cause suffering if patients believe a failure to heal was their fault due to insufficient faith. It can be deadly when patients are led to believe they don’t need conventional medical treatment.

Faith Healing: Religious Freedom vs. Child Protection
Harriet Hall on November 19, 2013
Link
We have written a lot about people who reject science-based medicine and turn to complementary/alternative medicine (CAM), but what about people who reject the very idea of medical treatment?
Faith healing is widely practiced by Christian Scientists, Pentecostalists, the Church of the First Born, the Followers of Christ, and myriad smaller sects. Many of these believers reject all medical treatment in favor of prayer, anointing with oils, and sometimes exorcisms. Some even deny the reality of illness. When they reject medical treatment for their children, they may be guilty of negligence and homicide. Until recently, religious shield laws have protected them from prosecution; but the laws are changing, as are public attitudes. Freedom of religion has come into conflict with the duty of society to protect children. The right to believe does not extend to the right to endanger the lives of children. A new book by Cameron Stauth, In the Name of God: The True Story of the Fight to Save Children from Faith-Healing Homicide, provides the chilling details of the struggle. He is a master storyteller; the book grabs the reader’s attention like a fictional thriller and is hard to put down. He is sympathetic to both the perpetrators and the prosecutors of religion-motivated child abuse, and he makes their personalities and their struggles come alive.
Rita Swan: From Christian Scientist to Crusader
Rita and Doug Swan were Christian Scientists who firmly believed that disease was an illusion, and that “the most dangerous thing they could do was to show lack of faith in God by relying on medical treatment.” (One wonders just how strong their belief was, since when an ovarian cyst caused intractable pain, Rita had surgery to remove it.) When their baby Matthew developed a fever, they paid a Christian Science practitioner to come to their home and pray over him. She told them fever was just fear; and indeed, Matthew recovered.
At age 16 months, Matthew developed a fever again and this time he didn’t improve with the practitioner’s prayers. Rita and Doug were worried but unwilling to reject the lifelong beliefs that made sense of their lives. Rather than taking Matthew to a doctor, they compromised by calling in a second Christian Science practitioner. The practitioner accused Rita of sabotaging her work with fear, and both parents believed that defects in their own thoughts were responsible for Matthew’s illness. Eventually they called in a Christian Science “nurse” (trained in metaphysics, not medicine). She did nothing except talk to Rita. Shortly after she left, Matthew began having convulsions. The desperate parents found an escape strategy: they would take Matthew to a doctor with the complaint of a broken bone (something the Church allowed to be treated by a doctor), and would not mention the fever. He was quickly diagnosed with bacterial meningitis and a brain abscess. They had waited too long. Despite intravenous antibiotics and surgery to relieve pressure on the brain, Matthew died.
That happened in 1977. The Swans promptly resigned from the church. They filed a wrongful death lawsuit, but the case was dismissed. Ever since then, Rita Swan has devoted her life to preventing the deaths of other children from faith healing. She founded the Matthew Project, which developed into a foundation called CHILD (Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty). She exposed case after case of child abuse that would otherwise have gone unnoticed and reported outbreaks of polio and measles in Christian Science schools and camps. She documented preventable deaths of Christian Science children from meningitis, diabetes, diphtheria, measles, kidney infection, septicemia, cancer, and appendicitis. The Church fought her at every step, but the surrounding publicity only contributed to the ongoing decline in Church membership (they don’t announce membership numbers, but the number of US churches has fallen from 1,800 to 900, and by one estimate they have fewer than 50,000 members in the entire world).
As time passed, she turned her attention to similar abuses in other religious sects. A one-woman tornado, she cut a swath across America. She headed a child advocacy organization, published a quarterly newsletter, wrote articles, became a media presence, spoke at conferences on child abuse, lobbied and testified in states where proposed bills would help or hinder her cause, and even moved to Oregon for a time during the campaign to pass effective legislation there. She was eventually instrumental in getting religious shield laws changed in several states.
An Indiana case
One of the first non-Christian-Science-related deaths Rita discovered was in Indiana. As Stauth tells the story,
4-year-old Natali Joy Mudd was found dead by detectives in her own home, with a tumor in her eye that was almost as big as the rest of her head. At the horrific scene, a police sergeant found horizontal trails of blood along the walls of the house. The trails matched the height of the girl’s head. Natali had apparently been leaning against the wall as she dragged herself from room to room, blinded, trying to find a way to freedom, before the tumor killed her.
Natali’s parents belonged to the Faith Assembly Church, a Pentecostal offshoot. They didn’t believe in medical care, and they were not prosecuted because Indiana had strict religious shield laws. Two years later, Natali’s five-year-old sister died from an untreated tumor in her stomach the size of a basketball.
The Faith Assembly Church was responsible for as many as 100 childhood deaths and for a maternal childbirth mortality rate that was 870 times the usual rate. The most common cause of death was infant mortality in home births; something that is now rare in Christian Science because it now supports prenatal care and hospital births attended by doctors.
The Faith Tabernacle Church
The Faith Tabernacle Church is a sect that has been responsible for deaths from exorcisms in several countries. One believer strangled her five-year-old son to death and kept his body for several days hoping for his resurrection. One couple in Pennsylvania lost six children to untreated illness, all under the age of two. A measles epidemic involving 491 people resulted in the deaths of six children. One couple was prosecuted for letting their sixteen-year-old daughter die of untreated diabetes, but their sentence was only two years’ probation and community service at a hospital (and the hospital didn’t want them).
The Pediatrics article
In 1998, pediatrician Seth Asser and Rita Swan published an article in the medical journal Pediatrics entitled “Child Fatalities from Religion-motivated Medical Neglect“. They documented 172 faith-healing deaths over a 20-year period, involving 23 different sects in 34 states. The true numbers were undoubtedly much higher, since these cases were collected informally rather than systematically and some deaths are never reported. In most of these cases the prognosis would have been excellent with medical care. Asser later characterized some of the cases as babies literally being tortured to death. In one case, a mother died in childbirth after the infant’s head had been at the vaginal opening for more than 16 hours. The infant’s corpse was so foul-smelling that it was inconceivable that anyone attending the delivery could not have noticed.
In 1988, the American Academy of Pediatrics had called for elimination of religious exemption laws, and in 1983 the federal government had removed religious exemptions from federal mandate; but at the time of the study there were only five states that had no religious exemptions either to civil abuse and neglect charges or criminal charges.
The Followers of Christ in Oregon
In 1997, 20 years after Matthew’s death, a six-year-old boy in Oregon died from a necrotic bowel due to a hernia that could easily have been treated. The pathologist’s first reaction was “Not again!” He and his associate had compiled evidence of 18 children who had died over the last 10 years from curable diseases in a Followers of Christ congregation of 1,200 people. That worked out to 26 times the usual infant mortality rate. And it wasn’t just children: followers’ wives were dying in childbirth at 900 times the usual rate. One died of a type of infection that hadn’t killed anyone in America since 1910.
Nothing could be done about it, because Oregon had one of the strongest religious shield laws in the country. It protected parents from allegations of religious intolerance and gave them the right to withhold medical care for their children. In fact, the shield had just been beefed up: a new law to increase the punishment for murder by spousal or child abuse specifically prohibited prosecution for manslaughter if the person responsible was acting on religious beliefs.
A TV reporter named Mark Hass was told that there had been a cluster of preventable deaths among the Followers of Christ in Oregon City. He looked into it, but there were no criminal complaints, no police investigations, and the county DA was uninterested. When his investigation seemed to have reached a dead end, someone suggested he visit the local cemetery. He counted the graves of 78 children. He launched America’s first major series of TV reports on faith-healing abuse on KATU in Portland.
The psychology of believers
Even Rita and Doug Swan found it hard to break away from the seductive premise that the power of belief itself could heal, a create-your-own-reality idea that is echoed by Rhonda Byrne in The Secret and by a host of other New Age gurus.
The faith healing sects truly believe they are doing the right thing when they let their children die; they accept it as God’s will. Some believers even refuse to wear seat belts. Their inconsistent behavior shows that they tend not to have thought things through very carefully. They hypocritically accept care from eye doctors and dentists. Adults often clandestinely seek medical care for both major and minor medical problems while children don’t have that option. In some cases parents saw a doctor for hangnails or mole removal for themselves yet refused to take their child to a doctor for a fatal illness.
Their beliefs come from groupthink and social consensus rather than from reasoned theology or the Bible. Many of them have not read the Bible; when a whistle blower did, he was surprised to learn how much it differed from what he had been taught. They have a supportive, close-knit community and face overwhelming peer pressure. If they resort to medical care, they are shunned by everyone they know and may never see anyone in their family again.
There has never actually been a single extraordinary healing among the Followers, only ordinary recoveries from common illnesses; but that’s enough to convince them prayer works, if only their belief is strong enough. Confirmation bias is a powerful thing, and when a child dies the death is considered unavoidable and is attributed to God’s will. An insider said he thought that if a few Followers were punished, the rest would rationalize that going to doctors was OK after all and would come up with a new doctrine. He thought most of them would be happy to change if everybody else did. When courts have ordered blood transfusions for the children of Jehovah’s Witnesses, they have sometimes seemed more concerned about what their co-religionists would think than about the religious implications of the transfusion itself.
Progress in legislation
The first state to repeal a religious shield law was South Dakota. Then CHILD won a federal lawsuit in Minnesota, arguing that taxpayers should not be required to subsidize Medicare and Medicaid payments for Christian Science nursing. Unfortunately, Senator Orrin Hatch negated their win by getting a new law passed that provided for Medicare payment for “religious non-medical health care.” CHILD sued again but this time they lost. In 1999, a compromise bill was passed in Oregon eliminating religious shields for murder by abuse, murder by neglect, first and second degree manslaughter, and criminal mistreatment. After this, no Followers died of medical neglect for the next five years, and there were major modifications in the shield laws in several other states.
Examples of prosecutions
Josef Smith, eight years old, was beaten to death during an exorcism in Tennessee. His parents, members of the Remnant Fellowship, were found guilty of murder and sentenced to life in prison plus 30 years.
A mother who beat and smothered her child was sentenced to life in prison for first-degree murder. She gladly accepted her punishment as part of God’s plan.
The people who starved a 16-month-old to death for failing to say “Amen” and then absconded with his corpse in a suitcase were sentenced to 50 years each for second-degree murder.
A test case was needed in Oregon, but DAs were reluctant to prosecute, and even church members who no longer approved of their own churches were too frightened to provide inside information. Finally Patrick Robbins turned whistle blower after the death of his newborn baby led him to doubt the teachings of the Church. His assistance led to several prosecutions.
In 2008, 15-month-old Ava Worthington died with a softball-sized lump on her neck that obstructed her breathing and caused pneumonia. Investigation of the case was difficult, because witnesses denied having observed any signs that the child was in distress. Her parents were the first to be tried under the revised 1999 law. The jury was sympathetic to the parents. The father was convicted of misdemeanor criminal mistreatment, but not of manslaughter; he spent two months in jail. The mother was found not guilty.
The Beagleys were convicted of criminally negligent homicide in the death of their 16-year-old son Neal for complications of a congenital urinary tract anomaly that could have easily been repaired. They each served 16 months (consecutively, so one of them was always home to care for their other children).
18-month-old Alayna Wyland nearly went blind from an untreated enlarging hemangioma that obstructed her left eye. She was rescued just in time for pediatric ophthalmologists to save her eyesight, and her parents were tried for first-degree criminal mistreatment of their child. They got 90 days in jail and three years’ probation.
These are tragic cases. No one likes to see children taken away from their parents, and these parents loved their children and truly believed they were doing the right thing. They were victims too.
Oregon’s 2011 law
The Oregon 1999 compromise bill was not enough: it had repealed five of the nine religious shield exemptions but left four others in place. After five years without a death, three more Followers’ children died in 2008 and 2009. In 2011, after extensive lobbying by Rita Swan and others, Oregon passed a new law to eliminate religious beliefs entirely as a legal defense and allow prosecutors to seek murder charges against parents who deny their children medical care for religious reasons. There are only five other states with no religious exemptions for sick and injured children: Hawaii, Nebraska, Massachusetts, Maryland, and North Carolina.
But Oregon law still allows religious exemptions for caregivers of dependent adults, and it still allows religious exemptions for immunizations, metabolic screening (for conditions like PKU), newborn hearing screening, vitamin K and prophylactic eye drops for newborns, and bicycle helmets. Ashland, Oregon has the highest school vaccine exemption rate of any US city; and in one school in Eugene, 76% of students had rejected one or more vaccines for religious reasons. The religious exemption for bicycle helmets is particularly puzzling: where in the Bible does it say “Thou shalt not wear bicycle helmets” or even “Thou shalt take no precautions against injury”? I guess the reasoning is that if God wants a child to die from a head injury, we shouldn’t get in His way.
The Oregon law is being enforced. Later that year, Dale and Shannon Hickman were found guilty of second degree manslaughter in the death of their infant son, prematurely born at home with only unqualified midwives in attendance. They were sentenced to six years and three months in jail, followed by three years supervised probation.
The tide turns
A few months later, when Oregon members of the Church of the First Born were accused of negligent homicide for the death of their son from a treatable condition, they didn’t even try to fight, but pled guilty. They agreed to provide medical care for their other children and were sentenced to probation with close monitoring.
Some members of the Followers sect were starting to accept medical treatment and even wondering what all the fuss had been about.
In Philadelphia, Herbert and Catherine Schaible, were put on 10 years’ probation after their two-year-old died of untreated bacterial pneumonia. The terms of their probation required them to purchase medical insurance and put their other children under the care of a pediatrician. They callously disregarded the terms of probation and their eight-month-old son died of untreated bacterial pneumonia when they failed to seek medical care for him. They were charged with third-degree murder, involuntary manslaughter, conspiracy, and endangerment. They were jailed and denied bail because the judge feared their co-religionists might hide them in other parts of the country. They pled “no contest.” Their pastor said the father “…knows he has to obey God rather than man.” He said the children died because of the parents’ “spiritual lack.”
Following the Followers to Idaho
Investigative reporter Dan Tilkin of KATU News covered the Oregon court cases, and he has recently reported on 10 more dead children of the Followers of Christ in Idaho, where religious shield laws are still in place. Of the marked graves in the Peaceful Valley Cemetery, more than 25% are children. Sadly, his report ends by saying “No significant move to change the laws is underway.”
Conclusion
The medical ethics principle of autonomy justifies letting competent adults reject lifesaving medical care for themselves because of their religious beliefs, but it does not extend to rejecting medical care for children. Society has a duty to over-ride parents’ wishes when necessary to protect children from harm. It is not uncommon for the courts to order life-saving blood transfusions for the children of Jehovah’s Witnesses, or cancer treatment against parents’ wishes. But 30 states still have religious shield laws, and every state but Mississippi and West Virginia allows religious and/or philosophical exemptions for school vaccination requirements. Those laws should be repealed. The Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”) requires insurance companies to cover “nonmedical” health care such as prayers by Christian Science practitioners. That provision should be removed.
Note: It has been argued that most of the increase in human lifespan was due to advances in hygiene rather than to advances in medicine. The estimates of a 26-fold increase in infant mortality and a 900-fold increase in maternal mortality among the untreated Followers of Christ demonstrate just how valuable modern medical care really is.
Another Note: For those who want to know more but prefer not to buy the book, another source with much of the same information is available free online: the newsletter archives of CHILD (Children’s Healthcare Is a Legal Duty). It describes many more tragic cases of children who have been harmed or have died from religion-motivated child abuse and neglect.

Trying to Impose Religion on Medicine
Steven Novella on June 24, 2015
Link

One of the major themes of science-based medicine (unsurprisingly) is that medicine should be based on science. We consider ourselves specialists in a larger movement defending science in general from mysticism, superstition, and spiritualism. We are not against anyone’s personal belief, and are officially agnostic toward any faith (as is science itself), but will vigorously defend science from any intrusion into its proper realm.
The so-called alternative medicine movement (CAM) is largely an attempt to insert religious beliefs into the practice and profession of medicine. CAM is also an attempt to create a double standard or even eliminate the standard of care so that any nonsense can flourish and con-artists and charlatans can practice their craft freely without being hounded by pesky regulations designed to protect the public. These are both insidious aspects of CAM that need to be exposed and vigorously opposed.
A recent article by Dr. Michel Accad demonstrates how brazenly some are trying to insert faith healing and spiritualism back into medicine. He does so by couching his arguments in philosophy and marketing terms, but in the end he is essentially saying that doctors should practice his faith. He doesn’t really make any arguments for this position, but rather simply gives a history of progress in Western thought as if that is sufficient. 
Why medicine needs to be science-based
Before I deconstruct Accad’s article let me explore the arguments for SBM. As a profession, medicine enjoys a special privilege in our society. Practitioners are licensed, which is a contract giving them exclusive rights to practice their trade in exchange for requirements to ensure quality control and ethical behavior. The health professions also benefit from public funding to pay for research, education, institutions, and patient care.
In exchange for this public support, the public has a right to demand regulations to ensure honesty, transparency, and quality in healthcare products and services. Such guarantees are only possible within a strictly scientific practice.
Science is transparent, and fairly and thoroughly considers all evidence in order to determine safety and efficacy. A science-based system is the only system that can ensure claims are fair and accurate. Once you erode the scientific basic of healthcare, then anything goes, and there is no possible way to maintain standards. Anything you do to ensure quality standards is essentially doing science, and then the only question is – are you doing it well?
CAM proponents want to allow what is essentially magic back into the practice of medicine precisely because magic cannot be held to any standard. Magic can also be optimized for marketing purposes – you can make grandiose claims without having to back them up with rigorous evidence. It is for this reason that CAM proponents have been attacking science and the scientific standard in medicine from every angle.
“Holistic” medicine
Accad falls for many CAM tropes in his article, but the main one is to confuse religion-based medicine for “holistic” medicine. He writes:
So why does conventional medicine seem so unable to attend to the complete welfare of the patient? Why, despite the manifest efficacy of scientific treatments, do growing numbers of patients consider their medical care altogether unhealthy?
The answer may have to do with what is meant by a whole person.
Each of his premises is false. First, medicine does address the whole patient. This is referred to as the “biopsychosocial” approach to medicine, and I learned it in medical school long before “holistic” medicine became hip. Every medical student at some point in their training will be told by an attending that they cannot treat their patient as if they were a disease – they have to treat the patient. You need to understand the patient’s psychological and social background and how that influences their understanding of their own symptoms and disease. Treatments need to be individualized to the patient’s values, desires, goals, and beliefs. This all needs to be done while respecting the need for informed consent.
Accad and other CAM apologists, however, ignore this reality. They have created the fiction that “Western” medicine is mechanistic, cold, and reductionist. To be fair, the demands of modern medicine can make it challenging at times to maintain the more cuddly aspects of medicine. We do use procedures and diagnostic tools that can be scary and unpleasant. We do try, at least in principle, to manage the patient experience to mitigate the demands of the modern technology of medicine, and don’t always succeed. This is not a philosophical problem with “Western” medicine, however, just a practical challenge of trying to balance the benefits of modern technology with the patient experience. We don’t always succeed, but good doctors, practices, and hospitals do this well.
The second premise is simply a naked assertion, also part of the CAM mythology. Surveys do not support the notion that people are increasingly seeking CAM because of negative attitudes toward scientific medicine. People who use CAM generally report they did so for philosophical reasons, or because they heard it might work, not because they are unhappy with their doctors. In fact, people are not seeking CAM in increasing numbers, the numbers are stable and low (unless you artificially inflate them by including things like prayer and nutrition in CAM).
These CAM claims are all about marketing – this is one brand trashing a competitor. For the record, I don’t think there should be any “brands” within medicine. There should be one fair and consistent science-based standard of care.
“What is meant by the whole person”
Accad has set up his false premise, that “Western” medicine is not holistic, and then defines “holistic” in a specific way that leads to the specific point he is trying to make. He asks, “what is meant by the whole person,” and his answer essentially encompasses his religious faith. “Holistic,” he asserts (again, he doesn’t actually make any arguments) means treating the soul.
If his essay can be construed as an argument, through inference, he is only making an argument from antiquity – we should treat the soul because people did it in the past. He writes:
St. Thomas Aquinas, borrowing from Aristotle’s philosophy of nature, explained that a human being is a substantial unity of body and soul or, to be more technically precise, a composite of “prime matter” (the principle of potency) informed by a rational soul (the principle of act).
He never states why we should care what Aquinas or Aristotle believed. Ironically, he reviews the progression of thought in this area sufficiently to explain why science has rejected the notion of a soul. He acknowledges:
The heightened attention given to the material aspects of the universe promoted the achievements of a bewildering revolution in the empirical sciences. And under the influence of the new sciences, diseases came to be conceptualized in similar terms: illnesses are accident [sic] of nature due to defective arrangements or to faulty motions of material stuff. Fix the defect and you fix the patient. This approach has yielded such astounding benefits to mankind that Descartes’ dream of conquering illness through the methodical application of empirical science seems to be well under way.
That is a wordy way of saying that “science works.” Over the centuries we tended to go with what works, and science undeniably “delivers the goods,” as Carl Sagan said. Why would we stick with a pre-scientific philosophy of illness that accomplished nothing in thousands of years, when a scientific approach revolutionized healthcare in tens of years?
Accad still has to cling to this notion that, despite scientific medicine’s undeniable success, something is missing. He accomplishes this by confusing “mind” and “spirit.”
But when medical science rests on a basis of material reductionism, the human mind—the intellectual and willful aspects of the soul—has a hard time finding its proper place. Descartes dealt with this difficulty by splitting apart the body and the soul of man
The human mind is not an aspect of the soul, it is what the brain does. The material reductionist approach to the mind is progressing quite well, thank you, without the need to appeal to any dualist notions. The mind, the psychological and social aspects of patients, is fully considered in modern medicine. We do not have to appeal to a “ghost in the machine” to be holistic. The only reason to appeal to such notions is to open the door for religious belief to enter into medicine.
Accad himself gives a partial explanation for why this is:
Following Descartes’ conceptual sundering of body and soul, scientists sought for a time to identify and isolate the vital principle of living organisms—as if that were possible. Vitalism, mesmerism, romanticism, and idealism became influential currents in Western Medicine in the eighteenth and nineteenth century. But when these efforts at grasping the essence of life proved futile or problematic, the inconvenient soul fell into neglect and was finally abandoned altogether as a subject worthy of inquiry or acknowledgment in polite scientific company.
That’s right – scientists gave a fair hearing to the notion of a vital force or spirit. In fact, this was the default assumption for a long time; it is what scientists assumed to be true. After a couple centuries of failing to find even the slightest bit of evidence for a vital force, scientists properly dropped the concept as a dead end.
There is another aspect to this that Accad misses, however. The vital force was also dropped because it ceased to become necessary. In the early days of science, before much was known about biology, vitalism was used to explain biological processes that were currently mysterious. It was a placeholder for our ignorance. Over time, however, everything that the vital force was supposed to do was eventually explained as a natural biological process. The role of the vital force shrank and shrank until it finally disappeared.
Can you blame scientists for discarding a pre-scientific notion that was of no value (it had no explanatory power and made no predictions) and for which there was no evidence? The history of progress in science is largely a history of discarding such notions. Scientists today don’t even think about vitalism because it’s “not even wrong” – it is of no scientific value.
The same is true of dualism, the notion of a spirit separate from the functioning of our brains. Neuroscientists have no need for such a notion, which adds no explanatory power, solves no problems, and makes no successful predictions.
Conclusion
Science-based medicine not only works, it is necessary if we are to have any effective regulations and standard of care. Introducing philosophical and religious beliefs into medicine goes hand-in-hand with eroding the standard of care and failing to protect the public from false or misleading claims, and unsafe or ineffective practices.
Further, similar to creationism and other anti-science movements, CAM proponents want to roll back the clock to a pre-scientific era. They want to rehash a fight they lost a couple centuries ago. Vitalism and dualism were given more than a fair chance, and they completely failed, because they are not scientific notions and they are not based in reality.
We should no more integrate these discarded notions back into science than we should reintroduce astrology back into astronomy, phrenology back into neuroscience, or alchemy back into chemistry. These ideas are best left on the trash heap of history.

   The Power of Faith and Prayer?
Steven Novella 
Link
Part of the Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) movement is an attempt to insert spirituality into the philosophy and practice of medicine. Most energy healing modalities, for example, have spiritual underpinnings. At the same time there are many attempts to use science to validate the healing power of faith. This is also an issue that is very attractive to the media, who love articles and headlines about the power of prayer. In our culture – faith sells.
A recent article in the Detroit Free Press is an excellent example of bad reporting and the sensationalizing of this issue. It does a good job of maximally confusing the issue.
To be clear, SBM is not anti-faith or anti-religion. But the issue of faith in medicine raises two main areas of concern. The first is the misrepresentation of the scientific evidence, both for intercessory prayer and the health effects of faith. The second are the ethical and professional implications of mixing faith with medical practice.
Intercessory Prayer
The Detroit Free Press article makes no attempt to distinguish the various issues with faith and medicine, and confuses them together in a misleading way. Intercessory prayer is, essentially, praying for the health of another person. There have been about a dozen such trials with reasonable design. In most the subjects know they may be prayed for. But of course, none of the trials can control for those who are not part of the study praying for a study subject.
Every time such a study shows a hint of positive results the media have a frenzy of reporting that “science proves faith.” When such studies are negative, the footprint in the media is much smaller. What we find when we look at all the studies of intercessory prayer is the type of scatter of results we would expect from a null intervention – one with no effect at all. A 2009 Cochrane review of intercessory prayer studies concluded:
These findings are equivocal and, although some of the results of individual studies suggest a positive effect of intercessory prayer,the majority do not and the evidence does not support a recommendation either in favour or against the use of intercessory prayer. We are not convinced that further trials of this intervention should be undertaken and would prefer to see any resources available for such a trial used to investigate other questions in health care.
These wishy washy conclusions are essentially saying the evidence is negative. The review was also criticized for its methods and discussion of the results – specifically mixing theological and scientific arguments in the discussion and failing to mention significant flaws of the positive studies. But even with these complaints, the results of the review are what we would expect from a treatment effect of zero.
The results of existing research are not sufficient to rule out a small and inconsistent effect – but medical research is never designed to reach such a conclusion, and not being completely disproved is hardly a sufficient reason to endorse a medical intervention.
Again – to be clear – the point of reviewing the evidence is not to argue that individuals should not pray for their loved-ones who are ill. Rather it is important to accurately report the results of the research that has been done – there is no scientific evidence that intercessory prayer is efficacious. Therefore the scientific evidence cannot be used as a justification for inserting religious faith into the practice of medicine.
The Health Effect of Faith
A completely separate question from intercessory prayer is that of the health benefits of having or practicing faith. This is a much more difficult question to assess scientifically. With intercessory prayer there is a specific intervention that can be isolated as a variable. The variable of faith, however, is very difficult to isolate, and most studies barely attempt to do so at all. Most such studies are retrospective and use surveys or questionnaires to gather data, which are plagued by artifacts.
One such study, highlighted in the recent Detroit Free Press article, looked at 88 patients who had suffered Traumatic Brain Injury in the last 10 years. They found a positive correlation between feeling a personal connection with god and having better rehabilitation outcomes. The authors concluded that personal faith “predicts” a good outcome, and the press release (dutifully reprinted by most news outlets) reported that personal faith improves TBI outcomes.
There are two major problems with this study, however. The first is that the survey process itself is likely to bias reporting. If you ask people about their faith (or that of a family member) and then ask them how they are doing, the answer to the one question is likely to influence the answer to the other.
Second – the study found a correlation only, and was not designed to infer any cause and effect. One possible interpretation is that those who were doing better in terms of their recovery from TBI were more likely, as a result, to feel positive about their connection to god.
Much of the research into the question of faith and health is similarly plagued by such flaws, which makes interpreting the research problematic at best.
However, my reading of the literature on this question leads me to conclude that there is a consistent signal in the noise – having a social network consistently positively correlates with better health outcomes. This can be through reduced stress and better practical and emotional support. Humans are social animals, and we simply do better when we are part of a social network than when we are isolated. Religion can provide a useful social network. Faith and religion itself, however, are not the important variable – it’s the social network.
Further, faith both encourages and may result from a positive and hopeful outlook, which can certainly influence the reporting of health outcomes in addition to reducing stress and encouraging better self-care. These variables are rarely controlled for or isolated, however.
Conclusion
The existing research does not support the conclusion that there is any efficacy to intercessory prayer. The research also does not allow for the conclusion that there are health benefits to faith or religion as specific variables. This latter question is open to further research, however.
The scientific evidence can therefore not be used to support the intermingling of faith with the practice of medicine. In any case – doing so raises serious ethical and professional concerns. For example, such practices raise the potential of faith-based discrimination against both physicians and patients. Mixing of faith with medicine can also compromise the professional doctor-patient relationship.
Even if one accepts that there is a health benefit to faith – such a benefit can be entirely realized through private means, without involving the medical profession.

   Another Useless NCCAM-Funded Study
Harriet Hall
Link
Sometimes I read an article in a medical journal that makes me say, “Well, duh! I could have told you that without a study.” Sometimes I read collected data that make me ask, “So what?” Sometimes I read an article that makes me wonder what kind of pogo stick they used to jump from their data to their conclusions. Sometimes I read a study that is so poorly conceived that you couldn’t hope to get any useful information from it. Sometimes I read a study that reminds me of class projects or term papers where you just thought of something easy to do to fill the squares to get credit. Sometimes I read a study funded by the NCCAM that makes me very angry that they wasted my tax dollars. Sometimes all these things coincide in one article.
“Ophthalmology Patients’ Religious and Spiritual Beliefs: An Opportunity to Build Trust in the Patient-Physician Relationship” is such an article. A questionnaire was anonymously filled out by 124 consecutive return patients in one ophthalmologist’s practice. It asked about their religious and spiritual beliefs and their understanding and level of concern about their eye condition.
Results:
• 76.6% Christian
• 82.3% reported that prayer was important or very important to their sense of well-being
• 45.2% reported weekly attendance at religious service
• More patients had positive interpretations of God’s role in illness than negative interpretations
They concluded,
The prevalence and importance of religious and spiritual beliefs in this sample of ophthalmology patients suggests that, like other medical patient populations, religion and spirituality are significant, and often positive, components of patients’ value systems. Attention to religion and spirituality is one aspect of acknowledging and respecting a patient’s value system and of establishing a relationship that promotes trust for making joint therapeutic decisions.
Why did they do this study? We already have demographic information about religious beliefs and practices; what could be gained by studying one more small sample? Could anyone be surprised to learn that most of these patients were Christians, that most found prayer helpful, that many attended religious services, and that more of them agreed with “God can help me with my illness” than “God caused this illness to punish me”?
Why study ophthalmology patients? Was there any special reason? Of course not. This was a sample of convenience. All patients were from one doctor’s practice. The doctor was a subspecialist in medical retinal diseases. There were more female patients than males, and the age range was markedly skewed towards older age groups. We aren’t told anything about their socioeconomic status. In short, this was a nonrepresentative sample of the population. It wasn’t even representative of the average ophthalmologist’s patients.
Some of the statements pushed my “Well, duh!” button:
• “Most patients reported awareness of their diagnosis.”
• “Patients who reported poor vision…were significantly more likely to report worry about their eye problem… compared with patients who reported fair or good vision.”
• “Christians reported more frequent religious service attendance… than individuals… reporting Jewish and agnostic beliefs.” [What, you mean agnostics aren’t regular church-goers?]
• Since there were few non-Christians in this sample, “This could produce biased results that are not representative of these non-Christian groups.”
They admitted that this particular ophthalmologist was known to have an interest in religious and spiritual concerns; in fact, he has an MA in theology. Patients who knew that might have been subtly influenced to give answers more favorable to religion. The data was all from self-reports – how do we know they really attended church or prayed as much as they reported? How much can we trust the results when some items were left blank and 6.5% of the sample didn’t even report their sex?
Even assuming the results were valid, what do they mean? The authors say “The consistency of these results across medical patient samples implies that R/S beliefs often can be a resource for patients in coping with adverse health problems and negative life events,” but
• Since there were already consistent results across other medical patient samples, that just points out how unnecessary the present study was.
• Consistency only shows that information about beliefs is consistent; it says nothing about whether those beliefs are a resource.
• It goes without saying that beliefs can be a resource for some patients. So what?
They recommend asking all patients:
• Do you consider yourself spiritual or religious?
• How important are these beliefs to you and do they influence how you care for yourself?
• Do you belong to a spiritual community?
• How might health care providers best address any needs in this area?
Their subtitle is “An Opportunity to Build Trust in the Physician-Patient Relationship.” They have established that patients have beliefs; they have done nothing to show that asking about those beliefs builds trust. They suggest that obtaining a routine religious/spiritual history may “assist in the healing process, especially when a cure is not possible.” That’s just speculation unsupported by any data.
They want us to know the patient as a whole person including his religious beliefs. OK. Good clinicians have always been holistic practitioners. We treat people, not diseases. We want to know what kind of person we’re treating and how social/financial/family and other concerns might impact on health care. But why emphasize religious beliefs? Why not ask about the patient’s beliefs about alternative medicine, ability to afford medication, attitudes that might affect compliance? Why not ask about his music preferences, favorite sports team, grandchildren, politics? Many nominally religious people are really apatheists; they don’t think about religion very often or care about it very much. Some patients are far more involved with and passionate about non-religious concerns; the authors have not made a case that knowing about a patient’s religion is any more important than knowing about other aspects of a patient’s life.
They say
By appreciating a patient’s value system, the physician may progress beyond treatment of pathologic features of a disease and honor the patient’s efforts to cope with his or her illness. A physician can then provide more effective management, which includes a compassionate response to the personal experience of disease.
I find this insulting. Every good clinician honors the patient’s efforts to cope with illness; every good clinician manages patients effectively and has a compassionate response to the personal experience of disease. Most good clinicians accomplish that without specifically asking patients about religion; the authors have not shown that engaging in a religious discussion improves the physician/patient relationship.
Some patients may appreciate their doctor asking them about spiritual matters; others may be offended. If the doctor doesn’t share the patient’s beliefs, it might tend to undermine trust rather than build it. This can be a rather delicate area that good clinicians have always managed to navigate judiciously. I don’t think they have made a case for routinely asking every patient about religion.
A more appropriate subtitle might have been “An Opportunistic Exercise to Build CVs and Promote Religious Belief.” This goes on the NCCAM’s scorecard as one more instance of wasting our tax dollars on studies that should never have been funded. That list is long and is steadily getting longer.

   AA is Faith-Based, Not Evidence-Based
Harriet Hall
Link
Alcoholics Anonymous is the most widely used treatment for alcoholism. It is mandated by the courts, accepted by mainstream medicine, and required by insurance companies. AA is generally assumed to be the most effective treatment for alcoholism, or at least “an” effective treatment. That assumption is wrong.
We hear about a few success stories, but not about the many failures. AA’s own statistics show that after 6 months, 93% of new attendees have left the program. The research on AA is handily summarized in a Wikipedia article. A recent Cochrane systematic review found no evidence that AA or other 12 step programs are effective.
In The Skeptic’s Dictionary, Bob Carroll comments:
Neither A.A. nor many other SATs [Substance Abuse Treatments] are based on science, nor do they seem interested in doing any scientific studies which might test whether the treatment they give is effective.
In the current issue of Free Inquiry, Steven Mohr has written a thorough and incisive article “Exposing the Myth of Alcoholics Anonymous.”
Mohr characterizes AA as a religious cult. The founder, Bill Wilson, had a religious experience while under the influence of strong psychotropic drugs.
He had a vision of a bright light and the revelation that he could be saved only by giving his life completely and fully to God – and that an important part of his recovery would be to bring the news of his epiphany and recovery to other suffering alcoholics.
The 12 steps of AA refer repeatedly to God. They require admitting you are powerless, accepting that only a Higher Power can help you, turning your will and your life over to God, taking a moral inventory, admitting your wrongs, being ready to let God remove your shortcomings, making amends to those you have harmed, improving your conscious contact with God through prayer and meditation, and spreading the word (proselytizing).
Criticism of the religious orientation led AA to switch emphasis from “God” to any “higher power.” One member allegedly designated a doorknob as his higher power and believed that praying to the doorknob helped him maintain sobriety.
There are other options for treatment. Inpatient programs, various medications, Secular Organizations for Sobriety. Curiously, the best treatment may be no treatment at all.
The 1992, the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism’s National Longitudinal Alcohol Epidemiologic Survey studied 42,000 Americans. 4500 had been dependent on alcohol at some time in their lives. Of these, only 27% had had treatment of any kind, and one-third of those who had been treated were still abusing alcohol. Of those who had never had any treatment, only one-quarter were still abusing alcohol. George Bush is a well-known example of someone who stopped drinking on his own without attending AA and without admitting that he was an alcoholic.
According to Stanton Peele in Psychology Today,
the most successful treatments are nonconfrontational approaches that allow self-propelled change. Psychologists at the University of New Mexico led by William Miller tabulated every controlled study of alcoholism treatment they could find. They concluded that the leading therapy was barely a therapy at all but a quick encounter between patient and health-care worker in an ordinary medical setting. The intervention is sometimes as brief as a doctor looking at the results of liver-function tests and telling a patient to cut down on his drinking. Many patients then decide to cut back—and do!
A Cochrane systematic review confirmed the effectiveness of brief interventions.
Instead of telling people they are powerless, wouldn’t it make more sense to empower them and build on their strengths? Why not tell them they are stronger than alcohol and they can choose not to let it control them? Even if you prefer a religious approach, you could pray for God to support your strength to change your own life, taking full personal responsibility rather than passively turning over the responsibility to a higher power. The old adage “God helps those who help themselves” applies.
Instead of the religious model of sin, confession and absolution, what if we avoided harping on the past and started fresh, concentrating on the patient’s behavior today and in the future? Sure, make amends to those you have harmed for the bad things you have done, but why not put the emphasis on doing good things for other people today and tomorrow? Instead of being “ready to let God remove your shortcomings,” how about taking active steps to improve your own behavior? Why not build self-esteem instead of re-visiting past experiences that damaged self-esteem?
There have as yet been no scientific studies of Secular Organizations for Sobriety, but their approach seems more promising than AA’s. More and more physicians are routinely screening all patients for alcohol abuse: every time I go to a doctor’s office I am asked “Do you drink” and “How much?” By asking everyone these questions we may help prevent some cases of full-blown alcoholism by catching problem drinking early. More and more doctors are offering the brief interventions that science has shown to be effective.
Surely we can do better than AA. If three-quarters of alcoholics can stop drinking on their own with no treatment, we should be looking for ways to help them succeed rather than imposing a treatment that has not been proven effective and that may actually make things worse.

Religion and SCAM
Mark Crislip on July 26, 2013
Link
I do not worry much about being dead although the process of getting there gives me pause. I have witnessed a few unpleasant deaths and I hope to never see the Grim Reaper coming my way.
One of the more awful and pointless deaths occurred early in my career. I had a patient with hepatitis C and cirrhosis. He had low platelets, low clotting factors (many of which are made by the liver), a previously undiagnosed clotting disorder, and a mouth full of bad teeth that were removed all at once when he acquired dental insurance.
Then he started to ooze blood from his extractions. An ooze that did not stop, it was a constant trickle of blood that would not clot. After several visits to his dentist he almost passed out and came to the emergency room. After 4 days he had bled out about half his blood volume, his haemoglobin had gone from 12 to 6. At this point we geared up for transfusions of red cells and clotting factors and he let us know that he was a Jehovah’s Witness and, no thank you, he would not accept any blood or blood products.
For the next week he continued to ooze despite all the interventions we could come up with to stop the bleeding and he remained adamant in his refusal of transfusions of any kind, despite the risk of death. At about a hemoglobin of 2 he had a large stroke and severe muscle pain from ischemia. At 1 he had a large heart attack and died. If you could rank deaths as pointless and horrific, this would be in my top 10. And I was struck at how nonplussed the family was, accepting this completely preventable death matter-of-factly.
The Jehovah’s Witness, at least by that name, started in 1931 and began the doctrine of no transfusions in 1944 based on two biblical verses, Genesis 9:4:
But you must not eat meat that has its lifeblood still in it.
and Leviticus 17:10-14:
I will set my face against any Israelite or any foreigner residing among them who eats blood, and I will cut them off from the people.
For the life of a creature is in the blood, and I have given it to you to make atonement for yourselves on the altar; it is the blood that makes atonement for one’s life.
Therefore I say to the Israelites, “None of you may eat blood, nor may any foreigner residing among you eat blood.”
‘Any Israelite or any foreigner residing among you who hunts any animal or bird that may be eaten must drain out the blood and cover it with earth,
because the life of every creature is its blood. That is why I have said to the Israelites, “You must not eat the blood of any creature, because the life of every creature is its blood; anyone who eats it must be cut off.
Sounds more like an admonition against steak tartar or vampirism to me. Jehovah’s Witnesses will accept some products derived from blood but not others, for example albumin. The fine points and the splitting of hairs of doctrine have always baffled me and perhaps are better explained by others.
Several years later we had a grand rounds on transfusion medicine. The head of the bloodless surgery program discussed ways to avoid transfusions and he kept using the word “respect” in relationship to Jehovah’s Witness avoidance of transfusions. Respect? “Admire (someone or something) deeply, as a result of their abilities, qualities, or achievements.” Nope. Understand? Yep. Accept? You bet. Part of what makes America a great place is we all get to do whatever dumb ass activity that suits us. But it is impossible to respect a belief that demands people to drip away their life’s blood.
Participation in SCAMs may not occur in a vacuum, isolated from other belief systems. There are a variety of other ways in which religious beliefs can influence medical care.
The deaths of children whose parents belong to sects of Christianity that rely on faith healing is an unfortunately common topic in the newspaper. It has been known for years that relying of prayer as a substitute for medical care leads to a shortened life expectancy, the archetype being Christian Scientists.
JAMA published a study that looked at outcomes in 5,500 Christian Scientists and compared them to a group of almost 30,000 controls using reality-based medicine.
There was an increased death rate for the Christian Scientists when compared to the control population, a difference made more remarkable as Christian Scientists neither smoke nor drink.
The JAMA study confirmed an earlier study that demonstrated the death rate from cancer among Christian Scientists was double the national average, and 6 percent died from preventable diseases.
Being a Christian Scientist led to 4 years less life for women and two years less life for men (Wilson GE. Christian Science and longevity. J Forensic Sci. 1965;1:43-60)
I would wager there would be similar outcomes in any group who avoids science-based medicine in favor of the topics covered in this blog.
There are belief systems of individual sects that avoid medicine or aspects of medicine. Then there is the effect on whole cultures where religious ideas dominate the culture. As an example, 13% of maternal deaths in South America are due to unsafe abortions, in part due to the Catholic Church’s ongoing opposition to birth control and abortion. Similar deaths can occur in the West, as Ireland recently demonstrated with Savita Halappanavar, who died from sepsis after a miscarriage. She was refused an abortion since “Ireland was a ‘Catholic country,’ she could not have (an abortion) while the foetal heartbeat was still present, although it was non-viable.”
There is a spectrum of influence from various faiths. Sometimes people use their position of authority to make medical pronouncements that run counter to reality, but are not really part of official religious doctrine.
The Bishop of Mozambique said that condoms and antiretroviral medications were manufactured to spread AIDS to Africans and, while not an official position of the Catholic Church, his comments have never been repudiated.
Polio was on the verge of eradication in Africa and the Mideast, but has seen a resurgence in part due to Muslims clerics who thought that vaccinations were a plot to sterilize the population and spoke against vaccination. In Pakistan they assassinated those in charge of vaccination programs.
Vaccinations are an area of doctrinal contention, since acceptance or denial of vaccines depends on whether to emphasize teachings in support helping and protecting each other or focusing on teachings where certain products are forbidden. You may focus on the body as a temple to deny a vaccine and ignore the part about stoning a disobedient child:
In multiple cases, ostensibly religious reasons to decline immunization actually reflected concerns about vaccine safety or personal beliefs among a social network of people organized around a faith community, rather than theologically based objections per se. Themes favoring vaccine acceptance included transformation of vaccine excipients from their starting material, extensive dilution of components of concern, the medicinal purpose of immunization (in contrast to diet), and lack of alternatives. Other important features included imperatives to preserve health and duty to community (e.g., parent to child, among neighbors). Concern that ‘the body is a temple not to be defiled’ is contrasted with other teaching and quality-control requirements in manufacturing vaccines and immune globulins.
Often religious reasons for refusing a vaccine are probably used to support a pre-existing anti-vaccine bias rather than a primary refusal based on religious principles, as was the case with polio vaccine in Nigeria:
Detailed consideration of the Nigerian situation revealed that what was described as ostensibly religious objections and assertions that vaccines spread the HIV virus or were vehicles for sterilization programs masked deeper struggles related to political power, inadequate health services, and a controversial clinical trial of an investigational antibiotic. While the boycott was centered within Islamic social networks, most of the objections raised related to social issues, rather than theological issues.
And the issues surrounding the Catholic Church’s opposition of condoms are not simple and the AIDS misinformation is more than one Bishop’s crazy opinion.
There are religious practices that have disease as a by-product of their participation. Many infectious diseases are spread by crowding: Group A Streptococcus and Meningococcus among many. The Hajj, the mass visit to Mecca every year, is a classic example and a well documented example of crowds facilitating the spread of contagion.
Years ago I was consulted on a patient with severe bloody diarrhea and the stool cultures grew Aeromonas, a waterborne organism. In asking direct questions looking for an exposure I discovered she had a gallon of holy water she had brought back with her from a trip to Mexico and she sipped a bit each day. We cultured the holy water and it grew Aeromonas as well.
Holy water is often contaminated with bacteria, and as a result I hypothesize that Pasteur went to hell:
Our aim was to assess the microbiological and chemical water quality of holy springs and holy water in churches and hospital chapels. Of the holy springs investigated, only 14% met the microbiological and chemical requirements of national drinking water regulations. Considering results from sanitary inspections of the water catchments, no spring was assessed as a reliable drinking water source. All holy water samples from churches and hospital chapels showed extremely high concentrations of HPC; fecal indicators, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus occurred only in the most frequently visited churches.
and holy water can be a source of infections in and out of the hospital, part of the reason that some churches have hands-free holy water dispensers.
There are other infections spread due to religious rituals such as herpes and ritual circumcision, with at least 22 cases reported of newborns acquiring herpes as a complication:
Ritual circumcision has three parts: the ‘milah’ or excision of the external prepuce, the ‘peri’ah’ or slitting of the inner foreskin, and finally the ‘metzitzah’ or sucking of blood from the wound. The metzitzah originated in the 5th century Babylonian Talmud where it states metzitzah should be performed ”so as not to bring on risk,” although what the risk is, is not explicitly stated. Historically, if the mohel failed to perform the metzitzah he was barred from performing future circumcisions. During metzitzah, the mohel sips wine and applies his lips to the involved portion of the penis and then spits the wine into a receptacle, which may be repeated until hemostasis is achieved. Metzitzah with direct oral- genital suction was commonplace until the 19th century when Rabbi Moses Schreiber ruled that an instrument, such as a glass pipette, could be used as an interface between the mohel and the infant.
Can you say ick? That is not a form of hemostasis I would recommend in the operating room.
Hindus can get cutaneous larva migrans, a cat or dog tapeworm that wanders the skin after inoculation causing an intensely itchy serpentiginous rash, from an act of penance known as a side roll:
The most devout penance that a devotee may perform is known as the ‘side roll’ or angapradakshinam where the night prior they engage in a ritual fast, soak in the temple water tank, then lie on the ground and side-roll in the same path that the icons previously traversed. For the comfort of the participants the local government ships in sand from coastal areas and waters the sand twice daily to keep dust down.
Most of the cutaneous larva migrans I have seen have been tourists retuning from the beaches of Asia where they lay in the litter box, er, I mean sand of the beach. Beach sand is often the toilet for many animals and with it their parasites.
There have also been a few cases of primary amoebic meningoencephalitis after ritual ablution where the amoeba was introduced by washing the sinuses with contaminated tap water.
Behavior and risk is never simple. The more I try and understand the motivations for behaviors that lead to disease, the more complex and curious I find them. Of course many human behaviors are associated with infections and diseases. No, make that all human behaviors. It is why I am so much fun at parties, constantly pointing out the infection associated with a particular behavior.

Idaho allows faith-based medical neglect to kill children
Idaho parents are shielded from criminal prosecution if they choose “prayer or spiritual means” over effective medical care for their children, even as their children keep dying.
Jann Bellamy on October 6, 2026
Link

In Idaho, as in other states, medical neglect of a child is a crime. However, if an Idaho parent (or guardian)
chooses for his child treatment by prayer or spiritual means alone
and the child suffers, even if he dies, the parent is exempt from criminal prosecution.
Not only does Idaho law shield the neglectful parents from prosecution, it prevents law enforcement and social workers from stepping in to protect a dead child’s siblings from suffering a similar fate.
Preventable deaths
The consequences of these barbaric laws were recently laid out in three maddening, heart-wrenching articles by the independent, non-profit newsroom, ProPublica. ProPublica reporters assembled law enforcement and death records involving children born into a faith-healing sect called Followers of Christ, a group we’ve covered before on SBM. The sect believes
that God heals the faithful and that life and death must be left to God’s divine will.
The news organization had medical experts review those records to determine whether the deaths would have been preventable with appropriate medical care. The review found that at least 15 babies and children died between 2015 and 2025 from illnesses that could have been successfully treated which, they concluded, was “almost certainly an undercount.”
Six deaths could not be evaluated due to incomplete or unavailable records. In four cases, experts could not say with confidence that medical care would have changed the outcome. (Although, I would think, almost certainly palliative medicine could have eased the children’s suffering.)
As well, experts identified numerous preventable losses of babies who died during birth or in utero very close to their due dates, cases labeled by the coroners as stillbirths.
The details of these deaths are horrific, gathered both from witness testimony and the conclusions of the medical experts about what the child would have experienced prior to death. These accounts are difficult to read but, unfortunately, in the torrent of news about human suffering being wrought by depraved governmental forces and medical bad actors, I felt these recent stories were not getting the attention they deserve; hence this post.
(ProPublica has also been at the forefront of digging out sundry other malfeasance, both health-related [raw milk, abortion bans, dismantling of USAID] and not, such as this recent blockbuster scoop involving a certain wedding.)
Faith-based medical neglect
A summary of some of ProPublica’s findings:
A newborn whose condition meant that he would have been gasping for air and turning blue due to lack of oxygen before dying from pneumonia. Thirteen months later, his newborn younger brother died of the same condition, which experts suspect was from a birth-related strep infection that expectant mothers in the U.S. are routinely screened for and is entirely treatable with antibiotics.
A 16-year-old “the size of a third grader” (62 pounds, just under 4 feet tall), whose death experts traced to a benign, treatable pituitary tumor that should have been discovered due to her stunted growth earlier in childhood. She suffered from many ailments during her brief life, her tumor sending “her body into a hormonal tailspin that destroyed her organs.”
At least three children who died from sepsis caused by common infections that could easily have been treated with antibiotics. One boy was born “happy and alert” but, over the next couple of days, grew “darker in color, coughing up phlegm and clenching his limbs in convulsions” before dying.
A two-year-old boy who was sick for six weeks with an untreated bacterial infection that settled in his heart and destroyed it. He had “fevers, abdominal pain, vomiting and swelling”.
A 16-month-old who died from an intestinal condition that can be fixed with a routine, minimally invasive surgery. Left untreated, the autopsy determined, the boy’s bowels had compressed his lungs and heart, which stopped beating; his lungs were so cramped they stayed the size of a newborn’s.
Four young children from the same family died from what appears to be untreated diabetes. They suffered from uncontrolled vomiting prior to passing away.
Two newborns from the same family died after aspirating meconium, an extremely rare occurrence in the U.S. A healthcare provider attending a birth is trained to detect meconium aspiration and to prevent illness and death of the infant with established protocols, including prescribing antibiotics.
In fact, records show at least five sets of parents have lost multiple children.
One of the sect’s “patriarchs” defended the Followers of Christ’s thusly:
Children and babies can’t make their own decision to rely on faith healing. [He] said their parents must keep them away from the doctor to set an example, so the young ones won’t be cursed later in life by turning to medicine.
Sect members who go to the doctor are shunned by their communities to reinforce its beliefs and, in the patriarch’s words, make sure they don’t go again. Family and neighbors form a protective shield around parents whose children die from neglect, trying to isolate them from law enforcement when the deaths are investigated, according to deputies who’ve been sent to follow up when a death is reported.
“Beyond comprehension”
Not everyone in Idaho agrees with shielding parents from the consequences of their neglect. Canyon County Sheriff Kieran Donahue, one of the most vocal opponents of the state’s faith-healing laws, has sent deputies to follow up on the deaths of at least 10 Followers’ children and infants since he took office in 2013.
‘This is needless,’ Donahue said. ‘This shouldn’t be happening.’
Retired pediatrician Dr. David Peterman, who reviewed the deaths of 18 infants and children, agrees. He finds it beyond comprehension that state legislators won’t change the law.
‘How is this tolerable?’ he said. ‘I don’t understand how there could be an exception in Idaho law that allows for these children to die.’
It’s hard to imagine any rational person disagreeing, but Idaho legislators have so far resisted changing the 1971 faith-healing legislation. In fact, the state legislature, in 1976, added a law that kept children from being placed in foster care solely for lack of medical attention.
According to ProPublica,
Since 2014, [state legislators] have rejected repeated efforts to dial back Idaho’s faith-healing exemption, instead crafting legislation to further limit the role of anyone but a parent when it comes to children’s health and safety. The state has codified ‘parental rights,‘ banned vaccine requirements in schools and childcare centers, and made parental consent a prerequisite for medical care of minors. Legislators also have tried to narrow the definition of ‘medical neglect’ for all families to only the most life-threatening situations, but those attempts have failed.
Next door, in Oregon, the rollback of similar laws protecting faith-based medical neglect has resulted in prosecutions of parents who put their children at risk. This provides a “powerful incentive for parents to seek medical care” and gives the state “legal leverage to order medical care for surviving and future children”, according to ProPublica’s reporting.
Given the current political support for ill-informed medical decision-making by parents and disregard for the resulting suffering it causes, I am not optimistic that Idaho’s laws will be revised in the near term. Unfortunately, we can be certain more children will suffer and die until that happens.



Islamic Medicine and the Biopolitics of Antiscience in Iran
When Islamic Medicine Kills the Ayatollah!
Kiarash Aramesh on March 13, 2025
Link
Ayatollah Sayyid Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi, the powerful Chief Justice of the Islamic Republic of Iran from 1999 to 2009 and one of the potential successors of the Supreme Leader, died of cancer in December 2018. After his death, his son revealed that the ayatollah had delayed the cancer treatments recommended by his doctors because he had trusted “Islamic medicine” to cure his disease. As a result, when he finally decided to use “western” medicine, it was too late, and the cancer had already metastasized extensively.
Ayatollah Shahroudi was not alone in his faith in Islamic medicine. Many other high-ranked Shi’a scholars avidly support it to be a part of the biopolitical agenda of the Islamic government. In contrast, others argue that medicine is an independent discipline and cannot be derived from religious scripture.
Religious Biopolitics and Islamic Medicine in Iran
In February 2019, a video went viral on Iranian social media featuring a prominent Shi’a cleric burning a copy of Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine. That cleric was Ayatollah Abbas Tabrizian, known to his followers as “the father of Islamic medicine.” By burning that medical textbook, he intended to symbolically declare war against what he refers to as “colonialist, western, and chemical medicine.” Instead, he promotes what he calls Islamic medicine.
Born in 1962 in Najaf, Iraq, Tabrizian is a high-ranked Shi’a cleric (an ayatollah) and a graduate of major Shi’a seminaries. Although he is currently the most prominent figure in Islamic medicine in Iran, he is not alone in supporting Islamic medicine; other prominent ayatollahs have asserted their different degrees of support for it.
Islamic Science
The founder of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Ayatollah Khomeini, once stated that “Fiqh (or Shari’a) is a comprehensive plan for human life from the cradle to the grave!” The Islamic Republic, over the past 45 years, has attempted to base its politics, economics, and social policies on the Shi’a version of Islamic Shari’a. Many Shi’a scholars wonder why not medicine.
Developing “Islamic” science, including Islamic medicine, has been a big part of the Islamization agenda for a powerful group of Shi’a scholars since the establishment of the Islamic Republic in Iran. For example, Ayatollah Sayyid Mohammad Mendi Mir Bagheri, the head of the “Islamic Sciences Academy of Qom,” and an influential figure and a potential (but not likely) future successor of the supreme leader, is an advocate of creating Islamic science, even Islamic physics, chemistry, and of course, medicine. Powerful figures like him are the faces of a branch of Islamic biopolitics in Iran that promotes the development of Islamic medicine.
Islamic Medicine as a Branch of Antiscience
Pseudoscience attempts to masquerade as legitimate science, yet it falls short of meeting scientific standards. In contrast, antiscience positions itself as superior to and more authoritative than science. Despite their differences, the boundary between pseudoscience and antiscience often blurs, making it challenging to distinguish between the two. However, in the case of Islamic medicine, this distinction is clear: It represents antiscience outright.
Islamic medicine asserts that understanding human health and illness, along with preventive and therapeutic measures and treatments, must be derived from the religious scriptures. The religious scripture in Shi’a Islam encompasses the Quran and Sunna. Sunna is what the prophet and twelve innocent Imams, his rightful successors, have said (hadith), did, or agreed upon. Through a process called Ijtihad, Shi’a scholars derive decrees from those sources.
Being well-trained in Ijtihad, Ayatollah Tabrizian, and his followers pursue an endeavor that has long intrigued clerics: deriving medical practices from the Islamic scripture to establish an Islamic medicine.
The Boundaries of Shari’a: Islamic Government and Islamic Medicine
It is important to clarify a few points:
First, this paper focuses on Iran’s experience, where approximately ninety percent of Iranians are officially classified as Shi’a. This designation is recorded on their birth certificates and cannot be changed later in life. While current Iranian law permits gender changes in rare cases, changing one’s religion is strictly forbidden and punishable by death. As a result, the true percentage of Iranians who genuinely adhere to Shi’a Islam is unknown. Recent polls and estimates indicate a growing trend, particularly among younger generations, towards identifying as non-religious or as followers of other religions such as Christianity and Zoroastrianism.
Second, Iran is governed as an Islamic Republic, meaning that, according to its constitution, all laws, rules, and regulations must be based on Islam or at least not contradict it. In this context, “Islam” specifically refers to Shi’a Islam. The officially recognized version of Shi’a Islam is the one that is taught in formal religious seminaries. A key concept in Iran’s Islamic Republic, known as “velayat-e faqih”, is the rule of the Supreme Leader, a senior figure (ayatollah) educated in these seminaries. Therefore, unless stated otherwise, this paper uses the term “Islam” to refer to the formal version of Shi’a Islam as practiced and interpreted in Iran.
Third, within Shi’a scholarship (comprising fuqaha or ayatollahs), there have long been debates about whether scripture or reason should be the primary source of law and ethics. “Scripture” refers to the Qur’an, considered the highest source of jurisprudence, and the Sunnah. As mentioned above, in Shi’a Islam, the Sunnah includes the sayings, actions, and approvals of the Prophet and his successors, the twelve Imams, which are recorded in various “hadith” books. Despite these debates, most Shi’a scholars aligned with the formal and ruling version of Islam in Iran maintain that when scripture provides a clear assertion or guidance, it takes precedence over reason.
Fourth, Shi’a scholars have long debated what aspects of life are covered by shari’a (fiqh or the jurisprudence and ethics derived from the Scripture) and what are not. This question has produced different answers over time. In the formal version of Islam that includes the theory of “velayat-e faqih,” it is accepted that there are such things as Islamic politics and Islamic economy—areas guided by the scripture and led by ayatollahs. However, there has been no consensus on whether there is such a thing as “Islamic medicine.”
The Role of Islamic Medicine
The current leader and the top brass of the Islamic Republic do not rely on Islamic medicine for their own healthcare. Instead, they access high-quality scientific medical treatments that are unaffordable to most Iranians. Instances like the one mentioned at the beginning of this paper are rare. While the Iranian Ministry of Health and Medical Education does support Traditional Iranian Medicine, it disapproves of Islamic medicine and frequently clashes with its practitioners. Furthermore, many high-ranking Shi’a scholars, including some who support the Islamic government, argue that Islamic medicine does not exist. They claim that the medical-related hadiths are either too few in number or insufficiently authenticated as being attributed to the Prophet or Imams to establish a distinct branch of medicine.
However, many influential Shi’a scholars, including ayatollahs, are avid supporters and providers of Islamic medicine. They contend that if politics, economics, and ethics must be derived from the Scripture, then medicine should be as well. Despite debates over the authenticity of some health-related instructions attributed to the Prophet or Imams, the sheer volume of these instructions makes it challenging for many Shi’a scholars to dismiss the existence of Islamic medicine entirely.
Practitioners of Islamic medicine, often educated in Shi’a seminaries, have strong connections in influential circles, making it challenging for the Ministry of Health to oppose them effectively. As a result, despite official disapproval, these practitioners maintain a presence in the media, including on government-controlled national TV. They continue to thrive in a profitable market by appealing to people whose religious beliefs lead them to become customers of Islamic medicine.
The COVID-19 Pandemic and The Purveyors of Islamic Medicine
The COVID-19 pandemic quickly became a fertile ground for spreading health-related disinformation as it gained global attention in early 2020. With a recovery rate of approximately 98%, proponents of unverified treatments often attributed natural recoveries to their own so-called success stories. Additionally, widespread public fear drove many anxious individuals toward self-assured promoters of “miracle cures.” Islamic medicine was quick to seek a portion of this lucrative market.
Ayatollah Tabrizian emerged as a notable purveyor of such miracle cures for COVID-19. A vocal anti-vaccine advocate, he frequently disseminated conspiracy theories through his lectures, which were shared on his popular online and social media accounts. He recommended applying violet oil to the anus as both a preventive and therapeutic measure against COVID-19, a suggestion that became a joke among Iranians. Additionally, he promoted a remedy attributed to Imam Kazim (765 – 799 CE), one of the 12 innocent Imams referred to above in Shi’a Islam, claiming it could cure all respiratory diseases, including COVID-19.
In March 2020, a video went viral showing one of Tabrizian’s students, Morteza Kohansal, inside a COVID-19 hospital ward. Without wearing a mask, Kohansal applied “Prophet’s perfume” to the noses of hospitalized patients. This dangerous behavior was extensively condemned by healthcare professionals at the time.
The Practice of Islamic Medicine
Islamic medicine is now practiced in numerous unlicensed clinics, and its products are being sold extensively by the representatives of Ayatollah Tabrizian and other purveyors all over Iran and even in other countries with Shi’a populations, such as Iraq. They are popular in social media; for example, the current number of followers of Ayatollah Tbrizian’s Telegram channel is almost 140 thousand, and it exceeded 200 thousand in the past; even though Telegram is banned in Iran and people need to use internet censorship circumvention (ICC) tools to access it. Here is a glimpse of some of the content, in addition to the treatments for COVID-19 mentioned above:
    • Their social media and other online pages are full of anti-science and anti-Western claims, such as conspiracy theories about the plans of the infidels and the imperialists to harm Muslims by depriving them of their natural remedies and religious lifestyle and, instead, selling them the products of pharmaceutical companies and genetically modified food.
    • Their understanding of human anatomy, physiology, and pathophysiology, and their terminology in these fields, are similar to that of Traditional Iranian Medicine, which is based on the theory of humors and temperaments.  The reason is apparent. The scripture they rely on was developed at a time (7th to 11th centuries BC) when those theories were dominant in the Middle East. However, they distance themselves from the philosophical bases of those theories and attribute all the processes and changes in the human body to the will and command of God.
    • For example, on the official website of Ayatollah Tabrizian, there’s a section that includes his lectures on “Islamic anatomy”. Those lectures are a funny mixture of modern, humoral, and scripture-based anatomy stitched together with magical thinking. According to them, for instance, semen is derived from vessels and hair; if during conception, the parents are under stress, their future child will resemble their (the child’s) uncles; also, the future children inherit their blood from the mother and their bones from the father (Lecture 30); the chest is made of phlegm; also phlegm comes from other organs, such as the brain, to the chest, that is why there is an overflow of sputum in the chest that makes its way to the outside of the body with coughing. The chest has a cold temperament and cools the heart to prevent it from becoming too hot and damage the body (Lecture18);  the basic material of hair and nails is “diseases,” and growing hair and nails is the body’s way to excrete diseases (Lecture #1); the reason behind some embryonic anomalies is their refusal to accept God’s creed at the time of conception; and Satan has the ability to flow within human vessels like blood and cause diseases (Lecture # 27).
    • Their preventive and therapeutic instructions and remedies are also derived from the scripture. For example, on their website, they sell potions and amulets to treat epilepsy (which they claim is caused by jinn), blood cancer, thalassemia, hemophilia, diabetes, and innumerable other conditions. These purported medications are made from a combination of various herbs. The only evidence supporting their safety and effectiveness comes from their descriptions in religious scripture and the interpretations of experts in Islamic jurisprudence and medicine. In addition, interventions such as wet cupping and bloodletting are performed according to the instructions found in the scripture.
    • In addition to the seminary-educated purveyors, many other practitioners of Islamic medicine, including many charlatans, try to gain a share of this lucrative market. Their practices include many bizarre claims, such as prescribing camel’s brain for treating platelet deficiency and camel urine for treating respiratory diseases. However, because they lack the knowledge and training to derive instructions from the scripture, it is hard to include them in the circle of valid practitioners of Islamic medicine.
An Aggressive but Declining Form of Religiosity
In his book Religion’s Sudden Decline, Ronald Inglehart describes how between 2008 and 2020, most developed countries have become less religious. In other words, organized religions have lost their popularity, and fewer percentages of people still consider themselves religious in that sense. This book also explains how, by becoming less popular, some religions become more aggressive and extremist in their social—including biopolitical—viewpoints and approaches.
Although no formal statistics exist, it is a consensual observation that in the past decades, the traditional version of Shi’a Islam has lost its popularity in Iran. The percentage of people who still follow the instructions of ayatollahs has shrunk significantly. At the same time, extremist ideas and aggressive approaches have become more prevalent among the powerful fraction of Shi’a scholars and believers who are facing social shrinkage and loss of popularity. For example, by having control of the parliament, they have passed extremist laws on family planning, abortion, and, most recently, women’s obligatory hijab, hoping to force people, especially women, to follow their medieval ideas. The recent outburst of Islamic medicine can be seen as a part of such a phenomenon.
Conclusions
Islamic medicine, as is currently promoted and practiced by some Shi’a scholars in Iran, is a branch of medical antiscience. The proponents of Islamic medicine in Iran try to integrate it into the political agenda of the Islamic government, so it becomes a part of the regime’s biopolitical agenda, along with its reproductive and forced veiling (hijab) policies. Most Shi’a scholars, either inside or outside of the government, oppose the notion of deriving an independent school of medicine from the scripture (although they agree with following the health-related instructions of the scripture in various degrees). Even most of the leading figures of the Islamic Republic don’t trust the purveyors of Islamic medicine with their health. However, the purveyors of Islamic medicine and their supporters are still powerful enough to safeguard a vast and lucrative market for practicing their medicine and marketing their products.
There are no formal statistics on the damage incurred by such practices. However, many cases, including the ones that occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic, have made their way into the media and show just the tip of the iceberg of the damage created by the purveyors of Islamic medicine in Iran. Informing people about the risks of such practices will always be part of the agenda of the proponents of science-based medicine in Iran. The same problem, with variations in their features, should be addressed in other Muslim-majority countries and Muslim communities all over the world.


   Touch

Why I Quit My Massage Therapy Career
Years ago, I was accused by my profession’s regulator of being an ‘unprofessional’ Registered Massage Therapist for criticizing pseudoscience in alternative medicine. I accepted an unusual public reprimand and made a few changes to my website, but my regulator pressed their case, effectively demanding that I quit writing altogether. I quit the profession instead.
Paul Ingraham on February 1, 2019
Link
[Editor’s note: Paul Ingraham, former assistant editor of SMB, makes a welcome return — this time with a guest post!]
May you come to the attention of those in authority.~ traditional curse[1]
At the end of 2010, I quit my nice job as a Registered Massage Therapist, exasperated by common anti-scientific attitudes, ideas, and methods in that profession and disheartened by an attempt to take away my right to write about it. My professional regulator had spent two years conducting a bizarre “investigation” into my professionalism because I was criticizing chiropractic and massage therapy on my website.
Rather than stop writing, I left my career, and became a traitor to complementary and alternative medicine, a rare CAM apostate. There aren’t many of us, just a handful I know of. Most CAM practitioners do not doubt the value of what they do, let alone quit because of it.
Many years later, I am finally ready to tell the story. I have been greatly delayed, mainly because right at the climax of my career crisis, my wife had a spine-crushing, brain-scarring accident while travelling alone in Asia. All that drama permanently changed my priorities, and for a long time I didn’t want to pick at any scabs. But now I’m finally ready to explain how I got these interesting scars…
When the tone police have power
The pseudo-legal hassle I got into was of a sort that I didn’t even know existed until it was happening to me. It was like a nuisance lawsuit, but I was not sued. I was … regulated.
From 2007–2010 I was embroiled in negotiations to defend my professional reputation. The threat came from my professional regulator, the College of Massage Therapists of British Columbia. The CMT is a government agency charged with setting and enforcing professional standards for BC massage therapists, which are laudably high. The profession aspires to be paramedical here, and has made a lot of progress towards that goal. I trained full-time for three years to get my certification, an unusually large requirement — in most places in the world, the bar is set much lower. The stakes were high.
The CMTBC has the power to investigate and punish RMTs for professional misconduct, and of course that’s important. But the misconduct they charged me with was peculiar: they tried to discipline me for the tone of my writing about pseudoscience and quackery, on my popular self-help website, PainScience.com.[2]
They had no complaints about my accuracy, mind you — they never questioned that. They just didn’t care for my tone.
I probably would never have left the profession of massage therapy if I’d felt safe criticizing treatments like therapeutic “touch” (actual touch not included) or craniosacral therapy (actual therapy not included). Unfortunately, the regulatory interest in my writing was both distasteful and extremely intimidating.[3]
Chiropractic hate mail
I had already been getting hate mail from chiropractors for a few years when the real trouble started in the summer of 2007 with a pair of particularly harsh, detailed complaints from two different chiropractors. They were no different in spirit from any of the other hate mail I routinely received, but these letters were more thorough and sent directly to the CMT instead of me, triggering an investigation by its Inquiry Committee.
The chiropractors wanted to get me formally spanked, and the CMT appeared to be sympathetic and cooperative. The committee was chaired at that time by a homeopath, so her cooperation wasn’t surprising to me — I had also publicly criticized homeopathy.
The Inquiry Committee of the CMT should be mostly concerned with allegations of genuine medical seriousness or moral turpitude, such as unsafe treatment or “bad touching”. They had never before investigated anything even remotely like this, or anyone like me: a skeptic in their own camp, an ideological traitor.
“Unprofessional” = opinions we don’t like
The CMT started their investigation with the strange allegation that the tone of PainScience.com was “unprofessional”. Specifically, they accused me of breaking these by-laws, which dictated that registrants must:
     1.  respect the honour, dignity and credibility of other professionals;
     2.  promote harmonious working relationships with other professionals;
     3.  refrain from undue criticism of the qualifications or the therapies provided by other Registrants or Licensed Practitioners;
It was their subjective, editorial opinion that my writing violated these by-laws. They believed my writing was disrespectful, unharmonious, and unduly critical of other professionals. But they never got more specific, and they never did assert that I was wrong about anything. They just didn’t like my tone.
And yet my tone was quite mild. Skeptical writing about alternative medicine (especially chiropractic) is often strongly worded indeed, while I was relatively polite. If I’d pulled my punches any more, I would hardly have been criticizing at all.
The back story: why was I writing critically about chiropractic and massage anyway?
I was a writer long before I was a massage therapist, and massage therapy started out for me as a sweet day job to support my writing habit: decent pay and a flexible schedule. I started writing about massage — because I always write about whatever I’m engrossed in — and by 2005 the self-help and educational articles I’d written for my clients were starting to attract readers from around the world. I saw potential to do some serious good and embraced the challenge of taking it further.
When the CMT Inquiry Committee’s investigation began, my writing about health science was amateurish compared to my standards now, but even then it was rigorous and idealistic. I had footnotes and everything.[4] My work was focused on patient education and showed plenty of respect for science. Bizarrely, I had even invested in custom-built software that facilitated referencing on my website, a $2,500 project requisitioned before I had any real income from writing. I was serious about upping my science journalism game.
And my interest in science and skepticism was fresh. I was a recently retired flake. Sagan’s Demon-Haunted World had inspired me to abandon a lot of beliefs, and I was full of zeal for my new way of life. I had written some rants about the sorry state of online information about musculoskeletal health and the manual therapies.
The most notable of those was an article critical of chiropractic, in which I wise-cracked about “crack addiction.” I do not deny that I was a little sassy — I was a budding skeptic, and there were a lot of things I wanted to make fun of back then. But it was pretty tame stuff.
“Crack addiction” and other offensive phrasings
The words “crack addiction” became my equivalent of Simon Singh’s infamous choice of the word “bogus,” referring to chiropractic therapy for children. It was one of three supposedly unprofessional phrases that the CMT inquiry committee originally cited. But, unlike Singh’s clearly scathing use of “bogus,” I had referred to “crack addiction” almost affectionately. It was clear in context that I was not actually knocking “crack addiction” per se, just identifying a major factor in the appeal of chiropractic adjustment. Here is the original text:
Nearly every fan of chiropractic is a “crack addict,” I’ve noticed. I enjoy joint cracking myself. I get real relief from a good joint crack, and I seek chiropractic adjustment from time to time. But I do try to promote a realistic view of what cracking can and cannot do. Although cracking can be made to sound more respectable by calling it “spinal adjustment,” and even though scientific research has shown that it does have some therapeutic benefits, it is fairly clear that crack addiction is the only reason that chiropractic survives as a profession. You can sell joint cracking. People want to be cracked!
Pretty harsh! The way I said that it has some therapeutic benefits that I seek out and pay for myself? Oooh, burn!
The only other phrases the IC ever specifically mentioned were:
    • chiropractic is “a bit of a one-trick pony” (referring to the crack addiction thing, and how spinal manipulation dominates chiropractic)
    • honesty is “in short supply among chiropractors” (referring to infamously aggressive chiropractic sales tactics, which are so excessive that even many chiropractors repudiate them)
Those were much more obviously negative and critical statements. But “unprofessional”? Worthy of censorship and censure?
For more than two years, the CMT escalated their case, always emphasizing and reiterating their concern about the “tone” and quality of my writing, but without further examples or more substantiating complaints. They simply believed that I had stated my opinions too colourfully, or something, and tried to penalize me for it.
Attack of the 50-foot committee!
Professional regulators have substantial power over their registrants. Getting investigated is like having your crotch sniffed by a huge, growling dog — a dog that can destroy your career. Regulatory law is a dark alley where you can get legally mugged and no one can hear you scream, and they wouldn’t have the jurisdiction to help you even if they did.
Regulators normally do not have any reason to investigate the professionals they certify unless there’s truly something wicked going on. But if they do investigate you, and if it’s unjust or motivated by internal politics or ideology … well, then you can have a serious problem. I’m aware of a case much like my own, concerning well-known potty-mouthed skeptical physiotherapist, Adam Meakins, whose paint-peeling rants about similar topics also attracted an accusation of professional misconduct. But while his case was wrapped up quite speedily, mine just kept going.
In the summer of 2008, the committee demanded a public reprimand as well as deletions and changes on my website (which I would define as censorship). Resistance would have been futile and disastrously expensive.[5]
Initially the committee’s investigation was only a disconcerting oddity. Despite their power over me, the complaint was about a relatively trivial matter. The idea of a disciplinary hearing was scary, but it was also remote and improbable. A volunteer lawyer advised me to take it on the chin and consent to their proposal — that I agree with their judgement that my writing was unprofessional, a fact that would publicized (like the results of all Inquiry Committee investigations). In her opinion, if I threw the big mean dog a bone, it would probably leave me alone. So I threw it a bone.
But it did not leave me alone. Instead, it started snarling and barking. The Inquiry Committee raised the stakes.
The report on a website disloyal to CAM
All was quiet for months after I consented to a wrist slap. I thought the ordeal was over. Instead it kicked into a higher gear when I found an envelope full of trouble in my mailbox. The CMT had hired a professor from the University of British Columbia to review my website.
When you’re paying for the tune you want to hear, that’s a “jukebox” report. In a two-page opinion letter and much longer analysis of my many citations, the professor gave the CMT a (presumably expensive) academic opinion that my writing was “insulting and derogatory” and that it was my intent to “do harm to other health professionals.” A thought crime, an accusation based on speculation about my intentions. The CMT used the report as a justification to demand extensive changes to my website that were still unspecified, despite the detailed report.
A few observations about the report:
    • It was mostly padding. Half the wordage was an essay on “good science.”
    • Most of the remainder was an analysis of the wrong website.[6]
    • The context of my citations was ignored. For instance, several sources were judged to be “poor quality” without acknowledging they had been cited as examples of poor quality evidence.
    • Other sources — skeptical sources, like QuackWatch.org — were denounced for blatantly ideological reasons.[7]
    • My website was accused of being “insulting” — a major feature of the conclusions — and yet only a single minor example was given. But that example didn’t exist![8]
How much did that report cost the CMT? And what if they demanded that I pay for it? They had invested in this fight, and I had no idea how much further they might be prepared to go. The CMT proposed that I “accept” the professor’s report and “amend” my website within 60 days, with no specific suggestions.
If my website had been a book, they would have proposed a burning. It had obviously been a tactical error to consent to their proposal the previous summer. It was time to fight back.
Meet the skeptics!
I reached out to the Vancouver skeptical community. I jetted off to The Amaz!ng Meeting in 2009 and introduced myself to the SBM bloggers. At an amazing Skepchick party, Dr. Novella and I discussed how I could effectively help him out with his many projects, which is the origin story for my role as the assistant editor of this here blog from 2010 to 2016.
My predicament was kind of hot for a while. Everybody at TAM wanted to chat with the massage guy who was in trouble with his regulator. Upon my return, I went to my first Skeptics in the Pub event, and was introduced to Dr. Rob Tarzwell (now impressively both a psychiatrist and a nuclear medicine specialist).
“We have to talk,” Dr. Tarzwell said. “You really need me. And I want to help.”
He was the first of three local heavy hitters that enthusiastically came to my defense. I was also aided by Dr. Dale Beyerstein (brother of the late Barry Beyerstein, much missed by skeptics). A medical ethicist, Dr. Beyerstein identified legal and ethical flaws with the allegations against me. Finally, I also got support from Dr. Jonathan Berkowitz, a UBC statistician specializing in medical research, and a distinguished teacher of statistics, research design, and critical appraisal in medicine.[9]
I had assembled a dream team of supporters, and all three wrote beefy letters of support. This is what skeptics will do for you. Because they care. And, as impressive my support already was, it seemed like it would have been easy to get more.[10]
I sent another letter off to the CMT, attaching my letters of support. The CMT did not reply.
Going public
Despite robust support from three credible experts, the situation was still delicate. The CMT had already shown that there were no clear limits to how hard they would press their case. I had to play one more card: I had to let the CMT know that they were going to get a public relations black eye if they didn’t start compromising.
So I went on the radio. Just a little bit.
I was a guest on Desiree Schell’s excellent show, Skeptically Speaking (now Science for the People).[11] I asked listeners to contact the CMT and express their support for PainScience.com, and their concern that I was being accused of professional misconduct for silly reasons. They did. The chair of the disciplinary committee — the homeopath, remember? — immediately wrote back to them, demanding to know how they had heard about my case.
The CMT had probably never faced a public relations kerfuffle like this. I took satisfaction in imagining the institutional consternation I caused. It couldn’t begin to make up for the personal stress I had endured since 2007, but it was something, and I savoured it.
Victory and fresh hell
I didn’t hear from the CMT again for months, and their next letter was conciliatory compared to all their previous correspondence. Reading between the lines of this much more cautious note, it seemed to say, “If you stop making a stink, we’ll back off.”
For the first time in years, I started to relax a little bit. But that didn’t last long. Just one week later, my wife had a horrific car accident while travelling alone in Laos, injuring her brain seriously, smashing her spine, and much else — proof that life (as well as history) is just one damned thing after another. Writing from a sweltering hospital room in a small town in northern Thailand, my wife lying beside me with a crushed spine, I told the CMT that I considered the matter resolved, and in any case I’d quit the profession and was indefinitely distracted by a medical emergency. Reading between my lines: “Buzz off — I have real problems to worry about now.”
I never heard from them again.
Coda on quitting massage
I love massage. Its medical value may be unclear, but I’m comfortable with that — if it’s not biologically useful, it’s still “just” inherently pleasurable and relaxing, and I’m happy either way. I see a massage therapist regularly and it’s hard to imagine my life without that service. If every massage therapist was like mine — someone who never talks about chakras — I would have no gripe with the profession at all.
And indeed many massage therapists are like her, and many are busily trying to drag their profession into the 21st Century. They embrace evidence-based medicine, vigorously advocate for it on social media, avidly read this blog, and mine, and many other good sources that have cropped up over the years. Even as the CMT was investigating me, I got vigorous moral support and advice from the Massage Therapy Association of BC, which has a long history of promoting evidence-based practice.
And yet the profession is also deeply divided (much like chiropractic). The massage world is still rotten with faith-based treatments and flaky magical thinking, and what little interest in science you find is often shallow. Vitalism is rampant and many therapists indulge in overt quackery like Reiki and reflexology, but that’s only the most obvious nonsense, the tip of a far larger iceberg of health care amateurism and hair-raising ignorance, incompetence, and overconfidence. Practitioners earnestly keen on science and evidence-based practice are a depressingly small minority, and they are inevitably sneered at by many of their colleagues. Massage therapy has a deeply pseudoscientific character overall, defining itself mostly in opposition to science-based or “mainstream” health care, where rejection of science is actually celebrated by many practitioners, probably a majority.
And that is why I left: not just because I had a scrap with my regulator, but because I wasn’t comfortable in a profession so conflicted about science. It was getting awkward. I didn’t want to spend the rest of my career explaining to scientists and engineers and doctors that I was one of the pro-science massage therapists. Others like me have remained, of course, fighting to modernize the profession, and my hat is off to them — I do what I can to support them with my writing and publishing.

Notes
     1.  This is one part of a three-part curse that is actually not actually “ancient Chinese,” but English or American. According to Wikipedia, “The Chinese language origin of the phrase, if it exists, has not been found, making its authenticity doubtful.” The other two parts of the curse are the more famous “may you live in interesting times” and “may you find what you are looking for.” ⤴
     2.  Back then, in the late 2000s, it was SaveYourself.ca. I changed it to PainScience.com in late 2014. ⤴
     3.  This was back when Simon Singh was being sued by the British Chiropractic Association. Today, in a world where Simon won (say that in the movie-trailer voice, very satisfying) I feel quite a bit safer from chiropractic litigiousness. But I sure didn’t feel safe back then. A chiropractor once even threatened to sue me for writing “chiropractors are litigious.” He didn’t see the irony. ⤴
     4.  I was still a little foggy about research methods back then, and tended to cherry pick trial conclusions I liked the sound of, free of worries about things like P-hacking, but my bias was skeptical — I tended to cherry-pick “bad news” studies that showed no treatment effect — and I was at least clearly making an effort to cite, support, and ponder plausibility at a time when there were almost no other similar websites or blogs in existence, let alone rigorous ones. ⤴
     5.  It would have triggered a formal disciplinary hearing — an expensive process, even more freakishly out of proportion to the seriousness of the issue than it already was. Suing a regulator is possible in theory but foolish in practice: the courts tend to strongly favour regulators. ⤴
     6.  I had three websites at the time, and he reported on by far the smallest and least relevant. It did share a bibliography with PainScience.com, and that is mostly what the report analyzed. While the bibliography was relevant, the report damningly failed to discuss the content that referenced those citations, on the domain that actually mattered. ⤴
     7.  The professor denounced QuackWatch.org as a bad source because it has a “known bias.” For the same reason, he also denounced Trick or Treatment, by Edzard Ernst and Simon Singh — an excellent book. Predictably, he found fault with any source that could be construed as skeptical or anti-quackery. ⤴
     8.  As far as I can tell, he wasn’t even paraphrasing anything. It appeared to be invented. I guess it’s what the author imagined I might have said while in a drunken argument with him about alternative medicine at a dinner party. ⤴
     9.  I remember asking Dr. Berkowitz, “What’s critical appraisal in medicine?” And he replied, “I study the credibility and validity of medical and health care information claims. In other words, I’m an expert in exactly what you need.” ⤴
     10.  At the time, I had been in touch with Simon Singh, Drs. Novella, Barrett, Colquhoun, and other experts and skeptical celebrities. All were generous and interested. All offered assistance of one sort or another. The skeptical community had my back, in a big way. ⤴
My interview starts at 13:30. ⤴

   Healing Touch and Coronary Bypass
Harriet Hall
Link
A study published in Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine is being cited as evidence for the efficacy of healing touch (HT). It enrolled 237 subjects who were scheduled for coronary bypass, randomized them to receive HT, a visitor, or no treatment; and found that HT was associated with a greater decrease in anxiety and shorter hospital stays.
This study is a good example of what I have called “Tooth Fairy Science.” You can study how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves in different situations (first vs. last tooth, age of child, tooth in baggie vs. tooth wrapped in Kleenex, etc.), and your results can be replicable and statistically significant, and you can think you have learned something about the Tooth Fairy; but your results don’t mean what you think they do because you didn’t stop to find out whether the Tooth Fairy was real or whether some more mundane explanation (parents) might account for the phenomenon.
Theoretical underpinnings
According to the study’s introduction:
Healing touch is a biofield- or energy-based therapy that arose out of nursing in the early 1980s…HT aids relaxation and supports the body’s natural healing process, i.e., one’s ability to self-balance and self-heal.” This noninvasive technique involves (1) intention (such as the practitioner centering with the deep, gentle, conscious breath) and (2) placement of hands in specific patterns or sequences either on the body or above it. At its core, the theoretical basis of the work is that a human being is a multi-dimensional energy system (including consciousness) that can be affected by another to promote well-being.
They cite a number of references to theorists who support these ideas. They cite Ochsman; he wrote a book Energy Medicine: The Scientific Basis which I reviewed, showing that despite the book’s title, there is no credible scientific basis and the “evidence” he presents cannot be taken seriously.
They cite Candace Pert, who said in the foreword to Ochsman’s book that Dr. Oschman “pulled” some energy away from her “stagnant” liver. She said the body is “a liquid crystal under tension capable of vibrating at a number of frequencies, some in the range of visible light,” with “different emotional states, each with a predominant peptide ligand-induced ‘tone’ as an energetic pattern which propagates throughout the bodymind.” Does this even mean anything?
They even cite the PEAR study, suggesting that it is still ongoing (it isn’t) and claiming it shows that “actions in one system can potentially influence actions of another on a quantum energetic level.” (It didn’t.)
This is nothing but imaginative speculation based on a misunderstanding of quantum physics and of what physicists mean by “energy.” It is a truism that electromagnetic phenomena are widespread in the human body, but there is a giant gap between that and the idea that a nurse with intention and hand movements can influence electrical, magnetic, or any other physical processes in the body to promote healing. There is no evidence for the alleged “human biofield.”
Previous Research
They cite several randomized controlled studies of HT over the last few years. One showed “better health-related quality of life” in cancer patients. One, the Post-White study, showed no difference between HT and massage. One small study by Ziembroski et al. that I couldn’t find in PubMed apparently showed no significant difference between HT and standard care for hospice patients. One study showed that HT raised secretory IgA concentrations, lowered stress perceptions and relieved pain, and results were greater with more experienced practitioners; but it only compared HT to no treatment and didn’t use any placebo treatment.
A pilot study compared 4 noetic therapies-stress relaxation, imagery, touch therapy, and prayer, and found no difference.
A larger study showed that neither touch therapy nor masked prayer significantly improved clinical outcome after elective catheterisation or percutaneous coronary intervention.
They cite a review of healing touch studies by Wardell and Weymouth It concluded “Over 30 studies have been conducted with healing touch as the independent variable. Although no generalizable results were found, a foundation exists for further research to test its benefits.” Wardell noted that “the question has been raised whether the field of energy research readily lends itself to traditional scientific analysis due to coexisting paradoxical findings.” This is a common excuse of true believers who find that science is not cooperative in validating their beliefs.
Study Design
237 patients undergoing first-time elective coronary artery bypass surgery were randomly assigned to one of 3 groups: an HT group, a visitor group, and a standard care group. All received the same standard care from the hospital. The HT group received preoperative HT education and 3 HT interventions. Practitioners established a relationship with their patients, assessed their energy fields, and performed a variety of HT techniques based on their assessment, including techniques that involved light touch and those that involved no touch (practitioners’ hands held above body). Sessions lasted 20 to 90 minutes; each patient had the same practitioner throughout the study. The “visitor” group patients were visited by a nurse on the same schedule. The visits consisted of general conversation or the visitor remaining quietly in the room with the patient. They mentioned that some visits were shortened at the patient’s request.
Results of the Study
The six outcome measures were postoperative length of stay, incidence of postoperative atrial fibrillation, use of anti-emetic medication, amount of narcotic pain medication, functional status, and anxiety. HT had no effect on atrial fibrillation, anti-emetics, narcotics, or functional status. The only significant differences were for anxiety scores and length of stay. The length of stay for the HT group was 6.9 days, for the visitor group 7.7 days, and for the routine care group 7.2 days, suggesting that the simple presence of a visitor made things worse(!?). Curiously, for the subgroup of inpatients, the length of stay was HT 7.4 days, visitor 7.7 days and routine care 6.8 days, which was non-significant at p=0.26 and suggested that both HT and visitor made things worse.
The mean decreases in anxiety scores were HT 6.3, visitor 5.8, and control 1.8. They said this was significant at the p=0.01 level. But the tables for results broken down by inpatient and outpatient show no significant differences (p=0.32 for outpatients and p=0.10 for inpatients). If it was not significantly different for either subgroup, how could it be significant for the combined group?
These discrepancies are confusing. They suggest that the significant differences found were due to chance rather than to any real effect of HT..
Problems with this Study
Four out of the six outcomes were negative: there was no change in the use of pain medication, anti-emetic medication, incidence of atrial fibrillation, or functional status. The only two outcomes that were significant were hospital stay and anxiety, and these results are problematic and might have other explanations.
It is impossible to interpret what the difference in length of stay means, because they did not record the reasons for delaying discharge. As far as we can tell from the paper, the doctors deciding when to discharge a patient were not blinded as to which study group the patient was in. It’s interesting that the visitor group length of stay was intermediate in the outpatient subgroup, but higher than control for the combined inpatient/outpatient group. They offer no explanation for this. I was puzzled by the bar graph showing these numbers, because the numbers on the graph don’t seem to match the numbers in the text. The numbers were manipulated: they did a logarithm transformation for length of stay “to handle the skewness of the raw data.” I don’t understand that and can’t comment. The range of hospital days is such that the confidence intervals largely overlap. In all, these data are not very robust or convincing and they raise questions.
They interpret the anxiety reduction scores (HT 6.3, visitor 5.8, and control 1.8) as showing a significant efficacy of HT, but it seems more compatible with a placebo response and a slightly better response for the more elaborate placebo.
There were fewer patients (63) in the visitor group than in the HT and control groups (87 each). This was not explained. The comparison of groups appears to show that the control group had significantly higher pre-op anxiety scores than either of the other groups, which would tend to skew the results
They didn’t use a credible control group. A visitor sitting in the room can’t be compared to a charismatic touchy-feely hand-waving practitioner. Other studies have used mock HT where the hand movements were not accompanied by healing thoughts. These researchers rejected that approach because they didn’t think it would be ethical to offer a sham procedure where the practitioner only “pretended” to help. Hmm… One could argue that they have provided no evidence that HT practitioners are ever doing anything more than pretending to help.
They don’t comment on how practitioners were able to “assess the energy fields” of their patients. Emily Rosa’s landmark study showed that practitioners who claimed to be able to sense those fields couldn’t.
The authors consist of 3 RNs (2 of them listed as healing touch therapists and presumably the ones who provided treatment in the study), a statistician with an MS, and two “directors of research” for whom no degrees are listed. The authors are clearly prejudiced in favor of HT.
They interpret this study as supporting the efficacy of HT. I don’t think it does that. I think the results are entirely compatible with a placebo response. With any made-up intervention presented with strong suggestion, one could expect to find one or two statistically significant differences when multiple endpoints are evaluated. And the magnitude of the improvement here is far from robust. This is the kind of result that tends to diminish in magnitude or vanish when better controls are used. I think the study is Tooth Fairy science, purporting to study the effects of a non-existent phenomenon, but actually only demonstrating a placebo response.
I wonder if better results might be obtained by having a patient advocate stay with the patient and offer reassurance, explanations, massage and other comfort measures – something like the doulas who have been shown to improve childbirth outcomes.
The frightening thing is that during the course of this study, patients increasingly bought into the HT belief system and refused to sign up for the study because they wanted HT and didn’t want to risk being assigned to a control group. And hospital staff bought into the belief system, were treated themselves, and became proponents of offering it to patients for other indications.
The paper ends with a rather incoherent statement one would not expect to find in a scientific medical journal: “At the very heart of this study is the movement toward recognizing that the metaphoric and physical heart are both very real, if we allow them to be.”

   Touched by a Touched Healing Toucher
Kimball Atwood
Link
Recent posts by Drs. Sampson and Hansen and some recent comments have got me to thinking for the umpteenth time about this issue: quackery is quackery, even if it seems harmless and even if some people seek it. This is the first of a series that will discuss it. I’m afraid I will ramble a bit; it may be that not every post will support that premise. Nevertheless, in the aggregate I’ll try to do exactly that.
The posts about Healing Touch sent me on a walk down memory lane, to one of my early forays into “CAM” skepticism. It was there that I discovered just how removed from reality some true believers, even those that project a superficial air of sobriety, can be. Here I’ll recount a brief exchange that I had with one such person, who was undoubtedly well-meaning. My attempts to influence her by the use of reason proved futile.
Shortly after the publication of the famous Emily Rosa article in 1998, I read a report about it in Newsday. It wasn’t all that bad, but my annoyance with mainstream publications giving the slightest credence to “alternative medicine” had been growing, and this moved me to act. I wrote a diatribe to Newsday that was not published (I can’t imagine why):
To the Editor:
“Therapeutic touch” is such obvious humbug that it never should have been taken seriously by anyone with the slightest aquaintance with how things work. Nevertheless, academic careers have been based on it, hundreds of useless papers have been written about it, courses in it have been given and even required of nursing students, grant money has been provided for it (but not used to test it!), and scores of ridiculous magazine and newspaper articles have praised it, apparently to a naive and credulous public. All of this constitutes a huge embarrassment to nurses, a fact that would appear to be lost on their largest professional organization (the ANA).
One of the statements in your article about the JAMA study was incorrect: the practitioners were not able to detect the energy field half of the time. They were able to guess the correct hand half the time, as would be predicted by chance alone. Thus there is no evidence that the “energy field” was detected at all. This is no surprise, because this kind of “energy field” exists only in the fantasies of true believers.
Dolores Krieger’s objection to the study, that the right practitioners were not tested, is disingenuous. She has been asked numerous times, by James Randi and others, to submit to testing of the same sort as described in Rosa’s study (Randi’s foundation has even offered a $1 million reward for anyone who can demonstrate the ability to detect the “energy field”!). Neither she nor any of her trainees or colleagues has come forward, nor has any of them published a single study supporting the efficacy of “therapeutic touch.”
Among the shamelessly fawning, uncritical articles on TT referred to above is one in Newsday by Tina Morales, 7/8/96. Really, now. There are very simple, basic skills useful for evaluating questionable claims. If the writer doesn’t have them the editor certainly should!
Before gentle readers admonish me for the scolding, schoolmarmish tone of that letter, let me assure them that I have long since learned to couch my objections to “woo” in more matter-of-fact, less provocative language. As frustrating as it may be, amiable, well-meaning, intelligent people who haven’t the slightest idea how to evaluate questionable claims vastly outnumber their more savvy counterparts, even in surprising fields: journalism and medicine, for example. Ten years ago I had no intention of becoming more than a temporary, annoying gadfly. I imagined that the “CAM” fad would soon blow over, and that I’d go back to spending my free time watching re-runs of Seinfeld and Law and Order. Alas, ’twas not to be. Patience.
Not long after that minor event, still reeling from the sheer absurdity of it all, I stumbled upon the “Official Response from Healing Touch International…to the April 1, 1998 JAMA article ‘debunking’ Therapeutic Touch.” It had been written by Cynthia Poznanski Hutchison, DNSc, RN, CHTP/I, Research Coordinator for Healing Touch International, Inc., Lakewood, CO. I’m sorry to say that it is no longer available online, but here are a few excerpts (bold type in the original):
The published study does not test any critical variables related to therapeutic touch. The ability to sense the energy field of another is simply not a requirement of a TT practitioner….What you do in your mind and heart far surpasses any kinesthetic experience in your hands….Some practitioners sense a client’s energy intuitively or are able to see, or hear subtle aspects of the energy body (clairvoyance). Each person is unique in her or his abilities as a practitioner.
The study design was not representative of a therapeutic touch session. It was set up more as a parlor game. Therapeutic touch studies using people with health problems would most likely demonstrate positive effects. The critical variables of practitioner compassion and holding the intentionality for the highest good of the recipient was not part of the study. In the study setting, no healing was sought.
The child conducting the study was not neutral about therapeutic touch, and therefore could have affected the results….Emily has grown up in a household where she couldn’t possibly be neutral about the existence of energy fields. Her parents have been activists in trying to debunk TT. Her thoughts may have blocked her own energy field from being perceived based on her belief that the practitioners could not be successful. Practitioners are keenly aware of people’s ability to block or close down their energy fields with their thoughts. Healing Touch instructors usually demonstrate this phenomena [sic] in introductory energy classes.
…Theirs is one study which looked at one variable of the 5 steps of therapeutic touch, and it is the least critical of all variables/steps. Dissecting therapeutic touch and claiming to disprove it by looking at a piece of it is like studying a horse by only looking at its legs…
…Studies since the early 1970s have progressively supported the use of therapeutic touch in the clinical setting. Interestingly, the authors did not mention Wirth’s (1992) TT study titled “The Effect of Non-Contact Therapeutic Touch on the Healting Rate of Full Thickness Dermal Wounds.”
…
A final point is one of acknowledgment that there are many unanswered questions about energetic therapy!! Practitioners know this and practice anyway because their experience has shown them phenomenal results. (Many practitioners also initially started out as strong skeptics.)…We don’t have all the answers yet, and may never figure out every piece of the puzzle. However, while striving to understand energetic therapy from a scientific view, practitioners also “embrace the mystery” and let go of “the need to understand” during sessions. This is part of the beauty, awe, and humility that is experienced by many practitioners and patients.
Newton’s theory in the 1600s described the human being as a divine type of mechanism or machine, with fixed parts, predictability, and alive within a closed system. But quantum physics of today describes us as fields within fields, as vibrating waves and particles, as equal to about 2 grains of sand in solid matter were we to be totally compressed. Modern physics supports the use of energetic therapy, most notably in the sentences: “Thought precedes form. Thought is a form of energy. Attention (presence) changes the object being observed.” …Spirituality and science have been kept separate since the scientific era, but more and more we are seeing the holism of all creation, the connectedness of everyone and everything, and the re-emergence of science and spirituality as different perspectives of the same thing.
Studies on the existence of energy fields and the effects of energetic therapy have been published regularly since the 1960s….The question is why so many mainstream medical practitioners have ignored, downplayed, or attacked a promising form of therapy to assist humanity in its suffering, healing, and dying?…Read Vibrational Medicine by Richard Gerber, MD, or some of Deepak Chopra’s books…experience a short series of therapeutic touch…Be skeptical if you like, but be open! (Since your thoughts are a part of you and your energy system, you can use them to block any positive effects.)
We encourage solid research to study all aspects of energetic healing in order to understand how it can best serve humanity. We invite healthy skepticism of all types of health care offered to society, mainstream and complementary…
Ayayayayay! Dr. Sampson has correctly observed that “there have been pages” written about the Rosa experiment, and it is not my intention to merely restate those. Some of the best pages, by the way, are by Steve Novella here on SBM and by Larry Sarner, co-author of the Rosa report. My intention here is to do something slightly different, although it necessarily covers some of the same material: to offer a bit of insight into the mind of a True Believer. After reading Ms. Hutchison’s Official Response, I couldn’t help myself:
Dear Ms. Hutchison,
Your response to Emily Rosa’s study is easily rebutted on many grounds, and I imagine that you’ve already received several letters pointing those out. Therefore I’d like to limit my remarks to the notion that “modern physics supports the notion of energetic therapy,” which it most certainly does not. The quotation that followed your claim, which was unattributed, may be most charitably described as an example of poetic license, but in no way is supported by quantum theory. For a discussion of the misuse of quantum theory, see http://www.csicop.org/si/9701/quantum-quackery.html What modern physics does have to say about the sort of “energy field” that is the basis for TT and other “alternative therapies” is that until it can be measured in any reproducible way, there is no reason to believe that it exists.
The Rosa experiment is important precisely for this reason: TT advocates have claimed for years that although unmeasurable, TT practitioners can “feel” the “energy field.” If that could be shown, it would constitute a heretofore unknown force in the universe, comparable to the discovery and characterization of electricity and magnetism. In the scientific world this would be HUGE, with equally huge repercussions for technological applications. Rosa’s experiment failed to show it, but the door has been opened for years for anyone else to demonstrate it. If you are so convinced of your objections to the study, why don’t you repeat it with practitioners who are convinced of their ability to sense the field and a subject who believes in TT? Science would welcome the results, whether pro or con.
The idea that the right practitioners were not tested, by the way, is disingenuous. Dolores Krieger and her disciples have been asked numerous times, by James Randi and others, to submit to testing of the same sort as described in Rosa’s study (Randi’s foundation has even offered a $million reward for anyone who can demonstrate the ability to detect the “energy field”!). Neither she nor any of her trainees or colleagues has come forward. Here’s your chance to make a real contribution.
I didn’t really expect a reply, but one came a mere day or two later.
Dear Kimball,
Thanks for writing to share your viewpoint. Yes, someone who is neutral is planning to replicate the study in way that is reflective of the true process of TT.
(We’re still waiting.)
And no, no one has written to me with your point of view, yet. Yes, we all want to understand this work and how it can be a help to humankind. Also, you wrote to me “The idea that the right practitioners were not tested, by the way, is disingenuous.” I don’t know why you shared that with me as I never heard a statement about the practitioners nor made a statement about them. I saw no obvious problem with the practitioners.
(But TT co-inventor Dolores Krieger, according to Newsday, did: ” ‘It’s poor in terms of design and methodology,’ she said, adding that the designer of the study – Emily – should not have been the one to conduct it, and the 21 subjects were too few and unrepresentative“(emphasis added).)
When I read research, including work published in JAMA, the conclusion section usually is a place where the author speaks to recomendations for further study and what can reasonably be concluded on the single piece of research. Most researchers emphasize the need to replicate the study and include a critique of their own work.
(Well, OK, but why haven’t advocates replicated it?)
They remind readers that one piece of research does not prove anything, and urge others to not jump to conclusions, whether results are perceived as positive or negative. The AMA press release did none of these, but stated instead “Their failure to substantiate therapeutic touch’s most fundamental claim is unrefuted evidence that the claims of therapeutic touch are groundless and that further professional use is unjustified.”
Sensing the energy field isn’t even a requirement to practice TT. [Huh?] This statement is reflective of unprofessionalism, lack of objectivity, ill will, and is void of scientific credibility. [Huh?] Please remember that everyone thought the “germ” theory was ridiculous until they could be seen under a microscope!
(Huh? Seeing them under a microscope preceded the germ theory by nearly 300 years.)
And what about the fact that there is no anatomical proof of the existence of the S-A node in the heart which has long been recognized by the mainstream medical community to be the electrical source of heart activity? [Huh?] Is there a related organization that you know of that is also demanding that someone prove the existence of God? [Yes, several]
Although human beings have come a long way, we are still quite primitive in many ways. [No argument there. And her point is?] I expect that were you to get a glimpse of the earth 100 years from now, there would be a few inventions and discoveries that you would have thought impossible in 1998.
(Maybe yes, probably no, and “impossible” has several meanings. Again, what’s her point? There are an infinite number of potential claims, and the vast majority will be wrong.)
TT practitioners do not want to participate in studies where there exists a hostile attitude, which is what they universally feel with people from organizations related to Emily’s studies. I don’t blame them. (Please reread our official response to understand why). Research needs to take place in a neutral environment of seeking truth, and not with the sole purpose of “debunking” someone else’s truth.
(Wrong: experiments are done to falsify, i.e., “debunk” hypotheses.)
Offering me a million dollars to “do it your way” instead of in a way that reflects the true nature of the work feels like a bribe or a bet rather than a sincere effort to find an answer to a rivoting question. Try making a similar offer where the methodology is agreed upon by both parties and the money (if won) goes to a charitable organization or the energetic organization, and see what happens.
I fully agree with you, as do my colleagues (as stated in the response paper), that research is crucial.
(Actually, I think and thought then that research on TT is ridiculous. My point was that if believers didn’t like Emily’s results, they had damn well better put their money where their mouth is and repeat the experiment.)
TT has been one of the most popular research topics in professional nursing for many years, and it continues to be. In addition, many other schools of energy healing are also engaged in research. On top of that, the whole area of distance healing and prayer research, which is related , is growing rapidly. Are you willing to say that all of the academic committees, hospitals, health institutions, and sources which have approved the practice or research of TT or dispensed grant monies for TT and related studies were all led astray or were out of their senses when they approved the study of energetic work?
(Of course I am (what world does she live in?), but are those the only possible explanations? What about fleecing schemes?)
What is your explanation as to how Daniel Wirth’s TT study showed the positive results that it did?
(Incredible. First, only two of Wirth’s 4 papers on dermal wound healing reported faster healing in the TT group; one reported faster healing in the control group—all reviewed here. Second, Wirth is a scoundrel who just spent the past few years in federal prison after being found guilty of numerous charges of fraud, not long after he had co-authored the infamous Columbia U. “Miracle” Prayer study. She didn’t know that at the time, of course, but is it really a surprise?)
Let me share a small piece of personal information. I’m married to a skeptical scientist who questions this work also. But what makes this marriage work is that we have love and respect for each other, and we support each other’s growth and paths in life. We even tease each other about this. Neither of us are arrogant enough to say we as individuals have the truth. We both know that the world has enough mysteries to keep humanity doing research for at least a few thousand more years. We keep respect and humor in our relationship, and quite frankly, I’d like to see more of that with the Skeptics Groups.
You and I both know that there are alot of quacks in the world (I’ve met quite a few!) and it takes inner discernment and healthy skepticism to make decisions that involve our lives and health. I have met some energetic therapists who I would personally like to see stop doing what they are doing. Then again, I’ve seen quite a few mainstream physicians that I would like to see out of practice also. The same goes for lawyers, politicians, religious leaders, bankers, salespersons, and Mr. and Mrs. Anybody. No organization, profession, or group is free of a dark side. If you have had a negative experience with energetic therapy, that is very unfortunate, but an unavoidable fact of life which one must reckon with.
My question to your organization is “what is the source of your negativity?” [What "organization"?] The strength of your attacks only points a red flag to a strong emotional and/or political response, not an objective question. Many mainstream physicians feel very threatened by a practice which they perceive as challenging their power and economic viability. Is your quest to debunk TT based on patient dissatisfaction, lawsuits against practitioners, or moral misbehavior?
(That’s easy: “moral misbehavior.” Quackery is immoral; TT is quackery. What also disturbs me is the profound anti-intellectual tone of that paragraph: the “strength of [my] attacks…points to a strong emotional and/or political response…” Actually, the strength of my argument (“attack” is in the mind of the beholder) is in its reasoning. Apparently, a reasoned rejection of TT demonstrates that reason itself is “the source of my negativity.” That’s literally true, of course, but by “negativity” she probably meant meanness, not merely a reasoned, “negative” conclusion. So if reason leads to rejection, we can’t allow it. It’s just too mean-spirited.)
Can you even find a group of dissatisfied patients who would be willing to to exert the amount of energy you have, to rid society of energetic therapy?
(In 1800 it probably would have been difficult to find a group of dissatisfied patients willing to exert energy to rid the world of bloodletting, purging, and scalding. So what? Determining safety and efficacy isn’t a popularity contest.)
TT is at best, a natural, non-invasive, economical, humanistic form of therapy, and; at worst, a benign, well-intended, caring action which makes people feel more at peace.
No, at worst, and in all likelihood, it’s an expensive hoax that gives false hope to desperate patients and further confuses a scientifically illiterate public, as does every other form of quackery. Consider the claims of efficacy for TT (from Rosa et al):
Back to Ms. Hutchison:
Time will tell. Energetic therapy is not (to my knowledge) an evangelical, preaching group of therapists trying to force this work down anyone’s throat.
(To my knowledge that’s an accurate description. For more evidence, see the very next edition of the Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo.)
The usual course of events is that people hear about it and pursue receiving the work or studying it. Yet the work is growing rapidly (without expensive ads in medical journals like the pharmacology companies) and with professionalism and the sense of the scientific. I am willing to be further engaged in a personal conversation with you, one person to another, if you have a mindset of openness and respect. Otherwise, I suggest that we agree to disagree. We are not enemies Kimball, we just see things differently and have different experiences. I understand how you feel because I’ve been there myself, trained as a left-brain scientist who wanted proof for everything. Although I’ve figured out a few things, I still see myself as terribly ignorant in so many ways.
Thanks for taking the time to write and listen. I hope you’re enjoying the spring.
Peace. Cynthia
Whew! I thought about replying to this in detail, discussing everything from the irrelevancy of ad hominem remarks to a reiteration of the physics issue, but I decided there was no point. She was so far from being grounded in rational thinking that it seemed hopeless. This was confirmed by an e-mail from her that followed closely on the heels of the previous one:
Subject: Fwd: THE GREAT EXPERIMENT
Dear Kimball, I thought you might be interested in this.
This came through the Healing Touch email and we thought you might be interested in participating:
Hello Friends! Don’t know if you’ve seen the following notice, but it looks like a fascinating opportunity to take part in a very large international project on the power of focused prayers for peace. You can do it wherever you are… or, if you would like to join us on April 23, please call 657-8837 and leave a message. We’ll be holding a small gathering at our house. All the best… and we’ll be in touch soon about some other matters.
Eric & Pearl
THE GREAT EXPERIMENT
Here’s the Question: Can millions of people, focusing their minds on inner and world peace, heal the world in an instant? Can we, through scientific and quantifiable means, prove that we are indeed the creators of the world we perceive, and that by changing our perception, the world itself changes? This is “The Great Experiment.” It’s time we prove scientifically what the saints and sages have always told us that we are powerful spiritual beings with the ability to create a world based on the laws of love, instead of the rules of fear. With the help of scientists, we are about to put an end to doubt forever.
Two months ago, James Twyman, author of the bestselling book, “Emissary of Light,” was invited by the government of Iraq to perform his “Peace concert” in Baghdad. The situation seemed desperate war seemed almost inevitable and diplomatic efforts seemed to have failed. “I was being used by the Iraqi government,” Twyman said. “But we had the same goal: to avoid this terrible war. I was given permission to sing the Muslim prayer for peace to Saddam Hussein and I wanted the world to join us in this prayer. Hundreds of thousands of people over the world participated, and when it was complete, I felt a profound shift in the energy of that whole region. Three days later, a peace agreement was signing, something which seemed impossible before the prayer vigil began.”
But The Story continues . . . “A week later, I was invited by the government of Northern Ireland to sing at Stormont Castle in Belfast – the building where the peace talks were being held. For days, bombs were exploding all around that area. Many people were trying to interrupt the peace process and it seemed like the talks might fall apart. Once again, thousands around the world joined us in prayer, and three days later there was a breakthrough in the talks. A peace agreement in May now seems inevitable.”
The evidence is there – we do have the power within us to change the world. Princeton scientist, Dr. Roger Nelson, has measured the statistically significant effect that focused meditations and events have upon the earth’s energy field. Dr. Nelson has measured these effects during the Gaia Mind Meditation and during Princess Diana’s funeral. His studies show that the greatest effects occur when groups synchronize their focus. During “The Great Experiment,” we will meditate upon specific affirmations in unison to achieve the power of a singular group focus.
NOW IT IS TIME TO PUT INTO PRACTICE WHAT WE ALREADY KNOW TO BE TRUE: “If enough people join their minds and hearts for peace, we can heal the world.” “The Great Experiment” will take place on April 23rd at 6:30 PM Eastern Time (This would be 10:30 PM GMT). Please mark your calendars now, and tell everyone that you know to join with us. James Twyman has been invited to sing the peace prayers from the twelve major religions at the United Nations building in New York on April 23rd. This presents an unparalleled opportunity for us all. Dr. Doreen Virtue, best-selling author of The Lightworker’s Way, and Gregg Braden, geologist and author of Awaken to Zero Point, join James in conducting this incredible experiment. Authors, entertainers, and other celebrities, will participate by sharing their vision of “a world transformed by love.”
Here’s how you can participate:
Tell everyone you know. Share this with everyone on your mailing list so that everyone can participate. Feel free to print this out and make copies. The goal is to get as many people focused on this meditation.
Begin preparing your spirit and mind for the event by spending a few moments in silence everyday. This will help build the energy.
Join at least one other person for the vigil on April 23rd. This is an experience to share. “Where two or more are gathered.”
The Format of the Meditation: We are asking everyone to follow this simple format during the meditation. As scientific studies at Princeton University show, the more focused a group meditation or event is, the stronger the effect.
Opening: Begin with this affirmation, said with great power and commitment: I am an Emissary of Light. I extend this Light to all beings, in compassion and love, knowing that they are one within me. this moment the world is healed – and I along with it. I will it – and it is so.
Then spend five minutes creating a sound (such as “Aum”) to carry the spiritual energy and vibration. This can be done with a single tone or by singing a song such as “Amazing Grace.”
Spend five minutes in silence allowing your spirit to receive the light and love which you yourself extended to the world.
End with this prayer: “It is done! I am one with all – and all is healed. Let love reign where fear once was. I accept this for myself and for the world. I am an Emissary of Light now and always. Amen” Then, with reverence, bow your head and thank God for this grand opportunity. The universe gives thanks to you for being part of this great experiment.
If you have any questions regarding this Great Experiment, please write: TheGreatExperiment@PeaceSeeds.com Healing Touch Canada, Inc. 75 The Donway West, Suite 1102, North York, ON M3C 2E9 416-449-3199 416-449-1962
Wow. At some point over the next few weeks I emailed Bela Scheiber of the Rocky Mountain Skeptics. I told him of my correspondence with Ms. Hutchison, and we decided that I would offer to her the possibility of collaborating with his group on a Rosa-like experiment. I did that; I’ve lost my email to her, but I still have her reply:
To Kimball Atwood, regarding our exchange on skepticism and the JAMA study.
Dear Kim,
I thank you for writing back to me. You have been on my mind since you wrote your first letter weeks ago. As HT research coordinator, I have been living and breathing this JAMA thing since right before the story broke. It led to lots of interviews with reporters, phone calls, emails, TV spots, etc. (Although I enjoyed my interviews with reporters, I was amazed at how often my words were misquoted or wrong information given…It gave me a whole new understanding on how media can fuel the fire of conflict!!) It was exciting for awhile, but part of me wants to tuck it away and put it to sleep, because I’m so far behind on all my other work, family life, and life in general. However, I am very grateful, very grateful, for some of the things it has brought to my life, including some wonderful new friends, conversations, interesting sharing, great humor, networking, planning, and growth. A part of me is very grateful to the Rosa’s b/c whenever this kind of thing happens, once we get through the chaos and emotion, the process leads to growth, inner and outer.
I personally am interested in some sort of collegial study and have been in conversation with some researchers about this. I have initiated a network of scientists regarding studies which would support our work and we are all in conversation right now. I will share your letter with them. This could take a fair amount of coordinating as everyones lives are so full, but it is an effort worth spending, I believe. I received a short, personal note from George Lundberg, editor of JAMA, who I believe was expressing an interest in a collegial effort also. I wrote back for clarification of what he was interested in, so perhaps he might like to be a part of this. I’ll get back to you as things arise. I may also be sending you some forwarded emails FYI. Thanks again for writing.
Warmly, Cynthia
PS I’d love to know where you live and what you do for a living…and any other background you’d like to share. Thanks.
I don’t know if she ever communicated with the Rocky Mountain Skeptics or if she was involved in any plans to repeat the Rosa experiment. I do know that there has been no such report. My memory fades after this, but I don’t believe that I responded to her last email or that she emailed me again. I don’t think I had the heart to keep it up. She seemed so ingenuous, so wrapped up in a magical fantasy, and so clueless; I’m convinced that the most I could have done was to hurt her feelings, if that. Regarding this HT Research Coordinator’s curious approach to how nature works, I guess I decided to embrace the mystery and let go of the need to understand.

Therapeutic Touch Pseudoscience: The Tooth Fairy Strikes Again
Harriet Hall on May 31, 2016
Link


A study out of Iran titled “Therapeutic touch for nausea in breast cancer patients receiving chemotherapy: Composing a treatment” was recently published in the journal Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice. It is a great example of the Tooth Fairy science that permeates much of the research in complementary and alternative medicine. In Tooth Fairy science, researchers attempt to study a phenomenon without first determining whether it exists.
What is therapeutic touch?
Therapeutic touch (TT) is a type of energy medicine; practitioners claim to be able to:
     1.  sense a patient’s “human energy field” with their hands,
     2.  manipulate the energy field by moving their hands near (but not touching) a patient’s skin surface, and
     3.  thereby improve the patient’s health.
TT was the delusional invention of a nurse and a theosophist, and it has no scientific basis. Scientists can detect and measure minute energies down to the subatomic level, but they have never detected a “human energy field.” And when TT practitioners were tested on their ability to detect such a field, they failed miserably.
“Therapeutic touch is pure vitalism, the belief in a soul or animating force,” writes Paul Ingraham, “exactly like the Force in Star Wars, and just as fanciful. Auras and life energy do not exist and cannot be felt, let alone manipulated therapeutically.”
Despite the combination of extreme implausibility and a total lack of evidence, TT is taught to nurses in many otherwise reputable institutions, and there are more than 90,000 practitioners worldwide. There is even a Therapeutic Touch International Association that claims TT is evidence-based. It is not.
TT practitioners believe they are helping patients. That belief is reinforced by seeing patients improve due to the natural course of illness, suggestion, and the “placebo” or nonspecific contextual effects of the provider/patient encounter. They allow confirmation bias to overcome scientific reality, and they do poorly-conceived research seeking further confirmation. Since the studies are designed to show that TT works rather than to ask if it works, they find evidence that is convincing to believers but not to the scientific community as a whole.
Study of TT for chemotherapy-induced nausea
Assumptions. The authors start with several questionable assumptions:
    • Humans are complex systems of patterned energy in continual process with the energy of their environments.
    • A person’s energy is a vital life force that permeates the individual and interpenetrates the energy of the universe.
    • In illness, there are imbalances in the patient’s energy field.
    • TT practitioners modulate the energy field through hand movements and mental imaging.
    • Nausea and vomiting are due to the disruption in energy balance in one of the body orbits.
This is meaningless pseudoscientific gibberish.
Methods. They studied 108 breast cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy. All patients were on the same chemotherapy regimen (Cyclophosphamide and Epirubicin) and the same antiemetic drugs (Dexametasone, Plasil, Kitril and Emend). They were randomly divided into three groups of 36 patients each. The test group got a standardized TT intervention “touching of first energy layer” (described in detail in Box 1 in the paper), the placebo group got the exact same intervention except that “the practitioner’s hands-to-patient’s body distance was different (more than 20 cm.) and in fact there was no energy transfer.” The control group got no intervention. A single practitioner performed all the treatments.
Findings. They report that the duration, frequency and intensity of nausea were significantly lower in the test group. They provide data for the mean duration of nausea in hours: Experiment 5.36, Placebo 10.81, and Control 10.01. They provide data on the frequency of nausea: Experiment 50.29, Placebo 31.44, Control 81.76. It’s interesting that nausea was less frequent with the placebo TT than with the “real” TT; they don’t comment on that. Although their abstract says the intensity of nausea was also significantly lower in the test group, they don’t provide any data for that. They mention that in 69.4% of women there was a need for re-intervention after reassessment phase, so if there was an effect it didn’t last very long.
Discussion. They comment on what they see as the strengths and weaknesses of their study. They mention a variety of other uses for TT: stress, anxiety, pain, positive effects on the cardiovascular and immune systems, wound healing, broken bones, joint mobility in arthritis, etc. They say their results can be extrapolated to the treatment of nausea in other diseases. They throw in some irrelevant comments about the alleged effectiveness of acupressure and foot massage in treating chemotherapy-induced nausea.
Their conclusions. Unsurprisingly, they believe their study establishes the efficacy of TT for treating nausea and vomiting. They recommend TT technique be taught as one of the main courses (!) in nursing schools and suggest that their research processes should be used to design education programs and standards of practice for TT practitioners.
Problems with this study
Since there is no evidence that the alleged energy field exists, there can be no evidence that a distance of greater or less than 20 cm makes a difference. Their claim that “in fact there was no energy transfer” in the placebo group is undoubtedly true, but it is presumably just as true in the TT group. The alleged energy can’t be measured, so they can’t show any evidence that there was energy transfer with TT; they can only imagine it. Since there was a single practitioner, one wonders whether she might have inadvertently given the patients some signal that the placebo intervention was not the standard one. One wonders about the patients’ beliefs and whether they could tell whether they were in the TT or the placebo group.
In studies like this, doing anything always works better than doing nothing, so of course the no-treatment control group did not fare as well. A competent peer reviewer should have insisted the authors present data for their claim about the intensity of nausea, and should have questioned a number of other things. A rigorously science-based editor would not have published it. There are many things that can go wrong in clinical research to lead to incorrect conclusions; we know that half of all studies are wrong, and we can assume that Tooth Fairy studies on nonexistent phenomena are even more likely to be wrong.
The skeptical conclusion about this therapeutic touch study
Nausea has always been a problem with chemotherapy. The anti-emetic medications in current use have proven very helpful, but they are costly and have side effects. It would be great if alternative treatments like TT or acupressure or foot massage could reduce or eliminate the need for medications. But there’s no credible evidence that they can. Some might argue for using them as placebos, but medical ethicists universally condemn that practice.
Therapeutic touch is a fantasy. Even doing well-designed clinical studies of it would be silly. The results of a poor quality trial like this can be disregarded as meaningless. The only useful study of TT would be to investigate the psychology of how the practitioners are able to fool themselves and their patients.

“Imbalanced Energy Field” is not a valid diagnosis and therapeutic touch is pseudoscience, so why can’t nurses just give it up?
“Imbalanced Energy Field” is not a valid diagnosis and therapeutic touch is pseudoscience. It’s past time nursing gave up both.
Jann Bellamy on August 12, 2021
Link

A recent nursing journal article reported the results of a rapid evidence assessment of therapeutic touch (TT) research, concluding:
No high-quality evidence was found for any of the benefits claimed.
This is, of course, no surprise to anyone. Therapeutic touch, a form of so-called “energy medicine“, is pseudoscience. What is surprising, and frankly disturbing, is the authors’ report that therapeutic touch
remains actively taught in many North American Colleges and in contemporary nursing literature and nurse education. A diagnosis of “Imbalanced Energy Field” is also included in the current North American Nursing Diagnosis (NANDA) manual [2018 ed.] . . .
The authors, Bernie Garrett, RN, PhD, and Marliss Riou, MSN, both of the University of British Columbia School of Nursing, undertook a rapid evidence assessment, covering 2009-2020, of studies exploring therapeutic touch as an intervention.
As background, the authors include a description of the alleged mechanism of action for therapeutic touch, its foundational assumption being that all humans possess “a massless human bio-energy field” within which “there may be balance which produces good health, or there may be an imbalance which may result in illness”. Practitioners claim they can, with their hands, but without actually touching the person, detect and manipulate a person’s energy biofield to “stimulate the body’s natural ability to heal itself” and to bring the energy biofield into better balance. The authors note that this idea of a metaphysical life force is prevalent in many cultures as well as in contemporary pop-culture, the “force” in Star Wars being one example.
(The latter might give an enterprising charlatan inspiration for a new form of “energy medicine”: the “force”. As with Oriental medicine, costumes could play a role in creating a theatrical placebo.)
Obviously, the authors continue, these notions “are in direct conflict with contemporary physics and biomedical science”. As well, “no underlying anatomical structures or physiology associated with the proposed human biofield energy has been identified” and it has not yet been proven to exist. The answer to this criticism, at least from some proponents, is that “the proposed energy is spiritual in nature and said to exist outside of” contemporary scientific knowledge.
The article contains a detailed discussion of the authors’ rationale for using the rapid evidence assessment, their methods, and their assessment of the studies, but we’ll skip to the end. (The article is open-access, so feel free to dig in.) Their conclusion:
After 45 years of study, scientific evidence of the value of TT as a complementary intervention in the management of any condition still remains immature and inconclusive:
    • Given the mixed result, lack of replication, overall research quality and significant issues of bias identified, there currently exists no good quality evidence that supports the implementation of TT as an evidence-based clinical intervention in any context.
    • Research over the past decade exhibits the same issues as earlier work, with highly diverse poor quality unreplicated studies mainly published in alternative health media.
As the nature of human biofield energy remains undemonstrated, and that no quality scientific work has established any clinically significant effect, more plausible explanations of the reported benefits are from wishful thinking and use of an elaborate theatrical placebo.
The authors then take their fellow nurses to task:
Given the deficiency of quality research evidence, it remains somewhat puzzling why nursing organizations and textbooks continue to support TT . . . as no other faith-based interventions have gained similar traction in nursing literature. The support of poor quality and biased research is clearly problematic and could affect the wider scientific credibility of the profession.
[Citations omitted.]
And, in a refreshing change from the typical “further research is needed”:
Without basic research, further clinical studies will present similar issues, and given the resources expended to date with no tangible evidence, similar work would seem unjustified.
If any research is to be done, the authors say, it should be to “establish a validated theoretic framework”:
As the claims TT practitioners make for, and their ability to detect a human biofield energy field can easily be tested with well-controlled practical experiments (as Emily Rosa attempted to do in 1998), it appears at best inept, and at worst disingenuous that this has not occurred to date.
[Link added.]
Indeed! And let’s apply this same reasoning to the entire universe of so-called alternative medicine: Before one more study is done, or one more penny is spent on research, let’s require other iterations of energy healers, acupuncturists, subluxation-based chiropractors, naturopaths, homeopaths, ayurvedic practitioners, and all the rest, to “establish a validated theoretical framework” for their particular brand of metaphysics.
“Imbalanced Energy Field”
The organization credited with creating the imbalanced energy field diagnosis cited by Garrett and Riou is NANDA International (formerly known as the North American Nursing Diagnosis Association). NANDA’s mission is, according to its website: “To facilitate the development, refinement, dissemination and use of standardized nursing diagnostic terminology”, meaning, in part, that “[w]e provide the world’s leading evidence-based nursing diagnoses for use in practice and to determine interventions and outcomes.”
NANDA publishes Nursing Diagnoses: Definitions & Classification, which it describes as “the definitive guide to nursing diagnoses”. According to NANDA, a nursing diagnosis (which is different than a medical diagnosis) is a
clinical judgment concerning a human response to health conditions/life processes, or vulnerability for that response, by an individual, family, group, or community.
As a 2013 NANDA blog post explains, “disturbed energy field” became an accepted nursing diagnosis in 1994. Upon receipt of some complaints about the diagnosis, including one from the late James Randi, NANDA undertook a review of the evidence, committing to apply its 2008 “Level of Evidence” criteria in doing so. “Disturbed energy field” was then removed from the 2015-2017 Nursing Diagnoses: Definitions & Classification (10th edition), only to reappear as the diagnosis “imbalanced energy field” in the 11th edition, covering 2018-2020. “Imbalanced energy field” is categorized under “Domain 4. Activity/rest” in the subcategory “Class 3. Energy Balance”, which includes only two other diagnoses, “Fatigue” and “Wandering”. According to the Table of Contents in the new 12th edition of Nursing Diagnoses (2021-2023), none of this has changed. (I do not have access to the publication itself.)
So much for the “Level of Evidence” criteria review and “evidence-based nursing diagnoses”.
A nursing text, Handbook of Nursing Diagnosis (14th edition 2013), which employs the NANDA taxonomy of diagnoses, uses the term “disturbed energy field”, stating what is described as the NANDA definition thusly,
Disruption of the flow of energy surrounding a person’s being that results in disharmony of the body, mind and/or spirit.
The “Defining Characteristics” of this diagnosis are a “perception of changes in patterns of the energy flow”, including temperature change, visual changes (e.g., color); “disruption of the field” (e.g., “vacant, hole, spike, bulge, obstruction, congestion”); movement (e.g., “tingling, dense”); and sounds. The diagnosis supposedly has “related factors”, characterized as “pathophysiologic”, that is, “related to slowing or blocking of energy flows secondary to” an illness, pregnancy, or injury, or “situational”, that is, related to slowing or blocking of energy flow secondary to pain, fear, grieving or anxiety. There are more, but you get the idea: illness, fear, and so on cause energy flow blockages that are detected by temperature change, tingling, and so forth.
According to the Author’s Note, “some may consider this diagnosis unconventional”.
No kidding!
But such considerations are waved off by the author, a nurse, who tells her fellow nurses that “there are many theories, philosophies, and frameworks of nursing practices” and “nursing diagnosis should not represent only mainstream nursing”. Nurses, rather, “should celebrate diversity” because “[f]undamentally, nurses are all connected though the quest to improve the condition of individuals, families, groups, and communities”.
This, of course, could be used as a rationale for just about any practice, no matter how implausible or lacking in evidence.
While “specialized instruction” is necessary for performing therapeutic touch, the Handbook describes some of the steps for those unfamiliar with the practice, including:
    • Scan the client’s energy field for openness and symmetry.
    • Sense the cues to energy imbalance . . .
    • Note the energy flow over lower legs and feet.
    • Briefly shake your hands to dispel congestion from the field if needed.
    • When therapeutic touch is complete, place your hands over the solar plexus area . . . and focus on facilitating the flow of healing energy to the client.
State-approved continuing education courses in “energy healing” (including therapeutic touch) for nurses abound. In my state, Florida, a nurse can take, for CE credit:
    • Energy Medicine Therapies: Therapeutic Touch, Healing Touch, Reiki, Reflexology, And Craniosacral Therapy
    • The Biofield (Human Energy Field): Foundations For Energy Medicine
    • Alternative Medicine In Rehabilitation: Energy-Based Therapies
Nurses can also get, again for CE credit, a “Certificate in Energy Medicine”. The course description begins:
Increasingly, scientific evidence shows that human beings are comprised of an energetic system that is highly integrated with the physical body, emotions, and the spirit.
“Scientific evidence” has shown no such thing.
Bernie Garrett, the lead author of our therapeutic touch review, posted this comment to the 2013 NANDA blog post:
Having a NANDA diagnostic statement of “Disturbed Energy Field” is about as much use as a diagnosis of “Feeling a bit under the weather.” Come on, this makes nurses look ridiculous. Time that NANDA got a grip on this situation.
James Randi himself, an instigator of complaints about the diagnosis, also commented on the 2013 NANDA blog post:
While accepting and agreeing with [another commenter criticizing the concept of a “human energy field”, or HEF], I’ll simplify the situation somewhat. The James Randi Educational Foundation offers our $1 million dollar prize to anyone – TTP [therapeutic touch practitioner] or not – who can simply show that they can detect the HEF. It’s that easy. No arguments, no fuss, no scientific or supernatural theories required. Do it, and walk away with the $1,000,000 prize. My experience in the quackery field tells me that NANDA-I will never come to grips with the HEF situation, but will continue to promote this attractive-but-false delusion. Please prove me wrong.
NANDA never took him up on the challenge and time has proven him right.
If nurses want to claim that “imbalanced energy field” is a valid diagnosis and therapeutic touch is effective, they must be able to defend it with a plausible mechanism of action and evidence of effectiveness. If they claim these are solely spiritual concepts, then they need to be clear that this is the basis on which they are offering their services, as it may conflict with the patient’s religion or belief system. In either case, whether lack of evidence or lack of full disclosure, it is unethical to do otherwise.

“Magic Socks?” Alternative Medicine’s Obsession With Your Feet.
Clay Jones on October 9, 2015
Link


I recently received an email from none other than Jann Bellamy pointing out a particular flavor of naturopathic nonsense that I had missed up until this point: “magic socks.” A quick search revealed that our own Scott Gavura had briefly mentioned this remedy in a 2013 post, but I plan on going into much greater detail. The claim contained in the newsletter attached to Jann’s email involved the use of said magic socks to “alleviate congestion.” Three links were thoughtfully provided for more information and I took the bait. Thanks Jann.
That’s right, magic socks!
The first link took me to the website of Bastyr University, where Britt Hermes matriculated to the tune of $300,000 and a leader in “innovation in natural health education” that offers numerous degrees in “science-based natural medicine.” According to the experts at Bastyr, wet sock treatment, apparently synonymous with “magic socks”, is “a natural method of stimulating the immune system and zapping a cold or flu” that involves forcing a child to don ice-cold socks overnight. They even admit that this is a treatment approach recommended regularly by the naturopathic physicians at Bastyr Center for Natural Health.
According to the chief medical officer at BCNH (seems like there should be an asterisk there or something), we shouldn’t be thrown by how much this sounds like complete and utter nonsense, because it works. He reassures us that magic socks “rally the body’s defenses” using the healing power of nature. And it’s free! All you need is water, socks, a freezer, and some electricity. Okay, so it isn’t free but it’s pretty darn cheap.
He explains that the underlying mechanism of action is something known as “heating compress.” The body, forced to deal with literal cold feet, must act to counteract the thermal challenge. In the process of restoring homeostasis to the ill child’s little piggies, blood circulation is increased and the immune system is stimulated, “revved up” for an epic battle with the invading infectious organisms.
Somehow, they claim, this also decreases nasal and chest congestion. And, while the immune system is in berserker mode thanks to the application of cold water to Timmy’s feet, there is a sedating action on the brain. According to Bastyr, many patients report improved sleep during the treatments. Or maybe they just don’t want to lose another toe to frostbite so they tell mommy what she wants to hear. And as if that weren’t enough, the aptly-named magic socks provide effective pain relief for a variety of complaints such as migraine headaches and sore throat, while also reducing inflammation.
Magic socks work best when applied at the first hint of a possible illness, and should be repeated for three consecutive nights. They caution readers with chronic conditions or compromised immunity to consult with a doctor first, however. After all, as Chief Wallace points out, wet socks are just one aspect of integrative care. It would be folly to ignore the expert use of “immunity-boosting supplements.” Do not taunt the magic socks.
Magic socks aren’t so magic
The magic socks choose the patient. It’s not always clear why. But I think it is clear that all we can expect from them is prune feet.
-Mr. Ollivander…I think
Regular readers of Science-Based Medicine have likely already picked up on some very common themes found in so-called natural medicine provided by naturopathic physicians. “Boosting the immune system” is a nearly ubiquitous claim that sounds like a great idea but falls apart under even light scrutiny. The immune system is an extremely complicated mechanism defined by the complex interaction of a variety of cellular and structural components rather than a singular entity that can be boosted by chilly toes or, as is also frequently claimed, suppressed by environmental toxins.
Which aspect of the immune system is “boosted” by magic socks? Innate or adaptive processes? Natural killer cells or lymphocytes? Complement or immunoglobulin levels? Furthermore, it is the immune system which is largely responsible for the initial symptomatology of most infections. Logically, revving it up might make a child feel worse or cause a complication from an otherwise self-limited viral infection (not to mention any autoimmune conditions). I find the concept of “boosting the immune system” and increasing blood flow, while also suppressing inflammation, which is a consequence of normal immune function and circulation, laughable.
Naturopaths like to keep these pronouncements vague because they don’t have any clue what they are talking about. And they expect the public to just take their word for it. All the while they hide their ignorance behind distracting marketing terms and compelling philosophical subterfuge. It’s a house of cards, easily brought down at any point by a patient who is truly ill.
Prevention is better than cure as long as it’s not a vaccine
Another common theme seen in the recommendations of worthless remedies like magic socks, is that the treatment must be initiated at the first hint of symptoms. This is very convenient considering that most of the time when people think that they might be coming down with something they aren’t. They are just tired or suffering from some other manifestation of chronic life syndrome, or have a mild and self-limited process like a cold, upset stomach, or headache. Naturally the ability to accurately predict the onset of an actual illness is even more limited when doing it for someone else, like a child or a hamster. Regardless, without proper scientific skepticism, it’s easy to see why people think that inert interventions have efficacy.
If more significant symptoms that are easily attributable to an infectious illness do develop, the weasel words included in the recommendations for magic socks don’t disappoint. Most self-limited infections in kids peak at around the third day. Even the dreaded “strep throat” starts to improve by day four even without treatment with antibiotics. So it’s easy to imagine a parent or patient with expectation of benefit from magic socks giving them credit after the recommended 3 nights of application, when in reality regular socks (or even more revolutionary – no socks at all!) would have sufficed. And if they don’t appear to be working, there is the convenient excuse that the treatments just weren’t started soon enough.
A look at the “research”
I was unable to find any helpful evidence regarding the use of cold feet to treat symptoms from an infection or improve recovery rates. The initial newsletter sent to me by Jann did include a link to a paper published in the North American Journal of Medical Sciences, which I’m not familiar with, to support the use of magic socks. I wasn’t impressed with the journal or the paper, which is a review of the evidence in support of the effects of hydrotherapy on a variety of conditions.
The authors of the paper come to the conclusion that hydrotherapy, in all its various forms ranging from a soak in a hot tub to colon cleansing, is helpful for everything. But nobody knows how it works, so “further studies are required.” According to the authors, colon cleansing can improve the mental state of patients with schizophrenia, which raises serious concerns about their ability to science.
The only mention of the feet, however, is a reference to a 1995 study published in Russian which found that localized exposure to cool water improved bronchial patency. Considering their evidence base, combined with a complete lack of plausibility, it’s safe to say that magic socks aren’t magic. They’re just mean.
Alternative medicine’s obsession with your feet
Magic socks are nonsense, but apparently fairly popular. I easily found numerous endorsements from parents online, including former classmates on Facebook, and even more websites from individual natural medicine practitioners recommending them. But the apparent infatuation with the feet in the world of irregular medicine doesn’t stop there.
Reflexology
Arguably the king of foot-based alternative medicine is reflexology. We all recognize that a good foot massage feels rather pleasant, and that a relaxing experience on the regular probably confers some non-specific benefits, be they from stress reduction or non-pharmaceutical distraction/altered perception. In the mind of the reflexology proponent, however, a foot massage done the right way can benefit not only overall health but also specific organ systems and diseases.
I’ve written about reflexology in the past, as has Dr. Crislip. But only my post includes the following quote, taken from an episode of Penn & Teller: Bullshit!, which I feel compelled to include:
Through Reflexology you can get someone to relax, the immune system can then respond to the crisis, and you don’t have to die! It’s way more than just a foot message that makes you feel good. It’s something that triggers the electrical aspect of the body’s self-healing processes.
Who needs magic socks when you have the Electro Reflex Energizer machine!
Acupuncture and acupressure
Not to be outdone, there is a special focus on the feet in acupuncture as well. There are several acupuncture/acupressure points on or near the feet that correspond to distant areas of the body. Still none on the genitals, though. Not even for treating herpes.
Chiropractic
Some chiropractic practitioners, sensing that the niche hadn’t quite been filled, also treat fictitious disorders of the feet. Yes, there are subluxations of the tiny bones in our distal lower extremities. Chiropractic clinics have even popped up that are especially devoted just to your barking dogs.
Detox foot pads and baths
Any post discussing alternative medicine and feet must include mention of detox foot pads and ionic foot baths. Despite being thoroughly debunked almost a decade ago, these treatments are still recommended by some practitioners of naturopathy.
If only it were silly walks
I’ll finish up with what are, in my opinion, the silliest approaches to improving health via the feet. Which is a tremendous waste of silly things we could do with our feet.
Bare feet?
Proponents of earthing believe that the connection of bare feet to the surface of the planet allows its healing primordial electrons to flow into our bodies. Shoes are seen as an evil source of poor sleep, pain, chronic disease, and “general unwellness. Joe Mercola is a big fan of making money off of this stuff.
Onion feet?
Have you ever heard that putting raw onion slices in your socks while you sleep at night can help treat cold and flu symptoms? Yes, this is a thing, and is surprisingly old. How does it work? By removing toxins and waking up dormant meridians of course. This video shows a mother trying out the onion sock remedy for her child, who has a headache and a high fever. After an hour of persistent fever despite the onions, her mother reaches for the Tylenol and her daughter is then shown happily eating breakfast the next morning. Guess which treatment is given “two thumbs up?”
Vick’s VapoFeet?
The winner for the silliest form of foot-based medicine is the application of Vick’s VapoRub at bedtime. This is actually a common home remedy, and I’ve even heard pediatricians recommending it to parents. As with onions, there is rock bottom plausibility. Vapor rub is not a systemic or even a topical treatment. At best, and it’s a stretch, it provides some distraction when rubbed on the upper lip or chest and the fumes are inhaled. This 2010 study in pediatrics, which employs a very creative yet useless means of blinding, is about as good as the evidence gets.
Why are feet such a common focus of alternative medicine and home remedies?
I don’t have a great answer for why feet are such a big deal in the world of medical nonsense. It’s much easier to tease out the slimy tactics of those promoting it and the understandable reasons why patients and parents might believe that it works. My hunch is that it is likely a simple explanation rather than some deep philosophical or cultural reason.
A foot massage feels good, thus helping to activate certain placebo responses, and feet are easily accessible. And we do tend to place a lot of importance on the function and health of our feet because relatively minor issues can lead to significant changes in our quality of life. Regardless of why they are prominently featured, alternative medicine yet again is revealed to be a clump of random oddities that are really only connected by a shared absence of science and skepticism. If you want an effective means of preventing illness and improving your life using your feet, go for more walks.

Socks to Treat High Blood Pressure?
Socks that lower blood pressure? The claims for Boliav socks are too incoherent to make sense of. I can’t take them seriously.
Harriet Hall on March 15, 2022
Link

Speaking of her childhood home in Oakland, Gertrude Stein famously said “There’s no there there” because the house no longer existed. The phrase has come to mean that nothing significant exists in that place. And that’s just what I found when I looked for information about Boliav Therapeutic Detox Socks and their claim to lower high blood pressure. There was “no there there”, no significant information, nothing that I could wrap my head around. My computer suggested I might want “Bolivia socks”. That probably would have made more sense.
The claims:
    • Say good-bye to high blood pressure.
    • Experience the comfort and the benefits of foot reflexology with the Therapeutic Detox Foot Socks. Made with scattered nanometer sizes tourmaline particles that work as acupuncture proved its ability for healing benefits, particularly decreasing blood pressure on the spot.
    • It is a non-invasive method that helps to remove energy blockages and imbalances. This area points on foot are the best acupoint for lowering blood pressure.
But wait! There’s more! It regulates blood flow, regulates the nervous system, relieves insomnia, relieves leg pain and leg fatigue, aids digestion, relieves stress, and is “suitable in low temperatures”. All that while fixing your blood pressure without medications! Such a deal!
Confusingly, the socks are also said to be magnetic, and the claims for the socks segue into claims for a hypertension laser device: “Before lasing, put a light guide plug on the therapeutic head and then put the therapeutic head into the nasal cavity. Simply wrap it around your wrist. and let it do its work.” Whaaat?
They offer not a speck of evidence to support these claims. According to. Stephen Barrett on Quackwatch, “Reflexology is based on an absurd theory and has not been demonstrated to influence the course of any illness”. I’m not going to waste my time on this nonsense. I will simply dismiss it. As Christopher Hitchens said, “That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence”.
Sure, a foot massage may feel good, but I find it appalling that customers are buying these products on the basis of such incoherent marketing. My cardiologist has been adjusting my meds trying to get my BP under better control. He has not suggested detox socks and if he did, I’d probably laugh all the way to a new cardiologist.

   Reflexology. Insert Nancy Sinatra Reference Here.
Mark Crislip
Link
In the last post on acupuncture, I noted that the University of Maryland offered reflexology along with other supplements, and complementary and alternative medicine (SCAMs). I was uncertain as to the particulars of this SCAM, and this post is a result of those investigations.
Although messy in reality, science is a tool that gives us an idea as to how the real world functions. People will observe some aspect of nature, often for a lifetime, and from those observations discover a pattern in the data. Tycho Brahe spent a life carefully measuring the orbits of the planets; the data was used later by Kepler to determine that the planets orbit in an ellipse with the sun at one of the foci. If you have knowledge of the history of science, you realize what an amazing feat this represents, both in the measurement of the orbits and the analysis of the data. Careful observation, analysis of the data, then conclusions.
This is in contrast to SCAMs, where so many of the interventions are discovered by revelation, and then developed independently of data and observation. Palmer and chiropractic, von Peczely and iridology, Usui and reiki are examples. These geniuses discovered aspects of existence unseen by anyone before or after.
In that time honored pantheon is Dr. William Fitzgerald who, at the turn of the last century, “discovered” that the human body is divided into 10 longitudinal energy zones that end in the hands and the feet. By massaging these zones, you could heal disease and alter bodily functions. These are reminiscent of the meridians of acupuncture, and will soon be illustrated in the New England Journal of Medicine (see posts Aug 4 and 13). Fitzgerald named it Zone Therapy, and it went by that name until the 1960′s, when Eunice Ingham decided that, since all the energy zones ended in the feet, that it was the terminus of the energy zones that was the important aspect of Zone Therapy.
The body, it turns out, is far more crowded that we could ever have expected from our understanding of gross anatomy and histology. There is so much packed into our bag of meat, I am surprised that we do not explode, although perhaps we do have a potential explanation for spontaneous human combustion: the friction of all the projections and energy channels described by various SCAM’s rubbing together in a tight space.
There is the map projected on the iris with iridology, the maps on the ear, the tongue, the head, the hand, and the feet of the various acupuncture styles. There are the meridians of acupuncture and zone therapy, the energy flows of reiki and chiropractic. And there is the map of the body projected onto the feet and hands by reflexologists. The feet must be particularly crowded as the maps for foot acupuncture are different than the maps for reflexology; no wonder my feet ache at the end of the day.
Reflexologists are of the opinion that by manipulating the feet, hands and/or ears that correspond to body parts they can induce changes in those body parts. Touch the liver zone on the foot, alter the liver in the abdomen. Alexander Pushkin could vouch for the veracity of a subset of those interventions. Others are of the opinion that the manipulation of the feet, hands and/or ears alters the qi balance in the patient. However, as the Reflexology Association of American notes, “no one definition that will work in all situations and yet, because of the multi dimensional affect [sic] of Reflexology, all are true at [sic] defining the work we do. ”
And it is true, these definitions are limiting, as they do not encompass … well, let’s be nice and call them the curious concepts describing reflexology:
The purpose of the nerves is to carry messages and instruct the body. When the nerves improve that instruct the body, the instruction has to improve, the body has to improve. Every nerve in the body begins and ends in the hands and feet. By applying this specialized exercise pressure on the foot, the outcome is improved instruction to each and every part of the body, resulting in a re-educating, a re-patterning, and a re-conditioning of the nerves& instruction through the reflex/neutral electrical system of the body…also every lymphatic vessel begins and ends in the hands and feet.
The hands and feet are crowded indeed. Safe to say that the basic premises of reflexology have no bearing in reality. There are not projections of the body onto the hands and feet. As I have mentioned in the past, when I was a child I thought the Broadway in Portland was the same Broadway in New York and that if I kept walking I would end up on the Great White Way. It is true, in a way, that the two Broadways are connected in the same way that the nerves in the foot are connected to the liver, but it takes more links to get from one to the other than to get to Kevin Bacon.
What can reflexologist treat? Near about anything; it depends only on the claim of the reflexologist. Like many SCAMs, reflexology can help all illnesses. I would not deny that it is relaxing and pleasant to have one’s feet massaged — er, reflexed? (Reflexologist emphasize they are not doing massage.) But does reflexology have any real effects on any pathological states? Besides sore feet? And, while we are on the topic, why doesn’t walking have the same effect as reflexology?
Reflexology has been tested in clinical trials. Here is an issue that really gripes my cookies, or maybe a severe case of jealousy re: alt med.
In the world of infectious disease, getting to test an intervention for human use is a long process. First they have to find a potential antibiotic, discover the chemical structure and mechanism of action. Then the antibiotic is tested against numerous strains of hundreds of pathogens to see if it works in the test tube. Then there are a variety of animal studies looking for safety and efficacy. Then graduated clinical trials, phase 1, phase 2, and, finally, phase 3, before the antibiotic is declared non-inferior to vancomycin in human soft tissue infection.
Reflexology, and all other alt med interventions, bypass all these steps and go straight to clinical trials. Someone can pull a therapeutic intervention out of, well, this is the SBM blog, let’s say thin air, yeah, thin air. They can pull an intervention out of thin air and the next thing you know, good money is being spent to see if it is effective, when, evaluating it on the basis of reality, it should have the same chance of being effective as more common substances found in, well, ‘thin air.’
So, ignoring the fact there is no reason to test the efficacy of reflexology, what has reflexology been found to be effective in treating? Almost nothing of note. It is not effective for post operative cortisol levels, head ache, asthma, post operative pain, cancer anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, pregnancy edema, low back pain, ovulation, and multiple sclerosis. It seemed to help pre-menstrual syndrome — so says the abstract which, I’m sure, accurately represents an unbiased and flawless experiment — but it did not even seem to help menopause symptoms.
What a hodgepodge of diseases. I thought aspirin was the wonder drug that worked wonders. The alleged near universality of reflexology, and other alt med interventions, is staggering. Imagine an antibiotic that not only treated all viruses, bacteria, fungi, and parasites but also infertility, headache, dementia and post op pain. Only alternative interventions have that kind of power. I am stuck looking for the underlying cause of a disease and targeting it with a specific intervention. How Western and reductionist of me.
While almost all individual studies show no benefit of reflexology, what would a systematic review reveal? The summation of nonsense, unfortunately, does not lead to validation of reflexology. Put all the small piles of nonsense together, you get one big pile of nonsense. The studies of reflexology are poorly done, with small sample size, and, not mentioned in the review, had no reason to be done in the first place.
Studies in breast cancer patients suggest to me that human contact is what it important, not the specific modality.
PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred and eighty-three women were randomized 6 weeks post-breast surgery to self-initiated support (SIS) (comparator intervention), SIS plus reflexology, or SIS plus scalp massage (control for physical and social contact). Reflexology and massage comprised eight sessions at weekly intervals. The primary end-point was 18 weeks post surgery; the primary outcome measure was the Trial Outcome Index (TOI) of the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy (FACT-B) – breast cancer version. The secondary end-point was 24 weeks post surgery. Secondary outcome measures were the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) and the Mood Rating Scale (MRS).
RESULTS: At primary end-point, massage, but not reflexology, was significantly better than SIS on the TOI. Reflexology and massage were both better than SIS for MRS relaxation. Massage was better than reflexology and SIS for MRS easygoingness. At secondary end-point, reflexology, but not massage, was better than SIS on the TOI and MRS relaxation. There were no significant differences between reflexology or massage. There were no significant between group differences in HADS anxiety and depression. Self-reported use of out of study complementary therapies indicated that this was unlikely to have a significant effect on findings.
Or this one:
…significant decrease in anxiety observed in this sample of patients with breast and lung cancer following foot reflexology suggests that this may be a self-care approach to decrease anxiety in this patient population.
Or in the demented:
The findings demonstrate that when receiving the reflexology treatment condition, as compared to the control condition, the residents demonstrated significant reduction in observed pain.
All groups whose underlying disease leads to less human contact. Have you hugged your demented, cancerous nursing home patient today? I didn’t think so.
Monkeys, and other animals, groom each other often with a marked reduction in stress. Touch is good, and one doesn’t need to wrap it up in pseudoscientific nonsense for it to beneficial. Well, maybe you do. Strange people offering to massage your feet because it feels good may be off-putting for some and could lead to the authorities being involved.
One doesn’t need the woo of reflexology (projected maps and altered qi) to recognize that people need and benefit from physical interactions. Like in the NEJM recently, demonstrating the tai chi was of benefit in fibromyalgia. Exercise helps fibromyalgia, and tai chi is a gentle form of exercise, so it’s no surprise tai chi was of benefit; so is yoga. The mystical magic adds nothing.
Oddly, no one seems to have tested reflexology as an intervention for foot pain, a common complaint, and reflexology could not decrease foot edema in pregnant females. One wonders, if reflexology can’t even help a foot problem, what good is it?
The irritable bowel syndrome study concludes
I want to conclude with a note of caution. Although the results of this study are quite clear, they should not be used to dismiss reflexology as a treatment option across the board, nor indeed to argue against the effectiveness of CAM as a whole. The simple fact is that we know very little about the effectiveness of very many treatment options in relation to very many conditions. Reflexology in particular remains not just under-researched but almost unresearched, something that is quite startling given the extent of its use.
This is somewhat mirrored in the systemic review:
…the paucity and the poor quality of the existing studies prevents definitive judgement about the value of reflexology.
Well, technically, that’s true. But there is more than sufficient understanding about the workings of the human body to render a definitive judgement on reflexology. It won’t work because it can’t work, in much the same way that we know that a perpetual motion machine won’t work because it can’t work. And yet people keep inventing perpetual motion machines. Just because the rules of the universe say something is impossible doesn’t stop them from trying.
The great majority of studies demonstrate reflexology had no effects that could not be replicated by beyond picking fleas off your mate (am I over sharing?). And it has no anatomic or physiologic justification.
Years ago I was at a conference and one of my attendings was being detailed about a new antibiotic. The rep concluded with “and it’s very popular in Europe” to which my attending responded “so was fascism” and strolled off. Popularity is not a good justification to spending money and wasting patient’s limited time with nonsense.

Modern Reflexology: Still As Bogus As Pre-Modern Reflexology
Reflexology is a belief system based on imaginary connections between spots on the skin and internal organs. It has no basis in science.
Harriet Hall on April 10, 2018
Link

Reflexology is an alternative medicine system that claims to treat internal organs by pressing on designated spots on the feet and hands; there is no anatomical connection between those organs and those spots. Systematic reviews in 2009 and 2011 found no convincing evidence that reflexology is an effective treatment for any medical condition. Quackwatch and the NCAHF agree that reflexology is a form of massage that may help patients relax and feel better temporarily, but that has no other health benefits. Our own Mark Crislip said, “The great majority of studies demonstrate reflexology had no effects that could not be replicated by picking fleas off your mate…And it has no anatomic or physiologic justification.”
We recently received an email from a representative of Modern Reflexology asking if they could advertise their website on ours and offering to pay. Of course, we don’t accept advertising. But I was puzzled as to why they approached us and what they thought was science-based about reflexology. I was intrigued enough to visit their website to learn what “modern” reflexology was all about. I learned about a lot of specific claims I hadn’t heard before, but I found no science whatsoever. By writing this article, I am in a sense giving them the advertising that they asked for; but it will be negative publicity, not positive. Old adage: Don’t wish too hard for what you want; you might get it.
Reflexology or acupuncture?
Their website seems to conflate reflexology with acupuncture and acupressure. There are five tabs at the top of the home page: (1) Store, which links to a single Amazon.com page selling a reflexology foot massager, (2) Acupressure Points and (3) Reflexology Treatment, both of which have multiple articles on acupuncture and acupressure, (4) Reflexology Machines – foot massagers and acupressure mats, and (5) Courses. Notable by its absence is a tab for scientific studies showing that any of this stuff works.
There are articles on “Learn the Importance of Five Elements Theory in Acupressure – Dao, Yin Yang,” how acupuncture is effective for smoking cessation; why acupuncture is a form of preventive medicine; how acupuncture treats various skin conditions, seasonal allergies, emphysema, hemorrhoids, gallbladder disorders, and emotional syndromes; the healing effects of Qi in acupuncture; the Five Spirits that impact mental health (Hun, Shen, Yi, Zhi, and Po); and on and on.
Claims for specific conditions
Detoxification: 7 best acupressure points for complete detoxification of the body include the Great Rushing point on the webbing between the big and second toes, the Three Yin Crossing on the ankle, the Shu Mansion just below the collarbone, Union Valley on the hand, Inner Gate on the arm, Upper Sea of Qi on the sternum, and Lower Sea of Qi below the umbilicus. They claim that pressing on these points will flush out toxins, improve the immune system, reduce weight, prevent chronic diseases, and improve mental clarity.
Asthma: They say that pressing on 8 acupressure points on the collarbone, sternum, shoulder, thumb, wrist, and fingers will stimulate oxygen in the body and prevent asthma-related deaths.
Better eyesight: They claim that 7 acupressure points have been successful in treating short- and long-sightedness, cataract, glaucoma, presbyopia, astigmatism, amblyopia, diploma (I think they mean diplopia, double vision), color blindness, night blindness and many other eye disorders.
Diabetes: 6 points specified. One of them: “Place your fingers 2 centimeters below the knee, as shown in the picture. Massage this area with a little pressure for 5 minutes every day. It balances the digestive system. Diabetes is said to begin with stomach fire and proper digestion can reduce this problem. You will immediately see the result. This method is also used to prevent aging, arthritis and other forms of weaknesses.”
Hair loss: Massaging several acupressure points will “stimulate and energize the nerves that are causing the problem.” The Paihui is important. “The Paihui is located right in the middle of your scalp. Most of the pressure points related to the hair re-growth are present near this area. Take ten toothpicks and wrap them in a rubber band. Use them to gently poke the paihui, be very careful not to hurt yourself. This action improves the blood circulation in the scalp, which reduces hair fall.”
That’s enough to give you an idea of their claims. The website has many similar claims for other specific effects of acupressure and acupuncture.
What are these points?
A rose by any other name…Whether these are reflexology points or acupuncture points or acupressure points, there is nothing to suggest that they have any existence in anatomic or physiologic reality. How could these points have been determined to represent internal organs? Not by any controlled studies, but by uncontrolled imagination.
And there is no credible evidence that pressing on those points benefits health. The website is larded with terminology from acupuncture mythology and with unsupported claims for therapeutic applications. It’s obvious that none of this has anything to do with science. It is a belief system, and a rather confused one at that.
Conclusion: Whether ancient or modern, reflexology is still bogus
Christopher Hitchens famously said, “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.” I dismiss reflexology. In my opinion, it is a theatrical placebo with a soupçon of relaxing massage.

Reflexology for Babies?
Clay Jones on December 19, 2014
Link
In the fascinating, if not rational, world of so-called complementary and alternative medicine, the age of the patient rarely seems to matter. This stands in stark contrast to the practice of science-based medicine. Sure, there is some physiological overlap across the spectrum of age, but caring for children often requires a vastly-different approach and there are numerous conditions not seen or only seen in kids.
Alternative medicine is more about the underlying belief system rather than the actual physiology, however. Chiropractic is chiropractic whether the subluxation belongs to a neonate or a nonagenarian. In traditional Chinese medicine, the flow of chi is obstructed in youngsters and old fogeys alike. No matter the length of our telomeres in fact, every major form of alternative medicine appears to contain a subset of practitioners that claim unique expertise in maximizing health and wellbeing at any age. But for kids, they simply do the same thing they would do for an older patient.
Newborns appear to be an increasingly-popular target of irregular medical practitioners. Even the unborn baby still in their mother’s womb isn’t safe. A generous interpretation would be that these true believers simply wish to aid in establishing health early in a child’s life, while the cynic in me worries that establishing a lifetime of billing opportunities might be the primary motivating factor.
Chiropractic has perhaps the most well-established professional pediatric focus, although the Pediatric Association of Naturopathic Physicians might disagree. The chiropractic pediatric community has its own organizations, conferences and advanced education, which teaches interested parties the finer points of “Neonatal Abnormals” during an intense two-day session. A lack of evidence has not interfered with efforts to expand their role in pediatric healthcare, nor has plentiful high-quality evidence proving the safety and efficacy of routine childhood vaccines convinced many of them to support their use. The following, found on the website of one chiropractor that specializes in treating children, demonstrates nicely why pediatric chiropractic is problematic:
Chiropractic care for children, and patients of all ages, has repeatedly been shown to be one of the safest forms of health care available. This becomes even more apparent when compared with the “alternative” to chiropractic and wellness care, drugs. Most times drugs are not tested on children (rightfully so) and therefore pediatric doses are the doctor’s ‘best guess’ and often times can lead to dangerous and damaging side effects. That is not the case with chiropractic!
Acupuncture is performed on children, even in world class pediatric academic facilities like Boston Children’s Hospital. In an effort to replace prescientific beliefs with cutting edge science, while not stepping on any toes by outright denying the existence of meridians and mystical life energy, they provide the following “In-Depth” explanation for prospective customers:
Scientific research suggests that needling acupuncture points stimulates the body to release chemicals into the nervous system and into the bloodstream. These chemicals change the experience of pain and trigger the release of other chemicals which influence the body’s internal regulatory systems.
It’s hard to argue with chemicals. Chemicals do everything. I do wish they would be a bit more explicit in their description of how tiny needles in the skin induce the production of chemicals that help children with such varied conditions as post-operative pain, nausea, intestinal inflammation and constipation. At least at Boston Children’s there is an emphasis on proper precautions to prevent the spread of infectious disease via an acupuncture needle and to reduce the risk of traumatic injury. This isn’t always the case.
The use of homeopathy in the pediatric population is extremely common, particularly for self-limited and largely subjective problems like colic, teething and viral upper respiratory infections. Typically homeopathy comes in the form of over-the-counter remedies recommended by friends and family, or endorsed by celebrities and talk show hosts, but it can also be found offered in pediatric practices and even academic medical centers. Homeopathy also has an abysmal track record in regards to evidence of efficacy, and has the distinction of being the least plausible form of alternative medicine because it necessitates the violation of fundamental laws of physics. The competition for this honor was pretty stiff.
There is Reiki for kids, which is kind of like The Force but without the special effects. There are also innumerable herbal remedies recommended for children. The list really does go on and on. In fact, if it exists as a form of alternative medicine, it almost certainly has been used on a child. Even Biodanza, crystal healing, Iridology and urine therapy. Yes, urine therapy:
The easiest internal form of the therapy for children is oral drops of the child’s own fresh urine. As mentioned in the studies, for acute flu, colds, viral infections, measles, mumps, chicken pox, etc., small frequent oral doses of 1-10 drops during illness have been shown to be very effective. For allergies, the research studies indicate that several drops of fresh urine should be given orally before and after meals containing allergenic foods, or when allergic symptoms are present.
Links to “the studies” were unfortunately not provided on Master Mantak’s website.
In 2010, our own Mark Crislip wrote a post about one of the more absurd flavors of alternative medicine, but I first learned about reflexology from a segment on Penn and Teller’s television program on Showtime back in 2003. As Dr. Crislip describes in his post on the subject, plausibility and evidence are lacking. He rightfully questions why clinical trials even exist. Why do clearly nonsensical therapies, with as close to zero plausibility as allowed in science, get to skip the steps required by conventional medicine? Why are valuable resources wasted on seeing if magic and make-believe work? I was inspired to again kick over the rotten woodpile that is reflexology, to see what comes scurrying out, when a follower on Twitter sent me the picture I included at the onset of this post.
Reflexology for babies? It boggles the mind. And this coming from a physician who promotes skin-to-skin contact for babies on a daily basis. But first, just a little background.
What is reflexology?
The reflexologist featured in the Penn and Teller episode on alternative medicine had the following to say about his calling:
Through Reflexology you can get someone to relax, the immune system can then respond to the crisis, and you don’t have to die! It’s way more than just a foot message that makes you feel good. It’s something that triggers the electrical aspect of the body’s self-healing processes.
Boosting the immune system, the concept of a healing crisis, mysterious electrical processes within the body and self-healing are common themes in alternative medicine. And the ability to prevent death is a bold claim, but one we’ve seen before many times. But these claims seem particularly bold considering that to the untrained eye reflexology usually just looks like a foot or hand massage, albeit a fancy one.
Let’s not jump to conclusions. According to proponents, confusing reflexology with a simple massage is a common mistake. While massage, they reveal, is the manipulation of soft tissues to relax muscles, reflexology involves the manipulation of specifically mapped points on the feet (mostly) as well as the hands and ears to trigger healing reflexes in specific zones of the body. Massage involves a variety of techniques that bring about stress reduction from the outside in, while reflexology, again according to believers, works from the inside out by stimulating the body to heal itself.
Reflexology is natural of course. And holistic because it “stimulates the movement of energy along the nerve channels, and helps to restore homeostasis (balance) in the whole body.” And while a good massage typically involves the use of lotion or oil, reflexologists appear to eschew them. Friction is apparently an integral part of the process because it helps to break up the toxic crystals that have accumulated in reflex points and are interfering with the flow of healing energy. Uric acid crystal deposition in the skin seems testable, yet no evidence of this exists.
The maps used by reflexologists to guide their treatment are fairly straightforward. The right foot corresponds to the right half of the body, the left foot with the left half. If the client is having right shoulder problems, for example, you rub an area a bit below the pinky toe on the corresponding foot. There are many versions of these maps, with significant variability in complexity, but they do tend to agree with each other for the most part. Nonsense that is consistent is still nonsense, however. These maps have no basis in reality and serve as yet another testament to the ability of humans to notice patterns that don’t exist or to just make things up. The only thing accurate about them is that the liver area is only on the right foot, and the spleen is only on the left.
Reflexology’s origin story also shares common themes with other forms of alternative medicine. It has a grandiose historical pedigree. It was developed using ancient (prescientific) wisdom and was supposedly practiced thousands of years ago by ancient Egyptian, Chinese and Indian cultures. This belief is based on the finding of old pictures/carvings of feet with symbols on them. Naturally it was also used by some Native American tribes, and even President Garfield rubbed his feet after a long day in the Oval Office. Convinced?
But this ancient and powerful healing technique needed to be “rediscovered” a century ago by Dr. William Fitzgerald, a physician based in Connecticut and the father of reflexology. He noticed that the application of pressure to specific areas using a cotton swab resulted in numbing or relief of minor surgical pain in other areas. He went about mapping ten vertical zones of the body and discovered through trial and error (confirmation bias) what came to be knows as Zone Therapy. Five decades later, after a few other pioneers in this new therapy had the opportunity to tweak it by adding horizontal zones and additional focus on the hands and ears, we have modern day reflexology. When alternative medicine is updated like this, I always imagine a kid who thinks that his pinewood derby car will go faster after he paints some flames on the side.
What can reflexology treat?
Reflexology has pretty much been tried for everything. While tending to avoid claims of efficacy for specific conditions, reflexology is often touted as helpful for vague complaints like stress, fatigue and musculoskeletal pain. Typical structure and function benefits are also commonly cited, like boosting the immune system, increasing energy and improving organ or gland function. There are unfortunately still plenty of practitioners out there who do make specific health claims, such as helping diabetic patients reduce their dependence on insulin. The American Academy of Reflexology provides a detailed list of the largely-subjective proposed benefits, as well as the secrets of building a successful practice in less than a year.
Again I refer to Dr. Crislip’s post on the subject. He breaks down some of the best studies that proponents of reflexology have to offer and it isn’t pretty. There is no evidence to support that rubbing the feet positively impacts any medical conditions, but it might feel good like a massage so there’s that. Placebo effects achieved via reflexology certainly might alter a patient’s perception of their subjective symptoms, but there is no anatomical or magical link between the feet and the rest of the body than can be taken advantage of to improve our health.
The impetus for this post was my discovery that reflexology is now being used on newborn infants, although I’m not sure why this surprised me. As I stated earlier, when a therapy is based on a belief system rather than evidence, there would never be any qualms about using it on a child of any age. If one version is obviously dangerous, or scary to parents (think high-velocity chiropractic neck adjustments), just tweak the belief system a bit and maybe invent some kid friendly technology like the Activator. Although in the case of infants, it’s really being used on the parents. Not through some kind of surrogate therapy as in applied kinesiology, although I was able to find a few examples of that online, but rather via parental placebo.
The conditions for which reflexology is being promoted for newborns and young infants are essentially the same as with chiropractic, acupuncture and every other form of alternative medicine. Vague conditions like colic, gas, teething and trouble falling asleep are a common focus. Blaming birth trauma was also a common theme.
These are all highly-subjective parental complaints and usually a marker more of parental stress than a medical problem. They also wax and wane and tend to resolve spontaneously, a perfect set up for thinking a treatment works when it doesn’t. Thankfully I was unable to find any recommendations for reflexology to be used in truly ill children, and a run through Pubmed yielded no clinical trials involving reflexology and infants.
Conclusion
Our understanding of human physiology is the result of a hard-fought journey of discovery that has taken thousands of years and still isn’t complete. But we have learned a great deal about how the body works and how to change physiology in order to improve health. One aspect of our anatomy and physiology that is frequently encountered during training in pediatric medicine is the fact that children are not just little adults, and babies aren’t just tiny children. It would seem that practitioners of alternative medicine are unaware of this.
Every form of alternative medicine approaches children in the same fundamental way that they approach adults, a result of following belief and personal experience rather than science. And many have infiltrated even our most respected pediatric academic facilities. Reflexology is a perfect example of how irrational and implausible the overwhelming majority of alternative approaches can be, and also of the double standard that exists in medicine today. From acupuncture to quantum healing, if you think that the evidence base for these therapies is weak in adults, research in children is almost always even more pitiful. But as we have witnessed time and time again, scientific evidence only matters if it appears to support the belief system.

Bodytalk: Medical theater
Scott Gavura on December 20, 2012
Link
If there were an icon of Science-Based Medicine, I think it should be Sisyphus: pushing a boulder uphill, only to watch it roll down again. Forever. Blogging about pseudoscience in medicine can feel that way at times. There is no end to the variations of nonsense, most health professionals are indifferent at best, and sometimes I wonder if blogging is just preaching to the converted. Compared to the media presence and web traffic of those that promote pseudoscence, I do wonder what to make of SBM. Does it have a bigger impact. Occasionally something comes along to give you some hope that the key concepts of SBM are having some resonance.
To effect meaningful change, we need to teach the concepts of SBM – the process is the product, not the topics we blog about. This all came to mind as I was reading an open letter from TED organizers. TED talks are now iconic, but if you’re unfamiliar with them, the conferences started as a means of colliding speakers in the technology, entertainment and design fields to talk about big ideas. With a slogan of “ideas worth spreading,” perhaps it’s not surprising that TED talks can be provocative: that’s the point. TED talks are posted online and their success is remarkable: some talks get hundreds of thousands of views. The TED template has become so popular that it spawned TEDx, independent but licensed events that bring TED-like talks to smaller cities and venues. I’ve seen several TED talks and while many are compelling speakers, it’s clear the content is not always grounded in evidence. For all the talks by science advocates like Ben Goldacre, or James Randi, there’s the consciousnessbabble from Deepak Chopra. I’ve never seen TEDx presentations, but recently there’s been some very public criticism of its speaker standards. Anyone, it seems, can be a TEDx speaker including anti-GMO crusaders and naturopaths. Stung by recent criticism that the TED brand is losing credibility with its questionable presenters, TED HQ recently advised TEDx organizers to stop featuring pseudosicence:
It is your job, before any speaker is booked, to check them out, and to reject bad science, pseudoscience and health hoaxes.
Vetting your speakers is hard work, and can lead to uncomfortable moments. But as TEDx organizers, your audience’s trust is your top priority, over and above any other personal or business relationship that may have brought this speaker to your attention. It is not your audience’s job to figure out if a speaker is offering legitimate science or not. It is your job.
The consequence of bad science and health hoaxes are not trivial. As an example, Andrew Wakefield’s attempt to link autism and vaccines was exposed as a hoax last year. But while his work was being investigated, millions of children went without vaccines, and many contracted deadly illnesses as a result.
We take this seriously. Presenting bad science on the TEDx stage is grounds for revoking your license.
So what does TED consider bad science? They provide some tips:
Marks of good science:
    • It makes claims that can be tested and verified
    • It has been published in a peer reviewed journal (but beware… there are some dodgy journals out there that seem credible, but aren’t.)
    • It is based on theories that are discussed and argued for by many experts in the field
    • It is backed up by experiments that have generated enough data to convince other experts of its legitimacy
    • Its proponents are secure enough to accept areas of doubt and need for further investigation
    • It does not fly in the face of the broad existing body of scientific knowledge
    • The proposed speaker works for a university and/or has a phD or other bona fide high level scientific qualification
Marks of bad science:
    • Has failed to convince many mainstream scientists of its truth
    • Is not based on experiments that can be reproduced by others
    • Contains experimental flaws or is based on data that does not convincingly corroborate the experimenter’s theoretical claims
    • Comes from overconfident fringe experts
    • Uses over-simplified interpretations of legitimate studies and may combine with imprecise, spiritual or new age vocabulary, to form new, completely untested theories.
    • Speaks dismissively of mainstream science
    • Includes some of the red flags listed in the two sections below
This is a good starting point to distinguish real science from pseudoscience. TED also identifies certain “red flag” topics that require close scrutiny, including food as medicine, alternative medicine, free energy, time travel (!), and what looks like a Chopra clause, “the fusion of science and spirituality.” Nicely, TED points to an SBM post on Dr. Oz and green coffee beans as an example of how to to check out a possible health hoax.
TED also points to Emily Willingham’s checklist as another filter that can be applied when evaluating claims.
     1.  What is the source? Does the person or group making the claim have any relevant expertise?
     2.  What is the agenda? What does the person or group making the claim have to gain?
     3.  What kind of language does it use? Watch for an emphasis on emotional terms, or jargony sciencey-sounding terminology
     4.  Does it involve testimonials? When it comes to scientific claims, testimonials are weak sources of credible information.
     5.  Are there claims of exclusivity? Was it invented out of thin air, by a single person? New treatments typically build on existing science.
     6.  Is there mention of a conspiracy of any kind? Anything THEY don’t want you to know about is a huge red flag
     7.  Does the claim involve multiple dissociated disorders? i.e., is it the “one cause/cure for all disease”?
     8.  Is there a money trail or passionate belief involved? i.e., Follow the money
     9.  Were real scientific processes involved? What credible evaluations have been performed?
     10.  Is there expertise? Are they specialists in their field, with credible education from legitimate organizations?
No list is 100% sensitive or specific, and not every questionable practice will set off every red flag. But if you know the signs, you’ll develop an impressive ability to detect it. Reading this blog regularly helps. In time you’ll annoy your friends and family with the ability to spot medical hocus-pocus with a quick glance.
Given the multitude of health claims and alternative practices that exist, It helps that some some themes are recurrent, making them easier to identify. Once you understand the key concepts of an alternative practice, you’ll be able to spot its variations easily. One of the more recurrent is applied kinesiology. It’s been covered before, but merits a repeated look, if only because of its tenacity and its chameleon-like nature to manifest as what appears to be different treatments.
Applied kinesiology is just as implausible as homeopathy, so the more people understand the absurdity of the practice, the better. (Note that AK is unrelated to kinesiology, the legitimate study of body motion.) AK involves some form of muscle “testing” that purports to identify illness or if you prefer, “dis-ease”. It can manifest as magical “energy” bracelets (think Power Balance) touted to improve sports performances. AK is even claimed to identify food intolerances, simply by holding the food in your hand. Not surprisingly, this form of testing is no more effective than random guessing. But you don’t even need to hold a product when you’re tested. Even just thinking about a substance can cause muscle weakness, according to AK advocates. There are no biologic or scientific principles that suggest AK might be effective. So not surprisingly, AK fails every test for every type of illness, condition, or intolerance. All of them. Despite this, AK is frequently offered by chiropractors, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners. It is a disproved treatment that cannot be killed with evidence or reason, like the other alternative medicine zombies. Why doesn’t it get dropped? Because to admit AK is nonsense would be tacit agreement that vitalism is bunk.
Applied kinesiology itself has only been around since the 1960s, but it’s a extension of vitalistic thoughts about the body and the interconnectedness of cells and systems. AK is believed to be effective because of the interconnectedness of cells based on some form of mysterious, undefined energy. This energy is vitalism: the pre-scientific belief that living objects differ from non-living objects because of some sort of “vital force” or energy field. Vitalism was a scientific placeholder, which was dropped from our understanding of the world when it was shown to be unnecessary. Alternative medicine practices that are not based on science, such as homeopathy, naturopathy, chiropractic and acupuncture remain permeated with vitalistic thinking.
Understanding the premise of applied kinesiology, with its roots in vitalism, make it easy to spot its hundreds of variants. I was recently asked a manual therapy called “The BodyTalk System“. I’d never heard of it, but the idea of body “talk” sounded a bit like vitalism (and also of Olivia Newton John). According to the advertising:
BodyTalk is an revolutionary form of alternative healthcare. It encompasses:
    • Western Medical Expertise
    • The Energy Dynamics of Acupuncture
    • Osteopathic and Chiropractic Philosophy
    • The Insights of Modern Physics and Mathematics
BodyTalk is an astonishingly simple and effective form of therapy that allows the body’s energy systems to be resynchronized so they can operate as nature intended. When a body is operating at its optima level, each system, cell and atom is in constant communication with each other at all times. Through exposure to the stresses of day-to-day life, these lines of communication can become compromised, which can lead to a decline in physican, emotional and or mental/health.
Wow. Sciencey jargon, disproved practices like acupuncture, chiropractic philosophy (i.e., subluxations) and explicit references to “energy systems”. Sounds a lot like vitalism. The treatment description suggests this is just a variation of applied kinesiology:
During a BodyTalk session, the practitioner facilitates communication with the innate wisdom of the body by using neuromuscular feedback. After asking Innate (sic) a series of yes or no questions, the client’s own body wisdom leads the practitioner to locate the imbalances within the body that are a priority, or are not communicating correctly and are out of balance with the rest of the body.
Next the practitioner hold the areas that have been highlighted by the testing procedure and taps gently on the head and sternum. By tapping on the head the brain becomes aware of and repairs the communication link. Tapping on the sternum, or heart, ensure that the new information is stored throughout the whole body.
When you look past the ritual, it’s clear that this is applied kinesiology. Innate wisdom is code for vitalism, and the references to “balance” are a fixture of homeopathy, acupuncture and most other alternative practices. Perhaps not surprisingly, Bodytalk was invented by an Australian chiropractor and acupuncturist, John Veltheim. Veltheim dismisses the materialistic, “Cartesian” view of health and instead proposes an approach he calls (pg 45) “quantum health care”:
The quantum scientific principles have been understood for over a hundred years. The ethical and philosophical principles, such the (sic) Indian Advaitic/Vedantic teachings, which underpin quantum scienc,e have been around for many centuries. Just a little careful observation reveals that our solar systems (sic) and mother earth are not two. Instead they comprise a dynamic matrix of interlacing morphogenic fields. In quantum physics this matrix is referred to as variations of Quantum entanglement. Int is critical that we recognize and acknowledge that everything we do has extensive, short and long-term, dynamic ramifications throughout the universe.
Here’s another screening question to add to the list above: Any reference to “quantum” in the context of health care is a red flag that almost always identifies pseudoscience.
One of the common practices of BodyTalk is called “tapping the cortices” which is claimed to be effective for stress, poor attention span, and even shock and coma. It’s better seen, than described:
Tapping the Cortices – Bodytalk
His video bring up another useful screening tool for pseudoscience: Any reference to magnetism in health care (unless you’re discussing MRI) is another red flag to watch out for.
Does Bodytalk work? Not surprisingly, there’s no credible published evidence to substantiate the concepts of BodyTalk or any of its claims. Credible science has references. Pseudoscience offers testimonials. When all you have is testimonials, you put them front and center: If the health product or service you’re investigating has a dedicated testimonials page, you’re pretty much guaranteed unproven or disproven treatments.
Conclusion
Bodytalk has all the characteristics of pseudoscience. It’s one example of a family of “energy healing” practices with roots in applied kinesiology which still reflects its origins in vitalistic thinking. Like other forms of applied kinesiology, BodyTalk is health theater, appearing to do something but accomplishing nothing substantive. Not surprisingly, there is no credible evidence to suggest that BodyTalk treatments have any meaningful therapeutic effects. There are endless variations of these kinds of alternative healing treatments. Sorting pseudoscience from science can look challenging, but its easier when you can spot the themes. Conveniently, pseudoscientific health practices share many key principles. Look for the red flags, and you’ll be a stronger science-based thinker.

Cranial Osteopathy in Dentistry
Grant Ritchey on October 17, 2011
Tweet

Editor’s note: Having just submitted a major grant on Friday and then having had to turn around and head to an NIH study section meeting today in Bethesda, I just didn’t have the time to produce something up to the usual standards of SBM for today. (And, being managing editor, I should know what’s up to the usual standards of SBM; what I started to write wasn’t it. Trust me on this.) Fortunately, Dr. Grant Ritchey and Dr. Steve Hendry, two skeptical, science-based dentists, did submit something up to SBM’s usual standards. Even better, since we’ve been having a number of requests for posts involving dentistry, it seemed like a perfect time to publish their first contribution to SBM and see how our readers like it. Maybe next time around, I’ll have them update the “state of knowledge” regarding amalgams.
Form follows function, as the old saying goes. Nowhere in the human body is this adage more fitting than in the oral cavity. In less than two generations, the practice of dentistry has evolved from basic pain relief and function-based procedures (such as extractions and fillings), into today’s practices of complex cosmetic rehabilitation, orthopedic and orthodontic management of the teeth, jaws, and facial structures, replacing missing teeth with dental implants, and treatment of sleep apnea and temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders, to name but a few. With such rapid progress, it is to be expected that for every science based advance made in our field, there are just as many claims that are either dubious in their evidential support or outright pseudo-scientific or anti-scientific nonsense.
In this article, we’ll be taking a look at the roles that health care practitioners such as chiropractors, osteopathic physicians, and physical therapists, are attempting to play in the dental field. We will also see how well-meaning dentists have been trained in and apply their pseudo-scientific principles in their dental practices. In particular, we’ll be examining Cranial Osteopathy (also known as Craniosacral Therapy or Cranial Therapy) in the management of the dental patient, the purported benefits claimed by practitioners of cranial osteopathy, and the quality and quantity of evidence for this type of treatment in the scientific literature. 
Basic Skull Anatomy
The human skull is made up of some eight cranial (head) bones and fourteen facial bones. These bones help protect the organs of vision, hearing, taste, equilibrium, and smell. They also provide attachment for muscles that move the head, control facial expressions and chew our food. At birth, the spaces between the cranial bones- called fontanelles – are wider and more elastic, allowing the infant to pass through the birth canal and later permitting brain growth in the first few years of life. In humans the lateral fontanelles close soon after birth, the posterior fontanelle generally closes several months later, and the anterior fontanelle may remain open for three years.
By early childhood, the cranial bones become tightly interlocked in a zig-zag, zipper like pattern (illustrated nicely here) that renders them immovable in a macroscopic sense, although each suture (called a synarthrosis if you want to impress your friends at parties) has a very slight amount of flexibility- 10-30 micrometers on average (1 micrometer = 1/1000th of a millimeter or approximately 4/100,000ths of an inch). These sutures fill the minuscule space between the cranial bones, essentially stitching them together with dense, strong connective tissue fibers called Sharpey’s fibers.
Tenets and Scope of Cranial Osteopathy
Cranial Osteopathy was invented by William G. Sutherland D.O. around 1900 when, while viewing a disarticulated human skull, he noted the way some of the skull bones were: “…beveled… like the gills of a fish… indicating articular mobility… for a respiratory mechanism.” Note that we said “invented” rather than “discovered,” as this discipline was indeed invented from whole cloth, based upon the happenstance similarity in the appearance of a skull bone and the gills of a fish, which he then superimposed on his 19th century osteopathic ideology. (Imagine what he would have come up with had he instead noted the similarity between the uvula and the male genitalia!) Sutherland claimed, and adherents of Cranial Osteopathy hold, that the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) has an inherent rhythmicity, which he likened to the tides of the ocean. He called this the “Primary Respiratory Mechanism (PRM)”, often referred to today as “Craniosacral Rhythms.” According to Osteopathic principles, the PRM underlies all of life’s processes and begets vitality, form, and substance to all of a person’s anatomy and physiological processes. Any disturbance in the natural flow of CSF could cause illness and conversely, practically any illness could be prevented or cured by the physical manipulation of the cranial bones, “freeing up” the functional flow of the CSF. Towards the latter part of his life, Sutherland believed that he could sense a “power” which allowed corrections to occur from inside his patients’ bodies without having to provide any physical manipulations. This has come to be known as “biodynamic craniosacral therapy” or “biodynamic osteopathy”. See this overview of the scope of Cranial Osteopathy (“The Cranial Concept”) in their own words.
Of course, none of this imagery would be of any use without a therapy to sell, and osteopaths assert that they can fix what ails you through hands-on manipulation of your skull bones. As one practitioner’s website puts it: “As incredible as this may seem, we feel the bones move, the membranes pull, the fluids fluctuate, and even the brain undulate”. And woe unto the poor sap who suffers from a rigid-boned, lax-membraned, fluid stasisy, un-undulating brain! Practitioners of Craniosacral Therapy or Cranial Osteopathy claim that they can detect this secondary CSF pulse with simple palpation and distinguish them from a regular vascular pulse.
Cranial manipulations are performed in a variety of different ways depending upon the condition being treated and the philosophy and training of the practitioner. (See an overview of some of the techniques.) Some of them include range of motion therapies similar to what a physical therapist would do; others involve the supposed manipulation and movement of the cranial bones, using only digital (i.e. finger) pressure with a very light force.
The Cranial Osteopathic Academy, a component society of The American Academy of Osteopathy (AAO), described it thus:
Treatment is typically very gentle. Tissues are supported and allowed to change. Usually very little force is used during treatment, but at times some force may be necessary. Diagnosis and Treatment are said to blend into one another. As tissues change the physician learns more about their nature. As the nature of the tissue dysfunction is better understood, the therapeutic response deepens.
Each patient’s experience is unique. Some patients sense only a gentle touch, while others feel their body change immediately. Some patients simply feel a deep sense of relaxation, and others feel nothing at all. Most patients feel a distinct change following the treatment.
Though Cranial Osteopathy is very gentle, patients can occasionally experience some discomfort during certain stages of the treatment. When this occurs, it is simply a part of the healing process. As the treatment progresses, the discomfort subsides.
Although physicians practicing Osteopathy in the Cranial Field will work anywhere on the body, they may find it important to diagnose and treat the head. Though styles of treatment may vary, the osteopathic physician will primarily focus on the body’s “mechanism” – the body’s natural striving for health and normal function.
According to Dr.Sutherland, within each patient there is great wisdom, an inner physician, a wise all-knowing force that is the source of all healing. In his own words: “Allow physiologic function to express its own unerring potency rather than apply blind force from without.”
Cranial Osteopathy and its variants make a number of imaginative leaps from histological starting points to therapeutic endpoints. From the slight (micrometer) flexibility of cranial sutures, and the slight-but-measurable fluctuation in CSF pressures, practitioners infer that the brain and spinal cord undulate rhythmically “like a jelly fish, coiling and uncoiling” which is critical for health.
Dental Applications of Cranial Osteopathy
Gradual movement of teeth within bones, and gradual orthopedic movement of facial bones themselves, are familiar to all dentists who do orthodontics. Dentists performing orthodontic treatment utilize various appliances to expand the palate (palatal sutures don’t normally fuse until adolescence) and move teeth within the jawbones. Further, the treatment of TMJ disorders has typically been in the realm of the dentist, involves the articulation of cranial bones in the scope of treatment (the mandible and the temporal bone), so the Osteopathy belief system would seem a natural fit to dentistry, especially in these areas. And sure enough, Osteopathy has colonized the dental profession. We’ve seen expensive dental continuing education courses with “Cranio-”, “Sacro Occipital Therapy” and “Chiro-” in their names that graft Osteopathic principles onto dentistry to create whole new, untapped disciplines to market.
Websites promoting these dental applications of Cranial Osteopathy claim to teach amazing new skills to dentists, including how to “free up” and move facial bones around, by hand, in minutes using only fingertip pressure. Additionally, in almost every case, these dental courses provide a gateway to other, more garden variety forms of CAM: nutritional supplements, detox, immune system boosting, nervous system balancing, and so forth. For the dentist, taking one of these courses is the first step in going “down a rabbit hole” into CAM-land – a metaphor that devotees enthusiastically embrace and frequently use.
An important point to reiterate here is that the emphasis in the dental application of cranial osteopathy is not merely to treat illness or facilitate the flow of the CSF as in “regular” osteopathy; it claims to actually bodily move the facial and cranial bones to more ideal positions to improve orthodontic and TMD outcomes. Cases are shown where overall changes in facial structure and the occlusion (i.e. the bite) are alleged to have been changed by as much as a half of an inch or more by cranial manipulation alone. Of course, these are case studies with little to no supplementary documentation (radiographs, CT scans, etc.) available for an objective reviewer to confirm the claims. We have yet to see a well-documented, objectively presented case study in the medical or dental literature which adequately demonstrates the validity of the treating practitioner’s claims, although one would think that after decades of the existence of their treatment modalities, such evidence would be plentiful, substantive, and readily accessible to the health care community.
Credibility as a Dental Treatment
For Cranial Osteopathy to be viable treatment, there needs to be good evidence anatomically and histologically that the sutures are indeed movable (by hand, no less) to a significant degree, and evidence that doing so is therapeutically beneficial. Neither appears to exist. Although Cranial Osteopathy can provide a modicum of basic research to support its claims, it falls far short of what is needed to establish a scientific foothold in the dental-medical community. Osteopathic applications are woefully lacking in any substantive research but instead rely on anecdotal evidence as the foundation of its validity and applicability. See the excellent overview of Cranial Therapy at Quackwatch.org.
Evaluating the literature, minute movements of the cranial bones appear to be possible (in the micrometer range as stated above) — but not the large rearrangements of bones that practitioners claim to make with hands-on manipulation. It is dubious that a practitioner can feel distortions in cranial bones that the most sensitive neurophysiological instruments cannot.
Moreover, even if an Osteopathic therapist could detect abnormalities in the skull, there appears to be no credible evidence linking small movements at cranial sutures to beneficial health outcomes. As a scientific principle, this is nothing more than wishful thinking and resembles faith healing more than evidence based medicine. The therapeutic claims, research protocols, treatment goals, and definitions of what constitutes solid medical evidence are as flexible as the cranial bones they purport to manipulate.
Cranial Osteopathic adherents predictably scold their critics as being closed-minded and unwilling to learn, or worse, a shill for the Dental Industrial Complex. But we like the old adage about staying open-minded, but not so open that your brain falls out. The really surprising (and disturbing) thing to us is the number of bright, conscientious, and highly-trained dentists we see being drawn to courses in Cranial Osteopathy, and in many cases buying into the smorgasbord of alternate-medicine courses offered as side dishes at the cranio-dental table. If there’s harm in the Cranio-dental movement, besides a lot of money wasted by dentists on dubious courses and by patients on dubious treatment, it may be that it seems to be a particularly attractive gateway to more bizarre alternate treatment philosophies – one that seems to appeal to surprisingly smart and educated dentists. By granting dentists a license to practice, the public trusts us to apply evidential knowledge to the management of their dental problems. This implies that we must critically examine new hypotheses, decide if there is rational evidence for them, reject the pseudo-science, and apply the knowledge that sifts through for the benefit of the patients we serve.

Alas poor Craniosacral. A SCAM of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy.
Mark Crislip on December 16, 2011
Link
It is hard to Sokalize alternative medicine. The closest has been buttock reflexology/acupuncture, but that is a tame example. Given the propensity for projections of the human body to appear on the iris, hand, foot, tongue, and ear, postulating a similar pattern on the buttocks are simple variations on a common SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine) theme. The buttocks? Not really different from any of the other focal acupunctures. Most of SCAM does not concern itself with application of reality and physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, etc can all be expected to be ignored with virtually all SCAM modalities.
Every time I think the heights (or depths) of absurdity has been reached, I discover a Braco the Starer or Himalayan Salt Inhalers. This blog is not affiliated with the British Medical Journal in any way, and although this is being published near Christmas, I want no one think that what follows is a hoax. I am not, I repeat not, making up what follows. It is not fiction. Well, it is fiction, but not written by me and believed and practiced by some who really should know better.
Craniosacral Therapy
Like many SCAM modalities, from Reiki to Chiropractic, Craniosacral Therapy (CST) was invented? discovered? fabricated? pulled out of the a.., well, er, Drs Novella and Gorski want this to be a professional blog *, so lets say, a three letter word that starts with ‘a’. Air. It was pulled out of the air by William Garner Sutherland.
While a student at the American School of Osteopathy in 1899, Dr. Sutherland pondered the fine details of a separated or “disarticulated” skull. He wondered about the function of this complex architecture. Dr. Still taught that every structure exists because it performs a particular function. While looking at a temporal bone, a flash of inspiration struck Dr. Sutherland: “Beveled like the gills of a fish, indicating respiratory motion for an articular mechanism.
Here is a picture of a temporal bone:
Here is a cranial suture:
And here is a fish gill:
I guess drug use was more popular than I thought back in the day. Maybe I am not able to get the right photograph of gills to see the connection. You? Do you see the connection, or do you lack the “unique genius” of Dr. Sutherland ? Because the temporal bones are beveled like fish gills (!), the bones of the head are supposed to move relative to each other (!) with respiration (!). That is the insight that lead to CST. I wonder if the abstract announcing his discovery would have been accepted at the International Conference on Integrative Medicine. It makes gluteal reflexology appear reasonable in comparison.
Dr. Sutherlands’ insight did not stop there. He synthesized his observations into “The Primary Respiratory Mechanism”:
This Primary Respiratory Mechanism has five basic components:
1) The inherent rhythmic motion of the brain and spinal cord.2) The fluctuation of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) that bathes and nourishes the brain and spina l cord.3) The shifting tensions of the membranous envelope (dura mater) surrounding the brain and spinal cord. This entire membranous structure acts as a unit and is called a “Reciprocal Tension Membrane.”4) The inherent rhythmic motion of the cranial bones.5) The involuntary motion of the sacrum (tailbone) between the ilia (hip bones).
I don’t know that means. I read the words, I think about what I understand about anatomy and physiology, I reread the above and I got nothing. A word salad, it appears to be all sound and fury, signifying nothing. Repeat. It is not meant to be fiction.
To make it more mysterious, or fanciful, the CSF has tides:
“1) the cranial rhythmic impulse; a more superficial rhythm expressed at an average rate of 8-12 cycles per minute,2) the mid-tide; a tidal rhythm that carries ordering forces into the body expressed at a slower rate of approximately 2.5 cycles per minute and3) the long tide; a deep and slow rhythmic impulse expressed about once every 100 seconds. The long tide is considered to be the first stirring of life and motion as the Breath of Life emerges from a deeper ground of stillness at the center of our being.”
I know topic was the death of MacBeth’s wife but Act 5, Scene 5, lines 26-28 keeps running in my head. It is an explanation of physiology that would be right at home on Dr. Oz’s site, but has no relationship to any known anatomy or physiology. Other explanations of the tides make no sense to me, containing nothing I can recognize as content amongst what appears to be a word salad. Although I suspect CST would appeal to Bloodline aliens.
I do not think there is a SCAM where the practitioners deny the evidence in their hands. There are videos of CST therapists saying that, unlike what is taught in medical school, the bones of the skull are not fused and articulate. They say this with Yorick in their hands, a skull evidently never contemplated. If you have ever held a skull in your hands, or been in a neurosurgical case, it is evident that the cranium is notable for the rock solid joinings of bones. The metaphor is thick skulled, is it not? It is not fish-gilled skulled.
Acupuncturists may blather about meridians and homeopathists drivel on about the memory of water, but at least they do not hold the dis-confirming evidence in their hands, denying its existence. I have seen patients deny an obvious tumor or the symptoms of advanced AIDS. Look at that skull in your hands. The bones do not move. To have a whole field of SCAM based on the denial of palpable reality is most curious. As Marx said, sort of, “Who are you going to believe, Sutherland or your lying eyes?”
What does a practitioner do with the insight that the CSF flows incorrectly and the cranial bones are out of wack? CST
“involves the practitioner “listening through the hands” to the body’s subtle rhythms and any patterns of inertia or congestion. Through the development of subtle palpatory skills the practitioner can read the story of the body, identify places where issues are held and then follow the natural priorities for healing as directed by the patient’s own physiology.”
As I gather from the gibberish of the YouTubes and CST sites, they push the bones of your skull back into place, alter and optimize the flow of CSF and make you better. I think. Because nothing they say really makes any anatomic or physiologic sense:
The trained practitioner palpates for the sensation of resistance on the skin surface overlying the spine and cranium. Resistance is thought to be indicative of underlying CSF stasis, and following treatment, the absence of drag may indicate that the CSF stasis has been reduced.”
as one of a tedious series of examples. They can feel the tides and CSF rhythms and alter them. They can change the tides, at least the CSF tides. I am old school when it comes to altering tides: And te tide and te time þat tu iboren were, schal beon iblescet. But that is obvious, which is why it is an aphorism.
The cranial rhythmic impulse is an oscillation recognized by many bodywork practitioners, but the functional origin of this impulse remains uncertain. We propose that the cranial rhythmic impulse is the palpable perception of entrainment, a harmonic frequency that incorporates the rhythms of multiple biological oscillators. It is derived primarily from signals between the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems. Entrainment also arises between organisms. The harmonizing of coupled oscillators into a single, dominant frequency is called frequency-selective entrainment. We propose that this phenomenon is the modus operandi of practitioners who use the cranial rhythmic impulse in craniosacral treatment.
Colorless green ideas sleep furiously indeed. Take an anatomy and physiology that does not exist, then postualte a mechanism of action. At least in that respect there is not a difference between CST and acupuncture or homeopathy. Except quantum. Where is the quantum. We need quantum.
Practical Uses of Quantum Physics Concepts in CranioSacral Therapy
Adding a few new intentions to your hands-on work is quite simple. All you need to do is incorporate a few principles of quantum physics.First, we direct our energy into hard, stiff or restricted areas of the client’s body.
Of course, I giggle like the immature person I am. I know. What an infant. But I giggled a lot writing this entry; truly a field of infinite jest. Of course, the only real parallel between CST and quantum of any kind are N-Rays, sharing identical reality.
Similar to other SCAMs, there is zero consistency in the ability of CST practitioners to feel the same tides in the same patients.
Two registered osteopaths, both with postgraduate training in diagnosis and treatment, using cranial techniques, palpated 11 normal healthy subjects. METHODS:Examiners simultaneously palpated for the CRI at the head and the sacrum of each subject. Examiners indicated the “full flexion” phase of the CRI by activating silent foot switches that were interfaced with a computer. Subject arousal was monitored using heart rate. Examiners were blind to each other’s results and could not communicate during data collection. RESULTS:Reliability was estimated from calculation of intraclass correlation coefficients (2,1). Intrarater reliability for examiners at either the head or the sacrum was fair to good, significant intraclass correlation coefficients ranging from +0.52 to +0.73. Interexaminer reliability for simultaneous palpation at the head and the sacrum was poor to nonexistent, ICCs ranging from -0.09 to +0.31. There were significant differences between rates of CRI palpated simultaneously at the head and the sacrum. CONCLUSIONS:The results fail to support the construct validity of the “core-link” hypothesis as it is traditionally held by proponents of craniosacral therapy and osteopathy in the cranial field.
Reproductively and the ability to consistently feel the tides has been refuted in more than one trial. King Canute they aren’t.
In reality what do CST practitioners do? They lightly massage your head. To treat everything from Downs to headache to PMS. It is an all purpose diagnostic and therapeutic intervention, like all SCAMs.
There are no shortage of videos demonstrating the techniques of CST, one practitioner states she pushes the bones back into alignment with a 5 gram pressure, the weight of a nickel. I do not think a nickles worth of pressure would move a skull bone a quantum amount, not even if dropped off the Empire State Building.
Once I had a colleague (really, a colleague. Not me) who commented he liked to have hair cuts because the scalp massage with the wash and condition was very relaxing, and I will admit that lying on ones back while you head is massaged looks very pleasant, especially if it occurred in the middle of a busy work day and was paid for by Blue Cross. If you had a process that was due, in part, from stress, I can see where a CST session would be most beneficial. I always return to the example of the relaxing effect of apes mutual grooming, although “in deference to one million years of human evolution, the therapist won’t try to pick fleas off his patient.” Or so one hopes.
I wrote the last paragraph before I did a Pubmed search on the topic. Lets see if CST helps headaches independent of the incomprehensible blather that underpins the field. I bet it will be helpful for anything with a subjective endpoint and I bet that for hard endpoints, CST will do nothing.
There are 56 hits on the Pubmeds using Craniosacral therapy, and there are no even remotely well done studies using CST. The most interesting predates the NEJM asthma article discussed at length at SBM.
In it
Subjects were randomly assignment to one of five groups: acupuncture, craniosacral therapy, acupuncture and craniosacral, attention control, and waiting list control. METHODS:Subjects received 12 sessions of equal length with pretreatment and posttreatment assessment of pulmonary function, asthma quality of life, depression, and anxiety. Medication use was also assessed.
Can you predict the results? Yep. Patients were subjectively improved, but their objective asthma was not better.
When treatment was compared with the control group, statistically treatment was significantly better than the control group in improving asthma quality of life, whereas reducing medication use with pulmonary function test results remained the same.
As one would expect from a relaxing head massage. Others are also less than enthusiastic about CST
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:A three-dimensional evaluative framework with related appraisal criteria: (A) craniosacral interventions and health outcomes; (B) validity of craniosacral assessment; and (C) pathophysiology of the craniosacral system. RESULTS:The available research on craniosacral treatment effectiveness constitutes low-grade evidence conducted using inadequate research protocols. One study reported negative side effects in outpatients with traumatic brain injury. Low inter-rater reliability ratings were found. CONCLUSIONS:This systematic review and critical appraisal found insufficient evidence to support craniosacral therapy. Research methods that could conclusively evaluate effectiveness have not been applied to date.
Despite the structural integrity of the skull, CRT proponents insist “Eppur si muove“. And there is one time where the bones of the skull are moveable: after head trauma. Then, perhaps, pushing on the skull, even 5 grams worth, may not he such a good idea. I have seen enough trauma over the years to be cautious around breaks in human structural integrity. Not so much with CST:
Although craniosacral manipulation has been found empirically useful in patients with traumatic brain injury, three cases of iatrogenesis occurred. The incidence rate is low (5%), but the practitioner must be prepared to deal with the possibility of adverse reactions.
Why do I think of the word “squelch” when I read the abstract; too much Joe Aberrcombie of late? It turns out that the adverse reactions from CST are every bit as fanciful as beneficial effects:
These three cases represent a diversity of adverse reactions following craniosacral manipulation. The first patient had exacerbation of vertiginous symptoms during diagnostic evaluation alone. After sphenobasilar decompression, visceral symptoms involving cardiac, respiratory, and gastrointestinal systems arose. This feature suggests either brain stem or vagal effects as a possible source of the symptom complex. The second patient had exacerbation of headache complaint, but, more important, a disturbing psychologic/psychiatric problem, necessitating psychiatric institutional care. The severe total body spastic reaction seen in the third patient continues to defy explanation. The possibility of a brain stem seizure triggered by stimulation of the upper cervical spine and cranial base or posttraumatic cervical dystonian remains plausible. Extensive evaluation failed to demonstrate a specific cause.
It is a tough economy, and jobs are scarce. For 5 to 12 thousand dollars and 700 hours (150 if you are already a licensed massage therapist) you can be a CST provider. That’s 88 days of education, about a semesters worth. And then maybe you can practice at a University Medical Center. Like Ohio. Or Duke. And of course, Dr Oz has offered CST, so you know it must be nonsense.
There are probably other institutions that offer the raging nonsense that is CRT, but I grow weary of the searching. But it should not be part of any University, since
…we believe that craniosacral therapy bears approximately the same relationship to real medicine that astrology bears to astronomy. That is, this approach to “health care” is medical fiction, and it is not appropriate to teach fiction as part of medical or allied health curricula.
I wonder if Duke or Ohio are going to offer astrological readings or have John Edwards as a Visiting Lecturer. It would only be a lateral step, not a step backwards. Seriously. If your local Hospital or University offers CST, go elsewhere. They have a demonstrated commitment to the irreparably goofy.
To sum up: CST now beats Braco the starer. I don’t think The Onion could do better.
Footnote
*I remain uncertain as to why the editors let these posts through.

Craniosacral Therapy Is Bogus but DOs Are Required to Learn It
The standard textbook used in many schools of osteopathic medicine includes a lamentable chapter on cranial manipulation. It is clearly biased and fails to meet the minimal standards of science-based medicine. Craniosacral manipulation therapy is bogus, and it should no longer be taught to DOs or feature on their exams.
Harriet Hall on May 18, 2021
Link

Craniosacral therapy (CST) is practiced by DOs and others, including some massage therapists, chiropractors, dentists, and physical therapists. It is a hands-on therapy that claims to manipulate the skull bones to relieve pain and remedy many other ailments. It claims that a rhythm exists in the flow of the fluid that surrounds the brain and spinal cord and that practitioners can reliably detect that rhythm by palpation. These claims are not true: the bones of the skull are fused and don’t move, there is no such rhythm in the cerebrospinal fluid, and palpation is unreliable.
The origin of CST
I wrote about the origin of craniosacral therapy (CST) in an article for Skeptical Inquirer titled “Wired to the Kitchen Sink”. In the 1970s, a doctor of osteopathic medicine named John Upledger had an epiphany:
He was assisting a neurosurgeon by holding the dura (membrane surrounding the brain and spinal cord) steady while the surgeon removed a calcified plaque. He wasn’t doing a very good job of holding still. The surgeon complained. Most of us would have thought our own muscles were at fault; however, Upledger observed that the dura was fluctuating up and down at about ten cycles per minute, overcoming his attempts to hold it still. Nobody had ever observed this before, not even neurosurgeons…He tried mobilizing the cranial bones through hands-on manipulation and convinced himself he could feel the bones move one-sixteenth of an inch or more. Patients with autism, seizures, cerebral palsy, headaches, dyslexia, colic, asthma, and other diseases reported dramatic improvement. He found that well people treated with monthly adjustments reported more energy, felt happier, and were sick less often.
Basically, he allowed himself to be deceived by an illusion, and he failed to recognize that subjective patient reports of improvement may be due to a placebo response.
Criticism of CST: not based on science
I wrote another SBM article in 2013 showing that osteopathic research on CST was Tooth Fairy Science.
Edzard Ernst did a systematic review of randomized clinical trials and concluded that craniosacral therapy was bogus. He said, “The notion that CST is associated with more than non‐specific effects is not based on evidence from rigorous RCTs.” And he said “to anyone understanding a bit of physiology, anatomy etc. CST looks like pure nonsense.”
PainScience.com reviewed CST and concluded:
There is good, recent scientific evidence that the most important and basic assumption about how CST works is just not true: craniosacral therapists cannot actually move the bones of the skull enough to affect the pressure or circulation of the fluid surrounding the brain and spinal column. Although CST fluid does circulate, we know that it’s pumped almost entirely by respiration, not skull movement.
Wikipedia doesn’t mince words. It says CST is based on fundamental misconceptions about the physiology of the human skull; it calls CST pseudoscience and quackery. And it describes several reports of harm; at least two deaths have been attributed to CST.
A 2002 article in The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine by Hartman and Norton (two professors at schools of osteopathic medicine) examined the inter-examiner reliability of craniosacral osteopathy. They found that the reliability was zero and the proposed mechanism was invalid. They found that there was little science in any aspect of cranial osteopathy:
    • There is no scientific support for major elements of the primary respiratory mechanism (PRM)
    • The only publication purporting to show diagnostic reliability with sufficient detail to permit evaluation is deeply flawed and stands alone against 5 other reports that show reliabilities of essentially zero; and
    • There is no scientific evidence of treatment efficacy.
They commented,
Without careful scientific controls, weaknesses of perception and interpretation can fool both practitioners and patients into believing that a treatment is effective when it is not. We believe that these and other natural human psychosocial influences help to explain how cranial osteopathy has achieved the 21st century without scientific support of any kind.
They recommended that:
cranial osteopathy should be removed from the curricula of colleges of osteopathic medicine and from osteopathic licensing examinations.
On Quackwatch, Stephen Barrett went even further. After explaining “Why Cranial Therapy Is Silly” he said,
I believe that most practitioners of craniosacral therapy have such poor judgment that they should be delicensed.
It wasn’t removed
Nobody listened. Nineteen years later, Hartman and Norton’s recommendation continues to be ignored. The most current, comprehensive osteopathic text available is Foundations of Osteopathic Medicine. This standard text is now in its 4th edition. It is not only endorsed by the American Osteopathic Association but is published under its auspices. It is a required text in many osteopathic schools. (The actual number of schools that require it can’t be determined, since many schools don’t list their required textbooks.) It features an entire chapter on CST, which it calls Osteopathic Cranial Manipulative Medicine (OCMM). That’s just another name for CST, focusing on its use in osteopathic medicine (and presumably excluding discussion of its use by other practitioners like chiropractors).
The textbook’s chapter on OCMM
The author of chapter 38 in the 4th edition, “Osteopathic Cranial Manipulative Medicine”, is Hollis King, who is a “double doc:” he earned a doctorate in osteopathic medicine from the Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine and a PhD in clinical psychology from Louisiana State University. (Doc Doc Goose comes to mind). He starts by covering the history and development of OCMM, then covers the proposed mechanism of action. (Proposed, not proven.) He claims that:
Midline bones (the sphenoid, occiput, ethmoid, vomer, and sacrum) move through a flexion phase and an extension phase around a transverse axis, while paired bones move through external and internal rotation. They are moved through this biphasic cycle in response to the pull or influence of the dural membranes, which are influenced by the coiling and uncoiling of the CNS and the fluctuation of the CSF…The overall motion of the cranium is similar to the motion of the chest during respiration.
He doesn’t provide any credible evidence to support those fanciful claims. Can you imagine the CNS coiling and uncoiling?
He describes the Primary Respiratory Mechanism as having these five components:
    • The inherent rhythmic motion of the brain and spinal cord
    • Fluctuation of cerebrospinal fluid
    • Mobility of intracranial and intraspinal membranes
    • Articular mobility of cranial bones
    • Involuntary mobility of sacrum between ilia.
He claims these are well established and not controversial – but they are not well established and saying they are controversial would be an understatement. They are not recognized by mainstream anatomists and physiologists and are not mentioned in medical textbooks nor are they taught in medical schools. He cites a 1966 osteopathy textbook as evidence for many of his absurd claims, such as that “The entire CNS shortens and thickens during one phase and lengthens and thins during the other.” Doesn’t he realize that mainstream scientists find such claims laughable?
He speculates about mechanisms of purported physiologic motion and covers studies that he thinks prove the existence of the primary respiratory mechanism. He reproduces fanciful illustrations of speculations about the purported anatomy – from the same 1966 book! He compares the idea that the cranial bones are fused and immobile to an anatomic version of “the world is flat” debate of the last millennium.
He does cite the Hartman and Norton study from The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine, (twice!). But he fails to mention its primary finding of the lack of interexaminer reliability, which establishes that the palpation by examiners is not objective, is inconsistent, and can’t be relied on for diagnosis. The first time he cites the study is to support his claim that “The most controversial phenomenon of the PRM from a scientific perspective is the concept of palpable cranial bone motion. Misgivings primarily surround the assumed anatomic impossibility of such motion. However, cranial sutures are constructed in a way that allows for motion beyond simple bony compliance.”
The second time he cites the study is in support of his claim that “Commentary that holds to the ‘cranial bones are fused’ perspective is particularly critical of the sphenobasilar junction mobility model.”
Under the heading “Principles of Diagnosis” he says, “Palpation by a well-trained and sensitive physician is the most reliable source of information”. But we know it is not reliable at all.
He acknowledges that the published evidence is insufficient but firmly believes better evidence will be forthcoming. He says from the perspective of practitioners, there is little doubt of the clinical applicability; they see improvement in the patients they treat with CST. In other words, he dismisses scientific evidence and accepts the delusional subjective palpatory findings of CST practitioners and the subjective reports of patients without taking into consideration the effects of suggestion and the possibility of a placebo response.
The research studies he lists include research on cats in space, extrapolation from anomalies, speculation, questionable studies, “plausible models”, and studies that don’t say what he seems to think they say. His bias is obvious. He systematically cherry-picks studies that support his belief system and finds rationalizations to dismiss studies that don’t.
One wonders if King even understands what science is. He says “systematic observation of anatomic relationships palpated by the osteopathic physician, and correlated with changes in the patient’s symptoms, is indeed scientific procedure.” No, that’s not how science works.
King describes applications of CST that he claims are supported by clinical research: otitis media; pregnancy, labor, and delivery; children with learning problems, neurological deficits, delayed academic performance, and seizure disorders; colic; cerebral palsy; gastrointestinal symptoms and length of stay in the neonatal unit for premature infants; dental conditions including TMJ dysfunction and orthodontia; and more.
Adverse events and contraindications
He claims there has been only one report of an adverse event from CST. In reality, there have been many reports of adverse events ranging from dizziness to diarrhea and including two deaths.
He lists these “somatic dysfunctions” that he says can be effectively treated with CST:
    • Bell’s palsy
    • Cranial neuropathy-nerve entrapment
    • Colic
    • Headache
    • Orofacial pain
    • Otitis media
    • Sinusitis
    • Temporomandibular joint dysfunction and malocclusion
    • Vertigo
    • Feeding difficulties
    • Plagiocephaly
    • Torticollis
    • Trigeminal neuralgia
    • Tinnitus
He cites a textbook’s contraindications to CST. Absolute contraindications include acute intracranial bleeding, skull fracture, and acute cerebrovascular accident. Relative contraindications: coagulopathies, space occupying lesion in cranium, and increased intracranial pressure.
This is unconscionable nonsense
While this chapter might impress some naïve osteopathy students, it doesn’t stand up to scrutiny by people with critical thinking skills or to those who understand the requirements of science-based medicine.
In the US, a DO is considered to be equivalent to an MD. They take the same exams and do the same residencies to specialize. They are presumed to have equivalent educations. A DO gets additional training in osteopathic manipulation, but many of them seldom or never use those techniques after they graduate.
If DOs expect to continue to be accepted as equal to MDs, it’s time for them to speak out. Their schools must stop teaching OCMM and requiring textbooks that endorse it. Hollis King’s chapter in this standard osteopathic textbook is a travesty and is completely unacceptable. There’s nothing comparable in schools that teach MDs. It’s as if a medical school were to require a textbook teaching the principles and practice of homeopathy and reflexology, or the anatomy and physiology of acupuncture meridians and acupoints.
Conclusion: CST is bogus
Craniosacral manipulation therapy is based on pseudoscience. It is quackery, plain and simple. I have to agree with Stephen Barrett that most practitioners of craniosacral therapy have such poor judgment that they should not be allowed to practice.

Structural Energetic Therapy
SET appears to be another form of massage therapy with unsupported claims.
Steven Novella on August 2, 2023
Link

The concept of adaptive radiation, an expanding branching proliferation of variations upon variations, is not limited to organic evolution. We see it in cultural evolution as well, such as the history of human languages. Unfortunately we also see it in the proliferation of dubious medical interventions, especially those unmoored to a rigorous dedication to science and evidence. This makes our job challenging, because new versions of questionable treatments are constantly being created.
For example, I was recently asked by a regular reader here about Structural Energetic Therapy (SET), which they could not find on the SBM website. The thing is – all the basic components of SET have been covered extensively on SBM, but this is just a new branding of old ideas, adding its own new “twist” (a pun you will appreciate shortly). Here is how SET practitioners describe it:
Structural Energetic Therapy is the only therapy that releases the spiral twist, found in everyone, into a weight-bearing support, which then relieves the stresses on joints, spine, and discs that lead to pain and body dysfunction. This is achieved using unique cranial/structural techniques and myofascial protocols, found nowhere else, to release patterns that maintain painful conditions in the body. By further integrating energetic healing techniques, we are able to release stresses and emotional blockages to alleviate sources of pain.
You don’t have to read between the lines too much to see what they are basically talking about. Reading further, it’s clear that they are incorporating some version of craniosacral therapy (which they call “cranial osteopathic mobilization”). We have covered craniosacral therapy here before. Multiple times. It is not a legitimate medical science. The short version is – the cranial bones are fused completely by the time we are adults, and there is no way to subtly manipulate them. Further, there is no valid evidence that the brain has it’s own rhythm of pulsations.
But I can imagine that an SET proponent would argue that what they do is different, citing some irrelevant distinction. This is like arguing about sun sign astrology vs stellar astrology – it doesn’t matter, they are both astrology.
They also integrate “energetic healing techniques”, and elsewhere specifically mention acupressure. We have similarly covered energy medicine before, both in general terms and specific manifestations. Again, short answer – there is no human energy field, life energy, vital force, innate intelligence, chi, or whatever. This was always a prescientific idea (a placeholder) that we slowly discarded as we figured our how biology actually works. Modern attempts to demonstrate its existence, let alone any alleged benefits from manipulating the non-existence force, have essentially failed.
Likewise, we have covered acupuncture exhaustively on SBM. There is no reason to believe that acupoints even exist – and if they don’t exist, then acupuncture and acupressure are not real.
So already SET proponents are building their claims on a house of cards – craniosacral therapy, energy medicine, acupoints. They appear to be building these claims around a core of massage therapy, and in fact the person who initial asked me about SET was referred to one while looking for massage therapy.
Massage itself is a legitimate practice. It can relax muscles, may help with muscle soreness, and appears to have positive emotional effects. I have no problem with someone getting a professional massage, if they enjoy it and/or find that it helps helps with their muscle symptoms. However, “message therapy” can incorporate a large number of dubious claims not supported by good science. The role of “trigger points” is questionable. There is no evidence that deep tissue massage releases toxins.
Myofacial release, the idea that you can loosen tight myofacia through specific massage techniques, is thoroughly in the gray area of science. It’s like meditation, in my opinion. There are plausible versions of what it is, but the research has not clearly separated it from just massage. Does myofacial release work better than just massage? This is similar to asking – does meditation work better than just relaxing? Here is a typical systematic review, this one for chronic low back pain:
The meta-analysis results showed that myofascial release significantly improved pain and physical function in patients with CLBP but had no significant effects on balance function, pain pressure-threshold, trunk mobility, mental health, and quality of life. However, due to the low quality and a small number of included literature, more and more rigorously designed RCTs should be included in the future to verify these conclusions.
This is a source (both the researchers and journal) that I would consider friendly to such therapies. The results are typical – mixed results with the subjective outcomes improved but not many of the more concrete outcomes. And the overall conclusion is that the quality of the science is very low. The core problem, as I see it, is that controls are never adequate. Just as meditation is poorly defined operationally, and rarely adequately controls for things like just relaxation time, studies of myofacial release usually don’t adequately control for the non-specific effects of just hands-on therapy, and the known effects of muscle massage.
SET therapy takes all this and adds the concept of the “spiral twist”. This is the notion that almost everyone’s body is just a little off kilter, a tad askew, and could benefit from being properly aligned. They give a long list of ailments that can benefit from untwisting the body, which they say is not the full list – whatever bothers you, give us a call.
It includes things like frozen shoulder, which is a specific physical condition. Frozen shoulder is adhesive capsulitis, caused by fibrous tissue forming in the shoulder joint. The treatment is physical therapy, slowly breaking down the adhesions over months and restoring range of motion. It is not caused by any body misalignments, and cannot be relieved by massage. So what are SET therapists doing? I don’t know – either they are doing nothing helpful, or they are doing standard physical therapy plus their added layers of dubious interventions which likely do nothing, or they tell their clients to get standard physical therapy for frozen shoulder which SET will help work better. But you cannot cure frozen shoulder with anything like SET.
There is a good rule of thumb in SBM – if an intervention is claimed to treat everything, it probably treats nothing. Their list includes migraines, herniated discs, and nerve entrapments. These are diverse entities with multiple causes, which brings up another SBM rule of thumb – the old saying that if your only tool is a hammer, then every problem looks like a nail.
A search on PubMed turned up no studies supporting any benefits for SET, or the existence of the spiral twist. General searches online also did not turn up any scientific studies. The SET website has their own library of articles – all commentary or case studies (i.e. anecdotal). If there were any well-designed scientific studies (positive ones, anyway) I imagine they would be listed there. SET seems to be unmoored to scientific evidence, which is consistent with the claim that it can treat a long list of problems and that anyone can benefit. Good for marketing – not for science-based practice.

Astrology, Alchemy, ESP and Reiki. One Of These Is Not Like The Other
Mark Crislip on June 13, 2014
Link
I knew that Jann was thinking of writing about reiki and fraud, but did not know the details of her most excellent discussion from yesterday until I had finished my penultimate draft for today. Think of them as a match set, two perspectives on the same elephant.
Fraud: a person or thing intended to deceive others, typically by unjustifiably claiming or being credited with accomplishments or qualities.
There are numerous activities that one human will offer another in exchange for money that are completely divorced from reality.
Astrology. Total bunkum.
There is no force, known or unknown, that could possibly affect us here on Earth the way astrologers claim. Known forces weaken too fast, letting one source utterly dominate (the Moon for gravity, the Sun for electromagnetism). An unknown force would allow asteroids and extrasolar planets to totally overwhelm the nearby planets…Study after study has shown that claims and predictions made by astrologers have no merit. They are indistinguishable from chance, which means astrologers cannot claim to have some ability to predict your life’s path.
Although 48% of Americans think astrology is a science, as best I can tell astrology is not part of the curriculum at any astronomy division or program. Astronomers know it is bunkum and avoid it .
Alchemy. Total bunkum. Outside of a nuclear reactor, you cannot turn base metals into gold. And, as best I can tell, alchemy is not part of the curriculum at any chemistry division or program. Chemists know it is bunkum and avoid it.
Parapsychology. Total bunkum. There is no ESP, no ability to read minds, talk to the dead, move objects with thought etc. etc. While as many as 75% of Americans believe in one form of parapsychology, as best I can tell, parapsychology is not part of the curriculum at any psychology division or program. Psychology departments know it is bunkum and avoid it.
Offering astrology or alchemy or talking to the dead for money seems to me to not quite meet the dictionary definition for fraud since I assume for most practitioners there is no intent to defraud. But they do anyway. Just not intentionally.
The legal definition of fraud? Those are waters I will not swim in. Why there are palm readers and astrologers and psychics who perform their services for money when there is no basis in reality for their services is beyond me. Like the lottery, those practices are for entertainment value? The law has limited resources and has to pick and choose?
What about pseudo-medicines? Isn’t that fraud? Jan Bellamy has a nice discussion of the issue. It is a complex issue under the law. Whether pseudo-medical providers taking money from the sick and desperate for therapies that have no basis in reality is legal fraud, I leave to lawyers. In my moral-ethical calculus, offering pseudo-medicines, such offerings may not be legal fraud, but are no different from astrology or talking to the dead.
I don’t see NASA joining up with the American Federation of Astrologers. While astronomers avoid astrology, psychologists avoid parapsychology and chemists avoid alchemists, how does the medical field respond to magic? They form Integrative or Alternative Medicine programs.
One would think that leading medical institutions, major hospitals and universities would know better. What hospital wants to offer imaginary therapies to their patients? Quite a few, evidently.
Take, for example, reiki. An energy ‘therapy’ that is nonsense has no effect on any disease in well done studies. It is, like homeopathy, 100% pure bunkum.
Much to my surprise, while I have done a Quackcast on reiki, I have never written on the topic. A quick summary of the pertinent features.
1) It was just made up. So many SCAMs have a origin story that is on par with gamma ray exposure or being hit by lightening when bathed in chemicals. In this case reiki was created, not unlike the works of Stan Lee, by Mikao Usui as part of a midlife crisis.
2) Its precepts are:
There is a universal and inexhaustible spiritual energy which can be used for healing purposes.
Through an attunement process carried out by a Reiki Master, any person can gain access to this energy.
This energy will flow through the Reiki Master’s hands when he/she places his/her hands near the patient.
As this energy has human-like intelligence, there is no need for diagnosis — the energy will automatically judge the disease and heal the patient.
This energy is, like all energy in SCAMs, has nothing to do with the concept of energy as understood by reality-based sciences like physics. Unmeasured and unmeasurable, this energy is not Kinetic, Potential, Mechanical, Mechanical wave, Chemical, Electric, Magnetic, Radiant, Nuclear, Ionization, Elastic, Gravitational, Intrinsic, Thermal, Heat or Mechanical work. And I suppose Dark, whatever dark energy may be.
This energy can only be detected by the reiki or other energy practitioner unless, of course, they are being tested by a fourth grader. Odd. We can detect the Voyager spacecraft transmitting with the power of a refrigerator light bulb from 10 billion miles away but cannot measure the human ‘energy’ field.
Watch the videos. The reiki practitioners sometimes touch the patient and sometimes they wave their hands over the patient. At least when the patient lays down, relaxes and is touched by a practitioner, you get a bit of the social grooming. It is probably why people feel good with a Reiki treatment. But hand waving the ‘energy’ away? Really. They are serious. And taking money from people to do it.
And what is kind of creepy, and I did not look at every video on the YouTubes, but every person being reiki-ed is female. Someone should do a survey of SCAM videos on the YouTubes. I bet 95% of those being SCAMed upon are thin, young females and most of those performing the SCAM are older males. Or maybe that’s a touch of confirmation bias on my part.
3) There are zero quality studies to demonstrate that reiki is effective beyond that of beer goggles.
To summarize reiki is an invented fiction with no basis in physical reality that has no proven efficacy beyond placebo effects, and you know if you read this blog what I think of placebo effects. If I had a drug I wanted to have on formulary with those characteristics, I would be laughed out of the P&T committee. But intellectual rigor is not always a prized characteristic.
So here is a sobering statistic:
More than 60 U.S. hospitals have adopted Reiki as part of patient services, according to a UCLA study, and Reiki education is offered at 800 hospitals.
That includes, with their description of reiki:
    • Sloan Kettering. Along with reflexology and Restorative Facial Acupuncture.
    • Yale-New Haven
healing energy lulls you into a deeply relaxed state. It is this deep relaxation that increases energy as the body rests and becomes revitalized during the session
    • Dana-Farber/Harvard Cancer Institute
Based on the belief that an unseen “life-force energy” flows through us and helps keep us alive, Reiki is a Japanese technique for stress reduction that is safe, natural, and easy to learn….You simply lay down on a table, fully clothed, while a licensed Reiki master (teacher) places his or her hands on various parts of your body. In addition to making you feel more relaxed, safe, and secure, a proficient instructor can facilitate energy flow to the areas where you need it most – often creating a warm feeling in those locations.Reiki treatments offered to all by the university health services (well-being)
Through healing touch, your energy level is balanced and immune system enhanced.
    • Brigham and Women’s Hospital. At least it is a volunteer program; they offer magic for free.
    • Columbia University
Reiki is an ancient, gentle hands-on healing technique that originated in Japan in which a Reiki practitioner allows energy to pass through him/her to another person, for the recipients higher good. This energy flow can realign, recharge and rebalance an individual’s energy field, which creates the conditions needed for an integrated functioning of the body’s healing ability
    • Johns Hopkins Hospital
Reiki is a very specific form of energy healing, in which hands are placed just off the body or lightly touching the body, as in “laying on of hands.” Reiki can also be done “long-distance,” as a form of prayer…In a Reiki session, the practitioner is seeking to transmit Universal Life Energy to the client.
    • University of Maryland
Reiki is a powerful yet subtle healing practice used as a support for wellness on a body, mind and spiritual level. It is offered through non-invasive, light touch to a clothed client on a massage table. Reiki energy work helps to restore balance, increase energy flow, improve sleep and relieve pain. One of the greatest benefits of Reiki is stress reduction and relaxation which triggers the body’s natural healing abilities!
    • University of Pennsylvania Health System
    • University of Maryland Medical Center
Therapeutic touch is a kind of healing that uses a practice called “laying on of hands” to correct or balance energy fields. Despite the use of the word “touch,” the hands usually hover over the body and don’t physically touch it.
    • The Cleveland Clinic 
Reiki is a form of hands-on, natural healing that uses universal life force energy. The term comes from the Japanese words “rei,” which translates into universal, and “ki,” which means vital life force energy that flows through all living things. This gentle energy is limitless in abundance and is believed to be a spiritual form of energy. It is not tied to any specific religion or nationality.
The Reiki practitioner is the conduit between you and the source of the universal life force energy. The energy flows through the practitioner’s energy field and through his or her hands to you. The energy does not come from the practitioner; it comes through the practitioner from the universal source.
    • New York University Medical Center
I only mentioned some of institutions that are involved with medical education or are considered one of the best US medical institutions. Many more community hospitals are offering reiki and lists can be found on the net (I could not, in good faith, click on their ‘agree’ button). If you Google reiki and hospitals you can find various lists of hospital that offer this and other forms of magic to the ill. And proudly I might add. And it seems that this particular form of pseudo-medicine has a real East coast popularity; and here I thought it was the West Coast that was the center of all things flakey.
One would think if the fundamental thesis of a human energy field could he disproven by a fourth grader, Harvard or the Columbia could figure out that reiki was bunkum. Guess not.
Usually when patients receive ministrations from those representing a higher energy and belief systems (I am thinking clergy here), it is a free service for the patient. Belief systems are usually provided free, or at least should be. And, to point out, with no little irony,
a Catholic who puts his or her trust in Reiki would be operating in the realm of superstition, the no-man’s-land that is neither faith nor science
I have this semi-pateralistic idea that health care providers and institutions are not supposed to offer worthless and imaginary therapies to ill people for money. We have a higher standard to follow.
Well, we did. Past tense.
I cannot find much on the medical ethics of offering worthless alternative therapies by health care providers, universities, hospitals and other institutions. Kimball Atwood has discussed the issue, but most of the references speak to SCAM issues that surround the patient-physician relationship: how to respond to a patient who desires a SCAM. I can nothing on the ethics of offering reiki, homeopathy or other fantasies.
The day of the private practice doctor is on the wane and most of us work for or will work for large institutions. I can also find nothing on the ethics of institutionalizing magical therapies outside of Hogwarts.
Offering reiki may not be legal fraud, although given the right set of circumstances evidently it can be, but it is not right. Evidently that ethical standards and integrity are not important to the major medical institutions in the US.
And energy therapies do not even make the patient feel better as is so often thought. As a recent study on energy healing showed:
Whereas it is generally assumed that CAMs such as healing have beneficial effects on well-being, our results indicated no overall effectiveness of energy healing on QoL, depressive symptoms, mood, and sleep quality in colorectal cancer patients. Effectiveness of healing on well-being was, however, related to factors such as self-selection and a positive attitude toward the treatment.
Similar to acupuncture, and probably all of SCAM, energy therapies have effects on subjective outcomes only if patients think it will work. While I often refer to these interventions as beer goggles, they are also self-fulfilling wishful thinking.
If you want a litmus test to see if your local medical institution may not by particularly concerned with reality, that their Board of Directors is not paying much attention to quality, and the institution prefers money and magic, see if they offer reiki. Or acupuncture, reflexology, craniosacral therapy, or has a naturopath on staff who provides homeopathic nostrums.
As I think about, it would probably be harder to find a large hospital that doesn’t offer at last one of these pseudo-medicines.
I will finish with the following quote, from The Ethics of Alternative Medicine: An Alternative Standard?
When we offer alternative treatments, we advise our patients, treat them and then cash their checks. We respond to a demand in the marketplace, hoping to help patients and then profit from it. We might help our patients, but there is no proven benefit to the treatment we offer. We assume we will not hurt them, but the safety of what we do is not really proven to today’s randomized, controlled standards, either. Aren’t we more like snake oil salesmen when we pitch alternative medicine to our patients?
To be sure, we all have much to gain by embracing change in medicine. Other cultures and non-Western medical traditions have much to teach those of us who are open-minded enough to listen. The list of “traditional” medical advances that have grown out of “alternative” avenues is long and important. In this environment, it is more crucial than ever not to lose sight of our responsibilities. Patients come to us for help in filtering. They trust that our traditions of integrity and scientific inquiry will help us to help them navigate a bewildering array of health care offerings. They could go to an herbalist or an acupuncturist or a massage therapist for alternative treatments alone. Instead, some of them visit us for a “scientific” seal of approval.
We must respond to our patients’ trust with integrity. Let’s do more soul-searching before we advise patients about untested therapies. Let’s make sure we are not administering acupuncture needles or gingko to patients just because of market demands. We must insist that clinical trials test alternative approaches before we embrace them. We would not place our patients on methotrexate before learning that it was safe and effective. Let’s not give them magnetic treatments without the same standard. That’s not “alternative medicine,” or even “traditional medicine”; it’s just good medicine.
As I have said before, Sisyphus had it easy.

Emotional Freedom Technique – Acupuncture for the Mind
Emotional Freedom Technique is based in pseudoscience and inadequate clinical research.
Steven Novella on April 27, 2022
Link

The Emotional Freedom Technique (EFT), also referred to as tapping therapy or energy psychology, has been gaining popularity both as a self-help technique and psychological intervention. However, it remains firmly in the realm of pseudoscience, and reveals significant weaknesses in the psychological research infrastructure.
EFT is based explicitly on acupuncture/acupressure points, specific locations on so-called “meridians” in the body where “energy” flows. Here is a typical definition:
EFT works by tapping on acupressure meridians to release blockages. When these blockages are released, the problem feeling can be released and move through the body. The process starts with a beginning statement of what the problem feeling is and includes a complete acceptance and acknowledgement of the problem.
This “energy” allegedly ties negative emotions to an idea or thought, and proponents claim you can free yourself from those negative emotions by tapping energy points while repeating a reminder phrase. This, of course, is magical nonsense. Every component of this claim is not only prescientific superstition, they have been adequately shown to not be true.
Let’s start with the fact that acupuncture points do not exist. A literature review found that acupuncturists cannot agree on where specific points are supposed to be, and cannot agree on which points to what. Even if we set aside the fatal problem that there is no physiological, neurological, or anatomical basis for the existence of energy points in the body, a hundred years of clinical research has found that there isn’t even agreement on where they are supposed to be. Even when there is a general idea, the uncertainty is so great that the acupuncture “point” could be anywhere within a large area on the body.
None of this is surprising, given the history of acupuncture points. Originally there were alleged to be 365 points, one for each day of the year. This is because the very underlying concept of acupuncture is astrological – with points reflected astrological concepts of the heavens.
Looked at another way, the existence, location, and function of alleged acupuncture points is purely a result of tradition, philosophy, and belief. There is no body of scientific research that establishes their existence or location. This is why there are different traditions of acupuncture points that vary with culture – because the very idea is purely cultural, not based in reality.
Further, there is zero evidence for the existence of any form of “life energy” or chi. This was always a conceptual placeholder, a prescientific notion that essentially was credited for any life phenomenon we could not currently explain. Modern biology, however, has completely pushed aside the need for appealing to a vague life energy. And again, not surprisingly, there is no body of evidence established that anything like life energy exists. The same is true of meridians.
So, if life energy, meridians, and acupressure points do not exist, how could tapping them have a specific psychological effect? The short answer is, it can’t. And yet there are many clinical studies that show an apparent benefit from EFT for anxiety, fatigue, stress, depression, and PTSD. Most of these studies are small and have methodological issues, but beyond that this type of clinical research is extremely challenging. The outcomes are largely subjective and highly amenable to placebo effects, including demand characteristics, introducing a novel element into therapy, and regression to the mean. Further, there is a component of EFT that is essentially exposure therapy and cognitive behavior therapy, which can be effective on their own.
It’s hard to imagine a more challenging clinical research challenge, to properly control for and tease apart the various non-specific and placebo effects from the claims of energy psychology. Not surprisingly, the literature fails to adequately make these distinctions, despite claims by proponents that it does. On the one hand we have thorough and reliable scientific evidence and reasoning that concludes life energy and acupoints do not exist, on the other hand we have very difficult, unreliable, and contaminated psychological studies. I know which evidence I find more compelling. It would be possible to convince me that EFT works, but it would take a much higher threshold of evidence than currently exists – and that is the core problem here. Practitioners are too quick to accept preliminary evidence in the face of extreme scientific implausibility.
Interestingly, one supporter of EFT had some skeptical questions about how it works (while being insufficiently skeptical of if it works). They wrote:
I wanted to understand more about how tapping allegedly interrupts the body’s fight or flight signal from the brain. Why does tapping result in emotional and cognitive shifts? If we can influence the body’s fight or flight response system by tapping, why does it only work in the positive? Can we make ourselves feel worse by tapping? What if you aren’t very precise in your tapping, does it still work? Does tapping harder or softer affect results at all? If you are physically incapable of tapping some of the points (say if you only have one arm) does it still work? If so, how important was that tapping point in the first place?
Those are all great questions. Real physical effects should be affected by things like dose-response and precision, and would likely have the potential for negative effects. Placebo effects, however, are not dependent on such things.
What about the clinical research? It is generally positive, but when you take a closer look it is apparent, in my opinion, that this reflects the inadequate quality of the research. Most of the studies do not have adequate controls or blinding, which are absolutely critical in this context with such a high potential for non-specific and placebo effects. The best-controlled studies tend to be negative.
A meta-analysis of EFT for anxiety, for example, found no difference in outcome between EFT and EMDR, although there was a benefit beyond other groups (usual care, for example). EMDR is another psychological intervention that is popular but suffers the same problems as EFT, in that there is no basis for a specific effect. It is, ironically, a great control for EFT because it would share all of the non-specific elements of treatment. So it’s interesting that the there was no difference between the two treatments.
What I would like to see going forward is highly rigorous clinical research. This requires pre-registration of study protocols. A recent meta-analysis of homeopathy trials found significant reporting bias in the literature. When all studies were included in the analysis there was a positive outcome. When the analysis was limited only to pre-registered trials, the effect entirely went away. Homeopathy is another great example to use because we know with very high confidence that it does not work, so it is a very telling window on the literature.
We also know from acupuncture studies how hard it can be to properly double-blind a physical treatment. When we finally got to well-blinded acupuncture studies, the effects also vanished. This is even more important in psychological studies, where demand characteristics (subtle cues that give subjects information about what kind of response is expected from them) are a huge problem.
In short, the research is nowhere near where it would need to be to properly establish EFT as having specific efficacy, even without the fact that it is based on pure pseudoscience without any basis in reality.

What Is Somatic Therapy?
Steven Novella on February 28, 2024
Link

Is modern medicine descending into pseudoscience, or is scientific medicine still going strong? Unfortunately, I think both of these things can happen at the same time. On the one hand, scientific research in medicine is progressing nicely. We are seeing the results of scientific breakthroughs made decades ago, with monoclonal antibody therapies, new therapeutic targets, the beginning of real genetic therapy, brain-machine interface applications, and many others. Advanced scientific medicine is not going anywhere.
But at the same time I feel that we have lost the cultural narrative on health and disease. Gurus, health influencers, snake oil peddlers, the supplement industry, paraprofessionals, and science deniers have had a massive impact on the broader culture. The health industry has been “goopified”. A lot of alternative medicine talking points have been internalized – especially the notion that there is an alternative to real medicine. Ideas such as being “natural”, irrational fear of toxins, and that all problems are potentially nutritional, are often not even questioned, or recognized as an underlying assumption.
One such alternative narrative is the mind-body connection. This one is complex, because there is a mind body connection, but the CAM wellness version is to go way beyond the actual relationship to claim some mystical mysterious connection, usually to justify a familiar list of dubious treatments. One manifestation of this phenomenon is so-called “somatic therapy”.
Here is an explanation of what that is, from Harvard:
“A somatic therapist helps people release damaging, pent-up emotions in their body by using various mind-body techniques. These can vary widely, ranging from acupressure and hypnosis to breathwork and dance.”
The idea is that negative emotions or the effects of psychological trauma can become “trapped” in the body. This begins with a well-established premise, that psychological stress can manifest physically, and takes it a few steps further, beyond the evidence and beyond reason. In so doing it likely reverses the arrow of causation.
To quickly summarize a large and complex body of literature, what does happen is that anxiety, depression, or stress have specific physical manifestations. They can disturb sleep, cause muscle tension, and release stress hormones. They can even sometimes cause specific neurological symptoms. Those physical manifestations may have their own consequences, and even feed back into the negative emotional state. A lack of sleep, for example, can exacerbate anxiety and depression. Somatic symptoms can make people who are already anxious even more anxious about their health.
The standard approach to such situations is essentially to treat everything – treat the underlying psychological stressor while managing the physical manifestations. Improve the sleep, treat the muscle tension, but also treat the anxiety with proven interventions.
Somatic therapy goes beyond that approach, claiming that the muscle tension, for example, is now causing the anxiety by trapping it in the body. It would be one thing if this were just a metaphor, but it isn’t. It is a reframing of standard medical care into wellness speak, establishing a basis for whatever “mind-body” intervention the practitioner wants to sell. Look at the short list given above – acupressure, breathwork, and dance.
Acupressure is complete nonsense, based upon pseudoscience. There are no acupoints, there is no chi or meridians, and there is no evidence that any intervention based upon these prescientific notions have any specific benefit.
Breathwork is just more of the same phenomenon – slow breathing, which can certainly be relaxing. But proponents add the claim without justification that it actually works through a physical effect, altering vagal tone. As evidence they point to heart rate variability, a noisy measure with unclear implications that serves well as a Rorschach test.
The result of all this is an internal system of claims and philosophy, mostly based on placebo effects, with hand-waving claims about mechanism, and all based on the thinnest of evidence. This resembles a prescientific system of medicine, like the four humors.
Practitioners are just going with what sounds good, based upon an evolving wellness mythology. But at no point do they do high quality science that actually addresses the fundamental question – are these claims true? Does the intervention have any specific efficacy? Is the underlying philosophy based in reality?
Unless you use science to sincerely address these questions there will be a tendency for belief and practice to drift off into fantasy land. That basically describes the entire wellness industry. Without a solid grounding in science, the only real feedback loops are – what feels good, and what makes money.


Pain Reprocessing Therapy
In a trial of Pain Reprocessing Therapy (PRT), 2/3 of patients with chronic low back pain reported significant pain relief with psychotherapy that helped them reconceptualize the pain as nondangerous. Impressive if true, but flaws in research design make the study untrustworthy.
Harriet Hall on May 3, 2022
Link

I don’t usually get my medical information from Reader’s Digest, but when I read their report on Pain Reprocessing Therapy (PRT), I was able to easily find the research it was based on: a randomized clinical trial titled “Effect of Pain Reprocessing Therapy vs. Placebo and Usual Care for Patients with Chronic Back Pain” by Ashar et al. published in JAMA Psychiatry in 2022. Does “mind over matter” work? The results were intriguing but the methodology was flawed.
The researchers asked “Can a psychological treatment based on the reappraisal of primary chronic back pain as due to nondangerous central nervous system processes provide substantial and durable pain relief?” The etiology of chronic back pain is unknown for 85% of patients, and persistence is influenced by “fear, avoidance, and beliefs that pain indicates injury.”
This was the first test of PRT. 151 subjects with low to moderately severe chronic low back pain were enrolled. 54% were female, duration of pain was 10 years, and disability was rated 23.34 out of 100. Subjects were randomized into 3 groups.
Interventions
Participants randomized to PRT participated in 1 telehealth session with a physician and 8 psychological treatment sessions over 4 weeks. Treatment aimed to help patients reconceptualize their pain as due to nondangerous brain activity rather than peripheral tissue injury, using a combination of cognitive, somatic, and exposure-based techniques. Participants randomized to placebo received an open-label subcutaneous saline injection in the back [they were told placebos were effective treatment]; participants randomized to usual care continued their routine, ongoing care.
Patients were followed for one year and MRIs were done.
Clinical outcomes
66% of patients in the PRT group were pain-free or nearly pain-free post treatment, compared to 20% in the placebo group and 10% in the usual care group. Large reductions in pain for the PRT group continued for a year after treatment. fMRI effect sizes were described as “modest”.
Caveats
    • This is the first study of PRT; it would be unwise to rely on it before other studies are done. Initial studies are often promising but subsequent studies tend to be less promising or even negative.
    • Results may not be generalizable to the entire population of patients with chronic low back pain or with other types of pain.
    • The control groups were not appropriate. The placebo group was told placebos were effective and were given open-label injections of saline. The comparison to a usual-care group was fruitless, since we know any interventions beyond usual care will always give positive results. The A + B vs. A design has been criticized by Edzard Ernst and others.
Conclusion
Can the level of pain in 2/3 of patients with chronic low back pain be reduced by psychological treatments that help patients reconceptualize their pain as non-dangerous? These results would be very exciting if true, but they are suspect for the reasons given. I sincerely hope PRT will be validated by further research, but I can’t recommend it on the basis of present evidence.

Can Airrosti Really Resolve Most Chronic Pain in Just Three Visits?
Harriet Hall on November 4, 2014
Link
A correspondent asked me to look into Airrosti because her employer’s insurance company had started covering it, and she was skeptical. She had tried to look up its effectiveness and safety record on the Internet and hadn’t found much. The information on their website didn’t tell me what I wanted to know, so I did a little digging. Like my correspondent, I am skeptical of their claims.
The name Airrosti stands for Applied Integration for the Rapid Recovery of Soft Tissue Injuries. One writer jokingly renamed it Owwwrosti because his first treatment was so excruciatingly painful. They say, “Wherever you hurt, we can help.” They claim to have special knowledge about the underlying cause of soft tissue injuries and pain problems and how to treat them; they claim they can resolve the problems of most of their patients in only 3 visits. The providers are chiropractors who have been trained by the company in their special methods…whatever they are. Their website is vague about what their modality actually consists of. I was able to piece together some of what they are doing from discussion groups and patient reports. There are plenty of testimonials, and the treatments are described as painful but effective. They offer quality 1-on-1 care for an entire hour, with detailed examination, hands-on soft tissue therapy, foam rolling, instruction in exercise and rehabilitation, and Kinesio Taping. Their main competitors are said to be the Graston technique and Gua Sha technique, and their treatment appears to be centered on myofascial release (MFR). In other words, it’s a mixed bag.

Myofascial release
Myofascial release is an umbrella term for several overlapping and allegedly advanced techniques and styles of manipulating muscles and fascia (sheets of connective tissue). The other word for all that is “massage.” The major common denominator for the various flavors of MFR is the much ballyhooed notion that fascia has clinically important properties. In fact, there is only a vague scientific rationale and inadequate evidence for any kind of myofascial release.
Wherever you see “myofascial release,” extraordinary claims of efficacy are likely to follow. For instance, the UK Advertising Standards Authority received a complaint in 2011 about claims from a company in the UK similar to Airrosti that offered “integrated myofascial therapy.” Their investigation determined that there was no robust evidence that MFR was an effective treatment for any of the conditions listed, and that the company was in violation of advertising codes. Similarly, the Aetna insurance company does not cover myofascial release and Kinesio Taping because it considers them experimental and investigational.
Airrosti’s methods are reportedly based on the fascial distortion model developed by the late Stephen Typaldos, DO. Apparently he trained a female physical therapist in his methods, then decided not to train any other PTs after she told patients she had developed the methods herself. Later she sold her business concept to entrepreneurs who started training chiropractors. Typaldos described six principal types of fascial distortions, each with its own body language and signature presentation. He tested his model for over 15 years in his own practice; in addition to treating injuries he treated conditions as diverse as Osgood-Schlatter disease, backaches, headaches, sciatica, chronic pain, and kidney stones. The AFDMA (American Fascial Distortion Model Association) was created after his death to continue his work and to educate the medical community. There are also FDM associations in Burkina Faso, Europe and Japan. They recently held a World Congress in San Antonio.
As far as I can determine, Typaldos did not publish any studies. He wrote a book but it is out of print and a used copy sells for $342.84, so needless to say I didn’t read it. On PubMed, a search for “Typaldos” located a single study, not by him but using his model to treat frozen shoulder. A search for “fascial distortion model” brought up only that same article plus one other that was irrelevant, a rabbit study comparing various materials for vaginal sling surgery.
The company’s evidence
So, no evidence in PubMed, but the Airrosti website claims to have evidence. They say:
Airrosti has been proven, through extensive third-party research and analysis, to be the most effective, efficient, and affordable option for resolving musculoskeletal conditions.
And they claim “measurable” prevention of surgeries, hospitalization, MRIs, injections, and pharmaceuticals for back pain and other musculoskeletal conditions.
I wrote the company asking where I could read the details of that third-party research and received this reply:
Thank you for your inquiry and I apologize for the delayed response. I have attached our stats that breakdown our reported outcomes. At Airrosti, our goal is to make an immediate impact on your injury, usually within the first 1-2 treatments and I am confident we can help alleviate any symptoms/pain you may be having. We will detail a personalized treatment plan for you, which will specify the amount of treatments necessary to improve your condition.
The attachment was a copyrighted PDF that prohibits redistribution or any other use without the expressed written consent of Airrosti. It is an internal company document describing patient-reported outcomes for 62,595 patients, based on questionnaires that patients filled out at their last visit. The data are broken down in several ways. One table shows that 89.6% of patients said Airrosti had resolved their injury/condition, 5,516 individuals said Airrosti had helped prevent a recommended surgery, 93.8% said it had helped them eliminate/reduce medications taken, and 92.3% said it prevented further medical services such as PT and chiropractic visits.
Another table seems to contradict that one. It says that at their last visit, only 60.2% of patients reported their condition “much improved,” and 33.9% “improved.” In another table, 37.4% reported no pain at last visit, 46.2% very little pain, 13.9% moderate pain. The numbers don’t add up, and they don’t tell us how many patients failed to complete the discharge survey or dropped out. They only tell us how patients reported their improvement at the time of the last visit; there was no long-term follow-up. Did the improvement last? Were the patient reports accurate? How much of the perceived improvement was a placebo response? There’s no way to know. The endpoints are all subjective self-reports; there are no measurable objective findings by third parties or even from Airrosti’s own providers, no way to quantify how many surgeries were actually avoided, and no attempt to compare Airrosti outcomes with the outcomes of other treatment methods. There is no attempt at using any kind of controls that might put their numbers into perspective. This information certainly doesn’t qualify as “third-party research” or as proving Airrosti to be the best approach. It is hard to see it as anything more than self-serving internally-generated advertising propaganda.
There are some good signs in the data. The average patient had 3.2 visits to Airrosti. Of patients who chose Airrosti as the first treatment option, 2.4% were referred to specialists. So at least they are recognizing that some patients require more than they can offer, and they are not sucking customers into long treatment plans.
When I complained that they had not forwarded any third-party research, I got an e-mail from “Dr. Jason Garrett,” who is not a medical doctor but a chiropractor and the company’s vice-president of clinical development. He provided a table, with the Airrosti logo, of “cost comparative data provided by Compass Professional Health Services, based on an independent regional analysis of episodic treatment costs according to specific injury/condition diagnosis codes.” It shows average costs for Airrosti cases and for cases without Airrosti, tabulated by knee, back, and other areas of the body. It also shows average post-Airrosti care costs, which are substantial; one can only wonder why care would be needed post-treatment if treatment is as effective as they claim. It shows Airrosti costs as lower across the board. I guess this could be considered “third-party research,” and it is consistent with the quality of other research that has been known to impress some chiropractors. But it doesn’t describe the methods used, the diagnoses, the treatments provided, or the source of the data, and there could be any number of confounders. I don’t think any conclusions can be drawn from such incomplete data, especially when presented second-hand.
The information they sent me doesn’t justify the claims the company makes (that it is proven, through extensive third-party research and analysis, to be the most effective, efficient, and affordable option for resolving musculoskeletal conditions and that it has measurably prevented surgeries, hospitalization, MRIs, injections, and pharmaceuticals). If Airrosti can really provide less expensive and more effective treatment than other sources of care, I’m all for it; but they haven’t made their case.
Conclusion
There is not enough evidence to determine whether Airrosti is safe or effective, much less whether it’s the best treatment method out there. They appear to have a lot of satisfied customers; but then, so do homeopaths and purveyors of snake oil. I hope they will eventually do some credible research. And if their methods prove to be effective, I hope they will share the details of what they are doing with other practitioners so that patients everywhere can benefit. For the time being, prospective Airrosti customers should understand that the treatment is still in the investigational stage, that they are essentially guinea pigs in an uncontrolled experiment, and that some insurance companies will not pay for it. Airrosti may be the greatest thing since sliced bread, but I will withhold judgment until they can offer some actual evidence from controlled studies.

Does massage therapy decrease inflammation and stimulate mitochondrial growth? An intriguing study oversold
David Gorski on February 13, 2012
Link
If there’s one form of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) that I find more tolerable than most, it’s massage therapy. The reason, of course, is that, whatever else anyone claims about massage, there’s no doubt that it feels good. Indeed, I’ve sort of come around to Kimball Atwood’s way of thinking. Back when he and I were on a panel together at TAM9, Kimball said something somewhat surprising, namely that he’s not sure we even need to test massage in randomized clinical trials because we all know that it feels good and if it feels good it can certainly be helpful at the very least to improve patients’ quality of life. Unfortunately, there’s a lot of woo in massage these days, and massage therapists who buy into the woo aren’t satisfied with simply using the rationale that massage feels good to recommend it to patients. They just can’t resist going beyond that to infuse massage therapy with every bit as much woo as any chiropractor or acupuncturist infuses into his respective specialty. For instance, some of the claims for massage include:
    • Decreases muscle pain & tension.
    • Rejuvenates the body and mind and lifts the spirit.
    • Relieves anxiety, stress and tension.
    • Relaxes muscles.
    • Alleviates headaches.
    • Hastens healing.
    • Increases ranges of motion.
    • Facilitates removal of waste and inflammation by-products.
    • Stimulates the immune system.
    • Eases symptoms related to fibromyalgia.
    • Promotes relaxation and comfort.
    • Reduces nausea in pregnant women.
    • Accelerates weight gain in premature infants.
    • Helps premature infants become more active and aware.
    • Increases energy and alertness.
    • Enhances morale and attitude.
Of course, there’s little doubt that a good massage probably can relax muscles, promote relaxation and comfort (which seems like the same thing to me), and enhance morale and attitude. I’d even be willing to concede that massage, properly administered, can probably also alleviate headaches (tension headaches, anyway) and increase range of motion in joints. But facilitate the removal of waste and inflammation byproducts? Stimulate the immune system (the all-purpose meaningless claim)? Hasten healing? Not so much.
All too often massage therapists ruin a perfectly good massage by imposing pseudoscientific and quack claims on it, such as claims that they are stimulating acupressure points or their adoption of the language of “energy healing.” Our own assistant editor, Paul Ingraham, a former massage therapist, has thoroughly covered claims about massage therapy and myofascial pain.
So it was with a bit of trepidation (but also more than a bit of interest) that I took a look at some links that readers sent me about a week ago (too late, alas, for me to write about this last Monday). These links were to news stories with titles like Scientists Uncover Why Massage Heals Sore Muscles and Massage Reduces Inflammation And Promotes Growth Of New Mitochondria Following Strenuous Exercise, Study Finds. My first impression, actually, was that this was somewhat counterintuitive in that one might predict that deep kneading of muscles might actually cause a bit of inflammation and that it’s the counterirritation effect that leads to the perceived reduction in the amount of pain. Yet, according to the press release issued by McMasters University, whose contents were mirrored in many news stories, a study claiming state-of-the-art methods is concluding that massage is reducing inflammation:
Most athletes can testify to the pain-relieving, recovery-promoting effects of massage. Now there’s a scientific basis that supports booking a session with a massage therapist: On the cellular level massage reduces inflammation and promotes the growth of new mitochondria in skeletal muscle. The research, involving scientists from the Buck Institute for Research on Aging and McMaster University in Hamilton Ontario appears in the February 1st online edition of Science Translational Medicine.
The study involved the genetic analysis of muscle biopsies taken from the quadriceps of eleven young males after they had exercised to exhaustion on a stationary bicycle. One of their legs was randomly chosen to be massaged. Biopsies were taken from both legs prior to the exercise, immediately after 10 minutes of massage treatment and after a 2.5 hour period of recovery.
My first thought upon reading this press release was that this was rather interesting and I wanted to find out more. My second thought, which turned out to be correct, was that the investigators were totally overselling their preliminary results.
Unfortunately, my third thought was: Muscle biopsies? Really? Although it is possible to do a needle biopsy of the muscle, most of the time muscle biopsies are surgical procedures, and, although the description of how the muscle biopsies were done is maddeningly vague in this paper, they do not appear to have been needle biopsies, which could not have provided enough tissue to do all the tests the investigators ran. In any case, I’ve done muscle biopsies before. They involve making an incision, carrying it down to the fascia overlying the muscle, cutting into the fascia, and then taking a piece of muscle. Sure, muscle biopsies can be done under local anaesthesia, and they’re not big procedures, but they are surgical procedures, in this case, being done for no therapeutic intent on healthy volunteers. One wonders how the investigators got this study past the Institutional Review Board (IRB), because I know for sure that the IRBs at the two institutions where I’ve been on the faculty would probably have—shall we say?—challenged the investigators on their experimental design. Yet approved this study was by the McMaster University Research Ethics Board. Leaving aside the problems I have from an ethics standpoint of doing not one, not two, but five (!) unnecessary muscle biopsies on research subjects, the next question I have is whether this study actually shows what the investigators claim it shows. To do that, I went straight to the source, namely the study in Science Translational Research by Crane et al. entitled Massage Therapy Attenuates Inflammatory Signaling After Exercise-Induced Muscle Damage. Here’s one of the investigators discussing the study:
Buck Institute Faculty Simon Melov, PhD, Discusses Recent Study on Molecular Benefits of Massage Therapy Following Exercise from Buck Institute on Vimeo.
When I first heard of this study, I couldn’t make up my mind whether it was good science, a fishing expedition that got lucky, or woo-omics. Then I got around to looking up the study, and I wondered if I was the only one disturbed by its design. Its big problem is that the investigators didn’t strike me as having a strong enough preclinical data base to justify doing a clinical trial in which medically unnecessary invasive procedures were carried out on healthy people and then whole genome mRNA expression profiling carried out. From my perspective, before doing five muscle biopsies on research subjects, there should be evidence from other less invasive (or preferably noninvasive) methods compelling enough to justify such an expensive study using invasive testing methods on humans. Yet, here is the authors’ justification:
Massage therapy is a well-known form of alternative medicine that consists of physical manipulation of muscle and connective tissue at a site of injury, inflexibility, or soreness to reduce pain and promote recovery (1, 2). Massage has been hypothesized to moderate inflammation, improve blood flow, and reduce tissue stiffness, resulting in a diminished sensation of pain. The potential benefits of massage could be useful to a broad spectrum of individuals including the elderly, those suffering from musculoskeletal injuries, and patients with chronic inflammatory conditions. About 18 million individuals undergo massage therapy annually in the United States, making it the fifth most widely used form of CAM (1). The functional benefits of massage remain contentious in humans (2–4), and experiments using massage therapy in animals may not properly mimic the human responses, limiting their usefulness. Despite several reports that long-term massage therapy reduces chronic pain and improves range of motion in clinical trials (5–7), the biological effects of massage on skeletal muscle tissue remain unclear.
After going on about various aspects of inflammation, which is what happens to muscle when it’s overworked because there are small tears in the myofibrillar structure of the muscle. So, basically, the authors’ hypothesis seems to be that massage somehow mediates inflammation and their rationale for choosing the study design they chose was that animal models may not mimic human responses, an assertion that, I note, the authors make without citing references to back it up. Is that enough to justify a clinical trial with this many muscle biopsies? I say no, but obviously the McMaster University Research Ethics Board did not agree. I also did not at all like how the authors bought into the language of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), referring to massage therapy as “alternative medicine.” It is not, or, at least, it should not be considered so. The extent that massage is “alternative” depends directly on the amount of woo overlaid on it. It is, after all, physiologically plausible that manipulating muscles can do something to inhibit or release cytokines or other factors that might either increase or decrease inflammation. Of course, this plausibility should have been explored in an appropriate animal model before moving straight to human studies.
Preliminary results overblown
There is little doubt that this particular study is the most “high tech” study ever done on massage therapy in that some fairly heavy duty genomic techniques were brought to bear on the question of what gene changes occur (1) after heavy exercise and (2) in response to massage therapy. It’s a small study (only 11 subjects), which means that there’s the potential for a lot of noise, which further means that the results had better be striking (i.e., at least a two-fold or better change in gene expression) to be suggestive or convincing, and that replication is needed. The former definitely didn’t apply, and the latter is awaited, although I don’t think that I’d want to repeat a study that involves five muscle biopsies per subject.
Let’s take a look at the trial design itself, as shown in Figure 1 (click for full size):
As you can see, there are two visits and a total of five biopsies performed on each subject, one baseline and then two performed on each leg, before and after massage of one leg and before and after no massage on the opposite leg. Total RNA was isolated from these muscle biopsy samples, which were also subjected to additional testing, which will be discussed later. First, since it was the aspect of this study that caught my attention (and that of other scientists), I’m going to look at the results of the whole genome expression profiling. For those of you not familiar with this technique, it basically involves simultaneously measuring the levels of messenger RNAs (mRNAs) for every known gene in the genome. This is done by hybridizing the total mRNA isolated with probes designed to bind to each mRNA coded by the genome. These probes are housed on a chip, and the binding (or lack of binding) can be read by the machine. It’s all very complicated, with several probes designed for normalization, but when it’s done the results of each chip can be compared to other chips, and the results are usually reported as log2 results (i.e. “1” means a two-fold difference between control and experimental; “2” a four-fold difference, etc., with negative numbers meaning a decrease by the same factor). Ten years ago these cDNA microarrays, as they’re called, were state of the art. They aren’t now. Next generation sequencing (NGS) techniques, such as RNAseq, are, but that doesn’t mean cDNA microarrays aren’t still useful. NGS probably would have been overkill for this study—or at least prohibitively expensive.
One thing that I immediately noticed about this study is that it didn’t exactly use what is state-of-the-art analysis techniques on the data that were generated. Basically, they analyzed their data pretty much the same way I analyzed microarray data back in 2005, which was to look at single genes that had the most profound increase or decrease in expression compared to control. In this case, each subject served as his own control because these were muscle biopsies done before and after massage therapy or control intervention (i.e., no intervention). These days, more sophisticated analyses, known as network analyses, are usually done. These involve looking for groups of genes that are turned on and off in synchrony that indicate broader pathways that are being turned on and off. Single genes don’t actually mean all that much. It’s the groups of genes going up and down together as part of a pathway that truly indicate specific pathways being turned on and off. To get an idea of what these sorts of analyses look like, check out Figure 5 in this paper. Instead, what we get is a circa 2005 gene list not unlike the ones I produced (click for full size):
The first thing I noticed about this list is that it’s a short list, particularly compared to the number of genes that changed in response to exercise:
Independent of the massage treatment, the control leg muscle exhibited a change in 943 probes (representing 592 genes) at 0 hours after massage (30 min after exercise) and 2307 probes (representing 1309 genes) at 2.5 hours after massage (3 hours after exercise), significant changes that were induced by exercise alone (tables S1 and S2).
In other words, these five genes were a tiny subset of the genes altered by exercise to exhaustion. Less impressive is that none of them were particularly strongly turned on or turned off. The gene most turned on only reached a level 1.68 times control at time zero after massage and was not detectably different from control by 2.5 hours. The gene most turned off only decreased to 0.73 times control, a 27% decrease. Not impressive, at least not to me. This was particularly true after I perused the supplemental data list, in which I found a whole bunch of genes whose expression appeared to change more than this, due to exercise. Unfortunately, the authors didn’t include the table I really wanted to see, namely the table doing the head-to-head comparison of massage versus no massage.
Now, let’s see what the authors said about the identity of the genes whose mRNA levels changed:
One of the five genes whose expression was altered by massage immediately after the treatment was functionally related to actin dynamics (filamin B, b) (Table 1). One of the four genes induced by massage after recovery from treatment (2.5 hours) was related to NFκB nuclear trafficking (nucleoporin 88) (Table 1). Overall, this profile suggested that massage altered processes related to the cytoskeleton the former process being activated early after massage and the latter induced later in recovery.
I found this very questionable based on my own experience analyzing a cDNA microarray. The reason is that what I found my gene of interest to do was to decrease nuclear factor-κB (NF-κB) signaling. I’ve also done studies looking at the nuclear localization of NF-κB using confocal microscopy and NF-κB. When NF-κB is activated or turned off in my experience the changes seen in whole-genome expression profiling assays are not subtle and do not involve just a single gene, like nucleoporin, whose messenger RNA was elevated (but, it should be noted, whose protein was never verified to be also elevated after massage). NF-κB changes the activity of dozens of genes in a pattern that’s so obvious that when I showed my initial microarray results to an NF-κB expert several years ago, he immediately recognized that pattern by “eyeballing it” (and now I can recognize that pattern too). The changes were also much more dramatic. Indeed, I was looking at fold-changes that ranged from two-fold to over a hundred-fold. While it is true that I was studying cultured cells, which are an inherently less noisy system than tissue biopsies, I would have still expected to see a lot more genes altered if massage were truly impacting inflammation in general and the NF-κB signaling pathway in particular.
So how did Crane et al. come to the conclusion that NF-κB was being affected? Basically, they observed that nucleoporin 88 was expressed at an increased level on the cDNA microarray. If that were truly related to NF-κB signaling in stressed muscle, we would expect that massage would increase, not decrease, NF-κB signaling because nucleoporin facilitates the entry of the NF-κB into the nucleus. Increased expression of nucleoporin 88 is associated with increased NF-κB activity, and depleting nucleoporin 88 results in decreased NF-κB signaling. Now, to be fair, the authors did follow up by measuring NF-κB level in the nucleus and found that nuclear NF-κB levels did appear to decrease at T=0 after massage but that by 2.5 hours there was no significant difference. This actually doesn’t really correlate with the changes in nucleoporin, which didn’t increase until 2.5 hours. To try to bolster their case, Crane et al. also looked at heat shock proteins and saw a decrease at 2.5 hours. They also looked at another inflammatory cytokine and noted a truly unimpressive decrease that was statistically significant at 2.5 hours. Finally, they saw an even less impressive decrease in tumor necrosis factor (another inflammatory cytokine) at 0 hrs that was statistically significant but was not significant at 2.5 hr. In other words, the data are not entirely consistent, nor is the magnitude of the decrease in inflammatory factors impressive or persistent. The authors might be correct in their interpretation, but what I see more than anything else is probably either noise or a mild effect that is probably not clinically significant.
Interestingly, contrary to many of the other claims made by massage therapists, anabolic signaling and muscle metabolites, such as lactate, macroglycogen, proglycogen, and total glycogen were unaffected by massage. So much for the idea of “washing out toxins” that we sometimes hear.
O Mitochondria, Mitochondria, wherefore art thou, mitochondria?
Finally, the authors looked at another signaling molecule, nuclear peroxisome proliferator–activated receptor γ coactivator 1α (PGC-1α), because they found evidence that upstream signaling pathways that activates PGC-1α were turned on by massage (hmmm, I have to be more careful about how I phrase things). Sure enough PGC-1α levels were slightly increased (by maybe about 20% to my eyeballing the graphs) at 2.5 hours after massage. However, contrary to the way some news outlets reported this story, the number of mitochondria did not increase. Worse, this is a misstatement promoted by Dr. Melov himself:
Buck Institute faculty Simon Melov, PhD, was responsible for the genetic analysis of the tissue samples. “Our research showed that massage dampened the expression of inflammatory cytokines in the muscle cells and promoted biogenesis of mitochondria, which are the energy-producing units in the cells,” said Melov. He added that the pain reduction associated with massage may involve the same mechanism as those targeted by conventional anti-inflammatory drugs. “There’s general agreement that massage feels good, now we have a scientific basis for the experience,” said Melov.
Uh, not quite. This paper doesn’t show that massage promotes biogenesis of mitochondria, only that massage might—I repeat, might—increase the level of one molecule that promotes the development of mitochondria by 20% at most. Paul Ingraham put it very well in his own article about this research:
What the authors actually reported is: “potentiated mitochondrial biogenesis signaling” and “promotes mitchondrial biogenesis.” In other words, they didn’t find more mitochondria … they found a mitochondrial growth signal. It’s the difference between finding bigger plants or just some bags of fertilizer.
Whether or not mitochondrial growth actually happens probably depends on many biological inputs, like everything else that our cells do. Inferring from one signal in a small sample that “massage increases mitochondria” is really just an enormous leap. Fortunately, the authors themselves didn’t make that leap — but lots of other people are making it.
Except that at least one of the investigators certainly is implying it very strongly—so much so that it’s a claim appearing in mainstream news articles about the study as though it were fact. As Paul also points out, the very design of this study indicates a lack of clinical insight into how massage therapy is usually used in the real world. What Crane et al. were studying was acute muscle injury in response to exercise to the point of exhaustion. Massage is not often used for that, and, in fact, as he summarizes, we already know that massage has only at best modest effects on exercise recovery; i.e., there isn’t much of a clinical benefit to explain. Rather, massage tends to be used used for chronic soreness. In fact, it might well be that a vigorous massage after a workout to the point where one’s muscles are so exhausted that one can’t even pedal a bicycle anymore would actually be painful.
When interesting results are oversold
My quibbles about the ethics of this study aside (well, they’re more than quibbles), scientifically this is not a bad study. However, as is so often the case in CAM studies, it is in the interpretation of the results that the authors go astray. They try to make something out of a mere five genes compared to hundreds that are changed by exercise when there doesn’t appear to be much to see. (In fact, my guess is that if they did a network analysis, the effect they observed would probably disappear into statistical insignificance.) They infer the wrong conclusion from the observation that nucleoporin 88 messenger RNA is elevated in muscle after massage. The correct inference would be to predict that NF-κB signaling should be elevated after massage, because nucleoporin 88 is involved in bringing NF-κB protein complex into the nucleus, where it does its stuff and turns on all the genes it turns on, which is why shutting down nucleoporin 88 inhibits NF-κB signaling. Yet they found that NF-κB signaling wasn’t increased but was rather decreased. Moreover, if the alterations in NF-κB signaling were significant, then there should have been a whole lot more than just a rather unremarkable change in the level of nucleoporin 88 messenger RNA. There should have been dozens of NF-κB target genes changing their levels in tandem because of NF-κB activation. There weren’t. Thus, the proper conclusion of this study is that there was little or no significant effect in inflammation-related gene expression from massage. That would have been perfectly fine as a conclusion. After all, negative studies happen and should be published.
Yet that’s not what was concluded. They did not report what was in essence a negative study.
Instead, the authors concluded that they had found that massage was anti-inflammatory, and that that’s how it “works.” They concluded that it “promoted mitochondrial biogenesis” without showing any evidence for anything other than the thinnest of thin evidence, a small increase in one signaling protein that promotes mitochondrial formation. And the news media ate it up.
None of this is to say that massage is useless or that it might not have therapeutic benefit in some circumstances. What this is to say is that this study, contrary to how it’s being portrayed, is not slam-dunk evidence that massage is some sort of “non-drug” treatment for inflammation that can replace non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Unfortunately, whether because the authors were naive or desperate to salvage something from a study that didn’t show very much, that’s not how it was sold. The media might be guilty of overselling this study, but at least one of the authors was either complicit or didn’t realize how his words would be represented. Now this study is out there; look for massage therapists who are into woo to be pointing to this study for years to come as “proof” that massage is anti-inflammatory and “regenerates mitochondria.”

Visceral Manipulation Embraced by the APTA
Harriet Hall on January 17, 2012
Link
Many years ago, when I was a naïve and gullible teenager, I read about a home treatment for constipation that involved rolling a bowling ball around on the abdomen. I was intrigued, thought it sounded reasonable, and might even have tried it myself if I had been constipated or had had a bowling ball to experiment with. Many decades later, with the advantages of a medical education and experience in science-based medicine and critical thinking, I encountered a treatment that reminded me of the bowling ball: visceral manipulation (VM), a practice developed by a French osteopath and physical therapist, Jean-Pierre Barral. This time I was far more skeptical. VM may be more sophisticated than a bowling ball, but its effectiveness and safety are equally dubious.
Visceral manipulation (VM) will probably be unfamiliar to most of my readers, but its promoters say it has been adopted by osteopathic physicians, “allopathic” physicians, doctors of chiropractic, doctors of Oriental medicine, naturopathic physicians, physical therapists, occupational therapists, massage therapists and other licensed body workers. Its origin follows the path of many other alternative health systems. Like chiropractic, ear acupuncture, iridology, EMDR, and others, it was developed by one individual based on his personal observations and experiences without any kind of proper testing. Like the others, it started with a single patient: in Ignaz von Peczely’s case an owl with a spot on its iris, in D.D. Palmer’s case a janitor whose hearing allegedly improved after something was done to his back, in Barral’s case a patient who said he had felt relief from his back pain after going to an “old man who pushed something in his abdomen.” From a single case they extrapolated to a general belief about disease causation and a whole diagnostic and/or treatment system.
How is VM Done?
A video shows Barral demonstrating his skills. He “listens with his hands” to detect tension (elsewhere the perception is designated as a thermal phenomenon). His diagnostic process begins by “listening with the hands” on the top of the patient’s head to determine the lateralization or general area of the problem. Then his hands “listen” to the areas of concern to further localize the problem. In this demonstration he detects something in the stomach which he says could be from decreased acidity or emotional tension. Then he listens to the skull repeatedly with both hands, does something simultaneously to the neck and abdomen, and finally he is satisfied that his hands are telling him that he has corrected the problem.
The Underlying Rationale
From the Barral Institute website:
Therapists using Visceral Manipulation assess the dynamic functional actions as well as the somatic structures that perform individual activities. They also evaluate the quality of the somatic structures and their functions in relation to an overall harmonious pattern, with motion serving as the gauge for determining quality.
The visceral system relies on the interconnected synchronicity between the motions of all the organs and other structures of the body. At optimal health, this harmonious relationship remains stable despite the body’s endless varieties of motion. But when one organ cannot move in harmony with its surrounding viscera due to abnormal tone, adhesions or displacement, it works against the body’s other organs, as well as muscular, membranous, fascial and osseous structures. This disharmony creates fixed, abnormal points of tension that the body is forced to move around. In turn, that chronic irritation paves the way for disease and dysfunction throughout many systems of the body – musculoskeletal, vascular, nervous, urinary, respiratory and digestive to name a few.
Barral says the organs remember physical and emotional traumas, and each organ is connected to specific emotions (!). He says “structural relationships” (peripheral, spinal, cranial) can self-correct after VM. He says that each internal organ rotates on a physiological axis. He says organ problems profoundly affect the spine.
Each organ has a regular intrinsic oscillatory motion that follows lines of embryologic migration. This motion resembles, but is distinct from, the craniosacral rhythm [a delusion accepted only by craniosacral practitioners]… If the kidneys are moving out of phase, with one moving inferiorly while the other moves superiorly, this side bends the spine every 3.9 seconds. This small motion is like water drop torture for the spine, resulting in a repetitive motion injury.
Strains in the connective tissue of the viscera can result from surgical scars, adhesions, illness, posture or injury. Tension patterns form through the fascial network deep within the body, creating a cascade of effects far from their sources for which the body will have to compensate. This creates fixed, abnormal points of tension that the body must move around, and this chronic irritation gives way to functional and structural problems.
Where’s the Evidence?
This is fantasy, not science. Adhesions do exist and certainly can cause problems, especially after surgery, but Barral claims they are widespread. For instance, he says they form around the heart in whiplash neck injuries. There is no evidence that they are responsible for symptoms of all the conditions Barral claims or are even present in those conditions, or that disrupting them improves health. And there is no evidence that Barral is actually disrupting adhesions and no reason to think that gentle manipulations like his could possibly do so.
The Barral Institute website claims that “Comparative Studies found Visceral Manipulation Beneficial for Various Disorders” including a long list of everything from whiplash to PTSD, from menopause to urinary reflux; but I have been unable to locate any such studies.
I won’t even attempt any evaluation of the literature, because there’s nothing worth evaluating. The extensive bibliography provided on the website is not helpful. It provides links to popular articles by Barral, to published studies that are not pertinent to VM, and to a few uncontrolled pilot studies and case reports where the clinical significance of the reported changes is uncertain or where any observed improvement can’t be attributed to VM itself. The bibliography reveals that VM has suspicious bedfellows: it is related to energy medicine, craniosacral therapy, zero balancing, Upledger’s bizzare ideas, neurodevelopmental therapies, and other dubious concepts.
Is It Safe?
I think we can reasonably assume that any abdominal manipulation sufficient to disrupt adhesions would risk tissue damage and internal bleeding, but VM is not likely to do that. As practiced, VM amounts to relaxation, suggestion, and gentle massage; so it is not likely to cause physical harm unless it replaces other, effective treatments. It’s more likely to cause harm to the wallet and to critical thinking.
The APTA Goes Astray
The American Physical Therapy Association is trying to establish evidence-based clinical practice guidelines. The Women’s Health Section features a prominent link to CME courses on visceral manipulation offered by the Barral Institute.
J.W. Matheson, a physical therapist in private practice and a long-time APTA member, wrote the organization to protest their promotion of pseudoscience. He provided supporting documents and said,
Visceral Manipulation is a pseudo-scientific practice that belongs outside of the field of physical therapy. The practice of visceral manipulation is not consistent with the vision and mission statements of the APTA.
Carrie Schwoerer, the Director of Education, replied with an astonishing letter. Here are some of her more alarming statements:
Our course offerings are based on the model of evidence informed practice, which Sackett defined as balancing clinical research with clinical experience and patient values. Some of our course offerings… were… based on extensive review of the literature and are clearly advertised as evidence based.
Other aspects of physical therapy practice reflect the clinical experience of the physical therapist providing care and the values, which the patient views as critical to their healing process… some of these techniques have not been validated by the more rigorous clinical research protocol because we have yet to develop measurement tools that could undergo appropriate testing… Adhering to clinical research as the only valid evidence is a disservice to patients who have responded time and again in case studies to so-called “pseudoscientific” interventions and threatens to undermine future innovation in the field.
The Board of Directors… embrace the instruction of visceral mobilization under the tenets of clinical experience and patient values. We disagree that this is pseudoscientific in nature but also recognize that clinical trials do not support its use and therefore do not advertise as evidence based. If individuals are not comfortable with the level of evidence supporting this coursework, there is no obligation to take it for any of the SoWH certificates or to sit for the WCS.
In other words, “We don’t need no stinkin’ science! We support any treatment that can provide positive anecdotes. We believe the plural of anecdote is data. Instead of offering guidance, we’ll let our members sink or swim: we’ll make them responsible for knowing ahead of time how much evidence supports a treatment and deciding whether they believe it is sufficient to merit a personal decision to study it.”
This is beneath contempt. I don’t think I need to elaborate. Another formerly respected organization has drunk the CAM Kool-Aid.

Videos Said to be “Proof” that Nonverbal Autistics Can Communicate by Spelling
The father of nonverbal autistic child believes videos constitute proof that other children with autism can communicate by by pointing to letters on a board held by a facilitator to spell out words. He is wrong.
Harriet Hall on March 29, 2022
Link


I get a lot of email inquiries about questionable treatments, and when I explain that there is little or no science behind them, my explanation is usually accepted with thanks. Recently I had a different experience: the inquirer wanted to argue with me. The father of a non-verbal autistic son, he had watched videos for Spelling to Communicate (S2C) and he believed they constituted proof that S2C worked.
In the S2C program, autistic children who don’t communicate verbally are taught to communicate by pointing to letters on a board held by a facilitator. I answered the email inquiry with a link to what Steven Novella had written about it, where he pointed out that this was just a new version of facilitated communication that was also subject to the ideomotor effect, and there is no evidence that the clients are actually doing the communicating.
The inquiring father begged to differ. He had watched videos where the autistic person had not only learned to communicate by spelling but had demonstrated knowledge that allowed him to beat his family at Trivial Pursuit. I found this hard to accept. Spelling is often difficult for non-autistic people. How could someone with autism be so good at it, and how could they have known information that allowed them to answer Trivial Pursuit questions that other family members could not answer? It simply didn’t make sense to me.
I tried to show him why these videos were not acceptable as evidence. I failed. I pointed out that when S2C didn’t work, no video would be made. I pointed out that videos can be faked; we have no way of knowing if the person is really autistic or is even a real person. How do we know he’s not just an actor? I pointed out that videos were essentially testimonials, which are not acceptable as evidence. I don’t go by testimonials or anecdotes, but by published peer-reviewed scientific studies with appropriate controls. I did everything I could think of to explain the need for good science. He was unimpressed. He had watched the videos and they proved to him beyond any doubt that S2C worked.
He offered to enroll his son in the program and provide me with updates on his progress that would surely convince me. I explained that that would just be more testimonials that couldn’t possibly convince me. He called S2C an evidence-based method that had helped hundreds of people become articulate spellers. He insulted me by saying I had not watched the video (I had!) and that science dissuades people from trying anything new (not true! Science only asks that claims be properly tested, and asks that new treatments be tried in the context of a controlled study to find out whether they work.) We ended up essentially agreeing to disagree.
I felt sorry for him. He could not be objective. He needed to believe his son had a rich mental life that he could learn to share with others. There are plenty of treatments for autism that are evidence-based and have been proven to help; focusing on a bogus treatment may mean denying his son treatments that might really help.
The whole interchange was an exercise in failed communication. We were speaking different languages with different meanings of the words “proof” and “evidence.” What could I have done better? Was I foolish to try to have a discussion with a person who values video testimonials over scientific studies? I ended up wondering why he had asked for my opinion in the first place. What did he expect I was going to say?

Facilitated Communication Is Still Pseudoscience
Facilitated communication is a harmful pseudoscientific technique that has managed to survive through rebranding and deception.
Steven Novella on April 13, 2022
Link

Facilitating communication (FC) was first introduced in the 1980s as a new method for helping non-speaking individuals to communicate. The basic method is for a facilitator to hold the hand of the non-speaker and help them point to letters on a board, or type at a keyboard. At first it seemed as if this was a breakthrough method, allowing many non- or minimally-speaking individuals to reveal their hidden inner voice. By the early 1990s, however, the illusion had burst. More and more studies began showing that the facilitator was the one doing all the communication, not the client.
Since then the professional community has largely been skeptical of FC. Appropriately burned by early acceptance of what is now clearly a pseudoscience, they have been extremely cautious of new methods since. Unfortunately, FC has never gone away. Like many pseudosciences, once banished from mainstream science because of things like high quality scientific evidence, it persists on the fringe, using a variety of dubious methods to fend off criticism and evidence. Many of these methods are common among alternative medicine pseudosciences in general.
Staking the moral high ground
This is perhaps the most pernicious method of pseudoscience promotion, because it attacks and stigmatizes professionals just trying to defend good science. With FC the narrative that has emerged is that those critical of FC are denying that any person who is non-speaking can have hidden cognitive abilities, that they are denying these people a voice and contributing to their marginalization in society, and that such a position is part of a broader “ableist” bias. Nothing could be further from the truth.
For example, the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) has a very clear position paper on FC in its various forms. They warn practitioners and clients that such methods are not scientifically valid and risk great harm. They can hardly be dismissed as not caring about those with speech challenges. They correctly point out that using an invalid method violates the rights of the person to their voice, by potentially substituting the voice of another (the alleged facilitator), that it distracts from other validated methods, and that there is no proven benefit.
Further, they correctly state that it is the responsibility of professionals to “first do no harm” which means only using methods that are validated and more likely than not to provide benefit rather than harm. The morality and ethics here are clearly on the side of those who are cautious about new methods with dubious features, but it is easy for proponents of FC to present themselves as the true champions of the non-speaking.
The American Association on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities (AAIDD) also does not recommend FC or Rapid Prompting Method (RPM), which is a variation of FC.They cite the large volume of evidence that FC does not work and that the facilitator is the true author and the RPM lacks evidence and raises the same concerns of authorship as FC.
To be crystal clear, we all support the rights of the non-speaking completely. We want their true voices to be heard. We in no way minimize the abilities or intelligence of those who have either deficits of speaking or other ways of communicating. Also, it has to be recognized that autism is a broad spectrum, and no one can make blanket statements about what those with autism are able to do or not. Also, FC is not specifically about autism, but anyone who is non-speaking or minimally speaking.
Deceptive rebranding
Proponents of FC have done a good job of rebranding, confusing the public and some professionals in multiple ways. One way of rebranding is simply to use a different term, or to subtly change methods to appear different, when in fact the technique is essentially the same. Two such attempts at rebranding are the RPM and Spell to Communicate (S2C). With standard FC the facilitator holds the client’s wrist or hand. With RPM and S2C they hold a letter board in front of the client who then points without physical contact from the facilitator. These changes allow FC proponents to argue that the client is communicating on their own – but this misses the essence of what FC is.
ASHA refers to all of these methods with a properly descriptive term – “facilitator-dependent communication”. This is a good technical term which is operational, and therefore more scientific. The core question is this: is the communication in any way dependent on the facilitator themselves? The reason this is critical is because this opens the door for the facilitator to be influencing the communication, even to the point of being 100% responsible for the communication. And indeed, systematic reviews show there is no evidence that RPM is a valid method.
That was the primary lesson of FC and the science that demonstrated it was not a valid method. Facilitators were essentially deceiving themselves, partly through the ideomotor effect. This is the same process that allows a Ouija board to work, no one individual holding the planchette may be aware that they are pointing to the letters. It’s subconscious. But there is more – there are also components of the “Clever Hans Effect“, in which essentially random responses on the part of the client can be crafted into communication by the facilitator.
Videos are a good way to demonstrate these effects. I wrote previously about the case of Rom Houben, who is severely impaired due to an injury and is non-speaking. A practitioner of FC, however, claims that he can communicate fluently through the technique. As you can easily see through this video, however, these claims are patently false. Houben is barely looking at the keyboard, and while he does not have the ability to even hold up his hand, he is alleged to be typing rapidly and precisely through the facilitator. This is simply not possible, regardless of what is going on inside Houben’s consciousness. A neurologically intact individual could not cue the facilitator that rapidly and precisely. And of course, when tested with blinded information, it became clear that the facilitator was doing all the communication.
The lessons of this video and of all the research into FC over the last 30 years is that any method which allows for the inadvertent influence of the facilitator needs to be carefully studied in order to determine definitively who the author of the communication is. More simply (and as professionals such as the ASHA recommend) any facilitator-dependent methods should simply be avoided as too risky and not valid.
Hiding in the herd
With decades of negative research and persistent opposition by professionals and professional groups, how has FC hung on? Another method they have used is hiding in the herd, by which I mean proponents pretend as if FC is part of a broader category of legitimate communication methods, called Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC). AAC includes things like using pictures, letter boards, keyboards, or voice synthesizers. These are proven and helpful methods that are non-facilitator-dependent, and for which there is no question about authorship.
But if you say that FC is pseudoscience that does not work you may be accused of saying that AAC does not work, and that all non-speaking individuals have no ability to communicate. In fact, this exact thing happened in response to a recent SBM article about S2C. In the article Harriet Hall refers only to S2C, and never once mentions AAC or any accepted AAC method. And yet we received an angry e-mail stating:
In said article, Dr. Hall claimed that there is “little to no science” behind alternative communication for autistic people who do not speak…
He then provided links to articles backing AAC. The e-mailer (a medical student) will hopefully learn a valuable lesson in why science-based practitioners need to be precise. We cannot conflate FC with AAC, and we need to deconstruct diagnoses and interventions to their core features (again – facilitator-dependent communication). One of the articles he (and other e-mailers) linked to in order to “prove” that FC “works” is this one. It uses eye tracking to show that the clients in the study were the ones pointing at the letters, not the facilitators. Even if legitimate (and the study has been highly criticized), it has absolutely nothing to do with the question at hand, but does demonstrate another aspect of hiding in the herd.
The subjects in this study were all relatively high cognitive functioning individuals who had several years of experience successfully using a letter board. So it’s possible that communication that was not facilitator-dependent communication was going on in this study. But even that is contested, as the facilitator (who was not blinded) held and moved the board. This is being offered as evidence for facilitator-dependent methods – even by the authors of the study itself, who take a defensive tone throughout.
This demonstrates another deceptive method of promoting FC, including a large variety of activity under a broad umbrella. Every person with autism is different, and will have different strengths and weaknesses, and there are non-speaking individuals who have other issues and are not autistic. Further, different facilitators will use different methods, have different levels of training and experience, and a different understanding of what they are doing. A well-trained facilitator using a valid letter-board method that is not facilitator dependent on a client who is non-speaking but has significant cognitive function and is able to communicate cannot be generalized to all facilitators with all clients, just because they are using what is called AAC.
Proponents of FC also miss a major point with the scientific literature that calls FC into question. For example, they dismiss studies showing the facilitator is doing the communication because some individuals communicate differently and we cannot expect them to convey information like typical people would. That is a non-sequitur. They are missing the point that in these studies the facilitators were communicating. They were typing out what they thought the answers were. This damns facilitator-dependent methods regardless of the mental state of the clients.
The bottom line is – why wouldn’t facilitators use a fixed board? Why hold it at all? This just opens the door to facilitator contamination.
Conclusion: Facilitated Communication is still pseudoscience
Facilitated Communication is still pseudoscience, after three decades. We cannot let proponents push these harmful methods into mainstream methods for helping those who are non-speaking or have impaired communication. We can’t be confused by the shell game of shifting branding, and trying to pretend like it’s all ACC. Fortunately organizations like ASHA have figured all this out, but the proponents are tireless.

Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises (TRE)
TRE exercises can supposedly cure PTSD by inducing tremors. Not credible. And there’s no science to support the claims.
Harriet Hall on April 14, 2020
Link


Pseudoscience and silliness are rampant. I couldn’t hope to keep up with it all, but my vigilant correspondents help keep me informed. I had never heard of Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises (TRE). I was asked to look into it by a friend whose book club was reading Pure Land by Annette McGivney. That book is by a journalist who investigated the brutal murder of a Japanese tourist in the Grand Canyon. It’s an interesting story, but it devolves into an account of the author’s nervous breakdown, her treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and her amazing cure through TRE, with details that I didn’t find believable. The account of her TRE treatment occupies only a couple of pages and is only a brief and somewhat bizarre intermission in what is otherwise a well-told murder mystery and human story. My friend’s alarm bells rang loudly when she read this:
symptoms stem from the frozen residue of energy that has not been resolved and discharged; this residue remains trapped in the nervous system where it can wreak havoc on our bodies and spirits….
The idea is that forcing your muscles to shake like they do with lactic acid buildup supposedly releases the trapped residue, permitting recovery. This method was invented by David Berceli, who is of course selling his books and has trained many coaches who are available for people to hire. The website is traumaprevention.com.
My friend was rightfully skeptical and wondered if there was any science behind TRE. When I looked into it, my alarm bells went off too. I concluded that it was a good example of pseudoscience, not science.
The exercises
TRE is a series of six exercises starting at the ankles and progressing up the body to the psoas muscle. In turn, the targeted muscles are stretched and then stressed by contracting until a tremor develops. In one exercise, you assume a sitting position with your back against the wall; in the last exercise, you lie on the floor and do various maneuvers to stress your muscles until a tremor develops. The psoas muscle connects the legs to the trunk and is supposedly critical to the prolonged retention of stress after a trauma.
In the case of PTSD, aroused energy generated at the time of the event is prevented from being discharged and remains trapped in a bio-neural-physiological loop that causes a repetition-compulsion behaviour. Until the brain receives a signal from the central nervous system that the danger is over, the body will continue to repeat the bio-neural pattern of protection and defense.
Some patients have violent tremors with moaning and emotional reactions, others simply quiet have quiet muscle tremors. Dr. Berceli explains:
The body releases what it needs to release. It understands what it must do [emphasis added] to soften and relax the patterns of tension that have been created over the years. For some, this deep relaxation allows deep emotions to surface. Others can just have a physical reaction of shaking.
McGivney says she had PTSD. I’m not convinced; her symptoms were not the characteristic ones of PTSD. Her description of her mental illness and her multiple different diagnoses didn’t ring true for me. When she did the exercises, they produced an emotional response and triggered a vivid memory of abuse she had experienced in childhood. She had forgotten the abuse and had developed distorted memories that were inconsistent with reality. Acknowledging that she had been abused was apparently a major factor in her recovery. At any rate, she received a succession of treatments, not just TRE; and TRE shouldn’t get all the credit.
The discovery
David Berceli is not a doctor or a scientist. He has a PhD in social work. While observing families in a bomb shelter in Lebanon in 1979, he noticed that children trembled as they clung to their parents, while parents showed no signs of fear and did not tremble. The children bounced back and had no sequelae, but the adults developed post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). He suspected that tremoring played a role in releasing trauma and reduced the risk of PTSD. To figure out how that might work, he consulted neurologists and “did extensive research.” He came up with a sciencey-sounding hypothesis that he didn’t bother to test. He just leaped from hypothesis into action. Today, the exercises he developed have spread to over 30 countries and are used by therapists to treat PTSD and by individuals as a self-help method to relieve stress and anxiety, or simply to improve their life in some way.
The bear
An online account tells us:
During the workshop Berceli showed us a video of a bear who had to run away from danger. After escaping, the bear lay on his back, trembling uncontrollably. The bear then let out a huge, loud sigh, calmed down and continued with his normal activities seemingly as if nothing had happened.
This is what allows wild animals to survive as they don’t live in constant fear or panic. Tremoring and release allow them to heal and to build resiliency for future trauma.
Can experts in animal behavior confirm that this is typical animal behavior? I doubt it. I watch a lot of veterinary programs on TV where animals are regularly stressed by handling and by medical treatments, sometimes to the point that the veterinarians have to stop and come back another day; and those animals never show any behavior like that of the bear. Stress causes adrenaline release, but after the stress stops, the adrenaline levels soon fall back to normal
Not everyone is impressed
For what it’s worth, A commenter on Reddit said:
I then read Bocelli’s [sic] paper on his experience developing TRE, which is basically a how-to-guide of saying “fuck you science and research, I’m going to use inductive reasoning as if I’m the first to tackle this”. This shit is jaw-droppingly unethical and shocking.
Another called TRE “somewhere between a massage and a really good night’s sleep.”
A commenter on the Amazon website said, “Works but not sure if it is helpful or just natural response to exercises.”
Does TRE work?
Testimonials report relief of anxiety, headaches, pains in various parts of the body, and nightmares; spiritual benefits; increased energy and endurance, improved marital relationships, less worry, better sleep, cure of fibromyalgia, even clearing of blockage in the carotid arteries! Testimonials are notoriously unreliable, and there have been no scientific studies to evaluate clinical benefits. I don’t doubt that TRE relaxes people and can produce placebo responses and subjective improvements due to expectation, suggestion, and other psychological factors.
But the rationale and the alleged mechanisms don’t make any sense from a medical or scientific viewpoint. The language they use reeks of energy medicine beliefs and New Age fantasies. The tremors induced by the exercises are simply a natural response to muscle fatigue; they are an annoying side effect of strenuous exercise and they have no documented benefits. The idea that muscles can remember may have originated with Wilhelm Reich, a questionable character whose fraudulent orgone accumulators led to legal prosecutions and whose ideas about muscle memories of physical and psychological traumas led to the development of the pseudoscience of bioenergetic analysis.
The bottom line
TRE is not based on science. People may enjoy the experience and may report subjective improvements, but there is no evidence that it has any objective clinical benefits. Side effects have been reported: mild nausea, headaches, and muscle aches. We can assume it is probably safe to try. But you must be willing to dedicate the necessary time and follow the detailed instructions or pay a TRE therapist to supervise you. And there are plenty of other relaxation methods that might work just as well, or even better. So I can’t recommend TRE.

The (binaural) beat goes on
Binaural beats are auditory illusions that are claimed to offer medical benefits.
Scott Gavura on February 17, 2022
Link

Some people love headphones while they work at their computer. I’m not one of them. Some background music I can tolerate, but only when I know it so well it disappears into the background. In most cases, I find music and sounds distracting, especially when I need to concentrate. But external noises can distract too. For the past few weeks I’ve been working in a noisy environment, so I was experimenting with different white noise playlists that could give me some acoustic peace. I stumbled across binaural beats which are decidedly not new, but were new to me. Spotify has hundreds (possibly thousands) of tracks and playlists with binaural beats, many with claims to improve focus, offer stress relief, promote lucid dreams, and even boost your love life (who knew that 528 Hz was such an important frequency?). Some of the claims (actually, almost all of the claims) sounded too good to be true so I did a deeper dive – presented here for your reading and listening enjoyment.
What is a binaural beat?
When two different sound tones that are close, but not identical, in pitch are played together (one in each ear), your brain interprets a “beat”. Each ear must receive a dedicated tone for this to work – so you need headphones. Here is a sample:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/transcoded/c/c8/Pure_Alpha_Waves_7_to_12%2C9_Hz_Binaural_Beats_V3.wav/Pure_Alpha_Waves_7_to_12%2C9_Hz_Binaural_Beats_V3.wav.mp3
If you listen with headphones, the sound should be gently pulsating. But remove one earphone, or the other, and the effect disappears. The beating you are perceiving is being entirely generated within your brain. it is an illusion. The beat that you perceive is the frequency difference between the two waves. For example, if one ear hears a 440Hz tone and the other hears a 480Hz tone, then the brain will perceive a 40Hz beat. This appears to originate in the auditory cortex and the brain stem. Binaural beats can be contrasted with monaural beat which are physically generated and objectively heard in either ear.
Binaural beats date back to the their discovery in 1839, and there has been considerable interest in them since, with the hypothesis that they could possibly induce effects in the brain. The idea, which has not been proven, is that the beats will nudge brain cells into firing at the same frequency, a term called “entrainment”. The intent is to use different frequencies of binaural beats with the goal of triggering the brain waves that naturally occur during different activities, ranging from delta waves (0.5-4 Hz, deep sleep) through theta (4-7 Hz, meditation, and REM sleep), alpha (7-13 Hz, relaxation), beta (13-30 Hz, concentration/alertness), and gamma (30-50Hz, arousal). Proponents claim that binaural beats can induce these brain waves, and consequently, these effects.
What does the evidence say?
The published evidence for binaural beats to affect brain activity or emotions seems positive, but not consistently so, with the strongest evidence looking less impressive. I could find no systematic reviews published in PubMed or cited elsewhere. PubMed has one meta-analysis published in 2018. Meta-analyses can be hit or miss, especially if the underlying trials themselves were poorly done. It included a total of 22 studies after applying search criteria. It concluded that there was robust evidence of a modest effect of binaural beats on memory, attention, anxiety, and analgesia. I also looked at some of the more widely cited papers. This 2017 study which was not included in the meta-analysis (it missed the search cutoff by a month) examined if binaural beats could affect EEG activity at the same frequency of the beat stimulation. It used a “placebo” which was an acoustically-generated beat. No effects on EEG activity were detected and no effects on heart rate or skin conductance (as a proxy for arousal) were found. The authors conclude that binaural beats are not an entrainment tool, nor do they have any clinically meaningful effects. Another study, this one with only 16 participants, was published in 2020 using similar controls and concluded that binaural beats could entrain the brain to some extent. However, monaural (control) beats entrained the brain more strongly than binaural beats. Neither form of beat had any effect on mood (it did not study memory or cognition). Is there something to the evidence? Possibly. Steven Novella looked at binaural beats in 2020 noting:
Applying my usual criteria to the claim that binaural beats improves memory, I would say the current research is suggestive but not definitive, genuinely warranting further research. Such claims become convincing when they not only replicate, but survive increasingly rigorous methodology, without suffering from the “decline effect” to either clinical or statistical insignificance. I also suspect that there may be a non-specific effect at work here, and at least this would need to be ruled out with careful controls. The question is, if there is a real memory-enhancing effect from specific frequencies of binaural beats, is that due to the increased cross-talk we are seeing in the brain, or is it rather due to a non-specific alerting effect from the stimuli itself? Might any stimulus that is sufficiently annoying or stimulating have the same effect?
This, in my opinion, is the critical question, assuming there is a real effect here at all. Are we really hacking the brain, or is this just a complicated way of producing a non-specific alerting effect?
Hype beyond the evidence
Pre-streaming-internet era, binaural beats were probably something that you purchased on CD or maybe even cassette. Now that streaming services and YouTube offer an unlimited array of binaural beats, the entry costs are low. There are some cool apps for you phone if you want to create your very own binaural beat, letting you choose the frequency of the beat and the base frequency. If you want “artisanal” beats, there’s a company that would very much like to sell them to you.
I’m listening to a “beta wave” binaural beat right now as I write this post, and while there is lots of chatter in my household. Is it helping me concentrate? Possibly, the drone synthesizer that overlays the beat drowns out most of the background sounds. And I personally find most of the audio tracks with binaural beats are easy enough to ignore after a while. Whether binaural beats do anything beyond a monuaral beat, or even white noise or music, remains an open question.

Dubious Autonomic Nervous System Claims
Beware overblown claims that autonomic testing can help almost anything.
Steven Novella on June 14, 2023
Link

The realm of personalized medicine, functional medicine, and of course integrative medicine remains rife with pseudoscience and dubious claims. The claims are often couched in scientific terms, as if this is the next step in scientific medicine, just a bit ahead of its time. This is particularly dangerous, as non-experts will have difficulty parsing the often complex claims being made. This is why it is often necessary for expert communities to regulate themselves to ensure some standard of quality – something that has been eroding within medicine for decades, under relentless and successful assault by the overall CAM community.
One practice that, in my opinion, is a good example of this phenomenon is in-office autonomic nervous system (ANS) testing being offered by some practices. ANS testing and diagnosis itself is legitimate, although this is a very complicated area of neurology. “Boutique” versions of many legitimate medical practices have been cropping up, however, such as questionable thyroid testing, fake allergy testing, and other questionable practices.
This particular practice was brought to my attention because of recent local news stories, which were uncritical and essentially amounted to free advertising for the practitioner. But before I get into that, let me give a little background on the ANS and clinical testing in general.
The ANS is part of the nervous system that regulates our overall nervous system activity in specific ways. The sympathetic nervous system reacts to stress or dangers by increasing blood pressure and cardiac function, dilating the pupils, increasing breathing, and increasing sweating. The parasympathetic nervous system is more active when we are in a calm state, and it increases the activity of our gastrointestinal system and glandular secretions while slowing down the heart and reducing blood pressure. These two systems exist in constant balance, adjusting their relative tone moment to moment in order to, for example, maintain a constant blood flow to the brain. It does this by making constant microadjustments in response to changes in position, muscle tone, and even the varying pressures that result from breathing.
Severe disorders of the ANS can result in dramatic symptoms, such as fainting upon standing up because of insufficient sympathetic activity to raise blood pressure to compensate, or severe constipation even to the point of food failing to move through the GI tract. But ANS disorders can also produce more subtle symptoms, such as just feeling dizzy or light-headed, occasional palpitations, or excessive sweating. Diagnosing ANS disorders can be tricky, especially when they are complex or subtle.
Most medical centers will be able to do basic testing. The most common test is a tilt table test, in which blood pressure and heart rate are measured as head position is altered. For more complex testing there are a few autonomic centers in the US (just a few) that can do extensive testing. Even then sometimes the best we can do is document that there is autonomic dysfunction, but may not be able to localize where the problem is coming from. Treatment is mostly symptomatic as most causes of ANS dysfunction are not curable.
If we are going to introduce a new testing method for ANS function (or really anything in medicine) we need to address a few questions. What, exactly, is it measuring, and what is the measured variable a marker for? What is the sensitivity and specificity of the test? And how useful is the information – does it predict the presence of a specific disease or the response to a specific treatment? Research would need to be done to validate any new test with respect to every condition in which it is used.
With that background I read the reporting of Dr. Plotnikoff who is claiming that his ANS testing device is a “gamechanger” for medicine. I could find no published studies by him or his colleagues regarding ANS testing. I was not reassured by his clinic which boasts personalized, functional, and integrative medicine. On his website he specifically claims that people with the following symptoms or disorders will benefit from testing:
Dizziness, Light-headedness, Fainting, Fatigue, Exercise intolerance, Post-exertional fatigue, Chronic pain including firbromyalgia (sic), Persistent, unexplained weight gain, Sleep disturbances of all types, Anxiousness, Heart palpitations, Depressed mood, “Brain fog”, Brain fatigue, Gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms including constipation, nausea, bloating, diarrhea, constipation, and randomly alternating symptoms, Frequent headaches, Falls or near falls, Urogenital dysfunction including urination difficulties and erectile dysfunction, Difficult to diagnose symptoms, Difficult to control blood pressure, diabetes, or hormonal states, Long COVID, Diabetes, Hypertension, Previous heart attack or heart surgery, Postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), Syncope, Anxiety, dysthymia, and/or depression, Neurologic diagnoses including neuropathies, migraines, and/or seizures, Gastroparesis, Traumatic brain injury (TBI), Post-concussion syndrome, Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS).
That’s a pretty impressive list, especially without any specific scientific research to back it up. The testing itself seems to be just a poor-man’s basic autonomic test, with cardiac monitoring, respiratory monitoring, and blood pressure testing. This might all be useful as part of a basic medical assessment, but claiming that it can diagnose autonomic dysfunction would require some extensive validative testing. The notion that the results of this testing would help, for example, guide treatment of medical entities and distinct as diabetes and seizures is a stretch.
In addition to incredibly overblown claims of using this testing to guide personalize medicine, they also claim that they can diagnose and treat ANS problems directly:
For those with low parasympathetic status (“rest-and-digest”) or excessive sympathetic status (“fight-or-flight”), we provide access to an FDA-approved parasympathetic system activator called GammaCore.
GammaCore is a device used for vagal nerve stimulation. This is a legitimate treatment for very specific conditions, but Plotnikoff’s clinic seems to think it is a panacea for everything listed above. Also, they falsely stated that the device is “FDA-approved”. “Approval” when it comes to the FDA specifically means that it has been tested and found to be both safe and efficacious for a specific disease. That does not appear to be true – the GammaCore website only says that it is “FDA cleared”, which means that the device itself is safe, without any claims for efficacy. This may have been just a sloppy mistake on their part, but it has significant implications. Falsely claiming FDA approval is not a minor thing.
As we can see, they appear to be taking a kernel of real science and medicine but then turning that into a simplified boutique treatment that is good for just about anything, making extremely overblown claims without sufficient evidence, and presenting themselves as the wave of the future. That’s the “functional medicine” marketing BS in a nutshell.

Soothing Your Heart: Does practicing self-compassion have physical and mental health benefits?
Does a recent study demonstrate that being kind to yourself has benefits for your mental and physical health?
James Coyne on April 1, 2019
Tweet

Does a recent study demonstrate that being kind to yourself has benefits for your mental and physical health? The authors think so. I see another thinly disguised null trial evaluating meditation with the usual confirmation bias.
Maybe we are left being kind to ourselves because it feels nice to do so, because there is currently no research showing substantial benefits for our health. Probing this study, we can learn a lot about research on meditation, and how hard it is to conduct a decent study. We can think about the pressures on authors to report benefits for meditating and to keep looking when these benefits are not found at first glance. I end with some suggestions for doing simpler, better studies of meditation, though these studies would carry the risk of discovering that meditation is not all that it is cracked up to be.
What if the effects of practicing standard meditation cannot be distinguished from something deliberately constructed as “sham meditation”, akin to sham acupuncture? What if effects cannot be distinguished from asking people to stop for a moment to think, or for them to exhale and make their breathing more rhythmic for just a bit? The huge program of meditation research is broken. Progress is not being made in showing meditating is anything more than a ritualized placebo.
You would never know the scientific status of meditation from the way it is portrayed in media. Although some cracks are developing in the façade, the media is almost uniformly positive in extolling the benefits of meditation for our mental and physical health, our close relationships, and our work performance. There is a strong message that we are not doing all that we can do to be all we can be unless we are meditating. Yet, the evidence for practicing meditation, rather than doing something else to get the same benefits, is weak.
How the study of meditation is broken
The mother of all reviews of mindfulness, a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis prepared for the US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), identified 18,753 citations for preliminary review, but only 47 trials (3%) of them with a total of 3,515 participants included an active control treatment.
The review found:
Low evidence of no effect or insufficient evidence of any effect of meditation programs on positive mood, attention, substance use, eating habits, sleep, and weight.
No evidence that meditation programs were better than any active treatment (ie, drugs, exercise, and other behavioral therapies).
The authors of another review included a leading proponent and researcher of mindfulness meditation, Richard Davidson. The review addressed “Is mindfulness research methodology improving over time?” The authors created a 6-item checklist for evaluating trials. Items included whether there was ample sample size to detect moderate treatment effects if they are present, whether there was an active control group, and whether all patients who had enrolled in the trial were included in analyses (the gold standard intent-to-treat analyses).
Across the 142 studies published between 2000 and 2016, there was no evidence for increases in any study quality indicator, although changes were generally in the direction of improved quality.
The typical randomized trial of meditation remains a small, unblinded study without an adequate, active treatment comparison/control group. Almost all studies depend on subjective self-report to assess outcomes. A trial with these design elements would likely be unable to detect differences between a treatment with established efficacy and homeopathy or sham acupuncture. How do we account for the excess of statistically significance findings reported in the peer-reviewed literature, particularly when you take into account the small size and methodological quality of the typical study?
The choice of comparison group stacks the deck almost to guarantee positive results, if there is a large enough sample. There is also confirmation bias, as analyses and papers that obtain positive results are more likely to get published. There is also liberal use of what are euphemistically called investigator degrees of freedom in picking particular outcome variables and analytic strategies from among many to ensure that there are positive results to be reported, even in those studies with inadequate sample size.
The new study
The recent study of the benefits of practicing self-compassion meditation was designed with the intention of fixing a number of the problems in a typical study of meditation. Ultimately, it fell victim to the authors’ grand ambitions. The study ended up a disguised null trial, not telling us very much – except demonstrating once again the strong influence of confirmation bias and the confidence that the physical and mental health benefits of meditation have already been established.
We can learn a lot delving into the details of how the illusion of a positive study was constructed, good enough to get through peer review.
It is also a tale of how difficult it is to conduct an adequate trial of meditation, given existing methods and tools, and how easy it is for authors to convince themselves that they have positive findings, when they rely on the acceptable flexibility in conducting and reporting a trial of meditation that is so common in the literature.
But first, we need to appreciate a pervasive pattern in the meditation literature, namely:
     1.  Authors typically start with an unrealistic portrayal of what we already know about benefits of meditation and the strength of evidence for the mechanisms by which these benefits are achieved.
     2.  The authors then conduct a study that doesn’t really extend this evidence, and usually does not even provide a critical test. The authors nonetheless make claims that the study succeeds on both counts, and rely on commonly used ways of making weak or null findings look strong.
     3.  Spurred on by hyped press releases, the media continues its strong confirmation bias for the benefits of meditation, citing what is portrayed as new corroborative evidence.
The pressure remains on the authors of the next trial to show again that mediation “works” and the ways by which we know it works.
Investigators of meditation do not necessarily consciously distort their findings to make meditation appear effective, although some promoters of meditation may be prone to do just that. Existing ways of conducting and interpreting a study are biased towards finding a positive effect. If investigators do not find benefits, they are convinced that they have done something wrong by what they compare with what is already in the literature. They can then get it right by trying another analysis or adopting another interpretation. Maybe even reviewers of their manuscript will coax them to try something different.
Readers need to appreciate how self-evident certain assumptions are held to be by the meditation community about the nature of stress processes and how meditation works to relieve stress. Whether because of conviction or as a marketing strategy, proponents of meditation take these assumptions to be no longer be in need of evidence. Research is largely a matter of demonstrating these assumptions, not testing them in a way that they can be disconfirmed. Not confirming these assumptions is taken to be a failure of the researcher.
The peer-reviewed article
The study’s authors included Willem Kuyken, an accomplished Oxford University researcher who is one of the leading proponents of mindfulness in the UK. The peer-reviewed paper stated:
The aim of this study was to investigate the mechanisms whereby self-compassion confers benefits, using a novel experimental paradigm employing carefully designed experimental and control manipulations and psychophysiological measures complementing self-report.
The press release for the study that echoed through the media explained:
Our study is helping us understand the mechanism of how being kind to yourself when things go wrong could be beneficial in psychological treatments. By switching off our threat response, we boost our immune systems and give ourselves the best chance of healing.
The press release explained some seemingly exciting results:
The findings suggest being kind to oneself switches off the threat response and puts the body in a state of safety and relaxation that is important for regeneration and healing.
The researchers said the threat system comprises increased heart rate and sweating, release of the stress hormone cortisol and over-activity of the amygdala, an integral part of the brain’s emotional network. And a persistent threat response can impair the immune system.
Perhaps, but this study did not assess the immune system, regeneration, cortisol, the amygdala, or the brain’s emotional network.
The abstract described what seems to be exceptionally well-designed study.
Self-compassion and its cultivation in psychological interventions are associated with improved mental health and wellbeing. However, the underlying processes for this are not well understood. We randomly assigned 135 participants to study the effect of two short-term self-compassion exercises on self-reported-state mood and psychophysiological responses compared to three control conditions of negative (rumination), neutral, and positive (excitement) valence. Increased self-reported-state self-compassion, affiliative affect, and decreased self-criticism were found after both self-compassion exercises and the positive-excitement condition. However, a psychophysiological response pattern of reduced arousal (reduced heart rate and skin conductance) and increased parasympathetic activation (increased heart rate variability) were unique to the self-compassion conditions. This pattern is associated with effective emotion regulation in times of adversity. As predicted, rumination triggered the opposite pattern across self-report and physiological responses. Furthermore, we found partial evidence that physiological arousal reduction and parasympathetic activation precede the experience of feeling safe and connected.
Seemingly a big study
The sample size of 135 was considerably larger than the typical study of the effects of meditation.
But a hint at what is ahead: what really matters is not the size of the study, but the size of the individual groups being compared.
Seeming better controlled than most meditation studies
It is exceptional for a study to have not one, but two active meditation groups, practicing different types of meditation exercise, along with not one, but three comparison/control groups.
This study compares five groups, dividing up 135 patients into equal sized groups. Maybe this is at first glance impressive, but why are there so many groups and what research question will guide comparing them?
Two kinds of self-compassion exercises
    • In the CBS [compassionate body scan], participants were guided to direct kind and compassionate attention to their body sensations, starting from the top of the head and going down to the feet.
    • In the LKM-S [loving-kindness meditation for the self] condition, participants were first guided to bring to mind a person they felt a natural sense of warmth toward and to direct friendly wishes toward this person. After this, participants were invited to offer the same friendly wishes toward themselves.
Inductions for these practices, along with those comparison/control groups, were delivered in 11 minutes of taped instruction.
How different are these two meditation exercises? Put aside the different sounding names. In the first instance, participants are directed to pay kind and compassionate attention to their body sensations. In the second, they are directed to offer friendly wishes to themselves. Would the recipients of one versus the other set of instructions actually be doing something radically different? Could we be confident that self-report of subjective mental states of meditators would reflect those differences?
Three comparison/control groups
In the self-critical rumination condition, participants were asked to dwell on something they felt they had not managed or achieved as they would have wanted to.
In the positive excitement condition, participants were asked to think about certain aspects of a positive event or situation in which they were working through or achieving something great.
In the control condition, participants were guided through a routine supermarket shopping scenario.
Control groups should control for something. The rationale behind having a control group is that treatment and control groups are identical in every respect except as to whether they receive the treatment.
The ideal blinded, randomized controlled pill-placebo trial controls for the ritual and support that goes along with being provided the active treatment in the context of a clinical trial. The patients being given a placebo also get the same nonspecific factors as the patients getting the active medication. Neither they nor their provider knows that they are being given only an inert pill.
What exactly is controlled in having these three comparison/control groups?
Capturing the subjective experience of self-compassion meditation exercises
Seven visual analog scales or prompts were used to measure the effects of the inductions on the participants’ mood state. Here is an example.The total score on the 26-item Self-Compassion Scale (SC) was used to assess self-reported self-compassion. Two forms of self-criticism were assessed with the Forms of Self-Criticizing/Attacking & Self-Reassuring Scale (FSCRS).
The Self-Compassion Scale (SC) sounds like something quite different than the Criticizing/Attacking & Self-Reassuring. But are they too closely opposite, so that one is the flip of the other? Some items on the Self-Compassion Scale (SC) are worded in a positive direction, with more self-compassion indicated by a higher score.
I am kind to myself when I am experiencing suffering.
Other items are worded in a negative direction, so that a lower score indicates more self-compassion.
When I think about my inadequacies it tends to make me feel more separate and cut off from the rest of the world.
One does not need formal psychometric training to detect that something could go wrong here.
Other researchers have separated out the negative-word items on the SC scale, and found the items, not surprisingly, correlated moderately to strongly with negative emotion, depressive symptoms, perceived stress, as well as to rumination and neuroticism. A large psychometric study concluded results “do not justify the common use of the SCS total score as an overall indicator of self-compassion, and provide support for the idea…that it is important to make a distinction between self-compassion and self-criticism”.
A meditation exercise is supposed to induces a psychological state, which participants report in the outcome measure. What if the participant is merely interpreting the induction as instructions on how to fill out the questionnaire, as an experimental demand? The transparent wording of the items on the two questionnaires and seven analogue scales makes it obvious how well-behaving participants should answer.
The state of the art and science of whether meditative states have been achieved is not good.
Psychophysiological measures, not just assessments of the subjective impressions of participants
This study supplemented the usual subjective self-report questionnaires with psychophysiological measures. Presumably the psychophysiological measures would be less susceptible to bias than the self-report measures and could get at the biological mechanisms that underlie self-reported subjective states.
The psychophysiological measures were heart rate, high-frequency heart rate variability (HRV), and galvanic skin response (GSR).
Let’s have no illusions. The psychophysiological measures are not biomarkers of participants being in a meditative state, they are potentially modest correlates. Researchers are not yet in a position to dispute a study participant’s report that they are or are not in some meditative state. Subjective self-report remains the gold standard for determining whether a person is in a meditative state. It is worrisome for the validity of these measures that studies find people who are asked to indicate whether they are meditating can be confused to provide similar reports for sham versus standard meditation.
Grounding self-report in the biology tapped by the psychophysiological variables is a matter of relating two sets of variables that are each messy and subject to extraneous influences. The psychophysiological variables have their own problems, with skewed distributions and large variation within and between people. The measurements are supposed to be immediately registering the effects of 11 minutes of instruction, but are also responsive to all the noise of complex things that are going on in and around each participant, including what they brought to a brief experimental session.
From a much larger literature correlating self-report with biological variables, I would estimate the noise in each would only allow only a correlation of .20 or a shared variance of 4%. That small figure diminishes any expectation that these trajectories of measures assessed over the 11 minutes could strongly reflect pre-post differences in self-report. Mediational analyses intended to determine the biological mechanism behind effects of meditation depend on partitioning these correlations. I would not expect impressive results.
Digression: I remember when I was studying hot flashes in men receiving hormone therapy for prostate cancer. I was frustrated that subjective self-report of discomfort was so susceptible to placebo effects, so I bought a fancy way of measuring thermal skin conductance, quantifying how much the men were sweating. The results were a lot more complicated and harder to interpret than I bargained for and I lost my enthusiasm for biological measures saving me from the messiness of self-report.
Statistical analyses
This study has an exceptionally complex design for a meditation study, with its two different meditation exercises, three comparison/control groups, and both subjective self-report and objectives psychophysiological data. Before we wade into the details, it be best to summarize the point I will be making:
The authors resolved a tough decision as to how best to analyze their data with a simple solution that wiped out the main benefit of having a control group. They examined whether each of the two meditation groups were statistically different on a measure administered before the induction versus the same measure given after the induction. They examined all nine outcome measures. They also did these analyses for the three comparison control groups for the same nine outcomes. So, 5 x 9 = 45 analyses. It is mind-boggling to consider all the permutations and combinations of meditation and control group and outcome measure. The authors considered their expectations confirmed if there was statistical significance for one of the meditation exercises, but not for a control group, or vice versa.
What these authors did is different from what is typically done. The typical strategy of statistical analysis for a clinical trial evaluating meditation is to conduct an overall repeated measure analysis of variance to see if the meditation group and a control comparison differed over time, pre- to post- treatment assessment. If there is more than a pair of groups being compared, the investigators can do an overall test if there are any differences and then test a hypothesis concerning which pair differs over time. Authors need to be careful not to fall into a fishing expedition, capitalizing on chance with repeated tests.
In this trial there is no clear indication why the two meditation groups would be different from each other or which comparison/control group – self-critical rumination condition, positive excitement condition, or shopping condition – would provide the best comparison. The authors started by testing if a group-by-time interaction effect existed for a given outcome variable. If significant, this analysis would indicate at least one significant difference among the groups over time was lurking somewhere. Fine, but…I would guess that maybe the self-critical rumination condition would be the best candidate to be different from the rest. But that induction did not seem particularly powerful, none of the three inductions were. Anyway, I am not sure what it would mean if self-critical rumination condition were the only group differing from the others over time.
The authors resolved the complexity by testing all seven groups to see if participants in the group had a significant difference from pre- to post-assessment on any of the nine self-report measures. They then looked to see if there was a difference within each of the two mediation groups and within each of the three control groups.The authors would consider their hypotheses confirmed if there was a pattern like “the pre-/post- differences for the meditation group were significant, but those for a control group were not”.
The psychophysiological measures were continuously monitored, so something different had to be done than for the pre-/post- self-report measures, but the logic making within-group comparisons was the same.
A novel statistical technique, latent growth curve modelling, was used to examine whether there were differences in the trajectories of psychophysiological response over an 11-minute session associated with the five groups.
Results of analyses for the psychophysiological measures for the five groups were discussed in terms of whether or not there were patterns of significant differences within groups for psychophysiological measures. The authors considered their hypotheses confirmed if a particular meditation technique that had a significant effect on self-report measures also had a significant change in a psychophysiological measure.
The authors also conducted some correlational mediation analyses to determine if changes in the psychophysiological measures mediated changes in the self-report measures. Basically, they were examining whether the psychophysiological measures might be the biological basis of any observed changes in self-report measures by seeing if the change in the psychophysiological measure was correlated with the change in self-report for a particular group.
Stacking the deck
The usual meditation randomized trial is designed so even homeopathy would appear effective. Could these authors overcome that problem? Typical studies compare one group of participants getting meditation to one poorly matched control group of participants either remaining on a wait list, or getting nothing. That comparison is stacked towards finding benefits for meditation.
How so? People enroll in meditation studies with the hope they will get training in meditation that they otherwise would not get outside of the clinical trial. Half of the people enrolling will typically be assigned to meditation, but half of the people will get put on a waiting list or simply get no treatment instead. People obviously know to which group they have been assigned. Treatment assignment cannot be not blinded. Those assigned to the control group are presumably disappointed.
Not only do the people assigned to getting meditation get meditation, they also get their positive expectations met, and they get a lot more support and attention than the control group. So, in an important sense, the typical meditation trial compares participants getting a combination of meditation plus nonspecific (i.e., placebo) factors, to getting nothing but maybe being disappointed.
Typical studies rely solely on subjective self-report questionnaires as measures of outcome. These measures are susceptible to the bias arising in an unblinded comparison of an active treatment and unmatched control group. Such a study design compares an active treatment to a mismatched control groups with subjective self-report outcome measures and would make even inert or homeopathic remedies look effective. Here is a striking demonstration.
In an important sense, randomized trials do not evaluate pre-post differences in the treatments. Rather, trials evaluate whether there are differences in pre-post outcomes, i.e. differences over time between the treatment and comparison/control group. Within-group differences for a particular treatment exaggerate its effect because it combines the active treatment and nonspecific effects.
You can now see the bias of the authors in the study conducting within-group analyses and trying to make sense of whether these differences were statistically significant within the meditation group, but not the control group.
The authors are evaluating meditation plus nonspecific factors versus nothing except perhaps a disappointing experience. They are doing that many times.
By focusing on within-group differences, the authors avoided confrontation with null findings, but any positive findings are likely being inflated and due to chance. Their sample size was too small and their multiple analyses capitalized on chance. Recall that the authors had nine self-report outcomes variables: three psychophysiological being compared in two meditation conditions and three control conditions.
The groups were too small to expect detection of even moderately-sized effects
Earlier I suggested that the impressive number of 135 participants was less important than numbers in the size comparison cells, which was 27 participants. The authors are banking on being able to detect the key differences in which they are interested with comparisons of two groups of 27 participants, not 135.
The authors state that they conducted a formal power analysis to determine the number of participants required to detect a statistically significant difference in outcome, if a difference were indeed present. But the formal power analysis is not presented in the paper or supplementary materials.
Having only 27 participants in a group is far less than the 50 needed to have 70% probability of detecting a moderate-size (d = .50) effect. Across studies evaluating psychological interventions, a modest effect size d = .30 is more reasonable, which leaves a sample of 27 with less than a 50/50 chance of detecting a difference. Most findings that would be significant in a larger sample would be missed. Because of the higher threshold needed to achieve statistical significance with n=27, most statistically significant differences will prove exaggerated or even false when replication is attempted. The mean outcome scores for a treatment group of only 27 are also unstable, subject to sampling noise. Dropping or rescoring one participant could substantially change the mean for the group, resulting in a gain or loss of statistical significance.
I am skeptical whether there is any difference more than d = 0.1 between the two highly similar meditation exercises. The benefits of evaluating the two in a single trial would require hundreds of participants to demonstrate. What possible clinical significance would there be to any such differences?
The interpretability of correlations with 27 participants per group is even more dubious. Analyses depending on a likely correlation of self-report of ~.20 between self-report and psychophysiological measures would require 167 participants per group. Differences between correlations would require even more participants. Furthermore, changes in correlation due to the data of one or two participants could fluctuate greatly. It would take 100s of participants for the correlation to stabilize, far more than the largest of trials of meditation.
We should not be chasing statistical significance in this study anyway
It is never a good idea to determine the outcome of a clinical trial by comparing whether within-group differences are significant in treatments versus controls. Two conditions could differ in whether they achieved statistically significant differences (p< .05) versus the null hypothesis of zero effect without differing from each other. The problem is particularly severe in small trials where a large effect, usually obtained by chance, has achieved statistical significance.
A finding of statistical significance (p<.05) is meaningless if there are so many comparisons without a specific hypothesis. With the amount of noise in play in this study, the probability is high that random fluctuation will be misclassified as a meaningful result. Especially with small groups, within-group differences contaminated with placebo effects, ineffective control groups, and multiple subjective self-report measures that are susceptible to participants wanting to give the investigators what they seem to be asking for in the instructions for the inductions.
But more generally:
P-values have taken quite a beating lately. These widely used and commonly misapplied statistics have been blamed for giving a veneer of legitimacy to dodgy study results, encouraging bad research practices and promoting false-positive study results.
Fortunately, the American Statistical Association has provided a great service by recently issuing an Official Statement on Statistical Significance and P-Values, along with some commentaries by experts in its great press releases with great quotes.
The p-value was never intended to be a substitute for scientific reasoning.
Over time it appears the p-value has become a gatekeeper for whether work is publishable, at least in some fields. This apparent editorial bias leads to the ‘file-drawer effect,’ in which research with statistically significant outcomes are much more likely to get published, while other work that might well be just as important scientifically is never seen in print.
Why I will not give a serious look at the pattern of significant results claimed by the authors
Readers can check the authors’ presentation and discussion of results in the open access article.
Given multiple tests to choose from and the role of chance, the authors obtain both plausible and implausible results. But plausible does not equal robust and generalizable. Furthermore, what is plausible is made so by invoking received assumptions about the stress process and how meditation can reduce its effect on mental and physical health outcomes. Such assumptions are not put to a strong test in this study, but can be used to filter the noisy results today into a seemingly strong positive study and a confirmation of these assumptions, but that is one illusion giving credibility to another.
But the exercise can have an amazing effect on a reader, persuading even one who has been armed with appropriate skepticism. Go ahead, give a look, and be surprised at how you get taken into accepting “marginally significant” when to say “null” would spoil the good story being told.
That is how the appearance of progress is created in social media about a huge meditation literature that really is not going anywhere fast.
What could have been done differently?
We are again reminded that underpowered studies of meditation can be mined for significant results and published. It is a recipe for success that is so common and formulaic that many authors follow it without realizing anything is wrong. We need a lot fewer randomized trials evaluating meditation and more trials that are adequately powered, have appropriate control groups, a suitable primary outcome, and features like intent-to-treat analyses to reduce bias.
If they are interested in furthering the understanding of meditation and risking being proven wrong, the authors would be much better off testing a simple hypothesis with a simpler design and more participants. Given that we have not established that meditation is more than nonspecific factors, how about examining whether one of these self-compassion exercises has stronger effects than simply having participants sit quietly with instructions to relax for 11 minutes?
Then there is the possibility of testing self-compassion against a sham meditation. One study compared the widely used Headscape app for meditation with such a sham. Participants were told they were in a meditation study, but whereas half of them received the usual Headscape protocol, in the other condition the protocol provided a sham meditation. Each session began by inviting the participants to sit with their eyes closed. These exercises were referred to as meditation but participants were not given guidance on how to control their awareness of their body or breath. Participants in the two conditions were indistinguishable across a variety of self-report measures.
Alternatively, participants could be instructed to simply exhale and let the natural rhythm of breathing take over, paying attention to it. I would not be surprised if both simple instructions were no different in the effects on the physiological measures used in this study from the self-compassion exercises. Investigators could set some a priori criteria for rejecting the likelihood of a clinically significant difference.
An inability to demonstrate a clinically significant difference between self-compassion meditation exercises and one of these active control groups would be disappointing to promoters of meditation, but think how liberating such results could be for everybody else. We don’t need weekend retreats; we don’t need lessons nor daily practice. We can simply stop and think for a moment or maybe exhale…

Is Mindfulness Meditation Science-Based?
Existing research has not yet clearly defined what mindfulness is and what effect it has. The hype clearly has gone beyond the science, and more rigorous research is needed to determine what specific effects there are, if any.
Steven Novella on October 18, 2017
Link

A great deal of electronic ink has been spread on these pages discussing the question of what it means to be science-based. While we have developed and iterated an operational definition, like many complex phenomena there is no sharp demarcation line. Practices occur along a spectrum from rigidly science-based to blatant quackery.
There are plenty of practices, however, that are in the middle. Further, an individual practice can range across the spectrum depending on the claims that are being made for it. “Nutrition” as an approach to health can be rigidly scientific (folate for pregnant women to reduce the incidence of neural tube defects) or pure snake oil (“superfoods” to cure what ails you).
One practice that I think straddles this middle-zone is mindfulness meditation (or just mindfulness). The “dictionary” definition of mindfulness is, “a mental state achieved by focusing one’s awareness on the present moment, while calmly acknowledging and accepting one’s feelings, thoughts, and bodily sensations, used as a therapeutic technique.” But before we get into more detail about this practice, let’s review what we mean by “science-based.”
What is science-based practice?
This, of course, is the core question of Science-Based Medicine and a topic of deep thought by its proponents. I will try to give the quickest definition I can here. SBM acknowledges that medical interventions which are safe and effective are preferred over practices which are unsafe or ineffective. Further, the best way to evaluate practices is by considering all of the available scientific evidence in the most thorough context.
That last bit is where the complexity is – each piece of scientific evidence needs to be evaluated for its rigor, context, implications, and relation to other relevant pieces of scientific evidence. Further, scientific research needs to be evaluated in total as a process. It is the arc of a research question that tells us what the best current conclusion is, not any one piece of evidence.
SBM also endeavors to understand patterns in the research to detect biases, flaws, and errors. We also use the history of science (and especially medical science) to understand how well the research predicts whether an intervention will ultimately be useful or not.
In short, SBM takes a detailed meta-scientific view of all the relevant research to make the best prediction possible about whether or not any individual practice is safe and effective for any specific indication.
Another way to look at the SBM approach is this – what does it take before a medical claim is considered compelling? What are the thresholds of scientific validity in various contexts before we would recommend an intervention? This question is important because medicine is an applied science. We have to make decisions about what to do with actual people.
These are all complex questions requiring much longer discussion (and you can find plenty of discussion in other articles on this site), but again to quickly review: Scientific evidence is only compelling when there are specific terms used that can be operationally defined (so we know what it is we are studying and discussing). The claims made should also be plausible, meaning that at the very least they do not defy basic scientific knowledge. We also need clinical evidence to show that specific variables which are adequately controlled for in a blinded fashion have an effect which is consistent, replicable, and both statistically and clinically significant.
The history of medicine and systematic reviews of the evidence show that less than something like this threshold and an intervention probably doesn’t work or is not a net benefit for patients. Most new ideas in medicine turn out to be wrong, and there is a massive positive bias in evaluating treatments (at every stage from early observation to citing published research). Only when we get to a relatively high threshold of evidence as outlined above can we be reasonably confident that an intervention actually works.
Mindfulness
With that review – let’s apply these basic SBM principles to the question of mindfulness. A recent review of the topic, “Mind the Hype: A Critical Evaluation and Prescriptive Agenda for Research on Mindfulness and Meditation,” helps this task considerably.
As the authors point out, there are significant problems with the mindfulness research and the overhyped claims that are being made for this intervention. Problems begin with the very first criterion of science-based practice – lack of an operational definition. This may seem nitpicky, but it is absolutely critical to be being science-based.
Good science is all about controlling for specific variables so that we can make firm conclusions about the effects of those isolated variables. If we cannot define the variables, let alone isolate them, then we cannot study them scientifically.
Mindfulness research, as the authors point out, is plagued by a lack of a consistent definition, or one that can be operationalized for research. What is/are the critical component(s) of mindfulness? Is it relaxation, introspection, being in the moment, directing one’s attention, avoiding mind-wandering, or something else? Granted, this is a frequent generic problem with psychological science because human psychology is complex. We often don’t understand psychological phenomena in a fundamental-enough way to operationalize it for research. But still, we need to acknowledge the limitations of any individual research question.
To show by analogy how critical this feature is, let’s turn to acupuncture research. If we define acupuncture as placing thin needles through the skin at acupuncture points, we can confidently conclude based upon the research that acupuncture does not work. It does not matter where or even if you place needles through the skin. However, proponents continue to claim that acupuncture does work, citing research results that use a deliberate loose definition of “acupuncture.” Acupuncture, when necessary, can mean just poking the skin in random locations, or using electrical stimulation.
Proponents have essentially said – acupuncture works, it just doesn’t seem to matter where or if you stick the needles. Then what is “acupuncture?” And if specific variables don’t seem to matter, how can you control for non-specific effects? Proponents respond by essentially saying it doesn’t matter. The non-specific or placebo effects are real (which misunderstands the nature of placebo) and that is all that matters.
Having followed the mindfulness research for years and discussed it with many proponents, the response is largely the same. The details of specific variables are either poorly understood or debated, and don’t seem to really matter. As long as there is a perceived subjective benefit, that is sufficient justification.
The authors of the current review agree. They write:
However, the aforementioned complexity, confounding, and confusion that surrounds empirical research on “mindfulness” limits the potential of the method to inform broad questions and inform specific theories. The extent to which a specific model is supported or disconfirmed by particular sets of empirical data or systematic observations depends on the meaning of “mindfulness” that inspired data acquisition.
Mindfulness, in various studies, can refer to alleged specific mental phenomena such as: “psychological distancing/reperceiving, decentering and inhibitory control, nonconceptual discriminatory awareness, acceptance and reintegration, or focused attention, decentering, and meta-awareness.” That is a pretty big umbrella.
Proponents have also argued that mindfulness is partly relaxation, partly cognitive therapy, and partly developing vaguely defined mental skills related to the above.
This creates a further problem – how do you control for nonspecific results. This gets to the second major issue that the reviewers and others have, most studies of mindfulness are poorly controlled or methodologically weak. Some lack a control group at all. The best studies have active controls, attempting, for example, to control for simple relaxation. But these best studies tend to have the most modest results (a meta-pattern important to note).
The reviewers point out, for example:
In a recent review and meta-analysis commissioned by the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, MBIs (compared to active controls) were found to have a mixture of only moderate, low, or no efficacy, depending on the disorder being treated.
MBI=Mindfulness based intervention. Results are mixed and unimpressive. That is a pattern with which we are very familiar, and does not exactly inspire confidence.
When I have expressed skepticism about mindfulness in the past, the response (even from skeptics) is often – well, it worked for me. The obvious response is – what worked, and how did it work, and how do you know it worked?
In order to answer these questions we need the kind of clinical research that can answer them – specifically defined variables controlled for non-specific effects. We need to know that mindfulness is a specific thing that has an effect beyond the non-specific effects of relaxation, or taking a mental break from the stress of the day, or just exercising your executive function.
So what’s the bottom line? It’s hard to say, and that is part of the point of the current review. Existing research has not yet clearly defined what mindfulness is and what effect it has. They make recommendations for future research to clarify these questions.
I think the best current summary is to consider mindfulness like yoga, or a specific form of exercise. There is evidence that doing yoga has specific health benefits. However, those benefits are likely not specific to yoga and are universal to exercise. It is therefore more accurate to say that exercise has many health benefits, and yoga is a form of exercise.
Likewise I would say that relaxation has health benefits and cognitive therapy potentially has psychological benefits. Mindfulness, taken broadly, seems to be a reasonable practice for relaxation and may have some effects similar to cognitive behavioral therapy.
But I am not convinced by the existing research that there is any other phenomenon at work here, that there is something specific to mindfulness, or that it has benefits beyond other similar behaviors. There may be – perhaps there is something specific about certain mindfulness practices that we can isolate and study. We are simply not there yet.
Further, public hype supporting a billion dollar industry has gone way passed the existing evidence.

Another Broken Meditation Study
Another study shows meditation does not work, but the authors manage to conclude that it does.
Steven Novella on July 15, 2020
Link

This is an article I could write on almost any given week – a study reports on the association between meditation and lower cardiovascular risk, which the press glowingly reports as another study showing the benefits of meditation. But on close examination, the study does not show that at all. The disconnect cuts to the heart of what it means to be “science-based”.
We often evaluate individual studies for their scientific qualities – were they well controlled, was the outcome measure objective, was the statistical evaluation valid, and was the outcome clinically meaningful? We can look for signs of p-hacking, or taking liberties with the methods in order to manufacture positive results.
But sometimes the problems with medical research go deeper than flaws in individual studies. Sometimes the entire research paradigm is basically broken. This does not mean every study is bad, but it does mean that most of the research suffers from scientific problems that are baked into the culture of research in a specific area. For example, homeopathy research suffers from rolling the dice with placebo-vs-placebo studies and then reporting chance positive studies, without ever achieving the kind of reproducibility that would indicate a real effect.
Acupuncture research is probably the worst – it suffers from a fundamental problem with the definition of acupuncture. It should be – sticking needles into specific acupuncture points to treat specific problems. However, the research consistently shows that it does not matter where you stick the needles or if you stick the needles at all. Further, the choice of acupuncture points is arbitrary and lacks consistency (which is unsurprising given the infinite variety of styles of acupuncture). And even more damning, the evidence clearly shows that acupuncture points don’t even exist. And yet we have hundreds of studies reporting that “acupuncture works” even for studies that are clearly negative.
The underlying problem with homeopathy and acupuncture research is that most of the researchers are, to put it simply, doing it wrong. They are committing the cardinal sin of pseudoscience – trying to prove their hypothesis correct, rather than trying to prove it incorrect. And so the entire research program is broken. If this problem were fixed, both homeopathy and acupuncture would be declared ineffective and scientific dead ends and would go away.
There is a similar situation with meditation, except that it might be more accurate to say that the meditation research tells us practically nothing, rather than indicating that meditation does not work. As I discussed in 2017, meditation comes in many flavors, but they lack clear operational definitions. This is the first step in any valid science – a clear definition. If you can’t do that, then it is impossible to have meaningful and interpretable research outcomes. As the review I discussed at the time concluded:
However, the aforementioned complexity, confounding, and confusion that surrounds empirical research on “mindfulness” limits the potential of the method to inform broad questions and inform specific theories. The extent to which a specific model is supported or disconfirmed by particular sets of empirical data or systematic observations depends on the meaning of “mindfulness” that inspired data acquisition.
This is a fancy way of saying that we can’t really conclude anything from existing research because the very definition of “mindfulness meditation” is too squirrelly. What about the best studies of meditation – can they tell us anything? The largest systematic review, which James Coyne discussed here in 2019, identified 18,753 citations for preliminary review, but only 47 trials that were of sufficient quality to include in their review. That is a lot of noise for very little signal. They found:
Low evidence of no effect or insufficient evidence of any effect of meditation programs on positive mood, attention, substance use, eating habits, sleep, and weight. No evidence that meditation programs were better than any active treatment (ie, drugs, exercise, and other behavioral therapies).
This conclusion is eerily similar to other programs, like homeopathy and acupuncture, in which the best studies show the intervention probably does not work. However, the vast majority of studies claim the intervention probably does work, but they are of insufficient quality to really draw that conclusion. So the press and the public are left with the opposite conclusion to the scientific reality.
The current study is a great example. The reporting declares, “Meditation linked to lower cardiovascular risk”. That is probably as far as most people will get, or they will read the press release – the first two-thirds of which is also glowing but misleading. If you look at the actual study, however, you see that the data is not only not convincing, it’s actually negative.
First, this is a correlational study only. There is no intervention and control, the authors are just looking at survey information about self-reported habits like exercise, smoking, and meditation. You should always suspect this when the headline uses the word “linked”. The fact that A was linked to B does not mean A causes B, even though that is often the implication given.
But the problems are deeper than that. This is a big survey, with 61,267 NHIS participants. That is both a strength and a weakness. It gives the study a lot of statistical power to find small effects, but it also means that any confounding factors will also likely be highly statistically significant. It’s like looking at an elephant under a microscope – you will see a lot of detail, but may miss the big picture.
In this study the authors controlled for demographic factors, like sex, age, and weight, but did not control for cardiovascular risk factors. This is because they were trying to say that meditation is linked to lower risk factors, implying that it causes lower risk factors. Of course, in the discussion they have to admit that their study does not show this because it is correlational only, but it allows them to say that meditation “may” cause lower risk factors, and that it supports other research that also shows meditation “may” have benefits. This is how a research house of cards gets built on itself.
But a close look at the tables shows how thin this argument is. Most of the factors were highly statistically significant. Those who meditate, for example, were more likely to be married and less likely to be divorced. Do you think that might be a confounding factor in heart disease? They give the game away in their discussion:
On multivariate analysis, after adjusting alcohol consumption, physical activity, exercise, meditation was only significantly associated with a lower prevalence of hypercholesterolemia. Our results may be confounded by alcohol consumption, physical activity, and exercise but we cannot be totally ruled out [sic] that some of these variables may be in the causal pathway making the associations non-significant when adjusting for alcohol consumption, physical activity, exercise in an initial model.
This is what I meant when I said the study was negative. When you control for the obvious confounding factors (while acknowledging there are probably others not captured in the data) all of the significant effects on stroke, heart attack, and other meaningful clinical outcomes go away. There was no independent association between meditation and good clinical outcomes. None. Normally this would be considered a negative study.
But in the broken paradigm of meditation research, negative outcomes are magically positive. The authors rescue their hypothesis (remember, they are trying to prove meditation works) by arguing that we cannot rule out that meditation causes the confounding factors. In other words, meditation may cause people to drink less and exercise more. OK, but then really it is the known healthy lifestyle factors that are causing the improved cardiovascular outcomes (including lower cholesterol), not the meditation itself. The authors have to retreat to this weaker alternate hypothesis that meditation causes better behavior.
But that is not what this study looked at, so it is just a gratuitous hypothesis. We would need to set up a study in which meditation was the intervention with an adequate control group, and exercise and alcohol consumption were the outcomes. Of course this would need to be compared to just counseling people on better lifestyle choices. So now meditation has become a counseling intervention, not a direct health intervention. None of this apparently matters, however, because the goal is to conclude that “meditation works” regardless of the twisting logical path you need to take to get there.
All of this shows how important interpretation of the data is. Data does not exist in a vacuum. If you look at this data through the lens of science-based medicine, it is clearly negative. Any positive association between meditation and clinical outcomes goes away when you include confounding factors. That should have been the end of the discussion.

Can mind-body practices “reprogram” our DNA?
A recent systematic review has been touted as demonstrating that “mind-body” practices like yoga can reprogram our DNA. There are several reasons to doubt these claims, not the least of which is the history of bias in past studies on this topic.
David Gorski on June 26, 2017
Link

One of the most persistent narratives latched on to by advocates of “integrative medicine” is that the “mind” can somehow “heal” the body. Sometimes, the claim is that such interventions work through “powerful placebo” effects. Sometimes it involves the abuse of emerging science, such overblown claims about what can be accomplished through epigenetic modifications of DNA and gene expression. While my wife and I were away on vacation, there was another example of this claim popping up in the media under headlines like these:
    • “Mindfulness and meditation dampen down inflammation genes“
    • “Yoga and Meditation Can Change Your Genes, Study Says“
    • “Meditation and Yoga May Change How Stress Affects Our DNA, Study Finds“
    • “Mind-body exercises may work at molecular level“
    • “Mind-Body Practices Downregulate Inflammation-Related Genes“
    • “How Meditation And Yoga Can Alter The Expression Of Our Genes“
    • “Meditation and yoga can ‘reverse’ DNA reactions which cause stress, new study suggests“
An example of the reporting:
Meditation and tai chi don’t just calm the mind – they seem to affect our DNA too. There’s evidence that such “mind-body practices” dampen the activity of genes associated with inflammation – essentially reversing molecular damage caused by stress.
Mind-body practices such as mindfulness meditation are widely claimed to protect against stress-related diseases from arthritis to dementia. But although there’s plenty of evidence that they can relieve stress, the scientific case for physical health benefits has not yet been proven.
Recent advances mean it’s now easier to study patterns of gene activity inside cells, and there has been growing interest in using this approach to investigate how nurturing inner peace might influence the immune system and disease risk.
Ivana Buric, a psychologist at the Coventry University’s Brain, Belief and Behaviour lab, and her colleagues have now conducted the first systematic review of such studies. The team analysed 18 trials including 846 participants, ranging from a 2005 study of Qigong to a 2014 trial that tested whether tai chi influenced gene activity in people with insomnia.
You get the idea, and there’s more where that came from. (I picked that particular quote because Jo Marchant wrote it, and we’ve met her before.) The idea is that “mind-body” practices change our genes. Some reports even went so far as to imply that such practices can “reprogram” your DNA. Of course, I always find the category of “mind-body” practices to be problematic because it lumps together practices with actual science demonstrating a plethora of health benefits with other modalities that are probably not. Inevitably, the “body” part of “mind-body” emphasizes “exotic” forms of exercise, like yoga, tai chi, or quigong, over more mundane forms of exercise like running, bicycling, or more gentle forms of exercise like walking. The “mind” forms of “mind-body medicine” also tend to mix potentially science-based with more questionable claims. Of course, the whole name “mind-body” is problematic in itself as well. After all, it rather assumes Cartesian mind-body dualism, when in fact the mind is a product of the activity the body, specifically the brain.
Buric is a graduate student in a joint program between Coventry University and Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, and the senior author of the paper is Inti Brazil at the Collaborative Antwerp Psychiatric Research Institute in Belgium. The study was published in Frontiers in Immunology and is entitled “What Is the Molecular Signature of Mind–Body Interventions? A Systematic Review of Gene Expression Changes Induced by Meditation and Related Practices.” Let’s take a look.
A systematic review of “mind-body” interventions, or: GIGO
I’ve read many systematic reviews and meta-analyses in my time, and if there’s one thing that I’ve learned it’s that they are very, very dependent upon the quality of the input. Computer programmers have a term that is very applicable here: GIGO, which stands for “garbage in, garbage out.” It’s a term that is applicable to virtually any form of data analysis or synthesis. If the data used to do the analysis is not of high quality (i.e., it is garbage), then the results of analyzing the data will also not be of high quality (i.e., it will be garbage too). When it comes to meta-analyses, what I like to say is that aggregating a bunch of low quality studies will not miraculously result in high quality, highly reliable conclusions. Indeed, if the studies share similar problems, such as bias, aggregating them will actually amplify those problems. Similarly, systematic reviews, which are different from meta-analyses in that they don’t involve trying to aggregate the data from the studies being examined and come to conclusions but rather are what the name implies, systematic reviews of existing evidence, can produce low quality and/or biased results if the input consists of low quality or biased studies. That’s why there are all sorts of rules and best practices for meta-analyses, but even those won’t save a systematic review or meta-analysis from the GIGO phenomenon. Unfortunately, these days, when it comes to meta-analysis and systematic reviews, GIGO all too often seems to stand for “garbage in, gospel out.” We sometimes see this phenomenon in evidence-based medicine (EBM), where meta-analyses and systematic reviews are considered the highest forms of evidence on the pyramid.
That means we have to dive into the weeds of how this systematic review was carried out:
We will now review studies on MBIs (mindfulness, yoga, RR [the relaxation response- DG], Tai Chi, and Qigong) that include gene expression analysis as an outcome measure, in order to assess the evidence for their effects on gene expression, and what changes in gene expression underpin the psychological benefits of MBIs. Studies were identified by searching PubMed through September 2016 using the following combination of keywords: (meditation OR mindfulness OR relaxation response OR yoga OR tai chi OR Qigong) and (gene expression OR microarray OR transcriptome). A total of 716 articles were returned and their titles and abstracts were screened (see Figure 1). We excluded studies that did not meet the following eligibility criteria:
     1.  The population studied should only contain adults.
     2.  Both clinical and non-clinical samples were allowed (for example, students, cancer patients, and caregivers) and studies with all sample sizes were included.
     3.  Studies with experienced practitioners or non-experienced practitioners were allowed, making both cross-sectional and longitudinal studies eligible.
     4.  Gene expression changes had to be one of the outcome variables (any number of analyzed genes, cell type and any gene expression technology were eligible).
     5.  The independent variables had to be any type of MBI.
     6.  Articles should be written in English.
     7.  Only research papers were included. Review papers, meta-analyses, commentaries, and conference proceedings were excluded.
Most of these are not unreasonable criteria. However, there is one big problem, and that’s the variety of interventions that fall under mind-body interventions (MBIs). For instance, on what basis does one group a psychological intervention (e.g., mindfulness or relaxation response) with various exercises (yoga, tai chi, quigong)? This is particularly problematic given the relatively low number of studies. The authors screened 716 articles, but only ended up with 18 encompassing 846 participants. None of the studies were particularly large, and most were not randomized. The average number of participants per group averaged over the studies was 23.6, which is not large. The studies were also of mixed design: cross-sectional (17%), longitudinal (50%), rapid response (11%), and mixed (22%). A cross-sectional study is an observational study in which data are collected at a specific point in time and compared between groups. A longitudinal study is also an observational study, except that data are collected repeatedly over time from the same subjects, specifically at different time points. Rapid response studies, as the name implies, observe what happens at brief time points after an intervention.
There were a lot of differences in experimental methodology as well, for instance, how gene expression changes were measured. Most of the studies (72%) harvested RNA from peripheral blood monocytes (PBMCs) to measure changes in gene expression, while others (17%) used lymphocytes. A variety of techniques for measuring gene expression were used as well, from just using reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to examine two to twenty-three genes to using Affymetrix or Illumina cDNA microarrays, to using next generation sequencing methods like RNASeq. Of course, as we’ve learned from John Ioannidis, reproducibility is a major problem in whole genome gene expression studies. Also, psychology studies suffer greatly from this problem as well, and mindfulness studies are no exception.
Of course, the studies one really wants to look at are randomized controlled clinical trials, and less than a third of the studies examined were randomized, specifically these:
     1.  Creswell JD, Irwin MR, Burklund LJ, Lieberman MD, Arevalo JM, Ma J, et al. Mindfulness-based stress reduction training reduces loneliness and proinflammatory gene expression in older adults: a small randomized controlled trial. Brain Behav Immun (2012) 26(7):1095–101. doi:10.1016/j.bbi.2012.07.006
     2.  Black DS, Cole SW, Irwin MR, Breen E, Cyr NMS, Nazarian N, et al. Yogic meditation reverses NF-κB and IRF-related transcriptome dynamics in leukocytes of family dementia caregivers in a randomized controlled trial. Psychoneuroendocrinology (2013) 38(3):348–55. doi:10.1016/j.psyneuen.2012.06.011
     3.  Irwin MR, Olmstead R, Breen EC, Witarama T, Carrillo C, Sadeghi N, et al. Tai chi, cellular inflammation, and transcriptome dynamics in breast cancer survivors with insomnia: a randomized controlled trial. J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr (2014) 2014(50):295–301. doi:10.1093/jncimonographs/lgu028
     4.  Bower JE, Greendale G, Crosswell AD, Garet D, Sternlieb B, Ganz PA, et al. Yoga reduces inflammatory signaling in fatigued breast cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial. Psychoneuroendocrinology (2014) 43:20–9. doi:10.1016/j.psyneuen.2014.01.019
     5.  Bower JE, Crosswell AD, Stanton AL, Crespi CM, Winston D, Arevalo J, et al. Mindfulness meditation for younger breast cancer survivors: a randomized controlled trial. Cancer (2014) 121(8):1231–40. doi:10.1002/cncr.29194
     6.  Epel ES, Puterman E, Lin J, Blackburn EH, Lum PY, Beckmann ND, et al. Meditation and vacation effects have an impact on disease-associated molecular phenotypes. Transl Psychiatry (2016) 6(8):e880. doi:10.1038/tp.2016.164
These, and the other studies, had a variety of controls as well, ranging from basically no controls to “active” controls to “passive” controls. Curious what constitutes an “active” control, I examined a couple of the studies above
“Mind-body” interventions: Less there than meets the eye
The first study I looked at was reference #2 (Black et al). This was a study of people who were caring for a frail or demented family member, based on the rationale that caregivers tend to have worse mental and physical health than matched controls probably due to stress-induced upregulation of inflammation-related genes and downregulation of innate antiviral genes. The two groups were Kirtan Kriya Meditation (KKM) or Relaxing Music (RM) listening for 12 minutes daily for 8 weeks, after which subjects had blood drawn for gene expression profiling studies. The authors reported that in the KKM treatment group, 68 genes were found to be differentially expressed (19 up-regulated, 49 down-regulated) compared to the RM control group after adjusting for potentially confounded differences in sex, illness burden, and BMI. Up-regulated genes included immunoglobulin-related transcripts. Down-regulated transcripts included pro-inflammatory cytokines and activation-related immediate-early genes. One thing I noticed right away in this study is that the effect sizes were quite small. The authors set their criteria for a positive result as genes whose transcript levels change by more than 1.2-fold, which is casting a very wide net indeed. None of the genes examined changed by more than 1.65-fold, something that always sends up a red flag to me as far as whether the effect observed is truly biologically relevant. Moreover, one of the sets of genes, the set that responds to Interferon Response Factors (IRF) barely achieved statistical significance (p=0.04, which for a study of this type is pretty lousy). As for NF-κB, having worked with this particular transcription factor in the past rather extensively, I know that it’s hyper-responsive to many things; indeed, I used to joke that if I just looked at my cells funny it would activate NF-κB signaling.
Another interesting publication was the last one, which describes the result of a collaboration with Deepak Chopra, whose foundation funded the study. The study itself took place at the Chopra Center for Wellbeing at the OMNI La Costa Resort and Spa in Carlsbad, CA. It looks very much to be a publication that flowed from a collaboration between Chopra and various academic medical centers prone to quackademic medical studies. Healthy women aged 30–60 were recruited to stay at the resort and then randomized to a vacation arm or novice meditator arm, for a total of 94 participants who completed the program. A comparison group of regulator meditators was recruited from women aged 30–60 who had already enrolled in the retreat. According to the supplemental data, the sample included women who were non-meditators and lived in California who were randomized to a “vacation” arm or a meditation arm. They did not pay for their stay at the resort. The comparison group of non-randomized women (the “experienced” meditators) was recruited from the pool of those already registered for the retreat and paid for their own expenses. I’m sure you can see part of the problem right here. First, it’s a bit dicey ethically to charge anyone for their stays. Second, the experienced meditators were not randomized, and they could easily have confounding differences that could affect their results. In any event, although it wasn’t described in the methods of the paper itself, promotional literature described the retreat goal as “to promote an intensive period of learning and psychological change.” The vacation group was hosted at the same resort, but they did not participate in any retreat activities. Subjects reported on well-being immediately after (on day 5), 1 month later, and 10 months later to assess maintenance of benefits.
Here’s an ad for the study:
And here’s a promotional video Chopra made for the study:
In the video, Chopra states:
The idea is to prove—scientifically—that your biology is a product of the choices that you make, and these choices are made every day, and that we can actually consciously create the experience of a joyful energetic body, a loving compassionate heart, a restful reflective mind, and lightness of being.
Very scientific sounding, isn’t it? But what does this even mean? How, specifically, do you measure whether or not the participants have consciously created “the experience of a joyful energetic body, a loving compassionate heart, a restful reflective mind, and lightness of being”? Besides, it’s trivial to say that our choices affect our biology. Of course they do! If you smoke, you hurt your heart and lungs and vastly increase your risk of heart disease and cancer. If you drink to excess, you vastly increase your risk of liver disease and, to a lesser degree, your risk of variety of cancers. If you’re a sedentary slug who never exercises (as I was and still sometimes am), you vastly increase your risk of developing any number of harmful conditions and diseases, such as hypertension and type II diabetes. These are trivial observations.
Of course, confirming such trivial observations, long confirmed by medical science, was not what Chopra was about. Notice his unscientific language. He didn’t say “test the hypothesis” or “see if this program results in X and Y.” He didn’t know what he’s looking for before the experiment was done. He only knew that it would be good. Basically, there was no hypothesis except that his center’s program is good for your health. So he said things like “prove scientifically” that his program does all sorts of wonderful things that aren’t specified in concrete, measurable ways. Instead, he planned to shotgun measure a whole boatload of markers and endpoints, including next generation whole genome sequencing. Here’s another problem. Because a “whole program” was tested, it is impossible to tell what’s responsible for the changes, as subjects in the vacation group could do whatever they wished. In fairness, “fishing expeditions” like this can be good for generating hypotheses, but the design of this trial makes me doubt the hypotheses generated from the conclusions of the study.
In any case, the study noted improvements in psychological well-being in all groups. (Surprise! Surprise!) Investigators also identified gene expression signatures that changed in all three groups consisting of 390 genes. This is code for saying that there wasn’t a detectable difference between the groups in changes in this gene signature, which the authors attribute to the “vacation effect.” They did, however, find differences in another gene signature whose change differed between the vacation and novice meditator arms versus the regular meditator arm. That’s nice, but it doesn’t really tell us anything, given that the regular meditators could easily have confounding factors at play based on behaviors and diet different from the vacation and novice meditator groups.
I didn’t go through each and every study in the systematic review, but I think you get the idea. The studies were generally preliminary and often not of the best quality. The Chopra study didn’t even really compare the effects of meditation versus not meditating in a rigorous fashion. That doesn’t stop the authors from concluding:
The results of 18 studies that used gene expression analysis in research on meditation and related MBIs have overall found downregulation of NF-κB-targeted genes, which can be understood as the reversal of the molecular signature of the effects of chronic stress. Even though the study designs, the population, and the types of MBI used in the studies included in this review vary, it indicates that some of the psychological and physical benefits of MBIs are underpinned by biological changes in NF-κB genes. These results need to be replicated in larger samples and with stronger research designs that control for non-specific effects of these practices and for as confounding lifestyle factors, such as sleep, diet, and exercise.
Ya think? I can’t help but note that NF-κB is basically at the heart of inflammation, but it isn’t alone. In any case, I also can’t help but note that a recent review of 20 randomized clinical trials of mindfulness meditation and the immune system was a lot more tentative. Only three of the studies found decreased NF-KB, for instance.
None of this means that I don’t find it fairly plausible that various exercise regimens could decrease the level of pro-inflammatory gene expression. I even find it plausible that relaxation and meditation might result in similar effects. It is, however a long stretch to claim that such activities “reprogram your DNA” in that changing gene expression doesn’t require doing anything to the DNA itself, just changing levels of the proteins that regulate expression of the genes whose levels change. In any case, this is preliminary research massively overhyped, and I didn’t even mention until now that it’s in a Frontiers journal, and Frontiers journals are known among my colleagues for their poor peer review.
But that’s not all.
Publication bias a-go-go
Remember how I started out this post with the aphorism “GIGO”? There’s plenty of reason to suspect bias in much of the research into “mindfulness” and “mind-body” interventions. Most recently, Tim Caulfield pointed me to an interesting paper:
Yes, and much bias in the reporting of #mindfulness research. See, for example, https://t.co/mx4uEzbPg5
— Timothy Caulfield (@CaulfieldTim) May 31, 2017
The study looked at publication bias in mindfulness research and noted as a rationale for undertaking an investigation:
MBSR [mindfulness-based stress reduction] and MBCT [mindfulness-based cognitive therapy] have been reported to improve mental health outcomes among patients with psychiatric conditions (e.g., depression [1, 10], anxiety [11, 12], posttraumatic stress disorder [13], eating disorders [14], substance use disorders [15]), and other medical conditions (e.g., diabetes [16], hypertension [17], cancer [18], arthritis [19], obesity [20], heart disease [21], stroke [22]). In the United Kingdom, MBCT has been recommended by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence to prevent depression relapse [23].
A concern, however, is that the overwhelmingly statistically significant results in favor of MBSR and MBCT interventions that can be seen in the published literature, despite very low power in many studies, may be influenced by reporting biases. Reporting biases are said to occur when statistically significant or “positive” outcomes have been preferentially published compared to non-significant or “negative” outcomes [24–26]. Reporting biases include (1) study publication bias, in which positive studies tend to be published, whereas negative studies are not; (2) selective outcome reporting bias, in which outcomes published are chosen based on statistical significance with non-significant outcomes not published; (3) selective analysis reporting bias, in which data are analyzed with multiple methods but are reported only for those that produce positive results; and (4) other biases, such as relegation of non-significant primary outcomes to secondary status when results are published [24–28].
In other words, there are way more positive studies of mindfulness therapies out there than the statistical power of the studies as reported would predict. The authors, Coronado-Montoya et al, from the Lady Davis Institute for Medical Research, Jewish General Hospital, Montréal, Québec and the Department of Psychiatry, Oregon Health & Science University, note that previous meta-analyses of the topic have not done an adequate job assessing the literature summarized for bias. They note that the methods generally used are not likely to detect reporting biases when there are fewer than 10-20 included trials and might require large numbers of trials in some circumstances. They also note that such methods “are also not appropriate when most studies have limited sample sizes, or when there is relatively little variance in sample sizes [45, 46], all of which are common in MBT [mindfulness-based therapy] trials” and observe drolly that they have “observed anecdotally that there seem to be few examples of published MBT trials without statistically significant results, even though many existing trials appear to have been conducted with very low statistical power.”
So Coronado-Montoya et al did their own systematic review and also assessed recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses to determine whether reporting biases were identified. They began by searching the CINAHL, Cochrane CENTRAL, EMBASE, ISI, MEDLINE, PsycInfo, and SCOPUS databases for randomized controlled trials of MBTs. What they did next was simple in concept, but difficult in execution. They counted the number of positive trials and compared that number to the number of positive trials that that might be expected if mindfulness-based therapy were similarly effective compared to individual therapy for depression. They also searched trial registries like ClinicalTrials.gov for mindfulness-based therapy registrations.
Guess what they found:
108 (87%) of 124 published trials reported ≥1 positive outcome in the abstract, and 109 (88%) concluded that mindfulness-based therapy was effective, 1.6 times greater than the expected number of positive trials based on effect size d = 0.55 (expected number positive trials = 65.7). Of 21 trial registrations, 13 (62%) remained unpublished 30 months post-trial completion. No trial registrations adequately specified a single primary outcome measure with time of assessment. None of 36 systematic reviews and meta-analyses concluded that effect estimates were overestimated due to reporting biases.
Only three were presented unequivocally as negative trials “without alternative interpretations or caveats to mitigate the negative results and suggest that the treatment might still be an effective treatment.”
The authors also point out:
Our review of trial registration records also suggest the possibility that reporting biases may have been an important factor. Of the 124 RCTs reviewed, only 21 (17%) were registered prior to data collection, even though 80 of the eligible RCTs were published recently (since 2010). When we examined trial registries, we identified 21 registrations of MBT trials listed as completed by 2010 and found that 13 (62%) remained unpublished 30 months after completion; of the published trials, all conveyed a positive conclusion. None of the 21 registrations, however, adequately specified a single primary outcome (or multiple primary outcomes with an appropriate plan for statistical adjustment) and specified the outcome measure, the time of assessment, and the metric (e.g., continuous, dichotomous). When we removed the metric requirement, only 2 (10%) registrations were classified as adequate. We evaluated more than 30 published systematic reviews and meta-analyses of MBTs, and none concluded that reporting biases likely exaggerated estimates of effect (see S6 Appendix).
The authors concede that they could not definitively determine whether there was significant reporting bias. One reason is that they could not conduct a statistical test to determine if there was excess significance bias and had to choose a reference point of a known effective therapy to compare to the MBT trials. However, from my perspective, something sure does smell bad here, particularly given that almost none of the MBT trial registrations defined outcome variables with sufficient precision to compare to subsequently published trial results, which would reduce the likelihood of selective outcome reporting. The authors themselves suggest that reporting biases are likely to be the “driving force” causing the disconnect between the expected number of positive trials versus the observed number.
As Tim Caulfield put it:
Not sure emperor totally naked, perhaps a Speedo (mindfulness might be an additional tool for some conditions?). But so much hype!
— Timothy Caulfield (@CaulfieldTim) June 25, 2017
Indeed. Perhaps a Speedo on an obese old man.
Mind-body: Fantasy versus reality
Mind-body therapies, such as mindfulness-based therapies, are very attractive because they are low cost, don’t involve pharmaceuticals, and, above all, provide a sense of control to the patient. Indeed, as ever more rigorous clinical trials find that most of the “unconventional” therapies (i.e., quackery) that “integrative medicine” integrates with conventional medicine are elaborate placebos, proponents of integrative medicine increasingly fall back to pointing to modalities like yoga, tai chi, and the like and “mindfulness.” Unfortunately, they increasingly oversell both. After all, yoga, tai chi, and qigong are basically forms of exercise. Of course it’s expected that they would be likely to have health benefits, but so do more conventional aerobic exercise and even moderate housework. It’s also not implausible that “mindfulness” or other so-called “mind-body” interventions could also have health benefits.
However, we have to be very careful here. I once said that the “central dogma” of alternative medicine is that wishing makes it so; that is, if you think about or wish for something hard enough, the universe will provide it. That’s why placebo effects are so seductive and attractive to integrative medicine proponents; they can be misrepresented as the “power of the mind over the body.” You can see how mindfulness and other mind-body interactions are just as attractive, because many of them involve actual thinking and meditating. Unfortunately, the science does not (as yet) support many of the overblown claims made for these practices. It’s not clear whether it ever will. Certainly it’s unlikely that they “reprogram” our DNA.

Past Life Regression Therapy: Encouraging Fantasy
Harriet Hall on July 26, 2016
Link


I recently got an e-mail from a PR firm about an “internationally certified regression therapist,” Ann Barham, who has written a book and who claims to help patients to “heal enduring challenges, release unhealthy patterns and beliefs, and find their way to more happiness and success.” They offered me the opportunity to review her book and/or interview her; I declined, but I was interested in learning more about past life regression therapy, so I elected to “interview Dr. Google” instead.
In past life regression therapy, therapists use hypnosis, leading questions, and strong suggestions to encourage patients to imagine that reincarnation is real and to imagine their past lives. Events and people from past lives are blamed for symptoms and problems in the patient’s current life. Finding a past life cause for current problems supposedly helps patients deal with them. The technique is also used in healthy people to promote spiritual advancement and self-understanding. There is no such thing as reincarnation, and the memories of past lives are nothing but fantasy.
What is a certified regression therapist?
You can certify almost anything; there are even certified psychics and certified dowsers. I learned that there is an organization that certifies regression therapists, the International Board for Regression Therapy. Their website says regression therapy focuses upon the discovery of the origins of a client’s problem and accepts the theory that present life issues or problems may have their origin in past lives, real or symbolic. They list only 63 certified therapists, located in the US, UK, Canada, Greece, Corfu, The Netherlands, and Turkey. Almost a quarter of them, 15, are in California. (Of course, there are many more regression therapists who have not been certified.) They list training opportunities in 10 countries, including India and Romania. The accreditation requirements include 40 hours of basic instruction in the induction and use of altered states, 15 hours of classroom instruction in past life therapy, and a significant supervised practicum. Certification for three years costs $265.
Are past lives real?
Reincarnation is a philosophical concept based on the idea of a personal essence that is non-material and that survives death to be eventually re-incarnated in another body. That essence is sometimes referred to as the “soul.” Reincarnation is a central belief of many religions, and a substantial minority of Americans and Europeans believe in it (estimates from various countries range from 12% to 44%). Our modern knowledge of basic science and brain science has effectively ruled out the possibility of reincarnation, and believers have never been able to produce any credible evidence that it has ever occurred.
You may remember Bridey Murphy, a Virginia housewife who became famous in the 1950s for her memories (recovered under hypnosis) of a past life as a 19th century Irish woman. Investigators found no records that matched her claims and were able to show that her alleged past life memories were fantasies built around real childhood memories of an Irish neighbor.
Believers cite the past life research of Dr. Ian Stevenson, who collected cases from all over the world. He interviewed children under the age of six who allegedly remembered details of a previous life. Skeptics have analyzed his reports and found them unconvincing, either explainable by more mundane ways the children could have obtained their knowledge or not properly verified by unbiased fact checking. Robert Carroll of The Skeptic’s Dictionary said:
I have to agree with Stevenson’s own assessment of his work: he’s provided evidence, but no compelling evidence for reincarnation. I see no way to move forward using his methods or his data, so I see his work as a colossal waste of time. On the positive side, however, I agree with him that past life regressive therapy, which uses hypnosis, is rife with methodological problems, not the least of which is the problem with suggestion contaminating any evidence that might be uncovered for a past life.
Does it matter whether they are real?
The past life “memories” are evoked by hypnosis and strong suggestions by the therapist. Essentially, the patient is encouraged to tell a story. It doesn’t seem to matter to the therapists whether the story is fiction or nonfiction. A writer on the IBRT website says, “only the person can decide whether they are real or not. It is a very subjective thing.” For example, the scene might be one where the client finds his past personality falling off a cliff. In such a case, whether it happened or not makes no difference because the purpose of this regression happens to be one where the client needs help with the emotion of fear of heights.
In a doctoral dissertation, Rabia Clark found that clients’ and therapists’ belief or absence of belief in reincarnation has no impact on the outcome of the therapy.
Similarities with other psychotherapies
I see similarities between past life regression and many other psychotherapy methods. There was the recovered memory therapy that harmed so many patients and their families by creating false memories of childhood sexual abuse. Similar false memories of Satanic ritual abuse put innocent people in jail. Freud postulated childhood traumas as the cause of adult neuroses, and many psychotherapists still spend a lot of time delving into memories of childhood experiences to explain the origins of adult problems. Dream analysis and free association dredge up fodder for inventive interpretation by the therapist. Methods like eye movement desensitization and reprogramming (EMDR), re-birthing, neurolinguistic programming (NLP), psychodrama, emotional freedom technique (EFT), primal therapy, narrative therapy, and chess therapy (yes, that’s a real thing) also provided “hooks” that were not effective in themselves but served to engage patients in the therapeutic process.
Therapy for multiple personality disorder (now called dissociative identity disorder) is another condition where therapists have used suggestion and hypnosis to encourage patients to imagine themselves as other people. They have invented “alters” that may have a different sex, age, and personality; alters have sometimes numbered in the hundreds or even thousands and have even included animals and inanimate objects (lobsters, trees, machines). Therapist and client become enmeshed in a folie à deux delusion and eventually imagine they are integrating all those alters into one to effect a cure.
Is it effective?
Regression therapists tell many success stories, and that is not at all surprising. Like many other gimmicks, past life regression can encourage patients to recognize problems in their lives, build a narrative that seems to make sense to them, and then hopefully move on to make changes in their lives. Just getting personal attention from a trusted, sympathetic person over several sessions can be helpful. Imagining former lives might help patients boost their egos and feel better about themselves (I used to be a princess!). It might allow them to create a satisfying explanation for the problems that brought them to the therapist and allow them to shift the blame from themselves to something that happened in a previous life. And it certainly is a way of getting patients to work with a therapist. Is it effective? We don’t know. There are no good studies. Is it a valid alternative to cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)? We don’t know; no comparison studies have been done.
Could it be harmful?
Even if it seems to help some patients, it is known to have harmed others.
The recovered memories can be very frightening. They can cause anxiety: one inquirer on the IBRT website was worried that he would become stuck in a memory and turn into a different person. Memories fabricated under hypnosis can seem more real than true memories, and it can be difficult or impossible for patients to accept that they are not true, even when presented with clear evidence that the events could not possibly have occurred. Various other kinds of harm have been documented.
The Israeli Health Ministry told hypnotists to refrain from helping patients explore past lives after receiving complaints from clients who said they had sustained serious emotional damage. One patient reported that he “became emotionally stuck in an experience which made him feel as though he was enclosed in a coffin. He began to gasp for breath. After the session the man suffered repeated panic attacks and respiratory problems, and he was referred for medical and psychiatric care.”
One past life regression therapist, Dr. Rakesh Jain, has reported that “In some subjects, hypnosis and past life regression can result in side effects which can range from mild to severe one and be temporary or durable.” He describes several incidents, including development of new physical symptoms, a patient who attacked the therapist during a session, and a patient who identified past enemies and announced that he would be taking revenge on them in this life. One female patient recalled five past lives as a male and became so afraid that she wouldn’t come out of the trance. He points out that reducing pain through hypnotherapy without identifying the cause of the pain could harm the patient. He cautions that abreactions might harm cardiac patients by causing elevations of heart rate and BP and might cause further tissue damage in patients with wounds or fractures. He cites research that documents 50 complications from hypnosis, including psychotic symptoms, panic attacks, depression with suicidal behavior, symptoms resulting from inadvertent suggestions, symptom substitution, masking physical pathology, etc.
Fantasy vs. reality
There is a real world out there. Reality is not subjective. There is no such thing as reincarnation. If you have imagined a previous life, that doesn’t make it true, no matter how true it may seem to you or how useful you think it is for giving you true insights. Daydreaming is fun, as is imagining what it would be like to be another person or to have lived in a previous era. That’s why we enjoy reading fiction and historical fiction. But in my opinion reality trumps fantasy for coping with the real world. There is no evidence that past life regression therapy offers anything that reality-based therapies like CBT don’t offer, and we do know it can harm patients. I agree with the Israeli Health Ministry’s rejection of it. I’m in favor of psychotherapies that don’t speculate about the origin of psychological problems but instead emphasize methods of coping and moving forward.

Pseudoscience invades Social Work
Acutonics, aura infusions and angelic channeling: pseudoscience has invaded the practices of social workers.
Jann Bellamy on January 31, 2019
Link

A recent article in the Journal of Evidence-Informed Social Work documents over 400 websites of social workers, most engaged in some form of mental health counseling, using questionable practices, from “Access Consciousness” to “Zero Balancing Practitioner.” Given the pervasiveness of pseudoscience in healthcare, discussed countless times here on Science-Based Medicine, this should surprise no one. After all, if the venerable Cleveland Clinic can offer reiki, functional medicine, and Chinese herbs to its patients without sanction, what’s to keep Licensed Clinical Social Workers from practicing Angelic Channeling, Plant Spirit Medicine, and Theta Healing?
This survey of websites does not purport to be systematic or to estimate the prevalence of these practices among social workers. Nor do the authors mean to indict the entire profession, recognizing “that there are social workers who conduct critically important work every day.” (On a personal note, my daughter, a social worker, is one of these: She works with foster families in a job that is both extremely stressful and incredibly rewarding.) Rather, the authors, two academics from New York University and The City University of New York, simply wanted to see what was out there. They conducted Google searches using search strings consisting of “LSCW” [Licensed Clinical Social Worker] and similar professional designations (e.g., “MSW” for the Masters of Social Work degree) and terms like “healing” or “angels.” They use their findings as a springboard to ask their profession whether social workers should be engaged in these practices and, if the answer is “no,” then “what will you do about it?”, questions they raise but do not answer. (We’ll return to these questions in a moment.)
So, what did they find? Unfortunately, a whole lot of utter nonsense. Space does not permit me to catalogue each practice, only a few highlights. (The article is online and provides links to all of the websites if you want more examples. Because of this, I am eschewing links to each and every website mentioned in the post, thereby avoiding turning practically the whole post blue.)
Some social workers practice the sort of pedestrian pseudoscience we’re all familiar with here at SBM: reiki, reflexology, acupressure, Bach flower remedies, aromatherapy, healing touch, and acudetox.
Other social workers are into angels. If their websites are to be believed (see also here and here), angels lack the heavenly agency ascribed to them in the Bible and need people with degrees in social work to act as intermediaries. There’s angel card readings, angel communicator, angel messenger, angel readings, angel therapy practitioner, angelic channeling, angelic massage, certified angel therapy practitioner, certified archangel life coach, certified angelic life purpose coach, archangelic light, certified master angel practitioner, golden angel healing work, guidance from the angelic realm, guided healing meditation followed by individual angel messages, intuitive angel and fairy expert, Mary Queen of Angels cards, and Spirit Wings: An angel painting course.
In fact, commerce with incorporeal entities is not uncommon. Practices listed in the article include akashic record reading, ancestor work, spiritual direction, chakra balancing, chakra healing and chakra dance, clairvoyant psychotherapy, extraction (“removing localized spiritual intrusion”), divine channel, and lots of shamanic work: shamanic clearings, shamanic healing, shamanic divination, shamanic extraction healing, shamanic ways of healing, shamanic interventions (“including extraction of psychotoxic intrusions, soul retrieval/power animal retrieval, divination”), shamanic journey circles and shamanic psychotherapist. Also: soul coaching, soul collage, soul detective, soul retrieval, soul therapy, spirit attachment work, spirit wings, spiritual awakening, spiritual empowerment, spiritual lovefare, spiritual medium, and spiritual response technique.
Different forms of energy “therapy” are popular as well (because, as one website says, “energy becomes stagnant and causes what is called energy blockages that can manifest as chronic emotional pain” etc.). Included are An-Ra energy healing, Eden energy medicine, integrated energy therapy, Christa energy attunement, core star energy healing, energy clearing, energy medicine, energy/tantric therapies, Four Winds Society energy practices, gua-sha with energy balance, intuitive energy healing, La Ho Chi energy healing, energy coach, soul-directed energy healing, subtle energy healing, transformational energy medicine, and Zensight energy healing.
This energy “therapy” is remarkably effective, according to its practitioners:
Bengston Energy Healing Method, a powerful, safe energy therapy that can produce remarkable results for both people and animals, from providing adjunctive treatment for cancer as well as helping improve asthma, depression, digestive diseases, anxiety, allergies, Alzheimers, arthritis, cataracts and other ophthalmological disorders, eczema and many other physical and emotional problems.
And:
Balancing your energies balances your body’s chemistry, regulates your hormones, helps you feel better, and helps you think better.
Another fantastic benefit:
Through the crown of the head, frenetic energy, stressful images, self incrimination/doubt and worry about the future is released up and out, like smoke up a chimney.
Acupuncture analogs
Acupuncture has proven a fertile ground upon which to build various permutations, equally implausible and lacking in evidence, but nevertheless used by several social workers in their practices. In addition to the acudetox mentioned earlier, social workers also practice acutonics, TAPAS Acupressure Technique, and REMAP.
Acutonics is worthy of its own post, but, briefly:
Everything in the Universe vibrates, from the smallest particle, to the planets in our solar system, to the billions of stars in the Milky Way Galaxy, creating patterns of geometric waveforms, frequencies, musical intervals, and sounds.
So,
The sounds of the Universe are brought into health care through the use of precision calibrated planetary tuning forks and symphonic planetary gongs. Acupressure points and chakras provide noninvasive access into these core energy systems within the body. The planets provide musical intervals, archetypes, psychological depth, and correspondences that help us to fine-tune the therapeutic frequencies that are applied to the body.
This is, of course,
. . . grounded in Oriental medicine, psychology, science, cosmological studies and sound healing principles.
In the case of acutonics, a picture really is worth a thousand words.
You can see the planetary gongs, which “set a powerful stage for the therapeutic setting by dramatically shifting the molecular environment, setting up layers of vibrations in the air that resound through our emotional, psychological, physical, and spiritual bodies” here.
TAPAS acupressure technique [TAT] was developed in 1993 by an acupuncturist named Tapas (so much for “used for thousands of years.”) According to the TATLife website:
While in the TAT Pose (touching acupressure points on your head), attention is put on a set of specific statements. This simple process can effortlessly dissolve past traumas, clear negative beliefs, or end critical voices…and you don’t have to talk about it, think about it, or figure anything out. The TAT process uplifts your entire system — physical, mental, emotional and spiritual. It helps you have more love, happiness and peace. TAT has been used successfully to end fears and phobias, lessen every kind of stress, heal the emotional origins of physical disease, and manifest a happy life here and now.
Really, why pay for expensive psychotherapy when all you have to do is touch some acupressure points on your head?
REMAP stands for Reed Eye Movement Acupressure Psychotherapy, which was developed by (you guessed it) someone named Reed. REMAP
. . . is the innovative synthesis of mind-body therapy, brain science, powerful behavioral desensitization, counter-conditioning, mindfulness and simple, yet effective cognitive interventions. . . . REMAP has a central focus of calming the emotional midbrain and soothing the sympathetic nervous system in order to counter condition subcortical conditioned responses. Through innovative applications of acupressure, mindfulness, breath regulation and activation of regions within the visual field, REMAP works from body to brain in order to desensitize emotional distress. Through this mechanism [as if they’ve actually explained it], the REMAP methods help to retrain the limbic system to make associations of relaxation and comfort with memories that were previously coded as painful.
One can actually become “certified” in acutonics, TAT and REMAP. In fact, the cachet of certification and its implied legitimacy can be achieved in any number of pseudoscientific practices employed by social workers: Certified Angelic Life Purpose Coach, Certified Avesa Quantum Healer, Certified Biofield Tuning Practitioner, Certified BTB Feng Shui Master, Certified Cuddle Party Facilitator (which sounds a bit creepy), Certified Dream Coach, Certified Flower and Gem Essence Therapist, Certified Humanistic Sand Tray Therapist, Certified Intuitive Healer, Certified Matrix Energetics Practitioner, Certified Neurokinesis Practitioner, and Certified Theta Healer, among others.
Like the creators of acutonics, TAT and REMAP, entrepreneurs have fabricated elaborate (allegedly) therapeutic systems, either by combining established pseudoscientific practices or, in some cases, just making stuff up on their own. For example, Bodytalk uses a modified form of applied kinesiology quackery to
. . . easily ask your body what communication circuits have become compromised and in which order these lines of communication need to be re-established for the fastest possible healing process to occur.
Then,
Your practitioner uses the BodyTalk Protocol Chart to determine the weakened or broken energy circuits in your bodymind complex that are being highlighted by your innate healing wisdom
Next,
The practitioner then lightly taps you on the top of the head, which stimulates your brain and causes it to initiate corrections to the broken circuits. This is similar to how the CPU of a computer runs and executes programs. [Actually, it’s not.] This tapping activates the brain centers in a way that causes the brain to reevaluate the bodymind’s state of health and then align the frequencies within the bodymind to match the formula that was created.
This is followed by taps to the sternum and navel for similarly laughable purposes.
Implausible hardly begins to describe Bodytalk, yet this social worker claims it eliminated allergies, food poisoning and jet lag, as well as “balanced” an irregular heartbeat, ADD and ADHD.
Finally, in the “you can’t make this stuff up” category, we find Aura Infusions, which apparently is made up and used by this single practitioner. (No “certification” in Aura Infusions is offered.)
Each Aura Infusion is carefully blended to bring in higher energies, repair your energy electrical system and balance your mood. The bottles are prepared individually, with the utmost care and attention to assure a high vibration product. A Herkimer Diamond is prepared for each bottle, which harmonizes the formulation of botanicals and gems, and prepares these energies to be transmitted to the aura. The Herkimer diamond is placed inside each bottle, which potentiates the botanicals and gems in the formula. The effect of vibrational alchemy allows your original energetic blueprint to emerge according to your own pace. . .
Typically, these botanical blends are sprayed into the air around you as you enjoy the aromatics. Your Aura Field will come into contact with the synergistic vitality of the spray. Also, the air-borne molecules of the high grade aromatherapy oils are taken into the olafactory [sic] bulb, where they are translated into impulses received by the limbic brain for relaxation, centering, and settling and balancing of emotions.
The answer is “no”
Returning to the question the authors ask in the title of their article, but do not answer – Should social workers be engaged in these practices? – I would answer most emphatically “no”. What, then, as they also ask, to do about it?
Social workers are regulated by the individual states in the U.S., each with different laws, rules, and requirements for licensure. Complaints can be filed with regulatory boards or, if the alleged wrongdoer is a member of the National Association of Social Workers, with that organization.
But if the prevalence of pseudoscience in medicine is any indication of how well a state regulatory system works to combat quackery, this is obviously not the solution, although it might offer some deterrence. There needs to be a concerted national effort to stamp out pseudoscience in all of healthcare. Unfortunately, since medicine and other healthcare professions have abandoned science as a standard, and legislators fail to effectively regulate quackery (in fact, they regularly incorporate it into law), that isn’t going to happen anytime soon.

Juvent: Space Age Technology to Achieve Total Health?
Juvent is a small vibrating platform that is advertised to provide all kinds of health benefits for everyone by just standing on it for 10 minutes a day. They have no convincing evidence and the price is exorbitant.
Harriet Hall on July 14, 2020
Link
Ads for Juvent keep popping up in my Facebook feed. It is a small micro-impact vibrating platform that looks similar to a bathroom scale. Standing on it for only 10 minutes a day is said to provide these benefits:
    • Better Bone Health
    • Less Joint Pain
    • Better Range of Motion
    • Better Circulation
    • Better Lymphatic Drainage
    • Faster Recovery
    • Enhanced Strength
They claim that “it is impossible to achieve total health without a sufficient amount of skeletal impact.” Standing on the Juvent platform for 10-20 minutes a day just 3 days a week “has been shown to help improve blood flow, ease joint, knee and back pain, and increase stability.” I couldn’t find any studies to support that claim. Its software allegedly “calibrates frequency to your body’s unique composition”, finding your body’s specific resonant frequency between 32 and 37 Hz. Within 12 seconds, it “adjusts to ideally fit his or her body, so multiple users of any shape and size can safely benefit.” Its patented mechanism moves you up and down by less than the width of two human hairs.
They call it “high frequency”, but 32-37 Hz is a very low frequency. Why do they think the body’s resonant frequency is between 32 and 37 Hz? And why do they think supplying it is beneficial? I question whether it is appropriate to speak of the specific resonant frequency of a whole living organism. A 2001 study by engineers assumed it was, but they said that exposure to the resonant frequency may cause undue stress and discomfort in the human body, and that researchers had determined the human whole-body resonant frequency to be either 5 Hz or 10 Hz. Other researchers have reported different resonant frequencies for different parts of the body.
The cost of the regular platform is $4,995.00; the “Pro” version costs $5,195.00. The only difference from the standard unit is the color. They try to justify the high price by saying they test extensively and calibrate the devices to within one 10,000th of an inch. They bad-mouth less expensive devices and brag that their motherboards are gold-layered for corrosion resistance and durability.
Juvent is “registered” with the FDA, a process that does not require premarket review. It is not “FDA approved.”
Testimonials
They provide lots of testimonials reporting improved balance, relief of pain from injuries and arthritis, improved golf swing, reduced PSA levels, relief of knee pain and swelling due to Lyme disease, relief of knee pain from medial meniscus tear injury, complete relief of restless leg syndrome, reduced swelling, and much more.
One woman says she has used Juvent every day for 4 ½ years and her balance and bone density have improved, and the inflamed nerves in her feet have healed. Her medical knowledge is shaky; she says “I AM USING A NUTRITIONAL SUPPLEMENT (PROTOCEL) FOR MY BREAST CANCER AND I MUST BE ABLE TO EXERCISE DAILY IN ORDER TO CLEAN OUT MY LYMPH SYSTEMS OF DEAD CANCER CELLS AND I USE MY JUVENT DAILY TO DO THIS.” The National Cancer Institute website tells us “The ingredients thought to be in Protocel have been tested, and none of them have been shown to be effective in treating any form of cancer. Protocel is not available in the United States.”
The evidence
As evidence, they offer “white papers”. In a clever marketing ploy, they make you sign up to get access to their evidence; and when you do, they start bombarding your email account with messages. The papers cite a few studies, but they are not actually evidence for the specific device they are selling. Many of the studies looked at whole body vibration. Juvent makes a big deal of distinguishing between Juvent’s low magnitude, high frequency micro displacement technology and the high to mid magnitude, high frequency, high displacement technology of whole-body vibrators. They even offer a table differentiating [PDF] between the two types of vibration.
They cite mouse studies whose findings may not be applicable to humans. One of them failed to show enhancement of bone or muscle by low-intensity vibration training. A study of human patients with spinal cord injury showed no improvement of bone density in response to vibration training.
They mention a study showing that Micro-Impact Therapy improves bone density in pediatric cancer survivors. And a study showing that low-magnitude high-frequency vibration enhances bone remodeling in osteoporotic rat femoral fracture healing. They cite a number of other studies that show benefits for whole body vibration. Juvent does not supply whole body vibration, and in a small study of 8 men with spinal cord injury (SCI) and 10 men without, when Juvent was compared to WAVE whole body vibration plates, the patients with SCI preferred the WAVE.
The NASA connection
They call it “Space Age Technology”. What are they talking about? Astronauts have decreased bone density after their sojourn in space. That’s not from lack of vibration, but from lack of gravity. They claim that micro-impact vibration is essential to health for everyone, not just returning astronauts. They say we used to get the vibrations by going barefoot, and now we need to get it from their machines. I guess they don’t want you to go barefoot, because they offer ridiculously expensive sandals. They also sell water filters and dietary supplements. Their HydroxyBMD AM/PM Bone Health System starts at $165.78. It contains a strange mixture of ingredients.
Conclusion: no good reason to buy Juvent
They extrapolate from a few suggestive studies and the evidence of bone loss in astronauts to say that everyone would benefit from using the Juvent device. They promise you will “feel better every day.” They fail to make their case. It might benefit some people with osteoporosis or poor balance, but the evidence is far from clear, and there’s no evidence that it would benefit people who didn’t have those problems. The marketing is slick, but the claims are not credible. I wonder how many potential customers will be seduced by the hype. I predict that they probably won’t sell many devices because the cost of $5,000 will be prohibitive for the average consumer.

Innovo for Bladder Leakage
An expensive pair of shorts promises to cure bladder leaks by using electrical stimulation to produce pelvic floor contractions, essentially doing the Kegel exercises for you. The science is insufficient and the marketing is misleading.
Harriet Hall on February 22, 2022
Link

My mailbox is a good source of questionable claims. The other day I received a spiffy ad for Innovo.
Innovo was invented by a physical therapist. It features fitted shorts that provide electrical stimulation to make the pelvic floor muscles contract, essentially doing the Kegel exercises for you. It is “FDA cleared…The shorts should be worn for 30 minutes a day, 5 days a week” but that doesn’t mean the same as “FDA approved” and it doesn’t mean the FDA has evaluated it for effectiveness.
The Innovo ad says that research showed that nearly 50% of women can’t do a Kegel exercise correctly. I was unable to verify that figure. A PT website estimated 30%. A 2013 study found that most women could do it correctly after a simple verbal cue, and many more did it correctly after brief instruction.
How common are bladder leaks? The Innovo ad says 1 in 3 women, but the incidence increases with age and can be much higher in older women. A poll showed a higher overall percentage of women reported bladder leaks but also found that some women didn’t consider it a significant problem and had not mentioned it to their doctors.
Innovo claims to “Eliminate leaks in 12 weeks…the only clinically proven device that eliminates bladder leaks for good.” It says that Innovo will eliminate the need for pads, liners, and leakproof underwear by fixing the underlying problem of weak pelvic floor muscles. It cites a single research study that they say showed 87% of women were defined as dry or nearly dry after 12 weeks of treatment with Innovo. I was able to locate that study. It compared the Innovo device to a modified device “programmed to produce a lower dose of pelvic floor muscle stimulation with a strong sensory response compared with the active device.” It did not say 87% of women were improved. The results were actually negative. There were only non-significant differences for most of the endpoints studied. And the company website ignores the “nearly dry” category and implies that all 87% were “dry”.
They say 98% of doctors recommend Innovo. I must assume that they just made that up. They also mention that Innovo was featured on “Goop” and on The View. To my mind, that’s no recommendation.
They offer a lot of testimonials, which reveal some problems. Some users reported significant pain with initial treatments. A spray must be applied before donning the shorts, and the controller must be adjusted for the individual. Users must adopt one of the recommended positions. Accurate fitting is essential, and sometimes supplemental padding is necessary.
The price is $449.50, although there is a $100 discount if you use a code, and apparently Medicare covers similar devices, but Aetna doesn’t.
Conclusion: The ads are misleading
Innovo may be effective, but the scientific evidence is not very convincing. I would hesitate to invest all that money and time, when there are so many other treatments available with better scientific support, including bladder training, biofeedback, medications, pessaries, lifestyle adjustments, and surgery.
I have no objections if people choose to try it, but I do object to the misleading marketing.

Allergy Release Technique
A dubious intervention for food allergies follows a typical pattern for such treatments.
Steven Novella on March 23, 2022
Link

Food allergies affect about 32 million people in the US alone. They can be a significant burden on quality of life and carry the risk of anaphylaxis, which can be fatal if not treated promptly. Living in fear of a deadly reaction results in significant anxiety, and requires vigilant avoidance which is disruptive to social behavior.
The standard management of food allergies is identification of the specific foods that trigger a reaction, avoidance of those foods, and education into the emergency use of epinephrine injections (epi-pens). Gradual desensitization is also a treatment option, either with injection or oral consumption of gradually-increasing doses of the allergen (oral immunotherapy, OIT). Most allergic responses are due to sensitivity of the IgE antibodies. Desensitization works by building IgG antibodies to the offending allergen, which neutralizes the allergen before a significant IgE response can occur. There are some risks to this approach, and it should only be performed under the supervision of a trained clinician.
Still there is a large unmet need in terms of effective cures for food allergies that allow people to live a normal life without fear of a deadly allergic reaction to a common food. Just as nature abhors a vacuum, unmet medical needs attract enthusiastic but dubious gurus and practitioners. One such dubious treatment is the Allergy Release Technique (ART), which was invented by Amy Thieringer, a certified health and life coach. She promotes the treatment as “holistic” but it is really just a repackaging of real treatments with a garnish of worthless pseudoscience.
She also promotes her treatment by referring to a recent clinical study:
Boston Children’s Hospital and Boston University have published a collaborative pilot study in The Journal of Alternative and Integrative Medicine on the A.R.T. process, which clinically validates the transformative results of Amy’s work.
Except that it doesn’t. Let’s take a look at that study, which unfortunately follows an all-too-familiar pattern. To call this a “pilot” study is being generous. The study looks at 20 subjects total, 10 receiving ART and 10 receiving standard medical care. The study is also retrospective, and potential clients were contacted by e-mail, letters, or phone. This isn’t even a sequential case series – subjects were self-selected. The authors acknowledge:
…this was not a randomized prospective study so some families who opted to participate in ART might differ in motivation or other variables that might affect allergy progression…Finally, ART was delivered by an experienced provider who may have developed special rapport with participants, perhaps affecting outcomes.
I wonder if having a “health coach” as a cheerleader affected the outcome. The standard management in this study involved diagnosis, avoidance, and education without any medical intervention designed to reduce the allergic response. The ART intervention group involved desensitization to minute and gradually increasing amount of food allergen. Wait a minute – that’s OIT. That is an evidence-based intervention shown to decrease allergic response. But it was combined with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) to reduce anxiety. That is a second evidence-based already established intervention. So what’s new?
Each week, using a galvanometer device (Bioscan system, International Health Technologies) with accompanying software (Bioscan MSA 141) to measure the electrical resistance between one of two acupuncture points on the fingers of one hand (in Chinese acupuncture, points Nervous system NE-1b* and Allergy (upper toxicity), AL-1b*) and an electrode held in the other hand (skin conductance) when allergens are placed on a metal plate on the galvanometer or highlighted in the software library.
This is common allergy pseudoscience, even without the non-existent acupuncture points. The fourth intervention is:
Tapping up and down the patient’s spine after allergen or electromagnetic exposures, using the side of the practitioner’s hand while patients take deep, slow inhalations and exhalations.
This is worthless medical theater. So we have two proven interventions one quack intervention and one magic theater. I wonder which components of this intervention had any effect. The study results, as worthless as they are given the severe limitations mentioned above, were also not impressive. The only real significant finding was that the SPT wheal diameter (size of the skin reaction after a prick test with the allergen) was decreased in the treatment group compared to standard care. However, SIgE and TIgE antibody titers were not different between the two groups. Anxiety levels were also not different, but reported quality of life was improved in the ART group. This mixed outcome is common when investigating essentially useless interventions.
This small retrospective study proves absolutely nothing. I would not even use it as evidence of safety, given the self-selective nature of the recruitment process. There were no food challenges in the standard treatment group, and no records of allergic reactions during the study duration of four years. The authors further acknowledge:
However, additional investigation is necessary to confirm these advantages and to understand the immunologic mechanisms, including which of the ART components are driving the effects.
But do we really? I think we can guess which of the ART components are driving the effects (if they are even real). Is it what amounts to a version of oral immunotherapy (a proven treatment), or the tapping along the spine?
I have no problem studying fringe treatments, but the medially trained authors on this study are being naïve. A pilot study should be used solely to get an idea of safety and help design studies that are rigorous and powerful enough to draw actual conclusions regarding safety and efficacy. But that is not what happens in the alternative medicine world. Rather, pilot studies like this, which are almost guaranteed to be positive, or are misinterpreted as positive, are used for promotion. The later more rigorous studies generally are never done. If they are, and they are almost always negative, the results are ignored and believers move on to less rigorous “pragmatic studies” that show what they want. Studies like this are not used to determine “if” a treatment works, only for promotion. That is what is happening here.
The authors conclude:
The efficacy and effectiveness of ART should continue to be investigated using larger samples, a prospective design, disaggregating individual ART components, and comparing ART to OIT.
I do not see any trials registered in clinicaltrials.gov to perform an actual clinical trial as above (this study was published in 2019). I have contacted one of the authors to inquire about any future plans for study without any response yet (I will add an addendum if they respond). Meanwhile desperate parents and children will continue to pay for a dubious treatment requiring weekly visits for two years or more, with the disclaimer:
As you consider the A.R.T. process, it is important to understand that successful outcomes are only possible with clients who are committed, active participants.
It’s always good to build in an excuse blaming the patient when a treatment does not work as hoped. This should not be considered a benign intervention. The authors also made pains to point out that OIT should not be administered by someone who is not qualified, and that ART does not follow standard safety protocol for OIT.

Fake treatments for real diseases: A review of allergy and asthma advertisements by naturopaths, chiropractors, homeopaths and acupuncturists
A majority of Canadian chiropractic, naturopathic, homeopathic and acupuncture clinics claim that they can diagnose or treat allergies, sensitivities and asthma.
Scott Gavura on December 29, 2016
Link


For the past few years I’ve been adding to what I call the naturopathy versus science series of posts, where I’ve been examining the public advice and writing by naturopaths on a particular topic, and contrasting it against the scientific evidence. I’ve focused on naturopaths instead of other “alternative-to-medicine” providers because naturopaths actively promote themselves as health professions capable of delivering primary care, akin to medical doctors. And in many parts of Canada and the United States they have been successful with this marketing, despite the fact that the naturopathic curriculum is filled with pseudoscience, and there is no convincing evidence to show that naturopathy offers anything that is uniquely useful or incrementally better than “conventional” medicine.
What I’ve learned from writing these posts has been sobering. I’ve looked at the naturopathic perspectives on fake diseases, infertility, prenatal vitamins, vaccinations, allergies, and even scientific facts themselves. While they can offer reasonable, science-based advice, naturopaths may also offer health advice that can be at odds with medical evidence and sometimes even basic laws of physics. Naturopaths claim to treat serious chronic diseases like diabetes, and their advice can range from sensible to the useless or potentially harmful.
Timothy Caulfield is a Canadian researcher who has done this type of work in a more systematic, structured way. A letter published a few years ago in Allergy, Asthma, & Clinical Immunology was one approach to understand the alignment between naturopathy and scientific standards. Caulfield and Christen Rachul found that the most widely-advertised practices in Alberta and British Columbia lacked a sound evidence base:
A review of the therapies advertised on the websites of clinics offering naturopathic treatments does not support the proposition that naturopathic medicine is a science and evidence-based practice.
Caulfield has a new paper that builds on his past study. He’s expanded the scan to include chiropractors, acupuncturists, and homeopaths, and has focused exclusively on treatment claims related to allergies, “sensitivities” and asthma. And what’s he’s identified raises concerns about the potential for ineffective and possibly harmful treatments being offered to consumers by these providers.
Fake medicine for real diseases can be deadly
Allergies and asthma can be mild conditions, but they can also be fatal. Asthma kills hundreds of thousands per year worldwide. It isn’t a disease that should be treated trivially, with treatments that don’t work. Yet that’s exactly what can happen when you don’t consider the scientific evidence supporting the treatments you use (or sell). Untreated (or under-treated) asthma can cause long-term lung damage. Fortunately there are demonstrably effective medications that can reduce the short- and long-term effects of asthma.
The best study I’ve seen that demonstrates how fake medicine can be perceived to treat real conditions was a study of placebo versus albuterol (an asthma medicine) and “fake” acupuncture versus “real” acupuncture in asthma patients. Rather than digress to this study (rather than the one I want to get to) I’ll point you to Peter Lipson’s post that summarizes it nicely. The bottom line from the study was that, not surprisingly, placebo can make an asthma patient feel better but when it came to objective measurements of actual effects on lung function, acupuncture (real or fake) offered no benefit whatsoever. This is an important finding and sets the context for Caulfield’s latest paper: Patients may report that they feel better when they use ineffective treatments like acupuncture, but these are placebo effects. To get real effects in the treatment of a condition like asthma, you must use real medicine. There are no objectively meaningful “placebo” effects.
Who are the providers?
For some of you that may not be regular readers of this blog, understanding the differences between alternative medicine providers may be helpful in interpreting this new paper, and the authors’ conclusions. Unlike what are called “allied health professionals” (e.g., nurses, pharmacists, physiotherapists, dieticians, speech language pathologists, etc.), alternative medicine providers offer services that do not share scientific and biomedical underpinnings with the conventional scientific medical model. The four mentioned in Caulfield’s new paper are:
Homeopaths: Homeopathy was invented by German physician Samuel Hahnemann in 1796. It is based on the belief that if you dilute something that causes your symptoms when healthy, it can cure those same symptoms when you are sick. The more you dilute the substance, the more powerful it is believed to become. Substances can range from coffee to vacuum cleaner dust or dolphin sonar. (Homeopaths, please let me know how you collect and bottle dolphin sonar.) Homeopaths believe the most powerful substances are those that are so dilute there is mathematically zero chance that any of the original substance remains. Homeopaths claim these remedies are effective because water is thought to retain a “memory” of the original substance. Not surprisingly, there is no convincing evidence that homeopathy is anything other than an elaborate placebo system.
Acupuncturists: Acupuncture is (most commonly) the practice of placing very thin needles in the skin in specific regions of the body. With Chinese origins, acupuncture is only several decades old as is currently practiced. While it is believed that pushing needles into designated areas is more effective than pretending to stick needles into people, the scientific evidence shows that “fake” acupuncture is just as effective as “real” acupuncture. There’s a lack of good evidence to show that acupuncture offers any meaningful medical effects beyond placebo effects.
Chiropractors: Chiropractic was invented by D.D. Palmer in 1895 and is based on the idea that the spine is connected to all other organs, so by manipulating the spine through the elimination of “subluxations” (which are identifiable only to chiropractors) that health can be restored to the body. Unlike acupuncture and homeopathy there is some evidence to suggest that the manipulation techniques used by chiropractors can be effective for some types of low back pain. However many chiropractors believe the can treat conditions for which there is no credible evidence that spinal manipulation can be effective.
Naturopaths: Naturopathy is an alternative medicine practice based on a belief in vitalism, the concept that living beings have a “life force” not found in inanimate objects. Naturopathic treatment ideas are all grounded in the idea of restoring this “energy”, rather than being based on objective science. Naturopathy has evolved to include practices like homeopathy and acupuncture, and also herbalism and Traditional Chinese Medicine. Pretty much anything goes in naturopathy (it’s not clear there is a naturopathic standard of care), as long as it is felt to align with the underlying naturopathic philosophy.
Selling falsehoods?
With this background in mind let’s now turn to a new paper by Blake Murdock, Stuart Carr and Timothy Caulfield at the University of Alberta. (I highly recommend Caulfields’s book A Cure for Everything?) Caulfield is one of the most outspoken Canadian critics of pseudoscience, particularly when pseudoscience masquerades as real medicine. This new paper is a straightforward cross-sectional analysis of marketing claims made by Canadian chiropractors, naturopaths, homeopaths and acupuncturists, entitled “Selling falsehoods? A cross-sectional study of Canadian naturopathy, homeopathy, chiropractic and acupuncture clinic website claims relating to allergy and asthma.” The paper was published in BMJ Open in December, 2016, and is open access.
The paper’s introduction describes the current context for complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in Canada. Like other countries around the world, CAM highly popular, with chiropractic being by far the most popular practice accessed by Canadians (40% access in a lifetime, versus 17% for acupuncturists, 9% for naturopaths and 9% for homeopaths.) The authors note that while CAM providers are increasingly being described as primary care providers, that the scope of conditions that are claimed to be amenable to alternative medicine is both broad and largely unsubstantiated.
The researchers selected 10 large Canadian metropolitan areas and using the web tool isearchfrom.com, performed regional searches to identify CAM practitioner websites. Within the 400 websites, they analyzed them for the terms “sensitivity”, “allergy”, and “asthma,” and then looked for claims about the ability to treat these conditions. Here are the main findings, broken down by mention/claim and type of CAM provider:

The majority of practitioners mentioned these conditions on their website, with the majority also claiming to treat allergies and asthma. Remarkably, about 75% of naturopaths claim to treat allergies and asthma despite the lack of unique “naturopathic” treatments that have been demonstrated to effectively treat these conditions. Also concerning are the substantial numbers of chiropractors, homeopaths, and acupuncturists who claim to treat allergies and asthma, despite the fact there are similarly no treatments that these practitioners offer which have been shown to offer any meaningful, objective benefits for these conditions. Despite this, efficacy claims are common:

The authors go on to break down the results by geographic region, which I’ll defer comment on other than to observe that Vancouver seems to be CAM central when it comes to claims about efficacy and treatment. More interesting (and concerning) is the list of tests and treatments recommended for the treatment of allergies, sensitivities and asthma. While disclaimers were noted on some websites, explicit claims were also made about the ability of these practitioners to diagnose and treat these conditions:

Not surprisingly, there’s a lack of evidence to support many of these treatments, which the authors note raises ethical questions. Live blood analysis, Vega testing, intravenous vitamins, and homeopathy are all clinically useless for the diagnosis or treatment of these conditions. The authors correctly point out that not only can this lead to dietary changes that may be harmful (particularly in children), that these types of treatments may result in greater healthcare demands overall and even the financial exploitation of consumers who may be led to believe these tests and treatments are of value.
Use caution when evaluating claims
Despite the growing acceptance of CAM and CAM providers, there is persistent evidence that the interventions advertised by chiropractors, acupuncturists, naturopaths and homeopaths lack evidence of effectiveness. To date, in Canada and worldwide, there have been few attempts to hold these providers accountable for the claims that they make, and the tests and diagnoses that they offer. The authors suggest a number of strategies that could be considered, including more effective regulation of advertising, as well as considering specific approaches to protect minors. Ultimately until there is the recognition that these providers and practices may be harmful, this remains an area where consumers must be very cautious. Given the findings of this paper, it would seem prudent to discuss the use of CAM providers or treatments for allergies, sensitivities or asthma, with health professionals, preferably ones that are legitimate specialists in these conditions.

Coca’s Pulse Testing to Diagnose “Allergies”
In the 1950s, Dr. Arthur F. Coca invented an elaborate method to diagnose a new kind of “allergy” by testing the pulse rate. He thought “allergies” were the underlying cause of most disease. His method has never been tested, but there is every reason to think it is bogus.
Harriet Hall on March 13, 2018
Link

I recently got an email from a gentleman who told me I was wrong about many things because I “come from an era of incomplete medical education and information.” He rambled on but had two main points: modern doctors fail to recognize a kind of allergy that defies standard diagnosis and that is the cause of pretty much every health problem, and MSG is a poison that should be banned. He said, “…about 3,500 unsuspecting Americans are dying prematurely of undiagnosed allergies aggravated with FDA approved food poisoning every day in 2018.”
I told him I would be glad to complete my medical education and asked for reliable sources that would properly educate me. He answered, “therein lies the problem. Despite all I’ve heard about medicine and alternative medicine I don’t know of any. About the best I can do for now and have been doing is to suggest the reading of Dr. Coca’s THE PULSE TEST and, much more recently, John Erb’s THE SLOW POISONING OF MANKIND and to learn by doing.”
I’ll leave MSG for a later date; today I’ll discuss Arthur F. Coca’s pulse test for allergies. The full text of Coca’s book is available for free online. I read it. I was not impressed.
The pulse test
Coca’s discovery of the pulse test was prompted by his wife’s experience. She developed angina pectoris and noticed that her attacks of chest pain occurred within minutes of eating certain foods, and that after eating those foods, her pulse always accelerated. Coca deduced that harmful foods could be identified by testing for an increase in pulse rate.
He decided that he had discovered a new kind of “allergy” that explained all these health problems: recurrent headache, nervousness, migraine, dizziness, constipation, canker sores, heartburn, epilepsy, overweight, underweight, irritability, gastric ulcer, abdominal pain, gallbladder pain, gastric pain, nervous and emotional instability (neurasthenia), abnormal tiredness, indigestion (vomiting, gas, nausea), neuralgia, sinusitis, hypertension, hives, heart attacks (angina), asthma, hemorrhoids, psychic depression, diabetes, chest pain, gastrointestinal bleeding, conjunctivitis, nose bleed, and colitis.
He claims to have treated all these conditions successfully by identifying and avoiding the offending foods.
He developed elaborate rules for diagnosis, with no explanation of how he arrived at them. For a baseline, patients are asked to take their pulse 14 times a day at specified times. If the highest count is the same each day and is not over 84, they are probably not allergic. If the maximal count varies more than 2 beats from day to day, they are certainly allergic. Foods are then tested one at a time and if the pulse rises, that means they are allergic to that food. In addition to foods, symptoms can be produced by environmental allergens like tobacco, house dust, fumes, medicines, soap powder, and wood smoke. He notes that there are exceptions to his rules, but he explains them away. For instance, he says sensitivities can be temporarily lost. He is content to accumulate a mass of examples that confirm his hypothesis but doesn’t look for examples that might disconfirm it. He never thinks to ask if there might be any other explanations for his results. He doesn’t take the essential step of testing with a control group.
There are a number of different versions of the Coca test promoted on various alternative medicine websites, using different criteria for how many increased beats per minute (and sometimes even decreased beats!) constitute a positive test. And none provide any credible evidence for the test’s validity.
He provides case histories (anecdotes) of “almost miraculous” resolution of symptoms both in patients he has seen and in patients he has not (hearsay).
He plays the “lone genius” persecution card, saying the establishment is unwilling to even consider his findings and has prevented publication of his results.
Here we go again!
Reading his book was a painful experience for me. I could see step by step how he had made unwarranted assumptions, succumbed to confirmation bias, and deluded himself. I have heard this same story so many times before! Just a few examples: Batmanghelidj and his water cure, Jennifer Daniels and turpentine , a Navy neurologist’s adoption of acupuncture, Upledger’s discovery of craniosacral therapy, Hahnemann’s discovery of homeopathy, Palmer’s discovery of chiropractic, the origins of iridology and ear acupuncture… the list goes on.
The story goes like this:
     1.  He observes something and misinterprets it.
     2.  He extrapolates from one or a few cases to invent a general principle.
     3.  He doesn’t even consider the possibility that he might be wrong.
     4.  He doesn’t do any controlled scientific testing.
     5.  He proceeds to treat patients. Many get better, perhaps because of the natural course of illness, regression to the mean, placebo effects, or other unrecognized factors, Without doing controlled studies, there is no way of knowing whether the treatment was responsible for the improvement, but he firmly convinces himself that it was.
     6.  He is flattered and reinforced by feedback from grateful patients who believe he cured them.
     7.  Confirmation bias sets in.
     8.  He becomes a true believer.
     9.  When others try to point out what is wrong, he refuses to listen; instead, he cries persecution and censorship.
Could there be anything to it?
Coca was born in 1875 and died in 1959, long before today’s understanding of the concept of evidence-based medicine. He thought he had “evidence.” He didn’t recognize that it was flawed. He didn’t understand the requirements of the scientific method, and he never put his beliefs to any kind of a valid scientific test. I don’t judge him too harshly; he was only doing what many other doctors did in his era. But I think it is obvious that he was fooling himself.The whole idea is implausible. In the first place, the heart rate is naturally variable; in fact, a low heart rate variability (HRV) seems to be associated with adverse health effects including an increased risk of death. Many factors affect the pulse rate, and when patients are aware that a food is being tested, anxiety, excitement, and other factors could affect the pulse rate. There are just too many variables for the pulse test to be a reliable indicator of anything.
Coca never defines what he means by “allergy,” and he offers no explanation for how it could cause all those disparate conditions. There is no plausible mechanism. How could a single cause underlie epilepsy, diabetes, hypertension, migraine, conjunctivitis, colitis, and constipation? Similar claims for “one true cause of all disease,” are ubiquitous and bogus.
Coca’s book was published in 1956. If he was onto something, we could expect to have seen some confirmatory studies in the medical literature over the six decades since he published it. There is nothing.
Conclusion: Not disproven, but not worth testing
If we can’t definitively say pulse testing for “allergies” is bogus, at least we can say it is highly improbable, bordering on the impossible. The only way to determine whether Coca’s hypothesis is valid is to test it properly in controlled studies. In my opinion, authorizing such studies would be a waste of scarce research funds that would be better spent elsewhere.
In the absence of evidence, if patients want to try pulse testing, there’s very little potential for downside. Checking your pulse and experimenting with eliminating specific foods from your diet are relatively harmless. Just be aware that such self-experimentation can lead to false conclusions. That’s why we need science: to keep from fooling ourselves.

Are skin-lightening glutathione injections safe and effective?
Naturopaths advertise injections claimed to lighten skin. Are these products safe and effective?
Scott Gavura onJ anuary 22, 2015
Link

A Toronto naturopath’s advertisements were recently criticized on social media for insensitivity and racism:

Naturopath Jean-Jacqques Dugoua sells glutathione injections, claiming it will give “brighter, lighter and glowing skin”. His URL, lightnaturalskin.com seems to imply that lighter skin is more natural, and he claims the following:
After over 3 years of treating patients for skin concerns, Dr. JJ has developed the Skin Brightening IV, which includes glutathione, vitamin C and other vitamins/minerals. Not only is this treatment effective for most people, it is also safe. The Skin Brightening IV glutathione is a good alternative to skin bleaching creams, which can damage, scar, inflame, discolour or irritate the skin, or microderm abrasion, which is painful and may also irritate the skin and sometimes worsen hyper-pigmentation.
This safe and natural treatment involves principally the use of intravenous (IV) vitamins (excluding vitamin A), minerals and amino acids, including glutathione. All ingredients are regulated by Health Canada and obtained from pharmacies or pharmaceutical companies in Canada or the United States. The treatment is performed in compliance with licensure in Ontario.
Dugoua is not the only naturopath that advertises glutathione injections for skin lightening. The Lococo Wellness Clinic in Hamilton, Ontario claims:
Want to lighten your skin tone? You can with the Glutathione Skin Lightening/Whitening Treatment!
Our Intravenous Glutathione Skin Whitening Treatment can lighten your skin evenly. Glutathione is administered via IV and is able to deposit evenly throughout the body. Glutathione will swop up the oxidative damaged cells (which cause skin to darken) and lighten your skin naturally, safely, evenly and in a healthy manner.
Glutathione is advertised heavily by naturopaths as a panacea for many conditions. Flourish Natural Medicine in Portland claims:
It’s the most important molecule you need to stay healthy and prevent disease — yet you’ve probably never heard of it. It’s the secret to prevent aging, cancer, heart disease, dementia and more, and necessary to treat everything from autism to Alzheimer’s disease. There are more than 89,000 medical articles about it — but your doctor doesn’t know how address the epidemic deficiency of this critical life-giving molecule … What is it? I’m talking about the mother of all antioxidants, the master detoxifier and maestro of the immune system: GLUTATHIONE
Skin lightening has a controversial background. Ideas equating skin lightness with desirability, beauty and even class/caste are prevalent in some cultures. Shadeism (or colorism) is a term used to describe discrimination based on skin tone within a community, with lightness being perceived as more desirable. The marketing of skin lightening products is widespread, as is their use. Worldwide, this is a billion-dollar industry, one with a lot of critics. The official reaction to the naturopath’s advertisement was quick: The Toronto Transit Commission pulled the ads, based on complaints received.
I’m not going to comment on the appropriateness of skin lightening, the social context, or the ethical issues these products present. I’m also not going to comment on intravenous vitamins or the other ingredients naturopaths advertise, as it’s been established that these vitamin injections are useless. What I want to examine is the scientific evidence supporting the efficacy and safety of glutathione injections for the purpose of lightening skin. The naturopathic profession has a reputation for touting products and services that are useless, ineffective, lacking good evidence, and sometimes even dangerous. Is glutathione different? Given the alternatives used by those that desire lighter skin, are glutathione injections preferable, or at least, less harmful than other products?
Before we look at the science, it’s important to consider the context, as these services seem to be delivered exclusively by naturopaths. As a health professional, I see my role as encouraging and supporting patient autonomy and decision-making by providing credible, unbiased, evidence-based scientific information to support treatment decisions. Health care today is a collaborative practice delivered by many disciplines. Whether it’s a doctor, nurse, pharmacist or a physiotherapist, our roles are built on a common foundation: science. Naturopathy is different. Naturopathy has its own definition of “medicine” that differs from that of science-based health professionals. While naturopaths describe themselves a primary care providers, just like medical doctors, they do not practice from a scientific framework. Naturopaths offer an array of disparate health practices like homeopathy, acupuncture and herbalism that are linked by the (now discarded) belief in vitalism – the idea we have a “life force”. From this philosophy can sometimes emerge reasonable health advice, but it’s not because it’s based on credible scientific information. As long as it’s congruent with the naturopathic belief system, it’s acceptably “naturopathic”. Over the past several months I’ve taken a closer look at naturopathy versus science, examining naturopathic advice in several areas against the scientific evidence. It has consistently come up short.
I’ve never recommended or endorsed the use a skin lightening product. But if given a question about glutathione from a patient, I would first seek to understand their rationale – is it simply to lighten one’s complexion? Or are there other skin issues of concern? I’d then turn to the medical literature, understanding the scientific evidence, the risks and the unanswered questions. I’d also look at costs to help the patient evaluate the value-for-money. It should be acknowledged that a lightening product that is safe and effective could be significantly better for consumers than the widely marketed creams and lotions that are the more traditional approaches to lightening. Mercury toxicity and poisoning is not uncommon from these products. Another common ingredient, hydroquinone, is banned in many countries because of the harms it can cause. The sometimes-dubious manufacturing practices heighten the risks.
The evidence
Glutathione is an antioxidant that is naturally synthesized in the body. It is involved with numerous biochemical pathways and may have some role in different diseases, but there is a lack of robust evidence linking supplementation to changes in health outcomes. In spite of this, glutathione seems to be a darling of the alternative medicine industry. Dr. Oz calls glutathione “the superhero of antioxidants.” Mark Hyman calls it “the mother of all antioxidants.” Importantly, while glutathione is also found in food, dietary consumption doesn’t appear to relate to blood levels, suggesting that oral supplementation may not be that effective. And given our bodies synthesize glutathione, the relationship between supplementation, blood levels and disease is not established.
There have been preliminary studies of glutathione for a number of uses, such as Parkinson’s disease. The best scientific evidence for infusions seems to be for its possible use to reduce the side-effects of cancer therapy.
When it comes to skin whitening, glutathione may have anti-melanogenic effects. There have been some studies conducted on the oral version and on a topical lotion. The trials have been small but generally positive.
I could locate no published evidence that demonstrates that intravenous glutathione is an effective skin-lightening agent. I could locate no clinical trials that have studied the injection or established that it is effective for this purpose. The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database makes not comment on the effectiveness of glutathione (injection or oral) for skin lightening at all, reinforcing the overall lack evidence supporting its use.
Safety
Dugoua makes the following safety statement about glutathione injections:
Glutathione injections are not only safe, they are beneficial for your health. Glutathione helps eliminate toxins from the body, supports the central nervous system, aids in fertility and supports a healthy and strong immune system.
Are there negative long-term effects? There are no known side effects or interactions with IV administration of glutathione.
What are the side effects? I have not observed any side effects with respect to the Skin Brightening IV.
I looked to the medical literature for safety studies and statements. There is very little published safety information on injectable glutathione. The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database says the tablets and injection are “possibly safe.” As noted above, there are some clinical trials of IV glutathione published for other purposes, and no serious safety signals have been identified. The most authoritative safety statement seems to be from the Phillipines Food and Drug Administration [PDF], which notes:
The alarming increase in the unapproved use of glutathione administered intravenously as a skin-whitening agent at very high doses is unsafe and may result in serious consequences to the health of users. There is inadequate safety documentation on the use of high doses of glutathione administered at 600 mg to 1.2 grams once weekly and even up to twice weekly. The only approved indication of the intravenous format of glutathione is as an adjunctive treatment to reduce neurotoxicity associated with cisplatin chemotherapy. Adverse drug reactions resulting from the use of glutathione IV for skin whitening have been reported and include the following:1. Reports of adverse drug reactions ranging from skin rashes to the serious and potentially fatal Steven Johnsons Syndrome and Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis.2. Derangements in the thyroid function3. Suspected kidney dysfunction potential resulting in kidney failure.4. Severe abdominal pain in a patient receiving twice-weekly glutathione administered intravenously had been reported.5. Incorrect technique in intravenous administration especially in association with administration by untrained persons can result in the following:
    • Introduction of harmful microorganisms that can result in serious infections including potential fatal sepsis.
    • Injection of air can lead to embolus which is also potentially fatal.
    • Unsafe use of needles (recycling, sharing) can result in the transmission of hepatitis B and even HIV.
    • Counterfeiting of glutathione has been reported and may lead to use of non-sterile preparations which could lead to serious infections.
Is the Canadian product that’s offered for sale safe? I was unable to find any glutathione products for injection that have been approved for sale by Health Canada (Canada’s version of the FDA). It’s possible the product is being compounded from imported ingredients. Compounded products can be safe when prepared properly, but when problems occur then can be disastrous. Dugoua’s advertisement notes that “ingredients are regulated by Health Canada” and that the “treatment is performed in compliance with licensure in Ontario.” Other providers make few if any statements about where they are obtaining the product and the conditions under which it is being prepared. Buyer beware.
Conclusion
There is very little evidence that establishes either the safety or efficacy of glutathione injections for skin lightening. Based on the limited information that exists, glutathione’s effects on skin tone are plausible, but haven’t been well established. The same can be said for safety: There’s a lack of good safety information when used for this purpose and some international reports of serious harms. Given this product appears to be prepared by naturopaths directly, ensuring the final product is sterile and of high quality is essential, but may be difficult for consumers to confirm. Given the unclear benefits, risks of harm, and the overall lack of medical need, I’m going to recommend consumers think carefully before undertaking skin lightening with glutathione injections.

Holotropic Breathwork
Holotropic breathwork is essentially voluntary hyperventilation, and old technique gaining in popularity as a way of generating “spiritual” experiences.
Steven Novella on October 23, 2019
Link

Many if not all cultures managed to find plant-based hallucinogens in their local environment. This is not surprising, as such plants are not uncommon and generations of testing plants looking for food would have uncovered these obvious effects. Almost uniformly these plants were incorporated into the spiritual traditions of the culture – the psychedelic experiences were interpreted as external (involving the relationship between the individual and the universe) rather than purely internal (affecting the biochemistry of the brain). This is understandable given the pre-scientific knowledge of cultures when making such discoveries.
The spiritual interpretation of psychedelic drugs, however, continues to this day. However, in the mid-20th century psychologists experimented with what they called hallucinogens to determine if they had a therapeutic potential. This experience was generally a negative one, leading to international banning of the recreational use of hallucinogens or psychedelics.
However, the spiritual use continues, and in fact, in an attempt to distance this use from the psychological or recreational use, a new term has been proposes – “entheogen“.
Entheogen is a neologism used to designate psychoactive substances employed in culturally sanctioned visionary experiences in ritual or religious contexts.
The word derives from the Greek which means “to generate god within”. This is a clear expression of the belief that hallucinogens generate a spiritual, rather than physical, experience. However, neuroscientists have a pretty good idea what is going on in the brain with these substances:
Serotonergic hallucinogens and psychotomimetic anesthetics produce overlapping psychotic syndromes associated with a marked activation of the prefrontal cortex (hyperfrontality) and other overlapping changes in temporoparietal, striatal, and thalamic regions, suggesting that both classes of drugs act upon a common final pathway.
There is much more to the neuroanatomical correlates, but this is a basic overview. These drugs cause sensory overload, mood alteration, a breakdown of our reality-testing circuitry, and a dissociation caused by a breakdown in the circuits that make us feel that we occupy our body and are separate from the universe (in some combination).
This is all part of a larger category of phenomena known as altered states of awareness. Our brains actively generate conscious wakefulness, and this is a very energetic state involving many components. Anything that compromises this process can cause altered states of awareness. This occurs normally through dreaming, but can also occur with sleep deprivation, intoxication, highly emotional states, psychological trauma, or altered physiology.
Spiritual practices that attempt to self-generate an altered state of awareness in an attempt to create a “spiritual” experience have explored many methods, beyond simply using drugs. This was a long prelude leading to the main topic of this post – one such method known as holotropic breathwork.
Holotropic breathing was developed and promoted by a new age psychologist, Stanislav Grof, in 1975. It is described as:
HB is a psychotherapeutic procedure involving hyperventilation, a voluntary, prolonged, mindful, and deep overbreathing procedure supported by music and elective bodywork. The HB session is largely nonverbal and without interventions. It concludes with mandala drawing and sharing. A typical HB session lasts for about 1–3 hours, and the client terminates the session voluntarily.
So basically, it’s voluntary hyperventilation. This is simply another way to alter brain chemistry. There is a common misconception that the breathing alters oxygenation of the blood, but this is mostly not true. If you take a deep breath and hold it, you can extract oxygen from the air held in your lungs for minutes without any difficulty. You don’t have to be breathing for this to happen (until the oxygen content of the breath of air gets too low).
Breathing is mainly about regulating CO2 (carbon dioxide). We breathe to blow off CO2, and for this reason CO2 is the main driver of respiration. Our respiratory drive is a feedback loop that maintains our blood CO2 levels within a very narrow range. When you voluntarily hold your breath, the CO2 levels rise, and you gasp for breath at the end due entirely to high CO2 levels (long before oxygen is a problem). When you voluntarily hyperventilate you blow down your CO2.
CO2 is acidic, and so regulating CO2 levels in the blood is also about regulating the pH of the blood. When you hyperventilate you force CO2 down, alkalinizing the blood (called a respiratory alkalosis). This affects the functioning of the nervous system, causing tingling in the mouth and fingers, light-headedness, and dizziness.
So essentially holotropic breathing is a simple method for creating physiological symptoms in conjunction with meditation to enhance the sense of a spiritual experience. This is again interpreted spiritually by believers:
The process itself uses very simple means: it combines accelerated breathing with evocative music in a special set and setting. With the eyes closed and lying on a mat, each person uses their own breath and the music in the room to enter a non-ordinary state of consciousness. This state activates the natural inner healing process of the individual’s psyche, bringing the seeker a particular set of internal experiences. With the inner healing intelligence guiding the process, the quality and content brought forth is unique to each person and for that particular time and place. While recurring themes are common, no two sessions are ever alike.
I was surprised to find actual published studies involving holotropic breathwork. The first is a small open-label case series just seeing what people feel like when they do it. They found increased measures of self-awareness and temperament, but also a transient increase in paranoia.
The second paper, interestingly, is an exploration to see if this spiritual practice can be appropriated as a psychological intervention in the treatment of anxiety and depression (following in the footsteps of psychedelic research beginning in the 1960s).
The third paper seemed the most legitimate to me. First, it dealt with voluntary hyperventilation – stripping that specific element from the broader context of holotropic breathwork. This is a good way to control for variables, and to properly define exactly what an intervention is. The paper mostly proposed a hypothesis – can we use voluntary hyperventilation to induce symptoms common in panic attacks as part of anxiety therapy? This could be a form of exposure therapy – induce panic attacks in patients in a controlled environment and then teach them how to deal with it cognitively without catastrophizing the symptoms. This intervention to holotropic breathwork is what phlebotomy for polycythemia is to bloodletting.
Holotropic breathwork has become the latest fad, and is being promoted as a spiritual and psychological intervention. However, it is nothing new or unique, and is just another way of tweaking brain function in order to produce unusual experiences that can then be interpreted in line with preexisting narratives.

Alternative Arthritis Treatments
Steven Novella on January 9, 2013
Link
A recent report commissioned by Arthritis Research UK reviewed 25 so-called “alternative” therapies for arthritis. They found, not surprisingly that there is little evidence to support most the studied treatments.
“There’s either no evidence that they’re effective or there’s some evidence that they are not effective.
Says lead author, Dr Gareth Jones. It is important to note that we are not just talking about that these treatments are poorly studies, but also that to the extent they are studied the evidence is mixed or shows lack of efficacy.
I want to discuss, however, the exceptions – the treatment the report found were effective. They include acupuncture, tai chi, yoga, and massage. Tai chi and yoga are basically forms of exercise and stretching, so it is not surprising that they are helpful in treating musculoskeletal disorders. It is deceptive, in my opinion, to even consider them “alternative” and lump them into the same artificial category as copper bracelets and magnet therapy. Exercise is not alternative – it is a very basic form of science-based activity for health, conditioning, and for musculoskeletal symptoms. The same is essentially true for massage, which is known to relax muscles (at least temporarily). Relaxation therapy should also not be considered “alternative” and existed long before this category was invented.
The only item on the list of treatment modalities that the report concluded showed some efficacy that is reasonably defined as “alternative” was acupuncture. This claim caught my attention because other reviews of the literature indicate that acupuncture is not effective for arthritis (or anything else). The report itself is not published in a peer-reviewed journal (at least not yet), but the lead author, Gareth Jones, has published prior systematic reviews.
For example, a 2012 review of acupuncture for low back pain found:
Three studies found a significant difference in pain scores when comparing acupuncture, or sham acupuncture, with conventional therapy or no care. Two studies demonstrated a significant difference between acupuncture treatment and no treatment or routine care at 8 weeks and 3 months. Three studies demonstrated no significant difference between acupuncture and minimal/sham acupuncture with no difference in pain relief or function over 6 to 12 months.
This is a consistent pattern for acupuncture research in general. When compared to no treatment or usual care (which is necessarily an unblinded comparison) there is a difference in outcome. This is sufficiently explained as placebo effects, which can be entirely bias and expectation. There is probably also some non-specific benefit from the kind attention of the practitioner. When acupuncture is compared to sham or placebo acupuncture, however, there is no difference. Since acupuncture is the insertion of needles into alleged acupuncture points, and the research shows it does not matter where or even if you insert needles, the only reasonable conclusion is that acupuncture does not work. There are placebo effects from the ritual surrounding acupuncture – but no effect from acupuncture itself.
What about acupuncture for rheumatoid arthritis? A recent review of systematic reviews concluded:
In conclusion, penetrating or non-penetrating sham-controlled RCTs failed to show specific effects of acupuncture for pain control in patients with RA.
Same outcome – no specific effects from acupuncture.
A 2010 systematic review of acupuncture for osteoarthritis showed:
Sham-controlled trials show statistically significant benefits; however, these benefits are small, do not meet our pre-defined thresholds for clinical relevance, and are probably due at least partially to placebo effects from incomplete blinding. Waiting list-controlled trials of acupuncture for peripheral joint osteoarthritis suggest statistically significant and clinically relevant benefits, much of which may be due to expectation or placebo effects.
Different wording, but same meaning – there is no compelling evidence that acupuncture has effects beyond placebo. I would add again that comparing acupuncture to “wait list control” (which means no treatment, and of course this means unblinded) is worthless and misleading.
The report also considered fibromyalgia – so here is a recent review of acupuncture for fibromyalgia:
A small analgesic effect of acupuncture was present, which, however, was not clearly distinguishable from bias. Thus, acupuncture cannot be recommended for the management of FMS.
To summarize, published reviews of acupuncture for back pain, rheumatoid arthritis, osteoarthritis, and fibromyalgia all show that acupuncture is no better than placebo. Reviewers vary slightly as to wording , but they all add up to the same thing. There are small effects when comparing acupuncture to essentially no treatment, but specific effects of acupuncture cannot be separated from placebo effects. In other words – acupuncture does not work.
It is surprising, then, that the UK report concluded that acupuncture is useful for arthritis. I can only presume that they consider superiority over no treatment as justification for acupuncture – which is usually the case. This is profoundly unscientific, however. This same standard would never be applied to conventional treatments, not shrouded in the distortion field of “alternative” medicine. When a treatment only seems to work when it is looked at in an unblinded fashion, and proper blinding causes any effect to evaporate – that treatment does not work.

SCAMlandia. CAM in Oregon.
Mark Crislip on January 11, 2013
Link
I quite like Portlandia. I find it funny and it captures a part of Portland. I recognize large swaths of the city’s culture in the show. Other representations of the city I recognize less. Sunset publishes beautiful photographs of the NW, but when I look at the photos I think, that section of the city never looks that good. It is quite wonderful how Photoshop can improve on reality.
Like most major cities, Portland has a monthly magazine, Portland Monthly. The city represented in that magazine is mostly alien to me. I look at the advertisement, the articles, the photographs, and wonder when did Portland become a city with an average 7 figure income? The Portland in which I grew up and currently live is rarely found in the pages of Portland Monthly. If you are extremely well to do, I suppose you are in the demographic Portland Monthly. But when I flip through the pages of the magazine, I see little I recognize, but I have never completely abandoned the hippie/grunge aesthetic of my younger days.
Every January they have the best Doctors issue* and this year, for the first time, they offer The Portland Alternative Medicine Guide. Well, less a guide and more an extended infomercial filled with ‘facts’ that deserve the quotes.
It is a difficult balance for a writer. I would like to be fresh with every entry, display new insights, find undiscovered territories in the terra incognita of SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine) and put up signs that say hic sunt dracones, and above all have new ‘jokes’ preferably at the expense of, oh, yeah, never mind. Do not want to inadvertently offend any readers, oh no, uh huh. This entry will fail those goals big time, since the Portland Monthly guide, from an SBM perspective, is one big pile of SOS DD. We have been there, we have done that, we are going there again and doing it again.
The Preface
They start by noting Portland has three SCAM schools (with apologies to Brian Brushwood):
The city is home to three nationally revered institutions: the National College of Natural Medicine (NCNM), the Oregon College of Oriental Medicine, and the University of Western States (which graduates chiropractors, massage therapists, physical therapists, and nutritionists).
Right off the language lets you know the focus of the article.Revered. By whom? Supplement manufacturers? Pas moi.
All three institutions offer a curriculum that is not based on reality but upon a fictional understanding of the human body in health and disease. The underlying silliness of naturopathic education has been discussed at length on the blog, but I will reiterate that (as always, in my opinion) homeopathy, chi, hydrotherapy, acupuncture and chiropractic are a phantasm. I find the fact the Oregon is home to three such institutions an embarrassment.
At the turn of the century Flexner took medical education off of its ‘anything goes including magic’ approach and grounded medical education in the sciences and reality. As the Bravewell report clearly demonstrated, our major medical centers are embracing non-reality based medicine at a depressing rate, including OHSU:
Our leading medical research center, Oregon Health & Science University, has also fully embraced the trend, routinely collaborating with all three schools on studies that have proven everything from fish oil’s ability to quell depression in people with MS to the positive effects of yoga for seniors.
Or are they? They are, but not with the studies mentioned above, which is the classic SCAM bait and switch where variations of standard medicine (diet and exercise) are defined as ‘alternative’ and used as a gateway supplement to transition into a justification of the fantastical alternative modalities. It gets to the definition of ‘alternative’. Diet and excise are not ‘alternative’ in the same way acupuncture or homeopathy are ‘alternative.’ The former is based on reality, the latter on fantasy.
There is an association between omega-3 fatty acids and depression in MS patients, but not a very strong association and, as we all know, association is not causation. There is also a variable literature on the association an treating depression with omega-3 fatty acids, some references favorable, some not.
There may be physiologic validity to the concept and OHSU did indeed have a study: Fish Oil for the Treatment of Depression in Patients With Multiple Sclerosis that has been completed. 4 years ago. As best I can determine it has not yet been published in any journal. All I can find is the abstract:
Lynne Shinto, MD (Oregon Health & Science University) and colleagues administered 6 grams/day of omega-3 fatty acids (fish oil) or inactive placebo (soybean oil) to 31 people with MS who had mild to moderate depression for three months. Both groups improved on the depression scale; there were no significant differences. However, the omega group did improve significantly more than the placebo group on a measure of cognition (PASAT). Further study is necessary to confirm this finding.
That’s proof? Seriously? An abstract where the data shows no differences for depression? Ah, but that is one of the continual differences between SBM and SCAM: SBM has a commitment to truth, evidently not a high journalistic priority as well. Having taken fish oils in the past, I would be most curious how effective the placebo at mimicking the fish oil was I was always belching up the taste of old tuna.
Yoga is a form of physical activity that should have benefits, although the article I found from OHSU was not that impressive:
Healthy seniors participating in a 6-month yoga or exercise class showed no differences in cognitive function compared to a wait-list control group. The yoga intervention produced improvements in quality-of-life measures not seen in the exercise group and also improvements in physical measures related to the intervention itself (eg, timed 1-legged standing and forward-bending flexibility).
It is a really weird paper. They say
There was no effect of assignment group on any of the cognitive function or alertness measures, which included the primary outcome measures for this study.
and show the data. Then they say
The SF-36 quality-of-life measure demonstrated a significant yoga assignment group effect on vitality/energy and fatigue (P = .006), role-physical (P = .001), bodily pain (P = .006), social functioning (P = .015), and the physical composite scale (P = .005). There were no effects on mood as assessed with POMS or CESD-10. On the MFI, reduced activity was better in the yoga group (P = .015), but there was no difference in the other subscales.
Fine. But they do not publish the data that lead to the p values to know if the statistical significance actually represents clinical significance. We have to take their word for it, so I can’t really say they have ‘proven’ anything about yoga in the elderly. But again, the only thing alternative about either diet or exercise is the advertising.
Note I am only in the first paragraph and with a wee bit of digging, more than the author evidently did, I find errors. My confidence in the veracity of Portland Alternative Medicine Guide is fading fast.
“It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts.” The worlds first consulting detective would be aghast.
The third paragraph states
With 40 percent of American adults using some form of natural medicine—and a naturopath or acupuncturist seemingly on every Rose City block—we thought it was high time to provide a local primer.
That old trope. Sigh. The percentage always relies on defining various forms of diet and exercise and relaxation techniques as ‘alternative.’ According to NCCAM, the big three are ‘natural products” (supplements), deep breathing and meditation. Use of alternative therapies is primarily for self limited problems or pain and very few use alternative therapies for serious or life threatening problems. But outside of chiropractic at 8.6% most Americans are apparently not using the non-reality based therapies that make up much of our ‘revered’ schools curriculum.
Chinese Medicine
They start with Chinese Medicine and show an ungloved hand approaching needles inserted along someones spine. Work has been progressively slow over the last decade as my health system has been very aggressive at instituting policies and procedures to eliminate hospital acquired infections, with great success. It is nice that acupuncturists continue to use sloppy technique so that I might have an MRSA infection or two to take care of.
They note that Americas interest in acupuncture started in 1972:
…a press-corps reporter named James Reston suddenly felt a stabbing pain: appendicitis. His surgery at Beijing’s Anti-Imperialist Hospital went smoothly, but for the severe abdominal pains that followed, which the Chinese treated with acupuncture. Reston praised the ancient technique in the New York Times, and American doctors took notice.
What did Mr Reston actually write about his experience?
I was in considerable discomfort if not pain during the second night after the operation, and Li Chang-yuan, doctor of acupuncture at the hospital, with my approval, inserted three long, thin needles into the outer part of my right elbow and below my knees and manipulated them in order to stimulate them and relieve the pressure and distention of the stomach.
That sent ripples of pain racing through my limbs and, at least, had the effect of diverting my attention from the distress in my stomach. Meanwhile, Dr. Li lit two pieces of an herb called ai, which looked like the burning stumps of a broken cheap cigar, and held them close to my abdomen while occasionally twirling the needles into action.
All this took about 20 minutes, during which I remember thinking that it was rather a complicated way to get rid of gas on the stomach, but there was a noticeable relaxation of the pressure distension within an hour and no recurrence of the problem thereafter.
The Portland Monthly gets it wrong again. “Considerable discomfort if not pain” is not quite the same as “severe abdominal pains”. Post operative gas is unpleasant and a self limited problem. Treat a problem that gets better on its own, then credit the intervention.
They note that “Traditional Chinese Medicine” (TCM) includes the
…use (of) acupuncture, herbs, dietary therapy, moxibustion (burning herbs near certain points on the body), cupping (using heat and a glass cup to create a suction on the skin), and other practices to restore the qi (or “life force”) of the body.
They do not mention that all of the above have no basis in reality and none have benefit for any objective findings and barely have any effect for the subjective endpoint of pain and that the entire subjective effect of acupuncture can be accounted entirely by bias on the part of the patient and the practitioner. Someone mentioned that my ‘humor’ is somewhat repetitive. Can an article on acupuncture avoid needle puns? Nope.
TO THE POINTPuncturing skepticism about acupuncture
Naysayers have long criticized acupuncture studies for being inconclusive. But last October, an overview published in Archives of Internal Medicine concluded that acupuncture outperformed over-the-counter pain relievers and other standard meds for people suffering osteoarthritis, migraines, and chronic back, neck, and shoulder pain”.
Again with the language. Naysayer is not a positive term. Define naysayer: someone who carefully reads the medical literature with an understanding of the various biases and methodological errors that can severely compromise the results of a clinical trial. Yeah. I’m a naysayer. The well done studies are not inconclusive, they demonstrated that acupuncture does nothing. The trajectory of acupuncture clinical trials, like all the clinical trials for treatments not based in reality, is increasingly well done studies demonstrate decreasing effect until excellent studies (those that remove all potential bias) reveal no effect.
The most critical factor in clinical trials is blinding: if the patient or the practitioner knows they are receiving acupuncture or placebo, then acupuncture works. If the trial is blinded, it doesn’t. To quote Dr. Novella 
The Vickers acupuncture meta-analysis (referred to by Portland Monthly), despite the authors’ claims, does not reveal anything new about the acupuncture literature, and does not provide support for use of acupuncture as a legitimate medical intervention. The data show that there is a large difference in outcome when an unblinded comparison is made between treatment and no treatment – an unsurprising result that is of no clinical relevance and says nothing about acupuncture itself.
The comparison between true acupuncture and sham acupuncture shows only a small difference, which is likely not clinically significant or perceptible. More importantly, this small difference is well within the degree of bias and noise that are inherent to clinical trials. Researcher bias, publication bias, outlying effects, and researcher degrees of freedom are more than enough to explain such a small difference. In other words – this data is insufficient to reject the null hypothesis, even if we don’t consider the high implausibility of acupuncture.
Further, meta-analysis itself is an imperfect tool that often does not predict the results of large, rigorous, definitive clinical trials. The best acupuncture trials, those that are well-blinded and include placebo acupuncture, show no specific effects.
A classic example of the problem with a meta-analysis: when you collect separate cow pies into a big pile, you do not get gold.
They note that
Ear acupuncture (also called auricular therapy) has long been used to help wean people off of addictive drugs, including nicotine.
It may be used, but that does not mean it is effective. Clinical trials assessing ear acupuncture show no efficacy for smoking, cocaine , or alcohol and I can find no good clinical trials for heroin addiction. The NADA (National Acupuncture Detoxification Association) has not been demonstrated to be effective either. As is always the case, the better the study is controlled potential bias, the less the effect. What probably matters is the of relationship with the patient and not the particular SCAM, even since a staple in the ear has subjective effects.
Staplepuncture, which is the manipulation by hand of a surgical staple implanted in the concha of the ear, was reported to relieve withdrawal symptoms at least partially in approximately 40 percent of subjects.
And why they give short shrift to hand, tongue, foot, Japanese and the German MAP (MikroAkuPunktSysteme) acupucnture I do not know. Maybe, like trying to decide on the valid form of astrology (Indian, European, Mayan), the real answer is they are all bunkum.
Infomercial follows for a local acupuncturists and an ear acupuncturist.
Naturopathy.
NATUROPATHY is based on a simple premise: your body has the ability to heal itself …Today, naturopathic medicine encompasses a wide array of modern and traditional therapies including nutrition, herbal medicines, homeopathy, hydrotherapy, massage, and even Chinese medicine.
It is a simple premise until you realize that humans have used the bodies ability to heal since the beginning of time and the result has been endless early death and needless suffering. Large section of the world still rely on the ability of the body to heal itself. Show of hands: who wants to get their health care in Uganda? I thought so. I have posed the question before: have there been any SCAM therapies that have led to any improvement of the human condition? Or any quality initiatives to improve outcomes and increase patient safety? Or have ever changed as a result of clinical investigation? No, no, and no.
However, naturopaths are trained in ineffective therapies and, as discussed in a prior posts, usually have no post graduate experience. Most are poorly trained medical students set loose upon the world to fiddle about with no supervision. It makes the next section, how to choose an alt doc all the more depressing.
I do feel sympathy for others when trying to choose a doctor. There is no way the average person knows what the skill sets of the doctor are and there is the issue as to whether you will get along with your doc. Not all personalities mesh. They suggest a variety of essentially useless approaches for determining an alt doc. As opposed to a Western doctor, as reality based physicians referred to in the text. Since homeopathy and hydrotherapy are invented in the west, are naturopaths Western docs? I still prefer the term reality based doctor, and would suggest that a simple question be asked. Do you use homeopathy? If the answer is yes then the practitioner is divorced from a science based practice of medicine and should be avoided.
Then follows an infomercial for an herbalist shop and a naturopath who (surprise) sells her own line of supplements. Many alternative providers are their own Big Pharma. No potential conflict of interest there, is there? Part of the infomercial is a moving story of a women with high grade cervical dysplasia who was cured by a natural concoction of herbs:
After less than three months of taking daily supplements (folic acid, selenium, vitamin C, green tea extract, and DIM, a concentrated nutrient that’s found in broccoli and other cruciferous vegetables) and a suppository treatment that included vitamin A and green tea, her dysplasia had disappeared completely. “My gynecologist’s jaw dropped,” Allen says. “She couldn’t believe it.”
Sounds like an impressive triumph of the natural approach, right? Well, not so much, although one has to wonder about her gynecologist since
In women who are immuno-competent, many low-grade, or CIN1 lesions, will nonetheless eventually regress without intervention (1, 2). Reported rates of regression range up to 58% over 24 months (3). A very small percentage (~2%) will progress to high-grade lesions.
In contrast, most high-grade, or CIN2/3 lesions are thought to be much more likely to persist than to regress. However, reported rates of spontaneous regression vary from 6% to 50%, depending on diagnostic criteria, and length of follow-up (4). The risk for progression to invasive cancer at 24 months in women with high-grade lesions is ~1% to 2%.
So the natural triumph over cancer is much more likely watching a spontaneous resolution and taking the credit. That is cunning medical practice. When patients get better, always take the credit. When they do not, blame someone else.
Touch Therapy
Human touch is important. Monkeys who are groomed relax as a result of being touched and everyone likes a good massage. Monkeys, at least, do not need to add a layer of nonsense to the mix:
But beyond traditional massage to relieve pain, heal sports injuries, and quell stress and depression, there are other touch treatments, like craniosacral therapy for musculoskeletal imbalances and Reiki, a light-touch energy healing for the body’s so-called biofield.
What follows is a paean to craniosaccral therapy, sciency sounding but all sound and fury signifying nothing. Unlike Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity, it is not meant as a hoax:
The cranial system, Jackson explains, is just like your respiratory system and circulatory system: it has a certain rate and cycle. “All the fluids expand and contract according to this rhythm,” he says, referring to the fluid that surrounds, protects, and nourishes the brain and spinal cord. Jackson’s job is to find the disruptions in this rhythm—the places where disease and discomfort usually lie—and “palpate” them (i.e., examine them by pressing with the palms and the fingers).
We have covered both reiki and craniosacral therapy in prior posts. Both modalities are nonsense. The ‘so-called biofield’ should be the ‘non-existent biofield’. If we can detect the Voyager spacecraft, over 7 billion miles from earth broadcasting with the power of a refrigerator light bulb**, I think we could pick up a biofield, don’t you?
And did you know that the twists in yoga are good for detoxing? No wonder Chubby Checker looks so fit.
Chiropractic
CHIROPRACTORS, who like naturopaths are licensed as primary care doctors in Oregon, receive extensive training in nutrition. Students at the College of Chiropractic at University of Western States take 90 hours of nutrition instruction—far more than MDs.
Perhaps they have more training in nutrition. They also receive extensive training in adjusting nonexistent subluxations that have nothing to do with health and disease. And they have no practical training in cardiology, pulmonology, dermatology, gastroenterology, neurology, gynecology, obstetrics, infectious disease, pediatrics etc etc. What doctors learn during residency, after graduating from medical school. That they are licensed to be primary care doctors is a triumph of the political process to the detriment of patients everywhere.
HOLISTIC DENTISTRY
They interview a dentist who thinks mercury fillings are a toxin, despite all the data to demonstrate otherwise. He makes the statement about fillings that
They go in your mouth at 50 percent mercury, and when you take them out it’s 20 percent mercury.
I cant find this anywhere as true or not; perhaps my google-fu is weak. Our readers will certainly set me straight.
The same dentist thinks fluoride is toxic:
The studies that exist aren’t well designed. Most dentists say, “That’s what the ADA says and you gotta use it.” Personally, my take is that fluoride is quite toxic.
Again all the data suggests otherwise.
He then notes the best approach to good dental hygiene is “eat whole foods, eat only three meals a day, and drink only water between meals.” Which is not bad advice. Diet certainly has effects on dentition, but then he wanders into the naturalistic fallacy:
For millions of years, our ancestors did not get tooth decay—and they did not floss and they did not brush.
Besides the fact that people tended to die young utilizing natural medicine (life expectancy 25 to 40 years), making it harder to develop caries, they did get tooth decay, although much less which is interesting .
The percentage of the occurrence of dental caries based on the individuals was 77.8%, whereas the frequency of dental caries on tooth type and class was 17.1% (18.0% maxillary decay; 16.2% mandibular decay). A comparative study of the frequency of caries in certain periods indicates the following: in the hunting–gathering period it was 1%–2%, in the Early Neolithic it was 3%–5% (Catal Hoyuk), in the Neolithic (beginning of agriculture) it was 5.6% (Cayonu), in the Chalcolithic it was 11.7% (Norsuntepe), in the Roman period it was 11.1% (Panaztepe), and 16% (Datca), in the Late Byzantine it was 10.9% (Iznik) and in the Medieval it is 14.2% (Arslantepe). These findings contribute to understanding how dietary change and life conditions are interrelated with the changing patterns of dental diseases in Anatolian populations.
NATURAL MEDICINE AND HEALTH CARE REFORM
The issue has been discussed by both Jann Bellamy and myself.
The statement “Naturopaths are known for their focus on preventive medicine.” Like most statements of fact in the primer, are, upon evaluation, not true when you look for supporting information.
As discussed a few entries back, those under the care of a naturopath get less screening, fewer vaccine and more vaccine preventable illnesses. Naturopaths most often prevent the imaginary diseases they diagnosis. Perhaps it is a typo and they meant: Naturopaths are known for their focus on preventing medicine.
Oregon needs to use every available provider in order to meet the needs of the giant influx of people the Affordable Care Act will bring to the system.
Alternative providers lack the training and experience to prevent and manage real diseases. The basis of their education is neither science or reality. I will quote me:
Health care in the US is a mess. I have no clue what the solution is. I hope for a single payer system. I came to the conclusion long ago that sometimes there are sometimes no good solutions to some problems, just the least bad solution. Right now health care is a mess in innumerable ways; a single payer system will make it a mess in one way.
If you have a problem in astronomy, you do not call an astrologer. Sure, he knows the names of the planets and the stars and has a good patter about how his system works. But astrology is nonsense. If you have a shortage of pilots, you don’t hire a transcendental mediation practitioner to levitate the plane. At least not a plane I would get on. And if you have a shortage of primary care providers, perhaps including those with inadequate training in real medicine, extensive knowledge of fanciful fields who treat cancer with alkaline water and misdiagnose asthma as a blood stream bacterial infection, might not be the best choice to improve the health of the population.
I grew up when Woodward and Bernstein were the height of what defined a good journalist: the information was accurate and exact. It has been a long time since All the Presidents Men. As was mentioned at the time:
I’m sick and tired of hearing thingsFrom uptight, short-sighted, narrow-minded hypocritesAll I want is the truthJust gimme some truth
I’ve had enough of reading thingsBy neurotic, psychotic, pig-headed politiciansAll I want is the truthJust gimme some truth
No short-haired, yellow-bellied, son of Tricky DickyIs gonna mother hubbard soft soap me…
All I want is the truth nowJust gimme some truth nowAll I want is the truthJust gimme some truthAll I want is the truthJust gimme some truth
John was unlikely to get what he wants from the Portland Monthly.
Notes
*No, I am not listed this year, thank you for asking, although I have been several times in the past. I guess you can’t really fool all the people all the time. I guess I will not make the list next year.
** not an original observation, I cannot find where I first read it. An English source I do believe,

Halotherapy – The Latest Spa Pseudoscience
Halotherapy, sitting in a salt room, is the latest spa trend, just as full of pseudoscience and false claims as we have come to expect from wellness spas.
Steven Novella on June 13, 2018
Link

The term “spa” likely originated in the 1620s from the name of an Eastern Belgium town known for its hot mineral springs. The practice, however, likely goes back to at least the Romans. It makes sense that in a time before modern medicine, before even the basics of biology were worked out, people would seek cures to common ailments and injuries. Soaking in warm water can certainly feel good, and ease sore muscles, so that’s an obvious place to start.
In the absence of more sophisticated knowledge, people relied mostly on simplistic notions, such as purity and balance, to address their problems. People with tuberculosis or other respiratory problems were often sent to the mountains, to breathe in the pure air in hopes it would heal them.
Of course every human need and tendency is exploited by someone for profit. Spas quickly became an industry, one with a great deal of persistence. Wellness spas are thriving today, even in our era of modern medicine, often with the same old claims of balance and purity. Spas are a triumph of marketing, selling an eclectic mix of holistic nonsense to the worried well with disposable income.
I have to say the marketing is brilliant – spas have positioned themselves as a pleasant experience with vague health benefits and a symbol of beauty and status. I even know some very skeptical and scientific people who go in for the first and third features, while ignoring or downplaying the whole medical pseudoscience thing as just a necessary annoyance. (Perhaps there is a niche for a pseudoscience-free spa, but probably not or else it would already exist.)
Halotherapy
Spa owners are always on the lookout for the latest fad, trend, or exotic pseudoscience they can incorporate into their offerings. It’s good to stay ahead of the competition by being the first to jump on a new health fad. Spa claims also mesh seamlessly with the world of alternative medicine, which is also largely based on vague health claims deriving from notions of balance and natural purity. The term “holistic” is thrown around a lot, to the point that it is devoid of all meaning. It is just a feel-good marketing term.
One recent to the list of spa pseudoscience is halotherapy. This basically consists of sitting in a room lined with rock salt – a salt cave. Sitting in a natural salt cave, popular in Poland, is called speleotherapy (yes, that’s the same root as spelunking). But if there are no natural salt caves around, no worries, you can make an artificial one.
What will sitting in a room lined with salt do for your health? At this point, any regular reader of SBM can probably make up the list themselves. Organic spa magazine tells us:
The calming and detoxifying effects of halotherapy can support the immune, nervous and lymphatic systems. Additional benefits are reduced stress and headaches, increased energy, and better sleep patterns. Salt ions purify the air and may increase lung capacity and reduce physical ailments for adults, children and athletes. Treatments are recommended to help keep the body healthy during flu or allergy seasons.
Like all such fake treatments, it’s good for what ails you. The list of claimed benefits is long enough to essentially include everyone, in order to maximize the potential target customer base. Some spas are careful not to make any actual health claims, using the pseudoscience buzzwords of “detox” and “supports X function.”
Some, however, will make specific claims. Since halotherapy “works” because of the negative ions and trace minerals users are allegedly breathing in, marketing is often targeted at respiratory problems. One company, The Salt Cavern, is even more ambitious. They claim halotherapy is good for:
• chronic bronchitis • asthma • hay fever • ear infection • breathlessness, chest tightness • pneumonia after acute stage • bronchiectatic disease • smoker’s cough (including secondary smoke) • cough with viscous sputum discharging with difficulties • dry, paroxysmal cough with distant rates • dry rales (mostly with low tone) changing its localization during auscultation • frequent acute disorders of respiratory tract • pharyngitis • multi-chemical sensitivity syndrome • sinusitis/sinus inflammation • respiratory infections • respiratory allergies to industrial and household pollutants • rhinitis • tonsillitis • eczema and more.
There is, as you might suspect, a complete lack of any credible scientific evidence for any of these claims. That is not how the spa (and alternative medicine) world works. They just make up nice-sounding explanations that seem wholesome, and then make unsubstantiated claims. They will back this up, of course, with anecdotes.
Some spa entrepreneurs will hunt for any scientific study they can use to support their therapy, and then such claims get spread around. In the case of halotherapy promoters will often cite a 2006 NEJM study that found that inhaling hypertonic saline mist may help improve symptoms in patients with cystic fibrosis. They extrapolate from this one study to support the claim that sitting in a salt cave is good for all respiratory symptoms.
First, sitting in a salt cave, even if they add some salt to the air, is not the same as breathing in a hypertonic mist. Further, in the study patients were pretreated with a bronchodilator. And of course cystic fibrosis is a very specific illness, and any results do not necessarily apply to other respiratory disorders.
But all these sciencey details don’t matter, if your only interest in creating the impression of being science-based for marketing purposes.
In the end halotherapy has no prior plausibility for the health claims made for it, and there is no evidence to support those claims. One feature that does set it apart from many spa fads, however, is that building a salt room does take a bit of investment. It’s not like spa reflexology, which uses existing infrastructure. That investment likely means that halotherapy will be around for a while, likely with an ever expanding list of claims, as spa owners try to capitalize on their investment.

Do You Need Daily Treatment to Repair Damaged Enamel?
Does a toothpaste provide “next level” fluoride technology that you need to use every day? You know the answer.
Harriet Hall on November 30, 2021
Link
The commercial keeps airing on TV with annoying frequency. She’s a dentist, she wears a white coat, and viewers are expected to assume she is offering good advice. I find her voice irritating, but that would be beside the point if her information were accurate. It isn’t. She is providing inaccurate information invented by marketers to sell a supposed remedy.
Consumers may find her advice credible. They have come to expect successive improvements in preventive dental care. Instead of just cleaning teeth any old way, they were told to use a toothpaste with fluoride. Then they were told they must floss regularly. They were advised to make more frequent trips to the dentist (every 6 months instead of yearly or when problems arise). In that context, they might not be surprised to hear that they need daily treatment to repair damaged enamel. But they don’t.
What she says: We have to be able to repair our tooth enamel on a daily basis. With Sensodyne Pro-Namel Repair Toothpaste more vital minerals enter deep into the enamel surface (compared to a non-optimized fluoride toothpaste), giving you an opportunity to repair acid-weakened enamel. Use twice daily. It’s amazing. It will always be her go-to toothpaste.
What the BBB says: Two years ago, the BBB National Programs National Advertising Division recommended discontinuation of the commercial because it makes these false claims:
Express claims:
    • ProNamel toothpaste provides “next level” or “innovative” sodium fluoride technology, beyond the typical remineralization effect marketed for decades.
    • ProNamel toothpaste heals cracks “deep within the tooth [or enamel] surface”.
    • ProNamel toothpaste “repair[s] what has already been damaged”, including the cracks in teeth shown in the advertisement.
Implied claim:
    • The product demonstration falsely communicates that ProNamel toothpaste fills and heals cracked enamel.
The manufacturer, GlaxoSmithKline, said it would comply with the NAD’s recommendations, but the deceptive ads continue.
The reality
Once lost, tooth enamel will never grow back or be replaced (although admittedly there are experimental treatments under development that may someday be recommended for that purpose). The BBB complaint explained:
Exposure to acids from foods or drinks can weaken and destroy tooth enamel. Once enamel is lost it will never grow back or be replaced. Fluoride is a naturally occurring mineral that can be found in most toothpastes. While fluoride helps to repair and strengthen weak spots on existing enamel, it cannot repair or strengthen tooth enamel that no longer exists, including enamel that has been cracked, chipped or otherwise permanently destroyed.
The dramatization in the video conveyed a misleading message.
Established ways to maintain healthy enamel
    • Good oral hygiene, including brushing, flossing, and mouthwash
    • Avoid sugary foods and drinks
    • Fluoride (in water and/or in toothpaste)
    • Stop teeth grinding (bruxism)
    • Treat acid reflux
    • See your dentist regularly
Conclusion: Don’t believe everything you see on TV
        ◦ No, you don’t need a special toothpaste to repair damaged tooth enamel on a daily basis. Remember: TV commercials are designed to sell products, not to impart good science-based information.

InstaHard: Hard to Believe, Easy to Laugh At
InstaHard is advertised in a stupid video as a cure for erectile dysfunction and other sexual problems. The claims are unbelievable, but they are good entertainment; they made me laugh.
Harriet Hall on June 8, 2021
Link

Oh, no, not again! Yet another video promoting an untested mixture of dietary supplements.
I’m not looking for these stupid videos, but they keep finding me. I’m feeling persecuted. This one appeared in my email inbox with the subject line “InstaHard”. It wasn’t difficult to guess this was a male enhancement product intended to treat erectile dysfunction (ED). I wondered why they targeted me. Harriet is the name of a woman, not the name of someone likely to suffer from ED.
I have reviewed several of these stupid videos and can easily recognize the deceptive marketing pattern for a bogus product, but they are too funny to ignore. Here are some of the many things that amused me about this one:
Questionable statements
They call the speaker “a famous sexologist”. He calls himself Bill Grant and says he is a marriage counsellor. Is Bill Grant a real person? In the absence of any identifying data, I must assume he is fictitious, and that “Bill Grant” is most likely a pen name invented for marketing purposes and to conceal the identity of the speaker, a ploy that was revealed in a similar video for tinnitus. He is not seen on the video; only his voice is featured, with rapid, pressured speech that doesn’t seem natural. Why should we believe anything the speaker says? I don’t.
InstaHard is allegedly only available from one source, but it is sold on Amazon.com (with free shipping!) and there are 144 customer reviews on their website. 38% said it doesn’t work. Some of the reviews made me laugh: “no affects”, “waist of money”.
“New research from Ivy League University proves its effectiveness”. There is no such university, and no research has been done on the product.
“It has helped more than 12,600 men restore their sex lives and regain their manhood”. Why should I believe that? Is there any documentation other than testimonials? Who did the counting?
“I don’t think this video will be up for much longer”. Big Pharma fears it will reduce sales of their prescription ED drugs; “they could get this controversial video removed at any moment”. I don’t think so.
The penis brain
The speaker explains that your penis has a mind of its own. Some call it the penis brain. The key to keeping it working is a “secret” that has been known for centuries by people who were able to satisfy multiple women even in old age, people like French royalty, Rasputin, and Francisco Pizarro, who allegedly stole the secret from the Inca king.
The speaker claims to have done extensive research to identify male enhancement herbs used by primitive tribes and to have identified 21 rare ingredients that boost dopamine or that have been reported to improve sexual function. These include Maca root powder, Tribulus terrestris extract, horny goat weed extract, zinc oxide, and 17 other natural ingredients. He believes dopamine is the key: a lack of dopamine is responsible for ED, premature ejaculation, and all other sexual problems. Dopamine acts as a signal to link the brain in the penis to the brain in the skull. He was able to locate published studies about natural remedies that increase dopamine levels. He assumes that taking all 21 ingredients together will be optimally effective but that’s an untested hypothesis. InstaHard does more than just restore hardness: it makes the penis permanently thicker and longer. And it has many other benefits for prostate, blood sugar, etc.
Drugs like Viagra rely on the idea that improving blood flow to the penis will restore potency. He says it’s not blood flow, it’s dopamine. And yet he claims that InstaHard also improves blood flow.
He rejects Viagra and similar pharmaceuticals because they cause heart attacks, heart failure, blindness, and hearing loss. He claims his 21 natural ingredients have no side effects; but we know that anything that has effects can also have side effects, and side effects for these ingredients are easily found on the Internet. For instance, horny goat weed has been reported to cause dizziness, vomiting, dry mouth, thirst, nosebleeds, spasms, severe breathing problems, irregular heartbeats, slowed blood clotting, low blood pressure, and fainting.
He says he knew the product was working when he awakened from sleep to find his wife performing oral sex on his erect penis. He says he now consistently makes his wife bleed, but she doesn’t complain. (I think she should complain!) A testimonial from a customer says sex now hurts the wife so much that they have to use lubricant. A testimonial from a Mormon says all three of his wives are happy (isn’t polygamy illegal?). This kind of report does not strike me as good advertising for the product.
He is often politically incorrect, racist, sexist, or simply wrong. He describes something as “Harder than Chinese calculus.” And he calls an orangutan (a great ape) a “monkey”. He assumes satisfying sex can only occur with an erect penis. He should talk to some lesbians. They typically have even more satisfying sex with other women than with male partners. No penis required.
Once the product InstaHard was available, he proceeded to give it to his clients, who all loved it. That’s highly unethical. Wouldn’t that constitute practicing medicine without a license?
For that matter, doesn’t this advertising violate DSHEA rules by claiming a dietary supplement is a cure?
The most hilarious thing
He found that it was hard to get ingredients imported and to find a reliable source of pure ingredients. After obtaining the best quality ingredients he could find, he searched for a reliable manufacturer in the US who could formulate a combination product.
Now comes the funniest thing in the whole video, an unbelievable story that made me laugh out loud. The manufacturer looked at a sample of one of the herbs under a microscope and called his colleagues to look too. They all agreed that it was the purest thing they had ever seen. Wow! I don’t believe that actually happened, but I wish it were true. Wouldn’t laboratories love it if they could get rid of all their expensive high-tech equipment and assess purity by simply looking through a microscope?
Buy now!
He warns that due to recent world events, the supply chain for his source materials is failing. For the moment he can offer InstaHard at a great discount – $49 a bottle, while it’s selling on eBay for $500. (That’s a lie. I just checked eBay, where InstaHard is selling for as little as $14.) He predicts his price will soon go up to $149. And it takes up to 3 months to create a batch, so it may not always be available. And the video may be removed by Big Pharma. So you should buy now. He even offers a money back guarantee (which doesn’t include reimbursement of shipping costs).
Conclusion: Deceptive marketing with unbelievable claims and no actual evidence
The mixture of herbs in InstaHard has never been tested. Does it actually increase dopamine levels? By how much? Does that translate to curing ED and other sexual difficulties? We have no way of knowing, but until there is scientific evidence from controlled studies, I’m skeptical. I think suggestion and placebo responses are responsible for the enthusiastic testimonials…that is, if the testimonials are real comments from real people rather than just marketing fiction. I don’t think the product is effective, but the video was effective in making me laugh. Silly videos can be very entertaining if you have a sense of humor.

Prolotherapy
Steven Novella on June 11, 2014
Link 
Prolotherapy is a treatment technique used for chronic myofascial pain, back pain, osteoarthritis, or sports injury. It involves repeated injections of dextrose solution or other irritating substances into the joint, tendon, or painful tissue in order to provoke a regenerative tissue response. Similar techniques have been used for about a century, but the first formal publication describing prolotherapy dates back to 1956, by Dr. George Hackett. He wrote:
Within the attachment of weakened ligaments and tendons to bone, the sensory nerves become overstimulated by abnormal tension to become not only the origin of specific local pain, but also definite areas of referred pain throughout the body to as far as the head, fingers and toes from specific relaxed ligaments and tendons.
Prolotherapy. A treatment to permanently strengthen the “weld” of disabled ligaments and tendons to bone by stimulating the production of new bone and fibrous tissue cells has been developed.
Initially the concept, referred to a sclerotherapy, was that the injections formed scar tissue to stabilize the joint, tendon, or ligament. The newer concept, called prolotherapy, is that the injections provoke the proliferation of tissue, allowing for limited regeneration.
The exact response to the injections is not currently known, and so explanations of mechanism remain speculative. The notion that injecting an irritant would cause a positive proliferation of tissue resulting in improved function seems implausible. This is not enough to condemn the treatment — something is physically happening and it is possible that a useful local phenomenon is occurring. It’s possible, for example, that even without tissue regeneration, there can be a decrease in local pain or inflammation.
Therefore speculative explanations as to how prolotherapy might work are insufficient to recommend the treatment, but neither does low plausibility rule out an effect. In this case clinical evidence is critical.
It has been almost 60 years since Hackett’s first edition describing prolotherapy. In that time prolotherapy has remained on the fringe, without sufficient high-quality clinical research to clearly establish its effectiveness. This is always a red flag for me. Why is the clinical research lacking over such a long period of time? Either researchers have been unable to obtain positive results with rigorous trials, or those using prolotherapy are insufficiently interested in testing whether or not the treatment actually works.
The clinical research is divided into various indications, the substances that are injected, and the specific techniques used. A thorough review of every possible application is beyond the scope of this article, so let me focus on a few of the more common uses.
Chronic low back pain
Back pain is probably not the most favorable clinical application, because it is frequently complex with multiple facets, defying any single treatment. However, if prolotherapy were providing any effect in reducing pain or improving stability it should be detectable with careful clinical trials.
A 2007 systematic review of the literature concluded:
There is conflicting evidence regarding the efficacy of prolotherapy injections for patients with chronic low-back pain. When used alone, prolotherapy is not an effective treatment for chronic low-back pain. When combined with spinal manipulation, exercise, and other co-interventions, prolotherapy may improve chronic low-back pain and disability. Conclusions are confounded by clinical heterogeneity amongst studies and by the presence of co-interventions.
In other words, when prolotherapy can be isolated as a variable, it provided no specific benefit to back pain. When combined with other treatments known to be effective, there was a benefit. Such results are most consistent with there being no specific benefit from prolotherapy in back pain. A 2009 follow-up review concluded that there was still insufficient evidence to conclude the therapy works for back pain. There do not appear to be any rigorous studies of prolotherapy in back pain since that review.
Knee osteoarthritis
The literature for knee osteoarthritis (KOA) is a bit better than for back pain. Unfortunately, the only reviews I can find date back to 2004 or earlier. This review by Kim et al. found that the studies to date were small and of limited quality, not allowing for any firm conclusion.
A 2013 study of 90 subjects found improvement with dextrose prolotherapy over saline injections or at-home exercise. These results are positive, but still preliminary. A 2012 study of 36 subjects showed similar results. Another 2013 study, while also showing symptomatic benefit, measured cartilage volume (CV) by MRI scan and found no difference between the prolotherapy and saline groups — both continued to lose CV at the same rate over the course of the study. Other studies I found were small, prospective, or unblinded.
My summary of this research is that — preliminary clinic research comparing dextrose prolotherapy to saline injections or exercise shows a consistent symptomatic benefit, but no change in objective outcomes, like cartilage volume. This research, however, should be considered preliminary. Larger rigorous trials are needed to definitively address the issue of efficacy.
Other musculoskeletal indications
A 2005 systematic review of prolotherapy for soft tissue and musculoskeletal injuries concluded:
There are limited high-quality data supporting the use of prolotherapy in the treatment of musculoskeletal pain or sport-related soft tissue injuries. Positive results compared with controls have been reported in nonrandomized and randomized controlled trials. Further investigation with high-quality randomized controlled trials with noninjection control arms in studies specific to sport-related and musculoskeletal conditions is necessary to determine the efficacy of prolotherapy.
By now this language should be familiar — it is the description of preliminary clinical research.
Conclusion
Prolotherapy is a treatment that has been around for a long time, but still lacks definitive clinical evidence for efficacy. The plausibility of an effect is dubious, but not impossible. It does not appear to work for back pain. The best evidence exists for knee osteoarthritis, but even here the evidence is still preliminary. At best we can say that these results warrant further research.
It should be noted that the current level of evidence is completely compatible with the null hypothesis — that there is no specific effect from prolotherapy. Researcher bias, p-hacking, publication bias, mixing variables, and placebo effects can all conspire together to create the impression of a positive effect where none exists. Most of the time, encouraging preliminary research such as exists for prolotherapy is not supported by later rigorous clinical research.
Further, it seems that the practice and promotion of prolotherapy greatly exceeds what is justified by this preliminary research. I would recommend caution to anyone considering this therapy, and certainly I would not believe the hype. Proponents should conduct the type of double-blind placebo-controlled trials that can definitely determine whether or not prolotherapy has any specific effect.

Dry Scooping – A Harmful Internet Fad
Dry scooping is just one more dangerous health craze being promoted online.
Steven Novella on October 13, 2021
Link

Don’t get your health advice from TikTok. That is the somewhat obvious conclusion of a recent study looking at a new social media fad called “dry scooping”. The phenomenon is also not an isolated case, but typical of several troubling trends – the overall poor regulation of supplements, a relatively low level of scientific literacy among the public, exploitation by clueless “wellness gurus”, and the rise of social media as a significant source of factual information.
The study looked at TikTok for videos with the hashtag “#preworkout” and analyzed the results. The author was interested in videos about taking creatine powder prior to workouts. For background, creatine is an amino acid found mostly in muscle tissue and the brain. It has become popular as a supplement for athletes and body-builders, because it can enhance the production of ATP (the energy carrying molecule in cells) and therefore increasing exercise endurance and muscle building. There actually is a reasonable body of evidence that regular supplementation with creatine can provide these benefits (although modest in magnitude), and is largely safe when used correctly.
That last bit (when used properly) is the focus of the recent study. The author found 100 videos on TikTok about using creatine supplements as a pre-workout regimen, with a cumulative number of likes over 259 million. Only 8% of the videos depicted creatine supplements being used correctly (according to the manufacturers’ recommendations). The study did not address the fact that even when used as directed, the products themselves may not follow the evidence.
The idea of using creatine supplements as a pre-workout itself is dubious. The idea is to load up on creatine right before an intense workout or athletic event. Studies with creatine, however, show benefit from regular daily low dose supplementation, allowing time for creatine levels to build up in the muscles. Taking a large dose right before a workout is likely of no specific benefit. There may also be no benefit for moderate exercise, as the benefits are likely largely dependent on pushing exercise performance to one’s limits (by extending those limits slightly).
Therefore, the very idea of a preworkout creatine supplement is scientifically dubious. Therefore, users may not see a benefit from this specific practice, although they may perceive a placebo effect. Creatine powders, however, contain more than creatine. They also contain vitamins, which are likely worthless in most cases, if overall diet is adequate. But most importantly, they typically contain a very large dose of caffeine, from 100-400mg per scoop (the equivalent of 1-3 cups of coffee). Those taking more than the recommended dose, or larger athletes dosing by body mass may get the equivalent caffeine of 5 or more cups of coffee in their supplement. That is a large enough dose that there can be safety issues in terms of blood pressure and heart health, especially in the context of pushing oneself to the limits of physical performance.
The questionable benefits and safety of using creatine supplement formulations as a large pre workout dose (rather than a small daily dose) are exacerbated by the fact that many people are additionally using it not in accordance to product recommendations. The most common incorrect method for taking the supplement was “dry scooping”, which is a recent social media fad. The powders are meant to be dissolved in water and then taken as a liquid. This further aids in hydration and kidney function. Dry scooping is the practice of just eating the powder straight, perhaps with a few sips of water to help get it down. This can be very dangerous. Further, powders meant to be dissolved in water are often finely ground, which means they are an inhalation risk.
The videos also depicted individuals taking multiple doses or diluting the powder in either energy drinks, coffee, or alcohol. Taking creatine powder, with its high dose of caffeine, with an energy drink, which also contains a high dose of caffeine, significantly increases the risks.
The popularity of using creatine supplement incorrectly and unsafely is partly due to the high levels of scientific illiteracy in the public, specifically regarding health science. The public has been largely influenced by marketing campaigns to make them responsive to the supplement industry and snake oil in general. Products are sold as “natural” without any specific meaning, and used as a health halo to imply safety and efficacy often in the absence of scientific evidence or even a plausible rationale.
Another popular fallacy is that if some is good, more must be better. This is essentially the entire rationale behind most supplementation. The reality is that biological systems mostly follow the principle of complex dynamic homeostasis, where there is an optimal range and balance of nutrients, electrolytes, etc., and simply taking more of something is unlikely to improve the functioning of the system. Taking a small daily dose of creatine may help elite athletes push the limits of their performance, but likely has no benefit for everyday exercise or moderate activity. There is also no reason to think that loading, taking high doses, or dosing just prior to a workout should be of any benefit.
        ◦ The other major factor in this harmful trend is the shifting of information and advice from edited, professional, trusted sources to “some guy on the internet”. This is a deeper problem beyond the scope of this article. But it means that doctors and other professionals need to be paying attention to the broader culture, not just their professional journals, to see what people are hearing and doing, and get involved in the conversation.

Taopatch Offers Everything… Except Science
Taopatch promises all kinds of vague benefits, but the mechanism of action is implausible and what they call scientific proof is no such thing.
Harriet Hall on September 1, 2020
Link
    • It promises to improve your health and wellness. Who wouldn’t want that?
    • Immediate health benefits. Why wait for things that work slowly?
    • Delivery via skin patch: no pills, no surgery, no discomfort, just a convenient stick-on patch.
    • Tao: ancient wisdom from Chinese philosophy.
    • Acupuncture: one of the oldest healing disciplines.
    • Nanotechnology: a groundbreaking advance in cutting edge science.
    • Laser therapy: lasers do all kinds of wonderful things, right?
It combines all those elements into a new product, the Taopatch, a 16-mm patented nanotechnology wellness device “scientifically proven to provide immediate and long-lasting relief, physically, emotionally, and mentally”. Wow! But before enthusiastic customers rush to buy, they might want to ask a few questions, such as:
    • What exactly does it do?
    • How does it work?
    • Is it plausible?
    • Relief of what, exactly? How do they know?
    • What do they mean by “scientifically proven?”
    • What does it cost? Is it worth the money?
    • Why wasn’t this in the headlines? Why am I first hearing about it from a commercial?
The answers to those questions are likely to dim their enthusiasm.
Taopatch is alleged to improve balance, posture, focus, sleep, immunity, athletic performance, emotional wellness, chronic pain, PMS, and symptoms of disabling diseases.
Indiegogo raised over half a million dollars based on claims that Taopatch will “upgrade your brain and body.” Various packages are offered, starting at $199. The patch is said to be effective for 2 years or more. It is applied to acupoints. Its nanocrystals convert body heat into specific frequencies of light, photons which travel to other acupoints, thereby improving communication throughout the nervous system. The standard patch contains two layers of nanocrystals, the premium version contains four layers. Taopatch is promoted to MS patients, and they claim to have studies showing it is effective, but we know MS patients have fluctuating symptoms and are easily convinced that bogus treatments have helped them. They have been called “quack magnets”.
There are plenty of testimonials. A chiropractor tells us that he suffered from years of underlying anxiety until he put the Taopatch on his ankle meridian, an actress clams that in a week her chronic tickle in the throat was gone, an MS patient reports relief of symptoms, another woman says she “immediately felt more grounded, more centered, more organized; more of me is present in every situation.” Another says, “I have more energy.” All these are vague subjective symptoms likely to respond to placebos.
Scientific proof? No way
Samuel Pinches, in Australia, has reviewed the literature offered by Taopatch. He found low quality, small preliminary studies, authors who apparently don’t exist, plagiarism, a poster, insufficient details, and “red flag” use of language like “quantum dots” and “upconverting nanocrystals” without explanation. One study didn’t even mention Taopatch. He points out that low-level laser is low-level, not zero, and compares biophoton therapy to homeopathy because both claim that incredibly weak signals offer immense healing power. He concluded that “Taopatch does not understand scientific rigor”. Perhaps the understatement of the year.
Mechanism of action
Their explanation of how it works is not credible. The words sound like science, but are pure pseudoscientific gibberish. I won’t waste any time trying to explain what is wrong with it.
Conclusion: No science to be seen here, move along
It can be difficult to distinguish between stupidity and malice, but I’m inclined to suspect the people selling Taopatch are deliberately and cynically foisting expensive placebos on naïve customers. What do you think?

Applied Kinesiology by Any Other Name…
Arm wrestling is not a good way to confirm a diagnosis. But it is a great way to elicit confirmation bias.
Harriet Hall on February 7, 2012
Link
Applied kinesiology (AK) was briefly mentioned in Scott Gavura’s article on Food Intolerance Tests last week. Since AK is arguably the second silliest thing in CAM after homeopathy, I thought it wouldn’t hurt to say a little more about it.
A press release on the Wall Street Journal website recently announced that a chiropractor in Illinois was offering “Nutrition Response Testing”:
…to help patients optimize overall health…[the test] determines the specific balance of nutrients necessary to optimize metabolic function at the cellular level… the chiropractor then uses this information to make nutritional recommendations for patients…[the test] provides precise feedback that can also help identify the underlying cause for chronic pain and illness.
My first thought was that he must be using one of the quack electrodermal testing devices that I wrote about here and here.
No, nothing so high tech. The chiropractor’s website explains:
The practitioner will do the analysis by contacting your extended arm with one hand, and contact the specific reflex area with other hand. If the tested reflex is stressed, your nervous system will respond by reducing energy to the extended arm (which will weaken and cause it to drop). A drop in the arm indicates underlying stress or dysfunction in that area which can be affecting your health.
This is nothing but AK disguised with a new name. It is nonsense based on magical thinking, suggestibility, and the ideomotor phenomenon. Steven Novella has explained the role of self-deception in AK. Practitioners are genuinely not aware that they are eliciting positive results by exerting less force on the arms of patients who in turn are not aware that they are not trying as hard to resist.
My first encounter with a believer in AK was when a local chiropractor gave a talk about how he diagnosed and treated allergies. He described having patients hold a sealed vial of allergen in one hand while he tested the strength in their other arm. In one case, he suspected that the patient was allergic to work, and since he didn’t have a vial of “Boeing” to test, he just had the patient think about Boeing and that worked just as well. In his introductory remarks, he had let slip that when he was in school he “had never been very good at science.” That was the only thing in his whole talk that I believed.
One of my favorite stories from the history of skepticism is Ray Hyman’s account of how he and Wally Sampson did a double blind test of AK. A group of chiropractors claimed they could distinguish between glucose (“bad” sugar) and fructose (“good” sugar) by putting a drop of dissolved sugar on a patient’s tongue and testing the muscle strength in their arms. They demonstrated that they could reliably detect which was which… as long as they and the patients both knew which was which. Under double-blind conditions, they failed miserably. The head chiropractor then commented to Ray:
You see, that is why we never do double-blind testing anymore. It never works!
I think that’s a hilarious example of how many CAM advocates think: they know they are right, and therefore there must be something wrong with science if it fails to support them.
And no, we skeptics don’t dismiss AK just because it sounds silly. AK has been tested. A typical study showed that the “use of applied kinesiology to evaluate nutrient status is no more useful than random guessing.” A systematic review of published evidence showed “the few studies evaluating specific AK procedures either refute or cannot support the validity of AK procedures as diagnostic tests.”
We know it doesn’t work. We know why it doesn’t work. We know how practitioners are fooled into thinking it works. Nuff said!
Nevertheless, AK is used by 37.6% of chiropractors in the US, according to the American Chiropractic Association. It is also an integral part of NAET (Nambudripad Allergy Elimination Technique), a quack treatment for allergies and chemical sensitivities that was invented by an acupuncturist and is practiced by an estimated 8,500 licensed medical providers.
A sampling of statements on the “Nutrition Response Testing” chiropractor’s “Advanced Chiropractic Wellness” website is illuminating:
    • We use the extraordinary properties of the human cells and tissues to bring about healing and health changes…exactly as nature intended.
    • The body responds to the procedure reliably and consistently. [Demonstrably not true!]
    • Energy flows exist between all parts and organs of the body. These flows can become disrupted for a variety of reasons. This disruption is easily discovered with our testing.
    • The first thing we must determine is whether or not you are a “Nutrition Response Testing Case”. If someone is NOT a “Nutrition Response Testing Case” then it is unlikely that Nutrition Response testing will ever help you. However, if you ARE a “Nutrition Response Testing Case”, then in our experience, it is our belief that nothing else will help you as much.
    • It is the nervous system’s responsibility to regulate the body’s functions for each and every organ. [What about hormones? What about transplanted organs with no nerve connections?]
    • NRT works upon principals [sic] based in Traditional Chinese Medicine, which state that a person’s energy flows through meridians throughout the body.
    • [Food] intolerances manifest themselves in a myriad of ways throughout the body…. Irritable Bowel Syndrome, back pain, neck pain headaches, migraines, ADHD, depression, allergies, asthma, men’s health issues, women’s health issues, and a very long list of other physical and emotional ailments.
    • We test the patient’s neurological reflexes at the acupuncture points
    • There has been a drastic decline in the quality of food over the past 70 years,
    • 20 years of success correcting spinal misalignments called “subluxations” that pinch nerves. [They explain that regular maintenance adjustments are needed to maintain health.]
They offer an individualized “designed clinical nutrition” program with “real foods” and concentrated whole food supplements that preserve all the active enzymes (it’s hard to see how this could help since enzymes are destroyed by digestion).
“A rose by any other name…” Whether you call this applied kinesiology or nutrition response testing or wallet biopsy, it still stinks.

Applied Kinesiology: Nonsense on Full Automatic
Mark Crislip on February 10, 2012
Link
I start these entries about a week before their due date, and when I saw Dr Hall’s Applied Kinesiology (AK) post from Tuesday, I thought the heck, there goes my post for Friday. After reading Harriet’s post, I think mine will be both complementary and alternative, and perhaps even integrative, to her entry. I do have one quibble with her post. She said
“we skeptics don’t dismiss AK just because it sounds silly.”
AK doesn’t just sound silly, it is silly. I have found over the years writing for SBM that I have developed an increasing bias around the concept of prior probability. As best I can tell there is a well described reality, and that reality constrains what is not only probable, but what is possible. Within the limitations of our current understanding of reality, some processes are impossible, i.e. have zero prior probability. AK’s prior probability is exactly zero. I sometimes think the blog should be called Reality Based Medicine. Science gives us understanding of reality and AK, like many a SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine) discussed in this blog, parted company with reality from the beginning.
This blog has two often overlapping purposes. Blogs offer timely commentary on contemporary issues, and this blog certainly fills that role. More than other blogs, SBM also has the opportunity to be a reference source on various SCAM’s . I have had the recent opportunity to reread the entire oeuvre of SBM, and it is impressive in the breadth and depth of topics covered in its three plus years. It is not yet encyclopedic and there are many topics not yet reviewed in the blog, such as Applied Kinesiology. So many many SCAM’s, so little time.
I tend to read about medicine and it’s alternative goatee wearing evil twin in a nonlinear way. I have 30 plus years reading about medicine and quackery, so day to day I add to my understanding incrementally, adding a brick here and a daub of mortar there to the edifice of my knowledge. Such a Victorian metaphor. Sometimes I need to go back and review a topic from scratch, as if I have no prior knowledge. I have places to start when I need to review a topic from the beginning. For infectious diseases I start with The Principals and Practice of Infectious Diseases, the ‘bible’ of my field. For SCAM’s I start with Google, and the Wikipedia entry usually pops up at the top of the list.
AK is like many other SCAM’s having its origin in the epiphany of one practitioner, in this case a chiropractor, George J. Goodheart, who, as Wikipedia mentions, ‘invented’ the process. Invent. When I hear the word invent, I think of Edison or Macaroni Marconi. Damn auto correct. I do not think of invent when applied to works of fiction, although I suppose Tolkien did invent his characters and world. Still, invent somehow doesn’t fit, and later the Wikipedia says he originated AK in 1964, which is more in keeping with its fictional characteristics. ‘Made up’ would fit the situation best.
Evidently Goodheart was having difficulty diagnosing and treating problems in his patients who were not responding to the chiropractic conceptual framework. What a surprise: processes that were neither understood nor treatable by standard chiropractic. That would appear to account for hmmm, let me see, everything. No wonder he was at an impasse with his patients. Undeterred and guided by the Triangle of Health, the Chiropractic concept of structural balance, and a ring of power, by long trial and error he cobbled together AK. Unfortunately for AK, Goodheart was not guided by anatomy and physiology, reality not being a strong point in his understanding of disease.
AK has the following underlying principals:
1) Specific health problems will cause specific muscles to test weak.2) Testing for muscle weakness can be used to indicate a treatment.3) Treatments that increase muscle strength demonstrate efficacy of the treatment.
I think I have discovered the cause of obesity: the last century has seen a marked increase in the number of pathways by which SCAM modalities function: all the meridians of the various forms of acupuncture, the connections of reflexology, of iridology, and now of AK, and more are crammed into one small volume of flesh and blood. Since a major aspect of SCAM the faux understanding that wishing it so makes it so, they are responsible for the proliferation of formerly imaginary pathways in the human body and they only way for all these pathways to fit is for the people to get larger. The way I lost weight was to quit believing in acupuncture, and when the meridians faded I lost 45 lbs. Pretty nifty.
The basic concept is that an illness in say, the lung, manifests by making a specific muscle or muscle group weak, and by improving the underlying problem the muscles strengthen. I still think craniosacral therapy is goofier, but AK is giving it a run for the money.
An example from the first web page I found searching for asthma and AK
Reflex areas that stimulate either the deltoid or the lungs stimulate both. If an individual has a lung infection or an abnormal function in one or both lungs, he or she will probably exhibit weakness of one or both deltoid muscles. Not only would there be a lung infection, but because of deltoid weakness a problem may develop in the shoulder. Under normal circumstances, once the lung infection clears, or if the body adapts to the infection, the deltoid muscle will return to its normal state. On the other hand, if a chronic, low-grade infection lingers, the patient can be left with a weakened deltoid muscle. The applied kinesiologist evaluating the patient will need to stimulate the nerve and blood supply, as well as lymphatic drainage and acupuncture energy to the lungs in order for them to clear. Once the lung problem is resolved, deltoid muscle function can return to normal.
As I said, AK doesn’t sound silly. It is silly. Multiple videos are available on the interwebs with a quick Google search to get a good idea of the silliness.
While, like all SCAM’s, there is not process to which AK is not applicable, it appears to be most often used diagnose and treat to allergies and food intolerance. The verbs and nouns in the preceding sentence need quotes, as the words diagnose, treat, allergy and food intolerance, have no resemblance to how the words are used in real medicine. As is often the case in SCAM’s, words are used as if they have one meaning when in fact they have another. It is like pointing at a chair and using the word dog. It is the SCAM aphasia. I wonder where the lesion would be on MRI.
The allegedly toxic/allergic substance is held in one hand, often in a vial, and the muscles on the other arm are tested for weakness. If you cannot resist the force Anakin, then you are allergic/intolerant to the substance. The AK practitioner then does some adjustments or acupuncture or beams a laser on you, then retests and, if the intervention was successful, the weakness is gone. Success.
I think of allergies as an interaction of an antigen (in my world it is often an antibiotic) with antibodies, with a subsequent cascade of physiologic events leading variably to rashes, hives, interstitial nephritis and other adverse physiologic consequences. Muscle weakness is not involved. But that is the reductionist in me, trying to understand a process from the level of the antigen/antibody to the effects on the whole human with the allergic reaction.
I live in a word where, although we use short cuts on occasion, language is meant to be precise to describe a situation. Precision of language represents precision of thought. It is important to be precise in medicine. Is it a Staph infection? A Staph aureus infection? A methicillin resistant Staph infection? What is done diagnostically and therapeutically depends on how exactly the problem is described. Reading the kinesiology ‘literature’ indicates that allergy has a far broader, aphasic, use.
…allergies are viewed from a holistic perspective based on Oriental Medical principles and defined in terms of the effect an allergic substance has on the energy flow in the body.
An allergy is a condition of unusual sensitivity of a person to one or more substances which may be harmless to the majority of other individuals. In the allergic person, the allergic substance (known as an allergen) is viewed by the brain as a threat to the body’s well-being. When contact is made with an allergen, it causes blockages in the energy pathways called meridians, disrupting the normal flow of energy through the body’s electrical circuits. This energy blockage causes interference in communication between the brain and body via the nervous system which begins a chain of events that can develop into an allergic response.”
So all diseases are due in part or in their entirety to an allergy.
What do cellulitis, sprue, and cataracts have in common? Vitamin C allergy. And a vitamin T allergy leads to “low immunity”. I am not entirely sure what vitamin T is, evidently it is found in sesame seeds, and I pity the fool who is deficient in vitamin T. So my allergy, and AK allergy are not the same thing. My use of the term allergy is relatively narrow. For the AK practitioner, it may describe everything and anything.
The weird thing, as if the whole process is not weird, is that the tested foods or chemicals are often in vials. How the allergen, or its essence, gets out of the vial into the human, sets up a cascade of effects that lead to muscle weakness is not explained. Glass and plastic are far more porous than I ever suspected.
Oh wait. It is quantum. I just started laughing as the speaker wrote quantum physics in the board as he started the talk. I couldn’t get Dr. Science out of my head. He Knows More Than You Do! The subsequent talk has nothing to do with the quantum physics I learned back in the day for my undergraduate degree. Oh. Sorry. I was wrong. The speaker doesn’t really explain how quantum physics is connected to AK. Bummer.
And why, as an aside, is he wearing scrubs? In the hospital we wear scrubs in part to avoid dragging environmental material into clean areas of the hospital, and in part to avoid getting blood and other body fluids on street clothes. Just what kind of AK is he doing that needs scrubs? Or perhaps it is an Ozian conceit. I see someone is scrubs outside the hospital, I think doofus.
But others are clearer in the explanation. I am using clearer and explanation in the SCAM aphasic manner, just to see what it is like.
This brings us to our theoretical understanding of kinesiology: When you test the viability of a given statement, you are determining whether or not the wave function will collapse.[8] Only something that is true has existence in reality.
Conclusion: AK has no existence in reality. But I knew that without a wave function collapsing.
Put simply, truth collapses the wave function. If you test a particular statement like “Today is Monday” and your arm (i.e. muscles) stays strong, a wave function collapsed, signifying that it is indeed Monday. Conversely, if you test weak (i.e. your arm drops to your side), there is no collapse of the wave function denoting that your statement was untruthful. Although it may seem counterintuitive, when your arm stays strong while testing a statement with kinesiology, a wave function collapses, but if your arms collapses (i.e. goes weak), there is no affect in reality.
That is more a Korsakoff’s syndrome than an aphasia, don’t you think? Neurology is not my strong point.
I see little difference between AK muscle testing and Power Band muscle testing, just variations on a theme. Richard Saunders has nice demonstrations of the amazing quantum physics ability of people to fool themselves and others with muscle testing.
I am old enough to remember when there was not the huge number of clinical trials to help guide clinical decisions. We had a saying when I was a resident: One patient was “in my experience, 2 patients were “in a series of cases” and three were “in case after case.” But still anecdotes, and still worthless.
The International College of Applied Kinesiology has all the collected papers available online, almost all some version of the saying mentioned above. While a wide variety of anecdotal cases are presented, my favorite was ROCK MUSIC AN ENVIRONMENTAL STRESSOR, where they concluded
In this selected group of patients, physical tests of muscle weakness and neurological disorganization appeared after exposure to rock-n-roll music.
It is remarkable the time and energy expended on publishing the fiction of AK, although World of Warcraft has a similar draw I suppose.
Still, there is no tooth fairy science that should go unstudied, no matter how ludicrous. Much to my surprise there are no Cochrane reviews on the topic. If homeopathy, why not AK?
There was a review in 2007, Chiropr Osteopat. 2007 Mar 6;15:4. Cuthbert SC, Goodheart GJ Jr. On the reliability and validity of manual muscle testing: a literature review which concluded that AK was of benefit:
More than 100 studies related to MMT and the applied kinesiology chiropractic technique (AK) that employs MMT in its methodology were reviewed, including studies on the clinical efficacy of MMT in the diagnosis of patients with symptomatology. With regard to analysis there is evidence for good reliability and validity in the use of MMT for patients with neuromusculoskeletal dysfunction. The observational cohort studies demonstrated good external and internal validity, and the 12 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that were reviewed show that MMT findings were not dependent upon examiner bias.
ConclusionThe MMT employed by chiropractors, physical therapists, and neurologists was shown to be a clinically useful tool, but its ultimate scientific validation and application requires testing that employs sophisticated research models in the areas of neurophysiology, biomechanics, RCTs, and statistical analysis.
The best they could conclude was that AK muscle testing was valid, not that it lead to effective interventions, noting
One shortcoming is the lack of RCTs to substantiate (or refute) the clinical utility (efficacy, effectiveness) of chiropractic interventions based on MMT findings.
This lead to a response by other chiropractors, who did a complete evaluation of Cuthbert and Goodheart, pointing out the numerous methodologic problems and concluded
Cuthbert and Goodheart conducted a review with important methodological deficiencies. When manual muscle testing as used in Applied Kinesiology is disentangled from standard orthopedic/neurological muscle testing, the few studies evaluating specific AK procedures either refute or cannot support the validity of AK procedures as diagnostic tests. In particular, the use of MMT for the diagnosis of organic disease or putative pre/subclinical conditions is insupportable.
It is an interesting to read the articles sequentially and it underscores the difficultly in conducting a review of any literature and the issues with meta-analyses.
There are other meta-analysis that conclude
There is insufficient evidence for diagnostic accuracy within kinesiology, the validity of muscle response and the effectiveness of kinesiology for any condition. The standards of reporting were low. We recommend a pragmatic study of the effectiveness of kinesiology as the most appropriate initial step to determine whether kinesiology has any clinical value.
The pragmatic study being a study where you do not worry about potential bias and ignore issues like blinding and placebo controls.
and
Several recent studies have refuted the use of applied kinesiology and provocation-neutralization in diagnosis. The placebo effect must not be overlooked as a potentially important factor in some approaches.
SUMMARY:There have been no studies supporting the use of these techniques, and several have refuted their utility. A beneficial placebo effect may be responsible for the perceived clinical effectiveness in many cases of food intolerance.
Given the prior probability of zero that AK would be useful diagnostically or that therapies based on AK would have efficacy, I would be surprised if there were good clinical trials that demonstrated efficacy. It is all placebo effect, and those who read the blog know my equation: CAM = placebo. Placebo = nothing. Therefore CAM = nothing. In the case of AK, it is less a placebo effect and more of a minor variant of the Stockholm syndrome. It would be an interesting topic to explore: compare and contrast the placebo effect, response to CAM treatments and the Stockholm syndrome. They probably have the same underlying psychological etiology.
I have never been fond of the meta-analysis, since they operate in part on the GIGO principle, Garbage In, Garbage Out. Given the issues with reading the medical literature second hand, I always prefer to read and evaluate the primary literature myself.
First up was going though the references of Cuthbert and Goodheart. It was the Oakland of medical literature: No there there. There are few controlled studies looking at the diagnostic and therapeutic utility on defined populations. There are almost no even mediocre evaluations to asses any aspect of AK, and those that have been published suggest that AK is a little bit less than worthless. I will give the caveat that much of the literature quoted by Cuthbert and Goodheart is not accessible, published in journals too obscure to be available on Pubmed or my medical library. Little was added after searching the PubMeds, finding mostly case reports and pilot studies.
One reasonable study Double-blind study on materials testing with applied kinesiology, found AK was no more reliable than chance for for determining intolerance to dental material. They evaluated “ two dentists qualified in AK”; there are two dentists I would not want mucking about in my mouth.
No surprise that if the AK practitioner and patient are blinded,
“… results suggest that the use of Health Kinesiology as a diagnostic tool is not more useful than random guessing”
and
“applied kinesiology to evaluate nutrient status is no more useful than random guessing.”
I can see why the first hit on my Pubmed search was an AK practitioner complaining about EBM. Reality doesn’t support their practice.
At least I came across Kinetics of hula hooping: an inverse dynamics analysis, so the time spent was not a complete waste, in the case of hula hooping, waist. At least hula hooping is a form applied kinesiology that exists in reality.
Postscript
If you want to hear more of me rant, and really, who doesn’t, try skeptikerpodden where I was recently interviewed. The English, or at least the American, begins 33 minutes into the program. And they used my fat picture on the web site, before I lost all my meridians.
The title is an oblique reference to the AK-47. I recently read The Gun by CJ Chivers, the history the the AK-47. Excellent.

The Influence of Kinesiology Tape Color on Athletic Performance: An Actual Published Study…Seriously
Does the color of kinesiology tape effect athletic performance or neuromuscular function? This serious research, published in a legitimate medical journal, asks this non-satirical question. The answer is pretty much what you would expect. No, it doesn’t.
Clay Jones on November 16, 2018
Link

This post is not satire. Seriously, it isn’t. I can understand why you might think it was, considering my past attempts at such. But you would be wrong.
No, it’s legit. The study I’m about to discuss was published in an actual medical journal by serious researchers. And I don’t think they are going to stop.
Does the color of kinesiology tape matter?
The study in question, published this month in BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation, is an investigation into the influence of kinesiology tape (KT) color on the primary outcome of athletic performance, or at least a lab simulation of it. Secondary outcomes included muscle strength and neuromuscular function. The online-only journal, which does charge authors a fair amount of money for publishing their research, is open-access. This includes the peer review process, meaning that the names of reviewers and the back and forth correspondence is provided for anyone to read. That’s pretty neat in my opinion, but it didn’t prevent this paper existing.
The authors point out in the introduction that the use of kinesiology tape by athletes is increasingly common. You’ve undoubtedly seen people, from the occasional jogger to the elite Olympic competitor, bedecked with colorful strips of this stretchy tape in patterns reminiscent of complex crop circles. There are several proposed mechanisms behind the tape’s perceived benefit:
Kinesiology tape has been proposed to enhance performance by supporting musculature, joints, and fascia without limiting range of motion. Additionally, kinesiology tape is believed to promote healing by facilitating lymphatic drainage, blood circulation, and corticomotor activity.
Though these products are popular, the explanations given by proponents are highly implausible and the evidence to date is resoundingly negative. The specific patterns, which proponents believe provide a unique benefit, are irrelevant. KT appears to be just a more expensive equivalent to the old-fashioned athletic tape traditionally used to help stabilize a joint or to provide compression bandaging to reduce swelling after an acute injury.
When it comes to pain relief or athletic performance, there may be a non-specific benefit that comes from expectation or, as has been skillfully argued by our own Paul Ingraham, the application of a novel sensory input. So kinesiology taping might serve as either a simple distraction from discomfort or a less impressive version of Dumbo’s magic feather, but there is no evidence to support benefit from unique “biomechanical tuning”. This would explain why perceived benefits tend to be transient as novel sensations quickly attenuate when continuously applied to the skin.
Seriously, what does color have to do with athletic performance?
The authors state that the data regarding KT use for pain or recovery after injury is negative. But in an attempt to explain its continued and increasing popularity, they figure that it must be more about performance enhancement. Here, they admit, the data is also mixed, although they leave out the fact that it’s the better studies that tend to have negative results. Perhaps, they argue, there is a color based psychological factor behind the disparity in research findings rather than any methodological divergence.
Now here is where we enter new territory, at least for me. There is apparently a literature on the effect of color on “sporting success”. The authors cite a study claiming to show that athletes wearing red are more likely to triumph over competitors in blue, even when skill level is taken into account. Other studies cited purportedly show increased success related to red uniforms in English soccer and rugby teams. They reveal a possible mechanism:
Indeed, the colour red has been proposed to enhance strength output and neuromuscular function in simple motor tasks via a threat-based response, thought beneficial during short bursts of activity.
Could this effect explain why athletes are lining up to use KT? Almost certainly not. There are bigger holes in this hypothesis than in the plot of The Last Jedi.
First off, there is no there there. The authors are looking for an explanation for a benefit that almost certainly doesn’t exist. The reason why some studies on KT show benefit in athletic performance is because they are crappy studies, not because those studies just happened to use red tape. I honestly am having trouble wrapping my head around how silly this study is.
Second, is the “red advantage” even real? I wasn’t able to access the cited studies, but the authors of this paper provide a potential weakness themselves. Perhaps players wearing red don’t perform better at all. Maybe they are more likely to win because their opponents play worse because the color red is intimidating. I found this discussion of the few studies on this phenomenon which postulates that there may also be a psychological effect on judges of competitive athletic performances. I don’t buy any of it personally.
The study methodology (because you never just skip to the conclusion)
The study, a randomized crossover controlled trial, involved 32 healthy subjects aged 18 to 40 years. Five experimental conditions were included and allocated randomly:
(1) no kinesiology tape (control), (2) beige-coloured kinesiology tape applied with tension (sham A), (3) beige-coloured kinesiology tape applied with no tension (sham B), (4) red-coloured kinesiology tape applied with tension, and (5) blue-coloured kinesiology tape applied with tension (Team Tape®)
As stated earlier, the primary outcome that the researchers focused on was athletic performance, in this case distance on a single leg hop test. Secondary outcomes involved the measurement of knee extensor torque using isokinetic dynamometry and neuromuscular function of the quadriceps muscle as assessed by transcranial magnetic stimulation. Fancy. They also collected data on color preference to see if that played a role in outcome differences.
There weren’t any outcome differences
Nothing mattered. Tape color didn’t matter. Color preference didn’t matter. “Proper” placement of KT with tension didn’t matter. No effect on performance, strength, or function was found in any experimental round compared to the control round for any of the subjects. It was a solidly negative result that is in line with previous, and much better studies, showing that KT doesn’t have any specific benefit or much of a non-specific benefit either. And the effect of colored versus plain KT doesn’t deserve any ad hoc excuses.
And now for some ad hoc excuses
The following potential “plausible” explanations for why this study did not find an effect of color on the primary and secondary outcomes were provided:
     1.  The subjects were not instructed to look at the color of the tape.
     2.  Maybe they didn’t use enough tape.
     3.  The color of the subject’s shorts and tee-shirts may have interfered.
     4.  Maybe the real effect occurs in the performance of someone looking at the color of the kinesiology tape used by an opponent.
     5.  Perhaps an effect would be found “in more functionally meaningful contexts across a range of sports and at a range of skill levels.”
     6.  Maybe an effect would be found in injured subjects.
     7.  I guess it’s possible that studies incorporating “a broader variety of tape manufacturers, patterns, tensions, and colours” just might find an effect?
No, further research is not required
Once again, this was not satire. This study happened and anyone with a basic understanding of physiology and psychology could have predicted the results. And anyone with a fair grasp of scientific skepticism could have predicted the conclusion made by the almost certainly well-meaning authors.
Doesn’t that ad hoc rescue sound awfully familiar? Similar logic is seen applied to all manner of pseudoscientific treatment modalities. Maybe the dose of the worthless herb was wrong? Or maybe they used the leaf instead of the flower? Maybe the skeptics in the room interfered with the psychic’s powers? We know it works, we just need to keep trying to find out in who!
To be fair, I don’t know if these researchers are true believers. I bet that they aren’t. If you read the paper, it is actually pretty clear that they think KT is bunk in my opinion. I think that they were being kind to a fault, however. Or, if you of a more cynical mind, setting themselves up for more publishable units of research. The bottom line is that this study fits nicely into the growing pile of research revealing that KT is just tape plus theatrics.

Nonsense for Elephants: The Houston Zoo Promotes Kinesiology Tape
The Houston Zoo is promoting a bogus therapy as a treatment for aging elephants.
Clay Jones on March 5, 2021
Link

I’ve written about some ridiculous stuff over the past several years, and this one is up there with the best of them. On Monday, the Houston Zoo posted on their social media accounts about an aging Asian elephant named Methai being treated with kinesiology tape:
You might see our elderly Asian elephant, Methai sporting a new look in the yard! She’s been fitted with kinesio tape by Dr. Marziani, one of our consulting veterinarians who specializes in rehabilitation therapy, chiropractic, and other non-invasive therapeutics in animals. The kinesio tape is an elastic sports tape designed to relieve pain while supporting muscles, tendons, and ligaments. Since Methai is getting up there in age (she’s 51!) she’s starting to show signs of arthritis and stiffness. Our animal care professionals work hard to ensure every animal at the Zoo receives the best care possible!
In 2018, I wrote about a study that attempted to answer the question of whether or not the color of kinesiology tape (KT) influenced athletic performance. It didn’t. And the use of KT on elephants makes even less sense. But before I explain, here is a brief refresher for anyone who isn’t familiar with this product.
Even if you haven’t experienced the colorful and stretchy tape firsthand, it is very likely that you have at least seen KT, or some generic version of it, applied to someone else. It has become extremely popular over the past several years, primarily because of the prominent use of it by elite athletes during recent Olympic competitions. The designs of the applied tape can be quite ornate at times, and I like to compare them to crop circles, only instead of aliens they are a sign of gullibility and a powerful drive to confuse correlation and causation.
KT is often promoted by physical therapists and chiropractors for a variety of reasons, the most plausible being to support injured muscles and joints. Traditional athletic tape has been used for this purpose for a long time, and much longer than KT which was invented by a chiropractor in 1973. But the way that KT is applied is more for show than support.
Proponents claim that the tape is designed to support targeted body structures without limiting a patient’s range of motion, and to promote healing by improving lymphatic drainage, circulation, and “corticomotor activity”. But the evidence in support of this in humans, let alone elephants, is extremely weak. The reality is that KT isn’t doing anything more than gently pulling on the underlying skin.
Proponents of KT will also frequently claim that it improves athletic performance, but any specific effect of this nature is even less plausible than use for injured muscles and joints. There may be a non-specific, albeit short lived, benefit for a patient or athlete primed to expect a positive result. KT also clearly has benefited from the myriad placebo effects that have fooled believers in holographic energy bracelets, magnetic insoles, and many, many more examples of pseudoscience in exercise and sports. And just as with pain, there is no legitimate evidence to support KT for performance.
Our own Paul Ingraham has written, and then updated several times, an in depth discussion of therapeutic taping for his website. His conclusion, which is similar to mine, is that these products are “more about marketing than medicine” and not worth the money. He argues halfheartedly, however, that there could be a tiny sliver of transient potential benefit from having something applied to an injured muscle or joint that serves as a novel sensory input to distract from discomfort:
At best it’s just a bit of minor sensory tinkering with trivial and inconsistent pain relief benefits. That’s fine as far as it goes, but consider not feeding your money to a hype machine — it’s not worth it.
Now about that elephant. If KT has no specific benefit in humans, and at most some minor and brief placebo-driven alteration in the perception of pain or impetus to try a little harder during a workout, what could it possibly do for an elephant? Elephant skin is tougher and much thicker than human skin, 25 to 40 millimeters compared to our paltry 2 millimeters. Their muscles are also considerably stronger and their superficial vasculature held even more firmly in place. So the claim that a strip of stretchy tape is doing anything at all to elephant physiology approaches homeopathy levels of implausibility.
But can an elephant experience the benefit of placebo? Many proponents of alternative therapies for animals have argued that they can’t, thus attempting to prove that their pet belief system is the real deal. But they clearly can, even if they don’t exactly develop an expectation of positive results, because their caretakers, trainers, and veterinarians do. Our own Brennen McKenzie, the fabulous Skeptvet, wrote an entire book about pet placebo and alternative medicine for animals. Grant Ritchey and I interviewed him for the Prism Podcast last year, and I highly recommend checking it out.
Frankly, the Houston zoo should be embarrassed. Despite their claims to the contrary, kinesiology tape does not provide the “best care possible” for their animals. And their promotion of it, and the veterinarian who applied it, is an unfortunate endorsement for quackery.
Based on the bio provided by her practice website, Dr. Marziani appears to truly love animals and to want what is best for them. I don’t doubt for a second that she believes in the nonsense that she is peddling. But her background sounds like one of the boilerplate origin stories that practice-building firms provide for chiropractors:
During this time, Dr. Marziani tried countless western therapies to try to reduce her neck pain without any success. All the while, she had witnessed several patients of hers improve dramatically through acupuncture therapies. This compelled Dr. Marziani to try acupuncture herself. After waking up for the first time in years without a headache, thanks to acupuncture therapy, Dr. Marziani was a believer! She knew this was a therapy method that she had to learn to help her patients even more.
She went on to attend the Chi institute to learn animal acupuncture and then gravitated towards other forms of pseudoscience. She then took a course at Parker University and became certified in veterinary chiropractic and at some point started using kinesiology tape on elephants. She also once gave a testimonial for using applied kinesiology to help determine what herbal remedy will work best for her patients. Again, with emphasis, the Houston zoo should be embarrassed. Their animals deserve better.

Olympic Pseudoscience – Tokyo Edition
Pseudosciences come and go with the Olympics.
Steven Novella on July 28, 2021
Link

The Olympic Games are a well-established international tradition, and every four years I, like many others, enjoy watching many of the competitions. What is also becoming a (much less well-known) tradition is that every four years we give an update on pseudoscience at the Olympics.
In London in 2012 I noticed the almost ubiquitous multi-colored tape snaking in unusual patterns along the bodies of athletes. This was a product called “kinesiotape” which was alleged to provide support, stability, and strength to the athletes. According to one manufacturer it works by:
…lifting the skin, which optimizes the flow of lymphatic fluids to transport white blood cells and helps remove waste products, cellular debris and bacteria. The tape also helps with overall body awareness to heal and eventually prevent injury.
Others claim it allows for better proprioception so athletes have better body awareness. All of this is unproven and implausible. The evidence for kinesiotaping depends on the specific indication, and is highly variable in quality. A systematic review for the treatment or prevention of ankle sprains, for example, found no evidence of efficacy. Generally studies that are well-controlled find no advantage over regular taping. But because taping itself can be useful, for example to support a joint, studies that are not well-controlled can find some benefit from the basic taping itself, and then used to support the unnecessary and implausible pseudoscientific layer.
This is a general theme as medical pseudoscience has become more savvy at self-marketing – sell a non-specific effect as if it were a specific special effect.
The appearance of kinesiotape decreased significantly at the 2016 Rio Olympics, and even further for the Tokyo Olympics this year, although you still might get a glimpse of it here and there.
Speaking of the 2016 Rio Olympics, the big pseudoscience there, especially visible among swimmers, was cupping. Cupping uses glass cups and burning herbs to create a partial vacuum over the skin, leaving behind characteristic round bruises – basically hickeys. Cupping is claimed to draw out toxins and improve blood flow, because those are the common fake claims often invoked for any dubious treatment.
However, this is just a retconning of what cupping really is, which is a form of bloodletting. This may be called “wet cupping” or simply “bloodletting cupping”. Once the cupping itself draws blood to the skin, the skin is then incised to let the blood out. The “spa” cupping used by athletes and others just skips the part with the incision.
This year, so far, I have seen the telltale cupping marks on Australian swimmer Kyle Chalmers, and a couple of other swimmers. There is probably more (not all athletes have bare skin to show the marks) but there is certainly a dramatic decrease from 2016.
Is there any new Olympic pseudoscience this year? So far, I have been unable to find it. This could be for several reasons. It’s possible that no new fad has taken sufficient hold to be apparent. It’s also possible that whatever it is, it is not externally visible (like tape or hickey marks). Or, it may also be a function of the fact that COVID is hogging all the health news at the Olympics. Any search I do to find evidence of Olympic pseudoscience is filled with COVID results.
Why is pseudoscience so common at the Olympics? When you are competing at that level, even the slightest advantage can make the difference between standing on the medal podium or not, so it’s unsurprising that athletes and their coaches would reach for any possible edge. This can result in a placebo effect, which itself may plausibly produce a slight psychological advantage. Perhaps coaches don’t even care if the intervention actually works. If their athlete believes it does, then they may feel it will give them a psychological edge. We have seen at these Olympics, dramatically at times, the effect that psychology and mental health can have on athletes.
But I do think the meta-observation at the last few Summer Olympics is worth pointing out. This is a sort-of reverse anecdotal evidence. Because competition is fierce, and athletic competition represents, in its own way, a large database of trial and error in the real world, if any intervention did provide a tangible benefit it is reasonable to argue that it would become popular and persistent.
The flip-side to this is that if something does not provide a real benefit, then it will tend to come and go with the winds of faddish nonsense. I think that is what we are seeing. Every Olympics some new fad pseudoscience makes an appearance, but then fades away over time, because they don’t actually work. We see this more generally with pseudoscience – while they usually don’t disappear completely, they come and go over time. They may flash for a while, but then fade away to the fringe, only to come back with a new generation.
The overall pattern of pseudoscience is circular, and I think the analogy of a dog chasing its tail is apt. There is no real progress, only the ebb and flow of fashion, culture, and marketing. Real science, on the other hand, is more linear. It does not follow a straight line, but there is tangible and enduring progress. Pseudoscience is not real, so it makes no real progress. There is nothing to anchor a success or to build on. It is all sand.

Iridology
Iridology claims that it can diagnose diseases through a careful examination of the iris. Unsurprisingly, there is no proof for this, and when tested it fails spectacularly.
Steven Novella on December 21, 2011
Link
There are many medical pseudosciences that persist despite a utter lack of either plausibility or evidence for efficacy. Some practices emerged out of their culture of origin, or out of the prevailing ideas of a pre-scientific age, while others were manufactured out of the imagination of perhaps well-meaning but highly misguided individual practitioners. They were just made up – homeopathy, for example, or subluxation theory.
Iridology belongs to this latter category – a system of diagnosis that was invented entirely by Ignatz Peczely, a Hungarian physician who first published his ideas in 1893. The story goes that Peczely as a boy found an owl with a broken leg. At the time he noticed a prominent black stripe in the iris of one eye of the owl. He nursed the bird back to health and then noticed that the black line was gone, replaced by ragged white lines. From this single observation Peczely developed the notion of iridology.
Peczely’s idea was that the iris maps to the rest of the body in some way, and therefore the flecks of color in the iris reflect the state of health of the various body parts. This basic approach to diagnosis or treatment is called the homunculus approach – the idea that one part of the body maps to the rest of the body, including the organ systems. Reflexology, auricular acupuncture, and even straight chiropractic follow this approach.
This is what might have happened next: After publishing his initial observations, Peczely set out to test his ideas with well-designed observations that were capable of proving his hypothesis wrong. He carefully built a body of descriptive, but well-established, facts about the relationship between the iris and health. Later, anatomists discovered the underlying mechanism of this connection – a vast system of interconnectedness between the iris and the rest of the body. Further research built on the iris connection, and later medical scientists found more and more ways to exploit this fascinating aspect of anatomy and physiology.
Of course, this is not what happened. Peczely did not do any serious scientific research. Rather, he simply invented a pseudoscience, by drawing maps of the iris that were as much a product of his imagination as observation, and were largely the result of confirmation bias. He did not perform blinded studies, or produce the kind of evidence that could separate a real phenomenon from an imaginary one. Iridology, as his practice became known, is the N-rays of medical diagnosis. Further, no subsequent science has supported the plausibility or reality of iridology. There is no underlying anatomy or physiology that can explain how the iris would reflect the state of function of any other part of the body.
This, unfortunately, has not stopped iridology from surviving on the medical fringe for more than a century. The modern popularity of iridology, especially in the US, can be traced back to a chiropractor named Bernard Jensen. He published the book, The Science and Practice of Iridology in 1952. Iridology, or iris diagnosis, continues to be practiced by so-called alternative practitioners, including some chiropractors and naturopaths. It has never been recognized as a legitimate medical practice. For example, for $150 naturopath Frank Navratil will diagnose you from a digital image of your eyes.
Often the iris diagnosis (which can also be done by software analysis) leads to recommendations for supplementation, which are conveniently sold by the iridologist. Here is a description of how iridology is used by a proponent:
The iris reveals changing conditions of every part and organ of the body. Every organ and part of the body is represented in the iris in a well defined area. In addition, through various marks, signs, and discoloration in the iris, nature reveals inherited weaknesses and strengths.
By means of this art/science, an iridologist (one who studies the coloration and fiber structure of the eye) can tell an individual his/her inherited and acquired tendencies towards health and disease, his current condition in general, and the state of every organ in particular.
Iridology cannot detect a specific disease, but, can tell an individual if they have over or under activity in specific areas of the body. For example, an under-active pancreas might indicate a diabetic condition.
Other sites caution that iridology cannot diagnosis pregnancy, because that is a natural condition of the body, and also cannot diagnose prior surgery, as anything that happens under anesthesia will block the signals that would otherwise change the iris. In other words – iridology only tells you about the susceptibility for disease – it cannot actually diagnose a disease or any other verifiable condition. This reasoning is called special pleading – the invention of a special rationalization for each fact that might otherwise falsify a claim or belief. Iridology, apparently, can only discern those things that cannot be verified or falsified.
What you end up with is a medical cold reading – similar to what a mentalist does to create the illusion of mind reading or psychic powers. While “reading” the iris the iridologist can ask about certain health issues. If they are present, that is used to validate iridology. If absent, then the subject simply has a susceptibility for the missing problem.
Iridology lacks any plausibility and its history is that of a pseudoscience, not a legitimate practice. But still we listen to the best scientific evidence in determining whether or not iridology is real. Perhaps Peczely got lucky and made a correct observation despite his lack of scientific confirmation. If iridologists could demonstrate that their readings provide real information, then we would have to take their claims seriously.
In 2000 Edzard Ernst (not surprisingly) published a systematic review of iridology research. He concluded:
In conclusion, few controlled studies with masked evaluation of diagnostic validity have been published. None have found any benefit from iridology. As iridology has the potential for causing personal and economic harm, patients and therapists should be discouraged from using it.
As with N-rays, when blinding is introduced iridology is exposed as a complete fiction. Under controlled conditions iridologists cannot agree with each other as to diagnosis, and cannot distinguish healthy subjects of very ill subjects. Since the Ernst review I found one other well-controlled study of iridology, this one in cancer diagnosis. From the abstract:
SUBJECTS:One hundred ten (110) subjects were enrolled in the study: 68 subjects had histologically proven cancers of the breast, ovary, uterus, prostate, or colorectum, and 42 were control subjects.METHODS:All subjects were examined by an experienced practitioner of iridology, who was unaware of their gender or medical details. He was allowed to suggest up to five diagnoses for each subject and his results were then compared with each subject’s medical diagnosis to determine the accuracy of iridology in detecting malignancy.RESULTS:Iridology identified the correct diagnosis in only 3 cases (sensitivity, 0.04).CONCLUSION:Iridology was of no value in diagnosing the cancers investigated in this study
There are no well designed studies that are positive.
Conclusion: Iridology is bunk
Iridology is an excellent example of pseudoscience in medicine, displaying many of the core features. It was invented by one individual based upon a single observation. It follows a pre-scientific notion of biology – the homunculus model. It lacks any basis in anatomy, physiology, or any other basic science. Its practitioners are mostly “alternative” practitioners who use the technique as a cold reading. And the research clearly shows that iridology has absolutely no effect – it does not provide any useful information at all.
Anyone using or promoting iridology is, therefore, a pseudoscientific practitioner. Any profession that endorses iridology is not science-based and should be looked upon with suspicion.

Lumen’s Information Is Not So Illuminating
Lumen is a handheld device that you can supposedly use to “hack your metabolism”. The science behind it is not convincing. Users are essentially navel-gazing.
Harriet Hall on July 27, 2021
Link

An introductory video on the website for Lumen presents it as the first device for hacking your metabolism. They make a lot of claims that have not been substantiated by good research. With one breath, it tells you what you are currently burning for energy: carbs or fats. By using it in the morning, you can get a personalized nutrition plan for the day. Use it before a meal to see how the last meal affected you. Use it before a workout to see if you have enough energy for a workout or if you should fuel up with a high-carb snack. Using it can help you understand why your weight fluctuates, why you feel low on energy, why your body is storing carbs and converting it to fat. It uses a CO2 sensor and flow meter to determine the CO2 concentration in a single breath. High CO2 means you are burning carbs; low CO2 means you are burning fat.
“Metabolic carts” are sophisticated systems using indirect calorimetry to determine the respiratory exchange rate (RER), the ratio of CO2 produced to O2 consumed. The systems are cumbersome, expensive, and only available in laboratories. Lumen is a $300 handheld device suitable for home use.
According to this website, “Indirect calorimetry measures the consumption of metabolic substrates; it is powerless to predict the requirement for them, which is what one actually wants to know.”
There is an informative critique of Lumen here. Among other things, it tells us:
    • ‘Lumen’s internal studies and a study conducted by San Francisco State University have found that Lumen’s measurements are “comparable” to an RER measurement taken by a traditional device. However, the experts Mashable consulted — two members of U.C. Davis’ Health Sports Medicine program — aren’t entirely convinced of its accuracy, or usefulness. The SFSU study concludes that “Lumen can be seen to be an effective instrument for monitoring relative, individual changes in metabolic responses (within-subject consistency), rather than a substitute for laboratory-grade RER measurements.” In other words, the Lumen scale is a relative score that can track change over time, but is not an analog for a measurement you’d take in a lab.’
    • They quote an expert from the UC Davis Physical Medicine department: “Lumen’s home page says it’s been scientifically proven to meet the gold standard of metabolic measurement,” Van Sickle said. “But when you look on their ‘how it works’ page, it says Lumen exhibits ‘similar trends’ to the gold standard. So, that’s not the same thing.”
    • A person’s RER does not typically change from day to day. It would make more sense to measure it after a month of a diet or fitness routine.
    • The company provides a “flex score” to measure metabolic flexibility. This article in Cell Metabolism provides a good review of the science regarding metabolic flexibility. Lumen’s flex score is a calculation of Lumen’s own creation based on the weeks of data users submit. While metabolic flexibility is a thing, there is no scientific analog for Lumen’s flex score.
    • It suggests that Lumen is best thought of as a tool for motivation.
Conclusion: A tool for motivation
The Lumen device gives users the illusion of control over their metabolism, but the science behind it is not convincing. Customers are just indulging in a kind of navel-gazing. It may be a tool for motivation, but is the motivation worth $300 and the time consumed by the repeated use of the device? That’s a question customers will have to answer for themselves. Will users lose more weight or have more energy? Maybe, but controlled scientific studies would be needed to find out. As far as I could tell, no such outcome studies are planned.

Oxygen Is Good, Even When It’s Not There
Harriet Hall on July 17, 2012
Link
Note: This article originally appeared in Skeptical Inquirer, 28(1), 48-50 & 55, January/February 2004. I’m recycling it now because I have been at The Amazing Meeting in Las Vegas instead of home at my computer writing new posts. It’s still timely: despite multiple debunkings and FTC actions, vitamin O is still for sale. Amazon has it for $4.80 an ounce. I’m no Mark Crislip; but I like to think this article borders on the Crislipian. Enjoy!
Oxygen is not just in the air; it’s on the shelves. It has been discovered by alternative medicine and is being sold in various forms in the health supplement marketplace. Back when I was an intern, we used to joke that there were four basic rules of medicine: (1) Air goes in and out. (2) Blood goes round and round. (3) Oxygen is good. (4) Bleeding always stops.
Alternative medicine has latched on to rule number three and won’t let go. The rationale, apparently, is that oxygen is required to support life; therefore more oxygen should make you more healthy. It’s not clear how this relates to alternative medicine’s advice on anti-oxidants, but that’s irrelevant. OXYGEN IS GOOD, so we should put it in our soft drinks and breathe it at oxygen bars. Take an oxygen tank home with you — you might feel better. The oxygen vendor might feel better, too. Dr Andrew Weil, the renowned health guru, tells patients with chronic fatigue to ask their doctors to prescribe oxygen for a home trial. Sure, why not? The money it costs will literally vanish “into thin air,” but who cares? OXYGEN IS GOOD.
Ignore the fact that you could find out whether you need oxygen by testing your blood oxygen saturation with that little-clip-thingy-they-stick-on-your-finger-in-the-emergency-room (aka pulse oximeter). Who cares if your blood is fully saturated with oxygen already? OXYGEN IS GOOD. If your oxygen saturation is a little less than 100 percent, there is no evidence that raising it will help with anything. If it is a lot less, and you do need oxygen, any competent doctor should be able to figure that out. But try an oxygen tank anyway: OXYGEN IS GOOD. Is this starting to sound like a mantra? It should. This is religious belief I am talking about, not science.
Oxygen therapies
Just breathing oxygen is boring: any dumb animal can do that. Why not drink it? Alternative medicine found ways to use oxygen in a liquid form. No, not liquid oxygen; that’s kind of chilly (around minus 183 degrees Celsius). You could buy a $1,600 home water cooler to infuse oxygen into your drinking water and call that liquid oxygen. Or you could use chemicals that release oxygen. Ozone gives off oxygen. So do hydrogen peroxide and chlorite compounds. They’re corrosive chemicals, but if you mix them with liquid and drink them, they will release friendly little oxygen bubbles in your stomach and maybe the dilution will counteract the corrosive effect. Corrosion may be bad, but OXYGEN IS GOOD.
Proponents of hydrogen peroxide found it worked wonders for everything from multiple sclerosis and cancer to hemorrhoids and the common cold. They tried bathing in it, drinking it, injecting it into their veins, and pumping it up their rectums. The proponents of hydrogen peroxide never reported any adverse effects. On the other hand, the medical literature reported that hydrogen peroxide caused deaths from gas embolism, gangrene, seizures, strokes, and other complications. How could that be? Didn’t those scientists know that OXYGEN IS GOOD?
Could oxygen cure cancer and AIDS? They tried ozone by enema. They tried oxygen under pressure in a hyperbaric chamber. They even put cancer patients into a coma with overdoses of insulin in the hope that it would somehow regulate oxygen delivery to the cancer cells. Scientists insisted there was no proof that these therapies worked, but they couldn’t prove to the true believers that they didn’t work. Scientists insisted that these therapies could be harmful, but how could anything as natural as oxygen possibly be harmful? OXYGEN IS GOOD.
Invention proceeded apace. Alternative “science” found a way to put “electrically activated” oxygen in water. No one knows what “activated oxygen” means, but it sounds impressive. OXYGEN IS GOOD, and if it’s activated it ought to be even better.
Once it bas been “activated” in water, you can take oxygen safely and conveniently in the form of drops. You can put a few drops under your tongue, or drink them in a glass of water, and you will feel better. Of course, the amount of oxygen in a few drops of water is many orders of magnitude less than that contained in every breath. Of course, little or no oxygen is absorbed from the stomach. But fish get their oxygen from water, and if fish can do it, we ought to be able to do it too, gills or not! OXYGEN IS GOOD. They recommend that you drink it, spray it in your nose, gargle with it, spray it on cuts, spray some on your houseplants, and spray it on vegetables, chicken, seafood, and pork to decontaminate them. You can even use it as a natural alternative to antibiotics or give it to your pets to prevent doggy breath. OXYGEN IS GOOD for just about everything.
Selling oxygen — even without oxygen
Several brands of activated oxygen appeared on the market, each better than all the test. Finally, one company came up with the best idea yet. They would sell plain water with a bit of salt and a trace of minerals, charge $10 an ounce for it, and pretend it contained activated oxygen.
The Rose Creek Company marketed oxygenated water without any oxygen in it. They said so themselves. Actually they claimed there was oxygen in it that “couldn’t be detected” in the laboratory. Their excuse was that the precision equipment couldn’t measure over 40 parts per million of oxygen. I guess if they pour a whole pot of coffee into their coffee cup, the cup stays empty; and if they overinflate their tires they create a vacuum. This probably has something to do with homeopathy or an alternate reality. OXYGEN IS GOOD, even if the lab can’t find it.
They called it “Vitamin O”. They claimed it would effectively prevent and treat pulmonary disease, headaches, infections, flu, colds, and even cancer. They claimed it regulates metabolism, aids digestion, relaxes the nervous system, boosts energy, promotes sound sleep, and sharpens concentration and memory. They were selling 50,000 bottles a month until the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) spoiled the fun. A consent agreement required them to pay $375,000 for consumer redress and to stop making false statements. They were prohibited from “making any unsupported representation that the effectiveness of Vitamin O is established by medical or scientific research or studies.”
They changed the name of their company to R-Garden, Inc. and modified their ads, but they weren’t happy. They knew that OXYGEN IS GOOD (it was definitely good for business), and they really wanted some scientific studies so they could thumb their noses at the FTC; so they hired the first scientist they could find who would stop laughing long enough to do some tests. They had to settle for an anthropologist. He reasoned that the oxygen that wasn’t there should raise the blood oxygen level of people with anemia. So he decided to measure the partial pressure of oxygen and carbon dioxide in arterial blood (PaO2, and PaCO2), hypothesizing that both would rise with “Vitamin O,” but not with a placebo. This next bit is going to be a little technical, so you may skip the next two paragraphs if you wish.
If you are anemic, you have less hemoglobin to carry oxygen. But the blood gases, the PaO2 and PaCO2, have nothing to do with hemoglobin or anemia. They are measures of gas pressure, not of total oxygen carried by hemoglobin. So people with anemia should have a normal PaO2. They might be able to raise their PaO2 a little by hyperventilating, but this would lower their PaCO2.
Anemic patients do not have low PaO2 measurements. In this study, all of the anemic patients did have low baseline PaO2. The researcher didn’t notice that this was abnormal. When subjects took “Vitamin O” their PaO2 went up, but mostly not up to normal. A couple of them developed a PaO2 of over 100 mm of mercury, which is not generally thought to be possible on room air without serious hyperventilation. He didn’t notice anything unusual about this. He also discovered that the PaCO2 went up right along with the PaO2. Ordinarily this would indicate hypoventilation, possibly from severe lung disease, but he wasn’t alarmed. He thought it would eliminate more nasty waste matter and would probably cause “greater youthfulness, improved mobility, better circulation, sharper mental clarity, enhanced heart and lung functions, and increased physical energy.” (Huh?) Of course, in several patients the CO2 went down as the PaO2 went up, but this didn’t bother him. Apparently he believes, with Ralph Waldo Emerson, that a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.
He concluded that he had definitely proved that oxygen is present in “Vitamin O.” In other words, if you find unexplained abnormal blood gas values and they change in a way that wouldn’t be caused by increased oxygen intake, that proves that oxygen intake was increased, which proves that the increased oxygen intake had to come from the “Vitamin O.” His logic didn’t work any better than his blood gas analyzers.
His subjects were all Hutterites, members of an Anabaptist sect who live communally in groups of 60-150 on collective farms, mainly in the western USA and Canada, and who remain aloof from outside society. He didn’t explain how he persuaded them not to remain aloof from his experimental interventions. He noted that “no protocol or consent forms” were needed, since the head minister could make all the decisions for his flock and just order them to cooperate”. It seems that Hutterites make even better experimental subjects than prisoners, because you have to get informed consent from prisoners. He didn’t bother with any statistical analysis of his data. He didn’t provide any references. He didn’t expect that anyone would try to replicate his findings. As far as he was concerned, his experiment had proved once and for all that there was oxygen in “Vitamin O.” He broke just about every rule of scientific experimentation. After all, he wasn’t searching for scientific truth, only for enough words on paper to meet the FTC’s requirements.
In another study, the same researcher discovered an unbelievably high incidence of chronic fatigue syndrome among the Hutterites, and found that “Vitamin O” relieved their symptoms better than a placebo. In his report of that study he gave an intriguing definition of his experimental method: “The three key features of this approach in assessing the efficacy of natural man-made substance [sic] were employed here: randomization, blindedness, and measurement of predetermined outcomes.” I don’t know what a “natural man-made substance” is; I agree that some kind of “blindedness” was at work; and if the outcomes were truly “predetermined,” that would explain a lot.
In essence, the company funded studies that pretended to be scientific so they could pretend to have proven that the pretend oxygen in their product is really there (and that it really works). This kind of fuzzy thinking is typical of alternative medicine advocates. They ask you to maintain your health with preventive, natural treatments that have not been proven effective, and to mistrust conventional medical treatments that have been proven effective. They exploit fears of pollution, food additives, pesticides, and side effects from pharmaceuticals. They play the science game to appease their critics, but they don’t really believe in science: they believe that truth can be accessed through intuition. They seldom disprove theories or report negative results; they rarely search for alternative explanations, or suggest that further studies be done for confirmation, or seek peer review. They believe in the mystical ability of the body to heal itself through communication with the vital forces of the universe. How could science understand these complex, holistic phenomena? Scientists aren’t even smart enough to sell water for $10 an ounce.
Science doesn’t know everything. Intuition counts for something, doesn’t it? There are more ways of knowing than scientists can imagine. Anyway, isn’t scientific “truth” wishy-washy? Newton contradicted Copernicus, and Einstein contradicted Newton. Paradigms are shifty. Eventually scientists will have to give up their materialistic theories and will come to understand that the Universe is just one big mind interconnected by a continuum of ineffable cosmic quantum something-or-others.
Proponents of alternative oxygen therapy will never be convinced it doesn’t work. As Lewis Carroll explained in Alice in Wonderland, practice makes perfect:
“One can’t believe impossible things.”“I daresay you havent had much practice,” said the Queen. “When I was your age, I always did it for half-an-hour a day. Why, sometimes I’ve believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast.”
“Vitamin O” is still being sold. Testimonials abound. You can’t argue with true believers. OXYGEN IS GOOD.
Further Reading
Barrett, Stephen. FTC Attacks “Stabilized Oxygen Claims.” Online at www.quackwatch.org/04ConsumerEducation/News/vitamino.html.
FTC Charges. Online at www.frc.gov/os/1999/9903/rosecreekcmp.htm.
FTC Consent Agreement. Online at www.ftc.gov/os/2000/05/index.htm.
Hall, Harriet. 2003. A Failed Attempt to Prove That There Is Oxygen in “Vitamin O”. Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine(7)1, 29-33.
Heinerman, John. Proving the existence of elemental oxygen in a liquid nutritional product (“Vitamin O”) through blood gas analyses of therapy/placebo-supplemented Hutterites. Online at www.rosecreekvitamino.com/original research2002.htm1.
Heinerman, John. Electrically-activated oxygen supplementation selectively improves energy efficiency in Hutterites demonstrating classic symptoms of chronic fatigue syndrome. Online at www.rosecreekvitamino.com/chronic_fatigue.html.
Marks, Stan. Vitamin O? Online at www.rgarden.net/forms/stanmarksinterview.htm.

Oxygen Myths That Refuse to Die
Harriet Hall on November 11, 2014
Link

One of my early forays into the world of pseudoscience was an investigation of “Vitamin O” (the O stands for oxygen). The story is hilarious; please click and read; I guarantee you won’t be able to read it without at least a chuckle. Vitamin O is still for sale; it’s even available on Amazon.com. You can read the manufacturer’s ridiculous rationalizations about the FTC’s and FDA’s regulatory actions against them and their bogus “research” here. In my article, I mentioned oxygen bars, which were popular at the time. I was under the impression that they had gone out of fashion since then. Alas, no.
Dr. Stephen Barrett of Quackwatch e-mailed me to suggest that I might want to write about the O2 Planet website. It calls itself “the largest oxygen bar and oxygen spa source on the planet.” I can’t decide whether to thank Dr. Barrett for steering me to a source of entertainment and making me laugh or curse him for making me suffer through a disgusting collection of pseudoscientific rubbish. Some of the company’s claims are listed on the graphic above.
Their website says,
Oxygen is a miracle, an anti aging miracle! Oxygen therapy can help to jump start the body’s antioxidant defenses and ability to fight free radicals, boost metabolism, and counteract the hypoxia (low oxygen level) that leads to slower cell activity and oxidative stress. Research has shown that oxygen therapy can help to improve the efficiency of hemoglobin in transporting oxygen around the body, improve blood flow by helping to keep cell membranes flexible, and detoxify and fight infection by destroying bacteria, viruses, parasites and fungi that thrive in low-oxygen environments and don’t have the antioxidant resources to fight back. Hyperbaric oxygen can treat carbon monoxide poisoning-by displacing the lethal gas with oxygen, it may also be beneficial to people who have sustained burns, crush injuries and radiation damage as it stimulates the regrowth of damaged tissues. There is some evidence to mean that hyperbaric oxygen may also help to kill cancer cells and reduce toxic symptoms associated with chemotherapy, relieve fatigue and numbness associated with AIDS, increase resistance to opportunistic infections in people with AIDS, reduce post-ischemic stroke damage, and relieve the symptoms of multiple sclerosis. However, none of these benefits of hyperbaric oxygen therapy has been clinically proven.
One wonders why they even mention hyperbaric oxygen, since it has nothing whatsoever to do with their normobaric products.
Some of their other questionable claims:
    • We lose our vision as we get older because of lack of oxygen
    • Oxygen both energizes and relaxes, users experience euphoria
    • Oxygen prevents wrinkles and makes you look younger
    • Oxygen therapy will slow aging, restore sex drive, make you lose weight, restore your energy, and make you happier
    • Oxygen reduces the risk of heart attacks
    • It lessens chronic fatigue syndrome and improves sleep patterns
    • Breathing oxygen before a test improves test scores
    • The skin needs detoxing; it is our third kidney.
    • Our ancestors were pure-air breathing, clean-water drinking individuals who lived in perfect biochemical harmony with their earth; the modern human body is a toxic bucket, contaminated with chemicals (This claim cites “Source: Dr. Mercola.” It’s hard to restrain myself from profanity here, but I’ll take a few deep breaths and simply say I don’t consider Mercola a credible source.)
They sell oxygen bars and kiosks, aromatherapy headsets, oxygen vending machines operated by tokens (perfect for gyms, vap shops, bars), air purifiers, an oxygen water maker, an oxygenated mineral water maker, an oxygen laser wand for facial rejuvenation therapy, infrared spas with O3 (an extra oxygen molecule [sic] to zap pollutants), and multiuser units. There is even a versatile steam spa that can be used for aromatherapy with essential oils, herbal treatment, full spectrum light therapy, and acupoint massage (I’m surprised they didn’t mention homeopathy). And then there is my favorite: an oxygen footbath that uses “negative and positive ions to pull the toxins out through the feet and into the basin.” It removes waste products such as diacetic, lactic, pyruvic, uric, carbonic, acetic, butyric, and hepatic acids. It infuses your body with oxygen. It evacuates heavy metals and blood clotting cellular debris. Only $1,400 for a course of 14 treatments!
Interestingly, their obligatory FDA disclaimer includes the statement that their products are for recreational use only. You can become a distributor and get free marketing material for your customers.
Of course they don’t supply any scientific evidence; there isn’t any. Time for a reality check. Normal oxygen saturation is 97-99%. Adverse effects of low oxygen levels are usually not seen until the saturation drops below 80%. We know that inhaling 100% oxygen is harmful. The flow rate of O2 Planet’s devices is 3 ½ liters per minute; a simple oxygen facemask used in hospitals supplies 5-8 liters per minute with an oxygen concentration of between 28 and 40%. It’s highly unlikely that inhaling oxygen from O2 Planet’s devices would measurably raise the amount of oxygen in the blood, and it’s even less likely that a small increment in oxygen would have any significant effect on health.
So no evidence, and no plausible rationale, but lots of testimonials. Some of those testimonials are quite amusing:
    • “I received the unit and it looks awesome. Thank you.” (Quite an endorsement! It looks pretty; who cares whether it does anything?)
    • “The Aroma O2 is working awesome!! I have a question, though, the oil drops, was I suppose to [sic] put it in the headset itself, or inside the little blue water filter?” (It works great, even though I don’t know how to work it.)
    • “Everything is going great the anti-aging center is growing steadily… we had 10 new patients for this month… we are starting our marketing campaign this month so we expect to get quite busy!” (This one was from a “Board Certified Chiropractic Neurologist.” Who cares whether it works, as long as it generates income?)
While looking for information on that company, I ran across a couple of other oxygen websites that are equally reprehensible.
Oxygen Elements MaxThis website tells us that “our bodies were also intended to get oxygen from water.” (True only of our ancestors during the fish stage of our evolutionary history. We no longer have gills, unless you count the vestigial remnants that appear transiently during embryological development.) They admit that their product actually contains very little oxygen. But that doesn’t matter, because it:
creates oxygen at the cellular level in your body by using the oxygen components that are already there. To put it simply, Oxygen Elements Max (formerly Hydroxygen Plus) actually splits the water molecule (H2O – two parts Hydrogen and one part Oxygen) and starts a chain reaction that releases the Oxygen as the body demands it. This reaction continues for up to 72 hours, but peaks in your body at about 6-12 hours. Thus, your body has a ready supply of oxygen stored up in its water and is released as needed.
The product also contains:
    • 19 amino acids
    • digestive & metabolic enzymes
    • 78 ionic trace minerals
    • electrolytes
    • and “it continuously provides your cells with Hydrogen & Oxygen”
Since the dosage is in drops, and a single bottle lasts a month, for all these components to be packed in, they can only be present in homeopathic quantities.
Ed McCabe, “best selling oxygen author and pioneer” brags about being raided by the FDA for selling his oxygen supplement. He claims that an increase in someone’s oxygen saturation can be measured 30 minutes after taking the drops. I find that hard to believe. I also find it hard to believe some of his other astounding claims:
    • “When the food you eat doesn’t contain the proper digestive enzymes, your body dips into your storehouse of metabolic enzymes to synthesize the needed enzyme. This results in you using up your storehouse of metabolic enzymes faster that you should.” (Most ingested enzymes are rapidly degraded by the digestive process and disassembled into their basic building blocks; they don’t act as enzymes in the body.)
    • On average, doctors only live 80% as long as the general population.” (Wrong! They actually live 3 years longer. )
    • “Many scientists believe that a periodic lack of oxygen must be held responsible for the formation of cancer cells, thus being one of the causes of cancer.” (Which scientists are those? Do they have any evidence, or do they just “believe”? What about the majority of scientists who disagree?)
    • “A cell denied the oxygen necessary for it to breathe mutates into an anaerobic plant type (Cancerous) cell. “ (Animal cells turning into plant cells? Yeah, sure!)
    • “The ancient atmosphere was 38-50% Oxygen (“Science“ Journal). That means today we have only HALF the Oxygen we were designed to run on…According to experts the oxygen levels of our atmosphere have dropped by as much as 50% over the past 500 years.” (Not according to this paper. It says “It is quite possible that the level of atmospheric oxygen has varied (roughly between 15 and 30% O2) over the past 550 million years.“)
    • “Most diseases can’t live in Oxygen, especially high levels of active oxygen! So, if we safely and properly re-supply our bodies with the missing oxygen, what happens to the offending toxins and microbes, the two causes of all disease, and aging?“ (This may be a step above the “one true cause of all disease” theories but not by much. How monumentally silly! Do they really believe that a person protected from any contact with toxins and microbes would never get sick and would never age?)
    • “the true cause of allergy is lowered oxidation process within the body.” (Sez who?)
    • “Hydrogen is associated with the properties of solidification, integration, and concentration. It brings together a matrix of energies, evolving these energies into solid forms. If the hydrogen properties are allowed to continue on unchecked, the form gets denser and denser. Finally, extreme hardness settles in. These properties are the ones that bring the form of our bodies into existence, out of the DNA. Hydrogen builds cells, and if left unmodulated, makes them hard and brittle. These effects are balanced by the action of the oxygen.” (If any of that makes sense to you, you might want to get your medication adjusted.)
Testimonials for Oxygen Elements Max abound, for a long list of practically every human ailment. Order options include a bottle with a 30 day supply for $31.95, membership to save money, and a Business Membership option which is a typical multilevel marketing (MLM) opportunity. There is a money back guarantee, of course, providing you return the unused portion.
Richardson’s Miracle Cure
Kevin Richardson offers a downloadable book The Miracle Cure: in which he “Reveals The Simple And Natural Nutrient Known To Relieve Virtually All Ailments, Diseases, And Illnesses With No Side Effects.” Among other things, his book promises to reveal a particular golden honey that is rich in oxygen water and will even provide recipes for an oxygen diet.
He claims that oxygen is the cure for 95% of all the diseases that you are otherwise doomed to suffer or die from. He lists some of them here.
It’s hardly surprising that his list includes the ever-popular autism and Lyme disease, but it did surprise me that it included insect bites and “Food Allergies Warts,” whatever that is. He says Dr. Robert Atkins was jailed for curing cancer with oxygen. He says there are no side effects other than “the rare ‘healing crisis’ when your body expels harmful, toxic and even deadly poisons from your body.”
He cites Otto Warburg; his simplistic misinterpretation of the Warburg hypothesis is that Warburg “proved” that lack of oxygen was the cause of cancer and that supplying your cells with it not only kills cancer cells and tumors, but blocks future cancer cells from forming. Warburg did have an intriguing hypothesis about cancer metabolism, but he “proved” no such thing.
Conclusion
There are a lot of myths about the health benefits of supplemental oxygen, and they keep popping up like whack-a-moles no matter how often science beats them down. I found all of this profoundly depressing. Apparently the American public is so ignorant of science that unscrupulous entrepreneurs can easily make money by snowing the gullible with the most egregious pseudoscientific nonsense. There are legitimate uses for supplemental oxygen and hyperbaric oxygen within scientific medicine. The kinds of oxygen therapies I have covered here are not scientific and are not medicine; they are simply disreputable moneymaking enterprises.

Quackery (still) kills: A five-year-old boy dies in a hyperbaric oxygen chamber
Even as quacks and antivaxxers take over our federal government’s health apparatus, let’s not forget why we need stronger, not laxer, regulation of “unconventional” medical practices.
David Gorski on March 17, 2025
Link
One thing that I like to do from time to time is to highlight a story or incident relevant to the mission of this blog that has happened in southeast Michigan, where I live. This time around, it’s the tragic story of a five-year-old boy named Thomas Cooper, who met a tragic end six weeks ago undergoing hyperbaric oxygen treatment (HBOT) for ADHD at The Oxford Center, a quack clinic that operates two locations, one in the suburbs of Detroit and one in Brighton, near Ann Arbor. Unfortunately, it’s such a horrific story that it is no longer strictly a local story; it’s hit the national and even international news. As regular readers know, I’ve long been critical of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), but not for the reasons that our new Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has been in his deceptive, antivax- and quack-friendly “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) manifesto or in his declaration of war on the FDA after he had suspended his independent Presidential campaign and bent the knee to Donald Trump.
Contrary to RFK Jr.’s apparent view of the FDA as jack-booted thugs who are “persecuting” brave maverick doctors curing chronic disease (and vaccine injury) with “natural therapies” (and even sunlight!), my view has been that the FDA has failed to protect the public by letting these sorts of quack treatments flourish mostly unpunished. Indeed, I’ve discussed numerous examples of this, although perhaps the one example most discussed a decade or more ago was that of Houston cancer quack Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, who has somehow managed to ply his antineoplastons-based quackery for nearly 50 years, with only occasional attempts by the FDA (or his state medical board) to shut him down, all of them failing. Of course, it’s not entirely the FDA’s fault, as it’s been chronically underfunded and understaffed compared to the magnitude of its tasks making sure that food is safe and that medical devices and pharmaceuticals are effective and safe, but that’s not RFK Jr.’s beef with the FDA. Instead, he portrays the FDA as insufficiently rigorous when it comes to vaccines and pharmaceuticals and way too harsh enforcing regulations when it comes to “alternative medicine” practices, you know, like HBOT. Just as a reminder, I’ll repost something RFK Jr. posted to X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, a few months ago:
Yes, RFK Jr. thinks the FDA is too strict regulating HBOT. No wonder HBOT quacks love him
What is HBOT, though? In brief, it is the use of 100% oxygen under pressures higher than atmospheric. By way of comparison, the amount of oxygen in the air we breathe normally is around 21%, the rest being mostly nitrogen, and, to a smaller degree, CO2 and other trace gases. Usually, HBOT uses 100% oxygen at pressures between 1.5- and 3-times atmospheric pressure. According to Johns Hopkins Medicine and the FDA these are the conditions for which HBOT is evidence-based:
    • Air and gas bubbles in blood vessels
    • Anemia (severe anemia when blood transfusions cannot be used)
    • Burns (severe and large burns treated at a specialized burn center)
    • Carbon monoxide poisoning
    • Crush injury
    • Decompression sickness (diving risk)
    • Gas gangrene
    • Hearing loss (complete hearing loss that occurs suddenly and without any known cause)
    • Infection of the skin and bone (severe)
    • Radiation injury
    • Skin graft flap at risk of tissue death
    • Vision loss (when sudden and painless in one eye due to blockage of blood flow)
    • Wounds (non-healing, diabetic foot ulcers)
    • The FDA further notes:
HBOT is being studied for other conditions, including COVID-19. However, at this time, the FDA has not cleared or authorized the use of any HBOT device to treat COVID-19 or any conditions beyond those listed above. The website, clinicaltrials.gov, has more information on HBOT clinical trials for COVID-19 and other conditions.
Anything else is not evidence-based or FDA-cleared.
Let’s just show what happens when HBOT is not “suppressed.” First, however, here’s one last thing. Some of the links go to stories that describe how Thomas Cooper died and his mother was burned trying to rescue him. The descriptions are hard to take. You might want to be careful reading and be ready to skip passages that might cause too much distress. I’m not going to sugarcoat anything, though, because I am indeed outraged that centers like The Oxford Center not only continue to exist and thrive, but could well, under RFK Jr.’s HHS leadership, become even more common and immune from the law. Worse, if anything, what we have learned in the six months since Thomas’ death makes this case even more egregious than it had first appeared upon initial reporting.
The death of Thomas Cooper
I debated about how to describe what happened on January 31, 2025 at The Oxford Center in Troy and ultimately decided on starting with how the event was reported and then proceeding to what has recently been reported, the latter of which makes the story so much more horrific and despicable than even the initial reporting did. So let’s start with the first story that I encountered that weekend, Boy dies in explosion of hyperbaric chamber at Troy medical facility:
A 5-year-old boy from Royal Oak died Friday during an explosion of a hyperbaric chamber at a Troy medical center, police said.
The explosion happened shortly before 8 a.m. at The Oxford Center at 165 Kirts Blvd. Police said the boy was found dead inside the chamber. His mother, who was injured, was with him at the facility at the time of the explosion, officials said.
The Oxford Center’s website says that it provides therapy for children with such health conditions as autism, cancer, ADHD, autoimmune diseases, and multiple others.
Troy Fire Lt. Keith Young said investigators do not yet know what caused the explosion, but concentrated oxygen and the pressure used inside hyperbaric chambers are fuel for fire.
In a statement from The Oxford Center, spokesman Andrew Kistner said the cause of the explosion is unknown and that Friday was an “exceptionally difficult day for all of us.
Naturally, The Oxford Center soon tried to spin what happened:
“As law enforcement officials have shared, at our location in Troy, Michigan, this morning, a fire started inside of a hyperbaric oxygen chamber,” Kistner wrote in the emailed statement. “The child being treated in that chamber did not survive and the child’s mother was injured.
“The safety and wellbeing of the children we serve is our highest priority. Nothing like this has happened in our more than 15 years of providing this type of therapy. We do not know why or how this happened and will participate in all of the investigations that now need to take place.”
Imagine my relief at the time.
Here’s a press conference given by the police and fire departments in Troy:
From the press conference above, according to Lt. Keith Young of the Troy Fire Department:
Shortly before 8:00 AM this morning Troy Fire and Police Department responded to a medical facility at 165 Kirts Boulevard for report of a hyperbaric chamber ber explosion with the child still inside the chamber. Upon arrival it was determined the child inside was deceased, and the victim has been identified as a 5-year-old boy from Royal Oak. A hyperic chamber contains 100% oxygen, which is up to five times the amount of oxygen in a normal room. The presence of such a high amount of oxygen in a pressurized environment can make it extremely combustible. Our initial research shows that this is not a common incident and the scene remains under active investigation. Social workers from the Oakland Community Health Network have made themselves available to work with emergency Personnel who responded to the scene and medical staff at the facility…
I can’t even imagine the horrific scene that the child’s mother saw and that the first responders encountered when they arrived. In fairness, tragic accidents like this involving HBOT chambers are rare, regardless of whether the chamber is being used at a hospital for science- and evidence-based indications (e.g., to counter the effects of decompression sickness in scuba divers, to treat carbon monoxide poisoning, to improve the “take” rate of skin grafts, or to speed up healing of diabetic foot ulcers) or at the many, many, “integrative” medical clinics that use HBOT for everything ranging from autism to cancer to stroke to dementia. Guess which one of these facilities The Oxford Center is? More on that shortly, but first let’s continue with the tragic story.
First, before I discuss revelations that came to light early this month, let me note that this is not the first time such an accident has killed a child. In 2009, a boy named Francesco Martinizi suffered massive burns that ultimately claimed his life in an HBOT chamber being used by quacks at a Florida clinic, the Ocean Hyperbaric Neurologic Center, to treat his cerebral palsy, a tragedy that also claimed the life of his grandmother. Again, as is the case for ADHD and autism, there is no good scientific or clinical evidence to justify using HBOT to treat cerebral palsy. This latest victim might be considered fortunate compared to Francesco, as Francesco lingered with his injuries for a month and a half before dying. I did rotations in burn units during my general surgery residency. I know from observing patients firsthand how painful being treated for large burns is and how disfiguring they can be. Moreover, news reports then described how the family had brought Francesco from Italy to the US for treatments supposedly not available there and had spent hundreds of thousands of dollars doing so.
It didn’t take long for the family to call in the lawyers, and in this case I can’t blame them.
Citing concerns about the oversight and regulations of hyperbaric chambers, Fieger Law announced Saturday that it has been retained by the family of the 5-year-old boy who died in a hyperbaric chamber explosion in Troy on Friday.
“This is an unimaginable tragedy, and our hearts are with the family as they navigate this immeasurable loss,” said James Harrington, managing partner of Fieger Law in a statement.
The high-powered law firm is also representing the boy’s mother, who was also injured in the explosion.
The law firm’s founder Geoffrey Feiger retired in 2024 after a major stroke. You might also remember him as having run for Governor of Michigan, although he is most (in)famous for having defended “Dr. Death,” a.k.a. Dr. Jack Kevorkian in the 1990s. I will admit that I’ve never been a fan of his and tend to view his law firm as among the worst of the worst when it comes to ambulance chasing attorneys, but in this case the firm that he founded might actually do some good. If there’s one thing I’ve often wondered, it’s why more victims and families of victims of clinics like The Oxford Center don’t sue quacks and quack clinics for malpractice after being harmed or having a loved one killed. Moreover, if you’re going to sue a clinic like this victimizing children and are in the Detroit area, Feiger Law or The Sam Bernstein Law Firm would be the ambulance chasers I’d recommend. Sometimes big sharks have their uses.
The family soon started a GoFundMe page for family support, and, I swear, reading it made my eyes tear up:
Thomas Cooper was 5 when he passed away in the hyperbaric chamber in Troy.
He was the smartest and cutest kid that liked to zoom, zoom, zoom. He asked to see pictures of germs, liked to know how things worked, he liked to make field journals and he had finally started adding facial features to his people drawings….
…He loved audio books and had just fallen in love with James and Giant Peach, BFG and Charlie and Chocolate Factory. He had just watched the first classic movie, then the Johnny Depp version and he was so excited there was a third newest one.
He loved life. He loved running and swimming. He was planning to try mountain bmx racing and karate in the summer.
Before his passing, he asked for a Chinese red pocket money for the new year. He placed it underneath his pillow and declared “he’d have the best luck ever!” The day of his passing was the day he was planning to spend his red pocket with his little brother.
His favorite thing to do is “super sonic mode.” Run as fast as humanly possibly. He had nature school last year and ran, jumped and rolled down hills. He loved mud. Loved to stomp on ice. Loved his mama and daddy so much.
Minecraft was his life. He loved all the characters and the YouTube channel with mikey and JJ. He loved Mario. He loved to dress as Mario and his brother dressed as Luigi. They were the best of friends.
He loved his Nintendo DS. His dad got him a Yoshi game the night before (for trying new foods) and he was excited to come home after the hyperbaric treatment to play.
He loved to sing “I love mama, I love mama, I love mama so very much.”
He also loved to say “my momma is the best in the whole world.”
He wanted to grow up to be a chef. His mom asked him why and he said,”so I can be with mommy forever.”
His family loved him very much. He was a smart, intelligent boy and his parents loved him how he was. He was perfect in every way. He was the best, best boy there ever was.
It was soon reported that at the time of his death, Thomas had been undergoing HBOT for indications that are most definitely not evidence- or science-based, specifically ADHD and sleep apnea. In other words, he was the victim of quackery and an unscrupulous quack. Just how unscrupulous, you will soon see when I revisit Thomas’ story. In the meantime, let’s take a look at The Oxford Center.
HBOT at The Oxford Center: The main quackery among other quackery
I like to think that I’m aware of most of the quack clinics in my neck of the woods. However, the metro Detroit area (indeed, all of southeast Michigan) is quite a large and populous area, and of course I don’t know all the local quacks (although there is a chiropractic “wellness” center disturbingly close to where I live that I’ve been meaning to write about). So I had never heard of The Oxford Center before I encountered this story. That’s why I feel the need to discuss this quack clinic a bit. As is usual, the original press stories, while being mostly accurate describing how HBOT is not evidence-based for the conditions for which it is used at The Oxford Center, tended to be too…moderate…in its description, for example, in the original Detroit Free Press article:
You can get a bit of an idea why HBOT quackery is the main—but by no means the only—quack modality sold at The Oxford Center just by looking at its origin story:
The Oxford Center is among the alternative medical centers or medical spas that, in recent years, have offered hyperbaric oxygen therapy for conditions that are not approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, such as autism spectrum disorder, cerebral palsy, sports injuries, COVID-19, depression, alopecia, HIV/AIDS, strokes, migraine headaches, and as an anti-aging treatment.
No kidding. I could tell just by perusing the clinic’s website some more. Just take a look at the splash page, which features photos of multiple HBOT chambers:
Line ’em up! Or so it would appear.
Then there’s a Google image on the website, where I count at least eight HBOT chambers:
Strike that! Definitely line ’em up!
Then, of course, there’s a spiffy little cute video touting HBOT for, well, almost everything!
Besides the pictures of banks of HBOT chambers, it doesn’t take long to learn that the founder of the clinic is a true believer:
Oxygen is a “nutrient”? No…just no. It’s not. It is true that oxygen is necessary for human life. It’s necessary to generate sufficient energy from the food that we consume. (There is such a thing as anaerobic metabolism, but it generates far less energy than aerobic metabolism, and is insufficient for anything other than short-term bursts of energy, which must be “paid back” using oxygen.) It is not, however, a “nutrient,” as the medical definition of “nutrient” is limited to substances that we ingest; i.e., to food. It does not apply to chemicals that we breathe, like oxygen. Scientific illiteracy is not a good sign on a quack website.
Let’s compare and contrast the evidence-based uses for HBOT to the uses touted by The Oxford Center. I’ve already listed the conditions for which HBOT might be indicated and evidence-based in the introduction to this post. Now let’s look at the conditions for which The Oxford Center touts HBOT as an effective treatment:
It claims that the benefits of HBOT include:
Basically, The Oxford Center sells HBOT as a magic therapy for almost anything and everything. My first reaction upon reading this was utter horror at how the child died. My second reaction (aside from horror) after reading the initial accounts above was to ask: What condition was being treated with HBOT? Was it a condition for which use of HBOT is in any way science- or evidence-based? I noted that, if you play the law of averages for these quack clinics (particularly given that I know knew that that it was a five-year-old boy who was being treated), it was not unreasonable to guess that the boy was probably receiving HBOT for autism or ADHD, the two most common indications (in my experience) for which quack clinics employ HBOT.
It turns out that I was partially correct:
The Cooper family’s attorney told the Free Press the boy was being treated at the center for ADHD and sleep apnea, which also are not conditions approved for treatment with hyperbaric oxygen therapy.
Oddly enough, I don’t see sleep apnea in the large list of conditions above. It is, however, another condition not considered to be an evidence-based indication for HBOT.
It is not surprising that The Oxford Center is all-in on HBOT. All you have to do is to read the origin story of the center:
Our Founder and CEO, Tami Peterson, discovered hyperbarics after her daughter, JeAnnah, was diagnosed with viral encephalitis. JeAnnah went from a happy, functioning 9-year-old girl to functioning at the level of an 11-month-old infant in one day.
Tami did not give up hope for JeAnnah, and through countless hours of research and talking to parents of children around the world with similar conditions, Tami discovered Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy.
She was able to convince a local hospital to treat JeAnnah, and within a few months, JeAnnah danced The Nutcracker ballet and was completely healed. Her recovery was a miracle. Tami knew that she was called to use her experience with JeAnnah to provide the healing and hope of Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy for others.
Tami founded The Oxford Center in 2008 in South Lyon, Michigan. Since then, she has worked to add multiple other therapies to our list of services, opened a second location in Troy, Michigan, moved our South Lyon location to Brighton, Michigan, and then expanded that location to the over 70,000 square foot facility that it is today.
This is the main form of evidence for HBOT success stories and “miracle cures,” namely anecdotes. The most likely explanation is that JeAnnah would have likely gotten better without the HBOT and that Peterson is confusing correlation with causation. However, without better evidence, it’s impossible to say. I did a PubMed search for hyperbaric oxygen and viral encephalitis, and all I could find were three articles, only one of which addressed the question of whether HBOT can treat viral encephalitis, and the paper was a mouse study.
As for The Oxford Center, although hyperbaric oxygen seems to be its raison d’être and the primary therapy that it uses for basically everything, it also offers a veritable cornucopia of the usual “integrative medicine” nonsense, in particular functional medicine, under the supervision of Anna Dobracki, MD, PhD. (It really disappoints me that an MD/PhD would embrace functional medicine, which I like to refer to as “reams of useless tests in one hand, a large invoice in the other.”
It’s rather interesting to look at some conditions The Oxford Center treats. For instance, if you go to the page on ADHD, the Center’s first choice of therapy is…HBOT! Its next choice, often done with HBOT, is a “quantitative EEG and neurofeedback therapy”:
A Quantitative EEG shows us electrical activity of the brain. We will be able to see if inflammation is present, if there are any areas of hyper- or hypoactivity, and any areas of disconnect. Using this information, we can focus on the area(s) of the brain most affected and bring those areas back into balance using Neurofeedback Therapy. Research has shown a reduction in hyperactivity, more focus and attention with Neurofeedback Therapy and ADHD.
NFT is very much a dubious therapy, with little evidence to support it and evidence that it does no better than placebo, with an article in Psychology Today noting that the “procedure is safe and non-invasive, but given that it can also be expensive, time-consuming, and less effective than proven treatments, patients should carefully consider their options” and a 2016 review article concluding that “current research does not support conclusive results about its efficacy.”
What about autism? The Oxford Center’s page on autism does recommend applied behavioral analysis (ABA); so I guess there’s that. However, The Oxford Center also recommends—you guessed it!—HBOT, justifying it thusly:
Research has shown decreased cerebral perfusion, increased neuroinflammation, inflammation throughout the GI system, and increased oxidative stress in individuals with autism. Decreased blood flow to the temporal region and areas that are specifically related to language comprehension and auditory processing. Decreased blood flow to these areas may contribute to many of the characteristics that are common with autism listed above. HBOT delivers 100% pure oxygen to the body through increased atmospheric pressure, saturating the plasma and oxygenating the entire body. Research has shown that HBOT reduces inflammation systemically, lowers oxidative stress, and increases circulating stem cells, up to 800% after twenty sessions, which leads to the possibility of regrowth of certain brain cells.
None of this has been shown in anything resembling rigorous to affect positivel the clinical course in autism and autism spectrum disorders. Not that that stopped the quacks at The Oxford Center from publishing a retrospective analysis of 65 of the clinic’s patients who were treated for autism in a dodgy journal (Cureus) comparing those who received ABA to those who received ABA+HBOT, which claimed to show better verbal behaviors in children with autism who received the combined treatment with hyperbaric oxygen. From my perusal of the study, my immediate question was whether confounders were adequately considered. (Surprise! I don’t think they were!) Perhaps I’ll look at the study in more detail at another time, but I’ll just mention that a Cochran Review concluded that “there is no evidence that hyperbaric oxygen therapy improves core symptoms and associated symptoms of ASD” and cautioned that “is important to note that adverse effects (minor-grade ear barotrauma events) can occur.”
Oh, and the only treatment that The Oxford Center offers for cancer is…HBOT. Because of course. Basically, the mainstay of treatment for every condition treated by The Oxford Center is HBOT, regardless of what else is also offered. It seems to me that it’s more appropriate to call The Oxford Center an HBOT clinic rather than any sort of “integrative medicine” clinic. It’s a one-trick pony.
And, as is typical for clinics like this:
The Oxford Center, which has locations in Brighton and Troy, has generated controversy. In August, the facility’s former director Kimberly Coden pleaded guilty to nine charges after officials with Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel’s Office said she used false credentials to treat children with autism.
She falsely presented herself as a board-certified behavioral analyst without being licensed and without the proper education and used an actual analyst’s certification to get jobs within the health sector, officials said. And she’d also used professional business cards, verbal statements, written documents and presented university degrees she allegedly didn’t earn.
Coden also tried to intimidate a witness through text messages to keep them from testifying against her, officials said.
When Coden pleaded guilty, her lawyer said her client was “really, truly remorseful.”
Lovely. Let’s just say that her behavior after Thomas Cooper died was…consistent…with her past behavior.
It’s so much worse than it first appeared
The story of Thomas Cooper is back in the news again, because investigations have yielded results. For instance, in mid-February, we learned more about what happened based on the testimony of the mother Annie Cooper. I will warn you that this testimony is difficult to read:
The boy, described by his family as curious, energetic and thoughtful, was in the midst of his 36th hyperbaric oxygen therapy treatment at the center when the pressurized chamber burst into flames. Thomas was trapped inside.
His mother, Annie Cooper, raced from a nearby waiting area to his side, but couldn’t get Thomas out of the sealed, tube-like chamber, said James Harrington, managing partner at Fieger Law, which is representing the family.
She was left to watch in horror as her son burned to death inside the chamber, which was full of highly combustible pure oxygen. Annie Cooper suffered third-degree burns to her arms, but the psychological trauma was far worse, Harrington said.
“It’s literally the worst thing that any parent could (experience),” he said. “And poor Thomas … his last moments of life were being engulfed in flames and perishing in front of his mother. He was certainly aware of what was going on.”
Then, last week it was reported that there had been several arrests, with the CEO, safety director, and others charged with second-degree murder:
Calling the death of a 5-year-old boy “an easily preventable tragedy,” Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said Tuesday that the Oxford Center in Troy operated the hyperbaric oxygen chamber that engulfed the child in flames on the morning of Jan. 31 “in defiance of international safety standards in accordance with whatever would provide them the most income or profit.”
“The investigation into this tragedy has revealed how the Oxford Center in Troy and several of its key decision makers held safety among their lowest considerations in their hyperbaric treatment practice,” she said.
Nessel charged three people with second-degree murder, which carries a penalty of up to life in prison:
    • The Oxford Center’s CEO and founder Tamela Peterson, 58, of Brighton.
    • Gary Marken, 65, of Spring Arbor, who serves on the center’s advisory board and is its director of operations.
    • Jeffrey Alan Mosteller, 64, of Clinton Township, who is the center’s safety director and director of training.
Each of them also was given an additional alternative charge of manslaughter, which carries a maximum penalty of 15-years in prison, Nessel said, “meaning that a jury will be able to decide which charge properly befits their conduct.”
A fourth person, Aleta Harward Moffitt, 60, of Rochester Hills, was the operator of the hyperbaric chamber on the morning of Thomas’ death, Nessel said. She is charged with involuntary manslaughter and one count of intentionally placing false information on a medical record, a four-year felony, Nessel said.
Although I generally like Attorney General Nessel and have tended to support her, I can’t help but add here that the State of Michigan bears at least a modicum of responsibility for Thomas Cooper’s death in that it allows quack clinics like The Oxford Center to flourish. Every time there is a harm, our law enforcement will (appropriately) treat it as the violation of the law, but then our regulatory agencies will do little or nothing to correct the underlying flaw in the system that allows such tragedies to happen.
Indeed, later in the story:
The Oxford Center staff failed to meet the following safety standards, Nessel said, on the day of Thomas’ death:
    • Conduct a daily maintenance check and pre-dive safety check.
    • Have a medical doctor or safety supervisor at the Troy facility at the time of Thomas’ treatment.
    • Provide a licensed technician to perform the treatment.
    • Complete yearly inspections of the hyperbaric chamber as recommended by the manufacturer.
    • Require Thomas to wear a grounding strap during his treatment. It controls the risk of static electricity inside the chamber to reduce risk of fire.
The Oxford Center, which has locations in Brighton and in Troy, issued a statement to the Free Press late Monday, calling the timing of the charges “surprising as the typical protocol after a fire-related accident has not yet been completed.”
It gets even worse, though. Later in the week, news stories started reporting that there were attempts to destroy evidence, as well as text messages found with some breathtakingly callous comments from CEO Tamela Peterson:
Tamela Peterson, the CEO of the Oxford Center in Troy, ran away from detectives when they asked for her cellphone and had her son scrub her laptop days after 5-year-old Thomas Cooper was burned alive inside one of the center’s hyperbaric oxygen chambers on Jan. 31, Troy Police say.
According to another news story:
Investigators noted that when they tried to get the CCTV footage from all of Cooper’s other treatments, Peterson claimed she did not remember her password to access the system.
IT personnel then said she should have it because they had just given it to her “very recently.” The IT personnel were the ones who provided the login information needed to access the video.
Investigators said Peterson was constantly monitoring video in real-time at the Troy facility, based on message and email correspondence.
“I don’t remember the password”? That reminds me of “The dog ate my homework.” But, unbelievably, it gets even worse (and, again, this is very, very bad—take care):
Still, police found electronic messages on Peterson’s devices, said Detective Danielle Trigger, including an exchange in which Peterson sent photos of the boy’s burning body and wrote “something to the effect of: ‘If my leg was on fire, I would at least try to hit it and put it out. He just laid there and did nothing.’ ”
First, it’s horrifying that pictures of the boy burning to death in the HBOT chamber exist on Peterson’s phone, but it’s even worse that she was so callous. “He just laid there and did nothing”? Was he already dead? Was he in shock? One can only imagine.
And, as I always like to say about these clinics, it was all about the Benjamins:
Peterson’s messages also show that when she was asked whether the company was promoting hyperbaric chambers to treat erectile dysfunction, she responded: “Whatever gets bodies in those chambers, lol,” according to a transcript of Trigger’s March 7 testimony before 52-4 District Court Magistrate Elizabeth Chiappelli, which was obtained by the Detroit Free Press.
We also learned that the HBOT treatment that killed Thomas Cooper was the 36th of 40 planned treatments, and that The Oxford Center wasn’t exactly careful about safety protocols. Compare what is recommended as best practice for such chambers to what happened the morning of Thomas Cooper’s death:
Hyperbaric chambers contain 100% oxygen that is pressurized. Those conditions make the environment inside them highly combustible. And while adults at the Oxford Center were required to wear medical scrubs when using the center’s chambers, children were allowed to wear their own pajamas inside, so long as they were made of 100% cotton, police said.
The type of material matters, according to a 1997 study that determined synthetic materials and wool fibers can “build up static charges (and) should not be permitted inside the chamber” because of the risk that they could ignite a fire.
A video obtained by Troy police showed that the tags on Thomas’ pajamas were never checked to ensure they were made of cotton before he went inside the chamber, Trigger said. And she said the facility hadn’t used grounding straps for years on patients, including on Thomas the day he was killed. The straps typically are worn around the wrist during hyperbaric oxygen therapy to discharge static electricity that could spark a fire. They were found by detectives in the center’s “junk drawer,” according to Trigger.
And, almost unbelievably, but really not, I guess:
Peterson, Marken and Mosteller allegedly advised employees that grounding strips, a safety measure, were not necessary, despite industry experts, safety manuals, and the Oxford Center’s own training materials suggesting otherwise. Police say Mosteller conducted his own experiments in an attempt to prove grounding straps are not necessary, even though he could not recall to police one facility that does not use them in his 41 years of experience with hyperbaric chambers.
Unsurprisingly, this story has gone national and international, and this NBC News report sums up the practices at The Oxford Center rather nicely as Hyperbaric chamber facility where boy died put profits before client care, Michigan attorney general says:
Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel described the business as “unscrupulous,” saying that, for years, Peterson, Marken and Mosteller disregarded safety measures. They used the highly pressurized oxygen chambers on children’s bodies “over and over again to provide unaccredited and debunked so-called treatments, chiefly because it brought cash into the door.”
Indeed. I would, however, repeat that the State of Michigan bears some culpability for letting these quacks operate for so long. Somehow, I doubt that Nessel will acknowledge that, other than by way of excuses:
In a news conference Tuesday, Nessel accused Oxford Center staff of holding “safety among their lowest considerations” but said officials had no way of knowing about the danger until it was too late, and cannot proactively investigate other facilities.
“Michigan law doesn’t require any oversight over the use of hyperbaric chambers, so without having some sort of probable cause to believe that there are crimes being committed involving hyperbaric chambers in other places in the state, we wouldn’t have the authority to go in and perform an inspection,” Nessel said.
It really sounds as though legislators in Michigan and other states should do something about that, doesn’t it?
What will happen now that RFK Jr. runs all nonmilitary federal health programs?
It took the tragic death of a five-year-old boy to stop the use of HBOT at The Oxford Center, but it’s only completely closed one location, the one in Troy; apparently the Brighton location is still in operation; it just shut down its HBOT program.
There is some hope in Michigan, as there are legislators who are working on legislation to do something about all the unregulated HBOT facilities across the state. This NBC News report notes that The Oxford Center where Thomas died was subject to occasional fire safety inspections by the Troy Fire Department, whose spokesman noted that “our inspections are fire- and life-safety focused” and that there’s “nothing that covers the operation or the maintenance of the chambers themselves.” Hospitals using hyperbaric chambers for evidence-based indications “abide by codes developed by the National Fire Protection Association, a standards development organization.” However, Michigan is not unique in lacking a regulatory framework for hyperbaric oxygen therapy outside of traditional health care facilities. Moreover, accreditation by Undersea & Hyperbaric Medical Society involves inspections and costs around $10,000 for each accreditation cycle of three or four years.
According to a spokesman for the Undersea & Hyperbaric Medical Society:
He estimated that thousands of spas, wellness companies and other storefronts are operating hyperbaric chambers in the U.S. without having undergone accreditation, and he said he fears many may not be upholding stringent standards.
No kidding.
I will say that the Michigan legislators seem to “get it” in that they aren’t just focused on safety but on cracking down on the quackery surrounding HBOT:
Two Democratic legislators in Michigan, state Sen. Stephanie Chang and state Rep. Sharon MacDonell, are working together to explore regulatory options after Thomas’ death.
Chang said she was alarmed by what appeared to be a myriad of problems that led to the fire, based on what the Michigan attorney general outlined, including allegedly not having a properly trained technician operating the hyperbaric chamber.
“Let’s fix all of those loopholes,” Chang said. She said she and MacDonell are aiming to introduce legislation in the spring.
MacDonell said it was important not just to make hyperbaric chambers safer but also to stop businesses from making unproven claims about what the therapy can do.
“People are taking advantage of parents with children with hard-to-treat conditions, and just kind of monetizing the desperation of the parents,” she said. “It’s just incomprehensible.”
Actually, if you had been paying attention, you would find it quite comprehensible. Quacks are either true believers in HBOT or they like money, often both. Moreover, these sorts of “holistic spas” have been a problem for literally decades. Indeed, the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs does not have oversight of hyperbaric chambers. In Michigan, they are not even required to be licensed.
This brings me back to RFK Jr., who now oversees the FDA. Of course, the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) just advanced Dr. Marty Makary’s nomination to be FDA Commissioner, and he’s likely to be confirmed by the full Senate this week. If there were an area that cries out for more FDA regulation, it would be something like hyperbaric oxygen chambers, given that:
While there are guidelines for how to safely construct and operate hyperbaric chambers, there is no consistent federal, state or local oversight of the practice outside of hospitals. The FDA said in an email last month that it regulates certain hyperbaric chambers that meet the agency’s definition of Class II medical devices, which are “intended for use in the diagnosis of disease or other conditions, or in the cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease.” But it does not regulate the practice of medicine and referred NBC News to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, The Joint Commission and state medical licensing agencies for more information.
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services requires Medicare and Medicaid providers to comply with parts of the National Fire Protection Association code, but that does not apply to other facilities, which must still adhere to local building and fire codes, said Brian O’Connor, a senior engineer at the National Fire Protection Association.
Oh, wait. America’s Quack, Dr. Mehmet Oz, will soon be running CMS.
My point in starting this story out by quoting RFK Jr. is that he’s not just an antivaxxer. He’s in favor of a lot of unproven medical treatment and outright quackery, which he hopes to “mainstream” through his MAHA agenda. Dr. Makary has made a name for himself claiming (falsely) that medical error is the third leading cause of death in the US and, with more justification, that the FDA’s approval process is too lax, although he definitely undermined that message by focusing primarily on COVID-19 vaccines to the point where his contrarianism suggests ideology more than a genuine desire to reform the FDA for the better.
What needs to happen are two things. First, the FDA needs to classify these HBOT chambers formally as medical devices, subject to FDA regulation. That includes all the thousands of HBOT chambers in all the spas and alternative health clinics throughout the US. Second, states need to consider HBOT therapy a medical treatment subject to regulation by their departments of health and state medical boards. The first, I just don’t see happening with RFK Jr. in charge, given that I highly doubt that Dr. Makary has the intestinal fortitude to challenge his boss on this issue. The second, I don’t see happening much, except maybe in a few states. Indeed, I’m not even sure that it will happen in Michigan even after this tragedy. After all, although the 2009 case that I mentioned above did lead the doctor to lose his license, no one went to prison. (One technician was sentence to house arrest.) Worse, no laws were passed or changed to prevent such a tragedy again.
Certainly, I hope that all those responsible for Thomas Cooper’s death receive the justice that they are do, particularly Peterson, whose behavior after the investigation started sure does suggest that she knew what she was doing. Failing to shut them down (which would have been a lot better), the best that the state can do is to do its best to convict them and send them to prison for a long time, while the parents can sue for civil damages. Unfortunately, more broadly, with RFK Jr. in charge of HHS, I expect harms and deaths from quackery to increase, not decrease. Why? Because I expect him to do his damnedest to make sure that no stronger regulations and laws are passed; more than that, I expect him to weaken the already lax laws and regulations governing quackery like The Oxford Center’s use of HBOT.
After all, if someone like Stanislaw Burzynski could operate for nearly five decades without being shut down by either the FDA or the State of Texas and that, he is still in business, what hope is there with RFK Jr. in charge and a lot of RFK Jr.-inspired politicians who are at least antivax-adjacent as well as pro-“health freedom” at the state level overseeing the practice of medicine? Sadly, there is not much, but that doesn’t mean we should stop trying to protect patients.


Drinkable Sunscreen Snakeoil
Steven Novella on July 30, 2014
Link
In May, prompted by an uncritical article in the Daily Mail, the internet was buzzing about a company that was offering drinkable sunscreen. This is one of those game-changer health products that immediately garners a great deal of attention.
At first the claim seems extraordinary, but it is not impossible. It is theoretically possible to drink a substance that becomes deposited in the skin and absorbs or reflects UV radiation providing protection. However, upon reading the details it becomes immediately apparent that the product in question is pure snake oil.
The product is Harmonized Water by Osmosis Skin Care. In fact, UV protection is just one claim among many for the harmonized water line of products. The website claims:
    • Remarkable technology that imprints frequencies (as standing waves) onto water molecules.
    • Advances in the ability to “stack” thousands of frequencies onto one molecule.
    • Revolutionary formula allows us to reverse engineer the frequencies of substances found in nature and/or the human body.
    • Newly identified frequencies that have beneficial effects on the body.
The website does include the “quack Miranda warning:”
Disclaimer: These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
The product list also includes this further disclaimer: “Recommended for (but not meant to replace effective medications):”
And is then followed by a long list of harmonized water products with the conditions they are “recommended for,” including arthritis, irritable bowel syndrome, eczema, asthma, depression, and many others.
Despite the aggressive disclaimers, I do believe that mentioning specific diseases by name violates FDA regulations. I did file a complaint with the FDA but never heard back.
This is a common snake-oil scam – selling “magic” water for one thing or another. The basic idea is that you can give special properties to ordinary water, and that somehow the water will retain these properties. Homeopathy, of course, is the grandfather of all such water woo. Ionized water, imprinted water, and energized water are all variations on this common theme.
The harmonized water is also playing off another common snake oil theme – reference to “vibrations.” There are multiple layers of nonsense in this particular claim. The first is that “standing waves” of specific frequencies can be imprinted onto water molecules. This is nonsense. Waves are just a form of energy, and energy has a way of being conducted away or dissipating as heat. If you did vibrate water molecules that would just heat the water, and then of course that heat would equilibrate with the environment according to the laws of thermodynamics.
The very basis of these claims, therefore, does not make any sense in terms of physics or chemistry.
But then they go on to claim that specific frequencies have been linked to specific medical conditions. So, asthma can be treated, they claim, by drinking water allegedly imprinted with one or more frequencies. This is incoherent nonsense with no basis in physiology or medicine. What is the “frequency” of asthma?
If the claims being made by this company were true, then the “founder and formulator” Dr. Ben Johnson would be up for several Nobel Prizes, in physics, chemistry, and medicine. It’s a huge red flag when a company claims to have made a remarkable breakthrough, especially when their claims require several remarkable breakthroughs simultaneously.
Another red flag is when such breakthrough claims are made in the complete absence of a scientific paper trail. Where are all the published research papers establishing the fundamental claims of this new stunning medical technology?
There is a tab for “research” on the Osmosis website. There you will find this:
Please note, customers must first complete the registration form and be approved. This is a necessary precaution taken in order to protect our customers. Once approved, you will have access to purchase and view professional only content. Approval generally takes 1-2 business days. You will receive an email once your account has been approved.
So I have to register and possibly pay for the privilege of looking at published scientific research? Why not just provide references I can look up myself? Apparently they are just protecting me from something. I wonder what that could be.
Conclusion
The Daily Mail completely failed in its reporting of this item. They missed the real story – the peddling of blatant snake oil with unsubstantiated claims. The UV protection is also just the tip of the iceberg, just one of many unsubstantiated medical claims.
I think the media could be educating the public to recognize the red flags of dubious products:
    • Make claims that sound too good to be true
    • Claim multiple simultaneous scientific breakthroughs
    • Lack of documented scientific research establishing basic principles
    • Use of technobabble that does not make it clear what is actually happening
    • Disclaimers that essentially say the claims are not evaluated and you shouldn’t actually rely on the product to do what it says
    • Long lists of many different conditions the product can treat
Those are just the ones relevant to this particular product. There are others, such as claims of a conspiracy to suppress their product or service, reference to ancient wisdom, and claims that the treatments are “all natural.”
A fellow skeptic in New Zealand reported the New Zealand distributor of this product to their Advertising Standards Authority, and the complaint was upheld, resulting in the removal of the drinkable sunscreen from their website. Unfortunately my complaint to the FDA went nowhere and the company is still free to claim that their magic water is “recommended for” a variety of specific conditions and diseases.

Access Consciousness: A New Version of Phrenology?
Phrenology assigned meanings to bumps on the skull. Access Consciousness claims to have located 32 points on the head that store thoughts, emotions, and memories. Is this a new version of phrenology?
Harriet Hall on March 30, 2021
Link
A March 16, 2021 article on the Canadian Broadcasting Company website (CBC Investigates) reported “How a client-therapist relationship left one Nova Scotian feeling more hurt than healed”. You can read it by clicking on the hyperlink, but it’s a bit long, so here’s a brief summary:
Eileen Carey’s social work registration was revoked in 2020 after 2-year investigation. A client named Taron sought her help to recover from a complex post-traumatic stress disorder. Four years later, he was having sleepless nights, thoughts of suicide, and marital problems, all of which he ascribed to sexualized harm by the therapist. After investigating complaints about her professional misconduct, the Nova Scotia College of Social Workers (NSCSW) permanently revoked Carey’s registration. Taron described hugs, social contacts, inappropriate touching, inappropriate sharing of the therapist’s personal information, and visits to the therapist’s home for sessions of touching where they alternated lying on a massage table (the therapist said they were “energy buddies” and were practicing Access Consciousness techniques). He developed romantic feelings for Carey which he disclosed to her and which she did not discourage. After numerous social encounters, gifts, and thousands of text messages, Taron eventually realized the relationship was unbalanced and was harming him. He ended contact with the therapist and filed a complaint. The disciplinary decision found that she had failed to maintain professional boundaries, was guilty of professional misconduct and incompetence, and had breached the standards of practice and the code of ethics.
It’s quite a story, but the thing that stood out to me was the therapist’s belief in Access Consciousness and her promotion of it. She persuaded Taron to spend thousands of dollars on online courses and in-person workshops.
What is Access Consciousness?
The article describes Access Consciousness as a practice founded by an American entrepreneur in the 1990s that claims to offer people the tools to change their lives and distinguishes between humans (those who judge others) and “humanoids” (people who have the power to create, change things, and recognize they’re different from humans). 32 specific points on the head are said to store thoughts, emotions, and memories. A practice of touching those points known as “running the bars” is said to clear clutter from the brain and clear negative energies.
The Access Consciousness website says that it empowers people to help themselves, that it focuses on your knowledge about yourself and the world around you, that nobody but you personally can know what truly works for you, that you’re not wrong, and that consciousness can shift everything. It allows you to know that you know. Consciousness includes everything and everyone and judges nothing and no one. You can choose your future. It allegedly offers 7,000 tools and is continuously being created. It is currently available in 170 countries and has allegedly changed the lives of thousands of people over the past 30 years. It has testimonials galore, for instance:
    • I feel expansiveness, space on the inside, a new sense of wonder and the excitement of new possibilities that has been missing for 13 years
    • I used to be unhappy and didn’t know I was unhappy.
    • I used to hate myself
    • It has changed every moment of my existence, from a life of listless drudgery to one of energized delight. I am here! I am here! I am here!
And, not surprisingly, they have a store. It sells expensive mugs, T-shirts, and other items with inspiring messages like “All of Life comes to me with Ease, Joy, and Glory.”
Who thought this up? A video promised to reveal how Access Consciousness was created. I listened to the first 11 minutes of the 58-minute video but that was all I could take. The man who developed Access Consciousness explains that he was a channeler. He channeled Rasputin (I wondered whether Rasputin spoke English, or the channeler understood Russian). The points on the head and the idea of “running the bars” came from information he obtained through channeling. I stopped listening because I realized it was not going to tell me anything useful.
Conclusion: No comment.
I will leave it to readers to draw their own conclusions.

Multiple Chemical Sensitivity: Separating facts from fiction
Does multiple chemical sensitivity exist? The symptoms certainly do, but it’s less clear if they are due to “chemicals”.
Scott Gavura on July 3, 2014
Link

One of the challenges to providing science-based medicine is managing debilitating symptoms in patients who lack a clear diagnosis. If a comprehensive workup on an ill patient reveals nothing conclusive, patients and their health care providers are equally puzzled and frustrated. A diagnosis is seen as giving legitimacy to symptoms, and can be the first step towards defining a science-based treatment plan. Vague or “medically unexplained” symptoms are among the most difficult therapeutic challenges. To patients, the science and profession of medicine has failed to “deliver” and the patient can be left feeling their condition lacks legitimacy. These patients are at the greatest risk for alternative medicine approaches, such as unorthodox diagnoses and treatments. In this world, the lack of objective evidence is no barrier to defining conditions and their treatments. One of the most problematic tactics used is the attribution of these symptoms to conditions known as fake diseases.
A “fake disease” doesn’t mean a patient’s symptoms aren’t real, or that they’re not suffering. Patients aren’t “faking” their symptoms. A “fake disease” means that the difficult work confirming the relationship between specific symptoms and an objective diagnosis is lacking. I’ve written about the fake disease called “adrenal fatigue” before. Steven Novella and Peter Lipson have examined a condition called Morgellons. Peter Lipson and Harriet Hall have discussed “chronic” Lyme disease at length. While different in how they are described, all fit the description of a fake disease. A real disease can be proven false or ruled out: There are objective ways to show someone does not actually have the disease. That’s not possible with fake diseases. They have a number of features in common:
    • A lack of scientific consensus on what the “disease” actually is.
    • A lack of scientific consensus on establishing who actually has the condition (and who does not).
    • Symptoms may be non-specific and common (e.g., headache), and there may be no objective differences from those without the condition.
    • A lack of objective evidence to establish a cause.
    • A reliance on unorthodox or unvalidated diagnostic techniques (e.g., food “intolerance” testing)
    • A reliance on unorthodox, unvalidated, or clinically useless treatments (e.g., colon flushing; dental amalgam removal)
The special pleading for fake disease
A recent series of articles in the medical journal Canadian Family Physician make the case for the existence of “multiple chemical sensitivity”, also known as “idiopathic environmental intolerance” (MCS/IEI), going so far as to call it a pandemic, using the terms “multimorbidity with sensitivities” and “idiopatic multimorbidity”. A close examination of the arguments and evidence presented in the “commentary” is nothing more than a special pleading for the scientific legitimacy of the condition, starting with the argument that we’re all toxic:
Just as accrued toxic compounds originating from cigarette exposure are a well established cause of various health conditions, myriad toxicants originating from many other day-to-day exposures are now bioaccumulating in people and causing a multitude of health conditions.21 To facilitate convenience, comfort, safety, and efficiency, there has been the manufacture and release of many thousands of untested synthetic chemicals over the past few decades. Extensive evidence published in various scientific and public health journals has recently verified that individuals from many population groups have experienced exposure to and bioaccumulation of numerous chemical toxicants from the air they breathe, from the food and drink they ingest, from vertical transmission, from dermal exposure, and from compounds injected or implanted into the body. Furthermore, the emerging field of nanotoxicology, a new discipline exploring the potential biochemical havoc resulting from exposure to some nanoparticles,22,23 has served to bring further attention to the expanding realm of potential toxicants. But just as the exposure problem from cigarettes, which was initially described by Delarue in the 1940s,24 was ignored for many years, the current exposure problem from innumerable domestic and occupational sources is also being ignored by many clinicians despite irrefutable and extensive evidence.
And yet, the author fails to actually present any irrefutable evidence at all. The rest of the column is a selection of cherry-picked citations that paint the picture of a civilization increasingly toxic, with some individuals manifesting an array of vague symptoms. It’s a paper more suited to Medical Hypotheses, rather than a supposedly peer-reviewed journal for primary care physicians:
A foray into the recesses of the scientific literature reveals discussion of a condition called sensitivity-related illness34 (SRI), with description of a credible causal mechanism39 to account for much of the emerging pandemic of multisystem health problems.40 This condition results when toxicant accrual within the human organism—typically from exposure to adverse chemicals—induces a state of immune dysregulation and hypersensitivity resulting in physiological disruption within various organ systems.41–43 The pathogenesis relates to an intriguing phenomenon called toxicant-induced loss of tolerance,41,44 a finding that represents a considerable advance in medical science pertaining to the origins and mechanisms of disease.
There is a notable lack of any reference to a systematic review or even to any objective evidence at all. The literature search described (which includes the phrase “several books”) is laughably non-systematic, and the cherry-picking is evident. A comprehensive literature search would have identified that there is a lack of connection between the exposure to environmental agents and the onset of MCS/IEI symptoms. Furthermore, provocation studies that have evaluated those with MCS/IEI have failed to establish any relationship between active chemical exposure and placebo.
The second column from the same author, a “clinical review”, clearly demonstrates the unorthodox diagnostic approaches and treatments used in patients with MCS/IEI (and also called sensitivity-related illness, or SRI):
A 59-year-old rabbi experienced episodic headache, dizziness, and muscle discomfort beginning in adolescence. Into adulthood, these symptoms became more frequent and manifestations expanded to include episodic vision and hearing loss, inexplicable rashes, memory impairment, ataxia, profound agitation, and eventual blackouts. He also complained of intractable fatigue, insomnia, recurrent wheezing, musculoskeletal discomfort, and cognitive dysfunction.The patient saw multiple physicians, but no physiologic cause for his multimorbidity was identified. Various diagnoses were given, but a subsequent psychiatric assessment conferred a diagnosis of “narcissistic, borderline personality disorder with extreme anxiety” to explain the totality of his presentation. As analgesic, asthma, and allergy medications provided minimal sustained benefit, psychotropic medication was employed but to no avail.
The treatment? Detoxify, of course:
The patient’s presentation was consistent with a diagnosis of SRI. Removal of inciting agents was meticulously carried out. In the early stages, the patient initially wore a filter mask designed to preclude particulate and volatile exposures both indoors and outdoors as required. The indoor air environment was initially addressed through a home inventory and associated high-efficiency particulate air filtration. Professional mold remediation was undertaken and follow-up mold testing was clear. Commercial scents, perfumes, and fresheners were eliminated. Common food triggers such as gluten, casein, refined fructose, nightshades, artificial sweeteners, and flavouring agents were temporarily eliminated from the diet.22With these measures, the patient’s symptoms began to abate steadily and attention was directed to remediating his nutritional biochemistry.49 An organic, traditional whole food diet to minimize further toxicant and pesticide or herbicide exposure was implemented, along with directed supplementation to target specific biochemical deficiencies. With ongoing improvement, elimination of his total toxicant burden was commenced.Amalgam removal employing exposure precautions and safe replacement materials was systemically done by a dental professional.50–52 A saline nasal rinse with sodium bicarbonate was used for 3 weeks to eliminate residual mold from the sinus area, and detoxification measures were used to facilitate removal of residual mycotoxin.53 General measures to facilitate toxicant elimination were undertaken, including exercise and regular transdermal depuration.25,54,55 High serum levels of trans fatty acid were addressed with dietary counseling.
Regular readers of SBM will recognize the treatment regimen as lacking a sound evidence base. So what are the facts of MCS, and what’s actually known about the treatments?
The facts of multiple chemical sensitivity/idiopathic environmental intolerance
MCS and IEI are used to describe a condition with the following general characteristics:
    • Those affected report “sensitivities” or “allergies” to multiple products in the environment.
    • There are recurrent, non-specific symptoms reported to low levels of exposure.
    • There is a lack of objective evidence or laboratory findings that define any specific illness.
Reactions can be quite debilitating to those that report symptoms of MCS – some even wear masks in public (like the one illustrated above). MCS has had many names including “allergic toxemia”, “cerebral allergy”, and “ecologic illness” but is now referred to as MCS, (and IEI), to reflect the fact that any actual sensitivity to any chemical has not been established. The most commonly reported sensitivities are to products like perfumes, scented products, pesticides, solvents, “off-gassing” of products like carpets and plastics. Other contributors include food additives, dental fillings, and sometimes even electromagnetic waves. Candida is sometimes included as a toxin that also causes sensitivities.
The idea of MCS/IEI is not implausible. People could conceivably react in a strongly negative way to small exposures to a chemical irritant. However, scientific investigations fail to show a consistent or repeatable pattern of effects. Reactions to noxious chemicals can vary but usually cause symptoms like headache, fatigue, confusion, depression, and muscle/joint pain. There is no specific set of symptoms that establishes MCS or can clearly distinguishes it from syndromes like fibromyalgia. There are no established laboratory tests that can diagnose MCS. No biochemical model has been shown to cause MCS. Chemical sensitivities have been ruled out owing to chemical challenges that cause symptoms only in the absence of proper blinding. Consequently, the chemicals commonly blamed for MCS have not been shown to actually cause the symptoms of the condition.
MCS is not recognized as a distinct clinical entity in any country (with the exception of Germany and Austria) given the lack of confirmed physical effects and the lack of clear diagnostic criteria. Consequently, a diagnosis is currently based completely on self-reported symptoms.
Despite the relationship between symptomatic findings and investigations, unorthodox treatments offered for MCS range from dietary interventions to supplements and detoxification/desensitization approaches – many of which are described in the paper above. There is no objective evidence that the detoxification strategies purported by advocates improve health or address the problem. Science-based treatments are limited. Given the high prevalence of psychiatric comorbidity found with MCS, a relationship has been postulated, and treatments for conditions like anxiety or depression, with counselling like cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and sometimes drug treatments may be offered.
Position statements and scientific reviews on MCS/IEI
Consensus statements and other documents from medical and government agencies are in no way definitive guides to the evidence. However, they can offer a general overview of the literature, often with discussion of contrary (or unorthodox) perspectives. The most recent comprehensive summary was published in 2010 by the Australian government’s Department of Health and Ageing, entitled “Multiple Chemical Sensitivity, Identifying key research needs” [PDF]. It noted:
    • Insufficient evidence exists in the literature for benefit from any medication, dietary supplements or other therapies despite support for some of the treatments by some clinicians at their interviews or in response to the questionnaire.
    • People with the symptoms associated with MCS run a variable course but for most, MCS is a chronic condition.
    • The basic management involves engaging with the patient and maintaining a long-term supportive relationship whilst encouraging self-management as with all chronic illness.
    • Self-management involves providing the patient with information about the nature of the problems being experienced and guidelines regarding symptom management.
    • Clinicians need to accept the patient’s issues as a debilitating and disabling illness irrespective of whether the clinician recognises or accepts the presence of a specific entity, in order to avoid the patient seeking unnecessary referrals and harmful or costly treatment of unproven benefit.
The appendix to the document contains a summary of the views of governments and professional medical organizations. They include the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (AAAAI) which noted (in 1999) an absence of scientific evidence for any particular mechanism for the aetiology and production of symptoms in MCS and the lack of any immunological or neurological abnormalities in MCS subjects. Causal connections between environmental chemicals, foods and/or drugs and MCS symptoms “continue to be speculative”.
Conclusion: The symptoms are real, the cause is unknown
MCS is a debilitating but subjective condition attributed to exposure to a variety of chemical, biologic and other agents. While it not a distinct medical condition, those that suffer from MCS are heavy consumers of health care, and may devote considerable personal resources to managing their condition. MCS patients suffer – not only from a lack of clearly effective treatments, but also by being prey to purveyors of pseudoscience and quackery. Unproven diagnostic testing is common, particularly among alternative health providers and even medical doctors, many of whom claim a specialty in “environmental medicine” or “clinical ecology”. These practitioners attribute patient symptoms to a disease that doesn’t exist. Despite the claims by proponents, there are no clear diagnostic criteria for MCS, owing to the lack of connection between exposure to chemical triggers and reported symptoms. There is no objective evidence to demonstrate that commonly used “detoxification” methods for MCS have any meaningful effects. Consequently, there is no credible scientific justification for these treatments. Recent papers published in Canadian Family Physician fail to properly present a science-based perspective on MCS, and, by uncritically profiling pseudoscientific and unproven treatments, do a disservice to patients that suffer from this condition.
Despite the evidence, claims of MCS can be firmly held. Given the lack of objective symptoms and diagnostic criteria, science-based treatment focuses on active collaboration with patients to acknowledge symptoms, rule out serious medical issues (including objective physical illness), improve self-management techniques, and address any other conditions. As science-based practitioners, the best we may be able to offer is to treat with compassion, give facts instead of false hope, and equip our patients to identify and avoid quackery and their purveyors.

Bach Flower Remedies
Harriet Hall on May 22, 2012
Link
May is the month associated with flowers, so I thought it would be timely to look at flower remedies. You may have heard of “rescue remedy” or other Bach flower remedies. (The preferred pronunciation is “Batch,” but it’s also acceptable to pronounce it like the composer.) They contain a very small amount of flower material in a 50:50 solution of brandy and water, and are said to work by transmitting a vibrational energy through the memory of water (not the same as homeopathy, but equally implausible).
Bach was trained as a homeopath and even created some bacterial homeopathic nosodes, but then he branched out. He used his intuition to access a psychic connection to plants. He would hold his hand over different plants to see which one affected his emotional state, and he would collect the dew from that plant to use as a remedy.
The Remedies
A facsimile edition of Bach’s 1936 book The Twelve Healers is available free on the Internet. It makes interesting reading. It starts off:
From time immemorial it has been known that Providential Means has placed in Nature the prevention and cure of disease, by means of divinely enriched herbs and plants and trees. The remedies of Nature given in this book have proved that they are blest above others in their work of mercy; and that they have been given the power to heal all types of illness and suffering.
I have no clue what he means by “proved.” He offers no evidence of any kind, not even testimonials. The book explains how to prepare flower essences by exposure to sunlight or by boiling, and lists the remedies and their indications under 7 headings:
    • For fear
    • For uncertainty
    • For insufficient interest in present circumstances
    • For loneliness
    • For those over-sensitive to influences and ideas
    • For despondency or despair
    • For over-care for welfare of others.
You see, the nature of the disease is immaterial. The mind shows the onset and course of the disease, and the outlook of mind is all you need to consider. Heal the mind and the body will heal itself. He isn’t just offering to affect psychology: he promises to cure all that ails you. The book was advertised as “An explanation of the real cause and cure of disease.” The “12” in the title refers to the original 12 remedies. Discovery of 26 more “completed the series.” He doesn’t explain how he knew the series was complete. I can only guess that a little flower told him.
As a specific example, he lists larch under “For despondency or despair” with the criteria:
For those who do not consider themselves as good or capable as those around them, who expect failure, who feel that they will never be a success, and so do not venture or make a strong enough attempt to succeed.
The descriptions sound more like personality types in astrology than like temporary manifestations of illness.
The Evidence
Bach died of cancer at an early age, but his supporters explain that “he died of exhaustion rather than of the disease itself.” The Bach Centre is carrying on his work. They say,
We don’t see it as our role to ‘prove’ that the remedies work, then — instead we simply demonstrate how to use them and let people prove the effect on themselves.
Nevertheless, they point to a summary of the evidence base, and to one double-blind trial of rescue remedy that is far from persuasive. I also found a study by 2 Italian geologists who used the remedies to enhance the inherent properties of rocks. I confess I couldn’t force myself to read that one.
The indefatigable Edzard Ernst did a systematic review of randomized clinical trials as of 2010, concluding that the most reliable trials did not show any difference between flower remedies and placebos. A search of PubMed found a couple of other reviews in CAM journals, one negative and one (a retrospective case-study analysis) claiming that flower essences had value in getting patients to open up about their issues.
People Actually Believe This Rubbish
They offer training courses in over 40 countries worldwide to become a qualified Bach practitioner and they provide extensive lists of qualified practitioners in over 60 countries. I looked at the website of one who practices near where I live. Karen practices Bach Flowers Essence therapy and she has lots of testimonials from grateful clients. She offers a consultation in person, by phone, or by Skype for $65, which includes a bottle of remedies and shipping. She also practices crystal healing (to balance the energy in the etheric body) and energy therapy and quotes Dr. Oz as saying energy medicine is the next big frontier in medicine. A website selling Bach remedies crows “Dr. Oz recommend Rescue Remedy for stress.” Thanks, Dr. Oz, for muddying the waters. 
Hilariously, the Bach Centre gives this answer to a FAQ about using dowsing and applied kinesiology to select remedies:
[they can] introduce a barrier… [they will] go straight to the heart of the problem before the client is necessarily ready to go that far. This means that self-knowledge, which is one of the aims of treatment with the remedies, is never attained properly.
They insist that it is essential to select remedies by the classic interview technique prescribed by Dr. Bach.
There is even an offshoot Down Under: Australian bush flower essences. Just meditating on Bach remedies is said to be helpful Just chant OM HUM NAMAHA. The naturopathic Bastyr University teaches Bach flower therapy and even sells a book about flower remedies for animals. 
Apparently the usually CAM-friendly NCCAM is not convinced: I couldn’t find any mention of Bach remedies on their website. The usually reliable Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database wimps out with a noncommittal
There is insufficient reliable information available about the effectiveness of Bach flower remedies.
The Cochrane Collaboration has not studied flower remedies, but it lists them among acceptable topics for funding.
At Least They’re Safe
These remedies are unlikely to cause any adverse reactions, since there’s so little of anything in them. What if you are allergic to the flower? No worries! 
The Essences do not contain any material substance deriving from the Flowers; thus they contain no allergens. They carry only the energetic information of each Flower.
The one thing that might have any real effect is the brandy used to dilute them, but a patient is unlikely to ingest enough of it to have much of an effect. I wonder if they might be dangerous for patients on Antabuse who are warned to avoid alcohol in any form, even in colognes and aftershave lotions.
Conclusion
This is all just too silly. But on second thought, nothing has ever proved too silly for people who want to believe. The term “bloomin’ idiot” comes to mind, but these people are not idiots, they’re just misguided. It’s depressing. They would probably tell me I should take a flower remedy for despair. I’ll pass.

Kambo: Frog Poison for Health?
The Kambo fad: people are applying frog poison to burns created on their skin, making them vomit repeatedly and feel terrible. They think this torture has health benefits. There’s no evidence that it does anything but poison them. Could anything be more ridiculous?
Harriet Hall on January 5, 2021
Link

2020 was a terrible year in many ways. Sometimes I felt like the whole world was going crazy. I was feeling more optimistic about 2021; but on January 1, 2021, The New York Times started off the New Year with an article that reminded me that there was still a lot of craziness in the world of alternative medicine, maybe more than ever.
The Amazonian giant monkey frog secretes poison from its skin when it feels threatened. Long used by Amazonian tribes to treat various illnesses, increase stamina, induce abortions, and ward off bad luck, kambo has become a New Age fad in the US. People who take it vomit repeatedly and feel worse than they have ever felt before. Afterwards, they say they feel as if they have been cleansed both physically and psychologically. Many choose to repeat the experience multiple times.
The ceremony
A ceremony in Berkeley, California, is described that costs $150. Attendees are instructed to prepare with a 3-day cleanse, eliminating sugar, alcohol, pharmaceuticals, meat, gluten, and dairy. The ceremony environment features Eastern prayer cards, crystals, sage, and meditative music. Powdered tobacco is blown up the nostrils, making you feel “like you’ve been pleasantly electrocuted”. Next, a drop of sananga, an Amazonian plant extract, is put into the eyes, described as feeling “like you’re burning your cornea”. The frog is captured, restrained, and essentially tortured to make it feel threatened so it will secrete drops of poison from its skin. Animal cruelty? Does the SPCA know about this? A glowing ember is used to produce tiny burns on the person’s skin, the blisters are wiped away, and a kambo-treated stick is applied to the open wounds. Within minutes, there is a flood of adverse effects: rapid heart rate, headache, flushing and swelling of the face (known as “frog face”), diarrhea, and profuse vomiting.
The claims
According to Wikipedia, kambo is used to purge toxins and psychological traumas from the body; to treat addiction, depression, and chronic pain; to reduce fevers, increase fertility; to boost energy and physical strength; and to improve mental clarity. It is also claimed to remove negative energy and cleanse the soul and body. Testimonials report feelings of invincibility, superpower immunity, purging of internalized anger from a divorce, feeling lighter, having fewer migraines, “a quietness in my soul”, and more.
The Psychedelic Times lists even more uses, including cancer, infections, Alzheimer’s, and Parkinson’s disease.
The evidence: There isn’t any
Kambo has never been tested in clinical trials, and there is no evidence to support the claims. It is a poison with no known benefits and is reported to have caused numerous adverse reactions, hospitalizations, and even several deaths.
This all sounded so monumentally silly that at first I thought it must be a spoof, but a little research convinced me that the kambo fad is very real. Its use is reported by several reputable news sources, it has its own Wikipedia page, and even has its own professional organization, the International Association of Kambo Practitioners, that claims to have trained over 400 practitioners.
Conclusion: It’s poison, not medicine
If putting frog poison in open wounds isn’t the worst idea alternative medicine has ever come up with, I don’t know what is. It deserves some kind of award: for quackery? Frogs croak, and croak translates into German as das Quaken, which sounds similar to quackery. Or perhaps we should call it ribbetry? Whatever. Kambo is not what it’s “quacked up to be”, although the descriptions of the tortures inflicted on frogs and humans are as “ribbeting” as any horror story. I strongly recommend you “froget” about trying kambo.
But as the New York Times article pointed out,
The idea of a body-shaking cleanse through projectile vomiting seems like an oddly appropriate response to a toxic year.

Ground Glass Is Not a Poison
Some people think you can murder someone by putting ground glass in their food. That’s a myth.
Harriet Hall on September 29, 2020
Link


Don’t believe everything you hear.
I recently watched an old episode of Midsomer Murders where the corpse was dead but the pathologist was dead wrong. An individual had died while on a trip to China and the body was sent home to the UK for burial. When he exhumed the body and did an autopsy, the pathologist found ground glass in the stomach. He said feeding ground glass to victims was an old Chinese method of poisoning and concluded that the death was a murder.
I knew that ground glass is not a poison, and eating it is not deadly. That myth has even been debunked on Snopes. I thought ground glass poisoning was widely known to be a myth, but my husband was watching the episode with me and I was surprised when he said he thought it was true. I figured if he believed it, lots of other people probably did too, so I thought it would be useful to set the record straight.
Australia’s “Dr. Karl” (Karl Kruszelnicki) also wrote an article debunking the myth. He points out that if the glass is not finely ground, the person eating it will notice sharp particles in the food and will stop eating it. If it is finely ground, ingesting it is as harmless as ingesting sand. Back in 1642, the physician Sir Thomas Browne fed ground glass to dogs and found it did them no harm. More recently, in 1916, a poisoner in New York testified that he had tried to use ground glass to kill people, but it had proved to be useless. The fictional depictions of ground glass murders in books, stories, movies, and television often show rapid deaths with bleeding from various body orifices, but that wouldn’t happen. Sharp particles of glass might lacerate the lining of the gastrointestinal tract, but the bleeding would be slow and likely to result in anemia and fatigue rather than in anything dramatic.
Todd Robbins eats light bulbs; I saw him do it at The Amazing Meeting. He explains that it is not a magic trick, but an old sideshow performance. The lightbulb is very real; he even plugs it in and lights it up before he eats it, to rule out the possibility of a fake lightbulb. He crunches the glass into a fine powder with up-and-down movements of his teeth, carefully avoiding movements that might allow a glass shard to slice into tissue, and then he actually swallows the resulting ground glass. He says he follows a special diet to minimize the chance of harm.
The picture above shows an Indian lawyer, Dayaram Sahu, who has been eating glass for 40 years for fun. He calls it an addiction, and says it is a dangerous habit that has harmed his teeth and health. He is trying to curb his habit and he is not asking others to try it.
You can learn how to eat glass safely by watching this YouTube video. But DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME.
The important lesson here is never to assume any claim is true no matter how plausible it seems, but to always do some fact-checking first. Believing ground glass is a murder weapon may not harm you, but false beliefs can be harmful. If nothing else, knowing that this is a myth might help you win a Trivia Night contest.
Another lesson is not to get your scientific information from movies or fiction; but you already knew that, right?

CAM use leads to delays in appropriate, effective arthritis therapy
A preference to use CAM before seeking medical advice may be harming patients with inflammatory arthritis.
Scott Gavura on November 16, 2017
Link

Several weeks ago I summarized the evidence that demonstrates that when you delay cancer chemotherapy and substitute alternative medicine, you die sooner. Thank you to the tireless Edzard Ernst, who identified non-cancer evidence that demonstrates how choosing complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) instead of real medicine, can cause harm. In this case, the example is early inflammatory arthritis (EIA), and what was studied was the relationship between CAM use, and the delay to initiation of medical therapy. Time is of the essence with inflammatory arthritis, as there are medications that can reduce the risk of permanent joint damage. This new paper adds to the accumulated evidence to show that CAM, while it is commonly thought to be harmless, can indeed harm – not only from direct effects, but also from delaying the initiation of proper, effective medical treatment. 
What is inflammatory arthritis?
Inflammatory arthritis is a term that describes inflammation of the joints (and other tissues). Inflammatory arthritis can include rheumatoid arthritis, and several other conditions. These are often autoimmune conditions, where your immune system treats its own tissues as foreign, and attacks it. Pain, swelling and tenderness are typical with inflammatory arthritis, and a diagnosis is usually based on a physical examination and laboratory tests. There are now many medications that can treat arthritis, ranging from the non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) such as naproxen and ibuprofen, to disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs which include biologic drugs that can be very effective and even put the disease into remission. While inflammation can be treated, joint destruction from arthritis can be permanent, so starting appropriate therapy, quickly, is important to reduce the risk of long-term damage. Today, aggressive treatment early in the course of the disease is considered to be the standard of care, so it is important for new cases to be recognized and referred for specialist assessment as quickly as possible. Barriers to early treatment include patient delays, but also system delays like wait times for referrals. Understanding why patients may not seek treatment is a question that led to this most recent study.
Studying CAM and inflammatory arthritis
Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is commonly used in different cultures, including Asian cultures, where traditional Chinese medicine may even be government-endorsed, despite the lack of evidence to show it is an effective system of medicine. When a group of researchers identified that many patients with a new diagnosis of arthritis had tried CAM prior to seeking medical treatment, they hypothesized that CAM may be delaying referral and medical therapy.
This paper is from Manjari Lahiri and colleagues and was published in the International Journal of Rheumatic Diseases. Entitled “Use of complementary and alternative medicines is associated with delay to initiation of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drug therapy in early inﬂammatory arthritis”, this was a prospective survey of patients with EIA. All patients seen at one of two hospitals in Singapore where they were invited to participate. Patients were included if they had a self-reported symptom of EIA, which was defined as inflammation of two or more joints, not caused by trauma. Patients were assessed at 3, 6, and 12 months, then annually for 3 years. All participants completed a nurse-administered questionnaire on demographic, health and lifestyle factors including CAM use. In this study, CAM was defined as the ingestion of tablets, herbs, powders or drinks purported to have medicinal properties. They could be prescribed (e.g., by a practitioner in traditional Chinese medicine) or purchase over the counter. Acupuncture, therapeutic massage and cupping, when used for the purpose of a therapeutic effect where included in the definition of CAM, while exercise (including yoga and tai chi), physiotherapy, and occupational therapy were not considered CAM. (This is among the more accurate delineations of CAM/non-CAM I’ve seen in a study.)
CAM users delay treatment
For this study, only the baseline (time=0) results were used. Overall, 180 patients were included. The median time from diagnosis to recruitment was 3 weeks. The median age was 51, and 71% of the participants were women. When stratified by CAM use, Chinese patients more commonly used CAM, and oral tablets/powders and acupuncture were the most common forms of CAM. Full details are in Table 1:

The CAM stratification also shows some additional differences between the groups. There are race, language, and smoking histories that are quite different. Note that the duration of symptoms (until rheumatologist review) was 13.7 weeks among non-users and 20.8 weeks among CAM users. That is, CAM users waited almost twice as long to see a specialist, compared to non-users. Not surprisingly, this meant a delay to the initiation of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs (DMARDs). Figure 1 shows the overall difference between CAM users and non-users:
Only CAM use was significantly associated with the time to first DMARD initiation.
CAM use delays effective arthritis therapy
This small study illustrates what appears to be an unfortunate consequence of CAM use: It may be contributing to delays in seeking effective therapies, which may have additional negative consequences. While this study does not show direct harms from CAM use, the relationship between earlier therapy and positive disease outcomes is well established. The authors conclude that patient and public education programs to raise awareness about EIA, and the importance of early treatment, are essential. I would add that continuing to raise awareness of the limitations of CAM, and the consequences of its use, need just as much awareness.

Freud Was a Fraud: A Triumph of Pseudoscience
Frederick Crews has written a reassessment of Freud based on newly available correspondence and re-evaluation of previously available materials. He shows that Freud was a fraud who deceived himself and succumbed to pseudoscience.
Harriet Hall on December 12, 2017
Link
Psychiatry is arguably the least science-based of all the medical specialties, and Freudian psychoanalysis is arguably the least science-based psychotherapy. Freud’s theories have been widely criticized as unscientific, and treatment of mental disorders has increasingly turned to psychotropic medications and effective therapies like cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). Freud’s impact on 20th century thought is undeniable, but he got almost everything wrong. He was not only not scientific; he was a liar and a fraud. A new book, Freud: The Making of an Illusion, by Frederick Crews, may put the final nail in his coffin.
Crews had access to material not available to previous biographers. The extensive early correspondence between Freud and his fiancée, Martha Bernays, has only recently been released, and it is very revealing of Freud’s character flaws, his sexist attitudes, and his regular use of cocaine.
Freud was trained as a scientist, but he went astray, following wild hunches, willfully descending into pseudoscience, covering up his mistakes, and establishing a cult of personality that long outlived him.
His early work in science was scattershot and lacked follow-through. He “deftly criticized premature conclusions reached by others but never crucially tested any of his own hypotheses.” He was lazy, reluctant to collect enough evidence to make sure a finding was not an anomaly; he generalized from single cases, even using himself as the single case. In an early article “On Coca” he demonstrated poor scholarship, omitting crucial references, citing references from another bibliography without reading them, and making careless errors (misstating names, dates, titles, and places of publication).
His advocacy of cocaine
His advocacy of cocaine was irrational. He wanted to justify his own use of the drug, which he took for migraines, indigestion, depression, fatigue, and many other complaints; and he presented it as a panacea. He claimed it was harmless, refusing to see clear evidence that it was addictive. When nasal applications resulted in tissue necrosis, he treated it by applying more cocaine! He used it to treat a friend’s morphine addiction and only succeeded in leaving the patient addicted to both morphine and cocaine. Then he claimed the treatment had been successful! And in his reports, he referred to other successful cases that never existed. There were many instances where it appeared that his own drug use affected his judgment.
He published a scientific study on the physiological effects of cocaine on reaction time and muscle strength. His only experimental subject was himself! In his write-up, he first tried to explain away his failure to test other subjects, and then claimed he had confirmed his results by testing colleagues, which was a lie. The study was riddled with other methodological flaws, and Crews comments that it “may rank among the most careless research studies ever to see print.”
Charcot and hysteria
Freud spent several months at Charcot’s Salpêtrière hospital in Paris. Another observer, Delboeuf, spent only a week there and quickly realized patients were being sadistically abused and coerced into stereotyped hysterical performances through hypnosis, strong suggestion, peer pressure, and other influences. Freud saw the same evidence Delboeuf saw, but his hero worship of Charcot and his need to ingratiate himself with his mentor made him blind to what was really going on. He believed Charcot had understood and mastered hysteria. Crews comments, “Every stage magician hopes that his audience will consist of precisely such eyewitnesses as Freud.”
Before specializing in the treatment of hysteria and neuroses, he practiced general medicine and neurology. He practiced useless electrotherapy for at least two years and may have continued using it even after he realized it was bogus. But later he claimed to have “soon” realized it was placebo and to have promptly stopped using it. He sent patients to spas for immobility and fattening regimens. He prescribed hydrotherapy. He steered patients to a gynecologist who treated hysterical women with surgical procedures like hysterectomy and excision of the clitoris. He put patients in needless jeopardy, acting on impulsive, sometimes fatal misjudgments. He became so enthusiastic about cocaine that he tried it on everything, even on a case of diphtheria that he misdiagnosed as “throat croup;” he interpreted transient symptomatic improvements as cures and failed to do any follow-up. At one point, he admitted privately that he had yet to help any patients.
In the first years of his practice, he was preoccupied with the rank and status of his patients. He came to specialize in a “disease of the rich,” hysteria, which could never be cured and which generated a continuing stream of income. When some of his “hysteric” patients were subsequently shown to have organic diseases, he still maintained that hysteria was part of the clinical picture. He never admitted being wrong, in one case saying his diagnosis had not been incorrect but had not been correct either. Crews says, “He chose to remain deceived even after having been proven wrong.”
Evidence of dishonesty
He treated pampered, rich socialites. His attitude towards them was cynical; they provided a steady source of income by not being cured, and in one case he rushed back to see a patient in the fear that he might get well in his absence. He had little sympathy for his patients; he actively despised most people, especially those of the lower social orders. He was a misogynist who believed women were biologically inferior. He treated his wife abominably.
Few of his ideas were original. He plagiarized. He borrowed ideas from rivals but then backdated them and treated them as his own. His debts to others were originally acknowledged but “eventually suppressed in favor of the specious appeal to clinical experience. ”He was “actively evasive, malicious, and dishonest” in covering up his mistakes. Crews relates many instances where he re-wrote history, changing the story to put himself in a better light.
He made things up as he went along, constantly changing his theories and methods but not making any actual progress towards a successful treatment.
If a patient disagreed with his interpretation, (“No, I’m not in love with my brother-in-law.”) that only strengthened his conviction that he was right. He violated patient confidentiality. If a former patient improved after leaving his treatment, he took the credit. He was oblivious to the dangers of confirmation bias.
The editors of Freud’s letters and other papers were members of his cult and were dishonest. Comparison to the original documents shows that they changed words and omitted passages that they thought would have made him look bad. They “put the most damning evidence under the rug.” For example, “Out of 284 letters Freud wrote to Fliess, only 168 were represented, and all but 29 of them underwent diplomatic and often silent alteration.”
One of the foundational cases of psychoanalysis, the prototype of a cathartic cure, was the “Anna O” case reported in a book by Breuer and Freud. They said she had recovered after Breuer’s treatment, but that wasn’t true. In fact, she got worse and was hospitalized. After leaving psychoanalytic treatment, she improved on her own and eventually led a successful life as an activist opposing the sex trade. (This was interpreted in psychoanalytic terms as a means of unconsciously wishing to prevent her mother from having sex with her father!) She probably didn’t even have a psychiatric illness, but rather a physical, neurologic one, and many of her most troubling symptoms were caused by the morphine addiction Breuer had inflicted on her. Freud’s interpretation of the case contradicted the facts: he was either lying or venting a delusion of his own.
He found his true métier as a storyteller, using anecdotes from his own case history to illustrate how his mind was “cured” of bafflement over the origin of mysterious symptoms. He described adventures of the intellect. His orientation was more literary than scientific.
Crews says, “Freud was something of a specialist in gleaning precious admissions from people who couldn’t be reached for checking.” His “standard practice was to smear his former associates as soon as they posed an obstacle to his goals.”
Freud’s obsession with sex
He was preoccupied by sex, presumably because of his own problems in that area. His own wife called psychoanalysis “a form of pornography.” He saw everything an infant did as a source of sexual pleasure, from sucking milk to excreting. He was obsessed with masturbation and believed it was the cause of most mental illness. He developed a succession of questionable concepts like virginal anxiety, penis envy, and the Oedipus complex. He decided each hysterical symptom was a depiction of a sexual fantasy; he told one virginal patient that her cough was caused by her unconscious desire to suck her father’s penis.
At one point, he was convinced that sexual molestation in childhood was the cause of adult psychoneuroses. He believed everything patients told him, and even made things up for them and interpreted their dreams as distorted evidence of actual events. He failed to distinguish their fantasies from his own, even believing they had telepathically transmitted their thoughts to him. He thought his neurotic patients had repressed their memories of abuse, which he tried to bring to light. At first he thought nursemaids and governesses were the abusers, then he came to believe fathers were the abusers. Eventually he realized some of the stories about fathers were too outlandish to be real, so he switched gears. He decided patients were merely fantasizing about sex with fathers because of an Oedipal repressed yearning for paternal incest, or because they were trying to cover up the auto-erotic activities of early childhood sexuality. Some of the fantasies were bizarre, like an account of female circumcision where the little girl was forced to eat her own labia after it was excised. This prefigured the repressed memory witch-hunt of the 20th century, with its many false accusations of child molestations and Satanic ritual abuses. At one point he entertained the possibility that he had forced daydreams of molestation upon his patients, but then quickly rejected the idea.
When he thought he could get away with it, he would align details of a case history to support his current theory. He “awarded himself a license to invent, suppress, alter, and rearrange facts in the interest of enhanced self-portraiture and theoretical vindication.”
Off the deep end
One whole section of Crews’ book is titled “Off the Deep End.” Freud developed into a “manic speculator,” who fantasized, interpreted, and guessed. And his speculations were often fueled by cocaine. In a damning admission that his editors suppressed, he once confessed:
I am actually not at all a man of science, not an observer, not an experimenter, not a thinker. I am by temperament nothing but a conquistador – an adventurer, if you want it translated – with all the curiosity, daring, and tenacity characteristic of a man of this sort.
He displayed an expanding grandiosity, saying psychoanalysis was the only possible treatment for certain conditions and claiming impressive successes. In reality, he had not achieved a single cure. He knew his claims of healing lacked any basis in fact, and sometimes he said therapeutic success was not his primary aim; rather, he aimed only to give patients a conscious awareness of their unconscious wishes. He told a friend, “we do analysis for two reasons: to understand the unconscious and to make a living…we certainly cannot help [the patients].”
He claimed that his critics weren’t entitled to pass judgment on psychoanalysis because they didn’t understand it. His criterion for the truth of his ideas was internal consistency, not external reality.
He believed dreams could reveal arcane knowledge and were more accurate than conscious memories. He believed in the paranormal, in numerology, and in occultism.
Conclusion: A bad man, but a good book
Freud was a despicable person with multiple character flaws. He betrayed his scientific training in a tour-de-force of self-deception, succumbing to all sorts of irrational beliefs. His vaunted psychoanalyses never objectively helped a single patient. It is astounding that his ideas and his cult were so influential for so long. Freud was a fraud, a liar, a bad scientist, and a bad doctor; but Crews’ book about him is excellent. Crews’ detailed, well-referenced investigation of Freud’s descent into pseudoscience is a fascinating read. Readers familiar with the development of alternative medicine treatments will find many parallels.

Leech Therapy
Mark Crislip on September 2, 2016
Link


Medicine can be aggravatingly slow to change and it can take years for new diagnostic or therapeutic interventions to percolate through the medical community. It can take equally long for old practices to fade. I have tried to follow the dictum of “be neither the first to try nor the last to abandon a therapy.”
But nothing in the real world rivals that of the pseudo-medical world, who follow the dictum “be the first to try and the last to abandon a therapy.”
New, often preliminary, findings are spun into grand diagnostic and treatment plans, especially in the world of naturopathy, where there is a fondness for innumerable one cause of all disease.
And the old is never abandoned, although there is a weird propensity for various pseudo-medicines to combine to produce a new mutant strain of pseudo-medicine. But leeches?
Who knew that leeches were still a thing?
No, seriously, leeches
Leeches have legitimate medical uses, primarily to aid in reattachment of digits and other surgeries where there is vascular congestion. Surgeons can attach the arterial flow much better than the venous but this leads to accumulation of blood due to lack of good venous return. A leech sucks up the accumulating blood and their spit contains an anticoagulant, hirudin, as well as other biologically active products. Much easier to apply than thousands of mosquitos.
I know of leeches from the risk of infection with Aeromonas. I remember opening the refrigerator on the trauma unit years ago and found a bag o’ leeches. Gave me the willies, flashing back to the African Queen, second only to Gone With the Wind as the most disturbing and traumatic movie from my childhood.
But old school uses, from the time of Theodoric of York, as well as new therapeutic mutations, of leech therapy persist.
I came across “Comparison of the effectiveness of medicinal leech and TENS therapy in the treatment of primary osteoarthritis of the knee : A randomized controlled trial” and did a double take.
I have seen leeches used in my hospital after finger reattachment to help decrease blood engorgement in the finger. But osteoarthritis? I would have thought it would have been so Middle Ages. But no pseudo-medicine ever dies.
TENS is transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, a form of analgesia that is likely not all that analgesic. There are many forms of TENS, including high-frequency transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (h-TENS), low-frequency transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (l-TENS), neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES), interferential current (IFC), pulsed electrical stimulation (PES), and noninvasive interactive neurostimulation (NIN). Kind of reminds me of the multitudinous forms acupunctures.
One meta-analysis suggests:
Although the recommendation level of the other ES therapies is either uncertain (h-TENS) or not appropriate (l-TENS, NMES, PES and NIN) for pain relief…
and my goto for analysis of pain modalities, Paul Ingraham’s painscience.com, looked at all the meta-analyses and found that TENS:
…doesn’t look great: five disappointingly non-positive,16 two spankings for back pain and osteoarthritis, and just the one clearly positive review out of seven (which is also one of the oldest and perhaps the least picky).
And concludes:
My official position for now is that it probably works well enough for some patients to be worth trying if you’re desperate…but keep your expectations low. There are solid reasons to doubt that TENS can work well.
Not a ringing endorsement for TENS but a good comparator for another pseudo-medicine. I suspect that there is a general inaccurate belief in the medical world that TENS, like acupuncture, is effective for pain. Relieving, not causing, pain. So if the pseudo-medicine is equal to TENS, then it must be effective.
A tale of two placebos
The problem, of course, is comparing two interventions with no placebo will always show benefit, especially when comparing two placebos.
And the same problem here:
Leech therapy relieves symptoms in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee and is as effective as TENS therapy in the management of osteoarthritis of the knee.
But would you even expect leech therapy, aka hirudotherapy, to work? Leech saliva does have analgesic effects. After all, Charlie didn’t know he had leeches until after he got out of the water. I would be skeptical that a topical application of leech spit would have efficacy in deep joint pain. As one study noted:
There is still no definitive explanation for the pain-reducing effect of leech therapy
There is actually a randomized study that used an artificial leech(!). Patients had one leech treatment, two treatments separated by four weeks or an artificial leech. All three had improvement and not unexpectedly, those with two interventions had a better response. The more theatrical the placebo, the better the response.
As is always the case with pseudo-medical studies, they cannot wrap their heads around the idea that when an intervention is no better than placebo, it doesn’t work:
Leech therapy can reduce symptoms caused by osteoarthritis. Repeated use of the leeches appears to improve the long-term results. We have not determined whether the positive outcome of the leech therapy is caused by active substances released during the leeching, the placebo effect, or the high expectations placed on this unusual treatment form.
The answer is staring them in the face but they can’t see it.
If acupuncture is a theatrical placebo, leeches are would be the Royal Shakespeare Theater of placebo. So no surprise leeches were beneficial in chronic tennis elbow pain in another study with no blinding or placebo.
Although given the complex constituents of leech spit, I am not totally skeptical of their use in pain. And the curious report of a positive bone scan after leech therapy suggests a deeper tissue response to leech spit is not out of the question, although I have seen a variety of positive bone scans obtained during superficial inflammation. It is safe to say that leeches for pain is not a robust literature. But there is a growing literature, as I am sure some proponent will note.
Leeches for pain? OK. Maybe. Given the nature of leech spit it might have been worth a look-see. But outside of musculoskeletal pain?
No really…leeches?
From 2015. This century. Just two years ago. A review on Pubmed suggests leech therapy, based on balancing body humours, yes body humours of blood, bile, black bile and phlegm, is indicated for:
scabies, psoriasis, eczematous dermatitis, chronic ulcers, ring worms, reddish freckles and favus… asthma, acute rhino pharyngitis and spasmodic coryza… and hypertension, migraines, phlebitis, varicose veins, arthritis, haemorrhoids, and ovarian cysts
Because leeches are good for local evacuation of morbid humours to improve illness. But given the growing literature on meridians and qi, I shouldn’t be all that flabbergasted.
Is there any support in the medical literature for leeches? Besides the occasional researcher with the last name of Leech? For the most part no. And there are a lot of researchers named Leech.
There was a useless
open labeled clinical trial study without control group was conducted with 27 patients
that suggested leeches decreased symptoms of eczema, but with such a design no real conclusions can be drawn. The plural of anecdote and all that.
They note one contraindication of leech therapy is:
Patient refusal to undergo leech therapy.
How nice of them.
And leeches are more like us, or at least me, than I had supposed
Keeping leeches in a saucer of fresh beer for some time, makes them active.
IPA or PBR now that their brewery is closed?
Leech therapy is not without complications besides local infections. There is one case of pyoderma gangrenosum, a disease every bit as awful as its name would suggest. Prior exposure to leech spit can lead to allergic reactions and care must be taken to prevent migrating leeches. Ewe. Migrating leeches. The case of the disappearing leech is not a Sherlock Holmes adventure I want to read. Migration is problem that can be cured with a leech condo although I would suggest building a wall and make the leeches pay for it. And to avoid these complications, some have even developed an electronic leech, probably to treat cyborgs. This world is too weird.
And reading the complications of natural acquisition of wild leeches makes the African Queen seem tame. Ocular leech infestations? And recurrent (!) penile self-amputation? There are some things I just do not want to know.
Not surprisingly, the use of leeches for a broad range of disease has become the purview of naturopaths. There are hints on the pubmeds where leeches are used for vertigo, tinnitus, and arthosis.
Plug ‘leech’ and ‘naturopathy ‘into the Googles and you will find Leech Naturopathy, based on Total Flow medicine. At Healthy Life naturopathy leeches are recommended for a wide variety of diseases, including “Infringement of blood pressure”. Leech therapy is available at a number of other naturopathic clinics, although much to my surprise, none in Oregon, ND or otherwise. Given the propensity of NDs to offer unique services to set them apart from the competition, it surprises me that none have latched on to this ancient and natural therapy.
Perhaps it represents a metaphor that hits to close to home.

Cryotherapy: A Layman’s Attempt to Understand the Science
Harriet Hall on July 11, 2015
Link
NOTE: I get a lot of emails asking me whether treatment X is evidence-based or a scam. This one was different. Zachary Hoffman had done his homework and had already answered the question for himself (at least, as well as it could be answered with the existing published evidence). I asked him to write up his findings as a guest post for SBM. This is a great example of how a layman can figure things out for himself using little more than google-fu and critical thinking skills. I hope it will be an inspiration to others who may not have thought they were qualified to do what we do on SBM.

Recently a friend alerted me to something called “Whole-Body Cryotherapy” which has been making the rounds on Facebook and is being promoted by many athletes and celebrities. I had only heard of cryotherapy in the context of freezing off a wart, but I was about to find out there was so much more. She explained that subjecting your entire body to extreme cold (-200˚F!) for a few minutes a day was a virtual panacea, with weight-loss, tissue repair, and beauty treatments as the target market. My limited background in biology hadn’t quite prepared me for understanding why subjecting oneself to cold air could possibly help treat any illness.
For instance, up here in Boston, I ride my bike all winter long, and on a particularly cold day, after a 5 degree ride, no one has commented that I seem particularly trim, or that my face is looking unusually beautiful. Unfortunately, a few days ago while riding my bike, I took a spill and mushed my hand pretty good. However, the cold winter air hasn’t done much to alleviate that pain or stop my right hand from being twice the size of the left. In any case, it seemed to me that I’d have to give this a closer look before I made any comments.
A quick search on Google led me to a website, Cryohealthcare, Inc. The website is aesthetically pleasing and has plenty of information about how this treatment can transform your life. To top it off, there are lots of endorsements from professional teams and athletes. It appears that for about $65 a pop you can subject yourself to unfathomably low temperatures and enjoy a whole-body tingle when you step out (when I was younger I used to jump in the snow and then get into a hot tub, so I get the appeal). A quick scroll down and we see indications for injury recovery, pain mitigation, and athletic performance, among others, followed nicely by the FDA quack Miranda warning.
They helpfully provide us with a full page of research, essential for understanding how this is really a scientific treatment and not just some recent fad (really!). On the research page we are confronted with an impressive page of peer reviewed articles. I pull up the second article in the list, “Ice Freezes Pain? A Review of the Clinical Effectiveness of Analgesic Cold Therapy.” This paper is from 1994, and is a literature review attempting to understand how appropriate cryotherapy is for the reduction of pain related to the musculoskeletal system. The conclusion states:
Cooling (usually of small areas) of the body surface seems an attractive approach to treating musculoskeletal pain and it is often used for this purpose. Unfortunately, there is little scientific evidence to show that it is effective. All clinical studies that have evaluated this modality are severely flawed. Thus, further trials should be initiated to provide the scientific proof of its effectiveness and to test which type of pain responds best.
I could feel a silly smirk forming uncontrollably across my face. Here is the second paper listed and it is concluding the exact opposite of what was being claimed on the previous page. But to be fair, there are nearly 50 others on this page. A quick browse and I found that there are a few positive studies, but they nearly all have severe methodological flaws and small sample sizes. Not to mention that they are dealing with extremely complex subjects such as depression, where citing one paper for clinical applications is totally inappropriate. Further browsing led me to an almost hilarious number of negative conclusions such as:
The analgetic effects demonstrated so far and the high percentage of adverse events observed with this challenging method currently do not support its routine use in clinical practice.
…all changes due to cold were relatively mild.
Based on our results, whole-body cryotherapy at -110 degrees C is not superior to local cryotherapy commonly used in RA patients for pain relief and as an adjunct to physiotherapy.
This last one takes the cake, because it actually considers the exact treatment that the website is selling, rather than attempting to extrapolate from related studies. The most bizarre part is that I found all three of these statements in the abstracts presented directly on their webpage; I didn’t even have to make the effort to sift through the linked PDFs to find them. Honestly, and not surprisingly, it would appear that they were attempting to make this page as long as possible rather than provide any helpful information. It seemed that this was nothing more than another pseudo-scientific marketing ploy to get people to pay money to freeze their butts off. Fortunately, they were nice enough to provide me with all of the evidence against their method right there on their website.
Getting back to that swollen purple hand of mine; as I giggled giddily at the “research” presented on this webpage, I adjusted the ice pack that was helping to control the swelling of my hand… and then it hit me, I’m using cryotherapy to treat my hand. My motivated reasoning kicked into full gear in an attempt to legitimize what I was actually practicing, versus the conclusions that I had reached from reading the research articles. Cognitive dissonance at its finest.
I could come up with justifications: “Lots of sports trainers from professional teams would pay tons of money to ensure their athletes heal quickly… The same athletes that use cryotherapy?” and “It’s different because the ice pack is… You know, different!” But after much struggle to resolve the dissonance, I started to think about what evidence I had that ice packs actually work for reducing inflammation or expediting the healing process. Where did I actually learn this? It seemed it was just something people always told me and I assumed was true. You know, like the way your mother puts rye bread on your elbows to prevent bruising? Of course that only sounds ridiculous because you didn’t grow up with it, but 8 year old me wouldn’t have it any other way. And besides, I can easily rationalize away the differences with the fact that rye bread is inert and ice packs use physics, or something like that. So, now that I’m an adult, one is ridiculous and the other isn’t… Right?
Everywhere I went people had a suggestion about how to help my hand, almost always consisting of some sort of ice treatment. So I found myself with an issue: I’ve got two very related therapies, but I’ve also got two very opposite conclusions about them. To complicate my dilemma, while I do have a science background, my experience with biology and medicine is very much limited. It feels very uncomfortable to question conventional wisdom like this, but I think it’s probably worse to have to live with a constant contradiction.
I started by attempting to find out whether any reputable groups had made a formal statement about the subject. In general, groups such as the American Medical Association, American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, and others are at least a good starting point for trying to form a well-informed opinion and finding an aggregate of reasonable papers on the subject. Unfortunately, there didn’t appear to be much information from any of these groups. General web searches for cryotherapy and inflammation yielded plenty of explanations about how ice numbs the skin and stops blood flow, but the sources were dubious. Further, I questioned how superficial cooling at the skin could have an impact on blood flow in subsurface tissue. I decided to try my luck over at PubMed to see what I could find there.
When I am doing research in my own field of optics, it can be a daunting task to wade through the amount of information that turns up on PubMed. The problem of separating the signal from the noise in a subject that I am wholly unfamiliar with seemed nearly insurmountable. In order to get some semblance of structure, I did my best to narrow down the question that I wanted to ask. In particular, subjective outcomes such as pain can be extremely difficult to assess. The fact that papers on elaborate placebos continue to get published and gain legitimacy seems to verify this and I honestly didn’t expect to be able to sort out any of these subjective outcomes. I tried to focus on objective outcomes such as swelling size and healing time.
Applying the search terms “cryotherapy,” “healing,” “swelling,” “ice pack,” and “inflammation” yielded dozens of papers. The first thing that I found was that there was very little controlled research done on cryotherapy, certainly less than I would have thought considering how much money there is in professional sports. Rather than comparing ice to no ice, a number of the papers that I found consisted of comparing differences in hot and cold temperatures, or applying cold for various time intervals, all with the assumption that icing is beneficial.
Eventually I was able to sort out a number of meta-studies that had exactly what I was looking for. Surprisingly, the conclusions I found were not what I had expected: many of them were totally neutral or even negative. I was able to find one recent meta-study (2012), where the authors concluded[1]:
Despite its widespread clinical use, the precise physiologic responses to ice application have not been fully elucidated. Moreover, the rationales for its use at different stages of recovery are quite distinct. Using cryotherapy to manage acute soft tissue injury is based largely on anecdotal evidence.
Another meta-study from 2004 concludes [2]:
There was marginal evidence that ice plus exercise is most effective, after ankle sprain and postsurgery. There was little evidence to suggest that the addition of ice to compression had any significant effect, but this was restricted to treatment of hospital inpatients.
A study from 2015 concludes [3]:
The physiological effects of cold therapy include reductions in pain, blood flow, edema, inflammation, muscle spasm, and metabolic demand. There is limited evidence from randomized clinical trials (RCTs) supporting the use of cold therapy following acute musculoskeletal injury and delayed-onset muscle soreness (DOMS).
And another study from 2015 finds [4]:
Cryotherapy or icing, as currently practiced, will not likely be successful in cooling muscle sufficiently to have any significant influence on muscle repair regardless of the degree of injury. However, based on studies in animal models, it may be that if sufficient muscle cooling could be achieved in humans, it could actually delay recovery and increase muscle scarring following significant muscle damage.
Furthermore, I found that most studies expressed their dissatisfaction with the overall availability and quality of studies and found that ice therapy isn’t necessarily a clear-cut solution in dealing with muscle injury. I was very confused about how it is possible that such a universally accepted practice could really have such a dearth of evidence behind it.
So there I sat, slowly moving the ice pack further and further from my hand as I considered whether the whole icing after an injury or icing sore muscles theory was wrong. Could this entire paradigm be incorrect and did I just debunk this myth? I think the answer is no, probably not. While many of these papers draw conclusions that are negative, it is important to remember that the authors of these papers almost uniformly complained about the insufficient number of high-quality randomized controlled trials, which precludes reaching a very firm conclusion one way or the other. These are the same deficiencies that have left us scratching our heads when it is claimed that whole-body cryotherapy is capable of curing your depression, based on a single point of “evidence.” It would be totally dishonest to make the opposite claim that it “doesn’t” cure depression based on the same deficient evidence.
Does whole-body cryotherapy work? Does icing a sore muscle help? Maybe, maybe not. There probably isn’t enough high quality evidence to support either in clinical practice and it is dishonest to state otherwise.
While on one hand, I would love to have been able to remove all doubt, it’s all too easy to forget that like most scientific subjects, medicine is extremely complex. In fact, for most subjects that we don’t fully dedicate our lives to, we know so little that we don’t even understand what we’re ignorant of. This often leads us to be overconfident in whatever caricature we’ve created in an attempt to oversimplify a complex subject (i.e. using four sketchy studies to make a conclusion about ice therapy or a few studies to justify whole-body cryotherapy). In our desire to have an answer we often just accept one side of the conversation or the other, without admitting that we just don’t know. By not conceding our ignorance, we allow “conventional wisdom” (whether right or wrong) to triumph over scientific reality.
Just because we’ve put in all this work with no solid conclusion, I don’t want this to sound like a deterrent from learning about and researching a complex or controversial topic. Here I am, a non-expert empowered with the ability to access and consider the latest research on any given subject. And while I have no intention of telling everyone who ices their hand that “they’re doing it wrong,” it is nice to get a handle on how tenuous the evidence is behind this practice. As a member of the public I have an obligation to understand the basic science and know when to hand over the questions to the experts.
Finally, for fear of this being misused, I feel an obligation to point out that this isn’t a call to question everything and demand more research unnecessarily. There are topics, such as vaccines, where the overwhelming consensus is rooted both in a mountain of scientific plausibility and evidence. These conclusions are rooted in decades of high quality studies, from a vast pool of experts in the field teasing out nuances of the subject that I can’t even begin to understand. Further, there are topics that have been put to rest long ago. This also isn’t an attempt to demand for “more high quality studies” on practices such as homeopathy, which are built on a framework of magical thinking and egregiously defy the laws of chemistry and biology. Most importantly, when stepping outside of our own fields, it is critical to understand our limitations and biases, ensuring that our actions follow the scientific conclusions and not just the evidence that we’ve found to support a particular position.
References
     1.  van den Bekerom, Michel PJ, et al. “What is the evidence for rest, ice, compression, and elevation therapy in the treatment of ankle sprains in adults?.” Journal of athletic training 47.4 (2012): 435-443.
     2.  Bleakley, Chris, Suzanne McDonough, and Domhnall MacAuley. “The use of ice in the treatment of acute soft-tissue injury a systematic review of randomized controlled trials.” The American journal of sports medicine 32.1 (2004): 251-261.
     3.  Malanga, Gerard A., Ning Yan, and Jill Stark. “Mechanisms and efficacy of heat and cold therapies for musculoskeletal injury.” Postgraduate medicine 0 (2014): 1-9.
     4.  Tiidus, Peter M. “Alternative treatments for muscle injury: massage, cryotherapy, and hyperbaric oxygen.” Current reviews in musculoskeletal medicine (2015): 1-6.


Anesthesia-Assisted Rapid Opioid Detox
Jann Bellamy on April 16, 2015
Link


Opioids are widely available as prescription drugs for pain: hydrocodone (e.g., Vicodin), oxycodone (e.g., OxyContin, Percocet), morphine (e.g., Kadian, Avinza), and codeine. Heroin, which has no medically approved use, is also an opioid. Unfortunately, opioids are also widely abused.
How enticing it is to imagine a magic bullet for opioid drug addiction. Addiction causes huge social problems. Yet it is hard to treat and suffers from a stigma that does not attach to other chronic diseases, like diabetes. Drugs like naltrexone, methadone and buprenorphine, as well as behavioral therapies, are common opioid addiction treatments, although the relapse rate for addiction treatment is high.
One of the barriers to treatment is the addict’s fear of the side effects of withdrawal, which can be extremely uncomfortable, including nausea, cramping and vomiting. It is no wonder, then, that the opioid addict and his family would be drawn to a detoxification procedure advertised as both rapid, to speed up the initiation of relapse-prevention therapy, and relatively painless: anesthesia-assisted rapid opioid detox (AAROD), sometimes called ultra-rapid detox, or even just plain rapid detox, although the latter also refers to detox under lighter sedation.
Several clinics in the U.S. offer AAROD, claiming it is safe and effective. A more sober analysis by responsible medical authorities doesn’t agree. In fact, AAROD can be extremely dangerous and appears to be universally rejected by experts who actually waited to see what they evidence would say before coming to a decision.
The overwhelming evidence against AAROD
Concerns about the procedure were published in the medical literature as early as 1997. As reported in JAMA, clinics were advertising AAROD as virtually painless opiate detoxification achieved in hours rather than days or weeks, even though
many addiction experts say that until claims of superior relapse rates for the ultrarapid detoxification methods are proven and concerns about the potential risks are allayed, the procedure should be considered experimental.
A Cochrane Review, in 2001, concluded that managing withdrawal by administration of opioid antagonists under anesthesia should be regarded as “experimental with both risks and benefits remaining uncertain.”
The California Society of Addiction Medicine was asked by an insurance company to evaluate AAROD. (Their report is undated, but appears to have been issued between 2001 and 2006). Their conclusion:
Until its safety and efficacy have been proven, and the procedure has been standardized, AAROD should only be used under research conditions . . . Two components of this procedure, precipitated withdrawal and anesthesia, are known to have risks that are not present in the more commonly used detoxification and withdrawal treatments. Any benefits of the procedure have not yet been shown to be worth these added risks.
“Precipitated withdrawal” refers to reports from clinicians that patients doing well in drug treatment had been targeted by AAROD clinics. They went through the procedure, lured by the idea that they could go to sleep and “wake up clean,” yet subsequently relapsed.
Based on the available evidence, the American Society of Addiction Medicine issued a policy statement in 2005, finding AAROD “not supportable until a clearly positive risk-benefit relationship can be demonstrated.” (Oddly, the procedure was approved, under certain conditions, by the ASAM as late as 2000, according to a Los Angeles Times story, even though it had not been adequately studied at that point.)
In 2006, two reports were published in the medical literature that should have sealed AAROD’s fate. A Cochrane Review updated previous Reviews (2001 and 2002). This time it said, flat out, that
Given that the adverse events are potentially life-threatening, the value of antagonist-induced withdrawal under heavy sedation or anaesthesia is not supported. The high cost of anaesthesia-based approaches, both in monetary terms and use of scarce intensive care resources, suggest that this form of treatment should not be pursued.
Researchers at Columbia University Medical Center’s Clinical Research Center conducted a randomized clinical trial (blinding wasn’t possible), funded by the National Institute of Drug Abuse (NIDA), comparing AAROD for heroin detox with traditional detox approaches. The researchers concluded, as reported in JAMA, that AAROD patients suffer withdrawal symptoms as severe as those of patients treated with traditional methods. Post-detox treatment outcomes were no better for AAROD.
Three patients receiving AAROD suffered serious adverse events related preexisting medical conditions the patients failed to disclose to researchers. This gave rise to a concern that AAROD patients would conceal medical conditions that might disqualify them for treatment due to the allure of painless, yet effective, detox.
After the study was released, Dr. Ivan Montoya of NIDA’s Division of Pharmacotherapies and Medical Consequences of Drug Abuse, concluded:
We now have several rigorous studies indicating that anesthesia-assisted detox— a costly and risky approach—offers no advantage over other methods.
Even if you weren’t convinced in 2006, warnings about AAROD continued to pile on. The U.K.’s National Institute for Healthcare and Excellence 2007 Guidelines warned against AAROD as well. Yet another Cochrane Review, in 2010, reached the same conclusion as in 2006.
Based on a serious adverse event rate of 9.3% at one New York City clinic offering AAROD, in 2012, the New York State Department of Health, the New York Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services, and New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene jointly issued a Health Alert informing New York health-care providers of AAROD-associated serious adverse events and recommending that they avoid use of AAROD in favor of evidence-based options for opioid dependence treatment. All adverse events required hospitalization and there were two deaths. There is no standardized AAROD procedure, but that used by the clinic was consistent with AAROD offered at other clinics: general anesthesia with intubation continued for a median duration of 8.3 hours, and the median time for administration of the opioid antagonist was 3.9 hours.
This, in turn, resulted in a CDC Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (September 27, 2013) warning that AAROD should be avoided.
So, as early as 1997 there were concerns in the medical literature. By 2006, the evidence was clear that AAROD carried serious risks and offered no benefit over other methods. As of 2015, the jury is in: don’t use AAROD. In fact, it is hard to imagine who else might be left to come out against it.
Evidence v. money
But never let the evidence get in the way of making money. Several clinics around the country still offer it.
For example, Houston Rapid Detox, in Texas, administers naltrexone while the patient is under anesthesia lasting 4-6 hours. The results? According to their website:
Once patients wake up, they are no longer physically dependent on opiates and they are unaware of the withdrawal that occurred during the procedure.
Although the website mentions complications at “other” clinics, they say this was due to improper procedure. While they say that “thousands” have benefitted, no research is cited in support of their claims for the safety and efficacy of their services. They even claim that traditional drug addiction treatment is itself unscientific and that they are among the few who understand addiction’s true nature. Again, they offer no research to support their allegedly novel theories. The website, as far as I can tell, doesn’t even say who is on the medical staff.
Midwest Rapid Opiate Detoxification Specialists, in Illinois (there is an affiliated center in Dallas as well), makes similar claims of safety and efficacy, without citing any supporting evidence. (Testimonials , yes; evidence, no.) It is as if the information discussed above doesn’t exist.
Anesthesia Assisted Rapid Opiate Detoxification (AAROD) is a safe and effective method to rapidly detoxify the body at the receptor level of active opiates. AAROD detoxifies the body of active opiates in 6 hours or less under the medical care of an anesthesiologist and skilled nurses. The AAROD procedure is safely conducted in a clinically equipped medical/surgical area by staff trained and experienced in the AAROD procedure.
This claim – that offering AAROD in a properly staffed and equipped facility is safe – is common among AAROD clinics. It may be true that it is safer, but that doesn’t mean it is safe and doesn’t address effectiveness. The 2006 JAMA study employed AAROD in a “safe” facility, but it made no difference in the study’s recommendations.
Interestingly, Midwest claims that:
Our ASAM (American Society of Addiction Medicine) trained physicians are directly involved in the individual care of each patient.
They either don’t realize, or don’t want to admit, that ASAM’s own policy statement advises against the use of AAROD.
A Beverly Hills rapid detox facility uses the “Waismann Method,” which is
a pioneering opiate treatment based on a safe and proven protocol that utilizes the most advanced medical techniques available.
Again, no research is cited. I did find Dr. Waismann, who has treatment centers in Israel and Switzerland, and his claims that his
ANR Method (Accelerated Neuroregulation) reverses both the opiate dependency and its symptoms. ANR reverses dependency on Heroin, Methadone, Suboxone, Subutex, and prescription opiate medications using an effective, safe, and humane treatment.
I cannot find anything in PubMed about him or his treatment and he doesn’t help me out by citing any research.
My state, Florida, has, or maybe had, an AAROD clinic as well. In fact, it was through an article about Dr. Rick Sponaugle, of Florida Detox and Wellness in the Cleveland Plain Dealer that I first heard of AAROD. Unlike the Plain Dealer’s more thorough article, Dr. Spanaugle was the subject of some credulous media coverage, including a story by Anderson Cooper (sadly, featuring Dr. Sanjay Gupta’s report, which was less than satisfactory, though Dr. Gupta has somewhat redeemed himself since). Dr. Phil actually sent patients to Florida Detox. (The Plain Dealer story contains links, if you can bear it.) The clinic still offers detox, although it is not clear if he is still offering this particular procedure.
Dr. Sponaugle does, however, claim that he successfully treated Cleveland Browns’ player Bernie Kosar’s brain trauma, a service he is now offering to others, as well as treatments for “chronic Lyme disease” and “mold toxicity,” if you get my drift.
If you Google “rapid detox” you’ll find other treatment centers, but we’ll leave it at that.
Why is this even legal?
The question of whether AAROD is safe and effective is settled: it isn’t. Yet, physicians continue to offer it. How can they do this?
Part of the problem, perhaps a large part, is the way we regulate medical practice in the U.S. Each state issues medical licenses under its own terms, which vary from state to state. Generally, once a license is issued, the medical doctor doesn’t have to stop using a diagnostic procedure or treatment until the state board of medicine makes him. And for the medical board to act, someone must file a complaint against the physician. No complaint, no action against the physician’s license. A malpractice suit might result in a monetary judgment, but it won’t cause the medical board to act unless a complaint is filed, although physicians must generally report malpractice settlements or awards over a certain amount, as well as other disciplinary actions, to the board.
There is always the possibility of a ruling that results in a fine, the requirement of additional education, temporary suspension, or other sanctions that fall short of losing a license. (Two rapid detox doctors were suspended in New Jersey. One of them was also suspended in Pennsylvania and had his DEA registration revoked. He is now back in addiction medicine practice.)
Even falling below the medical standard of care isn’t always a cause for discipline. Some states have “healthcare freedom” laws that provide physicians with wiggle room when they want to offer unconventional treatments.
The current system allows physicians to engage in unproven, and sometimes dangerous, practices for too long. There needs to be a way to stop the problem before it starts. I’m not sure what that system would look like, but if you have any suggestions, please post them in the comments.

Leaky Bowel
Mark Crislip on June 12, 2015
Link


We are at a disadvantage. We have to rely on reality to validate the practice of medicine. Anatomy, physiology, pharmacology, chemistry, the basic sciences that made up the first two years of medical school education and a huge chunk of pre-med. And we have to rely on the truth, as slippery a concept as that can be. I can’t just make up a disease or a therapy.
It would be so much easier to not have to worry about reality in deciding on a disease and treatment for people with symptoms.
I came across “Healthy Life: Leaky Gut Syndrome” in my feeds. I am always attracted to exclamation marks! They must mean something important! Or surprising to the author!
It’s called “leaky gut syndrome” and patients say it can wreak havoc on everyday life, but some doctors say there’s no such thing!
Some doctors. Must be that pesky 10% percent or so of obstructionist doctors who don’t recommend Tylenol or Advil.
Judging from PubMed, if you are going to rely on reality and science as your basis for the diagnosis for leaky gut syndrome, it would be more accurate to say that because of an almost complete lack of supporting basic science and few therapeutic clinical trials showing no effect, virtually no physician who has an understanding of the gastrointestinal physiology gives the disease credence.
Which is why is Leaky Gut a disease diagnosed and treated by naturopaths.
A household name in the ND world. Exclamation mark.
If leaky bowel is treated at The Center for Integrative Medicine of the Cleveland Clinic and promoted by Dr. Oz you know there is little legitimacy. The company you keep, birds of a feather, and all that.
What is leaky gut syndrome? The theory is that tight junctions of the bowel break down and food “wiggles though” into the blood stream and interacts with the immune system. Rather than being exposed to its elemental components, the immune system is presented with large chunks of undigested foie gras, Twinkies, Jiff (objectively the best peanut butter) and beer (am I over sharing?) as well as bacteria, parasites and, of course, toxins. These substances then interact with the immune system in dysfunctional ways to cause a host of symptoms and diseases, from diabetes to multiple sclerosis to autism.
Alterations in intestinal permeability can occur in patients with inflammatory bowel disease, sprue and other diseases. But as is often the case in pseudo-medicines the concept is used with less-than-perfect accuracy until:
The topic is further confused by use of the term “leaky gut syndrome” within the lay and alternative medicine communities, and even by some physicians, and claims that this is responsible for a dizzying array of disorders, including chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, allergies, depression, and skin disorders.
The diagnosis is made on the basis of a variety of non- specific symptoms and occasionally as a lactulose-mannose assay:
Remarkably, several internet vendors promoting leaky gut syndrome treatments also provide mail-order lactulose-mannitol assays. Thus, patients may arrive with their own lactulose:mannitol data.
Remarkably. I had to smile. Occasionally real physicians wander into the morass that is alternative diagnosis and treatment and are shocked, shocked, to find inadequate medical diagnosis and treatment. Louie would certainly understand.
Leaky gut is treated with the 4 Rs (a perfect therapy for Talk like a Pirate day):
Remove certain foods. Replace with digestive enzymes. Re-inoculate using a high dose of probiotics and Repair with glutamine
All of these interventions are without good support in the scientific literature or clinical trials that I could find. Glutamine to treat leaky bowel, as an example, has zero hits for clinical trials. Not even a bad case report or series in a low impact journal. For SCAMs that is remarkable. Usually there is at least a horribly done clinical trial or some case reports to support pseudo-medical interventions. I have been looking at SCAMs for years and it is rare to find so little supporting information for a therapy.
…the leaky gut cures being sold at a variety of internet sites and alternative medicine stores should be considered with caution. None have been tested in randomized clinical trials, and they may do more harm than good.
As is noted:
Leaky gut symptoms aren’t unique. They’re shared by other problems, too. And tests often fail to uncover a definite cause of the problem. That can leave people without a diagnosis and, therefore, untreated.
It’s crucial, Kirby says, to find a doctor who will take time with you and take your concerns seriously.
Take your concerns seriously, yes, but not necessary agree with the diagnosis of leaky gut.
As I have mentioned in the past, I never deny that a patient is suffering or claim that their suffering is not real. I am also not a fan of psychosomatic illness, although I have no doubt that the there is some interaction between the brain and a variety of symptoms.
Still, I wonder if patients who seek care from pseudo-medicine providers respond differently to their symptoms. It has always been curious to see how people with ostensibly-identical illnesses respond differently.
Perhaps those seeking care for their leaky gut and other pseudo-diagnoses are different, but not with their gut.
IM (Integrative Medicine) patients reported higher levels of perceived stress, pain, and depressive symptoms, and lower levels of quality of life compared with national norms. Per provider reports, 60% of patients had at least one of the following: stress (9.3%), fatigue (10.2%), anxiety (7.7%), depression (7.2%), and/or sleep disorders (4.8%). Pain, having both physiological and psychological components, was also included and is the most common condition treated at IM clinics.
And how much of these diseases are taught to the patient by both the culture and the pseudo-medical provider? Is leaky gut or chronic Lyme and response to therapy partially a learned response? I came across a recent a PLOS-ONE article “Multi-Acupuncture Point Injections and Their Anatomical Study in Relation to Neck and Shoulder Pain Syndrome (So-Called Katakori) in Japan.”
Katakori is a symptom name that is unique to Japan, and refers to myofascial pain syndrome-like clinical signs in the shoulder girdle.
Katakori is a culture-bound syndrome. There are quite a few other culture-bound syndromes, ranging from fan death to koro to bouffée délirante. People may have unique reactions to stress and other symptoms that are culturally determined and approved.
One of the constant topics of discussion is why these pseudo-medical diagnoses and treatment persist despite a lack of scientific validation. If you put “culture-bound syndrome” into Pubmed there is very little concerning US culture-bound syndromes, the references mostly concern the process in immigrants to the US. But there is no reason the US should not have its own culture-bound syndromes.
To quote the Wikipedia:
A culture-specific syndrome is characterized by:
     1.  categorization as a disease in the culture (i.e., not a voluntary behavior or false claim);
     2.  widespread familiarity in the culture;
     3.  complete lack of familiarity or misunderstanding of the condition to people in other cultures;
     4.  no objectively demonstrable biochemical or tissue abnormalities (signs);
     5.  the condition is usually recognized and treated by the folk medicine of the culture.
and
The term culture-bound syndrome denotes recurrent, locality-specific patterns of aberrant behavior and troubling experience that may or may not be linked to a particular DSM-IV diagnostic category. Many of these patterns are indigenously considered to be “illnesses,” or at least afflictions, and most have local names. Although presentations conforming to the major DSM-IV categories can be found throughout the world, the particular symptoms, course, and social response are very often influenced by local cultural factors. In contrast, culture-bound syndromes are generally limited to specific societies or culture areas and are localized, folk, diagnostic categories that frame coherent meanings for certain repetitive, patterned, and troubling sets of experiences and observations.
Sound familiar? Chronic Candida, chromic Lyme, leaky bowel, gluten sensitivity, electromagnetic sensitively and many of the syndromes covered by this blog would seem to meet the definition, and are perhaps a good conceptual framework for understanding these processes. I’ll leave that to the anthropologists and psychologists to sort out. This is Science-Based medicine after all, but it is fun to participate in some wild-ass speculation now and then.
Self-aggrandizement
For those of you who were unable to make it NECSS in April, there are now three videos featuring SBM speakers available for your entertainment. I am competitive as all get out and want these videos to be the most watched from NECSS. Get to work.
    • Science-Based Medicine: Beyond Integrated Medicine. Steve Novella
    • How Acupuncture “Works”. Mark Crislip
    • Scare Tactics? The Media Response to Infectious Diseases. This panel features Laura Helmuth, science editor of Slate.com, Dr. Paul Offit, Dr. Mark Crislip, and is moderated by ABC News producer Ann Reynolds
More videos to come.

Self-Deception
Harriet Hall on September 16, 2014
Link

José Jarimba believes that our bodies are physically molded into an asymmetric form by our mothers’ sleeping positions during pregnancy, that this has lifelong adverse impacts on health, and that shoe inserts can eliminate pain and other health problems by realigning the body. This is a silly untested hypothesis by a single individual. As such, it would be too minor to merit mention on SBM; but it is worth analyzing as a teaching opportunity. Jarimba attempts to bypass the scientific process; he provides a prime example of self-deception, confirmation bias, scientific ignorance, and the “Unpersuadables” I recently wrote about.
Much of alternative medicine originated with a “lone genius” who had an epiphany, thought he had discovered something no one had ever noticed before, extrapolated from a single observation to construct an elaborate theory that promised to explain all or most human ills, and began treating patients without any attempt to test his hypotheses using the scientific method. Some of them were uneducated laymen, others were scientifically trained medical doctors who should have known better. I wrote about one of them here, Dr. Batmanghelid, inventor of the Water Cure, who attributed a great variety of illnesses to dehydration after he thought he had cured a prisoner’s peptic ulcer disease by giving him a glass of water. Similar paths were followed by many others. Hahnemann invented homeopathy after he thought a malaria remedy gave him symptoms of malaria. Palmer invented chiropractic after he thought he had restored a man’s hearing by repositioning an out-of-place bone in his back. Nogier invented ear acupuncture after he imagined that the external ear looked sort of like a fetus. Shapiro invented EMDR after she noticed during a walk in a park that moving her eyes seemed to reduce the stress of disturbing memories. Bach invented Bach flower remedies after a walk in the country revealed his intuitive psychic connection to various plants. Jose Jarimba follows in their footsteps.
Jarimba has no medical or scientific training. His epiphany was a combination of two observations: he noticed that a man’s sideburns were asymmetrical and his hair coarser on one side, and he watched a film clip about a fetus. He thought: adults are not symmetrical, and when a mother lies on one side, that puts asymmetrical pressure on the fetus’ body. Eureka! He concluded that the mother’s sleeping position must cause physical deformation, organ deformation and malfunction, and various ailments.
He asked, what do pregnant animals do in the wild? He says that mammals alternate sleeping on one side and the other (Do they? How does he know? Are other mammals more symmetrical than humans?) and birds sleep on their feet because if they lay down their eggs would come out lopsided. (I think it’s because if they tried to lie down on their side they would fall off the branch where they are roosting.) He says pregnant women should sleep equal numbers of hours on the left and right side if they want a healthy baby.
He thinks the process of deformation begins at conception. He blames modern technology. Before we had machines, women worked and exercised. He thinks their fetuses were in an upright position and faced towards the mother. (Really? I don’t think so!) After the development of machines, pregnant women were advised to rest and got help with their domestic duties. Those who worked and were active throughout pregnancy had more symmetrically perfect babies. (Really? How does he know?)
He claims that physical misalignment occurs in proportion to the hours the mother sleeps on one side. 6 hours a night corresponds to 5-10% chance of misalignment, 16 hours to 60-70%. (Who sleeps 16 hours?) I asked him how he figured out those percentages. He explained that a day has 24 hours, and if a mother rests 8 hours a day, that’s 33 1/3%; then divide one inch by 3, and 8 hours equals one third of an inch. I asked where the figure of one inch came from, and he said that’s the measurement of deformity that can be corrected without surgery, and he cited a webpage about congenital hip dysplasia. (None of this makes a bit of sense to me; maybe it will to you.)
If the mother sleeps on her right side, he says it affects the baby’s left side. He seems to be assuming the baby’s left side will be down. The most common presentation at delivery is left occiput anterior, which would put the baby’s left side down when the mother slept on her left side. And the baby’s position is constantly changing. It only becomes fixed when the presenting part engages in the pelvis shortly before delivery; most breech babies turn head-first spontaneously by the 37th week. He thinks the internal organs are affected. He thinks the valves inside the heart can be malformed by fetal position; he thinks they become tilted towards the affected side and that this decreases oxygenation and cause heart attacks. He says resting on one side can cause upper body misalignment and on the other side, lower body misalignment (I asked him to explain how that would work, and he failed to answer.) He says sitting on a chair causes foot misalignment (how would that work if the baby was in the common head-down position?). He says vision is affected by position because the orbital muscles on one side become stretched toward the back of the head. He thinks too much sitting leads to breech deliveries. None of this is plausible; it’s impossible to visualize how gravity and pressure could accomplish those things.
I had never heard of Jarimba before he contacted me and sent me a copy of his book The Human Mold. We had a long e-mail exchange. I asked him what left-sided asymmetry meant and how he could determine which side was the abnormal one. His answer was nonresponsive: “When I say asymmetric from the left side, I mean that the left side is the abnormal side.”
I asked how he knew how many hours a woman slept on one side. He acknowledged that self-reports were unreliable, but claimed he could assess sleeping time accurately by measuring the degree of physical misalignment. He can tell the degree of misalignment from the number of hours, and he can tell the number of hours from the degree of misalignment. I pointed out that this is circular reasoning. He did not comment.
He says most women sleep on their right side “as recommended by the CDC.” He got that backwards: the left side is preferable, although not enough to matter. We know that in late pregnancy, the uterus may press on the vena cava, and lying on the back or on the right side may reduce blood flow; but in a normal pregnancy this is not significant. Women are encouraged to sleep in whatever position they find most comfortable.
He described an experiment he did with 17 women, asking them to alternate sleeping sides and finding that the babies were born more symmetrical. There was no blinding and no control group. When I asked him about that, he said, “I do understand very well that experiments with no control group might reach false conclusions, but in this case, I am proud to announce that my research produced no false conclusions.”
I asked how asymmetry could affect organ function, and he said when the structure is misaligned the weight of the imbalanced fluid pressing on the veins causes the veins to bend resulting in slow blood flow to the organs, heart, head (brain), and to all the body causing major health complications. He says a “tilted” kidney can’t function properly. I don’t believe any of those assertions.
I asked if he had talked to any obstetricians about his theories, and he said no, because he had studied their literature and found “a lack of deep knowledge into the development of our being.” His own lack of even basic knowledge is obvious in the cover illustration he chose to grace his book. It depicts a fetus in a woman’s abdomen. The fetus’ head is positioned just under the breasts at a height not reached even at full term. The fetus appears to be at about the 12 week stage of development and at that stage the uterus should be about the size of a grapefruit and still down inside the pelvis, and the fetus should be much, much smaller in relation to the woman. And the fetus’ position as shown is that of a footling breech, one of the rarest presentations for delivery.
He has treated over 2,000 clients. He doesn’t advertise, but he has an office where he sees them by appointment only. He charges $120, sees them only once, and gives them a shoe insert that he makes himself. He does no systematic follow-up.
He says you can analyze yourself by looking in a mirror, and you can analyze your friends. You will notice that one ear sticks out more than the other, one shoulder is higher than the other, one eye is smaller than the other (he says this is more noticeable at the end of the day), one leg is shorter than the other, one heel is more curved, etc. Once you know which is your bad side, you can sleep on the other side to counteract the asymmetry. He says the blood flows slower on your bad side.
He himself had 52 years of low back pain, foot pain, and overall body discomfort. All of these vanished after he put an insert in his shoe. He has plenty of patient testimonials. Back pain relieved. Back surgery avoided. More energy. Better sleep, more mentally focused, no headaches, no longer get sick. Alternating sleep sides during pregnancy produced a happy baby who doesn’t spit up and sleeps through the night. He apparently doesn’t understand that the plural of “anecdote” is not “evidence.”
He echoes the claims of chiropractors about spinal alignment, nerve interference, and disease. He cites the discredited Winsor Autopsies study from 1921 that supposedly correlated spinal misalignments with diseases of internal organs and concluded that 80% of chronic disease problems are linked to the spine. Jarimba comments that Winsor’s findings “indicate that most human physical deformities found in his autopsies were possibly caused by the mothers of the subjects sleeping/resting mainly on one side during pregnancy.” Winsor’s findings indicate no such thing!
He indulges in a bit of doctor-bashing, encouraging people to avoid dependence on the current health system. He says that reading media reports and visiting a doctor can cause stress and “lower” the immune system. He says overuse of medical care is wrecking your health. He says the mere act of purchasing health insurance may subconsciously prepare the mind and body to allow your health to break down. He says maintaining a positive attitude will help keep you healthy.
I suggested he might be risking prosecution for practicing medicine without a license. He said, “I do not practice medicine. I do not touch people physically.” Yet he is telling prospective clients he can relieve their pain and emotional symptoms, and on this Facebook page his occupation is listed as Family Doctor.
I asked him a lot more questions, but instead of answering, he replied, “I am sorry, since you haven’t witnessed my work in action (live), I see no need to keep on going.”
I eventually got him to answer 3 more questions:
     1.  “Has what I wrote made you question your theory in any way?” “No.”
     2.  “Do you think there is any possibility that you might be wrong?” “No, because it works, and if it works it is OK.”
     3.  “If good scientific studies found that time sleeping on one side was not related to asymmetry, and that your shoe inserts worked no better than placebo, would that change your mind?” “There is not a single possibility of that happening.”
Conclusion
In his book, Jarimba says, “I hope that my observations will one day have a positive impact in the health system and the entire human population.” I think there is little chance of that.
This is yet another sad example of a person who has deceived himself. He has adopted a belief without ever putting it to a proper test, and has been fooled by his own experiences and by confirmation bias. He has a poor understanding of science, of critical thinking, and of the cognitive errors we humans are all subject to. He fails to understand what Druin Burch calls “Medicine’s beautiful idea,” the idea that we can easily be misled into false beliefs and must test even the most apparently obvious hypotheses using reliable scientific methods. Jarimba demonstrates the hubris of a layman who thinks he knows more than the experts, the Dunning-Kruger effect. He demonstrates the closed mind of an “unpersuadable” to perfection. Fortunately, he is only a single crank who has not yet spawned a movement, and what he does is not likely to harm his clients. He may even do some good here on SBM by serving as a bad example.

Pyroluria and Orthomolecular Psychiatry
Steven Novella on February 29, 2012
Link
I have previously written about psychomotor patterning – an alleged treatment for developmental delay that was developed in the 1960s. The idea has its roots in the notion of ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny, that as we develop we progress through evolutionary stages. This idea, now largely discredited, was extended to the hypothesis that in children who are developmentally delayed their neurological development could be enhanced if they were made to progress through evolutionary stages. Children were put through hours a day of passive crawling, for example, with the belief that this coax the brain into a normal developmental pathway. The treatment was studied extensively in the 1970s showing that the treatment did not work.
However, those who developed this treatment, Doman and Delecato, did not want to give up on their claim to fame simply because it didn’t work and the underlying concepts were flawed. For the last 40 years they have continued to offer the Doman-Delecato treatment for all forms of mental retardation, surviving on the fringe, all but forgotten by mainstream medicine (except by those with an interest in pathological science).
I was recently asked to look into the claims for a disorder known as pyroluria, and what I found was very similar to the history of psychomotor patterning. There was some legitimate scientific interest in this alleged condition in the 1960s. Studies in the 1970s, however, discredited the hypothesis and it was discarded as a failed hypothesis. The published literature entirely dries up by the mid 1970s. But the originators of the idea did not give up, and continue to promote the idea of pyroluria to this day.
The story is told by Dr. Abram Hoffer himself, the originator of the pyroluria hypothesis. It started with a reasonable idea – since LSD mimics some of the clinical findings of schizophrenia, perhaps we can learn something about the biology of schizophrenia by studying the effects of LSD on the body. He specifically looked at the urine of patients given high doses of LSD before and after treatment. He found an increase in an unknown substance. As Dr. Hoffer recounts:
At first we called it the unknown substance (US), and later the mauve factor because when developed on the paper chromatogram it stained a beautiful mauve. When it was identified we called it, more accurately, kryptopyrrole. We named the disease characterized by large amounts of mauve factor “malvaria,” but Dr. Pfeiffer later gave it the more appropriate term pyrolleuria.
He goes on to recount how he and his team found kyrptopyrrole in the urine of patients who are physically ill, those with depression and other mood disorders, and schizophrenics, but not in healthy controls or recovered schizophrenics. So far this all sounds reasonable. It was later found that kryptopyrrole excretion relates to levels of vitamin B6 and zinc in the body, and therefore schizophrenics can be successfully treated with vitamin supplements.
There is nothing implausible about nutritional or biochemical disorder presenting with psychiatric conditions. In fact, acute intermittent porphyria (also believed by Hoffer to be related to kryptopyrrole) is a known biochemical disorder that presents as acute episodes of psychosis (the movie The Madness of King George relates the story of King George III’s bouts of this disease). Schizophrenia is a debilitating disease and it would certainly be very nice if we could cure it (or even a subset of cases) with a vitamin supplement. That is not, however, how the science turned out. Unfortunately, science does not always conform to what we wish to be true.
Pyroluria (which has various spellings, but this seems to be the most common in current use) did not survive replication. A number of studies in the 1970s failed to confirm the presence of kryptopyrrole in the urine of patients with schizophrenia or prophyria. For example, Gendler et al found no hemopyrrole or kryptopyrrole in the urine of healthy subjects or schizophrenics. Jacobson et al found similar negative results.
The pattern is identical to what I found when I researched psychomotor patterning, a string of negative studies in the 1970s followed by the complete disappearance from the peer-reviewed literature, except in journals dedicated to the now fringe idea. In this case Hoffer decided that he was not the victim of a failed hypothesis, but rather the victim of a conspiracy of mainstream psychiatry that was simply closed to his revolutionary ideas. He founded the journal Orthomolecular Psychiatry, now the Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine – a fringe journal in which he could continue to publish his ideas.
I also looked for research on the related but distinct question of using vitamin B6 to treat schizophrenia. If there were any clinically significant effect it should be easy to demonstrate in clinical trials. I found a few double-blind studies and they show two things: Vitamin B6 has no benefit on psychotic symptoms of schizophrenia, but it may have benefit for motor symptoms – specifically Tardive dyskinesia and Parkinsonism as a side effect of anti-psychotic medication. So B6 does not treat schizophrenia itself, but may reduce the motor side effects of medications used to treat schizophrenia. Perhaps this effect is what has led to anecdotal observations of improvements in schizophrenic patients from B6.
Hoffer, in his telling of the tale, has this revealing passage:
Since schizophrenic patients, most of whom had the factor in their urine, responded better when treated with vitamin B3, I concluded that any psychiatric disease, no matter what they were diagnosed clinically, might also do better with this vitamin. This was confirmed by a large series of open clinical studies. I will not term these studies anecdotal, which has become the politically correct term for denigrating any studies that are not double blind, since all clinical studies depend upon the history or herstory of patients and how they respond, i.e. upon anecdotes. The only difference is that in double blind studies the anecdotes are collected by physicians or others who are blinded by not knowing what treatment is being given. At least this is the theory of this type of procedure. In fact, the vast majority of these studies are so imperfectly blinded that few clinician or nurses have much difficulty deciding whether the patient was on placebo or something more active.
Worshippers of the double blind remind me of the emperor whose nakedness was seen only by a child not yet blinded by tradition. This report by Kraus is an excellent example of the type of anecdotal history which has contributed so much to medicine.
The denigration of double-blind studies and the holding up of anecdotal information as reliable is a sure sign of someone on the fringe, not wishing to listen to the scientific evidence but rather to pick the evidence they want to use because it better suits their theories. We have discussed the weaknesses of anecdotal information many times in the past. Anecdotes are overwhelmed by bias and uncontrolled factors. At best they can be used to generate hypotheses, but not to test them. We need double-blind studies to see if alleged effects are real. There is a kernel of truth in what Hoffer says in that not all studies reported as double-blind are reliable, and imperfect blinding can be a major, and often hidden, weakness of clinical trials. But he misses the point in his criticism.
First I need to point out that the “only difference,” as Hoffer claims, is not that the physicians are blinded – the subjects are also blinded (hence double blind). This is critical to controlling for biasing effects. But also the point here is that while anecdotal reports were positive, well-controlled double blind studies of pyroluria (biochemically and clinically) were negative. You cannot explain this pattern of results with improper blinding. Improper blinding causes false positive results – not false negative results, so Hoffer’s objections make no sense. The better controlled studies were negative, that pattern strongly implies the null hypothesis, in this case that pyroluria does not exist as a legitimate entity and vitamin B6 is not an effective treatment for schizophrenia (although it may help reduce the motor side effects of medication).
The bigger picture here (as with psychomotor patterning) is that it is a fundamentally flawed and failed strategy to essentially take your ball and leave the playground when mainstream science does not support your theory. I guess this also depends on your goals. If your goal is to set up your own clinic and make money treating patients according to your own pet theories, then certainly you can follow the Doman and Delecato pathway. If your goal is to convince the world that your ideas are correct, however, this is the wrong path to take. If your goal is to find the truth and develop treatments that are actually effective and helpful for patients, this is also not the right path to take.
Hoffer has had 40 years to do more and more rigorous research, to produce the data that would convince even a skeptical mainstream scientific community that his ideas are correct. If he truly believes that he is right, then this is the path that would help the most patients by changing the standard of care. Rather, he formed his own fringe journal and fringe community where he can brood about the conspiracy of mainstream psychiatry and rail against the dogma of rigorous scientific research.

Antipodean CAM
Jann Bellamy on February 9, 2012
Link
It is one of the pleasures of travel to read the local newspapers of places I visit. I wholly agree with In a Sunburned Country author Bill Bryson, who observed,
It always amazes me how seldom visitors bother with local papers. Personally I can think of nothing more exciting – certainly nothing you could do in a public place with a cup of coffee – than to read newspapers from a part of the world you know almost nothing about. What a comfort it is to find a nation preoccupied by matters of no possible consequence to oneself. I love reading about scandals involving ministers of whom I have never heard, murder hunts in communities whose name sound dusty and remote, features on revered artists and thinkers whose achievements have never reached my ears, whose talents I must take on faith.
In a Sunburned Country chronicles Bryson’s travels in Australia, which I recently visited, along with New Zealand. Lovely places both – friendly people, jaw-dropping scenery, delicious food and wine. And a welcome vacation from American political wars, American economic wars and American war wars.
Oh no! Not CAM again!
It was not to be a vacation from “complementary and alternative medicine,” as it turned out. Upon settling into Auckland, I picked up a copy of The New Zealand Herald, which was that very day beginning a series on “alternative relaxation and remedies.”
Today: Greek leech therapy
Tomorrow: Koran jimjjibang
Thursday: Indian ayurveda
Friday: Thai yoga massage
Saturday: Japanese ganbanyoku
I read this in the comfortable surrounds of the Auckland Langham Hotel which touted, in addition to the upcoming Seafood Festival, “Chuan Spa’s Traditional Chinese Medicine Wellness Retreat” via which I could start the new year “revitalized.” Included in this “holistic approach of Chinese medicine” was “a TCM consultation with our qualified TCM practitioner” who would interpret my “state of wellbeing,” followed by “a TCM treatment to restore any imbalance in the equilibrium of Yin and Yang.” As well, I would receive a “Micronised Marine Algae Wrap” [ewww!] to relieve my “muscular fatigue, boost circulation, detoxify and re-balance” my metabolism. All this for just NZ $1,186 per person for the two-day retreat, or NZ $1,746 for the three-day version. I decided to go sight-seeing instead.
But the NZ news media was not content to stop at five days worth of CAM. Even after that steady diet, I still had homeopathy, quantum physics and Vitamin C to go. So it came to be that I followed Kiwi CAM through Auckland, Rotorua, the Tongoriro River, Dunedin, Queenstown, Franz Josef and Christchurch. Although some of the featured modalities were unfamiliar, the rhetoric was not. Nor was the credulous reporting.
The Herald series started out with Greek leech therapy. (The article also reported a survey revealing a majority of New Zealanders believed in “alternative remedies.”) According to Mehdi Jaffari, an Auckland practitioner at Life Clinic Hirudotherapy, the first recorded use of leech therapy was by Greek physician Nicander in 200 B.C. Jaffari claimed the leeches can treat problems ranging from arthritis, diabetes, endometriosis, hepatitis, and “high blood pressure to bronchitis.” And leeches can reduce wrinkles to boot. They are no less than “nature’s gift to mankind to keep us in good health.”
Let’s see. Popularity? Check. Ancient therapy? Check. The one true cure? Check. Natural? Check.
On Wednesday, there was Korean jjimjilbang, which translates literally as “heated bathrooms.” I am all in favor of heated bathrooms but the literal translation doesn’t really do the place justice. We in the “west” we would think of a jjimjilbang as more of a spa. And like U.S. spas, there were outsized claims to go along. Treatment begins in a heated bath, which “circulates magnetic waves,” followed by a trip to the sauna and steam rooms “to flush out bad toxins and promote circulation.” Then there is the room with heated stones (in this case tourmalines) to aid in “skin rejuventation, enhanced circulation and [to] cut body odour.” In other words, it’s Eastern + magnetic waves + detoxification + rejuvenation + circulation promotion + B.O. eliminator. While the rest are familiar CAM claims to fame, I must admit the B.O. is a new one.
On Thursday, a reporter wrote up her visit to a practitioner of “the ancient natural healing system” ayurveda. Apparently, in New Zealand one can go straight to an ayurveda practitioner instead of a “Naturopathic Doctor,” which at least eliminates the fiction that ayurveda has been vetted by a “medical” school and is therefore somehow evidence-based. This practitioner said that ayurveda is “the most holistic health science system in the world.” Science?  I don’t think so. And the most holistic? Are the other systems just partially whole? How can that be?
According to this practitioner:
The human body is made up of five basic elements, and whenever there is any disorder, these elements become imbalanced and they affect bodily channels and tissues, creating illnesses in the system.
[Ayurveda is] about finding out the cause factors responsible for the imbalances, and getting that balance right, which is different for every individual.
Improper digestion can also create toxins in the body system, and these travel into deep tissues that leads to disorders in vital organs. Treatments include panchakarma (body cleansing), chakra (energy centre) balancing, meditations, yoga, massage with stimulations at 107 neuromuscular points and shirodhara, an oil treatment to stimulate the brain. . . . Besides relaxation, ayurvedic massage also removes toxins from deep tissues, cleanses the body and rejuvenates internal systems.
One hundred seven neuromuscular points seemed like an awful lot, but ayurveda has nothing on Friday’s topic, something called Thai yoga massage, “believed to have first been performed more than 2500 years ago.” The “theory” (their term) of Thai yoga massage is that the body is permeated with air, which, once it is inhaled into the lungs, travels along 72,000 pathways. Seventy-two thousand! They must be really, really tiny. The massage stimulates these channels and moves the air through the body with a “pumping action.”
What, no homeopathy?
As it turned out, it was only a matter of time. Several days later, the New Zealand Sunday Star-Times ran an article noting that, according to a recent survey, 51 percent of New Zealanders believe that homeopathy has been scientifically proven. Fortunately, this paper’s reporter had the good sense to ask a real doctor about homeopathy. His assessment: “It’s absolute nonsense.” This was countered by a Christchurch homeopath, who retorted, “we constantly get that it’s never been proven and it’s not working but that is not true.”
And what’s the evidence? Well, according to the NZ Council of Homeopaths, there are the accounts from the 1918 influenza epidemic and cases of success in homeopathic hospitals. Then there is the case of a NZ homeopath who gave a homeopathic remedy to a woman having trouble conceiving. And guess what? A few weeks later she was pregnant! Who can argue with that kind of success?
On the very same page, the Star-Times reported on the “Pawtect,” a pet flea and tick collar which, according to its developer, uses “proven bioenergetic technology” as well as combining “quantum physics and homeopathic principals to stimulate pets’ natural processes to return them to a harmonious state.” It was not made clear why this harmonious state would have any deleterious effect on fleas or ticks. In fact, one would assume fleas and ticks prefer pets in a harmonious state and therefore less apt to scratch away furiously when bitten.
Here’s how the collar, um, “works:”
Every living thing carries a frequency and there is a counter frequency that repels it. . . . [T]he frequencies that repel ticks and fleas were ‘imprinted’ on the Pawtect collar using a computer. Another frequency that supported a healthy immune system was also imprinted.
Of course, there was also the ubiquitous testimonial, this from an Auckland dog owner who found the “Pawtect” flea collar worked like a charm.
Fortunately, the story quoted Dr. Siouxsie Wiles of Auckland University, who said that when she saw some of what passed for “scientific” she “nearly choked.” Dr. Wiles decried people such as the flea collar developer who “used the language of science without any of its method.” She added, “it’s frankly offensive considering the time I spend writing papers so my peers can pull them apart.” Dr. Wiles summarized the “Pawtect” collar nicely as “bollocks” and “just a load of nonsense.” Well said, Dr. Wiles!
A letter to the New Zealand Journal Medical Journal criticizing alternative medicine was also mentioned. According to the news story, the letter’s authors lamented that “there were a plethora of different alternative medicine therapies and products, but that the ‘vast majority (were) either not biologically plausible and/or not supported by research evidence.’” The New England Journal of Medicine could take a lesson here from the New Zealand Medical Journal.
Disturbingly, the news story ended with the flea collar developer’s statement that “there are plans to launch a similar product for humans next year.”
The final NZ news story about CAM was a sad one. As reported in the Star-Times, NZ physicist Sir Paul Callaghan, who has terminal colon cancer, started high-dose intravenous vitamin C infusions, a highly touted alternative cancer treatment, in June, 2011. He made clear that he was never an advocate of the treatment, just curious, as scientists are. Of course, this didn’t stop alternative medicine advocates from using his experiment to promote this unconventional treatment in a misleading way, a fact that caused Callaghan some concern.
He tracked the treatment’s effectiveness via a blood test for protein carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), which indicates cancer levels, according to the news report. Callaghan has now announced an end to his experiment, stating “I have, as a result, learned enough to say that there is absolutely no evidence of any beneficial effect of high-dose intravenous vitamin C in my case.” He said he wanted to make the results known because of the risk that his use of vitamin C would be used to falsely promote it, adding that the way people promoted products without evidence was “quite repellent.”
A protest against quackademia
Fortunately, the trip ended with some really good news. Back in Australia, according to a story in The Sydney Morning Herald (and Dr. Novella yesterday on SBM), a group of more than 400 doctors, medical researchers and scientists have formed a group, Friends of Science in Medicine, to pressure universities to stop teaching alternative medicine. The Institute for Science in Medicine, which includes a number of SBM posters among its founders and members, is supporting the new group in its efforts.
As it stands now, several Australian universities award degrees in complementary medicine, chiropractic, naturopathy, herbal medicines, acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine. There are also individual courses in homeopathy, reflexology and aromatherapy.
The Morning Herald reported that the newly formed group wrote to the universities at the end of January, stating that by giving “undeserved credibility to what in many cases would be better described as quackery” and by “failing to champion evidence-based science and medicine” the universities are damaging their reputations. Harvard Medical School, take note. The group is also asking that government and private health insurance providers stop covering alternative medical treatments.
The news report noted that soon it would no longer be possible in Great Britain to receive a degree from a publicly-funded university in any type of alternative medicine, including homeopathy and naturopathy. As well, German and British health insurers are in the process of ending coverage of alternative therapies. In Australia, the federal government is looking at ways to get the Therapeutic Goods Administration to enforce more stringent criteria for proof of efficacy for CAM products.
What I learned on my summer/winter vacation
Although some of the practices and products are different, CAM down under is depressingly similar to CAM at home. Wildly implausible treatments and products marketed with pseudoscientific explanations of their supposed mechanisms of action. Use based not on science or evidence, but rather on (supposed) antiquity and popularity. “Eastern” versus “western” medicine. Credulous reporters. The one true cure for everything. And, of course, quantum physics.
There were encouraging signs of a push-back, more so than in the U.S. — demands to end university CAM courses and degrees as well as health insurance coverage for CAM, and possible strengthening of regulations to reign in CAM claims. And scientists there are willing to go on record in calling CAM quackery, nonsense and bollocks, at least when reporters bother to ask.
It’s all a part of the whack-a-mole experience of fighting CAM. Smack down university reflexology courses. Up pops Greek leech therapy. Smack down Vitamin C infusions. Up pops Thai yoga massage. Smack down bioenergetic technology-based pet flea collars. Up pops bioenergetic technology-based human flea collars. It’s exhausting. I simply must get revitalized.

Brainspotting is Classic Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on May 14, 2025
Link
Have you heard of brainspotting? It’s been around since 2003 when it was invented out of whole cloth (not “discovered”) by psychotherapist David Grand. It seems to be gaining in popularity recently, so it is worth the SBM treatment.
Here is how proponents describe the alleged phenomenon:
“Brainspotting makes use of this natural phenomenon through its use of relevant eye positions. This helps the Brainspotting therapist locate, focus, process and release a wide range of emotionally and bodily-based conditions. Brainspotting is also a brain-based tool to support the therapy relationship. We believe that Brainspotting taps into and harnesses the body’s natural self-scanning, self-healing ability. When a Brainspot is stimulated, the deep brain appears to reflexively signal the therapist that the source of the problem has been found.”
This is all complete and utter neurological rubbish from beginning to end, but let’s break it down. The idea is that trauma (not necessarily traumatic memories, but “trauma” in the abstract sense) is somehow located in specific spots in the deep brain, such as the brainstem. This is an extraordinary claim, and it is coupled with another equally extraordinary claim – that where your eyes physically look also maps to specific subcortical locations. These overlapping maps can then be used to locate the “trauma”.
Of course these maps do not exist. There is no neuroanatomical correlate to either component of the core principles of brainspotting. The anatomy of eye movements is fairly well understood, and does not correlate in any way with this core notion of brainspotting.
This is a main feature of pseudoscience – the core underlying principles are not established science. In this case they are also highly implausible and run counter to actual neuroscience. How did Grand come up with this idea if it is so counter to neuroscience? That brings up another common feature of pseudoscience – it is often based on anecdote, and sometimes a single anecdotal observation.
According to Grand’s own account, he was performing his own version of EMDR (another pseudoscientific therapy modality) on a 16 year old skater when he noticed that her eye movements would get stuck in one spot. He had her maintain here gaze in that location, which he claims resulted in her “releasing” her trauma. The next day she was able to complete a triple loop, which was the performance issue for which she was seeing him.
A proper scientific reaction to an anecdotal experience such as this is to generate a hypothesis, and then objectively test that hypothesis to see if it is real. But that is not how gurus respond – rather they leap to conclusions and then engage in confirmation bias. In this way chiropractic was born out of a single observation by DD Palmer, and iridology came from a single observation by Ignaz von Peczely. They typically confuse their confirmation bias, looking for and selecting observations that appear to support your belief, with actual evidence.
I can only find two publications by Grand on the machanism of Brainspotting – neither present any new evidence or research. They are just musings about neuroanatomy and what might be going on. Both are published in the journal Medical Hypotheses, which is a notorious crank journal full of such naked speculation.
Grand has had 23 years to convince the scientific community that he is onto something, the better part of a career, and has made no progress as far as I can tell. This is because he has been focusing on building Brainspotting as a treatment, not testing the underlying principles.
In the last 23 years neuroscience research has improved tremendously, with tools such as fMRI scanning. If he were, in fact, onto a real fact about the neuroscience of trauma then he should be able to demonstrate this, and other neuroscientists would have picked up on it and expanded his research. But that is not the pattern we see – rather, we just have a single anecdote, followed by a lot of hand-waving speculation about neuroanatomy with zero evidence, while promoting this new therapy as a revolution and it creator as a genius. Classic pseudoscience.
Brainspotting also shares some features with other medical and neurological pseudoscience. The underlying idea is to find some hack, this one crazy trick that allows for the bypassing of all that difficult diagnosis and treatment. You don’t have to spend weeks or months exploring your emotional and cognitive issues in all their complexity. You don’t have to spend weeks, months, or even years working on cognitive behavior therapy, understanding yourself, processing trauma, and developing improved coping and adaptive skills. Just look at this one spot, and your trauma will melt away.
It also shares the common feature of being based on some map or homonculus in the body. Straight chiropractic, acupuncture, reflexology, and iridology all share this feature – some part of the body maps to the entire body, or it maps to specific problems someone may be facing. Just activate this point, and it will fix or at least diagnose the problem. For all of these systems, however, there is no evidence to support the existence of such a map, not even an underlying plausible mechanism.
Interestingly, there are actual homonculus maps in the brain. The motor cortex, for example, occurs along a strip of gyrus that maps to the body. This is how the brain develops. The visual cortex likewise physically maps to your visual field, like a bit map. There is no such map in the midbrain, as Grand claims, that maps to specific eye positions. Further, there is no subsequent map, as Brainspotting requires, that maps to traumatic memories or biological effects.
This is the point at which proponents of a pseudoscience would say something along the lines of – well, we are not sure how it works, we just know that it works, and we are too busy helping people to work out the details. That is not an acceptable excuse for bypassing science. But also, we can determine if a treatment works without knowing how it works. There are standard research protocols for establishing efficacy. Grand hasn’t bothered to do this either.
Determining efficacy is critical in medicine, even in therapy. It is, admittedly, challenging in therapy because it is difficult to control for all the possible variables, and outcomes are often subjective. But this is not a reason to abandon science, it is a reason to have especially rigorous research methodology. At the very least we would like to see some blinded clinical trials with some objective outcome measure. You could randomize clients to treatment vs placebo, with the placebo group receiving some other novel element introduced into the therapy sessions but without any expectation or claim of efficacy. You could also compare both of these groups to a usual therapy control.
Taking this approach to establish the reality of a new treatment requires more than just a single trial. We would need to see a consistent effect that can be replicated with significant effect sizes. Ideally we would see some sort of dose-response curve, and some long term benefit to suggest it’s not just an immediate placebo effect. But that is something we never get with such pseudosciences – simultaneous rigorous clinical trials with statistically and clinically significant results that replicate.
What Grand has done is preliminary clinical trials – small studies that are not designed to establish or refute efficacy. In one study he compared Brainspotting to EMDR in PTSD, with no other control. The main outcome was subjective report of symptoms. This is the type of preliminary research almost guaranteed to generate false positive results, and not capable of determining efficacy. Claiming it is as effective as EMDR is also not impressive, since EMDR has also not established specific efficacy in my opinion.
I think this entire approach to therapy, so-called brain-body therapies, is a blind alley. It is born out of a desire for a quick fix, a hack or trick that can lead to easy quick results. No such therapy has been able to pass scientific muster, but we are likely to see a continued multiplication of such therapies. It’s easy to come up with some new gimmick and make hand-waving claims for how it might work, then combine that with uncontrolled observations or maybe some weak preliminary studies. It’s all nonsense until we do rigorous clinical research grounded in actual neuroscience.


Do our mitochondria need support?
Many products have claims to to “support” your mitochondria. For healthy adults, these claims remain largely speculative and unproven.
Scott Gavura on April 9, 2026
Link

“Boost your cellular energy.” “Support your cell’s powerhouse.” “Recharge your body at the source.”
Phrases like these are everywhere in health marketing, all built on a simple idea: if mitochondria are the engines of our cells, then helping them work better should translate into more energy, better health, and maybe even slower aging. It sounds scientific, and just familiar enough to feel credible. You may not remember much biochemistry, but you’ve probably heard of mitochondria.
But what does it actually mean to “support” something inside our cells? And more importantly, is there any persuasive, credible evidence that treatments aimed at “mitochondrial support” do anything that actually matters?
The energy appeal
There is a kernel of scientific truth behind the marketing. Mitochondria generate adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the molecule that powers nearly every energy-dependent process in the body. Tissues with high energy demands (muscle, brain, and heart) are packed with mitochondria. When mitochondrial function is impaired, as seen in rare inherited mitochondrial disorders, the clinical consequences can be profound.
From there, the logic is extrapolated: if mitochondrial activity is linked to cellular energy, then enhancing that activity should translate into you feeling more energized. It’s a short step from there to broader claims about well-being and even aging itself. We’ve seen similar arguments before: telomeres, hormones, and other biological markers positioned as levers we can pull,or dials we can adjust, to optimize “wellness” and slow decline.
But this reasoning skips several critical steps.
What mitochondria actually do
To assess the claims about “boosting” mitochondria, it’s helpful to have better understanding of what they actually do. Mitochondria are involved in several essential cellular processes beyond energy production.
    • Energy production: Through oxidative phosphorylation, mitochondria convert nutrients into ATP, providing the energy required for nearly every biological process.
    • Regulation of cell death: Mitochondria play a central role in apoptosis, the controlled elimination of damaged or unnecessary cells. This process is critical for maintaining healthy tissues and preventing disease.
    • Calcium signaling: By taking up and releasing calcium ions, mitochondria help regulate muscle contraction, nerve transmission, and other calcium‑dependent cellular activities.
    • Reactive oxygen species (ROS) management: Mitochondria produce reactive oxygen species as a byproduct of energy metabolism. They also contribute to controlling ROS levels, supporting normal signaling while limiting oxidative damage.
Mitochondria are fundamental to life. Their essential roles mean that no simple supplement, device or treatment is likely to dramatically alter their function. At the same time, their complexity sets limits on what targeted interventions can achieve: changes that may be observed at the cellular level do not automatically translate into improvements we can identify.
The evidence ladder: Biochemical → Functional → Clinical
When evaluating claims about mitochondrial support and energy, it helps to think in terms of three levels of evidence: biochemical, functional, and clinical. Different fields may use different labels, but you can think of this as additive and progressive. (It ties into why we call this blog Science-Based Medicine). Each level tells us something different, and problems arise when results at one level are implied as proof for the next.
     1.  Biochemical evidence: This is the most basic level. It measures molecular or cellular changes—ATP production, NAD⁺ levels, enzyme activity, or markers of oxidative stress. Biochemical studies are often conducted in isolated cells or animal models, and sometimes in human tissues or blood samples, but they still tell us what could happen under controlled conditions rather than what reliably happens in living humans.
     2.  Functional evidence: This level looks at measurable outcomes that reflect how the body actually performs—exercise endurance, muscle strength, cognitive tests, or fatigue scores. It could also include the measurement of a surrogate – something that isn’t itself meaningful to a patient. Functional studies can be done in humans and measure real performance, but they do not necessarily indicate durable or clinically meaningful benefits.
     3.  Clinical evidence: This is what we’re looking for. Outcomes that matter: disease progression, symptom relief, quality of life, or lifespan. Clinical evidence demonstrates that a treatment actually improves health in a meaningful way.
The challenge is that many “mitochondrial support” products and interventions never progress beyond the biochemical level. A supplement might change a value in a test tube or even in blood samples, but that does not guarantee any functional benefit, let alone a clinical effect. Marketing often implies that biochemical changes are automatically beneficial for health, skipping the intermediate questions that only functional studies and clinical trials can answer.
Understanding this hierarchy is essential for evaluating claims critically. Just because mitochondria are important doesn’t mean that boosting a cellular marker will make you feel more energetic, healthier, or younger. Without functional or clinical evidence, these claims remain speculative at best.
Products marketed for your mitochondria
NAD⁺ and Precursors
Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD⁺) is a critical coenzyme in energy metabolism, and its levels do decline with age. Supplements like nicotinamide riboside (NR) or nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) can raise NAD⁺ in blood or tissues in small human studies. But there’s little persuasive evidence that this translates into measurable improvements in energy, cognition, or aging in healthy adults. The effect remains largely biochemical, with functional or clinical benefits remaining unproven.
Coenzyme Q10
CoQ10 is a supplement that’s been popular for decades, without convincing evidence that popularity is warranted. It is essential for the electron transport chain, and has a role in mitochondrial energy production. Some evidence supports its use in specific conditions, like statin-associated muscle symptoms or certain rare mitochondrial diseases. For general fatigue or wellness in healthy individuals, however, the clinical evidence is weak or inconsistent. A biochemical effect does not automatically result in noticeable health improvements.
Red Light Therapy (Photobiomodulation)
I see influencers love red light therapy. Red or near-infrared light can be absorbed by mitochondrial enzymes in lab studies, potentially increasing ATP production and modulating ROS. Small human studies suggest modest improvements in localized pain, wound healing, or exercise recovery, but results are inconsistent and often poorly controlled. Evidence that it meaningfully boosts overall mitochondrial function or systemic energy in healthy people is lacking.
The marketing works
When you hear the term “mitochondrial dysfunction” used outside of a medical diagnosis, it’s usually as an explanation for common and non-specific complaints: fatigue, brain fog, low mood, or general malaise. It’s a convenient placeholder – it sounds scientific!
This vagueness is precisely what makes the marketing effective. The language is plausible, borrowing legitimacy from real biology. Subjective outcomes like energy and wellness are difficult to measure and easy to claim improvement in, which lowers the bar for perceived effectiveness. And add in placebo effects. If you’re investing in a treatment, you want it to work. The interventions themselves often feel harmless, like taking a supplement, or boosting your exposure to red light. Combine biological plausibility, personal relevance, and low perceived risk, and you have a powerful marketing formula.
What good evidence looks like
If a treatment genuinely “supports” mitochondria in a meaningful way, it would not be impossible to measure. But the evidence needs to go beyond cell cultures or blood biomarkers. Ideally, it would include:
    • Well-designed human trials: Randomized, placebo-controlled studies in clearly defined populations.
    • Functional outcomes: Measures that reflect real-world performance, such as exercise endurance, cognitive testing, or fatigue scales.
    • Clinically meaningful endpoints: Improvements in symptoms, quality of life, or disease progression, not just laboratory markers.
    • Sustained effects and replication: Benefits should be durable over time and consistently appear over multiple trials.
In short, good evidence links changes in mitochondrial biology to actual, measurable improvements in how people feel or function. Without this, these claims are speculative and unproven.
Mitochondria matter, but…
If your mitochondria weren’t working, you wouldn’t be reading this post. The question isn’t whether mitochondria are important. It’s whether they need any distinct “support.” Until objective evidence for mitochondria support treatments demonstrate meaningful clinical benefits, “supporting your mitochondria” will remains a marketing term, not a medical one.

Injectable Peptides – The New Snake Oil
Steven Novella on May 27, 2026
Link

We are going backwards. Hopefully this will be temporary trend, but it has been consistent for the past few decades. Prior to the FDA we had the “wild west” of patent medicines – anyone could put anything in a bottle and sell it with any claims. It was up to the average person to decide if a product was safe or effective. As you might imagine, this lead to an industry of snake oil that exploited the public while providing little benefit. The creation of the FDA in the US changed the picture, putting an end to most (not all – homeopathic products being a notable exception) of the abuse by requiring evidence of safety and efficacy prior to marketing any drug, and regulating what claims could be made for them.
The snake oil industry was never happy with this regulation; they wanted the freedom to essentially lie to the public, make hyped unsupported claims, and sell products with dubious benefits. But they persisted on the margins, and in 1994 their lobbying paid off with the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA). Prior to DSHEA, any product that claimed to treat or cure any disease was, by regulatory definition, a drug and had to prove safety and efficacy prior to market. But DSHEA created a new category of claims, so-called “structure function” claims, which are a massive loophole for the snake oil (I’m sorry, I mean supplement) industry.
With such claims you just have to be a little careful with your wording. A supplement cannot treat dementia, but it can support cognitive health. The supplement industry exploded with all kinds of products making all kinds of claims, some adhering carefully to the structure-function regulation but many not. We entered a new era of snake oil.
This also had the consequence of funding a massive and growing “wellness” industry, which has benefited from social media as well. Supplements sold with dubious structure-function claims now support a multi-billion dollar industry that promotes anti-vaccine conspiracy theories, many unscientific health claims, science denial, and further anti-regulation efforts. We may be seeing the peak of this movement with MAHA, which is essentially in power at the federal level.
We are now seeing yet another snake oil craze with injectable peptides (which we have covered before). Peptides are strings of amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. They are not technically proteins until they fold up into a specific configuration – prior to folding they are just peptides. There are many legitimate injectable peptides on the market, the first being insulin in 1923. All of the GLP-1 drugs on the market for diabetes and obesity are also injectable peptides. These are FDA-approved drugs.
So why are there now so many injectable peptides that can be sold without FDA approval? Good question. These are potentially powerful agents that have to be injected (usually subcutaneously), so why aren’t they considered drugs? Part of the reason is that they are not chemicals, they are technically biologics. They are not supplements, so they are not sold that way. They can, however, be purified and packaged by compounding pharmacies, so they are regulated that way.
Compounding pharmacies have lists of drugs they can compound (the 503A bulks list) and ones they cannot. There are three regulatory categories – category 1 substances were submitted to the FDA for review with adequate information and do not fit into any other category. Category 2 are considered by the FDA to be too risky for compounding pharmacies. Category 3 were submitted with insufficient evidence. Here is a more detailed description of all relevant federal regulations.
The Biden administration added 20 popular injectable peptides to the Category 2 list, essentially banning them from compounding pharmacies. This did not eliminate the market, but did create a “gray” market for these products. Now the Trump administration, under RFK Jr (who is a fan of peptides due to his personal use), is reviewing 7 of these peptides for inclusion in the approved lists, with 5 more to be reviewed next year. Kennedy is pushing hard for their approval, so there is no mystery about what is going to happen.
But make no mistake – these injectable peptides are snake oil. This doesn’t mean that they cannot or do not have any benefit, it means we simply do not know and the claims made for them are not adequately supported by high quality evidence. Here is a typical wellness site promotion:
“Peptides have quietly become the new MVPs in the world of functional medicine and anti-aging therapy. These naturally occurring compounds — tiny chains of amino acids — work like messengers, telling your body to heal, regenerate, and perform at its best.
Used in injection form, peptides can support everything from faster muscle recovery to improved metabolism, hormone balance, and even smoother, firmer skin.”
Notice the use of the term “support” – that is a structure function claim, designed to comply with DSHEA. That means they do not require any evidence to make such claims.
The most popular injectable wellness peptide is likely BPC-157, which is claimed to promote healing and recovery. A recent systematic review of research into this compound finds a single clinical trial, with only 12 subjects in an open-label design, looking at knee pain. That is a pilot study at best, absolutely useless for determining efficacy.
Loosening FDA regulations as a gift to wellness influencers and snake oil peddlers will virtually guarantee that no rigorous clinical studies will be done. There is no incentive to do such trials. We may see some in-house studies used to support marketing. Because there is a legitimate orthopedic and sports medicine question here, we may see some serious investigator-initiated research, but without the resources to do the large clinical trials that are really necessary.
This is why allowing such products to be sold without proper evidence is a lose-lose proposition. If the product is not safe or effective, then the public is being put at risk and is being cheated out of their money and resources for a useless product. If it does work, we may never know, and it will therefore be impossible to incorporate its use into science-based practice. Whether it works or not, everyone is better off (well, other than the snake-oil peddlers) if we confidently know through rigorous clinical trials.
Kennedy will not always have control of federal health care policy, but it remains to be seen what comes after him. Promoting the snake oil industry has been a bipartisan activity. But there will be an opportunity for more science-based regulation, and perhaps the pendulum can swing back again in the direction of the consumer.

Veternary Medicine

What do veterinarians think about complementary and alternative medicine?
A survey of veterinarians shows that belief in at least one CAM modality is more than twice as common as skepticism.
Greg Bishop on January 17, 2020
Link

There are about 100,000 veterinarians in the US. Speaking generally, we are conscientious, hard-working, animal-loving, and pretty likely to ruin a dinner conversation by bringing up the common parasites of whatever everyone is about to eat. We love science. If you want to slog through the years of study and training required to become a vet, you have to have a knack for and a love of science. You have to take chemistry five times (general, organic, biochem, organic, physiologic, okay I failed o-chem the first time). Every single person that has successfully become a veterinarian has had a solid understanding of a whole heck of a lot of science.
But we aren’t scientists per se. We like the fun gross stuff but we don’t necessarily think scientifically all the time. We usually aren’t running experiments, dispassionately reviewing evidence, and trying to prove ourselves wrong. Maybe we’re like airline pilots with a detailed knowledge of machinery and weather conditions, but who aren’t necessarily aeronautical engineers. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not that you can’t be both (and it’s often of great value), but most of the time we just don’t think in a purely scientific sense. Because it’s hard to do so. We have limited time, information, and resources, and we’ve got to get stuff done. We rely on subjective experience a lot. We’ll speculate and guess. We get hunches like a gothic cathedral bell tower. Often, we’re open to anything if it gets Mrs. Angry-Chihuahua-Owner off my case so I can go sedate this hissing cat for x-rays!!
We certainly haven’t scientifically assessed a lot of what we do in veterinary medicine. And because we have to go off of extrapolations and our best guesses, sometimes we’re open to ideas that might even be scientifically implausible. Specifically, I’ve always thought that complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) was fairly prevalent. You’re reading an SBM article, so your disinclination toward alternative medicine is probably the same as mine, but amongst my veterinary colleagues I always feel a bit more skeptical than most. Which is why I got curious when I saw a recent poll asking exactly this question: “What do veterinarians think about complementary and alternative medicine?”
SUUURVEY SAAAAYS…
The survey was part of a project of weekly polls conducted by the Veterinary Information Network (VIN), a wonderful online forum and resource for veterinarians. They ask all sorts of clinically and topically relevant questions in these polls, and they are a great snapshot of current veterinary thinking. This poll asked about “beliefs and practices” in CAM modalities. The following were listed: homeopathy, acupuncture, Reiki, chiropractic, and “other”. Veterinarians responded saying whether or not they believed the modality was effective for certain conditions, and whether or not they personally practiced it or referred patients for it (which is probably a better indicator of how much they truly believe it works).
Overall, a majority of veterinarians believed in the effectiveness of at least one of the modalities, but significantly fewer either personally practiced or referred for them. Acupuncture had the highest belief, at 63%, followed by chiropractic at 33% and 16% for homeopathy. About one out of every three veterinarians personally practiced acupuncture or referred patients for it, followed by 14% for chiropractic and 4% for homeopathy. These numbers can be hard to contextualize, but just for a fun comparison, about 36% of Americans have personally felt the presence of a ghost and 13% believe in vampires.
One could say that homeopathy is about as plausible as vampirism (well, actually porphyria makes me double-think that), so maybe these numbers aren’t too surprising. But unlike the ghost poll, the veterinarian survey asked a question to gauge skepticism, “none of these options are supported by enough scientific evidence for me to include them in my practice”. Only about 25% of veterinarians were smarmy, condescending buzzkills—errr… agreed. That is, only a quarter of veterinarians feel that these practices are so unproven as to not be worth using. Far less than are already convinced acupuncture is beneficial. And this isn’t the place to necessarily discuss the efficacy of acupuncture, but I think an impartial judge would probably have to conclude that it’s far from “proven” (see, for instance, here).
This is just a survey. It’s a small sample of veterinarians who happen to be willing to respond to a questionnaire in an online forum. If you asked the questions differently you might get different numbers. But the weird thing is these percentages seem completely realistic to me, and I’ve worked in a lot of different veterinary clinics. If anything, I would have said the quarter of veterinarians who didn’t feel there was enough evidence for those modalities was too high!
OK, what about other people that wear scrubs?
Is CAM belief more prevalent in veterinarians than physicians? Nurses? Dentists? Chiropracto—errr, nevermind? You can’t really do an exact comparison with other healthcare professionals because the exact same questions haven’t been asked. Plus, there’s a bunch of different CAM modalities and “indications” so it’s like trying to figure out how people that drive things feel about sports. Still, there is a fair amount of information on how healthcare practitioners feel toward CAM. For example, this older study found rates of support amongst physicians of 51% for acupuncture, 53% for chiropractic, and 26% for homeopathy. Other studies have found some support for CAM among healthcare professionals and students, although often there is some variation in this support. In a review that included responses by physicians, PA’s, NP’s, RN’s, social workers, dietitians, social workers, dentists and mental health professionals, a consistent finding was that physicians had a more negative view of CAM than other professionals.
As this post was in editorial purgatory, David Gorski wrote a post describing this study, in which physicians were surveyed about their use of CAM for patients. The rates were about 27% for chiropractic, 22% for acupuncture, and around 13% for homeopathy.
Conclusion: CAM is common, skepticism is not so much in vet med
Depending on your background, these percentages might either shock you, amuse you, bore you, or affirm your suspicion that most veterinarians (if not most healthcare professionals) endorse some form of CAM. You might also be a bit surprised that such a low percentage of us are skeptical of CAM. But that, for better or worse, is where we are in veterinary medicine right now. We are far from being a truly science-based field. We’re the ultimate general practitioners and we don’t always have the time or incentives to dig through scientific literature on a regular basis. There is a small group of people (The Skeptvet, The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, The Evidence Based Veterinary Medical Association, and The Centre for Evidence-based Veterinary Medicine) who are pushing to make this type of approach a priority, but it is not as widespread as some of us might hope.
This is a point worth discussing, because the body of scientific research in veterinary medicine is so sparse compared to human medicine. If we truly take a skeptical approach to our practices, we have to admit that maybe most of what we do is not proven. Rather, it’s maybe extrapolated from human medicine, maybe based on plausibility, or maybe just made up on the fly. We could and should investigate these things scientifically and overturn entrenched “mainstream” practices when they turn out to be harmful (the more recent move to reduce antibiotic use in cases of asymptomatic bacteriuria is a good example, although still far from a widespread practice). Let’s flip on the light of science-based medicine and let the incorrect ideas scatter.
All of this doesn’t mean veterinarians are backwards or anti-science. Believing in the benefits of acupuncture or using best-guess antibiotics when unnecessary doesn’t negate all clinical skills and scientific knowledge. You can also believe in vampires and be an excellent vet (especially for bats). I think it means that we’re busy, under-resourced, and susceptible to bias. Keeping abreast of the latest science is hard! I do think these numbers highlight the potential we have to become a more scientific profession though. In my opinion, evidence-based practice is to everyone’s advantage. If veterinarians think more critically, we’ll be better serving our patients and clients. This means abandoning disproven therapies while at the same time accepting proven practices even if they can’t be explained at every level. And it may be tempting to scoff at us in the animal medical field as gullible witch doctors, just remember that the numbers in human healthcare professions are hardly better. I take a little comfort in knowing that at least our patients don’t believe in magic.

Alternative Medicine Is Infiltrating Veterinary Continuing Education
Harriet Hall on September 6, 2016
Link

My friend Carmen Czachor is a science-based veterinarian practicing in Port Angeles, Washington. She has alerted me to a disturbing development that she fears will “put veterinary medicine back in the dark ages.” The Washington State Department of Health is contemplating a rule change in the regulations requiring continuing education for veterinarians. Current requirements are for 30 hours of continuing education every 3 years; the only restriction is that no more than 10 hours can be earned in practice management courses. The Veterinary Board of Governors had observed an increase in the volume of continuing education courses related to CAVM (complementary and alternative veterinary medicine) and they wanted to provide some guidance. They explain:
The board originally proposed a ten hour limit on the number of veterinary CAVM CE hours that can be earned in any three year reporting period. After stakeholder feedback from multiple veterinary practitioners who practice solely in CAVM, the board decided to revisit the proposal. The board now proposes to establish a twenty hour limit on CAVM continuing education and add a ten hour minimum requirement for conventional medicine. The board finds that doing so would not result in a reduction in the quality of care provided and supports the consumer’s choices about what kind of care they seek.
Note: “stakeholder feedback from multiple veterinary practitioners who practice solely in CAVM.” I find this alarming. Veterinarians are licensed to practice veterinary medicine, not CAVM. Alternative medicine is called “alternative” because it is not supported by the kind of evidence that would earn it a place in conventional medicine. What does it mean that veterinarians are “practicing solely in CAVM”? Does that mean they have abandoned the conventional veterinary medicine that they were licensed to practice?
And how on earth did they determine that the proposal “would not result in a reduction in the quality of care provided”? They just made that up because they wanted to believe it and because they believe alternative medicine constitutes quality care.The board’s chairman is biased
The Veterinary Board of Governors is chaired by Suzan Seelye,DVM. That explains a lot. I looked at her website and was appalled. She practices “Quantum Veterinary Healing,” offering “non-toxic wholistic/holistic methods while addressing both body and mind.” She says it allows healing at the DNA level. She is a certified Tui-na practitioner, a graduate of the Chi Institute (a school of traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine), a certified veterinary acupuncturist, and claims to have studied quantum physics, neurophysiology, molecular biology, therapeutic touch, Qigong, homeopathy, “nutraceutics,” Chinese and Western Herbal medicine, and Feldenkrais.
Her article on quantum physics says we create reality by what we focus on; that’s a complete distortion of what quantum physics actually says. Her website recommends books by unreliable New Age authors like Candace Pert and Lynne McTaggart. It recommends the ridiculous movie What the Bleep, which critics have characterized as “moronic beyond belief” and “not even wrong;” scientists have pointed out that the movie “…distorts science to fit its own agenda, it is full of half-truths and misleading analogies, and some of its so-called scientific claims are downright lies.”
Seelye also recommends a book I had not heard of, Zero Limits: The Secret Hawaiian System for Wealth, Health, Peace, and More. She says:
It is about a psychologist who helped heal an entire ward of mentally ill criminals without ever seeing any of them professionally. He used an unusual healing method from Hawaii called ho’oponopono. It takes self responsibility to whole new heights. The technique, in part, is seeing everything that comes into your life as a part of yourself and cleansing by saying “forgive me”, “I love you”, “thank you”.
Elsewhere on her website are references to “detox,” “animal communicators,” and locally prepared organic herbal blends for horses (which she not only gives to her horses but takes herself). The website provides numerous testimonials but nothing in the way of scientific studies.
Her article on DNA refers to “DNA frequencies” and claims that a Russian scientist has “uncovered the linguistic and psychic capabilities of junk DNA, ushering in a re-evaluation of the human gene in terms of words, wave genetics and grammar of spirituality.” She says “Man can literally reprogram his genetic blueprint through words” and “man originated billions of years ago in waves of consciousness.” Also, “group consciousness can bring about changes that dissolve violence and restore earth to its natural balance.”
I kid you not. I couldn’t make this stuff up. I can’t even repeat it with a straight face. It seems she has exchanged the realm of science and reality for full-blown New Age fantasies. In my opinion, a person who accepts these beliefs and who practices alternative or “quantum veterinary healing” should not be on a Board of Governors that makes rules for conventional veterinarians.
What kind of CAVM education are they talking about?
In my opinion, some kinds of education about CAVM would be useful. Veterinarians could be given factual, unbiased information that they could use to help educate patients who ask about CAVM. They could be told that when chiropractors claim to be fixing “subluxations” in a horse’s spine with manual “adjustments,” the bones are not actually out of place (and if they were, manual pressure wouldn’t be enough to reposition them: it would take a crowbar!). They could be told that homeopathy is bogus and that the evidence for acupuncture is compatible with a theatrical placebo. They could be told that “energy medicine” is based on a myth and has not been shown to work in rigorous controlled trials.
But unfortunately, the rules related to continuing education do not address criteria for the approval of CAVM courses. They would allow uncritical “how to” courses where “true believer” instructors teach students how they, too, can do CAVM. Anything goes.
This problem is not limited to Washington State. In 2012 two Swedish authors wrote a guest post on Science-Based Medicine describing how chiropractic is being taught to veterinarians around the world in courses that “mix science, pseudoscience and fantasy and make no visible effort to show which is which.”
Other problems
Dr. Czachor tells me three of the five veterinarians on the board use quackery in their practices: cold laser and stem cell at one, tui na at another, along with Seelye’s quantum quackery. She plans to file an ethics complaint saying they should recuse themselves from the vote. She also points out that it was the chair who suggested increasing the hours and that under Robert’s Rules of Order the chair should have NO opinion.
Dr. Czachor knows whereof she speaks: she is a former Board of Governors member and chair herself; her term ended in December 2012. She is also a Regional Officer of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medical Association (EBVMA), representing the Western United States and Mexico. The EBVMA is a prestigious organization whose Past President and current Board Member is Brennen McKenzie, whose name you may recognize from the numerous articles he has written for Science-Based Medicine; he also writes the SkeptVet blog.
What can we do?
This is a horrible proposal. It would allow veterinarians to get 2/3 of their continuing education credits from courses based on fantasy rather than on science. It doesn’t address approval criteria for CAVM courses. It doesn’t even define what it means by conventional medicine.
Dr. Czachor has emailed and messaged everyone she can think of, but she says she feels like she’s tilting at windmills. We can help. A public hearing will be held on September 19th. Comments on the proposed rules can be submitted on the department’s Rules Comment webpage, or directly to the program manager, Loralei Walker, at [email protected] by September 12, 2016.
Time is of the essence.

Alternative Medicine: Placebos for Pets
A skeptical veterinarian reviews the evidence for alternative medicine for pets, and concludes it’s mostly placebos.
Harriet Hall on December 3, 2019
Link

Alternative medicine is accepted by many humans, but we may forget that it is also imposed on their pets. Veterinarian Brennen McKenzie has done cats and dogs everywhere a great service, by compiling “The Truth About Alternative Medicine in Animals” and publishing it with the title Placebos for Pets?
Animal and human medicine are the same yet different. They both rely on scientific evidence, build on the same basic science, study the same subjects like anatomy and physiology, and have much more in common. But humans are not rats (although some people have been known to call others rats, usually with the addition of the word “dirty”). And all animals are not the same. What cures an elephant might kill a bunny. Aspirin causes congenital defects in mice, but not in humans. Horses don’t have gallbladders. It is not valid to extrapolate findings from studies in one species to another species.
Human and veterinary science are interdependent. Animal studies frequently precede human clinical studies; they can provide valuable information but not reliable clinical guidance. Veterinarians are forced to rely on human studies because they are more plentiful, and few or no studies may have been done on the species they want to treat.
Dr. McKenzie has written for Science-Based Medicine, and he tries to do for animals what the SBM website tries to do for humans, not only to provide science-based evaluations of treatments and claims, but to teach readers the principles of science and help them learn to do their own critical evaluations of claims. He points out that veterinarians spend as much, or more, time interacting with people as with animals. That reminds me of a pediatrician I once knew who said that good pediatrics consists of benign neglect of children and emotional support of parents. Dogs and cats can’t read this book, but their owners can learn from it, if they will.
But some of them will refuse to learn. McKenzie relates an encounter with a client who was sure her dog’s pain had almost completely gone away with homeopathy and acupuncture. When he pointed out that the dog couldn’t bear weight on his leg and cried when it was touched, she became angry. Another client believed an energy healer’s diagnosis that her dog’s cough was due to leukemia. All tests were negative, and the cough resolved with antibiotics. The client refused to believe that the healer could have been wrong: she was convinced that the healer had correctly diagnosed leukemia before it could show up on any tests, and then had cured it with homeopathy.
Beliefs like these can directly harm animals.
McKenzie lays a strong foundation by explaining how only science can give us reliable answers, and how complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) relies on anecdote, philosophy, and belief systems rather than on credible, reality-based scientific studies. He explains how pet owners are misled by metaphysical beliefs. Some CAM vets claim that we can influence the world by our thoughts, and that we can cause disease in our pets with our thoughts and feelings. They say the physical aspects of illness are secondary, if they matter at all; and that to be effective, practitioners must create a healing state with their own energy fields. McKenzie rejects such nonsense; he is firmly grounded in reality.
He covers homeopathy, acupuncture, manual therapies like chiropractic and massage, herbal medicine (the most promising but also the most potentially dangerous CAM), dietary supplements, and alternative nutrition, and then devotes another chapter to various other CAM practices such as aromatherapy, colloidal silver, cold/low level laser therapy, cupping, and many others. One that was new to me but apparently enjoys widespread use in veterinary circles was Yunnan Baiyao. The research on this herbal remedy is mostly negative and it’s not clear that it’s safe.
He debunks a number of myths about nutrition, raw diets, GMOs, etc. and quips that while cats thrive on a diet of raw mice, he doesn’t recommend it for readers of his book! He provides a handy visual aid to determine if your cat or dog is at, below, or above a healthy weight. He provides plenty of illustrations, some of which I got a kick out of: a deluded chiropractor leaning on a horse’s back in the belief that she is “adjusting” its spinal subluxations, a dog wearing multiple acupuncture needles in its butt, and a grumpy cat being subjected to cold laser therapy.
He provides a new slant on some old issues. He points out that a low-carb diet means a high-fat and/or high-protein diet. No one provides truly “holistic” medicine that addresses everything about a patient; they only address the things they think are important. “Natural”? “There is virtually nothing in medicine that doesn’t involve some effort or alteration of natural materials by humans.” Naturopathy? Little real substance.
He says the concept of detox “freely mixes bits of reality and science with unproven assumptions and outright myth to create a ‘toxic’ brew that can mislead us into irrational or inappropriate use of herbal medicines.”
McKenzie asks the same three simple questions of any treatment, whether alternative or mainstream:
     1.  What is it?
     2.  Does it work?
     3.  Is it safe?
He offers his eponymous McKenzie’s Law: if it has no side effects, it isn’t doing anything. He points out that a treatment that is claimed effective for many diverse conditions probably isn’t really effective for any of them. He offers a “Bottom Line” conclusion for each remedy he covers. He says homeopathy is based on ideas that are not compatible with established scientific principles. Although he is trained in acupuncture and practices it, he calls it “mostly a placebo”. (He offers it only after educating clients and getting truly informed consent; he knows placebos can make animals feel better but don’t actually improve their health). His language is circumspect, nuanced, and generally polite, but he doesn’t hesitate to call Reiki “complete nonsense”.
People say animals don’t respond to placebos, but they don’t need to. Their owners respond for them, and he explains in great detail how that can happen.
Some things I learned
The discussion of the evidence for the pros and cons of neutering dogs and cats was thorough and enlightening. I knew horses don’t have gallbladders, but now I understand the acupuncturists’ (faulty) rationale for sticking needles into a horse’s gallbladder meridian (it is not a physical entity but a metaphysical concept!). Despite their exclusively bamboo diet, giant pandas are carnivores. Dogs and cats don’t need carbohydrates, but they can use them perfectly well as a source of calories. Eating grass is a normal behavior, not an attempt to self-medicate. A historical use of marijuana was “take one pill every morning facing the sun and after 100 days one will see ghosts”.
Conclusion: An excellent resource
I highly recommend this book. It’s well worth reading even if you don’t have a pet. It is well-written and easy to read, with clear explanations provided in a conversational tone. McKenzie is respectful of most questionable treatments and describes the positive research findings, although he points out their failings. He provides exhaustive references, including all the classic skeptical articles and books as well as all the pertinent studies published in both the medical and veterinary literature. It’s a useful compendium of information on alternative medicine for animals, and it teaches readers how to figure out for themselves whether they can believe a new health claim.
If pet psychics really had access to animal thoughts, they might tell you the dogs, cats, and other companion animals of the world are very grateful and would like to thank the author. I once played a pet psychic in a role-playing exercise (it was great fun and easy to make stuff up. “Fluffy tells me she loves you and sitting in your lap reminds her of her mother – and the more expensive brand of food tastes better – and she wants you to buy this book!”). Since I know animals can’t read or speak for themselves, I will speak out for them: thank you, Brennen McKenzie, for this book, and for all your hard work and clear thinking!

Dog breath and stinky studies: Do pets need to be knocked out for dental care?
Most professional veterinary organizations recommend anesthesia to ensure thorough dental care for pet dogs and cats. Despite this, some companies are trying to mislead the pet-owning public by claiming they have high quality evidence showing they provide the same benefit without the risks. Their research smells worse than old chihuahua breath.
Greg Bishop on April 13, 2018
Link

I think anyone who’s ever been around a dog recognizes that their mouths usually stink pretty bad. “Doggie breath” is an endearing term for halitosis, or foul breath, and it’s extremely common. While technically speaking, there are a few different causes (including dogs guilty of recreational coprophagy), by far the most common cause of “doggie breath” is dental disease. And specifically periodontal disease, which is in fact the most common exam finding when dogs go to the vet. If you were to go to the dog park on any given day of the week and look in some dog mouths (I’m vaccinated against rabies so I have no compunction about doing this), you’d have a very high chance (upwards of 80%) of finding evidence of periodontal disease. It’s about the same for cats, but there aren’t any cat parks that I’m aware of (this might be the closest thing?).
Periodontal disease in dogs and cats is complicated, so without going too far into the weeds, what you need to know is that it’s related to plaque buildup and affects pretty much all of our dogs and cats (wild canids get it too, sorry appeal-to-nature-folks). There is a whole residency training program and professional association of veterinary dentists who tackle the complicated cases. For most dogs and cats though, typical plaque buildup can be treated with a dental cleaning by a veterinarian in general practice. The process is actually almost exactly the same as for people and involves: scaling, polishing, x-rays (radiographs), probing, and charting. We do these routinely on otherwise healthy pets, because in addition to making the animal feel better (periodontal disease is inflammatory and painful), there are systemic effects that are likely detrimental to health.
There is a big caveat in doing a dental cleaning in animals though, and it is this: it must done under anesthesia. The obvious reason is, that unless you’re a masochist, nobody likes going to the dentist. And when animals think “I don’t like this”, and people have to perform a procedure that requires the dexterity of a model-ship builder (e.g. placing a fine tipped ultrasonic scaler in the tiny gap between the teeth and the gums), it’s pretty much impossible to accomplish anything with the animal wiggling, squirming, or even thrashing and trying to bite. Not to mention that they have no idea that they’re benefitting, so they are usually terrified and feel like they’re in the movie The Running Man. Anesthesia lets the animal sleep through the procedure without remembering anything scary, and lets the veterinarian and technicians assess and clean the teeth thoroughly. Although anesthesia is necessary for success, most pet owners are put off for a couple of reasons, (1) they’re scared of the risk of anesthesia, and (2) it makes things more expensive.
Anesthesia for healthy pets is actually pretty safe though , with a mortality rate of about 0.05 to 0.15%. It is higher than for people (for comparison, the US anesthetic mortality rate for people is about 0.001%, or 50-150 times better than for dogs), but it’s still very rare for anything to go wrong. And the benefits of a healthy mouth do outweigh the risks for most pets with moderate to severe dental disease. As for the cost, that’s always going to depend on a number of factors such as what their veterinarian charges and what value the owner puts on dental care. If we consider the cost of a dental cleaning to be an investment in improving a pet’s health and quality of life, that makes it worth it to some people.
Most pet owners are aware their pet’s teeth are a problem. There is (fortunately) a proven solution: a standard dental cleaning. However, (unfortunately) many of them are afraid of this treatment because they lack important information (i.e. the benefits and low risk). What steps into this gap? SBM readers will know right away: pseudoscience! Heroically diving into this chasm of doubt and apprehension are a number of entrepreneurs willing to provide a service that purportedly fixes the problem: clean the teeth without anesthesia, and to do it for way less money! You can find these services all over the place (not only AFD but also a bazillion pet dental care products, very few of which are scientifically tested; if you’re looking for which have some evidence behind them, the nice people at the Veterinary Oral Health Council have done the work for you) and there are a number of names and acronyms for them, but for now we’ll call them anesthesia free dentals (AFD for short, I thought about Dental Anesthesia Free Treatment but that seemed mean).
What is AFD?
Here’s what happen during these services: someone removes visible tartar off of teeth, then they take money from pet owner, and pet owner leaves feeling like they just saved a bunch of money and avoided a risky procedure. “My vet is such a jerk for suggesting that we knock Mr. Fuzzybottom out to clean her teeth! Now her teeth are perfectly clean! Why are they so greedy?” And to most people, the teeth do look better, because the crowns of the teeth don’t have any gross brown gunk on them anymore, which is what they think the benefit of a tooth cleaning is. What does not happen during this procedure though, is any tangible benefit to the pet. There is an important reason for this, and that is because the vast majority of inflammation (and thus pain and detrimental health effects) is underneath the gumline.
Look at the gums of a dog who’s just had an anesthetic free dental, the crowns look pretty good, but the gums are bright red due to persistent gingivitis. That’s because in an awake animal, it’s usually extraordinary difficult to clean that space (and impossible if using better equipment like ultrasonic scalers and polishers that use water irrigation). The owners have just paid to have a cosmetic procedure performed and are now even less likely to do an actual dental cleaning. Worst of all, the animal just had to sit there while somebody scraped their teeth, and they don’t get any benefit from the procedure. If I haven’t made it clear, you have to get below the gumline to benefit the animal. When we talk dental cleanings in dogs and cats, we’re generally talking about the subgingival and periodontal spaces, which are (you guessed it) below the gumline. Good luck getting there when the pet is awake.
That has not stopped people from marketing and selling AFD services. There are licensed veterinarians who provide the service, despite the American Veterinary Medical Association and the American Veterinary Dental College (among many others) taking official positions against the practice. Whether or not these people are doing it because they truly believe in its efficacy, or because the demand leads to profit, who knows? The people selling AFD services run the gamut from mobile dog groomers to well-respected veterinarians. There are even national brands emerging who incorporate their techniques into existing veterinary clinics. One such example is Pet Dental Services Inc., a company that has stepped into the fray to provide AFD cleanings with the flimsy veneer of scientific and professional authority.
Pet Dental Services has an 11-step AFD process that they’ve created and are willing to incorporate into your local veterinarian’s practice. I guess a process with 12 steps was already being used (hmmm, maybe that’s why they left out anesthesia?)? Anyway, don’t be fooled by the officialty of counting strides, nor the equally authoritative acronym-izing of the service (it’s called a “Professional Outpatient Preventative Dentistry”, or POPD). They claim their service is different from most AFD care, since it’s under the supervision of a licensed veterinarian, they even have a button on their website to “report an unlicensed cleaning”, presumably someone providing a similar service but not under the direct supervision of a licensed vet. They claim that they are “the only company proven safe & effective through a double blind study conducted with dental specialists”.
This is extremely misleading.
The company has a “report”, although I think to call it a scientific study is inaccurate, and calling it “double-blinded” is delusional. There are a lot of problems with the report, even if we give them a pass on the blinding: the fact that it’s published in an unreliable journal (“unreliable” is generous, see the Skeptvet’s assessment of the IVC Journal), doesn’t have any board-certified veterinary dentists involved (but, for reasons unknown, has three human dentists as co-authors), and is full of splleing erorrs. It has the superficial appearance of being a scientific study, but it really does not hold up to even half-hearted scrutiny (which I’m happy to provide).
Here’s what they did: researchers took a dozen cats and a dozen dogs, did an AFD on them including charting dental lesions, then put the animals under anesthesia and had a veterinarian do a standard oral exam (including periodontal probing, full mouth x-rays, and checking for calculus under the gingiva). The first and second assessments were compared in terms of the pathologic findings. They claim that they were able to perform the procedure on all patients, that there was no residual subgingival calculus (remember that’s the important stuff that we really care about), and that there were no complications from the procedure. They are using this study to tout the procedure’s efficacy and safety.
Their conclusions are not even a stretch, they are a yoga move only achievable by teleportation. This is a really bad study. There are so many problems with its design, measurements, and even the conclusions reported that it presents almost no meaningful information. It reeks of bias like a Gilroy festival.
Can you perform a dental cleaning on awake pets?
The researchers stated that 100% of the animals allowed the technique. The most obvious, glaring, enraging problem is that they conveniently (their word, not mine, but my italics) selected the patients who underwent the procedure. They included only animals who would allow them to complete the procedure, so of course they all allowed it. This is not the general population of dogs and cats, and anyone that’s ever tried just to brush a dog’s teeth should be suspicious of this number. I would guess that only a small percentage of pets out there would allow this to be done to them, and that there would be a lot of injuries (to people and animals) if this was tried on every pet with dental disease. They also completely gloss over the fact that animals with advanced dental disease would absolutely require anesthesia for full assessment and treatment.
Also, despite their perfect compliance, they stated that during the AFD, the technician “recommended radiographs for 100% of the patients and recommended anesthetic dental treatment for 15 out of the 24 (62.5%) patients”. Anesthesia is required for radiographs, so 100% of the dogs undergoing this procedure would have required anesthesia. Huh? How is this evidence that an anesthesia free dental is effective? They also stated that 88% of patients had radiographic findings, which is a majority I believe [double checks with a second grader], yeah, it’s a majority! So if you don’t do an AFD, there’s an 88% chance that you’ll miss radiographic evidence of disease, and if you do an AFD, there’s a 100% chance that you’ll get a recommendation for radiographs. And that’s in your 100% hand-picked population of pets with mild dental disease.
The combination of cherry-picking patients to include and then apparently recommending that all of them get an anesthetic dental anyway seems like poor evidence that this procedure is worth anything. But for sake of argument, if you could do this on most pets and they didn’t end up needing anything that would require anesthesia, can you effectively clean the teeth?
Do you remove the subgingival plaque and tartar (or, does it actually work?)
This is the nitty-gritty, meat and potatoes, brass tacks question. If we give the researches a pass on their generous patient selection and ignore that they are recommending anesthesia for every pet after this procedure, did they measure any reasonable benefit? You’d assume they would have some pretty objective data showing that all of the subgingival plaque and tartar was removed. Actually, you might not assume that after getting this far in the paper, but that’s what they should have done. Instead they had the veterinarian use compressed air to peek under the gingiva and say if there was any residual tartar. And the veterinarian said there wasn’t. That’s it. No control group of pets who’d had a dental under anesthesia (or hadn’t gotten any treatment). No objective measurements of subgingival plaque and tartar (they could have used thiol strips or a disclosing agent). Just the veterinarian, who wasn’t blinded because every animal had the AFD done to them, looking and saying that they didn’t see any tartar. Do we take their word for it? Maybe if the rest of the study was watertight, but I have my doubts. And yet this finding is touted as conclusive proof of how effective their technique is.
Looking through the rest of the paper, the researchers confusingly report that lesion identification was much higher in the AFD than when the veterinarian was performing a standard dental. They explain this by saying AFD probably over-diagnosed pathology because the technicians performing it didn’t know what they were doing, but there’s no control for differently trained observers. Maybe the technicians are over-diagnosing because it’s really hard to probe the mouth in an awake animal. There’s also some hand-wringing about how this service must be done under the supervision of a veterinarian and that it’s not a replacement for dental cleanings under anesthesia, but then use it to market the effectiveness of not using anesthesia for dental care. They also try to explain away the high rate of radiographic findings by pointing out that half of the animals with findings had had an anesthetic dental within the last two years, a subtle attempt to discredit standard dental care. But since most people don’t provide any meaningful dental care for their pets at home, two years is plenty of time to develop radiographically significant disease. Plaque formation starts within a day of a dental cleaning, and without daily tooth brushing, these numbers don’t seem surprising at all. If you don’t believe me, stop brushing your teeth or going to the dentist for two years and get back to me.
Conclusion: AFD cannot be declared effective
        ◦ I completely disagree with the authors’ conclusion that their study showed AFD works and that it’s safe. This is not evidence that AFD works, and promoting it as rigorous science on the front page of their website is deceptive to consumers. I hope that my veterinary colleagues will take a critical look at this study and not just glance at it superficially. Fortunately the major veterinary organizations are taking a stand against these practices. There is a wide range of AFD providers out there, from the outright illegal practice of AFD without the supervision of a veterinarian, to the medically questionable ones done under a veterinarian’s care. Pet Dental Services appears to be flashing scientific credentials, but there’s no there there. If they can do a better study that shows real world applicability and doesn’t mislead the public, it will be important and helpful. To be fair, the company has stated that they are working on a study that fixes all of the problems in the original. I have my doubts, but I’ll be happy to take a look when it comes out. Their current paper appears to be just a marketing tool though, and unfortunately I think it will lead some pet owners to avoid actual dental cleanings and possibly even distract them from the importance of home dental care (i.e. brushing).

Do I really need to do a fecal test on my dog every year?
Why do vets want your dog’s poop so bad? Why does it have to be fresh? WHY IS IT SO WARM WHEN I TOUCH IT? WHY?? WHHHYYY?????
Greg Bishop on September 11, 2020
Link
Poop. We all do it. Pets do it too. It’s normal, but also gross. When you carefully scoop up the latest handiwork of your pet’s large intestine into an old newspaper bag, you can’t help but immediately scan for a neighbor’s trashcan to toss it into. And since we’re all so averse to turds, why is your veterinarian sending you a postcard begging you for fresh feces? Why are we greedily requesting that mushy bag like it’s full of brown gold?
We’re not trying to embarrass you by making you drive to the clinic with a steamy bag of poop on your dashboard. We’re looking for parasites!
But, you’ll contend, I never see worms in her poop! Ah yes, we know that. We do more than just look at it. Not to denigrate your own diagnostics capabilities, but we run analysis on the samples checking for microscopic evidence of parasites.
But the poop looks normal! I also understand the viewpoint that, if there are no gastrointestinal symptoms, it may not seem necessary to test for little creepy crawlies. Instead, why not put the money towards something your dog will actually appreciate?
Why are fecal screens done?
The poop that you awkwardly place on our front desks annually is part of our efforts to keep your pet healthy. It’s screened for parasites that are common causes of both animal and human disease. The reason you don’t routinely do this at your own wellness visits is that gastrointestinal parasitism is not a common human health problem in more developed countries. Animals, however, often with a slightly lower aversion to consuming their own feces, are still frequently infested by these internal freeloaders.
There are all sorts of strange life forms that can live inside of your dog or cat. Watch this informative music video for an overview. Although often shed asymptomatically or causing mild signs, some can cause severe disease including death. Roundworms, one of the more common dog parasites, can kill puppies if not treated. Killing puppies, I think we can all agree, is bad, but roundworms are actually even worse than that. If a human gets exposed to the infectious larvae, they can invade and damage tissue including the eye (warning, this photo will definitely gross you out).
Being capable of detecting gruesome disease is only one aspect of why fecal screens are done. There needs to be some level of the disease within the population to make screening tests useful. You can make arguments about where the cutoff level is based on how severe the disease is, how susceptible the population is, and what the risk is to environmental and human health. But in the case of intestinal parasites in pets, the prevalence of disease alone may be enough to justify widespread fecal testing.
There are a number of studies that have estimated parasite prevalence in pets. The populations investigated differ somewhat, but the most recent one involved over 3,000 dogs across the US and found that 20% of the dogs had at least one parasite. And since there are close to 80 million owned dogs in the US, that roughly equates to a crapload of parasites. The prevalence varies by parasite, geographical region, age and underlying health of the dog, and whether or not a heartworm preventative was being used (which also treats many intestinal worms), among other factors. For cats, the numbers also vary wildly, but the most recently published article showed that about 25% of feline fecal samples were positive for parasites.
The point is that intestinal parasites are still common in pets. One of the most common parasitic infections in pets in North America is Giardia, with the most recent study showing a prevalence of about 13% in dogs. In humans in the US, for comparison, the number of reported cases is less than 0.001%. Dogs are waaaaaay more likely to actually be hosting and transmitting these organisms than people. Even though people in the US don’t commonly carry parasites, exposure to animal parasites can be quite high. As much as 5% of the population have antibodies to a common dog and cat parasite, Toxocara (the one in the scary photo from before).
WORMS? IN MY PRECIOUS?! HOW DARE YOU!
You can’t usually see most of the stages of parasites in feces, so it’s probably not worth your while to comb through each defecatory production in search of worms (believe me, some people try). Some animals are also asymptomatic carriers, so even if your pet has “normal” poops, it doesn’t mean they’re “clean”.
As any ferret-legger will tell you, lifestyle choice can be a risk factor. For dogs, going to the park and running off leash increases the chances of contracting a parasite. But unless you are raising hermetically-sealed Labradors, there are enough parasites and enough modes of transmission that it’s hard to completely eliminate any exposure. Even the use of monthly heartworm preventatives doesn’t guarantee that your dog is parasite-free, since organisms like Giardia aren’t treated by those medications.
There is the issue, as in all screening tests, of the risk of overdiagnosis leading to unnecessary medical care. But in general, the treatments for gastrointestinal parasites are pretty benign, and the tests accurate enough that this problem is relatively minor. And especially given the high prevalence of these diseases, the risk-benefit ratio seems in favor toward screening.
Conclusion: It doesn’t hurt to check, what else are you going to do with that poop?
Truthfully, no one has ever rigorously evaluated the question of whether or not doing an annual fecal test makes your pet’s individual health any better. There is no mandate that says you must deliver warm dog poop to your vet’s office every year, but parasites in dogs are still common enough in developed countries that it’s not a bad idea. If you have a young dog, visit the dog park, don’t use a heartworm preventative medication, have a known coprophage, or listen to Nickelback, doubly so. You are never going to have zero risk unless your dog is a Tamagotchi. If you want an idea of what parasites might be lurking in that dog turd you just stepped in, check out this industry-funded organization’s interactive map. And pick up that poop, people!

Heartworms, fear-mongering, and perilous advice. The bad recommendations of Dr. Peter Dobias regarding heartworm disease in dogs.
A veterinarian is claiming to expose the pharmaceutical industry by helping you avoid parasite-preventing medications. His message is based on a dangerous misunderstanding of heartworm biology, carries several contradictory claims, and will lead to some serious risk for your dogs if followed. But on the plus side, if you’re a heartworm, this is great news!
Greg Bishop on August 17, 2018
Link

The reduction of parasitic diseases is one of the marvels of modern medicine. In the developed world, these infections in people are rare thanks to sanitation and continuously-improving treatments, but worldwide they are still an enormous problem, with an estimated one million annual deaths in people attributable to parasitic diseases. Although most of those deaths are from a single protozoal parasite (malaria), other typically non-fatal parasitic disease are extremely common in the developing world. For example, about one billion people are infected with roundworms, mostly in tropical and subtropical regions. In domestic animals, especially our pets, we can see some of the same patterns. It is unlikely that a Yorkshire terrier who poops on AstroTurf on the 50th floor of a high-rise building will get a roundworm infection.
We have also been very fortunate in the past few decades to have developed very safe and effective drugs such as fenbendazole, ivermectin, and pyrantel pamoate, all of which are used in both people and animals for a variety of parasitic infections. Some of these drugs can be used prophylactically, such the use of ivermectin to prevent tens of thousands of cases of a devastating disease called river blindness. In dogs and cats, we routinely “de-worm” with these drugs to prevent the spread of parasitic disease, often without knowing if a specific animal is infected or not. One of the best examples of this in veterinary medicine is the use of ivermectin-like drugs to prevent heartworm disease. These drugs have been around for decades, are safe, and very effective in preventing this serious infection.
But people being people, and alternative veterinary medicine being what it is, can’t leave a solved problem un-meddled with. There is of course a movement against the use of parasite-preventing drugs based on fear and misconceptions (see my post about flea products). And heartworm disease, arguably the most serious (my definition of serious = incidence x severity) parasitic disease of dogs in the United States, has unfortunately not been spared the bumbling interventions of alternative practitioners.
Dr. Peter Dobias is a veterinarian who has written an alternative heartworm prevention guide (and also here). The pitch is that you’re exposing your dog to dangerous chemicals if you give heartworm preventatives, and that you can completely avoid doing so if you really understand heartworm disease. It is extremely deceptive and factually inaccurate, but the falsely-compelling narrative will probably convince some dog owners. If this were just a silly alternative therapy that wouldn’t cause any problems, it might not require a response. The problem is that this protocol is going to put some dogs at serious risk if it is followed.
Background info: A heartworming story
Heartworm disease in dogs is potentially life-threatening parasitic infection. The extremely condensed life history of this parasite is that it is spread by mosquitoes, mainly infects dogs, has a relatively long incubation period of about six months, and is a seasonal problem in many parts of the world. There is a treatment for heartworm infections, but it does carry some risk of serious complications, so the main strategy used to deal with heartworm is to prevent it altogether. Fortunately, at certain points in their development the larvae can be killed by ivermectin-like drugs known as the macrocyclic lactones (hereafter referred to as MLs) before they ever reach the lungs to cause damage.
The catch is that there’s no good way to know when your dog has just been infected with these vulnerable stages. So instead of only treating after an infection, we prevent infections altogether by giving all dogs in heartworm-endemic areas a ML once a month during heartworm season (since the “vulnerability” window is about 45 days). If any larvae are transmitted to the dog, they get wiped out by the ML without anyone ever knowing.
This is a classic preventative strategy: cover an entire population with an effective tool that stops the spread of an infectious disease since you don’t know exactly who is going to be exposed (think vaccines to prevent viral and bacterial diseases, condoms to prevent STIs, making teenagers listen Nickelback to prevent devolvement into Canadian post-grunge pop rock fandom, etc.). It’s not perfect because you are treating lots of animals that won’t necessarily get infected and lots of dogs never get MLs for heartworm prevention, but overall infection rate is reduced. This is an acceptable strategy, especially when the preventative tool is not or is minimally harmful (e.g. all the above examples except Nickelback).
The claim
So we have this somewhat crude yet effective strategy for preventing heartworm infection. And pharmaceutical companies are involved (they produce the drugs after all). You give me these two conditions and enough time, and I swear there will be spontaneous generation of an alternative medicine pseudoscience pharma-conspiracy. It’s like having Ben Affleck and Jennifer Lopez hang out in the early 2000s, something terrible is going to come out of it.
Not to disappoint, Dr. Peter Dobias and dogsnaturally.com have promised to expose a corrupt industry (a) and cooked up an alternative guide on how to prevent heartworm without medication (b). They claim MLs are dangerous (c), and he has created a safer, smarter way to go about things (d). Except that: (a) they don’t, (b) they didn’t, (c) they aren’t, (d) and he really hasn’t.
This is his alternative protocol: use a new PCR test to detect the early stages of the infection and only treat dogs that actually need it. It sounds brilliant because it bypasses all of the crudeness of the current strategy where we treat every dog without knowing which ones actually need it. But (not to give too much away), it’s based on inaccurate or baseless information and is a self-contradictory pile of lukewarm mush. However, in the principle of charitability, I will present his argument.
He states that heartworm preventatives are largely unnecessary and dangerous. His reasoning is that heartworm has about a five-month incubation (or prepatent) period between when the infection is transmitted and when clinical disease starts, and during this entire period you have an opportunity to easily kill the worms before they become adults, thus arresting the infection. His method of determining when you need to treat your dog is based on a different heartworm test than the usual heartworm antigen test run in most veterinary clinics. According to Dr. Dobias:
Advances in heartworm diagnostics now offer DNA testing on the basis of PCR (polymerase chain reaction) technology. This test done by Healthgene allows you screen for any presence of heartworm and is very reliable with practically no false negatives.
He suggests that instead of giving your dog a preventative, you test it every four months. If the dog stays negative, congratulations! You’ve just avoided paying for all those preventative drugs!* If the test is positive, however, he says don’t worry, your dog has the worm larvae but you can easily treat it. Wanna know what he recommends treating your dog with? A heartworm preventative drug. Yes, these were dangerous chemicals before but now they’re okay. There is not a hint of irony in his guide about this, he says at this point it’s safe but be sure to check with a holistic veterinarian first. He congratulates himself on his clever protocol by concluding:
It is possible to completely eliminate heartworm drug use if DNA testing is done on a regular basis.
If you’re wondering how the words “completely eliminate heartworm drug” and “heartworm preventative can be safely administered” can be just a single page apart in this guide, and what this mind-numbingly erroneous reasoning means for the entire protocol, you’re on the right track.
The problems add up
There’s a reason (besides the Illuminati and Lizard people running the government) that Dr. Dobias hasn’t shaken up the entire veterinary industry and devastatingly exposed pharmacorporate corruption. He dun messed up. He made a few boo boos. Actually, he got completely mixed up and wrote a fatally flawed protocol with a fundamental misunderstanding of the disease he is supposedly an expert on, and he’s potentially put pet dogs’ lives at risk.
A number of screaming red flags should be obvious already, but wait, there’s more. In the guide he states that the DNA test can detect “microfilariae” (presumably he means the third and fourth stage larvae since microfilariae infect mosquitoes, not dogs, but more on that in a second) in the dog before they have a chance to mature into the harmful adults, and therefore as soon as you get a positive DNA test you still have an opportunity to prevent a full-blown infection. He thinks he’s got the worms by their little cuticular gubernaculae**!
That the presence of microfilariae will lead to a positive DNA test is true, as the research validating the DNA test show. The problem is that microfilariae are not the vulnerable, infectious stage of the heartworm parasite that indicate there’s still time to prevent adult worms. They are in fact an absolute indicator of adult worms in the body, since microfilariae are the brand-new babies of heartworms made by… adult worms. If your dog has microfilariae in its blood, it’s got adult heartworms.
Okay, let’s give him the benefit of the doubt and assume that he knows microfilariae mean an established infection. Let’s assume that he meant the DNA test will be positive before that established infection, when the actual larvae are deposited by the mosquito. Because if that were true, then intermittent testing and treating positives would still be a good idea. Let’s be generous.
Say that you have a 3.99-month-old heartworm infection (i.e. your last test was negative but immediately afterwards your dog got infected and now you’re positive). You decide to give a ML because this is Dr. Dobias’ holistic protocol. Can you expect that treatment to be effective? No, dogs that get a ML 3.5 months after exposure to heartworm infection are still very much at risk for developing infection, because the efficacy of the drugs decreases as the larvae mature. In other words, your limited window of opportunity to prevent heartworms with a ML is less than 3 months, and probably less than 2 months. It’s been well established that waiting 4 months results in larvae maturing to adults.
Ok let’s give this protocol any chance to be effective and say you’ve got a more recent infection or that you’re testing once a month and the larvae are vulnerable to a ML. If you know that you have these vulnerable larvae, then you can give a ML and you should clear the infection. So, you do the DNA test on a blood sample from your dog. Will this sample be positive? Nobody knows, but heartworm larvae don’t enter the bloodstream for 45-65 days, so it’s completely plausible the test will be negative. The larvae are in the body but is their DNA reaching the bloodstream to be detectable? It’s not impossible since you could imagine some larval cells being shed, or some white blood cell granule blasting off a piece of the worm, and having that debris make its way into the bloodstream. But no one has published any data on this all-important question. If you miss any of these larvae, you are going to let them establish the infection. In other words, you need this test to be 100% sensitive (meaning no false negatives). Do you trust Dr. Dobias on this? It’s dubious enough to put any dog on this protocol in a heartworm-endemic area at serious risk of developing a heartworm infection
Conclusion: Alternative heartworm testing is literally risky business
I think we’ve stretched our generosity to the max, like a dachshund trying to get scraps off the dinner table. We have some dangerous misinformation presented as classic pseudoscience, and careful reading of the alternative heartworm protocol shows just how poorly-thought-out it is. There is, however, very often a “kernel of truth” in pseudoscientific claims. It seems to be just enough of a science-y scent to throw off the average person. And this case is no different. Dr. Dobias does correctly state that not every dog needs a heartworm preventative every single month, because heartworm is neither endemic nor year-round in every region. He is also correct that pharmaceutical companies and testing laboratories are motivated by profit to encourage prophylactic use of the drugs and tests in areas where it might not be appropriate.***
These points conceded, he gets most everything else wrong, and writes a dangerous protocol while ignoring the gigantic neon “hypocrisy” sign above his head as he pushes unnecessary tests. I didn’t want to go any further down the rabbit hole, but unfortunately, I clicked on his link for holistic heartworm treatment and it only gets worse. He’s recommending black walnut hulls to treat (or prevent, it’s not clear) heartworm, and says that as long as you don’t feed processed foods, don’t vaccinate, and give the right supplements (I’ll give you one guess where you can buy them), your dog shouldn’t get heartworm. This is bad, bad, bad veterinary medicine, nose to tail and needs to be expunged from the internet before it causes some real harm.
One last thing. Thanks for reading this far down and sticking with me on this far-too-long rant about a topic that should be almost immediately dismissible. Before I finish though, I cannot, CANNOT write a post about worms without shamelessly plugging my vet school’s epic rap noir track, “Worm Burden“. Since it covers some heartworm biology, I think it’s allowed. That is NOT the reason I wrote this entire post though. It’s not.

*Which runs around $10 per month (you just paid for the test, and for your vet to collect and ship the blood sample, which if it’s more than $40…well you see where I’m going with that one).
**My possibly incorrect understanding of what heartworm reproductive organs are called.
***These last two points are VERY controversial in the veterinary field. There are several factors that are important to consider here, none of which will fit into this post.

The English (Bulldog) Patient: What A Travesty of Canine Health Teaches us About Cognitive Dissonance
Bulldogs are cute, loveable, and borderline an abuse to breed. Their adorable faces are the result of intense selective pressure that is accompanied by a large number of misery-inducing health conditions for the pet, and cognitive dissonance for the owner.
Greg Bishop on July 23, 2020
Link
I unhappily present to you, an English bulldog. Cute, no doubt about it. They’re an exuberant, friendly, photogenic breed of dog. Easy to fall in love with. If you imagine one with a British accent, top hat and a monocle, they become painfully adorable and you will have a strong desire to own one as soon as possible.
Resist that unholy urge.
The sad truth is that English bulldogs are abominations of nature cursed with high rates of miserable health problems. Breeding these dogs for “cute” external appearance has led to an alarming prevalence of diseases with often-tragic outcomes. Although the health conditions of these animals are well documented, the breed is more popular than ever. This may be in part because many passionate bulldog lovers are wildly disconnected from an appropriate understanding of canine health. If you love something so much, it can’t be a problem, right? But we’re not talking about spicy hot Cheetos, we’re talking about a working airway.
Yeah but do dogs really need a trachea to breathe?
The classic bulldog face is the prototype for a condition known as brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome (BOAS). This literally means “short-faced” and “air-don’t-go-to-lungs”. They are also chrondrodystrophic, meaning their skeletons don’t develop normally and can contribute to neurological and orthopedic diseases.* These issues are genetic baggage from selective breeding, and are also seen in the Pug, French bulldog, and other smashed (ahem, short)-faced dogs.
The list of adverse health conditions known to affect bulldogs (and similar breeds) is long. Just to name a few, they are overrepresented in skin and ear infections, prolapsed third eyelids and inwardly rolled eyelids (entropion), cryptorchidism, atopic dermatitis, corneal ulcers, umbilical hernias, dry eye (keratoconjunctivitis sicca), gastrointestinal disorders, periodontal disease, heart disease, cancer, and others. Their expected lifespan is an appalling 7 years, several years shorter than the vast majority of other dogs.
Why can’t we stop making bulldogs?
So owning a bulldog is like having a DVD of Halle Berry’s Catwoman on your shelf, right? With all of your options available, it’s one of the worst choices you could have made. You’d hope this (purely hypothetical, of course) person would be aware of how bad their taste in movies is, and not suggest that it is in fact better than average. Likewise, you expect that people who own bulldogs would have a realistic assessment of their dogs’ health.
But, you already know how this story goes (no, not Catwoman, which is full of exciting plot twists). A recent survey of English bulldog, French bulldog, and pug owners found that these people live in a fantasyland of illusions. The survey asked people about their pet’s health in several different ways, sometimes taking the direct approach (i.e. “can your dog breathe?”), and sometimes asking the same question through a series of more objective questions about their behavior, such as an owner-reported breathing (ORB) score. This is a clever way to get a more accurate picture of the animal’s health, since it somewhat bypasses the subjective feelings of the pet owner but still relies on their observations.
When looking at the same animal in these two different ways, the study found:
Based on owner replies to clinical questions, nearly 40% of dogs reached an ORB score indicative of clinically relevant airway obstruction [20]. In contrast, when asked directly, only 17.9% of owners of these dogs considered their dog to have a breathing problem.
Which stinks, because breathing is essential for life, at least in the long run, at least for most mammals. It wasn’t that owners never recognized their animal had a problem, but:
…greater severity of signs was significantly associated with recognition of a problem in that domain, indicating that dogs may need to reach a critical level of clinical severity (a threshold) before owners consciously acknowledge their dog has a ‘problem’ that is somehow worse than just being ‘normal’ for the breed.
Much like seeing your friend drive a Chrysler Sebring, it’s gotta get real bad before you know there’s a problem. There were some other interesting findings from the study, including that owners of these dogs underestimated veterinary costs and how much exercise the animals would need. Which I mean, come on, there are higher veterinary costs because there are more things wrong with them, and people don’t exercise them as much because they can’t breathe normally. Those would be two good reasons to go with almost any other breed, except that these owners love their dogs so much. The authors measured the bond owners had with their dogs**, and it was higher than what’s been reported for other breeds.
Bulldog owners are bulldog people, they don’t think there’s a problem with their dog because these dogs are awesome! They are literally looking past all of these serious health disorders and getting completely enamored. Have you ever known someone in a bad relationship who was full of excuses for their partner’s terrible behavior? Did they own a bulldog? The authors speculate,
This deflection phenomenon may be driven by cognitive dissonance, where owners are aware of health problems in their dog’s breed, but find accepting these problems in their own dog as psychologically uncomfortable, instead deflecting the issues to other individuals. This may have led to the skewed distribution seen here, where a large proportion of owners, whose dogs by definition must be less healthy than average for their breed, overestimate their own dog’s health.
The health of most of these dogs, just like all the children of Lake Wobegon, was above average. And I would agree that it’s uncomfortable, psychologically and otherwise, to be part of the perpetuation of an animal without an appropriate respiratory system. It feels better to believe that there’s not a problem, than to know about it and know you’re partly responsible.
Conclusion: If you love something, you have to let it go
It’s pretty clear that we can’t keep breeding bulldogs as they are and ever expect them to be healthy. And yet denial of this truth seems firmly set in the bulldog-owning population. This study highlights the kind of wall science-based medicine runs into. Most people are probably all for applying scientific knowledge to better healthcare for their animals, but when that cold clinical assessment pushes up against the soft, Malassezzia-filled facial rolls of a bouncy English bulldog, what can you expect of people? What do you mean the dog I’ve wanted my whole life is literally a genetic dead end? Which region of our brains wins the gray matter tug of war, the “cuteness” neurons or the “I’m making bad choices” ones? Being factually correct is one thing, but understanding the emotions and beliefs that contribute to misperceptions is a requirement for long-term solutions to problems like the English bulldog.
There are a million problems with breeding animals for physical appearances and it’s not just bulldogs that are the problem. I’m not really judging anyone here, even if you drive a Sebring. I don’t hate bulldog owners, and the dogs genuinely are friendly and loveable. However, the continued disconnect between how people feel about their animals and health consequences of breeding needs to be explored. I have personally seen heart-breaking suffering in bulldogs related to their brachycephalic physiology. This misery is preventable, but will take more than documenting the actual medical problems in the animals themselves. Human psychology appears to be a significant barrier here, which is so often the case in science-based medicine.

*It also makes their spinal x-rays look like a jpeg compression error occurred.
**As measured by the Monash Dog-Owner Relationship Scale (MDORS).

The White Coat Effect in Animals: Reducing Fear in the Vet Clinic
Fear during veterinary visits is a problem for everyone involved. While everyone wants less of it, there is limited evidence to support any interventions right now.
Greg Bishop on November 23, 2018
Link


In recent years, there’s been an interest among veterinarians in reducing fear and stress for our patients. This is not because animals are becoming softer, thin-skinned millennials, but due to a greater awareness and concern for our patient’s emotional states. Which is great and I have no problem with that! But as so often happens, there are a lot of products and services that are now being marketed specifically for fear reduction before we have good evidence for most of them. What’s the science-based argument for any of these? There is a fair amount of research and fear and stress in dogs and cats, but very little of it directly involves the veterinary clinic, and (spoiler alert) there’s almost none directly investigating fear-reducing interventions.
Why is fear in the vet clinic a problem?
One thing that appears obvious and is backed up by research is that most pets are afraid when they come to the clinic, almost 80% of dogs in one study. Sometimes painful or scary things are done at the clinic, but often just being on the same block as the vet is enough to cause the Shih Tzu shivers. This fear response doesn’t benefit any of the parties involved. Pet owners don’t wants to see their animal in distress, veterinary personnel don’t want to feel like they are torturing their patients* (although some should be feared), and the pets themselves prefer to not be in a state of terror. Beyond the ethical unpleasantness of terrifying the animals we’re trying to help (I’ve unfortunately literally scared the crap out of many pets), increased fear and stress can have negative physiological consequences. While’s it’s unclear exactly how this relates to any specific diseases or conditions, if there is any effect, it’s probably not a good one! Fearful animals are also more willing to bite or scratch, which can lead to serious injuries to people and pets. There are plenty of animals that can’t even be examined without sedation, and I’m not just talking about dangerous large animals. If we could reduce fear in our patients, it would make life better for everybody.
How do we define fear in the vet clinic?
One of the big obstacles is that fear, unlike midichlorian count, is a difficult thing to measure. Although we all know it’s there, there is a bewildering amount of different measurements used to research fear. Consider the many different types of behavior that could signal an animal is afraid: trembling, panting, freezing, hiding, even urinating and defecating. Most animals don’t display all of them and few of them are specific to fear only, which makes it hard to get an objective “fear score”. Many metrics have been used (stress hormone levels, vital measures, behavioral analysis, owner surveys, etc.) but there is no universal assessment technique. This muddies the waters in fear-reduction studies since we are sometimes comparing apples to salivary cortisol levels.
What are the interventions that reduce stress of fear during veterinary visits?
This review covers a lot of what we know contributes to fear and stress in veterinary patients and recommendations for improving the situation. The striking thing about it is that most of the recommendations are based on opinion or extrapolated from other research findings. In the absence of any of other data, this isn’t necessarily bad. There are a lot of obvious things that should help, such as having a separate waiting area for dogs and cats (so that the two-pound abominations of nature known as teacup chihuahuas don’t feel like they’re surrounded by tigers). The late Dr. Sophia Yin wrote extensively on some extremely useful strategies for reducing fear in the clinic (for example, see this helpful guide on how to greet a dog) which have the support of most veterinary behaviorists. But given the aggressive marketing of low-fear strategies, shouldn’t we have tested and proven interventions?
I tried to find what I could in terms of clinical trials for fear and stress reducing strategies, but there’s depressingly little in the literature. I also wasn’t able to access every article or evaluate all the methodologies, and a systemic review this ain’t. What follows is a sparse collection of small clinical trials and extrapolations, which is as of right now the state of our evidence in reducing fear in dogs and cats visiting their veterinary clinics.
Handling techniques
Modifying some of the experience of being at the vet might be low hanging fruit, since much of what triggers fear in animals has nothing to do with painful stimuli (for example standing on a scale). Manual restraint, or “patient handling” is often necessary for giving vaccines or collecting blood samples, and varies enormously between different clinics. Despite a great deal of specific recommendations for “low stress” manual restraint, there is only one tiny study showing that these techniques showed some beneficial effects for dogs in a veterinary clinic. Owner-driven methods such as carrier training (a desensitization technique where low-grade gradual exposure to a typically fearful stimulus eventually diminishes its scariness) appeared to be beneficial for cats. There is a lot of potential here but very little that has been explored yet.
Drugs
When it comes to reducing fear in the short term (i.e. a 30 minute veterinary visit), oral sedatives are an excellent option because they can be given at home, are generally safe, and don’t last for very long. Despite there being a variety of drugs being commonly dispensed for this purpose, we have very few studies on pharmacological fear reduction in dogs and cats coming into the clinic. Both gabapentin and trazodone passed small controlled trials for cats but to my knowledge there are no trials in dogs. There are drugs that are effective for fear reduction in dogs (usually for loud sounds like thunder or fireworks)** and that would probably work just as well for veterinary visits, but no one has studied it yet.
Music
Of course the idea of using drugs to chillax pets conjures up sad visuals, so there is always a desire to look for “alternative” strategies. Nothing is more alternative than music therapy, and I’m not just talking about The Shins. Music has been looked at a lot for fear reduction in animals, but unfortunately there’s little to suggest that it would benefit pets in the clinic. To my knowledge there’s only one study on dogs in the veterinary setting, and it did not show any beneficial effect. There are some other studies in shelter dogs, including one showing they appear more relaxed when listening to Beethoven rather than Judas Priest (presumably exposing the animals to Nickelback was deemed too cruel to receive ethical clearance). In cats, there are no trials using music during exams, but there may be some physiological effects from auditory stimuli during anesthesia. It’s certainly an interesting and appealing intervention, but we need some more evidence.
via GIPHY
Music therapy inducing vestibular signs in kittens
Pheromones
The idea behind pheromone therapy is that we can hijack the vomeronasal organ with certain volatile compounds and trigger strong behavioral pathways. Pheromones do play an important biological role in many animals and are somewhat plausible, however, much of the data in small animals hasn’t been supportive. There are a couple of small favorable studies though, one showing an effect in dogs at the vet clinic, and one showing reduced fear response to thunder noise. The only study for cats in a veterinary setting did not show any benefit. It’s a mixed bag at best, but lest you think we on the veterinary side are the only ones outlandish enough to pursue pheromonotherapy, there is apparently a human-appeasing pheromone that is being used for psychiatric disorders.
Somewhat similar to pheromones, various scents have been evaluated for their effect on the behavior of dogs and cats, mostly in shelter situations. Because pets are very sensitive to olfactory stimuli, it’s possible that certain scents could affect behavior, but to my knowledge there is no routinely recommended scent or diffuser in veterinary practice. I suppose you could say we have no “common scents”.
Miscellaneous
Surprisingly, that’s the extent of the research that I could find. Similar to the names of Usidore the Blue though, there may be other types of fear-reducing strategies that I just have not heard of yet. There are a fair number of therapies that have been evaluated for fear reduction with loud noises, but nothing specific to fear reduction in the veterinary clinic. Pressure vests,*** homeopathy, acupuncture, and nutraceuticals (1, 2) all have small studies of varying quality in noise phobia trials. It’s hard to say exactly what we can extrapolate, but it is a starting point.
Conclusion: I’m afraid it’s not enough
The takeaway here is that there is barely any research on what actually helps to reduce fear in the veterinary clinic. You don’t need peer-reviewed research for every little detail of your life though, and if nothing else, the awareness of veterinary visits causing a negative mental state in our patients will probably ensure that our approach is more compassionate. I am very happy that veterinarians as a community are trying to reduce stress and fear in our patients, but I am also concerned that this genuine and positive movement is being so thoroughly commercialized.
Take, for example, the Fear-Free program, which certifies veterinary practices as “Fear-Free” (starting at around $300 per individual for initial certification). This is a somewhat extraordinary claim, since eliminating pet fear would seem impossible even under the best circumstances. Although there are some very good people behind this movement and they appear to be well-intentioned and science-based (they do offer research grants), there is a distinctive lack of evidence showing that their methods are actually effective. It’s not enough to extrapolate from the few studies of fear in veterinary patients and claim that these strategies are proven. We need pragmatic, tested strategies to prove that their certification is more than effective marketing.

* I’m not sure if the awareness of causing fear in our patients contributes to job dissatisfaction, but since veterinary burnout is such a pervasive problem, it seems at least plausible that reducing fear would also lead to happier veterinarians.
**The thunder noise model is actually a pretty good one for fear response in dogs. Both thunder noise and visiting the vet can stimulate extreme fear, are acute situations, and affect most dogs. We have a number of trials showing variable efficacy for all sorts of thing from drugs to pressure vests, to nutritional supplements for fear reduction in dogs. Although there are important differences, we can draw from this body of research when coming up with strategies.
***The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons has an excellent website full of evidence reviews.
.

Pee Values: Tapping into large databases to answer an awkward situation in veterinary medicine
A handy research tool has just helped answer some long standing questions about the spaying of female dogs and urinary incontinence.
Greg Bishop on May 24, 2019
Tweet


Veterinary medicine is a bit of an ugly step-child in the medical world. We practice our arts in a murky corner, struggling to keep up with the scientific knowledge in human healthcare and limited by various ethical, financial, and technical constraints. Never mind the limited time and financial resources, never mind the sharp teeth and claws unleashed on us by our patients; one of the hardest things about this job is trying to be a source of reliable information for animal owners. Clinical research in veterinary medicine makes up a tiny fraction of the overall medical literature. We rely on experience and extrapolate evidence from one species of bipedal ape perhaps more than we should. Often we resort to downright superstition. We are research poor.*
Take the case of urinary incontinence (UI) in female dogs. This common condition is a great illustration of the current disparity between how we practice veterinary medicine and what we’ve actually proven scientifically. Most veterinarians will tell you that if your spayed dog wets herself when she’s asleep, she has what’s colloquially known as “spay incontinence”. For years we’ve assumed that spaying female dogs (in some cases) leads to an inability of their urethra to completely seal off, resulting in UI. We’ve been spaying dogs for many decades, and long assumed that UI was one of those tradeoffs for an individual dog that is the price of spaying (among the many benefits of spaying, perhaps the most important is that Bob Barker told you to do it, and you don’t want to be on his bad side).
Most cases of UI are pretty medically benign, and most dogs do well on oral medications, though complications do (rarely) occur. However, these “accidents” can be a source of major frustration for pet owners, and some will actually relinquish their animals to shelters or have them euthanized. So it’s a minor problem for most dogs, but in many individual cases it matters quite a bit. You would think such a common issue that impacts the lives of millions of animals and people over many years would be well worked out.
Uhh, yeah…not so much.
There have been a smattering of research articles over the years but not what you would call a robust buffet of data. In recent years, we as a profession have been a bit concerned about some of the long term health effects of spaying and neutering, and what effect the age of the dog when she’s spayed is as well (summarized nicely here). There has been a flurry of activity to try and figure out what the costs actually are. Better late than never, right?! Urinary incontinence, being such a common problem, finally got a systematic review in 2012, evaluating all of the evidence that had been published on the issue of what effect spaying has on UI in female dogs. It was worryingly slim; only seven eligible articles, four of them had to be thrown out due to high risk of bias, and then mixed results from the last three. They ultimately had to conclude that at best:
The evidence for a causal relationship between neutering and urinary incontinence is weak, although there is some evidence of an association.
Hmmmm. That, like waking up to a urine soaked bed, is a bit awkward. Here we have veterinary dogma, the link between spaying and UI, being exposed as resting on evidence weaker than a leaky urethra. Only one of the eligible studies actually directly compared spayed and unspayed dogs. On the question of how important age at spay is, there were conflicting results, with two studies that said there was no effect and another study that said there was. Each study had only a few hundred dogs in it, and measured different variables in different ways. For example, the study that found the association between age at spay and urinary incontinence looked at dogs spayed as young as six weeks, whereas the other studies’ dogs weren’t spayed until 16 weeks. And it wasn’t certain that the age at spay was even recorded accurately.
What a mess. There have been a few more studies since this review that have given us some information about prevalence and possible risk factors, but each one of these is also limited by a small sample size among other factors. We have a very small number of studies with high risk for bias and a range of results. This is our best evidence for a condition that affects probably hundreds of thousands if not millions of dogs, and is one of the (we think) most common long-term complications of spaying. This is a problem that we should have well figured out by now, and it turns out all we have a hodgepodge of papers with various degrees of bias.
Typically in clinical veterinary research, we as day to day practitioners hope that a handful of academics in tertiary referral veterinary hospitals will do their thing and churn out the science to better inform us. But this top down system often puts conflicting interest at odds. The types of conditions that are important to someone who is implanting fluoroscopic-guided pacemakers in miniature donkeys** are pretty different from the concerns of the family vet trying to get Mrs. Fuzzybutt from peeing on the sofa. We just haven’t had good real world data for problems like these. Urinary incontinence, although very common, isn’t a disease of particular severity, which may be why it is so underrepresented in the literature.
Episode IV: A New Hope
Fortunately, we have a new way of looking at things. Dan O’Neill, a veterinarian and epidemiologist at the Royal Veterinary College in the UK, and others have been hard at work on a project called VetCompass. It works completely differently than our typical research models; rather than small groups of animals in specialty clinics, it collects huge amounts of data from primary care clinics and analyzes it together.
The system works by skimming electronic records from clinics who have volunteered their records, and churning out information on patient demographics and clinical information. This generates a huge amount of data that can be analyzed for patterns. This is standard epidemiologic research, which is extremely valuable and also extremely uncommon in veterinary medicine. A combination of lack of funding, relatively recent adoption of electronic medical records in veterinary medicine, and technological constraints have limited large-scale epidemiology in companion animal research. VetCompass is making up for lost time and investigating a lot of problems; in the last ten years the project has yielded over 40 peer reviewed studies, with more than a dozen projects currently in the works.
So how does looking at data this way help us out?
Back to bed wetting Dobermans for a minute. In 2017, the team published a paper after analyzing the VetCompass data for UI in female dogs in the UK. In contrast to the several thousand dogs in the studies on which our previous clinical knowledge about UI had been based, VetCompass was able to look at a dataset of over 100,000 dogs. After sifting through everything, they were able to compare rates of UI for different variables in female dogs. They had data on breed, spay status, body weight, and breed-relative body weight (an estimate for overweightness).
There were a lot of helpful and interesting findings from the analysis. One of the important findings was that the prevalence rate for UI was about 3%, which is likely much more realistic than previous studies rates of anywhere from 2 to 16%. Several risk factors were also identified. Breed mattered quite a bit, with Irish Setters having an eight-fold odds ratio, and other breeds such as Jack Russell Terriers having decreased odds. They also found that bigger sized dogs and dogs who were overweight had a significantly increased risk.
Did it pay to spay?
The big question of what spaying has to do with UI was, of course, one of the big areas of investigation. The data did show that spayed dogs are over twice as likely to be incontinent as unspayed dogs. This convergence of findings from the previous, smaller studies with this larger one strengthens the connection between UI and spaying, although it is less than the eight-fold increase that had previously been reported.
One of the limitations of the data is that spay status is often counted as a binary “yes/no”. If the age of the dog when she’s spayed does in fact play a significant role in the development of UI, it’s possible that there might be no difference in rates of UI between dogs spayed after a certain age, and unspayed dogs. We might be able to keep millions of dog beds dry by spaying dogs a little bit later in life. Alas, this question has still not been answered.
There are a number of reasons why this seemingly simple problem has been so hard to solve. If we had clear data on when each dog was spayed and when/if they had been through heat ever, it could help. But different breeds and sizes of dogs develop at different speeds, so even if two dogs are spayed at six months of age, one might be expected to be physically and reproductively mature, while the other might not. Additionally, UI often manifests years after a spay, so it’s not clear how the relationship between spay status and UI risk changes over time. In other words, it’s complicated, there are probably a number of contributing factors, and we haven’t looked hard enough yet. As I was preparing this post, however, the VetCompass team published results from another study exploring this exact question. They found a similar overall prevalence rate of UI, and similar increased risk for being spayed overall, but when it came to the spay age question, they wrote “No clear association was identified between age at spay and UI diagnosis.”
This does seem to shift the weight toward the side of spay age not being related to whether or not UI develops, and is more evidence that spaying is a more clear long term risk for UI.
Conclusion: Urine for a golden stream of big data research
In the case of UI, our clinical suspicion that spaying causes or predisposes dogs to leak is probably correct, but it’s a bit mind boggling this link has been simultaneously taken for granted and unproven for such a long time. VetCompass has come on the scene and yielded some very practical information. This is important for dog owners and veterinarians when making decisions and recommendations about when to spay.
Science based veterinary medicine has been plagued by a lack of good epidemiologic studies. We are pretty far behind our single-primate-species-treating colleagues, but projects like VetCompass are a wonderful breath of fresh air. Hopefully, more projects like it can harness the power of these large datasets to look at old problems from new perspectives. We have a lot of problems that stand to benefit from this type of research, and it’s exciting to see the projects that are underway already. This type of approach is not a silver bullet however, as has certain limitations of its own (such as dependence on the quality of medical records). But it is part of a comprehensive approach to medical research that can greatly improve the quality of medicine.

* While there are literally hundreds of peer reviewed human medical journals, there are only a couple dozen in veterinary medicine. I want to state very clearly that I have incredible respect and love for anyone who does clinical veterinary research and we’d be much worse off without them. I just wish there were a hundred times as many of them.
**No joke, the first case I was involved with on my clinical year.
.

What’s the Truth behind The Truth About Pet Cancer?
The Truth About Pet Cancer (TAPC) is a slick bit of propaganda. Although it contains some interesting, even promising ideas, these are unfortunately served with a heavy seasoning of misinformation and fear-mongering. Hypotheses and opinions are presented as established facts, and anyone who disagrees is suggested to be ignorant at best, venal and corrupt at worst.
Brennen McKenzie on July 13, 2018
Link

Editor’s note: With Clay Jones being unavoidably prevented from his usual slot, we instead offer a post by Brennen McKenzie for your enjoyment!
The Truth About Pet Cancer (TAPC) is a slick bit of propaganda. Although it contains some interesting, even promising ideas, these are unfortunately served with a heavy seasoning of misinformation and fear-mongering. Hypotheses and opinions are presented as established facts, and anyone who disagrees is implied to be ignorant at best, venal and corrupt at worst.
It would have been possible to make a substantive, accurate, and very interesting documentary about some of these topics, from ketogenic diets to the epidemiology of cancer in pets. The reason The Truth About Pet Cancer isn’t such a film, and isn’t especially concerned with the truth, likely has to do with the biases and agendas of the participants, which I have already discussed elsewhere. Many of these folks will be familiar to readers of SBM, and several were involved in the template for The Truth About Cancer, which Dr. Hall ably reviewed several years ago.
Participants
The participants seem to fall into several broad categories: 1) Proponents of pseudoscience and critics of science-based approaches in human health; 2) Proponents of pseudoscience and critics of science-based approaches in the veterinary field; 3) Mainstream veterinarians or researchers in legitimate scientific fields with an interest in or sympathy for “integrative medicine” or for unconventional nutritional approaches, such as ketogenic diets.
Individuals in the first two categories are clearly the architects of this bit of propaganda. Several of these are not only evangelists for alternative medicine and lifestyles but purveyors of quite astonishing and bizarre conspiracy theories.
Those in the third category mostly seem like pretty reasonable people, so their reasons for participating in this project are less clear. Some have been so blinded by their enthusiasm for a particular idea, such as ketogenic diets, that they are willing to overlook the use of their statements to promote pseudoscience and attack science and science-based medicine. Others may have been misled as to the nature of the project and how their participation will be used. Many say perfectly reasonable and science-based things in their interviews, though these comments are often interwoven with more extreme or unscientific comments to build a narrative that might not accurately reflect these views.
I have spoken to one person in this group who was actually quite angry about how their words were used and their implied support for claims they do not actually believe in. Others I have communicated with indicate that they stand by their own comments but take no position for or against the claims made by others. It is undoubtedly true that not every individual who participated agrees with every claim made by all of the other participants. It may well be that some of the more science-minded participants are not even aware of how bizarre and anti-science the views of some of the organizers and other participants are.
Regardless of how the more reasonable folks interviewed came to be associated with this project, however, their reputations are now tied to it to some degree, and it is their responsibility to disavow any aspects of the project they feel are inaccurate or untruthful or that misrepresent their views in some significant way. Failing to do this gives tacit approval and support to the project, and to the many falsehoods, errors, and attacks on science-based medicine it contains.
The argument
An exhaustive review of every claim made in this series would be impractical. Not all participants agree on every claim, and they are often too vague be assessed by a critical appraisal of the research literature. However, there are several consistent themes and hypotheses that run through the series, and it is important for the pet-owning public to know that the evidence, and the truth, is not what it is made to seem in this series. I will briefly cover the evidence concerning some of the major claims made in this series. Here is the general argument presented:
     1.  Cancer is rampant in dogs and cats. More pets are getting cancer and at younger ages than ever before.
     2.  The main causes for this are:
        ◦ Commercial pet foods; and
        ◦ Our toxic environment, including chemicals in commercial pet diets, vaccines, conventional parasite preventatives and medicines, GMOs, wifi and other emf sources, and many other bad things.
     3.  Science-based veterinarians like myself are ignorant about the problem and the causes, largely because of entrenched dogma and the influence of pharmaceutical and pet food companies. At best, we are ignorant, at worst we refuse to study and accept effective strategies for preventing and treating cancer because we make our living from sick animals and from foods and drugs that contribute to the problem. Conventional methods for treating cancer in dogs and cats (pejoratively described as “cutting, burning, and poisoning”) are (depending on the person being interviewed) vary between useful but insufficient, to totally ineffective, to actually causing more harm than benefit.
     4.  The TRUTH about cancer treatment is alternative therapies and diets are safer and more effective than conventional cancer therapy. These include:
        ◦ “Detoxing” with food and alternative therapies;
        ◦ Completely reinventing feeding practices, with an emphasis on fresh, raw, ketogenic diets and calorie restriction (feed them like the wolves they are inside); and
        ◦ A plethora of alternative medicine treatments.
Claims and the evidence
Claim 1: Cancer is rampant in dogs and cats. More pets are getting cancer and at younger ages than ever before
Examples:
You look back 50 years ago, where some will say that the cancer rate may have been 1 in 100 dogs. Today, according to PhDs, the dog has the highest rate of cancer of any mammal on the planet. Literally, from last year, them saying 1 in 2, to this year, 1 in 1.65 dogs will succumb to cancer…And 1 in 3 cats.
In my experience, we are seeing cancer in younger and younger animals.
Breast cancer rates have gone up despite every effort. Prostate cancer rates have gone up despite every effort. Virtually every cancer is more common now than it was then.
The cancer rate in pets parallels the cancer rate in humans. We’re all getting cancer.
We do see, commonly, dogs under 18 months of age with terminal cancer. What used to be a disease of the old is now unfortunately a disease of the young.
What’s scary in cancer, human cancer, from 2012 to now, 2016. The rate of increase in deaths per year is actually going up faster than new cases per year. So, this says we’re not making any progress. We’re not making any major progress in the war on cancer. It’s getting worse.
Part of evaluating this claim depends on assess what is actually being said. If the point is merely that cancer is common, that is certainly true. If the point is that cancer is more common than it used to be, then this may be true, false, or uncertain depending on which type of cancer, which species, and lots of other variables that are ignored in this series. As far as the specific numbers offered for cancer rates, these are misleading and largely meaningless, and they don’t conform to how rates of disease occurrence are usually described in epidemiology.
The claim that cancer rates are rising across the board in humans is clearly wrong. Overall cancer incidence in the United States is 439.2 cases per 100,000 people per year based on data from 2011-2015. This general figure isn’t really very useful since it leaves out all the important details, including who gets what type of cancer and what the risk factors for each are. However, since TAPC makes quantitative claims about cancer rates in humans and animals, I thought it worth providing some real data.
The latest evidence from the National Cancer Institute shows an overall decline in cancer incidence and mortality in humans, though incidence may be declining, stable, or increasing for some cancers and some populations. Dr. Gorski has previously addressed the claims that conventional, science-based medicine is “losing the war on cancer,” and he has demonstrated that, while the issue is more complex than the simplistic comments in this series allow, on balance such a claim is not true.
The risk factors for developing cancer are complex, and as these change so do the rates of different types of cancer. As fewer people smoke tobacco, for example, lung cancer rates decline.
Similarly, stomach cancer risks have declined over time as risk factors (including H. pylori infections, salt intake, smoking, and others) have declined. As new risk factors are identified and reduced, rates for associated types of cancer will likely decrease. The introduction of the Human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine, for example, has dramatically reduced the rate of HPV infection. Since HPV is responsible for most cervical cancer, and other cancers as well, this will likely dramatically reduce the incidence of this type of cancer.
The incidence of other types of cancer, of course, are increasing. Some of this is due to better diagnosis, as when prostate cancer diagnoses increased dramatically with the introduction of the prostate specific antigen (PSA) test and then decreased as the problem of overdiagnosis was recognized and screening efforts decreased. Other cancers are truly happening more often, due to an increase in relevant risk factors (for example obesity), or simply due to the aging of the population.
Cancer rates increase with age due to the accumulation of damage to DNA, cumulative exposure to environmental risk factors, and many other complex changes in biology that occur with aging. As science and science-based medicine do a better and better job of reducing preventable deaths in younger people and extending average life expectancy, the risk of age-associated diseases, including cancer, will naturally increase. Overall, however, the evidence does not support the claim that in humans cancer is a rampant “epidemic.”
So what about pets? Is cancer increasing in dogs and cats? The answer, unfortunately, is that nobody really knows for sure. The kind of epidemiologic data collected for humans to help assess cancer incidence over time is much weaker and more scarce for companion animals. The claims made in this series, therefore, are speculation and opinion, not established facts.
There have been only a few studies attempting to assess the rates of cancer in dogs and cats over the last 50 years. These have used different methods and different populations, and they have been conducted at different times, so it is very dangerous to make direct comparisons between them. Additionally, we rarely have accurate information about the age distribution of pet populations, cancer rates vary greatly between breeds, and there is dramatic variation in how much effort is put into finding and identifying different types of cancer in dogs and cats. There are no formal, organized screening programs, many dogs and cats receive little or no medical care, and owners often choose not to pursue a specific diagnosis when their pets develop a growth or become ill. Therefore, the real rates of different cancers, and any change over time, is very difficult to know with any certainty.
The studies that have been done do show some consistent patterns that likely reflect underlying cancer biology. Age, for example, is always a significant risk factor, with more cancers seen in older animals. The claim that cancer is becoming “a disease of the young” is certainly not consistent with the evidence we have.
Some breeds have higher rates of specific cancers, and this indicates genetic risk factors are important, despite suggestions in TAPC that this is a false assumption mainstream science is mistakenly obsessed with. Other individual risk factors are important as well, such as sex and location. Females, for example, have much higher rates of mammary cancer in populations where the dogs are frequently not spayed, but this common cancer virtually disappears from populations where early neutering is the norm. Trends over time are rarely reported and are difficult to interpret due to changes in study methods, our ability to detect cancer, and the willingness of people to seek diagnosis and treatment for their animal companions.
Here is a glance at some of the few epidemiologic studies that have been done on cancer incidence in dogs and cats:
    • Dorn, 1968 – 381.2 per 100,000 dogs over 3 years, 155.8 per 100,000 cats over 3 years
    • McVean, 1978 – 507 per 100,000 dogs, 412 per 100,000 cats
    • Reid-Smith, 2000 – 852 per 100,000 dog-years, 319 per 100,000 cat-years
    • Dobson, 2002 – 747.9 per 100,000 dogs/year
    • Merlo, 2008 – 99.3 per 100,000 dog-years (males), 272.1 per 100,000 dog-years (females)
    • Vascellari, 2009 – 143 per 100,000 dogs/year, 63 per 100,000 cats/year
The variation here is significant. This reflects the different study methods, time periods, locations, and many other variables. In general, the rates in dogs are similar to the much more reliable overall numbers reported for humans, while the rates in cats appear to be consistently lower.
However, the devil is in the details. In nearly all studies, mammary cancer is the most common cancer, and as a result females have higher rates of cancer than males. However, in populations where most females are neutered, mammary cancer virtually disappears, so these numbers don’t reflect this single, clear risk factor.
There is virtually no data to assess changes in cancer incidence over time. One of these studies (Merlo, 2008) used a database with nearly 20 years of data collection to attempt to make some assessment of trends over time. Here is their summary of that data:These data do show an overall increase in cancer incidence for males, though most of this appears to be only in the most recent time period. For females, cancer incidence has fluctuated over time, most likely due to changes in mammary cancer rates caused by more people choosing to neuter their female dogs. This single, tenuous data set does not support the dramatic claims of rampant global increases in all cancer made in this video series.
Another of the claims made in this series, that cancer is exclusively seen in companion animals because of their diet, vaccines, and other conventional healthcare is absurd and manifestly false. Belgua whales in the St. Lawrence River, for example, have a tremendous cancer burden. And Tasmanian devil populations have been decimated by a bizarre transmissible tumor (which I’m sure the folks behind the series will be disgusted to learn, is being successfully fought with a vaccine). This is just part of the Appeal to Nature Fallacy, the idea that somehow life without human activity or technology is better and healthier than. This is one of the main ideological pillars of the raw diet argument, and it is no less ridiculous applied to our pets than applied to ourselves.
Claim 2: Causes of cancer
The causes of cancer are claimed to include:
    • Commercial pet foods; and
    • Our toxic environment, including chemicals in commercial pet diets, vaccines, conventional parasite preventatives and medicines, GMOs, and many other bad things.
Though the main target of the makers of these videos are commercial pet foods and dietary carbohydrates, there are many other casual references to purported causes of the supposed “cancer epidemic” in dogs and cats. Nearly all of these are speculative and unproven, a few are clearly false, and a few may be true under specific circumstances, though even these are misrepresented and oversimplified in the videos.
Commercial pet food
Examples:
Processed food is toxic. There’s some studies that indicate it’s probably carcinogenic.
When we feed processed pet food, which is so rich in sugar, particularly the ubiquitous dry food, we are feeding the perfect cancer growth diet. Our veterinarians, our oncologists, and our friends in human medicine appear to have no idea that this is the case. And isn’t that terrible? We recommend foods to our cancer patients that are going to make the cancer worse, that are going to kill the patient.
How does the pet food industry feed cancer? They feed it very well! They feed it with sugar, and cancer grows on sugar.
The overly processed, no nutrition, high sugar and starch with actually toxic properties to it. That whole package is what scares me.
Any processed food is going to be a problem with cancer as far as I’m concerned.
There is a very well-known cancer-causing agent that all veterinarians learned about in medical school. It’s called aflatoxin. It’s a toxin that’s made by mold, mold that grows on grains. ..It’s in your dog’s food….When a vet says that food has nothing to do with cancer and they’re ignoring that stuff, they need to be replaced as a vet, or they need to read the research.
Most of the food is cooked, which means there’s no activity left in it. And the fact that it’s extremely toxic. I mean, you’re basically poisoning your pet.
Tens of thousands of dogs and cats live long, healthy lives eating commercial pet food. The idea that these diets are causing an epidemic of cancer, disease, and death and that mainstream veterinary medicine either hasn’t noticed or doesn’t care is nonsense. We cannot yet predict the “optimal” diet that will minimize any and all disease risk for a given individual. It may even turn out to be true that fresh, homemade diets have health advantages, though this has not yet been tested, much less proven. However, we can be quite certain that we are not feeding horrible poisons to our pets when we give them reputable commercial foods.
Humans, dogs, and cats are all very different species with different nutritional needs. Though they share an evolutionary relationship with wild canids, dogs are not wolves, and they have multiple genetic and anatomic adaptations to living with humans and sharing our food. They do not have a nutritional requirement for dietary carbohydrates, but they are perfectly able to utilize them as a source of calories and nutrients, and there is no evidence that dietary carbohydrates contribute directly to cancer or other disease risk in dogs.
There are only a few studies looking at diet and cancer risk in dogs and cats. Most of these rely owner recollections for data about diet, which has proven a very unreliable approach in people. There are no studies at all showing restricting dietary carbohydrates reduces the risk of developing cancer in dogs and cats.
One study from nearly 20 years ago is often cited to suggest low-carb diets are beneficial for dogs with lymphoma, a type of white blood cell cancer. However, the truth is that the study was really looking at something else (fish oil and arginine supplementation), not carbohydrates. Both the test and control subjects in this study ate the same amount of carbohydrates, and there was no apparent impact of the low-carb diet on their cancer.
Despite the constant drumbeat in this series that carbohydrates are synonymous with “sugar” (which they are not), and are toxic and carcinogenic, this claim is pure speculation. There are lab animal studies and epidemiologic research in humans which suggest possible relationships between carbs in the diet and cancer. There are interesting features of the metabolism of cancer cells that suggest diet might have some influence on cancer progression and response to treatment. But there is no real-world, clinical trial evidence that supports the claim that dietary carbohydrates cause cancer in pets or that lower carbs will prevent or help treat cancer.
There are many other unproven or clearly false claims made about commercial pet diets. I’ve debunked some of these over the years elsewhere. These are standard talking points for advocates of pseudoscience and alternative nutritional approaches, but they range from unproven hypotheses to outright nonsense, and none can fairly be described as proven facts.
“Processed” pet foods
I think it is also important to address the concept of “processed” food, since this term is egregiously misused in TAPC. Obviously, anything not eaten raw and unwashed is “processed” to some extent, the term is broad enough to be nearly meaningless. And despite the negative implications usually attached to the phrase, some kinds of processing clearly improve the safety and nutritional value of foods (washing and cooking, in particular). However, in TAPC, the term is used in an exclusively negative way, as a synonym for “unhealthy” and “toxic.”
Most people probably hear the term and think of snacks and convenience foods for humans – potato chips, packaged hot dogs, frozen chicken nuggets, and so on. And there is some limited evidence that such foods may increase cancer risk in humans. Whether this is simply an association (e.g. people eating such foods are more likely to be overweight, exercise less, and have other risk factors for cancer), or a causal relationship (something in these foods increase cancer risk, directly or indirectly through something like increasing obesity) is unclear. In any case, clearly no one thinks a diet of convenience foods and snacks alone is healthy, and mainstream dietary guidelines recommend plenty of fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, low-fat protein sources, and so on because there is evidence to support the health benefits of such a diet. Therefore, it is reasonable to wonder how a packaged commercial diet could be safe or healthy for our pets.
One key difference between human convenience foods and pet food is that the former are designed primarily to appeal to consumers. Taste, appearance, mouth feel, packaging, price, and most other characteristics of packaged foods for humans are aimed at getting people to buy them. Nutritional considerations are a negligible factor, apart from those that can be used as marketing tools (e.g. calling a cookie full of sugar “low-fat” or slapping a meaningless label like “no GMO” or “All Natural” on something to fool people into imagining it is healthier).
Pet foods, in contrast, are typically designed by nutritional experts to be complete and balanced, and support normal health. Sure, they have to be appealing to pets in terms of taste and smell, and to owners (which includes being affordable and often leads to plenty of meaningless verbiage on packages). However, extensive research evidence exists demonstrating the nutritional needs of companion animals, and meeting these needs is a core requirement for a pet food from a reliable manufacturer. Pet foods are intended to be the primary source of nutrition, and they are formulated and manufactured with this in mind.
Now most pet foods intended for adult maintenance or for growth in puppies and kittens have not been tested in large-scale, long-term clinical studies to demonstrate their impact on health. Some feeding trials are done for many diets, but these are foods, not medicines, so they are not required to meet that level of evidence. There are only a few commercial diets specifically intended for therapeutic medical uses, such as supporting animals with kidney disease, dissolving bladder stones, and so on. These have been through extensive pre-clinical and clinical trial testing to validate medical claims made for them.
While it would be nice to have this kind of data for all commercial diets, it is false to suggest this means the health effects of feeding commercial foods haven’t been studied. And it certainly makes no sense to suggest that alternatives, such as raw or homemade diets, are healthier when there is even less evidence for the impact of those diets. The limited evidence so far suggests these alternatives are likely to be nutritionally incomplete or unbalanced (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4) and have risks, such as exposing humans and pets to serious infectious diseases, that are not outweighed by any proven benefits (1, 2, 3).
In theory, fresh, homemade diets that are properly formulated might be healthier than commercial pet foods. This is a reasonable hypothesis that can and should be investigated. However, the folks behind TAPC are basing their claims entirely on ideology, misuse of pre-clinical science, and ignoring the evidence and expertise of real veterinary nutrition experts, who are repeatedly dismissed using the shill gambit. The fearmongering in this series about “processed” foods and commercial pet diets is not founded on real evidence and is deeply misleading to pet owners trying to make decisions about how best to feed their animal companions.
Toxins
“Toxins” are one of the classic bugbears of the pseudoscience community, and they make multiple appearances in the TAPC videos. There are too many claims to critique each in detail, but here is a brief list of substances purported in this series to be causing the supposed “cancer epidemic” in pets, along with some resources explaining why these claims are, at best, unproven and implausible and, in most cases, simply false.
    • Grains in pet food
Absolutely, grains can play a significant role on a risk of cancer…It’s a roll of the dice. Are you going to roll the dice and feed grains or not?
There is no plausible reason to believe grains are inherently harmful or increase cancer risk. (1, 2, 3)
    • GMO ingredients
We saw that the number one ingredient in this new formula that we had been forced to use was either soy or corn, I believe, one of the two big, bad GMO products that you never want to feed to yourself or your kittens…But we believe now that that was what killed the kittens, and we know, we know what GMOs, genetically modified organisms, we know what they do to stomachs.
We’ve already seen that the GMO corn is causing sterility and tumors in rats.
Decades of research have failed to find real evidence that GMO ingredients cause harm (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) or that “organic” or “non-GMO” ingredients have health benefits (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6).
    • Colors and preservativesNo reliable evidence has linked the presence of these ingredients in pet foods to any increased disease risk (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10).
    • Fungal toxins in pet foods
There is a very well-known cancer-causing agent that all veterinari­ans learned about in medical school. It’s called aflatoxin…It’s in your dogs’ food/
Corn and other grains are sometimes contaminated with molds which can produce substances toxic to humans and other animals. As with any toxin, the dose determines the effect. In high enough amounts, these can cause both acute and chronic illness. Fortunately, low levels of these compounds are not harmful. The FDA has guidelines for safe levels of these fungal compounds in human and animal foods. The guidelines for grains used in pet food are as strict, or stricter, than those for human consumption. There have been instances in which pet foods exceeded these levels and dogs or cats have fallen ill. However, these instances are the exception, in which food safety rules and protections have not been adhered to. There is no evidence that under normal circumstances these compounds are present at harmful levels in commercial pet foods.
    • Gluten
Pets are not meant to break down gluten. They don’t know how to break down gluten. It’s very toxic to them.
The gluten-phobia that has been influencing what people choose to eat is largely nonsense, and there is no good evidence that gluten-free diets are healthier for most people who do not suffer from celiac disease. The same phobia, unfortunately, has taken hold in those advocating for unconventional diets for pets, and there is even less evidence to support it. As with grains in general, there is no reliable evidence gluten has negative health effects on pets, other than a rare condition in the Irish setter.
    • Vaccines
We try to treat cancer with chemotherapy but that actually causes cancer, right? We try to prevent disease with vaccines, but they actually cause disease, actually cause cancer.
Considering they are very safe and probably the most effective healthcare intervention ever discovered, vaccines get blamed for nearly every disease we can’t firmly pin on another cause, and even some we can. In terms of cancer, there is no evidence that routine vaccination increases the risk of most cancers.
The exception is a rare disease known, appropriately, as Vaccine-Associated Fibrosarcoma (VAS) in cats. This has been estimated to occur in between 1 in 5,000 and 1 in 10,000 vaccinations. VAS occurs almost entirely in association with specific vaccines (killed, adjuvanted rabies and leukemia vaccines) which have largely been replace by non-adjuvanted vaccines. They also occur more frequently in some populations than in others, suggesting genetic and other interacting risk factors. While it is perfectly correct to say, based on this, “vaccines can cause cancer,” it is not correct to claim or suggest that vaccines are a common or important risk factor for any cancer other than feline VAS.
    • Flea and tick products
Flea and tick treatments. We are putting poisons on the back of the necks of animals, pills in their bodies that change the biochemistry of the blood. So, when a flea or tick bites you and drinks your blood it dies. That’s not gonna cause any cancer?
There is no reliable evidence that modern flea and tick preventatives cause cancer in dogs and cats. Rodent toxicity studies are sometimes cited to show this, but these don’t appropriately represent the real world since they use difference chemicals in a different species at much higher doses.
One case/control study in dogs from 1989 suggested an association between “topical insecticide” use and bladder cancer in a breed genetically predisposed to such cancer. Those who use this to support claims that flea control products cause cancer ignore a lot of important facts. For one, the study did not show causation, only association, and this has not been shown in other breeds not at increased risk for this type of cancer. This study also looked at flea and tick products which are no longer used, not at current products on the market which did not exist in 1989. Finally, there have been other studies since showing no association between this cancer in this breed and newer products and no association between flea and tick products and another type of cancer (lymphoma).
As usual, there is even less information available on this subject for cats. One study found no overall relationship between flea and tick product use and one type of oral cancer. Various forms of these products showed inconsistent and implausible association patterns (e.g. collars raised risk but shampoos were protective), and again none of the products commonly used today were studied.
Claim 3: Ignorance, bias, and self-interest
It is standard practice for proponents of unconventional, unproven, and quack ideas to begin by claiming that any opposition to these ideas must stem from ignorance, bias, or self-interest. TAPC claims that conventional vets don’t accept Claims 1 and 2 because of ignorance, financial self-interest, or the malign influence of Big Pharma and Big Pet Food, that conventional cancer therapy isn’t very effective, and that it often does more harm than good.
We’re not taught in vet school how to identify lifestyle obstacles that we need to be helping clients remove in order to prevent cancer from occurring…So, we’re waiting until these animals get cancer and then we have to talk about cutting it out, poisoning it out with chemotherapy, or burning it out with radiation.
Linus Pauling, you know two-time Nobel Prize-winning scientist has said, “Cancer research is the most fraudulent branch of research in the world.” And just we encourage this narrow thinking, non-reproducible results….We’re stuck in this dogmatic, narrow-minded view about what cancer is and it’s just not working.
We’ve got an industry that seems to be driven by the dollar as opposed to trying to help pets. Just the same way the cancer industry with people is driven by profit motive and they don’t care about the cancer patients. It seems the vet practice is the same.
When vets go to vet school they come with open hearts. They’re trusting to be taught up-to-date, the best information, but they’re not. You know why?… Currently what students are taught in vet school are taught by the veterinary pet food companies.
[Vets] haven’t really taken the time to look at it as much as their customers. So, when—it’s like going into a doctor’s office and you know that the client knows more than the doctor.
I think that’s a reason also why it’s not really researched in universities. Most universities get sponsored by these big billion-dollar companies, and you don’t really want to step on their toes, I guess.
Our dying prematurely and suffering is sustaining a huge medical industry to be profitable.
So, if your dog gets diagnosed with cancer, the doctor says “Oh, they have to have chemotherapy.” You put the dog on chemotherapy, and immediately their health starts to deteriorate because they’re being poisoned, right? The doctor says, “Look how bad the cancer’s getting.” This is a fraud…This is charlatanism. This is con artistry in medicine…That’s what these people are doing. They’re conning pet owners into chemically poisoning their dogs and cats and calling it medicine. But it isn’t. It’s animal cruelty.
If we have to use something that is known to cause cancer – radiation is immunosuppressive and causes cancer – to treat cancer, we’ve failed in the field of healthcare. Period.
The arrogance here, assuming no one might disagree solely because these ideas are implausible, untested, or demonstrably wrong, is pretty astounding. One wonders what kind of cognitive dissonance it takes to convince someone that the entire field of veterinary medicine is so stupid or so greedy that it is willing to overlook simple and obvious ways to prevent and cure cancer. How is this more likely or more reasonable than the alternative, that the small cadre of true believers in these ideas are simply wrong?
The claim that most vets know little about nutrition, and less than pet owners or alternative medicine practitioners who are “self-educated” from internet articles or books by other self-labeled experts with unconventional views, is untrue. While the true experts are board-certified veterinary clinical nutritionists (the vast majority of whom dispute most of the nutritional claims made in this series), all veterinarians have instruction in nutrition and the use of therapeutic dietary manipulations. All veterinarians can, and should, keep up with the clinical literature, which frequently addresses nutrition as a preventative and therapeutic practice.
Undoubtedly, the limitations of time and knowledge, which most vets must split among nearly all major areas of clinical medicine for several different species, does prevent all of us from focusing exclusively on nutrition any more than we can focus exclusively on cardiology, oncology, or dermatology. But we do have and use many resources and experts in the area of nutrition, as in all other areas, to help us maintain an evidence-based approach in this aspect of clinical practice. The training and continuing education vets receive in nutrition is substantial and reliable, and veterinarians are useful resources for animal owners looking for best feeding practices for their pets.
The corollary made in this series to the argument that vets know little about nutrition is that what we do know is worthless because it is tainted by association with the pet food industry. This is just a variety of the shill gambit, in which any information produced by anyone with a potential financial interest in the issue at hand is immediately dismissed as unreliable. While financial bias is a real issue in scientific research, the shill gambit is just a self-serving and hypocritical tool for not dealing with evidence against a claim and for distracting from the lack of evidence for that claim.
The folks in this series who believe conventional nutrition causes cancer and that their preferred unproven alternative approach is superior have no claim to better education in nutrition than the majority of mainstream veterinarians, and certainly less than the veterinary nutritionists who nearly all disagree with most of their claims. The makers of these videos also have their own financial biases since many make their living selling products and services, from clinical treatments to diets to books and videos about nutrition, all of which depend on convincing people their claims are true and undermining the mainstream approach to nutrition and cancer care. Finally, and most importantly, there is no real evidence to support the claims against conventional pet nutrition (as we have already seen) or the claims for the alternatives they are promoting (as we will see shortly).
The claims that conventional cancer therapy is ineffective, does more harm than good, or is even a form of animal cruelty, are similarly untethered to truth or evidence. The other authors here at Science-Based Medicine have addressed the myth that conventional cancer treatment doesn’t work (1, 2, 3). The declining death rates for many cancers are due partly to reduced cancer incidence (contrary to Claim 1 of these videos), but they are also due to improvements in treatments and outcomes. The options of surgery, radiation, and chemotherapy, so maligned in these videos, can prolong life and even cure cancer for many patients both human and veterinary.
And contrary to the propaganda in this video, conventional cancer treatment includes many other treatments as well. Immunotherapy, hormonal therapy, stem cell treatments, and others are available, and new treatments are being developed. Therapeutic vaccines, bone marrow transplants, and other novel therapies are being introduced which will continue to improve outcomes for veterinary cancer patients. Determining the right treatment for each cancer and each patient requires rigorous science, and there will very likely be no “magic bullets” that cure every kind of cancer. However, progress in cancer treatment is being made.
The videos are also wrong in asserting that science-based medicine blindly pushes chemotherapy, radiation and surgery. A recent study, conducted by conventional cancer doctors, has improved our ability to know which women with breast cancer are unlikely to benefit from chemotherapy, and this will change guidelines and practice to improve the treatment of such cancer patients. Reducing unnecessary and unhelpful testing and treatment, for cancer patients and all patients, has become a major goal in human medicine, and there are many of us working to bring awareness of this to veterinary medicine as well. The idea that science-based clinicians intentionally inflict ineffective and unnecessary treatments on patients for financial gain is not just offensive, it’s clearly false.
Of course, the attacks in these videos on conventional thought and practice in cancer treatment are intended to lead up to claims that alternative approaches are better. There is evidence that use of alternative therapies endangers cancer patients and often worsens their outcomes (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4), so this is a pretty unlikely claim, but let’s finish by looking at a couple of specific ideas from the TAPC series.
Claim 4: Alternatives are better
TAPC proponents claim alternative diets and other unconventional treatments are clearly safer and more effective than conventional nutrition and therapy for cancer. Examples include:
[Cancer cells] all ferment. Take away their fermentable fuels, that’s going to be the solution…When you make radical changes in diet, there are so many examples of cancer remission…No chemo, no radiation, no surgery, just a dramatic dietary change.
[Our dog] was given just a few months to live because of some type of a crazy tumor…So, we really stepped up her diet….really pushing her into a therapeutic ketosis. Within a few weeks her symptoms were gone…We then added in high dose CBD oil…Within a month her tumor went from the size of a very large grapefruit to the size of a grape.
Feed dogs that have cancer with higher fat, lower protein, almost no carbohydrate diets. In other words just the opposite of dry food. We’re seeing cancer, the remission of cancer.
[For cancer] I would do acupuncture. I would do Chinese herbal medicine, absolutely, if they can tolerate it, because some animals can’t, do the right nutrition, and maybe spiritual growth for the family…If all else fails, you talk to an animal communicator and you find out what the animal wants.
In holistic medicine, I think we’re extending lifespans and extending quality of life in a way that conventional medicine is unaware of…“I get them off of their kibble, which I lovingly call “death in a bag” in my practice…We talk over vaccination. I say, ‘Say it with me.’ I make them say it with me ‘No more vaccines.’ So, we repeat that chant, ‘No more vaccines.’
I got involved with essential oils because of my dog having cancer…I learned how to soak a dog in essential oils and since then I’ve become enamored with essential oils as a modality for managing cancer.
I had a case…where this mass was sticking out of its face…I was doing acupuncture, we were doing herbs, and the cat got better for about 6 months…then it started going downhill…[the client]came back in two weeks later and the tumor was 50% smaller…She said “I talked to an animal communicator and the animal communicator was talking to the cat and talking about energy medicine and how to use energy medicine to heal the tumor. And apparently the cat said back ‘Oh, I can do that.’
Sometimes we change the food and the cancer falls off….And you say, “Well, that can’t happen.” Well, it just did.
In the past 22 months…we have seen a 73% success rate in reversing cancer, reducing cancer or stopping tumor growth…We have seen zero metastases in any of the dogs…We believe that is our ketogenic diet…that accounts for this high success rate.
I don’t hesitate for a split second about advocating a raw or at least a home­made diet for an animal with cancer. I try to have owners understand it’s a necessity to expecting that great outcome
We need to know as a profession, as a veterinary profession, that there are food options that can fight cancer. Raw is very important.
This series offers a pretty varied list of prescriptions for cancer treatment: raw diets, ketogenic diets, essential oils, acupuncture, herbal medicine, “energy” medicine, cannabis oil/CBD, pet psychics, and many others. What do these have in common? Primarily two things: They are unconventional, and they haven’t been shown to work. Some of these are plausible but untested for cancer treatment (e.g. ketogenic diets, CBD), others are clearly quackery (e.g. “energy” medicine and essential oils). But regardless of the plausibility or the confidence the participants in TAPC express, none of these therapies have good supporting evidence showing they can treat or cure cancer.
There is an important difference between looking for new treatments, and even being hopeful about their potential, and inflicting unsupported claims on patients while attacking established treatment options. I am interested in the potential for ketogenic diets as a tool in managing cancer based on the very limited evidence available in humans and animal models. However, there are no clinical trials at all in dogs and cats; given these species differ dramatically from rats and humans, it is unreasonable to promise people miracles from this approach without having that evidence.
I am also optimistic about the potential of cannabis products, such as CBD, for a variety of conditions (particularly pain and epilepsy). Several clinical trials are underway in dogs and cats, and I await the results with cautious enthusiasm. However, there is insufficient evidence in humans to recommend cannabis for cancer treatment, and there are zero studies in pets to support claims cannabis is an effective cancer treatment in these species.
These are probably the best of the bunch. Pretty much everything else mentioned as an alternative to the supposedly terrible and ineffective practices of science-based medicine is nonsense. I have followed claims for raw diets for years, and while there is plenty of evidence for their dangers (particularly poor nutritional quality and infectious disease/parasite transmission), there is zero reliable evidence that they have therapeutic benefits for cancer or anything else. Despite hundreds of reviews of many, many clinical studies in humans, it has been impossible to convincingly show that acupuncture is more than a placebo in cancer patients, and as usual there are no relevant veterinary trials. The case for herbal medicine and ludicrous nonsense like “energy” medicine and animal communicators is even worse. There is lots of bluster and confidence in these videos, but at the end of the day they don’t have much of substance to offer pet owners dealing with cancer in their animal companions.
The bottom line
As I said in the beginning, The Truth About Pet Cancer series is a slick bit of propaganda. The producers of the project are effective communicators and manipulators of visual and social media (more’s the pity). While it is easy to find potential personal and financial incentives for the project, I suspect most of the participants are absolutely sincere in their fears about mainstream veterinary medicine and nutrition. I also don’t doubt they believe their own hype about the miraculous alternatives they champion.
Despite all of that, their beliefs about the scope and causes of cancer in pets are at best unproven and more likely false. Their attacks on science-based medicine are unfounded and misleading. And their confidence in alternative therapies is not justified by real scientific evidence. There is much sound and fury here, but it signifies very little.
Pet owners naturally want to do everything possible to prevent and treat cancer in their animal companions. It is unfortunate that this normal drive is misdirected by the misinformation in this video series. As always, I would encourage people facing a cancer diagnosis in their pets to start by finding a veterinarian with experience in cancer treatment, ideally a board-certified veterinary oncologist. And rather than relying on the internet or even the personal experience of individual doctors, I would encourage a frank discussion with your vet about the evidence behind their recommendations. It may sometimes be appropriate to reach for therapies that have not been tested as thoroughly as we might like since the evidence base for veterinary medicine is often thin. But bold claims about dramatic success and no serious risks are not yet justified for any cancer therapy in pets, so these should be viewed skeptically regardless of who makes them.
Here are some reliable resources about cancer care for pet owners that offer real, trustworthy information rather than inflated claims and pseudoscience:
    • Veterinary Oncolink, University of Pennsylvania
    • Pet Owner’s Guide to Cancer, Cornell University
    • Canine Cancer Library, National Canine Cancer Foundation
    • Animal Cancer Center, Colorado State University

Are Rattlesnake Vaccines for Dogs Effective?
A company is now selling a rattlesnake venom vaccine. How much can we trust it when it comes to the health and safety of our dogs? Right now, it’s too early to tell.
Greg Bishop on March 16, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: Please welcome our newest guest blogger, veterinarian Greg Bishop!]
One of the funny things about living in Southern California is knowing that some people won’t go hiking because they are terrified of rattlesnakes. They think as soon as they step foot onto a trail, a horde of vicious, fanged-menaces are going to leap out and inject them with poison. I’m sure the same people avoid the ocean because of sharks too. However unlikely an encounter may be, some people are terrified of coming across a dangerous animal, and especially a snake with built-in maracas. Fear is always an effective marketing tool, and there are a number of ridiculous “snake-proofing” products on the internet. They run the gamut from ridiculous to plausible, but one of the more interesting products available right now is a rattlesnake vaccine for dogs and horses, available from Red Rock Biologics. But is this vaccine a good idea? Read on pet lover, and we will hopefully shake out fact from fiction.
While encounters are rare, I have to concede that we will occasionally come across a venomous little tube of muscle undulating across the trail. It’s exciting and scary, and the best option is always to be respectful and keep your distance, which will make a bite very unlikely. But while we bipeds may be careful and cautious, often we’re hiking with dogs who can only be described as “simple-minded“. Their eagerness to make new friends and grab things that look like sticks can certainly get them into trouble; it’s estimated that there may be more than 100,000 venomous snakebites in dogs and cats in the US each year. Fortunately deaths are pretty rare, but treatment is almost always necessary.
If a dog is bitten by a rattlesnake, they need veterinary attention ASAP, no question. If the dose of venom is high enough, then the dog needs antivenom. Antivenom is essentially pre-made antibodies to a mixture of different rattlesnake venoms. Because rattlesnake venom is a complex mixture of proteins (there are at least 50 different kinds), antibodies are a pretty good neutralizing agent. The antibodies are made by first injecting farm animals with small doses of venom, then collecting and purifying their blood for antibodies. These antibodies, which neutralize the venom, are injected into the bitten patient. Assuming the antivenom matches the injected venom, they should sop up all the toxin and allow it to be removed from the body safely (except in rare cases of an allergic reaction to the antivenom). It tends to work really well, although it’s not cheap (get pet insurance!), and multiple vials are often needed. If there are any delays in treatment, the antivenom may not get in soon enough to prevent permanent damage. Obviously the best case is to not get bit in the first place (and there is rattlesnake avoidance training), but as we all know, sometimes stuff happens.
This finally gets me to the rattlesnake vaccine. Is it a good idea to have your pet “immunized” against snake venom? Sounds cool, right? And the idea behind it is interesting. Here’s the concept: create antivenom in the bloodstream so that when the snake bites the dog, the antidote is already there, and the venom gets neutralized. Boom. Superdog. So why not just have the dog make its own antivenom rather than rely on purified sheep blood?
Maybe a little Old West analogy will help. Let’s say there’s a bad guy in town, and we don’t know when he’s gonna show up and get to causin’ trouble (please continue to read in a Sam Elliot voice). The town is the body, and the bad guy is the venom. Think of a vaccine as a way for us to tell the body to target that bad guy before he gets there, like a “Wanted” poster that gets everybody in town on alert. In theory, the antibodies (townspeople) will jump on the venom as soon as it hits the body. If there are enough of them, they’ll wrangle him up and lock him in jail, and nobody gets hurt (ok you can stop the fun voice if you want to). Like I said, it’s a very interesting theory, and in fact, some squirrel species are naturally resistant to rattlesnake venom, how cool is that?! So we can basically immunize the dog to the venom, right?
Not so fast.
Here’s the big problem with the vaccine: we don’t know if it works. Yeah, kind of a tough sell, right? We know that it could, maybe, possibly, under-the-right-circumstances, work. But there are actually quite a few leaps of faith to we’d need to make to trust it. To stretch our Old West analogy further, let’s consider what we know about this vaccine. We know that the vaccine does post wanted posters (i.e. it makes the immune system create antibodies), we know that it riles the townspeople up and that they do react when they see the bad guy (i.e. the antibodies react with and neutralize the venom). It all sounds good until we ask a few important questions. Here’s when we should be double thinking that leap. Ready for some monkey wrenches in the plan?
Monkey Wrench #1: What if it’s not the right bad guy who’s causing a ruckus?There are about 40 different species of rattlesnake species and the vaccine only produces neutralizing antibodies to one of them for sure. It might have some effect on other venoms, but we really don’t have any idea. Are you a good enough herpetologist to know which snake bit your pet?
Monkey Wrench #2: How long do those “Wanted” posters stay up for?If they get taken down after a week of not seeing our villain, how riled up are the townspeople gonna be? As of right now, we have no idea, meaning we have no idea how long a dog might actually benefit from this vaccine, and when to give boosters.
Monkey Wrench #3: How many bad guys are gonna show up?If it’s just one troublemaker, the small town posse could probably handle him. But what if there’s a whole gang them? We often don’t know how much venom is injected, and we don’t know how many antibodies are produced, so if our math is off by even a little bit, the antibodies can be overwhelmed.
Is there any evidence for this vaccine? A pretty recent study looked at how well this vaccine worked in mice when tested against a lethal dose of rattlesnake vaccine. The researchers injected mice with a lethal dose of venom from three species of rattlesnake after they had been vaccinated. Most of them died. Poor mice, they should have been born as ground squirrels. The good news is that some of the ones who got the vaccine actually lived, and the vaccinated mice lived significantly longer than unvaccinated mice. There are some “buts”, however, and these are pretty big “buts”. First of all, the vaccine did not work great for all three types of rattlesnakes tested. It worked a little bit for Western diamondback, maybe kinda a tiny bit for Northern Pacific rattlesnake, and not at all for South Pacific rattlesnake venom. So cross-protection was poor.
The other big consideration with this study is that the exposure was controlled. Although they used a whopping dose, they did it at a time when they expected peak antibody levels in the mice’s bloodstream. Who knows how long the antibodies are hanging around at beneficial levels? Nobody. And they even found that some of the vaccinated mice produced very little antibody, so there would presumably be some “non-responders”, just like with any vaccine. This study shows the challenge in extrapolating data in the lab to predictions in the field.
There is actually a pretty recent paper reviewing a few hundred cases of dogs who had been bitten by rattlesnakes and what factors were important in their outcomes. This is a very small sample (but not bad for a veterinary study). However, there were a number of rattlesnake-vaccinated dogs in the cases. The researchers found “…no measurable benefit could be identified associated with rattlesnake vaccination”. It’s possible that with a much larger sample size a benefit could be found, but with so many unanswered questions about duration of immunity and what levels are required for neutralization, I think the burden of evidence still rests on the vaccine manufacturer.
Could it work? It’s somewhat plausible. I would not trust it to save my dog’s life. I don’t currently recommend it. The only way I would consider using this product would be if rattlesnake avoidance was completely not possible, and even then, I would make sure the owner knows that if their dog is bitten, they need to not expect the vaccine be helpful and get them a veterinarian with antivenom right away. To be fair, the manufacturer says as much in their brochure. They also responded to my phone call about duration of immunity by saying there are ongoing studies. I’m curious to see what is found and what is published. The vaccine does appear safe, but so is homeopathy (hmm, let me rethink that). So if the small but possible chance of benefit is worth the cost to the owner, it might make sense. If you really concerned about your pet getting bitten by a rattlesnake though, you’re better off adopting a ground squirrel, or learning this move (don’t do either of those please).

Alternative Flea Control Products
Every natural pet health website has their recommendations for flea treatments that don’t use harsh chemicals. The evidence for their claims is nonexistent. It’s appropriate that they’re talking about parasitic organisms, but I don’t think they see the irony.
Greg Bishop on July 6, 2018
Link


Fleas are cool, but they suck
Fleas are extraordinary organisms. Since I’m going to spend the rest of this post discussing ways to kill them (don’t worry flea enthusiasts, many of the following methods don’t actually work!), I thought it would be fair to first acknowledge some of the amazing things they do. Were you aware, for example, that flea larvae eat their parents’ feces and cannibalize their siblings’ eggs? Or that they can jump 100 times their body length? Did you know they have a pad of almost perfectly elastic material in their leg that shoots them into the air at about eight miles an hour? When we’re thinking about fleas on dogs, we’re actually thinking of the cat flea, Ctenocephalides felis, which is the most common external parasite of dogs and cats in the world. Did you know you can identify different species of fleas by their mustaches (or genal combs)? Here’s a cat flea, here’s a dog flea, here’s some mouse fleas, here’s a chili flea. Fleas as a group co-evolved with mammals and have been around since the Cretaceous Age.
All right, enough flea fluffing, let’s talk about killing these suckers. We should kill fleas because a lot of our pets are extremely allergic to flea bites and it makes them miserable. They are also vectors for zoonotic disease such as rickettsial diseases, cat scratch disease, plague, and tapeworms. As individuals, fleas are not that hard to kill. A well-placed fingernail will generally work. The problem is that they reproduce rapidly and persist in the environment for a long time. Their life cycle is extremely fast. One flea can lay 50 eggs a day for 2-3 months and there may be around 15 fleas on your average infested cat. And they can complete their entire life cycle, from thousands of tiny eggs (which live in your floors and carpets) to hundreds of bloodthirsty adults, in three weeks. You don’t need to be too good at math to know that if you keep multiplying numbers like this, you’ll run out of space on your Casio fx-85v calculator pretty fast. Unless you’ve gotten to level 384 in Galaga, you’re not going to be able to kill these insects individually. You need control at a population level.
This is the fundamental problem with fleas. Because their life cycle is so aggressive, it’s not enough to do a one-time treatment and expect the problem to be fixed. If you have any gaps in coverage, even a few weeks, the infestation can become re-established. You don’t want to give them an opportunity to bite, feed, f—, and lay eggs. Young flea stages can stay alive for months waiting for a host, so there may be a potential reservoir already in the house looking to emerge. That makes it critical for effective control to provide around-the-clock flea killing. I can’t overstate this point. If you want to get rid of the fleas, you need a scorched earth policy on their entire population. If you don’t, you’re leaving the door wide open.
The good news is that there are some very effective ways to do this. We have molecules that kill fleas quickly, effectively, provide long-lasting coverage, and are generally extremely safe for pets. These molecules typically work by selective toxicity, which means they are much more toxic to some species (i.e. fleas) than to others (i.e. dogs and cats). They take advantage of some fundamental differences in physiology between insects and mammals, which are usually pretty dissimilar at a cellular level. The more specific the difference, the more selective the toxicity, which means that the drug both works better to kill the pest, and is safer to use on the host species.
There are different categories of commercially available flea products, and guidelines on how to evaluate them. The two most important things to consider are efficacy (which is a measure of how well the compound kills the fleas in a realistic environment), and its safety to the animals we are using it on. In general, veterinarian-prescribed flea medications have good studies showing that they are safe and effective. They go through multiple trial phases, from in vitro studies to show something might work, to real-world field trials with people’s actual pets. There are other types of products that you can buy over-the-counter, most of which have efficacy and safety data. This is how the evil companies that produce these useful products got approval from the FDA or the EPA to market their product.
There’s one more category of flea products available to the consumer, however, and it’s the type that has neither safety nor efficacy evidence: the “alternative” flea treatments. Because there is a general misunderstanding that synthetically produced chemicals are always bad, and naturally produced chemicals are always good, a market has sprung up for these alternative therapies. If you visit any natural pet health website or store, you will likely come across a lot of products that claim to kill fleas without using so-called “harsh” chemicals. You will be told that these natural, organic, “chemical-free” products are safe, work well, and are safer for your beloved pet than the products made by greedy pharmaceutical companies. They don’t ever have any studies to support them, but they do sound a lot nicer. There’s no reason they can’t be studied, and they are already being sold en masse, so you’d figure the people advocating their use would test them out, but not yet. Because these alternatives don’t have any data to support their use, I like to call them Scientifically Testable but Unproven Pesticides, Insecticides and Devices; or STUPID for short.
Yup, I used that word. Pesticide. It’s a word that just means “kills bugs“. If you want to kill fleas you have to use a pesticide. It can synthetic or organic, but if it kills bugs, it’s a pesticide. You may not want to use a pesticide, fine! Nobody’s forcing you to kill fleas. But assuming your natural flea product is designed to kill fleas, then it’s a pesticide. There is nothing fundamentally different about a naturally-derived chemical that kills fleas and a synthetically engineered one, except for marketing. For example, if I give you the name of a compound, can you guess if it is a “harsh” chemical or a safe natural alternative?
Let’s try “allicin”.
How about “spinosad”?
Both of these are chemicals, and both of them are organic molecules. Allicin is a natural compound found in fresh garlic that has been proposed as a natural flea treatment but has no efficacy data. Spinosad is a natural insecticide from bacteria that has been artificially synthesized for parasite control and is supported by good evidence and safety. Most natural pet health websites will adamantly recommend garlic for fleas but tell you to avoid a product that contains spinosad. Does that make sense? It’s a classic appeal to nature fallacy.
Where I finally stop rambling and get to the point
That was a long rant! Thanks for sticking with me, and my apologies for the detour. But background information is important, since understanding flea biology is so crucial to why we use the products we do. I promise now to actually talk about alternative flea control methods and the evidence in support of them, but (spoiler alert) there’s not a lot. I tried to be charitable and explain proposed mechanisms when clinical trials were lacking. The only reasonably good trials we have show that alternative therapies don’t work. But anyway, here’s a list of what is currently being advertised to chemically-conscientious pet owners.
Garlic
This one has to be the most commonly-recommended natural flea repellant. The garlic plant contains alliin, which is the precursor for all of the supposedly effective compounds. There are thousands of studies on garlic molecules, as they have in vitro antimicrobial, antifungal, and antiprotozoal properties. Napalm also has antimicrobial properties, but I can’t recommend it. There’s one trial on the use of garlic for flea control in dogs; there were only three dogs in it, no control group, and it appears a pile of fresh garlic was just dumped on the ground next to dogs in a confined space. I’m trying to be generous but it ironically doesn’t pass the smell test. Also, consider that in high enough volumes garlic has antidog and anticat properties. Thank you Skeptvet for collating a bunch of other stinky garlic health claims.
Diatomaceous earth
Another pretty common recommendation is diatomaceous earth, which is the fossilized skeletons of microscopic organisms. Leaving out whether or not it’s disrespectful to use the bodies of these Miocene organisms to murder Holocene arthropods, diatomaceous earth is a pesticide and kills insects when applied topically. It works by absorbing oil from the parasite and causing death by desiccation. The best evidence I could find for the use of diatomaceous earth was a trial in chickens which showed parasite reduction but not elimination. Tapatio hot sauce might also be effective in reducing parasite load, but it would not expected to break the life cycle or eliminate an infestation. Diatomaceous earth can also be irritating when inhaled. Personally I find most things other than air are irritating when inhaled, and since you’d need to use this on almost a weekly basis to provide good flea control, you’re better off avoiding it.
Essential oils
You knew EOs would make an appearance here! There are way too many different types of essential oils and possible uses to go into but a few different ones are recommended for flea control. Some can kill and/or repel insects, but there is only a single in vitro study of one essential oil showing efficacy against fleas. No clinical trials. With no information as to safety, duration, and practicality, this is so far from being clinically useful it might as well be a flea-killing nanobot. It is worth noting that some essential oils are directly toxic to dogs and cats.
Apple cider vinegar
The darling of natural healers looking to get pH back out of whack. There is exactly zero evidence that this is effective, and no plausibility. The vinegar part is acetic acid, which is a well-known antiseptic. The apples part sound healthy and the cider part sounds delicious. Acetic acid is great for cleaning counters but it does not selectively kill blood-sucking insects. I know this because cattle and other ruminants basically run off of acetic acid and other volatile fatty acids (the reason they have big bellies is that’s where the microorganisms ferment grass into those fatty acids), and their blood does not kill insect pests. I’m so happy I took ruminant physiology in vet school.
Organisms
Most natural pet websites recommend adding beneficial nematodes to your yard because there are some nematodes (and fungi) that kill fleas. But since the flea infestation is usually in the house and these worms can’t live in your carpet, it would be pretty unlikely that they would make a practical difference. You know who else eats fleas? Cats that are grooming themselves, but nobody recommends adding them to your potting soil.
Miscellaneous
There are so many other unsupported claims I really can’t go into all of them: coconut oil, Baltic amber resin, raw diets, special plants in your garden, et cetera. It goes on and on, always claiming to be perfectly safe and always more or less guaranteed to work. When we do have studies on alternative therapies, they’re negative. Special collars purporting to create a bio-resonance field didn’t work, but are still being sold. Ultrasound collars didn’t work either, but are also widely available for sale. Aloe juice powder didn’t work. Brewer’s yeast didn’t work. If you’re looking for published science on any other natural or alternative flea control, that’s where it ends.
The bar is relatively low at “show a shred of in vitro efficacy”, and it’s not hard to kill any one flea, especially in a controlled environment. In fact, this might be something that acupuncture works for! But demonstrating real world benefit, specifically that all-important, long-lasting effect for population control, is something that all of these other methods consistently fail at. That never stops a new product from popping up, as there’s an endless line of people willing to manipulate pet owners fear for profit.
Is there any reason to not use flea medications?
The question is then: if we have lots of products that are proven to work, and lots of alternatives that are not proven to work, why would anyone choose the latter? My guess is fear, so let’s investigate the risks of the standard flea treatments. Is there any evidence that those products cause chronic disease, cancer, or other negative health consequences for the vast majority of pets that use them? No. I don’t think a reasonable person would argue that there are zero risks to these products, but they generally need to have extensive safety research (something most if not all of the alternatives lack) to get government approval. If they are not used correctly, they can be toxic. One of the most common problems is when an owner applies a permethrin-containing flea product for dogs to a cat. Cats lack an enzyme that metabolizes the permethrin, making them really sensitive to this class of drugs.
Is there a risk to human health? It appears pretty minimal, as long as they are appropriately used. That is a big caveat, because humans can always find ingenious ways to screw things up. But remember, we’re using the compounds precisely because they don’t affect us hair-growing, homeothermic mammals. You can’t necessarily say the same thing about some of the alternative pesticides, which in some cases may be more toxic to people. You can always look up information for any specific product on the FDA website or on the National Pesticide Information Center website.
Finally, is there a risk to the environment? Some of the drugs used are potentially environmental hazards. Native invertebrate species (as well as fish and birds) can be negatively impacted by pesticides, however, it is much more likely that agricultural use is responsible for the damage, rather than flea protection for pets (see here, here, here, and here). Using an oral flea product and cleaning up your pet’s waste would conceivably reduce the environmental risk. This is also why getting more and more specific with our pesticides is good, since it will limit damage to off-target species that we care about.
Conclusion: Don’t fall for unproven junk, you already have great flea control options
What do you want?! To have a pesticide-free cake and not have parasites eat it too? If you want to kill pests but think pesticides are the wrong way to go about it, you’re worried about the wrong things. If you think dogs and cats get fleas because they’re eating processed foods and getting vaccines, you have forgotten about the 1800s when we had to hire monkeys to pick fleas off of our pets. If you are suspicious of all products made by German-sounding giant multinational corporations, don’t be surprised if you can’t get rid of your flea problem. I understand that big Pharma has deeper pockets than Big Garlic, but I’m sure we could put some of these alternative therapies to the test. Just don’t trust advice from people who are trying to scare you, and often selling you an unproven alternative. Demand some evidence from these people. It would be great if we had a cheap, readily available, completely safe, environmentally risk-free, perfectly efficacious way to keep fleas off of our animals. As it stands, we’re pretty close with the modern flea preventatives.
One last thing: someone (perhaps many someones) is going to jump in and tell us an anecdote about how they used Dr. Bronner’s soap or something for fleas and it worked! I don’t doubt their experience. But please, try to understand that your observation of something does not prove anything. Fleas are a common problem, but there is a lot of variation in how much they affect any one animal, and exposure and risk are not the same everywhere at all times. If your experience is true, it should be provable. It really would not be that hard to prove these alternative therapies work, since all you need is fleas and dogs, which are abundant. Oh wait, you’d need science too, and that might mess things up.

NuVet: Pet Supplement Snake Oil
Scott Gavura on July 17, 2014
Link

I’m a dog person. I always wanted a dog as a child, and while my extended family all had dogs, we never had one in our home. I finally got my wish just over a decade ago. My wife and I were referred to a breeder with an excellent reputation for raising healthy, family-friendly Labrador Retrievers. Within moments of meeting a tiny black lab, we immediately put a deposit down. When we took Casey home a few months later she was healthy – a ball of kinetic energy. The breeder offered us a health guarantee – free of hip and elbow dysplasia, supported by certifications from the dog’s parents and grandparents. The breeder recommended we use a specific brand of food (which we ignored), and other than vaccinating her and promising not to breed her, there were few conditions for the guarantee. We were excited “parents” and that first year was a lot of fun.
At about 12 months of age, Casey started limping. At first we thought it was a temporary consequence of boisterous play. It was initially subtle, but then became very obvious – she started walking differently, and it didn’t go away. The x-rays confirmed what we feared: elbow dysplasia. Our breeder was deeply apologetic – consistent with the guarantee, she offered to replace our dog. Giving up our pet was out of the question, so we started looking at treatment options. The veterinarian offered surgery, but even he wasn’t enthusiastic, citing the very real likelihood it would do nothing. Knowing the toxicity of anti-inflammatory drugs, I wasn’t optimistic that would be tolerable for the long run. Instead we went the supplement route.
Around 2002 or so, there seemed to be guarded optimism about the potential of glucosamine and chondroitin to help with joint pain. We obtained a pharmaceutical (human) supply and started giving it three times daily. The limping seemed to improve. At best, it definitely didn’t worsen. Casey was still stiff after exercise, and the limp never went away. But she was happy and we were relieved. We gave glucosamine and chondroitin consistently for at least five years. Her health was fine until she started putting on weight – almost 20 pounds over one year – which is a lot for a 60lb dog. The pain increased, and limping was much more noticeable. The veterinarian suggested we test her thyroid. Sure enough, she was hypothyroid. After several months of levothyroxine and a switch to a calorie-reduce diet, her weight dropped, her limp improved, and life went on. It was about this time I started wondering about the effectiveness of the glucosamine and chondroitin. The evidence in human trials was increasingly conclusive that the supplements were ineffective. Was it doing anything at all for Casey? Had I fooled myself? After reading a very critical article (it may have been this one) I finally decided on a stopping trial: I’d look for signs of pain or worsening mobility, and I’d restart the supplement if I spotted it.
You can probably guess what happened: After I discontinued the supplement, there was no objective difference in her mobility. I’d fooled myself for almost five years, and while the supplement probably didn’t cause any harm, I had wasted hundreds of dollars. Unless I’d read the evidence and conducted my own trial, I’d probably still be an advocate today, influenced only by my own pet and my anecdotal evidence.
If human supplements are the “Wild West” of regulation, pet supplements seem to be an order of magnitude worse. Not only are there effectively no limits on claims, there’s even less evidence to evaluate. Breeders may lack science literacy, and even veterinarians seem to have varying commitments to science-based medicine. The entire system (at least from a consumer perspective) seems to place the anecdote as the most credible source of information that exists. Never mind the evidence, just read the testimonials. Credible sources of information like SkeptVet seem to be the exception, rather than the rule.
A fellow dog owner and skeptic recently asked me about a supplement called NuVet that his breeder had insisted he purchase with his dog. Like my breeder, his dog came with a “health guarantee” – but this one came with a condition: His “health guarantee” would be void unless he purchased NuVet for several years. To prove he purchased it, he had to phone in his order (it’s not sold in stores) and quote a specific breeder number. He was told this process was necessary “to confirm it is being purchased.” Smelling a kickback scheme, I did some digging.
What is NuVet?
Nuvet Plus Canine (there’s also a feline version) is a vitamin supplement labelled as containing specific amounts of vitamins A, C, E, the minerals potassium, zinc, calcium, selenium, and phosphorus. It also contains an unlabelled amount of the following: blue-green algae, brewer’s yeast, cat’s claw, evening primrose oil, shark cartilage, oyster shell, alpha amylase, beta carotene, pine bark, papain, L-methionine, alfalfa, chicken liver, vitamin B1 (thiamin), vitamin B2 (riboflavin), vitamin B3 (niacin), vitamin B5 (pantothenic acid), vitamin B6 (pyridoxine), vitamin B12, vitamin D, vitamin K, manganese, magnesium, iron, copper, amino acids (tryptophan, threonine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, cystine, phenylalanine, tyrosine, valine, arginine, histidine, alanine, aspartic acid, glutamic acid, glycine).
There’s also a NuJoint Plus supplement that contains glucosamine, chondroitin, MSM (methylsulfonylmethane) and vitamin C.
What is the rationale for the ingredients in NuVet?
According to the manufacturer, NuVet Labs:
NuVet Labs® has spent over 8 years to create a product designed to attack the causes of disease instead of just covering up the symptoms. To do this we put together a team of top scientific, medical and pet industry professionals that shared our desire to find real solutions to an ever growing pet health dilemma.
There’s no information provided on how the ingredients were selected. The dose is the same for dogs 6lbs to 99 lbs: 1 wafer per day.
What claims are made about NuVet?
The statements made on the NuVet website are typical of human dietary supplements, with vague promises and scientifically meaningless marketing statements like:
    • “ground-breaking formulas”
    • “designed to fight illnesses at their root source”
    • “strengthen immune systems”
    • “focuses on the root cause of illness and disease while simultaneously boosting your pet’s immune system and overall health”
    • “a precise formula of vitamins, minerals, enzymes, herbs and antioxidants that performs synergistically”
    • “compounded to maintain their integrity and bio-digestibility for complete cellular infusion”
    • “these crucial elements can help your pet overcome illnesses, allergies and diseases”
    • “there are more free radicals actively destroying the cell membrane than our body can defend against” …”there is a boosting of the immune system and a decrease in the ravages of free radicals”
    • “Formulas that contain high quality minerals, a full range of amino acids, proteins and antioxidants – help to detoxify the blood stream.”
The manufacturer claims that NuVet can benefit the following: allergies, cataracts, colitis, diabetes, fleas, hot spots, infections, itching and scratching, kidney [sic], mange, seizures, tear stains, tumors.
What is the evidence supporting the claims made about NuVet?
There is no published information made available or cited on the manufacturer’s website to demonstrate that NuVet has ever been subjected to any rigorous or controlled clinical studies. While the manufacturer refers to “over 8 years to create a product designed to attack the causes of disease”, none of that research is cited or appears to have been published. The CEO notes:
An independent laboratory tested several dogs and cats, varying in age, size, and health conditions, under the direct supervision of a team of veterinarians. The results were better than we ever could have hoped for and now we are proud to be able to produce a nutritional pet supplement that is second to none.
At best this product appears to have been given to a small number of animals. No information is provided to describe how the product was tested, or how it was found to be effective against the long list of “ailments” for which it is claimed to be effective. There is no safety data provided.
Examining the list of ingredients directly, I could located no published evidence to demonstrate that any of the ingredients, when administered as supplement to pets, as a supplement to nutritionally appropriate pet food (e.g., meets Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) requirements) can meaningfully address any of the “ailments” cited by the manufacturer. The amounts of most of the ingredients are not stated, and given the dosage form (a wafer) it’s unlikely to contain enough per dose to be meaningful. From a biochemical perspective, there is no reason to expect any of the ingredients will offer any benefit to pets that eat a regular diet. And as has been now definitively established, glucosamine and chondroitin appear to be clinically useless supplements – for pets and humans.
Is there any evidence dogs need NuVet, or any supplements?
No. NuVet is an example of the “one true cause” disease claim – in this case, NuVet seems to believe that the “one true cause” of disease is a lack of dietary antioxidants. Yet there’s no evidence to demonstrate that the numerous “ailments” mentioned are caused by a lack of dietary antioxidants, or can be treated with antioxidant supplements. The arguments made by the manufacturer are simplistic to the point of absurdity – there is no obvious understanding of pet physiology or biochemistry. I have seen more sophisticated science at public school science fairs. Based on what’s know about animal medicine it is absurd to think a vitamin supplement will prevent conditions like kidney disease, cancer, or epilepsy. Importantly, as I have noted in humans – antioxidant supplements may actually do more harm than good. Consequently, before we give any supplement, we should be fairly certain it will do more good than harm. With NuVet, the evidence of benefit hasn’t been demonstrated with good scientific studies.
But what about the hundreds of testimonials?
I fooled myself giving my dog glucosamine and chondroitin. When we give a medication or supplement, we want to see a benefit – and often we do. It could be our own perception fooling us, or it could be the normal waxing and waning of the underlying condition, where the condition improves on its own, yet we attribute it to the supplement. It doesn’t mean the improvement is real, or that it’s due to a supplement. It’s easy to find hundreds of claims of effectiveness for NuVet online. Objective, conclusive evidence is completely absent. Testimonials are a poor form of evidence, and don’t provide any assurance that NuVet does anything meaningful.
What about the health guarantee?
There appears to be a close financial relationship between breeders and NuVet labs, with so many breeders using the same terminology and making the same purchase demands. It is even embedded into the ownership contracts you can find online:
The buyer agrees said puppy will receive Nu Vet Plus tablets for a period of AT LEAST (1) one year from date of this contract and a boosted immunity builder to whatever his environment might be during his critical growth stages. Nu Vet Plus tablets supplements are required as to ensure that said puppy will have optimum protection part of your pet’s health guarantee. SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM. Once you, the buyer, see the beneficial effects and wonderful results from this mineral supplement, we hope that you will continue the program for the rest of your dog’s life to ensure he/she has a long, happy one. ALL of the breeding dogs at SOUTHERN CHARM MINI AUSSIES are taking Nu Vet Plus tablets as a part of the health guarantee we give you that we take the best possible care of the dogs we choose to reproduce.
Some breeders require NuVet to be purchased for a year, and others expect you to give NuVet for much longer – sometimes for life. And perhaps not surprisingly, those breeders are all using very similar wording when making claims about the product. It’s not surprising that breeders link the supplement to a “health guarantee”: it gives breeders an additional reason to refuse to stand behind the quality of their breeding. Moreover, I suspect that very few owners want to return their pets, meaning the kickbacks (that are widely assumed to be going to the breeder) give the breeder a steady, reliable secondary source of income.
Is NuVet a scam?
One of the signs a supplement might be a scam is the manufacturer has a web page entitled “NuVet is Not a Scam“. The other sign your supplement might be a scam is a link to a web page entitled Testimonials yet no similar page labelled Evidence.
It’s important to note that breeders that insist on the use of NuVet supplements are doing so in the absence of any credible or persuasive evidence. They are simply parroting the claims of NuVet Labs, and perhaps incorporating their own observations and personal experience. There is no published evidence that shows NuVet supplements are superior to other vitamin supplements. All that exists are anecdotes. Facts and objective evidence are lacking.
Conclusion
NuVet is a heavily marketed pet supplement that contains a mix of vitamins, minerals and other ingredients without any coherent scientific justification. The manufacturer appears to believe that NuVet treats a universal underlying cause of disease – a lack of dietary antioxidants. This is a claim that is not supported by credible evidence. A large number of animal breeders appear to derive a secondary income by requiring the purchase of NuVet supplements as a condition of animal sale. Despite the claims made by both manufacturers and breeders, there is no convincing or persuasive scientific evidence to suggest NuVet supplements offer any benefits to dogs whatsoever. This is supplement snake oil, and potential pet owners may want to think carefully about the credibility of any breeder who insists on NuVet purchases as a condition of pet sale.

The Great Outdoors (Debate)
What are the health risks of letting your cat roam free?
Greg Bishop on May 11, 2018
Link

Of all the domesticated animals, cats are certainly the most polarizing; it’s pretty hard to find someone who is just ambivalent towards cats. When you stop and think about it, they are an odd animal to have in our homes. Nowadays, we have them as companions, but it seems strange that several thousand years ago, we permanently befriended a small, self-absorbed carnivore. They can have serious attitude and seem to run on their own schedules. This may be because they are probably unique among domestic animals in that nobody intended for them to become pets, they just hopped on the anthropocene bandwagon early. They really haven’t changed much from their wild ancestors. You don’t see wolves catching Frisbees or bison merrily trotting into the milking parlor, but often you’d be hard pressed to tell the difference between a completely wild cat and a domestic one. They’ve retained a lot of the features that make them… well, cats.
This strange phenomenon of pet cats begets a controversial question: should they be allowed to go outside? Weird question, right? It might seem perfectly reasonable to have cats come in and out of the house as they please, just like they’ve done for thousands of years. But the balance between the needs of an essentially wild animal and living in a 21st century home are a bit more complicated than appear at first blush. If you suddenly had a murderous wild caveman living on your couch, would it be okay to dress him in a tux and take him to prom? What are we supposed to do with our little self-domesticated mesopredators? Keep them indoors? Let them roam free? Is a life outdoors a basic right for cats fulfilling their ancestral needs, or is it a dangerous and fragile place from which they should be sheltered? Confine them to fluorescent lighting and bad carpeting for their own safety? Or pitch them out into a violent world so they don’t scratch up our La-Z-Boy? Does anyone actually know? Ok, that’s enough rhetorical questions for one paragraph (or is it?).
Let’s stay focused
This is a hot topic, and as usual more vociferance is used than science in the debate. Before going too far into it, I want to make it clear that this discussion can easily stray into the tangential and philosophical. This isn’t about whether or not cats want to go outdoors (most of them really do), it’s really about what the consequences are when they do or don’t. I have my own opinions about whether or not they should, but that’s not really the aim of this post (don’t worry, I’ll give it to you later just to be annoying). My focus will specifically be on the health of pet cats when they roam outdoors. Let’s make a science-based argument to Hank the Cat about whether or not he should run his Senate election campaign from the living room couch. Scientific findings in this field are emerging, nuanced,* often surprising, and open to passionate interpretation. With that said, let’s dive into it.
The risks of being an outdoor cat
The first and most intuitive question is, “do indoor cats live longer?” Impossibly, no scientific answer to this exists. Despite authoritative claims on millions of cat websites, I could not track down a source on this.** No one has actually compared longevity between indoor and outdoor cats. Claims that outdoor felines live years shorter than indoor ones are like the Cheshire cat: they appear out of nowhere, and then vanish if you try looking at them too closely. The closest thing I could find was one study looking at causes of mortality in French cats that stated outdoor cats usually lived about 10 years, and that indoor cats could live up to 20 or more years. But no direct comparison reported in the data, just that statement. We don’t have a study where that single variable has been examined.
So we have to concede that science does not have a clear answer to this frequently asked (and answered) question. What the crap, science? Now don’t get me wrong, it’s pretty obvious that there are many more dangers outside than inside, and that the expected lifespans of outdoor cats would be shorter. We actually have a fair amount of data about what happens to cats when they do venture out into the world, and oh boy what a scary world it is.
The biggest risk for outdoor cats appears to be trauma, specifically, road traffic accidents. Getting hit by a car, as you might expect, is deleterious to your health. There may be several thousand cats killed by cars every year in cities like Baltimore (I’m not sure if this was supposed to be commentary on how they drive on the East Coast or not). But it’s not just roads; in a fantastical study where researchers put cameras on cats and watched them roam about (they call it the “KittyCam”, but I would have suggested “Purr-veilance”), they found cats were engaging in all sorts of “risky behaviors”. These cats were acting like stoned teenagers: drinking strange liquids, hanging out with unfamiliar conspecifics, climbing trees and buildings, and entering storm drains (creepy, who knows what’s down there).
None of the cats in that study came to unsavory fates, but they were lucky to have not been eaten by a clown. Or anything else for that matter. Being on the smaller side of the carnivore spectrum, cats are definitely considered edible-eligible by other animals. Where I live, we have coyotes everywhere. They’re bold. I swear I’ve seen them ordering lattes at the local coffee shop. And they do in fact kill a fair number of cats (although whether or not these are pets or strays is hard to determine). Although less data is available, many other animals such as mountain lions, wolves, and birds of prey have probably tasted cat. Heck, I bet a pelican has tried once or twice (trigger warning: don’t click on those links, seriously). Cats themselves are not always cat lovers, and territorial spats leading to serious injury are pretty common.
For pure, murderous, non-accidental cruelty, however, nothing comes close to people. As the 1987 nature documentary Predator shows us, man is the most dangerous hunter, especially when mud-encrusted and harriedly tossing grenade-spears around. And indeed, a recent study identified cases of gunshot, poisonings, burnings, and asphyxiation in about 0.25% of cats from the general population. While these data didn’t directly compare outdoor and indoor lifestyle, cats that never leave the home are probably not getting shot very often. Sadly, there are a lot of assholes out there that like to shoot free-roaming cats.
Whether by tooth, tire, or firearm, it is unsurprising that most of the traumatic deaths are young, dumb kitties prowling about. In a study of English cats, accidental deaths start off as a big proportion, but then sharply drop off after five years of age (going from the #1 cause to the #6 cause). We can’t say directly that all of these deaths are from being outdoors since the researchers didn’t categorize that, but it is interesting to note that about 90% of cats in the UK are allowed outside. Other studies looking at feline mortality in other ways have confirmed the live-fast-die-young phenomenon. Accidental death may be responsible for half of young cats deaths.
Infectious disease also kills the young, although again we don’t know if these were outdoor cats or not. Not every infectious disease requires being outside to get, but there are plenty where it is an established risk factor such as feline retroviruses, mycoplasmosis, tularemia, plague, and rabies. I couldn’t find direct evidence (i.e. I got lazy), but I bet worms, ectoparasites, bite abscesses, fungal infections, and other infectious diseases are overrepresented in outdoor cats.
The last risk that is commonly mentioned for outdoor cats is poisoning, but this is a bit tricky since both indoor and outdoor poisons exist. There are definitely potential toxins outside, but you could make a reasonable argument that there are more potential poisons inside the house. No one, to my knowledge, has compared the risk of toxicity for indoor and outdoor cats.
Social costs of outdoor cats
Maybe you know a cat owner who is okay with the chance of some horrible fate befalling their pet. After all, that’s how they live in the wild, right? They may have a fatalistic stance, but outdoor cats have consequences beyond how satiated the local coyotes are. Is there a greater cost to feline libertarianism?
Unfortunately, yes. One of the most controversial topics regarding outdoor cats is their effect on wildlife, and cats can be devastating to small wildlife. It is difficult to know exactly how much of the carnage rests on the shoulders of pet cats versus feral ones, however, there is good documentation that owned cats hunt native wildlife species. That kitty door in your kitchen is home base for a killing spree.
After that endangered pocket gopher gets eaten by Garfield, it gets turned into feces, and there are no port-a-potty’s for cats. They can really turn out the turds (an estimated 1.2 million tons per year in the U.S.). This is bad, because cat feces are a major source of exposure for a parasite named Toxoplasma gondii. You may have heard about this as a serious risk to pregnant women and immunocompromised people, but domestic cats pooping al fresco might be very damaging to wildlife as well. In addition to toxoplamosis, there is a long list of bad bugs that can cats can spread. It should be said that feral cats are probably a much bigger factor in disease transmission than pets, but pets probably contribute a little, especially if they are unvaccinated and not on parasite preventatives.
How healthy are indoor cats?
Okay, okay, okay, so it’s dangerous for free-roamin’ felines, and they’re not exactly environmental stewards. From one Cat to the others, “just remember there’s a lot of bad and beware”. If you keep Mittens indoors, it’s gonna be hard (but not impossible) for her to catch rabies or get hit by a car, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t going to be tradeoffs. It would seem to stand to reason that keeping a cat indoors should keep it healthier, and that is probably true, however there is going to be an increased risk for other conditions. There is a mixed but growing body of evidence that when we keep cats indoors, they are at higher risk for some chronic diseases like obesity, hyperthyroidism, cystitis, dental lesions, and diabetes. I see these every day in general practice, where they are significant causes of morbidity and sometimes mortality (although less direct than a speeding Buick).
Why would this happen? Well, just like taking a tuber-gathering bipedal ape out of the wild and shoving an endless supply of cheeseburgers into his mouth comes with its own set of health consequences, you can’t expect cats living an inactive lifestyle to be perfectly healthy. Importantly, many of these conditions are not a direct result of being indoors, but related to too much food and lack of exercise (e.g. obesity and diabetes) and stress (e.g. cystitis). These are common conditions that reduce quality of life in pet cats, but they can be prevented or mitigated to some degree. This simplification doesn’t necessarily explain all the conditions (e.g. we still don’t know what causes feline hyperthyroidism), but it is likely that lifestyle plays a more important role in overall health than an unidentifiable toxin that only indoors cats are exposed to. Controlling diet and removing stressors can help to reduce the incidence of many of these conditions. Cats are gonna cat, and if you mess with what makes them a cat you can expect problems. As one source on what a cat wants put it, “the consensus seems to be that cats appear to benefit from appropriate access to resources, control of interactions with owners, and a tolerable intensity of conflict”. I love that. How many other domestic animals do you think require a tolerable intensity of conflict?
Conclusion: There’s chickadee blood on your hands
It probably is true that on average outdoor cats are not going to live as long as their indoor brethren, and most at risk are going to be young cats since, like young organisms everywhere, they are making stupid decisions. Outdoor cats can meet some gruesome ends, with a lot depending on where you live. Outdoor cats in Manhattan face a different set of dangers than those living next door to Alf. In addition to putting their own lives in peril, these free-roamers cause completely unnecessary and often severe damage to public and wildlife health. It’s probably better for everyone to just have your kitten stay inside, but there is a tradeoff. Increased risk of some chronic conditions comes with the safety of a sedentary life. These diseases are to some degree preventable with appropriate care. I know a lot of people like having cats because they seem easy to take care of, but that convenience might be hiding a true cost. If it means you let your cat outside, you’re exposing it to life-threatening dangers (and there’s chickadee blood on your hands). If it means you keep your cat indoors but don’t control its diet or pay attention to its health, don’t be surprised if medical problems develop.
My own opinion? Thanks for asking! It may not be worth much salt because I’m not currently a cat owner, but growing up I lost a cat to the great outdoors, and I’ve had plenty of patients disappear or show up with horrific injuries. I also happen to love wildlife and would like to do as much as possible to preserve it, so I’m unapologetically on the side of permanent confinement for pet cats. I think that cats can be perfectly happy and healthy without roaming free, but it does take more work. But if you want a pet that doesn’t take any work and won’t hurt anybody (unless chucked at their head), get a pet rock! If you’ve got an indoor cat, try keeping it physically and mentally healthy with controlled diet and stress (hey this is good advice, I wonder if it would work for people?). Go out for walks on a leash or build a “cat-io” (don’t be self-conscious, haters gonna hate). You’ll find your indoor cat is happier and more inclined to perform cute behavior for your cat video festival submission (sorry, cats are not allowed to attend).

* A major caveat to most of this research is that it’s often hard to distinguish between pet cats that are allowed outside, and feral cats that have gone permanently Alexander Supertramp.
** Please let me know if you have any better information.

FDA & CDC find raw pet food unpalatable
Jann Bellamy on June 25, 2015
Link


The FDA recently announced it would send field staff out to collect samples of commercially-manufactured raw dog and cat food. The samples will be analyzed for Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes and E. coli, all of which have been found in raw pet food, in the animals who eat it, in their feces, on their bodies after eating it, in the areas they inhabit, and on their owner’s bodies. Not surprisingly, this has led to both pet and human infection and illness. If the FDA finds pathogens, it could result in a recall, a press release and Reportable Food Registry Submission. The next day, the CDC joined the effort to curb illness caused by pathogens in raw pet food by posting information on safe handling.
Because of the risk to public health, and the lack of any proven benefit of raw pet food diets, the FDA does not recommend them.
However, we understand that some people prefer to feed these types of diets to their pets.
And why is that? For some of the same reasons humans follow absurd diet fads: the “lone genius” discovery, it’s “natural,” anecdotal evidence, appeal to antiquity, anti-corporate sentiment, and “holistic” practitioner recommendations.
The “lone genius” discovery
Although he may not have been original inventor of the raw pet food diet, Australian vet Ian Billinghurst is its most ardent popularizer, in the form of his trademarked “Dr. Billinghurst’s BARF Diet.” BARF is an acronym for “Biologically Appropriate Raw Food,” although other gastrointestinal-related events are called to mind.
Billinghurst recounts how the health of his own dogs declined after he started feeding them high quality commercial pet food. (Oddly missing from this story is information about what he was feeding his pets before he started them on commercial pet food and why he didn’t just go back to this diet.) However, it took him two years to realize his error. That realization came only when he switched them to a diet of raw meat, including bones, and household scraps. The results, as you might imagine, were “immediate and dramatic.” He urged his clients to switch their pets’ diets as well, with the same amazing results.
He reasoned that raw meaty bones and vegetable scraps were “very close to the evolutionary diet of cats and dogs.” He was also influenced by his study of acupuncture, although it is unclear how that led to the BARF diet, other than a willingness to trade the scientific method for anecdotal evidence as a basis of one’s practice.
Billinghurst wrote a book in the 1980s, catchily titled Give Your Dog a Bone, setting forth his unique pet nutritional theories. It became something of a pet-owner cult hit and was followed by more books. He later partnered with Robert Mueller, a pharmacist (not the former FBI director) who wrote the similarly lone-genius discovery book, Living Enzymes: The World’s Best Kept Pet Food Secret. Together with another partner, they created “BARF World,” which sells, among other things, commercially prepared raw pet food. We’ll return to this enterprise in a moment.
Billinghurst makes big claims for BARF, or at least the “raw meaty bone-eating” element:
Raw meaty bone-eating dogs lived much longer than their commercially fed counterparts, . . . Bone-eating dogs have the wonderful benefits of clean teeth with no periodontal disease, wonderfully improved digestion, a reduction in obesity, fabulous eating exercise, healthy stools, no anal sac problems, and the wonderful psychological, emotional, and immune system benefits that eating raw meaty bones has conferred on dogs for millions of years.
The raw food diet for dogs is based on a combination of the naturalist and appeal to antiquity fallacies: the notion that your dog is really, at heart (and stomach, I guess), a wolf. And cats are tiny tigers, I suppose. While raw cat food is promoted as well, the whole “theory” appears to be largely dog-centric. Because wolves ate a raw diet, it must necessarily follow that raw meat, with a few herbs, is best for your dog. (Wolves got their plant matter by eating the stomach contents of their prey.)
In this, the diet also is a form of evolutionary medicine, which is based on the faulty assumption that chronic diseases and degenerative conditions arise from a mismatch between our (and our pet’s) Stone Age genes and recently adopted lifestyles, including diet. It is the same fallacy that lies at the heart of the paleo diet for us humans.
Brennen McKenzie, DVM, sliced and diced the “dog as wolf” theory nicely in a previous SBM post. (You can find more raw pet food posts on his blog, Skeptvet.) In summary,
Yes, dogs and wolves are both in the order Carnivora, but so are giant Pandas, who are almost exclusively herbivores.
Dogs have not been wolves for a very long time — like 100,000 years or so.
The claim that dogs and wolves are anatomically identical with respect to an appropriate diet is simply untrue:
If you try to picture a pack of Chihuahuas bringing down and savaging an elk, the impact of thousands of years of artificial selection is obvious. . . . Dogs have lived with humans, eaten our table scraps, and been intensively bred for features we desire, none of which is likely to make them ideally designed for the diet of a wolf.
Wolves don’t have such a great life in the wild anyway. Disease, parasites and malnutrition are major factors in wild wolf mortality and they don’t live as long as captive wolves. And captive wolf breeders have found that the best diet for their wolves is – guess what? – commercial dog food.
An analogous argument has sprung up that feral dogs and cats eat raw meat, as if this is some conscious healthy lifestyle choice on the animal’s part instead of the result of appalling neglect and irresponsibility on the part of pet owners. Of course, feral dogs and cats also lead terrible lives, subject to malnutrition and early death, and don’t live as long as pet dogs and cats.
Bad, bad commercial dog food
The other main argument in favor of raw pet food has the flavor of “death by medicine.” Like that argument, trotted out to demonize “conventional medicine,” the failings of the commercial pet food industry do nothing to make raw pet food more nutritious, less risky, or otherwise better for your pet.
It is also underpinned by some grossly exaggerated and downright false claims about the commercial pet food industry. (And here we use the term “commercial pet food” to mean “conventional” commercial pet food, even though raw pet food has become plenty “commercial” as well.) While the commercial dog food industry has its problems, it is not the bogeyman that raw pet enthusiasts make it out to be. Dr. McKenzie has shredded these arguments for us as well. Briefly:
No, commercial pet food doesn’t make your pet sick. Like humans, pets live longer because of better nutrition and medical care. This means that illnesses of the aging pet, like cancer and degenerative diseases, are more prevalent. Coupled with the lack of a full understanding of what causes these diseases, this leaves raw food enthusiasts an opening to claim it must be the food.
No, commercial pet food is not “toxic.” This is based on the fact that commercial pet food contains preservatives and artificial coloring, two favorite boogeymen of the “natural food” crowd.
Yes, dogs can digest the grains used in pet food, contrary to claims otherwise.
No, cooking does not destroy all the nutrients. Some, but not all, by a long shot. It also kills bacteria and parasites, two big plusses in any food.
No, dog food is not made from dead pets. This offensive urban myth was investigated by the FDA and found wanting.
There are other myths raw pet foodies like to promote, such as veterinary schools not teaching nutrition, and what little they learn is controlled by the pet food industry. But let’s get to the facts.
Once fully digested, the raw pet food movement doesn’t seem so palatable.
As noted, the FDA plans to send agents out into the field for testing. Why? Because:
the scientific literature indicates that feeding raw foods to household pets such as dogs or cats carries a risk to human and animal health. Even if the pets do not appear to be sick after consuming raw pet foods containing pathogens such as Salmonella and Listeria monocytogenes, they can become carriers of such pathogens and transfer the pathogens to the environment. Humans can be infected by contacting pathogens in the contaminated environment. Raw pet foods containing pathogens can also contaminate food contact surfaces and human hands that increase the risk of human exposure.
But that’s not the only risk. Julie Churchill, DVM, a specialist in companion animal nutrition at the University of Minnesota’s College of Veterinary Medicine, strongly disagrees with the BARF diet, because eating bones can be fatal.
Bones, even raw and ground ones, can perforate the [gastrointestinal] tract. This can lead to peritonitis, severe infections, require emergency surgery, and dogs die from this each year…
Risks aside, what about evidence that a raw food diet is better for your pet? There is none. In fact,
on the basis of published diet reviews, most home-prepared diets (both raw and cooked) are deficient in 1 or more essential fatty acids, vitamins, or minerals or a combination thereof. Although the perceived benefits of home-prepared diets may be reinforced daily to owners through a pet’s appetite or coat quality, nutrient deficiencies and excesses in adult animals are insidious and can lead to long-term complications if not detected and corrected.
In addition to the FDA and the CDC, the American Veterinary Medical Association, American College of Veterinary Nutritionists, American Animal Hospital Association, National Association of State Public Health Veterinarians and American Association of Feline Practitioners have all warned of the lack of benefit, as well as the dangers, of raw pet food diets. The American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association doesn’t take a position, in deference to the “holistic” vets who recommend raw diets and sell raw pet food products.
So, risks to pets and their owners from infections and, to pets, from bone fragments and nutritional deficiencies, and no evidence to support it supposed benefits.
Billinghurst rejects the lack of evidence with that ubiquitous CAM practitioner claim – “I’ve seen it work.” As far as the risks, he blows them off with the unfounded assertion that eating pathogens is no big deal, because dogs are “designed” to eat these things. It’s even ok for immune-compromised animals.
All of this is nonsense, but Billinghurst has his reputation and a raw pet food empire to think about. For example, you can get two 3 lb. bags of BARF World “Juicy Chicken Nuggets,” which contains not only chicken, but also vegetables, fruits, cayenne pepper and garlic, for a mere $37.97, plus $15.50 in shipping costs. If this is really what wolves eat, they are surely the unheralded gourmets of the animal world. Who knew animals used herbs and spices? But wait – there’s more: if you sign up for the BARF World automatic shipping plan (meaning, they’ll automatically send you the right amount of food, expertly calculated for your pet, in perpetuity) you get free shipping.
But what if your dog or cat doesn’t tolerate BARF World pet food? Not to worry. Some may exhibit brief symptoms of “detox,” like diarrhea and vomiting, but this is normal, especially when converting from a “processed diet.”
BARF World also sells a lot of other CAM stuff for your pet, such as Kefir and “Eastern Medicine” herbal supplement formulas. For example, “G.I Tract Herbal Formula for Dogs,” “harmonizes the stomach,” and, as an added bonus, “helps maintain contentment during travel” for dogs that have digestion issues, as well as those who “don’t want to travel in a vehicle.” You can even get a consultation with a “holistic” vet.
Although BARF World may have the imprimatur of Billinghurst himself, several other raw pet food companies have gotten on the gravy train, and at similar prices. No benefit, more risk, and higher prices. Yep, sounds like CAM to me.
If you want to subject yourself to unproven raw food fads, I suppose that’s your business. But leave your poor pet out of it.

Pet Food Mislabeling: Let Food Be Thy Dogma
Should you feed your dog organic, biodynamic, grain-fed, non-GMO, high-protein, low-carb, unpasteurized, cruelty-free, free-range, soy-lacto-egg-free caribou Num-Nums? Particularly when their last meal was cat vomit?
Greg Bishop on August 30, 2019
Link

Zealotry about pet food is every bit as self-satisfied as a Food Babe mantra. Since food is the new religion, and pets are the new kids, the new angels and demons must be different ingredients in pet foods. Ask a chihuahua owner in the pet store why they’re reaching for a $40 bag of kibble with a painting of a wolf eating a caribou, and they’ll usually say, “Because it’s biologically appropriate“. As the joke goes, I’ve never seen a pack of chihuahuas hunting caribou (the closest I’ve seen is a Chihuahua wearing a reindeer outfit). But let’s just say for sake of argument that Paleo for poodles were better for dogs (it’s not). If that were true (and again, it’s not), can you wriggle your self-righteous nose knowing that you’ve given Mrs. Fluffybutt the finest tundra ungulate* meat available?
Well no, and not just because your premise is wrong.
The problem is a little-talked-about issue in pet food known as mislabeling. Mislabeling means the contents of the food are different from what is stated on the label. It can be either added ingredients that aren’t listed, or listed ingredients that aren’t added. It’s rampant in pet food, and despite being pervasive, it’s a largely ignored issue in the greater fanaticism about what our pets eat. Mislabeling is just one problem in pet food, which is about as full of myths as the Greek pantheon. We’ll get to mislabeling in a bit…
But first, let’s all freak out about pet food
If you want to test the limits of your sanity, walk into a boutique pet store and ask the kind-hearted attendant what you should feed your Norwegian puffinhund. There is a great deal of public confusion about what pets should be eating. We’ve seen a completely unnecessary “grain free” movement that now may be responsible for making hundreds of pets sick. And thousands if not millions of pet owners feed their pets raw meat in a misguided belief that they are doing them a favor. Many if not most of these people are well-intentioned but misinformed, but then of course there are all sorts of scams taking advantage of these fears, including a cringe-worthy Netflix “documentary”, and bogus food allergy kits marketed to pet owners.
This is all exhaustingly familiar to skeptical eaters of food, who know that most fear-mongering about most foods is ignorant bunk at best, and profit-motivated deception at worst. There are strong incentives in the pet food industry to hype their food, with annual sales of pet food in the US at about $30 billion, and over 600 brands (not types or formulas but brands) of pet food all competing with each other for your dollar. At the same time, the size of a bag of pet food is getting smaller, so we’re spending more money on smaller, more customized pet foods. People are paying a premium to get what they believe are superior ingredients. Even if they don’t need it (and again, they don’t), at least what’s on the label should be what’s in the bag, right?
The (actual) truth about what’s in pet food
Now let’s get back to mislabeling. You might be surprised to find out that the ingredient list on a bag of pet food is not a sacrosanct document verifying the precise contents of that particular bag. However, there are a number of studies looking at the discrepancy between food labeling and actual contents (reviewed nicely here). Of the nearly 800 foods investigated in this review, about 45% tested positive for unlabeled ingredients, with some studies showing rates as high as 83%. Most of these cases were of unlabeled added ingredients, but a significant number of them couldn’t find a labeled ingredient in the food! What’s more, most of these tests used PCR, which only works when you know exactly what you’re looking for,** so it’s probable that the actual percentage of mislabeled foods is much higher.
That is a decent sample of commercial pet foods and a shockingly high amount of mislabeling. Even with “limited ingredient” products, which are marketed to owners of pets who may have a sensitivity or allergy to certain foods, a recent study found that all the diets included had DNA from a source not listed on the ingredient list (and one diet didn’t even test positive for the listed ingredient!). And even in the diet that is considered the gold standard for dogs with dietary allergies (a hydrolysed protein diet) unlabeled proteins that could be allergens were detected.
It seems there’s a lot of “other” stuff in pet foods, although the amounts detected could have been trace and contaminants from using the same equipment to process different types of foods. In case you are smugly scoffing at the pet food manufacturers for being incompetent yokels, be aware that your own food supply is hardly better. Food mislabeling in human products is rampant as several high profile scandals (tah–dah!) made clear.
Does any of this actually matter?
We don’t actually know how much of a problem this is. PCR is extremely sensitive, so the amount of mislabeled ingredients in pet food might not even cause clinical problems. But obviously there are issues of consumer protection and outright food fraud to contend with. I, for one, would be a bit miffed if I walked into a movie theater to watch Toy Story 4 and was instead shown Fifty Shades Freed, even if they’re equally as entertaining.
For some individuals though, mislabeled food can be a serious problem. Consider the warnings on food packages that state whether or not a product was processed on equipment that also processes nuts. The FDA regulates both human and pet food, and issues dozens of allergen-related food recalls each year. Fortunately, dogs and cats don’t often get severely ill from dietary allergens, but there are lots of pets that don’t tolerate some ingredients. For those of us and our pets without dietary allergies, it’s pretty unlikely that any of these ingredients are making us sick in any way.
Conclusion: Don’t quibble about kibble
Most pet food labeling is simply not very helpful. The front of the package labeling is often woefully misguiding, and most pet owners aren’t aware of what they should be looking for. There’s little guarantee that the ingredients listed are an accurate representation of the food in the bag, even though mislabeling pet food is a federal crime. Pet owners, like most people, think food is a lot more important to health than it is. But dogs are evolved from dumpster diving mongrels, and wolves in captivity do great on commercial dog food, so can we all agree that most pets are going to be fine on most foods (in fact they’ll eat almost anything), as long as they’re not overfed? No? We can’t agree? Okay, well then I guess I’ll just keep working on suppressing my sense of irony as English bulldog owners proudly tell me they would never give their dog a food that contains GMO’s. Sigh.

*Can we please, please call caribou tundrgulates?
**For example, nobody was looking for tree DNA, which may be making its way into pet food soon.

Licking
A dog’s mouth is likely less ‘dirty’ than a meth mouth.
Mark Crislip on August 20, 2024
Link

There is this myth that a dog’s mouth is cleaner than a human’s mouth. I don’t think so. Yeah, an animal that neither brushes nor flosses and, depending on the breed, can lick its ass has a cleaner mouth than a human. Right. Seem believable only if the comparator human has meth mouth. But otherwise? Not so much.
I suspect, and this is just an edumacated guess, it is due to the circumstances surrounding the bites. A dog’s bite is often a ripping and tearing injury and those with the bite get to the emergency room ASAP for care. Human bites are often one drunk male hitting another drunk male in the mouth or getting bit, and due to the inebriation, there is delay in seeking care so the infection has an opportunity to fester. Cat bites tend to be injection injuries, the thin sharp teeth pushing bacteria deep into tissues with minimal tissue damage to I&D.
As one of many asides, although I watched the Adams Family as a youth, it wasn’t until I was late middle age that I realized the meaning of the name Uncle Fester. The Fester part, not the Uncle. Around the same time, I realized why the rocks next to Haystack Rock were the Needles. Nothing is as invisible as the glaringly obvious. Like Homeopathy is only water. Or Soylent Green is people.
Not that human mouths are all that clean. The mouth and teeth have a rich microbiome of Streptococci, anaerobes (depending on the dentition), non-syphilitic (one hopes) spirochetes, and a lot of other species.

The Oral cavity is one of the most well-studied microbiomes to date with a total of 392 taxa that have at least one reference genome and the total genomes across the oral cavity approaching 1500.[21]
Approximately 700 species of prokaryotes have been identified in it. These species belong to 185 genera and 12 phyla, of which approximately 54% are officially named, 14% are unnamed (but cultivated) and 32% are known only as uncultivated phylotypes. The 12 phlya are Firmicutes, Fusobacteria, Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Chlamydiae, Chloroflexi, Spirochaetes, SR1, Synergistetes, Saccharibacteria (TM7) and Gracilibacteria (GN02).
You kiss your significant other with that mouth? You betcha.
None of these organisms are particularly pathogenic, at least locally. Suck some spit into an airway during a drug-induced stupor, they may cause a lung abscess. Get them in the blood, you may get a heart valve infection. How do these bacteria get in the blood? Brushing, flossing and picking. Those with oral Streptococci as a cause of endocarditis were more likely
…to use toothpicks, dental water jet, interdental brush, and/or dental floss (OR, 3.48; 95% CI, 1.30-9.32), and to have had dental procedures during the prior 3 months (OR, 3.31; 95% CI, 1.18-9.29), whereas they were less likely to brush teeth after meals.
And IVDA. Many an injection drug user will lick the needle just prior to injecting. Some because the needle slides in easier, some to taste the drug.
Thirteen (32.5%, 95% CI, 18.6-49.1) of 40 subjects reported licking their needles prior to injecting. Reasons included ritualistic practices, cleaning the needle, enjoying the taste of the drug, checking the “quality” of the drug, and checking that the needle was in usable condition.
And with the drug some Streptococci go along for the ride and seed the heart valve. Although, as a variation on the theme (Infectious Diseases and Bach have a lot in common) I had one patient with a Neisseria sicca endocarditis likely from licking the blood off the infection site. Now don’t go ick, a show of hands, how many of you will stick a bleeding finger in your mouth?. No one? I’m it? OK.
Let’s move on.
Dogs do have an interesting oral microbiome with a few organisms that can occasionally become pathogenic. Streptococcus canis, Staphlococcus pseudintermedius, Capnocytophagia canimorusus and Pasturella spp. Cats are most associated with Pasturella infections, but most mammals have their own Pasturella, including humans. Get bit by a bison? Could result in a Pasturella infection.
Infections from Pasturella associated with cats were not uncommon. My most memorable? The diabetic leg infection from walking barefoot with a foot ulcer in a house with dozens of cats, the peritonitis in the peritoneal dialysis patient whose cat slept in their bag warmer, and the teenager with meningitis who liked to put tuna on her nose for the cat to lick off. The veins around the nose drain straight back into the CNS, so every time you sqooze a nose zit, you were flirting with death. It is called the ‘triangle of death‘ for a reason.
It is hard to get infected. Most organisms are not pathogenic, and the few that can cause disease do so only rarely. Just often enough, I suppose, to give me a career.
I did see the occasional infection from dogs mouths that were not due to a bite. The most curious was the child with Pasturella meningitis whose family dog liked to lick the head of the child. Kind of like trying to get to the center of a Tootsie Roll pop. And there was the occasional cellulitis of the leg from a dog associated Streptococcus due to the dog licking the feet of the patient. One patient, with severe neuropathy, had several episodes of cellulitis as he could not feel the dog licking. This can occasionally lead to the loss of a toe. Or two.
Never let your dog acquire a taste for sweet, sweet human flesh.
It has been noted that dogs will lick their wounds, occasionally past the point of benefit. Besides mechanically cleaning the wound, there are proteins in dog saliva with mild antibacterial effects and that perhaps aid in wound healing.
Canine saliva was tested for its bactericidal effects against pathogens relevant to the presumed hygienic functions of maternal grooming of the mammary and anogenital areas and licking of wounds. Both female and male saliva were bactericidal against Escherichia coli and Streptococcus canis but only slightly, and nonsignificantly, bactericidal against coagulase positive staphylococcus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. E. coli is the cause of highly fatal coliform enteritis of neonatal mammals and E. coli and S. canis are the main pathogens implicated in neonatal septicemia of dogs. The bactericidal effects of saliva would facilitate the hygienic function of maternal licking of the mammary and anogenital areas in protecting newborns from these diseases.
Which is true of all body fluids, as without antibacterial effects, spit, tears and other body fluids would be nothing but bacterial and fungal growth media.
Human mouths are the same yet different.
The oral proteomes of dogs and humans were appreciably different. Proteins related to apoptosis processes and biological adhesion were predominated in dog saliva. Drug-target network predictions by STITCH Version 5.0 showed that dog salivary proteins were found to have potential roles in tumorigenesis, anti-inflammation and antimicrobial processes. In addition, proteins related to regeneration and healing processes such as fibroblast growth factor and epidermal growth factor were also up-regulated in dogs.
Humans put a lot of…..interesting…. things in our mouths. I will not be one to judge. But what goes in the mouth can be chock-a-block full of bacteria that cause us no harm because of extensive anti-bacterial systems. The immune system consumes 25-30% of the body energy production keeping the microbial world at bay. About the same as the brain or resting skeletal muscle. Like I said, it is hard to get infected by most bacteria.
But some, noting that dogs and other animals like rats lick their wounds, conclude not that animals should lick their wounds, but that their dog and cat should lick the human’s wound, in my practice most often a diabetic foot ulcer.
Most sites suggest having a dog lick your wounds is a bad idea. But not all.
If your cut is small, you may feel comfortable with your dog licking and attending to your wound. If that is the case, it is suggested that you allow your dog to lick your wound. It is important to make sure your dog has been fully dewormed and checked by the veterinarian. It can be helpful in trusting this process, so no infection is created. If your dog is not willingly trying to lick at your wound, it shouldn’t be something you push at. Your wound may be something that your dog does not desire to lick and it may be something your dog feels sick over, too, and does not like it. Therefore, if you feel safe and your dog desires to lick your wound, then it may be something to encourage and allow. Yet, it is important to do what is best for you, your health, and your dog.
Many are wishy-washy,.
Letting your dog lick your wounds may not always be harmful, but it doesn’t mean you should encourage your dog to do it. The bacteria in a dog’s mouth could give you an infection and there have been some rare cases where the infection has been life-threatening.
And, of course, there is TicTok, land of fools.
Many of the websites mention the usual dog pathogens and rabies as a risk. There is almost no dog rabies in the US thanks in most part to a vaccine and in part due to Atticus. If your dog has rabies, you have more to worry about than it gently licking your blackberry scratches.
By the way, I remain of the opinion that blackberries are sentient and attack like apple trees when you pick the fruit. And that the thorns are more painful than equally sized sharp objects. I do not know if it is the shape or if the thorn has an irritant. The topic has never been scientifically investigated. And I guess from last weeks Nature, they are prickles, not thorns.
Pubmed has 43 hits for dog lick infection, including the dread Capnocytophagia sepsis in the asplenic. Cats not so much.
As another aside, as a kid I thought the Scott decision was considered so awful, it was the dread Scott decision. Like the dread Pirate Roberts. Only late in life did I discover his first name was Dred. But I still think I was correct in spirit if not in fact.
First, I know dogs will eat vomit and shit, but still. Ick. For the dog. And as I mentioned, you really don’t want human to be part of your dog’s diet.
While there are animal models to show benefit from licking wounds, there are zero clinical trials comparing animal wound licking to standard care. I would suggest that while you may get away with a dog licking a wound, the intervention is no better than soap and water and certainly has the chance of starting an infection.
But I was always a minimalist for wound care. As a medical student a plastic surgeon attending opined that you should never put in a wound what wouldn’t put in your eye. I usually, but not always, followed that idea and treated wounds with contact lenses.
But animal spit? Bad idea.
Being licked by pet dogs is frequently a common advice in articles for the uninitiated. An overview is given about the special antibacterial and wound healing properties of human and canine saliva. New developments in the human area are presumably assigned to dog saliva. Because of the presence of a quite different mouth flora including various potential zoonotic pathogens, it is strictly not advised to let dogs lick the wounds or face of the human.
Plus, while we often share bacteria, nonpathogenic and pathogenic, with our pets, why go out of the way to give dogs our pathogens?
My rule, a parallel to ‘lips that touch wine shall never mine,’ is ‘animals that can lick their butt shall never lick my wound or cut.’
But a dog licking your wound is likely better than one alternative:
You should be aware of the case of an Oregon teacher who was reprimanded after licking the blood from wounds on a track team member’s knee, a football player’s arm, and a high school student’s hand.
I mentioned all this to my wife. Her response? “What is wrong with people?”
I can’t disagree. Kind of sums up this blog.

Homeopathy
Brennen McKenzie on January 26, 2013
Link
It can be frustrating, and sometimes even a little depressing, to be a skeptic. Promoting reason and science-based medicine often feels like a Sisyphean effort that garners lots of hostility and ad hominem attacks from proponents of pseudoscience and few concrete victories. But once in a while, something happens to give a little hope and inspiration.
In 2010, for example, the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report on homeopathy came out, clearly unmasking homeopathy for the vitalist 18th century relic it is (though, sadly, politics is complicated and often unmoved by mere scientific truth, and the government didn’t eagerly embrace the findings or recommendations of the committee). About the same time, the British Medical Association called homeopathy “witchcraft,” and recommended it no longer be supported by the National Health Service. More recently, the Chief Medical Officer in Britain openly acknowledged homeopathy is “rubbish.” Perhaps there has been a shift in the winds? Maybe there is hope that the institutions of government and organized mainstream medicine here in the U.S. might be willing to start taking a stand against pseudoscience in the way they used to in the days before Wilk vs American Medical Association?
As a veterinarian, I was particularly delighted and inspired in March, 2012 when the Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) joined in this movement and took a firm and public stand on unscientific therapies, in particular washing its hands of homeopathy:
Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) resources will not be used to promote therapies that, in the Board’s opinion, are not compatible with current understanding of physiology and pathophysiology and have been demonstrated to be ineffective by the current accumulated body of knowledge.
That the Board agreed that the veterinary therapies of homeopathy and homotoxicology are considered ineffective therapies in accordance with the AVA promotion of ineffective therapies Board resolution.
This echoed the policies of the British Veterinary Association, and other national veterinary groups in Sweden, Denmark, and elsewhere in Europe. The idea that the central player in organized veterinary medicine in the U.S., the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), which has as members more than 80% of the licensed veterinarians in the country, could be moved to take a similar stand started to seem like a realistic possibility.

The existing AVMA policy on Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine (CAVM) has some nice sentiments in it.
The AVMA believes that all veterinary medicine, including CAVM, should be held to the same standards. Claims for safety and effectiveness ultimately should be proven by the scientific method… Practices and philosophies that are ineffective or unsafe should be discarded…
However, in the roughly 11 years since that policy was adopted, not a single practice or philosophy actual has been discarded, or identified as inconsistent with the scientific method or established scientific knowledge. It has become merely institutional cover for veterinarians practicing alternative therapies to claim that these are recognized and compatible with scientific medicine despite the lack of meaningful supporting evidence.
So a group of veterinarians from the Connecticut Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) and the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine Association (EBVMA; of which I am currently president), decided to submit a resolution to the AVMA governing body (the House of Delegates), re-affirming that veterinary medicine should be science based and finally identifying homeopathy as the pseudoscientific nonsense it is.
The full text of the resolution can be found here, but the core of it is in these statements:
RESOLVED, that the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) affirms that—
     1.  Safety and efficacy of veterinary therapies should be determined by scientific investigation.
     2.  When sound and widely accepted scientific evidence demonstrates a given practice as ineffective or that it poses risks greater than its possible benefits, such ineffective or unsafe philosophies and therapies should be discarded.
     3.  In keeping with AVMA policy on Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine, AVMA discourages the use of therapies identified as unsafe or ineffective, and encourages the use of the therapies based upon sound, accepted principles of science and veterinary medicine.
     4.  Homeopathy has been conclusively demonstrated to be ineffective.
There is nothing here that ought to be remotely controversial for the vast majority of veterinarians who practice conventional medicine. And while proponents of all pseudoscience like to pretend their practices are scientifically legitimate, the evidence that homeopathy is both inconsistent with established science (should not work) and demonstrably ineffective (does not work) is overwhelming. The CVMA and EBVMA accompanied the resolution with a white paper, The Case Against Homeopathy, which illustrated in detail the following points:
    • It is generally accepted in veterinary and human medicine that the safety and efficacy of medical therapies is best determined by scientific investigation and scientific evidence.
    • The principles of homeopathy are incompatible with well-established scientific knowledge.
    • There is abundant pre-clinical research showing most homeopathic remedies (those that are highly diluted) have no biological effects.
    • There is abundant clinical research in humans showing homeopathy to be no more effective than placebo.
    • The limited veterinary research available is consistent with the research done in humans in showing that homeopathy has only placebo effects, not specific therapeutic treatment effects.
The resolution had support among a wide range of veterinarians working in different fields. Official endorsements came from the American College of Veterinary Clinical Pharmacology, the American Academy of Veterinary Pharmacology and Therapeutics, and the American Society of Laboratory Animal Practitioners. A number of individual veterinarians also publically supported the measure.
A particularly compelling letter of support came from Dr. Narda Robinson at Colorado State University. Though supportive of some forms of complementary and alternative treatment, Dr. Robinson was concerned about both the evidence against any real benefit from homeopathy and the official policy of the Academy of Veterinary Homeopathy (AVH) to discourage conventional medical care. The presence of such allies added to the sense that the times were a-changing, and at last we might be able to do something about this ridiculous bit of vitalism.
There was also, however, a conspicuous silence from many organizations whose members aren’t usually practitioners of homeopathy but who, for various reasons, were unwilling to acknowledge publically that it is nonsense. There was hope, for example, that the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine (ACVIM) would endorse the resolution. One of the most respected specialty colleges in veterinary medicine, this group could have significant influence on the acceptability of pseudoscience like homeopathy.
The ACVIM declined to endorse the resolution despite the fact that most of its members do not accept the scientific legitimacy of homeopathy. The reasoning and individual comments offered in their explanation of this decision exemplifies the flaws in the philosophy of evidence-based medicine that have led the group founding SBM to take on the cause of science-based medicine instead:
It should be stated outright that the BOR believes that evidenced-based medicine should be the foundation of the practice of veterinary medicine as much as possible. Realistically, however, we all recognize that many treatment and diagnostic decisions applied to veterinary patients, both by general practitioners and veterinary specialists are made in the absence of evidence…
If I tried to say that I believe all therapy must be based on scientific evidence and clinical trial data, I would be an absolute hypocrite, and I would be reduced to being able to treat a handful of diseases.
This is the argument that says, in essence, that EBM requires optimal evidence before a judgment can be made, and in the absence of near perfect, gold standard RCT evidence, everyone should be free to do whatever they like based on any theoretical reasoning or personal intuition or experience. This approach, which ignores the vast knowledge we have already accumulated which makes some hypothesis far more likely to be true than others, reduces EBM to an intellectual curiosity with no practical value. If we cannot distinguish between homeopathy and conventional medicine after 200 years of scientific research, then we might as well give up entirely on the notion that science is of any use in informing clinical decision making.
Fifty years ago, we had no clue that genes could be normal, but silenced. We had no mechanism for how non-mutating substances cause cancer. We now know they do. I cannot feel comfortable speaking with strong certainty that an entire form of medicine does not work when it is practiced in many parts of the world, journals describing it are indexed in Pubmed, and many are equally convinced of its efficacy.
This is the familiar fallacy that because unexpected or improbable things have turned out to be true in the past, and because our knowledge is inevitable flawed and incomplete, we must refrain from ever judging anything to be untrue, with dash of the argumentum ad populum fallacy for seasoning.
There are too many shades of grey surrounding what we each do on a day-to-day basis to comfortably single out a particular therapy for condemnation because of a lack of evidence. There are many forms of “unconventional” or “alternative” therapy with no more evidence of efficacy than homeopathy. And even when using “conventional” therapy in an empiric manner, problems with the resolution arise. Every patient empirically treated without a definitive diagnosis is, in essence (in my opinion), a violation of at least the spirit of the resolution (and with as much potential for harm from delayed diagnosis as any non-traditional therapy). Every time I reach for certain dangerous drugs (eg, chemotherapy drugs, glucocorticoids) because I have nothing else to offer, I violate the spirit of the resolution (and arguably in a more severe manner in that my non-evidenced-based therapy has a greater likelihood of causing harm than the homeopathic treatment). Where would/should the lines be drawn then?
Given the necessity in many cases to make decisions with only scant, poor quality or even conflicting evidence an alternative wording to the resolution that many BOR members seemed comfortable with is offered:
     1.  Safety and efficacy of veterinary therapies should be determined whenever possible by scientific investigation.
     2.  When sound and widely accepted scientific evidence demonstrates a given practice as ineffective, or that it poses risks greater than its benefits, such ineffective and unsafe philosophies and therapies should be discouraged.
     3.  Veterinarians may legally employ any therapy not proscribed by applicable laws and regulations governing the practice of veterinary medicine. However, veterinarians have an ethical duty to society, and to their patients and clients, to ignore their biases and instead base their judgments and recommendations as often as possible on the best available scientific evidence.
This statement seems to me to be saying, “We believe science is the best way to validate medical therapies, but we aren’t willing to say that anything is ever invalidated unless nothing we do involves any evidentiary uncertainty.” To suggest that empirical use of chemotherapeutics is roughly equivalent to treating cancer with water is clearly ridiculous. Yet there is a component of humility and a sense of fairness that makes this sort of reasoning very appealing to the majority of veterinarians who don’t believe in homeopathy but are reluctant to criticize their colleagues who do.
While I applaud the recognition of our individual and collective ignorance and limitations, I believe it does no service to our patients and clients if we mistake post-modernism for humility. The evidence against therapeutic bloodletting was no better than that against homeopathy, and it was no less plausible. Should we revive that practice because we have not definitively demonstrated it is useless in all circumstances by extensive and perfect RCTs? Lines should, indeed, be drawn, and while they may not always be perfectly drawn and immutable, they can be based on a thoughtful and reasonable assessment of the available evidence.
As I see it, all conclusions in science are, of course, provisional and subject to revision as new evidence is developed. And our confidence in our conclusions should be proportional to the evidence available to support them. So it is possible evidence could be developed to validate homeopathy as a clinical intervention. Personally, I see this as about as likely as the emergence of evidence that the Earth does not, in fact, revolve around the Sun, but in some theoretical sense at least it is possible. And the evidence concerning homeopathy is not impervious to criticism, especially given the generally low level and poor quality of it. However, if we cannot draw conclusions about a therapy until near perfect evidence is available, then EBM is useless as a decision-making tool.
My own approach is that we must critically evaluate and rank the evidence according to EBM methods, then integrate this with other relevant information, such as biologic plausibility, and make a pragmatic decision based on the evidence that exists. Accepting the provisional nature of such decisions, we must be willing to re-evaluate them as necessary, but it does no good to simply refrain from making them at all if the evidence is less than ideal. We don’t entirely understand the mechanisms of gravity, but we refrain from leaping out of windows all the same.
In the case of homeopathy, the absence of evidence seems very much to be evidence of absence given the implausible foundations and the failure of numerous attempts to validate the method over two centuries. If even this is not sufficient to declare the therapy ineffective (with, of course, the very small caveat that allows for new evidence to someday emerge), then I cannot see how any therapy can ever be discarded or how EBM can provide effective guidance for clinicians in selecting interventions.
Less surprising and disappointing than the failure of support from the reasonable mainstream of veterinary medicine was the opposition from the expected sources. The AVH and the American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association (AHVMA) both opposed it. The AVH attempted to muddy the waters in the usual way by producing a white paper of their own, The Evidence for Homeopathy, which claims to show that homeopathy is based on legitimate, validated scientific principles and has abundant evidence of clinical benefit.
This paper illustrates exactly the points made and demonstrated in The Case Against Homeopathy. Low-quality studies with poor control for bias, confounding, and other sources of error are cited to justify claims that the evidence does not support. Sometimes, even studies which find no effect are cited to support claims of an effect. Bits of legitimate science are misinterpreted to generate the false impression that they validate the implausible theoretical foundations of homeopathy. Clear publication bias in support of homeopathy is ignored whereas negative evidence is dismissed on the basis of presumed individual bias regardless of the methodological controls used to account for this. This document was a transparent attempt to select and distort the evidence in favor of their pre-exiting beliefs.
Though tedious, I thought it might be useful to go through the AVH document point by point, including critically appraising each of the references cited. The result is The Evidence for Homeopathy-A Close Look, which deconstructs the bogus arguments of the AVH in exhaustive detail (for this, I want to specifically give my thanks to the other authors at SBM, to Orac of Respectful Insolence, and to the folks at Rational Veterinary Medicine, where I found invaluable information about some of the research cited in the AVH paper).
Apart from the AVH attempt to manufacture scientific legitimacy for their approach, there was the usual hue and cry of a less academic nature. The folks at Mercola.com offered some of the usual hysteria and hyperbole about “health freedom” and the right to peddle and procure whatever medical interventions anyone wants, regardless of evidence concerning safety or efficacy. And one leading opponent of the resolution, a homeopath involved in the AVH and often seen lecturing on homeopathy at mainstream veterinary continuing education meetings, went so far as to compare this resolution to the Holocaust: “She felt that this was her personal Kristallnacht, that the walls came down around her and that she was being marginalized from within her own AVMA.” The AVH submitted a letter full of smoke and mirrors and outright error commenting on specific statements in The Case Against Homeopathy, which I have responded to point by point. And apparently, individual veterinarians worried about losing their freedom to employ imaginary therapies contacted the AVMA to protest the shocking and outrageous idea of admitting homeopathy doesn’t work. About 700 emails and 250 phone calls were apparently received by the AVMA condemning the resolution. It goes almost without saying that the AVMA did not hear from nearly as many skeptics willing to openly speak against homeopathy.
So with pseudoscience and outrage pitted against a mountain of scientific evidence, any guesses as to the outcome?
Well, technically it wasn’t a defeat. The House of Delegates voted by about 3:1 not to vote on the content of the resolution but to refer it for evaluation to the committee that wrote the current CAVM policy quoted above. The same policy which made reasonable noises about the importance of science 11 years ago and has been rather quiet since in the face of apparently growing infiltration of homeopathy and other pseudoscientific practices into the mainstream. I’m not directly involved in the politics or the process, but my guess is the resolution will die quietly in committee, or perhaps be replaced by more vague noises about science and research without any clear statements about the validity of any specific intervention.
So are we slipping into a medical Age of Endarkenment in the U.S.? We still pay lip service to science evidence and reason, but even the best educated and trained among us accept shoddy science and postmodernist rationalizations as reasons to refrain from declaring even such egregious nonsense as homeopathy as out of bounds. It’s true, there are only about 130 members in the AVH, so homeopaths are a tiny minority within the veterinary profession. But with the complicity of the majority, unwilling to criticize anything our colleagues do, this minority can continue to sell pseudoscience and placebos to their clients.
And the AHVMA, which represents CAVM in general, is much larger and more influential than the AVH. They have recently raised about $400,000 to promote “integrative medicine” at mainstream veterinary schools, with an ultimate goal of $20 million and multiple academic centers promoting alternative therapies, positioning themselves as the Bravewell Collaboration of veterinary medicine. And despite their claims to respect science and support rigorous research, they have thrown their lot in decisively with the magic water that is homeopathy. What can skeptics use to combat those resources, other than mere facts and evidence, which seem less persuasive to our otherwise mainstream colleagues than we might hope?
The passionate few who are believers cannot, of course, make homeopathy anything other than a marginal practice, in most cases just added on to real medicine in true “integrative” fashion. After all, it doesn’t actually work. But the hope that we might actually see the death of it alltogether seems distant indeed. Like the proponents of intelligent design, homeopaths seem to be having some success generating a maufacturoversy, suggesting there is some legitimate scientific dispute concerning the plausibility and efficacy of homeopathy. And few of my colleagues in veterinary medicine seem inclined to look at the evidence critically and in depth themselves to see that there is, in fact, no real doubt or legitimate dispute. Money, popularity, and the voice of the passionate minority of believers seem unlikely to yield to mere reason and evidence, especially when shielded by the apathy or post-modern neutrality of the majority. Perhaps “Age of Endarkenment” is going a bit far, but some days the victories of the Age of Enlightenment seem evanescent, and it is clear we shall have to keep rolling the same old boulders up that hill for the forseeable future.

An Appraisal of Courses in Veterinary Chiropractic
R and O Kjellin an on March 16, 2012
Linl
Today’s guest article, by By Ragnvi E. Kjellin, DVM, and Olle Kjellin, MD, PhD, was submitted to a series of veterinary journals, but none of them wanted to publish it. ScienceBasedMedicine.org is pleased to do so.
Animal chiropractic is a relatively new phenomenon that many veterinarians may know too little about. In Sweden, chiropractic was licensed for humans in 1989, but not for animals. Chiropractors claim that their field is scientific, while others consider it to be a form of ”alternative medicine” with an implausible and unsubstantiated theoretical foundation and little evidence of efficacy. Chiropractic is not taught in medical or veterinary schools.
Courses in “veterinary chiropractic” are offered by two companies in Germany. In their classes, veterinarians and human chiropractors are purposely mixed. A recent malpractice case in Sweden involved one of their students, a veterinarian who was accused of injuring a horse with chiropractic neck manipulation. That case led us to inquire into the underlying theory, clinical practices, and training of “veterinary chiropractors”.
Human chiropractic was founded in 1895 when D.D. Palmer, a grocer and magnetic healer with no medical training, decided that 95% of all diseases were due to vertebral subluxations that blocked the flow through the spinal nerves to all muscles and organs of the body, including the brain, eyes and ears. Adjusting subluxations supposedly allows the body to heal itself by “innate intelligence.” Over a century later, there is still no evidence that such subluxations or “intelligence” exists.
Mainstream medicine has always been skeptical of chiropractic1. Even some chiropractors have criticized the practices of their colleagues2,3. Several recent meta-analyses of chiropractic for various ailments4,5,6 have concluded that musculoskeletal back and possibly neck pain may benefit from spinal manipulation therapy; but the results are not superior to other treatments, and there is no evidence of benefit for other ailments.
Considerable controversy surrounds the chiropractic field. It is therefore essential that veterinarians understand the facts about chiropractic before they consider practicing it, recommending it, or even condoning it for the animals they treat.
Materials and methods
The web sites of two training companies in Germany, viz. the BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts (BBA) and the International Academy of Veterinary Chiropractic (IAVC) and their parent organizations were reviewed. The 500-page course compendium7 from the BBA was closely scrutinized. As most of the Swedish veterinarians who attended chiropractic courses did so at the BBA, the focus of the appraisal was set on this organisation. Their claims were weighed against whatever evidence that could be found in peer-reviewed articles in PubMed and Ovid Medline concerning human as well as animal chiropractic.
Results
What is chiropractic?
Chiropractic is very poorly defined.2 Claims include:
    • ”Chiropractic is a health care discipline which emphasizes the inherent recuperative power of the body to heal itself without the use of drugs or surgery.
    • Chiropractic […] focuses particular attention on the subluxation.
    • A subluxation is a complex of functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes that compromise neural integrity and may influence organ system function and general health”8.
The subluxation is the core idea underlying chiropractic diagnosis and treatment. But there is no universally accepted definition. The original idea of a physical subluxation has not been substantiated, and neither have “functional and/or structural and/or pathological articular changes” been shown objectively to exist.
The subluxation concept is under constant debate within the chiropractic community3. A recent review of the literature by chiropractors searching for evidence that subluxations can affect health concluded that “No supportive evidence is found for the chiropractic subluxation being associated with any disease process or of creating suboptimal health conditions requiring intervention. Regardless of popular appeal this leaves the subluxation construct in the realm of unsupported speculation. This lack of supportive evidence suggests the subluxation construct has no valid clinical applicability”9. Despite this there are strong forces to preserve this concept10,11.
The standard chiropractic treatment is called adjustment or manipulation. Chiropractors claim that a “high velocity low amplitude” (HVLA) thrust in the plane of the joint will force it just slightly beyond its normal range of movement, but not so far as to cause an injury. This, they assert, will help the body to heal itself.
Chiropractic uses a plethora of treatment methods, though there seem to be no efforts to separate the chaff from the wheat12. Some are vigorous manipulations that cause audible cracking and popping sounds. Others consist of light touch or other methods that non-chiropractors may find strange. Many chiropractors mainly use physical methods directed at symptomatic areas, like physical therapists. Subluxation oriented chiropractors treat subluxations regardless of whether the patient has symptoms or not; healthy individuals, they say, need regular prophylactic adjustments. The courses and organizations of animal chiropractic under scrutiny here seem to belong to this latter group, as they emphasize the vertebral subluxation complex and its assumed effect on health and wellness.
History of animal chiropractic
Formal training in animal chiropractic was developed in the US during the 1990’s by the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association (AVCA), which was founded in 1988. From the very beginning, the basic course concept was to train veterinarians and (human) chiropractors together. In 2000, the AVCA was restructured into a professional organization and certifying agency for animal chiropractors. The training was then separated from AVCA and was named Options for Animals13.  Later on, two independent training organizations were founded in the USA with the same basic concept. One of them is the Healing Oasis Wellness Center (HOWC).
The two animal chiropractic courses in Germany, the BBA and IAVC, have strong connections with their parent organizations in the US, HOWC and Options for Animals, respectively. There also are strong bonds between the course organizers and the control organizations AVCA and IVCA (the International Veterinary Chiropractic Association). Options for Animals and AVCA were founded by the same person, and two of the owners of the IAVC founded the IVCA. The animal chiropractors are certified and the courses accredited by the AVCA and IVCA. The intricate relations are depicted in Fig. 1.

Course curriculum
The BBA course consists of five one-week modules: (I) cervical, (II) thoracolumbal, (III) sacropelvic, (IV) extremities and (V) integrated.
The curriculum contains established subjects like anatomy, neurology, biomechanics, pathology, etc., as well as more unconventional subjects such as adjustment techniques for “ribs, temporomandibular joints, tail and cranium.” Techniques taught include Logan Basic, Activator, and how to use “acupuncture, acupressure and applied kinesiology or magnetic therapy as well as physical modalities to speed up the healing process”.14
Other parts of the course are “Animal Chiropractic Philosophy” and “Chiropractic Basics” aimed at introducing the students to the vertebral subluxation complex. Under the heading “Chiropractic Pathology” they emphasize “the pathological changes of the joints, the body and compensatory mechanism that develop secondary to the vertebral subluxation complex”. Some of the ideas, techniques and methods taught warrant a closer look:
Craniosacral therapy
In craniosacral therapy the therapists use their hands to tune into what they call the craniosacral system. Working with the spine and the skull and its cranial sutures and fascia, the restrictions of nerve passages are said to be eased, the movement of cerebrospinal fluid through the spinal cord optimized, and misaligned bones restored to their proper position. They claim that they feel the pulse wave of the cerebrospinal fluid through the skull and along the spine to the sacrum, and even to the feet. The BBA compendium presents this as a useful technique to address the vertebral subluxation. Light touch will balance the craniosacral system and “remove restrictions in dura and fascia [and] cranial sutures”. This ignores the fact that the concepts underlying craniosacral therapy have been definitely refuted in several studies15-18. Even proponents find suture mobility to be no more than 0.07 mm even with very high distractive loads, though some still tend to regard this as “significant”19.
Logan basic
This technique regards the sacrum as the most important part of the body, and a “sacral subluxation” is said to cause impairments in the entire spine all the way up to the atlas20. According to a sample scenario in the BBA compendium, a right-sided ventro-caudal subluxation of the sacrum will cause lower cervical vertebrae to rotate to the right and the atlas to the left (called “Atlas left posterior”), and also cause a right paraspinal muscular spasm, a shorter right rear leg, and other abnormalities. To adjust the spinal subluxations, the sacrum has to be adjusted first. This is done with a very gentle touch with the thumb, “only 5 g”, on the lowest part of the sacrum21. The touch allegedly will cause a reflexive relaxation of the muscles, so that the sacrum can align itself. No scientific studies were found for Logan Basic.
The activator method
This is a system for diagnosis and treatment based on the idea that a difference in leg length will indicate where there is a need for adjustment. A small hand-held instrument with a spring-loaded mallet (Fig. 2) is then used ”to tap misaligned vertebrae back into place”22. The proponents claim that the Activator delivers a precise HVLA thrust, but that it is much gentler than the manual thrust and that they can direct the force more exactly23. (The thrust amplitude is up to about 4 mm.) The instrument also is claimed to be useful “for exciting a human spine at its natural frequency”24. In a British survey, 82% of the responding chiropractors said that they used an Activator25. Despite its long history and popularity, the Activator has been little studied and has not been validated for animals or humans26.

Applied kinesiology
AK is a diagnostic method where muscle strength is tested. It is based on the idea that the individual’s subconscious knows where in the body the problem originates, and that the muscle strength decreases when that part of the patient’s body is touched27. For instance, the patient is asked to extend an arm and resist the therapist’s pressure against it. If the patient has a knee problem, the muscle strength in the arm decreases when the therapist touches the knee. AK is also used to diagnose nutrient deficiencies, allergies and other ailments. Allergies are diagnosed if muscle strength appears to decrease when the patient holds a sealed vial of allergen in the other hand28. For animals (and small children), they test a surrogate person who is in contact with the patient29. One of the BBA instructors claims that “[m]uscle testing, when applied with knowledge, experience and passion, give the veterinarian an invaluable way to communicate with your patients and ask them the questions you’ve always wanted to ask them”30. We have not found any study corroborating these ideas31-34. On the contrary, the best evidence shows it is equivalent to coin tossing35.

The instructors
The instructors of the BBA, seven veterinarians and two chiropractors, are introduced on the web site. None of the veterinarians is a licensed chiropractor; they were trained at animal chiropractic courses in the US or Germany. Most of them practice acupuncture; some use applied kinesiology, osteopathy, and magnet therapy. The head instructor, Dr. Pedro Rivera, is also trained in homeopathy. Together with his wife, a massage and herbal therapist, he founded the Healing Oasis Wellness Center (HOWC) mentioned above. Both of the chiropractors and three of the veterinarians at the BBA are connected with the HOWC. This company organizes animal chiropractic courses and runs a veterinary hospital that focuses on alternative and integrative care, providing veterinary spinal manipulation, veterinary Chinese herbology, veterinary massage, veterinary homeopathy, veterinary acupuncture, mainstream veterinary care, and Feng Shui.
The compendium
The BBA compendium of animal chiropractic encompasses some 500 pages. Large parts deal with anatomy, neurology, pathology, saddle fit, etc. Other parts deal with the philosophy of chiropractic, specific treatment techniques, business tips, and more. Some of the sections are remarkable and deserve special mention:
Cranial sutures
Module I claims that “[t]he calcification process of cranial sutures is SLOW and UNEVEN. It is NOT completed even in the aged animal!: (Upper case and exclamation mark as in the original.) Their emphases seem to imply that they want their students to believe that these rigid, fibrous, highly interdigitated joints are actually possible to move to a significant and clinically useful extent. We have not identified any scientific support for this idea in the literature, but it obviously is necessary in order to rationalize craniosacral therapy.
Risks
It is widely accepted in mainstream medicine that neck manipulation in humans can cause strokes. There are hundreds of documented cases36,37 and a plausible pathoanatomical mechanism (injury to the vertebral artery in its tortuous passage through and around the atlas). But many chiropractors have denied any possible causal relationship, claiming that stroke at neck manipulation is a mere coincidence in persons who were going to have this stroke anyway, citing a study that actually fails to substantiate its hypothesis38.
In Module V, the BBA mentions the risk of chiropractic stroke but downplays its significance, saying it is less than the risk of dying under conventional medical care. However, a Swedish case of veterinary malpractice39 indicates that neck manipulation of a horse may be associated with stroke, which otherwise is unheard of in horses. This horse developed symptoms such as ataxia, dysphagia, and facial hemiparesis, compatible with a lateral medullary infarction (Wallenberg syndrome), which is typical of ischemia in the vertebrobasilar artery region. The horse died of esophageal obstruction some 18 months later.
Scientific validity
Under this heading the BBA cites four irrelevant references that fall very short of giving any validity to chiropractic in general, much less to animal chiropractic. The first one is the Manga Report, funded by the Ontario Ministry Of Health, Canada 199340. This political (not scientific or medical) report only dealt with the treatment of low back pain and concluded that chiropractic services were useful and more cost-effective than current medical treatment and should receive public funding.
The second reference is not even about chiropractic but about lumbosacropelvic anatomical variations in racehorses41. The third reference reports inconsistent variations in nerve signals from paraspinal muscle proprioceptors on manipulative-like loads in anesthetized cats, with no discussion of whether these findings had any clinical significance42. BBA’s fourth reference is a symposium abstract from 1999, not a peer reviewed article.
Discussion
Our research into veterinary chiropractic revealed that chiropractic as such is based on a pre-scientific, vitalistic belief system that can neither be proved nor falsified, and that the information provided for the courses in animal or veterinary chiropractic raises several concerns.
First, several of the subjects included in the curricula are patently pseudoscientific, lacking any biological plausibility, and even are irreconcilable with modern biomedical knowledge, e.g., the illusion that examiners can feel a craniosacral cerebrospinal fluid pulse; the idea that cranial bones can be repositioned in adults; the idea that subluxations exist in the sacrum of horses and can be adjusted with “five grams pressure” or a little mechanically assisted tap, whose proposed mechanisms of action seem rather absurd2. Of all subjects mentioned, Applied Kinesiology is the most bizarre and its surrogate testing beyond all reason. To include all this outlandish nonsense in courses for veterinarians is an insult to their profession.
Second, chiropractic is strongly connected with other unproven or disproven alternative methods, which is obvious from the CVs of the instructors and the range of treatments that the HOWC proffers in its web site.
Third, chiropractic calls itself scientific, but is based on a philosophy that the body can heal itself after adjustment of subluxations, not on any objective evidence. Nobody has been able to show that chiropractic subluxations exist, much less that they affect any functions of the nervous system to cause any illness.
Fourth, while in human studies there is weak support for some small beneficial effect of manipulation on low back pain, in animals there is no scientific support for any chiropractic manipulation treatment at all. Nevertheless, in all web pages and the BBA compendium the subluxation is presented as an obvious fact and the various methods and techniques as if they were well validated.
Courses that contain pre-scientific belief systems, pseudoscientific methods, imaginative ideas and unsubstantiated assertions have no place in veterinary medicine.
Animal chiropractic courses have only existed for a couple of decades and are given by a small number of zealots who are approved by one another. The merits of such accreditations have to be strongly questioned. We also question the basic concept of mixing veterinarians and human chiropractors in the same classes. How much veterinary medicine can the chiropractors learn in such a short time, and how much are the veterinarians influenced by the chiropractors’ strong faith and their skewed portrayal of the scientific evidence concerning chiropractic?
At the outset of this study, we expected that courses in chiropractic given by veterinarians for veterinarians would have selected elements credibly deemed to be applicable to animal care. However, this was not the case. The instructors and course materials do not discriminate between fantasy and reality but include even the most implausible ideas.
Conclusion: Animal chiropractic mixes science, pseudoscience, and fantasy
Animal chiropractic and the veterinary chiropractic courses scrutinized here mix science, pseudoscience and fantasy and make no visible effort to show which is which. They give biased information and refer to more or less irrelevant articles to make the courses look serious and credible. Many of the methods taught lack evidence as well as plausibility and are clearly outside the realm of medical science. We found no evidence for the use of animal chiropractic in veterinary medicine.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Dr. Harriet Hall, Dr. Brennen McKenzie, and Dr. David Ramey for valuable advice on various versions of this article.
About the Authors
Ragnvi E. Kjellin, DVM, is a graduate of the Swedish Veterinary University. She has always been a realist and skeptic, and has been keeping a scrutinizing eye over the Altmed frontier since a long time. She never stops being astonished of the gullibility of so many people. In the 1980’s there were not many alternative methods in veterinary medicine in Sweden, but they seem to be gaining ground at an accelerating pace. The Singh & Ernst book Trick or Treatment was a wake-up call, and she reviewed it in the Swedish Veterinary Journal.
Ragnvi has long had a particular interest in chiropractic, not only as it is the potentially most dangerous form due to direct injuries, but also as it cunningly has managed to put up and hide behind such a sciency facade that even many scientifically educated persons seem to have difficulties seeing through the obfuscation. The greatest shock was when she realized that even some veterinarians, i.e., persons with the same education as herself, were strong believers of animal chiropractic. And to her great dismay, even the Swedish Veterinary Journal regularly announces the courses in animal chiropractic!She wrote a critical article on animal chiropractic in the Journal — and got some remarkably hostile comments in subsequent issues.
Olle Kjellin, MD, PhD, is a Swedish radiologist and speech physiologist with a special interest in statistics and research methodology as well as in most medical subjects. Though not currently a researcher, he is a hungry but critical consumer of research papers. His MD is from Uppsala University, Sweden, and PhD (or, formally, Dr Med Sci) from Faculty of Medicine, Tokyo University, Japan. He also has an MA in linguistics, phonetics and modern languages from Stockholm University, Sweden. He can’t keep silent when he sees unsupported methods sneaking into the regular health care sector, and he has had several open conflicts with his employer and leading politicians against flimsy bullshit in the psychiatry sector.
Ragnvi and Olle share interests as above and have spent several years together researching all kinds of pseudoscientific ideas, mainly those with medical claims, and chiropractic in particular.
References
     1.  Kaptchuk TJ, Eisenberg DM. Chiropractic: origins, controversies, and contributions. Arch Intern Med 1998;158:2215-2224.
     2.  Homola S. Questionable Claims Made for Activator Methods. Website, 2006. Available at: http://www.chirobase.org/06DD/activator.html. Accessed July 21, 2011.
     3.  Keating JC, Jr., Charlton KH, Grod JP, et al. Subluxation: dogma or science? Chiropr Osteopat 2005;13:17.
     4.  Bronfort G, Haas M, Evans R, et al. Effectiveness of manual therapies: the UK evidence report. Chiropr Osteopat 2010;18.
     5.  Ernst E, Canter PH. A systematic review of systematic reviews of spinal manipulation. J R Soc Med 2006;99:192-196.
     6.  Rubinstein SM, van Middelkoop M, Assendelft WJ, et al. Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain: an update of a Cochrane review. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 2011;36:E825-846.
     7.  BBA (BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts). Veterinary Chiropractic, Modules I-V: Unpublished course compendia, 2007.
     8.  Association of Chiropractic Colleges. Bylaws; Chiropractic Paradigm. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.chirocolleges.org/paradigmscopepractice.html and http://tinyurl.com/chirocoll. Accessed March 12, 2011.
     9.  Mirtz TA, Morgan L, Wyatt LH, et al. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropr Osteopat 2009;17:13.
     10.  Lanigan R. United we stand, divided we fall. At last the UCA has taken the lead for chiropractors in the UK. Chiropracticlive. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.chiropracticlive.com/?p=842. Accessed March 12, 2011.
     11.  Rondberg TA. Saving our subluxation unites us. The Chiropractic Journal (electronic). Website, 2002:March. Available at: http://www.worldchiropracticalliance.org/tcj/2002/mar/mar2002rondberg.htm. Accessed Jan 25, 2010.
     12.  Keating JC, Jr. Several pathways in the evolution of chiropractic manipulation. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2003;26:300-321.
     13.  College of Animal Chiropractic. About Options for Animals. Website. Available at: http://www.animalchiro.com/aboutoptionsfor_animals.html#acc. Accessed July 17, 2011.
     14.  BBA (BackBone-Academy for Veterinary Chiropractic and Healing Arts). Basic Course. Website, 2010. Available at: http://www.backbone-academy.com/courses.html. Accessed July 17, 2011.
     15.  Green C, Martin C, Bassett K, et al. A systematic review of craniosacral therapy: biological plausibility, assessment reliability and clinical effectiveness. Complement Ther Med 1999;7:201-207.
     16.  Moran RW, Gibbons P. Intraexaminer and interexaminer reliability for palpation of the cranial rhythmic impulse at the head and sacrum. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2001;24:183-190.
     17.  Rogers JS, Witt PL, Gross MT, et al. Simultaneous palpation of the craniosacral rate at the head and feet: intrarater and interrater reliability and rate comparisons. Phys Ther 1998;78:1175-1185.
     18.  Hartman SE. Cranial osteopathy: its fate seems clear. Chiropr Osteopat 2006;14:10.
     19.  Johnson Zee L. The Controversy of Cranial Bone Movement. Massage Today 2008;08.
     20.  Logan Basic. Denver Gentle Chiropractic Dr. Albright. Website, 2009. Available at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=My3FbbxGPLY. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     21.  Equine Chiropractic. Logan Basic Move. Website, 2007. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/firstblob. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     22.  Glossary of Chiropractic Terms. Activator adjusting instrument. Website. Available at: http://www.superpages.com/supertips/chiropractic-terms.html. Accessed 19 July, 2011.
     23.  Cherok N. Introduction to Activator Chiropractic Care. Website, 2009. Available at: http://drcherok.com/ Accessed July 19, 2011.
     24.  Keller TS, Fuhr AW. Chiropractic adjusting instrument. 1997, US Patent No. US005626615. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/US005626615. Accessed June 19, 2011.
     25.  Read DT, Wilson FJH, Gemmell HA. Activator as a therapeutic instrument: Survey of usage and opinions amongst members of the British Chiropractic Association. Clinical Chiropractic 2006;9:70-75.
     26.  Fuhr AW, Menke JM. Status of activator methods chiropractic technique, theory, and practice. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2005;28:e1-e20.
     27.  Kuykendall K. Muscle Testing & Applied Kinesiology Demonstration 1. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm1. Accessed July 19, 2011.
     28.  Denver Chiropractor. Applied Kinesiology and Allergy Elimination. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm2. Accessed July 20, 2011.
     29.  Jankodyret. A veterinarian (E.S.) uses Applied Kinesiology with surrogate person. Website, 2009. Available at: http://tinyurl.com/AKfilm3. Accessed July 20, 2011.
     30.  DeStefano CJ. Applied Kinesiology and Functional Neurology in Animal Practice. Health Pioneers. Website, 2006. Available at: http://www.healthpioneers.net/art1.html. Accessed May 15, 2011.
     31.  Cuthbert SC, Goodheart GJ, Jr. On the reliability and validity of manual muscle testing: a literature review. Chiropr Osteopat 2007;15.
     32.  Haas M, Cooperstein R, Peterson D. Disentangling manual muscle testing and Applied Kinesiology: critique and reinterpretation of a literature review. Chiropr Osteopat 2007;15.
     33.  Hall S, Lewith G, Brien S, et al. A review of the literature in applied and specialised kinesiology. Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd 2008;15:40-46.
     34.  Gerez IF, Shek LP, Chng HH, et al. Diagnostic tests for food allergy. Singapore Med J 2010;51:4-9.
     35.  Lüdtke R, Kunz B, Seeber N, et al. Test-retest-reliability and validity of the Kinesiology muscle test. Complement Ther Med 2001;9:141-145.
     36.  Dziewas R, Konrad C, Drager B, et al. Cervical artery dissection — clinical features, risk factors, therapy and outcome in 126 patients. J Neurol 2003;250:1179-1184.
     37.  Leon-Sanchez A, Cuetter A, Ferrer G. Cervical spine manipulation: an alternative medical procedure with potentially fatal complications. South Med J 2007;100:201-203.
     38.  Cassidy JD, Boyle E, Cote P, et al. Risk of vertebrobasilar stroke and chiropractic care: results of a population-based case-control and case-crossover study. Spine 2008;33:S176-183.
     39.  Beck-Friis J. Ansvarsärende — Häst fick skada efter kiropraktisk behandling [Malpractice case — Horse injured after chiropractic treatment]. Svensk veterinärtidning [Swedish Veterinary Journal] 2009;61:51-55.
     40.  Manga P, Angus DE, Papadopoulos C, et al. A Study to Examine the Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness of Chiropractic Management of Low-Back Pain. Website, 1993. Available at: http://www.silcom.com/~dwsmith/manga.html. Accessed Dec 3, 2011.
     41.  Haussler KK, Stover SM, Willits NH. Developmental variation in lumbosacropelvic anatomy of thoroughbred racehorses. Am J Vet Res 1997;58:1083-1091.
     42.  Pickar JG, Wheeler JD. Response of muscle proprioceptors to spinal manipulative-like loads in the anesthetized cat. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2001;24:2-11.

Veterinary Chiropractic
Brennen McKenzie on April 12, 2013
Link
People are sometimes surprised to learn that all the heavy hitters of alternative medicine, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, etc., are inflicted on animals as well as humans. I’ve written about veterinary homeopathy, and the associated manufactroversy, in a previous post, and today I thought I’d take a look at veterinary chiropractic.
The Players
In most states, chiropractic is defined in terms of treatment of humans and chiropractors are thereby licensed only to treat humans. However, there are a variety of ways around this for people who want to subject their animals to this therapy. Some chiropractors will simply treat animals and ignore the fact that it isn’t technically legal for them to do so. And some veterinarians will take one of the many training courses available in animal chiropractic and then employ it as part of their practice of veterinary medicine. A previous SBM article has discussed the lack of consistency or legitimate scientific content in most of these courses.
State veterinary practice acts will also sometimes create legal space for animal chiropractic, often under another name, which avoids the jurisdictional problem of calling it chiropractic when that term is usually legally defined specifically with reference to humans. In California, for example, the practice of “musculoskeletal manipulation” on animals must meet certain requirements specific in the state veterinary practice act:
     1.  A veterinarian must examine the animal, determine that musculoskeletal manipulation (MSM) is appropriate and safe, and take official responsibility for supervising the treatment.
     2.  Then the owner is supposed to sign a form: “The veterinarian shall obtain as part of the patient’s permanent record, a signed acknowledgment from the owner of the patient or his or her authorized representative that MSM is considered to be an alternative (nonstandard) veterinary therapy.”
     3.  Then a licensed chiropractor can examine the pet, determine that MSM is appropriate, and then consult with the supervising vet before performing treatment.
I know of many chiropractors treating animals in the state, with and without veterinary supervision. I have never seen anyone follow these rules.
The perceived legitimacy of veterinary chiropractic is bolstered by the activities of professional veterinary chiropractic organizations, such as the American Veterinary Chiropractic Association (AVCA). This group offers a certification program which allows either chiropractors or veterinarians to claim to be board-certified in animal chiropractic, despite the technicality that the American Board of Veterinary Specialties, which credentials specialty boards, does not recognize this certification and thus it is essentially a fake board certification.
The International Veterinary Chiropractic Association (IVCA), based in Europe, is largely indistinguishable from the AVCA in terms of the content and general approach to promoting animal chiropractic and certifying chiropractors, including the lack of recognition of their specialty certification by the European Board of Veterinary Specialisation (EBVS).
These groups are not to be confused with the International Association of Veterinary Chiropractitioners (IAVC), a group of veterinarians, chiropractors, and apparently any other kind of “health care provider” who cares to join, who fix subluxations with methods difficult to distinguish from chiropractic but who claim to be practicing an entirely original form of therapy called Veterinary Orthopedic Manipulation (VOM) and who prefer to be referred to by the proprietary term “chiropractitioner.” They do share, however, the lack of any formal recognition as a legitimate specialty that characterizes the work of the AVCA and the IVCA.
And then, of course, there are all the individual chiropractors and veterinarians practicing some form of manual therapy based on chiropractic, often with their own idiosyncratic theories and techniques. For example, Dr. Hall recently drew my attention to a book called “Like Chiropractic for Elephants” by Norman “Rod” Block D.C. Dr. Block claims to have “an uncanny touch sensory perception that allows him to connect with the person or animal he comes in contact with…It is then that the animal senses his intention of wanting to help and releases inhibitions that allow discovery of where the root cause of the pain, stress or pressure may exist…The doctor uses his uncanny ability to tune into the root cause of animal states of disease without the use of drugs or surgery.”
I confess I have not been able to stomach paying to read Dr. Block’s book, but thanks to his press release and a few reviews, I have at least a small sense of what it offers. Apparently Dr. Block supplements his understanding of the vertebral subluxation and his “uncanny” sensory abilities with the practice of “Quantum Shamanetics.” In this method, “The quantum shamanist learns to trust and be guided by universal wisdom that exists beyond our genetic blueprint. By being part to, and observing, movement, one becomes more sensitive to subtle changes in energy. By following these dynamic changes, the shamanist develops a more expansive relationship with the flow of life and health.”
Sadly, this is not a unique case of a chiropractor leaving the at least marginally plausible terrain of treating musculoskeletal disease in animals and venturing further afield. Last year, I had the opportunity to evaluate the recommendations of Dr. Steven Eisen, a chiropractor who calls himself a “Holistic Dog Cancer Expert” and has a book and series of web videos explaining how to thwart the mischief of incompetent veterinarians and treat canine cancer with his dietary advice and a dedicated avoidance of vaccines and parasite control products. And perhaps not surprisingly, Dr. Eisen did not exhibit the scientific spirit of respect for open inquiry and debate when challenged for his claims. Instead, he threatened to sue me.
What Is Animal Chiropractic?
For the most part, the principles and practices of animal chiropractic are extrapolated and adapted from those applied to humans, despite the obvious biomechanical and anatomic differences between bipedal hominids and quadrupedal veterinary patients. As in human chiropractic, the core concept behind chiropractic for animals is the subluxation, or the vertebral subluxation complex (VSC). The AVCA criteria for certification includes familiarity with, “the anatomical, biomechanical and physiological consequences of the Vertebral Subluxation Complex,” and the organization suggests that in addition to pain and musculoskeletal disorders, treatment of the VSC can be beneficial for “bowel, bladder, and internal medicine disorders…glands and body functions.”
Veterinary journal articles about chiropractic often emphasize that the subluxation “is at the core of chiropractic theory, and it’s detection and correction are central to chiropractic practice.”(1) They then include lengthy, very impressive and sciency descriptions of how subluxations arise, cause disease, and can be treated. These are usually marred only by the small problem that no one has actually been able to show a subluxation exists in any species despite over a century of trying.(2)
Chiropractors working on humans cannot reliably agree on the location of a supposed subluxation despite extensive and involved theoretical and practical training supposedly intended to help them do so.(3-4) You can’t see it on x-rays, it doesn’t pinch nerves, and as the evidence for subluxations as physical abnormalities has failed to materialize, true believers in chiropractic have gone through amazing intellectual contortions to redefine it in ways that can make it sound real while still being undetectable. A dragon in the garage if there ever was one.
What’s the Evidence?
There is at least some reasonable evidence that spinal manipulations such as practiced by chiropractors may benefit humans with back pain, though Cochrane reviews of spinal manipulation and general chiropractic therapy for even this indication find small effects and research with a high risk of bias. There is no good reason to believe chiropractic is useful for any other complaint in humans.
Reviewing the literature on the effects of veterinary chiropractic care is quite easy since there is almost none. A search of the PubMed and VetMed Resource databases identified no controlled clinical trials of chiropractic therapy in any veterinary species.
Apart from a few case reports, there are several studies evaluating the putative effect of spinal manipulations on sensitivity to painful stimulus and on spine and limb movement in horses.(5-7) These papers suffer from significant limitations and risk of bias. They generally show a lack of adequate randomization and blinding, objective outcome measures and control groups. They frequently measure numerous variables of questionable clinical significance and then ignore the majority that show no change while identifying the few that do show statistically significant differences as somehow indicative of a meaningful treatment effect. While they represent a reasonable attempt to identify criteria for evaluating the effects of spinal manipulation on horses, they do not constitute evidence of efficacy for chiropractic therapy for any disease.
Of course, there is the usual mountain of testimonials and anecdotes which suggest miraculous curative results with chiropractic therapy in animals. These are both unreliable, for all the usual reasons, and unfortunately the most compelling kind of evidence for animal owners
What’s the Harm?
The risks of chiropractic care in humans fall into the usual categories for harm from alternative therapies; direct harm from the treatment and indirect harm associated with irrational belief systems and avoidance of truly effective care. Of the adverse effects documented in humans, the most significant is that of strokes associated with cervical manipulation.(8) There is no research evaluating the direct risks of veterinary chiropractic, so we can only speculate on the safety of spinal manipulation for animal patients.
The indirect risks of chiropractic therapy come from being exposed to irrational fear of science-based medicine and the use of other unproven or clearly ineffective alternative treatments. Chiropractors treating humans, for example, are often inclined to recommend against vaccination, and it is not uncommon for them to employ therapies far less plausible than chiropractic, such as colon cleansing, homeopathy, and many others.
Chiropractors practicing on animals have also been known to stir up irrational fear of vaccination, claim toxins in pet food are common causes of cancer, and otherwise express disdain for science-based veterinary medicine. And a look at the sponsors for the ACVA annual conference illustrates the frequently close relationship between animal chiropractors and practitioners of other alternative therapies such as Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine, Standard Process Supplements, Reiki and homeopathy, and others. Such synergy between chiropractic and other alternative therapies has the potential to harm veterinary patients even if direct spinal manipulation does not.
Since anecdotes are so commonly employed in defense of veterinary chiropractic, I feel justified in sharing one illustrating its risks. I was once asked to examine a rabbit that had come to my hospital to be treated by a chiropractor, at the advice of another veterinarian. The rabbit had been anesthetized for treatment of dental disease earlier in the day and upon waking was paralyzed in its hind legs. Even a cursory familiarity with rabbit medicine would immediately lead one to consider a fracture or dislocation of a lumbar vertebrae since these can happen when rabbits kick their powerful hind legs uncontrollably, and rabbits are susceptible to disorientation and panic when emerging from anesthesia.
The chiropractor had already examined the rabbit and concluded it had a subluxation in its cervical spine. He recommended giving a chiropractic adjustment to the neck and sending the pet home, with additional adjustments likely necessary in the following days or weeks. When I asked how he reconciled his diagnosis with the symptoms, which fit the classic pattern associated with a spinal cord injury in the lower back, the chiropractor informed me that he was familiar with “allopathic” neurology textbooks but had chosen to ignore them because they were not consistent with his daily experience in practice.
The client permitted me to take an x-ray which confirmed a traumatic lumbar vertebral fracture and severe spinal cord trauma. The patient was humanely euthanized in light of the severe symptoms and poor prognosis. Though this was sad, I consider it a better outcome for the animal than having its neck twisted and being sent home paralyzed and with a fractured spine but without any pain control, as the chiropractor had recommended. Granted, such a story cannot prove anything about the safety or efficacy of animal chiropractic therapy, but it is at least illustrative of some of the risks of substituting a pseudoscientific belief system for science-based medicine.
Bottom Line
Though there is no reliable data, the popularity of chiropractic for treatment of humans appears to translate, to at least some extent, to the treatment of animals. The fundamental theories and practices of animal chiropractic are copied or extrapolated from those employed in treating humans, however there is virtually no reliable scientific evidence to show any benefit from veterinary chiropractic treatment. There is also no controlled evidence identifying the risks of chiropractic therapy of animals, so we can only speculate about the safety of this intervention. It is clear, however, that chiropractic therapy for animals is often associated with opposition to conventional medical care and with other unproven or clearly ineffective alternative therapies, and this presents some risks to patients seeking care from so-called animal chiropractors.
References
     1.  Maler, MM. Overview of veterinary chiropractic and its use in pediatric exotic patients. Vet Clin Exot Anim. 2012;15:299-310
     2.  Miritz TA. Morgan L. Wyatt LH. Greene L. An epidemiological examination of the subluxation construct using Hill’s criteria of causation. Chiropr Osteopat 2009;2:17-13.
     3.  French SD, Green S, Forbes A. Reliability of chiropractic methods commonly used to detect manipulable lesions in patients with chronic low-back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2000 May;23(4):231-8.
     4.  Hestbaek L, Leboeuf-Yde C. Are chiropractic tests for the lumbo-pelvic spine reliable and valid? A systematic critical literature review. J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2000 May;23(4):258-75.
     5.  Haussler, KK. Martin, CE. Hill, AE. Efficacy of spinal manipulation and mobilisation on trunk flexibility and stiffness in horses: a randomised clinical trial. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2010; 48 (Supp. 38):695-702.
     6.  Gomez Alvarez, CB. L’Ami, JJ. Moffatt, D. van Weeren, PR. Effect of chiropractic manipulations on the kinematics of back and limbs in horses with clinically diagnosed back problems. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2008;40(2):153-159.
     7.  Sullivan, KA. Hill, AE. Haussler, KK. The effect of chiropractic, massage and phenylbutazone on spinal mechanical nociceptive thresholds in horses without clinical signs. Equine Veterinary Journal. 2008;40(1):14-20.
     8.  Ernst, E. Adverse effects of spinal manipulation: a systematic review. J R Soc Med July 2007 vol. 100 no. 7 330-338

People Encouraging Turtle Agony*: Animal Acupuncture
Mark Crislip on May 31, 2013
Link
Lest anyone think I am a heartless bastard, I would like it to be known that I do not like to see any creature suffer or die. I am the kind of person who, when finding a spider in the house, is likely to catch it and toss it outside. I always think, “I can’t squish the end result of 6 billion years of evolution”. Except mosquitoes. Those I squish with glee. Infection vectors can die die die die.
I like animals and hate to see them suffer unnecessarily. Like sticking them with needles. Frontal lobes are nice to have. They can let you know that pain is coming and provide preparation and compensation. Once I had a steel bar smack me on the head, opening up a six-inch cut to the bone. No, my brain was not affected, thank you very much. Everything predates the head trauma. When the ER doc numbed the scalp for sutures, he missed the last half-inch and I felt the needle. Knowing what was going on I steeled myself and let him do the last two sutures with no lidocaine, since the needle hurt only a little worse than the lidocaine injection. I have had many other unpleasant medical procedures in my 56 years but knowing what was coming and understanding why makes it easier to tolerate a needle popping into the knee joint or an abdominal drain being pulled.
Animals, and young humans, lack the ability to comprehend the what and why of pain inflicted as part of medicine. Adults can make a conscious decision to be endure pain and fool themselves into thinking it is of benefit. No pain, no gain. Animals can make no such choice.
For example consider sea turtles, who, apparently, are subjected to all sorts of nonsense at the New England Aquarium including acupuncture and laser therapy. As is obvious, I am no veterinarian, the only animal of which I have any understanding of anatomy and physiology is a human, but even with that background it is remarkable what is reported from New England. I used to say the ‘B’ students went into journalism; given the credulous reporting perhaps the standards have been lowered. They certainly have for marine biologists and veterinarians, who are evidently shortchanged in their education.
Several hundred sea turtles were washed ashore in New England after a severe storm. Hypothermic, injured, infected and malnourished, they were transferred to the New England Aquarium for care. It sounds like the animals were quite ill.
Some animals were not getting better rapidly enough with conventional medicine. Conventional medicine: based on known reality. The application of physiology, biochemistry, anatomy, epidemiology, etc to disease that has led to astounding increases in life expectancy and relief from innumerable diseases that plagued humankind.
So they decided to inflict a pair of fantasy based, I mean alternative, therapies on some of the turtles. Alternative: not based on physiology, biochemistry, anatomy, epidemiology, and has never had an impact on any important disease, ever.
At first I read the headline (with the obligatory pun) “Slow pokes: Acupuncture helps hypothermic turtles” as the acupuncture was being used to help hypothermia, which made me laugh. Turtle thermoregulation is complex but just moving them from the cold sea to a warm lab should raise their temperature. But then I realized I misinterpreted the headline. Acupuncture was being used as ineffective therapy for conditions other than hypothermia.
To summarize acupuncture, a topic discussed at length in this blog, its basic principles, those of meridians and chi, are fictional. I tried to find a meridian map of turtles and failed. I found a pig, a cat, a dog, a cow and a horse diagram, but no turtle. Not that it matters, since the meridians are fantasy. The horse, which has no gallbladder, does have a gallbladder meridian, although it conveniently has nothing to do with the gallbladder:
Although the horse does not have a gall bladder organ as such, the meridian is the same as in the human, and it has a lot to do with the integrity of ligaments especially in the hips and pelvis.
Like I said. Fantasy anatomy and physiology.
I note again that on every human and animal acupuncture map there are no meridians or puncture points in the genitalia. Ironically no important life energy runs through the reproductive organs, perhaps explaining why there is no acupuncture-based (or alternative therapy of any kind for that matter) birth control, although a few needles in the genitalia could certainly have a negative effect on reproduction.
Acupuncture does not have any effect on physiological processes outside of those that determine perception. It doesn’t matter where you put the needles, or even if you use needles. Twirled toothpicks have the same effect. Acupuncture only has effects on subjective outcomes and only then if the receiver is a believer and thinks they are receiving acupuncture. I am always amused by those who note sticking a needle into flesh yields a pain response:
The mechanisms underlying pain relief from insertion of needles are unknown, but it has been suggested that it may involve recruitment of the body’s own pain reduction system, possibly attended by an increased release of endorphins, serotonin, norepinephrine, or gamma-aminobutyric acid.
Gee, acupuncture does cause the physiologic effects one would expect from the noxious stimuli of being poked with a needle. Or hitting one’s toe with a hammer.
Acupuncture does not, as the report says,
…reduce stress, increase blood flow and boost the immune system.
Can an animal have a response to a therapy whose entire result is dependent on higher-level cognitive functions that convince the receiver they are improved? The same effect as your mother kissing your injury to make it better? I am, well, skeptical.
In the photographs the turtle looks nonplussed, although they appear to be holding the poor animal so it cannot escape. But then, every turtle in every picture looks nonplussed. Expressive faces are not in the reptilian repertoire. Usually. Not like some dogs who, to my anthropomorphizing eye, do not look happy being stuck with needles.
I am a very ill turtle. Infected, injured, starving. I have been hauled out of my usual environment, taken out of the water, held down on a table by enormous creatures who are sticking me with needles. I would think that the turtle would, in its tiny ‘I don’t want to get eaten’ brain’, be having the turtle equivalent of NONONONONONONONONO I DON’T WANT TO DIE.
But that’s probably just me who thinks perhaps the whole process of worthless needling would only be stressful for the turtle.
The turtle gets combined reality and fantasy based therapies and gets better, the fantasy based therapy gets some of the credit:
Dexter and Fletcher Moon have already had three acupuncture sessions, scheduled once a week, said Merigo, who broke into a broad smile as she described their improvements over the past three weeks.
“These two turtles really had very limited limb use and they weren’t eating. We are seeing improved limb use and improved appetite,” Merigo said. “They are eating on their own, which is fantastic.”
McManus, the acupuncturist, was restrained when describing her reaction to the results.
“It makes me feel very happy,” McManus said. “Acupuncture is not alternative to conventional medicine – they are also receiving Western treatments as well, but the fact that it can work in conjunction with the other treatments they are getting makes me very happy.”
Although the stress of being punctured may have slowed their recovery, it is the usual mistake of crediting effects where there is none.
It was nice that, unlike most acupuncturists, animal and human, the practitioner is using gloves, although everyone appears to wear gloves when handling the turtles.
I am extrapolating from humans and am probably in error when applying what I know to turtles. When humans have severe pneumonia or other severe infectious diseases or trauma, like these turtles, the inflammatory response may be followed by an anti-inflammatory response. A week or two into their hospitalization, a patient may have an increased risk of infection, not only from all the interventions but also because they are at an immune nadir. The greater the initial insult, the greater the subsequent immune dysfunction and risk of infection. Stress is bad.
Take the stress of the initial insult, the infections and malnutrition, being held down and poked with needles and then, with new holes in your hide, being tossed in bacteria-laden salt water. Can’t be good.
Years ago I was sitting in the wards of a hospital in LA when a patient started yelling in pain. The surgeon had ordered sugar for an open wound and the cafeteria had sent up salt by mistake, making the aphorism all too real. I doubt the needles were causing enough damage to the hide to sting when placed back in the salt water, nor to allow the bacteria in the water a chance to find a toe hold (pili hold?) but who can say? Yertle ain’t talking and, like all turtles all the time, looks unfazed.
The preponderance of data suggests that acupuncture effects are almost entirely in the mind of the beholder. The well-designed studies demonstrate that the effects are due almost entirely to bias and are clinically trivial. A placebo effect, the archetype of which was in Penn and Teller’s episode on magnetism. A gutter downspout was bent into the shape of a giant magnet and guess what? The patient had an effect from the fake therapy. That is the basic mechanism of all alternative medicine, including acupuncture.
I went searching the Pubmeds for animal clinical trials of acupuncture and found little, although human trials are animal trials.
Acupuncture being the needling equivalent of faux magnets makes experiments and therapies on animals a little discomforting. There are many animal models for acupuncture and I would wonder if they cross the ethical Rubicon. Is it OK to do studies on animals when the prior plausibility of efficacy is as close to zero as one could want and well-done clinical trials show effects are limited to higher cognitive abilities the animals lack? Is it OK to poke a turtle to induce a marginal placebo effect when it lacks the higher functions to generate such an effect? At some level are not all animal acupuncture studies animal abuse? I wonder.
Animal acupuncture raises other questions: are the rat, dog or turtle meridians the same as humans? If so, why? Genetics? Is the chi same? If so, why? Does a species as evolutionarily removed from humans as a sea turtle have the same response to acupuncture? Does the shell not have any acupuncture sites? If not, why not? It appears from the pictures on the web they only target the soft structures. If human meridians map onto reptiles, are they not missing important sites hidden under the shell, leading to misaligning the energy flow, like only balancing two tires on a car? Of course, asking reality-based questions about acupuncture is like asking about the genetic differences between Orcs, Elves, and Hobbits. It is all fiction.
At some level I can understand trying acupuncture as it has a certain cachet in popular culture, albeit an undeserved one. Most people are not going to wander to the pages of SBM looking for a critical appraisal of acupuncture. But lasers? Really? Laser therapy is nuts, unless you like to get your therapeutic interventions from advertising copy:
When all the results were in it turned out this turtle has a systemic infection. We started treating for the infection but the swelling did not seem to diminish. As we continued the antibiotics we also started using a laser for the edema (swelling) of the joint area.
How does the laser therapy work?I found this at the Companion Therapy Laser website:
The Companion therapy laser system sends photons, or packets of light energy, deep into tissue without damaging it. These photons are absorbed within the mitochondria of the cells and induce a chemical change called “photo-bio-modulation”. This light energy then inspires production of ATP in the cell. ATP is the fuel, or energy, cells need for repair and rejuvenation. Impaired or injured cells do not make this fuel at an optimal rate. Increased ATP production leads to healthier cells, healthier tissue, and healthier animals.
Show of hands. Does this modified photosynthesis make sense to anyone? I guess the biochemistry of turtles resembles plants more than I suspected. And why did it make sense to the veterinarians at the New England Aquarium?
The closest explanation I could find of this bizarro statement was:
ATP production, according to Kremer’s research, is not based on chemical energy release, as taught in universities today, but rests on the absorption of photons of light from the zero-point quantum medium.
Or for those who prefer their gibberish more science-y:
Biochemistry and medical science have failed to this day to explain the function of the adenine groups of ATP as no biochemical reaction with this adenine ring molecule is shown. However, an understanding can be gained, within the framework of the cell symbiosis concept, from the biophysical attributes of light absorption of the adenine group. All essential components of mitochondrial cell respiration are light absorbing molecules with characteristic “frequency windows” of absorption maxima from nearly UV spectrum to the longer wave yellow/orange spectral range of visible light up to ca. 600nm. Yet the source of the electromagnetic energy is not sunlight. In fact a low frequency pulsating electromagnetic field is induced by the constant flow of uncoupled, paramagnetic aligned electrons in the respiratory organelles. The electromotive power generated by this process is catalytically enormously strengthened by the enzyme complexes of the respiratory chain (acceleration factor1017). This effects an interaction between the electrons and the protons likewise aligned parallel to the induced magnetic field dependent on the strength of the magnetic field between the antiparallel aligned electrons and protons. This process produces a quantum dynamic transfer of information via photon exchange energy. The source of photons is ultimately fluctuations of resonance frequencies of the physical vacuum (zero-point energy field). The transferred information is stored in the spin of the protons that proceed to the ATP synthesis complex via proton gradients. There the resonance information is transferred by a unique rotation system to the adenine group of ATP whose electrons can move freely in the alternating double bonds of the ring molecules. The ATP serves as an “antennae molecule” for the reception and relaying of resonance information from the “morphogenetic background field.” Human symbiosis is consequently not a heat power machine but a light frequency modulated information transforming medium. All the time this cell symbiosis is resonance coupled with the lowest not yet materialized energy status (physical vacuum as inexhaustible “global information pool”).
I suspect the laser they used is not producing a zero-point quantum medium. As to why they further stressed the turtle with useless laser therapy, I cannot say. The internet said it would help, I suppose. In the photos the turtle has the same stoic expression that marks the species, but I can’t imagine that from the turtle perspective the process is any less terrifying than a shark coming at them. Three large animals holding it down, preventing flight or fight and flashing them with a worthless laser.
I just hope the laser unit was donated, as they cost $18,900 to $27,900 depending on the model. My fish would be fried if I was a member of the aquarium and saw that they wasted money on a laser therapy.
I am grateful they saved the turtles but I hope I do not come back as a turtle in the next life. Cold, starving, injured and infected, thrown from the sea, held down to prevent escape then poked with needles and flashed with lasers. Beats dying on the beach, but I hope my caregivers have a little more sense and education.
*I know, a stretch, but I so wanted the acronym PETA.

Animal Therapy
Mark Crislip on May 3, 2013
Link
Animal-assisted therapy is a huge topic: almost 1500 hits using those terms alone. There is no way I am going to cover all of them and do them justice. Instead I am going to cherry pick, er, I mean, select references of interest to illustrate issues surrounding animals in the hospital. Sometimes I get the impression that readers of the blog expect encyclopedic knowledge and understanding of a topic whenever we put pixel to screen. That is only true of the other contributors to the blog, not me.
I would like to mention that I do, in fact, like animals, even dogs. I loathe most dog owners, as confirmation bias suggests there is no such thing as a considerate dog owner. But I never have contact with the dogs that don’t bark, that don’t crap on my yard, that don’t run up to me to nip at my legs. I only see the dogs that their owners allow to behave in ways I would never allow a human to behave.
It is no surprise that my kids have grown up mostly animal free. My eldest did wear me down and I bought him a hamster. It promptly bit me, drawing blood. Great, I thought, LCM. Just what I need. Then in the dead of winter it escaped, fell down a heating duct (we were putting in new floor) and electrocuted itself on the heating coils so every time the heat turned on we smelled rotting, roasting hamster. It cost $500 to take the furnace apart and clean it. Good thing it wasn’t a beagle. That was enough pets in the house for me.
Animals have multiple uses in the medicine, from testing new drugs (how I learned rabbits can scream) to various and sundry, well just various, forms of therapy. As was alluded to recently in the comments, take a noun, add the word therapy, and voila, you have a treatment for patients.
Not that animals are useless in patient care but over the years I have noticed that I have noticed more and more animals being brought into the hospital. There is a time and a place for everything and hospitals are not the place for animals.
I first became aware of animal therapy in my hospital years ago when I was seeing a late consult in the ICU and I noted a cat. In the ICU. Sitting on the chest of a fresh open-heart patient. Let’s say I did not react mildly. I discovered we had no policies and procedures for animals in the hospital. That has since changed, although we have more animals in the hospital than I would like, human and otherwise.
A perusal of the literature suggests that for relieving pain petting a dog may be as efficacious as acupuncture and the proponents trot out the same mechanism of action:
Animal-assisted therapy is a complementary medicine intervention, typically utilizing dogs trained to be obedient, calm, and comforting. Several studies have reported significant pain relief after participating in therapy dog visits. Objective reports of reduced pain and pain-related symptoms are supported by studies measuring decreased catecholamines and increased endorphins in humans receiving friendly dog visits.
I am not going to deny that petting a dog is of benefit. Humans are social animals that like to touch and be touched. I have long thought that the placebo effect of SCAM therapies, such as it is, is a gussied up version of apes grooming each other. Ritual attention is good. Except “in deference to a million years of evolution, [the SCAM provider] will not attempt to pick fleas off patients; Earthmen are not proud of their ancestors and never invite them ’round to dinner“. At least I hope so. Nit picking should be reserved for the comments that follow the blog entry.
I have am intrigued by using animals’ sense of smell to help make diagnosis. Most of the time, like using a dog to smell for cancer, I do not see the point outside of proof of concept. It does not seem practical.
However in resource-poor areas, if an animal can be trained to diagnose an infection that could be very helpful. Some poor dog was trained to smell C. difficile diarrhea (there is an animal I feel very sorry for) and they have trained the African pouch rat to smell MTB. That would be a good use for animals as a reusable and reliable diagnostic tool in those parts of the world that cannot afford modern diagnostic technology.
Other diseases? I recently had a patient who had a companion dog for emotional support and as a seizure-dog who warned him when he was going to seize so he could take preventative valium.
There have been dogs trained to watch for the prodrome of seizures, although my patient’s dog received no such training. What little literature I could find suggests that animals who are not trained are not reliable and may be used to reinforce illness that is not there. Like the cat who could predict death, seizure dogs are most likely an excellent example of confirmation bias.
As is usually the case when someone has a service animal for emotional support, they become quite belligerent when it is suggested that the hospital may not be the best place for a dog or other animal. Words like ‘sue’ and ‘Americans with disability’ get thrown around and the animal stays. Yet another reason I am not a fan of dog owners. Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should, but consideration for others is not often high on the list of pet owners.* They do not seem to consider there may be people in the hospital with allergies who cannot simply leave.
Besides dogs and cats, people want to bring all sorts in vermin, er, I mean animals, into the hospital. One of the IC practitioners mentioned that at a prior job they wanted to bring a reptile zoo into a pediatric cancer ward. Good idea, lets bring a Salmonella vector to the most immunoincompetent patients in the hospital.
In Portland they are bringin llamas into hospitals (not mine) and horses (not mine). As some are aware, I am in charge of infection control in my hospitals and I see everything, and I do mean everything, as a potential infection risk. It makes me fun at parties as I can often come up with an infection risk from any human behavior or exposure.
We are all biased by our experience and I am continually impressed with all the weird and unexpected ways people can acquire infections. Murphy was more than an optimist. If something can cause an infection, it will.
There are two infection control issues with animals in the hospital.
First: entertain yourself by watching what people do with their hands. Hands go everywhere and are not always cleaned afterwards. People pet animals but do not clean their hands before, then the next person touches the animal, acquiring whatever organism was on the fur. While I have to foam my hands between each patient, no one ever foams the animal between patients.
While no animal has yet been identified in a hospital outbreak, dogs have been an intermediary for the spread of E. coli urinary tract infections and can be a source for MRSA and fungal infections as well.
Therapy animals have been cultured and they can carry have MRSA and C. difficile. And more:
Visitation of hospitalized people by dogs is becoming commonplace, but little is known about the potential health risks of introducing dogs to healthcare settings. This cross-sectional study evaluated the prevalence of zoonotic agents in a group of 102 visitation dogs from a variety of sources across Ontario. Between May and July 2004, owners were interviewed by a standardized questionnaire while dogs underwent a standardized physical examination. One specimen of faeces, hair-coat brushings and one rectal, aural, nasal, oral and pharyngeal swab were collected from each dog and tested for 18 specific pathogens. All dogs were judged to be in good health. Zoonotic agents were isolated from 80 out of 102 (80%) dogs. The primary pathogen was Clostridium difficile, which was isolated from 58 (58%) faecal specimens. Seventy-one percent (41/58) of these isolates were toxigenic. Extended-spectrum beta-lactamase Escherichia coli was isolated from one (1%) dog, extended-spectrum cephalosporinase E. coli was isolated from three (3%) dogs, and organisms of the genus Salmonella were isolated from three (3%) dogs. Pasteurella multocida or Pasteurella canis was isolated from 29 (29%) oral swabs, and Malassezia pachydermatis was isolated from eight (8%) aural swabs. Giardia antigen was present in the faeces of seven (7%) dogs, while Toxocara canis and Ancylostoma caninum were detected in two (2%) dogs and one (1%) dog, respectively. Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, vancomycin-resistant enterococci, Campylobacter spp., Microsporum canis, group A streptococci, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Cryptosporidium spp. were not detected. Further information is needed before the full implications of these findings for infection control can be assessed properly.
There has yet to be a reported infection transmission or outbreak with a therapy but probably it is because people are not looking. But given the results of the above, do you really want a dog wandering from room to room in your hospital?
With genetic techniques it is becoming increasingly easy to follow the chain of transmission. Anesthesiologists, as an example, can directly be the source for potential pathogens on the hub of central venous catheters. It is only a matter of time before these techniques are applied to animals in the hospital.
Not only can animals be the intermediary for human pathogens, they have their own set of pathogens that can spread to humans: Pasteurella and Capnocytophaga being two. I always bear in mind that animals lick their butt and then they lick you. Ick. If I were to scratch my backside and then offer to shake your hand you would likely refuse but probably think nothing of having a dog lick you.
People do not consider animals as a source of infection, in part because the infections are relatively rare, in part because we do not look for them, and in part because who wants to blame the animal? My favorite healthcare-associated infection, although not hospital acquired, was a patient who let her cat sleep in her dialysis bag warmer and she developed CAPD peritonitis with Pasteurella. And I can go on and on. And on. And on. About all the curious ways in which humans acquire infections from animals
To compound the problem, with the widespread use of veterinary antibiotics, it is of no surprise that pets and animals are a source for antibiotic-resistant bacteria. I have enough trouble controlling infections from humans, much less adding dogs to the mix.
All of medicine is about the risk vs. the benefit of an intervention. I am particularly paranoid about infections in the hospital given how easily they can be spread. But simple interventions can stop the spread of infection. It is why I am pushing for autoclaving any animal before we let it in the hospital.
*At some point someone is going to mention the poor behavior of children as a rationalization for lousy pet behavior. Don’t. It is no different than mentioning that since medicine is flawed SCAM is legit. You should know better.
P.S. The world needs more Mark Crislip: I was interviewed for the Skeptiles podcast. I have not heard the final edit, but I mostly rambled about infectious diseases and vaccines.

What to make of Medical Dogs
Peter Lipson on May 25, 2012
Link
For thousands of years we have guided the evolution of dogs to fulfill our needs for work and companionship. Service dogs are pretty remarkable. I love to watch herd dogs mimicking the dance of predator and prey. When you see a guide dog help someone navigate a building or street, you can’t help but to be impressed by the dogs “devotion” and “skill”.
It seems there is a new canine skill in the news every day. Now, in addition to the traditional roles guiding the blind and deaf, and helping the physically disabled, dogs are claimed to be able to calm autistic children, detect blood pressure changes and seizures, and find cancers. Dogs have been used in the bed bug epidemic to find the critters (with little scientific evidence of success).
Humans and dogs have co-evolved successfully to create strong owner-dog attachments (to the point of pit bull owners defending their dogs rather than acknowledging a dog’s danger to humans). It seems intuitive, and is quite plausible, that dogs can calm us, can help lead us in ways analogous to their roles in nature (if “natural” can even be applied to dogs). It’s easy to see how herding behavior can be adapted into guide dog behavior, or hunting behavior into chemical detection.
What’s less clear is whether any of these roles are based on fact rather than intuition.
What raised my interest this week was a dog featured on ABC News. The show followed a young woman with a “rare heart condition” that goes unnamed. It shows her dog alerting her to an impending fainting spell. The film itself is useless as data—it simply shows the dog nudging the patient and the patient responding by lying down. But even assuming that the family has seen “successful” alerts of fainting, there is no evidence in the literature to suggest dogs can actually do this in any context. It is likely that the dog improves the woman’s sense of security and well-being (something the literature supports in human-service dog relationships) but there is no way to know if the dog is “sensing” changes in blood pressure as claimed.
One of the most interesting medical claims for dogs is an ability to detect cancers in humans, perhaps before conventional testing might. While anecdotes abound, there is scant literature to support this ability. One unimpressive pilot study looked at dogs’ potential ability to detect bladder cancers from urine samples. The idea behind cancer dogs is that there may be volatile compounds produced in cancer patients that dogs can detect by scent. In these studies, the compounds are not identified, not tested for, not named. There are many confounders, for example, in the few samples used, there may be other differences being detected by the dogs.
In the other study (I found very few) dogs were “trained” to detect lung and breast cancers in humans. The methodology of breath sampling is not validated as far as I can see, and once again, the putative compounds in breath are not identified. Statistically, the efficacy is marginal at best.
Another controversial use medical use of dogs is for seizure detection. So-called “seizure alert dogs” are purported to warn their masters of impending seizures, and to stay with them during the event. It doesn’t take a bucket of skepticism to wonder what this actually means. Many seizures are preceded by marked changes in behavior as the patient experiences an aura, something anyone/anydog should be able to notice. Staying by a bonded human isn’t too unusual either. I do wonder how the humans know what the dog does, as many true seizures are accompanied by a period of confusion and memory loss. An objective witness would be needed to note the behavior.
And some case studies have done just that. There aren’t a lot of data, but one patient monitored in a seizure unit experienced nine seizures, one of which was “sensed” by her dog. In another, the dog sensed a “pseudo-seizure”, that is a fit that is not, neurologically-speaking, a seizure but a non-seizure set of behaviors, often precipitated by stress.
That dogs can be trained to help humans is pretty clear—we’ve bred them for this. But these abilities must necessarily have limits, limits set by biology. If a behavior seems implausible, the evidence for it must (from a Bayesian standpoint) be pretty damned solid.
I don’t doubt the social and emotional value of dogs as companions, and as active helpers in many circumstances. But beyond this, the evidence is wanting.
References
Allen K, Shykoff BE, & Izzo JL Jr (2001). Pet ownership, but not ace inhibitor therapy, blunts home blood pressure responses to mental stress. Hypertension, 38 (4), 815-20 PMID: 11641292
Lane, D., McNicholas, J., & Collis, G. (1998). Dogs for the disabled: benefits to recipients and welfare of the dog Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 59 (1-3), 49-60 DOI: 10.1016/S0168-1591(98)00120-8
Willis, C. (2004). Olfactory detection of human bladder cancer by dogs: proof of principle study BMJ, 329 (7468) DOI: 10.1136/bmj.329.7468.712
McCulloch, M. (2006). Diagnostic Accuracy of Canine Scent Detection in Early- and Late-Stage Lung and Breast Cancers Integrative Cancer Therapies, 5 (1), 30-39 DOI: 10.1177/1534735405285096
Dalziel DJ, Uthman BM, Mcgorray SP, & Reep RL (2003). Seizure-alert dogs: a review and preliminary study. Seizure : the journal of the British Epilepsy Association, 12 (2), 115-20 PMID: 12566236
Strong V, Brown S, Huyton M, & Coyle H (2002). Effect of trained Seizure Alert Dogs on frequency of tonic-clonic seizures. Seizure : the journal of the British Epilepsy Association, 11 (6), 402-5 PMID: 12160671
Doherty, M., & Haltiner, A. (2007). Wag the dog: Skepticism on seizure alert canines Neurology, 68 (4), 309-309 DOI: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000252369.82956.a3

Learning from Animals: Evolutionary Medicine with a Twist
Harriet Hall on September 11, 2012
Link
In 2005, cardiologist Barbara Natterson-Horowitz was called to the zoo to examine a non-human patient, an emperor tamarin with heart failure. She was surprised when the veterinarian told her not to look her patient in the eyes because eye contact could cause capture myopathy. In this condition, when an animal is captured, restrained, and feels threatened, there is a catastrophic surge of adrenaline that damages muscle tissues and can kill. It was described decades ago, but medical doctors don’t read the veterinary literature. It wasn’t until the early 2000s that American doctors began to recognize a similar phenomenon in human patients, takotsubo or stress-induced cardiomyopathy.
She began to wonder whether animals got other human diseases. She quickly learned that they did. Jaguars get breast cancer and may carry the same BRCA1 gene that plagues Ashkenazi Jewish women, rhinos get leukemia, penguins get melanoma, gorillas die from ruptured aortas, and koalas are in the midst of an epidemic of sexually transmitted chlamydia. Wild dragonflies infected with parasites become obese and develop a form of metabolic syndrome. Pretty much every human disorder occurs in animals too.
With the help of writer Kathryn Bowers, she distilled her findings into a book: Zoobiquity: What Animals Can Teach Us About Health and the Science of Healing. It’s a good read: informative, well argued, spiced with intriguing trivia, and more entertaining than a trip to the zoo.
If veterinarians and human doctors collaborated on a routine basis, what might they learn from each other? A doctor working on a novel therapy for melanoma asked a veterinarian “Do dogs get melanoma?” He had promising results in a mouse model with induced cancers, but needed to study the treatment in animals with spontaneously occurring tumors, intact immune systems, and a longer life span. Dogs do indeed get melanoma, and in the ensuing collaboration a vaccine was developed that dramatically prolonged their survival rates. Human applications are being investigated.
What about sex? The oldest penis on record belonged to a crustacean that lived 425 millions years ago. Animal studies shed light on human erectile dysfunction and premature ejaculation. Animals routinely engage in homosexual couplings, oral and anal sex, interspecies sex, and masturbation.
Human drug addicts are not alone: animals seek and respond to chemical rewards in the lab and in the wild. Human emotions evolved to influence behavior and fitness. Everything from gambling to compulsive shopping can be viewed in terms of beneficial animal activities like foraging and hunting. SIDS might be related to a response in young animals called “fear” or “alarm” bradycardia. Lessons learned from reducing the weight of obese pets and zoo animals might inform human dieting efforts. Humans engage in self-mutilating behaviors like cutting; self-injury also occurs in animals and probably represents grooming gone awry. Humans develop anorexia nervosa; eating disorders also occur in animals when stress and fear inhibit feeding.
The pathogens from animal diseases can adapt to humans, as in the case of HIV. A sexually transmitted disease in animals can become a human disease where infection is by ingestion, like brucellosis. Pathogens can affect host behavior. Advanced syphilis may promote the spread of spirochetes by compromising judgment and increasing sexual appetites along with egomania, impulsiveness and disinhibition; Al Capone, Napoleon and Idi Amin were syphilitics and the author speculates that their disease may have facilitated their power grabs.
Teenage risk-taking behavior is paralleled in young animals undergoing the transition to adult life. Bullying, gangs, peer oppression, and self-destructive behavior are not limited to humans. Understanding animal behavior could shed light on possible ways to influence human behavior.
An epidemic of dead crows in New York City coincided with the human outbreak of a mosquito-borne disease identified by the CDC as St. Louis encephalitis. An astute veterinarian realized that the bird deaths were not compatible with that diagnosis. He was ignored at first, but eventually the CDC admitted that it was wrong, and the true diagnosis was a virus not previously recognized in the US: West Nile virus. In the wake of this misdiagnosis, agencies are calling for the routine involvement of veterinarians in evaluating public health crises.
Although Carl Zimmer has pointed out some misconceptions about evolution in her book, Dr. Natterson-Horowitz makes a good argument for evolutionary medicine with a twist. Rather than speculating about our ancestors, we can study our living animal relatives for clues about human diseases and behaviors. Rather than speculating about how traits like homosexuality evolved, we can study how they affect survival in animals today.
There is only one medicine and one biology. Terms like “alternative medicine” or “veterinary medicine” create false dichotomies. There is much to be gained from a regular collaboration between people doctors and animal doctors.

Add-on Services for IVF – The Evidence
Steven Novella on November 30, 2016
Link
In vitro fertilization (IVF) is the only option for many couples who want to have their own genetic child. This is an expensive procedure – it can cost up to $20,000 per attempt, with about a 40% success rate overall.
Couples going for IVF are often desperate to have their own child, and the uncertainty of success can be emotionally and financially draining. For this reason they are an especially vulnerable population when it comes to optional services (“add-on services”) that promise to increase the chances of success.
A recent BMJ article reviewed the evidence for 38 IVF add-on services typically offered in the UK: “Lack of evidence for interventions offered in UK fertility centres.” The title gives away the punch line – of the 38 services they reviewed, only one had any compelling published evidence of efficacy, endometrial scratch (causing minor trauma to the uterine wall to enhance the probability of embryo implantation). Even then the evidence was only “moderate.” The authors write:
Our appraisal of the evidence shows only one intervention, endometrial scratching, for which the review evidence robustly supports an increase in live birth rate, yet even this evidence is of only moderate quality, and the observed benefit is only in women with more than two previous embryo transfers.
That could easily be just random noise in the research. If you look at 38 different treatments, what are the odds that at random one of them will have an excess of false positive studies, and only in one subgroup (which is a red flag)?
The authors did not conclude that these treatments do not work, but rather that they are not supported by sufficient evidence to conclude that they do work. In the article they also list representative costs for these procedures, ranging from £50-3,000. A couple choosing a few optional procedures in the hopes of increasing their success could easily spend an addition £5-6,000 for one IVF cycle.
They included some of the costs to make a specific point – couples who are already spending a lot of money for IVF could be wasting even more money on procedures that are not backed by evidence. They also point out that many of the procedures are not risk free.
The procedures themselves are all superficially plausible. They include things like surgical sperm retrieval, intrauterine insemination, sperm DNA testing, and preimplantation genetic screening. I was interested to see that acupuncture was not even included in the list. I am not sure if the authors found it was not commonly offered (which is good, because it does not work) or that it was not necessary to review the evidence.
Standards of evidence
The authors make several observations about the implications of this lack of evidence. They state:
    • Treatments with uncertain effects (benefits and harms) should be licensed for use only in the context of meaningful research.
    • People seeking fertility treatment need good quality evidence to make informed choices.
    • Patients may be desperate, and therefore vulnerable, and we have shown that fertility interventions are offered without supporting evidence to back up claims of effect.
    • Patients are unlikely to have specialist skills in seeking and critically appraising clinical evidence.
I am often struck when reading evidence-based reviews of conventional treatments of the cognitive disconnect between the mainstream context and the “alternative” or CAM context. All of the principles stated above apply to medicine in general. They are generally accepted as valid without controversy.
Patients are indeed often vulnerable. Unless they are specialists themselves, they will lack the education and skills to critically evaluate complex scientific literature. They should not be suckered into expending a great deal of resources on unproven treatments, which should only be offered in the context of appropriate clinical research.
In the CAM world, however, all of these basic and uncontroversial principles are discarded. A different professional and ethical standard applies (it shouldn’t, but it does in practice). In CAM world patients are not afforded proper informed consent. They can be charged for unproven treatments in the name of “Healthcare freedom.” Practitioners can even charge patients to participate in “research.” Patients are never seen as vulnerable, but rather are viewed as their own experts.
CAM practices have largely become “add-on” services offered by hospitals and practitioners. They are added to real medicine that works, to either mitigate side effects or “boost” the immune system, without compelling evidence that they actually do anything. They do nothing but add extra cost to patients and the healthcare system.
Over the last few decades the evidence-based medicine (EBM) movement within medicine has endeavored to strengthen the relationship between evidence and practice, to increase the standards of evidence. At the same time in history there has been a parallel movement to weaken the standards of evidence. Both groups have simultaneously advanced their agenda, mostly compartmentalized from each other.
The CAM movement, in fact, has bastardized the standards of EBM, declaring anything they want to be “evidence-based” without adhering to anything like the actual standards of EBM. There should be profound professional cognitive dissonance over this disconnect between the two movements within medicine.
This is why I think it is important to take every opportunity, when EBM standards are being championed within conventional medicine, to remind everyone that those principles must hold for all of medicine. That is actually all we are advocating at SBM, to have one consistent standard within medicine, and to eliminate the double standard that CAM advocates are trying to create.
Acupuncture and IVF
This gets back to acupuncture and IVF. The authors chose not to include acupuncture in this EBM review despite the fact that it is offered as an add-on treatment for IVF. This suggests they don’t consider acupuncture to fall within the purview of EBM.
There have been systematic reviews of acupuncture for IVF, which is actually much less plausible than the 38 treatments the authors did review. A 2014 systematic review concludes:
Since 1999, in spite of multiple trials and systematic reviews, the beneficial effect of acupuncture in improving the success of IVF remains unproven and debatable.
Some reviews have found possible benefit, and this is widely and uncritically reported. For example, a 2008 review was reported as showing a “65% increase in IVF success.” However, a closer look finds that this evidence is far from compelling.
First, the actual effect shown on the meta-analysis was an increase from a baseline of 27% to 32% – that is a 5% increase. The “65%” is a misleading relative increase.
More importantly, if you look at only those trials in which the baseline IVF success rate is in line with most modern clinics, there was absolutely no benefit to acupuncture. Only the trials in which the baseline success rate was unusually low (like 27%) showed an improvement. This strongly suggests that the improvement might be coming from just having better overall treatment in the clinical trial than the baseline for those clinics.
Also, most of the studies were not blinded at all. This was justified by arguing that pregnancy is an objective outcome, not subjective like pain. While this is true, there are ancillary effects (like relaxation for the patient and attentiveness from the treating physician) that may have made that small difference, especially if the baseline is far lower than most advanced clinics.
Overall the literature on acupuncture an IVF shows what we would expect from a treatment that does not work – no clear efficacy signal. Reviews only tease out barely positive results when they do multiple subgroup analyses, or when restricted to unblinded studies or clinics with a low baseline success.
If the same level of evidence were offered for a mainstream treatment I don’t think the reviewers would be as positive.
But clearly IVF clinics are willing to offer a range of treatments that are not backed by adequate evidence. The current BMJ review reveals this. The question now is how IVF clinics will respond to this article.
There is a tendency for treatment adoption to get ahead of the evidence. Research increasingly shows that if anything we should be more conservative, to raise the threshold where we think evidence is adequate to adopt new treatments.
The current review of IVF add-on treatments is further evidence of this fact.

Tampon: Our Closest Enemy vs. The Vagina Bible
On SBM’s first ever Fight Night, we have the good book for all vagina inquiries, The Vagina Bible, facing off against Tampon: Our Closest Enemy, a conspiracy thriller masquerading as a documentary aiming to inform women of the “hidden dangers” of tampons. Who will win? Find out.
Braden MacBeth on April 3, 2020
Link

There’s a spectrum of bad healthcare documentaries on Amazon from giving outright dangerous advice to just run-of-the-mill fear mongering. A few months ago I watched a documentary in the latter category, Tampon: Our Closest Enemy. Tampon: Our Closest Enemy is a French documentary produced by Audrey Gloaguen and it released in 2017. While I’ve been wanting to review it for a while now, researching would’ve taken a lot of time. I have significant knowledge deficits in the realm of vaginas and tampons for obvious reasons. That was until Dr. Jen Gunter released her book The Vagina Bible, which is a comprehensive guide on everything vulvar and vaginal. I couldn’t write a standalone review on it because there’s nothing to really say about it: it’s well-written, authoritative, comprehensive, and inexpensive. Dr. Gunter debunks many of the same myths about toxic shock syndrome and tampons that are perpetuated in Tampon: Our Closest Enemy. After reading the relevant sections in The Vagina Bible, the lines between myth and medicine were markedly less blurred when re-watching Tampon: Our Closest Enemy, so I figured why not use one to review the other?
Toxic Shock Syndrome and Rely
The first half of Tampon: Our Closest Enemy is dedicated to menstrual toxic shock syndrome (mTSS), an incredibly rare, life-threatening condition caused by the immune system’s reaction to a toxin in the blood stream. There are two basic categories of toxic shock syndrome by cause, menstrual and non-menstrual. The incidence of TSS overall is estimated to be between 0.8 to 3.4 cases per 100,000 people per year. According to the CDC the annual average incidence of menstrual toxic shock syndrome (mTSS) varied between 0.03-0.05 for every 100,000 people. Other papers have reported numbers as high as 0.52 cases per 100,000 people per year, it really depends on what year the study was conducted and how the data was collected. The bottom line is that TSS and mTSS are incredibly rare to begin with. So what’s the deal with mTSS?
There are lots of different types of bacteria living on and in your body. Most of which don’t cause any trouble… until they do. The main cause of mTSS is a type of bacteria is called Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), and only some women carry S. aureus vaginally. Just as we all have different genes, strains of bacteria carry different genes. Only specific strains of S. aureus can produce the toxins that cause mTSS. The specific toxin is TSST-1 is a protein that is a superantigen. A superantigen over-activates your immune system and triggers what can only be described as a full-on meltdown. In the case of mTSS this over activation causes high-fever, dangerously low blood pressure, muscle pain, kidney failure, coma, and death.
The film tries to portray the case of the Rely tampon TSS-outbreak as the rule and not the exception. Back in the 1975, Proctor and Gamble brought the Rely tampon to market, a first-of-it’s kind super absorbent tampon. Rely was a bit different in it’s composition, it used methylcarboxycellulose, which is often used to thicken food products, in a polyester casing. The problem with Rely’s composition is that it provides the perfect place for S. aureus to grow and cause mTSS, which is laid out in detail in Yale Biology. When fluids were absorbed by the Rely Tampon, the methylcarboxycellulose gelled and the foam cubes offered increased surface area for S. aureus to grow. During menstruation, the pH of the vagina is elevated to around 7.4 which made the Rely tampon the perfect environment for S. aureus to reproduce. Then finally, if that wasn’t enough, the toxins that cause mTSS also cause fever, and the increased body temperature makes S. aureus grow even faster to release even more toxins. When you consider all of that, it’s becomes hard to dream up a more worst-case scenario when considering mTSS risk.
The Rely tampon at the time was and still is the worst-case scenario when talking about the mTSS risk, and is brought up pretty much every time menstrual toxic shock syndrome is discussed. After a drastic increase in mTSS cases, medical societies began to investigate. Two studies by the CDC were conducted and the second one found that the women who used the Rely tampon had nearly 8 times the risk of developing mTSS. This lead to a lot of deaths, and many people sued Proctor and Gamble successfully, which Tampon: Our Closest Enemy talks about for quite a while. Rely was ultimately removed from the market in 1980.
The problem with Tampon: Our Closest Enemy is that it leaves women with more questions than answers. Dr. Gunter leaves women with practical advice about how to lower their TSS risk:
    • Use the lowest absorbency.
    • Don’t assume all-cotton tampons are safer. Some studies suggest a rayon blend may be safer.
    • Be mindful of trauma with insertion and removal. Using a less-absorbent tampon on lighter days may help.
    • The recommendation to change a tampon every eight hours is not based in hard science but seems to be the best expert advice for now.
Ultimately, the risk of mTSS is very low even in the worst case scenario but Tampon: Our Closest Enemy makes it seem like a hidden pandemic. It’s important to note that menstrual cups also carry a risk of mTSS, and mTSS can also just happen. The film makes a big deal out of questioning why the tampon industry doesn’t disclose the risk of mTSS with the use of their products and why more research isn’t done to assess the safety of tampons with regards to mTSS risk. But companies do have information on their sites about the TSS risk of tampons and the ingredients that they use. The problem is that the risk of mTSS is 1 in 100,000 women, so low that it’s incredibly difficult to assess the efficacy of any change made to products to prevent it. While it’s something that women should be aware of, it’s like warning them about the risks of a shark attack.
Toxins in tampons? Not quite
The second half of Tampon: Our Closest Enemy talks about toxins in tampons and how manufacturers are “hiding” the composition of tampons. The film mostly focuses on dioxins and dioxin-like compounds. Dioxins are highly toxic compounds that are usually the byproduct of manufacturing processes, but dioxin-like compounds also include things such as PCBs. Dioxins have been found to be carcinogenic and can damage the immune and nervous systems. The film states that a state Secretary imposed tests on various brands of tampons in 2016 and found that there were synthetic fibers and dioxins in the tampons. I’m unsure why the detection of synthetic fibers was presented as a “gotcha!” moment. Many tampons are made of synthetic fibers, so it’s like finding out that your computer has processor in it. After the results of the tests they passed the data onto the European Environmental Agency to investigate further and take any necessary action. The film presents it as a slam dunk that there’s dangerous toxins in tampons:
Very low levels. Potentially take any necessary action. When such measured language is used, it would easy to forget that dioxins are one of the worlds most dangerous chemicals according to the World Health Organization.
Dioxins are listed under the WHO’s chemicals of major public health concern. However, as Dr. Gunter explains in The Vagina Bible, the level of dioxins is so low it’s a joke. In a 2002 study published in Environmental Health Perspectives, researchers analyzed the level of dioxins in a variety of tampon brands. While they found detectable levels of dioxins in all of the tampons, there was no detectable amount of the most potent dioxin: 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. They also determined that the level of dioxins present in the tampons was between 30,000 and 200,000 times lower than what’s found in food.
Surely Gloaguen has come across that study right? It is the second result when you search “dioxins in tampons” on google. Anyway, Gloaguen went all the way to the US to the town of Perry, Florida to talk to someone who used to work for Georgia Pacific, a cellulose product manufacturer. The woman Gloaguen interviewed showed a copy of an MSDS for one of the chemicals Georgia Pacific uses to bleach wood pulp. It turns out that Georgia Pacific really uses chlorine dioxide to bleach paper products. The part that’s so strange about Tampon: Our Closest Enemy is that almost everything is presented as if it’s some sort of secret and that the tampon industry is trying to hide. What was shown on screen was presumably one of the many MSDS’ that are freely accessible to any employee; any employee working in a factory can walk to their safety supervisor and figure out where to get this information. Employers are required by law to provide their employees with the types of chemicals they use and the risks of those chemicals. It’s far from a secret either that companies use chlorine dioxide to bleach paper products, chlorine dioxide bleaching has its own section in the “Bleaching of wood pulps” Wikipedia page.
While chlorine dioxide is a very, very nasty chemical, the process of chlorine dioxide bleaching is safe and there have been very few accidents. Everything in manufacturing sounds super scary, and that’s because everything in manufacturing kind of is. That’s why they have safety meetings every month, that’s why they have all of those safety procedures. Besides, the dangerous chemicals and machinery aren’t even the scariest part of working in manufacturing, you never known when your boss is going to ask you to work with Rockwell’s software. The bottom-line is that while there may be trace amounts of dioxins in tampons, it’s not anything to worry about and many companies have moved to a chlorine-free bleaching process anyways.
Big tampon conspiracy? This is fear mongering
Tampon: Our Closest Enemy gets into absurd conspiracy theory territory very quickly starting about halfway through. Gloaguen makes it seem like big-tampon is trying to hide the secret dangers of their products, when in reality the levels of dioxins in tampons are of no risk to women’s health, and the risk of TSS is very, very small. Midway into the film, Gloaguen drops this bombshell:
In order to operate with impunity, the industry had to silence politicians and female consumers. To dissuade anyone from trying to find out more about their products, the industry had an ultimate strategic weapon: the taboo surrounding menstruation.
The problem is that the tampon industry doesn’t have anything to hide really. While they aren’t required by law to post the ingredients in tampons, many have them on the box or on their website. They’re generally made up of rayon or cotton in the core with a polypropylene string and polyester thread. As for trace amounts of stuff like dioxins, phthalates, and pesticides; companies are required to prove to the FDA that their products have pesticide and contaminant levels that are safe for human use before they can go to market. There is no conspiracy by the tampon industry to silence women or politicians, especially using social engineering on a grand scale. No matter how ridiculous it may seem, Tampon: Our Closest Enemy tries to make it seem that way:
So we often see happy women, wearing white, very active. We never see blood. We see blue liquid. If we see the product, it is always pre-use, never post use. Behind this veil of purity, the industry operates as it wishes.
This ignores the entire regulatory environment surrounding menstruation products. These statements all seem reasonable the way they’re presented in the film. But when you actually evaluate them on their merit, they don’t make much sense. Of course tampon companies are going to show the pre-use presentation of a tampon, do you really want to see a post-use tampon in a commercial? It would be quite…unaesthetic. Tampon companies are going to show women wearing white, and because that makes them seem clean. It’s just marketing, and it’s not any different than how any other industry markets their products. To portray the marketing as part of a grand conspiracy is just ridiculous, senseless fear-mongering.
Conclusion: Effort inequality
The dichotomy between The Vagina Bible and Tampon: Our Closest Enemy perfectly illustrates the problem of trying to communicate science, particularly medicine. Getting science communication right is hard and doesn’t pay very well. It really seems like Gloaguen was more focused on getting 45 minutes’ worth of content fit for television than presenting the facts. The risk of developing mTSS is so low it’s hard to definitively answer what women can do to reduce their risk or how to assess a new tampon for mTSS risk before it goes to market. Furthermore, tampons don’t contain any level of “toxins” worth considering and their composition is displayed on the box most of the time. It’s a lot easier and more profitable to take the science out of context, blow things out of proportion, or make stuff up.
If you search toxic tampons on the internet, you will find dozens of articles telling women to be wary of toxic tampons. The very first search result that I got when searching “toxic tampons”, was an article on Goop suggesting that tampons were toxic and you should buy organic tampons. By pure coincidence, Goop also sells organic tampons. While Gloaguen doesn’t try to sell women on organic tampons or other products, she doesn’t leave women with anything to go on. So the only thing the film accomplishes is attempting to scare women over nothing, and potentially push them to seek out products that are more expensive, and potentially less effective for no reason. Also, it’s important to remember that scaring people over nothing is still a harm in itself. I don’t think it’s healthy for people to be constantly afraid, as if everything in the world is out to kill them all the time.
It’s a lot harder to break down nonsense health claims on the internet than it is to make nonsense health claims on the internet. The barrier to entry is non-existent, and you can create your own website or video channel in a few minutes. There’s no peer review and you can say whatever you want, scientific accuracy is not required. You might hear a claim that sounds like complete nonsense, and there might be some evidence to back it. But you might not know how important that evidence is, or its quality. That’s why I like The Vagina Bible so much, it’s a single comprehensive source on a topic from an expert. Dr. Gunter breaks down a lot of research on really complicated topics and explains them in a way that’s easy to understand.
Tampon: Our Closest Enemy is a just another in a long-line of documentaries that are meant to make for 45 minutes of compelling television rather than informing viewers. The reality is that tampons are safe, and they are safety tested. While bad things have happened in the past such as the Rely tampon, it’s important to remember that the risk of developing mTSS was still very low. Safeguards have been put in place since then. There’s no great hidden risk to tampons being covered up by Big Tampon™, anyone that tells you otherwise is trying to sell you something. As for The Vagina Bible, it’s exactly what it claims to be. If that’s not high enough praise, I don’t what is.

SmartJane Test of Vaginal Health: Clever Marketing, Questionable Science
uBiome claims that its SmartJane test’s proprietary technology empowers customers to assess their own vaginal health. The company is being investigated for fraudulent billing practices, and the rationale for the test makes no sense.
Harriet Hall on May 14, 2019
Link


The uBiome company’s SmartJane test claims to use state-of-the-art DNA sequencing technology, machine learning, artificial intelligence, statistical genetics, algorithms, and other proprietary innovations so women can assess their own vaginal health. Customers collect samples with vaginal swabs and mail them in for processing. They get a report of findings for 55 components of the vaginal microbiome: 14 high risk Human Papillomavirus (HPV) strains that can lead to cancer, 5 low-risk HPV strains associated with genital warts, 4 pathogens that cause sexually transmitted infections (chlamydia, gonorrhea, syphilis, and Mycoplasma genitalium) and 32 bacteria that they consider to be clinically important.
I was only able to locate one study of SmartJane, published on PLOS One on May 1, 2019. It did not demonstrate any clinical benefits. Normal reference ranges for its test results were determined by testing a group of 50 self-reported healthy women (hardly a reliable validation!) It concluded:
…we here present a vaginal health assay that for the first time combines the detection of the most important bacterial and viral indicators of vaginal health and disease. We envision that this test has the potential to provide clinicians and patients with a more comprehensive understanding of the vaginal microbiome, and to encourage women to take an active role in related conversations with their doctors. We also hope that by improving accessibility through self-sampling, we may encourage more women to engage with current screening and treatment guidelines for vaginal pathogens and cervical cancer.
That’s speculation and wishful thinking, not meaningful scientific evidence.
Critics speak out
An article in Forbes says “Research on the vaginal microbiome is still at an early stage and doctors say there’s no use for the data in treating patients right now.” They quote Dr. Jennifer Gunter “I can see no value in knowing the 32 (or however many) types of vaginal bacteria. None at all outside of a research setting; I see that leading to unnecessary worry”. They quote Jeanne Marrazzo, who says “We don’t really have any interventions to change what they are potentially going to find.” The company’s website mentions the possibility of dietary changes, pre-biotics, probiotics, etc. but there is no evidence that any of these interventions are effective in improving patients’ health. Elsewhere, Dr. Jennifer Gunter is quoted as saying, “We have no idea what the data means. We know the vaginal microbiome changes throughout the day as well as day to day, and so this snapshot tells you nothing…To suggest otherwise is disingenuous on the part of the company.”
Misconduct
CNBC reported that the company used aggressive marketing tactics, encouraged repeat testing, and billed patients for multiple tests without the patient’s knowledge or consent. A doctor’s order is required for testing, but they hired doctors and paid them up to $180 per hour to approve requests, encouraging them to quickly approve every request. They “upgraded” samples without permission and billed insurance companies and Medicare two or three times for the same set of tests. They billed for tests that were never done. Following numerous customer complaints, the FBI raided the company’s San Francisco offices in April 2019 and seized computers and files. The company’s CEOs and founders were placed on administrative leave. The uBiome Board is cooperating and plans its own independent investigation of billing practices. After the raid, uBiome halted sales of the SmartJane test. They stress that this is only a temporary suspension.
The uBiome company was founded in 2012 by a computer scientist and a biophysicist. They started with crowdfunding and eventually attracted more than $100 million in venture funding. Last September the company was valued at $300 million. Comparisons with Theranos are inevitable. Both had founders who were not experts in the field, venture capital funding and rapid growth, unethical practices leading to downfall, and a rationale that simply didn’t make sense.
Privacy concerns
Patients who sent vaginal swabs to uBiome are worried. One customer wondered if the collected data might be leaked or sold. She had filled out a questionnaire about her lifestyle, sex life, menstrual cycle and the birth control methods she had used. She had relied on the company to protect her privacy, but now the FBI had the data.
What’s the point?
Their website says “NOTE: The test is not intended to replace traditional Pap smears or well-woman visits and does not diagnose or treat any disease.” If it can’t diagnose any disease, why does it test for them? What does a positive SmartJane test for syphilis or gonorrhea mean?
Since an appointment with a doctor is still necessary, why bother with a SmartJane test? A doctor can detect and treat cancer, infections, and sexually transmitted diseases, and can test for other conditions not addressed by SmartJane, such as HIV/AIDS and herpes. Is there any value in knowing that you are infected with a specific strain of human papillomavirus (HPV)? The majority of these infections will resolve over time and will never cause any problems. A minority will lead to cancer, but we have an effective vaccine to prevent those cancers. It makes much more sense to get the vaccine than to test for HPV infection.
Vaginal screening tests not indicated
The fact that we can do a screening test doesn’t mean that we should. The US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) has carefully thought-out guidelines for screening tests, and the tests in SmartJane are not recommended. Screening for something that has a low prevalence in the population typically produces more false positive results than true positives, leading to worry and unnecessary invasive testing. Early detection of an abnormality is useless in the absence of an intervention that can change the outcome. The multiple tests offered by Theranos and uBiome amounted to poorly conceived fishing expeditions that were more likely to mislead than to benefit customers.
The care and feeding of the vagina
Sex sells. Ads for penis enlargement led the way, and vaginal quackery soon followed. I wrote an article about it for Skeptical Inquirer titled “The Care and Feeding of the Vagina“. Gwyneth Paltrow advocates steaming the vagina and inserting jade eggs. There is douching, Holy Yoni Oil, yogurt- and vodka-soaked tampons, herbal detox pearls, Japanese vagina-tightening sticks, ground-up oaks galls (formed by wasp larvae), anion strips, peat tampons, orgasm shots, and even vaginal rejuvenation surgery. And then there are the foreign body stories like “dead cricket in uterus.” News flash: the vagina is self-cleaning and requires no special care or feeding. Especially not crickets!
Conclusion: good marketing but not good science
The appeal of SmartJane to customers is obvious. What woman wouldn’t want to “meet her vagina” and know what microorganisms are living there? People love to get detailed personal information, whether it’s true or not; that’s why they read horoscopes and visit fortunetellers. Microbiome research is new and sexy. It has great promise, but it just isn’t ready for prime time yet. The claims of this company can be disregarded unless they can provide evidence from controlled studies showing that using the SmartJane test objectively improves clinical outcomes. Not just a change in some lab test, but actual POEMS (patient-oriented evidence that matters). I’m not holding my breath.

Placenta Eye Drops
If you thought eating the placenta was odd, what about putting it in your eye?
Scott Gavura on November 12, 2020
Link

A recent Health Canada advisory identified a previously unknown (to me) form of what looks like pseudoscience, as reported by CBC:
Regener-Eyes Ophthalmic Solution was being imported and sold by the Calgary Trail Vision Centre in south Edmonton. But this past Monday, Health Canada announced it was recalling this unauthorized product, because it claims to contain placenta materials. Health Canada is advising people not to use this eye drop, because it could pose a health risk due to potentially containing human placenta. Health products containing human placenta meet the definition of a drug under the Food and Drugs Act, as previously communicated in 2018 with the Placenta Pills Information Update. The Calgary Trail Vision Centre was directed to immediately stop importing and selling these eye drops.
If you’re like me, your first question was probably “Why?”Digging into the story behind the story reveals some interesting science with stem cells, that not surprisingly, has been extrapolated into a dubious product that’s sold with a lot of claims but not much evidence to support it.
What is Regener-Eyes?
There isn’t much information about the exact formulation of Regener-Eyes on the manufacturer’s website. There is no indication that the product is FDA-approved, but it also lacks the Quack Miranda warning that you would see for supplements. This website claims that because Regener-Eyes is a “biological” that it doesn’t need FDA approval. Those who are more familiar with US regulations can let me know their thoughts in the comments, but I find it difficult to believe that a ophthalmic product that claims to contain various biologic growth factors escapes all federal regulation. It is claimed to be based, yes, on placenta-derived materials:
It is a bioengineered protein-based fluid, extracted from human placental-derived biomaterials. It is obtained from healthy, living donors with informed consent and full screening following, and exceeding, all FDA and AATB guidelines, collected via an AATB certified 501c3. All materials are from healthy pregnancies at the time of a scheduled C-sections; no ethical concerns.
They claim:
Regener-Eyes® contains naturally occurring anti-inflammatory cytokines, growth factors, and chemokines such as VEGF, TGFβ1, TGFβ3, EGF, HC-HA/PTX-C.PTX-3 (Pentraxin 3), IL-1Ra , PDGF, ST2, bFGF, KGF, Collagen Types I, III, IV, V and GDF11.
Apparently these growth factors are not drugs, which would probably surprise the pharmaceutical manufacturers that sell prescription growth factors. There are no specific indications noted, as you might expect for a drug. The manufacturer seems to imply it can be used for dry eyes, but also circumstances where there is irritation or inflammation. There are testimonials, but I couldn’t identify any published clinical trials in PubMed to substantiate any of the claims on the website. There is nothing resembling a placebo-controlled or head-to-head trial available, where the obvious comparison would be to plain lubricating eye drops. It should not be seen as a vote of confidence when a manufacturer of a medicinal product suggests you consult their Facebook reviews.
Not surprisingly, Health Canada blocked the sale of this product because of the web site statement that it is derived from human placenta.
Why the placenta?
Using placental-derived tissues isn’t completely implausible, but they are not a home run. The American Academy of Ophthalmology describes the use of amniotic membrane, a layer of the placental sac harvested after live Caesarean birth, to help heal eye injuries. The theory is that the amniotic membrane contains growth factors, and when the epithelium (the outer layer) is damaged, the growth factors (or some other component of the membrane) can promote healing. Prokera, a commercially-marketed product (and approved by regulators) fastens amniotic membrane to a polycarbonate ring (sort of like a contact lens) that can be used for moderate to severe dry eye where the cornea is injured. It uses tissue from an FDA-inspected tissue bank. While the hype may outpace the science, and results from randomized controlled trials are not impressive, there appears to be continued interest in its application. Notably, I could find no mention of placenta-derived drops to treat ophthalmic conditions – the research interest seems to be in the amniotic membrane.
Don’t put that placenta in your eye
Placenta-based eye drops that have been recalled by Health Canada are available via prescription in the United States, but appear to be sold in an unregulated state. Whether or not they provide any medicinal benefits hasn’t been shown in published randomized controlled trials. Their production and use is likely a consequence of broader interest in placental-derived products, and in particular, the ophthalmic use of amniotic membranes for serious eye injuries. Until some robust evidence emerges to show that placental-based eye drops are both safe and effective, it would seem to be a better strategy to rely on ophthalmic experts to guide the management of ocular injuries and disorders.

Lotus Birth To Blame for Death of Australian Newborn
Lotus Birth, an “ethically inadmissible” practice where a newborn is left attached to the placenta for several days, is risky, benefit free, and is likely to blame for the death of an Australian infant in 2017.
Clay Jones on June 26, 2020
Link

I last discussed the dangerous practice of Lotus Birth back in 2018. In the roughly 18 months since then, no evidence has emerged to change my final conclusion that there is zero benefit and plenty of risk. Unfortunately, more evidence for the potential serious harm inherent in the practice did come to my attention earlier this month. The tragic case of Harlow Eden is one of the more heart wrenching and infuriating that I’ve encountered in my nearly two decades of interest in pseudoscience in medicine.
A quick primer on Lotus Birth
Lotus Birth occurs when both the baby and the placenta are delivered without severance of the umbilical cord, which is typically delayed 30 to 60 seconds but must be done right away when a newborn needs urgent evaluation and possible resuscitation. In most Lotus Births, the placenta is left attached to the baby for at several days and is kept in a special salt and herb-filled sack or bucket until the dried umbilical cord separates naturally from the baby.
In her still prominent (top ten when searching “Lotus Birth” on Google) and recently updated post on Lotus Birth, Genevieve “Mama Natural” Howland attempts to present a balanced discussion of the practice, likely pulling in people on the fence, but fails miserably:
Lotus birth is about keeping the umbilical cord and placenta with the baby while he or she gently transitions to life outside the womb. It is a quiet and respectful transfer of attachment, without the trauma of being cut from the mother.
This implies that cutting the umbilical cord after 30-60 seconds, which has solid evidence of benefit compared to immediate severance when a newborn is stable, is somehow…disrespectful and traumatic. This is absurd. I put the full weight of my 2 decades of medical experience behind the fact that babies don’t care when the cord is cut. And it is a painless procedure, as there are no nerves in the cord.
Howland further reveals her bias by implying that Lotus Birth is based in some kind of ancient wisdom:
The name comes from the lotus flower, a flower important to Eastern cultures for its symbolism of unity, detachment, and rebirth. Lotus births speckle the history of childbirth in cultures around the globe, in places like Bali and Southern Africa. Historical traces of lotus births appear in Europe as early as the Middle Ages. And records of not cutting the umbilical cord appear on the American continent as early as the pioneer days. In Western nations, lotus birth seems to be a new birth trend steeped in early tradition.
She links to a 2012 article that discusses the timing of cord severance from a historical perspective but which doesn’t at all touch on Lotus Birth. Since 2012, we have learned a lot about the potential benefits of delaying clamping of the umbilical cord and it has become a science-based practice. But again, Lotus Birth is not remotely the same thing as delayed cord clamping.
So what are the proposed benefits? Besides claiming that for many it is a “spiritual practice that honors the birthing process and the sacred relationship baby has with the umbilical cord and placenta”, Howland lists five potential positive outcomes associated with Lotus Birth:
     1.  “More blood”: This is delayed cord clamping. Yes, there is benefit to the baby getting a little more blood from the placenta in a safe and controlled manner. Again, that’s not what makes a Lotus Birth a Lotus Birth. Delayed cord clamping for 30-60 seconds is very safe, although there is a small increase in the risk of jaundice. If done improperly, babies can get too much blood from the placenta, which puts them at risk of hyperviscosity syndrome and subsequent stroke, seizures, organ damage, and death. Thankfully that is pretty rare though.
     2.  “No open wound means less infection risk”: No. And I mean a hard no. In fact, Infection risk is increased by Lotus Birth and the practices that tend to be clustered with it, such as refusing vaccines and vaginal seeding.
     3.  “Faster healing of the umbilicus”: Nope. Not a thing.
     4.  “Emotional wellbeing”: No studies exist looking into whether or not newborns who experience Lotus Birth have improved psychological outcomes. Frankly, there is zero plausibility that they would experience a specific benefit after teasing out all the confounding variables. In my opinion, this is just another way for natural birth advocates and new age believers to pressure mothers and make them feel like they are doing it wrong.
     5.  “Postpartum healing”: She claims that Lotus Birth forces a mother to take it easy, thus improving healing, which is quite a stretch.
Now on to Howland’s discussion of the risks in her “balanced” post. To her credit, she mentions that most medical organizations do not support Lotus Birth. This is misleading, however, because exactly zero legitimate medical organizations support it. She does point out that the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynecology says Lotus Birth is an infection risk because, and I’m paraphrasing a bit, attaching a baby to a rotting sack of blood for several days might not be a good idea.
Howland mentions infection as a risk, but not that this infection can kill the baby. She also implies that it can be prevented if the placenta is properly cared for but she can’t possibly know this. Nobody knows this because it isn’t standardized and has never been studied. And infections have occurred despite “proper care”. As I’ll soon discuss, death has even occurred. The only other “drawbacks” she mentions are that mothers choosing Lotus Birth can’t eat the placenta or travel easily with the baby.
Check out this excellent discussion of Lotus Birth by Joshua Krisch as a counter to Howland’s egregious post. This paragraph in particular stood out:
Of course, not all parents have even a passing understanding of microbiology and those that swear by the practice speak of it in less medical terms, claiming to feel a spiritual attachment to what is essentially decaying, diseased tissue. But emotional urge to retain this piece of pregnancy shouldn’t be conflated with an evolutionary instinct. Nor should it be argued that cutting the umbilical cord too soon is bad for your baby.
The tragic case of Harlow Eden
We now come to the hear-wrenching story of Harlow Eden.
Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
In 2017, Harlow was born via an emergency C-Section in a Melbourne hospital. She was a “miracle baby” born after 13 years and more than a dozen IVF attempts. This, and exposure to all manner of pseudoscientific medical misinformation, likely led Harlow’s parents to choose a Lotus Birth. Their stated goal was to ease Harlow’s transitioning and to boost her immune system.
As is often the case, because parents unfortunately tend to cluster these types of poor medical decisions, Harlow’s parents also chose to refuse science-based recommendations for intramuscular vitamin K and the Hepatitis B vaccine. They also practiced vaginal seeding, another risk factor for serious infection. And, sadly, they also refused initial attempts by hospital staff to move Harlow to a special care nursery for closer observation.
By 16 hours of age, Harlow had developed hypoglycemia, which can occur in any baby but is more likely to occur when they are sick. At that point, the umbilical cord was cut and she was transferred to the special care nursery. She soon developed signs of sepsis, with respiratory distress and poor perfusion, so antibiotics were initiated. Despite this, she died the following day after having been transferred to a tertiary care center. The coroner determined that Harlow died from sepsis in the setting of a Lotus Birth.
Medico-legal considerations on Lotus Birth
In refreshing my fund of knowledge on Lotus Birth, I came across an interesting discussion of the medico-legal considerations on Lotus Birth in the Italian Journal of Pediatrics which was free and in English. It isn’t too long but goes into significantly greater detail than I do, particularly on the pathophysiology of the placenta, so it’s worth a read if you are curious about that kind of thing. But it is the ethical considerations that I was most interested in.
In the paper, the authors point out the connection between Lotus Birth and natural birth that I made earlier in this post. They describe how in this community, the act of cutting the cord can be viewed as a violent act. More importantly, a woman choosing Lotus Birth may be attempting to “exercise her right to individual choice and self-governance”. But, they point out, autonomy requires adequate information and awareness of the implications of a choice, which we know can be lacking in the world of medical pseudoscience.
        ◦ In the case of Lotus Birth, the ethical principle of autonomy faces off with the ethical principles of non-maleficence and beneficence. The baby has to be considered to be a vulnerable person that must be protected. Taking into account what is known of the risks and benefits of Lotus Birth, the authors conclude that it is “ethically inadmissible”. This conclusion naturally seems like common sense, but it was still nice to see a thorough discussion by experts in the field of bioethics.

FDA Warns About Miracle Mineral Solution
Jim Humble is still selling his industrial bleach as a fake cure, and the FDA gives another toothless warning.
Steven Novella on August 14, 2019
Link


You wouldn’t think that the FDA would have to warn the public against drinking industrial strength bleach, but that is the world we are living in. They write:
Miracle Mineral Solution has not been approved by the FDA for any use, but these products continue to be promoted on social media as a remedy for treating autism, cancer, HIV/AIDS, hepatitis and flu, among other conditions. However, the solution, when mixed, develops into a dangerous bleach which has caused serious and potentially life-threatening side effects.
They also warn:
The FDA recently received new reports of people experiencing severe vomiting, severe diarrhea, life-threatening low blood pressure caused by dehydration and acute liver failure after drinking these products.
This is not the first such warning from the FDA. The first one was in 2010. The warning is essentially the same as the 2019 version, and it is amazing that almost a decade later this blatant and dangerous snake oil is still around. David has been following the story on SBM for years, most recently in April of this year.
So how do we explain the persistence of not just useless snake oil, but seriously harmful snake oil? There is a clue, I think, in the origins of MMS – Jim Humble and his Genesis II Church of Health and Healing. This is an excellent example of the mixing of religion with alternative medicine. I and others here have long argued that this is a prominent feature of CAM, often overlooked by those not sufficiently familiar with it as a phenomenon. CAM, in fact, is far closer to religion than it is to science, although there is a lot of variability as it is a broad and eclectic category.
Take, for example, Reiki, a form of healing or therapeutic touch. Here is a definition from reiki.org:
When seeking a definition from a more spiritual context, we find that Rei can be defined as the Higher Intelligence that guides the creation and functioning of the universe. Rei is a subtle wisdom that permeates everything, both animate and inanimate. This subtle wisdom guides the evolution of all creation ranging from the unfolding of galaxies to the development of life. On a human level, it is available to help us in times of need and to act as a source of guidance in our lives. Because of its infinite nature, it is all knowing. Rei is also called God and has many other names depending on the culture that has named it.
Yep, religion. Sometimes modern practitioners try to strip the clear religious underpinnings of a treatment from its description, depending on who they are selling it to, so they may just refer to “energy” but as soon as you scratch below the surface, what you find is a spiritual and faith-based practice. The chiropractic concept of innate intelligence is similarly spiritual in nature. DD Palmer combined Mesmer’s notions of an “animal magnetism” with the spiritualism of his day. He felt he had discovered a new force of nature, and that force was decidedly vitalistic and spiritual.
The combination of religion and CAM is more than just historical and philosophical – there is a practical purpose here as well, which partly explains why MMS is still a problem a decade after the FDA first warned about it. On the Church of Health and Healing website they are still “selling” MMS:
Welcome to the Genesis II Church sacramental provider website!All sacraments and products are to be acquired by donation.The Genesis II Church is a free church under common law and is not under commercial law.Please enjoy our easy-to-use donation website!
You see why I put “selling” is scare quotes. They are claiming that this snake oil is a “sacrament” that they offer to their members for a “donation”. They emphasize that, according to them, they are operating under common law, and not commercial law. This is all a blatant end-run around the FDA, the FTC, and charges of fraud.
The FDA isn’t buying it, but it does seem to have slowed them down. Humble has also fled to Mexico, which is often used as a haven for quacks and charlatans who want to continue to sell their snake oil, just out of reach of American regulators. Humble has responded to the FDA warnings in completely predictable fashion:
Humble blasted back at the FDA, saying they “should get on and tell everyone how poisonous the FDA-approved drugs are,” according to a video on his site.
Humble has also pulled another stunt often used by medical con-artists – asking those who believe they have been helped or cured by the dubious treatment to call the media, or solicit help from politicians. There is a common pattern of behavior – make millions selling snake oil, then use the money to influence regulations and hide from regulators, and unleash testimonials from those who have already been conned. As an added bonus, hide behind religion. It’s sad how consistently these strategies can work.
From my perspective it seems like Humble is a heartless con-artist who is selling dangerous snake oil to vulnerable people and claiming it will cure serious diseases like cancer and HIV, and conditions like autism. Why is this man not in prison? Why is he still selling industrial bleach as a healing potion on his website? What more evidence do we need that the FDA does not have the proper authority and tools to protect the public from this kind of dangerous snake-oil? They keep releasing warnings to the public, because they can’t simply shut this down.

Skin pH: Salesmanship, Not Science
People are being encouraged to worry about the pH of their skin and to try to change it. These concerns and interventions are not supported by scientific evidence.
Harriet Hall on July 2, 2019
Link

You have probably heard of the alkaline diet. Public knowledge of pH, the scale by which acids and bases are measured, is plagued by misinformation. People who don’t understand science are restricting their diet, buying alkaline water, testing their urine with pH test strips, and buying into bogus cancer cures, all on the basis of pseudoscientific claims. I wrote a SkepDoc column about it for Skeptic magazine titled “pH Mythology: Separating Phacts from Phiction“. pH has become something of a buzzword or a fad akin to gluten-free diets, and now some people are worrying about the pH of their hair, scalp, teeth, and skin. Creating worry is a good way to sell shampoos, soaps, and cosmetics; but the science behind it is scant and questionable.
Most of the websites that address skin pH are not science-based sites, but women’s magazines, commercial sites selling “pH balanced” skin and hair products, and other sites that offer more pHantasy than pHact. One of them offers a questionnaire you can use to measure your pH, with questions like “how often do you moisturize?” There is no reason to think such a questionnaire could measure anything, as it has never been tested or validated. The websites also recommend testing urine and saliva, which don’t represent body or skin pH. They say alkalinity causes dry, sensitive skin, eczema, and inflammation that causes wrinkles and sagging; acidity causes angry breakouts, with redness and inflammation and skin that becomes painful to touch. To normalize pH, they recommend dietary changes and probiotics, neither of which is supported by scientific studies. They also recommend acidic hair rinses (lemon juice, apple cider vinegar), rainwater, herbs, and essential oils. And switching shampoos, soaps, or other products (preferably to the ones they sell).
One website suggests that inflammatory markers in the colon and skin can throw off the bacterial flora that helps boost the immune system, thereby triggering acne, rosacea, and other inflammatory skin conditions. It says probiotics decrease the toxicity being reabsorbed into the bloodstream: “Toxins inhibit the absorption of important vitamins, minerals and nutrients and interfere with the body’s ability to rid itself of necessary waste, causing inflammation.” It even claims that applying probiotics to the skin can delay aging and restore hair growth.
The authors of these articles have no medical or scientific credentials; they provide no evidence and no references to support their claims. Much of what they say is easily recognizable as pseudoscience and salesmanship.
A typical website says, “Many of the hair products that people use disrupt the natural pH of the hair. A substance that is too alkaline will cause the hair cuticle to open, while a substance that is too acidic will cause the cuticle to contract.” It says opening the cuticle makes the hair look dull. I found claims like this on many skin and hair websites, but none of them had links to scientific studies; and when I searched, I couldn’t find any corroborating studies.
Some of the websites mention scientific studies without identifying them. When I was able to locate the studies, I found their descriptions misleading. A 2010 study published in the British Journal of Dermatology was said to show that women with an alkaline skin developed more fine lines and crow’s-feet – and were more prone to sun damage – than those with acidic skin. The study didn’t show that. What it concluded was “Having a drier, more alkaline stratum corneum, a lighter complexion, being middle-aged (40s) or becoming menopausal were associated with faster persistent wrinkling.” pH was only one of many factors they looked at, and all they found was an association; they didn’t even speculate about causation.
I did find some science, but not what I was hoping for
I was able to locate several studies of skin pH in the peer-reviewed scientific literature.
A small study showed no difference in pH between young and old subjects, contradicting claims made on many popular websites.
A study in the Journal of Investigative Dermatology found that skin pH has a circadian rhythm, with a peak-trough difference of 7-16%. It found a higher transepidermal water loss (TEWL) in the evening compared to the morning, and suggested that cosmetic creams might be better absorbed if applied in the evening. But the circadian rhythms of TEWL and pH were not correlated. They pointed out that “no study is available on the effect of changes of cutaneous pH on drug absorption”.
One study found a higher skin pH in children with atopic dermatitis and suggested that measuring skin pH might be a useful way to objectively assess skin dryness in epidemiological studies regarding atopic skin disease. They speculated that increased pH might be due to cutaneous irritation, a result rather than a cause of atopic eczema. If that is true, it would make more sense to treat the irritation rather than to try to change the pH.
This study found that the natural skin pH was 4.7, (contradicting some pH website claims) and found that acid skin pH (4-4.5) keeps the resident bacterial flora attached to the skin, whereas an alkaline pH of 8-9 promoted dispersal.
Another study concluded, “The skin environment least likely to be associated with diaper dermatitis is one in which increases in both skin wetness and skin pH are minimized”.
Another study said, “Although it is usually agreed that the pH of the skin surface may influence the cutaneous microflora, much remains to be learnt”.
This review of the literature reported that “pH apparently varies little until the age of 70, after which it declines”.
This study found that Infants have less acidic skin than adults.
This study found that pH varies by location. It’s higher on the cheek than on the forehead.
Another study suggested that routine monitoring of wound pH “would most possibly improve chronic wound therapy”.
A study in dialysis patients found no correlation between skin pH and pruritus.
A study in a Chinese population found that pH and hydration varied with age, gender, and body site, with higher pH after the age of 70.
Another study confirmed that the average skin pH was 4.7. They commented that prior use of cosmetic products, especially soaps, have profound influences on skin pH, and plain tap water, which in Europe has a pH of 8, will increase skin pH for up to 6 hours after application.
What’s missing
While I found these studies interesting, it soon became glaringly obvious that there were NO randomized, controlled therapeutic clinical trials. Nothing to support the many recommendations offered. Nothing to validate any clinical applications of pH measurement. In short, all the pH advocates have is a little basic science, a lot of speculation, and some folklore. Remember Christopher Hitchens: “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence”.
I would have liked to see, for instance, a well-designed, randomized, double blind study showing that patients with dermatitis had abnormal skin pH values compared to subjects without dermatitis, that a treatment was effective in correcting the pH, and that normalizing skin pH produced objectively measurable improvement in clinical outcomes.
I have questions
    • What does pH-balanced mean? I don’t see that anything is being “balanced.” It just seems to mean the product has the same pH as skin.
    • Several websites refer to “ideal” pH, but they seem to be confusing “average” with “ideal.” There have been no studies showing that 4.7 is ideal, only that it is the average measurement found in studies or apparently normal people. What if 5.0 or 4.3 produced better outcomes? We don’t know.
    • Correlation is not causation. When there is a correlation between skin pH and a dermatological condition, was the pH the cause of the problem or simply a result of the disease?
    • What is the best, most consistent, most accurate way to measure skin pH? It varies with time of day and location on the skin and is altered by all kinds of other factors like water and cosmetics. Good science demands standardization of measurement.
    • What interventions will safely and effectively change skin pH?
    • What should your target pH be? The pH of vulvar skin is 5.3-5.6; should you shoot for that or for 4.7?
    • Is there any evidence that pH interventions improve objectively measurable clinical outcomes?
    • Is it possible that moisturizers and judicious skin care might work just as well as adjusting pH?
Conclusion: We need to wait for better science
There could well be some truth in some of the skin pH claims, and there may be a clinical role for testing and adjusting skin pH, but we simply don’t know yet. We’ll have to wait for the science to catch up to the speculation.

“Young blood” infusions: same old snake oil
There’s no reliable evidence that an infusion of blood plasma from a young donor will benefit an older person, and there are risks, but Ambrosia Health is selling “young blood” infusions for thousands of dollars anyway. The FDA has taken notice.
Jann Bellamy on June 20, 2019
Link

For $8,000 a liter, $12,000 for two, a company called Ambrosia Health will pump you full of plasma from young (typically, 16-25 years of age) donors, a treatment aimed at . . . well, they can’t tell you that because it might get them into trouble with the FDA. However, according to the company’s website, Ambrosia Health “is interested in” parabiosis, which (hint, hint) “has been shown in mice to reverse aging”.
So interested, in fact, that Ambrosia’s founder, Jesse Karmazin, was willing to extrapolate all sorts of health benefits from the results of experiments on mice and conduct a clinical trial of young blood plasma infusions on human subjects, who paid thousands of dollars each for their treatments. Despite Karmazin’s repeated promises, and his glowing reports of benefits, the trial results have never been published, or made public in any form for that matter. All of this has earned Karmazin rebukes from the scientific community and the FDA’s notice, but has not stopped Ambrosia from currently offering “young blood” (as they are often called, although it’s actually blood plasma) infusions at two U.S. locations.
According to an excellent news report published in HuffPost late last year, Karmazin, a 2014 Stanford med school graduate, left his Brigham & Women’s Hospital residency program in 2016 to pursue his interest in aging as a “treatable condition.” (He does not have a license to practice medicine in any state.) He got the idea for infusions of plasma from young blood donors from mouse studies showing improvements in older mice’s health when they were surgically joined to younger mice, thereby mixing the older and younger mice’s blood.
As SBM’s Dr. Steve Novella explained, the technique of surgically joining mice so that they share the same circulatory system, called parabiosis, was used in physiology studies to determine if blood factors affected some physiological property (e.g., the effects of hormones). In the 1950s, researchers discovered that biomarkers of youth returned in old mice connected to young mice and the old mice lived longer and experienced rejuvenating effects. (The younger mice didn’t fare so well; they had shorter life spans.) What we don’t know is why this happened:
does this benefit come from specific factors in the blood or from the fact that they are sharing their entire circulatory system? In other words, are the younger mouse’s kidneys, livers, and lungs just supporting the older mouse’s organs by doing the heavy lifting of cleaning and oxygenating the blood? This is probably a factor, but the other option is that there are proteins in the young mouse blood that exist in smaller amounts in the older blood.
In any event, by the 1970s, parabiosis experiments had run their course because researchers had learned what they could and more stringent regulation of animal experiments made the research more difficult.
The significance of findings from parabiosis experiments has been called into question by scientists, according to the HuffPost report, including Irina Conboy, who researches aging and rejuvenation at Berkeley:
Maybe there are secret sources [for human rejuvenation] in young blood . . . But there is no scientific evidence for that.
The indecisive results of mouse studies and total lack of evidence of benefit in humans apparently didn’t dissuade Karmazin, who, in 2016, announced a clinical trial of young blood infusions, for which participants age 35 and older would pay $8,000 for about 2 liters of young plasma infused over one to two days. Institutional Review Board oversight was provided through The Institute for Regenerative and Cellular Medicine, whose official defended the trial on the ground that, although controversial, she told HuffPost “there’s a lot worse being done”.
The trial was clouded by questionable ethics and criticisms from experts. One of the physicians involved in the study had been charged by the Medical Board of California with unprofessional conduct, including an allegation that he diagnosed a patient with “chronic Lyme” and treated the patient with daily antibiotic infusions, leading to significant side effects. Per an agreement with the Board, the physician was reprimanded but did not admit wrongdoing and was allowed to continue practicing.
Another issue was sourcing some 80 gallons of young blood plasma from blood banks that, as the HuffPost points out, usually don’t separate blood out by donor age and sell it to rejuvenate older people. Rather, “their primary mission is to provide donated blood for hospital patients and save lives”. Eventually, Karmazin found two blood banks to supply his trial, although one no longer does business with him after the HuffPost revealed some unpleasant facts about a blood drive specifically directed at millennials, who were called upon (with incentives like movie and amusement park passes) to “step up and donate” to save lives. The blood bank wouldn’t tell reporters whether young blood plasma from its “Generation Give” drive was sold to Karmazin and denied any connection between the reporters’ inquiry and its decision to terminate the relationship with Ambrosia.
The trial’s informed consent process was questioned as well:
Ambrosia told trial participants that “abundant data” from mice studies suggested young plasma infusions could help with “rejuvenation,” but the company said it couldn’t guarantee participants any specific results, such as the treatment of a disease. Rather, it noted in its informed consent form that there are “no known improvements” directly related to young plasma infusions. In fact, the form contained “an appalling lack of detailed explanation of what the actual effects of this intervention are supposed to be,” said Alta Charo, a professor of law and bioethics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who reviewed Ambrosia’s form at HuffPost’s request.
The lack of benefit versus the risk, which can include hives, lung injury and deadly infections, also worried scientists. The director of transfusion medicine at Michigan, Robertson Davenport, told reporters that a transfusion for anti-aging purposes is “not scientifically or medically justified and exposes patients to risk of harm”. Dobri Kiprov, chief of the immunotherapy division at California Pacific Medical Center, told MIT Technology Review that he tries to dissuade patients from young blood transfusions: “To expose people to danger unnecessarily – in my mind, that is really horrible”.
Finally, the significance of the trial’s object – to measure the effect of young blood plasma on about 100 biomarkers – was called into question. According to Irina Conboy, the biomarker results will be meaningless because there is no control arm and, in any event, blood biomarkers change for many reasons: “If you eat a meal, leptin changes”. Another expert noted that changes in biomarkers aren’t necessarily indicative of a change in actual health status.
Ambrosia’s clinical trial ended in January 2018. Despite the lack of published results, Karmazin and an Ambrosia official who has since left the company touted the trial as “a great success,” claiming to various media outlets that an Alzheimer’s patient showed improvements after one treatment, grey hair turned darker for a person in their 60’s, there was a 10% reduction in patients’ blood cholesterol levels and a 20% fall in the level of amyloids, erections resumed in a patient with depleted testosterone levels, “really dramatic improvements to biomarkers for inflammation,” as well as improvements in a tremor for a Parkinson’s patient, arthritis symptoms, sleep, memory, focus, appearance, muscle tone, and energy levels. A patient with chronic fatigue syndrome “feels healthy for the first time” and “looks younger”.
In other words, just the type of placebo effects you’d expect from patients with variable symptoms who received an expensive, elaborate, time-consuming treatment based on pre-existing expectations of benefit, plus a few random improvements in biomarkers that cannot be reliably attributed to the treatment and may be clinically meaningless.
The FDA takes note
Ambrosia operated five U.S. clinics at one time but ceased treatments following a sternly-worded advisory from the FDA and statement from the FDA Commissioner “cautioning consumers against receiving young donor plasma infusions that are promoted as unproven treatment for varying conditions”, both issued in February of this year. The agency, which regulates blood products, made clear that it was watching and not liking what it was seeing.
Without naming Ambrosia or any other company, then-Commissioner Gottlieb condemned “unscrupulous” and “bad actors” who were charging thousands of dollars and preying upon patients, touting young plasma as a remedy for conditions as diverse as “normal aging and memory loss to serious diseases like dementia, Parkinson’s disease, multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer’s disease, heart disease or post-traumatic stress disorder”, uses for which plasma is not FDA-recognized or approved.
Our concerns regarding treatments using plasma from young donors are heightened by the fact that there is no compelling clinical evidence on its efficacy, nor is there information on appropriate dosing for treatment of the conditions for which these products are being advertised. . . . Moreover, reports we’re seeing indicate that the dosing of these infusions can involve administration of large volumes of plasma that can be associated with significant risks including infectious, allergic, respiratory and cardiovascular risks, among others.
Commissioner Gottlieb said the FDA would consider taking regulatory and enforcement actions against companies who risk patients’ health with “uncontrolled manufacturing conditions” or by “promoting so-called ‘treatments’ that haven’t been proven safe for effective for any use”. The FDA urged patients and physicians to report adverse events from young blood treatments to the agency.
The effect of the FDA’s threat on Karmazin wore off fairly quickly. Ambrosia recently reentered the young blood biz with locations in Tampa and San Francisco and a bare-bones website only hinting at the putative age-defying effects of its product. And:
Plasma is an off-label treatment, so we cannot make any claims about its effectiveness. There may be risks to this treatment and your doctor will advise you on these risks.
“Your doctor?” That term gives me pause. If a physician’s only encounter with a patient consists of signing off on a blood transfusion, is he really “your doctor,” especially where there is, presumably, no referral from the physician who is actually following the patient for the particular condition he or she seeks to remedy with the transfusion? Can you call a physician who operates wholly outside the patient’s care team “your doctor”? While it is true that a physician-patient relationship is established, such that the patient could sue the physician for malpractice, calling the physician “your doctor” implies a familiar relationship with the patient that is belied by the facts. I would argue that “a physician” is a more suitable reference to this person hired by the company to oversee what may be a single encounter.
Considering the negative information that comes up in a Google search of “young blood” infusions in general and Ambrosia Health in particular, it’s hard to imagine anyone shelling out thousands of dollars for these unproven and potentially risky treatments. Unfortunately, as we’ve seen time and again here at SBM, good science doesn’t stop people from making bad health decisions about vaccination, autism treatments, CAM for cancer and other serious diseases, stem cell treatments, homeopathy, naturopathy, chiropractic, integrative medicine, functional medicine, dietary supplements, or acupuncture. Sadly, it’s unlikely “young blood” infusions will be any different.

Debunking Sleep Myths
Dispelling common sleep myths is the first step to improving one’s sleep.
Steven Novella on April 17, 2019
Link

It’s always good to see mainstream scientists directly addressing common myths and misconceptions about their specialty. This is especially true in medicine, because of the potential direct consequences of misinformation.
In the current issue of Sleep Health, sleep researchers surveyed websites to find 20 common sleep beliefs, and then did a literature review to find out how backed they were by published evidence. They address these common myths, and also point out questions that are still unresolved in the literature. Here are a few of the more important highlights, with some of my own experience as a physician thrown in.
In recent years, at least within my specialty of neurology, sleep difficulty has been increasingly recognized as comorbid with many of the conditions we treat. Asking patients about their sleep is now (or at least should be) routine. This is especially important because patients often do not even think about sleep as medically relevant. In my experience patients rarely volunteer information about their sleep when asked open-ended questions about their health, any problems they may be having, or anything that might influence whatever neurological problem I am seeing them for. But when I ask directly about sleep, they may tell me that their sleep is horrible and definitely worsens their symptoms. This leads me to suspect that many people just don’t see sleep as a medical issue they should discuss with their doctor, and why it is therefore so important to ask directly.
Perhaps some of the common myths exposed in this study also contribute to this phenomenon. For example, one common myth is that, “Many adults need only 5 or less hours of sleep for general health”. This is critical because some patients may only be getting 3-5 hours of sleep a night, but not perceive this as necessarily a problem. Or they nap during the day or on weekends and think this makes up for it. Perhaps their work and childcare schedule only allows for this duration of sleep and they feel they have no choice.
The reality is that chronic even mild to moderate sleep deprivation is a huge health risk factor. Chronic sleep deprivation becomes the new normal for some people and they don’t realize what an impact it is having. Often they will complain to me about symptoms of chronic sleep deprivation (poor memory, fatigue, weight gain, even excessive daytime sleepiness) and yet not connect these symptoms to their chronic poor sleep.
In reality everyone should get at least 7 hours of sleep per night. Ideally these hours should be continuous, and not interrupted or broken up throughout the day. The timing of sleep should also be as consistent as possible, to keep your brain in a 24 hour circadian rhythm.
The basic recommendations to achieve this are – no electronic devices in bed, low light is better prior to sleep to prepare the brain for sleep, get physical activity and sunlight during the day, avoid eating or drinking right before going to bed, empty your bladder before getting into bed, and address any physical symptoms that might be interfering with sleep onset or maintenance. There is more, but at this point you should probably be consulting your primary care doctor or a specialist.
Where there is enduring controversy is when trade-offs are necessary. What if you did not sleep 7 hours the night before – should you nap? Napping may make up for some lost sleep, but also breaks up your sleep cycle. So this needs to be individualized. Should you sleep in on the weekend? Same dilemma, it does make up some sleep (not completely) but shifts your circadian rhythm.
Another common myth is that a little alcohol before bed can help with sleep onset. The opposite, rather, is true. Alcohol disrupts the sleep cycle. And while we are talking about substances, caffeine is another source of sleep myths. Many people believe that as long as they restrict their caffeine to earlier in the day, caffeine will not affect their sleep.
However, having caffeine even 6 hours prior to bedtime is capable of delaying sleep onset and quality. Caffeine directly disrupts the brain’s circadian rhythm, no matter when you drink it. Further, if you have a lot of caffeine, you may be in withdrawal in the late evening or overnight, and this can cause symptoms that disrupt sleep. A good rule of thumb if you have poor sleep is to restrict caffeine to one 8 oz. beverage in the morning.
The authors also focus on snoring, which many people falsely believe is always benign. It may be, but it may also be a symptom of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). This is a closing off of the airway due to relaxation of muscles during sleep. The evidence suggests that we are in the middle of an OSA epidemic, being driven partly by the obesity epidemic, as obesity is the major risk factor for OSA. Estimates vary between 14% and 49% of middle-aged males having OSA in the US and Europe.
OSA is a serious health problem. It increases the risk for hypertension, heart disease, and stroke. Often patients do not realize they have OSA, because they do not remember the brief awakenings that the obstructions produce. Their partner will usually know that they snore, but also not realize how severe the problem is. Patients may think they are sleeping through the night, but wake up exhausted as if they haven’t slept and have symptoms of chronic sleep deprivation.
The definitive way to diagnose OSA is with a sleep study. It is also completely treatable. The most common method is to use continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) to keep the airway open at night. Many patients have difficulty adapting to wearing CPAP at night, but can eventually make it work. There may also be other treatment options, including surgery to widen the airway. Those with OSA are encouraged to follow up with their sleep doctor (or pulmonologist) until they have successfully treated their OSA. Weight loss, of course, may be a cure for some people, but that is a long term solution which is often difficult to achieve.
In my opinion the biggest myth of all is that poor sleep is not a medical issue. It is if it’s impaired sufficiently. There may be other underlying medical conditions causing the poor sleep also, such as OSA or even restless leg syndrome (and yes, this is a real thing). Sometimes medications may be the problem, and this needs to be reviewed with your physician. Chronic poor sleep can also occasionally be an early symptom of a more serious neurological disease.
So if you have poor sleep the first step is to dispel sleep myths. Then adopt good sleep habits. If this does not work, you have questions about what your sleep habits should be, or if you have any concerning symptoms such as severe snoring, then consult your physician.

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Systemic Exertion Intolerance Disease Speculcation
Mark Crislip on September 16, 2016
Link

My wife and I are entering an age where our aches and pains are becoming a major ongoing topic of conversations. The pain of raising kids has transitioned into the pains of growing older. These aches and pains are, in the scheme of things, minor and intermittent.
At work I get to see real suffering and it keeps my own in perspective. And there are a lot of people who feel awful, some for obvious reasons such as cancer or AIDS, and some from ailments that are more enigmatic, such as systemic exertion intolerance disease (SEID), the illness formerly known as chronic fatigue syndrome.
Worst. Gateway disease. Ever.
In the context of SBM, SEID is a gateway disease into the world of pseudo-medicine.
A syndrome with no known cause and few effective therapies at best, those who suffer from it are easy pickings for SCAM practitioners. When you feel like crap month after month with no improvement or even an explanation for your suffering, you keep looking until you find an answer.
For example, those with ‘chronic Lyme disease‘ have the same phenotype as SEID patients:
A subset of patients reporting a diagnosis of Lyme disease can be described as having alternatively diagnosed chronic Lyme syndrome (ADCLS), in which diagnosis is based on laboratory results from a nonreference Lyme specialty laboratory using in-house criteria. Patients with ADCLS report symptoms similar to those reported by patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)…In British Columbia, a setting with low Lyme disease incidence, ADCLS patients have a similar phenotype to that of CFS patients.
These patients have the misfortune of being sucked into the chronic Lyme vortex when they probably have SEID, whatever that is. And there are other pseudo-diseases that have been misidentified as the etiology of SEID.
There has always been the question as to whether SEID is due to an infectious disease. One of the patterns I have noted over the years is the high functioning people who develop an acute illness and never, or slowly, recover. In a subset of patients SEID sure seems to me to be some sort of acute to chronic infection, or at least triggered by an infection.
While there is certainly another subset of patients whose underlying process is depression, they are different from SEID patients who have an acute onset of symptoms, a remarkable need to sleep, and the ‘brain fog’.
SEID sure looks like an infection. There are even outbreaks. But from what organism? Over the years a there have been a variety of infectious agents purported to cause SEID. When I was an intern at the end of the last century it was EBV. Others have suggested less legitimate causes such as Candida, promoted by Dr. Crook in his book The Yeast Connection. The snark makes itself. I was quite excited a few years back over the discovery of XMRV as a potential cause of SEID and was disappointed it did not pan out. But despite extensive investigations, no one infection has been implicated as a cause or coinfection with SEID.
Lots of panning, little gold
Perhaps SEID is some sort of post-infectious/post-inflammatory process, but that never panned out either. Immunologic? Maybe. But that idea has had little traction as well.
I found it intriguing that CFS patients appear to have different expression of genes (and here) but that never panned out either. Many of these studies suggest that SEID sufferers are physiologically different than those without the syndrome, but a unifying etiology remained elusive.
Seeing patients with this process is rarely satisfying. I don’t know what you have, I don’t know why you have it, I have nothing to offer you, and I do not know when, or even if, you will get better.
I don’t use those words of course, but that is the basic message. I always thought that SEID was post-infectious immunologic/inflammatory process like rheumatic fever that one day someone would figure out. In the meantime I have used the metaphor with patients of a rock thrown into a pond. The rock, whatever it was and in my speculations assumed to be an illness, started with a splash. The rock is gone, and now the patients are left with the ripples of SEID, slowing fading. I thought it was a good metaphor, but who knows.
Now there is a new study, “Metabolic features of chronic fatigue syndrome“, that suggests an entirely different pathophysiology:
Patients with CFS showed abnormalities in 20 metabolic pathways. Eighty percent of the diagnostic metabolites were decreased, consistent with a hypometabolic syndrome. Pathway abnormalities included sphingolipid, phospholipid, purine, cholesterol, microbiome, pyrroline–5-carboxylate, riboflavin, branch chain amino acid, peroxisomal, and mitochondrial metabolism.
When compared to controls, SEID metabolism is slowed down, and most resembles, of all things, the dauer state of a nematode.
Dauer, which means persistence or long-lived in German, is an example of one well-studied system. The developmental stage of dauer is a hypometabolic state capable of living efficiently by altering a number of basic mitochondrial functions, fuel preferences, behavior, and physical features. Dauer is comprised of an evolutionarily conserved and synergistic suite of metabolic and structural changes that are triggered by exposure to adverse environmental conditions. Entry into dauer confers a survival advantage in harsh conditions.
The dauer state is one of many hypometabolic states including:
diapause, hibernation, estivation, torpor, ischemic preconditioning, ER stress, the unfolded protein response, autophagy, and caloric restriction.
The hypothesis certainly fits what is seen clinically and it would be nice to have a final common pathway to explain a syndrome that appears after a variety of insults.
The results are preliminary, with a small number of people, and needs replication. So maybe it will pan out or just be another dead end. But it would a very satisfying explanation of SEID if validated.
Ooh, it makes me wonder…
And it also makes me wonder why. Humans don’t hibernate (medical conferences not withstanding), but we certainly have an evolutionary history filled with harsh conditions. Is SEID some sort of some sort of pathologic residue from what was once a beneficial response to stress in our Fred and Barney past, like depression (and given the profound motor retardation of depression, is depression a variation on a dauer theme?) or is the metabolic syndrome a residual from our tuberculous past? Who knows. But fun to think about.
And I wonder how long before naturopaths offer anti-dauer therapy? If nothing else, 200C C. elegans should be the homeopathic treatment.

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Rituximab
IV rituximab has been used to treat chronic fatigue syndrome. A large, well-designed new study shows it doesn’t work.
Harriet Hall on April 16, 2019
Link

Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), also known as myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME or ME/CFS), is a poorly-understood condition characterized by profound fatigue and a constellation of other symptoms. The diagnostic criteria, cause, pathophysiology, and treatment have been embroiled in controversy. One hypothesis is that in a subgroup of patients it could be caused by an autoimmune disease mechanism, an immunologic dysfunction mediated by B-lymphocytes. Depleting B-cells with rituximab has been investigated as a possible treatment. Does it work? A new, large, well-designed study says no.
Research history
All the CFS/rituximab research has been done by a single group of researchers in Norway. It started when doctors Fluge and Mella observed that a patient’s CFS symptoms improved during chemotherapy for a malignancy. They speculated that it might have been due to depletion of B-cells, so they treated three CFS patients with IV infusions of the monoclonal antibody rituximab (brand name Rituxan), with good results, and published it as a preliminary case series in 2009.
Next they did a double-blind study of 30 patients, comparing IV rituximab to a placebo, IV saline. That study was represented as positive, but actually was negative for the primary end-point of self-reported symptoms at 3 months. B-cell depletion was rapid but the symptomatic response was delayed, with 2/3 of the patients reportedly showing a transient improvement after 6-10 months of followup.
In 2013 I wrote about patients from Norway with ME/CFS who were traveling to the US to have Dr. Andreas Kogelnik in San Francisco treat them with expensive IV infusions of rituximab, apparently to no avail. The protocol he was using was different from the study protocol. I was concerned that he was experimenting with patients outside of a formal study, with a drug that is known to have serious and potentially deadly side effects.
At that point, two more studies were pending, both open label and without a control group. In 2016 I wrote a followup article. One of the uncontrolled studies was still ongoing. The other had been completed. It reported “clinically significant” responses in 18 out of 29 patients. Symptoms were self-reported, and the responses were delayed. One major responder had a full relapse after 32 months and dropped out. Since there was no control group, it is impossible to interpret the significance of the findings.
Next they did an open-label study of four patients with very severe symptoms; the researchers classified all four as non-responders, and they warned against using rituximab outside of clinical trials.
The new study
Eventually they embarked on a large multicenter randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial of151 patients. The study was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine on April 2, 2019. Dr. Fluge was the lead author. The results were negative:
B-cell depletion using several infusions of rituximab over 12 months was not associated with clinical improvement in patients with ME/CFS.
Two IV infusions of either 500 mg of rituximab or an equal volume of saline (with added albumen to ensure no visible difference) were given 2 weeks apart, followed by maintenance infusions at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. Follow-up lasted 24 months. Subjects were aged 18 to 65 years, had had the disease for at least 2 years (or over 5 years if mild) but less than 15 years, and met the Canadian consensus criteria for diagnosis. Patients with very severe disease were excluded. All subjects were premedicated with oral acetaminophen, cetirizine, and dexamethasone to minimize the chance of reactions.
Subjects self-reported symptoms at various points using numeric scales. At baseline and between 17 and 21 months, they wore a SenseWear armband for 5 to 7 days to record physical activity as measured by number of steps. Only one patient in each group withdrew and none were lost to follow-up. In an exit poll, only 19 of the 151 patients correctly guessed whether they were in the rituximab or the placebo group. 81.8% of the rituximab group and 64.9% of the placebo group had any adverse event. 26% of the rituximab group and 18.9% of the placebo group had serious adverse events requiring hospitalization. No subjects withdrew from the study because of adverse events.
30% of each treatment group reported improvements over time in symptoms and activity levels. 10% reported sustained worsening. Response rates were better for placebo (35.1%) than for rituximab (26%). There was no difference in fatigue scores or in any of the secondary endpoints.
The authors point out the limitations of their studies (self-reports rather than objective measures, unreliable recall, limited knowledge of natural symptom variations over time, and unintended patient selection effects) and predictably, they call for more research. I’m not sure that’s warranted. The same researchers are doing a similar study on cyclophosphamide, because they observed improvement of CFS symptoms in two breast cancer patients who got adjuvant chemotherapy including cyclophosphamide.
Doctor disciplined
My correspondent in Norway tells me there is a Norwegian oncologist, Dagfinn Øgreid, who has treated 250 patients with rituximab since 2015, charging the equivalent of $25,000 US. The cost is not covered by insurance and has caused financial difficulties for patients. He disregarded the preliminary negative study results and the advice of the researchers to only use rituximab in the context of clinical studies. He says he has seen many patients get a better life. Maybe, but how can he know whether it was better because of rituximab or in spite of it? That’s the whole point of doing controlled scientific studies. Someone who prefers stories to studies doesn’t deserve the name of scientist.
The health authorities issued a warning in 2018, saying his choice of treatment seems haphazard and with poor medical reasoning. He said he would heed the warning but didn’t agree with it. 30 of his patients protested, writing letters to the authorities asking them to stop the case against him. My correspondent has been following the stories in the Norwegian press; they are not available in English. They contain reports from many of his patients who did not get better. When interviewed, Dr. Øgreid said 1/3 recover completely, 1/3 are a bit better, and 1/3 have no response. At least one patient who told him she was better reported that she subsequently relapsed and did not inform him, and a survey of his patients on a Facebook group found that hardly anyone improved, and those who did, later relapsed.
Øgreid is a controversial figure. He has been the subject of a dozen medical board investigations, with four still active. They involve prescribing rituximab for ME/CFS, experimental treatment of cancer patients with immunotherapy, prescribing large doses of antibiotics over time, prescribing large doses of benzodiazepines without seeing the patients, prescribing 12 times the recommended dose of addictive drugs, and not getting informed consent. After reading all the details in the press, my correspondent says she is shocked that he still has a license.
Conclusion: rituximab is not an effective treatment for CFS
In my opinion, we now know enough to reject any use of rituximab for CFS outside of well-designed controlled studies. Treating patients willy-nilly just because some of them seem to get better is unscientific and unethical. And I think research funds could probably be better spent elsewhere. This whole enterprise strikes me as a wild goose chase based on anecdotal observations from a single research group. It was reasonable to investigate, but they have done so and the results were negative. We need to learn much more about CFS, but isn’t it time to look elsewhere?

Medical Apartheid
Harriet Washington’s book tells the dark history of medical experimentation on black Americans. It also reveals broader problems of inequality, poor science, and human failures.
Harriet Hall on April 9, 2019
Link


In a recent post, Clay Jones reminded us that “the unconscious need to avoid cognitive dissonance serves as a powerful motivation to rationalize even the most horrific beliefs and behaviors.” I recently wrote about the horrific Tuskegee syphilis experiment, an unethical and racist study that denied treatment to black men with syphilis. I don’t condone or excuse what those experimenters did, but I do want to understand how good people can come to do bad things. To learn more, I read a book by the black journalist and ethicist Harriet Washington: Medical Apartheid: The Dark History of Medical Experimentation on Black Americans from Colonial Times to the Present. Comprehensive and meticulously researched, it shows that the Tuskegee experiment was not an anomaly; researchers who exploit African Americans have been the norm throughout our nation’s history. Longstanding problems of racism, misguided thinking, and poor science continue to plague our society today.
The racial health divide is undeniable. African Americans don’t live as long. Their infant mortality is twice that of whites. Twice as many develop diabetes. They have the highest rate of cancer and cancer deaths. The reasons for these discrepancies are complex and are largely due to socioeconomic and historical factors rather than racial characteristics.
The belief that blacks were an inferior race was built into our Constitution. It failed to abolish slavery and compromised by counting slaves as three-fifths of a person for the purpose of apportioning representation. Slaves were not citizens and were not permitted to testify in court. Religion was used to justify slavery; the churches quoted Bible verses and preached that slavery was part of God’s plan and was a benign establishment that protected those inferior beings who were incapable of managing their own lives.
Perversion of science
Pro-slavery scientists portrayed blacks as inherently and immutably debased. “No amount of training, education, or good treatment could make him the equal of a white man.” Blacks were believed to have a cranium 10% smaller than whites (not true). A Louisiana doctor asserted (with no evidence) that blacks had a very different breathing apparatus and skeletal structure from that of whites. Blacks were believed to sleep more, have thicker skin, feel less pain, be sexually precocious, and be intellectually retarded. They were thought to be more susceptible to some infections and less susceptible to others. Diseases were said to manifest differently in blacks. Blacks were said to suffer from made-up black diseases like drapetomania, a type of insanity that made slaves inexplicably (?!) want to run away from their owners, and hebetude, a singular laziness and shiftlessness that caused slaves to mishandle and abuse their owners’ property. The recommended treatment for these bogus psychiatric conditions was corporal punishment (which I would think would just make them want to run away that much more). Blacks were said to be a different species; mulattos a separate race. Black characteristics were said to demonstrate a mass of imperfections. The scientists did not notice the logical inconsistencies in their reasoning, and they violated the most basic principle of science: the need to test their beliefs to find out which (if any) were true.
Logical flaws
The scientists who made pronouncements about racial characteristics failed to notice the glaring logical inconsistencies in their arguments. They said blacks were physically inferior, riddled with imperfections from head to toe. And at the same time, they said blacks were hardy laborers who were impervious to most illness. These “inferior” beings were alleged to be resistant to malaria and to be far better suited to working in hot climates in conditions that would kill whites. They thought blacks were so different from whites that a treatment that cured a white man might kill a black man; yet they preferred to study diseases in black subjects and applied their findings to whites. Blacks’ typically thick lips were said to be a primitive, ape-like trait; but apes and chimpanzees have the thinnest of lips! They never did any controlled studies to test their beliefs.
Experiments on slaves
James Marion Sims is revered in medical history as a benefactor of women, the “father of modern gynecology”. He developed a surgical technique to repair vesicovaginal fistulas, a devastating complication of childbirth. White women would not have allowed him to experiment on them, so he acquired eleven slaves with vesicovaginal fistulas from their masters by promising to lodge, board, and treat them. He operated without anesthesia, claiming that blacks didn’t feel pain. They obviously did. Other doctors were recruited to restrain the women, but soon quit because they couldn’t stand the bone-chilling shrieks. He did as many as 30 operations on a single patient. Only one of his patients seems to have benefited.
As a plantation doctor, Sims used black infants for dangerous experiments in tetany. Tetany is a disease of malnutrition, but Sims thought it was caused by displaced skull bones. He believed the myth that black infants’ skull bones fused prematurely, leading to low intelligence. Washington provides this chilling description: “He took a sick black baby from its mother, made incisions in its scalp, then wielded a cobbler’s tool to pry the skull bones into new positions.” When the infants died, he blamed the sloth and ignorance of the mothers.
In another anecdote, Washington describes how a black man refused to consent to surgery on his jaw, so Sims had him forcibly restrained so he could demonstrate the surgery to students. He operated without anesthesia.
Illogical, dangerous, and torturous treatments were commonly tried on slaves. Doctors wantonly tested ideas that had no scientific rationale. For example, one doctor repeatedly poured boiling water on naked slave patients suffering from typhoid pneumonia. The only possible rationale: maybe it would increase circulation!
Race is scientifically meaningless, but discrimination persists
Racial prejudices and abuses persisted even as the science of genetics discovered that the concept of race has no genetic or scientific basis. It is a made-up label, not a scientifically meaningful term.
As we saw in the case of Tuskegee, the end of slavery didn’t mean the end of experimentation on blacks and other powerless people. The practice was well-established and was simply used on any available victims: the poor, the uneducated, prisoners, etc. Other minority groups (Jews, gypsies, the mentally defective) were the research victims of Nazi doctors. Racism was rampant in America. African natives were exhibited at the World’s Fair. The Bronx Zoo exhibited human pygmies as if they were just another exotic animal species. Sideshows exploited humans with anomalies such as the “white Negroes” who suffered from vitiligo.
Where slavery existed, slaves were deliberately used to test treatments, but where it didn’t exist, blacks still bore the brunt of experimentation. Thomas Jefferson used cowpox on 200 slaves before he would allow its use on his white family. In predominately white Brookline, Massachusetts, Dr. Zabadiel Boylston gave 251 experimental smallpox inoculations; all but one of the subjects were black.
Errors in book
Harriet Washington is a skilled reporter, but there are some flaws in the book that might make readers question her ability. She says the word “experiment” is derived from the Latin for “ex” (out of) and “periculum” (dangerous trial). All the sources I found said it is derived from the Latin “experimentum”. She mis-states Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle. She calls Oveta Culp “Oveta Gulp”. While she gets the facts right about the Tuskegee trial in most of the book, in one section she erroneously says the participants included women and children. Only men participated in the study.
Surprising revelations
The book added to my knowledge of the Tuskegee experiment. She pointed out that it wasn’t just white prejudice: black doctors who knew about the experiment approved of it. Some people wrongly believed the men were injected with syphilis. That misunderstanding was not surprising, since there were at least 40 other experiments where doctors deliberately infected healthy black patients with various diseases including syphilis and gonorrhea. She says there was one good scientific result of the study. Public Health Service (PHS) documents show that blood from the Tuskegee subjects was instrumental in developing more accurate blood tests for syphilis, including the FTA-ABS and VDRL tests that are used today.
I did not know that blacks were barred from some chapters of the American Medical Association (AMA) until well into the 1960’s. I did not know that the first successful open-heart surgery was done by a black doctor, Daniel Hale Williams, in 1893. He sutured the pericardium to repair a wound. I was surprised to learn that a bill to abolish slavery was introduced in the Virginia legislature by Thomas Jefferson’s grandson in 1831, and it was defeated by only seven votes.
The Tuskegee Study was not the worst
The Tuskegee experiment is the most famous, but it has been “eclipsed in both numbers and egregiousness by other abusive medical studies” which the book goes on to describe. In the interest of eugenics, black babies with congenital defects were allowed to die, hysterectomies were done without consent, and the government encouraged and funded involuntary sterilization.
Grave robbing provided an excess of black corpses to medical schools. Birth control measures were disproportionately tested on black women; some called it intended genocide. Norplant was selectively marketed to poor black women and young girls. Drug abuse in black women was ten times more likely to be reported to law enforcement although it was no more common in black women than in white women. The “crack baby” epidemic was a myth.
Radiation experiments
A truck driver with multiple broken bones was not expected to survive, so without permission, the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) took the opportunity to inject him with 41 times the normal lifetime dose of plutonium to see what would happen. They pulled his teeth and extracted bone chips to measure the plutonium levels, and five days later they finally got around to setting his broken bones. He not only survived, but he unexpectedly walked out of the hospital and disappeared, dying at home eight years later of unrelated heart disease.
The government did all kinds of radiation experiments to bleach skin, remove hair, treat ringworm, etc. There were a total of 435 human radiation experiments, some resulting in cancer and disfigurement. They gave blacks a higher dose of radiation because they believed they were more tolerant; there was no evidence to support that belief. The AEC used some of the same justifications used by Nazi doctors. They established informed consent policies but then proceeded to ignore them.
Prisoners
For a long time, prisoners were recruited for experiments. The ethics were questioned: they volunteered, but there was thought to be an element of coercion. Blacks were not specifically targeted, but they might as well have been since prison inmates were 40-61% black. They were often deceived and injured. In one study, cancer cells were injected into 396 inmates; more than 180 of them were black. Experiments were flawed. They involved psychosurgery, mind control, burns to the cornea that often caused blindness, and plasma transfusions that inadvertently infected 28% of subjects with hepatitis. The CIA funded drug experiments with LSD and other drugs. One drug to control violence was tested exclusively on black prisoners because they were thought to have “a weak type of nervous system.” Prison research largely died out in the 1970s but is enjoying a quiet renaissance. The laws enacted to protect prisoners have consistently failed to do so, and there’s no guarantee that they will in the future.
Children
Research on children has been problematic. Recruiting from lower socioeconomic populations selected a preponderance of black children. Some experiments recruited black children exclusively, stigmatized black children, or had racial agendas. To study violent behavior in black children, younger brothers of boys in the probation system were given fenfluramine. That drug had never been tested on children under twelve, and it was known to produce side effects in 90% of adults and to cause heart valve damage in 30%. The rationale for testing it was a presumed correlation between violence and serotonin levels, but there was no such correlation. The study was junk science with many scientific errors. Parents were lured with payments of $100 and children were baited with $25 toy certificates. A study looking for the prevalence of the XYY karyotype (falsely believed to be associated with violence) among black boys lied to participants and suffered from the same glaring logical flaws as the fenfluramine study. Newborns were tested for HIV and positive results were not divulged to the parents, depriving both mother and child of the opportunity for lifesaving treatment. Other experiments bypassed parental consent and got around federal legislation.
Other problems
Washington’s book reveals more problems. The drug BiDil was not approved for general use, so the company used a marketing ploy to get it approved as a special drug for black patients with high blood pressure. AIDS research has jeopardized the health and rights of HIV-positive children in the interests of completing research protocols. A researcher who needed live lice specimens for typhus research got a Boston policeman to arrest a homeless black man and hold him until the researcher could collect his lice. The CIA released infected mosquitoes. Documents were destroyed. Researchers in South Africa sought a deadly virus that would infect only blacks, as well as a virus that would make blacks sterile. There are examples of government-mediated bioterrorism.
Parallels with women
As I read the book, I was constantly reminded of similar prejudices against women. Religious teaching supported discrimination against women; preachers quoted Bible verses as evidence that women were inferior and meant to be subjugated to men. Scientists claimed that women were inherently weaker, less intelligent, less capable of math and science, less ambitious, more neurotic, unsuited to many occupations, etc.
In the Victorian era, women endured a type of slavery. They had no rights, and were considered the property of their husbands. Some Muslim women today are still subjugated to men and have fewer rights; they don’t even have the right to travel without a male guardian. Today, women are still under-represented in many occupations and are often paid less than men.
I am acutely aware of discrimination against women since I experienced it in person in my career as an Air Force doctor and flight surgeon. Because of my sex, I was denied jobs I wanted. I was paid less, because back then women were not authorized to get a dependent allowance for their spouse. I was not authorized to live in base housing. And I worked for a hospital commander who publicly announced that women are not motivated to pursue a career and don’t care about their jobs. I explained all this and more in my book Women Aren’t Supposed to Fly: The Memoirs of a Female Flight Surgeon.
Lessons learned
Washington’s book aimed to reveal the dark history of medical experimentation on black Americans. It did that, but it accomplished much more. It revealed broader problems of racial and socioeconomic inequalities, of poor science, of science pandering to prejudice, of superstitions falsely represented as scientific fact, of failure to submit beliefs to controlled scientific testing, of failures of critical thinking, and of failure of common human decency when it comes to the health and welfare of powerless minorities. We can learn a lot from the book, but will we? My understanding of human nature suggests we will not.

   The Real ID
Mark Crislip
Link
Stein: When we just saw that man, I think it was Mr. [PZ] Myers, talking about how great scientists were, I was thinking to myself the last time any of my relatives saw scientists telling them what to do they were telling them to go to the showers to get gassed.Stein (speaking about the Holocaust): …that was horrifying beyond words, and that’s where science — in my opinion, this is just an opinion — that’s where science leads you.]
Crouch: That’s right.
Stein: … Love of God and compassion and empathy leads you to a very glorious place, and science leads you to killing people.
I am a full time Infectious Disease physician. In the short hand of the medical field, I am an ID doc. Recently, saying I do ID is kind of like having last name like Himmler. No relation, but a vague discomfiture that I might be misrecognized as something else.
My ID, the real ID, along with medicine, is a branch of science (I always hear Mangus Pyke in the Thomas Dolby song when I type the word) with a long history, of, well, saving lives. Lots of lives. Millions and millions of lives. And relieving suffering. The simplest of things have been responsible for the long and reasonably healthy lives we get to have here in the industrialized world.
The Science-Based Medicine Blog deals with what Merlin Mann refers to as first world problems. The fine points of botanicals and prostatism or whether the placebo effect is the cause of the response to acupuncture. Interesting though these topics can be to some, when it comes to the overall health of most of us in the first world the main triumphs of science (Or is Ducks Breath I hear? “I have a masters degree in Science”) occurred over a century or two ago. The science of 200 years ago, by the standards of today, was simple, with simple results, but lead to remarkable advances in longevity and health.
Simple interventions. I always say the three reasons we get to live to be a burden on our children are clean water, good nutrition, vaccines, and antibiotics. And no one expects the Spanish Inquisition. Whether it was 400 years ago or this year, the application of science has saved lives and relieved suffering, or, at least, help us understand, sometimes imperfectly, how best to live a healthy life. And in the future our best chance to survive is through science.
Clean Water
Cholera. Due to the organism Vibrio cholera. It makes a toxin that causes a massive diarrhea. I still doubt the veracity of proponents of transcendental meditation who claim they can levitate. However, that may be possible with the severe diarrhea of cholera. Patients can lose a liter of water an hour and rapidly die of dehydration. Historical mortality rates have been enormous.
Examples of mortality from cholera (From Wikipedia) :
* 1829-1851 – Second cholera pandemic reached Europe, London and Paris in 1832. In London, the disease claimed 6,536 victims; in Paris, 20,000 succumbed (out of a population of 650,000) with about 100,000 deaths in all of France.
* 1849 – Second major outbreak in Paris. In London, it was the worst outbreak in the city’s history, claiming 14,137 lives, over twice as many as the 1832 c outbreak. In 1849 cholera claimed 5,308 lives in the port city of Liverpool, England, and 1,834 in Hull, England.
Cholera spread throughout the Mississippi river system killing over 4,500 in St. Louis, and over 3,000 in New Orleans as well as thousands in New York.
* 1852-1860 – Third cholera pandemic mainly affected Russia, with over a million deaths. In 1853-4, London’s epidemic claimed 10,738 lives.
* 1854 – Outbreak of cholera in Chicago took the lives of 5.5% of the population (about 3,500 people).[19] The Soho outbreak in London ended after removal of the handle of the Broad Street pump by a committee instigated to action by John Snow.[21]
* 1866 – Outbreak in North America. In London, a localized epidemic in the East End claimed 5,596 lives just as London was completing its major sewage and water treatment systems–the East End was not quite complete.
* 1881-1896 – Fifth cholera pandemic ; The 1892 outbreak in Hamburg, Germany was the only major European outbreak; about 8,600 people died in Hamburg
* 1899-1923 – Sixth cholera pandemic had little effect in Europe because of advances in public health, but major Russian cities were particularly hard hit by cholera deaths.
* January 1991 to September 1994 – Outbreak in South America. Beginning in Peru there were 1.04 million identified cases and almost 10,000 deaths.
This small slice of Cholera deaths adds up to 173,749 deaths. Thats only a few cities over a short period of time. Millions have died in Russia, India and China over the centuries from the disease, whose death rates were 25 to 50%.
Cholera is rarely seen in the industrialized world, and mortality rates from the disease are 2-3% with simple, optimized rehydration therapy. Therapy, by the way, that was identified by scientists (5).
Why has cholera faded in much of the world?
“Love of God and compassion and empathy.” I don’t think so. Could it have been………..science (Imagine Church Lady here)?
The science of epidemiology we use today to investigate and identify the cause of Infectious Disease outbreaks started with the Cholera epidemic in London in 1854.
John Snow was a physician who thought that cholera was spread by contaminated water, rather than the by the inhalation of poisonous vapors, the accepted medical opinion of the time. During the outbreak he took the simple (to us) expedient of plotting the deaths from cholera based on where the patients lived. The closer they were to a water pump, the higher the death rates. So what did they do? Offer ” love of God and compassion and empathy?” Nope. They did what I believe is referred to as a scientific experiment. They took off the pump handle and the death rates from cholera fell dramatically. Remember, this was before bacteria were known. Even without knowing about the Vibrio bacillus, the power of the scientific method allowed people to understand disease transmission, make an intervention, and prevent people from dying.
Dr. Snow’s map.
It was the beginning of epidemiology. Applying and expanding the concepts started by Dr. Snow has saved countless lives. Pick a disease. How do we know how it is spread and how to stop the spread? The science of epidemiology. Infections have a wide variety mechanisms of spread: Coughing, sex, mosquito bites, direct contact, blood. Who knows what infection you would get if you did all the above at once. It has been the science of careful epidemiology that has identified the source of these infections and allowed us to break the chain of transmission.
New sources and mechanisms of spread are discovered yearly. There was a recent outbreak investigated by the CDC of norovirus in an elementary school where disease transmission was traced in part to contaminated keyboards and computer mice (6).
When a new epidemic hits, be it avian flu or something unexpected, it will be the science of epidemiology and scientists that will decrease the morbidity and mortality of the disease. It will be science that will be saving lives.
Unfortunately, 1/3 of people still have no access to clean drinking water and an estimated 2 to 5 million people die every year from drinking contaminated water (WHO estimates). At the low estimate, that’s six people every minute. Next time you turn on your tap for a glass of water, say a toast to Dr. Snow for the safe water.
Diet
In the US the problem is excessive nutrition. Occasionally, in the alcoholic, nutritional deficiency is an issue, but in my hospital too much rather than too few calories is the issue.
Good nutrition is important for health, and eating a balanced diet can ensure we get sufficient vitamins to stay healthy. How do we know what vitamins we need? The “Love of God and compassion…………..” I know, I know. I’ll stop. I am sure you get the point.
Vitamin C deficiency leads to scurvy, an unpleasant disease with an unpleasant death. Vitamin C is required to make collagen. Without it you cannot make your supporting tissues and there would be nothing to augment your lips. Your soft tissues fall apart and you bleed and painfully die.
Vitamin C is easy enough to find in the diet: fresh fruits and vegetables are the key.
Tell that to the British Navy. While out at sea conquering the world and making sure the sun never set, their sailors came down with scurvy. Sailing ships, in the era before food preservation, were not noted for having fresh fruits and vegetables on the menu. Think of travel in the 1700′s next time you complain about airline food.
In 1747 James Lind did a simple experiment.
“Lind thought that scurvy was due to putrefaction of the body which could be prevented by acids; that is why he chose to experiment with dietary supplements of acidic quality. In his experiment he divided twelve scorbutic sailors into six groups. They all received the same diet, and in addition group one was given a quart of cider daily, group two twenty-five drops of elixir of vitriol, group three six spoonful of vinegar, group four half a pint of seawater, group five received two oranges and one lemon and the last group a spicy paste plus a drink of barley water. The treatment of group five stopped after six days when they ran out of fruit, but by that time one sailor was fit for duty and the other had almost recovered. Apart from that, only group one also showed some effect of its treatment. (Wikipedia)”
He found out that lemons and oranges (why were the British not referred to as Lemonies or Orangies?) prevented scurvy. Like cholera, he had no understanding of the biology of scurvy, but the power of the scientific method is such that if the experiment is done right, the results can still be meaningful. It was the first randomized controlled study in history. But it started medical science down the path of increasingly complex and sophisticated clinical studies to tease out the effects of therapies on diseases.
The importance of good nutrition and vitamins is well established, the uselessness of extra therapeutic doses (aka supplements), especially when used as antioxidants, is increasingly being established.
A recent JAMA (1) looked at
“5442 women who were US health professionals aged 42 years or older, with either a history of CVD or 3 or more coronary risk factors, were enrolled in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial to receive a combination pill containing folic acid, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12 or a matching placebo, and were treated for 7.3 years from April 1998 through July 2005.” to see if they had a reduction in cardiovascular events.
A wee bit more complicated than Lind’s study. The results?
“After 7.3 years of treatment and follow-up, a combination pill of folic acid, vitamin B6, and vitamin B12 did not reduce a combined end point of total cardiovascular events among high-risk women, despite significant homocysteine lowering.”
When used as antioxidants, these vitamins did not alter rates of stroke and heart attack, a result supported by Cochran reviews (2). So if you are taking vitamins as an antioxidant, you can stop. But do not come after my beer or chocolate, although future studies may show their uselessness as antioxidants and I will be forced to enjoy them only for the pleasure they provide.
Vaccines
Smallpox. Bad disease. And it was only a ‘’small’ pox. Like evolution is only a ‘theory’. 20-60% of people who contracted smallpox died. It has killed millions upon millions since it came into human populations around 10,000 BC.
Smallpox killed an estimated 400,000 Europeans each year during the 18th century. That’s 45 people an hour, every hour, for 100 years.
During the 20th century, it is estimated that smallpox killed 300–500 million people. That one disease killed more than twice the number of people killed in wars during the same time (7). In 1967, the World Health Organization estimated that smallpox killed two million people.
That’s just a small sample of the mortality from small pox, from times and places where the data has been available. In most places, through most of of time, millions died unknown and unregistered.
Smallpox is almost gone now, existing in few freezers and, given that we know the genome, can be reconstructed anytime. I guess those scientists may kill us all in the future after all.
We don’t have smallpox because of vaccines.
It started with the simple experiment by Jenner in 1796. He noted that people who developed cowpox did not get smallpox. So he took the fluid from the lesion of a milkmaid with cowpox and infected the most courageous man in history, a farmer named Phipps, who developed cowpox. Then a few weeks later he repeated the process with smallpox. Jenner must have been one convincing talker to get Mr. Phipps to take the smallpox. Jenner later went into multilevel marketing and Farmer Phipps did not get smallpox.
At one time I would have said that this study would not have passed an Institutional Review Board as ethical, but after reading the blog entries here on the Gonzales pancreatic cancer trial at Columbia University, I bet it could have been done at Columbia as long as it was funded by NCCAM.
The number of vaccines keep on growing and continue to decrease morbidity and mortality from communicable illnesses. There are many factors that contribute to spread and deaths from infection, like good nutrition and good hygiene. But do not underestimate the benefit of vaccines. A recent JAMA looked at the effects of vaccines on mortality and morbidity in the US
“…before and after widespread implementation of national vaccine recommendations for 13 vaccine-preventable diseases for which recommendations were in place prior to 2005. A greater than 92% decline in cases and a 99% or greater decline in deaths due to diseases prevented by vaccines recommended before 1980 were shown for diphtheria, mumps, pertussis, and tetanus. Endemic transmission of poliovirus and measles and rubella viruses has been eliminated in the United States; smallpox has been eradicated worldwide. Declines were 80% or greater for cases and deaths of most vaccine-preventable diseases targeted since 1980 including hepatitis A, acute hepatitis B, Hib, and varicella. Declines in cases and deaths of invasive S pneumoniae were 34% and 25%, respectively. (3)”
A. Maze. Ing.
It is incomprehensible the number of people who have gone on to live long lives thanks to vaccines. The most recent vaccine is the HPV, which will prevent death from cervical and throat cancer.
If the past predicts the future, and in infectious diseases it often does, if we cannot eradicate a disease it will return. There will be anther influenza pandemic like 1918 -1919 that killed about 6% of the world, about 10x what were killed in the trenches of WWI in 4 years.
And when it comes our best hope for preventing disease will be an effective vaccine.
Clean water. Good nutrition. Vaccines.
A few of the benefits that science has given us that will allow most of us to grow old enough to be screwed by Medicare.
As an aside, it should be noted that these basic foundations of science-based medicine were simple experiments. If you look over the history of science, all the basic studies that set the fields in motion were simple, but well done, studies that can easily be reproduced by high school or grade school students. Or even 10 year olds.
Simple experiments. After all the millions sent down the rathole of alternative medicine by the NCCAM, there has yet to be a single, clear cut study that demonstrates the plausibility of the science behind their interventions or a single clear cut study to show efficacy.
However a 10 year old, with a simple study, can show that the underlying premise of Therapeutic Touch, that human energy fields can be felt and manipulated, is nonsense (4). Maybe the NACCM needs some smart 10 year olds to devise some simple experiments for them.
So when I hear Ben Stein, a Columbia (Hmmmm. Columbia again. Is a pattern emerging?) educated lawyer, I think, no way is he that stupid. No one can be that willfully ignorant.
Then it hit me when I read “http://scienceblogs.com/evolutionblog/2008/05/what_i_really_think.php”
It’s obvious. Stein is doing performance art. It’s a put on. He is pulling a Borat. He is the Sacha Baron Cohen of the Intelligent Design crowd.
It is the ONLY possible explanation.
You wait. Someday the truth will be known about Ben Stein and we will all laugh at being taken in by his elaborate hoax.
References
(1) Effect of Folic Acid and B Vitamins on Risk of Cardiovascular Events and Total Mortality Among Women at High Risk for Cardiovascular Disease: A Randomized Trial. Christine M. Albert; Nancy R. Cook; J. Michael Gaziano; Elaine Zaharris; Jean MacFadyen; Eleanor Danielson; Julie E. Buring; JoAnn E. MansonJAMA. 2008;299(17):2027-2036.
(2) Bjelakovic G, Nikolova D, Gluud LL, Simonetti RG, Gluud C. Antioxidant supplements for prevention of mortality in healthy participants and patients with various diseases. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2008, Issue 2. Art. No.: CD007176. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD007176
(3) Historical Comparisons of Morbidity and Mortality for Vaccine-Preventable Diseases in the United StatesSandra W. Roush, MT, MPH; Trudy V. Murphy, MD; and the Vaccine-Preventable Disease Table Working GroupJAMA. 2007;298(18):2155-2163.
(4) A Close Look at Therapeutic Touch. Linda Rosa, BSN, RN; Emily Rosa; Larry Sarner; Stephen Barrett, MD. JAMA. 1998;279:1005-1010.
(5) Amylase-Resistant Starch plus Oral Rehydration Solution for Cholera NEJ, Volume 342:308-313 February 3, 2000 Number 5
(6) Norovirus Outbreak in an Elementary School — District of Columbia, February 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5651a2.htm
Deaths from war are subject to wide variations. My source: http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/warstat8.htm

Alternative Microbiology
Mark Crislip on November 1, 2013
Link
A man of science rises ever, in seeking truth; and if he never finds it in its wholeness, he discovers nevertheless very significant fragments; and these fragments of universal truth are precisely what constitutes science.
~ Claude Bernard.
I almost never have to search for material for this blog. The Secret always seems to provide topics. Subject matter appears unbidden out of the ether. But not this week. I enjoy deconstructing the nonsense of SCAM papers or blog entries more than any other type of blog entry. Perhaps the glee that last week’s entry provided had to be countered by some kind of cosmic balancing mechanism. Although the rational part of my mind objects to the personification of random existence, I suppose the Universe just does not want me to have that much fun two entries in a row. Probably explains why I have a viral URI and my brain has slowed almost to the point of functional inactivity. There is no shortage of SCAMs to write about, they are just not created equal in their ability to generate a passionate rant.
I am, as you know if you are regular reader, an infectious disease (ID) doctor. I find the field endlessly fascinating as ID reaches into all aspects of the human condition. I remember when I was driving from Minneapolis to LA in 1986 for my fellowship, Petersdorf wrote his (in)famous article that ID was a dying profession and soon, thanks to antibiotics, vaccines and other advances, infections would become a problem of the past. Fortunately for me, and unfortunately for thousands of people, that prediction has not come to pass although we are sliding slowly into the post-antibiotic era where soon I will be able to diagnose but not treat disease.
Infections have always been a major cause of human morbidity and mortality. Through most of human history, infections, trauma and starvation were the primary ways by which humans died. Tremendous amounts of work by thousands of people have elucidated many of the factors that increase the risk of infection. There are 1,213,762 citations on the PubMeds if you search for ‘infection’. Medicine has pushed infectious diseases to the edge of society. Compared to the past, most outpatient infections are trivial or easily treated. TB, malaria yellow fever, smallpox, measles, typhoid fever etc. etc. no longer commonly plague those in the developed world.
With the understanding of the life cycle of diseases, how they are spread, good nutrition, vaccination, flush toilets and a reasonably safe food supply we do not get infected at the rates that occurred in the bad old days. Infections do happen, sometimes for good reasons, sometimes for no reason at all, and with just enough frequency to keep me gainfully employed, although as I have whined about in the past, my consult volumes have declined about 50% this century as we have learned how to prevent many infections that once made up much of my practice.
We have an incredible understanding of the microbial pathogens that try to kill us and that will, someday unless we are cremated, consume us all. There is so much we understand about the microbial world and its interactions with us that it always flabbers my gaster to run across alternative microbiology: the many realty-free and somewhat incoherent frameworks that deny germs, our understanding of microbiology or have discovered their own unique understanding of the pathogenicity of various organisms. Rather than my usual detailed deconstruction of a single idea or topic, today will be a birds-eye overview, a compendium of microbiologic weirdness as seen through the fog of interferon.
I came across a peculiar book, The Genesis of Germs by Dr. Alan Gillen (the doctorate, ironically enough, in science education; like last week’s computer science degree, evidently the ‘science’ part was thought superfluous) a professor of biology at Liberty University. From my understanding, life on earth is old, billions of years old, and germs result from slow evolution over time. I never really had a sense of that time until I read John McPhee’s Annals of the Former World. Dr. Gillen has an alternative explanation for germs and infectious diseases.
I knew of intelligent design mostly in the context of the battles over the teaching of evolution in the schools several years ago, but I never paid it much mind professionally. ID is often understood as applied evolution. It may be the bacterial resistance or the human response to disease, but evolution has left its footprints all over my subspecialty. I suspect there are more variations in the human genome as a response to infections than any other process.
What is odd from Gillen’s textbook is that he starts from the premise that the world is about 6,000 years old, that evolution is not true and that intelligent design explains the world, then Gillen creatively interprets microbiology to fit these preconceived ideas. Why do we have germs and infection? Original sin.
It was not until after sin entered the world that some micro-organisms became pathogenic, or harmful, to man. One explanation is that the good bacteria began to deteriorate or degenerate into pathogenic bacteria. Genomic decay is one of the most likely theories for explaining the origin of bacterial pathogenicity….When a bacterium degenerates it loses valuable information and must find other sources to survive. Bacteria generally are made as one cell; as they lose information from their genetic hardware they consequently can no longer produce their own needed materials to synthesize their cell parts. And so, as they lack information they have to gain that information from some other creature (an animal or a person) and in doing so they cause disease symptoms.
Somehow I do not think that is a conceptual framework that will result in a deeper understanding of disease pathogenesis and treatment. Solutions to the next pandemic are unlikely to be forthcoming from the biology graduates of Liberty University. As we slowly slide into the post antibiotic era I am not sanguine that his approach of belief in scripture and Jesus leading to an end of germs and infectious disease, is likely to help me treat the next patient with a multi-drug resistant E. coli infection.
I know we have been writing on this topic for years but it remains remarkable how huge amounts of information can be ignored or creatively interpreted if they do not fit pre-existing beliefs. Does refining ones facts lead to opinion or does opinion lead to your understanding of the facts? My career, now in its 30th year, has been one of constant reassessment of my understanding of infectious diseases as new information appears with a change in my practice as a result. The old saying is half of what you learn in medical school will be eventually proven wrong, but the problem is you don’t know which half. It must be nice not having to worry about pesky facts or having to change your mind.
We have pro-SCAM commenters who come and go at the blog, but they all have a common characteristic: they do not change their mind because of facts. The pattern is consistent: they make errors of fact and those errors are corrected, but the pro-SCAM commenter never admits they were in error, nor do they have a change of opinion as a result of new information; they move on to other errors in fact. I suspect all the information about germs that contradict Dr. Gillen’s understanding of infection as a fall from grace 6,000 years ago cannot and will not be incorporated into a better understanding of infectious diseases. And I am glad the Dr. Gillen’s of the world, who advocate for a “biblical or creation perspective on disease”, are not in charge of the CDC.
The first cases of AIDS were reported when I was in medical school. AIDS has gone from a curiosity of unknown cause to a plague that filled my hospitals with sick and dying young men to an often-manageable chronic illness. It has been rare to see a death due to HIV this century; so much better compared to the 6 months from diagnosis to dead we used to see. It is amazing what has been learned about HIV and its complications and I would point out that none of the increase in survival we have seen has been due in any way to alternative medicines of any kind, for HIV or any disease. Science-based medicine delivers.
Germs don’t cause disease: if they did, we’d all be dead.
Yet there are those that still deny that HIV leads to AIDS. Last year I heard Peter H. Duesberg deliver a Gish Gallop on this opinion, contrary to a positively enormous scientific literature, that HIV does not cause AIDS but instead is due to drugs and sexual promiscuity. He may be the most prominent of the AIDS deniers. As I mentioned in the past, reality is a honey badger, it don’t care what your opinion is. You can deny the importance of HIV and convene a panel, as did the President of South Africa with Dr. Duesberg a member and support policies that HIV is not responsible for AIDS and promote alternative therapies. The result? Death.
Once that battle was lost in the courts and in the political arena, the Health Minister, Tshabalala-Msimang, continued to portray ARVs as ‘poison’ and to support alternative untested therapies. Demographic modelling suggests that if the national government had used ARVs for prevention and treatment at the same rate as the Western Cape (which defied national policy on ARVs), then about 171,000 HIV infections and 343,000 deaths could have been prevented between 1999 and 2007.
That is a remarkable record and a depressing result of denying reality. Not just HIV, there is still a contingent of people who deny germs cause disease, which to my mind is akin to denying that water is wet.
We do not catch diseases. We build them. We have to eat, drink, think, and feel them into existence. We work hard at developing our diseases. We must work just as hard at restoring health. The presence of germs does not constitute the presence of a disease. Bacteria are scavengers of nature…they reduce dead tissue to its smallest element. Germs or bacteria have no influence, whatsoever, on live cells. Germs or microbes flourish as scavengers at the site of disease. They are just living on the unprocessed metabolic waste and diseased, malnourished, nonresistant tissue in the first place. They are not the cause of the disease, any more than flies and maggots cause garbage.
You can always tell a germ denier as they spread the lie that Pasteur recanted on his death bed that bacteria cause disease. He actual final words were “I cannot” in response to being offer a glass of milk, although I suspect he spoke in French. He was right when he said “Messieurs, c’est les microbes qui auront le dernier mot (Gentlemen, it is the microbes who will have the last word)”. I hope my last words will be directed at my brother: “touched you last”. Like he will let me even on my death bed.
The real mystery—one that deeply intrigued me 25 years ago—is that so many therapies that totally disagree with one another manage to bring results. Ayurveda isn’t qigong; yoga isn’t Reiki; none of them is a placebo. Yet somehow healing exists, and the channel it takes can be quite unexpected and inexplicable.
~ D. Chopra
It is no mystery to me; they are all nonsense. But for every SCAM there is an equal and opposite SCAM. For every homeopathic nostrum there is a megadose therapy. And for every germ denier there is a proponent that all diseases or symptoms are due to infections. It is true of all interesting diseases, however.
Hulda Clark was of the opinion that all cancers and other diseases were due to Fasciolopsis buski, the liver fluke, and that HIV was due to the same pathogen.
If (Fasciolopsis) establishes itself in the thymus, it causes HIV/AIDS!
There is Candida and Lyme, both allegedly causing the same list of symptoms. How to tell the difference between the two? I have Lyme, given that only Lyme has the symptom of “Decreased ability to spell correctly.” Or the imaginary infection of Morgellons. Or the Marshall Protocol, which hypothesizes, among other things, that autoimmune illnesses are perpetuated by bacterial colonies in biofilms and that promoting vitamin D deficiency is the treatment. You know there is something wrong with an alternative treatment if even Dr. Mercola finds fault with it.
So many different ways to ignore the real, complex, and interesting fields of microbiology and infectious diseases. New microbiology, ignoring microbiology, new diseases and life cycles for existing organisms. A rich fantasy world.
Despisers of their fellows: They make poor observations, because they choose among the results of their experiments only what suits their object, neglecting whatever is unrelated to it and carefully setting aside everything which might tend toward the idea they wish to combat.
~Claude Bernard.

Your terrain, your fault? Germ Theory Denial 2025
Terrain theory is making a comeback, offering the illusion that illness is always preventable, and blaming the sick for being sick.
Scott Gavura onJ uly 17, 2025
Link
Image: This is typical of the type of marketing you’ll see for terrain theory.
Two weeks ago I reflected on an old but still relevant blog post by Peter Lipson titled Your Disease, Your Fault. His argument was simple but compelling: Alternative medicine often frames illness as personal failure. Today, that same sentiment is gaining more traction than I would have thought possible, but with new names and in new contexts. Terrain theory is making a comeback, rebranded with terms like “body sovereignty” and “internal terrain”.
According to terrain theory, germs don’t cause disease – it’s your body’s failure to maintain internal purity. If you’re healthy enough, pathogens can’t hurt you. It’s an idea with roots in reality, but goes well beyond the science of disease: terrain theory proponents ignore biology, chance, and social determinants of health. You can see terrain theory beliefs in the statements and worldview of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has publicly rejected germ theory. He is an open proponent of miasma theory, an obsolete 19th century idea that attributed disease to “bad air,” poor hygiene, and moral weakness. With major changes underway in health care in the United States, it’s worth taking a closer look at the language, the rhetoric, and the science.
Germ Theory vs. Terrain Theory: How One Prevailed
The germ theory of disease is foundational to modern medicine, but it wasn’t always this way. In the 19th century, two competing theories offered different explanations for why people got sick. Louis Pasteur argued that disease was caused by microbes – external pathogens, like bacteria and viruses that could invade the body and cause illness. This is germ theory. Antoine Béchamp proposed an alternative. He argued the real culprit was the “terrain”, the body’s internal environment. Béchamp’s terrain theory emphasized the importance of the body’s internal environment, suggesting that disease arises when the body’s “terrain” was weakened by poor nutrition, toxins, or stress. Only then would microbes (normally harmless) cause harm. In the Béchamp model, germs are not the issue – they are a symptom of a terrain issue.
The debate between Pasteur and Béchamp was fierce, but in the end, Pasteur’s germ theory prevailed for a simple reason: it produced dramatic results. Once scientists could link specific microbes to specific diseases, medicine was transformed. Public health measures like sanitation, sterilization, and vaccination became not just possible, but profoundly effective. Antibiotics transformed once-deadly infections into treatable conditions. Smallpox was eradicated (regardless of anyone’s “terrain”) and polio has been nearly eliminated. Childhood mortality rates dropped dramatically. Infection control became the backbone of modern surgery and hospital care. Pasteur’s model didn’t just explain disease, it led to the tools that could prevent, treat or even eliminate it. It’s worth noting that germ theory wasn’t solely the work of one man. English surgeon Joseph Lister and German physician Robert Koch are also credited for the development and acceptance of the theory.
Terrain theory, on the other hand, didn’t lead to any effective interventions. It wasn’t testable in the same way. Its vagueness made it sound plausible, but hard to act on. And while Pasteur is often quoted as accepting the importance of terrain on his deathbed, this appears more like a posthumous attempt to validate Béchamp’s ideas, than a serious statement. Even if Pasteur did make the statement, the science speaks for itself. Reality is not based on what one person says: it is based on objective evidence.
Béchamp’s ideas, while discredited, never really disappeared. Like many beliefs in alternative medicine, terrain theory beliefs didn’t arise from scientific evidence. For that reason, it’s effectively immune to being disproven by it. To be fair, modern proponents of terrain-like thinking may not even know the term “terrain theory” or the name Antoine Béchamp. But the core belief, that all disease can be avoided with the right habits, and that immunity is strictly personal, rather than something important to a population, is gaining traction.
Terrain Theory in Disguise: Recent Sightings
You might be asking why I’m arguing there’s a resurgence of “terrain theory” when that phrase itself is rarely mentioned. But once you start looking for it, you’ll spot it everywhere: The idea that a “clean” balanced internal environment prevents all disease – is everywhere.
Terrain theory underpins the raw milk movement, where the risks of pathogens are downplayed or dismissed outright because it’s believed that the healthy body can handle it. You’ll also see terrain theory in the claims that “healthy kids don’t need vaccines,” or that “food should be your medicine.” And all the detoxification, cleanses, dietary supplements, coffee enemas and IV infusions of vitamins – all are grounded in this idea that you can optimize health and eliminate the risk of disease simply by cleansing yourself from the inside out.
I’ve also recently discussed the tech-adjacent forms of terrain theory. Biohacking influencers are using glucose monitors and wearables to “promote Good Energy” and optimize your health. The vocabulary has expanded, but the unstated premise is the same: if you manage your body and its internal environment just right, you’ll be immune to external threats and illness.
Notably, terrain theory appeals to a desire for control and agency. This can be compelling to those that may be confused about how to live a healthy lifestyle, or facing a life-threatening diagnosis. And to be clear, some of what terrain theory proponents endorse may be reasonable, and even science-based. Maintaining a healthy lifestyle with a good diet, enough sleep, and regular exercise while managing your weight and not smoking can reduce your risk of chronic illness. But buying in too much to terrain theory, and discounting or dismissing germ theory has a darker implication: If you do get sick, it’s your fault. Terrain theory takes prevention and turns it into an all-encompassing worldview—one where infectious disease, chronic illness, even cancer are preventable through willpower and “clean” living.
This isn’t just bad science. Terrain theory belief creates a framework or worldview for looking at health that shifts blame for sickness on to the sick.
Body Sovereignty and the Language of Control
The idea of “body sovereignty” has gained traction over the past few years. I first heard the term when the COVID-19 vaccines were launched, and mandates were introduced. While it may sound like a simple argument for autonomy over one’s own body, when you listen to the rhetoric, it’s being used to argue against public health measures, deny science, and even reframe medical consensus and guidance as acts of oppression.
Body sovereignty accompanies terrain theory. If your internal “terrain” is all that matters for health, then external interventions—like vaccines, antibiotics, or even public health measures like fluoride in the water aren’t just unnecessary, they’re viewed as violations of your autonomy and your freedom. Public health is therefore seen as coercive: there is no need for community measures, as individuals are responsible for their own health.
This framing co-opts the language of bodily autonomy and repurposes it to reject social responsibility. “My body, my choice” becomes a rallying cry not for reproductive rights, but against vaccination. “Informed consent” becomes “misinformed refusal“, a justification for rejecting evidence-based therapies. And “health freedom” has long been a slogan for anti-vaccine activists and wellness influencers selling detoxes, supplements, and other treatments not actually shown to work. As RFK Jr. puts it,
“I’m a freedom-of-choice person…We should have transparency. We should have informed choice, and if people don’t want it, the government shouldn’t force them to do it”
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
With a terrain theory worldview, health, and particularly public health is no longer something we need support as a society—it’s something you earn through your virtuous choices and lifestyle, or you forfeit health based on the decisions you made.
Conclusion: Germ Theory Still Matters
Terrain theory doesn’t just reject evidence: it rejects uncertainty. And in doing so, it offers an illusion of control: Live life purely and holistically, and you can avoid illness. But reality is messier. Disease can strike even the healthy. Through acknowledging the reality of germ theory, we’re also accepting a necessary truth: some aspects of our health are beyond individual control.
Germ theory gave us something terrain theory couldn’t deliver: effective, lifesaving interventions like vaccination, antibiotics, sterilization and sanitation – together they have saved many millions of lives and are cornerstones of medicine.
Healthy living matters too. Diet, sleep, physical activity, and avoiding tobacco reduce the risk of many illnesses. But when taken to extremes, which terrain theory encourages, it can lead to pseudoscience, stigmatize the sick, and undermine the public health systems and interventions that meaningfully contribute to a healthy society.
    • 

   The Marshall Protocol
Mark Crislip
Link
While there are many taxonomies of alternative medicines, one thing almost all alternative therapies have in common is they are originally the de novo discovery of one lone individual. Working outside of the mainstream, they are the gadflies who see farther because those around them are midgets.
Hanneman conceives of homeopathy, the treatment of all disease.
Palmer conceives the cause of all disease and its treatment in chiropractic
Mikao Usui, while having a mid-life crisis, conceives Reiki.
Virgin births all. These pioneers boldly go where no man has gone before.
Others have been less acclaimed after seeking out new life. An example is Virginia Livingston, MD, the discoverer of the cause of all cancer (1). She discovered a bacterium, the cause of cancer, she called Progenitor cryptocides, which, unfortunately only she could grow. Her therapies include an autogenous ‘vaccine” made from your own urine, which will probably preclude widespread use even in alternative therapies circles. I wonder if Jenny would object to vaccines if there were naturally derived from the patients urine?
Discovering a new form of pathogenic microbiology that no one else can see or grow is not uncommon, since people seem to be unable to recognise artifact on slides, be it Oscillococcinum being seen by Joseph Roy 200 years ago or Virginia Livingston in the 1960’s. Sometimes I regret the discovery of H. pylori as a cause of gastritis as it gives the alternative microbiologists a medical Galileo to point at. H. pylori is used as an example, erroneously, of a bacteria causing disease that was laughed at by the medical establishment (Parenthetically, as my flawed memory has it, while I was an Infectious Disease Fellow the data for H. pylori came trickling in. I remember discussing the papers with one of my attendings who was an expert in GI infections. We all thought is was an interesting hypothesis and waited further data with interest. I cannot remember anyone dismissing the idea out of hand with derisive laughter. But then, I remain convinced that infections are the cause of all disease, at least the diseases that matter).
A letter from a reader lead me another lone reseacher who has discovered the cause and treatment of many, if not all, diseases. So may I introduce to you, Trevor Marshall, the developer of the Marshall Protocol. (As I have said many time, I want something in medicine named after me, and it is not the glove breaking during an exam. “Damn, I just had a Crislip. I need to go and clean my nails.” If Swan or Groshong can get some silly little catheter named after them, well, I should be good for some eponym). You have not heard of Trevor Marshall? Often the fate of originality is to languish in obscurity.
The Marshall Protocol has all the characteristics of modern alternative therapy: a single discoverer, a hitherto undiscovered biology, an unproven therapeutic intervention and one of the most aggravating issues in alternative medicines: Taking a scientific truth the size of a molehill and transmogrifying it into a Cascade Range of exaggerated disease etiology and treatment. Unlike most alternaive proponents, however, as best as I can tell Dr Marshall does not seem to be in the business of making a business from his discovery, although he does have patent applications for his protocol.
Dr Marshall is a PhD in electrical engineering and was diagnosed years ago with sarcoidosis. It was his diagnosis with what is often a fatal disease that lead to his insights into diseases. One cannot help but think of Linus Pauling and his vitamin C epiphany after almost dying of kidney failure. Staring into the eyes of your own mortality almost always leads to personal epiphanies. Most people learn to appreciate the little things in life they had hitherto ignored. Others aim higher.
Sarcoid is an interesting disease whose etiology is unknown but is characterized by non-caseating granulomas. Granulomas are an immunologic response to infections, often fungal or mycobacterial, and I will not be surprised if some day an infectious cause of sarcoid is discovered. Same, I will bet, for Crohns, another disease of uncertain origin that has granulomas. For as of today, no definite infection has been found to cause sarcoid or Crohns.
However, Dr. Marshall was intrigued by studies that demonstrated Rickettsia DNA in two patients with sarcoid and by the fact that his disease was worsened by sunlight. He then developed an hypothesis, unproven, but interesting, as to the cause of many chronic illnesses. And from there he developed a protocol to treat diseases.
Marshall suggests that autoimmune diseases are due to a correctable defect in innate immunity from a dysregulation of vitamin D. This immunologic defect allows L-form (cell wall deficient) bacteria, to proliferate. In an interview he points to ‘bacteria” on electron micrographs that are living happily in white cells. How does he know they are bacteria 100 times smaller than usual? Can he grow them? No. It appears that they are bacteria because, well, they look like bacteria. To him. Not to me. But underlying all of the diseases treated by the Marshall protoall are due to colonies of
“intraphagocytic, metagenomic microbiota… The term intraphagocytic refers to the fact that these bacteria have developed the ability to remain alive and proliferate undetected inside the cytoplasm of the cells they infect. These cells include macrophages, the very cells of the immune system that the body uses to kill invading pathogens…The term metagenomic indicates that there is a tremendous number of different species of these chronic bacterial forms. Finally, the term microbiota refers to the fact that these bacteria are also hypothesized to sustain themselves by grouping into communities called biofilms. The bacteria inside a biofilm produce a protective matrix that allows them to more effectively evade the immune system and develop resistance to antibiotics.”
It is nice that at least they use the term hypothesis, although redundant, should also include the adjectives untested and unproven.
He refers to these infections as TH-1 infections, “after T-helper Type 1 (Th1) immune response. The T-helper Type 1 (Th1) immune response is usually defined as one which generates significant quantities of the cytokine Interferon-gamma (3).” The Th1 is the humoral immune system, Th2 is the B cell, or antibody wing of the immune system. Many infections are attacked with both Th1 and Th2 and to call pathogens Th1 is false dichotomy and a term only used by Dr. Marshall et. al. It does sound nice and sciency, although no one in the closed minded field of infectious diseases has ever used the term Th-1 infections around me that I can remember.
These bacteria then interfere with the vitamin D receptor to shut down the immunologic modulation of vitamin D.
“Recent molecular modeling research (which has been confirmed by a large amount of clinical data) has shown that levels of 25-D over 20 ng/ml can bind and inactivate the VDR, which subsequently shuts down the innate immune system. Certain species of bacteria also produce substances that can bind and inactivate the VDR in a manner similar to 25-D. Consequently, people who are infected with the Th1 pathogens and consuming vitamin D are no longer able to produce the AMPs or turn on the innate immune response. This allows their bacteria to proliferate and spread. (5)”
Bacteria and Vitamin D act together to shut down the immune system and the bacteria take off.
Vitamin D is an important immunomodulator and a pubmed search will reveal an a growing and interesting literature that vitamin D deficiency, increases, note increases, the risk of a variety of infections. There is a concomitant SCAM literature to suggest that all you need to treat influenza and other infections is to increase your vitamin D intake. As found in the Weekly World er, I mean, the Natural News, taking vitamin D helps treat or prevents cancer, stroke, psoriasis, schizophrenia, and depression (8). Who are you gonna believe? One (or both) of these approaches should be wrong, although I suppose that influenza is a Th-2 pathogen and as such doesn’t count.
From this untested hypothesis, there is a therapy.
1) Kill the bacteria with long term (years) of antibiotics like doxycycline like minocycline. This is to eradicate the supposed L forms found in the granuloma. Unfortunately, the L forms, or even pathogens, have not yet been discovered in most of the diseases treated by the Marshall Protocol. And when bacteria have been found in rheumatoid arthritis or sarcoidosis, the studies have not been replicated, which is most annoying.
2) Use of angiotensin receptor antagonists. They recommend olmesartan which is said to be able able to bind to and activate the vitamin d receptor and block vitamin D effects.
This has never been shown to occur either in the test tube or in humans or animals. The data to support this, and please read it slowly so it sinks in, is based on a computer model (3). Computer simulations, not experiments. As the FDA has said “The FDA-approved prescribing information for Valsartan states “Valsartan does not bind to or block other hormone receptors or ion channels known to be important in cardiovascular regulation (3).” Again, as a closed minded arrogant tool of the medical industrial complex, I worry about going straight from computer models to treating patients. Wouldn’t do it with an airplane, wouldn’t do it with a medication.
3) Avoid vitamin D. This is interesting. Vitamin D does more than build strong bones and has wide ranging effects on immune regulation. Given the growing literature demonstrating the a deficiency of vitamin D increases risks for a variety of infections, from viral to tuberculosis, I am uncertain of the wisdom of suggesting this intervention without supporting clinical trials. I would worry more if there is a history of osteoporosis in the family.
Some collagen vascular diseases, like lupus, worsen as vitamin d levels decline. Multiple sclerosis is improved with vitamin D. A recent review suggests “Epidemiological evidence indicates a significant association between vitamin D deficiency and an increased incidence of several autoimmune diseases (4).”
Sarcoid has dysregulation of vitamin D with increased levels in the blood, the vitamin D being made in the granulomas. Maybe avoiding vitamin D in sarcoid is not completely without reason, but I would not extrapolate to other diseases that have nothing in common except for unproven Th-1 pathogens.
Generally speaking the problem for patients, especially in the northern latitudes, are diseases made worse by vitamin D deficiencies.
What diseases are treated with this protocol?
“Th1 inflammatory diseases and symptoms currently being treated with the Marshall Protocol include:
ALS (Lou Gehrig’s), Ankylosing Spondylitis, Asperger’s, Back pain, Barrett’s esophagus, Bipolar disorder, Candidiasis, Cardiac Arrythmia, Celiac disease, CFS / CFIDS / ME, Chronic Lyme/Borreliosis, Crohn’s Disease, Diabetes insipidus, Diabetes type I, Diabetes type II, Dementia, Depression, Epilepsy, FM (Fibromyalgia), Gastroesophageal reflux disease, Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis, IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome), Interstitial cystitis (IC), Inflammatory bowel disease, Irritable bowel syndrome, Kidney stones, Lofgren’s syndrome, Lupus In ‘Overlap’ With Other Connective Tissue Diseases, Mania, MCS (Multiple Chemical Sensitivity), Migraine headache, Morgellon’s, Multiple Sclerosis, Myasthenia gravis, Neuropathy, OCD(Obsessive Compulsive Disorder), Osteoarthritis, Panic attacks, Parkinsons, Pervasive Developmental Disorders- Not Otherwise Specified, POTS (Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome), Prostatitis, Psoriasis, Psoriatic arthritis, Raynaud’s syndrome/phenomenon, Reactive Arthritis (Reiter Syndrome), Restless leg syndrome, RSD (Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy), Rheumatoid Arthritis, Sarcoidosis, Scleroderma, Sinusitis, Seasonal affective disease (SAD), Sjogren’s, Ulcerative colitis, Uveitis, Vertigo , Other Th1 diseases which should respond to the Marshall Protocol: Alzheimer’s, Anorexia Nervosa, Bulbous pemphigus, Cystic fibrosis, Macular degeneration, Polymyalgia rhuematica, Polymyositis, Schizophrenia (5)”
That’s a good list. Back pain, mania, osteoarthritis, vertigo, and kidney stones all have the same pathogenesis and treatment. I went to medical school for what? And it is good to see a treatment for Morgellon’s.
And there may be no end to diseases that could fall to the Marshall protocoll:
“I disagree that Th1 patients each have different illnesses. I have seen no data to confirm this. Everything I see is that all the Th1 diagnoses spring from a common pathogenesis, a special adaptation of intra-phagocytic bacteria which allows them to evade phagocytosis by stimulating a Th1 response in the parasitized phagocytes.
“I personally believe that ALL the Th1 diseases result from the same bacterial pathogenesis. This belief is grounded in my understanding of how the bacteria directly drive the phagocytic biochemistry, causing the Th1 cytokine release.
“IMO, it is important for everybody to stop thinking about these Th1 syndromes as being separate and discrete diagnoses. IMO, all Th1 illness has a common pathogenesis, only the mix of symptoms varies from person to person, depending on bacterial species present, and the sequence of infection/coinfection.
“We are not all different. Th1 disease overrides ALL the issues of diet, location, exposure to pathogens, etc. (My bold) We can see that by standing back and looking at ALL the folks on the Marshall Protocol. There are more similarities than differences, and it does not help recovery to focus on perceived differences. (7)”
So what do I make of the Marshall Protocal?
Unproven. Based of hypothesis that are almost certainly not true. Potentially harmful if it induces side effects from unneeded antibiotic uses or, more worrisome, from vitamin deficiency.
Notes
(1) http://www.rense.com/general72/cancer.htm
(2) Waterhouse, J.; Perez, T.; Albert, P.; “VDR Receptor Competence Induces recovery from Chronic Autoimmune Disease.” 6th International Congress on Autoimmunity. Porto, Portugal. 2008 Sept 10-14. Retrieved 2008-12-31 from http://AutoimmunityResearch.org/transcripts/ICA2008_Transcript_TomPerez.pdf
(3) http://www.tbiomed.com/content/3/1/1#IDA0SVWF
(4) Nat Clin Pract Rheumatol. 2008 Aug;4(8):404-12. Control of autoimmune diseases by the vitamin D endocrine system.
(5) http://www.marshallprotocol.com/forum32/1263.html
(6) http://www.marshallprotocol.com/forum2/1071.html
(7) http://www.marshallprotocol.com/forum32/1263.html
(8) http://www.naturalnews.com/003069.html

   The Microbial Metagenome
Mark Crislip
Link
First some background. I was first directed to the Marshall protocol by a reader who wondered about the information the found on the web. So I went to the web and looked at the available information, much as any patient would, and discussed what I found there.
I have subsequently been lead to believe that none of the information on the website http://www.marshallprotocol.com can be considered up to date or accurate. As as result of, I have told that my post is chockablock with errors, although, outside of writing doxycycline where I should have put minocycline, I am left in the dark as to exactly what my errors are. I am told that it is my responsibility to locate the errors in the last post, yet I can find none when compared to the website.
However, to remedy the deficiency of having reviewed inaccurate and out of date material, I have been sent 6 articles that I am informed represent the state of the art in understanding the science behind the Marshall protocol. Ah, the peer reviewed medical literature. An opportunity to carefully read and critique new ideas. It is one of the reasons people publish: to see if their ideas can withstand the scrutiny of others.
Several of these papers concern Vitamin D, the Vitamin D receptor, and olmesartan which I will review, perhaps, another time. I don’t find them a compelling read, but it not an area about which I have more than a standard medical knowledge. The other papers concern the role of infection in autoimmune diseases, which I will discuss here. It is easier as an infectious disease doctor to read this literature as I am, as least as far as the American Board on Internal Medicine is concerned, a specialist in the field. Alternatively, I am a closed minded tool of the medical industrial complex who only seeks to push his own twisted, narrow agenda at the expense of suffering patients (1). We can’t all be perfect.
The main article, which was published in July of this year, is “Autoimmune disease in the era of the metagenome (2)” will be discussed along with several (2, 3) references that are, as of the writing of this post, not yet published. For the clarity, footnotes in ‘()’ are mine, footnotes in ‘[]” are from the referenced material. I added any bold face type.
The article starts with an interesting sentence.
“According to the NIH, a mere 10% of the cells that comprise the organism known as Homo sapiens are human cells. The remaining 90% are bacterial in origin. Thus, Homo sapiens is best described as a superorganism in which a large number of different organisms coexist as one (1).”
That is certainly a curious way to think about the microbial ecosystem we carry around with us. It is true that there are 10 to 100 times more bacteria on us than there are cells that make us up (for the sake of clarity, bacteria on the skin and in the GI tract I will refer to as on us even though from one perspective the bacteria in our gastrointestinal tract are in us. Prepositions can be imprecise. But the GI tract is contiguous with the environment, so I will use the word on. To be in us, the bacteria will have had to breech the cells that line us and be in the blood, the cytoplasm, the nucleus, the interstitial spaces, etc.).
We are covered in bacteria and carry a complex ecosystem that we are just beginning to understand and of which we can grow or, by molecular techniques, identify a minority. However those cells are not us. While we do have some interaction with these bacteria, they are not the cells that make us. It would be the same as saying that the cells of the fleas on a dog are part of what constitutes a dog or the cells of a monkey in a tree are part of what constitutes a tree. There is self, and there is not-self, and our bacteria are not-self. Our genome is what we pass on to our children with reproduction. So the opening sentence does not inspire confidence in the authors understanding of what constitutes being human. From my understanding of human-microbial interaction the opening sentence is wrong.
“Medicine is now comfortable with the bacterial populations that exist in the gut and areas of the body in contact with the external environment, such as the mouth, ears, nose and skin. Yet, components of the human microbiota also likely persist in many other body tissues, including those which become inflamed in autoimmune disease [5] (1).”
Reference 5 is a video of a lecture of one of the authors which is a keynote address summarizing the ideas found in the articles discussed here. You evaluate a review by the quality of the arguments and the quality of the referenced material. It has more credence if the information is based on first class, reproduced research in high impact journals. Linking to your own lectures? Well, no so much. I should put up YouTube video of me reading this blog and link to it as proof of the assertions in this entry as I suppose an on line video constitutes now constitutes valid, scholarly reference material. See. It’s on the interwebs, so it must be true.
What they appears to be saying is the complex microbiology found on us is also to be be found in us, in our cells and tissues, and are involved in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases. We shall see.
They continue with
“Such bacteria can persist inside the very cells of the immune system that are supposed to kill them [6], or in bioﬁlm communities in which they are protected from the immune response by a self-created polymeric matrix [7].”
The reference in regards to persisting bacteria is scanning electron microscopy (EM) of white cells in three patients with eye disease and the alleged pathogens were never shown as living organisms nor have the findings of the paper ever been reproduced or verified by others. Dr. Witosko, the author of reference 6, published a number of studies in the 1980′s where he found what he considered to be mycoplasms in several diseases, the proof of an infection being based on EM and response to antibiotics. Unfortunately since that time, his findings have not been confirmed by other researchers. Searching Pubmed for mycoplasms and uveitis, sarcoid, Crohn’s and JRA yield next to nothing. If the primary references to support your hypothesis, at least the ones that are not internet videos, are one off’s, never reproduced or verified, then the foundation upon which your are building your argument may be less than solid.
Bacteria can persist for short times in phagocytic cells during acute infections. However, extrapolating from this paper to bacteria living for years in phagocytes for the lifetime of the patient with an autoimmune disease is a leap across the Grand Canyon of medical hypothesis. Biofilms are important in persisting infections associated with prosthetic material and osteomyelitis but the role of biofilms in other diseases not associated with inert material is uncertain.
So they are building an argument for disease pathogenesis, based in large part on examples and parallel, for infections due to colonies of as of yet undiscovered organisms that evade the immune system and live in biofilms.
Because some organisms cannot be isolated, ours exist and cannot be isolated.
Because some organisms can evade the immune system, ours evade the immune system.
Because some organisms live in biofilms, ours live in biofilms.
The next paragraph concerns the easy exchange of bacterial DNA and how calling an organism E. coli may by old fashioned. I am sympathetic to this view of bacteria, because at one level, given their ability to exchange and utilize DNA, bacteria are a metagenome and our classification of bacteria can be imprecise. I tend to think of bacterial identification as probability functions rather than an absolute characteristic. They are fuzzy, and not in a good way.
“Due to their small size, hundreds, or even thousands, of bacterial cells can ﬁt inside a human cell [6]. The combined genetic contributions of these microbes inevitably provide myriad gene products not encoded by our own relatively small genomes. This means that the human genome is only one of the many genomes that affect Homo sapiens function. In reality, the organism we call Homo sapiens is controlled by a metagenome, a tremendous number of different genomes working in parallel. “
Sorry, this seems ludicrous to me. Sure. We have covered with millions of bacterial genes and in some places there is an ongoing interaction between the bacteria and us. But to suggest that these genes in bacteria are part of our genes and controlling us is an unwarranted extrapolation and, in my understanding, more science fiction than science fact. And just because thousands of bacteria could fit into a cell it doesn’t mean they do. One would think, given the last 50 years of light and other forms of microscopy and the ongoing search for infectious etiologies of most autoimmune diseases (a search that keeps coming up negative) that someone, some time, would have noticed huge numbers of bacteria stuffed into cells. And that such findings would be easily reproduced by others. Curiously, that hasn’t happened. So if the bacteria don’t seem to fit, we must acquit…. sorry for that one.
Then another odd example:
“Bacterial gene products can be very similar to our own. For example, the metabolism of glucose-6-phosphate by both the human body and E.coli is nearly identical, so that remarkably similar metabolites are produced by both species [11]. With this in mind, the interaction between an E.coli genome and the human genome, as they exchange nutrition and toxins, increases the complexity of transcription and translation for both species.”
Thanks to evolution, we do share many common metabolic pathways with many bacteria; it is why some antibiotics will affect human cells and some anticancer drugs will affect bacteria. However, the role of the interaction of bacterial metabolic products, out side of locally, is currently speculative in disease. They then mention that in a test tube system that probiotic bacteria grown in skim milk make enzymes that inhibit angiotensin 1 converting enzyme. How this is relevant to human systems requires another huge leap. It is always a question whether test tube examples have clinical relevance. In this case, unlikely, as we are not skim milk and the bacterial strains in probiotics are usually different than the strains found in us. Possible, but I would not generate a treatment plan based on it.
The authors then give examples of how two genes are altered by bacteria in the test tube: one up regulated, one down regulated. No argument here. When infected the body responds in a variety of ways. Genes get up regulated and down regulated. It is always a question whether these test tube phenomena are of clinical relevance or if they are lost in the complex human metabolic system. Often these effects are the equivalent of tossing a rock in the Oregon ocean and to increase the size of the waves in Hawaii. The effects are too small to be noticed, butterflies and hurricanes not withstanding.
Then the move on to capnine:
“Created by the gliding bacteria that are present in bioﬁlm, the sulfonolipid Capnine provides a speciﬁc example of how a bacterial metabolite could manipulate human gene expression in order to dramatically alter the progression of autoimmune and other chronic diseases.Capnine has the capacity to disrupt transcription by the VDR, one of the body’s most proliﬁc nuclear receptors [15].”
Note could, not does. And the proof? The reference is from a paper that is from computer modeling of the interaction of capnine and the VDR. Again with the computer modeling. No real data to show an interaction of this molecule and the VDR. No data to show that this molecule has ever been found outside of biofilm where it could have pharmacologic effects. Going from computer modeling to disease pathogenesis and treatment is another huge stretch. As a clinician I am not impressed. Computer models are interesting but have to be compared to that pesky reality before they can be taken seriously. It is a shame that one cannot jump straight from the computer model to real life, as I would love a computer model that would makes me a Powerball winner.
“Thus, if Capnine was deregulating the VDR, it would greatly hamper the innate immune response. VDR dysfunction would cause the active vitamin D metabolite 1,25-D to rise to excessively high levels where it could inhibit expression by the bulk of the body’s other nuclear receptors -including alpha thyroid, the glucocorticoid receptor, and the androgen receptor [20]. This would result in hormonal imbalances and also interfere with expression of the dozens of other AmPs expressed by these receptors. In vivo, the microbiota appears to gradually shut down the innate immune response over a person’s lifetime, resulting in the increased accumulation of chronic bacteria and other pathogens [21]. “
If wishes were horses, Beggars would ride: If turnips were watches, I would wear one by my side. If capnine was pathogenic, Bacteria would more than glide.
All an unproven speculation presented as fact, all following from could and if. There is no in vitro or in vivo data to suggest that capnine is involved in anything but the production of biofilms. Reference 21 leads to a speculative review that will be discussed later, not original research. But none of this is based on original research in real biologic systems. The shutting down of the immune system by bacteria, while stated as fact, is yet more unproven speculation.
“Eventually, genes from the accumulating microbial metagenome may determine a clinical disease symptomatology such as an autoimmune diagnosis, or simply drive the inﬂammation associated with the aches and pains of aging [5]. This accumulation is an extremely logical evolutionary survival mechanism. Components of the human microbiome have evolved to dysregulate the VDR receptor that would otherwise activate a potent immune response against its presence.”
No. Most bacteria in our microbial metagenome are simply not pathogenic and lack the capacity to invade and cause disease. Bacteria need to have the capacity to cause disease, and most do not. They live outside of us, on us, and in symbiosis with us. Even if you wipe out most of the immune system with chemotherapy or AIDS and patients become ill with their own bacteria invading, the number of pathogens in these patients is limited relative to the number of bacteria they have. Of our thousand bacterial species, I only have to worry about a couple dozen. Of the millions of microbial species in the world, less than a thousand have the ability to infect humans. Most bacteria simply can’t cause disease. They do not need to have evolved to dysregulate the Vitamin D receptor to survive. Unless, of course, they are forming large, unseen, intracellular colonies, which as best as I can tell, they do not.
“As Royston Goodacre comments in Journal of Nutrition, we are born with a genome that, aside from the genes of species that can survive in the womb and endometrium [22], is largely human. But we inevitably die with a genome that is at least 90% bacteria.”
Nonsense. The genome that is on us is not the genome that is in us. Our genome, what makes us human, is what we pass on with reproduction and those genes are most certainly not bacterial in origin. I suppose under this paradigm, that if you were to drown in a sewage pit, then you would die with an even greater genome.
They move on to discuss antibody production as a result of infection with the metagenome.
“Yet now that Homo sapiens is understood to be the product of multiple genomes, it is equally possible that the antibodies observed in autoimmune disease result from alteration of human genes and gene products by the bacterial metagenome.”
If we take one unsupported hypothesis as true then anther unsupported hypothesis is equally true. We are not the product of multiple genomes, that is hyperbole. But if you repeat something frequently enough, maybe it will be considered true despite a lack of evidence. Works for politicians. Are they saying that the metagenome alters our genes to cause disease? That the bacteria lead to genetic mutations? They are not talking natural selection here.
They are saying that the DNA is altered by the bacteria. News to me, and, if true, leads to a new understanding of disease pathophysiology. It is only “equally possible,” although I would classify that speculation as extremely unlikely.
Next is a discussion of how the bacterial flora varies in time and in location and as a result the products of that bacterial flora will change with time. No argument here, the ongoing ebb and flow of out bacterial flora is just beginning to be elucidated. How this alters disease manifestation is hinted at in the text, but I infer that different microbiota in people will lead to different autoimmune diseases. Which would be good excuse for the not finding a consistent pathogen causing a given disease in each patient. Each patient has a different microbial metagenome causing their sarcoid or RA or whatever disease is present. I admit to being wedded to the idea that one bug causes one disease. For over a century that concept, at the core of Koch’s postulates (5), have helped to discover the cause of everything from AIDS to Zygomycetes. If inference is true, it may make the pathophysiology espoused in this paper unable to be tested or falsified. It would also make the it impossible to isolate the infecting organisms and test it to see what is the optimal antibiotic to be used to kill it. A clinician could never say that the patient DIDN’T have a disease, which is often important information to give a patient.
Then they move on to where and how the microbiota cause disease:
“Persistent bacteria including Francisella tularensis [25], Mycobacterium tuberculosis [26], Rickettsia massiliae [27], Brucella spp. [28], Listeria monocytogenes [29], Salmonella typhimurium [30] and others, use a variety of mechanisms to evade the immune response and survive inside macrophages and other phagocytic cells.”
It is the rare pathogen that survives, usually for a relatively short time, in the cytoplasm of cells. Eventually it either kills the host in relatively short order or is cured. Chronic infection of cells is not the norm of these organisms, although extracellular persistent infections can occur. As will be discussed later, it is postulated that cell wall deficient organisms persist in the cytoplasm to cause autoimmune disease. What is curious about the organisms above is that is the mechanisms by which these organisms evade the immune system are often part of, well, er, the cell wall. Often what allows bacteria to evade the immune system and survive intracellularly is due to constituents on the cell wall and I would suppose that cell wall deficient organisms would lack that mechanism.
“Furthermore, various species of bacteria have been detected inside the cells of patients with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis [31],sarcoidosis [6], and other inflammatory diseases [32].”
The search for a reproducible infection in these and other autoimmune diseases continues and I will not be surprised if one day one or more microbes are found at the center of a sarcoid granuloma. Or in a JRA joint. But the consistent, reproducible demonstration of an infectious agent in any of these autoimmune diseases is still pending. When they discover an infectious cause of some of these autoimmune diseases, it will probably be one lone organism, not a colony. If it takes a village of bacteria to cause a metropolis of diseases, that would be a novel pathophysiology.
“This suggests that disease-causing microbiota largely persist in the cytoplasm of nucleated cells, where it has access to both the DNA transcription and protein translation machinery of Homo sapiens. “
Really? It does? If so, where are they? Colonies of bacteria should be seen by light or electron microscopy and yet for 100 years these bacteria have evaded detection. Romulan cloaking technology is probably beyond their capacity. It might be suggested, but it has never been noticed. There are the occasional reports of quasi bacterial products found in the cells on EM, never reproduced, never confirmed by alternative techniques. Just where are they in all the specimens in all the pathology labs all over the world? It should be easy enough to find the microbiota, should they not?
“Microorganisms are also capable of integrating their DNA with our own [36]. This results in alteration of the human DNA by the microbiota over time, potentially leading to genetic mutations associated with autoimmune diagnoses. Genetic haplotypes observed in autoimmune disease frequently have very low statistical significance, as would be expected based on knowledge that the metabolome varies from population to population and individual to individual. In addition, host DNA repair mechanisms are susceptible to modification by the products of the metabolome. In fact, bacteria may hijack DNA repair mechanisms to generate genetic diversity without losing genomic stability [37, 38].”
The microorganisms referred to is a herpes virus, and there are a few viruses, herpes and retrovirus, that can insert its DNA into ours. The paper refers to bacteria as the constituents of the microbiota and then they switch to a virus and do not bother to mention it. That is disingenuous at best and misleading to anyone who did not bother to go to the footnotes. This kind of scholarship is not reassuring to the reader. However, higher organisms (bacteria, mycoplasma etc) do not put their DNA into ours. There is zero data to suggest that the accumulation of bacterial DNA in humans accounts for autoimmune disease. This is stated as if it were fact, when it is closer to science fiction. Reference 37 is in an insect and reference 39 is computer modeling. Quite a leap from a bug and a PC to the cause of human disease.
So what do we have?
Humans have in them colonies of unseen and undiscovered bacteria that persist undetected in the cytoplasm and alter our genome in ways as of yet proven to suppresses the immune system by way of uncharacterized and unproven metabolites interacting with the Vitamin D receptor to cause a wide variety of autoimmune diseases ranging from sarcoid to diabetes. Hey, I’m convinced. Nothing like lots of speculation and extrapolation from primary sources that are poor in quality and never reproduced or validated by alternative lines of data, and are unsupported by primary in vivo or in vitro studies.
Maybe the reader can see why I am less than enamored of the validity of the pathophysiology noted above. I read dozens of papers a month to keep up in my field. This one is not going to rank high of the compelling review list.
So how does that translate into treating infections? For that we must turn to “Reversing Bacteria-Induced Vitamin D Receptor Dysfunction is Key to Autoimmune Disease. (2)”, which is in press. Sorry. I have a copy and you do not.
Here is the basic hypothesis from the introduction:
“An intraphagocytic bacterial microbiota is proposed to be the primary cause of VDR dysfunction. Because the VDR is key to the innate immune response, its dysfunction would lead to chronic infections with a wide range of pathogens, leading to inflammation and frequent elevation in autoimmune disease markers.”
The first part of the article is a review of the same issue discussed above. Intracytoplamsic colonization of colonies of bacteria make products that interfere with the VDR. No new data, no primary research, many of the same references. I am again going to focus on the infectious disease aspect of the paper, rather than the vitamin D.
“The use of pulsed, subinhibitory, bacteriostatic antibiotics is an important part of this approach. Research indicates that most standard antibiotic protocols used so far to treat chronic inflammatory diseases are ineffective, and so new ways of using antibiotics are called for to deal with the relative treatment resistance of the bacteria involved.”
I read this and my jaw dropped. I promised myself not to be snotty when I evaluated these papers, but such statements really do deserve ridicule. Maybe they are ineffective because the disease do not have infectious etiology? Maybe? The new ways of giving antibiotics? Dose them so that they cannot be effective.
In the practice of infectious diseases when patients do not respond to therapy, there can be a multitude of reasons for the failure. One is that the patient does not have an infection. Another is that the organism is resistant to the antibiotics being used. In the context of the e pathophysiology of the paper, what they say is that since standard antibiotics at standard doses do not work, they will give the same antibiotic, but dosed intermittently and in small amounts, or in such a way that it should have no effect on the infecting organism.
Your infection is not getting better, so we will continue the antibiotic that is not working, but we will give you less of it. That would only make sense to a homeopath but if I were to treat infections this way we would have no shortage of cases for morgue conference. However, novel infections get novel therapies, right?
That’s assuming that bacteria are involved, which as we have noted, while interesting, is far from proved. Antibiotics are presumed not to work against the bacteria in autoimmune disease as the bacteria are cell wall deficient and the antibiotics are dosed too high.
The first part I understand. If there are indeed L forms persisting in the cytoplasm, which have never been demonstrated definitively in autoimmune diseases, then cell wall active agents will not work. Which is why the tetracycline class (minocycline) and macrolides are used against these bugs.
There is a long history in infectious disease of the concept of the minimal inhibition concentration. It takes many more than one antibiotic molecule to inhibit an organism. How many depends on the antibiotic and the organism, but is takes hundreds of antibiotic molecules to have an effect on a bacterium. If you fall below the MIC, the organism still grows, although perhaps more slowly. Using subtherapeutic concentrations of antibiotics are the quick and easy way to develop resistance to the antibiotics. What doesn’t kill it makes it stronger. Currently for most infections you give maximal dose for as short a period of time to maximize killing and minimize the development of resistance. The opposite of what is suggested in this paper. Of course I am biased by 60 years of the successful treatment of infectious diseases and am stuck in my ways.
“The survival of “persister” cells when constant dosages are used means that pulsed antibiotics are likely to be more effective.[18] The ability of bacteriostatic antibiotics to be effective at low dosage levels has been documented.[37]“
To date, there is not an infection treated with pulsed antibiotics. Intermittent antibiotics helps breed resistance. Reference 37 does not concern the ability of low doses of antibiotics to be effective against bacteria, it is an article about the effect on antibiotics on the phagocytosis of bacteria, the ability of cells to ingest bacteria. In the context of the paper, this appears to be a misrepresentation of primary sources. Since the alleged bacteria in autoimmune disease are already intracellular, one wonders about the relevance of this reference as it applies to the use of antibiotics as proposed in this paper.
“The existence of communities of multiple bacterial species, like those occurring in biofilms, means that combinations of antibiotics are likely to be necessary to fully target all species. Thus, there is increasing support for the use of pulsed, low dosages of combinations o bacteriostatic antibiotics.”
Where are these biofilms? In the cells? Extracellular? Never quite certain where the biofilm is in the context of autoimmune diseases. Where are the multiple bacterial species? One does not necessarily need multiple antibiotics just because there are multiple species of bacteria. Often the judicious and rational use of antibiotics allows one to kill multiple organisms with one antibiotic. Rather than delaying the development of resistance in bacteria (bacteria, not mycobacteria, so do not use Tb as an example of why I am wrong), multiply antibiotics may intensify the evolutionary pressure on bacteria to become resistant. There is no support outside the extrapolations of this paper for the use of pulsed, low dose combination antibiotics in any disease that I treat (and cure) for a living.
“The waxing and waning of symptoms that typically follows each of the pulsed antibiotic doses supports the model’s contention that bacteria are involved in autoimmune disease. The fact that these immunopathological responses decline over time, as the patient improves during treatment, provides evidence of disease reversal.”
This is the most risible statement in the paper. An equally unjustified conclusion from a similar paper:
“Perez showed that 81% of a group of 54 patients representing 20 different autoimmune diagnoses reported continual improvement after treatment durations of 18-53 months with aVDR agonist and antibiotics – further pointing to bacteria as a causative agent in autoimmune disease.[21] (4)”
Here is the reasoning: we dose antibiotics in a manner that should have no effect on bacteria (pulsed and subinhbitory).
We therefore conclude that because the ineffectively dosed antibiotics are having an effect, the diseases have an infectious etiology.
That’s a clinical paradox that would shut down an M-5 multitronic unit.
I emphasize with the residents that unless you have firm evidence of infection (culture, serology, PCR etc), response to therapy is not a good way to prove an infectious disease etiology. If they were to make such a suggestion, I would pat them on the head, smile patronizingly and point out that there are four solutions to an alleged antibiotic response:
The patient improved because they had in infection that responded to antibiotics.
The patient improved because they had a self limited infection and the antibiotics did nothing. Treating a viral pneumonia with ampicillin as an example.
The patient improved because they had a non infectious disease and the antibiotics did nothing. They received antibiotics for their stasis changes in their legs misdiagnosed as cellulitis but responded to elevation.
The patient improved because they had a non infectious disease that responded to the antibiotics.
It is the last that makes the treatment success problematic to prove. I used to think that the immunomodulatory effects of antibiotics and other agents were too minor to be of clinical importance. Now I am not so sure. The association of NSAID use and the development of group A streptococcus necrotizing fascitis and the possible decreased mortality with infections in patients who are on statins are non-antibiotic examples of possibly clinically relevant effects of minor immunomodulation.
Both the tetracycline and the macrolide classes of antibiotics are immunomodulatory, and several recent studies have demonstrated decreased mortality for infections resistant to macrolides that are treated with adjunctive macrolides. An animal model suggests that the decrease in mortality from macolides is due to a decrease in cytokines. The minor immunomodulatory effects may, much to my surprise, be clinically relevant.
So assuming that tetracycline and macrolide antibiotics are indeed effective in decreasing the symptoms of autoimmune diseases, in the absence of a well defined infection, you cannot know for sure of the result is from the antimicrobial drug treating an infection or the result of an immunomodulatory drug altering immune function. I bet, since they are dosed at levels to low to be effective against bacteria, that it is the latter that will be the mechanism of action, if, indeed, they are demonstrated in clinical trials to be effective.
“Diseases responding to treatment include systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, scleroderma, Sjogren’s syndrome, autoimmune thyroid disease, psoriasis, ankylosing spondylitis, Reiter’s syndrome, type I and II diabetes mellitus and uveitis8 and sarcoidosis. [3] Fibromyalgia, though not generally established as an autoimmune disease, has also responded favorably to this approach.”
If there is a recurrent theme in this blog, it is the difficulty of assigning causality to therapeutic interventions, especially when the underlying treatment has no or unproven biologic plausibility. The acupuncturists say their interventions are effective and that chi exists because of anecdotes of efficacy and poorly controlled studies. Yet when rigorous trials are done, acupuncture is no better than twirling toothpicks on the skin. The plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data. With diseases that can naturally wax and wane there is always a question of true causality with anecdotal information. Until you do a placebo controlled trial, anecdotal evidence may be interesting but is not definitive.
So perhaps you can see why, as an infectious disease doctor, I am less than convinced about the infectious diseases component of the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases as presented in these papers.
No reproducible, credible evidence that colonies of organisms and their biofilms exist inside of human cells.
No evidence outside of in silico (I love that term. It means computer modeling, but suggests parallel validity with in vivo and in vitro) data to suggest that bacteria make molecules to alter the VDR to suppress immune function.
No controlled trials to suggest that patients are having a response to the antibiotics due its antimicrobial, rather than immunomodulatory, effects. 
Antibiotics are used in a manner that has a long history of being ineffective and aids in the development of resistance.
Lots of extrapolation, hypothesis and anecdote. To me it is all, as Shakespeare might say, all sound and fury, signifying nothing.
All aspects of the pathophysiology are amenable to testing, so I could easily be proven wrong. I can easily imagine a clinical trial that would prove or disprove the therapies independent of the theory behind it. It could be that they have the right therapeutic idea for all the wrong reasons. It wouldn’t be the first time in medicine. Take a well defined population of sarcoid or another illness. 4 treatment groups: 2 placebos, one placebo plus antibiotics, one placebo plus olmesartan and both antibiotics and olmesartan. Everyone blinded. It also makes me wonder: what research would the proponents consider valid in falsifying the pathyphysiology and treatment in the Marshall protocol?
Much is made by the fact that these articles are peer reviewed. After reading the papers closely, what peers and what they were reviewing, I am uncertain. Perhaps spelling and punctuation? They didn’t pay a whole lot of critical attention to the arguments or the references. Certainly, peer reviewed does not mean true; much of the published literature in medicine is subsequently shown to be incorrect. It is good to have speculative ideas published, it drives innovation. To use speculative ideas as the basis of a complex treatment protocol is not, to mind, the safe and prudent practice of medicine. I have in my mind a factoid, and I am not sure where I read it, it so it may be in error, that if you have no data to support a therapeutic intervention, the odds are you will do more harm than good. I heard that, I think, as a resident almost 25 years ago and could be misremembering, but I am sure the commentators will set me straight.
“It should be noted that the immunopathological reactions resulting from this approach are sometimes strong enough to be life-threatening in patients with more advanced disease.[3]“
It is good to note that you may be killing people with an intervention. The ethics of almost killing people with unproven treatments is problematic. The ethical guidelines for doing research are found in the Declaration of Helsinki, I will quote from the Wikpedia summary, which I sure will lead to derision.
“Research should be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific background (Article 11), a careful assessment of risks and benefits (Articles 16, 17), have a reasonable likelihood of benefit to the population studied (Article 19) and be conducted by suitably trained investigators (Article 15) using approved protocols, subject to independent ethical review and oversight by a properly convened committee (Article 13). The protocol should address the ethical issues and indicate that it is in compliance with the Declaration (Article 14). Studies should be discontinued if the available information indicates that the original considerations are no longer satisfied (Article 17). Information regarding the study should be publicly available (Article 16). Ethical publications extend to publication of the results and consideration of any potential conflict of interest (Article 27). Experimental investigations should always be compared against the best methods, but under certain circumstances a placebo or no treatment group may be utilized (Article 29). The interests of the subject after the study is completed should be part of the overall ethical assessment, including assuring their access to the best proven care (Article 30). Wherever possible unproven methods should be tested in the context of research where there is reasonable belief of possible benefit (Article 32).”
I am not so certain that these (nonbinding) guidelines are being adhered to. But if you are almost killing people, it really behooves the proponents to subject the therapies to careful clinical trials to make sure the potential for death is worth the benefit.
Which brings us to China, an internationally recognized center of human rights and ethics. A press release has noted that the Marshall protocol is to be used in the biggest hospital in China. Bigger, of course, is always synonymous with quality. What is being done in China is not clear: a clinic to make money and turn out more anecdotes? Like the fake stem cell clinics? Or is a protocol finally to be put to the test with a placebo control blinded trial in a well defined patient population. If the former, well, I can go to Mexico for a cheaper alternative. If the latter, I look forward to eating my words when a well done clinical trial demonstrates the efficacy of the Marshall protocol.
References
(1) For the record, I have not talked to a drug rep not accepted anything, not even pizza at a conference, for over 25 years. I am, however, the Head of the Vitamin D subcommittee of the trilateral commission.
(2) Autoimmune disease in the era of the metagenome
Amy D. Proal, Paul J. Albert, Trevor G. Marshall
Autoimmunity Reviews. Jul;8(8):677-81. Epub 2009 Feb 13.
(3) Reversing Bacteria-Induced Vitamin D Receptor Dysfunction is Key to Autoimmune Disease
Joyce C. Waterhouse, Thomas H. Perez, Paul J. Albert, 
in press.
(4) Dysregulation of the Vitamin D Nuclear Receptor may contribute to the higher prevalence of some autoimmune diseases in women
Amy D. Proal, Paul J. Albert, Trevor G. Marshall, 
in press.
(5) From Wikipedia
Koch’s postulates are:
1. The microorganism must be found in abundance in all organisms suffering from the disease, but should not be found in healthy animals.
2. The microorganism must be isolated from a diseased organism and grown in pure culture.
3. The cultured microorganism should cause disease when introduced into a healthy organism.
4. The microorganism must be reisolated from the inoculated, diseased experimental host and identified as being identical to the original specific causative agent.
There are ethical and practical limitations to these postulates, but they serve as a reasonable starting point for determining causality.

   Live Blood Analysis: The Modern Auguries
Mark Crislip
Link
I saw a patient last week who was self referred. He had been seeing a DC/ND for a variety of symptoms that turned out to be asthma. Not that the DC/ND made that diagnosis. His DC/ND diagnosed him with an infection, based on live blood analysis, and offered the patient a colonic detox as a cure. My patient thought he should get a second opinion before he submitted to a cleansing enema, always a good policy
Live blood analysis to diagnose an infection. I had never heard of the technique, but thanks to the google and the interwebs, I was soon immersed in the field.
In live blood analysis, the “physician” takes a drop of the patients blood and examines it under a high power phase contrast or a darkfield microscope. Changes in the constituents of the blood are noted and linked to a variety of ills.
It is an impressive and expensive system: microscopes and various support equipment start at around $5000 (3). However, live blood analysis has the opportunity to be lucrative in the right hands as the patient often gets weekly analysis to see how the interventions (usually supplements sold by the blood analyst) are working. Evidently in the hands of a skilled snake oil salesman, an income of $100,000 a year to more can be generated (8).
Live blood analysis is one of these alternative methodologies that has a hint of legitimacy that is extrapolated far out of proportion to its validity.
Phase contrast and darkfield microscopes are used in medicine, in my world primarily to look for syphilis. As a rule, most pathologic changes in the blood are best seen when various stains are applied to the blood sample. Most commonly a Wright”s stain is used on blood cells, because many diagnostic features are invisible on phase contrast. There are many different stains used in the pathology laboratory to help identify what you are observing under the microscope. Using different stains on microbial specimens can help categorize organisms before they can grow. It is not either-or, both phase contrast and other modalities are used in clinical medicine. More practical clinical information is derived from light microscopy on stained specimens.
An evaluation of the cells of the blood can give hints to the presence or cause of many diseases, from vitamin deficiencies to infection to leukemia. The CBC (complete blood count) with or without a differential (the types of cells seen) is part of any initial evaluation of ill patients.
With live blood analysis, practitioners take the seed of truth that the evaluation of the blood constituents can give valuable information and grow a forrest of fantasy and magic. It is something to behold.
Besides live blood, some practitioners also practice dry blood analysis, where they examine clot to look for patterns that are allegedly indicative of diseases.
Let’s evaluate each diagnosis made on live blood analysis. Note the key feature of each alleged diagnosis. The problem lies in diet, and supplements are the solution to the problem, which, it just so happens, are sold by the live blood analyst. Curious that while I am alleged to be a shill of big pharma, I do not get dime one from any supplements or other products sold in my office because I don’t sell stuff to my patients. Any alternative provider who makes part of their living from selling supplements has far more conflict of interest than most physicians.
Someone may argue that I am an Infectious Disease doctor, what do I know about blood analysis. I also showed these photographs to a hematopathologist and a hematologist. It was refreshing how they laughed and laughed and laughed at the descriptions I showed them of live blood analysis.
Live blood analysis evidently began with Gunther Enderlein at the turn of the last century. He was in the Bechamp school of disease etiology and his concepts are unintelligible in the context of modern biology and physiology. Enderlein placed blood under a darkflield microscope and interpreted the artifacts he saw as quasi-life forms, which he called protits, symbionts or endobionts, that could transform into pathogens (11). Only Live Blood analysts can see these forms. As one site says “Enderlein’s “Endobiont” only had meanings to dark field microscopists following his teaching (10).” There is large inter-operator variability in analyzing live blood and no two live blood analysts see the same pathologic changes on the same slide (7). Live blood analysis is the N-Ray of microscopy.
Overtime live blood analysis expanded to include multiple diet related diagnosis, and is sometimes called nutritional blood analysis, the better, I suppose, to sell expensive supplements.
Here is where I apologize.
It appears that copyright laws prevent me from showing specific examples to blood analysis, so I add the link instead. Lots of clicking back and forth, I know, but I do respect intellectual property, although to apply the word “intellectual” to live blood analysis is akin to calling a naturopath a doctor. Lets say I respect their property. These photographs are widely reproduced on the net, but I am uncertain as to who, if anyone, owns the copyright, so I will be careful. There is evidently one lawyer for every 265 Americans.
Rouleau (http://www.healthsystem.virginia.edu/internet/hematology/HessEDD/BenignHematologicDisorders/redbloodcelldisorders/rouleaux.cfm)
In real medicine rouleau is an anomaly seen with paraproteinemias such as multiple myeloma. The extra proteins in the blood alter the charge on red cells, causing them to stack like coins.
In the world of live blood analysis, the are more causes:
“Often poor protein digestion. The pancreas may be off. Excess dietary protein, poor assimilation. Eating too much animal protein. Blood too toxic (altered blood pH) from stress, coffee, cigarettes, meat, etc. Dehydration, not drinking enough water (2).” None of these issues is known to cause rouleau formation. However, it you have multiple myeloma and you see a live blood analyst, the chance of having a serious and important diagnosis misdiagnosed and incorrectly treated is high.
Other photos here: http://healthenlightenment.com/live-blood-cell-analysis.shtml
RBC Aggregation http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“The loss of the negative surface charge; this is a more disorganizing symptom where plasma acids act as molecular glue, causing RBCs to stick together (0).”
The “Live Blood Analysis Diploma Course (1)” says it is due to “ingestion of high fat meals, high blood cholesterol levels, and blood fat chemistry imbalances.”
No. That is not the cause of red cell aggregation outside of Dr. Young, the acid maven. There are no plasma acids that act as a molecular glue. Diet does not make red cells stick together, unless you dine on Elmer’s.
Protein Linkage http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Over acidity and blood pH imbalance. The diet is high in strong acids from proteins and carbohydrates. (0)” Perhaps “digestive insufficiency, excess protein consumption, imbalanced electrolytes, and inability to assimilate lipids or toxicity (1). ” A pathologic finding due to an excess and an insufficiency.
This is a made up nonsense. Blood pH is constant at 7.4 and varies not at all except under severe metabolic derangements like diabetic ketoacidosis and sepsis.
Macrocytes, Microcytes http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Ingestion of an excessive amount of over acidic food and drinks which causes a deficiency of sodium bicarbonate in the alkalophile glands (4).”
Macrocytes are most often due to B12 or folate deficiency, although there are other causes like AZT and hypothyroidism. Microcytes are most often due to iron deficiency and can be a marker of bowel cancer. Microcytes and macrocytes on a smear can represent serious underlying diseases, but are not due to “a deficiency of sodium bicarbonate in the alkalophile glands. ” Missing the real cause of these abnormalities could prove fatal, which, with their erroneous understanding of blood cell morphology, live blood analysts would be prone to do.
Echinocytes http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Latent tissue acidosis in the extra cellular fluid and the body’s inability to remove acid waste build up in the blood causing the cells to break down (0).”
No, latent tissue acidosis is not the cause of echinocytes. These are pathologic and a marker of liver disease.
Fibrous Thallus http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Indicates a nationalization of bacteria, yeast/fungus, mold, and their acid wastes and acid crystals lying in a dormant/inactive state (0).” Sounds worrisome. Biomedx says “The presence of large numbers of protoplast structures in peripheral blood is an unfavorable sign. Some authors propose they are a collection of progenitor cryptocides (Livingston-Wheeler). Progenitor meaning existing across millennia at the beginning, cryptocides meaning cellular killer. Protoplasts are thought to be related with infectious disease or neoplastic activity and or L-form bacteria. They are thought to be viral in origin (5).” Try as I might, I cannot understand what any of this means.
When you look at the photograph, what is seen is artifact of the slide, not a constituent of blood. Schmutz. Slides are not pristine and stray bits of cloth, cells and environmental dirt is common on the cells. A skilled microscopist understands the difference between artifact and real pathology. The patient, however, does not, and if I were not knowledgeable about cellular morphology I would be most impressed to see a large fibrous thallus in my blood. The explanation of fibrous thallus is nonsensical pseudoscientific gibberish.
Fibrin Spicules http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Involved in clotting to prevent internal bleeding. There is usually an increase during detoxification with the complete program and effective diet because the body is pulling acids stored in the connective tissues back into bloodstream for elimination (1).”
Glass is good at causing fibrin to precipitate out of blood, so occasionally you will see clot on the slide. Some of the photos in the net are artifact, some are fibrin, and all are the normal response to blood on glass. Again, the explanation is nonsense.
Mold http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Yeast overgrowth, collection of yeast, bacterial, fungus, mold. very toxic. Indicated in advanced stages of latent tissue acidosis. Highly disruptive to normal blood circulation (0).”
You never see mould in the blood in people who are not in the ICU dying of sepsis and profound immunocompromise.
These are not mold, they are artifacts on the slide.
Target Cells http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
“Fermenting RBCs; White spots or white yeast forms inside RBCs; Indicates the diet is too high in carbohydrates/simple sugars; sugar intolerance and/or imbalance; endocrine system/ pancreas stress (0).”
Red cells do not ferment and yeast do not live in red cells. This is fiction.
Yeast http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“Born out of RBCs due to blood pH Imbalance from latent tissue acidosis; diet too high in protein, carbohydrates/ sugars; may be caused by excess antibiotic use, hormonal therapy, steroid use; fungal outfection (0)”
This is artifact, not yeasts. Yeasts can only been seen in people dying of overwhelming sepsis from profound neutropenia. Yeasts are not “born out of RBC’s.” More nonsense.
Platelets http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“High counts are due to latent tissue acidosis and excess acids in the bloodstream not being eliminated through the urinary tract causing RBCs to biologically transform giving birth to “filthy, dirty, platelets.”
Red blood cells do not biologically transform into platelets, much less filthy dirty ones.
Rod Forms http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“Bacterial forms born out of RBCs and found in the blood when there is latent tissue acidosis which alters the blood pH; due to acidic diet, emotional or physical stress, low nascent oxygen (O1); waste products of bacteria and yeast/ fungus (0). ”
Bacteria are not born out of red blood cells. More fiction and fantasy. The rod forms, like the L forms seen in some slides, are artifacts. The rods are many times larger than any known bacteria.
Anesthetized WBC”s http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“Indicates recent consumption of excess sugars/ carbohydrates or proteins; WBCs are paralyzed by the acids (acetyl aldehyde, ethanol alcohol, lactic, nitric, uric, sulfuric, and phosphoric) for up to 5 hours (0).”
White cells cannot be anesthetized, although I can be when reading these sites. The photo to me and others appears to be a normal cell. Of course, if you can diagnosis a normal cell as paralyzed by a dietary lack, then everyone can benefit from supplements.
Basophiles http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“Perceived to be related to allergies and/or sensitivities to foods or the environment; exotoxic and mycotoxic reactions; histaminea. Alergic reactions to dairy (0).”
The only way you can diagnose a basophile is by staining it.
Crystals http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
“Crystals are observed when there is excess acidity. It is the body’s preservation mechanism to buffer acidity and create a solid form which is less toxic than the liquid acids. Crystal are perceived to be he signature of the microzyma fermenting sugar, protein or fat (0).”
Making more stuff up. I feel like there should be a midget shouting “Boss, Boss, Da live blood, the live blood” as they only place such physiology exists is on fantasy island.
The crystals on every live blood site are artifact not of blood, but of schmutz on the slide. One practitioner noted some of the crystals looked like glass, but were in cholesterol. No, it was glass, a by-product of making the slides from glass. Microzyma are not the small empress of Oz, but the imaginary micro organisms of Bechamp and are artifacts of darkfield microscopy.
Black Crystals http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
More schmutz/artifact on the slide.
“Tobacco, marijuana; chemical, recreational and prescription drugs. Brown is also associate with the fermentation of protein (0).”
I can imagine some gullible person losing a job because of drug use found on live blood analysis. If companies will use handwriting analysis or, in Japan, blood type as a basis for hiring and firing, live blood analysis will be next.
Cholesterol http://www.betterblood.net/gallery2.htm
More schmutz on the slide. You cannot see cholesterol on a blood smear.
“Usually indicates high blood pressure, arterial sclerosis, high cholesterol. Diet is too high in animal source proteins. Dehydration, acidosis (0).”
Taking the blood pressure usually indicates high blood pressure. It is a simple enough diagnostic procedure and more reliable than looking at live blood. Similarly, a fasting lipid panel may be the more accurate way to diagnosis hypercholesterolemia.
In summary, virtually every diagnosis in live blood analysis is nonsense and much of the alleged pathology is either normal or artifact on the slide. The alleged pathophysiology is also nonsense; they just make this stuff up.
Live blood analysts tend to make up words and processes that sound scientific and cromulous (6): several sites refer to seeing orimbryonic bacteria, but the google cannot find a definition. This pseudoscientific jargon and imaginary physiology combined with the a microscope and a view of their own blood, which most people have never seen, gives the live blood analysis proponents the trappings of real science. A nickel says they wear white coats.
There is no validity behind almost all of the claims made by the practitioners. The one study that looked at the ability for blinded live blood analyzers to make the same diagnosis demonstrated that no two viewers saw the same thing (7). The one diagnostic trial of live blood analysis demonstrated that practitioners were unable to accurately diagnose patients with known metastatic cancer (9).
Many of the web sites show before and after slides to demonstrate the benefits of the detox or supplements or diet have had on the blood. It all depends on what microscopic field on a given slide you choose to present. If you were to show the front of my scalp as the before and the back as the after, you would conclude that something made my hair grow in the interim.
Live blood analysis is a remarkable the combination of artifacts being diagnosed as pathology combined with an imaginary pathophysiology that is completely divorced from reality. It is microscopic paradolia, with the practitioners seeing their own imagining in the structures on the slides. When I was a child, before I learned to cursive writing, I would make squiggles on paper occasionally crossing a ‘t’ and dotting an ‘i’. It was gibberish but I called it real writing. I didn’t realize I was in training to be a live blood analyst.
Live blood analysis does not resemble most alternative medicine modalities, but is more akin to high tech reading of tea leaves or the entrails of pig to divine the future. It is the cargo cult of quackery, with the trappings of science but none of the substance.
Notes
0) http://www.betterblood.net/gallery.htm
1) www.collegenaturalmedicine.com/images/LBA/LBACOURSES/interpretng%20blood%20morphologies-8-1.pdf
2) http://biomedx.com/microscopes/training/LB1.html
3) http://biomedx.com/microscopes/systems/pricing.html
4) “alkalophile glands” appears to be an invention of Dr. Young, a major shill for acids as the cause of every diseases. As he says “alkalophile glands that need these quick bases in order to build up their strong sodium bicarbonate secretions. These glands and organs are the stomach, pancreas, Brunner”s glands (between the pylorus and the junctions of the bile and pancreatic ducts) Lieberkuhn”s glands in the liver and its bile with its strong acid binding capabilities which it has to produce.” http://articlesofhealth.blogspot.com/2008/10/get-off-your-fat-acid.html
5) http://biomedx.com/microscopes/training/LB6.html
6) Thanks Steve.
7) Altern Ther Health Med. 2006 Jul-Aug;12(4):36-41. Reliability of Enderlein’s darkfield analysis of live blood.
CONTEXT: In 1925, the German zoologist Günther Enderlein, PhD, published a concept of microbial life cycles. His observations of live blood using darkfield microscopy revealed structures and phenomena that had not yet been described. Although very little research has been conducted to explain the phenomena Dr. Enderlein observed, the diagnostic test is still used in complementary and alternative medicine.
OBJECTIVE: To test the interobserver reliability and test-retest reliability of 2 experienced darkfield specialists who had undergone comparable training in Enderlein blood analysis.
SETTING: Inpatient clinic for internal medicine and geriatrics.
METHODS: Both observers assessed 48 capillary blood samples from 24 patients with diabetes. The observers were mutually blind and assessed their findings according to a specific item randomization list that allowed observers to specify whether Enderlein structures were visible or not.
RESULTS: The interobserver reliability for the visibility of various structures was kappa = .35 (95% CI: .27-.43), the test-retest reliability was kappa = .44 (95% CI: .36-.53).
CONCLUSIONS: This pilot study indicates that Enderlein darkfield analysis is very difficult to standardize and that the reliability of the diagnostic test is low.
PMID: 16862741
http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Tests/livecell.html
(8) http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Tests/livecell2.htm
(9) Forsch Komplementarmed Klass Naturheilkd. 2005 Jun;12(3):148-51. Epub 2005 Jun 23. [Does dark field microscopy according to Enderlein allow for cancer diagnosis? A prospective study]
BACKGROUND: Dark field microscopy according to Enderlin claims to be able to detect forthcoming or beginning cancer at an early stage through minute abnormalities in the blood. In Germany and the USA, this method is used by an increasing number of physicians and health practitioners (non-medically qualified complementary practitioners), because this easy test seems to give important information about patients’ health status.
OBJECTIVE: Can dark field microscopy reliably detect cancer?
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In the course of a prospective study on iridology, blood samples were drawn for dark field microscopy in 110 patients. A health practitioner with several years of training in the field carried out the examination without prior information about the patients. RESULTS: Out of 12 patients with present tumor metastasis as confirmed by radiological methods (CT, MRI or ultra-sound) 3 were correctly identified. Analysis of sensitivity (0.25), specificity (0.64), positive (0.09) and negative (0.85) predictive values revealed unsatisfactory results.
CONCLUSION: Dark field microscopy does not seem to reliably detect the presence of cancer. Clinical use of the method can therefore not be recommended until future studies are conducted.
(10) http://www.drseeger.com/endobiontprion.html
(11) A miniature form of Venom.

The Paddison Program for rheumatoid arthritis: An unproven treatment that provides only the illusion of control
Clint Paddison is an Australian comedian with a science degree who developed rheumatoid arthritis at age 31. He now claims to have controlled it with a diet he developed to alter the gut microbiome. How plausible is his story, and does his Paddison Program work? Answer: Not very and almost certainly no.
David GorskionApril 29, 2019
Tweet

If there’s one thing about blogging, day in and day out, over the course of fourteen and a half years, it’s that sometimes you get stuck for a topic. Back in my early days at my not-so-super-secret other blog, I used to be so obsessive that when that happened I’d find something—anything!—to write about, even the end result ended up being not so good. These days, I’ve mellowed considerably. If I don’t have a topic over there on a given day, I don’t sweat it and instead let the topics come to me. Unfortunately, Science-Based Medicine is different. I’m the editor; I’m scheduled every Monday. Writer’s block is not permitted. Usually it’s not a problem, as I have an idea by Friday or Saturday and my post written by Saturday night or Sunday morning, but yesterday morning arrived, and I had no idea what I was going to write about. Then I saw this:
I don't know anything about it, don't recall anyone chatting about it. Let's call some other skeptic MDs too: @gorskon @palmd @HHSkepDoc @ScienceBasedMed @SBMPediatrics Anyone know what this is about? Science based?
— Dr. mem_somerville | Wossamotta U (@mem_somerville) April 28, 2019
It was almost like firing up the Bat Signal!
Even better, the Paddison Program is a treatment that I don’t recall ever having discussed. A search of SBM and my not-so-secret-other blog turned up no mention of this treatment for rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Google searches turned up nothing but the Paddison Program website and lots of laudatory material about the program. So there it was, a dubious-sounding dietary treatment for RA that I hadn’t heard of before and about which there appeared to be very little, if any skeptical material available on the web. Perfect! Let’s take a look!
The Paddison Program
If you peruse the Paddison Program website, you’ll immediately find a number of red flags for quackery and pseudoscience. The site urges readers to “Get Fast And Dramatic Rheumatoid Arthritis Relief With A Proven Step-By-Step System That Is Recommended By Health Professionals”. The entry page for the website is festooned with little other than testimonials. Clicking on the Get The Paddison Program Now leads to a page urging:
Reverse Rheumatoid Arthritis Symptoms With The Paddison Program And Get Your Life Back.
Join over 10,000 others and have less joint pain, less swelling, more mobility and more energy with this unique program.
There’s also a video of a TEDx Talk by Clint Paddison, the inventor of the Paddison Program. (More on that later.) In addition, there are more testimonials. This time the testimonials go further, with people claiming that the Paddison Program allowed them to get off their methotrexate, sulfasalazine, prednisone, and Humira (adalimumab) for their RA, ankylosing spondylitis, etc. Even worse, there are testimonials from physicians, one of whose name I recognized, Dr. Michael Klaper. You might remember him as Penn Jillette’s water fast guru, and his big thing is to advocate vegan diets and extreme fasting as a treatment for, well, almost everything. As for the others, predictably, they ranged from “integrative medicine” doctors (e.g., Dr. Nina Malek, who’s on faculty at the University of Arizona working for Dr. Andrew Weil) to physicians pushing fad diets (Dr. John McDougall and Dr. Monica Aggarwal) to a “chiropractic neurologist” (Dr. Richard Matthews) who specializes in chronic Lyme disease and “brain fog” and appears to be heavily into unproven treatments based on the “gut microbiome.” (Watching his video was painful.)
It gets worse. The Paddison Program website also features glowing recommendations by naturopaths and other chiropractors. Meanwhile, it states:
The standard approach from Rheumatologists is to ‘hit the disease as hard as possible’ with dangerous pharmaceutical drugs that can have side effects that are as bad as the disease itself.
Whilst we must keep the inflammation as low as possible, we should also be addressing the underlying cause so as to stop the disease progression.
This is done by healing the gut (more on this below).
As if the numerous patient testimonials and recommendations by integrative medicine doctors, naturopaths, chiropractors, and purveyors of fad diets weren’t enough in the way of red flags for quackery, we’re now seeing the claim of “addressing the underlying cause” of a disease that is not the underlying cause (as you will see) and the inflammatory (if you’ll excuse the word—I couldn’t resist) characterization of how doctors do treat the disease. If you’re hearing echoes of how cancer quacks characterize cancer treatment as “cut, poison, burn,” you’re not alone. That’s the first thing I thought reading the website. I got the same vibe reading the next segment:
NSAID‘s (like Advil, Voltaren, Nurofen etc) cause digestive issues, quickly exacerbating RA. Taking these drugs usually worsens RA long term.
NSAID damage is so great that they are often accompanied by Proton Pump Inhibitors (PPI’s) which negative impact gut bacteria, cause more RA symptoms.
Clients on antibiotics for RA usually go backwards long term. I see these patients after treatment and they are some of the most difficult clients to help.
Prednisone is exceptionally bad for leaky gut, osteoporosis, vitamin D absorption and more. Long term use is both dangerous and results in worse RA symptoms.
Studies show that RA Sufferers have low levels of healthy bacteria and an overgrowth of pathogenic “unfriendly” bacteria. The more sever the bacterial overgrowth, the more severe your RA is. This bad bacteria, along with undigested food particles, can get into your bloodstream via a leaky gut. Your body sends in antibodies against these particles and creates circulating immune complexes which can get lodged in the joints triggering inflammation. Chronic acidosis, from poor dietary habits, lowers pH levels in the synovial tissue which promotes inflammation. Associated with RA sufferers is low stomach acid, resulting in undigested proteins. When undigested proteins enter the bloodstream the body can develop molecular mimicry, mistaking your own tissue’s proteins for those entering through the gut wall. Studies show that persons with RA have poor intestinal mucosal lining, often worse than that of people with intestinal disease, and some RA folks are lacking an epithelium altogether. This digestive disaster is exacerbated [sic] by low digestive enzymes, further promoting an under active, highly problematic digestive system that needs a massive overhaul.
Paddison even has a cutesy mnemonic for his program: BLAME (Bacteria, Leaky Gut, Acid, Mucosal Lining, Enzymes).
I’ll examine just what Mr. Paddison’s claims entail after I provide a brief primer on rheumatoid arthritis. Here’s his TEDx Talk video, which I will be discussing along the way:
Basically, the video above is Mr. Paddison’s story of his being diagnosed with RA, how it was treated, and how he came up with his protocol. The idea is that RA sufferers can take control of their disease through dietary interventions that alter their gut microbiota. Unfortunately, it’s the illusion of control.
Rheumatoid arthritis
Most readers of the blog probably know that rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is an autoimmune disease that primarily affects the joints. Indeed, RA is the most common type of autoimmune arthritis. It affects more than 1.3 million Americans, about 75% of whom are women. The disease most often manifests itself between the ages of 30 and 50 but can start at any age. Classic symptoms include joint stiffness that is at its worst in the morning (which Mr. Paddington had and related in his talk, as you’ll see). This is in contrast to osteoarthritis, the stiffness and pain of which are usually not more pronounced in the morning. RA often improves with movement of the joints throughout the day. It also most commonly afflicts the joints of the hands, feet, wrists, elbows, knees and ankles, and the joint effect is usually symmetrical; i.e, if one ankle is affected usually the other will be too. Although there is a familial component, with a family history of RA being able to increase the risk of RA three to five times, most patients with RA do not have a family history. (In his video, Mr. Paddington makes a big deal of his not having a family history of RA, which means, really, little or nothing, contrary to his harping on it.)
Other signs and symptoms of RA include fever, loss of energy, loss of appetite, lumps known as rheumatoid nodules that grow beneath the skin in places such as the elbow and hands. Being an autoimmune disease, RA can affect many other organs besides the joints, including:
    • Kidneys
    • Skin
    • Liver
    • Neurological
    • Eyes
    • Lungs
    • Heart
    • Salivary glands
    • Nerve tissue
    • Bone marrow
    • Blood vessels
RA is diagnosed by a combination of physical examination, radiological imaging, and blood tests. Blood tests include tests to look for specific antibodies, inflammation, and anemia. The most well-known of these is an antibody known as rheumatoid factor, which is found in about 80% of patients with RA in time, but as few as 30% when the arthritis starts. Antibodies to cyclic citrullinated peptides (anti-CCP, for short) are found in 60-70% of patients with RA. Erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), a nonspecific indicator of inflammation, is often elevated as well. Some viral infections can cause symptoms that can be mistaken for RA, and false-positive blood tests can occur, so it’s important to be evaluated by a rheumatologist (which Mr. Paddington was).
RA is treated with a combination of drugs. Steroids are sometimes used initially because of their powerful nonspecific anti-inflammatory activity. The mainstay of RA treatment, though, consists of disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs, commonly abbreviated as DMARDs. Common DMARDs include methotrexate, leflunomide, hydroxychloroquine, and sulfasalazine (Azulfidine). Gold and the antibiotics minocycline, azathioprine, and cyclosporine are also DMARDs, but are rarely prescribed for RA these days because of the advent of biological agents used for more severe disease or disease refractory to DMARDs. These include abatacept (Orencia), adalimumab (Humira), anakinra (Kineret), certolizumab (Cimzia), etanercept (Enbrel), golimumab (Simponi), infliximab (Remicade), rituximab (Rituxan, MabThera), sarilumab (Kevzara), and tocilizumab (Actemra), all monoclonal antibodies against proteins involved in the inflammation of RA. Usually, ultimately a combination of drugs, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS) are used to treat and control RA.
The concept of remission is important, too, because drug-free remission in RA is possible. It could also explain much of Mr. Paddison’s story. You see, Mr. Paddison came up with his protocol because he himself suffered from RA.
The goal in treating RA is to stop the inflammation and achieve remission, even better, drug-free remission.
Clint Paddison’s story versus science
In his TEDx Talk video, Mr. Paddison provides an engaging story of his RA diagnosis, symptoms, and treatment, describing how this led him to his protocol. Annoyingly, he talks about his “discoveries”, and how they might “provide hope” to others with this crippling disease. He begins by describing how, seven years ago, at the age of 31, he woke up with swelling in his fingers. (The talk is five years ago, which means that Mr. Paddison is now 43.) This happened a few times; so he went to see his GP, who examined him, ordered some blood tests, and diagnosed him with RA, referring him to a rheumatologist.
The rheumatologist, apparently, told Mr. Paddison that the standard approach to RA is to take drugs for the rest of your life. (I noticed immediately how Mr. Paddison led with that, given that it’s a standard talking point in alternative medicine testimonials.) The drug the rheumatologist wanted to start him on methotrexate, a DMARD, but he balked, noting, as I mentioned above, that no one in his family had had RA, plus that he was a young, fit guy, a runner, and more. He also noted that he had been working as a standup comedian (great qualification!), leading him to point out that he only worked a couple of nights a week and should be able to “work it out” on his own. Obviously, you and I see deadly hubris here, but apparently Mr. Paddison did not.
I will admit that the next part of the testimonial did surprise me a bit. Mr. Paddison describes going to see every naturopath, homeopath, Chinese herbalist, acupuncturist, and massage therapist that he could and being on up to ten supplements at a time. None of it worked, and his disease had progressed alarmingly after 18 months of this. One of his elbows had such limited range of motion that he needed surgery, a synovectomy, followed by six weeks of rehabilitation, to restore range of motion. His fingers were so swollen that he couldn’t close his hands into fists. He had chest pain that sounded like pulmonary involvement (pain with every breath), in his jaw, and in many other areas of his body, including his left knee, which had swollen enormously. So, yes, the quackery didn’t work.
I felt bad for Mr. Paddison, as he was in rough shape, but hopeful because he decided to go back to his rheumatologist, who put him on methotrexate, which he took for twelve months. Unfortunately, as is often the case, the methotrexate became less effective. The other problem Mr. Paddison had was that he wanted to have children but because methotrexate is mutagenic you can’t have children while on the drug and in fact have to wait six months. This is what inspired him to come up with his treatment. He also discussed how great he had been as an undergraduate science major. Specifically, he studied physics, and bragged about all the science awards he won (1st Class honours, The Macquarie Foundation Science Prize, Australian Institute of Physics prize, NSW Branch, and Semi-Finalist for Young Australian of the Year) and his one peer-reviewed publication, joking, “If I could do all that, I should be able to kick some rheumatoid butt.” Uh, no. Physics is a very different science than biology, and the skills are not necessarily transferrable. It’s also more hubris to think that you can succeed where generations of immunologists and rheumatologists had failed. I don’t care if, as he claims, Mr. Paddington really did spend the equivalent of a second university degree “studying” RA, especially when his research was guided by books by “the only two people who had ever recovered from this disease” and did it through diet.
Mr. Paddison claims that his great insight was what he calls the “cherry incident,” where he ate a bunch of unwashed cherries, got violently ill for 24 hours, and felt much better, including his joint pain. It’s at this point where he got into all sorts of dietary woo, and related that he felt pain whenever he was full but no pain whenever he was empty. Ultimately, he ended up on a raw food diet, then reintroduced some cooked vegetables. He showed a picture of his left hand before and after, claiming there was nothing wrong with his hand in the “after” photo. I’ll admit that the “after” image looks much better, but his middle finger’s proximal interphalangeal joint still looked quite swollen to me.
Now here’s the kicker. He did this for 24 months, during which time he was still taking methotrexate. As he felt better, eventually he got off of his methotrexate. As an aside, one thing I don’t understand at this point is why the rheumatologist apparently never added another drug or switched Mr. Paddington to a biological agent if he was really doing as poorly as he described at the point right before his “cherry incident”. Something sounds a bit fishy in the story there. Normally what you do when one drug isn’t working as well any more is to add or switch to another.
In any event, let’s move on to BLAME-ing the microbiome.
BLAME the microbiome and diet!
Mr. Paddison came up with his BLAME concept based on his experience. It’s very much a “just-so” story to explain how changes in gut microbiome can lead to damage to the intestinal mucosa, which in turn can lead to “leaky gut“, which leads to antigens getting into the bloodstream undigested, which leads to their triggering autoimmunity through molecular mimicry. Similarly, decreased stomach acid contributes, as do decreases in digestive enzymes, because both contribute to proteins making it to the intestine less digested. It all sounds so reasonable, but is there any evidence?
In a word, sort of. Basically what Mr. Paddison is doing is what so many other alternative medicine and diet mavens do. He’s taking correlative data that hasn’t been firmed up and definitively shown to be part of the pathophysiology of a disease, and extrapolating wildly based on it. For instance, research has been published showing differences in gut microbiota between RA patients and normal controls associated with disease and duration. However, there doesn’t appear (yet) to be good evidence that these are not epiphenomena, that they are causative. More importantly, there isn’t a lot of evidence that dietary interventions to alter the symptoms, pathology, or clinical course of RA. In fact, there’s almost no such evidence that I could find. There’s a study here and there suggesting that specific foods or nutrients affect symptoms. Most are observational or negative. In other words, although it’s certainly possible that the gut microbiome affects RA risk and progression and that dietary manipulation might be a useful adjunct treatment, most of what we know now is preliminary and speculative. Indeed, in this recent review, the microbiome is mentioned, but not as a critical new target for intervention.
None of that, of course, stops Mr. Paddison from building a veritable empire selling his dietary intervention program for RA. He hasn’t, as far as I can tell, published anything in the peer-reviewed medical literature on his program, or verified that his intervention has any significant effect on the gut microbiome at all. All he has are anecdotes. Sure, it’s not unreasonable that decreasing stress would be good for RA symptoms. Sure, it’s possible that dietary interventions might have an effect on the disease symptoms and progression. Unfortunately, Mr. Paddison has done none of the hard work to show any of this. He thinks he has, but he hasn’t. Yet, none of this stops him from selling unproven interventions to desperate patients, even though he is not a physician.
How do I explain Mr. Paddison’s recovery, though?
RA remission: Not as uncommon as you think
The first thing that struck me about Mr. Paddison’s story is how long it was. He spent 18 months after his diagnosis pursuing quackery. He spent twelve months on methotrexate before deciding he had to try something different, and it was two years after that before he got off of his methotrexate. All told, that’s four and a half years, by my estimation, three of which he was on a DMARD, methotrexate. During that time, despite Mr. Paddison’s claims of how poorly he was doing, his rheumatologist never switched drugs, which is very odd if he really was doing so poorly on just methotrexate. Again, most RA patients require more than one DMARD; if Mr. Paddison was doing reasonably well on just methotrexate, it suggests milder disease. Of course, we don’t know why he was never switched to another drug. Maybe he refused. On the other hand, if he was so afraid of methotrexate’s effects on his sperm, you’d think that he would have jumped at the chance to try a different drug.
What I suspect is that Mr. Paddison was fortunate enough to go into remission and that his diet probably had little or nothing to do with it. Indeed, a 2017 review article states, notes that “with new treatment strategies drug-free sustained remission is becoming an achievable goal”. It also cited several studies, dating back to the 1990s, that show that drug-free remissions are not uncommon in disease that is successfully managed with DMARDs:
Once a good response on DMARDs and stable remission are achieved, the treatment could be tapered; and once remission is further sustained, the treatment could be stopped.9 Drug-free remission has been described in several patient groups which supports that drug-free remission could truly be achieved.
The approach of benefit/risk assessment of continuation or stopping DMARDs was examined as early as the 1990s in a double-blind placebo-controlled study.10 In this study, RA patients with a good long-term therapeutic response, after median duration of DMARD therapy of 5 years, were randomized to continue therapy, n = 142, or to receive placebo, n = 143. At 52 weeks of follow up, as many as 62% of the patients who were randomized to placebo and 78% of the patients who were randomized to continue therapy did not have a flare, defined as recurrence of synovitis. Side-effects that necessitated dose reduction or discontinuation occurred equally in each group.
This sounds not unlike Mr. Paddison, who was on his methotrexate three years, at which point he appeared to be in remission. Given that he reported that he wasn’t getting better on methotrexate, another possibility is that he might have undergone spontaneous remission, as described in this review:
Spontaneous remission is not uncommon in patients who present with very early arthritis, some of whom may meet criteria for RA over less than a few months. Spontaneous remission is thought of as a “natural remission,” in which disease activity essentially disappears, and medications are no longer required. Spontaneous remission may be seen in 13% to 55% of individuals presenting with undifferentiated arthritis, probably as a result of different underlying etiologies, such as a transient viral infection [32]. About one third of patients with undifferentiated arthritis go on to develop RA. In a study of three cohorts of recent-onset undifferentiated arthritis from the United Kingdom, Germany, and the Netherlands, the severity of morning stiffness and presence of autoantibodies were the strongest predictors of progression to RA [33]. Spontaneous remission can be seen not only in early undifferentiated arthritis but in RA pregnancy and juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) as well.
So, what’s more likely, that Mr. Paddison cured his RA with a diet that altered his microbiome, a diet that he stumbled across through trial and error, or that he was fortunate enough to undergo remission? Barring compelling evidence, I vote for the latter, but leave open the possibility of the former, although I consider that possibility to be highly unlikely.
What Clint Paddison is really selling
Chronic disease is frustrating. Aside from the symptoms and the impact on quality of life, the patient suffering from a chronic disease like RA suffers from a loss of control. What Clint Paddison is selling, above all, is the same thing a lot of quacks sell: The illusion of control. I realized this when I came across this video:
In this video, a woman asks Paddison how she can eliminate random RA flares. Beginning at 0:45, Paddison goes on an extended discussion of why he never uses the term “flare”, because it implies something beyond the patient’s control. He defines a flare as meaning that a disease is out of our control, that it’s random, and that we can’t do anything about it. He then goes on to argue that RA is almost completely within the patient’s control and that “if we apply a consistent pattern of behavior with our foods—our exercises as well—our stress levels, and also supplementation, then we’re going to get the same outcome with our symptoms” and that “the disease responds to influences that are mostly and largely under our control.”
Holy hubris, Batman! No physician goes that far with almost any disease. Also note that the implication is that this woman is having flares because she’s not doing something right; in other words, her symptoms are her fault. It’s the common quack trope that the treatment doesn’t fail the patient, but the patient fails the treatment, and it’s despicable.
Unfortunately, for patients with a chronic disease like RA, that message of taking control is very seductive. Certainly, it’s that very idea of being able to control his disease himself, without the help of doctors, naturopaths, homeopaths, acupuncturists, etc., that led Mr. Paddison down the path to believing he had found the answer to RA when in reality his story of self-recovery due to his own treatment is dodgy at best when examined critically and his treatment is based on ideas that are speculative at best. If you’re an RA patient, run, don’t walk, from Clint Paddison. He was lucky, not good, and now, sadly, he appears to be descending into the role of charlatan. Stick with science-based treatment.

Urinary Tract Infections Cause Depression. Directors Cut.*
Mark Crislip on January 24, 2014
Link
As some may know I am infectious disease doctor. Urinary tract infections (UTI) butter my bread. Figuratively speaking. There is an enormous amount known about the pathophysiology of UTI’s. It is both a common and complex problem. But for all our knowledge, chronic and recurrent UTI’s remain a vexing issue for the patient and the doctor.
One reason people develop recurrent UTI’s is not because of altered chi along meridians altered by needles stuck in the skin distant from the bladder. That would be ridiculous. I like reasoning from basic principles. Given what we know about anatomy, physiology and microbiology, how might acupuncture interfere with the development of a urinary tract infection? Would it prevent colonization with pathogenic E. coli? Prevent retrograde travel of bacteria up the urethra into the bladder? Stop E. coli from binding to uroepithelial cells? Have a bactericidal or bacteriostatic effect?
None of the above seem likely. To my mind, postulating any of the above as a potential mechanism for acupuncture as a preventative for UTI’s would be ludicrous. And spare me your Boosting the Immune System, a concept that exists as a marketing tool, not a useful therapeutic intervention. My boss used to say that many an academic career floundered on attempting to prevent and treat UTI’s using an immune system approach. With some exceptions, and there are always exceptions, recurrent UTI’s in normal humans are usually due to anatomic or microbiological anomalies.
Despite its popularity, it is clear that acupuncture is not based on reality and, like all pseudo-medicine, only has demonstrable efficacy in poorly-designed studies. Acupuncture displays the usual progression of all pseudo-medicines. Increasingly-well-done studies show decreasing effect until a study that removes all bias shows it to be no better than placebo. Which one would expect for an intervention based on fantasy. Prior plausibility (the toy boat of SBM, try saying it three times very fast) would predict that acupuncture is worthless. And that should be acupunctures, all 6 styles are an elaborate ritual with no more likelihood of efficacy than the superstitions in a Budweiser commercial.
Much to my embarrassment, Clinical Infectious Disease (CID), the flagship journal of my specialty, published “Recurrent urinary tract infections among women: comparative effectiveness of 5 prevention and management strategies using a markov chain monte carlo model.” One of the five interventions included in their analysis was acupuncture. Really. They thought a pseudo-medical intervention divorced from reality to be worthy of consideration for the prevention of UTI.
As to be expected, the study generated the usual ‘acupuncture works’ headlines, especially as the analysis suggested acupuncture was second only to antibiotics in preventing UTIs, and better than cranberry pills, estrogens, and symptomatic self-treatment.
Now we get into problems, given my non-statistical brain. What is a markov chain monte carlo model? Fortunately I have a statistician at work who was kind enough to translate statistics into Crislip, a.k.a. dumb it down.
It is a simulation. In this case they simulated 10,000 patients over a year and then summarized what happened on average for each intervention.
Each virtual patient in the model had an assigned probability per day of having a UTI, and there are probabilities for the various interventions being effective. They used an algorithm to determine whether or not a UTI occurs on a given day. That is why “Monte Carlo”: they pick outcomes at random with a certain probability. So if you sample enough virtual patients a UTI will occur roughly the correct percent of the time.
The “Markov Chain” part means that what happened in the past for the virtual patient is irrelevant, all that matters is what state they are in that ‘day’. So it’s a simplifying assumption, which makes evidently makes the simulation much easier.
It is a simulation and, like all simulations, the end results are dependent on how the initial conditions are set.
There is a table of Probability Values for Variables in Model. They have risk reduction probabilities for the interventions evaluated in the simulation:
Daily antibiotics/nitrofurantoin, 100 mg once daily, risk reduction 0.86
Acupuncture, risk reduction 0.68
Estrogen use, risk reduction 0.65
Cranberry risk reduction 0.50
I appears to me that the initial conditions are set up to show, as the accompanying editorial says, the ‘surprising’ result that acupuncture was second only to antibiotics in UTI prevention. The order of efficacy that came out of the simulation appears to parallel the order of the initial conditions. Go figure. Again, I am no statistician, correct me if I am wrong.
They derived their probability of risk reduction of 0.68 from two clinical trials. I asked my statistician how that number was derived and he said it was a mystery as he could not tell from the paper and that I should email the authors. As I publish this I have not heard back from the author, who said a week ago they would get back to me. When they do, I will post an addendum.
I would have expected the risk reduction probability of acupuncture to be zero, since there is zero prior plausibility acupuncture would work. It made me curious about the articles that demonstrated efficacy. Both were done by the same authors in Sweden. As we learned from Benveniste and homeopathy studies, the same group doing a study does not a reproduction make.
The most recent study, “Acupuncture Treatment in the Prevention of Uncomplicated Recurrent Lower Urinary Tract Infections in Adult Women”, did not have a sham acupuncture group, so the study is worthless. Equally important is the patients were only followed for 6 months, probably not long enough to decrease normal variability of recurrent UTI’s. What is the natural history of uncomplicated urinary tract infections in women (bold added)?
we observed 51 infection-prone women in a standardized fashion for a median of 9 years. During intervals when patients were not receiving antimicrobial prophylaxis, infections occurred at an average rate of 2.6 per patient-year, but the rate varied widely from patient to patient (range 0.3-7.6 episodes per year). Seventy-three percent of the observed episodes were symptomatic, with an 18:1 ratio of cystitis to pyelonephritis episodes. Infectious episodes were strikingly clustered, and rates of infection decreased in the winter months.
Their microbiologic definition of UTI is probably outdated and would fail to diagnose many UTI’s:
bacteriuria (10^5 or more colony-forming units per milliliter of uropathogen or any amount of Staphylococcus saprophyticus).
As a recent NEJM study, “Voided Midstream Urine Culture and Acute Cystitis in Premenopausal Women”, suggests 10^2 CFU of E. coli is predictive of UTI.
And with a p value of 0.08, it is far from the .005 that would be suggestive.
An earlier study, “Acupuncture in the prophylaxis of recurrent lower urinary tract infection in adult women”, has the same fatal flaws they were to repeat later: inadequate duration of follow up, an inadequate microbiologic definition of UTI (although of course they could not have known), poor statistical validity and very small numbers in each arm of the study (acupuncture (27), sham acupuncture (26), and control (14)).
There was no microbiologic information in the latest study, but the early study reported 5 patients with enterococcus as the pathogen, with the NEJM article suggesting that enterococcus is not a pathogen in this population.
In the latest study no mention was made as to what mechanisms was used to get follow up, in the earlier study it was patient initiated. We have no way of knowing, given the self-limited nature of cystitis, if patients became symptomatic and did not bother to come in or sought care elsewhere.
And, importantly in the first study, no mention was made as to whether blinding to sham or real (as if there is a difference) acupuncture was successful, which the authors recognize was a flaw with plenty of opportunity for the clever Hans effect (unconscious cuing):
The study otherwise mainly applied a single-blind design, since patients were not informed about the type of treatment they were receiving. It is however difficult to ensure that there was no non-verbal communication about treatment type between the acupuncturist and the patient, and patients receiving real acupuncture may have felt an increased anticipation of an effect.
Two profoundly flawed studies from which no valid conclusions can be made about the efficacy of acupuncture, much less an estimated acupuncture risk reduction of 0.68. There was a recent review of UTI prevention in the Journal of Urology with the same conclusion:
Cranberries decreased urinary tract infection recurrence (2 trials, sample size 250, Jadad score 4, RR 0.53, 95% CI 0.33-0.83) as did acupuncture (2 open label trials, sample size 165, Jadad score 2, RR 0.48, 95% CI 0.29-0.79)
This is a classic example of the difference between evidence and science-based medicine. There is evidence for acupuncture that stinks on ice if anyone would take a moment to read the articles. A science-based consideration of reality, anatomy, physiology, microbiology would suggest that any real risk reduction by acupuncture should be zero. Prior plausibility would suggest any positive outcome in an acupuncture study would be a false positive due to methodologic errors in the study. As we have discussed at great length over the years, there is zero reason to suspect any true efficacy of acupuncture beyond study bias and poor methodologies, which were rife in these studies.
That being said, the authors say:
Somewhat surprisingly, we found that acupuncture was the next most effective prevention method. Acupuncture’s high efficacy may be a function of publication bias, as there were fewer studies on acupuncture compared to other management
No. Acupuncture’s high efficacy was a function of profoundly horrible studies and an estimation of risk reduction that is too large by 0.68. No one involved gives the appearance of having read the original papers to see if the estimated risk reduction is reasonable. The editors and reviewing peers evidently did not as well.
It is an oddity of medicine. I would wager that astronomy journals do not publish editorials touting astrology as a solution for difficult problems. Similarly, psychology journals do not look to psi and chemistry journals do not advocate the methods of alchemy. In medicine, the editors have no problem with suggesting nonsense on the basis of GIGO in their journal. The accompanying CID editorial says:
For example, in an individual case, a clinician and patient working together may opt to use acupuncture in combination with cranberry juice and self- directed therapy at the first sign of symptoms.
Did the editorial writer read the paper? The simulation evaluated cranberry pills, not juice. Goodness gracious great balls of fire, an editorial in CID recommending two simultaneous worthless therapies, acupuncture and cranberry juice. I would so love to have the editors and authors come up with a plausible explanation for how acupuncture may work for UTI prevention and why this simulation had any validity as to the efficacy of acupuncture after reading the original papers. I did not go back and read the papers touting cranberry pills, but my father taught me to judge a risk reduction by the company it keeps.
I used to have a slightly smug attitude about CID since it had been the only journal I regularly read that had not published an article erroneously promoting pseudo-medicine based on bad studies. No longer. And to add salt to the wounds, it comes out of the institution where I did my fellowship. When ID falls for pseudo-medicine (because we are the best and brightest in medicine) we are indeed doomed.
I am so bummed. I am going to have to look into treatment for reactive depression. I wonder if acupuncture would work…
——-

   Hi Ho Silver
Mark Crislip
Link
I was making rounds at the hospital and, for some strange reason, I was being asked about influenza. No, this is not going to be an entry on influenza. But I was asked if there was anything besides the vaccines that can prevent influenza. Masks and good hand washing will help, I said.
Anything else?
A nurse suggested colloidal silver.
I said there was nothing to colloidal silver. With what I would describe as a withering look, she opined that not only had she never had the flu because she took colloidal silver, but that she has a friend whose tumor has been in remission for 6 years because of colloidal silver. She had to respond to an alarm and I had to move on to the next patient, so we yet had an opportunity to converse further on the topic. Which is good because it occurred to be I did not know much about colloidal silver beyond the fact it can turn you blue. So this entry in my attempt to prepare for my next discussion with a colloidal silver proponent.
Silver is an antiseptic, not an antibiotic. It has the advantage of most antiseptics in that organisms do not easily become resistant. It does kill a large number of pathogens and is used clinically. Silver is impregnated into catheters to prevent infections. Silver nitrate has been put in the eyes of newborns to prevent gonorrhea.
Various formulations of silver have been tried to aid wound healing, with little effect and Silvadene, silver sulfadiazine, has long been used to treat burns, although its efficacy, when compared to everything from honey to aloe, is often found wanting. So there is variable clinical data to perhaps supporting use of some forms of silver to treat or prevent some infections. I will admit to an affinity to suggesting honey and or sugar for chronic wounds; that should be a topic for another post. There are also uses of silver for water purification. So there are legitimate reasons to use silver as an antiseptic.
Ancient wisdom is always a guide for therapy. Cupping. Bleeding. Purging. Popular therapies back in the day. Silver containers was used by ancients to keep water and other fluids fresh. I cannot find independent verification of this fact, perhaps they kept water in silver because silver is pretty and rare and good for demonstrating wealth, and we are attributing its antiseptic properties retroactively. Nor can I find independent verification that Royals were called blue bloods due to chronic silver exposure from their eating utensils. Odd that colloidal silver sites would mention this, since it is evidence of toxicities they deny occurs in other sections of the same websites. The use of apocryphal information appears to be standard in the colloidal silver ‘literature’. It is rare to have so little verifiable information about a treatment.
As I have discussed before, users of alternative therapies are not comfortable with nuance and subtlety, and, I think, prefer black and white binary approaches. Mercury in one form is toxic, so all forms of mercury are toxic. Some forms of silver are beneficial, so all forms of silver of benefit, including colloidal silver. The inability to deal with shades of gray is a hallmark of many forms of alternative therapy.
As best I can tell, silver was used as a medicine for years by grinding it up and suspending it in water. The problem is that the silver is not dissolved but is a suspension and it rapidly settles out of solution. What people were looking for at the turn of the century was a way to keep the silver in suspension. Colloids occur when one substance is evenly distributed in another without being dissolved, like antibodies or albumin in blood. Or fat in milk. Proteins like albumin have the advantage of binding metals like silver and allow them to stay in suspension for long periods of time.
“The broader commercial definition of “colloidal silver” includes products that contain various concentrations of ionic silver, silver colloids, ionic silver compounds or bound proteins in purified water. Colloidal silver with concentrations of 30 parts per million (ppm) or less are typically manufactured using an electrolysis process, whereas colloidal silver with higher concentrations of 50 ppm or more are usually silver compounds that have been bound with a protein.”
In the form of colloidal silver it is ingested for various alleged health benefits, especially to treat infections.
How many infections? “Colloidal Silver safely kills over 650 disease-causing bacteria, viruses, fungi, parasites, and molds, has no negative side-effects.” 650! Wow! Where does that number come from? It, evidently was pulled out of thin air in a 1976 Science Digest article entitled “Our mightiest germ fighter”
which was a discussion of of of not colloidal silver, but silver sulfadiazine, aka silvadene and other topical uses of silver.
And nowhere in the article is 650 validated. It was a number that appears to have been invented by the headline writer. Not that Science Digest is peer reviewed journal and has to reference their headline. But that 650 has taken on a life of its own. Like 98.6 being normal body temperature. Many of the colloidal silver sites trumpet this on their websites (43,000 Google hits for “Colloidal Silver kills over 650″ as a search term.” 650 is so sciency, even if made up.
Could silver kill 650 various and sundry organisms? I would not be surprised if it were the right concentration. Silver is toxic to cells, so it should kill germs. And it does. Like mercury or gold. In its elemental form they are toxic and will kill living things at the right concentration. As will isopropal alcohol; ingestion may not be such a good idea. Many chemicals can kill a wide variety of bacteria in the test tube. The question is whether they have the same effects in humans and or animals.
If you look on Pubmed for the antimicrobial effects of colloidal silver, I find nothing. No test tube studies, no animal models, no case reports, no clinical trials. As far as the medical industrial complex is concerned there is, outside of toxicities, no supporting data of any kind for the use of colloidal silver. The interwebs does allow access to susceptibility tests of colloidal silver that are published by the companies that make colloidal silver products. However, conflict of interest is not part of the alt med world, so we do not need to worry about their validity. Sarcasm aside, the studies are growth of bacteria in various concentrations of colloidal silver products and as the concentrations increase, the bacteria die more rapidly. That’s the usual dose-effect of a poison. They also tout that bacteria can’t become resistant to silver. Always a mistake, for to misquote the Borg, resistance is inevitable as E. coli has demonstrated.
So there is no data to support silver to treat infections. What about cancer? It is suggested, with often identical wording on website after website, that “Dr. Bjorn Nordstrom, of the Karolinska Institute, Sweden, has used Silver in his cancer cure method, for many years. This brought rapid remission in patients given up on by other doctors.” I do not know who was first with this sentence so I am uncertain whom to credit with the first use of this phrase.
But here is the weird thing. Although Dr. Nordstom is credited with the same breakthrough with exactly the same sentence in site after site, I can find no English language reference that confirms there is a Bjorn Nordstrom or any details as to how he uses silver for a cancer cure. Dr Nordstum has not published on Pubmed. The only reference on the interwebs to a Dr Nordstom is in Swedish. If someone can translate http://www.cancerochallergifonden.se/priset1998.html we may find out more. The Swedish word for silver, silvret, is not on the page. I suspect, from reading the Swedish, he may be married to Betty Crocker.
So for what diseases is there evidence for which colloidal silver is efficacious? Well, nothing. Pubmed is silent on taking colloidal silver to benefit any disease, infection or otherwise. There are no clinical trials to show efficacy. Nothing.
There is, however, little to suspect that colloidal silver, taken orally, would be of benefit. There are not even basic pharmacokinetic studies to show how much of a given colloidal silver preparation is absorbed. Nothing. We know it is absorbed, as there are multiple cases of argyria reported in the literature. Argyria is where the silver gets irreversibly into the skin and you turn not silver but blue or blue gray. It is an unusual side effect, but the only documented effect of prolonged ingestion colloidal silver.
If you Google colloidal silver, you will find multiple sites where you can purchase various formulations of colloidal silver with variable concentrations of silver. All of the purveyors of these substances agree that theirs is the one true formulation for silver and that the others are flawed with the wrong size of silver molecule or the wrong preparation. Which one is truly the true silver colloid? All. Or none I would suppose.
One seller (many of these people really need a web designer) sells increasing concentrations of colloidal sliver, with the higher concentrations for the most cost (1500 dollars for 6 bottles) to treat ” Severe Infections and Life and Death Infections Ebola, Dengue Fever, Malaria, SARS, West Nile at a dose of 1-3 tablespoon (15-45 cc) every 4 hours”.
There appears to be as many silver formulations as there are silver sellers, and if you are a do it yourself kind of person, you can make your own colloidal silver.
What perpetuates the use of colloidal silver are testimonials, like the nurse who suggested silver to prevent H1N1. The interwebs are filled with unsubstantiated testimonials, for common infections and unusual infections, with one gentleman crediting colloidal silver, rather than the vancomycin and gentamyin, for the cure of his subdural empyema (pus between the brain and skull).
The FDA, with little effect to judge from the interwebs, has declared that colloidal silver is neither safe nor effective and, as an unclassified drug, cannot be sold for medical reasons.
Even the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, who rarely finds anything alternative therapy without some caveat to support its use, says:
“* Silver has no known function in the body
* Silver is not an essential mineral supplement or a cure-all and should not be promoted as such
* Claims that there can be a “deficiency” of silver in the body and that such a deficiency can lead to disease are unfounded
* Claims made about the effectiveness of colloidal silver products for numerous diseases are unsupported scientifically
* Colloidal silver products can have serious side effects
* Laboratory analysis has shown that the amounts of silver in supplements vary greatly, which can pose risks to the consumer.”
Of course, this review leaves me with blanks in my SBM gun. I have no data to say there is no reason to use colloidal silver. To combat the testimonials I have, well, nothing. No science and no substance. It is the Oakland of alternative medicine. Except for toxicity, all the supporting data I can find, history, 650 germs killed, Dr. Bjorn Nordstrom, the testimonials, and the formulations of colloidal silver are based on unverifiable information or apparently made up. It is a house of silver cards. However, if the Blue Man Group is looking for members, I know a potential source that will save on makeup costs.

   Honey
Mark Crislip 
Link
I cram for TAM, and, combined with other commitments, not the least of which is that it is finally sunny and warm in Portland, after a year that has resembled All the Summer in a Day, which leads to a relatively short post. There are just so many hours in a day and if possible those days need to be spent in the sun.
In my first year in practice I was sitting on a nursing station writing a note when a patient started howling in pain. Further investigation revealed that the patient had a chronic, open surgical wound and the (old) surgeon had ordered sugar poured into the wound as part of wound care. The cafeteria mistakenly sent up salt, and a metaphor became reality. It did pique my interest in both sugar and honey for wound care, an area where you have to be careful not to fall prey to all the errors in CAM thinking: a reliance on anecdotes, using suboptimal studies as evidence, mistaking a gobbet of basic science as a meaningful clinical application, and not realizing the warping effect of confirmation bias.
That being said, I have suggested honey and sugar for years for patients, and many patients with prior refractory wounds had healing. And what are the three most dangerous words in medicine? In my experience. I have recommended honey less in the era of the wound vac, but there are not an insignificant number of people with insufficient financial resources who cannot afford even simple wound care supplies. Many of the ointments, creams and special bandages for wound care costs too much. Patients also like honey as it is natural (people do love to fall for the naturalistic fallacy) and inexpensive, and I always tell patients that the data is iffy, but not stupid.
Wound itself is mostly a combination of tradition and hype. One doc learned from his attending who learned from their attending, in a line that stretches back to the first barber-surgeon. I was told as a medical student, never put in a wound what you wouldn’t put in your eye, which seemed to be a good guiding principle, although it is expensive to pack a wound with soft contact lenses. New products, often combinations of old treatments, come out monthly with flashy brochures and little good data.
“There is a lack of large, high-quality published RCTs evaluating debridement per se, or comparing different methods of debridement for surgical wounds, to guide clinical decision-making. ”
So I rely on basic principals. Keep the wound clean, keep the new tissue from drying out, remove the dead meat, and keep the bacteria at bay, and do not let your pet lick it are more or less guiding rules in wound care. That, and no matter what you do, most people will heal. My rule remains: take credit for success, blame nursing when things go wrong. That’s ‘humor’ for the sarcasm impaired.
What is the rationale for sugar and honey for wounds and burns?
Basic Biologic Plausibility
The first is mechanism of action is primarily mechanical. The high osmolality of sugar and honey prevents bacterial overgrowth. Food can be preserved in sugar (jam is a good example) so the honey and sugar can prevent or decrease bacterial colonization of wounds. Honey has a low pH and contains hydrogen peroxide, both of which are antibacterial, but I doubt clinical relevance of the latter. And there may be bee and flower constituents that aid in antibacterial properties, although again I wonder about clinical relevance. Also, sugar and honey do not damage new tissues and when the honey is washed off, it painlessly removes the dead tissues with it, so it is good for debridement.
Honey, and to make sure you can charge a premium amount call it medical grade honey, can kill bacteria and decrease skin colonization. Avoid raw honey, as it can contain C. botulinum and has been the source of botulism in children. I don’t expect it would be of much use on facial wrinkles
At least from a basic science perspective, honey and sugar have mechanical, perhaps biochemical, and certainly financial, reasons it could be beneficial in wound care.
Clinical trials
So how are the clinical trials? There are lots of poor quality studies. Almost 400 references if you are in the mood for cherry picking. The preponderance of the poor quality studies points to benefit.
For burns?
“Available evidence indicates markedly greater efficacy of honey compared with alternative dressing treatments for superficial or partial thickness burns, although the limitations of the studies included in the meta-analysis restrict the clinical application of these findings.”
and
“Honey may improve healing times in mild to moderate superficial and partial thickness burns compared with some conventional dressings”
For Wounds?
From the ever helpful and potentially flawed Cochrane reviews:
“Honey dressings as an adjuvant to compression do not significantly increase leg ulcer healing at 12 weeks. There is insufficient evidence to guide clinical practice in other areas.”
and as they note
“The poor quality of most of the trial reports means the results should be interpreted with caution.”
So be it. I have read many of the 400 references over the years, and the sense is that honey is of some value in wound care.
There is even less information of granulated sugar, where it looks encouraging and has been used to treat mediastinitis , diabetic foot ulcers and sloughing wounds.
Of course, honey is not the end all and bee all of treating soft tissue infections. Depending on the process, surgery and antibiotics will do far more to resolve the infection and promote healing, espcially for acute and/or acutely infected wounds. Relying on only natural products has lead to one death in a complimentary practitioner who treated himself with honey:
“a minor injury became infected with gangrene, the judge was told. He died, aged 52, in April 2007. Instead (of standard care) he used honey and magnesium sulphate.”’
The doctor who treats themself has a fool for a patient and an idiot for a doctor.
So in the end, do I recommend honey and sugar? Yes. The literature is interesting and I give patients a long list of caveats. It is maybe sort of probably useful in patients with chronic wounds who cannot afford other interventions. In my experience it always works. Back to TAM.

Candida and Fake Illnesses
While Big Pharma has been accused of inventing diseases, alternative medicine is the real champion of this practice. Compromised immunity can lead to overgrowth of the fungus Candida albicans, but this doesn’t happen in people with intact immune systems, and it doesn’t lead to the vague, unrelated symptoms described as “systematic candidiasis” by alternative medicine proponents.
Steven Novella on September 25, 2013
Link

Savvy consumers have learned over the years that the primary goal of marketing is to create demand for a product or service. This has risen to the point of inventing problems that do not really exist just to sell a product that addresses the fake problem. Who knew that my social status could be destroyed by spotty glassware?
Better yet, if you can make people worry about a nonexistent problem, something that they were not previously aware of and don’t understand, they might buy your solution just to relieve their worry.
This type of “artificial demand” marketing can be very insidious when it occurs with medical products and services. The pharmaceutical industry has been accused of generating artificial demand for some of their drugs. For example, osteopenia is a relative decrease in bone density, but not enough to qualify for osteoporosis. Osteopenia is not really a disease, or even necessarily a mild version of osteoporosis, although it is a risk factor. Merck, however, was happy to broaden the market for its drug for osteoporosis and argue that patients with osteopenia should be treated also, even though the evidence really did not support this.
Sometimes the accusations are flat-out wrong. GSK has been accused of inventing restless leg syndrome (RLS) to sell a failed Parkinson’s drug. In fact the drugs used for RLS are successful Parkinson’s drugs. Further, I found references to RLS in neurology texts going back over 50 years, and there were even older references although not using the same name.
I don’t think the pharmaceutical industry invents new diseases. It seems that they do try to extend the market for their drugs into milder and milder indications, spreading into the gray zone of evidence, but they don’t get to invent their own diseases.
Those who practice medicine outside the constraints imposed by science (and ethics), however, are not above inventing imaginary diseases and conditions out of whole cloth.
Candida
One popular fake illness is chronic candidiasis. Candida albicans is a fungus that colonizes about 90% of the population (meaning it is present in the body but not causing an infection or any problems). It can, however, become an infection, usually at times of stress or immunocompromise. The most common manifestations are thrush (a superficial Candida infection in the mouth) and vaginitis, also commonly referred to as a yeast infection.
Candida can also rarely cause serious systemic infection, but this is mostly restricted to those with compromised immune systems, such as patients undergoing chemotherapy or with advanced AIDS.
Candida became the focus of a fake illness beginning in 1986 with the publication of The Yeast Connection by Dr. William Crook. In this book Crook proposed the idea that systemic candidiasis, or Candida hypersensitivity, was responsible for a host of common conditions and non-specific symptoms, such as fatigue, sexual dysfunction, asthma, and psoriasis.
Over 25 years later Candida hypersensitivity remains an unproven claim, but popular among “alternative” practitioners. The claims have also spread, unhindered by logic and evidence. For example, in a 2009 article in The Huffington Post, Kim Evans claims:
First, an estimated 90 percent of the population has a problem with candida overgrowth, although most don’t know it. And second, candida overgrowth can be the root cause of literally hundreds of different problems in the body.
And:
It’s also fascinating that an oncologist in Rome, Dr. Tullio Simoncini, says that cancer is a fungus and actually an advanced form of candida overgrowth.
There is absolutely no science behind the claim that 90 percent of the population “have a problem with candida” or that Candida causes cancer, or that cancer is actually a fungal infection.
Of course, fake illnesses require fake treatments, and they are numerous for Candida. One such example, ZapCandida, claims:
Fungus is the silent killer that robs you of your life-force, controls how you feel, and even how you think, this website will not only help you understand what fungus, Candida Albicans among others, and its relation to severe skin-issues, it will introduce you to a little known method to heal yourself by reclaiming your Immune system.
They don’t say what their treatment actually is – it sounds like some type of supplement with lifestyle advice to avoid Candida.
While there is precious little in the published literature about Candida hypersensitivity, the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology did review the claims and evidence and concluded:
     1.  The concept is speculative and unproven.
     2.  Elements of the proposed treatment program are potentially dangerous.
I could only find a single double-blind placebo controlled trial of treatment for Candida hypersensitivity, which found:
In women with presumed candidiasis hypersensitivity syndrome, nystatin does not reduce systemic or psychological symptoms significantly more than placebo. Consequently, the empirical recommendation of long-term nystatin therapy for such women appears to be unwarranted.
Dr. Crook himself conducted no research to demonstrate the claims he made in his popular book. He essentially bypassed research, peer review, and scientific consensus and went straight to public promotion.
Conclusion: Candida hypersensitivity isn’t real
Candida hypersensitivity is an implausible syndrome, simply another “one cause of all disease” alternative claim. Such claims are useful only for generating demand for fanciful and worthless treatments.

Black mold is the new Candida
How concerned should we be about mold in our homes and environment?
Scott Gavura on January 18, 2024
Link

How concerned should we be about mold in our homes and environment?
With the disintegration of Xitter, I’ve turned my social-media attention to what appears to be far more useful waste of time: Reddit. Reddit is amazing in that there’s a subreddit for every possible topic you can think of. The content is human- and not bot-generated, and the best comments rise to the top – based on reader votes. One of the subreddits that I enjoy following is called Cleaning Tips, which is pretty much exactly as described – people ask for advice on how to clean different objects, and other people comment. Some of the before and after photos are both horrifying and satisfying. One of the major concerns of the community seems to be black mold, something that everyone has likely seen but some people are truly frightened of. I thought it was just odd and didn’t think much about it until one of my regular podcast listens, Unbiased Science dedicated an entire episode to debunking fearmongering about black mold. Listening to it I learned that there’s a growing concern about black mold, fueled by social media. Google searches bear this out. The podcast made me reflect back on earlier in my pharmacy career, when just of school, I learned (acccording to my local pharmacy’s customers) that the root of all illness was just one thing: Candida, a yeast. Is black mold the new Candida?
Old School yeast fears
Concerns about Candida – yeast – seemed common over 20 years ago. Most chronic diseases could be traced back to Candida, patients informed me. And pharmacies did little to dissuade it – some even sold “Candida removal” kits. These didn’t contain antifungal drugs – most were combinations of laxative and purgatives, combined with psyllium and bentonite clay, all promising to sponge up toxins and Candida and restore health. There was a strict diet to be followed, too: No sugar, no bread – anything it was thought the yeast would consume. While you can still find these kits for sale, the enthusiasm for them seems to have waned. Whether consumers have caught on that these kits are useless, or have abandoned them because they don’t actually treat any underlying medical issues, isn’t clear.
New School mold fears
Molds and mold spores are are everywhere – indoors and outdoor. They are carried in the air and on your clothes. When molds encounter excessive moisture, typically in places like bathrooms, they will grow. Many materials inside our home can support mold growth, such as carpets, ceiling tiles, furniture, and drywall.
Moldy environments can cause a variety of health effects, but they are not certain to. Some people are sensitive to molds, and they may describe symptoms like congestion, wheezing and itchy eyes. Those with existing lung diseases, like asthma or chronic obstructive lung disease, may have more severe reactions. For these people, exposure to molds can lead to symptoms such as stuffy nose, wheezing, and red or itchy eyes, or skin. Some occupations may face regular exposure to significant amounts of mold (e.g., farming) and they may also experience more pronounced reactions.
Social media and influences appears to be driving fears about molds. Dave Asprey (the guy who puts butter in his coffee) writes about “mold poisoning” and promotes a long list of supplements to help you “recover” from “mold toxicity”.
Posts on black mold have millions of views on TikTok. Any form of mold, no matter how small, is blamed on any health-related concern. Mold is said to change how you will feel and even how you look. Weight gain is blamed on mold. So is weight loss. Celebrities blame mold for sickening their children. You can even find advice about how to keep mold out of the latest social-media-must-have, the Stanley Quencher.
Understanding molds
Mold is a common term used to describe a visible collection of fungi that develop as multicellular filaments or hyphae, which then come together to form web-like structures. Incredibly, while 100,000 fungi have been identified, the actual diversity of fungi is thought to be at least 7 to 10 times greater. Millions of fungal species have not yet been described and classified.
Fungi in the soil and on plants play crucial roles in breaking down organic matter, making essential nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus available to other organisms. The survival of many plants relies on mycorrhiza, a symbiotic relationship between a fungus’s mycelium and a plant’s roots, facilitating the supply of water and essential nutrients to the plant.
Yeasts (which are single-celled fungi) and molds are critical to foods like bread and certain cheeses, as well as delicious beverages like beer and wine. They also serve as sources for medications, including antibiotics, immunosuppressants, and the statin drugs.
Both outdoor and indoor environments have microbiomes of molds, with their levels indoors being strongly influenced by their outdoor counterparts. Molds and other fungi are everywhere. They cannot be avoided – they live on our skin and in our mouths – and we are constantly exposed to them.
With molds ubiquitous, our immune system is naturally pretty adept at dealing with them. There are some cases where disease is known to occur. One example would be rare diseases like “farmers’ lung” or “pigeon breeders’ disease”. Infections can also occur in the immunocompromised – think untreated HIV, or patients being treated for some forms of cancer.
Evidence and expert opinion
Exposure to molds and the impact on health and in particular, air quality, have been examined. In 2004 the Institute of Medicine (IOM) found there was sufficient evidence to link indoor exposure to mold with upper respiratory tract (nose and throat) symptoms, cough, and wheezing in otherwise health individuals, with asthma symptoms in people with asthma; and with hypersensitivity pneumonitis (which is a rare immune-mediated condition) in susceptible individuals.
The World Health Organization also has a guideline on indoor air quality. It summarizes the evidence (as of 2009) on problems associated with moisture and exposure to molds. That review concludes that the most common effects are an increase prevalence of respiratory symptoms, allergies and asthma:
Our review of the epidemiological evidence presented in this report, the previous review by the Institute of Medicine and the quantitative meta-analysis of Fisk, Lei-Gomez and Mendell (2007) leads us to conclude that there is sufficient evidence of an association between indoor dampness-related factors and a wide range of respiratory health effects (Table 8), including asthma development, asthma exacerbation, current asthma, respiratory infections, upper respiratory tract symptoms, cough, wheeze and dyspnoea.
The CDC has a page on molds. It says,
Exposure to damp and moldy environments may cause a variety of health effects, or none at all. Some people are sensitive to molds. For these people, exposure to molds can lead to symptoms such as stuffy nose, wheezing, and red or itchy eyes, or skin. Some people, such as those with allergies to molds or with asthma, may have more intense reactions. Severe reactions may occur among workers exposed to large amounts of molds in occupational settings, such as farmers working around moldy hay. Severe reactions may include fever and shortness of breath.
Some molds are “toxigenic”, producing “mycotoxins”. Color is not an indication of how dangerous a mold may be, or if it produces mycotoxins. A review article from 2017, entitled “Mold and Human Health: a Reality Check” published in Clinical Reviews in Allergy and Immunology, provides an overview of concerns about molds and the accumulated evidence. It concludes:
Molds and fungi are ubiquitous and generally live in harmony with human beings. Only rare molds have been associated with human disease. The diseases that molds can cause are restricted to allergies, hypersensitivity pneumonitis and infection. There is no validity to the hype of “toxic black mold” and “mycotoxicosis.” Humans are not exposed to enough mycotoxins to develop illness, unless they ingest toxic quantities of mycotoxins or become exposed to intense organic dust storms.
Are molds the new…Candida? Or gluten?
When I started this post I saw the parallels between fears about black mold and worries about Candida. But there was something in between. Remember several years ago when all sorts of health ills were being blamed on gluten? This wasn’t previously-undiagnosed Celiac disease, or even subtle Irritable Bowel – it was the ascribing of vague health concerns health ills to a bogeyman in our diets. While the craze for gluten-free foods exploded (which was admittedly good for those with Celiac disease), my sense is that most people went back to breads and gave up on cauliflower pizza crust. Today, it looks like mold is that new substance that social media is hypervigilant about.
Like gluten, mold can be be potentially harmful in some circumstances, especially in individuals who may be predisposed. There is no argument from health organizations that mold, when identified in our homes, should be removed. We should look for evidence of mold whenever there is water damage, and clean or remove anything that is moldy. When there is mold growth in our carpets, walls or insulation, the only way to fix it is to remove it. It is also important to regulate moisture and humidity to reduce the likelihood of mold growth. However, it’s worth noting that the CDC does not recommend routine sampling for molds. There’s also no evidence that mold toxins cause diseases in people, so you don’t need to detox after mold exposure – you simply need to reduce your exposure. Unapproved or unvalidated diagnostic studies and treatments based on theoretical infections or suspected toxicity are both useless and potentially costly.
Like much pseudoscience, there is a kernel of truth at the heart of mold fears. Regrettably and also somewhat predictably, mold has become are marketer’s dream and the anxious consumer’s nightmare. I have no doubt that in a few years time, I’ll be describing some new product as “the new black mold”.

   Delusional Parasitosis
Steven Novella
Link
A new study looks into the disorder known as delusional parasitosis, which many dermatologists believe is the true diagnosis behind the controversial disorder called Morgellon’s disease. Morgellons is a controversial disorder because many patients with symptoms believe they are being infected by an unusual organism, causing excessive itching, but no offending organism has been found. Some patients claim they have strange fibers exuding from the sores in their skin.
The term “Morgellons” was coined in 2002 by Mary Leitao, who was trying to find a diagnosis for her son who was suffering from skin lesions. Since then it has become a grassroots diagnosis – used by some patients to describe themselves but not accepted by the medical community.
Most dermatologists, rather, feel that the disorder is actually a manifestation of delusional parasitosis – a mental disorder. This has set up an unnecessarily confrontational situation. And of course, some charlatans are exploiting the situation by taking the side of the patients and offering them their nostrums as a cure.
These situations are always helped, but rarely resolved, by better information. It is in this context that Hylwa et al performed a retrospective analysis of patients diagnosed with delusional parasitosis at the Mayo dermatology clinic. They analyzed records from 108 patients who had either a skin biopsy (80 patients) or presented their own sample (a patient-provided specimen – also 80 patient), or both (52 patients).
They found that in all 108 cases no evidence of infection or infestation was found.
They did find, however, that 48% of biopsies showed dermatitis – inflammation of the skin. This finding has two plausible interpretations. The first is that in some patients with delusional parasitosis, they may have an underlying skin condition that causes non-specific dermatitis (an allergy, for example) and the symptoms of this dermatitis triggers the psychological reaction that results in the belief that they are infested with something foreign. In this case they could be simply misinterpreted their skin sensations. Further the chronic symptoms can cause stress and lack of sleep and result in the anxiety and depression that often accompanies this disorder.
The other plausible interpretation is that the dermatitis is secondary to scratching and perhaps treating the skin with irritating substances intended to treat the problem. The current study is not capable of distinguishing between these two possibilities.
The authors acknowledge the limitations of this study – mainly that it was retrospective. It also needs to be considered that their search criteria was for patients diagnosed with delusional parasitosis – not all patients with unknown or mysterious skin lesions. In that respect the results are not surprising – the diagnosis may result from a negative biopsy or sample analysis, and so of course patients with that diagnosis will have had a negative biopsy.
The authors do not even address the controversy surrounding Morgellons. Rather they are asking if skin biopsy is useful in patients presenting clinically with delusional parasitosis. Again – given the retrospective nature of this study I don’t think it answers that question.
This study does, however, review a large series of cases demonstrating a lack of biopsy or sample analysis findings in patients who fit within the clinical syndrome that is labeled as either Morgellons or delusional parasitosis. It should further be noted that those who claim that Morgellons is a distinct disease caused by a skin infestation cannot point to any objective evidence of an actual infestation to support that claim.
What proponents do have are mysterious fibers sometimes found in the skin lesions of people with this syndrome. The fibers often cannot be specifically identified, or they are identified as foreign fibers consistent with clothing. They usually do not appear to be of organic origin. At best the fibers represent an anomaly, and are not specific evidence of any underlying cause.
What is especially disturbing about the Morgellons phenomenon is the tone of the discussion, the extent to which the controversy has been politicized. Often irrelevant issues are brought to the forefront, such as patient empowerment or medical authority. Not that these issues are not important – they are just not relevant to the real question of what, exactly, is the underlying cause of what is referred to as Morgellons.
Patients who suffer from this syndrome are best served by bringing objective scientific evidence to bear to discover exactly what the cause(s) and best treatments for their symptoms are. But this issue is often derailed by accusations that the medical community is dismissing them and their claims. By grabbing the reigns of diagnosis and treatment such patients are given a false sense of empowerment, but are likely just cutting short earnest attempts to understand and treat their condition.
And of course, good science has to follow the evidence wherever it leads, even if the answer is not what is hoped. The truth does not care what people need or want – it is what it is.
Conclusion
This latest study will likely not change the debate about Morgellons vs delusional parasitosis. Although it should be kept in mind that delusional parasitosis (DP) is a disorder in its own right, and pre-existed any notion of Morgellons. Morgellons is likely just a recent manifestation of DP – a cultural entity spreading mainly on the internet. It should also be noted that DP likely contains two or more subgroups that have distinct causes – such as the two causes of dermatitis I discussed above.
At present there is no compelling evidence that Morgellons exists as a discrete entity separate from DP. The CDC is currently studying the condition (which they are calling unexplained dermopathy) but has not yet made any report of their findings.
My review of the evidence is that it best supports the conclusion that Morgellons is a mostly a psychocultural condition (it may be triggered in cases by an underlying skin condition). It is a combination of a cultural phenomenon spreading mostly online, giving specific manifestation to an underlying psychological condition. I am willing to be convinced that there is a biological process going on, but so far no compelling evidence to support this hypothesis has been put forward.
I also think that specific harm can be done to individuals with this syndrome by the spread of false information. Sufferers can easily be made to settle prematurely on a false conclusion, and in fact can reinforce their delusions if that is ultimate cause of their symptoms. They can be lured away from practical interventions and the medical community to dubious treatments that are, if nothing else, a waste of their resources.
The situation represents a challenge to the medical community. Perhaps the only solution is to explain and promote the scientific approach to diagnosis and treatment.

   Morgellon's Itching and the Imaginary Passenger Brake
Wallace Sampson
Link
The press and government agencies ally to shine a disproportionate amount of publicity on false and improbable medical ideas. (Danger: Congressmen and reporters at work.)
The latest was a press release from either the Centers for Disease Control (and prevention? – I’ll get to the “prevention” part later,) or from Kaiser-Permanente Medical Group. Three Bay Area newspapers carried simultaneous articles. The articles announced a new, $338,000 CDC/Permanente study of something they call “Morgellon’s disease.” I say they call it that because what they are describing is not what was originally described as “Morgellon’s,” but what is most likely a form of somatiform illness – delusional parasitosis, or neurodermatitis.
What is Morgellon’s and why is CDC funding Kaiser/Permanente with $338,000 to study it? I was never taught about anything called Morgellon’s, and althoughI had practiced medicine for forty years, I still had not known of it until several years ago when a group of affected San Francisco patients and R L Stricker MD, were reported as having a number of cases of it.
It turns out that in 2001, a South Carolina biologist named Mary Leitao, mother of a young son who complained of painful, itching skin lesions, somehow found reference to an obscure report of a disorder describd by a person named Morgellon from 17th century France. A drawing from that period or later showed a skin opening with a sizeable wormlike object protruding from it. From the picture, the mother proposed her son had a form of that disorder, and she named it Morgellon’s. No such disorder was known to exist in modern times.
In 2006, newspapers reported that SF’s Dr. Stricker and another physician had accumulated increasing numbers of patients complaining of similar symptoms. The Bay Area, Los Angeles, Florida and a few other areas became centers of these cases, but then reports began coming from UK, Australia, and Canada. No specific diagnosis could be made on these people, whose skin lesions they reported exuded fine threads of black, blue, red, or white material. No constant bacterial cultures were found, but the physicians treated patients with antibiotics, nevertheless. They claim that they found high incidence of antibodies to the bacterial agent of Lyme disease. The sources of the pieces of fine thread could not be identified, but suspicions were that they came from clothing and other materials, rubbed into the breaks in the skin, produced by scratching.
Cases accumulated world-wide, most reports came from English speaking countries. Dermatologists recognized the paients as having “delusional parasitosis,” and treated them with anti-depressants on the assumtion of a somatiform reaction to anxiety or depression.
If this all sounds familiar, it should. A similar phenomenon in the mid-1980s began at South Lake Tahoe when a single internist claimed that scores of people accumulated in his practice, all of whom reported chronic fatigue, mental fogginess, muscle aches, and other symptoms but with no physical findings. (Ask any internist or family practitioner what percent of patients have those symptoms.) That was the germ of the chronic fatigue syndrome epidemic that resulted when millions of people who were feeling tired or depressed suddenly realized they could have a real disease, and bandwaggoned together to form a mass sociogenic illness of unprecedented volume. Newsweek and other news sources reported the problem as a real organic disease, estimating some 2 million cases in ther US alone. Curiously, no such masses accumulated in most other countries. CDC is still “looking into it” spending millions of dollars on what has been historically established as a mass delusion.
The late Stephen Straus made his reputation when assigned to lead the NIH investigation into chronic fatigue, leading to his eventual appointment as the last Director of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. (He never solved the “problem” but added to the confusion by finding non-specific blood pressure and other changes in CFS patients.)
A characteristic of episodic, localized sociogenic illesses – sick building syndrome, schoolgirl fainting, etc. – is that they spread by line of sight. Interestingly, this current epidemic spreads locally via a line of sight surrogate – local TV reports and newspaper columns, and that the predominant reported early centers were all in English speaking countries.
The likelihood of “Morgellon’s” being an organic disease – bacterial, viral, or auto-immune – is vanishingly small. Physical symptoms like itching are almost universal, but kept below the horizon of awareness or concern, overwhelmed by the multiplicity of normal external stimuli, and suppressed through consciousness and other mechanisms. All one has to do is to concentrate on them or allow expression through depression or other causes, and they can magnify to frightening degrees. The physician sees nothing but the patient’s depression and concern, the patient rejects attempts at reassurance as disbelief or lack of understanding, accusations of professional neglect and conspiracies accumulate, reinforcing patient mistrust, and on it goes.
But criteria for diagnosis of emotional and psychological conditions are rarely physical or objective, so the CDC and Permanente experts will have severe credibility problems if they try to classify the problems as “functional” or somatiform. This “epidemic” is something best left on a lower key level, examined by physicians and other medical scientists in universities and academic institutions, not by government agencies, under pressure from members of Congress.
Now about that imaginary brake; a new radio commercial states that Mercedes Benz engineers recently experimented and determined that the passenger side “imaginary brake” that the passenger “uses” in certain urgent situations “does not work.” A clever ad, but also a real-life example of how imagination results in real organic responses, in this case motor rather than sensory – but quite real, nevertheless.
On to the prevention business. The CDC taking on this investigation and its probable unresolved ending a decade or more away, as with the NCCAM, gives legitimacy to the false idea that “there might be something there.” This unexpected consequence is likely to cause further spread of this imaginary disease and classic somatiform illness. All parties would benefit from reading Edward Shorter’s “From Paralysis to Fatigue.”

   Parasites
Mark Crislip 
Link
I saw a patient recently for parasites.
I get a sinking feeling when I see that diagnosis on the schedule, as it rarely means a real parasite. The great Pacific NW is mostly parasite free, so either it is a traveler or someone with delusions of parasitism.
The latter comes in two forms: the classic form and Morgellons. Neither are likely to lead to a meaningful patient-doctor interaction, since it usually means conflict between my assessment of the problem and the patients assessment of the problem. There is rarely a middle ground upon which to meet. The most memorable case of delusions of parasitism I have seen was a patient who I saw in clinic who, while we talked, ate a raw garlic clove about every minute.
“Why the garlic?” I asked.
“To keep the parasites at bay,” he told me.
I asked him to describe the parasite. He told me they floated in the air, fell on his skin, and then burrowed in. Then he later plucked them out of his nose.
At this point he took out a large bottle that rattled as he shook it.
“I keep them in here,” he said as he screwed off the lid and dumped about 3 cups with of dried boogers on the exam table.
To my credit I neither screamed nor vomited, although for a year I could not eat garlic. It was during this time I was attacked by a vampire, and joined the ranks of the undead.
I have seen the occasional earthworm thought to be an intestinal parasite. Sometimes people start to pay attention to their stool, often for the first time, and note tube like structures that move in the water. Most likely mucous or undigested fiber wafting in the gentle currents of the toilet water. Doesn’t that sound romantic? The contents of the average stool, like hot dogs and laws, are better left unexamined. In those patients, an examination of the stool for worms and worm eggs is usually unrevealing and makes me glad I am not a microbiology technician.
Morgellons is, as best I can tell, a variant of delusions of parasitism.
Here is a thing about germs in general and parasites specifically: they have patterns and can be seen. There are patterns of disease and patterns of their life cycle. You can tell when a disease is probably delusional because the “organisms” have no understandable pattern in the life cycle, the disease, the physiology, the anatomy or the epidemiology.
And germs can be seen. Well, most germs. Single celled organisms can be tricky and may require special stains to be seen under the microscope. Viruses are, of course, too small to be seen by a lab microscope. But parasites? Worms? These wee beasties are multicellular. They are big. Not a long way to the chemists big, but sizable, not hard to see with a microscope unless they have Romulan cloaking technology.
So what is Morgellons?
Before we continue, I would like to clarify one thing. I see patients self diagnosed with Chronic Candida Syndrome or Morgellons or Chronic Lyme or some other process. I do not doubt these people are ill and have symptoms that can be severe and life altering. What I may disagree with the patient is the reason for these symptoms. As best I can tell none of the above are due to an infectious disease.
Unfortunately when the patient is convinced they have an etiology for their symptoms and I think that their reason is nonsense, it does not lead to a therapeutic physician-patient interaction. I try and phrase it as gently and non-judgmentally as possible, but it rarely leads to a good time in the clinic.
Morgellons has existed as a disease since about 2002 and is an internet phenomena right up there with Rebecca Black. See. For a 54 year old man, I am hip. Morgellons received its name from a paper from 1935 called SIR THOMAS BROWNE AND THE DISEASE CALLED THE MORGELLONS By C.E. KELLETT, M.D., M.R.C.P. and published in Annals of Medical History, n.s., VII (1935), 467-479, where it refers to a disease from the 1600′s (yes 1600′s) described by said Thomas Browne.
“Hairs which have most amused me have not been in the face or head, but on the Back, and not in Men but Children, as I long ago observed in that endemial Distemper of little Children in Languedock, called the Morgellons, wherein they critically break out with harsh Hairs on their Backs, which takes off the unquiet symptoms of the Disease, and delivers them from Coughs and Convulsions.”
Who know what these hairs/worms really were; the 1600′s were not a time noted for its diagnostic accuracy. Unlike the modern disease, it was usually a disease of children and often fatal, so whether these “hairs” had anything to do with the disease or were actual living creatures, one cannot say.
In 1715 when the first microscopist, Leuvenhoeck, took a look at the bristles and thought them “inanimate”, starting a long tradition of looking at the detritus presented by Morgellons patients and seeing nothing. I, for one, always look at the fluff brought in by Morgellons patients and have yet to see anything resembling a living creature. Diseases have come and gone in the past, like the English Sweating Sickness, so maybe there was a plague of virulent hairs (that’s hair not hare, it was not a virulent bunny, for which Hef is undoubtedly grateful), but no longer.
Fast forward 400 years. Round about 2002 this disease was described on the net in regards a child with the symptoms now referred to as Morgellons, and since others have had the disease. It is transmissible as an internet meme, but not spread person to person.
What are the distinguishing characteristics of Morgellons? Here are features as noted from the Morgellons Research Foundation
1. “Filaments” are reported in and on skin lesions and at times extruding from intact-appearing skin. White, blue, red, and black are common among described fiber colors. Size is near microscopic, and good clinical visualization requires 10-30 X. Patients frequently describe ultraviolet light generated fluorescence. They also report black or white granules, similar in size and shape to sand grains, on or in their skin or on clothing. Most clinicians willing to invest in a simple hand held commercial microscope have thus far been able to consistently document the filaments.
2. Movement sensations, both beneath and on the skin surface. Sensations are often described by the patient as intermittently moving, stinging or biting. Involved areas can include any skin region (such as over limbs or trunk), but may be limited to the scalp, nasal passages, ear canals, or face…and curiously, legs below the knees.
3. Skin lesions, both (a) spontaneously appearing and (b) self-generated, often with pain or intense itching. The former (a) may initially appear as “hive-like”, or as “pimple-like” with or without a white center. The latter (b) appear as linear or “picking” excoriations. Even when not self-generated (as in unreachable regions of babies’ skin), lesions often progress to open wounds that heal incompletely (e.g., heal very slowly with discolored epidermis or seal over with a thick gelatinous outer layer.). Evidence of lesions persists visually for years.
4. Musculoskeletal Effects and Pain is usually present, manifest in several ways. Pain distribution is broad, and can include joint(s), muscles, tendons and connective tissue. Both vascular and “pressure” headaches and vertebral pain are particularly common, the latter usually with premature (e.g., age 20) signs of degeneration of both discs and vertebrae.
5. Aerobic limitation is universal and significant enough to interfere with the activities of daily living. Most patients meet the Fukuda Criteria for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome as well (Fukuda, Ann. Int. Med., 1994). Cardiology data and consistently elevated heart rates suggest a persistent myocarditis creating lowered cardiac output that has been partially compensated for by Starling’s Law.
6. Cognitive dysfunction, includes frontal lobe processing signs interfering with logical thinking as well as short-term memory and attention deficit. All are measurable by Standard Psychometric Test batteries.
7. Emotional effects are present in most patients. Character typically includes loss or limitation of boundary control (as in bipolar illness) and intermittent obsessional state. Degree varies greatly from virtually absent to seriously life altering. “
It is the filaments. Over the years I have seen a smattering of Morgellons and they bring in the filaments and I look at them under the microscope. I see hairs, and threads, and non-specific detritus, but never anything that resembles the results of a living creature. I have looked carefully at the skin of these patients, and have never seen an intradermal fiber.
So you can see why I am skeptical that this is anything but a version of delusions of parasitism. In one series of 25 patients
Most patients in this study (23 out of 25) had prior psychiatric diagnoses (most determined by specialists) as follows: 11 out of 25 bipolar disease; 7 out of 25 Adult ADD; 4 out of 25 Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD); and 1 out of 25 Schizophrenia.
The same study had a hodgepodge of lab abnormalities, but there were not compared to matched controls. It may well be that the patients have some underlying inflammatory process that causes skin lesions and a feeling of the creepy crawlies and are misidentifying standard environmental material as associated with the diseases. But I am skeptical.
Against this hypothesis are the case reports where Morgellons is cured with Pimozide, an antipsychotic. Delusions of parasitism is often treated with olanzapine, another antipsychotic, but others have suggested pimozide is superior. Most infections would be unlikely to respond to antipsychotics, but I have never been satisfied with response to treatment as a means for confirming a diagnosis, that is a path better not followed without good reason. In my world docs often think if patients are improving on antibiotics the response is considered evidence of infection. I know better. But given the lack of a demonstrable parasite, a response to psychiatric medications is certainly suggestive.
So response to anti-psychotics would suggest patients with Morgellons could have a psychosis, but I keep in mind it does not necessarily extrapolate to all patients. I try to bear in mind that when patients present with odd symptoms that they attribute to worms and parasites, it may be simple misunderstanding.
As of this entry, no one has fulfilled Kochs postulates with Morgellons.
For those not immersed in infectious diseases, Koccs postulates were a series of criteria to demonstrate the causality of infections, Here there are, with the word filament substituted for microorganisms:
1) The filament must be found in abundance in all organisms suffering from the disease, but should not be found in healthy organisms.
2) The micro filaments must be isolated from a diseased organism and grown in pure culture.
3) The cultured filament should cause disease when introduced into a healthy organism.
4) The filament must be re isolated from the inoculated, diseased experimental host and identified as being identical to the original specific causative agent.
So far proponents of the disease are 0 for 4.
But if this disease is due something that can be visualized with the naked eye or a magnifying glass, it should be simple enough to characterize. Lets say you are a DNP and a member of ILADS. Well, I have to admit that you have lost some credibility with me. But lets say you saw a series of patients with Morgellons and you could see the fibers. There, right there. You can see them. Would you not biopsy the fibers? Would you not try to characterize them? Nope. So aggravating. It boggles the mind that someone could have a diagnostic coup right in front of them and let it pass.
Delusions of parasitism can be nosocomial. Well, not truly delusions, but patients can be convinced they have parasites when, in fact, they do not, and waste serious amounts of time and cash in pursuit of an imaginary diagnoses.
I recently saw a patient who had unexplained abdominal pain for a year and a half. The patient had an extensive evaluation and no explanation for the symptoms, and, looking for answers, eventually wandered into the arms of a naturopath.
One of the shows my eldest liked to watch was I Love the 80′s on VH1. The 80′s was the decade I was in medical school, residency and fellowship. When I watched I Love the 80′s I recognized virtually nothing of popular culture of time. Not the TV shows, the hair styles, the music. Nothing. It really brought home how consuming becoming a doc and a subspecialist is. A decade of my life was spent understanding medicine and infectious diseases. I am not complaining, mind you. There are lots of reasons people go to an alt med provider, but I do not think gullibility is on the list.
The patient with the abdominal pain and their spouse are educated people, why would they see a naturopath?
Looking for answers. Their areas of knowledge are totally removed from medicine and science, and while it is popular to bemoan the science illiteracy of the US population, and it is sorry, if your career arc was law, or finance or auto repair, or stoner at the 7/11, are you going to find time to become literate in medicine? Doubt it. I can’t design a bridge or fly a jet. Why would I expect someone who has mastered these tasks to understand medicine? There are just so many hours in a day to accomplish tasks.
I have, as a further example, zero idea if my mechanic is giving me good diagnostic and repair advice on my car. I have to take everything he says on faith. I have neither the time or inclination to become expert in car repair, and most people do not have the time to become fluent in medicine. Am I gullible? I do not think so.
I had my epiphany years ago when I told a father of a meningitis patient, your daughter has an infection in the fluid that surrounds her brain and he replied, could you phrase that in a way I can understand it? He had no idea of basic brain anatomy or infections, and why would he? So I drew him a picture. It helped.
So anyway, the patient wandered into the lair of a naturopath and was diagnosed with parasites. Now mind you, the patient did not have symptoms that could be reasonably ascribed to parasites or worms, and, more importantly, had no risks for parasites or worms. The industrialized West is reasonably free of worms and their brethren. The naturopath did not do serology or blood work or even a simple stool study looking for the eggs of various worms. It is how I, along with a history and physical looking for the pattern of disease that marks a parasite, come to a diagnosis. No, he or she (I do not remember the pronoun used at the time) proudly used electrodiagnosis.
Proudly. As my patient related it to me, the naturopath, a graduate of Bastyr, (if there is an legitimate opportunity for a deliberate mispronunciation, it is with Bastyr) considered herself to be an expert in parasite treatment and diagnosis.
What is electrodiagnosis you ask?
There are many devices out there, so I do not know precisely which one the patient used.
My patient said they held an electrode in each hand, the naturopathic expert in parasitology twirled a dial, and told them that the reading indicated parasites. Really. I am proud that I did not burst out laughing during the interview, as from my perspective it was a ludicrous joke. But, as I mentioned, not everyone knows what I do, and EEG’s and EKG’s can also diagnoses a variety of medical problems, so why not parasite infestation?
Electrodiagnosis are said to measure disturbances in the body’s flow of “electro-magnetic energy” along “acupuncture meridians” but are expensive galvanometers that measure electrical resistance of the patient’s skin when touched by a probe. Two pseudosciences in one. I have seen better. It is sometimes called electroacupuncture according to Voll, or EAV, and was pulled out of Dr. Volls backside in the 1950′s.
“The basic concept for all of the ElectroDermal screening devices, was the invention of Dr. Reinhardt Voll[1], who in the 1940s, discovered that the electrical resistance of the human body is not homogenous and that meridians existed over the body which may be demonstrated as electrical fields. Furthermore, he showed that the skin is a semi-insulator to the outside environment. By the 1950s Voll had learned that the body had at least 1000 points on the skin which followed the 12 lines of the classical Chinese meridians. Each of these points, Voll[2] called a Measurement Point (MP). Working with an engineer, Fritz Werner, Voll created an instrument to measure the skin resistance at each of the acupuncture points, patterned after a technique called Galvanic Skin Resistance (GSR). This was named Point Testing. In 1953, Voll had established the procedure that became known as Electro-Acupuncture according to Voll.”
There is zero validity to making any diagnosis this way. Except, of course, the E-Meter of Scientology. I wouldn’t want to cross the them there Scientologists. Oh no, uh uh. No way. E-meter forever. But those other electronic diagnostic devices? Pure bunkum. I could not say it better than Quackwatch:
“The devices are used to diagnose nonexistent health problems, select inappropriate treatment, and defraud insurance companies. The practitioners who use them are either delusional, dishonest, or both.”
That the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians has a position statement on electrodiagnosis that considers it experimental is another sign that naturopaths have no business taking care of people. To quote their position paper
“There are three levels of electro-diagnosis:
a. Meridian testing: Readings are interpreted in indicate strength of specific meridians, organ strength or physiologic function.
b. Remedy testing: Variations in readings are interpreted when remedies are given to the patient either orally, to hold or put on a “testing plate” wired to the electrodiagnostic equipment. Interpretations may include sensitivities, nutritional enhancement, or improved function.
c. Energy medicines: Electrodiagnostic equipment interprets information and manufactures an energy medicine which is given to the patient to take orally.
THEREFORE IT IS THE POSITION OF THE AANP THAT:
It is appropriate that the naturopathic profession pursue scientific research regarding the reproducibility and reliability .”
There is nothing on the Pubmeds on the validity of electrodiagnosis, and, on basic principals and prior probability, to suspect that electrodiagnosis would have any utility in the diagnosis of parasites or anything other disease.
Despite this, my patient received prolonged courses of mebendazole, thiabendazole and praziquantel, all at half doses, and all out of pocket.
Uncertain of which parasite to kill, the naturopath tried to kill them all with under-dosed medications. Good thing, come to think of it, that he did not use his infernal contraption to diagnose cancer, who knows how many anticancer treatments would have been prescribed.
And what is an energy medication and how does one manufacture them? Besides a triple shot of espresso? The principals of EAV have been expanded for
“BioScan (remote DNA resonant testing) – This procedure utilizes extremely sensitive EAV computerized equipment to accurately measure stressors in the body. It bombards the clients sample DNA (usually hair) with up to 10,000 frequencies to locate bacteria, viruses, pesticides, heavy metals, industrial pollutants, chemicals, parasites, foods, allergies, dental materials, trees, weeds, pollens, inhalants, molds, yeast, fungus and many other substances that poison the environment today. These stressors and related deficiencies are identified in print form for the client along with the organs and glands affected by the stressors. Supplements are suggested that resonate with the test subject and homeopathics are customized to support the body to remove the stressors and return to homeostasis.”
Only 275 dollars, plus 5 dollars shipping and handling. And they recommend a minimum of 4 evaluations.
Try as I might, I cannot write a satisfying concluding paragraph to this entry, so I will just stop.

   Parasite Cleanse
Link
Steven Novella on March 13, 2024
Tik Tok is a cesspool of wellness pseudoscience and misinformation. All of social media has the potential to spread misinformation without any filter, but for some reason Tik Tok has become the preferred platform for the most outrageous claims and nonsense.
A recent trend on Tik Tok (and within the wellness community generally) is the parasite cleanse. The idea is that many people are walking around with GI parasites and don’t know it, and so a regular parasite cleanse should be part of a healthy routine. These claims are false and potentially dangerous.
Parasites are organisms that live on or inside other organisms as part of their lifecycle. They can exist chronically without causing an acute infection. Gastrointestinal parasites, like worms, can cause gas, diarrhea, bloating, stomach pains, fatigue and weight loss. Of course, a lot of other things can cause these symptoms as well.
This creates a perfect setup for a typical wellness scam – scare people into thinking they may have some otherwise rare or fake illness, then sell them a snake oil treatment for said illness. It’s best (for cash flow) if the treatment has to be done on a routine basis indefinitely.
While parasitic infections are a real thing, they are extremely rare in industrialized nations. We have the privilege of being able to easily prevent such infections – don’t eat raw or undercooked meat, and don’t drink “raw” water or untreated water. That’s pretty much it, and it’s really easy if you live in the US. Traveling to parts of the world where parasites are endemic and with poor hygiene is the main risk factor for people living in developed nations for getting parasites. It’s also possible if you eat food you hunted without preparing it or inspecting it properly, or if you camp and drink untreated spring water.
For most people it is not something you have to worry about. In the rare event that you may somehow contract a parasite, this is a serious medical condition and requires real medical treatment with medication. A “cleanse” won’t be enough if you actually have a parasite. See your medical doctor.
Here is just one example from Tik Tok – fearmongering over a case where someone had parasite eggs in their brain presenting as a “migraine”. First, anyone with a new headache is likely to get imaging, which can easily make the diagnosis, as it did in this case. Treatment with actual medicine is then required.
But the Tik Tok producer uses this case to claim that everyone should do a parasite cleanse multiple times a year. That would not have helped or prevented the parasite infection in this case. The parasite cleanses that are out there are generally not effective. Some include simple dietary restrictions, which may be benign, but can risk poor nutrition in extreme cases. In the case of an actual GI parasite, which includes weight loss as a symptoms, dietary restrictions may exacerbate the weight loss resulting in worse outcomes. The idea is to “starve the parasite” but that would not prevent or eliminate a parasite infection.
There are also many herbal concoctions promoted as parasite cleanses, with the most common ingredient being wormwood, which contains artemisia. Artemisia does have some anti-parasitic (helminthic specifically) activity, but when given as an herb suffers all the limitations of this approach. As this study demonstrates, for example, in vitro effects do not always translate in vivo. This means that because an herb or derivative kills parasites in a Petri dish, that does not mean it will have any such effect when taken orally. There are issues with bioavailability, half-life, and distribution, for example.
Further, there are over 500 species of wormwood, with highly variable amounts of specific constituents, which can also vary considerably by season, part, method of collection and preparation. This is a problem generally with herbal products, there is no consistency. If you have an actual parasitic infection, then you want to take a purified drug with known properties and amounts in a dose proven to be safe and effective.
Some herbal parasite cleanses also cause diarrhea, which is meant to create the impression that they are working. But this can be a dangerous side effect. Also, again, if you had an actual GI parasite, taking a drug that causes diarrhea would be counterproductive.
Artemisia in wormwood has also been shown to cause liver toxicity. Remember – herbal products are drugs, they are just poorly regulated drugs. They can have all the common toxicity and interactions that pharmaceuticals have, and liver toxicity is very common.
Good medicine is all about carefully considering risks vs benefit. The potential benefit of a routine parasite cleanse is negligible, because the risk of actually having a parasite for those living in developed nations is incredibly low. You are far better just not engaging in risky activity. The parasite cleanses out there also have unproven efficacy, with good reason to think that they are likely ineffective. They also carry some risk of direct harm through toxicity.
There is also the potential of indirect harm, through generating a false sense of security, delaying proper medical care, or diverting people from a proper medical evaluation.
A good rule of thumb is not to listen to wellness influencers on Tik Tok – which has risk massively in excess of any potential benefit.

Rope Worms: C’est la Merde
Harriet Hall on May 27, 2014
Link
When I first heard about rope worms, I assumed it was a spoof. Alas, not so!
Rope worms are rope-like meter-long human intestinal parasites that were only recently discovered in the returns of cleansing enemas and are often reported after coffee enemas. Strangely, no one had ever noticed them until 2009. They have never been observed during endoscopy or surgery, during medical bowel cleansing in preparation for surgical or imaging procedures, with x-rays or MRIs, at autopsy, or by any colorectal specialists. Yet according to Nikolai Gubarev and Alex Volinsky, the two of them have never yet found a single patient who didn’t have these parasites.
Two articles by Volinsky, Gubarev, and colleagues (here and here) describe the rope worm and its five developmental stages. They include pictures of each stage. I urge you to take a look. You will be amazed, and not in a good way. You might even bust a gut laughing.
The articles have not been published in a peer-reviewed journal, but are available online at arxiv.org. That was originally a repository for pre-prints of scientific papers on physics that was subsequently expanded to include astronomy, mathematics, computer science, nonlinear science, quantitative biology, and statistics. But not zoology, medical science or clinical medicine; so I don’t understand why these articles appear there. The lead author is a mechanical engineer. None of the authors have any credentials that would indicate any level of expertise in the relevant areas of study, and it shows.
The 5 developmental stages are:
     1.  Mucus that can be hosted almost anywhere in the human body.
     2.  Viscous mucus with bubbles. The bubbles are later used as attachment points.
     3.  Branched jellyfish stage. (No, I’m not making this up! Look at the pictures.)
     4.  Rope parasite 4th stage — looks similar to the 5th adult stage, but is softer and slimier.
     5.  Adult rope parasite: anaerobic, resembles human feces, dries out outside the human body in air. They resemble twisted fibers of rope; the color depends on the food a person eats, varying from white to black. They can be located anywhere in the human body but prefer the small and large intestines. They attach to the intestines with suction cups/heads that develop from suction bubbles. They twist like a corkscrew, increasing their cross section and blocking the intestine. They squeeze the juice out of the fecal matter and feed on it osmotically. They achieve this with multiple channels along their length. They emit gas bubbles inside these channels that allow them to move by jet propulsion. (Are there two different kinds of bubbles? Propulsion by jets implies high pressure, attachment by suction implies a vacuum.) They are most active between 1 and 6 AM. They release toxins that suppress the immune system and can alter human attention and reaction. They can cause multiple symptoms, including weight gain or loss, food allergies, common colds, coughing, back pain, rashes, headaches, indigestion, hair loss, etc. They produce slime with a distinct odor.
It is thought that they also feed on blood, because some come out with their heads covered with blood. (How do they know it’s a head? And if they feed on fecal matter by osmosis in those long channels, how and why do they penetrate the intestinal wall and get at the blood?) Volinsky and Gubarev tell us that people with alkaline blood (pH 8-10) are the most susceptible. They helpfully tell us that blood pH can be determined by examining the color of the conjunctiva of the eye: bright pink signifies normal blood pH, bright red means alkaline, and pale means acidic blood. (In case you don’t realize how colossally ridiculous this is, people with a blood pH of 8-10 would not be “susceptible” to anything because they would be dead, and the color of the conjunctiva has nothing whatsoever to do with pH; it becomes redder with infection or inflammation and becomes paler with anemia.)
Unlike other parasites, rope worms do not have muscles, nervous systems, or reproductive organs. They are often mistaken for decaying remains of other parasites, feces, or intestinal lining. (Or vice versa, perhaps?)
These parasites can be purged with eucalyptus and lemon juice enemas. Conveniently, the second author, Gubarev, who works for an occupational safety organization in Russia, just happens to hold a Russian patent on a eucalyptus enema concoction for treating various intestinal parasites. But caution is advised because this leaves open wounds in the intestine, causing internal bleeding.
And they know all of this how? They provide no explanation of how they figured it all out or how they determined that the various stages were the same entity. What would you do if you thought you had identified a new species of parasite? I hope you wouldn’t just write papers like these. I hope you would consult zoologists, taxonomists, and parasitologists; especially if your training was in mechanical engineering and you were ignorant enough about biology to think a person could survive with a blood pH of 10. New animals don’t arise de novo by special creation. They evolve from other species. These “rope worms” bear no resemblance to any other known human parasite or to any known relative of worms or to anything else in the animal kingdom. There is no reason to think these “worms” are anything other than enema artifacts analogous to the spurious “gallstones” produced by liver flushes. Those who claim they are real animals have the burden of proof, and they haven’t offered anything that would qualify as such.
Science, anyone? When rope worms were tested for DNA, only human DNA was found. Never mind — no sufficiently intelligent, imaginative, motivated rationalizer is ever stymied by contrary facts. It was suggested that the rope worm triggers the gut to produce a body for it that may be a mix of parasites and human DNA. Others have suggested that rope worms are a biofilm produced as a way for the body to detoxify itself. It has been suggested that they form in response to GMO foods. They are even suspected of being involved in cancer, heart disease, and Alzheimer’s.
Volinsky uploaded a video to YouTube titled “Rope Worm in the Nose.” It is no such thing: it shows an ENT surgeon removing polyps and suctioning thick ropy mucus from infected sinuses, explaining as he goes and never once mentioning worms.
As would be expected, patients report feeling better after expelling these “worms.” The patented treatment methods are being advocated by “CAM experts” for treatment of Lyme disease, Morgellon’s and autism.
Conclusion
Rope worm parasites? There’s no such critter. This is just another example of the fallible human brain’s susceptibility to delusions and illusions. It is reminiscent of N-rays, of the liver flukes that Hulda Clark zapped, of the mysterious elusive Morgellon’s whatsis-thingies, of the nonexistent Oscillococcus bacterium that provided the rationale for the most popular homeopathic flu remedy, and of the Virgin Mary’s portrait on a toasted cheese sandwich. Look up pareidolia and apophenia. Such errors are part of the reason we need the scientific method.
Pardon my French, but in my opinion everything that has been written about rope worms is arrant pseudoscientific merde de taureaux.

No, Everything You Thought You Knew About Disease Is Not Wrong
The authors of this book are not doctors or scientists, but they try to convince readers that science-based medicine gets it all wrong, that germs don’t cause disease, and that drugs and vaccines can’t possibly work. No, the book gets it all wrong.
Harriet Hall on June 2, 2020
Link

The book What Really Makes You Ill?: Why Everything You Thought You Knew About Disease Is Wrong, by Dawn Lester and David Parker has been featured on conspiracy podcasts and shows like Crrow777 and it’s getting a lot of attention. I’ve always been willing to follow the evidence and admit I was wrong about something; and if everything I thought I knew about disease was wrong, I needed to correct my errors, so I struggled through the whole 1,030 pages. I’m willing to follow the evidence, but this book contained no actual evidence for me to follow. It failed to convince me that science-based medicine is wrong.
Unequaled chutzpah
The authors have no background in science or medicine. Their backgrounds are in accountancy and electrical engineering. They say those fields require an aptitude for logic, and they claim that their freedom from the dogma and biases of “medical science” (the quotation marks are theirs) enabled them to follow the evidence with open minds. What chutzpah! Their minds must have been so open that their brains fell out. Instead of asking what was true, they started with a preconceived belief that they already “knew” the truth. Their “research” was classic confirmation bias: they simply located everything they could find that questioned the dominant paradigm. They were “enabled” to mistake opinion for evidence, to cherry pick from the writings of quacks and other questionable sources, to make obvious errors of fact and logic, and to reach conclusions no reasonable person could agree with. They say, “Unthinking respect for authority is the greatest enemy of truth,” but they demonstrate an unquestioning respect for people who are not authorities.
Their starting point was their belief that germ theory is a myth. Yes, they are germ theory denialists. They say the germ theory remains unproven and there is overwhelming evidence that it is a fallacy. They say no original scientific evidence definitively proves that any “germ” causes any specific disease: no so-called infectious organism has ever met Koch’s stringent postulates, the four criteria needed to prove a causative relationship between a microbe and a disease. They claim that toxins in our environment and in our food are what really makes us ill. They even deny that specific diseases exist.
They say Paracelsus’ idea that the dose makes the poison was wrong. Since we know that very tiny amounts of hormones produce effects in the human body, they assume that infinitesimal amounts of any substance must have toxic effects, and when people are exposed to multiple natural toxins and manmade products, the effects must add up. They are chemophobes, assuming that every chemical is a poison to be avoided. They believe Multiple Chemical Sensitivity is a real disease.
They say the claim that everything is made of chemicals is misleading, because matter is also electrical in nature. They believe all electromagnetic fields are harmful, whether from cell phones or home appliances. They believe EMF causes cancer. They believe EMF hypersensitivity is a real disease. They don’t mention any of the scientific studies showing that the symptoms are due to the nocebo effect.
They say no virus causes any disease. They say all medicines, in any dose, are poisons, as are all vaccines.
They quote Stephen Sinatra, one of the authors of the book Earthing, which I reviewed unfavorably for Skeptic magazine : “Emerging science reveals that direct contact with the ground allows you to receive an energy infusion.” No, it doesn’t!
They repeatedly cite Death by Modern Medicine by Carolyn Dean, the MD and ND whose book on magnesium I reviewed last week. They accept everything she says as gospel truth, even though she was declared unfit to practice medicine and was stripped of her license.
They believe Fereydoon Batmanghelidj’s pronouncements on water. I don’t: see my SBM article.
They complain that drugs have not been tested in combination with each of the other drugs a patient might conceivably be taking. As I said in a previous article, that’s impossible. The number of studies needed would far exceed the number of people in the world.
A few of their many errors
They say neutrons have positive and negative charges which balance each other. Wrong! Neutrons have no charge.
In their discussion of drug testing, they say Phase III clinical trials are done on normal, asymptomatic subjects. Wrong! In both Phase II and Phase III trials they test patients who have the disease the drug is intended to treat.
They say virtually all the kids responsible for school shootings were on SSRI medications; they weren’t.
They say fully half of prescription drugs are pulled from the market due to side effects. That’s false. The FDA says only 3 out of the 222 drugs they approved between 2001 and 2010 were later withdrawn from the market.
They say the active ingredient in aspirin is salicylic acid. It isn’t. It’s acetylsalicylic acid.
They adopt the strategies of evolution denialists
People who argue against evolution seem to think if they can identify a single missing link, that will disprove the whole edifice of evolution. Or if they can find two scientists whose words seem to contradict each other. Or if there is any legitimate controversy about some tiny detail. Both the Theory of Evolution and Germ Theory are correctly called “theories” in the strict scientific sense, because they comprehensively explain all the pertinent facts, they are supported by overwhelming evidence, and they are so well established that no new evidence is likely to alter them. Rejecting a scientific theory requires denial and perversity, traits Lester and Parker demonstrate in abundance.
They point out that medical explanations for diseases “contain many anomalies, inconsistencies, and contradictions and present a number of aspects that remain poorly understood.” They have assiduously accumulated statements from anywhere and everywhere that they perceive as questioning the dominant paradigm. They crow about things like the WHO fact sheet that says, “The fundamental causes of asthma are not completely understood.” They quote the CDC: “Experts don’t know the cause of many forms of arthritis.”
As if statements like that disproved the Germ Theory!
Anti-vax arguments
They oppose vaccination. Of course they do. They repeat most of the usual anti-vax arguments and misinformation, but they go even further. They say vaccines can’t possibly work because they’re based on a false theory. They say, “It is clear from this discussion that no disease is caused by a virus.” They seem to think a “discussion” of opinions, rather than science, is the way to determine the truth.
Where’s the evidence?
They don’t trust science because they think it has been corrupted by vested interests. They believe patient anecdotes about alleged adverse effects of statins, rather than the evidence of controlled studies. They claim that Andrew Wakefield and others who have dared to question mainstream ideas were unfairly persecuted.
Here’s an example of what constitutes “evidence” in their world. They say that in her 1957 book The Poisoned Needle Eleanor McBean quoted a Dr. Laurie as saying “I am thoroughly convinced that the increase in cancer is due to vaccination.” A random person’s unsubstantiated opinion. How can they imagine this would mean more to us than all the scientific studies? Occasionally they do mention a controlled clinical study, but they ignore all the other studies that got the opposite results.
They claim to have expertise in logic, but their words demonstrate logical fallacies and false dichotomies. Their defective reasoning produces non-sequiturs like “Phosphorus is a proven neurotoxin. It should be noted that the definition of polio includes references to effects on the central nervous system.” (Yes, so what?)
I previously mentioned their acceptance of Carolyn Dean and Fereydoon Batmanghelidj. They also quote Peter Duesberg, an AIDS denialist. They think Florence Nightingale’s casual observations in the Crimea were evidence that one disease could morph into another. They quote John Tilden, a “drugless doctor” who died in1941, who claimed “Measles is the manner in which a child’s body throws off toxemia.” They cite the infamous Gary Null, who is notoriously hostile to evidence-based medicine; Dr. Robert Mendelsohn, whose book Confessions of a Medical Heretic calls bottle-feeding of babies “the granddaddy of all junk food;” Devra Davis, who opposes cell phones and has been accused of doing “junk science;” and many others whose names will be familiar to readers of SBM, such as Vandana Shiva, Betty Martini, Stephen Sinatra, T. Colin Campbell, Viera Scheibner, Joel Fuhrman, and many others. Nowhere do they mention real experts like Siddhartha Muherjee, the author of The Emperor of All Maladies, who could have readily corrected most of their misinformed ideas about cancer.
They call Pasteur a plagiarist and imposter who deliberately deceived the public. They say Semmelweis was wrong: the unsanitary surgeons didn’t transmit germs to their patients but poisoned them with “noxious matter” from autopsies.
Questionable opinions
The book is full of questionable opinions not backed up by evidence. Here is just a sampling of them:
    • Malaria is caused by unhealthy living conditions, not by Plasmodium.
    • “Antibiotics should never be used.”
    • Gulf War Syndrome was proven to be caused by chemical exposures and vaccine overload.
    • Diseases are not transmissible between people.
    • The Black Death was caused by toxic chemicals in comet debris.
    • “There are no separate and distinct disease entities with distinct causes.”
    • Humans are not natural omnivores.
    • Neurosyphilis was actually mercury poisoning.
    • “Pharmaceutical drugs can neither prevent nor alleviate disease.” (What about insulin?)
    • They address 5G, fracking, phthalates, bisphenol A, and fluoride, blaming them for causing illness.
    • Their rant on animal experimentation covers all the usual points but adds germ theory denial.
    • They question climate change and believe chemtrail conspiracies,
    • “No infection can cause a birth defect.”
Conclusion: Wrong, wrong, wrong!
This book is wrong, wrong, wrong! They don’t seem to understand science, how it works, and why it is so important. They rely on opinions rather than on evidence. If you don’t think “some random scientist reportedly said” is evidence, if you value science, this book is not for you.

There is really nothing super about Antibiotic Resistant Gonorrhea
Reports out of Massachusetts are raising concerns of a highly resistant strain of gonorrhea being seen for the first time in the United States. Are we close to living in a reality where there are no more effective treatments for this nasty, and potentially deadly, infection?
Clay Jones on February 3, 2023
Link

Unlike killer bees in the 1970s, Y2K at the turn of the century, and numerous fear fads spread via social media over the past several years, the potential appearance of so-called “super gonorrhea” has been a legitimate concern for doctors in the United States since the 1990s. Sadly, it appears that time is close at hand. At least it sure looks that way according to a number of recent news reports.
But what is super gonorrhea, and is it something that we should all be worried about? Are there any effective treatments left? Is it time to make a run for our emergency apocalypse bunkers hidden deep in the Black Hills of South Dakota? The answer to all of these questions is an unqualified yes. Fly, you fools!
What is super gonorrhea?
Back on January 19th, Massachusetts health authorities announced the identification of a “concerning gonorrhea strain” found in two unrelated individuals diagnosed with the infection. The bacteria in each case showed signs of resistance or reduced response to 6 of the 7 antibiotics tracked for resistance by state and federal surveillance programs, the first time this has been observed in the United States. Both patients were still able to be successfully cured using an antibiotic named ceftriaxone, which has been the standard first line treatment for gonorrhea for several years, but don’t let that reassure you too much.
Ceftriaxone is an injectable (IM/IV) broad spectrum antibiotic in the cephalosporin class, and It is one of the most important drugs currently in our armamentarium when treating a wide variety of serious bacterial infections, including meningitis, pneumonia, soft tissue infections, and urinary tract infections. Since 2012, it has been recommended as the first line treatment for gonorrhea because of rising resistance to other choices that could be taken orally. Unfortunately, the strain of bacteria in the recent Massachusetts cases was found to have the penA60 allele, a mutation in the penA gene associated with resistance to ceftriaxone.
The two Massachusetts isolates mark only the 2nd and 3rd time that the penA60 allele has been seen in the United States, though it has been identified in several other countries around the world. In the first case, seen in Nevada, the strain of gonorrhea was sensitive to several other antibiotics. These recent cases were not.
Ceftriaxone worked this time, but there was a reduced response that could quickly evolve in to full resistance. In susceptibility testing, the only antibiotic without any reduced gonorrhea murderability, at least in a Petri dish, was gentamicin. This particular drug has a worse safety profile, though I would still consider it pretty safe in most cases, but isn’t as effective in treating all types of gonorrhea infections as ceftriaxone.
How worried do we need to be?
Well, it depends. If you don’t plan on ever contracting gonorrhea, and take well established precautions, you are probably going to be fine. I’m not sure how many people actually plan to get gonorrhea, though. Certainly some people take a riskier approach to life than I would recommend.
Gonorrhea is an incredibly common infection, second only to chlamydia among reported sexually transmitted infections, and it effects people from all walks of life. Even children aren’t spared from it. Newborns acquire the infection when passing through infected fluids during a vaginal delivery and can develop vision-threatening eye infections, arthritis, meningitis, and even sepsis. Some younger children become infected during acts of sexual abuse. And sexually active older kids also encounter gonorrhea the old fashioned way.
Most gonorrhea infections are mild or even asymptomatic. When symptomatic, most men and women have inflammation in the genitourinary tract, but the throat and rectum are other common locations. Infection in women can spread to the uterus and ovaries leading to infertility. In some cases the bacteria can disseminate throughout the body, causing inflammation of the joints and skin in particular. Systemic disease can even be fatal.
Like all sexually transmitted infections, gonorrhea is on the rise. In Massachusetts, confirmed cases have gone up by more than 300% since 2009. In total across the country, there has been a 131% increase, with nearly 700,000 cases reported in 2021. According to Massachusetts authorities, the two patients with the highly resistant strain were not linked in any way. And because one of them had no history of travel to regions where this strain is known to exist, it is likely that others are infected with it and spreading it right now.
Losing ceftriaxone as an effective treatment for gonorrhea would be really bad. Some patients would still be curable using older treatment strategies, but there would be many treatment failures. If this new (to us) strain takes hold, our options would become even more limited, and with a few strokes of genetic bad luck there may be no options left at all. Numbers of gonorrhea cases would skyrocket since treatment prevents spread, and a lot of people would suffer.
Through the efforts of CDC and FDA fast track programs, there are two new antibiotics currently in phase 3 trials that look promising. There is also some hope that a vaccine could be developed considering that the bacteria that causes gonorrhea shares 80-90% of its DNA with Neisseria meningitidis, a common and vaccine-preventable cause of meningitis. But we can’t count on these to be available anytime soon. So, in the meantime, be careful out there.

oes Everybody Have Chronic Lyme Disease? Does Anyone?
Harriet Hall on September 3, 2013
Link

A deplorable article by Suzy Cohen on Huffington Post is titled “Feel Bad? It Could Be Lyme Unless Proven Otherwise.” It consists of irresponsible fear-mongering about a nonexistent disease. A science-based article would be titled “Feel Bad? It Couldn’t Be Chronic Lyme Disease Because CLD Is Nonexistent Until Proven Otherwise.”
Cohen says:
People often attribute uncomfortable symptoms to aging, stress, or the “aches and pains of daily living,” especially if blood tests and body scans are normal. What if you have Lyme and don’t know it? If you’ve ever been for a walk in the woods, laid in the grass, live in or visited a Lyme-endemic area, or have a pet cat or dog, you may have exposed yourself to Lyme disease and associated co-infections. There is even the possibility of contracting Lyme if you were born to a mother who has been exposed. Tick born infections can also be transmitted from blood transfusions.
That pretty much covers everyone. Who hasn’t been for a walk in the woods, lain down on the lawn, or had a pet? (And incidentally, are there no editors or proofreaders at HuffPo who realize that the past participle of lie is lain and that infections are tick-borne, not tick born?)
Cohen says:
Lyme is a multi-systemic illness, and may affect every part of the body causing fatigue, stiff neck, headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), anemia, dizziness, joint and muscle pain, brain fog, tingling, numbness and burning sensations of the extremities, memory and concentration problems, difficulties with sleep (both falling asleep and frequent awakening), chest pain and palpitations and/or psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety.
That pretty much covers everyone. Who hasn’t experienced one or more of those symptoms? I’ve personally had 10 of them just in the course of the past week, none significant and none requiring a hypothesis like CLD for explanation. If I wanted to identify myself as “sick” and to believe these symptoms were due to a single underlying cause, it wouldn’t be hard to fit them into the CLD framework.
Cohen interviewed Dr. Richard Horowitz, who claims to have treated more than 12,000(!) patients for chronic Lyme disease and has dubbed it “Lyme-MSIDS” for multiple systemic infectious disease syndrome. He claims that most of his patients have a whole host of associated tick-borne illnesses such as Borrelia hermsii (relapsing fever), Babesia, Bartonella, Mycoplasma, Chlamydia, Rocky Mountain spotted fever, Q-fever, Ehrlichia or Anaplasma. He says that MSIDS
…involves not only the bacterial and parasitic infections mentioned above, but also associated viral and fungal infections, immune issues, inflammation, hormonal disorders, mitochondrial dysfunction (the mitochondria are the part of the cells responsible for energy production), sleep disorders, environmental toxins with heavy metals, and detoxification problems.
He says this is why:
… the standard treatment protocol (consisting of 30 days antibiotic therapy) doesn’t offer the cure for most sufferers. You can’t just blow up bugs. Detoxification, hormone balancing, heavy metal removal and ramping up immune function are equally important.
Criticism of “chronic Lyme disease”
Horowitz is one of the self-styled Lyme literate medical doctors (LLMDs), mavericks who have built a whole industry around diagnosing and treating something not recognized by mainstream medical science. A 2011 article in The Lancet exposed LLMDs for scientific misconduct, fraud, disciplinary actions, use of unvalidated laboratory tests, and other unethical activities. It also showed how activists have diverted attention away from evidence-based medicine and it expressed concern that their activities will endanger the public’s health unless responsible parties firmly stand up for an evidence-based approach.
In the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology (FASEB) Journal, PJ Baker, the executive director of the American Lyme Disease Foundation, wrote:
There is no better example of a relentless attack on evidence-based biomedical research and the integrity of outstanding scientists than that associated with the treatment of a poorly defined condition called “chronic Lyme disease.” Here, a scientifically naive general population, the lay press, and legislators, who in most instances are unable to evaluate and judge scientific evidence properly, have been misled by patient advocate groups to believe that extended antibiotic therapy is the best and only solution to this condition. This has resulted in the unprecedented intrusion of government and the legal systems into the practice of medicine and scientific research. Because there is no clinical evidence that this condition is due to a persistent infection, advocating extended antibiotic therapy is not justified and has been shown to be harmful and of no benefit.
An article in Environmental Health Perspectives said:
Lyme disease is a relatively well-described infectious disease with multisystem manifestations. Because of confusion over conflicting reports, anxiety related to vulnerability to disease, and sensationalized and inaccurate lay media coverage, a new syndrome, “chronic Lyme disease,” has become established. Chronic Lyme disease is the most recent in a continuing series of “medically unexplained symptoms” syndromes. These syndromes, such as fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, and multiple chemical sensitivity, meet the need for a societally and morally acceptable explanation for ill-defined symptoms in the absence of objective physical and laboratory findings. We describe factors involved in the psychopathogenesis of chronic Lyme disease and focus on the confusion and insecurity these patients feel, which gives rise to an inability to adequately formulate and articulate their health concerns and to deal adequately with their medical needs, a state of disorganization termed aporia.
That article is worth reading in its entirely; the link is to the full text. It provides a lot of insight into how the CLD diagnosis evolved, why patients with medically unexplained symptoms welcomed it, how a science-based multidisciplinary approach might more effectively help these sufferers, and why most can be expected to reject that approach in favor of the simplistic understandings and false promises of the “LLMD” approach.
Two randomized trials published in The New England Journal of Medicine concluded that long-term antibiotics were no better than placebo.
Fallon et al. in the Open Neurology Journal have reinterpreted the existing human studies as showing a benefit of antibiotics. You can read their article and judge for yourself.
A 2007 article in The New England Journal of Medicine, “A Critical Appraisal of ‘Chronic Lyme Disease”, concluded that CLD was a misnomer, that it is only the latest in a series of many labels that have attempted to attribute medically unexplained symptoms to infections, and that antibiotic treatment is not warranted. The CDC agrees that so-called Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome should not be treated with long-term antibiotics.
Chronic Lyme disease has been addressed on SBM several times: here, here, here, here, and here.
Testing for Lyme
Cohen recommends testing for Lyme disease with IgM and IgG Western blot tests, and she specifically recommends IgeneX lab in California, a questionable lab that has been investigated because it reports positive results for Lyme disease that can’t be confirmed by other labs.
The CDC says:
…you should only have an immunoblot (such as an FDA-approved Western Blot or striped blot) test done if your blood has already been tested and found reactive with an EIA or IFA.
Second, the IgM Western Blot test result is only meaningful during the first 4 weeks of illness. If you have been infected for longer than 4-6 weeks and the IgG Western Blot is still negative, it is highly likely that the IgM result is incorrect (e.g., a false positive). This does not mean that you are not ill, but it does suggest that the cause of illness is something other than the Lyme disease bacterium.
Who is Cohen?
Suzy Cohen bills herself as “America’s Pharmacist”. She has a syndicated column and has written several books. She is “passionate about natural medicine” and promotes a number of nonsensical treatments, from Bach flower remedies to coffee enemas to acupuncture for tinnitus. An example of her spurious reasoning:
Antibiotics are actually derived from mold/fungus so it’s recommended that you avoid antibiotics if you have any fungal infection or various immune system disorders.
You are known by the company you keep. The usual suspects believe in CLD, including Joseph Mercola, Mike Adams, and Dr. Oz. Dr. Oz is a very agreeable man. He agrees with promoters of psychic surgery. He agrees with every new purveyor of snake oil who comes down the pike, with every new miracle solution for effortless weight loss. And predictably, he agrees with Cohen. He assumes Chronic Lyme Disease exists and is “either a chronic condition or an autoimmune response” or both. He quotes a scientist who says there is no scientific evidence for CLD; but he chooses to disregard him and believe Horowitz instead. Oz supports certain supplements to strengthen the body’s ability to repair itself: vitamin B12, coenzyme Q10, chromium, folate, omega-3 fatty acids, and herbs such as Rhodiola rosea.
There is even a Hollywood movie and proposed legislation targeting the evil establishment that is allegedly suppressing these new discoveries.
Conclusion: Chronic Lyme probably doesn’t exist
The belief that chronic Lyme disease exists is not supported by the evidence. It is a disservice to patients with unexplained symptoms to paste that label on them and treat them with potentially harmful long-term antibiotics. They are suffering, and they deserve our compassion and the best that science-based medicine has to offer, not bogus treatments by charlatans or well-meaning but misguided LLMDs.

Lyme: Two Worlds Compared and Contrasted
Mark Crislip on March 20, 2015
Link


The practice of infectious disease (ID) is both easy and difficult. If you read my ID blog on Medscape you are aware of my trials and tribulations in diagnosing and treating infections.
ID is easy since, at least in theory, diseases have patterns and an infecting organism has a predictable epidemiology and life cycle. So if you can recognize the pattern and relate it to the life cycle and exposure history, you can often make a diagnosis before the cultures come back.
My favorite story is the time I was asked to see a young girl with endocarditis. The history was she had a week of fevers, headache and myalgia that went away for five days, returned for a week, went away for five days and returned yet again.
So I asked her “How was your vacation at Black Butte?”
The look of astonishment on her face as she asked how I knew she had been to Black Butte was so satisfying.
But the pattern was relapsing fever and Black Butte is where all the relapsing fever in Oregon is located. And sure enough, her smear had Borrelia. A course of antibiotics and the spirochete was dead and gone.
However, my son says all I ever do is say “Get cultures and start vancomycin.” How hard is that?
ID is hard because in practice patients do not read the textbooks and do not always present with the correct signs and symptoms. If you have an uncommon infection with an uncommon presentation it can be difficult to diagnose. I get a fair number of these in consultation and syphilis has been the tricky one the last few years. While there is the classic progression from primary to secondary to latent to tertiary, patients often have peculiar manifestations that bypass the classic findings and are sometimes hesitant to mention risk factors.
Once you make the diagnosis of syphilis, you give a course of antibiotics and the spirochete is dead and gone.
Relapsing fever and syphilis are two spirochetal illnesses that can be both straightforward and difficult. Both have well-understood pathophysiology but that doesn’t mean that they are easy to diagnose.
Lyme is also a simple and complex diseases. Caused by the spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi (as least in the US; there are other Borrelia in Europe that cause Lyme and worldwide there at least 36 Borrelia species) its epidemiology, pathophysiology, and treatment are well understood. Like all infections, it can be tricky and present atypically, but the science is clear: there is no chronic Lyme disease that is amenable to long term antibiotics.
Let me mention here, not that it will make any difference, that I do not deny the symptoms and suffering of patients with the “diagnosis” of chronic Lyme. They are often quite ill with something that is not, however, from Lyme.
Unfortunately, in public discourse science and reality do not necessarily triumph over pseudo-science. Last year, New York passed a bill to allow:
rogue doctors [to] be able to shill their non-evidence-based treatments without worrying about intervention.
the bill:
prohibits the state Office of Professional Medical Conduct from investigating a licensed physician based solely upon the recommendation or provision of a treatment that is not universally accepted by the medical profession.
Those protections include, but are not limited to, treatments for Lyme disease and other tick-borne illnesses.
A similar bill is now before the Oregon Legislature, House Bill 916. A public hearing on the bill will be held on Monday, March 30th. I have no doubt that similar bills will be appearing in legislatures throughout the US. They may be there now, unbeknownst to you. I only discovered the Oregon bill by serendipity.
The bill, sponsored by the Oregon Lyme Disease Network, says:
SECTION 1. (1) The Oregon Medical Board and the Oregon State Board of Nursing shall each adopt rules regarding the diagnosis and treatment of Lyme disease.
(2) The rules adopted under this section must:
(a) Permit professionals regulated by the boards to diagnose and treat, in manners consistent with the standards of care guidelines developed by the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society, Lyme disease and associated viral, bacterial and parasitic diseases;
and
(b) Establish disciplinary procedures that consider as a mitigating factor whether, in diagnosing or treating Lyme disease or associated diseases, a professional who is facing discipline followed evidence-based diagnosis and treatment guidelines not recognized by the boards.
There are two sets of Lyme Treatment Guidelines. One is from the Infectious Disease Society of America and is about to undergo an update from the 2006 guidelines. The guidelines suggest (note the not):
Selected antimicrobials, drug regimens, or other modalities not recommended for the treatment of Lyme disease.
    • Doses of antimicrobials far in excess of those provided in tables 2 and 3
    • Multiple, repeated courses of antimicrobials for the same episode of Lyme disease or a duration of antimicrobial therapy prolonged far in excess of that shown in table 3
    • Combination antimicrobial therapy
    • Pulsed-dosing (i.e., antibiotic therapy on some days but not on other days)
    • First-generation cephalosporins, benzathine penicillin G, fluoroquinolones, carbapenems, vancomycin, metronidazole, tinidazole, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, amantadine, ketolides, isoniazid, or fluconazole
    • Empirical antibabesiosis therapy in the absence of documentation of active babesiosis
    • Anti-Bartonella therapies
    • Hyperbaric oxygen therapy
    • Fever therapy (with or without malaria induction)
    • Intravenous immunoglobulin
    • Ozone
    • Cholestyramine
    • Intravenous hydrogen peroxide
    • Vitamins or nutritional managements
    • Magnesium or bismuth injections
I suspect, given the creativity of those who treat chronic Lyme, that this list will grow in the next version of the guidelines. These are the kinds of pseudo-therapies, and there are many more, that the people with the pseudo-diagnosis of chronic Lyme undergo. All useless, all costly, and, occasionally, fatal. Key in the IDSA guidelines is the avoidance of long term and repeat courses of intravenous antibiotics.
Long term antibiotics are not benign. Besides allergic and other side effects, secondary infections of the intravenous catheters can and has killed people.
A 30-year-old woman died as a result of a large Candida parapsilosis septic thrombus located on the tip of a Groshong catheter. The catheter had been in place for 28 months for administration of a 27 month course of intravenous cefotaxime for an unsubstantiated diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease.
I keep thinking the 27 months is a typo, but it is neither a typo nor atypical in the chronic Lyme world. Twenty five years of infection control has only served to emphasize that unnecessary intravenous catheters can only cause harm and one of the keystones of non-standard chronic Lyme therapy is prolonged intravenous antibiotics.
The other Lyme treatment guideline is from ILADS, The International Lyme and Associated Disease Society. They differ from the IDSA, as noted by ILADS:
The ILADS panel recommendations differ from those of the IDSA. Different guideline panels reviewing the same evidence can develop disparate recommendations that reflect the underlying values of the panel members, which may result in conflicting guidelines. The IOM explains that conflicting guidelines most often result ‘when evidence is weak; developers differ in their approach to evidence reviews (systematic vs non-systematic), evidence synthesis or interpretation and/or developers have varying assumptions about intervention benefits and harms. Conflicting guidelines exist for over 25 conditions and there is no current system for reconciling conflicting guidelines.
It may be more than a simple difference of opinion. But I would note that every recommendation in the ILADS guidelines is based on:
very low-quality evidence.
There are multiple differences in the two approaches to Lyme. First is the belief (belief is what you have when you lack data), unsupported by the preponderance of the scientific medical literature, that Lyme persists despite adequate treatment.
The other major issues concern treatment. ILADS supports prolonged intravenous therapy for Lyme, re-treatment for patients with persisting symptoms after treatment and the use of adjunctive therapies including treatments of co-infections. All are not supported by Lyme literature.
ILADS suggests repeat courses of intravenous antibiotics for patients who remain symptomatic; IDSA does not and the best studies to date supports the IDSA approach:
There is considerable impairment of health-related quality of life among patients with persistent symptoms despite previous antibiotic treatment for acute Lyme disease. However, in these two trials, treatment with intravenous and oral antibiotics for 90 days did not improve symptoms more than placebo.
This is because antibiotics are effective in killing off Lyme:
There continues to be no evidence that viable B. burgdorferi persist in humans after conventional treatment with antimicrobials.
Most studies looking for living B.burgdorferi after treatment have failed and those that do have severe flaws. Antibiotics eradicate the organism and in animal models, where they can culture the entire mouse, 5 days of antibiotics is enough to kill off all the Lyme:
Our findings further document the effectiveness of antibiotic therapy in eradicating cultivable cells of B. burgdorferi, irrespective of tissue or organ site.
The organism does not hide out, protected in some organs, as some believe. As the 2014 NEJM review succinctly puts it:
Several carefully conducted, placebo-controlled, randomized trials of prolonged antimicrobial treatment in patients with persistent subjective symptoms after treatment for Lyme disease have shown a minimal benefit or none and a substantial risk of adverse effects. Consequently, prolonged antimicrobial treatment for subjective symptoms is not recommended in patients whose objective signs of Lyme disease have resolved in response to conventional therapy. Consideration of other causes of persistent symptoms is warranted. In most of these patients, nonspecific symptoms resolve over time without additional antimicrobial treatment.
When it comes to adjunctive therapies, ILADS is less proscriptive than the IDSA:
ILADS agrees that first-generation cephalosporins, intravenous hydrogen peroxide and bismuth injections are not recommended. However, ILADS has concluded that it is premature to exclude other potentially beneficial therapies based on the evidence to date. Therefore, ILADS contends that the use of such agents should not be precluded until studies have demonstrated their ineffectiveness in the treatment of Lyme disease.
A real difference in approach to treatment. Given the potential dangers in all medical interventions, therapies should be precluded until studies have demonstrated their effectiveness in the treatment of Lyme disease.
Lyme diagnosis is also mentioned in the Oregon bill, although the ILADS guidelines do not address issues related to the diagnosis of Lyme. Lyme is classically diagnosed by a two-step procedure: a screening ELISA followed by a confirmatory Western Blot, although the ELISA for antibodies against the C6 peptide may be helpful.
There are laboratories, in my experience evidently beloved by naturopaths, that use unvalidated and unreliable non-standard tests, of which there are many. This is because:
in the mid–1970s, the FDA began exempting certain diagnostic tests from its approval process. Many of these tests — developed, manufactured, and offered by a single lab, such as in a hospital — were variations on common tests, low-risk, or devised for rare diseases and could not be adequately validated.
And Lyme testing has proliferated with all the subsequent false positives in patients and resultant un-needed therapies. Patients often do not realize that when a lab is CLIA certified it means little as to the validity of the testing offered, just as a restaurant being certified as sanitary says nothing about the quality of the cooking.
The FDA recognizes this is a problem with many kinds of tests:
The US Food and Drug Administration, responding to growing concerns that a host of diagnostic tests for illnesses from cancer to Lyme disease may be inaccurately identifying conditions, announced Thursday that it intends to regulate many of the tests.
and there are new guidelines for these tests that may result in less unreliable testing.
I heard a story at a meeting that a company developed a Lyme test and everyone tested positive. Rather than recognize a flawed test, they concluded everyone had Lyme. Probably apocryphal, but the mindset of the Lyme world is often:
No Lyme test has no false negatives, but it is important to understand that there is no such thing as a false positive.
Also popular in the nonstandard Lyme world is treating co-infections. I once had a patient tell me she also had a Babesia infection as well as Lyme, diagnosed at one of the creative Lyme labs by a naturopath. The accompanying photomicrograph had an arrow pointing to…a platelet clump misidentified as Babesia. While there is occasionally more than one infection spread with a tick bite, it is not common:
Often, the controversial diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease is given to patients with prolonged, medically unexplained physical symptoms. Many such patients also are treated for chronic coinfections with Babesia, Anaplasma, or Bartonella in the absence of typical presentations, objective clinical findings, or laboratory confirmation of active infection…The medical literature does not support the diagnosis of chronic, atypical tick-borne coinfections in patients with chronic, nonspecific illnesses.
The ILADS guidelines mention:
A survey of 3090 patients diagnosed with Lyme disease found that laboratory confirmed cases of babesiosis and anaplasmosis were reported by 32.3 and 4.8% of respondents, respectively
Although given that this is a survey, we have no idea as to the rigor with which these diagnoses were made; they may have had misidentified platelet clumps.
This bill is especially worrisome when combined with HB 3301 that designates naturopaths as “primary care” providers. Not only will this bill remove consumer protections from providers of questionable therapies, it has the potential to expand the ability for pseudo-doctors with no standards to provide pseudo-therapies for pseudo-diseases.
The reason that the ILADS approach is not embraced by other organizations such as the IDSA is that their recommendations are not based on the best understanding of the treatment and diagnosis of Lyme and they ignore or rationalize away high quality evidence.
The IDSA is often vilified for supporting the best data and science. When not supported by the science, organizations often resort to the law, a poor way to adjudicate medicine and science; House Bill 916 is no different in that respect to attempts to legislate the value of pi.
Removing consumer protections and institutionalizing substandard medical care will not benefit the health of Oregonians, will lead to the protection of those practicing substandard medicine, and will protect those practicing substandard medicine from being held accountable for their practice.
As an aside, I will mention that I have no relevant affiliations or financial involvement with any organization or entity with a financial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter or materials discussed above. The odd thing about the world of pseudo-medicine is that most of the time we are accused of being big pharma shills, prescribing vaccines willy-nilly to line the pockets of our masters. Except for Lyme where we are accused of being insurance company shills, not willy-nilly prescribing antibiotics to line the pockets of our masters. Can’t win for trying.
More information on the status House Bill 916 as well as Oregonians for Science-Based Medicine, part of the Society for Science-Based Medicine.
Other Lyme posts
    • Political Science: Chronic Lyme Disease
    • Lemons and Lyme: Bogus tests and dangerous treatments of the Lyme-literati
    • Does Everybody Have Chronic Lyme Disease? Does Anyone?
    • Connecticut Legislature Intrudes on Debate Over Chronic Lyme Disease
    • Lyme disease—who is credible?

Chronic Lyme Disease – Another Negative Study
Steven Novella on April 6, 2016
Link


While Lyme disease itself is a real and often serious infectious illness, the existence and proper treatment of so-called chronic Lyme disease is dubious, and some would say controversial. However, like many controversies we cover, the science itself is not very controversial, but the topic is made so by a persistent minority of outliers who refuse to accept the scientific consensus.
The issue has been raised yet again by a study published recently in The New England Journal of Medicine: “Randomized Trial of Longer-Term Therapy for Symptoms Attributed to Lyme Disease.” The study was negative, but I will get into the details below.
Lyme disease
Lyme is an infection caused by the bacteria Borrelia burgdorferi, and related species. In Europe the infecting species are B. afzelii and B. garinii. These bacteria are spirochetes, which refers to their spiral shape. They are related to the bacterium which causes syphilis, Treponema pallidum, which is also a spirochete.
Syphilis and Lyme both have three stages of illness – a primary infection, secondary symptoms, and then a persistent tertiary syndrome. With Lyme disease, stage 1 involves local infection, including headache, fever, chills, and local arthritis. Stage 2 is disseminated Lyme, including the classic target- or bullseye-shaped rash at the site of the bite, pain, weakness, fatigue, and diffuse arthritis. Stage 3 is persistent late stage infection, and includes ongoing stage 2 symptoms, heart involvement, and neurological involvement.
As you might suspect, treating the infection early is important and most effective. The bacterium is sensitive to a number of antibiotics. Doxycycline is an oral antibiotic most often given in the early stages. Tertiary Lyme often requires IV antibiotics.
Lyme can be diagnosed by a combination of presenting with the classic clinical features, and a positive antibody titer, which can be confirmed with a western blot test. Antibodies can show an acute infection, or can have a profile that reflects a past infection.
Chronic Lyme disease
Fortunately, most patients will recover from Lyme disease after an appropriate course of antibiotics. The evidence shows that antibiotics are capable of eradicating the infection, and there is no evidence that the spirochete can evade treatment by hiding out somewhere in the body, going dormant, or resisting the antibiotics.
However, 10-20% of patients diagnosed and treated for Lyme disease will continue to have chronic symptoms of fatigue, muscle aches, poor sleep, and cognitive fog. Experts believe in some cases this may be due to a post-Lyme syndrome – the effects of inflammation or perhaps an activation of the immune system. There is also the possibility that symptoms in some cases are not due to the infection itself but to another cause, which may or may not have been triggered by the infection. Possibilities include disturbed sleep, deconditioning, and depression.
There are also patients who never had confirmed Lyme disease but have a similar syndrome of pain, fatigue, poor sleep, and mental fog.
This is where the controversy comes in – there are some patients and practitioners (who sometimes call themselves “Lyme literate MDs”) who believe that these chronic symptoms are due to persistent infection with the Lyme bacteria, and that the proper treatment is recurrent and long term treatments with antibiotics, often intravenous (IV).
Their only real source of evidence for this claim is the apparent response of such patients to courses of antibiotics, and the only real published evidence is case reports and case series or uncontrolled studies. However, responses are subjective and temporary, and often patients require ongoing treatment. This has all the hallmarks of a placebo response.
Physicians and scientists skeptical of this claim (myself included) will point to the fact that patients with alleged chronic Lyme disease are often seronegative (they don’t have antibodies, or their antibodies reflect only past infection), and often lack classic clinical features of Lyme disease.
In other words, chronic Lyme advocates are claiming that their patients have seronegative, atypical, treatment-resistant Lyme disease. That is a lot of special pleading, very much like Sagan’s invisible, floating, heatless, noncorporeal dragon. The more parsimonious interpretation is that these patients do not have Lyme disease.
This is a critical distinction for two reasons. The first is that treatment with antibiotics, especially IV antibiotics, is not benign. There is tremendous potential for complications.
The second is that these patients, if they don’t have chronic Lyme disease, have something else which is being missed because they and their practitioner are distracted by the false diagnosis. This is a missed opportunity to treat the real cause of their symptoms. If there is no treatable cause, it is then better to focus on symptom management and quality of life, rather than chase a fictitious infection.
Treatment trials
Initial research trying to settle the question of whether or not chronic Lyme disease is a real entity focused on trying to find evidence for persistence of the spirochete in patients with symptoms diagnosed as chronic Lyme. Such efforts failed, but did not settle the controversy. Proponents of chronic Lyme just special-pleaded away this negative evidence.
Research efforts then shifted to seeing if such patient responded to courses of antibiotics, with double-blind placebo controlled trials. This is often a good strategy to addressing such questions, because it cuts right to the clinical management question – do these patients benefit from courses of antibiotics?
A 2013 systematic review of the major clinical trials of antibiotic use for patients with alleged chronic Lyme disease concluded:
On the basis of this analysis, the conclusion that there is a meaningful clinical benefit to be gained from retreatment of such patients with parenteral antibiotic therapy cannot be justified.
A 2015 review also concluded:
Prolonged courses of antibiotics neither prevent nor ameliorate these symptoms and are associated with considerable harm.
This brings us to the current study. I found the trial design to be a little unusual, but was justified as trying to replicate how chronic Lyme is often treated in real practice. The study occurred in Europe, and therefore involved the European Borrelia species which causes a slightly different clinical picture than the North American variant.
Enrolled patients did not need to have confirmed prior Lyme disease, so they could include both subjects with post-Lyme symptoms and subjects who never had Lyme. All subjects were given a course of IV antibiotics, ceftriaxone, for two weeks, followed by either placebo or a longer course of oral antibiotics (doxycycline and clarithromycin with hydroxychloroquine.)
The study showed no difference between the treatment and placebo groups, demonstrating that long term antibiotics are ineffective.
In an accompanying editorial, experts who were not part of the study concluded:
Critics may rightly say that this trial does not truly capture with certainty the consequences of bona fide Lyme disease. However, studies with more stringent inclusion criteria have already been conducted, and the approach used by Berende and colleagues probably reflects the common practice in ambulatory care settings, in which patient presentations of fatigue or nonspecific pain prompt serologic checks for Lyme disease, despite evidence suggesting that these tests will not identify a probable cause or result in a treatment benefit.
Conclusion: Where are we now?
If you look at the totality of scientific evidence, it does not support the existence of chronic Lyme disease or the approach of treating patients with long term or recurrent courses of antibiotics.
Patients who end up with this diagnosis tend to have non-specific symptoms that could have many causes, and lack a clinical picture specific to Lyme. They also lack serological proof of active Lyme (although may have had past Lyme). Most significantly, they do not respond to antibiotics in rigorous clinical trials.
Proponents of chronic Lyme essentially just dismiss the scientific evidence, and instead resort to anecdotal evidence of a subjective response to treatment in some patients.
As would be expected, when a group has a persistent belief that experts reject due to lack of scientific evidence, or even evidence of lack of efficacy, conspiracy theories proliferate. In this case the usual “Big Pharma” conspiracy won’t work, because the treatment being offered is pharmaceuticals. So a new enemy was invented, insurance companies. They were made the bogeyman for not wanting to pay for multiple courses of IV antibiotics.
The Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA), a professional organization of experts who reject the claims made for chronic Lyme (and have been sued for holding that opinion), are also accused of being in on the conspiracy. What possible motive would an infectious disease society have for denying that a common illness is caused by an infectious illness?
This just shows how versatile conspiracy theories are. Villains and motives can be made up as needed out of whole cloth, without any burden of logic or consistency.
Unfortunately, gullible (or perhaps cynical) legislators have fallen for the conspiracy theory. In 2009, for example, my own state of Connecticut passed a law shielding health care providers who treat chronic Lyme with long term antibiotics from being held to any standard of care. Insurance companies and the IDSA were specifically pointed to as perpetrating a conspiracy against such providers.
At the time I argued that it is a folly for legislators to decide on what the standard of care is, let alone enshrine it into law. The standard of care is a moving target that shifts with the scientific evidence. Here we are, 7 years later, and the scientific evidence has only moved more in the direction of rejecting chronic antibiotic treatment for alleged chronic Lyme. There is no lobby, however, to get CT legislators to reconsider their past mistakes on this issue – which is precisely why you shouldn’t calcify a particular practice into law.

Chronic Lyme disease: Fake diagnosis, not fake disease
Believe it or not, an encounter on Twitter actually changed Dr. Gorski’s mind. Chronic Lyme disease is a fake diagnosis, not a fake disease.
David Gorski on May 20, 2019
Link

Today, I’d like to do something a bit different than what I usually do, and that’s to take a step back and discuss how an experience in the weeds on Twitter last week led me to start to think about a term that we frequently use or, more specifically, rethink that term. The term to which I refer is “fake disease,” and my rethinking started innocently enough, with me doing what I do sometimes on Twitter: responding to the promotion of quackery by—who else?—Dr. Mehmet Oz:
So @DrOz is promoting chronic Lyme disease quackery. Why not? He promotes pretty much every ornery major firm of quackery.
Chronic Lyme disease is a fake disease, and long term antibiotics do more harm than good. https://t.co/erLyWNp0sW
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) May 15, 2019
Yes, big surprise, last week Dr. Oz was promoting the quackery that are treatments for chronic Lyme disease. I’ll elaborate a bit more in a moment, but for the moment it suffices to point out that we refer to chronic Lyme disease as a “fake disease” because there is no evidence that the symptoms patients diagnosed with chronic Lyme disease suffer are, in fact, due to the tick-borne spirochete that causes acute Lyme disease. What chronic Lyme disease advocates and “Lyme literate” doctors claim is that the symptoms these patients experience are due to chronic persistent infection with B. burgdorferi or other Borrelia species of bacteria that can cause Lyme disease, and that long term antibiotics (as in months or even years of antibiotics) is the treatment. As we’ve pointed out time and time again, though, there is no evidence that chronic Lyme disease/infection exists, and several randomized clinical trials that show very clearly that long term antibiotics do not help and can cause harm. It is, of course, not surprising that prolonged courses of antibiotics can cause harm. They decimate the normal flora of the colon and other niches where bacteria live on the body while selecting for resistant bacteria.
That’s why the CDC, the NIH, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, and the American Academy of Neurology all reject the notion that “chronic Lyme disease” is a scientifically and medically valid diagnosis and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment. Over a dozen international organizations, like the Canadian Public Health Network, and the European Federation of Neurological Societies, concur.
With that knowledge in the back of my head, I didn’t really think that my Tweet would garner much, if any, reaction, as it just didn’t seem too controversial to me. Then Dr. Jen Gunter retweeted it, which exposed it to a much larger audience than I’m accustomed to. Twitter, being Twitter, this predictably led to a lot of angry people Tweeting at me or subtweeting my original Tweet. Here are some examples:
Bit by a tick at 7 yrs. old. Despite tx & other antibiotics over the decades for infections & post surgery protocols I tested CDC positive for Lyme 40 yrs later! I have Post-Treatment Lyme disease syndrome, NOT a FAKE disease.
— Leslie B (@ruready1st) May 17, 2019
And the worlds flat….oh and HIV is fake!!!😂 If you cant keep up with advancements in your field then get out!!!
— J.A.C (@ottyjac) May 16, 2019
Someday you will find out you are as wrong about this as the medical community was when they vehemently denied that ulcers could be caused by bacteria. Because of faulty testing guidelines, Lyme goes undiagnosed and untreated for far too long, at which point it becomes chronic.
— Betsy Cahoon (@SwimBikeRowMom) May 17, 2019
This is what I like to refer to the fallacy of future vindication.
You all laugh and poke fun of lyme. My whole family has it and yes we got tested and for me I tested years after treating and was still positive….if it's fake how is it possible?
— Zimbur (@Zimbur1) May 17, 2019
Yes! This charlatan promotes the fraud, corruption & collusion that keeps shrinking our pool of lyme literate doctors, specialists & treatments. Anxiety, depression, PTSD caused by denial/delay of even inadequate treatment, not Lyme/TBD's infections. Pain, inflammation etc igored
— terri scofield (@terriscofield) May 17, 2019
You sir, are profoundly ignorant. I’ve had Chronic Lyme Disease for 14 years now, and have seen my live spirochetes under a medical microscope. You may want to actually listen to the thousands of patients with this disease, and doctors who have experience in treating it.
— Julie Passetto (@poetgirl2) May 17, 2019
DANGEROUS SHILL ALERT. https://t.co/QYi3MBdD6f
— Dana Parish (@danaparish) May 16, 2019
I do so love the “pharma shill gambit,” but let’s continue:
If tests weren’t so flawed, fraud and failing then more Chronic Lyme disease patients would pop up. You’re inconsiderate for a doctor and pretty uneducated. You lack compassionate care. I feel bad for your patients, who almost all have given you a bad review.
— Holly Lyme 13 (@13Lyme) May 16, 2019
Yes, I do have bad reviews on those doctor review sites, but I haven’t been able to find one of them that, as far as I can tell, was actually one of my patients. Why do I say that? Simple. There are various “tells” and dead giveaways, such as mentioning that I mentioned my blog to them. Basically, I never discuss my blog with patients unless the patient brings it up first, and when that happens I only do it reluctantly. I also can’t help but note that posting bad reviews on doctor review sites is a tactic of the antivaccine movement to harass and intimidate doctors who speak out against their pseudoscience.
In any event, you get the idea. A lot of chronic Lyme disease patients were very unhappy at my characterization of chronic Lyme disease as a “fake disease”. Many of them viewed the term “fake disease” as a direct attack on them, an insinuation that they were hypochondriacs or that their symptoms weren’t real. In the intense world of Twitter, where it’s frequently “Tweet first and ask questions later” and the pithy, biting comment is valued more than it should be, it’s easy to fall into the trap of going for memorable sarcasm, and I appear to have done that. After all, far be it for me (or, I daresay, any of the bloggers here at SBM) to deny that patients with chronic Lyme disease experience symptoms ranging from mild to severely debilitating. The message that we as advocates of science-based medicine trying to promote is that, whatever is causing those symptoms, it’s not what “Lyme literate” doctors claim it is. It’s not persistent infection with B. burgdorferi or other Lyme-associated spirochetes after the initial Lyme infection is treated with antibiotics, and treating people with long term antibiotics for months or even years does not help them and can definitely hurt them.
That’s why I’ve reconsidered and will no longer use the term “fake disease” to describe quack diagnoses like chronic Lyme disease. Instead, henceforth I will use the term “fake diagnosis” or “quack diagnosis” to describe these terms. Now, I can hear the more “militant” and “reason-based” of you out there making like Picard in a facepalm meme and asking, “What the heck is the difference?” Certainly, that’s your prerogative, and—who knows?—you might even be right. But hear me out before dismissing me as going all wobbly.
What is “chronic Lyme disease”?
It’s probably worthwhile here to discuss Lyme disease and its treatment. Lyme disease, as you probably know, is the most common tick-borne infection in the Northern Hemisphere. In the US, it is caused by B. burgdorferi, while in Europe multiple spirochetes (e.g., B. afzelii, B. garinii, B. burgdorferi) can cause it. Lyme disease is a complex infection and has a number of objective signs after one is bitten by a tick harboring Lyme-causing spirochetes, the most common of which is erythema migrans, which is seen early in the infection in about 80% of Lyme disease cases and sometimes called a “bull’s eye rash” because that’s what it often looks like. Even if it doesn’t look like that, it’s still a characteristic expanding rash. Other early symptoms can include fever, fatigue, and headache, while more advanced symptoms can include neurologic symptoms, joint pain and stiffness, severe headaches with neck stiffness, and cardiac symptoms such as palpitations. All of these symptoms usually respond well to conventional antibiotic therapy. However, as noted in a New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) Current Concepts article:
Despite resolution of the objective manifestations of infection after antibiotic treatment, a minority of patients have fatigue, musculoskeletal pain, difficulties with concentration or short-term memory, or all of these symptoms. In this article, we refer to these usually mild and self-limiting subjective symptoms as “post–Lyme disease symptoms,” and if they last longer than 6 months, we call them “post–Lyme disease syndrome.”
It’s true. There is a subset of patients who’ve been treated for properly diagnosed Lyme disease who still have symptoms that persist months or years after treatment, perhaps 10-20% who will develop chronic symptoms of fatigue, muscle aches, poor sleep, and cognitive fog, hence the term post-Lyme disease syndrome. What cause of these symptoms remains poorly understood. Perhaps they’re sequelae of inflammation or an activation of the immune system, or perhaps they’re due to another cause that was triggered by the acute infection. We don’t know yet. What we do know is that there is no convincing evidence that these symptoms are due to persistent B. burgdorferi infection or that long term antibiotics are required to eradicate the disease. Sure, “Lyme literate” doctors point to anecdotes of sometimes-dramatic improvement after long term antibiotics, but anecdotes are one of the lowest forms of medical/scientific evidence, and multiple well-designed clinical trials have failed to demonstrate that longer courses of antibiotics relieve these patients’ symptoms.
The article also echoes the CDC and NIH in pointing out that many patients diagnosed with “chronic Lyme disease” have no evidence of having or ever having had Lyme disease in the first place:
The diagnosis of chronic Lyme disease and its treatment differ substantively from the diagnosis and treatment of recognized infectious diseases. The diagnosis is often based solely on clinical judgment rather than on well-defined clinical criteria and validated laboratory studies, and it is often made regardless of whether patients have been in areas where Lyme disease is endemic.6,7 Although proponents of the chronic Lyme disease diagnosis believe that patients are persistently infected with B. burgdorferi, they do not require objective clinical or laboratory evidence of infection as a diagnostic criterion.
Thus, for “Lyme-literate” MDs, naturopaths, chiropractors, and all manner of other dubious practitioners, “chronic Lyme disease” is a wastebasket diagnosis that “Lyme literate” doctors use for patients with unexplained chronic symptoms. The symptoms are real, hence my objection to the term “fake disease”, but the diagnosis is not based on science or any conventionally accepted reproducible diagnostic criteria. Yes, the NIH notes that there are studies showing that “B. burgdorferi may persist in animals after antibiotic therapy”, including in mice and nonhuman primates, but in the nonhuman primates the NIH noted that it was “not possible to culture these bacteria and it is not clear whether they are infectious.” Not surprisingly, “Lyme-literate” doctors point to these studies as evidence that chronic Lyme disease is a real entity caused by persistent infection with B. burgdorferi. Unfortunately, randomized clinical trials are where the rubber hits the road, and if chronic antibiotic therapy doesn’t improve the symptoms of patients diagnosed with post–Lyme disease symptoms or syndrome, it’s unlikely that the persistence of the Lyme spirochete is the cause of those symptoms, even if someday scientists demonstrate the persistence of B. burgdorferi in humans after standard treatment for Lyme disease.
Fake diagnoses: Beyond chronic Lyme disease
In light of my discussion above, I note that, yes, I’m aware that symptoms do not a disease make. How often do you or I have a headache that goes away, aches and pains, or unexplained fatigue that resolves, none of which are associated with a definable disease? It’s called living and getting older. We all experience these things from time to time, some of us more than others. I’m also aware that, although it might seem deceptively straightforward at first glance, defining just what a “disease” is can be devilishly tricky. I’m not going to go into the weeds of that discussion right here, other than to note that defining a disease is often the necessary first step to determining how to treat it. That’s why it’s so important to note that these patients with chronic symptoms have been labeled as having a disease. Whether the definition of that disease is supportable by science or not doesn’t matter in terms of the explanatory power that it has for the patient. The label assures them that someone is taking their symptoms seriously, as does the treatment associated with the label. That’s why so many of them react so strongly to an attack on their fake diagnosis as a fake disease.
I like the term fake diagnosis more than fake disease, because it’s such a generalizable term in pseudomedicine. I bet that, if you just took a minute to think about it, you could name quite a few other fake diagnoses. If you think about it more, you’ll realize that these fake diagnoses are applied to patients with real symptoms that are as yet unexplained. In my experience having studied these things for nearly two decades, I’ve concluded that, in addition to chronic Lyme disease, the most common fake diagnoses used by quacks include adrenal fatigue; chronic candidiasis; heavy metal toxicity (I still can’t believe that no one’s named a rock band after this); electromagnetic hypersensitivity (sometimes called EMF or Wi-Fi allergy); or deficiency of a nutrient or nutrients, my favorite example being orthomolecular medicine, a whole pseudomedical specialty constructed around testing as many nutrient levels as possible and then massively supplementing any “deficiencies,” whether the deficiency is real or not, whether it needs supplementing or not.
Like chronic Lyme disease, these diagnoses are vaguely and poorly defined, such that basically any patient with any set of puzzling and persistent symptoms can be shoehorned into one of these diagnoses. All of these conditions allow quacks to provide the illusion of “treating the cause, not the symptoms” and to exercise “individualization” of treatment so extreme that they can basically do whatever they want or, as I like to say, make it up as they go along. That same fetish towards “individualization” makes patients feel special and cared for more than a cold, standardized diagnosis and science-based, sometimes algorithmic, treatment or, even worse, lack of a definable diagnosis to explain their symptoms.
What’s the harm of fake diagnoses? Plenty!
What’s the harm of these fake diagnoses? you might ask. Plenty! First and foremost, the problem with placing a fake diagnosis on a set of symptoms that a patient is experiencing is that it can forestall proper medical investigation that might find the real cause of the patient’s symptoms. Indeed, in response to one of my Tweets, just such a patient stepped forward:
Agreed! https://t.co/KVNRL5KMpG
— It's Training Cats and Dogs🐱🐶 (@AbbyHartman) May 16, 2019
Her essay, Lyme Warrior No More, is well worth reading. Here’s a relevant excerpt:
For nearly 11 years, I told people I had chronic Lyme disease. It wasn’t true. Then I told people I had Post Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome, but that can’t be true anymore, either. The one thing I know for sure is that I was a victim of “chronic Lyme” treatment. This consisted of false diagnoses, long-term antibiotics, and other inappropriate drugs and supplements, all based on dangerous pseudoscience.
People who identify as having chronic Lyme usually become entrenched in a cult-like support group community both online and in real life. These Lyme groups are echo-chambers for pseudoscience. They convince followers that they must see self-appointed and often secret “Lyme-literate doctors” (LLMDs) who will treat them for chronic infection. These groups empower their marginalized members with validation, support, and the ability to even treat themselves by comparing notes when there is no access to a LLMD. Their multiple conspiracy theories mirror those of the anti-vaccine community in many ways, and both movements overlap. As it is with cults, it doesn’t matter who you are or how educated you are, anyone can get sucked in. However, this community is disproportionately female. I suspect one reason is that more women report not being taken seriously by doctors, and perhaps many women have little choice but to look to the fringes for help out of desperation. Once you’re marginalized, vulnerable, desperately ill, entrenched in online pseudoscience and conspiracy theory echo chambers, and wooed by the nicest quacks you’ll ever meet, you’re a Lyme Warrior. If you or someone you love is a Lyme Warrior, then please learn from my mistakes.
Her doubts finally started to lead to her leaving the world of chronic Lyme disease quackery when she was told that her son had “congenital Lyme” based on his chronic pain and testing positive for Lyme by a “Lyme literate doctor’s” standards even though he tested negative by CDC standards:
After a few rough nights, I told my husband I was thinking about treating our son for Lyme, but I wasn’t sure if that was the right thing to do– I just couldn’t watch him suffer anymore. My husband had more doubts than me. He wondered if my son was mimicking my own illness he’d been witness to instead of it really being real. I wondered this, too. We decided to wait and talk to Dr. Anderson more. Dr. Anderson did a fantastic job of convincing me with perfect patience and compassion that congenital Lyme is pseudoscience. He also went out of his way to research for over a year until he finally figured out that my son had joints that grossly hyperextended (future contortionist?), which could cause this amount of pain and nightly pattern of pain while growing. Physical therapy was the answer. His pain stopped. Aszani Stoddard, on the other hand, was trying to convince me to treat him and referred me to a Lyme-literate nurse practictioner who treats children at Newbridge Clinic. I declined. She even appealed to my duty to protect my son from medical neglect. This was when I found myself Googling “is chronic Lyme disease real?” in earnest.
The result was that she found Lymescience.org, which led her to question her “Lyme literate doctors” even more and:
I reached out to friends, family, and even veterinarian coworkers with extensive knowledge about Lyme in dogs. I was shocked to learn that some people close to me knew this was quackery and didn’t speak up before I did, even feigning support. This was more upsetting to me than if they had argued with me about my illness really being Lyme, which feels like gaslighting for sick people. I watched my son get back to normal with no Lyme treatment. I felt myself getting better off antibiotics. I spoke with others online who are victims of chronic Lyme treatment. I left my integrative medicine doctor and found a traditional MD. I was no longer a Lyme Warrior.
My new doctor has never heard of the cult of chronic Lyme and stared at me in shock when I told her my story. She thinks my mysterious illness is partly damage done, and she is properly appalled that people think chronic Lyme is a real thing. I trust her to tell me the truth, even if it’s not what I want to hear, and I trust she’ll do it compassionately. When you’ve lost everything to illness, you build up a network of support in which to survive it. People who leave the chronic Lyme cult are often still ill, but now they’re without support to boot. They are even attacked by other Lyme Warriors for speaking out. Honestly, if my speaking out means I might indirectly save even one child from harm, then it is worth it. Being able to eat gluten again isn’t so bad, either.
Indeed. I realize that it must be horrible for these patients who have unexplained symptoms. There’s no doubt that we in medicine need to do better by these patients. However subjecting them to quackery is not the answer.
There are other stories of just this sort of phenomenon. Worse, the cult of chronic Lyme and “Lyme literate” doctors has political power. They’ve not only persuaded state legislators in some states to introduce bills mandating insurance coverage for long term antibiotics for chronic Lyme disease (and in some cases, like Massachusetts, passing them into law, legislators there overrode a veto by the governor so that insurers would have to pay for long-term antibiotic treatment) and protecting “Lyme literate” doctors from sanctions.
Fake diagnosis, not fake disease
This brings us back to the concept of referring to entities like chronic Lyme disease or adrenal fatigue as fake diagnoses or quack diagnoses rather than as fake diseases. I realize that some might view this as a minor matter, a quibble, but as a physician I do not. We at SBM started and continue this blog in order to protect patients from unscientific, ineffective, and potentially harmful medicine. Given that, I, at least, do not want to do anything that patients, even erroneously, interpret as attacks on them. It’s become clear to me that they do interpret the term “fake disease” that way. The term “fake diagnosis” or “quack diagnosis” however, directs the charge of fakery right where it belongs, at the quacks making the bogus diagnosis. The symptoms these patients experience are real. The diagnoses used by quacks to describe these symptoms are not.
I’m under no illusion that a simple change in terminology will lead patients with fake diagnoses to be less hostile to science-based medicine. Nor am I under any illusion that medicine does anywhere near as good a job as it should deal with chronic symptoms that don’t fit easily into a specific disease. On the other hand, language matters, and there is utility in trying to be as clear as possible. Using the term “fake diagnosis” or “quack diagnosis” does help to remind me (and, I hope, others) to take the patient’s complaints and symptoms seriously even if I can’t explain them now and to put the blame for quackery where it belongs, on the quacks, by reminding myself (and, I hope, others) that it’s the quacks who make the fake diagnoses, not the patients and that the answer to helping poorly-understood symptoms is not pseudoscience.

Political Science: Chronic Lyme Disease
Jann Bellamy on November 13, 2014
Link

New York may soon join a handful of other states who reject science-based guidelines for the treatment of Lyme disease in favor of ideological guidelines based on the vociferous lobbying of patients and “Lyme literate” health care providers. Ignoring science is an unfortunate but well-known legislative phenomenon. I’ve discussed it a number of times on SBM, in the form of Legislative Alchemy, the process by which credulous state legislators turn practitioners of pseudoscience into state-licensed health care professionals, such as naturopaths, chiropractors, homeopaths and acupuncturists.
Lyme disease is an infectious disease transmitted by a tick bite. Its symptoms are a rash, fever, headache and fatigue, although not all symptoms may appear. According to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA):
Lyme disease is diagnosed by medical history, physical exam, and sometimes a blood test. It may take four to six weeks for the human immune system to make antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi and therefore show up in a positive blood test. That is why patients with the Lyme rash usually have a negative blood test and diagnosis is based on the characteristic appearance of the rash. Patients with other clinical manifestations such as Lyme arthritis will usually have a blood test. Anyone who has symptoms for longer than six weeks and who has never been treated with antibiotics is unlikely to have Lyme disease if the blood test is negative.
Treatment with antibiotics usually eliminates the symptoms, but delayed treatment can result in more serious problems.
“Chronic” Lyme disease (CLD) is not recognized as a disease in the medical community. Its symptoms are, well, pretty much anything. One description from a post by Harriet Hall:
Lyme is a multi-systemic illness, and may affect every part of the body causing fatigue, stiff neck, headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), anemia, dizziness, joint and muscle pain, brain fog, tingling, numbness and burning sensations of the extremities, memory and concentration problems, difficulties with sleep (both falling asleep and frequent awakening), chest pain and palpitations and/or psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety.
As Dr. Hall correctly notes, “that pretty much covers everyone.” Mark Crislip, SBM’s very own infectious disease guru, uncovered an even broader list of symptoms.
A new term, post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, has been coined for those who had Lyme disease but whose symptoms remain, although there is no good evidence that these symptoms can be attributed to persistent Lyme infection. There is no scientific controversy, however, that “chronic Lyme disease,” as applied to patients with nonspecific symptoms who show no objective evidence that they have been infected with Lyme disease, is a fabricated disease. It is these patients who have been victimized by “Lyme literate” doctors and alternative medicine providers. The main treatment for CLD is long-term antibiotics, for which there is no evidence of effectiveness but serious risks. (Also here.) As you would expect in cases where a collection of vague symptoms have been bootstrapped into a disease (e.g., chronic candidiasis, adrenal fatigue) there are also a number of bogus diagnostic techniques and worthless quack treatments available. (And here too.)
The whole idea that the scientific community is somehow ignoring the evidence is nonsensical when you think about it. What possible incentive would the IDSA and others have to deny the existence of CLD or reject long-term antibiotic therapy? Infectious disease doctors could make a bundle from treating patients with oral, IM and IV antibiotics, especially if it is fee for service. Of course, doctors who promote these treatments, and provide them, likely make a tidy profit doing so (again, especially if they are fee for service). What do you imagine their incentives are?
State legislatures fall for the manufactroversy
But never let the lack of controversy among scientists get in the way of a good manufactroversy, as we’ve seen again and again over in the anti-vaccination department of the nation’s wildly successful anti-science movement. After the manufactroversy has poisoned the well, a variation on the “teach the controversy” strategy can be deployed, whereby credulous legislators, convinced that a controversy among scientists actually exists, proceed to legislate the manufactorversy into existence. That turns the manufactroversy into a real controversy, you see, because the law now says the controversy exists. (Just like the law says chiropractic subluxations and acupuncture meridians exist.)
Lobbying by CLD advocacy groups has resulted in several states passing laws blocking state medical boards from taking action against a physician because he prescribes long-term antibiotic therapy. Currently, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts and California all have these laws on their books. In addition, Maine passed a law requiring state health authorities to provide information to the public about Lyme disease from both the Infectious Diseases Society of America and the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society, the latter of which promotes the validity of CLD diagnosis and the use of long-term antibiotics. Minnesota, Connecticut and Rhode Island require insurers to cover CLD treatment.
Rhode Island’s law bears a closer look, as it demonstrates how lobbyists can successfully insert unsupported assumptions into a law. In its preamble, the bill which eventually became law states that:
Physicians whose practices are devoted to treating chronic Lyme disease patients, and who continue to provide treatment if they feel such treatment is medically necessary, have noted significant improvement in the condition of their patients.
As Steve Novella explained, this perceived improvement could well be due to the placebo effect. Or, it is possible that the antibiotics are having an anti-inflammatory or other pharmacological effect that offers symptomatic relief, in which case we should explore treatments that offer these benefits without the risks of long-term antibiotics. Yet the Rhode Island legislature saw the reported benefits (which could also be due to a number of other reasons, such as confirmation bias) as reason to exonerate these physicians, while at the same time ignoring the evidence against the existence of CLD and the use of antibiotics to treat it.
The preamble also says that “consensus guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of chronic Lyme disease have not been developed.” I don’t know if that was true in 2002, when the law passed, but it certainly isn’t true now. And just because consensus guidelines haven’t been developed, it doesn’t mean “anything goes.” The law goes on to define “Lyme disease” as an infection consistent with the CDC surveillance criteria,
but also includes other acute and chronic manifestations of such an infection as determined by the physician.
In other words, it gave physicians carte blanche to ignore the substantial evidence disconfirming CLD and warning against long-term antibiotic use.
New York appears poised to join those states protecting “Lyme literate” doctors from prosecution, a position supported by at least one credulous newspaper editorial board. Both the Senate and the Assembly passed just such a bill, which awaits the Governor Cuomo’s signature. He’s indicated he will sign it.
In the hearings leading up to passage of the bill, one legislator said he’d been asked by his constituents “suffering from chronic Lyme disease” to pass legislation like this for a long time because:
This will offer a great amount of relief to families that are truly suffering, that are going bankrupt, they’re mortgaging their homes, trying to find a way to deal with this devastating disease.
Sadly, that indicates to me that a lot of people are being ripped off by “Lyme literate” doctors.
This bill is unlike the others in that it begins with this startling introductory sentence:
Neither the board for professional medical conduct nor the office of professional medical conduct shall identify, charge, or cause a report made to the director of such office to be investigated based solely upon the recommendation or provision of a treatment modality by a licensee that is not universally accepted by the medical profession, including but not limited to, varying modalities used in the treatment of lyme disease and other tick-borne diseases.
This seems to cover not only treatment with long-term antibiotics but pretty much anything any physician wants to dream up in the way of a “treatment modality” for any disease or condition as long as there is not “universal acceptance” that this is not a good idea. Of course, anytime a small group of dissenters wants to take exception to the medical profession, they can argue that there is not “universal acceptance,” no matter how kooky their ideas are.
This interpretation appears to be confirmed by the next sentence in the bill, which says a physician can employ these “varying modalities” as long as the treatment is in accord with this “health freedom” provision of the NY physician practice act that permits the use of:
whatever medical care, conventional or non-conventional, which effectively treats human disease, pain, injury, deformity or physical condition.
I suppose there two outs here for the science-minded. One is that the bill covers only treatments, not diagnoses, perhaps providing some leeway for disciplinary action based on a diagnosis of CLD. The other is the provision in the existing law, which says the treatment must be effective.
All I can say is good luck to the state medical board and the courts in interpreting this one.
The legislature also passed a resolution asking the CDC, the NIH, and other federal agencies for additional Lyme disease prevention efforts and research. One does wonder, however, if they will pay attention to the research produced. If the legislature is ignoring the medical consensus at this point, what exactly is it that would convince them of their folly? And will they go back and repeal the new law (if it becomes law) if this new research somehow persuades them that the IDSA and other responsible experts are, in fact, correct?
Blumenthal: still promoting CLD after all these years
As I explained in an earlier post, former Connecticut Attorney General, and now U.S. Senator, Richard Blumenthal:
sued the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) for antitrust violations because both groups reached the same conclusion regarding the non-existence of Chronic Lyme disease.According to Blumenthal, both groups’ reasoning in reaching the same conclusion “at times used strikingly similar language.” He smelled a conspiracy. In his view, the guidelines “improperly ignored or minimized consideration of alternative medical opinion and evidence regarding Chronic Lyme disease.” Apparently, Blumenthal knew so little about science he didn’t realize that when the same evidence is reviewed by two different groups it is perfectly reasonable for them to come to the same conclusion. Nor did he realize that, in reviewing evidence, it is not appropriate to consider any quack theory that comes along, no matter how ludicrous. The irony is obvious: Blumenthal was willing to accept Chronic Lyme disease despite the lack of evidence that it exists. He then turned around and sued the doctors’ groups for relying on good evidence to support their conclusion that it didn’t.
The suit was settled when the IDSA agreed to review its position. That review has now been completed with the IDSA reconfirming its earlier position after another look at the evidence.
Sen. Blumenthal remains unrepentant and as far as I know has never acknowledge the IDSA’s confirmation of its earlier position in 2010. At a forum last year hosted by, among others, Sen. Blumenthal, he continued to maintain that there is a legitimate controversy in the medical community and that insurers should cover treatments doctors think is best, noting Connecticut’s insurance mandate. The latter sentiment, if applied to quacks and charlatans and all diseases, real or imagined, could drive us all to bankruptcy with increased premiums.
A similar hostility to the current evidence was displayed by U.S. Rep. Chris Gibson (R-NY), who also spoke at the forum. He is the sponsor of legislation recently passed by the House of Representatives, the “Tick-borne Disease Research Transparency and Accountability Act,” now pending in the Senate. Rep. Gibson accused the CDC of “Lyme illiteracy” and spoke of a “bifurcation in the medical community” concerning Lyme disease.
The House bill may not be a bad idea. It forms a “Lyme and Tick-Borne Disease Working Group” to look into the evidence and make recommendations, although it provides no money for the Group to perform its duties. It requires the inclusion of advocacy groups. The bill also requires that a “diversity” of scientific opinion be represented.
As with NY’s effort, however, one wonders exactly what level of evidence would be acceptable to those convinced that their symptoms are due to chronic Lyme disease and that long-term antibiotic therapy is the proper course of treatment. Or to Lyme literate doctors who treat them, whose income is jeopardized by further evidence of the lack of safety and effectiveness. There is clearly a scientific consensus among responsible parties that CLD is not a valid disease and that long-term antibiotic treatment is not only not beneficial, it can be dangerous. What else is necessary to sway the dissenters?
I don’t think anyone doubts there are people who experience fatigue, joint stiffness, neck pain and the like, but for whom no clear diagnosis exists. Nor does anyone doubt that some medical professionals brusquely dismissed their symptoms. And no one doubts that real Lyme disease exists or that improvements in diagnosis and treatment, as well as research into other tick-borne diseases and prevention, is warranted. But none of that is an excuse to take advantage patients with a fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme disease” or treat them with long-term antibiotics and other dubious remedies. Nor is it a valid reason for advocacy groups to browbeat legislators into enshrining CLD into law or for legislators to equate popularity with scientific evidence.

Lemons and Lyme: Bogus tests and dangerous treatments of the Lyme-literati
John Snyder on July 18, 2014
Link
It’s that time of year when every day I can expect to see at least one patient with a concern about Lyme disease. In Lyme-endemic regions such as Western Massachusetts, where I practice pediatrics, summer brings a steady stream of children to my office with either the classic Lyme rash (erythema chronicum migrans, or ECM), an embedded tick, a history of a tick bite, or non-specific signs or symptoms that may or may not be due to Lyme disease. Sometimes the diagnosis is relatively straightforward. A child is brought in after a parent has pulled off an engorged deer tick, and there is a classic, enlarging ECM rash at the site of the bite. More often the presentation is less clear, requiring detective work and science-based reasoning to make an informed decision and a diagnostic and therapeutic plan based on the best available evidence. Depending on the story, the plan may include immediate treatment without any testing (as in the straightforward case described above), immediate testing without treatment pending test results, or waiting as we watch and see how a rash progresses before doing anything. An example of this latter course of action would be when a patient comes in with a pink swelling at the site of a new tick bite. In this case, it may not be clear if the swelling is a Lyme rash or simply a local reaction to the bite, a much more common occurrence. The classic ECM rash (an enlarging, red, circular, bull’s-eye rash at or near a tick bite) typically develops 1-2 weeks after a tick bite, but can occur anywhere from 3-30 days later. It then expands and darkens over another 1-3 weeks before fading. This classic rash is not the most common rash of Lyme disease, however, as it occurs in only about 30% of cases. Instead, the rash may be uniformly pink or red (or even darker in the center) without the target-like appearance, or may be a linear rash, expanding outward from the tick bite site. In the case of a patient who comes in with a vague, pink swelling within a day few days of a tick bite, we will typically wait and see what happens to the rash. If it is a local reaction, it will likely resolve within another few days. With Lyme disease, the rash will continue to enlarge and declare itself as an ECM rash. Another unclear and not uncommon situation is when a patient comes in with non-specific symptoms such as fatigue, musculoskeletal pains, and headache. If warranted by the history and the physical exam, we may in this case order Lyme testing. This may not give us an answer even if the patient has Lyme disease, because results are often negative in the first few weeks of the disease. In this case, if symptoms persist or evolve, we will repeat the testing in another few weeks at which point true Lyme disease will test positive and can then be treated. The good news is that the treatment of Lyme disease, particularly in the early, localized phase of the disease, is extremely safe and effective with a 14-day course of antibiotics. The testing is also relatively straightforward, with very good sensitivity and specificity when performed correctly. And this is where the bad news comes…
Lyme-literate doctors
Though providers who choose to practice a science-based approach to caring for their patients stick to the CDC-recommended testing protocol, created using the best evidence, there are many so-called “Lyme literate” providers who stray from the evidence-based path to offer up a potpourri of unapproved, non-recommended, and expensive tests to their patients. The purpose of these tests is without a doubt to detect cases of Lyme disease that other, presumably Lyme-illiterate providers missed due to their “close-mindedness” to these superior tests. Before we discuss these maverick, enlightened providers further, let’s review the tests that are currently recommended by the CDC and the best available evidence.
The CDC has set forth a relatively simple protocol for the use of laboratory testing to confirm a suspected case of Lyme disease. The current, science-based consensus on laboratory diagnostic testing for Lyme disease comes from the Second National Conference on Serologic Diagnosis of Lyme Disease, which convened in 1994. Based on the best available evidence, the Conference recommended a two-step testing protocol using a single blood sample.
Step I: ELISAIn step I, an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is used to detect antibodies to a wide assortment of antigens from B. burgdorfori, the Lyme organism. If this test is negative, it is likely that either the patient does not have Lyme disease, or that the test was performed too early in the course of the illness (the first 3-4 weeks). In this case, the test should be repeated in a few weeks, assuming the diagnosis is still being considered due to persistent signs or symptoms. If, on the other hand, the result of step I is positive or equivocal, a more definitive and specific test is performed.
Step II: Western BlotIf Step I is positive or equivocal, we move to step II, the Western blot (WB) test. This looks for antibodies to specific Lyme proteins that have been separated based on their molecular weights. These separated proteins are then exposed to the patient’s blood sample. If the patient has antibodies to these proteins, they bind to them and are visible as bands on the WB. A specific pattern of positive bands of sufficient intensity are required to be present for the WB to be interpreted as positive.
When performed correctly, this test is considered highly specific for Lyme disease. When well-trained individuals at certified labs perform the correct FDA-approved tests in appropriate circumstances, and when providers interpret the results correctly, Lyme disease testing can be a reliable way to confirm or rule out the disease with a high degree of validity. Unfortunately, this does not always occur.
Confirmation bias and the Lyme-literati
Individuals who believe they have Lyme disease that was missed by their own providers will sometimes seek out so-called “Lyme-literate” providers; I’ll call them Lymlits. Often these individuals believe they are suffering from chronic Lyme disease (a non-entity discussed elsewhere), and are hoping to confirm this diagnosis. Lymlits provide the confirmation bias these patients are looking for. They quickly empathize with these patients and offer what they claim to be a more informed approach to their diagnosis and treatment. Like all alternative medicine providers (and make no mistake, that is exactly what we are talking about here), they are quick to cast the patient’s more conventional provider as shackled by convention, or to Big Government or Big Pharma. Often they claim a more holistic approach as well, infusing other sCAM modalities or spiritualism into the mix. Again, like many sCAM providers, they claim special knowledge and insights not available to or ignored by conventional providers. To the sCAM-credulous, the Lymlits represent an open, understanding ear and long-sought answers to their problems.
The websites of Lymlit providers clearly pander to the fears, anxieties, and preconceptions of their clients. Often they contain entire sections devoted to the “problem” of undiagnosed (but not over-diagnosed) Lyme disease, and how the Lymlits can help uncover the diagnosis and provide the correct (often dangerously incorrect) treatment. The patients I see at my practice who have bought into a wide variety of woo diagnoses and treatments have often been seen by providers of the Northampton Wellness Center, and the over-diagnosis and treatment of Lyme disease is no exception. Their services are so typical of this this kind of practice that I will use them as an example. A quick perusal of their website’s Lyme disease section should be of concern to anyone who cares about the practice of EBM and SBM. Like many sCAM practitioners, this group does not serve as primary care providers but rather as “consultants”. This is a misnomer, however, as they are rarely consulted by science-based providers. Rather, patients typically self-refer. Using a “holistic” approach, they claim the ability to help patients with chronic illness who have not been helped by their conventional providers. What they offer is reassurance that they have come to the right place, that they will get the answers they are looking for, and receive treatments not available through most providers. Ironically, their diagnostic tests and treatment modalities are usually described with terms borrowed from true science, and are often claimed to be evidence-based as well. The Northampton Wellness Center’s website seems to do everything possible to reaffirm people’s fears about their chronic or undiagnosed Lyme disease. It explains why the organism is so tricky to diagnose and treat (it really isn’t), and how they can do so safely, effectively, and often “naturally” and “holistically”. They hype the existence and importance of biofilms, co-infections, weakened immune systems, and heavy metals in the pathogenesis of Lyme disease, and explain how they can help diagnose and fix these problems. And unsurprisingly, the Northampton Wellness Center website has the clear red-flag seen on many other sCAM practice websites – the ubiquitous web store. These stores typically hawk all manner of supplements, potions, and snake oils to treat your every ailment. I couldn’t access the Northampton Wellness Center’s web store without being a patient, so I don’t know exactly what they offer the chronic Lyme sufferer. Perhaps most alarmingly, Lymlits like those at the Northampton Wellness Center hype unapproved and non-recommended laboratory tests for diagnosing Lyme disease in their patients. One example is an extended, purportedly-superior Western blot assay. According to their website:
Unfortunately, most laboratories leave out the most specific bands, 31 and 34, on their Western Blot assays. If we use a special laboratory and get a positive band 31 result, we can confirm that this is truly related to the Lyme organism by doing a “31 kDa epitope” test, to make sure it is not positive from a cross-reaction, which could occur from having a chronic viral infection.
Without getting too deep into the weeds here, the Internet is rife with conspiracy theories about why the CDC would fail to include the 31 kDa band in the group of bands required to be present for a positive Western blot interpretation. At the heart of the conspiracy is the belief that this band, which represents OspA, the outer surface protein of B. burgdorferi, was left out because OspA was the main component of a Lyme vaccine (Lymrix) which is no longer available but was given to nearly 2 million people before it was taken off the market. The allegation is that the band was not included because people who had received Lymerix would likely test falsely positive. Given the limited number of individuals vaccinated with Lymerix, this seems an unlikely explanation. Another allegation is that the CDC and FDA do not want people to be diagnosed with Lyme disease as a result of a conspiracy involving the insurance industry. However, as explained by Halperin et al. in the book Lyme disease: an evidence-based approach, the explanation is much more mundane (and rational) than this:
the bands selected for use in the Western blot were chosen not because they are unique to B. burgdorferi but rather on the basis of statistical considerations that included an analysis of those combinations of bands that provided the best predictive values for well-characterized specimens known to have been obtained from individuals with and without Lyme disease
In other words, though OspA is a relatively specific marker for infection with B. burgdorfori, in the assessment of actual patients it was not found to be among the group of bands which best distinguished Lyme disease patients from controls.
They go on to add that that:
laboratories using criteria other than these must establish the validity of their own criteria based on equally rigorous scientific assessments.
Scientists are actively working on better, more sensitive and specific diagnostic tests for Lyme disease. But it will take reproducible and validated results to move these tests forward. Not the direct marketing of unsupported tests to Lymlits by specialty labs. Other examples of unapproved and non-recommended tests discussed on the Northampton Wellness Center website and recommended by many Lymlits include dot-blot testing, PCR, and T-lymphocyte response assays. The CDC clearly states that none of these tests are sufficiently reliable for diagnosing Lyme disease. In 2005, the CDC became so concerned about the proliferation of non-validated and potentially dangerous tests for Lyme disease, that it issued an alert in its Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR). In April of this year, the CDC issued yet another warning about a new laboratory-developed culture method that has been made available commercially. Again, the CDC has warned that the results of these types of “home-brewed” tests should not be relied upon. According to the warning:
Published methods and results for this laboratory-developed test have been reviewed by CDC. The review raised serious concerns about false-positive results caused by laboratory contamination and the potential for misdiagnosis.
The CDC’s warnings are justified. While Lymlits claim these specialized tests are better able to detect Lyme disease than those used by conventional practices, what they do, in fact, is produce a predictable increase in false-positive results. Thus, by pretending to have superior testing options than those provided by the patient’s primary care provider, Lymlits provide patients with the elusive Lyme disease diagnosis they are searching for, and then offer unnecessary treatments for a non-existent infection. Ignoring the science-based treatment recommendations of the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA), Lymlits often recommend dangerously long, sometimes intravenous courses of antibiotics, in addition to myriad other potentially dangerous sCAM modalities for the treatment of these questionable infections. Additionally, the misdiagnosis of Lyme disease in these individuals potentially delays the diagnosis of other, real conditions, which then go untreated.
Ironically, Lyme advocates and Lyme-conspiracy proponents were at the forefront of the manufactroversy surrounding the demise of Lymerix, the first FDA-approved Lyme vaccine. Although Lymerix, whose main component was the OspA protein, was not the most effective vaccine (with an efficacy rate <80%), it was still a cost-effective preventative strategy for people at risk in endemic areas. Unfortunately a slew of adverse events reported soon after the vaccine was licensed, combined with an irresponsible (but predictable) media storm, put a chill on the use of the vaccine, eventually leading to its economic failure and being pulled from the market. Pre- and post-marketing studies involving large numbers of patients failed to link any significant adverse events to Lymerix beyond the usual injection site redness and swelling and occasionally fever seen with other vaccines. There was some evidence that a small subset of people with the HLA-DRB1*0401 genotype might be at risk for developing an autoimmune reactive arthritis in response to the vaccine, though the data was inconclusive and did not prove causality. Still these concerns, combined with the spreading fear of unsupported adverse events and the ensuing media frenzy was enough to put an end to the vaccine, a vaccine that could have led to the prevention of many cases of Lyme disease.
Conclusion: Lymlit tests are not supported by good evidence
Lymlit doctors claim they are providing their patients with a service that most others are either unwilling or lacking the knowledge to provide. They balk at the argument that these tests are not supported by sufficient evidence of validity, citing junk science, data from the proprietary labs themselves, or anecdote to support their position. These arguments are often shrouded in conspiracy theory, invoking closed-door sessions in which physicians and scientists do the bidding of Big Pharma or the insurance industry. So-called Lyme advocacy organizations have evolved to support individuals who believe they have chronic Lyme disease or Lyme disease undiagnosed by their doctors. While research is underway to develop even more sensitive and specific tests for diagnosing Lyme disease, the current strategy recommended by the CDC is the best we have to date. Unfortunately, as long as there are providers willing to pander to conspiracy theorists and to patients looking to confirm their fears, people will continue to be needlessly treated, and our societal approach to science will move further back in time.

Lyme Testing
Mark Crislip on January 8, 2016
Link


I hate those oh hell moments. I was up way too late last night, but who can pass up the opportunity to see Patti Smith playing Horses (and more) for the 40th anniversary of the album. Only 44? Behind the Eagles? No way. I would nudge it up a few more spaces. Hard to believe I was 18 when that album came out. Horses is one of the few albums that made the transition from vinyl to CD. It was a tremendous show, and at 69 Patt performs with the energy and passion of a 29 year old. And she sure can spit. I had the evening off, so food and drinks at Swine until well past midnight. First time my wife and I closed a bar. I am too old for this.
But as I was blearily drinking my a.m. coffee on a dreary PDX morning, I opened the browser to SBM and there was a post by Jann. Oh hell. That means I have a post due tomorrow and I had lost track of the time over the holidays. I thought my next post was next Friday. Oh. Hell. So unlike most posts which I write over a week, this one was done in about 4 hours. And I am sure it will show.
How do you diagnose an infection?
Not always so simple. You always start with a history and, for infectious diseases, an exposure history is paramount. People get what they are exposed to, so you want to know travel, animals, diet, water, sex etc. If you have ridden a horse to have sex in an Indian lake while drinking raw milk (not really an unusual history in my practice; people do the darndest things) you have exposure risks for a variety of infections. If you have not left the Willamette Valley it is unlikely that the cause of the illness is malaria, although you always have to consider that the infection came to the patient rather than the other way around.
A panoply of bacteria
In Oregon it is also unlikely that the cause of your symptoms is Lyme, as we do not have much Borrelia in the state. Yet there are many symptomatic people who have a positive blood test for Lyme. Having a positive blood test for a disease is a very powerful confirmation that you have a disease, right? Well, yes and no. Like much of medicine, it is not as straight forward as one would like.
First, Borellia. In the US, Lyme is due to Borrelia burgdorferi. In Europe there are Borrelia burgdorferi, Borrelia afzelii, and Borrelia garinii. And there are the relapsing fever Borrelia, B. recurrentis, B. hermsii, B. parkeri, or B. miyamotoi, the last probably more common than suspected. And there are other spirochetes, like syphilis and leptospirosis, in family. Spirochetes are a large phylum of what I think are particularly evil appearing organisms. They just look pathogenic and I can always imagine them corkscrewing into tissues to cause disease.
The gold standard in ID for diagnosis is culture. If you can grow the organism then you have the diagnosis. Usually. Again it depends. The world is a remarkably filthy place and sometimes the cultures are contaminated. And more aggravating are negative cultures. There are a variety of reasons that cultures can be negative, but the main one is that we simply cannot grow the vast majority of microorganisms from people or the environment. Some organisms, such as Borrelia, are too difficult to grow outside of specialty labs.
When you can’t grow an organism you have to rely on less accurate methods of diagnosis. Some diseases, like syphilis and extrapulmonary tuberculosis, remain very difficult to rule in or out with confidence, despite plaguing humans for millennia.
Lyme testing: Do little but dab it
For US Lyme we rely on indirect, two-step testing to determine if the disease is present; first is a screening ELISA followed by a confirmatory western blot. The test we use was validated in patients with culture-proven Lyme, so we know what the false positive and negative rates are, the sensitivity and specificity.
The ELISA is a screening test and, like many screening tests in ID, are designed to be overly sensitive. You don’t want to miss a real case of Lyme but it is at the cost of having a positive test that due to other processes. Remember all those spirochetes mentioned above? They, and other infections, can lead to a positive Lyme ELISA. The ELIZA is sensitive, but it is not specific. It will pick up Lyme, but a lot of other diseases as well.
To get a more specific answer, you do a western blot. The western blot has two flavors, the IgM (for acute disease) and the IgG (for more prolonged disease). IgM is the first antibody to respond to infection, lasting a couple of months and eventually supplanted by IgG, which is lifelong. The current testing may occasionally give a positive that is actually from infection due to B. miyamoitoi in the US, but for spirochetes, there is not a lot of data, but most will have a negative western blot.
So a positive standard two step Lyme test says you have (or had if it was treated) Lyme disease. But that is the problem with serology – it does not say if you have active disease or reinfection. That is where risk and symptoms come to play.
The diversity of species
But what about European Lyme? Is the Borrelia in Europe the same as in the US? Doubt it. Organisms separated by geography will diverge. It has happened with histoplasmosis, coccidiomycosis and Plasmodium ovale to name but a few. They may look the same and act the same but genetically they are different. The same applies to US and European Borellia; they are different enough that it affects testing. The US two-step test was developed against a US strain of Borrelia and is probably not optimal for the diagnosis of European Lyme. A better test if you can’t fly back to Germany is probably the C6 ELISA, and that may be a sufficient screening test that does not need a confirmatory Western blot.
It is an interesting question whether the genetic diversity of Borrelia as you get further away from the NE epicenter may alter the sensitivity of Lyme testing if using tests developed in the US. There are also issues in the future with genetic drift due to climate change and the movement of the animal reservoirs, the natural evolution of the organism, and the discovery of other Borrelia that could affect the epidemiology and testing for Lyme. As of now, these do not appear to be issues and the standard testing remains both sensitive and specific for diagnosing Lyme.
All this testing is under the assumption that there is a reasonable pretest probability that the patient could have Lyme. If the pretest probability is low, as in Oregon, any positive test in a patient with no risk and atypical symptoms is likely a false positive:
Predictive value is determined both by test characteristics (sensitivity and specificity) and, importantly, by the population in which it is used. The practice of testing patients with a low likelihood of Lyme disease can generate more false-positive results than true-positive results, resulting in misdiagnosis and thereby harming ill people…However, when the pretest probability is low, most positive test results are false positives (67%).
That is a tough concept for doctors and patients to wrap their heads around with any type of testing. The test is positive; it must be due to disease.
What about other Lyme tests?
With little oversight, laboratories can develop their own tests and offer them to patients. The questions are whether they are accurate, and what they were validated against, so you know what the true sensitivity and specificity is. Many of the alternative tests for Lyme have no documented validation, so their sensitivity and specificity is not known. And some labs have their own unvalidated interpretation of the standard two step. Any indirect test for infection has to be validated against a population with known disease, patients with positive cultures, to be of use.
The specialty labs for Lyme testing have been evaluated and found to be wanting, with false positive rates approaching 50% depending on the lab. With the Lyme specialty laboratories:
…one could claim that their methods provided greater sensitivity. However, this increase in sensitivity came at what can only be considered an unacceptable price, a steep decrease in specificity: 15 of 40 (37.5%) of the normal healthy controls met their IgM criteria, 11 of the 40 (27.5%) met their IgG criteria, and 23 of the 40 healthy controls (57.5%) met one or the other.
Widespread testing for Lyme in populations at little risk for the disease offers little benefit:
With 20%–25% of the population having nonspecific complaints, the positive predictive value of a positive serology using CDC criteria, IgG only for complaints of >4 weeks, is extremely poor. It is certainly not diagnostic. For serologies with specificities like those of reported for Lyme specialty laboratory B, a “positive” serology in this patient population has such a low positive predictive value that it has virtually no value. Simply stated, basing a diagnosis of LD or any other tick-borne infectious disease on the presence of ≥1 of these common vague symptoms is unjustified.
These unvalidated tests are one of the reasons why the FDA is in investigating the process by which these labs offer their tests.
And, interestingly, those with false positive Lyme serologies get labeled as chronic Lyme disease but their clinical presentation is identical to patients diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome (now called systemic exertion intolerance disease, abbreviated SEID). Whatever the etiology of SEID is, it is a debilitating illness and sloppy diagnostic testing will result in patients being funneled into the black hole of chronic Lyme treatment instead of, hopefully, the more fruitful future of SEID research.
Alternative tests: More “science fiction” than science
Other diagnostic tests not to be used for Lyme:
    • Capture assays for antigens in urine
    • Culture, immunofluorescence staining, or cell sorting of cell wall-deficient or cystic forms of B. burgdorferi
    • Lymphocyte transformation tests
    • Quantitative CD57 lymphocyte assays
    • “Reverse western blots”
    • In-house criteria for interpretation of immunoblots
    • Measurements of antibodies in joint fluid (synovial fluid)
    • IgM or IgG tests without a previous ELISA/EIA/IFA
And, unfortunately, the PCR is of little use.
Of course it’s really all just a conspiracy!
There does need to be better Lyme testing. As a practicing ID doctor, tests like these are an indirect means of diagnosing disease; while very good, they are still far from ideal. I am sure there will be no CDC-supported test that will satisfy those who believe in chronic Lyme disease. In that universe there are no false positive tests, only false negatives, and the CDC and FDA are in a conspiracy to cover up the truth about Lyme.
For Lyme, and many other infections, diagnosing a disease is not based on a test in isolation. It depends on the risks, the symptoms, and the operative characteristics of the test. No specific risks, no characteristic symptoms, and a positive result from an unvalidated test, is not the way to diagnose Lyme.

More Lyme ‘Guidelines’
Mark Crislip on October 2, 2015
Link


I noted with understanding that the Doubtful News can’t take it anymore. The relentless tsunami sewage slurry of pseudo-science (who says I can’t alliterate?) has worn her down. She is:
currently experiencing a phase in which I can’t seem to bring myself to promote another ridiculous story in the media about a haunted location, scary sounds from the sky, or the latest outrage fueled by ancient superstition. You might call that… jaded. It’s been over four years now of nearly daily effort to keep track of the weird world of woo. It can wear one down when virtually or literally the same thing appears and reappears over and over as if it hasn’t already been passed around a million times.
I sympathize. I have had a touch of SCAM ennui of late. It is a bit due to the repetitiveness of the SCAMs. I still find the variations on the theme of pseudo-sciences curious. It is like infectious diseases where every case has unique and subtle diversity so no two SCAMs are the same. But there are almost 4,000 clinical trials on acupuncture and I would wager that they all have several of the same half-dozen fatal errors. It is like hand hygiene at work. We have known for, oh what, 160 years, that hand hygiene prevents the spread of disease but people still can’t do it right. We know how to do a good clinical trial but the SCAMsters just can’t seem to figure it out.
The ennui is not the seeming futility of the endeavor. I have always been comfortable with futility, secure, as an example, in the knowledge that someday I will be consumed by the bacteria I spent a career killing. Unless, of course, they get me cremated right away. I keep looking for a motto for the SfSBM; I am attracted to “Sisyphus had it easy.”
The painful necessities of Lyme literacy
There are some topics I feel an obligation to cover, a necessity that is hard to tackle with enthusiasm, like taking out the trash. But after six years of writing for this blog I fear I am running out of ways to discuss SCAMs in novel ways. Simply rolling my eyes and making a gagging motion is hardly a sufficient blog entry, which was my initial response to “Evidence assessments and guideline recommendations in Lyme disease: the clinical management of known tick bites, erythema migrans rashes and persistent disease” over at the National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC). Not unlike Publishers Clearing House, the NGC are not responsible for the content of the product they offer as long as the guidelines meet their criteria, but I doubt they are going to send me a big check.
Some of those criteria include:
A description of study selection that includes the number of studies identified, the number of studies included, and a summary of inclusion and exclusion criteria.
A synthesis of evidence from the selected studies, e.g., a detailed description or evidence tables.
A summary of the evidence synthesis (see 3d above) included in the guideline that relates the evidence to the recommendations, e.g., a descriptive summary or summary tables.
I am reminded of several posts ago where I discussed how the system was gamed to allow a naturopathic clinic to be a center of excellence. I have filed a Freedom of Information request for more information on that farce. I get the hint that these Lyme guidelines are the same. This guideline is like that curious incident of the dog in the night-time; it is what is not mentioned that is interesting.
An update and a downvote
There are numerous issues with the International Lyme and Associated Disease Society (ILADS) guidelines, some of which I have discussed in the past. One problem I have as I write this is that the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) guidelines are being updated with an expected release date in the fall of 2016. So we have at least a year to wait before we have a more reality-based approach to Lyme disease.
Time and energy preclude addressing every part of even this brief guideline. I hope that when the IDSA releases their guidelines they will also do a compare and contrast with ILADS. But I will not hold my breath. When it has come to Lyme and vaccination the IDSA has not been on the front lines of defending science against pseudo-science.
So I will focus on one section, the need for retreatment of Lyme:
…in the panel’s judgment, antibiotic retreatment will prove to be appropriate for the majority of patients who remain ill. Prior to instituting antibiotic retreatment, the original Lyme disease diagnosis should be reassessed and clinicians should evaluate the patient for other potential causes of persistent disease manifestations. The presence of other tick-borne illnesses should be investigated if that had not already been done. Additionally, clinicians and their patients should jointly define what constitutes an adequate therapeutic trial for this particular set of circumstances.
When antibiotic retreatment is undertaken, clinicians should initiate treatment with 4 to 6 weeks of the selected antibiotic; this time span is well within the treatment duration parameters of the retreatment trials. Variations in patient-specific details and the limitations of the evidence imply that the proposed duration is a starting point and clinicians may, in a variety of circumstances, need to select therapeutic regimens of longer duration.
What do you call a recommendation based on very low quality data? Belief. Belief is what you do in the absence of data. Like most the ILADS recommendations, the recommendations, often strong recommendations, are based on low-quality data. But more than basing their suggestions on low quality data, they ignore the fact that there is data that contradicts their position.
There are clinical trials that address the issue of re-treating Lyme. Like all clinical trials, you can find issues in study design when you read them carefully. But they say more or less the same thing: treating patients with persisting symptoms of Lyme has no long-lasting effects:
    • “A randomized, placebo-controlled trial of repeated IV antibiotic therapy for Lyme encephalopathy“:
IV ceftriaxone therapy results in short-term cognitive improvement for patients with post-treatment Lyme encephalopathy, but relapse in cognition occurs after the antibiotic is discontinued.
    • “Study and treatment of post Lyme disease (STOP-LD): a randomized double masked clinical trial“:
Because fatigue (a nonspecific symptom) was the only outcome that improved and because treatment was associated with adverse events, this study does not support the use of additional antibiotic therapy with parenteral ceftriaxone in post-treatment, persistently fatigued patients with PLS.
    • “Two controlled trials of antibiotic treatment in patients with persistent symptoms and a history of Lyme disease“:
There is considerable impairment of health-related quality of life among patients with persistent symptoms despite previous antibiotic treatment for acute Lyme disease. However, in these two trials, treatment with intravenous and oral antibiotics for 90 days did not improve symptoms more than placebo.
You can quibble over issues in these studies. I can with every clinical trial. But all the information points in the same direction: there are no persisting symptoms after treatment for Lyme that are amenable to further antibiotic therapy. And it is better data than that used to support retreatment.
I love killing microscopic corkscrews
As an ID doc who spends a lot of time with hard-to-kill organisms, spirochetes are refreshingly susceptible to antibiotics and die with ease. I am well aware of the various arguments to suggest that Lyme has developed ways to avoid being killed by antibiotics. That would be a blog entry in itself, but I have read the papers and find them less than compelling and, when considering the biology of spirochetes, probably not even wrong. I have suspected that the complete lack of response to even months-long courses of IV antibiotics is a strong clinical suggestion that there is nothing there to kill. Patient being treated for chronic Lyme just never seem to get better with ILADS-based therapies.
Don’t trust the antitrust
In 2006 there was an antitrust investigation by the Connecticut Attorney General that cost the IDSA money they could ill afford. They settled and as part of the settlement the IDSA agreed:
to convene a Review Panel whose task would be to determine whether or not the 2006 Lyme Guidelines were based on sound medical/scientific evidence and whether or not these guidelines required change or revision.
I will also mention with no irony that one of the complaints about the IDSA guidelines was that those who were involved with their production were compromised by ties with industry, and biased against chronic Lyme and its treatment. The National Guidelines Clearinghouse document was written in part by the President of ILADS, the organization that is the biggest proponent for the long term treatment of Lyme. Oh no, no bias here. Keep on moving.
And now the big reveal!
Here now are the results of that IDSA review:
2006 RecommendationTo date, there is no convincing biologic evidence for the existence of symptomatic chronic B. burgdorferi infection among patients after receipt of recommended treatment regimens for Lyme disease.
Panel Determination/Discussion – The Review Panel determined that this recommendation is medically/scientifically justified in light of all of the evidence and information provided (7-1).
2006 RecommendationAntibiotic therapy has not proven to be useful and is not recommended for patients with chronic (>6 months) subjective symptoms after recommended treatment regimens for Lyme disease (E-I).
Panel Determination/Discussion – The Review Panel determined that this recommendation is medically/scientifically justified in light of all of the evidence and information provided (8-0)
And they further noted on review:
     1.  The prospective, controlled clinical trials for extended antibiotic treatment of Lyme disease have demonstrated considerable risk of harm, including potentially life- threatening adverse events.
     2.  Prospective, controlled clinical trials have demonstrated little benefit from prolonged antibiotic therapy. Nearly all primary outcome measures have failed to demonstrate a benefit to prolonged antibiotic therapy. Statistically significant improvements in treatment groups were not demonstrated across studies, were nonspecific, were of unclear clinical importance, and in one case, not sustained at the end of the trial.
     3.  The risk/benefit ratio from prolonged antibiotic therapy strongly discourages prolonged antibiotic courses for Lyme disease.
Emphasis in original, citations removed. The NGC guidelines not only use weak data, they ignore the data that doesn’t fit their world view. I suspect next they will run for President of the United States.

More Political Science: Proposed laws protect “Lyme literate” doctors from discipline
“Lyme literate” doctors are scamming patients out of thousands of dollars with needless long-term antibiotics based on a fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme.” So why are state legislators trying to protect these doctors from discipline and make insurers pay for unnecessary treatments?
Jann Bellamy on March 15, 2018
Link


In yet another example of the ubiquitous practice of Legislative Alchemy, bills are pending in several state legislatures this year giving sustenance to the fake diagnosis of “chronic Lyme” disease and its treatment with unorthodox and potentially dangerous means. The most troublesome bills protect so-called “Lyme literate” physicians and other practitioners from discipline for substandard practice. “Chronic Lyme” patients want to protect their doctors from what they see as persecution by the medical establishment, even as these same patients are being fleeced out of thousands of dollars for unproven treatments. Other bills force insurers to pay for discredited treatments for “chronic Lyme” or require that burdensome and misleading disclosures be given to patients about Lyme disease.
Before we get to the specifics of these proposals, a brief refresher on “chronic Lyme” and “Lyme literate” physicians, a subject we’ve covered covered many times on SBM.
Lyme literacy
Lyme disease is an infectious disease transmitted by a tick bite. Its symptoms are a rash, fever, headache and fatigue, although not all symptoms may appear. According to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), it is diagnosed by medical history, physical exam, and sometimes a blood test. Treatment with a short course of antibiotics usually eliminates the symptoms, but delayed treatment can result in more serious problems.
“Chronic Lyme” is not recognized as a disease in the medical community. Its symptoms are, well, pretty much anything. One description from a post by Harriet Hall:
[Chronic] Lyme is a multi-systemic illness, and may affect every part of the body causing fatigue, stiff neck, headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus (ringing in the ears), anemia, dizziness, joint and muscle pain, brain fog, tingling, numbness and burning sensations of the extremities, memory and concentration problems, difficulties with sleep (both falling asleep and frequent awakening), chest pain and palpitations and/or psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety.
As Dr. Hall correctly notes, “that pretty much covers everyone.”
A new term, post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, has been coined for those who had Lyme disease but whose symptoms remain, although there is no good evidence that these symptoms can be attributed to persistent Lyme infection. There is no scientific controversy, however, that “chronic Lyme” disease, as applied to patients with nonspecific symptoms who show no objective evidence that they have been infected with Lyme disease, is a fabricated diagnosis. (As are the newer, move-the-goalposts putative infections to which “Lyme literate” doctors attribute “chronic Lyme.”) It is these patients who have been victimized by “Lyme literate” physicians and alternative medicine practitioners.
As you would expect in cases where a collection of vague symptoms have been bootstrapped into a disease (e.g., chronic candidiasis, adrenal fatigue) there are also a number of bogus diagnostic techniques and worthless quack treatments available. The main treatment is long-term antibiotics, for which there is no evidence of effectiveness but serious risks. (Also, here and here.)
The CDC, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, the Medical Letter, and the American Academy of Neurology all reject the notion that “chronic Lyme” exists and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment. Over a dozen international organizations, like the Canadian Public Health Network and the European Federation of Neurological Societies, agree.
That has not stopped “Lyme literate” doctors from banding together to form the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) and issuing their own guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme,” guidelines based on very low levels of evidence that are accepted only by themselves and, in contrast to the IDSA guidelines, no other professional medical organization. ILADS teaches physicians and other practitioners how to become “Lyme literate.” ILADS, again in contrast to IDSA, is not an ACCME-accredited provider of continuing medical education and, to my knowledge, none of its courses qualify for continuing medical education credit. Nor are ILADS guidelines taught as appropriate in any medical school, residency or fellowship program.
Making a fake diagnosis and treating the patient with unnecessary long-term antibiotics can put a “Lyme literate” doctor on the state medical board’s radar, especially when patients are harmed by the treatment or there is a failure to diagnose the patient’s real condition, such as Parkinson’s disease. Hence, the need to protect the “Lyme literate” from prosecution. This effort is assisted by a small but vocal contingent of patients who see their “Lyme literate” doctors as saviors and flood medical boards with letters of support. These same patients, armed with anecdotes of their supposed cures, petition their legislators for protection of what they deem persecution of their physicians.
Maryland: All in on “chronic Lyme”
In 2016, the Maryland legislature passed a bill substituting its healthcare advice for that of physicians. The law requires labs to tell patients that current tests for Lyme are “problematic,” that a negative test does not mean they don’t have Lyme disease, and that they should contact a health care provider if they continue to exhibit “unexplained symptoms” to “inquire about the appropriateness of retesting or initial or additional treatment.”
The IDSA opposes this type of notice as “non-evidence based.” That being the case, I question the constitutionality of the law because:
the First Amendment prohibits the government from compelling people [including physicians] to make false or misleading statements or to express the government’s point of view as their own.
At the time, Delegate Kathy Afzali, a co-sponsor of the bill, whose background is in theater and real estate, said it was only the first of a series of bills she hoped to get through the legislature:
The question is, what is the proper treatment for the disease [sic] There’s many different schools of thought. We want to be able to pass legislation that helps these patients who have long-term treatment for Lyme.
Even though there are not “many different schools of thought,” true to her word, Delegate Afzali and 38 of her fellow Delegates are sponsoring a bill (House Bill 880) in this legislative session forcing insurers to pay for long-term antibiotic treatment of “chronic Lyme” disease, which includes a clinical diagnosis that does not meet the CDC’s criteria:
but presents other acute, persistent, or chronic signs or symptoms of Lyme disease as determined by a licensed physician, whether that diagnosis is based on knowledge obtained through medical history and physical examination only or in conjunction with testing.
In other words, if the “Lyme literate” physician says it’s Lyme, it’s Lyme, and the health insurer must provide coverage for:
the full length of the long-term antibiotic treatment to be administered in the manner prescribed . . . [The insurer] may not impose a quantitative limitation on the long-term antibiotic treatment . . . [and] may not deny coverage . . . solely because the treatment may be categorized as unproven, experimental, or investigational in nature.
In sum, Maryland legislators, including the Senators who support a companion bill (Senate Bill 793) are willing to put the force of law behind a fake diagnosis, as well as unproven treatments for the fake diagnosis, and make everyone (though the shared cost of insurance) pay for it. This won’t be the first time. In 2016, Massachusetts legislators were so enamored of a similar bill that they overrode Governor Baker’s veto so insurers would have to pay for long-term antibiotic treatment.
Sadly, testimony in favor of the bills only serves to demonstrate just how badly “Lyme literate” physicians are scamming patients. In one media report, a mother said she had taken her daughter to 51 doctors before she was “properly diagnosed” with “chronic Lyme.” One legislator told a reporter that people were being bankrupted paying for long-term treatment. That’s unsurprising, considering media reports that “chronic Lyme” treatment can cost $10,000 to $35,000. (After one of my posts on the discipline of a “Lyme literate” physician by a state medical board, I received a thank-you email from a parent who had been scammed out of $30,000 for a child’s treatment.) In contrast, the cost of the IDSA-recommended treatment for Lyme disease with antibiotics is about $40 and is covered by most insurance. Fortunately, good citizens with no connection to the insurance industry showed up as well (although in far fewer numbers) to testify against these bills.
But that’s not the worst “chronic Lyme” bill pending in Maryland. That honor goes to House Bill 1266 and its companion Senate Bill 950. These would protect not only “Lyme literate” physicians from disciplinary action by the medical board, but “Lyme literate” chiropractors and naturopaths as well – anyone, in fact, who is licensed under the state’s health practitioner licensing statutes. Typical of the ill-advised state laws protecting quacks in general, the bills allow a “Lyme literate” practitioner to avoid the constraints of evidence-based medicine as long as he or she makes a few disclosures. The bills’ saving grace may be that they are so poorly drafted that the quack practitioner won’t be able to figure out how to comply, thus forgoing the proposed law’s protection.
“Lyme literate” practitioners could not be disciplined:
solely because of the . . . practitioner’s diagnostic evaluation, testing, or treatment of Lyme disease or another tick-borne disease in a patient if [he] . . . discloses to the patient
that the evaluation, test or treatment:
    • is integrative, complementary, alternative, nontraditional or nonconventional, but none of these terms is defined;
    • has risks and benefits, and what they are, and its FDA “status;”
    • may not be widely recognized in the medical profession and “subject to disagreement among qualified medical experts.”
If the patient has a “potentially significant medical condition” and hasn’t yet had a “conventional diagnosis or treatment,” she must be told of medical specialties that may provide her with other options. All patients must be told of “significant known risks of deferring widely accepted treatments, if any, for the patient’s condition.”
This last bit really got me confused. If the practitioner thinks the patient has “chronic Lyme,” does that mean no other specialties could provide her with other options, because no other specialties believe in its existence? Or, on the other hand, is the “Lyme literate” practitioner going to be forced to consider that she may have a “conventional” disease or condition and not “chronic Lyme,” in which case, how is he going to justify his ruling out that condition in favor of “chronic Lyme?” And when determining the risks of deferring accepted treatments for the patient’s condition, do we pretend the condition is “chronic Lyme” or are we talking about the patient’s real condition?
In any event, none of this exempts the practitioner from discipline if the evaluation, testing or treatment has a “significant safety risk greater than the conventional methods” and the risk is not outweighed by the potential benefits. By “conventional” medical standards, this would seem to rule out long-term antibiotics in every case. But, having been legislatively forced to accept the existence of “chronic Lyme,” do we also have to accept the benefits of long-term antibiotics claimed by “Lyme literate” practitioners, or are we allowed to point out that several clinical trials showed that they provide no benefit?
In other words, once pseudoscience is made into fact by this bit of Legislative Alchemy, will the medical board prosecutors be allowed to rely on science at all in making their case? Just how far does the medical board have to go in pretending to believe in a fake diagnosis and its attendant “treatment?”
While passing a law shielding substandard practice is ill-advised and will make prosecution more difficult, fortunately it is not an absolute bar to prosecution. In 2014, New York passed a similar bill. Yet, 2017, two leading lights of ILADS were successfully prosecuted by that state’s medical authorities using the clever strategy of avoiding the “chronic Lyme” issue altogether and simply focusing on the atrociously bad medical care these two delivered. After all, if a physician is willing to ignore efficacy and safety to the point of prescribing long-term antibiotics for a fake diagnosis, it is unlikely he or she is otherwise meeting the standard of care in his overall treatment of patients. One particular requirement that tripped up these “Lyme literate” physicians was failure to keep adequate medical records, such as documenting a rationale for treatment.
The “Lyme literate” cabal seems to have learned from its substantial experience in disciplinary proceedings. Maryland’s proposed legislation also protects them from being disciplined for record-keeping and, much more broadly, all other regulatory requirements, “for acts or omissions that arise from professional differences of opinion” if the practitioner has acted in good faith to comply with the intent of the requirements. It is interesting to note that only “chronic Lyme” practitioners are legislatively blessed with this particular good faith exception.
Finally, if the medical, chiropractic or other healthcare practitioner board uses a system of peer review in standard of care cases, these bills ensure that at least one member of the review panel include a practitioner with “demonstrated training, competence, and experience in the same methods” as the licensee facing discipline, thereby insuring that quacks will be protected by other quacks.
Pennsylvania, Indiana and Illinois
Similar bills are pending in Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Illinois, although none is as complicated, or provides as much protection for “Lyme literate” practitioners, as Maryland’s.
Pennsylvania House Bill 174 begins with a swipe at the IDSA, noting that there are “multiple” diagnostic and treatment guidelines for Lyme disease but the National Guideline Clearinghouse maintains only the ILADS guidelines, having removed the IDSA guidelines because of their being “outdated and not in compliance with current standards.” (In fact, the IDSA is reviewing the evidence and developing new guidelines.) The bill fails to note the very low level of evidence that support the ILADS guidelines.
HB 174 forces insurers to cover antibiotic treatment for Lyme and related tick-borne illnesses even if the treatment is “unproven, experimental or investigational” for whatever “duration the health care practitioner determines appropriate for the patient” for controlling both the patient’s [presumed] infection or symptoms. It also provides immunity to physicians, nurse practitioners and physician’s assistants from disciplinary action “solely for” diagnosing Lyme disease or prescribing long-term antibiotic therapy as long as the diagnosis, treatment plan and ongoing monitoring has been documented in the patient’s records.
HB 174 passed in the House and has moved to the Senate for consideration. A similar bill, Senate Bill 100, is also pending there.
Indiana’s Senate Bill 284 manages to combine these provisions (which are almost identical to Pennsylvania’s) as well as those similar to Maryland’s law requiring that patients be told that standard lab tests for Lyme are “problematic” and “often result in false negative and false positive results” and that, if the patient’s results are negative, it doesn’t necessarily mean he doesn’t have Lyme disease. If he continues to have symptoms, according to the mandated statement, he should consult a health care provider about retesting “or additional treatment.” Even though this sort information isn’t back by good evidence, it is the perfect segue into the “Lyme literate” physician’s office, who will happily offer unvalidated testing and “additional treatment.”
Finally, in Illinois, House Bill 4515, also prohibits the medical board from disciplining physicians who diagnose and treat “chronic Lyme.” The physician must have examined the patient, gotten informed consent, provide a “medical reason” for the treatment, informed the patient of “other treatment options” and his or her credentials, and make a medical judgment based on “a thorough review of all available clinical information on Lyme disease.” Of course, “Lyme literate” physicians already rationalize their way through all of these steps to a diagnosis of “chronic Lyme,” so how much protection this offers patients is questionable. On the other hand, patients can be comforted by the fact that the legislation requires the physician to determine:
the treatment will not, in the opinion of the [physician], result in the direct and proximate death of or serious bodily injury to the patient.
Indirect causation of death and minor bodily injury are apparently ok and no risk-benefit analysis appears to be required.
You can gauge the passion behind HB 4515 by what the Illinois General Assembly calls “witness slips,” indicating pro and con stances on the bill. There are 286 witness slips in favor of the bill and only one opponent, the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, upon whose unfortunate shoulders will fall the task of trying to discipline “Lyme literate” physicians after the legislature ties one hand behind its back.
You can check on the status of bills mentioned in this post by clicking on the links, which will take you to the states’ legislatures’ websites. The website Lyme Science has a list of all state “chronic Lyme” bills with summaries and links to bills and other helpful information. (Yes, there are more, although none, as of this date, protecting “Lyme literate” practitioners from prosecution.) To oppose these efforts, check out the American Lyme Disease Foundation’s excellent list of questions and answers exposing common misinformation about Lyme disease. The IDSA also has helpful materials on its website, especially its Lyme Disease and State Policy Primer for State Legislators.
Don’t just complain about quackery. Do something about it.

Avoid prolonged antibiotics for “Chronic Lyme”
There is no evidence to suggest that “chronic Lyme” exists, or that long-term antibiotics are required to treat it.
Scott Gavura on April 18, 2019
Link


Lyme disease is a real and growing concern in much of North America. The spirochete Borellia burgdorferi was only discovered in 1982, and today, Lyme is the most common vector-borne disease in the United States. While Lyme disease is treatable, some people have prolonged or non-specific symptoms that they may attribute to Lyme disease, sometimes on the basis of nonstandard/unorthodox testing or diagnostic criteria. While the debilitating symptoms may be real, the relationship to Lyme disease is not. There is no evidence that “Chronic Lyme” exists, but there are repeated reports of signs and symptoms that are regularly attributed, incorrectly, to Lyme infections.
Along with the emergence of “Chronic Lyme” have been self-identified experts in treating these symptoms, often with a variety of unproven treatments, of which long-term antibiotic therapy is the most common recommendation. There is no evidence that long-term antibiotics are evidence-based, appropriate, or effective. Recently the Association of Medical Microbiology and Infectious Disease Canada has put out a position statement on the diagnosis and treatment of people with persistent symptoms attributed to Lyme disease. The position statement outlines why unproven, unorthodox treatments like long-term antibiotics are more likely to harm, rather than help, patients.
What is Lyme disease?
Lyme disease is a bacterial infection spread by ticks. Its name comes from Lyme, Connecticut, where a cluster of cases called “Lyme Arthritis” were reported in 1977. While it’s highly prevalent in New England, Lyme disease has been reported in every state, and its reach continues to grow. Several species of the Borrelia bacterial family have been found to cause Lyme disease, but B. burgdorferi is the primary cause in North America. Lyme disease is carried by various Ixodes ticks, which vary based on geography. Ticks contract B. burgdorferi from a blood meal from an infected host – usually a mouse, but it can be any rodent, and also birds. Infected ticks reside on shrubs or grass (peaking in June of each year), and will attach to mammals when they detect warmth and carbon dioxide. It’s preferably the white-tailed deer, but increasingly, a human. They can attach to any part of the body, but it is locations like the back, armpits and scalp where they may not be noticed for a few days – which is when infection can occur. This image from the CDC gives a good illustration of the circle of (a tick’s) life:Ticks must be attached for 36-48 hours before a transmission of B. burgdorferi occurs. Infections can be divided into three phases:
    • Early localized infection appears as a rash (often in the form of a series of concentric rings, or “bull’s eye rash”) and what feels like a viral illness (fatigue, headache, aches, and sometimes fever). It can occur in about 80% of those infected, usually within a month of infection.
    • Early disseminated infection occurs weeks to months after the initial infection. It can include neurologic (e.g., meningitis), and cardiac complications. This may be the first sign of infection in some.
    • Late disease occurs months to years after the initial infection. Arthritis is the most common sign, but there may be neurologic signs as well.
Lyme is diagnosed based on signs and symptoms, plus a history of possible exposure to ticks. Laboratory testing may also be used. Treatment of Lyme disease depends on when it was detected and how it has manifested. Treatment is usually weeks of antibiotics and other therapies when more serious complications are present. When treated early, Lyme responds well to antibiotics, and a full recovery can be expected.
Treating after treatment
Some people with Lyme disease report symptoms after treatment that are attributed to the infection (and some people with no history or signs of infection also report similar symptoms). There is no evidence to demonstrate that B. burgdorferi infections cause chronic occult infections after standard treatments endorsed by the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA), AMMI Canada, the CDC, or, in the UK, the National Institutes for Health and Care Excellence. The cause of these symptoms may not be clear, and may be non-specific (e.g., fatigue, pain, difficulty concentrating.) While it is important that these symptoms receive proper investigations, there is a lack of evidence supporting the use of long-term antibiotics.
Unorthodox and unproven testing and diagnostics are commonly used by practitioners to arrive at a diagnosis of “chronic Lyme”. The AMMI notes the following:
Concordant with the NICE guidelines (2018), AMMI Canada recommends that Lyme disease testing be done in accredited laboratories that participate in proficiency programs and use validated methods (“Validation should include published evidence on the test methodology, its relation to Lyme disease and independent reports of performance”) (NICE 2018). Given the high rate of false positive results (some as high as 50%) (Fallon et al, 2014), the use of laboratories that do not use FDA or Health Canada approved tests or use alternative interpretive criteria is not recommended.
Alternative and unproven testing methods are necessary to propagate the “chronic Lyme” diagnosis in order to explain away the negative results of conventional, established testing. As Steven Novella noted in 2017,
Patients with alleged chronic Lyme may have negative blood tests for Lyme, but that’s OK because the antibody titers and Western blot tests are not 100%. They may also not have all the classic symptoms of Lyme, but a long list of non-specific symptoms that do not point specifically at an infection or Lyme. They also are not cured by a single round of antibiotics, but that is because, it is argued, they have treatment-resistant strains of the Lyme spirochete.
In essence the argument is that chronic Lyme disease represents an atypical presentation of seronegative treatment-resistant Lyme. That is what we call special pleading – inventing a specific explanation for each instance of evidence (or lack of evidence) that would seem to falsify a hypothesis.
Long-term antibiotics do not benefit and may harm
In addition to the cost and ineffectiveness of long-term antibiotics, many patients experience adverse effects. The AMMI notes:
Well-designed studies have shown that long-term antibiotic treatment –beyond standard recommended treatment– is of no more benefit to the patient than a placebo, but caused significant adverse events in up to 26% of participants including Clostridioides difficile, intravenous catheter site infections (when intravenous catheters are used for medication delivery),and significant allergic reactions (Patel et al., 2000; Fallon et al., 2008; Holzbaueret al., 2010; Klempner et al., 2013; De Wilde et al., 2017; Marzec et al., 2017).
The AMMI points to a program at BC Women’s Hospital, the Complex Chronic Diseases Program, as a model approach to helping patients manage debilitating symptoms. That program offers group-based education, and self management support, in addition to medical consultation for myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, and symptoms attributed to chronic Lyme. They do not offer long-term antibiotics.
The AMMI has published a fact sheet on Lyme that answers common questions about the disease and its treatment.
Conclusion
People who believe they have “chronic Lyme” are suffering and deserve compassionate treatment. But giving medicine not based in evidence is magical thinking, not good science. Regrettably, practitioners that do believe they are treating “chronic Lyme” continue to propagate erroneous information and offer dubious treatments despite good evidence they are ineffective. Multiple organizations in Canada, the United States and worldwide caution against the indiscriminate use of intravenous antibiotics for the treatment of symptoms attributed to Lyme disease.

Another “Chronic Lyme” VIP disciplined by NY medical authorities: Bernard Raxlen
Another “Lyme literate” NY physician is on probation and under orders to clean up his act. Will other physicians treating “chronic Lyme” take note?
Jann Bellamy on November 9, 2017
Link

Bernard Raxlen, MD, who devotes more than 90% of his practice to the treatment of so-called “chronic Lyme” disease, is on a three-year probation imposed by the New York State Board for Professional Medical Conduct (BPMC). Raxlen agreed to probation and a lengthy list of practice requirements last month following allegations, filed in September, of negligence, incompetence, gross negligence, gross incompetence, and failure to maintain adequate patient records. In doing so, he becomes the second “Lyme literate” VIP disciplined by the NY medical authorities this year. Based on similar charges of professional misconduct, David Cameron, MD, was also put on probation with numerous practice restrictions in June.
Who is Bernard Raxlen, MD?
Raxlen is a psychiatrist and solo “chronic Lyme” practitioner in New York City who says he’s “successfully treated” over 3,500 cases of tick-borne disease in the past 15 years. (He named his practice “Lyme Resource Medical of New York.”) He touts a “total comprehensive treatment program which utilizes both oral and intravenous (IV) antibiotic treatment.” It doesn’t come cheap, either. An initial visit with Raxlen costs $1,200 with follow-up visits between $600 and $700. A PICC-line insertion (presumably for long-term antibiotics) is $750 and a “nutritional IV” is $150. He does not accept public or private insurance.
Raxlen has a history of disciplinary actions against him in two states stretching back almost 20 years. In Connecticut, where he was formerly licensed, he was reprimanded and paid a total of $35,000 in civil penalties in two cases arising out of his refusal to provide patient records to the Health Department and insurance companies, even though patients had signed releases. He was also disciplined for inappropriate prescribing and failing to maintain malpractice insurance. Because these infractions constituted professional misconduct in New York as well, he was subject to two disciplinary actions in that state, resulting in censure, reprimand and a $2,500 fine.
According to the Chicago Tribune, Raxlen had other professional misconduct charges brought against him by Connecticut authorities but they were ultimately dropped. The Tribune reported that, in one case, Raxlen was charged with telling a patient with Lou Gehrig’s disease (ALS) that she had Lyme disease and treating her with an illegal drug from Germany. He told the reporter that the relationship between ALS and Lyme was “unclear,” even though ALS experts concluded that there was no evidence of a connection.
Per his New York State Department of Health physician profile (just type his name into the search engine), Raxlen completed residency training in psychiatry and lists his specialty as psychiatry, but he is not board certified in any specialty. He did not train in internal medicine, family medicine or pediatrics (although he treats pediatric patients), specialties that normally treat routine Lyme infections. Nor did he train in infectious diseases, experts to whom patients with more complicated cases of Lyme would normally be referred by other practitioners.
Yet, he is described by the International Lyme and Associated Disease Society (ILADS) as a “leader in Lyme disease treatment and research.” In fact, he is a founding member of ILADS, former Secretary of the Board, and has taught a number of ILADS courses. He was a co-author of the original ILADS guidelines for the treatment of tick-borne diseases. Despite their troubling disciplinary status, both he and David Cameron are scheduled to speak at the ILADS Annual Scientific Conference, which starts today in Boston.
How can this be? How can one be a leading light in ILADS with a disciplinary history like Raxlen’s and no graduate medical education in infectious diseases?
“Lyme literate” physicians like Raxlen have fabricated a disease they call “chronic Lyme,” which they regularly “diagnose” and treat with long-term antibiotics, sometimes for months to years. Board-certified infectious diseases doctors and other “conventional” physicians all agree that “chronic Lyme” is not a valid diagnosis and rely on well-conducted trials showing that long-term antibiotics do not substantially improve the outcome for patients diagnosed with so-called “chronic Lyme.” Long-term antibiotics can, in fact, result in serious harm, including death, a subject our good friend Orac covered recently over on Respectful Insolence. Orac’s post nicely summarizes the differences between real Lyme disease and “chronic Lyme,” “a prototypical fake medical diagnosis,” and the dangers of long-term antibiotics, as have posts on SBM, here, here, here, and here.
The CDC, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, the Medical Letter and the American Academy of Neurology all reject the notion that “chronic Lyme” exists and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment. There is something called “post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome,” but responsible medical authorities do not equate this syndrome with the nebulous symptoms and unvalidated lab tests of “chronic Lyme” and specifically reject the utility long-term antibiotic treatment based on well-conducted clinical trials. None of this is to say that patients who’ve been told they have “chronic Lyme” are not truly suffering, a fact that makes “Lyme literate” practices all the more reprehensible.
None of this stopped “Lyme literate” doctors from banding together to form ILADS and issuing their own guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme,” guidelines based on very low levels of evidence that are accepted only by themselves and, in contrast to the IDSA guidelines, no other professional medical organization. ILADS teaches physicians and other practitioners how to become “Lyme literate.” ILADS, again in contrast to IDSA, is not an ACCME-accredited provider of continuing medical education although, for some inexplicable reason, the Westchester [County, NY] Medical Society has teamed up with ILADS and is using its accrediting authority to grant CME credit for some of the talks (also here) at the ILADS Scientific Conference.
Despite the lack of evidence that “chronic Lyme” is a valid diagnosis, and the lack of efficacy as well as the risks of long-term antibiotic treatment, ILADS healthcare providers currently treat more than 100,000 patients with “chronic Lyme” and tick-borne diseases in the USA and around the world. Given media reports that patients can spend $10,000 to $35,000 for treatment, “Lyme literacy” translates into millions of dollars for practitioners.
While it may be profitable, “Lyme literate” doctors risk running afoul of state medical boards. Raxlen is just one among ILADS-trained, “Lyme literate” physicians who have had their medical practices questioned by their peers, up to and including discipline imposed by state authorities (also, here and here).
With that background, let’s look at the allegations against Raxlen and the terms of his probation.
The BPMC v. Raxlen
New York’s medical misconduct procedures do not require the physician charged to stipulate to any particular acts of misconduct as a condition of settling his case. The physician can, as Raxlen did here, simply state he is unable to “successfully defend against at least one of the acts of misconduct alleged” and agree to the imposition of sanctions. This means the allegations in the state’s Statement of Charges were never proven, as it was unnecessary to reach a decision on the factual issues once Raxlen agreed to a settlement. However, per the Office of Professional Medical Conduct’s (OPMC) standard procedures, the allegations were based on expert review of Raxlen’s patients’ records and they remain uncontested by him.
The allegations of misconduct arise out of Raxlen’s care of eight patients. As is typical of “chronic Lyme” diagnosis and treatment, patients (whose identities are protected) presented with a variety of disparate symptoms, such as:
    • Patient A: freezing, burning, air hunger, weakness, fatigue, neck pain and intestinal pain.
    • Patient E: fatigue, migraines, neck pain, joint pain, numbness and tingling, irritability, sound, light and temperature sensitivity and nonrestorative sleep.
    • Patient G: back pain, abdominal pain, feet pain, extremity weakness, anxiety, depression and mood swings.
    • Patient H (who got the Hickman catheter and numerous antibiotics mentioned below): mouth, teeth and jaw pain, confusion, forgetfulness, irritability and mood swings.
Diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme” is never mentioned, a wise decision on the part of the BPMC prosecutors in light of the ill-conceived New York law protecting “Lyme literate” doctors from prosecution
based solely upon the recommendation or provision of a treatment modality by a licensee that is not universally accepted by the medical profession, including but not limited to, varying modalities used in the treatment of lyme disease and other tick-borne diseases.
Instead, the BPMC focused on the fact that Raxlen had failed in the most basic tenets of good medical care, although the fingerprints of “chronic Lyme” diagnosis and treatment, such as failure to consider alternative diagnoses, prescribing IV antibiotics and using a Hickman catheter, are all over the charges. The charges included:
    • Repeatedly failing to perform or note in the patient’s chart a comprehensive history and appropriate physical exam, including (despite his being a psychiatrist) a psychiatric history, neuropsychological testing and mental health status exam.
    • Failing to construct a differential diagnosis and pursue a thorough diagnostic evaluation prior to instituting a treatment plan.
    • Inappropriate prescribing, including prescribing Rifampin for a patient on Tamoxifen and prescribing addictive medications prior to a making a diagnosis and without considering non-addictive treatment.
    • Inappropriately relying on Applied Kinesiology (which is quackery) to formulate a diagnosis.
    • Placement of a Hickman catheter without medical necessity.
    • Inappropriately administering antibiotics, including intravenous Invanz, Clindamycin, Flagyl, Rifampin, Minocycline, Mepron, Plaquenil and Bactrim, all of these for one patient.
    • Failure to present or note in the patient’s chart potential risks, benefits, side effects and safe use of prescribed medications.
    • Failure to appropriately identify, address, and/or follow-up on potential side effects.
    • Treating inappropriately with an ongoing and/or escalating medication regimen without appropriate physical exams and clinical reassessment for consideration of alternative diagnoses and treatment.
    • Poor record-keeping.
These allegations resulted in charges of negligence, incompetence, gross negligence, gross incompetence, and failure to maintain adequate patient records. As noted, Raxlen agreed to a three-year probation in addition to the imposition of conditions on his practice. He must, among other things:
    • Communicate to patients the nature of his medical role, whether it be a primary care physician responsible for the patient’s general medical condition, or for a defined or limited purpose, and/or as a practitioner of a particular medical specialty.
    • Obtain written informed consent addressing all aspects of treatment and document same, including documentation of all discussions with the patient about the nature and scope of his evaluation and treatment and the patient’s need to pursue “conventional medical care elsewhere.”
    • Document all histories and physicals.
    • Refer patients to primary care physicians, specialists or consultants for further evaluation and/or treatment where medically warranted and provide these physicians with all relevant patient information.
    • Cooperate fully with the state in enforcing the Consent Order and timely respond to all state requests for written periodic verification of his compliance and all documents.
What now?
Based on a birthdate of 1938 in his state physician profile, Raxlen is either already, or soon will be, 79 years old. One wonders whether he will continue his practice in face of these new sanctions, although his website is still trying to attract patients.
Sadly, the “chronic Lyme” lobby responsible for passing the law protecting “Lyme literate” doctors has its sights set on even greater rewards. Several bills are pending in the NY legislature which would force insurers to cover “chronic Lyme” treatment (Assembly Bill 114, Senate Bill 4713, Senate Bill 670). Other bills give them the opportunity to argue in yet another venue for insurance coverage. (Assembly Bill 4863, Senate Bill 2168, Assembly Bill 6927).
In any event, it is commendable that the Board for Professional Medical Conduct has not let New York’s unfortunate law get in the way of its prosecuting physicians who take advantage of patients with a diagnosis of “chronic Lyme,” no matter how they frame the specific charges. With two leading NY “Lyme literate” physicians now on probation and under strict orders to clean up their acts, it remains to be seen what effect this might have on other “Lyme literate” doctors in the state.

“Chronic Lyme” VIP Daniel Cameron disciplined by New York medical authorities
“Chronic Lyme” guru Daniel Cameron, MD, has been put on 3-year probation by New York medical authorities. Will fellow “Lyme literate” doctors take note?
Jann Bellamy on June 22, 2017
Link

The medical practice of “Lyme literate” guru Daniel Cameron, MD, will be closely supervised by the authorities during a three-year probation imposed last week by the New York State Board for Professional Medical Conduct (BPMC). The order was based on professional misconduct charges filed against Cameron earlier this year.
Cameron agreed to the imposition of sanctions during administrative proceedings on the charges and a consent order was entered by the BPMC based on his concession. He stipulated that
he could not successfully defend against at least one of the acts of misconduct alleged. Those allegations included practicing the profession of medicine with negligence on more than one occasion, incompetence on more than one occasion, gross negligence, gross incompetence, and/or failing to maintain accurate patient medical records.
Who is Daniel Cameron, MD?
Cameron is a solo practitioner in Mt. Kisco, NY, and board certified in internal medicine, but not fellowship-trained in infectious diseases and not board-certified in that sub-specialty. He also holds an MPH and describes himself as epidemiologist. According to his website, he:
is a nationally recognized leader for his expertise in the diagnosis and treatment of Lyme disease and other tick-borne illnesses.
That is partially true. He is a “recognized leader” among those who consider “chronic Lyme” a real disease and who treat it with long-term antibiotics, sometimes for months to years. He is not a “recognized leader” among board-certified infectious diseases doctors and other experts who agree that “chronic Lyme” is not a real disease and who rely on well-conducted trials showing that long-term antibiotics do not substantially improve the outcome for patients diagnosed with so-called “chronic Lyme.” Long-term antibiotics can, in fact, result in serious harm, including death, a subject our good friend Orac covered just yesterday over on Respectful Insolence. The CDC, the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, the Medical Letter and the American Academy of Neurology all reject the notion that “chronic Lyme” exists and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment.
(Orac’s post nicely summarizes the differences between real Lyme disease and “chronic Lyme,” “a prototypical fake medical diagnosis,” and the dangers of long-term antibiotics, as have posts on SBM, here, here, here, and here.)
That has not stopped “Lyme literate” doctors from banding together to form the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) and issuing their own guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme,” guidelines based on very low levels of evidence that are accepted only by themselves and, in contrast to the IDSA guidelines, no other professional medical organization. ILADS teaches physicians and other practitioners how to become “Lyme literate,” although there is precious little information about the courses on the ILADS website. ILADS, again in contrast to IDSA, is not an ACCME-accredited provider of continuing medical education and, to my knowledge, none of its courses qualify for continuing medical education credit. Nor are ILADS guidelines taught as appropriate in any medical school, residency or fellowship program.
Unfortunately, according to Cameron,
ILADS healthcare providers currently serve more than 100,000 patients with Lyme and associated tick-borne diseases in the USA and around the world.
Cameron is a leading light among the “Lyme literate.” He is the past president of ILADS and is the lead author of both the original ILADS guidelines and its 2014 update. He has testified before several state legislatures promoting the protection of “Lyme literate” doctors from prosecution by state medical boards, including the legislature in New York, where such a bill became law. He also makes presentations to Lyme support groups, spreading the gospel of “chronic Lyme.”
He has written a number of articles in the medical literature promoting the notion that “chronic Lyme” exists and that long-term antibiotics are an appropriate treatment, including two in the bottom-feeder journal, Medical Hypotheses, known for its publication of pseudoscientific papers.
His bibliography includes a letter to the editor of the New England Journal of Medicine, complaining about an article by infectious diseases experts rejecting “chronic Lyme” as a valid diagnosis and its “treatment” with long-term antibiotics. The evidence, Cameron claimed, is actually in “clinical equipoise.” This drew a sharp rebuke from the article’s authors:
The term ‘clinical equipoise,’ used by Cameron, is difficult to justify in view of the published reports of five double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trials that have convincingly demonstrated that antibiotic treatment of post–Lyme disease symptoms is not in the best interests of patients. Our article summarizes the consensus among clinicians who practice evidence-based medicine . . .
The direct implication being, of course, that Cameron is not one “among clinicians who practice evidence-based medicine.”
Cameron, for his part, brushes off the expert opinion of infectious diseases doctors versus “chronic Lyme” pseudoscience manufactroversy as simply “different points of view:”
Only by airing these different points of view will the medical and scientific community reach a better understanding of controversial topics such as treatment of chronic Lyme disease. Meanwhile, physicians must be able to exercise their clinical judgment and patients should be provided with treatment options.
With that, let’s turn to how, in the view of the New York state medical authorities, Cameron exercised his “clinical judgment” and provided patients with “treatment options.”
“Clinical judgment” and “treatment options”
Apparently, New York’s medical misconduct procedures do not require the physician charged to stipulate to any particular acts of misconduct as a condition of settling his case. Rather, as noted, Cameron simply stated he was unable to “successfully defend against at least one of the acts of misconduct alleged” and agreed to the imposition of sanctions. This means the allegations in the state’s Statement of Charges were never proven, as it was unnecessary to reach a decision on the factual issues once Cameron decided to settle. However, per the Office of Professional Medical Conduct’s (OPMC) standard procedures, the allegations in the Statement of Charges were based on expert review of Cameron’s patients’ records and they remain uncontested by Cameron.
The state’s allegations were based on Cameron’s care of seven patients. According to the Statement of Charges, some of his more egregious actions include:
    • Continuing to prescribe narcotics to a patient diagnosed with bipolar disorder and narcotic abuse for two years after the patient had moved to another state.
    • Failing to follow up on previous diagnostic tests and symptoms indicative of multiple sclerosis, “thereby depriving the patient of an accurate diagnosis and years of effective therapy for her progressive disease.”
    • Failing to appropriately and timely evaluate a patient, who suffered from Parkinson’s disease, when she complained of pain associated with a PICC line inserted at Cameron’s direction for parenteral antibiotics, which itself was done without an appropriate physical examination or “clinical re-assessments for consideration of any alternative diagnoses and/or treatment.”
    • Failing to consider “other infections or inflammatory processes” in a patient with a recent termination of pregnancy and diverticulitis, who had abnormal lab results, including abnormal liver function tests and an elevated sedimentation rate, and failure to order a CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis as well as additional blood testing.
The state wisely avoided specifically challenging Cameron’s diagnosis of his patients with “chronic Lyme” or his treating “chronic Lyme” with long-term antibiotics. In fact, the term is never mentioned. In doing so, it circumvented the quagmire of arguing over “different points of view” and concentrated on the fact that Cameron quite simply failed his patients by giving them substandard care, “chronic Lyme” or no “chronic Lyme.” This strategy also avoided any shield which might have been provided by New York’s foolish law aimed at protecting “Lyme literate” doctors.
Yet the fingerprints of “chronic Lyme” diagnosis and treatment show through loud and clear in the state’s case. For each and every patient, Cameron was charged with:
    • Repeatedly failing to take and/or note an adequate history of present illness.
    • Repeatedly failing to perform and/or note an appropriate physical examination.
    • Failing to appropriately construct a differential diagnosis and pursue a through diagnostic evaluation.
    • Failing to maintain records accurately reflecting care and treatment rendered to the patient.
For six of the seven, he was charged with:
Treating patients inappropriately with an ongoing and escalating antibiotic regimen without appropriate sequential physical examinations and clinical reassessments for consideration of any alternative diagnoses and/or treatment.
And for four of them, according to the state, Cameron failed to follow up in a timely fashion when the patient developed possible adverse reactions to therapy.
Two of the patients who presented with complaints of fatigue and pain had previous diagnoses and treatment for Lyme disease, 9 and 16 years earlier, fitting the “Lyme literate” notion that their current complaints are most certainly sequelae to inadequately-treated Lyme and cannot be attributed to other causes.
Reading between the lines, Cameron had only one tool, a hammer, so he saw every problem as a nail. The possibility that the patient might be suffering from something other than “chronic Lyme” was tossed aside via inadequate physical exams and medical records, failing to consider other diagnoses, and bulldozing ahead with inappropriate long-term antibiotics, adverse consequences be damned.
Of course, if you think about it, substandard care and “Lyme literacy” would appear to go hand-in-hand. It is hard to imagine the “Lyme literate” doctor, who routinely ignores medical science in favor of unvalidated testing, makes repeated diagnoses of a fake disease, and orders unwarranted long-term antibiotics, otherwise delivering standard-of-care medical practice. As with the Cameron case, this offers a way forward to state medical boards hamstrung by laws designed to protect the misconduct that is “chronic Lyme” from disciplinary action.
Terms of three-year probation
In entering into his probationary period, Cameron is in the company of other “Lyme literate” doctors who have had their medical practices questioned by their peers, up to and including discipline imposed by medical regulators (also, here and here).
Hopefully, Cameron will be hard-pressed to continue his usual M.O. under the terms of the Board’s Consent Order. He has agreed to practice medicine only when monitored by a licensed physician (a “practice monitor”) who must be “board certified in an appropriate specialty considering [Cameron’s] specialty of practice, who is familiar with the diagnostic and treatment modalities practiced and offered by [him].”
The practice monitor can see all of Cameron’s records and must visit his office “on a random unannounced basis at least monthly” and examine no fewer than 20 records. The monitor’s review is to determine whether Cameron’s medical practice “is prudent and competent.” Any perceived deviation from prudent care or refusal to cooperate must be reported to the OPMC within 24 hours. The monitor must also report to the OPMC quarterly and Cameron must pay the expenses of monitoring.
Cameron gets to propose his own monitor to the OPMC. This, coupled with the language about familiarity with Cameron’s “diagnostic and treatment modalities,” leaves some concern that a fellow traveler would be put in charge. The fact that the OPMC must approve the monitor, plus the broad authority given to the OPMC in the Consent Order to look at his records and otherwise investigate what he is up to, somewhat allays those concerns.
He must also, among other things:
    • Obtain written informed consent from each patient “specifically addressing all aspects of treatment” and provide the OPMC with copies of his consent forms.
    • Fully document all discussions with patients concerning his evaluation and treatment “and of the patient’s need to pursue conventional medical care elsewhere, if indicated.” This is of some concern as well, as it implies Cameron is free to provide unconventional medical care as long as he tells the patient she needs the conventional kind.
    • Obtain and review medical records from physicians who previously or are currently treating his patients and refer patients to other physicians for further evaluation and treatment “where medically warranted and beyond the scope of [Cameron’s] role with regard to the patient.”
    • Maintain at least $2 million per occurrence/$6 million per policy year limit medical malpractice insurance.
    • Complete CME courses as directed by OPMC.
But, Legislative Alchemy
Whether Cameron’s case will prove to be a cautionary tale for other “Lyme literate” doctors remains to be seen. Even as one branch of state government successfully prosecutes a “Lyme literate” doctor, another branch, the legislature, is considering forcing insurers to cover treatment of “chronic Lyme,” the subject of no less than three bills now pending. (Assembly Bill 114, Senate Bill 4713, Senate Bill 670). Three other bills are sympathetic to the cause in that they will give “chronic Lyme” advocates yet another venue to argue for insurance coverage. (Assembly Bill 4863, Senate Bill 2168, Assembly Bill 6927). Pseudoscience, it seems, is endemic in the state of New York.

Jarisch-Herxheimer and Lyme disease
When patients diagnosed with chronic Lyme are treated, no matter what happens as a response to the treatment is considered by believers to be evidence in support of the diagnosis. If they get better, then that is evidence that the treatment is working. If they get worse, then that is evidence that the treatment is working and they are experiencing the JHR (or “herxing” as the community calls it). If nothing happens, they just need more treatment. No matter what happens or doesn’t happen, it’s chronic Lyme.
Steven Novella on October 25, 2017
Link
In one of my favorite lines from Full Metal Jacket a solider notes, “Anyone that runs, is a VC. Anyone that stands still, is a well-disciplined VC!” Or if you prefer, from The Simpsons, Chief Wiggum observes about the ghost cars that he believes haunts the highway near Springfield, “They always come out at night, except during the day.”
These lines are funny because we immediately recognize the flawed logic. They are blatant examples of, “Heads I win, tails you lose.” In scientific terms, no matter what the outcome it is evidence that supports the original hypothesis, rendering the hypothesis unfalsifiable. And yet, as obvious and funny as these examples are, it is easy to make the same mistake ourselves in perhaps less obvious fashion.
Let us take, for example, the Jarisch-Herxheimer reaction (JHR) and its relation to alleged chronic Lyme disease. For background, the JHR was first described by Austrian dermatologist Adolf Jarisch (1895) and German dermatologist Karl Herxheimer (1902). They described a reaction to mercury in treating syphilis, in which the patients would have an exacerbation of their symptoms beginning 1-3 hours after treatment, lasting for about a day. Jarisch hypothesized that the mercury was killing off the syphilis spirochetes in large numbers, and the lysed bacteria were releasing endotoxins which were causing the symptoms.
This is almost exactly right. The reaction, it has recently be discovered, is caused more by nonendotoxin pyrogen and spirochetal lipoproteins which stimulate the immune system, including inflammatory cytokines and tumor necrosis factor. The reaction has also been observed in Lyme disease, which is also caused by a spirochete, and in several other bacterial infections.
Symptoms of JHR include fever, chills (often to the point of rigors), worsening skin rash, and may include hypotension, tachycardia, hyperventilation, flushing, and myalgia (muscle pain). In rare severe cases reactions can include meningitis, alterations in consciousness, seizures, and strokes. Death is very rare, except in young children or those who are already in compromised health. 
How does all this relate to unfalsifiable hypotheses and the discipline of possible VC? The issue involves how to interpret symptoms occurring during treatment for alleged chronic Lyme disease. But some further background is necessary. I have already reviewed the issue of Chronic Lyme, so see that article for details, but here is the very quick overview: Lyme disease is a real thing, and infection with a spirochete bacteria that causes a primary, secondary, and possibly tertiary infection if left untreated. Patient with tertiary Lyme can have neurological involvement, including symptoms of meningitis, nerve or spinal cord inflammation, in addition to systemic symptoms. The bacteria is killed off by standard antibiotic treatment, but may require IV antibiotics for tertiary Lyme.
All of this is non-controversial and well-established. However, there is a dubious claim that some patients can have chronic Lyme disease which can survive even IV antibiotic treatment. Treatment reduces the symptoms, but the infection remains chronic and cannot easily be eradicated. The problem with this hypothesis is that proponents have rendered it unfalsifiable by explaining away negative evidence. Patients with alleged chronic Lyme may have negative blood tests for Lyme, but that’s OK because the antibody titers and Western blot tests are not 100%. They may also not have all the classic symptoms of Lyme, but a long list of non-specific symptoms that do not point specifically at an infection or Lyme. They also are not cured by a single round of antibiotics, but that is because, it is argued, they have treatment-resistant strains of the Lyme spirochete.
In essence the argument is that chronic Lyme disease represents an atypical presentation of seronegative treatment-resistant Lyme. That is what we call special pleading – inventing a specific explanation for each instance of evidence (or lack of evidence) that would seem to falsify a hypothesis.
None of this means that patients who are diagnosed with chronic Lyme are not sick. The probably just don’t have a chronic Lyme infection. This is critical because if they are being wrongly diagnosed with a dubious entity then their real diagnosis is being missed, and they may be subjected to multiple rounds of long term IV antibiotics, which is not without risks, to say the least.
Finally we get to the connection to the flawed logic referred to at the top of this article. When patients diagnosed with chronic Lyme are treated, no matter what happens as a response to the treatment is considered by believers to be evidence in support of the diagnosis. If they get better, then that is evidence that the treatment is working. If they get worse, then that is evidence that the treatment is working and they are experiencing the JHR (or “herxing” as the community calls it). If nothing happens, they just need more treatment. No matter what happens or doesn’t happen, it’s chronic Lyme.
Further, just as the symptoms that are used as evidence for chronic Lyme don’t match the actual symptoms of documented Lyme disease, “herxing” after treatment for alleged chronic Lyme can also be highly variable. Here is one chronic Lyme disease site’s description of the JHR:
A Herxheimer Reaction usually causes near-immediate physical symptoms such brain fog, pain, fatigue, and just an overall lack of motivation or passion for anything, but one that lasts for days on end can begin to influence the mentality of a person enduring that Herxheimer Reaction.
You will notice that this does not resemble, except very superficially, the classic description of the JHR. There is no mention of fever, chills, rigor, or hypotension. Instead we get a list of typical non-specific symptoms – similar to the symptoms that lead to the diagnosis of chronic Lyme in the first place. The symptoms can also last for weeks, and fluctuate with good days and bad days. This also does not fit the known pathophysiology of the JHR, which results from starting treatment when there are large numbers of spirochetes that all die and lyse over a short period of time.
Further, I have to note the inherent contradiction here. The JHR results from killing large numbers of spirochetes, and yet chronic Lyme is premised on the existence of treatment-resistant Borrelia burgdorferi (the spirochete that causes Lyme) that can survive antibiotic treatment. You would think that a treatment-resistant strain wouldn’t die off so effectively as to cause a JHR. You can invent an explanation for this as well (a hidden reservoir of the bacteria survives to spread again), but this amounts to more special pleading as there is no evidence for any such explanation nor a reason why it would differ from all our current research into the life cycle of Borrelia burgdorferi.
In science, and in medicine specifically, we have to be careful about the criteria we use to validate or falsify our hypotheses. This is not just in research, but in treating patients as well. We need to decide ahead of time what objective criteria we will use to determine outcomes. It is easy to fall into the trap of ad hoc or post hoc reasoning – interpreting outcomes after the fact. We are great at making everything appear to make sense – just as astrologers are very creative in explaining how behavior, personality, and events are consistent with astrological charts, but only after the fact. They are abysmal at actually making predictions.
Medicine becomes astrology unless we use evidence to decide how we will interpret future data, such as a response to treatment. Related to this is the need to think of signs and symptoms in terms of how predictive they are, not just how typical they are. The predictive value of specific signs relates to how specific they are to one or a category of diagnostic entities. For example, fever may be typical of a specific infection, but it is not very predictive by itself of that one infection because fever can occur in hundreds of entities. This is precisely why we frequently criticize the reliance on non-specific symptoms to allegedly establish the existence of scientifically dubious conditions.
Finally, I want to emphasize that Lyme disease is real, and the JHR is also real and may occur in response to antibiotic treatment for Lyme disease. However, it is a fairly specific reaction in terms of time frame and symptoms, varying mostly in severity. Proponents of chronic Lyme disease, however, rely on a broadening of the possible symptoms, natural history, response to treatment, and reaction to laboratory tests to maintain belief in this entity. They also have to deny the various studies which show a lack of response to treatment for alleged chronic Lyme. Similarly they have taken the concept of the JHR and then applied it to any worsening of symptoms that happens after any treatment for alleged chronic Lyme. This is used to further validate a dubious diagnosis, and to keep patients invested in getting a treatment which the evidence shows not only doesn’t work but may be giving them side effects.

A Review of Under Our Skin, A Cult Classic
Under Our Skin is a propaganda film attempting to sell viewers dangerous treatments for ‘chronic Lyme disease’, a rejected diagnosis not recognized by any legitimate medical organization.
Braden MacBeth on April 8, 2019
Link

[Editor’s note: Dr. Gorski will be absent for another week, so in his stead we present another post from Braden MacBeth.]
Under Our Skin is a documentary about Lyme disease, a tick-borne illness mostly relegated to the northeastern US. It was released in 2009 and received mostly positive reviews from critics. Having watched the film, I don’t really understand why. Under Our Skin exists to sell viewers on unnecessary and dangerous long-term antibiotic therapies, and the existence of chronic Lyme disease.
Lyme disease is boring
Under Our Skin tries to make Lyme disease seem like the most terrifying illness anyone could ever get, and that ticks are going to take over the universe or something. The filmmakers grossly exaggerate the severity of Lyme disease, and the intensity of the required treatment.
Lyme disease is not that scary
The filmmakers try to make Lyme disease seem like it’s as debilitating and dangerous as cancer or something. While the symptoms of Lyme disease can be pretty nasty, it’s still pretty tame compared to the ailments you could possibly suffer from. Early symptoms of infection include: fever, chills, headache, fatigue, muscle and joint aches, and swollen lymph nodes. If left untreated, symptoms can get markedly worse but it’s still very treatable. Lyme disease can be treated easily with a course oral antibiotics and symptoms will resolve quickly in the vast majority of cases. A very small number of patients may still experience minor symptoms following antibiotic treatment up to 6 months, however I am unable to find a study in any credible journal that symptoms will persist beyond that. A study in Pediatrics studied long-term neuropsychological outcomes of children who had facial palsy as a result of Lyme disease, and found that “The neuropsychologic and health outcomes of children with facial nerve palsy attributable to Lyme disease 7 to 161 months earlier are comparable to those who did not have Lyme disease”. Another study published in JAMA also found that the frequency of symptoms following Lyme disease treatment occurred no more often than in the group that never had Lyme disease in the first place.
Lyme disease doesn’t do that
Under Our Skin makes numerous outlandish statements about the possible effects of Lyme disease, none of which are true. According to one “Lyme Literate MD”:
At this point I’ve had many women who’ve gotten pregnant, who’ve lost the baby or they give birth to a baby who has Lyme. The babies don’t have– the developmental growth may be off. Their IQ may be lower. They may develop seizures. They may have other neurological problems because it was not known that the mother has Lyme.
There is no evidence to suggest this is the case, and it’s been studied to a rather large extent. One study tested 2,000 mothers for Lyme disease at their first prenatal visit and at delivery, and found that there was no risk of fetal death, prematurity, or congenital malformations associated with having Lyme disease at the time of conception or during pregnancy. There is no evidence that Lyme disease during pregnancy results in a child having a lower IQ, or has led to the development of neurological problems in children. Furthermore, there is no evidence that a mother with Lyme disease can pass it on to her child.
Chronic Lyme disease is fake
Under Our Skin heavily promotes the idea that Lyme disease can turn into a chronic, persistent infection that requires the long-term use of antibiotics. The Infectious Disease Society of America (ISDA) held a special review panel about their Lyme treatment guidelines in 2006 and unanimously concluded that there is no existing evidence of a chronic Lyme infection and attempting to treat it can be dangerous. A good portion of the film is dedicated to trying to disprove the findings of scientists using anecdotes and conspiracy theories. Chronic Lyme advocates even managed to convince a Connecticut attorney general to investigate the ISDA for possible conflicts of interests on the part of the those who wrote the ISDA guidelines. In 2010, another board review was conducted of the 2006 guidelines, and the guidelines were upheld unanimously.
There are a large number of “medical” organizations that solely exist to try to legitimize chronic Lyme disease as a diagnosis, based on weak scientific evidence. These organizations also work tirelessly to lobby for legislation that prevents medical board sanctions against doctors who use long-term antibiotic therapies to treat “chronic Lyme”. Also on their agenda is forcing insurance companies to pay for long-term antibiotic treatments. In Pennsylvania, ILADS (a Lyme Literate organization) is currently trying to pass legislation that would force physicians to complete two hours of Lyme disease CME and require that they include input from ILADS in creating the Lyme disease CME requirements. There is an overwhelming scientific consensus that long-term antibiotic therapies provide no benefit for Lyme disease. Dr. Lipson covered the investigation by the Connecticut attorney general in 2009, and the fight is still ongoing.
Lyme Disease probably won’t kill you but quack treatments just might
Under Our Skin tries to claim that Lyme disease can be deadly, when that isn’t really true. Lyme disease is one of the least deadly illnesses in existence, since 1985 only 9 deaths have been recorded out of over a million cases. Assuming that there were 30,000 cases every year from 1985 to 2019, your chances of dying if you get Lyme disease are .00091%. Despite no real evidence of long-term negative effects or high chances of death, the documentary advocates risky antibiotic treatments from “Lyme Literate” MDs. A number of the LLMDs in the film have been sanctioned by their state medical boards for prescribing unnecessary long-term antibiotic therapies for the treatment of Lyme disease.
Early on in the film it shows a woman who believes she has chronic Lyme disease meeting with an LLMD. He said that she would need 6 to 8 months of antibiotic therapy and he will need to put a catheter in. He was, of course, referring to a peripherally inserted central catheter (PICC line). Apparently in the chronic Lyme community the use of PICC lines to administer antibiotics over a long period time is quite common. There are even stories online of children having PICC lines inserted and administering IV antibiotics themselves. There is no reason to have a PICC line inserted for the treatment of Lyme disease as IV antibiotics are rarely recommended. There are many risks associated with long term antibiotic use in general, especially when you’re giving those antibiotics through a PICC line. You don’t have to look hard to find stories of people dying because of various complications of PICC lines or long-term antibiotic use for the treatment of “chronic Lyme disease”. The CDC published a report of three patients dying from infections resulting from a PICC line inserted to give antibiotics over a long period of time to treat “chronic Lyme disease”. To reiterate, the evidence shows that there is no benefit from the use of antibiotics for longer than the recommended guidelines. The CDC’s states in their report:
These cases highlight the severity and scope of adverse effects that can be caused by the use of unproven treatments for chronic Lyme disease. In addition to the dangers associated with inappropriate antibiotic use, such as selection of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, these treatments can lead to injuries related to unnecessary procedures, bacteremia and resulting metastatic infection, venous thromboses, and missed opportunities to diagnose and treat the actual underlying cause of the patient’s symptoms. Patients and their health care providers need to be aware of the risks associated with treatments for chronic Lyme disease.
The many amazing moments of Under Our Skin
Under Our Skin features many unforgettable and hilarious moments and it would be irresponsible for me not share them with you.
World’s strangest conspiracy theory?
Under Our Skin presents the most ridiculous conspiracy theory I have ever heard. The major conspiracy theory is that the CDC, and physicians in academia, are conspiring to suppress the severity of Lyme disease and keep patients from expensive treatments. According to the “science writer” on-screen (anyone can call themselves that), it was a perfect storm of a couple different events starting with:
1980, the United States said it was okay for government institutions and universities to patent and profit from live organisms. So the Lyme disease organism was discovered in 1981, and all of a sudden there was the equivalent of an Oklahoma land grab, people looking under their microscopes, patenting pieces of the organism, so the people that are credited for being the Lyme disease experts no longer shared information about a new, really dangerous pathogen.
The ruling she is presumably referring to is Diamond v. Chakrabaty in 1980, which did not rule that universities and government institutions could patent and profit from live organisms. The ruling allowed genetically modified organisms to be patented, but does not extend to “newly discovered products of nature”. This well established in many cases long before this ruling such as in the Supreme Court case Funk Brothers Seed Co. V. Kalo Inoculant Co. where the court stated:
Their qualities are the work of nature. Those qualities are of course not patentable. For patents cannot issue for the discovery of the phenomena of nature. See Le Roy v. Tatham, 14 How. 156, 175. The qualities of these bacteria, like the heat of the sun, electricity, or the qualities of metals, are part of the storehouse of knowledge of all men. They are manifestations of laws of nature, free to all men and reserved exclusively to none.
Basically, what she is claiming is utter nonsense and reflects flagrant dishonesty or ignorance of even basic legal concepts. It gets better:
The other thing was the rise of managed care. Insurance companies and HMOs realized that if they can get researchers in universities to define diseases and write guidelines for diseases a certain way, then they could help manage the escalating medical costs.
Her argument almost seems reasonable if you don’t think about it in the slightest. There are researchers, universities, and government health organizations researching diseases around the world, the US insurance companies paid all of them off? It would take a massive amount of money to pay off people who have it pretty good already, and researchers would incur a huge amount of risk in participating in a scheme like this. If someone working for the NIH or CDC did what she’s suggesting, they would almost certainly be charged with fraud, and their careers would certainly be over if caught. Lyme disease occurs in other nations too, what do they recommend? The European Center for Disease control also says that Lyme disease should be treated with appropriate antibiotics for a few weeks. Are they on a US insurance company’s payroll too?
Now for my favorite part of this conspiracy:
really what this means is, the people who protected public health, so, like, the CDC, and the NIH and universities. Who didn’t have any commercial interests, all of a sudden, they were partners with big pharma.
Here’s the problem, the NIH and CDC don’t really have financial interests. They work for the United States government, they’re bankrolled by an organization that literally prints money. This is by far the weirdest conspiracy theory I have ever heard.
Lyme disease basement research/Lyme disease causes everything guy
About 15 minutes into the film we are introduced to Dr. Alan MacDonald, who researches Lyme disease on his own time, in his basement, with his little Maltese dog named Travis. According to him the view that the bacteria that causes Lyme disease doesn’t stay around in the body very long will be disproven. To date, there is no evidence that symptoms following antibiotic treatment for Lyme disease are the result of a persistent bacterial infection. He also believes that the Lyme disease bacteria is responsible for Alzheimer, Lou Gehrig disease, Parkinson disease, and multiple sclerosis, because he was able to find the DNA of the spirochete that causes Lyme disease in 7 out of 10 brain DNA samples. His reasoning is that if a spirochete like syphilis can cause dementia, then the Borrelia spirochete could also do that. The problem with his theory is that Lyme disease is pretty rare in most parts of the world, and many parts of the world will never see a case of Lyme disease, while the diseases he believes Lyme disease cause are common throughout the world.
Anecdotes vs. evidence
Under Our Skin, like all quack documentaries, is filled with testimonials. The problem with testimonials is that most people are poor historians and couldn’t present their own medical history accurately if they tried. They could also be actors or just mistaken, lying about or exaggerating their symptoms. Under Our Skin is different from most quack documentaries because they actually have testimonials from experts which always come before or after showing someone giving a ridiculous opinion or anecdote with no evidence to back it up. Just to give you an idea of how ridiculous it gets: they show an interview with a researcher stating that the scientific evidence shows there is no benefit to long-term antibiotic treatment. They follow it up with an anecdote from a LLMD’s secretary who claims that patients who received long-term antibiotics seemed to be doing better afterwards. Another absurd example is when they try to prove that Lyme disease is everywhere by filming one woman driving in her car and pointing at houses claiming that the person who lived there had Lyme disease. I have no idea how anyone is supposed to take the testimonials in the film seriously.
Conclusion: A cult classic
Under Our Skin is a documentary designed to sell viewers on a fake illness that supposedly comes from a real illness. Dr. Lipson’s post back in 2009 examining a study that surveyed households a month after viewing the film suggests it might actually be successful. Throughout researching this article, I have tried to identify anything about Lyme disease that makes it something you should actually worry about over any other illness. Lyme disease is uncommon even where it’s the most prevalent, and the only hard part about treating it is finding a pen to write ‘Doxycycline’ on a prescription pad. Lyme disease is the most overhyped illness of all time. The horror stories you hear about it are a million times worse than it actually is. It’s a bacterial infection that causes temporary neurological symptoms and can be treated with oral antibiotics; that’s it.
The story of how Lyme developed a reputation of being this incredibly dangerous disease that you should be terrified of is far more interesting than the disease itself. There is no such thing as ‘chronic Lyme’ but there is an online cult obsessed with it. I’m being quite serious when I use the term ‘cult’, as I think it’s accurate to call online chronic Lyme support groups cults. However, chronic Lyme cults differ from how we would usually define a cult in a few key ways. Chronic Lyme cults (CLCs) differ from normal cults in that they don’t form around a charismatic leader, however believers flock around doctors they consider to be heroes. The last thirty minutes of the film are dedicated to portraying “LLMDs” as heroes standing up against the medical establishment to protect their patients. The reality is that these physicians practice substandard medicine to treat Lyme disease or are administering dangerous treatments to patients for a condition that does not exist. Practitioners in the film were reported by other physicians for following unusual practices in treating Lyme disease because they were following unusual practices in treating Lyme disease. The evidence shows that there is no benefit to long courses of IV antibiotics to treat Lyme disease. Furthermore, practitioners being sanctioned for substandard practices in the treatment of Lyme disease is not going to make physicians practicing competent medicine afraid to treat patients with Lyme disease (which the film argues.
An article in the Psychiatric Times on the nature of cults provides a list of traits of people who are most prone to join cults, some of which are particularly applicable. One of these traits is a low tolerance of ambiguity, and the film’s many testimonials showcase this. One woman’s son was born with an unspecified neurodegenerative condition, she claims that she had Lyme disease when she was pregnant and that her son was born with Lyme disease and that was the cause of his condition. While it’s a sad state of affairs, there is no evidence that being treated for or having Lyme disease during pregnancy will result in any neurodegenerative conditions in children. Many CLC websites promote the idea that Lyme disease causes or mimics the symptoms of autism. There is no evidence that Lyme disease causes or mimics the symptoms of autism, and research has shown there is no correlation. These people want a reason for why something terrible has happened to them that science might not have a great answer for, and ‘chronic Lyme’ gives them a simple, digestible answer.
The most notable characteristic of cults also exhibited by the chronic Lyme cults is how they treat critics and non-believers. The chronic Lyme disease cult is very passionate and has a long history of protesting the investigation of doctors treating Lyme outside established guidelines, and harassing doctors who do not want to incorporate pseudoscientific treatments into their practices. Whenever a “Lyme Literate” physician is investigated by the medical boards or taken to trial for questionable practices, a chronic Lyme cult protest can always be found. Researchers and physicians who speak out against chronic Lyme are often the target of harassment campaigns in the form of baseless complaints to the board of medicine, death threats, protesting their place of work, and libelous online blogs. One physician received 11 complaints to the board of medicine shortly after speaking out against the use of long-term antibiotics to treat the illness, and simply stating that there is no evidence that chronic Lyme disease exists. All of the complaints were dismissed, and his record is still spotless, but it made him deeply afraid to even talk to the media. One of his colleagues wrote to the medical board stating:
“A complaint campaign to the board is just the latest escalation in a guerrilla war against physicians, scientists and federal officials who are not inclined to view Lyme borreliosis as the Fifth Horseman.” Since the campaign, Steere’s friends say that he has grown more and more depressed, though he wouldn’t say so publicly. “This is criminal what is being done.”
However, the chronic Lyme cult would not stop in their attempt to harass him, the director of the Lyme Disease Coalition said: “There will be a day of reckoning”.
It’s easy to see hardcore believers of chronic Lyme as mentally ill given their actions, but it’s important to remember that they’re also victims of an incredibly successful health misinformation campaign. There is more inaccurate information about Lyme disease on the internet than accurate information. When searching “Lyme Disease” online, the first result that isn’t from the CDC, Mayo, or WebMD is a link to LymeDisease.org. Surely you would think that LymeDisease.org is a credible source of Lyme information…right? Not quite. There are Lyme Disease support groups, Lyme disease organizations, and articles in The New York Times talking about the “Lyme Controversy”, all of which promote the idea that Lyme disease is a life-altering, possibly chronic condition. There are Lyme disease support groups in Australia, when there is no evidence that Lyme disease even occurs in Australia.
People who claim to suffer from chronic Lyme disease may not be suffering anything related to Lyme disease but they can still have real illnesses. They can be suffering from an untreated illness, such as one man who was treated for ‘chronic Lyme’ that actually had a brain tumor that would’ve been treatable without surgery if found sooner. It’s likely that people claiming to suffer from chronic Lyme have somatic symptom disorder. According to the APA: “Somatic symptom disorder involves a person having a significant focus on physical symptoms, such as pain, weakness or shortness of breath, that results in major distress and/or problems functioning. The individual has excessive thoughts, feelings and behaviors relating to the physical symptoms. The physical symptoms may or may not be associated with a diagnosed medical condition”. The more I check the research against the claims of the documentary, the weirder this documentary appears to me. Under Our Skin is a very strange film for an audience who in all likelihood, already has their minds made up. This documentary is as educational as the information videos on the Scientology YouTube channel and I would advise steering clear.

Conspiracy theories about monkeypox: Déjà vu all over again or same as it ever was?
Last Thursday, the Biden administration officially declared monkeypox to be a national public health emergency. Unsurprisingly, conspiracy theories abound, many of them recycled from COVID-19 and older antivax conspiracy theories.
David Gorski on August 8, 2022
Link

Last Thursday, the Biden administration officially declared the rapidly growing monkeypox outbreak to be a national public health emergency (PHE). It’s a declaration that the virus represents a significant risk to Americans and frees up resources to address that threat:
The declaration by Xavier Becerra, President Biden’s health secretary, marks just the fifth such national emergency since 2001, and comes as the country remains in a state of emergency over the coronavirus pandemic. The World Health Organization declared a global health emergency over the outbreak late last month.
Mr. Becerra’s announcement, at an afternoon news briefing where he was joined by a raft of other top health officials, gives federal agencies power to quickly direct money toward developing and evaluating vaccines and drugs, to gain access to emergency funding and to hire additional workers to help manage the outbreak, which began in May.
Currently, there have been over 6,000 cases of monkeypox reported in the US, and it’s hard not to get a feeling of, as Yogi Berra’s delightfully twisted term described, déjà vu all over again, after the declaration by the World Health Organization (WHO) that COVID-19 had become a pandemic nearly two and a half years ago. What do I mean? You’d think that after all this time dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic the US would be prepared if another pathogen arose with the potential to become pandemic itself, but the response to the monkeypox outbreak has thus far shattered that expectation, as this New York Times article suggests:
Supplies of the monkeypox vaccine, called Jynneos, have been severely constrained, and the administration has been criticized for moving too slowly to expand the number of doses. Less than a decade ago, the United States had 20 million Jynneos doses; by May, the vast majority of them had expired.
In echoes of the early coronavirus response, tests have been difficult to obtain, surveillance has been spotty and it has been challenging to get an accurate count of cases. The administration has also been faulted for not doing enough to educate people in the L.G.B.T.Q. community, who are at high risk, before gay pride celebrations in June.
“We have 5 percent of the world’s population and 25 percent of the world’s cases,” said Dr. Carlos del Rio, an infectious disease physician at Emory University in Atlanta. “That, to me, honestly, is a failure. We were caught sleeping at the wheel.”
Of course, monkeypox is a different disease than COVID-19. Whereas COVID-19 was a brand new disease caused by a new coronavirus to which the population was immunologically naive, monkeypox has been around for a while. Even so, back in May, when the first cases in the US were making the news, Dr. Novella expressed much the same sentiment as I am now:
Now, outbreaks understandably make people a little twitchy. I remember in February 2020 the “voices of reason” were saying about COVID (myself included) that we should be concerned, but it’s too early to panic. I don’t know if in retrospect that struck the right tone (without Monday morning quarterbacking), but it feels like we are in the same place now with the monkeypox.
However we deal with monkeypox (and right now I’m not particularly optimistic about our government response), the disease, showing up so soon after COVID-19 while the COVID-19 pandemic is still raging, provides an excellent “teachable” moment about conspiracy theories and antivaccine misinformation. Why? Because the very same conspiracy theories that arose about COVID-19 (in some cases slightly modified) are showing up about monkeypox, thus demonstrating that truly there is, as I like to say, nothing new under the sun in terms of conspiracy theories about disease outbreaks and vaccines.
First, however, what is monkeypox?
Monkeypox
As I mentioned, in contrast to COVID-19, monkeypox is not a new disease. It’s been around for a while and is relatively known. The monkeypox virus itself is a member of the Orthopoxvirus genus in the family Poxviridae, the same genus as the smallpox virus, to which it is closely related. Fortunately, monkeypox is less contagious and produces less serious disease than smallpox, which, before vaccination eliminated it in the 1970s, had long been a scourge of humanity, with traces of smallpox having been found in the head of the 3,000 year old mummy of Pharaoh Ramses V. For example, smallpox killed roughly one-third of those infected with it and often left survivors with horrible scars from the “pox” lesions on the skin that were characteristic of the disease. Since the eradication of smallpox was officially declared in 1980, monkeypox has emerged as the most important orthopoxvirus for public health.
In terms of symptoms, monkeypox causes fever, headache, lymphadenopathy, and then the characteristic “pox” rash with skin eruptions, which can number from a few to thousands, to the point that in especially severe cases sections of skin can slough off. The overall disease course usually lasts between 2-4 weeks, with poorer outcomes in those with underlying immune deficiencies, and potential complications include secondary infections, bronchopneumonia, sepsis, encephalitis, and infection of the cornea with ensuing loss of vision. The WHO reports that in modern times the case fatality ratio is around 3-6%.
A zoonotic disease, monkeypox can infect a number of animal species besides monkeys and human, including rope squirrels, tree squirrels, Gambian pouched rats, dormice, non-human primates and other species. Before the current outbreak, the disease had been mostly confined to central and West Africa, with a history dating back to 1970:
Human monkeypox was first identified in humans in 1970 in the Democratic Republic of the Congo in a 9-month-old boy in a region where smallpox had been eliminated in 1968. Since then, most cases have been reported from rural, rainforest regions of the Congo Basin, particularly in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and human cases have increasingly been reported from across central and west Africa.
Since 1970, human cases of monkeypox have been reported in 11 African countries: Benin, Cameroon, the Central African Republic, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Gabon, Cote d’Ivoire, Liberia, Nigeria, the Republic of the Congo, Sierra Leone and South Sudan. The true burden of monkeypox is not known. For example, in 1996–97, an outbreak was reported in the Democratic Republic of the Congo with a lower case fatality ratio and a higher attack rate than usual. A concurrent outbreak of chickenpox (caused by the varicella virus, which is not an orthopoxvirus) and monkeypox was found, which could explain real or apparent changes in transmission dynamics in this case. Since 2017, Nigeria has experienced a large outbreak, with over 500 suspected cases and over 200 confirmed cases and a case fatality ratio of approximately 3%. Cases continue to be reported until today.
However, the disease has been found outside of Africa dating back two decades, as in 2003 the first outbreak in the US occurred and was linked to contact with infected pet prairie dogs. Monkeypox has also been reported in travelers from Africa to Israel, the United Kingdom, and Singapore before the most recent outbreak.
As far as transmission, fortunately monkeypox is far less transmissible than SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, is. Its mode of transmission is also different in that its primary mode of spread appears not to be respiratory but rather, as the WHO notes, “through close contact with respiratory secretions, skin lesions of an infected person or recently contaminated objects.” In the current outbreak, sexual contact, particularly sex between males, is the primary mode of transmission:
“Right now, about 98% of monkeypox cases are in queer and gay folks and our sexual networks. Of course, that includes trans and non-binary folks,” says Joseph Osmundson, a biologist at New York University who identifies as queer and is helping to lead the effort to stop the outbreak.
Sexual contact is not the only way monkeypox is spread, points out infectious disease doctor Susan McLellan at the University of Texas Medical Branch in Galveston, Texas. But she agrees with Osmundson: It is by far the most likely way in this current outbreak, so far.
“Epidemiological data for the outbreak in Western Europe and the United States makes that clear,” she says. “We’re not detecting many cases in kids and individuals who aren’t sexually active. We’re detecting cases mostly in individuals from networks with a lot of sexual encounters.”
As several scientists have pointed out, although its mode of transmission is primarily through sex, monkeypox as it is spreading now is not just a sexually transmitted disease. It’s possible to get the disease through other means, such as face-to-face interactions and touching contaminated objects, but these routes of transmission are very rare and likely require quite prolonged contact.
Fortunately, those of us old enough to have been vaccinated against smallpox likely have some protection, and there is a vaccine against monkeypox. Unfortunately, that vaccine is not yet nearly as widely available as it should be.
On to the conspiracy theories…
Lab leak
As I pointed out when COVID-19 first hit, every time there is an outbreak of a new disease (or even a not-so-new disease), conspiracy theories declaring the outbreak to have been due to release from a laboratory, either accidental or intentional, of the pathogen responsible arise. These conspiracy theories arose for HIV/AIDS, Ebola, and the H1N1 pandemic, among others, and they appeared with a vengeance after COVID-19.
Indeed, I love to point out that the very first “lab leak” conspiracy theory that I encountered about COVID-19 came from James Lyons-Weiler in February 2020. Lyons-Weiler appeared on Del Bigtree’s video show and claimed to have “broken the coronavirus code”. In brief, he reported that he had found in the just-published nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 sequences from an artificial plasmid commonly used in molecular biology research to express protein from genes and to transfer genes from one vector to another. Naturally, because he is an antivaxxer, Lyons-Weiler claimed that this sequence came from a failed effort to make a vaccine against the original SARS virus that caused a major outbreak in 2002, thus letting him conveniently link a conspiracy theory that the coronavirus had been “engineered” in a lab with a chance to blame vaccines for the virus. If true, obviously, that would be strong evidence that SARS-CoV-2 had been engineered. However, for someone who before turning antivax crank had run bioinformatics core facilities Lyons-Weiler made a lot of rookie mistakes, and his analysis did not show what he claimed that it did, as I described in gory detail. Unfortunately, “lab leak” conspiracy theories about the origins of SARS-CoV-2 still proliferate and have been weaponized to great effect by conspiracy theorists, even though recent evidence strongly suggests a natural origin for the virus.
It should therefore be no surprise at all that soon after monkeypox started making the news conspiracy theorists claimed that it had escaped from a laboratory. They even blame the Wuhan Institute of Virology, just as “lab leak” conspiracy theorists blame the same institute for COVID-19 using similar distortions of science, with Tweets like this:
BOMBSHELL REPORT: Wuhan Lab was EXPERIMENTING WITH MONKEYPOX Last Year – Published Research Report in International Journal in February 2022…
— Chuck Callesto (@ChuckCallesto) May 23, 2022
For instance, two weeks ago The Jimmy Dore Show aired a segment titled “Wuhan Lab Was Experimenting On Monkeypox Before Outbreak“, while John Campbell, someone who seemed semi-reasonable early on in the pandemic but long ago turned into a total COVID-19 crank, had posted a YouTube video about how the NIH and the WIV had been working on monkeypox, pointing to this NIH grant and a recent paper, “Efficient assembly of a large fragment of monkeypox virus genome as a qPCR template using dual-selection based transformation-associated recombination“.
As described at FactCheck.org:
Jimmy Dore, a frequent purveyor of misinformation on “The Jimmy Dore Show” on YouTube, produced a segment on July 20 with the headline, “Wuhan Lab Was Experimenting On Monkeypox Before Outbreak.”
During the segment, Dore showed a video of Dr. John Campbell, a retired nurse educator, discussing monkeypox and the Chinese study.
Campbell says in the video that the National Institute of Health and the Wuhan Institute of Virology were conducting experiments with monkeypox prior to the outbreak and misleadingly suggests viewers may “draw some parallels” between the origins of the monkeypox outbreak and the origins of SARS-CoV-2.
After playing a clip of Campbell saying the NIH and the Wuhan Institute had been studying monkeypox before the outbreak, Dore asked, “What are the odds of that?”
Dore continued, “whenever there’s a new outbreak now, 50/50 chance it was started in the Wuhan Lab funded by Dr. Fauci and the NIH,” referring to Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.
Kurt Metzger, a comedian and Dore’s partner on the show, added, “not even a different virology lab accident, the same one.”
As I like to say, humans are pattern-forming animals, and we’re especially good at imputing causation from a pattern when that causation agrees with what we already believe.
I looked up the study, and—surprise!—it shows nothing like what Dore and Campbell claim that it shows. First of all, the scientists didn’t create a whole monkeypox genome, only a portion of it and then only to use to test a method known as “transformation-associated recombination”, which is used to assemble large pieces of DNA. Also, the monkeypox sequence used to assemble the partial genome is different from that of the monkeypox virus now circulating. The current outbreak is due to the West African clade virus while the viral sequence used in the research belongs to the Congo Basin clade.
Unsurprisingly, with the war in Ukraine raging, conspiracy theorists promoting pro-Russian narratives claiming that Ukraine had a number of bioweapon labs quickly pivoted to claiming that monkeypox had escaped from a Ukrainian lab, with headlines like “ECDC Bombshell: ‘Monkeypox Outbreak Appears To Have Leaked From Ukraine Lab’” and Tweets like this:
A Russian-Chinese joint task force has been tasked with establishing: where it originated, whether it is detectable in research conducted by the US in Ukraine, Georgia; whether there is a link to biological research conducted by the US on smallpox in Ukraine.
— Dr. Ben Braddock (@GraduatedBen) May 21, 2022
There is, of course, as usual zero evidence to support this claim, which is based on an anonymous source claiming knowledge of what the European Centers For Disease Control has concluded. Let’s just put it this way:
Richard Ebright, board of governors professor of chemistry and chemical biology at Rutgers University in New Jersey and a figure who has voiced lots of support for the COVID lab leak theory, echoed the point. “All indications are that the monkeypox outbreak involves a natural monkeypox virus,” he told Newsweek.
I’ve tangled with Ebright on Twitter before over lab leak conspiracy theories about SARs-CoV-2, and he’s a total conspiracy theorist. If he thinks your claim of a lab leak origin for monkeypox is nonsense, you’ve really wandered far into conspiracyland. The Ukrainian “lab leak” conspiracy theory is totally fake news, even more ridiculous than the claim that monkeypox came from WIV.
Same as it ever was, though. There is nothing new under the sun, including…
Plandemic 2.0: Monkeypox edition
Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, a “documentary” called Plandemic went viral. Its primary claim was of a massive conspiracy theory in which the entire pandemic was actually planned—”Plandemic”, get it?—all in order for the “global elite” to enslave us all with vaccines and pharmaceuticals. It was followed by Plandemic 2, in which Mikki Willis wove a conspiracy theory implicating an October 2019 pandemic preparation exercise held by Johns Hopkins University’s Center for Health Security in partnership with the World Economic Forum and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation that had envisioned a pandemic due to a fast-spreading coronavirus. The whole narrative involved linking together disparate events in a misleading manner to imply an overarching conspiracy that the current coronavirus pandemic had been planned.
In some cases, the “plandemic” conspiracy theory got really wild. In one version, it involved aliens teaming up with the global elite to release a two-stage “bioweapon” (COVID-19 and the vaccine, naturally) to cause global depopulation to about 10% of the current number of humans alive on the planet, all so that the aliens and elite could profit. I kid you not.
Cue May 2022 and monkeypox in the NY Post:
An eerily accurate simulation exercise at the Munich Security Conference in March 2021 centered on a monkeypox outbreak – and had the rare and potentially deadly “hypothetical” disease starting exactly when the real one did.
The Nuclear Threat Initiative (NTI), a non-profit founded by US media mogul Ted Turner and former Democratic Sen. Sam Nunn, gathered a panel of 19 experts — including government officials from the US and China, representatives from the World Health Organization and the UN, and researchers from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and major pharma companies — to game out responses to a “12 Monkeys”-like bioterror attack.
The fictional scenario, sponsored by Facebook co-founder Dustin Moskovitz and his Open Philanthropies non-profit, hinged on the secret release of a lab-enhanced monkeypox virus that eventually killed 271 million people in a worldwide 19-month pandemic.
Sound familiar? It involves a lot of the same players, in particular including—of course!—Bill Gates. The main twist is that this conspiracy theory seems to have originated (or at least spread widely) in China on its social media platform Weibo before making the jump to the West, likely as a response to all the lab leak conspiracy theories about COVID-19 and the WIV:
A 2021 report on biosecurity preparedness planning by a US non-government organization, Nuclear Threat Initiative, which included a scenario of a monkeypox pandemic, has been taken out of context to suggest that the US government knew the outbreak was coming.
Nationalist influencer Shu Chang, who has 6.41 million Weibo followers, deliberately misconstrued the report and posted that it showed “a plan by the US to leak bioengineered monkeypox virus.”
There is, of course, no evidence that this exercise is any indication that the monkeypox outbreak was planned any more than the Johns Hopkins University/Gates Foundation exercise in 2019 was evidence that the COVID-19 pandemic was planned. Health experts and authorities plan for pandemics, and when they do they pick scenarios that seem plausible and likely. Given the SARS outbreak 20 years ago, in 2019 a coronavirus seemed most likely as the next big pathogen to cause a pandemic. Monkeypox has been simmering for years and in 2021 seemed like the next viral threat:
“The risks posed by monkeypox”, according to the NTI, “have been well documented for years” and cases have been on the increase, making it an obvious virus to choose for this workshop.
Outbreaks of infection are a fact of life, so an organisation predicting and planning for them is not in itself suspicious.
Same as it ever was…again.
But…it’s the vaccines!
Going back to James Lyons-Weiler and his attempt to blame COVID-19 on a failed attempt to develop a SARS vaccine, I also can’t help but add that the very earliest COVID-19 conspiracy theory I encountered, way back in January 2020, was that COVID-19 arose in Wuhan because the Chinese had ordered more influenza vaccines in fall 2019 than they normally would. This conspiracy theory then mutated into a version in which the flu vaccine was falsely blamed for increasing one’s chances of getting COVID-19, a claim that persists.
Fast forward to spring and summer 2022, when, to the surprise of no one who has paid attention to antivaccine conspiracy theories over the years, COVID-19 vaccines are being blamed for the monkeypox outbreak, because of course they are. This conspiracy theory tends to take one of two flavors. The first is a claim that the chimpanzee adenovirus vector used in the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine is how monkeypox arose. The second is a more general claim not unlike the conspiracy theories about the flu vaccine and COVID-19 that COVID-19 vaccines weaken the immune system to make people susceptible to monkey pox.
Examples of the first can easily be found on social media:
Who is surprised that after millions of people have been injected with genetically modified chimp virus, there is now an outbreak of monkeypox?
— David Kurten (@davidkurten) May 20, 2022
"The AstraZeneca vaccine uses a chimpanzee adenovirus vaccine vector" Makes you wonder doesn't it.🤔🤔🤔🤔
— Goldie Hawn (@GoldieH34757900) May 21, 2022
Molecular biologists, virologists, and others with significant knowledge of molecular biology and virology are likely cringing at how obviously these claims are nonsense (as did I). However, the percentage of the population with sufficient scientific knowledge to immediately recognize these memes and posts as utter bullshit (there is no other word) is, alas, small. So they sound credible. Adenovirus and monkeypox are not just different viruses, they’re very different viruses, and the one used for vaccines is genetically engineered so that it is unable to replicate. Adenovirus-based vaccines use the virus as a tool to induce cells to make the desired antigen, in the case of COVID-19 vaccines the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. The only viral proteins made are those absolutely necessary for the vector to serve its purpose of entering cells and forcing them to make the protein from the DNA code inserted into the virus’ genome. Also, not all of the adenovirus-based vaccines use the chimpanzee version of the adenovirus.
Finally, I particularly like this statement in a more general debunking of this claim:
Meedan added: “It should be noted that chimpanzees are not monkeys.”
Chimpanzees are from a group of primates known as great apes, see here.
The second version of blaming monkeypox on COVID-19 vaccines posits an immune suppression due to the vaccine that supposedly laid the groundwork for monkeypox to flourish. More recently, antivaxxers have also tried to blame COVID-19 vaccines for polio, but that’s a secondary claim:
"It is well established the mRNA vaccines affect the natural immune system. A monkey pox outbreak following massive covid vaccination: *Is not a coincidenceDr Shapira 'suggested that the monkeypox outbreak was connected to mRNA vaccines." https://t.co/NGMwGAjwGl
— Ruth Stewart (@RuthSte67917853) August 7, 2022
What if monkey pox is a reaction to the covid vaccine 😅
— BlammySosa (@blammysosa) August 7, 2022
Antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. is pushing this narrative on his Children’s Health Defense website:
Twitter last week censored Shmuel Shapira, M.D., MPH, for suggesting a connection between the monkeypox outbreak and mRNA COVID-19 vaccines, according to a Kanekoa’s Newsletter Substack post published Wednesday.
Shapira, who said he was injured after receiving his third dose of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine, said Twitter demanded he remove a tweet that said:
Monkey pox cases were rare for years. During the last years a single case was documented in Israel. It is well established the mRNA vaccines affect the natural immune system. A monkey pox outbreak following massive covid vaccination: *Is not a coincidence.
Shapira is a full professor of medical administration at Hebrew University and served as director of Israel’s Institute for Biological Research from 2013-2021.
Again, none of this should come as any surprise to anyone who’s followed the antivaccine movement for a long time. The claim that vaccines either suppress the immune system or cause autoimmune disease by cranking it up too much—antivaxxers can never make up their minds and craft their narrative depending on what they want to blame vaccines for—are oldie-moldy vaccine tropes.
It turns out that a lot of those claiming that monkeypox arose because COVID-19 vaccines had suppressed the immune systems of those who got them tend to cite two recent papers, one in The Lancet and one in Food and Chemical Toxicology, which they misrepresent as evidence that COVID-19 vaccines cause immunosuppression. The second one is easy to deal with. It’s by Stephanie Seneff, Greg Nigh, Anthony M. Kyriakopoulos, and Peter A. McCullough, and I discussed it in great detail when it was published in April, also noting that Seneff has been an antivax conspiracy theorist for a long time and that McCullough went full COVID-19 and antivax conspiracy theorist early in the pandemic. Both have been featured multiple times in this very blog, with Seneff having achieved her prominence back in 2015 when she predicted that GMOs would render half of all children autistic by 2025, which is now less than two and a half years away. (Early in the pandemic, she even blamed e-cigs and biofuels for COVID-19.) Let’s just say that that review article was an excellent example of Gish galloping and the use of a scientific review article published in a dodgy journal as antivax disinformation.
The first article was indeed published in The Lancet and is a retrospective cohort study from Sweden published in February. Its conclusion was that COVID-19 vaccine effectiveness waned over several months but that effectiveness against severe COVID-19 was better maintained. That’s it. It said nothing about immunosuppression due to the vaccine at all, but that didn’t stop Tucker Carlson from finding a comment that falsely claimed that the study did show immunosuppression from the vaccine:
Carlson cited a comment a Japanese physician, Dr. Kenji Yamamoto, published in a different journal, which claimed the Lancet paper “showed that immune function among vaccinated individuals 8 months after the administration of two doses of COVID-19 vaccine was lower than that among the unvaccinated individuals.”
After suggesting that the Lancet paper hid “a major finding,” Carlson pointed to one piece of data in table 3 of the paper for viewers to check themselves. “Among people around the age of 80 who have been double vaccinated — that would include people like Joe Biden — the per capita rate of medical incidences, including hospitalizations or death, is nearly twice as high as the rate of serious incidence for the unvaccinated,” he said.
Carlson added that the Lancet paper “also includes a chart showing negative vaccine efficacy for all ages after eight months for all participants in the study.”
Carlson, however, is distorting cherry-picked data from the paper.
“The paper we have published [does] not show any of the claims” Carlson made, lead author Dr. Peter Nordström told us in an email, because they were not statistically significant. The findings that are statistically significant and the conclusions of the paper are “presented in the summary of the paper,” he added.
Also:
As for the Japanese physician who claimed the Lancet data “showed that immune function among vaccinated individuals 8 months after the administration of two doses of COVID-19 vaccine was lower than that among the unvaccinated individuals,” Jewell said he found nothing to support that in the Lancet paper, as it also appears to be an erroneous interpretation of figure 2.
Yamamoto’s comment shows a misunderstanding of the figure, and it also incorrectly generalizes a specific and expected decline in immunity to the coronavirus over time following vaccination with a general decline in immunity to all things. There is no evidence of that in the Lancet paper, nor anywhere else.
This is, of course, a typical antivax technique. They love to cherry pick one line of one figure or table in a paper, especially when it’s unadjusted data, and misrepresent it to mean what they want it to mean.
Again, same as it ever was.
There is nothing new under the sun
I had thought about taking just one of the conspiracy theories about monkeypox and doing a deep dive into it, explaining in my usual painful level of detail why it’s a conspiracy theory. However, as I tried to decide which one to examine, it occurred to me that monkeypox is, as I said at the beginning of this post, an excellent “teachable moment” to explain again how there is nothing new under the sun in the world of disease and antivaccine conspiracy theories. Just as COVID-19 conspiracy theories were rehashed and repurposed versions of older antivax conspiracy theories, monkeypox conspiracy theories are so rehashed from COVID-19 conspiracy theories that in many cases they’re the same damned conspiracy theory.
The point is this. Once you start seeing the patterns, you’ll recognize the conspiracy theories. There is nothing new under the sun in antivax conspiracy land (or any conspiracyland, for that matter). It is, as David Byrne once sang, the “same as it ever was” and Yogi Berra once described as “déjà vu all over again”. What’s different is that these conspiracy theories have far more power and influence than ever before.


Medical Misinformation Falsely Links a Serious Infection to Leftover Chinese Food
A young man contracted a dangerous infection that was newsworthy, because it could have been prevented by a safe vaccine, but it had absolutely nothing to do with leftover Chinese food despite what is being promoted by a viral YouTube video and several news articles.
Clay Jones on March 4, 2022
Link

In March of 2021, The New England Journal of Medicine published a case report from a team of doctors at Massachusetts General Hospital involving a 19-year-old man with meningococcemia, one of the most historically infamous infectious diseases. I am not at all exaggerating when I say that this disease, caused by systemic infection with the bacterium Neisseria meningitidis, strikes fear in the hearts of medical professionals at the mere consideration of the possibility of its diagnosis in a febrile and ill-appearing patient. It is, and again I am quite serious here, an infection that is known for its ability to cause catastrophic injury and even death in a matter of hours.
The case report discussed the initial presentation of this unfortunate young man whose condition rapidly deteriorated from nausea and abdominal pain to fever and severe diffuse muscle ache, then to respiratory failure, hypotensive shock, multiple organ failure, and a disseminated coagulopathy that would ultimately result in the loss of both legs below the knees and parts of all 10 fingers. He progressed from feeling fine to suffering severe illness over just 15 hours, and then became profoundly critically ill requiring maximal intensive care over only an additional 4 hours. Thanks to the amazing skill of the pediatric intensive care team, a couple of which I’ve worked with personally since moving to Boston in 2013, and the progress medical science has made in developing life saving pharmacotherapies, the patient survived and was able to be discharged home after a lengthy stay in the hospital.
What does this have to do with leftover Chinese food? To be frank, not a damn thing. But that didn’t stop this ridiculous idea from going viral when a popular medical YouTuber posted a video dramatizing the case report last week that blamed food poisoning for the patient’s illness.
The video, which involves actors portraying the patient and his roommate, uses a lot of generic stock images and video as well as heavy handed narration that I suppose is meant to add a sense of drama. Unfortunately, it also contains a number of assumptions about the events leading up to the patient’s initial evaluation at a community emergency department that are presented as established facts of the case. It all comes across as manipulative and geared towards getting the maximum amount of views rather than actually educating the viewers. The video was then featured by numerous news outlets, such as the New York Post, and the inaccurate assumption that the patient’s infection came from contaminated food was parroted over and over again.
It is true that the authors of the report mentioned, as part of a thorough discussion of the events preceding the patient’s illness, that he had eaten a meal consisting of rice, chicken, and lo mein that was leftover from the night before. They also wrote that the patient’s roommate had eaten the same meal the night before. The roommate had an isolated episode of nausea and vomiting but did not otherwise become ill. At no additional point in the report, in particular during the discussion of the potential causes of his clinical presentation and abnormal lab results, did the meal come up again. This is because it is irrelevant to meningococcal disease.
Despite this absence of concern from the MGH PICU team regarding the meal consumed prior to the patient becoming ill, which again is because meningococcal disease is not a foodborne illness and there has never been a documented case of Neisseria meningitidis being spread this way, Bernard Hsu, the pharmacologist and clinical adjunct professor at the University of Illinois, claimed it was the source of the infection in his viral video. The video, which has been viewed more 1.5 million times (Hsu has nearly 2.5 million subscribers) is terrible for numerous subjective reasons in my opinion, some of which I have already mentioned, but I’ll stick to an objective assessment of this one huge error for this post. But first, a brief primer on meningococcal disease epidemiology.
Meningococcal disease 101
As I stated in no uncertain terms above, infection with Neisseria meningitidis is serious, even more so when it results in meningitis, an infection and associated inflammation of the protective membrane covering the brain and spinal cord. Prior to the development of effective antibiotics and modern intensive care modalities, this condition was almost always fatal. Even with early diagnosis and the best medical care in the world, death is still common and surviving patients often suffer significant long-term disability.
Historically, and sadly also currently in certain regions of the world such as Sub-Saharan Africa, epidemics of meningococcal disease have occurred. In regions privileged enough to have access to the marvelously safe and successful vaccines that significantly reduce the risk of infection from serogroups most likely to cause invasive disease, epidemics are rare. In the United States, the incidence of meningococcal disease has plummeted since the mid-1990s, especially since routine vaccination of adolescents began in 2005. Currently this disease is seen in .11 out of 100,000 people, which represents a roughly 75% decrease over the past 20+ years.
While epidemics of meningococcal disease resulted in cases in patients of all ages, there are certain groups that are at higher risk even in regions where these epidemics are rare. This is because Neisseria meningitidis, a bacteria that only infects humans, is endemic. This means that it is out there, among us, silently colonizing our nasopharyngeal tissue and jumping from person to person, pretty much causing disease whenever it feels like it.
At any given time, 5-10% of the general population and as many as 35% of older teens are colonized. Most people clear the bacteria, never having known it was there, but it may hang out in our nasal passages and throats for weeks to years first. Before being cleared, a colonized individual may spread it to others, but this only happens with close, typically intimate contact. So you are not going to become infected and colonized by simply talking to someone or even being near them for significant periods of time. You really need to swap spit, by kissing or sharing objects that one might insert into the oral cavity for example, be on the receiving end of a juicy coughing fit, or spend a lot of time in very close contact.
The folks who are most at risk tend to be teens and young adults living together, in particular college students in dorms and soldiers in army barracks, and children under two years of age, likely because they like to slobber all over each other. Smoking is another risk factor for colonization. Once colonized, most people never get sick and those who do mostly just have some serious bad luck. People with certain immune deficiencies are at increased risk of disease, however, as are people taking certain immune modulating medications. Another independent risk factors for developing meningococcal disease is a recent respiratory illness.
About the case report and the leftover lo mein…
So what happened to the 19-year-old patient in the case report? How did he develop meningococcal disease and is it possible that the lo mein was to blame? No, no it wasn’t.
Again, this bacteria is not spread by food. It just isn’t. There have been zero reported cases of this. Neisseria meningitidis only lives in humans and is susceptible to desiccation on surfaces that significantly decreases its ability to survive and cause infection. This is why it takes sustained close contact with other humans to spread, and this typically comes from lots of kissing or inhaling droplets from a cough, although it is possible that repeatedly sharing a toothbrush in close temporal proximity could do it.
The meal so hyped by the professor that should have known better and in all those news articles was a red herring that had nothing to do with the patient’s illness. Based on our understanding of meningococcal disease, he was almost certainly colonized with the bacteria. He is an adolescent smoker with a roommate, after all, so he’s pretty high risk for it. As I mentioned earlier, just based on his age alone there was a roughly 35% chance. Add in the other risk factors and it was likely much higher.
Even if, for argument’s sake here, he somehow became infected with Neisseria meningitidis because of the leftover food, it still wouldn’t make sense given the rapid onset of his symptoms. During epidemics of this disease, when large numbers of people are becoming ill and we know it isn’t just colonized people with bad luck, illness typically takes 2-3 days to set in, and it can take up to 10 days. It would be very unlikely to be exposed and then become deathly ill all in less than a day.
The patient’s initial symptoms of nausea and vomiting with associated abdominal pain may have been consistent with possible food poisoning, but that is also a classic early presentation of meningococcal disease. The authors of the report knew that by the time he presented for medical care, and began to rapidly deteriorate, his illness was not at all related to any recent meal. Again, that’s why it wasn’t included in the discussion of his disease process in the body of the report.
Conclusion: Be wary of viral videos and lazy journalism when it comes to medical information
Bernard Hsu really has no excuse for the massive error in his popular YouTube video. He is a highly trained pharmacologist with access to experts and expert resources. My hunch is that visions of virality clouded his judgement and confirmation bias impaired his research. I haven’t watched any of his other videos, and to be honest I don’t plan on it, but I hope they are of better quality considering the large number of people he reaches with them.
The lazy journalism, which not coincidentally wasn’t produced by any dedicated science or medical writers, is an even bigger problem. Simply parroting the views seen on a YouTube video is highly irresponsible and can even be harmful when it spreads medical misinformation. Maybe this particular example isn’t likely to result in any risky lifestyle changes, but I’m confident that readers of SBM can easily think of several that have. But millions of people potentially avoiding eating Chinese food, take out in general, or even leftovers, could have economic downsides. We have also seen significant increases in anti-Asian hate crimes during the pandemic and this is the last thing they need.
There is at least a silver lining to all of this. In Hsu’s video, and even in the many poorly written news articles, the fact that there is a vaccine that protects people at risk from such a severe outcome was mentioned. Unfortunately, the young adult discussed in the NEJM case report had not taken advantage of them, having only received the first dose of the two recommended vaccine series. Hopefully people will be inspired to take advantage of these lifesaving medical marvels and get themselves or their kids vaccinated.

The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment: A Fiasco with a Silver Lining
The Tuskegee syphilis experiment studied black men with advanced syphilis for 40 years. Patients were lied to and prevented from getting treatment. A black mark in the history of American medicine, it led to important reforms.
Harriet Hall on March 5, 2019
Link


The Tuskegee experiment was one of the most regrettable incidents in the history of medicine in the U.S. Conducted by the U.S. Public Health Service, it started in 1932 as a six-month study of the natural course of untreated syphilis in 399 black men and 201 controls. It took on a life of its own, lasted forty years, and was only terminated in 1972 after whistleblowers sparked a public outcry.
Patients who could have been cured were denied effective treatment and most of them suffered the complications of advanced syphilis and died before their time. 40 of their wives contracted syphilis, and 19 children were born with congenital syphilis.
The doctors were accused of racism and genocide. They were compared to the Nazi doctors whose unethical experiments cruelly tortured and killed prisoners in Hitler’s concentration camps. Many myths were circulated. It was widely believed that the doctors injected patients with syphilis; they did not. It was assumed that doctors told patients they had syphilis; they did not. It was widely believed that no treatment was given; in reality, most patients did receive some treatment, although it was inadequate. It was often believed that both men and women were enrolled; but the study was restricted to black males who had advanced syphilis and were in a specific age group, excluding younger men. The reasoning was that it was important to know when patients contracted the disease; men usually had an identifiable, memorable skin lesion, while women often did not. And they needed to be able to follow patients who had been infected long enough to develop late complications.
When I first heard of the Tuskegee study, I was appalled. I couldn’t imagine what those doctors were thinking, or how they could sleep at night after participating in such an unethical experiment. As I learned more, especially from reading the book Bad Blood by James H. Jones, I realized the truth was far more nuanced than I had realized. I now have a better understanding of what those doctors were doing and thinking; I don’t condone their actions, but I can cut them some slack because I know they were heavily influenced by peer pressure and by the social milieu of their time.
To set the scene
Racial prejudice was rampant, and segregation was in full force. The study subjects were all black and impoverished; the researchers were all white and well-to-do. Conventional wisdom held that blacks were inferior in various ways. The high incidence of syphilis in blacks was attributed to physical inferiority and sexual promiscuity. The effects of abject poverty and ignorance were confused with intrinsic racial traits. Doctors believed that diseases had different effects in patients of different races. They thought blacks were more likely to suffer cardiovascular complications of syphilis and whites more likely to have central nervous system complications.
A study in Oslo, Norway, had examined the natural course of untreated syphilis in white males, but it was a retrospective study pieced together from information about patients who, for whatever reason, had not been treated. The U.S. Public Health Service researchers thought there would be value in prospectively following black males who were diagnosed with syphilis but not treated. Macon County, Alabama, was a convenient place for such a study, with a rural population of isolated, uneducated, illiterate, ignorant, malnourished, desperately poor black sharecroppers who had no access to medical care; many of them had never been seen by a doctor in their entire life. They didn’t know what syphilis was, and the researchers didn’t explain; they just told them the test showed they had “bad blood”. They were promised treatment for their bad blood, free medical care for minor ailments, free transportation to appointments, free meals on study days, and free burial insurance. Since they had no other way to afford medical care or burial insurance, they could hardly refuse. They were initially told the study would last six months and would provide treatment.
As time passed, the researchers lied to subjects repeatedly. They gave them token placebos (aspirin and iron tonics) and let them believe they were getting effective treatment (some subjects had never taken an aspirin before, and they were impressed when it relieved their headaches). They went to great lengths to prevent them from getting effective treatment outside the program. They got permission for autopsies by calling them “surgeries” and making them a requirement for receiving funeral benefits.
They wanted to gather data with spinal taps, but they knew patients often had serious side effects like prolonged incapacitating headaches, and they were afraid the word would get around and other patients would refuse. So they found a way to process a large number of patients at once before the word could spread, and they cynically enticed patients in with a deceptive letter that said “Last Chance for Special Free Treatment”. Some patients didn’t realize that the purpose of the spinal tap was diagnostic; they believed their spine was being injected with curative medication.
Contemporary treatment for syphilis
Apparently the original plan was to treat everyone who tested positive with the standard anti-syphilis drug, Salvarsan, an arsenic-based drug, along with mercury. But the study was only supposed to last for six to eight months, and effective treatment required a full year. The injections were painful, and the treatments were toxic. The side effects were so bad that some doctors discouraged treatment, arguing that the treatment was worse than the disease. Due to the Great Depression, private funding for treatment medications was withdrawn; but the study was continued as an observational study of untreated patients. The partially treated patients were considered untreated for the purpose of the study. So it was never really a valid study of untreated patients; it was hopelessly contaminated by partially treated patients. It never even had a formal study protocol, and it didn’t have an appropriate control group. When subjects in the control group developed syphilis during the study, they were simply transferred to the syphilis group.
When a safer, more effective treatment, penicillin, came along in 1943, it was never offered to study participants; they weren’t even told it existed. Some researchers argued against it to maintain the “untreated” integrity of the study, and some argued that it was new and was not really a good treatment; it might do more harm than good to patients with advanced disease. Some argued that withholding treatment did not injure the participants, because if the study had not existed, the patients would not have had any kind of medical care.
Nurse Eunice Rivers
A black registered nurse, Eunice Rivers (later Eunice Rivers Laurie), played an essential part in getting the study done. She gained the confidence of patients, knew how to talk to them, became friends with them, visited them at home, provided transportation in her own car, and worked hard to locate patients when the researchers lost track of them. She never questioned the study. She believed a nurse’s duty was to not ask questions and to simply carry out the doctor’s orders.
When interviewed years later, she refused to believe the patients had been harmed. She felt it was best to withhold treatment in the 1930s because there were bad reactions and some patients would have died. She wasn’t so sure about the wisdom of withholding penicillin when it became available, even though withholding it was illegal: it violated state laws and the federal Henderson Act of 1943 which required testing and treatment of venereal disease. But when asked what mistakes had been made, her main concern was the lack of informed consent: it bothered her that the doctors never told the patients they had syphilis.
Similarly, the doctors who participated in the program felt they were simple clinicians who were not qualified to evaluate the scientific merits of a study that the expert scientists had said was important and necessary. They simply did what they were directed to do.
Compensation
The victims received a formal apology from President Clinton on behalf of the United States in 1997. The researchers themselves never expressed contrition; they insisted they had acted in good faith. The 74 participants who were still alive were offered free medical care and burial stipends. A lawsuit was settled out of court for $10 million.
Lessons learned
The Tuskegee experiment was a terrible fiasco, but there was a silver lining: one good thing did come out of it. Nothing of scientific value was learned from the study. Nothing that would “prevent, find, or cure a single case”. But there was one very valuable, important result. Due to the public outrage, laws were passed to protect the rights of human subjects in research studies. Today human studies must be approved by Institutional Review Boards. Subjects cannot be denied effective treatment. They must understand the purpose of the study and they must give informed consent. Protection is not perfect, and there will still be abuses, but hopefully none as egregious as the infamous Tuskegee experiment.

No, Purell Does Not Breed Super-Anything
Adam Wegman on November 28, 2015
Link


Recently, I was sitting in a meeting and reached for the dispenser of Purell hand sanitizer sitting on the conference room table. A colleague of mine gave a small, rueful shake of her head to the person on her other side. Apparently I had erred. I asked what was the matter, and got a brief answer to the effect of “because superbugs.” We exchanged nothing more about it; the interaction was over before the alcohol had dried from my hands.
I wouldn’t have thought anything of such an interaction with anyone else, but my colleague is a PhD student in immunology, six years older and more schooled than I, doing her doctoral research in a lab run by a physician-scientist — a specialist in infectious disease, no less. A touch ironic.
And so I noticed a need for some mythbusting: alcohol-based hand sanitizers do not breed resistant bacteria.
Superbugs: whence they come
Antibiotics breed resistant bacteria. I’ll leave the topic of antibiotic stewardship out of this post — suffice to say that antibiotic use and the resultant resistant microbes are a serious problem — but I’ll explain how alcohol-based sanitizers do not breed “superbugs,” either bacteria or viruses. I’ll then touch on the hygiene hypothesis as it pertains to personal hygiene.
First, bacteria. Antibiotics have specific mechanisms of action by which they weaken or kill bacteria. Take penicillin and its derivatives (β-lactam antibiotics) as a classic example: they inhibit the synthesis of the peptidoglycan wall of gram-positive bacteria at the final transpeptidation step. This in turn renders the bacteria fragile and vulnerable to physical and osmotic stress, as well as unable to divide. This inhibition process requires high molecular precision.
This specificity is what characterizes antibiotics’ function. It is also what creates a selection pressure for bacteria to evolve to survive what was previously toxic to them. We tend to think of evolution as a process taking place over millions of years, but it’s faster for microorganisms — a lot faster. The vast numbers of bacteria, their short time of replication, and their capacity for horizontal gene exchange, accelerate their evolution when they are in the presence of an environmental pressure such as an antibiotic.
These factors create the dangerous potential for evolution of bacteria into resistant strains. Over time, and with improper use, antibiotics can breed superbugs.
Why you shouldn’t worry about (alcohol-based) sanitizers breeding resistant bacteria
What, then, separates Purell from penicillin? The answer lies in the mechanism of action of ethanol — a type of alcohol, and the active ingredient in Purell and similar products.
(It is important to note that I have deliberately specified alcohol-based hand sanitizers in this post. They are by far the most common kind of instant sanitizer. Other active ingredients, like triclosan, may promote resistance, because they have different mechanisms of action.)
While antibiotics target very specific cellular processes, ethanol is a nonspecific bactericidal agent. It disrupts several bacterial functions at once, “caus[ing] membrane damage and rapid denaturation of proteins, with subsequent interference with metabolism and cell lysis.”
This is not something that can be evaded as simply as activating a specific gene and secreting β-lactamase to destroy the antibiotic, for example. Tolerance to the action of ethanol would take much longer to evolve, and would be comparable to the organism becoming an extremophile.
Moreover, antibiotics are administered over the course of days or weeks (or even months) and therefore represent a sustained environmental pressure against which bacteria can evolve. By contrast, alcohol in hand sanitizers is present for about twenty seconds and is gone — there’s no continuous stress against which the bacteria are being selected. Further, because of the very brief exposure, there is no opportunity for the bacteria to replicate in the presence of ethanol — and therefore a negligible selection pressure over time.
Alcohol hand sanitizers and viruses
Next, viruses. The ethanol in hand sanitizers is effective against some viruses, for the same main reason: overwhelming force. Ethanol can denature the protein coat of some (not all) viruses, or break down the outer lipid envelope (depending on the type of virus in question).
There’s another reason, quite different from the case of bacteria: viruses are obligate intracellular parasites that need to be inside a cell to replicate. Viruses on the surface of the skin aren’t even replicating, and therefore a denaturant such as alcohol doesn’t constitute a selection pressure. No evolution, no resistant organisms!
And so, just as they don’t breed resistant bacteria, alcohol-based sanitizers don’t breed resistant viruses. (And neither do antibiotics, as those are ineffective against viruses and wouldn’t create any selection pressure either.) Alcohol hand sanitizers are second only to hand washing (which is sometimes absolutely necessary), and nonetheless represent an important and convenient approach to curtailing contagion, especially in hospital environments.
But there’s another reason some people object to hand sanitizers.
The hygiene hypothesis
We can kill bacteria and viruses with sanitizers, and it does not breed resistant strains…but should we? The hygiene hypothesis — the idea that we need microorganisms — is another concern that often comes up along with the worries about superbugs. Basically, the rationale is that nuking microganism populations could have unfortunate unintended consequences for human health, even if it doesn’t breed superbugs (Harriet Hall has discussed the hygiene hypothesis previously, reviewing a book about it in the process).
There have been questions raised about the hygiene hypothesis concerning hand sanitizers and personal hygiene in general. The hygiene hypothesis has gone through several redefinitions since its 1989 introduction by David Strachan, but can be broadly described as the “potential beneficial role of microbial exposures for the development of asthma, allergies and autoimmune disorders.” The logic is that exposure to antigens (through infection by bacteria, or helminths – parasitic worms) hones the specificity of the immune system, reducing the incidence of autoimmune events.
The hygiene hypothesis is, by definition, not a scientific theory — it is still being evaluated, reformulated, and appended. This summary does a good job of listing some of the gaps and inconsistencies in the hypothesis, some of which include:
    • “…numerous unknown mechanisms and inconclusive findings to date…”
    • “The potential role of viruses has not been explored…”
    • “There is large uncertainty with respect to the potential beneficial effects of probiotics…”
    • “…we still do not know whether prenatal or postnatal exposures matter”; and
    • “…the use of comparative animal models has not sufficiently been explored…”
I don’t mean to cast doubt on the entire idea. The hygiene hypothesis is not pseudoscience. It shows all of the makings of a genuine (if fledgling) scientific idea: plausible mechanisms, explanatory potential, initial validating evidence, reasoned challenges, careful review, and much more to be discovered. What this early-stage status means is that scientific medicine cannot recommend specific actions at this time.
A thorough (if somewhat aged) 2006 review is cautious: “the relationship of the hypothesis to hygiene practice is not proven,” and recommends further study. The authors of this summary succinctly write: “We consider it too early to provide recommendations on an individual level with respect to personal hygiene.” A 2015 paper specific to asthma and allergies concluded: “…neither personal nor home cleanliness was associated with a risk for asthma and allergies. Other microbial components in house dust not affected by personal hygiene are likely to play a role.”
The hygiene hypothesis and hand sanitizers
Concerning the hygiene hypothesis at large, the body of evidence is growing. However, it has not converged on an interpretation — there aren’t enough consistent data to recommend specific interventions. There have been isolated studies, mostly epidemiological or in mouse models, with helminths (parasitic worms) and a few species of bacteria. But there are a prodigious number of “microbial exposures” which might have a potential effect on “allergies and autoimmune disorders,” and the research thus far has explored only a fraction of these.
What we do know doesn’t boil down to advice regarding exposure to pathogens or about personal hygiene. This includes any recommendation for or against using alcohol-based hand sanitizers.
Even if the body of evidence grows large and cohesive and suggestive enough to promote the hygiene hypothesis to a theory, there are still a number of important questions and considerations. For example: is it just antigen exposure that is needed, or is the full-blown infection required to hone the immune system? If it’s the former, then one could reasonably hope for a “vaccine” of sorts that would contain the relevant antigens to coach the immune system (although we well know that many have issues with vaccines). If, however, a true infection is required, it becomes quite a murky question about how prophylactic microbial exposure would be reliably and ethically obtained. In any case, wherever this fledgling area of research leads, it’s sure to be interesting.
Alcohol hand sanitizers have no known downside
Ethanol-based hand sanitizers are a safe and practical approach to personal hand hygiene. While they can’t replace hand washing, use of such products should not be discouraged for fear of breeding microorganisms — because they just don’t.
Fears of unintended health consequences based on the hygiene hypothesis are premature. Although the hygiene hypothesis is a fascinating and potentially promising scientific idea, it is not coherent or complete enough to make specific recommendations about personal hygiene. As such, nothing in the hygiene hypothesis should deter use of ethanol-based sanitizers at this time.
While it is possible that sanitizers have unknown health consequences, it’s a certainty that not using them has consequences.

Elephants, Herpes, and Protests: A Zoo Tragedy Distorted
There has been a recent kerfuffle over the death of a young elephant from elephant endotheliotropic herpesvirus hemorrhagic disease. Was it the zoo’s fault? Probably not.
Greg Bishop on January 18, 2019
Link

A couple of months ago, a young elephant died in a zoo in Oregon. The cause of her death was a viral disease known as elephant endotheliotropic herpesvirus (EEHV) hemorrhagic disease, which is a common cause of young Asian elephant mortality. Undeniably tragic for everyone involved, this high profile death triggered activist demonstrations, who protested the confinement of elephants and in some cases claimed that captivity caused her disease or made her more susceptible to it. In fact, this enigmatic disease has claimed the lives of wild and captive elephants, and it is largely from the captive population of elephants that we know as much about it as we do.
Let’s talk about herpes
The causative agent of EEHV hemorrhagic disease is a herpesvirus. I can hear you snickering in the back, so just be aware that it’s not lack of elephant sex education that causes this, and in fact herpesviruses are extremely common in animals, usually not sexually transmitted, and usually don’t cause significant disease in their hosts. EEHV is an exception to the “harmonious pathogen” rule, however, as it has been documented to cause a lot of elephant deaths.
Herpes viruses in general tend to be strongly associated with a single host species. They may cause mild symptoms in the host (e.g. cold sores in humans are caused by a herpesvirus) but very rarely cause serious disease. But there are some examples of a virus “jumping” into a closely related species and causing disaster. Herpes B virus, for example, is a common host-adapted infection in macaque monkeys that causes minimal symptoms. But if a human is infected through a bite or a scratch, it causes encephalitis and has one of the highest case fatality rates of any known infection. Fortunately it’s relatively rare, but I still cringe when I see people conducting monkey business without protection.
There are an extraordinary number of herpesviruses, and given non-native host disease is so uncommon, when researchers were first trying to figure out why Asian elephants were dying from this virus, they reasonably thought that it was a host-adapted virus from African elephants* housed in the same zoos. Although this was a sound hypothesis at the time, it had yet to be tested, and has been misrepresented ever since. The speculation was enough to be used as “evidence” that housing elephants in artificial conditions (if it’s not clear, African and Asian elephants’ ranges do not overlap in the wild) directly led to the deaths of these young animals.
The Oregon Zoo
Lily’s death was the most recent case of EEHV hemorrhagic disease and the first to occur at the Oregon Zoo, in Portland, Oregon. This zoo is unfortunately no stranger to controversy and has attracted severe criticism from animal rights activists over the years. And yes, it is Portland, which may have a lower protest threshold than say Des Moines, and seems out-there enough to have been a plausible setting for the infamous hoax paper equating dog park behavior to rape culture. All the same, there is a history of controversial incidents at the Oregon Zoo, and this was not the first organized protest in front of its gates. The most prominent group is specifically opposed to the elephant program.
I’d like to briefly dab the distal millimeter of my toe into the firestorm of controversy surrounding elephants in captivity and say this: most modern zoos are deeply dedicated to the humane care of their animals as well as conservation and endangered species survival, while at the same time undeniably the descendants of an exploitative system. Elephants are not endemic to Oregon (for at least the last 15,000 years), and it was not high-minded conservation efforts that brought the original population of most zoo animals to where they have ended up today. That’s not the case nowadays, but it was not that long ago when we practiced some pretty shameful methods of “obtaining” exotic animals. That doesn’t change our responsibility to take care of the animals in modern zoos, or make it any easier to return captive species to the wild. And it doesn’t mean species in the wild can’t benefit from knowledge gained from their captive relatives.
After Lily’s death there were protests at the zoo, and although they were opposing elephant captivity in general, there were some suggestions that the zoo was responsible for the death. Of course, the activists are against captivity, so they’re motivated to assign the blame to the zoo for any negative outcome. According to the activist website Care2.com, “Elephants in captivity are susceptible to life-threatening health problems, like … endotheliotropic herpesvirus”. EEHV, however, has been documented in wild elephants and there is no evidence to suggest that it’s more common in captivity. That’s not to say there aren’t important differences between captive and wild animals (for example, there are a number of diseases in captive black rhinoceros that are virtually unknown in their wild counterparts), but that doesn’t mean that every problem a zoo animal gets is because it’s in a zoo.
One of the main claims still made by activists is that EEHV hemorrhagic disease is the result of unnatural zoo conditions, in which different species are often in close proximity. As stated above, this was the original hypothesis for why a herpesvirus would cause fatal disease in what was suspected to be a non-native host. Research in the last 20 years has since shown that there are more than a dozen subtypes of EEHV and that not only are the most common types responsible for deaths (EEHV1A and EEHV1B) not found in African elephants, but that wild Asian elephants who had never had been near African elephants have died from the disease. It appears that the most fatal subtypes are actually host-adapted to Asian elephants, although no one knows why.
Gaps in knowledge about EEHV
“We don’t know, but we’re working on it” would probably be an appropriate motto for EEHV researchers. There are so many things we don’t know about this significant killer of elephants. That’s not going to satisfy the grieving public or passionate activists after an elephant calf death, but it is the truth. A ton (I’m going to give myself credit for an elephant pun here) of work has been done on this disease over the last 20 or so years since the first cases were described, but the picture appears to be getting more confusing, not less.
Here are some depressing facts we’ve learned about EEHV: It has killed about 20-30% of the captive-born elephant calves born in North American zoos in the last 50 or so years. There have been about 100 cases worldwide, the vast majority in Asian elephant calves (only four cases are known in African elephants), and there are about eight documented survivors. All of the survivors were treated with expensive and sometimes difficult-to-access antiviral drugs, although many of the animals that died were also treated with these drugs, so it’s hard to say if the treatment actually helped or not. Most of the deaths are in animals between 1 and 4 years of age. The epidemiology of this disease has been a tough nut to crack, with almost every individual case caused by a different strain, and no clear reason as to why some individuals are affected and some aren’t. One of the craziest parts of the problem is that this virus is endemic in almost every herd of elephants that’s been examined, so it’s extremely unlikely that we’d be able to eradicate it. It’s been killing young elephants left and right for decades and we don’t understand how it’s transmitted, why it’s so virulent, or how to prevent it. It may have even been a cause of elephant mortality for hundreds if not thousands of years, but we have no idea.
One of the major reasons our knowledge is limited is that we haven’t been able to grow the virus in the lab yet, despite apparently a great deal of effort in doing so. If this hurdle could be crossed, we could make a lot more progress in our understanding of the pathology and treatment of the disease. There have been recent developments in elephant cell culture that might get us closer, and there are a lot of very smart people working very hard on solving the problem.** It’s indisputable that research on captive elephants has shed the most light on the disease. It’s also reasonable to suspect that the only animals who have survived the disease are ones in captive settings that received veterinary care.
Conclusion: Everyone loves elephants, this virus sucks
The trunk and tail of it is that EEHV hemorrhagic disease is one of the most serious threats facing the global Asian elephant population and we know frustratingly little about it. The passions ignited by a high profile animal death in a zoo are understandable but probably misplacing blame in this case. I happen know people in both the “liberate the pachyderms” camp, as well as the “hands-on daily care of individual elephants in zoos” group. The thing they share in common is a deep love of these animals and a desire to protect them. The truth is we know so little about EEHV and what to do about it that it might be a long time before we get any good answers. Captivity has its faults, and there is reason to suspect that many of the “charismatic” species such as elephants and orcas that you can currently see in a zoo will not be on display forever, but there are undeniable scientific benefits that can be gained from non-invasively studying these creatures while they’re in our care.

And after that bummer, allow me to present:

*There are three extant elephant species, two of which are commonly housed in zoos: the African bush elephant (Loxodonta africana), and the Asian elephant (Elephas maximus). The third species, the African forest elephant (Loxodonta cyclotis), is extremely rare to nonexistent in captivity. For super-nerd points, there are 185 known species of extinct elephants.
**Many of whom are at the National Elephant Herpesvirus Laboratory run by the Smithsonian’s National Zoo, although there are a lot of zoo veterinarians and researchers working on this problem.

Jurassic Farce
Mark Crislip on August 10, 2012
Link
It feels like I live in the real world example of Ray Bradbury’s All the Summer in a Day but for the last two weeks we have had sun and heat and it has been glorious. I get Christmas and Thanksgiving and New Years as vacation, but who needs that? I need July and August to live the vida loca in the Oregon summer. Who wants to blog when I can be outside, at concerts, golfing, hiking and…
Yes Dr. Gorski. I did agree to write an entry every other Friday. Yes Dr. Gorski. I know you have the documentation. Yes Dr. Gorski, I do not want any of that information made public. No one needs to know that I wanted to be a naturopath when I was young. Sigh. Yes, Sir, I will get to blogging. Damn those youthful indiscretions. Let’s see how little I can do and meet my obligations with the powers that be.
My professional career is based upon inflicting death, and in my time I have obliterated uncountable numbers of unicellular organisms. If there were such a thing as Karma, I would certainly return in the next life as a rabbit in a syphilis lab. But there isn’t, and I can kill and kill with a clean soul. There is no guilt or hesitation in killing unicellular life, or even multi-cellular life, as long as it cannot be seen without a microscope. I start to get a wee bit squeamish as soon as I can see a life form. I tend to not kill bugs or animals, unless, of course, they can be eaten. If it tastes good, all bets are off. But as a tree hugger, I tend to look upon killing wildlife and extinctions as a bad thing.
Well, maybe. I am glad that smallpox and rinderpest are no more, but they are viri* and not really life. I would not be saddened to see the end of polio, measles, or many of the other diseases that plague mankind. Extinction of organisms whose sole ‘purpose’ is to sicken and kill humans would be, I would think, a good thing. As life gets more complicated, the unease with extermination grows. Except for the dogs in my neighborhood, but that is really irresponsible dog owners (a redundant phrase) and not the barking vermin.
Mosquitoes have been a bane on humans since the beginning of time. It has been estimated that half of everyone who ever died has died of malaria. There are the other mosquito borne infections that kill and sicken: West Nile, Yellow Fever, Dengue, the various hemorrhagic fevers. I think mosquito borne illnesses have left more evolutionary footprints in our DNA than any other illness, from sickle cell disease to G-6-PD deficiency. And wildlife, without ready access to netting and DEET, suffers more. The world would be a better place without those blood sucking insects.
Well maybe. Bug Girl was kind enough to point me to an article that suggests that, unfortunately, mosquitoes, even the blood sucking mosquitos, may have an important niche in the ecosystem as food, if not as blood suckers. I will mention here a bit of skeptical heresy, but I was never that enthralled with Cosmos. Most science shows elicit ‘a tell me something I don’t know’ response. My PBS epiphanies were Shock of the New (an art show?!?) and Connections. Actions always have unintended consequences and mosquitoes probably have many under-recognized connections with their environment. No good deed goes unpunished, so getting rid of all 3500 species of mosquitoes would undoubtedly be a bad thing, but controlling or eradicating the few that are responsible for so much human death and disease would be a net benefit. In medicine sometimes there are no good solutions, just the least bad solution. What is worse? A million humans dead a year or the end of Aedes aegypti? As the experiment with DDT demonstrated, eradication of mosquitoes is probably impossible, but control? Probably.
Dengue, along with other infections, is coming north. Dengue has been reported in the Florida Keys and at least 40% of people in Brownsville Texas are seropositive for dengue. It is one of many infections that may infect or reinfest the US as the world warms. If we could control mosquitos, we could decrease the chances of the spread of dengue and other infections.
There have been some clever approaches to the control of infections. Mansonella perstans, a parasite that causes filariasis, can be controlled by killing bacterial endosymbionts found in their gut with doxycycline. Another way to control infection spread is the use of mutant mosquitos. One slick approach is to release sterile males into the environment. If the females mate with the sterile males, then they lay sterile eggs. They used to release irradiated mosquitoes, but now they render the males sterile with genetic modifications. It is, by the way, very difficult to perform vasectomies on mosquitoes.
The nice thing about mosquitoes is they are homebodies, staying close to where they are were born. If you release a swarm of of sterile males into a local environment, the females mate with sterile males and viola, no children. And the effects are limited to the local environment. Sound like a good approach for other species as well.
It appears to work. When sterile males are mixed with a wild population, there is an 80% drop in the mosquito population. That can only be a good thing.
To my mind it is the perfect way to control mosquitos: no spraying of chemicals, no side effects and, perhaps unfortunately, no permanent eradication of the mosquitoes. And since it is a local application of sterile males (only females, by the way, feed on blood) there is little impact on wild populations, where the bugs can breed to be a continued food supply and repopulate human habits, requiring repeat treatments. Good for bottom line.
They want to try this approach in Florida and, what a surprise, over 100,000 people have signed a petition to prevent the release of the GM mosquitos. Why?
First, people do not want to be guinea pigs, from what I am not certain.
“”Have there been studies of what can happen if someone is bit by one of these mosquitoes?” said Key West realtor Mila de Mier. “Are we the subjects, the guinea pigs of this experiment?””
Male Aedes aegypti mosquitoes, which is what is modified, do not bite, only females. Unless they are making homosexual mosquitoes as part of a government conspiracy. That would be just like the government. So there should be no bites from gm mosquitoes.
Of course there is always the worry about being bitten by a mutant insect. Think Peter Parker, although Bug Girl has written the definitive essay on what should happen if you are bitten by a radioactive spider. Imagine what would happen if you were bitten by a genetically modified gay male mosquitoes. It makes web shooters pale into insignificance.
The other worry is ‘a Jurassic Park event happening in the Keys.“ In Jurassic Park the dino DNA was extracted from a preserved mosquito and cloned to make new dinos. So a Jurassic Park event would be what: someone would clone the DNA from the blood in the gut of a mosquito to make what? More Floridians? With a Presidential election coming up, that is scary indeed with packs of voters unable to read a ballot or punch out a chad.
There is also the worry about the environmental impact of killing off large amounts of mosquitos, and that could be a real concern. That, to my mind, is the tricky one, and it is an interesting calculus: how much animal life are you willing to kill to decrease human suffering and death? But that is a political-ethical, not a scientific, question.
The science of sterile mosquitos would point to a safe and clever way to decrease the vector of many of the infections that kill and sicken humans with little downside.
The drive against the GM mosquitoes seems based on fear of government, fear of science and fear of biting gay mosquitos and a lack of understanding of the biology of mosquitoes and an appreciation of how rapidly infections can spread in a community if they can gain a proboscis hold. It looks like the ethic of the Natural News is more widespread than I had suspected.
I write this essay on my front porch and I have to stop now and then to slap a mosquito. We have yet to have West Nile in Oregon, and I have been predicting a small epidemic for about 5 years now. Still hasn’t happened, and I am uncertain why. I like to credit the superior beer for keeping the virus and mosquitoes at bay. Perhaps those in the Keys should make note.
Can I go back to playing Dr. Gorski? Please?
* the plural of Elvis is Elvi, so the plural of virus is viri. What is the pleural of empyema?

Buzzword Medicine – Anti-Proinflammation
Does it make sense to simultaneously recommend interventions to suppress and boost the immune system?
Steven Novella on August 11, 2021
Link

Alternative medicine is essentially what you get when you remove science from the equation (at least as a method of determining if an intervention is safe and effective) and emphasize marketing. Pre-FDA, for example, we lived in an era of patent medicine, where marketing was everything and the market was full of useless snake oil with vague or unproven claims. We have partially returned to that world in the post-DSHEA era. Likewise alternative medicine (regardless of the branding de jour) at its core is about eliminating the standard of care or a scientific basis for medicine and letting market forces reign.
In such a world what matters is the narrative, the story are you trying to sell. Narratives, in turn, are supported by basic concepts and buzzwords, which substitute for evidence and careful thought. For example “natural” is a marketing term, based on the appeal to nature narrative which creates a health halo around any product or service that is labeled so. It is not a coherent or internally consistent principle, just a vague sense designed to make people feel good about a product. What, operationally, is “natural”? Why would we think that something evolved in nature is good for us? Nature is generally trying to kill us for its own survival.
I was reminded of all this when I saw an article about the “Naturopathic approach” to COVID-19. The article mostly recommends herbs and supplements, thinly sourced and typically making unsupported clinical claims based on pre-clinical data. As is common they start with some common-sense recommendations, like getting enough sleep, but the core of the article is unsupported herbalism. What struck me is that the recommendations were divided into three categories: “anti-oxidant support” (potentially dangerous), “upregulating the immune system” (what part?), and “anti-inflammatory support” (dubious).
The phrasing here is due to DSHEA, which allows for “structure-function” claims for supplements, but not disease claims. Anyone can claim that anything “supports” a biological function, without the need for evidence. As long as you don’t mention a disease by name, you won’t run afoul of the FDA. But perhaps more interestingly, three of the most common alternative medicine narratives are invoked, even though they are largely contradictory to each other. They nicely represent how a health-halo buzzword is all that matters when it comes to alternative medicine.
Let’s start with anti-oxidant support. The basic idea is that oxidative stress, resulting from metabolism and specifically creating ATP (energy carrying molecules) with oxygen in mitochondria, can cause cell damage. Anti-oxidants chemically neutralize oxygen free radicals and prevent cell damage from oxidative stress. At least, this is the 1980s version of the science. In the last few decades we have learned a few interesting things about the oxidative system.
First, the body makes its own anti-oxidants, and they are orders of magnitude more powerful than anything you can get in a supplement or in food. Therefore, if greater anti-oxidant activity were advantageous, why wouldn’t we have evolved to just make a little more? This question leads to other important facts we learned about oxygen free radicals – they are used by cells for important functions. For example, they are signal molecules that trigger important protective metabolic processes. They are also (and this is important) used by certain cells of the immune system to fight off invaders. Oxidative stress can also damage cells of the immune system, so free radicals are definitely a double-edged sword.
But that is the key – oxygen free radicals exist in a delicate homeostasis with endogenous anti-oxidants. This is a complex system, and there is no reason to think that taking extra (and wimpy) anti-oxidants will somehow improve this balance. In fact, during an infection may be the worst time to take them as they may impair the immune response to the infection. At the same time, the immune response to an active infection can itself cause harm to the body, and sometimes suppressing aspects of the immune system might have more benefit than harm. How do we balance the potential benefit vs harm in any intervention that inhibits immune activity during an infection?
This requires careful study for each individual infection type. It remains to be seen if anti-oxidants are useful in COVID-19, but there is some reason to think that they may be. That is not enough, however. We need rigorous clinical trials. Our track record of predicting whether or not altering immune function will be helpful or harmful is not very good. Immune function is extremely complex, and is a delicate balance of trade-offs. Simple narratives (such as “anti-oxidants good”) are not sufficient.
The same goes for boosting the immune system and anti-inflammatory treatments. Inflammation is also what the immune system does to fight infection, and it can cause damage to the host. Are we boosting the right part of the immune system? Will this unnecessarily cause more damage? If we suppress inflammation, will that worsen the infection? These answers differ for each type of infection.
In COVID-19 it turns out that perhaps the most effective treatment discovered so far is corticosteroids. This is an old-school anti-inflammatory drug. This will worsen some infections, and improve outcomes in others. It was researched in COVID-19 because it was recognized that the worst patient outcomes may be due to “cytokine storm” – a flare of immune activity triggered by severe infection that can be devastating. But not all kinds of anti-inflammatory treatment are the same. The immune system has many components, and if you suppress the wrong one that can hamper defenses against the virus. By the same token, if you increase immune activity you may help fight the virus or increase the risk of cytokine storm or other inflammatory damage.
There is therefore no rationale for simultaneously recommending some interventions that reduce immune activity and other interventions that increase immune activity as blanket recommendations, without evidence for net clinical outcomes from a specific treatment in a specific infection. But researching specific clinical outcomes would be doing science-based medicine, and that is not what alternative medicine is. Alternative medicine is based on marketable buzzwords, applied simplistically, and without proper evidence.

Wim Hof, the Iceman
Wim Hof, the Iceman, is extraordinarily resistant to extreme cold. His Wim Hof Method (WHM) combines breathing exercises, cold exposure, and meditation. Hyperventilation has been shown to reduce the body’s response to inflammation, but Hof’s extravagant claims of health benefits are not supported by scientific evidence.
Harriet Hall on January 12, 2021
Link

Wim Hof, also known as “The Iceman”, is a 61-year-old Dutch extreme athlete famous for his ability to withstand extreme cold. He has set several Guinness World Records for swimming under ice, for prolonged full-body contact with ice, and for a barefoot half-marathon on ice and snow.
The Wim Hof Method
He promotes his Wim Hof Method (WHM) which consists of three pillars: breathing, cold therapy, and commitment (or meditation). The breathing consists of three phases: 30-40 cycles of hyperventilation are followed by breath retention and finally a recovery breath. The cold is applied through cold showers and ice baths. The third pillar trains the brain to improve willpower and self-control; and teaches people to observe their thoughts, emotions and impulses, without identifying or acting on them.
He was featured in Gwyneth Paltrow’s Netflix series Goop Lab, where he taught Goop staff members to tolerate sitting in the snow and plunging into frigid water wearing only skimpy swimsuits. He explained that his breathing method raises the body’s pH levels. Of course it does, because hyperventilation increases the excretion of carbon dioxide; but that’s not a good thing. It produces a temporary state of respiratory alkalosis, an abnormal disruption of acid-base homeostasis. When hyperventilation stops, the acid-base balance quickly returns to normal. If hyperventilation persists, the person will pass out, and the body’s normal compensatory mechanisms will be able to take over and re-establish homeostasis. Wim Hof cautions against using his method when diving or driving, where passing out could be fatal. In fact, there have been several reports of deaths resulting from his methods.
Alleged benefits
He claims a multitude of benefits including increased energy, better sleep, heightened focus and determination, improved sports performance, increased willpower, reduced stress levels, greater cold tolerance, faster recovery, enhanced creativity, and a stronger immune system. He also suggests that his WHM may be useful to treat cancer and many other specific diseases.
Scientific studies
Wim has an identical twin who lives a sedentary lifestyle without exposure to extreme cold. A study comparing their responses to a challenge of cold exposure found no difference in cold-induced thermogenesis, suggesting that habitual exposure to extreme cold was not a factor. However, both twins did have similarly high levels of cold-induced thermogenesis. This was attributed to the brothers’ practice of a g-tummo-like breathing technique, suggesting that the vigorous isometric respiratory muscle contractions caused increased heat production.
G-tummo breathing techniques have long been practiced in Tibet and are reported to enable practitioners to voluntarily raise their body temperatures. A 2013 study found that forceful breathing during g-tummo increases body heat production, but only temporarily; meditation is required to sustain the response.“The Influence of Concentration/Meditation on Autonomic Nervous System Activity and the Innate Immune Response” was a case study of Wim Hof by a group of researchers in The Netherlands. It was published in Psychosomatic Medicine in 2012. With ice immersion, the cytokine inflammatory response was attenuated; and with intravenous administration of an endotoxin, the cortisol levels were higher than in previously studied individuals. Their conclusion:
The concentration/meditation technique used by this particular individual seems to evoke a controlled stress response. This response is characterized by sympathetic nervous system activation and subsequent catecholamine/cortisol release, which seems to attenuate the innate immune response.
Another case study of Wim Hof, the 2018 report “Brain Over Body” in NeuroImage by Musik et al. used fMRI and PET/CT imaging. They found changes in sympathetic innervation and glucose consumption when he used his Wim Hof Method (WHM). Imaging showed that “the WHM also engages higher-order cortical areas (left anterior and right middle insula) that are uniquely associated with self-reflection, and which facilitate both internal focus and sustained attention in the presence of averse (e.g. cold) external stimuli”. Their conclusion suggested that “the WHM might allow practitioners to develop higher level of control over key components of the autonomous system, with implications for lifestyle interventions that might ameliorate multiple clinical syndromes”.
In another study from The Netherlands, 30 healthy Dutch males were randomized into an intervention group and a control group. The first group was trained in “third eye” meditation, voluntarily exposed themselves to cold in various ways (such as taking cold showers), and were instructed in breathing techniques. Then they were injected with an endotoxin. In the intervention group, epinephrine levels increased, and anti-inflammatory markers increased, while levels of proinflammatory markers and flu-like symptoms decreased. They claimed to have demonstrated that voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system suppresses the innate immune response.
An open-label “proof of concept” study of 24 patients with axial spondyloarthritis was published in PlosOne in 2019. Participants were trained by Wim Hof and then exposed to cold. There was a significant decrease in one inflammatory marker (ESR sedimentation rate) but not in others. They concluded that “the add-on training program used in this study can safely be applied in patients with axial spondyloarthritis and potentially modulates inflammatory response”. They acknowledged several limitations of their study and called for further research.
Conclusion: The science is lacking
A Dutch skeptic, Pepijn van Erp, said it best. He reviewed the scientific evidence and wrote an article about ““Wim Hof’s Cold Trickery“. He says science has shown that hyperventilation reduces the body’s inflammatory response; but that isn’t always desirable. And when it is desirable, that doesn’t necessarily mean there are any practical clinical applications. Inflammation is a normal protective response that promotes healing, and it only becomes a problem when an overactive immune response causes autoimmune diseases. He points out that most of Wim Hof’s claims are just speculation and are not supported by any scientific evidence. I agree. His extraordinary resistance to cold is an interesting fact worthy of further investigation, but I don’t think it justifies taking cold showers or hyperventilating.

Tattoos Won’t Boost Your Immune System
Can getting a tattoo help reduce your risk of catching a cold? What about getting a bunch of ’em? Sadly, no amount of ink is going to boost your immune system.
Clay Jones on October 18, 2019
Link
Earlier this month I stumbled on an article in Mic, an online magazine aimed at millennials, that discussed the possible role of tattoos in “boosting the immune system” (which you can’t do) and reducing your risk of catching a cold. I am not a millennial, but thankfully I was still able to access and read the content. It was terrible in a well-meaning sort of way, and a great example of why dedicated science and medicine journalists are best suited for discussing these issues.
The author of this particular article is a yoga instructor. Not that there is anything wrong with that, of course. My wife is a certified yoga instructor. She just also happens to be quadruple boarded in pediatrics, pharmacology, pediatric oncology, and palliative medicine. Neither of us have any tattoos.
Speaking of tattoos, what do they have to do with the immune system or your risk of viral infections? Probably nothing at all. Well, almost certainly nothing at all. The whole concept, as I will discuss in absurd detail considering how silly it is, is absurdly silly. There is a tiny sliver of plausibility, and now two studies, but this is very unlikely to result in anything other than an Ig Nobel Prize.
But before I discuss the current article, we need to go all the way back to 2016. 2016, the year the Chicago Cubs broke the curse of a goat, or Babe Ruth, or something like that. Russia interfered with our elections. Oh, and Brexit. Also in 2016 there was a slurry of articles about tattoos preventing the common cold, like this one.
In March of that year, a study authored by Christopher Lynn and a team of anthropologists from the University of Alabama was published in the American Journal of Human Biology. It investigated a link between tattoos and immune function. Lynn was working from the personal observation that getting a tattoo seemed to make people feel tired and more likely to become ill. He further hypothesized that any negative effect on immune function would be reversed as more tattoos were accrued over time, and that there might actually be a beneficial response.
In the above linked Science Daily article, he is quoted likening this to the difference between someone who is out of shape going to the gym once, and someone partaking in regular exercise:
“After the stress response, your body returns to an equilibrium,” Lynn said. “However, if you continue to stress your body over and over again, instead of returning to the same set point, it adjusts its internal set points and moves higher.”
Though perhaps intuitively satisfying, this is nonsense from a medical standpoint. His use of the concept of stress is so nebulous that it renders this statement uninterpretable. He is trying to say that regular exercise, particularly of moderate intensity, is good for you and better than just occasionally hitting the gym. This is true in a variety of ways, including when it comes to immune function, but equating that to getting tattoos doesn’t make much sense.
Lynn recruited a convenience sample of 29 adult subjects, almost all women, with varying degrees of tattoo experience. He obtained saliva samples both before and after each subject got their planned tattoo in order to measure levels of cortisol and secretory immunoglobulin A (SIgA) as surrogate markers for stress and immune function respectively. Obviously the immune system and the human response to stress is extremely complex and involves many more factors than this, but cortisol and SIgA are easy to measure in saliva and these were anthropologists, after all, not medical researchers.
Before we get to the results, a quick and basic primer on IgA:
IgA is the most abundant antibody type in our bodies, and its secretory form is particularly prevalent in saliva and mucous secretions in the respiratory, GI, and genitourinary tract. This form is produced locally in mucous tissue rather than in the bone marrow where other immunoglobulins, including serum IgA, are made. Unique SIgA is produced in response to exposure of mucosal tissue to different microbial antigens, thus they provide protection from future infections largely by coating pathogens and preventing them from penetrating the mucosal surface.
There is much more to IgA, but for our purposes today that is about all you need to know. IgA clearly plays a role in preventing infections such as the common cold, among many others, but it isn’t quite that simple. A lot of people are deficient in the stuff, but because there are many redundant immune functions the vast majority, around 90% in fact, don’t have more infections. And in the 10% of IgA-deficient patients who do develop more infections, they don’t tend to be more severe. And this is over a lifetime of having no IgA. So the notion that transient changes in SIgA levels in response to acute stress might alter your risk of catching a cold is not well supported.
Now back to our study. I was unable to obtain the full paper, and the abstract linked to above was unfortunately not very helpful. But based on it and the numerous articles published at the time, it looks like they found that getting a tattoo was associated with a decrease in SIgA levels, but less so in subjects with more previous tattoo experience, and all results were within the normal range. Again, not that that really matters in this context.
This could have just been random fluctuation in an underpowered study. Noise, essentially. And who knows how long any changes in SIgA lasted after the tattoo session? Once again, not that it matters…at all. There is very little reason to expect a clinically meaningful difference in the risk of catching a cold when SIgA levels are a little lower. The authors attempted to link the drops in SIgA to stress, which is why they measured salivary cortisol levels, but I was unable to find any mention of those results. It was implied, however, that there was an inverse relationship with more experienced subjects having less of a stress response with repeated tattoo sessions.
It’s important to point out that cortisol levels vary significantly depending on the time of day. It does not appear that this was taken into account. The bottom line is that it was ridiculous in 2016, based on this study, to conclude that tattoos play any role whatsoever in the function of the human immune system regardless of how many you get.
Now lets fast forward to October of 2019 and see if there is reason to update this assessment based on new data. Here again is the Mic article that first got my attention. It starts by repeating the implausible and unfounded conclusions made in 2016:
Tattoos are wounds and when your body is hurt, your immune system swoops in like a cellular superhero that fights infections in not just the tattoo, but throughout the whole body.
This is wrong on many levels. Remember, the 2016 study found that SIgA levels decreased in all subjects, just less so in those with more tattoo experience. The implication was that more experienced subjects were less stressed and thus had lower cortisol levels, which had less of a negative effect on immune function. This does not mean that the overall function of their immune system was improved or that they would be less likely to get sick. Also, that study was garbage and didn’t tell us anything about cortisol levels in relation to getting a tattoo, and it isn’t even clear that cortisol spikes would change SIgA levels.
I’m going to move on from the Mic article now. More helpful in this discussion is the article in The Conversation which it was based on, and that was written by Christopher Lynn himself. In it, he discusses the details of his attempt to replicate the 2016 study in a population of American Samoans. The new study was published last month, again in the American Journal of Human Biology, which apparently is a respected publication.
I’m going to quote liberally here.
He starts off with a reference to his 2016 study:
This field season was the fourth of my research on the relationship between tattooing and immune response. My first study had focused on a small sample, mostly women, in Alabama. What I’d observed among that group suggested that tattooing could help beef up one’s immune response.
No, it didn’t. It suggested that randomly checking salivary SIgA levels yields random results.
He then demonstrates some admirable insight:
But one small study in the United States wasn’t proof of anything – despite headlines blaring that tattoos could cure the common cold. Good science means finding the same results multiple times and then interpreting them to understand something about the world.
Yes…sort of. Good science means attempts to replicate results after taking into account flaws in the design methodology of earlier studies and the prior plausibility of the hypothesis in question. In this case, replication with just another small study, particularly one that is needlessly complicated by aggressive statistical processing, just wouldn’t be enough.
He follows with an incredible leap in logic:
Tattooing creates a permanent image by inserting ink into tiny punctures under the topmost layer of skin. Your body interprets a new tattoo as a wound and responds accordingly, in two general ways.
Innate immune responses involve general reactions to foreign material. So getting a new tattoo triggers your immune system to send white blood cells called macrophages to eat invaders and sacrifice themselves to protect against infection.
Your body also launches what immunologists call adaptive responses. Proteins in the blood will try to fight and disable specific invaders that they recognize as problems. There are several classes of these proteins – called antibodies or immunoglobulins – and they continue to circulate in the bloodstream, on the lookout lest that same invader is encountered again. They’re at the ready to quickly launch an immune response the next time around.
This adaptive capacity of the immune system means that we could measure immunoglobulins in saliva as approximations of previous stress caused by tattooing.
Wait…what? There is no connection whatsoever between skin wounds and the production of salivary SIgA levels. As I discussed above, SIgA is only produced locally in the mucous membranes as a result of exposure to pathogens on those surfaces. And what does stress have to do with that process? Nothing. That last sentence is garbage.
He discusses the new study, which involved 25 subjects that were mostly tourists visiting American Samoa:
We collected saliva at the start and end of each tattoo session, controlling for the tattoo duration. We also measured recipients’ weight, height and fat density to account for health. From the saliva samples, we extracted the antibody immunoglobulin A, as well as the stress hormone cortisol and inflammatory marker C-reactive protein. Immunoglobulin A is considered a frontline immune defense and provides important protections against frequent pathogens like those of the common cold.
By comparing the levels of these biological markers, we determined that immunoglobulin A remains higher in the bloodstream even after tattoos heal. Furthermore, people with more time under the tattoo needle produced more salivary immunoglobulin A, suggesting an enhanced immune response to receiving a new tattoo compared to those with less or no tattoo experience. This effect appears to be dependent on receiving multiple tattoos, not just time passed since receiving one. This immune boost may be beneficial in the case of other skin injuries and for health in general.
So in this small study, they found that some of the subjects had higher levels of SIgA after getting a tattoo. Remember, in the previous study they all had decreased levels. This supports the notion that it’s all just random noise rather than that the immune system was somehow boosted. The claim that elevated SIgA levels, even if directly caused by the tattoo, would play a role in non-mucosal surface healing or general health goes against the basic scientific understanding of what these antibodies actually do in our bodies.
He goes on, quite a bit more in fact, but doesn’t say anything that is really different from what I’ve covered. He does at one point imply that getting tattoos is similar to being vaccinated. Yikes. And he does reveal that he is in the middle of another study, this time involving 50 subjects. He has collected more saliva samples which will be used to help him understand something about the world I suppose.
I have nothing against Lynn. And what a cool job, am I right? He gets to travel and hang out in tattoo parlors. He’s just way out of his element when it comes to the medical sciences. It’s hard to wrap my head around why there are anthropologists studying the immune system without any apparent input from a relevant expert. It’s like they just googled it one day.
Tattoos are fine, although not risk free. Make sure that you are going to a reputable establishment that follows proper safety protocols. And don’t expect that they will protect you from catching a cold no matter how many you get.

Tattoos Still Won’t Boost Your Immune System
Does the repeated stress on your immune system from getting tattoo after tattoo make you better able to fight off infections? No, no it does not.
Clay Jones on May 10, 2024
Link

One of the silliest topics that I’ve covered over the past 10+ years of writing for SBM, at least among the ones that I didn’t make up myself, was the claim that tattoos might boost the immune system and even make recipients healthier in general, but only if you get a bunch of ’em. Not that I have anything against tattoos, as long as appropriate safety measures are in place. Being tattooless, I have no skin in this game except for a desire for a better informed public.
In the innocent days of October of 2019, I first discussed the work of University of Alabama anthropologist Christopher Lynn on the potential relationship between getting some ink and “boosted” immune function that had been published in the American Journal of Biology in 2016 and again in 2019. This paper had resulted in some news articles that left a lot to be desired and I took them all to task. Lynn thanked me for the analysis on Twitter but accused me of sullying the good name of medical anthropology. In reality, I merely sullied the good name of Professor Lynn and called into question why an anthropologist was doing terrible medical research seemingly without any input from actual experts in immunology.
History, like Ka, is a wheel.
Lynn had initially set out to show that people who had received multiple tattoos over time have a more robust immune response to a new tattoo than people who are tattoo naive, a hypothesis based on pure conjecture that awkwardly compared getting a tattoo to going to the gym. The idea was that this repetitive stress could train the body to fight off infection more successfully. His initial 2016 study was small, with only 29 subjects, and involved measuring cortisol and secretory IgA (SIgA) in saliva both before and after participants got a tattoo. The decision to use these as surrogate markers of global immune function was based more on convenience rather than good science, however.
SIgA, as well as the small amount of serum IgA floating around in our bloodstream, is a component of our immune system’s response to microbial pathogens and does play a role in protecting us from some infections. SIgA coats the mucous membranes lining our respiratory, GI, and genitourinary tracts and works by attaching to antigens on the surface of microbial pathogens to help prevent penetration through these membranes where they could gain access to the bloodstream and other tissues. It’s also easy to measure because a blood draw isn’t necessary.
IgA isn’t that important, however, and it isn’t a helpful surrogate for general immune function. Millions of people have a selective IgA deficiency to varying degrees and it is by far the most common primary immunodeficiency. But most people who don’t have enough IgA are asymptomatic and diagnosed incidentally. Again, while some people do present with an unusual number of infections, most people with low or absent IgA do not get sick more often than people who are just lousy with the stuff.
As I explained back in 2019, relying on salivary SIgA levels isn’t helpful:
A lot of people are deficient in the stuff, but because there are many redundant immune functions the vast majority, around 90% in fact, don’t have more infections. And in the 10% of IgA-deficient patients who do develop more infections, they don’t tend to be more severe. And this is over a lifetime of having no IgA. So the notion that transient changes in SIgA levels in response to acute stress might alter your risk of catching a cold is not well supported.
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/tattoos-wont-boost-your-immune-system/
Lynn’s initial study found that undergoing placement of a tattoo resulted in a decrease in salivary SIgA, but this response appeared to be more robust in subjects getting their first tattoo. Experienced subjects were still found to have lowered SIgA, just less so. But all the measured levels were within normal parameters for SIgA and, as I hope I’ve made clear, none of this matters anyway. There was, and still remains, no plausible scientific reason to think that these changes, even if the observed pattern wasn’t just random noise, would have any clinically relevance. These results don’t add anything to our understanding of the immune system or even the body’s response to tattoos.
The cortisol levels were obtained in order to show an association between stress and SIgA levels, with the assumption that acute stress (higher salivary cortisol) would be associated with decreased immune system function (lower SIgA). There is a nugget of plausibility to this as it is well recognized that stress, primarily chronic stress, absolutely does play a role in many negative health outcomes, decreased immune function definitely being one of them. Lynn’s overarching hypothesis, however, was that getting multiple tattoos, essentially brief stressors spread out over time rather than chronic constant stress, somehow trains the body to be more resistant to stress in general, which would result in a “primed” immune system better capable of responding to invasion by microbial pathogens.
And though they did appear to find an inverse relationship between cortisol and SIgA, it is almost certainly random noise, or lab error, because numerous studies in animals and human subjects have consistently found that acute stress transiently increases SIgA levels in saliva. Chronic stress is associated with lower levels, but chronic stress impairs immune function through mechanisms more varied and significant than specifically just a reduction in SIgA. Again, SIgA levels have never been accepted as a marker of overall immune function but have been used as a marker of stress.
The bottom line is that the results of Lynn’s study were almost certainly spurious and couldn’t have answered his question anyway. It was, to put it bluntly, garbage. His approach needed to change.
Narrator: “His approach would not change.”
That was 2016. In 2019, when I wrote my original post, Lynn had published a follow-up study in an attempt to replicate his meaningless findings. This time, 25 subjects were recruited and pre and post tattoo saliva samples were collected for measuring SIgA, cortisol, and an inflammatory marker. As I wrote in my previous post, the results did not shed much light on the situation:
So in this small study, they found that some of the subjects had higher levels of SIgA after getting a tattoo. Remember, in the previous study they all had decreased levels. This supports the notion that it’s all just random noise rather than that the immune system was somehow boosted. The claim that elevated SIgA levels, even if directly caused by the tattoo, would play a role in non-mucosal surface healing or general health goes against the basic scientific understanding of what these antibodies actually do in our bodies.
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/tattoos-wont-boost-your-immune-system/
Lynn would claim that the new study bolstered his belief that tattoos have immune system benefits and even added improved wound healing and general health to the list. His language in an article he wrote at the time came very close to comparing tattoos to vaccinations:
Tattooing seems to exert a priming effect: That’s what biologists call it when naive immune cells are exposed to their specific antigen and differentiate into antibodies that remain in the bloodstream for many years. Each tattoo prepares the body to respond to the next.
https://theconversation.com/untangling-tattoos-influence-on-immune-response-121852
In that 2019 article, Lynn hinted at the future by mentioning an ongoing study involving 50 subjects. Nothing of much importance happened in the world for a while after that except for Taylor Swift becoming the embodiment of Satan. Fast forward to 2024 when, last week, I randomly had an unprovoked memory of this topic and decided to see what had become of Professor Lynn and his research into the health benefits of tattoos.
I found that in April of 2023, Parade Magazine had published an article on the subject for no apparent reason that I could find, as it only mentions the 2016 and 2019 studies I’ve already discussed. It is apparent, however, that Lynn had continued to expand on his belief system despite the lack of scientific plausibility or any new supporting research, and more clearly compared tattoos with vaccines:
The dermal injury of getting the tattoo and the pigment left in the skin—in both cases, we are purposefully injuring ourselves, but in a way that is analogous to exercise,” Dr. Lynn says. “We are tearing muscles to build muscles. We are stimulating the immune system to have a more robust reaction.”
Dr. Lynn says the research also draws comparisons between tattoos and vaccinations. “[With vaccines], we introduce a challenge, cause our immune system to turn on, and when the immune system turns back off, it remains somewhat vigilant,” Dr. Lynn says. “It creates new antibodies in circulation at a higher rate. Our immune system is adaptive. It interacts with our appraisal of stress.”
“What we see with novel or first tattoos is that cortisol, a stress hormone, goes up, while immunoglobulin A goes down,” says Dr. Lynn. “For people with relatively more tattoo experience [these reactions vary].”
(Clay here. Again, many studies have previously and since found that acute stress raises SIgA levels. The varied reactions that he found were likely due to lab error or random noise in the data and do not represent any actual trends in human physiology.)
In a way, you can think of tattoos as “training” the immune system. “One of the things that training the immune system is useful for is dealing with the topsy-turvy up and down of life,” says Dr. Lynn. “Even if the tattoo lasts a long time and is putting stress on the body, the immune response is happening immediately and throughout the experience. That suggests there is a priming effect [between tattoos and the immune system].”
https://parade.com/health/tattoos-immune-system
Thankfully Lynn doesn’t actually go so far as to claim that getting a tattoo is truly equivalent to a vaccine when it comes to preventing disease:
“I would never say anything like that,” Dr. Lynn says. “What we are saying is that there is an effect. Is it clinically significant? Not by itself. It is an extra influence on our health and well-being. What I usually say is, ‘If you want to be healthy, there are a hundred ways under the sun to be healthy. Tattooing is part of the lifestyle…here are additional benefits.'”
But even this milquetoast support of potential medical benefits from tattooing isn’t reasonable. Later in the article, and to his credit, Lynn clearly states that tattoos are not something he recommends to people with autoimmune disease to “strengthen the immune system” and mentions that his wife has lupus. We don’t generally think of these conditions as being caused by a weakened immune system, but rather one that is confused and causing damage from friendly fire, though treatment of these ailments often does consists of medications that do suppress the immune system. This adds to my concern that Lynn is way out of his depth here and should be relying on actual experts for help, which brings us to the unfortunate involvement of an actual expert. Sigh.
In the Parade Magazine article, there are several quotes from Dr. Sharon Nachman, who is the Chief of the Division of Pediatric Infectious Disease at Stony Brook Children’s Hospital, Vice Dean for Research at the Renaissance School of Medicine at Stony Brook, and she directs their Office of Clinical Trials. So she is an actual expert and should have no problem seeing just how bad these two studies are. She should be highly skeptical of the entire premise that tattoos improve immune function.
That isn’t what happened, and I am honestly baffled. She says the following in regards to the 2019 study:
“It’s a great paper,” said Dr. Sharon Nachman, MD, the chief of the division of pediatric infectious diseases at Stony Brook Children’s Hospital. “It looks at patients with a long history of tattoos. It looks at those who got tattoos versus those who didn’t. Did they have lower infections or rates of common illness? The answer is yes…as part of immune functioning, they were better able to handle infections.”
None of that happened. Neither the 2016 or 2019 study, and these two studies represented the totality of the literature on the subject of immune boosting tattoos at the time, did anything of the sort as I’ve explained in painful detail. So she either didn’t read the study, and perhaps regurgitated the take presented to her by the articles writer, or she was horribly misquoted. I truly hope that it was the latter, but frankly both are terrible.
In regards to people with autoimmune conditions getting tattoos in the hopes of seeing a benefit, she appropriately states that we don’t know if the risk outweighs the benefit, which seems to imply that there might be some benefit. She calls it an important scientific question and calls for more research. I disagree and I’m still confused as to how we got here. She does at least point out that tattoos should be done in a safe and hygienic fashion.
I was disappointed to learn that Lynn’s claims continues to be given an undeserved patina of academic legitimacy when I came across a September 2023 study. Sadly it is essentially just a rehash of the same flawed approach used in the first two experiments and used saliva samples left over from the 2019 study and a 2022 study that I believe is the one Lynn had referenced as ongoing back in 2019. 40 samples from subjects with with varying degrees of tattoo experience taken both before and after getting some fresh ink were included, only this time they focused on something called a bacteria killing activity (BKA) assay as a marker of overall immune function instead of SIgA.
Their results, as expected, were a mess. First off, the BKA assay is something that the 2nd author of the paper developed and is not a validated marker of general immune function. And there were problems with sample contamination that they just ignored. They also lost or didn’t have enough remaining saliva to perform the assay in a number of subjects. And what they found completely contradicted the earlier two (really 3 according to the discussion but I can’t access the 2022 study to see for myself) studies using SIgA, so they threw them under the bus and claimed that the BKA assay just works better. Convenient.
In fact, their failure to replicated the supposed immune suppression seen in tattoo naive subjects in this study completely undermines the entire hypothesis this was all based on. Acute stress is supposed to cause a transient insult that, with repeated exposures over time, teaches the body to be stronger like when Daniel-San learned karate by waxing Mr. Miyagi’s car. They also failed to find, using their unproven saliva assay, that subjects with more tattoo experience have a more robust immune system prior to getting the new tattoo. But they just forged ahead, cherry picking and nudging the goalposts a bit so that they could claim some degree of success:
We found that dermal stress of tattooing results in increased innate immune activity that is influenced by previous tattoo experience, supporting the model of tattooing as a phenotypic gambit. Tattooing may therefore enhance evolutionary fitness signals.
Garbage all the way down.
Of note, there was a March 2023 article in The Atlantic entitled “Tattoos Do Odd Things to the Immune System”. Unfortunately, I was unable to access it to see if this topic was covered with more appropriate skepticism, but I’m not hopeful considering the title. If anyone can get a hold of it, please let me know in the comments.

Dry Drowning
What is dry drowning, and should we worry?
Harriet Hall on July 7, 2020
Link

Parenting websites have been alarming parents about the possibility that their children might experience dry drowning or delayed drowning, with warnings like these:
a child can seem fine after getting out of the water, but start to have trouble breathing an hour—or even 24 hours—later.
Your child is in the pool, she swallows a bit of water and goes on playing—but a few hours later, she’s in the hospital on life support.
The Scary Mommy website warns parents that:
Not all instances of drowning happen right away. Sometimes your child may go under water or unintentionally swallow water while swimming, and then only experience symptoms of drowning hours or days later. And yes, sometimes these symptoms – especially if not addressed right away – can lead to fatalities.
Another website reports:
The phenomenon of “dry drowning” first gained national attention in 2008 through the tragic story of John Jackson, who was a 10-year-old boy with autism and ADHD. John accidentally inhaled some water while swimming in a pool. At the time, he coughed for a bit, but then calmed down. As the day went on, however, he started to seem a bit off—he had two poop accidents in his pants and he was overly tired, eventually putting himself to sleep earlier than usual. When his mom checked on him later, he was unresponsive and, ultimately, died.
This was not technically a case of “dry drowning,” and the child had other health problems that may have contributed to his death.
The CDC tells us “drowning kills more children 1-4 than anything else except birth defects,” so water safety is a serious concern for parents; but so-called “dry drowning” is rare. Parents have been frightened by inaccurate, alarmist messages.
What is dry drowning?
The idea originated when a small percentage of autopsies found no water in the lungs of people who had obviously died because of submersion in water. When water first enters the airway, it can trigger a spasm of the larynx, preventing water from going beyond and entering the lungs. Even a small amount of water in the lungs can destroy surfactant and lead to pulmonary edema. It is the lack of oxygen that causes harm, not the water itself.
Drowning requires going under water; it is not caused by just swallowing water or playing in water. “Dry drowning” is not accepted medical terminology, and it is used inappropriately by the media. Other unacceptable terms are “near drowning”, “secondary drowning”, and “delayed drowning”. A World Congress on Drowning and numerous professional organizations have agreed that the medically appropriate terminology is:
    • Fatal drowning
    • Nonfatal drowning with injury
    • Nonfatal drowning without injury
A 2017 article in Emergency Medicine News reported:
Earlier this month a young child died following days of vomiting. He had been in shallow water in a Texas dike about a week before his death. The story was picked up as an alleged case of a rare condition called dry drowning or secondary drowning…The media accounts went viral, spreading significant fear in parenting communities and among those learning about these alleged conditions from the news or social media…Unfortunately, there is significant misinformation in the media reports of this case, and we hope this evidence-based discussion of drowning and the best practice medical care of drowning patients will help set the record straight.
The authors go on to urge the media to use proper medical terminology and to abandon the terms near, dry, wet, delayed, and secondary drownings. They emphasize that anyone with respiratory symptoms after being in water should seek medical care, and they point out that “There has never been a case published in the medical literature of a patient who received a clinical assessment, was initially without symptoms, and who later deteriorated and died.”
Conclusion: “dry drowning” is a myth
        ◦ Rather than worrying unnecessarily about “dry drowning”, parents should worry about prevention. They should be encouraged to practice water safety, to include adult supervision, swimming lessons, life jackets and flotation devices, fences around home pools, and learning CPR.

Nurse Practitioner Pushes Dubious Aesthetic Treatments
Nurse practitioner aggressively advertises a plethora of aesthetic treatments, some of which are dubious. It’s legal, but is it ethical?
Harriet Hall on November 19, 2019
Link


Larson Medical Aesthetics, an organization with three locations, is run by a nurse practitioner named Margaret Larson. It is being promoted through full-page ads in a local daily newspaper, the Tacoma News Tribune. A typical ad that appeared right before Halloween screamed “Spooktacular Special” and asked “Are You Ready for Holiday Parties, Gatherings, and All the Group Photos? Get ready with the aesthetic experts at Larson Medical Aesthetics”, a ploy apparently designed to make readers feel insecure about their appearance. It offers a number of special deals that will expire on Halloween (4 days away). The offerings are questionable and the advertising is over the top.
The full-page ad offers:
    • Boo for Two: if you bring someone special for services and purchase $100 or more, you will get a Spooktacular Gift Bag.
    • BooTox: 20 units of Botox for $199 and discounts on future purchases ($10 instead of the usual $14.)
    • 20% off on Aladdin’s 3 wishes for Juvederm: lift the cheeks with 2 Voluma, plump the lips with one Volbella, soften the smile lines with 2 Vollure, then receive a complimentary Advanced Peel and lots of BD points.
    • 20% off on Thor Hair Restoration Package: 4 PRP treatments, a Thermadome Laser Helmet and PhytoMultiGen supplement, and a turbo-charged HydraFacial.
    • 20% off on the Captain America Package to “regenerate a strong jawline or more defined for others”: PRP-enhanced Bellafill Jawline Sculpting Treatment with a complimentary Bellafill syringe and Universal Peel. Add 2 Kybella treatments to reduce the hard to get rid of double chin and receive 1 kit free ($1200 savings).
    • 20% off on the Wonder Woman Package, a 2-month plan that includes DermaPlaning, HydraFacial with Collagen Booster and SkinPen Microneedling and the Larson Recovery Kit, with one complimentary PRP treatment.
    • Add PRP to most treatments for $350 and release your regenerative (healing) powers. Can be added to Bellafill Lift of Face, Neck or Derriere, Feminine Rejuvenation GAINSWave ED Treatment, CO2 Laser Resurfacing of the face and Decolletage Resurfacing, and SkinPen Microneedling Scar and Texture Treatment.
And there’s a Cool Night Out Event where you can learn about CoolSculpting and enjoy refreshments, live demos, personal consultations, and a chance to win a free CoolSculpting treatment. Attendees will get special pricing and 10 free units of Botox with gift bag.
Wow! Are you impressed? Does it make you want to call right now? In case you’re not impressed enough, a “News” footnote informs you that Margaret has received the prestigious BellaDiamond Award from Suneva Medical for being the Top US Bellafill provider and injector of Bellafill, and in 2018 she was recognized as The Top World Bellafill Injector, providing over 18,000 Bellafill Treatments!
None of this tells me what I want to know: what are these treatments? Have they been scientifically studied and shown to work? If they work, how well do they work? What do they cost? Are there risks or side effects? How do they compare to other available treatments?
What does the evidence say about these treatments?
Microneedling is a minimally invasive procedure that creates hundreds of tiny puncture wounds; the micro injuries are thought to stimulate the body’s natural wound healing processes, increasing cell turnover and stimulating the production of collagen and elastin. The literature supporting microneedling is sparse, with few large or high-quality studies; and is hard to interpret because assessment measures differ and studies frequently combine it with PRP and other modalities. A systematic review in 2018 “positioned microneedling as a safe and effective therapeutic option for the treatment of scars and wrinkles” but added that “The current literature does show some methodological shortcomings, and further research is required to truly establish microneedling as an evidence-based therapeutic option for treating scars, wrinkles and other skin conditions.” A study comparing topical minoxidil plus microneedling to minoxidil alone for androgenetic alopecia concluded that the addition of microneedling increased hair count and patient satisfaction but the response was not cosmetically significant. In a systematic review of microneedling for acne scarring all the studies showed some improvement but they concluded that more studies were needed to compare it to other minimally invasive treatments.
CoolSculpting or cryolipolysis is intended to remove areas of body fat. It freezes the fat cells but does not damage other cells. It takes 4-6 months for the fat cells to leave the body, eventually producing a 20% reduction in the area of fat. Fat can re-accumulate, and long-term studies are lacking. Paradoxical adipose hyperplasia is a complication once thought to be rare but now estimated to occur in 1 out of every 4,000 treatment cycles.
Bellafill is an FDA-approved dermal filler combining microsphere enhanced bovine collagen with the local anesthetic lidocaine. An allergy test is required 4 weeks prior to its first use. It can cause minor side effects and bruising, and, less commonly, lumps or granulomas. FDA-reported side effects included blindness associated with dorsal nasal injections. The microspheres are not absorbed and can only be removed surgically. User reviews include a few success stories but many more horror stories and reports of ineffectiveness.
Juvederm is a hyaluronic acid filler approved by the FDA, designed to help address the facial signs of aging. Juvederm Voluma increases the size of the cheeks; Juvederm Vollure fills out wrinkles and smile lines around the mouth and nose; Juvederm Volbella is for lip enhancement. The average cost is $620. Results can last 1-2 years.
Kybella is a fat-dissolving injection of deoxycholic acid approved by the FDA for the treatment of double chins. It was welcomed enthusiastically by dermatologists and plastic surgeons, but now it is facing a backlash. It requires multiple treatments, results are inconsistent, and a course of treatment costs over $6,000. It causes soreness and swelling (sometimes described as bullfrog-like) that can linger for weeks.
PhytoMulti is a dietary supplement containing a laundry list of vitamins, minerals, and phytochemicals that claims to recharge, nourish, and defend cells like no other supplement. It has antioxidant properties and has been shown to affect biomarkers but has not undergone clinical testing for efficacy and safety.
Theradome (not “Thermadome” as the ad says) helmets use lasers to treat the scalp for hair loss. There have been some positive studies of lasers for hair restoration, but more research is needed. Long-term safety and effectiveness have not yet been established.
Femilift is a laser treatment offered for vaginal tightening and reduction of urine leakage. The CO2 laser devices are FDA-approved, but not for “feminine rejuvenation”. Such treatments have been strongly discouraged by the FDA, and the FDA has issued warning letters to several companies. An article in The Guardian called it “a depressing load of nonsense“.
It’s legal, but is it ethical?
My first reaction was “a nurse practitioner”? But I soon learned that Washington State is one of twenty states that allow nurse practitioners to practice independently, without physician supervision. They are authorized to run their own aesthetic practices and to inject Botox if they have been properly trained. So what Larson is doing is legal.
But the way she is advertising makes me very uncomfortable. It may be creating medical “wants” and unreasonable expectations instead of responding to real medical needs. Some of these treatments are not medically indicated. Some report high rates of patient satisfaction but have drawbacks and only minimal objective improvements. All are very expensive. Important details are not divulged, and I worry that the average layperson may be misled and pressured into treatments that they might not choose with true informed consent. Of course, I don’t know what they are told once they make an appointment, but it would be in the interests of the aestheticians to give biased information to persuade customers to buy.
We don’t see similar advertising by mainstream medical doctors. Aggressive and deceptive advertising tactics are discouraged by medical ethics. Mainstream doctors who are offering medically necessary, evidence-based treatments like diabetes management or orthopedic management of broken bones can advertise to let the public know who they are and that they are available for consultations, but there is no need for them to hype their treatments with exaggerated claims, special offers, and discounts. (Imagine: your blood glucose levels will be spooktacular and if you call in the next 48 hours you will get a free diabetic cookbook! Or: 20% off on x-rays and a free cast, limited time offer!)
I showed the full-page ad to a non-medical friend. After perusing it, he said it impressed him as “odd”. I agree, but I probably would have chosen a different adjective.

Can A One-Minute Cure Really Heal Virtually All Diseases?
The author of this book claims to have found a one-minute cure that will heal virtually all diseases. The claim is ludicrous, and is not supported by any evidence.
Harriet Hall on June 18, 2019
Link

I guess medicine as we know it might as well quit. We don’t need it any more. Madison Cavanaugh has discovered The Secret to Healing Virtually All Diseases and shared the secret in the 2008 book The One-Minute Cure.
And now for something a bit different. Many of you have been reading the Science-Based Medicine blog for long enough to have learned how we go about evaluating health claims. It’s time for a little audience participation in the form of a quiz to test your critical thinking skills.
Take the test
Read the following paragraph from the description of Cavanaugh’s book and answer these two questions:
     1.  Do you think the statements in the paragraph are true?
     2.  Can you guess what the “powerful healing modality” might be?
The One-Minute Cure reveals a remarkable, scientifically proven natural therapy that creates an environment within the body where disease cannot thrive, thus enabling the body to cure itself of disease. Over 6,100 articles in European scientific literature have attested to the effectiveness of this safe, inexpensive and powerful healing modality, and has been administered by an estimated 15,000 European doctors, naturopaths and homeopaths to more than 10 million patients in the past 70 years to successfully treat practically every known disease — including but not limited to cancer, AIDS, heart disease, diabetes, Alzheimer’s Disease, Parkinson’s Disease. hepatitis, multiple sclerosis, herpes, Rheumatoid Arthritis and asthma.
Answer the questions before you scroll down to compare your impressions to mine and to learn the identity of the powerful healing modality.
How did you do?
This is a self-graded test. You can check how you did.
    • Did you notice that no supporting evidence was offered? As Christopher Hitchens said, “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.”
    • Did you figure out that the miraculous treatment was hydrogen peroxide?
    • Did you wonder how a single treatment could be effective for such a wide variety of diseases, diseases with completely different etiologies and mechanisms?
    • Did you wonder if the author was a trustworthy expert?
    • Did you try to look up Madison Cavanaugh and discover that there was no information about scientific or medical credentials and no other publications listed for that author?
    • Did you do enough research to figure out that Cavanaugh was recommending 35% food grade hydrogen peroxide, starting with one drop in a glass of distilled water three times a day and working up to 25 drops? (I guess the “one minute” is the time it takes to mix the dilution each time, or to drink the mixture; but that would add up to many minutes over a long period of time, making the title deceptive.)
    • Did you discover that the regimen includes not eating for 3 hours before and an hour after taking each dose, and you’re supposed to stay on a maintenance dose forever?
    • Did you look for those 6,100 articles? Did you find any of them? (I found that many articles about hydrogen peroxide, but not a single article about its effectiveness for any of the diseases listed here.)
    • Did you wonder how they arrived at the estimate of 15,000 doctors, naturopaths, and homeopaths? Did you wonder who they were? Were you able to identify any of them? Was the treatment promoted on their websites? Were you impressed that homeopaths were using it? Did you notice the logical fallacy (appeal to popularity)?
    • Do you accept that 10 million patients were successfully treated? Would there be any way to verify that number? Did you wonder how many patients were successfully treated for each of the diseases listed? Did you wonder if the diagnoses of those patients were correct? Did you wonder how many patients were unsuccessfully treated?
    • Did you look for clinical studies published in peer-reviewed journals? Did you find any? I didn’t. No controlled studies, not even published case studies.
    • Did you notice they were allegedly treated over a 70-year period? Did you wonder why the effectiveness of the treatment is not widely known after such a long time?
    • Instead of looking for confirmation and succumbing to confirmation bias, did you look for sources that disagreed, that said hydrogen peroxide therapy was not safe or effective?
None of this makes sense
Think about it for a minute. If they had been able to reliably cure patients of almost all diseases for all those years, or even just since the book was published in 2008, can you imagine that we all wouldn’t know about it by now and be using it? No conspiracy is capable of suppressing the evidence of 10 million patients cured of diseases like cancer and Alzheimer’s or of suppressing their bragging rights. Patients and providers would not want to keep it secret; they all have friends and relatives with those diseases; they would want to spread the word and let others be cured. The news should have been all over the headlines. And surely someone would have won a Nobel Prize for such a paradigm-changing scientific discovery. The whole paragraph is laughable.
The rationale is pseudoscientific
The premise is that almost all diseases are anaerobic and cannot exist in the presence of oxygen. This is simply not true. It is a ridiculous extrapolation from a grain of sort-of-truth, the Warburg effect. Warburg studied cancer metabolism and made some useful discoveries; but his idea that oxygen would inhibit the growth of cancer cells proved wrong, and there is no way that ingesting hydrogen peroxide could increase the exposure of cancer cells to oxygen. Arterial blood is already 98% saturated with oxygen; it can’t carry much more, and hydrogen peroxide couldn’t supply more.
Testimonials are easy to find
There are numerous videos online with testimonials from people who have read the book and used its protocols and have noticed amazing results like complete clearing of their psoriasis.
Warnings are easy to find, too
Hydrogen peroxide therapy has been criticized on Quackwatch, Science-Based Medicine, and numerous other websites. There is even a video explaining the science that invalidates the pseudoscientific claims. Hydrogen peroxide is converted to water and oxygen in the stomach and the oxygen is burped out, not absorbed into the body. It does not raise body oxygen levels. The amount (a few drops added to a glass of distilled water) is negligible; adding this amount of 35% hydrogen peroxide to water doesn’t even bring it up to the level of the 3% solution sold as a topical disinfectant.
In 2018 Karen Savage wrote an article explaining how “ Peddlers of ‘FoodGrade’ Hydrogen Peroxide Exploit the Sick and the Desperate“. She reproduced an advertisement claiming benefits for a long list of diseases, including Alzheimer’s, cancer, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, food allergies, and cirrhosis. She quoted an FDA spokesperson:
No one has presented any evidence that hydrogen peroxide taken internally has any medical value. In fact, consuming hydrogen peroxide in the manner touted by these websites could lead to tragic results.
She went on to say:
The ingestion of hydrogen peroxide… has not been approved by the FDA to cure, treat, prevent, or mitigate any disease, so vendors who market hydrogen peroxide for ingestion — or with claims that it can cure or prevent cancer, AIDS, or other ailments by whatever means — are in violation of FDA regulations and they risk criminal prosecution.
She reported that there are thirty cases a year of hydrogen peroxide poisoning, sometimes resulting in death; and she covered the difficulties of taking any regulatory actions.
The FDA has been working to stop companies selling high strength hydrogen peroxide products from making illegal medical claims. In 2006 they warned consumers
not to purchase or to use high-strength hydrogen peroxide products, including a product marketed as ‘35 Percent Food Grade Hydrogen Peroxide,’ for medicinal purposes because they can cause serious harm or death when ingested. FDA recommends that consumers who are currently using high-strength hydrogen peroxide stop immediately and consult their health care provider.
Customer reviews
It is interesting (indeed, highly entertaining) to read the many customer reviews on the Amazon website. There are testimonials about improved eyesight, resolution of “minor arthritis,” warming of cold hands and feet, hearing 10% improved, white tongue turned pink, cancers cured (melanoma, brain tumor, lymphoma), more energy, better sleep, wonderful dreams (!?), dialysis down from 3 to 2 times a week, off all medications. One said it cured his skin cancer – before he could get a biopsy to find out if it was cancer! One user had tried a lower concentration and claimed that the preservatives in the 3% product made his kidneys hurt.
Several commenters said it didn’t work, was hard to do, and required a lifelong commitment. Several reported bad side effects. One said:
There was no data to back up the claims, no references cited, and no personal experiences cited. There was no information about the author’s education or experience treating patients.
Several said it was a short book (really just a pamphlet), overpriced, with no information that wasn’t readily available on the Internet for free. One said it was mostly a rant against the pharmaceutical industry. Many advised against buying the book. Some called it a rip-off and a hoax. Several called it dangerous. One pointed out false statements in the book like “in some especially polluted areas [oxygen] is as low as 10%.”
Conclusion: Pull the other one!
When a proposed treatment is untested or inadequately tested, I generally call for controlled studies and promise to follow the evidence. But in this case, I think we already have enough evidence to conclude that it doesn’t work, can’t possibly work, and is likely to cause harm. I think doing controlled studies to test the efficacy of Cavanaugh’s protocol would be a big mistake, a waste of money and a risk to the health of participants. You can call me biased; I am biased in favor of science and reason.
These claims for hydrogen peroxide deserve some kind of “worst ever” award. My immediate reaction was “pull the other one!” I find it hard to comprehend how anyone could believe such arrant nonsense. It’s a sad commentary on the thinking skills of the general public. It shows that common sense is not common. I despair!

Integrative Psychiatry
Alternative medicine is not just restricted to physical health. Practitioners have insinuated themselves into mental health as well, to the detriment of patients and science.
Jesse Luke on August 4, 2017
Link


Psychiatry hasn’t had the best reputation for a long time. The practice has sat under a cloud made up of poor understanding, stigma and many dangerous, often cruel treatments. Psychiatric patients are truly among the most vulnerable and underserved in the field of medicine, and many struggle on a daily basis. To make matters worse, there is a massive cadre of integrative practitioners, proponents, and related companies who are promoting and practicing what they call integrative psychiatry.
(Note that integrative psychiatry should not be confused with integrated psychiatry, which is merely the placement of psychiatrists into other patient care environments to increase access.)
A (very) brief history of mental illness

From ancient times until the middle of the 20th century there have been numerous pseudo-psychiatric treatments based upon religion, superstition and/or poor science. These include trepanation – drilling holes in the skull to release evil spirits (still practiced by some, believed to increase blood flow); exorcisms – also to rid the body of spirits; insulin shock therapy that would induce hypoglycemic comas; and the infamous lobotomy (leucotomy), which surgically isolated the prefrontal cortex. Antonio Moniz controversially received the Nobel Prize for the latter in 1949. However, for many conditions, the only treatments were psychoanalysis and far too often, long-term confinement in institutes across countries, some used for centuries (a few still exist as modern hospitals).
In the 1950s major psychiatric medications were introduced to the field: chlorpromazine, the first anti-psychotic, and imipramine, the first antidepressant; many others followed quickly. Through this new- found ability to control conditions, patients gained better control of their lives. A large movement of deinstitutionalization followed in the 60s, moving care from institutes to local centers and private practice. Psychiatry became more mainstream very quickly, consultations occurred more, and people became less afraid of the profession and its treatments. In the following decades further advances were made with the increased usage of the more recent benzodiazepines to replace the more dangerous barbiturates, and SSRIs to replace tricyclics and MAO-inhibitors, that often came with severe side effects and sometimes severe lifestyle restrictions, to treat depression. The asylum and lobotomy days are fortunately behind us, though there still exists a need for psychiatric hospitals and in unique, resistant cases the use of older drugs, electro-convulsive therapy, and sometimes involuntary admittance.
Though compared to the past the contemporary treatment of mental illness is far more advanced and humane, there are still major issues. The medications available are far from perfect. Research funding in the field typically falls far behind that of other diseases, and undertreatment is still a significant problem. The WHO estimates that more than 300 million people suffer from depression worldwide. With less than 50% treated (imagine that for other possibly fatal diseases), it is the current leading cause of disability worldwide. That is just depression though; if we were to factor in the number of people suffering from other mental illness in the world the number would likely be over a billion. With these numbers it must also be noted that the suffering endured is truly immeasurable; as a result, a patient’s desire for help is often just as great as those with cancer or other serious illnesses. Their mental states, often already fragile, unfamiliarity with mental illness, and desperation will allow predispose them to grasp at any hope, and integrative medicine stands ready to offer the illusion of a helping hand. Psychiatric illness is serious and should be taken seriously by society. Patients need science-based psychiatry, not more delusions.
Integration of CAM I – The nonsense
The methods employed by integrative psychiatry, like integrative medicine, can be roughly divided into two types: re-branding conventional advice as “alternative”, and promoting unproven and unscientific treatment options. Many of the purported treatments will be familiar to regular readers and well-researched medical sceptics, but there are a few that are quite rare and fringe, even in CAM. Integrative psychiatry doesn’t have any true centralization by itself like functional medicine does. As a result, practitioners fall under the broad aegis of integrative medicine, each choosing any point on the spectrum they like and defining the practice as they see fit.
The 2015 copy of Kaplan & Sadock’s Synopsis of Psychiatry (not to be confused with their Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry) has a chapter on CAM treatments. The book, and its ten prior editions, are mainstream and commonly used for education and reference. In the chapter devoted to CAM and integrative psychiatry, it has an extensive list of CAM options, and here I have excerpted some of the more obscure interventions, with a brief description:
    • Anthroposophically extended medicine: using “wisdom of life” to perform mental exercises that balance mind and body
    • Bates method: purportedly cures vision problems by splashing warm and cold water on the eyes, swaying, focusing on objects and thinking happy thoughts
    • Trager method: sitting in a chair for an hour or so and being guided through the unconscious mind choosing its own better movements
    • Environmental medicine: concerns about hypersensitivity and disease caused by electricity, wifi, etc. (note that there is also science-based environmental medicine and this ain’t it)
    • Ozone therapy: introducing ozone (O3) to the body in order to treat everything from cancer to AIDS. It includes drinking ozonated water and “…insufflations, in which a catheter is inserted into the rectum or vagina with ozone administered at a slow flow rate; and autohemotherapy, in which a person’s own ozonized blood is reintroduced into the body.”
    • Past life medicine: Using hypnosis to regress a person to a past life and “…the healing process is aided by contact with spiritual beings that are believed to have the ability to reverse illness and maintain health”; according to the text it is up to the psychiatrist to take the actual regression literally or figuratively
The list also includes many more, like acupuncture, chelation, chiropractic, colonic irrigation, homeopathy, naturopathy, therapeutic touch, and even shamanism.
Integration of CAM II – The rebranding
As far as rebranding is concerned, there is quite a bit – such as listing exercise as a CAM modality, as is often seen in similar writing. Tai chi and yoga are also listed separately even though they are just other forms of exercise. Nutrition is also listed as alternative, but criticizes the USDA guidelines and gives fad diets like the Atkins and Ornish diets as examples of “alternative diets”. Strikingly, the use of B-vitamins in alcoholics is also listed as alternative when it has been standard care for a while.
Biofeedback and hypnosis were not on the full list because these “modalities” are now “incorporated into standard psychiatric practice.” Both are umbrella terms that can cover many things, but neither are truly commonplace in psychiatry. Biofeedback has been experimented with by multiple fields of medicine, including psychiatry for some time now. It is, put simply, using a machine interface to provide perceptible readings on normally imperceptible bodily processes (such as blood pressure, skin conductance, or brainwaves) in an attempt to help patients monitor and control them in some way. There is evidence both for and against the intervention but considering the many different forms it can take it seems inappropriate to give such a blanket endorsement of the practice.
Hypnosis, on the other hand, is partly approved of by both the American Psychiatric Association [PDF] and the American Psychological Association. These endorsements are not, however, a blanket approval of all forms of the therapy. In fact, along with other medical organizations they condemn the practice of regression therapy with the aim of recovering repressed memories, because the likely result is actually the implantation of false memories, many taking the form of alien abductions, satanic ritual abuse, and sexual abuse. Integrative psychiatry, on the other hand, considers it to be a useful tool and encourage its use.
It may appear that the list of interventions was put in place simply to inform readers of the various forms of CAM and wasn’t an approval, but the sentence that follows the section implies otherwise:
Any of the complementary methods described in this section can be integrated into standard psychotherapeutic practice, although some lend themselves better than others.
These treatments don’t simply reside in ink though, they are in actual practice. A quick google search will reveal a tremendous number of doctors offering integrative psychiatric care, many offering phone consultations. It is likely that you can shop around for just about any alternative treatment you would like and get someone with a medical degree to condone it. This movement isn’t confined to small and individual practices, though; the Wellness Institute at the Cleveland Clinic (yes, that Cleveland Clinic) offers holistic psychotherapy that may consist of regression hypnosis, breath therapy that utilizes vibrational energy, guided imagery, and rebirthing breath that can help overcome the previous trauma of birth. UCSF offers acupuncture and ayurvedic massage among other things. It also seems that integrative psychiatry is buying into unproven diagnoses: ILADS (yes, that ILADS) has produced its own pamphlet for psychiatrists, in which it shows that nearly all psychiatric symptoms can be caused by chronic Lyme disease (yes, that chronic Lyme disease!) and mentions of it can be found on many websites.
Keeping with the forward march of CAM into mainstream medicine, the American Psychiatric Association has a dedicated “sub-specialty” devoted to integrative psychiatry. They offer a CME course through their online education center, and various webinars, and their publishing arm offers multiple books on the subject (this is the same organization that publishes the DSM).
Conclusion: Psychiatry needs more science, not less
It isn’t unfair to say that psychiatry is far from the most science-based specialty in medicine (a problem it shares with psychology and psychotherapy). The causes of many conditions are not known, and most hypotheses as to what does cause them are largely based on what effects psychiatric medications have inside the body. Researchers are working diligently in multiple fields to understand the genetic, environmental, and social causes of mental illness. Amazing progress has been made and there is a lot to come, but just because the train of science moves slowly does not give a reason to hang off the side and pick up magical cures along the track. Mental illness can often be severe and debilitating. It contributes greatly to shortened life spans, poverty, and global economic loss. It therefore must be taken extremely seriously. It is difficult now to get even basic treatment to half the people that require it. The solution requires a massive expansion of funding, outreach, and social awareness.
Adding unrealistic and fictional interventions to the field will only cause harm, and in my opinion it seems cruel for psychiatrists to be putting delusions into the heads of patients with mental illnesses. This can only be stopped through the work of an informed public. If these treatments were to enter the mainstream in significant amounts, it would be extremely difficult to push them back out. Nothing is without risk, and the risks present are simply too large. It is easy to imagine a patient with schizophrenia or depression that gets the idea their conditions can be treated simply and without medications that often come with adverse effects, especially when medication compliance is already a serious challenge in the field. Modern psychiatry isn’t great, but it helps and it is far better than what we used to have — but that’s the direction integrative psychiatry moves, towards pseudo-science and superstition harkening back to a time when psychiatrists treated their patients on personal whims and theories with no true regard for the patient. As a patient with depression and anxiety I want real science-based psychiatry, not to be propped up by a placebo that could shatter at any moment with possibly disastrous results.

Scientology’s War on Medicine
Scientology is famously anti-psychiatry, teaching its believers that psychiatry is not only bogus, but downright evil, and in its place promotes a variety of unscientific and pseudoscientific practices. However, Scientology’s war on medicine goes beyond just psychiatry.
Harriet Hall on March 24, 2015
Link

Note: The film Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief will be available on HBO starting March 29th. I haven’t seen it yet, but apparently it profiles former members who reveal details that have elicited a very angry response from the Church of Scientology. I thought I would use the occasion to reprint a SkepDoc column that originally appeared in Skeptic magazine (Volume 18: Number 3) titled “Scientology’s War on Medicine.”
Scientology has openly declared war on psychiatry and is ambivalent if not openly hostile towards the rest of medicine. Its “mind over matter” philosophy promises that attaining the “Clear” state will eliminate illness.
Recently there has been a spate of exposés of Scientology, ably reviewed by Jim Lippard on eSkeptic. They offer some shocking revelations. Defectors from Scientology have described kidnappings, deliberate lying, unnecessary deaths, human trafficking, thought control (“brainwashing”), coercion, violations of labor standards, violations of human and civil rights, and other crimes. Scientology has been protected from prosecution by its designation as a religion and its vast wealth and influence; but if even a fraction of these accusations are true, Scientology has much to answer for.
Initially people are attracted to Scientology because it provides answers. Your problems are due to past experiences holding you back. Scientology can help you deal with those problems and the upper levels will reveal the secret of life itself.
Members are audited with an E-Meter (similar to a lie detector) and one-on-one attention. The auditing process is similar to psychotherapy in that it encourages people to think about their problems and work to overcome them. In Scientology, ideas are not immaterial: they have weight and solidity. The E-Meter locates and discharges mental masses that are blocking the free flow of energy. Memories are blamed and traced back in time even into past lives. Patients keep repeating the details of the experience until they are drained of any emotional charge. Once the painful experiences and associations are drained off, there are astonishing results: asthma, headaches, arthritis, menstrual cramps, astigmatism, and ulcers simply disappear. The reactive mind is replaced by the rational mind. In one case a boy’s IQ supposedly rose from 83 to 212.
Scientology believes no memory is ever erased: every sound and smell can be completely recaptured. Even prenatal memories and past life memories remain. The fetus remembers if the mother attempted to abort it and develops psychological problems because it knows it is living with murderers. Cells are sentient and remember painful emotions. “Engrams” become a physical part of cellular structure, controlling behavior like a post-hypnotic suggestion. This understanding of memory is incompatible with current scientific knowledge.
Then there is a second stage of Scientology where people pay for ever more expensive classes, are indoctrinated into the mythology, progress up the church’s ladder of OT (Operating Thetan) levels, and may even join the elite Sea Org, signing a billion year contract.
The Scientology myth was originally a secret revealed only to those who reached the OT III level, but it is now public knowledge. The universe began 4 quadrillion years ago. Evil lord Xenu and his psychiatrist co-conspirators froze individuals (thetans), sent them to the planet Earth, dropped them into volcanoes and blew them up with hydrogen bombs. Freed from their bodies, the thetans were trapped in an electronic ribbon and subjected to brainwashing with a colossal motion picture device which implanted them with all the world religions. Free-floating thetans attach themselves to living people, as many as millions of them in a single body. These “body thetans” have to be eliminated to achieve spiritual progress. If not cleared by Scientology, these thetans will blow themselves up and destroy civilization as they have done many times before. Only Scientology can save humanity from the cycle of self-destruction.
We are all thetans (Scientology’s term for the soul), immortal spiritual beings that are incarnated in innumerable lifetimes. Auditing is not just to resolve psychological problems but to “recall to the thetan his immortality and help him relinquish his self-imposed limitations” – to emancipate a person from the laws of matter, energy, space and time (MEST). Bored thetans had created MEST universes and then forgot they weren’t real.
When you become “clear” of body thetans, you have a flawless memory able to recall anything you have ever studied; are less susceptible to diseases; rarely have accidents; and are free of neuroses, compulsions, and psychosomatic illnesses. As you progress to the higher OT levels you will be able to levitate, travel through time, control the thoughts of others by telepathy, and have total command over the material universe. With these superhuman powers you can make a traffic light turn green or emit an electric shock that can put out someone’s eyes or cut him in half.
Only one problem: there never were any “clears.” Attempted demonstrations of these powers consistently failed. When auditing was independently tested, it failed (Hubbard claimed they didn’t do it right). Auditing may indeed help people, but its results have never been validated.
As in other cults, confession and re-education are used to control thought. Past lives provide misdeeds to confess. Instead of providing consolation, confession exploits vulnerabilities and steers people into thinking about their faults. The cult keeps its victims in a suggestible state and vigorously suppresses questions and doubts. Exit costs make the prospect of leaving more painful than staying.
Scientology was invented by a science fiction writer, L. Ron Hubbard. He was a liar, fantasist, bigamist, and adulterer; charismatic, vindictive, with sexual and psychological problems that he revealed in the Affirmations, a secret memoir which the church now claims is a forgery. One ex-lover described him as manic-depressive with paranoid tendencies and delusions of grandeur. At one point, concerned that divorce would hurt his reputation, he proposed that if his wife really loved him, she should kill herself.
Hubbard began to develop his ideas in Dianetics, a book that Nobel physicist Isidor Isaac Rabi said “probably contains more promises and less evidence per page than has any publication since the invention of printing.” The book empowered people to become practitioners themselves. Hubbard said, “I’d like to start a religion. That’s where the money is.” A religion could maintain control of devotees permanently with a series of veiled revelations and levels.
Scientology discourages any use of medication. Pain and other symptoms are treated by “Assists.” For the Contact Assist you repeatedly press the injured part of the body against the object that hurt it until the pain goes away. There is also the Touch Assist; one person who was treated as a child said her mother wouldn’t stop prodding her with a finger until she said she felt better. So of course she said she did. John Travolta once did an Assist on Marlon Brando at a party; he touched Brando’s leg, both closed their eyes, and Brando said it helped.
Assists can supposedly awaken unconscious persons, eliminate boils, reduce earaches and back pain, and make a drunk sober.
At age 7, Jenna Miscavige was assigned the post of Medical Liaison Officer, responsible for treating sick children and providing vitamins to the healthy. Scientology allowed vaccinations but didn’t permit the use of medicine for the treatment of pain or fever. The church doesn’t believe in comforting children, believing they are adults in young bodies and can handle pain like an adult.
Hubbard chastised subordinates for wearing eyeglasses, tried to convince them they could see without them, and said needing them was a transgression against Scientology.
OTs should not have accidents and illnesses; when one woman developed a cold sore, she was consigned to a condition of Treason.
Hubbard had his own (untrained) medical officer. He was afraid of doctors. When a motorcycle accident left him in severe pain from broken ribs and other injuries, he refused to go to the hospital and even refused pain pills, complaining that they slowed down his heart.
Operating Thetans supposedly didn’t get sick, but L. Ron Hubbard had poor hearing, poor vision, was obese, and had numerous physical and psychological problems. His lame excuse was that he was at such a high level he couldn’t get down to the power level of a body. When he died following a stroke, they said that he didn’t die, but intentionally dropped his body to move on to a higher level of existence. He is expected to return some day. Every Scientology facility maintains an office furnished exactly as he liked, even down to a pair of slippers.
Hubbard theorized that one wealthy Scientologist was not making progress because he had taken LSD and it must still be in his system. He put him to work swabbing the decks on the Sea Org ship to sweat it out of his system. That was the beginning of the Scientology drug treatment program, Narconon.
A fundamental feature of Narconon is the Purification Rundown, a 3 week program to eliminate toxins. Patients spend up to 8 hours a day in a sauna; they exercise and take massive doses of vitamins, especially niacin. Niacin causes skin flushing and tingling sensations which they interpret as evidence of toxins being purged. One woman said Novocaine from previous dental work began to surface and her mouth went numb for 90 minutes.
Psychotic episodes were treated with the Introspection Rundown: solitary confinement, vitamins, calcium and magnesium. 1995 Lisa McPherson suffered a mental breakdown and died following 17 days of this treatment under guard in a Florida hotel. She lapsed into a coma and died en route to a hospital where there was a doctor affiliated with the church (the ambulance bypassed several closer hospitals). Church officials lied in sworn statements to police, claiming that she hadn’t been subject to an Introspection Rundown. A defector later confessed that he had destroyed incriminating documents. The medical examiner determined that the cause of death was a pulmonary embolus: a clot had formed due to the worst case of dehydration she had ever seen, following 5 days without any liquids. Church lawyers pressured her attorney, threatening a legal battle, and she changed her ruling to say the death was “accidental.” Shortly thereafter she retired and became a recluse.
One former Sea Org member said he went psychotic on OT III. He said he lost his sense of identity when he found out that thousands of individual alien beings were struggling for control of his body, trying to give him cancer or drive him insane.
One auditor was declared a “Suppressive Person” and had a nervous breakdown. Instead of treatment he was punished and made to do manual labor. He escaped, killed his wife, and committed suicide.
Anyone who questions Scientology doctrine is sent to RPF (Rehabilitation Project Force). There they are subjected to terrible living conditions and an inadequate diet, and are made to do manual labor; it has been compared to the prison camps of the Soviet Gulag. One Sea Org man was forced to shovel up asbestos in a renovation project with no protective gear, not even a mask. A woman was made to weld without protective glasses; she burned her eyes and got no medical attention at all. A severely handicapped MS patient who was unable to talk was sent to RPF.
Medical treatment is often cruel and inadequate. A woman who had incapacitating migraines kept auditing herself on the E-Meter in lieu of treatment, because she felt responsible for her pain. A little deaf mute girl was isolated in the Sea Org ship’s chain locker for a week because Hubbard thought it might cure her deafness. Yvonne Gillham, a Sea Org member, died of a brain tumor that would have been operable with earlier diagnosis. She blamed herself for her symptoms and refused to take pain meds because it might interfere with her auditing.
Scientologists are persuaded to wean themselves off any medications. John Travolta’s son was taken off his seizure meds, which may have contributed to his death. A young man taking Lexapro was labeled as a drug addict and his father was ordered to lock his son’s Lexapro in the trunk of his car. The patient killed himself with his father’s pistol. The case was dismissed for lack of evidence.
Brooke Shields got through post-partum depression with the help of antidepressants. Tom Cruise erupted with fury on a talk show, dissing psychiatry and saying she should have treated her depression with diet and exercise.
Despite their aversion to prescription drugs, Scientologists are curiously gullible about alternative medicine. John Travolta is enthusiastic about bee pollen. David Miscavige, the current president, follows the Blood Type Diet and takes his personal chiropractor along when he travels. Hubbard invented Dianazene, a mixture of nicotinic acid and vitamins taken daily with milk and chocolate to cure cancer and sunburns. He recommended a baby formula of boiled barley and corn syrup that he picked up in Roman days in a former lifetime. He was fanatical about taking vitamins.
Hubbard blamed psychiatrists for helping Xenu commit genocide 5 billion years ago. Scientologists hold psychiatrists responsible for modern wars, racism, ethnic cleansing, and terrorism, including the Holocaust, apartheid, and 9/11. Hubbard called psychiatry the sole cause of decline in the universe. He said if psychiatrists “had the power to torture and kill everyone, they would do so…they are psychotic criminals…” He accused them of trying to institute world government by manipulating human behavior. Scientologists accused Osama bin Laden’s deputy, a “psychiatrist,” (actually a general surgeon) of controlling his thoughts. Another “psychiatrist” who allegedly masterminded the Madrid train bombings was actually a used-car salesman who had nothing to do with the incident. Scientology maintains the exhibit “Psychiatry: An Industry of Death” in Hollywood, featuring errors of psychiatry like madhouses, lobotomies, electric shock, and drugs for spurious diagnoses. Scientology aims to eliminate psychiatry in all its forms, claiming that no mental diseases have ever been proven to exist.
When TIME magazine criticized Scientology, they claimed Eli Lilly had ordered the article in retribution for the damage Scientology had caused to their “killer drug Prozac,” which supposedly causes people to commit mass murder and suicide.
Scientology lobbyists even got legislation passed in Florida that would hold schoolteachers criminally liable for just suggesting to parents that kids might have a mental health condition such as ADD. Fortunately the governor vetoed it.
Hubbard claimed to have obtained a perfect understanding of human nature by self-examination and to have an exact science. Nonsense! There is no science in Scientology. Crispian Jago has created The Venn Diagram of Irrational Nonsense: overlapping circles for quackery bollocks, religious bollocks, pseudoscientific bollocks, and paranormal bollocks; he put Scientology at the center where all these overlap. I agree: that’s exactly where it belongs.
Note: My source for much of this information is Going Clear: Scientology, Hollywood, and the Prison of Belief by Lawrence Wright. Further details and full references can be found in the book.

Eminent Harvard psychologist, mother of positive psychology, New Age quack?
James Coyne on November 16, 2014
Link

Be less curious about people and more curious about ideas.– Marie Curie’s advice to journalists
Harvard psychologist Ellen Langer was on CBS This Morning News explaining plans for a psychosocial intervention study with women with Stage IV metastatic breast cancer. The project would attempt to shrink women’s tumors by shifting their mental perspective back to before they were diagnosed.Seeing her on TV unsettled me because I had just supplied a journalist with quotes for his article in the New York Times about Langer. I hadn’t been following her recently. Instead I focused on her now-famous study from the 70s. Langer had claimed that giving nursing home residents a plant for which they were responsible cut their mortality by half (the nursing home residents, not the plant), compared to residents whose plants were attended by staff. The paper continues to get uncritical coverage in the media and in introductory psychology texts.
I looked up the Times article after seeing CBS This Morning News, and it accurately quoted me:
The study that arguably made Langer’s name — the plant study with nursing-home patients — wouldn’t have “much credibility today, nor would it meet the tightened standards of rigor,” says James Coyne, professor emeritus of psychology at the University of Pennsylvania medical school and a widely published bird dog of pseudoscience. (Though, as Coyne also acknowledges, “that is true of much of the work of the ’70s, including my own concerning depressed persons depressing others.”) Langer’s long-term contributions, Coyne says, “will be seen in terms of the thinking and experimenting they encouraged.”
However, the quote from me was the single discordant note in a longread article singing the praises of Langer’s medical studies in which:
Results were almost too good. They beggared belief. “It sounded like Lourdes,” Langer said.
The study providing plants to nursing home residents had a key role in shaping her thinking:
To Langer, this was evidence that the biomedical model of the day — that the mind and the body are on separate tracks — was wrongheaded.
In the CBS News interview, Langer explained further:
CBS Anchor Gayle King: What is your theory? How does it work?
Langer: The mind-body unity theory. Right now this problem around forever is “how do you get from this fuzzy thing called a thought to the body?” Although everybody knows there is an effect. Walking down the street, the wind blows in your face, you get startled, your blood pressure increases, your house, and so on, till you see that it is only been a leaf. And so I said, well, let’s forget about how you get from one to the other… And see those as just words, mind and body. You put the mind and body back together and anything you putting into the mind you necessarily putting into the body.
I had been familiar with only one side of Ellen Langer’s career. She had done a number of famous psychology experiments, sometimes loosely controlled and extravagantly interpreted, but nonetheless respectable. But in the article and TV interview she comes across as a New Age quack. I learned elsewhere in the Times article that Deepak Chopra:
credits Langer with a profound influence on his thinking as a young doctor, and later as an author and lecturer on spirituality and mind-body medicine.
(You can find interviews of Langer by Chopra here and here)
And Langer has been labeled as the mother of positive psychology:
Tal Ben-Shahar, who taught a popular undergraduate course at Harvard on the subject until 2008, calls Langer “the mother of positive psychology,” by virtue of her early work that anticipated the field.
I dug out Langer’s 1978 nursing home study, confirmed my skepticism, and blogged about it. Any mortality effect in this small study was likely spurious and disappeared anyway in an obscure erratum that has received none of the attention of the original report.But let’s get back to the medical claims for which she claims support from 40 years of personal research.
Diabetes
Langer described a study in which she manipulating the sense of time of patients with type II diabetes using a special clock that could be set to display accurate time or run at half or double speed. Details presented in the Times article are sparse, but Langer hypothesized that their blood glucose levels would fall according to the time presented by the special clock, rather than actual time:
In other words, they would spike and dip when the subjects expected them to. And that’s what her data revealed. When a student emailed her with the results this fall, she could barely contain her excitement. “This is the beginning of a psychological cure for diabetes!” she told me
The Times article described the study as “yet to be published” (In press, submitted, or not yet written?). In the CBS Program, she described it as “hot off the press” but still in need of replicating. Langer does not have a record of ever replicating her studies before announcing their results. And if the study is not ready for peer review or even a presentation before a professional audience capable of expressing skepticism, how is it ready for national TV and the New York Times?
Reversing aging
The nursing home study may be the one mentioned in textbooks, but it is the so-called Counterclockwise study that garners the most media attention, in part because of Langer has written the book about it with that title and having relentlessly promoted it.
The Times article opens with:
One day in the fall of 1981, eight men in their 70s stepped out of a van in front of a converted monastery in New Hampshire. They shuffled forward, a few of them arthritically stooped, a couple with canes. Then they passed through the door and entered a time warp. Perry Como crooned on a vintage radio. Ed Sullivan welcomed guests on a black-and-white TV. Everything inside — including the books on the shelves and the magazines lying around — were designed to conjure 1959. This was to be the men’s home for five days as they participated in a radical experiment, cooked up by a young psychologist named Ellen Langer.
The methods and procedures of this study have never been described in a peer-reviewed article, only a chapter in a book that Langer herself edited. I tracked it down and found there were no tables or basic statistics. With only 9 men in the experimental condition and 8 in the control condition, any significant results were unlikely for the battery of measures. This is glossed over in the chapter:
Joint flexibility (finger length) increased significantly more for the experimental group them for the control group. Finger length increased for 37.5% of the experimental group and remain the same for the rest of the group, whereas 33% of the comparison group actually got worse on this measure. Only one person in the latter group improved. There was also an increase in sitting height for the experimental group when compared with sitting height of the control group. Those in the experimental group were able to sit taller, and they also had gained more weight, as measured in body weight, triceps skinfold, and bideltoid breadth.
“Replications” consist entirely of made-for-TV re-enactments, one with aging celebrities.
Cancer
The shrinking-tumor study will involve three groups of 24 women undergoing therapy for Stage IV breast cancer. One group is a no-treatment control. Two of the groups will be sent to a resort in Mexico supervised by Langer and her staff. One group going there will simply receive social support from the other women patients. The other intervention group will live for a week in environment saturated with cues invoking 2003, a time prior to their diagnosis with breast cancer.
They will be told to try to inhabit their former selves. Few clues of the present day will be visible inside the resorts or, for that matter, outside them. In the living areas, turn-of-the-millennium magazines will be lying around, as will DVDs of films like “Titanic” and “The Big Lebowski.”
These women will have a week of classes in art, cooking, and writing intended to distract them from their condition and re-engage them in the health that they experience back in 2003. They will also bring personal reminders of 2003 with them, like photographs. They will be encouraged by Langer’s staff to:
purge any negative messages they have absorbed during their passage through in the medical system. This is crucial, Langer says, because just as the mind can make things better, it can also make things worse.
The study raises obvious IRB concerns. The Times article suggests that the Harvard Department of Psychology institutional review board has approved the protocol, but the psychology department does not have an IRB, only the College of Arts and Sciences. I emailed their IRB and asked for the protocol. I immediately got a response.
Dear Professor Coyne
The IRB clarified with Dr. Langer after the NYT article was published whether human subjects activity had occurred since the protocol had not yet been approved. Indeed, we are waiting on the collaborating hospital to complete review; and, it was confirmed that no human subjects activity has occurred.
Please direct requests for documents on the study to the Principal Investigator.
Sincerely
Betsy Draper
The protocol is currently under review at the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, where Debu Tripathy, Langer’s oncologist collaborator has now relocated from University of Southern California. At USC, the protocol ran into trouble, some of which involved the language of the consent needing to include acknowledgment that there were no known benefits:
[Langer:] They want me to add a consent form for the people to sign saying there’s no known benefit to them. But that just introduces a nocebo effect!
Aside from the need for disclosure to the patients considering enrollment in the study, what assurance does Langer and her oncologist colleague have of the likelihood of any benefit? The Times article is vague on that. It cites somebody else’s study of baldness and risk for subsequent prostate cancer. Langer’s interpretation:
Baldness is a cue for old age…Therefore, men who go bald early in life may perceive themselves as older and may consequently be expected to age more quickly.
The article also cites Langer’s unpublished study that reportedly found breast cancer survivors’ self-description as being in remission was associated with lower functioning and physical health than that of survivors who describe themselves as cured.
Langer apparently has an ongoing study as to whether mindfulness can slow progression of prostate cancer at her Mindfulness* Institute in Bangalore, India. It is unclear what IRB committee approved its protocol or what its consent form states.
There is an additional human subjects’ issue that is not easily resolved. Part of the justification for involving humans in research, beyond any benefit they individually receive, is the promise of them contributing to scientific knowledge and human welfare. But there is little reason to believe that a study involving a week at a spa for 24 women with metastatic breast cancer will produce statistically-significant results publishable in a peer-reviewed journal. I would be quite curious to find any study, even of a biomedical intervention, that has ever yielded statistically-significant changes in tumor size in two dozen stage-IV breast cancer patients with only a week of treatment.
Arguments can be made that even attempting to conduct such an underpowered study is unethical because it denies human subjects the promised opportunity to make a contribution to science. Most cancer centers require a review of studies by some sort of Clinical Trials Scientific Review and Monitoring Committee, in addition to IRB clearance. Statisticians pour over the evidence for likely benefit, including formal power analyses based on relevant data. I cannot imagine that this study would pass muster.
My concern is that this spa retreat will not produce credible scientific data, but will get these breast cancer patients involved in providing anecdotes and even videos for use in Langer’s self-promotion. That is not an unreasonable concern. Past studies of support groups with metastatic breast cancer patients have yielded videos used on television and in well-paid talks to lay audiences, despite the lack of evidence that support groups extend survival. Similarly, an underpowered fMRI study conducted by James Coan and Susan Johnson has yielded a video used in promoting Johnson’s workshops, even though results were not significant.
Conflict of interest
Journalist Bruce Grierson has inordinate interest in Langer’s involvement in multiple resort projects around the world. These details might inspire awe among some readers, but they also indicate a potential conflict of interest between doing science and collecting real estate and franchise deals:
Langer told me that she chose San Miguel for her new counterclockwise study primarily because the town had made “an offer I couldn’t refuse.” A group of local businesspeople, convinced of the value of having Langer’s name attached to San Miguel, arranged for lodging to be made available free to Langer. They also encouraged her to build a Langer Mindfulness* Institute, which will take part in research and run retreats. (A local developer donated a beautiful casa, next to his Nick Faldo-designed golf course, to serve as staff quarters for the institute.) Starting sometime next year, adults will be able to sign up for a paid, weeklong counterclockwise experience, presumably with a chance at some of the same rejuvenative benefits the New Hampshire test subjects enjoyed. Langer says she is in conversation with health and business organizations in Australia about establishing another research facility that would also accept paying customers, who will learn to become more mindful through a variety of cognitive-behavioral techniques and exercises…
To my question of whether such a nakedly commercial venture will undermine her academic credibility, Langer rolled her eyes a bit. “Look, I’m not 40 years old. I’ve paid my dues, and there’s nothing wrong with making this more widely available to people, since I deeply believe it.”
And what about the women being recruited for the shrinking tumor study? Will they pay for their spa experience? If not, is being sent to an expensive Mexican spa an inappropriate inducement for consent to participate in the study? And if they survive their stay at the spa and wish to continue, will it be for free or at reduced rates, or will the study participation become an introductory offer for which they will have to continue to pay?
Such enterprises are based on the assumption there is some medical value in the spa experience. This adds to the pressure on Langer to demonstrate such a benefit. Her active involvement in the “experiment” gives her ample opportunities to attempt to influence the results.
Scientist as New Age guru – Once a guru, does the scientist remain?
Ellen Langer’s identification as an eminent, well-published Harvard psychologist is an important part of her branding and the promotion of herself and her products. The promotion is infused with references to her 40 years of research. Yet, she assumes none of the responsibility that goes with being a scientist. She does not consistently submit her work to peer review. She makes references to unpublished studies, even those that have remained so for many years. Some of her studies are described only in an ostensibly peer reviewed journal, Perspectives on Psychological Science, but with insufficient details to allow any independent evaluation of her claims. There is evidence of deliberate, selective publication from her direct quotes in the New York Times article. She talks about ongoing studies in ways that suggest biases being introduced by her monitoring incoming data. She is flippant in presenting her theoretical model and the sources of her hypotheses. There are discrepancies between claims that she makes to the media and what is available in published accounts of her research. And finally, she is dismissive of the basic responsibilities of a scientist conducting biomedical research to justify the work with reference to plausible mechanism and to provide patients with an accurate sense of the evidence base supporting or not supporting treatments.
Langer has published in scientific journals, but she is not otherwise acting like a scientist. One of her studies involved telling hotel chambermaids that their work involved lots of exercise, with the result that the women lost weight without increasing their actual exercise. These implausible results are reported in the peer-reviewed journal Psychological Science, with Langer with the same sort of mental frame explanation. If I am skeptical, do I owe it to her to carefully examine this article before dismissing it? I don’t think so. Her other activities establish sufficient prior probabilities it will not be worth the effort.
An embedded journalist and gullible CBS anchor people
Bruce Grierson went to Langer’s kitchen in Cambridge while she was preparing lasagna for her lab staff. He attended lab meetings where over 30 ongoing studies are discussed. He even went to her second home in Puerto Vallarta. He seems quite in awe of her, generally accepts everything that she says, even justifying the expensive resort experiences by suggesting the added expense will increase the placebo effect. I am the only skeptic in his article mentioned by name. Grierson sets up a narrative in which:
Medical colleagues have asked Langer if she is setting herself up to fail with the cancer study — and perhaps underappreciating the potential setbacks to her work.
But the crucial issue is not between Langer and skeptical colleagues whom she is challenged to prove wrong. And not the possibility of a setback to her work. It’s a matter of her proceeding with medical experimentation on women who are chosen because they likely have a short time to live. It’s a matter of proceeding without any encouragement from available evidence and lots of evidence to the contrary.
When I googled Bruce Grierson, I was taken to a webpage where he was described as a social science writer. Among his books is What Makes Olga Run?, which is described as “the mystery of the 90-something track star and what she can teach us about living longer, happier lives”. An earlier book, U-Turn, asks the question “what if you woke up one morning and realize you are living the wrong life?” Does U-Turn parallel Langer’s Counterclockwise? Is he an Ellen Langer wannabe? Certainly he lacked the distance to challenge some of her outrageous claims.
Someone from the New York Times called me to check carefully whether direct quotes from me were exact and whether my position was accurately portrayed. Why did so much else in the article survive fact checking?
The anchor crew on the CBS This Morning Newswas certainly not in CBS 60 Minutes investigative reporting mode. Can you imagine a muckraking 60 Minutes account announced with “Harvard Professor operates foreign resort franchise giving incurable cancer patients false hope”? The 60 minutes cameras would be brought down to Mexico and the deals with local businesses would be exposed. Experts in white coats would challenge any evidence that such experiences could be beneficial for survival. Harvard officials would decline comment.
Gayle King and Norah O’Donnell seemed totally charmed by Langer and competed for her attention. Only Charlie Rose evinced skepticism and ended with a wry, mumbled comment at the end, seemingly “we hope that everything you say proves to be right”.This seemed to be genre confusion going on. Certainly Ellen Langer was entertaining, almost like a standup comic at times. But this was not a sitcom in which we don’t have to worry about the protagonists. This is an utterly uncritical publicizing of a biomedical study with no evidence of background research having been done.
Essentially Langer is offering a quack treatment similar to Simonton’s visualization technique. Indeed, Langer’s approach is warmed over and re-served Simonton, and her theory cannot explain why visualization would not work. Her shrinking-tumors experiment is being undertaken with no more support from evidence than the Greshon organic coffee enemas, also offered at a Mexican resort. The main difference between what Langer is serving up and Gershon is that a stay at her resort would be less messy and more pleasant than a coffee enema.The readership of the New York Times and the viewing audience of CBS This Morning News expect properly-vetted and carefully-researched coverage of biomedical topics, especially any involving life-and-death issues like cancer. Desperately vulnerable patients and their families are seeking hope, even a false hope, but will be led astray by sources they thought they could trust.

FOOTNOTE
*“Mindfulness” as in mindfulness meditation? Hardly. An article in the Harvard Magazine clarifies:
“Mindfulness” might evoke the teachings of Buddhism, or meditative states, and indeed, the name and some of these concepts do overlap. But Langer’s version is strictly nonmeditative (“The people I know won’t sit still for five minutes, let alone 40,” she quips). Hers is a simple prescription to keep your mind open to possibility.

Is Gaming Addiction a Thing?
The WHO has added gaming disorder as an official ICD diagnosis, and the APA is considering adding gaming disorder to the DSM. What is gaming disorder and how should it be diagnosed?
Steven Novella on June 20, 2018
Link

Full disclosure – I am an avid video gamer. I have been since Pong first came out in 1972, and I have enthusiastically indulged in video games all the way to the current virtual reality games. Playing video games has always been one of many recreational activities I engaged in, always in moderation, and has never taken over my life. OK – there was this one stretch in 1994 after Doom was released where I played more than I should have, and I had to delete the game from my computer. But otherwise, video games have been a fun and harmless pleasure.
For some, however, video games do take over their lives. For this reason the World Health Organization (WHO) recently added Gaming Disorder to their official list of health conditions in the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11). Many are calling the disorder “gaming addiction,” although the term “addiction” should probably be reserved for biological addiction to substances. Gaming disorder, rather, is a pure compulsive behavior.
So what is gaming disorder?
Gaming disorder is defined in the draft 11th Revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) as a pattern of gaming behavior (“digital-gaming” or “video-gaming”) characterized by impaired control over gaming, increasing priority given to gaming over other activities to the extent that gaming takes precedence over other interests and daily activities, and continuation or escalation of gaming despite the occurrence of negative consequences.
For gaming disorder to be diagnosed, the behaviour pattern must be of sufficient severity to result in significant impairment in personal, family, social, educational, occupational or other important areas of functioning and would normally have been evident for at least 12 months.
This is a pretty standard pattern for psychologically-based diagnoses. A “disorder” is defined as an impaired ability or function, a symptom, or a behavior that is persistent, perceived as negative, and causes demonstrable harm. There isn’t necessarily any pathology, and therefore there is no disease. That does not mean disorders are not real.
The brain is the organ of mood, thoughts, and behavior. The function of the brain is dependent upon not only the health of the various types of brain cells, but the pattern, strength, and function of connections. There are therefore many potential types of mental disorders that involve only the pattern of connections, without any classical cellular pathology.
The function of the brain is also dependent on biological as well as environmental factors. It’s complicated, and teasing apart the cause(s) of any identified problem behavior is also complex. For this reason mental disorders are primarily characterized by their clinical features – the pattern of mood, thoughts, and behaviors that typify them. Something as complex and chaotic as human behavior defies any attempt at unambiguous categorization, so there is a lot of overlap and fuzzy boundaries, but it is still possible to identify different basic types of disorders.
This is what the new WHO classification attempts to do. The other relevant document to this question is the DSM – the handbook of mental disorders. The American Psychiatric Association (APA) added “Internet Gaming Disorder” as a “condition for further study” in the DSM-V. So it is not yet an official diagnosis, but they want clinicians to give it a try and let them know how it goes. Is it a useful diagnosis, and should it be added to the DSM?
Here is their working definition:
1. Repetitive use of Internet-based games, often with other players, that leads to significant issues with functioning. Five of the following criteria must be met within one year:
     1.  Preoccupation or obsession with Internet games.
     2.  Withdrawal symptoms when not playing Internet games.
     3.  A build-up of tolerance–more time needs to be spent playing the games.
     4.  The person has tried to stop or curb playing Internet games, but has failed to do so.
     5.  The person has had a loss of interest in other life activities, such as hobbies.
     6.  A person has had continued overuse of Internet games even with the knowledge of how much they impact a person’s life.
     7.  The person lied to others about his or her Internet game usage.
     8.  The person uses Internet games to relieve anxiety or guilt–it’s a way to escape.
     9.  The person has lost or put at risk and opportunity or relationship because of Internet games.
I don’t know why they decided to limit the diagnosis to internet-based games. The exact same phenomenon can occur with offline games. I suspect the people involved were not gamers. But that nitpick aside, you can see that there is a reasonable operational definition that includes all the elements of a disorder – persistent, negative, and causing demonstrable harm.
As a compulsive type disorder, there is also an element of loss of control. Those with alleged gaming disorder persist in their behavior even when they know they shouldn’t, when it is causing them harm, even ruining their health and their lives. They engage in behavior that is otherwise not consistent with their personality, such as lying and manipulation – behavior typical of addiction.
Of course not all avid gamers have a disorder. Compulsive behavior is a typical human trait, and can be very adaptive. It can make us industrious, it is how musicians and artists master their craft, and athletes excel. Even if art or sports are for pure recreation (and not a person’s day job), we tend not to criticize avid artists or sports players. But being an avid gamer has a bit of an unfair stigma attached to it. That is not what makes it a disorder, however. Again – it has to have a demonstrable negative impact on your life, it has to cause harm.
Like all behavior-based disorders, there is a continuum, and no sharp demarcation line. But still, at one end of the spectrum there is a clear problem that may respond to intervention. So it makes sense to have a label to identify this harmful pattern of behavior, so we can talk about it and research it. There is also a practical angle in that professionals need to get reimbursed for their time, and insurance companies need to know what they are paying for, and so ICD codes are primarily used for billing.
In the end I think gaming disorder is a real thing, and the working definitions of the WHO and APA are reasonable. It is a type of compulsive behavior, like gambling, and is a harmless recreation in moderation, but can be ruinous if it takes on a life of its own. This may occur if there is an underlying disorder, like anxiety or depression, and someone is using the compulsive behavior to self-treat. Some people may have a compulsive personality type. Others may get into a compulsive pattern of behavior for a variety of non-specific reasons.
Perhaps it is often the case that gaming disorder, or another harmful compulsive behavior, is more of a symptom of deeper problems in someone’s life. It is still a useful entry point to address those deeper problems, and it has become a problem unto itself that needs to be addressed.
Like all such disorders that are one end of a spectrum of behavior, it is important to stick to strict diagnostic criteria, and be wary of diagnosis creep. That’s bound to happen, but it also does not mean that gaming disorder is not real.
        ◦ Finally, I don’t think that gaming disorder is a unique or entirely new phenomenon. It is simply a cultural manifestation of a more general compulsive behavior disorder. Humans, to an extent, are not much different than rats. We have a reward system wired into our brains. When we pull that lever and get a reward, something that gives us a pleasant shot of dopamine, we will pull that lever again and again. It’s built into the system. We just need to know when to stop pulling that lever. For some people it’s easier said than done, and they may need some help taking their hand off the lever.

Video Games and the Brain
A new article looked at the effect of playing video games on the brain.Its results confirm what was previously suspected from prior research. First, it is another demonstration of use-dependent plasticity in the brain. Further, it supports a direct relationship between the types of activity in which people engage and increases or decreases in the respective parts of the brain. And finally it supports the inverse relationship between the hippocampus and caudate nucleus with regard to different learning strategies.
Steven Novella on August 9, 2017
Link

In the last few decades there has been a rapid and profound change to the way people in industrialized countries interact with information and the world around them. We are now multi-media creatures. Children are more likely to spend time playing video games than playing ball.
It seems likely that this will have an effect on our brains, which is an adaptive organ especially when it comes to processing information. The question that has not yet been resolved definitively is whether or not these changes are a net positive or net negative.
A new study looking at the effect of playing video games on the gray matter of the brain suggests that the answer is – it depends. Prior research suggests that video-game players may derive a number of cognitive benefits from playing. The current researchers summarize these findings:
Action video game playing, in particular, has been shown to increase performance in cognitive tasks within several domains including visual attention, visual short-term memory, executive function and procedural learning abilities.
These findings are not surprising. The brain displays what is called plasticity – the ability to make new connections in response to specific activity. This can be significant enough to actually see an increase in the size of the part of the brain responsible for that function. For example, violin players will have increased gray matter in the part of the brain that controls the hand that works the frets. In fact the research on music is similar to the research on video games – those parts of the brain involved demonstrate plasticity.
The current researchers were looking at the hippocampus, which is part of the brain involved in short term memory and specifically spatial memory. They divided their subjects into those who tend to use a visual-spatial strategy while playing, and those who are more “response learners,” which relies on the reward system for procedural learning.
This division was not arbitrary. The hippocampus, as notes above, is involved in using a spatial strategy to navigate a video game environment. A separate structure in the brain, the caudate nucleus, is involved in the reward system and procedural learning. Interestingly, previous research has shown that in humans (and rodents) there is an inverse relationship between these two systems. If you increase the size of the hippocampus, you decrease the size of the caudate nucleus, and vice versa. The reason for this relationship is not clear, but research suggests that the optimal condition is to have a balance between the hippocampus and caudate.
The researchers also looked at two different types of games, first person shooters (like Call of Duty) and 3D platform games, like Super Mario 64. 3D platform games generally require a spatial strategy for playing, and unsurprisingly all players of these games showed an increase in the size of the hippocampus after 90 hours of play.
Players of first person shooter games could use either strategy, although 83% were response learners rather than spatial learners while playing these types of games. In those players who tended to be response learners playing first person shooter games resulted in a decrease in hippocampus size after 90 hours of play.
These results confirm what was previously suspected from prior research. First, it is another demonstration of use-dependent plasticity in the brain. Further, it supports a direct relationship between the types of activity in which people engage and increases or decreases in the respective parts of the brain. And finally it supports the inverse relationship between the hippocampus and caudate nucleus with regard to different learning strategies.
There are specific implications to this research beyond wonky neuroscience. Decreases in the size of the hippocampus are associated with a higher risk of psychiatric illness such as depression and PTSD, and also Alzheimer’s disease. Further, playing certain video games, as noted above, may have benefits for certain types of tasks. Playing video games, for example, improved the skills and outcomes of surgeons using laparoscopic techniques. So there are real-world implications at stake.
The bottom line of all of this is fortunately probably simple. The best advice remains – do stuff, do different kinds of stuff, and do new stuff. When you engage in any activity you are using your brain, and this will result in learning and plasticity. The brain responds to anything you do by reinforcing whatever connections and structures are necessary to do it.
Playing video games is therefore no different than anything else, it is just another type of activity. Playing a video game will increase whatever cognitive strategy you are using to play that game. Video games may have an advantage of having a rapid response because of the intensity of the interaction. They can also be tailored so that the difficulty increases as a player’s skill increases, so they can stay in the optimal range of difficulty for learning.
The potential disadvantage of video games is that they may encourage playing one type of game for many hours at the cost of other activity. This gets to the – do different kinds of stuff – recommendation. The old advice of everything in moderation seems to hold pretty well with this kind of neuroscience research. Engage in different kinds of activity, including different kinds of video games, and of course more physical activity. And try new things, which seem to be especially stimulating to the brain.
The result of engaging in a variety of cognitive activities and trying new things will be a decreased risk of mental illness and dementia. It will probably also be more fun and enjoyable.

Mental Illness Denial
This is really hard, and we have limited knowledge, but we have accumulated enough knowledge about mental health and illness to take a practical approach to many patients and to help them improve their lives. This should include the full range of options available, including medication and counseling. To deny the role of medication can do great harm to those who may need it.
Steven Novella on January 24, 2018
Link

I was recently pointed to an article by Johann Hari in The Guardian that takes a critical look at depression and the treatment for depression. Unfortunately, it turned out to be nothing more than the usual mental-illness denial talking points, misdirection, and obfuscation.
Mental illness denial is a well-worn topic for me. The basics are this – there are those, for various reasons, who are engaged in what I think qualifies as mental-illness denial. They include Scientologists, because they push their cult/religion as an alternative to psychiatry. There are also those who follow Szasz who saw psychiatry as a mechanism for political oppression. I also find denial at times among rival professions who want to take psychiatry down a peg or two (often they just confuse their experimental expertise for clinical expertise – always a problem).
They all tend to have in common the core claim that “mental illness” is a fiction. How can thoughts be diseased? This is ultimately a straw man that confuses different types of illness. Some illness is based in biological pathology – cells are damaged, deteriorating, poisoned, genetically flawed, or essentially not functioning within healthy parameters for some reason. You can often see the pathology in a biopsy or measure it with some physiological parameter.
But not all illness is pathological disease. There are also disorders in which some biological function is outside of healthy parameters without clear pathology. The brain in particular is prone to this type of illness, and that is because brain function depends on much more than just the health of its cells (neurons and glia). Even healthy brain cells can be organized in such a way that their neurological function is compromised.
Let’s say, for example, that the anxiety circuitry in the brain is hyperactive creating spontaneous, unfocused, and debilitating anxiety. Now of course, anxiety itself is part of our natural neurological function. It serves a purpose. But excessive and spontaneous anxiety no longer serves a functional purpose, it just inhibits the ability to function. It is a mental disorder, in the absence of biological pathology.
Mental health deniers, however, twist themselves into logical knots trying to deny that there could possibly be anything about excessive anxiety that we can properly call an illness or disorder.
Like all campaigns of denial, there is also a range of approaches to denying the existence and implications of mental illness. At the extreme end you will find pseudoscience and conspiracy theories. At the milder end you will find softer denial, and denial that they are deniers. At this end there is the attempt to sound reasonable, and to conceal that at the end of the day they are engaging in motivated reasoning to deny the topic they oppose for ideological or other reasons. They give themselves away, however, by using the tactics of denial, and always flirting with the more extreme arguments.
For example, climate change deniers trying to sound reasonable will often acknowledge that the Earth is warming, we just can’t be sure that humans are causing it. But if you back them into a corner with evidence, they will acknowledge this but just deny that we can do anything about it. There is evidence that this behavior is rooted in “solution aversion” – in the end they oppose proposed solutions to climate change, and will deny the science only as much as they need to in order to oppose those solutions.
With mental illness denial, sometimes the motivation is psychiatry denial – opposition to the psychiatric profession. Of course you can do this by denying mental illness, but for those trying to seem reasonable you can also say you accept that there is such a thing, but then deny that we understand it well enough to treat it. Or you can simply deny the approach to mental illness of the psychiatric profession.
At this point I want to be clear – there are legitimate criticisms of psychiatric science and practice. Just as there are legitimate criticisms of medicine in general, and any applied science, including climate science. There is also no sharp demarcation between fair and legitimate criticism and motivated denial. You need some knowledge and judgement to see the difference at the fuzzy border. That is why I tend to characterize denialism as a process, try to define and understand the process as best as possible, and then be vigilant about the intrusion of denialism strategies at any level.
So let’s get back to Johann Hari’s article and see where I think he veers into denialism. Hari is writing about the difference between a depression disorder and normal grief. He is commenting on the DSM (the manual psychiatrists use to make diagnoses – a popular target among deniers):
The authors conferred, and they decided that there would be a special clause added to the list of symptoms of depression. None of this applies, they said, if you have lost somebody you love in the past year. In that situation, all these symptoms are natural, and not a disorder. It was called “the grief exception”, and it seemed to resolve the problem.
So, in order to avoid confusing normal grief with a depressive disorder the DSM included a grief exception. This is common in defining mental illness. The brain interacts with the environment, so if we want to decide if a certain pattern of mood, thought, and behavior is due to a brain disorder we have to rule out that it is just responding to environmental triggers. Like with the anxiety example above – anxiety is normal if you have something to be anxious about, but a disorder if it is spontaneous or clearly out of proportion to the stimulus.
Hari continues his narrative:
Then, as the years and decades passed, doctors on the frontline started to come back with another question. All over the world, they were being encouraged to tell patients that depression is, in fact, just the result of a spontaneous chemical imbalance in your brain – it is produced by low serotonin, or a natural lack of some other chemical. It’s not caused by your life – it’s caused by your broken brain.
This is an oversimplification to the point of being wrong. See above – depression is caused by life, and when it is, that is not a disorder. But if an evaluation rules out reasonable life causes of depression, then we are left with the possibility that there is something about brain function that may be causing depression. Also keep in mind that the depression, in order to be considered a disorder, has to interfere with one’s life. It has to cause “demonstrable harm.”
And now here is where Hari goes entirely off the rails:
The grief exception seemed to have blasted a hole in the claim that the causes of depression are sealed away in your skull. It suggested that there are causes out here, in the world, and they needed to be investigated and solved there. This was a debate that mainstream psychiatry (with some exceptions) did not want to have. So, they responded in a simple way – by whittling away the grief exception. With each new edition of the manual they reduced the period of grief that you were allowed before being labelled mentally ill – down to a few months and then, finally, to nothing at all. Now, if your baby dies at 10am, your doctor can diagnose you with a mental illness at 10.01am and start drugging you straight away.
Is he really claiming that a competent psychiatrist practicing within the standard of care would diagnose a client with mental illness and prescribe medication one minute after their child dies? You might be tempted to say he was using an extreme example to illustrate a point – but that misses my point. Making such a diagnosis is all about context.
Hari creates a neat little narrative here that serves his purpose of mental illness denial. In his narrative, psychiatrists removed the grief exception from the DSM because it was inconvenient. However, here is a passage from the DSM-V that Hari neglects to mention:
Note: Responses to a significant loss (e.g., bereavement, financial ruin, losses from a natural disaster, a serious medical illness or disability) may include the feelings of intense sadness, rumination about the loss, insomnia, poor appetite, and weight loss noted in Criterion A, which may resemble a depressive episode. Although such symptoms may be understandable or considered appropriate to the loss, the presence of a major depressive episode in addition to the normal response to a significant loss should also be carefully considered. This decision inevitably requires the exercise of clinical judgment based on the individual’s history and the cultural norms for the expression of distress in the contest of loss.
So what they really did was remove it from the list of criteria, which required putting a time limit on grief, and instead moved it to a note that was more open-ended and encouraged “clinical judgment.” Any fair and reasonable discussion of the psychiatric approach to mental illness and the evolution of the DSM should have contained this passage. But I guess it didn’t fit Hari’s neat little narrative.
After recounting his startling discovery that people are psychological beings with emotional needs (shocker), he finishes with this false dichotomy:
If you are depressed and anxious, you are not a machine with malfunctioning parts. You are a human being with unmet needs. The only real way out of our epidemic of despair is for all of us, together, to begin to meet those human needs – for deep connection, to the things that really matter in life.
This is a hopelessly simplistic approach to mental health, ironically as simplistic as the straw man “malfunctioning parts” approach he is criticizing. Rather, our mood, thoughts, and behavior are the net effect of a complex interaction between brain and environment. There are always a complex mix of psychological and psychiatric and sometimes neurological factors involved (rarely, it is a brain tumor). It takes care and clinical judgement to tease apart when someone just needs some counseling, or to make some practical changes to their life, or just time to process grief or other life events – and when they have a disorder that also needs to be treated in order to make it even possible for them to engage in therapy.
The DSM psychiatric approach to patients who have mental complaints, signs, or symptoms is to take a multi-tiered approach. First, rule out any underlying medical condition (make sure their anxiety isn’t due to hyperthyroidism, for example). Then assess their signs and symptoms in the context of their history to determine how much of it is likely to be due to life events. How much is personality. And how much, if any, may be due to some misfiring circuit in the brain.
This is really hard, and we have limited knowledge, but we have accumulated enough to take a practical approach to many patients and to help them improve their lives. This should include the full range of options available, including medication and counseling. To deny the role of medication can do great harm to those who may need it.

Psychology and Psychotherapy: How Much Is Evidence-Based?
Harriet Hall on March 31, 2015
Link

Despite all those Polish jokes, Poland has its share of good scientists and critical thinkers. A superb new book illustrates that fact in spades:
Psychology Gone Wrong: The Dark Side of Science and Therapy, by Tomasz Witkowski and Maciej Zatonski, Witkowski is a psychologist, science writer, and founder of the Polish Skeptics Club; Zatonski is a surgeon and researcher known for debunking unscientific therapies and claims in clinical medicine. Together, they turn a spotlight on research and treatment in the field of psychology. They uncover distressing flaws, show that many commonly accepted psychological principles are based on myths, argue that psychotherapy is a business and a kind of prostitution rather than an effective evidence-based medical treatment, and question whether psychotherapy should even exist, since in most cases it offers no advantage over talking to a friend about one’s problems, and in some cases can cause harm.
Research
They describe how disasters of social control like forced sterilizations and uncritical application of questionable IQ tests were instigated by psychologists who relied on their own flawed thinking rather than on empirical evidence from scientific studies. They tell horror stories about researchers who lied, plagiarized, distorted, falsified or even fabricated data, and got away with committing outright fraud over and over again. In some cases fraudulent studies were accepted as gospel and became the basis for ill-advised treatments.
They argue for transparency in research and show how difficult it is for others to obtain the raw data from studies even when the researchers say they are willing to provide it. They offer proposed solutions to increase transparency and promote data sharing. They discuss problems with peer review, editorial policy, poor research design, non-publication of negative studies, and failure to replicate positive studies. They show how these have created a situation where psychological theories are virtually unkillable.
They show how study results can get distorted and changed in re-telling. Remember the Little Albert experiment? An infant was conditioned to develop a fear of white rats by exposing him simultaneously to a white rat and a loud noise. This confirmed a popular theory, so it was immediately accepted as evidence that early childhood experiences could create lasting phobias that would extend to similar objects (in this case, to anything white and furry). Most psychology textbooks have misrepresented the facts about that experiment. They get the child’s age wrong, say he was conditioned with a white rabbit, and make up other stimuli that he supposedly reacted to, like a puppy and a teddy bear. Some textbooks even described how the researchers later “deconditioned” Little Albert, but that never happened. The research was done while he was in the hospital; they knew he would soon be leaving the hospital and it would be impossible to continue the research, and they deliberately decided not to decondition him. He died of hydrocephalus at age 6, so there is no way to know whether he would have had a lifelong phobia.
They uncover social control problems in the scientific community. Scientists who observed misconduct in their peers failed to report it in 36% of cases, and 69% of whistleblowers experienced negative consequences after reporting fraud.
Common yet questionable ideas
PsychoanalysisPsychoanalysis is a castle built on sand. Investigation has shown that Freud falsified or fabricated the details of every case he used to build his theory. His approach was not scientific. He never tested his ideas with experiments that might have falsified his beliefs, and he ignored facts that contradicted his beliefs. Many of his supposed original ideas came from other authors. How did he “discover” the Oedipus complex when none of his patients ever suggested they had such a problem? The answer is in a letter he wrote to a friend saying, “I found in myself a constant love for my mother, and jealousy of my father. I now consider this to be a universal event in early childhood.” Talk about projection and confirmation bias!
When tested, psychoanalysis was shown to be less effective than placebo. Its theories have been disproven, and no reasonable scientist or practitioner takes it seriously today. Yet it persists in popular opinion as one of the primary canons of practicing psychology.
Childhood experiencesWitkowsi and Zatonski provide ample evidence to debunk these myths about childhood experiences:
     1.  Personality is formed by early childhood experiences.
     2.  Mental disorders are caused by early childhood experiences.
     3.  Effective psychotherapy depends on the reconstruction of childhood experiences.
Delving into childhood memories often causes serious problems, and has led to terrible abuses such as the recovered memory movement. The idea of repressed and recovered memories is a creative invention of therapists. Patients are easily duped because it provides a convenient scapegoat to explain their problems and relieves them of responsibility for their inability to cope with their lives. Academic psychologists bear much of the blame for failing to subject pop trends to empirical verification and failing to speak out and denounce false theories.
Childhood sexual abuseThe typical consequence of childhood sexual abuse is not psychopathology but resilience. Studies have found no correlation with adult mental disorders, even when abuse is frequent or extreme. Less than 10% of victims experienced the abuse as traumatic or shocking at the time it occurred. Childhood sexual abuse is abhorrent enough in itself without tarring it with false claims that it causes adult mental illnesses. And those who point out the research findings (such as Bruce Rind) should not be accused of advocating crime.
PsychotherapyPsychotherapeutic interventions in general have been remarkably unsuccessful. Only one of the many varieties of psychotherapy is supported by acceptable evidence: cognitive-behavioral therapy. There is no correlation between a therapist’s training or experience and patient outcomes. Amateurs get equal results. The benefits of psychotherapy may be no better than the benefits of talking to a friend; in a sense, psychotherapists are paid to act as friends, which could be considered a sort of prostitution.
The harms of therapyTherapy can do real harm and can lead to suicide. It encourages dependence, false optimism, and externalized responsibility. Not one study of AA has ever shown it superior to any other approach for treating alcohol abuse, and in fact untreated patients have similar or better outcomes. Sexual misconduct by therapists has become so common that insurance companies have been refusing to insure them.
What are the alternatives?Can we replace psychotherapy with something else? Can a new “salutogenic” paradigm replace the pathogenic paradigm by focusing on human resilience and coping abilities? Mental health is characterized by commitment (a sense of purpose), by the belief that you have some control over your life, and by the understanding that change, not stability, is a natural element of reality. Hardiness is largely genetic but can be developed by exposure to stress.
Psychobusiness
Psychotherapy is more business than medicine. Bogus therapies abound. The authors devote two entire chapters to neurolinguistic programming (NLP), showing how it developed and flourished without any basis in reality, how the scientific literature served as theater decoration for a pseudoscientific farce, how it infiltrated academia, and how the scientific community irresponsibly failed to denounce it.
In another chapter, one of the authors describes how he perpetrated a psychological Sokal hoax. He got a bogus article published about a new therapy he invented based on Rupert Sheldrake’s pseudoscientific concept of “morphogenetic fields.” He invented and plagiarized outrageously, and offered clear hints about what he was doing, but the editors didn’t notice. They had some questions, but he made up nonsense answers and they bought his explanations. He accuses the editors of failing in their responsibility to protect their readers from false information and harmful recommendations. He conducted a test by having 172 people read the article: 77% said they would recommend the article to friends, and 61% would recommend the invented therapy to a person struggling with psychological problems. It’s scary to think how easily he could have marketed his new therapy and become rich at the expense of patients. In fact, after he disclosed that it was a hoax, he got a letter from a man who insisted that it was not a hoax; he said he had been thinking along the same lines and had reached the same conclusions.
Reacting to pseudoscience
In the concluding chapter, they describe the strategies employed by scientists with regard to pseudoscience:
     1.  Remaining indifferent and keeping silent.
     2.  Playing down the problem (Val Jones calls them “shruggies,” those who don’t feel the need to react because they think it’s no big deal and does little harm).
     3.  Attacking critics by questioning their competence and even their mental health rather than by engaging with the evidence.
     4.  Talking and giving the illusion of action without actually doing anything. Encouraging further debate, which is always a mistake.
     5.  Passive acceptance of criticism.
     6.  Arrogant hostility. Insulting pseudoscientific practitioners and using words like psychobabble, mumbo-jumbo, quackery, and flimflam.
     7.  Open, matter-of-fact criticism. The most fruitful strategy but the one least popular among psychologists.
Conclusion
You may find some of these ideas questionable or unpalatable. If so, I hope you will read the book and give the authors a fair chance to explain their thinking. This is a well-referenced, well-reasoned book that is chock-full of information about the state of psychology today. It exposes a lot of dirty linen that would be of interest to any reader. I agree with James Alcock, Professor of Psychology at York University, whose back-cover blurb says it should be required reading for every psychologist and psychology student and anyone contemplating psychotherapy.
I have only one criticism of the book – English is not the authors’ native language, and it shows. There are many infelicities of expression and even errors of grammar and usage. This does not interfere with understanding what the authors meant, but a good editor could have done a lot to improve their text.

False Memory Syndrome Alive and Well
Steven Novella on November 5, 2014
Link


It is disheartening that we have to return to pseudosciences that have been debunked decades ago, because they continue to linger despite being eviscerated by scientific scrutiny. Belief systems and myths have incredible cultural inertia, and they are difficult to eradicate completely. That is why belief in astrology, while in the minority, persists.
Professions, however, should be different. A healing profession should be held to a certain minimum standard of care, and that standard should be based upon something real, which means that scientific evidence needs to be brought to bear. Professionals are not excused for persisting in false beliefs that have long been discredited.
The 1980s saw the peak of an idea that was never based on science, the notion that people can suppress memories of traumatic events, and those repressed memories can manifest as seemingly unconnected mental health issues, such as anxiety or eating disorders. The idea was popularized mostly by the book The Courage to Heal (the 20th anniversary edition was published in 2008), in which the authors took the position that clients, especially women, who have any problem should be encouraged to recover memories of abuse, and if such memories can be dredged up, they are real.
The notion of repressed memories led in part to the satanic panic of the 1980s, and many of those subjected to recovering techniques not only “remembered” being abused, but being part of satanic ritual abuse.
Recovered memory syndrome was a massive failure on the part of the mental health profession. The ideas, which were extraordinary, were never empirically demonstrated. Further, basic questions were insufficiently asked – is there any empirical evidence to support the amazing events emerging from therapy, for example? Is it possible that the recovered memories are an artifact of therapy and are not real?
Now, with three decades of hindsight, we can say a few things with a high degree of confidence. Recovered memory syndrome is either entirely or mostly a fiction. People do not repress memories of extreme trauma. Further, as Elizabeth Loftus pointed out, memories are constructed and malleable things. Also, independent investigations by the FBI, other law enforcement agencies and scholars never found any evidence of the satanic ritual abuse, murders, and other atrocities emerging in recovered memory sessions. The events never happened.
What emerged from the entire sad episode was an increased understanding of what is now called false memory syndrome, the construction of entirely false memories. This was accomplished through guided imagery, hypnosis, suggestion, and group pressure. These techniques violate basic rules of investigation. Every medical student learns not to lead their patient or put words in their mouth. This is especially true if the patient is vulnerable and confused.
While there is some legitimate controversy over whether or not it is even possible to repress such memories and accurately recall them later, there is no question that the massive repressed memory industry of the 1980s and 90s was not evidence-based and was essentially an industry of creating false memory syndrome. The fact that a controversial idea was put into practice so widely, despite the risks to patients and their families, indicates, in my opinion, a systemic lack of self-regulation within the mental health profession.
More disappointing is the fact that recovered memory therapy is still ongoing today, which is completely unacceptable. Even if you wish to adhere to the minority opinion among memory experts that repressed memory is possible, the evidence does not justify putting it into practice. The potential for harm is more than sufficient to suspend the practice pending further evidence (if you wish to be a holdout).
An analogous situation in the health profession would result in a thorough banning of the procedure until further evidence demonstrates a favorable risk vs benefit ratio. If, for example, a drug on the market is found to cause liver failure, it is often immediately pulled until further evidence shows that it is safe, or at least can be used safely in some situations.
Loftus recently conducted a survey on persistent beliefs in recovered memory and found:
Even though skepticism toward the idea has increased among general respondents, more than 80 percent of them still hold fast to the idea that traumatic memories can be repressed, and 70 percent believe memories can be accurately retrieved by therapy. More troublingly, over 43 percent of practicing clinical psychologists think it is possible to retrieve repressed memories. Among Internal Family Systems therapists, 66 percent believe it is possible.
A recent article demonstrates that recovered memory therapy still has the potential to completely destroy innocent lives. The article details the case of a father accused of long-term sexual abuse by his daughter who “recovered” the memories while being treated for depression and an eating disorder. He was eventually cleared, but only after his life was shattered. Child Protective Services actually took the “recovered memory” claims seriously, which is yet another failure.
Conclusion
The evidence is fairly overwhelming that the majority (perhaps all) of the cases of alleged recovered memory of abuse are in reality cases of false memory syndrome produced by gross therapy malpractice, utilizing disproved techniques that violate basic rules of investigation and flagrantly disregard the potential for harm.
The myth of repressed memories is likely one that we will have to debunk over and over, for each new generation.
Perhaps more importantly, the persistence of this myth and practice among some therapists indicates that the profession has a serious problem with self-regulation and maintaining a reasonable evidence-based standard of care.

The Medical Medium’s Thyroid Pseudoscience
Anthony William calls himself a “Medical Medium”. He has no medical expertise, but he provides medical advice based on claimed communication with the spirit world. What could possibly go wrong?
Scott Gavura on May 4, 2017
Link

It seems increasingly difficult for consumers to sort out credible medical information from complete bunk. Thyroid conditions have their areas of legitimate medical controversy, but the sheer volume of pseudoscience and dubious advice on offer buries the fact that most thyroid diseases are well understood and highly treatable. Two weeks ago I examined a clinical trial that answers an important question about whether or not treating a laboratory-diagnosed form of low thyroid offers patients any meaningful benefits. Since that post I’ve received several emails and messages from people seeking more information about treating thyroid dysfunction. I was pointed to a thyroid post on Goop which I have to admit, left me a bit shocked. Sure, Goop’s advice is dubious, but I didn’t realize the website lets totally unqualified individuals give medical advice, especially when that advice is based entirely on claimed communication with the spirit world. This was my introduction to Anthony William, the “Medical Medium”, whose apparent claim to fame is channeling ghosts that give medical advice. Since William was also on your list of suggested blog topics for me to write about, I couldn’t resist diving in. Take a deep breath.
Ignorance of science is seemingly no barrier when you have the spirit
The website Psychic Gurus (yep) tells me that a medium is someone who can communicate with spirits (spirit guides, angels, etc.). All mediums are also psychics, but not all psychics are mediums. It’s worth noting at this point that no medium has ever been proven to be legitimate. Probably the strongest critics of mediums are the “mentalists”, who know it’s all a con, and are more up-front about the fact that any apparent “skill” of a medium is based on insights derived from the real world, and not based on supernatural abilities.
Anthony William has an extensive and detailed disclaimer on his Facebook page which gives a more concise summary of his qualifications than his own biography. In short, he advises:
    • His information is not a substitute for medical information or advice
    • You should never disregard medical advice based on his writing
    • He is not a medical doctor or healthcare professional
    • You should speak with a medical doctor or healthcare professional before acting on any of his advice
    • Quack Miranda, etc.
With that in mind, here’s what William says about his own abilities:
Anthony William was born with the unique ability to converse with a high-level spirit who provides him with extraordinarily accurate health information that’s often far ahead of its time. Since age four, when he shocked his family by announcing that his symptom-free grandmother had lung cancer (which medical testing soon confirmed), Anthony has been using his gift to “read” people’s conditions and tell them how to recover their health. His unprecedented accuracy and success rate as the Medical Medium have earned him the trust and love of thousands worldwide, among them movie stars, rock stars, billionaires, professional athletes, best-selling authors, and countless other people from all walks of life who couldn’t find a way to heal until he provided them with insights from Spirit. Anthony has also become an invaluable resource to doctors who need help solving their most difficult cases, and has recently released his NY Times Best Seller “Medical Medium.”
The Spirit’s views on hypothyroidism
Judging by William’s writing, his spirits are channeling straightforward alternative medicine approaches. His advice seems largely similar to the pseudoscience that you see offered by naturopaths, homeopaths, and other alternative-to-medicine practitioners today. Reading his writing, you’ll quickly discover you have adrenal fatigue. Gluten needs to be avoided. You need a detox, and so on. But the thyroid seems to be a focus for William, likely because he has a book about thyroid on the way. There’s just too much to wade through in William’s 7,000+ word opus to respond point by point, so I’ll touch on some of the highlights. (TL; DR: William blames the Epstein Barr virus for causing thyroid issues, and recommends herbs and supplements to cure it.) William’s advice isn’t supported by any credible evidence, yet that doesn’t stop him from making very specific statements about the causes and treatments of thyroid disease:
The Medium	The Science / The Translation
“because without true insight into what causes thyroid illness, medical communities aren’t yet able to offer remedies that heal the underlying problem”	There are safe effective medical treatments for thyroid conditions that can enable people to live normal lives without symptoms.
“Currently, the autoimmune theory proposes that in certain conditions, a person’s immune system becomes confused and starts attacking part of the body. In the case of Hashimoto’s, patients are told that the immune system mysteriously produces antibodies that target and damage the thyroid gland as though it were a foreign presence. This hypothesis will not hold up over time. Why? Because it’s not the real answer.”	Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (chronic autoimmune thyroiditis) is a common cause of hypothyroidism, seen in up to 10% of the population. There is sequential thyroid failure duo to an immune dysfunction. The cause is believed to be a combination of combination of genetic susceptibility combined with environmental factors.
“What medical research has not yet uncovered is that the body never attacks itself; it only goes after pathogens.”	There are numerous autoimmune diseases where the relationship to infection is unclear or unproven.
“It’s also important to keep in mind that while science has advanced in its understanding of many aspects of physical function, the thyroid gland remains largely a mystery.”	Most mysteries of the thyroid can be addressed by consulting medical resources, or asking an endocrinologist.
“In over 95 percent of today’s thyroid disorders, including Hashimoto’s and even thyroid cancer, Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) is the cause.”	There is no evidence this is the case.
“(The other 5 percent of thyroid problems come from radiation exposure due to chest X-rays, dental exams, and/or plane travel.)”	Ditto.
“It [the thyroid] uses this memory of homeostasis to transmit radio-like frequencies (not yet detected or measured by medical science or research) that delegate tasks and responsibilities to multiple body systems and organs.”	How the thyroid, and thyroid hormones work, is well documented. As evidence by thyroid replacement therapies, medical science has developed an effective treatment.
“When EBV enters the scene, this ideal functioning gets thrown off, which in turn throws off the entire endocrine system. To compensate and power the body, the adrenal glands pump out excess adrenaline, which is one of EBV’s favorite foods. The virus feasts on the adrenaline in order to get stronger, multiply, and go after its ultimate target: the nervous system.”	No. Virus don’t eat adrenaline.
“Hypothyroidism can cause body temperature fluctuations, a bit of fatigue, and dry skin—that’s it. What about all the other symptoms typically associated with low thyroid hormone levels? They’re symptoms of the EBV that’s infecting the thyroid, not low levels of thyroid hormones. Aches and pains, muscle weakness, memory issues, mood changes, and more: these are viral symptoms, not a result of hypothyroidism.”	Thyroid replacement alleviates symptoms of hypothyroidism. They are not symptoms of an EBV infection.
“What’s really happening is that back when Epstein-Barr was in Stage Two and hiding out in your liver, it weakened the organ and burdened it to the point of creating a sluggish liver.”	There’s no such thing as a “sluggish liver”.
“It’s worth noting that even if haven’t been diagnosed with a thyroid condition, a viral infection of the thyroid and the effects I just described could still be behind your struggles to lose weight.”	(Here’s where the supplement pitch begins.)
“In some cases, instead of causing an underproduction of thyroid hormones, EBV prompts the thyroid to overproduce them. This is called hyperthyroidism—and the diagnosis that many people with hyperthyroidism receive is Graves’ disease, an illness tagged as autoimmune that leaves far too many patients feeling that their bodies have let them down.	William isn’t even internally consistent, blaming EBV for both promoting and suppressing thyroid function.
“It wasn’t until the publication of my first book, Medical Medium: Secrets Behind Chronic and Mystery Illness and How to Finally Heal, which includes a chapter on hypothyroidism and Hashimoto’s, that the truth finally reached the public about EBV as that underlying cause.”	There is no clear evidence EBV causes Hashimoto’s, despite William’s claim.
“It’s time to reclaim your power and understand that Hashimoto’s is a label and not a judgment or life sentence. The reason for your suffering does not come from within. Your immune system is not going haywire or out to get you. It’s this virus—this invader—that’s causing the damage, making you feel miserable, and holding you back in life. Your body just needs the proper support, which I’ll describe soon, to triumph over the virus.”	Hypothyroidism is almost always a lifetime treatment.
“When the immune system isn’t able to destroy the virus altogether, it goes with its fallback option: attempting to wall off the virus with calcium. That’s what thyroid nodules are: calcium prisons for EBV cells.”	There’s no evidence of this.
“Your body fights for you. Your body is on your side. Your body loves you unconditionally. It just happens to be up against a pernicious adversary—one that can be tamed with the right approach.”	In essence, your disease, your fault.
“With adrenal fatigue, the adrenal glands can produce adrenaline and cortisol erratically, sometimes flooding the bloodstream and sometimes holding back. In this case, your adrenals may be overactive when you’re getting your blood drawn even if the doctor’s office is your favorite place in the world, and so, again, the results can be inaccurate.”	Adrenal fatigue is a fake disease.
“Millions of women unknowingly walk around with hypothyroids that wouldn’t register on today’s tests.”	Hypothyroidism is laboratory-diagnosed. There is legitimate medical debate about treating laboratory-diagnosed thyroid dysfunction when there are no symptoms.
“If your thyroid is in need of help, you’ve come to the right place. Below are foods, herbs, and supplements that can help restore a damaged thyroid, strengthen the other glands of the endocrine system, and lower the viral load specifically within the thyroid—as well as insight into iodine and a warning about a food trend that’s derailing many who suffer with thyroid issues”	There are no specific foods, herbs or supplements required to treat hypothyroidism.
“Among the most healing foods for thyroid conditions are Atlantic dulse, wild blueberries, celery, sprouts, cilantro, garlic, asparagus, radishes, kale, parsley, butter leaf lettuce, spinach, hemp seeds, coconut oil, Brazil nuts, kelp, and cranberries. Variously, they can kill EBV cells, provide micronutrients, repair thyroid tissue, reduce nodule growth, flush toxic heavy metals (which feed EBV) and viral waste, and boost production of thyroid hormones. For maximum benefits, consume at least one cup each of wild blueberries, celery, cilantro, and asparagus daily.”	You cannot heal Hashimoto’s hypothyroidism with food, and specific foods will not “boost” thyroid function or “flush toxic heavy metals”.
“No matter what food belief system you subscribe to, whether paleo, vegetarian, or the like, it’s a good idea to remove eggs, dairy products, pork, canola oil, soy, corn, and gluten from your diet while you’re dealing with a thyroid issue. It’s not that these foods cause inflammation, which is the theory you might have heard. Rather, these foods feed EBV, and then the EBV creates inflammation.”	There is no need to remove any foods from your diet in the belief you are “feeding” EBV.
Same whine, new bottle
William the “Medical Medium” offers alternative medicine, with a supernatural twist. William may genuinely believe he has a gift. But he has no medical knowledge or training. His ignorance of medical science is evident from his dismissal of it. It’s worth remembering that William has enough sense (or caution) to write a disclaimer that emphasizes that anything he says should be reviewed with a medical professional. If you’re seeking credible, science-based advice on thyroid issues, this medical professional’s advice is to ignore anything suggested by the Medical Medium, and to discuss your questions with your family doctor or an endocrinologist.

Overtreating the thyroid
For decades there’s been debate about whether thyroid medication is necessary for a mild form of thyroid dysfunction. A new trial helps answer that question.
Scott Gavura on April 20, 2017
Link


Levothyroxine was one of the first drugs I dispensed as a pharmacist where a patient became visibly upset with me after receiving (what she thought) was a generic version of the drug. The store I was working in had recently changed their labelling to show the generic name, instead of the brand name, on each vial. The drug being dispensed didn’t change – just the label. One patient, who had been taking Synthroid (a brand of levothyroxine) for years, was livid with me for suddenly giving her “levothyroxine”. I tried to explain that the drug was the same one that she’d been receiving, that levothyroxine was the generic name for Synthroid, and that I hadn’t actually switched anything. She wouldn’t accept my explanation, stating that her symptoms had worsened since “you switched the drug”. It was an early lesson in how perceptions can shape expectations and even symptoms, in this case, a form of nocebo effects.
The thyroid doesn’t get much attention despite thyroid medications being among the most dispensed drugs in the world. When people start thyroid medication it can become a lifetime therapy. Yet there are persistent concerns that thyroid disorders may be overdiagnosed and overtreated, and that millions may be treated with thyroid medication unnecessarily. Now there’s new evidence to answer an important question about when thyroid medication might be necessary.
Hypothyroidism is the consequence of the thyroid gland failing to produce enough thyroid hormone (My old post gives more background, but I’ll repeat some here). The body produces two thyroid hormones: thyroxine (T4) and liothyronine (T3). Primary hypothyroidism is the result of insufficient production of T4 by the thyroid gland (Secondary hypothyroidism is a consequence of pituitary or hypothylamic disorder). The overwhelming majority of cases of hypothyroidism are primary, and the major cause of primary hypothyroidism is autoimmune thyroid disease (Hashimoto thyroiditis). Iodine deficiency can cause primary hypothyroidism too, but it’s rare in developed countries.
Hypothyroidism may have zero symptoms, but in severe forms can cause coma, organ failure, and death. Patients with untreated but mild primary hypothyroidism sometimes describe weight gain, cold intolerance, dry skin/hair, constipation and hair loss. While the assessment and treatment of hypothyroidism is based around patient-relevant symptoms, the diagnosis of hypothyroidism must be based on lab tests, owing to the non-specific nature of the symptoms. Three laboratory measurements evaluate thyroid function and are used to diagnose hypothyroidism:
    • Thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH), secreted by the pituitary, is the primary screening measure in most situations. The normal range is usually reported to be 0.3-5.5 mIU/L, and a diagnosis of hypothyroidism is likely when the TSH is elevated above 10. The less functional the thyroid, the higher the TSH (Values will vary for what is a “normal” TSH depending on the lab).
    • Free T4 (FT4) is evaluated when the TSH is abnormal. The usual range is 9-19 pmol/L and will be reduced in hypothroidism.
    • Free T3 (FT3) has a usual range of 2.6-5.7 pmol/L. It may be reduced in hypothyroidism, but its value is not useful for diagnosis.
Subclinical hypothyroidism is generally defined as a “normal” T4 and a slightly elevated TSH: That is, some laboratory signs of a thyroid dysfunction, but not sufficient enough to warrant a diagnosis of hypothyroidism. Between 8-18% of adults over the age of 65 are reported to have these laboratory findings. There may be no symptoms, or they can be vague and nonspecific: fatigue, dry skin, constipation and depression. However, there’s an association with coronary heart disease, making the overall significance unclear and raising the persistent question of whether or not it should be treated with medication at all. A 2007 Cochrane Review suggested that treating subclinical hypothyroidism doesn’t seem to result in meaningful differences in symptoms or quality of life, nor does it appear to decrease cardiovascular morbidity. The USPSTF is also skeptical. It notes in a 2015 review:
A large magnitude of overdiagnosis and overtreatment is a likely consequence of screening for thyroid dysfunction, particularly because the disorder is defined by silent biochemical parameters rather than a set of reliable and consistent clinical symptoms. The high variability of TSH secretion levels and the frequency of reversion to normal thyroid function without treatment underscore the importance of not relying on a single abnormal laboratory value as a basis for diagnosis or the decision to start therapy. Currently, it is not possible to differentiate persons who will have advancing thyroid dysfunction of clinical importance from those whose TSH levels will remain biochemically stable or even normalize. Treating the latter group (at a minimum) will not lead to benefit, and these persons may experience harms associated with antithyroid medications, ablation therapy, and long-term thyroid hormone therapy.
There’s some data cited by the USPSTF to suggest that the threshold at which physicians initiate thyroid replacement therapy in subclinical hypothyroidism may be dropping, and consequently more people are being treated. Given the high number of prescriptions, it’s possible that millions of people with no symptoms of hypothyroidism are receiving thyroid replacement therapy. So an important question that’s been asked for some time is if treating subclinical hypothyroidism offers any meaningful benefits to patients. Now we have a trial that gives some important information to answer that question.
Does treating subclinical hypothyroidism help?
This new study from Stott and colleagues, entitled “Thyroid Hormone Therapy for Older Adults with Subclinical Hypothyroidism” was well designed to answer an important clinical question: Does treating subclinical hypothyroidism offer patients any meaningful benefits? This trial was funded by the European Union, and sponsored by several non-profit entities in Scotland, Ireland, the Netherlands, and Switzerland. Supplies of levothyroxine (T4) and the matching placebo were donated by Merck KGaA. The study was randomized, double-blind, and placebo controlled, recruiting 737 adults over the age of 65, who had what would be deemed persistent (3 months to 3 years) subclinical hypothyroidism (they defined it as a thyrotropin level of 4.6 to 19.99 mIU/L, and normal free thyroxine). Patients were excluded if they had taken any thryoid medications, medications that can affect thyroid function, and several other medical conditions. Participants were randomized 1:1 to treatment or placebo. The active treatment arm started with a low dose of levothyroxine, with gradual dose adjustment (by computer algorithm) to bring thyroxine to the normal range (0.40 to 4.59 mIU/L). (There was a mock dose adjustment in the placebo group.)
There were two primary outcomes: thyroid-related quality of life scores, and tiredness scores, measured using standardized tests (from 0-100 with a significant difference being 9). Secondary outcomes included general quality-of-life tests and several other measures, including grip strength. While they had initially planned for cardiovascular events to be a primary outcome, that was changed mid-trial owing to difficulties recruiting patients (which meant the trial would have been underpowered.)
The average age of participants was 74.4 and about half were women. After one year, the average thyrotropin level had decreased to 5.48 mIU/L in the placebo group and 3.63 mIU/L in the treatment group, with a median daily dose of 50 μg of levothyroxine. In short, the levothyroxine did exactly what was expected, which was to bring the thyrotropin down to the normal range. Despite this, the investigators found no difference in the mean change of thyroid-related quality of life scores or tiredness scores between the two groups. There were also no meaningful differences in any secondary outcomes either. In short, treating this “subclinical hypothyroidism” had no effect on any relevant patient-reported or objective measure.
What this means
I love clinical trials that answer a specific and relevant therapeutic question, with the potential for widespread benefit. Overtreatment is a significant issue in medicine, and it’s essential that any medication be initiated with an objective and relevant purpose in mind. This trial showed clearly that treating older adults with subclinical hypothyroidism has no meaningful or apparent benefits to patients. Consequently, it will provide good evidence to inform physician and patient discussions and decisions in evaluating whether or not thyroid medication may be necessary at all.

drenal fatigue: A fake disease (updated)
“Adrenal fatigue” is not a real medical condition, but some claim it is real and that medicine is ignoring it. What does the science say?
Scott Gavura on June 29, 2017
Link

While Scott Gavura is taking a summer hiatus from blogging, here’s an update to an an old post, on a popular topic.
One of the realities of being a pharmacist is that we’re easily accessible. There’s no appointment necessary for consultation and advice at the pharmacy counter. Questions range from “Does this look infected?” (Um, yes) to “What should I do about this chest pain?” to more routine questions about conditions that can easily be self-treated. Pharmacists have an important triage role — advising on conditions that can be safely self-managed, and knowing when medical referrals are necessary or appropriate. Among the most common questions I’ve received in my time working in a retail pharmacy are related to stress and fatigue. Energy levels are down, and patients want advice and solutions. Some want a “quick fix,” believing that the right mix of megadoses of vitamins are all that stand between them and unlimited energy. Others may ask if prescription drugs, herbal supplements, or even caffeine tablets could help. Evaluating vague symptoms is a challenge. Many of us have busy lifestyles, and don’t get the sleep and exercise we need. We may also compromise our diets in the interest of time and convenience. With some simple questions I might make a few basic lifestyle recommendations, talk about the evidence supporting supplements and vitamins, and suggest physician follow-up if symptoms persist. Fatigue and stress may be part of life, but they’re also symptoms of serious medical conditions. But they can be hard to treat because they’re non-specific and may not be easily distinguishable from the fatigue of, well, life.
This same vague collection of symptoms is called something entirely different in the alternative health world. It’s branded “adrenal fatigue,” an invented condition that’s widely embraced as real among alternative health providers. There’s no evidence that adrenal fatigue actually exists. The public education arm of the Endocrine Society, representing 14,000 endocrinologists, recently updated their advice on a common medical question, noting:
“Adrenal fatigue” is not a real medical condition. There are no scientific facts to support the theory that long term mental, emotional, or physical stress drains the adrenal glands and causes many common symptoms.
But if you search the internet, there are hundreds (probably thousands) of posts arguing that your doctor (and the entire medical community) is wrong. But the scientific facts are clear when it comes to adrenal fatigue. It’s a fake disease, and there’s no credible scientific evidence to support it.
Invented by a chiropractor and naturopath
The adrenals are a pair of glands that sit on the kidneys and produce several hormones, including the stress hormones epinephrine and norepiniephrine that are associated with the “fight or flight” response. Can you tire these glands out? In the absence of any scientific evidence, chiropractor and naturopath James Wilson coined the term “adrenal fatigue” in his 1998 book of the same name. Take a look at Wilson’s own extensive questionnaire, at adrenalfatigue.org. Do you ever experience the following? You may have adrenal fatigue.
    • Tiredness not usually relieved by sleep?
    • Having trouble getting up in the morning?
    • Get low energy, moody or foggy if you don’t eat regularly?
    • Feel worse if you miss a meal?
    • Need salty or sweet snacks or caffeine to keep going?
    • Eat lots of fruit?
    • Feeling run down and stressed?
    • Muscles sometimes feel weaker than they should?
    • Struggling to keep up with life’s daily demands?
    • Can’t bounce back from stress or illness?
    • Decreased sex drive?
Some lifestyles are apparently more vulnerable to adrenal fatigue, including single parents, shift workers, an “unhappily married person”, and the “person who is all work, no play.” There’s no information provided to substantiate the quiz, qualify the vague terminology, or link to any relevant literature. (Of course there is the usual Quack Miranda warning on every page which makes all of this possible: “These statements have not been evaluated by the Food & Drug Administration … etc.”)
Based on this quiz, it’s safe to assume that adrenal fatigue is the most prevalent fake disease in the world. And sure enough, that’s what its proponents think too:
Dr. John Tinterra, a medical doctor who specialized in low adrenal function, said in 1969 that he estimated that approximately 16% of the public could be classified as severe, but that if all indications of low cortisol were included, the percentage would be more like 66%. This was before the extreme stress of 21st century living, 9/11, and the severe economic recession we are experiencing.
What does the evidence actually say?
So let’s look into the medical literature on adrenal fatigue. There’s not much in Pubmed, though there is a systematic review from Cadegiani and Kater entitled “Adrenal fatigue does not exist: A systematic review“, which notes:
Theories on adrenal impairment as the genesis for fatigue are tempting, as they allow for a treatable condition. Despite the widespread use of the term “adrenal fatigue” by the general media and certain health practitioner groups, in this systematic review, only ten citations were found with this exact expression, and they were all only descriptive and did not perform any test regarding the HPA axis and “adrenal fatigue”. Studies that tried to correlate the HPA axis and fatigue states used the term “burnout” instead of “adrenal fatigue” to denote adrenal depletion. Therefore, a distinction between the “general information” and the actual scientific literature regarding this condition is evident.
And also:
No confirmed methods of clinical screening for AF are available. Indeed, the popular questionnaire developed by Dr. Wilson and published in the first book exclusively dedicated to the description of this supposedly disease has not been cited in any indexed databases.
The conclusion is important, so I’ll quote it in its entirety:
To our knowledge, this is the first systematic review made by endocrinologists to examine a possible correlation between the HPA axis and a purported “adrenal fatigue” and other conditions associated with fatigue, exhaustion or burnout. So far, there is no proof or demonstration of the existence of “AF”. While a significant number of the reported studies showed differences between the healthy and fatigued groups, important methodological issues and confounding factors were apparent. Two concluding remarks emerge from this systematic review: (1) the results of previous studies were contradictory using all the methods for assessing fatigue and the HPA axis, and (2) the most appropriate methods to assess the HPA axis were not used to evaluate fatigue. Therefore, “AF” requires further investigation by those who claim for its existence.
Why is adrenal fatigue a “fake disease”
One of the hallmarks of alternative medicine is the “fake disease”. Fake diseases don’t actually exist – they are invented without any objective evidence showing that they are real. Fake diseases tend to emerge from vague symptoms which can’t be attributed to a specific medical diagnosis. This is not to say what patients are experiencing isn’t real – the issue is the diagnosis, and the practitioner making the call. As has been pointed out by other SBM contributors, it’s understandable to want reasons and answers when you have debilitating symptoms. But symptoms need to be studied in rational and objective ways in order to understand the underlying illness – call it the “root cause” if you prefer. The diagnosis guides the treatment plan, so getting a diagnosis right is essential. While a group of vague symptoms might lead a medical doctor to run tests to rule out serious illness, alternative medicine providers seem to jump to the diagnosis and techniques they prefer, even if they’re completely unvalidated, or made up out of thin air. It’s your Chi. Your energy fields. It’s wifi. It’s gluten. In this case, it’s your adrenals. Rather than offer a guide to proper care, a fake disease is a distraction from the truth.
Adrenal fatigue is a prototype fake disease. Defining a cluster of symptoms in general terms is the first mistake. Symptoms need to be collated in a rational way to understand the parameters of the disorder. With adrenal fatigue, there’s no objective operational description, nor is there a validated symptom score, as the systematic review notes. Using a vague list of symptoms to identify patients is the second mistake. While laboratory tests are advertised for identifying adrenal fatigue, there’s no persuasive data to suggest that any testing used by naturopaths is valid in any way.
Adrenal fatigue shouldn’t be confused with adrenal insufficiency, a legitimate medical condition that can be diagnosed with laboratory tests and has a defined symptomatology. Addison’s disease causes primary adrenal insufficiency and usually has an autoimmune cause, with symptoms appearing when most of the adrenal cortex has been destroyed. Secondary adrenal insufficiency is cause by pituitary disorder that gives insufficient hormonal stimulation to the adrenals. Some liken adrenal fatigue to a milder form of adrenal insufficiency — but there’s no underlying pathology that has been associated with adrenal fatigue.
While adrenal fatigue may not exist, the same can’t be said for the treatments. When you’re treating a fake disease, anything goes. Everything from homeopathy to herbal remedies to hydrotherapy, to traditional Chinese medicine and vitamin supplements are advocated for treatment. The endpoints of treatment are as nonspecific as the criteria for diagnosis. Wilson, conveniently, has his own supplement programs, and there’s no shortage of solutions out there.
Conclusion: Symptoms are real, adrenal fatigue is not
While adrenal fatigue may not exist, this doesn’t mean the symptoms people experience aren’t real. These same symptoms could be caused by true medical conditions such as sleep apnea, adrenal insufficiency, or depression. Accepting a fake disease diagnosis from an unqualified practitioner is arguably worse. Patients don’t receive a science-based evaluation of their symptoms, and they may be sold unnecessary treatments that are probably ineffective and potentially harmful. The Endocrine Society’s guidance is entirely appropriate:
Doctors urge you not to waste precious time accepting an unproven diagnosis such as “adrenal fatigue” if you feel tired, weak, or depressed. If you have these symptoms, you may have adrenal insufficiency, depression, obstructive sleep apnea, or other health problems. Getting a real diagnosis is very important to help you feel better and overcome your health problem.
There’s no question that it would be frustrating to be experiencing fatigue symptoms and then to be told by a health professional that there is nothing medically wrong. But that is arguably better than the distraction of treating a fictitious condition.

Australian review finds no benefit to 17 natural therapies
A review by the Australian government has assessed the evidence for a variety of natural products covered by private health insurance. Their conclusion was that most lacked clear evidence of clinical efficacy. Hopefully this will end insurance coverage of seventeen different pseudosciences.
Scott Gavura on November 19, 2015
Link

Health care systems around the world are being pressured to “do more and spend less”, to make healthcare more cost effective. Owing to aging populations and the growing cost of providing health services, there’s more scrutiny than ever on the value of different health treatments, with the goal of reducing the use of treatments that don’t help. The Choosing Wisely initiative was establishing expressly for this purpose. Regrettably, while well-intentioned, Choosing Wisely hasn’t had as much of an effect as you might expect. Medicine can be slow to change, as David Gorski discussed earlier this week. Unless we ruthlessly scrutinize what we do for effectiveness, and are willing to act on what we learn, self-driven change is unlikely. One way that governments (and insurers) can dramatically reduce the use of a health service or treatment is to simply stop offering it, or paying for it. Yet stopping funding is something that is relatively uncommon in health care. It seems to be much more difficult to stop a practice, possibly owing to inertia, a reluctance to change, and the sometimes-vociferous protests that can emerge from patients or physicians that may feel that their preferred therapy is effective. The formidable challenge of stopping health care funding, once it has started, is one reason why this blog has been very critical of the expanding scope of practice being granted to alternative medicine purveyors – the legislative alchemy that is the first step towards insurance coverage. Because once that’s in place, it will be far more difficult to stop it. So it’s essential to understand the evidence.
Yet sometimes, which the evidence is so stark, insurers and governments face facts and start cutting benefits. Economic circumstances can strengthen that resolve. The most politically-acceptable approach, not surprisingly, is to conduct ruthlessly rigorous scientific reviews. When done effectively, these reviews can lead to solid, science-based decision making. Consider the slow death we are witnessing of homeopathy on the UK’s National Health Service (NHS). The NHS is a comprehensive public insurance system that maintains a “blacklist” of services that won’t be reimbursed if prescribed by a physician. It would seem self-evident that sugar pills should fall into this category, and that’s exactly what we may soon see.
Australia is another country with a fairly comprehensive public healthcare system that is also facing economic challenges and the desire to use its resources more efficiently. It also has a complex system in which the public insurance program (Medicare) is supplemented by private insurance which covers the cost of treatments and service that are not publicly funded. The risk to good care (and choosing wisely) is that there are often fewer incentives to reduce inappropriate costs from private plans, because those costs can be passed right back to the insured, typically in the form of higher premiums.
The Australian government recently undertook a review of natural products covered by private health insurance. It did this for two main reasons: The first was to ensure that private insurance plans were paying for “clinically proven” treatment. The second was based on concerns about tax dollars being used to subsidize ineffective treatments. The government provides a rebate on private insurance, and questions were raised about the extent to which the government was effectively subsidizing “natural” therapies that were not supported by good evidence yet were still being paid for through insurance. So in 2012 the government announced a review of natural treatments to determine if these therapies were effective, safe, and provided good value for money. Perhaps not surprisingly, the report has concluded:
The Private Health Insurance Rebate will be paid for insurance products that cover natural therapy services only where the Chief Medical Officer finds there is clear evidence they are clinically effective.
Such clear evidence has not been found.
The Review of the Australian Government Rebate on Natural Therapies for Private Health Insurance
The reality with many “natural” remedies is that there is often a lack of good evidence with which to evaluate them. Consequently, we’re often left with an “absence of evidence” rather than evidence that points clearly in one direction or another. (This gets to the distinction of evidence-based medicine from science-based medicine). In this review, the authors did not consider plausibility (a problem I will come back to), but looked only for direct evidence, drawing a very strict definition:
    • The data set was limited to systematic reviews (i.e., reviews of trials) published in the last 5 years. However, the authors noted that most reviews searched for all potentially relevant primary studies, without date limitations. They also considered literature submitted by stakeholders. Upon examination, both were felt to be low-quality evidence.
    • Searches were limited to the English language (which might limit the evidence base for some therapies).
The major problem with this approach was summarized by the authors as part of the quality assessment, and they noted the following:
    • A lack of randomized controlled trials. Even trials reported as RCTs didn’t contain enough information to demonstrate that they were truly randomized.
    • Poor comparators. Often trials were designed to make the assessment of a particular “natural therapy” impossible.
    • Lack of power. Studies were underpowered and not designed to actually answer the question being asked.
    • Lack of blinding. With most trials measuring subjective effects, blinding the investigator and the patient was critical. This was rarely observed. It was also observed that some therapies are very difficult, if not impossible, to truly blind (e.g., massage).
What was reviewed?
In three cases, the review had to modify its approach. Multi-modality therapies, like herbalism or naturopathy, needed to be studied differently. One topic, Ayurveda (natural medicine with Indian roots) was dropped owing to the diversity of the treatments and the requirement to translate data. Four others (hypnotherapy, biochemistry, nutrition and psychotherapy) were also dropped as it wasn’t clear which aspects of these therapies were “natural therapies”.
I’ve been blogging for years, but some of these therapies were new to me:
The evidence
Alexander technique
Alexander technique is a type of physical therapy that aims to improve movement and correct posture, with the goal of improving health and reducing pain. Invented by Frederick Matthias Alexander, the process seems to encompass elements of mindfulness in the practice. Nine systematic reviews were identified, but the overall evidence base was poor. The reviewers concluded that the Alexander technique may be effective in improving pain and disability of low back pain in the short term (up to 3 months) but the long-term effectiveness of Alexander technique was unclear. There was insufficient evidence for other conditions to draw any conclusions.
Aromatherapy
Aromatherapy uses essential oils with the intent of delivering a medicinal effect. It’s used as part of massage therapy, but also on its own. The main uses are to treat stress and anxiety, but the oils are also thought to help reduce pain and nausea. Proponents make very wild claims about the effectiveness of aromatherapy of essential oils, but the actual evidence is lacking. There was limited, low-quality evidence to suggest aromatherapy may be effective in reducing anxiety and agitation in patients with dementia, and possibly in reducing generalised anxiety in some other situations, such as before health-care procedures. However, this observation emerged from data that was judged to be of poor quality. The overall effectiveness and relevance of aromatherapy for these uses felt to be unclear. The effect of aromatherapy on health outcomes with other conditions remains uncertain.
Bowen therapy
Bowen therapy is a form of physical manipulation/massage/bodywork that is described as a soft-tissue remedial therapy or a form of bodywork that primarily focuses on the myofascia. Therapists use their fingers and thumbs to apply gentle rolling movements over muscles, tendons, and connective tissues. Invented by Australian Thomas Ambrose Bowen which he described as a “gift from god”, you can learn to offer Bowen therapy over a weekend. When the limited data were considered, it was concluded that there was insufficient evidence to make any conclusions about the safety or efficacy of Bowen therapy.
Buteyko
Buteyko (the Buteyko method) is a breathing technique developed in Russia for the treatment of asthma. It involves shallow breathing, through the nose, with breath-holding at the end of the exhalation. It is promoted as a treatment for respiratory disorders. It was invented by Konstantin Buteyko in a moment of inspiration when he was dazzled by a bright light (I’m starting to see a pattern here). The quality of the evidence for Buteyko is low. None of the evidence reviewed demonstrated that the Buteyko breathing technique improves pulmonary function, asthma symptoms or quality of life in adults. There is weak evidence that it may decrease bronchodilator use compared with inactive controls, however.
Feldenkrais
The Feldenkrais method was invented by Moshe Feldenkrais. It is a gentle form physical therapy that focuses on breath, posture, and movement. What the Feldenkrais technique promises is vague and seems to revolve around nonspecific “wellness” rather than any objective effects. While several systematic reviews were found, few contained any RCTs. Data quality, again, was poor. Overall, the effectiveness of Feldenkrais for the improvement of health outcomes in people with any clinical condition was felt to be uncertain.
Herbalism/western herbalism
Herbalism was the basis of modern pharmacology and involves the use of plants and plant-derived substances as medicine. The report identified three main types of herbalism: Chinese, Ayurvedic and “western”. Herbals treatments can be administered in many ways – not just orally. This review looked at the overall effectiveness of herbalism – not just herbal remedies, as the question facing the review was the funding of herbalists as an insured service. Chinese and Ayurvedic medicine were excluded from the review as they were determined to be out of scope. No systematic reviews were found. While there is considerable research on individual plants and products, there was no data on the overall effects of herbalism, and the process of “individualized” treatments as provided by herbalists. Given herbalism is effectively the provision of impure drugs and chemical combinations, the authors noted the significant potential for adverse events with herbalism, particularly when herbal remedies are combined with drug products.
Homeopathy
Homeopathy is an elaborate system of placebos where most homeopathic “remedies” contain no active ingredients at all, invented 200 years ago by German physician Samuel Hahnemann. Based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is a form of sympathetic magic) and the belief that sequentially diluting a substance will increase its effect (because the water has a “memory” of the substance), most remedies are inert. The authors looked at the National Health and Medical Research Council report as part of this review. They noted that there is little high-quality evidence, the available evidence is not compelling, and overall fails to demonstrate that homeopathy is an effective treatment for any condition.
Iridology
Iridology is an alternative health practice that is based on the belief that medical conditions manifest in the iris. Examining the iris is thought to bring insights about overall health as well as specific organs and body functions. Iridology is prescientific pseudoscience, yet is used by iridologists, naturopaths and homeopaths for diagnostic purposes. No systematic reviews were identified that have studied iridology, signaling there is a lack of evidence to demonstrate any effectiveness for the practice.
Kinesiology
Kinesiology is the study of body movement that identifies factors that block the body’s “natural healing process”. It is more commonly referred to as “applied kinesiology (AK) or specialized kinesiology, which should be distinguished from the science-based use of the term kinesiology, which refers to studies of mechanics and anatomy. (This portion of the review was poorly done and confusing to parse, as it did not distinguish clearly between the different practices that may be called kinesiology.) AK was invented by chiropractor George Goodheart and is a combination of chiropractic, acupuncture and western biomechanics. Applied kinesiology is pure pseudoscience. Dysfunctions found in AK are addressed by focusing on acupressure points and other specific body movements. The literature search found only a single systematic review on the topic of applied or specialised kinesiology. Not surprisingly, it was observed that there is a lack of evidence showing AK is effective for any condition.
Massage therapy
The term massage therapy or myotherapy encompasses a number of different manual therapies, and this review included remedial massage, sports therapy massage, deep tissue massage, myofascial release, therapeutic massage, myotherapy, lymphatic drainage, traditional Thai massage and Swedish massage. Systematic reviews were sought for any form of massage therapy. This was an extensive review and the data search results for each type of massage therapy are outlined in detail. Overall, the data was found to be of low quality. It’s important to acknowledge that like other manual therapies, blinding for providers and patients is difficult, as is data collection, as most outcomes are patient-reported, subjective measures.
The reviewers noted that there is a lack of good-quality evidence that examines the effectiveness of massage therapy for many conditions, and is actually inconclusive/uncertain for 29 clinical conditions it assessed. There is mixed but promising evidence for low back pain, and for reducing the length of stay in pre-term infants. There were some specific recommendations made about future research which I think are worth noting, as they point to the number of variables that may affect the effectiveness of massage therapy, and our ability to assess it:
In practice, massage therapists often combine various treatment modalities or techniques within a single session, and may also treat patients over longer periods of time than those assessed in an RCT. To allow for more firm and conclusive statements about the effectiveness of massage therapy for a particular clinical condition, more rigorous, multicentre, and well-designed clinical studies assessing the effectiveness of massage therapy for a particular patient population are required. RCTs need to combine treatment approaches so as to properly reflect the way that massage therapy is applied in practice. Also, there is little data about what constitutes an effective massage therapy session. Further research is required regarding optimal treatment parameters such as number of sessions or duration of sessions required, combined with longer-term follow-up of patients to assess the long-term effectiveness of massage therapy. Similarly, further high-quality research is required that reflects the way that myotherapists use various touch and equipment-based interventions in practice, to enable the effectiveness of this therapy to be assessed.
Naturopathy
As has been noted many times on this blog, naturopathy is an alternative medicine practice that encompasses a variety of modalities including homeopathy, herbal medicine, and Traditional Chinese Medicine. “Vitalism” is the belief that living beings have a “life force” not found in inanimate objects; as a concept vitalism was disproved by Wöhler in 1828. Despite this, the idea remains the central dogma of naturopathy and informs much of its practice. Naturopathic treatment ideas are all grounded in the idea of restoring this “energy”, rather than being based on objective science. Naturopaths can use conventional medicine as part of their practice, but this tends to occur only when its use aligns with the naturopathic belief system. This review focused on the overall effectiveness of naturopathy and naturopathic practitioners, rather than individual remedies or treatments, some of which are covered separately in the report (e.g., homeopathy, which is a “clinical science” in naturopathy). The reviewers found a single systematic review as an unpublished abstract. Conditions studied included cardiovascular disease, multiple sclerosis, anxiety and various types of musculoskeletal pain. There was no data on acute conditions. The overall quality of the evidence was rated as low. It wasn’t clear if this data was generalizable, as the studies were North American, where many states (and Canadian provinces) licence naturopaths. Naturopathy is unregulated in Australia. While the reviewers concluded that there is some evidence to suggest that naturopathy as a service is effective in improving patient health for a range of chronic conditions, there were numerous limitations noted with that data. And as regular readers to the blog will know, the evidence demonstrating that naturopathy is effective is lacking.
Pilates
Pilates is an exercise practice that is said to benefit health through improvements in strength, coordination, balance, flexibility, proprioception, range of motion, body definition, and muscle symmetry. It focuses on the body’s core muscles, as well as posture. Invented by Joe Pilates, there are over 500 exercises that may be done on the floor or using specialized equipment. Despite the popularity of Pilates, there is little published evidence that examines its efficacy. A search found 10 systematic reviews that included 18 unique RCTs. Conditions studied included obesity, breast cancer, strength/balance and falls prevention, low back pain, and stress urinary incontinence. Overall the data was quite limited, even for the conditions studied. The authors concluded that the effectiveness of Pilates for the conditions studied was uncertain. The most favourable interpretation was that Pilates may offer some benefit for low back pain, but even this tentative conclusion was limited by poor data quality.
Reflexology
Reflexology is the practice of applying pressure to the feet in the belief that points on the soles correspond to different organs and locations in the body overall. This type of massage is believed to release “blockages” and stimulate healing. Reflexology is another alternative medicine practice that is pure pseudoscience. Like iridology above, reflexology is a homonculus, or mapping-based system. Not surprisingly, this review found a lack of data and concluded that the effectiveness of reflexology was uncertain for all conditions that were assessed.
Rolfing
Rolfing is another form of manual therapy (sometimes referred to as structural integration) that is used to treat different health conditions, both musculoskeletal and non-musculoskeletal in nature. It seems to have elements of massage, yet focuses on the fascia and seems to veer more into beliefs about “energy medicine”. Rolfing was invented in the 1950s by Ida Pauline Rolf who claimed to identify a correlation between muscular tension and emotions. While anecdotal claims of effectiveness exist, there is a lack of published evidence that has critically examined Rolfing. The review concluded that there is a lack of evidence effectiveness of Rolfing for any clinical condition. Consequently, the safety, quality and/or cost-effectiveness of Rolfing could not be determined.
Shiatsu
Shiatsu is a form of massage therapy that incorporates acupressure, with origins in Japan. Shiatsu is considered a gentle massage (unlike Rolfing) where pressure is applied to over 150 pressure points on the body. Its aim is to restore and “balance” “energy flows” in the body. Practitioners may also use other treatments, such as moxibustion, cupping, food as medicine and judo therapy/tai chi/qi gong. The researchers found no systematic reviews for shiatsu for any condition, so were unable to draw any conclusions about its effectiveness or safety. They noted that the lack of evidence makes it difficult for consumers and others to make informed assessments of this therapy.
Tai chi
Tai chi, taiji or taijiquan is a mind/body exercise that involves slow, flowing movements. It has origins in China as a martial art and is based on Confucian and Buddhist philosophies. It is thought that tai chi can balance the body’s yin and yang and the overall “life force” or “qi”. While there are several variants of tai chi, all use slow movements and focused breathing techniques. There is a substantial evidence base for tai chi: The authors found 37 systematic reviews that included 117 unique RCTs, and almost 9,000 participants across 16 clinical conditions. Overall, the quality of the evidence was not good however. The reviewers concluded that there was low-quality evidence to suggest that tai chi may have some beneficial health effects compared to control for some conditions. However, owing to the dearth of good data, the magnitude of any benefit was not clear. Tai chi is well tolerated, and the reviewers concluded it could be considered a safe treatment in the populations studied.
Yoga
Yoga is a traditional Indian mind and body practice that involves a combination of physical postures, breathing techniques and meditation or relaxation. Depending on the form of yoga, there may be elements of stretching, strengthening and mediation. While spiritual elements are important components of traditional yoga, it is more popular as a form of exercise that ignores many of these elements. The reviewers found 67 reviews, 59 of which contained a total of 111 unique RCTs of yoga. The evidence base is limited by small, poor-quality studies that were poorly reported, making interpretation difficult. Consequently, the reviewers could only identify that there is weak evidence that yoga improves symptoms in people with depression compared with control. There was insufficient information available for other conditions.
Conclusion: Absence of evidence and plausibility
A comprehensive Australian review has found that there is a uniform lack of good quality clinical evidence to support the use of 17 different “natural” treatments. While absence of evidence is not the same as evidence of absence, the lack of good data to demonstrate efficacy suggests that these practices cannot be considered evidence-based. While this report gives a comprehensive summary of the current evidence, it is not without its problems. These therapies vary widely in their plausibility. On one end, iridology and homeopathy are pure pseudoscience. Pilates, yoga, and tai chi, however, are physical exercise which are admittedly difficult to evaluate in RCTs, yet are much more likely to have the potential to be beneficial. It’s here that a more clear science-based medicine filter would have been useful, something that the authors seem to acknowledge in their comments on the report, where plausibility is mentioned as a potential guide for future research. Given the very rigorous evidence bar it established, it is likely that insurance subsidies for these 17 treatments may end as a consequence of this review.

In the Spirit of Choosing Wisely
Mark Crislip on November 28, 2014
Link


Oh, loneliness and cheeseburgers are a dangerous mix.– Comic Book Guy
Same can be said of viral syndromes and Thanksgiving. My brain has been in an interferon-induced haze for the last week that is not lifting anytime soon. Tell me about the rabbits, George. But no excuses. I have been reading the works of Chuck Wendig over at Terrible Minds. (Really, really like the Miriam Black books). Writers write and finish what they start and only posers use excuses for not completing their work.
Recently I attended an excellent Grand Rounds on some of the reasons doctors do what they do. Partly it is habit. We learn to a certain way of practice early in our training and it carries on into practice and it is not always best practice. Patients also learn from us and have expectations on what diagnostics or treatments they should receive, and that too it is not always the best practice.
So to educate physicians and patients, the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) started the Choosing Wisely initiative.
Their goals:
Choosing Wisely® aims to promote conversations between providers and patients by helping patients choose care that is:
    • Supported by evidence
    • Not duplicative of other tests or procedures already received
    • Free from harm
    • Truly necessary
To do this they asked various medical societies for five or more do’s and don’t’s’. Punctuation humor.
In the world of pseudo-medicine, Choosing Wisely has one win from American College of Medical Toxicology and The American Academy of Clinical Toxicology:
    • Don’t use homeopathic medications, non-vitamin dietary supplements or herbal supplements as treatments for disease or preventive health measures.
    • Don’t administer a chelating agent prior to testing urine for metals, a practice referred to as “provoked” urine testing.
    • Don’t order heavy metal screening tests to assess non-specific symptoms in the absence of excessive exposure to metals.
    • Don’t recommend chelation except for documented metal intoxication which has been diagnosed using validated tests in appropriate biological samples.
    • Don’t remove mercury-containing dental amalgams.
and two fails. One fail for low back pain:
If you don’t feel better after four weeks or so, it might be worth talking with your doctor about other options, including physical therapy, chiropractic care, yoga, massage, acupuncture, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and progressive muscle relaxation.
and the other for choosing a pain reliever:
Staying physically active often helps. Acupuncture, massage, physical therapy, and yoga, might work, too. Chiropractic care might also be beneficial.
Both acupuncture and chiropractic do not meet the four criteria of the organization.
It is also ironic that while the ABIM is striving to improve care with the initiative, many organizations are institutionalizing pseudo-medical therapies in Integrative Medicine Departments that meet none of the Choosing Wisely criteria. What SBM givith, pseudo-medicine taketh away.
So much of what we are for at SBM manifests in what we oppose. That makes Choosing Wisely a nice fit for SBM recommendations. Much of this blog concerns what to avoid but it is not realistic to simply say “read the 2,147 blog entries and you will know what to do”. None of the medical societies have a particular interest in pseudo-medicines and SCAMs. I have always been surprised, as one example, at how little the IDSA does to combat the anti-vaccine movement in the US both on their website and at their meetings.
While SBM is not a medical society, in the spirit of Choosing Wisely I offer the SBM Choosing Wisely. I am going for the top 10, since I cannot stop at 5.
Avoid chiropractic manipulation of the neck
While rare, tears of the vertebral arteries can occur from chiropractic neck manipulation with catastrophic strokes and death. There have been at least 26 deaths following neck manipulate and the American Heart Association review suggests the risk is real. There is no proven benefit for chiropractic manipulation of the neck and there are safer and equal interventions.
The major chiropractic organizations have been aggressive in denying the risk of stroke and death, having little interest in improving patient safety or chiropractic as a profession. I is unlikely that individual chiropractors will be careful and follow the precautionary principle and abandon the procedure
And avoid any x-rays looking for chiropractic subluxations which do not exist. You only get radiation and cost without diagnostic benefit.
Avoid naturopaths as a Primary Care Provider
The 4 year education in naturopathy consists of the extensive study of non-reality based therapies (homeopathy, acupuncture, energy therapy etc.) but little training in real medicine. They usually have none of the post graduate training (internship, residency and fellowships) that prepare MD/DOs to provide competent care. With totally inadequate educations, a lack of supervised post graduate training and an understanding of disease and health that is divorced from known reality, naturopaths are rendered unfit to be a primary care physician.
Avoid any practitioner who sells the pseudo-cure for their pseudo-disease in their front office
It is a gross conflict of interest to sell the herbs, vitamins and supplements to treat the diseases and often pseudo-diseases diagnosed in the CAM clinic. If a provider makes a diagnosis and sells the remedy from their front office, be very suspicious of both diagnosis and treatment, and find another provider
Avoid any acupuncturist who does not use good infection control technique: hand hygiene, gloves and cleaning of the injection site
While acupuncturists deny the need for good technique, the literature is filled with infectious complications from acupuncture and poor technique, from bloodstream infections to infected joints. It is hard to infect a human being, but the average acupuncturist seems to go out of their way to maximize the potential to cause a rare infection.
Avoid any product that can “boost your immune system”
While it sounds impressive, the immune system cannot be boosted. When it is, in medicine we call it the inflammatory response, and is not without risk: stokes, heart attacks, and pulmonary emboli often occur after infections, probably as inflammation increases the rate of clot formation.
Avoid products that…
    • were invented by school teachers or other lone geniuses working in their basement
    • rely on anecdotes to sell their products
    • are being suppressed by big whatever
    • that represent an ancient truth, and/or
    • are promoted in the media but not the medical literature
These are all signs of bogus science.
Avoid any product that “supports” an organ or a physiologic process
Any product that suggests it functions like a truss, bra or jock strap doesn’t. Like boosting the immune system, it is a phrase that, while sounding promising, is a code word for ‘does nothing but we want you to think it does.’
Avoid any product that offer includes the Quack Miranda Warning
“These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.”
They use the Quack Miranda Warning as a way of avoiding the fact the claims made for the product are, in fact, not true and that the product does nothing
Avoid homeopathy
Homeopathy is not an herbal product or a supplement. Homeopathic products are literally water and/or a sugar tablet. There is no active product in a homeopathic product. It is nothing that does nothing.
Avoid any practitioner, alternative or legitimate, who uses the phrase “in my experience” in deciding on a therapeutic intervention
Experience is important for any health care provider in diagnosing patients but when it comes to deciding what the best intervention is, experience is unreliable at best and dangerous at worst. “In my experience” is a distillation of all the cognitive biases that make human thought unreliable.
Conclusion: Choosing Wisely in CAM means avoiding it
The interesting aspect about the Choosing Wisely initiative is how many of the recommendations are proscriptive. They are about avoiding the useless, the dangerous and the expensive that do not add to quality medicine. The quality improvement process avoided or ignored by SCAM practitioners.
I wonder if a chiropractor could come up with five standards treatments in chiropractic to be avoided or if naturopaths, homeopaths and acupuncturists could as well. I know they would say avoid vaccines and NSAIDS and most of reality based medicine. But could they come up with five treatments or diagnostics in their own field to avoid? I bet not. We have a few alt med providers who occasionally comment; I look forward to their proving me wrong.

Acupuncture, Organic Food, and Other Questions
In this post I respond to some reader mail regarding several different issues – organic farming and pesticides, acupuncture, and herbal supplements. In each case I clarify my position and discuss the evidence base.
Steven Novella on January 14, 2015
Link
SBM frequently receives questions from readers asking for more information or even challenging our position on various topics. We make extensive efforts to answer such questions, since engaging with the public is one of the primary purposes of this blog. In fact, I specifically chose the blog format because of its interactive nature and the ability to rapidly respond to items in the news or being discussed publicly.
Sometimes it’s helpful to provide answers to questions in the form of its own post. I do this when the questions are common or explore some new or interesting angle of a topic. I am also more likely to engage when the questions are polite and genuine.
We recently received the following e-mail which meets all these criteria, so here is my response. I will reprint the e-mail in sections as I address each question.
Organic pesticides
I have the utmost respect for the scientific method, and we subscribe to the Skeptical Inquirer. I respect much of what your organization does, and I do not believe that Reiki or Therapeutic Touch is effective, unless the person receiving these therapies believe they work. However, your organization seems to go out of its way to disprove things like the benefit of organic produce which has less pesticides than conventional produce. You claim that natural pesticides could be just as harmful. Here are some examples of these natural pesticides: apply 1 tablespoon of canola oil and a few drops of ivory soap to the leaves of plants and vegetables to repel insects. Also, apply 2 TBSPS of hot pepper sauce with a few drops of ivory soap to leaves, use baking soda and water or pureed onions to repel insects. How can you claim that these innocuous substances are as harmful as conventional pesticides?
The e-mailer is mischaracterizing our position, setting up a straw man. We never specifically mentioned the “natural” pesticides she lists above, and so never claimed they were harmful. I have written about this topic several times myself and here are the conclusions I have drawn from the evidence.
In 2012 I reported on a systematic review of studies of the health effects of organic produce, stating:
The recent review did find that organic produce had fewer pesticide residues than conventional farming. However, there is no evidence that these low levels of pesticides present any health risk.
But in a 2010 SBM article I pointed out:
With regard to pesticides, it must also be noted that organic farming, while using methods to minimize pests and the need for pesticides, still uses organic, rather than synthetic, pesticides. For example a rotenone-pyrethrin mixture is commonly used. Such pesticides are not as well studied as synthetic pesticides, often require more applications, and may persist longer in the soil. In fact the use of “natural” pesticides is nothing more than an appeal to the naturalistic fallacy – there really is no evidence for superior safety, and they have not been adequately studied.
To summarize, there is no evidence that organic produce is more healthful or less risky than conventional produce. There is some evidence for increased synthetic pesticide residue on conventional produce, but such reside is still well below safety limits. These studies, however, are rigged because they don’t measure organic pesticide residues. This includes many untested and potentially-harmful agents that generally have to be used more often and in larger amounts than synthetic pesticides. It is assumed that organic pesticides are harmless because they are “natural,” but this is a fallacy.
When they are studied it is found that some natural pesticides can have the same potential for adverse health and environmental effects as synthetic ones.
Of course, there is a wide range of practices under the banner of “organic.” Not all organic farmers use natural pesticides. There are non-chemical approaches such as using predator species and careful crop selection. I never claimed that all organic farmers use natural pesticides, just that some do because they are allowed to.
The bottom line remains – pesticide residues in conventional farming are below safety limits and there is no evidence that they cause any adverse health effect at those levels. Meanwhile, some organic farmers use natural pesticides with the false security that they are “natural” when in fact they are likely no different in safety from synthetic pesticides and often need to be used in larger amounts.
I would also point out that while exploring non-chemical approaches to pest management is a great idea, and may even be practical for small farms, there is currently no way we can produce food for 7 billion people without pesticides.
Oil-based pesticides, for example, may be a great option for a home garden or small farm, but they generally need to be sprayed directly on insects to have an effect, and have little ongoing effect. Frequent applications are therefore necessary.
Acupuncture
The e-mailer continues:
On another matter, your organization claims acupuncture is nothing more than woo. Of course there is no proof that qi exists, but there are western explanations such as increased blood flow or the involvement of neurotransmitters which could explain why acupuncture may work in limited situations. One example is the use of acupuncture to help alleviate the nausea and vomiting from chemotherapy. Do you believe the American Medical Association is a woo organization? The AMA has stated that indeed, acupuncture can help patients who experience nausea from chemotherapy. I have read the research which is very convincing because they use control groups.And there is more than one study.
There are two points being made here, both extremely common: there are respectable medical organizations who endorse acupuncture as effective, and aren’t there plausible science-based mechanisms for acupuncture?
Generally speaking, if multiple scientific and professional organizations systematically review the evidence addressing a specific question and arrive at position statements that generally agree with each other, then it is reasonable to take such positions seriously. Unfortunately, in the case of acupuncture such organizations sometimes have not systematically reviewed the evidence, but have simply allowed acupuncturists to provide position statements based upon their own dogma.
The World Health Organization’s (WHO) 1996 position statement on acupuncture is probably the best example. This is still presented as evidence for mainstream acceptance of acupuncture. I did a thorough analysis here, but the short version is that the authors of the statement were all acupuncturists who made statements that were in direct conflict with the published evidence.
In the case of the AMA they did apparently review the evidence, but their vague statements are being misrepresented as more positive than they are. Here, I believe, is the AMA position referenced by the e-mailer – actually a consensus statement published in JAMA from 1998. They concluded:
Acupuncture as a therapeutic intervention is widely practiced in the United States. Although there have been many studies of its potential usefulness, many of these studies provide equivocal results because of design, sample size, and other factors. The issue is further complicated by inherent difficulties in the use of appropriate controls, such as placebos and sham acupuncture groups. However, promising results have emerged, for example, showing efficacy of acupuncture in adult postoperative and chemotherapy nausea and vomiting and in postoperative dental pain.
This is a long way away from saying that acupuncture works for nausea. Most “promising results” do not hold up to well-designed clinical trials.
In reviewing the current research looking at acupuncture and chemotherapy induced or post-operative nausea and vomiting, I find that it is plagued by the same problems with the acupuncture literature in general. Most studies are not controlled with sham or placebo acupuncture. Most that are controlled do not report allocation blinding – there is a particular problem in acupuncture studies with subjects becoming unblinded to their treatment group. Also, reviews are contaminated with “electroacupuncture” studies, which introduce the new variable of electrical stimulation.
There is also the problem that the evidence strongly shows an almost-completely-positive bias in the Asian literature on acupuncture. Any reviews containing studies from China, for example, are therefore suspect.
Those few studies that are best controlled tend to be negative. For example, a 2015 study of stimulation at the K1 point in chemotherapy induced nausea, with a sham acupuncture control, showed no benefit.
A 2006 Cochrane systematic review concluded:
This review complements data on post-operative nausea and vomiting suggesting a biologic effect of acupuncture-point stimulation. Electroacupuncture has demonstrated benefit for chemotherapy-induced acute vomiting, but studies combining electroacupuncture with state-of-the-art antiemetics and in patients with refractory symptoms are needed to determine clinical relevance. Self-administered acupressure appears to have a protective effect for acute nausea and can readily be taught to patients though studies did not involve placebo control. Noninvasive electrostimulation appears unlikely to have a clinically relevant impact when patients are given state-of-the-art pharmacologic antiemetic therapy.
These are curiously mixed results. Often treatment reduced vomiting but not nausea, or reduced acute but not delayed symptoms. Most were not adequately controlled, with properly blinded sham groups.
While I agree that the studies for acupuncture are more consistently positive with nausea and vomiting than other indications, the research methods are still wanting, contain significant limitations, and overall are unimpressive. It is possible that there is simply a larger placebo effect for nausea and vomiting than other tested symptoms. It is also possible that local pain does have a temporary inhibitory effect on vomiting, but I don’t think the literature is sufficient to confidently conclude this.
None of this, however, leads to the conclusion that “acupuncture works.” This blends into the other point about mechanism of action.
What is clear from the scientific literature is that chi does not exist. It is a pre-scientific delusion. It is also clear the acupuncture points do not exist – they have no basis in reality, and adhering to acupuncture points has no clinical effect. It is also clear that specific acupuncture techniques, such as inserting needles to a specific depth, and eliciting a “de qi”, also have no effects.
What, then, is acupuncture? Give me a definition that does not involve sticking needles into acupuncture points. If you count any local application of pressure, minor tissue trauma, or pain with electricity, needles, dull toothpicks, heat, or whatever as “acupuncture” then the definition loses any specific scientific meaning.
It is possible, for example, that any physical stimulation might contain a modest and short-lived effect to reduce the perception of pain or nausea. What the studies show is that this non-specific effect is minor to non-existent, and is swamped by other non-specific effects such as simply being nice to patients.
As a scientific hypothesis, acupuncture has failed. It is based on no unique understanding of anatomy or physiology and entails no specific effects. Acupuncture training is without benefit, as poking people randomly with toothpicks after a 10-minute prep seems to be just as effective. We need to completely dispense with any notion of chi or acupuncture points.
The fact that stuff happens in the local tissue after needle insertion does not mean that this stuff (any physiological changes) is a “mechanism for acupuncture.” That conclusion is highly misleading, for the reasons stated above.
Perhaps in the end we will demonstrate that rubbing parts of the body may be a benign and effective way of distracting people from their pain or nausea, or just giving them something to do, or may provide some counter-irritation (like rubbing your elbow after banging it into something). Tactile stimulation may even inhibit the vomiting reflex. None of this, however, is acupuncture.
These distinctions are important. Scientific questions need to be clear and unambiguous, as do definitions. Proponents of the worst manifestations of “medical acupuncture” exploit the slippery definition of acupuncture often employed to argue that these dubious, transient, and minor nonspecific effects show that “acupuncture works” and therefore justify using “acupuncture” to treat real medical conditions.
Supplements
She raises one more issue:
When it comes to herbal supplements, many are indeed unsafe, and possibly contaminated. However, ConsumerLab does test many herbs for purity. I suffer from osteoarthritis, and take several herbs which have helped me. Sometimes the evidence is only anecdotal, but often that’s because there is little money to be had by testing these non- drug supplements.
I can’t really repeat the many posts we have here on supplements, which collectively address her questions. Let me just highlight a few points.
While some supplements are tested and some do have reasonable purity, on the whole the industry is poorly regulated, and rife with contamination, product substitution, and dose variability. Many are adulterated with prescription drugs. The fact that they are not universally contaminated is of little comfort.
We also point out that effective herbs are drugs and should be treated as such. In addition to the above problems, they are unpurified, and may contain variable doses of many active ingredients. Herbs are dirty, variable, and poorly-regulated drugs.
Most of the popular herbs on the market also do not work for the indications for which they are marketed, or they lack sufficient evidence to know their efficacy.
It also cannot be assumed that they are safe – they often have the same toxic effects and drug interactions as other drugs.
These concerns should not be brushed aside. Nor is it legitimate to defend anecdotal evidence by saying there is little money for testing. This is both untrue and irrelevant. Anecdotal evidence is completely inadequate, whether or not there is funding for well-controlled trials.
But further – the supplement industry is largely the same as the pharmaceutical industry. Big Pharma and Big Supplement are often the same companies. They have plenty of money to conduct research. Supplements are also a billion-dollar industry.
The NIH has also granted millions of dollars for supplement research, and has funded many high-quality studies.The problem is not that there is no money for research. The problem is there is no regulatory incentive for research. Further, there has been research (mostly publicly or academically funded) but it is mostly negative. Herbs that have active ingredients that are safe and effective are researched and developed into pharmaceuticals.Chondroitin and glucosamine for arthritis, for example, have been extensively studied. A 2009 review found:
In the literature satisfying our inclusion criteria, glucosamine sulfate, glucosamine hydrochloride, and chondroitin sulfate have individually shown inconsistent efficacy in decreasing OA pain and improving joint function.
A large 2 year study published in 2010 found:
Over 2 years, no treatment achieved a clinically important difference in WOMAC pain or function as compared with placebo.
Also keep in mind that we have no bias or ideological axe to grind against glucosamine or chondroitin for arthritis, or any particular herbal product. We are simply reporting the findings of the research and putting it into a meaningful clinical and regulatory context.
Conclusion: The rules of science must apply everywhere
It is also worth pointing out that science-based medicine in general is about raising the bar of scientific evidence before concluding that any treatment is safe and effective. There are numerous challenges to doing reliable clinical research, and the literature is filled with bias and error.
We apply these standards universally, but it is easy to feel picked on when we apply them to some treatment in which you believe. The e-mailer goes on to say that she agrees with us when we criticize homeopathy or anti-GMO nonsense. Well, we are using the same process when we analyze the claims made for organic produce, acupuncture, and supplements.

CAM and Headaches
Steven Novella on September 3, 2014
Link

A recent editorial entitled “CAM in the Real World: You May Practice Evidence-Based Medicine, But Your Patients Don’t” published in Headache: The Journal of Head and Face Pain by Robert Cowan, a headache specialist, addresses the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in the treatment of headaches. Unfortunately he propagates many common misconceptions about CAM in the article.
I do agree with one point – physicians need to be more aware of CAM treatments and their patients’ use of them. We should be directly asking our patients about such use, in a non-judgmental way, and we should be familiar enough with common CAM treatments so that we can provide knowledgeable guidance to our patients.
Cowan begins by, in my opinion, grossly exaggerating the current popularity of CAM. He writes:
As much as 82% of headache sufferers use complementary and alternative approaches.
The reference he cites, however, states:
Adults with migraines/severe headaches used CAM more frequently than those without (49.5% vs 33.9%, P < .0001); differences persisted after adjustment (adjusted odds ratio = 1.29, 95% confidence interval [1.15, 1.45]). Mind–body therapies (eg, deep breathing exercises, meditation, yoga) were used most commonly.
Only 4.5% of adults with migraines/severe headaches reported using CAM to specifically treat their migraines/severe headaches.
In order to get the inflated figure you have to include treatments that are, at best, in the gray zone. This is a game proponents of CAM have been playing for years – the definition is vague enough that they can include common practices an inflate the apparent popularity of CAM. Even the lower figure of 49.5% includes people who are simply exercising.
Cowan also did not mention that the same study found that only 4.5% of migraine patients use CAM to treat their migraine. That would have undercut his premise that use is common so that headache doctors need to pay attention.
He continues with perhaps the second most common CAM trope:
There is limited evidence suggesting the vast majority of these treatments are harmful (regardless of the evidence they are helpful), and most have withstood “the test of time,” having been handed down over hundreds, even thousands of years.
“The test of time” has proven to be utterly worthless. Galenic medicine, based on balancing the four humors, survived for a couple thousand years even though its interventions almost certainly caused harm and no benefit. It only faded away in the wake of scientific medicine.
The plural of anecdote is not data, and this includes anecdotes over a long period of time. Long use of treatments can be explained by cultural inertia, in the absence of any real benefit.
Further, lack of evidence of harm is not very compelling. Anecdotal evidence is useful in eliminating immediate obvious harm, such as deadly poisons, but not useful in exposing long term harm or low probability harm.
There are now plenty of example of herbal remedies, used for centuries, that only recently were discovered to have significant toxicity, such as aristolochia and renal failure or kava kava and liver damage. Many herbal supplements also contain heavy metal contaminants, or don’t even have the ingredients on their labels, opening the door for unknown allergic reactions or drug-drug interactions.
Risks are not limited to herbal drugs. Chiropractic neck manipulation has been linked to a rare but serious complication of stroke and even death. A review of acupuncture side effects found they occurred in 11.4% of treatments.
Much of the harm of CAM is also indirect. Patients expending time and limited resources on treatments that are ineffective may delay or even forgo science-based treatments. Even for self-limiting or purely symptomatic syndromes, there is potential harm in patients being convinced that an unscientific treatment is effective due to practitioner recommendation and placebo effects. If a patient feels their migraines are improved due to acupuncture, perhaps they will be more open to using acupuncture to treat their cancer and delay definitive treatment. (Yes – some “medical acupuncturists” advocate using acupuncture to treat cancer.)
It is unreasonable to expect practitioners in an unscientific paradigm to be science-based in the application on their interventions.
I also have to wonder which treatments Dr. Cowan believes have been around for thousands of years. Perhaps some herbs have been in use for that long, and those that work are mostly already incorporated into modern pharmacology. Acupuncture is often claimed to be thousands of years old, but prior to the 20th century acupuncture had more in common with bloodletting than what passes today for acupuncture. Chiropractic and naturopathy are less than two centuries old, and homeopathy is a little over two centuries.
Cowan also does not discuss evidence for lack of efficacy, and like many CAM proponents pretends that this does not exist. There is sufficient evidence, for example, that acupuncture does not work for any specific indication, and specifically does not work for migraine (despite the claims of acupuncturists).
Cowan makes the usual excuse, however:
The most widely used of these are Ayurveda, classical Chinese medicine, homeopathy, chiropractic, and naturopathy. Because these are medical systems rather than discrete interventions, studies are much harder to come by and in general, each has its own internal logic. It is much more difficult to evaluate a system which is based on centuries of trial and error or of an oral tradition.
Why? If any of these interventions work, regardless of their internal logic or history, careful clinical trials should show an effect. I would also point out that astrology has an internal logic. That is not sufficient to make a philosophy legitimate or recommend it as a medical system.
He mentions homeopathy in a few places in the article, without ever pointing out that homeopathy is based purely on magical thinking, that its premises run contrary to modern science, and that a large body of clinical evidence shows that homeopathy does not work for anything.
Here, however, is the worst statement in the entire article:
To summarize, what is presently accepted as conventional medicine came to be so by caveat. Other medical systems have neither been subject to the rigorous vetting that Western medicine approaches have undergone in order to further develop nor have they been demonstrated to be ineffective or dangerous in any systematic way. In other words, there are no scientifically accepted criteria for inclusion or exclusion of specific modalities as CAM or as conventional. Conventional medicine is exactly that – medicine by convention.
He is arguing that scientific medicine won out over competing medical systems because Flexner (a German educator and not a physician) arbitrarily decided that science would be the basis of modern medicine. This is an astounding argument, considering that the application of scientific principles transformed the practice of medicine and has arguably doubled the human life-expectancy since its inception.
Cowan again also ignores the fact that competing systems at the time not only lacked scientific evidence, many of them were demonstrably absurd. Homeopathy was ridiculed long before the Flexner report.
Further, regardless of history, scientific evidence is clearly the best tool we have to determining if a treatment is safe and effective. There is simply no viable alternative. He is also flatly wrong when he argues that CAM systems have not been demonstrated to be ineffective – they largely have, as I pointed out for homeopathy and acupuncture.
Conclusion
Cowan tries very hard to make it seem as if he is being objective and is simply looking out for the best interests of patients. In the end, however, in this article he has simply repeated the misconceptions and distortions typical of CAM proponents
He makes a false dichotomy between “Western” medicine and alternative medicines. He exaggerates CAM’s popularity, and blurs the line between CAM and scientific medicine by including treatments that are solidly science-based, such as nutrition and exercise.
He pretends that the scientific basis of medicine is just an arbitrary historical choice, rather than the transformational and defining aspect of modern medicine that finally dragged the medical profession out of the era of witch-doctors.
He pretends that we do not already have sufficient evidence for lack of efficacy for most CAM modalities. I would add that a science-based approach would also consider plausibility, which most CAM modalities lack.
In the end Cowan used an elaborate and indirect justification for the same list of magical and disproved therapies that CAM proponents have been promoting for years.
I agree that physicians need to be more familiar with CAM treatments and discuss such issues with patients when appropriate. They should do so, however, from a solid understanding of the actual science and history of such treatments.

And Now for Something Completely Different
Harriet Hall on December 17, 2013
Link
This will be a departure from my usual posts. Several announcements in the news and medical journals have caught my attention recently, and as I delved into the details, I thought I would share them with our SBM readers. Topics include AIDS cures, the continuing danger of polio, eating nuts for longevity, racial differences in vitamin D, and the use of pharmacogenetic testing to guide the dosage of anticoagulant drugs. They are all examples of science-based medicine in action.
Have patients been cured of AIDS?
I read that the HIV virus had returned in patients thought to have been cured by bone marrow transplants, and I mistakenly thought they were referring to the original claim of cure I had read about. Nope, that one still stands.
The CCR5-Δ32 mutation encodes a cell-surface receptor that allows the HIV virus to attach and enter a host cell. People with two copies of that gene are resistant to HIV infection, even considered immune. An AIDS patient in Germany, Timothy Ray Brown, developed leukemia and was intentionally given a bone marrow transplant from a person who had that mutation, and the HIV virus became undetectable in his blood. He was considered to be the first person “cured” of AIDS. Bone marrow transplants are risky and are not an option for treating AIDS in the absence of a malignancy. Subsequently, two other men with AIDS and lymphoma were treated with bone marrow transplants from donors without the mutation; it was hoped that the “graft vs. host” battle would eliminate the HIV virus from their bodies, and indeed their HIV levels became undetectable. After several months, they stopped taking their antiretroviral drugs, and doctors hoped they had been cured. Unfortunately, detectable levels of the virus returned after 12 weeks and 32 weeks off medication, respectively.
The CCR5-Δ32 mutation remains an intriguing avenue for further research into mechanisms, vaccines, and the possibility of a treatment based on the mutation that doesn’t involve the risks of bone marrow transplantation.
AIDS is one of the great triumphs of science-based medicine. It took only 2 years to identify the responsible retrovirus after the first clinical cases were reported. Big Pharma was quick to prove the value of a drug that was already available (zidovudine) and to develop several classes of new, effective drugs known for highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART). It took little more than a decade to turn a death sentence into a chronically-manageable disease with a nearly normal life expectancy. And at the same time, AIDS denialists and superstitious CAMsters were responsible for around 171,000 AIDS cases and 343,000 deaths between 1999 and 2007 alone. I can’t think of a better example of why science-based medicine is important and why we need efforts like this blog to combat nonscientific thinking.
Has a baby been cured of AIDS?
A child whose mother was HIV positive was empirically started on antiretroviral treatment 30 hours after birth, and treatment was continued after tests on the infant met the diagnostic criteria for infection. On treatment, the infant’s HIV-1 RNA levels progressively dropped until they were undetectable at 29 days of age. Compliance was suspected to be poor, and the mother admitted she had stopped giving the child medication at age 15 months. The child is now 30 months old and neither the virus nor viral antibodies are detectable. This is only one case report, and it’s too early to say whether the child is cured, but it suggests the possibility that early antiretroviral treatment in newborns may interfere with the development of persistent reservoirs of virus. These patients may not need a lifetime of therapy.
Will eating nuts prolong your life?
A study published in The New England Journal of Medicine showed an association between the reported frequency of nut consumption and mortality. Headlines trumpeted “Go Nuts!” Previous studies had suggested a beneficial effect, and a randomized primary prevention trial had shown a reduction in cardiovascular events on a Mediterranean diet supplemented with walnuts, hazelnuts, or almonds. The new study was a high-quality trial showing a dose-response relationship: the more nuts a person ate, the less likely he was to die of all causes and of specific causes (cancer, heart disease, and respiratory disease). Separate analyses for tree nuts and peanuts showed similar results. The authors stressed that they had found a correlation and were not claiming causation. Unidentified variables could have been a cause, and reverse causality is possible: maybe people in poor health are less likely to eat nuts.
The FDA allows advertisers to claim that “eating 1.5 ounces per day of walnuts, as part of a low saturated fat and low cholesterol diet and not resulting in increased caloric intake, may reduce the risk of coronary heart disease.” Besides the high calorie density of nuts, another caveat is the possible risk of salmonella from nuts.
Racial differences in vitamin D
A recent study measured vitamin D-binding protein levels in white and black Americans. The Institute of Medicine recommends a blood level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D greater than 20 ng per milliliter to maximize bone health, but blacks can have lower levels without any decrease in bone mineral density. Vitamin D levels are lower in blacks than in whites; but since levels of vitamin D-binding protein are also lower due to genetic variants, their bioavailable vitamin D is the same. Blacks have higher calcium levels, bone density, and slightly higher parathyroid hormone levels than whites. Evolutionary explanations have been suggested for racial differences that developed as people with dark skin moved to climates with less sun. Blacks are being over-diagnosed as vitamin D deficient based on blood tests that do not reflect a true vitamin D deficiency. We need a better test to measure bioavailable vitamin D.
No country is safe from polio
In 1988 polio was endemic in 125 countries, with 350,000 new cases of paralysis annually. Thanks to an aggressive vaccination campaign, the incidence has been reduced by 99% and polio is now endemic in just 3 countries (Afghanistan, Nigeria, and Pakistan). Wild-type poliovirus type 3 is close to eradication, and type 2 is probably already eradicated, but type 1 remains in circulation and is a threat to every country including those that are currently polio-free. China’s last case of indigenous wild-type poliovirus infection was in 1994. A few cases of wild-type virus infections have been imported from Myanmar and India since then. China experienced a polio outbreak in 2011 in the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region. The index case was a 16-month-old girl with no history of travel, but nucleotide sequencing confirmed that it was a strain imported from Pakistan. 21 confirmed cases and 23 clinically-compatible cases were found. The population was already close to herd-immunity thresholds. Of the ten affected children, three had not received oral polio vaccine (OPV), two had received one or two doses, and five had received three or more doses, indicating primary vaccination failure.
The Chinese Ministry of Health declared an emergency and responded vigorously. They were able to stop the spread of the disease within a month and a half, but they continued vaccinating until 43.7 million doses of oral polio vaccine had been given at a cost of $26 million. Adults were included, and OPV was given regardless of vaccination history. The oral vaccine has several advantages: low cost, ease of administration, can passively immunize non-recipients, and produces better intestinal immunity to reduce spread. It has the disadvantage that it can cause paralysis on rare occasions and can regain some of the properties of wild strains. Adverse event reporting was required during the vaccination campaign, but I wasn’t able to find the resulting data; it would be interesting to know, so we could directly compare benefits to risks. Eliminating type 2 from the trivalent vaccine is expected to reduce the risks. One shot of inactivated poliovirus can be used to maintain the protection against a possible recurrence of type 2.
Lessons to be learned: polio vaccines are not 100% effective, and every country in the world remains at risk until worldwide eradication is achieved (hopefully by 2014). Vaccine rejecters are a danger to worldwide public health.
Genetic testing not useful to determine warfarin dosage
Pharmacogenetics holds great promise for predicting individual responses to drugs based on genetic variants, but so far there are not many practical applications. One of the first proposals was to guide warfarin (Coumadin) dosage by genome testing. When I first heard this, my initial reaction was “Why bother?” Warfarin is an anticoagulant used to reduce the risk of blood clots in patients with atrial fibrillation, artificial heart valves, deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary embolism, and other conditions. Dosage is adjusted to keep the international normalized ratio (INR) of clotting factors within a prescribed range, usually between 2.0 and 3.0. This requires frequent blood tests and dosage adjustments (up to three times a week at first, and eventually decreasing to monthly in fortunate patients whose INR is stable). All kinds of medications, foods, and other factors affect the INR, so fluctuations are common. Overdosage can lead to serious bleeding complications and can be counteracted by vitamin K. Some patients require much higher doses than others; but that’s not a problem, since you can simply start with a low dose and titrate upwards as needed. Genetic variants of cytochrome enzymes affect the metabolism, requiring either higher or lower doses than usual to maintain the desired INR.
Pharmacogenetic enthusiasts predicted that genomic testing would be a more precise way to control dosage and would reduce the risk of clotting or bleeding complications. Recently three studies were simultaneously published in The New England Journal of Medicine to determine whether usual care or genome-guided care provided better control. The first found no difference, the second found a small (7%) advantage to genomic guidance, and the third found no difference. An accompanying editorial points out that the studies only covered the initiation phase without long-term follow-up, and concludes that pharmacogenetic testing is of marginal usefulness at best and represents a large expense. It suggests we should concentrate on making the current practice safer with better management.

April Fool Cannot Surpass SCAM
Mark Crislip on April 1, 2016
Link


It’s April Fools’ day in the US of A. One of the internet traditions is to come up with a story that is weird or unlikely, but not so weird or unlikely that it is not believable, in order to fool people that the story is real.
I gave it the old SBM try, I really did, but I couldn’t do it. I wanted to come up with a SCAM therapy so weird, so unlikely, that I could not find an example of it actually being practiced.
It can’t be done. Like a Trump utterance*, you can’t invent a SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine) that someone, somewhere, has already pulled out of, er, well, thin air and are using it on patients.
Of course, what would you expect given that many SCAMs were in fact, pulled out of, er, well thin air. Think chiropractic and DD Palmer, iridology by August von Peczely, and reiki by Mikao Usui. Making up fantastical stuff is what they do.
But even within the spectrum of pseudo-medicine there are those are practices and papers that are so bizarro they should be an April Fools’ joke. But are not. It may be a matter of taste, what one person considers wack-a-loon another would find imminently reasonable. There are certainly assigned delegates that prove that assertion. But even within the wack-a-loon world of SCAM, there are those practices and papers that are more wack-a-loon than others and should be April Fools’ jokes. Maybe it is like more unique. Unique is one of a kind, so something can’t be more one of a kind. More wack-a-loon? Such is the world of SCAM.
Acupunctures and voodoo
There are dozens and dozens of forms of acupunctures, probably as many as there are practitioners of the art. Art as in a blacklight velvet Elvis painting. The variety is remarkable. But almost all are some variation of literally sticking it to the patient. Not Tong Ren.
In this form of acupunctures, the patient hits a meridian-covered voodoo doll with a magnetic hammer to alter energy. Really. Watch the video.
Homeopathy
Virtually any substance can be turned into a homeopathic nostrum.
Homeopathic remedies can also be made from non-material sources, for instance, electricity, musical frequencies, magnetic fields, and even moonlight. In fact, the possibilities are infinite.
If you can use duck liver and heart at 200C, you can use anything. But the most wack-a-loon is sound, digitalized into an mp3 as a cure for Ebola<. EBOLA!!
It turns out that the energetic signal in homeopathic remedies can be extracted via a device consisting of a simple coil connected to an amplifier and digitizer, and the resulting signal can be stored on a computer as a .wav or .mp3 file. A .wav file? You would trust your digitized homeopathic cure to a .wav/Windows format? With Ebola it gives a new meaning to blue screen of death.
At least there was no waterboarding
There is a lot of basic animal pseudo-science on acupuncture, AKA rat abuse. There have been thousands of rats used in acupuncture studies, all for no good purpose. Especially from the rat’s viewpoint.But who wants to know the effect of electroacupuncture at different acupoints on hormones and neurotransmitters of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis in rats under simulated weightlessness? It is just not a question that needs answering on Planet Reality.
These researchers do. Probably the only ones in the entire world. NASA could have/should have been in the April Fools’ business as well with the headline “Astrobiology Acupuncture“, although they were just using an acupuncture needle to probe a rock, no chi or meridians involved.
I do not have access to the full text of Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, the Chinese journal that published the rat abuse. So I only have the abstract , but they used:
tail suspension to simulate weightlessness effect.
Suspending a rat from its tail is in no way simulating weightlessness. Hanging me from my ankles is not going to simulate weightlessness.
So if I understand the article, they hung rats by their tails, stuck them with needles, and shocked them. I think that’s called the Guantanamo method. All to answer a question no one gives a rat’s ass about.
Worst. Animal. Study. Ever.
Medical Time Cube
The Time Cube, the archetype of pseudo-physics, is gone. Long live the Time Cube!The Time Cube suggests (all errors, grammatical, mathematical, logical, factual, rational, ecumenical, theological, and/or historical from the glorious original):
If Earth stood still, it would have mid-day, mid-night, sun-up and sun-down as 4 corners. Each rotation of earth has 4 mid-days, 4 mid-nights, 4 sun-ups and 4 sun-downs. The sixteen(16) space times demonstrates cube proof of 4 full days simultaneously on earth within one (1) rotation. The academia created 1 day greenwich time is bastardly queer and dooms future youth and nature to a hell. Ignorance of 4 day harmonic cubic nature indicts humans as unfit to live on earth.
Fortunately, there is nothing in medicine that can be described as a spinning…oops!
Vital Force receives a modern incarnation as a metaphorical multidimensional spinning gyroscope.
But at least it is not quantum…oops!
Quantum theoretical discourse has previously illustrated (1) the therapeutic process as three-way macro-entanglement (between patient, practitioner, and remedy, called PPR entanglement), and (2) depicted the Vital Force (Vf) as a quantized spinning gyroscope.
And 45 others. The most extended Sokal riff in the history of Pubmed? Nope. As serious as a heart attack.
Gadgets
There is no end of gadgets not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease, but nothing is as impressive as the SweatEvaporating/Sauna/HealthyUrn/NanoAnion/NegativeIon/FarInfraredRay/Hyperthermia/Fumigate/PulseMagneticField/PurpleClay/Underglaze Pastel And Brown-glazed—Birds Chirping In Plum-Flowering Shrubs…hinged pot? ChairVase? Elaborate bucket? Spare bedroom?
It has anion therapy, fumigating therapy, hyperthermia therapy, molecular-friction-heat reaction, and pulsed magnetic circulating field therapy. Impressive. It actually surpasses the revolutionary new insoles that combine five forms of pseudoscience.
Although they do warn:
Because of traditional handmade product, it is kindly for your understanding that actual product dimensions have slightly errors.
I suspect it is more than the dimensions that have slightly errors.
Some would say that $24,900 would be a bit much for such power in an urn but it has free shipping. And if chirping birds are not your thing, they have a bird-free version for $ 26,900. You have to pay extra to avoid being given the bird.
Legislating reality
Legislatures have tried to make of pseudo-science the law of the land. The most infamous may be the attempt to make pi equal to 3.14, although that is a bit of a myth. The altitude is getting to the Swiss. They have decided that:
Homeopathy, holistic medicine, herbal medicine, acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine will acquire the same status as conventional medicine by May 2017.
Why?
The ministry has finally come to the conclusion that it impossible to verify the efficacy of these therapies in their entirety. It has therefore opted to accept them on par with other medical disciplines.
Really. The mind boggles. Every SCAM meets that criterion.
By that standard they might as well add SweatEvaporating/Sauna/HealthyUrn/NanoAnion/NegativeIon/FarInfraredRay/Hyperthermia/Fumigate/PulseMagneticField/PurpleClay/Underglaze Pastel And Brown-glazed—Birds Chirping In Plum-Flowering Shrubs to their health care system. But it is no different than Oregon, where naturopaths are primary care docs. I have been getting the odd referral (deliberate choice of words) from NDs as they try to apply their form of medical Guitar Hero to patient care.
I see lots of curious antibiotic usage by other providers. Usually it is overkill due to the fog of medicine, the fear, uncertainty and doubt that occurs in the hospital around acutely ill patients. But here is a real quote from the chart I saw a couple of months ago in a patient with no diagnosis after extensive testing:
Initiation of penicillin as an attempt to eradicate anything that may be present of an infectious nature.
I read that out loud in clinic and my office mate laughed and said “has to be a naturopath.”
Yep. Even with my 35 years of work in infectious diseases I can’t think of any infection, however improbable in this case, that would be expected to respond to 10 days of 500 mg po of Penicillin VK.
That one sentence encapsulates a tremendous lack of understanding about the nature of infectious disease and the proper use of antibiotics. The inchoate idea that there is this ‘anything’ that could be the vague idea of ‘infection’ that can be ‘eradicated ‘with an antibiotic. Just what would be expected for a provider with no education or training in reality-based medicine.
April Fools’ jokes. They just cannot surpass the reality of SCAM.

*The most reliable way to get me to make a snide political comment is to complain of a prior one. I must, just must, poke the monkey with a stick.

Hungover
Hangovers: a problem with only one solution.
Mark Crislip on October 15, 2024
Link
A relatively brief post for me this month. It takes me a couple of weeks to produce these essays and a big chunk of the time I would usually spend on writing is going to be traveling. I most certainly lack the energy to blog and be a tourist. You know the saying, when in Rome, don’t work.
I must be on some sort of e-mail list. I receive many emails suggesting I interview providers of Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicines, aka SCAMs. Evidently, I am someone who is interested in promoting pet acupuncture or fascial maneuvers or, as an inspiration for this post, a hangover preventative. At no time in my writing or podcasting endeavors have I ever shown an interest in promoting these products and I have never done an interview.
Someone has not done their due diligence and reviewed my vast multimedia empire to see if I would be an appropriate sucker, er, I mean, person for the task. Reviewing these promotions was something that the late, great Harriet Hall used to do. I do miss her writing. It did occur to me that these emails would make good blog fodder, and while Harriet and I had different writing styles, we did share a similar skepticism. And maybe I will be removed from said mailing list as a result. I can wish.
The email in questions was for Jelly IV, a
plant-based, jelly-formatted hangover cure is designed to tackle the “hangover effect,”
since
Jelly IV combines the best of Eastern medicine with modern wellness trends, delivering a practical solution to a common workplace issue. With just one dose before bed, employees can wake up refreshed, reducing absenteeism and ensuring productivity the next day.
Ah, combining the best of both worlds, a la Hanna Montana. My kids loved that show. It is what one genius blogger referred to as the cow pie in apple pie effect. If you like intellectual shortcuts, such a declaration has almost perfect sensitivity and specificity that whatever is being touted is likely worthless and you need not read further. I get no such luxury, for read on I must.
Would I be interested in speaking with the inventor? Um, no. Did you read this blog or listen to the Quackcast? I think not. Just who generated this email list? I guess PR competence parallels SCAM practitioner competence. But it did bring up the question, how does one treat a hangover? An important topic if, say, one was about to travel to the land of pasta and wine.
As an aside, there are also red wine headaches, that are due to histamines found in red wines (20-200 times that found in white wine and some other alcoholic drinks) although there are other potential causes of red wine headaches. I notice of late the waiters now ask if you want a beverage instead of a drink. I want a drink. Anyway.
Headache can be induced by histamine in wine in patients suffering from histamine intolerance, a disease characterized by impaired histamine degradation based on reduced diamine oxidase activity or a lack of the enzyme.
A little non-sedating antihistamine may prevent the headache. It did save my dad’s wine tasting club.
But that isn’t a hangover. It has probably been 50 years since I have had a hangover. College, if I remember correctly. Been there, done that, and vowed never to do it again.
Before moving on to Jelly IV, and other hangover interventions, what is the cause of a hangover? I mean, besides drinking too much alcohol. What is the pathophysiology? Once we understand that, we can then determine the likelihood that a hangover cure is better than the hair of the dog what bit you. A curious expression, it comes from
The expression originally referred to a method of treatment for a rabid dog bite by placing hair from the dog in the bite wound.
The Wikipedia page also points out this is a ‘like cures like’ treatment, so beloved by homeopaths.
Hangovers were not an important part of my medical practice. ETOH withdrawal, overdose, and complications of cirrhosis (along with Chrohn’s and ophthalhmology, medical words where I never remember where the ‘h’ goes) were common enough, but I do not think I ever saw a hungover patient. I had it in my mind that hangovers were due to a combination of dehydration (alcohol is a diuretic) and a mild poisoning from acetaldehyde, as the liver’s alcohol dehydrogenase oxidizes ethanol to acetaldehyde, and then aldehyde dehydrogenase oxidizes acetaldehyde to acetate, the way ethanol is metabolized.
Turns out the literature on hangover is rather sparse. And the studies are often of poor quality
Many of the human studies of hangover are not well controlled, with subjects consuming different concentrations of alcohol over variable time periods and evaluation not blinded. Also, studies have measured different symptoms and use varying methods of measurement.
Not a surprise upon reflection, as it is a process that I think would be difficult to find volunteers to study. I would not want to deliberately, or accidentally, have another hangover.
One review notes
In contrast, research on the pathology of the alcohol hangover remains limited. Reviews on this topic suggest a variety of possible causes of the alcohol hangover such as the role of the presence of ethanol and its metabolites in the blood, oxidative stress, and the immune response to alcohol consumption. However, the data presented in these reviews to support these hypotheses are limited.
And another article notes
These analyses showed that concentrations of various hormones, electrolytes, free fatty acids, triglycerides, lactate, ketone bodies, cortisol, and glucose were not significantly correlated with reported alcohol hangover severity. Also, markers of dehydration (e.g., vasopressin) were not significantly related to hangover severity. Some studies report a significant correlation between blood acetaldehyde concentration and hangover severity, but most convincing is the significant relationship between immune factors and hangover severity. The latter is supported by studies showing that hangover severity may be reduced by inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis. Several factors do not cause alcohol hangover but can aggravate its severity. These include sleep deprivation, smoking, congeners, health status, genetics and individual differences.
Much to my surprise, even dehydration is likely not a major cause of a hangover
Survey data revealed that water consumption during or directly after alcohol consumption had only a modest effect in preventing next-day hangover. Also, the amount of water consumed during hangover was not related to changes of hangover severity and thirst. Thus, water consumption was not effective to alleviate the alcohol hangover.
So the cause of a hangover is likely multifactorial, although one review suggests that it is the rate at which you metabolize the alcohol that is important. The slower the metabolism, the more the alcohol poisoning (alcohol, unlike acetaldehyde, easily crosses the blood-brain barrier) and the greater the hangover:
The data summarized in this review suggest that the ethanol elimination rate is a critical determinant of hangover severity for a number of reasons. First, significant correlations have been found between ethanol concentration (but not acetaldehyde) and hangover severity. Second, nutrients, microbiota, and hangover treatments that speed up the conversion of ethanol into acetaldehyde are associated with less severe hangovers. Taken together, the data suggest that a more rapid conversion of ethanol to acetaldehyde and other aldehydes is associated with less severe hangovers.
It is not unreasonable to postulate that anything that increases alcohol metabolism could lead to less severe hangovers. But alcohol is a poison with widespread effects on many physiologic processes, so there is likely no simple solution to the physiology or treatment of a hangover, outside of the unacceptable choice of avoiding a vieux carre or negroni.
The most effective way to avoid the symptoms of alcohol induced hangover is to practise (sic) abstinence or moderation.
Moderation works for me. But let’s one does imbibe a wee bit too much and drives the porcelain bus. Are there SBM approved effective interventions for hangovers? Not really.
From these studies it must be concluded that most remedies do not significantly reduce overall hangover severity. Some compounds reduce specific symptoms such as vomiting and headache, but are not effective in reducing other common hangover symptoms such as drowsiness and fatigue. Hangover cures that showed positive effects were those inhibiting prostaglandin synthesis or accelerating alcohol metabolism. Future studies should elucidate the pathology of alcohol hangover. Until then, it is unlikely that an effective hangover cure will be developed.
There was a meta-analysis of all the double-blind studies in the BMJ
The agents tested were propranolol, tropisetron, tolfenamic acid, fructose or glucose, and the dietary supplements Borago officinalis (borage), Cynara scolymus (artichoke), Opuntia ficus-indica (prickly pear), and a yeast based preparation. All studies were double-blind.
And the findings?
No compelling evidence exists to suggest that any conventional or complementary intervention is effective for preventing or treating alcohol hangover.
There are many supplements and herbs, that purport to cure or prevent hangover. Not good data for any of them. Jelly iv, which inspired this essay, has a science page with non-referenced descriptions of the contents of the product. Jelly iv contains dihydromyricetin, which in high doses has many antagonistic effects on alcohol in rats. Although the data in rats, depending on the study, is iffy:
although the expected hepatoprotective effect of dhm was not fully achieved, dhm (in a concentration manner) proved to reduce the level of ros/rns in hepatocytes. however, no change in the rate of alcohol metabolism in vivo was found when rats were administered with a single or repeated dose of ethanol supplemented with dhm. in conclusion, the proposed positive effect of dhm during alcohol intoxication has not been proven.
Humans are not rats. Well, some of the time. I could not find studies to support the use of dihydromyricetin in humans.
Jelly IV also contains artichoke extract, which has been studied and
Our results suggest that artichoke extract is not effective in preventing the signs and symptoms of alcohol-induced hangover.
Although it is not used as such in this hangover preventative. It is used for liver protection and elimination of (unnamed) toxins.
At this point I grew bored. Outside of electrolytes, none of the included products seem to target the symptoms of hangovers or any alleged pathophysiology. They just provide ‘support’. So many alternative medicine treatments act as nothing more than a truss. It is usually unproductive to go down the rat hole of the evidence for any herbal products effectiveness. At best they are extrapolations from marginal basic science. All sound and fury, signifying nothing. I did wonder about the name. Jelly IV. It is not an intravenous product (I hope), since it is a jelly. The fourth iteration? Jelly. Jelly Jr. Jelly the third. Now Jelly IV.
There are a variety of homeopathic hangover treatments, at least 7, depending on the subtle variations in your symptoms. Splitting headache with movement or just a headache. Is there flatulence? Then a different nostrum. But no human studies on Pubmed to demonstrate efficacy.
Oddly, the most popular homeopathic cure for a hangover is 30C (i.e., nothing) of the wonderfully named Nux Vomica tree, but not ethanol. It would seem the perfect opportunity to demonstrate that like cures like. Nope. Nux Vomica is also used to treat digestive problems such as constipation, bloating, heartburn, and nausea, male infertility and impotence, colds and flu, particularly in the early stages of the virus, allergies, back pain, irritability, impatience, and high sensitivity to stimuli, caused by stress or mental strain, headaches and migraines symptoms such as a sore scalp, frontal pain, light sensitivity, or stomach problems, menstrual problems and insomnia. All processes with a similar underlying pathophysiology to hangover, he notes sarcastically.
Quite the wonder drug that works wonders.
Chiropractic will treat your hangover
By realigning the spine and promoting nervous system function, chiropractic adjustments can provide relief from headache pain and support your body’s natural healing processes.
I doubt it.
By addressing the root causes of hangover symptoms and promoting overall wellness, chiropractic adjustments can offer a natural solution for those post-party symptoms
The need for spinal adjustment is the root cause of a hangover? Here I thought it was drinking too much alcohol. Glad I wasn’t enjoying a beverage when I read that. I hate milk coming out my nose. The AI summary is very positive for using chiropractic for hangover, referencing, well, chiropractors who say they can treat hangovers. Go to Midas, get a muffler.
But the real root cause it not the spine. Nope. It is alcohol as
When you drink alcohol, it enters your Stomach and is digested by your Spleen and Stomach organ systems. Thus the nutrients that can be derived from it are processed, and the remaining elements excreted as waste. But because of the volatile Damp-Hot nature of booze, when you drink too much of it your ability to process the volatility becomes corrupted. When this happens, the Damp-Heat persists, and a few things can happen
What followed was a traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine explanation of persisting damp-heat aka gibberish. Yes, there are words there. Nouns. Verbs. Adjective. But no, they make zero sense. The site was interesting as it warned of the danger of using the wrong acupoints:
Once again it’s good advice to seek the proper diagnosis of a TCM practitioner, as taking the wrong herbs or using the wrong acupuncture points for your own personal pattern could lead to you feeling even worse.
I do not believe I have ever seen that warning before. Just how does one go about determining what constitutes a proper fictional diagnosis?
But there are a variety of acupoints and Chinese herbs used for the non-treatment of a hangover. Like chiropractic and homeopathy, none proven in clinical trials.
My browser AI summary was also quite positive for acupuncture for hangover. Looking at the links, it was because acupuncture sites were positive about using acupuncture for hangover. Using AI with SCAM is not a good combination, all garbage in/garbage out.
And if you search for naturopathic cures, you will find plenty of advice, often multiple and expensive, to cure your hangover.
It is safe to say that most SCAMs offer a treatment for hangovers, even reiki, although participating in reiki with the wrong people can induce a hangover-like state. So beware.
So my take home? Got me. Hangovers are a problem with no solution and prevention is not gonna happen if you drink too much. Salute.

ovember Hodgepodge
Mark Crislip on November 18, 2011
Link
There have not been a lot of topics of late that warrant extensive analysis and discussion.  But there are a number of little topics of interest, each worthy of a few paragraphs of discussion, archetypes of issues in medicine, science based and otherwise.
Xigirs. No, it is not whale vomit, but close.
Last month Xigris  was pulled from the market by Lilly.  Yes, I understand the shock. Xigris, we hardly knew ye.   Xigris is the brand name for drotrecogin alfa, or activated protein C.  It is an enzyme in the clotting cascade that is/was given for the treatment of sepsis.
Sepsis is the syndrome the occurs when bacteria, or  parts of the bacteria, get into the blood stream.  A large number of mind bogglingly complex physiologic derangements occur, often with refractory multi-organ system failure and death.  At a minimum sepsis kills one in three, about 200,000 deaths a year in the US. During my career the best and brightest have looked for interventions that modify the underlying pathophysiology and alter the course of the disease.  Besides antibiotics and support of failing organ systems, there had been no breakthroughs in the treatments of sepsis until the PROWESS trial  in 2002, published in the NEJM, that demonstrated  survival benefit in patients with severe sepsis: 24.7% of patients taking Xigris surviving and 30.8% in the placebo group died.
Although the drug was approved, the vote was split and there was debate about the results from the beginning. Besides the study protocol changing in mid-trial, the survival benefit was only found in post hoc subgroup analysis aka data dredging.
Was it a statistical fluke or the real deal?  Well, at up to $20,000 a therapeutic course, Lilly was of the opinion it was of benefit:
Xigris is a proven lifesaving advance for the treatment of adult patients with life-threatening severe sepsis. To imply otherwise in the pages of one of the world’s most prestigious medical journals — 10 months after the FDA approved this therapy based on the strength of our clinical data — attempts to turn back the clock on the treatment of severe sepsis. The opinion article’s assertions serve only to confuse physicians who are attempting to make the best treatment decisions for their patients with severe sepsis, ” says August M. Watanabe, MD, executive vice president of science and technology for Lilly. “We disagree with the authors’ suggestion that we should contemplate denying severe sepsis patients fighting for their lives access to an FDA-approved therapy in order to replicate the proven findings from the largest trial of its kind ever conducted. In our viewpoint, that would be unethical.”
And
Severe sepsis shows no mercy, so I want to offer my patients every advantage in their struggle to survive,” Greg A. Schmidt, MD, from the University of Chicago in Illinois, says in Lilly’s news release. “There is no doubt in my mind that Xigris, when used appropriately, is an unprecedented, lifesaving advance for this vulnerable patient population.
So, do you want to give our drug despite real concerns about efficacy and safety,  or do you just want people to needlessly die?  I will defer that question to Ron Paul.  Quite the message for clinicians, who, of course, will always err on the side of patient survival.  There are times I truly sympathize with the anti-Pharma conspiracy proponents, I really do. So often Pharma companies behave just as one would expect if they were driven by greed with no concerns for patients. So I repeat the aphorism,  “Never ascribe to conspiracy that which is adequately explained by incompetence.”
When the drug was released hospitals developed guidelines to ensure that the agent was only used in severe sepsis, those in whom the drug was allegedly effective and where the risk was less than the benefit,  since there was an increased risk of bleeding with the drug.  My hospitals used less Xigris than other institutions in the Portland metropolitan area, and I heard through the grapevine that it was being suggested we were not providing optimal care since were relatively parsimonious in using the drug. As the years past, more studies were done, none definitive, that suggested Xigris had no efficacy but did have serious complications.  As of 2011 the Cochrane review concluded
This updated review found no evidence suggesting that APC (activated protein C) should be used for treating patients with severe sepsis or septic shock. Additionally, APC is associated with a higher risk of bleeding. Unless additional RCTs provide evidence of a treatment effect, policy-makers, clinicians and academics should not promote the use of APC.
Like acupuncture, despite mounting data that Xigris was neither safe nor effective, it’s use continued, although at volumes far less than Lilly would have liked.  When the drug was approved, Lilly was mandated to do another study to prove that Xigris was indeed effective and safe. Up to this year about a billion dollars had been spent on Xigris, but no longer, because a new trial demonstrated that yes indeed, PROWESS was a statistical fluke, and that Xigris as no better than placebo for the treatment of severe sepsis. Unlike acupuncture, or any number of SCAM’s, definite trials demonstrating lack of efficacy and safety are, eventually, heeded and Xigris was pulled from the market.
If Dr. Watanabe has any comment now, I can’t find it on the internet; he is evidently retired and Dr. Schmidt has also been silent in the topic.
There are multiple lessons to be learned from this very expensive exercise in medical futility.
1) Don’t trust the results of a single study, especially a study as flawed as PROWESS.
2) Don’t trust the results of a single study whose benefits are only demonstrated in after the fact analysis: post hoc subgroup analysis is not to be believed.
3) This is a good example of the so called decline effect, but is not due to the medications losing effectiveness, but to better designed studies removing potential bias.  My rule of thumb, which I discovered in a post hoc analysis, is that in the real world diagnostic tests and therapeutic interventions are only half as good as the published results.  Given the minimal effect in the poorly done studies for most CAM efficacy, a 50% decrease in real effectiveness takes even the most robust findings almost to zero.
4)  Medical practice changes and ineffective interventions are abandoned. Eventually.  That has never happens with CAM.
5) When I was an Intern I carried a NEJM article  in my coat on how to interpret  Swan-Ganz catheter measurements, and every time I had a patient with a Swan, I would re-read the paper until one day I realized I knew the information in the reference and chucked the paper into the recycler.  Swan’s are rarely used today (another change in practice due to evidence), but I would recommend to every resident they carry Why Most Published Research Findings Are False by John P. A. Ioannidis in their lab coat, and read it every time they get excited about a new intervention.  To bad Ioannidis was not available when the FDA was approving Xigris.
6)  And  damn if the whole this doesn’t just piss me the hell off, that so much time and money and potential patient risk was wasted all because of bad science and bio-politics.  But of course, if we ignored the bad science and bio-politics and only paid attention to the good science, there would be no Departments of Integrative Medicine.
Informed Consent
Dr. Novella, Jann Bellamy, and Orac have discussed the article in Paediatrics on informed consent and CAM.  The basic argument is that  physicians should give informed consent about those CAMs that allegedly are of increasingly proven value. Not that I can think of one that meets the criteria.  The arc of CAM and EBM has consistently been that better designed studies demonstrate decreasing effect until excellent studies show no effect.
The article start with a case designed to tug at the heart strings:
The parents of 6-year-old Jake, a young boy with medulloblastoma, are distressed by the nausea and vomiting he is suffering as a result of chemotherapy. His chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting (CINV) occur spontaneously and are also being triggered by sights, sounds, and smells for up to 2 weeks after a course of chemotherapy. His parents believe that this is preventing him from eating properly and that the psychological toll of the adverse effects of treatment are limiting his ability to combat the cancer. They ask Jake’s oncologist about other options to alleviate his nausea. He has tried dimenhydrinate and dexamethasone in addition to ondansetron, but like metoclopromide, they have not provided Jake with sufficient relief. Jake’s oncologist recommended that he continue with nabilone, a synthetic cannabinoid; however, Jake refuses to continue this drug, because it makes him feel dizzy and anxious. Disappointed, his parents resign themselves to the possibility that Jake might not find relief from his CINV.
While communicating online with other families of patients with cancer, Jake’s parents discover that a consensus panel through the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) has recognized the effectiveness of acupuncture for alleviating CINV. They ask their oncologist about it, but his response is noncommittal. Jake’s parents take him out on intermittent passes from the hospital to an acupuncturist in the community. They are delighted to see that his nausea and vomiting are much improved after each acupuncture session. Jake begins to regain his appetite, gains weight, and generally has a better sense of well-being.
Jake’s parents are upset that their physician, whom they believe also had access to information outlining the potential benefits of acupuncture, did not tell them that it was potentially a safe and effective treatment option for CINV. When they describe their son’s improvements after acupuncture, their physician dismisses them as a “placebo effect.” Jake’s parents are concerned that the physician instead offered antiemetic medications that, from their point of view, only created more problems and unnecessary adverse effects.
I would  like to offer a more realistic case:
6 year old Jake gets acupuncture, despite the studies that consistently demonstrate that acupuncture is no better than sham acupuncture even for cancer therapy induced nausea and vomiting and that sham acupuncture, such as toothpicks twirled on the skin, has fewer complications.
Because of the suppressed immune system and sloppy acupuncture technique, Jake gets an MRSA necrotizing fasciitis, bacteremia and sepsis that leads to increased vomiting, aspiration, respiratory failure and intubation. Despite aggressive debridement, including limb amputation, he dies of multiorgan system failure, primarily vomiting induced aspiration ARDS.
Oh, says the acupuncturist, it wasn’t my doing.
Due to guilt over inadvertently killing their son by inflicting upon him a dangerous yet worthless intervention, the parents  marriage dissolves in a bitter stew of recriminations, infidelity, and alcoholism.
I do agree with one aspect of the authors vignette:  acupuncture does have the potential to be safe.  It all too often fails to  live up to that potential as best I can tell.  But effective?  Not so much.
There are two studies that compare sham acupuncture with real acupuncture in oncologic nausea and vomiting: one for chemotherapy induced nausea and vomiting  and another for radiation induced nausea and vomiting.
Both showed that acupuncture and sham acupuncture were equal in decreasing nausea and vomiting.  When an intervention is equal to placebo, the procedure is considered to nothing.  The conclusion should be that acupuncture does nothing.  Oddly with acupuncture the conclusion is  often that both real and sham acupuncture are efficacious.  No wait.  Xigris was equal to a sham intervention.  Therefore they both work.  Xigirs need not be pulled from the market, just reposition it as an alternative therapy.  Lilly, you can keep the Xigris gravy train running.
To quote the abstract
However, as many as 95% of patients in both groups considered the treatment to be effective, and 89% were interested in receiving the treatments in the future.  In the light of the apparent conflict between lack of specific effects from verum acupuncture and large subjectively experienced positive effects it seems interesting to evaluate if acupuncture has antiemetic effects related to nonspecific mechanisms.
and the discussion
Our results indicate that nonspecific factors such as the extra care or the high expectations of positive treatment effects, not the specific characteristics of verum acupuncture, reduced emesis.
Acupuncture needles do nothing.  Like all SCAM, the benefits are the evolutionary equal of monkeys picking nits and grooming each other.  It is calming. So why risk killing a few children with cancer by sticking them with needles? Would it not be better to harness the power of the lie (and we all lie to our kids, just think Santa) by the parents kissing the boo boo to make it better?  And maybe get rid of some nits in the process.
Stare Master
Every city has its alternative newspaper, the edgy, often left leaning, and somewhat soft about science, freebie.  In Portland it is the Willamette Week, and being left leaning myself (my youngest son says I am edgy in the same way I am cool.  In other words not) I pick up a copy every week. In the November 9th edition there was a 3/4 page article in the Headout section entitled Stare Way to Heaven.  The topic does lend itself to plays on word.
I tend towards the left leaning, tree hugging approach to the world so I like the Willamette Week, but  I could not tell if the tone of the article  was meant to be ironic or  a legitimate health care recommendation.  I emailed the  author of the piece asking and he never responded. Although I want to see it as ironic, I can’t tell.   I am old enough that my hipster irony meter no longer functions, and perhaps it never has.
They recommend a visit to Braco, the Croatian gaze healer.  What does Braco do?  He just stands and looks at you, with what appears to be a kind face and a gentle smile.  That’s it.  He stands and stares  for 5 to 7 minutes and miracles happen, from cancers vanishing to preventing Irene induced apartment flooding.  His website specifically says his gaze is no substitute for medical care and Braco denies he is a healer, just a conduit for energies.  It is the gazed upon who make all the effusive claims of benefit.
My wife points out I tend to stare at people in public, especially if there have medical anomalies, and I know it is not polite to stare.  Unless you are Braco.  He is a marathon gazer:  “Groups of 50 to 1000 people gather for a healing session and Braco now does twenty sessions a day working 10-12 hours each day at locations across Europe. He is booked with appearances four years in advance.”  He charges 8 dollars per person for a 5 minute group gaze, preferring volume purchasing,  although the web sites say he does take any of the money for these appearances.  I would love to see his tax returns.
There is nothing unique in what Braco offers; it is another form of faith healing, albiet it a minimalist form for the practitioner.  Low overhead, minimal exertion, the epitome of the ideal of ‘don’t just do something, stand there.”  The explanations for the effects he has on others are the usual vague energies and consciousness raising:
Prof. Alex Schneider explains that “Braco is taking the people up to a higher level of consciousness. During those moments when he is gazing at us, he is lifting us up to this higher level where we can feel who we really are – and this is much more than just our physical body. He brings us home to ourselves!
and
But today, we have some ideas about the structures in the human nervous system that allow some individuals to affect a “non-local reality” just by mere intention. Although Braco doesn’t consider himself to be the saint of any congregation, he often experiences the states of  “inner certainty” that things are taking a certain course. He avoids pointing to the individuals in question because that always creates the flow of unneccesary and counterproductive inquieries that are threatening the positive outcome when it’s already at the sight.
The spontaneous and natural flow of energies is an absolute must. The surrender to “what is” is the most favorable starting point to resolve any complex and seemingly hopeless situation.
It is generally believed that there are two possible ways Braco’s „non-active action“ works. First, it’s the activation of a brain structure now known as The God’s Module and second, the creation of a radical change in spiritual anatomy. Of course, both views are opened for discussion, even more, it is desirable to clarify these ideas in the favor of improvement of the statistics connected to Braco’s work.”
Non-active action.  Sounds like what occurs when I ask the boys to mow the lawn. I scoffed when Jacques Benveniste suggested that homeopathic information could be transmitted over the phone lines.  It turns out Benveniste was ahead of his time. Braco can live stream his stare or you can watch a You Tube video with the same effect as a personal stare down.
I recently was asked what I thought was the oddest CAM and I answered oscillococcinum.  But we have a new winner.  And it really isn’t polite to stare.

Olympic Pseudoscience
Pseudoscience is rife within the sporting world, and reaches its apogee with the Olympic Games.
Steven Novella on July 25, 2012
Link
The Summer Olympics are coming up, which means that, in addition to world-class athletic performance, the public will be exposed to a variety of sports-related pseudoscience. This is not unique to the Olympics, of course. The world of sports competition is rife with pseudoscience, false claims, dubious products, superstitions, and magical charms. The most egregious example of this recently has been the energy bracelet scam — multiple companies have and are marketing little bits of rubber, plastic, or metal that you wear on your wrist and they claim (based on parlor tricks rather than evidence) will improve athletic performance. They give classically pseudoscientific explanations for the alleged effect, such as negative ions or energy frequencies. In fact the new icon of the entanglement of sports with pseudoscience is the Power Balance Stadium.
Occasionally the scientific community takes notice of such claims and bothers to review them. Also, in the internet age, the information is actually available to the public (rather than buried in an obscure journal). A recent joint investigation by BBC Panorama and the British Medical Journal (BMJ) recently found a shocking (to them) lack of evidence for many claims made to market performance-enhancing products. The BBC reports:
A team at Oxford University examined 431 claims in 104 sport product adverts and found a “worrying” lack of high-quality research, calling for better studies to help inform consumers.
High quality studies would be nice, but the article fails to ask the question — who is going to fund those studies? What incentive do manufacturers have in proving their products don’t work?
The researchers did learn a few things about how the game is played, how companies create the impression of scientific support for their claims without the substance of science. For example, regarding a popular sports drink:
Dr Heneghan and his team asked manufacturer GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) for details of the science behind their claims and were given what he said scientists call a “data dump” — 40 years’ worth of Lucozade sports research which included 176 studies.
GSK apparently pulled several classic pseudoscientific ploys. The first is to attempt to replace quality research with quantity. The assumption is, if you pile it high enough, you end up with compelling evidence (at least they hope the public will think so). A lot of low quality research does not add up to even a single rigorous study, however. Dr. Heneghan found that the studies were mostly of very poor quality, the kind of studies that are likely to generate some conveniently false positive results that are great for marketing (the goal is to slap the ubiquitous claim, “clinically proven,” onto the marketing).
Related to this is the problem of in-house vs truly independent research. An in-house study performed by researchers on the company payroll (not academics with reputations and careers to worry about) is less than worthless. You can produce any results you wish with even subtle tweaking of a study. Transparency, replication, and peer-review provide at least some check (although imperfect) on researcher bias. A variation of the in-house study, which is more deceptive, are the “independent” companies that perform product testing for other companies. This is essentially outsourcing in-house studies, with the added benefit that the company can say that their claims were “independently tested.”
The second ploy is to tout “minuscule effects” as if they were significant. All that is necessary is for the study group using the sports-enhancing product to perform slightly, barely, teensy tiny bit better than the other group, and the company can tout an effect (while not mentioning the effect size). Of course such tiny effect sizes are not even reliably real — they are within the noise of such studies, especially those that are small or not tightly controlled.
The third marketing tactic is to claim a real effect, but not one that is specific to the product, and which can be obtained much more cheaply from everyday items. With regard to nutritional supplements the BBC article reports:
Nutrition expert Professor Mike Lean of the University of Glasgow described what little evidence there is that certain amino acids, which form part of proteins, may improve muscle strength as “absolutely fringe evidence and I think that that is almost totally irrelevant, even at the top level of athletics”.
The marketing of such products typically will talk about basic science facts that make their claims seem plausible. Proteins are made of amino acids, so if you want to build muscle you have to have sufficient amino acids in your diet. This is true, and it is easy to conceptualize the food you eat fueling the building of muscle. The real question is, however, is this process limited by your nutrition, and is the nutrition you are getting from the sports product any better than regular food you can buy from the supermarket. Dr. Lean concludes that the fancy supplements are, essentially, just really expensive milk.
Running shoes are another example. Fancy and expensive shoes designed to reduce injuries or enhance performance simply do not work any better than regular sneakers. Any effect is tiny and insignificant.
A fourth marketing ploy commonly used is to cite evidence for a small benefit at the extreme end of athletic performance (like marathon running) and then use that to support claims for the average user. This is an example of misapplying evidence or the unjustified extrapolation. Effects that are apparent for professional athletes may not be significant for the average user. Further, products that may help compensate for an injury do not necessarily enhance performance in healthy individuals.
The BMJ authors set out to review evidence — and they found that the evidence is low quality, with insignificant effect sizes and non-specific effects that do not justify high prices for specialty items. The marketing of sports products, however, has been very successful (as the Power Balance Stadium attests). The usual strategy is to get high profile sports stars to use the product. They will likely perceive a benefit, simply because of the inherent biases in making such assessments. Further, there is a huge financial incentive for them to feel that the product helps their performance. They then endorse the product, and the average sports fan likely believes that a professional athlete must know what they are talking about when it comes to performance. Sprinkle in some dubious in-house studies and you have a marketing campaign.
There are other countless products not discussed in the BBC/BMJ article. For example, breathe right strips — those little white strips that began appearing across the noses of many athletes. The claim is that they enhance performance by opening the nasal passages and making it easier to breathe. There is some evidence that the strips at least do open the nasal passages a bit, and this is often the kind of evidence that is used to support such products. It seems to support the claims made for the product, but is not a direct test of performance. Studies looking at endurance performance, recovery from exercise, and the work of breathing during exercise have all found no benefit from such strips, however.
Kinesiotape
Now a new product, kinesio tape, is looking to become the next breathe right strips. This tape is applied over muscles to, allegedly, enhance performance, reduce injury, and reduce soreness and stiffness. So far the evidence is mostly preliminary, but a recent review concluded:
In conclusion, there was little quality evidence to support the use of KT over other types of elastic taping in the management or prevention of sports injuries
There is some evidence that taping an injured muscle may help it perform better, just like a brace, but there is no convincing evidence that there is anything special about kinesio tape over regular tape. This is therefore an example of marketing a non-specific effect that can be gained from cheaper products as if they were a special feature of an expensive product. It’s not even clear from the existing evidence that kinesio taping has a net positive effect. The same article notes, for example:
KT had some substantial effects on muscle activity, but it was unclear whether these changes were beneficial or harmful.
There was also a study published since the review, looking at the effect of kinesio taping on the leg muscles of healthy women, which concluded:
Application of KT to RF, VL and VM muscles did not significantly change lower limb function, postural balance, knee extensor peak torque or electromyographic activity of VL muscle in healthy women.
Conclusion: Be skeptical
Consumers should be very skeptical of claims made for products marketed as athletic performance enhancing. Given that the BMJ article looked at 104 such products and found no convincing scientific evidence to support their claims, it seems reasonable to conclude that this is a general feature of the athletic performance marketplace. Some common sense rules of thumb seem reasonable – don’t believe the hype, don’t believe in magic, don’t be overly impressed by professional endorsements, be skeptical of claims for scientific support, and don’t waste money on expensive versions of products when cheaper versions are likely to be just as good.

Is your workout gear killing you?
Endocrine-disrupting chemicals have been detected in athletic clothing. Should we be worried?
Scott Gavura on April 10, 2025
Link
Athletic gear is everywhere, and “athleisure” is everyday clothing for many. Compared to what people exercised in decades ago, today’s workout gear seems vastly superior: Better fitting, wicking sweat, and much, much more comfortable. Cotton is a rarity, synthetics are king. And almost everything has materials that add stretch.
In recent years, concerns have emerged around the presence of endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) in everything from yoga pants to sports bras. These compounds, found in industrial and consumer products, have been linked to hormonal imbalances, fertility issues, and even cancer in animal studies. But does their presence translate into real-world risk? This is not an easy question to answer – but let’s look at some of the issues and the science.
What are EDCs?
Endocrine-disrupting chemicals are substances that can interfere with the endocrine (hormonal) system in animals and humans. EDCs can be natural or synthetic. They can mimic natural hormones, prevent hormones from binding to receptors in cells, and even affect the production of hormones in the body. Useful EDCs include prescription drugs like corticosteroids and birth-control pills. Common EDCs used for non medical-purposes include bisphenol A (BPA), phthalates, and per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). These EDCs are present in food packaging, plastics, cosmetics, water-repellent coatings, and other products. Most human exposure in the United States appears to come from food packaging. The FDA, which oversees food packaging, states that BPA is safe at the current levels detected in foods. Health Canada agrees, and states that skin contact from handling thermal printing paper may be a secondary but important route of exposure, highlighting concern about the dermal absorption potential of EDCs.
Athletic Gear and EDCs
Athletic wear is often made from synthetic materials such as polyester, nylon, and spandex. These fabrics may contain EDCs for various reasons:​
BPA: Used in the production of certain plastics and resins, BPA has been detected in some sportswear. As noted above, BPA can be absorbed into the body through skin contact.
Phthalates: These chemicals are used to make plastics more flexible and are sometimes found in clothing materials.
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS): Often referred to as “forever chemicals” due to their persistence in the environment, PFAS are used to make fabrics water- and stain-resistant.
Exposure Risks from EDCs in Clothing
It’s important to note that the identification of chemical does not automatically mean that its presence creates a risk. The potential for EDCs in a piece of clothing to affect health would depend on the type of EDCs, the concentration of EDCs in the clothing, the duration and frequency of wear, skin conditions or other factors (e.g., sweating?) that might affect absorption, and then, if absorbed, their ability to cause harm based on the amount absorbed. While studies have detected the presence of EDCs in athletic apparel, the actual risk to consumers is unclear and would be impossible to test prospectively. Perhaps not surprisingly and somewhat depressingly, given the ubiquity of EDCs in our modern environment, clothing appears to be one of the many sources of daily exposure. There are likely greater concerns about EDCs in cosmetics and food products, where exposure and absorption is more more likely. Even if we are not exposed through dermal contact by wearing them, discarded clothing (accelerated by today’s fast fashion?) and their eventual decomposition could be leading to more EDCs in the environment and eventually, into our water supply.
While risks of EDCs in clothing have not been quantified, this does not mean regulators are not acting. In the European Union, BPA has been restricted as a substance on its own and in mixtures intended for consumer use in the EU since 2018. In 2020, the EU implemented restrictions on 33 substances classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic, or toxic for reproduction (CMR) in textiles and footwear. These substances include phthalates and other chemicals. France and Sweden have proposed to restrict over 1000 skin sensitising chemicals in clothing, footwear and other articles that have contact with the skin. Bisphenols that have been identified as skin sensitisers would be included in this restriction if it were adopted.
Minimizing Risks
With EDCs everywhere, and unclear (but likely low) risks from exposure to athletic wear, it’s not clear what we can do do meaningfully reduce our overall exposure, even if we could find and wear clothing without EDCs. Given detecting EDCs is impossible for the consumer, we are left with making decisions that have to be based on the best available evidence and our current assessment of risk. It’s worth nothing that there is no question about the benefits of exercise, which are demonstrated and significant, which certainly outweigh any potential risk of EDCs. However, if you want to exercise and reduce any potential EDC exposure risk in your clothing, you could consider the following:
Wash new clothing before wearing – This will help reduce EDCs (and put them in the water supply).
Wear natural fibres – Natural fibre-based clothing made from cotton and wool seem less likely to contain (but may not be totally free of) EDCs.
Read the label – Look carefully at claims of stain- wrinkle- odor- and water resistance. This likely signals the addition of EDCs to the fabric.
Remove wet/saturated athletic gear after use – The substances in our sweat may ease the absorption of EDCs, so reducing their contact time with our skin may be helpful.
Conclusion
While the presence of EDCs in athletic wear may sound alarming, it does not mean you’ll be better off discarding all your gear – or not working out at all. A wardrobe of natural textiles may not be feasible or possible – and if even if you have one, the degree to which it reduces your total exposure to EDCs (and your risk) is unclear. However, ultimately, removing EDCs from clothing and other consumer products is likely better for society overall, if only because it will remove the total amount of these chemicals that are being created (and will eventually enter our food and water supply).


Corrigendum. The week in SBM for 1.22.2017
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon: Liver toxicity from herbs. Popped lungs from acupuncture. Chiropractic does not help scoliosis. Yoga is just exercise. There are eight kinds of wind: Great Feathery Wind, Scheming Wind, Hard Wind, Great Hard Wind, Ferocious Wind, Infant’s Wind, Feathery Wind and, yes, Breaking Wind. And more! Duty Calls.
Mark Crislip on January 22, 2017
Link

Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest with comments.
What’s the harm
“Red Yeast Rice, Sold as Statin Alternative, Has Similar Risks.”
Those events were most commonly myalgia and/or increase in creatine phosphokinase (19 events), liver injury (10 events), or gastrointestinal reactions (12 events), but there was one case of rhabdomyolysis as well as nine cutaneous reactions and four “other” reactions. Among them, 13 required hospitalization.
Case Rep Gastroenterol. 2016 Nov 25;10(3):706-713. doi: 10.1159/000452209. “Drug-Induced Liver Injury Associated with Complementary and Alternative Medicines.”
The presented case took complementary and alternative medicine (LEVERCOL® and Jacko®) before every appearance of his liver dysfunction.
Natural does not necessarily mean safe and liver toxicity is one of the more common complications of herbal preparations.“An acutely dyspnoeic woman after acupuncture.” Bilateral pneumothorax (popped lungs) after thoracic acupuncture. The distance from the skin to the lung is not very far, as this video shows (although I do love the way he puts his bare hand where the needle went in, aka how to transmit infections).
Vaccination
“Vaccine exemptions are on the rise in a number of US states.” 80,000 Kindergartners in the 2013-14 school year exempt from at least one vaccine.
…nonmedical exemptions have continued to rise. In 11 states — Connecticut, Florida, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, and Virginia — the number of kids not being vaccinated for nonmedical reasons is higher than at any point in the past five years.
Given how these unvaccinated children are often clustered we are primed for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases.When we see these outbreaks, be sure to send congratulations to those who helped make it happen. See “The Shadow Network of Anti-Vax Doctors” for who to write. An interesting review in The Atlantic.
Naturopathy
The American Council on Science and Health summed it up best: “Massachusetts Becomes The 20th State Where Naturopaths Can Hurt You.” The Massachusetts legislature passed bill 2335, “An Act establishing a board of registration in naturopathy.” I am increasingly of the mind that we were overly optimistic choosing Sisyphus as our logo at SfSBM.For Legislative Updates for your state, visit Summary Pending Legislation 2017.
Acupunctures
There were a tremendous number of articles touting acupuncture for infantile colic based on a poorly-done, unethical study. For the truth they don’t want you to know, see “Acupuncture isn’t the answer to a crying baby” by Professor David Colquhoun, and “No, torturing colicky infants by sticking them with acupuncture needles won’t calm them” by my favorite box of blinking lights.In the acupuncture literatureEur J Pain. 2017 Jan 20. doi: 10.1002/ejp.1001. “Acupuncture and electro-acupuncture for people diagnosed with subacromial pain syndrome: A multicentre randomized trial.”
In the current investigation, neither acupuncture nor electro-acupuncture were found to be more beneficial than exercise alone in the treatment of subacromial pain syndrome.
So there is nothing special about acupuncture’s effect for pain. More theatrical placebo.Why do we rarely see numerous articles when a SCAM fails, but, as in acupuncture and colic, innumerable articles when a SCAM ‘works’?Anaesthesia. 2017 Jan 16. doi: 10.1111/anae.13785. “A randomised controlled trial examining the effect of acupuncture at the EX-HN3 (Yintang) point on pre-operative anxiety levels in neurosurgical patients.”
After measuring baseline anxiety levels, 128 patients were randomly allocated in a 1:1 ratio by a web-based computer program to receive either acupuncture at the EX-HN3 (Yintang) point (acupuncture group) or no intervention (control group). Participants were not blinded…
An intervention versus usual care will ALWAYS shows benefit for the intervention, no matter what the intervention is. This mythology methodology guarantees a positive outcome, is useless for determining efficacy, and should never be published.“Acupuncture in the Treatment of a Female Patient Suffering from Chronic Schizophrenia and Sleep Disorders.” A report of abusing the mentally ill.Medical school debt can be tremendous, an average of $167,000, but at least as real physicians have an earning potential based in reality that can actually help people. Acupuncturists? To learn their theatrical placebo, at Southwest Acupuncture College :
…graduates earn a median of $17,260. That school’s website says tuition runs from about $57,000 to just under $70,000 for a degree.
With that kind of debt to earnings (also an issue with DCs and NDs) you can understand the allure of selling supplements and other questionable products to mollify the financial burden.
Chiropractic
Ortop Traumatol Rehabil. 2016 Oct 28;18(5):409-424. doi: 10.5604/15093492.1224615. “Manual Therapy in the Treatment of Idiopathic Scoliosis. Analysis of Current Knowledge. ”
Conclusion: “1. Few papers verifying the efficacy of manual therapy, chiropractic and osteopathy in the treatment of idiopathic scoliosis have been published to date. 2. The majority are experimental studies with poor methodology or observational case studies. 3. At present, the efficacy of non-specific manual therapy in the treatment of patients with idiopathic scoliosis cannot be reliably evaluated. 4. It is necessary to conduct further research based on appropriate methods (prospective, randomised, controlled studies) in order to reliably assess the usefulness of non-specific manual therapy in the treatment of idiopathic scoliosis.
Sorry. These reviews always suggest further studies need to be done. They do not.
Yoga
Yoga treatment for chronic non-specific low back pain. The money quote from the Cochrane review:
There is low- to moderate-certainty evidence that yoga compared to non-exercise controls results in small to moderate improvements in back-related function at three and six months. Yoga may also be slightly more effective for pain at three and six months, however the effect size did not meet predefined levels of minimum clinical importance. It is uncertain whether there is any difference between yoga and other exercise for back-related function or pain, or whether yoga added to exercise is more effective than exercise alone.
Which is no surprise because Yoga is exercise with an added patina of Indian mysticism.And of course, as with acupunctures reviews, they appear to assume every form of Yoga is equal, but:
The types of yoga varied between trials. The most common type of yoga was Iyengar yoga or a modification of Iyengar yoga. Study authors reported using Hatha yoga (2 trials), Iyengar yoga (4 trials), the ‘Iyengar style of Hatha yoga’ (1 trial), a combination of Iyengar and British Wheel of Yoga (described as Hatha yoga on the British Wheel of Yoga website) (1 trial), a combination of Iyengar and ‘traditional’ yoga (1 trial), Viniyoga (2 trials), or ‘Integrated Approach of Yoga Therapy (IAYT)’ (1 trial). All interventions included meditation, relaxation, or breathing exercises in addition to physical yoga poses.
They need to make it Yogas (Yogi?) plural and not use the singular form of the noun. The marked heterogeneity of Yogas suggests that whatever minimal effect there is, it is not specific to Yogi.
Weird therapies
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2016;2016:6520475. doi: 10.1155/2016/6520475. Epub 2016 Dec 26. “Potential Health Benefits of Deep Sea Water: A Review.”
It (Deep Sea Water) is usually associated with the following characteristics: low temperature, high purity, and being rich with nutrients, namely, beneficial elements, which include magnesium, calcium, potassium, chromium, selenium, zinc, and vanadium. Less photosynthesis of plant planktons, consumption of nutrients, and organic decomposition have caused lots of nutrients to remain there. Due to this, DSW has potential to become a good source for health.
Curious statements
Gwyneth Paltrow’s toxic tampon advice. A couple of weeks ago GOOP suggested that parasites like milk, then that vaginal jade eggs are a good way to, among other things, balance hormones. They are not. Now GOOP suggests that tampons contain toxins. They do not. As Dr Jen Gunter, a board certified OB/GYN, notes:
Okay, let me science it up for you.There are no toxins in tampons. Really. I can say this with 100% certainty as a toxin is a preformed poisonous substance made by an organism, think botulinum toxin or the bee venom that you have used to reset your humors. It’s shame [sic] Dr. Maggie Ney N.D., your naturopath, couldn’t set you straight on that lede.
GOOP is a site of endless pseudo-science and pseudo-medicine.In the article “Holistic integrative medicine: the road to the future of the development of burn medicine,” the author notes:
Holistic integrative medicine is different from translational medicine, evidence-based medicine or precision medicine.
I don’t think that was meant ironically and may well be the biggest understatement I will read in 2017.“How To Get Rid Of Plantar Warts: Dr. Starbuck Explains. ”
The word “plantar”, spelled p-l-a-n-t-a-r, is an adjective describing things related to the sole of your foot.
I can see how it is spelled when it is placed in quotes, why add the s-p-e-l-l-e-d?
“The Concept of Wind in Traditional Chinese Medicine.” Wind is one of the humors of traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine. There are eight kinds of wind: Great Feathery Wind, Scheming Wind, Hard Wind, Great Hard Wind, Ferocious Wind, Infant’s Wind, Feathery Wind and, yes, Breaking Wind. From the small intestine. You would think Breaking Wind would be associated with the large intestine, but that is Ferocious Wind, and, to judge from my teenage boys, perhaps more fitting. The whole article is breaking wind. Pure nonsense.

Corrigendum. The Week in SBM for 01.29.2017
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon: FDA confirms elevated levels of belladonna in certain homeopathic teething products. Homeopaths prove water not toxic to fish. Lots of acupuncture recommendations, little good data. Everything is CAM. And more! Duty Calls.
Mark Crislip on January 29, 2017
Link

Points of interest with comments.
What’s the harm
FDA confirms elevated levels of belladonna in certain homeopathic teething products.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced today that its laboratory analysis found inconsistent amounts of belladonna, a toxic substance, in certain homeopathic teething tablets, sometimes far exceeding the amount claimed on the label.
The other name for belladonna is deadly nightshade. I suspect that having “Deadly Nightshade” in large letter on the box would have been off-putting for consumers, but homeopathic products have never been known for their transparent labeling. These products were linked to at least 10 deaths. Thanks to Congress, homeopathic nostrums and supplements have been under no manufacturing oversight and it is not until problems arise that the FDA can intervene. In other words someone has to be harmed or killed first.
Not an optimal oversight mechanism.
In India there have been 6 deaths from methyl alcohol and/or chloral hydrate poisoning with fake homeopathic nostrums. The report is not as clear as one would like, but it raises the question. If you are going to make counterfeit homeopathic products, why bother to even use real chemicals? Just slap a label on a bottle of water and avoid accidentally harming or killing people.
Homeopathy
J Pharmacopuncture. 2016 Dec;19(4):319-328. doi: 10.3831/KPI.2016.19.033. “Embryonic Zebrafish Model – A Well-Established Method for Rapidly Assessing the Toxicity of Homeopathic Drugs: – Toxicity Evaluation of Homeopathic Drugs Using Zebrafish Embryo Model..”
I have mentioned in the past that Harriet’s excellent concept of Tooth Fairy Science seems incomplete. Tooth Fairy science covers the “what” of pseudo-medicinal research, but not the “how”. What continues to amaze me is the use of advanced technology to ‘investigate’ pseudo-medicines. In the above study they evaluated three homeopathy nostrums at ‘potencies’ of 30CH and 200CH.
30CH and 200CH is also known as water. At that delusion, er, I mean dilution (thirty and two hundred dilutions of one drop of the previous dilution to one hundred drops of water, but oh, they shake it in between which is where the actual magic allegedly happens), there is nothing in the water but water.
And then, for no reality-based reason (they were looking for nanoparticles in water) they used:
…ultraviolet-visible spectrometry (UV-Vis) characterization of the homeopathic drugs, their particle sizes were evaluated by using an Epoch Microplate Spectrophotometer (BioTek-SN-141215F) to monitor the visible absorption band. Data reported encompassed the wavelength range from 190 to 1100 nanometers (nm) [20]. For the nanoform characterization of the homeopathic drugs, the sizes and the morphologies of the homeopathic drugs were determined by using field emission gun – transmission electron microscopy (FEG-TEM) (Tecnai G2, F30 magnification 58 X 1 million X (300 kV)). Carbon-coated grids were immersed in the sample and left to dry prior to observation. The selected area electron diffraction (SAED) ring patterns were examined using high-resolution TEM (HR-TEM).
And then they evaluated the water, er I mean, the medications, for toxicities by trying to induce birth defects in zebra fish embryos. Poor fish, but they found no toxicity.
Our findings clearly demonstrate that no toxic effects were observed for these three homeopathic drugs at the potencies and exposure times used in this study. The embryonic zebrafish model is recommended as a well-established method for rapidly assessing the toxicity of homeopathic drugs.
What a surprise. Water is not toxic to fish. Who’d a thunk it.
This research was done in India where I would think they would have a better use of funds than for studies like this.
Acupuncture
Nothing like a review of reviews. The worse the methodologies the more and more likely a positive result, and the clinical trials of acupuncture are usually fatally flawed. But fatal flaws don’t prevent organizations from suggesting acupunctures’ use in clinical guidelines. The British NHS has, rightly, abandoned acupuncture for back pain. But acupuncture is still recommended in many guidelines to a degree that is sobering.
Over at the National Guideline Clearinghouse they have 39 guidelines with 80 recommendations concerning acupuncture:
49 recommendations were clearly for acupuncture, 25 recommendations were against acupuncture and 6 recommendations did not indicate any clear recommendations, 37 recommendations were for painful diseases/ disorders,
And these recommendations:
are not high in strength, and most of the evidence is moderate or low in quality.
I know from the guidelines in my own specialty of Infectious Diseases that some recommendations are not based on the best of data, but are at least grounded in reality. Interventions suggested in any guidelines should at least be based in the reasonable extrapolation of reality if no good clinical studies exist, not the fantasy that is acupuncture.
As we have seen with Lyme, the National Clearinghouse does not judge of the quality of the guidelines, nor should they. That is the responsibility of the organizations that produce the guidelines, and they are often lacking. But somehow I expect Ed McMahon to show up at my door with the next set of guidelines. Yes. I know.
In the literature
Addict Behav. 2017 Jan 18;69:27-34. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2017.01.022. “Efficacy of mindfulness meditation for smoking cessation: A systematic review and meta-analysis.”
They found that:
Overall, mindfulness meditation did not have significant effects on abstinence or cigarettes per day, relative to comparator groups.
So mindfulness meditation offers nothing special, although I do not doubt that the practitioners of mindless mindfulness meditation found the process pleasant. If I were going though nicotine withdrawal I would like an opportunity to mellow out. And is always the case:
Low-quality evidence, variability in study design among the small number of existing studies, and publication bias suggest that additional, high-quality adequately powered RCTs should be conducted.
No. Don’t think so. Many flawed negative studies are not a reason for further studies unless you really need a well done to prove you interaction does nothing. Not like anyone would pay attention.
Law and legislation
In California the vaccine law was recently challenged:
a group of over twenty individual plaintiffs filed a complaint in a federal court in Los Angeles against a group of legislators, their wives, the governor and his wife
Yes, they went after the wives because, well:
the biblical principle that the wife falls under the husband’s covering, and whatever the husband does in public comes back to haunt him in private.
Yep. The wives must pay for the sins of the husband by being sued. And they argue that vaccines are dangerous and part of a pharmaceutical conspiracy, under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. Neither are true.
Their suit was dismissed and in their appeal rather than address the legal flaws of their argument, they attacked the judge. I guess How to Win Friends and Influence People is not required reading.
It would appear that the vaccine law in California is safe.
For updates on the pseudo-medical Legislative shenanigans in your state, visit the Legislative Updates page at the Society for Science-Based Medicine website.
Precise language
In medicine we almost have a complete language to describe diseases and treatments. And it is more useful than Klingon. You want to be precise when describing a patient. No one wants a surgeon to way they are going to remove your thingy. Precision of language reflects precision of thought and understanding.
The genius of alternative medicine is that it uses imprecise language as if it were precise. My favorite example has been acupuncture; there are as many acupunctures as they are acupuncturists but the pseudo-medical world, and often reality-based medicine, speaks, and acts, as if all these acupunctures were the same: Acupuncture. Damn near anything can be called acupuncture, just as damn near anything can be called CAM. For example:
J Altern Complement Med. 2017 Jan 23. doi: 10.1089/acm.2016.0288. “Inpatients’ Preferences, Beliefs, and Stated Willingness to Pay for Complementary and Alternative Medicine Treatments.” And anything can be CAM, including:
acupuncture, aromatherapy, art therapy, guide imagery, healthy food, humor therapy, massage therapy, music therapy, pet therapy, Reiki, and stress management.
Which of these interventions were patients willing to pay for? Nothing CAM:
[Inpatients] were most willing to pay for healthy food (71%), massage therapy (70%), and stress management (48%).
I can’t access the table to see how many would pay for the fraudulent interventions like reiki and acupuncture.
But of course they conclude that “CAM” should be implemented in hospitals, whatever “CAM” is.
Tax dollars in action. Or perhaps inaction
The Tewksbury (Massachusetts) Health Department and Town Nurse Sarah Kinghorn sponsored a lecture on Tong Ren, the goofiest form of acupuncture: you hit voodoo doll with meridians painted on it with a magnetic hammer. Really:
The acupuncture model becomes an energetic representation of the patient’s body,” a way to impart the benefits of acupuncture without using needles.
The same speaker will be back to discuss acid reflux and diabetes in his role as a nutritionist. I can’t wait.
Odd language
The Massachusetts legislature now has their double 0 with licensure of naturopaths. I would hope, in spirit of openness, the each license number begins with “00”. In the spirit of 1984 and the era of alternative facts I give you the following quotes from a naturopath:
This licensure ensures the safe practice of naturopathic medicine in the Bay State.
And:
This law affords people of Massachusetts an option to include well-educated and trained NDs on their health care team for the ND expertise in both preventive care and natural integrative medicine.
Sigh.
See the Naturopathic Diaries for the truth the Massachusetts legislature ignored.

orrigendum: The week in review for 2/5/2017
Drinking hydrogen peroxide kills. Homeopaths don’t care if their nostrums kill children. Acupuncture is placebo. But you knew that. Saudi Arabia bans reiki for the damnedest reasons. Eating placentas. And more!
Mark Crislip on February 5, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest with comments.
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
What’s the harm?
The harm continues.
Two chemists walk into a barThe first one says “I’ll have some H2O.”The second one says, “I’ll have some H 2O2.”Then he dies.
Back in 2012 I wrote “Blonde Blood: Hydrogen Peroxide (H2O2 )Infusions” about using H2O2 intravenously. Hydrogen Peroxide is also a recommended as an oral nostrum for treating cancer and a variety of other diseases, thanks in part to:
The growing naturopathic health industry has promoted the use of hydrogen peroxide in treating a wide variety of medical conditions.
I mean, hydrogen peroxide is just water with an extra-oxygen, right? Just like Drano is half salt (Na) and half water (H0). How could that understanding of chemistry lead to any harm? Or so saith the hydrogen peroxide providing pseudo-medical provider. Hydrogen peroxide is just a concentrated source of oxygen. And oxygen is good for you.
Nope.
It is not such a good idea to ingest hydrogen peroxide, as chemist number 2 referenced above failed to realize and is confirmed in “Outcomes After High-Concentration Peroxide Ingestions.” Hydrogen peroxide kills:
In the 10-year study period, 41 of 294 patients (13.9%; 95% confidence interval 10.2% to 18.4%) with symptoms after high-concentration peroxide ingestion demonstrated evidence of embolic events, and 20 of 294 (6.8%; 95% confidence interval 4.2% to 10.3%) either died or exhibited continued disability
The embolism is from H2O2 producing gas resulting in a gas embolism, and gas where it doesn’t belong is a known complication of drinking H2O2 .
Patients also had damage to the esophagus and stomach due to the caustic nature of hydrogen peroxide that was not fatal but can be very debilitating.
29.3% were drinking the H2O2 for therapeutic reasons, the rest were unintentional or for self-harm.
Good rule of thumb: anything that can bleach hair is unlikely to be good for you.
“FDA Finds Poison In Homeopathic Teething Remedies.”
The FDA confirmed this week that variable levels of deadly nightshade (you might guess from the name it is a poison) in some children’s teething nostrum that may have killed 10 children. The result?
I have noted many times in the past that pseudo-medical providers never respond to the potential of patient harm by altering practice. They ignore the precautionary principle.
that if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public, or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus (that the action or policy is not harmful), the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking that action.
Almost every time.
The song remains the same. One company that makes the product is NOT doing a recall and National Center for Homeopathy called the FDA’s warnings “arbitrary and capricious” and due to:
groups interested in seeing homeopathy destroyed continue to hammer away at the system – making exaggerated claims that create misunderstandings about and limit consumer access.
Suggesting children not take deadly nightshade is arbitrary and capricious. Welcome to CAM world.
If you under the impression that pseudo-medical providers are interested in the safety of you and yours, think again.
You learn in medical school that licorice root contains:
Glycyrrhetic acid, the active metabolite in licorice, inhibits the enzyme 11-ß-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase enzyme type 2 with a resultant cortisol-induced mineralocorticoid effect and the tendency towards the elevation of sodium and reduction of potassium levels.
Resulting in a rare form of hyperaldosteronism. I would never expect to see a case, as who can consume that much licorice, a vile flavor at best? People taking supplements, that’s who:
“Liquorice-induced apparent mineralocorticoid excess presenting in the emergency department..”
A 65-year-old woman with a background of myalgic encephalitis, who was taking alternative medicines and dietary supplements, presented with hypokalaemia and hypertension. After a thorough history it became apparent that this was most likely secondary to regular consumption of liquorice tea.”
Myalgic encephalitis, by the way, is an English term for chronic fatigue syndrome.
Acupuncture
More information to support the overwhelming studies that point to acupuncture being no better than placebo aka worthless was released this week with “Moderators of acupuncture effectiveness in breast cancer survivors: Randomized clinical trial (RCT).”
Although acupuncture produced significant improvements from baseline to follow-up in insomnia symptoms, fatigue, and QOL, these improvements did not differ from sham.
Although there was the suggestion of efficacy in subgroup analysis, if you look up worthless in the OED you will find one definition to be subgroup analysis. Also, gullible is not in the dictionary.
Interestingly the less severe the patients’ depression, the better their response to acupuncture. They say it was due to more available serotonin. Uh huh.
Turns out, the less severe the depression, the greater the response to placebo.
A more appropriate conclusion would not be it is because of serotonin but that acupuncture is placebo.
Still, as is always the case, they suggest more studies need be done. No.
Another recurrent theme is that there is no acupuncture, a unique intervention, but there are as many acupunctures as there are practitioners. Since acupuncture is a placebo, it doesn’t matter where the needles are placed or the style used. Yet another example in A comparative study on the effects of systemic manual acupuncture, periauricular electroacupuncture, and digital electroacupuncture to treat tinnitus: A randomized, paralleled, open-labeled exploratory trial.”
They were all the same; the kind of acupuncture doesn’t matter as acupuncture is all placebo.
Some other acupuncture studies of note:
“Evidence-based therapy for tendinopathy of the knee joint : Which forms of therapy are scientifically proven?”
No reasonable data are available for the treatment of tendinopathy in the knee region by acupuncture, fascial therapy or cryotherapy.
Reasonable data. I love the term, especially as the methodologies of acupuncture studies, and other pseudo-medicine, usually results in unreasonable data. As an example this week may I offer “a href=”https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27502820″>The effect of auricular acupressure on nausea and vomiting caused by chemotherapy among breast cancer patients.”
As is so often the case, intervention vs usual control. A study that guarantees a positive result. And it was. People are apes and are a calmed by touch and compassionate interaction, as long as in deference to a million years of evolution, you will not attempt to pick fleas off him. You do not to add pseudo-scientific ear pressure to be a good nurse and provide patient support.
Supplements
Unlike most pseudo-medicines, there is not necessarily zero prior plausibility that herbs will be ineffective. Still, there is often no reason to suggest they should be effective. The indications for herbs are many and the rational(e) lost in the mists of time. This shows up in the almost random way herbs are evaluated. And often found wanting.
In “Herbal medicines in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): A systematic review” they found.
Limited evidence could be found for pine bark extract and Gingko biloba. The other herbal preparations showed no efficacy in the treatment of ADHD symptoms and …no concrete recommendations for use can be made so far.
Vaccination
It is always a nice reminder that vaccines work. Middle school vaccine mandate cut whooping cough 53%. It is good to vaccinate the vectors and those most at risk for infection.
And not just for the benefit the person receiving the vaccination. Use of the HPV vaccine has been associated with the decrease in vaccine strains in unvaccinated women. That benefit has now been demonstrated in the HPV vector, er, I mean unvaccinated men: “Human Papillomavirus Prevalence in Unvaccinated Heterosexual Men After a National Female Vaccination Program“:
A 78% lower prevalence of 4vHPV genotypes was observed among younger male subjects. These data suggest that unvaccinated men may have benefited from herd protection as much as women from a female-only HPV vaccination program with high coverage.
Herd immunity. It works.
Homeopathy
Denial. More than a river in Iran.
In “Effect of Homeopathy on Pain Intensity and Quality Of Life” they found
This study could not show any significant effect of homeopathy on primary dysmenorrhea in comparison with placebo. Considering the possible effect of the homeopath and the homeopathic remedies prescribed on the results of such interventions, further studies are needed to help us arrive at a conclusion.
LOL. No, I do not think we need further studies to know that water will not help any symptom but thirst. And, as I mentioned above, you do not need to add pseudo-science to be a compassionate provider.
Despite being useless and even dangerous, homeopathy use is expected to grow: “Global Homeopathy Product Market: Increasing Demand for Dilutions to aid Revenue Rise at 18.2% CAGR 2016–2024, says TMR.” They say:
Of the key product varieties in the market, the segment of dilutions is expected to achieve the most promising share in the market’s valuation by the end of forecast period, retaining its dominant position with over 35% of the market by 2024
As I understand it, water is anticipated to be the kind of homeopathic product with the biggest growth potential. As in:
Homeopathy Product Market (Product Type – Tincture, Dilutions, Biochemics, Ointments, and Tablets.
The homeopathy theme song? Money for Nothing by Dire Straits
Now look at them yo-yo’s that’s the way you do itYou make you dilutions at BorionThat ain’t workin’ that’s the way you do itMoney for nothin’ and checks for free
In the literature
Some papers of note:“A systematic review and meta-analysis of complementary and alternative medicine in asthma.”
…there was limited evidence on the effectiveness of CAM in adult asthma as most CAMs were only assessed in a single trial. CAMs with multiple trials provided null or inconsistent results.
You know the rule, over time studies with better methodologies show decreasing effect. Reproducibility is even more a problem when the intervention is based on a fantasy.
It is curious how culture can result in the most curious of studies, such as “Effect of Vocalization of the Holy Quran With and Without Translation on Pregnancy Outcomes: A Randomized Clinical Trial.”
Why do such a study?
The harmonious tone of the Holy Quran is a type of mystic music, which contributes to the secretion of endorphins by affecting the brain and stimulating alpha waves. Therefore, it enhances the stress threshold, removes negative emotions, creates a sense of relaxation, and improves the immune system.
And so help with the stress of pregnancy. Did it work? Nope.
Based on the results of this study, despite the lower prevalence of preterm labor and caesarean section in the intervention groups as compared to the control group, no statistically significant effect was seen. This was apparently due to the small sample size.
Small sample size? Or perhaps an ineffective intervention.
Legal and legislative
Physical therapists are winning their suit for the right to practice their form pseudo-science, dry needling:
A North Carolina federal judge on Monday denied a bid to dismiss a lawsuit against the North Carolina Acupuncture Licensing Board accusing it of trying to stifle competition from physical therapists, saying the therapists’ antitrust claims were sufficient to proceed.
Acupuncturists are under the delusion that there is something special about their intervention and want to prevent others from doing it. There isn’t. But with most of the major medical institutions wallowing in the pseudo-medical integrative clinics, why shouldn’t physical therapists get their piece of the magical pie?
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
“Saudi Arabia bans training on Reiki therapy.” Why ban reiki? Not for religious reasons like Catholics.
The Saudi National Centre for Complementary and Alternative Medicine warned early in January of the negative effects of Reiki on patients who could neglect their modern medical treatment and face serious health complications for believing that such alternative medicine could heal serious illnesses.
Weird. Doesn’t the Saudi National Centre for Complementary and Alternative Medicine know they are supposed to promote pseudo-medicine? It is what the NCCIH does. Talk about not understanding their job. Perhaps Betsy DeVos has a Saudi Arabian twin?
Weirdness
“Perspectives from Patients and Healthcare Providers on the Practice of Maternal Placentophagy.” Placentophagy. Eating placentas. Not for vegans, I would suppose. They conclude”
Most providers and patients have heard of placentophagy but are unsure of its benefits and/or risks. Further research examining the potential therapeutic efficacy and/or risks of placentophagy is needed.
Benefits. Of auto-cannibalism? There aren’t any. Placentophagy is touted for postpartum depression, based on anecdotes. Still, the most disgusting clinical trials are suggested:
Despite these challenges, Marraccini and Gorman underscore the importance of continued research on human placentophagy, as well as the importance of clinician awareness and openness in discussing placentophagy with their patients. Given the growing interest, further studies investigating the physiologic response and related benefits or adverse effects to hormones and minerals present in placenta capsules is warranted.
Ewwwwwwww. Placenta capsules.

Corrigendum. The week in review for 02/12/2017
The week in review. Chiropractic and stroke. Integrative Medical doctors don’t trust vaccines. Death from medical marijuana. Shilajit: compost or mulch oozing from Himalayan rocks. India goes full Tuskeegee with AIDS. And more!
Mark Crislip on February 12, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
What’s the harm
We always begin with harm. Many pseudo-medicines have the unique combination of no potential benefit and only the potential for harm, unlike the alternative assertions by pseudo-medicine providers that their interventions have only benefits and no harm. At the forefront of the only harm not benefit approach is chiropractic. So I assume, as usual, chiropractors will ignore “Adverse events associated with the use of cervical spine manipulation or mobilization and patient characteristics: A systematic review” (emphasis added):
Most patients were treated by chiropractors (66%). Manipulation was reported in 95% of the cases, and neck pain was the most frequent indication. Cervical arterial dissection (CAD) was reported in 57% (P = 0.21) of the cases and 45.8% had immediate onset symptoms
Of course, association is not causation and chiropractors suggest that the cervical arterial dissection was already in progress when their patients sought care, which begs the question, why can’t chiropractors recognize the cervical arterial dissection and why would they treat CAD with manipulation? So either chiropractors have no idea what they are are doing or they are causing CAD. I wonder which conclusion chiropractors would prefer? As I think about, the two are not mutually exclusive.
The article also suggests that:
There seems to be under-reporting of cases.
Many hospitals have stroke programs. Some researcher should insert a few questions about neck manipulation in to the voluminous data that is already being collected. It may give an interesting clue as to the frequency of chiropractic associated CAD and stroke.
From the perspective of an infectious disease doctor, the world is covered in microorganisms, most of them non-pathogenic. But organic material is often covered in bacteria and mold and that can have serious consequences: “Contaminated medical marijuana believed to have killed cancer patient.” The patient, 1 of 5, died of a rare fungal infection. Which fungus I cannot tell. The link in one article points to Candida auris, but I cannot find a specific organism mentioned. I would expect Aspergillus or Penicillium, but who knows.
Inhale the joint and with it comes the mold on the leaves.
The marijuana isn’t contaminated; to be a plant, especially a dead plant, is to be covered with mold. Contaminated suggests that the marijuana accidentally or deliberately acquired the mold. Marijuana is no more contaminated than the usual mulch pile. It’s perfectly natural that:
The team also commonly found fungi and bacteria in the products.‘It’s pretty startling just how dirty a lot of this stuff is,’ LaFrate said.
No.
One quote was of zero help:
Dr. Michael Hirt specializes in integrative medicine and says that the fungus that was in the man’s body was equivalent to what is on rodent droppings.
I have no idea what that could refer to. Penicillium marneffei? Got me.
Bottom line? Brownies may be the way to go.
No real harm except aesthetic: A “London woman releases images of bump after tumour removal.” She was diagnosed with a fibroid and decided to treat it with with herbal medicines, acupuncture and exercises. Over the years the fibroid grew to 6 lbs and she looked like she was expecting. Fortunately fibroids are benign, so minimal harm except to her bank account as I suppose she will have to get a new, nonmaternity, wardrobe.
Hopefully the herbs were the safe kind; in the US we never really know what is in herbal products. In Australia they have a similar problem. “What risks do herbal products pose to the Australian community?” Many.
Some traditional herbal preparations contain heavy metals and toxic chemicals, as well as naturally occurring organic toxins. The effects of these substances can be dire, including acute hepatic and renal failure, exacerbation of pre-existing conditions and diseases, and even death. The content and quality of herbal preparations are not tightly controlled, with some ingredients either not listed or their concentrations recorded inaccurately on websites or labels. Herbal products may also include illegal ingredients, such as ephedra, Asarum europaeum (European wild ginger) and endangered animal species (eg, snow leopard). An additional problem is augmentation with prescription medications to enhance the apparent effectiveness of a preparation. Toxic substances may also be deliberately or inadvertently added: less expensive, more harmful plants may be substituted for more expensive ingredients, and processing may not be adequate. The lack of regulation and monitoring of traditional herbal preparations in Australia and other Western countries means that their contribution to illness and death is unknown.
That sounds worse than Twinkies.
Vaccination
You might remember a few weeks back the brouhaha over the antivaccine screed by the Cleveland Clinic’s Daniel Neides, M.D., medical director and chief operating officer of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute. Dr Neides is part of the staff the Cleveland Clinic Center for Integrative & Lifestyle Medicine staff, purveyors of a wide variety of pseudo-medicines.
But perhaps Dr. Neides is an outlier, not representative of those who specialize in integrative medicine. While crank magnetism (the tendency to accumulate more crank beliefs over time) would appear to be the parsimonious explanation for the standard make up of an integrative medical clinic, it doesn’t mean that a given crank idea is necessarily representative of a whole medical specialty, a form of crank homeopathy, like attracting like.
Except that it does: “Vaccination Attitudes and Practices of Integrative Medicine Physicians” which evaluated:
the attitudes and practices regarding vaccination of members of the American Board of Integrative and Holistic Medicine (ABIHM).
They surveyed:
(1) use of and confidence in the vaccination recommendations of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and of medical-specialty associations,(2) confidence in the manufacturing safety of vaccines and in manufacturer’s surveillance of adverse events, and(3) attitudes toward vaccination mandates.
And it wasn’t purty.
Integrative medicine physicians were less likely to administer vaccinations than physicians in traditional allopathic medicine.
Among the 44% who provide vaccinations, 35% used alternative schedules regularly.
Integrative medicine physicians showed a greater support of vaccination choice, were less concerned about maintaining herd immunity, and were less supportive of school, day care, and employment mandates.
Toxic chemical and viral contaminants were of greater concern to a higher percentage of integrative medicine physicians.
Integrative medicine physicians were also more likely to accept a connection between vaccinations and both autism and other chronic diseases.
When you think of an ND or DC, it should also suggest an anti-vaccine practice informed by pseudoscience. Add ABIHM and Integrative Medical doctors to the list.
Acupuncture
The Cochrane Library published “Acupuncture for acute hordeolum.” A hordeolum is a creature from the original Star Trek… no, sorry, it is a sty, an acute infection of the eye lid, usually from S. aureus and usually self limited.
Of course the reviewers write like acupuncture is a thing, but different studies used different points or bloodletting !?!?!?!?! At least four different interventions were lumped together as if the same:
Four RCTs used bloodletting methods at the ear apex, that is ipsilateral or bilateral Erjian (EX-HN6) (Pang 2009; Qi 2013; Xu 2004; Yang 2014). Two RCTs used needling acupuncture at other body points such as points at upper back (i.e. Du 13 and Du 12) or at upper arm (i.e. ipsilateral LI 14) (Li 2006a; Zhang 1991).
In addition to an intervention being divorced from reality (bloodletting!?!?!?!?!?!?!) they noted:
The certainty of the evidence was low to very low mainly due to small sample sizes, inadequate allocation concealment, lack of masking of the outcome assessors, inadequate or unclear randomization method, and a high or unreported number of dropouts.
But still hint at benefit:
Low-certainty evidence suggest that acupuncture seems to have an additional benefit when used along with conventional treatments such as warm compresses and topical antibiotics
And they suggest avoiding bloodletting if the patient is on blood thinners. Outside of hemachomatosis, I can think of no rational reason for blood letting.
Ear bloodletting for an eye infection. Sure. We are not just post fact in medicine, we are now post reality. The Cochrane Collaboration really is doing its best to lose all respect.
And they say:
All RCTs were conducted in China, which may limit their generalizability to non-Chinese populations.
What does that mean? Eye infections are different in China? Only the Chinese respond to acupuncture? A sly hint that Chinese biomedical research may be rife with fraud? A very odd statement.
As of today there are 25,777 hits on Pubmed for acupuncture, with clinical trials dating back 1970. During this time the methodologic issues with clinical trials, especially the importance of a good sham controls, has been repeatedly mentioned. Do acupuncture trials care? Do journal publishers care? More importantly, do the review boards that are responsible for not wasting a patient’s time and money give a moldy rats ass? Nope. The garbage keeps on a comin’.
We have “Moxibustion for pain relief in patients with primary dysmenorrhea: A randomized controlled trial.”
It can’t rule out the effect of psychological factors during treatment process, because no blind procedure or sham control was used due to availability.”
And:
“Impact of acupuncture on stress levels of professionals working with maltreated children.”
However, given the lack of an appropriate control group, we cannot exclude the potential contribution of the placebo effect, non-specific needling effects or even the natural history of stress or regression to the mean.”
So why even bother? They prove NOTHING and that result should have been known before the trials even started. Why were these total wastes of time and money approved? When it comes to pseudo-medicine, oversight is broken.
And remember how I mentioned earlier that there is no acupuncture, but acupunctures? For more of the same see “Comparing the Effectiveness of Electroacupuncture with Different Grades of Knee Osteoarthritis: A Prospective Study.”
Of course, with no placebo/sham control so worthless. Again. They used:
three treatment groups, including two-point group, four-point group and six-point group. Patients in the six-point group received treatment at six-points including ST34, SP10, SP9, ST36, ST35 and EX-LE4. Patients in the four-point group received treatment at ST34, SP10, ST35 and EX-LE5, while patients in the two-point group received treatment at ST35 and EX-LE4.
All ‘worked’ for osteoarthritis since it ever matters where you put the needles and, as would be expected, more needles equals a larger placebo response.
And finally, “Acupuncture for the Treatment of Adults with Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” Another example of GIGO, garbage in, garbage out:
We identified very low QoE indicating significant differences favoring acupuncture (versus any comparator) at post-intervention on PTSD symptoms
And, as is always the case, despite:
No significant differences were observed between acupuncture and comparators at post-intervention for depressive symptoms (SMD = −0.58, 95% CI [−1.18, 0.01], 6 RCTs, very low QoE), anxiety symptoms (SMD = −0.82, 95% CI [−2.16, 0.53], 4 RCTs, very low QoE), and sleep quality (SMD = −0.46, 95% CI [−3.95, 3.03], 2 RCTs, low QoE).
They suggest more time and money needs to be wasted on pseudo-medicine:
To increase confidence in findings, sufficiently-powered replication trials are needed that measure all relevant clinical outcomes and dedicate study resources to minimizing participant attrition.
Because this kind of nonsense only leads to the Man Who Stare At Goats approach to medicine: “Battlefield Acupuncture Introduced at Naval Health Clinic Corpus Christi.”
Eleven doctors and nurses learned how to reduce pain with semi-permanent needles during the first Battlefield Acupuncture (BFA) training at Naval Health Clinic (NHC) Corpus Christi Jan. 27.
Army major general Albert Stubblebine, the man behind the army’s psychic warfare research, passed on this week, but his spirit continues thanks to Richard Niemtzow.
And the nonsense spreads.
Naturopathy
Why do we have Sisyphus as the logo of the Society for Science-Based Medicine? “Institute for Natural Medicine Launches Public Outreach Campaign.”
The Institute for Natural Medicine (INM; Washington, DC), a non-profit organization dedicated to increasing access to care by licensed naturopathic doctors, announced last week that it has launched the INM Ambassador Program to increase public awareness around the value of naturopathic medicine.
Should not take long to increase a value of zero. And then we have A NEW DOC IN TOWN.
Dr. Pais is a Naturopathic Doctor – which means he has gone through an equally rigorous medical training as a regular MD, or Medical Doctor.
Except without the whole focus on basic science, two years of medical clinical rotations and, most importantly, the internship, residency and fellowships where MD’s really learn the profession. For more information I point you to the Naturopathic Diaries.
Homeopathy
Homeopathy is huge in India, perhaps one of the holdovers from when they were part of the British Empire? A shame they did not send homeopathy back when the British left. It leads to the unbelievably awful “AIDS body rubbishes govt. hospital’s claim on HIV cure.”
A government-run homeopathy hospital in Hyderabad has been treating over 10,664 HIV positive patients with a homeopathy pill as an experimental treatment.
The natural history of HIV in the era of effective treatment. Tuskeegee moves to India. A fatal illness treated with water. I must channel my inner Trump tweet: SAD!
In the literature
Some papers of note, this time on why reality based health care workers offer pseudo-medicine. For “Nurses’ attitudes towards complementary therapies: A systematic review and meta-synthesis” it is because:
Some nurses promote complementary therapies as an opportunity to personalise care and practice in a humanistic way. Yet, nurses have very limited education in this field and a lack of professional frameworks to assist them.
For cancer doctors it is “The influence of spirituality and religiosity on the personal use and practice patterns with complementary and alternative medicine (CAM): A national survey of US oncologists.”
This is the first study to identify self-reported spirituality as a significant factor among US oncologists’ decision to use CAM and recommend CAM to patients.
Legal and legislative
Nothing to report this week, but remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Weirdness
Pseudo-scientists are still wiggins over accurate classification. ‘Furor in China After Wikipedia Calls Acupuncture “Pseudoscience”.’ If the shoe fits…
It is weird what will be used as a medication. I ran across “10 Health Benefits of Shilajit: Alternative Medicine Remedies For Anti-Aging, Healing, Cognitive Strength, More.” What is Shilajit? It looks to be compost or mulch oozing from Himalayan rocks, a pre-oil.
As the mountains formed, tropical forests were crushed and compacted between massive boulders. The compressed forests gradually transformed into a nutrient- and mineral-rich biomass loaded with medicinal humic and fulvic acids. Now, every summer as the mountains warm, India’s most prized herbal remedy literally oozes from these biomass resins in the high mountain crevasses.
Probably mold and bacteria central. At least don’t smoke it.
And I never realized just how fragile homeopathic products can be: “While Consuming Homeopathy Medicines Take Care Of These 7 Basic Things, Or Results Won’t Be Effective.” Besides having a clean mouth, not consuming coffee, tea, fruits or real medications, they suggest:
Do not put the medicine balls on your palm. The spirit in them vaporizes, and this renders the medicines ineffective.
Which is how everyone takes a pill: from bottle to palm to mouth. The perfect excuse for a therapeutic failure.
See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 02/19/2017
More poorly done acupuncture studies. Burzynski eats just desserts. Italians like homeopathy. New Jersey is going after Oregon. And more
Mark Crislip on February 19, 2017
Link

Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.Not every article and study that pops up in my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
Vaccination
I have said before that infectious disease is like birding, only interesting. ID has a life list, although there are diseases I never want to see: smallpox, plague, and measles to mention a few. Oregon is one of the top states for vaccine exemptions. Go us. As a result I may get to see an actual case of measles before I retire or die. Other states are trying hard to catch up, as an example: “Religious vaccine exemptions on the rise in New Jersey“:
The number of state religious exemptions among children in primary school more than doubled within a six-year period.
There is a mumps outbreak in Washington with over 400 cases. Maybe we will all get to see a case of a vaccine-preventable infection in the future as exemptions keep increasing. Herd immunity is a fragile thing.
It is nice that there are ongoing difficulties in spreading the alternative facts by the anti-vaccination proponents. “Homeopathic College Pays Heavy Price for Helping to Screen VAXXED.”
In England they had troubles finding a theater (or, as they call it, a cinema) to screen VAXXED. The Centre for Homeopathic Education decided to offer a screening, but snuck the film in, telling no one what the film was about. The administration of Regents University, under whose auspices the Centre for Homeopathic Education exists, were none too happy with the subterfuge and:
severed their contract with the Centre for Homeopathic Education (CHE). They are now homeless. A heavy price indeed to pay for this underhand works.
Not that any reality-based university should have been offering degrees in magic, er, I mean homeopathy, in the first place.
Acupuncture
In Friday’s entry on chiropractic I mentioned the problem with comparing an intervention to standard care rather than to a placebo/sham intervention.
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is ‘A trial design that generates only “positive” results.’
We conclude that the ‘A + B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
Yet the hits just keep on coming: “Randomised controlled trial of contralateral manual acupuncture for the relief of chronic shoulder pain” which, as would be predicted, demonstrated benefit for contralateral manual acupuncture compared to a wait list.
But most amusing was the rationale for the study:
Several randomised controlled trials (RCTs) have investigated the effects of acupuncture for the treatment of shoulder pain, with different combinations of acupuncture points, treatment protocols and methods of needle stimulation, all of which potentially influence the therapeutic outcome of acupuncture treatment. While most acupuncture trials have involved acupuncture needling close to the site of pathology, with or without addition of distal or contralateral acupuncture points, many Chinese medical practitioners purely use acupuncture points contralateral to the site of pain to treat unilateral limb pain, such as that arising from the shoulder or leg. However, there is little scientific evidence to validate the clinical effects of contralateral acupuncture in morbid subjects, despite there having been several studies in animals and healthy human volunteers.
As I keep harping on, there is no such thing as acupuncture as a distinct entity. Every acupuncture study uses a different intervention and is further evidence that the acupuncture is nothing but placebo. At its core the purpose of this study is to see if yet another style of acupuncture placebo has effects. It does. A placebo effect.
And pseudo-medical providers cannot wrap their heads around the idea that if their intervention is no better than placebo it doesn’t work. Take “Acupoint Stimulation on Weight Reduction for Obesity: A Randomized Sham-Controlled Study“:
The results showed significant differences in body mass index, blood pressure, total cholesterol, triglyceride, and leptin or adiponectin over time within the group, but not between the groups.
Sham acupoint stimulation was no better than real acupoint stimulation. So it doesn’t work. Why?
This study could not exclude the effect of placebo and dietary consultation.
Well, I would quibble over the uncertainty over the placebo effect. These results define the placebo effect. But no, they want to make sure in the future that there is an effect with a study methodology that will guarantee a positive result.
Further study that adds a control group receiving no treatment is therefore needed to confirm the effects of auricular acupressure.
Such is the power of belief over science, they will continue until they can declare victory, no matter how flawed.
Herbs and supplements
Last week I mentioned five cases of invasive mold with a death that were associated with marijuana use. Now its toxins: “Medicinal marijuana users skeptical of product safety after recalls for banned pesticides.” There was the:
presence of myclobutanil – a banned pesticide that produces hydrogen cyanide when heated (aka smoked)
The myclobutanil was being used to control a mildew outbreak on the crops.
Having a career in the treating infections associated with various drugs, it does not surprise me that the producers of these substances are less then punctilious in producing their product. Somehow I suspect their driving main motivation in making weed is not safe product.
Doctors, it appears, are not the only allegedly science-based practitioners who should know better than to suggest useless pseudo-medicines. “Unproven alternative medicines recommended by third of Australian pharmacists“:
Choice survey finds therapies with little to no evidence of their benefits, including Bach flower remedies and homeopathic products, being suggested to shoppers…Fifty-nine per cent of people were just told the complementary and alternative product recommended to them worked, and 24% were told the product was scientifically proven.
Not encouraging, and why Sisyphus is the logo of the Society for Science-Based Medicine.
But alternative medications have efficacy, just as long as they contain real drugs: “Health dept cracks down on alternative meds containing sildenafil citrate.”
Sildenafil is better known as Viagra. I guess it is better than the lead and other toxic chemicals in Ayurvedic Indian medications. Barely.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
I was under the impression that exercise was of benefit for depression, but when I reviewed the topic I found that the evidence is modest at best:
The evidence was limited regarding the benefits and adverse effects of various other MDD interventions—alone or in combination with SGAs—when compared with SGAs alone. These interventions included… Exercise therapy
Yoga is a form of exercise, often with a patina of mysticism. Like acupuncture, it has many forms, but unlike acupuncture, at its core the yogas are exercise and I would doubt that the particular style makes much difference for efficacy. Do the yogas help depression? A systematic review of yoga for major depressive disorder” results in the standard pseudo-medical conclusion that poor studies show a modest effect:
This review found some evidence for positive effects beyond placebo and comparable effects compared to evidence-based interventions. However, methodological problems and the unclear risk-benefit ratio preclude definitive recommendations for or against yoga as an adjunct treatment for major depressive disorder. Larger and adequately powered RCTs using non-inferiority designs are needed.
But I am still biased towards the overall benefits of exercise so even if the yogas do not help with depression, it should be better than staying home, sitting on the couch and exacerbating depression by watching the news.
Homeopathy
Years ago at a conference one of the drug reps was detailing a new antibiotic with my attending and she commented that it was popular in Europe. He responded, “So was Hitler for a while”. A pre-internet version of Godwins Law. I always remember that bon mot when popularity is used as a reason for justifying a pseudo-medicine: “Millions of Italians use homeopathic remedies.”
Of the 13 million Italians who use pseudo-medicines, 76.1% use homeopathy. And this despite the complete lack of efficacy for any product, a pattern that continues with “Homeopathy for Allergic Rhinitis: A Systematic Review.”
The low or uncertain overall quality of the evidence warrants caution in drawing firm conclusions about intervention effects. Use of either Galphimia glauca or a homeopathic nasal spray may have small beneficial effects on the nasal and ocular symptoms of AR. The efficacy of isopathic treatment of AR is unclear.
The efficacy of the homeopathic nostrum is as clear as water for me.
Legal and legislative
And, better late than never, the “Burzynski ruling is in: Stan saddled with an overseer.” The Texas Medical Board has found his practice wanting and has added the following stipulations to his practice.
Revocation of license. Unfortunately, this was stayed assuming he follows the rest of the requirements. But he was put on probation and given a public reprimand.The Burzynski clinic’s billing practices will be monitored and the records reviewed.Burzynski must complete a Physicians Ethics program and undergo continuing education to obtain credits of completion in several topics of medical research.
I suspect this one may doom him to failure; I believe the saying is you can’t teach an old duck new ethics. It would be like requiring me to shoot under par at Augusta.
Informed consent forms must be submitted to the Board for review to demonstrate they comply with rules and laws. Each patient must now get these new forms and sign them before treatment.Ownership interest disclosure must be submitted to the Board for review and all patients must be informed (that he owns the pharmacy he is making them use).He must pass a Medical Jurisprudence Exam.He must pay a 360,000 penalty based on the incidents shown to have occurred with patience [sic]. (The false billing really got him here, constituting a huge portion of the assessment.) And, he must pay restitution of $20,125 to the American Cancer Society.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 02/26/2017.
I get the month right. Mumps cases, like an infected parotid gland, grow. Acupuncture graduates will not have gainful employment. Hypno-Reiki. The one true cause of all disease. And more.
Mark Crislip on February 26, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest a daily compendium of links of interest with comment.
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
Vaccination
Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases continue to occur as herd immunity fails due to declining vaccination. It doesn’t take much; get below 95% vaccination rates for some infections and spread becomes not only possible but inevitable. For mumps that threshold is around 87%.
Mumps continues apace. Now a hokey, er I mean hockey, team has been infected: “Mumps outbreak decks Medicine Hat Tigers, could massively spread, says AHS.” There were over 5,000 mumps cases last year. As a result the “Rise in mumps outbreaks prompts U.S. officials to weigh third vaccine dose.”
The US is not the only country where vaccine-preventable illnesses are increasing due to alternative facts: “Measles increasing in Croatia.” I always remember that the 1918-1919 influenza epidemic went around the world three times in an era where the fastest form of transportation was a train. Just imagine a kid with measles landing in Chicago and being taken through the warrens of O’Hare. Or visiting Disneyland. All of these infections are an airplane flight away.
Practitioners of one alternative medicine (perhaps a term that should have a comeback, a nice parallel with alternative facts) more often than not are proponents of other ideas divorced from reality, aka crank magnetism.
A homeopath, a naturopath, an anti-vaxxer, a reiki practitioner, and a conspiracy theorist walk into a bar. He orders a drink.
In England, where homeopathy is Prince, “Homeopaths are keeping Andrew Wakefield’s ‘anti-vax’ fantasies alive.” I would not be at all surprised if homeopaths also consider the world to be flat.
With the current President having strong anti-vaccine leanings, it is nice to see some push back against ideas that will eventually kill some children in the US if continued. In a rare bipartisan show of support for reality, some “Congressional Leaders Just Took a Stand Against Anti-Vaxxers.”
It is critical to recognize the importance of protecting public health against vaccine-preventable diseases.
Acupuncture
Department of Guaranteed False Positives. A recurring feature I am sad to say.
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is ‘A trial design that generates only “positive” results.’
We conclude that the ‘A + B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
Acupuncture studies in particular seem to love this methodology and the resultant studies often generate inordinate positive press. An example this week: “Electroacupuncture and cognitive behavioural therapy for sub-syndromal depression among undergraduates: a controlled clinical trial.”
Three interventions but no placebo control. A waste of time and resources and a ‘positive’ result that means nothing. I remain puzzled why these studies continue to be approved by IRB’s. It is not worth the paper it is printed on or, as I read all my papers electronically, they are not even worth the electrons to read the screen, of which there are 15 747 724 136 275 002 577 605 653 961 181 555 468 044 717 914 527 116 709 366 231 425 076 185 631 031 296 in the universe. SAD.
Sometimes I have a hint of a suggestion of a possibility of sympathy for our Presidents opinion of the press. When you read the reporting on, well, alternative medicine studies by the press, I get a twinge of sadness. I don’t think fake or false. But I do think gullible and remain impressed at the lack of critical thinking.
For example, “Acupuncture Lessens Migraine Attacks in Chinese Study” resulted in numerous hits to the effect that acupuncture prevents headaches. It doesn’t. At least the above press release mentions the critical editorial that notes:
…seriously limited by its lack of blinding, both among participants — who may have been able to tell whether they were in the real or sham acupuncture group based on pain intensity — and acupuncture practitioners.
This study has been nicely reviewed both by Dr. Novella and Dr. Ernst. My only comment on the study is to note that 4 standard points were used for each patient adding to the great variability of techniques used as ‘acupuncture‘:
The acupuncture interventions tested in the included trials varied to a great extent. Five trials (Allais 2002; Ceccherelli 1992; Li 2012; Wallasch 2012; Zhao 2014 ) standardized acupuncture treatments (all participants were treated at the same points); seven (Alecrim 2006; Diener 2006; Facco 2013; Linde K 2005; Linde M 2000; Linde M 2004; Wang 2015) semi-standardized treatments (either all participants were treated at some basic points and additional individualized points, or there were different predefined needling schemes depending on symptom patterns); and 10 trials individualized the selection of acupuncture points (Alecrim 2005; Alecrim 2008; Facco 2008; Hesse 1994; Jena 2008; Streng 2006; Vickers 2004; Vincent 1989; Weinschütz 1993; Weinschütz 1994). The number of treatment sessions was between six and 12 in 13 trials, and 16 or more in nine trials. Most trials reporting the duration of sessions, left needles in place for between 20 and 30 minutes; one trial (Hesse 1994) investigated brief needling for a few seconds. Electro-stimulation of needles was used in one trial (Li 2012). Agreement among acupuncturists on whether they would do acupuncture similarly to that used in the study assessed and whether they had confidence in the quality of the acupuncture was low (intra-class correlation coefficients -0.08 and 0.24). For two studies (Hesse 1994; Linde M 2004) both acupuncturists rating the study had 50% or less confidence that the acupuncture had adequate quality. For a further six studies (Ceccherelli 1992; Li 2012; Linde M 2000; Wallasch 2012; Weinschütz 1993; Weinschütz 1994) at least one acupuncturist gave a rating of 50% or lower. We could not assess four trials using individualized treatments not described in detail (Alecrim 2005; Alecrim 2008; Facco 2008; Jena 2008).
As I continually note, there is no standard intervention for any process that can be called acupuncture.
Chiropractic
There is a bill before the Oregon legislature that:
Allows chiropractic physicians and naturopathic physicians to provide release for athlete who sustained concussion or is suspected of sustaining concussion.
A bad idea given the lack of education and training of naturopaths and chiropractors in reality-based medicine. And the data suggests that chiropractors are not qualified to treat concussion and chiropractors lack insight into their lack of knowledge. This example of Dunning-Kruger is “Survey of Primary Contact Medical and Chiropractic Clinicians on Self-Reported Knowledge and Recognition of Mild Traumatic Brain Injuries: A Pilot Study.”
The majority claimed confidence in diagnosis of MTBI, but a lack of knowledge of many of the assessment tools and the international guidelines.
If the bill passes, it will be children who bear the brunt of their evaluations.
Maybe chiropractors will treat the concussion with a brain-stick. One chiropractor has come up with the oddest product in a field of odd products: a natural lip-stick that glues the labia together to keep menstrual flow contained: “A Male Chiropractor Wants Women To Use Controversial Methods To Contain Menstrual Flow.” Perfect media for S. aureus toxic shock or Clostridia sordellii. And since when did stupid become controversial? Sometimes it is the headline writers that do the most damage.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
Looking for a back door into guidelines is “An interpretive review of consensus statements on clinical guideline development and their application in the field of traditional and complementary medicine.” Even if the data is weak or nonexistent, other criteria should be used to make strong recommendations for inclusion of pseudo-medicine into guidelines:
In instances of very low quality or equivocal evidence of efficacy, guideline developers must consider the paradigmatic situations where nonetheless a strong recommendation can be made. Failing this, broader contextual information is often available for T&CM even when there is low quality scientific evidence regarding efficacy.
Such as:
Modifying factors such as burden of disease, magnitude of effect, current use, demand, equity and ease of integration should also be considered.
Always with the special pleading. I think I will stick with good evidence.
Homeopathy
Out of Australia comes “Majority of pharmacists stock CMS including homeopathic items.” Money for nothing, despite “Hundreds of Babies Harmed by Homeopathic Remedies, Families Say.” Although those deadly nightshade products have been sold in the US. Despite the potential for killing children, evidently the companies are not all that concerned, leading to the question “Why Is This Company Selling a Toxin For Children?”
The FDA has asked for a recall of homeopathic teething products that may cause seizures or worse—but consumers can still easily get their hands on the product.
Pseudo-medicine providers are NEVER interested in patient safety.
Quackademia
“UA Center for Integrative Medicine receives $1M gift.” The center is the home of Dr. Andrew Weil, offering training and fellowships in Integrative Medicine and is perhaps ground zero for the movement.
I am so jealous.
Anyone out there with a cool million they are interested in donating, the Society for Science-Based Medicine is a worthy recipient.
The Department of Education is of the opinion that alternative medicine schools of acupuncture and traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine are not providing enough training to allow their graduates to work and then be able to repay their loans. As a result students at these schools do not qualify for federal financial aid. These schools account for:
11 percent of the total higher education population, but 44 percent of federal student loan defaults.
So it would be a reasonable conclusion that loans to these students would be liable to go unpaid. The school disagree and “Alt-Medicine Schools Challenge Their Failing Grades“:
…challenging a Department of Education “gainful employment” regulation that labels them as failing to prepare students for work.”
However, even if they do get a job after graduation, no alternative provider can be considered as having gainful employment.
I suspect the stress shows: “Acupuncture clinic fails to prove point before COA.”
An employee at an Indiana acupuncture and yoga facility who was repeated screamed at by the owner had good cause for quitting and is thus entitled to unemployment benefits, the Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed Friday.
Maybe the acupuncturists are overly stressed at not being able to make their student loan payments. Too bad the calming/centering effects do not seem to extend to its practitioners.
Legal and legislative
“Wyo. acupuncture bill will harm patients, providers.” Who objects to licensing acupuncturists? It is an acupuncturist, being worried about public safety and the cost of licensing. As noted in the past, Wyoming is the home of rogue acupuncturists, those who ran afoul of the law in their home state, lost their license (just how bad do you have to be for that to happen) and skedaddled to Wyoming. The last thing these practitioners evidently want is even a bit of quality control.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Pseudo-medical weirdness
Pseudo-medicines are infinitely recombinable. There is no end of odd hybrids, mutants that should not survive birth but do. And as example: “Hypno-Reiki: A Way to Let Go of the Pain – The Mind Matters.”
The mind doesn’t know the difference between what is imagined and what is perceived as reality.
Sums it up for most pseudo-medical practitioners.
I suspect that I am unable to come up with a pseudo-medical combination that someone, somewhere, doesn’t offer.
“Leading Integrative Medicine Institute Reveals the Single Unifying Cause of All Disease.” And the answer is…
Wait for it…
inflammation at the cellular level.
Huh? Well what is inflammation at the cellular level?
All cells need four basic elements to live and thrive. Oxygen in, water in, food in and waste products out. If these are done on a timely basis the cells will live very long… If there is a breakdown of any of these four at the cellular level, this is when inflammation, the precursor to all disease, begins.”
Makes no sense to me, but what do I know? Dr. Hall can add it to her list of 67 one true causes of all diseases.
And don’t let Deepak know, as “Deepak Chopra explains recent study that may revolutionize medicine“, as he has found:
the most fruitful discovery in medical science over the past two decades.
Or not. It is not inflammation at the cellular level. That one is taken.
And lastly, the bastion of weirdness, GOOP, gives us Why We Shouldn’t Dismiss Iodine. We shouldn’t. But we should dismiss this entire article as I think Wolfgang Pauli had it in mind when he said “”Das ist nicht nur nicht richtig; es ist nicht einmal falsch!” (That is not only not right; it is not even wrong).” For a wonderful deconstruction, see “Gwyneth Paltrow And GOOP Give Dangerous Info On Iodine. Their Expert Gets His Info From A Ghost.”
I know GOOP likes to point to their disclaimer that they “intend to highlight alternative studies and induce conversation,” but speaking with a spirit is not an accepted scientific method and the only thing I think they have induced with me is my gag reflex.
A writer after my own heart.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The week in review for 03/05/2017
Canada’s Bad Science Wants You. Penguins get acupuncture, tiger cubs get chiropractic. Homeopathic lead for lead toxicity. I’m an idiot. And more
Mark Crislip on March 6, 2017
Link


Running a bit late this week, as I was on call and worked the weekend and my eldest came home for spring break.
Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
Not every article and study that pops up my feeds in the world of pseudo-medicine is worthy of a complete blog post. But they need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York city with an entire day, June 28, devoted to science-based medicine. More information to follow.
If you are in need of something to do to help in the battle against pseudo-medicine, “Canada’s Bad Science Watch wants to know if purveyors of “natural” health products are following the law.” They want to know:
Are manufacturers of natural health products (“NHPs”) marketing/advertising their products in ways that do not align with their Health Canada licenses as permitted under the Food and Drugs Act, 1985 (“FDA”)?
Volunteers are needed and information can be found on their website.
Vaccination
“Why You Should Skip That “Chickenpox Party”.” Chickenpox parties are still a thing? Who knew. Chickenpox parties are where parents take their children to be exposed to chickenpox. In the old days, the pre-vaccine days, I can kind of sort of see why you might have your child go to a chickenpox party. Everyone got chicken pox growing up and you might as well get it out of the way at a time of your choosing to make the infection less disruptive.
With the availability of the vaccine, which is very effective in preventing chickenpox, what you are offering you child from said party is an acute and unpleasant illness as well as the risk of complications:
    • Bacterial infections of the skin and soft tissues in children including Group A streptococcal infections
    • pneumonia
    • Infection or inflammation of the brain (encephalitis, cerebellar ataxia)
    • Bleeding problems
    • Blood stream infections (sepsis)
    • dehydration
Some people with serious complications from chickenpox can become so sick that they need to be hospitalized. Chickenpox can also cause death.
Plus the joys of shingles as an adult. Party, or child abuse?
Animal Abuse
I always feel sorry for animals and children as they have no choice when pseudo-medicine is inflicted upon them. If you look at “Behind the scenes at Denver Zoo” you will find penguin acupuncture. I know it is silly to apply a consistent rational approach to pseudo-medicine, but how do they know where the meridians and acupoints are on a descendent of dinosaurs? And Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine uses pulse and tongue analysis to make a diagnosis; that is a process I would like to see applied to a penguin. But it is the animal who suffers as:
We’ve been able to reduce dancer’s medication by half in the past 6 months,
With, I would assume, a concomitant increase in pain.And the ‘Cincinnati Zoo uses chiropractic on tiger cub, adjusting spine to cure “failure to thrive”‘ by adjusting the cub’s cervical spine. Hope they don’t cause a stoke. And it looks like they were using the useless activator in the video, a spring-loaded plunger, on the cub. The DC says:
There is a lot of science behind what really happens with the chiropractic adjustment
And follow up with the pseudo-science that by adjusting the top vertebra:
You restore the nerve flow to the rest of the body.
Thane Maynard, head of the Zoo, considers this “terrific stuff”, expressing an enthusiasm for abusing, er, I mean adjusting, dogs and horses as well. Sigh.
And I wonder how all the DCs translate their vertical spine pseudo-science to the horizontal spine of quadrupeds. He appears to adjust the spine side to side but in a four legged shouldn’t the subluxations be up and down? The poor tiger had ‘birth trauma’ as the reason for its need for adjustments, another favorite DC pseudo-diagnosis.
Medicine
There is an old saying in medicine: “do not be the first to try the new nor the last to abandon the old.” But that is easier said than done: “When Evidence Says No, But Doctors Say Yes.” They note:
Medicine is quick to adopt practices based on shaky evidence but slow to drop them once they’ve been blown up by solid proof.
It is a long standing problem, less to do with medicine and more due to the ways humans think. Doctors, to state the obvious, are as prone as the next person to all the cognitive biases that define human cognition. I can affirm that it is hard to change ingrained practice and it is easy to rationalize why the negative studies do not apply to my practice. It is difficult to change. But at least medicine slowly changes. In the world of pseudo-medicine, nothing ever changes or is abandoned by its practitioners.
For example there was a recent review of “156 Medical Practices That Are All Failures<.” 10 out of the 156 bad medical practices involved acupuncture: labor, uterine fibroids, irritable bowel syndrome, otitis media with effusion, lower urinary tract symptoms in men, hyperbilirubinaemia, laser acupuncture for carpal tunnel syndrome, depression, osteoarthritis and Bell’s palsy.
I would argue that acupuncture has been a failure for any process for which it has examined. But I wonder. Is there an acupuncturist anywhere that has abandoned any of the above? Bet not.
Acupuncture/traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine
In medicine we often use simulators to learn, for example, how to respond to a cardiac arrest. Better to learn CPR on a dummy than a real person. Simulators allow providers to learn new skills without having to learn on real people. No one, I suspect, is going to volunteer to be a cardiac arrest patient and no one wants to be any providers first of anything. But “Study on the Depth, Rate, Shape, and Strength of Pulse with Cardiovascular Simulator” leads only to a smirk. In traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine (TCPM) they make their fanciful diagnoses on the basis of evaluating the tongue and pulse. The authors devised a machine to simulate the pulses of TCPM because, well, they can. The result? They made the string-like pulse, the slippery pulse, the vacuous pulse and the replete pulse. It is not unlike making a bicycle for a fish, because pulse diagnosis is not reliable. “Reliability of Manual Pulse Diagnosis Methods in Traditional East Asian Medicine: A Systematic Narrative Literature Review.”
Poor reliability was related to unclear definitions and terminology existing within the classical definitions, and with standardized systems to persisting imprecise descriptions that can be interpreted differently.
No, poor reliability was related to the fact that pulse diagnosis in TCPM is nonsense. Or maybe they just need more training on a simulator.
And why do people use acupuncture? In “A cross-sectional survey of pain catastrophising and acupuncture use among breast cancer survivors” it was:
High levels of pain catastrophising, and specifically the processes of rumination and magnification, were associated with greater acupuncture use.
Which is an interesting reason. It was people who worry about developing horrible pain who used acupuncture. I would wonder if this is more widely applicable to pseudo-medicine use.
Chiropractic
‘”After 155 Years, the Cause of Meniere’s Disease has Finally Been Discovered,” Burcon Chiropractic.’ Huzzah! And the cause of Meniere’s (which, by the way, is unknown to medicine)?
Ligaments are damaged allowing an upper cervical subluxation complex to slowly develop over time. Additionally, the brain slips lower into the foramen magnum, slowing the flow of cerebrospinal fluid out of the skull, creating normal pressure hydrocephalus. Since the skull acts as a closed hydraulic system, less blood flows into the head.
That strikes me as nonsense, if for no other reason (but there are many others) than vertigo is not a symptom of normal pressure hydrocephalus.I would still be inclined to avoid any chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine as it will treat nothing and can cause a stroke. For a more reasonable explanation of a pathologic process than above, see “How spinal manipulation could cause a stroke.”
Herbs and supplements
Herbs are touted for virtually everything, expect for herb overdose. Herbs, unlike most pseudo-medicine, do not necessarily have a prior plausibility of zero. An herb may contain a substance, like digitalis in foxglove, that is effective cardiovascular disease. But as “Herbal Medications in Cardiovascular Medicine” notes:
Despite most of these herbs showing an effect on biological mechanisms related to the cardiovascular system, data on their clinical effects are lacking.
Naturopathy
Years ago, as a fellow, we were in line at a restaurant in Palm Springs and the elderly lady in front of us, when asked if they had a reservation, announced loudly, ‘Yes, DOCTOR and Mrs. Smith’. My wife and I just rolled out eyes. I never want to be the diminutive of Richard who uses my title outside of the hospital. Not so with some pseudo-medical providers. Naturopaths and homeopaths refer to themselves as “doctor” more than doctors.
The researchers also used hidden microphones at numerous dinner parties attended by the three groups and found that on average, naturopaths and homeopaths averaged just under 4 seconds of conversation before mentioning they were “doctors”. Many of the medical doctor group did not mention it at all.
4 seconds! That’s premature ejaculation (in the Dr. Watson sense of the word).
Note: See comment.
Homeopathy
“What Homeopathic Medicine Offers to People with Lead Poisoning and Other Environmental Exposures.” Well nothing. Literally. Giving diluted lead to treat lead poisoning wins the Wolfgang Pauli ‘That is not only not right; it is not even wrong’ award. The Huffington Post is publishing a worthless intervention for a very serious disease, by Dana Ullman. Of course. Someday someone may die as a result of this kind of nonsense. I don’t suppose those other exposures include Ayurvedic nostrums, not that homeopathy would help.
Not that major universities care. For example “Oxford University college accused of ‘lending credibility to quackery’ by hosting homeopathy conference.” The Good Thinking Society says that by hosting the AGM of the Society of Homeopaths, Lady Margaret Hall, Oxford, is “adding gloss to a pseudoscientific event”. Oxford or the Cleveland Clinic, pseudo-science continues to advance in the age of alternative facts.
Sometimes there is at least a bit of unintended humor. In “Serious mistakes in meta-analysis of homeopathic research“:
[ The authors of t]he article discussed the immanent problems of meta-analyses selecting a number of independent trials in homeopathy…The main flaw was that trials reflect the point of view that the treatment with a specific remedy could be administered in a particular disease.
That is main flaw with all pseudo-medicines, not of those evaluating them.
Legal and legislative
“Chiropractic under siege in Texas: what’s happening and how you can help.” Written by the Palmer College of Chiropractic, they fret that:
Current legislation and lawsuits in Texas have the potential to drastically reduce the chiropractic scope of practice
Including:
Current legislation seeks to remove diagnosis from the scope of chiropractic, even after the Texas 3rd Court of Appeals ruled doctors of chiropractic can diagnose…Lawsuits have been filed to limit the scope of practice of non-medical providers. Recent lawsuits have succeeded in removing diagnosis and treatment of neurological conditions from the scope of care, including diagnosis and treatment of subluxation.
Appears to be a good thing to me.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
SCAM Weirdness
“Veteran OKC chiropractor teaches techniques, treats children worldwide.”And what is she teaching?
“With gentle realignments of the spine, the life force — or the vibrations that hold every cell in the body together — flows freely into the tissue, which has been so tight for these children for so long, restoring life,” she said. In chiropractic, this life force is known as “innate intelligence,” Doscher said, “but it has many other names including the Holy Spirit and Chi.”
No better argument for restricting chiropractic practice than their own words.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The week in review for 03/12/2017
Waiting for a vaccine-preventable infection. More lousy acupuncture studies. Medical students interested in homeopathy are not as strong at science. Water wet. TCPM consuming donkeys. What the FDA does, and doesn’t do, for now.
Mark Crislip on March 12, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 28, devoted to science-based medicine. More details to follow but registration opens this week.

What’s the harm?
Behaviors have consequences, sometimes fatal consequences. As an example, “Infection fears grow in Byron Shire, the ‘home of the anti-vaxxers’.” Seven years ago in the Australian city a 4 week old baby died because the mother refused a Vitamin K shot on the advice of a community health nurse. Not the kind of community health that I recommend. But the area has become the epicenter of the anti-vaccination movement Down Under, with:
lowest immunisation rates in Australia. According to the latest figures, only half of all five-year-olds are vaccinated in Mullumbimby and only 60 per cent are in nearby Byron Bay.
It is only a matter of time for some vaccination preventable illness to rip through the community, perhaps killing another child or two, especially if measles is the first infection. With infection, it is not if, but when.
Sometimes the harm is filled with sadness when there seems to be no good options for the patient as in this Thai example: “Boy, 2, WON’T have surgery to remove huge cancerous tumour because his parents hope alternative medicine will offer a cure instead.” The accompanying photographs are awful and I would not be sure surgery would be helpful at this point, but I doubt any alternative therapy will fulfil the mothers wish that
We don’t want our son to go through any more painful procedures. He has suffered enough already.
A lose-lose situation.
Other complications of pseudo-medicine are less serious. Or so one hopes if the patient doesn’t hit their head on a cement floor. In “Case report: fainting during acupuncture stimulation at acupuncture point LI4” there was a:
clinical trial aiming to observe a relationship between acupuncture stimulation at LI4 acupuncture point and EEG in healthy adults.
This is, of course, a relationship no one needs to understand. More tooth fairy science, like much of the pseudo-medical literature. And a patient fainted from acupuncture. I love the dry clinical description of what happened:
A sterilised single-use acupuncture needle (0.3 × 30 mm, Dongbang medical, Korea) was inserted into the acupuncture point large intestine 4 (LI4, Hapgok) of right hand of participant approximately in depth of 1.8 cm by licensed KMD who has a 10 year’s career and 4 year of the career was as a [sic] assistant teacher of acupuncture practice at the university, after 30 min of rest. The EEG data were recorded for approximately 5 min before the acupuncture needle was inserted, and researchers noticed the fainting approximately 4 min after needle insertion. The participant did not report any symptoms or uncomfortable feelings. The researchers heard the sound of some objects falling down and saw participant falling at that time. The EEG electrodes were separated from the participant’s body due to the impact of falling down.
Fainting during acupuncture is not uncommon, but rather than research on the topic, perhaps the useless procedure should not be done?
Or, in the case of “Inappropriate ICD Discharge Related to Electrical Muscle Stimulation in Chiropractic Therapy: A Case Report” you can try and kill the patient:
We present a 63-year-old female who presented to the emergency department after an ICD [Implantable cardioverter defibrillator] shock while undergoing electronic muscle stimulation in chiropractic treatment, during which light electrical pulses were sent through skin electrodes. (TENS) Our case highlights the importance of recognizing methods used by alternative medicine doctors, including electrical muscle stimulation that may cause electromagnetic interference and inappropriate ICD discharge and therefore, a higher overall mortality risk.
Chiropractors want to be treated like real doctors, as if they know what they are doing. When it comes to electricity and defibrillators, evidently not.
And pseudo-medicine can result in a triple tragedy as “Widower: Slain Naturopath Said ‘Chemotherapy Is for Losers’” demonstrates. The patient had cancer and she went to a naturopath who:
told them that “chemotherapy is for losers,” and guaranteed he could cure her within three months.
She instead died of her cancer, or perhaps more accurately her ND killed her, after avoiding real medicine, leaving behind a husband and two children. Then her husband shot and killed the naturopath. A double murder.
I have mentioned before the first case of naturopathic care I witnessed, a young female with a soft tissue cancer of the leg who took naturopathic ‘treatment’ instead of a curative amputation. She died after her tumorous leg became gangrenous. Except for the shooting of the naturopath, I expect to see an uptick in similar cases now that naturopathy is getting the false imprimatur of legitimacy from state legislatures. More on this from Dr. Gorski.
Vaccination
Vaccines save lives and due in part to the discovery of the human WI-38 cell line, in which many viruses are grown to be processed into vaccines. What has been “The Role of the WI-38 Cell Strain in Saving Lives and Reducing Morbidity?” Tremendous. From this one immortal human cell line the:
… estimated total number of cases of poliomyelitis, measles, mumps, rubella, varicella, adenovirus, rabies, and hepatitis A averted or treated in the U.S. alone due to the introduction of vaccines developed with the WI-38 cell strain, is 198 million. The estimated total number of deaths averted from these same diseases in the U.S. is approximately 450,000.
Acupuncture and traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine
Department of Guaranteed False Positives:
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is ‘A trial design that generates only “positive” results.’
We conclude that the ‘A + B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
And the worthless studies just keep coming. This week we have “The effect of acupuncture on chemotherapy-associated gastrointestinal symptoms in gastric cancer“:
A cohort of 56 patients was randomly divided into an experimental group and a control group…Patients in the experimental group received 30 minutes of acupuncture therapy daily for 2 weeks.
Acupuncture compared to standard care will likely result in a false positive. Which it did. With that methodology the authors really cannot claim:
Acupuncture, a safe technique, could significantly reduce gi symptoms induced by chemotherapy and enhance quality of life in patients with advanced gastric cancer.
And we have “Effectiveness of dry needling for chronic nonspecific neck pain: a randomized, single-blinded, clinical trial“:
These participants were randomly allocated to receive: DDN plus stretching (n = 65) or stretching only (control group [n = 65])
With:
Significant and clinically relevant differences were found in favour of dry needling in all the outcomes (all P < 0.001) at both short and long follow-ups. Deep dry needling and passive stretching is more effective than passive stretching alone in people with nonspecific neck pain. The results support the use of DDN in the management of myofascial pain syndrome in people with chronic nonspecific neck pain.
No no no. With no sham dry needling comparator you can make zero claims of efficacy.
And finally we have “Integrative Acupuncture and Spinal Manipulative Therapy Versus Either Alone for Low Back Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial Feasibility Study.”
They kicked it up a notch, perhaps the wrong directional metaphor, with three, yes three, interventions and no adequate control:
Participants with acute or chronic LBP were randomized to (1) acupuncture, (2) SMT, or (3) integrative acupuncture and SMT groups.
And they all got better:
Participants in all 3 groups experienced clinically meaningful improvements in the primary outcome measures; however, no between-group differences in outcomes were apparent.
And with no sham controls, a meaningless efficacy study but a classic placebo response.
It is always remarkable how pseudo-medicine trials just can’t bring themselves to report the simple idea that if a drug/procedure has the same outcome as a placebo/sham procedure the drug/procedure does nothing.
And a real drug or intervention in the reality-based medical world would never be approved on the basis of a negative study. But pseudo-medical providers cannot come to grips with the fact that their interventions do nothing.
A case in point, “Out of Sweden comes Reduced Need for Rescue Antiemetics and Improved Capacity to Eat in Patients Receiving Acupuncture Compared to Patients Receiving Sham Acupuncture or Standard Care during Radiotherapy.”
The title is a very Kellyanne Conway and suggests that acupuncture is better than sham acupuncture.
In the abstract’s conclusion, all that many will read in passing, they say:
Patients receiving acupuncture had lower consumption of antiemetics and better eating capacity than patients receiving standard antiemetic care, plausible by nonspecific effects of the extra care during acupuncture.
So acupuncture works…?
Nope.
They compared ‘real’ aka verum acupuncture, sham acupuncture (telescoping needles), and a control for effects on vomiting and eating on patients receiving radiation therapy for cancer.
The dense abstract obfuscates the findings:
Results. More patients in the verum ( of 89 patients still undergoing radiotherapy; 82%, Relative Risk (RR) 1.23, 95% Confidence Interval (CI) 1.01–1.50) and the sham acupuncture group ( of 95; 83%, RR 1.24, CI 1.03–1.52) did not need any antiemetic medications, as compared to the standard care group ( out of 63; 67%) after receiving 27 Gray dose of radiotherapy. More patients in the verum ( of 89; 56%, RR 1.78, CI 1.31–2.42) and the sham acupuncture group ( of 94 answering patients; 62%, RR 1.83, CI 1.20–2.80) were capable of eating as usual, compared to the standard care group ( of 63; 39%).
Let me simplify:
Results. More patients in the verum (82%), and the sham acupuncture group (83%) did not need any antiemetic medications, as compared to the standard care group (67%). More patients in the verum (56%) and the sham acupuncture group (62%) were capable of eating as usual, compared to the standard care group (39%).
Simple. Acupuncture was no better than sham acupuncture.
You do not need a 1,636 word discussion to try and make a silk purse out the sow’s ear trying to find efficacy from acupuncture. You need 7.
Acupuncture is ineffective for the conditions studied.
But but but:
That the consumption of emesis-related care did not differ between the verum and sham acupuncture group may be interpreted as that verum acupuncture does not affect consumption of emesis-related care during radiotherapy, or that a “floor-effect” was seen.
No no no. It may be interpreted that way. It should be interpreted as doing nothing. Although at the very end they grudgingly recognize the fact:
Since nonspecific antiemetic treatment effects during the needling caring situation seem to have achieved the fact that both patients receiving verum and sham acupuncture needed less antiemetics and had larger capacity to eat compared to patients receiving standard care, further studies should evaluate the effect of contextual caring factors for strengthening the quality of care and reducing side-effects such as emesis during cancer therapy.
But pseudo-medical providers just cannot call a negative study what it is: negative.
And “How to tell the difference between acupuncture and dry needling methods.” That’s easy. Unlike dry needlers, acupuncturists don’t wear gloves as the picture in the article shows. Otherwise there is no substantive differences I can find.
I have discussed the catastrophic effects on traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine (TCPM) on plant and animal populations. TCPM may be second only to climate change for driving species extinction. Now it is donkeys. “The donkeys Kenyan families need to survive are heading to China for medicine promising longer life“:
…a global trade in donkey skins has emerged as ejiao has become popular among middle-class Chinese who prize it as an anti-aging agent, an aphrodisiac, a cure for insomnia or poor circulation, among other health benefits. At least 1.8 million donkey hides are traded a year, according to a report last month from the Donkey Sanctuary, a British nonprofit. China’s own donkey population has more than halved since the 1990s,
Yeah, I can see how all those problems would all respond to processed donkey hide, the wonder drug that works wonders. In Africa the donkey decline is increasing the hardships on humans who can no longer afford an important beast of burden. And it isn’t so good for the donkey either. Any species in decline thanks to worthless TCPM.
Department of Tooth Fairy Science
The ability of the Chinese to waste time and resources throwing modern technology at TCPM is truly amazing. As an example we have “Proteomic analysis of tears following acupuncture treatment for menopausal dry eye disease by two-dimensional nano-liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry” where they took:
Tear samples from the AC AT group were subjected to two-dimensional nano-liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (2D nano-LC-MS/MS). Western blot analysis was also performed on tear samples from both groups.
In future studies they will apply the same analysis to unicorn tears, with the same applicability to reality. Such a study makes me want to cry.
Did you know that:
According to traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) theory, a specific physiological and pathological relationship exists between the lungs and the large intestine.
I knew that often in TCPM they often blow it out their…um…no I did not. Well, in “Association of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and hemorrhoids: A nationwide cohort study” they set out to prove it. And did. By showing:
patients with COPD have a higher likelihood of having hemorrhoids
Really. COPD patients are more likely to have hemorrhoids. And so they conclude that:
This study verifies the fundamental theorem of TCM that there is a definite pathogenic association between the lungs and large intestine.
I think the blowing out their, um, well, you know, is more applicable than I realized. Medicine (Baltimore) was a valuable journal when I was a resident. It is sad to see how far they have fallen.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
“How do medical students engaging in elective courses on acupuncture and homeopathy differ from unselected students? A survey“:
Students participating in elective courses had much more positive attitudes towards CAM, somewhat lower science and status orientation…
Somehow I am not surprised the medical students interested in homeopathy and acupuncture were less science-orientated.
Legal and legislative
What does the FDA do? And not do? “Is It Really ‘FDA Approved?’” Here is the list, at least for now. Who knows what will happen to the FDA the next few years.
    • FDA doesn’t approve companies.
    • FDA approves new drugs and biologics.
    • FDA doesn’t approve compounded drugs.
    • FDA uses a risk-based, tiered approach for regulating medical devices.
    • FDA uses a risk-based approach for human cells and tissues.
    • FDA doesn’t approve tobacco products.
    • FDA approves food additives in food for people.
    • FDA approves color additives used in FDA-regulated products.
    • FDA approves animal drugs and approves food additives for use in food for animals.
    • FDA does not approve cosmetics.
    • FDA doesn’t approve medical foods.
    • FDA doesn’t approve infant formula.
    • FDA doesn’t approve dietary supplements.
    • FDA doesn’t approve the food label, including the Nutrition Facts panel.
    • FDA doesn’t approve structure-function claims on dietary supplements and other foods.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Pseudo-scientific weirdness
Gwyneth Paltrow drank only goat milk for a week (and the results are annoyingly impressive) (She is thin. Or photoshopped). She drank the goat’s milk get rid of ‘parasites’. She said:
I’m really interested in the impact of heavy metals and parasites on our bodies… I think they’re two of the biggest culprits in terms of why we feel bad. I’m knee-deep in figuring out ways to clear them from the body, looking at all sorts of potentially weird modalities.
Some NDs love parasites, usually invisible, undiagnosable parasites never seen before by modern science. That kind of parasite. Not the parasites I see in an Infectious Disease practice. And not a ‘person who habitually relies on or exploits others and gives nothing in return’. Oh no, not that. Nothing that meets that definition here.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 03/19/2017
What happened this week? Measles returns to kill. Stem cell injections blind. Lousy acupuncture studies. Fire hot. Skinny jeans are not a reason to see a chiropractor. Lesbian tendencies do not respond to homeopathy. And more.
Mark Crislip on March 19, 2017
Link


Selections from the Society for Science-Based Medicines Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 28, devoted to science-based medicine. More details to follow but registration is open.
What’s the harm?
Does this sound like a good idea to you? Go to a stem cell clinic, pay $5,000 to have the stem cells from your abdomen isolated, then inject those stem cells simultaneously into both eyes to treat macular degeneration. It is not a good idea as “Doctors Say Unproven Stem Cell Treatment Blinded 3 Women” demonstrates:
This report joins a small but growing medical literature highlighting the risks of such wanton misapplication of cellular therapy,” he wrote. Providing such treatments for profit outside a proper research setting “is a gross violation of professional and possibly legal standards…
I had a patient whose naturopath was injecting abdominal stem cells into the knee to treat osteoarthritis and into the gums to treat a receding gum line. She ended up with a knee infection caused by a mouth bacteria. I never could ascertain exactly how the infection occurred, but a suspicious combination of events.
Stem cells are the new antineoplastons, only much more popular.
Vaccination
The adverse effects of the anti-vaccine movement are growing. There has been a threefold rise in measles cases as Italy’s anti-vaccine movement grows with over 700 cases this year, but no deaths. So far.
Other countries are not so fortunate: “Romania Urges Vaccinations to Stop Measles Outbreak.” With a country that has a less than 80% vaccination rate for measles, they are well below levels needed for herd immunity. So they have had over 3,400 cases of measles and 17 children have died, all unvaccinated. I wonder if Dr. Wakefield feels any remorse or guilt?
“30% of Croatian Parents Reluctant to Vaccinate Their Children” and as a result measles has returned to Croatia.
Australia, always competitive, is looking to take the lead in outbreaks of vaccine preventable illnesses: “Vaccinations: Northern Beaches mum wants to open ‘vaccine-free daycare’ to avoid No Jab No Play laws.” What better way to start an epidemic than to cluster all the susceptible children in one place? They should name it the Epicenter Daycare.
Acupuncture
From the Department of Guaranteed False Positives.
Clinical trials that compare an intervention to standard care are often useless.
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is
A trial design that generates only ”positive” results.
We conclude that the ‘A + B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
Yet that is the methodology beloved by traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine and other pseudo-medical researchers. Probably because it tells them what they want to hear. Here are this week’s likely false positives:“Acupuncture in Patients with Allergic Asthma: A Randomized Pragmatic Trial.” Pragmatic is Latin for no valid control. Pragmatic in the title guarantees the trial was a waste of time and money and no conclusions can be drawn:
Patients with allergic asthma were included in a randomized controlled trial and randomized to receive up to 15 acupuncture sessions over 3 months or to a control group receiving routine care alone.
And the acupuncture group had subjective benefits, as would be predicted from a classic placebo effect. Researchers in TCPM don’t read the literature, don’t understand the literature, or ignore the literature. I can think of no other reasons they keep churning out these methodologically-suspect studies.
And now there is a meta-analysis on false positive studies: “The Efficacy of Acupuncture for Treating Depression-Related Insomnia Compared with a Control Group: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.”
Of course they show benefit from acupuncture but it is classic GIGO. When you collect all the small cow pies into one large pile the result is not spun gold, just a large pile of cow pie.
There is also the standard conclusion for most pseudo-medical meta-analysis. Some variation of ‘may be of small benefit but only poor quality studies were located (see above) so more and better studies are required.’ You can almost predict the conclusion when you see Meta-Analysis in the title. As an example, “Clinical Evidence of Chinese Massage Therapy (Tui Na) for Cervical Radiculopathy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis“, which concluded:
Tui Na alone or Tui Na plus cervical traction may be helpful to cervical radiculopathy patients, but supportive evidence seems generally weak. Future clinical studies with low risk of bias and adequate follow-up design are recommended.
Same as it ever was.
Chiropractic
The British Chiropractic Association brings goofy to a new high. First it was text neck. (bunk!) Now “British Chiropractic Association issues health warning over skinny jeans and other wardrobe items“:
WEARING skinny jeans and large fluffy hoods can be bad for your back, experts have warned.
Experts?!? Chiropractors are experts only at instilling fear to generate customers for their worthless interventions.
They refer to a ‘study‘ that was not a study but a consumer survey, the actual results of which I can’t find. We have to take the BCA’s word for it. But evidently 73% of British women had back pain and the BCA blames their wardrobe.
Those skinny jeans are evil:
Tim Hutchful, a chiropractor with the BCA, has said that “they restrict free movement in areas such as the hips and knees, affecting the way we hold our bodies.” Tim went on to berate restrictive clothing in general, saying it “can lead to a loss of ‘bounce’ in your stride, and the natural shock-absorbing qualities in your walk, causing pressure in your joints.” Who knew?
Who knew? No one. It is why it is called chiropractic manipulation. The advice of a chiropractor is worthless.
Herbs and supplements
Hymenaea are a species of South American tree whose sap is used in a product called jatoba as a restorative. The common name of the tree is Stinkingtoe, which does not inspire confidence, and jatoba can be purchased on Amazon as:
an energizing and toning bark. It is also useful as an antibacterial, antifungal, anti-inflammatory, expectorant, anti-yeast and hepatoprotector (liver tonic). It is loaded with nearly 40 phytochemicals, making it useful for many more conditions, as well as a general tonic…
40 phytochemicals! I am impressed, especially since it is an antifungal AND anti-yeast. More is better. As is so often the case when similar products are analyzed, what is on the label is not what is in the product. In “Adulteration and Contamination of Commercial Sap of Hymenaea Species” they analyzed commercial products and found:
…the metabolites composition and multivariate analysis revealed that none of the commercial samples were authentic. In the microbiological contamination analysis, five of the six commercial samples showed positive cultures within the range of 1,700-100,000 CFU/mL
Maybe it should be sold as a probiotic. And they concluded with:
…the commercial samples were deemed inappropriate for consumption and represent a danger to the population.
Quackademia
“This London University Keeps Hosting Pseudoscientific Events.” Regent’s University London has hosted a series of events and lectures which promote pseudoscientific treatments such as homeopathy and screenings of Vaxxed`:
A member of the House of Commons science and technology committee told BuzzFeed News that any universities “lending their good name” to such events risked giving credibility to “unproven quack cures”.
LOL. This from same country with homeopathic hospitals. When you consider all the pseudo-medicine infiltrating US medical institutions under Integrative Medicine, I think we need to redo Casablanca
University: I’m shocked, shocked to find that quackery is going on in here!
[an Integrative Clinic hands University a pile of money]
Clinic: Your earnings, sir.
University: [sotto voce] Oh, thank you very much.
Legal and legislative
Drinkable sunscreen would seem to be ridiculous. Because it is. And others agree: “Iowa attorney general: Drinkable sunscreen ‘flat-out dangerous to consumers’.” The makers feel picked upon by the AG who:
…claims to represent Iowans and yet we have only sold roughly 35 bottles of UV Neutralizer into Iowa in the 5 years it has been for sale. He has no complaints or reports of individuals being burned so we still don’t understand why he thought this was an important spend of taxpayers money.
Of course they were burned, you just need to apply definition 31. That’s why the AG is involved.
“Complaint puts New Age healers on Minnesota regulators’ radar.” The healer in question is Mas Sajady, who offers:
…a powerful meditation and healing tool to help support and accelerate total abundance in all areas of your life; health, wealth, relationships and spirituality.
The Health Department is trying to determine if Mas Sajady is practicing medicine and if so:
…decide whether the provider is following state rules, such as providing a Client Bill of Rights and factual advertising.
They are not in the business of determining:
…whether a treatment is effective or fraudulent.
Which is a good thing for University of Minnesota, which is enthusiastic over holistic practices such as:
Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese MedicineAromatherapyAyurvedic MedicinesBotanical MedicineClinical HypnosisCraniosacral TherapyCreative TherapiesFood as MedicineHealing EnvironmentsHealing TouchHolistic Pregnancy and ChildbirthIntuition in HealthcareMassage TherapyMind-Body TherapiesMindfulnessNaturopathyOsteopathic MedicinePrayerQigongReflexologyReikiShamanismShiatsuSocial SupportTherapeutic TouchTibetan MedicineYoga
And has their own Center for Spirituality & Healing. If you want to offer fraudulent and ineffective therapies, do so in a Integrative Medical Clinic at a University following the rules. You can even get tenure.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Weirdness
“Effects of Intravenous Pharmacopuncture with Harmonizing and Releasing Formulas on Hepatic Recovery after Partial Hepatectomy in Rats.”
Intravenous pharmacopuncture: From the day after the partial hepatectomy, herbal extract (10 mg/kg) was given intravenously.
Intravenous injections are now pharmacopuncture. LOL. I order my antibiotics as pharmacopuncture. Anything and everything can be some form of puncture, just like every political scandal eventually has ‘gate’ appended to it. I still want to do a study of blood draws, with half the patients being told their blood is being drawn through an acupuncture point to decrease discomfort and increase energy. I bet I would show less pain in the phlebopuncture group. And those who draw blood can be called phlebopuncturists. Since neither word shows up on a google search with that spelling, I hereby trademark and copyright the terms. Pay me if you want to use them.
And people do the weirdest stuff, some of it being published. There is placentopuncture: “Therapeutic effect of acupuncture point injection with placental extract in knee osteoarthritis.” This is the usual useless study: no placebo control. Unfortunately, all the links to the full text are dead ends, so I can’t see whose placenta was being extracted and how, although all the articles I could find on placentopuncture are out of Korea for pain. Usually placenta is touted for postpartum depression, so I wonder how it would work on knee pain.
And we finish with: “Shockingly, Fetus Water Will Not Cure Your Lesbianism .” The homeopathic preparation Dr.Reckeweg R20 Glandular drops for Women apparently:
Treats the failure of a female to respond to sexual stimulus (frigidity), lesbian tendencies, congestion and faulty circulation
Yep. All those issues belong together. Does it work? Nope. A funny tongue in cheek N of 1 trial resulted in:
Outcome at day five: totally gay. At the end of the week, I’m just as filled with lesbian tendencies as I was when I started. The only thing that’s significantly different about me are my hands—which are much softer thanks to the moisturizer that came free with the R20.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review. 03/26/2017
Death from naturopathy. Cows and soldiers have a similar problem. Pseudo-medicines never die. Chiropractic complications. And more.
Mark Crislip on March 26, 2017
Link


Selections from the Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 28, devoted to science-based medicine. More details to follow but registration is open.
What’s the harm?
This week there was a death from intravenous turmeric: “A Naturopath’s Human Experiment Ends In Death.” Experiment. Somehow I do not think the headline writer knows what an experiment is. Turmeric is a spice with alleged anti-inflammatory effects. Why use it IV?
“There are some doctors who use Turmeric extract in IV form to try and heighten the physiological effects, so the anti-inflammatory effects of the turmeric,” Stengler explained. “It hasn’t been well studied. It’s more theoretical, so it’s more investigational.”
Investigational? Like an IRB approved protocol? Or ND investigational: screwing around killing people because they really have no idea what they are doing.
The patient died after a cardiac arrest while receiving the preparation. I am sure the ND involved also has extensive experience in resuscitating a cardiac arrest. I except to see similar cases as more NDs are licensed and given free rein to inflict whatever ‘investigational’ therapy they see fit.
NDs are not the only ones trying to kill people. I have seen one case of tetanus in my 31 years. It was an elderly Asia immigrant who never received the vaccination series as a child. It was a terrible disease, every muscle in her body contracting at once. I hope to never witness another, but I am not optimistic. As Clay discussed on Friday, in Australia an unvaccinated 7-year-old developed tetanus: “Vaccination debate flares on NSW north coast after 7yo contracts tetanus.” The NW of Australia evidently has the lowest vaccination rates in the country, so they are also likely to see measles and mumps.
Acupuncture
Mice, cows, children and our soldiers often suffer due to those in authority over them. A researcher, a farmer, a parent, or a commanding officer gets the erroneous idea that acupuncture has efficacy, and it is mouse, child, or soldier who gets to suffer. As in “Acupuncture becomes popular as battlefield pain treatment.” It was once noted that I seemed angry. Let’s see, is giving a wounded solider a theatrical placebo worthy of anger? I would think so. And they are wasting 5.4 million dollars in the process of training others to apply battlefield acupuncture.
The training is standardized to ensure it’s done right,
There is no such thing as the right acupuncture. But at least they are using gold needles. “Battlefield acupuncture was considered the worst quackery of 2011.” The result? More battlefield acupuncture not less. Sigh. Such a waste. And our troops deserve better.
“Swiss trainee vets to give cows acupuncture in new classes.” How now brown cow acupuncture? They see it as:
a way of maintaining animal health without the use of antibiotics.
Like that is going to work.
Be it opiate overuse or antibiotic overuse, the solution to problems with medicine is not to turn to pseudo-medicine.
Chiropractic
Pseudo-medical providers often say their interventions are risk free. Not so, of course. Everything has risk and, as “Adverse events in a chiropractic spinal manipulative therapy single-blinded, placebo, randomized controlled trial for migraineurs” shows, mild complications are not rare, occurring about 20% of the time. Local tenderness, tiredness and neck pain were the most common AEs. Fortunately no severe reactions occurred in the study.
The adverse effects from chiropractors also come from their advertising and general practice. An investigation into DC advertising in Canada found they often run counter to science-based medicine. Including:
    • Offers of treatments for autism, Tourette’s syndrome, Alzheimer’s disease, colic, infections and cancer.
    • Anti-vaccination literature and recently published letters to the editor from chiropractors that discourage vaccination.
    • An article claiming vaccines have caused a 200 to 600 per cent increase in autism rates.
    • A statement that claims the education and training of a chiropractor is “virtually identical” to that of a medical doctor.
    • Discouraging people from getting diagnostic tests such as CT scans, colonoscopies and mammograms.
    • An informational video discouraging the use of sunscreen.
No surprise. It is not as if chiropractic training is based in science and, like many pseudo-medical providers, they are prone to crank magnetism. One reaction was “Manitoba chiropractors need proactive oversight over members, says health lawyer.” As if their professional organizations are any better at understanding SBM. They are made up of chiropractors after all.
I suspect there is no way to improve chiropractic practice. Can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear.
Herbs and supplements
Two more supplement fails this week: “Vitamin E and Selenium Fail to Prevent Alzheimer’s.”
And:
“Sorry, moms: Prenatal vitamins with DHA won’t boost your kids’ IQ after all.”
Not that such results will have much impact on the 21-billion-dollar-a-year vitamin and supplement market.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
“Can We Determine Sasang Constitutional Body Type Merely by Facial Inspection?” Nope.
As SC type cannot be precisely diagnosed using anthroscopic examination alone
But what is the Sasang Constitutional Body Type? A form of classification in traditional Korean pseudo-medicine where people have one of four types that inescapably determine their destiny. It is one of many forms of medical astrology and total nonsense. No surprise that its practitioners can’t reliably make the diagnosis. Good luck with your goal of “a definitive objective and scientific diagnosing method to [become] a scientifically verified alternative medicine”.
Pseudo-medicine promotion
“Your Craniosacralist Will See You Now: Can A Startup Bring Alt Medicine To The Mainstream?”
SereneBook, a subscription-based holistic health network, is betting on the $30 billion alternative medicine industry.
It looks like they are trying to be the Angie’s List of pseudo-medicine.
Every practitioner on SereneBook is certified, rated, vetted and approved. We bring you the best of the best in wellness worldwide.
Certified, rated, vetted, and approved pseudo-medicine is still pseudo-medicine.
Legal and legislative
Last week we, and by we I mean me, noted the patients who became blind after stem cells were injected into their eyes to treat macular degeneration. The problem of stem cell clinics is further discussed at “Strip mall stem cells” and “Sunrise stem cell clinic behind blindness cases is largely unregulated.” Stem cell clinics has been described as the Wild West of medicine. More like Boot Hill.
Really, we need to start our own science-based medicine predatory/opinion journal to promote SBM. Such an approach is de rigueur in the pseudo-medical world. Take Issues in Law & Medicine which is described as:
A One-Stop Journal for Anti-Vaccine, Anti-Abortion Pseudoscience.
SBM is so behind the times.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Weirdness
As I have mentioned in the past, no pseudo-medicine ever goes away. Like leeches. “Garfield Therapist Specializes In Mankind’s Oldest Medicine: Leeches.” I wonder if there is a parallel with the world’s oldest profession. The leech whisperer mentions he is not a doctor and cannot diagnose or treat illnesses. Well duh.
I just wonder if he is aware of the risk Aeromonas infections from leeches. I bet not. But:
the Comprehensive Body Leech Detoxification has no equal in the world.
I am sure it doesn’t.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/02/2017
Death from vaccine-preventable infections. Homeopathy and acupuncture do not work. There is a difference between cost and worth. And more.
Mark Crislip on April 2, 2017
Link
Shares

Selections from the Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
Announcement
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 28, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change).
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in Medicine: Statin Denialists and Others.
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong.
    • David Gorski: TBA.
    • Steve Novella: TBA.
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine. How are we doing? and Q&A.
Vaccination
We are heading into the end of the influenza season. Finally. Flu still kills. The CDC tracks pediatric deaths. In 2013, 111 children died of flu. In 2014 it was 148. In 2016, 89. This year, 61.
Numbers do not do justice to the tragedy of death from a vaccine-preventable illness. For that I suggest “How my daughter died from a simple case of flu.”
Something was horribly wrong.When she leaned back in the tub and I saw her eyes, I knew she was dying.I got behind her and lifted her out. I sat on the toilet with her sitting on my lap and she died.There was nothing that could be done to save her.Health care professionals — from ambulance EMTs to the mighty Mayo Clinic — couldn’t bring her back to me.The flu destroyed her organs. She didn’t even know it.
If not flu, then measles. Infections kill.
Olivia, my eldest daughter, caught measles when she was seven years old. As the illness took its usual course I can remember reading to her often in bed and not feeling particularly alarmed about it. Then one morning, when she was well on the road to recovery, I was sitting on her bed showing her how to fashion little animals out of coloured pipe-cleaners, and when it came to her turn to make one herself, I noticed that her fingers and her mind were not working together and she couldn’t do anything.
“Are you feeling all right?” I asked her.
“I feel all sleepy,” she said.
In an hour, she was unconscious. In twelve hours she was dead.
“Deadly measles outbreak spreads in Europe as vaccinations fall.” Romania, with less than 90% of children vaccinated, has had 2,000 cases with 17 deaths. Why? The “Measles outbreak spreads across Europe as parents shun vaccinations, World Health Organisation warns.” And it will likely spread further, causing even more needless suffering and death.
The Anti-Vaccine Body Count for the US has not been updated since 2015 when it was at 9,028 preventable deaths. It was called the Jenny McCarthy Body Count. It should be renamed the “Ileal-lymphoid-nodular hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive developmental disorder in children” body count, in ‘honor’ of the retracted Lancet article by Andrew Wakefield that launched the current measles epidemic. Autism has not declined with decreasing vaccination but it has been a boon for ICUs and morticians.
Acupuncture
The pseudo-medical world often operates under the twin delusions that healthy people can’t get infections and that their interventions are harmless.
As an infectious disease doctor I am all-too aware of how, with a perfect storm, perfectly healthy people can be fine in the morning and be dead the next day from an overwhelming infection. I remember a case as an intern of a patient who had an IV placed in the field during a cardiac arrest. The IV site got infected, the S. aureus from the infection seeded her aortic valve, which failed, and she died.
Needles are dangerous, not that acupuncturists are aware, given their cavalier approach to using gloves. That leads to “Man dead after acupuncture treatment“:
Four days after the acupuncture treatment to his hand in February 2015, the man began to feel poorly, he threw up, had diarrhea and also complained of pain in his hand.
A few days after he was admitted, the doctors decided to amputate his arm to try to save his life, but it was too late. The 64-year-old man died due to sepsis and multiple-organ failure.
Sounds like a S. pyogenes infection, also known as the flesh-eating bacteria. Paying with your life from a useless placebo.
And acupuncture is a useless placebo. The results from quality placebo-controlled studies will demonstrate that acupuncture is be no better than placebo, as in useless. Two examples this week. First, “Electroacupuncture Therapy in Nicotine Dependence: A Double Blind, Sham-Controlled Study.” Their conclusion?
This study showed that both TEAT (true EA therapy) and SEAT (sham EA therapy) have similar efficacy and safety profiles in patients with ND.
And:
This study showed that the effectiveness of EA in ND therapy is at the level of placebo.
Although they cannot quite make the leap to make the declarative sentence that therefore acupuncture does nothing.
Not in “Acupuncture for menopausal hot flashes: clinical evidence update and its relevance to decision making“, where they found that:
Acupuncture improves menopausal hot flashes compared with no treatment; however, not compared with sham acupuncture. This is also consistent with the evidence that a range of placebo interventions improve menopausal symptoms… Some women may choose acupuncture for hot flashes, a potentially disabling condition without long-term adverse health consequences. Yet, women should do so understanding the evidence, and its strengths and weaknesses, around both effective medical therapies and acupuncture. Likewise, cost to the individual and the health system needs to be considered in the context of value-based health care.
Just because acupuncture is a fiction doesn’t stop its practitioners from trying to validate it with science. Well, pseudo-science. Take “Acupuncture Meridian Energies in Patients Who Are Mentally Disturbed.” They used the AcuGraph, a meridian-energy measuring device. Not really. It measures skin conductance, like an E-meter, and measuring skin conductance is popular in the world of pseudo-medicine, adding a science-y patina to their practice.
That skin conductance changes with emotional states is well known, it is part of the basis of the lie detector. Interpreting this response as due to the pseudo-science of acupuncture meridian energies and publishing it in PubMed is appalling.
Department of Acupuncture Meta-Analysis. Same as it ever was.
Meta-analyses of acupuncture usually conclude with a version of ‘some effect, the studies are poor, more studies need to be done’. Well, two out of three are true. As examples, this week we have “Acupuncture and moxibustion for chronic fatigue syndrome in traditional Chinese medicine: a systematic review and meta-analysis“:
In the treatment of CFS, CbAM and SAM may have better effect than other treatments. However, the included trials have relatively poor quality, hence high quality studies are needed to confirm our finding.
And “Acupuncture plus moxibustion for herpes zoster: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
Acupuncture plus moxibustion may improve pain and cutaneous outcomes, although current evidence is limited by the number of studies and methodological shortcomings.
Chiropractic
“Global Chiropractic Care Market Projected to be Worth USD 39.58 Billion by 2021: Technavio.” Global chiropractic care may cost $39.58 billion, but it is worthless.
Homeopathy
Homeopathy is water. You know that, I know that. Water only treats thirst. That studies are done on the efficacy of water, and that IRB’s will approve such studies, demonstrates that reality-based medicine doesn’t understand the world of pseudo-medicine.
Remember how I mentioned that flu kills? No often, but it can. So how do we get studies like “Effectiveness of preventive treatment by Influenzinum in the winter period against the onset of influenza-like illnesses“? Influenzinum in not an ancient Roman city but is a homeopathic remedy made from the influenza vaccine aka a nosode. Influenzinum didn’t work. Influenzinum shouldn’t work. And to evaluate it for a potentially fatal illness defines unethical.
And that is not the only trial to evaluate water for a disease that kills: “Homeopathic medicines for prevention of influenza and acute respiratory tract infections in children: blind, randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trial.” It amazes me that searching “homeopathy infection clinical trial” has 34 hits.
I wonder of Prince Charles noted “Randomized, blinded, controlled clinical trial shows no benefit of homeopathic mastitis treatment in dairy cows“?
The results indicated no additional effect of homeopathic treatment compared with placebo.
What a surprise. At least if a cow dies, you get dinner rather than a grieving family and a life cut short.
And homeopaths, taking their cue from acupuncturists, have the same template for their conclusions of a meta-analysis. In “Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials of non-individualised homeopathic treatment: systematic review and meta-analysis” they conclude:
There was a small, statistically significant, effect of non-individualised homeopathic treatment. However, the finding was not robust to sensitivity analysis based solely on the three trials that comprised reliable evidence: the effect size estimate collectively for those three trials was not statistically significant. There was significant evidence of publication bias in favour of homeopathy.
Legal and legislative
Science doesn’t seem to sway legislatures when they are evaluating pseudo-medicine, which is why, for example, at least 20 states have licensed naturopaths. But money talks and legislatures listen. “Arkansas senators reject Medicaid chiropractic services bill.”
A bill that would allow Medicaid recipients to seek chiropractic services without a physician referral failed Thursday in the Senate after opponents complained that it would add to the costs of the government-run health insurance program for the poor.
866 Medicaid recipients had physician referrals for chiropractic services in the prior year. Without the referral there might be 52,000 chiropractic visits a year costing $3.4 million. All for nothing.
Some of you may remember that Science-Based Medicine was sued and won. And in the process legal precedence was made: “No Scrubs Permitted: Eleventh Circuit Affirms Blog Post Is Not Advertising Actionable Under Lanham Act“:
the Eleventh Circuit held that a doctor’s blog post criticizing another doctor and his clinical practice could not form the basis of a Lanham Act claim because the blog posts were not commercial advertising or promotion.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/09/2017
The NECSS is coming. Acupuncturists mimic chiropractic. Flu vaccine prevents death. In the UK they care more for cats than people. The problem is my middle burner, not too many burgers. And more.
Mark Crislip on April 9, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30th, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change):
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in Medicine: Statin Denialists and Others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: TBA
    • Steve Novella: TBA
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine. How are we doing? Q&A
Other appearances of SBM principals
Dr. Gorski was interviewed for the Trolling With Logic podcast. This time around, he discusses VAXXED.
What’s the harm?
Acupuncturists probably only have a vague idea what lies under the skin. There are all sorts of important structures that can be hit by a needle, puncturing which can result in everything from a popped lung to a bleed. As an example, “Acute Spinal Epidural Hematoma after Acupuncture: Personal Case and Literature Review” joins 6 similar cases:
64-year-old man who presented a left hemiparesis associated with paraesthesias. This appeared several hours after acupuncture treatment for left lumbosciatic pain. The Cervico-thoracic Spine MRI scan showed a cervico-thoracic spinal epidural hematoma from C2 to T12.
Needles in the neck for low back pain. Yeah, that shows understanding of neuroanatomy. They jammed the needle “most of the needle length”, around 2 to 3 inches, into the neck until an electric shock feeling let the patient know the spinal cord had been hit. Then came the gusher.
The acupoint used is:
On the nape, in the depression on the lateral border of m. trapezius, within the posterior hairline
And comes with the warning:
Do not insert the needle deeply medially upwards to avoid injuring the medulla oblongata.
Ya think? Because the medulla oblongata is somewhat important.
In subsequent letters to the editor, it is suggested that the points used were safe if the needle penetrated < 34.8 mm at the Fuchi point. That is 1.37 inches. That’s deep. And I like the 0.8. As if there is a practitioner who can tell 0.8 mm.
And of course, true to the inability of pseudo-medical providers everywhere who ignorantly muck about where they do not belong causing injury, they suggest that the epidural hematoma was spontaneous rather than due to a needle jammed to its hilt into the spine.
First chiropractors, and now acupuncturists, are trying their best to damage the cervical spinal cord. And denying it.
Vaccination
Here on Science-Based Medicine I have pontificated at great length about the benefits of influenza vaccination. It is not a perfect vaccine, but it decreases the odds of acquiring flu and, if you get influenza, it decreases the chance that you will die. Not dying is good. In “Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Against Pediatric Deaths: 2010–2014” they found:
Best estimates based on NHIS survey data suggested that vaccination reduced the risk of influenza-associated death by half among children with high-risk conditions and by nearly two-thirds among children without high-risk conditions.
In 2013 111 children died of flu. In 2014 148. In 2016 89. This year 61. Many of those deaths may have been preventable with the vaccine.
Low vaccination rates are often found in affluent communities and are in part due to anti-vaccination fears. But poverty can also play a large role. In Richmond Virginia: “Lacking Tdap vaccine, 44% of Richmond sixth-graders missed class this school year.” Some of the lack of vaccination is due to vaccination fears and exemptions, but with 40% of the city’s children living in poverty:
Having so few Richmond Public School students submit religious or medical exemptions suggests that other reasons — such as cost, transportation or a lack of education — may be getting in the way of students receiving their vaccinations on time, Holmes noted.
So the poor of Richmond are primed for an outbreak, just like the affluent children of Silicon Valley. The nice thing about infections is they don’t care if you are rich or poor, just that you are susceptible.
Anti-vaccination fears have found new ways to kill and injure children, as it spills over into other medical interventions. As the misleading headline demonstrates: “Five-week-old baby boy fighting for life in hospital after parents’ refused a vital anti-vax shot .”
It is not an anti-vax shot, but a vitamin K shot. Newborns can be deficient in vitamin K (needed to make clotting factors) and, if not boosted after birth, babies can bleed into their brain, as occurred with this child. The shot has nothing to do with vaccination, but is another way for the anti-vaccine rhetoric to kill and maim:
The preventative vitamin K shot has been regarded as new fighting points of anti-vaccine activists, who tactically scare new parents into dismissing the shot – a safe injection which has saved hundreds of newborns from fatal haemorrhagic disease
There has never been a cerebral bleed in a child who has received a vitamin K injection, a few in those who have opted for oral vitamin K, and hundreds in the old days before supplementation. As noted by Forbes “The Anti-Vaccine Movement Has Found A New, Alarming Way To Threaten Public Health.”
Acupuncture
More poorly done acupuncture studies. Of course, that’s being redundant. We have “The effects of acupuncture versus sham acupuncture in the treatment of fibromyalgia: a randomized controlled clinical trial.”
They compared SHAM and real acupuncture in 50 fibromyalgia patients (25 in each group) and evaluated 16 different parameters, of which 8 were ‘statically significant’. They did not show error bars, but every ‘significant’ parameter had huge overlap. They did not evaluate to see if blinding was successful in patients, important since it is belief in receiving acupuncture that results in a positive response.
At least two reasons the results are likely false:
Corollary 1: The smaller the studies conducted in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 3: The greater the number and the lesser the selection of tested relationships in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Plus there was a key and fatal flaw
Baseline demographic findings, pain intensity during activity, rest and at night, quantified with a 10 cm visual analog scale (VAS), FIQ, Medical Outcomes Survey Short Form-36 (SF-36), Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) and Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS) were obtained. Patients were evaluated by the same physician (not blinded)for these parameters before treatment, 1 month and 2 months after the first session treatment
So when they say:
Additionally, a potential bias would have ensued due to the fact that the physician who performed the assessments was not blinded. Nevertheless, our results are noteworthy.
Potential bias? Really? That’s like saying the Grand Wizard of the KKK has potential bias. I would say, yeah, noteworthy for yet another worthless acupuncture study.
Department of Guaranteed False Positives
Clinical trials that compare an intervention to standard care are often useless.
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is:
A trial design that generates only ”positive” results.
We conclude that the ‘A B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
It’s 2017. They have been doing acupuncture research for over 50 years. One would think researchers would know better. Yet that is the methodology beloved by traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine and other pseudo-medical researchers. Probably because it tells them what they want to hear. Here are this week’s likely false positive studies, a waste of time and resources:
There is “Effects of Auricular Acupressure on Obesity in Women with Abdominal Obesity.” Treatment with:
auricular acupressure using vaccaria seeds was administered to the experimental group
And compared to a control. And they purport causality.
auricular acupressure using vaccaria seeds was effective in decreasing body weight, abdominal circumference, body mass index, and triglyceride levels in adult women with abdominal obesity.
I just want to know why ‘battlefield acupuncture’ doesn’t use vaccaria seeds instead of needles. One of these acupunctures is wrong.
And there is “Electroacupuncture and splinting versus splinting alone to treat carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomized controlled trial.”
181 patients were randomly assigned to electroacupuncture combined with splinting or splinting alone.
Given the methodology that will always lead to a positive result, it is not surprise that:
For patients with primary carpal tunnel syndrome, chronic mild to moderate symptoms and no indication for surgery, electroacupuncture produces small changes in symptoms, disability, function, dexterity and pinch strength when added to nocturnal splinting.
But what were the small changes? Of 18 endpoints, one had a p <0.01. There was almost NO added benefit to adding electroacupuncture. Pseudo-medical researchers are the Fonz and just can’t say the study is negative. Only in the world of pseudo-medicine would such a negative study be spun as positive and the intervention recommended for patients.
Same as it ever was.
Naturopathy
California NPR asks the question “Should naturopaths be allowed to perform sports physicals?”
Well, no. But the article contains the standard alternative fact:
Naturopaths are trained in four-year “post graduate naturopathic medical schools that are comparable to that of an MD or [Doctor of Osteopathy,]” says Bahr. “This training includes the same diagnostic skills and tools as medical doctors, including physical exams.”
So not true and provided with no contrary information.
NDs and DCs are slowly but surely convincing the world they can perform the same function as real doctors.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
Exercise is valuable for a variety of processes and is not ‘alternative’. But exercise can get a pseudo-scientific patina, as in Does Tai Chi relieve fatigue? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
The results suggest that Tai Chi could be an effective alternative and /or complementary approach to existing therapies for people with fatigue. However, the quality of the evidence was only moderate and may have the potential for bias.
Such a result from exercise does not surprise me, but part of the underlying rationale is bogus.
In the theory of Chinese medicine (CM), Tai Chi can maintain the harmony between qi and the blood, keep yin and yang in balance and also enhance immunity. These properties are both important in relieving fatigue and maintaining energy. Qi, the energy which promotes the body’s movement, can circulate around the entire body freely if yin and yang are kept in balance.
And, as is always the case, there were at least 6 different styles of Tai Chi in the analysis. Like many evaluations of traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine, Tai Chi is treated as if it were a monolithic entity instead of the hodgepodge of styles it is with no commonality beyond movement.
Homeopathy
I have long been suspicious that people care more about pets than we do for each other. The UK is home to homeopathy hospitals for humans paid for by the National Health Service. But don’t mess with cats: “Woman’s animal ban after she used homeopathy on ill cat instead of taking it to the vet“:
“The vet was shocked to see the condition he was in and said there was an atrocious smell that was caused by the poor cat’s rotting flesh that had been left untreated for several weeks.”
Ringblom claimed that the abscess had only begun to get progressively worse over the course of a week and said she specifically wanted her pet to be treated with homeopathy.
As well as being banned from keeping any animals for life, Ringblom was ordered to pay £100 costs and a £85 victim surcharge. She was ordered to do 50 hours of unpaid community work which must be carried out within the next 12 months.
Next up: Prince Charles loses his farm? I don’t think so.
Legal and legislative
The current Trojan rabbit of the pseudo-medical world has been opiate addiction and chronic pain. “As opioid crisis flares, naturopaths and chiropractors lobby for bigger roles in treating pain.” And it is working. Unfortunately, the world is opting for magic carpets.
Acupuncturists are not fans of dry needling and try to stop it at every turn: “Acupuncturists sue Colorado’s physical therapy board over the very definition of their craft.” Their objection?
In the suit, the groups say they pushed to have Rule 211 — adopted five years ago — abolished because it allows physical therapists to practice dry-needling with only 46 hours of training for the very same procedures acupuncturists must attend 1,905 hours of classes to be licensed — more than 40 times the amount.
Doctors can get by with 200 hours of training.
The problem is, of course, that 46 hours or 1,900 hours of training in pseudo-medicine does not make its application any safer or effective.
And the Wyoming legislature has given its imprimatur of approval to acupuncture: “State acupuncturists celebrate new regulations“:
The bill, House Bill 165, was passed by the Legislature and signed last month by Gov. Matt Mead. It creates a board of acupuncture with five governor-appointed members and a mandate to approve license applications and create standards for licensed practitioners.
One reason for the bill was:
To help treat people in pain, which hopefully will reduce opiate use.
Drip, drip, drip. The slow advance of pseudo-medicine.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Department of Goofiness
The goofiest statement this week was in “Cooling kidney and spleen heat through acupuncture.”
In traditional Chinese medicine, obesity can be distinguished in terms of emptiness, fullness, and full heat. Primary obesity is due to a weakness in the middle burner of spleen and stomach.
And here I thought it was eating too much and exercising too little. I am going to turn down the gas on that middle burner.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/16/2017
Mumps cases, like infected parotids, swell. Doctors win with false news?!? More acupuncture studies not recognized as negative. Paying for pseudo-medicine in Vermont. Your consciousness is in your organs. And more.
Mark Crislip on April 16, 2017
Link


Selections from the Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change):
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in Medicine: Statin Denialists and Others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: TBA
    • Steve Novella: TBA
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine. How are we doing. Q&A
What’s the harm?
Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable illnesses keep popping up. The Texas Department of State Health Services is investigating multiple outbreaks of mumps and they are on track to have the highest mumps incidence in 22 years with 221 cases.
Manitoba has had 290 cases of mumps and public health authorities are worried they may reach 600 cases. And there are outbreaks of mumps at Penn State with at least 68 cases and Kansas State which has had 15 cases of mumps.
There were also five cases of measles in unvaccinated children in Minneapolis and two cases in Ann Arbor.
I wonder when he looks in the mirror if Andrew Wakefield is proud of what stares back.
Vaccination
Outbreaks of vaccine-preventable illnesses are not inevitable. It’s why we call them “vaccine-preventable”. “In ‘stealth move,’ Michigan refines vaccine waivers, improves rate among kids.” What they did was genius, requiring:
families to consult personally with local public health departments before obtaining an immunization waiver.
Public health departments are unlikely to have a low bar to meet to get a waiver. Good move.
But it would be nice if there were a way to sway the vaccine hesitant, and there may be a way. In “The Immunity Community: A Community Engagement Strategy for Reducing Vaccine Hesitancy“:
The program successfully engaged parent volunteers to be immunization advocates. Surveys of parents in the intervention communities showed statistically significant improvements in vaccine-related attitudes: The percentage concerned about other parents not vaccinating their children increased from 81.2% to 88.6%, and the percentage reporting themselves as “vaccine-hesitant” decreased from 22.6% to 14.0%.
Not bad.
Acupuncture and TCPM
More negative studies this week, although not always spun as such. In “Clinical Evaluation of Acupuncture as Treatment for Complications of Cerebrovascular Accidents: A Randomized, Sham-Controlled, Subject- and Assessor-Blind Trial“, they found:
Reduction in pain was significantly greater in the acupuncture group than in the control group (p value = 0.04). There were no significant differences in the other measures between the two groups.Conclusions. Acupuncture provided more effective poststroke pain relief than sham acupuncture treatment. However, acupuncture had no better effect on neurological, functional, and psychological improvement.
I would be skeptical that the 0.04 was meaningful, even if ’statistically significant’. I have been persuaded that significant is at least 0.005 and better if 0.001 especially for interventions with a prior plausibility of (almost) zero. The study was out of Asia, where all the women are strong, all the men are good looking, all the children are above average, and all the acupuncture studies are positive. Plus, they do not report if blinding was successful in the patients – a fatal flaw since the acupuncturists were not blinded and could have been giving cues to the patients, the Clever Hans effect.
There are all sorts of acupunctures, including injecting bee venom, a form no better (i.e. worthless) than any other of the endless forms of acupuncture. But the nice thing about bee venom is it a potent allergen. In “Safety of essential bee venom pharmacopuncture as assessed in a randomized controlled double-blind trial” they noted:
frequent occurrence of allergic reactions during the treatment process is burdensome for both practitioner and patient.
You think? So they decided to modify the bee venom:
isolated and purified essential BV (eBV) pharmacopuncture filtered for phospholipase A2 (PLA2) and histamine sections.
And found it was less allergenic but, as would be expected for a placebo, it had similar effects. So now there is a less toxic formulation of a placebo. If they really want to make it non-allergenic, might I suggest using homeopathic bee venom? Same placebo, even less toxicity. Except for the bacterial and mycobacterial contamination.
What is the problem with using sham acupuncture? From a science-based medicine perspective, nothing. From an acupuncturist’s perspective, the problem is that when done correctly, acupuncture is not better than sham acupuncture, aka no effect. Acupuncturists, like other pseudo-medical providers, just cannot handle the truth that their intervention is a placebo and are always looking for an out. In “The U.K. NICE 2014 Guidelines for Osteoarthritis of the Knee: Lessons Learned in a Narrative Review Addressing Inadvertent Limitations and Bias” they whinge and suggest:
Given the problems with sham acupuncture, perhaps now is the time to embrace pragmatic studies and employ comparative effectiveness studies instead.
Yep. Embrace the methodologies that confirm your bias rather than inform your understanding of medicine. Hear no science, see no science, speak no science, the pseudo-medical motto. Denial is more than a river in Egypt. Same as it ever was.
The Chinese are worried that they are losing the C in TCPM. In “Others profit from our medical lore” they complain that:
Japan and South Korea together hold 70 percent of herbal medicine patents, while China “holds an embarrassing 0.3 percent.” … In the past decade, South Korea and Japan have aggressively marketed their products not only in their own countries, but also in China and even the West… “Apart from the name,” there is no longer anything Chinese about Chinese traditional medicine.
Boo hoo. Everyone is co-opting TCPM. Now we can call it Modern Asian Pseudo-Medicine?
Homeopathy
The reports on deaths and seizures for homeopathic teething products began in January of this year, although the first FDA warning was in 2010. So four months, or perhaps seven years, later, “Homeopathy company launches nationwide recall of tablets blamed for infant seizures.” About time.
I have said many times that pseudo-medical providers care nothing for patient safety. I am waiting for a counter example.
In fact, their delusions lead to harmful, and perhaps fatal, interventions. If you celebrate “World Homeopathy Awareness Week: Try homeopathy for these 7 diseases that usually need surgery, suggests an expert“, make sure all your affairs are in order. Surgical diseases where homeopathy was suggested instead of surgery included nasal polyps, uterine prolapse, umbilical hernia, and tumors. Evidently the author an expert in lunacy. Or a mortician looking for business.
Critical thinking
‘Doctors have decades of experience fighting “fake news.” Here’s how they win.’ A nice review, except for the whole ‘win’ thing, at least to judge from the growth of Integrative Medical Clinics, the continued legitimizing of NDs, DCs and LAcs as real medical providers by legislatures, and the declining vaccination rates. Except for that, we have certainly been winning the war against fake news.
A case in point: “‘pH Miracle’ Author Admits He’s No MD, Microbiologist or ‘Trained Scientist’.”
The defendant also admitted that he was not a microbiologist, hematologist, medical doctor, naturopathic doctor or trained scientist.”
Why is naturopathic doctor on this list? The drip drip drip of pseudo-medical legitimization continues, with at best rare wins.
Sigh.
Legal and legislative
Acupuncture has no efficacy for pain or withdrawal, but these problems continue to be the Trojan rabbit for pseudo-medicine to enter the mainstream aka get insurance reimbursement. “Progress on health coverage for acupuncture” in Vermont, where a legislator is proud to say
I am happy to report that many measures the Legislature enacted to address the opiate crises have started to move us toward universal access to acupuncture.
Mandating fraud payment. Great. What pseudo-medical providers cannot get with science they get through the legislature. I am reminded that the opposite of progress is Congress.
In New Jersey, a “Legal opinion could curb ‘dry needling’ practice by physical therapists.” The:
Attorney general [decided] physical therapy does not include treatments that break the skin; acupuncturists applaud opinion
Acupuncturists complained that physical therapists were endangering patients by performing a type of acupuncture they are not trained to provide.
As if acupuncturists are any safer. At least dry needlers wear gloves.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Department of Goofiness
This week we have “Heart-conscious chiropractic: ‘He works magic,’ say patients of Grass Valley’s John Mayfield.”
Mayfield began attending seminars where he learned each organ is part of a person’s total consciousness.
I have patients with any number of removed organs: spleens, kidneys, bowel, lungs, and they do not lack for consciousness, although I did have the patient who had a hand transplant from a murderer. That ended badly. At first glance I thought the title of the movie with that plot was The Hands of Orac. LOL.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/23/2017
Protection from vampires. An autistic muppet upsets anti-vaxers. Naturopaths want insurance money. Big Chiro: what THEY don’t want you to know. This blog is futile. And more.
Mark Crislip on April 23, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change):
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in Medicine: Statin Denialists and Others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: Whither the antivaccine movement in the age of Trump
    • Steve Novella: TBA. He is the International Skeptic of Mystery. Skeptics want to be him.
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine. How are we doing. Q&A
What’s the harm?
What pseudo-medical harm was reported this week? There is “Garlic Dermatitis on the Neck of an Infant Treated for Nasal Congestion.” The title says it all. At least the child was protected from vampires. Over the years I have seen a variety of examples of contact dermatitis mistaken for cellulitis from a number of different natural products: aloe vera, tea tree oil, and lavender oil have been the big three.
Pop pop. I am amused by the contention that licensed acupuncturists are safe. Practitioners of pseudo-science often have only a vague understanding of anatomy and physiology. With acupuncture that can lead to needles being pushed too deep, as in “Safety Concerns with Thoracoabdominal Acupuncture: Experience at a Tertiary-Care Emergency Department“:
There were 10 cases of pneumothorax (one combined with pneumomediastinum) and two cases of pneumoperitoneum induced by acupuncture.
The authors suggest:
To maximize the safety of acupuncture, adequate competency-based training should be provided.
How can you become competent in a useless pseudo-medicine with no basis in reality? It is like suggesting becoming a unicorn wrangler.
You don’t have to go to Flint for heavy metal toxicity. Yet another Ayurveda nostrum filled with a deadly metal: “Lead Poisoning Due to Herbal Medications.” Stay away from Ayurveda.
And finally there was “Back pain in the emergency department: Pathological fracture following spinal manipulation“:
Following initial presentation to the family physician, the patient underwent three treatments of spinal manipulation from his local chiropractor, which resulted in worsening lower back pain. A re-examination and new radiographs in the hospital revealed multiple compression fractures and an underlying diagnosis of multiple myeloma.
Ouch. Tough way to make a myeloma diagnosis. Poor guy.
Vaccination
Outbreaks continue apace. In Minneapolis anti-vaccine advocates told the local Somali community that vaccines were linked to autism and that autism was more common in Somalis. Now only 42% are vaccinated and as a result there is a measles outbreak.Now 12 cases.
Not to be outdone, Italy has over 1,600 cases and the CDC has issued travel warnings for Italy. It is a good thing there is no international travel between Italy and the rest of the world. Oh wait.
48.6 million tourists a year (2014), Italy is the fifth most visited country in international tourism arrivals.
“Anti-Vaxxers Are Furious With Sesame Street “Normalizing” Autism.” Julia is a puppet with autism and the anti-vax folks are not happy with ‘normalizing autism.’ As one mother with an autistic child notes:
I can’t express this sentiment deeply enough: Anti-vaxxers are the scum of the earth.
Everything about them is horrible on every level. As the parent of an autistic child, their crusade to make my son a pariah infuriates me. As a parent in general, their efforts to spread preventable diseases is a threat to the lives of my children. As a liberal, their selfishness is rivaled only by the very worst of Republicans. As an educated thinking human, their reliance on verifiably fake science disgusts me.
Works for me.
Acupuncture
Acupuncture for back pain? Not in Daneland. In the Danish National Clinical Guidelines for non-surgical treatment of patients with recent onset low back pain or lumbar radiculopathy they recommend against acupuncture and NSAIDs among other interventions. I only had access to the abstract. I would love to know more about the content, but these national guidelines are behind a paywall and cost $39.95 to access. That is just wrong. National guidelines should be freely available and not used to generate profits for journals.
Naturopathy
Pseudo-medical providers continue using the opiate problem as their Trojan rabbit for legitimization and reimbursement. Over at the HuffPo we have “Naturopathic medicine’s role in fighting the opioid crisis“, where an ND continues with the alternative fact that NDs have legitimate training. They argue that ND care is cost effective for back pain based on a study that has the classic methodology that always leads to a positive result: treatment compared to standard care. Part of that care was acupuncture, so it will be a no-go in Daneland.
But science-based medicine is slowly being eroded by the drip drip drip of pseudo-medical lobbying. Once licensed by the state, pseudo-medical providers want insurance reimbursement. In “Maine Naturopaths Rally Behind Bill to Guarantee Insurance“:
Naturopaths in Maine are rallying behind a bill designed to prevent insurers from discriminating against health care providers who are licensed by the state.
NDs are arguing that:
We need patients to have access to the health care that will best suit them, whether it’s for their annual exam or for alternative options to pain management.
Pain management again. I don’t think it is discrimination to avoid paying for pseudo-medical ND care.
Colorado might be next, despite warnings about their capabilities and training. Legislatures never seem to see or care about the naturopathic quackery that kills.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Chiropractic
Looks like Big Chiropractic is every bit as evil as Big Pharma. In Canada there was a government report reviewing the cost effectiveness of publicly-funded chiropractic services. The report was not favorable and recommended limiting funding to low back pain and suggested, among other things, that DC’s not be allowed to do X-rays in their offices. This was in 2003. The report was suppressed for 14 years because…? No good reason I can find. If only I were of a conspiratorial bent. But chiropractors have continued to bilk the government out of taxpayer dollars:
In 2016, the province paid out $11.9 million for claims from 166,897 patients.
Not to mention the DCs with misleading information on vaccines, autism, and the benefits and training of chiropractors on their websites.
Manitoba is the:
only province in the country that universally covers a portion of chiropractic treatments for all residents, to a limit of 12 visits per year.
Money down the toilet.
Supplements
When do supplements work? When they have real medications as part of their ingredients. Following in the footsteps of Viagra, female libido booster Addyi shows up in supplements.
Adulteration with pharmaceuticals is the secret behind the efficacy of many supplements.
Critical thinking
“Scientists, Stop Thinking Explaining Science Will Fix Things.” A nice review on why the whole skeptical/science-based medicine approach is a waste of time:
The takeaway is clear: Increasing science literacy alone won’t change minds. In fact, well-meaning attempts by scientists to inform the public might even backfire. Presenting facts that conflict with an individual’s worldview, it turns out, can cause people to dig in further. Psychologists, aptly, dubbed this the “backfire effect.”
Our motto? Sisyphus had it easy.
Department of Goofiness
I can’t make this stuff up. The titles speak for themselves.
First: “Chiropractor Discovers The Cause Of Diabetes.”
And:
“Can Tea Bags Help With a Vaginal Tear? Here’s How To Use Them.”
For real. Not The Onion.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 04/30/2017
Stroke from chiropractic. Measles in Minnesota. Fraudulent methodologies? How do your remove homeopathy from a product? Acuwhatever. And more.
Mark Crislip on April 30, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine Points of Interest a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change):
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in medicine: Statin denialists and others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: Whither the antivaccine movement in the age of Trump
    • Steve Novella: Homeopathy regulations, with the FDC and FTC reviews
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine: How are we doing? Q&A
What’s the harm?
Pseudo-medical providers tout their interventions as safe to the point where they never alter care to increase patient safety. Given the lack of efficacy of the interventions covered in this blog, all pseudo-medicine has to offer is harm, either the nocebo effect or physical injury.
“Young mom in critical condition after stroke” after getting neck adjusted by a chiropractor:
doctors at the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics are being very specific as to what caused her to spiral into critical condition, saying it was neck manipulation by chiropractor that triggered her stroke.
With similar forces to being hung by the neck, I would especially avoid chiropractic manipulation of the neck. University of Iowa has no chiropractor on staff, although their Integrative Medicine Clinic will:
refer patients to licensed holistic practitioners, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, or massage therapy providers.
One hopes not those who manipulate the neck.
And then there is acupuncture. Usually it is trauma from the needles, but sometimes they leave the needles behind. It’s the advanced training they receive. My favorite example was the former South Korean President who had an acupuncture needle found in his lung:
“I can’t figure out how the needle got into there,” Dr Sung Myung-whun said at the hospital after the operation. “It is a mystery for me, too.”
Oopsie. Now we have “Acupuncturist told to ‘smarten up’ after leaving 40mm needle in man’s stomach without advice“:
A complaint after a man received treatment for a shoulder injury. The acupuncturist inserted a 40mm long needle in the man’s abdomen, but did not tell the man it would be left there for a few days to extend the effects of the treatment.
The man discovered the needle a day after it was inserted and removed it.
It took the patient a day to notice a needle in his abdomen?
On the day the indecent happened, the acupuncturist said she had experienced an unusually high number of telephone calls – distracting her throughout the man’s treatment.
Gives one confidence in that acupuncturist.
The harm that CAM sometimes causes can be from what doesn’t happen, the dog that doesn’t bark. In “Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) use and delays in presentation and diagnosis of breast cancer patients in public hospitals in Malaysia” they found:
The prevalence of CAM use among the breast cancer patients was high. Women of Malay ethnicity and not interpreting symptom as cancerous were significantly associated with CAM use. The use of CAM is significantly associated with delay in presentation and resolution of diagnosis. This study suggests further evaluation of access to breast cancer care is needed as poor access may cause the use of CAM. However, since public hospitals in Malaysia are heavily subsidized and readily available to the population, CAM use may impact delays in presentation and diagnosis.
Vaccination
There is an outbreak of measles in Minnesota. 32 cases and spreading. Public health wants at-risk children vaccinated. The response? “Minnesota Health Officials Face Opposition From Anti-Vaccine Activists Over Measles Vaccination“:
The activists will hold a meeting on Sunday, April 30, in the Brian Coyle Community Center in Minneapolis to spread the message “epidemic is autism, not measles”.The activists also posit that the state’s health department was withholding information regarding the safety of the vaccines.
No deaths from measles. Yet. I wonder if the ‘activists’ will attend the funeral when a child does die.
Acupuncture
Acuwhatever, perhaps a better term for the pseudo-medicine since no two acuwhatevers are ever the same. But acuwhatever is tried for every process known to man. Labor? You bet: “The effect of acupressure on the initiation of labor: A randomized controlled trial.” In this waste of time and effort they had:
3 groups; acupressure, sham acupressure and control. Acupressure points SP6, BL 60 and BL 32 were pressured bilaterally. The intervention was done by the researcher every other day between 9 am and 11 am
Pushing on the leg, the foot and the back is going to induce labor how? Well, it didn’t. What a surprise.
it seems that acupressure treatment was not effective in initiating labor as compared with the sham acupressure and the routine care groups.
I love the tepid ‘it seems’. No declarative sentences for acuwhatever practitioners. Not that acuwhatever practioners can admit that their pseudo-medicine does nothing, as in “Self-Acupressure for Older Adults with Symptomatic Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Controlled Trial“:
There were no significant differences between verum and sham acupressure groups in any outcomes.
No difference means no efficacy everywhere but pseudo-medicine, as they conclude:
Self-administered acupressure is superior to usual care in pain and physical function improvement for older people with KOA. The reason for the benefits is unclear and placebo effects may have played a role.”
Ya think? I suspect that pseudo-medical researchers never, ever read the relevant literature.
And pseudo-medicine leads to the damnedest things in the medical record as if it is meaningful. In “Acupuncture for Pain and Nausea in the Intensive Care Unit: A Feasibility Study in a Public Safety Net Hospital“:
The most common single TCM diagnosis was Qi and blood stagnation.
I have also seen that diagnosis in the medical record. When I searched “icd 10 qi stagnation”, the third hit was, really “Borderline intellectual functioning.” While practitioners can bill for the procedure, it looks like they have to bill according to the ‘western’ diagnosis. The ‘western’ diagnosis has little to do with the TCPM diagnosis. Would it not be fraud to diagnosis qi deficiency, do the acuwhatever, but then bill for low back pain? Seems sketchy to me.
Department of Guaranteed False Positives
Clinical trials that compare an intervention to standard care are often useless.
As Dr. Ernst points out, it is:
A trial design that generates only ”positive” results.
We conclude that the ‘A B versus B’ design is prone to false positive results
Where A is an intervention (acupuncture, chiropractic, reiki, homeopathy) and B is standard care.
As Dr. Edzard Ernst notes:
We have been over this so many times… that I am almost a little embarrassed to explain it again: it is fairly easy to design an RCT such that it can only produce a positive result. The currently most popular way to achieve this aim in alternative medicine research is to do a ‘A B versus B’ study, where A = the experimental treatment, and B = routine care…
As I stated above, it is fairly easy to design an RCT such that it can only produce a positive result. Yet, it is arguably also unethical, perhaps even fraudulent, to do this. In my view, such RCTs amount to pseudoscience and scientific misconduct.
Here is this week’s likely false positive study, a fraudulent, unethical waste of time and resources:
“The Effect of Reflexology on the Pain-Insomnia-Fatigue Disturbance Cluster of Breast Cancer Patients During Adjuvant Radiation Therapy.” And it wasn’t even a randomized study (emphasis added):
Women were allocated upon their preference either to the group receiving reflexology treatments once a week concurrently with radiotherapy and continued for 10 weeks or to the control group (usual care).
So do you think those with predilection for pseudo-science responded favorably to the pseudo-science?!?
The reflexology treated group demonstrated statistically significant lower levels of fatigue after 5 weeks of radiation therapy (p < 0.001), compared to the control group.
A methodology that really is fraudulent. The only thing that can be concluded from this study is that Israeli Institutional Review Boards are every bit as defective in protecting patients from worthless studies as in the US.
In the literature
A paper of note.
“Is reiki or prayer effective in relieving pain during hospitalization for cesarean? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.” Betteridge’s law of headlines (“Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no”) yet again.
Three trials in this meta, all compared to usual care. And from this they conclude:
Evidence with a high risk of bias suggested that reiki and prayer meditation might be associated with pain reduction.
Such a compelling conclusion. A meta of BS studies results in a BS meta.
Naturopathy
Naturopathy in action:
For years, one of my patients took a daily high-dose vitamin B6 supplement at the recommendation of a naturopath. She trusted the scientific-looking genetic test he based this recommendation on, and never questioned whether she was actually deficient in vitamin B6 before buying and taking the expensive product, which contained a dose 3,800 percent of the daily recommended intake. After a few years, she started experiencing pain and tingling in her arms and legs, and finally sought care from a credentialed medical doctor. The diagnosis? Irreversible nerve damage (neuropathy) caused by toxic levels of vitamin B6. To add insult to injury, she learned there was never a medical reason for her to have been taking vitamin B6 to begin with.
From “What Your Alternative Health Provider Might Not Tell You About Megadosing Supplements.” Probably any worthwhile information.
And the pseudo-medical privileges for NDs are increasing. Oregon is leading the charge, as “Oregon bill shows full impact of allowing naturopaths to practice primary care” demonstrates.
In Maine, NDs want to make sure they get insurance payment for their pseudo-medicine,”Bill to Guarantee Insurance for Naturopaths Held for Review.” And to not pay NDs for their worthless pseudo-medicine is somehow discrimination. By that standard, it would be discrimination not to hire me as starting center for the Portland Trailblazers. Like NDs, I have none of the skills required for the job.
The article describes naturopathy as follows:
Naturopathy’s an alternative medical system that focuses on diet, herbs and vitamins instead of pharmaceuticals.
Naturopathy is so winning the PR battle.
Homeopathy
“Ridgecrest Herbals to Phase out Homeopathics in Their Formulas, Beginning with ClearLungs Extra Strength.” Why the good news? The company:
feels that in the current hostile regulatory atmosphere it is safer as a company to remove homeopathy from their products.
Clear Lungs contains, for the ‘active’ ingredient,
(Homeopathic/HPUS 30C each) Antimonium Tartaricum, Carbo Vegetabilis, Natrum Sulphuricum, Phosphorus.
At 30 C, nothing. 30 C is the:
Dilution advocated by Hahnemann for most purposes: on average, this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient.
It will be easy to remove nothing from the product moving forward, they will just have to change the label. And Clear Lungs also has the following:
Inactive Ingredients: Cellulose capsule, ClearLungs herbal blend, 750 mg/cap (chinese asparagus root, chinese licorice root, chinese skullcap root, dong quai root, gardenia fruit, luo han guo fruit, ophiopogon root, platycodon root, poria fungal body, schisandra fruit, tangerine mature peel, white mulberry root bark, zhejiang fritillary bulb), microcrystalline cellulose.
The active ingredients are nothing and the inactive ingredients are something. So pseudo-medicine. So in the future will the product contain only inactive ingredients?
Legal, legislative, and regulatory
“FDA Takes Action Against Fraudulent Cancer Products“, having sent letters of warning to companies that are:
illegally selling more than 65 products that claim to prevent, diagnose, treat, mitigate or cure cancer. The products are marketed and sold without FDA approval, most commonly on websites or social media platforms. They have not been reviewed by FDA for safety and efficacy, and can be dangerous to both people and pets.
On the list are a variety of intravenous liposomal products, including curcumin aka turmeric, the herb that killed a young lady this month.
Probably a drop in the anti-cancer pseudo-scientific bucket.
24 states allow chiropractors to do school exams despite a complete lack of education and training in medicine and a mythical understanding of the musculoskeletal system. Now Wisconsin wants to join the crowd. “Bill would let chiropractors do physical exams for student athletes.” The bill is opposed by the Medical Association of Wisconsin and for Wisconsin readers it is ASSEMBLY BILL 260. Follow up the March for Science with Letter to Representative?
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Department of Goofiness
Acuwhatever. “Development of an Economical DNA Delivery System by “Acufection” and its Application to Skin Research“:
To perform acufection, mouse skin was first infused with DNA in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and then pricked lightly with a bundle of acupuncture needles to facilitate the absorption of DNA and transfection into cells.
Why acupuncture needles? No reason.

In the video it is just a cluster of needles on a plastic grip. Nothing acupuncture about it. But they get to call it acufection. I assume they were trying to be cute. Fail.
Acustupidity. It never ends.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/14/2017.
The week in review. Measles cases climb in Minnesota; Texas is jealous. Koala and rabbit abuse. FDA suggesting pseudo-medicine? And more.
Mark Crislip on May 14, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicines Points of Interest a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change).
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in medicine: Statin denialists and others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: Whither the antivaccine movement in the age of Trump
    • Steve Novella: Homeopathy regulations, with the FDC and FTC reviews
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine: How are we doing? Q&A
What’s the harm?
“Dutch boy can refuse chemotherapy, says Court.” Another sad case. The child had a brain tumor removed and treated with radiation. Chemotherapy was recommended. The father wanted the son to receive chemo, the mother and son wanted to go the alternative route and avoid the toxicities of chemotherapy. Oddly, the court evidently thinks a 12 year old is capable of making such a decision. Hopefully the surgery and radiation will be enough to cure the child although if he has a cure, I bet the alternative therapies will get the credit.
Vaccination
They are now up to 54 cases of measles in Minnesota as the outbreak stutters along since beginning April 11th. No deaths, 14 hospitalizations, and an eventual total cost to the state of millions. Each case of measles costs the state at least $11,000. So at $594,000 so far. Too bad they cannot make the anti-vaxers pay.
Minnesota is setting the example and others want to join in.
“Stockholm clinic probed for discouraging vaccination, says measles is good for child’s development” where they:
advised parents to wait before vaccinating their child against measles, mumps and rubella, claiming that having the diseases can help along their child’s development.
And Texas, already primed for a measles outbreak, is putting more kindling on the pyre. “Texas House Passes Bill Banning Mandatory Vaccination Of Children In Foster Care.” This thanks to the Freedom Caucus who considers vaccines as invasive and unnecessary:
‘Immunizations do not qualify as emergency care,’ conservative lawmaker tacking on bill amendment asserted. ‘No vaccine cures a disease.’
Freedom to get measles. Just what every Texan wants. I don’t suppose the Freedom Caucus would be willing to personally pay for each case when the outbreak hits.
Acupuncture
“Can a science-based definition of acupuncture improve clinical outcomes?” No. But acupuncturists and their ilk cannot come to terms with the realization that their intervention and life’s work is nothing more than a placebo and they desperately want to tie acupuncture to science-based medicine:
However, the widespread use of traditional terms confounds the ability of acupuncture, or needling therapy, to find a useful place in US medicine. Description and explanation of acupuncture’s therapeutic effects as a neurochemical phenomenon along with otherwise medico-scientific conventions is hardly novel. Despite decades of scientific arguments that support a biomedical model, steadfast insistence on the use of traditional terms remains a standard in the conduct of acupuncture research. The use of prescientific language in place of medical language commonly used in mainstream healthcare is harmful to the profession, practitioners and the public.
And the article suggests comparative outcomes are better measures of acupuncture than effectiveness outcomes. In other words, despite being a placebo, the ends justify the means. Color me skeptical.
Sorry. There is no compelling biomedical model. The problem is there is no science-based framework within which acupuncture can be considered if for no other reason that there is no single entity that can be called acupuncture. I suspect, like most pseudo-medicine, they are doomed to failure on that score. But acupuncture will likely thrive.
And they continue to inflict worthless placebo on helpless animals. In this case, a koala who had some sort of paralysis treated with steroids and acupuncture. Guess which intervention got the nod for success in the headline? That’s right: “Old Koala Tries to Climb Tree After 9 Weeks of Recovery and Acupuncture.” I suspect the poor beast was trying to escape the acupuncture.
Homeopathy
In Canada:
Health Canada is no longer allowing companies (that make homeopathic products) to make specific health claims … for cough, cold, and flu for children 12 and under, unless those claims are supported by scientific evidence.
Is the rule working? Are parents being protected from fraud? Of course not: “Unproven homeopathic remedies for kids still promising relief despite new label rules.” If they are not going to pay attention to the laws of science, why bother with the laws of man?
And another IRB fails to protect animals from unneeded abuse. This time Islamia University allowed “Effects of homoeopathic ultrahigh dilutions of Aconitum napellus on Baker’s yeast-induced fever in rabbits,” where part of the study included:
Rectal temperature was measured with digital thermometer hourly.
Poor bunnies.
Legal and legislative
In the UK they are wondering “Should complementary and alternative medicine charities lose their charitable status?” Part of the requirements for a charitable status includes:
the advancement of health or the saving of lives
Some of these organizations promote interventions like homeopathy or are anti-vaccine. These ideas are not supported by science and therefore, it is argued, do not meet the basic requirements to be a charitable organization. Seems reasonable to me. As is so often the case in the UK, the Good Thinking Society is leading the charge.
In the US, the ongoing problems with chronic pain and opioid abuse are pushing the FDA to opt for flying carpets as the “FDA proposes that doctors learn about acupuncture for pain management” and chiropractic. Carl Sagan noted:
I worry that, especially as the millennium edges nearer, pseudoscience and superstition will seem year by year more tempting, the siren song of unreason more sonorous and attractive. The candle flame gutters. Its little pool of light trembles. Darkness gathers. The demons begin to stir.
The pseudo-medical demons are not stirring. They are partying like it’s 1499.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/21/2017
Choosing CAM leads to bad outcomes the world over. How deep can an acupuncture needle go? Measles continues and Minnesotans and will be welcomed in Texas. Rat rectal stimulation for Science. And more.
Mark Crislip on May 22, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change).
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in medicine: Statin denialists and others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: Whither the antivaccine movement in the age of Trump
    • Steve Novella: Homeopathy regulations, with the FDC and FTC reviews
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine: How are we doing? Q&A
Be there or be square.
What’s the harm?
Two weeks ago I noted an Australian who opted for alternative medicine instead of science-based medicine for her rheumatoid arthritis. Her disease progressed and she did not improve until she tried reality-based therapies. One of harms of pseudo-medicine: People delaying or avoiding effective therapy in favor of SCAM. I suspect it is an under-reported harm.
SCAM instead of SBM occurs the world over. For example, in Africa we have Ikenna Udeh, an artist, with pain from an incapacitating ‘cracked spine” and for him Not being able to paint is like dying – Buffalo. With regret in his voice he said.
I am not too keen on alternative medicine but they said let’s try and we did. Perhaps things would have been different if we had persisted with medical treatment,” the artist said. The talented artist has been incapacitated and has since been unable to express himself creatively.
And in China? “Use of complementary and alternative medicines is associated with delay to initiation of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drug therapy in early inflammatory arthritis.” Not only was use of CAM associated with delay in effective treatment, but curiously it was in patients with more severe disease. The more symptomatic the arthritis, the more likely they were to rely on CAM.
At least the use of CAM for arthritis did not result in death. Not always the case, as “An autopsy case of fatal acute peritonitis complicated by illegal acupuncture therapy” demonstrates (errors in original):
The victim was a 55-year-old woman who had a recent history of chemo-radiotherapy due to breast cancer. She was collapsed three days after receiving acupuncture. She had symptoms of fever and chilling sensation, general myalgia, and vomiting during three days. The autopsy revealed several needle marks in the lower abdomen and 180ml of bloody exudate in the abdominal cavity. There was no visible intestinal perforation, but hemorrhagic foci in the mesentery and paracolic area of sigmoid colon were noted. The deepest portion was 13.5cm from the needle marks on the abdominal skin.
The acupuncturist had no license, as if being trained and licensed in fantasy makes it safer. And there is, among the innumerable forms of acupuncture, a form called long-needle acupuncture where the needles are pushed in 75–90 mm. Good god, look at this video from Perforations R Us. At least they are wearing gloves and a mask as they skewer the patient. I am not this aggressive with my kabobs for the grill.
Vaccination
The measles outbreak in Minnesota is now at 66. Still no deaths and, one hopes, no subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) in the future.
In Italy they have had over 1,600 cases of measles, about 90% in the unvaccinated children, and to control the outbreak? The one intervention that is effective: “Italy makes 12 vaccines mandatory for school children in an attempt to combat ‘anti-scientific theories’“:
children will not be accepted into nursery or pre-schools without proof of vaccinations, while parents of children legally obliged to attend school will face hefty fines for noncompliance.
Texas, in an attempt to make sure every physician has an opportunity to see a case of measles in the most vulnerable population in the state, is working to prohibit vaccinations for foster children. The misnamed Child-Welfare bill will help ensure that children who have been physically and/or mentally abused now have an opportunity to get measles, mumps and more. Go Texas.
Acupuncture
Minnesota is on a roll. First measles, now “Shakopee Hospital Among First to Offer Acupuncture in ER“:
Doctors at St. Francis Regional Medical Center hope it will replace traditional opioid treatment in many cases.
Theatrical placebo in the ER for acute medical problems. I just broke my arm and I get acupuncture? Sign me up. The logical end result of the response to the opioid abuse problem. There are issues with airplanes, so we are going to rely on magic carpets.
Faith-based medicine
Maybe Shakopee will add prayer to their response to pain in the ER since “Health Secretary Tom Price Favors ‘Faith Based’ Approach To Opioid Crisis“:
Price, a medical doctor, claims faith-based treatment is better than medication-assisted treatment when treating opioid addiction, despite a great deal of scientific evidence to the contrary.
Since when does a great deal of scientific evidence make a difference for CAM?
In the literature
Some papers of note.
“An overview of systematic reviews of complementary and alternative therapies for fibromyalgia using both AMSTAR and ROBIS as quality assessment tools“:
There was low-quality evidence that acupuncture improves pain compared to no treatment or standard treatment, but good evidence that it is no better than sham acupuncture.
Which means the good evidence shows NO EFFICACY. Sorry I shouted.
The evidence for homoeopathy (sic?!), spinal manipulation and herbal medicine was limited…No firm conclusions were drawn for efficacy of either spinal manipulation or homoeopathy (sic?!) for FM.
When it comes to spinal manipulation or homeopathy, knowledge of the basic sciences is perhaps enough to know that neither should have efficacy beyond the placebo effect.
While I am only peripherally involved with treating patients with chronic back and neck pain, I do have a dog in the fight. I had a herniated cervical disc a few years back that caused nine months of misery before surgical resolution and I continue to have mild to moderate back and neck pain issues. My take home from both personal experience (yeah, I know) and reading the literature is nothing really helps the pain except time. For example there is the recent Cochrane review, “Exercises for mechanical neck disorders“:
No high quality evidence was found, indicating that there is still uncertainty about the effectiveness of exercise for neck pain. Using specific strengthening exercises as a part of routine practice for chronic neck pain, cervicogenic headache and radiculopathy may be beneficial. Research showed the use of strengthening and endurance exercises for the cervico-scapulothoracic and shoulder may be beneficial in reducing pain and improving function. However, when only stretching exercises were used no beneficial effects may be expected
Looks like exercises doesn’t do much. Science-based or pseudo-science based, I think the only real option for most non acute pain is to keep calm and carry on. Nothing really relieves back and neck back.
Mindset for disease probably doesn’t alter the clinical trajectory of diseases, but it makes the disease tolerable, especially for processes, like back pain, that have to run their course. I wonder if much of the interaction with pseudo-medical providers can be characterized as a form cognitive restructuring based on fraud and fantasy. For example, in ‘“Placebo effect is probably what we refer to as patient healing power”: A qualitative pilot study examining how Norwegian complementary therapists reflect on their practice‘ they note:
A successful consultation was characterized by a fruitful relationship between the therapist and the patient. Moreover, the therapist needs to be humble and show the patient respect. Patients’ positive beliefs and expectations about the treatment play a significant role in the healing process. The more hope the therapist can bring about, the more easily the patient can start believing that it is possible to get well.
Changing patient perception without altering the underlying disease. Alt Med in action and Alt Med inaction.
Homeopathy
In India the money wasted on homeopathy is staggering, as is the belief in the ultimate nothing pseudo-medicine. Now “Government fund to find a homeopathic cure for cancer“:
The institute has assigned a project to a Cell Biology professor to screen out different homeopathic treatments for the cancer cure.
I’ll bet good money this goes nowhere.
Weirdness
Pseudo-medicine generates some of the weirdest forms of rat torture. This week we have “Comparison of the analgesic effects between electro-acupuncture and moxibustion with visceral hypersensitivity rats in irritable bowel syndrome.” Are you ready for this?
Rats in the normal group were stimulated through manual manipulation around the anus, while rats in the other groups were stimulated by distending the colorectum (CRD). Daily CRD using an inflatable balloon (constructed from a latex glove finger, length 4 cm, inflated with air) attached to an intravenous line connected via a Y connector to a manual pump and a sphygmomanometer. The balloon was inserted into the colon while the animal was sedated, and CRD was induced while animals were fully awake. The distention was repeated twice daily at a 30-min interval.
Somehow I suspect that:
All efforts were made to minimize the number of animals utilized and their suffering. All animal experiments in this study were performed under the guidelines approved by the Animal Ethics Committee of the China Academy of Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Is a wee bit of a farce. The only way animal suffering can be minimized is to stop doing dumbass pseudo-science on rats.
Legal and legislative
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
And that’s it. See you next week.

Corrigendum. The Week in Review for 05/28/2017.
More measles in Minnesota. Yet another form of acupuncture: Snafu. CAM cancer studies are of poor quality. The future of CAM is LSD.
Mark Crislip on May 28, 2017
Link


Selections from Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Points of Interest, a daily compendium of links of interest with comments.
There is not enough time to write a complete blog post on the thousand points of pseudo-medicine that show up in my feeds. But some stars need to be noticed and commented upon. Duty Calls.
A short one this week. It is both a call weekend and a holiday weekend (ie BBQ) so not a lot of time.
NECSS will be June 29-July 2, 2017 in New York City with an entire day, June 30, devoted to science-based medicine. Preliminary schedule (subject to change).
    • Britt Hermes: The naturopaths are coming! The naturopaths are coming!
    • Harriet Hall: Denialism in medicine: Statin denialists and others
    • Clay Jones: Cultural inertia and various commonly promoted medical beliefs that are wrong
    • David Gorski: Whither the antivaccine movement in the age of Trump
    • Steve Novella: Homeopathy regulations, with the FDC and FTC reviews
    • Two Panels: Science-Based Medicine: How are we doing? Q&A
What’s the harm?
Kidney failure is one of the unexpected complications traditional medicines, the most notorious example may be “Chinese herbs containing aristolochic acid associated with renal failure and urothelial carcinoma” (the Aristolochia incident was discussed here by Steve Novella). A nice review of the topic can be found in Traditional Medicines and Kidney Disease in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: Opportunities and Challenges. The issue is made more complex given the complete lack of standards for what may be in these concoctions and they are often adulterated with real medications, ratcheting up the risk for harm.
Plus as Dr. Ernst notes in “The harms of alternative medicine: what we see is just the tip of the iceberg“, medicine is a balance of risk and benefit. We often do not know if there is benefit and:
On the safety side of the equation, things are even worse. There is no post-marketing surveillance of alternative therapies, and all we know about their risks comes from the occasional case report published in the medical literature. This means that under-reporting of harms is huge, and our data are just the tip of the iceberg.
We simply do not have any understanding of the risks associated with pseudo-medicine.
Vaccination
We are now up to 68 cases of measles as Minnesota’s measles outbreak about to exceed total 2016 U.S. cases. Go Minnesota.
The Germans are not messing around with vaccines, “New German Law To Impose Hefty Fines On Anti-Vaxxer Parents Who Refuse To Get Their Kids Vaccinated.” As of June 1:
Parents found in violation of this upcoming law may be fined up to 2,500 euros, or about $2,800 in U.S. currency.
Not a bad idea.
Acupuncture
A trifecta of pseudo-science can be found in “Effect of Lotus Posture on Acupuncture Meridian Energies: A Controlled Trial.” They used the Acugraph, a device that measures skin conductance and is touted as able to measure merde-idians. And they found:
those sitting in Lotus Posture for 30 min showed increases in subtle energy levels (E_Ls) in all acupuncture meridians; those sitting in chair produced universal decreases.
Research is getting closer and closer to The Onion.
Yet another in the endless variations of acupuncture: “Sanfu acupoint herbal patching for stable asthma: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.” The usual conclusion: maybe some benefit but poor quality studies so better research needs to be done.
But what is Snafu, er, I mean Sanfu?
Sanfu refers to the hottest period of the year, from July to August, and is considered to be the richest time for Yang Qi [16]. Therefore, the Sanfu period is of special significance for TCM in treating AR to gain more Yang Qi from the environment.The Sanfu herbal patch (SHP) is a treatment method in which processed Chinese herbal preparations are applied directly to specific acupoints during the Sanfu period. This is done in order to produce therapeutic effects through the combination of herbal infiltration absorption, acupoint stimulation, and time effect [16]. The herbs with a nature of warm or hot are used to cause irritation on the skin such as local redness, hotness, and/or even blisters [17]. Therefore, skin absorption and stimulation of the meridians and/or acupoints are enhanced to generate a greater effect on patients.
Sure sounds to me like a reasonable basis for a therapeutic intervention for bronchospasm.
And acupuncturists are working hard to prevent physical therapists from getting a piece of their pseudo-medical pie: “Is dry needling a safe acupuncture replacement, or a shortcut around years of essential training?”
Trick question or false equivalents? I would take my theatrical placebo from a physical therapist since PTs, at least, have a reality-based background. And years of training in magic makes the magic neither safer nor more efficacious.
Naturopathy
You might remember the young man in Florida who set himself up as a natural doctor? He is going to jail for fraud, but not medical fraud. He tried to buy a car with one of his patient’s checking accounts. He has yet to be tried for medical fraud, which will be hard to prove given the nature of ND practice. Perhaps practicing medicine without a license, although Florida doesn’t license NDs.
Chiropractic
Department of Enthusiastic Conclusions.
This time it’s “The Effectiveness of Manual Therapy for Relieving Pain, Stiffness, and Dysfunction in Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis“:
The preliminary evidence from our study suggests that manual therapy might be effective and safe for improving pain, stiffness, and physical function in KOA patients and could be treated as complementary and alternative options. However, the evidence may be limited by potential bias and poor methodological quality of included studies. High-quality RCTs with long-term follow-up are warranted to confirm our findings.
Same as it ever was.
In the literature
Some papers of note.
“Evaluation of complementary and alternative medicine trials registered in clinicaltrials.gov database“:
CAM research in patients with cancer is currently limited, both in terms of quantity and quality.
I guess it is the CAM cancer providers who have information THEY don’t want you to know.
Best way to keep in business is not to do disconfirming research or have lousy studies that prove nothing.
Herbs and Supplements
“Usefulness of nutraceuticals in migraine prophylaxis“:
There is a growing body of research on nutraceutical use for migraine prophylaxis.
The research is always growing, just not a quality research that demonstrates efficacy and safety.
Legal and legislative
Pseudo-medical providers continue to worm their way into the medical system. They want to be licensed and be paid. “Reimbursement for integrative health care suggests violation of non-discrimination law.”
Pseudo-medicine is more likely to be paid for if it done by an MD instead of a pseudo-medical provider. The problem is not that pseudo-medical providers are denied payment but that real doctors are being paid to do magic.
“Vitamin Shoppe class action says ‘weight loss’ pills don’t work.” What? Taking a pill doesn’t lead to weight loss?
Vitamin Shoppe falsely states that its Garcinia Cambogia is “an effective aid in ‘weight management’ and ‘appetite control’ despite that the Product’s only purportedly active ingredients, Hydroxycitric Acid (‘HCA’) and chromium are scientifically proven to be incapable of providing such weight-loss benefits,” the class action asserts.
Didn’t he read the disclaimer before purchasing the product?
These products are dietary supplements and are not intended to diagnose, treat cure or prevent any disease. Reviews are not intended as a substitute for appropriate medical care or the advice of a physician or another medical professional. Actual results may vary among users. Vitaminshoppe.com makes no warranty or representation, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy or validity of the information contributed by outside product review submissions, and assumes no responsibility or liability regarding the use of such information. The information and statements regarding the dietary supplements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. If you have a medical condition or disease, please talk to your health care provider. If you are currently taking a prescription medication, you should work with your health care provider before discontinuing any drug or altering any drug regimen, including augmenting your regimen with dietary supplements. Do not attempt to self-diagnose any disease or ailment based on the reviews and do not use the information contained herein for diagnosing or treating a health problem or disease. Proper medical care is critical to good health. If you have a health concern or suspect you have an undiagnosed sign or symptom, please consult a physician or health care practitioner.
Remember to go to Summary Pending Legislation 2017 to keep abreast of the pseudo-scientific legislative shenanigans in your state.
Weirdness
“Future of Alternative Medicine May Lie in Microdosing of Hallucinogens, Advocates Say.”
I suppose a little LSD would make alternative medicine appear more reasonable.
And that’s it. See you next week.

I Got Nothing
Really nothing here from me this week. Go have a beer. Time better spent.
Mark Crislip on May 26, 2017
Link

It has been a distracting week. Good weather (finally), my boys home for the start of summer break, NBA playoffs, and nothing of real interest to write about in the world of pseudo-medicine has popped up in my feed. I got nothing substantive to write about that really interests me. Really. Which is odd given the volumes of pseudo-medical material that comes through my feeds. Readers can stop here. I have spent hours on the web looking at BBQ and bread and butter pickle recipes and the best burgers in the US (Portland. Of course. And a place in my old neighborhood). I keep coming back to iA Writer and think, screw it.
But just because I have nothing of substance to bloviate about doesn’t mean I can skip my every other week commitment. Nope. But I have plenty of fluff I can write about. I am certainly not the deep thinker of the blog, but let’s see what I can collect from the shallow end of pool to this week. Prepare for a Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Men Tell No Tales entry.
You still reading? Please. Do something else. Trust me. There are better ways to spend your time than to read what follows. I know. I am struggling, and losing the battle, to write it.
There was a Harvard Harris poll that suggested:
65 percent of voters believe there is a lot of fake news in the mainstream media.
That number includes 80 percent of Republicans, 60 percent of independents and 53 percent of Democrats. Eighty-four percent of voters said it is hard to know what news to believe online.
What can you believe online? Besides SBM? Fake news. Alternative facts. They have been the grist for this blog’s mill from the beginning. I have two areas of expertise: infectious diseases and pseudo-medicine. And the articles on medicine and infomercials for the pseudo-medicine du jour that show up in my feeds or in my local paper are, more often than not, wrong.
I have long wondered about my local newspaper: if I see errors and mistakes on topics I really know something about, how much is inaccurate in articles on topics about which I don’t have any knowledge i.e. everything else on the planet? That some of the articles are in the Living section, and therefore considered more entertainment than news, is not an excuse. I judge a person by the company he keeps.
But what happens if there is widespread acceptance of false news and alternative facts? After all, there is stuff circulating on the internet, so there must be something to it.
Perhaps we can guess from the world of pseudo-medicine what the world based on fake news and alternative facts will be, and it isn’t pretty.
The consequences of using fake news and alternative facts as your standards are grim. Time, money, hope and life lost. Because of anti-vaccination fake news we have seen outbreaks this year of measles in Minnesota, Italy, and Romania (all foreign countries to me, oh yeah sure doncha know). So far. We haven’t even reached the half way point of the year. And anti-vaccinationists are making headway in Texas, denying vaccines to children who have had physical and mental abuse.
I remain amazed at how little medical societies are involved in pushing back against pseudo-medicine. They seem not to care about fake news and alternative facts. My professional society, the IDSA, has been mostly silent for the last decade as the anti-vaccination industry has expanded and vaccine-preventable illnesses have boomed. They IDSA is probably are gun shy after their Lyme debacle, another area of pseudo-medical inaction. The IDSA guidelines have been in ‘review’ seemingly forever and as a result the only Lyme guidelines in the National Guidelines Clearinghouse are the alternative ILIADS guidelines. Perhaps why in Pennsylvania the ILIADS guidelines were the only input for the law mandating insurance payments for alternative Lyme treatments. The only thing necessary for the triumph of fake news for good men to do nothing.
At least those in the news media are speaking up against the charges of providing fake news. Not so in medicine, where fake news and alternative facts are embraced.
With the shruggie approach to pseudo-medicine we have seen the increase in Integrative Medicine departments in almost all the major medical institutions in the US. Fake news and alternative facts has given the opportunity for patients to receive fake and alternative medicine from Harvard to Stanford and beyond. At the top medical centers in the US you can find acupuncture, reiki, therapeutic touch, homeopathy, reflexology, and chiropractic a.k.a. fraud.
And it is only getting worse. The opiate crisis has been a boon and a boom for pseudo-medical providers, where they are offering their magic as the treatment of chronic pain. Even the FDA may be buying into the nonsense of chiropractic and acupuncture for chronic pain.
truth (small ’t’ despite starting a sentence) or an approximation of truth, is important in medicine. While I do not expect the bulk of medicine to abandon its science/evidence base, a double standard is becoming standard and growing.
And what is the average person, with no expertise in medicine or pseudo-medicine, to do? Believe it all, ignore it all or pick and choose? What to do about all this? Got me. I got nothing.
Not that it will matter in another 25 years or so. We are all doomed, or so the fake news would have us believe.
You read this far? I warned you. That was time you will never get back. But at least the pain is almost over.
Hopefully in 2 weeks I will have something to write about.
In the meantime, if you feel the urge to comment, try and limit it to bread and butter pickles, BBQ, and best burgers.

Science-Based Medicine’s Not-So-Psychic Predictions for 2016
Clay Jones on January 1, 2016
Link


The new year is upon us, and with it comes a unique opportunity for the Science-Based Medicine team to look deep into our crystal balls, to channel our Atlantean spirit guides, and to ride the waves of cosmic consciousness in order to bring to you our predictions for 2016. But before you scoff at our collective powers of prognostication, know that we have never made a prediction that has not come to pass. We’ve also never made any official predictions before, but that’s neither here nor there.
In the process of discussing what will become of this new alternative medicine fad (have you heard of it?) in the coming year, I have discovered that the contributors to SBM are all extremely pessimistic. Sadly, the vast majority of the responses to my request for predictions were focused on the future advances of pseudoscience in medicine and the steady decline of our ability to tell the difference between reality and medical fiction. But I agree with each and every one.
It is hard to imagine a rational future full of Bayesian analysis and the marginalization of quackery when even the hallowed halls of academic medicine are increasingly overrun with nonsense. Just this week I learned about Seattle Children’s inpatient acupuncture program and the sobering concept of “paging acupuncture” for the stat treatment of a child in severe pain. Quackery has become fully entrenched at this point and the outlook is bleak for those of us who strive to do something about it.
Dr. Crislip, whose unblocked third eye sees far and wide, is almost certainly correct when he predicted that our few victories will be overshadowed by the “tsunami of BS” that is pseudo-medicine. Shruggies will continue to shrug. Those that profit will continue to do so at the expense of the desperate and/or gullible. Proponents of SBM will whack each mole as it emerges from cover and eventually the Sun will engulf the Earth.
So what is in store for us in 2016? Will the FDA crack down on homeopathic remedies? Will Dr. Oz regain his former glory or be reduced to selling miracle weight loss cures for spare change on the street outside his former production studio? Our vision, though clear for the most part was cloudy at times, thus not all of our predictions are as certain as others. Some are sure bets while others are perhaps more of a long shot. Sometimes the spirits mumble.
Vaccines in 2016 (sure bet)
According to Dr. Harriet Hall, there will be outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases in areas where vaccines are widely available. That means the United States. Pertussis and mumps are a near certainty but even measles is poised to spread like wildfire among vulnerable populations with low rates of vaccine adherence despite their proven track record of safety and efficacy.
Dr. Hall further predicts that once again nobody will suffer serious harm or die as a result of receiving the HPV vaccine in 2016. I’ll add that regardless of its exemplary safety record, credulous journalists and fearmongering profiteers like Joseph Mercola will continue to publish anecdotes and misinformation about supposed reactions to this life-saving immunization. Rates of HPV vaccine utilization will inch upwards a bit in both male and female pediatric patients, but they will remain shockingly low considering what is at stake, in part because of the ridiculous claim that the vaccine will lead to promiscuous behavior in teens.
The year of the subluxation (long shot)
Australian chiropractic surgeons will perform the world’s first open fetal spinal adjustment on a baby still inside the mother’s womb. Chiropractors will begin using subluxation-sniffing dogs to help diagnose subtle abnormalities in the spine years before they cause symptoms. The International Chiropractic Veterinary Association will even begin to offer a Diplomate course in Canine Subluxation Detection that will consist of 3 weekend sessions held out back of the airport Howard Johnson in Portland. Chiropractic scientists will also isolate the first adjustment resistant subluxation.
Won’t somebody please think of the children? (sure bet)
Another high profile case of a child suffering from a treatable medical condition because of the fear of conventional medicine, the false promises of a charlatan, or faith in a miracle cure will make the news. This child, like so many before, will be allowed to suffer by those with the authority and moral obligation to intervene. An institute with a misleading name, like 2015’s infamous Hippocrates Health Institute, will be involved in providing court sanctioned but worthless “alternative” treatments.
Alternative janitorial services (long shot)
Academic hospitals will begin offering energy-based alternative janitorial services. Fast and lacking the typical pungent odors of more mainstream cleaning supplies, Quantum Cleaning will take advantage of the electron transitions associated with visible and ultraviolet interactions with trash, body fluids, and dirty linens where the quantum energy of photons precisely match the energy gap between the soiled and clean states. In the interaction of energy with matter, a Quantum Cleaning practitioner can elevate the quantum state from the lower to the upper state, rendering the matter void of any and all unclean quantum entanglements, thus balancing the energy field believed to envelop the room, leaving a fresh lemony scent.
Oh, how the mighty haven’t fallen (sure bet)
One of the most frustrating issues we deal with at Science-Based Medicine is the seemingly preternatural ability to avoid regulation and incarceration displayed by certain long time proponents of cancer quackery. Dr. Gorski predicts that both Stanislaw Burzynski and Robert O. Young will be allowed to return to their old tricks of placing profit above patient safety. Yet again the inability of those tasked with protecting the public’s health and resources to effectively do so will be revealed.
Antibiotic stewardship (Long Shot)
Pfizer will begin selling Zithromax Flavor Blast™ liquid water enhancer. It will be a first-of-its-kind method of administering an antibiotic and a revolutionary means of enhancing water as a healthy beverage. Pfizer will claim that the product will improve medication compliance, help consumers to maintain hydration, and support a healthy and active lifestyle. It will come in Grape, Tropical Punch, and Human Tear flavors.
More research is needed (sure bet + long shot)
In 2016, much like the end of last year, there will be no shortage of questionable research into implausible, if not already disproved, alternative therapies like reiki and homeopathy. These studies will be increasingly poorly designed, with weak to nonexistent blinding and no placebo control group. So-called pragmatic trials, seemingly designed to yield positive results, will continue to impress and to be wielded by proponents while skeptics scratch their heads in disbelief and scientists are thoroughly baffled. Many will be funded with taxpayer money through government institutes that provide more propaganda than insight.
Despite currently being on the defensive in the United States, homeopaths will continue to produce research that relies on the ability of water to remember where it’s been. Chiropractors will publish enough case reports to fill in the research sections of thousands of practice-building websites. And acupuncture enthusiasts will discover an entirely new set of acupuncture/acupressure points located on specific organs. The specialty of surgical acupuncture will be developed and quickly included on the lists of integrative medical services offered at academic medical centers across the country.
Positive studies will be discussed without a hint of skepticism by major news outlets while negative studies will be largely ignored by everyone except the people who already know the remedy is baloney. Patients will become even more confused by the avalanche of “evidence” produced by believers. “More Research is Needed!” will become the official motto of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH).
The Quackery Awakens (long shot)
Grant Ritchey DDS has seen a vision of a future where <href=”https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/oil-pulling-your-leg/”>oil pulling evolves into a new form of alternative medicine that will be championed by high profile personalities like Dr. Oz and Gwenyth Paltrow: Oil pushing. Like oil pulling, where an oil (usually sesame or coconut) is swished in the mouth for 20 minutes ostensibly to “draw out the toxins,” oil pushing addresses the situation from the opposite end of the alimentary canal. Since one can’t swish one’s colon, the experts recommend doing the Time Warp dance for twenty minutes for an equivalent effect. While oil pushing may not reduce cavities, it also “draws out the toxins” and has the added benefit in helping to rapidly eliminate food from the digestive system, often before the meal is even over.
More legislative alchemy (sure bet)
Jann Bellamy, our resident expert in courtroom clairvoyance, has predicted that state legislatures across the land will continue to enact legislative alchemy by considering the expansion of the scope of practice of chiropractors (DC as PCP!), naturopaths, and acupuncturists/TCM practitioners. CAM believers will push for more of a presence in the VA healthcare system and Medicare programs. Sadly, she also predicts that some of these attempts will be successful.
DSHEA will continue to limit the FDAs ability to regulate over-the-counter supplements, which means that consumers will go through 2016 misled by vague “structure and function” claims and have absolutely no idea what they are actually ingesting. A few companies will be slapped with fines or even shut down, but it will remain the Wild West in stores and medicine cabinets across the country.
Robots (long shot)
The da Vinci Surgical System involves state of the art robotic technology and features a 3D high-definition magnification system and instruments able to maneuver with greater precision than the human wrist and fingers. Its use will allow acupuncturists to both locate and successfully target hard-to-reach acupoints. This will expand the number of conditions amenable to acupuncture significantly.
Dr. Oz has learned nothing (sure bet)
Dr. Oz will continue to demonstrate that he has learned nothing from his trouncing in 2014.
Welcome to 2016!
Prepare to be amazed! Behold the future!! Meh.
(I look forward to seeing some SBM predictions for 2016 from our brilliant readers in the comment section.)

Yet Another Miscellany of Medical Malarkey
Acupuncture for menstrual cramps, chiropractic for the prevention of domestic terrorism, and more in this miscellany of medical malarkey. Or would you prefer hodgepodge of healthcare hokum?
Clay Jones on October 6, 2017
Link

Prepare yourselves for yet another collection of the various odds and ends from the world of irregular medicine that I’ve collected over the past few days.
“I am an educated, vaccine-choice mother.”
The ongoing saga of a 9-year-old Michigan child caught between the push and pull of divorced parents was covered in typical extensive detail by a friend of the blog yesterday, but I will provide a quick synopsis. The boy’s father had successfully petitioned the courts nearly a year ago to ensure that his child received the full protection of the recommended vaccine schedule. Despite this, the child’s mother refused even after being given an ultimatum by a judge last week.
Yesterday it was reported that she will be jailed for 7 days and that the child’s father will be granted temporary custody. This will allow the child to receive any vaccinations necessary to be caught up. As is often the case, the media has not done the best job covering this issue. In the Respectful Insolence post linked to above, Orac describes the false balance that has been employed by the press and also the disgusting response from the anti-vaccine community. Essentially, they are going after the boy’s father and even implying that he hopes that his child will die from a vaccine injury so that he won’t have to pay child support.
Meanwhile, the mother has admitted to lying about her impetus for refusing vaccinations, after initially going the route of claiming religious reasons. It appears, however, that she evolved from a position of vaccine hesitancy, with acceptance of a delayed/spaced out schedule, to 100% anti-vaccine based on her own personal research. She also is attempting to wield the banner of vaccine choice, implying that in part she is also refusing because she objects on principle to being forced to vaccinate her child.
Regardless of the outcome, this child is likely going through a very tough time. I’m happy that at least he will be protected from vaccine-preventable diseases. I do worry, however, that the this high profile parental battle might distract from a possible need for counseling to help him have as successful a transition as possible through this difficult period in his life.
Un duo d’absurdité d’acupuncture!
Acupuncture has been covered many times on the pages of Science-Based Medicine, and I don’t see any signs of it going away any time soon. Cases in point, two examples of acupuncture related nonsense came to my attention this week. The first involved a study on acupuncture for menstrual pain that was first reported on back in July, when it was published in PLOS One, and again this week for some reason.
In the study, 74 women were randomized to one of four arms. This included manual and electroacupuncture that was subdivided into high and low frequency of treatments. Each subject underwent 12 treatments over 3 months, with the high frequency group receiving 3 close together at the start of each period and the low frequency group receiving 1 each week. The primary outcome was reduction in peak menstrual pain after 12 months, but they looked a number of other pain and quality of life measures several times during the course of the study.
They found that the type and frequency of acupuncture didn’t matter much when it comes to subjective reports of menstrual pain, with all groups having statistically significant improvements, but manual treatment resulted in less pain medications being taken. The authors admitted that they actually expected the opposite to be found. Subjects getting three treatments close together at the beginning of each period had statistically significant improvements in more subjective quality of life measures compared to the once a week group.
This study is fairly worthless, despite claims being made by the authors and in the press, and certainly doesn’t do much to counteract the lack of plausibility that shoving needles into the skin would improve menstrual pain. The authors suggest that there may be an anti-inflammatory effect, however. But it’s a small study with just a handful of subjects in each arm, and there were significant numbers of patients lost to follow-up.
Other than the distinction of manual versus electroacupuncture, and treatment frequency, there was no consistency to the treatments at all in regards to where the needles were stuck. Also some got moxibustion, some didn’t. Each treatment might have been completely different based on subject feedback to the provider. Subjects also got diet and lifestyle advice.
This was a pragmatic pilot study, which is dumb. You have to prove that there is an effect before you run a trial without blinding, because numerous placebo effects can skew the results, and most of the subjects said that they expected the treatment to work. This is now commonplace in acupuncture research, unfortunately, I assume because acupuncture doesn’t work and research with good methodology wasn’t any fun.
Because it’s such a worthless study, no conclusions can be drawn. That being said, it was interesting that there were no differences between manual acupuncture and electroacupuncture for any pain outcomes. In both groups, there was manual insertion of the needle and manipulation until the power of suggestion resulted in the sensation of de qi, which is believed to signal that the acupuncture is working. In the electroacupuncture group they just also ran some juice through the needles. So if taken at face value, which I wouldn’t recommend, this implies that the electricity wasn’t necessary.
But manual acupuncture appeared to be better in the only objective outcome, how much pain medication the subjects needed. It’s just noise, but again if this were legitimate data it would seem that the electric current actually made things worse for subjects. But, again, for reals, it’s all nonsense and it makes me sad.
The second example of acupuncture nonsense is considerably more concerning. It involves an article from Medical News Today on the treatment of diabetes using various forms of acupuncture. It gets the history and epidemiology of acupuncture wrong, making the claims that it’s ancient, commonly used for diabetes in China, and that acupuncture is increasing by leaps and bounds in the United States. It isn’t…at all.
The author also claims that research supports the use of acupuncture for diabetes, as if there is just one diabetes. The studies it bases this conclusion of acupuncture safety and benefit on are terribly cherry picked. They include one study in rats and two in Acupuncture in Medicine, not exactly an unbiased source of peer reviewed research. The article makes the claim that acupuncture is safe, but failed to mention this.
Who says we can’t learn anything from naturopaths?
Naturopathy is nonsense, employing all manner of unproven, disproven, and not even wrong approaches to health. Here is an example, one of many, where a patient suffered at the hands of a naturopath. The patient, diagnosed with gallstone disease, suffered acute liver failure after being advised by a naturopath to consume large amounts of hydrous magnesium sulfate, more commonly known as Epsom salt, in order to flush the stones out. There isn’t a shred of evidence to support this, although it is a common recommendation from people practicing medicine without a license.
Despicable Him
I have said for many years that the most despicable claim I’ve ever encountered from practitioners of alternative medicine was that chiropractic care of newborn infants can prevent SIDS. I stumbled upon a new low this week. In this video, Chiropractor Dan Barrett makes the claim that the man who only just a few days ago gunned down 58 people in Las Vegas would not have done so had he been undergoing regular chiropractic care since infancy.
This isn’t surprising considering that Barrett is a Maximized Living chiropractor, a concept which I discussed in my last post. This means he is a hardcore straight practitioner advocating a dogmatic philosophical approach that is anti-science, anti-vaccine, anti-germ theory, etc. It typically employs fundamentalist Christian beliefs as well. And while this was the only example I could find of a chiropractor making specific claims regarding the prevention of mass murder, there are many examples of chiropractors claiming to treat various forms of mental illness.
See ya next time!
Sorry for the brief (for me) and unfocused installment. In two weeks, I’ll have a post with a little more substance. I’ve been meaning to take the AAP to task for their approach to alternative medicine for quite a while, and I think I’m ready.

An Unexpected Miscellany of Medical Malarkey
Clay Jones on August 26, 2016
Link

I had originally intended a focused discussion of a single topic, but life circumstances have conspired to prevent me from doing so. In the place of my intended post, please enjoy the following collection of hastily assembled pseudomedical odds and ends brought to my attention over the past few weeks.
Psychic ear acupuncture for neonatal withdrawal?
You read that correctly, but sadly it isn’t this kind of psychic acupuncture. I mean psychic as in psychological, as opposed to somatic (from the body) or paranormal (from the nutter). Sorry for the confusion but you’ll understand soon enough.
I’ve written about the use of ear acupuncture in the management of neonates and infants at risk for or suffering from opioid withdrawal in the past. In summation, it is a clinically useless and unethical waste of time. But believers in pseudomedical nonsense are not easily swayed and there is no shortage of “evidence-based medicine” for them to cling to.
The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine has a track record of publishing all manner of inanity, and investigations into neonatal ear acupuncture are no exception. In 2010, German researchers at a university teaching hospital published a paper on their use of a stud finder neuronal pen acupuncture point detector to “determine the presence and absence of acupuncture ear points in neonates with neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS).” To absolutely nobody’s surprise, they found some in each of the 5 withdrawing newborns and concluded that “for the first time it is possible to identify psychic ear acupuncture points in neonates.”
The authors imagined that the “In the future it could be possible to use active ear points in neonates for diagnostic and therapeutic options.” Fast forward six years to earlier this month and some of the same researchers, at the same facility, published data, in the same journal, on 31 more newborns diagnosed with NAS that were found to have the same active acupuncture points using the same acupuncture point detector. They concluded that “The activity of psychic ear acupuncture points may be specific for neonates with NAS.” Of note, one baby was excluded because his mother had been weaned off of narcotics prior to delivery, but just to be safe they checked for acupuncture points anyway and found none.
So is there anything to the use of an acupuncture point locating device to determine if a baby is undergoing withdrawal? I hope so, because NAS can be subtle at first. And while many babies demonstrate tell-tale signs soon after delivery, in the case of maternal use of longer-acting agents for the treatment of opioid addiction, withdrawal can develop days after delivery. So we often have to keep a baby in the hospital under close observation long after their mother has been discharged home. It would be wonderful to have the ability to know which babies to keep in house and which to discharge home with mom.
But in order to accept that these devices work, we would need to make a lot of assumptions. First and foremost we would need to assume that acupuncture points exist in the first place, which already puts us on shaky ground. And if they do exist, we would need to assume that they alter the electrical conductivity in the skin as measured by a simple device, which if true would be surprising considering how meridians and acupuncture points make Bigfoot look gregarious by comparison.
Then we would need to assume that these acupuncture points, once detected, are reliably stable in their location and not just a transient or migratory phenomenon. And if stable, we would need to assume that they could be used to consistently determine the existence of underlying health problems. Once clearly demonstrated to serve as a real, reliable, and valid dashboard warning light for the human body, we would have to figure out if they serve as indications for general health problems or disease in specific organs or regions of the body. Science is hard!
In case you haven’t figured it out already, all these assumptions add up to equal an extremely low prior plausibility. And none of these assumptions has any reasonable evidence supporting them. Furthermore, measuring electrodermal activity is a common component of a variety of pseudoscientific health claims as well as Scientology e-meters and lie detectors. And as Steve Novella discusses in a 2015 post, it is essentially a measurement of how sweaty the skin is and is very prone to influence by a variety of environmental factors as well as the bias of the person doing the testing. Pressing a little harder over the spot one expects to see a change, for example, may be enough to cause the device in question to light up.
Using a device that measures electrodermal activity to detect acupuncture points is no different than using an EMF meter to hunt for ghosts.
Seriously, more cupping nonsense?
Cupping isn’t just for elite Olympic athletes with more medals than neurons. Sadly, this prescientific hickey-inducing therapy is being used on children for virtually every possible health complaint, including some real and potentially very deadly conditions. According to “Dr.” of Chinese Medicine Suzy McCleary on AcuKids.com, we should consider cupping before reaching for “the drugs.”
Cupping is generally recommended for the treatment of pain, gastrointestinal disorders, lung diseases (especially chronic cough and asthma), and paralysis. It is also very helpful for the treatment of headaches and migraines, digestive disorders (constipation, abdominal tension), menstrual disorders (cramps), respiratory problems (cough, allergies), as well as being very beneficial for reducing stress and anxiety, improving energy and helps to calm hyperactive behaviour in children.
McCreary’s website has one of the biggest and most comprehensive disclaimers I’ve ever seen. A simple “I’m full of crap.” would have sufficed. Wait, paralysis?
McCreary is also a proponent of something called Shonishin, a non-invasive form of acupuncture that involves gently massaging a child with little metal instruments. As with cupping, it appears to fix nothing everything, and is particularly effective during a full moon:
Full Moon treatments are given each month on or just before the full moon for general wellness. It is during this time that children are more sensitive to change. Often, symptoms that are hidden during the rest of the month become more apparent during this time. The same way the full moon affects the tides, it affects people too –especially children!
Children often develop fevers, grow taller, or have a tooth break through the gum at this time of the month. It is because of their increased sensitivity that children respond quickly when treated with the building energy of the full moon.
Abdominal complaints appear to be a common focus of kid cuppers. Pediatric cupologists? Here is an example that involves flaming alcohol swabs held inches from a constipated child’s abdomen. And another.
In this case, an 11-year-old child developed severe ulceration and infection after a cupping session for her eczema.
Kinesio tape for newborns?
Kinesio tape (KT) was a prominent feature of the 2008 Beijing and 2012 London Summer Olympics, especially during sports that require less clothing equipment. And although it was overshadowed by cupping in Rio, it is still a popular pseudoscience among athletes despite a lack of much actual benefit beyond that of standard tape. It doesn’t reduce pain, increase strength, improve blood flow or increase lymphatic drainage, and it won’t restart your heart. Okay, that last one was satire.
Despite being nothing more than tape that is a bit stretchier and more colorful, KT is also being used on children for a variety of musculoskeletal conditions:
Infants and children with developmental delays, central nervous system dysfunction, brain injury, movement disorders and more can benefit from the ongoing use of kinesiology tape. Specific conditions that have responded positively to kinesiology taping include toe hypotonia, toe clawing, joint hypermobility, hemiplegia, brachial plexus injury and torticollis. Conditions involving low muscle tone can be taped to activate weak muscles as well as assist with postural control.
There are numerous websites touting anecdotal benefit of KT in pediatric physical and occupational therapy, and several published case reports and series, but no properly blinded controlled studies. Here is one example involving a premature infant with feeding difficulty, a common problem that often improves over a short period of time once a certain level of developmental maturity is reached. Ultimately there is no reason to think that KT would be any more likely to work in children than it is in adults, where there is considerably more available evidence showing its lack of clinical usefulness.
Conclusion: Triple the fun nonsense
There you have it, three examples of so-called soft targets in the fight against pseudoscience in medicine. But two of these can result in very real harm. Children being treated with acupuncture for neonatal abstinence syndrome, something that unfortunately requires subjective assessments of discomfort, may be less likely to receive proven medical treatment if caregivers are biased by a belief in nonsense. Cupping isn’t simply a waste of time but a possible cause of serious injury to a child’s skin and, like acupuncture, a potential cause of delay in seeking real medical care for a child suffering from an asthma exacerbation. Finally, although kinesio taping is silly and unlikely to be used for urgent medical conditions in children, it adds to the growing list of unscientific interventions eroding our societal understanding of and appreciation for science-based medicine.

A Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Episode 3: The Revengening
A setback for bogus marketing claims for fancy athletic tape. E-cigarettes aren’t a good Christmans stocking stuffer for your kids. An update on the European measles outbreak. That’s right, it’s time for another miscellany of medical malarkey!
Clay Jones on March 9, 2018
Link

As I found myself digging my life out from yet another nor’easter here in Boston on Thursday, an endeavor that continues to offend my Southern sensibilities, I realized that I haven’t done one of these in a while. So I have compiled a list of interesting happenings from beyond the borders of science-based medicine. Sit back, relax, and don’t be afraid to ride the snake!
A successful lawsuit against bogus marketing claims? Well, sort of. Maybe?
We haven’t written much about kinesio taping on SBM. This is the stretchy tape, often quite colorful and applied in a variety of eye catching designs, that first achieved widespread recognition during the 2008 Olympics. Steve mentioned it in a post on Olympic Pseudoscience back in 2012 when it was first seen adorning numerous high profile athletes, and I gave it some attention in 2016 when pointing out the absurdity of using the product on children with developmental delays and muscular disorders.
The claims made by manufacturers and promoters of the tape are highly implausible, particularly those involving increased muscle strength, improved blood flow to an injured areas, and better lymphatic drainage to reduce swelling. No evidence supports these claims. Pain reduction and injury prevention are also frequently-cited benefits that similarly lack evidence, at least none showing an effect specific to kinesio tape.
We know that using tape to stabilize an injured joint can have benefit. We also know that compression bandaging can help with controlling swelling. The proponents of kinesio taping believe that their favorite brand, and there are many, does this and much more when expertly applied in specific patterns. One company, KT Health, which manufactures and sells the popular “KT” brand kinesio tape products has been involved in a class action lawsuit for the past few years because of exaggerated health claims.
Last month it was announced that KT Health has settled the suit, agreeing to compensate thousands of customers. But, as is often the case, they have admitted no wrongdoing and are simply going to put a disclaimer on their products stating that they don’t work for all injuries. They will continue to charge significantly more than the cost of equally effective plain compression tape.
Despite this l was easily able to find all manner of bogus claims being made by this company that won’t be affected by the lawsuit. Take their KT Recovery Patch+, for example. According to the manufacturer, they are a “natural, drug-free way to reduce pain and promote faster healing without medication.” The product label adds that the patches work by draining lymphatic fluid to “promote faster healing without medication.”
Again, there is no evidence that these superficial applications of stretchy tape, regardless of how colorful and exotic they appear, do anything of the sort. The most charitable interpretation of the literature on kinesio taping is that putting something on that you can feel, and perhaps reminds you to be careful, might result in minor and transient improvement in subjective reports of pain. There is no evidence of a specific benefit related to kinesio tape itself, or to any kind of expert application of it, despite what you might learn at “Kinesio University.”
So, this is a slap on the wrist, just the cost of doing business when it comes to misleading the public about health related products. But at least some good information made the rounds with the media coverage of the lawsuit. Thankfully use of any kinesio tape product is unlikely to cause anything other than financial harm. And no, the 2020 ACLS guidelines will not include the use of kinesio tape.
E-cigarettes and teenagers are not a good combination
There has been a lot of hype surrounding so-called e-cigarrettes, used for doing the vaping or whatever the kids are calling it these days. While fewer teens are smoking traditional cigarettes, the number of vaping adolescents skyrocketed over the past several years, with an increase in half a million from 2014 to 2015, when 16 percent of high school students had used e-cigarettes. The most recent data from 2016 showed a drop, with only 11% of teens vaping, but that’s still a lot of kids.
There is reason to believe that vaping is a safer option than smoking analog cigarettes. If someone who smokes regularly switches to e-cigarettes, I don’t think any medical professional would say that’s simply a lateral move. But vaping is not harmless, and the better option is to do neither. When it comes to kids, the best option is of course to never start. Unfortunately, ads for e-cigarettes are commonplace and there are serious concerns about marketing with kids in mind. But no, e-cigarette manufacturers have not made a handheld gaming/vaping device…yet.
The American Academy of Pediatrics very recently highlighted two studies that shine some light on the problems with vaping. In the first study, researchers found that teenaged e-cigarette users had metabolites of carcinogenic volatile organic compounds in their urine compared to non-users, and that this was true of those using products that don’t contain nicotine. Many kids start off with these because they believe that they are safer. I’m left wondering why these companies would market a vaping product that doesn’t contain nicotine if not to entice kids.
One of the major concerns regarding youth use of e-cigarettes is that they will increase the likelihood of eventually smoking regular cigarettes. This has pretty much already been established in fact. But what about the potential benefit of vaping diverting kids who have begun to experiment with cigarettes and preventing the establishment of a more dangerous habit? In the second study highlighted by the AAP, researchers looked specifically at this population and found that no, no it doesn’t. It probably encourages it.
Unfortunately, there are a lot of people out there who do not think of secondhand e-cigarette exposure as particularly risky to children. And while it probably isn’t as bad as exposure to smoke from the conventional variety, we don’t have long term studies and we don’t know how vape smoke would impact the risk of pediatric asthma, ear infections, and SIDS, to name just three of many potential examples. So it is a good idea to limit exposure.
The European measles outbreak continues apace
There is currently an extensive measles outbreak affecting 15 European countries, particularly Romania and Italy. The World Health Organization recently announced that there were over 20,000 cases in 2017, four times the number in 2016. The roughly five thousand European cases that year was a record low. So why the huge increase?
Overall the vaccination rate is still fairly high, although lower than in the United States, but there are regions where it is on the way down thanks to a persistent anti-vaccine movement and the resulting deluge of misinformation that parents are exposed to. This is likely playing the largest role, however there are also issues with access to medical care for certain groups. The WHO specifically mentioned the Roma population in Romania and throughout Europe.
As would be expected, the vast majority of 2017 European measles cases occurred in unvaccinated and partially vaccinated individuals. So far there have been 35 confirmed pediatric deaths from measles in Europe in 2017, but more will certainly come. At least a few more will die years later, after a period of good health, from a complication known as subacute sclerosing panencephalitis.
The European outbreak is occurring at a time when we should be celebrating the success of the measles vaccination program. This is a disease that every year killed children by the millions as recently as the 1980s, but 2016 marks the first year that the global death rate dropped below 100,000 thanks to a massive public health campaign. We should be using this success as inspiration to drive the nail in the coffin of this deadly disease, an affliction which could be permanently eradicated just like we did with smallpox.
Many of the involved European countries, like Italy, are common destinations for American tourists. Our immunization rates remain strong, but there are worrisome pockets primed for a major outbreak. Measles is incredibly contagious, and all it would take is one family returning from a trip abroad to cause thousands of cases if their home community immunization rates are low.
Spring is coming…eventually!
That’s it for this edition of the MMM. Unless you want to read about thousands of cheerleaders being exposed to the mumps virus at a national competition, that is. You do you. As for me, I’m heading back out to shovel more snow.

Rise of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey…Again
More deaths in the European measles outbreak. Experts call for a national registry of sleep-related deaths in infants. Raw milk puts several Tennessee children in the intensive care unit. Oh, and medicinal dog urine. It must be time for another miscellany of medical malarkey.
Clay Jones on June 29, 2018
Link

Some weeks I have time to dedicate my blogging efforts to a thorough discussion of one specific topic, and some weeks I just don’t. Fortunately, I came across a few newsworthy items that I think readers will be interested in, and only one of which involves drinking dog urine for its medicinal benefits. Welcome, once again, to yet another Miscellany of Medical Malarkey.
Measles continues to spread across Europe and people are dying
Thanks to a growing anti-vaccine movement and decreasing immunization rates, cases of measles have been on the rise throughout Europe. And despite the frequent claims from some anti-vaccine propagandists that it is a mild infection in healthy individuals with good nutritional status who are replete with vitamin A, implying that it’s fine for poor people in developing regions to suffer and die, in reality it is an infection with serious potential for morbidity and mortality. But don’t take my word for it.
In February, The New York Times reported that measles cases throughout Europe quadrupled in 2017 with over 21,000 recorded cases. I’m sure it goes without saying that this is almost certainly a significant underestimate of the actual numbers, and I’ll tell you why that really matters shortly. The largest outbreak took place in Romania, which had more cases in 2017 than in all of Europe the previous year.
Italy was a very close second with around 5,000 cases, Ukraine just a few hundred less than that, and several other countries had large outbreaks of up to 1,000 cases, including Belgium, Britain, France, Germany, Greece, Russia, and Tajikistan. Just under half of the reported cases were in children under the age of 15 years, but the single most effected demographic were children under a year of age. As expected, virtually all reported cases involved individuals who were not vaccinated or who had not received the full series. So the fact that these countries tend to have the highest levels of “vaccine skepticism” isn’t a coincidence.
But how many died from this “mild infection” that according to vaccine science deniers should run its course uneventfully in patients living in developed countries? I found a couple different answers, but most of the reporting and WHO data was somewhere in the 30-50 range. Most of these were in children, as would be expected.
In addition to the people of all ages that succumbed to the initial infection, we can also expect the eventual death of many of the young children that recovered in the years to come. This will include kids who had milder infections and weren’t officially diagnosed. This second round of deaths will come in the form of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a horrific, slow-yet-steady cognitive decline that ultimately results in death. I’ve written about SSPE before. To be clear, there will be children and young adults years from now who begin having mild cognitive impairment that will, over several months, slowly progress to death.
The 2017 measles outbreaks across Europe have continued into 2018. In France, to give just one example, there have been roughly 2,500 cases since November. 88% of these patients were not fully immunized and about 1 out of 4 have required hospitalization.
This is France, which has better healthcare than the United States and a generally healthier population. Unfortunately, French health authorities announced that there is no region in the country that can boast levels of vaccine uptake that would provide proper herd immunity so they are primed for a major outbreak. Just this week, they announced two more deaths.
And while I realize that Papua New Guinea isn’t in Europe, and that Steve covered this in a post earlier in the week, I’ll still shoehorn in the announcement of polio cases popping up 18 years after the country was declared free of it. This is very scary stuff.
As many babies die unexpectedly during sleep in the United States every year as all pediatric motor vehicle fatalities combined
As a parent of young but rapidly aging* children, one of my greatest anticipated worries is the day that they are able to get behind the wheel of a car. I won’t be the first parent to lose sleep over this concern and I certainly won’t be the last because cars are terrifying death machines that kill thousands of people every year. We are constantly bombarded with reports of these accidents by our local news outlets, and many people can relate to this concern through personal experience.
But as a pediatrician, particularly one who primarily cares for newborns, the specter of sleep-related death haunts me as well. I spend a significant amount of time with each family discussing safe sleep practices that have been proven to reduce the risk of death during sleep, the most commonly known presentation being SIDS. SIDS deaths, however, are just one component of the total number of sudden unexpected infant deaths (SUID) that occur every year.
Unfortunately, the literature is confusing because historically different terms have been used in a haphazard manner to catalogue these deaths. In order to improve our ability to draw conclusions from the data, there has been a move to try to stick with SUID as a global category and then break it down from there. Only recently has there been the creation of a CDC registry to keep track of SUID cases, but only 16 states are currently contributing.
In a recent JAMA Pediatrics Viewpoint, three experts in the Rush University Department of Pediatrics call for more support for efforts to create a comprehensive SUID registry. They believe such a database can better guide research and help fine-tune public health efforts, and they use the dramatic drop in pediatric motor vehicle fatalities over the years as an example of how successful this approach can be. They point out that this is necessary because, after initial reductions in sleep-related deaths when the AAP and NIH endorsed Back to Sleep program was rolled out in 1992, there has been a plateau at around 3,700 yearly cases since 1999. This is equivalent to the current number of yearly pediatric deaths from car accidents.
One of their concerns, and I absolutely agree, is that many parents just don’t seem to take the risk as seriously as they should, and they may not be strictly following recommended safe sleep practices because of it. This may in part be because these deaths are not reported publicly in the same way that pediatric traffic fatalities are, giving a false sense that they are very rare. I’ll add that there is also a worrisome amount of science denial and misinformation available online regarding the risk factor of sharing a bed with young infants.
Consuming raw milk is dangerous, especially for kids
Earlier in the month, news of several children in Knox County, Tennessee being hospitalized with severe E. coli infections made the rounds. Many of the cases, and in particular the two toddlers featured in the news reports, were linked to the consumption of raw milk from a local farm. They were extremely ill and required ICU admission for management of a very dangerous potential complication, seen when children are infected with certain toxin-producing strains of the bacteria, known as hemolytic uremic syndrome.
HUS is serious stuff. I’ve been involved in the care of three children with HUS in my career. One died, one survived with permanent cortical blindness, and one had a full recovery. The two children in this story both developed kidney failure requiring dialysis, and needed multiple blood transfusions. One had a staph infection of his central line that complicated his course. Both are now home and continue to have residual kidney injury as of the latest report I could find.
The father of the two children admitted to being completely unaware that raw milk could result in such severe illness. This is unfortunate because that information is readily available through the CDC and numerous other trustworthy sources of medical information, not the least of which should have been the children’s pediatrician or family doctor. More unfortunate is the fact that the family had signed up for a “cow-share” program, which is perfectly legal while selling raw milk at a store is decidedly not, because they had read about health benefits of avoiding pasteurization.
This is dangerous misinformation. There is absolutely no health benefit experienced by consuming raw milk over pasteurized, only risk. It makes no sense to me that these cow-share distribution systems are legal. Thankfully the family is now speaking out about the risks of raw milk consumption, a refreshing outcome considering the response of Ezekiel Stephan’s parents to their child’s death by worldview.
Finally, medicinal dog urine?
Yes, it’s a thing. Not that there are medical benefits, just that apparently some people believe that there are. The woman in question collects a clean catch specimen of her clearly well-trained pooch’s urine every morning, topped off by the neighbor’s dog if supplies are limited, and down it. She claims that it has given her perfect skin, cured her depression, and prevented cancer since she began this routine two years ago. I feel compelled to point out that she has also not been attacked by a bear in the past two years.
She began drinking dog urine after reading a decades-old study that discussed antibodies being found in human urine, although I doubt she just stumbled on it. The interest was probably already there. She also says something about a Big Pharma conspiracy but it doesn’t really matter why though, does it? Urine therapy, even using animal urine, isn’t new but it certainly isn’t mainstream. It’s pretty ridiculous actually.
There obviously isn’t any good evidence that it is beneficial in any way to drink urine. There is, however, good reason to consider not drinking it, especially canine urine. Leptospirosis, a serious infection that can cause meningitis and organ failure, can be spread through exposure to dog urine. Wait, the neighbor’s dog? How do you start that conversation I wonder?
See you next time.

*To be clear, my children are aging at the normal human rate. They aren’t Benjamin Buttoning. It is my false perception of the passage of time that gives me the impression that they are gaining at least two years to my one.

The Return of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Strikes Back
The flu season is upon us, as is the first pediatric death. A polio-like illness is spreading, and experts are baffled. Kids probably shouldn’t be around giant spinning metallic blades. Magic tape! You guessed it, another miscellany of medical malarkey has risen from the grave.
Clay Jones on October 19, 2018
Link

You thought it was dead. The credits had started to roll and you whispered to the random guy sitting next to you that “there’s no way it’s coming back after that. Yep, definitely dead this time.” But you were wrong.
There was a post-credit scene where a hand shoots up from a freshly filled grave in the middle of a thunderstorm. So no, it wasn’t dead. In fact, it’s found you. Yet another collection of medical (and sometimes pseudomedical) odds and ends that have caught my attention recently is walking up the stairs. You can hear the creaking floor as it approaches. Now it’s slowly turning the doorknob. It’s too late to run.
It (the flu season) has begun!
Cases of the flu are now starting to be pop up across the country. Just as I was taking my daughters to get their yearly flu shot this week, the first report of a pediatric death was announced in Florida. No details have been provided, only that it was a child with no underlying health conditions who had not been vaccinated. We don’t know why, and I wouldn’t jump to conclusions considering how early it is in the season.
Last year was a particularly bad season, with an estimated 80,000 deaths caused by the influenza virus. 180 deaths occurred in pediatric patients between 6 months and 17 years of age, which is about on par with recent years. Unlike the child in the most recent fatality, most deaths caused by the flu involve patients with an underlying health condition such as asthma or an immune deficiency. These patients benefit from as many people as possible, including themselves unless contraindicated, being vaccinated. Unfortunately only about 60% of eligible children received the vaccine last year. This just isn’t good enough.
Mysterious polio-like illness has now been reported in 22 states
Almost exclusively effecting young children, a mysterious polio-like illness that damages the spinal cord has been confirmed by the CDC in 62 patients, and 60 more are currently being investigated. The condition, acute flaccid myelitis (AFM), presents with muscle weakness and decreased reflexes that can be severe enough to require the use of mechanical ventilation. The prognosis varies from good in mild cases, with some having a full recovery, to severe persistent weakness or paralysis.
AFM isn’t a new condition, rather it is a rare final common pathway seen in several different processes. Polio and West Nile virus infection, for example, can cause AFM, and various autoimmune and genetic processes can cause a very similar presentation. What is different about the current spate of cases is that there has been a significant (though still rare) increase in the number of cases without any clear cause despite extensive investigation since 2014.
In 2014, pediatricians saw an increase in severe respiratory infections caused by the first ever national outbreak of a particular enterovirus (EV-D68). While it was plausible to suspect a link between the surge in AFM to EV-D68, because this virus has been known to target the spinal cord in addition to the lungs, most cases since 2014 have not tested positive. And after the 2014 EV-D68 outbreak, reported cases plummeted to typical numbers.
The CDC currently considers the cause of increased cases of AFM to be unknown. They are asking that samples of blood, spinal fluid, and stool (enteroviruses love to infect the gut) be sent in for analysis in any suspected case. So far, no cases in the United States have been caused by the poliovirus, but this is a very small taste of what it would be like should that disease come back.
Lawn mowers are extremely dangerous, especially for kids
Earlier this month, The New York Times reported on the surprisingly (not to emergency department doctors) large number of injuries related to the use of lawn mowers. A recently published study that tracked these injuries across the country revealed that just over 51,000 were seen in emergency departments during the 8-year-period of 2006-2013. Of the reported ED visits, there were roughly 11,000 broken bones and the same number of amputations. The researchers estimated that these injuries cost about $36 million every year.
These numbers, which were obtained from the US Nationwide Emergency Department Sample, underrepresent the actual number of cases, however, likely because they focused on a single diagnosis code involving only powered mowers. A study published one month later in the American Journal of Emergency Medicine reported significantly larger numbers of lawn mower-related injuries using the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s National Electronic Injury Surveillance System and all codes relating to mowers. In this database, there were almost a million ED visits for lawn mower injuries in the United States from 2005-2015.
One thing is clear in both studies, and it’s that children suffer the worst injuries. Though representing a small percentage of the total number of visits, young children were by far more likely to present with severe injuries and to require amputation. These injuries likely occur when they wander close to the mower and are struck or when they fall from a caregiver’s lap. I’ve personally taken care of a toddler who was accidentally run over by a riding mower and it isn’t something I’ll ever forget.
Here is some good info from the AAP on kids and lawn mower safety.
A few colorful and stretchy scraps left on the cutting room floor
Runner’s World published an article on kinesiology tape this week, and it’s bad. It’s very bad. It’s essentially just an ad for certified KT roller-unrollers and is deserving of its own dedicated post, especially considering how we have surprisingly never covered this topic in any real detail. Maybe next time, but until then here is a choice quote:
“It looks easy, but you don’t want to be turning on or exciting a muscle that’s already overactive or turning off a muscle that’s already underactive,” says Scantlebury. “Over time, that can cause even more damage. Getting some education from a licensed professional is tremendously valuable.”
Don’t laugh. I think I read an article about the dangers of haphazard and unprofessional Kinesio Taping a couple years ago. Oh, here it is.
You survived!
Yet another edition of the MMM is in the books, and you’ve survived…for now. You can relax and return to the water, unless of course you want to read about a measles outbreak in Brooklyn among unimmunized children in an Orthodox Jewish community that has the potential to become very serious, very fast. As for me, that’s it, man. It’s game over, man. Game over!

Dr. David Villarreal’s “Holistic Dentistry:” Full of Holes?
Harriet Hall on April 21, 2015
Link


I get a lot of e-mails from publicists offering suggestions for articles and interviews with their clients. I quickly delete most of them, but one recently caught my eye. It said that patients travel from as far as Europe and Africa to have California “holistic dentist” Dr. David Villarreal remove the old silver fillings that are damaging their health. He has removed 20,000 of them in his 30-year career; removing fillings accounts for 75% of his practice. It said your dental fillings could be killing you – and not just the mercury in your “silver” fillings. Dr. Villarreal says that filling materials that are not compatible with your particular body chemistry can suppress immune responses, leading to a host of illnesses from frequent colds to autoimmune diseases to far worse conditions. He performs a blood compatibility evaluation to pick the right material for your body. He picks the right composite to maintain optimum health and help heal the immune system.
He says amalgam fillings are 50% mercury, the most toxic non-radioactive element on earth, more toxic than lead, arsenic or cadmium. He says heavy metal poisoning has been linked to MS, ALS, chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, lupus, Parkinson’s, arthritis and many other autoimmune diseases. He says most European countries banned mercury fillings almost 40 years ago.
I’d heard similar criticisms of amalgam fillings before, but what really caught my attention was the description of his filling removal process. He wears special protective gear including a gas mask, and uses a special suction system, an ionizer in the room, and a mercury separator to ensure none gets into water systems or oceans. He drapes the patient, provides protective eyewear, and uses extra protective covering in the patient’s mouth. In addition to all that, a naturopathic doctor is on hand to administer intravenous vitamin C in order to help pull the heavy metals out of the system so they can exit the body as waste. This offsets any possible negative health consequences or withdrawal symptoms that may arise from the extraction of the heavy metals from the system. He practices “ozone dentistry,” purifying and sterilizing the tooth so it can be filled with a more healthful alternative. He says his patients report back that they have seen significant overall health benefits and often the elimination of specific conditions that they didn’t perceive were related to their teeth at all.
More information from his website
I didn’t know of any scientific evidence that would support his beliefs and practice methods. I went to his website, BioDental Healing, hoping to find out more. I didn’t find even a shred of evidence there. But I did find a few other things.
I found that he is a disciple of the late Hal Huggins, a notorious crusader against mercury fillings and root canals who believed mercury amalgams were responsible for a wide variety of ills (from mononucleosis to leukemia) and made extravagant claims for his methods (he got wheelchair-bound MS patients up and walking by fixing their teeth!). Huggins lost his license for gross negligence and the use of unnecessary and unproven procedures.
I found that he provides nutritional counseling.
I found that his clinic offers acupressure massage and other massage therapies to “help heal the disharmonies between internal organs and blockage to the circulation of Chi, or energy, through meridians.”
I found that he is the founder and formulator of an all-natural whitening toothpaste and mouth rinse line, called Estrella (the Spanish word for star).
The Meridian Tooth Chart
And then I found something that almost made me fall out of my chair: the Meridian Tooth Chart on his website. It explains that every tooth is related to an acupuncture meridian, which is connected to other parts of the body through an “energy highway.” This connection “is so apparent that an experienced dentist can often assess your overall health and wellness by reviewing your dental condition. If a person has a weak internal organ, the condition of the associated meridian tooth could make it considerably more problematic.”
The chart has two interactive features:
Click on an organ, for example the pancreas, and you will learn that it is related to teeth 2,3,5,12,21,22,27, 28, and 29. The “organ” bile ducts is related to teeth 11 and 22.
Click on a tooth, say the right front incisor, and you will see that it is related to:
    • Specific organs: kidneys, bladder, urogenital
    • Glands: pineal and epididymis (Is the epididymis a gland?)
    • Spine and spinal cord segments: L2,3, S3,4,5, coccyx
    • Sense organs: frontal sinus (Are the sinuses sense organs?)
    • Musculature: lower extremities
    • Joints: foot, sacrum and coccyx, knee (posterior)
    • Other relationships: conceptual connections, mental dynamics, vitality, hormonal capacity, emotional disturbances, impotence, sterility, creative genetic world (what do you suppose that means?), fear, sadness, instability, kidney functions, anger, depression, and moodiness.
Incidentally, an article on the DentalWatch website highlights the absurdity of these meridian charts. The author found more than 50 different versions on the Internet.
How do they know?
I wondered how the developers of the Meridian Tooth Chart figured out all those relationships. I e-mailed the BioDental Healing website to inquire. And I also asked them to identify some of the “many European countries” that supposedly banned mercury fillings 40 years ago. My own understanding, from information I found on the Internet, is that they are still in use throughout Europe. A European commission only very recently recommended phasing them out and suggested that a ban would be one way to reduce total environmental mercury exposure. Subsequently two countries, Norway and Sweden, introduced legislation that would ban mercury fillings, but that was for environmental reasons rather than because of any danger to patients from fillings.
They answered my questions about meridians with a link to a PDF filled with discussions of “energy”, ancient Chinese wisdom, and the activities of Reinhard Voll, a German doctor and engineer known for his development of Electroacupunture of Voll (the basis of a number of bogus devices that I have written about previously). To the skeptical eye, it is self-explanatory. It doesn’t even mention teeth!
Regarding the banning of mercury amalgams, they sent two articles, one a press release, the second an article from the notoriously unreliable Mercola.com. These sources say mercury fillings were banned in three (not “most”) European countries in 2008 (not 40 years ago).
I kept trying to pin them down. They finally admitted the 40 year claim was wrong; they said they were checking with their publicist as to why that claim was released and would get it re-worded to “a few countries.” My requests for information about the meridian tooth chart were first answered by links to copies of the chart on other websites, and eventually they admitted that there was nothing “scientific” about the meridian tooth chart but denied that they had ever claimed there was. Their excuse:
Our office has been careful to state that it is an alternative point of view and it is not scientific nor do we aim that it is a diagnostic tool. I have overheard the dentist state that the chart is a concept based on traditional Chinese acupuncture points.
Conclusion
One undeniably true statement on the BioDental Healing website is “we practice a type of unconventional dentistry.” Conventional dentistry is conventional for a very good reason: scientific evidence is the best guide to reality. Quackwatch recommends “Stay Away from ‘Holistic’ and ‘Biological’ Dentists.” I do too. I’m not going to provide a detailed critique of Dr. Villarreal’s beliefs and practices, because I would have to bite my tongue into bloody shreds to talk about it without using words I might regret. I think BioDental’s own words speak volumes, and I will leave it to my readers to check out the evidence for themselves.

(Dys-)Functional Medicine Comes to Dentistry
Grant Ritchey on August 28, 2015
Link


The great philosopher Deepak Chopra wrote: “I do not believe in meaningless coincidences. I believe every coincidence is a message, a clue about a particular facet of our lives that requires our attention.” So when SBM author extraordinaire Jann Bellamy emailed me last week with an article about so-called “Functional Dentistry” with the comment “Blog fodder?”, I looked it over with interest and then promptly filed it away in my brain along with other things that I might get around to doing but probably won’t. The very next day, Dr. Clay Jones – also an SBM bloggist extraordinaire – asked me if I’d mind pinch-hitting and write a blog post for his upcoming Friday morning time slot while he was away on vacation.
Coincidence?
Personally, I find it more plausible that Jann and Clay secretly conspired to have me write this article in order to lure me into a rage spiral, than the notion that The Universe was sending me a message about a particular facet of my life that required my attention. But we are at Point B now, are we not? Regardless of whether the first domino was pushed by The Universe or by Jann and Clay, I suppose it is now incumbent upon me to share with the SBM readership yet another way where pseudo-scientific practices and deceptive branding and marketing tactics have trickled down from medicine into dentistry.
In this blog post, I will review what Functional Medicine (FM) is, what is wrong about it and what is right about it (yes, there are aspects of FM that are legitimate, if not admirable), and how it has infiltrated (some say contaminated) the field of dentistry. I think you’ll find that, when you pull back the curtains, the reality of FM as a “new and improved” medical/dental paradigm is vastly embellished and overstated, and the Great and Powerful Functional Medicine Oz is really just an old geezer pulling the levers of spin and hyperbole and pushing the buttons of pseudo-science.
What is Functional Medicine?
Functional Medicine, according to the Institute for Functional Medicine’s website:
addresses the underlying causes of disease, using a systems-oriented approach and engaging both patient and practitioner in a therapeutic partnership. It is an evolution in the practice of medicine that better addresses the healthcare needs of the 21st century. By shifting the traditional disease-centered focus of medical practice to a more patient-centered approach, functional medicine addresses the whole person, not just an isolated set of symptoms. Functional medicine practitioners spend time with their patients, listening to their histories and looking at the interactions among genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that can influence long-term health and complex, chronic disease.
Functional Medicine has been covered thoroughly in SBM by the late Wally Sampson, and the not yet late David Gorski and Steve Novella, among others; consequently, I need not delve too deeply into it here. However, a cursory unpacking of the above definition reveals a recurring logical fallacy, namely the Unstated Major Premise or Unstated Assumption. When it is claimed that FM “…addresses the underlying causes of disease,” or “Functional medicine practitioners spend time with their patients, listening to their histories and looking at the interactions among genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that can influence long-term health and complex, chronic disease,” the unstated premise is that “regular” doctors don’t do any of these things; they must be only symptom-oriented, not preventive in their outlook, and don’t take all of a patient’s personal, medical, and social factors into consideration before arriving at an invidualized course of action. This, of course, is false, and is what any good physician will do. I know mine does, and he does not identify as a Functional Medicine physician. This dubious technique is employed by most if not all CAM providers in an attempt to set themselves apart from the crowd.
Where does FM get it right?
Where FM gets it right is that, from all appearances, FM physicians as a whole tend to leave more appointment time for the history and physical exams, and claim to do a more thorough genetic, environmental, and lifestyle evaluation of their patients than a typical primary care physician. Functional Medicine practitioners emphasize healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, exercise, good sleep habits, smoking cessation, and so on, in addition to the normal comprehensive physical examination and lab tests, which is a good thing. This, of course, typically comes at a cost, as FM patients often (but not always) have higher out of pocket co-payments due to some tests and fees not being covered by medical insurance. However, patients state that they feel they are heard by their FM health care team, and the chances of some illness or condition being overlooked potentially could be reduced with the extra time spent and tests performed (although this hasn’t been demonstrated). Patients don’t want to wait hours in their “regular” doctor’s reception room, only to feel as though they are herded like cattle into cold examination rooms, then to wait another eternity until their nurse or physician gives them the proverbial seven minutes of their time before scribbling out a prescription that treats a symptom only. And while I hope you see through my above Straw Man scenario, you can see where the perception of individualized, caring medicine would be appealing to a significant percentage of the population, particularly those who are proactive and preventive in their health care decisions, those who may have a mistrust of “mainstream” medicine, and the worried well.
They are also right when they point out that the incidences of chronic diseases (such as cancer, heart disease, diabetes) have risen and that the health care costs associated with these diseases are burdening health care systems in many nations. Further, many if not most of these chronic disease are lifestyle related (smoking, poor sleep hygiene, sedentary habits, poor diet, etc.) and are thus preventable. Again, this is just good medical practice, and not a recent innovation of Functional Doctors.
Another area where FM is winning in the marketplace of perception and image is that they have branded themselves as progressive, a new paradigm in medicine. They throw around such enticing buzz- words and phrases as “powerful new operating system”, “empowerment”, “biochemical individuality”, “high touch/high tech”, et. al. while demonizing “conventional” medicine by describing it as “doctor centered”, “disease oriented”, “expensive”, and an “acute care model.” This message is indeed powerful, and has resulted in the integration (pardon the pun) of FM into such esteemed institutions as The Cleveland Clinic and George Washington University, and others. Even in my neck of the woods, The University of Kansas Medical Center has an Integrative Medicine department, where they boast of such quackery as vitamin C infusions and neurofeedback, the latter of which promises to “rebalance your brain.” Yes, those exact words are on the official University of Kansas Medical Center website. Sigh. Well, at least my alma mater still has the best college basketball program in the world.
What is wrong with Functional Medicine?
What is wrong with Functional Medicine is that it often promotes many CAM practices which have been shown to be of questionable therapeutic value, or outright ineffective. Reiki, acupuncture, chiropractic adjustments, “detoxification” programs, the aforementioned vitamin C infusions (unless you’re a bescurvied 18th century sailor fresh off the boat), and many other CAM modalities are offered as “holistic patient centered” options (again, at a significant cost and not without risk). Individualized care based on biochemical and genetic markers have some merit in some situations, and I’ve no doubt that this will become more prevalent in the future as techniques improve and applications are demonstrated scientifically. For now, however, it is an idea whose time has not yet come on a broad scale, and it is disingenuous to state or imply otherwise.
The other area where FM is a bit misleading is in how they frame their message. As stated earlier, the concepts of treating the cause of disease instead of just the symptoms is the foundational basis of all health care. I’m sure that Mark Crislip, an infectious disease doc, actually tries to kill the bugs that cause his patients’ diseases; he doesn’t just treat the symptoms. Often, however, treating the cause isn’t possible. For example, with many auto-immune diseases, there is no cure for the underlying pathophysiology, therefore managing the patient symptomatically is the best modern medicine can do at the present time. Using deceptive rhetoric and logical fallacies to their advantage, they frame FM as cutting edge and (ironically) science based, while portraying the mainstream medical community as closed minded, archaic, and behind the times.
Functional Dentistry – Coming to a theatre near you
Not wanting to feel left out, some dentists who have for years called themselves “biologic” or “holistic” dentists decided that a cool new word would really help separate themselves from the “ordinary” dentists who recommend such poisons as fluoride and amalgam fillings. Originally, “alternative” was the word of choice, but over time it grew stale and was subsequently replaced by “complementary”, a kinder and gentler term that implied a sort of truce between science based medicine/dentistry and non-traditional practices. After a while, the term “integrative” became fashionable, as complementary and alternative medicine attempted to insert itself into mainstream medicine. Thanks to promoters like Mehmet Oz, Andrew Weil, Deepak Chopra, and Joltin’ Joe Mercola, integrate it did. Not only into university-based medical centers, as mentioned above, but into private medical and dental practices worldwide. Within the past couple of years, some dentists have seized upon the “Functional” moniker and have co-opted it for their own use. Mind you, for these dentists, there has been no change in philosophy or standard of care from when they were only bioholisticompleternative dentists, it is a marketing/branding term only, which they presumably hope will help their websites’ Search Engine Optimization.
To date there are no “official” Functional Dentistry organizations, although I wouldn’t be surprised if one was founded in the near future. However, many individual dentists’ websites blatantly ride FM’s coattails. One dentist’s website states:
Functional Medicine Based Dentistry is the application of the principles and practices of Functional Medicine with the practice of the art and science of Dentistry. Philosophical differences exist today between traditional Evidence-Based Dentistry and Biological Dentistry, which have an impact on all patients and their oral and systemic health. Functional Medicine believes that a patient’s history, physiology, and lifestyle are fundamental factors when evaluating a patient’s health. Examination and interpretation of a patient’s individual biochemistry and genetics can give clues and hence better understanding of a patient’s chronic disease.When we apply these concepts in the course of dental examination, diagnosis and treatment, the “one size fits all” philosophy of standard American dentistry becomes outdated and dentists transform from “molar mechanics” to true “physicians of the mouth.”(emphases in the original)
Just like in Functional Medicine, statements like the above are disingenuous and fairly drip with the Unstated Assumption fallacy. As a non-Functional dentist, I can honestly say that I too believe that a patient’s history, physiology, and lifestyle are fundamental factors when evaluating their oral health. In fact, I know of no dentist who believes otherwise. Further, “examination and interpretation of a patient’s individual biochemistry” is a bit vague; while there are some useful genetic and salivary tests (when indicated) that are available in dentistry, they shouldn’t necessarily be utilized routinely and indiscriminately as screening tools until the evidence justifies it. And last, there is no such thing as a “one size fits all” approach to dentistry. Every person, every mouth, every situation is unique, and every prudent dentist takes all of these factors into consideration when determining a course of action for a patient, involving them in their treatment decisions. This is in our code of ethics and is not the domain of any one particular brand of dentistry.
Conclusion: Choose substance over marketing
All that said, most “alternative” or “functional” dentists are very conscientious dentists who sincerely want the best for their patients. If your dentist claims to be “holistic” or “functional” or “biologic”, you may want to put your antennae up if you are a science-based consumer of health care, but don’t throw the baby out with the bath water and summarily reject him/her. He or she may be a fantastic, science based dentist who is merely adapting the cloak of Functional Medicine Based Dentistry because they believe they are indeed “whole person” centered, want to appear to be cutting edge and progressive, and to gain a marketing advantage on their competition. There’s nothing wrong with that per se. To that end however, never hesitate to ask for good evidence if your dentist recommends something that seems “non-traditional.” The Center for Evidence Based Dentistry is a great resource for patients and health care providers alike. By being aware of what labels are being employed by physicians and dentists, what these labels mean, and why they are being used will help health care consumers make sound, science based decisions for themselves and their loved ones.

Science-Based Satire: Hiring a Doula for Dental Procedures
Clay Jones on April 8, 2016
Link


Suzy Flanders had always dreamed of having a natural tooth extraction without pain medications, sedation, or local anesthesia, just like in the Bible or on an episode of Keeping Up With Kardashians. “When the day finally came on April 1st 2011, and my dentist recommended the removal of an impacted third molar, I almost couldn’t believe it,” Flanders explained. “After reading everything I could find online and talking to a few trusted friends and family members, the right choice became clear. I had to do what was best for me and for my precious tooth.”
What she found in her research was the consistent recommendation to have someone present during the procedure that had been through the experience themselves. Many proponents of natural dental care endorse this practice because there is evidence that it helps to reduce the need for harmful medications that might prevent a quick return to normal activity. They also argue that a dental procedure is about more than just the removal of an abscessed tooth or the correction of malocclusion, it’s about experiencing what the procedure feels like and discovering what you are capable of achieving. Natural dental care patients learn to manage their pain and remain open to the excitement and exhilaration of the process, and often report feeling higher levels of satisfaction. After all, modern humans have been experiencing the beauty of natural dental pain for 250,000 years.
After discussing the idea with her husband Daniel, Flanders decided to seek out the services of a dental doula.
What is a dental doula?
Similar to doulas that attend the birthing of children or farm animals, the specific focus of a dental doula involves being present prior to and during a procedure in order to provide reassurance, support, and information. The dental doula that Flanders found served as a calming presence and a firm voice of support and encouragement throughout the extraction. “We really connected. She had been through it all herself after a rollerblading accident resulted in a fractured maxillary central incisor, so she knew the pain that I was feeling. I was able to focus on her voice and cling to it like a piece of floating driftwood during a powerful storm.”
Introspective data from across the nation has shown an increasing utilization of dental doula services over the past decade. According to the American College of Dental Doulas spokesdoula Kate Orberton, people are realizing that dental doulas empower patients and ease communication with dentists, orthodontists, and their support staff without giving dental advice. Orberton stressed that dental doulas are not a replacement for licensed oral health professionals.
First-time dental patients are especially vulnerable, according to Orberton. When a dental doula enters the room, they allow for the patient to relax and focus on blocking out the agony that they are about to experience. They are ready with helpful information and they encourage reasonable expectations. “We can tell the patient that they made the right choice and help them to focus on the benefits of that choice, between the intermittent shrieks and sobs.”
Are there downsides to using a dental doula?
The American Dental Association recently raised concerns over the increasing popularity of dental doula services. Although this hasn’t been studied specifically, some ADA members believe that there is a link between dental doulas and the rise in home dentistry. Though almost unheard of a few decades ago, currently about 1-2% of dental procedures are being performed at home by direct entry traditional mouth healers. Although in low risk patients, such as healthy children with an uncomplicated loose tooth, home dentistry is considered by many to be safe and effective, more complicated procedures should be performed under the care of a trained professional. Some dental experts argue, however, that even seemingly uncomplicated extractions have the potential to require higher levels of care.
Currently, no states require certification of competence for dental doulas or any form of licensure. Grant Ritchey, a natural dentist in Tonganoxie, Kansas, compares the current dental doula climate to the Wild West. “You don’t know what you are going to get unless you do your homework. Some dental doulas are excellent, some don’t know the oral cavity from a hole in their head. I know when a patient has made a good choice though. They all scream, but there is an underlying peace beneath the screams that reminds me of why I got into dentistry in the first place.”
What’s the bottom line on dental doulas?
A dental procedure, like the extraction of a diseased premolar, can be one of the most rewarding and meaningful experiences in a person’s life, but it can also be one of the most challenging. Patients who rate their procedures as positive on Yelp tend to express feelings of being in control. Dental doulas work for the patient, not the dentist or insurance company, which frees them from many constraints that interfere with the desired outcome. Dental procedures are about more than just fixing a tooth, they are about fulfilling a mouth’s destiny.
Fast forward to today and Suzy Flanders has now had three natural root canals in addition to the extraction, all with the aid of a dental doula. She is even considering a fourth root canal and is interested in having the procedure done in a warm water environment surrounded by koi and/or a dolphin. Because of her positive experiences with dental doulas, she says she would recommend them to anyone. “I will never forget when Dr. Ritchey handed me my extracted tooth, my husband on my right and my dental doula on my left, both enveloping me with gentle and relaxing energy.”

Science-Based Satire: Alternative Medical Adverse Events on the Rise
Are patients being senselessly slaughtered by poorly trained Reiki practitioners? Probably not. Okay, they aren’t…at least not directly. But Reiki is dumb and so is the belief that the power to manipulate human energy fields would be risk free. Here satire article is.
Clay Jones on December 1, 2017
Link

Isn’t it ridiculous that proponents of so-called alternative medicine rarely ever own up to the risks? Nothing in medicine is risk free. Nothing! But believers in pseudomedicine from acupuncture to Z Wave technology want to have their alkaline electric zucchini cake and eat it too.
Last time I wrote about a bogus energy healer who has scored a spot on the TLC schedule and some false legitimacy thanks to gullible academics at NYU. During a discussion on Twitter, I asked Goldsmith if there were any risks to manipulating a patient’s energy. Could he, I wondered, choose to unbalance their energy and cause symptoms. He didn’t respond, but it got me thinking.
What if energy healers, Reiki practitioners, and therapeutic touchers could use their powers for evil? What if they simply were having a bad day and gave someone gout? What if a novice trainee got in over his head? It’s absurd of course, but still.
That’s right! It’s time for more science-based satire.
Wait, alkaline electric zucchini cake?
Alternative medical adverse events on the rise according to new study
Bethesda, MD – A new report out of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) is calling into question the safety of Reiki, a technique which was developed in Japan in the early 20th century as a way to manipulate innate human energy fields in order to improve health.
The report, which will be published in the upcoming issue of The Vitamin Shoppe’s Amazing Wellness magazine, reveals that the number of Reiki related deaths have increased by almost a quartile since the last assessment in 2007. Lead author Lance Unglesby, a Level IIB practitioner of Therapeutic Touch, estimates that as many as three to four thousand people and animals are injured each year at the hands of poorly trained Reiki practitioners.

Mittensby J. Ticklepaws III, shown here mere seconds before suffering catastrophic cardiopulmonary failure during a botched veterinary Reiki session
“Many of these deaths occur in July, when new Reiki trainees are starting programs all over the country,” Unglesby explains. “People go to a healer expecting to be healed. This is a crisis and something needs to be done about it.”
Featured in the report is 10-year-old Louisiana child Timmy C., a boy whose life was tragically cut short when he was brought to a Reiki training facility for help managing his ADHD, which had been diagnosed earlier that week by the lady who cuts his hair. Timmy’s mother describes in chilling detail how things turned from miracle to mayhem.
We had a coupon for a free session and I figured it couldn’t hurt, and at first it seemed to be working. The student meditated and then placed his hands over Timmy’s body. It was like a light came on in his eyes and I could just tell that his ability to focus was returning. But something went wrong. I heard the Reiki student muttering something about how this shouldn’t be happening. He called for help and two Master Teachers rushed in but it was too late.
Only after a full alternative medical autopsy was performed did an explanation for Timmy’s death emerge. Parish Coroner Frank Grimes DC, who performed the examination in the basement of his clinic, found a number of vertebral subluxations and a touch of adrenal fatigue, but the true cause of death only became apparent when he hooked Timmy up to an Electro Interstitial Scanning (EIS) system and found a complete absence of resonance. “If you had asked me what killed him before the exam, I would have absolutely said it had to be Acute Severe Subluxation Syndrome, because that is the cause of 99% of non-traumatic deaths. But Timmy was one of those one in a million cases.”
What Dr. Grimes discovered allowed him to piece together Timmy’s final moments. During Reiki therapy sessions, a practitioner sends his own healthy energy into the patient in order to correct imbalances. Unfortunately, the normal flow of energy reversed during Timmy’s session. While a well-recognized complication, and one that countermeasures have been developed for, such as counting backwards from ten or crossing the big and second toe of the dominant foot, the unskilled student working on Timmy was unaware of these techniques because he had not started chapter 4 (“Management of Energy Flow Reversal and Energy Stream Crossing Emergencies”) in his Clinical Reiki textbook.
Devoid of any human energy, his body became riddled with dis-ease and he died, right there in his mother’s arms. Sadly, had Timmy’s mother been trained in Emergency Energy Replacement (EER) she might have been able to save him. An investigation by local authorities revealed that the Reiki training facility did not meet safety code, as it did not have a functional automated energy delivery device (AEDD) on site.

Science-Based Satire: NASA Teams with NCCIH to Study Alternative Medicine in Space
Are NASA and the NCCIH working together to study reiki in space? It sounds plausible I know, but this isn’t even remotely true. It’s satire. Enjoy!
Clay Jones on April 6, 2018
Link

Washington, DC- Two federally funded scientific organizations tasked with the advancement of our understanding of the cosmos are teaming up for the first time to study alternative medicine in space.
“Frankly I’m surprised it took this long for the two agencies to get together,” National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health director Josephine Briggs MD explained. “Until now, we’ve been handicapped by our inability to study alternative therapies beyond the Karman line. How else can you explain so many years of negative studies?”
For nearly three decades, the NCCIH, formerly known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, has investigated a wide variety of natural healing practices and herbal remedies supported by tax dollars under the guidance of the National Institutes of Health. So far, despite trying really hard, they have had little if anything to show for their efforts. This failure to produce proof of efficacy didn’t sit well with some congressional leaders, like former Iowa Senator Tom Harkin.
Harkin, who in the early 1890s recovered from a viral upper respiratory infection with the aid of an elixir he bought from a travelling salesman in Des Moines, became a believer in alternative therapies. A century later, in 1992, he would be instrumental in the formation of the office that would become the NCCIH. Harkin was also the force behind this unprecedented collaboration with NASA.
The first NCCIH trial to be run with the assistance of NASA will take place on the International Space Station and study the use of an energy-based healing therapy known as Reiki as a treatment for space adaptation syndrome, a severe motion sickness commonly experienced by space travelers. Developed in 1922 by a Japanese monk, Reiki practitioners claim to tap into and manipulate a patient’s qi, the universal life energy that, according to Reiki practitioner and lead researcher Ben Kenobi, “Surrounds us and penetrates us, binding the galaxy together and activating natural healing processes while restoring physical and emotional well-being.”
Until now, evidence of any benefit from the practice has been lacking, leading some to question the existence of this elusive “force”. H. Solo, a member of the Corellian Skeptical Society, has even gone on record denying it entirely:
…I’ve seen a lot of strange stuff, but I’ve never seen anything to make me believe there’s one all-powerful force controlling everything. There’s no mystical energy field that controls my destiny or that can prevent or treat space sickness.
According to Briggs, space is the perfect environment for studying Reiki because it is far, far away from the many potential sources of interference on Earth, like overhead power lines, Wi-Fi and skepticism. “We are of course primarily interested in its healing ability, but I think we’d all love to see some Reiki Lightning.”

Science-Based Satire: Florida Authorities Report First Case of Mosquito-Borne Fentanyl Overdose
Can a mosquito bite result in a fentanyl overdose? Will police soon be fitted with wearable naloxone pumps? Can fentanyl be detected by a handheld electronic device? The answer…is no. This is merely more nonsense cooked up in the mind of someone who probably should stick to his day job.
Clay Jones on March 17, 2023
Link

Miami, FL – The first case of a fentanyl overdose caused by a mosquito bite was recently reported by the Miami Police Department, and local authorities are raising awareness of this potential new threat.

“I was handcuffing a suspect and saw the mosquito go straight from his arm to mine, MPD officer Corporal Chad Blaze explained. “I immediately overdosed, and I kept overdosing all the way to the hospital where I received care and was discharged home after an hour. The crisis was over, but I think on some level I’ll always be overdosing on some level…at least a little bit…on the inside.”
Corporal Blaze was saved by the quick action of the very man he was in the process of detaining for suspiciously waiting for a bus. Wince Jenkins, a Miami bartender who has been battling an addiction to painkillers since an unfortunate alligator attack in 2019, recognized the telltale signs of a fentanyl overdose and called for help. “That cop started breathing real fast and talking about how he has kids and how he didn’t want to die in the street like an alligator. I yelled for his partner and she called for an ambulance. They both looked really scared.”

Fentanyl, a synthetic version of drugs like morphine, codeine, and super codeine, is much stronger than naturally occurring narcotics. Some medical experts, like police toxicologist Mort Fishman, aren’t surprised by this case of a mosquito-borne fentanyl overdose. “This stuff is potent. It’s like heroin on crack, and then on steroids. And if my certificate of participation from the third best toxicology academy in Tampa means anything, anything at all, this won’t be the last time it happens around here.”
Several high profile cases of police officers requiring treatment with an opioid reversal agent have been reported across the country in recent years, with most not even being caused by mosquitoes. According to Corporal Blaze, the close physical contact required in policing is a major risk factor for developing an overdose when an officer is worried that fentanyl has touched their skin. “And you know it is happening more than what you see in the news. That’s why I can’t wait until I get my pump.”

The “pump” Blaze is referring to will likely be a game changer when it comes to fentanyl overdoses in the line of duty. Researchers at the American multinational biopharmaceutical company Emergent BioSolutions Inc. are close to the successful development of a wearable pump for the continuous infusion of naloxone, a lifesaving drug used to reverse the effects of an opioid overdose.
“Our initial target demographics are police officers and other first responders,” Emergent BioSolutions Inc. CEO Robert Kramer Sr. explained. “Essentially anyone at high risk of being really worried about coming into contact with fentanyl. But in light of recent news reports, we are considering expanding this to anyone who might also live near a mosquito.”
Not all experts are fully on board with the naloxone pump. Fishman and other police toxicologists are raising concerns over the possibility of officers having a false sense of security. “I want our boys in blue to feel safe when they’re protecting us from the evils of the world, like when fentanyl that looks like glitter is being used on kindergarten birthday party invitations or when black people are picking up their kids from soccer practice. I just don’t want them getting reckless because they feel invincible. Qualified immunity only works when they are violating Fourth Amendments rights, not when they are overdosing on fentanyl!”

Fishman believes that prevention is key to keeping officers and other first responders safe. That’s why he recommends all patrol cars carry and use a Fentascan portable fentanyl security system. “When it comes to this stuff, you just can’t be too safe. It’s everywhere and in everything. And it’s patient. It will wait until you make a mistake.”
An injection of reality
Yes, I did some fentanyl fear satire back in October and I apologize for the repetition. But this nonsense just refuses to go away. Since then there have been numerous cases of police officers blaming fentanyl for panic attacks and/or simply passing out. Here is a typical scenario from December of last year.
Why is this a problem? In a follow-up piece on the above claimed “overdose”, actual toxicologist and expert on fentanyl exposures Ryan Marino sums it up:
Overdoses are killing hundreds of Americans every day, and the biggest driver of our overdose crisis right now is fentanyl in street drugs,” Marino said. “So I mean, I think it is something that everyone should be talking about. But these myths that come up, unnecessarily scare people, distract from meaningful conversations and even prevent people from doing the things that are necessary to really stop overdoses.
Marino has been pushing back against this false narrative for years. In this article, he further points out that this simply isn’t how fentanyl overdoses work. Our own Scott Gavura also delved into this issue last July, concluding that no meaningful absorption occurs with transient skin contact and simply washing the area with soap and water is all that is necessary.
These myths increase the risk that someone in actual need of a reversal agent on the street might be allowed to die because of fear of a contact or inhalation overdose. They originated as DEA disinformation designed to increase funding but have had the unfortunate side effect of distracting from efforts that might actually help people reduce their risk of death from overdose. Some people are even facing additional charges, such as “assault with intent to kill” after an officer has a bogus fentanyl overdose.

Science-Based Satire: A Powerful and Ancient Practice is Revolutionizing Medical Venipuncture
Are experts in medical dowsing using medical grade rods to locate blood vessels to improve venipuncture success rates? No, they aren’t. That’s absurd and this is clearly satire. But dowsing for dead bodies might be accepted in a court of law near you, which is also absurd but not made up. Really.
Clay Jones on July 22, 2022
Link

Boulder, CO – In an effort to improve patient care by reducing the number of needle sticks needed to obtain IV access or to draw blood for testing, an increasing number of nurses have turned to an ancient method used for finding sources of underground water.
“Finding a suitable vein for drawing blood or placing an IV can be challenging, particularly in older or obese patients,” explained Hortense Samuelson, a nurse at the Mountain View Manor skilled nursing facility in Boulder and recipient of a practitioner certification in Medical Dowsing. “Since I began using medical dowsing to locate good veins, I can hardly remember any instances where I haven’t been successful in the first few tries.”

Dowsing, known historically as “water witching”, is a 600-year-old method of divination traditionally used to find groundwater. But over the years, dowsing practitioners have branched out into other areas. These days, dowsers can be found not only on farms finding new sources of fresh water, but also working with petrochemical companies on the hunt for new oil deposits and prospectors searching for hidden gold.
The addition of locating hard to find veins to dowsing’s repertoire was truly a no-brainer, and it originated in Boulder, right down the street from the Mountain View Manor skilled nursing facility. Since 2008, the Institute of Medical Dowsing (IMD) has offered certification to interested nurses and other healthcare professionals. The IMD is actively pursuing national accreditation of their Medical Dowsing Certification (MDC) with the National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA) as well as credentialing from the Institute of Credentialing Excellence (ICE) for their Medical Dowsing Certified Practitioner (MDCP) program. They have successfully obtained approval from the National Acronym Approval Association (NAAA).
For those interested in a more advanced understanding of medical dowsing, the MDCP program consists of a rigorous weekend session designed to teach the knowledge of dowsing as it applies to a variety of medical areas, not simply phlebotomy. For instance, a certified medical dowser can also help locate hidden areas of inflammation or cancer. They can also be called upon to find lost articles of clothing or a patient’s car keys upon discharge from a facility.

How medical dowsing, and dowsing in general, works remains somewhat of a mystery. Proponents believe that their specially designed tools, often in the form of two L-shaped rods, allow for the detection of subtle energies or vibrations. One school of thought, in regards to medical dowsing, is that the metallic rods are drawn together when over a source rich in iron such as human blood.
A hit occurs when the two rods move over one another. Or they may point in opposite directions, forming a straight line and perhaps indicating a particularly long segment of blood vessel close to the surface. Sometimes the rods are prevented from moving by nearby interference, such as when there is a skeptical family member in the room or when the clinic had been built on iron-rich soil. But for a highly trained medical dowsing practitioner, the rods don’t always need to move in order to successfully locate an area of clinical concern or interest.
“I once worked on a man who, several years later, was found to have metastatic liver cancer right under where I remember getting a strong feeling as my rods passed over,” Samuelson revealed. “You don’t forget something like that. That’s why I trust my training and the scientific foundation it was built on.”
Critics have questioned the validity of dowsing, citing the failure to successfully find water under controlled testing conditions and an overall lack of scientific plausibility. But this type of negativity doesn’t concern Nurse Samuelson and other proud practitioners of medical dowsing. “I know it works because I’ve seen the results myself. And patients love it. At the end of the day, isn’t that what truly matters?”
Uncrossing the rods
I realize that medical dowsing sounds ridiculous, largely because it is ridiculous. This does not, as I’m sure readers of SBM know all too well, mean that there aren’t plenty of people out there who believe in it and support incorporating it into conventional medical practice. This is true despite the many controlled attempts to replicated dowsing success that have failed to show it works better than mere chance, and a highly plausible explanation for what dowsing practitioners experience known as the ideomotor phenomenon.
What inspired me to post this today, however, was a March 2022 article on dowsing in the field of forensics that I recently stumbled upon. The article features a highly respected program in the field of crime scene investigation:
Dowsing for the dead is not exactly endorsed by scientists or forensic experts. But it is a highlight for some students attending the National Forensic Academy, a 10-week training program sponsored by the University of Tennessee. Since the academy’s inaugural class 20 years ago, school administrators say, more than 1,200 crime-scene investigators from agencies in 49 US states and five foreign countries have attended the program, which currently costs students $12,000.
The featured forensic dowsing expert is a walking textbook in pseudoscience belief systems, even comparing himself to Galileo:
Cutting-edge scientists have always faced skepticism and even persecution, he says. “Galileo’s a great example. Remember what the church did to him when he said Earth was not the center of the universe?”
Though dowsing in the field of forensics is hardly mainstream, my jaw hit the floor when I read this:
In particular, some experts are distressed that a Vass trainee recently got witching results admitted as evidence in a Georgia murder trial. This could set a legal precedent and allow witching-based evidence to be used in other cases, says Chris Fabricant, a lead attorney for the Innocence Project, which works to exonerate wrongfully convicted prisoners. “The search for the truth is never advanced through junk science,” he says.
Sadly, I was able to confirm this and even found video of the testimony involving dowsing. It starts at 15:45 and involves a description of dowsing as well as a demonstration, in a court of law during a murder trial. The man even makes an excuse ahead of time in case his demonstration fails, claiming that a nearby cemetery could interfere with the rods. This is a completely uncontrolled test with a box of bones in clear view, so there was zero chance that the rods weren’t going to behave as desired by the so-called expert.

Science-Based Satire: Alternative Medical Alert Systems in the News
Clay Jones on February 13, 2015
Link

Belvidere, NE- Bref Albright was taking an unfamiliar route home from work because of a stalled 18-wheeler when he passed by the cell phone tower. As the electromagnetic field washed over him, symptoms of his sensitivity quickly set in. He first noticed a tingling sensation throughout his body and an odd dryness in his mouth and throat. Then nausea and headache. Once the palpitations and difficulty concentrating on the road began, he knew he had to pull over in order to avoid an accident.

“Getting off the road was the right thing to do,” Albright explained. “I couldn’t risk injuring somebody else if I lost control of my truck, but it left me vulnerable. I was a sitting duck!” As expected, Albright’s condition worsened because of continued exposure to the deadly yet fundamental force of nature. Despite blurry vision and difficulty remembering his wife’s cell phone number, he managed to place a call. No answer. His wife, home brewing kombucha, had left her phone in another room.
Albright, a 53-year-old taxidermist for the Belvidere Parks Commission, then pressed the red button that activated his alternative medical emergency alert system. Within seconds, a satellite had pinpointed the location of Albright’s pendant and a team of emergency alternative medicine experts was soon on its way. While on route, a member of the team was even able to contact Albright’s wife Norleen and ask a few questions about Bref’s alternative medical history.
“Speaking to family members can be very helpful when approaching these situations,” Emergency Chiropractic Technician Frank Grimes revealed. “Yes, we have a detailed file on each customer, but sometimes people forget to update their records when new issues come up. Mrs. Albright was able to inform us of Bref’s recent exposure to a genetically modified corn fritter.”
Norleen credits her husband’s alternative medical alert system for saving his life on multiple occasions. In the past year, Bref has accessed the system nearly one hundred times for concerns ranging from gluten exposure to sudden-onset chronic Lyme disease. “Sometimes it’s just nice to hear somebody tell us that everything is going to be okay, as long as we follow their recommendations unquestioningly.”
When the team arrived at the scene, they found Bref conscious but scared and a bit unsteady on his feet. Company president and naturopathic physician Mort Fishman, who leads the team and is certified in Acupuncture Cardiovascular Life Support (ACLS), says that in situations like this there is a golden hour where appropriate intervention can make the difference between life and irreversible chakra degradation. “This was one of those days where everything went right. It was a good day. They aren’t all good days, but we focus on the saves. You’ve got to focus on the saves.”
The key to the success of alternative medical alert systems like the one that saved Albright’s life, in addition to the highly trained men and women who respond to calls, is the customer’s motivation to use the system correctly. Fishman says that when a customer fails to respond to therapy, or when the rare fatality occurs, there is almost always a frustrating explanation. “Sometimes they don’t adhere to our treatment recommendations. Sometimes they wait too long to activate the system. In fact, I haven’t seen a case of treatment failure yet where it wasn’t ultimately their fault.”
Long known in the world of conventional medicine, alert systems have traditionally been used by the elderly to notify a 24-hour call center in the event of a fall or when they mistake people talking on a television or radio in another room for an intruder. The GeriAlert system, one of the most popular on the market, achieved notoriety with its famous slogan, “I’ve fallen and my own son never visits me anymore!” Alternative medical alert systems, although only around for a few years, have revolutionized the care of people who are really worried about things that their regular doctor has probably never even heard of.
Cutting edge technology is one of the ways that alternative medical alert systems are outpacing conventional competitors. Fishman’s company, EmergenQi, has recently added an automatic alert feature to its higher-end products, which can cost an excessively worried customer as much as $500 per month. This grants a customer access to the system but they are charged an additional fee each time it’s activated. “The auto alert feature detects imbalances, toxic exposures and even overgrowth of yeast in the blood,” Fishman says. “And our own studies show it to be nearly 100% accurate.”
Zoo KnudsenThe Belvidere Bugle

Okay, back to reality.
Several things inspired me to write this satirical piece about how an alternative medical alert system might work. First and foremost, and this is a frequent theme in my satire posts both here and at Knudsen’s News, is the thought experiment of what life might be like in a universe where alternative medicine proponents and practitioners truly attempted to replace conventional medicine. What if chiropractors obtained consent for “Do Not Manipulate” orders? Or the da Vinci robotic surgical system was used for acupuncture? It may seem far-fetched, and it is, but then again we have a military using acupuncture on the battlefield?
We live in a world where anything and everything, even low level non-ionizing electromagnetic fields, might be blamed as the cause of nonspecific symptoms. My article isn’t meant to poke fun at the symptoms, which are real even if the etiology isn’t organic in nature, or the people suffering them. My target is the community of pseudo-medical pseudo-professionals, many of whom have found employment in our most prestigious academic institutions, which helps to legitimize unproven and highly implausible etiologies.
I especially enjoy the mental imagery of an irregular medical practitioner getting an “alternative medical history and physical.” The H & P, as it is more commonly referred to as, is a skill medical students begin to hone early on in their training, striving to perfect it as they progress through residency. But the reality is that we are always learning and improving our ability to navigate the complex interactions of our patients’ historical and examination findings.
We improve with experience, but more importantly through continued exposure to science-based research. Without any such linchpin, what an alternative medical practitioner looks for or asks about is entirely based on their individual unscientific world view. And like GMO corn fritters, it is frequently random nonsense.
Another inspiration for writing this article was the always-frustrating use of ad hoc rationalizations by alt med practitioners. It never seems to be their fault when a patient suffers. The list of excuses is long but typically includes such canards as seeking their care after too much damage was done by the condition or conventional treatments, or that the patient just wasn’t motivated to heal.
There are other subtle, and not-so-subtle, digs at the absurdity of so-called alternative medicine in this faux news article. But I’ll let interested readers peel the onion for themselves. Hopefully this attempt at humor finds it mark. And if not, I’ll happily blame the five feet of snow, with another foot on its way this weekend, greeting me each day on my walk to work over the past few weeks.
